2012-07-05T11:45:53.103116Andrew LlanwarneThis is a very worthwhile objective, which should be extended to colleges and university campuses as well.15982012-07-05T12:41:34.697117Alan SpeedieEco-Schools success has demonstrated how a bit of pressure (statutory performance measure) can work wonders. A similar push on recycling would be well worthwhile, making recycling the default choice for life15982012-07-08T16:50:09.527118Mandy MurphyCouldnt agree more with this. Things need to change....and fast16002012-07-08T16:57:17.917119adam shankstotally support it16002012-07-08T19:11:18.263120Andrew MorrisonMental health problems are on the rise in Scotland and there is still a stigma attached to these in society. I think this is due to financial pressures, work pressures and unemployment caused by the present economic climate.\r\n\r\nI am happy to support this petition, congratulate the lead petitioner for her initiative in submitting the petition, and hope that the Scottish Parliament takes the necessary action to resolve the issues raised.16002012-07-09T11:25:23.737121Sally GallagherAs a retired teacher, I am in full agreement that education should play a greater part in learning about recycling - the younger the child the better. How to keep the recycling bins in the playground in a hygienic state ( ie clean lids) could be an issue, however.15982012-07-09T14:03:35.733122Emma PollockI couldn't agree more, services should be improved for people with mental health problems, I hope the necessary action is taken to resolve the issues raised and well done to the lead petitioner for getting this petition under way.16002012-07-09T20:04:57.62123QuentinZero instances of Litter is the objective of the new campaign at www.Zilch.org.uk and so we fully support this initiative.15982012-07-11T12:05:01.42124Christine BellEvery opportunity to educate and take practical action towards changing attitudes towards the three 'r's should be grasped by all! 15982012-07-14T15:09:11.64125Margaret BryceI am all for changes as I do agree there is still a stigma of mental health. It's time to treat it the same as we would any physical illness. 16002012-07-14T16:01:37.843127Thomas SimpsonI agree that this illness is not something that can be delayed and should be treated as a matter of urgency. Your normal gp does not have the training to deal with this and should have a professional deal with within days not months.16002012-07-16T10:44:35.353128Cat NewshellerPlease provide recycling in the schools. It is only through early education that the sort of messes we see now will be prevented. Children influence their parents hugely!15982012-07-16T15:35:40.753129Jim BollanThese cheque shops pray on the poor and charge extortionate rates to those who are that poor thay they cannot access the high street banks.16022012-07-16T17:54:44.643130Caitlin BrownIf those with mental illness are lwft feeling ashamed then we really must question the ability of these 'professionals' who treat them!!16002012-07-17T14:37:02.63131Petricia CraibGood work, glad someone is drawing attention to the importance of play.15992012-07-19T16:11:40.693132Arthur BergThis issue cuts not only to the way people dispose of things, but also how we go about manufacturing consumable materials and packaging. Education allows an ongoing message to be embedded with the next generation of consumers, and so is of critical importance. Much recycle, reduce and re-use education in the late 1990s and early 2000's was funded by Landfill Tax Credit scheme, but Central government took away that category from the scheme. Perhaps an independant or heavily devloved Scottish Government should consider re-instating Category c and cc to the LCF as a proven and sustainable funding mechanism.15982012-07-20T01:21:29.913133AmandaMy story of the lack of care given to me in my local psychiatric ward: beautyfrompainblog.com (blog post title - Scotland's Silent Deaths) - sorry would post url but it won't let me. \r\n\r\nFeel free to use if it can help in any way. \r\n16002012-07-24T12:23:39.46134Allyson INgramGreat work Lyndsey16002012-07-24T13:48:57.293135Elinore P Drummond.If that was the persons wish & it was known irrespective of whether he had left a will or not - his wishes shown be adhered to. This Law is out of place in the way we live our lives in this 21st century. and our government should replace this 1964 Law we are subjected to.- 50years out of date.16082012-07-25T18:04:03.96136Mary HolliganI really hope that this changes behaviour and attitudes in Scotland. I am looking forward to schools promoting the 3 Rs and a cleaner environment.15982012-07-26T18:40:14.033137heather langgood for you lyndsey hope you get good support16002012-07-27T13:44:36.667138Myra StruthersPlay is so central to a child's development and wellbeing - we need to ensure they have safe spaces to do this.15992012-07-30T12:32:38.69139Elizabeth GreeneCuts have created a vast catalogue of additional inequalities and deterioration of services for people with mental health problems in and out of hospital. \r\n 16002012-07-30T15:22:41.96140Lynn StewartI am supporting this petition. My children live across the road from our school and there is a huge pitch they could play in safely away for. The busy main road and side roads. They would also benefit from being allowed to ride their bikes in the playground instead on the road too. We have a run down park that has been left to ruin by Glasgow City Council and it is a total disgrace that they won't invest a few thousand pounds to install some new equipment for the kids to play.15992012-07-30T17:25:37.623141Lynne MacdonaldThis is a start to giving the children of Scotland safe areas to play,Society go on so much about children of all ages causing bother in streets and being noisy Well they need good parks to play for all ages,More community youth Centers where there is activities to suit all and a place to hang out with their peers!!15992012-07-30T19:29:54.98142Jacqueline KerrPlease pass this bill for ALL our kids. Thank you.15992012-07-31T06:12:19.043143Jackie SheridanMy kids has no where to play as the council refuse to cut the grass across from my house due to cut backs, no cut back in my council tax15992012-08-01T18:30:04.957144carol lamondits time that the high streets were given back to the people, and away from the parasites16022012-08-01T23:53:17.853145AndezThanks for posting this Jane. This is a REALLY impnatrot issue for all people with disabilities in Australia.My niece here in Queensland is an amazing 18 year old lady with autism. She is struggling to make the world understand what she wants to say. She has a very supportive father and sisters. But they can't speak for her as much as they would fervently wish to be able to do so.I so hope that policy change can facilitate her access to the technology that she so needs to be able to make her way out into the real world after leaving the support of the Special Education system.That is just my family story. We hear of so many others every day on Spectronics' phones and emails.16002012-08-02T06:28:26.59146Ann JonesThe money should be used for treatment for those whose gambling has become a problem.16022012-08-02T15:03:17.533147mahnaz DastooriAll children should be given the opportunity to play in a safe secure environment. Please give them this chance. Thank you15992012-08-05T00:12:37.14148anne willhaving suffered the distress miscarriage can cause i feel any investigation regardless of how many miscarriagesa woman has had can only be of help to women who have suffered in helping find a reason for this to have happened to them16112012-08-05T14:03:58.05149Nicola clarkeHaving suffered a miscarriage myself I would like more investigation done to help other women. 16112012-08-05T20:33:17.99150Laura MarcantonioVAT exemption best way to go. City of Edinburgh Council cannot be trusted to conduct building works anymore either and perhaps their exemption should be removed. There must be serious concern about CECs ability to run a city. We despair but do not want our city to deteriorate further.16142012-08-06T01:00:44.107151Annette CarberrySadly, my partner and I have lost 4 babies, three of which were miscarriages. It has been devastating for all of the family and it is only now that I "qualify" for testing. Some women could benefit greatly both physically and emotionally if the policy was changed. Women should be entitled to investigation regardless of the number of losses they have suffered! 16112012-08-06T10:03:26.653152Anne HayesI feel that this petition should apply to all older tenement buildings as they are an important part of our city architecture.16142012-08-06T13:57:19.73153Angela McKennaHaving suffered a miscarriage nearly 4 years ago now I still think about this a lot. I am now 45 and ofcourse at the time was 41, was a bit of shock to find out I was pregnant and then to lose the baby only 2 weeks later was devastating felt my only chance in life was taken cruelly away from me. Maureen at SCIM was amazing though and helped me through the tough times.16112012-08-06T16:38:12.527154A cullyA simple £35 blood test can check for aps which is sticky blood and Is a common cause for recurrent miscarriage and stillbirth. If found it is easily remedied by low dose aspirin and possibly other blood thinners during pregnancy. Currently in Scotland you have to have 3 miscarriages before qualifying for this test - in my opinion one is enough heartache for a women and her family to suffer to qualify being tested. I unfortunately carried my daughter to 39 weeks when she was born sleeping and I discovered I have aps. Any loss whatever trimester is devastating and we should be doing all we can to help find solutions early. Having researched a bit I am horrified to find that the uk put very little funding into miscarriage and stillbirth research compared to other countries. 16112012-08-06T19:34:58.153155Colin MurrayI think this is a brilliant cause16112012-08-06T20:16:13.38156John MillerIncentives are certainly required to keep our inner cities more attractive, especially in the wake of the tramway fiasco!\r\n 16142012-08-07T15:45:18.113157KThis is a brilliant cause, after suffering a miscarriage at 8weeks pregnant, almost 4 weeks ago I've been left with no support from Doctors or Hospitals , I feel like i've been left in limbo & just don't know where to go next, so the more that can be done to help people in my situation the better. 16112012-08-07T17:17:55.447158Derek R PowellDumping industrial turbines of this magnitude on the edge of Strathmore and the Grampians would be an act of unbelievable vandalism, destroying this unique landscape for ever for which the only winners are landowners and opportunists.16172012-08-07T17:35:36.12159Sue SmythIt cannot be possible that ANYONE could be so misguided as to consider spoiling such a beautiful glen with such enormous monstrosities which are not even proven to be effective16172012-08-07T18:07:20.277160Terry GreigIt's unbelievable that anyone would grant planning permission for these huge turbines plus thousands of tons of concrete to be poured on to these beautiful glens. I would hope that sense prevails and these beautiful glens are preserved for future generations.16172012-08-07T18:36:33.98161FIONA DOWI feel that if there is no legislation regarding where and how many of these windfarms are placed, Scotland will be ruined for ever.16172012-08-07T19:04:06.447162Patricia BurrThese wind turbines to be placed in the most prominent position will totally desecrate the wild and beautiful natural landscape of the glens. People come from all over the world to enjoy just this scenery. The turbines produce very little benefit and ruin the landscape. I do not understand how Scotland, who rely so much on tourism, could wish to build this wind farm.16172012-08-07T19:34:38.29163Catherine LewisWind farms are an ugly and expensive abomination, often constructed in places of natural beauty: allowed to despoil them with ugliness and noise on the spurious "green" excuse. Undemocratic and unforgivable.16172012-08-07T19:48:46.823164Gordon AdamThis will be catastrophic for Angus's landscape. Get a grip.16172012-08-07T19:48:52.057165Gordon AdamThis will be catastrophic for Angus's landscape. Get a grip.16172012-08-07T20:27:08.353166Barrie CooperHow can this application be seriously considered? It will spoil one of the most neautiful parts of Scotland. How is that 'green'?16172012-08-07T20:30:01.903167Jacquie SteelWhen will these people realise that things are a waste of money - they are inefficient, they ruin the countryside and if we are not careful, our Scottish countryside will be desecrated for years to come. Answer this question why are Denmark and Germany closing their Windfarms down? Answer: they are financially unviable. Politicians take note - we are becoming more vocal and we object most vociferously!! Not in My Back Yard! 16172012-08-07T20:41:00.44168Diana BignellIt would be sad for the residents of such a beautiful area to have the surrounding countryside ruined by unsightly wind turbines and of no benefit to the tourism industry of the area which is one of its main attractions.16172012-08-07T21:05:07.713169christina shawthis is a brilliant cause. as i have had 8 misscarrages. i am lucky i have went on to have 3 healthy children.16112012-08-07T22:51:24.447170Donald RiceAnother windfarm, another cash bonanza for a few landowners desecrating the birthrights of the rest of us. I dare the people putting this up to go and live under a wind turbine for a week and see what it's like.16172012-08-07T23:17:46.26171Lesley KilpatrickI think this is a very worthwhile cause! as i know only too well how awful it is to experience a miscarriage, after having one at 9wks.16112012-08-07T23:45:15.417172g.a.robertsonthe area proposed for this windfarm is totally unspoiled by any commercial entity for in excess of 5000 years and I firmly believe that this particular area must be left as nature intended for the natural enjoyment of everybody and for our future and our childrens future and their childrens future 16172012-08-08T06:18:53.05173Jacqueline Gittoes foreman Women shouldn't need a number of miscarages before they "qualifiy" this is terrible 1 is bad enough mentally and physically draining my thoughts and prayers are with you Annette I hope you get all the answers and much much more. 16112012-08-08T08:44:49.3174Jane BrewsterThis application, would be killing the the golden goose of Scotlands iconic Landscape and Heritage,setting a precedent for development of the Angus Glens.\r\nIt is ironic that on the deadline date to submit objections the heather on this site will be coming in to bloom!\r\nIf wind energy for Scotland is the right way for our economy and communities, why have Scottish ministers ignored the request to examine the impact of built sites ? At some turbine sites local residents are suffering problems from noise issues, properties lie empty directly due to the planning conditions imposed to protect or developers have had to buyout homes from those who are directly impacted. Windland clearances!\r\n The value of international tourists, staycations and recreational amenity are being ignored. \r\nGovernment are passing applications with no regard to human rights or EU environmental legislations,Local Authority or community comment.\r\n\r\nThe wind power issue will be greater scandal than MPs expenses or the banking crisis when our energy gap kicks in.\r\nPublic money is being squandered on an ill thought out policy,promoted by career environmentalists and misguided politicians.\r\nLocal authorities and consultees are swamped by applications and cannot process them properly due to the quality of the information submitted by developers and the overwhelming amount of applications being submitted.\r\nWe are privileged to live in a country with a wealth of natural resources, these are finite so should be used prudently.\r\nTribute must be paid to those landowners who refuse to be enticed by the lucrative consumer sourced subsidies, who have greater regard for their duty as stewarts of our countryside, a genuine interest in their local community and the heritage for future generations.\r\nThis issue is about generating money for the few and 'seen to be green' politics it is riding roughshod over local democracy,our landscape and our heritage.16172012-08-08T09:10:42.697175Tara Douglas-HomeThe business case for land based windfarms is far from assured and is only made possible through massive subsidy by the taxpayer. In addition to that the damage done to the local environment and wildlife is becoming more and more apparent.16172012-08-08T09:23:22.113176David ForsythIn this part of Scotland there is no way to minimise the visual impact of these turbines. They will simply stand out as a stark testament to our disregard for the simple beauty of the land. The efficiency of these turbines is insufficient to warrant such an exchange of vista. And we are all aware that should this wind farm be allowed others will follow and the loss of peace and land will be just too great.16172012-08-08T09:41:05.397177Noel LambLet us not destroy our wonderful countryside with more of these unsightly wind farms.16172012-08-08T10:30:06.183179Elizabeth CorriganChange has to happen the NHS have done very little for far too long !!!!16112012-08-08T10:40:15.35180Jan PesterWind turbines are not yet efficient enough to justify this. Cant they be put offshore where at least they impact alot fewer people? Offshore wind energy technology is improving rapidly I believe. 16172012-08-08T10:40:49.867181Dr KingI despair at the apparent disregard some humans have for their neighbours, but often they are absent landlords. Councils ought to have regard for this fact and it should count against the development. The East coast of Scotland is a unique area where any turbine will stand out like sore thumb. We have to have regard for farmers who use the electricity and live nearby if their turbines are a maximum of 37 metres and stand near buildings16172012-08-08T10:51:44.9182MornaWell done Maureen. Much needed! 16112012-08-08T11:08:32.467183Alexandra RichardsWhilst the developers and the land owners reap the financial rewards of these huge constructions, those residents who live nearby have to suffer loss in value of their home, their most valuable asset. This is not a planning condition, but should be. However, impact on their amenity is a planning condition and these will indeed have an enormously lengthy detrimental impact on the local amenity from construction through to turbines operating, for the next 25 years.......16172012-08-08T12:26:32.917184FBI used to be a staunch supporter of SNP - but because of the desecration of my beloved country by windfarms, I am totally against any political party who supports these.16172012-08-08T12:34:30.06185Lynn ReidHaving gone through 2 miscarriages at 10 wks and having first lot of tests for blood abnormalities carried out I feel that chromosomal testing should be carried out at the same time. It is a horrific time and feel there is not a lot of support through nhs at all 16112012-08-08T13:08:26.48186Maureen SharkeyAs a counsellor, I see the devastating effects that the current policy has. I am hopeful the Scottish Parliament with properly exercise its powers and do something about it. 16112012-08-08T13:56:21.943187NEIL GUNNINLAND WIND FARMS SHOULD BE BANNED EVERYWHERE AS THEY PRODUCE A VERY LIMITED AMOUNT OF ELECTRICITY AND SPOIL THE COUNTRYSIDE16172012-08-08T14:33:42.193188Duncan TannahillThe proliferation of wind farms must be stopped until a full evaluation is completed and their economic and environmental impacts are fully understood. 16172012-08-08T15:38:09.273189Louise GardnerWhat happens after 20years when the maintenance contracts run out on these costly turbines, we will have a countryside littered with rusting dangerous monsters that farmers and landowners will be unwilling and unable to maintain.16172012-08-08T17:02:38.58190david gouckI lived in Lethnot for 30 years and left for other chages to the glen is this more greed to spoil a part of scoland loved by so many16172012-08-08T17:51:33.27191William BowieWind at more than 10% of total demand will result in\r\nimbalance in the grid and 'brown outs' when the wind does not blow. It should be noted that UK wind turbines produce less than 10% of their rated power about a third of the time. Without 'backup' from conventional power plants the lights will go out.16172012-08-08T21:33:20.437192Anne LynchUnfortunately, comments are just being read by people objecting to windfarms for various reasons. Attempting to reach people who think there is not point in objecting because 'we are going to get them anyway', is very hard. By the time it is realised how serious the situation is regarding the impact on our wildlife, landscape and our pockets, it will be too late.16172012-08-08T21:49:23.787193isobel simpsonwell done to lee for taking this further given hope to woman that have suffered miscarriage.. i tshd be investigated after 1 never mind 3!!!16112012-08-09T09:41:40.983194Philip Johnston Let's stop kidding ourselves wind power is inefficient - also it's ugly,invasive and requires too much land which is best left to nature's uses. 16172012-08-09T10:10:12.063195Robin TaylorSorry to disagree but I cannot support this. People who own their own house accept that it is their responsibility to pay for the maintenance of their property, why should people who live in tenements not have the same responsibility ? If all tenement property owners paid a regular contribution into a common fund then the cost of upkeep could be sensibly shared amongst the owners.16142012-08-09T10:53:53.817196Suzanne TrillAs one of the few owner-occupierfs in a tenement of 21 flats for the past ten years, I know just how difficult it is to get enough people to agree to get work done (or to agree to hire a factor or have a stair partnership). The current issues around statutory notices makes the situation worse: something really needs to be done to encourage all owners to take their responsibilities seriously16142012-08-09T13:28:29197Neil PurvesI wholeheartedly support this petition. I remember that a waitress at Ryan's Bar at the West End in Edinburgh was killed by falling masonry from a gable end - so,so sad. Edinburgh trades on its architecture throughout the year so this is another reason to encourage and support preservation. As a property owner common repairs are always a major hurdle and previously I found there was no incentive to organise repairs myself. Instead I found there was a huge advantage of avoiding almost all the VAT by getting a statutory order placed for the work by the council. Owners should have the same treatment both in VAT tearms and the method of repairs to take the load off the Council. 16142012-08-09T15:23:19.187198JEAN MACLEODIs the Scottish nation to be involved in a constant battle to hold on to its natural heritage? Why is this Scottish Government who up-hold all that IS Scottish, destroying the country to fill an energy quota that is not only destructive but unsustainable?16172012-08-09T16:32:38.843199Carol BallChildren develop numerous skills through play so the more opportunities that are available to support these developments the better. 15992012-08-09T18:57:58.713200Ann CrossI used to let out a flat in Edinburgh. 4 of the other owners in the stair were co-operative about repairs, but because the other 2 always refused to pay up, every repair needed to be dealt with through Edinburgh Council. 4 owners ended up paying more because the other 2 owners expected to be subsidised by everyone else. 16142012-08-09T21:29:53.36201Kirstine Morrison Testing should be done for every woman who has a miscarriage not just recurrent miscarriages. 16112012-08-10T08:35:07.267202Elaine As statutory notices are no longer readily available and stair partnership has disappeared due to lack of funding there is hardly any help now for getting mutual repairs carried out. As some of this is due to the corruption with the previous statutory notice scheme it is a real shame that little has been done to encourage owners to repair their own buildings since. We need a mutual repair but as not all neighbours agree it it is proving impossible to get help, guidance or any incentive to make the repair ourselves16142012-08-10T08:36:07.12203Jacky HatchwellWe seem to pay a lot of money for little reward with wind farms The money going from our taxes to overseas companies with little interest in our country side. 16172012-08-10T12:55:50.323204Ian MurrayWind power is a bit of fool's paradise. Tidal power is more efficient and sustainable...and a whole heap less ugly. Though don't expect the Scottish Government to listen to sense.16172012-08-10T15:39:59.12205Adrian DargueYou'd need a wind farm two miles deep encircling the whole of the UK to generate 10 to 15% of the UK's power needs. These things are not the answer to our power needs, these eyesores can only harm Scotland's tourist industry\r\n16172012-08-10T23:57:49.42206Sheena gall-EdwardsHaving had 8 miscarriages, a dvt and pulmonary embolism, then still not being tested, I had to battle for a diagnosis. I'm from England but feel very strongly that testing should be done so much earlier. 16112012-08-11T09:34:33.727207Angela BlairIt is vital that testing is carried out in order to stop couples continually going through this heartbreaking time.16112012-08-11T13:51:36.157208Kathleen WilkieWill need this more and more16122012-08-11T16:20:00.16209Beverley Jane LawsonThis is a massive step forward, however, why wait for one miscarriage when the inexpensive tests for APS could be incorporated into routine blood tests for pregnant women and avoid many more miscarriages. Surely prevention is the ethical and cost effective policy. 16112012-08-11T23:55:05.263210SIt is time to focus on sustainable rather than renewable energy. Sustainable energy means that the new generator completely and effectively replaces the legacy generator whilst causing less harm when both are calculated using lifecycle accounting rules.\r\n\r\nWind is renewable but not sustainable, it must be fully backed up by traditional generators thereby the infrastructure for wind is unnecessary duplication. When considering the additional infrastructure and environmental harm from lifecycle accounting the CO2 output increases with every turbine constructed, thereby exacerbating the greenhouse gas emission situation. Meantime consumers are forced to pay for this folly driving increasing numbers of households into fuel poverty.\r\n\r\nDo we truly want tourists to believe that the flower of Scotland is the wind turbine or do we want to retain our tourist industry, health, ecology and credibility and lead the way with a sustainable energy policy?\r\n\r\nScotland has an opportunity to replace legacy generators with clean burning natural gas linked ot carbon capture and storage using our North Sea Oil and Gas fields and expertise. This not only buys us time to mature Sustainable Renewables such as deepwater turbines and 4th generation bio-fuels, but also reinforces our reputation for innovation and cutting edge technology. Isn't it time to invest in something worthwhile and which will strengthen our economy rather than continuing to throw good money after bad on a technology that has been proven to fail, is desecrating our landscapes, ecology, residential amenity and tourist industry, is globally harmful when considering the concrete and rare earths involved and will leave us completely exposed to a monopoly market in rare earths (China) thereby increasing the likelihood of power outages and price fluctuations?16172012-08-12T12:42:08.223212John MilneA shame that this windfarm is being considered for the beautiful Angus Glens. Wind power could never provide base load needs or peak requirements.16172012-08-12T16:16:40.49213Kenneth MacAlpineI have suffered from the inability of doctors, police, social work, local council, even mental health suppert providers and my life has been hell not getting the help I ever need. Proud to say I am on the mend but not with any help.16002012-08-12T16:20:57.63215Kenneth MacAlpineBusinesses and greed seem to get away with what it wants. Stop the impoverished being prayed upon like dying animals by greedy vultures. 16022012-08-12T16:28:58.543216Kim MillerThe Angus Glens are unique and one of the very few assets we have, hereabouts. Take away their remoteness and their beauty and you take away their whole purpose. It is a no brainer - do not consider it. Although, it would be in keeping with the Trams in Edinburgh, the new Forth Crossing and even the cost of Parliament scandal. When it comes to the big ones rest assured...16172012-08-12T16:55:07.41217Gordon mcgilvraylet's get it sorted people the folk needing health care here are genuine. how many folk do we all know that fiddle the system. please see sence and sign what ever needs to be signed to start saving lifes16122012-08-12T17:02:02.21218Carol HigginsWhere are the play areas for wheelchair using children? Disabled children need to play too!15992012-08-13T09:54:14.417219Hannah ForbesThis is great and I have signed the petition. But I think abortions are something that should be challenged long before miscarriages are. If people are willing to kill their babies, then why should it be such a big deal to lose them naturally? I think both are awful but maybe we need to work out what we're fighting here...16112012-08-13T11:38:39.5220Maureen PatersonI have been concerned about this issue,not only the amount of betting and payday loan shops but the amount of online gambling,poker,casinos you name it. We are going to have really big problems with compulsive gamblers,if not already.16022012-08-13T13:47:39.6221Penelope GregoryThe Angus Council agreed that turbines in this area would conflict with the historic and deeply rural character of the landscape. If these proposed turbines are erected they will be seen by everyone driving along the A90 on their way to the historic sites of the Caterhuns, the Standing Stones at Aberlemno, the castles of Glamis and Edzell, Brechin Cathedral and Round Tower etc. The foothills and glens of Angus are famous for their beauty. Surely this cannot be destroyed when there must be many other far less obtrusive locations.16172012-08-13T15:43:41.487222Deborah MurphyThe council, when they do issue a statutory notice - issue it to so many properties that organising a repair becomes impossible. This has been identified in the recent fraud unpleasantness, however leaving the decision to the council involves an exorbitant cost and VAT and no help. After the awful incident outside Ryan's bar the council swiftly relinquished all responsibilty onto residents and were even "fixing" that. Edinburgh council are experts in shifting blame and then making money from tenants given very few choices. Perhaps a completely different method should be used one where honesty & overcharging are unacceptable.16142012-08-13T17:06:18.05223Gillian EacottI think that a simple blood test that is inexpensive is the way to go to avoid such heartbreak as miscarriages. This would seem to be an effective way to ensure the health of women and unborn babies, it's a no brainer.\r\n16112012-08-13T18:06:30.577224Carole Richardson.This is a really good cause it is so sad how many miscarriages ladies must have before being tested.16112012-08-13T19:07:21.727225George HerraghtyHas no one noticed the 14,000 abandoned turbines, rusting in the Californian desert? It is an outdated, discredited, grossly inefficient technology. I object to our extortionate energy bills being used to subsidise foreign multinationals, and millionaire landowners to trash the finest landscapes in Western Europe. What sort of green policy actually destroys the very environment it is supposed to protect? Let's have intelligent renewables that deliver reliable baseload energy. All the Firths between Inverness and Tongue have bridges or causeways, yet NOT ONE has a tidal barrier to provide virtually limitless, constant power.16172012-08-14T09:41:33.86226Catherine MitanPeople with any condition should not have to appeal for help its their right to a better life without worry.16122012-08-14T12:00:42.71227KaySchemes such as the Edinburgh Stair Partnership should be set up and made *compulsory* so that ongoing repairs are carried out in a timely fashion and flat owners aren't suddenly faced with huge repair bills.16142012-08-14T15:03:38.64228Khalidah MohammedPlay in any form is every child's right, please do not take this away from them !15992012-08-14T18:13:52.507229Hazel Greig-Midlanestandards of care raise awareness amongst clinicians as well as patients and remove obstacles to identifying the correct treatment due to ignorance.16122012-08-14T21:46:28.59230Kathleen Georgepatients should not have to appeal for help it is their right to a better life without uncertainty of care causing stress and worry.16122012-08-14T22:05:17.8231Crystal Bridgesi have suffered from 5 miscarraiges and never ever had them looked into i want more to be done about it and hope this petition will change that as i am desperate to have children :(16112012-08-14T22:16:11.5232cheryl hollandgr8 cause close to my heart and most peoples x16112012-08-14T23:33:12.843233tracy lyons,wonderfull cause16112012-08-15T00:42:52.36234julie nelson having had a stillbirth and two miscarriages myself last one two weeks ago. i think this is a disgrace eh asked for testing and they wouldnt include my son being stillborn as one , how many times do women have to go through this heartache ! 16112012-08-15T00:58:30.817235Lisa Marie WildmanI think its a good idea myself as in the future it could be prevented16112012-08-15T01:54:31.767236lindsie larzelerei would like to know 16112012-08-15T08:40:22.43237miriamdo it for the mum's and dad's who want to know 'why' 16112012-08-15T12:57:07.983238Libby WelshYoung ACHP adults at the point of transition from paediatrics need to have a clear pathway for care well into their adulthood which is underpinned by excellent standards and practice from specialist cardiologists.16122012-08-15T14:34:52.437239Alan SmailTo line this ridge top with turbines would be an act of scenic vulgarity. The view of the Angus Hills as seen from the A90 between Forfar and Brechin is one of the iconic views of Scotland.16172012-08-15T18:45:21.807240Marilyn Foden All woman need to know this,as it affects many many woman 16112012-08-15T19:04:23.543241Pamela MitchellIts so sad when we have to appeal like this to save lifes 16122012-08-15T19:19:17.23242Margaret McLeaneveryone deserves equal treatment16122012-08-15T20:43:46.15243J CarrollI have had 1 miscarriage and 2 ectopic pregnancies. I got tested after my first ectopic and got the all clear. I was advised then after that by my gynocologist to take baby asprin and progesterone suppositres the next time I became pregnant which I did but unfortuately I had another ectopic pregnacy where I had a tube removed. I think I had a sympathetic doctor who referred me after my first ectopic which was good. Even after all the tests and medication you can't predict what will happen. It's so hard not knowing why miscarriages happen so it would be good for more help from the government but I think it will take a long time before they find any answers. 16112012-08-15T20:49:00.807244Silke Thomsonwith the need for this petition it seems once more as if all we have to do is fight for things other people take for granted. 16122012-08-16T09:05:36.67245Joy HooksEveryone deserves a chance.16122012-08-16T13:31:21.587246Ailsa McKelvieSoC(s) provide a backbone to any health service. This shouldn't require a petition - it is clearly necessary to protect ACH patients who need to be treated as unique cases within the NHS.16122012-08-16T18:40:49.487247Katherine GunnWind Farms are a creeping blot on the beautiful landscape of Scotland- we are an island -tidal power is the way forward.16172012-08-16T21:11:49.6248Iona DonnellyMy 2 year daughter with a complex CHD will hopefully be one of the GUCHers who will benefit from a supportive, comprehensive and capable network of cardiologists, surgeons and other health care professionals when she reaches adulthood. I hope such standardised care will be in place long before then. 16122012-08-17T01:35:03.413249James CassidyBearing in mind part 1 of the Scottish Governments own planning policy, Scotland's landscape and natural heritage are internationally renowned and important, underpinning significant industries such as the food, drink and tourism industries, and are a key component of the high environmental quality which makes Scotland an attractive place in which to live, do business and invest.\r\nThis development would significantly detract from the landscape in its natural form, and would have an effect on tourism, hillwalking, angling and cycling amongst others. Likewise it fails to make the area an attractive place to live and could deter investment, particularly in those areas previously mentioned. \r\n16172012-08-17T08:17:13.973250S.FarquharI agree this is an issue16022012-08-17T12:39:07.05251Alan Clark Signing this in support of friends16122012-08-17T13:24:16.817252Barbara De MariaSigning in support of standards for care for worldwide CHD community.16122012-08-17T13:58:15.597253Margaret MacdonaldI am a middle-aged CHD patient with a complex history. I appreciate hoe stretched our services are but feel that we are not being supported in the way that people with other medical conditions are.16122012-08-17T14:53:26.793254Suzanne PhilippsTerrestrial wind farms are inefficient, because the wind is spasmodic and the national grid has to give input in addition. Much better are offshore wind farms. The wind is mostly constant and marine life (including fish stocks) are protected and thrive.16172012-08-17T16:32:05.713255Marion RossIt's about time you started listening to the people.\r\nWe have less control over our local areas that before devolution. The Scottish Government is acting like a dictator!16172012-08-17T17:32:31.14256Ann Standring I am with you all, in support of all my friends 16122012-08-17T19:00:08.87257Elizabeth PaulAs the mother of an amazing daughter, I appreciate that the NHS saved my baby's life 34 years ago and am grateful for her life and the care she has received but it has been difficult for her to fight unnecessary battles and suffer needlessly in addition to having to fight to stay alive. 16122012-08-17T20:10:27.483258K WalkerLove to see the Scottish Government support ALL adults with congenital difficulties e.g. Spina Bifida16122012-08-17T21:05:16.727259Jacqui FordyceStandards and guidelines will support people like my sister to receive the care they require by Specialists who understand their needs. Please give your support!16122012-08-17T22:03:36.053260James SuddonPrecautions will have to be taken to ensure people and the government are not ripped-off. This happened in a big way when a scheme of this sort was grossly abused by builders, architects and many others with shoddy workmanship to boot. The scheme took place approximately 20 years ago and the costs were that the grant was 90% to 10% for the owners. Despite this the cost of the 10% to owners often ran into thousands and a lot of the work done then has not lasted.\r\nWe should beware of giving further power to people employed by the councils and it may be that the watchdogs for the scheme would be [PROFANITY:employed] by the Scottish Government, but this too would have its dangers.\r\nJim16142012-08-18T11:12:59.4261Lindsay SavegeI have experienced this myself and more recently had a good friend go through utter devastation. any progress is bound to help even just a little.16112012-08-18T14:11:07.013262LesleySupport from the Council to help tenement property owners share their contact details - in particular where a large number of flats are rented - would be useful in encouraging owners to be more proactive in maintaining properties. Schemes such as the Edinburgh Stair Partnership should definitely be encouraged.16142012-08-19T12:27:34.343263JillThis is a very timely request, particularly in an era when councils have been found to be lacking with regard to the legality of the 'statutory' work they endorse, which is often to the financial benefit of the contractors they use...16142012-08-20T10:45:58.56264James HirstWhy destroy the natural beauty of Glen Lethot?16172012-08-20T10:55:03.237265Malcolm"No encouragement to organise repairs themselves"? Is the fact that a substantial portion of your net worth is invested in the building not incentive enough? Why should you expect a subsidy from those of us who pay taxes but do not own property?16142012-08-20T12:59:35.35266Florance KennedyMalcolm's point on 20 August, and Robin Taylor's earlier are valid. However, they do not address the fact that some owners do not fulfil their responsibilities and this causes immense problems which responsible owners cannot rectify. I think incentives are a fair swop for being able to walk down the street safe from deadly falls of masonry, and they would also benefit the tenants of some landlords who don't always look after their properties properly.16142012-08-20T17:30:02.747267Anthony SanfordThe text reading check is virtually impossible to use\r\n16122012-08-20T21:38:36.04268MICHAEL FENTONI am saddened that this beautiful area which exemplifies what Scotland is known to look like is now under threat of destruction for monetary reasons, and to fulfill a futile renewable energy quota by 2012. If this is allowed to happen, we will only have memories of the tranquil environment that was once ours.\r\n16172012-08-21T09:16:06.747269Maureen O'BrienSigning this in support of all sufferers who deserve the best care and attention16122012-08-21T12:10:39.83270Melanie JaffreyThere are alternatives to these hiddious structures look into them before its too late. They are destroying everything about Scotland and will have a serious impact on tourism. They are killing our birds and bats, they are noisey and not all that efficient. 16172012-08-21T13:15:37.94271Lynsey PattieAndez. This is my petition for people with mental illness. Think you might have got a bit confused!16002012-08-21T17:16:38.817272Peter PhillipsThe proposed wind factory at Nathro does not meet the Scottish Government Planning Policy, it will affect both the Angus Glens and the vale of Strathmore and is detrimental to the tourist industry in Angus.16172012-08-21T20:27:23.093273Neil McLeanSupport this petition please, thanks.16112012-08-21T20:48:31.697274Margaret McKeddiePeople shouldn't have to suffer 3 times before someone takes action, we need to move quicker.16112012-08-21T20:50:17.57275Charles McKeddieI saw my daughter go through this twice, it's heartbreaking for everyone. We need to take action a lot quicker to prevent losses as best we can16112012-08-21T20:52:34.823276Lee McKeddieLet's take a stand and make a difference to people's lives!16112012-08-21T21:03:58.513277Anne-Marie RamsayIt's not until you go through it yourself you realise how heartbreaking it is 16112012-08-21T21:18:26.143278Kelly RockeNo one should have to suffer this heartbreak three times before they can get answers!16112012-08-21T21:28:06.12279Beverley DonaldsonThis is a must, it's got to happen. 16112012-08-21T21:36:10.137280AlisonSaddest day of my life 13th Jan 2000 with no answer and no explanation!16112012-08-21T22:06:57.32281M AdamsOne miscarriage is more than enough! I have recently suffered my 3rd, only now to be offered further support! It all comes down to the NHS and budgets, as usual! Time off work recovering from a miscarriage probably costs the government more!16112012-08-22T09:42:41.897282Ashley HackettAgree 100%16112012-08-22T10:10:40.29283Kathryn WhiteI found that there was a real lack of empathy from health professionals in relation to miscarriage. It appeared to me that because they see this happening every day its a case of "well thats life". This attitude only causes more distress to the women affected and adds to the feeling of helplessness. It is about time we stood up to this and demanded a change. Well done SCIM!!!16112012-08-22T16:27:28.733284LyndaLee -your so right to pursue this. Well done for not giving up!16112012-08-22T17:43:40.203285Mrs Sarah Sheldon I can't express how important this is to me! I also was advised to go home, try again and after the next miscarriage, they would be able to test. My husband and I have only managed to concieve twice in 12 years of trying and there was a real lack of understanding as to how utterly devasting the most recent miscarriage was for us. I am still emotionally struggling with our loss 2 years later and a large part of that is due to the detached and cold advice that we got from the NHS. It is not so easy for some of us to just go home and get pregnant again - to have the third miscarriage for testing! There is a good chance that we will never concieve again and because of this blinkered rule, we have perhaps lost the only chance we had of finding out why! 16112012-08-22T19:32:51.943286Carole TysonI hadn't realised till recently that this beautiful glen was facing the prospect of a totally inappropriate wind farm and I can't say how dismayed I feel. I've been coming here for years, on and off, and have always found it a real haven of tranquility and beauty. The planned development is out of scale with the environment and is likely to detract significantly from the desirability of the Angus glens as a tourist destination and to have no long-term economic benefit to the local population, who will also be deprived of much of what makes it such an attractive place to live. I wish I could believe that the Scottish Government was not going to ride roughshod over any objections but, given recent planning priority statements,I am very much afraid that it will try to do just that.16172012-08-22T21:15:50.617287Marcello MegaA few years ago, a statutory notice was served on the tenement block in Edinburgh East of someone close to me. The owners had been unable to secure the commitment of one owner who rented out his flat. He used a very common British surname, that clearly was not his own, and he instructed his tenants not to reveal his true name and address to the other residents and flat owners. Despite this obstruction, they managed to track him down and attempted to persuade him to look after his property and his own interests, He refused, the notice was served and the owners found themselves facing a bill of £14,000 each. Because one of the owners, who let his property out, was well-connected, he managed to persuade the relevant person in the council department involved to give the owners a short period to organise the repairs themselves. The unhelpful owner was suddenly just as keen as everyone else to see what could be done to avoid paying £14,000 and probably have a rotten job done. Agreements were soon reached, a clerk of works was appointed to oversee and check the calibre of the work (just as well as he unearthed a few major faults at the end and had them rectified) and the job was done to a decent standard at a cost of £4,000 per flat, plus a small sum to the council to cover admin costs. The point of this is to illustrate the sort of problems owners can experience when just one of their number will not co-operate, and the fact that any job organised by the council is pretty much guaranteed to invole some sort of kick-back at our expense. How else can a difference of £10,000 per flat be explained? Our wee country is far more corrupt than most would like to think.\r\nFinally, there is clearly a need for money to be found from the public purse to help maintain our magnificent Victorian and Georgian buildings, which are responsible for the stunning good looks of our capital city. We cannot afford, in any sense, to let them crumble.16142012-08-22T21:41:50.807288Natalie MurphySigning in memory of Catherine Hunter, a beautiful girl inside and out, taken far too soon to shine among the stars. Sleep tight my friend x16122012-08-22T22:48:17.227289Amy OwensI am signing this as I have a heart condition called Transposition Of The Great Arteries people need to understand that people who have a heart condition like me shouldn't be treated different to anyone people who have a Heart condition have to fight for their rest of their life people like me need the best care available 16122012-08-22T22:48:29.743290Amy OwensI am signing this as I have a heart condition called Transposition Of The Great Arteries people need to understand that people who have a heart condition like me shouldn't be treated different to anyone people who have a Heart condition have to fight for their rest of their life people like me need the best care available 16122012-08-22T23:53:47.12291J KaneyIt's so difficult to pick yourself back up after the heartbreaking experience of miscarriage. Being given the option of testing as soon as possible helps greatly in taking those steps forward. How frightening it is to try again without some answers from medical professionals. Well done to SCIM for this campaign...and for all the wonderful work you do.16112012-08-23T10:52:21.297292Sue StrachanEveryone should have an opportunity to play outside in a safe and stimulating environment. We need to ensure that all of Scotland's children have that opportunity in the future.15992012-08-23T14:25:27.94293Joanne ThomsonHaving suffered 5 miscarriages I find it abominable that its only once you've had 3 that investigations are offered. I previously suffered 2 ectopic pregnancies, prior to the 5 miscarriages and finally gave birth to our son last November. Going through that was harrowing for my husband and I. Miscarriage should be investigated after one, no one should have to lose subsequent babies if it can be prevented. Taking 8 pregnancies to have my son took a horrendous toll on me and my body. Perhaps if I'd been offered tests to find the reason why I would not have gone through 7 years of pain.16112012-08-23T14:26:30.337294chris patersonin addition the issue of acceptaing responsibility needs to be understood by home owners. too many ignore and obviously it is usually the parties most affected organise the work ie top floor flats.\r\nmixed use blocks need serious discussion as we use a historic % calculation based on rateable values set 20 odd years ago. many residential owners have a 1 or 2% liability totally unrealistic to their area liability or current notional rateable value should residential properties be revalued now. whilst you may moan that it will add additional costs to home owners it is no different to current position with home owners ignoring their responsibility but you often have the case of a retailer rejecting repairs becaue they can have up to 80% liability so again no incentive to get work done. clearly not a vote winner but that is the reality of mixed buildings and needs like other areas looked into.16142012-08-23T15:43:57.76295Christine CampbellIn this day and age mothers to be shouldn't have that worry on their minds. A change is needed to improve on how people are treated after 1 loss never mind 3. 16112012-08-23T17:29:09.527296IainIt is not clear that you must enter both words and why is one so difficult to read?16002012-08-24T07:33:23.4297Ashley HallFor Amber and the rest of the CHD community x16122012-08-24T08:14:40.91298Arthur JarrettThere may be other legal routes to achieve this worthwhile end. The Scottish Government should pursue these if the Petitioner's exact proposal is not accepted. 16082012-08-24T20:29:24.357299Donna ParkesSomething so worthwhile and under fuinded.16112012-08-24T21:08:40.147300kiara o'dowdas someone who had 2 miscarriages it is very harsh to be told no one cares enough to find out why uour baby has died all miscarriages shold be investaged16112012-08-24T21:48:56.48301amie jacksonAs someone who has had 4 miscarriages it was hard to find out no-one was willing to help or try find out why its happening all because I haven't had 3 in a row surely ones enough!!!16112012-08-24T22:10:31.107302c andersonIt is hard enough to go through this once and have no answers let alone 3 times the unanswered questions about why this happened is one of the most difficult things to deal with will never forget the feeling of devastation and helplessness i felt in 2005 its about time someone took notice of the pain and anguish this issue causes.16112012-08-24T23:15:09.247303Alan RuxtonA Windfarm on this site would totally ruin the look of the area and potentially compromise any tourisim business ,which this area needs badly .As well as the fact that it is miles away from any market needing the electricity,supposing that they would generate enough to warrant all the effort any way.16172012-08-25T00:00:55.283304Jill McKenzieIt should be like an organ doner card. If you carry one, your wishes should be respected!16082012-08-25T21:08:15305Raymond CattanachPlay is a very important part of a child's development so we need to protect green spaces and invest in outdoor facilities to create a safe and stimulating environment for our children. 15992012-08-26T14:34:28.8306jane tylerI support this petition wholeheartedly16112012-08-26T19:11:01.713307Maureen YeomanSigning in support of all patients with CHD16122012-08-27T10:44:47.88308Fiona CameronHaving lived with the construction of Griffin windfarm and now Calliacher, and watched the devastation of our local landscape, I cannot urge the Scottish government to begin to think clearly about the disastrous impact these windfarms are having on the land for which you are meant to be custodians.16172012-08-27T11:46:25.303309Susie BiglandIt will be a tragic blight on the landscape, with little practical benefit.16172012-08-27T11:52:41.537310David GrantI have tried over 20 times to sign this but each time the reCaptcha has been rejected. This is disgraceful and appears to be an attampt to prevent people signing.16172012-08-27T12:02:46311Rebecca RowlesI've made 10 attempts to enter the recaptcha text and have now given up. what a great way to make sure no-one signs anything.16172012-08-27T12:08:25.047312David GrantYour reCaptcha is faulty and prevents people signing. Is this deliberate I wonder? 16172012-08-27T12:48:19.227313Robert GeelanThe Captcha is not working and stopping me from signing16172012-08-27T13:22:31.763314ethel forbescant read the recaptcha text. Is this a ploy to stop people signing16172012-08-27T15:45:00317Fred de FThe reCaptcha text run by the Scottish Parliament does not work despite several attempts - has prevented me from signing. Deliberate? 16172012-08-27T15:54:46.027318Kevin McCannIn support of the development of a national standard of care for all Scottish ACHD patients (including myself).16122012-08-27T18:36:00.42320Pinkie MethvenThought it was just me, the reCaptcha text has missed another signature !16172012-08-27T21:24:41.007321pam BarnesI too cant sign because the reCaptcha wont let me - it is very unreadable and I have tried lots of times. Lots of signatures must be being missed because of this - Why dont you try it out and see for yourselves and do something to put it right.16172012-08-28T09:56:43.46322Simon OsbornereCaptcha is a joke, but try emailing representations"at"scotland.gsi.gov.uk instead16172012-08-28T10:26:04.063324Anthony HickmanYou seem to be doing everything to deter the public from objecting.16172012-08-28T11:05:46.627325Richard BiglandHaving the same problem as those below. Tried numerous times to enter the words and eventually texted to the number given. This has not registered so I have no idea whether my objection has registered or not......16172012-08-28T15:19:26.553327Margaret DaymanI have lost count of the number of times I have tried to do the reCaptcha! The help button is not working so you are doing a good job in making it very difficult to object.16172012-08-28T18:10:47.383328Gillian MacdonaldThe reCaptcha tests written and audio seem not to be working at all. Do you have shares in mobile phone companies? 16312012-08-28T18:32:15.25329Jo MiddelthonLike others I'm unable to object as the reCapture isn't accepting any of the text although correct. I enter. I totally object to the building of these turbines in this unique spot. I sincerely hope it doesn't go ahead. It would be such a mistake.16172012-08-28T21:02:24.987330Robert BardnerNatural countryside at the foothills of the Angus Glens will be ruined forever.16172012-08-28T21:25:40.23331Robert ElsleyMe too - sent a text instead!16172012-08-28T21:52:04.773332Angie LThere is an obvious problem with the reCaptcha that NOONE is BOTHERING to ADDRESS this is ridiculous !16172012-08-28T22:25:55.847333Christine HallCannot sign due to reCaptcha text. And I've tried countless times.16172012-08-29T11:51:03.213334Robert LTried reCaptcha several times, but failed. Don't let this mess the statistics!16172012-08-29T14:28:39.193335Jim BartyI cannot sign due to problems with reCaptcha text. I trust this is not a widespread occurrence, since it would surely undermine the whole point of this protest exercise.16172012-08-29T22:11:46.78337Andrew WalkerTried numerous times but couldn't get any of the reCaptcha text correct.16172012-08-29T23:54:34.25338pam barnesstill cant get in because of the reCatchpa \r\nTHis has happened on several days - you must be missing loads of people - you are supposed to be monitoring the site and I complained a day or so ago but it is just the same - why hasnt anyone done something?16172012-08-29T23:59:38.157339rosy Barnesproblem with reCatchpa please add my name to listof supporters ie against the wind farm16172012-08-30T14:01:15.913340Markus HiemannTeach sustainability early and we may just have a chance.15982012-08-31T08:47:08.443341Frances BarbourPlay is what children do, it is at the core of their being. Every child has the need to play including children in hospital. We need to make sure sick children have access to good play services.15992012-08-31T09:46:31.647343Craig WrightWell done Grant, a great effort.16262012-08-31T09:51:27.553344Claire CannonWell done Grant hopefully now others will be more aware of the risks 16262012-08-31T09:53:40.517345Graham BogleExcellent stuff16262012-08-31T09:56:24.877346Chris LoobyLets save other people the anguish this has brought to Grant & kids16262012-08-31T09:56:52.447347Fiona Munro Well done. Keep up your good work raising awareness. 16262012-08-31T10:06:30.877348Stephen wilsonGood luck! 16262012-08-31T10:30:05.077349janet blountwell done and good luck16262012-08-31T10:30:18.323350Tracy HillisGood luck with this.16262012-08-31T10:47:28.99351Robbyn McLooneAll the best with this!16262012-08-31T10:53:55.563352Mr David BradleyThese poor people need all the help they can get.16262012-08-31T11:14:48.73353Eileen BlackCongratulations on getting this far! Good Luck!!16262012-08-31T11:21:38.457354Lynne KellyThank you..... Everyone needs to know this :)16262012-08-31T11:26:23.46355CRAIG WELSFORDGOOD LUCK MORE PEOPLE NEED TO NO THIS.16262012-08-31T11:43:16.763356annie mitchellplease make all transplant patients be aware 16262012-08-31T12:06:09.647357rosemary sccotlandgood luck Grant, I hope everyone keeps signing xx16262012-08-31T12:06:21.833358Gillian Mckinlay Good luck16262012-08-31T12:24:52.283359Claire Taylor CumbernaukdSharon was a thoroughly decent lass, such a sad loss but if we can make changes in her honour that would be amazing 16262012-08-31T12:40:51.43360Katie SwintonGood Luck. Everyone should know this and be aware of this as well.16262012-08-31T12:42:12.257361sarah killenGood luck to you .keep up the hard work x 16262012-08-31T12:44:58.537362Hazel EadiePlease help other transplant patients. 16262012-08-31T12:48:04.037363Lesley BurtWe need to know all side effects of drugs, medication and hospital procedures in future to ensure this does not happen again. 16262012-08-31T13:13:31.293364Helen McCairnSad sad story..good luck with the petition 16262012-08-31T13:15:28.66365Sean ArgueI am Shaz's father please sign to help others be more aware of this and share the link with your friends16262012-08-31T13:33:43.753366Ian SimpsonPlease make this happen.16262012-08-31T13:48:40.88367Alix StewartEvery person should know the risks...please make this happen!16262012-08-31T13:54:28.167368CharmainePlease make this happen such a sad time.we can all make it happen if we all show our support x16262012-08-31T14:01:30.743369Michael JohnstonIts unbelievable that in this day and age. The companies don't put warnings on the packaging of drugs the high risk of cancer is greatly increased. As I've just lost a best friend to this :(16262012-08-31T14:23:01.357370heather grahamGood luck hope more people sign this16262012-08-31T14:39:02.833371Kayla McDonnellSo sad to hear, my heart goes out to all your family.....I hope the petition makes a difference. 16262012-08-31T14:43:47.68372Vikki beckettMore awareness is definitely needed get signing16262012-08-31T15:34:17.55373Lyndsay fordMore awareness is need. People should know all the risks included and should regularly be screened for side effects including skin cancer. My husband had skin cancer 9 years ago and is lucky to still be here. please help other people do the same x 16262012-08-31T15:49:55.793374Nicola PenderPlease raise this issue..Sharons family have lost such a special woman please help their fight so others are aware of all the facts and this could save others x16262012-08-31T15:59:03.307375Fiona McLearyThe more people read about this and are made aware, the better for everyone16262012-08-31T16:16:06.067376Stephen wilsonThis is important,it only takes a few mins, and could save lifes,please sighn it everyone.\r\n16262012-08-31T16:48:53.21377Yvonne Hendryplease sign this and show your support as more awareness is needed16262012-08-31T17:14:10.197378ANNE ORRif one person is saved through this petition,it will be worth it so please sign up everyone.16262012-08-31T17:26:30.08379Mark O'MailleyHad no idea of the risks. Gladly signed. 16262012-08-31T17:52:30.377380Laura ForresterPlease sign this - such an important cause. Grant, his children and their wider family have experienced such a loss which could have been avoided. x16262012-08-31T18:30:59.093381Dianne RankinPeople need to be fully advised on treatment that may affect their lives in the futue and the consequences of such treatment. If the medical profession is not fully aware, how can we the general public be expect to raise our awareness. The only way to beat Cancer is by prevention and early detection. The medical profession and the public need to pull together only then will we drive down the death rate. I would urge The Scottish Parliament to increase routine screening in all areas. That way lives are saved and surely the cost of screening and saving lives far outweighs the cost of drug treatment, radiotherapy, chemotherapy, hospitalisation further down the lin!16262012-08-31T18:31:39.923382Shirley Payne You owe it to people to keep them aware!! 16262012-08-31T19:12:45.243383Pauline McArdleI hope this campaign and petition help ALL in Scotlsnd get the same information, advice and screening opportunities when they are exposed to th vastly increased risks of dkin cancer when tsking immunosuppressant drugs following transplant. 16262012-08-31T19:25:55.513384Colin PollockThis cause has to be looked into and addressed as a matter of urgency to save any future loss of life and heartache to loving family members.16262012-08-31T20:05:17.61385Donna QuailePlease add my signature to this petition.16262012-08-31T20:32:30.88386Margaret Fergusonno family should be torn apart through lack of information - please sign and get your friends involved to make this happen 16262012-08-31T20:39:21.223387Nicole Punton Please sign we must raise awareness thank you xx16262012-08-31T20:49:33.843388Karen adamson This is so important 16262012-08-31T20:54:26.37389LJRPlease raise awareness, nobody should go through what Sharon and her family had to go through so needlessly. So sad, how would you feel if it was someone in your family??????16262012-08-31T21:29:26.053390Hector MacVicarHoping for change.16262012-08-31T22:56:15.933391Angela LiddleCould everyone please sign this petition to raise awareness of skin cancer risks in patients who have received transplants and improve screening in these patients to prevent tragic deaths like that of our friend Sharon x16262012-09-01T00:03:49.783392MaryShocking that these details are withheld & check-ups not a routine part of aftercare. So sorry to hear of your loss & although I didn't know Sharon she would be so proud of you. Stay strong.\r\n16262012-09-01T02:00:32.677393Mr Baileyto be honest im awaiting for a renal transplant and i couldnt give a flying about the long term effects of immuno suppressants id sooner take that risk than have to continue on dialysis for the rest of my life !!!!16262012-09-01T07:59:00.197394Jackie NeilWhat Grant has achieved thus far is amazing. 16262012-09-01T09:45:27.507395Pauline FrielSo sad that two young children have lost their mum, raising awareness of the cancer risks could help so many families in future.16262012-09-02T00:10:28.657397AnneI support this and hope something is done.16112012-09-02T00:31:58.007398sharon morrisonHave a friend that has had quite a few miscarriages and if this helps in anyway not just for her but all the other women out there going through this awful thing x16112012-09-02T00:50:16.657399claire forbesI will support this 100%, bout time women were treated with respect and investigations sought after their loss instead of being another percentage for a miscarriage statistics. having 1 miscarriage was heartbreaking enough, women need more support and help instead in being shown the exit of the hospital doors.16112012-09-02T11:23:27.753400Kathleen McNabSuch a sad story and more people need to be made aware of the risks, this could have been prevented if all the correct information was given.16262012-09-02T21:28:58.973401Keith WaddellA very worthwhile petition. It's just a shame what has led to this. 16262012-09-03T01:54:58.873402Bella CrawfordThe more awareness the better x16262012-09-03T13:41:01.413403Margaret SloanMore awareness needed on risks of cancer with transplant patients.16262012-09-03T18:32:43.67404Pamela CraigMore information is needed for patients before and after transplant. Well done Grant, you're an inspiration and a credit to your family! 16262012-09-03T22:02:07.093405Derek HendersonFor my wee hero Lucy lou :)16122012-09-03T22:10:20.357406Glen ElliottThis generation will teach the next, and the next, that recycling is simple and necessary and virtually effortless. As a child it was ingrained in us "Be A Tidy Kiwi" and it was us children that taught our parents that it was unacceptable to throw rubbish out the car window. NZ is a better place for it. 15982012-09-03T22:21:38.263407Lynne macmillanNot enough done about it16112012-09-03T23:04:42.72408LeighThe risk of melanoma is a particular problem with transplants. Why is there no regular dermatology check for transplant patients? 16262012-09-03T23:28:14.543409Lisa Gadon signing in support of people with CHD16122012-09-04T21:13:46.017410Jennifer GrayFor our wee CHD man, Ethan :) 16122012-09-04T21:21:12.907411Bruce PaulConsidering the ongoing council statutary notice repairs scandal with estimates for work done to tenament flats doubling in price, i would suggest that VAT is reduced or zero so that owners can oversee their own repairs.16142012-09-05T22:27:04.983412MichelleI never met Sharon, but her Cousin Elaine is my best friend, and I know how much she was loved by everyone who knew her. Such a shame, RIP Sharon, my heart goes out to Gavin & the kids, xXx16262012-09-06T15:03:25.293413Cllr Thomas CochraneThese companies have caused a number of my families in my ward to get into finacial difficulty. There interest rates are way to high and they need to be brought under tighter contol. 16022012-09-10T23:17:31.64414AnonymousThe Scottish Government has a consultation out at present on the future of the Private Rented Sector. You may find you have more success in putting your comments and experiences in a response to the consultation that the Petition. Also I would note that effective property management, a good lease and swift legal action can ensure you evict tenants more quickly. 16312012-09-11T18:28:05.113415Eileen BoyleI am behind this 100%16262012-09-12T16:32:31.507416Maryanne StewartThoughts are with the family and friends at this sad time xxxxxx16262012-09-12T17:29:50.513417John MallonSmoking restrictions divide society, close businesses and cost money.16552012-09-12T20:55:21.76418The ArchivistFunny how smoking bans are so vigorously monitored but no notice is taken of the financial depravity caused!16552012-09-13T00:27:31.873420christopher whittakerthe sooner a review is done the better,before more Pubs etc., and jobs are lost due to the ban.16552012-09-13T02:00:09.307421Sheila MartinMy lifetime dream of a trip to Scotland is on hold until pubs can decide who they wish to cater to. This smoking ban nonsense has gone too far!16552012-09-13T02:20:29.073422Michael McFaddenThere is no sound reason for government imposed smoking bans rather than the simple setting of reasonable, non-biased, air-quality standards for businesses. We tolerate businesses allowing outdoor daytime patio dining despite the fact that solar radiation is a known human carcinogen with no safe level ever having been established, and such outdoor facilities are neither inherent nor necessary to the business of providing food and drink for patrons. If it is necessary to impose a universal smoking ban on pubs then it should also, likewise, be necessary to impose a universal ban on daytime serviced patio drinking and dining. After all "Why should THEY be the ONLY workers forced to work in a carcinogenic environment?"\r\n\r\nMichael J. McFadden\r\nAuthor of "Dissecting Antismokers' Brains"\r\nPhiladelphia, USA16552012-09-13T08:53:10.513423Sean SpillaneThe campaign to amend the smoking ban must succeed other wise the health zealots of this country will up their campaign on alcohol and sooner or later we will be told how many pints we are allowed to drink in a week. Sounds ludicrous but they have got the bit between their teeth and will not stop. There is a greater threat to life than smoking and its always been shoved under the carpet, air pollution. A gov report in March 2010 said that it was thre times more lethal than passive smoking, yet we are told that there is no safe level of second hand smoke. Ask your local MP and council to publish how many of the 82, 000 people die from your area every year. I asked that question in Luton and they could not tell me but said around two hundred die each year in Luton from smoking related diseases. Keep the campaign alive.16552012-09-13T09:25:48.69424Robert Feal-MartinezThe smoking bans in the UK have always been based on false science mainly sponsored by the Pharmaceutical industry but also UK Governments.\r\n\r\nThe truth is passive smoke is virtually harmless. However not content with this ban they are now going after electronic cigarettes because Big D fear the loss of billions from their useless smoking cessation products, some of which have killed dozens of people.16552012-09-13T12:51:25.427425Stephen DuffTeaching and exemplifying what should be matters - let's make sure our schools are definitely included, but not stop there...15982012-09-13T15:19:39.16426mark wernimontAir quality testing across the globe proves shs is far SAFER than required by occupational governing authority OSHA.. Further, new advances in air filtration technology insure that shs 'health hazard' effects are even more greatly reduced.\r\n\r\n 16552012-09-13T17:48:04.443427martin carrollTHIS BAN HAS COST MILLIONS\r\n20,TO 30,OOO JOBS LOST(as a result)\r\nCHANGE IT MAYBE WE GET SOME BACK16552012-09-14T01:50:04.507428Karl Edward TrotterThis is the way forward.16122012-09-14T15:49:42.197429ModeratorWe were recently made aware of a technical difficulty with the reCaptcha system. We are pleased to advise that this difficulty has now been resolved. If anyone becomes aware of a problem with the online petition system could they please report it to petitions@scottish.parliament.uk.\r\n\r\nThank you.16002012-09-14T16:50:32.083430mike cowleyIf the Scottish Parliament is to fulfil its founding principles, a debate at minimum on the provisions of the People's Charter would offer a positive demonstration of its priorities to the Scottish electorate. 16632012-09-14T23:49:04.22431Michael Johnston Let's never let this happen to anyone again as I've lost a best friend. Rip Sharon argue always and forever in our thoughts x x x16262012-09-15T13:00:12.743433Simon MacfarlaneLet's spread the word far and wide on this petition.16632012-09-15T15:56:10.747434Andi BowdenIt seems clear that not all the available evidence was considered before bringing in a completely unnecessary ban. I hope that Scotland will show the world some common sense.16552012-09-16T08:42:50.943435sonia mclay Litter is so unnecessary and affect wildlife \r\nhow would you like it if people dumped their litter in your garden 15982012-09-16T14:19:57.42436Isabelle Buchanan Something should be done,save a lot of heartache !16112012-09-17T08:46:16.04437PeteThe smoking ban is based on lies and deception and the old adage that if you tell a big enough lie and keep telling it people will believe it.\r\n\r\nVentilation is one method that guarantees cleansed air in a smoking environment, many pubs and jobs can be saved now by introducing clean air technology.16552012-09-17T11:15:20.81438Linda ColquhounNot having the appropriate standars in place only causes more anxiety for the patients and their families. 16122012-09-17T13:50:40.273439Raymond MennieThese are the real alternative solutions to the crisis of Capitalism16632012-09-17T14:53:32.13440James MacfarlaneSmoking in public places is not only harmful and unpleasant to those around you. There's no way it should be brought back.16552012-09-17T17:01:56.597441Maggie RossUntil today i did not even realisse there was any such support services such as SACCS, Iam a 41year old mother of three and granny of one, i was born with congenital heart defects which have affected me throughout life but now i feel empowered that there are others out there and that we can support each other and our families.16122012-09-17T17:21:17.527442Marie BrownFully support this petition. After having two miscarriages and being told that they would not check out as to why until I had three, was too frightened to mentally go through another pregnancy but I knew why I had the first two, I would have tried for the baby we so wanted in our family. Thankfully I have a son Matthew whom i love so much but he would have also have liked to be a big brother. My 2nd miscarriage was a missed miscarriage and the treatment you recieve should change 16112012-09-17T18:57:45.377443annamarie ash We need all the help we can get 16122012-09-17T20:25:05.91444Jocelyn Erskine-Kellie, UK expat living in MaltaThe unnecessary smoking ban has contributed to the depressed state of the economy. So many pubs have gone out of business in the UK and many jobs have been lost. Prior to the smoking ban, a lot of pubs in England had good ventilation systems. The smoking ban is based on false science - second hand smoke is virtually harmless - it can be irritating to some people but good ventilation and keeping the place clean can solve that problem. The antismoking zealots have gone too far. Now they're going after e-cigarettes, which have helped people cut down or quit. But of course they're not made by the pharma companies, are they! The sooner this smoking ban is reviewed, the better. Hopefully the rest of the world will follow suit.16552012-09-17T20:41:32.423445Jane HeslopI'm the third of 5 known generations within my family born with Marfan Syndrome. Having experienced the best and worst of parts of our Health Service, I would like my grandchildren to be spared the additional stress of dealing with services that are haphazard. We need fully integrated services in Scotland, and the funding to bring that about. 16122012-09-17T21:40:00.497446Jennifer Graham If the level of service requested by this petition had been available a few years ago, it is likely that my friend would have received the correct treatment when he had his stroke and would have sustained less significant damage.16122012-09-17T23:52:52.6447Stuart PatersonExcellent & much-needed cause.16122012-09-18T01:28:36.393448Robert sewellWe are the lucky ones, make sure you sign up16122012-09-18T10:03:01.917449Billie CochraneThis is for my mammy Maggie Ross.16122012-09-18T10:05:01.917450Jamielee CochraneLove you mammy bear x16122012-09-18T10:35:55.897451Lisa Marie ReillyCould be anyone, mum, dad, son or you16122012-09-18T10:44:13.23452Susan ArchibaldImproved services and resources are needed urgently to give the people of Scotland a better chance in life.16122012-09-18T11:07:42.143453Susan ArchibaldI am keen to support the development of a national standard of care for all Scottish ACHD patients and hope all my friends join me in signing the above petition16122012-09-18T11:45:28.877454David CattoI agree with this petition because it is my hope that wild fishery mis-management will be held to account for their actions over the years. They have continuously attempted to blame fish farming for the demise of sea trout when they have been making introductions of ravenous interbreeding trout for many years and have bought out almost all the netting stations around our coastline thereby allowing that most efficient of hunters, the seal, to have free reign. They have also buried their heads in the sand with regards the hydro schemes across the country which have blocked passage to breeding grounds.16302012-09-18T12:51:03.68455Bill GibsonJames, the science says otherwise. The Smoking Ban was introduced to protect Bar Workers yet by way of a FoI Request the Scottish Government cannot provide any evidence of anyone having died from second hand smoke. Governments have maipulated scientific studies to meet thir own particular agenda and to further the aims of financial backing from the Pharmaceutical Industry.16552012-09-18T15:47:03.19456thomas wilsonwould like to wish you the best of luck hope your petion does some good16632012-09-18T20:17:10.71457C HensonI agree with the majority of that stated in "The People's Charter" but would like to add:\r\n\r\nPLEASE fund CAB fully NOW as the other charitable - council funded advice orgs do NOT work in the interests of justice for the people they work for the broken SYSTEM.\r\n\r\nI remember a 1970's BBC programme, "Tomorrows World" telling us that computerization of industry would lead to reduced working week & increased standards of living for ALL. What it has lead to is GREEDY corporates & successive, self-serving opportunistic puppet governments discarding the people on to a scrap heap.\r\nThis imbalance has been the main cause of the economical & social crisis we find ourselves in today imo.\r\n\r\n 16632012-09-18T20:37:08.5459william blackMy wife is disabled and we need help with dept problems the help out there is almost nil it can take weeks to see someone16002012-09-18T21:19:03.09460Susan SherrySTOP GOING ON ABOUT KATE AND HIGHLIGHT VERY VERY IMPORTANT THINGS LIKE THIS TO HELP PRIMARILY WOMEN BUT WHOLE FAMILIES IN AN EXTREMELY DIFFICULT TIME.\r\n\r\n(Edited by Moderator)16112012-09-19T10:53:16.227461Liza MortonHelen Puttick, Health Correspondant at The Glasgow Herald covered this petition in an article on the 17th of September 2012. It is not possible to post the link here but this article can be easily found online on the Glasgow Herald's website. In this article Helen says "THEY were miracle babies whose lives were saved by groundbreaking surgery but now the first generation of Scottish adults with complex heart defects is campaigning for better NHS treatment." She quotes Gill Mitan, chairwoman of the Bravehearts Patients Association, which represents adults with congenital heart defects, as saying: "Our concern is in the worst-case scenario that an adult presenting at accident and emergency will be sent home and suffer a sudden cardiac death because they did not have timely specialist support."\r\n\r\nThank you to everyone who has signed this petition so far. 16122012-09-19T10:58:59.323462Care-AwareMy whole-hearted support goes out for all those who need more support for their hearts!16122012-09-19T13:31:49.07463KarenIt happened a long time ago but you never really get over it 18th October 1987 RiP x16112012-09-19T19:52:56.333464Morag MacAlisterA great deal of time and effort goes into treatment during childhood and this support must be lifelong.16122012-09-19T22:26:41.283465A I have pulmonary stenosis and I am grateful for all the skill and knowledge of those who have monitored my condition since birth ! 16122012-09-20T08:59:08.533466gill bodenI entirely endorse this petition16122012-09-20T10:01:21.527467PeteI would just like to add that the RCP do not have any evidence that one person has died from this mysterious second hand smoke and that their so called formula for calculating deaths by second hand smoke is purely hypothetical. I urge the Scottish Parliament to contact the RCP along with the Scottish press so that true facts can be published.16552012-09-20T13:46:39.413469Rose HarvieAs Secretary of a Community Council in Dumbarton, where there is a marked degree of poverty and unemployment, and where the High Street is already dominated by the outlets mentioned in the Petition, I have been asked by ilverton and Overtoun Community Council support Mr McColl's Petition. The last thing we need in Dumbarton is yet more betting shops and cheap loan shops, and we urge the Scottish Parliament to grant the Petition.16022012-09-20T15:14:05.997470victoria greenI have signed this as my dad had a major heart attack and thanks to the help of the golden jubilee hospital in glasgow my dad is now healthy and enjoying life with his 4 grandchildren.16122012-09-20T15:49:27.64471Dr Malcolm James CookI feel it is important for society to help all people fairly to enjoy their life and to contribute, but especially to help those who cannot help themselves.16632012-09-20T18:24:08.757472Lynsey PattieIan, If you live in Scotland, the scottish association for mental health (SAMH) have a debt service. have a look on their website16002012-09-20T21:35:34.12474Sarah DonaghyEvery year for 33 years now at my babys due date I cry.Its something I can never ever forget. My poor baby lost forever. I was told at the time that it 'was just one of things', go away and try again in three months. Not good enough.16112012-09-20T21:37:46.8475Claire LonieIn support of all the lost angels16112012-09-20T22:15:02.01476ann mcmahonnever happened to me but right behind u all 100% xx16112012-09-20T22:56:17.617477Amanda DohertyI hope this helps to get things changed. 16112012-09-21T10:16:57.353478Jim WhyteAusterity robs the poor to put money in the pockets of the rich and that is what it is intended to do.We lose £100 billion every year to the tax-dodging rich..The richest 1,000 people in Britain have increased their personal wealth by £155 billion in the past three years.No austerity for them! Time we stopped being taken for mugs. There is no shortage of money, it just happens to be in the hands of the wrong people. Workers by hand and by brain create the wealth, it is time they owned it. Defend our Welfare State that we fought so hard to win and build. No return to the 1930s! All power to the people's Charter and an end to Tory Party rule. I was born into a 1930s Tory Britain, I don't want to die in one!16632012-09-21T13:15:09.42479Caroline MacGregorIf it were not for the dedication,expertise and commitment of the staff at the SACCU at the Golden Jubilee Hospital I would not be here to sign this petition. All patients with congenital heart defects should have access to the same treatment. 16122012-09-21T16:31:41.307480Pam MacdonaldThinking of all the wee sleeping angels when signing this, sleep tight xx16112012-09-22T13:23:07.073481E.P.DrummondEvery person should have the right to appeal or contest an injustice, yet that is not the case. We have Laws that favour the rich & powerful in Scotland and the working classes are of only secondary or of no importance. I was child of the 50's both my Late husband & myself were hard working yet because he died intestate (no issues) I'm not allowed to keep what is rightfully mine & no legal right to appeal or contest it. (I have recently submitted a petition please read it when it is lodged & if in agreement please support it.)16632012-09-22T20:01:00.68482John HughesThis smoking ban is a ridiculous violation of our human rights. By all means impose restrictions in public places, but on private property? Completely assinine and totally unacceptable. Whatever happened to us Brits fighting for our rights? What a nation of wimps we've become. 16552012-09-23T22:29:41.693483Ian BrownWe went through this as a family and they should change the way the nhs do things, my wife had two miscarriages and we where called into the same room and we called it the BAD NEWS ROOM, this should change as it so hard hearing the news that you have lost a baby \r\n16112012-09-24T00:28:05.877484Margaret DurranceWe travel a lot but choose our destinations on how smoking friendly the country is. At the moment you're not. Save your economy.\r\n16552012-09-24T10:22:24.88485Liza MortonA significant number of people have reported that they couldn't get past the capcha code when trying to sign this. We have lost many other signatures because their were false instructions to a texting facility that hadn't been set up. I hope this is noted when numbers are compiled. \r\n\r\nThank you to everyone who has persisted & managed to sign. 16122012-09-24T10:34:29.917486B.M.ConnaughtonA totalitarian,blanket ban has no\r\nplace in a nation which has given \r\nso many of its young in the defence of freedom and liberty elsewhere.\r\nSo many lies,so much deception ,\r\nso many half truths,such an avalanche of junk science,not to\r\nmention a background of financial reward from corporate interest.\r\nThe Ban is little more than an\r\nexposition of puritanical spite,\r\nunfit for a modern Democracy.16552012-09-24T11:00:32.57487Archie RoyLast year I benefited from major heart surgery at The Golden Jubilee Hospital to resolve a major congenitical heart defect. I cannot say enough in praise of the expert care I received at this hospital and for their support.\r\n\r\nSince then I have met many patients some of whom have suffered from heart defects from birth and have to live with the consequences of their condition for the rest of their lives. It seems inconceiveable to me that the Scottish Government is unable to provide a level of service to congenital heart suffers which is at least as good as elsewhere in the UK. I was astonished to find that this is not the case.\r\n I read in The Herald on 17 Sept 2012 that the Scottish Government is waiting for the England & Wales guidelines to be reviewed before taking any action. On the basis that future guidelines in England & Wales are likely to be no worse than at present, surely the least NHS Scotland can do is to move towards the scale of provision currently being provided elsewhere. \r\n\r\nWhy should health provision on this important issue in Scotland be tied to a review taken elsewhere especially as there is no Scottish control of the process? What if that review in England doesn't take place for some time? What will happen in the meantime?\r\n\r\nI fully support this petition.16122012-09-24T11:03:26.86488Steve Shepherdl'll be honest and say that l see little chance of petitions working until we can get the message out on the streets. Majority of smokers simply don't use the internet and those that do use it for such as Facebook or Ebay. Without funds to reach these people nothing will be achieved. Without the backing of the pub chains and tobacco companies our voice will never be heard.16552012-09-24T14:56:36.36490Bill GibsonSteve, On this occasion the Petition has the support of the Scottish Licensed Trade Association and has been featured in the media over the weekend in the Scotsman and the Scottish Sunday Express. Hope springs eternal that vicory will be ours one day soon as on this occasion, the issue is one of Air Management Technology , not tobacco, not ETS but that of 21st century technology removing a mix of chemicals that are all around us to an approved Indoor Air Quality Standard.16552012-09-24T22:56:08.71491BraveheartsHealth Services in Scotland should not be dependant on what is happening in England & Wales as Health is a devolved issue. We as a patient group have supported the SACC service since its inception and continue to do so. Adults with CHD deserve and require excellent and timely care at the point of need. We fully support the campaign for CHD Care Standards in Scotland and urge the Scottish Government to implement the standards as a priority in this term of Government.16122012-09-25T10:02:28.93492Paul SmithThe Elderly are often targeted by violent individuals as they are easy targets. Working with these offenders is dangerous.It is realistic to expect staff up to 68 years of age to physically restrain and intervene in violent incidents with young, fit and sometimes disturbed prisoners. Would you want your Grandparents to be patrolling overcrowded prisons, trying to make society a safer place for everyone. We ask the goverment to recognise Prison Officers status as a first response emergency service and as such allow a retirment age of 60.16632012-09-25T14:15:42.923494Alec JohnstonI counted less than 20 signatures on this petition from people saying they are from Scotland today (25th Sept).\r\nAround 110 people from elsewhere in the world have signed.\r\nDoesn't this impart a very strong mandate to the Scottish Parliament to keep the smoking ban as it is?16552012-09-25T19:16:28.987495Shelly HerdDoing this for a special friend at this very sad time x16112012-09-25T22:04:46.363496Karen kellyWent threw it 3 times its the worst feeling ever,thoughts go out to those who its happened too16112012-09-26T11:38:41.56497John WattLet everyone retire at the age of 60 and let the young population into the work force, I have worked since i was 12 years of age due to my father being in a fatal accident in the late sixties. Their is a lot of people out their like myself who would like to call a day. This Goverment wants everyone to retire when we are fit for nakers yard just like our cars, then dispose us into our graves to save giving us our pentions to what we deserve. 16632012-09-26T15:43:58.4498Gabi Luscia ColemanWhether you smoke or not, it is important to stand up against the smoking ban in pubs and clubs. The pub, working mans' club, bingo hall and meeting rooms for the elderly are closing, communities are breaking down and persons are becoming isolated as a result. A business should be free to thrive and make decisions about the facilities that are demanded and supply the demand.16552012-09-26T17:33:31.507499Bill GibsonAs you have signed the Petition Alex, you should then promote the cause at every opportunity. Why be governed by gross misinformation when it is easier to present the truth? A quote from Andy Kerr MSP, Health Minister on the 26th March 2006 on STV " There are 4000 carcinogens in second hand smoke" and I hae the evidence on video to present to the Petitions Committee.16552012-09-26T19:22:04.707500Andrew HirstThis illiberal act by the nanny state should be challenged everywhere,16552012-09-27T11:05:34.553501Frank JThere are not '4000 carcinogens' in tobacco smoke. There are 4000 chemicals, only a handful being in the slightest carcinogenic and none above the approved safety levels.16552012-09-27T12:56:26.107502Chas WinfieldIt doesn't matter whether there is no wind or not it is far healthier to sit in a pub where there is smoking and ventilation than sitting outside, because the ventilation inside will take nearly all the smoke out of the room but outside the smoke will go sideways (sidestream).16552012-09-27T13:20:04.487503Alec JohnstonAre you referring to me Bill Gibson? I haven't signed this petition, unless someone has forged my name on it. \r\n\r\nWhy do you think so few Scots have signed the petition?\r\n\r\nSurely the Scottish Parliament shouldn't be influenced by signatories from USA, Canada, England, Italy, Croatia, Jersey, Germany, Denmark, Australia, Netherlands, Brazil, Taiwan, Wales, Ireland and Greece.\r\n\r\nThis smacks of the efforts of the international tobacco lobbying community rather than being something of real interest to genuine Scottish citizens. Only 19 or 20 signatories say they are from Scotland (1pm on 27 9 12)\r\n\r\nIf this was a big issue in Scotland, wouldn't more Scottish people have signed up? \r\n\r\nIt can't be that people don't know about it. 175 people from outside of Scotland have found their way here and signed.\r\n\r\nIt was in the Scotsman on 21st September.\r\n\r\nEverything points to Scots liking the current arrangements, and only a tiny minority of the population, most already engaged in smoking pressure groups, being motivated to sign this petition.16552012-09-27T13:28:59.243504sam macartneystop making the poor pay for the mistakes of others, our health and public services must remain protacted from the private sectors greed!, our children must have a future not the dole!16632012-09-27T14:42:35.727505Jack CurrieScotland needs to follow the example of several other countries, for example the Swiss, in allowing a measure of choice to its population. A return to complete freedom for smokers is never going to come but provision of limited facilities - e.g. separate rooms in pubs - is in no way an infringement of non-smokers' liberties and is indeed an indication that Scotland is a place where diverse people can live in harmony and with respect for others' rights and privileges.16552012-09-27T16:03:19.853506I.G.EllisI wish this petition all the best, I am a non smoker,but have seen the financial destruction this selfish,nasty unnecessary meddling has caused to the UK & other countries16552012-09-27T16:31:50.273507Bill GibsonAlex\r\n\r\nYou should consider that there are many ex-pats on the list born and bred Scots. Just because you are agaist free choice and prefer dictatorship does not give you the right to impose such on the rest of us 16552012-09-27T17:47:50.277508Bill GibsonAlex would do well to consider Article 1 of The Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948\r\n\r\nAll human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood. \r\n\r\nWe scots are well known for our open welcome to others, the First Minister wants ex-pats to return to their homeland but first of all we need to be seen to be tollerant and accommodating to encourage them home and to bring their friends with them.\r\n\r\n&6% of the nation wanted choice when the sham Consultation took place in 2005 ... look what we got and now the pub trade is on its knees.16552012-09-27T21:17:23.7509graham allewayThe ban has always been about prejudice against tobacco enjoyment, and preference of the anti tobacco lobby. A so called charity, a much distorted description these days, only exists to continually deny the liberty to enjoy a vice in peace and comfort. Their charity status should be removed, and sponsors denied the right to fuel the machine with donors money. Funds should be used for proper charitable work, not supporting political organisations. It is OK to provide help for people who wish to give up tobacco, but not engage in stigmatising, or encouraging employers and public services to impose prejudice that they have no right to do so. The ban has been a catastrophic financial and social disaster. If the same degree of extremism was applied to alcohol then weird pictures should replace the enticing labels and logos. Sponsorship money would be stopped for sporting events. Cars would be forced to display accident pictures across the bodywork, burgers would be badged with clogged arteries. The ban has been so negative and divisive, it would have been better to have improved air conditioning in pubs and clubs, creating jobs in that industry and accommodating an inclusive comfortable environment. A more balanced approach would have been gained if groups concerned with tobacco were staffed with a majority of tobacco users that would have prevented the prejudice and distorted outcome we have now. Sensible restrictions on tobacco use i am sure is supported by all, but nonsense bans, extremism and prejudice just discredits those who promote such. Respect and provision for all is a much more civilised way forward. Perhaps as the screw turns and the antis realise that extremism and prejudice isolates them, and has no place in a tolerant and inclusive society, they might adopt a fairer stance. After all the first person on the scene in their moment of need might be smoker, as we exist in every sector of society.16552012-09-27T23:07:15.473510Alec JohnstonBill, my name is Alec. You say that "there are many ex-pats on the list born and bred Scots". I presume from this that you must know everyone on the list from your pro-tobacco lobbying activities.\r\nI'm not imposing anything on you. The will of the people of Scotland is very clear from their absence from the petition signatories.\r\nI don't think the Scottish Parliament should be influenced by a showing of your tobacco lobby friends from USA, Canada, England, Italy, Croatia, Jersey, Germany, Denmark, Australia, Netherlands, Brazil, Taiwan, Wales, Ireland and Greece. 16552012-09-28T00:02:04.067511David GavinStop making the Poor ,Infirm,Elderly the scape goats for everything .Renationalize everything at no cost to the country and make the rich pay there way and if they want to leave the country let them but let the state retain there assets .Then we may have a level playing field and be rid of the class system and have a new synergy16632012-09-28T12:55:36.49512Belinda CunnisonUnlike the Scotsman and the Express, Alec dismisses the petition purely on the number of signatures. The petition was reported by journalists who had read it and considered it added to the discussions we have had so far. Alec states the international source of signatures means that the campaign is orchestrated by the tobacco companies, and then alleges that Bill Gibson knows personally everyone who has signed . \r\n\r\nNone of this is relevant. The petition looks at whether the hospitality industry should make use of air quality standards and air cleaning equipment (designed to remove toxins that are perilous to health in the _immediate_ term, and so _far_ more toxic than tobacco smoke, where there is significant dispute about its _long-term_ effects) in order to allow smoking in hospitality and recreational venues, and also ridding the air of toxins from all other sources.\r\n\r\nTo say that the will of the people of Scotland is decided on the level of signatures is absurd. The discussion is only just beginning.16552012-09-28T16:12:38.03513Alec JohnstonBelinda\r\nHow else are we to judge support for an issue other than by the numbers of people who support it. The fact that Bill Gibson knows all the people who've signed shows that it is only a bunch of lobbyists who are bothered enough to sign. And only around 10% of them are from Scotland.16552012-09-28T16:28:35.597514Bill GibsonAlec, you present us with the classic symptom of a Tobacco Control Advocate. You may well recognise the disease when you look at this web site\r\n\r\ngoogle.... tobacco control tactics dot org16552012-09-28T17:07:43.147515Alec JohnstonBelinda\r\nIt is wrong to say that 'all toxins have safe levels listed in ...EH40'. EH40 lists maximum exposure levels, not 'safe levels'. It also doesn't give a 'level' for some of the carcinogens in tobacco smoke, eg benzopyrene or some of the carcinogenic combustion products of nicotine, eg nitrosomines.\r\nIndustry doesn't use general ventilation to deal with carcinogens and similarly harmful agents. The most toxic compounds are handled in completely sealed glove box fume cupboards. Slightly less toxic compounds might be handled in high flowrate fume cupboards with a restricted open area in the front. As we get less toxic you would have to use local exhaust ventilation which uses powerful suction to remove the dust or gas from next to where it is generated, as with woodwork machines or welding in enclosed places. Despite what current and former ventilation salesmen might tell you, to comply with health and safety law when handling carcinogens it is the requirement to reduce the air levels to as far as is reasonably practicable, not just to the standards in EH40, which you have very selectively quoted in your petition. As it is possible to lower the concentration of carginogen exposure to workers to levels far lower than general ventilation can achieve, these methods described earlier would still have to be used. I hope the Scottish Parliament will run your proposals past the Health and Safety Executive for some impartial and expert advice. 16552012-09-28T17:22:45.75516Jim McNaughtI do wonder why the "Tabloid" press do not inform their readership of this petition,after all most people read these "papers" and are most affected by the issues it addresses.16552012-09-28T17:27:44.157517Sarah LindsayMy daughter suffered this condition throughout both pregnancies-definitely need a specialist nurse for support16412012-09-28T17:55:07.51518Bill GibsonOh Alec, another clasic symptom by a Tobacco Control Advocate namely bending the truth to suit you agenda. Where have I claimed that I knew all these people you must try harder, much hrder in future to get you facts right.. \r\n\r\n16552012-09-28T18:41:23.553519Bill GibsonAlec, to avoid further confusion I will attempt to enlighten you .\r\n1. I am a lifelong non-smoker\r\n2. I know some of the signatories, many I would like to know.\r\n3. We Scots lost our right to control our own destiny in December 2010 when the UK signed the Lisbon Treaty.\r\n4. The current Smoking Ban was as a result of demands made by the EU as we hold documentation dated 2002 detailing how legislation should be enforced, how anyone defying such a ban should be delt with and to make examples of any high profile decenters.\r\n5. As the EU is a Partner of the United Nations, other nationalities have a right to participate in any debate created to make amendments as seen fit and to ensure that fairness prevails throughout all UN member nations.\r\n\r\nAs there are already internationally accepted Indoor Air Quaity Standards in operation it is only right that the Smokefree Legislation be revisited to take into account 21st century Air Management Technology linked to these Standards already in operation and in particular those approved across all EU member states for the reasons given earlier.\r\n\r\n16552012-09-28T19:27:41.91520C,petersIf you smoke get this signed16552012-09-28T21:08:05.57522Gillian Mckie I've had 5 miscarriages And it's horrific, totally in support of this petition. My love and prayers to everyone suffering from the pain of recurrent miscarriages. Xx16112012-09-28T22:55:56.993523Mike Holden Please allow smoking in pubs and bring back joie-de-vivrel. 16552012-09-28T23:38:16.783524pamela jarvisabsolutely.16112012-09-29T04:31:09.99525Prof. Mark PowellThere has been too few studies about the impacts of farmed salmonids on the interactions with wild fish. Those studies that have been conducted in manycases are seriously flawed scientifically. The continued mismanagement of rivers around teh world by governments who are undertaking so called ecological enhancement and protection is only making issues significantly worse. It is time we had some solid science and evidence and that rivers start to be managed properly by those who actually know about the biology.16302012-09-29T14:27:38.323526susan taylor well said Belinda this should have been the answer from the start, then we would not have had closure of so many pubs and our elderly and disabled would still be able to enjoy there social life instead of not going out for fear of getting soaked or catching colds while enjoying there cigarette or pipe.\r\nThe only enjoyment some of the elderly had was there afternoon in the pub with there friends a game of dominoes and there smoke. Some of whom fought in the war for there country what a way to treat them. The solution should have been the equipment to filter the air and let these old veterans enjoy there time left on this earth. We have not got the climate to send old people outside for a smoke and let's not forget when they started smoking it was pushed on them by all the advertising and cheap cigarettes from the service.16552012-09-29T15:06:08.46527Ronnie MoranEveryone needs decent affordable homes, decent secure jobs, free education,free healthcare and a safetynet of welfare benefits ensuring the well being of all.\r\nWe need to protect the vulnerable in society with decent pensions and disability benefits.\r\n 16632012-09-29T22:49:54.17528Hugh Gaffney I have attended public meetings hearing first hand, how the elderly are suffering poverty as we approach the winter, with making the choice of Heat or Eat, going to bed early to reduce fuel cost of gas and electricity. \r\nThey have heard from workers in poverty, with low wages subsidize by benefits, struggling to give their children what they need, with the rising cost of living and wages been frozen or getting a token rise of 1% and to be grateful for the rise in low pay for their hard work. We have seen disabled jobs closed down, with Remploy a safe haven for disabled workers, who were proud to work and enjoyed going to work. Now we hear of disabled people in wheelchairs being told if they can use their upper limbs, they are no longer classed as disabled but able bodied to do work, which means a reduction on their welfare benefit. \r\nyoung people have less chance of securing a job now as to oppose 5 years ago. Clearly young people getting into a job, is a struggle, with many taking on any job with part time hours or zero hour contracts just to get on the ladder. We need to see a growth in jobs with decent pay and better conditions than a zero hour contract, where our youth are being exploited, we face a generation of workers without employment. 16632012-09-30T00:28:39.16529heather greenI have suffered this condition twice.It is a very isolating and debilitating condition.\r\nIt is not taken seriously in my opinion,especially in hospitals!It would help immensely to have someone trained to provide the care necessary for the women experiencing this cruel condition especially at a time which is supposed to be the most enjoyable experience in a woman's life.16412012-09-30T12:52:27.62530Charles GrayScotland is the true home of Socialism: with our \r\nTrade Unions, let's recover what is best for those \r\nin need!16632012-09-30T20:41:40.067532Julie MichieMy husband and I suffered a silent miscarriage in 2010. We went for our 12 week scan to be told that there was no heart beat. We were ushered to a room where other people were waiting for their scans, which was awful other obviously pregnant women. We were offered three choices how to get rid of our much wanted baby. Our baby left us three days later on valentines day. Only when this happens to you you realize how common miscarriage is. I work for the Nhs and now money is tight, however I think it is unspeakable to be expected to have multiple miscarriages before you are investigated! We were lucky we then went onto have a beautiful baby girl. My mum says everything happens for a reason- she also has had a miscarriage, maybe so! If our first baby had have survived we wouldn't have our daughter !16112012-10-01T08:53:46.17533Esther NolanWe should have at least some places where we can sit have a coffee and a cig it's getting beyond a joke16552012-10-01T09:59:55.067534Alec JohnstonBill, in you list of enlightening information you neglect to say that you were a ventilation salesman, and seem to spend a big chunk of your life posting links to ventilation system promotional literature. As a former ventilation system supplier you really should be honest and tell teh Scottish Parliament that the most effective way to remove pollutants from the air that people breathe is firstly not to have them created in the first place, and secondly to remove them at source so they don't mix with the air in the room. Your petition proposes the far less effective version of letting the smoke mix with the air as it is created, then filtering the air. This is not the most reasonably practicable solution, and therefore wouldn't meet the requirements of EH40 for carcinogens. I sincerely hope the Scottish Parliament don't let themselves be duped by your sales pitch.16552012-10-01T10:46:29.973535Bill GibsonAlex, in 2005 for approximately 6 months of my career, I looked into the market potential on. behalf of Tornex Europe (including attending the SLTA Seminar on 13th January 2005 in Edinburgh on their behalf). At no time did I sell, or technically support the installation of any equipment for that company and acted on a self employed, consultancy basis. Unless you can prove otherwise then you are treading on very dangerous, legal grounds.\r\n\r\nBeyond that, I have taken my own personal time (unpaid) to research the market, the manufacturers and the very, very interesting subject of Indoor Air Quality issues especially in the healthcare environment and the subjects of MRSA and C-dif. \r\n\r\nI now challenge you to make public your proof of your claims regarding my career or to make a pubilc apology.16552012-10-01T11:22:48.53536Bill GibsonAlec, whta to fail to include in your views regarding workplace chemical hazards is that all measurable chemicals have a safe limit of exposure based upon an 8 hour working day.\r\n\r\nScience holds the key, look towards Close Coupled Field Technology (CCFT) or Plasmacluster Ion Technology where the ions attach themselves to th pollutants, changing their molicular structure, rendering the polutant harmless and turning it into a water vapour.. Such systems can also be installed within existing ventilation, air filtration ducts so there is no major redesign of a building HVAC system. 16552012-10-01T12:06:12.143537Irene MurrayWonderful role for a midwife - not a nurse!16412012-10-01T12:06:39.41538Bill GibsonOh, and don't worry Alec, should I be afforded the opportunity of speaking to the Committee, I will make sure that they are aware of any vested interests that need to be declared in advance of making my views known, such as that I represent an Organistion Member of the Human Rights Cross-Party Group within the Scottish Parliament and have done for sweveral years. This position has brought me into contact with several senior politicians over the years and I would not compromise my or their positions by not disclosing anything that is relevent to this Petition.16552012-10-01T12:36:33.097539Alec JohnstonBill, you declare that "all measurable chemicals have a safe limit of exposure based upon an 8 hour working day". What is that level for each of the carcinogens in tobacco smoke? Is simply achieving the level for a carcinogen good enough for EH40, or do you have to go lower if a method to reduce it further exists and is reasonably practicable? And what level of the carcinogens in tobacco smoke is 'safe' for the ones not listed in EH40?16552012-10-01T13:29:01.287540Bill GibsonAlec, what makes you think that carcinogens are different be it they are derived from tobacco smoke, smoke from an open fire, smoke from a bbq, smoke from frying. The same carcinogens are released from the soft furnishings within a room as a result of the manufacturing process or chemical cleaning agents. So can you actually determine the source of the 6 carcinogens that have been identified as being cancer causing that may or may not be present in a room where tobacco may or may not have been used. I know the answer by do you?16552012-10-01T14:54:04.393541Bill GibsonAlec, you should be addressing your concerns to the Health and Safety Executive not me as they have clearly stated that they cannot offer evidence that second hand smoke is an increased risk to health. \r\n\r\nIt is also noted that as yet you have not offered a shred of evidence that I acted in a sales capacity within the Ventilation Industry and would therefore expect a withdrawal of your claim and an apology.16552012-10-01T15:57:15.727542Alec JohnstonBill, I apologised for assuming you were a salesman in a post that has not been published. I'll apologise again, and note that you merely worked for Tornex as a self employed consultant.\r\nYou're being evasive about the carcinogen requirements of EH40. Is that because you don't understand, or because it destroys your argument that ventilation (other than fume cupboard or local exhaust) would be acceptable to reduce carcinogen levels to the degree required by EH40? 16552012-10-01T15:58:28.413543Bill GibsonFor anyone who is interested in the truth this is an excellent read Toxic Toxicology by Littlewood & Fennel16552012-10-01T18:15:19.94544Bill GibsonFinally\r\n\r\nGoogle JTI, Dubai Airports and JCDecaux unveil striking smoking lounge initiative\r\n\r\nProof if any is needed that this is the way forward to save what remains of our hospitality sector and to boost the economy creating jobs instead of losing them.16552012-10-01T19:35:11.553545Bill GibsonFinally, finally\r\n\r\nAlec, as the HSE, OSHA (USA) and MAK (Germany) operate in parallel, the data presented in Toxic Toxicology (see previous post) may be applied to all three.\r\n\r\nAs is shown in the chart, the chemicals are of extreme trace elements, presenting no real health hazzards when exposed over a typical 8 hour work pattern.16552012-10-01T19:35:54.103546WendyLiving in the USA. Please realize that the world it watching.16112012-10-01T21:26:57.99547Alec JohnstonBill's suggested read is not the truth, and is popular with the pro-smoking groups he associates with. For proper, unbiased advice about ventilation and hazardous substances like carcinogens, go to the HSE website and read their advice. "Local exhaust ventilation (LEV), or extraction, is an engineering control solution to reduce exposures to dust, mist, fume, vapour or gas in a workplace. \r\nUse a properly designed LEV system that will draw dust, fume, gases or vapour through a hood or booth away from the worker. \r\nAn extraction system should be easy for workers to use and enclose the process as much as possible. \r\nIt should effectively capture and contain the harmful substance before it is released into the working environment." Bill and this petition are advocating a far less effective system than HSE describe.\r\n16552012-10-01T22:47:37.32548Linda HanrattyMy daughter was born in 1971 with a congenital heart defect and is now 41 years old, give our children a chance, a future and allow them to grow old like us.16122012-10-02T07:31:07.35549stephen mc killop when will stop cutting and start investing in our future ? cuts to frountline service and attacks on the sick and disabiled via Adeso are a reflection on the state of our nation and is a national shame 16632012-10-02T09:07:14.24550Bridget HarrisThis is an important issue long overdue for sorting out16142012-10-02T09:34:03.96551Bill GibsonThere are many well ventilated Smokers Lounges in existance, working within the respective country's Occupational Health Limits. ETS is no more dangerous than other Occupational Hazards such as Paint Spray Boothes etc. \r\n\r\nwww.osha.europa.eu.en.topics.ds.oel.members.stm\r\n\r\nsubstitute . for forward slash16552012-10-02T10:49:17.1552Belinda CunnisonAlec, what you say about isolating the toxins assumes that the ambient air is clean. But we know that there is ambient pollution everywhere because of the UK breaking records in its emissions. Declaring air clean and safe because it doesn't hold cigarette smoke does not wash.16552012-10-02T13:10:54.937554Alec JohnsonBill, why don't you answer my questions? Is it because you don't understand, or is it because a truthful answer would destroy your case.16552012-10-02T23:43:50.343555Belinda CunnisonIn answer to Alec Johnson, or Johnston, your suggestion to Bill Gibson at 21.26 refers to only one kind of air cleaning technology, but not one suitable for tackling ambient air: see links on plasmacluster technology. You will have to look them up.16552012-10-02T23:46:47.133556Harriet Sophie Wyn-EvansI lost my first baby in 1997 whilst a student in Dundee due to undiagnosed HG 16412012-10-03T16:46:21.817557Alec JohnstonBelinda, you are missing the whole point, and it just shows how poor your understanding of the requirements of EH40 is. It doesn't matter how effectively you can clean the air, the whole hierarchy of controls for COSHH and for ventilations of airborne carcinogens doesn't allow for the carcinogenic pollutant to be emitted into the air of the workplace, regardless of levels, if a more effective means exists for eliminating exposure. And it does. But you and Bill won't talk about elimination or local exhaust ventilation. 16552012-10-03T16:52:19.957558Alec JohnstonFrom the manufacturers - and not a very reassuring assessment of the capability in the real world of pubs and clubs, "Again, we can not guarantee that in real conditions we will eliminate the virus and chance of spread but Plasmacluster is a real tool in helping to prevent infection in the air."16552012-10-03T16:59:01.433559Alec JohnstonMore from the manufacturer about the product you are suggesting will protect people from carcinogenic chemicals if your petition is successful, "Plasmacluster Ions have no immediate effect on chemicals". In your quest to smoke in pubs, you are being remarkably cavalier with other people's health. I didn't get these quotes from a detractor or competitor. They are from the manufacturer's website. 16552012-10-03T17:03:23.17560Alec JohnstonFinal few quotes from the manufacturer. "PCI products are not medical equipment and therefore we do not claim that they will prevent infection. " But then they say "Plasmacluster is a real tool in helping to prevent infection in the air." And "The test results were obtained under controlled laboratory conditions. In an actual room, the efficacy will be affected by factors such as room shape, appliance location, and windows. Results will not be exactly the same as those obtained in tests" So even the manufacturer doesn't claim that they will work in the real world for tobacco smoke.16552012-10-03T18:45:13.643561BelindaActually Alec I don't believe that the manufacturer specifically excludes tobacco smoke. But give me a link if that is what it does.\r\n\r\nIf we exclude everything from the marketplace that did not achieve in the real world what it achieves in the lab, not much would be invented at all. Where equipment is critical to safety of course checks, maintenance and improvements have to be made. But if the equipment did not make a noticeable difference to air quality there would be no demand for it. Saying it is not as good in the workplace as in the lab does not necessarily mean that it is not fit for purpose.16552012-10-03T18:53:42.83562Bill GibsonThe response to a Freedom of Information Request by Tobacco Control Department, Edinburgh\r\n\r\n We hold no information about actual deaths due to passive smoking. It is not possible to give precise figures on deaths resulting from tobacco use16552012-10-03T18:54:19.923563Belinda CunnisonActually I don't believe that the manufacturer specifically excludes tobacco smoke. \r\n\r\nIf we exclude everything from the marketplace that did not achieve in the real world what it achieves in the lab, not much would be invented at all. Where equipment is critical to safety of course checks, maintenance and improvements have to be made. But if the equipment did not make a noticeable difference to air quality there would be no demand for it. Saying it is not as good in the workplace as in the lab does not necessarily mean that it is not fit for purpose.16552012-10-03T18:54:36.25564Belinda CunnisonNobody said that the machine was medical equipment and who said anything about viruses? \r\n\r\nAs for rules prohibiting a carcinogen being released unnecessarily, that is moot. First of all the ambient air already contains carcinogens. The current system does not require the removal of anything except tobacco smoke.16552012-10-03T19:04:37.693565Belinda CunnisonSecondly smoking is a societal phenomenon in which up to one quarter of the population partakes. More in some districts, less in others. Prohibiting public smoking makes it harder for them to get together, which diminishes their quality of life.16552012-10-03T20:13:44.8566Dermot HanwayWhy are the majority of signatories not from Scotland?16552012-10-03T20:28:24.85567Bill GibsonAlec\r\n\r\nPoint of Law ..... Kay Labate v Commission of the European Communities\r\n\r\n16552012-10-04T08:10:38.137568Otto KjaergaardI am have been frequent traveller to Scotland for many years, I have seen how much damage this ban has done to your pubs. I dont smoke myself but being in a pub with smokers is always a very good experience. Your Scottish pubs are World Heritage and must be protecred as such.16552012-10-04T09:23:07.443569Bill GibsonDermot ... until at least October 2014 Scotland is part of the United Kingdom, therefore many of the signatures that have the United Kingdom shown may well be from residents within Scotland.16552012-10-04T12:51:28.963570Alec JohnstonDermot, a similarly pertinent question would be why there are so many signatories to the petition from the international pro-smoking movements. Bill seemed to suggest he knew most of them in an earlier post and he is, after all, a mover and shaker in a few international pro-smoking (although he'd probably try the tired argument that they're pro-freedom) movement. I don't go with the 'freedom' angle that they trot out because addicts aren't 'free'.16552012-10-04T13:00:02.123571Alec JohnstonBill, your point of law is irrelevant to this. Why are you bringing in irrelevant points when the key issue is that your proposed ventilation solution won't be good enough to meet the requirements of EH40?16552012-10-04T13:02:33.923572Alec JohnstonBelinda, the equipment manufacturer says " "Plasmacluster Ions have no immediate effect on chemicals". You are claiming that they somehow make tobacco smoke safe. The manufacturer says they have no immediate effect on the carcinogenic chemicals in the smoke.16552012-10-04T13:06:28.59573Eddie DouthwaiteThe comprehensive evidence which will be given to the Petitions Committee by the petitioner will prove the effectiveness of Air Filtration systems and destroy the myth that "Tornado Strength Winds" would be required as stated in one study used in support of the smoking ban.\r\n\r\nFood for thought:-\r\n\r\nIt's too early for post legislative scrutiny.\r\n\r\nGoogle. Health & Sports Committee Meeting 12 Sept 2007.\r\n\r\nBut the Health Committee meeting on 6 Feb 2007 \r\ndetails the post legislative scrutiny carried out.16552012-10-04T13:53:19.913574Alec JohnstonBelinda says "As for rules prohibiting a carcinogen being released unnecessarily, that is moot." It is only moot in a parallel universe that doesn't understand the requirements of EH40. Back here in the real world it is a big issue, and one that you and your associates clearly don't understand. Are you really suggesting that the presence of carcinogens in ambient air means that employers are free to add carcinogens as they like?16552012-10-04T13:56:25.82575Alec JohnstonEddie, surely it doesn't help your case that Belinda and Bill can't string together any decent evidence that your super new ventilation system will adequately protect workers if the smoking ban is relaxed. Even the manufacturer agrees, although Belinda doesn't seem to grasp this. Why not post your evidence here if it is so compelling? I suspect you won't because it isn't at all compelling, and we've probably already heard about it from Bill and Belinda.16552012-10-04T14:07:11.857576Belinda CunnisonIt makes absolutely no sense to remove smoke on the grounds of improving air quality as if it is the only pollutant in ambient air that will make any difference. The point of the petition is to establish acceptable limits of ambient pollution in the air, and treat air that exceeds these limits. There is no reason to suppose that it should be impossible to remove the content of tobacco smoke before it becomes an annoyance or irritation to others. As to international coverage, campaigns to promote smoking bans are also global, and it is only to be expected that petitions attract certain interest groups.16552012-10-04T14:32:29.623577Eddie DouthwaiteAlec, As I said, the FULL evidence will be presented to the Petitions Committee for consideration and not in this comment forum. \r\n16552012-10-04T15:31:58.827578Bill GibsonFor every hospitality venue that is forced to close, politians must accept that there is also loss of sales tax, business tax revenue, etc to the treasury. This will result in further increases in indirect taxation to attempt to keep the nation afloat while paying out more unemployment benifits ... all in the name of health when as a nation we cannot afford the costs of growing old as it is.16552012-10-04T16:05:12.2579Alec JohnstonBelinda, you continue to flaunt your ignorance about the requirements of EH40. Firstly your petition states that "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40", which is simply not true.\r\nThen you suggest a solution involving a product that doesn't have any impact on carcinogenic chemicals, and want to ignore the requirements of EH40 about carcinogens.16552012-10-04T17:02:27.2580Alec Johnson"all in the name of health when as a nation we cannot afford the costs of growing old as it is.\r\nBill Gibson" Smoking has been proposed by the tobacco industry as a means of keeping down the numbers of expensive older people before Bill. 16552012-10-04T17:18:58.137581brian moorelets make this land FREE again and fight the tobacco TALIBAN and all the anti people who wish to make our lives as missrable as THEIRS.16552012-10-04T21:51:17.38582Eddie DouthwaiteAlec, it will be up to the Petitions Committee to make an informed decision on this petition. For someone who has commented so much on this site it is surprising that you do not appear in Internet searches. The possibility exists that you may be an " agent provocoteur" in an attempt to find out the extent of the evidence that will be given to the committee. 16552012-10-05T11:57:14.847583Alec JohnstonEddie, I hope the Petitions Committee are told the truth. Your petition says that "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40" which is untrue. Your colleagues from the pro-smoking movement promote plasmacluster technology as a solution to the problem, even though the manufacturer says it isn't effective against chemicals (including carcinogens). I think it is important that the Petitions Committee get good advice from properly qualified Health and Safety experts. If you had bothered to get that advice, you wouldn't have created such a misleading petition.16552012-10-05T16:07:41.207584Heather MirandaHyperemesis is a horrific illness and so much more needs to be done to care for women going through it.16412012-10-05T16:39:25.797585AngelaHG is a terrible condition and has caused hardship in mine and my families lives. There needs to be more specialized help in this area... NURSES and DOCTORS!!!!!!!16412012-10-05T16:48:21.247586Margaret O'HaraThe shoddy treatment of women with hyperemesis gravidarum through most of the 20th century until now is nothing short of a disgrace. Not only should the obstetric and midwifery professions provide best practice care for all sufferers as a matter of urgency, they should publicly apologise to the hundreds of thousands of women who have been fobbed off and sent home to suffer alone instead of being given treatment. Shame on you all you doctors and midwives who tell women it's psychosomatic.16412012-10-05T18:19:40.34587Amanda McGregorI have suffered this horredous condition three times and have only one child as a result. It was misunderstood and unsupported with only 'crisis' admissions when I was seriously ill. There are alternatives, in other countries it is better supported and managed. Please put an end to needless suffering by women who endure this condition by providing better training and specialist resources to prevent the crisis stage occuring.16412012-10-05T18:48:05.08588 Eddie DouthwaiteAlec, for a start it's not my petition and I understand the organisation raising it is "PRO-CHOICE" not pro-smoking. The Law Courts will eventually decide what the truth is. 16552012-10-05T21:00:25.093589Denise PenneyMy sister and a friend of mine have suffered badly with hyperemesis throughout their pregnancies. There's no question that introducing specialist practitioners in this field would be of great benefit. It's a necessity!16412012-10-05T22:50:48.81590Joanne pearsonNot just for midwives may I add. When a patient has severe HG, they may need to go on TPN through Hickman line, like myself. Midwives are not trained on how to use Hickman lines nor administer TPN. They are specialist nurses. It would be great to have a nurse or midwive that would be qualified for this. I had to spend 3 months on a gastro ward due to the lack of midwives not being trained on this.16412012-10-06T13:19:04.2591Ann Marie KingThis is wonderful ladies! As the Co-Founder of the world's largest non-profit dedicated to raising awareness, research and education we all need to work together around the globe to make a difference! I ask that you sign our petition as well in the United States at www.hyperemesis.or or www.HelpHER.org. Great job and together our voices will be heard!16412012-10-06T14:04:25.983592Maryon PenneyA member of our family suffered for her entire pregnancy and received no help whatsoever.16412012-10-06T18:19:42.257593Michael J. McFaddenAlec, is there a safe level of exposure to the Class A carcinogens of UV radiation and ethyl alcohol?\r\n\r\n- MJM16552012-10-07T01:10:26.96594Ellen StewartHaving had 7 miscarriages I would love to see some changes! So other women don't have to suffer.16112012-10-07T10:41:53.883595Alec JohnstonAt 10.30 on Sunday 7th October there were 298 signatures. 50 were from Scotland. * from Canada, 10 from Denmark, 3 from Netherlands, 2 from Germany, 24 from USA, 4 from Italy, 3 from Australia, 5 from Wales, and 110 from England. So much for Scottish independence, we aren't that bothered, the rest of the world wants to tell us what to do. (Edited by Moderator)16552012-10-07T14:39:04.25596McFadyen,Murray,Rorrison, Hemphill & Hepburn Family We sign this petition for our sister, who like many others had another congenital defect as a child and spent the first year of her life in Yorkhill Childrens hospital where she underwent major surgeries. Many of these children and children like her are born with congenital heart defects. This has resulted in further surgeries and complications during pregnancy. Recently over a 9 month period she has underwent 2 major open heart surgeries, further surgeries and a pacemaker implantation. The care she has recieved in the SACCS team has been inspirational to her and to us as a family. However she has encountered difficult obstacles in her local care. She has however remained positive and focused that education is the way forward, and she throughout her illness has arranged and delivered education to others by letters, emails, audios and meetings to create awareness and an understanding of congenital heart defects. Writing to the government even when she was very ill. We as a family hope that standards are delivered .The correct standards that the SACCS team will be able to meet and deliver a patient experience both within and outwith the arms of the team that she admires and who throughout her difficult time has left her with the biggest smile and with a legacy of hope. A smile and that make us proud to call her our sister. 16122012-10-07T14:53:49.327598M & G Hepburn My daughter was born with esopahageal atresia, she spent her young life in Yorkhill Childrens Hospital where she was also diagnosed with congenital heart disease and as an adult has had to encounter very difficult surgeries, but she has had the support of a truly amazing team. We support the petition for standards in the care of adult congenital heart patients and I am sure the consultants and doctors will make sure that the right standards will be implemented, and that the patients who have been writing to the government will see a benefit in their own care and the care of others.16122012-10-08T08:46:47.233599Michelle ParsonsI think it is extremely important to try to raise awareness and find suitable treatments for this. The care you receive during your journey with HG vastly affects the outcomes, both for you and your child's health and for your mental health too (many women end up with PTSD after prolonged HG, as it depletes the body of vital nutrients and in some cases can cause organ failure) I had some lovely nurses but also ad experiences with the not so nice ones who treated me like a hysterical waste of everyone's time who should just pull herself together. Surely with the emphasis on the health of future generations this should be given due consideration.16412012-10-08T12:57:50.313600Sam WallerPLEASE PLEASE help the ladies who suffer from this horrific condition. If only it WAS "morning sickness", that I could cope with, HG is on a whole new scale and desperately needs more awareness and people in the medical profession who actually KNOW what it is, how to treat it and not give stupid advice to eat ginger and sip water (like we havent already thought of that and tried it!!)16412012-10-08T13:55:26.86601Alec JohnstonEddie says "I understand the organisation raising it is "PRO-CHOICE" not pro-smoking." They all say this Eddie but the only choice they seem to be really interested in is the freedom for people to be addicted to smoking, which seems to be one of the least worthwhile 'freedoms' to be fighting for.16552012-10-08T13:58:54.97602Alec JohnstonMichael JM, your signature on the petition says you are in the USA. What do you have against letting Scots make up their own minds about issues like this? We have enough people trying to mislead our government over this issue without importing extra ones from across the Atlantic.16552012-10-08T22:19:05.267603Stephen HelferThe problem with the data on passive smoking...is that the estimated risks are so close to zero. \r\nCanadian Medical Association Journal (editorial), August 5, 2003\r\n\r\n16552012-10-09T14:17:47.487604Alec JohnstonStephen, are you from Scotland or are you another person trying to manipulate what our Government does on our behalf? Checking your name on the web reveals someone with your name as the founder of Cambridge Citizens for Smokers' Rights in Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA "Cambridge Citizens for Smokers' Rights is a non-profit group based in Cambridge, Massachusetts. We actively oppose excessive tobacco regulation and efforts to stigmatize smokers." Is this you Stephen? 16552012-10-09T14:20:43.89605Alec JohnstonPS Stephen. The web also says this about the Stephen Helfer from CCSR. "Stephen is an avid tobacco user. He is fond of tobacco either as it is found in cigarettes, or smoked in a pipe. His favorite cigarette is the unfiltered Camel. He has the notable habit of field stripping each cigarette after he smokes it. His tobacco activism centers on a philosophy of protecting and maintaining personal freedoms in the face of 'big government' policies that would seek to legislate the private habits of individuals with their so-called welfare in mind. Stephen strongly believes the individual is in a far superior position to determine their own self-interest regarding life style and health choices." 16552012-10-09T16:49:10.377606KarenI had hyperemesis. My daughter is now 17 and an only child as couldn't face the possibility of going through that again, but with a young child to look after as well. Obstetrician at time told me it was psychological not physical! I'd love to have swapped places with him for a day and see what he thought about it then.16412012-10-09T20:21:56.01607Gemma Frances BradyThis is such a horrific condition! Suffered it myself and it was the worst time of my life! Still suffering mentally due to this,would love to have more kids one day but until there is people specially trained to help and take it seriously I can't consider having anymore.16412012-10-09T22:59:16.01608Bill GibsonAlec\r\nMaybe you can explain why ASH New Zealand and the Cancer Society of New Zealand offered written evidence to the Scottish Parliament Health and Sports Committee with regard to the Tobacco Display Ban. Purely a Scottish issue or are you cherry picking as is normal practice for a Tobacco Control Addict.\r\n16552012-10-10T02:34:18.133609Jamie PanelleI have had HG twice. I was lucky to have an HG educated doctor through out both of my pregnancies. I wish I could say this for all that suffers from HG. You feel like you are dying a slow death. I suffered the whole 9 months. If it weren't for the help and support of my doctors and nurses, I don't think I would have been able to give life to my 2 beautiful girls. Please help the victims of HG and give babies a chance. Most don't make it.16412012-10-10T11:13:44.72610Bill GibsonAlec, you must complain to the very highest level within the Scottish Parliament as on the 10th January 2012, the Health and Sports Committee took oral evidence from Professor Timothy Stockwell (University of Victoria, British Columbia on the subject of Minimum Pricing of Alcohol ... again in your mindset, a Scottish issue and not subject to influence from an overseas perspective.16552012-10-10T12:11:19.773611Bill GibsonPhase two , to obtain justice for all the businesses that have endured financial and moral hardship as a result of the Smoking Ban " Private Investment Fund Horecaclaim" All those who have misinformed the public over the years must be brought to account for their actions.16552012-10-10T15:39:54.993612Alec JohnstonOnly 51 people from Scotland have signed this petition in the month it has been here. It was in The Scotsman about 3 weeks ago, and still Scots don't support it. There are over 5 million of us nowadays, and yet only 51 signed the petition. (Edited by Moderator)16552012-10-11T00:16:00.593613Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: The number of signatories to a petition is irrelevant, I suggest that you have a look at other petitions on this site.16552012-10-11T10:38:15.267614Alec JohnstonEddie "The number of signatories to a petition is irrelevant" Surely it is highly relevant how many people from Scotland (merely 51 after a month) want something to happen, how many don't want to sign (over 5 million), and how many activists from lobby groups around the world want our parliament to change things to suit their agendas.\r\nI think the lack of support, coupled with the misleading wording of the petition, and the inability of those behind the petition to show how their proposed ventilation systems will comply with EH40 (which they can't because they won't) should consign this petition very effectively to the waste bin.16552012-10-11T10:41:28.06615Liza MortonThe Children's heart foundation share our petition on facebook stating that: \r\n\r\n"This is a petition from Dr Liza Morton calling for National Standards for the care of Adult Congenital Heart Patients in Scotland. \r\n\r\nCHF believe that all congenital care in the UK should meet agreed minimum standards."16122012-10-11T14:24:30.873616Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: Talking of "lobby groups" the Scottish Government funds ASH Scotland to the extent of nearly £1 MILLION a year. Until you have the courtesy to reveal your true name then I will treat your comments as I would an anonymous signature to a petition.16552012-10-11T15:09:33.253617Alec JohnstonEddie, so you are resigned to getting a paltry 51 Scottish supporters in a month, being unable to show that your ventilation systems can comply with EH40 (they can't, smart move!), don't want to address the fact that over 5 million Scots have chosen not to sign, and don't wish to tackle my suggestion that the petition is misleading. Instead, you try to derail the discussion with a ASH Scotland's funding. I for one am not put off by your attempt at a smokescreen. 16552012-10-11T15:59:41.3618Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: If the Petitioner had a fraction of the £49.2MILLION that the Scottish Government has planned to spend on Tobacco Control between 2011 and 2015 it could be given greater publicity. I think I have hit a nerve mentioning ASH Scotland, you might wish to Google "Government lobbying Government" to find out how "Smokefree" was exposed in England.16552012-10-11T20:02:38.01619joe kirbyif independance is to happen then we need to secure our country to make it our own16632012-10-11T20:03:17.73620john campbellGlasgow 1&2 I've signed16632012-10-11T20:28:03.447621catriona kirby stuarti agree to the charter 100 percent16632012-10-11T20:37:00.573622jordan stuartwe need this to be passed16632012-10-11T20:37:37.12623anne jackfreedom and indepandance and a propserous country16632012-10-11T20:38:10.603624cheryl kirbyim moving back to vote so that scotland can prosper16632012-10-11T23:24:20.543625Mrs StevensonI have thought long and hard about my support on this petition for standards in the care of adults with congenital heart disease.Undoubtedly these standards have to be decided by the correct governance, and I support this on that basis. 16122012-10-12T08:36:26.207626german1964Hello. \r\nIn Germany, no traces of elevated lung cancer or COPD risk for waiters and waitresses in restaurants and bars where people used to smoke have been found (look at www.grieshabers-passivrauchen.de ). On the contrary: waiters and waitresses in such restaurants have been associated with LOWER risks of the kind mentioned, compared to the average working cohort and to the average local population. Consequently, either there cannot be an elevated risk for smoke-related deseases or waiters and waitresses have another (maybe hidden) preventing factor (such as: they move a lot during working hours - or the like)\r\nThus, making restaurants and bars smoke-free is fighting a non-effect, whilst smoke- free bars are prone to premature closure, as statistics on gastronomy show, especially in Britain.\r\nRe-evalution of legislation is thus overdue!16552012-10-12T08:41:41.503627Alec Johnston51 Scots have signed, and so have 270 people from other parts of the world. Over 5 million Scots haven't signed. Let's hope democracy prevails over organised lobbying by international networks of pro-smoking groups.16552012-10-12T09:02:01.19628Claudia FrankeGood luck - this is so important! 16122012-10-12T14:58:59.19629Janette WisemanWe need a decent pay for the work we do, I got this same houly rate in 200416632012-10-12T15:30:27.607630michaelaA fairer economy16632012-10-12T15:31:04.52631Murray SteeleNeo-liberalism has failed the world over, now is the time to push for a democratic socialist alternative.16632012-10-12T15:38:06.783632AngusThis is the way forward, this has to be done so we can be heard and for us all to move in a united manner and for our future16632012-10-12T16:00:05.79633Gerry Skeithwe are not a strong country unless our voice can be heard above the political pigeons in office.16632012-10-12T16:15:04.49634C SmithThis petition is signed for my dad who had a heart attack I support care of coronary heart disease patients , I am so glad I seen this on twitter. \r\n\r\n\r\n16122012-10-12T16:45:33.35635Joyce PargeterThis will improve quality of life for everyone16632012-10-12T17:10:20.317636judithkeep people employed16632012-10-12T17:29:12.953637BIKIBetter future for all please.16632012-10-12T17:41:52.333638Lorraine ConwellGive the Power to the people16632012-10-12T18:01:57.007639Rab AmosThe charter outlines the aspirations needed to develop a society that we be proud of.Having listened to the dangerous comments from Osbourne, onn workers rights, Grayling two strikes and your in for life,Cameron wanting Eton opened to the masses, it always is just need the moneyTory Conference. That is importance of STUC's Charter.16632012-10-12T18:22:26.303640Brianlets stop talking about action, now's the time to take action.16632012-10-12T18:37:39.307641Mariafor the betterment of Scotland, let's go for it.16632012-10-12T19:07:36.257642 Aboud NemaThis is a great work, we need this to be passed, and for good future.16632012-10-12T19:37:38.03643Ailsa Wilsonmake the bankers pay for the suffering that they have caused and make sure it can never happen again!16632012-10-12T20:23:52.89644Jennifer GrayReading Scottish History book by T C Smout. Always assaults on the workers - people can and have changed outcomes over the years.16632012-10-12T20:46:35.103645Martin KetchionI am glad to sign this petition, the way in which our current coalition Government is behaving is ridiculous. Job cut,s tax avoidance for the rich, public sector pension reviews its all a nonsense.16632012-10-12T20:53:55.327646Jonathan HoylandBritain needs all the help it can get and this can only be done if we stand together.16632012-10-12T21:10:31.617647Norma MurphyWe must strive to fight our corner via The Charter in the hope that we in turn will be living in a society where there is fairness and equity.\r\n16632012-10-12T21:12:34.583648Heather GarrettThousands of moms-to-be around the world are misdiagnosed, mistreated and misunderstood when they are told their dehydration, malnutrition and constant vomiting is simply morning sickness. Their bodies literally reject food and water. Many terminate due to despair and lack of proper diagnosis. This misunderstood and deadly disease is called Hyperemesis Gravidarum, or HG. These women and babies need YOUR help.16412012-10-12T22:01:16.517649John NeilThe present regime is a future devoid of promise or incentive. When accountants steer the ship you run to close to the rocks.16632012-10-12T22:12:18.07650AlisonI \r\nThe whole tory conference has been about dividing people and looking for people to blame who have no power in the scale of things. We need to be united and show that working together is what the majority wants. Power to the People as John Lennon said.\r\n\r\n16632012-10-12T22:34:41.257651Brian SmithThose who say they represent trade unionists and working people better start showing it or move over......16632012-10-13T00:04:18.673652Diarmid MacAulayBetter jobs is too vague. Scots should have a constitutional right to a liveable wage, decent housing and justice before the law16632012-10-13T00:37:27.977653James ForsythI feel myself that the only way we are going to get a fair way is Scotland on there own we are a very proud people and ambitious16632012-10-13T11:07:43.323654AnneWe can only hope someone- somewhere LISTENS to people at the 'cliff face'16632012-10-13T12:29:13.88655J A DonagheyIts about time those in Government listened to those that voted them in. Not go blindly off in a direction of their own despite warnings to the contrary.16632012-10-13T12:54:02.147656alex blythi hpoe this signature is sufficient for ur purposes16632012-10-13T13:50:23.747657Margot StoegerSecondary smoke is a big hoax to control the people. More restrictions will follow\r\n\r\n16552012-10-13T14:58:46.983658Caroline McCawWorried about my grandson and son who are due to leave school in a year or 2 - what will be out there for them the way these cuts are going, you want them to have a decent job with fair pay, but this is becoming more and more unlikely with all these cuts and redundancies and forcing people to work into old age there will be even less vacancies - I would like to go at 60 and leave room for a younger person to get a job, but there's no way to afford it without the old age pension. Also fed up with the posh rich boys and the press trying to divide the working class by going on about our pension - ALL working should have the right to build up a fair pension. 16632012-10-13T18:22:18.82659Jessica PinkardHG nearly killed my babies and me. It is so important to have resources in place to help women who suffer from this horrible disease.16412012-10-14T10:00:04.087660Wendy-Lynn BrookesSomething's got to be done. There's people starving and people freezing all because of power and greed.16632012-10-14T10:18:25.787661E.P.DrummondIn principle why are we in Scotland denied the right to access any information unless we incur the additional cost of having to employ a Lawyer to access any records that are, or should be available to the public. I'm taken aback that this information is available in England & Wales yet we in Scotland are denied similar rights.16292012-10-14T13:02:32.6662Belinda CunnisonThis is the petition against allowing smoking on film sets in Wales, Alec. The full list isn't visible but there is still quite a lot of interest from outside Wales on the front page, I think you will agree? Search The Welsh Government: keep smoking ban strong in Wales16552012-10-14T14:25:07.923663AnneWho is kidding who? There is the same amount of money in this world as there always has been..No to austerity!!16632012-10-14T14:44:58.79664James"We are all in it together" is a lie.16632012-10-14T16:33:34.693665PaulMuch better alternative to all these cuts16632012-10-14T19:59:29.51666Barry WeldonIt's about time the working class people were given a fairer more socialist alternative to the despicable society where bankers and politicians are rewarded for failure, where there is no real justice and a safe, water & wind tight home is an aspiration not an expected standard for young people today16632012-10-14T21:44:28.303667micky maccormickGood idea butperhape we should use our energy for the YES campagne16622012-10-15T07:56:09.817669Brian WhitemanAs a staunch trade unionist for many years, I have learned that you must fight to achieve a just world. Then you must fight to keep it!16632012-10-15T08:34:15.12670JimTime for action16632012-10-15T09:00:42.74671elizabeth hornei worry that there will be no health service, jobs, housing for future generations. it is hard enough to make ends meet as it is 16632012-10-15T09:27:07.863672AdeliaHelp to make Scotland the best and fairest country in the world.16632012-10-15T09:48:08.387673Connie McManusWe have no other choice but to push forward,things cant get any worse4 what choice do we have. People unite.16632012-10-15T10:07:30.773674Rhoda PullarWe need to unite against this government of the rich! we( the ordinary folk) did not make this situation but it is us - low paid workers, single mums, students, pensioners. who are being made to pay, Why? how can any government minister justify what they are doing? they need to stop lying and put the money - that is there! to the right places, jobs make a country prosperous not, a rich out of touch jobs for the boys government!! I could go on but that'll do for now.... cheers xx16632012-10-15T10:37:31.617675Susan ShannonWe have to fight the appalling policies that this government is inflicting on working people, and fight for a better future for us all.16632012-10-15T10:48:17.077676Victor Serge WeretelnikowI Totally Agree With The All Contents Of The Peoples Charter Petition Summary16632012-10-15T11:27:39.49677Barbara ClarkFairness for all is a must16632012-10-15T11:31:26.227678Craig Thomsonsomethings gotta give coz this present government is SIMPLY NOT WORKING !!!16632012-10-15T12:12:04.303679John PollockThe austerity measures are nothing more than a blatant attack on the low paid, unemployed and people with disabilities. Austerity doesn't work and is designed to fail. The future is bleak for all if we continue to allow these draconian measures to take place. 16632012-10-15T12:25:20.253680Alec Johnston"Secondary smoke is a big hoax to control the people. More restrictions will follow \r\nMargot Stoeger" - of Austria? And Belinda (the petitioner) is encouraging people via this Scottish parlaiment site to interfere in parliamentary matters in Wales. This is just a shameless example of how the international pro-smoking lobby works to create the impression of large scale support by the mobilisation of a few individuals across the world.\r\n16552012-10-15T12:35:27.523681Alec JohnstonMeanwhile, with 7 days to go, this petition has drawn 53 people from Scotland to sign it, plus 278 from other parts of the world. Still over 5 million Scots haven't signed, and the shameless international lobbying continues. It's noticeable that the pro-smoking lobbyists have given up trying to claim that the ventilation solution will comply with EH40. I'm glad to have helped them realise that it won't. I presume from Belinda's shift to lobbying the Welsh Assembly here that her organisation have given up this particular petition as dead in the water.16552012-10-15T12:50:27.257682Gordon ForresterLet us stop being driven in the wrong direction and lead the way for the UK16632012-10-15T13:39:08.867683Linda McGlynnGovernment attacks on the public sector result in an attack on local communities and the loss of our schools and services. The current attack on Abronhill High School, a school which does well in national comparisons, is a direct reult of these cuts.16632012-10-15T14:32:11.663684Belinda CunnisonAlec, you haven't even read what I wrote, far less understood it. There is no facility for people who oppose the aims of the Welsh petition to comment. I pointed out simply that all petitions on either side of the smoking debate attract attention and support from outside their locality. The latest three signatures on the Welsh petition are in Scotland. \r\n\r\nThey also seem to think 500 signatures are enough! 16552012-10-15T15:55:50.42685lynsay grahamAfter having 2 and being told that I'd have 2 wait till a had another before the would do anything. Am now 2 scared to even try again. :( 16112012-10-15T15:55:59.703686Eddie DouthwaiteThis petition will be a very difficult one for MSPs to handle. If they allow the petitioners the opportunity to present the full evidence held they could be in the position of having to admit they were wrong in supporting the introduction of the smoking ban as it currently exists. The integrity of the Scottish Parliament and it's members is at stake and justice must be seen to be done in the handling of the petition. The so called "experts" in Tobacco Control, their supporting "Charities" and NGOs may regret some of the claims they have made when called to do so under oath in the Law Courts16552012-10-15T17:48:52.487687lillias mclachlanwould like to see more changes to help mothers.16112012-10-15T18:08:21.993688Neil BuchanTime for change16632012-10-15T22:27:03.607689Lesley MunnLeave public section workers alone, get police officers on the street, not on full pay in desk jobs!!!!16632012-10-16T02:26:54.867691john watson I don't smoke however smoking should be a life style choice. Government should not be interfering in the life style choices of others. You are born free, and we should all be allowed to die free. Government can advise and warn, other than that government should stay clear. If some one wants to smoke, run a smoking bar or enter a smoking bar that choice should be left to every one of us. It is not the duty of government to protect us from our selves.16552012-10-16T08:14:05.7692Chris McGilvrayA nation of sheep, of followers need to waken up, need to rise up and be counted before the tories and nu labour sell us down the river, with an imaginary debt! Who do we owe this money too? Who created this debt? You? Me? Bankers? Hedge betting? \r\n\r\nHow long can this austerity be suffered? How long before this country devolves into Greece style rioting?\r\n\r\nMy fervent hope is that enough people can wake up and deny this debt like the Icelandic people who are thriving without paying their debt!16632012-10-16T09:25:50.9693Jason StanworthPlease note everyone i have signed this petition before and my name was not registered, please check your name is on the petition if you have voted.\r\nJase16552012-10-16T10:47:33.143694Alec JohnstonEddie, I think you're a bit deluded when you say "This petition will be a very difficult one for MSPs to handle.". The MSPs will conclude that Scots don't want this, the international tobacco and smoking lobby community do, they will be given technical advice that the petition is misleading in its claims, and that the ventilation systems you propose won't comply with the requirements of EH40. 16552012-10-16T10:49:56.397695Alec JohnstonJohn Watson, why are you promoting people's right to be addicted to a harmful substance under the guise of freedom? If you don't smoke, why are you meddling in other people's habits?16552012-10-16T11:35:26.907696Morag DevlinMy husband and I suffered two miscarriages. we were told it was just mother nature doing her thing!! Thankfully we have three beautiful kids now, but it never leaves you, even after twenty years! Things need to change....16112012-10-16T11:51:37.5697Bill GibsonAlec, likewise why are you interfering in the rights of others to express thir opinion on what is a legal pastime.\r\n\r\nI refer you to the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948\r\n\r\nArticle 1.\r\nAll human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.\r\n16552012-10-16T12:04:55.57698Bill GibsonAlec, I suggest that you read the WHO Guidelines on Indoor Air Quality .... all 484 pages16552012-10-16T12:11:05.72699ModeratorFAO Jason Stanworth: Mr Stanworth, your signature to the petition was registered on 27 September at 8.53am and is showing in the list of signatories. Moderator.16552012-10-16T12:18:23.923700Alec JohnstonBill, you should read EH40 and give this up as a bad job. Also, "All human beings are born free" but quite a lot of them get addicted to tobacco and are no longer free. Sinister that so many non-smokers go out of their way to promote tobacco addiction in the name of freedom.16552012-10-16T14:41:09.923702Bill GibsonTobacco use is a habit and not an addiction. You are certainly out to make a foll of yourself Alec and doing so in grand style.16552012-10-16T14:51:52.017703Bill GibsonAlec, to enlighten you further read Science Daily Surprising New Study Shows Cigarette Cravings Result from Habit, Not Addiction. 16552012-10-16T15:58:02.173704Alec JohnstonHere we go, tobacco use is not an addiction eh Bill? That just adds to your credibility. I know some people smoke because of habit, but a fair few are addicted and not free. You seem to suggest that nobody is addicted to smoking. Pull the other one.16552012-10-16T19:04:04.75707ann mccullochthe devastating number of miscarriages which women experience should be investigated. It is not good enough to think that any miscarriage is tolerable. Only with improved investigation and research will we see progress for families, leading to fewer miscarriages 16112012-10-16T21:01:50.877708MarionMy daughter very distressed after two miscarrages and desperately hoping not to have to endure another before any help is available.16112012-10-17T10:47:07.963709Irene LesterIt is ridiculous that we are one of the richest countries in the wetern world and we are cutting so many crucial public sector jobs. Its time we informed the Government how dissapointed and frustrated we are in their mismanagement of funds. 16632012-10-17T13:22:52.04710Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: Just Google " TC Tactics" and you will get all the details about the dirty tactics of Tobacco Control.16552012-10-17T22:39:36.9711william john borthwickI am not the most politically motivated trade unionist there has ever been but if we do not waken up and see what this government is doing to its people then we are all going to turn up for our public sector jobs one day and the padlocks will be on the gates and there will be no way back for the working class people of this great country to help get us back to being a nation of wealth and growth in the UK, in europe and the rest of the world.The Peoples Charter is the way forward for the working people of this country to let their voices be truly heard.16632012-10-17T23:39:17.597712Alec JohnstonEddie, have a read of EH40. You'll see that the claim in the petition that "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40" isn't true. You'll also see that your proposals for ventilation won't meet EH40's requirements for carcinogens in the air of a workplace.16552012-10-17T23:45:17.917713Alec JohnstonBill, I googled Science Daily and Nicotine Addiction and found their article "Why Some Smokers Become Addicted With Their First Cigarette". This doesn't help your claim that nicotine isn't addictive.16552012-10-18T10:48:32.397714Michael G RooneyI think for any charter to work there has to be some clout behind the words. So this petition needs to be part of a wider campaign of civil action, demonstrations, active and passive resistance and a display of the type of moral and physical courage shown by trade unionist of the past.16632012-10-18T23:47:18.937715Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: I don't debate with a cardboard cutout.16552012-10-19T10:29:22.22716Alec Johnston"I don't debate with a cardboard cutout". You have nothing to debate anyway. Your petition is wrong and misleading. The ventilation systems you're proposing don't comply with the requirements of EH40. The vast majority of the petition's signatures are from tobacco advocates outside Scotland.16552012-10-19T13:35:00.767717Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: As I said before, it is NOT my petition. 16552012-10-19T14:20:32.863718Alec JohnstonEddie, back on the 4th you said "The comprehensive evidence which will be given to the Petitions Committee by the petitioner will prove the effectiveness of Air Filtration systems". It might not be 'your petition' but you clearly feel you are involved with it, otherwise how would you know what they are going to present?16552012-10-19T15:07:06.337719alex MutebiA great idea of a Scottish Genius!!!!, Scotland should have a National tree indeed!16622012-10-19T15:30:43.503720Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: If you know where to look on the Internet the evidence is available. Enjoy searching for it. Remember there are lies, damned lies and Tobacco Control.16552012-10-19T16:04:57.89721Colin Gill independence YES. E.U. N.A.T.O. NO.16632012-10-19T16:50:32.17723Norman A SpinkIt is time the gap between rich and poor is reduced so that we can all enjoy a fairer society. 16632012-10-19T16:56:44.207724Alec JohnstonEddie, if you're looking for lies, then you need go no further than this part of the petition "All toxins have safe levels listed in Health and Safety Executive Workplace Exposure Limits, EH40"16552012-10-21T10:59:04.027725Ann CrozierI marched yesterday in Glasgow along with thousands of others all over the UK and I'll do whatever it takes to show this government that Austerity is not working and we are not all in this together. This government is determined to destroy ever single thing that ordinary people (phelbs) have worked to build for the last 70 years and to take us all back to where the rich got richer and the poor got ill and died!!!! 16632012-10-21T15:54:56.393726Chris RendallSHS is really deadly!!?? Wow this is great, it means I can get myself a soft top sports car now. Great, and it is also wonderfull because it means I can be behind a bus, lorry, or even another car I can then breath in the beautiful aroma of there fumes because its safer than breathing in deadly second hand smoke! When is the next trip to Afganistan????16552012-10-21T23:31:18.57727Alec JohnstonEddie, if you read the forum you can see that I went to the site of the systems that the petitioner referred to, and they say it doesn't work for airborne carcinogenic chemicals like those in cigarette smoke. The petition is misleading, and your constant references to the evidence being on the internet is clearly wishful thinking, because you have failed to provide it. When the petitioner suggested a manufacturers site it said it wouldn't work. And not a single one of you has managed to show that your ventilation proposal will comply with EH40's requirements for carcinogens (because it won't). Lies, damned lies and tobacco industry propaganda.16552012-10-21T23:38:26.63728Alec Johnston369 signatures at 23.33 on 21st October. 68 from Scotland, 301 from the rest of the world. It has been discussed in The Scotsman, and still the rest of the world seems to want us to change our smoking ban far more than Scots do. Considering the efforts made by the pro-smoking and tobacco lobby groups to promote this, 68 Scots is a particularly feeble showing.16552012-10-22T12:11:15.547729wendy straiton really feel sorry for all those young folk unable to find work, where is their future? while those in power waltz around in a bubble, making up plans to protect themselves\r\n16632012-10-22T13:34:26.433730Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: Stop hiding behind your anonimity. At least the Petitions Committee do not make their decisions based on the number of signatories of a petition. Talking of numbers ASH Scotland have 27 staff yet get funded £1MILLION a year by the Scottish Government. They must be one of the few "charities ?" that exist mainly on public funds, you never see them on the street collecting for their " Charity ?" 16552012-10-22T14:02:52.54731Brian DaveyProud to report that the Scots Pine grows well in southern Spain despite the drier climate there and covers thousands of hectares over the Sierras.16622012-10-22T15:01:06.163732Richie SherrattOne more national pride symbol.16622012-10-22T16:57:03.28733Eddie DouthwaiteAlec the Anonymous: The petitioner does not have the resources or money that GLOBAL TOBACCO CONTROL, THE GOVERNMENT, ANTI-SMOKING ALLIANCES and their SUPPORTING CHARITIES have to publicise their PROPAGANDA. 16552012-10-22T18:14:08.43734Jill DempseyIf you don't get hyperemesis, you don't "get" hyperemesis. We need someone in Scotland who can help with this awful, horrible condition, someone who understands and doesn't just treat us as neurotic women who cannot deal with a "bit of morning sickness".16412012-10-23T10:10:29.183735Ross RobertsonHow long will the UK government continue to try to dupe the public with the smoke screen of austerity measures for the supposed benefit of all when it is obvious they are using the current economic circumstacnes as an excuse and unwarranted justification to dismantle the welfare state, local authority services and pusue their right wing agenda of cuts for the poor, perks for tehrich.16632012-10-23T19:15:01.67736Arthur M PiggotScotland must recognise this iconic tree16622012-10-24T10:14:32.223738The Practical Realist- looking beyond the smokescreenInteresting that we have a Coalition Westminster governement now suggesting retired individuals shsoudl work and be less of a burden to the public purse but the reality is there are insufficient jobs for what is traditionally the working population - 16 - 65 years olds. Where are the job opportunities for "retirees" coming from?16632012-10-26T17:56:10.613739JMI would have thought there was one anyway. If there isn't, then there certainly should be.15972012-10-26T19:32:42.4740Paulo QuadrosEvidence shows that social factors directly affect health, including chronic pain. By addressing this aspect and transferring the focus of pain management into primary care with appropriate funding, people suffering from chronic pain would be much more able to have equal access to a more effective service within a shorter period of time.16872012-10-28T09:26:03.287741speedy bjornGood job16872012-10-28T22:27:04.537742Allyson Wilson Please don't let this happen to anyone else miss you lots Sharon xx16262012-10-29T13:28:08.863743Ross HetheringtonThough many of the proposals on this charter face substantial political opposition, and economic and structural difficulties in implementation, it is hugely important for those who care about justice and a more caring society to have a clear vision of their basic ideals, and to demonstrate its commitment to them, even if change may be an arduous and fraught process. In its broad scope, then, I am behind this charter 100%, and urge those in power to always keep such ideals in sight, attempt get as close to it as is feasible, and not be disuaded from these goals by the partisans of social fragmentation masquerading as pragmatists, no matter how little of these goals may in practice, at present, be realised. 16632012-10-29T16:06:36.16744Sam PurdieWhen will the inhabitants of the Westminster Bubble admit that it is impossible to "Cut" your way out of a recession. We must Grow our way out of this mess.16632012-10-29T17:08:51.94745Tommy BrennanI tossed up between the Rowan and the Scots Pine....guess what one won??16622012-10-29T17:56:10.863747Iain Mac InnesThe points outlined in the Peoples Charter are indications for the starting of a programme of humane benefit for the common good. \r\nIf we are to live in Scotland with Social Justice the People's Charter is surely the minimum starting point. End the housing crisis which both chronic and acute by investing in Council Housing to stimulate the economy as a whole. \r\nIain Mac innes\r\n\r\nI want to live in a Scotland that will see a massive \r\n16632012-10-29T19:15:03.113748Peter AdairIconic tree that is truly something to be proud of.16622012-10-29T21:29:18.667749Matthew CrightonWe need a real alternative! And some Scottish politicians prepared to stand up for it.16632012-10-30T10:06:39.89750David JacobsenThe six demands in this petition are achievable. They can be practically applied and promoted in our daily lives. I am reminded of the original Chartists whose crusade for working class trade unions was achieved only through struggle. A great power when the film from our eyes is wiped clear and the People of Britain work to build a better future free from the harness of Capital. We Stand on the Shoulders of Giants and Remember their Sacrifices for a better world.16632012-10-30T10:25:28.28751Patricia PlunkettMost of my adult life has been fighting for Independence. I truly believe we as a nation will encourage the heart back into politics which has sadly been missing for a long time. The coalition government have had their way with austerity measures on debt we do not even owe, whilst spending our oil revenue on English projects. I have had enough of this Westminster parliament and want rid of it. The Trident latest being forced once again on us Scots is diabolical. I was one of the original Faslane peace campers who set up camp in June the 10th. I fought Thatcher and her cuts and her poll tax. I will continue to my dying breath to fight for fairness in Scotland.16632012-10-30T15:08:17.043752Michael Davisthe Scottish Goverment should be doing more about this and other matters that confront the lives of the public.16562012-10-30T18:17:08.157753Tommy MastersonSave the trees!!16622012-10-30T22:55:46.017754Maria LavertyMore recognition and help needed for this condition and Fibromyalgia16872012-10-31T11:12:58.443755Colin Hayward YoungThis petition demands support as the issues raised affect a number of communities around our coastline. The lack of action by authorites and the detrimental actions by others who have control over rivers and estuaries have led to continual deterioration of river banks and coastlines with serious financial implications for local inhabitants due to flooding, loss of land and the threat to dwellings. Those responsible need to be brought to account and effective measures brought forward to address the problems.16562012-10-31T12:30:15.217756Melessaving nature saves our globe!16622012-11-01T11:46:11.327757Rafael YoungThis isn't just about improving the care given (although that's important), it's about protecting the rights of Scottish patients, and - perhaps most of all in these difficult times - preventing a huge, HUGE unnecessary spend to ship these people out of the country. 16872012-11-01T23:20:10.143758 CarliThank you for doing this and for anyone who signs. HG almost killed me and my little one. I was deathly ill for 9 months straight. I suffered with multiple PICC lines and a portacath, was in the hospital so much with blood infections and severe dehydration and starvation. I was kept alive on IV's 24-7, bed ridden and alone. This disease is so far beyond morning sickness, it goes deep and tortures it's victim on every level. These women need help and support- please do not forget us.16412012-11-03T03:09:46.773759AishaThough i dont live in scotland i badly want that they provide good medical support to all the HG sufferrers. Only HG patient can truly understand how it feels\r\nthanks to everyone for signing this petition\r\n\r\n16412012-11-03T14:48:02.663760KyleenI am in the States, but really wish that this would become a more recognized illness globally, with support for all of the women who suffer through these difficult pregnancies. Having qualified and adequate support makes all the difference!16412012-11-03T21:50:32.19761TovaKnowledge is power and empowering. To suffer through hyperemsis gravidarum without adequate support (physical, emotional or otherwise) is unfortuantely too common. I've had HG twice. Thank you for helping to end the ignorance about this severe and unrelenting disease. 16412012-11-03T22:57:03.413762CarrieHyperemesis is awful for all those who suffer it. I think support should definitely be put into place for those who need it as it can cause a lot of distress. 16412012-11-03T23:45:18.07763Lynnette SpraggHaving been hospitalised 3 times with HG myself, I can safely say it depends which staff are working that shift as to how you are treated. My first stay was amazing, my nurse was lovely and I sent a thank you card. My third stay was horrific, the nurses wanted me out ASAP and i complained. HG women need more support and midwives need more training.16412012-11-04T13:00:04.523764Arthur Mc FarlaneYes, I completely agree. If we, the people, are to continue to ask judges to make, on our behalf, huge decisions which affect our fellow citizens we have a duty to find out much more about them than we presently know. In matters of justice we can never have too much transparency.15972012-11-04T13:15:01.97765Isabel Corcoranseems to me this needs urgent attention16412012-11-04T21:26:01.627766Natalie RobbThank you to EVERYONE who has signed!! Spread the word to family and friends, we desperatly need this help in Scotland xx16412012-11-05T00:57:09.723767Dorothy-Grace ElderSusan Archibald is a superb campaigner for the disabled - chronic pain services are grossly under-funded and must be aided. Remember that over 700,000 suffer pain long term in Scotland, to varying degrees, up to a suicidal state of agony.16872012-11-05T10:52:06.667768Richard Dixonhurrah16622012-11-05T23:14:32.997769Louise WoodlandA needed support unfortunately many women may be so Sick they have to abort their own child I have heard in their past, specialist nurses need to suppose women with this condition and also conditions like Obstetric cholestasis which my Mother suffered from when pregnant with me and my sister at times she felt suicidal with the itching such a shame on people with these conditions. 16412012-11-06T00:15:39.873770Arlene CaldwellAs a healthcare professional working with many patients for the past 10 years in a pharmacy setting- I still find it incomprehensible that in this day and age we don't have a specialist in this field closer to home. Too many patients wait far too long for a referral to a pain clinic if that is even offered to them once conventional treatments fail. I have heard of too many patients in crippling agony having to fight to see a specialist which I find unacceptable. In today's fast paced world there can be and should be more facilities available for patients. I fully support this petition.16872012-11-06T11:55:49.73771Sophie RobertsExtra help for pregnant woman is needed!16412012-11-06T12:49:41.683772Rebecca MacaulayI suffered this condition throughout all 3 pregnancies, it was the worst feeling in the world I actually physically felt my body giving up on me an really believed I was going to die, I felt no one understood just how serious it was I understood my friends an family, even my partner not understanding the condition an believing I was exaggerating the sickness but I was totally mortified and shocked to see how little "so called" health professionals knew or cared about the condition, as a result of the condition I ended up in hospital with all 3 pregnancies on drips and medication to help me an I got extremely depressed! Thankfully all 3 of my babies survived an were born very healthy but I've heard of people lossing their unborn babies an in extreme cases their own lives! More funding needs to be put into the research of Hyperemisis and ALL doctors, nurses and midwives should be fully trained and aware of the condition! We must help all the women who have, are and will suffer with Hyperemisis to feel they are not alone!16412012-11-06T12:52:58.587773Rebecca MacaulayI totally support this petition to get the help n support needed in Scotland but I do feel help an support should be given everywhere, not just Scotland! I'm from Wirral, England and there is no support here, what so ever, especially from health care professionals! 16412012-11-07T16:21:08.303774Sean EdgarPeople should support this!!!16412012-11-07T16:34:06.853775mike wallaceMore power to ye Susan...if Drumatik Drum Group can help, just ask :-)16872012-11-07T16:39:16.7776Shonagh Potter MillsThe Scots Pine, perfect choice.16622012-11-07T16:52:37.773777James RobertsonLet's celebrate our trees16622012-11-07T17:51:49.13778mrs alice guyim Scottish and proud of it so come on u scots lets do it 4 our future children make it count 16412012-11-07T18:59:54.367779Nicola BartlettGood luck with the petition. You have done Sharon proud x 16262012-11-07T19:43:09.537780Duncan macphersonHopefully this will help towards better and faster diagnosis from doctors, this shouldn't have happened, now a wife, mother, sister , daughter, friend is gone, you will be missed Sharon 16262012-11-07T22:23:01.8781Susan StrachanI suffered from this in my second pregnancy and its absolutely awful. I had a little boy already who was only 1 and my husband was unfortunatley away with work (armed forces and his job meant I could not tell him what was happening let alone him getting back to help!). I was sent to the hospital so many times and was always the same thing placed on drip for few hours then packed off home! eventually I got an appointment with my own doctor as I was going out my mind and couldnt cope anymore and he forced the hospital to admit me as it had got so bad my liver wasnt functioning properly! its so bad that there isnt more support for this. when i was being "treated" with the drip at the hospital they were so rude and were basically like you're fine get on with it. If it had not been for my doctor making sure I got admitted for a week I dont know how things would have turned out. There is a definite need for specialist help with this and fast!!16412012-11-08T00:08:06.977782Katherine DiscombeI had a friend with this condition, who was so ill in pregnancy that she couldn't even get out of bed in the morning before she had thrown up - it was dire.16412012-11-08T02:55:55.647783Arlene Holmes Please please, make this happen... In memory of Sharon... XxXxXxX 16262012-11-08T08:44:38.547789prakashcpandaevery country should name a tree as their national tree , a gift which can offer to our future generation.16622012-11-08T08:46:44.67790Mr Johannes Feigl....................as per usual...................the public are always the last to know, and the first to suffer................insurance companies are a cancer in our society, feeding on the fear and misfortune, and getting rich in the process.16262012-11-08T10:05:52.86791LynseyI didn't even know Sharon but work with someone who did and they spoke highly of Sharon. It is unfortunate circumstances that this petition is being collaborated however let's make amense and help to save some other live by making people aware xxx GBNF RIP Sharon x16262012-11-08T10:29:12.907792Karen HendersonAs a fellow dancing mum it is important that we support Grant & the kids as we certainly don't want to loose anymore of our dancing family if we can help it. You are doing a fantastic job, please don't give up16262012-11-08T10:44:52.047793CherieCancer takes too many people too soon. Everything that can prevent this should be done.16262012-11-08T11:03:09.423794Laura JenkinsLife is cruel that it takes the death of loved one to make people aware. I really hope this petition does some good. RIP Sharon xx16262012-11-08T11:51:41.857795Lorne WalkerLets kick Cancers ass! To many taken by this terrible ilness.16262012-11-08T11:59:27.817796Gerry MullenIn loving memory of shaz R I P, this fight for awareness shall grow stronger & stronger ti save other lives from this terrible condition16262012-11-08T12:47:53.18797Graham MillarI'm fortunate to have been registered for annual screening post transplant and believe all patients should be guaranteed this service.16262012-11-08T13:06:28.75798Grant ThomsonThank you to everyone who has supported this petition and also for the supportive comments. I saw one comment about preferring the risks of medication to a life on dialysis and I understand completely that point of view however the point of this campaign is that, post-transplant, patients should be in the best possible position to manage those risks so they have the best chance of leading a healthy and long life.16262012-11-08T14:59:51.313799Robert BoltonIf you have had the opportunity to walk through one on of our ancient forests this is a must go and see them in all their grace.16622012-11-08T15:45:55.687800Nikki HillGood Luck Grant!!!16262012-11-08T16:56:26.873801Tom MinogueWe should know as much as possible about the interests (pecunary and fraternal) of our decision makers. \r\nI would go further and call for a ban on judges holding directorships of companies that their decisions have affected. It cannot be right that a judge can waive prosecution of big businesses such as oil companies whose employees are killed by corporate manslaughter and then the judge goes on to the board of the oil company.15972012-11-08T17:16:23.483802Linda DignanThe Scots Pine is the most beautiful tree, I just love looking at them in our glen and wish the country was more populated by them. They absolutely should be Scotland's national tree.16622012-11-08T17:40:30.47803katrina mitchellGreat cause to raise awareness too many lifes lost16262012-11-08T18:47:40.967804Annette Connelly In memory of sharon i knew her from high school was a year above me cant believe that such a tragic thing like this has happend to someone that i knew and that if she and her family had the full facts that she may still be with us today if this prevents some other family from going through this then it will be worth it x good luck for the future x\r\n16262012-11-08T19:25:29.91805ROBERT ALEXANDERNOT BEFORE TIME15972012-11-08T23:14:48806CherieCancer takes too many people too soon. Everything that can prevent this should be done.16262012-11-09T10:13:15.39807LornaI would love the Scots Pine to be recognised as Scotland's National Tree as it is, and has for many years, been my favourite tree. Whenever I see one I am reminded of happy memories of holidays all around Scotland.16622012-11-09T15:02:23.907808Gemma Frances BradyI've commented here before but wanted to comment again to emphasise how important this cause is! I suffered for 9 months with this condition and got treated in hospital but they made me feel like I was making it up! Thankfully I made it through it somehow! I suffered it again recently and thought I was ready to take it on however it hit me quicker and harder than before! Didn't think it could've got worse only this time I'm ashamed and sad to say I ended the pregnancy, my 2 year old was extremely distressed seeing me so ill and made my family angry as they thought I was selfish not being there for her,no one supported me during it,such an horrific condition! I really want more kids and don't want my daughter suffering this when she's older!16412012-11-10T09:18:36.807810Rosemary CameronMuch needed service.16412012-11-10T16:52:48.803811Robert GreenThere has been a welcome movement in many countries for greater transparency over the backgrounds of those in positions of considerable power and trust.\r\n\r\nIt is time that the judiciary were subject to such scrutiny, so as to avoid any possible suspicion over any conflict of interest issues15972012-11-10T20:54:44.537813William GordonIf MP & MSP's interests are to be made public so should Judges.15972012-11-11T00:00:03.173814Stewart ThomsonMy wife Jude had hyperemesis,many variations in how many women are affected. Many of the professionals I have had to deal with have had little or no idea at all about the condition. I have encouraged them to find out more by visiting the pregnancy support services website. Had the professionals known about hyperemesis Jude would have had the correct support,diagnosis and medication much much earlier.16412012-11-11T14:59:07.993815lizzyhope u feel better soon16412012-11-11T22:13:34.553816Anne SCould not have suggested a more appropriate tree.\r\n16622012-11-11T23:36:05.24817Rose Elgart-FailMy daughter and I survived hyperemesis only with the help of www.helpher.org, which I found nearly by accident. Every single time I share this resource, someone speaks up who either suffered this nightmare illness or knows of a woman who did. Please don't leave the fates of thousands of women to chance. Create a nursing position that cares for women and unborn children who can be saved by your actions.16412012-11-12T00:12:33.127818Jane A CondieAlthough only a symbolic gesture, I think this is a lovely idea. I support this petition16622012-11-12T00:16:39.037820Roger W. Ross (Selkirk Pipey)Makes perfect sense to me!16622012-11-12T00:19:10.583821WayneMore trees should be planted all over Scotland.16622012-11-12T01:23:04.943822Brian ClarkFavourite tree of the Osprey !!16622012-11-12T08:02:32.787823Kristen BakerI have suffered from this in 2 pregnancies and have found it to be a hugely misunderstood condition. To have specialist nurses available not only validates this debilitating illness but also would provide support which would help get pregnant women through. I know of women who have considered terminations due to this condition, and know it will limit the number of children I have. Nurses who don't treat you like you're making a fuss or making it up would be amazing.16412012-11-12T08:28:20.96824Michael G CooperI live in pain, more needs to be done for us chronic pain sufferers. :(16872012-11-12T11:22:10.233825Marion FergusonIt's urgent now, that this petition for such a worthy cause, is signed and shared as soon as possible.16772012-11-12T11:43:36.773826David McCannGood luck with this worthy petition16622012-11-12T11:46:31.273827Natalie FeeThis drug is a must! Why should people be left to suffer when there is a known medication available with MASSIVE benefits. How can you put a cost on someones life? Lets get this ASAP!! 16772012-11-12T11:48:08.93828Teresa SuperThe CF G551D community have tracked the the development of this drug for years. It is innovative, there is no alternative to it, they need access NOW - it is litterally life saving! 16772012-11-12T11:50:43.84829Susan HartInstead of spending millions on drug addicts why not spend on the kids that want to live life to the full. These kids were born with CF they did not ask for it and spend too much of their lives taking med or in hospital when 2 blue pills would get rid and let them lead the lives they deserve.16772012-11-12T12:20:12.68830Teresa FullerKalydeco is the first drug of its kind to treat the underlying cause of Cystic Fibrosis. It is truly a life saving drug for those with the G551D mutation. To deny this medication to those who could directly benefit is medical cruelty. For decades, patients with CF and their loved ones have waited and hoped for a groundbreaking medication like Kalydeco. Now it is finally here. Please show compassion and save lives by making it immediately available to all who can benefit.16772012-11-12T12:40:06.93831lorna whiteit's terrible that people have to rely on donations for drugs like this, when the government is spending millions of pounds on Methadon users, and 90% of them have no intention of getting clean.\r\nour governments is needing to get their act together.\r\nthe rules change when any of their childern become ill, and need some kind of special drug that is not available in this country,\r\nits time we started looking after our own sick people instead of sending all this money to other countries.16772012-11-12T12:42:26.853832Tony CaunceThis has dragged on too long stop haggling and provide this essential drug NOW16772012-11-12T12:42:34.103833Donna VaughanI have a 26 year old daughter with this gene. I have waited for this miracle for so long. These children were born with this. It is not self inflicted and yet the goverment. Still spend millions on drug addicts without any hesitation. It makes my blood boil. Our children need this lifeline. Please find it in your heart to fulfill our dreams. Would the decision be easier if it were your child?16772012-11-12T13:07:56.303834Angela McGowanThis new drug has helped my niece so much please make it available to everyone else please. Thank you16772012-11-12T13:09:29.773835hayleyi had a sister with this gene and sadly she past away 5yrs ago on her 18th birthday so in allways happy to help cf..just wish they would find a cure x16772012-11-12T13:21:42.93836Claire WhelanPlease start this now & save lives PLEASE, Save lives not money 16772012-11-12T13:25:18.47837Sarah NorthThis will transform young peoples lives, enabling them to stay out of hospital, to have careers and live normally16772012-11-12T13:41:42.097838Laura BrownMy friends daughter has it and by god it would be amazing gor her to receive this drug. Her and her family suffer enough like you all do. God willing . All c.f. sufferers will be granted a life xxxxxx 16772012-11-12T13:48:39.29839Bryan slavencut back on the funding given to drug addicts,and fund the cystic fibrosis treatment so badly needed.16772012-11-12T13:53:11.04840Kylie Ryan Find a cure quickly and save those little lives!16772012-11-12T13:56:55.317841Lorraine SmithIt is your moral duty to make this drug available NOW! CF sufferers need to be put before people addicted to alcohol, drugs or food!16772012-11-12T14:05:29.437842Gareth BarwiseThis will transform young peoples lives, lets do this!!16772012-11-12T14:09:38.473843florence bruceMy poor sister was like that during her pregnancy, only thing she could keep down was Sugar Puffs16412012-11-12T14:15:31.447844Robert AitkenAs parent of two daughters with the gene, one of whom was on the drug trial preceding approval, I know what a huge difference it can make. A National Health Service which does not approve this is not worthy of the name.16772012-11-12T14:29:21.993845Kathleen M SmithWe must preserve the Scots Pine now. Rather forests than concrete jungles.16622012-11-12T14:30:27.44846Julie GordonPlease give our daughter Kate the future she deserves and all her fellow CF sufferers 16772012-11-12T14:54:51.21847Peter ChisholmThe delay in making this drug available is cruel beyond comprehension. Make this available NOW!16772012-11-12T15:00:49.383848Katrina HowiesonThis drug will add years to my young daughter's life and those of all CF G551D patients... but they must get it so very soon!16772012-11-12T15:17:38.46849Rebecca SchroederMy son has been taking Kalydeco since Feb, 10 2011 and it has been nothing short of a life-changing miracle! Considering the degenerative nature of cystic fibrosis, it is extremely important to get this drug to patient's NOW! After seeing the impact of the drug first hand, I can honestly say that denying access to those with who need it should be considered torture and medically unacceptable.16772012-11-12T15:32:06.447850david merriganthis drug will add years to my nephews life, make this available NOW!!!!!!16772012-11-12T15:53:05.367851Mathieu CareyPlease give CF sufferers a chance to live long and fruitful lives!16772012-11-12T16:25:37.757852frances clark rossPlease help save lives of children who are dying because they cannot get this medication. My grandaughter who lives in US, it saved her life by finally gettting on this medicine. Please don't you want to lie down at night and think about the lives of children, not dying but the ones of those lives that were saved because of YOU..\r\n16772012-11-12T16:31:32.697853Fiona DuthiePlease give CF sufferers a chance to live long and fruitful lives!16772012-11-12T16:46:42.823854Tilda BlackThis drug will give my daughter a future. Please, please make Kalydeco available now!!!16772012-11-12T16:50:14.413855Emma whelanmy nephew has been through so much already and needs this for a longer life please get it out ASAP16772012-11-12T17:00:59.493856Gavin McLeanPlease make Kalydeco available16772012-11-12T17:02:24.793857Eileen McLeanPlease help all the CF sufferers in Scotland16772012-11-12T17:12:54.523858Maria McGivernIt's awful that it is being delayed it should be made more available. Please! 16772012-11-12T17:24:57.477859Vicki SalvageThis drug should be made available to everyone with CF. I hope this petition helps to achieve this goal. . . .16772012-11-12T17:33:22.71860diane mcmillanKalydeco should be made available in Scotland, for all the people who would benefit from it!!16772012-11-12T17:34:46.93861John McLeanAs you all sit round the table imagine your child has CF.16772012-11-12T17:57:07.32863William VogelsangSigning for a friend whose daughter suffers from this.16772012-11-12T18:01:02.697864Cindy BaldwinPlease make kalydeco available!16772012-11-12T18:23:18.337865dawn lavertySurely anything to relieve the suffering of these unfortunate people must be made available now.16772012-11-12T18:30:20.96866Suzanne diversPlease get this cure for our babies!16772012-11-12T18:30:24.21867Karen-Ann Robertsonplease help CF sufferes of Scotland,16772012-11-12T18:31:58.367868Stephen McPheeSave the forrest walks :)16622012-11-12T18:43:51.553869Kathryn walkerPlease make funding available to help CF patients in Scotland. 16772012-11-12T18:44:28.947870Paul RuddPlease make this available NOW.16772012-11-12T18:47:51.257871Davina A GriffinThe change this drug would make to those with the G551D gene is awesome. PLEASE make this available in Scotland as soon as possible. If the drug is considered too expensive deduct medications, long, frequent stays in hospital, care of many professionals, equipment and other treatments which will be deductable from cost.16772012-11-12T18:50:23.513872June BarclayPlease ensure that Kalydeco is offered as treatment to those with CF in Scotland.16772012-11-12T19:20:22.003873MaureenMy great niece and nephew have CF...please give them all the help they can get to have a good quality of life16772012-11-12T19:31:24.853874E Gallagher This drug would be beneficial for not only me but for my family member who also has C.F... 16772012-11-12T19:39:58.227875Lorraine HunterPlease help all the CF sufferers in Scotland16772012-11-12T19:42:28.753876Julie AskinsThis drug must be made available for all G115D suffers to give them a Brighter, Happier and Healthier Life, They have the right to Breathe.\r\n16772012-11-12T19:45:11.603877Michelle Purdie If any of you have a heart please make this treatment available. Thank you 16772012-11-12T19:47:33.117878Andy AskinsEveryone that needs this should be getting it without having to fight!!!!16772012-11-12T19:52:14.203879gina burkegood luck with the petition,,lets hope it does some good,,,best wishes to all who suffer from this disease16772012-11-12T19:52:35.58880Aimee AskinsPlease stop the suffering for people with CF 16772012-11-12T19:54:33.087881Leigh VerdotI suffered from this condition in my last pregnancy. To have someone who had understood how I was feeling and offered support would have made such a difference to me. Please help other women to receive the help they deserve.16412012-11-12T19:56:50.853882Kate AskinsWe need to stop the suffering. I watched my brother suffer, it hurts.16772012-11-12T20:05:38.11883Hayden AskinsIt's so cruel to invent a life changing drug and then having to fight to make it available.16772012-11-12T20:10:11.49884Julie SymePlease make kalydeco available in Scotland to save lives16772012-11-12T20:36:17.827885LINDA BLACKMy granddaughter and niece both have this rare G551D gene and would benefit greatly from this drug please help them and all others who suffer CF16772012-11-12T20:39:51.503886jacqueline sutherlandPlease make Kalydeco available to C.F. patients in Scotland.16772012-11-12T20:45:50.493887John McDermottaything to help these poor children and the trauma they go through16772012-11-12T20:47:49.2888Fiona MurphyPlease help ease the suffering 16772012-11-12T20:50:52.53889Clare RodgerPlease help everyone with CF xx16772012-11-12T21:05:02.053890Liz EckersleyPlease help! its a horrible disease!\r\n16772012-11-12T21:29:47.803891Margaret HowshamSo many young children would benefit from this drug, especially my friend's one-year-old grandson! Medical assistance should be available whatever the cost!! PLEASE!16772012-11-12T22:06:03.117892Pauline Morrison Please let sufferers like my god daughter get this drug kalydeco and give them a chance of living a longer life 16772012-11-12T22:06:37.913894Thomas FergusonI have cystic fibrosis G551D, and I believe that this life-saving drug should be made available in Scotland immediately!16772012-11-12T22:07:31.673895Amy FeePlease help all the scottish sufferers. I work with babies who have this condition.. 16772012-11-12T22:26:22.037896Jill penmanAmazing breakthrough, cf sufferers and their families must be thrilled16772012-11-12T22:26:53.443897Sean Robinson Help my boy Thomas ferguson 16772012-11-12T22:30:56.51898Sean Robinson Help my boy Thomas and all the other CF patients x16772012-11-12T22:33:50.257899Douglas Elliott EskdalePlease make some funding available for this to progress the cost of not doing so will outweigh the cost of doing in not just in financial loss from future and present taxpayers but in moral loss from a failure to do good when it is in our power to do so.16772012-11-12T22:36:56.697900AdenThis is for my friend Hannah 16772012-11-12T22:37:30.257901gunilla gordonIt would be awful if this huge advance in treatment of this disease were not given financial support.16772012-11-12T22:45:55.773902J DolanLets all Help and work together x16772012-11-12T23:22:57.077903j.corkethe Scots Pine seems the obvious national tree \r\nfor Scotland16622012-11-12T23:55:09.633904James McMahonAye16622012-11-13T00:08:27.993905Sarah KellyI agree that they should give more money! Very good\r\nCause! Xxx16772012-11-13T00:30:39.68906Andy WilsonSigning this for my mate tam ferguson!!16772012-11-13T00:31:33.117907Sean McHugh For tam ferguson make kalydeco available 16772012-11-13T00:44:55.573908Jamie cameronGet well soon16772012-11-13T00:56:25.93909Brian SteeleJudiciary should declare all financial interests, including income sources, directorships, shareholdings and investments. Also membership of any organisations and associations.15972012-11-13T01:24:11.71910kim apterYou cannot put a price on a childs life..you should make this drug available now .16772012-11-13T01:29:34.767911andrew thomsonmake kalydeco available!16772012-11-13T02:04:32.54912Fiona AndersonSigning for my friend who I've known all seventeen years of my life, hopefully this will help her somehow! x16772012-11-13T02:09:14.17913Yasmin LoveWe really need to cure this disease. Please help us!16772012-11-13T04:48:05.857914Kim GrahamThis is for our nephew16772012-11-13T07:03:23.96915Sean BlakePlease fund this drug.16772012-11-13T09:06:16.96916June Wright"why? with millions being spent on people with self inflicted illnesses!! why do children with a geneticly unavoidable illness have to suffer???16772012-11-13T09:06:51.117917Dave SoutarIf we all just paid £1 for our prescriptions it would mean others could breathe - is that too much to ask?16772012-11-13T09:15:37.243918Aimee craigGive cf suffer the chance to lead a normal life like anyone else!xxx a friend of mine has it and my cousin also has it!xxx 16772012-11-13T09:29:22.06919Tony HigsonWhy do we pay lazy people to stay at home on welfare, when kids are in pain. The world has gone mad !!!16772012-11-13T09:34:04.993920Stephen NaylorGood luck 16772012-11-13T09:34:16.413921mandi andersonis it really worth putting all these people through this suffering for the cost of this drug, im sure there are people out there that would rather see our taxes put to this instead of some of the things we are funding. these people deserve to live life to the full, you can make it happen with one little word YES.16772012-11-13T09:43:34.197922karin mcnallyMy cousin and friends mums daughter has this condition so sad please sign 16772012-11-13T09:55:37.247923Leigh WallacePlease make available in the UK & Ireland16772012-11-13T10:05:29.46924Kathryn SpencePaperwork shouldn't stand in the way of saving people. 16772012-11-13T10:08:30.743925Alan Henderson Please help all CF sufferers x16772012-11-13T10:14:29.743927peter stockwellstop unnecessary suffering now16772012-11-13T10:39:49.487928Robert RaeOver the years my family have had great treatment from the NHS hope this treatment can be added to the list.\r\nBest Regards\r\nRobert16772012-11-13T10:49:55.053929Elizabeth TaitEvery child in Scotland deserves the best available healthcare.16772012-11-13T11:36:39.04930sarah mcgeoughYay!16772012-11-13T11:38:22.37931Daniel McElhinneyPlease help CF sufferers - we in Scotland need this groundbreaking medicine.16772012-11-13T12:05:17.087932Ciaran CareyMake it happen16772012-11-13T12:16:23.243933Ray HawkinsA great cause that affects many people in Ireland and Scotland. I have many friends who suffer with C.F. and we did a parachute jump 18 months ago\r\n for C.F. Ireland. The very best of luck with this petition!! 16772012-11-13T12:17:57.507934Simon CoakleyPlease help all the CF sufferers in Scotland\r\n16772012-11-13T12:22:52.773935Callum Hopkins Please make this stuff available16772012-11-13T13:05:38.29937chantelle baillie Help my friend xx16772012-11-13T13:06:37.837938Karen HastiePlease make Kalydeco available16772012-11-13T13:42:25.087939louise bridgesPlease make this life changing drug available now!16772012-11-13T13:42:51.127940Stewart McFarlaneBig well done to everyone who signed this. Lots of love16772012-11-13T13:45:12.96941aileen darrochSupporting my friend and her son xx16772012-11-13T13:53:12.907942Cameron RobbinsMy big brother passed away after a long battle of 22 years with Cystic Fibrosis. I've witnessed first-hand how horrible this disease is, and everything should be done to prevent and cure it. Please pass this around to friends and family, share it on Facebook, Tweet it, do your bit.16772012-11-13T13:56:31.627943Robert BrownHelp this little girl and her family16772012-11-13T13:57:19.613944Mark GlancyPull the finger out Salmond and do something good and worthwhile for once.16772012-11-13T14:02:11.227945Robert BellShocking situation for 2012 What is going on in this mindless world16772012-11-13T14:05:47.477946Margaret BellHave we gave up caring16772012-11-13T14:08:17.737947Iain MorrisonWe need a better resourced and funded pain management clinic for all parts of Scotland!16872012-11-13T14:12:20.18948Gabriella PansiniPlease make kalydeco available16772012-11-13T14:19:16.21950Mr G Chalmerskeep up the good spirt16772012-11-13T14:26:32.48951Tillie BeatonPlease make more funds available16772012-11-13T14:31:54.343952Patrick Marleymake additional funding available for the immediate prescription of Ivacaftor (Kalydeco) whilst awaiting SMC approval in order that patients do not suffer as a result of administrative delays.16772012-11-13T14:37:12953mandy martinPlease make Kalydeco available16772012-11-13T14:51:30.417954Agnes Craig Anything that helps should be made available regardless of cost 16772012-11-13T14:52:51.993955kirstie macdonell Please make this drug available. \r\n16772012-11-13T15:13:31.577956moira macdonaldPlease give these children and adults a fair chance at life.\r\n16772012-11-13T15:17:58.007957Nicola CrossanThis would make a huge difference to all the cystic fibrosis patients out there!!!!16772012-11-13T15:24:05.823958karen macleanplease help those struck by this illness16772012-11-13T15:25:40.213959Diana BlajPlease make the medicine available, we desperately need it!16772012-11-13T15:25:49.98960Patric BairdCan there be any other tree?16622012-11-13T15:39:57.757961Julie McErlean Every child in Scotland deserves the best available healthcare.16772012-11-13T15:40:53.023962Keyser SauzeyIt is incredible that the Scottish Government has not insisted that this must be in place.\r\n\r\nIt is even more incredible that the Government & Court have no intention to do so.\r\n\r\nAre we the Public supposed to take the Judiciary's word of mouth promise that they are acting according to the law? If we are then we the Public are leaving ourselves open to Institutional abuse of power.\r\n\r\nIf the Scottish Public are to have any faith in the Judiciary in a climate when MP's, Police, the BBC and the Press have been shown to be liers then it must be MANDATORY for the judiciary to be able to show that they are fit for purpose and have characters beyond reproach as a minimum standard to be able to carry out their duties.\r\n\r\nExperience has shown, if a group is resistant against transparency then they have something to hide.15972012-11-13T15:49:39.893963John PrimroseHealth v Cost no contest, make it available asap!16772012-11-13T15:55:57.14964Jessica WilliamsHelp!16772012-11-13T15:57:28.84965euan russell Please give thomas this treatment. He's hard working and really deserves it 16772012-11-13T15:58:22.513966Jacqueline fergusonPlease make this pill available in the uk ! 16772012-11-13T15:58:33.25967Lisa BrockettMake this available ASAP 16772012-11-13T16:08:27.017968Gillian McCallumThis could give sick kids a much better quality life. Please do not deny these children that chance.16772012-11-13T16:16:13.683969Hazel IrvingAnything which will make a difference is surely worthwhile!16772012-11-13T16:21:34.97970Miriam Pye Please help these sick children live a better life16772012-11-13T16:32:37.597971Callum WilsonHave no idea why this isnt available already! It could save so many people16772012-11-13T16:34:49.737972Josh JoyceMake this available as Thomas really needs it!16772012-11-13T16:41:22.39973Calum GibsonMake it happen now, lives depend on it.16772012-11-13T16:47:04.36974Anne Dunnplease make this available as soon as possible and make a positive impact on numerous lives.16772012-11-13T16:53:18.773975David ForsythThis drug is required now and should be made available without delay16772012-11-13T16:55:22.463976Rhonda HallIt's a no brainer, if this condition was suffered by the politicians kids then they would be pushing it through mega fast. If you want our votes then get Crackin !!!16772012-11-13T16:59:56.063977john robertsonMake this available ASAP16772012-11-13T17:06:18.617978Lynsey HallChildren should never be denied any health care. They are too precious. X16772012-11-13T17:22:41.737979nikole kesslerGod bless16772012-11-13T17:28:06.987980Clare ciambroneMake this available as it can save so many life's! 16772012-11-13T17:31:28.147981Marlyn GodfreyWhatever it takes to help manage this horrible illness. Our children deserve the best regardless of cost16772012-11-13T17:47:29.773983Victoria RowlandsI can't believe we need a petition for something as important as this, the Government have no problem finding billions for a never to be completed transport system but childrens lives....... Says a lot about the country we live in.16772012-11-13T17:53:44.487984jordan youngHope everyone with this condition recieves the funding they need to get better 16772012-11-13T17:55:07.237985Tracey BallYour captcha is dire. It took me about 10 attempts.16772012-11-13T17:55:25.767986Pauline Lambe CF Sufferers need this NOW!!!!!16772012-11-13T18:04:25.343987Karly HendersonMake this available deffos16772012-11-13T18:06:18.403988walter brown please sign \r\n16772012-11-13T18:14:29.923989Susan ShawTime to be pro-active!\r\n16772012-11-13T18:28:36.89990christine duncanplease dont let these kids suffer anymore than they already do16772012-11-13T18:32:02.08991Esther devineIll be keeping you and your family in my prayers. 16772012-11-13T18:33:04.237992Paul DalyHow people can give drug addicts help but cant help this its very bad....16772012-11-13T18:38:17.05993Kay NisbetThis drug really makes such a huge difference to the lives of these people! Please make it available! 16772012-11-13T18:53:08.097994Ken GodfreyJust do it!!16772012-11-13T19:04:33.203995Iain mortonKids are too precious to noit pick on treatments 16772012-11-13T19:07:00.547996Alice MooreThis drug should be made available to those with the G551D gene mutation without any further delay as it will save lives.16772012-11-13T19:08:34.507997Isabell hollis I think it's a disgrace that there has tone a petition for this drug ppl with this condition are going thru enough as it is and anything that is going to help or make suffering easier so to speak should be on the market immediately 16772012-11-13T19:08:57.227998stacey cairns cure cystic fibrosis fast be 4 wee lose more people wee love pleace xxx16772012-11-13T19:30:02.7431000Nicola Kane I hope it happens x16772012-11-13T19:41:16.6271001Liz von DoussaWould make an immeasurable difference to those it affects - needs to be made available ASAP16772012-11-13T19:52:19.111002neil struthersIf something makes a difference use it16772012-11-13T19:53:53.3171003KeriHeroin addicts get methadone on the nhs easy as that, but we are fighting to get this drug to save people with cf lives. It's all wrong. Get this drug ASAP!!!!!16772012-11-13T19:54:41.4571004Thomas SuperOur politicians need to look at their priorities. Children like my Grandson, 15, and a wonderful young man, deserve to live life fully. Without this new medicine, there will be further deterioration in his organs- that is for certain. he needs Kalydeco(Ivacaftor) NOW, please heed this petition!16772012-11-13T19:54:45.4531005Thomas SuperOur politicians need to look at their priorities. Children like my Grandson, 15, and a wonderful young man, deserve to live life fully. Without this new medicine, there will be further deterioration in his organs- that is for certain. he needs Kalydeco(Ivacaftor) NOW, please heed this petition!16772012-11-13T20:09:45.4431006Sheila SheddenThis would make a huge difference to these children and requires urgent action.16772012-11-13T20:10:10.9231007violet dempstermake this availlable asap in scotland16772012-11-13T20:14:54.0471008David carverWhile you wait and decide if its worth the governments money junkies will be picking up their methadone and getting every benefit under the sun...makes me so proud to be part of the uk....16772012-11-13T20:25:37.3331009Andrew MackayThis drug should be made readily available in this country as soon as possible to help assist people with this horrible condition.16772012-11-13T20:27:41.6931010claire daviesthis should be available 16772012-11-13T20:40:51.3771011Leanne kellyMake this available no one should be deprived of care they need 16772012-11-13T20:46:09.541012Joleen HutcheonPlease make this medication available. So many people will benefit and too many people have been lost. 16772012-11-13T20:46:39.3131013scott mckenziethink this should alreay be available16772012-11-13T20:53:13.3131014david grahamjunkies get methadone. these kids dont have a choice get your prioritys right government16772012-11-13T20:56:50.411016Jill HaymanEveryone should be able to receive this treatment16772012-11-13T21:01:50.6271017Dave MarshallMy wee grandson is two and a half a suffers from CF. This cost is far from prohibitive, please release the funds now to ensure his future,in Scotland. D. M. 16772012-11-13T21:01:55.0931018Jade LoudenMake this happen NOW!16772012-11-13T21:02:11.8071019Jenni WynneThis induction is very misunderstood and so are it's sufferers. Not enough people in the medical profession know about this. I am pleased to say I am a hg survivor!16412012-11-13T21:07:56.0331020Jennifer La TrobeWhat an opportunity16772012-11-13T21:16:38.861021Lynne BeatonAnything which will make a difference is worthwhile\r\n16772012-11-13T21:16:46.881022Andy RyanPlease help this boy with the treatment he needs 16772012-11-13T21:24:25.861023Stephen ConnellyHope this fills quickly16772012-11-13T21:32:52.111024kelly nussatiplease help!16772012-11-13T21:39:58.2971025Stephen jackMake this treatment available16772012-11-13T21:41:19.9331026Conor McCorryThis can help so many people.16772012-11-13T21:45:36.111027paddi obrienif you suffer with cronic pain the support you get from professionals is something cronic pain suffers should have easy access to.\r\nlike many cronic pain suffers medication is only part of the story the other half is called pain management this can only be achieved with cronic pain consultants16872012-11-13T21:51:53.51028Derek Smith ScotlandDo it now please16772012-11-13T22:05:40.2971029j campbellshe is a friend of a friend16772012-11-13T22:09:47.9371031Julie MichieAny thing that improves lives is a good thing16772012-11-13T22:33:20.211032Mark Mclaughlin Please make this drug available. To give better quality of life. 16772012-11-13T22:43:15.441033Linda BrownThis medication should be available to all those suffering from this terrible disease. Why should anyone be denied the right to a full and healthy life when this drug changes lives..16772012-11-13T22:44:52.051035Charles FergusonSupporting our childrens right to life ,treatment not trident !16772012-11-13T23:47:59.9831037Rebecca Barclay Surely there should be no questioning the availability of this where children's health and lives are concerned!16772012-11-14T00:09:10.7731038Chris RiddleOnce again I'm signing a petition for our kids to have the treatment they DESERVE, change things NOW!!16772012-11-14T02:51:52.9571039Faye UpstonThis medicine has saved & transformed my life! Please approve Kalydeco!!!!!16772012-11-14T07:35:59.4771040Elly HaywardIt seems an obvious choice -make it available.16772012-11-14T08:07:51.7631041rachel alcockwell done and thank you for doing this after 3 kids and no 4 on way my eldest being 11 now i would have thought people would be more aware but im still treated like im idoit by midwives and docs when i tell them how ill i am and if i mention hg they look at me as if it something i have made up so again thank you 16412012-11-14T08:23:08.2031042Val DarrochIt has transformed my nieces life, she lives in England and has just got married!16772012-11-14T08:44:44.561043Anna WaghornThere are more important things in life than money. Somethings should outweight cost. You will only realise that when you or someone you know has been seriously ill.16772012-11-14T09:46:00.8871044Jim McSkimmingThe best drugs should always be available to all. I work in Clinical research and have a keen interest in this topic.16772012-11-14T10:01:14.8971045gary rintoulLets hope the government see sense. Its a real shame for the family and those who are suffering.16772012-11-14T10:04:06.871047april harte Don't see why money should be the issue here,this is someone life we are talking about,someones daughter son,brother or sister or friend,make this acessable to the people who need it.16772012-11-14T10:19:28.371048AnnMarie McKennaA type of Independence that should be a higher priority.16772012-11-14T10:24:43.2931049Irene HudsonI think this sounds like a fabulous drug which will change lives and save on many hospital hours and other drugs. 16772012-11-14T10:52:47.2431050Nicola WalshWatching someone you love suffer from this terrible illness is heartbreaking. Give love a chance. Give life a chance. Give CF suffers a chance to breath. 16772012-11-14T11:15:34.2671051Jack RobbinsPeople with CF need the best treatment options made available now. 16772012-11-14T11:27:26.7071052Benjamin UpstonKalydeco gives quality of life like nothing else before, my wife's life has been restored, true hope for CF suffers!16772012-11-14T11:41:19.721053theresa leethis little girl needs this treatment so badly plz plz give it to her. if in same posotion she would sign for nyone 16772012-11-14T12:38:04.9631054FionaA beautiful and unique tree!\r\n16622012-11-14T12:46:11.5571055Max BurtonMy niece suffered and died from CF at the age of 5. Anything that prolongs life and enhances the enjoyment of that life should be promoted not resisted, not just for that person but for all those emotionally involved which brings the cost per person down considerably. 16772012-11-14T13:03:32.9931056elizabeth hoeygiving my full support 16772012-11-14T13:21:38.091057helen payneThis is not a drug that replaces a similar product, this is a ground breaking approach. The results seen in patients on this is astounding. If the NHS doesn't fund this, then ask yourself what will become acceptable for them to turn down next. Please sign for CF sufferers, but also for the future of the NHS in Scotland. We need a quality health care system, one that will fund and embraces new effective treatments, and not one that will be reduced to prescribing older less effective treatments because they are cheaper. Consultants who are not given the right tools ( i.e. be limited in what they can do for their patients), will go to greener pastures out of frustration. So all the funding the NHS has put into their training will be lost. By not funding this drug, the NHS will medically be taking a huge step backward. 16772012-11-14T13:25:29.591058Holly Richardsonfor Maisie16772012-11-14T14:30:15.7771060Julie Caunce, USAPlease make this groundbreaking drug available in the UK for all CF sufferers who can benefit. 16772012-11-14T15:30:03.231061Natalie For Maisie xx16772012-11-14T15:49:27.1631062William BurnsThis could be a stepping stone to make judges more accountable, as promised, but as quickly and sinisterly abandoned, by the former Justice Minister. At the end of April 2001, the Scottish Executive Justice Minister Jim Wallace made a long-overdue proposal that the exemption of Scots judges and sheriffs from being disciplined for "performance" and "behaviour" discrepancies was set to be removed because under the present system only two sheriffs have been dismissed in 30 years, while a Court of Session judge has never been removed from office. Supporting this petition will be a warning to the judiciary that the eyes of the public are as justified to appraise the integrity of their members as they are with the public.15972012-11-14T16:10:04.3531063Bowden PayneFor Maisie16772012-11-14T16:10:39.921064David MarleyFor Dylan16772012-11-14T16:10:56.8531065Bowden Paynefor Maisie16772012-11-14T16:15:21.871066Saskia RichardsonFor Maisie XX16772012-11-14T16:29:09.2231067Mr MurrayFor the wonderful Maise!16772012-11-14T16:31:33.6971068george comptonim on this drug and i KNOW it works and how amazing it is!!16772012-11-14T16:42:20.131069Craig MilneFor all CF sufferers.16772012-11-14T16:52:59.2931070Leeann DarrochPlease...16772012-11-14T17:47:58.1331071MaysellThe Scots Pine is a perfect representation of her people, tall strong and rich in heritage.16622012-11-14T18:02:26.9131072Jan Rollo-SmithIn rememberance of Karen x16772012-11-14T18:47:42.3671073Scott RichardsonFor Maisie xxx16772012-11-14T18:49:17.321074Colin BullThis needs to be made available in the UK 16772012-11-14T19:02:40.5331075Valerie Bevington WoodAnything that helps all with Cystic Fibrosis must be worth doing what ever the cost.16772012-11-14T19:07:14.861076Susan ReidEach and every person who suffers from CF deserves the right to have access to this drug. 16772012-11-14T19:21:42.4331077Mark PatonPlease allow this drug to be available, I give this my full support. Help please. Life is to short.16772012-11-14T19:27:03.441078ChristineFor Maisie16772012-11-14T19:37:11.7471079Ella Loganhoping that this drug will help our little grandson Logan!! please please make the funding available for this drug.. so that CF will stand for Cure Found 16772012-11-14T19:46:54.821080Christine evansFor Maisie X16772012-11-14T19:52:19.811082Marie Roselyne CareyPlease help and make this drug available for the CF sufferers. It would make such a difference to Kate's life ( our 7-year-old little niece)\r\n16772012-11-14T19:55:53.591083Stephanie Patterson Best wishes x16772012-11-14T20:10:54.0371084Stephanie Gilmour please allow this treatment to stop necessary suffering for cf sufferers.16772012-11-14T20:53:04.0771085Lynn GowFor Maisie Black xxxxx16772012-11-14T20:56:51.911086Joanne TealPlease support this bill.16772012-11-14T21:06:11.1731087Clare BonifaceDon't put a price on lives, give CF patients in Scotland and the rest of the UK the same chance as in other parts of the world!16772012-11-14T21:11:23.6931088Patrick Vincent CareyThis would provide an opportunity to extend and enhance the lives of many young people and their families.16772012-11-14T21:26:10.941089elizabeth milneFor Isabella16772012-11-14T22:01:26.2131090Pearl WiseFor Maisie16772012-11-14T22:03:05.841091Stephanie FraserPlease let this be effective as soon as possible because my best friend needs this and i want her in my life for a long time #65 roses \r\n16772012-11-14T22:08:51.061092Peter MacleodAbsolutely. There are no other trees that are only found in any numbers in Scotland and nowhere else.16622012-11-14T22:12:52.0431093clare bairdplease make this drug freely available for those who suffer this debillidating disease !16772012-11-14T22:17:17.1071094elaine alexandergood luck!hope it all goes well x16772012-11-14T22:19:03.7471095Fraser ThomsonMy 16 year old son has this gene. He is a fantastic person and I want to help any way I can. Please support this petition. Thanks.16772012-11-14T22:29:48.2931096CarolineFor Natasha Gibson x16772012-11-14T22:59:55.9071097Jack CollAye, Pinus Sylvestris does it for me16622012-11-14T23:27:28.51098moBack of the queue as always, get it sorted! 16772012-11-14T23:29:58.6531099Ina StewartThis little angel need help so bad,please let's help her for this treatment.16772012-11-15T00:11:04.7871100nikki haydenin very big support 16772012-11-15T03:30:55.5131101Irene LoganWe need to improve access to specialist chronic pain specialists services as soon as possible. Instead of GP's handing out pain medication they need to refer patients to pain services before it turns in to chronic pain16872012-11-15T03:54:11.781102allana norwoodFor maisie x x :)16772012-11-15T09:33:29.611103Wendy Wallis.....for all the little " Maisies " in Scotland x. x .16772012-11-15T09:59:49.7971104Donaldi'm pretty sure it is already the national tree of scotland16622012-11-15T10:32:20.7231105Amanda Murphy For Maisie and all the other children that are as special as her xxxx16772012-11-15T10:33:38.8771106Saskia RichardsonFor Maisie X16772012-11-15T10:48:27.7971107Helen RichardsonFor Maisie, Tilda and John thank you for all the effort and time you have given in order to raise awarness about this issue. We are all behind you and are signing this and getting friends and family to sign it to. Keep smiling as you always do.16772012-11-15T11:21:48.2031108Dawn Craig McLeanFor Maisie and all children who desperately need this treatment. When will the Government stop playing God and give the people who desperately need treatment what they deserve!!!! Where are their HUMAN RIGHTS!!!!!16772012-11-15T12:21:56.741109Please make this available and soon.Kate16772012-11-15T12:26:04.5971110SH I am too young to sign, my mum writes this but these are my words. I want my friend to be well for longer bits of time so we can play and she can be happy and not go into the hospital again. Please help.16772012-11-15T12:39:21.121111Angela LawsonI knew a little girl with this condition several years ago. This drug would have been a lifesaver for her. It should be available now for every child who would benefit from it.16772012-11-15T12:46:45.1271112Anne GordonIt's criminal that people will die for want of cash when people are getting big payoffs, politicians are found guilty of fraud etc etc16772012-11-15T13:37:24.421113Roseann mc SevenyI don't think you can put a price on anyone's life, and with the results every where else , it makes sense to give it to the people who need it, it will pay of in the long run too give it as gov will save money in the long run 16772012-11-15T14:25:30.7131114rita donnerstagplease make this drug available for the children16772012-11-15T14:48:08.7371115Mary MoffatMy husband suffers Rheumatoid Arthritis the pills they give him do not help but no-one listens you are regarded as a moan.16872012-11-15T14:56:23.9871116Frank WalkerI think our Government should get their priorities in order, this is human life we're dealing with not a debate on cutting tax issues!16772012-11-15T15:28:20.581117jean dornanthe goverment should make drug available to the kids xx16772012-11-15T16:10:58.4071118Patrick DonnerstagBe just. Be smart. If rules are in the way, rethink the rules to see if a greater good can be achieved - if so, act on it. Doing the right thing, will always benefit all of us in the long run. 16772012-11-15T16:26:01.3771119IanAn effective drug should not be kept from any patients due to cost. If the drug has already been used and proven to work in other countries then the drug should be made available to those who need it in Scotland ASAP.16772012-11-15T16:40:09.691120Laura McGuiganThere should be no money issues when theres life's at stake!16772012-11-15T16:46:46.2071121thomas mccartneyhave a young cousin who suffers from cystic fibrosis and i can say that these drugs would benefit him regardless of the cost, just typical government not willing to help him and others you ought to be ashamed that while you lot are dragging your heels poor innocent children aswell as adults are losing thier fight to live shame on you16772012-11-15T18:10:30.441122Stephen Dayplease make this drug available for the children. This should not be a money issue at all then it's about children 16772012-11-15T19:57:36.4231123Kirstin sharp Money should not prohibit 16772012-11-15T20:02:37.0171124Richard QuinnScots are historically supreme, and they elect their leader. The Court should derive it's power from the people. People are accountable to the Court, so the Court should be accountable to the people. It is only fair.15972012-11-15T20:17:55.0031125Rev. Robert A. Brown,osfsRequest the Parliament of Scotland expedite funding for the treatment of Cystic Fibrosis.16772012-11-15T20:55:55.5171126Danielle CassidyThis is a life saving drug need to help my little cousin evie 16772012-11-15T23:04:09.8171127Linda LumsdenBecause Fibromyalgia has lowered my intolerance to additives and chemicals, I cannot take painkillers or anti-depressants. My Rheumatologist says there is nothing much he can do for me now,16872012-11-16T00:08:08.5971128catherine smythplease start to recognise fibromyalgia as a debilitating illness and provide the support and research needed to assist sufferers.\r\n16872012-11-16T00:58:47.2831129James downesLook after your people as they are the people who voted you in,people before profit, find the fund for this life changing drug,long term it will be cheaper as a lot of other meds may not be required as frequently if at all16772012-11-16T07:48:18.9771130Sally Mc CaffertyPlease make the additional funding available now! Consider the joy you would bring to so many families.Don't leave it too late for some!!!!!!!116772012-11-16T09:17:55.8071131nicola jeffreyWe need this now!!16772012-11-16T11:07:48.0671132Sandra MillerGive the kids a chance and allow them this life saving drug16772012-11-16T12:44:03.511133Charlene MeechanPeople need this drug, it will save lives ! 16772012-11-16T12:58:19.6771134BryanGet a move on!16772012-11-16T14:43:52.631135Victoria BlakeMedical staff are given little training in chronic pain illnesses and very often don't understand the person's condition and needs leading to unnecessary suffering. Greater awareness, knowledge and support of chronic pain sufferers would make a huge difference.16872012-11-16T14:54:04.0131136Alan SinclairFor life saving medication like this, its disgraceful that red tape and bureaucracy is allowed to delay its availability to those that direly need it16772012-11-16T17:23:14.0031137Patricia HutchisonIt is a disgrace that more people can't be given the new drugs which could save or make their lives better because of money.\r\n16772012-11-16T17:59:41.6471138Geraldine E. GordonMy granddaughter Kate has cystic fibrosis. Her mother and father spend their working lives as emergency doctors saving lives and dedicating themselves to the NHS.Please make this life saving drug available for their little child, age 7.\r\n16772012-11-16T20:12:16.5731139Elaine RuddyAs a cystic fibrosis carrier who has a relative with cystic fibrosis I welcome this petition.16772012-11-16T21:19:25.1871140Lydia MirrleesPlease16772012-11-16T22:31:22.6331141Alison FisherPlease bring in legislation that NHS does more to help people with Chronic Pain and more research .16872012-11-16T23:13:59.5731142Mhairi ReynoldsGP's have little or no resources to help us FM ME CFS sufferers. Most they can do is hand out pills, which is not ideal. More funding to help us here in Scotland16872012-11-17T07:55:17.4471143Venus SavageI have suffered from hyperemesis every day from week 5 through delivery, of 2 pregnancies. My mother also suffered from it through multiple miscarriages and 2 successful pregnancies. It's extremely important for pregnant women to get proper diagnosis, medical care, and emotional support. 16412012-11-17T10:43:41.371144Maureen LaverThey can send men to the moon, which cost billions. How much more important to save the life of our wonderful children who are hear on earth suffering. We want this medication now. It's not too much to ask. 16772012-11-17T11:13:06.0971145Gerry CarrollC'mon16772012-11-17T11:26:10.4231146Frances StewartPlease start to recognise fibromyalgia as the debilitating and disabling condition that it is. It has been scientifically proven to be REAL!16872012-11-17T12:41:18.4531147Joanne KennedyWee Evie needs this please help her!!16772012-11-17T13:31:51.221149Kathleen KellyIt's unbelievable that it takes an online petition to highlight this issue. Hope it gets resolved sooner rather than later.16772012-11-17T13:56:14.3131150Hazel McNabFingers crossed this is passed. I'm signing on behalf of Maryanne. What a woman she's an inspiration and her daughter is a wee star. Xx16772012-11-17T13:58:19.0971151Katie BrownSuch a worthy cause for such a dreadful disease16772012-11-17T14:21:30.231152Paul GrayA total disgrace this drug is widely available in the US and parts of Europe but people in Scotland need to raise a petition to save lives. Something seriously wrong with that. Hang your heads in shame.16772012-11-17T17:20:18.7631153Sophie brownHurry up & give these people the chance to live..people are dying waiting for this wonder drug !!!!16772012-11-17T17:28:08.331154Irene Grantscotland need this LIFE saving drug, our loved ones need this LIFE saving drug, 16772012-11-17T17:41:11.191155Chris BondI would love for all sufferers of CF to be cured and be able to live a normal life. They deserve this treatment.16772012-11-17T19:45:14.1831157Anonymous!Come on Scottish and UK Government stop sitting a drinking tea and chomping on biscuits and start taking action to get the drug available to the NHS. "Its a human right to live as an equal like everyone and more important for children to be able to enjoy their childhood.16772012-11-17T20:11:53.8431158maureen mcilwrathwe desperately need it in australia to\r\n16772012-11-18T12:22:48.7071162Ian McDonaldI think money should not be a problem for anyone in Scotland or the UK but in Scotland we are talking about our future,maybe our future government,we must show the world out of this postcode lottery and put our children and our country forward and not backward,and money no excuse.16772012-11-18T12:44:37.6431163isabella quinnif it will save lifes whats stopping u from doing the right thing and making it widely available 16772012-11-18T16:28:54.131164lauraIts discusting how the government can pay for criminals to be hidden but can't help innocent sick children with this treatment!16772012-11-18T16:38:03.0531165Craig WalesWe should be at the forefront of appropriate drug use here in Scotland. This is an example where we can lead the way in targetted therapies. The savings made in hospital admissions and ancillary treatments will be massive.\r\nDo the right thing.16772012-11-18T17:17:38.6831166marie hunterThere should no price on saving lives.16772012-11-18T18:30:28.5731167bernadette poveythis drug needs to be given now,children and young adults are dying,whats wrong with you people.16772012-11-18T18:51:05.0271168d fraserThis is needed now! We shouldn't need to fight for a life saving drug! My daughter who is 21 months old has cf she has been admitted to hospital twice I've seen her go through so much in her short life and although she doesn't have the g551d gene many other mothers fathers and children are going through the same and will benefit from this! Have a heart and save their life16772012-11-18T19:31:03.81169bigyinGet the finger out its tried and tested stop wwasting time and lives 16772012-11-18T19:36:08.041170Alison CrerarI am sure that fibromyalgia will eventually be found to have a real biochemical cause. Please fund research to discover what causes this condition and in the meantime offer sufferers the very best help in managing to live with it.16872012-11-18T19:47:26.6931171Hayley Scott Give the people who need it this new drug. 16772012-11-18T20:34:09.8631172Paula jenkinsPeople need this drug16772012-11-18T20:42:15.1931173Jenny HazelThank you, thank you, thank you! I had my daughter nearly 8 years ago after having severe HG. I was constantly being told that the sickness would stop, or it was all in my head and even accused of being a heroin addict by one pharmacist (despite all blood results being clear). There is a huge amount of ignorance surrounding this illness and I applaud you for trying to make a difference. Here's hoping it works.16412012-11-18T21:27:55.9271174Catriona Please approve asap16772012-11-18T21:39:31.7471175Gayle LawtonIn this day and age it is ridiculous that we are still offering antiquated treatment t people with this horrendous condition when in the states and other European countries they are on a drug as good as a cure. Get with the program uk, lets save lives and stop dawdling when the answer to give kalydeco is a no brainer. Time isn't money in this case it is life. 16772012-11-18T22:23:40.5671176David GreerDo Something positive with your position as MSP's16772012-11-18T22:37:41.8171177James McDonaldThis will save people get a shift on with the red tape.16772012-11-18T22:55:08.3131178Nicky Beatonif they can fund methadone then they can afford to fund this desperately needed BENEFICIAL drug !!!!16772012-11-18T23:37:14.571179Lesley allison Signed16772012-11-19T00:33:00.2171180L CrosbyI have fibromyalgia.... ask anyone with fibro the effects of stress and aggro? WELL the stress and aggro I have suffered which ultimately resulted in chronic pain and fatigue FIGHTING to be recognised as a sufferer, my mental health has suffered ! Its time the ignorant were educated of and by ignorant I mean the so called health professionals who continue to deny our conditions exist 16872012-11-19T01:36:00.7731181Gregory S Wilsonplease keep up the progress16872012-11-19T01:53:45.9371182Beatriz Robles It is very important that advanced economies take further steps into giving chronic pain syndromes or diseases an important attention for patients within their healthcare systems. These actions do matter to other countries (like Mexico), as healthcare systems have tendencies to standardize following leading countries steps. 16872012-11-19T04:46:08.131183Beatriz roblesI can't believe there is no meds that can help me to kill my pain. I wish not to live anymore. This pain is hard to believe.16872012-11-19T08:29:18.9271184Helen BrownThis is needed urgently.16872012-11-19T09:38:13.2931185jillian kerrgoodluck in ur work x16772012-11-19T10:24:07.4831186kellie ann grayif this work,s y are,nt you giving it to them stop and do it\r\n16772012-11-19T10:36:22.571187Charles GibsonBillions are spent on weapons, spend money on health instead!16772012-11-19T10:40:37.5071188ANNE MCKERR GET A MOVE ON DISGRACEFUL \r\n16772012-11-19T11:41:19.631189Iain leeIt makes me so angry that cost should come before human life,a world full of greed with all the priorities wrong.Please get it right.16772012-11-19T12:17:53.5871190Keira ProctorScotland needs this.16772012-11-19T14:09:02.0371191michelle balfourIts a disgrace that this is available in America but not available to cf sufferers in scotland. Our government should be ashamed of themselves. While priminister and polotitians sit on their big fat pay checks, claiming thousands of pounds in exspences and giving themselves 40 grand wage rises their are ppl dying not only of cf. Makes me ashamed to say I am scottish sometimes. Put the priminister and poloticians on minimum wage and I bet we could find the funds for this drug.16772012-11-19T15:56:01.711192Brendan CoganCF patients can spend weeks, turning into months in hospital at a time, taking up bed space, testing facilities, doctor and nurse time and so much more. The cost of this drug will be offset by all of those factors and many more I've missed.16772012-11-19T16:37:00.1471193Annabeth RobbI suggest that people who fail to turn up for an appointment without phoning to cancel or providing a good reason be subject to a fine--this would release plenty of funds to be used for pain management. Also, small trial amounts of prescriptions could be issued to reduce the amount of drugs returned unused. The NHS could do with some sensible business audits. I've met too many people whose chronic pain is very badly managed!16872012-11-19T16:45:12.7931194Mary MacfarlaneUniversity Hospital North Durham Chronic Pain Services is making use of NIHP integrating Bowen Technique as core treatment for pain. Scotland could lead on this.16872012-11-19T17:19:09.9771195carl hardinHealth should ALWAYS come BEFORE cost\r\nespecially for the very young!16772012-11-19T18:54:39.681196Denise GillespieI think it's a disgrace that any medication that could help or even cure any illness should be available to every one regardless of where they live\r\n16772012-11-19T20:38:27.1631197Bill LowrieI am painfully aware of the failings in provision, having watched my daughter suffer with limited access to medical help and physiotherapy.16872012-11-20T15:55:16.9131198MairiAfter suffering horrendously throughout my pregnancy and having no support other than being told its 'one of those things' I believe its incredibly important that support be available for sufferers - I lost my job and felt like I was on the verge of a nervous breakdown, I have decided against further children because I can't bear the idea of going through this condition again with no medical support or recognition of what is a severely debilitating condition.16412012-11-20T16:19:38.8331199Lorraine CaddellThis is a disgrace to with hold access16772012-11-20T17:15:02.6771200Lorraine MacKinnonI know all about this as had this with all four of my pregnancies - would have welcomed some support.16412012-11-20T20:28:40.7631201Carol WallaceHaving suffered from hyperemisis in my first pregnancy it took me 7 years to even consider falling pregnant again. I was then 10 times worse with my 2nd pregnancy! At my worst I was being sick every 30 minutes 24 hours a day. It is a horrendous condition that really makes - what should be a happy time - memorable for all the wrong reasons.16412012-11-20T20:40:29.6471202Marie malleyFor my friends 2 grandchildren. x 16772012-11-20T21:24:28.6471203John Lazzari Disgraceful! You can't put a cost on a life!16772012-11-20T21:36:14.9431204Mrs j steelI am very much aware of the little access there is to medical and physiotherapy overall in scotland. I have however been on a pain management course which did bring some awareness to my problems but i agree the travelling to these hospitals can add to the stress we as sufferers already deal with.16872012-11-20T21:44:21.9371205Roberta McDougallThis must start to be prescribed here in Scotland as routine so as to save millions on endless treatment for patients with Cystic Fibrosis and to end this terrible suffering.16772012-11-20T21:59:11.631206Helen superKalydeco is available where I live in the midlands. Why not available everywhere -we all live under the same elected government and pay same rate of taxes - do we not !!!!!!16772012-11-20T22:02:29.7631207Patricia MannWhat not available to everyone in UK. Should not depend on where you live!!!!!,!16772012-11-20T22:12:59.4271208Shree McKeeverAs above16772012-11-20T22:16:45.4371209Greig AddisonThis needs your support!16872012-11-21T05:12:43.271210ROBINA M HADDOWWE NEED MORE RESEARCH AND FOR BENEFITS TO ACCPET THAT THIS IS REAL.WITH THE LACK OF PAIN CONSULTANTS WE SUFFER NEEDLESS LAY. AS WE NEVER KNOW FOR DAY TO DAY HOW WE WILL BE FI WE GET ANY SLEEP WITH THE PAIN. IF WE HAVE SOME SLEEP THEN WE FEEL THE PAIN FAR MORE. 16872012-11-21T06:54:57.7971211Kevin ScaridifeldWorldwide Awareness Campaign\r\nYoutube The RSD Fighters Anthem16872012-11-21T08:25:481212jERRY tAYLORTHE VERY BEST OF LUCK WITH THIS.16772012-11-21T09:49:09.1631213Ann RossFunding must be provided to stop this level of suffering. Money is no object where health is concerned.16772012-11-21T10:40:26.5931214Theresa HendryGood luck16772012-11-21T10:42:12.1931215louise durkin we are loosing cf people, children far to young this needs to STOP full stop. Its so hard to belive they they can let people and children suffer this terrible disease and out there is a tablet to help them have a better quality off life. what really gets me is the people out there are funding every day TO HELP FUND cf chairty to find cures, and when they find some kind of cure we have to fight to get it. what kind off world are we living in....with out these people doing all these charities the research would not be as good as it is so why not share to all that need this drug, this is why people do the charities to help find a cure for these cf people to make there lifes more comfortable not to make your pokets fat its a disgrace.16772012-11-21T11:03:46.421217Karen Prenticegood luck xx16772012-11-21T11:44:50.211218Jennifer watsonMy son has cf and I hope this drug will let him live a longer life. He is just turning 7 16772012-11-21T12:43:21.7231220Ron ScrimgeourThis serious condition needs urgent attention and specialist health care workers in every community is the best way forward.16412012-11-21T14:28:21.5531221Duncan Biddulphi agree strongly with all that is said.\r\n16562012-11-21T15:21:06.081222Claire DaviesGood luck with this.x16772012-11-21T16:04:46.4471223Emma RolfeThis is too late for my son who died 17 years ago today. Gone but not forgotten x x 16772012-11-21T17:04:55.6771224Lauri kearneyHope it gets the funding thats needed!16772012-11-21T17:21:33.141225Salvador Gonzalez Martini wish you get all the objective . Good lucky :)\r\n16772012-11-21T17:43:11.4071226Nieves Maria MarquezEn una causa justa como es la salud de una persona no se puede ni por un momento dudar de que hay que ayudar . Esperamos que los politicos que legislan sean conscientes de que la vida de las personas son lo primero.Fuerza y un fuerte abrazo.16772012-11-21T17:55:21.7671227Jacqueline KerrBest wishes to all driving this campaign.16772012-11-21T21:19:44.1431228Deanna CameronPlease find a cure for this terrible disease16772012-11-21T22:21:12.9871229nikkiPlease get the funding for this please16772012-11-21T22:40:07.6931230John ThirdJames Mackie's description of the current situation at Kingston Beach is a very accurate description. It is time someone took some action as the warning signs ave been there for too long.16562012-11-21T23:25:15.3071231Clint BarkerSafeguard this heritage NOW16562012-11-22T00:08:42.291232Michael Colin MulgrewReally wish good luck on this one guys!x16772012-11-22T00:35:48.821233Jimmy GrantHope the goverment take heed and listen 16772012-11-22T09:48:19.521234Esther GrantAs always Scotland are last in the queue ! Hope the Government act quickly on this and give the funding so desperately required.\r\nGood luck 16772012-11-22T10:28:54.4271236Tiffany Xxxxxx 16772012-11-22T12:21:26.1131237Liz AllumSigned and also shared on my Facebook page x16772012-11-22T14:46:47.911238LauraThink this is fab cf is not a well known thing so please sign x16772012-11-22T14:59:52.2771239Judith FolkesTackling health problems at an early stage is the most cost efficient and human efficient we can be. Too many times we see reactive treatment far too late. Better outcomes for pregnant women, their babies and their families are the way forward and the business case is plain to see.16412012-11-22T15:18:47.0831240Rita williamsIt seems obvious that these people living this\r\nclose to disaster need urgent help from the Govt.16562012-11-22T17:38:37.71241Kyle saltI have cf and live in england would we be Able get it do u know? 16772012-11-22T18:18:20.7131242rab alexanderNot before time, but what about the freemasons.15972012-11-22T18:46:13.511243Sarah Englishhope this helps x 16772012-11-23T01:39:39.2971244Christina UsherI have suffered from Hyperemesis Gravidarum during all three of my pregnancies. It is such a debilitating condition, and one that needs more care and attention brought to it. HIckman and PICC lines while curled up in the hospital or on the bathroom floor is no way to spend "the most wonderful and joyous time of your life". 16412012-11-23T08:24:06.6371245julie hamrrXxx16772012-11-23T08:33:48.071246Anne McInnesGood luck Natalie.16412012-11-23T10:01:17.5571247ElaineIt is heartbreaking for people living with C. I have seen this first hand. Young bright people whose light is extinguished far too soon. give them a chance to live a long and happy life, to study and become all they can be. 16772012-11-23T10:27:23.8131248David FennesseyNobody should have to suffer pain or the risk of damaging their organs when there is a drug avilable that could ease their symptoms and give them the chance of a better life16772012-11-23T10:35:09.0071249NICOLA MCMURTRIEXXXXXXXXX16772012-11-23T10:54:00.2231251Emily BishopA good friend suffered from this in England, and was able to access support and treatment in a timely manner, that allowed her some relief. I can only imagine what it must be like if there is no support available. national health service means NATIONAL and this includes Scotland! Good luck.16412012-11-23T11:22:48.1371252veronica PandeyIts definitely for a good cause16412012-11-23T11:24:12.7631253Fiona Whytepleas end this unfair discrimination against people who's lives are difficult enough already16772012-11-23T11:46:12.8371254Moira PriestleyReally hope this helps and you can get this treatment asap x16772012-11-23T15:47:35.7271255Micheal sharkey Donegal Ireland 16772012-11-23T16:01:50.091256patricia breengood luck with this petition.16772012-11-23T16:11:39.521257Madgie GildeaGood luck hope this works16772012-11-23T16:32:01.0071258Pauline Forde (Forker)God i hope this drug becomes available for everyone that needs it! Good luck with the petition.xxx16772012-11-23T16:53:421259rajeshHope new drug will help to cure Cystic Fibrosis.16772012-11-23T17:02:21.1531260Mandar Kinalekarhope this helps.16772012-11-23T18:18:47.0171261mary fosterhope this comes through as soon as possible16772012-11-23T19:42:10.5731262Geraldine bryceMy niece suffers from the condition n would love for her to get proper treatment if not a cure x16772012-11-23T20:13:43.5171263Donna IrvineI suffered from HG. When i was in hospital, no one had a clue what i was going through! I was so lonely and i felt isolated because of this comdition. No one understood. Not even the Doctor's or midwife's! I was just a burden to them. I just hope that people stand up and take note that this is a serious condition, That left untreated may have fatal consquences. 16412012-11-23T21:37:06.2431264Walter CameronSign this ppl :)16772012-11-23T21:53:22.3631265Janice Cameron My son was diagnosed when 2 let's please help find a cure xxx16772012-11-23T22:16:33.61266Tracy BrownGood luck16772012-11-23T22:32:15.1671267susan hobbshope this helps16772012-11-23T23:16:13.141268anne thomsongood luck I hope you are successful\r\n16772012-11-24T16:57:05.4631269Jandia Martinez PastranaNever heard of this illness before. Thank you for your effort on making women aware of it and also for your innitiative to support and improve health care for them. I will read more about this illness. 16412012-11-24T19:20:30.061270Jeannie ButcherIf only they would make this drug available it would save heartbreak for thousands of families and save money because there would be less hospital admissions of Cystic Fibrosis patients\r\n16772012-11-24T20:53:40.6771271Amanda WrightGood luck with this :) xx16772012-11-24T21:17:51.9331272Caroline ChristieGood Luck xx16772012-11-24T21:48:06.151274c caldwellSadly this has come too late for my son who died, aged 22, from cystic fibrosis a year and a half ago. I hope that this drug will be available for all the young people suffering from this horrible illness. 16772012-11-25T11:08:47.9571275Suzie MurphyProperly diagnosing and treating Hg will be beneficial for both mothers and babies, decreasing risk of miscarriage, pulmonary embolism, deep vein thrombosis, liver and renal failure, and permanent damage to both mother and baby in terms of GI issues and intrauterine growth retardation. Also, proper treatment for Hg will decrease the number of women who are tempted to seek abortion because they are so gravely ill and can not stop vomiting. Left untreated, Hg can result in serious metabolic imbalances can actually cause Wernicke's Encephalopathy due to a thiamine deficiency in the brain. Also, women who suffer from Hg can develop post-traumatic stress disorder and they often continue to need emotional and physical help for medical and emotional issues following the pregnancy. Scotland should be proud of offering the most current and best treatment available to one of its most vulnerable populations: the expectant mother and her unborn child.16412012-11-25T22:28:28.4871276Laura McCarthyReally hope this helps16772012-11-26T00:11:27.9971277Joanne browneHope everyone gets involved!!16772012-11-26T07:53:54.241278Pamela Kerr & Allan Yule Our son (our sunshine) has CF and we know first hand how debilitating this disease can be. Has the government considered the existing cost that a patient with CF already has on the NHS. Perhaps in that respect this drug would not be such financial drain after all! x16772012-11-26T11:44:01.4671279Laura Herron Praying this helps x :)16772012-11-26T12:51:45.2071280bernadettei cannot believe that we have to sign petitions for this drug its a disgrace that it's not been made available to cf sufferers.16772012-11-26T13:40:13.071281Avril Mckechnie-HuntHoping that this petition works!! This drug needs to be available for all in need!!!16772012-11-26T13:40:17.071282mrs lorna wilsonAn utter disgrace that money comes before lives.16772012-11-26T14:07:52.261283estella stewarti have copied Donna Irvine comment as it was exactly my own experience in the r.i.e edinburgh.\r\n\r\ni suffered from HG. When i was in hospital, no one had a clue what i was going through! I was so lonely and i felt isolated because of this comdition. No one understood. Not even the Doctor's or midwife's! I was just a burden to them. I just hope that people stand up and take note that this is a serious condition, That left untreated may have fatal consquences.\r\n\r\n16412012-11-26T15:15:30.9471284Kimberley Wilkie This should be readily available for all suffers! 16772012-11-26T15:21:06.3671285Elizann O'KaneWhy not use all the money set aside for the METHADONE Programme !! there would be no problem with cost then !!16772012-11-26T15:36:45.731286Lauren McClellandDrug companies have a lot to answer for. Sure, they discovered something amazingly beneficial, but then they mark-up the cost to such high levels that no one can really afford it. The scientists work to save lives, while the board members and shareholders rake in the cash. Not cool. That's why CF sufferers can't get access to the drug here.16772012-11-26T15:45:11.131287Elizabeth McKelvieMy family in Canada are fighting for this drug for my 3 year old Grand nephew. and I know that this could make his life so much better Good luck16772012-11-26T17:05:12.4271288Paul lees This should be available bad news ! 16772012-11-26T17:29:08.1931289Siobhan McBrideA treatment like this should be available no matter the cost! 16772012-11-26T18:03:56.5431291Gina MillsThis should be available!16772012-11-26T21:23:26.461292Elaine hendersonLets get involved!16772012-11-27T01:49:55.31294Aliza PerlmanI have a friend who suffers from this disorder and I know how difficult it has been for her, both physically and emotionally. As a pregnant woman I know that pregnancy is already a stressful time, but it should be an overall positive experience. I know that any support in terms of medical knowledge and emotional support would help to ease the trauma of this experience for those who are suffering. So little is being asked. Can you not find a way to help? 16412012-11-27T06:40:58.9331295gary burgessStop messing with peoples lifes and put health before profits.16772012-11-27T06:45:28.5631296Lisa quigley Make the drug avaliable16772012-11-27T09:21:12.8931297Eleanor Connellyif we can afford to Send £100 million pounds to Africa and find the money for the Methedone Programme surely we can save the lives of CF people who are suffering in Scotland these people did not choose this way of life help them!!!16772012-11-27T09:30:18.2131298Brian ConnellyThis drug is a life saver now can the NHS pay out millions for hospital blunders but cant fund medicine to save lives 16772012-11-27T10:18:27.6771299Alicia McDougallThis drug is vital for CF sufferers costs should not come before lives16772012-11-27T12:06:36.5431301Tom BerneyApparently the drug cost £180,000 pa per patient in the USA but as it is only useful for a limited number of patients I'm sure the NHS shoud make it available. However it's hard to have respect for drug companies that charge that much for a cure.16772012-11-27T12:16:54.1731302Fiorella NashWhen I became severely dehydrated with HG a smirking GP gave me a telling off for 'purposefully' dehydrating myself (!!) and told me to 'nibble dry crackers' and keep drinking even if I was vomiting uncontrollably as 'some of it would be absorbed'. It was one of the most horrific and frightening experiences of my life, I wouldn't wish HG on my worst enemy. Well done for drawing attention to this condition. Hopefully the medical profession will start to take it seriously and women will get the help they need. 16412012-11-27T12:41:11.5531303Allison SavilleThis treatment should be available for all CFRs16772012-11-27T16:13:58.8231305Liz Farquharsurely young lives are more important than bankers bonuses, profit margins, expenses claims, BBC CEO,s annual salaries-getting my drift???16772012-11-27T16:18:49.2931306lesley martinLet these people who suffer this horrible illness breathe normal again,x16772012-11-27T18:13:02.7431307Nurunnisha VersiMy niece has 2 kids and is pregnant with her third and she had hyperemesis in the first two kids too but did not know of it. This time she was lucky to be treated at a clinic where they were aware of it and it made a big difference to her life. The nurses and doctors who help her are very understanding and compassionate and do not feel that she is just faking it for attention. I agree that every hospital should have nurses and doctors who are trained to recognize and treat this.16412012-11-27T22:14:51.6671309Matt BuckmanPlease sign !16772012-11-27T22:36:44.8871310Sharon SneddonThis treatment is essential for some people with this illness. Please make it available to those who need it immediately. 16772012-11-27T22:38:22.6231311Thomas BlackCome on Everyone Sign This 16772012-11-27T22:42:36.191312trish smithmy dear nephew died in march of this year,unfortunatly he was too ill to have undergone any transplant surgery. please therefore give the people of scotland the oppertunity to try this new drug and go on to save many young lives,and to give hope too many people and many families who have been born with this gene and let the drug show. the results to all the individuels who at this present time are suffering from cf in loving memory of our dearest jamsie boy x 16772012-11-27T22:55:39.7331313trisha jukessupport16772012-11-28T03:06:19.1431314Susan KellyThese young people deserve the improved quality of life that this drug can offer.16772012-11-28T09:40:46.331315Lisa HendersonNo cost can be put on peoples lives16772012-11-28T14:19:00.4071317Anne McIntyreany drug that is going to improve quality of life should be available to all not a postcode lottery 16772012-11-28T15:48:25.761318Cristina LamasThere is not money to pay, the beutifull life of a Childs health........16772012-11-28T16:08:55.4131319Sylvia ReidCF is a heartbreaking disease. The cost of the new drug must be set against the continuing cost of current treatment and the improved quality of life of patients. 16772012-11-28T21:28:21.081320Susan McIntoshThis campaign has to have a positive outcome please get as many people to sign the petition as possible.16772012-11-29T09:11:15.261321Lorna ProudfootPlease allow the use of this new drug to people who can benefit now. Transplants and hospitalisation later are not only cruel but unnecessary.16772012-11-29T09:32:25.0571322MargaretMcKnightTwo of my granchildren are affected by this disease. Any breakthrough in treatment should be explored to benefit as many as possible.16772012-11-29T19:28:54.841323lansana f banguraCoastal Erosion for those of us that are so close to the coast is a very important subject and this petition speaks for all of us and there is no doubt that this petition has highlighted all that is required to be know so that those who have the power to protect our coastline to take the necessary action before it is too late. SO PLEASE DO. 16562012-11-29T23:23:31.291324Heather MirandaHyperemesis was without doubt the darkest time of my life. I suffered beyond description both physically and mentally. It was made impossibly worse by the fact that nobody properly understood hyperemesis or how to deal with it... certainly not the the general public, but very upsettingly not even midwives, nurses or doctors. All the medical professionals kept telling me... you will feel great at week 12, 14, 16, etc... I NEVER did. They all had differing opinions on what medication I was or wasn't allowed. The professionals would just tell me to just get on with it, even to 'cheer up'... how this is even close to possible when either being on the verge of, or actually, throwing up 24-7 for MONTHS on end with NO relief, not even for a minute, is beyond me!!! I was left feeling very alone, having to research the illness online and reading various sources of information, but with noone in the 'real world' to reach out to for any proper medical or emotional support. Since going through HG, I have now emotionally supported countless of others going through it. Many of these desperately ill women have heartbreakingly lost their babies to this illness, either for HG medically related reasons, or via very much unwanted abortions. Some healthcare professionals have suggested abortion to end HG! Many women have also had their own health put in serious jeopardy as a result of shockingly poor medical treatment. Things NEED to change. Desperately. PLEASE Scotland, improve the healthcare for these desperately ill women. At what SHOULD've been such a happy time for me, it left me with nothing but feelings of isolation and despair. Action being taken from this petition would determine for MANY women whether or not they could ever face going through pregnancy again. Upsettingly, my son is an only child due to hyperemesis... PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE improve the health care for HG sufferers...16412012-11-30T10:42:39.21325Shirley MacIntoshI am a friend of a family who has more than 1 member with the condition and their Mother has done everything within her power to give her children a healthy lifestyle. Any breakthrough in treatment should be available for ALL.16772012-11-30T11:24:02.921326Anne B. CareyThis drug is essential for cystic fibrosis sufferers. It would make an life-saving difference.We could lose families to America if we don't introduce it in Scotland! Please listen to these petitions! 16772012-11-30T16:49:18.4031327Alisha Good luck16412012-11-30T19:01:33.591328Natalie hunterMy little boy has cystic fibrosis only starting his fight as he only 22 months I really hope the drug comes available to make him have a better life that he deserves x 16772012-11-30T19:27:30.761329vivienne hunterI have an 22 month old grandson who has cf never new what it was till i attended cf trust open night so with support and raising fun for the butterfly trust more people with cf can have a normal live as possible16772012-11-30T21:57:18.121330David Watson RAF Veteran RetdPlease allow the use of this new drug to people who can benefit NOW. \r\nSupported by RAFA Edinburgh Lothian & Borders Lanark Veterans Branch.16772012-12-01T19:42:02.3171331wendy kellythose imposing the post code rules, re- help for people suffering with chronic pain, do not face the same problems themselves, they have little empathy for people in pain, these decision makers, need to be made to walk in the shoes of the victims of post code lottery medical help .16872012-12-01T21:27:12.681332Holly Scullionhyperemesis specialist nurses needed in all hospitals. I suffer and find it hard without any specialist or much needed support16412012-12-01T21:47:51.4231333nicola rossi suffered from this horrible illness with my two pregnancies,my youngest is now 12 and my body still hasnt fully recovered,i was also advised to have no more children,which was such a shame...16412012-12-01T21:50:43.121334Susan MacdonaldAs a fibromyalgia sufferer who is struggling to keep working full time I feel completely abandoned by the medical profession. No-one seems interested in helping me manage my symptoms or helping me keep working. I was simply told because i don't have rheumatoid arthritis there is nothing anyone can do for me!16872012-12-01T22:31:34.4831335Stacie I've had hyperemesis 3 times and this last time was the worst. Luckily I received treatment early on or it could've been much worse. Early treatment is KEY. It is so important for a woman with hg to have a caring, understanding and educated healthcare provider. Hopefully these women will get a provider who has these qualities.16412012-12-01T23:12:50.5931336Angie LattoI was told to consider abortion and put in a ward full off mothers that had already had their baby's , there was no one to talk to and I was made feel like a hypercondryact x not fare :-(16412012-12-02T16:40:17.4431337Oli RaynerKalydeco works, it is easy to make and it will transform lives. Each day that passes means more jeopardy for many very poorly children. There is no excuse for delay. 16772012-12-02T17:42:19.761338Lisa IngramAs a sufferer of HG myself I know how scary this condition can be, especially as it is so widely not recognised. I have ended up not being able to work or care for my son on my own as some days I can't even get out of bed. This condition being diagnosed and recognised after having to be admitted to hospital for rehydration was such a relief it brought me to tears. There needs to be more support for women suffering this tremendously debilitating condition.16412012-12-02T20:30:31.6031339Marina McCuaigThis is so important for anyone with CF , where you live shouldn't come into it....please please make this available to ALL that will benefit xXx 16772012-12-03T00:05:54.5371340Alyson DunlopI find it astounding that there is still no involvement of hypnotherapists in chronic pain treatment. I have used hypnosis on clients for pain control, and it has worked better (and is more long-lasting) that heavy duty painkillers such as co-codamol. Why on earth is this not being promoted as a possible form of treatment. It would save the NHS so much money, and give much needed employment to hypnotherapists.16872012-12-03T10:09:31.1871341Morag GrantPlease ensure this is available NOW for all who can benefit16772012-12-03T10:56:23.391342Victoria A GrieveSomething that is very much needed in the NHS. 16412012-12-03T11:32:01.751343sheona erskinei think it is important that any person with CF should be able to get the treastment as it is no fault of their own that they have this condition. drug addicts get veerything16772012-12-03T11:35:48.5031345william erskineit is important that these patients get the new treatment16772012-12-03T14:40:38.2371346Olive HughesNo families of people with life threatening diseases should have to battle like we do to improve the lives of our loved ones16772012-12-03T16:26:47.1371347Melina MacleanI knew a brave girl who died of this disease16772012-12-03T16:39:47.3531348Heather MirandaJust heard that Kate Middleton is currently suffering from this!16412012-12-03T16:45:58.881349K ScottAfter suffering twice with HG I cannot believe some professionals ignorance of this condition. I suffered for 18 weeks with my first child and for most of my second pregnancy. HG was a massive strain both physically and mentally. I had to move house so to he closer to family as for weeks I couldn't get out of bed, care for my daughter and run a home. I had 4 jobs before HG and had to give them all up due to be I'll for so long. Because of this I get no maternity pay therefore Ive had to look for other work and my baby is only 3 months old. If it wasn't for my family I dread to think what would have happened with my daughter as I received no help or support. I was admitted to hospital 6 times and took medication throughout. Mental I don't know how I got through it. Some medical staff were good, some where very unhelpful which made the nightmare of HG so much worse. Please do whatever is necessary to help these women who suffer during pregnancy so they don't suffer for a long time after!16412012-12-03T19:07:16.511350RheIm still going through HG and couldn't feel worse! There needs to be a worldwide change in how it's dealt with. Kate and William appear to be suffering and its the first time I've heard it ever mentioned! Let's hope something is done....16412012-12-03T20:02:25.941351Margaret ConnickPlease sign16772012-12-03T20:20:18.371352Julie WilliamsHG took away my daughter's life for 9 months. She needed constant 24 hour care. Just so glad I was able to be there for her and now have a beautiful giggling grandson of 7months.16412012-12-03T20:32:50.741353nadia allenWould hate being sick all the time through my pregnancies :-(16412012-12-03T20:45:40.2371354lee hendriehappy to help16772012-12-03T21:09:07.771355Roxanne StewartALL pain patients everywhere deserve prompt and proper treatment. We have the capacity to reduce suffering, if not eliminate it, and we have the moral obligation to do so. The unreasonable failure to treat pain is an unethical breech of human rights. As more than one body has declared (WHO, UN, IASP) - pain management is a unquestionable human right!16872012-12-03T22:54:45.9771356alan robertsno one should have to leave their own country to seek treatment and help elswhere16872012-12-03T23:04:08.7331357Stephanie BridgewaterHad hyperemesis gravidarum with both pregnancies. Its nine months of hell, i didnt get any help or understanding, i was left to rot mentally and physically. It was the worse time of my life...bad memories still anger me. Unconcerned doctors and unconcerned midwives, had a mental break down which i still medicate for, often i self harmed to cope with the misery, no body cared apart from my family whom had never seen me so ill and were left perplexed by the lack of support from midwives and doctors. 16412012-12-03T23:09:16.8571358frances rossMy grandaughter has been on this medication foe 5 months and she has gained 15 lbs. and grown 2 inches. Five months ago she could barely walk up the stairs at her home and Saturday she ran a 5Krace in 42 minutes. This medication is truly a miracle drug and everyone with CF should be allowed to have this medication. It has saved her life and I pray all children can get it.\r\n16772012-12-06T09:03:02.991359AlexPain, really is a PAIN.16872012-12-06T09:43:22.611360Barbara RobertsonWe watched my mother die of stomach cancer in a hospice, I cannot imagine the suffering she and others would have had without the excellent care and, particularly pain management, provided in Dunoon, Argyll, where family and friends could also visit easily. To suffer chronic pain and be carted around the UK seems cruel. I am a farmer's daughter. No farmer would inflict this on an animal with impunity. Please make it a priority to provide this service locally to patients. Thank you.16872012-12-06T10:53:01.3431361Andrew Sneddoneven with chronic pain ATOS health say that you are perfectly fit to work and the goverment believes them even with X-Rays and doctors statements. You cannot sign on for jobseekers as the statement requires you to state that you will work for 30 hours per week. so do you have to lie to live?16872012-12-07T06:36:25.831362Mrs Mary CareyPain is a terrible thing to endure, everyone should be entitled to the best pain management available to enable them to cope and try to enjoy their lives. Chronic pain can also lead to mental health which is really not acceptable.16872012-12-08T06:43:55.951363SWMore should be done to help those hundreds of people in the UK suffering from Complex Regional Pain Syndrome...often misdiagnosed there are hundreds of professionals who know nothing about it and therefore don't help those who need support!! So care is a post code lottery! Pain is deemed subjective and therefore the person gets blamed for not being able to cope with it.....I would like to give them pain level 10 for half and hour just to see how they would manage! Education is urgently required! 16872012-12-08T17:45:04.5871364Jackie AndersonI am a chronic pain sufferer who has had the fortune to have met and had a pain consultant in Gartnavel Hospital in Glasgow who has made my life better by working with me to manage my pain.16872012-12-10T14:07:57.581365Michael GrieveMy Wife is a Chronic Pain sufferer more must be done to help these people who have constant pain 16872013-01-22T16:57:34.4771367LOUISE DOWNSShocking decision in light of the economic climate. Moving the goalposts!17172013-01-22T17:13:16.4971368Iain PrenticeSustaining Rateable Values at historically high rates set at a tone of April 2008 will not assist with regenerating and populating High Street's, infact it is likely to hit already struggling retailers hard and have the opposite effect.17172013-01-22T17:29:10.4331369Louise Daly Trying to justify this as promoting certainty for businesses is simply insulting. This decision will in fact be very damaging and result in more business failures and have a further impact on Scotlands already suffering retail sector especially on our High Streets.17172013-01-23T11:28:44.0071370Alistair WoodJust a bit of slight of hand to keep the tax take as high as possible as long as possible. Hitting business like this is seen as more attractive because the general voters won't notice as they might other taxes even if they are actually affected by them through higher prices.17172013-01-23T23:52:56.5231371Mario pacittiSmall businesses need help.times are bad enough we are the back bone of the economy .do we want more high street closures ?i hope that they see sense and stop punishing the small community shops.\r\n17172013-01-25T15:08:12.461372Matthew GriffithsIt is disgraceful that the Scottish Government are proposing to preside over a grossly unfair and inequitable rating assement for commercial property in Scotland. What is fair and equitable about keeping rates bill artificially high. The Business Rates should be a fair and reasonalke tax which assesses the values fairly and correctly. This proposal utterly penalises struggling towns and Cities. Surely this should have been an openly stated policy of penalisation of the poorest perfoirming Cities in Scotland with excessive and unreasonable levels of Business Rates.17172013-01-27T09:01:55.0471373HaigThis is nothing short of a complete rip off. Typical.17172013-01-29T09:53:27.61374Alistair WoodThe whole point is 5 year revaluation is to reflect shifts in rental levels, either up or down and to reflect general changes in incidence across market sectors. Postponement puts unacceptable pressure and burdens on ratepayers where rental levels have dropped since the valuation tone date of the last revaluation. A re-balancing of the roll and "tone" should be carried out in 2015.17172013-02-01T16:24:11.4771375TinaWhole heartedly agree with this petition and what you are trying to accomplish.\r\nI have no doubt that it will be a success.17362013-02-01T16:59:13.8331376Brian McGuireGood luck with this!!17362013-02-01T22:13:25.6931377DonnaI thought the government were elected to help the country and its people. Obviously I was wrong.17302013-02-01T23:05:12.711378Joe WoodsIts disgraceful that evictions are allowed to happen, where has compassion and understanding went to . Lets start using common sense and help those who need it, stop punishing them17302013-02-01T23:15:29.2231379Kevin Hayes Where is Tommy Sheridan when you need him most17302013-02-01T23:16:51.491380Annette DickinsonI to am affected by this bill, so your speaking to the converted, I know all about the country wide shortage of one bedroomed accommodation, and that this is just another vindictive and bullying measure to persecute the poor, by this evil uncaring govt of millionaires.17302013-02-01T23:36:21.091381AnonThis is an absolute disgrace. So landlords with only one property like myself are expected to suffer the debt because of someone's job loss or benefit cut? Disgrace. 17302013-02-02T00:26:21.5831382ross frewI wholeheartedly disagree with the bedroom tax and wish to give support to any people affected by this heinous law.17302013-02-02T09:18:19.2171383Elaine ManAnother ridiculous Tory move :(17302013-02-02T09:24:39.081384jacqui MasonThis should not even be happening, never mind the eviction concern17302013-02-02T09:33:06.8931387Nicola McCartneyI agree.17302013-02-02T09:36:42.591391Dorothy CookThis is appalling. I do not know what ends it is meant to serve apart from suffering and misery. Are the government going to magically have the right roomed houses for the families who are evicted due to inability to pay their increased rent? Or how will families fund the increase? Tightening budgets even more leaving vulnerable families with even less to work with.\r\n17302013-02-02T10:35:40.661392carole fitzgeraldThis policy of eviction needs to be changed. It affects the poorest in society.17302013-02-02T10:37:34.241393SharronAn unfair tax on those who can least afford it....it's a disgrace. 17302013-02-02T10:40:12.0431394JOAN BORLANDGET THIS OUT,OUT,OUT,AND MORE OUT...MUCH AS I HATE SUNNY GOVAN...THEY SHOULD BE PUNTING THIS FOR YOU...I WAS ONCE THEIR 'STAR' PRESENTER...AND ID'V HAD YOU IN REGULARLY TO PROMOTE GETTING SIGNATURES FOR THIS PETITION+DONE A 'JINGLE' TO INFORM +REMIND PEOPLE TOO...I GAVE SUNNY GOVAN 2 QUOTES TO DESCRIBE THEMSELVES:'UNITY IN THE COMMUNITY',AND 'YOUR STATION,YOUR CREATION'...USE THEM...MAKE THEM HELP...IT'S IN THE SMALL PRINT OF THEIR CONSTITUTION AS A REGISTERED CHARITY...USE THEM...THAT'S ACTUALLY WHAT THEY ARE THERE FOR...NOT JUST TO PLAY HIP-HOP...CAN YOU TELL WHY I LEFT?TOO SHALLOW AN OUTFIT FOR ME...BUT THAT WASN'T THEIR REMIT...YOU ARE PROMOTING WAS MEANT TO BE THE NEWS THEY CARRIED TO THEIR COMMUNITY+BEYOND...USE THEM...DON'T TAKE NO FOR AN ANSWER...GOOD LUCK...I HAVE SHARED YOUR INFO...KEEP ME POSTED...CHEERS...\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n17302013-02-02T10:41:36.281395Donna ScottAs a practitioner in the homelessness sector I am appalled at the arbitrary nature of this change in benefit. All of this will lead to vast increases in homelessness and the social cleansing of communities. It is a moral disgrace in a country which prides itself on civic duty to those less fortunate.17302013-02-02T10:43:21.6471396JOAN BORLANDUSE SUNNY GOVAN.MAKE THEM DO THE JOB THEY ARE MEANT TO BE DOING....17302013-02-02T10:54:44.4571397Jill O'SullivanI whole heartedly agree with Mike Dailly on behalf of Govan Law Centre Trust's petition. To evict people under these circumstances is barbaric and will only add to an already serious homelessness issue. 17302013-02-02T10:55:43.281398Robert LivingstoneIn full support of the petition. The next step the government is going to need to make is to open the "poors house"??? I think not!!!!!17302013-02-02T11:29:42.2071399elaine crawfordi think it is shocking having to give up ur home 17302013-02-02T11:37:24.71400Alasdair Whytethey wont be satisfied until we are living in overcrowded squallid condition a la Victorian times17302013-02-02T11:39:54.5431401Margaret GowAn unfair tax from an unfair government...17302013-02-02T11:45:37.0131402caroline dougancan't pay won't pay17302013-02-02T11:52:32.1871405karen oneillits took me years to get my house to the standard it is at and now im being forced out!!!!! 17302013-02-02T11:55:41.311406Rosie KaneA direct attack on the most vulnerable in society which will result in major disruption and trauma devolved powers mean control over housing but not benefits therefore the Westminster government are placing pressure on our alrwady inadequate social housing stock...... please take action against this assault. \r\n 17302013-02-02T12:39:51.3171407Elspeth CrocketThis current Tory government is worse than Thatcher.17302013-02-02T12:48:10.8471408Stephen HyndsThere May be Trouble Ahead......if push come to shove i will drag my housing association through every court in the land because of this bedroom tax....Sort it out Alex....you want to win our votes for independence....then lets hear what you have to say on this travesty of justice.17302013-02-02T12:49:44.171409patrick marley to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.17302013-02-02T12:54:57.1531410Pamela Mitchellthis is an especially aggressive attack on the vulnerable who's homes are being targeted by a UK government that seems to have no conscience and no interest in anything other than lining the pockets of the rich. It is the biggest social injustice since the Poll Tax of the 80's and is entirely unjustified given that the tax payers within this group of people are already being used to bail out banks, pay bonuses to the failures of these bankers and others and are the victims of the cruelest cuts to their pensions and wages whilst food and petrol prices continue to soar. The Scottish Government MUST NOT Allow this tax to be imposed on the Scottish people. 17302013-02-02T12:59:33.5771411Fiona ForbesI would hope that all local authorities would develop policies and support that will assist tenants. I could suggest a few.\r\nAlso, my hobby horses:\r\nCall it Landlord Benefit\r\nSET REASONABLE RENT LEVELS IN PRIVATE SECTOR (eg mortgage over 50 years level)\r\nSET UP CREDIT UNIONS SO THEY COULD LEND FOR LOW COST MORTGAGES\r\nLEASE COUNCIL OWNED LAND FOR HOUSE BUILDING(ask me for the conditions to make it practical)\r\n17302013-02-02T16:19:16.821412Lynsey Sarah BellI only get £99 a fortnight this is meant to pay bills and food how do the government expect people on low income to be able to live...17302013-02-02T16:20:02.7771413ANN MOOREJUST ANOTHER R,I,P OFF17302013-02-02T16:20:02.7771414Marie McWatersStop this now or it will be too little, too late for the most vulnerable of Scotlands citizens.17302013-02-02T16:35:19.0871416Gavin MitchellI cannot believe nor support such an unjust law,affecting some of the most poorest people in our society,and forcing some of them onto the street.Some whose homes are their family homes for generations.It's an unacceptable outrage in this so called democracy and society.17302013-02-02T16:51:49.0271417Kirsten EasdaleMy disabled son and the 2 other disabled people he shares his supported living accomodation with, are having to take in an extra tenant in order for them to avoid paying this extra room tax. Although the new tenant will be welcomed into their little family, this does mean that they will lose their existing recreation, quiet room.17302013-02-02T17:09:20.521418sally evanswho thought up this awful measure? who passed it? disgraceful government. let's at least do something to prevent its worst consequences\r\n17302013-02-02T18:13:07.0631419helen waddellSay no to the latest abomination from whitehall17302013-02-02T18:19:25.811420Wilma WattsA poll Tax by another name.17302013-02-02T18:56:05.6371422Chuck McGuiganPoliticians of all parties need to stop the playground game of points scoring against each other and start listening to the people they claim to represent.17302013-02-02T21:40:38.6831426Leslie MarshIt is about time we remembered that we live in a democracy and we are supposed to be civillised the poor are not here as cannon fodder or scapegoats there is only so much you can take from limited resources - but of course - like oil companies keep squeezing it till it bleeds, but that is all you have now - our blood and there will be more of it with this. Sit in your ivory towers with your cut glass crystal and bad mouth those who are less than you, you who have the lawyers and accountants to find the loopholes so you get tax breaks and don't pay this tax - is this what we can expect from an independant Scotland is this the excuse for usuary? this is the new Clearances - genocide of a section of the community that you have betrayed every minute of every day while you build your great houses and reputations on the bent backs of those less fortunate. 17302013-02-02T22:27:46.061427Rob ScottRidiculous legislation. I am a single parent being penalised for my Childs bedroom, because I am not the parent claiming child benefit, irrespective of how many nights he stays with me. I have been asked to move to a smaller home and give up my Childs room. Not a chance. The reason I applied and was given a 2 bedroom property was so I could have my child stay with me. 17302013-02-02T22:52:25.1371429Arnold GrayThis is outragous and will be a blight on our society.17302013-02-02T22:55:38.3431430Graeme YoungDo the right thing please. Help people instead of turning them out of their homes. 17302013-02-02T23:47:36.171431craig smillieLet's not penalise the poor.17302013-02-02T23:48:42.8531433Fiona HardieThink its disgusting that the government are trying to get money out of us for this now. 17302013-02-03T00:13:36.5371434Peter ThomsonA most disgusting piece of legislation though, sadly, only one in a series aimed at widening the gap between rich and poor...17302013-02-03T00:51:45.5471435Tracey BrownThe way the tory government is going it wont be long till they have made us into a 3 world country. Time the people took a stand and got rid of the tories before they do any more damage grrrrrrrrrrrrr17302013-02-03T09:04:52.361436Steven AlkerThough I now live in England, I have lived for 8 years in Scotland and I love the place, the country and the people. Making people homeless is not a Scottish thing, it's the king of repression enacted by a distant English Government. And I'm a pro Independence Conservative!17302013-02-03T09:19:02.9571440Lorna BettFor me, this is the most odious thing yet to be done to the poorer people of this country. It is tantamount to blackmail, for the councils have no two bedroom houses to give to people. An absolute disgrace.17302013-02-03T09:49:00.5831442David HardyI have already contacted my regional SNP MSP.\r\nThey have informed me there is nothing they can do to help as all benefits are under Westminster control. Not the answer i wanted to hear but it was the answer i expected. This tax is most unnecessary and cruel and retrograde. Hope this petition has some force or will it merely fall on deaf ears. Still we all must fight it and resist any way we can!17302013-02-03T11:14:21.2671444Caadfael.This is regressive, Victorian!!17302013-02-03T11:56:39.5031445Johnny21 Ct Uk - disgrace17302013-02-03T12:22:46.0871446mark out of my home of 41 years with no help from gha or anyone17302013-02-03T12:27:20.3371447anneplease dont let it happen17302013-02-03T12:29:54.8471448Deirdre MurrayWhere are people with an extra room expexted to move to when there are not enough smaller homes to rent. The Government should endevour to find extra funding for local authorities and housing associations to build more one and two bedroom homes. Idealy this money should come from Westminster as they are the ones forcing this legislation on the poor.17302013-02-03T12:30:56.9231449anneyour home is the biggest part of you17302013-02-03T12:37:37.1031450Catherine McCollThis is a cruel piece of legislation. You could be living in your home all your life and be forced to move. Someone should take this matter up through the 'Human Rights' legislation.17302013-02-03T12:51:22.7371451alan mcfarlaneback to the dark ages of window tax17302013-02-03T13:08:39.7371452luisepeople should have security of a roof17302013-02-03T13:15:21.8131454john this will kill people17302013-02-03T13:21:19.1571458Mandy WardI hope you can make a difference as its an Outrage whats happening. As allways Scotland are the Guinnie Pigs England wnt put up with this. I stayed in London for over 10yre & the Rent is 4 times Higher than up here. Good Luck il allways Sign Good Cause for Scotland i just Wish Scottish Pple Would STICK TOGETHER. We are Good at Talking About it But when it comes Down to it is a Different Story maybe this will give Us All a Good SHAKE. I HOPE SO.17302013-02-03T13:53:06.0171459terry my housing association say they are determined to pursue rd17302013-02-03T14:21:21.6371461Margaret HartI do not support the bedroom tax. This tax is nothing more than a way to penalise the poor and disabled for no other reasn than the fact that they are poor and disabled.17302013-02-03T14:24:43.5331462Anne McMillanDisgusting state of play. Disabled people who need a separate room being made to pay absolutely beggars belief.17302013-02-03T14:27:57.941463stephen boswellPlease help protect vulnerable people from these draconian measures voted for by an out of touch government.17302013-02-03T14:29:57.831464Sylvie BurnettThe bedroom tax is an obscenity brought about by a self serving minister not intelligent enough to think of positive legislation to help this nation.17302013-02-03T14:41:51.5131465Elizabeth McKayWhat I want to know is if people cannot afford this stupid extra bedroom tax where are they supposed to go? It is not the peoples fault there is not enough social housing to give them the size of house they require, and what about old people who had a family who have now left home are the Tories just going to throw them on the rubbish heap. What I would also like to know is are they going to pay extra money to those families who are over occupied and do not have enough bedrooms?17302013-02-03T15:05:17.1731466Allen HendersonThis is about as low as any government can get surely, forcing people out of thier homes. Disgusting,Mr Cameron you should be ashamed, there again you had to try and better Mrs Thatcher.17302013-02-03T15:20:47.9231467frances mcginlayAdding my voice to register protest at this tax\r\n17302013-02-03T15:36:59.3471468Hugh ReidI oppose the bedroom tax.17302013-02-03T15:42:44.5031469Deborah RumblesThis is a unfair and unjust tax, I am in a disabled adapted home, with my husband who is my full time carer, When i got the house in 2002 I had my 2 sons living with me, now they have left home and we have 2 extra rooms. I am on benefits only and will have to pay up to £80. a month for the 2 rooms off my bebnefit. I cannot work due to disabilities. Please get this government that nobody actually voted for out. before they end up with a mass suicide of desperate people.17302013-02-03T16:12:39.4231470edward hesterthis tax by the tory libdem gov.will hit the poorest \r\npeople in the country.Making poor people pay for the deficit caused by the greedy rich,bankers etc,,\r\nis typical of this right wing tory cabinet,who do not care a jot about the poorest in our society.17302013-02-03T17:48:55.8771471Jean BremnerThis will directly affect me as we live in a property that is adapted for my daughters special needs so not cost effective for us to move 17302013-02-03T18:01:17.9531472Alistair FultonWhy are the poor being punished for the failure of the rich?17302013-02-03T18:13:40.2731473Donna Pickett People are unable to afford to pay the extra with this increase. They shouldn't have to bear another burden of the costs with living in today's society. All this is doing is increasing the pressure on those on low incomes. Should they be punished because they have space, even if its slight. 17302013-02-03T18:17:56.3731474John QuinnThe scottish government must not allow evictions for the bedroom tax.17302013-02-03T18:22:14.771475tezcant believe this is happening in this day and age. its a form of ethnic cleansing17302013-02-03T18:25:12.8331476c a morrisonSooner we become independent the better- feel sorry for any English people affected by this despicable change17302013-02-03T18:49:03.831477Liz DalyWe cannot allow the most vulnerable people in society to be bullied in this way.17302013-02-03T19:21:13.4071478Dougie EvansThis is repugnant and should be scrapped now.17302013-02-03T19:30:12.8771479Anne-Marie SmithThe most vulnerable people in our communities will suffer. This will create more homelessness17302013-02-03T21:14:47.9831480gavwher do i go after eviction for arrears?17302013-02-03T21:49:30.8171481Linda GowThanks Mike Dailly, this tax will have a catastrophic effect on the hardest hit people iin the welfare reform attacks17302013-02-03T23:29:03.3831482FrancesCurranIt's time to launch a campaign of direct action to stop evictions just as the Red Clydesiders did before us.17302013-02-04T07:00:59.4771483Barbara SwansonAbsolute Disgraceful the council is to get away with this new law ..misery for me !!!!17302013-02-04T07:45:24.41484Paul whiteleyThis is THE most evil law ever passed .The conservatives really have reached the bottom when they do these horrible things then give money abroad.17302013-02-04T09:05:33.921485margaret smiththis has to be stopped pronto17302013-02-04T10:06:53.31486Shona MorrisonMy God. What are they thinking? Have they looked at Maslows hierarchy of basic human needs? Shelter being at the bottom? The thought of people being evicted from their family homes makes me feel physically sick! Cant believe this proposal! 17302013-02-04T10:49:07.9131487need not knowI might be OK considering, but the fact is its a disgrace the Government are doing this. For a start not only will it affect the people living in these homes and will affect the councils trying to re home everyone just to accommodate the government new plan and I know for a fact there is not enough 1 or 2 bedroom houses out there. So I take it the plan is to build newer and better housing? No I dont think so.... so the council have actually got no choice but to keep families in these houses.\r\n17302013-02-04T11:10:46.471488Cara McNaughtNot only is this insensitive to the circumstances of modern UK families but it is an ill concieved solution to the massive housing benefit bill. The gov would be better looking into the how local authorities use the homeless and temporary housing sector to cash in on the housing benefit system. LAs charge inflated rates, GHA for example, charge as much as £274 pw for a typically £50pw rental property, knowing those on section 5 referals are usually entitled to Housing ben. And so, being the landlord they reap maximum benefit this is where the money is really being wasted!!17302013-02-04T11:57:47.0471489anne tomsWe will not let an unelected govt force evictions in scotland. 17302013-02-04T12:37:26.091490Christine ChurchThe government have not thought this idea through with the bedroom tax as this will affect a lot more people then there is suitable accommodation. 17302013-02-04T12:43:44.7771491Carrie mackenzieIts disgusting. How can people sleep knowing the poorest are being made destitute, 17302013-02-04T12:45:35.6671492VeronicaThis is very long overdue - there is a massive disparity between the top 20% of earners and the rest of the working population. Its a disgrace that in this era we have classification of the 'working poor'. I would hope this petition would also cover the so-called apprenticeship banner - the loophole where employers pay outrageously low rates per hour and get away with it.17362013-02-04T14:33:05.291493Lz WalkerIt seems people with a so - called 'empty room ' are supposed to take in a lodger but if you're renting privately you're not allowed to sublet as far as I know .We must all fight this evil attack on the poor and disabled.\r\n17302013-02-04T15:14:54.6131494Marjory RossPlease stop this section of the Under Eviction Bill as this could affect anyone through no fault of their own. There not the properties to be moved to so you suit the new requirements and then you end up in debt for a bill you did not create. It is so unfair on the Poorest of Society. 17302013-02-04T16:51:20.771495Andrew GintyThere's a shortage of decent affordable rented housing in the UK in the areas where people need to live. \r\n\r\nThere's also a recession in the building industry. \r\n\r\nThe way to deal with this is to build more social housing, not to penalise families on low incomes.17302013-02-04T17:32:35.881496paulprotect scottish 17302013-02-04T17:35:53.7531497catherine nisbetstop all bedroom tax some people cant move to a smaller house due to disability aids installed in there house and the goverment are not prepared to pay to have them installed in another smaller house17302013-02-04T18:26:05.9931498Peter HawkeyPlease protect the most vulnerable in our society from one of the more despicable of this coalition government. 17302013-02-04T19:42:18.2971499Councillor Lawrence O'Neill, West DunbartonshireThis is clearly an attack on our communities and affects us all - we must do all in our power to alleviate the suffering that this will undoubtedly cause17302013-02-04T20:29:19.4471500lorainThe goverment are not interested in the low earn workers or the people who cant work due to illness stop sening millions to other countries spend in britain david cameron and co do not know what true life is all born with silver spoons 17302013-02-04T20:29:31.0871501Sarah FindlayThis is an attack on the poorest and most vulnerable. When Tory MPs can swan around their ten bedroomed mansions and enjoy second homes equipped and furnished at the expense of the taxpayer, the hypocrisy of pushing this through makes me very, very angry. 17302013-02-04T21:18:08.211502Eileen FInlay Barbaric ..unjust ..bill sneaked in and passed by those with mor than one home never mind a room... "most houses now you can't "swing a cat in "..even animals have social needs .. Is it a crime now ..after mab'y staying in your home for many years .. are we to leave our communities , friends , schools ,social circles ..to go whre ??...th reason that there are few sincle homes is that we moved away from that after the war ,,people needed space, better quality of lives .less crouding for a healthier life !.. we need to have children ..grandchildren ..friends stay over ! help if ill etc ... now people are to made feel like criminals .. we don't have extra money to pay this ..inhuman tax!..this was not on the manifesto then they were voted in ! .Alex Salmon.. now is the time to wine votes .. your people need justice .. stop this now !!.. depression "oh and that's ok there are free meds " ..and worse will follow .. worry stress .. suiside.. will follow . Save money on needless wars and all the Billions that costs .never mind lives ..I have worked all my days and paid taxes.I do object to abuse of the system but this is peoples lives ..Build us prison like cells and be done with it !.. disgusted ....and circumstances can change .. most people on housing benefit are on it not by choice! some may need it long term others until circumstances improve ... to say we need to leave our homes that we have invested in or pay up is to me criminal .. I am willing to march as protest and I suffer from Rheumatoid arthritis ...even if it won,t affect me ! .. already people are worried .. times are hard enough and health in this country . disease spread faster when we he crowded together !... stop the perks that mps get that's bound to save a few "bob" ! .....\r\n 17302013-02-04T21:22:03.291503sandra strachanI was told by Aberdeen City council that l would be wasting my time getting on the housing list as theres no houses available! Private sector has the monopoly and the prices are sky high.17302013-02-04T22:47:31.8071504George McIrvineThe bedroom tax is just the latest assault on our poorest and most vulnerablt citizens. This right wing Government needs to demonise its victims as state dependent leeches to evidence this unjust tax.\r\n17302013-02-04T23:50:51.7531505Caroline Corfield Willie Rennie, leader of the Libdems in Scotland once spent a night in a tent outside Paisley College of Technology to highlight the plight of the homeless, perhaps he could be asked what has changed his mind since then? 17302013-02-05T01:00:15.6471506Chris DalyMy landlord a housing association informed me in a letter of my options : Take in a lodger, move to a one bedroom property, get a job. Neither of these are viable for me as I have PTSD ,Depression and a Personality Disorder all related to Childhood Trauma. I can't even live with my own family and I think people will harm me. So no I can't get a lodger.. Get a job I'm in and out of the psychiatric hospital and have severe mental illness... I'm unfit for work. For the first time in many years I'm settled in a place I call home with neighbours and care workers (not my carers my neighbours) in the complex of flats who I have learned to trust. Social landlords tell me they don't have enough 1 bedroom properties to meet the new demand. In my view this was thrust upon them and tenants by an uncaring out of touch Westminster Government. Our MSP's and the Scottish Parliament need to be more than vocal on this issue they need to act NOW...... April is too late 17302013-02-05T07:21:29.3871507GAYLE MILLERBedroom Tax is an abomination of basic human rights. Many people need the "extra" room for many reasons, i.e caring for disabled, sick, elderly, families with shared custody, would-be parents etc Protect human rights and stop the attack on the poor and vulnerable.17302013-02-05T09:58:21.2671508Matt BellshawThis approach has all the hall marks of a tax increase buy stealth, if Scottish Government has a shortfall in income which it plans to fill from Businesses and Landlords, then a more transparent approach would surely be to amend the UBR, instead of this arbitrary delay.17172013-02-05T10:11:43.9431509Maureen GrantWhere is the moral complience in forcing people to move out of homes that they have lived in for decades, by all means encourage people to downsize. Many local authorities do not have the housing stock to allow the movement within their tennants specific area. Where is this governments thinking process, is it still in the past the bed tax sounds like something out of the dark ages ie, window tax. I certainly will not give my vote again to either party currently in power.17302013-02-05T10:15:58.241510joanne boylethis is a good thing it stops the landlords given rights to kick tennants out right away 17302013-02-05T11:24:46.5231511Janice MartinEviction because of under occupancy is abhorrent & yes this Act must be amended & yes action must be taken to ensure it does17302013-02-05T11:52:23.5771512Hugh McRobertsI Think the bedroom tax will add to the excisting problem and feel that this will force people to move from tenancys that have been part of their live since childhood, god forgive them for they no not what they are doing.17302013-02-05T12:08:08.321513Catherine BradleyWe have a number of clients who would gladly move to smaller properties and have their names on the waiting list. Like every other Local Authority there is a shortage of smaller properties her and huge waiting lists.17302013-02-05T12:30:56.571514Karen M CampbellIt is time that we as a nation speak out against the rising divide that has become so obvious in this country. The poorest people in our society are being forced into homelessness with no hope whilst the top earners in this country are getting tax breaks. 17302013-02-05T12:36:34.3331515Janice MitchellGreat to see Govan Law Centre taking this forward!!17302013-02-05T13:09:35.691516Gerry BoylePeople on benefits will find it impossible to pay this tax and should not be evicted. Everyone has got to make a stance so that people are not isolated. The Trade Unions and the Labour party should call for a mass organised no payment campaign they wont be able to evict everyone, an injury to one is an injury to all. Evict the Tories.17302013-02-05T13:24:06.3031517lorraine gibsonI have been in my house for 42 years my parents died wen a i was 17 and hae brought my kids up in this house i am being punished for circumstances out within my control17302013-02-05T13:30:01.151518Pauline McDonaldIs this even legal, I am on JSA for which the government says I need £71.00 a week to live on, they are only giving a 1% increase in April, which takes me up to £71.71 per week, are we not being paid by the old rules but paying by new rules. I pay £71 per fortnight to heat my home, £8 for my tv liscence and the rest goes on food and clothing come April I will have £35 a fortnight for food and clothes to keep me going, not going to look very good when I go for a job interview, with tatty clothes and shoes is it. Also where do the government expect me to go have tried swapping from a two bedroom to a one bedroom but there are not enough properties out there. Then when I'm made homeless again how am I expected to get a job without a fixed address.17302013-02-05T13:53:49.711519bernadette pollockmy nerves are shattered with the whole business!! 17302013-02-05T13:59:18.6631520mickawful worry will cause medical treatment and more to rehouse it will cost them money and a lot of sorrow and mental illness for people17302013-02-05T14:05:46.3831521stevie god bless mike dailly17302013-02-05T14:39:22.5371523Teresa SadlerHow can the government target the most vulnerable of our society? Shame on you who voted this sham of a government in. 17302013-02-05T14:53:39.9271524helen allanwhere are are they going to get smaller houses for some people as most housing offices say they have none avaiable just a way to make ypu poorer17302013-02-05T15:43:25.6871525Elizabeth LawsonThis is unjust and unfair and hits the most vulnerable. I think we know better here in Scotland. 17302013-02-05T16:03:14.3271526Margaret AndersonIF there was money being put into a SENSIBLE building programme to provide enough smaller houses to which to move people to then this wouldbe a good idea. The cart is before the horse, the government needs to get things in the right order. Build the kind of houses needs THEN ask folk to move into them! But as usual, the 'haves' are telling the 'have nots' how to live their lives!17302013-02-05T16:06:12.2031527Anne CampbellUnjust and yet another attack on the most vulnerable citizens in our country.17302013-02-05T16:26:46.481528Frazer CampbellIf ever there was a clearly unjust policy under occupancy is it! In many areas there are no appropriately sized houses so people are placed in houses that have too many bedrooms - not their fault. And what about the right to a family life this policy deprives parents who no longer live with their children of their right to be a part of their lives. It's a disgrace.17302013-02-05T16:36:12.511529Terry TurtonHow can you penalise somebody for having a property that is larger than they need when there is a shortage of 1&2 bedroom social housing17302013-02-05T16:55:11.761530ALLISON WARDWhy on earth are the government putting the most vulnerable people in such a position that they could potentially get into rent arrears, with the very real possibility that they could get evicted? what then? its absolutely unimaginable that our government could even consider this let alone implement it.17302013-02-05T17:27:23.781531joegood on you govan law centre17302013-02-05T17:37:00.141532sharon rankini live in a 3 bedroom flat with my 8 yr old daughter and my 6 yr ols disabled son , i whated for a yr and a half for a sutable property for my family , i am now been told i have to pay for my disabled son's room or mover to a 2 bed which would leave my family in a very difficult position as my son will need major open heart surgery though out his young life and it sickens me that i'll have to move again , as my son has settled well in our new home . i will be consulting a lawyer on this matter as my disabled son has the right to have his own room due to his disability.17302013-02-05T18:18:23.3471533Jane islesOf course it's unfair17302013-02-05T18:30:47.6171534Richard QuinnThere are no one bedroom flats available for people to downsize to. This is the craziest policy yet introduced by this Government which will cost much more to implement than any money it might save.\r\nIt is also inhumane and will make many thousands homeless causing devastation up and down the country. Soon you will quite literally have to step over the homeless just to get to the shops. The only answer to this policy is Independence from Westminster, so that we can make our own country fit for humans to live in.17302013-02-05T18:45:33.2931535joe help17302013-02-05T19:12:50.1831536brian dalydisgracful piece of legislation,flies in the face of tenancy laws and tenancy agrements,17302013-02-05T19:19:57.9431537Graeme YoungThe Scottish Parliament should be fighting tooth and claw against this reprehensible attack on the poor and vulnerable. David Cameron has twenty spare bedrooms that are bank rolled by the tax payer.17302013-02-05T20:42:38.9631538joe keep up the good work mike dailly17302013-02-05T22:23:21.2271539Susie ArnottTime to be different from Westminster. Let's have some social conscience here please. 17302013-02-05T22:48:05.3371540Gordon CoplandThis bedroom tax is draconian in nature and is attack on the most vulnerable in society which this government has no liking of. They cut benefits then they decide to add tax that costs more money . It is ok for these millionaires with money but don't attack the vulnerable who need these benefits or indeed evict the people fromtheir homes.Shockingly discriminatory17302013-02-05T22:49:17.291541Just a NumberWe need investment in one bedroom properties in the social rented sector. Holyrood are you listening????17302013-02-05T22:52:23.6871542George BlockleyIt's always those who are the most vunerable on the poverty line of our society who suffer the most.17302013-02-05T23:32:30.5571543David Paterson Crazy spiteful policy... Action needed now 17302013-02-06T03:23:05.291544Sandy BlackBedroom tax is complete madness. There simply aren't enough smaller properties to fill the demand. Single people are already paying more by having to heat homes that are bigger than their needs.17302013-02-06T08:30:39.1471545Lisa B KayAnd yet the majority of MP's have 2nd homes and are given all sorts of tax relief. Stop unfairly hitting people who can least afford these ridiculous penalties! 17302013-02-06T09:48:25.081546Kitty WHow about MPs with empty second and third homes give them up to those being evicted?!17302013-02-06T10:11:42.331547Carolcompletely unfair to pay your rent throughout your life to be evicted as a pensioner17302013-02-06T11:28:54.9431548Mairi SutherlandThis will only penalise the most vulnerable in society yet again. 17302013-02-06T11:30:21.4131549Sherry ByrdPossibly the most regressive and harmful tax since the poll tax..this cannot be allowed to stand.17302013-02-06T12:02:33.7071550Anne McLarenUnrealistic. \r\nThis claus will destroy families already struggling to stay together and will make many homeless. How will these things improve employability or increase the quantity of council houses? 17302013-02-06T12:30:56.1131551Douglas CampbellWhen MP's get a home allowance because they are from outside London are they restricted to a 1 bedroom flat? Or are they just better than ordinary people?17302013-02-06T12:37:02.131552JOE MY RENT IS 84POUND A WEEK IF IM FORCED INTO A PRIVATE BEDROOM ITS 105POUND COSTING THE GOVERMENT MORE17302013-02-06T12:46:30.0071553donnaspread this petition in every way possible17302013-02-06T12:50:17.4731554morrison youngI consdier this to be uncivilised as is anyone who supports such a policy or government.Independence HERE I COME, Voting Labour elected this shower.17302013-02-06T13:08:20.771555maria johnstondiscusted that yet again the most vulnerable in our sociaty are hit again,when will this government stop? 17302013-02-06T14:01:53.541556Robert JonesWe at SAMH Outreach West support this petition.17302013-02-06T14:07:04.2471557johnhelp17302013-02-06T14:21:02.5031558G MorrellIf benefits are set at the minimum the government says we need to live on, how can they justify taking back as much as perhaps £20 or more from a single persons allowance?17302013-02-06T17:57:04.1771559Mick RileyY17302013-02-06T18:43:15.311560Alistair McCabeI'm a carer for my 83yr old mother, when she passes on I'll be evicted from the council house (presumably). It's been our family home for 63 years, I'm really sickened by the Torys and their lackeys, the liberals. 17302013-02-06T18:58:19.171561DavidThe Tories caused this mess with Right to Buy and stopping replacement builds.However, those that stayed loyal to the council and had secure tenacies are now to be made to pay for it, if they have a spare bedroom, or face being evicted .. Truly wicked stuff! 17302013-02-06T19:14:10.2371562Susan GoldmanThis is a very cruel tax which will affect the poorest and most vulnerable in society. It must not be allowed to go ahead!17302013-02-06T20:52:39.231563harrymass non payment would work17302013-02-06T21:33:04.3571564e darraghshame on you cameron and shame on everyone who voted for him17302013-02-06T21:40:28.561565michael nugentunbelieve, idiocy, from those who run the country, people must take to the streets17302013-02-07T06:10:03.1471566JacobiteThis is part of "Agenda 21" Google it!17302013-02-07T09:50:47.7031567Gordon WardropeIt's just another form of oppression by a ruling elite looking after their own interests! People have the power, use your vote. 17302013-02-07T10:07:18.1031568Jamie MacNeilTenants should not risk loosing their home for a debt that is outwith their control. For most it will not be a case of wont pay it, but a case of cant pay it. 17302013-02-07T11:07:52.8671569 M AndersonUnfair on people who have low income and stayed in their home for years they should not be punished and have to worry about debt building up.17302013-02-07T11:45:32.3631570Claire ChristieRushed in, not thought through and very very dangerous.17302013-02-07T15:34:15.21571John McGuiganCHAOS.17302013-02-07T15:53:16.0231572Andy DonnellThis proposal is totally incompetent governance and shows a disgracefully irresponsible lack of care towards the less well-off sections of our community. It is not even half-baked as a proposal to solve a perceived problem. Just another sketch on the back of a cigar packet from m'lud. 17302013-02-07T16:35:36.821573Ian CampbellThis is a typical Tory policy which will hurt the elderly who have brought up their family and are now alone. The Tories should remember that after a while a house becomes a home.17302013-02-07T17:15:00.2831574Margaret GrahamNot enough thought or planning has been given by the Goverment17302013-02-07T17:44:44.631575MRS E CLARKIT IS RIDICULOUS OLDER PEOPLE ARE BEING FORCED TO DOWNSIZE WHEN THERE ARE ACTUALLY NOT ENOUGH HOUSES TO DO SO .SO WHY PAY THE TAX WHEN YOUR WILLING TO MOVE BUT CANT BECAUSE THERE ARE NO HOUSES AVAILABLE?WE HAVE LIVED IN OUR HOUSE MOST OF OUR LIVES.HOW CAN WE AFFORD THIS TAX ON BENEFIT ?WE ARE BARELY GETTING ENOUGH TO LIVE ON AS IT IS! WE HAVE NO MONEY TO RE- HOUSE17302013-02-07T22:50:15.7631576Caroline McCalmanThese changes haven't been thought through, where are all these one bedroom flats? It could kill an elderly person to move out of their home leaving their neighbours, family & support system. If other people move into private accommodation they will have to claim more benefit because the rents are higher! These are some of the most vulnerable members of our society who are already struggling with higher food, energy & other rising costs, how are they meant to pay the extra costs they will be asked to pay? This Bill is nonsensical, unfair, cynical & perverse it has been written by multi- millionaire MPs who don't live in the real world & aren't affected by the reforms they put in place. They have came up with this because the Daily Mail wrote a story about a few families living in expensive properties in London & receiving thousands in Housing benefit. This is more about keeping Tory voters in the Home Counties & "chattering classes" happy than saving tax payers money or making the benefit system fairer. The Westminster Government have definitely taken a sledge hammer to crack a nut!17302013-02-08T01:20:51.4171577Jacqueline Doyle In a civilised society we cannot allow this type of draconian measure to pass without challenge. To see the worry and anguish etched on people's faces when the subject is raised is heartbreaking!!! Can you look anyone in the eye and wish this on them to pay a debt they did not create?17302013-02-08T03:39:37.871578James MacfarlaneThere already is a scheme, run by the Living Wage Foundation. The SYP is essentially calling for needless duplication.17362013-02-08T12:24:47.5231579Douglas PearsonIs there anyway this can be taken to court as there is not enough smaller housing available so how can we be charged for the governments mistakes in not having a proper building program it is just another way to get money from poor and keep the rich rich is that this governments policy it looks like it17302013-02-08T14:34:33.5931580billy Wintonso if a client comes in for help with a debt that has arisen from bedroom tax that is being pursued as a normal debt, in particular people who will never work again ,what options would this leave a money adviser because of the continuing liability would das td or sequestration be a realistic option.should it not be the case that if a landlord is not able to supply suitable alternative accomodation bedroom tax should not apply.17302013-02-08T22:11:42.071581elma sutherland reminds me of stories of the Highland clearances forceing people out of their homes \r\n17302013-02-08T22:14:22.421583sambrutality is what it is17302013-02-09T07:37:00.5331584Tressa BurkeGlasgow Disability Alliance welcomes this petition. We are concerned that two thirds of households affected have a disabled person living in them. Disabled people are being unfairly targeted and this is on top of community care charges and cuts to other benefits and services. These are targeted measures which unfairly affect those for whom we should provide a safety net. This used to be called the welfare state.17302013-02-09T10:48:18.0731585Rachel BowlesAnother shameless attack on the disabled by the government.17302013-02-09T16:06:15.891586Sue DownieI think this is shocking piece of legislation that will punish people simply because their family circumstance change or because there are health or disability issues which require them to have an extra bedroom. It is blatantly discriminatory against people who are reliant on financial support to meet their housing costs, and could lead to the wholesale uprooting of people from their families and communities.17302013-02-10T02:19:29.911587JanNever thought that me and my disabled husband would end up on the street at our age, but it's a possibility, just feel sick everyday17302013-02-10T06:32:27.581588K. EdinburghApproached, Fri 8th Jan, by housing officer for Housing Association, was given two choices...Pay or Move! Callous and Heartless, I have arthritis, Rhumatoid and Poly, pain is 24hours, waited over 20 years for ground floor and only option last year was two bedroom, now I'm being told I will have no options as no ground floors available, flat with stairs or if Im really lucky I may get a lift. At this point I was then told I could not be fussy at this time. Thanks to ToriesLibs I now face the prospect of either moving back to a flat and never getting out the house or ending up homeless. REMEMBER O.A.P's are exempt, will not be forced to pay, and Disabled will more than likely be means tested every few months for exemptions for carers, because you may be cured over night thanks to a miricle, another form of harrassement from this farce of a government. THIS IS NOT A BEDROOM TAX IT IS IS A BENEFIT CUT AGAIN17302013-02-10T15:45:44.0571589Sheilagh DouglasConcerned that yet again the most vulnerable people \r\nare being targeted with this unjust tax.17302013-02-10T20:20:44.5631590Ian CarleCommunity action stopped poindings in the Poll-Tax era and it can stop evictions in the Bedroom Tax era17302013-02-10T22:26:24.6571591gavthe stress is unbearable with this17302013-02-10T22:27:44.4071592gavin know one seems to be able to give any answers to this17302013-02-11T01:23:10.4031593NickyI think this is dreadful. I don't see how it will help anyone. I think punishing the most disadvantaged only marginalises more and more. I think more people will become more and more ill because of lack of money and will have to use NHS services and Social Services. I think less money will go into the local economy because more people will have less money. I think Councils will have less money because less people will be paying into their systems and they will have to pay more in services. \r\nOn the other hand, if people are able to find places of which will be very difficult considering there's a National Shortage of Housing and unfit housing for those with extra needs, the extra in rent will be covered.\r\n\r\nI also feel local Government have been slow to act, my own advising these are just proposals so we don't need to train or inform our staff.\r\nAberdeen Council was only a few months ago approaching bankruptcy - I'm unsure if they can afford any more mishaps....\r\nOn the other hand, many charities are unable to support people, the worst being Lynn Hendry of the STV Appeal who advised me that they could not be seen to criticise the Government who could withdraw funding - she had to begged to share the information privately!\r\nMarie from Save the Children advised me that they felt the same way. I asked Save the Children directly through email but never received a response.\r\nOver the last month, I was advised of an article from the Guardian regarding this matter of charities not wanting to be seen to speaking out because their funding would be withdrawn.\r\n\r\nI would like to offer my full support and would also like you to contact Stewart Hunter of the SNP Parliamentary Office in Dundee who is very interested in hearing about your thoughts. \r\n\r\nMany thanks, \r\n\r\nNicky P\r\n\r\nPS\r\n\r\nI have emails in support of my conversations with the two ladies in question and am happy to share them with you.\r\nxxxxxxx17302013-02-11T07:31:43.931594dawn I am exempt because my partner is 76 i am 59 if my partner dies before I'm pensionable I will join the BT .. please this is a terrible thing for everyone and I'm scared ,,, 17302013-02-11T10:38:41.9631595Julie SempleMany individuals on low incomes manage their budgets to the penny in order to prevent the anxiety that comes with beng in debt. This situation may push individuals, through no fault of their own into ever increasing debt. Already advisers are being told that the poorest in society are choosing whether to heat their home or feed themselves. The added burden of stretching their income to pay the bedroom tax will make their situation untenable.17302013-02-11T12:03:11.191596jason williamsreminds me of the 80's what a sham17302013-02-11T12:31:45.1631597Lorraine DearieMany people will be put in impossible positions by the westminster policies, it's only right for Scotland to try to mitigate the affect where it can until we can be rid of this once and for all. Vote YES for a fairer Scotland who can rule itself so we never see the likes of this abhorrent tax or other draconian cuts all aimed at the poor, the disabled and the low paid workers.17302013-02-11T13:00:32.1631598Lynsey DawsonWhat a ludicrous law! It's basically forcing people into homelessness17302013-02-11T13:30:06.0271599john spenceits an unavoidable retaliation from the public on an issue that effects us all, this petition however is democracy in action. 17302013-02-11T16:03:56.011600Julie-Anne MorganAs the mother to a disabled son who has Asperger's I find this new law unacceptable and think the government should have thought of the impact it would have on disabled and low paid families before they implemented it as law17302013-02-11T16:15:32.711601Ben WrayThe Scottish Government have a responsibility to at the very least prevent evictions because of this backward, regressive tax policy17302013-02-11T19:33:26.4571602Michael O'ConnellI consider the evictions occurring as a result of this tax unjust morally.17302013-02-11T21:12:33.5431603Tommy SheridanResistance is necessary.17302013-02-11T22:40:33.0871604Mark ConnellyAnother example of Tory "democratic" rule.17302013-02-11T22:44:34.6371605margaret lorimerTypical Tory government, punish the poorer class17302013-02-12T09:12:20.621606Alasdair MacPhersonThis petition has my full support. The Bedroom Tax is a barbaric, draconian and unjust attack on social rented tenants. 17302013-02-12T12:39:09.851607Jacqui PollockThis is so hard for people to take and the stress on them is enormous, and what for may I ask?. There are not enough houses tp put people in, will people get compensated for adaptations they paid for to meet their needs,its private landlords who should be targeted as the government pays their morgage while whoever stays in their property gets housing benefit, who then owns the house?there is a lot of troubled people going to take this matter further.17302013-02-12T16:21:09.7271608margaret flemingThey have to remember these house's are our home's we built a lifetime of memories in for to have it taken away it should be against the law to treat people so poorly when they can't fight back.17302013-02-12T17:47:13.7271609Stuart YoungIt should not be permissible for a person to erect a wind turbine which is closer to a neighbouring property and, or, more visible and, or audible to the neighbouring property than to the applicant's own home.17372013-02-12T20:41:13.911610Mary AlladiceI am not directly affected by this vile bedroom tax but I know people that are and their lives are being ruined. In my humble opionion this is the tory way of getting rid of social housing and kicking the poorest in the country17302013-02-12T20:41:49.5971611David TOWNSENDThe same complaint was made against Moray Council and to the Ombudsman which but for the Burghead Community Council who notified the Cummingston community would have imposed seven turbines surrounding our beautiful coastal village.17372013-02-12T21:15:56.6371612Nigel WillisThe current 20mtrs notification distance is woefully inadequate for wind turbines or any other industrial development. The distance for notification needs to be increased to 2Km in my view17372013-02-12T21:42:19.9931613rodthanx govan law centre for caring 17302013-02-12T22:04:03.9831615guyunbelievable17302013-02-12T22:04:08.171616John ScottA proposal which is long overdue. The effect of the structures has a radius measured in hundreds of metres (not counting the visual effect which is measured in kilometers). To have a statutory requirement for notification limited to 20 metres is absurdly inappropriuate. This requirement was formulated before the age of wind turbines and needs to be updated.17372013-02-12T22:09:34.8371617guygood to see some old familiar names backing this petition17302013-02-12T22:41:03.1671618Vivienne Earl InfanteAlthough I live in the United States, Scotland, the land of my grandmother, is important to me as it is to numerous expat Scots here and around the world. The destruction of the magnificent scenery in Scotland will be a great loss to descendants of Scots worldwide who carry the love of that special land in their hearts. 17372013-02-12T23:41:15.221620bernadette skivingtonwhat will happen if a family is evicted from their home will social work take the children off the parents and rehome them 17302013-02-13T09:41:39.291622ROB FALCONERIN MY VIEW, ANYONE WITHIN 1.5 KILOMETRES SHOULD BE NOTIFIED OWING TO THE RISKS TO HEALTH FROM WIND TURBINE NOISE.17372013-02-13T09:59:34.3131623Douglas ReedmanThe whole windfarm idea will prove a disaster for Scotland just like its SNP Government17372013-02-13T11:25:10.2331624Colin AndersonWe have to fight for what is right and what happens to the animals dogs cats ect 17302013-02-13T11:35:59.5971625Chris BerminghamThere is already a lack of social housing provision and this tax will only exacerbate this. We are asking people to do the impossible as even those willing and able to move have no options. Why would the goverment, with their vast array of ancestral homes, consider that the homes of people supported by benefits are any less important to them. Financially people are worse off on benefits that they have ever been and its about to get much much worse.\r\nAll those who feel they are currently not affected by this legislation should think again, this will affect all of us, our families and our communities.17302013-02-13T11:59:34.661626Joy CodonaMany people will suffer because of these changes in housing benefit, the sick and vulnerable will be the worst affected. I volunteer at the Citizen's Advice Bureau so I have first had experience of the effects this change will have. Steps must be taken to support the most vulnerable17302013-02-13T12:00:48.521627Ian CavanaghWhy does the Government make life difficult for people when they can leave peaple to live a good life.17302013-02-13T13:06:01.8531628Stephen McAlaneyThe DWP state that Jsa of £71 pw is what the law says I need to live on-this tax reduces my living expenses by £9.66. At least a contradiction, possibly illegal? Definetely a further impact on the poverty line.17302013-02-13T14:14:23.6731629Rosemarie CzarneckaPeople are finding it hard to feed their children and live without all this added!!!! just go's to show that the westminister does not care about the little people.... just cos they have the money, why not have a year living in our shoes, then come and we will talk bout the stupid tax.....17302013-02-13T14:47:48.61630karen mcguireto me the government are contradicting themselves as they already give out what they deem to be the minimum that people need to live on so where are they expecting people to get the extra money needed to stay in their own homes, have they not thought about the consequences of this new tax, crime rates will sore and prostitution will increase in order for people to finance this rediculous bedroom tax, why not save money by making things more equal once again its a case of take from the poor in order for the better off to continue in their comfy life styles....shame on the UK government. 17302013-02-13T14:55:22.611631Deborah Jean ChambersThis would allow people to live with dignity and not depend on handouts from the government. People who work should be rewarded accordingly, we all count together - let's unite as a country and make our children proud.17362013-02-13T14:56:17.071632K MuirWhy don't they site them on Arthurs' seat ,plenty of space up there,why is it always in rural areas,where the only income people have,is from tourism.they are going to decimate the countryside.17372013-02-13T14:57:57.8031633J MoodieI think it's unfair to turn an 'anti-wind' campaigner into an 'anti-independence' campaigner. It is possible to be 'against' one and 'for' the other. Alex Samond is not the be all and end off of independence - just because he would lead us to independence does not mean he would stay in power.17372013-02-13T14:58:47.3571634George EsslemontIt is high time this total waste of public money was stopped concerning Turbines whether onshore or offshore they are all awaste of the general publics money and ignoring the laws of them should allow us to claim against those responsible for placing them especially near to peoples homes.17372013-02-13T15:53:49.5571635samwhy should i feel a terrible burden and worthless better off dead everytime the conservatives are in power17302013-02-13T17:24:09.4271636William CochraneIt is a national scandal thst we are having to address this issue at all, wind turbines are blighting the unique landscape that we must treasure and protect.17372013-02-13T22:38:09.0231637Tas Gibson..."Democracy in UK is just an insidious form of Dictatorship with the richest being the Dictators!"\r\nAs shown by Corporates and landowners and Governments to persons with properties close to windfarms..... "Take us to court they flaunt, knowing you need money and lots of it to succeed! 17372013-02-13T22:40:51.8971638Darren brownlowPeople who can't work or get about already have a hard enough life with their illness with out having to worry about this new policy coming out17302013-02-13T23:29:28.9431639Les HudsonDivisive, hitting poor hardest, prejudicial towards single parents and those in Local Authority areas where there is a deficit of single bedroom accommodation. Vulnerable particularly at risk, huge burden on Local Authority personnel and budgets.17302013-02-14T00:10:48.9731640Tim Harrison10 times the height of 140m is still less than the guideline of 2km separation from properties. Perhaps that would be a better limit then neighbour notification would be required whenever a developer breeches the minimum separation, reducing the chance of seeking planning "on the fly".17372013-02-14T01:35:03.1231641pete if know one paid this we would defeat it17302013-02-14T04:29:24.9231642steve41years in the home i love will get arrears then eviction very unfair17302013-02-14T11:36:38.81643Douglas MoirWhen will those responsible at council and government level wake up to the economics and impact that will have on consumers for over two Decades to come. What is currently there is irreversible and has to be paid for along with hundreds more turbines. A so called green policy now blood red in terms of the millions blowing out of Scotland on so called "free wind".17372013-02-14T12:27:20.9231644Peter Clapton20 metres is ridiculous when applied to wind turbines. It should be anyone within sight of a windfarm or whose view of the countryside is seriously affected.17372013-02-14T12:33:12.3331645Eddie MurrayIn the council block where I live 25 of the 56 tenancies will be forced to pay this disgusting bedroom tax or be evicted. In the North Edinburgh area almost 1000 council tenants will be hit - and that does not include private and housing asociation tenants. This tax is a Tory obscenity and must be crushed, just like its predecessor, the cursed Poll Tax, was crushed by popular resistance and a refusal to pay.17302013-02-14T13:24:30.0631646Father Ross K BellThis bill is iniquitous and bordering on evil, it will destroy communities, disrupt children's education and create social isolation. It must be stopped. NOW.17302013-02-14T13:45:19.4931647Nick TelfordThis is yet another badly thought out Tory policy that terrorises the most vulnerable in our society yet does not address the causes of poverty and deprivation.17302013-02-14T14:38:55.111648Paul BlandIn the current economic climate where businesses need every support they can get, a decision to defer the revaluation to 2017 would be morally wrong. The repercussions for such a decision will see many more businesses going to the wall and a lot more empty shops on our High St.17172013-02-14T15:14:43.9271649sarah claptoni have heard that my house will be impacted - I have no idea what to do and also our water supplly comes from Sleuteuch wood which will be trashed in the scheme of things17372013-02-14T17:45:41.8531650Jim SwiftApart from the subsidies that will drive us all into penury and be the root cause of the biggest transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich in history, windfarms are great. I would not want to live next to one with all the attendant risks to health and well-being that appear to be emerging we should want fair warning if one was proposed. I think this peition seeks common sense. However, the proliferation of windmills is testament to the obvious lack of abundance thereof.17372013-02-14T18:16:22.7171651Andrew John YoungerUnder occupation, bad luck or bad management?\r\nHowever those circumstance arrives making someone homeless is no way a progressive Scotland. \r\n\r\nCore of Social Housing must be fundamental to charity status and removal of that from a magnet on commercial activity, effective spiffs parity to private sector is very wrong indeed and be very ugly to decent Scots. \r\n\r\nCause of under occupation, too late once that is a situation, would you throw out a problem? Charity begins at home. 17302013-02-14T18:17:24.061652Mairi AdkinAs usual they always taget the wrong people. The government certainly have no understanding of real life nor do they appear to want too.17302013-02-14T18:26:33.551653Andrew John YoungerSupport this in principle and would ask for Scottish Parliament to initiate a design of a charter mark on par to BSI or ISO institute allow recognized employers to attach an official charter mark to letter heading, publicity, etc. \r\n\r\nVerification of any scheme could be from existing organisation, trade guild, local authority, from all government departments that tender for services. \r\n17362013-02-14T21:47:46.481654anneim in tears every day with this i dont want to lose my home i love it17302013-02-14T22:00:45.81655Brian McNeilI agree fully with the principles of this petition, and believe the Scottish government has a moral obligation to implement the proposal, or other measures with an identical effect.\r\n\r\nThe 'bedroom tax' threatens to undermine Holyrood's stance on homelessness, to further line the pockets of grasping slum landlords, to break community and family ties, and to 'socially cleanse' areas where property values are high. In short, it's the sort of malicious fiscal attack on the poor that only Lord Snooty and the Bullingdon Club Thatcherites could dream up.17302013-02-15T08:52:57.7571656mark mccafferAbsolutely disgusted by this bedroom tax and I will likely be thrown out my flat. My '2nd room' is currently needing a carpet and furnishings. Do we get to let out the room? Do we get any financial aid to bring it up to scratch? Do we get financial aid to move house in the event that we may get evicted? Come live here for a while David Cameron and see how you like going without heating in winter just to pay for food. Another government we never voted for. Please vote yes to independence as we will probably get a government who care for Scottish peoples needs.17302013-02-15T12:15:10.2071657William DonaldsonWhat I want to know is as of the moment as I am a jobseeker and have to pay 14% of my rent from April, if i return to work will I then be liable for normal rent or will I still have to pay this. if the case is that I have to pay normal rent then how can this tax be legal i.e. if i am unemployed I am classed as under occupier but if I am in work my property is no longer classed as under occupier.17302013-02-15T15:52:07.831658Craig FrewI support this petition 100%, in this current financial climate it is not necessary to penalise already vulnerable tenants with an unfair bedroom tax.17302013-02-15T16:27:42.241659jodieif they are going to do this sham of a bed room tax then they need to start building and providing people with what they need not charging them for the housing associations not having enough sutable houses to put people in ita a down right disgrace also i have 3 kids under 10 one of chick is disabled there is not chance my other 2 can stay in the same room as my disabled child for a number of reasons the main on being HEALTH AND SAFETY 17302013-02-15T17:02:59.081660Robert Geelanthis is not a good idea at all.17302013-02-15T17:10:42.2131661arlene macneiillplease sing this we all need halp some times and its me this time17302013-02-15T18:35:09.5231662denise I think this i just wrong all over the place boys and girls should not be made share a room the need there privacy and to charge people for wanting to give there children this privacy or keep a room for there children while they are away is just wrong the keep taking are money and spending it on crap like there 150 a month food allowence and there rent or morgage getting paid for them and all the other hard tax payers money they spend on them self instead of the things that matter like better housing and fixing the roads making better parks for are children improving hosptials ect they just want to make the rich even ritcher.17302013-02-15T18:37:43.0871663Jeannie BennNot from Scotland but I fully support this petition and have signed for the sake of the poor and the working class who have been forced to 'go private' owing to the lack of social housing. A cap on private rents should also be placed to stop these greedy Tory voting landlords from ripping off both the poorest and the benefits system.\r\n17302013-02-15T20:42:55.331664Gillian GrochlaAs a support worker for a mental health charity, I am only too aware of the devastating effect the mere prospect of this tax is having on the most vulnerable members of our society. 17302013-02-15T21:18:58.351665J.EassonI depair for the future of our society. I work in local authority customer services and am already aware that the poorest most vulnerable are already suffering with the stress of this tax and will suffer when it takes effect. We are heading towards a Dickensian poorhouse future unless an amendment is made.17302013-02-15T22:31:20.5731666Jean RattrayAnother daylight robbery. God help us all if we allow this to come about.\r\n17302013-02-16T07:33:31.3971667J FosterThe full impacts of turbines on residents has not been fully explored. Shadow flicker is very disturbing both to mental and general health- the implications have not been fully investigated and are of great concern. That policy is worked to accept development such as this as a quick cash grab is ridiculous. The impact on residents is horrific. The locality is rich in many resources which are relied upon, and would be impacted heavily as a result of the development. Surely the current prolific numbers of turbines in the area is sufficient, and if investment was given to the grid to accept what they can generate, no further would be required. There are many other negative impacts that arise from such development, the loss of peat bog, giving rise to increased water levels and ground saturation, the loss of wildlife and their habitat. Once the land is gone, it cannot be replaced or restored. 17372013-02-16T07:37:52.2571668chrisdont pay it17302013-02-16T12:07:43.8031669Mrs. V.C.K. MetcalfeAnyone who has questions about the validity of claims being made by the EU, UK Governments and wind industry in respect of the renewable energy policy currently being imposed, should look at the Complaint now lodged and under consideration by the UNECE (United Nations Economic Commission for Europe) Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee under ACCC.C.2012.68. A great deal of valuable information will be found about which all MSP's should be aware and taking due note.17372013-02-16T14:38:07.131670Sarah DavisNoise from wind turbines creates a nuisance, which in some cases can cause sleep deprivation and in severe cases impacts on health. The greater the distance from a home, the lesser the impact.17372013-02-16T20:03:16.551671George HerraghtyThe Waubra Foundation insists on a 10 Kilometer distance from any large turbine!17372013-02-16T20:56:57.9171672CJNicolsonThis tax would only be justifiable in the slightest if there were enough one bedroom properties in all areas to enable folk to downsize within their communities. There isn't, therefore it isn't.17302013-02-17T00:51:45.211673Mrs Sandra ReidThey spoil our countryside, they disturb wildlife, they cause disruption with the noise, and the glistening of light off their blades cause distraction to people living near to them.17372013-02-17T08:49:43.771674Christine martinI have had first hand experience of not receiving a neighbour notification due to the fact that I'm over 20 metres away. The farmer next to me has just got planning permission to build 2 wind turbines 500 metres from my front door. My house featured in his plans, measurements from my door were clearly visible, but yet no on had the common decency to inform me. When I did find our about the application, the date for making a representation had passed. I did however make one as did my neighbours (they didn't know either!) unfortunately though, because I had missed the deadline date, mine or their comments weren't included in the report. The whole process is flawed. One has to wonder whether it's set up like this to ensure minimal representation???17372013-02-17T10:17:39.851675SIt wouldn't even be so bad if the 20m started from the boundary of the property owned by the applicant or developer, but when it relates exclusively to the base it means neighbours can be within the topple distance of the turbine yet not notified of the application. \r\n\r\nAll residents within the area impacted should be notified. According to independent research from Waubra, residents up to 40km from a turbine can be affected by symptoms of Wind Turbine Syndrome. Properties several miles from turbines can be impacted by flash from turbine blades which can have consequences for epileptics and migraine sufferers, or even those who have never previously suffered these symptoms.\r\n\r\nIt is time the Government put Health and Safety ahead of money making schemes and started building SUSTAINABLE rather than merely RENEWABLE generators.17372013-02-17T10:45:55.4971676Duncan TannahillThis petition addresses one of the key issues with wind farm development and if the petition changes legislation then there will be a degree of balance in favour of the local resident which has to be welcomed.17372013-02-17T11:39:49.151677Andrew KiddWind Turbines should not be sited next to dwelling houses when they will cause disruption to their inhabitants.17372013-02-17T13:53:45.5971678Andrew ShiellsThis is absolutely criminal and typical of the SNP. It happened to us last year. Please see saynotowindturbines.com and sign our petition. Thanks.17372013-02-17T15:53:00.8771679GCFalkirk-----William Donaldson----\r\nYou only have to pay anything if you are receiving housing benefit. The idea is that you should get what you actually need if paid for by the rest of the workforce or you should pay for what you want if your in employment.17302013-02-17T18:53:20.851680Dorothy WatsonHow many extra rooms is the Queen going to be taxed on? How many rooms are the millionaire MP's going to get away with not declaring that they are allegedly sub-letting?17302013-02-17T19:02:33.8331681Irene Fleming We didn't vote conservative but are having this act imposed which is essentially a tax on the poor. 17302013-02-17T19:12:25.6031682Peter ShealThe economic benefits of these imported wind turbines are unproven. As well as paying for this industrialisation of the countryside, we'll probably have to pay for their decommisioning. 17372013-02-17T21:19:59.681683Cllr Patrick HoggThis legislation is perniscious Tory persecution of the poor and must be repealed in the first week of SCottish Independence as no nation should ever treat their poor in such a disgraceful manner!17302013-02-17T22:43:46.3971684Francis Fallan MBE This particular legislation is purely based on a right wing government cementing a policy of people control the likes of which has never been seen since before the signing of the Magna Carta, remember it only applies to the dwellings owned by public authorities with exception of police, armed forces and other citizens on work associated to government or crown occupations, it's a clear attack directed at controlling purely working class people.17302013-02-18T01:48:09.0431685allan rutherforddont be scared of independence vote..... Torieshave already used propoganda by announcing the holding back navy contracts for yarrows bae systems. As they are unsure of independence for scotland. The changed scottish north sea to english channel border to steal our rights to gas and oilin 1999. But...... Scotland has all rights to gas and oil exploration in arctic...... A mistake by parliment signed wrong paper to us... Thats their appeal to the UN. \r\nWe are all under UN rule of depopulation Agenda 21 in UN papers. All countries are to reduce population by imposing imunizations that are poisons... Bill gates congratulates depopulation for world programme. All sponsored by major countries n leaders of the world for nwo aka UN....17302013-02-18T07:17:56.7871686Drew Brownutter madness 17302013-02-18T09:56:33.3571687Alex DavidsonThis is an appalling piece of policy, which directly illustrates how nasty the 'nasty' party has become, with the support of the Liberal puppets. You should be ashamed of your attack on the poor, the disabled and the elderly, but enjoy your tax concessions, large houses with duck houses, and stables for the police horses you get a wee loan of when times are hard. 17302013-02-18T10:25:05.461688Andrew PearsonThe Tories have conveniently forgotten how many council houses they removed from the social housing stock through the right to buy scheme, leaving a shortage of suitable properties. The bedroom tax is utterly repellant and is punishing people who have no accommodation to move to even if they wanted to.17302013-02-18T10:44:16.0831689Maureen BonnerA Snowflake is a wondrous beautiful sight, no 2 are the same.On its own it is fragile but look what they can do when they stick together.17302013-02-18T11:06:50.071690Alicia MurrayMan's inhumanity to man. I loathe the Tories.17302013-02-18T11:12:32.8771691John HamiltonEveryone in the country should rise up against this evil ConDem tax and say - Not to our people!! Roll on 2014!17302013-02-18T11:47:47.391693Ian VallelyDisgrace, 17302013-02-18T12:05:33.441694Mary ThomThis goverment has lied to the people they are preying on the disabled and poor people they are bring the people most needed down disgrace they should be ashamed off there selfs let them live that the poor for a month I don't think they would last a week lets get them voted OUT !!!!!!!17302013-02-18T12:49:43.8231695Sandra SullivanI feel sorry for everyone even myself I have lived in my home for 23 years I have one spare bedroom17302013-02-18T13:57:02.7071696David Listened to the Scottish Lib Dem leader trying to defend this outrageous Tax and thought to myself, I will never vote for your party ever again ! 17302013-02-18T16:06:51.7531697SusanIn a country where there was enough social housing to accommodate all those who needed it I would not be entirely against this tax, as long as it was enforced in a reasonable manner. However, during a period when the number of social houses being built has fallen off a cliff, how can this be justified? It is nothing short of victimisation.17302013-02-18T16:42:00.361698Michael McFadyenThis is just another proof of why Scotland needs independence. Most "Scottish" Labour MPs voted against this unfair and immoral tax but to no effect. Their votes were ineffectual and as with Thatcher in the 1980s any laws passed in Westminster no matter how detrimental to the health, wealth and well being of the people of Scotland it will be imposed upon us. Only an independent parliament with control over all its resources and spending will ever change that. Welfare reform may be a necessary process but due to the neo-liberal consensus at Westminster targeting the poor and the disabled is given a greater prominence than the tax avoidance schemes of companies and individuals who are able to pay taxes but who chose not to. A YES vote in 2014 is not about the SNP its about doing what is right, standing up for those who need help and be willing to share the burden of tax to enable better services to be provided. 17302013-02-18T16:47:26.6331699John SouterThis is an iniquitous tax of little use or purpose.17302013-02-18T17:07:44.2731700AnnaI am ill enough without this hanging over my head\r\n17302013-02-18T17:34:56.561701Michael TaylorNeighbour notification is vital. My neighbour has lost some £0.35m on her property because a farmer put up a turbine about 150 metres tall without saying.17372013-02-18T17:40:45.981702JamesMy mother has been in the same flat for 20+ years. She needed this flat at the time as she was a single mother with 3 children. Why should she have to downsize? Her children visit her all the time, sometimes all at once. Where are we to stay? Everybody on the floor in the lounge? Are they going to offer her other accommodation and help her move? She is 53 years old and needs a knee operation! It's just making the poor poorer. How many people are going to die of starvation or cold when they really are going to choose between eating and heating? It's not about not paying it, they just take it from your benefits. Population control? Kill the elderly? Needs to stop!17302013-02-18T17:45:43.671703johnnyso glad govan law centre has started this petition17302013-02-18T17:48:35.9971704john starkthis is nearly as great an attack on the consept of social housing as the right to buy17302013-02-18T18:30:18.351705Brian HThe UK(Con-Dem)Government has decided on this tax without giving consideration to the devastation it will cause to individuals and families throughout Scotland.17302013-02-18T20:10:18.8231706joe mcgoldricktaking more money of the poor to pay back money the rich lost17302013-02-18T20:58:49.9831707Sally CameronHow will this work for disabled people that have been housed by the council who have not requested a spare room but have been given a property that has an extra bedroom purely to have accessible facilities?? Will they be offered accessible housing with less bedrooms? I don't think so as there is not alternatives available!17302013-02-18T22:22:41.371708Ken HoodLets also call for a no developments to be sited a minimum of 2km distance from property. Sauchen against WindTurbines17372013-02-18T22:44:49.111709Stephen McMahonA ridiculous attack on the poor while disproportionately affects the working class while the rich stay in homes with more rooms than they could ever possibly use.\r\nAny money made from this disgusting charade would be dwarfed by the revenue raised from tax-dodging corporations and mega-rich CEOs.17302013-02-18T22:51:03.2171710Dominic McnellisAnd did you notice there was no choice of Scotland available? yes to independence!17302013-02-18T23:35:14.311711Ann McAlpineThe Scottish Government should protect vulnerable people from this UK legislation.17302013-02-19T00:27:45.0871712Robbie PenningtonScotland did not vote for this. Resist this foreign interference.17302013-02-19T08:50:15.791713Catherine HughesDisgraceful!!17302013-02-19T09:45:06.5031714vicky thomsoni think its disgusting :-(17302013-02-19T09:47:48.8131715eve robinsonThis is not in Manifesto.17302013-02-19T10:18:49.7571716Colin Steinim sick to death of these EU laws guissed as british law.........17302013-02-19T10:30:33.951717Pamela Herta LumsdenThis is so unfair to so many people, im surprised they havent started to build poorhouses as we seem to be going backwards in time!!!!17302013-02-19T10:59:36.7231718Garry MaclachlanAnother attack on the worst off in society! We fought the poll tax and won, we will fight this too and win!17302013-02-19T11:00:46.591719Gerry GreenIt's hard to believe a 'democratic' government would impose such an unfair tax on their most vulnerable citizens. Must not be allowed to be imposed!17302013-02-19T11:06:47.6271720AnonHeartless Government17302013-02-19T11:28:37.5371721Louise brownThe sustained attack on the poor and vulnerable of society must end. Pennies will be scraped back with this legislation and to what end? A poorer, more polarised and damaged community17302013-02-19T11:36:41.3931722peter dougalhow dare they, unite and fight dont let them away with this stand up and be counted, we are the people.17302013-02-19T11:57:07.9071723Alan Wylliewww.no2bedroomtax.co.uk\r\n\r\nWell done Mr Dailly. \r\n\r\nOK SNP, show us how different life would be in an indy Country. You have a responsibility to stand up for the most vulnerable. DO NOT LET US DOWN.\r\n\r\nYOUR ACTIONS WILL BE REMEMBERED IN 2014.17302013-02-19T12:22:58.3271724Alexander LoughWe who live in the East Lammermuirs have enough as it is,what with the turbines and a massive landfill site thats only half a mile from our village INNERWICK.\r\nThen we have the cement works destroying the land along the coast from Whitesands to the DRYBURN near Skateraw.\r\nWe were never consulted about these plans,there was no consideration or openness,all done by stealth and circumvention and corruption.17372013-02-19T12:29:27.161725Rob Allan, EdinburghThats the Tories for you.17302013-02-19T12:39:39.8731726Mrs Helen CarstairsThis is the most ill thought out policy any government has introduced\r\n17302013-02-19T14:00:43.871727andrea cairdpeople are givin houses that a required for there needs and family sizes. children grow fly the nest. this tax is unfair 17302013-02-19T14:04:46.751728Lucy GraywoollfIf the govt chose to peruse say the Edindex (Key to Choice) Housing Guide provided free in the Evening News each Monday evening or pick up a copy of the above guide in all libraries within the Edinburgh region he and his Tory chums would realise the ONLY one bedroom flats and houses automatically are ALLOCATED to tenants aged 60 and over (on a few occasions they have reduced the deficit by 10 years). In other words an individual can be 50 years of age and apply for the above one bed property. However this does NOT mean they will be granted the exchange! What of the other age groups who own insufficient criteria in which to apply for a one bed flat? What do they do? Cameron does not care! He's swanning it in Delhi discussing 'cyber crime' what next!17302013-02-19T14:35:19.11730John MulhollandThe eviction of tenants due to arrears in the vast majority of cases is simply wrong the eviction of tenants due to size reduction is immoral17302013-02-19T14:37:01.4231731Annamarie Theresa CauserIf Cameron and his Tory chums chose to peruse the (reduced to fewer every week) available properties advertised in every local Housing guide throughout Scotland and England HE and THEY would come to realise, if it sinks in of course, there are NO 1 bedroom properties on the housing tenant 'market.' The few available are ONLY for 60 years old and in the upwards age group! Very occasionally they reduce the age gap by 10 years (to 50 years) but more often than not it is individuals who earn pension credits and pensions who are applicable for 1 bedroom flats and single story sheltered housing! ! What happens then to every other age group then? 18-59 year olds? 17302013-02-19T15:02:01.61732frances kimmetthis is an unfair tax because of the housing situation there is no houses available for people who wish to downsize, so they will be taxed on this through no fault of their own which is another reason why it is an unfair tax17302013-02-19T15:09:47.0171733Anna RossSo what about the grannies on housing, will they no longer have a room for their grandkids? And what about those that are unfit to share? And how do you plan to re-house all those currently living in a 2 bedroomed flat with a 1 bedroom when there is a shortage of 1 beds? Another example of Tory ineptitude as a result of being completely removed from the normal population! 17302013-02-19T15:33:05.081734Dave I will be voting Yes in 2014 , if the SNP take this petition and put it into action and also scrap the Spare Bedroom Tax as they have promised to do ! 17302013-02-19T15:40:24.7031735Donna Clarkonly the torries could come up with this .Just because families grow up & set up there own houses does not mean that they never need to go back home plus sometimes it can be ill health & you need a family member to look after you if you don't have it you can't help them then the state needs too 17302013-02-19T16:03:441736fionaR the government going to compensate the people that r overcrowded or that have a son and daughter in the same room. I bet not.17302013-02-19T16:10:26.2831737Ann Marie RichardsPeople have asking for smaller houses and being told there is none.....how can tax someone for the extra room they don't even want!! 17302013-02-19T16:15:10.3771738John Wilson Thought up and brought forth by people that never have and never will need to live in social housing. The Tories are more out of touch than ever!17302013-02-19T16:16:54.4071739neil mackayvote yes for independence and you will never have a tory goverment again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!17302013-02-19T16:52:21.661740gerry kaneif we do nothing about it the tories will introduce the tax and the low paid will suffer.17302013-02-19T17:03:04.051741fionaThis tax is disgusting, i work with the elderly and i know several of them are sat in large houses they no longer want to be in because they are too big, they are begging their local authority for a smaller house and are being told there is'nt any, so these people are going to be penalised through no fault of their own, while struggling to live now. I have happily signed the petition not just for them but for all of us, if we let the government get away with this whats going to be taxed next. We have to stay united.17302013-02-19T17:38:38.2871742Heather MackintoshIt's the most ill thought out policy in a long time and that's saying something. It's more to do with the situation in London, but everyone is being penalised. Absolutely shocking. It targets the most vulnerable, once again.17302013-02-19T17:47:53.7571743G.williamsonwhen i was first on the housing list i kept getting given 2 and 3 bedroom flats as there was no one bedroom flat's .. thats not my fault yet i'd lose out 17302013-02-19T17:50:59.631744Pat WardIf they want me to live in one room they can send me to jail cos I ain't paying. Jail would be great, no rent, free food, no bills and visits twice a week. That'll do me.\r\n17302013-02-19T18:17:45.1771745Tam LairdJust,,disgusted.....17302013-02-19T19:25:56.9671746david nelsonevery person thats to pay this tax should get the addresses of every tory and lib dem mp and councillor and send them letters of petition,telling them that you will be campainging to vote them out at the first available election if they dont reverse this tax,come back robin hood and guy falkes we need you . 17302013-02-19T20:12:15.5071748Eileen McMurrayTime to fight back people....17302013-02-19T20:18:36.8731749Marie NapierI have lived in my house and been part of the community for over 20 years, I now have to be shipped out to who knows where...what is this country coming to??????????????????17302013-02-19T20:22:31.6471750Patricia TaylorThis proposed tax beggars belief and is leaving people who are already on the breadline with the added worry of how they will fund this extra expense. Most have no choice in where they live and local housing associations do not have smaller properties to rent. It is an unfair tax on our poorest and most vulnerable.........NOT FAIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!17302013-02-19T20:34:07.7831751Jennifer BroadhurstThis doesn't affect me or my family but it is very important that we understand that the reason for this problem reaching us in Scotland is in response to a London problem of rogue landlords raising rents to a ridiculous level and profiteering from the welfare state. Instead of this tax on the poor and vulnerable in social housing we should be addressing the issue of landlords raising rents above reasonable levels17302013-02-19T20:34:40.361752Eddie CassidyDon't forget it's the caring Lib Dems that are doing this to the neediest in our country.17302013-02-19T21:03:06.1771753John GrantAn immoral, harsh and insensitive policy by the Tory led coalition government, let's get them out at the next election.17302013-02-19T21:13:55.5971754Mark Destrymany people will be unknowingly affected by this legislation. i work in the welfare rights sector and people are still shocked when presented with this information! the DWP and local councils are still pursuing their policy of non-disclosure! 17302013-02-19T21:20:31.4771755Andrew MalcolmNew poll tax on the poor 17302013-02-19T21:24:51.4031756JamesThis is another reason why I believe that Scotland should be an independent country. 17302013-02-19T21:29:10.2431757margaret beananother tax on the poor,build more social housing then people may want to move from a house that is now too big for them.Sometimes your home is the only secure thing in your life.17302013-02-19T21:47:52.1931758Karen peuthererThis tax is ludicrous and unfair 17302013-02-19T21:55:37.5171759tammike dailly is a hero17302013-02-19T21:57:44.7571760bernadette skivingtonits a disgrace people will be home less and what are you going to do with the children a and elderly when parents and elderly people fall back in paying their rent17302013-02-19T22:00:06.61761bernadette skivingtondisgusting why is the queen being allowed to live in a place while tax payers are paying for it get her to pay for her rooms as well 17302013-02-19T22:07:08.591762theresa beattie i think this will lead to many children suffering and i for one am sick of yhe way this goverment attacks the poor and the workers these ppl are in power because the working class put them there time to grow a back bone and go after the rich . ppl will lose their homes because of this 17302013-02-19T22:10:11.5431763allan thomsonsick to death of living under english rule17302013-02-19T22:19:15.3531764kgraytax the rich not the vulnerable in society. Cameron & Co have to go17302013-02-19T22:30:33.51765LesleyIn a house with 2 'spare' bedrooms, not gonna be able to afford to live in it but will struggle to afford to leave it as well. Very few 2 bedroom places left in the area I want to live in. Either been sold or created into homeless flats. 17302013-02-19T22:34:26.061766Donald MacmillanWe have to stand up as a nation and reject this outrageous idea17302013-02-19T22:49:46.2171767lindawhy don't they reduce the wages of the prime minister and his cronies and charge them mansion tax and charge the queen for all the bedrooms she doesn't need or let homeless people use them!!!!!!!\r\n17302013-02-19T22:55:29.4671768Brian HLet's not forget David Cameron's mortgage claims of 2005-06 from taxpayers of £21,293.86.\r\nAssuming average of £12 per week "bedroom tax," would allow David to continue his tenancy in under-occupied home for approximately 174 years.\r\nWe live in a very unfair society....\r\nEach and every Westminster MP should have "fallen on their sword" when found to overclaim their generous expenses.17302013-02-19T22:57:00.3271769Drew RichardsonThis tax is wrong and ill thought out. It shouldn't be enacted.17302013-02-19T23:09:32.9471770Kathie Bergthink it is very unfair some people have been in their "homes" since birth or from a bery young age and their parents probarly paid enough rent on these "homes" to pay for it 10 times over and they are being punished because they dont have jobs what kind of a goverment can do this 17302013-02-19T23:28:20.2571771Graham LangmuirThe only escape from this Westminster govt is independence - Vote YES in 2014.17302013-02-19T23:43:32.1631772linda strachanSometimes, hard working, decent people find themselves in circumstances beyond their control and have to make the choice.......do I feed my family or pay the rent? People HAVE to eat......nuff said. Give help to people at home before we send billions in foreign aid.17302013-02-20T00:21:27.5431773Thomas HarveyThis is yet another tax directed at the poorer sector of society, why dont the rich and wealthy just honestly pay their rightfull taxes instead of dodging the tax and projecting the responsibility on to the poor.17302013-02-20T01:17:16.6471774rosemary thomsoni am disabled and my husband is my carer and my sleep pattern is out of this world so we need two bedrooms are you thinking about the hardship this tax is going to cause17302013-02-20T01:50:53.161775Mrs J MenziesMy mum has already downsized from a 3 bedroom to a 2 because she understands people are waiting on houses with kids, but she has 2 to allow her grandchildren \r\nto come visit and stay with her overnight. Must she be deprived of this too. It's bad enough that she's losing her heating allowance as its been scrapped as well. Is t it about time we looked after our own instead of making life harder for them in their old age. 17302013-02-20T02:41:51.0031776Simon Peter MacaulaySuch a poorly conceived policy made with no regard, let's hope the Scottish government can mitigate some of this Tory madness!17302013-02-20T07:58:50.281777Mr steven hamiltonGovernment gone crazy again17302013-02-20T09:10:27.721778George MatthewsAll the people that can see the wind farm should be notified17372013-02-20T09:23:08.521779Paul LeslieThis is a most divisive tax on people and will split family units. How awful it would be to see people who are not prepared to move from their homes rounded up and shifted into hotels and hostels. There is a shortage of smaller accommodation. It is also unfair on young people ( boys & girls ) having to sleep in a same room. LIke most coalition policies this has been poorly thought out and there will have to be another U turn! 17302013-02-20T09:33:13.0671780hannah mackiePeople shouldnt have to pay extra, david cameron doesnt! !!17302013-02-20T10:36:29.8531781stewartwe should not have a government as we have a royal family ??????????17302013-02-20T10:40:14.8971782David KirkwoodIt is just another tax on the poor17302013-02-20T10:46:45.9731783Suzanne McCash Boys and girls being expected to share up to the age of 8 while their is another room that then will then be taxed !! It seems like madness to me.17302013-02-20T11:32:10.051784colin warnockIts disgusting that the Scottish government are willing to this to fellow Scots,where would the point be of home rule when we are just going to end up with the same type of treatment that Scotland and the Scots have been put under by an English Government....Money grabbing where they can instead of positive changes.Fair to say that if this goes through,all the monies will disappear to Edinburgh and not used for ant type of improvement ,not een in housing.....You the Scottish Government should hang your head in shame.17302013-02-20T12:07:46.4131785John B BushnellTory plus liberal equal Monsters17302013-02-20T12:31:03.831786Simon Peter MacaulayHey there Colin, unless I'm mistaken the 'bedroom tax' is not a devolved matter and is coming from the dark heart of Westminster. Perhaps a good argument for further devolution or Independence?17302013-02-20T14:01:36.5031787maggie smithi work for the government and need my extra bedroom to do my job and still i have t go cap in hand to ask for a discretionary payment allowing me to continue my job???\r\n17302013-02-20T14:07:10.9171788Michelle CallachanAgain this is a tax soley aimed at the poorest in our society. I have 2 daughters who live with me and a 7 year old stepson who stays with me every Wednesday and every 2nd weekend. Should he be sleeping on the floor of my daughters' bedroom? Outraged.17302013-02-20T14:19:36.9871789Gary FraserI smell a revolution! oh no its just the smell of the camp fire im having to feed the kids from now we will be living in a tent, it has 3 rooms no dowt get a tentroom tax next.17302013-02-20T14:40:49.9771790lynn mcmillani think its rediculous what the government is doing to the families on a low income.17302013-02-20T15:28:50.0171791colin coupar just another way to rob people that can't afford it17302013-02-20T15:43:49.8131792Marie McDonaldThis is the worse government we have ever had how can they bring this bedroom tax in when they put all these people in houses with more than 1 bedroom in the first place also as per usual it will affect all the wrong people 17302013-02-20T15:45:21.8431793John NisbetThere are not enough one bedroom flats in the country for people to downsize.17302013-02-20T15:54:55.171795David RedpathExactly the type of thing we should expect from a Govt akin to the top table at Eton. Pathetically out of touch to the point of discriminatory to the less well off. Their attitude to the working class is an absolute disgrace.17302013-02-20T16:05:26.7271796bill oneill and Harley Guide Dog would some 1 tell me where is the glasgow demo leaving from thanks Harley guide dog 17302013-02-20T16:20:44.0171797mrs sandra coxNo to bedroom tax unfair on most vulnerable17302013-02-20T16:30:10.741798Mike RoseThe deferment of the 2015 Revaluation will cause increased distortion and unfairness in the rating tax base. The combination of the revaluation deferment and the Court's recent decisions to effectively truncate ratepayers' rights of appeal between revaluations would be unacceptable at any time but is particularly inappropriate at the present time when the lack of relief from excessive assessments and liabilities, based on pre recession property values, is driving many businesses to failure and choking any fresh tenant demand. \r\nIf the Government wishes to stimulate growth it should provide a rating framework which allows the fluidity of the commercial property market to be properly refected in rateable values and rate liabilities. 17172013-02-20T16:30:37.061799catherine mcleani hope those mps who recieve expenses for their second homes rent, are also going to pay for any extra rooms they may have out of their own pockets, they can afford to pay it with the money they made when they sold the house or flat (then rented back), following the expences fiasco17302013-02-20T16:34:48.491800Mary Steel Scotlandnot enough smaller housing for people17302013-02-20T16:41:29.1931801Ricky SkinnerThis is pure madness.....to all the people we vote into power to represent us I emplore you....do not allow this to happen.......remember we vote you in and we can vote you out.......................17302013-02-20T16:42:04.351802Mahrione word it's a "JOKE"!!!!!17302013-02-20T17:05:11.11803Thomas LynchThis ( Unbelievable ) tax will create more hardship for people who are already strugglin' to make ends meet. What next, a window tax !!!17302013-02-20T17:06:05.7071804Sarah Ridiculous ...17302013-02-20T17:12:16.9371805Stacey MoonMy mum is going to suffer so bad with this...she is so ill and works all she can...this is making her so ill...make the rich pay...the poor are already suffering !!17302013-02-20T17:47:43.0631806George MartinThis tax is theft, you already pay for your house through rent, Cameron and his public school boys, should'nt get away with this, If we get Independance the Scottish Goverment will do away with this tax, I have this on good authority, Vote Yes and get rid of this of westminster,17302013-02-20T18:02:24.411807Kenneth CarmichaelI have 5 children and some have left home and 2 havent, but I want to be able to offer them a room or two to stay in if they wish to visit or if they need somewhere if things get awkward in their home lives.I dont want to be taxed on the basic right to give my family somewhere to stay if they need it17302013-02-20T18:14:14.3171808Les HunterI feel sorry for the English, Welsh and Northern Irish. Scotland has an answer to the rapacity of the Westminster government, vote YES in 2014!17302013-02-20T18:16:15.771809Bruce Allan SInclairMggie Thatcher revisited , Cmerons poll tax he and his rich cronnies should be utterly ashamed of themselves, poverty is returning to Brittain117302013-02-20T18:28:03.7571810Scot WallaceJust another example of a government trying to bleed this country dry. They are an absoloute disgrace.17302013-02-20T18:28:36.8631811GwenMy spare room is for my son in the forces how can i tell him he cant come home anymore as there is no room for him if we are forced to move17302013-02-20T18:43:42.6131812leeannethis is a joke, absolutely ridiculous!17302013-02-20T18:45:16.9271813Joanne MillerAm disabled and use my two rooms because of my illness its not right 17302013-02-20T18:45:37.661814Angela Doherty Your rent is charge by size so you are already pay regardles of its occupancy and for lots of people its not just a house its a home were they have raised a family and now having granchildren to stay lots of people would happly move to homes that are appropriate in room size for them but for others its about family andhaving that extra room and thats for them to beside not every can aford to buy there Homes lots have to rent and even at that a Home is were your heart is and that mite be a councle house .17302013-02-20T19:01:15.4271815Carol EnglishMansion Taxes!! Bring them on!\r\n17302013-02-20T19:06:02.0531816George McIrvineCamorons Bedroom Tax is the 21st century Thatcher's Poll Tax. The people must say NO to this !! 17302013-02-20T19:25:03.61817D P AllisonTalk about treading on the poor and vulnerable. You should be ashamed of yourselves. I thought Scotland and Britain were meant to be places of democracy,freedom, equality and inspiration. Apparently not. 17302013-02-20T19:30:00.2531818mark munroI will be directly affected by this.17302013-02-20T19:56:34.721819RichardHOPE WE CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE AND STOP THIS.17302013-02-20T19:59:32.7871820fiona mcmurraywe have already been waiting almost 7 years for a smaller house (we are in a 5 apt and are looking for 2 bed bungalow).only me and hubby left now and I have a feeling we will still be here in another 7 years.we are being penalised as well .FAIR I don't think so\r\n17302013-02-20T19:59:45.7671821Jennifer Johnston,This is terrible, not fair on all the people that have access to their kids, there not intitled to a room for them, to stay overnight. x x x 17302013-02-20T20:00:53.7871822James MitchellPlease amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001.17302013-02-20T20:01:43.0971823maureen mc curleyanother unfair change that will have devastating impact on those with limited incomes17302013-02-20T20:17:40.9931824Tony28 years i have lived in my house brought 3 kids up in a 2 bedroom house what they call the family home, now im sharing my spare room with my grandkids 10 of on a weekly basis, to now find if i want to keep this going i have to pay a tax on the empty room for which i am un-employed through no fault of mine, i do not intend to give up my house so i will have to pay the amount it is to keep my house, if the goverment past and present had acted more responsible to not creating the decifit that we have i might not be needing to pay the bedroom tax and all the other tax,s they plan to instil. typical every one looses except the rich, just my feelings.17302013-02-20T20:24:57.2471825Hazel LewryPenalising the poorest in society is just business as usual for Westminster and Tories.17302013-02-20T20:25:00.11826Barry RossThe Bedroom Tax should not be allowed17302013-02-20T20:29:55.261827AllisonThis is truly disgusting, what a nerve putting people out of their homes. I cannot believe the so called government is even considering such an appalling \r\nthing. They will need to build a vast amount of smaller houses and flats bearing in mind that it will on the whole be older people that will be getting evicted (no other word for it). So would it not make more sense to just build houses that people can actually afford instead of so called affordable housing which if we are honest no one can afford get a grip and look at what the housing situation really is\r\n 17302013-02-20T20:32:00.4171828G Somervillewe are already skint are they trying to put us out on the streets17302013-02-20T20:35:23.551829joan devlinsickening17302013-02-20T20:54:18.0271830david weircan someone tell me 2 things 1 why does this help anyone 2 who benifits from the most unfair tax off all time17302013-02-20T21:15:59.6431831John WelshHitting the poorer people again, people with disabilities will suffer, evictions will start when people cant scrape up the money to pay it because they are living on a shoestring already, not enough one bedroom houses to rehouse everyone with more than one room to move into. The old window tax springs to mind where the phrase "Daylight Robbery" was seemingly coined. Bedroom Tax should not come into force lest many shall suffer.17302013-02-20T21:18:26.0171832Laura What is the government thinking snp need to get the finger out just an other pole tax that the torys came out with, I'm a snp member and I fed up with the way they're working lately the better ship up or ship out 2014 better hurry up. If they think that waiting so they have a full term in government will do them any favours guess what it's not!! Scots, English, Welsh and Irish time we stood together and stop letting this government do what they want power is the people THE people R The power.. No more taxing the working class to fill the riches pocket!!!!17302013-02-20T21:29:16.5531833Alistair McCabeI want to inherit our family home we've lived in for near 60ys, under the BTAX I'll possibly be evicted. OVER MY DEAD BODY MR CAMERON17302013-02-20T21:31:14.5871834Lizzie StevensonAre we to be treated as cattle? Draining the soul out any form of community left in this country after the previous housing disaster when being born in a community stopped guaranteeing you a house in the same area, near friends and family and the wee old neighbours we grew up with. The Big Society? Nobody knows anyone living near them. Now this insult to people's dignity and memories - people's lives, our lives.. we do not count in this Big Society. You who might suffer and voted in this government, yer getting what ye deserve!17302013-02-20T21:39:56.791835TraceyGlasgow District Council doesnt have enough 1 bedroom houses to give people who are in 2 bedroom homes. This is so unfair as the only people this effects is the unemployed. So many people will become homeless due to the fact they wont be able to afford to pay this ridiculous tax. Come on folk its time to take a stand and tell this tory government its not on grrrrrrrrrrrr17302013-02-20T21:45:43.321836Anne GairThis Bedroom Tax should be unlawful and if it gets to go ahead it will take years to get all the cases seen to through the courts. What a headache this is going to turn into for everyone involved. Absolutely insane, this government hasn't a clue.17302013-02-20T21:52:40.071837Mrs. Jane McCaigI object to the proliferation of wind farms and ind turbines in Scotland17372013-02-20T22:11:35.7231838Neil TorranceDevelopers encourage applicants not to inform neighbours and submit proposals during the holidays. This leads to a lot of bad feeling in the affected communities. Proposals that do not include consultation with immediate neighbours should be thrown out immediately. This would end such practice immediately.17372013-02-20T23:35:09.271839William CraigWhat a mean-minded proposal by the Tories! It's short-sighted, at best, and shows a lack of understanding about ordinary people. Just like the Poll-tax.17302013-02-20T23:38:34.8071840David ChalmersWe voted for our Scottish government. Nobody voted in the current shower in parliament. They fiddled it between them. Lets hope our MSPs do the right thing. 17302013-02-20T23:50:41.631841Lisa elliottOnly had my council house 10 months orignally asked for 2 bedrooms but got 3 beds and 2 boys under 16, had the council around today ( I was out but my partner was in ) to discuss MY bedroom tax, I moved frm Scotland to newcastle but IF Scotland get there independence I have no second thoughts of heading back home, this torrie goverment are nothing but bk door theifs, this is there new poll tax with a clever name to try and disguise it17302013-02-21T00:01:49.7071842loubrutality by the tories again17302013-02-21T00:14:43.4971843susan jackPeople do not work all their days on the lowest wage available to try and make their houses etc nice for some stupid policy to be passed so that we can't afford to live in our homes and someone else will get all your nice fixtures and fittings and you will be left to start again in a home where you have no room to house your kids when they come home from colleges, armies or whatever! Their aren't enough 1 bed houses in the rent sector to moved to anyway so the lowest paid and the people on benefits will be pushed into debt and yet more poverty! A total farce!!!17302013-02-21T00:21:57.5971844elaine reidit a joke anything to keep yourself in a job 17302013-02-21T01:11:11.931846Stewart MacGregorthis is a disgraceful way for any government to treat people - worse for Scotland since we never voted for them - let Mundell and his allies pay a heavy price for this treachery17302013-02-21T02:58:56.991847johnSo mutch for the tories wanting fathers tobe more involved with their children.I have my son staying with me from sunday to wednesday since my divorce 13 years ago,but now i have to make a choice of taking in a lodger and not seeing my son , or having to find extra money to lt him sleep in his own room as a normal 15 year old boy should .17302013-02-21T03:10:14.0431848johnThere is no 1 bedroom houses available in the social sector,the only ones are in the private sector .It will be these landlords who will be making huge profits out of councils as they start to turn their ex council houses bought under thatcher into bedsits to maximise profits .17302013-02-21T06:29:23.7971849mary roywhy shoud we pay tax on our emty rooms. ive lived in my council house for 50 years. 17302013-02-21T09:11:47.2471850Tracy RoachDisgusting, the poll tax fiasco all over again!!!!!17302013-02-21T09:44:03.1031851Thomas JaapWhy are we allowing this to happen from a Tory government who is hell bent on taking us back to 18th century values and why is Scotland allowing this? David Cameron would you pay this COUNCIL tax because its not for people with their own house is it? Get this man out give us a government that works for the working people not the rich.17302013-02-21T09:56:58.091852Pat Carrolltypical condem move. let's make it look like the poll tax protests were a walk in the park!17302013-02-21T09:59:14.5871853Caroline CarberryDisgusting tories17302013-02-21T10:28:27.531854Sandra FlintIf the UK Gov. had a bit of spare room in their brains we would all be better off.\r\n17302013-02-21T10:29:13.7031855morrison young2014 cannot come quick enough. Your date with destiny SCOTLAND 17302013-02-21T10:38:27.891856christine mcghie i might live in england now but im scottish and proud of it and this bedroom tax is just another way to screw the poor again\r\n17302013-02-21T10:56:26.881857Brian M SmithThis will mean a reduced income for the poorest people of Skye as there are NO alternatives to the houses that the people already have. It seems to be just a way of reducing their income. Onceagain the remote parts of this country get hammered.17302013-02-21T11:10:15.171858Kenny BeatonThese cuts in transport links are sending the islands back to the dark ages.17552013-02-21T11:20:43.921859neil gallacherdoes that include damp rooms that you cant use? need to ask QC HOUSING17302013-02-21T11:46:34.4771860Stephen SmithDisgusting! This is just a reincarnation of the poll tax. The people of rural Scotland will be most affected by a Torie government they did not, and never have, voted for. 2014 cant come quick enough17302013-02-21T12:14:18.5571861jenniferutter disgrace! there are people out there that can find one bedroom flats due to the guarantor system. THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO CAN NOT AFFORD TO LOSE THEIR HOMES! FOR GOODNESS SAKE SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT MAKE THE BEDROOM TAX ILLEGAL!!! YOU HAVE THE POWER TO DO SO!! THERE ARE FAIRER ALTERNATIVES THAN THIS!!!17302013-02-21T13:16:26.9471862Robert DrummondStop this regressive tax before people come to harm because of it as I'm sure they will.17302013-02-21T14:07:58.1571863Lord Andrew D LochAccording to GHA 7,000 homes in Glasgow will have to pay the 'bedroom tax' myself included. Years ago the Government told local authories to make family homes. That's what they did, two, three, four bedroom houses.. they didn't make one bedroom houses. So if I did want to move, there are not enough, so people are stuck!\r\n\r\nCan't remember the actual figure but my LHO has 95 one bedroom but 595 two bedroom homes, I asked for a one bedroom and I was told that there weren't any to get and if there was one it would go to an OAP before me.\r\n17302013-02-21T15:22:22.0571864Robert J S ChristieWhat on earth are the Uist Councillors thinking of by cutting these life-line services? Certainly NOT their constituents.17552013-02-21T15:49:35.9031865josephine mcphailbedroom tax should be illegal17302013-02-21T16:03:36.1671866Tony ProbertYet again it shows how lifetime politicians have no idea what life is like on the street for millions of people.17302013-02-21T16:37:42.3531867Elaine When people find it hard to obtain paid work, why cut an essential service and make many people jobless, thus adding to the high unemployment situation. These flights are required for business, tourism, and social activity as well as work.17552013-02-21T16:37:49.3071868Roddy MacKayThese air links are a necessity in the islands. They are a lifeline service, to lose this service will not just save money, it will cost lives.17552013-02-21T16:41:14.5731870Stephen WIlsonHow could the council cut this lifeline air service??? This will impact on health, travel tourism and general commuting on the islands. Shocking decision. It will put the island back 40 years17552013-02-21T16:54:22.041871John MacKaySave a quid instead of saving a life! Shame on you all! Disgraceful decision to cut these flights.17552013-02-21T17:05:33.581872Tom McLaughlanThose who voted for these cuts should hang their heads iin shame.17552013-02-21T17:31:45.321873Kevin McCaldinWe were considering renting a cottage on North Uist for a week in summer. Not sure I would do it, if I have to go by car and ferry. 17552013-02-21T17:34:47.2571874Marie SavageHard to believe the Council would want to cut such an essential service.\r\n17552013-02-21T18:05:18.2431875Gillian HamillIt is totally outrageous that the council feel this service is not required. We should be building links between the islands - this will set us back decades! Not to mention the impact on jobs, tourism, business and social interaction! Absolutely Shocking! Time to take stock.........17552013-02-21T18:05:33.3671876Jannette BoydWe need this service17552013-02-21T18:06:37.7731877Iain MacdonaldCNES cutting transport links in remote island communities and at the same time cutting education provision in rural areas stinks of centralism. 17552013-02-21T18:55:34.61878Clifford MainI have been a Council tennant with Edinburgh Council for over 35 years and have lived in my current home for around 30 years, bringing up two children. I class this as my family home and feel disgusted that I am being forced to leave this house because someone has judged I am living in a house which is too big (three bedrooms) for myself and my wife. My two kids have grown up and have moved on. I have only just had an operation to have my Prostrate removed due to discovering I had Cancer. The extra stress of this 'bedroom tax' along with my recovery from the operation has really affected my home life. Yes I have three bedrooms, however due to my condition I now use a bedroom for myself and my wife uses another, as I need care either my Son or Daughter stay at the weekends in the 'spare' room to help with my care. Being forced to move has just added to the stress.17302013-02-21T19:11:57.2631879Jude RobinsonThese services are a lifeline to remote communities, these cuts will be paid for in lives, which should not be gambled with to meet cut back targets17552013-02-21T19:15:04.9471880JoanThis makes no sense at all. These flights are neccessary for people attending hospital, whether as a patient or visitor, tourism, business, meetings, visiting relatives in the other islands, or whatever. Not everyone has a car to make the ferry and overland journey. This decision will affect the elderly and frail more than any other group. To leave Barra without any flights is shocking. Goodness knows why they did this - what are they thinking they will get in return. They should at least explain why they did it. As a Uist person I find it shameful.17552013-02-21T19:21:38.5171881Roddy MacNeilWhy do you have to cut a lifeline service to many people that relay need it??? your not on please leave it alone.17552013-02-21T19:24:23.371882Colin GodfreyDestroying people17302013-02-21T19:34:28.611883Joe MacleodA dreadful decision. Any savings will be fairly insignificant (think legal fees, con com, gritting, schools etc,etc) while the consequences will run deep.17552013-02-21T19:38:29.6931884Michelle Davidson Please keep this flight so my friend can come visit me!!! 17552013-02-21T20:27:31.481886markgha are not being helpful at all to there tennents affected especialy the new regime in pollok17302013-02-21T20:28:21.5131887Dorothy MullenThis law will not have the intended effect while causing havoc in people's lives. My brother is disabled and must move because he has two bedrooms and cannot afford to pay the extra from his benefit. He has been offered a one bedroom apartment which will cost the taxpayer an extra 25%, this is ridiculous.17302013-02-21T20:30:32.1031888IzzyWe were surveyed some 6 years ago to determine size of house required for our needs. We got this two years ago, since moving in 4 kids have moved out. House now too big. On waiting list for smaller house in order to free up this one for a larger family. Given priority 1 for move but sadly no houses immediately available. Not our fault so why should we, like others be penalised. Does those who are over crowded get a rebate then!!!!!17302013-02-21T20:55:43.2531890fiona jenkins How could the council cut this lifeline air service??? This will impact on health, travel tourism and general commuting on the islands !!17552013-02-21T21:00:38.0271891Elizabeth TUPPERPlease don't cut off the subsidiary for flights to the islands of Scotland. They are such a beautiful part of our heritage and should be shared. 17552013-02-21T21:50:59.931892Donald MacKayBring back ring-fenced funding for this lifeline service. The council cannot be trusted to safeguard our interests. Shocking. 17552013-02-21T22:06:16.931893donna mairlike tommy said resistence is required17302013-02-21T22:25:53.61894fred tunnspread the word about this petition17302013-02-21T22:29:45.8031895Dave Surely this is discriminatory legislation on the grounds of Age , as it is targeted solely against Social Tenants of a certain age ! 17302013-02-21T22:38:45.3031896Patricia FergusonBedroom tax must be stopped! Politicians have no idea what it's like in the real world, most of them were born millionnaires!17302013-02-21T23:55:58.8731897Sandra Wallsdont bring these taxes to scotland.17302013-02-22T00:47:18.8371898margaret devlinThe bedroom tax is disgusting. Who are these WEE people who sit in a WEE room trying to think of ideas to get more money from the tax payers who are already paying too much tax. They are taxed on wages, taxed on clothing, taxed on certain foods, taxed on fuel, taxed on drink, taxed on cigs it seems like before long people will be working for nothing as it all goes on tax for the greedy greedy politicians and fat cats in this country17302013-02-22T01:26:14.1931899Sarah GundryTha na seirbhisean seo cho cudthromach do mhuinntir nan Eileanan Siar nach tuigidh mi riamh an aobhar a bhotadh a' Chomhairle an aghaidh nan tursan-adhair sin. 'S e deireas taod-teasairginn a th' ann, chan ann direach do thurasachd as t-samhradh is gach seorsa de mhalairt a tha cudthromach dhan eagonomaidh ionadail, ach na bu chudthromaiche builleach airson nan ceanglaichean eadar teaghlaichean is coimhearsnachdan. Chan eil seo na 70an nuair a dh'fhagadh daoine na h-eileanan airson foghlam is obair gus am na Nollaige. Tha fiughairean ura againn a tha gu tur iomachaidh airson amannan-nodha. Leis na chlaran-ama 2012, bha roghainn aig daoine a tha, no a aig a bheil teaghlach a tha a' fuireach ann air saileamh nan ceanglaichean-adhair, ach as an aonais bidh aca ri siubhail nas fhada air a' bhata, no amannan suimeil, m.e. mionadean mu dheireadh parant, a chall.\r\n\r\nTranslation:\r\nThese services are so important to the people of the Western Isles, that I’ll never understand why the Council voted against them. This is a loss of a lifeline, not just for tourism in the summer but for every type of trade that is vital to the local economy, but more importantly still for connections between families and communities. This isn’t the 70s when people had to leave the islands for work and education and could only return for Christmas. \r\n\r\nWe have higher expectations that are entirely appropriate for the modern world. With the 2012 timetables, people who live or have family in the islands, had a choice die to of the air links but without them, they will have to travel further on the ferry or to miss important moments e.g the final moments of a dying parent. (Moderator)17552013-02-22T03:51:35.641900D McMWe're getting penalised for being 3 generations of females in our house. We just got a (rotten with damp) house after being on the waiting list for years. We are actually overcrowded, but not according 'Thatchers new breed of children' in London. But this make the case for Indendence a winner... 17302013-02-22T04:10:58.1471901colin robertsonyet another tax on the poor and vulnerable did the tory party not learn from the shambles that was the poll tax?! and are these multi millionaires who live in 10 bedroomed mansions paying bedroom tax of course not absolute disgrace!! 17302013-02-22T07:06:38.571902AndrewCrazy idea to remove what has become an essential service to all surrounding communities17552013-02-22T07:08:05.8131903J brownThis tax is for people on benifit , why should we pay for this . I say get out and get a job pay your own way then you can have luxury of large house . 17302013-02-22T07:17:12.6671904Lorraine KieltyCameron and Clegg just prove that like Thatcher they do not care about people. This is not about saving money it's about feeding off the poorer people to supplement the fat cats 17302013-02-22T09:34:10.8531905Graham McLarenif i have to pay this tax i will not be able to heat my house and feed my self, wife and daughter properly. I am on job seekers allowance getting £21.50 weekly and my who is working 14 hrs per week only receives £89 week, my daughter is a student on a bursary. With gas electricity water charge food and mail order catalogue payments not including tv licence i find it very difficult to survive, add this tax and i will flounder.17302013-02-22T12:14:36.8271906William DuthieSooner we are in control of our own country the better17302013-02-22T15:32:07.51907J BellSpare bedroom is used as dining room. In open plan loung kitchen there is no room for table and chairs. Flat is really 2 bedroom not 3 as per housing association.17302013-02-22T16:26:19.31908J. R. MitchellAnother Tory idea not thought through that is going to cause mayhem and misery for hundreds if not thousands of families and unfortunate single people. 17302013-02-22T17:25:28.4131909Marion HeneghanSurely a lifeline for the islands.17552013-02-22T18:22:37.4731910Matthew RitchieCameron & Clegg risk alienating and discriminating against a considerable section of society by implementing this legislation. We in Scotland cannot accept this is the way we want to treat the most vulnerable in our country. We must fight against this and stand with those who might be facing eviction. This is Cameron's 'Poll Tax' moment. My only concern is that the fabric of our society might be compromised as a result. 17302013-02-22T18:27:54.3971912Kim O'BrienThis will cost jobs and facilities in the Uists17552013-02-22T19:11:39.5871913June Osborne I have worked since I left school and at 51yrs old am lucky enough to be still working. I am a single parent with 1 child still at school and I pay my Morgage which means I have to pay out for all my repairs and also pay out for dental and glasses. I pay my taxes to my country and have done for the last 35 yrs without a say in what it is spent on, I do not agree with this bedroom tax. I feel you's the government are trying very hard to destroy our country. Stop giving what I and billion of other people pay to other country's HELP Britain!!!! Please 17302013-02-22T20:08:12.011914cheryl young this will affect me and my disabled daughter spare room is used to store equipment and medical supply. and no one has a clue about this in the job centre, council or housing assocation. stressing me out 17302013-02-22T22:14:20.9171915leigh doherty I just think what is going on is a joke???the rich get richer n the poor suffer,aint fair at all!!!17302013-02-23T00:01:49.8571916Tommy CrocketPernicious! A crime against those in our society who are already downtrodden. Scotland is better than this.17302013-02-23T00:26:57.2031917Fiona GiddeyMaintain support and protection for all communities17552013-02-23T00:31:55.421918Alexander MacleanWhy pay taxes if they are not used to protect the community?17552013-02-23T10:30:56.5431919gina burkethis country is a joke,,if the government want to save money on housing,,why dont they start by cutting the 2nd home subsidy paid to mp,s,,its a total farce !!! what really riles me is the fact that out of the 29 mp,s who are the members of this governments cabinet,,23 are millionaires !!!,,,they do not have a clue about having to live on a budget....what,s the next thing they,ll start charging for ,,,,,, fresh air maybe ???...people should stand up to them\r\n17302013-02-23T10:35:36.2231920Roddie Lumsdenno wonder people commit suicide17302013-02-23T10:55:56.0671921JAMES MONAGHANDISGRACEFUL17302013-02-23T12:37:42.411922Alasdair CodonaTha sin cho ceart sa ghabhas: chan urrainn dhan a' chomhairle ceangal ri tir mor a ghearradh agus an uair sin duil a bhith aca ri taic bhon an riaghaltais airson ceanglaichean ri tir mor a ghleidheadh!\r\n\r\nTranslation:\r\n\r\nThat’s so true: the council can’t sever a link to the mainland and then expect support from the government to conserve links to the mainland!17552013-02-23T14:16:24.8131923angela chesneyThis is a crazy tax which is to me an infringement on peoples human rights. Someone living in council housing would need to move a number of times as their family grows changes etc. The housing is not always readily available for thos even willing to move.I'll give it a couple of years and it will be all change again once reality sets in.17302013-02-23T14:40:08.0671924johndont pay17302013-02-23T16:03:12.9871926Paul ReidThis is shameful by this Government of millionaires, I have two children of 5 and 6 which would mean they would be made to share a room, As it stands just now we have three bedrooms,1 for my wife and i,my 2 children in the other 2 rooms,there is no end to what this lot will do.17302013-02-23T16:51:49.281927mark fight it17302013-02-23T17:44:30.7871928cath mcmanusA cynical and shocking attack on people, many of whom are vulnerable. A "mansion tax" would be much more just.17302013-02-23T18:02:57.231929HelenI remember when I was a little girl in the early eighties ,watching a family being evicted from my street sherrifffs officers throwing all their wordly possesions over a veranda four floors up .It made me sick to my stomach even then ,and instilled in me a flame of fighting soacial injustice .I am the mum of a soldier and also a child with complex medical needs .I have been told I must pay for keeping a bed for my son and my 16 year old disabled child now has to share a room .Totally disgusting from a government full of inherited wealth.17302013-02-23T19:34:31.6031930Niall MacDougallThis tax won't wont affect me personaly...but it's down right disgusting for people that it does.Out with this Tax,and in with and Independent Scotland.17302013-02-23T20:23:31.2531931Ian MillerWindfarms look revolting and when seen in the distance they resemble untidy scrapyards.17372013-02-23T22:08:16.9471932Daniel MacLeanKeep the Barra to Benbecula and cut the stornoway to Benbecula to 1 flight instead of 2 empty flights and why not link Benbecula to Inverness and cut out stornoway altogether and save a fortune.17552013-02-23T22:20:50.0231934Duncan MacLeanThe council or the uist councillors who voted to do away with this service don't actually care about the decision they took, they don't care about the consequences, this could mean redundancies in the islands where employment is fragile and hard to come by. I'll bet the voters regret their decision now!!!!17552013-02-24T03:38:10.2671935Stefanie MackieRegardless of whether the residents are living off of benefits or working full time, all this is going to is create more debt, resulting in another round of recession that we are only just starting to come out of. The already poor will have to get high interest loans to subsidise their income in order to pay this tax , and why should they? We all know that this is going to benefit the already rich who own their homes and therefor have no worries. it makes me sick. This country's government seem to to be there for everyone but their own people and thety have the cheek to wonder why no one votes for them 17302013-02-24T09:45:27.1731936J.RobertsonWhy do conservative governments always hit the worse off in our society. They never have a social policy and have the attitude that if you are unable to work, either due to health or lack of jobs, you dont deserve anything from the more fortunate. They never mention the huge amount of grants that land owners receive which would be as much, if not more than the welfare budget. Like business, industry, the strongest asset are the people. What makes Britain great is the people, so why is this government determind to destroy that. Bring in the mansion tax and get that class of people paying.17302013-02-24T13:07:19.0271937Maree MacRaeStupidest Idea they have had to date. Never mind, looking at the unrest from this, I would say their time in government is over along with Lib Debs. Did they really think the people who voted them into power and who they are meant to be looking after would stand for this ludicrous change?17302013-02-24T14:42:44.0831938Robin BowdenI support the proposed amendment taking out a possible default "room tax" as a reason for eviction17302013-02-24T17:04:22.4771939Billy WoodsI am paying rates based on" boom time" turnover, during the greatest recession in my lifetime with no sign of recovery in the immediate future. This is putting my business under extreme pressure for survival but this government decides to extend this pressure by an extra 2 years!This short-sighted,arrogant stupidity will only serve to exacerbate an already unbearable burden. If this is an indication of what to expect in an independent Scotland I may as well file for bankruptcy now before the inevitable rush starts.17172013-02-24T18:15:14.2471940iain sutherlandi had to stop work just over 18 months ago i had to fight for a year before i got DLA still fighting to get ESA and now this 17302013-02-24T19:00:23.2771941Gary StewartThis does not make sense at all17552013-02-24T23:18:46.6731942doreen murraythey wont us all back in the workhouse to keep us in check\r\n17302013-02-25T01:26:44.6571943Ronald ChapmanI think the bedroom tax is disgusting and i am an pensioner with my wife and 18 year old son who special needs and my wfie is not british in fact we have had enough of this goeverment need to get david andclegg also obronse out now they are the worse in goverment in history as my wife cant get a job but this made her angry as she dont get extra help and she is now trying to get back home to usa and trying to get help with that and david mnick and george will not save anythign in the long run17302013-02-25T10:46:24.1631944melanie carrAlthough this bedroom tax does not affect me personally, I think it is a disgrace when people are already struggling with the budget living at the moment as it is. This is going to cause massive problems in an already broken society.17302013-02-25T14:11:55.0531945terry good on you govan law centre17302013-02-25T15:42:19.971947maggie carrThis is a total outrage, I will attend any demonstrations against this.17302013-02-25T18:49:01.641948Graham LangThe present neighbout notification process descriminates against rural dwellers like me who do not scrutinise the public notices in the local paper or have any access to planning application up dates. It is not fit for purpose and should be changed in lines with the petitioners recommendation17372013-02-25T18:53:21.0831949Marion LangThe present neighbour notification process is grossly unfair on country dwellers and those on the edge of communities who need to know about applications that would impact on their amenity but only find out when the development is permitted and commenced17372013-02-25T20:02:11.611950stevegreat that mike dailly and govan law centre are standing up for those who cant stand up for themselves. i applaud you17302013-02-25T20:48:14.541951Betty LyonA high number of benefit claimants have lost all benefits because of the unfair atos system how can they pay the bedroom tax when they can't feed themselves, heat a room never mind a home.? People will be homeless, there are few one bedroom flats, its not their fault councils put themin 2 bed flats, that's all there is we must stop this before someone dies17302013-02-25T23:15:22.491953yangthis terrible thing17302013-02-26T05:33:36.2631954Marisa sangiovanniGetting to the outer Hebrides is not easy. The FlyBe flight is amazing. It only takes an hour from Glasgow to barra. The alternative is a 6 hour ferry ride. Barra also is the only airport in the world that has its runway on the beach, that is amazing when you think how big the world is and how many airports there are!!! Many people who have a passion for aviation will travel on the twin otter aircraft just to land on the beach. It's an wonderful experience. Plus the people who live on the island need their flights as Barra is so remote. Before thinking of closing it down can one of you go and see just how lovely and wonderful it is to be able to land on the beach. Also because of the type of aircraft used they fly low so you get the most amazing view of Scotland. From a personal point of view Barra was the first place in Scotland I had ever visited, taking that flight and seeing the scenery has made me want to visit more of Scotland and I am sure it would be the same for other visitors to.\r\n\r\nPlease don't cancel the flights to and from Barra. Once again I urge you to visit and see what it is like coming into land on the beach . As I say it's the only airport in the world that does this and it's in Scotland!!!!!\r\n\r\n\r\nKind Regards\r\n\r\nMarisa sangiovanni17552013-02-26T08:19:52.2871955Kevin WalkerYet another immoral Tory Tax deigned to hit the less well off.While one top Tory minister claims £1600 a month on top of their considerable wages for a second home in London so they can commute to the house of commons from their first 1.8 million pound home .......however this minister only lives 19 miles away from the house of commons.That is enough money to keep 3 households from paying bedroom tax for a year.The sooner we are an INDEPENDENT COUNTRY the better.17302013-02-26T08:33:59.3371956Brian CarrollThe smug milionaires of the front bench of the UK government, making those who did not cause this crisis, pay for it - absolute disgrace. They are not prepared to have a Mansion Tax on the number of bedrooms a house has but are prepared to cut benefits for those who have 2. The sooner thIs lot are gone the better !17302013-02-26T08:46:40.291957chrisshocking17302013-02-26T09:52:16.4271958Jeanne GrantThe 'bedroom tax' is particularly unfair in the Highlands and Islands, where unemployment (causing young people to leave) and then having to travel long distances home mean that family members need to stay the night when visiting and need a room. Most people's children study and work away from home. My son works at sea. What provision is there for needling a family room in these cases?17302013-02-26T14:35:13.0231959johnplease spread the word of how brutal this tax is please people17302013-02-26T16:47:37.231960Salim ShukisI think it is sick how these politicians are mugging my brothers and sisters ,, we will rise against them 17302013-02-26T18:41:54.4731961greeta v longtaili do not think that the cuts we are told we must make should start with the least able to afford them.... when the bill starts to rise for the mistakes this govt. is making it scapegoats anyone we allow it to ....say no... tell your mp you will never again vote for anyone helping to implement this vicious tax\r\n17302013-02-26T20:51:22.4331962micheal richardspoll tax was defeated lets do the same with this because its simply unjust..17302013-02-26T21:04:05.121963charliehow many spare bedrooms do the cabinet have between them?17302013-02-26T21:24:29.2371964seanjoin the pratest on the 30th of march in glasgow17302013-02-26T21:26:27.3331965sean where and what time is the protest?17302013-02-26T21:41:33.1131966Colin SmythToday, even the Tory led Dumfries and Galloway Council backed the Labour's Groups 21 recommendations to help local residents mitigate as far as possible against the damage that be caused by the Welfare Reform Act, including working with local Social Landlords towards a no eviction due to the bedroom tax policy and to receive a report to the Welfare Reform Working Group on this excellent proposal to amend the Housing Act. Hopefully they will see sense and get behind this campaign when they read that report. 17302013-02-26T21:46:38.7571967brian hutchisonit is time people of this country brought this torylibdem government to there knees with this and then the dla reforms they are a joke17302013-02-27T06:41:43.1371968Mary LommersThis is a very necessary service for the people of the Western Isles17552013-02-27T09:00:06.4571969Kevin PatersonThis is a direct attack on the low paid, the disabled and the unemployed. We cannot allow it to happen. Fight the evictions and fight the bedroom tax.17302013-02-27T09:10:06.0331970tamthe queen has hundreds of spare bedrooms17302013-02-27T10:02:09.021971Karen Boyd To cease this service would be total madness!17552013-02-27T10:40:16.2231972MoThis is a direct attack on people with low incomes who are already struggling to make ends meet17302013-02-27T10:45:39.3671973Joanne WakeleyAs there is insufficient single-bedroom social housing available for those unable to afford their existing properties to downsize into, they will be forced to look to the private sector. As renting privately is typically more expensive than renting from a social landlord, even when the smaller property size is taken into account, and those who do move into properties without spare rooms may then be entitled to full housing benefit, I am not convinced that there will be a significant saving, if any. 17302013-02-27T12:09:40.6831974Emma StewartI think neighbout notification should also be given if your boundary abuts the land boundary that the wind turbine site is located on regardless of the distance from the actual turbine(s) site.17372013-02-27T12:10:54.8071975Estelle ForresterThe delay in revaluing the Rateable Values as scheduled in 2015 prevents a correction to be established between locations. High Streets will be further disadvantaged as the effect of rental reductions are not reflected across Business Rates. In some locations the rates are higher than the rent preventing investment into these locations with retailers moving out both national and local. The UK is already preceived to be one of the most expensive retail locations in the world and rates is always flagged up by international retailers who acquire more units abroad as a result. Also the banding on incentivised rates is way too low to have any effect on retail as very few decent shops lie withing the banding of £10,000 and £18,000pa. These bandings need widened to support independant retail. Tax out of town more using a higher UBR and have tighter time scales for rates appeals as retailers go bust before the appeals are even processed.17172013-02-27T13:23:42.351976jane rosswhy would a well off person with no financial worries want to make the less well off have no home? vote this goverment out17302013-02-27T14:28:01.5271977P beagleyThe deferment of the 2015 Revaluation will cause increased distortion and unfairness in the rating tax base. The combination of the revaluation deferment and the Court's recent decisions to effectively truncate ratepayers' rights of appeal between revaluations would be unacceptable at any time but is particularly inappropriate at the present time when the lack of relief from excessive assessments and liabilities, based on pre recession property values, is driving many businesses to failure and choking any fresh tenant demand. If the Government wishes to stimulate growth it should provide a rating framework which allows the fluidity of the commercial property market to be properly refected in rateable values and rate liabilities.17172013-02-27T20:05:01.351979Stewart ConnorIsland life is fragile enough without removing essential transport links 17552013-02-27T20:16:45.031980StefanMaybe Independence is the way to go in Scotland as there is no way Alex salmond or the Scottish Government would do this to there people rich or poor.. Its a total disgrace17302013-02-27T20:52:48.141983MaryThankyou for all you are doing. x17302013-02-27T22:32:04.8271985jim hutchisonhas anyone calculated the bed room tax costs for the queen \r\n17302013-02-27T22:33:42.051986Derek ElderThere might be be a possible defence for this policy if there were sufficient and varied social rented housing stock in each area. There isn't, so there isn't.17302013-02-27T23:02:35.4771987margaret thomsonits a disgrace what they r doin 2 this country .17302013-02-27T23:34:58.871988isobelif we all stick together then maybe we can do something i for one will be joining the rally i cannot afford to pay this tax and if i do i will have to sacrafice either food or heat and light to pay it as would many many folk across britain.I hope to get other people from fife to join me17302013-02-28T07:38:05.041990MR ANGRYThis is going to cause a lot of heartache. What about someone who has over the years done a lot to their council house and because of a few years unemployment they will have to give it all up? Once a job becomes available they may have lost a home17302013-02-28T12:56:19.331991bryan jonesplease can someone tell me when the protast is in glasgow17302013-02-28T14:28:51.0931992Christine Dumonceauit is shocking that because i have a spare bedroom while on benefit i must pay rent. The people who have huge mansions can live so well. i did not cause the economic crash, i live a very simple life, with no credit cards, no holidays abroad, no fancy clothes, i will have to live on 50 pounds a week, and during the winter give up heating the house, live on candles, the pets will no longer be able to go to the vet when needed. i will have to stop using the electricity and eat only cold! Off with the bus, in with walking and cycling, whatever the mileage to cover.I,m asthmatic, this is going to be fine during the summer months when its dry, but mad over the winter.I suffer of depression pretty bad, the stress and worries, the deprivations will cause more health problems that the N.H.S will have to bear! I will have to get rid of the cats so someone else will have to bear that too! The state is ruining all the hard work that i have put in to regain my health in a winner, for what? so that cameron can live with his mansions, and what do we have a scottish parliament for anyway if it can and won't fight for social justice, honest logical politics!How is creating more poverty and human suffering going to help the economy and the country and its reputation abroad? Its beyond me! beacaus fear not i will talk to all my folks and friends abroad, what is the U.K going to look like?17302013-02-28T14:58:07.141993phil think the 30th of march but not 100percent sure17302013-02-28T15:55:10.3931994Gareth BrownThis attack on the poor, disabled and vulnerable must be stopped.17302013-02-28T21:59:24.661995Colin BrooksThis doesn't affect me personally, but it affects many of my family and friends. Just another form of raising their rent, but why do it in such a fashion? Seems to me they're covering something else up, as you watch the left the right is up to something else!17302013-02-28T22:09:35.131996BrooksyThis "tax" doesn't affect me personally, but it affects many of my family and friends. Causing lots of fear and alarm, and all for an underhanded way to bring in a rent rise. Makes you wonder what they're covering up when people are focusing on this!!!17302013-02-28T22:17:19.671997Marion MacNeilIt is often easier to look at the negative and in this case, the 'lack of users' on this route. But if more thought was given to the positive aspects, the opportunities far out weigh the negative and we need to focus on retaining this service to maximise this to the benefit of the islanders. 17552013-02-28T22:22:02.311998Ann Marie HowieAbsolutely disgraceful. Cameron and his cronies should be totally ashamed of themselves!\r\n17302013-02-28T22:23:25.311999helen hamilton wonder when they will tax the air we breathe?17302013-02-28T22:31:14.922000alan mcgrawi urge people not to just accept this.17302013-02-28T23:00:46.6072001Kenneth HoodProper public consultation should be mandatory of all wind turbine applications or a minimum 2km from property recommendation made mandatory!17372013-02-28T23:07:30.5972002margaret connellyi have two disabled sisters they have to have 24hrs a day care and carers stay every night.17302013-02-28T23:49:29.0872003George McCarronThe Glasgow protest is 30th March, 11am George Square, as far as I know. This bedroom poll tax needs to be stopped.17302013-03-01T00:28:40.3532004John morrisonThis is essential to the island come and live here for a while and tell us what we don't know then 17552013-03-01T01:00:18.2632005MazzIsland life is penalised just because we live on an island. Why punish us more?! Absolutely ridiculous idea and typical for the southern isles (anywhere south of Lewis) of the Western Isles to get hit the hardest. Total disgrace and huge disappointment. This should not be allowed to happen!! Save the inter island flights!!17552013-03-01T01:17:38.822006Donald MacKayA shocking betrayal.17552013-03-01T07:12:27.9072007Billy MartinYet another stealth tax being brought in by the Millionaire Torys that will cause financial and physical heartache to those who can least afford it. Cameron obviously has forgotten what we, The Scottish people, did to Thatcher. Remember we will have the chance to break the shackles that tie us to Engerland next year. Vote yes for FREEDOM. 17302013-03-01T08:14:06.4772008Ellen BramwellThis service is badly needed in the islands and is worth subsidising and saving!17552013-03-01T09:46:36.1272009Denise HuttonI find it disgusting that yet again Westminister is punishing Scots as is the usual, they continually hit the poorest of people and dont care about the stress they will put families under, please stop this going threw it is appalling.\r\n17302013-03-01T11:10:22.7532010Matthew Ronaldson Under occupied if mum has kids 4 days and dad 3 mum gets child benefit and is viewed as main Carer, dad squeezes 3 kids into one bedroom but dads house is under occupied?? The government are victimising separated family's and singling out dad in that, I'm not a scrounger I work but don't earn enough to not clam housing benefit, therefor get pinned for an extra 14% oh and they increase the rent, in April my rent will be twice what it is in March, guess my kids will get nothing when they come to dads, \r\nBang out of order infringement of human rights, 17302013-03-01T11:53:12.292011Karin KaneThis would cause chaos for everyone. 17302013-03-01T12:14:23.3032012Linda fawkesI'm in total disgust that the most vulnerable are being targeted Again!! Mr Cameron and his ivory towered camp will reap what they sow! I pray their conscience torments them! 17302013-03-01T12:14:35.0872013Elaine HallAusterity does not work, They should be after the Bankers who caused this in the first place , They must have known the bubble would burst and what these greedy buggers were up to, Sick , disabled ,unemployed have to pay the price, This crude tax will indeed cause hardship drive more people into poverty. Children who suffer most here what happens when there is not enough food and not lets forget heating bills, CHILDREN today are tomorrows future or have goverment forgot that? 17302013-03-01T12:34:15.2572014Duncan SmithIf another Westminster Tory government under Thatcher hadn't let councils sell off stock without provisions being made to build more to replace them then there would be enough housing to go around.17302013-03-01T12:55:53.3432015David A.My friend is affected by this tax. His housing association only do two bedroom flats. He does not have any housing points for any other area. The points he does have are for his area only - but they don't have one bedroom flats. Ever felt your just going around in circles?17302013-03-01T13:18:46.492016sophie eptonThere is no need for this tax anywhere, its cruel and unfair, we all have more than enough to struggle with , without things being made worse..17302013-03-01T13:30:23.8632017Elizabeth Richards Disgusting 17302013-03-01T13:57:16.0532018JohnThis would devastate loads of families including me and my 2 boys aged 6 and 8 pure greed. We are paying the price for the banks mistakes not happy about this at all 17302013-03-01T14:22:52.1072019MariaHuge benefit!17622013-03-01T14:40:04.7732020J.A. BradyThis is such a cruel, and crude device to supposedly 'save' money, while bankers continue to live high on the hog and whine about lower bonuses. Two different worlds ...17302013-03-01T15:04:17.0872021Darryl BainMy Scottish bretheren, rid yourself of the Saxe Coburg Gothas and become independent once again. Don't let some group of snotty nosed English 'ahem' nobility make decisions that adversly affect you and your standard of living. ET ARTE ET MARTE !!\r\n17302013-03-01T15:11:03.222022Bob HowieDespicable tax, shows just how stupid Labour and Con-Dems are as they think this is going to save money. It is going to cost more money because it will force people to seek advice and apply for DHP which all takes time and money. If you want to find how to save money, ask the SNP they do a good job with the universal benefits because they know that is cheaper than Means Testing.\r\nThis was done to stop the problem in London but it affects people around the country and mainly disabled and jobless but worse than that it greatly affects disabled who are jobless because the Con-Dems closed Remploy.17302013-03-01T15:28:44.4072023Martin LambLet's get connected!17622013-03-01T17:04:43.1072024patfight the tories17302013-03-01T18:58:22.292025GEOFF REYNOLDSPOOR MANS CASTLE, RICH MANS TORTURE...17302013-03-01T19:01:40.252026E.D'......Shocking!17552013-03-01T21:35:57.1432027John BellNO to the Bedroom and NO to evictions through this unfair tax.By any means necessary.17302013-03-01T22:21:39.9672028Heidi McLeanThis can and does save lives,why on earth would you decide to withdraw these services.Oh yes money just goes to show what a human life is worth now?.....17552013-03-01T22:48:59.6832029Jamie McIntoshI do not mind 50 minutes on the 'plane.17552013-03-01T22:50:17.872030rod fight it17302013-03-01T22:59:34.62031Ro BellThis is an act of wickedness and an attack on the poor. We subsidise the rich who have a spare house and punish the poor for having a spare room.17302013-03-02T10:34:59.3232032Fiona Macdonald This is a savage attack on the poorest and less fortunate in society. It is an explicit illustration of everything that is wrong with our society, where the vulnerable are hounded whilst the rich lifestyles become more extravagant. 17302013-03-02T12:06:29.3972033Marie MacraeStop this cruel and greedy madness!!!!!!17302013-03-02T12:07:29.2132035William BeebyYet another tax which hits the poor the most . All in it together are we ? I dont think so do you ?17302013-03-02T12:11:50.412036Alistair MorrisonNative of South Uist. This service is imperative for the Islanders.Cutting this service will definatley cost lives, can you live with that??17552013-03-02T13:45:05.822037dawn Please stop the Bedroom Tax for Scottishpeople17302013-03-02T15:12:40.8572038Peter MabonUnfair that the poorest in society are being hit by this.\r\nWhile the rich get tax cuts.17302013-03-02T15:57:47.9472039DAVIE ANDERSONAnother version of the POLL TAX.....and we all know what happened to the Tories after that....how can they evict people that have stayed in their houses for years because they have a spare room that perhaps gets used at weekends for kids whos parents have split up....or for disabled people who need seperate rooms....totally unfair tax on the poor again.....17302013-03-02T16:18:38.082040Isobel-Anne LogueIt is ridiculous decent people who work hard and have too to make ends meet and live a comfortable life are being punished yet again and the workshy scroungers of this country are getting their rebate in their hand supposedly to pay the rent, duh waken up dont think that will ever happen17302013-03-02T17:58:22.9772041paulalets stick together and fight this17302013-03-02T19:49:39.5472042michelle coxonThis is not only pretty pathetic, but greedy, and no more. This will hit many many families, including my own. Iam on benefits and have mental health issues, I live with my two daughters (both over 16) who try every day for jobs that they are over qualified for, but there's just too many people going for the same Job, so they only ever have temporary jobs. They cannot afford to pay this, I already can't afford to heat my home let alone pay this. I need my daughters living with me for support, but the thing that really angers me is that we will be split up, when the government says so, not when they can afford to leave home, our family will be torn apart on 'their' terms! Its a disgrace. I was against an independant Scotland but now I'm all for, I wished we had nothing to do with the English goverment whatsoever, they must know this is going to cost the country a lot more in the long run? Grrrr, I'd love just 10mins with cameron!!!!17302013-03-02T20:34:55.5232043athair siochainTheir is one underlying factor, all politicians around the world collect rent, this tells us that they are not the friend of tenants, words will not stop them, we need to end their rule power over humanity, they are no better than bed bugs.17302013-03-02T20:57:57.0032044mark steeleHow can these tories do this when they are spending\r\n£25 billion on nukes each year as well as giving the rich tax cuts.17302013-03-02T23:39:30.3172045mr graham nessthis should be abolished as it affects the poor disabled and families ,not only that should be against our human rites .17302013-03-03T04:19:29.5372046Iain F MacMillanMore reason for Scottish independence. 17302013-03-03T15:11:04.542047Gordon WThe government have already admitted that this measure will only save money if people don't move. Given the lack of available, appropriate housing, much as they say it isn't, this clearly amounts to a tax on those least able to pay. 17302013-03-03T15:29:20.3072048Les SharpWhere are we to put all the people who suffer under these draconian measures? And who is going to pay for the foster children who will have no home.17302013-03-03T15:42:07.482049alex mclatchieLets see if the goverment looks after scotland when it matters this will determine my vote on independence\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\nLets see if the goverment has got what it takes to pass this law.this will determine whether i vote yes or not17302013-03-03T20:45:05.3572051rick johnsonlet common sense prevail17302013-03-03T20:53:10.592052tommy CANT PAY AND WONT PAY17302013-03-03T21:31:27.352053alnon payment is the answer17302013-03-03T23:43:49.3372054Bruce NorvalIn the Scotland I want for my children this kind of State imposition would never even be considered, instead the focus would be on providing the properties for people to move to .17302013-03-03T23:54:59.912056maureen grahamMust stop bedroom tax17302013-03-04T09:39:57.092057Michael KellyThis is almost the most disgusting act of the coalition yet. Something needs to be done about it\r\n17302013-03-04T10:43:49.3272058James Hanlonsend this link to 10 of your friends and watch the power of justice for the people take hold.....God bless17302013-03-04T11:16:24.4172059edward calveyGood luck tommy17302013-03-04T11:38:07.9972061David FaganNo one should face eviction because they cannot afford the consequences of this vile policy. We should unite against this policy and force the Tory Lib Dem Government to reverse the unfair bedroom tax.17302013-03-04T11:57:54.4532062June Abbottthis tax is disgusting what about the pensioners that are in houses that they raised their kids in are now having to pay this tax because of the spare bedrooms..this governement is a disgrace its bringing the country to its knees!17302013-03-04T12:43:36.6872063Antony Steven BurrHow can the state make a person relying on benefit get in debt with their landlord when there is no income. All benefits get stopped to summon the individual and rent arrears accumulate because its not backdated. This is a sorry state of affairs to set up, How to reduce the unemployment figures, evict them then with no address they cannot claim benefit.17302013-03-04T12:58:43.4772064Antony Steven BurrThis is a government legislated forced attempt to free up what could be classed as under-used housing, because of lack of housing stock. On the willing where do you move them too? To the slums? There is nowhere to degrade the occupant to. \r\nJust like the unemployed it is just to cover up the fact the government has not and does not keep up with the demand of housing stock.17302013-03-04T13:16:43.2472065S CameronCan you be taxed for a bedroom smaller than the legal requirements for a police prison cell? 17302013-03-04T13:55:05.7532066Sarah GlynnThis change could make a real difference to people - but of course we need to keep fighting the bedroom tax too. It was never about saving money. This is an attack on the principle of social housing.17302013-03-04T14:36:12.6232067Frank FrankgateFor every pound raised from this tax ,just how many more will be spent on evictions , emergency ,temp housing and trying to recover debts owed. \r\n17302013-03-04T15:04:56.1072069johni am filled with hope and pessimsin now that TOMMY SHERIDAN is on board17302013-03-04T15:09:59.72070Stephen TonnerLike most people I deplore this new tax and aim to withhold payment until such a time when it becomes absolutely necessary to pay it, if my landlord decides to evict me. Even then, I won't pay in full all at once. Meantime I aim to join in with protest marches where and when I can. I am disabled and chronically ill, but will do my best to stand shoulder to shoulder, comrades.17302013-03-04T15:14:24.1672071Patricia L HillHow low can this government go, lets hope that this and the march will get sosme positive reaction17302013-03-04T15:55:37.0872072Janis SloranceYou cannot throw people out of their homes. The homes they've been in all their lives17302013-03-04T16:00:46.6332073Catherine RossThank God Tommy Sheridan is helping fight this ridiculous tax17302013-03-04T16:06:23.4732074A. CraigGood for Tommy Good Luck17302013-03-04T16:06:34.242075GordonIts time to re-invent democracy, it only works if you can afford it, the same applies to justice. 17302013-03-04T16:15:50.2532076tam murphythe people will have to stand up and be counted this govermment has to challenged17302013-03-04T16:43:11.0732077Elizabeth O'Hara McLeanthey are going to force people into the private sector renting that's what they want.17302013-03-04T16:46:02.072078margaretwhy should i be taxed on an extra bedroom when iv already asked for a smaller flat and not being offered one, so why should i be penelised when its not my fault i have an extra bedroom, how am i going to afford 43.00 a month , this tax is obscene and will just put thousands of folk in debt through no fault of there own, my standard of living will go down drastically, as if its not bad enough. 17302013-03-04T19:16:16.9332079Jennifer ZotouThis Westminster policy is actually very scantily concealed eugenics. It is also an attempt to do away with social housing altogether. Scotland must stand against it - and I am ashamed that nothing has so far been done17302013-03-04T19:16:48.4172080andrew harrisonWe need to get rid of this any way we can, and personally i cant see a yes vote for independent Scotland doing it.17302013-03-04T19:37:43.3172081william kellyThis bedroom tax charges can not be seen a serious attempt to plug the Goverments budget deficit, a deficit not brought about by people on benifit but by the failures in the Banking Sector.\r\nThis tax is just an extrension of Conservative ideology to reduce the public sector and that the private sector should prevail.\r\nIt is worth remembering that the cause of the Goverment deficit was brought about by those in the private sector who are still raking in fat cat salaries and bonuses whilst those on benifits are villifiled.17302013-03-04T19:56:59.9372082Annawhere is your spine, government? Bent under the bankers bonuses? How shameful! What is it THEY give to society, getting rewarded for their inhumanity by spreading their inhumanity (never mind the billions in bonuses!)!17302013-03-04T20:10:20.4172083paul smithglad tommy has took up this cause , it is so unfair17302013-03-04T20:53:07.622084louisa moncrieff. Solidarity.What will this government come up with next. We need to go out in the streets and protest as we did with the war in Iraq. Power to the people.If they can come out in their thousands abroad we can do it here.The cuts the government is making is going to effect all of us in some way.The public are needing to wake up and get out there.17302013-03-04T21:12:46.0872085Helen Please remember our under 35's , some have paid into the system for 18 years having left school at 16. If made redundant they are not even allowed ONE bedroom and are being forced to flat share , at 35 ,just wrong !17302013-03-04T21:14:13.7632086philrally the troops tommy sheridan17302013-03-04T21:21:17.8272087stella websterStopping grannies from having their grandchildren over at the weekend - just one example of the effect of the so called 'Bedroom Tax' 17302013-03-04T21:40:24.1072088Valerie HuttonThis has to be the most ridiculous idea I have heard of in my life.\r\nWhere have people who are on benefits meant to find this extra money? There is quite enough hardship in this country, are they now trying to strip people of their dignity, because that is what they will do if this goes ahead.\r\nNo one should be forced to make a decision between being homeless, or allowing a stranger into your home in order to pay for a room they happen not to use. What is going to happen to all the men, women and children who will become homeless?............perhaps they can all move into No 10, and use up all the spare rooms !!!!\r\nThis has to be stopped, and I hope and pray that it is.\r\nGood luck.17302013-03-04T21:50:45.852089sharon craig disgrace people should stand united and say no as well as all councils what can they do if weel all refuse this un just tax hitting the poor again 17302013-03-04T21:51:07.462090Eleanor ReillyPlease stop this ludicrous tax.17302013-03-04T22:00:32.4832091ANN BEGGSALL THEY DO IS CUT CUT CUT TIME TO GET RID OF THEM.17302013-03-04T22:02:34.1632092Diane richesDictatorship-telling you what to do whith your own home.forcing people to move.17302013-03-04T22:10:27.0132093linda kirkwoodthis bedroom tax is taking food out our kids mouth and the shoes of their feet count my self in al be doing my bit by joining the march in glasgow 17302013-03-04T22:15:06.4332094linda kirkwoodput your self beside tommy sheridan hes the man that will help us all he can 17302013-03-04T22:20:02.282096JuliaWasn't going to vote for independence but if they scrap this then they get my vote17302013-03-04T23:12:28.22097Anna DonaldsonBang out of order its just making the poor even poorer and affecting people who have health issues making them worry more17302013-03-05T01:31:36.772098olly stearndiscusting17302013-03-05T14:01:10.1372099Theresa Mcleodthe Government is taking from the poor and don't care .. against this tax may we stand united\r\n17302013-03-05T14:03:36.842100Laura craigPeople of Scotland get up and fight this atrocity!!!.17302013-03-05T14:20:56.492101Iain BuchananThis disgusting law needs to be struck down!17302013-03-05T15:12:18.6232102christine gallagherwe must all stand together on this, this tax is ridiculous, it can only cause more poverty, this is totally shocking , we need to make ourselves heard loud and clear, no more sitting and doing nothing, 17302013-03-05T15:24:55.8332103Yvonne MacDonaldThis is an absolutely ludicrous idea.!!! Why is it the poor are always hit??? What about all these Fat Bankers? ? This government should be tottally ashamed of themselves !!!!!!!!17302013-03-05T15:30:442104Davie One Solution - Revolution !17302013-03-05T15:52:32.032105Steve MeeseNo matter where we are in Britain we must all stand together to stop this wicked coalition and it's plans so NO to evictions anywhere ever!17302013-03-05T16:31:04.0972106robert smith we need more like tommy, this time im all in ,stand together and we are stronger17302013-03-05T16:38:13.052107Gerard DevlinCameron is finishing Thatcher's hatchet job on our country, he will be sending children up chimneys next, this country has to waken up VERY soon..we are paying for a federal state of London..the rest of the country will be a barren and desolate wasteland, we've been told for too long that we are stupid, can't look after ourselves, and we can't live without Westminster..WAKE UP SCOTLAND..we need Independence..then we only have ourselves to blame if we make a mess of it all..why let these people do it..and thank them while they are at it..C'MON SCOTLAND..RISE UP AND BE A NATION AGAIN...FOR THE SAKE OF OUR CHILDREN...17302013-03-05T17:15:19.92108kazwhere are the councils going to rehome everyone after they sold off so much of there housing stock and have very few houses left17302013-03-05T17:42:38.9832109William ToddIts typical of the condems to bring in this tax under the guise that it will free up properties for larger family's when its just another way to reduce benefits councils have very little one bedroom properties for people to escape this tax so if they cant provide people with smaller accommodation the tax should not apply The SNP should be doing a lot more to fight this tax instead of telling people to obey the law and not get into debt the hardship this is going to cause means people wont be able to avoid getting into debt. 17302013-03-05T18:01:39.6872110John LoftusThis has to be the most evil piece of legislation ever,even worse than anything Thatcher's lot could think up!!! Time for mass uprising!!!\r\n17302013-03-05T18:47:10.3232111ANNA GRAHAMWILL U BE ABLE TO RE HOUSE PEOPLE INVOLVED IN THE SAME AREA ?17302013-03-05T19:36:58.6872112james joycewhens the protest march17302013-03-05T20:07:38.7072113Gwen Stewart Disgusting vermin.. I pray that all. involved in this tax rot17302013-03-05T20:34:01.462114Ellis Cullen This just isn't right , \r\nThere sure lots of other ways to raise money \r\nThis just isn't one , \r\nThere are also lots of ways to save money \r\nNot rocket science \r\n17302013-03-05T20:43:30.0832115jane gunnThis tax is a blatant attack on the low paid and poor\r\nof our country.I would hope that our scottish government will pass a law to stop this affront on the most vulnerable in our society.I for one cant stand back and watch this happen.17302013-03-05T21:01:44.2632116andyhorrible Government..need to get them out ASAP!!17302013-03-05T21:08:18.1132117allan petrieIt would also be helpful if the Scottish Government gave local authorities and housing associations the power to re designate the house size to fit the criteria for full housing benefit to be paid.17302013-03-05T21:25:37.8932118Maureen CrossleySo where are these people suppposed to go?17302013-03-05T21:42:42.2772119wendie herdi think its a disgrace what theyre trying to do so please sign this as i did!17302013-03-05T21:54:55.412120Graham ArcherHow much are we going to take from these millionaire mps before we sort them out?17302013-03-05T22:37:51.1632121laura geddes everyone needs to stick together and stand up to this goverment\r\n17302013-03-05T23:30:27.4472122Valerie HuttonThis has to be stopped. No one should have to face the worry of being homeless through no fault of their own. As usual,the people being targeted are the ones who should be receiving help, this is only going to cause more stress and heartache. This will not affect me personally, but will affect my parents, who should be at a time in their lives where worry should not come into the equation. We must all stand together on this, we cannot allow this to go ahead. My fear is, what is next?\r\n17302013-03-06T00:02:47.6432123Agnes Arthur How nasty is this how can they do this to us all and eviction to all the We all need help 17302013-03-06T00:09:52.652124GrahamDidn't the scottish Government tell councils 2 years ago to reduce evictions? So what's changed now as Holyrood had to agree to section 1617302013-03-06T00:30:47.2772125nichola brownThis is a disgrace and is yet another way to punish families who are all ready at their most vunerable this will only cause wide spread poverty to people like myself who are struggling to support their family as it is 17302013-03-06T07:54:22.832126CAROLANN BLAIR these people have no regard to the less fortunate than themselves because they are so money orientated and greedy they dont care for people on the street or the family who dont have a proper meal at night all full of promises to get voted in then their reighn of terror begins on the poor and needy oap, unemployed, homeless even their lunches cost more than our weeks shopping on our tax money all jokes only out to fill their own pockets every last 1 of them sad society we live in :-(17302013-03-06T07:55:30.0172127Michelle Mac InnesGetting wi fi will be a fantastic benefit on a very long and tedious journey its bad enough we have to make a five to seven hour journey with very little for entertainment often a telly thats out of range or broken 17622013-03-06T10:10:25.0872128Donna MartinAnother sure sign that Central Government is only interested in lining the pockets of their City Pals and are not interested in Joe Public - the Rich get richer and the Poor get poorer - just exactly what they want17302013-03-06T12:54:30.3032130frankyhave the tories heard of human rights?17302013-03-06T13:58:52.7732131artyglad tommys on board17302013-03-06T14:05:48.322132harryappreciate mike daillys commitment17302013-03-06T14:06:31.8832133john sinclairfight it17302013-03-06T16:13:05.6772135Charlotte MacKayI've always found it surreal that you get it on a 1 and half hr PandO ferry but not on a upto 7hr Oban-Lochboisdale one! Come on calmac! 17622013-03-06T17:49:44.7932136W McCULLOCHTHE POOR GET POORER, AND RICH TORIES LINE THERE POCKETS17302013-03-06T18:07:25.8872137Doreen JonesHard enough to survive on low incomes with no possibility of getting jobs, how many times does the poor need to get hammered?17302013-03-06T18:20:11.12138ELIZABETH MACKENZIESurely in this day and age, it's little enough for us to get wifi on the ferry. I though it would have already been included in the plans! Would really help passenger comfort on such a slow boring journey, which is apparently going to be even slower on this new ferry. (surely it should be faster?!)17622013-03-06T22:14:38.6632139Alastair John Menniecheck out the housing act 1985 section326 it tells you that if the room is 50 square FT to 70 square ft it is only Half a room so to speak they dont advise tennants of this as it will net them so much money I think17302013-03-06T23:03:29.0932140william smithIts the usual story, tax the poor to give to the rich. When you see the ammont of millions being paid to fat cats, whether they perform or not. This tax on the hardest hit in society is scandalous. I wish it was polling day so we can get rid of these uncaring tory attitudes.17302013-03-06T23:32:15.7772141C Humphreysrobbing from the poor its just not right. sort out immigration that may ease overcrowding. why should ordinary folk lose their family homes 17302013-03-07T09:43:12.982142lauraThe scottish government should b ashamed.\r\nThe need to stand united with the people ( they r elected to represent us ) against this medieval tyranny.17302013-03-07T10:07:10.062143Iain RobertsonI'm a frequent traveller to the Isles on business, and the return journey is a great opportunity to complete the paperwork, but for that I really need good internet connectivity. Otherwise the journey is just wasted time (especially when it's dark).17622013-03-07T11:07:10.6632144jimget people to sign this petition17302013-03-07T11:15:18.4172145John millsMaking the poor pay for the crimes of the rich is a sin...The kleptocratic political class that rules on behalf of the banks and corporate power, should be swept away. Sad to see that some of the comments on here have fallen for the red herring of ''controlling'' 'immigration' as being the palliative to so many woes.17302013-03-07T11:41:33.0332146Alex MacDonaldThese councillors know the cost of everything but the value of nothing. I for one will not forget what they have done. at the next council elections.17552013-03-07T12:19:28.5772147David Milligan - a very Sovereign ScotIf we want Scotland to develop as an integrated independent country in the future, communications and transport links must be improved, not taken away, In my Scotland, the people of the island communities will be as much a part of my everyday life in Clydebank as someone who lives just down the road. The links between the islands are therefore doubly important.\r\n\r\nThis is a piece of nonsense and independence can't come soon enough so that we can properly start "Project Scotland".\r\n\r\nKindest regards,\r\n\r\nDavid Milligan - a very Sovereign Scot17552013-03-07T12:42:14.312148Margaret KerrThis tax is so wrong, why penalise people this way. Scotland thought it bad to have a window tax in the 18th century, now a bedroom tax in the 21st centruy....but why not rehome these people if they wish, not say they cannot consider them if they have rent arrears ...mad, the rent arrears are going to increase exponentially with this mad tax...makes me ashamed to be British.\r\n17302013-03-07T12:53:50.3872149AL PILLAYContempt is not a virtue! when directed at the poor and less well off in society the tories have no mandate from the people to do as they are doing drag the tories out put them all on the street and fight like mad the celts raise your BRAVE HEARTS! 17302013-03-07T13:15:08.9832150jennifer burtoneven if you can not get evicted from your house due to bedroom tax you will be stuck because you will get rent arears so you will be unable to exchange even if you get the chance of moving to a smaller property leaving people in debt with no way out we all need to make a stand and get the goverment out they give to the ritch and take from the poor .17302013-03-07T14:41:11.532151jonathon leviunite and fight honestly we will defeat this injustice17302013-03-07T15:20:20.7332152CharlieShocking legislation - well seen it doesn't impact on the legislators!17302013-03-07T15:46:30.492153Mr G SlaterThe current Welfare Reforms are a shameful modern day witch-hunt that will make the content of the 1487 Malleus Maleficarum, and subsequent persecutions with swathe of paranoia, pale into insignificance by comparison.17302013-03-07T15:54:21.52154NinaWhat little we have is in our home and they want to take that away from us. When we have nothing left what will they want our souls??17302013-03-07T16:18:04.7132155Mairi JohnstonWe do not need another Highland Clearance!17302013-03-07T17:10:02.0672156colinquicker this government goes the better not one of these politicians will ever be affected by these draconian measures and its even more sickening that it effects disabled people17302013-03-07T18:25:26.8832157Frank LynchTotally unacceptable that the poor and vulnerable should continue to pay for the mistakes of the rich investors - they made the mistakes they should pay - increase there tax 's on every transaction they make trying to make profits tax the large homes of the people in homes above £400,000 capitalism caused this, let them find a way out not the poor and vulnerable, greedy capitalism is dead... 17302013-03-07T19:21:20.5972158ninatories are extinct in scotland yet they still make the rules17302013-03-07T19:49:13.8672159John A policy to starve the most vulnerable in society. Radical evil.17302013-03-07T20:46:01.882160chris smith in my house 42yrs cant afford 23pounds a week this is too much to take17302013-03-07T21:36:38.342161Cathy MacinnesThese links are vital to the islands and to ensuring equity of opportunity and healthcare throughout the area. No one expects parity for rural & island areas with cities but some extra help to achieve reasonable standards must be the aim. To lose reduce these services is a very backward step.17552013-03-08T03:43:02.1332162Chris LaurieBeing a frequent user of Island Services, I would say that this would be the single most important upgrade since the beginning of Sunday sailings.17622013-03-08T07:48:18.5232163Terry Wildinghit the people who don't vote conservative and arn't rich17302013-03-08T08:02:27.52164Ant PowerFrequently in the Isles - Mull next month - love the ferries, but hate being cut off from the world 5 minutes after pulling out of Oban. Calmac give a good efficient service, surely this is a must-have addition.17622013-03-08T08:11:22.7172165alister macintyregood idea17622013-03-08T09:02:50.922166William McLachlanSuch a small but obvious advance17622013-03-08T09:36:36.0472167JohnMr Cameron\r\n\r\nYou are head of a nasty ruthless government.17302013-03-08T10:08:05.7732168Carol JohnsonSurely for the convenience of passengers Wifi should be made available. This question has been raised with Calmac by business travellers serveral times, and I its encouraging to see Barra Youth Council actively campaigning for improvements on behalf of their own communities.17622013-03-08T10:30:36.2032169Kevin Van AllenI'm a regular on the Oban - Barra service and it gets tiresome having to stand out on the deck in all weathers trying to get a signal. It's 2013, we can't live without our smartphones.17622013-03-08T10:41:34.5132170Catherine MacneilWhen Comhairle nan Eilean was established, the councillors of that time worked very hard to bring the Islands close together and I must applaud them in achieving this very competently by improving transport links throughout the Islands. The links ie public transport, better ferry links and better air links however, sadly there seems to be an element in our present Coucil who seem intent on reversing the good work done.By cutting the air service is this the first step?17552013-03-08T10:47:34.062171Tony JamesI have been a frequent visit to the Isles in the past few years and trust that I will be able to do so again in years to come. I love the ferries and fully support the suggestion for WI-FI on all Calmac ferries17622013-03-08T11:13:39.8532172Michael MacleanIt is about time those so called councillors, who voted against the inter island service, put there political views to one side. and help the people who elected them.17552013-03-08T11:42:04.1872173John DunsmuirIf people in under occupied houses are being hit by the bedroom tax then surely people in over occupied houses should receive a tax rebate !!!17302013-03-08T12:15:56.82174Trevor HuntWe regularly use the ferries to the Western Isles to visit family and having an Internet connection is essential these days. The facility should be available on all public transport.17622013-03-08T12:29:32.2172175christine grimleyThere is not enough single bedrooms to house those need them, we are being penalised for being poor, councils are putting single people in 2 bedroom houses knowing they will get bedroom tax. The Scottish Parliment needs to step in.17302013-03-08T14:10:52.492176williammy nephew is in a 3 apartment in an east ayrhire village and been told that he will lose £30 a fortnight as the council have no 2 apartment houses or flats. he is already 6 weeks in arrears with his rent. be worse next month.17302013-03-08T14:37:27.732177johnpaul monteithI hope we get this sorted17302013-03-08T14:42:41.3672178Roddy CurrieTypical council Bureaucrats they forget who they are in their jobs to serve and who money they use. It is never the case when they squander public tax payers money to serve there own ends. You'll never find a counciler in this day and age that will look for a more constructive solution to a problem instead they look for the quick fix that only serves their short term objectives. We the public elected you the western isle council to come up with better solutions than this, one that benefits everyone not your council careers. For once take a better look at all the options and find the correct solution and for once earn those over inflated pay packets you all cash without a thought to whether you have done you job right.17552013-03-08T14:49:32.8032179jacqueline rosshow we meant to pay ,a pure joke 17302013-03-08T14:52:35.4272180diane stoney100% against it!!!17302013-03-08T17:08:39.7372182heather buchananSaw a lawyer at length about this bedroom tax. She said evictions will happen and that people will be rehoused when evicted because there is a legal obligation to house homeless. People will be placed on a restrictive tenancy if rehoused she said punishment for non payments of our rent. Making it easier to evict us. If we do nothing to warrant eviction then a normal tenancy will eventually replace the restrictive one.\r\n Eviction not pleasant obviously Just means being put in street with all our things first before being housed as homeless. Who wants that.\r\nShe said we can seek legal aid to fight eviction. There will be a 2 or 3 week warning we will have notice for eviction.\r\n She said unless the law is pushed through in scotland to make it illegal to evict scots, then evictions will take place after october. Legal aid stops in england come april but legal aid will NOT stop in scotland.\r\nShe mentioned govan law centre are fighting the evictions however I think thats for only people from govan but they may be able to give you advice at least.\r\nSo we can clog the court system and challenge it. \r\nThere will be a six months settling in period to bring in bedroom tax nationwide.\r\nHope this helps give some information. 17302013-03-08T17:39:09.9672183stewartscottish goverment must make a stand17302013-03-08T18:01:49.2172184William C BlackerThis service should never been considered for a cut. It is a basic service that any island population should expect. The service needs to be protected from the panic reactions of councilors and officials until they have properly investigated the options. The council urgently need to reestablished their priorities for spending public funds on behalf of island people, and seek their support.17552013-03-08T19:18:50.0732186Jeanne GrantI have already been told by my audiologist that she may not be able to continue coming to Barra as she now has to go from Stornoway to Glasgow and then Barra.17552013-03-08T20:15:05.9172187Johnagree with the comment about The Scottish Government should step in and start protecting people from illegal taxs like this!17302013-03-08T20:20:20.0172188Mrs S McNabthis is not a fair tax inexpressible17302013-03-08T20:46:44.922189Archie MacleanWI FI availability on our ferries would help to make our journeys seem shorter especially on long routes like Oban Barra Lochboisdale which can be in excess of 7hrs.17622013-03-08T23:47:27.5372190lily FindlayI am a neighbour that has not been notified about a proposed wind farm as our property is out with the 20m limit,although the proposed wind farm will have a direct effect on our quality of life, noise pollution, visual impact and shadow flicker. We only found out because someone in another part of the town told us. 17372013-03-08T23:49:02.9432191Nigel HindleyI Usually use Calmac crossings for work purposes. I catch up with work on my laptop, but no wifi means its very frustrating. Not a single crossing goes by where I don't ask staff when wifi will be available. Its available on buses and trains why not ferries? Needs to be looked into as a matter of urgency, make long crossings fly by and be a productive time.17622013-03-09T00:02:06.0332192JohnSometimes I think this Tory Government would do away with poor people if they could. 17302013-03-09T02:41:04.7072194KimThis country is being Victorianised! People will end up constructing shanti towns. YOU WILL LOOSE CONTROL OF THE PEOPLE ONE WAY OR ANOTHER MR CAMERON!\r\n17302013-03-09T03:57:48.5632195katrina colburnThis tax its fundamentally unfair. It is taxing people who already can barely afford to live. This will increase evictions and cause even more homelessness, the crime rate will soar as people who lose even more benefits will need to find ways to meet even the basic standards of living..your govern,meant is archaic and you can bet your last £ Mr.Cameron enjoy your time in office whilst you can..the people will not re-elect you again. Disgusting!!!!!!17302013-03-09T04:22:12.4132196Jackie BellThis doesnt affect me at the moment, but I do require an extra bedroom as I suffer from severe copd, depression and diverticulitis and need room for carers, family to sleep in when they are here helping me. Scottish Government should put up a fight for people,not be more yes men to PM and his government.17302013-03-09T09:58:08.662197david reganGovernment are modern day robin hoods send in guy fawlks17302013-03-09T11:16:15.442198Roy HunterThe upcoming changes to the benefits system are an appalling retrograde step which will place the very people the welfare state is supposed to protect in danger of losing their homes and their quality of life. The Scottish Government should resist these measures in any way it can.17302013-03-09T18:50:21.6232199Linda ClarkThe is just typical of the SNP. They blame everything on Westminster and yet when they can do something to help the disabled with this dreadful bedroom tax they shy off. They're just chancers and political opportunists. I hope one of them dares to come to my home asking me to vote for them - they will be sent homward to think again by the time I am finished with them!17302013-03-09T20:02:38.2572200john paulsick a these tories ruining lives vot them out17302013-03-09T21:17:55.8872201douglas taylorin scotland, its all about alec salmonds ego. turbines cause utter misery to many, and the fiscal model does not stand scrutiny.17372013-03-10T03:32:50.772202JohnPity Mr Cameron is not on the receiving end of his extreme policy. I have applied for two hundred and eighty jobs to date. He is going to starve people. We are "not all in it together".17302013-03-10T08:45:28.8032203Margaret KellyI object to wind turbines being placed within our area. 17372013-03-10T17:53:56.82204Susan HowardWind turbines are appearing all over the country and are making many peoples lives a misery. How long is it going to be before the Scottish Government realise they are destroying our countryside and peoples lives? 17372013-03-10T18:27:45.5172205Edward BaxterI support Emma Stewart's sensible suggestion.17372013-03-10T20:54:34.6832206IAN ROBERT ALEXANDER20 METRES IS NOT A REASONABLE DISTANCE.17372013-03-10T22:18:48.0332207davey jonesscrap this tax 17302013-03-11T00:37:56.5372208Brian SmillieThe Scottish Govt MUST make a stance against this new tax imposed on Scotland via \r\nLondon !17302013-03-11T12:33:56.5132209jeremy smithi dont think anybody should pay this17302013-03-11T14:06:23.192210Brian OrmeThe way the Scottish Government is railroading through their green energy policy (i.e. wind farms) is destroying Scotlands landscapes and will not meet the country's energy needs, a more balanced approach is needed for energy generation. The current neighbour notification distance for wind turbines needs to be increased substantially to enable locals to be informed of proposed schemes and give them the chance to object if they want to.17372013-03-11T15:03:48.7332211john Slaven The bedroom tax is a act of unspeakible cruelty\r\n17302013-03-11T15:56:13.0932212margaret mcenhillmy daufghter gave up her tenancy in rutherglen due to this tax being brought in. She now lives with my sister. Housing association stated that they did not have any 1 bedroom flats for her to move to, so basically they forced her to become homless.17302013-03-11T20:47:34.3532213james dunnyour homes you castle defend it17302013-03-12T05:22:25.2732214Andrew Findlay45 year old male, unemployed! I will be affected by bedroom tax - already considered moving - no suitable one bedroom houses - \r\n\r\nOUTCOME - EAT LESS, HEAT LESS, WORTH LESS!\r\n\r\nNO MORE HOPE - NO MORE ASPIRATION! Want NO SYMPATHY just FAIRNESS and JUSTICE!\r\n\r\nIan Duncan Smith - CENTRE FOR SOCIAL JUSTICE - - Welfare Reforms! Simple - DISCRIMINATION against the POOR! \r\n\r\nWhat about underoccupied homes in working households? \r\n\r\nShame on you Ian Duncan Smith and SHAME ON this governement for attacking the poor in this way! \r\n\r\nMessage to Scottish Government - BUCK THE TREND and FIGHT AND LOOK AFTER THE POOR!!!!!!!\r\n17302013-03-12T12:28:34.5432216john spencerhad to give up my home of 39years im at my sisters waiting to move into a high riser with asylum seekers and vdrug addicts as my new nieghbours17302013-03-12T15:55:09.9032217Edith The bedroom tax is completely unreasonable. It is madness to impose this policy when there are not even enough alternative or suitable council homes to move to. Loads of people would move to smaller accommodation if they could, giving up all their social security and memories in the process, but you can not even provide that option. What on earth are you thinking with.\r\n17302013-03-12T16:18:22.0432218JacquelineMr Duncan Smith should be at the sharp end of his policy. A tax on the poorest in society. 17302013-03-12T16:47:55.2232219Mark StewartThere is not enough 1 bedroom houses in scotland to house every single person when going for a house the turn over for 1 bedroom houses is at least a five year wait SHOCKING !!!17302013-03-12T19:23:46.52220Patrick O'RourkeIf you truly are a government for the people, you will protect them! No evictions due to bedroom tax arrears!17302013-03-12T20:40:01.312221helen wallaceI wonder how many rooms not being used in Ian Duncan smiths house - perhaps he could help by taken some peopl in and helping with the load that his goverment has given by opening the flood gates and letting everyone in! \r\n17302013-03-12T20:51:11.4872222Margaret GardinerThis has to be one of the most inhumane moves by any UK government, to date but then, the Tories are well practiced. \r\n\r\nDoes the "under occupancy" tax mean that the government will be paying those in "over occupancy" situations?17302013-03-12T21:09:53.3772223STANleft a lot of my posessions as my new flat with bed in living room isnt big enough17302013-03-12T22:01:06.5632224Isabella Goldie This is one of our most concerning public health issues. Our unequal society will become even more so and both mental health problems and long term conditions will rise as a result. Not to mention the sheer misery and social injuries that will be endured by a large section of society. 17302013-03-12T22:03:36.252225shirley fitzpatrickmr duncan smith surely you could rethink how this is going to effect many people,or are you too thick skinned to care about your own people in your own country.how you sleep at night is beyond me.17302013-03-13T08:57:25.1972226JohnI am a construction professional and lost my job. I live in a council flat at the moment and I feel that this government is simply attempting to starve people into getting a job, when the job market is struggling. I had a very good salary and did not mind paying tax but this is a ruthless policy by a party who know the price of everything and the value of nothing. Cameron and IDS are totally ruthless and they will pay the price in the May elections. I hope the Scottish Government can mitigate the effects of this policy on the people of Scotland and this will have a domino effect in England and Wales. 17302013-03-13T08:59:21.432227Marjory SmithA tax on those least able to afford it, so unfair ...17302013-03-13T09:11:17.6072228FranzTry a spoonful of your own medicine Ian Duncan Smith. 17302013-03-13T09:15:32.2932229FranzI am not saying it will happen here but the political theorist Hannah Arendt in her book The Origins of Totalitarianism warned that where people are regarded as superfluous governments may be tempted to do away with them. I wonder how far this government would go if we lived in a totalitarian regime? 17302013-03-13T09:35:21.6932230JohnThe bedroom tax has one purpose, to starve people into employment. Their work program is failing because there are not enough jobs so take the food out of people's mouths, that is the strategy. The head of a food bank in England told Cameron and Osbourne to visit and see we are not all in it together. They just want people off benefits. It is a policy of an extremely ruthless callous government. Hopefully they will be obliterated in the May elections. 17302013-03-13T12:02:14.5732231patriciaiain duncan smith litteraly makes me ill17302013-03-13T12:42:49.3872232Grainne RiceSee Michael Mecher's letter to the Guardian re. taxation of the poorest. Proportionately we experience the biggest hit when rents, utility bills increase and with pay freezes and benefit cuts, adding the bedroom tax hits the same (large) group of people again. 17302013-03-13T13:52:13.7072233Christine DumonceauI saw on the net yesterday words of Ian Duncan-Smith saying that people will have to take on lodgers the frist £20 will be free ! My friend Susan on realised last night how bad things are, when I told her! Plus on radio yesterday evening I heard that the service men and their families were to be exempted! More separatism! £20! But that will not cover the extra heat, electricity, water! Plus you don't know who you are taking in! Beyond £20 you will be taxed! You are not gaining anything , they are just finding a cheap and easy way to fix a long term issue of lack of affordable social housing. It was the policy a few years ago to only build 2 bedrooms properties beacause people live alone more with friends and families staying for visits, and carers coming in , doing sleep-overs when needed! So logical really! 17302013-03-13T14:18:15.5672234Catherine McGowanThis is a down right injustice to people who are already struggling. I noticed in a newspaper they have voted against a mansion tax surprise surprise!! Take from the poor while helping the fat cats to get fatter. Unreal!!!!17302013-03-13T15:34:08.7172235Maria FyfeWhat will happen if people are evicted? We know there is not a sufficient supply of smaller homes, and even if there were, the bedroom tax uproots people from their homes and disrupts children's lives.17302013-03-13T16:03:38.062236Veronica BolanTypical of this ConDem government to hit the poorest in society. the Scottish Parliament must get Section 16 of the Housing Act amended to prevent evicitions.17302013-03-13T18:32:37.972237Christy-Anne SurteesMost like me have no choice I will not and cannot move away from here to somewhere miles away si I have only 1 bedroom I have already downsized to as small a property as is available near my family and friends whom I rely on for help each day So no choice I have to pay How fair is that? 17302013-03-13T20:13:01.9672238FranzIf people cannot pay this a few possibilities will manifest themselves. If their landlords take action against them Legal Aid expenditure will soar, as the courts will be involved. Another possibility is normally law abiding citizens resorting to crime which will give the Police more work. The new ideology of this extremist government is starve them out to work I have applied for three hundred and fifty jobs. I am a Quantity Surveyor who had a good salary before I lost my job. When I was employed I paid my taxes like everyone else but I think this government have shown a new ruthlessness and they are a party of the rich and detest the poor. Anyone can fall on hard times. In my view social cohesion will be affected. The David Cameron's of this world want a nightwatchman state, police to maintain internal law and order and armed forced for defence. They want to destroy all of the public services. 17302013-03-14T01:10:56.1472239Kim ScottThis is a despiratelly needed petition and PLEASE lets fight against such ridiculous measures......it is time to stand up against the trashing of the socialist systems which make britain so great!17302013-03-14T08:51:27.9372240JohnAll governments are selective in who they help and this applies to the SNP too. People talk of Independence but the assumption is that things will get better if we are Independent, and this cannot be proven until it happens. The radical Tories are slowly hanging themselves. I am always wary with political issues, because there is a vast difference between an assumption and fact. Nicola Sturgeon wants more powers from Westminster but my question to her is what she will do with those powers? There are factions within Scotland who are only accountable to themselves. 17302013-03-14T09:31:59.0632241JohnNo doubt Mr Cameron and his government will feel the boomerang effect of their policies at the next election. They are trying to drive a wedge between the poor and the employed and anyone who is working can be ill tomorrow of lose their jobs. I had a good job with a reasonably good salary and a company car etc, but suddenly I become a target for their pernicious policy when no one complained when I paid my taxes. Its a blanket policy. Not all unemployed people are work shy. seventy one pounds per week plus rent and council tax of course but I earned six hundred pounds per week plus a company car. I would go back to my salary tomorrow and I would still vote against the Conservative Party. They steal off the taxpayer and call it expenses, but see the poorest in society as outcasts. They want to help themselves to expenses, ninety five thousand pound salaries and accept bribes from donors to shape policy in the donors interests. I wonder what these people would do to the most vulnerable in society if they could get away with it? 17302013-03-14T09:50:24.462242Isabella MooneyI waited 11 years for the Council to provide me with adequte housing to enable me to live independantly and Im so thankful for the fabulous house that I have, it has been well worth the wait, I still need assisstance to live that independant life in my fab house, but that costs money and unfortunatly, that is where the Government is going to kill me! they may not pull the trigger, but they loaded the gun and pointed to the targets, I could give you all sorts of woe's about Heating bills, taxi bills ( as I can't get on public transport with my powered wheelchair), so now I shall life independantly in my wee house, hardly ever to got out, afraid to put on the heating as I now have to re-assess my monthly budget so that I shall be able to stil eat healthy.......in the END, Iam very grateful for the help and support Iam given by the Gov and other agencies.........but I fear, I dont feel safe and secure in knowing that the Country that I love ( among one of the richest ) doesn't care about it's people, It's all about savig money.......Mr Cameron if my £44 extra a month into your purse, helps save this country from rack and ruin please I give you it willingly.............but if I've to give out of the little that I already have, yourserlf being a gizzillionare, what are you paying personally towards bring the deficit down you live in this country also??\r\n\r\nregaurds Issy17302013-03-14T10:40:17.6532243Fay YoungThis is both immoral and bad economics. It will cause suffering without solving the housing crisis or cutting the deficit. \r\nWhere people are able to move to smaller accommodation the government ends up paying more in housing benefits. The root of the problem (and the present economic crisis) is the UK's housing crisis. Displacing families, making people homeless or causing them to go hungry in order to meet the increased costs of their rent, will not solve the problem. Build more homes, build them well with energy efficient designs and then make it possible for people to make real choices. 17302013-03-14T12:03:14.9172244bennettlets get a last push for signatures b4 this petition runs out17302013-03-14T14:40:57.3832245cameronwhat we need is a little more action and a little less talk, all these petirions and demos are getting us nowhere, We need to start going in the way of the arabs and creating some civil disorder to make these career polititions wake up and listen, they have no ideas what chaos they're causing as they are not experiencing the misery in their ivory towers so lets show them please......17302013-03-14T15:01:30.3632246Dr Brigitte AntonThe bedroom tax is just wrong. Simple!17302013-03-14T18:19:33.532247JayIf we have the power then use it - for goodness sakes, why should the coalition tell us (Scotland) what and what not to do. If there is a way out of this then stand up and say "NO"!\r\n17302013-03-14T18:39:08.8072248nickcmon lets not lie down and take this17302013-03-14T18:45:14.4172249carol#NO BEDROOM TAX#17302013-03-14T18:52:31.012250tomdesperately sad17302013-03-14T18:59:43.1372252normanPLEASE HELP17302013-03-14T20:00:05.662253Eileen FraserSimple...Please listen to the people17302013-03-14T21:53:35.0072254JohnConservative Government RIP. 17302013-03-14T22:43:16.1672255JohnIan Duncan Smith, you should think of all of the implications of the boomerang effect before you introduce radical policies. This bedroom tax is over the top. You would all be lining your pockets with false expenses claims due to self regulation if you could. Resign before your are removed with your pernicious government by the electorate. 17302013-03-14T23:11:27.4432256Jonny GarnerBetter late than never,Scrap the Tax!17302013-03-15T00:38:34.2872257neil williamsonmy son was on a waiting list for a good time because our local councils one bedroom properties had been converted for people with mobility problems(i.e wet rooms) yet when in the bidding process for a property he was not eligible for these due to them being converted which meant he had to take a two bedroom property for which he will now be penalised,but what in the future if he has a family, what would have been the chance of moving from a one bedroom to a two bedroom?Not very much due to lack of social housing.come on the tory government get your act together you caused this problem by the right\r\nto buy but don't penalise the tenants of today.I guarntee i WILL not vote tory ever again,although i have never voted tory.YOU will NEVER win my vote17302013-03-15T13:43:58.982258Christine Once again the poor and sick are the easy targets while the fat cats get richer.17302013-03-15T14:49:21.752259Jack Ward FinchamThere is a kernel of a good idea here, but the approach is spiteful and angry.\r\nIf we have a problem with single occupancy of 3-4 bedroom houses then granting incentives to promote movement. Eviction isn't an incentive.17302013-03-15T15:03:54.7872261madlena a big thanx to mike dailly17302013-03-15T15:31:15.4572262joeAAAARGH HELP17302013-03-15T18:20:58.132263Dai KellandNo Bedroom Tax!17302013-03-15T18:29:47.9932264Marie johnstonNO NO and NO17302013-03-15T18:56:52.0532265Elizabeth McCullochEnough of the savage cuts on the vulnerable from Westminster Mr Salmond.17302013-03-15T18:59:45.8272266debbie mcmillanA think its a disgrace no one should be made pay bedroom tax. If that's the case then people who move to the uk should pay money to stay in the uk 17302013-03-15T19:39:04.982267margaret reddyThink this is a pathetic way to shaft families whos kids wrk away in the army navy ect putting there lives on the line for our country and the goverment are just thinking of money in there own pockets its discusting! Some parents only get there kids at the weekend what are they supose to do its hard enough to survive!!!17302013-03-15T20:45:16.1332268Marie MacraeNo Bedroom Tax!!!17302013-03-15T20:47:12.12269James MacraeStop the bedroom Tax17302013-03-15T20:47:47.6332270Ken RossThe Bedroom Tax is morally corrupt and indefensible in a civilised society!17302013-03-15T22:22:16.3772271Kenneth WaddellPoor legal drafting reflects poor political thinking17302013-03-15T23:53:25.082272Kenneth CampbellWhy can the government arrange for more houses to be built? This would be of great assistance to the construction industry, employment and exschequer income from PAYE and NI. No, to simple an idea!17302013-03-27T08:43:07.8472273James McLIt is a disgrace that the city of Aberdeen that is a significant driver for the Scottish economy stlll has a single lane road like some back water village. this is the only main artery into the city from the north and it is something out of the 60's. I look at the road investment in the central belt with dualing, mortoways, road widening, bypasses, etc, etc, and I know where the interest groups and capital investment resides for Scotland. The third city of scotland, and one of the wealthiest in the UK per capita is poorly served by this and previous governments.17422013-03-27T09:58:09.4232274Julie Christie Sooner this is done the better 17422013-03-27T10:09:15.4532275Mike WallerAs someone who has been a regular commuter from the North East corner of Aberdeenshire to Aberdeen on a daily basis for 40 years I think the road infrastructure to support the population and industries in the area is unacceptable. 17422013-03-27T12:22:46.112276claire bYou wouldn't get this in the central belt. I remember talking to my parents as a kid about why it wasn't a dual carriageway the whole way. that's over 20 years ago. We need this. Simple.17422013-03-27T14:51:38.092277Pauline InschTransport infrastructure to and from Aberdeen from Ellon is an absolute joke during the working week. The alternative of public transport is not reliable with buses often full especially at peak times. Linking into the AWPR project timescale is a ridiculous, proposition. This area needs attention in the form of improved roads and public transport links. It's a shame there isn't the same apathy regarding granting planning permission to house builders. Increased housing equates to increased pressures to the already overloaded commuter traffic. 17422013-03-27T16:04:24.762278Grant LeslieThis road need to be upgraded before anyone else loses their lives on this bottle neck!17422013-03-27T16:18:31.3432279Harry ButlerThis upgrade, and a further upgrade to Peterhead, is absolutely urgent. With exoerts predicting that North Sea Oil reserves running to around a 40 year life span, the main road to the North will be used more and more often in the years to come. We should not be short sighted in this..... build for the future, and not to sort out today's problems on the road. More and more traffic on the roads today, a problem that will only get worse in the next half century.17422013-03-28T13:01:20.6472280Ben HowardIts a disgrace. Should have been made a dual carriageway years ago.17422013-03-29T08:13:33.032281LJMCan't keep building new houses and encourage people to live North of Aberdeen without improving the antiquated road structure.17422013-04-01T21:19:15.8372282Martin Dillon I wonder, could the over spend on building The Scottish Parliment Building, have been enough to pay for this stretch of dual carrigeway \r\n17422013-04-03T16:32:46.7072285Malcolm Hardy-Randall.This project was first discussed in 1936! I think that that is enough time to talk, now is the time to start work.17422013-04-04T17:59:58.3132286Chris RitchieTotally get this done asap17422013-04-16T17:12:05.112288Anne Lumsden Not to give it to both sexes repeats the mistake when only girls were given rubella vaccination17542013-04-17T17:10:50.9372289Dave McCuskerLooking at industry as a whole in Scotland I would imagine that the TAX collected from Aberdeen Business in general along with the Offshore revenue that seems to disappear south should justify the project - Oil Capital of Europe?17422013-04-17T19:30:57.4632290Nelson McFarlaneIt makes no sense to perpetuate gender-specific vaccination. A relatively small investment is likely to save the NHS in the longer term. There is also a moral obligation on MSPs to consider and change the current situation.17542013-04-18T09:29:48.1532291William AllanNeeds to be done ASAP , major delays every day !!! .17422013-04-22T08:42:09.7832292Iain MackinnonBy upgrading this stretch of road a time saving of at least an hour travelling will be gained.17422013-04-22T15:56:51.942293Gemma MorriceEssential and need pronto!17422013-04-22T17:48:05.3332294Mark smithGet it done! Sooner rather than later please17422013-04-23T19:58:55.8172295Chris Curtis, Chairman Swallows Head & Neck Cancer GroupGood luck in getting all your Boys vaccinated, we are running the same campaign here in England 17542013-05-02T12:03:28.4732296Hegel HernandezProtecting everyone for cervical cancer, penis cancer, anal cancer, neck and head cancers HPV related. 17542013-05-03T12:01:52.6032297ClaudiaInstead of pushing aheontr Big Pharma profit venue on unsuspecting citizens why not recommend those considering submitting their children as guinea pigs for an untested vaccine first do their research, starting with Judicial Watch. Next research the astronomical amount of money spent on lobbyists who have successfully convinced elected and appointed officials to work in the best interest of special interest (Big Pharma) vs the interests of their constituents. Contrary to your derogatory comments re Republicans, parents can easily confirm the risks associated with this vaccine and reasons why it has been banned in certain countries by people who, to the best of my knowledge, are not Republicans.17542013-05-11T14:16:11.252298Pat KellyThis is a terrible illness and seems wrong that a person with the same illness cannot receive free care because of age. Why should a person aged 63 year with dementia have to pay for care yet someone at 65 gets free care? That is blatant age discrimination. We need to change this NOW!\r\nGood luck Frank, Amanda and Scott. 18132013-05-11T14:18:29.8932299Lynne KellyAll the best for the campaign Frank, Amanda and Scott we are all thinking of you! Good luck with the fight!18132013-05-11T15:22:36.442300Pat Kelly Frank Kopel would receive free care for his illness but because he is only 63 this has been refused! This is blatant discrimination. Why should people with the same illness be treated differently because of age? Please sign the petition. 18132013-05-11T15:35:32.1772301IAN GRANTTHE SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT REALLY HAS TO LOOK AGAIN AT THIS. AGE SHOULD NOT BE AN ISSUE.18132013-05-11T17:19:05.3132304Edith Mason Wishing you all the best xxx18132013-05-11T17:35:41.9572305Derek DoigAlzheimer's and dementia care must be free to all regardless of age18132013-05-11T17:56:45.9072306Brian DunbarIn today's society this is scandalous.Considering all the money that is spent on drug addicts etc.18132013-05-11T18:01:27.5772307Dave WebsterHad the priveledge of knowing Frank when he used to hand out my kids team player of year trophies. Great guy, and though I'm a Dundee fan I hope he gets the treatment he deserves. A true gentleman.18132013-05-11T18:20:47.922308grant andersonget this sorted out18132013-05-11T21:49:29.0972309Karen GrayWhat does it say about our country that we have to sign petitions to get people the care they need and deserve, Frankie Kopel- yer a legend18132013-05-12T10:00:48.1172310Karen SmithAn issue close to my heart as my mother in law is suffering with this.. 18132013-05-12T11:44:53.922311Dave StillDisgraceful treatment of anyone ! This is a condition that is becoming more prevailent yet the government want to stick their heads in the sand.18132013-05-12T12:31:34.2072312Ian RitchieBest of luck in changing their decision !18132013-05-12T22:38:27.0272313Anne BairdHave had the pleasure of knowing Amanda and Frank for many years and they really are wonderful couple, the devotion Amanda has for Frank is amazing18132013-05-13T09:37:27.8532314Michael WellsIllness is no respecter of age.\r\nSimply make the change.\r\nGood luck and best wishes in your fight for justice 18132013-05-13T10:58:26.292315Barbara SherriffA very worthy cause which I am proud to support18132013-05-13T11:04:06.3872316John SherriffThis should not be necessary , provision for people of ALL ages should already be in place 18132013-05-13T11:54:39.5432317Claire SmithGood luck with your campaign. I simply cannot believe that a person with the same illness is treated differently. This is discrimination and must be stopped NOW!18132013-05-13T15:49:06.72318Ian RoacheBest wishes with the campaign. Signed.18132013-05-14T08:40:02.2032319Susan ElliottIt is so unfair how age differentiates what care is provided. Is this not age discrimination?18132013-05-14T09:22:16.7332320Ian DuffKeep up the good work18132013-05-14T09:27:25.1372321Victoria RobertsonAn extremely well deserving case. 18132013-05-14T11:49:35.082322Audrey Ireland Good luck amanda, hope you get this sorted for you and frankies sake. You are such an anazing lady!! This should already be happening thoughout no matter what age you are! You go girl!! Xx18132013-05-14T11:59:19.332323Ashley baillieSigned, good luck18132013-05-14T12:51:21.9672324Karen BennettThis is a disease, people who suffer from it should have the full support of the NHS no matter what their age.18132013-05-14T13:15:39.4372325Kerry ThomsonI have a relative with this disease. It's so sad to watch someone you love who has had such a fulfilling life, lose touch with those around them through the erosion of their memories and thought processes. Everyone should be entitles to the same level of care regardless of their age. I hope your campaign is successful. x18132013-05-14T13:20:36.4532326Lyndsay AllanI hope this works good luck 18132013-05-14T16:10:17.5132327Sheila AndersonHelp should be given free of charge regardless of age.18132013-05-14T16:20:48.122328Louise JohnstoneI am district nurse and have regular contact with people with alzheimer's and their carers. Life is difficult enough without having to worry about financal concerns,age doesn't come into it, I think your campaign is very worthy and wish you all the best, stay strong.18132013-05-14T16:47:05.3772329Brian LaingShould be free of charge regardless of age18132013-05-14T17:11:06.6332333Bill ForrestWe are aware of the problems and stress that alzheimers brings regardless of age and how life changing it is for everybody involved with the sufferer.This is a very worthy cause.18132013-05-14T17:37:32.2872334Mark GrantWith you on this one Amanda.18132013-05-14T18:15:07.5932336lynne douglashope this is successful\r\n18132013-05-14T18:19:47.0532337Paula Hope This helps! xXx18132013-05-14T18:20:41.462338Gordon EllisMy father has vascular dementia and is now in residential care. He remained at home until aged 87 down to home based personal care. In terms of the Adults with Incapacity legislation, the Scottish Government have a responsibility to ensure that individuals are allowed to lead as fulfilling a personal life as they can, regardless of age. That must begin at home with free personal care.\r\n18132013-05-14T18:22:59.1632339Pat McIntoshBrought tears to my eyes. I admire your strength and love for each other. I wish you well with this.18132013-05-14T18:23:16.4132340Amanda McraeI wish you all the best with this petition I hope you get a positive outcome from it.18132013-05-14T18:24:28.2132341tracy mccabeHad Amanda at our college today giving us a talk about life with frank very inspiring lady totally agree what does it matter what age you are everyone should be able to get help their needed \r\n18132013-05-14T18:28:03.6032342Leigh ClarkWishing you all my luck x18132013-05-14T18:29:23.4932343Vivienne CookSurely people and families affected by this horrific illness need all the support they can get. Good luck with the campaign....x18132013-05-14T18:29:44.9932344Rhona WhiteMy mum died five years ago from alzheimers the amount of care she needed and got was so good but it should be for available for suffers of any age I admire your fight Amanda and hope you achieve your goal. Best wishes to you and your family 18132013-05-14T18:31:50.462345MarieCurrMy thoughts go to you and your family x18132013-05-14T18:57:03.012346Margaret Cruickshank There are so many sufferers of Alzheimer's or dementia, raising awareness of this issue is such a worthwhile cause , good luck 18132013-05-14T18:58:51.452348michelle boltmy mother was diagnosed at 52,8 years ago, i'm with you as she also had to pay before going into care,discriminated due to age,this disease is life changing for all age should not come into it,18132013-05-14T19:01:33.6972349Vivienne CookIts difficult enough for all who are affected by this horrific illness...about time something is done....all care should be free...Good luck ..x18132013-05-14T19:06:04.4332350Lorraine Malloy Alzheimers affects people of all ages and as such, everyone should be entitled to the same benefits and treatment. Life is difficult enough for them.18132013-05-14T19:19:26.6232351Nicola I lost my mum to early onset Alzheimer's. We had to fight for every minute of care she had due to her age, thank you so much for raising this issue, but I'm so sorry you need to18132013-05-14T19:27:30.1432352Donna Clarki was deaply moved today , thankyou 18132013-05-14T19:28:26.1072353Sheila GalbraithFree personal care should relate to the condition, not the age, of the sufferer.18132013-05-14T19:35:16.872354ainslie clellandThings can only improve....surely.18132013-05-14T19:38:12.6072355Pamela GildeaI am a nurse taking part in the dementia champions programme. I wish you all the best with your campaign.18132013-05-14T19:49:50.22356Robert Laidlaw,LocheeI wish you the very best with your campaign stay strong and keep fighting18132013-05-14T19:50:01.5572357Clare ClarkeSigned..Good luck :)18132013-05-14T19:53:29.6532358Ellen LaidlawKeep fighting the cause we're with you all the way18132013-05-14T20:25:22.3072359Gavin MuirHaving met Frank a few weeks ago I fully support this campaign18132013-05-14T20:29:17.652360Peter EvansThis is one of the worst examples of discrimination in todays society, people don't have any choice over the age at which they start to suffer from dementia and to think otherwise is a poor reflection on our politicians and law makers. Good Luck with your campaign.18132013-05-14T20:30:09.3872361Arlene Dickson Let's raise awareness everyone!18132013-05-14T20:45:00.4472362Christine SmithXx18132013-05-14T20:46:32.6972363Derek McLarenHope this campaign gets Amanda to Parliament, scandalous decision by the authorities. All the very best to Frank and family.18132013-05-14T21:21:37.082364sheila o'kaneamanda is so strong. It shouldn't matter what age you are18132013-05-14T21:27:52.152365Anne ToddHope this petition gets something done and fast \r\n18132013-05-14T21:30:58.512366Jacqueline MastertonAlzheimer's and Dementia does not only affect the elderly, It is becoming more popular in people under 65, free care should be available to EVERYONE.18132013-05-14T21:32:29.512367sheila o'kanegood luck amanda18132013-05-14T22:03:42.5672368Derek RamsayWishing you every success in your campaign Amanda. I have known you both for a long time and you are such lovely people you deserve all the help you need.18132013-05-14T22:13:45.262369Karen As a family we understand what care we have recived from Angus Council after my granny was digonised with Demintia. \r\nUnlike Frankie Kopel my granny was 84 years old and we recived all the care we needed to help us and I understand its hard for everyone friends and family. I also understand that the added pressure of going through this and having to pay for the services cause you are under the current age to work in the UK. \r\nI do believe that anyone that is digonised with demitia under the age 65 should get free care.18132013-05-14T22:18:24.8672370Iain FallerMy Dad worked for the health board for 40 years and the social work department practically pushed out of an NHS bed after 8 weeks ! he has dementia and lost my Mother to Alhziemers 7 years ago. 18132013-05-14T22:24:08.052371Susan CampbellGood luck. My dad died age 60 from Alzheimer's. Horrific illness. Everyone with the illness should be treated equally no matter age 18132013-05-14T22:32:57.0172372Tracey RobertsBack this campaign all the way18132013-05-14T23:18:33.5932373Martha MackayEquality for all regardless of age. 18132013-05-14T23:25:32.812374Audrey Ireland To the scottish parliament Get your heads on the right way and look after people who have worked hard to make our place a better place.Support Amanda Kopel on her journey it's hard enough for her x18132013-05-15T00:12:58.2132375Douglas TottAlzheimer's Society and Alzheimer Scotland is the chosen charity for Lloyds Banking Group for 2013 and 2014. \r\nI suggest you get in touch with them to see if they can help.18132013-05-15T00:27:59.752376James TurnerAll the best Amanda, there needs to be a greater awareness and support from the powers that be.18132013-05-15T01:21:51.8372377Gregor StephenThe NHS was set up on the idea that the goverment should provide it's people with care "from the cradle to the grave". Not providing Frank help based soley on his age is a clear violation of this ideal.18132013-05-15T09:57:27.2032378Pat AllanIt is a disgrace that families are penalized financially they have more than enough to worry about.18132013-05-15T10:55:12.472379Linda Linford - ScotlandEvery little helps, I know what you are going through. Good Luck hope you get lots of signatures18132013-05-15T13:21:54.2572380Murray DavidLets get this sorted immediately for the good of all regardless of age!!18132013-05-15T14:12:13.3872381nancy mcgregorI am a retired nurse and am fully aware of the pressures family are under trying to care for their loved one at home-- and should never be burdened with financial issues on top of all this -- care should be free regardless of age..--Hope your campaign will bring some positive results..18132013-05-15T14:36:11.1532382Frances malley Having worked with so many mental health cases we can not discriminate with age race religion or gender as stated in the national care standards so why can they !!!!18132013-05-15T15:58:38.062383J A TaitIt's ridiculous that age should bar someone from the care they require.18132013-05-15T18:11:50.8132384barbara sturrockit can happen to you or yours, its heartbreaking enough without the added burden of financial difficulties18132013-05-15T19:33:06.8072386ruth massonIt is an illness and should be treated like one by healthcare professionals, my father at the age of 84 was treated very inappropriately by staff who didn't seem to understand his condition 18132013-05-15T21:31:01.5732387Mike Barile Arabest and keep the faith. You'll make a difference 18132013-05-15T22:42:16.8032388Shona HannamGo get them girl! You can do it18132013-05-15T23:36:01.1772389Sheila KettlesThis illness knows no boundaries and can strike anyone. Wishing you all the best with your campaign Amanda. 18132013-05-16T12:36:36.0432390Arthur CormackThe Scottish Parliament passed the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Act 2005 which calls for equal respect for Gaelic with English. Of course Gaelic should be included.18082013-05-16T13:04:16.6232391Duncan McLeanThe Scottish Government's Gaelic Language Plan says:\r\n\r\n"The Scottish Government will increase the use and visibility of Gaelic in its most commonly used forms: we will make more Gaelic visible on forms. We will identify situations in which completion of forms in Gaelic will be encouraged."\r\n\r\nGiven the active suppression of Gaelic following the union, it is appropriate that the form used to bring the union to an end should be available in Gaelic.18082013-05-16T17:37:01.492392Seumaidh UallasThere is still time to submit opinions to the Referendum Bill Committee too. Gabh an cothrom!18082013-05-16T18:50:51.3132394Davine SutherlandLanguage support planning involves a stage called 'status planning', which means making the language more visible and more clearly officially welcome. The Scottish Govt signed up to all of this and should be aware of its obligations - I am only dispappointed it has come down to 'obligations' and not 'desires'.18082013-05-16T20:55:58.7472395Steven RitchieTha mi ag aontachadh gum bu choir Gaidhlig a bhith air paipear baileit an reifreinn mu dheidhinn neo-eisimeileachd. \r\n\r\nTried to write the above in with grave accents, but the technology wouldn't let me. I agree that Gaelic should be on the referendum ballet paper.18082013-05-16T21:00:25.72396John MortonCiallaichidh neo-lathaireachd na Gaidhlig air paipear-bhotaidh an reifreinn dimeas chun na Gaidhlig. Cha dean seo an gnothach idir.\r\nThe absence of Gaelic on the referendum voting paper means disrespect towards Gaelic. This just will not do.\r\nIn trying to post this comment, I got "A comment can only contain letters, numbers and simple punctuation characters only" - several times, until I had removed all the accents on the Gaelic words. This also needs looked at urgently.18082013-05-17T22:03:07.452397Cairistiona Nic 'Ille MhoireBu chorr seo a tachairt.\r\nThis should happen.18082013-05-18T11:15:19.8532398michelle boltmy lovely mother diagnosed at 51 treated like a second class citizen ,hard worker all her days and had to pay for help,discrimination,well done amanda and good luck xx18132013-05-18T14:16:55.1772399Anthony DilworthAll languages in the world are valuable and must be preserved and not be allowed to die out. 18082013-05-19T21:53:38.9872400Caoimhin If we are to treat Gaelic as an equal language, it should be on important legislation like this referendum in 2014. 18082013-05-20T13:11:26.1372401Duncan ScottThere is a commonly held axiom regarding these kinds of issues along the lines of "everyone who can speak Gaelic can speak English just as well, there's no reason to have it in Gaelic too." I think this should be turned on it's head. I can't think of a reason why it shouldn't be both in Gaelic and in English, Scotland's two languages. When we're at it, why shouldn't it be in some of our other minority languages too? (I would have written this in Gaelic, but some of the Gaelic letters were not recognised.)18082013-05-20T13:30:54.9672402Domhnall DomhnallachNan leanadh an riaghaltas an argamaid aca gu bheil a h' uile duine a' tuigsinn a' Bheurla co-dhiu, carson a dheanadh iad rud sam bith airson na Gaidhlig?\r\n\r\nIf the government stick to their argument that everybody understands English anyway, why would they do anything for Gaelic?18082013-05-20T16:47:39.7172403Mary CampbellEvery effort must be made to raise awareness of how devastating this illness is and how it not only affects the sufferer but also all their family and friends. Lots more work needed.18132013-05-20T17:51:40.8472404William FrielIn the last year, my wife has had to spend time in a small shared room (4 patients) in Edinburgh Royal Infirmary for two weeks. I am positive that the company and shared experience helped with her recovery. In addition, the oldest patient was on occasion bewildered and forgetful. They cared for and ensured that the staff took her needs into account. Only those with an infectuous disease should have to suffer in isolation. 18182013-05-20T22:38:53.3232405John O'BrienTir gan teanga, tir gan anam!\r\n\r\nA land without a language is a land without a soul.18082013-05-22T00:10:33.9772406A J Brown.God bless the health service of this country ...pity they offer to help them whom least need or deserve....c,mon people we need some of that old dunkirk spirit.please help push this message home we can not stand by and let people be treated like second class citizen's.let our voices be heard. united we must stand.18132013-05-22T06:45:33.7332407Roisin FrielAge should not be a barrier to being cared for, simple.18132013-05-23T00:36:31.6032409Christie NicIlleathainThis is got to be done, for the language to grow, tobe appreciated as one of Scotlands' languages and to be taken seriously as a strong part in our country's culture, heritage and future. Gaidhlig agus Alba gu brath!' ' 18082013-05-23T14:49:26.6432410Myra Lamont MBEDementia is a terminal progressive syndrome that can affect individuals under the age of 65,due to factors not associated with age. Syndromes can be of neurological, vascular, as well as Alzheimer's Disease, there are over 3,000 individuals under 65 with this condition in Scotland. People diagnosed with any terminal illness have the options of excellent palliative care in Scotland.People with advanced stages of dementia have the same Right to a range of NHS palliative care services. It is discrimanatory that these individuals requiring palliative care for a progressive illness classified under the dementia umbrella, have to pay for that care, irrespective of age. This is a breach of Human Rights. It is now a matter for the Scottish Government to address in the next National Dementia Strategy the health needs of people under the age of 65. 18132013-05-23T15:04:09.8432411Joan FlemingDecision makers have a duty to fully understand the devastating implications of this ilness for the carer, cared for and care providers. The information and evidence is available - please use it and do the right thing.18132013-05-23T15:05:12.812412Seonaid MacLeanWishing you the best for this very important campaign. Keep up the good work!18132013-05-23T16:05:28.4372413Iain HarrisonAge should NOT be an issue in any giving treatment to anyone really.\r\n18132013-05-23T18:06:01.8472414Kelly MacinnesWishing you all the best with the campaign 18132013-05-23T18:06:33.7532415wilma young cameron II think it should be free for all !! no matter what age \r\n\r\n18132013-05-23T18:22:09.32417Jacqueline LairdWishing you every success with your campaign . Good luck \r\n18132013-05-23T18:57:10.6872418Linda SpaldingLiving with and caring for an Alzheimer's sufferer is extremely difficult and stressful enough without having to worry about the financial hardship. Free personal care should be compulsory for all such patients regardless of age.18132013-05-23T19:28:06.2672419Paula BeveridgeDreadful illness, support should be readily available for it18132013-05-23T19:36:15.2972420Donna DyeGood luck with your campaign Amanda,,, and thank you for raising awareness of this heartbreaking illness. 18132013-05-23T20:27:10.652421Mairi McArthurThis is a campaign so worthwhile fighting for. Good luck.18132013-05-23T20:44:44.792422Lynne ReillyWishing you & your family every success with your campaign. 18132013-05-24T09:40:28.1672423Margaret AlexanderThose with Alzheimer's and those who care for them more than need our awareness. A very worthwhile campaign.18132013-05-24T15:39:46.392424Catherine KellyI could write a book on the horrors of Alzheimer's and Dementia sufferers and their carers. The system is appalling and unfair. I have been in and out of Nursing homes for more than 20 years, visiting family members, one of whom was only 57 years old when it started. It is shocking that your relatives have to wait until 65 years old to be counted as a deserving case for free care. The rest of our family dread ever having this horrendous illness.18132013-05-25T21:15:32.2532426Gordon MasonFrank is only just older than me and I remember him as a great player down the left side for United as they became a force in Europe. As such, he did a great deal for the image of Scotland abroad and Scotland should support him at this time.18132013-05-26T01:25:07.32427Wilma McPhersonI am visiting relatives in Tasmania and we attended the Alzheimer's Austrtalia 15th National Conference in Hobart. My brother was diagnosed 4 years ago .We attended workshops covering Rehabilitation, Leisure, creativity, wellbeing, research and liberation It was hertening to see all the areas that were covered and also speaking to dedicated people who are,working together to ultimately to achieve better treatments and eventually a cure.\r\nWhen I return I will dedicate my time to help this good cause which is noiw very close to my heart..18132013-05-26T01:42:56.5932429Joyce MacleodMy husband has been battling alzheimers dementia for approximately 4 years. He was diagnosed at age 63 which was a great shock to us as a family.\r\n\r\nMy sister has been visiting us in Tasmania and we attended ther Alzheimer'ds Australia fifteenth national conferernce in Hobart.\r\n\r\nThe conference was excrellent andf covered so many areas experienced by people suffering from dementia and their families and carers.\r\n\r\nI have great admiration for everyone involved who works nd are continuously researching toi obtain better treatments and breakthroughs in the hope to eventually finding a cure.18132013-05-26T10:27:26.462430john barclayglad to help in some small way for a gentleman.18132013-05-27T16:17:16.012431George A H FergusonSuas leis a' Ghaidhlig! Up with Gaelic!18082013-05-27T17:24:50.52432Cairistiona GhreumachDear Parliament, please have the courage of your convictions. You have a Gaelic department, have helped and encouraged the use of Gaelic in many ways over the years. It won't cost a penny more to write the important question in Gaelic - or for that matter, Scots. Do not risk losing our support.18082013-05-27T17:52:21.1772433Rod MackenzieI know that there will be few, if any, potential referendum voters who will be disadvantaged by having the ballot paper in English. However, the issue is really that of extending to the Gaelic language the recognition and respect it deserves as one of Scotland's main indigenous languages. Our Scottish government has committed itself to such recognition so it should ensure that the ballot paper is bilingual Gaelic & English. Whether or not we are speakers of Gaelic, we should surely sign this petition simply on the grounds of principle and fairness.18082013-05-28T10:03:49.4232434Fiona MackenzieIndigenous languages have to be given the respect and recognition that should rightfully placed upon them. It's not even about Gaelic as such, but about understanding the huge importance a country's linguistic heritage plays in building confidence and respect within it's social structure.18082013-05-28T10:33:32.082435Iain MeldrumHaving experienced Alzheimer's at close quarters with both of my wife's parents, this is a devastating illness that unfortunately only ever appears to get worse. Age should not be a criteria for help for care and I add my support for this petition to help all sufferers and their families cope with this disease.18132013-05-28T10:46:03.5872436Jennifer CantwellLanguage is part of culture, culture is part of identity. Its not about understanding English its about saying, this is part of our identity we respect our culture. 18082013-05-28T13:34:01.162437Ian MacKenzie TelferAs an economist I totally believe that an Independent Scotland will bring enormous benefits. Dennis Healey the former Chancellor has now admitted that the London Government has always totally underplayed the value of North Sea Oil. As a Gaelic columnist I feel that it is essential that all official proclamations should also be written in Gaeli18082013-05-28T20:09:41.3972438russell & sheona smithRemember we all grow old and many of us may fall victim to this scourge . It doesn't pick and choose & this is certainly obvious in Franks case for someone to be so fit and yet struck down. Russell & Sheona Smith. 18132013-05-29T20:10:36.4772439Cynthia StentGood luck with your petition I know first hand what you are going through and admire everything you are doing when you have enough to do with Frank. 18132013-05-29T23:36:28.0732440Colin SmythMy father recently passed away in hospital in a single room. A single room was appropriate for his final days, but before then he shared a room with three other patients. The company he kept helped pass the days and his company helped those he shared with in their recovery, including him being able to call for assistance when the gentlemen in the bed across from him fell out of bed in the middle of the night and was unable to raise the alarm himself. I can only wonder what would have happened had he fell out of bed in a single room. 18182013-05-30T07:46:33.1872441Colin WyperI recently spent a month in DGRI, most of the time I was in a 4 bed ward and would not have had it any other way, the few days I spent on my own I felt isolated, hardly saw a sould for hours on end and was really down. If this had continued for the full month I would have had major depression. While in a 4 bed ward we all looked out for one another and on many, many occasions had to ring for a nurse on others behalf, had we not been there goodness knows how long it would have taken a nurse to happen upon the problems. 18182013-05-30T17:15:20.632442Christine Fraser Fight the good fight xxx you need to be the voice of the voiceless. Only if you can really make people listen will they try to do something to help those in your position and there are many 18132013-05-31T00:19:23.842443betty gledhillThis should apply to all dementia sufferers, not just alzheimers. Pick's disease is even worse.18132013-05-31T18:58:56.4132444Ann BellMy mother-in-law died last year and she had Alzheimer's. Good Luck with the fight and I hope you win.18132013-06-02T10:23:16.4672445Lisa FultonThis is an utter shambles for families I should know I had to fight same case year 2000 when I already had a child starting P3 at same school .... I was one the lucky ones in the end up my son eventually got the last place !! 18112013-06-02T11:38:04.1972446Jacqui McMinnShocking that the authorities are willing to separate siblings & perhaps force women to leave their jobs. I say women as traditionally women earn less & therefore more likely to stop working. 18112013-06-02T12:44:49.6772447Shibani HarveyOur family could be in this very situation next year. Thoroughly supporting this campaign in the hope that the voives of concerned parents are heard. It the right thing to do.18112013-06-02T12:52:53.6172448Shibani HarveyWe could be in this situation next year. Thoroughly supporting this campaign in the hope that the voices of concerned parents are heard. It's the right thing to do.18112013-06-02T13:20:21.112449Laura phelpsThings need to change to allow more children in 18112013-06-02T19:58:47.9932450ashish dahiya this is child molestation it should not happen18162013-06-02T20:00:14.112451Mattias Samuelssonit's a disgrace, in this time and age that one has to opt out for something one has not chosen to take part of.. that you are automatically set up to take part of a religion, without even getting asked if it is what you want... it's a disgrace that people would shamelessly exploit this in order to "lure" kids into a religious belief system... it should be illegal, and it should be the complete other way around.. you should first get asked if you want to participate, nd hopefully not until you are old enough to make use of critical thinking so that you have a chance to reject it if it does not appear sound to you... imagine a different place where people that are religious are automatically set up to take part of something that is not part of their belief, or even the complete opposite of what they believe.. imagine how a christian would feel or react if he is without getting asked, set up as if he were a worshiper of satan, or any other fantasy character... that is exactly what is done to people who never asked for it, but that are expected to "opt out" ..it really is a shame and a disgrace, and i would expect more from a place in this part of the world.18162013-06-03T11:45:56.4032453DJ MacIntyreEqual respect- Cha chan mi an corr!18082013-06-03T14:28:11.7832454Robert CanningA teacher who tells atheist children to pray and worship is encouraging dishonesty.18162013-06-03T15:22:54.1572455George MuirI urge the Scottish Parliament to take steps to overturn the effects of the pernicious cultural vandalism to which Gaelic has been subjected for almost a thousand years.\r\nProvide a bi-lingual ballot paper for the independence referendum!18082013-06-03T18:14:01.2932456AlistairNo single religion at school but a knowledge of all options and the main thrusts should be part of general knowledge.18162013-06-03T18:40:40.7632457Keith ChartersI have a simple test of fairness: turn things around. If they're still fair, fine. So let's apply this test. Assume all children are to be pro-actively taught that no gods exist. Religious parents can choose to have their children singled out to walk out of the class before the lesson, with everyone looking at them. Would religions think that was acceptable?18162013-06-03T19:02:54.9272458RonnieNo place for fairy tales in modern society.18162013-06-03T19:49:01.3532459Fiona m JohnstonMake up for lost time NOW!18082013-06-03T21:30:59.6272460James RigbySchool are places of learning. By all means teach children about religion, but forcing them to take part in praise of a supernatural being who's existence is highly questionable has nothing to do with education at all, and everything to do with indoctrination. I hope that a progressive Scotland will act to ensure that only those children who's parents expressly permit it, are required to take part in these sessions.18162013-06-03T21:49:50.6732461Kenny SmithCeartas airson na Gaidhlig! Justice for Gaelic!18082013-06-03T22:10:35.2532462Peter Hinchliffe It should absolutely be an opt in if schools are going to be used as places of worship, there is no reason to presume it is alright to preach to children about any faith. Teach don't Preach.18162013-06-03T22:19:28.8172463Andrew Galeawhy should an unfounded ideology, with a history of breeding violence, dishonesty and injustice, enjoy special privileges? 18162013-06-03T23:27:00.662464Norry PasswayStill recall the moment of clarity when, as a child in a church for a school service, I decided not to bow my head and pray - as we had all been led to do - and rather looked up and around and in silence observed for myself what was happening. I am completely in favour of RME, but would prefer RO was not part of school education. The faithful can pray in church or similiar institutions as appropriate. This petition however, is perhaps more likely to be successful.18162013-06-03T23:38:16.922465Derek Mc LellanThis is a progressive decision that acknowledges the rights of parents over their child's education. Parents of faith who have children can decide the level and what type of religious education their children receive. Likewise, parents of no faith can safeguard their children from enforced inculcation and proselytizing.18162013-06-04T07:28:45.62466Stephen CalderI've seen at first hand how invited visiting pastors and extremist sects can use school assemblies for their own ends - preaching eschatological nonsense and telling students they will be going to Hell if they don't follow their belief system and sect. It is clearly unregulated and can amount to propaganda and, at worst, serious abuse.18162013-06-04T08:21:59.812467David WilliamsI think it is outrageous that in a multicultural and secular society there should be any form of religious activity in schools.18162013-06-04T08:30:10.8632468Duncan ForbesPeople should not be forced into being brainwashed by Religion, they should have a choice whether or not they want to take the class.\r\n\r\nAs a child growing up in Scotland in the 80's and 90's both me and my brother were forced to sit through countless hours of Brainwashing in "Religious Studies" in Primary & Seconday school, even though we both had not interested in the fairy tail.\r\n\r\nEven if you said you were an Atheist in secondary school, you were still forced to attend these brainwashing sessions.\r\n\r\nAnd they were both Christian schools.18162013-06-04T09:02:37.6432469Islay ReidUtterly ridiculous that you should have to opt out in this day and age. Forcing religion on children is child abuse.18162013-06-04T09:23:24.522470Duncan Rd WoodwardReligious observance and indoctrination should be illegal in a any school and illegal to be taught to any minor. Its a disgrace that when all the evidence points to these bigoted ideologies being at the root of so much human suffering and for the most part totally fictitious. Mindless Medieval bull! 18162013-06-04T09:25:51.0432471Gwennan HighamPlease listen to the requests of your citizens' right for equal treatment in the referendum. As a Welsh speaker and Gaelic learner, I see this decision to be pivotal for the future of Gaelic in a civic Scotland.18082013-06-04T09:27:10.4972472daniel browndisgusting18162013-06-04T09:44:07.5832473Tom YoungIt is important that children learn about religion but this should be in an unbiased way and all beliefs should be treated equally. Having any religious observance in this way amounts to endorsing one religion over another and is completely inappropriate in a secular country like Scotland.18162013-06-04T10:00:51.6972474Alan D. DuncanI am an ex-pat Scot currently living in Australia. Scotland should be taking the lead on encouraging a secular society. Religion has no place in politics and should not be part of Scotland's enviable education system. Please act to remove the influence of religious bodies on all state-funded schools. 18162013-06-04T10:03:32.462475Robert J S ChristieThe inculcation of faith in children is a matter for parents and should not be dependent on third parties.18162013-06-04T10:08:49.9472477Colin McLeanI think children should be taught about all religions and not just taught religion 18162013-06-04T10:20:28.252478Stuart DonohoeBelief in religious nonsense is perpetuated through children being forced into it before they are able to make a rational decision for themselves. I feel that religious groups are aware of this and want to exploit the young and fertile minds of our most precious children to keep their little club going. Disgusting. get it out of our schools NOW. 18162013-06-04T10:36:23.272479Hannah MostertPlease can you start a petition in South Africa, we need more voices here18162013-06-04T11:23:10.8672480Angela McLarenThere should be no RO in school, schools should be secular and Religious Educations should be non bais18162013-06-04T11:40:36.8672481Rory McLarenNo RO in schools18162013-06-04T11:49:29.762482Donald RintoulCovering up the opt out certainly happened in my time at school in the 80s. I was brought up in a secular family and have always opposed religion being rammed down my throat. This of course brought me into conflict with the school authorities. Particularly when I tried to duck out. Considering one option for evading religious dogma was corporal punishment, I would consider that to be bullying.\r\nMy school would have better used resources finding a repalcement maths teacher for the year we missed out, than chasing pupils who 'opted out' of the walk to church at every Christian holiday.\r\n It was unacceptable in the 80s to force people to participate in something they have no belief in. It is unacceptable now. Opting in would mean my experience would not be repeated.18162013-06-04T12:27:09.872483Russell FreemantleReligion should not be forced on anybody18162013-06-04T12:29:21.1372484William GrahamTake us out of the dark ages and stop this mumbo jumbo, please!18162013-06-04T12:56:26.1172485Iain ReidWe live in a country that our politicians say prides itself on its multiculturalism and freedoms. Why should children have to feel like pariahs because their parents are one of the few to actually go to the bother (or be aware of the right) of having them opt out? The state should not be forcing religious indoctrination on the youngest, most pliable minds in society in a place they are led to believe is a source of truth.18162013-06-04T12:58:12.0232486Mike TanguayCompletely irresponsible to force upon humanity observance of a force that has raped the dignity of humanity. Stop this. The religious are free to observe freely and in peace, but why mandate that it must be "opted out?" Call me another stupid American, but I don't think you need a reason to opt out of listening to a lie.18162013-06-04T13:36:11.8632487Pauline LynchThere are so many areas of life for children to learn about. Why, in an increasingly secular society, do schools waste time on religion? There are not enough hours. Choosing to take a child out of religious education stigmatises that child. The present system is unfair and unreasonable.18162013-06-04T14:10:33.4932488Bryan JacksonStop brainwashing kids18162013-06-04T14:35:47.332489Brian RossJustice and fairness for Frank and all sufferers. Good luck with the campaign.18132013-06-04T14:45:46.552490Laughlan SmithMake it happen18162013-06-04T15:01:32.8832491Richard J LaingNever believed in a system that tells people there is an invisible man in the sky. Teach kids anything other than that load of tripe18162013-06-04T16:06:13.9872492Franz GrimleyIn this day and age no one should be compelled to do anything.18162013-06-04T16:34:54.522493DuncanThe religious population in Scotland is an aging and increasingly irrelevant one. Religious observance should in no way still be the default position taught in schools. It's a backwards tradition and one that should end now.18162013-06-04T16:48:29.592494Brian SmillieWell done to Secular Scotland for raising this awareness .18162013-06-04T17:06:15.2932495Crawford MackiePersonally I would go further. I don't want religion inflicted on children in schools even at their parents' wishes. 18162013-06-04T17:13:01.72496Graham RamsayTime to grow up and leave the fairy stories behind.18162013-06-04T17:14:43.8772497AudI was brought up in the sectarian atmosphere of west Scotland. The sooner all schools are secular the less hatred there will be.18162013-06-04T17:42:34.7672499Karen KerrI went to a school that taught religion, as if it were absolute fact, the ideas that were foisted on young minds, were often frightening, and damaging. I don't think that anyone, schools, parents or religious groups have the right to impose their beliefs on children. If adults choose to believe, that their choice, but they should be able to come to that decision, with a mature mind18162013-06-04T18:26:00.712500Alasdair H. MacinnesGaelic is a living language in Scotland. Those who have learned it as children, or who have chosen to acquire it, have improved access to other languages and to Scottish culture,past, present and future. 18082013-06-04T19:53:50.112501Ron McPheeAnd not afore time.18162013-06-04T20:10:44.0632502James BurgonTeaching children about other peoples beliefs is an important and noble thing for the education system to do, but the state should be secular and faith personal. Pressuring a child into Christian worship is wrong, and though not the intent an opt-out system does just this. 18162013-06-04T20:34:51.242503Rosemary SceatsI believe that religious indoctrination of children amounts to child abuse. Children should be taught critical, evidence-based thinking, not brainwashed with ancient, irrational superstition. They should be free to make up their own minds about what they believe, and what is even believable. Young children subjected to religious indoctrination are incapable of this.18162013-06-04T20:36:02.7872504Holly RobertsSigned. All the best in the campain to ensure all our family will be looked after should they need it regardless of age.18132013-06-04T20:36:51.1132505Hazel LewryI'd prefer no religion in school - full stop! Leave the brainwashing and indoctrination to the family, if they can be bothered.18162013-06-04T21:15:01.542506Ailith StewartHaving had a good family friend suffer from Alzheimers, I wish you success with the campaign.18132013-06-04T21:15:54.9532507Ranald MacKechnieHow can there be a referendum on Scottish independence without equivalent wording in Gaelic -- and Scots?!18082013-06-04T21:37:34.8732508Pat CrawfordThe practice of religion is not an appropriate activity for schools to impose on pupils.\r\n\r\nExploring world religions (including a study of atheism and agnostcism) is perfectly appropriate but it must be facilitated in an unbiased and open manner.18162013-06-04T21:55:01.082509Alan McBroomEducation proves religion is a load of rubbish, so why mix the two.18162013-06-04T22:05:29.5432510VikkiI would like to opt out, but I don't know of any parents who do (regardless of their beliefs) so I don't want my children to have to be treated differently. I'd rather there wasn't religious observation at all. 18162013-06-04T22:42:13.022511Kate JoesterOpting out of something you aren't actually told will happen - and try getting accurate information out of a four-year-old about what goes on at school - is not an appropriate level of choice.18162013-06-04T23:01:44.572512pamela angeliniWe all know how important this is in order to keep our kids together at school. 18112013-06-04T23:52:46.0672513Eve MorrisAs a Jewish child, I was compelled to attend Christian worship at my school and always found it profoundly uncomfortable. It was the beginning of a system which Othered people from non-Christian faiths. I am now an atheist, and I still find the idea that this secular country compels children to join in religious worship appalling.18162013-06-04T23:59:38.9072514Martin MacInnesexcellent idea18162013-06-05T00:56:03.182515Sherry ByrdSaor Alba!18082013-06-05T01:01:59.0872516Tam McTurkCarson nach eil?18082013-06-05T07:49:40.6832517Helen JohnsonIf the Scottish government really wants to keep Gaelic alive, they need to be a great deal more proactive both in education and legislation in promoting the language - making a certain amount of Gaelic compulsory in schools, for example and making it so that people can't be employed without a certain amount of Gaelic. 18082013-06-05T08:08:59.7872518Peadar O DonnghaileIn point "Language rights" must be interpreted as "human rights" for those who speak a language because a language is not a legal person and therefore cannot of itself have rights. 18082013-06-05T09:48:40.632519Tracey LomasDementia is a debilitating and humiliating condition that has a huge impact on both the sufferers and those who care for them and with an aging population the problems are only going to increase. Please give patients and their families more support!18132013-06-05T09:51:52.492520Alan RogersWhen I have succeed in making organised religion fund religious care in NHS Wales hospitals (£1.3 million p.a.) I will begin a campagn in Wales like yours. Good luck.18162013-06-05T10:14:41.2232521Barry KeylockEducation is about knowledge, not belief or opinion. Schools should be built on a secular foundation. Religion should be a personal thing, for the home and church.18162013-06-05T10:22:50.1472522David FrierWhy weren't the instructions on filling in the petition given in Gaelic too?18082013-06-05T10:42:34.512523Stewart CoeMore than happy to have religion feature as an element of history, modern studies, social science but the place for observance is church and the choice should be entirely personal.18162013-06-05T10:47:16.5832524George JonesNarach, direach, gun smaointichte air a leithid a dheanamh ann am Beurla a-mhain! Narach cuideachd nach leig larach na parlamaid leam litrichean le stracan a chur a-staigh!\r\n\r\nIt is just shameful that it should even be considered that the like should be done in English only. It is shameful too that the Parliament’s website won’t let me insert letters with accents18082013-06-05T11:03:33.6732525James ClarkShould have been done a long time ago.18162013-06-05T11:52:33.7632526Alison LindsayI went to School in the 50's when children were still belted for speaking Gaelic. I cannot speak Gaelic in consequence\r\n18082013-06-05T12:36:18.832527Andrew WoodI would like to see a mixture of both single and multi occupancy rooms, as I do agree with single rooms for infection control after major surgery, with patient then moving into multi for general recovery.\r\nI would also like to see the return of a ward sister with full control of all duties and being very much a part of the shift changeover, so that family and friends can get the correct information on patient progress, as this is not happening within D&G infirmary at present.18182013-06-05T13:00:05.532528gerry gallacheronward forward to a free thinking society18162013-06-05T14:29:02.632529G. PetrieI was not aware of this possible change.\r\nI'm not against my kids going to RO in principle, but I think that you should have to choose to go to a religious event, rather it just assumed that you will. 18162013-06-05T14:43:41.0032530Duncan CuthillSeems like an ironic law, my reading of the gospels is that Jesus didn't make anyone do anything. On the contrary, he welcomed children and encouraged personal choice and responsibility. Also, church tends to flourish when it is on the margins of and serving society so ending this law might be good for Christianity too? The discussion is particularly interesting in a Scottish context since an emphasis on education was a distinctive of the Scottish reformation, again, it seems odd that Christianity has now become entangled in the education system in this way. If there is to be RO in schools in a predominantly non church attending country, opt-in sounds fair to me. 18162013-06-05T15:32:26.2172531William TwycrossFaith develops within the individual and is personal. Like wise the choice of where and when it is expanded and re-enforced is also a personal choice. 18162013-06-05T16:29:25.7872532Louise Cousins, Ridiculous!18082013-06-05T16:33:47.862533Lillis O LaoireNormalisation means just that. 18082013-06-05T17:19:45.912534Seumas Mac an t-sagairtSimple really - 'The Gaelic Language (Scotland) Act 2005 (the Act), passed by the Scottish Parliament, seeks to secure the status of Gaelic as an official language of Scotland commanding equal respect to the English language.' 18082013-06-05T17:42:40.12536Kara Jane PaulI hope you get what you are wishing for18132013-06-05T18:54:52.2932537Scott MacDonaldFeumaidh Gaidhlig a bhith air a phaiper-bhotaidh airson neo-eisimilach na h-Alba. 'Se 'English only' an t-seorsa rud a bha duil againn bho Westminster agus tha mi an dochas nach dean Parlamaid na h-Alba an aon rud.\r\n\r\nGaelic must be on the voting paper for the independence referendum. ‘English only” is the type of thing we would expect from Westminister and I would hope that the Scottish Parliament wouldn’t do the same thing.18082013-06-05T19:00:31.0332538Caroline WallerThis is directly affecting us at the moment , my daughter has been refused a place at the school her sibling goes to. We appealed with two other families, they got in and we didn't . Explain that to a four year old :-(18112013-06-05T21:23:08.9872539alex dalgettiethis situation is a nightmare that is hitting mostly hard working families , the children should all go to the same school , it is crazy to have different ones 18112013-06-05T21:26:22.6572540Jacqueline walker This is a disgrace. Sort it out ASAP . 18112013-06-05T21:47:33.3372541StewartVery happy to support this - and I'm a Catholic.18162013-06-05T23:05:12.162542Alistair MackayWhy not?18082013-06-05T23:09:40.622543Theresa RitchieI walked into a local school one afternoon on business and found 100 young dancing, singing and clapping to a Kidz Club Evangelical Church group who I discovered go into every primary school in town once a week and perform a cutesie style encouraging kids to be 'saved'. Scary. I know their background - they are fundamentalist, miracle believing, signs and wonders woshipping church who encourage children to come to their 'Kidz Club' after school. Parents just don't know the depth of the belief of these people and it's hard to say no to their children. This has no place in school.18162013-06-05T23:28:03.012544Katherine NapoliShould have heard about this before now!18082013-06-06T00:10:37.6372545Dj MacdonaldAs an official language of Alba the referendum should also be available in Gaidhlig. Actions speak louder than words. 18082013-06-06T07:51:58.3732546Remy HallidayShocking decision!18112013-06-06T10:29:09.7572547Fiona SetterySurely keeping families together should be a major priority. ...unbelievable decision! 18112013-06-06T12:31:21.0572548DavidWhy should children be made to subjected to the ramblings of the deranged?18162013-06-06T12:42:58.3832549Jean BuckettGood luck with the campaign. Everyone deserves to be treated fairly.18132013-06-06T16:43:21.3772550Mark DaleScotland should follow the lead of its auld alliance partners France, and adopt this policy.18162013-06-06T16:47:06.1772551Kevin EdwardIt is absurd that schools still have this, often opt out is not mentioned almost like a not asked don't tell situation, children that are removed from observance are made to feel outcast by the school and made fools off. Parents I know don't want the observance, however don't opt out as it is less stressful for the child who would otherwise be made to feel excluded. Enough is enough18162013-06-06T17:12:06.512552Archie MacbethI survived a Plymouth Brethren upbringing and would hope to shield future kids from that.18162013-06-06T17:35:56.8672553Julie WallerDisgusted at the lack of humanity in this decision.18112013-06-06T20:25:13.7372554Mark NotarangeloGood Luck Aunt Amanda you are a true inspiration to us all god bless you in your fight for justice!18132013-06-06T20:46:51.7772555Ann CorstorphineAll the best with your petition and power to your elbow for all your effort. 18132013-06-06T22:58:56.2132556Linda SimeWish we had the right to 'opt out' when I was at school. Even as a primary school student, I knew I was being taught a lot of nonsense under the guise that these fairy stories were FACTUAL!18162013-06-07T07:50:55.812557Robert HowittReligion should be taught in your place of worship NOT in a school.18162013-06-07T08:37:28.9132558MandyGood luck with the campaign.18132013-06-07T11:55:41.822559Shaomin lee-murrayKeep education secular.18162013-06-07T12:02:01.7172560Gilbert McGill The introduction of single rooms is an attempt to hide the true picture of falling hygiene standards in hospitals and has nothing to do with improving patient care.18182013-06-07T14:51:08.3572561T dalzielHaving recently spent a few unexpected days as a patient in ward 6 I would worry dreadfully about the single room status. During my three day stay in a four bedded unit each and every one of us in that room (age ranges from early forties to seventies) had moments of upset, anxiety etc and each and every one of us supported each other with a laugh or an ear. I dread to think the impact single rooms will have on patients general wellbeing. Socialisation is necessary, help from each other when nurses are pushed to the limit is necessary. \r\nAsk the patients not the doctors !18182013-06-07T21:20:20.362562Catherine PittendreighMy husband was a patient on three separate periods in Dumfries Royal Infirmary in 2011. Each time he was in four-bed rooms. The friendliness of families visiting other patients sharing the rooms helped and encouraged me through a difficult time. This would not be likely to occur if all patients had been isolated in separate rooms.18182013-06-07T21:36:08.552563Sandy PittendreighRecent spell in hospital convince me that sharing the day in a four-bedded room with others is far more preferable to being isolated in a single room. Such groups quickly develop relationships of friendliness and concern for the wellbeing of others. This often transfers into practical outcomes where concerns are aired and experiences shared.18182013-06-07T21:51:16.852564Pearl BissettI am not in favour of single rooms the reason being I was in the Golden Jubilee in January for a total hip replacement in January , and it is single rooms. I was in for 10 days and it was very lonely as I did not have any visitors. Too far to travel.18182013-06-07T23:25:00.3332565robbieover 20 years ago my parents supported me in opting out of religious observance. i was the only one at the school to do so and had to sit outside the headmaster's office, in the place where kids due to be disciplined normally sat. attendance at any religious ceremonies in a secular society should only ever be by a positive choice - ie opt in.18162013-06-08T11:29:24.792566Gordon BarrieRO shouldn't even be a part of schools IMO18162013-06-08T13:44:30.9572567Richard TI hope you win your fight!18132013-06-08T20:35:56.632568Margaret PollittHave noted the isolation of patients in private hospitals at weekends with few staff available and thought they were very vulnerable if any setback suddenly occurred18182013-06-08T23:32:13.0272569Jane IngallI would be so afraid to be alone in a hospital room if I was ill.18182013-06-08T23:36:14.1372570J.L. IngallStaff are too busy to look after single rooms properly and so those in single rooms may be left alone in crisis unable to get attention18182013-06-08T23:43:59.3832571eirinnReligion should be a choice, and not forced on children.18162013-06-09T09:46:51.062572Alison PerryReligion has no place in schools anymore as it is not the majority anymore18162013-06-09T11:39:54.132573clement david proudlockpersonal experiernce of single rooms was not good when i was in a four bed ward we watched out for each other moral was also higher18182013-06-09T15:40:49.7872574Robin RaybouldWe have the means to teach our children without influencing them with religion.18162013-06-09T17:40:42.572575Keith BromleyEnd all privileges and benefits for non-secular activity18162013-06-09T19:25:53.2932576YvonneWithout people like Amanda, things would never change for the better. Good luck Amanda, they can't ignore you.18132013-06-09T19:27:29.392577Janet LaidlawI was in Edinburgh Hospital last year in both single and shared wards and I positively disliked the single room, except for the private bathroom which was wonderful. So shared rooms with bathroom facilities for each bed. 18182013-06-09T21:12:18.5832578IAN RODGERMENTAL WELLBEING IS VITAL, BE IT TO AID RECOVERY OR TO MAKE THE MOST OF WHATEVER TIME ONE HAS. MANY PREFER COMPANY, SO PLEASE GIVE THEM THE CHOICE TO HAVE IT. 18182013-06-10T08:56:01.0632579Billy SandsHow absurd that the default position is opt out. World views should not be forced on anyone - by stealth or otherise18162013-06-10T09:13:30.982580Brent Cheethamto be fair to all- it is only right that folks should have to opt-in if they require their children to have "RE" !18162013-06-10T11:43:54.542581Ruth PatersonI have had two hospital stays for hip replacements and found being on a ward with others most companiable. A single room may be appropriate at certain stages of recovery but there should be an option.18182013-06-10T18:40:43.8072582Julie SimkinsAll patients should be given choice. Single rooms do not suit everyone.18182013-06-10T21:59:36.1672583Rona Scottgood luck Amanda,so many people behind you 18132013-06-11T15:06:50.42584Jez KempstonReligion is on the way out.... quite rightly18162013-06-11T16:42:48.5032585Allison StevensonReligion should be practiced in any place of worship but not made compulsory in education. The time in school should be given to more productive topics.18162013-06-11T20:33:26.2472587Philip AllanI respect others' religious views, but religion should be restricted to the home, and the chosen church of that home.18162013-06-12T16:07:34.9372588Patricia CairdI see absolutely no need nor requirement for religion to be part of a secular education except as an embedded within such Social Science subjects as History, Politics, Languages etc. where the historical and current role of different religions could be accurately recounted within the context of the individual subject. Religious Observance classes should be replaced with Critical Thinking and Philosophy classes and religious instruction should be treated as a private matter for individual parents and not given undue status within Public Sector Education.18162013-06-12T18:40:33.9132589Graeme McKigganMy kids have been bullied because we did opt out. Education should be about facts.18162013-06-12T18:51:03.6372590Tim AbernethySchools are there to educate, not to be proselytized Pupils should have the option to decide to go to services, but not be expected to go by default. The worrying and shocking emergence of Creationism and science-deniers in our education system is a source of great concern and should be redressed sharply.18162013-06-12T22:12:15.7572591James YuleOpt in offends no one18162013-06-13T00:24:21.4832592HelenI didn't realise I could opt out of religious observance in High School. I sat through hours of services (at a non-denominational school), some of which implied that I as an atheist had a defective moral compass due to my lack of belief in someone's god, because I thought it compulsory to everyone save for those who were of different religions. Frankly I would have preferred to spend an hour in supported study.18162013-06-13T01:29:27.0372593helen mcmahon I cared for my father with dementia for 12 years and being a registered mental health nurse did not make the experience any easier, we need training for corida, need increased respite for carers, and of course increased support from the NHS not less. Guardianship process improved to prevent issues for all, and more RMN's top care in the community but not from existing funds, which are a result of ward closures but from new money\r\n18132013-06-13T05:49:38.5572594Michael RichardsonWhen I was at school, Religious Education class was always considered a "free" period because there was no exams to take and therefore no need to study or even really to show up at class. If schools have to teach religion, they should offer all belief systems equally or none at all.18162013-06-13T08:31:51.412595Teresa BransonIsolation is not psychologically beneficial to most people. A choice should be given to patients in hospital.18182013-06-13T08:53:26.8072596Robert McLeanGood luck, in blazing a new awareness and collective responsibility18132013-06-14T09:02:56.8932597Angus BrownThis proposed change is a logical and fairer\r\nmethod for both believers and non-believers\r\nand offers parents a wider choice of their personal wishes.18162013-06-14T12:52:41.742598Pete GregsonI have thoroughly explored the problem of scottish class sizes at www.kidsnotsuits.com18112013-06-14T16:17:50.9632599Ian CobbI think religious observance should be banned from all schools. That's not going to happen, so as a minimum the pupils should be allowed to opt-in to any religious service. OK, if that's still a bit too strong, at least allow 16 year-olds to opt-out especially as the Scottish Government considers them capable of voting on Scottish "independence".18162013-06-15T16:15:42.162600Magister iratusI believe children should not be forced into a particular religion and to let themselves decide when they are old enough to make an informed decision.18162013-06-15T17:04:35.962601John WiltshireThe primary spiritual virtue of science is honesty. Those who claim to know outrageously unlikely facts about the Universe that are not underwritten by science should not be allowed to impose their views on the young by default. They should be challenged to explain, in all honesty, how they can know what science doesn't know. It is dishonest to claim that religious belief is a reliable source of truth about the Universe. It is not. Ask Galileo. We must look to science for that truth and the honesty of science should be the default and parents should be encouraged to think very carefully before opting their children into the dishonesty of religion and its claim to know what cannot be known.18162013-06-17T15:44:08.5872602andrena milnegood luck Amanda and Frank x\r\n18132013-06-18T00:39:47.8332603Margaret MilneThe worst illness going, my husband has it and he has lost his whole personality and quality of life, more money needs to be put into research and awareness as far as advertising etc you here of all the other charities but very little about Alzheimer's 18132013-06-18T11:24:40.082604stefanie jamiesonGood luck amanda and frank. X18132013-06-18T13:59:37.852605Kev SheehanAll the best to a legend and a wondeful lady.18132013-06-18T16:54:12.4032606SteveNo one should be forced to pray.18162013-06-18T21:57:46.372607Allen KerrReligious indoctrination has no place in education. Children should not be frog-marched into assembly and forced to pray to a certain god of a certain religion. I'm employed to teach, not to convert.18162013-06-18T22:30:00.4232608Andrew CI don't think it should be "opt in" either! If you want your child to learn that load of twaddle then teach them it yourself. Schools will still be able to teach good morals etc without the "Christian" label attached. In fact if they were true Christian schools they'd be teaching homophobia, racism, sexism etc.18162013-06-19T00:35:31.822609HarrisBeliefs and ideologies should not be enforced on children in any way, shape or form! Let them make up their own minds through their innate curiosity!18162013-06-19T11:44:16.8672610Brian GreatorexKeep up the good work Amanda!18132013-06-19T18:57:25.8472611Julian AdkinsChildren should be taught about religions in the diversity in a balanced and factual way so they can decide for themselves how they wish to interact with these traditions. It is not the job of the state to promote religious observance of any kind.18162013-06-19T20:50:22.562612Keith GilmourI have taught RME-RMPS (secondary) for over ten years. For the first few years, I taught in six different schools in three different authorities. In my experience, RME-RMPS teachers avoid RO involvement like the plague, fearing this might compromise their neutrality. Christmas and Easter services are held on the last day of term when attendance is low anyway but Muslim, Hindu, Atheist, etc pupils do still turn up and would really have to make quite a fuss to get out of going. Ditto staff! I have known several school chaplains (all Christian) and found most to be friendly and fairly sensible. Services are less religious than they used to be (e.g. pupils listening to the school's gospel choir but not being expected to sing along, reference to a moment of "silent reflection" rather than "prayer", etc). The emphasis is invariably on shared values and a shared sense of wonder. Chaplain assemblies are basically 'Thought for the Day' and are, in my experience (which may not be typical), pretty uncontroversial. I have two tentative reservations about this petition. The first is the language and principle of 'opt-out' and 'opt-in.' (Are any of us pleased to see the children of fundamentalists removed from RME classes, PSE sexual health lessons, LGBT talks, PE dancing, etc? Would we be happy for the children of creationists to 'opt out' of -- or opt not to 'opt in' to -- science lessons on evolution?). Secondly, I worry that religious parents might 'opt-out' of non-denominational schools altogether, if they begin to view them as atheistic. Those reservations aside, I can't see how anyone could object to 'an instruction to attend a religious service' being replaced with 'an invitation to attend a religious service.'18162013-06-19T22:03:39.9772613Ian ArmstrongYoung children will believe anything you tell them and older children just get demotivated by having to sit through boring lectures by the minister. Not to mention the fairly obvious fact that opt out RO is completely outdated. Teaching about religions is important but give the Christian sales pitch a rest. 18162013-06-20T06:58:08.3532614Derek Campbell Very best wishes Frank & Amanda, fitted your kitchen in the Roods Kirriemuir many years ago xx18132013-06-20T09:45:01.942615fergus kingthis country cares more about drug users than it does about people who are ill through no fault of there own, keep up the good work amanda and good luck .18132013-06-20T10:23:13.772616Steve ThomsKeep going Amanda and Frankie18132013-06-20T10:28:04.142617Ross NicollGladly signed . Shocking story but I expect no less from the NHS and the DWP . I've fond memories from Monifieth when we were neighbours and I was class mates with Scott . All the best ....18132013-06-20T10:29:20.5772618Muriel GuthrieGood for you Amanda.Wish you every success. Think about you often-know what you and Frank are going through.18132013-06-20T10:34:08.8632619Tom McGrathAlzheimer's and dementia are both extremely debilitating illnesses for the sufferer and from personal experience are emotionally and physically demanding on the carers and their families. Financial assistance for this type of illness should not have any age barriers to it to help families through the most difficult of times.18132013-06-20T11:03:00.8332620Scott YeatsAll the best Amanda and Frank.18132013-06-20T11:03:59.9432621Claire MortonGood luck with the campaign x18132013-06-20T11:27:54.062622Kevin FraserGood luck with the campaign. Frankie deserves the best treatment available. Treatment and help should not have any barriers to financial assistance. Frankie deserves better and so do all Alzheimers sufferers under the age of 65. Lets hope the government listens. Good luck Amanda and Frankie.18132013-06-20T11:48:24.522623Bob ReillyGood luck Amanda and Frank. No one deserves to have this hastle at a time of great heartache for their loved ones.18132013-06-20T12:44:17.7072624Christopher BennisonBest of luck, Amanda. Shed Rule.18132013-06-20T12:44:35.2532625Murray GrayI hope all Arabs and fellow football fans get behind this campaign......best wishes to Frank and Amanda18132013-06-20T12:50:57.3172626George ShandFrank is one of life's good guys. All the best and good luck with the campaign18132013-06-20T13:13:20.1932627Bob Curranbest Wishes and never stop fighting regardless..x\r\n18132013-06-20T13:24:50.1132628PeeeelArabest, Amanda and Frank!18132013-06-20T13:27:47.352629Lynne Cattanach-RodgerBest Wishes and Good Luck with this campaign18132013-06-20T13:49:22.7772630Marilyn CosgroveThinking of you both x18132013-06-20T16:24:20.432631Alan McLarenThis disease is what took my father, very disturbing seeing what it does to a person and how quickly it does. Not enough done to highlight this disease and to recognise the symptoms sooner.18132013-06-20T16:25:58.6632632john huntergood luck ..shouldn't be age related .Frank Kopel a Utd legend 18132013-06-20T16:54:18.922633Graeme SmithMy mum has this horrible illness. You need all the help you can get. Good luck Amanda Frank was a legend18132013-06-20T16:59:20.762635Ian RobertsonThe very best for a very worthy campaign18132013-06-20T17:04:18.8572636Charlie Stirton As a carer. I know what Amanda is going through, as I look after adults with this disease,good luck,,\r\n18132013-06-20T17:17:23.4272637Jim CrosbieAs a United supporter it is distressing to hear the details of Frank Kopel's illness. the punitive attitude of the DWP comes as no surpirse but we need to make sure the health and social care authorities in Scotland continue to support all those with genuine needs. \r\n\r\n18132013-06-20T17:52:21.8132638ed parkhouseyou were my hero & what a goal18132013-06-20T17:56:49.6432639kelly percyThere is so many people with dementia and alzhimer they should all be treated fairly .18132013-06-20T18:00:57.1932640Andy Crighton & FamilyBest wishes to Amanda & Frankie,good luck in your campaign.18132013-06-20T18:18:52.152641Fiona ReidGood luck xx18132013-06-20T18:20:59.0732642Theresa KennedyThinking about you and your family, keep up the good work xxx18132013-06-20T18:41:05.7532643Ally StrachanPetition signed. This countries health care is a joke at times. Age should not be a factor in all this!18132013-06-20T18:46:32.772644Heather FordUnder 65s with dementia should be entitled to the same benefits as those over 65 due to the levels of care required. I am fully behind the campaign to support this, especially for Frank and those who are also in similar positions.18132013-06-20T18:46:43.6632645margaret masonAll the best Amanda & Frank been there with a member of family its very frustrating and soul destroying to watch xx\r\n18132013-06-20T18:47:32.442646CAMERON MCBAINGive my full support for Mr Frank Kopel18132013-06-20T18:48:20.9132647Rae FordAs a carer who realises the impact this illness has on families, I am fully supportive of Amanda's campaign and well both her and Frank well for the future.18132013-06-20T19:04:21.172648Alistair BoydGood luck18132013-06-20T20:13:11.2932649Doug FrewGood luck in your brave fight. This petition might just be the catalyst for change.18132013-06-20T20:17:16.3532650Steve AllardyceKeep up the good work Amanda.Best wishes to you and Frank.18132013-06-20T20:28:14.232651William CurleyAll the very best....18132013-06-20T20:33:08.6132652Fiona MartinFrank was a DUFC legend! 18132013-06-20T20:45:552653kevin liddellgood luck, my thoughts are with you both. frank a gentleman on and off the park. 18132013-06-20T20:47:41.1272654Dave SneddonGood luck with your campaign Amanda - a truly deserving cause.18132013-06-20T20:52:52.4872655Iain DunbarThe very best of luck with a vitally important campaign. Frank Kopel was a fine player. Remember Anderlecht!18132013-06-20T21:00:09.0732656Scott BaikieFree personal care for our chronically sick, disabled, elderly and mentally ill should be a basic entitlement. It should be a sign of the type of compassionate country most people believe that Scotland and the United Kingdom should be. 18132013-06-20T21:15:51.9732657David NicollAll the best Frank, legend x18132013-06-20T21:19:35.662659claire bertieGood luck x18132013-06-20T21:21:16.1732660Leanne MaillieBest wishes and good luck for the campaign18132013-06-20T21:22:29.9872661jo martinMy nan has dementia its so important that suffers and there family have the support they need 18132013-06-20T22:15:47.5172662sharon ainslieim so sorry ive only just seen this petition, i work with people with dementia on a regular basis, it is such a horrible illness. There needs to be more help out there for sufferers and their families, and nobody should have to fight for what they are entitled to.. good luck Amanda and Frankie18132013-06-20T22:22:43.6572663Lyall RobertsonAll the best to Amanda, Frank and Scott. Frank gave me many happy memories on the pitch and I enjoyed many a good night in the Roods Bar with you both as perfect hosts18132013-06-20T22:33:25.822664Barry macmillanBest of luck with the campaign, a very worthwhile cause and a problem that needs fixing! Xx18132013-06-20T22:34:13.5272665Barry macmillanGood luck with the campaign, a worthwhile cause that needs put in the spotlight.18132013-06-20T23:03:13.9172666Margaret Rose Braid A dreadful illness and becoming more commonplace which is very frightening for everyone.Sufferer's and families need more support.18132013-06-20T23:55:37.12667BruceYour perseverance has been fantastic.Good Luck18132013-06-21T06:08:09.2672668Kerry BainGood luck x18132013-06-21T07:07:42.6972669John & Barbara SherriffSupport Amanda 100% , many people in the same position who simply cannot afford to pay for care , in todays world this sort of - Frank deserves better 18132013-06-21T07:08:17.3532670Ross ForbesWishing the best for Frank and Amanda18132013-06-21T07:51:39.0232671Colin Gillan All the best - with your campaign Amanda and Frank Kopel ( A Dundee United Legend ) 18132013-06-21T08:09:54.9072672stewart w couttsgood luck Amanda & Frank18132013-06-21T08:20:25.3872673AlanNo illness is a respecter of age and care and support should be available for everyone whose life is affected by any debilitating illness which results in the need for care.\r\nGood luck with the campaign18132013-06-21T08:23:38.0472674Dougall MacArthurMy father suffers from this but was over 65 so was entitled to care. Why should the likes of Frank be any different? Good luck Amanda. You have a big heart like Frank has!18132013-06-21T08:25:47.432675Graham BrownFrank is a Dundee United legend, so it's the least I could do. Good luck. 18132013-06-21T09:54:20.7872676Linda WardenI cannot agree more, i watched my father die of this cruel illness. He was only 60 when he first started to show signs and died by the time he was 66. Although back then (1986) it was even worse than it is now, we had no carers, no help at all, there is still a huge gap in the services offered to sufferers and their families. This illness can hit at any age despite what our government tells us, i know of a woman in her 50's who has it. This should be priority, the minute you become ill with this you qualify for whatever care you require! At least that way your family can support you and make the Alzheimer's journey less painful.18132013-06-21T10:11:32.752677Angela LawrenceAll the best with your petition Amanda. 18132013-06-21T10:47:41.972678Susan PrendergastGood luck Amanda and Frankie.18132013-06-21T11:57:15.6232679Iain LeesMy father is an alzheimers sufferer, and my mother is his only source of care. Provision should be made for both the sufferer and carer, before this disease breaks both of them.18132013-06-21T11:59:48.1472680gary rattray Good luck :-)18132013-06-21T12:02:36.382681Gordon McDAlzheimers can strike at differemt ages and we need a sensitive and positive policy to help those who are suffering and their carers.18132013-06-21T12:08:30.3872682Peter DavidsonOne of my all time heroes for Dundee United my heart goes out to Amanda hope the campaign is s success Peter Davidson. 21.06. 201318132013-06-21T12:52:31.52683Joyce BaxterGood luck Amanda and frank x18132013-06-21T13:50:57.492684bryan wylieGood luck to the kopel family, dwp are a disgrace18132013-06-21T15:00:40.22685Ben ThomsonBest of luck, Amanda and Frank.18132013-06-21T15:19:07.3232686alun grayAll the best to u and frank,grew watching him a UNITED LEGEND18132013-06-21T17:23:26.4672687Eleanor AndersonGood luck with the Campaign Amanda x18132013-06-21T17:38:06.652688LauraMy Grandad died of Alzheimer's at 77. Horrible thing to have happen to anyone :-(18132013-06-28T16:03:43.112689Andrew McleanI dont understand how this situation could have been allowed to develop and deprive us of so much administrative justice18582013-06-30T12:05:17.092690Rehab AufMost who dealt with the SPSO and did not have a case which the SPSO can publish to show he is attacking public bodies like death in NHS have suffered at the SPSO. Even there is service delivery complaint reviewer is paid by SPSO and there is no other pathway for people to take further their complaints. Court actions are beyond the reach of normal people who do not qualify for legal aid. This leave the majority of middle class with no access to proper pathway to resolve problems they face at public bodies. Nevertheless, Minister as Mr Alex Neil has confirmed the SPSO is not worth a fathering while several million are being spent on this dysfunctional organization.18582013-06-30T13:59:19.3272691Jan Ooms"When complaints are freely heard, deeply considered and speedily reformed, then is the utmost bound of civil liberty attained that wise men look for." Milton, John\r\nnot in my experiences18582013-06-30T14:13:15.4832692Jan OomsIn a perfect world we would not need whistleblowers but we do because our governments lie repeatedly. Julian Assange18502013-06-30T17:21:21.592693Colin DavidsonI agree wholeheartedly18582013-06-30T18:12:36.4772694John DuffFor too long cases have been brought before the Ombudsman and not been dealt with in the appropriate manner. There has been no overseeing of these mistakes. No one has checked or investigated these complaints further. It is the job of the Scottish parliament to be seen clearly to ensure accountability with the public. That so far has not happened. I sincerely hope it does begin to ensure there is clear accountability for the Scottish people18582013-07-01T08:44:32.672695Eur Ing Richard Townsend-Rose MA CEng MICEAlthough the SPSO indicate that they have a Quality Management System, it is not adequate and meets no known standard such as the most common British, European and international BS EN ISO 9001.\r\n\r\nPossibly an explanation of why the SPSO has not sought accreditation might be made.18582013-07-01T21:31:32.1972696Pete GregsonWhistleblowing... "We leave unmolested those who set the fire to the house, and prosecute those who sound the alarm." Nicolas Chamfort18502013-07-01T21:56:15.1732697John GibsonThe SPSO and local authorities have made my life a complete misery for over 5 years. National government needs to address the issue. I believe that this situation is part of the problem of the suicide statistics in Scotland.18582013-07-02T10:47:23.5572698M Vesco This petition reflects my own experiences with local authorities and SPSO. 18582013-07-02T11:24:58.5072699Andrew MuirI complained to the SPSO over a five-year period but they performed no investigations. I submitted a similar petition about the SPSO last year but it was closed without any actions. The SPSO should employ several of our intelligent unemployed graduates at a reasonable level of pay to carry out some long overdue investigations to those people that have suffered grave injustices over the years.18582013-07-02T16:11:09.8932700David WilsonDemocracy without justice and justice with Statutory Authority bias is a form of tyranny. No one should be proud of or tolerate such and those that do should hang their head in shame.18582013-07-02T19:47:06.6532701anne robertsonUnder auspices of Prof Brown the SPSO are not accountable despite, in my case, an admission of maladministration and apology by the Authority involved.. The vast amount of money spent on SPSO is a waste,unjustified and needs to be investigated. A fairer system would be a mixed panel of professionals and volunteers with relevant experience to judge the circumstances without prejudice or favouritism. 18582013-07-02T20:11:33.3672702a robertsonThe SPSO has no purpose and a waste of public money. Maldministration was admitted by local authority involved with my case yet the SPSO so called 'investigation' was unfounded, . The investigation panel should be unbiased mixture of professionals and volunteers, failure to reach a fair decisions often causes grief to individuals who seek justice or vindication. The waste of taxpayers money needs to be explained. Public servants should not be protected and must be accountable to the people who pay for the service they provide ie the public.18582013-07-02T23:24:44.62703david mcleanI don't think that the services they provided were very helpful. I had sought out help and they were very unprofessional and not really giving me the support and resolutions I was asking for. there communication with myself was also very poor I always had to be the one to contact them for updates on my queries18582013-07-03T15:02:24.3132704Alison BourneI fully support this Petition as a means of ensuring better transparency and accountability from public service officials. If granted, then, in time, it would be hoped that the reputation of pubic sector organisations as honest and competent might be restored.\r\n18502013-07-03T20:41:30.1732705jack wardno need to ask why. all of us know who the phonies are. All of us know they only exist to preserve their own existance. 18582013-07-12T13:34:14.7532706Lucy Johnson McDowallI wish to lend my support for the critical need for greater and more effective scrutiny of every area of public sector spending. Failure to deal with complaints effectively often means that thousands of pounds of public money per complaint is wasted without effecting real change. 18582013-07-13T20:16:28.362707Sean Having been a victim of very nasty abuse, bullying, intimidation, threats and discrimination. I support any policy that allows greater disclosure of wrong doing within local authorities.18502013-07-15T21:24:23.4772708John ColledgeThis is long overdue. When someone claims a building can be in two places at once you know they are not dealing with your complaint in a professional and accurate manner. They have not only let down the people of this city but potentially left our elected representatives open to legal action for failing to serve the people of Scotland.18582013-07-15T23:35:21.5872709Kay LangOne word sums the SPSO up - JOBSWORTH!!!! What a waste of tax payers money. 18582013-07-16T20:48:20.3972711LMWhen the SPSO corresponds on first name terms with the public body you are complaining about what chance do you have of an impartial decision?18582013-07-17T08:50:44.1932712John BannisterIt is now clear that some form of control is necessary. This is a wholly disproportionate number of geese to be allowed the freedom to exploit this fragile landscape. A quota on culling and authority to sell carcasses would help offset the economic losses of crofters in that area.18042013-07-17T12:01:00.8832713Carola BellThe numbers of Greylag Geese resident all year in the area have already stopped arable crops from being worth planting. They currently reduce silage and hay quantiities considerably and reduce the quality of grass and forage crops through contamination. The numbers must be reduced or crofting agricultural activity, particularly cattle keeping will decrease further.18042013-07-17T14:37:24.3772714Niall McKillopCan anyonefrom outside the islands imagine what these birds are doing to the machair and the machair lochs? There has been some very interesting research in Canada regarding how much each bird excretes onto the grass or into the water showing serious nitrate enrichment of the areas studied. And the number of 'conservation professionals' now in the Islands, most of them with no cultural or economic connection there, seems to be growning in direct proportion to the geese.18042013-07-17T16:00:45.42715William MacraeGeese numbers in the islands must be reduced to manageable levels.\r\nWe are now seeing large numbers of geese in Wester Ross at times when grass is at a premium , leaving little for overwintered livestock18042013-07-17T16:01:16.012716william macdonaldIn North Uist the goose population is completely out of control. What grass they do not eat their droppings soil the grass for sheep.18042013-07-17T16:24:38.7072717Stephen WalkerAlthough I am a crofters I have no crop that is particularly vulnerable to goose damage. Nevertheless I have seen the quite catastrophic effect of damage caused by what is clearly a population out of control. It is high time to take action.18042013-07-17T20:49:01.472718Donald Martin There is no doubt the numbers are out of control and will continue to grow exponentially unless action is taken. This is a matter of urgency to all crofters and something needs to be done.18042013-07-17T22:34:12.5272719neal kinghornI agree with this petition.18042013-07-18T00:10:58.5432720angus a macdonaldanser anser the birds latin name says it all those of the past knew how to control excess of nature not the mamba bamby lot we have today.They killed all the regulators of the bird world the humble crow ,once she disappeared the goose numbers exploded support by the stupidest of all a gang of people called Scottish National heritance,what a stupid name when they have no intention of protecting anything they are just another employment agency18042013-07-18T07:59:43.542721Ronald CameronCrofters are an endangered species. Geese are not18042013-07-18T10:10:19.22722Alistair GilliesGeese out of control here in Arisaig18042013-07-18T10:56:26.392723Steve RobisonThe figures speak for themselves. Wild goose numbers need controlled in the name of the conservation of some of the most precious environments in Scotland. Something has to be done to support the custodians of the Western Isles, namely the people who live there. 18042013-07-18T11:40:34.282724Donald MacIsaacProtected status needs to change as a number of 10,000 in the Uists alone indicates that there is not a need for protected status.18042013-07-18T13:00:38.292725Iain Macdonaldgeese should be culled and made available for public consumption18042013-07-18T22:33:12.962726Donald HoustonThe Scottish Executive is self evidently not interested in the problems faced by crofters and farmers in the Highlands and Islands as this matter has been brought to their attention on many occasions in the past. They are more interested in ensuring that they don't upset enormously wealthy organisations such as RSPB than they are in the few votes they might get from the Crofting Counties. The extent of the damage caused to both grazings and the reduction in the annual silage crop is enormous and directly affects the viability of significant numbers of crofting and farming enterprises.18042013-07-19T08:34:27.1372727Jim StamperWhile conservation has its place it seems now to have got out of hand in many cases. If it carries on the only human inhabitants will be the conservationists. 18042013-07-19T10:34:17.2272728Kevin KennedyOut of control! 6 years ago I seen the first goose on the croft and thought it was a great novelty. Now I have them camped out all year eating everything in the early season where a bite of grass is at a premium. I've also noticed more abortions and deformitities in sheep as the geese increase. It may be unrelated but their leavings are everywhere, bursting with e-coli and salmonella. Can't be healthy.18042013-07-19T12:46:11.112729alex morrisona major cull will have to start asap otherwise the good investment in crofting is going to be flushed down the swannee18042013-07-19T15:20:17.132730Karen TaitGreylag geese caused significant damage to our barley field. They also eat a lot of our winter grass. Something needs to be done!18042013-07-19T21:13:21.392731Andrew MacKinnonMy land is always under threat from geese. They ruin crops and they ruin a lot of much needed grazing. Also when you get large flocks eating the grass, the stock will not go back to that area until the following year.18042013-07-20T08:39:12.2972732Hugh MacInnesconstantly keeping geese off crops. need a cull18042013-07-20T16:24:55.6332733Mabel Georgina MacaulayHad difficulty with security words18042013-07-20T22:21:28.6732734Mark CockramIts not just the Western Isles that are being affected, their numbers are increasing in Orkney as well and already have a finacial affect on the farms they gather on.18042013-07-21T17:56:25.892735Lynn Thomson Geese are becoming a problem on Westray Orkney, something needs to be done control their increasing numbers.18042013-07-21T18:41:31.3872736magnus hendersonI support this petition18042013-07-22T08:48:20.7872737Ronald MacleanSome questions -\r\nWho is stopping realistic action being taken to significantly reduce geese numbers. E.g. allowing their meat to be sold into food chain?\r\nHow many geese are on Lewis?\r\nWhat is the target number?\r\nWhat is the purpose of their protection?\r\nWhat benefits do they bring?\r\nAre these benefits worth more than farming or crofting?\r\nEtc\r\n\r\nThere's more questions than answers!18042013-07-22T13:23:53.542738Steven BainGreylag geese that nest in Orkney should be wiped out as they shouldn't be here.18042013-07-23T11:15:01.8132739Nick JoyThere are way too many geese on all of the outer isles. Orkney and Shetland are inundated. It is time something was done. 18042013-07-23T14:48:28.5572740Martin PalmerGeese in this area of Point on Lewis have become a real problem both for eating grass all year round and for the mess they make on pavements, paths and roads from their droppings. They also leave these droppings around houses where young children play and then tend to pick them up. This is surely a health hazard. Geese are not natural in these numbers and may well be affecting other species with whom they compete for breeding space. This may partly explain the reduction in Terns as on our local loch the Terns have to compete with the Geese for space and, being smaller, the Terns tend to loose out. Geese should be culled back to their former level and should not be allowed to breed here. If the Government and or SNH cannot afford to do this Crofters cannot afford not to do it and will, if allowed, soon sort out the problem.18042013-07-23T17:58:47.7032741Jeannie ErskineI was let down by my own country which had promised me justice in one hand but snatched it away with the other, without properly examining my complaint, a case of medical negligence. It became a mechanical exercise designed to achieve a result for the bureaucracy without understanding that a vulnerable citizen was hanging on to her sense of fair play, only to have it thrown in her face.18582013-07-23T18:03:38.9732742John Allen"SPSO? Good idea, badly thought out." Shameful for a democratic parliament to set up a dictatorial bureaucracy. Poor investigative procedures with hurried conclusions. Not a good way to spend taxpayers money.18582013-07-24T10:11:28.82743Angus MacleodThe Geese on Lewis are nesting in such high numbers that the longer this is allowed to go on crofting will become a thing of the past.\r\nPlease do something about this sooner rather than later?18042013-07-24T20:37:17.492744Mike BriggsI just cannot understand why these geese can't be shot and eaten. When we are visiting the Uists we always ask where we can get goose to eat and answer comes there none... All that free food going to waste.18042013-07-25T11:13:26.612745Alexander Murray"dominion over the creation" is a basic ordinance, irrevocabably given to man by the Creator Himself, and requiring continuing implementation on our part18042013-07-25T16:07:30.6232746Alasdair MackenzieCrofting, by definition, is barely sustainable and the locust like damage to crops and grassland on the islands is a real threat to the economy.18042013-07-25T17:17:43.0032747Andrew MillerIt is said that 5 geese eat the equivalent of 1 sheep, I've never seen so many as this year. Time to reduce the amount of geese to protect crofting 18042013-07-27T22:00:54.062748Iona MacDonaldThe number of geese has a detrimental effect on various asspects of farming. In one case they cleared a field of potatoes. It is a situation that requires to be addressed18042013-07-27T22:54:35.692749Lewis ShandIgnoring this obvious problem is no longer an option. We need a viable control plan NOW!\r\nI have over 30 geese in front of our house daily in the winter, and the numbers keep increasing. They have returned again in the past week.18042013-07-30T12:03:03.8572750John ForbesI fully support this petition18582013-07-31T06:40:28.8172751calum morrisonWe have to cut goose numbers.18042013-08-01T14:06:08.8472752Iain CampbellIf nothing done there be no Crofting18042013-08-01T20:15:20.612753Joe Di PaolaI am in full support of this petition. all dealings of public bodies must be free of any bias or secret influence17152013-08-04T13:08:25.012754Robert AlexanderWith a Scottish government there should be no bias or corruption in the judicial system. Scotland should lead the way.17152013-08-04T23:02:34.682755John WilsonI fully support this petition.18582013-08-08T04:35:56.492756CG BURRYThis is long overdue. I have had personal knowledge on more than one occasion where local authority staff members confidentially (authority name withheld) hinted and voiced their disagreement and discomfort with decisions which had impacted negatively on Article 8 related matters within proceedings, which then established Article 6 circumstances and failings, contrary to government legislations, as well as the authority's own procedural guidelines. I most certainly will be keeping an eye on the whether this gets the green light or not. It ought to. If it does there perhaps could be a online reporting system put in place complete with encrypted privacy measures which will allow whistle blowers to feel confident that their revelation will have guaranteed anonymity, certainly important for those who would be in fear of being victimized or penalized for breaching confidentiality clauses which is written into most Article 8 type cases, in particular child protection proceedings for example. Maladministration is a huge problem despite the under reporting and adverse publicity and those who may have knowledge about wrong doings or culpable deviation from good procedural practice are worried about losing their pensions.18502013-08-09T11:05:20.1372757John McLeanWhat a very worthy Petition. \r\nPerhaps limiting it to Local Government and not to be fully inclusive of all aspects and levels of Governance is its only potential weakness?\r\nThere are cases where Councillors have been criticised in external audits for not holding the Council Officials to account due to a lack of training provided by the very Council officials that were not being held to account! There are many good people that would come forward in the name of Administrative Justice if their employment was not on the line. All Contracts of Employment should have such a protection as part of our democratic rights.18502013-08-09T14:51:13.412758John McLeanThis is a very worthy Petition.\r\nPerhaps it would be enhanced by being more inclusive of all tiers of governance?\r\nThere are many people that would be prepared to help uncover much more of the fact based evidence if their jobs were not on the line for doing so. ALL public sector employment contracts should contain rigid protection for people offering evidence in such cases. Isn't that simply a requirement of any democracy?18502013-08-09T22:23:46.4072759Robbie the PictParticular focus should attend those organisations which demand an oath of any kind. Which master will be served in such circumstances?17152013-08-11T12:56:01.6172760David TraceyCivic Scotland should be open and honest and the citizens of the country treated equally without favour.17152013-08-11T15:19:07.5132761bmaclong overdue to be changed for proper justice,fairness and transparency to be implimented17152013-08-11T16:33:55.0172762alex andersoncant harm the majority. can it?17152013-08-11T22:27:34.2432763Bob ClarkThe petition doesn't go far enough - it should include ALL aspects of public life. For example, freemasonry still plays a big part in the recruitment processes in many sectors, including local government.\r\n\r\nThat said, the judicial system above all must be free from any corrupting influence.17152013-08-12T09:00:30.972764Ray McAllisterAbsolute transparency is a fundamental requirement in any modern society, the days of secretive dealings and understandings need to end.17152013-08-12T10:04:31.2272765John k floodIf Freemasonry is, as I am frequently informed, a benign, fraternal and positive force for good in our society, then there should be no need for membership not to be disclosed by any mason in, or seeking, employment in our public services. I support the petition.17152013-08-12T10:36:53.362766Paul CochraneImportant that transparency and justice is paramount.17152013-08-12T10:43:55.852767AndyLong overdue, there should be no secret societies of this nature in a modern Scotland. 17152013-08-12T11:12:39.0932768John TonnerPublic servants must be free of conflicts of interest.17152013-08-12T12:19:26.832769Janice McLeanThis petition is worthy of serious consideration and the implementation of its suggested actions in full. It must not be allowed to become another talking point only exercise. The time is long overdue for perpetually "talking the talk" at the public's expense. This petition offers a substantive vehicle to allow us to "walk the walk". I strongly support this petition.18582013-08-13T20:13:34.732770Alayne CameronWe are having in excess of 100 geese landing on our fields just now 13 th August.we can no longer put up with these numbers or we will have no feed for our sheep.18042013-08-14T11:57:47.422771KevCan't believe this is not already required by law17152013-08-14T13:07:49.9232772Chris JohnsonI hope this will extend to the remainer of the United Kingdom, also to cover Police Officers and others in a position of power, able to be manipulated!17152013-08-14T21:42:27.1772773Declan Egar"We leave unmolested those who set the fire to the house, and prosecute those who sound the alarm." Nicolas Chamfort\r\nA very apt quote. Everybody from children in school right up to adults in any employment need to know that they can report wrongdoing without fear of recrimination. 18502013-08-15T20:00:00.3172774Martyn BeatonThis law should already exist. But we all know there is too much of this happening in Scotland. Too many cover-ups. look at Hamilton shootings Piper Alpha, Lockerbie, Ibrox Disaster, Solway Harvester, US extradition flights, RFC cheating the tax man etc etc.17152013-08-16T13:48:25.1032775Robbie the PictMembers of an ancient 'debating society' were involved in the setting up and judicial protection of the criminally unlawful A87 road tolling scam at the Skye crossing. This extorted tens of millions of pounds from the scottish road-users and tax-payers, the cover-up of which was aided and abetted by all major political parties, including the SNP. Give us one honest Judge in Scotland, please!!17152013-08-16T15:39:57.912776Martin McCrumAll public servants in particualr should declare their memberships in all cases. there should be no bias or deemed bias in any way regardless of the society. its a fair and a holistic approach, if they are honest in their approach there should be nothing to worry about.17152013-08-17T16:18:06.6432777P Dochertyno opportunity should be given to any conflict of interests when it comes to upholding & maintaining the law.17152013-08-17T19:46:46.3472778Jan OomsWhere secrecy or mystery begins, vice or roguery is not far off. Johnson, Dr Samuel17152013-08-21T21:32:53.732782Billy CoyleThey are Scotlands answer to the K K K 17152013-08-22T23:23:04.982783Patrick CullinaneThe Legal & Judicial Mafia, Politicians & Police have HIJACKED God's Laws and the Law of the Land for their own ENRICHMENT! 17152013-08-24T20:07:52.582784Tom DohertyThe Masons in charge will block this one. 17152013-08-26T17:47:11.22785Jim Mc GinnScotland will never be united with the Secretive Masonic bias & prejudice against non members and Catholics.17152013-08-27T10:57:59.322786Mark Lynchfairness and transparency for all !17152013-08-28T10:32:54.2632787M KimmPromote crofting?? The crofters are fighting a losing battle!18042013-08-28T16:19:24.22788Richard OliverThe geese damage crops and cost the farming community hundreds of pounds in damage the only solution is to shoot as many as possible.18042013-08-28T19:18:50.9172789John Murdo M MacLennanI can no longer be chasseing geese of my crofts. I have crofts in Arnol 13 miles away from Stornoway and I have crofts in Newvalley to so I cant travel 13 miles to geep geese of my crofts and they are making a mess and eating all the grass so I have no place to put my sheep. I hope you will do something about this.18042013-08-28T23:32:59.2472790DW SinclairAn appropriately worded 'General License' for a couple of years would be of huge benefit to those affected. this could then be reviewed and extended if necessary. Numbers are now beyond easy control and require a more concerted effort to bring the numbers down.18042013-08-29T08:10:30.0572791Gary StangerGeese are wrecking crops nearing ready for cutting. cut them to a better number or the farmers will be eaten under!18042013-08-29T11:58:23.5872792William HarcusThe geese are way out of control we should be aloud to shoot on an open licence all year. It is very hard to get a big number culled in the summer time by shooting alone.We should be aloud to round up the young before they can fly and manage them in this way for a few years.The grass and crop damage is massive now. 18042013-08-29T13:43:36.762793Alan StevensonWe have hundreds of geese on our fields. They ruin the grass and eat the barley leaving less for our cattle. In the past we just had a few migratory geese but now the population has exploded and there are ever more geese breeding here in Orkney. Something needs to be done. It would be more humane to deal with the geese when they are still flightless.18042013-08-29T13:46:11.6072794Ann StevensonThe damage done by the geese is enormous. Something needs to be done to control the numbers.18042013-08-30T10:09:00.0332795hugh seatterGoose numbers here on hoy are forcing huge extra cost on our farm geese eat the barley seed the day you sow it they eat it when it when it is growing and now as it ripens it takes a gas gun to 5 acres if you want crop to harvest.We have had to stop growing swedes turnips as you just lose the hole crop . The Orkney country side is rely changing as growers place old cars around there fields in desperate attempts to move the geese on to someone else . Reckon it wont be long till someone takes foxes hear might be the lesser of the 2 evils. 18042013-08-30T10:33:13.4332796george craig archibaldgrelags need to be designated on an open licence as vermin.\r\nprotected spieceis need to be managed to a level the public can afford and farmers and crofters can sustain18042013-08-30T11:45:35.022797David J. KerAbout 20000 greylag geese landed in the two fields shut up for early grazing on the 3rd of April 2013 and completely bared them making it the middle of May before we could turn out the cattle about three weeks later than normal18042013-08-30T12:07:05.4872798William G MurrayGeese are becoming a majopr problem throughout the whole of the North oif Scotland, and urgent steps should be taken to control their numbers 18042013-08-30T14:52:05.092799Mr Arthur Donaldson (RIP)No secret societies.Freedom and Fairness for all.Gor rest Daddy D . 17152013-08-30T16:25:59.9432800jo inksterNot only are the geese annihilating our grass and barley fields they are disturbing the other less aggressive wildlife such as ducks and red throat-ed divers. The RSPCB should take note and do something useful for a change! 18042013-08-30T17:35:23.8872801paul archibaldit is incredably underestimated the cost in time and damage they are causing not only to farming but other wildlife as well !!\r\n\r\n18042013-08-30T19:55:14.862802William HamiltonGeese were an interesting sight migrating North and South, their population grew to such an extent they then wintered in Strathspey, begining in the early 1980's. They are now resident and breeding here and the population is now soaring. They are eating grass for silage and leaving their droppings through the crop as well as eating barley crops, Controling their numbers is essential to avoiding a population explosion, we may even be past that point.18042013-08-30T21:41:36.112803Sandy HendersonThe last 2 years have seen an inordinate increase in numbers in an area of SSSI around the Eden Estuary in Fife. Result - Devastation of 78 acres of wheat which had to be resown with less suitable spring barley. After 3 years of wheat loss, the bann on the sale of wild geese is hard to absorb. The numbers are so that great shooting, especially in the early Spring, would now have very little effect on the population. To extend the Season into the Spring would at least provide a bit of scaring. Often the birds give the impression that they realise thier protection rights. One shot in a 50 acre field only sees them to fly to another area of the crop or take a 3-5 minute detour to arrive back in the same luscious field. Two years ago , a winter barley was consumed. usual in out experience in that wheat is the preferred diet.\r\nFinally, in their only favour, is a deposit of guano but of no real benefit to the annillated wheat crop18042013-08-31T01:08:34.4972804M MoodieThis is a critical problem for rural communities that has got out of hand.18042013-08-31T08:58:36.722805david beattiewe live about one mile from Inverness airport and are under the flightpath of the approach to the airport. our main concern re control of wild goose numbers is that from september till may, the geese graze here. the geese are often seen taking flight when a plane takes off and to us, it is an air accident waiting to happen. with the ever increasing numbers of geese, a bird strike is greater. it is of real concern to us.18042013-08-31T13:02:36.7272806Morag MackenzieGeese are out of control and we should be aloud to shoot on an open licence all year long \r\nMorag mackenzie18042013-08-31T13:46:19.0572808Michael SummersWe have lots of geese on our land virtually all year round.They eat the grass,trample the crops and dirty the silage with their dung.Numbers are increasing and culling is required18042013-08-31T15:04:47.5272809Angus MillarHaving seen at first hand the devastation of improved pastures designed to feed pregnant ewes by vast flocks of geese that farmers must support for no gain whilst accepting financial losses, I have no hesitation in signing this petition and urging others to do the same. If wildlife is a 'national resource' then the nation must contribute to its upkeep or accept that no single body must bare the brunt of maintaining it. 18042013-08-31T16:36:43.0272810andytransparency please17152013-08-31T19:38:40.622812David CainI wish to see all vested interests, masonic and otherwise, fully visible to public scrutiny.17152013-08-31T21:30:52.1672813William BeckmannUnfortunately SNH do not know how to interact with the people who have to live on and manage land. We have problems in our area with geese and the whole process was a farce. Despite promises of undertaking scientific research to refine their scheme nothing has changed. We see fields that are full of rushes where the farmer is paid to fertilise them and then paid to cut the fertilised rushes down, no geese ever land on the ground. A sward height requirement that is too high for the geese to eat was set despite proper scientific evidence to the contrary. The highest use fields are not in the scheme, what a waste of public money.\r\nInterfering with nature without the knowledge of what you are doing always leads to disaster. It is time that the Scottish Parliament took control of the situation and changed the law so that an independent committee, appointed by Parliament with out representatives of SNH or RSPB on it, could then provide best advice. We have the ACSSSI committee but their advice can be ignored by SNH and often is, another waste of public money. This should be changed. There is no independent committee who looks at European designations and can comment or control them, one needs to be set up. SNH, despite promising me in writing that I could comment on the advice sent to the Minister for our SPA, have steadfastly refused to provide it, it will probably be full of errors and false representations but where is the open government process? If we treat ourselves like this now under our own elected Parliament what hope is there for us.18042013-08-31T23:37:41.7432814Bryan RendallAside from agreeing with all the above comments, given that it is possible to introduce variations to existing legislation, as seen in the cull programmes and sale of goose meat on Orkney, we need a dispensation to allow shooting of greylags on a Sunday to increase the opportunities for trying to reduce numbers. If a "sale of goosemeat can be sanctioned, then so could Sunday shooting.18042013-09-01T01:05:152815Elizabeth WatsonThis is important, because there is irrefutable evidence that judges or those in high office, who are members of a Club, Society, sect or Masonic, are acting with vested interests and conducting to an alternative Agenda which is prejudicial to those whom they are supposed to sit with, impartially! They can't have it both ways. 17152013-09-01T02:28:31.082817John LawrieI have seen this problem far too often and I would like some action to be taken18042013-09-01T09:52:49.922818International Mens OrganisationWe have many members that have been made bankrupt, homeless and penniless thanks to ruthless judicial decisions that the Scottish Parliament have been made well aware of and have until now failed those men .\r\n\r\nThe freemasonic hold over judicial decisions MUST STOP and will continue to be exposed until ALL decisions in law are no longer tainted by the vile stench of freemasonry. Juries must be reinstated where masonic judges have stealthily given themselves undue influence over non mason mens wealth and property and heavily weighted in favour of their own lodge buddies who do NOT suffer a similar fate.17152013-09-01T13:49:33.0132819david robertsspring and autumn grazings are now getting ravaged leading to a 8-9month winter with no grazing for stock.Our fields are the last jumping off point for migrating birds.The greylags are now robbing grass from the other migrating geese species before they make their long journeys north and the spring return18042013-09-01T14:09:35.342820George SimpsonThe damage to grazing land and crops by the geese is enormouse, so decisive action on controlling their numbers is required, they are no longer transitory but are here all year round.18042013-09-01T17:13:25.0632821Viv MontgomeryThere was that many geese landing in the fields around Newtonmore in the spring they were hitting the power lines at dusk, the village was getting power cuts every night. SSE had to put disc's on the line to try and prevent this. Not to mention the amount of grass they were eating.18042013-09-01T18:28:15.12822Margaret DearnessThere are hundreds of geese on Sanday & they are destroying our barley crops - we're losing tonnes of barley because they're eating it. We've tried everything to keep them off - gas guns, scarecrows, electric fencing, balloons, CDs, abandoned vehicles in the fields, shooting them - but nothing seems to work. The numbers are getting more & more every year. Something really needs to be done to cut back the numbers of them. We can't afford to plant barley to feed the geese. They wreck our grass fields before we get our young lambs on them in the spring time too, as they are on Sanday all year round now, and they destroy our fields of new grass.18042013-09-01T19:08:52.182823Roddy MorrisonTime something was done to keep number of geese under control.18042013-09-02T14:43:05.732827International Mens OrganisationPrior to the hearing of this petition ALL committee members should declare any undue influence or connections they may have that might prejudice the outcome of this very important petition.17152013-09-02T15:32:21.0732828kelvin evansnobody in a public office should belong to a secret group of any kind17152013-09-03T08:41:04.6132829martinThis is an important petition, long overdue.\r\nOne of the proscribed organisations to be included is called Common Purpose, whose motto is 'Leading Beyond Authority', is secretive about its membership and practices, and has infiltrated every tier of governance, from Downing Street to neighbourhoods, undermines the democratic processes, procures business via insider dealing, and exercises influence, interest and control for its own benefit.17152013-09-03T11:44:30.972830john griffin people in this country have a right to know the influence some bodies have on the outcome of many decisions made.17152013-09-03T14:40:02.1972831Greg DumelowTotally against it.17152013-09-05T07:40:38.8072832MaireadDoes this include investigation into Roman Catholic secret societies too?17152013-09-05T14:54:48.732833M. McGinleyThere can be no justifiable reason for not having transparency.17152013-09-05T21:32:29.972834Paul Flynn"We need clarity".17152013-09-06T03:59:09.262835M GILLENGood luck with this,no-one should have an advantage due to closed and secret societies17152013-09-06T09:09:10.8372836John McDonnellTime to shine some light on the murky corners of funny hanshakes and underhand, back-room, back-scratching.17152013-09-06T10:58:29.522837Martin TigheIf they have nothing to hide they should have no issue with this petition! Time to come clean gents.17152013-09-06T12:37:15.0072838Matthew MochanTransparency is vital in positions such as those cited for the populace to have faith in the democratic system. The proposals mooted in this petition are ones that should already be in place.17152013-09-06T13:48:58.4132839Tom Minogue, petitioner\r\nIf they have nothing to hide they should have no issue with this petition! Time to come clean gents.\r\n\r\nMartin Tighe\r\n\r\n10:58 on 06 Sep 2013\r\n&\r\n\r\n\r\nnobody in a public office should belong to a secret group of any kind\r\n\r\nkelvin evans\r\n\r\n15:32 on 02 Sep 2013\r\n.............\r\nAgree with both of these supportive comments even though you guys don't appear to have signed the petition.\r\n17152013-09-06T16:28:08.5972840thomas cochraneThis cult has held sway and corrupted sport,local gvmt,& business and all walks of life,in this country for far to long. 17152013-09-06T16:50:14.062841billy whytei think a stand has to be made on these matters.17152013-09-06T20:45:44.812842Paul FlynnShould we not have clarity ?.17152013-09-06T22:37:03.4332843John MahonMake the courts transparent17152013-09-06T22:52:39.5132844Palacio67transparancy is paramount17152013-09-07T02:13:07.6272846THE MAD MONTTHE SCALES OF DISCRIMINATION SHALL BE REALIGNED, IT IS TIME!17152013-09-07T11:29:43.6032847Daniel MurrayA worthy petition17152013-09-07T11:45:15.4072848James McQuadeIf they have nothing to hide,what's the problem for them in declaring any secret society membership.17152013-09-07T14:52:28.932849JohnTheyve nothing to hide Martin except the old shifty handshake Cover your work17152013-09-07T19:10:05.042852AndrewThis is an extremely pertinent question that should be foremost prior to next years vote on independence. All candidates should be made to state their position on this very clearly , and very soon. 17152013-09-09T14:28:27.8432853Sidney McKechnie GallagherI fully support Tom Minogue in his petition. 17152013-09-09T19:52:18.022854CraigAn idea whose time has come. Let the cleansing sunlight shine into the dark secret places.17152013-09-10T01:27:03.4432855James ShorttWe are forever being told by the Establishment that if we have nothing to hide we have nothing to fear, Practice what you preach, LONG OVERDUE17152013-09-10T10:20:32.72856kevin budgedeclare yourselves.this is not the dark ages anymore17152013-09-10T11:51:40.3932857Tom MinogueGood enough for Norwegian judges, so why not their Scottish counterparts to register extra-judicial activities such as the freemasons? \r\n\r\nSee freemasonry page on Tom Minogue blog for details.17152013-09-10T12:09:07.2832858James A BarrThe Freemasons, I believe, do a lot of good work . This being so, anyone in a position of power should be happy to let their membership be known. Unless, of course, said membership compels one to be biased in favour of fellow members.17152013-09-10T17:35:44.0572859gerry whitecan you not be proud of your membership of your organisation?17152013-09-10T20:05:23.622860A MartinDoes this include such secret society's as Opus Dei ? 17152013-09-11T00:39:18.2872862Craig GallagherThe British justice system will always be viewed with suspicion as long as the allegiances off the people within it remain secret. 17152013-09-11T08:17:14.0632863Kevin McQuadeFolk who operate within 'secret societies' do so because they've something to hide.\r\nSinister ?\r\nI believe so.17152013-09-11T19:07:59.2972864Tony HughesTransparency required for all!17152013-09-11T20:12:31.762865Gerry DoyleSack them....end of story!17152013-09-12T09:09:06.6472868Nigel RossToo many miscarrages of justice and establishment cover-ups have the suspicion of masonic involvment17152013-09-12T09:16:42.3232869Paddy TurnerThey say it's a Society of Secrets & not a Secret Society........WHY the Secrecy......WHAT are they afraid of?17152013-09-13T09:36:44.7772870GingernutMaybe they are aliens trying to infultrate the Scottish legal system in order to take over the world. 17152013-09-13T11:44:01.5532871Brian McAuleyGood Luck!17152013-09-13T11:57:35.5472872lord sealandALL secret societies have something to hid thats why there members want to hid there involvment17152013-09-13T14:47:46.992873rhThe British Justice System needs to be neutral and fair.17152013-09-14T03:45:44.3132875John DuffyJFK said once just before his death "the very word secrecy is repugnant in a free and open society"\r\n\r\n17152013-09-14T23:30:04.3632876Mary CattersonLONG OVERDUE!17152013-09-14T23:30:36.4272877B McThe reason they are secret is because they have something to hide. There should be no place in a democracy for these medieval societies. 17152013-09-15T11:56:36.4872878Peter BroughanIt is howlingly clear that justice has been mocked over the decades because of masonic (and other) baleful influences in the police, judiciary and othe professions.\r\nThe "society with secrets" nonsense should be outlawed immediately. Transparency and justice. We all know it makes sense.17152013-09-15T12:24:49.7632879ARA member of a group people who cannot survive by\r\ntheir own singular endeavor. Name them!17152013-09-15T17:03:17.7032880ChRiS SMITHPeople must get more involved, governments even employ "ombudsmen" that are a s bent as the "officiaLS"17152013-09-16T01:23:51.4872881Jim McGraneThe same bill should include serving police officers17152013-09-17T03:18:46.7572882sheva burtonI believe the House of Lords changed the statute of limitations in 1993, to prevent more child sexual abuse cases being brought out into the open.17152013-09-17T15:43:31.3932883James Reynoldswhy does the bill not include the Police ?17152013-09-17T23:45:02.5732885f.greenTransparency please.17152013-09-18T00:21:40.242886robert rogerbigitory is indemic in scotland imo as i have exp first hand17152013-09-18T09:15:49.862887Allan McleodI agree with James and Jim.. Why does the bill not include serving police officers ?17152013-09-18T09:34:15.9132888Tom Minogue-PetitionerRegarding police officers being obliged to declare, if the PPC see these comments they may agree particularly when giving evidence in court. I agree. 17152013-09-18T11:48:54.0532889DerekMy comments keep getting deleted by the moderator for no good reason. \r\nI stated I had encountered Masonic workings in a Court and they will not allow it to be added.\r\nHas anyone else experienced this?\r\n17152013-09-19T12:37:03.0532890Tom Minogue, petitionerYes Derek one of my comments was not posted and I was told that there was no record of it. 17152013-09-21T13:28:38.0632891william woodthis petition is long long overdue.Best of Tom.17152013-09-21T14:09:40.4772892MARGARET D MACMILLANWe desperately need a resident Doctor here, not a substitute nurse.18892013-09-21T21:19:37.9932893John MullanIf you need to be secret, you can't be impartial.17152013-09-22T15:34:00.452894Mark McQuadeno room for secrets in Modern Scotland17152013-09-22T15:51:06.762895John KerrSurely the trial of the guy who attacked Neil Lennon says it all. He pled guilty to the assault charge but the jury came back with a not guilty. The judge failed to instruct them that they had no need to discuss this as he had already pled guilty. Shocking!!!!17152013-09-22T17:30:03.9632897Susannah DawsonThe recommendations in the Wilson Barber report pertaining to rural GPs should be acted on, and any existing applications should be suspended until the report has been acted on. 18892013-09-22T23:30:51.8572898Jacqui CollinsOur so called judicial system is corrupt to the core! The people who are supposed to uphold the LAW are in fact at the core of the corruption!!!17152013-09-24T09:07:17.0472899Patrick Mc GroryAll anyone can expect is honesty and fairness in this wee country of ours? Nope I don't think so, it stinks of corruption and injustice.17152013-09-24T09:29:38.3432900Hamish Park Lets have an open and transparent society 17152013-09-24T13:47:50.7572901Michael JobsonIt's only right that we know who you are !!17152013-09-25T09:54:13.592902J RHad doubts about incoming e-mail about request to visit petition. Billy Burns needs to include more references about who he is and where the e-mail came from. People are wary of unsolicited but convincing e-mail requests. Many people will delete and pass it over because of this.17152013-09-26T13:11:55.6832903Doreen Hopkins.Having written three letters supporting a pharmacy in the past 2 years, I hope at long last the residents of Balmullo will get their requests granted.18892013-09-26T20:51:09.532904amy woodget rid of secrecy like the masons17152013-09-27T17:17:49.4172906William McRaeThe way the citizens of Balmullo have been treated at all levels of government is disgraceful. Our wishes have been disregarded by committee after committee, usually for not presenting the petitions the "way they would like it"!!! I've personally sent letters to the Prime Minister, The First Minister and of course Nicola in her previous guise - all to no avail and did not receive a reply from any of them. I hope sincerely that this petition will not fall on deaf ears and that someone with a little "bottle" in the Scottish Parliament has the backbone to follow this to a positive conclusion.18892013-09-29T10:37:58.192907James BurnsIt's only right that we know who you are.\r\nGet rid of secrecy like the masons,if they have nothing to hide they won't mind.17152013-09-29T17:35:14.412908Christine MacVicarThe Mental Health Act has done nothing to stop people being locked up for years without access to basic health care. Psychiatrists say it is not their job to find out why their patient is ill. Many have treatable physical illness and should not be there in the first place.18942013-09-29T23:36:31.5232909Lesley D McDadeI have raised a similar argument in the Scottish Human Rights Action Plan18942013-09-30T09:58:12.5332910Thomas GilchristThe present legislation permits new pharmacy licences in small remote rural areas. The consequent removal of licences from dispensing GP Practices is seriously reducing the wider clinics and services provided by the Health Centre. By removing the scope of the service the Primary Care delivered by the G P Practice is at risk of closing from the evidence of other rural communities where the G P dispensing licence has been removed. This has a damaging effect on the Primary Care Service in Rural Communities all as detailed in the Wilson and Barber report being considered by the Scottish Parliament.18892013-09-30T10:46:29.832911Claire MuirAn invitation for an online discussion is offered. The mental health act is not ECHR compatible. Can anyone refute this here while we have a chance to reply ?18942013-09-30T11:20:09.2672912Barry I CaulfieldI cannot believe that the wishes of a wide range of patients in this rural area have been ignored for so long. It is quite obvious that the way of determining the outcome is weighted towards the pharmacists. If the rules need changing in Scotland then kindly change them. It used to work perfectly well before, one saw the doctor and on the way out picked up the prescription. Now it means using the car or bus and wasting time.18892013-09-30T11:41:47.8172913Judith GillilandI believe my son Joseph Gilliland would be alive today if he had not been unjustlly put on a CTO at the end of August 2008. It was in Herdmanflat Hospital Haddington.He was unable to appeal immediately and was forced to accept intramuscular injections. He described it as inhumane. He wrote to the Mental Welfare Commission to make a complaint but his letter was never answered.He was destroyed by the psychiatric treatment he received, including a wrong diagnosis of schizophrenia. He died on October 17th 2009.18942013-09-30T13:41:37.4032914Dominic BereI believe any such amendment should include measures to ensure it's enforceability. There's no point having a law which psyciatrists continue to flout with impunity. There should be tribunals run by totally non-medical people tasked with ensuring human rights are not being abused. These non-medical personnel must be afforded full powers to sift through every official statement made by medical personnel and to judge these statements in accordance with common standards of honesty, integrity and appropriateness. Furthermore, they must be afforded full power to examine evidence both supporting and contradicting these statements, by calling witnesses.18942013-09-30T17:55:07.3732915David M SutcliffeIt is beyond my understanding that the wishes of the community of Balmullo have been ignored or overturned so regularly and for so long. Not only does our local practice need this pharmacy for the benefit of the community but it is necessary for the long term health of our GP practice.18892013-09-30T20:45:48.2472916Nick HopkinsThis is an important issue and directly impacts the health service as experienced by the local population - especially those with limited transport.18892013-09-30T22:28:59.862917Mark GillespieThe very word 'secrecy' is repugnant in a free and open society.......\r\n17152013-10-01T10:20:00.6232918Tom Dalyin todays society the very thought of people belonging to secret organisations is troublesome. Someone has to ask the question: Why do these people want to hide behind the shadows what are they shielding the rest of society from?17152013-10-01T22:10:59.5232919angus filescompletely un just to the patient and only benefits the psychiatrics'\r\n 18942013-10-02T13:50:48.812920Peter J SmithWe had a perfactly good sertvace from our practice untill it was passed to a comercial concern, even though the whole comunity patitioned for it to stay with the practice.18892013-10-03T15:41:37.622922Robert M CooperThis petition and appropriate action is long overdue18942013-10-03T20:53:33.4632923Rose RivendaleCorrupt Masons are destroying what is meant to be humanitarian organisation17152013-10-03T21:13:31.4272924Jan OomsWhere secrecy or mystery begins, vice or roguery is not far off. - Johnson, Dr Samuel17152013-10-03T22:32:41.842925Gary PearsonWhat happened to Transparency or declaring an intrest.17152013-10-04T09:13:01.122926thomas leonardThere needs to be a clause in the act stating that medical practitioners who effecting criminally assault, torture, or attempt to murder their patients via the physical side effects of their psychiatric medications, or sexually abuse them, should be automatically prosecuted, and charged with criminal assault, torture, abuse of human rights, attempted murder, serial murder, rape, or with whatever criminal offence best suits their crime, and they should also forced to pay financial compensation and damages to their victims18942013-10-04T11:04:04.7272927Claire MuirThere is a clause in the Act. In fact it's a whole Act in itself called Human rights. The mental health act, the human rights act and the Scotland Act are all ignored in Scottish courts.\r\nIt's only words. We need enforcement. Until we get enforcement psychiatry will be the only area where the criminal is protected and it is the victims that are arrested by the police. Apart from slavery and jews which have now stopped. Where is my Martin Luther King ? My Churchill ? Psych wards are laboratorys just look inside one they are not healing places of care. They are lawless hellholes.18942013-10-05T09:21:15.0232928Maurice FrankAll the references to the European Court of Human Rights are subject to the situation since 1999 described in PE6, that all court decisions, in that court and any other, are open endedly faultable on their reasoning. They are no longer ever final. This resulted from claiming finality for a factually impossible decision that 2 dated events happened in reverse order than the time order of their dates.18942013-10-05T15:01:12.2872929DerekHow can they be allowed to not allow comments without keeping a record of them and a reason for deletion?\r\n\r\nYes Derek one of my comments was not posted and I was told that there was no record of it. \r\n\r\nTom Minogue, petitioner\r\n\r\n12:37 on 19 Sep 2013\r\n\r\n\r\nMy comments keep getting deleted by the moderator for no good reason. I stated I had encountered Masonic workings in a Court and they will not allow it to be added. Has anyone else experienced this?\r\n \r\nDerek\r\n\r\n11:48 on 18 Sep 2013\r\n17152013-10-05T17:52:21.0372930david wilsonI believe local authority members, directors & staff should also declare membership of Round Table & Rotary Club as well as Masonic Orders on an public accessible register17152013-10-06T21:36:22.9972931Andrew John Younger1941 and seventy plus thousand Germans now executed in the name of racial hygiene. As the main planner a certain psychiatrist wrote, my thirty year dream has come true. Upon the revocation of the laws that gave legal right to take the lives of those Germans' considered "unworthy of living," we should ask where were the objections from psychiatry? Facts are those psychiatrists created the Shoah. When Hitler revoked the lawful killing of Germans it was psychiatrists whom took their machina to Poland, killing homosexuals, Jews, gypsies, anyone those psychiatrists considered unworthy of living. And where did they go at wars end, majority all returned to academic institutions. Psychiatry, its unwell, cannot cure, never developed a method of action for any of its treatments, psychiatry is lawful human experimentation, that cannot be fit and proper Scotland. Yet a monopoly exists, failure triumphs, choice is no option, too expensive, we must deny actual self management to those whom know best value. Today psychiatrists say their drugs are generally well tolerated, well in that statement existence of a fact, of a scientific truth, that a percentage of the populous cannot consume from nature a psychiatric drug treatment. I ask all where are those whom psychiatry releases and passes to those professionals those could treat and treat to wellness? In my own professional career I was taught a basic rule that a professional knows when to call another professional, then for what reason cannot psychiatry walk out of its institution and talk to another professional? That I believe displays a grave problem in any service. 18942013-10-07T12:48:58.4572932george blackyour capcha image is terrible ,out of focus and almost illegible 18942013-10-07T14:22:50.8232933ModeratorFAO George Black, 12.48 on 07 Oct 2013. Thank you for your feedback. We will forward it to our IT department to look at.18942013-10-07T15:51:13.452935John McDonnellBehind the scenes or under the table funny handshakes have no place in a democracy or a court of law, and should in themselves be a criminal offence17152013-10-07T16:06:55.152936Stewart No place for secret organisations in 2013 got to wonder why people would want to join these pathetic schoolboy cabals17152013-10-07T16:23:43.9632937Thomas lamb The fact that this is secretive makes me suspicious of it if it does any good in society why the need to hide the fact folk are in it what are they hiding ? 17152013-10-07T16:55:46.342938David Forbes Time to have a fairer sytem in scotland17152013-10-07T19:09:29.632939Jim McLaughlinSecret societies are the scourge of Scottish democracy. 17152013-10-07T19:44:49.4472940Martin McKerryThis is vital in ensuring equality to all and protecting a democratic society.17152013-10-07T19:54:57.2232941NeilThis is Scotland 2013, no more secrets, everyone is equal. \r\n17152013-10-07T20:30:12.7072942Billy CoyleIts about time these people were called to boot,they think theyr above the law.17152013-10-07T20:33:58.22943Michelle SmithStop now! 17152013-10-07T20:57:18.1132944pat hyneswell done. 17152013-10-07T20:59:13.5032945FrankieAnyone in public service should ne subject to this bill. 17152013-10-07T21:08:30.5972946Ian FitzpatrickDisgraceful this has not been legislated on before now. 17152013-10-07T21:10:40.7532947Ian FitzpatrickIt's 2013!!!17152013-10-07T21:44:37.6132948Mark BrennanNo place for secret societies in this day and age. Tell the truth and shame the devil.17152013-10-07T22:49:40.72949stephen martinIts time for transparency, we deserve to know if those sitting in positions of power are freemasons.No place in our society17152013-10-07T22:57:32.6132950fatherI would like to know if I say YES to an independent Scotland. Will I be living in a secular country, governed my masons? They already are in positions of authority. We know this. So if Scotland becomes independent what will we have? I would like to see this investigated, and to what degree will we be governed by a masonic power.17152013-10-07T22:58:50.5032951JoeOut the masons .No need for secret societies in a free and democratic society\r\n17152013-10-07T23:14:35.9272952Kirstin Williams Its all secrets and lies!!!!!!17152013-10-07T23:50:43.5032953Philip hodgeI wish to be told of this information without request17152013-10-07T23:51:56.0672954ColinWe need full visibility in all of our Govt - after all, we pay the wages through our taxes, so we should understand fully any conflicts of interests.17152013-10-08T05:03:14.0772955mike ivoryPeople employed by the nation to take care(uphold the laws) of it's inhabitants equally and fairly shouldn't belong to secret societies who help and protect each other, declaring their involvement should be the minimal requirement and the public should have the right to know and choose an alternative to mediate! 17152013-10-08T05:54:30.4032956Philip McSherryDisgusting systematic abuse if position has been rife for too long, time to end the flagrant disregard for moral, ethical correctness17152013-10-08T09:20:18.0772958Marie ChristieWe need a to know that the scales are even, not tipped to one side in favour of someone on the basis of membership of certain groups. 17152013-10-08T11:31:51.6572959Alexander Jackson LaingIt takes a lot away from each community each time a supermarket opens, siphoning money away from a local economy concurrently siphons off its individuality and culture, making us all poorer.18842013-10-08T11:57:12.0872960Catriona PatersonThere's a Tesco on Byres Road and in Maryhill and at Charing Cross. There are 2 Co-ops and a Sainsburys- also not wanted in the same stretch too. Really?! No to ANOTHER Tesco chain store Supermarket!! I prefer to support local business where I can!18842013-10-08T12:20:30.3872961Louise HorneStop the proliferation of huge chains and give independant stores with hard working people a chance to make a living.18842013-10-08T13:28:08.2172962John SweeneyThis is ridiculous - there is already a Tesco within minutes - around 3 minutes walk - of this location. And there is a Sainsbury's too - about a minute's walk away. I live right across the street from the proposed location, and don't want to be subjected to the noise and disturbance of early morning deliveries. 18842013-10-08T13:39:56.0332963Stewart GrantOur doctors retired early as it was financially impossible to carry on without the income from the dispensary, which they had been told to close by AAHB. \r\n\r\nThe whole cost paid to our previous surgery by AAHB was approx £250,000 p.a.\r\n \r\nToday we are running at, in excess of, £750,000 ( with Locums, because the cannot get doctors, as it is financially infeasible to run the practice without the dispensary). Who ever calls this a better and more economical service for the people, should not be representing the people because they cannot add up!!18892013-10-08T15:43:37.2972964Fiona SinclairWhat many people will not know is that people with Learning Disabilities and Autistic Spectrum Disorders are included within the provisions of the Mental Health Act, whether or not they have a mental illness. Autism Rights is campaigning to bring this to an end. Please read our Seven Deadly Points leaflet, which lays out why this is both discriminatory and dangerous. Just do a web search on Autism Rights and Scotland, and you will get our web address, which is exactly the same as our name - with a UK location.\r\n\r\nI gave a presentation earlier this year to the Scottish Parliament's Cross Party Group on Human Rights, entitled Should people with Learning Disabilities and Autism be included in the provisions of the Mental Health Act?. The fully referenced version of this presentation formed part of the response that I submitted on behalf of Autism Rights to the Scottish Human Rights Commission's Scottish National Action Plan (SNAP) on Human Rights. And here, rather bizarrely in this day and age, I am not permitted to post the weblink to this, but you can locate this very easily by going to the SHRC website.\r\n\r\nThe Scottish Human Rights Commission included a number of the arguments made by Autism Rights in their Participation Report, especially in their section on mental health.18942013-10-08T16:40:24.342965Peter KeillerThere's a huge benefit for patients in the "one stop shop" that dispensing GP's are able to provide in rural areas. This valuable service is being sacrificed in order to give patients a right of access to "pharmaceutical services". Patients don't recognise the difference between a dispensary and a pharmacy - they just want to be able to get their medication conveniently.\r\nNew pharmacies frequently destroy carefully constructed rural primary care services whilst offering very little extra that wasn't already available to patients.18892013-10-08T17:56:23.5772966Marcello MegaWe are asked to believe that judges and sheriffs are somehow superior beings, immune to bias or petty discrimination of any kind. That is preposterous. Take a group of 200 professionals from a single body: lawyers, doctors, accountants, teachers, journalists, politicians, clergy, academics, etc, and ask the public to accept that every single one of that group of 200 is equally fair, impartial and open-minded and of course no one would believe it. But we are asked to accept that, without question, of our judges and sheriffs. The system is out of date and does not meet the standard test that all tribunals must not only be fair impartial, they must also be seen to be such by a relatively informed onlooker. If a judge can preside over the trial of a fellow Mason or a fellow Orangeman, having sworn the same oath to the same cause, and to the brotherhood that exists between them, without declaring it, how can that be seen to be fair?17152013-10-08T21:34:12.6372967Eva BolanderThis again highlights problems with the planning system on Council level - even when there are local policies they are set aside for shoehorning in developments against the local opinion and detrimental to the area.18842013-10-09T14:05:24.9332968Michael Houstonlets got all citizens of this country on an equal footing no unfair privileges and no crony-ism for a select minority 17152013-10-09T18:47:57.0932969AmberlyGood luck 17152013-10-10T10:20:45.8072970Linda WallaceWhere there is doubt, there is no doubt !! Wake Up Scotland 17152013-10-10T15:03:18.5172971Clare CameronAbsolutely no place for secret societites in any walk of public life17152013-10-10T16:31:07.8272972Tom Minogue, PetitionerJFK said: 'The very word 'secrecy' is repugnant in a free and open society and we are, as a people, inherently and historically opposed to secret societies, to secret oaths and secret proceedings. We decided long ago that the dangers of excessive and unwarranted concealment of pertinent facts far outweighed the dangers which are cited to justify it.'17152013-10-10T18:13:54.6672973Jim WoodPushing for an open and transparent society is the only way we can combat prejudice.17152013-10-10T19:09:37.6572975Michael BeltonNo room for this in modern society 17152013-10-10T21:36:35.8932976Andrew SmithThe ECtHR ruling notwithstanding,what has become of human compassion? Do most of these shrinks dwell in ivory towers?18942013-10-11T10:07:00.6572977Ella Daniel-LoweIn my small home town there are now three Tesco shops within a mile of each other with plans to build another large superstore on the space where an independent garden centre used to lie. A large number of people within Churchdown protested and petitioned against the construction of yet another Tesco but sadly to no avail. With Tesco shops already within a few miles drive in either direction from the village, another is not at all necessary and very detrimental to local businesses.18842013-10-11T10:34:12.5232978Elaine VennI don't live in Scotland, but I do believe that Tesco are bullies! They seem to think they have a right to go where they please. The arguement from them is always that they are bringing in employment. HOW? When local businesses go out of operation and town centres close. Surely Tesco have enough sites already and that includes the superstores, express and metro stores. I feel the UK has had enough of farmers being given a bum deal too. We have orchards closing and we are losing hundreds of local public houses too, because of undercutting by supermarket giants. Tesco, you want to come out on top? Stop your march across this country. 18842013-10-11T12:12:38.8032979Jim CampbellOur pharmacy applications were approved and then overturned, more than once, by the appeals committee, totally ignoring the wishes of the community and pampering to the commercial outlets. No wonder any trust in these panels and organisations has been eroded to the point of non existance.18892013-10-11T13:29:36.4872980Andrew WilsonI'm not sure why believing in a god should allow someone a free pass into positions of responsibility in contemporary Scotland.19012013-10-12T12:09:28.522981Kathleen, Dowager Duchess of HamiltonMy husband underwent unlawful detention from which he never really recovered. Since his death I have found so many people have suffered in the same way. I am certain the Scottish Government, will help with this injustice.18942013-10-12T15:17:47.622982William John SellPatients who suffer from dementia have human rights, as do their next of kin, relatives and carers. No mental health official should have the right to covertly predetermine that they should be detained under the Mental Health Act.\r\nThere are different types of dementia which vary from mild to severe in their impairment of mental faculties. Therefore care plans should involve consultations with next of kin, relatives and carers, in a spirit of openness and candor.18942013-10-12T16:13:01.5132983John McFadyenNo place for this in a modern Scotland!!17152013-10-13T03:52:03.5132985Anne Maria RennieFreemasons are a secritive society that are duty bound to help if help is asked of them. Seceret hand shakes and practices they can determine the outcome of a trial. In the Scottish Borders, if the man in the dock is reffered to as a Border gentleman, he gets a more lenient sentence, if convicted at all. record will expose this. 17152013-10-13T10:52:32.0632986KMIf we truly are a modern and inclusive society, this sort of transparency should come easily and naturally. 17152013-10-13T15:01:44.822987Andrew MuirThe 2003 mental health act was rushed through parliament without proper scrutiny.\r\n\r\nIt is a very bad piece of legislation. In 2009 a survey showed that at the end of their course of treatment only about half of people thought that it was right for them to have been sectioned. \r\n\r\nFour experiences have been put online. This can be found by searching the internet with Google. Try implementation, Ridley, Rosengard. Then duke, mental health, overhaul. Then Gilliland , express. Then Christine MacVicar, Spain. Then Claire Muir , Dumbarton\r\n\r\nThese horrific stories, which are the tip of the iceberg, should not be happening in a so called civilised society, a fair country leading up to the independence vote.\r\n\r\nThe admission process is very weak. Patients are treated worse than criminals. The reason for admission can be based on hearsay, relying on a single assessment by a doctor, with the interview by a Mental Health Officer and family contact often being ignored. The patient has no legal representation. In England the situation is improved since two doctors signatures are required. \r\n\r\nAnders Breivik, the Norwegian who murdered 77 people, was able to stand up in court and lucidly defend his actions publicly. He was able to examine the evidence and get excellent legal assistance. He proved that a report stating he was mentally ill was wrong. This justice is what Scotland should aspire to. The extra cost would be met by less people being sectioned.\r\n\r\nIn the August 2012 issue of the British Journal of Psychiatry it states that mental health services have overestimated the benefits of antipsychotics while underestimating the side effects and it is time to reevaluate the risk reward ratio of these drugs.\r\n\r\nThe tribunal system is very poor and heavily biased against the patient. A tribunal is typically held in private, with the patient heavily sedated and the panel consisting of a psychiatrist, a lawyer and a health worker.18942013-10-14T10:33:08.772988Alistair McBayFrom the evidence we have of churches leveraging their chaplaincy roles in schools and the religious observance guidelines for the purposes of evangelism and proselytising, so they also leverage these undemocratic appointments for their own self-serving interests. The Church of Scotland, for example, highlights these roles in its Education Committee workplan and provides training courses, handbooks etc so as to provide "better trained LA reps able to be more effective on LA Education Committees". Effective for whose ultimate benefit, exactly, given that the Church has boasted of 'holding the balance of power' on more than half the committees?19012013-10-14T11:35:31.4272989Matthew McCurdyWhy do religious organisation still have such positions of influence? Irrational belief in the supernatural and ancient mythical stories is disappearing at an exponential rate yet these organisations are still allowed such disproportionate influence. They need to be removed.19012013-10-14T15:13:00.1532990Meghan JonesI don't believe in the government forcing officials that were not elected by the people to sit on education boards, If the people wish to see religious officials sit in a place of responsiblity to our children then the people should have the right to elect them, not have them thrust upon us. 19012013-10-14T15:59:25.5372991Paul SandersonThe Non Christians that make up something like 47% of the population are not being represented properly by the unelected pious which is outrageous in a democracy.\r\n19012013-10-14T16:51:32.0772992Alistair J PaxtonReligion should play no part in any Government.19012013-10-14T17:01:04.1132993Angus BrownLong overdue amendment to an imposed religious presence in a committee which is well served by elected Local Councillors. Their non-elected presence is not democratic.\r\n19012013-10-14T17:09:44.0372994Jean ParkFar too often, the representatives of the various churches are provided with a platform to air their views on secular issues, as if they represented Scotland's society as a whole. This is no longer true. As far as education is concerned, and speaking as a former Depute Head of a Senior Secondary school, I feel religious observance (as opposed to comparative Religious, Moral and Philosophical Studies) has no place in schools. Our country has been divided along religious grounds for too long, and the best way to solve this is to educate our children together, without recourse to superstitions and fairy stories more suited to primitive, illiterate and uneducated societies existing hundreds or thousands of years ago in the Middle East!19012013-10-14T17:12:53.662995Ian GeganTheir reasons for continuing the status quo are that they 'used' to run the schools...yes 'USED' to. Also some weak argument about bringing experience to the educational discussion...utter nonsense, it is about them maintaining influence and power for their irrational and outdated organisations. Get them out, then we can have a reasoned discussion about finally having a properly secular and inclusive education system in Scotland.19012013-10-14T17:19:51.8972996Rob WilloxThe current position gives disproportionate influence to a group of unelected representatives from bodies that are not fully representative of the views and opinions of a large proportion of the population. Undemocratic, unrepresentative, unnecessary.19012013-10-14T18:41:01.1072997Liz AlbertNearly half of Scottish people are of no religion. It is undemocratic and outdated to have a legal requirement of 3 religious representatives on every education committee, none of those representatives elected. 19012013-10-14T22:04:41.0772998Marie MoserI don't believe that non-elected, unaccountable and sometimes bigoted or intolerant people should have any say in the education system . 19012013-10-14T22:24:46.2732999David A LordWe non-religious have to put ourselves up for election to the council. Why do the religious need this privilege of avoiding democratic election in our diverse community today?19012013-10-14T23:23:40.2973000Graham HughesI have never been able to understand why an irrational belief in a giant invisible man in the sky and a desire to structure modern society along the principles set out in a book of ancient middle eastern creation myths should be seen as reason for someone to be given special influence in society rather than as something which should call into question their ability to make a rational contribution. If children weren't taught religious belief as historical fact at an early age the number of those with religious beliefs would decline even more rapidly. Schools should be places of education and not religious worship. Some people with religious beliefs may undoubtedly be able to make a positive contribution to running schools as individuals but religions themselves should have no place in forming education policy.19012013-10-15T04:16:45.9433001John MacKenzieThe World is becoming an increasingly smaller place and if Scotland is to play a meaningful role in it then our young citizens need to appreciate and understand the beliefs and values of people across the Globe. Education in Scotland therefore needs to be geared accordingly and free of any bias towards a particular religion or cult. We cannot stick our head in the sand. If we are to cope with far away events that affect us then we need to develop citizens who are sufficiently broad minded not to condemn on the basis of some outdated belief.19012013-10-15T10:21:02.433002Les ReidEqual rights for all, regardless of religious or non-religious belief! Let's have an end to religious privilege! Equal rights for humanists, atheists, agnostics and secularists!19012013-10-15T12:24:11.7233003Brian CaseyReligious education is the route cause of sectarianism and division within Scotland. We also shouldn't force religious beliefs on anyone especially children .19012013-10-15T13:03:10.633004Fiona KennedyOur judiciary get aware with being unfair and unjust displayed in their judgements on a daily basis, this is just another means for them to be above the law by not answering to those they apparently represent! 17152013-10-15T14:56:24.143005David LattoIf there were less religion and more democracy, Scotland would be a better place.19012013-10-15T15:06:32.963006Peter HarrisonIf people want religious representatives in the councils then they can elect them in. That's the way it should work. No free pass just because you happen to be a member of a certain religion. Nobody gets a free unelected position because of other superstitious beliefs. If people want them, they can elect them.19012013-10-15T15:47:15.3173007Eric hendersonFear and the need to be part of something or group that will take care of are all very human feeling. yet as always this insecurity leads to opportunity to collect power. My most horrifying experience of late was the "god channel" on sky this is truly frightening literally with the usual banner of we need to collect $5 million at the bottom.This truly is an uphill battle I am glad to be part of it and hope that one day even the smallest of contribution leads to a world of rationality without fear. ps my bible or as close to it is the "ragged trousered philanthropist" Robert tressel. where all things human are considered.19012013-10-15T16:18:01.5173008MikeyEven disregarding the ludicrousness of religion, it is still ridiculous that a religious person is afforded extraordinary rights and sympathy over a non-religious person.19012013-10-15T16:19:50.7273009marcusThought for the day. Tax religions and give the money to the poor.19012013-10-15T16:33:33.9933010Campbell Gavin BoydUnelected representatives are anti-democratic and simply not appropriate in a modern country like Scotland.19012013-10-15T16:43:18.383011Max JacobsonIt should not be forced upon children to be educated on the teachings of increasingly derelict religious beliefs. Only facts should be represented in schools, which are after all eduction establishments, not a means for preaching to children.19012013-10-15T17:33:14.8533012julie tippinsI have no problem with people believing in unsubstantiated ideas- such as deities, but allowing them the power to influence decisions on the education of children in the 21st century is surely unacceptable when you consider religious views on the oppression of women, religious homophobia and irresponsible views on contraception. Religious indoctrination has no place in schools or education policies19012013-10-15T17:35:56.53013R.McPolandLet reason ad rationality prevail.19012013-10-15T17:40:343014Derek HutchesonHaving any religious faith should immediately bar people from any public office. Any and all charity status should be removed from these organisations also. Only then will we be able to break the endless cycle of brainwashing of humanity.19012013-10-15T17:42:52.313015Gordon Blair CouttieScotland suffered from the effects of religion for long enough. Please seperate Church & State NOW!!19012013-10-15T17:44:26.53016Julie GilmoreThere is no need for religion to be part of the education system. Should follow the French example by having it excluded. Religion is in schools because they prey on children of an impressionable age who if they question what is being stated, the teachers and religious figures dismiss them and do not have the tools to answer them onstructively. When I said to my sons Head Teacher that he will not participate in the prayer in assembly she said that he did not need to go to assembly. I stated to her that assembly was for news of the school not for religious purposes. Throughout his time at school there has been various points when religion was wrongly and inaccurately taught. Such a shame that these predators are allowed so much influence in our childrens education. Thank goodness my child has a balanced upbringing by me, where I encourage him to make up his mind about religion when he is an informed adult (hence the reason he is not Christened). Good Luck with the petition, hopefully these insecure religious figures in education are going to be a thing of the past.19012013-10-15T17:49:32.7773017kenneth daileyYour religion should never qualify you to sit on education committees.19012013-10-15T18:06:27.0973018glennIf one of God's supposed representatives is to be seated on these committees, perhaps He could get His rep elected first?19012013-10-15T18:08:45.7173019Barry ClarkAthiest should be the chosen background as that would be the most common and unbiased background to have. 19012013-10-15T19:22:09.033020Gary MillerTime to move forward. 19012013-10-15T19:51:25.033021Tom DonaldPeople who adhere to religions are not the right people to influence children. The catholic church in particular has shown utter disregard for children's welfare in recent years, isn't that enough to show that religious people can't be trusted? 19012013-10-15T19:59:21.923022David NewmanHard to believe this is 2013 sometimes.19012013-10-15T20:03:04.813023Derek LittlerEducation should be about verifiable facts, not mythology purporting to be 'truth'. Stop poisoning the childrens' minds.19012013-10-15T22:38:11.9673024Janet MoxleyIf people want to be on public bodies on a religous "ticket" they should go through the same selection or election procedure as other members of that body. No special privileges for those how prefer to believe than to rationalise!19012013-10-15T22:57:21.33025Harley BaretzMr.Hughes, I couldn't agree more strongly! Over here,on the other side of the pond , many in the southern states reject Darwinian evolution for what is known as "Creationism". I.e. The man in the sky created the universe , the Earth is only a few thousand years old , there never was a Big Bang, and we are certainly not descended from apes (God forbid). And, believe it or not, there are about 40 or so percent of this nation of some 3 hundred million who when polled, agreed with this backward , non science. Small wonder the U S is losing it's status in the world.19012013-10-15T23:27:48.0773026James IrvingI agree with Graham Hughes, John MacKensie and Les Reid statements below 100%19012013-10-16T12:59:26.5973028William ForsythTheir only mandate is from is from a captive audience.19012013-10-16T13:31:27.653029Mike NealReligious privilege is an anachronism that has no place in 21st century society. By all means have religious bodies put up candidates, and if they win ALL the seats, fair enough.\r\n19012013-10-16T14:29:52.243030Prof Paul BratermanChurches with their vested interests have privileged seats on education committees, with full voting rights over the allocation of public funds, whether anyone wants them or not. this is so, so wrong.19012013-10-16T15:10:17.7673031Maureen HutchisonSimply cannot believe that unelected religious representatives are on school boards given the number of people in Scotland of no religion .19012013-10-16T15:27:32.3133032John & Rachel SangsterA Care Plan should be tailored to the individual's illness and the needs of the patient always approved of by the next of kin. 18942013-10-16T17:08:09.753033tony walkerthe very fact that these people are delusional and have an invisible friend should disbar them from going anywhere near children at all never mind being able to affect what they are taught.19012013-10-16T18:57:17.6733034Tony HamiltonThis is archaic and anti democratic not to mention giving political power to a group that openly discriminates against minority groups. Giving power to groups who profess to be working on behalf of, and answerable only to to, an invisible, unverifiable entity through ancient texts and telepathic processes, is an unnerving thought that could easily lead to bad places if you really think about it rationally19012013-10-16T19:24:24.873035Iain KerrThe audible option is inaudible!19012013-10-16T21:46:18.343036Eilidh SmithRight to a fair trial is a human right. In a country that prides itself on our enforcement of human rights, we should have no such possible barriers to justice.17152013-10-16T21:52:51.6273037william RodgersThe country should be Scotland not Afghanistan, my laptop is playing up as it's getting on a bit, like me in fact.19012013-10-16T22:40:14.523038OOMSWhere secrecy or mystery begins, vice or roguery is not far off. - Johnson, Dr Samuel17152013-10-16T23:37:15.6873039Gail AddisScotland should lead the way to a Secular Society. 19012013-10-17T00:32:31.4573040Josh LordI can't even imagine what the justification for this archaic policy could be. The idea that religious representatives have some kind of sagacious status simply by virtue of being well versed in a particular mythology is risible.19012013-10-17T08:38:34.0033041Paul HendryI agree there should be no doubt that cronyism is wholly unwelcome. Scotland's lack of awareness about the presence of secret Masonic membership is something we should all be concerned about. I observed such at a tribunal and was unable to understand its influence on the outcome.17152013-10-17T11:13:53.853042MichaelWhy should anyone have to be a member of any secret organisation just to get on in life. 17152013-10-17T11:44:20.3173043Pat McLindenAs a proud member of the Masonic Lodge I feel with the years I have been in it that it is other people who are non members who make a big issue of this organisation. I feel it is no secret to declare your membership of such a charitable organisation if asked, it is not asked it is not required for you to mention it. It is the same as your religious practice unless asked it is no one else's business. These things are your own business but if it is required for you to answer it on a document does that mean you will be favoured or not favoured???\r\n17152013-10-17T12:11:13.0173044Tom MinoguePat McLinden, I know of no religion that demands preferment by thier members of fellow brethren over non-brethren. Nor do I know of any religion that demands that their members must help a fellow member in trouble or keep the secrets of their church under pain of the most hideous torture, such as Quote. having my throat cut across, my tongue torn out by its roots, and my body buried in the rough sands of the sea, etc. Of course if religions did demand this from their flock I would agree with you. As for charity of course there is that side of freemasonry but police officers in the Craft have been banned from the Hillsborough cover up inquiry for non charitable reasons I suspect. But I note you are in favour of declaring membership if asked and hope you are a judge. 17152013-10-17T12:37:52.8233045Joe CannonThere is no place in a modern Scotland for this secret society nonsense anyone in public office the judiciary or decision making process should be banned from holding such positions if they are part of ANY secret society simply because they cannot be trusted to be impartial if it comes to a choice between their brethren or the ordinary guy in the street 17152013-10-17T12:40:34.163046JohnTruth, honesty and integrity, not secret handshakes and winks.\r\nI am fully aware of the good works done by the vast majority of Masons but there are a few bad apples which tarnish the rest i'm afraid.17152013-10-17T14:43:58.9533049Derek TBan Secret Society Membership it is 2013 for gods sake17152013-10-17T15:04:04.5333050Willhelm AndersonI agree. Anyone in a position of power and belonging to sectarian groups such as the Knights of St Columbus or AOH should be forced to reveal their involvement. For too long, these hate mongers have got away with remaining secret.17152013-10-17T15:18:22.2673051KellieTesco are monopolising the CBD at an alarming rate and need to be cut down to size.18842013-10-17T15:20:03.6273052Andrew BarrieThis is appalling, and it needs to stop NOW.19012013-10-17T16:20:38.0633053Ken WoodPeople do not need to be members of secret societies to collude and promote their own aims above others. That freemasonry has been singled out in this petition displays ignorance of this society and its principles. Anyone who is a member of any society should not be afraid to disclose this. However, the ignorance displayed here shows why many will not do so. There is a prejudice against member of secret societies particularly Freemasonary. The Freemasonary I know has moved with society (so sorry to disappoint, but nobody is threatened with any physical violence) and it's brethren are asked to pledge allegiance to their state and uphold its laws. My experience is that it is a social club, predominantly for older gentlemen, where the ceremonies are the centre of attention. These ceremonies are symbolic as are any penalties mentioned (that those who like to imagine they know something make a point of saying mean we have something sinister to hide). Anyone who would take these literally is an idiot and probably unfit to be a member. The circumstances which prompted the petition are regrettable but hardly representative. I have met no one who could be described as holding position of power in my 20+ year in the craft, nor have I heard of any inappropriate actions of this sort. Is this Scotland or Stalinist Russia? Should the state listen in on all meetings of more than 2 people?17152013-10-17T19:01:04.163054kevini see no reason religious representatives should have to stand for election like everyone else.19012013-10-17T22:18:39.353055David MillerSchool-based indoctrination of children is one of the strongest reasons (I do mean *reasons*) for being against organised religions. Let the children alone - make your own mind up when you are an adult.19012013-10-17T22:55:45.6633056Tony bentleyIf gets the go ahead it must include all secret societies not just the masons. This will upset most politicians in Scotland because of there religious beliefs, also the BBC.17152013-10-17T22:59:10.693057Ruth LawsonI am happy for elected officials, teachers and members of parent councils to vote on school policy decision making irrespective of their religious beliefs but to allow unelected officials the same rights simply because they espouse predominantly Christian beliefs is profoundly undemocratic in our multicultural society. I oppose Creationism in the classroom and in particular, the science classrooms. I am also extremely concerned at the lack of clear directives for the screening of chaplains in our state run schools. I have sought information on this from local authorities and my childrens' school and have found that screening is not evident. It would seem that the only criteria which determines whether chaplains are accepted into the school is the geographical proximity to the school. I am also extremely concerned that non-religious viewpoints are not considered important in state school education. I also recognise that as a parent I have a right to opt my children out of religious observance but most parents are not fully aware of their rights and when they are made aware of them are fearful of 'rocking the boat.' Whether this fear is real or a perception is irrelevant as it serves to undermine non-religious peoples and they are oftentimes viewed as anti-authoritarian, difficult and as nuisances. I resent the implication that any decision to opt-out of religious observance places me in this regard and agree that the fairest solution is to remove religious observance from non-denominational schools. 19012013-10-17T23:58:47.7933058Andy GaffneyThere should be no privileged positions unless every educational subject has a privileged position.19012013-10-18T10:07:58.13059Tom MinogueKen Wood, Wilhelm Anderson, Tony Bently, suggest you read the petition terms again or for the first time. Petition refers to societies such as the freemasons and have . SUCH AS. If other societies that you mention meet in secret, swear oaths in secret and demand fraternal preference to their brethren over non-brethren, or are organisations which have constitutions or aims that are biased against any particular sect, religion or race then of course they are included in the terms of this petition. Do the ones you name have these characteristics? 17152013-10-18T10:29:10.713060Anthony BrannanMasons owe allegiance to their Order and fellow masons before anything else, so it's hardly surprising that people in positions of power and influence such as judges and police could be seriously conflicted and compromised when dealing with other masons in a professional capacity.\r\n\r\nIf they have nothing to hide then they have nothing to fear.\r\n\r\nOn the other hand..............17152013-10-18T10:42:19.8573061Paul Starmorethis should have been abolished years ago19012013-10-18T11:27:07.5073062Elizabeth LewisThe sooner we get past these repressive and narrow minded ideologies, the better for Scotland as a modern nation.19012013-10-18T14:27:26.8833063Mark SpenceWe don't NEED more Tescos!18842013-10-18T14:28:14.83064Rosemary McNeillWe need a balance between local, independent traders & the chain supermarkets. Currently, it's out of balance. The Goliaths are muscling in & putting smaller traders out of business. Local councils & communities should have power to actively discriminate against supermarket giants & support local traders when necessary. Also, our high streets are becoming increasingly bland, corporate & soul-less, due to this monopoly. Let's breathe some life back into our communities by going LOCAL.\r\n18842013-10-18T15:18:16.7433065DcGreed,greed,greed I have never seen a tesco metro benefit the locals18842013-10-18T16:25:07.6973066tom mciverGreat Western Road does not need a tesco, it is well supplied by local traders. This is part of the beauty of this area, please do not destroy that by disrupting the balance.18842013-10-18T18:55:57.1573067Iain CuthbertLocal shops means diversafication, more jobs and a better quality of high street.18842013-10-18T21:41:43.8673068Daphne McCullochReligious beliefs are personal, cultural and family choices. Children in public education should be protected from religious bias. Avoiding legislative advantage in the appointment of representatives of one or more religious group is the first essential step in ensuring the freedom of choice for children and families.19012013-10-19T06:17:35.9873069William curranLong overdue. Well done.17152013-10-19T09:48:02.1433071Robb Ross Save the diversity of our communities!18842013-10-19T14:09:24.2133072Frank BoydI agree with the above petition and support it.17152013-10-20T08:33:50.0773073Alison GreenSurely we don't need another Tesco.I don't live near Roots and Fruits anymore but support my local independent deli.18842013-10-20T08:41:54.2333074Norman OgilvieReligious teaching should not be part of the school curriculum until secondary level and even then should be optional.19012013-10-20T10:57:33.8773075Mrs Anne McGregorPlease note that this petition email came in as SPAM. almost missed it 19012013-10-20T11:17:42.5133076BillyPlaces on the panel should be given on the basis of ability and election19012013-10-20T12:03:53.063077John WiltshireLogic demands that, since truth cannot contradict truth, any government that promotes multiple, incompatible religious faiths must therefore be promoting falsehood.19012013-10-20T15:56:07.1133078Gerry MoranThis is outrageous. There should be no religious instruction or observation n schools. Our children deserve better and should be taught facts, not have their heads filled with religious nonsense based on myths and superstition.19012013-10-21T00:28:46.753079Deborah CollinsThese beautiful and unique businesses are disappearing under the power of the foreign owned and unscrupulous supermarket chains. I find this so sad and such a huge loss. It takes the "Great" out of Britain and we are a wonderful people who deserve our own identity. 18842013-10-21T07:05:08.5233080tracey thanopoulosI lived in Glasgow for many years until 2009 you really don,t need yet another supermarket.They are retail cannibals and suck the life out of any business that surrounds them!18842013-10-21T09:55:11.9533081Nik AlldayIt would be insane for a mental health act to not comply with human rights.18942013-10-21T11:19:49.3373082MariaIllogical and undemocratic, not even based on experience and merit.19012013-10-21T11:28:31.4633083Marcus Mac Veighabout time.17152013-10-21T11:42:40.8933084Trevor WilsonHistory has clearly shown that opening too many supermarkets had a hugely detrimental affect upon local businesses. The Kelvinbridge are of Glasgow is already a lovely thriving retail area full of independently owned and very popular shops. To allow a supermarket to be built there is criminal and will damage the local economy.18842013-10-21T13:17:59.783086donnyShould have a compass and dividers tattoo on their foreheads17152013-10-21T15:05:15.6573087Tom MinogueDonny, the sign is a compass and square and I don't think your comment adds anything to the reasonable tone of debate so far. Why the clerks have allowed it I do not know.17152013-10-21T15:29:47.5573088Sue MackechnieThe Kelvinbridge area is well served with independent shops and if anything needs more small businesses to contribute to the character and variety on the streets. There are also already several supermarkets in the vicinity, we really really do not need another!18842013-10-21T17:08:47.1573089paul reynoldsLong overdue in my opinion, the obligtion to the society may have confliction in the duty obliged in this part of the justice system.17152013-10-21T20:15:07.973090laurence reidI would feel much more comfortable about voting for an independent Scotland if matters like this were more transparent.17152013-10-22T12:06:06.5573091Diane GrahamI work for one of the local independent retailers in the Kelvinbridge area and along with my colleagues, we are worried about the lose of our jobs if this proposed store was to go ahead. There is no doubt that the opening of this proposed store would have a huge impact on many livelihoods within this area resulting in reduction of working hours and possibly redundancies. Business has been really hard for independent retailers over the past few years and we have to fight for every single sale. Adding Tesco would be a devastating pressure that many retailers would not survive.18842013-10-22T14:28:50.1573092Fiona WellinsSupermarkets have already blighted small businesses, livelihoods and communities in so many towns across the UK. How long before Tesco value housing, cars, etc.? It's a grave new world.18842013-10-22T14:44:51.9673093John ThomasReligious organisations should have no special privileges any more than any other organisation. If they seek representation at local authority or parliament level, they should work with representatives who share their views, or put up candidates for election, the same as anybody else. 19012013-10-22T15:35:17.023094Katie leesNo to tesco18842013-10-22T15:59:00.8133095Brian ArnoldApproach proposed for ECT belongs more to the dark ages.18942013-10-22T21:02:34.883096Wendy HetheringtonI don't live in Scotland, but fully support this petition. Tesco are opening too many stores throughout the UK, in many cases against the community's wishes e.g. savetheharp.co.uk18842013-10-23T08:42:31.493097Michael NewStop these bullies18842013-10-23T11:28:56.6133098Gerry McGheeWhy would they possibly want to hide anything , aye right .17152013-10-24T09:35:50.5233099Caroline McDonaldI see too many supermarket chains opening smaller stores on the high streets & towns. For each supermarket opening up 5 local shops close down. Soon we will have no choice to shop elsewhere only dominated by the big supermarket chain who may abuse their positions in order to make money.18842013-10-24T09:53:42.643100DarrenI don't really care as I will shop at the cheapest place so if that means corner shop closes down, that's due to them not being competitive. 18842013-10-24T14:18:373101R. OmozikNo one should benefit from secret societies17152013-10-24T16:12:02.3373102DawnWe have ANOTHER tesco opening about 100 yards from our house when we already have 2 co-op (which I want to support) a sainsburys and 2 tesco within 3 minutes walk, its ridiculous. I want to shop with my local butcher and fruit shop and small deli, where I get good advice and feel part of a community. We dont need anymore tesco, thats for sure.18842013-10-24T17:28:26.563103David ConwayIf you have nothing to hide, then why hide?17152013-10-25T01:38:42.0873104Roger NichollsWhy is Scotland still in the Middle Ages?19012013-10-25T09:38:25.4873105Brian WilliamsSecret societies should not operate within the judiciary17152013-10-25T10:12:20.3673106Dougie Bellyou can see the effect already in Edinburgh. two specialty shops have gone in Bruntsfield. Peckhams being replaced by Sainsbury. There are 5 new express supermarkets within walking distance of my Deli. In Glasgow a Sainsbury garage opens in Woodlands followed by a Sainsbury on Great Western road and now a fairly big Tesco metro is planned just up the road from Sainsbury. If you dont think this is of any concern, take a look at Inverness and Paisley and the effect that this has had on independents or better still take a look at the obliteration of smalll shops that happened in American cities over the past 3 decades.18842013-10-25T14:04:29.4573107stephen higginsif a judge had a personal interest in fox hunting, would they be assigned a case involving such a thing.17152013-10-25T14:37:16.2973108Ian GoldenAll in the spirit of "Transparency" as they say in the establishment!17152013-10-25T14:46:55.183109DavidWhat possible justification can there be -other than assumed privilege-, for there to be unelected representatives advising and deciding on such important matters as PUBLIC education?19012013-10-26T18:43:02.833111Dave OwenFreemasons shoud be banned from any position in Public Office.17152013-10-26T19:13:06.9333112Sandy EdwardsWhy not call religious education Philosophy?\r\nThis would be inclusive to all life stances.\r\nAs for assemblies, they should surely be celebrating the community of the school.19012013-10-28T09:02:21.423113Maggie MuirHaving had personal experience of a loved one with dementia being detained I would state that the impact of this experience has had a devestating effect on his health and well being and was of no benefit to him WHATSOEVER.\r\nI have grave concerns for those detained who have no one to advocate and fight on their behalf, the system is such that they just get lost, and one has to wonder how many people are exhibiting behaviours as a result of medication that is administered to meet the limited resources of the facilities and not the needs of the individual. Also the 'power' base of the medical hierarchy does not enable a balanced approach as the majority of individual family and carers do not have the financial or even knowledge capacity to challenge, added to this is the emotional turmoil and the fact that most carers are just so exhausted and do not have the energy to take on a battle. Let us not forget that there are a lot of caring staff involved who on a day to day basis do the best they can.18942013-10-28T11:53:11.983114James FlynnNo Comment17152013-10-28T15:49:09.4773115Anne McShaneThis petition has long been needed. Mental health laws in this country are archaic and inhumane. Despite people speaking up about the treatment of people deemed to have a mental illness by others, nothing changes. Nobody cares unless it happens to you. This must change.18942013-10-28T18:38:33.1233116P McKennaMy grandparents explained to me how if you were of a particular religion in Scotland it was harder or simply impossible to get particular jobs. Preference was given to people of other religions for no good reason. Many of the people responsible for this were members of secret or biased societies. I am certain, sadly, some of this still goes on today. Anything which can therefore make people in positions of power - especially justice - more transparent should be welcomed.17152013-10-28T18:53:05.963117Fiona lundieI had a family member become mentally unwell as a result of medically prescribed steroid use. Initially the psychiatrist expected an improvement within a week. Sadly he was moved hospital and the new registrar disagreed that is was due to steroids. he was later proved wrong. He decided to try to sanction my relative without my knowledge despite the fact I was actually visiting at the time. When I asked for a second opinion I was told it was nothing to do with me. He was wrongness two accounts. my opinion did count and I was due a second opinion, which thankfully agreed with me. My family member was not trying to leave as the nurses had decided his behaviour suggested. If only they has talked to us. Sadly our mentally ill people are treated rather badly as a result of ignorance about the mental health act by professionals. This act is used instead of care and treatment. When I was not around my relative was put under a short term order and THEN given one to one support and medication to which he settled immediately. When I asked why this was not tried first they were flabbergasted. MHA first. I fought and won twice to prevent sectioning apart from the short term one. It should not be a fight. The MHA is there to protect patients, not make life easier for nurses and medical staff.18942013-10-28T18:54:02.9133118Liam WelshNo room for secret societies in this day and age. What good has come out of any secret?17152013-10-28T19:49:32.9273120IanIf you think about it religion in one form or another has probably caused more conflicts in this world than any other cause. 19012013-10-28T19:50:11.853121Paul CochraneAny secret society should be declared.17152013-10-28T20:09:04.733122BillyNo ban, just a declaration of conflict of interest17152013-10-28T22:18:38.4173124Robbie PenningtonSecret organisations have no place in the official mechanisms of a democracy. 17152013-10-28T22:48:36.853125Gavin AlexanderI don't know if members of any secret society are any worse than any other members of public office. However, in the interests of transparency, and to allow the population to have faith in these people, this is a good idea.17152013-10-29T00:06:43.0373126davie Hutchisonits about time something like this has come up, 17152013-10-29T07:08:24.0433127Trevor William StoneA representative must by definition be representative of the whole community, not a highly opinionated section of it. That is why we have elections. That is what makes us a democracy. That is why intelligent, honourable people defend democracy throughout the world.19012013-10-29T08:39:37.8733128alex lairdClear and transparent17152013-10-29T09:44:50.643129Alfred NobileAll public figures should be seen to have no bias towards any particular grouping.17152013-10-29T11:30:10.7173130John FitzpatrickTransparency please17152013-10-29T11:49:21.393131John MacfarlaneWhen someone has the power to take away someone liberty for a possible lifetime then we should be completely confident that everything is 100% above board. Nobody should be hiding anything. Ever.17152013-10-29T13:00:16.4673132Geordie ReidThis make the men in power sweat a little, wonder what the percentage is? No more discrimination! 17152013-10-29T20:28:50.833133Ryan MuldowneyCommon Sense must prevail 17152013-10-29T20:30:14.723134Stuart KennedyCouldn't agree more! The men with such power should disclose any information that's deemed in the publics interest. 17152013-10-30T09:03:53.5233135florence hewittStalinian... but it is all about money, isn'it ?18942013-10-30T19:49:10.9633136Elle MoI suppose one major draw of an independent Scotland would be the hope for greater support for small businesses. This would be a great way to illustrate this commitment to other voters and I. 18842013-10-30T20:51:49.9773137Cheryl PraxI was wrongly detained by three strangers who did not know me or even try to find out about me. They did not explain why I was being detained and so I tried to escape. They broke my arm in two places. The next day they stole my mobile phone and then injected me for complaining. My employer got me out after 8 days of hell. This was 2009 and I still have not got over the injustice. Psychiatry has far too much power. They hold mothers and children and refuse to let their loved ones look after them. Jailed without trial.18942013-10-31T16:50:44.0333138ann macfarlaneIt is important to have General Practice facilities in rural areas in order that local people can access the practice. Practices need to be able to continue to dispense to retain viability18892013-10-31T17:04:32.643139RhonaPlease do not allow someone to interfere with the life of a village just because he has money - and wants to!!!!18892013-11-02T20:18:06.6733140Stanley RichardsonI was wrongly diagnosed with "chronic mental disorder" in order to cover up malpractice in the NHS as I was butchered by a surgeon who has already been found guilty of malpractice for similar nasty deeds on other patients, the NHS and the GMC are nothing but a bunch of crooks who will do anything to cover their evil practices. Pure Evil!!!18942013-11-04T11:17:18.2433141Sophie PalmerWhile detention under the mental health act may be necessary for some, why is it used so much against young children who are denied the opportunity to live with their natural family?18942013-11-04T12:50:18.6133142Andrew MuirI have been asked to post the following:\r\n\r\n"I have been fighting my sectioning since 2000, which was brought about by my husband, he received help from his relative in the police and his crooked lawyer. I was sectioned under a 117 warrant, which gives the police powers or another authorised person to enter the premises, your home, and remove you to a mental hospital for 72 hours. When in hospital my GP, who had only met me once when I changed to her practice, and a social worker who had the title of MHO whom I had never met, both sectioned me under a Section 24. They approached me with 6 other people outside my flat telling me they were there to section me. I started to run, I was assaulted, carried to the hallway of my building, thrown onto the concrete floor, flipped over and forcibly held face down, my trousers pants taken down and I was injected with anti psychotic drug into my bottom and knocked out. I woke up in a mental hospital with two doctors taking blood from my arm and on a ECG monitor. My cousins (my next of kin) were told by the nurse in charge at the time, that he was concerned about my high blood pressure and that he was not happy by the way that I was taken in to hospital.\r\nI have been denied a copy of the warrant from Aberdeen Social Services and Aberdeen Sheriff Court, and to date I still do not have a copy of the warrant or the diagnosis as to why I was sectioned. Having gone through the terrible experience of being forcibly detained, having no mental health history, the whole thing was based on lies. The law has to change all my complaints have fallen on deaf ears. One is left with a label and NO VOICE. The Mental Welfare Commission is not independent and does not take a stance to help people in their hour of need. They do not even answer your letters. The Scottish Government has to listen and change this process of sectioning which open to abuse and corruption. I feel for the Duchess and everyone else." 18942013-11-04T15:42:45.7573143Norman ScarthA mistake in diagnosis is one thing. DELIBERATE incarceration of whistle blowers in 'Mental Hospitals' to silence them is another! see www.normanscarth.blogspot.com , though it is not as up to date as it should be. 18942013-11-07T11:19:10.5773146Leslie MitchellThis is a much needed sweeping away of an outdated and undemocratic privilege.19012013-11-07T12:10:18.3673147Catherine JoshiPlease do not give special privileges to those who profess religious beliefs. Scotland is a secular country. Put GOOD before God.\r\n19012013-11-07T17:39:07.0633148Linda BrittonEquality, respect, tolerance, all needed to ensure our children grow up in a democracy19012013-11-07T18:32:25.3133149mike foreman given my experiences as a social care supplier in shropshire from 2006 until the present day i am absolutely convinced that mental health service are facilitating the abuse vulnerable people for local authority fiscal advantage, an aktion nouveau if you will. 18942013-11-08T07:57:47.9933150Robert CanningThe problem with unelected church representatives sitting on education committees is not that they're church representatives. It is that they're unelected. If they want to sit on committees and have the desirable qualities they boast, they can present these in support of their election bids, like other candidates.19012013-11-08T10:10:54.313151Bill BedboroughA welcome removal of an untenable anachronism 19012013-11-12T12:30:36.9673152A. Burns We have experience of the Mental Health Tribunal system and have submitted a report of how we found the process to the Scottish Government and other interested agencies which led to a recent meeting with the Minister for Public Health. We have drawn similar conclusions and have made similar recommendations. We support this petition. PEO1494 18942013-11-13T20:14:42.393153Claire Muir"Any law which violates the inalienable rights of man is essentially unjust and tyrannical : it is not a law at all."\r\n\r\nMaximillien Robespierre18942013-11-17T22:15:38.773154Margaret GrahamWe are still uncovering new information from the authorities about what happened on the night my son died - the current system encourages corruption . 18872013-11-17T23:58:43.773155James ForbesAs an elected member of the General Teaching Council for Scotland, I asked in March 2010 why churches should sit on the GTC. For asking such a reasonable question I was thereafter subjected to a smear campaign of hatred. It's time Scotland liberated itself from the non-elected in education.19012013-11-18T06:14:07.123156Tom MinogueToo many cases of deaths in suspicious circumstances are simply attributed to suicide with no evidence to support this theory. The authorities don't like unsolved and thereby costly cases on their record and this is the driving force for the easy option: C.O.D. Suicide. 18872013-11-18T09:41:34.2173157James GibbonFirst class cause19222013-11-18T11:58:54.6273158Adrian StapletonAm member oF R.S.P.B.and i agree it should be Scotlands national bird ,and if we get the referendum vote yes all the more reason 19062013-11-18T12:10:25.9733159Paul TurnerThese beautiful birds are an iconic part of our Scottish natural history and are definately worthy of being our national bird. However they continue to face illegal percecution and I hope that making them our national bird would both raise the profile of these birds and also the work we need to undertake to protect them.19062013-11-18T12:26:26.8873160Mike FullerAnd while we are at it, might we see a realistic allocation of resources to secure the effective protection of this and other raptors, from persecution?19062013-11-18T13:00:32.173161Marion Hopkinsthese cars are part of British motoring history & should be saved to stay in Britian19222013-11-18T14:37:14.063162Kathy GormanThese magnificent birds need protecting along with all other threatened raptors. It's our duty, as custodians of this planet that we all share, to ensure they live and thrive for future generations.19062013-11-18T14:46:10.0073163Barney ThomsonThe Golden Eagle? Only if Scotland votes Yes in September. If the vote is No, it should be the cuckoo, aka gowk19062013-11-18T16:32:19.233164Chrissie HarperI to would like to see much more effort to stop the disgraceful persecution of our raptors.19062013-11-18T16:34:42.7233165Hazel KerrUs humans need to appreciate whats round us,so yes i certainly go for this,and to stop the people killing these wonderful birds 19062013-11-18T16:37:27.353166Christine MerrickThe golden eagle is such a majestic animal.its the first creature you think of when visiting Scotland.what a iconic bird.19062013-11-18T16:38:58.2573167Irene The Golden Eagle is a magnificent and statuesque symbol of freedom, which would be ideal as the symbol of Scotland.19062013-11-18T16:52:48.953168Martin MoirThe eagle and other birds need more protection. The eagle is iconic.19062013-11-18T16:57:20.3433169Peter WoodruffHOPE THIS HAPPENS.19062013-11-18T17:52:20.623170leslie.p.carterGolden eagles are such an iconic bird which should be scotlands symbol you see them all the time in scotland come make it your symbol.19062013-11-18T18:22:02.0073171David AdamTo watch a Golden Eagle soar over our Scottish mountains is a rare and unique experience, to some an expression of freedom and hope. Maybe this designation will encourage future generations to value this species as part of Scotland's precious wilderness habitat.19062013-11-18T18:33:59.413172peter harwoodif it strengthens the protection for this beautiful bird then it must be signed19062013-11-18T18:41:26.473173alice mullen shanksThese cars are part of our history they need to stay in the UK.\r\n19222013-11-18T18:48:16.563175Jane SmithHope you get the support it deserves19222013-11-18T19:30:21.23176Raymond GoodmanWe have a first class transport Museum and this would make a fantastic centrepiece!! The most famous Race car Transporter in the world and it belongs in Scotland. Lets rejoice the things we are good at rather than throwing money away at the things we arent...19222013-11-18T19:44:20.4133177Dorothy Girvan This collection must be kept in Britain, preferably Scotland19222013-11-18T19:47:39.863178Peter GirvanPart of Scotland's great Motorsport heritage 19222013-11-18T20:15:22.4573179Roisin NigFhloinnI think this is a very good idea as this will help to secure the protection of this magnificent bird. Plus, as National birds go - I think this one is hard to beat!19062013-11-18T20:23:38.8033180Dan SchobelockDone, hope it helps!18872013-11-18T21:14:21.553181william scottmon the eagles19062013-11-18T21:38:13.1673182ronnie grahamHopefully with the magnificent golden eagle as the national bird of Scotland it may spur the government on to provide realistic protection for this and Scotland's other iconic species of raptor.19062013-11-18T22:04:49.8073183Steve OrmerodWhat better symbol for Scotland to reveal its sense of power, spirit and pride in its landscape 19062013-11-18T23:40:08.0373184Sue TitchmarshI went to Scotland on a bird watching holiday and wil never forget the day that one of these magnificent birds flew out of some trees right over our heads. It was an unforgettable moment. These birds should be protected and revered for their beauty and importance to tourism in Scotland. 19062013-11-19T01:34:06.0073185Steve JohnstonThis collection is so much a part of Scotlands motorsport history. If this cant be kept in Scotland, then at the very least it must be kept in the UK. \r\nIt would be sickening to see this iconic collection broken up or going abroad.\r\n\r\nPlease, please, please keep these cars together in Scotland.19222013-11-19T06:41:53.4733186Brian WalkerVery good idea.19062013-11-19T08:20:45.3073187john milesWith half of Scotland killing eagles it must be the national bird to try and protect it,19062013-11-19T09:33:08.2933188Brian MinshullScotland should make way more of its natural assets and the Scottish government should take the lead on this on behalf of all, rather than running scared of vested interests..19062013-11-19T09:54:08.4173189sonia allan Hope this helps,and i will be sharing xx 18872013-11-19T09:59:27.63190Paul & Diann HindYes, this beautiful and iconic bird, the Golden Eagle, should be named at Scotland's National Bird.19062013-11-19T10:13:14.63191Barry O'Donoghue, IrelandIt would be a clear indication to people internationally of Scotland's interest (or otherwise) in Birds of Prey19062013-11-19T10:16:12.5673192den matheruse it or lose it!19062013-11-19T10:16:23.0673193Samantha FarrellI saw the lone golden eagle at Haweswater earlier in the year. It would be fantastic if the Lakes could have a breeding pair once more. My 8 year old son supports this as well. Good luck !.19062013-11-19T11:15:17.7973194Tony WhittleThe involvement of an Independent Coroner, as applies in all cases of 'Sudden Death' in England and Wales ensures the interests of the bereaved family and the public are served, rather than those of the State. 18872013-11-19T12:48:26.733195Martin MoirA soaring golden eagle: the symbol of a confident soaring independent nation.19062013-11-19T13:22:12.6533196Alex MackayMajestic and powerful.19062013-11-19T13:26:41.0173197ian hayhope this helps !!18872013-11-19T13:27:59.4033198Alan TempletonIt is vital that this iconic species is protected from persecution.19062013-11-19T13:35:03.993199Peter GustasPlease stop the persecution of Raptors in the UK !!19062013-11-19T14:55:31.6873200William SwanneyI have lived in Scotland most of my life. My wife and I live in the Scottish Highlands and often see Golden Eagles soaring over the hills near to our home.\r\nThis is why I support this petition19062013-11-19T15:16:38.993201Vicki BloomfieldThey're one of the reasons my family and I holiday in Scotland every year - high time they were better celebrated!19062013-11-19T15:20:32.323202Chris AvantiMajestic! Just like Scotland19062013-11-19T15:24:01.263203Matthew EllisHow lucky we are to have the Golden Eagle as native to our land. Let's hope it can thrive, spread and conquer Northern England!\r\n19062013-11-19T15:26:33.5573204Paul ForecastI have seen golden eagles on Islay and Mull. They are magnificent birds that would be befitting of a magnificent country. 19062013-11-19T15:30:04.563205Desmond Duganeagles are important but so are all our birds!19062013-11-19T15:37:04.3733206Elaine VennIt's shameful how huge supermarkets are able to go seemingly where they like. Tesco is the most aggressive in this behaviour. Build affordable houses not supermarkets!18842013-11-19T15:45:32.013207angela fearnGood luck19062013-11-19T15:58:54.0773208Damon BridgeIn my mind - living here in the South West of the UK - the Golden Eagle is so associated with the wild, rugged, and beautiful uplands of the British Isles for it to become the national bird of Scotland will give it a status that it well deserves and will hopefully help to protect it throughout the whole of its native range.19062013-11-19T15:59:45.2473209David JonesAs a top predator it's population reflects the health of our whole environment.19062013-11-19T16:04:38.9333210Dee WilliamsSave it!19222013-11-19T16:06:43.7033211David BraithwaiteAnd more Scottish eagles gives hope for their sustained return to England!19062013-11-19T16:37:32.093212Alan JohnsonPlease adopt the golden eagle as the national bird of Scotland!19062013-11-19T17:01:38.9333213Claudio LabriolaSarebbe bellissimo se la Scozia riconoscesse l'Aquila reale, come rappresentante della Nazione.\r\n\r\nIt would be great if Scotland recognises the Golden Eagle, as a representative of the nation.19062013-11-19T17:08:25.6233214Monica WhittonQuite Right Too!19062013-11-19T17:10:17.73215Maria JustamondA beautiful bird and the perfect choice to represent a beautiful country!19062013-11-19T17:15:29.6833216S ButtPlease declare the golden eagle as Scotland's national bird. 19062013-11-19T17:25:52.533217Gordon BuchananA potent symbol of power, beauty and majesty. Help offer further protection and officially declare the Golden Eagle Scotland's national bird.19062013-11-19T17:30:46.483218Gilly RobinsonI saw a golden eagle soaring high above on the Ardnamurchan peninsula many years ago. One of those 'Wow!' experiences... An iconic bird for an iconic country.19062013-11-19T17:51:02.733219Danny UdallMy best memories of Scotland contain Eagles.\r\nWithout them the landscape would seem empty.19062013-11-19T17:55:12.5673220Shonah GibbonThese cars are too precious to loose19222013-11-19T17:56:33.383221David Gilfillan Perhaps we should have done this years ago , many countries would be proud of the Eagle . 19062013-11-19T17:58:01.8573222david blairIt should have been well before now 19062013-11-19T18:05:14.7133223Shona ButlerA beautiful bird for a beautiful country.19062013-11-19T18:06:57.513224Lorne BrandHelp it happen.\r\n19062013-11-19T18:25:34.473225Rick VonkGolden eagles - top predators and a worthy icon for Scotland.19062013-11-19T18:41:09.713227Sue RobertsonPlease be the voice for these wonderful birds.19062013-11-19T18:47:40.9773228Carolyn LeeGreat idea and rightly so.19062013-11-19T19:13:00.2933229David PollardA good choice\r\n19062013-11-19T19:35:04.1133230Claire PoolePlease adopt the Golden Eagle as Scotlands' national bird, awe inspiring bird.19062013-11-19T19:49:45.043231Tom CoffieldWe must have this fantastic bird as our National Bird 'The Golden Eagle'19062013-11-19T19:51:03.313232Kenneth LittleA truly iconic species of natural Scotland.19062013-11-19T20:19:18.5573233www.borderreivers.coThis is home for these cars need we add more19222013-11-19T20:32:45.2333234Ann StanleyHope this helps18872013-11-19T21:06:40.6073235Sandra FarrI take two holidays each year on mull and get immense pleasure from watching eagles on this beautiful island. Good luck in your efforts to get this iconic bird recognised as a national bird of majestic Scotland. 19062013-11-19T21:47:46.3333236Ian PatersonAs an iconic symbol of Scotland's contribution to the Motorsport industry this needs to stay in it's homeland. 19222013-11-19T22:35:08.023237Heather RobertsonWhat a wonderful bird to have as the national bird of Scotland....powerful,handsome and important...just like our nation!19062013-11-19T23:31:19.4233238robin smithok, who owns this collection of motly race cars, could it be a Scotsman who wishes to cash in on their value19222013-11-20T06:13:38.593239Emma ErikssonMy boyfriend died in a fire, the police know it's not an accident but they can't find proof against those who set the apartment on fire....\r\nIt hurts even more to not know, why is the question that keeps coming to me and i belive is the same for you! I hope my name gave you some kind of help! 18872013-11-20T07:07:35.7773240Michelle MinellI do what ever to help18872013-11-20T09:17:25.4433241Paula BakerCharismatic and emblematic, an ideal candidate for Scotlands national bird!19062013-11-20T09:29:44.2633242Shireen GreenA wonderful icon for a beautiful country.19062013-11-20T09:42:54.9373243Damian WoodgateI only visited Scotland for the first time this year, the reason being to look for Golden Eagles. Well I succeeded and went back another 2 times to see them again. I cannot think of a better way to honour such a majestic bird. This is a step in the right direction for Scotland, cannot think many scots would disagree.19062013-11-20T11:16:26.043244Ellen GledhillThis beautiful bird is a fitting emblem for Scotland's iconic landscape.19062013-11-20T12:45:31.3733245Jacqueline SmithDo it for Keith!19062013-11-20T13:58:04.73246Iain B MackenzieWhy not have a National Animal Flower Insect19062013-11-20T14:20:14.893247Marcello MegaI've been a journalist for almost 25 years and have some knowledge of how investigations into deaths are conducted. I know that in many cases where a grieving family suspects foul play, the evidence doesn't support it. In both these cases, there is considerable evidence to support foul play and even more evidence to support ineptitude by investigators, and much of what has followed, by way of action by officials, has been about covering up the investigative failures rather than seeking justice for Annie, Colin and those who love them.18872013-11-20T14:26:47.033248Lisa DoveFly like a eagle19062013-11-20T15:24:09.9073249Jennifer BlairHope my support is of some help Stuart & Margaret. 18872013-11-20T16:39:30.4833250Allen FishAs a US raptor biologist, I can say that Golden Eagles are not secure in their population status here either. 19062013-11-20T16:47:25.453251Stuart MacfarlaneBest of luck with the petition, hope it makes a difference.18872013-11-20T18:17:26.533252Finlay DowellA noble cause but the eagle is already high profile and there are other birds which need to be made high profile with stiffer jail sentences for those who persecute birds in any manner. 19062013-11-20T20:53:35.7333253James K CraibSecond to no other Scottish bird just like Scotland as a country once we get independence.19062013-11-20T20:58:03.783254Michael PearsonGood work going on in Scotland. Please look after the hen harriers too. Unlikry to be any breeding pairs in northern England in the near future. We have to watch out for the buzzard as well now. In fact,recent legislation is a foot in the door for most of the lager raptor species.19062013-11-20T21:57:49.3433255Theo ter HarkWatched them flying for the 1st time in my life just outside Uig summer 1996. Great and wonderful creatures. Besides all the other worthwhile natural aspects of Scotland this bird could be the One!19062013-11-20T22:39:47.4833256Ron HessThere is no bird more regal than the Golden Eagle. It should be protected all over the world.19062013-11-20T23:50:59.623257Gary RippinTotal transparency with all available information,shared between all the relevant parties and complete disclosure should be the only course adopted by the authorities.\r\nIf there is nothing to hide then why not share the information.\r\nIt is too easy to hide behind data protection and not in the public interest !!!!\r\n\r\n18872013-11-21T09:57:04.283258Iain Clark Great idea19062013-11-21T11:18:47.213259Mina NakhaiThe Golden Eagle is a magnificent bird and will be an asset to Scotland if named as the country's national bird. The native Indians of the United States were expert scalpers, no wonder the Bald Eagle is their national emblem.19062013-11-21T12:13:49.1633260Lorraine CairleyGreat idea!19062013-11-21T12:51:50.1773261Dee RaineyFast, powerful, gracefull and Beautiful - The Golden Eagle19062013-11-21T15:10:10.873262Chris DawesWe need to stop the takeover of our towns by unwanted superstores. I am one of many campaigning against an enormous superstore in the historic fishing port of Brixham, Devon.18842013-11-21T16:20:52.9433263Eva OrtoftHope this helps, and I will be sharing with my friends about this as long as I can!18872013-11-21T16:41:20.1773264David ClarkeA bird of wild places, fills the imagination. 19062013-11-21T16:49:16.4133265stacey livngstonesave the golden eagle19062013-11-21T16:51:04.3233266diana scraftonI believe the public should chose where supermarkets are located because these large operators undermine local markets and suck money out of communities, furthermore thier buying tactics are widely recognised to be unacceptable and their dominance needs curtailing.18842013-11-21T17:03:42.4133267Michael KelsoThis is a fantastic idea !!!19062013-11-21T17:27:01.593268Debbie CuthbertA magnificent bird. Perhaps the fact that it is persecuted, along with other birds of prey in Scotland, would be viewed as a more prominent issue if it were to become our national bird.19062013-11-21T17:29:37.2633269Dougie SalteriA more noble bird could hardly fly across Scotland.19062013-11-21T17:45:10.0533270Lynsey Faulkner Beautiful bird 19062013-11-21T17:48:59.6633271Jeff ClarkeIt's an absolute disgrace that raptors are still being persecuted in the UK, including Scotland This move will help to protect them into the future and may suggest that the governments of the UK and Scotland are not pandering to the every wish of the large estate owners and there gamekeepers.19062013-11-21T17:53:04.4773272Keith PerryAll raptors need protecting from shooting estates who are breeding birds to shoot and illegally kill these magnificent birds in case they eat a few of the chicks they are going to kill anyway! 19062013-11-21T18:14:23.0233273Shona blackA magnificent bird.19062013-11-21T20:29:32.3973274Tony FramptonWhy isn't it already so??19062013-11-21T20:29:32.7873275bill holmesWatched two soaring over Largybaan, Mull of Kintyre.\r\nWild as the heather !!19062013-11-21T22:36:05.493276iain kerrmake it so please19062013-11-22T07:20:12.5473277Walter HampsonThe eagle like Scotland is magnificent, powerful and pleasing to look at. It has been a symbol of Scotland throughout history19062013-11-22T10:19:04.6873279Sue RowleyI have been fortunate enough to see several golden eagles during my thrice-yearly wildlife watching holidays in the Highlands and Islands of Scotland and nothing epitomises the wildness and beauty of the country more. It should definitely be the national symbol of Scotland.19062013-11-22T11:47:56.4373280Sarah DixonI am a member of a protest group trying to stop my local pub becoming a Tesco Express. If Tesco and its rivals continue to bludgeon their way into our local communities there will be less and less choice as to where to shop.18842013-11-22T13:05:09.3433281Alice GroomGolden Eagles truely engender that sense of the wild and magnificant rurality in Scotland19062013-11-22T14:10:30.533282Nigel JoslinThis is a fantastic and majestic bird and is appropriate for the accolade.19062013-11-22T15:09:25.1873283aynslievery well19012013-11-22T16:39:06.5073284Susan RobertsonAlways thrilling to have the privilege to see one soaring above you in the wild open spaces.19062013-11-22T17:43:10.6633285jagtar gillI have been a grocer for 31 years.the feedback I get from my customers is that Tesco prices are the most expensive.tesco take advantage of there store location,meaning if your nearest supermarket is Tesco then it is expensive to travel to another suopermarket.it has been a few years now that asda guarantee that your comparable shopping will be 10% cheaper than any rival.i could compete with Tesco on prices,however customers feel that a supermarket is cheaper.this is ideology is now changing.however as a small grocer I can only offer a fair price and hope that the customer feels good about getting the odd items needed before the next trip to the big supermarkets.TESCO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THEIR TRADING LOCATION AND THEREFORE IT LEAVES CUSTOMERS WITH LITTLE CHOICE BUT TO SHOP THERE.18842013-11-22T20:17:42.1073286alan gowThis collection must stay in Scotland.19222013-11-23T08:05:26.283287Christopher SomervilleIt's incredible to think that the golden eagle is NOT yet Scotland's national bird! I'm sure anyone who has seen one would be amazed that the species is persecuted. My memory of watching a golden eagle driving a bunch of grouse across a snowy hillside in Upper Glen Findhorn is still vivid. Well done, petitioners, and good luck!19062013-11-23T08:38:15.513288Anne GilmoreAnnie deserved better from Scotland, I am ashamed that no more was done to find her killer. It's never too late for justice!18872013-11-23T11:47:27.6773289Alyson HoneymanHope this petition is a success and the law is changed. current system obviously doesn't work. Stay strong.18872013-11-23T14:49:38.1833290Steve PalmerI agree with Gary Rippin below. Total transparency needs to be achieved in this and any similar matters. Carol and i hope all the heartache and work you have gone through can remedy a seemingly obvious injustice.18872013-11-23T15:51:12.8433291Struan BadburyI fully support this petition.18872013-11-24T08:39:35.1873292Lynne MackayHopefully the real problem will be looled at. The lack of safe areas to overtake and clearer road signs.18682013-11-24T08:53:20.3733293Kevin AnnandaleSpend the money to duel the A9 instead of spending millions on a Border train line.18682013-11-24T08:57:56.7173294Fraser SteellAs a regular traveller to the Black Isle to visit my partners grandmother who suffer dementia I really hope they do not go through with this 18682013-11-24T08:59:16.063295Paul EvansAverage speed cameras should be done awa with & more actual speed cameras placed on the road ...this will stop abiguity for drivers by forcing them too slow down & cause frustration on this perilous road18682013-11-24T08:59:53.753296LauraUse the money for duelling more of the A9, cameras are definately not the answer! 18682013-11-24T09:00:05.173297Davie MacleodDual The A9 .... It's the 40 mph speed limit for HGV's that causes frustration, which leads to accidents which causes Death ... I am an HGV Driver with 14 years experience and use the A9 every day ..... I have witnessed a few bad ones where people have died .... 18682013-11-24T09:02:30.063298BillySlowing the traffic down is not the answer. Dualling the whole stretch from Perth to Inverness, with safe junctions is the answer. Because the road has a mixture of slow and fast moving traffic. Junctions are very un safe, some people are impatient some people cant judge the speed of traffic coming towards them. I think putting ave speed cameras on the route are not the answer. Speed it not the danger but dangerous driving is.18682013-11-24T09:03:13.4533299Christopher BarkerAverage speed cameras are only going to cause Its at joffs.. nana had it and as she was gettn out the car the wind blew the door open n nana got dragged out n her foot hit the accselerator pedal n car spun round n auntie janets car n zhen my car ended up in sophie's garden at lime park....opposite janets hse... front passenger side wing n bumper n headlite smashed on my car xmore fustration between car & van drivers weavibg in & out of hgv lorries....\r\nIf the A9 speed limit was put upto 50mph for hgv's then you would get less impatient car & van drivers!! (FACT)...\r\nDualling the A9 also has its benefits also as then you get a steady lineof vehicles travelling up & down it...\r\nThis will not stop accidents BUT it will definatley reduce the number of accidents...\r\nHGV's are getting blamed for accidents on the A9!!!\r\nBut in this year alone (2013).. hgv's have not been the major factor in these incidents just careless impatient car & van drivers trying to sneak outof laybys & junctions because they have it in thier minds that they will be stuck behind the hgv vehicle for a long period of time!!\r\nNot true!! Most hgv drivers pull in and let ques past!! But what alot of small vehicle drivers dont seem to understand is that it can take a few minutes for a fully frieghted lorry to get up to speed & maintain it.. especially on uphill gradients!!\r\nSo if small vehicle drivers were educated in this way then they would understand & maybe think twice before trying to get past at ridiculous times on these roads i.e.( A9 ) etc.....\r\nSo show more respect towards hgv's !!!\r\nRemember these words!!\r\n\r\nWhen behind a lorry\r\nDon't try & hurry\r\nYour life depends on it..!!!!!\r\n\r\nFact!! : Lorry drivers keep this country running !!\r\nYour Food,Medicines,Cars,Vans,Clothes,Toiletries etc etc etc......All get deliverd by HGV Transport!!! \r\nSo .\r\nShow Respect, Not Neglect!!!18682013-11-24T09:04:09.2333300Ken PoveyVverage speed cameras are not what is required, The A9 needs to be dual carriageway between Inverness and Perth and the Central Belt.18682013-11-24T09:05:37.1573301JI think the money should just be spend on making the A9 duel carriage all the way. Why spend all this money on cameras. 18682013-11-24T09:07:353302Rachel MakenzieUse these funds wisely. I was up and down the A9 in the last3 days n it's overtaking opportunities that are urgently required if lives are to be saved. Reinstate tge sight lines that were there at the time of construction as a stop gap before dualling. Also lorries need to be able to travel faster18682013-11-24T09:18:58.213303gavin EdwardI think this a waste of public money that will only cause more frustration on the A9\r\nAs a regular user I find. It is a few idiots causing havoc with idiotic overtaking maneuvers and not speed that causes the problems18682013-11-24T09:19:54.573304John m steeleAverage speed cameras will not work, because there will b too mutch build up of traffic travelling behind lorrys at 40mph, and frustrated car drivers will try to overtake at any time, even when they can't see , 18682013-11-24T09:28:52.8433305KevinProposed speed cameras do not address overtaking issues which are a significantly higher cause of accidents. Also does not take account of distance HGV's will need to travel at 40mph, effectively increasing the cost of living for everyone North of Perth.18682013-11-24T09:32:18.8433306Mark SutherlandAverage speed cameras will do nothing to promote safety on the A9 because the average speed is already well below 60. People speed when they overtake because they put the pedal to the metal to get past and back in again before a truck coming the other way wipes them out. You could 85 passing a truck and be back down to 60 and it will make no nevermind to your average speed. What will hapen, and we saw it happen recently with the average speed cameras on the M90 when the road works were on, is that people will drive well under the speed limit because they are scared their speedos aren't completely accurate or maybe they sped a little further back by accident and so although the speed limit was 40, huge swathes of people were doing 30 and th rest were doing 35. This would happen on the A9 making the tailbacks and frustration and dangerous overtaking even worse.\r\nReCaptcha is the most irritating application on the internet. Please stop using it.18682013-11-24T09:33:46.9333307Craig LambMaking drivers stick to 40 mph for long periods will amplify frustration and the number of risks taken will be horrendous the A9 is not a bad road it's the minority of idiots taking high risk overtakes etc that has spoiled it for the majority of good safe road users.18682013-11-24T09:43:19.0473308Yvonne BoaI live in Ullapool but from Edinburgh and go down for most Hearts football matches and to visit my friends, I can honestly say adding average speed cameras will just add to more frustration and therefore even more accidents on this road. Simple measures that are more cost effective could be done now before its dualled, improvements on speed signs, a layby to stop north of Drumochter with facilities like a mobile van with coffee and a port a loo could make significant difference to accidents. I would average less than 50 from Inverness to Perth on the A9, as you always get stuck in long convoys of traffic. With average speed cameras the entire stretch will make people spend more time looking at their speedometer rather than the road and will add a lot more time on to the journey. Are we not trying to progess the access to the Highlands? Or we trying to isolate even further? I would like the Parliament to seriously think about the people who live up north in all of this. The tourist and business industry will be badly damaged with 100 odd miles af average speed cameras to contend with on your trip and therefore add more costs to the average Highlander for goods and services and less income from the tourist market. Improve our public transport links and get the money spent on upgrading the A9, not on a revenue stream to punish A9 users even more. 18682013-11-24T09:47:28.4533309james forbesAs a trucker who daily uses the a9 i have come across many an accident and had countless near misses with cars overtaking dangerously. this dueling desperately needs done to prevent more needless death.18682013-11-24T09:51:56.2273310John ScottEnforced spacing between HGV's is the single most straightforward action that should be taken, along with allowing these vehicles to travel at 50mph, which they are perfectly safe to do in this day and age.18682013-11-24T09:59:26.983311Lorraine MacFarlaneI use the A9 several times a week for business purposes as a car driver. Slowing traffic further will increase RTAs not reduce them. In my opinion the root cuases of A9 accidents are poor driver (not speeding ones) and frustration caused by a road not fit for purpose. ASC will not address these issues but will exacerbate them when more drivers become over-caution leading to extensive tail backs and thus riskier overtaking manoeuvres. 18682013-11-24T10:05:06.2173312Sharon QueenReducing the limit will solve nothing and cause more overtaking which is the main cause of accidents!18682013-11-24T10:09:18.6573313Heather MackinnonIt makes sense to delay any workings till they know what money they fork out is for the right decision made.18682013-11-24T10:14:57.563314Michael O'DonnellThe average speed camera idea is an awful idea, and dualling the entire A9 is the only way to cut out horrendous overtaking maneuvers by frustrated drivers.18682013-11-24T10:17:16.1933315George CameronASC are not the answer, it needs central money diverted ASAP to ensure the A9 is dualled immediately!\r\nSpeed is not the main cause of accidents, the road is not fit for purpose and the sooner the Scottish Government pay as much attention to this as the Yes Campaign, the better for the Highlands!18682013-11-24T10:18:08.143316Emma SharpDualling is the only way to go. Use the money you were going to spend on cameras to duel another section now. Keep duelling small sections when money available. 18682013-11-24T10:23:33.5073317John McRaeAs a frequent A9 user I agree it is risky overtaking driven by frustration that causes accidents. The only solution to this is dualling the A9. All average speed cameras will do is swell the coffers of Parliment.18682013-11-24T10:24:38.7573318Kenneth MackenzieThis would only slow all traffic down to 40mph behind lorries. This would cause frustration and also reduce cars average speed. This would mean that cars could then to overtake a very high speeds well in excess of 60mph to try to clear long tail backs which will lead to many more deaths on the A9. This cannot be allowed to go ahead.18682013-11-24T10:30:03.8073319Sean DonnellyThe ultimate answer is to dual or even install a motorway but in the short term additional lengths of dual carriage way or overtaking lanes. The other problem is the placement of road safety camera vans on the only stretches of places safe to overtake making people take chances on other stretches. Average speed cameras are not the answer here!18682013-11-24T10:34:28.6533320Roderick BoydI firmly believe that cameras will only increase driver frustration on this busy road, leading to more accidents. 18682013-11-24T10:39:05.9033321Lesley MeldrumThis wont stop the accidents this will make them worse build bridges 18682013-11-24T10:41:35.673322Diane DavidsonSlow speed just as dangerous as fast speed. Lorries should be allowed to keep up their speed after dual carriageway. Cameras wouldn't help frustration of drivers and that's how the A9 is so dangerous. Frustration is a killer force.18682013-11-24T10:42:15.893323Stephen LovieA9 is a good road, just drivers become impatient and frustrated by slower lorries and some cars and try to overtake. I personally experienced at least 1 idiot on Friday the 22nd November. 18682013-11-24T10:42:57.253324Diane DavidsonSlow speed just as dangerous as fast speed. Lorries should be allowed to keep up their speed after dual carriageway. Cameras wouldn't help frustration of drivers and that's how the A9 is so dangerous. Frustration is a killer force.18682013-11-24T10:44:52.4733325chrisRepeatedly claiming my email address is invalid will not discourage me from signing this petition. Nice try!18682013-11-24T10:48:32.313326CharlesworthAverage speed cameras are NOT the answer. This will simply ensure HGVs travel t the regulated 40mph, cause more tailbacks and, therefore, more overtaking resulting in more accidents!18682013-11-24T10:48:50.8273327Neil Cruickshanks There is a lot of frustration on the A9 caused by small moving Vehicles, trucks doing 40mph, Causing inpatient drivers to do dangerous over takes, 18682013-11-24T10:51:21.893328Ross HughesHope it makes a difference18872013-11-24T10:53:05.3573329Ruan PeatThe A9 needs to be dueled not have more cameras that do nothing when your part of a line of 50+ cars etc stuck behind a slow moving anything!18682013-11-24T10:53:39.4673330c bellslowing the traffic wont help,let hgvs travel at 56 mph18682013-11-24T10:53:39.9533331Karin StewartNO18682013-11-24T10:57:20.7973332Mark WillenbrockCameras - and in particular average speed cameras - are nothing but a revenue stream.\r\n\r\nThere are excellent arguments for siting them outside schools and in urban areas, but as as the revenue raised is insignificant, few are in such important sites. Despite this, these are the positions where they are most likely to save lives.\r\n\r\nAverage speed cameras will increase bunching, frustration, dangerous overtaking and inevitably accidents, whilst extracting totally disproportionate fines and bans.18682013-11-24T11:02:35.1533333Elliot TomsI agree one hundred percent with the above comments18682013-11-24T11:20:30.4373334Kenneth f MurdochAverage speed cameras are a must for long term road works \r\nFor safety only there is enough cameras and camera vans to cover the most black\r\n spots in Scotland without more \r\n18682013-11-24T11:24:13.913335Mark ElderI use the A9 every day to work between Strathspey and Inverness. Speed camera's are not the answer. Its been near misses due to overtaking that I have witnessed that are the issue so dual carriageways are the only sensible option instead of a short sighted camera system. I am sure this would not be allowed to happen in the central belt!18682013-11-24T11:26:46.8733336Simon davidsonI use the a9 on a regular basis with a truck and I see all the crazy over taking cause of the lorry speed limit. I personal think raising it 50 mph for trucks would solve the problem certainly do think average speed cameras are the answer 18682013-11-24T11:34:26.813337James DuffSpeed cameras will NOT improve road safety they will seriously increase the hazard by forcing drivers to take more chances to get past slow moving vehicles, the problem lies in the road in that there are very few places to safely overtake because of the plethora a blind summits and blind bends, speed cameras will make this far worse, the problem isn't speed, the problem is the road ahead can't be seen far enough ahead.18682013-11-24T11:35:01.673338Stephen Scott OlivantThis road is a death trap due to several factors, most notably the 40mph enforced speed limit of lorries which prevent safe over-taking, long stretches of road with no clear overtaking areas or views and atrocious road surfaces. The North has been ignored again whereas the Central Belt has had yet more road improvements announced. This is criminal negligence.18682013-11-24T11:38:23.1373339Michael SantWe have been using the A9 regularly for 12 years : the road layout constantly changes from single carriageway to three lane to dual carriageway which creates extremely difficult and potentially dangerous conditions particularly in poor weather and in the dark.Major improvements to the road should be the priority not wasting money on large numbers of speed cameras which will have a terrible visual impact particularly through the Grampians. 18682013-11-24T11:41:36.7173340Richard allenWhen can you. Ever average over 60 on the A9 anyway. 18682013-11-24T11:43:10.5473341Catrina Angela MacleanAverage speed cameras are not the answer! Widen the road 18682013-11-24T11:46:19.7133342Allen BrownThey have no idea the biggest danger is overtaking slower drivers. they need to create a law where if you build up so many cars behind you for so far you MUST pull over to allow people who need to go the speed limit to pass.18682013-11-24T11:55:08.0933343Leslie McLagganThe A9 does not need average speed cameras18682013-11-24T11:59:42.783344Tam ReidThere are other issues that are causing accidents on tnis road and speeding isnt the issue , I have seen accidents on this road and it hasnt been speeding thats caused it 18682013-11-24T12:09:44.1873345colin cappcameras are not the answer up the speed limit off hgv and duel the A9 inverness to perth18682013-11-24T12:15:44.3473346David MooreIt is BAD driving that causes the problems on the A9. Drivers who are ignorant in their manouvers and drivers who pay NO attention to the road. Also since the A9 was designed and built the vegitation has closed off many of the designed in lines of visability to make it a safe road. Also poor sighting of road signs have also made visability worse.\r\n18682013-11-24T12:20:46.7873347Tricia AdieSeems to me that the brains behind this idea are not regular users of the A9 or they'd know it's not the solution. 18682013-11-24T12:25:02.923348Adam BeckThe issue is not with drivers speeding, it's them not going fast enough. Therefore frustrating other drivers into making mistakes by not being able to overtake.\r\nWhat does worry, though, is that an investigation would end up costing as much as the cameras themselves.\r\nThe road clearly needs to be duelled.18682013-11-24T12:32:45.8433349chrisDual carrige is only option but exspensive so the average speed cameras is a easy and cheaper wsy to save face and forget about the problem18682013-11-24T12:33:54.063350Andrew Murdoch No need for this rubbish get the30MPH and 40 MPH to get of the road they cause most accidents and get the lorry drivers to pull in and let traffic flow when they see 6 vehicles behind them18682013-11-24T12:35:20.733351Andrew CecilSelfish and aggressive driving need to be addressed, speed cameras will not do this. I have had cars that close i could not see their headlights, un-marked patrols would be better.18682013-11-24T12:46:183352Lesley SilverI am astonished that this petition is necessary. I wish it success. 18872013-11-24T12:48:00.2633353Donna Beck This road should have been dualled a long time ago instead of wasting money on the trams. How many people have died because of this. As far as I am concerned having driven this road many times it is the overtaking that is the issue. Ok may be average speed will work in that people won't necessarily overtake for fear of messing with thier average BUT I have driven so slow in this road that the average speed is prob lower than the speed limit due to congestion! This will NOT help! 18682013-11-24T12:48:213354John SeharIf anyone from the southern end of the A9 had to use the road daily they would sigb this petition without hesitation! !!18682013-11-24T12:48:31.253355Dawn MorrisonAverage speed cameras will encourage more dangerous overtaking due to longer time required to pass vehicles.18682013-11-24T12:48:31.893356Darren HuntPut the monet from buying cameras towards another stretch of dual carriegeway..18682013-11-24T12:59:52.5133357Jonathan OxleyAs a regular user of the A9 over many years, I cannot see how the installation of these average speed cameras will have a positive effect on road safety on the A9. The road has such a mixed range of traffic - speed and type - that such a flawed proposal will merely serve to increase frustration among road users and lead to riskier overtaking manoeuvres.18682013-11-24T13:00:58.1533358Wendy PieroniAverage speed cameras will cause frustration and make a dangerous road even more dangerous.18682013-11-24T13:08:53.7833359Stuart RoxburghWhilst I am all for reducing the number of accidents on the A9, average speed cameras are not the answer.18682013-11-24T13:10:20.863360Paul DunnettCameras are not the answer.18682013-11-24T13:36:45.893361MikeIf the government were serious about saving lives they would upgrade the full A9 to dual carriageway. I note instead they chose to waste millions on a tram system that doesn't even replace ONE bus route and won't save a single life. 18682013-11-24T13:38:03.343362Alan mackayYears of advancement on technology and engineering and no advancement on the speed limit18682013-11-24T13:43:21.063363Robert J S ChristieThe problems on the A9 are due solely to a total lack for foresight on the part of the planners etc in the 70s when the " old " road was upgraded. The reason for then then upgrading was the impact the (then) embryonic oil industry was having on the North of Scotland. Had some of the oil revenues been ring-fenced to do the job properly then, this road would NOT have had the dreadful litany of death and carnage which the original lack of foresight produced.18682013-11-24T13:51:24.7973364Drew Reidmore traffic bunching would occur,no real thought given to affects on those actually travelling on the road.18682013-11-24T13:54:09.8733365Alan BellGet a grip an just get it duelled! 18682013-11-24T13:55:15.5273366leighann mcgartlandThink this would put families minds to rest \r\n18872013-11-24T14:05:53.5473367Philip BurginDangerous and risky overtaking manoeuvres, in part brought about by the inherent frustration caused by the necessity to follow or be part of a following convoy behind HGVs is responsible for the vast majority of road accidents on the A9. The proposed introduction of average speed cameras is not only ill advised but irresponsible as this WILL promote MORE of these same overtaking in.18682013-11-24T14:10:37.4873368John LuckwellAccident are caused by mechanical failure or bad drivers. Not all drivers who keep within the speed limits are GOOD drivers and not all drivers who exceed the speed limit are BAD drivers. When cameras become sophisticated enough to tell the difference between these two types of driver, I will support them.18682013-11-24T14:20:50.883369Wayne A MunroI am against the proposals in their current form, and believe there will be little to no improvement, also that the funds could be better spent to actually save lives.18682013-11-24T14:31:41.5133370graeme cuthbertThe implementation of these cameras will fundamentally increase accidents,choke the traffic flow,there are other ways of improving traffic safety,but prior to implementing any please consult the people that use the road and take facts from them,as opposed to the facts being taking from a road in Ayrshire That bears no direct similarity\r\n18682013-11-24T14:47:38.613371John bellBring in a law where trucks must travel at least 6 truck lengths apart or only 3 trucks in 1 mile stretch 18682013-11-24T15:24:47.3433372jim wilson I travelled Inverness to Perth return last thursday my average speed on the way down was 43mph and that was with Hgv's travelling at 50mph god now's what it'll be if they drive at 40mph. Lets throw down the gauntlet to the MP's requesting average speed cameras, get them to drive invernes to perth return every day for a month then ask they if it should be dualled!!!!!!18682013-11-24T15:36:33.5773373Andrew HamiltonCaithness is in Scotland too. The A9 must be dual carriageway all the way from Inverness to Thurso. Please do not discriminate against us.18682013-11-24T16:05:32.6073374Angela WindsorI would like to reiterate my concerns regarding the A9 cameras. The traffic flow is such with the varying types of traffic on the A9 that the cameras will endanger the economic prosperity of all north of Perth (before Perth there is continuous dual carriageway). I am concerned that my views were not asked for that this is an imposition and if this is the new Scotland then I am very unsure that my views will be taken regard of. Please consult widely within the community and I really need to be sure that you are listening to the ROAD USERS.18682013-11-24T16:08:35.0133375john binnieslow vehicles are the problem not speed18682013-11-24T16:31:55.3133376Jill BelchThese camera will not do anything but add to frustration. Start dualing the carriageways sooner, or have more of the three lanes with one clearly single and other clearly double. These latter could make a huge difference in allowing safe passing and decreased frustration, as the few there already do. Pls think this thro!18682013-11-24T16:39:28.7033377Mathew MackayIncorrect decision. 18682013-11-24T16:40:47.5773378John MacdonaldPolice need to concentrate on the absolutely shocking overtaking that goes on. It would do no harm either to pull over some of the slower moving traffic now and again, I don't mean the lorries here, more the caravan tourists who don't use mirrors often enough to see the traffic building up behind them. Really, the traffic using the A9 should not be looked on as a means of collecting revenue by way of speeding tickets, it's a pointless exercise if the real aim is preventing accidents.18682013-11-24T16:41:20.023379Karen petersImprove the road not the cameras, I drive the A9 every day.18682013-11-24T16:57:473380Rory ForrestSpeed does not cause accidents. Poor judgement by frustrated and poor drivers does. Average speed cameras will make no difference and will increase frustration.18682013-11-24T17:01:07.393381Marlen FairweatherScotland18682013-11-24T17:19:55.513382Paul GallagherIt appears that the proposal for average speed cameras is little but an attempt to shirk the responsibility for taking real action. Any user of the A9 will know that accidents are caused by a combination of slow vehicles, limited opportunities to overtake safely, and the impatience caused by such long stretches where their are neither duel carriageways nor opportunities (and incentives or compulsion) for slow vehicles to pull in and allow other vehicles to pass safely. If the budget does not allow for immediate duelling of the A9 then at least suitably long pull-in lay-bys could be constructed, that would allow slow vehicles to use them efficiently without constantly having to stop. These are used effectively in other countries in conjunction with rules that say that slow vehicles must let queues clear. It is difficult to believe that anyone involved with transport planning could be unaware of this and seriously believe that a stretch of road well over a hundred miles long could seriously benefit from average speed cameras that have only been designed to be used with roadworks.18682013-11-24T17:20:00.0733383Paul GallagherIt appears that the proposal for average speed cameras is little but an attempt to shirk the responsibility for taking real action. Any user of the A9 will know that accidents are caused by a combination of slow vehicles, limited opportunities to overtake safely, and the impatience caused by such long stretches where their are neither duel carriageways nor opportunities (and incentives or compulsion) for slow vehicles to pull in and allow other vehicles to pass safely. If the budget does not allow for immediate duelling of the A9 then at least suitably long pull-in lay-bys could be constructed, that would allow slow vehicles to use them efficiently without constantly having to stop. These are used effectively in other countries in conjunction with rules that say that slow vehicles must let queues clear. It is difficult to believe that anyone involved with transport planning could be unaware of this and seriously believe that a stretch of road well over a hundred miles long could seriously benefit from average speed cameras that have only been designed to be used with roadworks.18682013-11-24T18:12:28.7173384Donna WebsterFrustration will just make the road more dangerous to drive on18682013-11-24T18:28:58.283385carol humphreyI am against average speed camera's they are not the answer spend the money on duelling the A918682013-11-24T19:41:15.9373386Irene McLeanJust put up speed limit signs! But they wouldn't make as much money in fines!18682013-11-24T19:55:09.533387Fiona Macdonalddriving over the speed limit is not the reason the A9 is a bad road18682013-11-24T20:02:19.8273388Ian laneAverage speed cameras will not solve any problems on the A9, and will only exacerbate the existing problems with slow moving traffic. If cameras are installed, we're all going to be stuck behind convoys of slow moving HGVs, thus increasing the risks of dangerous overtaking by a few idiots. Almost all accidents on the A9 have been caused by frustrated, and impatient, drivers trying to get past slow traffic. Slowing HGVs down to 40 mph will only make things worse. When will the bureaucrats who think up these 'bright' ideas wake up to reality?18682013-11-24T20:45:14.5633389James GordonNo average speed cameras. Need to get lorries going at 50 mph first and the dual it all. Lorries frustrate motorists at 40 and then one goes for it!18682013-11-24T20:47:22.533390Steven Munro Average Speed cameras on the A9 are not the answer, just ships how out of touch with reality politicians. No snp vote for me after this awful idea.18682013-11-24T21:04:48.6233391James Gordon Lorries at 40 frustrate and cause accidents. Average speed cameras are another frustration. Dual carriage is the way forward.18682013-11-24T22:41:46.2033392Douglas Alexanderenforce a rule that says if more than six? vehicles behind you you should pull over and let them pass. Also with modern braking system the trucks should be allowed to travel at 60mph.18682013-11-24T22:51:12.673393Ann SmernckiSpeed cameras are a complete waste of resources..save that money for duel carriageways. No excess money should be spent on investigations either. All resource should be to upgrade with immediate effect!18682013-11-24T22:54:52.7173394Darren BoaGet it duelled ASC will do nothing for the road18682013-11-24T22:56:11.173395Fiona RussellHaving traveled up and down the A9 several times lately the average speed we did was 45 mph due to the huge tailbacks of traffic. why waste money on speed cameras when it could be better allocated to the upgrading of the A9. 18682013-11-24T23:27:56.6233396Tommy Bryson. Plz sign folks. Need more signatures. 18682013-11-24T23:55:24.143397RossI accept duelling is very costly but you could also look at a central barrier on particular bad sections to stop overtaking or better policing. We can't forget Education, Enforcement and Engineering. 18682013-11-25T04:36:37.423398Kieran PringleThe 2011 census had 36.7% of people tick "no religion", making it the most common choice - ahead of the 32.4% of people that identified as Church of Scotland. Is it then fair to give CoS members privileged access to council positions? Positions that are NOT voted for by the public? If they are elected that is another matter, but they not. What about Scotland's population that hold other faiths? Is this not also unfair to them?19012013-11-25T06:18:30.913399Sheila TraceyWe need more independent retailers of all types. If we allow the unlimited spread of supermarkets and express stores into our high streets we will soon be left with no real choices.18842013-11-25T07:27:03.2773400Joel HaylockA complete separation of state and religion can be the only reasonable way forward today. This is just one good move.19012013-11-25T08:02:02.9033401Jonathan InnesAs someone who drives the A9 almost every week I would totally disagree with speed cameras. Overtaking is the main cause of accidents not speed. With lorries sitting at 40mph on the road car users become very frustrated and I believe that the only solution is dualling the road. Speed cameras will have the effect of slowing the route, thus increasing costs to business and also will not stop the frustration of Drivers sitting behind lorries at 40mph. An alternative is to put haulage on the train to Inverness and reduce the number of lorries on the road. A journey that takes me 3 hours driving all the time within the speed limit can already take me 4 and half when stuck behind lorries I hate to think what it would take me with average speed cameras.18682013-11-25T08:34:58.793402William ShanksWhat is the length of dual carriageway that could be constructed for the same cost of installing these ineffectual cameras?18682013-11-25T08:48:56.3673403Craig Bruce Average speed cameras are not the answer. A better more consistent standard of driving is the answer.18682013-11-25T08:54:05.3133404Peter HendersonThe money this would cost would be better spent on making the A9 dual carriageway.18682013-11-25T08:55:03.0373405Jason RobertsonSpeed DOES NOT kill\r\n inappropriate speed, inattention, ignorance selfishness and do gooders proving a redundant view, being fatigued through a multitude of reasons. Not speed18682013-11-25T08:57:25.7533406Tim BuglerAverage speed cameras should not be installed between Dunblane and Perth where the A 9 is already dualled. The problem here is the junctions not the speed of traffic, and traffic speed through the junctions is likely to actually increase because drivers will no longer slow for them as they strive to maintain the maximum legal average.18682013-11-25T10:04:37.1633407Moira McCarrellAs a very regular user of the A9, average speed cameras are definitely not the answer. Every near miss which I have witnessed (and there have been many over the years) have been caused by drivers taking undue risks as a direct result of impatience following sitting in long queues caused by inability to overtake large vehicles. Duelling the A9 is the only answer to this problem.\r\n18682013-11-25T10:40:53.6233408Helene BostNo!18682013-11-25T11:04:07.8333409John LigertwoodAverage speed cameras over a long distance, will create havoc and unacceptable frustration to good drivers.18682013-11-25T11:17:40.8273410Patricia Hutchison Don't think speed cameras will make any difference to this black spot area it won't stop people driving silly or over taking where they shouldnt18682013-11-25T11:18:39.4533411CJW Robsonnothing wrong with road - its peeps who cannot drive except on dual carriageways!!\r\nsight lines need cutting back to what they were originally! 18682013-11-25T11:22:19.5533412Bill RossAverage Speed cameras are not necessary - better signage and dualling of the road is better together with forcing trucks to enter lay-by's to let cars pass.18682013-11-25T12:24:36.1073413John ClarkThe A9 is one of Scotlands only two major arteries north of the central belt (the A90 being the second). Unlike the A90, it is also a major tourist route and sees a higher than average amount of foreign drivers as well as caravans. We cannot seriously look to the future of our nation without making this road safe and fit for purpose. Personally, I agree that the accident problem is typically lack of attention by the road user, but a complete dual carriageway between Perth and Inverness still makes the most sense. Meanwhile, Westminster wants to spend £Billions on upgrading an existing rail link between London & Birmingham just to shave a few minutes off the journey time.18682013-11-25T12:27:18.7633414Alan GrayThanks for highlighting this Shonah. An important part of our nation's motoring heritage which deserves to be saved for future generations of Scots and tourists to see here.19222013-11-25T12:38:02.8773415Cate Lincolnwe need to fight for justice and never give up.18872013-11-25T13:43:11.1473416William & Joyce Powney (Malta)We are frequent travelers to Scotland. We just love it. When we are there we look for our friends........and the Golden Eagles!!19062013-11-25T14:22:45.6773417Norman MacLeodWe all want something done about the A9 but this is the wrong 'something'. The figures prove it: overtaking and turning cause accidents, speeding is not an issue. Anyone who drives in an extended Average Speed Camera zone knows what a miserable experience it is. After 120+ miles of speedometer watching people will be driven to madness. Those with cruise control will be daydreaming, reading, sleeping or -more likely- toying with their smartphones in convoys at 58mph!18682013-11-25T14:36:28.7873418Mrs Jennifer Mary BuckleyThe presence of the Golden Eagle has been the main reason for coming to Scotland over a period of over forty years now, from once a year visits to now, several times a year. These iconic birds and their habitat need all the protection we can give them. The mere sight of one for even a few seconds is a thrill beyond words.19062013-11-25T14:53:18.783419Bob Thomson.HGV's MUST be allowed 50mph.\r\nApart from police stopping drivers who break the speed limit they should be stopping drivers who drive unnecessarily slow and cause tail backs which in turn causes dangerous overtaking manoeuvres.18682013-11-25T15:13:36.7573420Alexander Stuart DowInvestment saves lives18682013-11-25T15:34:51.1433422Alexander vDowInverness since awarded city status for the turn of the last milenium has been one of Europes most rapidly growing towns or cities per head of population. Nigg has reopemed Europes largest dry dock for the fabrication and mantance for North Sea development just North of Inverness. I hate Westminster Governed Scotland though the 18682013-11-25T16:11:30.7873423IMHaving used the A9 for over 30 years on a regular basis my travelling time has not changed from the old road to the modernised route due to the increase in traffic. I have, however, noticed that there is a distinct lack of speed limit signs especially coming off a section of dual carriageway which may confuse foreign tourists and cause accidents. I also use the A77 regularly to Stranraer. This road is completely different from the A9 and any comparison would be invalid. The only viable solution is for the Scottish Government to dual the A9 instead of wasting money on average speed cameras.18682013-11-25T16:25:24.883424A.S.GardenSpeed cameras are not going to address the main cause of accidents - risky overtaking. Improve the road markings to make it more obvious which sections are 2-way, and put on additional visible police patrols.18682013-11-25T16:34:30.1073425Tommy Jones What a wonderful idea totally befits the majesty of the birds in flight.19062013-11-25T16:55:00.1933426Michael Napier BartlettJust driven both directions on A9. Found absolutely no problems whatever. Accidents can only be due to bad driving. Speed cameras just a cop-out by the authorities.18682013-11-25T17:25:09.5073427karl freemani'm sure the only people who will not sign this petition,are the land owners who are placing a strangle hold on this beautiful bird.\r\nthis petition should be taken to the streets.i would bet,almost everyone will sign it.even those who are not interested in birds at all.but still know of the golden eagle.19062013-11-25T17:46:57.6933428Russell BuchananI think ther should be a debate in Edinburgh,but I still think the new bridge could have been held until the A9 was fully addressed18682013-11-25T17:51:40.463429William MaidlowI think it would be an excellent idea for Scotland to adopt this iconic bird. America has its Eagle, and I think this would create an internationally recognisable symbol and logo for Scotland.19062013-11-25T18:10:02.073430Frances Phillpottsthere is nothing more perfect on or over this earth than a golden eagle19062013-11-25T18:46:26.3373431Stacie Ann StewartWho's idea was this anyway? Some jobs worth from the central belt who only knows the a9 from a map!18682013-11-25T18:51:52.0373432Mary McFadyenUpgrading needed not cameras.18682013-11-25T18:53:39.9773433Christopher GellPoor driver attitude and lack of basic road craft (such as an inability to plan and safely execute an overtaking manoeuvre) mixed with a diverse range of road users (locals, tourists, business drivers and freight) are the key issues on the A9. Average speed cameras will have no impact on these factors and, I believe, will increase driver frustration due to 40mph HGV's - potentially causing an increase in serious accidents and fatalities. The proposal is a misuse of £2M public money and must be stopped. What is required is a highly visible police presence on the route.18682013-11-25T18:54:41.2273434Chris LeaneyDuel the A9 NOW18682013-11-25T18:57:41.213435Marie Feeney Totally agree with plans to enforce spacing between HGVs and no overtaking on dual sections and overtaking lanes 18682013-11-25T19:06:56.3333436Mark Barnes Stop wasting money on trams and other pointless ideas and duel the A9 . Cameras won't help , and could cause people to force silly overtaking manoeuvres b4 they reach the next camera . Cough up the coin and make it duel carriage way . It's the only safe option 18682013-11-25T19:06:56.9833437David M EdesLorries need to be allowed to do 50 mph on single carriageway but forbidden to overtake on dual sections Distance chevrons similar to the M6 would help,18682013-11-25T19:21:08.7833438Andrew ShandPerhaps the saftey group should spend some time driving on the road rather than studying statistics18682013-11-25T19:26:21.4273439roy clearyDual it all the way. If you can afford trams and forth bridges that arnt as bad as you first thought the A9 should be come a national priority to b3 dual carriageway from Perth to Inverness 100 %\r\nSpeed is not the issue however being able to a constant maximum speed limit is on such a long trunk route18682013-11-25T19:47:33.6773440bboyNothing more than a cash generator. 18682013-11-25T19:48:24.9433441Samuel MacLeodAverage speed cameras are a cynical attempt to cover up the real issue of lack of proper investment on a crucial artery of our road network. Spend more outside the Central Belt. Lives are being lost due to inept policies of all political parties in Scotland. No cameras, just cash and dual carriageway.18682013-11-25T19:52:57.1633442Ryan ForbesI am extremely concerned at the possibility of AVERAGE SPEED CAMERAS on the A9. This will restrict business and is a complete waste of public money. The Scottish Government should be pressing ahead with Dualling the A9 and not wasting millions of pounds on an unworkable plan that penalises us in the Highlands.\r\n18682013-11-25T20:05:51.073443Robert Agnew Speed Cameras do NOTHING to stop bad driving and reckless overtaking!!!!!18682013-11-25T20:20:04.8673444Richard WhiteThe problems are the drivers who sit at 40mph EVERYWHERE!!!! it's a straight road so do the limit if the conditions suit.18682013-11-25T20:21:25.633445Tom jacksonIncrease the road signs and road markings. It's no rocket science. 18682013-11-25T20:23:29.883446Graham macpherson Cameras are not going to solve the problems on the a9 A waste of money18682013-11-25T20:42:28.8333447steven corrySuch a sad waste of our money18682013-11-25T20:48:30.8673448Irenelocal councils should also consider the detrimental effect that parking charges have on small local businesses on the high street.18842013-11-25T20:51:36.43449Douglas RossFrustration causes accidents. Frustration comes by not beimg able to overtake easily. Non dualed A9 causes regular travellers and forgein travllers to take risks.18682013-11-25T20:54:00.4033450Steven WrightInstead of wasting millions on the Edinburgh Tram Project they should have dualled the A9 and the A96 to create a proper roads network which would support industry, improve tourism and most importantly improve road safety!!18682013-11-25T21:10:19.8333451mrs EA RobertsMyself and my husband regularly travel the a9, we live north of inverness but weekly commute to the central belt. I'm worried speed cameras will cause impatience north and south of the camera zones as drivers try to make up lost time causing accidents in these areas. I'm also worried tourists will then not travel as far north due to extended travel times.18682013-11-25T21:52:21.433452Graeme McIsaacPlease keep Scottish treasures in Scotland.19222013-11-25T22:01:26.223453Brian ChalmersIntroducing speed cameras will have little or no effect on reducing accidents, the statistics support this, it seems the decision to install the cameras without a proper independent study is ludicrous. My support would be to make the A9 dual carriageway as a minimum between Perth and Inverness18682013-11-25T22:09:02.83454Bert Shocking decision I cannot think of any plausible reason for this. Except maybe finance !18682013-11-25T22:28:34.5273455EddieIt would help if HGV's were forced to pull in when a tailback has built up behind them - say 10 vehicles.18682013-11-25T22:40:04.9073456Duncan GrahamI would suggest that the biggest root cause of accidents on the A9 is vehicles slow driving. Lorries at 52MPH are understandable but car drivers should be liable to prosecution. Slow moving vehicles on a trunk road today are a travesty. Instead of wasting time on his wee braveheart dream Mr Salmond should focus on decent infrastructure: roads from Inverness to Perth and Edinburgh to Newcastle.\r\n18682013-11-25T22:40:25.3673457Paul CarlyleIt would be great to keep it in Scotland.19222013-11-25T22:41:50.7973458Kristoffer WishartWhy spend money on this when you can spend it fixing the road and upgrading the infrastructure of the highlands18682013-11-25T22:45:10.843459john witty hope Scotland get the golden eagle as it status19062013-11-25T23:20:37.1473460Lynsey richardsonLove to see this happen19062013-11-25T23:20:40.1473461Harry MonroePeople can still stay within a speed limit, at whatever level, and perform dangerous overtaking manoeuvres18682013-11-25T23:43:32.133462Pauline Patricia DiackThe most majestic and beautiful of birds . We are so lucky to have it as one of our native species and it would be an honour to have it as our national bird.19062013-11-26T02:04:09.0673463Vanessa LingThey have signs saying that frustration causes accidents so they know it's not speed per se, but overtaking without having enough clear space to do so safely, because you've lost it after following something slow for what feels like hours.\r\n18682013-11-26T10:43:56.3333464Robert InceA truly excellent idea.19062013-11-26T11:01:15.9033466avril allanwe have lost so much of our heritage and it is so very important to keep these cars for history19222013-11-26T11:45:25.6633467chris dowlingaccidents will be reduced by more dual carriageway 18682013-11-26T12:19:10.8673468Mike RogersA very cheap 'fix', what is needed is complete dualling of the road. 18682013-11-26T12:24:52.853469Glenda GeorgeAll for this. Magnificent birds.19062013-11-26T12:50:48.2233470Victoria MacDougallWishing you all the best in getting this through18872013-11-26T12:52:34.0673471Tim Walker Average Speed Cameras are likely to lead to greater frustration and an increase in accidents.18682013-11-26T13:10:11.8673472ShepherdSpeeding is not the problem...it is caused by bad driving....taking that risky overtaking manoeuvre. 18682013-11-26T13:20:21.523473IDRIS FRANCISBELIEVE NOT BELIVE! OTHERWISE EXCELLENT\r\nAPART FROM "SHOW LESS COMMENTS" SHOULD BE "SHOW FEWER COMMENTS"18682013-11-26T13:49:50.5673474Caroline AngusThe speed camera is irrelevant on this road. Too much traffic sitting at 40 mph (ie tesco lorries) causing annoyance and hazards. Duel carriage way and solve the issue.18682013-11-26T14:01:53.053475Peter AndersonPutting in average speed camera's wont stop the accidents I have driven the A9 for over forty years seen plenty of accidents and loads of near misses. This road has dual carriageways dotted all along it's length and most of the accidents occur in between these carriageways. If you want to cut the accident rate make it all dual carriageway and difference will be seen right away. The big problem with it just now is you think your still on the dual section and your not I will hold my hand up and say I been guilty of thinking that same thing, ready to overtake and then realized that it's not what you think it is.18682013-11-26T14:25:21.9273476Eddie AndersonCan we also have the Scottish Wildcat as a national symbol. 19062013-11-26T14:45:00.9333477Alan OgilvieIn my experience if traffic is moving at 60 or 70 mph over long stretches of road there are less incidences of overtaking. However, when traffic bunches up behind a slow moving truck or car towing a caravan that's when the problems start and other drivers become frustrated. 18682013-11-26T15:28:50.4573478Adrian HicksA majestic symbol, why not do it19062013-11-26T15:39:51.8033479Robin ScottAwesome idea 19062013-11-26T15:40:52.5233480Bill GillespieDrivers (private and commercial) driving too close together is a major issue, and not speed per se. This can often result in drivers "taking on" potentially hazerdous overtaking of multiple vehicles, but I have yet to hear of anyone being cautioned for creating the danger viz: driving too closely together.18682013-11-26T15:42:56.713481Paul SoppLong overdue, superb bird representing a wonderful country19062013-11-26T16:27:44.7733482Malcolm HeymerAgree speed cameras not the answer. Raising HGV speed limit might help to reduce need to overtake.18682013-11-26T17:46:55.7673483Terry HudsonIf there was no speed limits, there would be no 'speeding.'\r\nBut you would still have dangerous drivers!\r\nWhy punish everybody with longer journey times for the mistakes of a very few?18682013-11-26T18:07:45.963484Jason HoffmanSpeed camera's are not the solution to the A9's problems. Bad driving is bad driving, and will continue until the road is dualled.\r\n18682013-11-26T18:11:40.4933485John BrownLove this bird and love Scotland,19062013-11-26T18:28:38.5133486Colin BrownThe eagles will land in an independent Scotland.19062013-11-26T19:08:34.0833487William RichmondMagnificent!!19062013-11-26T20:08:04.6473488Drew HarleyA truly iconic Scottish wildlife symbol recognized the world over19062013-11-26T20:40:27.0233489Carole MortimerEagles need the protection that would come with being the national bird.19062013-11-26T20:59:08.3873490Louise WebbA truely magnificent bird. It would be wonderful if this was our National Bird.19062013-11-26T21:20:10.5333491AndrewSpeed or Average cameras are not the answer because if people are continually concentrating on there speed a lot they will be more likely not to pay attention to the road ahead, this is a key point in speed camera effectiveness in that it diverts vital concentration from the road ahead to a fixation with the speedometer. \r\n\r\nOn the A9 this is a very dangerous move on a single land road where people are overtaking a lot and there are heavy goods vehicles going slower.\r\n\r\nIf average cameras are installed then people will be less likely to overtake in fear of going over the limit, causing more tailbacks, more frustration, and ultimately more accidents.18682013-11-26T23:56:02.243492DaveI recently attended a talk by Transport Scotland where it was stated that they could prove a "business case" for dualling the A9 by reducing journey times, accidents and driver frustration. Pretty obvious really, so I think what they are trying to do in the interim by introducing cameras is to increase journey times, accidents and driver frustration so that their "business case" can be more easily proved! Why do we need a "business case" anyway - its a rubbish road, its outlived its design life - get it dualled!18682013-11-27T09:09:02.7973493PETER WILLIAM BALLGOOD LUCK !!19222013-11-27T10:45:12.853494Andrew mcdonaldDo not out camera's on the A9 it will a bad road worse18682013-11-27T11:13:53.6173495Max MackenzieSo many amazing birds in Scotland to choose from, but this seems appropriate. Wild majesty...19062013-11-27T13:07:07.7033496Ian P.Wonderful creature, let's give it the status that it deserves. 19062013-11-27T15:26:42.643497Mike GrantIt's a highly impressive bird, everyone wants to see one, and therefore the natural choice for National Bird of Scotland.19062013-11-27T15:39:42.4033498David HannahThe majority of accidents caused on the A9 are as a result of the lack of investment in Scotland's road network. Instead of looking to upgrade an obsolete road the government should be looking to provide a new motorway direct from Stirling to Thurso. This would link into the existing motorway network to England and Europe.\r\nThe A9 should be improved to dual carriageway from Perth to Wick thereby providing an alternative for those wishing to travel more slowly and enjoy the route leaving those of us with more urgent business need to get on.\r\n18682013-11-27T15:55:37.1233499Robert DawsonGolden Eagle is a superb eagle. Beautiful proportions. Majestic. So many fabulous memories from Scotland.19062013-11-27T16:09:24.313500Jonathan TylerHopefully this will send a strong message to those out there that still persecute this magnificent raptor, but I doubt it.19062013-11-27T16:24:19.0573501Sue DowellPeople deserve the right to know the truth and if circumstances are suspicious irrespective of whether or not the police or law authority can solve same. In this situation so many loose ends and not enough clarity and indeed discrepancies surround all. Please honour the parent and understand their needs as in human needs and not those on the paper front. 18872013-11-27T16:36:48.143502derek brayPlease all sign up for this NOW lets try and keep them here19222013-11-27T17:22:013503Richard PeglerThis would be a fantastic step in the right direction - but we mustn't forget the White-tailed Sea Eagles that also need protection and heightened awareness of their plight.19062013-11-27T17:23:29.8733504F CSuch a wonderful bird deserves this status19062013-11-27T17:54:31.653505E FrewIncrease the speed of ALL the heavy goods vehicles for a start, they are the main cause of frustration, anger and accidents. An exception for them on the A9 only would solve most if not all the problems on this road - AVSC's will only exaggerate the problem and cause further problems with having to continuously check the speed dial.18682013-11-27T17:57:34.063506Paul Jacksonit Must stay in Scotland Good Luck!19222013-11-27T18:54:21.9033507colin mcintoshCars do 60 and can overtake a lorry doing 40 a lot easier than one doing 50 (56). So whats the problem18682013-11-27T19:09:42.3033508Christopher ShirleyCome on everyone this collection of Scottish history needs saving. What a great piece of history that should remain in the UK19222013-11-27T21:39:46.1333509Bob the GreyhoundAnother made-cap scheme by those completely detached from the real world.18682013-11-28T00:34:56.7673510David HowieA better use of oil money than independence.19222013-11-28T05:42:58.9873511Sheila M BuryMost definitely should be.\r\n19062013-11-28T08:24:08.9933512Caroline GrayJustice for Colin!!! Good luck I hope it goes thru x18872013-11-28T08:45:18.0633513Anne MoghrabyBeautiful majestic birds we must protect them 19062013-11-28T12:34:11.163514Roger CrawfordSPECS System cameras on the A9 will not solve the accident rate problem it is just another classic knee jerk reaction,.the cameras will be a total nightmare especially during May 'thro September.\r\n18682013-11-28T12:45:523515chris flemingtypical politics,unless money is involved they just do not care.do they wait till there are no golden eagles and then bring them back like the white tailed sea eagles.its all about grouse moors. get the finger out salmond. do somthing decent. 19062013-11-28T14:00:33.6373516Gregor GrahamThe Collection is part of Scottish Motorsport history and should stay here.19222013-11-28T14:02:08.23517Nigel CrawfordYet again, those in positions of responsibility have no concept of how to deal with a problem. Through a short cut and lack of detailed investigation into the true cause of accidents on the A9 they come up with a hair brained scheme rather than looking at the logic and hard fact that impatience and the inevitable rushed overtaking on the A9 is the big problem. It appears the do-gooders have invaded another area of our precious world!!18682013-11-28T14:47:35.153518Eric DymockSave Jimmy Stewart's C-type first.19222013-11-28T18:54:19.043519Brian Sharp IAMAverage speed cameras will only lead to more frustration and more accidents. The money should be spent on bringing dual ling forward.18682013-11-28T21:10:21.0933520gordon brockie,this collection is part of scotlands motoring history when the minows took on the big boys and beat them at there own game, some of the cars have been sold in the past and gone from us, surely this collection should stay here to inspire future motor sport enterprise. 19222013-11-28T23:17:51.9633521james crossani love birdwatching nesting time lifts the spirits.19062013-11-29T08:54:34.3673522Jimmy McInnesAs Chairman of the Veterans of Scottish M vehiclesotor Sport Association I feel that loss of these to Scotland woulod be a sad loss of part of our history19222013-11-29T09:10:30.793523Jimmy McInnesAs Chairman of the Veterans of Scottish Motor Sport Association I'm sure I speak for all our 250 members that these vehicles shoukld remain in Scotland19222013-11-29T12:32:06.483524M WRIGHTIconic bird of Scotland,would be a sad day for Scottish tourism if they were to be allowed to become extinct19062013-11-29T14:26:41.3073525Mike MayfieldThe range of cars, together with the team transporter, represent an irreplaceable able piece of Motorsport history, and must be retained in the UK as part of Scottish heritage.19222013-11-29T16:53:55.8533526susanGood Luck xx18872013-11-29T16:54:13.983527nicolaall the best 18872013-11-29T16:55:53.7133528susanhope you get more votes x18872013-11-29T16:57:11.1833529nicolgood luck 18872013-11-29T19:06:58.9373530dolina douglasMy father in the 50's worked part time for ecurie ecosse as a mechanic19222013-11-29T20:19:46.0473531Joyce C FarquharPlease save at least SOME (if not ALL) of this fabulous collection.19222013-11-29T20:22:27.7633532Sandy Black The Ecurie Ecosse team cars are such an important part of our motor sport heritage , to have at least some of them to remain in Scotland is vital .indeed of national importance .19222013-11-29T21:19:04.4373533Paul LawrencePlease save this iconic collection. 19222013-11-29T22:08:20.1273534Keith g BrownI hope we can save some of this priceless national history for the country, especially given the weekend it is19222013-11-29T22:26:18.0933535cynthia bruce-gordonBy the time they get round to completeing the dualling the A9 it will be obsolete--just like most other DC's in Scotland.\r\nSpeed cameras will do absolutely nothing to prevent accidents on this road.\r\nAs it stands, much of the frustration is caused by ignorant drivers or bloody minded drivers.\r\nThis is seen daily when slow drivers hold up laden vehicles (hgv's and caravans etc) on the approach to the hilly sections of the road. They don't seem to realise that such vehicles require to get a run at the hills in order to maintain reasonable progress and minimise tailbacks.18682013-11-30T00:45:47.9873536NicholaThere are other safety measures that can be put in place: if it was compulsory to have your headlights on driving on A roads, everybody would appear more visible. If there were more visible police then it may deter tailgaters and lane hoggers, and pick up on others incompetent driving, giving advice, warnings and no doubt fines, however possibly overall improving some people's skills and attitudes to driving, therefore reducing the risks and frustrations to the rest of us. Maybe the "wear your seatbelt" sign should be replaced with "when did you last read the Highway Code", cause lets face it we all know a seatbelt can be a lifesaver but some people don't even know that a solid white line in the middle of the road means no overtaking. 18682013-11-30T22:10:58.3133537Katrina CastlesLocation is Stonehaven, Scotland - not Macao!!!19222013-12-01T15:44:03.373538Joyce MackenzieMore clarity please ! I may live in Belgium at the moment, but I am Scottish ! And what happens in Scotland is very important to me !18872013-12-02T00:11:22.083539elizabeth harland-hazebroekMay justice been done. R.I.P.18872013-12-02T07:46:46.5933540Kate BuchananThinking of David O'Halloran and all others like him, with respect and love for their families18872013-12-02T07:52:57.263541Kate BuchananThinking of David O'Halloran and all others like him, with respect and love for their families18872013-12-02T11:24:33.883542Gemma CoyleThe truth must come out. If I was in this situation I would be exactly the same. 18872013-12-02T12:56:56.643543Graham BuchanEagles dare19062013-12-02T13:56:11.3073544Terri CunninghamWhat a wonderful bird but how easy it would be to lose it with such low numbers and persecution still happening. Let's protect this bird and the habitats it needs to survive.19062013-12-02T16:59:02.6573545Aubrey MooreFrustration is the main cause of accidents on the A9. Whilst average sped cameras on the A77 may have reduced accidents tree one cannot compare the 2 roads. If I,in my car, am stuck behind a lorry travelling at 40 mph for 2 miles, can I then drive at 80 mph for another 2 miles?\r\nMore frequent stretches of dual carriageway or overtaking lanes are required. The few temporary mobile signs indicating dual carriageway ahead certainly calm drivers nerves.18682013-12-02T22:08:19.5733546Rosa ElswoodTescopoly puts local businesses in danger and takes away from the personality of community high streets. I've been boycotting Tesco for about two years and feel my diet has improved and I feel closer to my local community. 18842013-12-03T02:23:56.5073548Michael Nicolle Good luck God bless18872013-12-03T09:27:31.0873549JIM MCGIBBNEYFOR OUR CHILDRENS CHILDREN CHILDREN TO ENJOY19062013-12-03T16:02:18.063550Johan LarssonIts so unreal. We studiy In the same school. She was a talent person and very very kind!18872013-12-03T23:46:46.1333551J. N. LehmannNow, please do your job!18872013-12-04T11:51:06.2273552Patrick Mc GroryJustice for all.good luck and god bless18872013-12-04T12:07:34.9133553John JohnstonAs a parent I can only imagine their torment.18872013-12-04T13:12:40.5633554Patrick HaneyEvery family deserves to know WHY!\r\nJust do your jobs and give these victims justice.18872013-12-04T15:49:31.93555william woodparliament needs to pay attention to good governance-spend less time making out expense claims and do the job they are elected to do.18872013-12-04T16:03:58.6873556fraser greenI lived in Prestwick at the time and remember this \r\nstrange case well. I hope the family find closure and peace. 18872013-12-04T16:47:40.933557sylvie calvetEveryone's unnatural death must be explained ! 18872013-12-04T17:13:56.7573558James McQuadejustice for all18872013-12-04T18:34:26.6433559John ConnellyLet's do things properly....families have the right to expect an investigation and objective assessment of the cicumstances.18872013-12-04T21:43:05.893560Benjamin AshworthEven where speed is a factor in accidents, it is never the sole cause. Average speed cameras do not look at drivers who are uninsured, do not have licences, are driving vehicles in an unroadworthy condition, are tailgating, are carrying out dangerous overtaking maneuvers, are using handheld mobile phones and are generally driving dangerously and carelessly while not actually averaging more than the speed limit. Speed has not been the main factor in any of the accidents that have occurred on the A9 and it's unlikely any of them would have been prevented by cameras.\r\n As for the overtaking issue in itself, much of the section the cameras will cover is dual carriageway where overtaking isn't an issue. On the single carriageway roads people will be reluctant to overtake even the slowest vehicles because of the fear they have of the cameras watching them. Others will accelerate past the long lines of slow moving vehicles before slowing down to lower their average speed. The result will be greater speed differentials and even more erratic and dangerous overtaking and than there is now which will result in more impatience and thoughtless acts of carelessness and more collisions.\r\nOne of the initial primary arguments for the average speed cameras was to force HGV drivers to stick to their 40mph limit on the single carriageway sections. HGV drivers have proposed a protest where they actually will stick to 40mph just to show what the road will be like when they are all constantly forced to abide by the limit rather than being flexible and exceeding it to help traffic flow. This has led to a policy rethink where trials of a 50mph limit for HGVs will be carried out, going back on the idea that HGVs exceeding 40mph is incredibly dangerous. How can there be an unswerving attitude that all speeding is dangerous when the policy makers are admitting they have to allow some drivers to exceed their current limit just to keep the road operating in a practical and safe way?\r\n18682013-12-04T22:40:15.553561Grace FranklinMultinationals such as Tesco sook up the economic life blood of any community they are in, destroying the fabric of local society in the process. When the small traders go to the wall, the fine fibres of community interaction are severed. A dependency on the multinational is also created. And with the technology they use to monitor customers, mass manipulation of people is the next step.18842013-12-04T23:03:29.2833562James WemyssOvertaking will be more dangerous if SPECS cameras are introduced. More serious accidents will occur on the dual and 2 + 1 sections of the A9 so the fatality rate will NOT drop but probably go UP!18682013-12-04T23:27:04.333563Rebecca BrownI hope something good can come from all the pain you've had to go through. 18872013-12-04T23:34:06.7673564Steven McCrackenThis has been a tough long fight for the family and instead of getting the truth they have found just what a web of lies are woven in trying to prevent them getting the truth. This petition is fighting for the basic right to just have the truth.18872013-12-05T10:12:37.6273565David BelcherTesco are corporate thugs. Keep them out!18842013-12-05T16:16:53.6073566Douglas DanielAbsolutely agree with this, the power of supermarkets must be reined in. This is just the tip of the iceberg of what really needs to be done.18842013-12-05T17:09:22.2333567Elaine PearsonThe first time I saw a golden eagle was in Scotland as a child, unfortunately I have to live in Southampton for work but get to the Highlands as often as possible. 19062013-12-05T17:28:28.5873568Alastair RossAnnie Borjesson's case worries me. I hope this petition will stir the authorities into further action to bring a resolution and some peace to her family. 18872013-12-05T20:11:07.493569James MooreTime for the authorities to re-investigate to conclusion to enable these poor people to have closure.18872013-12-05T20:14:24.9073570Malcolm StevensonWhen Tesco and the other big chains move into and area, they are able to use their economic muscle to out gun the small independent traders. These presence of small traders is what gives an area it's character and invigorates the community. Once these traders are gone, all we will have left is the supermarkets. What kind of Orwellian prospect is that?18842013-12-06T01:04:24.13571Donald ScottIf you really want to reign in a corporation, then just don't buy their products and spend your money in smaller local businesses that really need your support.18842013-12-06T09:49:09.023573Duncan NisbetWhere Eagles Dare19062013-12-06T11:30:05.0073574Jennifer SpenserMy husband and I saw a golden eagle on a trip to Scotland three years ago. It was magnificient! This species must never be lost and to make them Scotland's national birds will hopefully give them the protection that they need and even help to swell the numbers.19062013-12-06T11:34:16.9133575Rose FraserTesco is not only taking the place of local traders, they are becoming a large, ominous, pervading force with their brightly lit shop fronts open all night.18842013-12-06T15:06:44.2473576Marnie SilverHorrible. I can't think of anything good. Support local trade. \r\n18842013-12-06T15:35:14.223577Frances ButtonWe have been coming to Scotland for nine years now, and lucky enough to see this beautiful bird. It is a truly iconic species.\r\n\r\n19062013-12-06T15:42:30.9933578CatherineMagnificent beautiful creature and a true icon of Scotland.19062013-12-06T20:17:26.1633579DarioNOW 19062013-12-06T20:20:42.723580S.McRitchieThe co-op determined to open a store in our village despite the community saying no - they are so arrogant and don't listen. It would kill our wee local shops which sustain a number of families and more18842013-12-06T21:30:19.9873581Arthur Mc FarlaneThis country owes it to the family of anyone from another country who dies here to establish as far as humanly possible the cause of that person's death. This should be understood by our authorities without the need for public petitions.18872013-12-06T23:52:02.613582eugene butterworthAn amazing animal that Scotland should be proud of19062013-12-07T01:21:09.973583David WilsonJustice is the bases of democracy - undermine justice you undermine democracy. MSPs should, as a matter of duty, integrity probity and justice defend both.18872013-12-07T11:30:08.143584DaveThe introduction of a 50mph limit for HGV's is unlikely to make much difference as it will merely legalise the status quo. HGV's operasted by large supermarket chains are still going to be limited to 40mph by their companies.18682013-12-08T14:37:08.3873585Derek WallaceKenny MacCaskill needs to get his house in order and support the people who elected him. Shame on those who have manipulated the system and facts to cover their own ineptitude. Shame.18872013-12-08T20:50:59.2833586John MalcolmsonPlease support this petition to give litigants the rights they deserve.17792013-12-09T01:53:02.0533587michelle woodCommon sense and justice please. 18872013-12-09T15:25:40.8073588Daniel MurrayLet us give treat people with the same respect we would expect if we were pursuing the same truth.I support fully this resolution and I do not like way this family have been treated by Scotlands Government,its investigative system and its legal system.18872013-12-09T20:57:24.033589Craig BruceDon't go up the A9 often but in 24 years of driving still my 2 closest experiences to death if i hadn't braked to a halt to avoid a crazy overtaking move coming the other way.18682013-12-09T20:59:27.043590Norman LauritsenIt is impossible to understand what this will. Achieve, except to waste money which could be better spent on genuine safety improvements. The presence of so many HGVs on the road makes it impossible for the motorist to exceed the AVERAGE speed limit on this road. The real danger is from overtaking on the single carriageway sections. Forcing people to concentrate more on their speedometers rather than watching the road ahead will do nothing to improve safety.18682013-12-10T00:59:33.1673591Mark aldredGet a grip and sort it out. Uncover these lies and show that courts have a clue what there doing and know a case thats put in front of them.18872013-12-10T10:36:04.8673592Stephen HoustonFor the goverment we want the Truth and nothing but the Truth,no cover up's to hide the guilty at least give the grieving families that it's the least they deserve18872013-12-10T19:18:00.243593Tina WelchWhy should victims especially the family have to do this for any answers or form of justice?????18872013-12-10T19:46:56.753594Lydia ReidI do not believe this is even an oversight on the part of this government but I do believe there has been so much to do since they came into office that we must expect some things will take time\r\nI believe the petitioner is correct\r\nI believe we should have transparency in all things and that way lies justice.18872013-12-11T13:35:37.043595Derek HughesCorrect this injustice, Have we lost our heart as a nation now.18872013-12-11T14:03:01.2373596David McArthurFamilies need to know the truth. If there is a transparent investigation that shows it is a genuine suicide, then people will live with the knowledge. When it is not clear and there is no transparency, how is a family going to get closure. We need a system that uncovers the truth in all cases. A transparent system would have uncovered the mistakes before it is too late. Shame on a 'Justice Minister' who does not seem to want to meet people to talk about it.18872013-12-12T00:51:43.1873598Guje BorgessonThank you Stuart for this petition, which so distinctly points out the need of improved legislation for cases like ours where our loved ones have died in suspicious circumstances. We really hope your petition will result in the Scottish government making a thorough overlook at the current legislation and procedures by investigative authorities. This is necessary for it to better fit the need that the deceased and families have and must be entitled to in a democracy like Scotland.\r\n \r\nOver 1000 people from more than 30 countries are supporting this petition, and have been signing it in just a few weeks time. This shows a world wide concern about Scotland and its citizens. But Scotland is also a part of a larger unit. In these days when we travel from country to country, as tourists, on work assignments or as students, we need to know that when the worst thing possible happens to our loved ones, we can be sure their deaths are treated with professionalism and transparency even if this happens abroad.\r\n \r\nScotland has a long and proud history of leading the world in the field of justice and fairness. And the Scottish Parliament is rightly lauded for it’s unique public petitions process, whereby a citizen can change the law. We all stand together hoping for this.\r\n \r\nGuje and Maria.\r\n\r\n18872013-12-13T22:04:18.8833599DaveUnfortunately the average speed cameras don't work over the whole length of the road - only between adjacent pairs so your average between Perth and Inverness might only be 45mph but on the one stretch where you've manged to overtake a few slow moving cars at 65mph average between 2 cameras - you've committed an offence!!!18682013-12-16T15:28:08.4673600Murdo grahamAs a regular user of the A9 I fed up being stuck behind slow moving lorries no curtice very few pull to allow overtaking as far as roads we are the poorest country world I have driven it a lot of different places even in3 country they have better roads than us .18682013-12-16T17:07:35.2933601John MacDonaldMore visible police traffic patrols would prevent a lot of these accidents. In most cases accidents are caused by instances of drivers becoming imatient and trying to overtake when the circumstances are wrong.18682013-12-16T18:16:57.1573602Graham ThompsonFrustration causes accidents, not speed! Bring the A9 upgrade forward instead of wasting money on cameras! 18682013-12-16T21:57:12.1873603Scott MckenzieAverage speed cameras are not the answer as car drivers do noy know how they work so wont overtake fast enough as they will think they will get done for speeding therefore travelling along on the wrong side for a longer time making accidents more limely to happen18682013-12-16T22:03:41.7173604Roy Clearywaste of money better to spend it dualing the road all the way. So much for independence and infrastruture18682013-12-17T08:49:10.7433605Darren faulknerIts revenue that the government are more intrested in. 18682013-12-17T10:26:00.843606CarolAs a regular traveller on this road I have regularly witnessed extremely dangerous overtaking manoeuvres and near misses, people driving at faster speeds stop tailbacks when faced with slow vehicles.18682013-12-17T17:17:07.0433607Robert GreenYes, a change in the law must be considered in the interests of justice and of fundamental human rights. Scotland has had a terrible reputation for too long over human rights abuses by the state.17792013-12-17T18:04:47.83608Alex AyersWhen towing a caravan on this road at the prescribed speed limits 50 and 60 mph, solo cars overtaking pose real danger to my family and on coming vehicles. Speed limits and their enforcement is a mess in the UK18682013-12-18T06:56:21.5373609Calum MackinnonThe money for cameras n all the hype that goes with it would be better spent on dialling the A9 now, notin years to come. They can find money for disasters all over the world, why not spend it on the disaster that is the A9. As is is a disaster for the families of everybody killed on it every year, no matter the cause......if Alex Salmond lived in Inverness it would be done, same as it has been done from Edinburgh to Ellon a few miles from his home........rant over18682013-12-18T10:44:04.3673610Fiona MacQueenLook to prevent hgv's travelling together - happens frequently - makes it a massive and dangerous overtake!!18682014-01-10T15:24:55.7773611Derek YoungAs someone with longstanding connections to Prestwick Airport, where my father worked for over two decades, I cannot support the aims of this petition. The idea of naming airports after historic figures lies somewhere between questionable and ridiculous, and this instance is no different. Doncaster and Sheffield airport's decision to use Robin Hood airport as their name causes both controversy and confusion, given Robin Hood's long association with Nottinghamshire (where there is another airport, East Midlands). The marketing value of such a rebranding is highly questionable, and the costs of changing signs (including road signs, at public expense) are real and avoidable. It aids public understanding for transport hubs to be named after places rather than people: it would be of little use for anyone who sees the name Robert Burns airport online but knows little about Scotland or Burns and would then have to look up where it was located. Indeed, they might choose not to bother. The airport was already renamed from Prestwick to Glasgow Prestwick, presumably because of Glasgow's greater name recognition, despite its considerable distance from Glasgow city centre. I hope the Committee refuses this wrong-headed petition.19082014-01-10T16:25:06.5633612Alison McClymontPlease sign,help save Babies from unnecessary death and suffering18282014-01-10T19:16:47.6973613Misty Gallagher I think people should be told a lot more about this as it's not been fully explained to pregnant mothers 18282014-01-10T19:37:26.123614Margaret youngThis is for my beautiful grandaughter Lola young who sadly went to sleep having this18282014-01-10T19:42:00.0033615charlenedefo not enough information given ivenot long had my baby and dont know anything about Strep B x18282014-01-10T20:54:41.2273616Deborah TolandIts an outrage that something so damaging to your baby health is not seen to be important enough to be tested for. 18282014-01-10T21:04:54.623617Lisa Irvine-WatsonI was one of the lucky ones who was detected positive in all three of my pregnancies due to other symptoms. 18282014-01-10T21:08:00.373618michaela gregsonThey shud test every pregnant woman . I got tested a week be4 and had it.i never herd of this step b. But If I didn't get tested there cud of bin serious consequences for my baby18282014-01-10T21:19:16.723619April LaneReally hope this petition gets all the signatures needed 18282014-01-10T21:22:40.9773620Bonnie EdwardsThis needs to be given to all potential new mums to be, it's awful would not wish anyone to have to go through what we did :-( thankfully our little girl was treated and is ok xx18282014-01-10T21:36:07.223621DonAgree with this.18282014-01-10T21:36:27.3473622Scott McClymontAbout time!!!!!18282014-01-10T21:40:59.683623Shelley WoodcockHaving gone through the trauma of my daughter having Group B at 12 days old, it's a so ridiculous that she could have been spared this illness if I had been offered this simple and cheap test. 18282014-01-10T21:54:17.4773624marie clare earlmy daughter had group b strep she only survived because of the special care she received almost immediately after birth, I had NEVEFR heard of group b strep, she was my second baby. gbss and not the hospital gave me information about group b strep. Group b strep should be standard testing, in the long run it would save money, my daughter spent 12 days in SCBU. She is now Thankfully a healthy, feisty 17 year old! \r\n18282014-01-10T22:26:59.6033625Susanne bicket trundleThis should be a routine test !!!18282014-01-10T22:51:35.8773626Paula McfarlaneI'm a carrier of strep b and I only found out after losing my first baby! It should be routine to test!18282014-01-10T22:58:07.053627Nichola wellsI got a positive result for gbs with my youngest who is now 3 ! If I did not receive antibiotics he may of died or been left with disabilities which would of been traumatic for him and us as a family . Helping pregnant women with the need of testing and antibiotics will not just help them but the nhs also . With the amount of medication and care that goes into looking after disabled children is astronomical. By reducing the risks of gbs we are also reducing the number of fatalities and disabilities . Good reason to push this as a new testing . 18282014-01-10T23:02:20.7833628Paula QuinnEven after receivingp the antibiotics my son was I'll with double pneumonia when born,as I was a carrier of strep B. I wouldn't like to think what could have happened if I was unaware that I was a carrier.( found to carry strep B in previous pregnancy)18282014-01-10T23:09:25.6333629richard irvinehelp18282014-01-10T23:20:18.9473630Grant McFadyenAgreed. 18282014-01-10T23:43:01.5733631Emily ParsonsWe lost our beautiful baby boy 'Dimitris' to Group B Strep on 07-01-2012 age 4 days and18 hours.We were not aware of the facts and had never heard of GBS. In a following pregnancy I was tested and found to be positive. I was given antibiotics in labour and our baby girl was given them for three days following delivery. She is now one and very healthy. Please help prevent other families from suffering the heart ache our family has to live with. Four siblings had also cuddled and loved Dimitris at home before he was suddenly taken away from us.18282014-01-11T00:08:18.873632Mia De Marco After learning that one of my friend lost her beautiful baby girl.. And how bad it was for her, I can't understand why this is even a question!! Test everyone.. We're losing precious souls that would have an amazing impact on this earth!! This test needs to be a must... 18282014-01-11T01:19:29.083633SteveGood cause18282014-01-11T08:08:47.3073634Joy Skjei Everone Should be tested!!!!!18282014-01-11T09:40:44.5273635Jackie ThomasPlease raise awareness of this serious health issue. Far too many babies have died due to ignorance.18282014-01-11T09:50:27.2433636nicola gibsonthere should be more awareness of this.my nefew was admitted to hospital 3wks ago with it thankfully hes ok but still cant walk on his own and hes 2 and able to walk afore.x18282014-01-11T10:15:44.293637lynn doyleThis test should routinely be given to expectant mums \r\n18282014-01-11T11:47:31.443638margaret cleggHope this helps18282014-01-11T12:16:13.3773639Wee Ernie Happy new year Jackie Stevie Nicole I will always sign your petition xxxx 18282014-01-11T13:21:12.973640Nancy Kaythis needs to become part of anti-natal care, as common as having a scan, checking blood pressure etc etc. 18282014-01-11T13:51:48.5873641Rachael BellEverybody should read up on group b strep,I had it in 3 of my pregnancys.a18282014-01-11T15:33:31.943642yvonne gardinerI was tested after miscarriage and confirmed for streptococcus group b. The midwife said she doubted this was my reason for loss. But I was told that I would need an iv of antibiotics all through my next possible labour. I had never heard of this before. 18282014-01-11T17:50:34.2673643Diane WilliamsEvery expectant mother should be screened for StrepB so their child can live,babies dying needlessly18282014-01-11T19:49:25.4873644LisaSigned x18282014-01-12T01:11:05.7533645Andrena BallantynePlease note - "Robert" not "Rabbie"19082014-01-12T10:37:08.4573646Lorraine MccrindlePlease test for this its such a simple and cost effective thing to do! 18282014-01-12T16:07:56.4873647Lillian ColquhounThanks18282014-01-12T17:36:07.3233648Lauren macintyreLet's raise awareness of Strep B so people know about Strep B and it's symptoms and how harmful it is to newborn babies. 18282014-01-12T20:02:56.4573649lynn rattrayI had this with my 5th pregnancy and was discovered due to having urine infection hate to.think what outcome wld of been had midwifes not found out I was carryin it definitely shld be a compulsory test \r\n18282014-01-13T08:20:48.913650Margaret Cook This is something that should have more dine about it18282014-01-13T09:23:30.7773651johnny wallaceevery woman should have the right to this test.18282014-01-13T09:36:49.663652Annmarieyes i think that you should be told about Strep B.Special when it can result in your baby being severe disabilities or death..18282014-01-13T10:50:31.7133653kayleighI think every parent should be informed of group b strep. The first time I heard of it was 6 hours after my son was born and didnt have a clue whag to expect was just given a leaflet to read. 18282014-01-13T10:55:48.873654SiobanIt should just be done without question 18282014-01-13T11:30:08.433655Marie WingfieldI have learned almost at the cost of my son's life how dangerous this can be. My son had to be flown to Glasgow for treatment in NICU at Southern General hospital. He was on full life support for 3 days followed by CPAP for a further week, still with a need for oxygen in his incubator after that. I wasn't even told what it was that caused so many problems until a debrief that I requested some months after the birth. As a nation we are always conjuring up new ways with regard to medical care and treatment yet the attitude towards Group B Strep is very backward and lacking. How many more babies are the NHS and government prepared to put at risk?!18282014-01-13T12:37:09.3073656Richard This should happen as I nearly lost my wee boy. And all the stress that we had with him in nicu not just that the travel we had to do as he was taken to Glasgow. We are in the north of Scotland. Could all have been avoided if the done this test to let us and the midwife know what they are dealing with. It is not fair that what should b a joyfull time for parents it been taken away just because u want let them get this test done. 18282014-01-13T13:16:23.793657john mc dadeit should be there for every new mother and new baby no maybe's everyone.\r\n18282014-01-13T15:19:51.8373659Maureen MooreAs a retired midwife this should be information available to all mothers to be babies die from this FACT as midwife's we had policies for everything I hope that all midwife's get the training required to inform mother's and father's to be about this people need this information.\r\n18282014-01-13T15:46:13.7433660Andi McCannLet's honour the national bard by renaming Prestwick Airport after him 19082014-01-13T15:51:40.543661Nita AmbaI only heard about GBS back in July 2001 after losing my 1st born 'Our Precious Son' to this fatal infection. I wouldn't want anyone to go through such a devastating experience, losing a child is one of the most hardest things to go through....18282014-01-13T17:17:01.793662Kirsty MartinI was diagnosed with group b strep 6 weeks ago with my son 3rd pregnancy we had a routine swap after questioning whether waters had broken at 38 weeks were then told i have group b strep scary to think a infection that lies in your body can be so harmful to your baby i went into rapid labour so docs could only get one bag of antibiotics into me before i delivered my son we spent 24 hours under observation before being allowed home all being well 6 weeks later happy and healthy but unfortunately this is not always the case we found out by chance all pregnant woman should be swabbed to check for this.18282014-01-13T17:52:05.3373663Linda PatersonGlad 'pure dead brilliant ' is history. Robert Burns international airport is much more suitable and certainly more dignified!19082014-01-13T21:39:14.3473664Sharon HI lost my baby daughter aged 2 hours in 2001 to an overwhelming Group B Strep infection....it's preventable....no-one should experience losing a precious baby like I did...18282014-01-13T22:15:26.013665Sarah QuinnA friend lost her baby to Strep B 12 years ago...I still can't believe it is not routinely tested for in pregnancy. How many completely unavoidable deaths there must have been. 18282014-01-14T00:27:17.2073666Jean Macmillan-ForsterPrestwick Airport should be renamed after our National Bard. A well deserved tribute.19082014-01-14T06:28:15.7833667Jean HillhouseIf there is anything I can do to help, it would be a pleasure.19082014-01-14T08:43:53.6733668Jo ScottMy son had late onset Group B Strep at nearly 7 weeks. Thankfully he made a full recovery. My partner and I had never heard of it and had not come across it in any of the literature we had been given. I can't believe that this information and the option of testing is not more readily available. Good luck with the petition. 18282014-01-14T09:20:46.8233669Reg TaitScotland should advertise the diversity of the country as well as paying tribute to a famous son that will attract people from all over the world. The present system of branding Prestwick as being contained in Glasgow is disasterous for bor Prestwick, Ayrshire and Scotland as a whole and just gives an image of sameness within Scotland. Please rename to Robert Burns International Airport at least for an extended trial period.19082014-01-14T15:22:22.723670Rachel simondsWe are no just an extension of glasgow and have a great deal to offer in Burns Country. It is madness not to make the most of our poet who is famous world wide. 19082014-01-15T08:17:37.293671Sandra HannawayShocking that this is not already in place.18282014-01-15T09:36:07.1433674phyllis thrieplandThis must be mandatory too many babies and familys suffering xpx\r\n18282014-01-15T09:45:45.4173675Natalie This should be nationwide not just Scotland my poor son had 2 experience this on the 1st week of his life it's so scary and no parent shud have 2 go through wot I went through with my son 18282014-01-15T16:06:27.283677ALEXANDER COWANlets educate and prevent to save lives.18282014-01-15T17:13:55.7433678Jamie SimpsonI believe that we should display our national pride even without a referendum, and dedicating one of our most popular airports to our most famous poet would be a great way to display our pride to the rest of the international community19082014-01-15T17:18:18.433679Lucy BowenLuckily I had read about this as I was never offered a test but asked and consequently received iv anti b's during labour. Everyone should be informed!18282014-01-15T18:06:41.4333680leighann mcdadeThis should be mandatory, same as checking for cleft palate etc. Families should not need to suffer unnecessarily. Save the lives of our future babies18282014-01-15T18:31:06.383681claireI have gbs and almost lost my son with the nhs letting us down badly18282014-01-15T23:05:38.2273682nicola shearermore awareness needed asap18282014-01-15T23:24:27.3673683Gordon Not acceptable that strep B testing is not mandatory. There is nothing to debate here. I only ask the people who make these decisions , would you gamble your babies life to save £15 ? \r\n 18282014-01-16T12:59:03.0633684Danniicannot believe that something that can be life threatening to a newborn isnt routinely screened and tested for. Also even when told you are infected no information is given about what precautions should be taken. Totally unacceptable!18282014-01-17T09:36:01.833685Mairi RodgersI like the sound of that....Robert Burns International Airport ...hope it happens.. Mairi x19082014-01-17T10:42:44.483686Connie HendersonI have flown in and out of this airport many times and felt safe and comfortable. Although living in Canada now, I am still very proud of my heritage and background and feel the airport should be given a name of pride of the local vicinity.19082014-01-18T09:28:08.2133687Lesley-Ann rawlingsOmg!!!! What will make the health ministers accept the fact by giving every pregnant lady the right GBS info it will save babies lives? Inform them about the options they have the right to have. Because my daughter and son in law knew nothing about this baby killing infection, in the last stage of full term + labour,my beautiful granddaughter Ella,was born sleeping. This is murder through not giving us the info!!!! As for the actual numbers affected, NO ONE in the government has ever bothered to do a accurate survey so have no idea how many this infection has affected. My darling Ella is not even counted on their list cos she didn't take a breath. How is that right? I know of many cases the same, god knows what the real numbers would be!!!! Please change this NOW.18282014-01-18T09:28:44.1033688Derek Hanlon I support the proposal to have Glasgow Prestwick renamed "Robert Burns International Airport". I find it astonishing that it had not been done before and am glad that the error of "pure dead brilliant" has been corrected. Robert Burns is Scotland's single most important historic figure representing Scottish culture. 19082014-01-18T11:10:22.543689James MacfarlaneNo, you need the name of the place in the name of the airport, or people won't know where it is. Maybe 'Glasgow Robert Burns Airport'?19082014-01-18T16:48:54.7573690sammy I had it when I was pregnant but I never knew I had it until i was in labour . You have to get 2 doses of antibiotics . Still don't really understand want it is . But i do know its really bad xx18282014-01-18T16:49:33.233691Gemma newsonI have strep b and after having my 2nd son last week I don't feel I know enough about the infection and effects. More needs to be done about this!!! 18282014-01-18T18:37:28.3173692Gus RobbScots Wha Hae...now its time to recognise a true ledgend.19082014-01-18T23:16:47.3933693Julie ThompsonThis matter needs urgent attention. Best of\r\nLuck Jackie xx18282014-01-19T00:17:19.5833694Lynn TuckerCome on, this a no brainer! Even if one baby is saved it is so worth it.18282014-01-19T00:31:00.8733695Kelli GuineyThis is screened for in Australia and managed if the mother has it. It's a simple and cheap test to do - incredible that it isn't done routinely in the UK.18282014-01-19T00:43:51.553696margo mcgregorTotally unacceptable that no screening takes place. This affects the whole family and for the sake of a few Pounds could minimise this condition for many babies and their families 18282014-01-19T10:40:18.3973697Angela Susan HarrisonMore health awareness is needed to ensure pregnant mothers are screened for Strep B and knowing that it can cause severe disabilities or death there should be more attention given to protect both mother and infant. As vaccination stipulation for infants so should there be screening for any signs of this Strep B at the onset of pregnancy and before birth, for the mother, and to protect the foetus while developing. 18282014-01-19T17:28:11.423698Dorothy LobleyIt beggars belief that the NHS do not routinely screen pregnant women for Group B Strep. I strongly believe this needs to be introduced urgently. In addition staff need to be trained and procedures introduced to ensure a mother with GBS is given antibiotics early in labour. 18282014-01-19T17:56:11.173699Nicole tFreya should not have gone through this18282014-01-19T21:45:17.8033700Joanna MckechnieIt should be tested like everything else that is done through pregnancys !!!18282014-01-19T23:14:47.423701Lesley mcgeachyPoor little baby. This should not happen. X18282014-01-20T08:02:12.3873702Lauren HughesI have just been tested positve for GBS and I am 33 weeks pregnant, i hadn't even heard of it. Thankfully I am aware of it now and can have the antibiotics to prevent my baby from getting it.18282014-01-21T06:57:38.7733703JackieI'm overwhelmed by the response to my petition and hope that Group B Strep can be brought from under the carpet as it's only often when it's to late you learn about it,knowledge is power and the power of the people can save life's and disabilities and hopefully we can get things changed,thanks everyone x18282014-01-21T16:39:44.1873704Geoff CrolleyThe Ayrshire airport is owned by the Scottish Government please let the Ayrshire and Scottish people have a say on her name.19082014-01-21T21:11:57.5873705matthew allenthis should be a standard routine. my wife only discovered afterwards that she had gbs, thankfully the dr who delivered suspected during labour as she was given iv penicilan but her and my baby daughter were kept in for 5 days. both mum n baby on iv lines for twice daily antibiotics. not good for a husband and new daddy to see his wife and daughter like this18282014-01-22T07:46:46.4533706SuzanneIs there not a petition for England? 18282014-01-22T13:40:44.4173707IsabelHaving first hand knowledge of the devastating effects that Group B Strep can cause, the NHS should be providing routine tests for ALL expectant mums....this could help prevent fatalities and disabilities.18282014-01-22T14:19:25.3033708kelly traviswould really like to see this in England . 18282014-01-22T14:52:42.8373709KateI had group b strep in my last three pregnancies the test should be available for every pregnant woman.18282014-01-22T15:12:30.93710MICHELLE DOYLEBaby died at three days old in 2007 contacted melingitis...because i carried strep b in pregnancy simply antibiotics during labour and she would be with me today..18282014-01-22T15:16:29.3233711richard mcskimmingsthis will be a good thing .Robert burns nothing better19082014-01-22T18:31:32.6273712caseybeen for a check up with my daughter today she 20 months now. she had GBS, meningitis, septic arthritis and hydrocepalus she now has a vp shunt.18282014-01-22T22:30:25.213713charmaine kellyWe Need This All Over The World My Son Had Strep B Twice And Thankful Pulled Through I Blame Doctors Never Told Me I Had It After My Son Was Cleared Of It The First Time I Never New And Reinfected Him Again The Health Services Dont Have a Clue And My Lil Man Could Of Died Twice From It We Need The Funding Everyone Spread The Word!!!18282014-01-23T09:28:28.333714ALAN MCPHERSONEasy to do and will save lives and heartache. Let's do it, NOW.18282014-01-23T09:48:37.7433715George HenrySign this and potentially save children's lives? It's a no brainer...18282014-01-23T11:18:41.913716GillThis Test should be Routine in Scotland, England & Every other Country of the World !\r\nThe outcome of non-detection of STREP B can be Devastating & Heartbreaking for the Whole Family. Many couples have to go through months & even years of trying for a Baby - how devastating if such a treatable complication was not then detected & cancelled out any hopes of being a parent.\r\nThis Test for All needs to be carried out NOW !18282014-01-23T11:32:57.5373718michaelnot a bad idea19082014-01-23T13:55:03.113719Louise burns Strep b must be taken more seriously !!18282014-01-23T14:48:26.3773720John BaileyMy wife hard strep B never knew a thing about people need to be aware and all mum's to be should be tested to save lives.18282014-01-23T17:27:09.8673721Claire StephenSign sign sign! 18282014-01-23T17:38:24.853722Susan AlexanderDiffently should be 18282014-01-23T21:59:00.443723Mrs Caroline HayI agree that measures should be taken to screen for group B strep and mothers given information.18282014-01-24T08:17:27.163724Kyhla gerrardI cant understand why this is not routine. I was a carrier with both my children and with the first only found out by chance i had no idea what it was. I was given IV during labour and thankfully this stopped any infection to my daughter. Every expectant mother i know i have warned them about this and none had even heard of this which is shocking. I pray that it will become compulsary to advise pregant women about this. Please sign x18282014-01-24T08:32:34.5073725tina brysonI had this with my youngest boy bit they said i must have it all with 3 off my pregnancys and this could of been the cause of why i went into premature labour with my 1st and he died 15 mins later... I've been early with all my kids my 1st was born at 23 weeks and 5 days gestation my 2nd oldest was born at 35 weeks and in special care for a nite n day and my youngest had him at 3 weeks earlier all my pregnacys have difficulty reachin there full term .the hospital had to stop my 2nd oldest and my youngest at 27 weeks...they should be doing mandatory checks . 18282014-01-24T08:33:14.2433726jansave lives and heartache. Let's do it, NOW.18282014-01-24T20:01:28.223727ruth rothwellhe is a historical son of scotland and should be treated as one people around ta world admire and love robert burns and what fitting place is ta pay tribute to ta great man as a traveller to land in an airport name after ta great one and on his home soil 19082014-01-24T23:31:01.0833728Sherry ByrdWhat could be more appropriate than to honor the bard with naming an international airport after him since he is known and loved worldwide, and near his own hometown! \r\n19082014-01-25T00:08:18.0633729ElShould be called the Robert Burn International Airport, 19082014-01-25T05:16:58.933730morrison youngThank You for your signature suggest I have signed this, but nothing I have done is consistent with this. I intended to sign certianly,but ambiguity rules the day here.I shall find out if I have signed this in certainty when this appears is my opinion..Maybe I am just different, but if I have doubts Im convinced so do others.19082014-01-25T15:25:36.9973731Mariana YarnoldSaves thousands of lives. I'm SB positive. It is a nightmare. Tests are legally mandatory in some 3rd world countries! 18282014-01-27T08:22:24.953732Ben PowerA fantastic ides to name our only all weather international airport after our most memorable international Scot whose works so change the world continually.19082014-01-27T13:46:08.5573733Kate Richardson Should be screened for routinely! If it was my baby boy might not have been born with pneumonia, needing to be ventilated, and not cuddled for the first few days of his life. A 2 week stay in the NICU could have been so easily avoided through a simple swab in pregnancy. 18282014-01-27T14:28:42.4833734Emma branaghanI had it. Not enough awareness18282014-01-27T14:58:18.733735SusanI was diagnosed with having GBS after having had my son at 29 wks last year (this then was put down as the cause of my pre-term labour). He was then not breathing for the first 19 mins. of his life and had to be resuscitated. He then was infected by it once he was born, but thankfully was treated with the appropriate antibiotics.18282014-01-27T15:15:52.583736Jodie mitchellI have strep b but was tested during pregnancy and made aware of what can happen 18282014-01-27T17:52:08.4373737Bill FlemingRobert Burns International Airport. Wonderful ring to that. 19082014-01-27T18:11:25.1333738michelle bowesI'm currently pregnant with my third, I sadly lost my second. But that was when I discovered I have gbs.. All the blood tests they take, one more wouldn't hurt and can save lifes!! What more important is there.. 18282014-01-27T20:27:48.043739A.J.MortonAs a friend of the Federation and a co-founder of a "Rename Prestwick" Facebook page of over 7000 followers (the largest on the net!), I happily sign and endorse this petition.19082014-01-27T21:31:43.1933740Andrea ReayHaving my daughter born with this I know 1st hand the awful experiences parents go through for something that could be so easily avoided18282014-01-28T10:04:11.073741Sophie DowWholeheartedly19632014-01-28T13:26:25.9073742Antoinette This should automatically be done, for these pregnant ladies 18282014-01-28T14:25:38.3033743Rachel mackayThis scandalous no more cuts19632014-01-28T14:30:52.353744alan mcfarlaneall children need educated, not just the clever ones .19632014-01-28T14:32:25.733745tanya Our children deserve the right to a proper well supported education just the same as any other child alot of children are not getting the educational suppoert that they need through the main stream schools that the attend this needs to change and the children should be educated to be the best they can be 19632014-01-28T14:41:28.923746Elizabeth Cannon As a patent with a child with ASD ADHD & ODD this is terrible, LA's are struggling enough without the loss of funds which are desperately needed. 19632014-01-28T14:47:59.743747Laura jamesThe cut backs in my son's speci needs school are a disgrace19632014-01-28T14:53:24.853748Lorraine DearieMy autistic child is in a mainstream secondary with a autism unit, it has ran for about 16yrs and was held as excellent and it should be expanded around scotland - that was when it started with 1 expert autism teacher to 4 pupils, it is now 1 to 10 and all I get told is how they dont have enough time or enough staff to do things they used to do which helped our children with their difficulties - it isn't fit for purpose anymore and could be so excellent as it once was with proper resourcing - and yet all I hear is more cuts more cuts, it has to end - it can make such a difference to the outcome for our children when they have the proper support - it does make a difference! The cuts in ratio weren't made to save money they were increased because demand increased it has a very determinetal effect to all the pupils and demand is still increasing, funding must increase too!19632014-01-28T15:33:41.573749Raymond CoyleShameful 19632014-01-28T16:05:23.5533750james russell andersona wonderful idea19082014-01-28T16:16:49.6333751Glynis Morrismore services needed not less19632014-01-28T16:44:04.63752karen Gracie Additional support is much needed and my son Couldn't go to nursery without19632014-01-28T16:48:39.073753Teresa Catto-Smith With rolls being capped and specialist provision harder to access more than ever, the funding for ASL provision has to be protected. The 'presumption of mainstream' practised across the country is damaging children who are already vulnerable and puts pressure on schools already stretched to the limit. \r\n\r\nThese cuts affect vulnerable children disproportionately but people also need to remember that the impact of a child with additional neess not being supported appropriately is felt by the rest of their class too. Sweeping cuts to Children & Families budgets are coming and this will impact on all families. \r\n\r\nImmoral and shameful - kept quiet too, but it wont help with the 'Yes' campaign for people to know what cuts are coming. Sneaky. 19632014-01-28T17:22:46.1473754Joe Thompson You have my support :-)19632014-01-28T17:24:12.0073755Nicola MunroMy middle son has Asperger Syndrome and receives little support in Mainstream school. We have been fighting for years for additional help to little avail. Schools have a duty o care to all children to provide an education - sadly this is not always upheld especially with children who have ASN. More funding is needed desperately. We have now had to make a request for our child to be placed in an ASD unit as Mainstream cannot cope due to lack of adequately trained staff. Obviously this is due to lack of funding. This is an awful situation in today's society.\r\n19632014-01-28T17:24:26.0533756Eleanor FergusonIt is very important that children get the right support at school to give them the best chance of maximising their potential19632014-01-28T17:39:22.3333757d dicksonteachers in mainstream schools dnt have the expertise or time to deal with kids who have additional needs ....its a no brainer !\r\n19632014-01-28T18:01:05.0733758Mairead MurrayCreate fairness for families without them having to fight for basic rights19632014-01-28T18:14:58.7273759John HuttonProper support at school is so important to the development and education of our kids. Cuts cuts and more cuts. Enough is enough, let's make a voice to be heard, loud and clear, don't cut the support in school our kids desperately need.19632014-01-28T18:19:28.073760Alexandra DuffThere should be more services available19632014-01-28T18:34:51.2673761Bev McguckinGIRFEC has a long, long way to go before it's coming close to meeting the needs of our children. The theory of it on paper is good but the practise is a daily battle!! People are willing but cost cuts at every turn !! Frustration 19632014-01-28T18:42:20.5533762Andrea GavinEvery child has the right to access the correct education.19632014-01-28T18:54:54.5473763Charles H. Cameron CDAs a friend of the Federation and a Vice President of the Robert Burn's Club of Winnipeg, Manitoba, I happily sign and endorse this petition.19082014-01-28T19:00:24.0633764Jennifer AllanMy son attends a specialist nursery with additional support and he has came on so much, he absolutely would not cope in mainstream nursery.19632014-01-28T19:42:10.0673765Kirsty LawsonWith provision for special and or additional needs children already too small I cannot see how this will work. If those who decide where the funding went had children who require specialist help they would soon fight for the budget to be increased instead of reducing it yet again when services are already too low.19632014-01-28T19:54:42.683766Anne McMathEvery child deserves the additional support they need to help them achieve their goals no matter what the cost.19632014-01-28T20:16:00.853767Kristy jonesAddional support is needed a lot of children wouldnt be able to attend nursery without it including my son. 19632014-01-28T20:46:25.1933768sandra reesMy child needs more support in class to meet his full potential19632014-01-28T20:47:56.963769MikaelaThis will save lives.... do we need to say anything more?!18282014-01-28T20:57:54.8573770Calum AuldMuch needed assistance for our schools...19632014-01-28T20:59:38.8973771Fiona AuldRidiculous! 19632014-01-28T21:01:47.843772Janice MillsChildren need adults to stand up for them in this kind of issue19632014-01-28T21:03:37.7873773Lisa HunterServices during childhood are essential and if good children's services in place reduced costs may result for individuals in later life as they achieve greater skills, coping and confidence.19632014-01-28T21:23:59.213774Suzanne clarkYet again the most vulnerable are being targeted. They are still children and they should be given the same opportunities as the rest but they are not. They are treated like second class citizens. If teaching staff was being cut back in mainstream school there would be an out cry but not the same outcry for kids with disabilites19632014-01-28T21:49:44.0073775Mark Stewart Please support this cause. 19632014-01-28T21:55:00.8433777Denise McMillanThe cuts for children and young people with ASN is beyond ridiculous! It has a major impact on these children, their classmates who do not require additional support as teachers are so stretched, and families. You MUST invest in our children's future and allow them to reach their full potential!! 19632014-01-28T22:02:52.6733778Tracy MetcalfWe have already had strike days from psa staff in mainstream shools as a result of the pressure put on them as a result of this. It's concerning when the staff are publicly saying its too much!19632014-01-28T22:12:49.7873779Laura StantonAdditional learning support needs more funding not less! This is especially required now to the increasing numbers of children who need support in school due to complex medical conditions & the real needs of the children. No help then no positive future for them or the country.19632014-01-28T22:19:19.7273780Marie FarrellThis funding is vital to the development and education of all additional needs students covering all ages. This funding is a necessary ingredient in supporting these needs.19632014-01-28T22:35:03.323781Lesley MorricePlease do the right thing by our children and the right thing for the future of Scotland.19632014-01-28T22:46:14.1233782Deborah bestMy son has just been failed by our local authority\r\nWho have admitted to disability discrimination 19632014-01-28T22:53:27.9773783roberta colesNo questions asked every pregnant woman and her unborn baby should be protected 18282014-01-28T23:44:11.1973784Hannah MarieFor Ella with love x x x18282014-01-28T23:49:24.4273785Alison LeightonVitally important that young people with ASN get the extra support and help they need to enable them to cope in education. Teachers have a tough enough time with inclusive classes and base provision now disappearing and ASN classroom assistants being cut to stretching point!19632014-01-29T07:20:48.4373786Euan R BrownThe proposed cuts will have a severe impact on the very parts of services designed to help integrate services between special schools and mainstream. Specifically, reducing budget for 1-2 days per week placement in mainstream will have the result of increased isolation of special needs pupils.\r\n19632014-01-29T07:30:30.173788Sandie MelvinMy son needs more help. Plenty money goes to helping people with selfinflicting health issues my son was born with autism. Not fair in anyone's eyes19632014-01-29T08:42:41.693789Margaret GoodwinNeed more services not less all children should have the support which they need and deserve 19632014-01-29T09:19:33.0033791Aileen BullochMore help needed not less19632014-01-29T10:47:07.4033792debbie kempSuch a demand in mainstream schools19632014-01-29T11:02:58.2373793Angela Greenlawas all child are needing the additional support for learning and additional support needs for special needs learning too xx 19632014-01-29T11:14:14.643794Claire I totally agree with this. I had Strep B and only found out at the very late stages through another illness. I was subsequently treated for my three pregnancies. I hope this is available to all women. 18282014-01-29T11:45:49.0933795charlene brownmy daughter needs the extra help but doesnt seem to b getting what she needs!!19632014-01-29T11:53:45.0173796Isobel mitchellSupport for Additional Support Needs must be adequately funded to enable children, families & staff & to implement legislation & guidelines.19632014-01-29T12:55:09.583797Tracey BlackieOur kids need help and respect like all kids do19632014-01-29T12:55:59.2973798verashould always be checked for every pregnancy18282014-01-29T13:21:06.6873799Brenda candlishMoney should never b a factor when it comes to any childs education and additional support needs. Supposed to be the Curriculum For Excellance. 19632014-01-29T13:28:16.0933800Pamela McNameeChildren's services are vital, much more support is required, not a reduction!19632014-01-29T14:08:18.6873801Gina WittyThere is not enough help as it is. Cutting services is not an option. As it is I have had to pay for extra tuition for my son with dyslexia as he was not getting the help he needed in the school system. 19632014-01-29T14:16:55.2333802Alan WilsonYou need to discharge your responsibiliyies for young people. They are your future19632014-01-29T14:49:39.5973803Pearl BroadfootIt is a disgrace cutting back on this vital funding. Specialised schools are closed and more and more children attend mainstream schools but for them to understan and be part of the curriculm they need help. Even when children leave school more help is needed for them to be intigrated into society and to live like a human being. it is unfair and immoral for funding to be cut and leave these children without a means for them to be educated as is the right of every child.19632014-01-29T15:05:09.0573804Martin DAVIES"Savings" like this create future debt. These children are part of Scotland's future. They need to be helped to be productive.19632014-01-29T17:03:54.7033805Allison WallsFunding should be available for additional needs in school. Children are getting no help as teachers say no money. Scottish govt is letting them down. 19632014-01-29T18:04:47.9033806Shevon McLeodWhat is the point in drawing up a document like GIRFEC if there is no intention to provide the resources required to fulfill its recommendations. I am a parent with additional needs and right now you are failing her. Shame on you Scottish Government!!19632014-01-29T18:28:15.8173807Emma Fleming My son has aspergers and in mainstream school, he is struggling and there is note nought understanding and knowledge with the teachers and lack of supports for his needs, not enought assistants in school or learning support teachers to cope with the amount of ads children that are being forcsed to learn in an unsuporting environment for there needs more needs to be done if these children are to thrive in the education system as currently they are not and coping is not the same as thriving 19632014-01-29T19:03:16.0773808chris heggieThe Scottish Parliment, should ensure that the current and all future cuts to services in Education especially those affecting Children with, Additional Support Needs, are reversed. Edinburgh Council, have spent £ 1 million, Plus, on the unpopular Tram System, how much are, my Children with, Aspergers Syndrome, Worth ?. If these Cuts are not reversed - i call on all parents to Boycott the Independance Vote.19632014-01-29T20:19:01.7673809Sarah SingletonThis is a valuable resource 19632014-01-29T21:08:23.1273811Catriona GrantShort-term savings, long-term costs, both in terms of children's happiness and the financial support needed for the adults they may grow into if unsupported now. Please prioritise children's needs.19632014-01-29T21:58:28.7833812Jason Cowan. It's a no brainier really. Why would you not highlight the risks?!18282014-01-29T22:37:16.8473813Liz BAll expectant mothers should know the risks18282014-01-29T22:48:21.0433814Elaine GregorySuch short term gains and long term disaster for both children and country.19632014-01-29T22:49:09.2773815Loretta MooneyOur children are the future of this country,therefore it is our ultimate duty to fight to give them every opportunity to be proud, responsible, well adjusted & confident adults. If a child requires additional support to learn then we must provide it. Really it's a no brainer!!! 19632014-01-30T00:03:42.7373816Johan Mackinnon Please give children like my son the support and care needed to help them learn. Make the learning environment a better place for them.19632014-01-30T01:36:14.6573817Siobhan PatersonWith first hand experience of the lack of support it is vital that more is done for children with additional needs not less. Children are our future.19632014-01-30T08:41:12.7633818Nicola StevensIn order for my daughter to make as useful a contribution to society as possible, she requires the appropriate educational support. Please ensure this is equitably available for all.19632014-01-30T12:32:56.473819HAZEL SHAWIn order for my daughter to make as useful a contribution to society as possible, she requires the appropriate educational support. Please ensure this is equitably available for all.19632014-01-30T12:59:38.053820Angela CoubroughEvery child has the right to be able to reach their full potential. The number of children with additional support needs is increasing and funding should be increasing appropriately.19632014-01-30T14:07:56.5333821Tessa HumbyCutting funding for children with additional support needs is a false economy which will come back to haunt us when large numbers of today's children become adults who have been denied the chance to contribute fully. Take the long view.19632014-01-30T16:54:34.443823Jamie MurrayGet on with it. This has waited too long.18282014-01-30T17:25:22.7973824sarah mclachlanour children are our future. Deny them the support they need will cause unnecessary complication for the future and costs will increase significantly to remedy deficits in their capability to reach their goals in life. A happy child will develop into a happy adult. We all need our future.19632014-01-30T18:12:17.23825Julie-Anne MorganAs the mother of a 12yr old son with Asperger's it is very important to me and my son that he is fully supported in mainstream school so he can function to the best of his ability. Therefore this funding is very important to us and other familys like us who rely on this funding to act as a full memeber of our society x19632014-01-30T18:48:28.0133826ANNE DUNBARI lost my Grand-daughter Ella in 2009 - if we had only known about the test she would have had a chance18282014-01-30T18:56:35.3733827Lorna WalkerMany children and young people require additional support. We have legislation - the ASL Act, 2004 amended in 2009, and national guidance- GIRFEC- which cannot be effectively implemented unless Local Authorities have sufficient resources to ensure the learning and social and emotional needs of potentially all children are met.19632014-01-30T19:06:43.4733828Mrs Elaine RobertsWhat happened to equality? It is always a challenge keeping on top of teachers who only do the bare minimum for support and even then may not be giving the correct support and thats before any cuts to funding! So cutting funding will seriously disadvantage our children who will not get an EQUAL opportunity to learn.19632014-01-30T19:32:37.1233829Sally VercosaGiving a child a diagnoses and a 'label' and then not supporting them is far from helpful. We should pride ourselves in this country for helping people and getting rid of stigmas - don't let it go back the way.19632014-01-30T21:14:53.733830Eileen o'hareI gave birth to twins in 2011 and one of them fell ill with strep b late onset at 6 weeks. i had no idea what it was before he developed it. Every expectant mother has the right to basic info!! We were lucky our son made a full recovery. others have not been lucky. my heart goes out to them.\r\n18282014-01-30T21:57:01.2573831Denise BennettMy beautiful little girl passed away in December 2013 6 days after being diagnosed with group b strep. More should be done to raise awareness and prevention of this so that others do not have to endure the pain and sadness I have as a mother who lost a very precious baby girl. 18282014-01-30T22:18:16.383832Billy MailThere are many smart and capable kids out there who are extremely capable and bright but are missing the special attention and guidance and education they need and deserve to be the bright adults of the future. Let's get behind them and give them the chance they deserve. 19632014-01-30T22:20:45.273833Cheryl StewartFor my son Ben and every child like him.19632014-01-30T22:24:32.5233834Diane McIntoshWe need to make sure our children have the right support and resources to help them flourish. Forcing them through an education without proper help and support won't work and will only damage their confidence, self worth and dreams. 19632014-01-30T22:42:12.3173835June SavageMy son has additional support needs and although is reasonably well supported at a small mainstream primary school, I really fear for the future with all these cuts to specialist provision. PLEASE there must be some other way!!!19632014-01-30T23:11:51.8933836Lyndsey JohnstonChildren who are already at a disadvantage should not have their ability to reach their potential removed by policy and finances 19632014-01-31T00:49:42.943837Linda JFirst I heard of GBS was when my only child was seriously ill in a special nursery in 1999. I can't believe in 2014 it's still not routinely checked for - they have done in the USA for years - it's a life saving simple blood test - what they waiting for?!18282014-01-31T00:57:24.3333838Sarah PatersonEvery pregnant woman should have this! The after effects don't show till it's to late. Women get tested for everything else and this should be included!18282014-01-31T06:58:43.7073839Alan EdwardsYour are destroying children's future and having a negative impact on the country as a whole19632014-01-31T10:48:58.5573840John HoldenGet the right people in the right places at the right time,before it's too late.19632014-01-31T12:59:53.1533841Laura joinerMy daughter, now 12 nearly died from group b strep, so I am in full support of screening during pregnancy. We are very lucky to have Shannon today and I would hate any other family to have to go through what we did.18282014-01-31T14:15:23.243842MMWas diagnosed with GBS in my second pregnancy due to excess bouts of thrush. Still had an unpleasant experience at hospital as I was sent home while in the throws of labour so didn't have time for antibiotic to be administered while in labour, as a result the baby was whisked away immediately after birth for antibiotic. Thankfully the baby was absolutely fine but still disappointed with the midwife sending me home.18282014-01-31T15:55:04.8633843fiona fitzgeraldwe need more funding for learning support not less.19632014-01-31T17:13:55.7533844Kerry macdonaldThese people require funds not tomorrow now19632014-01-31T18:47:06.1633845Alan TennantMy son has been dependant on ASN throughout his schooling. He is entitled to be treated the same as any other pupil, albeit with that extra support needed. \r\nI call for any planned cuts in ASN to be cancelled. 19632014-01-31T18:49:39.3673846Diane StevensonSomething has to be done quickly to stop any further cuts in funding or services this is actually harassment of disabled people 19632014-01-31T19:07:53.033847Katie NevansChildren's services need to be protected.19632014-01-31T19:11:09.0333848lorraine doylePupils with special needs do not need this cuts.!!!19632014-01-31T19:14:30.4273849Wilf MarshallEducation cuts are disgraceful. Education cuts affecting gifted children are outrageous 19632014-01-31T19:20:01.9433852trisha gaffneydont make cuts make give more help and support when needed to support both the child their support worker.19632014-01-31T19:49:30.7873853Fiona Hanchardall children deserve the same level of teaching, and for some more help is needed this should definitely be given without thought as it is every childs right to learn19632014-01-31T19:51:17.4133854eddie fergusonIt should be about prevention not intervention!! children are forced on a daily basis to endure what they simply cope with due to lack of correct support impacting on every aspect of what already is a very difficult life for them, setting them up to fail before they have even started its so so wrong in this day and age19632014-01-31T19:53:51.0873855sandra novakMy work colleagues daughter nearly died because of this-she is now visually impaired and has cerebral palsy18282014-01-31T21:39:25.493856Louisa DarlingPeople need to remember Glasgow has been run by the same people for the last 50 years so I think we should be taking this up with our council19632014-02-01T01:14:50.4273857Joan MitchellIf these kids dont get the help they need how are they going to get on in life19632014-02-01T08:05:08.213858scott lindsayChildren should come first!!19632014-02-01T10:50:57.9033859William NeilsonMy eldest child who is now 33 received support at school and this support was vital19632014-02-01T14:09:59.443860David Sneddon Come on Holyrood, get your finger out and get this sorted19632014-02-01T15:38:12.8333861Wullie KnightProvisions for children who require additional support is insufficient already. Children who require the support are not receiving it at the correct level. Funding needs to be increases for the future of these children and not reduced. Our children are the future, give our future a chance of succeeding without having to struggle and fight to achieve an education that it deserves and needs.19632014-02-01T16:25:48.8273862stephen quinnkeep on keepin on18282014-02-01T20:16:57.763863Teresa HilliardMy daughter has just had a baby but i dont know if she was offered this test. Luckily my grandaughter is fit and healthy despite being born 3wks early. This test should be compulsory for every pregnant woman no matee what their religion is. 18282014-02-01T20:27:37.0173864Joan lappinOur children need this HELP do not take it away 19632014-02-01T20:30:58.0473865Brooke HamiltonPregnant women should be tested automatically18282014-02-02T02:51:03.9473866Amy munnI'm currently 36weeks pregnant and was only by chance early on tested for gbs after admitted to hospital for something else. Every pregnant woman should be offered testing or information on gbs as this is my third pregnancy never new about gbs befor. I will hopefully be having antibiotics in labour fingers crossed my baby will be ok just by stroke of luck and I no beforehand.18282014-02-02T07:45:34.033867Chris SimmAs a business woman who has on several occasions gone up to Glasgow Airport to pick people up only to find that they were at Prestwick. I think that this is long overdue and an excellent choice of name. 19082014-02-02T07:51:10.1473868Joseph Boylefunding should never be an issue where childrens well being is to be improved19632014-02-02T08:26:29.0673869Mairi KaneMore training for pupil support assistants is needed as these members of staff are usually the ones with the most contact with children with additional needs. Teachers are too busy with the more clever and able kids.19632014-02-02T08:56:54.813870Suzanne Loughton All women should be routinely tested for this. I had it with my little boy and it was only discovered by chance as my hind waters broke but I didn't go into labour. Every time I ask about being tested in this pregnancy I keep getting fobbed off. I pay my tax and ni - surely my contribution entitles me to have this simple test!!18282014-02-02T13:05:36.263872Kim FosterIn aberdeen the Psa and asn has been cut the support in secondary schools are truly shocking, kids are made to be the bad ones 19632014-02-02T13:10:27.2833873Kim FosterSecondary support is shocking, my son was lucky in primary and managed to get a place in specialist unit but now he is once again left in a class of 32 and I get notes to say he not performing, little asn and although she does her best the asn he does get isn't trained in his needs. 19632014-02-02T19:08:21.213874HillsMy Great Grandaughter has it my Grandaughter had streps when pregnant nothing was done she did tell all involved with her as she had Streps with the last child it has to be a priority in pregnancy my Great Grandaughter is 10 days old and having to go through all this is awful.18282014-02-02T21:00:43.693875Fiona MorrisonMany of these remarkable children face educational challenges with great courage. As a society we have a moral responsibility to support them in this. To reduce the levels of support means we fail these already vulnerable children and their ability to reach their potential. Surely that doesn't make economic sense in the longer term?19632014-02-03T00:10:55.7233876Katie O'SheaIt is imperative that full support is made available for children with special learning requirements. Their rights and their future are exactly equal to that of all other citizens.19632014-02-03T08:11:57.6733877Kerry kayeAs this is not a routine test I only going out by accident that I had group B strep. I had a lot if bleeding during pregnancy and it was only then that they did some tests. I had to have a course of antibiotics and in labour an IV line to get antibiotics into me before giving birth. I had never heard of it before then and this was my 4 th child. 18282014-02-03T09:42:18.1633878Sandra ScrivenerWas not even aware of this, until heard about a new born baby suffering immediately after birth. If all pregnant women were aware then prevention would be in situ, the babies would not suffer. It must be part and parcel of all testing for pregnant women.18282014-02-03T10:36:51.13879Sheila KettlesAll children should be entitled to equality of opportunity to learn. If some children require additional support, then that's what we need to provide them with.19632014-02-03T12:43:20.3033880Nikki CavanaghI only found out by accident I had strep B after I had bleeding late in pregnancy and was tested for infections. I knew nothing about it and this was my 4th pregnancy. Every pregnant woman should be tested for this during pregnancy, especially as the risks to newborns are so severe!!18282014-02-03T14:24:16.8533882Julie DaleI am a strep b carrier - found it during first pregnancy and had antibiotics during labour. Unfortunately had to insist on antibiotics during second but midwife great with third and made sure I got antibiotics.18282014-02-03T18:42:23.4373883Paul GilstonAll pregnant women should be made aware of this and also screened for it if possible!18282014-02-03T19:24:58.153884Fiona SmithPlease it makes so much sense18282014-02-03T19:59:44.3233885craig andersonthese politicians should buck their ideas up if they want to save money TAKE A PAY CUT!!! stop taking from folk who need it most! or how about this for a radical idea! stop giving free methadone and use the cash they waste on these waters and use it to bolster the services they are trying to cut!19632014-02-03T23:01:19.4773886Wendy branchI had this when expecting my second child luckily I had mine detected when investigating something else18282014-02-03T23:16:21.9833887Sharon dryburghMake this a routine test18282014-02-04T18:56:21.753888LouiseI didnt find out i had strep b until a week after my daughter was born n then found out it can cause death in infants if undetected, it should be screened for routinely, they do it in america so why cant they do it here!18282014-02-05T09:44:12.333889Elaine TaitI got more information from tv article than from the NHS and got private test as I was told their tests were unreliable and pointless! 18282014-02-05T12:32:33.063890Louise McCarronGreat idea - an obvious choice. Good luck.19082014-02-05T14:55:02.153891Susan GilliesYou build bigger , state-of-the-art schools that accomodate the growing population but you then have no funds available to put in the vital support for children that require it causing them to suffer greatly with their education. How can you state GIRFEC principles when there is not enough funding to help the children that need additional support? 19632014-02-05T18:49:20.873892Anonymous ScotAs much as I credit Robert Burns as a poet. I can't sign this as I think any airport with "Burns" (the word, not the name necessarily) associated with it just plain stupid. Just think of the poor newspaper puns they'd come out with if there was ever an accident at Burns Airport.19082014-02-06T02:40:44.943893C. McCrimmonIt is beyond my comprehension that a government that supports legislation to enforce greater support for pupils in school should allow authorities to reduce support for learning staff quotas. Primary class teachers and secondary subject teachers cannot deliver equality of learning to their pupils, which was clearly identified as a deficit in the Scottish education system by the OECD, in such circumstances. How on earth can a Curriculum for Excellence respond to those criticisms when essential learning support staff are removed from classrooms. Let us not forget that there is a legal obligation here for schools and authorities to identify and provide support. You can't give parents rights to challenge schools and place class teachers in such a vulnerable position by taking away the very specialised support that allows them to deliver the new curriculum in the manner it was first intended. 19632014-02-06T10:11:08.933894SamanthaI had never heard of this before until I found out my little boy had it a few days to a week after he was born. it was awful! he was very very ill, went blue and stopped breathing 4 times, (once in our arms!!) had signs of meningitis, needed a lumbar puncture and constant tests. He spent 2 weeks in a special care baby unit and it was the most horrific time of my life. Luckily the staff at the hospital were amazing and you wouldn't know now that my little boy had been ill, except for a few ear problems - which I believe is connected! I had antibiotics while in labour with my second boy but I dont think they did the job correctly as he still got poorly from it and spent a week in the special care baby unit. He wasn't as ill as my first but it was horrific all the same!! \r\n\r\nI don't wish to go through this ever again, and would not wish it on any other parent! Please get this sorted! Like the lady above said, America screen for it so why not here???? \r\n\r\nThank you for reading.x18282014-02-06T18:41:31.1973895colleen kellymy son has ASN and is being severly let down by the education system and the pure lack of support there is, in addition to this the pure lack of interest and nasty remarks education staff IE teachers is disgusting and if they are not doing their job right they should be made to step down as it is disgusting the treatment my son and other child receive considering they have to recieve a education by law19632014-02-06T19:39:33.6573896K HApparently it would take only one new passing loop to permit an hourly service on this line. When set against vague plans to dual the A96, it would seem sensible to provide this extra rail loop (much cheaper) which would have the added benefit of taking some of the pressure off the road by allowing people to travel in a more environmentally-friendly way.19572014-02-06T20:28:44.373897Bruce CooperMy partner and I went through a tough time delivering our first born, no idea what Strep B was or how it affected our baby, second child and the same worries. now five years later our friend has been diagnosed after a quick delivery, no time to give her baby antibiotics so now she faces days of stress and worry at a time when she's supposed to feel nothing but joy. PLEASE start testing as a matter of course for all pregnancies18282014-02-07T10:58:15.3733898Wendy ChrystalMy child is a very bright little girl who i knew from a young age had dyslexia. She has support from her local school and is currently learning touch typing ,this can only be supported when there is extra classroom support staff to help her.The teacher already has a composite class where there is a great range of needs to be met. It is critical for children like her that there is additional support so her learning needs can be met.It would be great to see more additional support for learning teachers who have had further specialized training and qualifications in this area.. Please continue to support our children19632014-02-07T11:02:20.613899Morag RorisonMy baby girl was stillborn due to undiagnosed Strep B..she would have been 19 this year...never forgotten...She was my firstborn. Her two brothers and sister were tested and monitored from the start of pregnancy and arrived safely. I can't believe this procedure isn't routine for all mums to be...a simple test literally saves lives...and a lot of heartache. RIP Zoe xxx 18282014-02-07T11:14:33.8333901Alison PattersonStrongly AGREE!18282014-02-07T11:44:22.253902Denise Anderson I didn't know I was a Strep B carrier and I nearly lost my son who's heart stopped 10 days after he was born, thankfully my sister was there and saved him but it was a long time before the effects of the infection ended. This is not an expensive or invasive test, a simple antibiotic whilst in labour could prevent so much heartache! ALL pregnant women should be entitled to it! X18282014-02-07T13:31:40.233903Carolyn DouglasStrongly agree with this petition. Even one baby being lost due to undiagnosed Strep B is too many...18282014-02-07T20:07:34.383904Michelle I had never heard of strep b until my first son was a few hours old with meningitis caused by strep b, I was told 50% chance of surviving! He is 14 this year but I will never forget my baby fighting for his life! I went on to have 2 more children, both had antibotics before birth and had no problems! If I had been tested the first pregnancy my baby wouldn't have needed to spend 8 weeks in hospital, awful time that I will never get over ! Please please test routinely for strep b, some people not so lucky! 18282014-02-07T23:27:47.943905Geraldine Awareness & knowledge is power & every woman & mother should be given a chance to protect her unborn child! My baby was born 10 weeks early & is disabled because of GBS infection which caused my waters to break early! Screening is normal practice in USA, Canada & in parts of Europe. 18282014-02-07T23:35:33.7073906Anne MacinnesMy elder son was born prematurely as a result of strep B infection and so very nearly died as a result. I was monitored carefully during my second pregnancy and received antibiotics during labour. Treatment is simple and effective but only if expectant mothers are aware of the infection and therefore screening is important.18282014-02-08T09:36:01.33907Victoria CoeMy mum lost my sister on 13th jan grandstand we didn't know that she had strep B but she is so scared of having another one but she is gonna try... it is a very rare thing...18282014-02-08T12:19:30.413908Suzanne StewartThis should be introduced in northern ireland as well !!!!!! I nearly lost my son to strep B 5 weeks early then at 2 weeks old he went blue and floppy on us very lucky to be here xx18282014-02-08T14:06:21.4473909donna kenyonI think it is imperative that people are made aware of this 18282014-02-08T15:32:19.4733910rachelI lost my son, and was not even aware this existed, I think parents should be aware 18282014-02-08T17:55:14.3333911Stephanie ParnellBabies shouldn't be affected by this in this day and age! In America it is routinely checked during pregnancy so if you have strep b, antibiotics can be started straight away! 18282014-02-08T20:11:22.5373912CaroleCompletely agree with this. I asked my midwife for swabbing time and time again as I thought something wasn't right. Labour came where I was ill, clearly passed strep b to my boy who then 24 hours later ended up in special care. We were lucky and had a strong fighting baby boy but what about the others? One baby lost is far to many when this could be addressed so easily. 18282014-02-08T21:05:04.853913mary mallis My niece lost her daughter to this terrible strep b it was awful and to be able to help someone else would be wonderful"18282014-02-08T21:35:12.2273914Stefani-Jean SimpsonMy midwife and doctors discovered I had group strep b at 32 weeks pregnant .. failed to tell me. Had my son and luckily the midwifes at the hospital discovered in the back of my notes that I had it. My aon was taken from me so quickly with no explanation and returned with a drip. The midwife and doctor there told me my son could fall seriously ill and gave me lots of information on it. I was 19 ans terrified at this point. Thankfully my beautiful avoided any infection and we were allowed to leave the hospital a few days after .. I'm blessed that I have him and don't take a day for granted. They should test every pregnant woman for gsb and inform them! 18282014-02-08T23:12:48.6273915Sarah pageI was given this test and not told it was positive until after I had been home with my daughter and we was rushed back in.. Very scary times but luckily my daughter was fine 18282014-02-08T23:22:09.9573916Amanda Bryant I have had strep b twice my first child has cerebral palsy and my second got pneumonia and sepsis as a result of this. It is about the midwives being more aware as well. 18282014-02-09T00:05:48.163917Becky mcgearyI found out I had group b strep after my baby was born, I had never heard of it before. Thank fully she's fine but it could have been so much worse . Why aren't all women screened for this when pregnant? 18282014-02-09T02:12:35.8033918suzanne lumbI had this tested in all 3 pregnancys, was discovered before birth with my first pregnancy & was not going to be tested 2nd or 3rd until I insisted, luckily I felt so strongly about it!!18282014-02-09T08:33:54.0773919Marie WheeldonI had Step B whilst pregnant and only found out due to having Thrush which a took a test to diagnose. It's a simple swab test which can even be done yourself at home then taken in to the Doctors to test. It does not take long at all. I don't understand why they do not test every pregnant woman for it as routine during one of the midwife appointments. It's so quick and easy to do. When I went into labour I got to hospital in plenty of time, as advised by my midwife, however they failed to get both lots of antibiotic in me before my baby was born. This seemed to be because they were too busy as they kept disappearing and telling me they would set up my antibiotic drip soon but took them hours to get round to it. I'm guessing this is due to understaffing issues. Thankfully my baby was fine despite not getting the proper amount of antibiotics. I have read stories of woman that were not so lucky, however, and have lost their babies from not receiving the proper antibiotics while in labour. It must be absolutely devastating for then to know it could have been avoided very easily! 18282014-02-09T08:39:58.1633920April CheyneStrongly agree 18282014-02-09T09:56:29.83921Jane GrayI only found out I had it as I had a car crash at 30 weeks and was bleeding .very lucky but other not so .\r\ndefinitely screen every pregnant women , we get screened for all most everything anyway ..18282014-02-09T10:25:40.53922Zoe WalpoleWith my first child I discovered I had Strep B when I was 36 weeks pregnant. It was on my notes that I had to be treated. When it came to me being in labour they didn't give me the antibiotics as they couldn't find the results that I had it. So they left me without anything until they eventually found the results and I was already pushing. They didn't give my son anything and assumed he would be ok. About 2 weeks later my son became very ill and wasn't breathing properly so went to the hospital straight away. We found out he had meningitis which caused his heart to dis function. We were sent to The Royal Brompton Hospital in Chelsea where he was cared for 4 weeks. Now 2 years on he is a happy wee boy and running crazy. If it wasn't for that hospital he would of died. So I agree with early screening for GBS! 18282014-02-09T19:54:37.73923Alan Taylor Hope all this helps you and good luck x18282014-02-09T20:18:34.5673924Victoria StubbsI had never heard of Group B Strep until my daughter was lying in the High Dependency Unit at the local hospital at 21 days old, and we were told she was shutting down. We were lucky, she survived, we have to raise awareness as many parents aren't so lucky18282014-02-09T20:26:05.1673925Wendy LangleyPlease screen for strep b now!!18282014-02-09T20:59:47.163926Tracy AlharahI strongly agree with this petition, every woman should be tested for strep b during pregnancy, I didn't know I had, it was only because I was spotting early during my pregnancy that they tested me for it, considering the serious implications that can happen every woman should know about this test. 18282014-02-09T21:15:19.43927Delli MackieEvery pregnant person has the right to be tested for Strep B.18282014-02-09T21:35:41.4273928Sybil MackieStrongly agree, every mum to be should be tested18282014-02-10T08:12:24.5173929Teresa listerIn loving memory of baby Ella Bella x18282014-02-10T11:01:31.033930Donna bryceDont have a comment as i think its a total discrace towards the NHS usual !x18282014-02-10T11:09:01.3173931Annmarie PearsonI found out 3 days after having my 3rd child that I am a carrier Fortunately my baby is Fine xx I belive all should be offerd a test xx18282014-02-10T11:41:03.893932emma patonevery 1 should be tested for strep b18282014-02-10T11:45:56.883933leanna stanley-wrightevery mum has a choice to try and protect her unborn baby. give here the choice and she will make sure her baby is safe. in memory of all babies lost, fighting or fought.18282014-02-10T12:24:27.0033934kirsteen hutchisonevery1 should b tested especially babies18282014-02-10T13:08:24.4273935Natalie FrostUK CALL TO ACTION! Please contact me on Facebook. I am calling on all mums, dads, nannies, granddads, aunties, uncles, cousins, ANYONE who has ever been affected by Group B Strep. I want to organise a parent conference for us to get together and discuss what we can do to change this. I do not believe that the statistics and information presented on GBS are correct and I would like us to do our own data collection. I lost my first and only baby, my daughter Ella Alma Frost on the 10th July 2011 during labour at 41 weeks 2 days. She died just 10 mins before her birth and as a result is NOT counted as part of the statistics for GBS. The consultant who told us what she had died from said that he didn't know a lot about it because it is so rare, and to look it up on the internet. He also said not to worry, next time I would automatically be given antibiotics during labour and everything would be fine. So we researched and discovered what this infection can cause, that it is preventable in the majority of cases AND that the majority of the world test for and act upon on the results, apparently our vagina's in the UK are different to other countries! Since this happened we have raised over 12,000 pounds for the charity Group B Strep Support, have appeared in our local paper in Portsmouth several times, spoken with our local MP and have been to the House of Commons for a presentation from the charity. Nothing has changed. More babies have died, become seriously ill and or permanently disabled or afflicted by it. I have spoken to other parents via social media and I know how much we all want this to change. I am of the opinion that the only way is for us to UNITE. Power comes in numbers and, as we are part of the worst club there is, I think we are more than strong enough to fight this. If you are interested in standing with me then please get in touch via Facebook. Together we will change this. With hope and hugs, Natalie Frost x18282014-02-10T13:22:47.273936Kaye SunderlandMy daughter caught late onset Step B she is now blind and has cerebral palsy. We were told by professionals that everything would be fine as I was having a c section and she would have a course of antibiotics at birth. Things are definitely not fine and Strep B is not something that should ever be taken lightly!! 18282014-02-10T14:41:37.1473938tricia I had this in both of my pregnancy's they said it would be very unlikely I could have it twice they didnt want to test my but Id kicked up a fuss and test results came back positive its awful they should test everyone! 18282014-02-10T15:39:56.8473939Lorraine Paton This test should be done for step b18282014-02-10T16:17:20.83940Yvonne AlexanderAs well as increasing the frequency, perhaps consider taking the price of the trains down also. This would increase the number of passengers to pay for the improvements to the track. I commute from Inverurie to Elgin 5 days a week and I'm cheaper taking my car than I am the train. This would also benefit the environment in a time where we are being pushed to be more environmentally friendly.19572014-02-10T16:21:44.053941P MI have moved down to Glasgow and still use the train to visit family at home in Elgin. I frequently experiance overcrowding on this line which ever direction I go due to the lack of proper service on this line. The waiting times for connecting trains is also dreadful. In the last 6 months alone I have had to find alternative means of getting home because the connecting train was sent away early leaving not just myself stranded in the station. 19572014-02-10T16:32:30.5933942Stuart JamesUntil there is in existance a credible integrated public transport system people wil continue to rely on their cars and thus there never can arise a strong enough market demand for buses and trains.\r\nThe service must be provided first and then the public will have an option to use that service it cannot happen the other way around.\r\nThe current unjoined-upness of our woefull public transport system is at best laughable and at worst a form of stupidity. Please look to Switzerland, Holland and Germany for examples of how to do it. ' Simples'19572014-02-10T16:48:22.743943Jane RossDue to the timings and the price of the service I do not rely on the service and take my car which is not very enviromentally friendly, however also works out cheaper. If the service was more frequent and cheaper more people may use it, making more services viable.19572014-02-10T17:06:24.7073944frustrated Elgin travellerI use this line frequently to get down to business meetings and family in the central belt and further south. It is ridiculous that it should take up to 5 hours journey time from Glasgow to Elgin-it is quicker to travel from Edinburgh to London. How do local politicians manage to travel down to Edinburgh efficiently? The trains are crowded at peak times and often have at least an hour to wait at Inverness or Aberdeen to go on to a connecting train. It is frustrating that they are considering reducing Edinburgh to Glasgow service times at a huge cost on a service which takes place every 15 mins. How are businesses in the north of Scotland supposed to work efficiently and use sustainable transport solutions if the infrastructure is outdated. There is no point criticising the high speed network down south when we cannot travel to the central belt in a reasonable time. Often connecting trains are not "held up" by a few minutes if a train coming from the south is slightly delayed and hence can lead to being stranded or an even longer journey.19572014-02-10T18:10:48.7073945Brenda SeatterThis line is past due for improvements. 19572014-02-10T20:11:58.7533946m g wellsI agree that the prices are also too steep, esp. Elgin return to Aberdeen19572014-02-10T20:12:59.5373947Alan PatonI commute between Elgin and Aberdeen by car because I can't afford to use the train.19572014-02-10T21:01:07.543948sharlene giffI agree all mothers should get this test i got my swab done in greenock maternity when my waters broke, got to paisly and by luck e results came in time for me to recieve antibiotics not all mothers get this dne, should be routine everywer.18282014-02-10T21:19:17.383949Eileen KellyEvery woman should be able to get tested18282014-02-10T22:06:21.583950Robert Dennis Soar Alba 19082014-02-11T09:58:31.0833952Margaret FlemingThis test needs to be made compulsory for all pregnant women. 18282014-02-11T10:47:21.2273953PaulineGood luck 18282014-02-11T12:17:05.733954HSMore carriages on all services & a carriage where ALL seats are NOT reserved would be a good idea.19572014-02-11T12:47:39.7933955GAIL MORE CARRIAGES ON THE WEEKEND 19572014-02-11T14:24:37.9773956Phil JacksonIt is vitally important not only to ring fence ASN but to bring funding back to at least where it was prior to the austerity cuts.19632014-02-11T14:37:44.743957cherylI had this and i gave birth before i found out. so no drip whilst in labour. thank fully my baby didnt get it. but it could of been worse. iv heard of a frends bby getting meningitus from it. id of been devistated. i had never heard of it during pregnancy. it needs to be more know18282014-02-11T17:05:11.7733958MichelleThis should be made available to all pregnant women, my granddaughter was born with meningitis strep b lucky for us she came through as she is a very strong little girl, please don't let other families go through the same please 18282014-02-11T18:32:11.2733959James WheeldonMy wife had this and it was only discovered by chance 18282014-02-11T19:52:41.073960Harriet NorthwayAll pregnant women need to be encouraged to have this important test.18282014-02-11T20:02:57.9633961Louise buckleWhy is it so hard to say yes to a vaccine that will help the future generations!!!!!! \r\nI'm sure if it happened to you, you would think twice!18282014-02-11T20:28:14.713962donaldH2 in england extra siding in scotland that sounds about right! 19572014-02-11T20:46:34.0533963HelenI had this and the hospital knew but didn't bother treating it,my baby is 2 weeks old and I was told today by a midwife that spotted it on the hospitals system,the hospital knew since October and it's February and no one had bothered to tell me or treat it so now it has me panicked and a health visitor is giving my baby a good check tomorrow I think this needs to tested on every woman who is pregnant even though I was tested and no one had bothered to inform me or treat it 18282014-02-11T21:28:46.3573964YVONNE BYRNEI had Strep B when I had my son. I was given intravenous antibiotics as soon as my waters broke and my son was born healthy. I had Strep B when I had my daughter but due to the incompetence of medical staff they didn't give me the antibiotics whilst in labour. My daughter was born with a rash which they treated as suspected meningitis. We stayed in hospital for a week while she was monitored and given antibiotics. It turned out that she was born with congenital CMV which caused the rash and deafness but still due to the staff not listening to my insistance I was in full labour she could well have contracted meningitis and the outcome could have been a lot worse18282014-02-11T23:42:28.2233965Claire huntI had gbs in my 3rd pregnancy I went on to have 3 more babies and had to have antibiotics Pryor to giving birth a test should be given to all woman I was lucky that the gbs was found 18282014-02-12T00:51:58.0273966KellyAny tests that may be able to detect an unborn child could potentially have any condition, whether life changing or not, should, in my eyes, be compulsory for any pregnant to under-go. The child, after all is the one who suffers the most if they are born with a disability. The sooner an abnormality is detected, the sooner the correct care and help could become available. 18282014-02-12T01:38:05.9373967emma deerymy daughter is due her first baby in 12days,she has strep b ,this test should be carried out on every pregnant woman.thankfully she will be able to get the antibiotics needed during labour.it should be made a compulsory to have this test 18282014-02-12T06:03:02.393968Julie Bonsall I was found to have this during my second pregnancy, and after researching the problems this could cause my baby I was disgusted that this test is not offered as routine!!! I was only given this test as I had problems during my pregnancy !!! 18282014-02-12T06:08:59.1073970donna whitakerI had strep b but did not know until I went into labour, I was put on a drip of antibiotics for four to five hours but my daughter ended up being born by c section. 18282014-02-12T08:20:35.2633971Jan Sissons We really shouldn't need to be doing this. It should be a standard test. It saves lives and potential tragedy to the families. 18282014-02-12T10:49:45.2733972AnonI have this bacteria, the nurse made me aware of it after I attended a sexual health screening. This bacteria is non-threatening to women who live with it but devastating to babies who contract it without any knowledge. 18282014-02-12T17:31:42.713973Lorraine MontgomeryGreat cause xx18282014-02-12T18:17:31.233974Laura This is something I didn't know about until it effected a friend of mine and sadly lost his daughter!! I have had 2 children , this is ridiculous we are not informed abt ths!!!!18282014-02-12T18:35:48.623975Aimee HoodBabys have died because of this 18282014-02-12T20:13:35.0233976ElaineThis test should be standard procedure18282014-02-12T21:04:41.43978jayne hattersleythis should be a common test for all pregnant woman i was lucky to get tested for it so had antibiotics during labour and my daughter had them to as soon has i had given birth,my friend wasnt tested and was a carrier she nearlly lost her child !18282014-02-12T21:52:31.7573979Victoria CrouchThis shouldn't be happening in this day and age, something needs to be done!18282014-02-12T22:15:21.963980Katy TraceyI have strep b I am 28 weeks found out very early though signs of thrush so glad I no x18282014-02-12T23:35:30.6233981MariaI had a temperature during labour. my baby was in distress and required forceps to turn her within the hour my baby was grunting and had a temperature.my baby needed iv antibiotics for a week In neonatal unit due to group b strep I was never tested during my pregnancy.i think this should b compulsory! this bacteria can lead onto meningitis.18282014-02-12T23:59:39.6633982Alana youngIts disgusting that we are having to petition for something that should be routinely tested for the parliament should be ashamed of themselves if they do not make changes to help save babies from a life threatening infection over 700 babies in the uk die each year after contracting this infection and i bet not one of these parents have a clue about STREP B its just a shame that my neice contracted this and we are having to go to this length to raise awareness and help save babies lifes something that the nhs should already be doing How much does a an extra piece of information cost as opposed to a babies life18282014-02-13T09:27:24.1733988kym In loving memory of my niece Lisa-leigh Xx18282014-02-13T09:27:25.2033989Georgina SmithPlease make the test compulsory, strep B is as bad as cot death and can be prevented. To be told hours after giving birth that your child could have strep B from you and that you have to wait seven days to see if they are in the clear and that a simple test and anti biotics during giving birth could have prevented the situation is horrific. Please dont ignore this and help.!18282014-02-13T13:48:48.5033990Larrissa DTurns out that I had Strep B when I had my little one. I'd never heard of it before. We both had to stay in hospital for 7 days on Antibiotics. It's heartbreaking seeing your baby being a pin cushion to needles :-( I agree, all women should be tested for Strep B. Its so important to raise awareness to it. 18282014-02-13T21:33:03.4573991Eric SmithNo more cuts for essentials.\r\n19632014-02-13T22:37:08.2873992kari dicksonBecause there are so many who need this support and because I see my friends who provide this support struggling to do so on the resources they have. So important.\r\n19632014-02-14T06:19:58.8473993Karen mcmillan Save our service19882014-02-14T06:51:49.3173994Charlie ClarkeThe biggest mistake you could make , local knowledge can't be replaced by GPS and technology19882014-02-14T07:31:04.1433995Marilyn WilsonThe special schools were closed to save money\r\nSpecial needs children need help if they are al expected to 'integrate' into a mainstream system!!19632014-02-14T08:17:13.6773996nicola murrayThese should remain local and provide an adequate service it isn't, or shouldn't always be about penny pinching.19882014-02-14T08:20:09.6273997Maureen ThomsonIf Scotland goes independent everything will go to the Central Belt. This is such a disgrace and an example of things moving already. Stop the decision to move our emergency centres NOW!!!19882014-02-14T08:20:34.1733998Jess BlackmoreIt is a ridiciulas and ill thought out proposal. Local knowledge of call centre staff is imperative to the service they provide and public safety.19882014-02-14T08:35:21.2373999G SmithThere is not enough police presence on the streets as it is. The local knowledge of call centre handlers is critical to ensuring emergency services can respond quickly.19882014-02-14T08:59:09.054000Jill BrebnerWorried that staff won't know local area if manned further south. 19882014-02-14T09:00:01.5074001Wendie DurrandPlease like and share!19882014-02-14T09:26:19.274002Dawn PriestWe need to save this centre19882014-02-14T09:46:28.84003Kim KingClosing this local service centre is putting lives in danger 19882014-02-14T10:07:48.414004Andrew StokesCentralisation of services may improve financial and service efficiencies, but as a country it creates problems elsewhere. If everyone does this, there will be no country left other than a centralised command and control centre.19882014-02-14T10:12:59.054005Clare TaylorAs a response police officer based in Peterhead I am very concerned about the closure of the Aberdeen control room and service centre. This will have a negative impact on public and officer safety.19882014-02-14T10:21:02.7834006Nicki WaltonThis is a very worrying idea. Gives the impression that those residing and employed in the central belt are in fact creating a them and us division within Scotland. Proves that they are not interested in the well being of anyone north of themselves, and are not concerned with our opinions either, disgraceful. 19882014-02-14T11:52:22.9574007Lorna DonaldWhen we became Police Scotland, we were not aware at the time that all main jobs were to go to Central Belt! 19882014-02-14T12:04:24.024008tracey dickie I had strep b with my 3 pregnancy 18282014-02-14T12:34:49.274009Shona CoullLosing all local knowledge is just ludicrous and bound to have a detrimental effect on the service provided by the emergency services. 19882014-02-14T13:08:58.744010Claire NotmanNeed to keep the local knowledge19882014-02-14T13:18:27.464011HeatherIn order to keep the people of Aberdeen safe, the service centre needs to stay in Aberdeen.19882014-02-14T13:40:12.5674012Sarah Keep the Aberdeen Control Room and Service Centre, local knowledge is key19882014-02-14T14:02:55.414013Chris JohnstonLocal knowledge is tantamount to delivering these services. It's quite obvious that nothing will exist north of the Central Belt if the SNP get their way.19882014-02-14T15:09:18.6934014Linda BurnettI have signed we lost our baby I was five months pregnant step b crossed the placenta and grew with her would love if everybody got tested that is having a baby so there more aware 18282014-02-14T15:14:09.2734015PaulineKeep the north of Scotland services where they'll best serve the north of Scotland! 19882014-02-14T15:45:39.3374016Alan cullingSomething so simple could save so many lives needs sorting!18282014-02-14T15:56:51.9874017Raymond Johnstonwe need centres in Aberdeen 19882014-02-14T15:59:44.784018Penny GilmourI think there are far too many cut these services are most importsnt19882014-02-14T16:03:54.2634022Revd. Andy AtkinsSomething so simple that could save on so much heart ache and pain.18282014-02-14T16:05:02.164023Georgina AdiePlease stop this centralisation of services. Scotland exists North of Stirling Mr Salmond. 19882014-02-14T16:14:22.8474024Andy McCaffertyThe Scottish government need to realise that the North of Scotland does exist and that Scotland doesn't end just north of Dundee19882014-02-14T16:25:36.5334025Fiona Hardieobviously there is nothing north of Dundee, take it the rest of us up north don't count19882014-02-14T16:26:24.3474026PaulineA bad decision, needs seriously looking at again and with public consultation! 19882014-02-14T16:28:29.084027Ann This is the start of a worrying trend of services being centralised and must be stopped before lives are put in danger!!19882014-02-14T16:29:19.6434028SheilaWith the oil and royalty, local knowledge is paramount and therefore we need our control rooms.19882014-02-14T17:14:56.664029Carol GroveKeep the Aberdeen Control Room and Service Centre, local knowledge is key for public and officer safety. It is ludicrous to close the best performing service centre to save money!19882014-02-14T17:16:43.4174030James GroveDoesn't make sense to close their best performing Service Centre and take Police off the front line in order to support administration. This can only result in a poorer service to the public and put Police safety at further risk.19882014-02-14T17:35:01.9674031Lorraine sandisonyou have to retain these centres, local knowledge and peoples livlihood, just because we are the oil capital doesnt mean you can get a job in oil. Maintain these local offices too much is biased around central belt 19882014-02-14T18:04:09.7374032DeeI had this with my first pregnancy and only found out when I was leaving to go home the midwife told me it was nothing to worry about yet standing in the passage with my newborn baby I spotted a poster about the dangers of it. Made my blood run cold. 18282014-02-14T18:10:13.374033Elaine Clunie Keep services local, local knowledge is paramount! No more cuts. 19882014-02-14T18:32:02.8634034Kerry BroughI had this with my son and didn't realise how serious it was thank god it was found and I had antibiotics during labour. 18282014-02-14T18:33:44.8834035christopher auldKeep the Aberdeen centre open19882014-02-14T18:35:49.8434036Eileen JonesHow ridiculous closing the Aberdeen call centre. This could cost lives.19882014-02-14T19:15:29.914037mark jarretlet's spend lots of money upgrading the fire and police call centres and close the 2 that need little investment. how prudent. no central belt bias there then!19882014-02-14T19:29:37.9574038Debbie AndersonGreat local knowledge and service going to be lost from the service centres and control rooms that are to close. 19882014-02-14T19:45:53.3934039christopher auldLeave the service centres open north of Dundee as if the centres close you loose all the local knowledge19882014-02-14T19:55:57.1474040Lorraine TaylorHow can Aberdeen be stripped of its identit by losing the Control room with it being the oil capital it just does not make any sense.19882014-02-14T19:59:27.9574041Jackie GauldThis cannot seriously happen!!! 19882014-02-14T20:46:19.6734042Kirsten HayShocking they are thinking of closing Aberdeen, especially being the oil capital. Utterly disgraceful! 19882014-02-14T20:55:14.34043Margaret MillerI think it's a little strange that next year we get to vote if we want an independent Scotland and I was against voting for it but know I'm beginning to change my mind, if the government wants to try anything out or cut money it always hits Scotland first because they treat us like guinea pigs in a laboratory, I think it's time the politicians took a wage cut and instead of closing call centres we could probably open more...politicians are paid to much to sit pushing a pen and making silly decisions like closing much needed call centres.19882014-02-14T20:58:39.0674044Suzie MooreSuch important work that is vital to support our young people. 19632014-02-14T21:23:47.2874045Neil Sutherland Pay off MPs, MSPs n councillors that'll save some money cos they do nothing apart from feather their own nests grrrr19882014-02-14T21:29:36.9134046Elaine KasparianIt is essential for the well being of the north of Scotland that the control room and service centre remain open 19882014-02-14T22:53:43.9774047Muriel AdamsThis must be a priority. Every child has a right to an education tailored to particular needs.19632014-02-14T23:08:32.6534048HANNIFFIA MCRATHNo more cuts to additional support for learning.19632014-02-14T23:36:19.754049Angela Purcell No more cuts in education! Children should have the best possible start in life and if they need extra support this should be made available to all kids that need support. 19632014-02-15T10:19:28.484050Arlene StewartDue to the geography of Scotland, it has many different 'nooks and crannies' and isolated areas which local knowledge can be crucial to assist emergency services. Often it is the staff in the local service centres and control rooms who have this local knowledge who can give, not only the emergency services staff, but also the public assistance and reassurance.19882014-02-15T11:37:12.4334051Michelle LowreyI didn't know I had it when I was pregnant, they told me out son had it as he had a very runny eye and we were lucky it wasn't in his blood stream. They monitored me closely with our daugther. I never knew this existed they should offer tests to pregnant women x 18282014-02-15T13:30:22.3934052lianneYour asking to much for so little. How are the forces to cope if you shut down the local stations. Its nice to know there is someone on the end of the phone who will know exactly where you are!19882014-02-15T13:31:54.3774053Hazel farquharUnfair people in the north need there own services Aberdeen is a big city and covers a lot in north.19882014-02-15T16:48:33.3174054Ron HughesIt is time the SPA carried out their remit to police the police service and get a grip on Steve House and his management team whose micro managent style will destroy the camaraderie and welfare of the Scottish police service.19882014-02-15T18:13:17.4774055Jean CraigIn an emergency local workforce will know the area and understand the local dialect, without this knowledge it could cause long delays in getting help to people and even cause fatality.19882014-02-15T19:25:31.6434056Morag MorrisonAs a member of Aberdeen Service Centre support staff, I obviously have a vested interest in keeping the Service Centre from closing, but I sincerely believe this to be a very poorly-made, shortsighted decision, which is only about cost-cutting, which cannot possibly best-serve the communities affected in the long-term, but rather is likely to have a detrimental effect on those communities' safety and welfare. It is imperative that public consultation is sought (should have been prior to the decision being made), and due consideration given to maintaining the quality of service which is currently delivered by Aberdeen Service Centre support staff. We have worked so hard to achieve the high standard we deliver, and do not deserve to be cast aside on a political whim.19882014-02-15T20:31:26.9374057Brian RobertsonDo people still think freezing council tax and business rates are a good idea given what is happening to all areas of public services ?19882014-02-16T10:16:26.3934058JohnTerrible 18282014-02-16T10:34:19.8274060Andrew BurnettIt is utter stupidity and criminal negligence to even think of closing Aberdeen. Dundee would be hopelessly inadequate to cover the needs and dialects of our area and the North.19882014-02-16T15:57:54.524061Rhona Strachanwe need centres north of Dundee19882014-02-16T19:36:41.094062Emily So very important more awareness and testing is needed 18282014-02-16T19:39:49.7534064Lindsay CairnsI lost by baby at 39 weeks, when my waters broke and I didn't know, letting the GBS through to her. She died hours before she was born. \r\nThe first I heard of Group B Strep was when it came back on her post mortem results. \r\nMore needs to be done to raise awareness and inform pregnant ladies about Group B Strep. 18282014-02-16T19:52:35.044065HelenI had B Strep and had antibiotics in labour and got lovely Baby boy Theo. Only got tested due to discomfort down left side and urine sent to lab...if it was not that I had discomfort I would never have known and could have been a different story. UK should routinely test ALL pregnant women.18282014-02-16T19:58:57.6074066Kerry KeenanMy newborn girl has just been discharged from hospital after 2 weeks of intense drugs after strep b. She was a late onset - 10days old & not very pleasant to witness.18282014-02-16T20:04:40.6074067Derek MilliganThe call centres of the emergency services should be based locally 19882014-02-16T20:07:27.1234070Gemma phillipsIn support18282014-02-16T20:25:37.1734071Mrs Clare Joyce DoigAberdeenshire emergencies should surely be dealt with in Aberdeen? Local knowledge is very important when dealing with distressed people in situations where lives are in danger.19882014-02-16T20:36:44.3374072abbie grovesI had this it during my pregnancy. My son never caught it but it played up during labour making me really ill18282014-02-16T21:08:42.8634073Maria CookMy beautiful baby was born asleep 15 years ago! This simple test would of prevented it then and still we are not testing!! 18282014-02-16T21:36:37.2834074TL AndersonLocal knowledge is so important to the ongoing success of our services. Safety needs to be prioritised over cost cutting. 19882014-02-16T22:05:15.124075Charles McPhersonLocal knowledge and understanding accents is of vital importance in emergency situations19882014-02-16T22:09:30.724076Raymond BurgessScotland exists outside the central belt. Please don't make the mistakes that Westminster has and centralise everything. 19882014-02-16T22:52:49.584077Heather BurgessPlease support our emergency services.19882014-02-16T23:02:11.424078DawnWorking in a wide area of the Northeast I come across many different dialects. I struggle to always make them out & am from the North East. Also loss of local knowledge will be critical when trying to guide emergency services to the right areas & may cost lives... Cannot believe that highly proficient service is being pulled out of such a large area.Can only qoute central belt bias once again.19882014-02-16T23:36:23.3774079BernadetteI had this with my fourth pregnancy and never heard of it before. My baby was born healthy but we stated over night in hospital 18282014-02-17T00:44:23.6434080Barbara BellMy daughter carries strep B too late for my first grandson who is now left brain damaged but my second grandchild a girl is fine due to having the antibiotics everyone should be tested too many babies are dying or left disabled still people have never heard of it it's not right 18282014-02-17T05:00:34.1434081Jenny StrachanI think it is a disgrace that Aberdeen and local areas are to lose their Police Fire and other Non emergancy services.Scotland doesnt stop at Edinburgh and Glasgow and we have the same problems as everyone else,also as someone pointed out how is someone in Glasgow going to know where to send a fire engine when they cant even pronounce the Scottish names,are we to wait till our houses burn down while waiting for them to figure out where we are,shame on you for closing these services!!!!!!!\r\n19882014-02-17T06:38:21.794082GaynorDisgrace to close 19882014-02-17T09:56:21.4234083Rachel LittleThe emergency service in Aberdeen do a fantastic job and unfortunately it maybe too late before many of the general public realise this. I truly hope we can save our Aberdeen service. 19882014-02-17T10:17:56.7534084Gundula Sharmancan't be rocket science to work out that local help is better for the local community. 19882014-02-17T10:35:39.9874085janis cardnovery concerned about this this should not be happening it needs to be kept if this goes ahead it will be a disaster waiting to happen Mike&Janis Cardno19882014-02-17T11:12:48.5134086Sue StocktonThis is all a cost cutting exercise and nothing about making an already highly efficient service better. It is only a matter of time before these emergency arrives are brought to their knees and the public are put in danger. 19882014-02-17T11:37:53.5334087A FyfeRidiculous to close the Aberdeen centre and the Inverness one for that matter. Just stupid ! 19882014-02-17T14:12:12.454088Judith BarkerYet another stupid idea to make me think that an Independent Scotland is a farce .. 19882014-02-17T15:16:32.6574089Fiona SimpsonEmergency Centres must remain in the areas they serve as extensive experience and detailed knowledge of the area in which an individual Centre operates is essential to provide a fast, efficient and effective response.19882014-02-17T15:27:33.5534090Keith macMillanCost cutting at the expense of another public service we cannot do without. I cannot see the sense of trying to control essential services from the central belt. 19882014-02-17T15:38:29.5174091Craig McGrattanAbsolute disgrace 19882014-02-17T16:31:35.024092Kirsty WhyteWe need this service to continue. 19882014-02-17T17:23:39.2234093Phil MurrayLocal expertise and knowledge cannot be lost. All work to review position gas been carried out with clear bias against NE of Scotland. 19882014-02-17T17:26:15.0834095Bill ArchibaldAberdeen and surrounding area is served by a call centre recognised as being very successful. Why close it and pay money to upgrade elsewhere that will not deliver that quality of service?19882014-02-17T18:18:55.2734096Kenneth MackieJust what we expect from SNP government, only interested in central belt. We need controllers who understand the local dialect.19882014-02-17T18:34:49.4974097Alexander SouterOnce again common sense has failed to prevail. Take an existing functioning control room disband it and move it to Dundee. Just another example of devolving power to the Central belt. DUNDEE THE FURTHEST north control in Scotland. We have Police in Glasgow that believe that the train runs north to Shetland !19882014-02-17T18:36:57.874098Mhairi JarvieIt's vital to public safety to keep these control rooms local!!19882014-02-17T18:43:09.6334099Ian ThomsonKeep the local knowledge local retain Aberdeen save money but not upgrading Dundee19882014-02-17T18:49:26.24100Jon SmithSNP will do anything to increase their voter base in the Central belt.19882014-02-17T18:52:44.3174101Doris websterClosure is ridiculous !!19882014-02-17T19:19:38.9974102Donald BoydVery poor decision which has not been thought through 19882014-02-17T19:27:47.794103Bill CowieDoes an operator in Dundee know where Crichie, Foggie, Fishie or Broch are, to name but a few.19882014-02-17T19:34:07.664104William CormackAnother cost cutting measure which will cost us a\r\nfortune19882014-02-17T19:38:52.014106Alexander WatsonThe SNP claim rule from Westminster. The SNP already do not care about the north and north east. It is all about Central Belt. When ast did they do something positive about Aberdeen and beyond. I thought the First minister had his roots here. He has been bought over!!!19882014-02-17T20:01:06.1674107Claire Ann CushnieYou cant cut back on such a valuable and badly needed service in the North of Scotland. 19882014-02-17T20:10:11.1934108Kevin HeatlyWhy get rid of the original service centre and the only one which is actually accredited. They perform to the highest standard and continually produce the goods. Kenny McCaskill said they were what other centres should aim to be what has changed, shame on you mcCaskill- two faced say something mean another who could possibly trust you19882014-02-17T20:10:53.0374109Gordon SimpsonAberdeen - Scotland's third largest city with no Police or Fire control centre, absolutely ridiculous.19882014-02-17T20:19:49.34110Leanne TsuiPlease change this law! 18282014-02-17T20:47:28.624111Charles DonaldWith the Royalty in Deeside, Oil Industry serviced from Aberdeen and local Airport a Control Room in Aberdeen is a must.19882014-02-17T21:39:11.754112Rona BoydTo lose Police Control Room staff (sadly) experienced in many offshore major incidents as well as having vital local knowledge for dealing with onshore emergencies is both short sighted & wrong. But as long as the Central Belt is covered!! 19882014-02-17T21:43:02.44113Francis WatsonShort changed again\r\n19882014-02-17T21:47:12.6834114Tom McLennanThis would leave the North of Scotland out on a limb!19882014-02-17T21:53:07.54115Rona InschWe need to retain local knowledge. 19882014-02-17T21:54:12.644116Ian MenziesIt's all about local knowledge, and that isn't possible\r\nfrom a remote area.19882014-02-17T22:45:18.7834117Derek PickthallIf you remove local contact you are removing local and district knowledge which are essential with local issues, whether crime or minor incidents. I think this is a very poor decision and as usual is finance driven as always and not for the good of the community that is served by the present dedicated teams.19882014-02-18T00:41:22.7574118Dave MilneHow can a devolved government justify centralisation of services without undermining its reason for being?\r\n19882014-02-18T01:19:38.3074119Hazel ThompsonHaving worked in a Police Control room for 24 years believe me you do need local knowledge, not only about the local characters but the area - it does save lives, 19882014-02-18T06:23:16.9034120James Mackay BeattieAlready I have had a report of an ambulance call where the person making the call was asked "Where is Union Street?"\r\n"Aberdeen".\r\n"OH, Aberdeen"\r\nLocal knowledge is essential.19882014-02-18T07:09:01.4874121Heather Schofieldwhy do you want to spend more money on doing up dundee when we have an adequate one here in Aberdeen . And Once again it is just wasting money that could be used for other much needed projects.19882014-02-18T08:55:22.6274122Ian McAllisterAbsolutely ridiculous idea to relocate this service away from Aberdeen. Pay attention people, this is the type of political thing which will be common place in an independant scotland. Better off with Westminster! While they are equally stupid, at least they dont differentiate between the north of scotland and the central belt19882014-02-18T11:49:49.684123GeoffNot a warrior or a politician. Definitely not a saint but a man, a farmer, an excise man, a passionate and compassionate man. Our national bard, born less than 10 miles from the Robert Burns International, Prestwick Airport. Put him on the international map!!19082014-02-18T12:15:54.264124Mrs SutherlandInstead of cost cutting measures in Aberdeen, why not cut the roles of some of the pen pushers in the central belt! We need these services!19882014-02-18T12:37:52.6074125George PatersonAnother ill- conceived and unjustified attack on our emergency services.19882014-02-18T12:38:39.7734126Brenda BrownAbsolutely essential that these centres remain local to the area .Full knowledge of the area is paramount in an emergency situation. Aberdeen, as the "Oil Capital of Europe" & 3rd largest city in Scotland should have full access to immediate city-based emergency centres. Ludicrous, dangerous & life-threatening to think otherwise. 19882014-02-18T12:46:46.514127Joyce C FarquharBeing Governed by the Central Belt is no different from being Governed by London. Scotland stills needs to be regional. STOP DESTROYING OUR EMERGENCY SERVICES. I can see a new postcode appearing, instead of AB it will be EH19882014-02-18T14:03:06.0574128David Smith Another example of doing this without any trials of the new so called control rooms and other centers actually working and showing what they can and can't do. They are positioned well out of the areas they are supposed to be serving and this will cause more delay in respo nding to everything because instead of one communication to get one thing done it will involve several layers to get the message to where it is meant to be going... 19882014-02-18T14:07:51.6334129Margaret CruickshankThe older I get the more exasperated I become by all government activities, most of which are ill conceived and badly prepared, and the affect on you and I ( Joe Public) barely considered,\r\n I wonder why I am considering giving up my right to vote, I am beginning to wonder if people in power really listen to us at all.\r\nFor years I have believed that government has been hellbent on centralising all services,trouble is most of it hasn't benifited the vast majority of us.\r\nAs far as I am concerned moving our emergency calling centre from Aberdeen to Dundee, will end up in happenings that all of us will live to regret these actions.19882014-02-18T15:35:55.9934130Lawrence DeansI think local knowledge and the ability to understand local language accents is a very important reason for keeping local control rooms open19992014-02-18T15:36:05.8074131Andy GardinerLocal knowledge for local people 19992014-02-18T15:37:34.7434132Pauline. BainToo much at risk19992014-02-18T15:39:02.2374133DerekThis is only the start. Policing in the north of Scotland is slowly but steadily being destroyed.19882014-02-18T15:39:56.134134Lewis MacLennanSave the Inverness Control Room and safeguard the Highlands and Islands.19992014-02-18T15:48:49.74135Karla StevensonComputers cannot replicate local knowledge or understand different dialects or pronunciations of place names. Local knowledge is vital for the safety of people in the highlands & islands!19992014-02-18T15:54:29.584136Debbie NicolSigned and shared.19992014-02-18T15:59:16.414137Lawrence DeansI think local geographical knowledge and the ability to understand local language accents are vitally important in real time life saving operations. This knowledge and ability to translate information is lost with the closing of local control rooms. 19992014-02-18T16:01:49.214138Andrew DallasLet's keep the Highlands safe and stop the relentless centralisation of the Fire Service in Scotland! Leave our Fire control where it belongs!19992014-02-18T16:04:13.4734139Neil RossThis service covers an area larger than Belgium, and with the longest coastline, highest mountains in Scotland, is a truly unique area which NEEDS its own control rooms.19992014-02-18T16:04:15.2074140David MacartneyScotland involves a lot more than just the central belt. Prove that everyone's safety matters and keep the control room open in Inverness!19992014-02-18T16:04:38.9474141Shiona MartinThe Highlands and Islands are a geographical nightmare and that's only for those who have knowledge of the area, imagine the loss to lives if those handling the calls have 'NO' local geographical knowledge. 19992014-02-18T16:05:53.0234142Roger BindingThe loss of local knowledge will cause delays and increase the risk of injury and death to service users as soon as this badly thought out decision is implemented. 19992014-02-18T16:06:26.9134143Flora SumervilleI don't believe that removing control from the Highlands will do anything but cost lives.19992014-02-18T16:12:32.5874144colin couparSigned and shared.19992014-02-18T16:19:17.7734145Mary StewartLocal knowledge is vital for fast response times and the saving of lives19992014-02-18T16:19:53.624146Allan MorrisonHelp protect the highlands and island s fire control fire fighters rely on getting to incident as quickly as possible inverness control room has all local knowledge required to get nearest appliance there 19992014-02-18T16:29:54.824147Nicola McVeanLocal knowledge is vital, save the Highlands Control Room.19992014-02-18T16:33:48.944148robina macgregorSigned and will share19992014-02-18T16:39:39.0874149Annelouise campbellSigned & shared19992014-02-18T16:43:56.6034150Fiona JonesLocal knowledge in a geographical area such as the Highlands is vital in providing an emergency service effectively.19992014-02-18T16:44:59.514151Christine WoodIt beggar's belief that this could even be considered. Weather conditions can affect computer signals - what happens then? Scotland is bigger than the Central belt though you'd never know it!19992014-02-18T16:45:11.7134152derick murchisonI know first hand how rural this brigade is, HQ is based in the city. The population they look after is scattered over a very large area. Local knowledge is a must, not some far away control room (no disrespect). KEEP IT LOCAL,KEEP US SAFE.\r\n19992014-02-18T16:46:29.4474153Ruth LeslieI would like to know when Aberdeen became a second class city. According to the things the government do to us it appears that this is indeed the case.19882014-02-18T16:46:31.1834154John campbellShared safe Inverness control room 19992014-02-18T16:46:35.684155Alan GowansLocal knowledge is so vital in this area,It cannot be replaced by having it stuck away down in Dundee!!!..The folk down there couldn't even pronounce some of the places properly!19992014-02-18T16:51:42.5574156Jackie MackenzieThe Highland and Island communities deserve the same access to a "tried and tested model" to quote SFRS managers as the Central belt does, Inverness Fire Control is a quality tried and tested model - leave it alone!19992014-02-18T16:53:36.8834157Evelyn StaffordLocal knowledge is essential in situations where life is at risk and the person making the emergency call is in a highly agitated and excited state. Local dialects are also difficult to understand and are exaggerated even more on the phone. Vital time is lost trying to pin down where someone is. Once local knowledge and experience goes it cannot be replaced.19992014-02-18T16:54:28.6034158Stuart EdwardsSave the Inverness control room it is the way forward.19992014-02-18T16:59:00.684159Sean cameronIt a must for the highlands & islands19992014-02-18T17:00:31.2974160Dawn MaclennanThe Highlands and Islands cover a large area how is a computer going to understand place names and dialect. local knowledge is vital. Save our Control Rooms.19992014-02-18T17:03:58.864161Jim MacfarlaneIt would be a disgrace if it were to close, the Highland & Islands needs the knowledge for the Firefighters to attend remote areas...19992014-02-18T17:04:03.9234162Alexander MurraySave the fire contolroom in inverness.if this contolroom should close it will cost lives.19992014-02-18T17:12:25.8534163Paul YoungStop centralising public service jobs. Jobs for the highlands.19992014-02-18T17:13:14.714164Nigel Newell5 minutes to late because the operator does'nt know the area who's to blame...19992014-02-18T17:16:35.8974165Ian HallamThere is no way of having local knowledge of such a huge area when emergency services are being controlled from the central belt19992014-02-18T17:22:21.574166A JLocal knowledge and expertise are essential to ensure that both the communities living within the Highlands, and those millions that visit each year to experience some of the best scenery in the world are in safe hands.\r\n19992014-02-18T17:23:21.94167Ian SmithThe area and crews will struggle during busy periods, like the wildfire season.When through local knowledge and experience our control staff are able to move resources to where they are required. Rapport with local RDS crews will also be lost and goodwill from the crews stretched. 19992014-02-18T17:24:30.0574168Rhona RamsayAs a citizen of the Grampian Region, and a former Service Centre Advisor, I find the idea of 101 calls being answered in Motherwell absolutely appalling. Aberdeen's Service Centre is the flagship model for the whole of Scotland, being rhe only accredited centre. How the standards will be improved by losing the knowledge and expertise of the staff who work both in the Service Centre andcthe contol room is beyond me. Just a ridiculous exercise, with no gain other than to the local economies of the central belt...surprise surprise! 19882014-02-18T17:27:29.0274169Albert mcivorToo not have a control room in Inverness which covers the same area size as Belgium geographically is absolutely ludicrous & disgraceful and seriously putting peoples lives at risk.Why they have to centralise 3 control rooms so close looks awfully a one sided decision.19992014-02-18T17:30:49.7274170Eilidh MckenzieSigned and shared19992014-02-18T17:35:36.9274171brian cameron for the good of the highlands local knowledge can be a life saver19992014-02-18T17:46:42.794172charlotte leysThe closure of Aberdeen leaves one feeling unsafe and vulnerable. Just what are we paying our taxes for? 19882014-02-18T17:47:49.8674173james airdLocal Knowledge could save time and lives. 19992014-02-18T17:48:44.1334174Helen Stuartthey there has been consultation, i would like to hear from anyone who has been consulted!!! 19882014-02-18T17:57:57.44175Alastair KeldayYou can not beat many years of local knowledge. No computer system is capable of this.19992014-02-18T17:59:40.7774176Shona BainLocal knowledge of area vital when directing to an emergency. 19992014-02-18T18:19:19.7274177Julia McNeil A disgrace to even think about closing Invernrss fire control - the knowledge and skills of these people save lives every day \r\nKeep it in the Highlands please 19992014-02-18T18:25:15.684178Graham MackenzieLocal knowledge crucial when lives are at risk.19992014-02-18T18:30:25.824179Gary WilliamsThe Scottish Government harp on about Westminster bias in their dealings with the UK govt. as far as I can see this is bias but in Scotland with the southern regions being the winners. The cynic in me says that it is an attempt to buy support in those areas retaining their contact centres. The realist in me says that the SNP are risking their core vote by attempting to harvest the west coast vote. This will backfire spectacularly. Surely they should be looking after their core supporters first. That has certainly been the history of non SNP governments. Rethinking all my voting intentions as a result of this.19882014-02-18T18:31:23.1674180Laura Roy Signed and shared, 19992014-02-18T18:36:17.3634181Thomas WhyteTypical of Scottish government,they say its up to the police to make the decisions on how they decide where and where not to close.Don't they realise that it is our money they are spending and they should at least look at the most cost effective way of dealing with this matter.Typical of SNP.keep everything in the central belt19882014-02-18T18:39:38.264182Mhairi SturrockWe all know that the Highlands are complex with an abundance of minor roads all over, so, we need someone with great local knowlege!! Please, get signing this petition!!19992014-02-18T18:40:46.24183Ryan RaymondIts not just the local knowledge that needs to stay up in Inverness its the people who work there, they do a great job directing the crews and giving them the information they need. They are like the mums and dad of the crews and to be able to speak to someone on the end of the radio makes the job a while lot easier! They are a vital part of our crews out in the field and the eyes and ears for us too. To get rid of Inverness will be like putting the crees up for adoption!!!! 19992014-02-18T19:04:41.1534184greig flemingshould leave valuable stations alone and leave whats best for the highlands and surrounding communities.19992014-02-18T19:07:21.454185C ReidSad times and bad decision if no local call centres cover Aberdeen and the North East. Scotland covers more than the Central Belt!19882014-02-18T19:21:06.4874186Robert Scott MacleodI have recently left the fire service within Inverness retained, and I would like to stress that the knowledge of the workers with regards to who to mobilise to certain insidents cannot be matched or taught. The entire area of the Highlands has now got a diminished service due to closures of stations that were supplying a valuable service. This has in my opinion put lives of Rural Highland residents at risk due to increased turn out times. This can and should be seriously debated and take the input of the residents to the debate . 19992014-02-18T19:23:01.294187SteveThe start of cuts and moving everything to the Central belt. This is a step backwards19882014-02-18T19:27:20.3474188Karen ColtartA very important part of our emergency services, cannot let this close19992014-02-18T19:30:20.574189Robert McKinneyAnother wrong step by the SNP! The must really want to lose the referendum and 2015 election!19882014-02-18T19:32:45.5574190Linnie quailSigned 19992014-02-18T19:42:31.184191Pamela BurnsHaving working knowledge of communicating with automated or central call centres I witness the problems with locality on a daily basis...not life threatening but a constant reminder as to the importance of trained local emergency response teams with a sound knowledge of the area the serve.19992014-02-18T20:04:28.94192Martin MackennaPlease don't take this valuable resource & mobilising location away from the highlands. 19992014-02-18T20:07:30.1334193Pierre Veuger, station commander ret.Do not loose local people in the control room. Real locals know a lot about local specialities, like nicknames for areas, names of farms etc.\r\nThis is lost with large areas-controlrooms. 19992014-02-18T20:08:19.0274194Michael BryantLocal knowledge is vital, this comes from our control room staff. They understanding the different dialects, they have knowledge and understanding of the Highlands and its single track roads, and they know the Highland areas, many with similar place names but miles apart. They manage incidents, they do not just answer calls!19992014-02-18T20:08:49.1974195Brian youngLocal knowledge is a great benefit to the control rooms , don't take that away , lives will be at risk 19992014-02-18T20:12:52.5274196Brian SpenceNot in the best interests for the highlands 19992014-02-18T20:18:06.4134197Mike RenwickAs a currently serving Firefighter in Dingwall and the surrounding area, I feel very strongly, and know, that this really is a backward step. Anyway sensible person can surely realise that reducing Fire control rooms by any measure is increasing the risk to the public. 19992014-02-18T20:22:13.9774198jill CruickshankAberdeen is supposed to be the oil capital of Europe. A vibrant , proud, multicultural city and it won't be able to care properly for its vulnerable because of some naive, conceited politician who can see no further than Dundee. Dundee for gods sake!!!!!!!\r\n19882014-02-18T20:24:10.2274199Lesley Matheson Who will have to die as a result of the local knowledge being lost in the closure of this control room? We must keep it open, it's so very very wrong to let it slip away without fighting.19992014-02-18T20:37:24.1334200Eric RaeThe decision to close the Aberdeen centre is a classic case of asset-stripping and typical of the way the North-east of Scotland has been treated by the Scottish Government since devolution, and will be even worse should we get an independent Scottish Government19882014-02-18T20:56:31.6274201Hilary JohnstonSigned in support for Inverness even though I stay in Dumfries. I have family in Inverness therefore I would like to think that should any of my relations should need the Emeegency services thatvtye person in the end of the phone would have local knowledge to be able to assist them quickly and safely. 19992014-02-18T21:06:42.8374203Moyra JossRidiculous that Dundee chosen for 3rd emergency call centre19882014-02-18T21:07:34.464204irene williamsonwe need to keep the local knowledge built up over years.19992014-02-18T21:35:44.824205Terri FlemingShared & signed19992014-02-18T21:46:09.6674206Jackie McCabeI cannot believe computer's would replace human beings responding to what would be a frightening and dangerous time.. shocking\r\n19992014-02-18T22:21:31.154207Evelyn RobertsonFrom what is happening to the call centres in the Aberdeen area it appears we have exchanged one centralised government for another. This area is being ignored by the Scottish government but they are quick to demand money engendered in this area. We have been underfunded by governments of all parties both for local council and NHS - time the people of this area let our voices be heard - we are fed-up being ignored. I hope your petition is successful, it deserves to be - remind the powers that be that there are some or the population live north of Dundee - a fact they seem to have forgotten - OFTEN!!!!!!19882014-02-18T22:21:32.464208jack bryantSee sense and keep the station, inverness is growing constantly! It needs the control room!19992014-02-18T22:31:42.1534209James petrieSave this lifeline service!!19992014-02-18T22:33:19.074210Eric RobertsonCentral Belt bias has never been more obvious and the closure of our call centres is symptomatic of the mind set of this Government. All monies are allocated with the central belt well-being their main concern. Why would you close a up and running modern call centre and have to spend a large amount updating Dundee - and why did the cost of upgrading Dundee suddenly drop by £3 million ? - to make the move sound less stupid? The SNP politicians might like to consider that the people of this area are unlikely to forget the considerable amount of snubs they have inflicted on us.19882014-02-18T22:39:04.8834211Mervyn walkerLocal knowledge is a great asset 19992014-02-18T23:11:39.124212Alistair PantonGood luck19992014-02-18T23:19:15.5134213Malcolm HannahPlease members of the public you have to support this before we see loss of life.Support the control room in the Highlands 19992014-02-18T23:24:22.54214Gary Anderson Save the backbone of the Highlands and Islands fire service and the now Scottish fire service.19992014-02-18T23:47:37.3074215Sandra willoxPolice answering calls NEED local knowledge 19882014-02-18T23:52:20.54216Christina MaclellanPlease please please Do not close the Inverness Fire control Room.They know all the area names and the geographical area,other control rooms Don't and therefore will not respond as fast to send to sending out fire crews resulting in the loss of lives in our areas.Please please think again and DO NOT CLOSE INVERNESS FIRE CONTROL ROOM !19992014-02-19T00:05:55.2434217Lynda Rowan-O'NeillSigned and shared19992014-02-19T00:13:45.324219Brian CummingWe all know cuts are necessay, but Grampian Police have a wealth if knowledge and experience in a unique are(Oil, Royal Protection) and a large population. No- one in Dundee will find the Back o' Bennachie in an emergency sitting in Dundee19882014-02-19T00:19:30.5874220chris caselyToo much local knowledge will be lost for the Highlands. 19992014-02-19T00:35:12.8374222Paul DunnettI am a local taxi driver and know how much local knowledge can make a difference to how long journeys would take and how many places with similar names need local knowledge to determine19992014-02-19T01:33:13.1034223Susan MitchellVery dangerous, it is essential. Would be a terrible thing if someone died because of it.19992014-02-19T01:36:43.3134224neil mutchcant believe this can happen for the sake of common sense this control room has to stay19992014-02-19T03:22:05.8734225John SmithAs a former firefighter, and resident of the Highlands, I understand the importance of local knowledge and local controllers in responding to an emergency. I urge parliament to reject the proposal to close ANY of the fire control centres in Scotland, and to make every effort to protect and preserve life and property in our communities.19992014-02-19T07:15:40.4574226Mairi DingwallSigned and shared19992014-02-19T07:38:474227myra brownwe need it 19992014-02-19T07:38:54.7974228jan mackenzie Signed 19992014-02-19T07:41:57.914229Paul DinneenSave the Inverness Control Room19992014-02-19T07:49:49.484230Darren muirOrkney19992014-02-19T08:01:19.5634231Niall inglisAs an ex retained fire fighter on the isle of skye the information Inverness control room provided us with was vital and I do not believe it would be in the best interests of any resident in the Highlands and Islands for the control room to be closed. As previously been stated, a computer cannot replicate local knowledge!19992014-02-19T08:03:50.5334233Jimmy GeddesA bheil gaelic agaibh, is some controller down south going to understand this question? Lives are going to be lost!19992014-02-19T08:11:52.3674234Fraser TaylorThere is life after perth19992014-02-19T08:12:14.4274235Angela GunnSave Inverness Control Room !!19992014-02-19T08:16:15.4234236Melanie HillinIt's should remain open for the safety of inverness and surrounding areas.19992014-02-19T08:58:34.6274237Julie WoodI so hope this petition works. The emergency services are getting shafted so much I know as I am in the Police and the cuts we have suffered are intolerable. 19992014-02-19T09:04:42.194238Tony McDowellPlease save this highland asset, it is much needed and not replaceable by control room in the Central belt. 19992014-02-19T09:16:24.864239Linda McDermott Local knowledge by a local Control Room to serve the local community... This information cannot be just handed over it is gained over years 19992014-02-19T09:19:13.3774240Chris NewI am a fire fighter with 30 years experience and have been a New Zealand Chief Fire Officer for 12 years.\r\nHere in NZ we did what is happening in Scotland and I have found the centralised controllers do not have a good sense for the geography of distant areas. We also have communication problems with tourists an new New Zealanders. Over all I don't think it is a great idea to centralise just to save money. You must think of the people you serve19992014-02-19T09:47:20.974241Jacqui HumeLocal knowledge is significant even more so in this geographical area. Keep the control room and don't put lives at risk. 19992014-02-19T10:04:24.14242Kathryn HunterIf you limit the call centres, be prepared for somethig massive to happen that you can't deal with, with your limited resources, because you need everyone you have! By limiting the areas of call centres you are putting yourself at a disadvantage, do Dundonians speak Doric? No. Will they understand people from the coast and the country? I highly doubt it! 19882014-02-19T10:08:10.5334243Jane MacLeanThere were problems before when the local control rooms were centralised to Inverness. What chance have the Highlands got without 'local' knowledge ? 19992014-02-19T10:32:06.334244Karin ThompsonLocal knowledge will save lives. 19992014-02-19T10:49:07.2874245Allan YoungAll through Fire Reform we have heard about the decentralisation of the Fire and Rescue Service. Surely moving all Control Rooms to the Central belt is centralisation. If the decision was made comparing apples with apples then that would be more acceptable however this would appear to be a decision based on the desires of individuals and not common sense nor indeed for the outcomes for rural communities. It would appear the decision making process is flawed, not in the best interests of providing an effective Fire and Rescue Service to the WHOLE of Scotland and really does need to be reviewed. If Mr Salmond is serious about independence he needs to start taking the Highlands and Islands seriously as they also have a vote.19992014-02-19T11:09:26.7674246Dawn ForrestThose that think local knowledge is no longer needed due to advances in technology are making a huge mistake. I do this job for a living in a control room that was made up of 5 smaller ones several years ago and It is commonplace for personnel use their knowledge of their respective home towns to gain accurate incident location details. Don't leave the North without this local knowledge.19992014-02-19T11:45:53.644247sandy grayLocal knowledge is paramount to quick response and in turn will save life and property. This is just another Scottish Government notion to centralise all public bodies.\r\n 19992014-02-19T11:50:42.9574248CJMore carriages at all times. When there is a shortage ensure that the Inverurie - Inverness route is given the greater number of carriages, rather than the return service to Aberdeen from Inverurie. Rolling stock is old and in need of replacement, problems or faults seem to be weekly at the moment.19572014-02-19T12:05:32.374249Elizabeth IrvineWith the duplication of many Highland and Island names and all the Gaelic names, local knowledge is a key factor in ensuring accurate deployment. 19992014-02-19T12:24:27.0934250Linda GattOperators need to understand what we are saying south of Dundee may struggle to understand our dialect. Plus they need local knowledge19882014-02-19T13:13:17.8434251MargotFor me, as an incomer to this area, for me the main issue is that it has taken me more than 10 years to understand the various county accents in this area.\r\nI don't doubt that the actual dispatching can be done anywhere with our lovely technology, but when the technology fails, or more so, when trying to understand quickly a panicked Doric accent over the phone, is why we need these services to be retained locally in every area, not just Aberdeenshire.19882014-02-19T14:35:45.54252Jim McPhersonIf the system is not broken, why try to fix it ?.\r\nThis is purely about cost cutting.\r\nIf, God forbid, someone dies because of these changes, who will be held to account ?.19882014-02-19T15:21:16.4074253Edna BoothIt is an absolute disgrace that these services are being cut and all the local knowledge lost. This is a prime example of the Scottish Gov. and its continued central belt bias.19882014-02-19T16:47:33.134254Alastair RitchieIt would be a disaster if local knowledge was lost with the proposed closure of the control rooms.for a small cost saving.puting lives at risk.19882014-02-19T18:33:28.0434255Juliet JohnstonWe need the control room here in the highlands local know age is so important19992014-02-19T18:45:55.754256janine brownPlease save Inverness fire police and ambulance control rooms thank you 19992014-02-19T19:57:00.0974257RubyA handful of passengers at Inverurie given priority to travel to Aberdeen over dozens of passengers travelling to Inverness -ridiculous!!! More coaches -now.19572014-02-19T20:10:08.6974258Miriam MacDonaldNo other part of the country can possibly understand the geographical impact on our service. 19992014-02-19T21:53:41.744259Anna TempletonI also use my car as the prices are so high19572014-02-19T22:19:06.5474260Jim WatsonI feel very strong, that our Police and Fire control rooms are not based in Aberdeen, I read today 19-2-14 that Police calls will be handled in, Glasgow, Motherwell which is approx. 25 miles south of Glasgow in the district of Cunninghame, which is approx. 175 miles south of Aberdeen, you tell me how experienced the staff will be to understand all calls from Aberdeen and Aberdeenshire and Banff, and relay the correct locations for the local officers to respond correctly in all situations without mistakes being made, which could mean the difference between life and death situations, we all know that when emergency or non emergency calls are phoned in by people under extreme pressure of an emergency call or not can get slightly unsure of surrounding's or locations, this is where local call handlers, most certainly come into their own, that is why this latest, idea by Police Scotland ( central belt logic, and administration is not in the best public safety of the North East of Scotland, as tax payers we are not getting value for our money locally.19882014-02-20T08:22:09.6774261Roger CormackThis is another example of a decision being made by people who do not understand the unique requirements of the Highlands & Islands. Local knowledge and understanding local dialects is vital to a quick response. 19992014-02-20T09:34:35.914262Angela AuldI do not agree with the decision to close the emergency & 101 call centre from Aberdeen. Local knowledge will be lost and I am concerned over the closure. Our nearest centre will be in Dundee. The Aberdeen Centre should be retained in Aberdeen. 19882014-02-20T10:30:57.914263BRIAN SMITHThis is crazy what is Aberdeen, a small Village North of Dundee ?19882014-02-20T11:44:50.7374264Michael John CowdrySigned but this will not make a scrap of difference to an arrogant and unlistening Salmond, MacAskill et al.19992014-02-20T12:25:02.0334265Cheryl CollinsAberdeen has a modern upto date call centre for the Fire service and it's being scrapped does this mean tax payers moeny will be thrown at the new (central belt) centres to bring them up to date when this is already in place in Aberdeen another example of wasting tax payers money and nothing existing in the north of Scotland - we need centres that will have local knowledge and understanding of local dialect\r\n19882014-02-20T12:33:55.7674266Margie MellisThis is a shortsighted move which totally disregards the importance of local knowledge and expertise in ensuring a quick and appropriate response.19882014-02-20T12:38:13.944267Nicola LeishmanThis is another example to cut services and make decision on people who do live in this area nor understand the requirements of the people in the Highlands and Islands. False savings to impact on peoples lives, bet you would not do this in the City areas. 19992014-02-20T12:51:37.554268Mary DonaldA major fire in Beach Sea Front this morning and I feel that we should not close our emergencies services centres that is the Fire, Police and Ambulance services we do really need them open.19882014-02-20T12:52:30.0674269meg mcgregorI do not think we should loose our control centre\r\nmy husband was in a serious road collision in January if the emergency services had not been so quick I would not have him now. I thank everyone who helped. our serves deserve better mr salmond should remember where he started it seems that Aberdeenshire does not come into anything apart from the oil.our emergency men and women do a good job and work very hard to look after us but if they do not get the proper support.then what can they do .19882014-02-20T12:56:21.6434270Andrea MennieTotal disgrace if this goes ahead.\r\nOur community needs to be 'looked' after by their own.19882014-02-20T13:55:30.8874271Kim KyddSign to save.19882014-02-20T14:28:30.6134272Michael RiddleI am disgusted by the Scottish governments continued removal of resources under the banner of improvement. We are not stupid, it won't matter how often you try any tell us how much better the new systems work- we can see that they are failing at ground level! 19882014-02-20T16:44:59.3474273Raymond Smart Leave the Police and Fire Service control roome in Aberdeen and do not move them to the cenrtal belt area19882014-02-20T16:53:06.3734274Sian LyonDisgrace..local knowledge is key....19882014-02-20T18:46:13.3274275Leslie DuncanSince most of the SNP's arguements are about London running everything from Central London and how it diminishes Scotlands interests, how can they now carry out a series of cuts that centralise Operations and withdraw funds to areas they have maximum support - otherwise their supporters would be voicing concerns for their areas, or are they prepared to sacrifice some of their principles for a 'Holy Grail'? 19882014-02-20T19:07:27.8434276suzanne sinclairshame on the Scottish government. Once again you give the people of Scotland the clear message that only the central belt matters. 19882014-02-20T20:44:01.3174277Kathryn RoughScotland does exist above Glasgow,Edinburgh and Dundee19882014-02-20T23:28:42.964278JamesEmergency call centres that are divorced from major cities such as Aberdeen lead to a loss of skill and knowledge of local call handlers. No amount of mitigation measures can make up for this. I have experienced first hand the problems associated with diverting ambulance 999 calls from Aberdeen to Inverness. On two seperate occasions calling for an ambulance the operator failed to recognise my location. A problem which would have unlikely have happened if dealt with by a local call centre. 19882014-02-20T23:29:06.0374279SelinaI was in a situation where I needed the emergency services back in 2012. A man who sounded like he was from Glasgow couldn't understand my accent. It took a good few attempts until he got my address and then whilst waiting I wasn't sure if they were coming or not because of this problem. This wasn't good when there was a big emergency and I'm just glad I wasn't in a worst state or this could have been life threatening. \r\n\r\nDon't let this happen!19882014-02-20T23:47:42.774280Johnny As usual the north of scotland gets treated as if we not important... 19882014-02-20T23:48:16.9274281Amanda McConnachieI reported something important the other day and had to be specific about the area. The call centre staff knew exactly the area and street I was speaking about. Taking the call centres outwith the area could caused problems and maybe even delays on more important matters as the staff at centralised centre wouldn't be familiar with the area. This could also become very frustrating. It would also be wrong not to mention the obvious job losses caused by this centralisation. Bad decision all round!19882014-02-21T00:02:39.6774282Sharon BradfordThe loss of local knowledge will undoubtedly have catastrophic consequences. It is completely ludicrous to even contemplate centralising such vital services. This I must admit may well be a deal breaker for me when it comes to the independence referendum later in the year, because at the end if the day, who wants a government who clearly holds so little regard for our basic safety and welfare 19882014-02-21T00:22:44.7374283Edna KirtonOnce again the North East is losing out! Local knowledge is invaluable in an emergency. Save our control rooms!!19882014-02-21T01:08:46.3474284Eddy HallIf the SNP needs our vote they need to start listening to the public about Centralisation..Thats a NO NO !\r\n19882014-02-21T01:11:33.884285John ReddinI find this little short of disgraceful, that Joe public has not been consulted or allowed debate on this. Aberdeen is the Oil capital of Europe with award winning services, now to be serviced in a continued effort to centralise all power to the central belt, House is little short of a bureaucratic's whip, stripping all of local law enforcement down to a strathclyde run organisation used at the whim of the politicians that helped usurp local commands to push through MacAskill's policies of centralisation of power. 19882014-02-21T03:27:58.384286Peter Greenthe current snp government should start listening to the people and stop acting in such an autocratic fashion. We need to stop them lecturing us and send them to to the ukrane where their ideology would be tested more19572014-02-21T03:38:45.9274287Mark CushnieStop eroding local services - not everyone wants to be governed by Police Glasgow.19882014-02-21T07:08:18.1474288Ronald MacdonaldIt not good not having locals put out of work when they know the areas. This can put life's at risk. Bad call on this one. 19882014-02-21T08:06:57.7074289graemepolice moral is at an all time low as it is, closing call centres in the north east is a bad move.19882014-02-21T08:30:21.2974290A ForbesCentral belt bias yet again19882014-02-21T09:07:46.3974291Ian RossYou can't close down Aberdeen call centre the staff know all Aberdeen and shire area . We have a great police force and support staff in this area . Closing this down gives crooks the idea that they will have a easy life lets close down the central belt see how they like it 19882014-02-21T09:35:43.024292L BeattieIt's a step too far. We need the local knowledge, not delays because emergency services has been sent to the wrong town. I feel you should be opening another emergency call centre north of Aberdeen & not closing Aberdeen at all.19882014-02-21T09:49:54.8634293Margaret ShortI live in a rural community and my fears are that lack of local knowledge will cause delays in reaching the local community and this decision would without doubt put public safety at risk19882014-02-21T11:56:58.7874294Mrs Mary AnnalAberdeen needs their own services run from Aberdeen, only our own emergency people know the locations in their own town. A lot of lives could potentially be lost if services were moved.19882014-02-21T18:56:47.5534295Ann DavidsonThey are doing the same in Dumfries and Galloway, we need the local knowledge of control room staff, we also need jobs and resent everything being moved to the central belt!19992014-02-21T19:35:47.044296Gordon MciverWhy are all the fire control rooms being kept are only 60 miles leaving some places in the North over 200mls away from 1 of these centres19882014-02-21T22:07:40.754297kyle smithThe prices are high just like the buses as there is only one company that operate that route so they think about profit first and as allways money that should be spent on better things are never done like the failed edinburgh tram line 19572014-02-21T22:35:22.744298BrianYet another West Coast bias decision that will seriously effect the well being of the Oil capital of Europe and the main bill payer of Scotland.Not a very good decision based on the hopes of yes vote for independence in this part of Scotland.Wakey Wakey SNP,stand up for the North East of Scotland for a change !19882014-02-22T07:04:34.7034299John HayAnother huge backward step again. Pounds over safety once more, disgusting!19882014-02-22T10:05:45.7634300Christopher TerringtonIt is disappointing to find that no lessons have been learnt from previous disasters in public services. Public services are supposed to serve the public and to be constructed to do so. When they become a political issue and are thought to be a financial burden, they deteriorate with disastrous consequences for the people that are supposed to be served. This has been seen repeatedly in the NHS. It is vital that the people who serve their community so valiantly continue to do so.19992014-02-22T11:20:56.984301J DuncanHaving been a Control Room Sergeant in Aberdeen I know the value of having a locally staffed and locally positioned Control Room. Its more than about taking a call Its knowing the area and knowing what resources you have - not just from a computer screen. The North East is now becoming the forgotten area of Policing due to Central Belt influence. Colleagues still in the Police in the North East are doing an excellent job in trying times.19882014-02-22T13:44:46.014302Jean StevensonI believe that this centralising of everything is the root cause of the present lack of community presence in our towns and villages. I know the supermarkets have blamed but they didn't close local schools, post offices, hospitals, police stations. Now any town is just a place to live, certainly not a community and centralising our call centres leaves us ever more remote. It is time those in charge of Police Scotland realised that Scotland is not a city and can not be run like London.19882014-02-22T16:12:47.6374303Doreen FraserAll the money is being spent in the Central Belt whereas Aberdeen does not get its fair share and it is supposed to be the Oil Capital - it does NOT make much sense. More money needs to be spent in the Aberdeen area to support our local industry and people who stay here.19882014-02-22T17:18:44.814304Alasdair MacNeillToo important to lose.19992014-02-22T22:14:35.2634305jacqui ross we need our own serive run from aberdeen with large area they cover they know all the small community's and the quickest ways of getting to them there service is hard pushed as it is y make more cuts its about saving lives not money 19882014-02-22T22:26:22.754306tracey raitDo not move our 999 services we need it here concern it will b so bad for our area x worry about what could happen 19882014-02-22T23:03:15.034307Donald ThorburnSigned this as I'm a born and bred highlander, and I'm supporting a friend who's a retained firefighter in Lochcarron.19992014-02-22T23:19:03.064308Jennie TaylorIn support of all families impacted by this move, both employees & those in the community. 19882014-02-23T07:31:34.674309Neil SpinksEven with the promised state of the art technology...how can anyone in central belt locate a remote rural location to report road blockage...the caller may be calling from home and need assistance to identify the locus. Glasgow do not even know that Huntly is near to Aberdeen and not Inverness.19882014-02-23T13:24:55.5274311G,BurkhillAmalgamate both Fire and Ambulance control rooms into the new Mounthooly Fire Station complex in Aberdeen. From all I've read in the local newspapers, this control room is up-to-date as far as technology is concerned. Surely it would be more sensible to train (or re-train) operators to take both Fire and Ambulance emergency calls. Not only would this save millions of pounds of taxpayers money, but there would seem to be little need to move these vital control rooms to either Dundee or Glasgow.19882014-02-23T15:21:50.2274312CatherineIf it wasn't for inverness control room and them knowing Inverness so well i wouldn't be alive from a fire in 2003. I was put thru to another call centre and had to be asked to be put back as they wouldn't be able to help...they also couldn't understand my accent...which is why you need to keep it local.\r\n19992014-02-23T16:35:33.7674313J. Lynne BatikWe need call centres with local knowledge, or lives will be unnecessarily lost -- please do not close these centres, we depend on them.19882014-02-23T21:14:29.814314George RossInverurie has been known as Inveraray19882014-02-24T08:54:50.9834315StellaSave these service centres19882014-02-24T12:18:14.5934316James GallagherI firmly believe that emergency call centres should stay local and that police front desks open times should remain as is.What is proposed is more centre belt control.19882014-02-24T12:51:11.644317kenneth downieIt is crazy phoning someone in an emergency that has no knowledge of the area19882014-02-24T12:57:29.0934318stephyou can't put a price on the professionalism & knowledge of the service centres in local areas - this needs a complete re-think!19882014-02-24T14:21:45.7134319Peter ReidAnother hugely damaging cut that could ultimately cut lives!19882014-02-24T18:23:22.354320adam mcneillLets keep it as it is with people that know the place and can work out where you are. I have had a situation where I didn't know the arrest name but told the way I had gone and the person on the phone knew where I was. 19882014-02-24T19:41:04.8734321Gary Swinscoe, ScotlandThis decision seems to show a central-belt bias.19882014-02-24T19:54:14.7574322David HarwoodSave our control room it is important to Inverness 19992014-02-24T20:57:34.644323Suzanne falconerFor all those that do such a good job running an essential service that should stay local19882014-02-24T22:38:55.0534324Leanne MorrisonKeep service centres local!19882014-02-25T06:48:08.6274325John TimminsDublin Fire Brigade . . Supporting Your Petition19882014-02-25T12:22:18.384326Eileen DallasPlease leave our local emergency services where they are. They are doing a great job. We need them!19882014-02-25T14:16:26.4434327Aileen MitchellHow would Piper Alpha been dealt with without local knowledge and services19882014-02-25T19:38:47.824329Glenelg Station (B47)We consider that the local knowledge, so vital in previous incidents, will be lost with a change to a centralised system of control. We have found that a Control that has an understanding of both the physical landscape and social environments that we work within has given us a distinct advantage in our fire fighting capabilities as well in our Community Fire Safety responsibilities.19992014-02-25T21:46:44.7774330Laura StephenKeep the centres open!19882014-02-25T21:55:05.0634331Graham maclennanKeep it local... you know it makes sense :)19992014-02-26T10:23:09.044332Steven PetersonThe loss of local knowledge could have fatal consequences given the repetitive use of some places names. The mis-direction of emergency services within rural areas could be disasterous.19882014-02-26T13:07:11.0534333GR ElginI commute daily to Dyce then back to Elgin. The train is always overcrowded with limited seating after leaving Aberdeen. Nightly i have to stand until a seat becomes available. Inverurie travellers in the morning struggle for a seat every day. There is a regular serviceability problem which compounds the problem as we are squeezed into less carriages, which there are not enough to begin with. Scotrail are happy to take the fare money but disregards passenger safety by overcrowding the carriages. I see frustration every day from passengers failing to get a seat on the 1733 from Dyce. The line requires inmproving to allow passing places for an hourly service to operate. The stations with shorter platforms (Elgin) require updsting. Slightly off topic but Dyce staion should have a proper platform building. We live in the NE of Scotland which is known for its poor weather in theb winter months. Dyce is a busy staion and 2 small shelters is not enough. It sometimes like living in the dark ages. Aberdeen is the oil capital of Europe and Dycwe station and the northerly line is not a shiniong example for the area. I sweriously feel passenger safety is compromised by thye lack of funding put into the Aberdeen Inverness route. 19572014-02-26T14:20:41.2734334Steve Mackay17 years of loyal supervisory service to legacy Grampian Police and now Police Scotland, sorry Police Glasgow, for what? To be thrown on the scrapheap by Kenny McAskill all so he make savings & adhere to the SNP's centralised agenda. Well they've got what they wanted. Heaven help the Grampian region. The Aberdeen Service Centre is one of the top performing Service Centre's in the whole country. Fact. It is the only Service Centre in Scotland to achieve an accreditation from the CCA. None of this appears to matter though. 300 people out of jobs means nothing to Alex Salmond, but it's 300 people & 300 familes & a lot of votes.19882014-02-26T22:12:36.6274335Elizabeth FullerFor a service like this local knowledge is crucial.19882014-02-27T18:39:21.444336Jamie DoullWith a landscape such as this, you can't begin to replace knowledge and familiarity, with technology.\r\nPeople lives are not a cost cutting exercise.19992014-02-27T20:17:21.554337H SFor the past 12 months I have been a daily commuter on the Inverness to Aberdeen route. It is not a service Scotrail should be proud of. I have experienced a variety of problems such as regular signal failures or delays at Inverurie, buckled train track, engine failures, lack of carriages due to lack of available rolling stock and theft of signalling cable. Every week there is a problem or delay on the line.\r\nThis line must be one of the most profitable lines in Scotland due to the number of regular commuters to Aberdeen and those travelling to Dyce to go offshore or the airport. The rolling stock is of extremely poor quality when compared to that available in Central Scotland. The 15.28 service leaving Aberdeen is consistently overcrowded surely this is dangerous for passengers and staff? Providing a train every hour and a half between Aberdeen and Inverness is not acceptable. There should be more frequent trains on the timetable.\r\nThe people of the North East of Scotland deserve a better service and the Scottish Government should demand Scotrail make improvements to the schedule and the rolling stock.19572014-02-28T09:53:32.4334339Callum StevensonFor a service like this local knowledge is cruicial19882014-03-02T15:58:08.884340Brenda ChallonerWhen I read the terms and conditions I wondered if there was anything relevant that I could say without breaking all the terms, BUT LOCAL KNOWLEDGE IS CRUCIAL, no-one in the central belt has a clue about anything that happens north of Perth, or even that we exist as humans.19882014-03-03T12:29:11.24341Josephine Ann GilchristI'm signing this in support of my Nephew who is retained with the Fort Augustus Fire Station.19992014-03-03T18:02:18.964342Mrs Linda CullenIt is essential that these services are kept locally for the people to have local knowledge and to ensure the public safety of the public. Trying to save a wee bit of money can cost lives. Which is more important?19882014-03-03T20:05:59.394343Paul WingCuts have got to stop or we'll have nothing worth keeping. Local knowledge must not be lost. Good Luck 19992014-03-03T21:23:45.8434344Katrina ClarkeGood Luck with your campaign from a fellow Fire Control Operator x19992014-03-03T23:30:26.7174345Mary MacdonaldWe are losing everything in rural communities, do we not count. Most of our community are elderly.19992014-03-04T09:58:40.1334346Robert ClelandIt makes no sense at all to move this station. Local Knowledge is essential to this service.\r\nThat goes for all the stations not just Inverness19992014-03-04T13:04:40.754348Lesley RossWe need local police now more than ever.\r\nRediculous decision to close local centres.\r\n19882014-03-04T13:06:29.3574349Mrs CranA large city such as Aberdeen should have local services. It will cost lives. Oil capital? Joke more like!19882014-03-04T13:10:21.2774350Lynn BruceCertain services just NEED to be localised! It's common sense and more importantly LIVES that are potentially put at risk. It is essential the public can be assured of safety! 19882014-03-04T13:11:10.194351victoria christiei dont have a clue what our goverment is coming too! are they not concerned on us the public,s saftey, wellbeing, and protection surley knot! it is absolutly disgracfull what they are trying to do.19882014-03-04T13:18:13.324352S GrassickLocal knowledge is essential for the area19882014-03-04T13:18:20.854353Beth CarmichaelLocal knowledge and dialect knowledge is critical. Precious seconds and minutes can be lost with someone not understanding these.19882014-03-04T13:22:04.7734354Andrew SmartAnother example of Scottish Government gone mad. And they expect us to be independent with them?!? No chance.19882014-03-04T13:38:12.1334355Vivian Davidson An absolute disgrace 19882014-03-04T13:46:45.854356Paula Burns We need local knowledge to assist in the Saving of lives. What's more important a life or £'s? I know what my answer to that is. 19882014-03-04T14:28:55.4134357Catherine DixonLocal knowledge is so important in a rural area where I live half of the places are off the main roads.19882014-03-04T15:10:18.9174358Linda ShepherdPlease local services as they are. Local knowledge is worth more than cost cuttings. These services should never have cutbacks. Cutbacks costs lives.19882014-03-04T16:51:38.6474359Frances Davidsonlocal knowledge and dialect is paramount what are they thinking on second thoughts I do not want to know19882014-03-04T17:03:02.0274360Brian HarwoodI Fully support the petition its a disgrace anything to save money also its going to cost lifes.19882014-03-04T17:33:27.5234361Alistair TaylorAbsolute nonsense.19882014-03-04T17:54:17.744362Marilyn WallaceThe Highlands are not like other areas. Please keep the Inverness Control Room. Stop centralising and keep things local.19992014-03-04T19:46:30.0074363A NonymousThings will only get worse if we get Indepence! If this is what the SNP is doing to try and win our votes, just imagine what it will be like if they get their way.\r\nVOTE NO.\r\nTogether we stand, Diveded we fall.19882014-03-04T19:49:23.2034364KatrinaI believe the Government are being short sighted with their money saving changes in various areas of the public sector. I believe the short term savings will cost more in the long term, not only financially but in the quality of staff too. We are meant to promote health and wellbeing, taking away local emergency services will surely have a detrimental effect on our population. 19882014-03-04T20:47:58.6674365Lorraine TurnerOil Capital Of Europe and NO CONTROL ROOMS? WHAT ??? Wise up Alex!19882014-03-05T08:55:23.1734366Catherine smithHow can we be independant with the government making decisiond like this! Its ridiculous!!!!19882014-03-05T10:37:184367Gillian LamarraMen need all the support they can, especially from women 20032014-03-05T11:07:27.864368Anne SinclairMy sons ex partner does not allow my son to see his daughter even although he has never missed a payment. Also we as Grandparents have no rights.\r\nPlease do something as our hearts are broken.20032014-03-05T12:51:55.9374369JMAs a regular communter from Inverurie to Aberdeen, the situation is now at a dangerous level for travellers. The 07:43 train is always full by the time it reaches Inverurie and those with luggage leaving at Dyce for the airport regularly struggle to get off the train. Returning from Aberdeen, the 15:52 train is too early for many to leave the office but the 16:44 only goes as far as Dyce. If this train went as far as Inverurie perhaps there might be a little less pressure on the 17:21 Inverness train. It doesn't bare thinking about all these standing passengers in the event of an accident!19572014-03-05T15:09:51.684370Gemma PatersonIt's took my partner 4 years to get contact every other weekend and half of school holidays, he was faced with false allegations where there was no evidence of violence, but still courts choose to pussy foot around the mother. Men should not go through this20032014-03-05T18:43:02.94371VishayWe are moving forward with so much and I'm so happy with that. Parenting is not a liberty, it's something not a single human being should be denied. Absent fathers have such a detrimental affect on our society and future generations. We need to make sure we are letting as many willing fathers who have shown no faults as much access to their child as the mother. It takes two to make a kid. \r\n\r\nSigned,\r\nVishay Krishan20032014-03-05T19:00:30.6174372Joan DavisEvery parent should have the right to see their child especially when they would make a good parents until otherwise proven differently. Ron would make a wonderful father, and should have the right to do so.\r\n20032014-03-05T20:05:44.1334373nicola feeleyMen should have the same rights as the mum x20032014-03-05T20:16:17.184374MarcTo not be in a country were you are told what you can and cant do by law, sums the UK up. "You are a great father but your ex who hates you doesnt agree, therefor you will never see them". \r\n\r\nNever give up. And keep fighting. 20032014-03-05T20:25:17.6174375Ashley McilvennyThe law does have to change, my husband has been fighting the court for 7 years & at every turn he is always the one that's lost out. It's ok for his ex partner to withhold his son for no reason & nothing happens but if my husband was to withhold him he would be in jail. She has tried everything in the book to try & stop my husband from seeing his son but still happy to take his money every month. He has fought tooth & nail with the courts to get contact back each time this really need to change as it's not fair on the child or children.20032014-03-05T20:31:32.134377maureen HughesI have a nephew who is having issues with access to his son,after him and his partner separated20032014-03-05T22:05:43.1034378Stacey CampbellSo far it's taken my partner 18 months of fighting to eventually be granted 4 supervised contact sessions and then go back to court to see what judge decides next. He has had to endure false allegations of violence and drug abuse from his ex with no evidence, along with false allegations about myself from his ex family members. Things definitely need to be changed as there is too many females using their children as weapons to hurt the dad while continuing to take money from them. 20032014-03-05T22:13:42.3674379Stuart WallaceIm a father who has faught for past year and half to see my daughter. I have been faced with a false accusation which my ex and her mother mistakenly contradicted on two different legal papers. Even still i must wait. I pay every week from my wages and being the only clear thinking perent for my daughters future. Fathers should have more rights. Its been another four months since i last seen my daughter. One week was bad enough. 20032014-03-05T22:35:40.0574380Hearts ApartThis should include alienated mothers too. There is even less support for them than fathers. The law needs changing and quickly. 20032014-03-06T13:36:34.2974381June MurrayMy son gets to see and keep his son 3 to 4 nights a week. He is working on minimum wage and is struggling, to buy him clothes and food when he has him, he can't afford to take him away days. The mother has a job an is getting all the benefits for their son. What rights has my son got?20032014-03-06T16:24:33.234382ClaireNeed more carriages on all trains especially peak time trains. Never get a seat Inverurie -Aberdeen as train normally full when it arrives in Inverurie. 19572014-03-06T17:14:27.4734383JOHN A SAMPSONI agree with the substance and merit of this petition.20242014-03-06T17:46:36.454384Jimmywhat we need is not more rights for each. We need equal rights.20032014-03-06T21:35:55.3934385Linda mcmahonThis service is a disgrace19572014-03-06T23:39:58.1034386Lynn AndersonWhere parents are unable to agree over contact arrangements, there must be more legal protection allow both parents the ability to exercise their parental rights and responsibilities. All too often, the best interests of the child are forgotten whilst parents get caught up in emotional disputes. The law change suggested will recognise that fathers play an equally important role in the upbringing of children.20032014-03-06T23:48:58.864387Karen DawsonIf u r going to charge the same amount whether you sit or stand there needs to b more carriages at peak times.19572014-03-07T00:22:31.694388hannahEvery father has a right to see there child! Any kother that stop the bond between child and father is sick!... A dad should always get a say no matter what. 20032014-03-07T17:37:39.3134389Clark RoseThe service is rubbish19572014-03-08T08:20:52.3474390K SmithLocal knowledge and dialect can be vital in an emergency, time wasted trying to communicate effectively could cost lives.19882014-03-10T05:45:34.5734392Graeme HoustonAll information held by Public Owned Bodies, i.e. Council, Government, Political Parties, Companies should be made freely available immediately without the need for FOI's20242014-03-10T10:09:08.8474393Jennifer CowieYet again another slap in the face for Aberdeen. Why Dundee, they have nothing to do with Aberdeen19882014-03-10T15:35:49.084394Donald S MurrayI have always believed in devolution. This policy is both dangerous and tugs more power to the centre. Unacceptable for both reasons!19992014-03-12T18:02:03.6774395Carole BridgeWe are paying premium fares for a less than standard service. The same distance on the Inverness to Aberdeen line is more than twice the price of a similar distance on other lines.19572014-03-13T11:54:03.1934397Colin McNabIt is a nonsense that Freedom of Information can effectively be Freedom of Misinformation without any sanction being imposed on the Provider.20242014-03-13T14:59:18.244398Fiona CelliIn Sutherland when we called Inverness instead of Wick for an ambulance, many were sent to the wrong place or from a base that wasn't the closest. There are several Laids etc and the post code is based on Kirkwall and the numbers of crofts etc are not in consecutive order. Inverness had trouble with this. How on earth will the central belt cope?19882014-03-13T15:29:23.9534400Geoff CraigAfter 5 attempts I finally was able to read the cryptogram. Nigh impossible for humans.20182014-03-14T19:33:06.3274401Lesley RhodickEvery father should be allowed to see they're child as much as they possibly can :) good luck with the petition x 20032014-03-16T21:39:51.1434402Eleanor Its time both parents were seen as important as each other!20032014-03-17T21:48:57.524403Nicola ritchieLocal knowledge is key in dealing with an emergency in that town19882014-03-18T12:31:00.734404Yvonne berryStay in Aberdeen\r\n19882014-03-18T12:40:01.014405Natasha WellburnRediculous another time waster. Time is vital in an emergency ! Keep them. North of Dundee aberdeen is the oil capital one of Scotland's largest city's !19882014-03-18T12:59:54.154406Anne McMillanBad decisions19882014-03-18T13:14:41.594407Fiona TaylorPlease keep this service in Aberdeen.19882014-03-18T13:16:27.064408rachael daviesKeep it open! Such a stupid idea, local people who know the city are by far the best people to advise in a siruation where police are going to be involved. Keep it open and save the jobs that so many people need19882014-03-18T13:46:38.764409Jo MilliganThere has never been, nor will there ever be, any substitute for local knowledge. Moving these call centres WILL cost lives19882014-03-18T14:26:27.7474410Laura forbesPlease keep it open, important to have local knowledge 19882014-03-18T14:41:54.1274411Angela SavageKeep it open19882014-03-18T15:00:51.564412Lesley NaylorLocal services are essential. Saving money should not be the only consideration. Common sense please!\r\n19882014-03-18T15:48:54.5534413ArlenePlease, please keep us safe!! 19882014-03-18T17:12:54.7274414mandykeep it open, what if people call saying we need an ambulance down the bouly" where im from this is down the beach boulevard, how is an operator from down south going to know our local dialect or location if a person is panicked on the phone?19882014-03-18T18:17:57.774415Rose WilsonIt is ridiculous not having these services in Aberdeen19882014-03-18T18:38:12.9134416JenI'm half Shetlander half Orcadian....this is important to me.20332014-03-18T19:53:10.344417TerriPlease keep the services local 19882014-03-18T20:48:49.0434418Andrew RossHopefully common sense will prevail.19882014-03-18T20:56:30.8734419John TullochIslanders must be allowed to tell the politicians what they want and a referendum is the right way to do that.20332014-03-18T21:03:03.9874420Lisa ThomsonWe rely on the expert local knowledge of these services - it could be the difference between life or death! 19882014-03-18T21:16:24.634421Keith McDonald Think beyond the money box !!! You all know it's wrong to close these local services !!!!19882014-03-18T23:16:50.5934422Ian F HoyleCould we not also be asked if we want to join Russia?20332014-03-19T03:21:45.7874423Ooi Chiat HoeIt would be sad for Scotland to break-awayer her 307-years of Union. UNITED Kingdom will never be United if any of the country leave this Union. UK is unique in her own way. No other country have the admistration same as UK. United we stand, divided we fall. All I can suggest is Scotland to seek greater autonomy and not full independence. \r\n\r\nEurope is too fragmented compare to other continents!!20332014-03-19T08:28:53.2634424Brian CowanFamily laws in this country are sub-standard & utterly incapable of protecting the best interests of the children whom they ought to protect.\r\n\r\nThe current implementation of equal parental rights is wrong & flies in the face of common sense, it is devisive & ill-considered.\r\n\r\nFamily law is not fit for purpose & is being further corrupted by lawyers who manipulate the system for their own gain...profiteering in the misery of loving parents & their innocent, helpless, voiceless children.\r\n\r\nA child needs & deserves the full & active involvement of both parents, they deserve alaw which enshrines & preciously guards these fundemental rights.\r\n20032014-03-19T10:13:30.4574425Carol DuncanThe loss of local knowledge and understanding of local dialects will cost time, if not lives. These call centres need to be as local as possible to help provide services for the communities involved.19882014-03-19T11:12:34.284426Bill SmaleIn the event of an overall Yes vote, all parts of Scotland where the majority have voted No should be able to decide whether they wish to be part of Scotland or part of the United Kingdom20332014-03-19T11:14:59.144427Brian GrayIt will be a huge mistake to leave the UK. It will turned Scotland into a shambles.20332014-03-19T11:30:50.664428patriotThe so-called uk does nothing for anyone apart from england.time to end englands empire on ALL levels.good luck islanders.scots will always be your friends 20332014-03-19T12:38:34.5874429Christine SangsterThe Local System works - why change it?!... Saving money is never more important then saving lives!19882014-03-19T13:11:20.364430Alasdair Morrison closing the Inverness control room i feel puts local lives at risk and puts the highlands and islands at severe risk due to a big loss of local knowledge and geography as well as knowledge of dialects and Gaelic 19992014-03-19T13:13:55.7274431Douglas YoungShetland left to run it's own financial affairs?\r\nHow would we subsidise both Northlink and air fares?\r\nThis is going nowhere, sorry, 80 % YES and nothing less for Shetland too.20332014-03-19T14:19:22.094432An Orcadian Scottish British European Separation is regressive - strength comes as countries becoming more united not less.20332014-03-19T14:39:54.474433Robin MairI went to school in Orkney for a few years and loved my time there. I have been back several times. Orkney people have a great sense of identity and view the Edinburgh elite - establishment in much the same way as they do the equivalents in London. Orkney deserves to have much more say in there affairs. I suspect things will get worse if there is a yes vote because they will be even more isolated from the rest of the UK. I guess the same holds for the Western Isles and Shetland.\r\nOne more thing to consider is oil - geographically and territorially is not more Shetland's oil (and Orkney's)?\r\n When the big vote comes the Yes No votes in Orkney, Shetland and Western Isles should be published to reflect the desires of these administrations. 20332014-03-19T15:23:41.1834434Ali InksterDouglas we would not need subsidies we would be stinking rich with OUR OIL. As it is we pay net £86million to the treasury after all subsidies are taken into account. And if you don't like it you are free to take the first plane or boat sooth.20332014-03-19T15:43:11.9534435Ali InksterIs there a paper version a lot of folks have said they don't use the internet but would like to sign it anyway20332014-03-19T15:58:37.44436StanI am signing this petition as I strongly agree that the islanders should be a able to decide their own future without the interference of the Scottish or English Parliaments. 20332014-03-19T16:54:55.524437Lord SimmonsForget it. The Islands are Scottish and shall remain so. 20332014-03-19T18:49:58.2934438ann kanequite right and the very best of luck to you all20332014-03-19T19:17:23.1934439Leo BrennanThe 'Yes' campaign people are forever saying that decisions effecting our llives should not be made in London. They should NOT be made in Edinburgh either!20332014-03-19T19:45:03.8734440jimmy budgeShetland is doing well in the oil and gas industry but orkney is struggling. I will vote no... Stay with the UK is the best for the future in the long run. Wait until oil and gas reserves run lower! Every man for themselves then...20332014-03-19T20:31:00.7674441William RendallAs an Orcadian living and working temporarily in London, I would like to be able to have this vote. I personally think the islands would always be better off in the UK, and should Scotland go independent, I am sure we would be welcomed back into the UK and have a bit of bargaining power with all the oil to secure a good deal for the islands from Westminster.20332014-03-19T22:01:16.2434442Malcolm StoutShould Scotland secede from the Uk Orkney & Shetland should move for a return to Norway or the Danish commonwealth. It's worse to be discriminated against by Edinburgh than disregarded by Westminster20332014-03-19T23:00:09.1974443christian kaneThere should be no double standards and that's why I sign this petition. Hopefully Scotland will go independent and the 3 isles will stay with the rUK. Good luck.20332014-03-19T23:34:28.834444frank gillinghamWhere is the "Box Belopw"?20182014-03-20T01:23:09.7374445Derek Macraeits not the Scottish FM that can grant the right of a ref for the islands, its westminster, unless, of course, you vote yes on Sept 18th, then resubmit the petition, Support the Scottish Ref Indy first, vote YES on sept 18th.20332014-03-20T01:50:29.1234446alan duncan the snp want democracy then the islands can have it also 20332014-03-20T02:27:55.9474447J LondonI think more thought should be given re offering a referenda, and devolution, in addition the Western Isles, to the Northern Isles as a whole. \r\n\r\nI also think the 3rd option - to remain a constituent part of the UK - should be included whatever the result of the referendum re separation of GB and Scotland from the UK.\r\n\r\nThe above said, whilst celebrating historical and cultural differences, we should also celebrate our shared British history and culture ...\r\n\r\nand I no more want the Northern and Western Isles to be separate any more than I wan Britain and Scotland to.\r\n\r\n#RegionalDevolutionAndBritishNationStateEqualsBestWayForward\r\n20332014-03-20T06:36:22.944448John M GrahamWe should make in roads to associate ourselves with Norway and there culture which for obvious reasons are similar to our own.20332014-03-20T07:30:16.364449Lorraine MilneAberdeen is a world recognised City at the heart if the oil industry, and it can't have its own locally based call center? REALLY??? Disgraceful 19882014-03-20T09:44:52.234450ModeratorFrank Gillingham - it is the box directly underneath the Captcha text in which you should re-type the words or numbers in the Captcha challenge, the rectangular box with 'Type the text' in.20182014-03-20T10:29:07.5974451Vicki Redpath-WatsonI hope you don't need to but in the event of a Yes vote I hope you vote for the third option.20332014-03-20T10:42:13.7534452Stephen ClacksonDevolution has stopped at Edinburgh, why should independence do the same?20332014-03-20T10:53:52.194453craig It scotland goes its sell I honestly think we are going to the wall 20332014-03-20T10:57:40.684454Graham IrvineI dont believe Alec Salmond will allow us this option.20332014-03-20T11:55:02.264455Kirsty MacleanAli Inkster - I think if you email petitions(at)scottish.parliament.uk they will be able to tell you how to get a paper version. It might be possible to print out a pdf version (click where it says "Click here for the petition PDF") and then circulate printed copies and ask people to send them in. Another thing that really needs doing is for someone to create a Facebook group, with a link to this site, encouraging people to sign. Can you do this? I'm afraid I don't know how and am a bit too old to learn! Kirsty20332014-03-20T12:13:54.3174456Joyce MackenzieScottish, living in Belgium at the moment, I am not entitled to vote in the Referendum & the future of my country ! So, I can understand these Islanders ! Let their voices be heard !20332014-03-20T12:39:38.234457Island manSome of you guys need to get a grip fast, the isle are Scottish and will remain that way for a long time after a yes vote, if ruk then decided to cherry pick they would risk causing troubles ie. nireland... I don't think they would welcome that prospect also they would then need to give Cornwall a referendum, can of worms spring to mind20332014-03-20T14:20:06.4834458Barry PorteusOrcadians don't think that they are "Scottish" - they are Orcadians with a different view than that of the SNP. If Orkney and Shetland want to stay in the UK then that's fine. If they want their own Parliament like in the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands, then that's fine too. Its already been proven that Salmond and Co. don't care about anything beyond the Central Belt.20332014-03-20T15:35:46.814459Munster FanReply to Island man\r\nThe exact same arguement can be used for Scotland leaving the UK. What's good enough for the Scots is good enough for the Shetlanders and Orcadians. If the Cornish want a referendum, let them ask for it.20332014-03-20T15:37:09.2834460Christopher KealyThe islanders should have their voice. Scotland is getting its chance - why shouldn't they ? 20332014-03-20T15:53:47.7534461John ChallonerSalmond and his gang don't give a hoot as regards the needs and future of the western and northern isles20332014-03-20T16:22:48.0134462Gregor McIntyreIf Scotland sleepwalks in the nightmare of independence I fully support Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles to stay within the United Kingdom!\r\n\r\nFeel very badly let down by the Scottish Government for opening divisions in society and racism and hatred shown towards England shows the country in a very bad light!20332014-03-20T17:15:10.0974463Andrew linkas I understand it true orkadians don't consider themselves scotish and would relish this chance to break away from scotland.20332014-03-20T17:57:14.194464Graham LaneSelf determination applies to the northern isles as much as it does Scotland so yes they must be allowed to choose if they wish to remain part of Scotland if Scotland can choose if it wishes to remain part of the UK.20332014-03-20T18:23:50.284465C Cardell30% of the remaining oil is in Shetland waters. We too should get a say. 20332014-03-20T18:50:48.5834466Fiona WebbCan someone please set up a Facebook group for this petition as soon as possible!\r\n\r\n384 signatories in the first 2 days is great. I think we are well on our way to getting Parliamentary time.\r\n\r\nBut if we end up with 5000 or 10000, the Scottish Government won't just have to "take notice" - they will have to give us the referendum we want. They won't want to tell us we're all wrong and that the people of the islands shouldn't get a chance to decide.\r\n\r\nRepeat - if you are reading this and know how to set up a Facebook group, please do so! Please spread the word. Many thanks, Fiona\r\n\r\nThere is also the Twitter hashtag #islandsreferenda\r\nPlease can people circulate this, or do whatever you do with Twitter hashtags. (I'm too old to understand Twitter!)20332014-03-20T19:09:07.0774467Daniel RobinsonGraham, you say you "don't believe Alec Salmond will allow us this option."\r\n\r\nHe probably isn't inclined to, but if enough of us sign this petition, he will HAVE to allow these referenda. Let's be positive here! Let's all try to get us many signatures as possible. We should all canvass everyone we know: neighbours, colleagues, family, Facebook friends, etc.\r\n\r\nThis petition is already in the media. People should come up with angles to make sure it gets more and more coverage. The momentum is with us now. This is quite amazing really, but if we maximise the number of signatures, we win.\r\n\r\nIt doesn't matter what status people support. Everybody who thinks islanders have a right to decide (which should really be everybody) should sign this. Let the miserable and mean refuse to sign it if they want.\r\n\r\nI have to say well done to Malcolm Lamont and the other organisers for wording the three options so well, in such an unbiased way. If anyone is interested, personally I am in favour of the status quo (Western Isles in Scotland in the UK), but if Scotland goes independent then I will be in favour of the Western Isles leaving Scotland and staying in the UK. My sister takes the opposite view. She wants Scottish independence, but if Scotland stays in the UK she wants the Western Isles to leave Scotland and go independent. We have both signed the petition!20332014-03-20T19:12:38.4534468Donald MackenzieChristopher Kealy says, "The islanders should have their voice. Scotland is getting its chance - why shouldn't they ?"\r\n\r\nThat's an excellent question. Let's give it a catchy name. Everyone's heard about the West Lothian question. How about calling Christopher's question "THE LERWICK QUESTION".\r\n\r\n(All due respect to our friends in Orkney and the Western Isles. Calling it the KIRKWALL question or the STORNOWAY question would be absolutely fine. The only reason I suggest "LERWICK" is that the status issue has slightly more of a history in Shetland than in the other two island groups.)20332014-03-20T19:19:32.834469Natalie SmithOoi Chiat Hoe - I agree with you: the UK should stay together. But there has been so much divisive talk recently. That can't be ignored. Let's renew our marriage vows for the future. A new 'settlement'. This is why I and my family, future-looking Unionists, have signed this petition.20332014-03-20T19:31:53.0374470John T LelandSomeone set up a Facebook group for this NOW. You don't have to ask anyone's permission. Please just do it. And why isn't it on Twitter? Someone please put it on there. (I am a pensioner on Barra. I would do it if I could, but I can't.)20332014-03-20T19:53:05.7834471Angus MacmillanWhat about Glasgow? Should it not be allowed to side with being part of an independent Scotland or the UK?\r\n\r\n20332014-03-20T20:12:04.2434472Island manMost on this page are not even from the isles, so really their opinion is twisted and bitter. Give yourself a shake,and by the look of the poll the concervitve mad P&J reported there is no appite for what you non islanders are shouting about. It is not an empire no more and divide and concur Is a thing of the past20332014-03-20T20:20:23.1674473Island manSo will each of the three hundred islands get a vote on weather they stay part of scotland?20332014-03-20T23:05:30.4374474Sam SmithI think it is about time that those secretive organisations who have been exposed by the State Broadcaster who are effectively State Regulators are forced to be transparent and accountable for their actions, like the Law Society of Scotland and the Scottish Solicitors Discipline Tribunal20242014-03-21T12:17:50.8334475David ClarkThe Islanders should be allowed to decide their destiny. If that meansd they stay with the UK, fine, if they decide to stay with Scotland, fine. Also in the mix should be the Norwegian option. Whatever they decide they have my support and I will keep visiting.20332014-03-21T15:13:46.0174476Fiona usherPlease don't let others go through this 20352014-03-21T15:19:57.0934477another island manisland man - support in each of the island groups is spread over the various options. You can't genuinely believe that everyone who disagrees with you (and I'm not even sure which option you support) is not a true islander. I'm as much of an islander as you are. I've always lived in Kirkwall except for 5 years I spent in Glasgow. If you want islanders to decide, sign the petition! If you don't think islanders have any right to decide, don't. But if it's the latter, then why are you expressing your opinion as an islander? Much better to decide in the ballot box at a referendum than in a "comments" section on the internet!20332014-03-21T15:37:47.5434478Leslie McGlinchey Please please don't let anyone else go through this nightmare !!!!!! 20352014-03-21T16:13:36.2974479Vivian McDermottI was not told by my doctor, just how permanent this procedure was, now I don't know if to live with it or under go several ops to try to remove it, which is not always successfull.20352014-03-21T16:15:36.2574480Jeff HolmesMesh needs to be suspended ASAP to stop others going through the nightmare of pain and reduction in quality of life20352014-03-21T16:28:28.4834481Norma RobertsPlease don't let anybody go thru the pain and discomfort I suffer all the time.20352014-03-21T16:30:33.5934482Barrie DaviesI have fought for the United Kingdom's freedom and I expect the Islanders to have that freedom to vote for what they truly believe. So anyone who denies them that should be tried and punished for treason. 20332014-03-21T16:53:52.954483Annemarie ConleyPlease hear our voice we are all real women and need your help.thank you 20352014-03-21T17:05:15.7034484Darren JarvieHope this suspension happens very soon20352014-03-21T17:11:29.274485Samantha Rooney I was told nothing about any complications of this procedure . It has ruined my life the constant pain of razor blades and needles inside you and being left so debilitated its horrific please please ban !!!20352014-03-21T17:14:33.4734486Kerry KerrDont let people suffer anymore than they have too. 20352014-03-21T17:22:53.8434487Keith WaughI very much agree that the island communities should be permitted to decide their destiny. However, I would ask if the Norwegian government has been approached regarding the possible annexing of the northern and western isles?20332014-03-21T17:24:54.2734488David McLelland Please stop this procedure. It impacts on patients and their families life's is devastating . 20352014-03-21T17:26:45.1074489Elaine McEwanI was told by my consultant in 2012 that this mesh was perfectly safe, I have since found out the truth and the mesh implants need to be suspended ASAP. The outcome has been absolutely horrendous after having the mesh fitted.\r\n20352014-03-21T17:28:58.4634490MRS YVONNE TOBYNThis issue has to be taken seriously, too many women and men are suffering due to this Mesh. Did the Manufacturers consider when selling these products to also give instructions on how to remove it if problems arise?20352014-03-21T17:47:22.524491JohnIndependent Scotland yes.\r\n\r\nOrkney independence is just a cynical egotistical power grab by the cabal of bovine brained parasites with a long history of incompetence in school place......the question is where is the money coming from.......YOU ......NO GOVERNMENT HANDOUTS .forget about this totally impractitcal nonsense and the idiot promoters.\r\n\r\nForget about the other bunch of parasites in londonshire.\r\n\r\nIndependent Scotland you know it makes sense.20332014-03-21T17:55:23.464492Kathleen ParrishAs a mesh sufferer I am still awaiting a complete diagnoses but my muscles suffer constant pain. These things should never have been allowed on the market. I too know that figures on mesh removals are false, but am awaiting a review of a well and truly falsified mesh removal FOI.20352014-03-21T18:06:32.2974493April CheyneAbsolute disgrace that this is happening. Local knowledge is priceless!! If a controller doesn't understand the local dialect lives could be a risk! 19882014-03-21T18:11:52.564494Jim FraserI was unaware of the Western Isles was part of Norway.20332014-03-21T18:30:36.794495Gail KerrWish I had never had this procedure done!!! 20352014-03-21T18:39:39.854496Maryanne TwaddleIt is vital that this situation is resolved. It is not satisfactory in any way that women are having to live with the after effects of this inappropriate practice. There should be huge compensation for the loss of enjoyment of life for those affected. They had no idea of the risks and indeed of the incapacitation they might face. It is just unacceptable!20352014-03-21T18:41:07.964497barry kellyjust listen to the stories out there people20352014-03-21T18:45:50.044498Angela WelshMy poor mother died because of the results of havinv this mesh implant!!! Toxic20352014-03-21T19:07:04.7774499Wael AgurAs a clinician and surgeon involved with TVM, I agreed with most of the 6 points and decided to sign the petition. All the very best.20352014-03-21T19:09:29.0434500annette smartplease save others from the suffering myself and many others have had to go through because of MESH IMPLANTS .20352014-03-21T19:22:02.7034501Marion McBethAround the world hundreds and thousands of women have suffered horrific internal injuries as a result of mesh implants. It is one of the biggest medical scandals in the world and we can all do something to protect women in the future by simply signing this petition. Do it! Now!20352014-03-21T19:47:08.2174502Grace HamiltonThis needs to be suspended asap. This mesh ruins your quality of life - forever !!!!!20352014-03-21T19:50:55.0634503Claire DaisleyThis product must be banned or be used at your own risk after being told of ALL the damage it may cause. if you decided on the latter an decided to have this in your body, i'd describe you as a FOOL. My life is well and truely ruined thanks to this stuff. Had I known in 2011 what I know now, i'd still have a good quality of life. I was told it would be life-changing but, the Surgeon should have left out the words 'for the better'. PLEASE do-not agree to have this poison inserted in your body!!20352014-03-21T20:03:43.574504michelle creeI want to see this operation banned and to stop the use polypropylene transvaginal mesh 20352014-03-21T20:07:11.634505moBan the mesh. 20352014-03-21T20:10:34.6334506Gillian McAllisterThis needs to be stopped asap before anyone else has to suffer, a good family friend has went through so much due to this procedure, peoples quality of life should not have reduced due to a medical procedure that was supposed to better their lives, the evidence is clear to see, get rid of it.20352014-03-21T20:25:35.0634507Karen HeafeyStop all mesh procedures ASAP20352014-03-21T20:34:47.9434508Carolanne mccahillPlease discontinue the use of this before it ruins any other lives.20352014-03-21T21:04:10.3434509Antonia Mcculloch Iv had Double figures for corrective surgery complications and need more surgery but state I am in it is impossible for time being . Please stop this In humane unsafe surgery affecting so many lives . 20352014-03-21T21:06:15.5334510ian muirListen to the comments and learn from this.20352014-03-21T23:26:21.214511Jemima WilliamsMy life has been devastated by POP Mesh. Even after 12 years and several operations, I am still having to go through more surgery to remove it. This time a colostomy is thought to be inevitable.\r\nDont stand by and allow other people and their family to go through this hell. Ban it now!20352014-03-21T23:31:00.7174512christina morrisonthe suffering is unbearable ..icannot handle being in an ambulance everyweek .on strong meds that dont help with the pain in between my legs .like iwant to give birtth to amesh .the stabbing pains .mental anguish for all is to much .please stop this from doing more woman suffering .20352014-03-21T23:50:06.2874513Jennifer FauldsThis is for a friend who is suffering after having mesh destroy her quality of every day living. You know who you are xxx20352014-03-22T00:36:20.5134514Lynda garlingeMesh has ruined my life, something must be done to stop this genocide upon women.20352014-03-22T02:28:06.8734515Gill WattTo many life's already ruined, robs you of every area of your life & causes great isolation & pain, please ban this product.20352014-03-22T07:48:48.9574516Helen MaxwellIts a risk thaya not worth takomg stop ot now20352014-03-22T07:51:32.7134517Morgan McGlinchey Please stop using this you have broken my mum using it nobody else shud go through this !!20352014-03-22T08:48:35.7974518linda mclaughlinplease help another human person go through the horror i have endured with stopping this now ! 9 ops later20352014-03-22T09:51:52.7674519Alexandra MurrayNational disgrace. I applaud the dignity the ladies have in the face of incomprehensible suffering. 20352014-03-22T10:00:04.514520Sue SayerI love Scotland. I hate that your government thisk it is justifiable for a multi million pound industry to shoot seals around marine farms, when viable alternatives exist such the extremely robust anti predator nets installed in Shetland.20292014-03-22T10:30:24.724521Anne-Marie SmaleStop20292014-03-22T10:43:04.454522Island manThis petition will never be taken seriously until an official one is done BY ISLANDERS. It's okay for joe blogs from Kilmarnock to say the islander should get a say but he is no islander so what right has he to even have a say he understands nothing of the history and culture of the isles.people say 30% of the oil is in Shetland water? I think you will find it will be a lot less than that as they made the boundaries with the amount of coastline each country had on the north sea.what about fishing? I am sure the pelagic men will get there quota slashes by more than three quarters ,what about the whisky distils on Orkney and the western isles do they no longer become scotch? If there are any islanders on here? You need to see through this nonsense I believe we should get greater devolved powers but this talk of independence is really getting my back up especially when it is not islanders or people who have thought so little of their"home" to stay in other parts of the country20332014-03-22T10:53:08.4734523Thomas McIlroyI still love the wife I have but have lost the wife I married to mesh complications. Please sign this petition the benefits don't outweigh the risks when patients are being disabled.20352014-03-22T11:04:34.214524James Magnus eunsonHas the snp not been bleeating on about the English opreshon against scots now they are going to do the same to the outer Islands. If that's there attitude we would be beter staying with the rest of the uk20332014-03-22T11:47:51.9034525Brian MennieThis loophole in planning application should be closed to prevent open exploitation by developers which purely for commercial gain.\r\n20402014-03-22T12:28:32.414526Allison MIllerYou cannot use these procedures without informing patients of the risk and danger .My sister is in so much pain every day someone must be held accountable for what has happened 20352014-03-22T12:30:55.6474527Hope PaganoPlease be aware that TVT Polypropylene Mesh is Toxic and can cause or trigger auto-immune diseases that can not be cured.20352014-03-22T12:47:23.064528David HewittIf you could hear them, you'd understand how annoying they are. So it's understandable it's effecting the life under the waves. Though as usual, most dont see it, so dont care.20292014-03-22T12:59:06.3134529Patricia DochertySTOP THIS PROCEDURE NOW PLEASE Thank You :)\r\n 20352014-03-22T13:29:36.9274530Fiona of the sealsPlease take this wonderful opportunity to protect seals and other wildlife from this appalling injustice.20292014-03-22T14:01:35.7734531kath threlfallSeas are beautiful animals, the only creature to destroy the planet is man, he kills at a whim, kills for pleasure. Seals don't ask for much just their food whereas the human race has a lot of foods to choose from please leave the seals alone, their beauty enriches the world. 20292014-03-22T14:33:55.5534532Beth BurnhamAt the very least the UK needs to train Dr.s to completely remove this dangerous and painful material from our bodies. We are tired of being guinea pigs for greedy corporations that do not care about our health or our futures.20352014-03-22T14:50:44.5134533Carolyn SolI am boycotting all "Atlantic" salmon until you quit these killings, because I do not want to support seal killing companies. 20292014-03-22T15:23:13.4934534Sue BaumgardtIf we continue to take over all environments, pollute and kill, we won't have a planet left worth living on20292014-03-22T16:56:08.174535Patricia ReidThis needs to be brought to the attention of everyone 20352014-03-22T17:10:38.334536Mandy CoulsonThis must stop. 20292014-03-22T17:20:56.4934538AGWThe Orkneys, the Shetlands and the Western Isles all have a unique identity, each of which is distinct from the rest of Scotland. Given the legal positions as to the Orkneys and Shetlands, certainly, there is a genuine case for a referendum. More democracy is a good thing, I say.20332014-03-22T18:40:34.024539Stephanie CrossanMy mum was offered this procedure by her doctor but after some research refused. Unfortunately my sons gran went ahead and is suffering with pain on a daily basis and her quality of life has deteriorated. This procedure needs banned 20352014-03-22T19:53:50.084540J. IrvineBetter together.20332014-03-22T20:00:10.9234541DIANE M. KASTELSAVE THE SEALS FROM BEING SHOT FOR EATING SALMON!20292014-03-23T01:09:09.3974545Samantha RooneyBan ban ban I have need left disabled Bessie's if this it's so hurtful and destoing my life !\r\n20352014-03-23T01:45:04.4834546Mr Greer Hart, seniorFor many years I have awaited a response from the Scottish Government on this issue of fish farms and their slaughter of predators in and around their cages. What appalled me was that my country had not addressed this humane issue, by enforcing the regulations governing fish cages, with regard to deterrent fencing etc to keep seals and other creatures away from the fish. If the Government follows the purpose of this petition, then it will have taken a step in bringing Scotland into a more humane and ethical way of dealing with wildlife interacting with human economic activities.20292014-03-23T06:57:41.0734547Mary WakefieldI live in US but my grandparents were from Scotland and I have a lot of family in Scotland. I unfortunately have mesh and it really has ruined my life. I visited Scotland many years ago and always hopef to return. The Scots were wondrrful oeople. Please don't allow any more people to have their lives ruined by mesh. I am reallly proud of Scotland. You seem to be on the forefront of making a statement to the entire world about the horrors of mesh. Way to go Bonnie Scotland!20352014-03-23T07:26:23.5834548Karajane HenryPlease stop these mesh procedures,not enough is known about the effects this has on womens bodies. So far the results are not good. Women are not lab rats to be used on a trial and error basis as has been the case so far. Too many women are suffering intolerable pain due to these procedures and it must end now.20352014-03-23T08:29:11.454549Elizabeth BarbourPlease, please stop this torture NOW!20352014-03-23T08:31:15.2634550Coleen McleodScottish wildlife destroyed to line the pockets of barbarians. Disgusting and unnecessary. 20292014-03-23T09:42:44.1374551Russell HogbenI think the islands have to right to self determination. Scotland says it owns the oil in the North Sea but actually a great deal of it belongs to Shetland. 20332014-03-23T09:44:22.8434552Peggy Maccormick A horrible operation.it has ruined my life.it must be banned20352014-03-23T09:45:45.4174553Michelle BarrasSigned in support of my friend who is suffering as a result of MESH. Stay strong x20352014-03-23T09:47:13.74554Yvonne TobynI remember I was told this 'MESH' would transform my life, it sure has and not for the better, the damage it causes both physically and mentally is unbelievable. 20352014-03-23T11:40:09.9774555Catherine MacDermidI have watched my young sister go from a lively person to a old unfit full of pain day and night sister since she got this operation the sad fact is it has ruined her life and robbed her husband and children of the wonderful wife and mother they had to a mother who cannot participate in everyday joy and fun you have as a parent and wife.20352014-03-23T12:36:47.5834556Magnus GearTake the island groups away from the corrupt leadership of England and Scotland. Let the island groups be an example to the world with a fair and just system of rule for the common good, not plutocratic gain. 20332014-03-23T12:45:36.324557Ruth ChesneyNo meshing......20352014-03-23T13:30:04.374559Margret Powell-JossI love to eat salmon but will boycott the product until Scotland leads the way with seal-friendly salmon farming using techniques such as on-shore farming in enclosed tank systems, proper predator exclusion nets around marine farms and a complete ban on anything that harms echolocating sea life.20292014-03-23T13:37:59.4134560mary youngI am one of many crippled by this mesh. we need to stop others being hurt.20352014-03-23T14:03:43.5474561Ali InksterFolk have been signing the petition but their names are not listed. why is this? Also the captcha has become near impossible to decipher\r\n20332014-03-23T14:12:47.9834562Joan MccormickPlease suspend these implants immediately to prevent further devastating consequences for the poor recipients. .. if you don't make it illegal they will continue to be used20352014-03-23T14:50:53.314563Jill lottI too am a victim of this dreadful implant and still suffering consequences four years on. It MUST be stopped before thousands more are irrevocably damaged.20352014-03-23T15:25:09.164565Ruth ChesneyA thing which has cut a dear friend like a cheese wire is not something that ANYONE should risk again, ever. Ever.20352014-03-23T15:29:01.344566maureen deangeloStop this operation now before more people have their lifes ruined 20352014-03-23T15:30:38.494567Fiona HudsonShould have been banned from the onset, terrible stuff! 20352014-03-23T16:59:33.0274568Catherine MurphyConsidering the amount of evidence showing worldwide concerns about current mesh procedures, it is incomprehensible to me that so few health specialists recognise that there is a problem. Its not rocket science - mesh procedures cause devastating harm - end of story!20352014-03-23T18:05:04.194569daniella wurmsPlease do not get a mesh i suffer 4 years now and this night merry is still not ending i had 4 operations and still have pain every day 20352014-03-23T18:07:10.634570Lesley Anne RomerilGood luck. A subject close to my heart. 20352014-03-23T20:44:29.974571patriciaI had routine operation for vaginal hysterectomy and a sling procedure mesh to support the prolapse of the vagina in 2003 result I nearly died had almost full body tranfussion 2nd op in 2005 still on going problems feel trapped in an old womens body I was told the risks associated with this procedure were rare and affected approximately 1-1000 people not enough information was highlight before bthe operation I thought I was alone20352014-03-23T21:12:10.6374572Catherine McLarenThis procedure has left me in agony with nerve damage and having to attend a pain clinic. Don't let go through what others have.20352014-03-23T21:30:33.0274573Jaye LeeIf a doctor tells you, "This is the NEW mesh, not the one in lawsuits", please do not listen. Every day new people from around the globe are joining mesh support groups. Many of them newly meshed with NEW mesh and loads of pain. There are other alternatives to getting a mesh implant, whether for POP, SUI or Hernia. PLEASE ask your doctors for repairs that don't use mesh. If they refuse or tell you it's the gold standard find another doctor who knows the old ways.20352014-03-23T23:23:12.894574Gillian MillikenMy mum is one of the victims of this n it's nothing short of shocking that this is allowed. This must stop now!! 20352014-03-23T23:40:00.9234575Cecilia BrydonI did not receive any information about the mesh implants, nor was I aware of an alternative procedure20352014-03-24T00:27:21.6274576Ian LeaskI Live in the Shetland Isles, this Petition should be stopped at once, this is just an attempt by unionist to cause trouble, this person Malcolm Lamont probably does not even live in any of the Island groups so has no say, and the fact that any one from any where in the uk can sign this Petition makes in invalid, not that many people would want to stay with the rest of the uk after independence anyway20332014-03-24T10:13:36.2934578Heather ArmstrongThe use of this needs to be suspended immediately, the impact on some women has been awful.20352014-03-24T10:54:54.5074579Island manAnd BTW shetland was under the Danish crown when it was pawned off back to scotland. It was part of the Pictish Kingdom as were the western isles and Orkney before they were taken by the Norse men.20332014-03-24T11:54:05.6134580Anne ChristieIs this another situation where women are ongoing\r\nguinea pigs? 20352014-03-24T13:12:26.1274581Carol WoodI holiday in Scotland because of the wonderful wildlife. Please don't trash it like England has20292014-03-24T14:03:40.354582Sheenagh GrantSurgeons are able to perform as many as six mesh operations compared to one using natural tissue!!!! D'oh!20352014-03-24T14:15:55.654584William PirieI want to remain in the UK 20332014-03-24T15:09:01.6434585Bruce JohnstonI think we should stay in the UK the SNP need their heads looked at.20332014-03-24T16:40:34.094586Andrea DonnellyWhat more information is needed before these implants are banned.My friend Karen got this done 2 years ago and has been to hell and back,something must be done to stop these operations immediately they only need to look at world wide figures20352014-03-24T18:12:31.94588julie davisAll over the world women and their loved ones are suffering and my opinion is that the corporations behind these unsatisfactorily tested devices have a lot to answer for....stop them selling and implanting these devices before more lives are ruined....20352014-03-24T19:23:45.9834589Victor MuirIf Scotland were to say 'Yes' , I would very much welcome for us in Orkney and Shetland a vote to see if the majority wish to stay in the UK and continue to be governed from Westminster .20332014-03-24T20:51:20.8934590Cecilia BrydonI was not given any information about mesh implants or that there was an alternative procedure!20352014-03-24T20:57:51.5334591DBRIf it is the settled will of the islanders to remain with the UK then so be it. Who are we (mainlanders) to deny you this vote - don't let Holyrood bully you out of your democratic right.20332014-03-24T20:58:39.2974592Thomas NugentDone x20352014-03-24T21:16:16.4034593Allan J CampbellI have to go back at least three generations to find a connection to any of the islands to which this applies - maybe that means I haven't got the necessary background information to make an informed decision here, but I prefer to think I'm looking at it with my head instead of my heart. I signed the petition because I believe that if there is sufficient desire that any people should be allowed to determine their own future. For what it's worth I think the best deal for the islands would be increased autonomy within a Scotland independent from the UK, something akin to the Aland Islands relationship with Finland, and if they wanted it would give the islands the opportunity to form closer ties to Scandinavian governments (as many commentators here seem to desire) as the Aland islands have (they hold their own seat on the Nordic Council).20332014-03-25T00:24:52.9434594Helen WestwaterI was about to get this type of surgery and if it was'nt for a chance meeting with a person who has had this mesh procedure and told me of all the complications she is now having, when I challenged my doctor about this procedure he said it was safe and I was talking nonsense. I decided after researching that I would not go through with my op. I cant thank Elaine enough for helping me. 20352014-03-25T01:49:22.9974596Carmel BerrySupporting our Scottish Mesh Injured Friends from MeshDownUnder. 20352014-03-25T02:21:41.0974597Teresa SawyerThe risks of TVM in women was never studied. The toxins in the plastics are damaging women's immune systems as well as the sharp unresearched plastics tearing at their tissues in the pelvic floor. 20352014-03-25T04:54:49.8574598Ana Maria BrownTransvaginal mesh implants destroy lives. It destroyed mine.20352014-03-25T06:07:01.8834599charlotte korteSurgical mesh needs to be taken off the market until the proper research and the necessary testing is done on the products. Too many people are being harmed.20352014-03-25T07:19:42.2734600carol For some reason the people making the decisions in Scotland regarding our natural heritage fought and died for think it's ok to destroy it in a generation for profit by global corporations. Regardless of the pollution in our sea and lochs killing everything we hold in high esteem and cherish. The beauty of our natural heritage is not yours to destroy. It belongs to us. Our ancestors preserved and protected it in order to pass this on so that we could live in a country that was self sufficient, free, full of natural wonder. It's not for sale at any price to line the pockets of global companies. If you cannot be trusted to preserve what belongs to the Scottish people as a right then you will be removed and be accountable for the devastation and destruction of our water our wildlife and our natural world. You will be named ad shamed and justice will prevail for all Scottish people and those who assist to protect our country. Seals are part of this natural wonder. They require a food source and are eating contaminated farmed salmon from fish farms full of disease and chemicals as well as other diseased fish that swim past these farms. For a handful of jobs mostly low paid to local people with very poor job opportunities in remote areas of Scotland. The large profits going to the global companies who own them. This industry is unsustainable and therefore a short term profit. So our natural world is being destroyed for short term profit for foreign investment. It is deplorable and the sooner the people responsible are named publically in the media and taken to court removed from office is not a day too soon. 20292014-03-25T07:31:29.184601Ewan MagnusWhilst I agree with the idea - I do think a referendum should be for islanders only. Better together I say.20332014-03-25T07:51:33.524602Charles LloydMy wife suffered from this treatment for over seven years until was removed. It caused unnecessary illness during this time.20352014-03-25T08:31:33.1574603Pearl LewisIf its not bad enough slaughtering badgers, foxes & wild boar, please reconsider issuing these licences to kill even more defenceless wild animals.20292014-03-25T09:12:11.9534604Richard RendallI will never in my lifetime get another chance to see an independent Scotland, so it's now or never. So vote yes and make an old man very very happy! 20332014-03-25T09:47:55.3474605Geoffrey RaynerThe people of the islands should have the same right to self determination as any other cultural or geographical grouping in the UK, or indeed anywhere. Other parts of Scotland should have the right to break off from the hegemony of the southern (ie Edinburgh)elite.20332014-03-25T10:34:48.9274606Alastair LingsA Health Board claimed that it would be too expensive to find out and report how many times people had been sedated after being forcibly restrained. They had previously reported about 50 incidences of restraint. It shouldn't be too expensive to look through the cases they had already identified, to identify a sub-set of data. It makes one wonder what information they are hiding. 20242014-03-25T10:46:23.5734607Neill HallBecome an independent country? After the shambolic administration over recent years by Shetland Islands Council do you really want to give these people more powers? Let's stay as part of Scotland and build a small successfull nation like Norway\r\n 20332014-03-25T10:57:58.3874608Colin HoustonIt os only fair that the Islands get there say too. It is not just for Salmond and the SNP to push for in dependence and then deny others the chance to determine their own destiny.....FREEDOM!\r\n20332014-03-25T12:38:21.6474609Carole AndrewThis procedure was mentioned as a possible treatment in the future for me and it scares the life out of me. We have to stop these procedures as soon as possible.20352014-03-25T14:06:22.5874610Carole WiseHow scary is this - if there's any doubt at all then it HAS TO STOP !20352014-03-25T14:29:40.1734611Jane Fitzroy SmithThe Channel Isles and Isle of Man are already in this situation and do very well so there is no reason why this cannot be successful. If they wish to be independent of Holyrood I wish them every success.20332014-03-25T14:42:53.1074612lesley kaneScary reading the comments20352014-03-25T14:56:44.1174613David BurgessIt's the Northern Isles' Oil. Not Holyrood's!20332014-03-25T15:17:24.8034614Graham LeiperDon't know how real this petition is, or if it's obfuscation by bettertogether. Re staying in UK, Isle of Man gets a 12 mile zone, not median line. Would ask somebody from there what they think of Westminster. Independence would give Shetland a lot of oil, staying in UK if Scotland became independent wouldn't. Different rules apply regards Islands in another countries waters. Have lived in Lerwick as a child, great place, but as a Soothmoother, am wondering who (and why) is behind this petition.20332014-03-25T15:57:49.3174616Linda BrownNo way should that be done - what an awful procedure20352014-03-25T16:34:24.5974617 Janina I think its appalling that women suffer so much from this procedure yet some doctors really dont care.20352014-03-25T16:59:55.4374618Irene Hart Do one for the Highlands as well as 20332014-03-25T17:08:40.394619Nick bealThe northern isles, in my case Orkney, are largely ignored by the Scottish government. If you don't live in the central belt they really couldn't give a fig about you. We would be better of staying with RUK if Scotland gets independence. We were given away as a wedding present by the king of Norway so it would be nice if Scotland gave us back!20332014-03-25T17:27:16.324620Anne Hardiethis is typical, although the problems are recognised they continue to use things like this, it's only women after all.20352014-03-25T18:30:48.974621TomLiving between Inishowen and Northern Ireland we can see the beautiful Outer Hebrides. These island are quite disconnected from Scotland and if they had more autonomy they could do greater things. I think they need some kind of economic investment to sustain themselves as an independent nation. Hopefully tourism, agriculture, fishing and maybe even oil will sustain them. It is understandable that they feel they are overlooked by the scottish parliament, the rural and even wild nature of these parts are badly connected to the mainland and maybe simply signing this petition will demonstrate that these islands need more attention, or more devolvement or even independence. Open the doors to discussion and investigate what the options are. 20332014-03-25T19:43:52.014622helen taylorno ll about the pain in hands of my lawyer 20352014-03-25T20:20:33.4634623Alison harriganThere must be something else that can be used rather than mesh...20352014-03-25T20:31:07.0474624Annmarie GrantDisgrace20352014-03-25T20:51:06.294625Jackie IrvineWe'll it is it's own island20332014-03-25T21:53:47.3734626Aaron McDaidI agree that there should be a discussion on this topic but i dont think they should go ahead with the independence votes for the islands, even to stay within the UK. Those island were part of Scotland under the UK, and should follow scotland should it vote for indepenedence, you cant pick and choose specific parts of a country because they may have some people wishing to stay within the UK. Its like Scotland voting for independence and Liverpool or Manchester calling for a vote to stay aligned with Scotland. The islands should put their fate in the hands of the referendum.\r\n\r\nOn another note, should this go ahead and the islands vote in favour to stay within the UK, doesnt that look remarkably like what happnened in Crimea? Except without the military involvement of course. Annexing scottish territory which also just so happens to hold rights to oil reserves. Some seriously dirty tricks being played here. I expect no less from the British empire.20332014-03-25T22:02:01.754627William TullochThe Islands deserve to choose their own future the same as the SNP has forced on the public of Scotland20332014-03-25T22:36:30.814628david irvine flettAm I correct Angus McNeil thinks it is a fair idea ? please correct if I got that wrong20332014-03-25T22:40:30.174629Mandy flisherwhy on earth don't you just leave these beautiful beings alone...why does man have to rip everything apart 20292014-03-25T22:56:27.0834630Di ShawSave lives not take them. 20352014-03-25T23:58:36.0134631Teresa HughesThere is a petition of same on go petition Teresa Hughes mesh is a killer make it mandatory for surgeons to report complications. Please sign20352014-03-26T00:00:47.9274632john chisholmEvery voice should be heard, fair deal all round. Go for it.20332014-03-26T02:03:33.5774633Steven Lavery This must stop now !!!!20352014-03-26T02:10:17.6674634Michael Allow life to live natural. 20292014-03-26T02:22:15.3034635Paul BrightIf Scotland feels it should be independent of Westminster because they don't want to be ruled by a distant voice then it makes sense for the Islands (and even the Highlands) to become Independent of The Edinburgh Government for the same reasons. If Ministers in London are out of touch with their fellow cities of Edinburgh and Glasgow then Holyrood certainly does not understand the needs and Culture of the rural communities to the North.20332014-03-26T09:36:04.314637Rachel ThornleySo far, the SNP in power has made it clear that they have little or no interest in Orkney and what happens here. The latest example is their review of the impact on the Isles when the lifeline ferry service was disrupted last year. If the 'Yes' vote wins, we will be completely forgotten about.20332014-03-26T10:39:15.0234638G M GrantLet your views be known!20332014-03-26T15:17:41.4374639PaulaWhy do we have to destroy every good thing God has given us and just appreciate the beauty ?20292014-03-26T15:53:34.5774640Andrew PearsonWhat next - independence for Mull or Arran?\r\nWhat about Iona, Islay or some of the other 700 plus?20332014-03-26T18:03:38.2374641Ian MacCorquodaleMy wife has suffered terribly as a result of having this procedure and has had to endure DOUBLE figure operations to try and repair the damage done to her and with another procedure now likely I fear that things will never be right for again. If you are ever in a position where this procedure is suggested as a treatment I have only one word of warning - Don't. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED !!!!\r\n20352014-03-26T18:06:11.84642Janet HunterMore research required please.20352014-03-26T18:45:01.0034643Donald MackenzieMonaco manages it. So do San Marino and Liechtenstein. Personally I prefer the status quo, but I think islanders should be able to decide in a referendum. Lets actually do democract rather than talk about it. Let's go for it. Spread the word about this petition, because if enough of us sign it the Scottish Government will HAVE to call these referenda.20332014-03-26T18:51:25.274644Kirsty PetersonThe Scottish Government should maybe wait until the petition is lodged before they respond, but the SNP should respond to it, publicly, right now. They're not the government. They're a political party. Come on! Show some leadership! What does the SNP think of this? Or do they only think that if they ignore the islanders we won't have any influence except what the Edinburgh govt allows us to have? Come on, SNP, what do you think of the idea to hold referenda in the islands on 25 Sep? For or against, and why?20332014-03-26T22:13:01.1674645wee wThe secretary of this group says,\r\nWe have no official contacts, but several of our members are either councillors or married to councillors.\r\nWe also have contacts on a completely unofficial individual level with executives and with other councillors in all three island groups.\r\n\r\nNuff said. Inspired by Bernard Ingham, who said he invented this meme to "muddy the waters of independence".20332014-03-26T22:18:21.2134646JulieSuffering in silence :-( 20352014-03-27T00:12:58.2534648Barry ClarkIf we vote in Scotland to leave the UK - The Northern Islands MUST be given the vote to leave Scotland and stay in the UK.20332014-03-27T00:17:26.1834649Carol ClarkYes lets leave Scotland the SNP have no interest in Orkney, remember last year with the lifeline ferry - and giving the ferry contract to SERCO who normally run - but badly prisons, what was wrong with Northlink, - nothing, Serco have put up all the prices on the Ferry and are actively reducing staff and the safety of Passengers.20332014-03-27T09:53:47.5034650William HunterShetlanders should be able to chose, to stay part of the UK, rather than be forced to leave.20332014-03-27T14:08:37.6234651Teresa BurtonWe just can't seem to leave these animals alone.20292014-03-27T14:17:31.2334652David BroomI agree with other commenters: islanders must get the right to stay in the UK if Scotland goes independent. Anybody who agrees, please help publicise this petition, because if it gets enough signatures, the Scottish Government will have no option but to allow us that right, and we can then actually exercise it - in September, with no nonsense. 800 signatures sounds like a lot but it isn't that many. Please can someone set up a Facebook group and publicise it. I've met one of the organisers of this petition, who is in his 60s and does not use Facebook. Young people, please help! Creat some Facebook groups and help islanders get what we want!20332014-03-27T14:17:48.0434653Barry PorteusWe want to remain British - its that simple. Our history is not that of the SNP fuelled hatred of anything south of Berwick, so let us have our own say.20332014-03-27T14:39:32.574654richardAs a Shetlander I can't imagine how disappointed I would be if we voted Scotland independent then Shetland voted to remain in the UK. A chance for change instead of the guaranteed austerity, narrow mindedness and [theft] of our countries wealth.\r\nThe chance to be the 14th richest oil producing nation as opposed to 28th as part of the UK. Don't buy into the fear of change. If we don't get out now, we condone the disgusting behaviour of westminister. Illegal wars, corruption, fraud, billions [wasted], funneled into friends businesses. \r\nPlease do some research into the viability of an independent Scotland. 20332014-03-27T16:18:30.6434655jeanI want to remain British and part of Britain - and I don't want to see any break away parts.20332014-03-27T16:56:03.6434656PeteWe should stay part of Britain it has served us well so far20332014-03-27T18:25:57.8774657John I ve been through the courts and they are not father friendly. I have started a petition too for enforcement of child access orders. Fathers decent fathers do not deserve to be treated like this. Children needs fathers and mothers and it is proven if the child has father input they grow up more rounded and to say mothers are more important is rubbish fathers can do the same jobs as a mother in bringing up their children and fathers if able and fit should have equal time with their children too. This country interferes with other countries rights and laws and human cases but ignores their own peoples rights. Come on scotland lead the way lets give fathers equal rights and time. Fix this instead of trying to fix other countries society defects 20032014-03-27T20:41:34.264658Geoff McLeishHow can the SNP goose deny equivalent choice to these three Nordic ganders? Fair's fair, surely.20332014-03-27T22:29:04.324659Craig MurdochConstitutional matters are reserved to Westminster, there is little point in petitioning the Scottish Parliament for something which is entirely out with their control.20332014-03-28T08:54:42.5774660Anne BrearCurrent mesh proceedures can cause lasting traumatic physical and psychological reaction. Wondering about the conclusions reached by clinical research in this area?20352014-03-28T12:12:04.8334661Catharine BeckThe islanders have the right to decide the status of the islands. If you agree with that statement, sign this petition. If you don't, don't.\r\n\r\nThe Scottish Government will hold these referenda on 25 September 2014 if enough people sign this petition. We expect to be successful.\r\n\r\nThe idea that it is pointless to petition the Scottish Parliament because constitutional questions are reserved to the UK Parliament is nonsense. Both Parliaments and both Governments would obviously have to respect the result of these referenda.\r\n\r\nIf the UK Parliament tried to stand in the way of the Scottish Government holding these referenda in the first place, that would be appalling and we would expect maximal support from the Scottish Government. The principle here is self-determination. That's the same principle which is behind the Scottish referendum. Let's not pack up and go home because of often facetious arguments. If you want these referenda to be held, sign this petition.\r\n\r\nIf enough people sign, the Scottish Parliament will have to support us, and so will the Scottish Government. We will then get the referenda. We have a right to them. We have had enough of representatives or others who tell us we should know our place and that such matters are for our betters. This is democracy in action. We should be proud of ourselves.20332014-03-28T12:13:51.0974662lorna farrellI have been left in agony, and severely impacted physically and emotionally- THIS HAS TO BE STOPPED- NOW!!20352014-03-28T12:50:59.1234663David MachonI would like to hear the SNP respond to the call for referenda on the islands. Right now! Will they say OK if enough people say they want them? The answer can only be "yes". Let's hear it. Now.20332014-03-29T09:53:13.8874664Patricia KnowlesThis petition is well-conceived and will have real force. But after they have signed it, people should write to Alex Salmond and ask him whether he will allow these referenda if enough people sign this petition. Yes or no. Put him on the spot!20332014-03-29T13:56:42.224665CarolineI know a few dads who get a raw deal in the courts and I feel this should be stopped. I feel that once an order has been set by the court if not followed the parent stopping it should be charged.\r\n \r\nAt the other side of it I think a parent who has been convicted of serious crimes i.e. rape, attempted murder, serious assaults to danger of life and domestic violence these parents should be stripped of their rights. \r\n\r\nChildren are always in the middle of it and its about time the courts reconise this and not just say it.20032014-03-29T16:50:45.4574666Mr harmerAll who post on here please say where you stay as it is no good people out with the isles trying to put an opinion across, when frankly they have no right too... 20332014-03-29T19:11:05.594667Jacqueline SouterIt should be banned now!!20352014-03-29T20:10:11.0074668margaret mcneilHaving looked through the list of names and where the people come from I am really surprised that a large majority of the signatories of this petition do not live on Orkney, Shetland or the Western Isles. people from England, Canada, United States etc, they would have no say in any referendum on this matter so why sign the petition?20332014-03-30T03:34:34.954669Joanna SmithLet's circulate news about this petition by email as well as by other means. Even joke petitions can get thousands of signatures nowadays, just because they go "viral" by email. The petition for referenda in the islands is serious, worthwhile, and significant. It should get as many signatures as possible. I know a circular email has started. If you receive it, please forward it. Otherwise, please write your own and send them to friends, family members and contacts. And remember to include a link to this site, to make it easy for people! Thanks! Joanna in Stromness20332014-03-30T03:38:48.7774670David SmithYes. If you want to help this petition more than just by signing it, please circulate the news by email, telling people what it's about and giving them a link to this site. This includes members of local Better Together groups. Don't be shy!20332014-03-30T03:42:12.4634671Bertha Marpey67 percent of "Scotland's" oil is Shetland's. If Shetland stays in the UK while Scotland goes independent, all of that oil stays with the UK. If Shetland goes independent on its own, that oil goes with Shetland. 67 percent!! Source: Jonathan Brown's article in the Independent, 26 March.20332014-03-31T00:33:56.8174672Lydia ReidA Child has a right to both parents\r\n\r\nA child has the right to know and love both parents\r\n\r\nA Child has a right to direction, love and care from both parents\r\n\r\nIt is time the right of the child became uppermost in law.\r\n\r\nIt is time the best interest of the child is truly enshrined in law\r\n\r\nIt is time the right of a child to both parents in their life is enshrined in law\r\n\r\nIf a parent whether that be a mother or a father is a bad parent then any child is better of without that parent but if they are a loving parent then the child has a right to equal time with that parent. \r\n\r\nFor too long our laws have been influenced by the current and "trendy" campaign groups that leave fathers feeling they have no right to spend time with their children\r\n\r\nVery often fathers are made out to be uncaring and unloving and people who leave their children.\r\n\r\nThe truth is that often they are pushed out of the lives of their children.\r\n\r\nA law that says a child has a right to know and love both parents would change the lives of children in Scotland\r\n\r\nAll it needs is a group of MSPs that see what is needed\r\n20032014-03-31T07:51:23.9434673Dave BallardWhy shouldn't the highlands & Islands get their own powers\r\n20332014-03-31T09:44:20.1734674James HarrisEverybody has a right to sign this petition who supports the islanders being able to decide the status of their islands. Signatures are very welcome from everyone who supports that aim, regardless of where they live. If an islander does not wish to have a say in the future of their island group, all they have to do is abstain in the island referendum. I live in Shetland and 90% of my friends and neighbours and family have signed this petition.20332014-03-31T11:11:22.9734675Sheena ReidI feel that the North East of Scotland -Moray, Banff and Aberdeen Shires should also be given the choice to stay in the UK as we have a different culture also Pictish - Norse. Some of us do not want to be governed by the Central Belt.20332014-03-31T18:49:00.2934676dougie ritchiegot a reocurring hernia and was given transvaginal mesh implant that has turned my life upside down due to severe chronic pain after operation was done 3 years ago ..now my hospital uralogy said there was nothing more they can do but send me to painclinic ..so pain clinic said it was nuralogical and was all in my head ..i know what pain is but since i got mesh put in i am in bed 6-7 days a week ..i was a fit 42 year old and very fit and was told i would be back building in 6 weeks and that was 3 year ago and i am in agony ..i have no freinds or social life since day my operation was done..i raked the internet for more help and found on an american site the name off Proffessor Dr patrick Odwyer who is the co founder of the brittish Hernia society at glasgow university..so i emailed Dr Odwyer and got my doctor to refer me to him ..so now getting operation in 2 weeks to see why i am in so much pain ..according to the american site .it said he is the only Dr .. who can take mesh out and help ease the pain ..Ban this mesh ..does anyone have a site on this terrible implant. i am 45 and my life is wasting away in my bed. ..20352014-03-31T20:51:44.5774685david irvine flettNearly at the 1000 already !20332014-03-31T21:06:18.9534686L WeatherleySomeone with some sense!20332014-03-31T22:57:43.9574687David InnesLocal authorities everywhere need more empowerment. These are the political structures cl i sest to people, many of whom feel that Edinburgh is as remote and out of touch with their locality as London currently is. Freedom for pre-1974 Banffshire. 20332014-03-31T23:20:12.9734688kath threlfallSurely the human raace can find many more good things to eat instead of plundering the oceans and killing so many animals and fish.20292014-04-01T01:53:37.0174689Ali InksterThose folks complaining about people signing the petition when they don't live in the isles please note many islanders live all over the world forced to by lack of opportunity at home. And many might want to return to independent islands with the opportunity that will bring for them and their families. So why should they be barred from signing the petition.20332014-04-01T12:24:35.2874690susanne sturgeonhad the mesh fitted in 2009 and I am still in pain after several operations on numerous medications feel its ruined my life.20352014-04-01T14:36:43.4534691Andrew Craig-BennettI first heard about repaying the dowry in the bar of the Queens Hotel in September 1977. It struck me as a good idea, then, and I think it's a good idea, now. 20332014-04-01T16:19:19.364692James WattMy family came from the Western Isles (Harris), but left three generations ago for economic reasons. We have flourished elswhere in the UK and abroad but still retain a close interest in the affairs of the Isles. I do not welcome the 'Balkanisation' of the UK - but feel that the Isles deserve better than to be governed by the Lothian belt politocracy.20332014-04-01T16:44:22.2934693Elaine HolmesDougie Ritchie \r\n\r\nPlease contact Scottish Mesh Survivors Facebook page.\r\nBest wishes\r\n\r\nElaine 20352014-04-01T21:24:42.814694May GahaganI dont know where to start my daughter Elaine Holmes who I am very proud of for the research and fight she is putting up to get this mesh banned\r\nso that nobody will suffer what her and all you other women have go get them Elaine. x\r\n20352014-04-01T21:36:01.4234695John I have just read the other two posts above mine and I couldn't agree more. I am lawful I am a nurse I have a pay freeze but went into debt as I can't get legal aid to obtain an order and the mother changes it when I contacted the law they said they can't do anything to enforce it. I have since started a petition to change the law which I am waiting for them to approve so you can all see it. I have also contacted all msp members and got replies today saying their going to take it to parliment to ask the law to be changed so let's hope it does as I am now having to go into more debt to go back to court to have my order enforced which is unbelievable as an order should be enforced from the get go. But I am willing to get broke so I have my daughter in my live. Ironically if I were a drug addict or that I woukdnt need to pay a penny to go to court as legal aid would cover them. Where is the justice in this country. We stick our beaks into other countries here's a hint to the scottish parliment. FIX YOUR OWN COUNTRY FIRST BEFORE PREACHING TO OTHERS.... 20032014-04-01T23:15:35.934696Karen neilDougie Ritchie, please fell free to come join us on our support group page on Facebook called Scottish Mesh Survivors...were we can help you talk with others in similar position as yourself. No more feeling alone.20352014-04-02T10:48:54.8674697Jules RedmanI am absolutely gobsmacked and disgusted that you give permits for the destruction of beautiful, innocent wild seals for the benefit of financial, human gain - who told you that you had the right to do this...almost lost for words, there is too much destruction, death and devastation in this beautiful world - IT IS NOT YOUR RIGHT TO KILL SEALS!!! PLEASE STOP20292014-04-02T11:28:05.7734698scott mackayplease show respect to all, seals and salmon20292014-04-02T14:01:18.294699June linarts Why is can't we live in harmony with other animals we have depleted their food source through over fishing now we are killing them it's just so wrong. 20292014-04-02T16:37:12.514700J ScoIt is indicative of how communities are not consulted with regards to planning applications. The planning laws seem to be on the applicants side, rather than the opposition or the community. Councillors try to hide behind red tape and officials but at the end of the day they still have the power to refuse and allow it to be appealed. After all councillors are there to represent the people who elected them but that is all forgotten when an election is over and a candidate returned, after all it's a job, since councillors are now paid as opposed to what it used to be be.20402014-04-02T16:41:40.874701Ji ScoSame complaint time after time about regulators failing to properly regulate and people wonder why this country is in the state that it finds itself today!20242014-04-02T19:30:25.124702marie richmondI am so shocked that you allow the killing of beautiful seals god gave them life its not yours or anyone's to take away animals suffer all over the world and its always humans that is cruelest20292014-04-02T19:52:16.3474704Lesley McDadeDestroyed my friend quality of life, now has limited mobility and in tremendous pain.20352014-04-03T06:55:10.424706Melanie BarrettStop slaughtering seals!!!!20292014-04-03T07:00:40.5634707A P WilliamsThe Scottish Govt, having destroyed the wild salmon populations, aims to now industrially destroy all other competing populations. 20292014-04-03T10:24:26.034708kathleen AronThis should be banned now20352014-04-03T15:01:54.7134709john c laurensonI was born in Shetland, went to school in England, and have worked all over the UK. I consider myself British, and as a Shetlander certainly not Scottish. We have no traditions involving tartan, kilts or tam-o'-shanters, gaelic, or hurling cabers around at the highland games. \r\n\r\nA few years ago, pre-oil, the average scotsman had very little idea where the Shetland islands were.\r\n \r\nAnd as for Alec Salmond, he seems determined, through systematic centralisation, to take all he can from the islands. Fire service and NHS lately.\r\n\r\nHistory can tell us what the Scottish lairds and lords did to the islands, and its inhabitants. They were cruel taskmasters. They cant blame the English for that.\r\n\r\nI have no wish to be classified as Scottish.20332014-04-03T16:27:51.5534710MORAG NICOLSONPlease suspend mesh procedures now! 20352014-04-03T16:46:05.7934711Jan McGarryPlease treat women with the respect they deserve20352014-04-03T18:07:33.0174712isla macaulayI support the petiton\r\n20352014-04-03T22:09:45.974713Alastair MacintyreI would encourage Orkney, Shetland and WI to hold a separate referendum and perhaps split away from Scotland if a yes vote happens. Indeed Fife where I stay could become a separate country. We have water to the North, East and South and would only need a land border at the west. We could make our money by charging Edinburgh people extortionate rates to enter the kingdom20332014-04-04T03:24:39.9434714Catherine DonnellyAt last this Mesh procedure is being exposed and should be banned. 20352014-04-04T06:41:26.2174715Stacy Seymour7 surgeries, never the same.....20352014-04-04T10:13:18.9534716Susan ThompsonThis is an incredibly bad idea. I support Reforesting Scotland's Thousand Huts campaign, and the adoption of Tan6 low impact planning regs (or others which are easier to understand and comply with which allow low impact dwelleings to be built where people are working on the land). As has been stated elsewhere-'sign this if you want.. bungalows and pastiche mansions with three garages stretching for miles around every town...abolishing planning permission would be carte blanche for high impact car-dependent suburbia'. Also, this 'is a neoliberal solution...to a neoliberal problem, when what we need is a democratic, social solution to that problem'. Restrictions on landbanking by construction companies might help with the problem of the housing shortage, but more social housing and land reform is the only way to solve this, not by allowing anyone rich enough to buy land and build, probably without a mortgage being available in the circumstances outlined in the petition. 20202014-04-04T12:25:45.5334717Ann BoniAs far as I am concerned the Scottish Government have no other option but to suspend the use of this mesh. The devastating damage done to ladies is life changing, life threatening and life long. Stop this procedure NOW before any more lives are ruined.20352014-04-04T14:31:11.024720David MorrisThis is a brilliant idea. The only reason why some people who consider themselves to be land radicals oppose it is that they do not understand that it would crash land prices and make land easily available to the majority of the population.20202014-04-04T15:28:39.5434721Michelle AffleckStop killing seals it is cruel. They are gorgeous creatures.20292014-04-04T20:42:42.984722Lisa price It's in -humane practice to kill gods beautiful creatures 20292014-04-05T16:19:58.1434723Dawn HarrisonWhen we associate seal slaughter we think of Canada. When we think of dolphin and whale slaughter, we think of Japan. Please don't allow Scotland to be associated with any kind of slaughter. Leave the seals alone.20292014-04-05T17:09:40.3674724KevinWhats next, viliages and towns wanting independence, worst idea ever.20332014-04-06T00:22:37.64725J. Cartwright I stopped buying Scottish salmon years ago because of the detrimental affects they have on the wildlife and the surrounding environment. Please impose a ban on shooting seals and force companies look for a more environmentally friendly way to farm salmon. 20292014-04-06T11:03:45.1974727Janice MurrayI am one of the unfortunate women who has been left in pain for 2 years now after this operation. I can only sit to one side and can't walk or run anymore. If I had known the consequence of this mesh, I never would have got it done. I work for the health board and know they are still using it to this day (April 2014). They don't care. 20352014-04-06T14:12:35.664728Joyce CoxStop killing any wild creature unless really need to.20292014-04-06T15:19:25.6574729Anne WatsonIf this petition helps even 1 person it will be worth it.20352014-04-06T16:29:23.554730Margaret McBride I'm supporting this petition as I have also had mesh fitted & I've said all along I would never have recommended it to anyone.20352014-04-06T17:28:35.5034731Bill StonesIf we have to be ruled by someone else, better the enemy you know than the one you don't20332014-04-06T17:33:31.664732Mark CarterThere are numerous valid reasons not to shoot seals including the use of non-lethal methods. This government should stand up against the will of these industries that mainly rely on false propaganda to try to overcome their own short-commings.20292014-04-06T20:35:23.6374733Rosie DowerThere are more humane ways to deter seals. Spend the money on seal exclusion nets not paid killers!!20292014-04-06T22:09:16.144734Yol. SakyiSeals do not belong to us humans.\r\nLike we do, they belong to the planet Earth. We've no right to kill them. So please stop slaughtering!!20292014-04-06T22:15:09.124735P CrightonWhich part of killing sentient mammals is right in this day and age ? \r\nPlease stop the killing of defenseless creatures.20292014-04-06T23:05:18.0034736Margaret BellShocking not getting told of the risks envolved 20352014-04-06T23:44:31.5534737Raymond Hardacre This procedure has changed our lives, adversely! My wife has struggled from the moment she woke up from surgery, 2010. Why are they still "selling" these products to the medical authorities? Why are they still offering these procedures to unsuspecting patients, when all risks are now well known and data is now available to prove these risks have existed from the very beginning in the mid nineties? How can any patient ever trust again? 20352014-04-07T08:32:06.7134739jackie mitchellMy sister in law has went through years of pain due to this mesh.20352014-04-07T08:32:54.2934740Bernard WalkerMy sister has went through hell.20352014-04-07T11:33:30.5774742Holly McLaughlinPage Three is not news. The naked women on page three does not deserve to be the the largest picture of a women in a national newspaper. A women's body is not entertainment, and nor should it be treated as such IN A FAMILY NEWSPAPER. 20572014-04-07T11:34:04.924743James SmithIt's Shetland's oil - and the SNP has got no answers to that, except ones that depend on tricksy wordplay.\r\n\r\nOf course there should be referenda in the islands. If Scotland goes independent, most people I know in Shetland will want to stay in the UK. We should get a chance to choose that option.\r\n\r\nBy the way, can I say a big thankyou to people outside the islands who have signed this petition to support our right to decide the status of our islands. Your support is much appreciated. Please keep it coming!\r\n\r\nIn response to Bill's comment about better to be ruled by the enemy you know. I'm not sure what you mean, but it's interesting that in Scotland the turnout in UK general elections is significantly higher than the turnout in Scottish general elections.20332014-04-07T11:35:17.814744Mark StickleyGood idea. It's an outdated institution that needs tearing down to make way for progress and enlightenment.20572014-04-07T11:35:20.7174745Patricia MullenLong overdue!!!20572014-04-07T11:39:51.4534746Rachel Fitzpatrick It's a daily reminder to society that woman should be sexually available and desired. As if that's all they have to offer. It's harmful.20572014-04-07T11:46:18.3634747Lauren JonesNo more page 3!20572014-04-07T11:48:53.774748Hazel WilliamsWe don't need naked women in a newspaper, no excuses 20572014-04-07T11:51:33.2234749Terri smith Scotland's next generation of newsreaders are against page 3, it's time for change. 20572014-04-07T11:52:11.3334750Eleanor HillNo more page 3!20572014-04-07T12:01:23.4934751Dan WheelerTime for it to go20572014-04-07T12:06:08.4634752Chloe Tisnley-HallPage Three is out-dated! Women are not objects!20572014-04-07T12:17:19.294753Pearl JacksonIt's time the 'Sun' woke up to the fact that they are old fashioned, outdated and shameful! 20572014-04-07T12:36:50.9074754CEmbarrassing. No place in Scotland. 20572014-04-07T12:46:45.3674755Lynne CoulstockSorry what year are we in again? Why is this still acceptable? 20572014-04-07T12:55:21.6974756Rachel MossIt's 2014 - boobs are not news.20572014-04-07T13:20:05.4134757Lesley McilwraithPage 3 is degrading to women and embarrassing to Scotland as nation - it has to stop!20572014-04-07T13:22:41.5234758Lee shanksPage 3 has no place in modern society - it's about time the sun came in to the 21st century.20572014-04-07T13:27:33.8234759Jill smithWhy is page 3 still in existence? All it does is perpetuate the notion that women are 2nd class citizens who contribute noting to society except their breasts - is this the message you really want to be conveying to young scots, it's time for long overdue change.20572014-04-07T13:30:45.6034760Victoria BrownScotland can really lead the way on this issue and take a stand against the objectivation of women in the media.20572014-04-07T15:02:59.2034761Jack FletcherThe Scottish Government needs to make more of a stand against media sexism and promote gender equality.20572014-04-07T15:46:29.4074763Hugh TobynMy wife is another victim. She has had symptoms for years but kept being told that it's media hype, not too worry, symptoms unlikely to be caused by the 'TVT Mesh' implant put in for stress incontinence in 2008. At last she has the truth and having seeked a second opinion by another Consultant - you've guessed it, her Mesh is indeed the problem. Just awful, she suffers, the kids suffer watching their Mum in pain and all I can do is watch in the hope that after her surgery to remove this awful product my happy, cheerful wife of old returns. 20352014-04-07T16:16:57.0634764Making HerstoryThere is no place for a Page Three in any country which declares to be striving for equality between men and women: its very existence, belittles and degrades one half of the population in they eyes of BOTH halves of the population. The Scottish government must make its stance on Page 3 clear and act towards its demise: to not do so, suggests the biggest fans of this kind of 'literature' sits within...20572014-04-07T16:22:08.334765Rebecca WalkerThis is an extremely worthwhile campaign which draws attention to misrepresentation in the media, paving the way sexual violence. 20572014-04-07T17:01:05.994766Sarah-Jane JamesIt's great that Scotland has a vision of gender equality but any vision or strategy needs action, not just policy and empty words. By taking the action we ask, not only will you lead the way for other parliaments to follow, you will be greatly helping to shift cultural attitudes by saying: we won't tolerate sexism and neither should you. Without a shift in cultural attitudes, we will never create a gender-equal society. The media, especially a paper with such large readership as The Sun that is available to children and teenagers to see, is negatively affecting cultural attitudes by perpetuating and reinforcing sexism. 20572014-04-07T17:13:30.0434767louise munroPlease sign20572014-04-07T17:50:43.4934768Mark SkipseySociety has significantly changed since 1970. I wonder if the Sun newspaper has the bottle and the foresight to reflect this fact. 20572014-04-07T18:11:03.8374769Jessica ShentonPage 3 and the associated gender inequality fed to the nation every day in the Sun newspaper normalises the objectification of women in wider society. This feature does not exist within a cultural vacuum, and if women are to be taken seriously in politics, law, business, academics and the wide array of unequal professions in our society, our media must treat them as equals. Page 3 does not fit in with the aims of our progressive scottish parliament. 20572014-04-07T19:16:09.7874770Carol HeggieGood cause20292014-04-07T19:34:03.0374771Janet Reid Time to put your hands up and admit these people you operated on was the surgeons fault.20352014-04-07T20:55:10.64772Adam CookPorn should be kept with porn not in our newspapers!20572014-04-07T21:09:59.434773HamishWhat complete nonesense. I suggest Scotland calls on Russia to invade our native soils which for a time were invade by external forces.\r\nPlease tell me if the custom posts would be in Wick or Stromness or Aberdeen?20332014-04-07T21:30:13.1234774Joanne BentleyMaking seals into scapegoats because of decades of negligent stewardship of fish-stocks is as monstrous as American "good-ol'-boys" shooting wolves on sight for the loss of an occasional cow.\r\nThis all must stop. Wake up, get sane. Now.20292014-04-08T05:53:56.774775Kevin TullockNo way! Scottish Independence or bust, plain and simple!20332014-04-08T11:09:13.424776JoannePlease get rid of page 3. It's disgusting and objectifying. My little sister reads is and things she should look like these big busted women. She is wanting a breastfeeding enlargement. On the news they don't interrupt it for a show of tips. It's making the readers stupid. I'm sure you should respect that women read this too! If you continue it took should be equal with naked men on page 3 every second day! It's pathetic, outdated, and embarrassing! 20572014-04-08T11:13:27.2374777Ariadne RobinsonThe argument in favour of the referenda is clear: the islanders have a right to decide.\r\n\r\nThe argument against? There isn't one. People say things like "get back to Russia" or "why can't villages go independent?", but they aren't arguments - sorry.20332014-04-08T11:16:11.444778Frank JonesHamish - you don't get it, which is probably why you open by saying "What complete nonesense." Sarcastically saying you want a Russian invasion isn't an argument. As for customs posts? Please read what this petition is for. It isn't for independence. It isn't for a change. It isn't for the status quo. It is for *referenda* so that the islanders can democratically decide which option they prefer. Not sure that you understand about customs post either. Have you travelled between France and Germany recently? Or the Republic of Ireland and the UK?20332014-04-08T12:10:40.4174779Jane Morgan TownshendThe salmon are trapped and farmed, wrong. The seals are being killed for trying to feed from an 'easy catch', wrong. Stop farming the salmon, stop killing the seals for doing what is natural and let nature take its course. Imagine being shot at every time you shopped for food.20292014-04-08T12:22:57.094780DaveSurely the SNP would support an Isles referendum. Their reason for existing is that they do not believe that smaller, more distant communities should not be ruled by their larger southern neighbour who does not understand their needs. So obviously they would not want Orkney to be ruled by Edinburgh and the central belt.\r\n20332014-04-08T13:33:44.714782Another Islander who wishes people would stop using us as propaganda materialThis is not democracy, our Councillors don't know the meaning of the word democracy. They have no mandate from us to be asking for this. We are already getting a vote on UK or Scotland, lets focus on that. Stop playing games with our future.20332014-04-08T14:18:59.594783Lilian BrooksMy family has been severely affected by the after effects of this barbaric plastic mesh implant. It is clear from the support for this petition and reading all the comments that this scandal is off the scale! Why are surgeons still using plastic mesh when so many lives have been devastated? Is money more important than human beings?\r\nGet your act together Scotland and ban this stuff!20352014-04-08T14:24:57.014784HamishFrank Jones \r\n\r\nWhat this is all about is a couple of anti YES campaigners trying to cause some upset. But we have been here before. If islanders from Barra in the West, up the west coast and North to Orkney and Shetland wish to be heard more they will need to vote YES. Then all of the peoples making up this country will be able to be heard and demand local democracy that works. Voting No will mean such concerns are buried for a generation.\r\n\r\n20332014-04-08T16:42:27.864785John McAndrewIn response to the comment made at 13.33: of course a referendum is democracy, so long as all serious options are included, which they will be.\r\n\r\nAs for a mandate, the whole point of a referendum is to give the politicians a mandate. Let the people decide.\r\n\r\nYou tell us to focus only on the Scottish referendum, but why? Did you say that before the Scottish referendum was announced? Personally I want us to stay in Scotland if it stays in the UK and to leave Scotland if it doesn't. Nobody is playing games with anybody's future. Why don't you trust your fellow islanders to make the right decision?20332014-04-08T16:48:12.314786Frank JonesHamish: if you think that whether or not islanders' concerns are addressed depends so starkly on the result on 18 Sep, then you should support the holding of islands referenda on 25 Sep. Why? Because if the islands referenda are held, then our concerns will certainly be addressed. It won't matter what the result was on 18 Sep. We won't be dependent on whether people in Perth or Galashiels vote or against Scottish independence. At the end of the day, it is up to us to make our voices heard, and the best way for that happen is in clear, no-nonsense referenda on the islands. The announcement of the date should be made within a month of when this petition gets lodged, in my opinion. 25 Sep sounds fine to me.20332014-04-08T18:21:53.7834787david irvine flettA significant number of people in the islands would like the opportunity of such a referendum - always have. Not everybody on the islands by any means. The point of the request for signatories to a petition explores that. If the number interested is only two or three then that's that. However the islands historical links with Scandinavia and subsequently the often unusual relationship with Scotland make them somewhat \r\nUnique. Orkney folk are smart enough not to be hi-jacked by badly motivated folk looking for more personal power in a smaller pool -if that's the case nobody will sign the petition nor vote in a referendum if there is one. We either put in place representatives we trust who we empower to make decisions on our behalf or we have reps who simply refer our views and desires people's reps and then have who shouts loudest democracy. Anyhow we have a vote , if we feel strongly we can stand up and state our party and policy. If this petition and referendum is daft idea or worse stilt a badly motivated coup by ambitious councillors it will be easily seen through and disappear. I don't believe that and do think it is great chance for islanders to really say what they want - if islanders don't want to they won't.\r\n20332014-04-08T19:55:07.5234788Lee-Ann RatcliffI was 25 years old when I had the TVT put in and I was lead to believe it was better than the old procedure. A week after the procedure I ended up with a urine infection, and since then it has become a never ending thing to the point I am on an antibiotic full time. As time has progressed it has affected my life in other ways. I have been suffering from sharp stabbing pains that is sometimes so bad I pass out. break into a cold sweat or that I can barely walk. This does not help matters and shows how bad the pains are because I am on extremely strong pain killers for my hip due to having had a full hip replacement, this gives you a clear indication of how painful it can get. It has also affected my marriage as it has become painful to have sex. Within the last year I have developed another problem I have been finding it difficult to pass urine at times I can not pass urine at all.\r\n\r\nI hope other women will never have to suffer this way.. We have laws in place to prevent genital mutilation in young girls and women in other countries. Is this not a form of mutilation and disabling women so severely that it affects their lives and that of their entire family. 20352014-04-08T21:18:35.7634790Irene HamiltonI have witnessed first hand the terrible pain and complications following this surgery on my life long best friend. If this petition can help government listen and to take action to prevent woman being subjected to the horrible aftermath endured by some woman then I fully endorse this petition.20352014-04-08T22:16:09.8374791Tracy JamesEvery day sexism. This hangover from the sexist 70s should have been abolished decades ago. Even The Mirror stopped this in the 80s stating it was degrading to women. It is degrading and offensive.\r\n20572014-04-08T23:09:26.9234792Charles HallierProtection of these is a must. Government intervention has always been proven to be wrong. 20292014-04-09T01:32:02.4374793Kenneth DonaldsonPage 3 has got to be stopped! It has caused so much harm to lives of young women already, don't let it continue. The women of our good Scottish nation deserve better than this.20572014-04-09T11:07:45.384794Pauline NelsonAfter 2 operations (1 inserting the mesh and another trying to remove it) I am still having problems and pain. This procedure must be stopped now as some hospitals are still using this method. Have they not read about the problems people are having with the Mesh Implants!! 20352014-04-09T11:40:24.944795Ann Boni"I feel as if I am an unsuspecting, unwilling participant in a cruel experiment that has gone wrong"20352014-04-09T13:46:29.7474797JadeA THINKING world will give us equality. EQUALITY will give us a thinking world. To save this planet, to respect the inhabitants of this planet we need to THINK. WE can do that can't we!?20572014-04-09T14:38:56.6774798Gary HollywoodI urge everyone to show their support and put a STOP to this once and for all !!! Don't delay please sign this petition 20352014-04-09T17:39:46.1074800elizabeth murrayi have not been affected with with this type of operation but i do support the petition to stop this happening to anyone else there have been too many so far it is didpicable to continue to use these materials when there has been proof of the injuries that some of the women have suffered time to put an end to it.20352014-04-09T19:43:59.7334801Jan Houston I as very woman ,just ca,nt believe the pain and destruction this has caused , my family have been torn apart through this ,it mus t be stopped ASAP 20352014-04-09T21:48:06.744802margaret belleverybody should be told about the risks involved using the mesh then you can make an imformed choice , I read about it the day after I got home from hospital this has got to stop NOW\r\n20352014-04-09T22:36:28.8734803Bianca PymontGet the degrading smut out of the sun and fill it with what it's meant to contain - NEWS!20572014-04-10T07:16:28.944805Loretta Reid What an embarrassment indeed for Scotland! Sort this now! How disgusting that we are doing this to seals!! Heartbreaking and Immoral. The fishing is bad enough but killing even 1 seal is abhorrent. Do the right thing , NOW ! 20292014-04-10T09:17:40.2074806Teresa BurtonWe have same problem in the USA. They are having lawsuits against mesh problems. People are dying and have major problems. Thank you.20352014-04-10T11:28:59.114807Estie KretschmerThe animals of the world exist for their own reasons. They were not made for humans any more than black people were made for white, or women created for men. (Alice Walker)20292014-04-10T13:33:35.1774808LyndaShocked and appalled, must be stopped straight away20352014-04-10T14:09:07.9834809Austin FletcherSeals are vital part of coastal ecosystems and are embedded in Scottish culture and literature. Please preserve and protect them. 20292014-04-10T17:35:59.5574810SusanCan't believe that this mesh is still being used - to save money!!!!!20352014-04-10T20:02:00.5234811john moffatIs there really demand for this? By September we will all be done with the referendum - and to think we can have another straight after when we'll not have had time to properly digest the results of the first is ridiculous. 20332014-04-10T21:43:01.084812teresa ann mitchellHow many more lives will be affected with this malpractice20352014-04-10T21:44:31.4934813Lizzy BlanchThe manufacturers of the mesh have known for a long time that it has the potential to cause terrible pain and suffering. This procedure is barbaric and must be discontinued.20352014-04-10T21:48:54.484814Lynne Parker A good friend of mine as has suffering after surgery with this mesh, it should be abolished ASAP 20352014-04-10T21:57:50.4634815PaulineIt is totally unacceptable for a father to be denied parental rights under any circumstances (unless he is an unfit parent)\r\n\r\nI speak from personal experience. As a child, I was not allowed to see my father. My mother denied him his rights by denying that he was my father even though she continued for many years to accept financial support from him.\r\n\r\nBoth my parents are dead and I only ever got to meet my father once as a young adult. it was too difficult to develop a relationship due to all the anger and rejection felt by both of us.\r\n\r\nI pray that this legislation will be changed so that no other child has to deal with the pain of 'rejection' for no reason other than spite of the other parent.20032014-04-10T22:10:14.564816Kim ZwickerStop killing animals!!!20292014-04-10T22:12:09.244817MariWhy do so many men think it is okay to buy a newspaper and look at nude or semi nude women?20572014-04-11T04:58:20.7674818Martha MilneWe should be preserving and protecting our wildlife, not killing them for specious reasons. This is so anti-nature and so counter-productive. You are hurting yourselves and working against any gains that are to be made in this situation. Please stop killing the seals! You aren't going to end up with more salmon and are actually messing up the natural balance which will make everything much worse in the end!20292014-04-11T07:25:05.2134819Victor maneiGood job seals are too getting threatened and pushed to death not only in scotland but all over the world islands 20292014-04-11T10:40:41.884820Rory CowanHorrendous ! We must put a stop to this immediately let's get signed up all x Best Wishes Rory Cowan 20352014-04-11T10:41:59.8974821Mr C CarusI believe in self determination. 20332014-04-11T11:06:35.444822Ross CombeHorrible and must be stopped20352014-04-11T11:42:33.5934824Maria hose I have been suffering from the side effects of this TVS since 2001. Please stop its use20352014-04-11T12:42:10.0074825Elaine Margaret SingerTotally appalled. Urgent action needed to halt this now!20352014-04-11T12:43:43.6534826Brian H Donohoe MPSerious thought should be given to ban this procedure across the U.K. immediately and I will be asking Parliamentary Questions about the situation20352014-04-11T13:15:32.7934827Morag MaciverThe three island groups would have twice as much sea area as Scotland! This will belong to the UK if the islands stay in the UK, and it will belong to the islands themselves if they go independent. Click here for details: i58.tinypic.com(slash)ao7udz.jpg\r\n\r\nDenmark has a 200-mile economic zone around the Faroe Islands. A similar zone (up to the midpoints with other countries where necessary) would exist around the islands.20332014-04-11T13:17:14.7834828David BrownThe islands issue finishes the call for Scottish independence. Only a lunatic would now back Scottish independence. Without the islands, Scotland loses 67% of its oil and 70% of its sea area. The country could go bankrupt within the first week.20332014-04-11T15:27:58.934829Barbara MaloitPlease stop this senseless slaughter. It harkens to the slaughter of the dolphins in Japan for equally senseless reasons. Animals in the wild balance themselves, we have no need to interfere.20292014-04-11T17:14:13.034830Ian LeaskWhat really annoyes me is the fact that most people signing this Petition, don't even live on the islands, I live in the shetlands isles, I want Scotland to be independent and the isles to be part of that, and not part of some Westminster agenda, which is what this is, and I will be voting YES SCOTLAND no matter what, yes it is shetlands oil, but we are part of Scotland and not england20332014-04-11T17:40:32.574831Karen NeilPlease help us be first country to stop this awful product being used. If there was a product that could be used as means of torture in the 21st century ,then TVT TVTO POP,hernia mesh is it. It has single handily has ruined lives and peoples mental health has suffered greatly,along with the other effects of repeated surgeries . 20352014-04-11T18:16:24.3474832FJ CouzensMyself and my family visit Scotland on average 4 times per year specifically to see and photograph the wildlife. Why would anyone harm a natural National asset ?20292014-04-11T18:58:31.4774833Barbara B MillerStop the killing of innocent species.\r\n20292014-04-11T19:34:02.234834Diane CartonA Newspaper should not show Women as Naked Objects. A newspaper is that it inform's the public of important issues. It isn't supposed objectify half the population.20572014-04-12T00:55:19.3034835AdamGood on the islanders for standing up to Mr Salmond. Every drop of revenue from oil will be needed to prevent an ailing Edinburgh from economic collapse and you can be sure that Orkney and Shetland will be left with nothing. If Mr Salmond is so sure about self determination then he should have no problem with this? I truly hope the UK does not rip itself apart, but hopefully this independence debate will bring about a more federal system. This isn't just about Scotland v England - Wales and Northern Ireland contribute so much to what makes up this unique union of nations. 20332014-04-12T08:11:08.484836Vivien FraserHumans have no right to kill these wild animals20292014-04-12T08:51:19.164837Diana Please let's be a protective force in this world not a destructive one!!! 20292014-04-12T18:45:13.7634838laureFor the THE DIGNITY OF WOMEN ! MORE RESPECT !! NO BOOBS IN MAGAZINES !!20572014-04-12T19:20:39.6434839andy conleyLike all the other husbands and partners out there this product has taken the light out of my wife and its is still a nightmare if you have any sence aviod the product like you would avoid the plaque20352014-04-13T07:25:23.9674840Paul DaviesIf Alex Salmond demands self-determination for the Scottish people on the grounds of their unique heritage, then it is only right that he should allow the same for the people of the Isles who also have their own unique hertitage.20332014-04-13T14:28:24.5334841CATHERINE BESTi had this proceedure done and i am classed disabled because of the side effects do something now to suspend this .before someone dies through complications\r\n20352014-04-13T19:16:42.1174842Kirsty Macdonald When Scotland's commons are in severe decline I can't even begin to understand why this should go ahead. 20292014-04-13T20:15:38.64843jean allenhow do I know what type of mesh I was given and how can I find out if affected me as I have back and stomache pain thx20352014-04-13T20:25:41.7974844Barbara MitchellSupporting Annematie Conley 20352014-04-14T02:08:41.3134845Linda KempNo No No!20292014-04-14T09:30:21.094846cecil robertsonI now live in Inverness, but was born and brought up in Shetland, and can trace my ancestors who all all lived there, back until the time of the Scottish Bruce and Steward incomers in the 16th century. I should have a vote in any referendum which would determine the status of my homeland Shetland. 20332014-04-14T09:43:48.9534847p dellowSince I found out that the Scottish government allows the Scottish salmon farmers to kill seals so the farmers don't have to put their hands into their money filled pockets to put up proper fencing, I have cancelled my plans to have a nice long holiday in Scotland, I have stopped eating Scottish salmon and cheese and anything else that comes from Scotland. I will continue this until the murder of seals is stopped. Hurry up as I miss the good stuff!20292014-04-14T13:38:46.044848lorraine hillmy friend had this mesh done 3 yrs ago and had been in pain ever since . doctors have said she is imaging the pain .she has lost all get up and go for a woman that was able to enjoy sports and other activities now she is doesn't have the energy to go out .20352014-04-14T14:27:13.194849Ali InksterIan Leask, you say most folk signing the petition dont even live in the isles While i would say that most folk either live in the isles or are expat islanders. My proof is in the surnames of those signing where's your proof? Or is your comment just another Scotnat shout it enough and it must be true tagline. As a Shetlander ask yourself this will Edinburgh give us enough of our own income (they like to call it a grant) to maintain our way of life when the oil runs out? And for the answer you just need to see that they are not letting us keep enough of our money just now to maintain our way of life. Our budget is set by Edinburgh not Westminster. Now if you are daft enough to believe the "free beer tomorrow" promises of the Scotnats fair enough but some of us require a little bit of proof when dealing with politicians. 20332014-04-14T15:54:06.2734850Paul RawnsleyI was planning a FAMILY HOLIDAY in East Lothian until I was told allow the SLAUGHTER of SEALS. We will be nolonger coming to Scotland and will not be until this barbaric practice is stopped. I am also asking all my family and friends not to go to Scotland and as ANIMAL LOVERS they will follow my actions and pass the message on.20292014-04-14T16:18:10.1874851MRS MARGARET MC LAYI HAVE HAD TWO MESH OPERATION AND AM WAITING TO GO BACK IN TO HOSPITAL AS I AM STILL HAVING PROPLEMS20352014-04-14T19:49:21.4434852ElenaStop this!20292014-04-14T21:29:56.3674853Eada J WebbPlease stop allowing the killing of seals who are just trying desperately to survive alongside mankind. It's enough that we are taking a disproportionate amount of resources for ourselves already. 20292014-04-14T21:46:26.224854JennyThis is disgraceful, Scotland should be ashamed if this goes ahead20292014-04-14T21:50:50.9974855Mrs Agnes GigliI had this op about 18 months ago and i am having problems with pain I never had before this op and I feel my problem is falling on deaf ears.20352014-04-14T22:57:04.184856Hazel TaylorThis is barbaric non-essential action and shames Scotland in its inhumanity. I will no longer be visiting Scotland, nor will any member of my family. I will boycott Scottish products and urge my family, friends and their friends to do likewise. Please, have a heart as big and beautiful as your country and stop the slaughter!!!20292014-04-15T01:39:51.174857Linda RayPlease stop this awful and unnecessary cruelty. Please lead the way to being kind to seals. Why is this allowed to happen. I thought Scottish people were good people until hearing of these cruel torturous beating to death of natures beautiful seals! Please stop!!!!20292014-04-15T06:38:45.1574858marie grenuwhy not for once use the power we have,humans,to protect and save those seals ...it will not only contributes in keeping nature arround in Scotland as beautiful as ever, but makes us feel so good...so as we sadly always need a conpensation for our acting,just let only emotions be our reward ,it has an unestimated value !!!20292014-04-15T15:13:16.314859Elizabeth HarleyIn view of today's comments re how women are portrayed in the UK media - I would think this is a matter of urgency. Decades overdue!20572014-04-15T16:08:28.174860Duncan JonesPlease don't cull seals. There are other ways to alleviate the conflict between the Salmon farmers and the seals.20292014-04-15T16:43:12.534861Agnes HerrityI had a TVT op in Feb 2002 for Bladder problems, and since I have had years of hospital visits and I am now incontinent,and very depressed.20352014-04-15T20:18:30.634862vanessa hillSTOP IT NOW! HORRIBLE PEOPLE!20292014-04-15T21:29:50.9434863Jessie TribeLovely animals,so nice to see up on the rocks resting and sunning themselves20292014-04-15T21:56:01.124864Blair Frazer SmithIf you are looking for a Yes vote on independence from me in September that will all depend on if you continue this barbaric and totally unscientific 'cull' of Seals. 20292014-04-15T22:24:31.2474865BobSmithPlanning regulations as they stand favour the developers not those opposing the applications.\r\nThen again what would you expect, "Big Business" runs the governments both at Westminster and Holyrood and can exert pressure on local councils. Donald Trump is a prime example of this20402014-04-16T01:01:26.934866vicki bildenTo beat these babies to death is Barbaric. 20292014-04-16T03:26:09.6374868Dorothy LawsonWhat a disgrace, can't abide cruelty.\r\n\r\n20292014-04-16T06:19:03.6834869Joanne PrandleStop this mindless slaughter of our beautiful indigenous wildlife before it TOO late.20292014-04-16T07:20:41.1034870Malcolm FisherKilling wildlife is an ignorant and shameful activity.20292014-04-16T08:14:53.94871Leigh-Anne AdamsSeals have as much right to the river systems as we do, they were here before mankind. Human means having compassion and empathy. Please keep the seals safe and let them live in the environment they were intended too.20292014-04-16T12:17:58.384872HelenDisgusting20292014-04-16T12:22:51.844873Tanmayi Please stop killing innocent animals for human greed. Stop.20292014-04-16T13:53:35.644874Colin son of AndrewNo one has any rights over land.. The land is gods land and he provided it for all to use.. We are all born human beings and no one man has the authority over any other. So with United Kingdom being a corporation we are only governed by consent, and any act or statute cannot be enforced if we do not consent... Simples... 20202014-04-16T15:32:20.6674875Master Ryan TobynSigned up for my Mum who is suffering due to this TVT Mesh implant, amazing that this is requiring a petition to get something done about the procedure. Seems obvious that theirs an issue. \r\n20352014-04-16T15:37:05.7034876Master Shaun TobynWhy does my Mum need to keep going back to hospital and be in pain? She keeps mentioning a Mesh?20352014-04-16T19:03:29.74877Marion ChalmersIt looks like that the ink was hardly dry on the Hierarchy of Developments Regulations 2009 before planners and government officials had devised and agreed this scheme to avoid it?\r\nIt would be interesting to know the substance of the conversation between Scottish Government officials and Aberdeenshire Council planners which gave this scheme the green light?20402014-04-16T19:10:40.4974878Sue StarkeyJust take the necessary steps to ensure they & the salmon are kept apart and safe - there is no need to kill them at all - its barbaric\r\n20292014-04-16T19:12:15.7934879Martin EkdahlThis has to stop immediately!20292014-04-16T19:12:23.3134880NicoleDeath for greed is not a policy, it's immoral. 20292014-04-16T19:26:13.774881David PalmerThe shooting of seals is abhorrent. Do not let greed win. Save our seals!20292014-04-16T19:43:34.364882Ruby moonHow can we try to stop the terrible slaughter going on in Canada of seals when we are just as bad! The seals have more right to live in the environment they were born into than the greedy salmon farmers who shoot them they should make the nets stronger after all we are the ones with the technology leave our seals alone!!!!!20292014-04-16T19:44:27.9834883TonyLive and let live. STOP exploitation and cruelty to innocent animals.20292014-04-16T19:55:52.214884kevinHow awful, uncompassionate barbaric and selfish. you will also kill the tourist trade in Scotland if this happens, the world is aware of this lack of compassion it reflects poorly on the rest if the British Isles.20292014-04-16T20:04:51.3674885Rosario Rodriguez LeonWe must evolve to be better persons, not only with our own human especies, but with the nonhuman species too. They' inhabitant The Earth too. We must learn to be humane and compassive. In killing there's no mercy. There's no compassion in killing a conscious being, human or not.20292014-04-16T20:09:04.1474886Janice SinclairI have supported animal cruelty charities most of my life and cannot believe that I didn't know that this is going on in my own country, the Scotland I love and support. I abhor mans inhumanity that some humans will stop at nothing for their own greedy ends, the animal kingdom kill to live, we are the only species that kill for sport or greed! We ought to hang our heads in humble shame for the injustice we do to the living creatures on our earth, I feel the shame on behalf of those cruel, greedy profiteering people!20292014-04-16T20:16:39.5974887Muir MurdochI feel as strongly about this as I feel about Estate workers poisoning falcons. There is quite simply no need at all. It must stop. \r\n\r\nHow can we be proud of our wealth of natural produce if we abuse our environment while doing so?20292014-04-16T20:28:22.994888LindaWhy do we always have to destroy every other creature that 'gets in our way'? Seals bring in tourists, who contribute to the economy. We need to find another solution.20292014-04-16T20:30:17.4874889silvia herrerano more blood, no more cruelty and torture, save lives, not eliminated, they also are part of this land as all living beings \r\n20292014-04-16T20:32:37.854890CRISTINA,SPAINOH GOD,I FEEL SO SAD!STOP THIS CRUELTY LORD PLEASE!20292014-04-16T21:00:33.6734891mark schramits time we as humans adapt, and stop killing and capturing animals20292014-04-16T21:20:23.7934892Elaine Roft 1,000 seals are shot and killed under Government Licence in Scotland each year. These deaths are totally unnecessary and an international embarrassment to Scotland. We would like to see Scotland lead the way with seal-friendly salmon farming using techniques such as on-shore farming in enclosed tank systems and proper predator exclusion nets around marine farms.\r\n20292014-04-16T21:22:23.4874893Pauline HaywardScotland England Wales I believe are sn example to the world. We are a nation of animal lovers and we need to respect all creatures. 20292014-04-16T21:28:51.8634894John GrahamDon't know if I would want to vote "yes" for independence if such a government condones such treatment of seals 20292014-04-16T21:33:47.0034895Victor Beattie Angling is more valuable to tourism than betters who steal what others have sown. Seals are beautiful creatures and are also a great tourist pull. If you allow netting and culling on the Ythan Estuary, Shame on you. If You vote SNP whilst they allow this-Shame on you! 20292014-04-16T21:34:21.724896Dona LaSchiavaIT'S THEIR WORLD TOO!20292014-04-16T21:35:29.4874897GINA CHRONOWICZ It is the duty of salmon farmers to comply with the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006. The Scottish Government must stop issuing licences to any Tom, Dick and Harry who wants to shoot these seals.20292014-04-16T21:36:06.8974898Dave WhiteDisgraceful. Who is invading who's space? They have as much right to live in their own natural habitat. 20292014-04-16T21:38:53.2334899Michelle MorrisPlease STOP killing these beautiful creatures.20292014-04-16T21:40:36.5434900Patsy GregoryI am at present waiting to go and see the surgeon..re-operation no.3...to try and fix the mess out...that this mesh has caused..I am in constant pain daily and can't sit for long...and can't lift anything heavy...some days I have double incontinence...I have to be within five minutes from a toilet. my quality of life is not what it once was.20352014-04-16T22:02:39.0134901Arnim van BrachtSave the seals cause they are a part of Scottland.\r\n\r\n20292014-04-16T22:44:09.2974902Andy IAppalling, never even knew this was permitted!20292014-04-16T22:50:12.2034903Michael ArcherFor humanity to evolve we need to take a leap of faith and stop killing things.20292014-04-16T22:55:22.6774904Christine ForbesMankind always has to interfere with nature, time it stopped.20292014-04-16T23:17:18.124905Fiona hargreavesI wish to sign this petition but was unable to so as my ipad did not recognise the security captcha challenge20292014-04-17T07:58:33.2874906LINDA BRADYHow dare they kill seals for hunting for food? The seals have more right to the seas and rivers than we do. The human race is a virus to the animal world. We kill for greed NOT need. Let the seals forage in their ocean in safety. Would we like to be shot for foraging in our supermarkets? 20292014-04-17T08:25:08.6474910Kathy JI did not believe it when I was told ... Scottish people are civilised said I ... how wrong can one be ... hope you get independence then we can put sanctions on Scotland just like Canada 20292014-04-17T10:36:17.624911Tarja ArpalahtiStop salmon farmers from polluting the waters and killing the seals, and stop anyone killing the seals.20292014-04-17T16:42:39.4934912zarina alex moneriefStop killing Salmons and Seals i yre people all over the world to come forward and Help their lives and Help save Nature20292014-04-17T17:36:50.5834913Dennis Alfred Bryant.I fully support the petition for independance for Shetland and Orkney20332014-04-17T17:40:33.2134914Betty Bryant.I would like to see a referendum for independance of Orkney and Shetland.20332014-04-17T18:33:21.234915sandra ennishad mesh done a few years ago no problems then but have now20352014-04-17T18:48:07.0174916Helen Graham"He who is cruel to animals becomes hard also in his dealings with men. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals."\r\n --Immanuel Kant20292014-04-17T19:19:52.394919Jenny BlainGood luck! This is an important issue and I hope will be taken up by many people throughout Scotland.20702014-04-17T19:20:48.3634920Helen JonesI'm priviledged to sign this really important petition. \r\n20702014-04-17T20:08:09.974921will lathamThe cultural contribution in music,song,and storytelling of the Travellers is worthy of praise.20702014-04-17T20:40:59.314922Neil McDonaldI am apalled that this is allowed to happen in Scotland.20292014-04-17T20:41:15.3434923Elisa S-RAt long last - well done, Jess - well done, all!20702014-04-17T21:51:08.4474924Astrid HockeyJust.... WHY wouldn't you want to save a historical memorial site? It is after all such a small site and would take little to maintain but its ability to touch the heart of so many speaks volumes to its importance to the everyday people. Let us hope that common-sense has not died out completely in governments! 20702014-04-17T22:21:32.8374926Jan VosdellenIts important for the world 20292014-04-17T22:39:48.924927Yvonne Creighton I suffer with this everyday. I wish I was told the truth about what would happen to me, I was only advices of the benefits !!!20352014-04-18T01:03:04.4974928Diane LarowskaThere must be a saner way than killing native wildlife, horrified by this sanctioned killing of seals.20292014-04-18T01:46:20.54929Bruce SanelliReally? At this day and age???20292014-04-18T04:20:31.6874930Gretchen OchsHaving visited Scotland I love the gorgeous country and I love animals to live free from harm.20292014-04-18T04:39:35.2574931Myriam SeyfarthAre you going to behave like the Japanese killing whales??? I thought Scotland was a better country.20292014-04-18T04:56:57.754932RAMONA PAOLINIJUST BECAUSE HUMANS HAVE RIGHTS DOESNT MEAN WE HAVE THE RIGHT TO ABUSE AND KILL OTHER SENTIENT BE INGS..... WE ARE ALL CONNECTED. STOP THE MURDERING THE INNOCENT20292014-04-18T05:52:06.5834933Kristina Ruiz-MesaPlease do not allow this bloody stain on your country to continue.20292014-04-18T07:02:08.474934Louise VijnSigned20292014-04-18T07:14:39.514935Barbara SwansonStop this now!! This has highlighted this for me and should not be allowed to happen to anyone else.20352014-04-18T08:17:00.2834936Wendy WaterreusNot only are they beautiful and endangered, there is a long folklore associated with them.They are symbolic of these regions and those who live there .\r\nI hope they can survive us 20292014-04-18T08:23:30.4874937Carmelina MasciaJust another tale of human greed, another animal being killed in the name of farming, just like the Badgers in somerset. Discusting.20292014-04-18T09:24:01.7074938Donna CunninghamStop these terrible killings20292014-04-18T09:25:54.224939Mary MacleanLet's hope this petition helps 20352014-04-18T11:08:59.0834940Susan BailliePlease stop the shooting of seals20292014-04-18T11:21:54.624941James StewartWhy do you take land from people and destroy history from the past) to put money into the government's pocket.20702014-04-18T11:58:05.5234942Marion HortonI live in England but was born in Glasgow. It is vital that the Scottish Government embrace and celebrate the diversity of groups and traditions of the many that makes Scotland unique. 20702014-04-18T12:00:44.5734943Stephen DicksNo-one should be in a hurry to destroy a church, nor any Holy Place, surely God will see.20702014-04-18T14:54:12.9974944Tom ColeOne Scotland many cultures? I hope so. 20702014-04-18T15:26:23.8834945LynNews not boobs please!!20572014-04-18T16:48:21.074946Lynn ThomasFairly typical really - wildlife looses out to monetary gain. The seals were there before artifical salmon farms.20292014-04-18T17:35:19.2474947melissa wallI am so sick of the way people treat animals!!!20292014-04-18T18:17:29.8834948Marie PriestHow amazing if the Scottish parliament took the lead to end this relic from the past. Please do it for the sake of women everywhere in the U.K.20572014-04-18T19:46:30.8134949Sue HorneI spent 9 years living on the north east coast of Scotland I was on many occasions called out to record dead seal, often with aborted seals hanging out of them. No one has the right to kill animals on this scale, the seas of their homes and we visit them. As usual we blame animals for everything that goes wrong, low salmon stocks, never think that it is us humans that have over fished for decades, and what do we do, we kill them. They are left rotting on Scotland's beautiful beaches for the public to see and smell. It has to stop. Britain is home to half the world's population of grey seals, something we should be proud of, not so. How many successful prosecutions have there been for unlawful shooting, as far as I know 1. I have witnessed first hand the inept justice system to bring about prosecution for this offence. It is a joke. Stop the issuing of the licences. please20292014-04-18T20:08:26.5134950Susanne Greenhowe-WeisWhatever reason you think you have for killing seals, it doesn't fly - it's just murder. Canada has similar issues and claims the seals are killing the fishing industry. That's absolute rubbish - it's the flagrant greed of the fishing industry and the waste they perpetrate when discarding all fish caught that is not immediately marketable. Humans cannot stand competition and prefers to commit murder than accept it's own involvement in the problem. Stop it!20292014-04-18T21:18:43.1974952Bernadette MahoneyI hope this historical site is reclaimed and preserved as a vital part of Scottish heritage. 20702014-04-18T21:19:36.1574953Karina KellyWomen are degraded as sex objects throughout the western world. Page 3 is only the tip of the iceberg, but a very important tip. It was when Page 3 was introduced in the 1970s that pornography and degradation of women became more acceptable - the fact that this was allowed in a national "newspaper" (if you can you really call this rag a newspaper) obviously made exploiting women in this way more acceptable. I feel that banning Page 3 would be a huge landmark and hopefully it would reverse the process that Page 3 started. There is very powerful evidence that pornography and the whole general western culture of treating women as sex objects leads to rape and sexual abuse. Why else do we have advertising if it doesn't have an effect on people's minds? \r\n20572014-04-18T22:05:37.434954Maranda WillsonWe must retain this important, amazing and unique part of our history!20702014-04-18T22:07:06.44955Christopher BlackwellThe travelers are part of of history and their sites deserve as much to be noted ad protected as anybody else's.20702014-04-19T10:03:47.214957jean mcmoniesThis is a very important site to the Travelling people especially but also to the people of Scotland as a whole..We owe the travellers a huge debt of gratitude for the retention of songs and tunes and stories which would have been lost to our culture without the Travellers... Please sign this petition..Jean Mcmonies20702014-04-19T12:33:53.1574958Angel DominguezI´m pretty sure that my venerated master Sir David Attenborough will be agree with this petition.20292014-04-19T16:08:16.844959amy duffI work with more males than females. I have to sit in the staff room while the guys gather round and discuss the size of the breasts on page p3 and I have to sit there listening to there disgusting attitudes. This is the only time I hear them talk like this Though. Its because its there their attitudes change. Sometimes being the only female there I not only get embarrassed but feel like am being ogled, I dont know what goes through there heads. What if they ganged up on me to see what my breasts looked like. No witnesses so my word against theres. There is a time & a place for images like these. But not in any paper during the day where women & children can see it, on a bus or train. They may not have bought the paper but can still see the images when other people are looking at it. It makes me feel disgusted to be female. I am only here for men to stare at my breasts, im not here to try and get through a tough day but just to be laughed at. The tables will never be changed. Naked pictures of men will never appear on page 3. So women will never get the chance to sit together and laugh at what they look like, point at random men in the street and shout disgustin crude things and let us laugh at you. Men would have alot to say if they were made to feel worthless. They are celebrated in national papers, women are shown to be just sex objects. Times need to change. Both men and women should be celebrated, give hope & inspiration to the younger generation\r\n 20572014-04-20T11:50:18.7974960Isabelle GagnageDesesperee de certain etre humain qui semble soit prendre du plaisir, soit n'avoir aucun respect pour toute forme de vie. Cette planete appartient à tous etres vivants. Tuer pour faire de l'argent ? Quel dommage. Meme 1 million de dollar ne vaudra jamais la vie d'un phoque pour moi.\r\n\r\nDesperate for some human being who seems to be taking pleasure, or have no respect for any form of life. This planet belongs to all living beings. Kill to make money? What a pity. Even $ 1 million will never be worth the life of a seal for me.20292014-04-20T13:28:58.5074961Elaine cairnsMy sister is waiting for major surgery to repair the damage this mesh has caused! She is terrified of the repercussions and has gone from a bubbly outgoing person to someone racked with pain and fear! This has to be addressed -now.20352014-04-20T13:34:47.9074962Steven JarmsonShetland and Orkney shouldn't be lumped in with the Western Isles.\r\nWe're very different in all sorts of ways.\r\nThe Western Isles is truly Scottish whilst Shetland and Orkney are neither Scottish nor Scandanavian but we are also both of those!!\r\nOrkney and Shetland are run as one area whilst the Western Isles is split among several council areas.\r\nThe western Isles waste millions on promoting its dying language, Shetland and Orkney have never had that language and have no interest in it.\r\nFar too many things to list, but don't think for one minute that I, a Shetlander, have anything in common with a Western Islander!!!20332014-04-20T17:13:41.564963Gwen LimingMy daughter Is suffering from this.It Is heart breaking to watch her being in so much pain.20352014-04-20T18:44:45.264964Daniele HalleI live in Canada and I know the heart ache I feel for the Canadian seals, no babies should die for this abject need for the fashion industry20292014-04-20T18:48:08.9834965Elspeth WaldieThis is an important part of our heritage I urge Historic Scotland to ensure the restoration and preservation and it should be important to the Scottish Government.20702014-04-21T09:46:04.7274966Jennifer HobsonI believe the Scottish government is far better than to allow this to continue. They should stop salmon farming. It's unnatural and poisonous.20292014-04-21T10:11:46.4634967David Adams McGilpThe supporting information is incorrect. I was the VisitScotland representative at the meeting with Michael Russell MSP. I did not ask how my organisation would benefit - I asked how the wider visitor economy would benefit. 20702014-04-21T11:31:05.364968Einar Gunnar BirgissonI had a synthetic mesh implant for hernia last September. I was in complete pain and misery for months because of this mesh implant and had it removed in Las Vegas, USA in late January. I have a new life now. 20352014-04-21T14:11:45.574969Mary dykesI got mesh after operation 46 months ago had another two operations since and going back into hospital on Wednesday morning,not had much of a life for over 4 years,lost ten months work first year six months work second year four months last year,back at work full time struggling ,doctors don't care ,don't know what's going to happen on Wednesday ,just have to wait and see ,no life whatsoever I'm not the person I was before my first operation no one explained anything to me about mesh.it dosn't just affect me it affects my husband,my kids,and grand kids .20352014-04-21T15:52:00.1234970Annette O'DonnellIt's little to ask in order to honor a culture and preserve a heritage of the people who have contributed so much to everything that is Scotland!20702014-04-21T15:57:32.9874971Angelique LagardeSuch a disappointment to learn about Scotland killing seals. Please stop this!20292014-04-21T16:29:24.8134972Ewan McVicarI do not usually sign these petitions - but this one speaks to my heart! 20702014-04-21T18:43:35.874973David BellPreserve culture for everyone.20702014-04-21T20:10:17.9574974peter Macdonaldgive them more space20702014-04-21T21:13:23.0034975Paul DixonIf you do not know your past you do not know your future. Any distinct cultural group which has contributed to our national history deserves at the very least recognition of its existence. If we have any sense of honour we will not turn our faces away. We will grant the travelling people, through the auspices of Historic Scotland, assistance to restore and preserve the Tinkers' Heart. This will signify to our humanity and show the world that Scotland is genuine in its respect of minority cultures. 20702014-04-21T22:37:19.4934977LauraStop killing these animals...we live in 2014, not 1014, so you don't need to kill them!! Get your food somewhere else that don't kill animals. How old are you? You guys are not 10 years old.. You are grown ups, so behave like grown ups and have a little more respect for the seals!! It has to end!!! 20292014-04-21T23:43:55.7574978DEBORAH FUCHSScottish people are civilised. Their is a minority in every country who are acting wrongly to our wildlife.we have to stop this and making it public and naming and shaming can be a way forward. 20292014-04-22T00:19:53.594979James DippieI've been a 'towny' all my life, but that life has been greatly enriched by our breadth of cultures in Scotland, not least that of the travelling communities, for me through their stories, music and song - invaluable. Thanks to you all and Adam McNaughtan & Hamish Henderson among others for introducing me to so much.20702014-04-22T07:29:20.8774980LINDA BRADYHow dare they kill seals for hunting for food? The seals have more right to the seas and rivers than we do. The human race is a virus to the animal world. We kill for greed NOT need. Let the seals forage in their ocean in safety. Would we like to be shot for foraging in our supermarkets? 20292014-04-22T13:19:14.734981Jane CartneySTOP allowing commercial fish farming interests to persecute animals in the natural environment. SEALS ARE NOT VERMIN.20292014-04-22T14:31:58.2074982A FisherI now know of two people who have had awful trouble because of this proceedure. It needs sorted out!20352014-04-22T17:27:20.9434983John urquhartPlease sign and help our seals20292014-04-22T18:33:36.9874984Roberta Helen SmithLots of love and luck x20292014-04-22T21:53:37.354985William NorwoodScotland must stop this disgraceful cull. Does commercial gain really come before nature?. This is disgraceful.20292014-04-22T22:01:33.5274986Ali InksterYes Steven a lot o whit du says is true, but yuns no reason ta deny da Western Isles da right ta a say in dir ain future.20332014-04-22T22:19:12.5674987Jessica AdamsSeals are one of the reasons people visit Scotland. How on earth can you shoot them? That's 1000 tourists in the bank, with 1000 seals. Minimum.20292014-04-22T22:20:27.2734988Euphemia MacdonaldThey have taken so much from us already, surely they can leave "The Tinkers Heart" 20702014-04-22T22:25:35.744989Linda Hillit's not just about giving the seals protection, in a way it protects the fish stock as well. seals hunt to not be hungry, to live., Man hunts to make a profit, by selling to those who can afford the luxury that salmon and trout are.20292014-04-22T22:55:16.7674990Maria KoutsoumanisSeals are a wonderful tourist attraction. Why would you want to kill them? Embrace them. The tourists will come. Kill them and the tourists will stay away. V bad for your economy. 20292014-04-23T01:22:59.294992David WrightKilling Seals is bad enough, lying, cheating & extortion is completely unacceptable.... bad business Scotland...20292014-04-23T06:10:39.584993Sharon TempletonThanks for helping these women. 20352014-04-23T08:11:24.854994annette erdtsieckIt's bad enough that Perth WA are culling innocent sharks. Seals and sharks just do what comes naturally...move the salmon out of their reach. Simple.20292014-04-23T08:37:15.0234995Sharon LivingstonePreserve this Historic sight for future Generations20702014-04-23T08:57:40.4134996Alec Connah.Stop this abuse please.20292014-04-23T09:10:01.574997bella stewartThe true Travllers made us Travllers today so we are today we should respect them Travllers that's made this life for us to be happy to carry the memorys and the honor to those Travllers that's though all there life for us to have the life we have today so we ask everyone to sign this for us to keep tinker heart make more apace for us to live and bring out young wains into the life of Travllers more space for all Travller family to come toghter stay near each other to live and laugh toghter 20702014-04-23T10:52:38.444998ann margaret allan i remember my daddy taking me here when i was a little girl lovely piece of our heritage keep the heart please 20702014-04-23T12:33:04.5674999Ryan AI personally signed this petition because I have always hated the idea that papers make women feel absolutely worthless. I would be happy to see all nude magazines removed and page 3 in newspapers taken out. How would other men feel if it was them on page 3? Ashamed and worthless so why should we allow women to have the same pain?20572014-04-23T12:44:10.1935000EILEEN MACLEODIt must come to a time of reason, killing the whales over here, killing the sharks in Australia, surely exclusion nets would be the solution. Having just seen ' Islands on the Edge ' here, it was a shock to read of this planned culling of seals. We have plundered fish stocks globally now we want to shoot the seals ???? Sad news indeed . 20292014-04-23T16:29:59.695001julie davidsonThese procedures are destroying women's lives and others something has to be done 20352014-04-23T16:30:12.025002Marcello MegaThis is a genuine scandal that leaves victims facing appalling consequences. It's very hard to see why the First Minister and the Health Minister don't simply act on the evidence already available. How many people need to be crippled and have their lives devastated before we see action?20352014-04-23T17:10:19.695003peter smithAs a frequent visitor to Scotland I am appalled by your cruel and barbaric behaviour towards your wild life shame on you20292014-04-23T18:38:33.9435004Jane McneillGood luck20702014-04-23T18:55:12.2035005AdmanDon't blame the seals, look closer to your own actions and get better in the future.20292014-04-23T19:04:31.4875006LauraThis must stop here in Canada they have the baby seal hunt where they club them to death, it is discussing and needs to stop. They say it is taking away from the natives tradition and way of life. Time to change tradition.\r\n20292014-04-23T19:06:10.6735007Marjorie CarusoPlease stop killing. Why must we kill everything in sight, there's always a better way. Thank you.20292014-04-23T19:19:27.435009Rachael PankowJust sad...there is not point to it...just wrong. The fishermen should try to keep their fish outta their reach..or Mayb they should just give sum to them20292014-04-23T19:19:49.145010b. knowlesto shoot seals for the benefit of commercial salmon farms is morally bankrupt.\r\ni have debated long and hard about wild fish stocks and realize some form of husbandry is required.\r\nthis is not the case for the sole benefit of commercial and questionable fish farm practices is not good husbandry.\r\nthe farms are the problem more than the seals.20292014-04-23T19:23:59.6675011Steve McGhieThis has to stop - it is essential that all medical devices are under review, especially when adverse events are evident in other markets. An urgent review must be carried out and would cost nothing compared to any future adverse event in Scotland.20352014-04-23T19:31:24.645012filip nuyttens belgiumWe try everything to get them and keep them before the coast. Don't kill them. Let them live...please20292014-04-23T20:02:23.185013Colin birdSeen the results of salmon netting in Thurso Bay. Netting has been going on for years by local company. a London bases company obtained licence and within weeks most if not all the Common seals in the Bay were shot.And these were all very young seals and goes a long way to explain why the Common seal population has crashed.20292014-04-23T20:03:19.325014Paula HowarthKilling wildlife because they are doing what comes naturally ie eating to survive, disgusting...stop it right now please!!!!20292014-04-23T20:03:39.4775015Sylviane RoncinsI really like Scotland and I like to spend holidays there (I come from Belgium). But I can't understand such a cruelty. Please stop it. \r\n20292014-04-23T20:05:42.6335016Jo This is barbaric and has to stop 20292014-04-23T20:08:48.3535018June LinartsPlease stop this slaughter of innocent creatures.20292014-04-23T20:09:43.935019Phil BarlowCruel and unnecessary20292014-04-23T20:10:08.5735020Cristina MendesStop this now!! 20292014-04-23T20:11:09.4635021Bee Evans, EarthlingHumans have gone far beyond insanity in their greed to "harvest" sea life, to suck every large animal & even the oil from the oceans. There is no "competition" with seals, it's theft & slaughter, by industrial apes with killing machinery. Restore the oceans, stop the killing.20292014-04-23T20:15:28.2935022Jane AlexanderEmbarassed to be Scottish!20292014-04-23T20:16:05.4975023sharon hesford Seals eat fish that is nature. Stop killing seals salmon farmers should protect their salmon from predator attack by the use of nets not kill seals\r\n20292014-04-23T20:18:54.015025Michael BateWe are no better than than the Canadians by your actions stop barbaric act20292014-04-23T20:19:09.895026Jayne MThis needs addressing!20292014-04-23T21:00:06.4375028Elaine RoftJUSTICE FOR ALL SCOTLANDS SEALS KILLED BY SCOTTISH WILD SALMON COMPANY (USAN)20292014-04-23T21:12:18.5975030stephanie MandrusiakAny mass species loss will affect the community of which we are resident. The more species that dies out the weaker the ecosystem becomes. Stop the killing. Think over solutions. Innovation is the key not the killing. 20292014-04-23T21:26:52.615031valentina piscioneri"Wake up" thank you.20292014-04-23T21:36:58.545032Jeremy DuxburyThere has to be a better solution than just shooting the seals. Come on, Scotland! Show the world what you stand for.20292014-04-23T21:40:49.1235033Petra HoeferIt's time for humans to stop interfering with wildlife and nature. Every time we do it hits us back. We have no right to kill seals, deer, badgers, hare, pheasants or whatsoever for agriculture or so called sport. Culling and hunting are murder and nothing else.20292014-04-23T21:48:04.9875034J Lesley AdamsSince receiving the mesh, both on my bowel and my bladder, I have suffered dreadful pain. I have had 5 operations to cut away and repair mesh erosion and am waiting for another op. It has affected not only my life, but also my husband and family's lives.Mesh use has got to stop!20352014-04-23T21:52:09.3535035Judith FindlaterDisgrace and sickening please put a stop to this killing. Get more fish farms up the employment.20292014-04-23T22:12:46.265036Cesaria Sir, it is your duty to save nature and wildlife. Those seals have the right to live and belong to this planet as much as you do. Prove me wrong! 20292014-04-23T22:15:26.815037Kristie Stephens I think it's so cruel what they do to seals n they only do it for fun n these poor little animals stuffer so much20292014-04-24T01:12:52.9835038Claire woodWhat a way to treat a monument. Surely such a lovely part of Scottish history deserves better?20702014-04-24T01:16:35.0835039Paul C.So many fish are wasted by over fishing quotas generally and the farmed salmon industry causes lot of pollutants to foul the water yet seals are blamed for eating their natural food source and slaughtered for this ? \r\n\r\nThe nitrogen and phosphorus discharged from Scotland's 350 marine salmon farms, whose salmon are fed on fish meal pellets, pose a risk to fish, mammals, shellfish and other wildlife in what were until recently pristine waters, says the report commissioned by the World Wide Fund for Nature.\r\n\r\nThe report by Malcolm MacGarvin, an independent ecologist, uses new criteria used by Ospar, the intergovernmental body for the North East Atlantic, to calculate the extent of pollution. On one sample year salmon farms produced 7,500 tons of nitrogen, equivalent to the annual sewage from 3.2 million people, and 1,240 tons of phosphorus, comparable to sewage from 9.4 million people. The ecological result is effectively greater than the sewage produced by Scotland's 5.1 million humans.\r\n\r\nNutrients stimulate plant growth and contribute to toxic algal blooms, thought to be a factor in amnesic shellfish poisoning, a disease which led to the widespread closure of scallop farms this summer. Algal blooms may be toxic to wild fish larvae and marine mammals, such as porpoises and seals, according to the report. It also kills caged salmon on salmon farms.\r\n\r\nExcessive nutrients have contributed to the decline of eel grass beds, a habitat which has declined by more than 80 per cent, and is home to unusual species such as the pipefish, says the report. It follows a report for the Scottish Executive by Aberdeen Marine Laboratory, which said it had yet to prove that nutrients from fish farms were responsible for toxic algal blooms. These could occur naturally.\r\n\r\nDr MacGarvin said: "The evidence available shows that you can't simply dismiss the impact of nutrient pollution from fish farming. To dismiss it out of hand is to ignore the science."\r\n20292014-04-24T05:13:53.435040Jenny HooperThese deplorable practices should immediately cease. 20292014-04-24T06:12:55.4975041Barbara MullerThe seals are entitled to live in their habitat. Commercial interests do not take precedence over the welfare of innocent animals. Killing them is not the answer, have some compassion.20292014-04-24T09:02:38.025042Barbara WhiteNot only is it a sad and revolting sight to find bodies of dead seals regularly washing up on the beach but visitors stay away after witnessing this horror. It must be terrifying for pregnant seals who often abort from the fear of gunshots. As part of their contract the gunmen are obliged to recover the dead bodies but they don't and someone else has to do it or leave them to rot. Those shooting the seals say they stay within the limits of their contract but they may not be educated enough to be able to count. Please stop this unspeakable horror now and let places like Gamrie become a beautiful place to live and visit once again. 20292014-04-24T09:06:01.2235043Lea SilholMy family won't buy anything coming from Scottish fisheries till you change your methods. And I cancelled my holiday plans near Loch Awe too. 20292014-04-24T09:52:50.5675044Jean GardnerPlaces like this NEED to be preserved, it's part of our history, too many have been lost already, please save this one.20702014-04-24T14:27:00.5275045Carole Mckillop-Mash Wishing the campaign all the very best.20702014-04-24T14:31:21.1835046M.O.I know people who have to collect the dead bodies because those shooting them have not. This is just wrong. There are seal-friendly alternatives - use them!20292014-04-24T14:44:46.915047Aria McNeillGood luck20702014-04-24T16:36:33.4375048Jacqui RussellSeals are just another creature who inhabit this planet, no more or no less right to live in peace. As humans we neither need them for food or clothing and to encroach or their territory and pay someone to kill them (whilst pregnant or with young) is nothing short of barbaric!20292014-04-24T17:19:47.4835049Bob SmithSorry Mary but as far as changing the planning laws is concerned this is as daft an idea as I have heard,It would be open to all sorts of crazy buildings appearing all over the countryside.20202014-04-24T21:47:25.5075050Amanda BowmanPlease stop killing our lovely seals when it's so unnecessary. X20292014-04-24T22:41:26.875051Margot YoungWildlife is not a resource for us humans to use or destroy for profit or pleasure, This effects of this ideology have been devastating: Its had its day & its now time to live amongst other species not destroy them at will.20292014-04-24T22:53:55.45052diane glancy My mother in law has had 9 ops and due to.have another. ruined her life .20352014-04-24T23:06:34.7135053Nadia BlaneyWhy persist doing the obviously wrong thing when an alternative is there?20292014-04-25T08:26:00.345054David BurnettNo justification and Scotland should be an example to the rest of the world regarding animal treatment.20292014-04-25T10:19:50.865055Sue EdwardsThe 'dolphin-friendly' campaign with tuna works, so isn't it about time we have 'seal-friendly' wild salmon - there is no reason why seals should be killed to provide private companies with more profit. Why do humans think they have the right to the fish in the sea - live and let live.\r\n 20292014-04-25T10:23:16.9475056Kristie MullikinI am not from Scotland but I think its just wrong to kill any animal. Makes me sick to my stomach. Hope all this stops!!20292014-04-25T10:49:30.7475057Steve RhodesIt is imperative that ancient sites such as this are preserved for future generations.20702014-04-25T15:38:13.7935058Yvonne LilleyThis practice is barbaric and has no place in modern day society. Please Scotland lead the way in showing what a responsible and caring country you are.20292014-04-25T16:43:46.1835059joyce ellawayit is not too much to ask that they have such a small piece of ground for something that is very important to them. what harm can be done ?20702014-04-25T17:17:28.7575060Daniela BressYour intention to slaughter seals is a disgrace for your country and your people. Such killings are pointless and do not belong in these times of loss of habitats, environmental pollutions, dangers caused by shipping, global warming, overfishing, etc., I always considered the Scottish people to be more farsighted than the Canadians. Too bad that I was obviously wrong.20292014-04-25T17:35:03.3775061Rosemary V BernierWhy are we so obsessed with killing sentient beings? God did NOT intend for this to happen yet we do it anyway :(20292014-04-25T18:49:42.565062jill adamsonSeals rely on fish to survive, we do not. Greedy humans yet again.\r\n20292014-04-25T20:59:50.35063fiona worrellPlease remove the right to slaughter seals for commercial gain in the whole of Scotland, and in particular refuse licences in conservation areas ie Moray Firth..there are enough areas with salmon that no longer sustain seals!20292014-04-26T00:06:38.8335064Martin ByrnesMy address may be outwith Scotland, but my heart will always be there. Travelling people in Scotland should be remembered, not forgotten about.20702014-04-26T00:14:07.495065Betty Keegan I'm so very disappointed in Scotland \r\nScotland has become Famous not because of her scenery or Golf, but as one of the countries that doesn't care for her wildlife, along with Taiji, Faroe's, Canada etc 20292014-04-26T00:56:08.5835066Margaret MortonSeals are our British wildlife they are precious and should be protected....stop the killing!20292014-04-26T09:46:15.4635067Manus DohertyGood Luck20702014-04-26T09:46:37.6335068Mike MaasAlternatives are available. Make them compulsory !20292014-04-26T11:24:09.4435069Judy SaleNot sure what right we have to deprive the seals of their food source-we have choices,they don't.Killing them is the wrong option,i understand fishermen have a living to make but slaughtering seals because they eat the profits of the fishermen?Sorry its wrong,very wrong.20292014-04-26T13:37:04.875070Melanie HaywardFor gods sake let's just stop killing ANIMALS 20292014-04-26T14:09:10.065072Nathan HudsonI detest animal cruelty of all kinds. I've been vegan for years and encourage others to do so. However, money talks, and this attacks the supply, not the demand. Animal protein is responsible for more cancers than any chemical carcinogen (and milk has pus in it). I sign this to bolster the cause, but fear everyone signing it may be barking up the wrong tree. Promote the ills of eating it, not hunting it, as they're hand in hand.20292014-04-26T15:15:28.255075Nicole Thibault Please let all those marvellous sentient Beings live the life in Freedom like they were meant to live, just like us humans they have soul and feel pain. Thank You 20292014-04-26T16:09:25.745078Valerie PetersThis communities need to wake up to the damage being caused by comercial fishing. Stop blaming the wildlife. The sea existed in balance long before humans came.20292014-04-26T16:29:26.7075080Nancy YoungThere has to be solutions. What is happening is morally wrong. Killing seals must be stopped.20292014-04-26T16:41:28.4735081Larisa KonovalyukSTOP THIS TORTURE20292014-04-26T17:07:49.0475082Lindsay TomlinsonThis is so wrong! Please save the seals!20292014-04-26T17:29:59.2535083Cesar CastroStop issuing licences permitting salmon farming20292014-04-26T17:55:34.435084Laura HillmanKilling Seals is not the answer. There is always another solution that does not involve the slaughter of innocents.20292014-04-26T18:28:10.0875085susanna minacheilisave Scotlands seals 20292014-04-26T18:32:52.045087Paula SteinThis is a shameful act...almost as shameful as Canada's terrible, cruel and inhumane slaughter of east coast seals. Almost as shameful of the dolphin massacre in Taiji, Japan. Stop the killing!20292014-04-26T18:36:03.3075088Lynn ThyneI'm a shadow of my former self due to the chronic pain and suffering from Gynecare Prolift Mesh and mesh repair surgery. The mesh migrated and it eroded into my bladder. It is destroying my body and lives of my myself and my family, As well as the debilitating effects of nerve and tissue damage caused, I am deeply concerned about the leaching chemicals of this device (nonyphenol) as I am also constantly fatigued and my body is experiencing burning heavy throbbing limbs, aching all over, ceasing up. Weakness. Twitching all over body. Tightness in chest. Numbness, infections. Foggy memory. (Auto immune disease symptoms) Please suspend the use of mesh surgery until the completion of a full public inquiry into mesh devices. A large number of women who have had mesh devices are suffering many of the same symptoms as myself. Please do the right thing now before any more women suffer. 20352014-04-26T18:54:41.975089Joanna LangadaSustainable fishing is a must. And it solves the problem of cruelty against seals. Everyone wins. Please do the right thing. Thank you. 20292014-04-26T18:57:42.9035090Crystal Mathies (Scotsman in California) Please stop allowing the seals to be killed. They are a valuable part of the ecosystem and nature in general. Killing them is cruel and unnecessary. 20292014-04-26T19:01:55.1735091Renee PeelThere is no need for all this aggression and there is certainly no NEED to kill the seals doing what is absolutely natural, the abuse by man to animals in their natural environment has become a crime against nature. 20292014-04-26T20:11:17.1075092susan ballariniplease protect the seals20292014-04-26T20:16:51.1435093Aaron IngebrigtsenStop killing defenseless seal babies! That's not Hunting, that's cowardly baby slaughter!20292014-04-26T20:23:52.6335094Simon Nicoll-GriffithLike the badger cull, you can not keep on killing the wildlife to suit your profit margins20292014-04-26T20:26:52.6335095Barry TerryIf this is the price we pay for buying your farmed salmon YOU CAN STUFF IT20292014-04-26T20:33:39.7135096sharon hesfordPlease do not allow any further killing of seals in Scottish waters. It has no place in modern society seals will always eat fish it is up to the salmon farmers to protect their stock not kill seals for what comes naturally.. Thank you\r\n20292014-04-26T20:47:57.8475097kathy hallinanstop killing the seals, the tourists will come to see them.....the world is in favor of stopping killing them ..from san francisco, ca- in fishermans wharf they love the sea lions now....save your seals for the world to come and visit ....the salmon will be happy too 20292014-04-26T20:54:42.1775098Jill GoesslingPlease STOP this travesty!20292014-04-26T20:58:58.9575099Ashley Marie ReeseScotland, stop this cruelty!20292014-04-26T21:03:13.855100Irene GaliciaGod put animals into this world for human mankind to care for. What happened to human mankind? So, many are living in the dark vs the light. So many are following the dark vs the light. As the Bible says, "There are the evil and wicked in this world" God, vividly states in the Bible, "These are the ones He will send to the pit" I am a steward of His creation.20292014-04-26T21:04:40.6935101s kargunbelievable barbarians still living here in EU20292014-04-26T21:09:31.8075102Sandra WillistonThe Scottish Government needs to legislate the closure of all salmon netting stations in Scottish waters, allowing tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon and seatrout to return to their native rivers to breed! 20292014-04-26T21:12:31.5535103Manu VaillantThis is not a way to behave with our fellow earth inhabitants...20292014-04-26T21:12:38.2435104kun kangthis is old ancient barbarian act. there are many ways humans can survive without this act. please stop.20292014-04-26T21:33:49.0375105Sarah PlocekThese animals already have enough stress on their lives from global warming.20292014-04-26T22:38:47.5135106Marian EvansSending every good wish for this petition, knowing that this is a serious public health issue in New Zealand as well as in Scotland and elsewhere. I think women all round the world need to work in solidarity to end the use of this mesh. I hope we can do that!20352014-04-26T22:57:46.6635107PERSON christelprotection20292014-04-27T02:04:18.3575109Jemima WilliamsIn 2002 I had a surgical mesh implant fitted for pelvic organ prolapse. I live through the hell of multiple surgeries for mesh erosion, migration and extrusion. Also bowel and bladder obstruction, ever since. I live a life of excruciating pain.\r\nNow, after 12 years, I have just been informed that I have to undergo another major mesh removal surgery, which will almost certainly lead to a colostomy. \r\nThe use surgical mesh has to stop. The experiment has to stop. The harming of women AND men because of hernia mesh, has to stop.20352014-04-27T05:56:09.7075110DawnScandal : mesh does more harm than any of these Dr.'s can even imagine. Until they have it in their bodies they have NO RIGHT to tell us what and how we are feeling . We are not crazy . It is not a coincidence that women all around the world are in the same pain.20352014-04-27T06:33:39.335111vicky frederickhave a heart close down20292014-04-27T07:15:49.275112Daniel Thamstop killing seals20292014-04-27T08:07:52.6375113Elizabeth DanaThis is an unnecessary act of barbaric species killing for profit to "special interests". We no longer need fur to keep warm or seal meat to keep from starving so why is this being done? Because Jennifer Lopez wants to show off her cosmetically altered body in dead fur and Japanese men think seal meat will increase their sexual performance??? Scotland has thousands of years of fighting injustice and She should pick up Her sword and fight this with a clean stroke of the pen !20292014-04-27T08:47:14.6875114Karen MorrisI will do anything to make this world a better place to live! 20292014-04-27T10:47:25.1275115Abigail BengstonI will actively promote the boycott of products from Scottish fisheries until the government stops issuing licences to kills seals.20292014-04-27T12:05:12.895116Judith SwiftGood luck and thanks for drawing attention to the Tinkers' Heart!20702014-04-27T12:29:24.315117Kate EllixGood luck20702014-04-27T12:45:43.4675119Barbara WarkI had mesh surgery in 2010 I have just recently become unwell, I am undergoing tests as hospital Doctors are unsure if my symptoms are connected to the mesh implants, looking back I was not given enough information before the surgery it was explained that whilst they were repairing my bowel prolapse they maybe insert the mesh in my vagina. 1 day post op they informed that this procedure was carried out, on reflection they carried this out with no real consultation with my self. This type of surgery must end until it has been fully tested and investigated, as it has become quiet clear that it is ruining people's lives.20352014-04-27T12:52:35.0075120Janine CowieThe killing of seals is not an appropriate solution. More foresight is needed to deal with this issue. I support the proposal put forward by John F. Robins on behalf of Save Our Seals Fund.20292014-04-27T14:04:59.295121Mary RobinsonSteven - I don't know why you think Orkney and Shetland are run as one area while the Western Isles are split among several council areas. Exactly the opposite is true. The referenda in the three island groups will be completely independent of each other. Personally I think the islands could work fantastically well if all three island groups became a new country in the form of a union. Its maritime zone alone would be twice as big as an independent Scotland's! (Even Shetland on its own would be the second biggest oil power in the North Sea after Norway.) 20332014-04-27T14:52:09.9035123James ParkSave Scotlands Heritige20702014-04-27T14:56:40.5135124orv lehmango vegan20292014-04-27T15:10:39.445125robert sandisonWe hold all the aces use them or lose them.20332014-04-27T15:14:18.025126Donald MacKenzieThis is a proven part of our history and culture. It should be precious to all of us.20702014-04-27T15:20:44.8835127Susan MacleanGood luck, it is so important that Scotland's heritage is preserved for future generations we have lost too much of it already.20702014-04-27T16:19:12.0135128Wilf WilshawAs a Gorger who grew up near the biggest Gypsy encampment in Kent, Corks Meadow, I fully support this petition. And I would like to see the Traveler culture and traditions preserved.20702014-04-27T16:25:27.6275129Ian Peter NelsonLand Reform long past overdue.20702014-04-27T16:25:47.9535130Mary MckMy dear friend, a young mother is now bedridden. She's had multitudes of operations to take it out and it just keeps getting worse! FIX THIS!20352014-04-27T17:17:54.6775131RoddySave rthe seals , save the world 20292014-04-27T17:37:41.1835132Kenny BrillWe all need connections to place and culture.20702014-04-27T17:55:39.4575133Diana BrownI had ventral mesh rectopexy surgery done in December 2012.I did not think my health could get any worse...how wrong was i!!!This mesh surgery has ruined my life and health.My quality of life is poor:-(.Thank goodness i have a supportive husband.Dont know what i'd do without him.Trying to stay strong and positive though very difficult.\r\n20352014-04-27T18:30:47.5035134Rachel WhyteThe contributions that tinker and travelling people have made to our country are to be celebrated and their stories told and re told. We must stand together to ensure Tinkers Heart, this little piece of Scotland remains with the people of Scotland forever. 20702014-04-27T18:38:47.495135Lesley PayneAn unnecessary and barbaric practice that needs to be stamped out. Makes me ashamed to be British. 20292014-04-27T18:41:50.0035137Jana WigginsPlease stop your barbaric practices. The Seals were there first. Lead the way instead of lagging behind.20292014-04-27T18:44:13.3675138Isabelle GirouxThis immoral killing of healthy animals, beautiful seals, MUST STOP immediately, it is a SHAME!20292014-04-27T18:45:13.4775139Mia ElisdotterAren't we bigger than this? We live in the 2100 century and know by now that every animal has its place in the world. Please stop this horrendous killing and show the world that things can change.20292014-04-27T18:52:16.75140Viktoria SchmidtI respect every single animal, just last week I rescued a common field cricket. I can't understand why someone can kill a seal or any other animal. All forms of killing (shooting, burning, cutting...) are unacceptable.20292014-04-27T18:52:17.735141Chasta Schneider This must stop. Let's finally earn the name humanKind. 20292014-04-27T18:53:43.9635142Tom ForrestThis important cultural and historical site should be maintained by Scot Gov and should also be taken into public ownership.20702014-04-27T18:57:28.3575143DELAFOSSE GuillaumeI love Scotland and I like salmon - but not at any cost.20292014-04-27T19:24:07.5535144Thomasina MiddletonI had mesh procedure on my bladder around 15years ago. So far I have had no problems. My heart goes out to all the woman who have had problems. I suppose I just have to keep my fingers crossed I will be okay. Scary.20352014-04-27T19:24:34.895145SarahI am not from Scotland, but I am against any act of cruelty being performed on innocent animals. The fault does not lie with the seals but yet again with human interference. 20292014-04-27T19:25:41.1475146Derek PretswellThis is part of Scotland's cultural heritage and should rightly be protected. Well done Jess and Michael Russell.20702014-04-27T19:27:35.6235147Audrey ManasterskiEvery living thing has to eat. The overfishing is a human fault, not the seals. Killing them will not solve the problem. Stop eating wild salmon might be a solution. Slaughter isn't.20292014-04-27T19:37:28.8335148Brigid BraunPlease stop this madness!20292014-04-27T19:38:585149mandy sharpnot here , not anywhere , its barbaric20292014-04-27T19:43:09.895150Ana FantiniWe are not in the 1800's....you know this is not right20292014-04-27T19:47:25.555151Colette FontaineStop this killing once and for all!20292014-04-27T19:48:34.195152William TownsleyAye find this quite amusing that's why aye will put my name down and you may do with that as you well20702014-04-27T19:51:23.2435153charlotte mckenzie I am traveller and i say yess to whatever this is 20702014-04-27T20:00:10.9175154carolineits wrong man has to feel like a man(not)to murder animals there is always an excuse pathetic20292014-04-27T20:02:16.9775155Chloe Cameron-CarterThis makes me ashamed to be Scottish. It does not paint us in a good light. Sickening how anyone thinks that this is ok. 20292014-04-27T20:50:53.1435156Sarah johns There is no valid reason for this to continue - it's an embarrassment to your country 20292014-04-27T21:08:54.0335157Jodi DomianPlease don't allow people to kill the Seals, they have a right to eat.20292014-04-27T21:15:17.8175158Julie WilliamsNo more killing!20292014-04-27T21:30:49.5335159Aaron P. D'Souzapls save Mother Earth and the Seals of Scotland. stop the slaughter!20292014-04-27T21:38:45.945160Margaret MulhollandGood luck.20702014-04-27T21:40:32.4535161Rebecca HewitsonThis is barbaric and entirely unjustified. Please end it, now.20292014-04-27T21:51:33.1575162Jennett griffithsThese animals have a right to live their lives the same as you and me 20292014-04-27T21:52:28.595163Liz ChapmanIs this only transvaginal mesh or is it all mesh that has been used20352014-04-27T21:54:28.6835164Lisa ScharinWhen will the atrocious acts against other species END??? We are such a violent species and THE MOST destructive!! STOP the killing of helpless, innocent animals and learn to CO-EXIST with them! They are ALL vital to the health and survival of the ecosystems they live in and to the other species as well! Ultimately, we are destroying ourselves!\r\nI have also stopped eating any fish due to the negative impacts man has had on fish populations all over the world, as well as the enormous killing of "by catch"! All life is being threatened by TOO many issues! Time to begin GIVING back and STOP taking SO much and killing so much!!!20292014-04-27T22:11:44.9075165Mary SmoldersI agree with all the comments below protesting the killing of seals. It is unnecessary, and they have a right to life as much as we do. We don't need their pelts or their meat. Let them live!!20292014-04-27T22:17:05.2335166Stuart PatersonBest of luck with your campaign. The neglect & vilification of the history & culture of Scotland's travelling people, going back many centuries, shames us all. This might go some small way towards rectifying that recognition & in some small way help contribute to moving towards the official & legal parity they should definitely be given.20702014-04-27T23:15:58.1975167Sandi MurrieThis is so cruel!!! Why any animal has to suffer at the hands of humans...why??? Please stop this barbaric slaughtering of such beautiful animals!!! I am from England, but love to visit Scotland for it's wildlife!!! Please please stop!!!20292014-04-27T23:22:50.7135168Margaret GreenI hope the health minister doesn't try to pass the buck after all he is top dog here so come on do the job you are being paid for and get this terrible procedure stopped immediately20352014-04-27T23:40:06.475170Sue DoringI do not live in Scotland, but her history needs to be preserved for future generations to see and for travelers as myself to be able to see it in person. \r\n20702014-04-27T23:45:33.5935171Alan downingStart to listen to the people20292014-04-28T00:20:18.5875172Jennifer RademaI believe a world wide investigation of the effects of surgical mesh on the human body is long over due.It is time they disclosed exactly what they are implanting in every device they manufacture as in every other product, especially a permanent device. 20352014-04-28T00:34:24.915173Terri RogersMesh has had a devastating effect on my life and my family and should have never been marketed without long term studies. 20352014-04-28T00:35:52.7975174Rose Barden unless 'humans' STOP Killing we will Never learn to Live in Peace 20292014-04-28T00:37:14.9375175Arthur BardenCompassion must reign over Cruelty, if we hope to EVOLVE!20292014-04-28T00:50:39.3935176Joleen ChambersThe medical device industry enjoys unprecedented power in the U.S. Our FDA charter for these devices was written in 1974. The regulators are conflicted because industry fees provide the budget and dictate the activity. This should be a caution to any country that uses the U.S. FDA as the 'gold standard'! 20352014-04-28T01:09:26.5435177Roslyn BourgeoisI have been in severe pain over 3 years. The mesh had perforated my bowel .... discovered when I was taken to ER and had surgery. I am presently in a rehab facility awaiting surgery to have mesh removed and colonscopy reversed. Please stop implanting the mesh!!!20352014-04-28T01:43:46.9475178Samantha SquiresI send my love and support to every mesh victim...20352014-04-28T01:58:52.55179Katherine BringhamPlease don't let any more women get hurt by this.20352014-04-28T02:03:08.8435180tracey ahmetAs as pip lady and on my 7th op i know how let down by the government so support mesh victims20352014-04-28T02:43:25.9835181RachelKilling seals is wrong.20292014-04-28T04:35:36.7475182jacquie walkerProtect the seals please! They have the right to eat!!\r\n20292014-04-28T04:42:41.0775183Bethany HuntFishermen maximising their profits does not justify mass slaughter!20292014-04-28T04:58:53.0875184Alicia OgburnThis practice is wrong, please evolve and show the world how compassionate Scotland can be. 20292014-04-28T05:53:24.45185Paula LeCompteMesh is inhumane and should not be implanted in women!!!20352014-04-28T06:32:41.515186IvanI am not from Scotland but I think Scotland can lead the way for other nations to stop this barbaric and cruel practice. Please stop!20292014-04-28T07:06:45.2675187Kimberlee QuinnThis mesh is of the Devil himself. Wrecking so many lives.20352014-04-28T07:49:21.6935188Elaine McconaghyI had my TVT inserted in 2007 and have been attending GP since 2008 with severe pain. At long last someone is listening!20352014-04-28T09:01:16.55189Anne-Marie LindblomPlease stop this meanless killing20292014-04-28T09:56:54.3035193Isabella Mcgiff Makes me angry that historical sites even have to prove their rights . Where is the intelligence in destroying such a landmark and why would anybody benefit !! If it's not enough trying to end the travelling ways and their culture but also their history too !!!! Are you's for real !!!! 20702014-04-28T09:58:44.7635194Sandra MacaskillAll the best !20702014-04-28T10:14:14.2975195agnes townsleyHope all works out xxx20702014-04-28T10:28:45.8435196william.hailesthis is a great petition i think there should be wifi in every building20712014-04-28T10:31:185197Dianne BaxterSalmon farming is possible without culling seals...the law has to recognise how important all of our wild life is, especially the Seals...culling must be banned!\r\n20292014-04-28T11:41:03.8635198Miranda MorrisonThere is no need to kill these seals, other ways can be used that are humane to move the Seals along. This is needless slaughter of beautiful creatures that of course will eat fish! How dare you as Humans have the right to cull fellow beings just because it gets in the way of your profits. Start ow in showning your humanity. You know there are other ways to solve this problem and it isnt in crucifying another specie simply for existing in theri own land. And you The Scots dont see the irony of this. Leave them alone.20292014-04-28T12:16:20.335199John CouttsI currently live in Spain, but spent close to 50 years of my life living in Shetland where I was born and brought up. I can trace one side of my ancestry back to around 1510 in Fetlar, and by inference back another five generations to around 1350, also in Fetlar.\r\n\r\nThat surely makes me a Shetlander, and while I don't live there today, I keep a very close eye on what's happening.\r\n\r\nI fully agree that Shetland and the other island groups now have the best opportunity they are ever likely to have to decide a future for themselves and for generations yet to come.\r\n\r\nI truly hope that Shetlanders everywhere, and anyone else who has the islands' interests at heart, signs this petition to give the residents of Shetland, Orkney and the Western Isles the chance to have their say in this very important matter.20332014-04-28T14:12:28.695200Mr Greer Hart, seniorIt is cynical to proceed to allow unnecessary seal slaughter to placate a strident fishing industry. The conservation of our wild fish stocks are essential for future generations, but we should minimise the killing of other creatures that depend on such resource for their survival. Conservation ethics teach that a harvester of a natural resource, should be content with what remains after natural predation.20292014-04-28T16:11:11.8575201nan taylorsooner this petition is activated the better20352014-04-28T17:27:33.5375203Gina McGregor I'm a Scottish traveller n proud I cond off a great line a them off my granny's side wee have the Stewarts n the Mackenzie's n Stewarts again n my papas side there is the McGregors the Townsley's n the Reid's......I'm proud a my rotes x20702014-04-28T18:16:17.9075204MARY MATTHEWSi had mesh put in 2011.have never been right .in pain all the time.\r\n20352014-04-28T19:23:02.565205jess smithWe are so encouraged by all your comments, taking the time to sign the petition and helping others understand the heart of the Travelling people. Your support gives this petition a powerful spine and we cannot thanks you all enough xx20702014-04-28T19:24:32.675206Jill PesqueiraThis is so wrong. Please stop!20292014-04-28T19:35:20.175207kiwiriaukI am, to be frank, absolutely GOBSMACKED that they shoot seals, issue licences that people can abuse, and not make the farmers farm OFFSHORE. This is rediculous.... Its like setting up a cabbage patch in the middle of a rabbit warren.... I mean REALLY.\r\nOr how's about setting the farm up with better fences instead of killing the local wildlife. I am astounded.\r\nSigned and shared20292014-04-28T19:36:34.9535208DENISE SMITHPlease just listen to the views of the public......20292014-04-28T19:59:17.7435209CristianaPeople around the world are shocked by the unnecessary and cruel killing of seals in Scottish waters. Alternatives exist for the coexistence of wildlife conservation and salmon farms. I'd like to see Scotland stop issuing licenses to shoot seals, make the high-strength, high tension predator exclusion nets mandatory or make the farmers move salmons in an on-shore tank system. Instead of allowing the seal slaughter and the ecosystem destruction, Scotland should protect the wildlife in its waters. Please, do the right thing. 20292014-04-28T20:01:52.2435210Colin ParkerI am a UK Citizen although I do not live in the UK now. I still think this is a despicable way to treat any animal and it is about time the World stopped killing living creatures like this.20292014-04-28T20:13:56.4935211john bainI heard Gary Robinson say on radio that " It would be greedy of Shetland to claim the oil revenue" - well now, who was greedy and self centred when the Tories sacrificed our fishing industry for entry into the "Common Market" The only "Common Market" WE see is Spaniards, Frenchmen and the rest taking OUR fish - we don't go South and take there grapes! why should they come north and take our fish !\r\n\r\nWhether or not you agree withStuart Hill's efforts regarding the relationship between Shetland and Scandinavia or not my research clearly shows that indeed Shetland still belongs to Scandinavia, therefor we could, if the will were there, invite Norway to "buy" us back ( they have tried at least 11 times in the past ) and tell the EU and the UK to go their own way, we, and our forebears owe them NOTHING.20332014-04-28T20:49:47.7635212Gina GowThere is no place in our society for an unnecessary cull of wild animals that can be controlled by other non-lethal methods such as ADDs. 20292014-04-28T21:13:04.745213Reagh Campbell StewartToo much of our history is being lost in the name of progress. 20702014-04-28T21:13:28.665214Cameron MurrayThis is an important site for many reasons, it needs saved, valued and its message taught to children so it's importance is passed on. There is a very important message here.\r\n20702014-04-28T21:21:42.2435215susan maxwell The Tinkers Heart is an iconic relic.This structure should be preserved in as close a form as it was in the old photo, with a simple interpretive sign, and access gate through the railing. It would be good if cattle were excluded from the area and the original road layout was reinstated, to restore the ambience of the scene.20702014-04-28T21:22:28.435216Mary Foleyplease stop killing the seals wildlife is important to the ecosystem and for tourism there is no excuse for this cruelty20292014-04-28T21:53:595217Liz ParkhurstThis is a piece of history. It means so much to the Travelling People - remember we are all children of the Earth, and must all stand by each other. Please help save it.20702014-04-28T22:10:59.065218Christine AntleWith each seal killed...so is humanity20292014-04-28T22:30:11.35220Sharon Mistic"culling" seals is inhumane!20292014-04-28T23:19:53.6435222Suzie DoncasterI sign this from respect for the Scottish Travellers I have been privileged to know and so that their ancient traditions will not be lost- to lose Traveller traditions diminishes us all- Traveller and non-Traveller alike.20702014-04-28T23:24:31.3875223Ronald H FreemanWas going to vacation in Scotland this year. WAS going, now....I don't think so.20292014-04-29T00:12:48.2275224Phillip AndertonPlease don't follow the lunatic policies against British wildlife as exempified by the ConDem's in Westminster!20292014-04-29T05:40:21.095226Birgit CaminadaThese animals have every right to live out there ! 20292014-04-29T07:57:28.4235227Graeme PurvesHaving gypsy ancestry, I am keen to see greater recognition of and protection for Scotland's gypsy and tinker heritage.20702014-04-29T08:34:37.0175228Nuno SacramentoWe need to shift our emphasis from econometrics, to culture, social justice and the environment. This is a prime example of the importance of a site, to one of the cultures that form Scotland. It shows the cultural and historical importance of a site, in the hands of a single landlord. We need to proceed with caution, and should this be confirmed by travelling community and Historic Scotland to be an ancient monument, it ought to be legally and phisically protected as a matter of urgency.20702014-04-29T10:38:23.9775229Dr swati kumarWe are not living in stone age. Be humane. Ban seal slaughter 20292014-04-29T11:38:25.995230Jennifer SkirpanThis is horrific & cruel!!!!20292014-04-29T12:36:59.6675231Tara Walters We are connected to this earth and we all animals and humans have the same right to live. Please STOP the killing of defancless creatures. This is their home too!20292014-04-29T13:23:36.3875232PoveAll historic places in Scotland should be preserved for future generations, regardless of culture. This site should be enhanced to include more information on the people who deem it to be sacred. 20702014-04-29T13:32:12.5935233katey hartCan't believe anyone would think this is ok! 20292014-04-29T16:04:39.5735234Linda MooreThere are options to the salmon farmers. Please, please don't shoot the seals, please!20292014-04-29T16:35:07.325235mel hamiltonI grew up in Perthshire alongside the tinkers and this is a beautiful and important monument to their, and so our, culture.20702014-04-29T17:19:46.0235236Isobel reside Should be taken off the market 20352014-04-29T17:29:40.4135237MathewWhy? Why would you do this to any living thing, let alone seals? This is really bad and it has to stop. 20292014-04-29T17:57:39.2835238MartinSee there are hardly any signatures from Scottish compared to elsewhere even though this is a local issue20292014-04-29T18:09:43.25239Kirsty BellHave watched my friend suffer terribly. This must be stopped. 20352014-04-29T18:58:59.5275240Aileen McKayPlease support the suspension of TMD's and prevent further pain and resources.20352014-04-29T19:00:15.545241gordon masonno more wildlife killing in the name of fish monger profits from salmon please.20292014-04-29T19:27:20.7575242Nigel AldersonI wish you luck. Too much of our history was been lost due to greed and shortsightedness.20702014-04-29T20:17:33.185243Mary ErasmusScotland is responsible for persecuting innocent precious wildlife ... Shameful 20292014-04-29T20:21:14.6935244Lucie HowardThe 'Tinkers Heart' is an important site both culturally and historically, and should be conserved to represent the past, present and future of the travelling folk in Scotland.20702014-04-29T20:36:27.8675245Samantha McHughThese women deserve justice.20352014-04-29T20:36:45.5375246IsobelI am reading these comments and the tears are flowing. I thought I was the only person who was having 'issues' and that my complications were unusual. Couldnt be further from the truth!! I struggle on a daily basis with extreme pain, trying to maintain a normal life. This has to STOP! It is inhumane.20352014-04-29T20:59:04.185247Pauline MacleanWell done to Sea Shepherds for protecting these voiceless beautiful creatures x20292014-04-29T21:14:02.6735248Libby PottsTHERE HAS TO BE AN ALTERNATIVE --PLEASE.20292014-04-29T21:19:13.3935249Jean MoyesPlease ban the use of these and compensate those who have suffered as a result . I have a friend who is still suffering as it has broken away and lodged itself in other parts of her body . This should never have been passed as safe and an investigation should be instructed.20352014-04-29T21:23:03.225250Anne-Marie BoyleI was shocked to learn that a 'caring' government is happy to sanction the 'legal' killing of these innocent creatures. I would urge the SNP to review and disregard their present policy which is I would regard as barbaric. 20292014-04-29T21:30:44.895251liz RevueltaShame on Scotland for allowing the killing of seals to happen.We are grateful for the dedication of the Sea Shepherds who are protecting the seals.20292014-04-29T21:32:28.7035252Iris KochSeals have a right to live! Humans don't own this planet...20292014-04-29T21:50:32.4635253Annabel GardnerPlease please please use non-lethal ways of scaring the seals off. Killing the seals is so unecessary and barbaric and must be stopped!20292014-04-29T22:30:24.965254Elizabeth Trueman This is barbaric you need to stop shooting the seals 20292014-04-29T22:45:31.75255anne whitaker cruel and no need for it\r\n20292014-04-29T22:45:32.9035256Dawn BlissAbsolutely no need for this!20292014-04-30T00:08:58.7335257daniella wurmsA had a mesh put in 2010 from day 1 i had pain fhe docter never listen to me and they say the problem is in your head not the mesh .... i removed the mesh 5-03-2014 from day 1 am pain free ......20352014-04-30T00:20:39.0635258Joan BueterI had this done in 2007 and have had nothing but problems ever after. I actually had this done twice and it's a nightmare.20352014-04-30T01:33:49.5475259John RichardsonAll Scots should be recognized regardless how the past treated and saw them 20702014-04-30T02:14:34.735260Mykel WarmackWhat kind of people are we if sit back and do nothing about the seals being killed, they deserve our protection.20292014-04-30T02:31:45.165261Katina BrooksI BELEIVE this is a pure and wonderful place take into your thoughts for a moment if you will for you to distroy this would be an unholy act this is a place that is secret in Gods eye a beautiful joining of two lives becoming one I mean think about it would you like this done to you I think not !! We eat breath and bleed just like you we are no different God made us special was it not a gypsy women that took a spike for It not to be driven into Jesus we ask you for nothing we make a way that is us because of you people never wanting to look at yourselves and your problems instead you make others Huey cry and bleed so you and your problems don't make you look how you truly are in front of others please please I beg you let my people keep their small peice of land you have so much be Godly and hold you hand out in Jesus name I ask this of you . God bless and be well .\r\n20702014-04-30T05:39:53.885262elaineA lifetime of infection - Please include free antibiotic prescriptions for victims. 20352014-04-30T06:43:49.4135263Sandra HajekI really wish all this evil killing would stop. What happened to the world we used to live in and human compassion for animals. Please stop this madness! You can change this! Do the right thing!20292014-04-30T07:09:13.685264mary howeshow can a country do this in the 21st century- it brings shame on you20292014-04-30T07:29:03.075265Suzanne Locklin SOBS - please save our beautiful seals 20292014-04-30T08:22:47.7475266Richard MertensMy daughter is mesh injured. She is in unbearable pain. It has ruined her life. 20352014-04-30T08:23:50.065267Anne MertensMy daughter is mesh injured. Please stop the use of mesh. It has ruined her life. 20352014-04-30T08:26:33.065268Anne MertensMy parents were born in Scotland. My relatives lives in Scotland. Thank you Scotland for taking action against mesh. I am very proud of my heritage. 20352014-04-30T08:32:35.4535269Amy KeeperThis breaks my heart, having just been on a wildlife holiday to Scotland, I can't bear to think that some of those incredible creatures will be killed unnecessarily. Scotland attracts nature lovers from all over the world and the abundance of seals are a big part of that. We don't have that many large mammals left in the UK we need to look after those we have! 20292014-04-30T08:54:45.635270Janneke WijchersIt will not take away my mesh and my pain, the mesh ruined my life, i'm 100% unable to do a job, live just half the day :( "Plastic" in a women her body ? we can even get allergy and cancer from it ... But this law can save other women!!!20352014-04-30T09:16:57.1275271binnie shawTime to take a stand to Stop loss of biodiversity!20292014-04-30T09:43:26.985272shona mcleishThe sooner this is looked at the better 20352014-04-30T11:11:26.2035273Nandita ShahIts a shame that Scotland does not respect its wildlife. The whole world is moving towards stronger animals rights rules too. Scotland will and should catch up20292014-04-30T11:13:47.4975274LISA YATESThere is no need to do this nature takes care of itself and doesn't need mankind sticking its nose in.20292014-04-30T11:45:31.725275Lesley I've had a TVT for 10 years and thankfully had no problems with it so far, but if women are suffering then this has to be sorted !! Keep strong and keep fighting !!!20352014-04-30T12:02:40.2735276simon lazarusStop and look around !!! destruction, destroys!!20292014-04-30T12:36:06.8035277Sharon CampbellMy mother in law has suffered terribly because of this procedure, 10 yrs down the line with absolutely no hope of reversal and still going through agonizing pain daily. This should never have been allowed to happen in this day and age and disgusts me that Alex Neil continues to support such an attrocitie shame shame shame on him20352014-04-30T12:42:12.8475278Marion OxleyI am a frequent visitor to Northern Scotland primarily because of it's outstanding natural beauty, marine and birdlife. It is essential to protect this delicate ecological balance of which we are also a part. Tourism I'm afraid will suffer, bringing further economic distress if Scotland does not do something to stop the barbaric culling of seals by individuals and fishing companies alike, something that is being morally and legally sanctioned by the state but is now out of control. Surely Scotland has progressed from this "caveman" mentality to a more informed way of managing the economics, environment and ethics of it's salmon farms? I really hope so, as I would like to continue visiting Scotland. 20292014-04-30T12:43:48.1475279anne jourdanplease stop this cruauty\r\n20292014-04-30T12:47:44.585280James BoyleAn independent Scotland needs to take a look at its attitude towards animal welfare. Shooting seals is unnecessary, cruel and unworthy of the Scottish nation.20292014-04-30T13:05:10.0735281Ann CampbellThe past 10yrs of my life have been denied me because of this procedure, i have been left mentally and physically scared and life for me is in bed, the pain I endure as soon as I am on my feet is excruciating and my tummy swells where you would think I was having triplets and have great difficulty passing urine. I could go on and on telling you how bad it has been but know after reading other comments we're all dealing with the same pain and betrayal. Please put a stop to this now and don't let another woman endure this suffering20352014-04-30T13:49:14.165282Jennifer stewartIts my heritage please keep it20702014-04-30T14:08:10.525283Belinda DempsterWhat can I say.....typical HUMAN behaviour!!!20292014-04-30T14:39:44.985284LESLEY JACKSCHHow disgusting this is. Leave these seals alone!!!! SHAME, SHAME, SHAME........20292014-04-30T14:50:56.5335285YvonneHope someday to visit this place x\r\n20702014-04-30T16:57:36.715287Dawn RennieThis needs to stop20352014-04-30T17:03:40.385288GMarcusMany cultures throughout the world and through the centuries have had sacred places and their accompanying stories marked, to be memorialised for future generations. As Scotland fights for its independence this year, it would be but a small yet inspiring gesture for Tinkers' Heart to be officially recognised and preserved as part of the rich history of Scotland and her Travelling peoples. Don't bury the Heart, preserve it!20702014-04-30T17:06:19.2275289Clive SwinscoI , and many others campaigned to successfully stop the Orkney seal kills.... We're now 30+ years on .... When will we ever learn....!! Let our Seals Live...20292014-04-30T17:34:58.3635290liznever knew about this, hopefully will go with my sister to visit it this year\r\n20702014-04-30T18:48:48.1575291Caroline McallisterThis must be dealt with. 20352014-04-30T19:23:42.0235292Kelly NEVER EVER Buying any Salmon caught in Scotland or Canada AND making sure I tell friends! Until Seal slaughter ends!20292014-04-30T19:25:10.95293KellyI am asking all Salmon and Seafood from seal slaughter countries like Canada & Scotland to be labelled so we can easily boycott!20292014-04-30T19:30:15.3675294Lee MillerGood luck in stopping this disgusting licencing.20292014-04-30T19:33:28.3035295John CurrenShooting seals is entirely unnecessary, barbaric and shows no understanding of balance of nature. At a time when there is condemnation of similar approaches to the killing of raptors in NE Scotland why are we not also condemning the shooting of seals?20292014-04-30T19:44:28.2775297Shane M HolmesThis slaughter is an outrage. I hope the government take immediate steps to put an end to this before this petition is even concluded!20292014-04-30T19:55:49.265298VaNessa RupersburgPlease stop this cruel, inhumane act NOW!!20292014-04-30T20:00:09.3235299antonia bairdI have heard about this heart my whole life as an argyll woman - I would want it to be preserved.\r\n20702014-04-30T20:14:33.195300RebaThis world is so full of cruel behavior and such little care for life it's disgusting. I just have to say there is a special place for those that do these things. I hope that karma gets them for lack of having a heart and caring for all life.20292014-04-30T20:23:32.335302Chetan BarotBe humane.20292014-04-30T20:39:37.0635303Karen WenmanShame on Scotland if this is allowed to carry on!\r\n20292014-04-30T20:44:58.6135304Sofie van VeenNoone wants to eat Scottisch salmon anymore if they would know the real cost is seal blood. I for one wouldn't and would spread the word in the Netherlands. Tourists like the seals alive. 20292014-04-30T20:48:50.3535305 Star Aeslt Very disappointing to find out the Scottish Government is issuing licences permitting salmon farming, salmon netting and salmon angling interests to shoot and kill seals. If it's been pointed out to you as being unnecessary, why would you continue?? Rabid disregard for the highly visible and treasured mammal? 20292014-04-30T20:53:14.8375306Rebecca Mulholland When there are no wild animals left, will humans turn on each other!!!20292014-04-30T21:12:46.375307naoisesave the seals20292014-04-30T21:13:48.375308Venita ReichMesh hurts men and women. It ruins marriages and destroys our bodies. If polypropolene leaching into our water from plastic bottles is a major concern then why isn't it a major concern when they put it in our bodies!20352014-04-30T21:16:10.75309Annette ElgertI have loved Scotland and its nature ever since my youth, when I first came to Scotland 35 years ago. I am disgusted by the way this wonderful, unique nature, which is Scotland's wealth, is abused and spoilt. This is unworthy behaviour by the government and industry. Please save this paradise. Once lost, it will never return.20292014-04-30T21:56:55.9775311Lisa AndersonI have been suffering immense pain as a result of a mesh implant. I had no idea I had a permanent medical mesh implant inside me and that this was not designed to come out once placed. I did not consent to mesh being used. I have a very young family and am the main provider for them. Many people have made a significant amount of money from mesh products, many people now stand to lose a lot of money as a result of the impending litigation. People are scared. However the only people that really matter in all of this are the women who are affected by the mesh and all the family and friends who are trying so hard to support them through immense physical and psychological pain. I want to see and enjoy my children growing up and provide for them. I live every day trying to do this now, however in pain, trying to hide this from them and all the time with the immense worry of whether I will be able to continue to do this. We need organised and trusted specialist care from whoever in the world has the best experience in this highly specialised area of healthcare. We need understanding, counselling and ongoing support as patients and also for our families who are significantly traumatised. We need respect and where necessary financial support for our families. We do not need to be punished further by being caught in the cross fire of acceptance that mistakes have been made in using these mesh devices in UK women. We deserve humanity and compassion. 20352014-04-30T21:58:55.5675312Chrystine VernonSTOP THIS DISGUSTING INHUMANE PRACTICE NOW20292014-04-30T22:01:43.135313Gary VernonShame on you, where is your humanity!!!20292014-04-30T22:56:10.1535314Alison NivenScotland should put the truth on the Salmon products, just as you would the tuna and see how much they would sell then!\r\nCan you imagine reading only 1000 baby seals were slaughtered to bring you this gorgeous smoked salmon!\r\nScotland should embrace it and turn the seals to their advantage baby seal tours just as the dolphins. Also start labeling the Salmon with Seal friendly. I'd support any company that did this. Good luck with the petition. \r\n\r\n20292014-05-01T00:03:03.465315Karen WinsorWhy can't man co-exist with nature, without wanting to shoot, poison, trap or hunt anything that dares to impinge on any form of human activity?20292014-05-01T00:12:44.3175316Elaine HolmesTHANK YOU TO EVERYONE WHO HAS SIGNED OUR PETITION AND SUPPORTED US.\r\n\r\n20352014-05-01T01:12:53.5275317John Lawson I'm studying my ancestry and would like to see this and many other historical sites remain for future generations20702014-05-01T01:44:38.3275318Charles mozitisStop the killing of innocent seals!20292014-05-01T02:19:03.0675319Cliff herthelStop the killing20292014-05-01T04:26:03.2875320mark schramlets save them!20292014-05-01T06:31:15.7635321Summer SecrestStop shooting these beautiful animals. Start a eco tourism business around them and leave them in peace.20292014-05-01T07:40:15.845323Rebecca Lawrence Totally unnecessary, something needs to be done & soon!!!! 20292014-05-01T09:20:59.555324Tracy J HolroydScotland, please protect your beautiful wildlife.\r\n20292014-05-01T09:38:13.385325Andrew SinclairI am a scuba diver and have had the honour of sharing a dive at 30 meters with theses amazing animals. When you can look into their eyes and sense they are watching us then this cull needs to be stopped.20292014-05-01T10:21:11.8275326Marc R SherlandAll cultures have a heartland which provides a focus for their community, sometimes in paper, or stone or precious metal. Give the travelling people back their heart, its only a tiny bit of land of which they are the natural stewards..20702014-05-01T11:54:55.95327Sohani GonzalezThe old paradigm of male dominance and basically ignorance is over , we are in the Aquarian Age now where recognition of equality will happen ,no longer will women put up with abuse ,ridicule and harsh treatment .20572014-05-01T11:57:57.7635328DebbieI hate feeling like a sexual object and even though I have a professional job, I'm still subjected to comments which I'd rather not hear. It must be even worse for women who work in environments where these awful topless pictures are on display. I despise the banter that men and teenage boys indulge in about women. We still have a long way to go before women are respected as equals. Banning page 3 is a step towards helping achieve this.20572014-05-01T12:34:34.045329Ani SatheThere are 100s of freely available sources in our society today that people can go to if they wish to see page 3 type of models in bare glory & more. The sun is classified as a newspaper and makes its way into family homes with kids, page 3 is not needed here20572014-05-01T12:51:27.8475330Ebonee GregoryIt's just plain wrong.20572014-05-01T12:54:00.9275331Beyant BathI'm sick and tired of this degradation of women, it\r\nhas to stop now.20572014-05-01T12:54:28.0675332AlanThank you Ryan A - I totally agree.20572014-05-01T12:57:17.885333Jill BassettWe must protect women and children20572014-05-01T12:58:14.2235334Tracy GWomen are objectivised the world over and it is time it stopped. Societies that are striving for equality and humanity should not be fostering this outdated attitude towards 50% of the population in this day and age. Whilst these attitudes not only prevail but are tacitly supported by society, females will not achieve equality and society will not benefit to the full extent from their efforts. We really ought to be ashamed of ourselves for continuing to perpetuate a situation that puts females at risk and dishonours our mothers, sisters and daughters - let's be the generation that walks the walk.20572014-05-01T13:26:26.035335Amy ThompsonPlease do the right thing and set an example of a sexism-free media, so the next generation of Scots (and Brits) do not buy into the same sexist and demeaning attitude towards women (known to contribute to rape culture) that we have right now. 20572014-05-01T13:26:39.755336JamieIt's entirely to possible to enjoy the female form but understand there is a time and a place. No more topless models in newspapers please! 20572014-05-01T13:27:24.2575337Ginnie CummingHow would men like having male genitalia exposed (and described) daily on Page 3? Would it make them feel inadequate or anxious about their own appendages? Would they mind women laughing in the office? Of course they would. Its all about empathy.20572014-05-01T13:30:17.3935338J Payne Please protect your wildlife, it's not there to be destroyed. 20292014-05-01T13:47:00.2775339PAULINE WALSHNot before time!20572014-05-01T13:49:00.095340jane sawyer so glad to be one of th many wanting to ban this obscenity20572014-05-01T13:49:04.9475341Debbie PeacockThis is horribly cruel and completely unnecessary...what gives humans the right to do this?? 20292014-05-01T13:52:39.2775342L WhitworthIt would be a great coup for Scotland if it led the way on this.20572014-05-01T13:55:09.395343Claire JWe were campaigning for this in the 1970s, when will they listen????20572014-05-01T13:55:43.3075344Sid Ali DerradjiThis need to stop, we value our women's our sisters our mothers better than that. 20572014-05-01T14:10:05.1875345Lucy RossWe do not see male page 3 - objectification for one sex only - enough said20572014-05-01T14:10:21.1575346Marc ProweFull equality and dignity for everyone is one of the core values of the Christian faith - as Paul writes in Galatians 3:28 "Faith in Christ Jesus is what makes each of you equal with each other, whether you are a Jew or a Greek, a slave or a free person, a man or a woman". No-one must be turned into an object or commodity.20572014-05-01T14:31:18.7135347Janie NicollThe Sun is out of date and out of touch - end Page 3, and its objectification of women. Zero tolerance of sexism, there is no excuse.20572014-05-01T14:39:36.8575348Susan BestThis needs to stop, there is no need for this to happen, they have a right to be here and live a life.20292014-05-01T14:43:45.4535349tricia shawcrossWe are the worst species on this planet, Man is determined to make All animals extinct, and the way he is going they Will be EXTINCT in the next decade, please think about what your doing before it is to late...20292014-05-01T14:47:52.8975350gavin mcgregor hi folks a we note on the tinkers heart.\r\nthere no promises no guaranteed not here to talk with a politician jargon not here to thank you for doing this its because you want to do this and we have a past and this is what has come out of our past this is a historical avent that we are all witnessing that has never happened before it mite not make your life better but by being united in a common understanding with what is the right thing to do and if that means the right thing to do is by saving one square yard of ground for future generations so be it just to say we were not a myth we where here and we did not go quietly.GAVIN\r\n20702014-05-01T14:51:00.8275351andrew smithI am a BDMLR medic from Seahouses we have about 5000 grey seals here. The pups i rescue go to Hessielhead then released on the west coast. Im now having doubts to where i take them now ((20292014-05-01T14:53:03.5735352Asim HussainPlease please take this out of newspapers. This is a cheap trick to sell papers. If people really cared about society and "real" news they wouldn't apply such cheap tactics. People say Islam oppresses women when it is completely un true. So I push it back to you, why do you allow women to be subjected to that. Men look at it get the wrong idea, any wonder why UK has the highest pregnancy rating then the knock on to the taxes everyone pays for. Please it's not about one thing its the knock on effect it has on all forms of society. Please lets work together to make this a better place. 20572014-05-01T14:54:50.865353Gail BinghamHope something is done this time its a shame for the seals:-(20292014-05-01T15:21:03.9375354matt derringtoni commend the Scottish Parliament for recently setting the standard on how to combat slavery.\r\n\r\nSad and astonishing that in this day it should also have to consider making an official stand on another form of gross barbarity- the objectification of women's bodies.\r\n\r\ni believe there will be no better day until efforts like this are made and helped to succeed.20572014-05-01T15:32:54.25355Biddi KingsOnce more Scotland is showing the way! Demonstrating that we in England have more to lose that Scotland if we part company.20572014-05-01T15:48:45.775356Karen ThomsitThis is so barbaric. I bet you don't show this aspect of Scottish life on your tourist adverts. You should be ashamed of YOUR actions.20292014-05-01T15:56:03.5935357Robin EcclesThe cull is unnecessary and cruel.20292014-05-01T16:01:41.715358Ellen HowardCome on Scotland, show some compassion and stop this senseless and brutal slaying.20292014-05-01T16:16:51.9235360Sarah BestPlease restore long overdue dignity to women so that we may be treated with respect and as equals instead of our having to feel shame and pity for our current society and humanity.20572014-05-01T17:38:06.4535361Emily BacharachPlease stop pretending boobs are news. Page 3 is an outdated, irrelevant and harmful feature - sexualised nude pictures do not belong in a family newspaper.20572014-05-01T18:33:32.9335362amanda robbCome on Scotland! Lead the way on this, like you did with the smoking ban! Page 3 is an anachronism now, and if it dies the death north of the border, maybe it will meet the same south of the border. 20572014-05-01T18:34:32.095363Merril Archerno more boobs in the sun please. Give women their dignity.20572014-05-01T18:39:20.6235364Dawn TaylorI have felt strongly about the issue of page three pages objectifying women for decades .I urge Scotland to lead the way again in standing up for Values .\r\n20572014-05-01T18:43:21.015365Carl WrightThis is not necessary for wildlife - only the interests of commercial fisheries are pushing for this. we need to protect our environment,20292014-05-01T18:49:34.765366Annette HaighYet again man prooves what a disgusting, greedy creatures we are...I,m sure there,s plenty of fish for us all!! 20292014-05-01T18:55:33.645367Twiligha MacMahonI just signed the petition for the " Tinkers Heart of Argyll back to the Travelling People"" and I pray the Lady Laird of this land will approve if needed. For this is a sacred site for travelers who seeked comfort, rest, and peace. It will be celebrated again for all births and weddings, and a place of rest for all those who needed refuge without judgement. The Heart of Argyll belongs to the Tinkers.20702014-05-01T20:13:36.8735368Kay LeitchI'm proud to be Scottish. The Scots make great leaders. Lead the way in this: ban breasts on page 3 of The Sun. If they were denigrating black people, gay people or Jewish people, you'd be (quite rightly) quick enough to act. Why is it still considered OK to depict women in such a contemptuous way?20572014-05-01T20:20:42.1575369denise gentwhy why why!!!! so angry!!!20292014-05-01T20:21:26.4875370Vary Ferguson Its their culture,please give it back,i have read all Jess Smiths books,which I have enjoyed,20702014-05-01T20:21:46.6575371T MurphyPlease set an example to your colleagues in the House of Commons and House of Lords! Thank you.20572014-05-01T20:40:46.075372Chris BerryPage 3 belongs with the rest of the paper-in \r\nthe recycling bin.20572014-05-01T20:46:16.6035373Barbara dippleSave our seals.20292014-05-01T21:16:05.9675374MAGDA SERRANO SERRANOVIDA PARA TODA LA FAUNA MARINA.\r\n\r\nLIFE FOR ALL MARINE FAUNA.20292014-05-01T21:22:30.4475375Martina WolnyPlease stop this. It is such a privilege to have these seals in our coastal areas. Put your efforts in protecting them, not killing them.20292014-05-01T21:23:07.185376Kim HaslamYes. Please do the right thing Scottish Parliament and do the right thing...Ban topless woman in The Sun & Scottish Sun newspaper.20572014-05-01T21:24:38.925377Cathey CousinsThe Page 3 feature only serves to encourage men and boys, women and girls that the role of females is primarily for sexual gratification.20572014-05-01T21:38:55.425378RoseShooting seals because they eat fish? Come on Scotland - what happened to your usual pride, and harmony with wild nature?20292014-05-01T21:46:05.275379Gaye TimbrellThere is something we humans have forgotten....how to feel compassion, respect and love for our fellow creatures. God help us when the human race has destroyed all the seas, animals and the land..........will we never learn?20292014-05-01T22:12:52.4635380B MaceShow respect for human beings, they're sentient beings not hollowed out carcases.20572014-05-01T22:19:16.065381nichola mayburyPlease stop the cull, these seals have a right to be in these waters, its there home not ours to abuse! We have the privilege of sharing our planet if we keep messing with it for our own gain us humans will be sorry in the end, please just be seal friendly!20292014-05-01T22:27:42.8875382Debra BrogarthThese atrocities must be stopped. Why murder defenceless creatures.20292014-05-01T22:45:59.6035383Paul JarvisLets move things forward a bit.Blokey blokes & Girlie girls should just grow up.20572014-05-01T23:18:29.135384pauline haywardPlease protect your wild life. You will lose visitors if you continue this. People visit for your wildlife.20292014-05-01T23:51:23.3135385Junette PhillipsThis is degrading to women and totally disrespectful, and also bad for the future generation. Why has this taken so long to stop this in this day and age. Thought it was respect and equality for all and against the law on discrimination grounds. I and most people I know have not read the Sun newspaper for several years because of the sleaze it,s generally known for.20572014-05-02T00:01:45.8175386Pearl JacksonI really only found out how men react to Page 3 when working in a pub 3 years ago! The disgusting comments directed at me after leering at the page 3 girl were too much to bear so I left and will never work in this environment again. By the way I am a well preserved pensioner and have never known anything like this in my life having worked in may pubs in the past.20572014-05-02T01:13:31.2375387Teliah StuartStop!!!! 20292014-05-02T03:41:05.5475389malcolm bougheyIt is high time this kind of sexism was stopped there is no need for it in this day & age20572014-05-02T07:31:09.7235390John GibbonsFinding alternatives to protecting salmon farmers' livelihoods is doable, with a little effort. Seals in Scottish inland waters are a wonder and a tourist attraction just like whales (and they look right back at you). Our stand on protecting them, too, sets us apart and is a leader for others to follow in creating policy on environmental care. Commercially, it can only be good for Scottish salmon farming to be seen to be environmentally responsible. This move is bound to be popular with voters in Scotland, young and old as well as tourists. In this age, a strong signal, a win win!20292014-05-02T07:44:54.5775391Wendy UnderwoodIt seems unnessary to use such methods and violent means to rid us of wildlife.20292014-05-02T09:24:48.6375392Maria LaneSeals need and only eat fish or they starve. We can eat anything.20292014-05-02T10:43:09.0075393SylviaI can't stand the thought of these lovely animals being killed for their coats or otherwise..... let's save them!20292014-05-02T12:26:26.4575394Joana MelloI don't even now why this is a question... waht are you doing Scotland? Killing is the only way? I don't think so.20292014-05-02T12:30:08.7035395Sue Woodviolence for our own greed - again20292014-05-02T12:32:04.9075396Taniesha RowanYou should nbe so ashamed of yourself , this is barbaric , im disgusted and will now never come to this horrible country ever20292014-05-02T12:33:52.2675397Kieron MurtyAnimals are not here for our benefit whether it be to eat, "cull", wear or to put into a cage!! People need to wake up before they disappear 20292014-05-02T12:34:18.6875399StaceyI visit Scotland at least once a year, I come to photograph both the wildlife and the landscape. You should be protecting wildlife that attracts visitors from around the world instead of killing it. 20292014-05-02T12:36:54.1775400JewelAnimals also have the same right to exist in our planet..\r\n20292014-05-02T12:38:20.7935401Robert StephensGet your head together Scotland! Stop this vile cruelty!!!20292014-05-02T12:38:23.925402PaulineMake this illegal ASAP! please.20292014-05-02T12:39:01.195403Lauren McConnell "The idea that some lives matter less is the root of all that is wrong with the world".\r\n- Paul Farmer 20292014-05-02T12:40:40.735404Josef CrossPlease stop this.20292014-05-02T12:41:20.6875405Rebecca RamsdenIt is disgusting that this is happening. Please leave the beautiful creatures alone.20292014-05-02T12:41:32.795406amandaThere is no need for this let them live in peace20292014-05-02T12:49:32.265407Lynn IrelandDisguising. It is the same old story - "We can't be bothered to protect our stock in a humane way, so well just shoot anything that comes near them". Shame On them. Signed and shared.20292014-05-02T12:55:18.7935408RachPretty sure seals were there long before fishermen were. They're just trying to get on with their lives peacefully like any other creature... leave them be!20292014-05-02T12:55:24.625409Matthew NadelhaftManagement schemes manage have no beneficial effect on either wildlife or the economy, they only exist to appease constituents. Stop sacrificing both the environment and good science for votes.20292014-05-02T12:58:50.75410Diane cullimoreWhy should the seals suffer?Its wrong we need to protect our wildlife not destroy it!20292014-05-02T13:00:015411RaheraAll beings count. Not ours to use!20292014-05-02T13:04:39.4975412robert mcavoyWe are messing it up for marine wildlife enough as it is with careless pollution. This is ridiculous.20292014-05-02T13:09:25.9335413Clare mossThis is shockin20292014-05-02T13:10:19.275414Maureen martinDidn't realise Scotland does such horrific cruelty to seals. I love this country but this makes me feel very a ashamed to b Scottish.20292014-05-02T13:12:48.995416Samantha BeatonWhy in this day and age would you want to let this happen. Please stop. 20292014-05-02T13:14:54.5835418David BennettAs ever, total disregard for life boils down to a preference of money over life. Genetically modify the growth of Salmon in order to kill them and sell them... Kill the seals for daring to try to feed themselves on commodities of capitalism.. We live in a world where money takes precedent over all forms life, nature, animals and humans.. and that is something i will fight until i perish.20292014-05-02T13:17:57.375419CarolynDespicable just for eating Salmon. Very unnecessary behaviour just put nets round the stock. 20292014-05-02T13:19:22.765420GeorginaUnnecessary!!!!!20292014-05-02T13:32:45.5735421AnnaThis is utterly disgusting !!! 20292014-05-02T13:41:19.335422jackie rogersPlease please stop this very disturbing sick treatment of these poor poor animals 20292014-05-02T13:49:33.8175423Diana from PortugalI wish this violence finish, and seals stay in save, they sooo beautiful is one big crime do this for them. ( I´m sorry for my English i don´t know much about English but i try it).20292014-05-02T14:00:50.215424Susan Beesleyplease make them stop20292014-05-02T14:08:05.8075426Nina StevensIt is there home and we are encrouching on it. They cannot fight back. The people who do this are cowards, picking on defenseless animals. Shame on them.20292014-05-02T14:23:08.0635427Jon EvansIt is not mans right nor should it be to change nature because it suits us. Who on earth do we think we are?20292014-05-02T14:53:17.545428Barbara HortonShame on us humans, one more example of mans cruelty to our fellow creatures , they have a right to live their lives ! ! ! LEAVE THEM ALONE !!!20292014-05-02T14:55:27.9935429simon.Salmon isn't worth killing these animals for.20292014-05-02T14:59:08.3235430Teresa PriorCruel practise that belongs in the dark ages please stop this now Animals feel pain too.20292014-05-02T15:02:41.5635432Mrs Jeanne EdwardsStop it Now20292014-05-02T15:10:04.435433SuziI do not see any excuse for killing a wild animal that is merely acting in its natural way by hunting salmon.... it is us humans that need to rethink our ways of farming in order to ensure that no seals or other creatures ever need killing. I am horrified by this! 20292014-05-02T15:19:20.6935434michelle campbellthis is not being done in my name. if we weren't encroaching on their habitat then this wouldn't be happening20292014-05-02T15:37:31.895435Bienfe ChivaAll forms of animal cruelty should be outlawed20292014-05-02T15:42:46.1275436Paula MossStop killing innocent animals..its as easy as that.20292014-05-02T15:48:00.175437Mark ParsonsThe time is right, the time in NOW20572014-05-02T16:06:02.4635439Lawrence chang weiThey need to be stop!20292014-05-02T16:10:53.395440Deb Harcourt.What disgusting excuse for a human being could do and allow this to go on, we all have a place on this earth.\r\n20292014-05-02T16:38:06.595441Karen KnightWhy that's all I want to ask WHY!20292014-05-02T16:57:18.2935443Bogdan CojocaruI didn't expect to see this happening in Scotland...20292014-05-02T16:58:10.5475444Ilonka Stop killing the animals shame on you20292014-05-02T16:59:41.095445C ReesPlease stop killing these beautiful innocent animals . 20292014-05-02T17:09:24.335446JamesNo! Someone could build a skyscraper in a little village where it would be completely out of place, and if people don't need building warrants they will cut corners and make their buildings unsafe.20202014-05-02T17:26:50.3835447Linda SimmonsIts time to start reversing our need to dominate other species and learn to share earth wonderful resources. We make too much food anyway!20292014-05-02T17:48:32.2535448jo lewisWe have no right to kill anyone, no matter what species they are.20292014-05-02T17:50:06.1935449Joanne LewisNo one has the right to kill anyone, no matter what species they are.20292014-05-02T17:50:53.6135450mari88sto cease a being from existence due to your own greed and pleasure indicates that you are no fit human being. The world isn't just yours alone to decide what lives or dies, you are only here because earth lets you be in existence - it doesn't work the other way around. RESPECT ALL THINGS THAT LIVE AND LET THEM BE LIKE THEY LET YOU DESTROY YOURSELF AT YOUR OWN HAND!20292014-05-02T18:26:47.25452Jason Hartley-SmithThere is just no need for us to be killing these or any other animals in this day and age20292014-05-02T18:28:29.1835453Carole moorePlease,,you don't need to do this,,your country is better than this.20292014-05-02T18:31:30.3335454Adam RahmanThe beauty inside woman is what matters.20572014-05-02T19:07:24.125455brian grantmurder in the name of fish farming!!\r\n\r\nScotland should be shamed!!20292014-05-02T19:27:46.0775456Krishna UpadhyayaThere are more productive and profitable industries Scotland can support. If the leaders are true visionaries and forward thinkers, we'll see a change. The country will move away from barbarianism. If they are narrow-minded, stubborn and support this barbaric industry, then the nation will never prosper. It's like walking with boulders attached to one's feet. I hope that latter is not the case and a positive and productive direction is selected by the leaders of Scotland. 20292014-05-02T19:35:21.515457sheila owenneeds to stop20572014-05-02T19:44:35.365458RowanThey aren't pests, end this barbarianism! 20292014-05-02T19:45:52.2035459Karen NicklinThis shouldn't be allowed, and needs to be stopped. Let's hope Scotland takes the lead and stops this terrible act.20292014-05-02T19:57:15.665460Christine O'HaraPoor seals. Leave them alone.20292014-05-02T20:10:30.1435461E FranklinI am shocked Scotland are responsible for the seals deaths:( no more holidays there20292014-05-02T20:16:41.775463sally finchThis is shocking behaviour it must stop20292014-05-02T20:18:13.85464angela frostThe only creature to over populate the earth is mankind, do we cull them ? We do so much harm ,while other creatures merely try to survive . Shame on us!! 20292014-05-02T20:18:35.165465Sarah TyndallSenseless killing nothing more.END THE SLAUGHTER NOW!\r\n20292014-05-02T20:32:27.7875466John MuirI think it pathetic that Scottish and English landowners alike, along with some Scottish organizations cannot support this campaign by Jess Smith to preserve a memorial for a race of people who were a part of society free born like all others and since time immemorial provided a service for Scotland whether farm work, tin smiths & etc or fighting and dying for King and Country. Also never awarded any recognition whatsoever down through the ages and in this 21st century when most of the above mentioned were likely as not around when the tinkers were actively going about their business all over Scotland. Judgement never the less seems to have been passed by negative action. Those in power should hang their heads in shame.20702014-05-02T20:46:49.045467Pamela RaffertyWe must get this stopped! 20292014-05-02T20:47:26.7435468douglasthe heart belongs to our people it's been there for years it should be left a lone we have a wright as we are more part of Scotland through history and culture20702014-05-02T20:55:02.5875469amanda mizellThere has to be a way that the animals can live and not hurt anyone's way of life. The people just need to take a stand. \r\n20292014-05-02T21:37:40.715470Dilini AbeygoonawardanaPlease act like you still hsve heart!20292014-05-02T21:47:54.095471Christine LadymanIt really is time we stopped killing for the sake of it....or do people see this as sport?!!20292014-05-02T21:51:10.645472amaliaStop the cruelty20292014-05-02T21:56:53.2735473Barbara jane GrayI find it totally abhorrent that this culling is sanctioned by the Scottish Government. I had respect for them until now!20292014-05-02T22:02:14.5535474marsha druryit is putting me off my visits to scotland20292014-05-02T22:33:17.6075475Reg LeeThis is a foul stain on your country!20292014-05-02T22:34:52.1775476JessicaPlease stop killing these innocent animals!! 20292014-05-02T23:02:02.4475477Neil wellarThis is disgusting! Humans have no right to take a innocent life! Look into your heart and stop this killing ! 20292014-05-02T23:09:18.1375478kathleenGood Luck Kate x\r\n20392014-05-02T23:14:46.0635479Maria1.Hiere mi sensibilidad, debe llegar el momento en que todos respetemos a los seres vivos, a todos por igual\r\n\r\nHurts my feelings, must come a time that we all respect the living beings, all equally20292014-05-03T00:17:08.4775480CatherinrWe have no right to take another life, whatever species!! They have a right to live as do we!20292014-05-03T00:21:31.1035481Daz LeighStop this cruel act.It's sick, cruel and unjust...STOP!20292014-05-03T01:03:18.5235482CathyI can't believe that this campaign is still necessary - it's been going on for how many years now? It makes me sick that people think it's ok to mercilessly slaughter thousands of animals for their simple convenience. Preservation of human business and economic growth are not more important than the sanctity of life - whatever the species.20292014-05-03T01:30:04.9275483Emma PriceI cannot believe in this day and age that this barbaric and pointless act is allowed to continue :( we are the blight on this earth NOT animals.20292014-05-03T07:57:42.615485Chrissie SmithWhy do we think that we are better than animal and that they don't matter!!!20292014-05-03T08:14:52.8835486eva taylorStop killing seals in Scotland show the world the way!20292014-05-03T08:16:24.465487Jean BellWe should stop using 19th century 'solutions' to non-existent problems20292014-05-03T08:53:04.7575488Derek ChristieAbout time we put a stop to this.20292014-05-03T08:56:54.575489Madeleine GoumasHuman stupidity and greed again. Leave our wildlife alone. Find something else to eat.20292014-05-03T09:33:25.465490Kathryn HamesHumans are foul20292014-05-03T10:19:57.7735491andrea WHY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!20292014-05-03T10:36:09.8735492Tom MckinnonThese animals are eating to live, not for profit, they have a right to life.20292014-05-03T10:52:09.2875493Rebecca may How dare you think you have the right to inpose on this beautiful animals natural habitat & destroy it so inhumanly for doing what comes naturally to it!! You are the ones invading territory that doesn't belong to you, these poor animals can't up & leave they belong where they are, you don't!! Instead of cutting corners & resorting to animal cruelty, pull your fingers out! 20292014-05-03T11:00:18.385494Sam BlakeLeave the defenceless seals alone. It's barbaric and unnecessary.20292014-05-03T11:01:04.3975495Ryan WhitePlease stop this disgusting behaviour20292014-05-03T11:04:34.525496JulieBe nice to animals!\r\n\r\nStop killing them. Murdering humans is illegal - the same should go for animals. Besides, you're invading their home. Stop it.20292014-05-03T11:06:10.9475497Chloe AdamsClean your act up! This is totally barbaric, unnecessary and cruel.20292014-05-03T11:08:51.7235498Katie GridleyHideous, cruel, unnecessary and embarrassing. 20292014-05-03T11:10:41.3875499Lisa Foremanwhy??? Just why would you do this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!20292014-05-03T11:10:57.4435500elishaI can't believe people are getting away with this, evil sick murderers 20292014-05-03T11:13:05.5075501Liam ShattockHope all goes according to plan. Came here via Ricky Gervais so big thanks to him for sharing your cause.20292014-05-03T11:14:26.3635502StuartC'mon the seals!!20292014-05-03T11:14:36.785503Lisa MenthaThere is absolutely no need for any type of animal cruelty20292014-05-03T11:14:40.315504Terry SmithYou must be some one really big to kill an harmless animal with no means of defending itself. 20292014-05-03T11:15:38.135505Faye OppitzThis must stop!20292014-05-03T11:17:30.0935506Maxine ButtonWe can survive without salmon, wildlife can't, simple20292014-05-03T11:17:39.3175507David MeredithAbsolutely no need for this kind off cruelty. It says a lot about the kind off person carrying this out. They are harmless animals that have just as much right to live as we do.20292014-05-03T11:19:48.965508Elizabeth VaughnThis is a disgusting practice and should be stopped immediately. Killing for the sake of killing is shameful!! These farmers and government officials need to be taken to task. There's no excuse for this travesty! 20292014-05-03T11:20:20.4075509Anthony Woods.....does anything more need be said?20292014-05-03T11:21:01.225510Mike HensleyII thought civilised society was above this kind of thing?20292014-05-03T11:22:54.7235511MichaelaStop maximizing Profit and start being compassionate. Don´t destroy that beautiful Country of yours .Please.20292014-05-03T11:22:55.5675512robert zurawskiSick and subhuman20292014-05-03T11:25:00.9435513JenHorrified that these poor creatures are shot for no reason, they do no harm.20292014-05-03T11:29:29.1775514Katie MahoneyThere has to be a better way.20292014-05-03T11:30:26.6775515Rebecca berlipsStop the killing of innocent animals20292014-05-03T11:31:33.3175516Katherine AdewumiPlease support the No More Page Three campaign as best as you can as it mirrors and perpetuates discrimination against women in our culture. There are many of us who are sick of it. \r\n\r\nThank-you.20572014-05-03T11:37:05.995517Kelli DeGarmoThere is no need for this barbaric practice to continue. PLEASE STOP THE KILLING!!20292014-05-03T11:41:00.0875518pTheir existence is hurting someone? why would someone do that... so much idiot people20292014-05-03T11:45:54.565519Martha McIntoshStop the killing of poor innocent animals 20292014-05-03T11:46:03.755520HelenStop profit over life.20292014-05-03T11:49:17.6835521Paul a HaleIn the name of a fish, of all things! A pink, horrible fish, too. Seals are a higher order.20292014-05-03T11:53:42.3575522Rachel DickensI always choose Scottish Salmon....not any more. Shame on you!20292014-05-03T11:53:53.2835523ceciliaits a simple case of it has to stop... were killing ourselves with our own ignorance and destructive nature... and the world will quite happily go on without us!20292014-05-03T11:53:55.695524Vicki JonesToo many humans killing to many animals, for what reason? None!20292014-05-03T11:56:11.5475526Henri GuyWhat have animals ever done to us?20292014-05-03T11:59:40.7675527melissaWe have to be smart enough in this day and age, to be able to make aliving without having to slaughter these beautiful native creatures.20292014-05-03T12:00:36.55528Lesa MowbrayPlease stop killing these beautiful creatures,iam so sick of man killing animals it has to stop,I love to look at animals in the wild not someone wearing it please stop killing them.20292014-05-03T12:05:26.4075529Stewart GoldieIf you put fish farms in the seals habitat with weak nets you shouldn't be allowed to then kill them for going to lunch. Buy better tanks and comply with the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006. Revoke these bait and kill gun licences. 20292014-05-03T12:08:34.5175530Louise RoseKilling innocent animals so company's can make even more profit is just disgraceful. We should be protecting all living beings above greed!20292014-05-03T12:08:39.6275531Denise JacobsonJust how much damage can 1000 seals do compared to the damage trawling and nets etc do to marine creatures .If you are farming Salmon are they not kept in sea pens...?Circa 1,000 seals are shot and killed under Government Licence in Scotland each year. These deaths are totally unnecessary and an international embarrassment to Scotland. We would like to see Scotland lead the way with seal-friendly salmon farming using techniques such as on-shore farming in enclosed tank systems and proper predator exclusion nets around marine farms.20292014-05-03T12:15:07.2375532Jose da CostaStop embarrassing your beautiful country international & stop the unnecessary killing of innocent living beings!20292014-05-03T12:22:19.7535533Brigitte Baart-SluitmanRespect all life as well as your own intelligence20292014-05-03T12:25:23.0975534LuluThis is so unnecessary....WHY,WHY,WHY :(20292014-05-03T12:25:41.165535Jwana K WickliffMurdering seals is an abomination. Please stop this unethical, inhumane treatment of animals. 20292014-05-03T12:25:49.445536Laura LaneThey live in the sea, we do not. We need to work around them and cherish them.20292014-05-03T12:27:30.6435537Elen DaviesStop this now20292014-05-03T12:27:40.0975538Toneya KennedyThis needs to stop. If it were happening to humans then something would be done. We are all the same. The only difference between humans and animals is that we have a voice and the power to change things, they don't.. 20292014-05-03T12:28:59.4575539josefstop the killing..\r\n20292014-05-03T12:29:33.2535540Aaron KarnovskiA needless and barbaric practice that reflects badly upon Scotland. Why is it that slaughter is always mankind's go to solution for almost anything to do with nature and business. Perhaps a nationwide boycott of Scottish salmon would send a message? 20292014-05-03T12:32:24.5535541sue sparksShooting of seals so wrong in many ways 20292014-05-03T12:34:20.5035542Matt LackfordNo20292014-05-03T12:34:50.55543hampus johansenthis is just terrible, it needs to be stoped20292014-05-03T12:37:43.595544AdamThe Seal cull has no place anymore, and is a barbaric act. It serves no population maintenance strategies used in other species, and essentially is only undertaken as a means of selling the meat + fur, as well as allowing those whom for some unknown reason call it a tradition, to enjoy their annual clubbing of an infant animal that is of no threat to them. It is just senseless killing for the sake of it, Seal meat is not essential to food markets in Scotland or anywhere in the world. It may have once been the case but has long not been the case. There needs to be a re-evaluation of the laws that allow the cull, that take into account the "need" based on food supply, as well as if there is a reason for population control to allow the cull to occur. If neither can be legitimately substantiated, the cull should be outlawed and those that engage in the annual act treated as poachers. A hefty fine as well as a prison sentence.20292014-05-03T12:47:43.25545Miriam LarmourToo many incidents like this are happening worldwide, it makes you question mankind!20292014-05-03T12:55:52.6175546Jessica SakareassenPlease make this stop.20292014-05-03T12:57:14.5635547Samantha Dawes We don't own this planet, we share it. This just illustrates human greed & selfishness at its worst. 20292014-05-03T13:00:00.9075548Lisa Emma SawyerClub each other, bunch of brutes! ...and leave the poor seals alone! 20292014-05-03T13:02:08.0435549Jackie KnowlesI don't want this done in my name stop killing!!!!20292014-05-03T13:02:22.985550Emma WatkinsAbsolutely disgusting! What are you gaining from killing these innocent animals?!! I would sign this 100x over if I could! 20292014-05-03T13:08:24.2375551Shane SheridanAll threats can be controlled without violence20292014-05-03T13:13:19.195552Linda CattermoleStop the slaughter of these beautiful creatures.20292014-05-03T13:24:04.8975553Anand TiwariStop animal cruelty.20292014-05-03T13:24:15.295554Cassandra BondThis needs to stop20292014-05-03T13:25:35.85555Hamish MacGregorWe have been stript of everything in life by landowners. let us keep our heart.\r\n20702014-05-03T13:29:08.0635556Susan BattyQuite shocked that this is happening in Scotland. The seals are just living their lives and it's us humans once again that are the problem. Please stop this cruelty.20292014-05-03T13:30:44.7075557Elizabeth PermanPlease stop this cruelty!!20292014-05-03T13:34:56.5035558DianneI used to want to travel to Scotland from the US, now I don't want to go there know this barbaric act is going on.20292014-05-03T13:38:53.8475559fiona malcolmI cannot believe this goes on in Scotland, I am ashamed that we let this happen. If this doesn't change please note that I will not be voting yes to independance!20292014-05-03T13:40:40.8735560James YoungMake this illegal! 20292014-05-03T13:45:22.1035561Nic maleneyPlease stop. It's not acceptable in today's society.20292014-05-03T13:48:55.8735562Jayne bradburyAppalled. This is a disgrace. As human beings we act beyond contempt. In the last 200 years our own population has grown from 1 billion to 7 billion which isn't sustainable long term. Yet we act with arrogance and believe we have the right to control other species. This is sick and barbaric and is not justified. Stop this hateful action. 20292014-05-03T13:49:10.2475563anysia parkerKilling seals is cruel they are beautiful creatures and deserve a nice life as much as us20292014-05-03T13:49:57.535564Joy GreenwoodWillfully causing such pain to seals in this manner to kill them is a brutal bloodthirsty diabolical practice and should not be allowed to continue anymore .20292014-05-03T13:52:32.55565Tracy CartyWe don't NEED the farmed Salmon to live! These Seals DO need the sea to live! And, they were there first! Killing ANY animal just for profit is wrong!20292014-05-03T13:56:17.9075566Bobby ChapmanWhy do we do this? The seals are eating the fish we plan on wrapping in plastic and throw away?20292014-05-03T14:00:30.8935567Craig TarrIf you're worried about salmon stocks, stop wiping them out with nets. Seals certainly aren't the reason there are no fish left.20292014-05-03T14:06:31.0235569Natalie LinkHumans trying to change nature is never going to be a good thing. Just one more animal to become extinct because of human greed and laziness20292014-05-03T14:07:42.855570Peter RylanderPLEASE, PLEASE STOP THIS!\r\nWhy are you killing the seals?\r\n\r\nPeter Rylander 20292014-05-03T14:12:02.65571JennyWhy because we as a species can, do we think it's ok to kill whatever we like. Shame on you.20292014-05-03T14:13:15.1735572RachelleTHIS HAS TO STOP! !!20292014-05-03T14:19:42.6935573Maureen hallBarbaric practice20292014-05-03T14:21:36.3435574MayitoYou can't go around killing animals for eating what constitutes their diet! Leave nature alone and it will take care of its own balance!20292014-05-03T14:26:01.8975575Leigh Brownsmith Stop killing our seals!!! You are attracting them with the way the salmon are caught! Slaughtering them is them needlessly is barbaric, idiotic and cruel. Stop this now!!! These kinds of acts makes me ashamed to be part if the human race. We need to live together. We don't have to resort to killing and brutality as a solution. Can't believe this is happening in Scotland! WE ARE BETTER THAN THIS!!! Wise up guys!!! 20292014-05-03T14:33:50.2875576Jessica DixonPlease stop needless killing of these animals who are more precious and innocent than any of us.20292014-05-03T14:36:48.275577Sandra BradyPLEASE! PLEASE! Save the seals!!!20292014-05-03T14:36:51.2235578John FootePlease stop the killing of seals. There is no reason for this to happen in the 21st century.20292014-05-03T14:38:00.565579Claire miles To kill innocent seals is undesirably morally wrong !20292014-05-03T14:38:34.5775580John FootePlease stop the senseless killing of seals. There is no reason why this should happen in the 21st century.20292014-05-03T14:38:51.3635581rachiethank you to all who have signed. It's nice to know that there are people like me who care and who will not stand for this injustice. 20292014-05-03T14:59:46.895582Chris ElrodWhy does it take a act of government to protect the fishersman's needs and the seals? Where's the sense of protecting both without government involvement? I was just wondering? 20292014-05-03T15:04:20.525583Nathan IsaacsIf you do this your destroying the planet and ruining your own life.20292014-05-03T15:06:45.0935584Marion BennettNo animal is ours to kill, they all have a right to live.20292014-05-03T15:15:04.1335586Daniel thorneleyDisapointing Scots.20292014-05-03T15:17:17.0235587HarryWhy would you even want to kill seals. They're so cute.20292014-05-03T15:18:45.015588Alex OrlovHORRORS OF INHUMAN ACTS BRING HORRORS INTO THE WORLD OF HUMANS20292014-05-03T15:19:01.9475589Jamie WrightThis world is not ours alone! we do not have the right to end life and by doing this we give away any right to morals we assume ourselves to possess \r\n20292014-05-03T15:20:04.8235590carlyI think all animal cruelty should be made illegal its funny how they don't kill these black widow deadly spiders cos they haven't got the guts they just choose to be cruel and kill innocent harmless loving friendly animals and I'm sick of it this is animal cruelty and needs to be stopped now,they wouldn't kill an innocent person or a criminal so why kill an innocent animal that's not doing any harm,this makes me soo disgusted and angry and I absolutely love seals so leave them alone!!!! X( 20292014-05-03T15:24:19.925591Rafael RecaldeThis should finish20292014-05-03T15:28:16.0935592AgaBGood luck! x20292014-05-03T15:35:29.4375593Thomas We don't belong in their habitat. This must be stopped!20292014-05-03T15:47:12.6135594JoannaDisgusting, who would be proud to be Scottish when we condone such a thing.20292014-05-03T15:47:12.6475595varun jadwaniThey're like sea dogs. Who kills a dog?? A psycho is who. If you want to get the british off their high horses, this would be a good start.20292014-05-03T15:48:16.6335601EMMA LEEThis is inhumane and disgusting. The seals were there long before fish farms.20292014-05-03T16:03:04.765602Elizabeth Kent Shame! Shame! Shame!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!20292014-05-03T16:08:34.3875604 Caroline CampbellThese greedy fishermen are literally getting away with murder!!! It must stop now! X20292014-05-03T16:10:20.3235605Marc NationThe murder of innocent seals must stop! I am sick to the stomach of this barbaric behaviour.20292014-05-03T16:22:38.0735607Sam WillisTo kill a helpless animal takes no courage... only ignorance and low seff-esteem...\r\n20292014-05-03T16:25:21.6535608Christina These animals are here for a reason and deserve to live, stop being so ruthless and cruel!20292014-05-03T16:32:51.1635609Michael HattinghThe biggest problem with humans is that we think that some lives is less important than others.20292014-05-03T16:33:13.345610Pamela Turnbullplease stop making legal the destruction of the ecosystem ,simple as that. These are beings with nervous system therefore feel the same amount of pain that any of you will feel if being murdered in such cruel ways 20292014-05-03T16:42:28.6675611Jacqueline BlevinsThere are more humane and intelligent alternatives to this farming! It is simple...stop any form of cruelty! 20292014-05-03T16:45:41.395612Robert CallaghanJUST STOP!!!20292014-05-03T16:59:05.9075613Debra SmithStop the killing. I thought Scotland was better than this.20292014-05-03T17:06:43.6335614Caroline ORiordanplease stop the unecessary killing of seals in scotland20292014-05-03T17:27:36.575615jean mcallanI think us as proud scots should be caring to our wildlife, it brings a lot of tourisim hense brings in much needed money to scotland20292014-05-03T17:32:58.435616Jennifer PatalskyThis is unnecessary and barbaric in today's world. Please cease this senseless slaughter immediately!20292014-05-03T17:34:35.865617KAREN JANINA FAJARDOStop the killing. Our planet is our Home, there is no other place for us... we don't get a second chance. This is the time to live in peace and do things right. And you show peace not just among ourselves but also with our planet's wildlife. The strongest was born to protect the weakest. 20292014-05-03T17:48:13.2875618Nicholas TateThis needs to stop.20292014-05-03T17:50:09.3175619M AndersonWhy are man,s perceived needs always made the priority and never innocent animals who just want to live out the lives in peace.20292014-05-03T17:54:48.15621Fiona BarclayDisgusting abuse of power20292014-05-03T18:18:47.4435622Jacqueline GraysonSTOP killing now!!!!20292014-05-03T18:21:24.5175623Paula PlikhWhat is wrong with Scotland? I am so shocked to learn this.20292014-05-03T18:35:10.6775624Natalie JonesHuman kind needs to learn how to live alongside other species rather than destroying everything in our path.20292014-05-03T18:50:00.7775625robert petersbarbaric, we are a nation that needs to love our wildlife not kill it for our own personal gain, I would rather not eat salmon then one seal be killed in the name of man, no need for this at all.20292014-05-03T18:50:11.5275626Marianne WitteveenDit kan niet waar zijn! Alstublieft, stop dit nu!!\r\n\r\nThis can not be true! Please, stop this now!20292014-05-03T18:53:46.6235627Ben ShulmanThis is so wrong, the Scotlandian government should be ashamed...20292014-05-03T18:54:34.7635628Guy KiriakI thought Scotland was protecting the seals!!!20292014-05-03T18:57:31.675629Christine LewisPlease put a stop to the barbsric and unnecessary killing of seals. 20292014-05-03T19:12:02.915630nathan plymI am because we are. We are all accountable for the well being of humanity and the magnificent animals of this planet. We are killing ourselves, from seals to bees! All play an important role in the great circle of life. This cannot be allowed to continue. 20292014-05-03T19:25:17.9475631Alicia ForbesHope this petition will help save them!20292014-05-03T19:28:42.7375632carolina pereirastop this. this is the 21st century!20292014-05-03T19:32:06.0635633Chloe FoxSeals have a rightful place in Scotland's ecosystem, they must not sacrificed to commerce.20292014-05-03T19:47:53.0275634Wendy EdmundsonJust don't do this to a living creature please... no need. Please have compassion not hate.20292014-05-03T19:48:25.2435635Frances ButterworthI am so sad this is going on..Why are us humans so cruel to living breathing animals?? They have feeling too 20292014-05-03T19:52:32.75636Alexandra SingerI thought this was the 21st century20292014-05-03T19:53:05.8875637Alexandra SingerWhat's the point?20292014-05-03T19:55:11.1375638Marylyn ScottTinker's Heart is a monument worth honoring. My father was born in Scotland, so my heart has pathways there and here in America. Please acknowledge and help secure Tinker's Heart by making it one of Scotland's Monument. Thank you.20702014-05-03T19:58:22.295639David BurnettIt is a shocking indictment that the unnecessary brutal slaughter of our countries own beloved animals is sanctioned. Take a progressive approach and learn from the outrageous behaviour of WM govt.s badger cull debacle.20292014-05-03T20:03:18.3875640TeometeKilling animals is not good to Scoothish nobelness.You guys noble people even cannot harm an ant. 20292014-05-03T20:07:56.7175641Daniele De LucaStop do everything for money...20292014-05-03T20:17:58.9675642Helen YoungThis is disgusting and must stop and must stop now!20292014-05-03T20:37:49.9775643sherry knightJust stop!20292014-05-03T20:37:54.1175644Julie LyonI can't believe this is happening in Scotland, the land I grew up in and love. So upset.\r\n20292014-05-03T20:39:20.965645Angela TaylorPlease stop this mindless slaughter of defenceless little animals.20292014-05-03T20:39:58.055646RafalStop kill it!20292014-05-03T20:44:25.4175648Meredith Penneystop killing innocents animals, its animal abuse and it isnt fair, if you were in there position you would hate it!20292014-05-03T21:03:19.145649Rachel ColombNo animal cruelty is ever correct!20292014-05-03T21:06:45.725650Sonya McCallumYou won't be getting my vote unless fairness is issued to all man, beast and environment. 20292014-05-03T21:12:44.6935651Daniel Whittlestop it.20292014-05-03T22:09:15.135652Jeannette LavoiePLEASE STOP!20292014-05-03T22:35:30.685655Christina Greenland''Animal cruelty is one of the most unfortunate and barbaric demonstrations of human beings manipulating ill conceived notions of ''power'' over other species.'' - Ian Somerhalder 20292014-05-03T22:37:44.7335656sheila mcknightThey have been here longer than us leave nature alone .20292014-05-03T22:41:33.3175659Monica AlfaroMake it illegal the abuse of these benign and beautiful animals. 20292014-05-03T22:48:19.3735660Norman MaciverYes totally agree it's a pretty sad state of affairs. I was always under the impression that legal aid was just that......aid for people who could not afford to fight their corner without financial help. Yes time for a change in the law.20392014-05-03T22:50:52.4035661Lidija PodgorelecAnimals should be protected, not killed, for no reason! 20292014-05-03T22:53:07.8635662Giedre KleivaiteYou can change this anytime you want. It's only a choice. Just a simple choice, right now!20292014-05-03T23:29:53.075663CamThis is sick and heartless!20292014-05-03T23:34:05.6775664George This is a sick joke, there is NO need to kill innocent, defenseless animals and if you do your a sick evil coward20292014-05-03T23:43:09.795665Sandra PantingWhat makes ours lives any more important than theirs. Every living breathing being has the right to a life. Stop the killing 20292014-05-03T23:46:41.9375666JessicaPlease stop killing these innocent creatures!20292014-05-03T23:48:10.8535667Toni GardinerHope it gets banned cause it's awful:(20292014-05-03T23:53:25.3135668Leo CrossfieldYep - totally aggree - Stop killing innocent animals - its a disgrace!20292014-05-03T23:56:15.575669Rosemary GodwinObjectifying-of-women-style adverts or photos make my stomach heave: they should never be in newspapers, billboards or in public places.20572014-05-03T23:57:45.585670Theresa RitchiePlease stop seal culling in any form in Scotland. They enrich our lives and the areas we live in. They are beautiful, funny creatures. The greed of the Salmon industry will be their downfall.20292014-05-04T00:06:11.9475672Alyssa ChampagneWhat did these innocent animals ever do to you?20292014-05-04T00:21:07.9335673CaPPsiEThis is a shameful and barbaric practice and I hope the Scottish government will distance itself from this practice, outlawing it and revoking the licence.20292014-05-04T00:22:56.2075674Nati Stop the cruelty, we are more than just humans killing inocent beings..20292014-05-04T00:28:30.895676David LamymanStop killing seals, and preserve the natural breeding habits of wild salmon. Live for the future, not the present.20292014-05-04T00:28:56.9875677linlda robbinswould have thought more would have come out of you people, as a human being, but I guess you've succumbed to joining china's insane attitude and heartlessness when it comes to thinking about animals verses profit, shame on you why are you allowing this, have totally no respect for a country that insists on mass slaughtering there are easy and more human ways to manage your fisheries you have choose to do it the dirty way , again shame on you I for one and I'm sure many others who do not condone this would never spend my hard earned monies to take a trip to your sick thinking country to support your tourism 20292014-05-04T00:37:23.595678Lyn Gastonimagine a world without the beauty of animals - it's time to help and protect them. 20292014-05-04T00:43:48.4575679Lori KlimczakPlease stop killing innocent seals.20292014-05-04T01:24:58.9575680Celia M J CrockettThought thus gas been banned years ago it was going on in Oban and other Scottish areas when I was in my teens over 40 years ago. This a barbaric and in humane thing to do they are beautiful creatures and do no harm....unlike man who kill everything on the land and sea for " fun" or sport. Grow up and stop this NOW!!! 20292014-05-04T01:46:22.0435681Ashley Moidell End it now! Stop it Scotland! 20292014-05-04T01:59:54.7075682Elaine Ellis 'The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated.'\r\nGandhi20292014-05-04T02:09:12.245683Silvia BaumeisterStop killing innocent lives. There is room and food for all forms of life if people would not be so bloody greedy!!20292014-05-04T02:23:27.585684Jo TThis is how extinction happens... 20292014-05-04T02:51:49.5075685Robyne braggI can't believe such a beautiful country would kill it's natural fauna. I'm disappointed Scotland20292014-05-04T03:00:06.2135686Holly ByersPlease sign! 20292014-05-04T03:06:09.4075687Denise OswaldKilling innocent animals how cruel, how can they do this! These poor animals can't speak for them selves so i will, stop!!!!!!!!!!!!!!20292014-05-04T03:22:59.5475688Sylvia VossStop this unnecessary slaughter of innocent animals.. They have a right to a life just as we do! 20292014-05-04T03:34:02.2035689Doreen ReardonFor the love of God, please stop killing these beautiful animals! It's just disgusting and absolutely unnecessary! 20292014-05-04T03:38:49.825690Dawn in USA Stop killing the seals \r\nThe world is watching!\r\nAnimals don't have the luxury to shop at a grocery store they need to eat!20292014-05-04T04:03:34.915692Caron ElliottI can't believe this hasn't been done sooner! Time to listen to the people! 20572014-05-04T04:06:07.9075693GlennDo you guys still kill seals come on Scotland, what are you, Japan?20292014-05-04T04:12:59.865694KieranYou have no right20292014-05-04T04:43:16.195695Carol LaBranchestop with the killing! They were here first! We don't need to kill any animals!20292014-05-04T05:12:59.7635696Maryellen HoscilaWhat century are you people living in? We no longer KILL indiscriminately!20292014-05-04T05:39:44.2275697Gary C. SobieCruelty to any & all types of animals or mammals. Which may be domestic ones large or small or even wild animals large or very small. Should be very much punishable by permanent death in the most inhuman way as possible. And should be carry out quickly & swiftly with the most importesnt. Very SSwiftly! !!!20292014-05-04T06:02:33.565699sharon murphyAbsolutely barbaric to shoot seals, please STOP THIS FROM HAPPENING!!20292014-05-04T06:21:53.795700Denise BarlowWhy does the human race feel it's necessary to kill any and every living thing on the planet. It's disgusting.20292014-05-04T06:46:58.265701TeresaThis is happening on my doorstep and I am utterly ashamed20292014-05-04T07:17:26.6835702Jade McCallYou are being selfish and unnecessary. I'm disgusted by this. Please stop.20292014-05-04T07:47:05.6035703kelly quinnPlease stop killing them!!! They have done nothing to you! !!20292014-05-04T07:54:34.1235704jose m Romero I can't believe I'm disappointed with that in this world 20292014-05-04T07:58:19.6375705Jennifer WilcoxNot only are salmon farms incredibly damaging to our seas, most owned by foreign - Norwegian - investors, who send the bulk of 'their' produce to China & abroad, the industry are allowed to shoot our wild marine mammals. Are our resident and transient Orca pods excluded? This has to stop. The country has to start thinking long term rather than 'short term economic growth'. We all need a healthy environment to survive. We share this world with many. I hope the Governments 'targets for industrial expansion' - both energy & fisheries - are closely reviewed. 20292014-05-04T08:07:51.1235706Katherin Evelyn DoddThese R such Beautful Animals so stop the senseless killing. Shame on you all!!! One day it will catch up with you and you will start experiencing problems in your life & you will deserve because of all the evil suffering you imposed on these helpless innocent Animals that our lord put on earth for a purpose20292014-05-04T08:08:30.2475707Marie hitchenplease stop tbe killing !20292014-05-04T08:08:44.9035708Skander KechihStop killing animals 20292014-05-04T08:51:54.045709ShelleyHumans do enough damage to the Earth & her inhabitants, please stop being part of the problem instead of the solution! Take action now & put a stop to these practices, before more damage is done to both Salmon & Seal species as well as the evident echo system damage that. It's doing too!20292014-05-04T08:58:42.7435710Linda Bergantino"Humankind has not woven the web of life. We are but one thread within it. Whatever we do to the web, we do to ourselves. All things are bound together. All things connect. " - Chief Seattle20292014-05-04T09:17:40.2835711Ben TylerI saw this on Facebook on Ricky Gervais's pages. He does such a lot for charity but also a hilarious guy. I will be sharing this on my page too.20292014-05-04T09:21:27.1435712Dick GlasgowI, for one, will NOT be eating any more Farmed Scottish Salmon. ... Perhaps Chris Packham could take a look at this & raise a stink, when he comes home from Malta.20292014-05-04T09:43:19.7935713Jenna AngleEveryone acknowledges that human cruelty is wrong, but why can people not understand that any cruelty to animals is also wrong.20292014-05-04T09:45:43.6235714Lynn HemsworthBe forward thinking Scotland, be leaders not followers. Be seen to be making a difference 20292014-05-04T09:45:55.4035715Audrey ShannonNo more persecution of animals please20292014-05-04T10:18:09.9935716Tracey ParkerDisgraceful. 20292014-05-04T10:20:20.1335717Rebecca MadourieSave the Seals20292014-05-04T10:23:00.0535718Vincent MadouriePlease immediately stop issuing licences to permit salmon farming, netting, angling interests, shooting and killing of seals in Scottish waters that is unnecessary and barbaric.20292014-05-04T10:24:06.5135719katieIm disgusted by this. You cant persecute wild animals in their natural habitat for doing what comes naturally. Its ignorant and wrong. Do what's right! 20292014-05-04T10:25:15.355720Coral MadouriePlease stop issuing any licences to allow any netting, angling, killing , hunting of seals in Scottish waters.20292014-05-04T10:31:14.9075721Ross FlettThis has gone on for too long. I have worked with seals from as far back as 1978 and have witnessed the mass slaughter of seals by the with the fishing industry. Now is the time to put an end to the needless slaughter of our wildlife20292014-05-04T10:47:44.9735722Jackie HammonThis is disgusting - humans are overfishing and there is no need to slaughter seals20292014-05-04T10:59:17.6135723Jamie KnowlesThis is ridiculous, leave the ecosystem alone and maybe we'll have one left to rely on!20292014-05-04T11:05:15.095724Alec SunterBarbaric! What happened to preservation????20292014-05-04T11:11:37.5375725sebaround 1000 seals killed each year, are an embarrassment to the people of England, hopefully scotland will vote yes in its referendum... then they can carry on being embarrassed on their own.\r\n\r\nOR stop killing the seals, the seals are not harming the local wildlife and are a part of said wildlife... the killing is pointless as the salmon are being farmed and do not live in the wild!20292014-05-04T11:13:09.6135726Alan HarrisWhile I support this petition I also feel that the decision should be made in Scotland by the Scots20292014-05-04T11:26:53.665727Colin McWilliamNon lethal alternatives exist. Scotland's wildlife is a true natural resource and asset, it is important to our tourist industry. The lazy option is to cull, the salmon farms can take greater responsibility to explore alternatives.20292014-05-04T11:28:27.3175729Kay KellyGovernment simply doesn't want to understand the seriousness of the current situation in our marine ecosystems. 20292014-05-04T11:39:19.625730Sandraleave the animals alone!!!! 20292014-05-04T11:54:19.045731Fiona lakeShame on Scotland! This is vile, disgusting, heartless abuse to such a beautiful animal. Scotland deserves to be shamed for such a violent atrocity towards it's beloved seals. 20292014-05-04T12:07:24.3975732Diana RomanosPlease stop the slaughter of innocent animals! 20292014-05-04T12:11:05.4975733Peter Ostarek-GammonCall for a boycott on Scottish salmon until this situation is rectified.20292014-05-04T12:23:37.5735735Henry PeralesClean up your operation!\r\nIt stinks! 20292014-05-04T12:49:20.2635736morganWhere does Alex SALMONd stand on this? Money or animal welfare? Well, he is a politician, so...20292014-05-04T12:51:01.965737Sam CamilleriThis is disgraceful. Enough is enough.20292014-05-04T13:10:13.7335738Louise GoodThe whole world is against this unnecessary slaughter of innocent animals. Please hear us & stop20292014-05-04T13:13:19.0135739Marina HoldenIt's awful stop now!20292014-05-04T13:16:30.3435740SHEILA JOHNSONBy the time my grandchildren get to my age, I doubt whether there will be any animals or sealife around to rome free20292014-05-04T13:31:21.425742Ciaran GormanUnjustified and cruel. It's primitive and most shocking. 20292014-05-04T13:51:51.3735743Debra RobertsonThis is senseless, inhumane and simply murder. Let's get it right and give habitats back to wildlife and make sure they are in good condition for life to prevail and flourish on this planet. 20292014-05-04T14:18:33.3075744Dawn AustinThis is horrible and must stop!!20292014-05-04T14:50:03.9235745deborah archerthis cruelty should be stopped 20292014-05-04T14:57:29.5335746Dawn Marie Allen LockleyStop Killing these precious babies20292014-05-04T15:21:31.6435747Euan FinlaysonDon't kill the seals!20292014-05-04T16:16:29.495748Catherine HuffmanI have always wanted to go to Scotland to see where my Henderson Family came from but this is so horrible that I will not travel there until this stops.20292014-05-04T16:33:50.4275749ANNE DUNLOPIn the P&J Scott Landsburgh said that they were protecting fish from harm and suffering by killing the seals, these fish farmers murder the fish for human consumption! I also don't believe they shoot the seals as a last resort they probably see it as sport and enjoy doing it, this cruel practice won't help Scottish tourism either! 20292014-05-04T16:43:00.9735750Marie HaleWe are Scots and smart enough to find another way of managing seals if this is truly an issue. 20292014-05-04T17:20:59.9075751Leanne wrightson Horrendous and unesscesary cruel!!20292014-05-04T17:25:40.7535752Cindy HerrPlease stop the slaughtering of these innocent animals!!!!!!20292014-05-04T18:41:23.0175753Meredith Harley InserraI sign to honor my Traveller friends, tradition bearers of Scotland, who taught me so much.20702014-05-04T19:10:26.085754Emily HamesThese deaths are unnecessary and should be stopped immediately!20292014-05-04T19:49:57.4375755Suzanne LocklinSave our Seals. I am Scottish and I value these wonderful animals which make our shorelines so interesting and welcoming. I have stopped eating Salmon due to this abuse. The seals are commercially valuable in their own right. Please find another solution. 20292014-05-04T19:50:31.5935756Janet LocklinSave our Seals. Salmon can be produced without slaughter. 20292014-05-04T21:11:15.4375757Alex mackenzieGood luck with the petition 20702014-05-04T21:52:38.015758NICOLA PACEAbsolutely disgusting - barbaric.20292014-05-04T22:02:28.915759Caroline DenisonDon't you think there is enough murdering animals in the uk now,as it is? What will you do when there are absolutely no living creatures left for you to murder? Please come out of the caves. It is 2014.20292014-05-04T22:04:58.5975760Elizabeth WoodFor those who want to know more about the salmon issue...watch 'Salmon Confidential' on You tube or face Book. What are we doing to our marine environment?20292014-05-04T22:52:25.0075761Wendy ScottThis needs to stop, we are supposed to be a civilised society, this is far from civilised !20292014-05-04T22:54:14.525762Craig RaltonI cant believe such barbarity is being practiced in my own country. every time we humans take action to counter things, we actually make it worse like killing 40000 elephants to stop desertification IT MADE IT WORSE. Stop fish farming if you want to Save our Salmon but I suppose the damage is already done.20292014-05-05T03:17:08.795763Brenda Perrott Williamson Stop the seal killing ASAP PLEASE!!!!!!!!20292014-05-05T08:57:52.4935765margaret georgiousThere should be no need for barbaric practices in this day and age.20292014-05-05T10:20:02.9735766Merete Mowinckel, NorwayTo get things into perspective, how would we react if somebody killed a human being and left the child to starve... All creatures are worthy of being treated with respect.20292014-05-05T11:05:48.8935767gabriella ferenc"You shall not murder" - One of the Ten Commandments20292014-05-05T12:31:45.425768Emma RobertsStop the slaughter20292014-05-05T14:58:27.095769Alexander Miles"They erected three posts and wire. This was damaged. There are now cattle feeding and tramping on the Heart, leading to its destruction."\r\n\r\nThis detail from the "background information" is incorrect or, at best, very outdated. The current site is safely preserved behind a cattle-proof fence. Cattle are not walking on the heart and it is not being damaged. The heart is a well-loved local monument and is in no danger of destruction.20702014-05-05T16:27:49.6035770Duncan GibbPin-up pictures are for specialist magazines etc and should not be used routinely in the newspapers where they are liable to embarrass some members of the public who are forced to see them when a colleague opens a newspaper. They also coarsen the public dialogue.20572014-05-05T19:57:40.4735771DavidNobody have the right to kill them to protect fisheries... Others solutions exist.20292014-05-05T20:48:04.4575772mary stanleyAll life is precious.20292014-05-05T21:06:01.2675773Jane HebbornI find it completely shocking that such a sexualised and reductive images of women are still permitted in a " family newspaper". Is this the 1970s??20572014-05-05T21:17:15.95774Samantha BeckettSeals have as much right to eat fish as we do!!! Stop killing these innocent creatures!!!20292014-05-05T22:25:00.9975775Tonicha BaldockAbout time, in the fight against the sexualisation and degrading of women 20572014-05-06T10:40:06.4575776Anne JarvisSNH is neglectful in its role. This site is of national importance to the Travelling People. Are they not a community? 20702014-05-06T11:18:17.7075777Cathy LowThere are so many historic and listed buildings in Scotland, and that is a good thing. However, the Tinker's heart is more significant than any grand castle or stately home. Just as the great wealth of music, song and story that the Tinkers' held in their hearts and memories with no need for libraries or great literary tomes, the heart tykes up a small space, yet is deeply significant and special, pulling people in towards it. Not only is this an important site for Tinkers, but it is also (whether we are aware of it or not), perhaps a very special place for the whole of Scotland. Indeed, the world needs more Tinker's hearts! Please protect this one.20702014-05-06T13:08:19.7635778Mark HeavenorSTOP!!20572014-05-06T13:39:50.825779Joanna GregsonThe costs of the work required to protect the Heart will be far outweighed by the social value of protecting an historical monument of great importance to Scotland's Travelling people.20702014-05-06T14:56:00.235780Margaret PatersonThinking about, We believe you 100 per cent x20392014-05-06T21:15:20.9375781DonnaI hope and pray that the right thing is done here. 20702014-05-06T22:53:27.9635782Rosermary WebbHope you get justice20392014-05-06T23:42:47.4675783Elsa FraserAn honest lady fighting for truth for all well done.20392014-05-07T01:12:32.795784Ian MacGregorWe have been persecuted all our lives.and stripped of everything even our dignaty dont strip us of our heart.Please let it beat on.20702014-05-07T08:25:40.485785AnisaBan this embarassment of a newspaper completely!!20572014-05-07T10:40:45.885786hamishThe Duke of Argyll says "NO" ! Draw your own conclusions.20702014-05-07T13:03:31.0875787Eleanor O RiordanPlease support this cause. The settled community own this to the travellers20702014-05-07T13:29:46.7275788Katy RelphA new generation that respects women and teaches yound girls to respect themselves. ITS TIME!20572014-05-07T14:43:14.8175789Timothy MucklowIt's the little sticks and stones, the words from the past and the amazing pride and history of the Scottish people that make Scotland the country it is.\r\nI join all others who care, to implore the Scottish Government to find the resources necessary to resolve this problem.20702014-05-07T15:01:15.8675790Farquhar MunroAttention - is everyone, making these comments, aware of the background of this case. Consider how you would feel if a serious allegation was made against you and the suffering this would cause. This person raising this petition was proved guilty by a civil court of law to have made a malicious allegation and fails to accept the judgment made against her. I believe this petition was raised in an effort to lose sight of the outcome of this case. For full details and the truth of the story read the case on scotcourts web site 20392014-05-07T21:03:57.4635791Bonnie MacGregorAll over the world ethnic groups who had been robbed of their sacred sites, have now had their sacred sites restored to them, the Aborigines of Australia, the Maoris or New Zealand, Native Americans - where is Scotland going to stand in this hour. Shall she be a nation that recognises all that have given her a special uniqueness and stand with the nations that have been willing to acknowledge both Equality and Diversity for all, or shall Scotland remain in the darkness afraid to release her true potential by allowing commercial interests to destroy true heritage.20702014-05-07T23:35:29.3535792fiona macdonaldit is one small pile of stones in the middle of the road, it is not a enormous metalic eyesore like some of the monuments i see around clackmannonshire,on every round about in alloa there is a gigantic metal catastrophe of some sort, and they have no reference to scotland or the scottish people, yet the council paid around £30.000 each for these which are soposed to be art!, i beg to differ. surely if they can raise the funds for those statues in clackmannonshire, they can sort out this memorial for the Travelling people which in my eyes is far more significant than semi naked figures on round abouts20702014-05-08T10:14:49.8135793david parkread the case transcript, i'm sorry but cannot sign this perition20392014-05-08T10:17:37.585794K KennedyI've just read the courts report on this case, it is worth reading, I'm glad I did as now being aware of the full facts had enabled be to make a more informed choice. 20392014-05-08T11:47:07.125795Ross FraserPeople seem to be getting confused here...these petitions are not about individual cases, however most of them arise through individuals experience through their own circumstances. This petition asks the question are the same opportunities available for people to defend the outcome of defamation cases regardless of financial background, for defamation cases? The answer is no and is why this issue should be looked at. I for one was not aware of this issue but would like to think my basic human right to be able to appeal a court decision was possible. In the situation of defamation it is not the case.20392014-05-08T17:11:22.9235796MariaThe sexual objectification of women needs to stop now!20572014-05-08T20:30:51.595797AilsaFor beside the heart, the soul can flourish. 20702014-05-08T20:35:57.2975798Neil ShepherdI believe that defamation cases should be treated differently from criminal cases, and as a tax payer I would object strongly to funding an individual to challenge a court decision just because they don't like the outcome, when they have already had the opportunity to present their case at a fair and honest hearing. 20392014-05-08T23:03:13.395799Bob LovellPlease save this tan for the Travelling people .\r\nWe have been around for many hundreds of years and deserve the same respect for what we hold dear as all other ethnic peoples , Bokt ,\r\n20702014-05-08T23:42:44.4835800Cristina Morrison The tinker's heart... The gypsy wedding place... Would be such a shame to lose such a strong part of the traveller's heritage. It's just a restoration programme, they won't be setting up camp! 20702014-05-09T11:58:16.5075801LRWas asked to support a 'friend of a friend' by signing this petition. Glad I read the case first, just shows there are 2 sides to every story. Cannot sign this petition.20392014-05-09T18:34:04.6835802Charlie Menzies.This site is sacred to me and my deceased parents and my children, more important than any others in the country. Please preserve it.20702014-05-09T19:27:20.4935803Hugh Cameron-WhiteJohn McCorkindale the Lochgoilhead minister from 1875 - 1915 used to up to the heart and conduct weddings etc.\r\nMy family are from the area and I know this for sure.20702014-05-09T21:30:59.75804Carolyn DwyerA member of my family had a similar experience at the hands of the justice system. After a long haul he finally proved that he had not lied,although it was not easy. Good luck to anyone in a similar situation. I am sickened by some of the comments but it proves how quickly people are judged without the full facts being known.20392014-05-10T16:29:10.6575807Hannah DearingJustice should be freely available equally to all persons regardless of colour, class, creed or nationality irrespective of wealth.20392014-05-10T16:48:05.365808LynneAlthough I live in England, my mother's ashes are scattered near the heart, as will my father's be when his time comes. It's a place that means a great deal to us.20702014-05-10T17:08:08.9535809JPFrom reading the court decision it looks like justice was served appropriately by a well respected judge. I'd be angry if I thought good honest peoples taxes were being used on cases such as this one.20392014-05-10T21:34:47.895810Heather MackayColleague and friend of mine. I do hope you get some form of justice Kate, you deserve it. You are such a caring, honest person, and surely those qualities will win through in the end. Never give up. x20392014-05-10T23:09:04.1935811Tanya Muttittthis is of huge importance to the travelling community please keep it for them x\r\n20702014-05-11T00:29:50.5975812Norman MaciverIt is well documented that injustices do occur and those people have long hard struggles, sometimes many years, before the truth finally comes out.This petition is not about an individual case but is aimed at changing the law so that nobody is denied access to justice. I believe this is a basic human right, and in a fair society anything other than this can only be described as a form of descrimination. Please support this petition....look at the big picture. 20392014-05-11T17:25:47.6835813ANNE STEWARTSO MUCH HAS BEEN TAKEN AWAY FROM THE TRUE TRAVELLERS ALREADY PLEASE LEAVE THEM THE HEART AS THIS IS A REAL PIECE OF HISTORY TO OUR STORY WHICH IS SURELY DYING LITTLE BY LITTLE\r\n20702014-05-11T17:28:33.5135814Michael J. Blythe (FB Admin of Blythe Genealogy)This means so much to so many people. Monument status is the best thing for the Tinkers' Heart.\r\n\r\n20702014-05-12T09:56:49.2975815James MacLeodhaving read up on the petition raisers case - why should we, the tax payer, fund legal aid to defend a person, when in this case proves they were in the wrong. statistically there are very few defimation cases that go to court. as a tax payer there are many more serious and deserving cases that should benefit from funding - I do question the petition raisers motives. legal aid surely should be to defend or protect the innocent through the justice system. 20392014-05-12T10:29:56.5775816Ian RussellThis is a very special place for Travellers and is therefore a very special place to us all. The significance of the site is indisputable and it needs to be sympathetically restored and managed for future generations.20702014-05-12T14:04:43.7635817Peter QuelchThe tiny and crude steel fenced enclosure is an insult itself, though not much worse than deliberately siting a cattle feeding area around the monument. The site with its special history should surely merit a decent sized surrounding, with some trees planted to protect it in future. Scheduling it as a historic monument may help give the site the protection it deserves.20702014-05-12T17:01:28.3835818SusanPlease ban page 3 and help promote women as more than sexual objects 20572014-05-12T21:30:46.7575819Linda LennenAn important place and part of our heritage that is surely worth preserving.20702014-05-12T21:39:05.575820Anne HamiltonBrilliant! 1000 signatures recognising the importance of a Memorial to the Travelling Community in Scotland, a community which deserves to be remembered and valued for the important contribution it has made over the centuries to the very fabric of this country of ours. Well done Jess for not giving up on your beloved culture. I'm sure the Heart will survive for generations to come.20702014-05-13T18:54:13.685821cecilia reillyThe women who pose for the sun page 3 should also think about what they doing it is not all about money and fame20572014-05-13T21:47:27.0135822Edith ReyntiensThese monuments are priceless for our culture's continuity and heritage, we need to keep them. Thank you Jess, for bringing it to our attention!20702014-05-13T22:17:26.035823Hannah DearingPerhaps I have misunderstood what this petition is about when signing! I believed it was trying to secure justice and fairness for all persons regardless of financial ability to secure legal aid!\r\nAs regards the petition raisers case, I truly believe one individual albeit it through personal experience & suffering is trying to bring about a change in the law to benefit her fellow man. \r\nThroughout history it is well known that change often occurs due to the perseverance & persistence of one individual who refuses to accept that which is unacceptable. Absolutely legal aid should be to defend & protect the innocent through the justice system!\r\nAs we all know even in this Age of Enlightenment ---2014--- because of the human condition human error can occur!\r\nThis petition I believe is not about one individual but about the bigger picture.20392014-05-15T22:03:18.3135824Karen WilsonI hope the heart gets restored and protected. I pass it often and have always known it as a sacred place. I would love to get married there !20702014-05-15T22:30:12.6675825Elizabeth LewisIts high time the Sun dropped this outdated page 3 and gave women some credibility as thinking people and not objects who are valued by their breasts.20572014-05-16T10:22:57.0775826Judy FergusonNaked pictures displayed in a workplace would be illegal, therefore it defies logic that they are allowed in a 'family' newspaper often on display in numerous public places- cafes, waiting rooms etc as well as being read openly where the sexualised image of topless women can be seen by all and sundry. It is completely inappropriate and devalues and objectifies women. Children are influenced by this and as the Scottish Government fully acknowledges that VAW is caused by gender inequality this type of image perpetuates the problem and conflicts with policy approaches.20572014-05-16T12:58:37.515827Peter UptonIt's so sad that the richer people get, the meaner and smaller their hearts become. It is a rare joy to find wealthy philanthropists who aren't mean and who love their fellow humans. I hope this dream comes true. The black iron cage is ugly and this spot deserves so much better.\r\n20702014-05-16T14:13:03.325828Martha StewartSome one a long time ago made this beautiful mosaic for whatever reason. It would be lovely to keep it as beautiful as the day it was created for anyone and everyone who wishes to visit it.\r\n 20702014-05-17T11:38:24.5175830Leonard McNeillSurely this small tribute should be preserved for future generations!20702014-05-17T12:14:09.0235831Kenneth AbernethyThe Heart is an important fragment of the fabric of Argyll culture and protected.20702014-05-17T22:20:41.395832margaret mckayThere isn't much left of traveller tradition this should be protected for future generations to come for our children to be proud of their culture i hope that my signature helps protect this landmark i have never been to see the tinker hart but i would like to 20702014-05-17T22:26:05.365833nicole mckayThe tinkers heart should be protected to stay as strong as it is we need our traditions protected as there's not many of them left were all proud of the landmark that's been set there for years it would a shame to take it away now its appart of scottish travellers tradition a landmark our great grandchild could look upon and be proud of what they are!20702014-05-18T04:35:28.1275834Morag DonnanMay this petition be successful .\r\n20702014-05-18T12:40:08.25835Arlene CaldwellIt's about time this outdated feature was removed from the Sun- completely sexist and objectifies women. Should be banned!!20572014-05-18T13:38:14.535838Rhona McMeneminShow the way Scotland 20572014-05-18T14:09:26.3375839Eleanor SeeligHow will women ever be treated with respect if items such as page 3 are normalised within the mainstream media.20572014-05-18T15:11:32.075840Lee ReedArchaic!20572014-05-18T17:19:45.3535841Katherine HughesBecause if the country's most widely read newspaper objectifies women on a daily basis, it teaches its readership to do the same thing.20572014-05-18T17:27:37.895842Pauline Ellis It's time we moved forward, many women feel like second class due to the way they are portrayed in these newspapers. We're not just sex objects 20572014-05-19T11:19:11.7675843Josephine CrawfordRestore and preserve THE TINKERS' HEART!20702014-05-19T19:34:09.2875844JackyEducation of of key importance along with fostering basic values19622014-05-19T20:42:40.655845James ForbesYoung people all over the world should have the right to make informed decisions regarding their gender identity and expression of their sexual desires. They need protection from homophobia, biphobia and transphobia and they need full awareness of their rights in order to protect themselves from unwanted predatory attention. Well done to Sexexpression for raising this petition with the goal of creating a better Scotland.19622014-05-20T09:20:03.575847DianaI think Sex Education is an incredibly important thing for so many reasons. I realise that a lot of people think that such a personal subject should be in the hands of family - but to some degree I think these are the same people who don't actual teach their kids anything beyond this is how babies are made and it's a sin. Sexuality can be such a huge part of what we are and yet so many people learn all the wrong lessons in this. Lets make sure that respect and mutual enjoyment are at the core of what everyone learns.19622014-05-20T11:17:39.3035848penelope ann mckeeteachers involved should ALL be accurately informed and trained in dealing with thtese sensitive issues, and the necessary contraception etc easily accessible19622014-05-21T00:31:25.655849Alexander McCallumThe Tinkers and Travellers Scottish Claim to be descendents of the Picts the Broken Clans , some were covenanters and Jacobites who ran to the hills and never went home they are integral every part of our history please respect them and there artistic and cultural contributions to our country 20702014-05-21T11:26:07.475850Joyce LeysIt is definately worth reading the petitioners case report on scotscourts before deciding to sign or not.20392014-05-21T12:48:10.235851George SmartGo on - you know it makes sense.20702014-05-21T19:00:00.215852Margaret smart Restore the tinkers' heart 20702014-05-21T23:06:53.995853amandaTeach our children self respect and what love is. Don't leave it to the media.19622014-05-22T14:39:10.1835854Michael McLeodThis petition puts its finger right on the big point: independence may sound like a nice idea but it would be extremely risky financially for almost everyone who lives in Scotland.\r\n\r\nAnother financial crash like Lehman's can't be far off.\r\n\r\nPLEASE TWEET THIS AND CIRCULATE IT AS MUCH AS YOU CAN!20812014-05-22T16:22:32.235855Winnie Riley I hope the Scottish Government will let the Scottish Travellers keep their landmark known as Tinkers Heart, My Great Grandparents came from Scotland, as well as Ireland so I think it's important to the Travellers heritage, Please consider this petition, because it would be nice for Scottish, Irish people of America to come to visit, God Bless all who are for this cause 20702014-05-22T22:44:00.1335856Alison MitchellThe SNP *must* be made to respond to this. And the way to achieve that is if as many of us sign it as possible. This really is common sense. Everybody wants their bank account to stay protected. For goodness sake, let's make this an issue!20812014-05-23T12:37:16.945857Joe TaylorThe more information young people have the lower the risk of sexual assault, sexually transmitted disease and unwanted pregnancy. \r\nTaking care of children increasingly needs to focus on how they understand sexuality and sex in a world dominated by unreal media expectations and pornographic concepts entering the common lexicon. 19622014-05-23T18:55:52.7575858HelenSchool nurses have previously taught not just SRE but other health education topics however due to commissioning of services we are now being told this is not core business how wrong they are!19622014-05-23T22:41:31.4875859Norman MaciverIt is a fact of life that the justice system is not perfect. Like everything else involving human participation, it is at best flawed and at worst dangerous. I find it hard to understand how people can be so naive in believing everything they read without question. Perhaps a person would have to experience the justice system to appreciate just how flawed it can be. I wonder how many people would consider the petitioners efforts to change the law, a waste of tax payers money, if they themselves were walking in her shoes. The reason laws change is very often due to failings which are highlited through individual cases. If nobody was willing to stand by the courage of their convictions, nothing would ever change. I stand beside you all the way. 20392014-05-24T02:06:07.2235860Anna Lawrence-RobinsonAdvice to NO people.\r\n\r\n1) Don't be put off from saying independence would be unsafe. That statement is true, as the issue of bank account protection demonstrates.\r\n\r\n2) Don't get scared when the YES crowd say they're closing the gap. It's true they've got to win over the Don't Knows. But we should be fighting on THEIR home ground: we should be persuading the non-diehards among the intending YES voters that YES means they'll be worse off. This is the TRUTH. And this petition raises exactly the main issue we should use.\r\n3) Publicise this petition. Don't wait for it to close. If your MSP is a Lab,Con, or LIbDem, bring this issue to their attention. Get onto your local newspaper or any journalists you know. We need to force a statement from Salmond as soon as possible. Then we can watch the support for YES collapse in the polls. Sure of a NO victory, we can then have a nice summer. Face it - the NO campaign has been 'lacklustre' so far. We need to liven it up and focus it. Practically EVERYONE can understand the bank account issue. Practically EVERYONE knows that another crash is possible. So let's do our utmost to publicise bank account protection and how our position will be MUCH safer in the UK than as an independent state.20812014-05-24T08:44:58.2635861Elizabeth ShimmaI'm a Youth Worker and know from experience that the young people start thinking and talking about sex and relationships long before they start to have sex. If they don't receive appropriate and honest information, they will get information from inappropriate sources e.g. Internet porn, friends, older siblings. Young people who have sex early usually do it because they're uninformed about the consequences, easily influenced by peers , have low self esteem and often aren't mature enough to make an informed choice. Scotland would do well to invest in helping Scottish young people to make well-informed choices about becoming sexually active and follow the guidance, values and education systems of countries where they have invested in SRE and have lower teen pregnancy and STI rates.19622014-05-24T23:31:50.9935863sarah HagueGood Luck, claim what is our heritage!20702014-05-25T11:37:50.325864KevinI find it is an injustice that you go throughout court obtain a court order and no one cares about it and no one enforces it. The courts have deemed what is best for the child so it should be enforced. To spend a lot more money to go to court to obtain what you already have is a criminal act to the pursuer. If you need to return to court you should not have to pay to have something you already have enforced. 20472014-05-25T11:45:11.815865Frank Why is it that a country like ours is stuck in the dark ages when it comes to children. Studies have proved that both parents having shared custody means the child grows feeling loved and not dismissed or up unloved by the other parent. Why does the courts still think the mother should have all the power and the father should only see their child once a week or even fortnightly. It should be half or close to it if both are fit parents. Courts should be made if both oarents are fit to have a near 50 50 split so the children see both parents and their external families fully. Scotland says they are a progressive country but lack the basic needs for children and their parents. This has to be changed for the sake of our children 20492014-05-25T12:47:51.4075866Barry LiddleJust do it.20702014-05-25T14:19:38.565867ALAN MACDONALDThe people commenting negatively on the case report sadly do not realise the subsequent findings and statements that cause serious doubt over original verdict. The point of the petition is that ordinary people should not be denied justice by way of appeal or when new evidence arises casting doubt on original case hearing. Reading the original case report does not show future developments.20392014-05-27T09:32:47.8675868Katherine McClureI strongly feel that SRE should be mandatory in all schools.19622014-05-27T10:33:18.4335869Miranda ClarkeComprehensive education about the dangers or pornography too.19622014-05-27T18:47:15.3835870Roy KilpatrickWe can also learn from the developments in England and the guidance issued there, alongside the Brook charity's supplementary guidance. It must also include information on HIV and relationships education for young gay and bisexual men and women \r\nand for those who might be unsure.19622014-05-28T23:17:09.4975872neil towseyTravellers or not, heritage is heritage. Leave this landmark where it belongs!20702014-05-28T23:40:42.1475873rachel cassiniSave traveller history please20702014-05-28T23:55:35.3075874Gemma COSIMINI Good luck20702014-05-31T15:54:55.6635875JohnIn Sweden separated parents share custody roughly 50:50 in 28% of cases. In the UK the equivalent figure is 3.2%. I don't know of any comparative research on long term outcomes for children of separated parents in the two countries but I am willing to bet good money that the Swedish children do better, and certainly no worse. There is a huge body of research that supports the benefits of shared parenting post separation. The really sad thing is that I do not think there should be a need for any change in the law. The courts in Scotland and the rest of the UK are routinely ignoring their existing duties under the Gender Equality Duty(Equality Act 2010) and European Convention on Human Rights. Care for and of children is a core part of private and family life and thus covered by Article 8 of the ECHR. Gender discrimination with regard to the other Articles is prohibited by Article 14. Thus children have an equal right to care from both parents regardless of their gender and parents have an equal right to provide care for their children regardless of their gender. The best interests of children do of course rightly take precedence over their rights, and those of their parents but my point is that any interpretation of duties under the GED and ECHR mean that the starting point should already be 50:50 care or near 50:50 care. It is worth examining why the figures for the UK are so much worse than for other more enlightened countries. Personally I think it is due to a number of factors including the malign influence of the CSA, the strength of a misguided misandrist domestic abuse lobby and the vested interests of the legal profession.\r\n\r\nThe CSA takes account of only one parent's income for child maintenance calculations. 97% of the time this parent is male. This means that some mothers stand to make vast amounts of money from their exs by abdicating their own financial responsibility to their children and limiting child contact with their ex. \r\n20492014-06-02T13:20:58.6435876K WillsEducating children on what constitutes good parenting would also be vital to future generations... The vicious cycle of parenting as you experienced parenting is devastating for some families. 19622014-06-03T12:15:14.1935877James AlexanderMake sure the faith groups don't run the agenda as usual !19622014-06-03T22:28:42.6235878JohnHi John I agree with what you say but unfortunately we don't have the modern society others do even tho we have the legal system to make it that. I am also unsure if you agree with shared parenting or not but I cannot disagree with your figures and judgement on human rights etc as the government and legal system preach to other countries but cannot uphold the values they expect other countries to uphold.20492014-06-05T20:42:07.0575879Leeze Lawrencei feel that sexual expression in education should cover all sexualities and genders, this will reduce hate crime in schools due to lack of understanding and will allow a more diverse society for scotland. 19622014-06-09T18:13:02.9575880JRichardsImportant19622014-06-09T18:43:37.7235881Lewis HughesWhy is this not a thing.19622014-06-19T19:12:53.1775882Laura SinclairIf I ever have a child, I would like for it to be well educated, this would then reduce the chance of it being ignorant to the feelings of others. I also don't want other children being horrible to my kid just because of his gender or sexual orientation. 19622014-06-20T13:56:01.9975883Maura Stotteducation and awareness are key factors and Schools are a good target audience.19622014-06-21T12:20:36.7935884Megan Birtill This needs to happen the only way we progress is through education. We can never accomplish great things with our eyes shut. \r\nMy sex and realionhsip education was shockingly bad and I don't want any children I have to be misinformed 19622014-06-21T19:01:03.7575885gul wakilgoood19622014-06-23T10:59:10.365886Kathleen Murrayreality is that whether we like it or not children are having multiple sexual partners from an early age. it is imperative that children are given the information they need to prevent this or at least increase awareness of safety precautions.19622014-06-24T08:41:04.8135887Jennifer ForsythIt is important that all young people are able to recognise what constitutes non- exploitative and non violent sexual relations. With the increase in access to Internet porn and violent porn it is important that children have the tools to deal with this.\r\n19622014-06-24T20:35:16.0135888Bridget Sex is not something that cannot be ignored 19622014-06-24T21:15:35.555889Rachel FitzpatrickThis should not be a taboo subject in 2014. It is time young people were taught about healthy attitudes towards sex.19622014-06-25T00:32:20.6635890Les Morganwe need this in England, well we need it in all schools world-wide, plus #NoMorePage3 19622014-06-27T21:55:04.285891Frann LeachIt's difficult for gay and trans children in any case, they should have education to help them work out where they are going.19622014-07-01T21:49:17.235892Lydia ReidOver many years I listened to Grandparents and fathers on the phone telling me the stories of the loss of contact to a much loved child \r\ndepression feelings of suicide from them at times \r\nWhat most people find hard to understand is that the father feels just as worried and bereft when contact is in dispute\r\nOften these men have been the main carer and want to know about dentist and doctor appointments \r\nIs the man my ex is seeing really a drug dealer \r\n\r\nI also watched men sell houses Grandparents take out loans \r\nFathers lose their businesses to fund the constant court cases \r\n\r\nThis is heartrenching to watch \r\n\r\nWhen a Mum or a Dad loves a child you simply love that child and will do anything to keep them in your life\r\n\r\nMy heart goes out to all in these cases \r\n\r\nMostly though my heart hurts for the child \r\nSome children can be put to bed at night by a loving dad and by the time they wake up this same person has turned into a monster that they cannot speak about \r\n\r\nSo my sympathy lies with this child\r\nthe child has the right to the stability love and care of both parents \r\nThe child does not stop loving the other parent \r\n\r\nWhen a court order is made to grant contact as it should be \r\nThe child has been granted the right of parentage \r\nThe god given right to know and love both parents \r\nNothing should stop that \r\nChange our courts\r\nGive a child the right to know and be loved and feel the security of both parents and when the court order is made \r\nEnforce it for the child's sake 20472014-07-22T15:27:21.6975894Mark GordonSuch anti-scientific nonsense has no place in Scottish schools save for discussion as a particular minor worldview in Religious Education.21122014-07-22T20:24:03.6675895Richard CoxCreationism is religion-based and has no place in (any of) our schools.21122014-07-23T19:52:52.3875896GordyIf a newly independent Scotland outlawed all faith schools I would be even more impressed. It's the 21st century Scotland...come on!21122014-07-24T11:43:13.395897Terence MartinYoung people deserve the best in scientific teaching. Creationism and Intelligent Design is anti-science and goes against all objective sense.21122014-07-24T20:55:16.615898Bill OliverThe actual science of evolution should be taught in schools and alongside this an explanation of the religious beliefs of all faiths and their version of how we came to be should be presented. Freedom of belief and tolerance of alternative view points should be instilled in everyone, should it not?21122014-07-25T08:18:05.7335899Dr Gail AddisThe Scottish Government must take a strong stance on this. Children must not be taught lies about the origins of life on this planet.21122014-07-26T14:31:37.435900David KellyCreationism is a licence to indoctrinate children to know otherwise in religious values in their Science classroom. It cannot be allowed by any enlightened government anywhere. 21122014-07-26T16:03:09.495901Achilleas Paul ZotosWe've moved past the time for beliefs in creationism and magical beings, it's the Era of science, and people should be educated in such a way that it'd benefit them and the rest of society... Creationism leads to many other beliefs, it should be stomped out.21122014-07-27T12:49:09.5875902Gordon DrummondThe recent reports into governance of Birmingham schools demonstrate that religious infiltration into education is far from a merely theoretical threat. Adequate governance starts at the top: this is a national, parliamentary, responsibility.21122014-07-27T17:23:37.6875903kay saxonChildren should be taught to question everything and the prevailing theory, amounting to truth by way of evidence, is evolution.21122014-07-29T21:42:41.155904The Rev. Dr. J. Stuart WellsScience and religion are not enemies. Each has something important to tell us about human life.21122014-07-30T20:27:19.945905Kevin CargillEducation must be about facts and evidence. Religious fairy stories must be presented as such to malleable young minds. 21122014-07-31T10:51:15.75906S MurrayWe will be a laughing stock in the international setting if creationism is taught in our schools (other than in a Current Affairs setting.) We have our international science and research base to protect.21122014-08-01T11:50:54.0375907Michael RobertsI am a Church of England priest and geologist and oppose teaching nonsense dressed up a science anywhere whether in my country of England or Scotland 21122014-08-02T17:05:13.6875908frank gillinghamThe Scottish parliament is restricted in its powers by the ECHR. 1st. Protocol Article2 of which states that -"the State shall respect the right of parents to ensure such education and teaching in conformity with their own religions and philosophical convictions." So, if parents want their children to be taught creationism that is the business of the parents and no one else. What the anti - creationists want to do is impose their own dubious theories on others. Since this petition is contrary to the rights of parents under the above protocol it must be rejected.21122014-08-08T12:16:15.725909Ron McLarenGod Centred life views or Young Earth advocates should only have presence in Religious, Philosophical & Moral Education. But certainly not within a science curriculum.21122014-08-08T17:48:52.4535910Paul J. McConnochieThe children of Scotland have a right not to be preached at, and not to have their education affected by religion.\r\n\r\nIt is our moral responsibility to ensure them an education free from religious indoctrination, and of a standard to ensure they are equipped to navigate the world effectively.\r\n\r\nEnd obligatory worship. End faith schools. And, stop fundamentalist groups gaining access to our children.21122014-08-09T15:54:12.6575911Richard ReidWe are plagued by support for this drivel by the 'government' in Northern Ireland sad that a more enlightened country like Scotland should even remotely consider such medieval trash in its schools.\r\n21122014-08-09T17:12:05.095912John ArmourAs a retired secondary school teacher in Northern Ireland I am shocked to learn that creationism has found its way into the curriculum of Scottish schools to compete with Science on an equal footing. This is patent nonsense and has no place here. There is no creationism in Science and no Science in creationism. If it has to be found a place then it must ONLY be in religious education classes.21122014-08-09T23:34:14.3635913Jonathan DoreFrank Gillingham, the State has to respect the right of parents to make their own provision for their child's education, if they don't like that provided in state schools. But the state is under no obligation to provide, at taxpayer expense, an education that conforms to the particular religious doctrines of the parent.21122014-08-10T15:42:26.795914Alexander Robert FraserCreationism is not fact and has no place in the classroom. Leave it in church where it belongs.21122014-08-11T15:54:35.35915John OgdenScotland is noted for leading in science and technology. Let's not lose this. Facts not myth based lessons in the science class please. 21122014-08-15T09:45:49.6775916Patricia CairdThe most important tool we can give our children is the ability to question and to recognise bad arguments. The only way to do that is to encourage inductive thinking and critical analysis. Creationism should not be taught, especially as a 'fact' or as an alternative to science, or to teach the 'alternative' argument. There is no argument between science and Creationism: Creationism is j wrong in its premises and conclusions and is therefore no alternative to science as a tool for discovering reality. Creationism, if it has a use, is only good as an exercise into what constitutes and demonstrates a 'bad' argument. one without merit,or any basis in reality.. Other than that, it is of no worth whatsoever within an educational environment, especially one that purports to have a modern and forward thinking.curriculum. Creationism is anti-antithetical to such an endeavour. There is little enough time to teach children important knowledge without using precious time in the classroom to teach useless and unimportant drivel.\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n 21122014-08-17T13:24:35.455917john duffinBe sure to teach a class how humpty dumpty was born, fell, then tried to be put back together again.\r\nEvery school child needs to learn this lesson.\r\nFor cultural reasons, community cohesion, community diversity, blah, blah, blah.21122014-08-17T22:50:31.6275918Iain BowlesBelief does not belong in the classroom the same as facts are not accepted in Chuches21122014-08-21T22:19:43.7835919Professor Brian BoydIf we want to achieve a fairer, more equal society, we need to realise that private schools are a barrier to this aim. The very least that should happen is that charitable status should be removed.21182014-08-22T12:38:04.3235920Doug DanielAgree with Professor Brian Boyd - this is the very least that should happen. I was bemused when I first found out a few years back that private schools get charitable status. What we really need is a ban on private schools entirely, however. Their very existence undermines the idea of education being based on talent rather than money.21182014-08-22T13:26:42.9775921Dale BilsonI'm sorry, but this argument is too one-dimensional, sensationalised, and ill-informed. \r\n\r\nWhat, pray, do you think these schools do with their money? Do they pay out dividends to shareholders who languish on yachts on the caribbean? No - they reinvest in providing a quality education, including a commitment to providing this education (often enshrined since their very foundation) to those who would otherwise not be able to afford it. \r\n\r\nThere are other issues of course - including the fact that these schools save the state money by educating children who would otherwise have their education state-funded - but this is the crucial reason they deserve to be considered charitable entities. \r\n\r\nUltimately, if you consider the pupils of these schools to be getting an unfair advantage, then your issue is with the quality of state schools - it is counterintuitive to argue against the success of independent schools. 21182014-08-22T15:28:18.5875922ROBERT BROWNI find it incomprehensible that teaching of creationism is permitted and offered as an alternative to evolution. \r\n21122014-08-25T14:24:38.2135923ALISTAIR DONALDSONI'm all for level playing fields - look at the current Westminster cabinet line-up.21182014-08-25T16:44:36.0735924Ian CollacottCreationism, or "Creation Science", is not a testable scientific theorem which might be modified in the light of new evidence. It is a faith-based doctrine, and has no place in any science or science-related syllabus. To dignify this incoherent belief with consideration as a science is indefensible.21122014-08-25T18:27:03.595925M. HerbertYoung generation should learn science not creationism tales. Science has been proven as very useful to human history, and a universal language that all kind of people can understand.21122014-08-25T23:26:59.2435927Ritchie AnnandCreationism is no mere religion on its own terms, it is also a smear against scientists and a smear against teachers, claiming everything from scientists just looking at the data differently to being the underlying cause for crime, divorce and depravity.\r\n\r\nRead any creationist book you like... they can be had online if you wish. You will be astounded at the number of things claimed to remain unsolved and the postulated alternatives that are somehow still possible and, of course, support a 6,000 year old Earth. Where they don't lie, they ignore or handwave, and they've got to know they're doing it by now, because they've been doing the same thing for the past four decades.21122014-08-26T10:42:49.125928Andy NimmoKeep religion in the churches and science in schools! 21122014-08-26T12:00:58.1575929Liam McGradyCreationsim? No thanks. But my son's first school assembly this week is all about the Son of God?! Why? I clearly stated in the paperwork that he came from a non religeous household. Why is religion in our schools at all? Aren't there enough empty churches to go to if you want your child indoctrinated with bogus creation myths?21122014-08-26T13:31:28.8375930Sandeha LynchCreationism and its equivalents are mythical interpretations and cannot be presented alongside scientific enquiry. Our children deserve better.21122014-08-27T12:42:04.8075931Allan BeattieInaccurate religious dogma should not be taught in schools as if scientific fact. To do so is utterly reprehensible.21122014-08-27T13:05:31.9635932Brian ReesBrainwashing young minds is obscene. Any coverage of religion should be in a History lesson. Any idea of individuals entering into any unsubstantiated sect should only happen when they have a critical brain able to cope with it.21122014-08-27T13:17:35.5735933Nigel WalkerUnbelievable that we still have to fight this battle in this day and age21122014-08-27T22:11:09.6975934Paul BratermanWe don't allow anti-vaxxers into our schools to undermine health education and we shouldn't invite (as we presently do) anti-evolutionists into our schools to undermine science teaching.21122014-08-28T15:40:42.285935Carl WrightBy allowing ALL religion the 'acceptance' and legal protection that it currently enjoys, we are storing up a major problem for the future generations which will prove to be the demise of all 'civilized' cultures. People are entitled to believe in absolutely anything they wish (a point which cannot be denied under any circumstances), but no 'belief has a right to be included in law, and certainly not in any education system. We must wake up to the dangers of any religion infiltrating political systems. Most, at least in the western world, are at present, fairly benign, but all have the potential to produce extremists,and impose their will on everyone else at some point in time. It is time to act now by removing EVERY trace of religion from law so that we all, whatever our beliefs, can live together in harmony. Every single one of us is entirely dependant on science, and it is the only thing that keeps us all ticking along. To undermine it in any way is pure stupidity and should not be tolerated at all. 21122014-08-29T13:54:57.2535936mich woodJust stop this nonsense please. 21122014-08-29T20:33:18.7575937Lesley Ann CassidyJust another example of an unfair society that favours the rich. 21182014-09-02T12:32:13.925938Lois BellPersonally I don't think any form of religious belief should be part of the publicly funded education system. If people want to educate their children in matters of faith or religion, then they have the ability to do so through churches, sunday schools and their own family time. Religion should stay out of education, healthcare etc. It's only relevance is in matters of faith, and education is most definitely not a matter of faith. \r\n21122014-09-02T12:51:37.3275939David SomersSeriously, just don't.21122014-09-03T15:54:12.4775940Patricia CosgroveNot before time\r\n21182014-09-03T23:06:03.955941Keith GilmourHappily creationism is only being promoted in a very small number of Scottish schools but it should be promoted in zero! It is not science. It is an attempt to interpret one particular set of religious myths as science and to deny any and all scientific evidence that contradicts this approach. I have talked to several school chaplains over the years. To my knowledge, only one was a creationist. That is still one too many. I have worked with several science teachers. Some were theists and some were not. To my knowledge, 'none' were creationists. A few had, however, received unsolicited creationist tripe through the post at their school addresses. Science cannot rule out a God but it can certainly rule out creationism. Theological and philosophical questions of whether or not a God exists who is ultimately responsible for the existence of life, the universe, and everything can be passed along to the RMPS department. Some scientists (e.g. Francis Collins) would argue yes, other scientists (e.g. Richard Dawkins) would argue no. Creationism is not "in the museum of discarded ideas" -- but it should be! Intelligent Design in not a "technically complex semi-science." -- It is a mix of god-of-the-gaps reasoning and evolution-denial! A pity, by the way, to see a few comments below arguing for pupils to be kept ignorant about the beliefs, values and practices of Muslims, Jews, Hindus, Humanists, Sikhs, etc ("Belief does not belong in the classroom the same as facts are not accepted in Chuches", "Keep religion in the churches", "Why is religion in our schools at all?", "Any coverage of religion should be in a History lesson", "If people want to educate their children...").21122014-09-05T17:34:12.8835943John Edward, Director, SCISThe Scottish Council of Independent Schools has produced a short response to this petition, which can be found on our website under "About SCIS" then "Press and Media". http://www.scis.org.uk/about-scis-membership/press-and-media/21182014-09-07T13:35:37.865944Andrew HarrisonI have no issue with Private Schools, and the best of luck to those who are fortunate enough to pay for the. However, they should not recurve state funding where state schools do not.21182014-09-07T18:36:38.5175946mary doonanAbolish inequality\r\n21182014-09-07T19:05:32.5835947Andrew MortonTo them that hath shall be given.21182014-09-07T21:33:24.215948David RushentThe rich o not need public subsidy.21182014-09-08T13:19:07.1475949Alison LamondWe need a fairer society21182014-09-08T15:57:43.835950Paul walkerI wa aware they got tax breaks but was not aware the state did not, this needs to be highlighted far and wide.21182014-09-09T23:30:11.2035951Craig wattIn a free society you can't stop these places being set up, but you can recognise them as a force of inequality and stop subsidising them.21182014-09-15T22:52:43.8535952Joanne PatonIf police want to have guns why don't they train to be in the Armed Police?It's been proved in America that Police having guns STOPS NOTHING then puts more guns on the streets.Then police are known to make mistakes.This country has an armed gun squad.Why more?\r\n21382014-09-19T17:24:07.9275953Rikki AllanHelp those who really "need" help!21182014-09-23T13:27:56.0935954Pamela DawsonI can't believe only 63 people feel strongly about this. I it anything to do with the fact that I do not seem able to post it on Facebook?21382014-09-24T14:13:32.625955Ian B MalcolmOnly became aware of this by default, seems strange the links to promote it are disconnected?\r\n21382014-09-25T11:18:21.9075956Carole HarveyI would like to see an end to charitable status for private education in Scotland. Private education, above all else is divisive in a community, creating a feeling of entitlement and difference in those who experience it. How was charitable status ever justified. Let us see the beginnings of social equality and fairness in Scotland. Let us see the merging of different cultures, not the seperations within society.21182014-09-25T17:58:45.145957Fiona MathesonPrivate school foster elitism. They have no part in a fair Scotland21182014-09-26T00:15:48.7335958Allyn brownNo guns on patrolling police21382014-09-26T08:33:17.2135959John WardhaughWe need to do what is right.21182014-09-26T12:02:47.5335960roy lairdthis is a fundamental change in the way we police and more over the perception of the policing by the public 21382014-09-26T13:57:45.3735961Thomas WalkerThere is no need for the Police to open carry in Scotland. Firearms should be locked up in their safes in the boots of patrol cars until needed and authorised.\r\n21382014-09-26T15:31:06.55962Robert Elder It is bad enough that I have seen the miss use of cs gas and extendable batons on the public and if we seek to complain we are told to get away (but not so politely) and now you want a weapon that is fully lethal this is an injustice from those who we are soppsed to trust with justice 21382014-10-01T14:19:05.195963Peter FindlayThe initial step to humanitarian social division. Educating your children at a school on a basis of personal wealth is obscene in itself. If parents can afford the fees to these charity schools then the bill should include their tax burden also. Remove these elitist institutions charitable status immediately.21182014-10-01T15:02:44.335964Peter FindlayIn reply to Dale Bilson.\r\nYou might have read the background information added to this petition. You would therefore know that the state appears to be subsidising the independent school. Their right to be deemed 'charitable' actually appears to be a rather good tax avoidance scheme. Sorry but far from saving State money,\r\ndesperately needed for State schools, a few independent schools appear to benefit from the many Scottish taxpayers.\r\n\r\n\r\n21182014-10-07T13:46:48.3475965Kristiana Gotzsche Robertson Great idea - Scandinavia did this when I was a child, over 30 years ago!21492014-10-07T13:52:20.695966Sophie BiggWhile sustainability is a cross-cutting theme and appears prominently in some schools' improvement plans, the same cannot be said for all schools and in many relevant subject courses the environment remains an optional topic.\r\n\r\nBanning plastic bags is a move some supermarkets have already taken and is a good start to make consumers think about their effect on the environment.21492014-10-07T19:16:10.6435967Margaret TrevelyanSustainability is absolutely fundamental to our survival on this planet. It should infiltrate everything we do and everything we teach our children. It is that simple.21492014-10-10T11:19:48.7535968Gwen StewartWe have done our time having the power station on our doorsteps move further down the coast to torness!!!21952014-10-10T11:33:49.715969Fiona OliverI live on the East Lothian coast because of it's wide open skies and open landscape - do not destroy our quality of life with this proposal. Our councillors should represent their communities not their own opinions.21952014-10-10T11:55:55.865971Deborah ThomsonPlease do not destroy our coastline and our communities with these horrible proposals. Do something constructive to benefit the local people and the environment21952014-10-10T12:08:36.7775972JaneWe moved to Cockenzie specifically because of all the fields & green space where we enjoy walking daily with our dogs. Please do not take that away, it would have massive impact on all of our quality of life.21952014-10-10T12:33:16.9035973Susan RobertsonPlease do not destroy the beauty that is in East Lothian. I have moved to this small community for the pleasure of both the countryside and the beautiful seashore with its thriving sealife.21952014-10-10T12:36:58.9075974Tony MitchellWhy this lack of local consultation?21952014-10-10T12:48:38.8075975Rachel MarrThe proposed development will destroy the villages of Prestonpans, Cockenzie & Port Seton. 21952014-10-10T12:50:41.5735976Janis LaidlawThe reason we moved to East Lothian was for the gorgeous beaches, walks and fantastic outdoor life we could offer our children. Please do not destroy this lifestyle for our future generations.\r\n21952014-10-10T12:52:45.7375977Stuart FoleyWhy we understand there has to be some some of energy producing facility on the current site of the old Cockenzie Power Station. I strongly object to the proposed monstrosity that is the Energy Park which will bring road, light and noise pollution into our beautiful coastal town #keepourcoast 21952014-10-10T13:15:52.2375978Kim O.NeillWe live in a beautiful place please dont spoil it, Torness would be more suitable as not so close to houses.21952014-10-10T13:36:06.6935979Julie Davidsondisgraceful that a proposed energy plant will be bigger than the local town! We have had enough and done enough, let us have our heritage and coast line back21952014-10-10T13:36:18.0335980Tom BuchananAlthough I have moved away, still want to go back from time to time, and I would like it to be as nice as it always was.21952014-10-10T13:37:47.0175981Nikki Spence I've lived in cockenzie 24 years. It's coastline is beautiful. Our sunsets are magnificent. There is so much more that can be in place other than an energy park. Tate Northern, marina, hotel, new primary and secondary school to name but a few. Please save and keep our coast!!21952014-10-10T13:40:30.085982Diane McGhiePrestonpans has a historical battle ground that will be lost if this building goes ahead. 21952014-10-10T13:48:15.285983william morrisThis proposed energy park should not be anywhere around residential Holmes, the whole thing is a disgrace this is not why i have been backing Scottish politics it must not go ahead. 21952014-10-10T14:05:19.775984janice wheelanbeing brought up in Preston pans me and my family spent many happy times around cockenzie port seton setonsands it would be a great shame for the area to be changed beyond recognition\r\n21952014-10-10T14:09:16.1275985Mandy ThomsonI was born and lived in Port Seton for almost 30 years. The people of Cockenzie, Port Seton, Prestonpans and the neighbouring villages and towns deserve better than this. This is not the answer, as it would ruin a beautiful part of East Lothian, and destroy the fishing industry in the area. The land should be given back to the people as a green area which they can enjoy. They deserve that much. X21952014-10-10T14:36:37.815986Keith TurnbullThis is a blatant over development proposal. Destroying local History and total disregard for residents livelihoods. Future site development should reflect the industrial heritage ie mining and power workers.\r\neast Lothian iconic chimneys should be preserved whatever the final outcome. Over 850 supporters in favour of retaining chimneys. Land could be used as a landing point for a hovercraft service and attract cross forth traffic21952014-10-10T14:45:12.695987Stuart youngGive us a place where we can take our families have fun and not be in fear of construction, huge traffic congestion. We want somewhere that our children can play safely and where we can keep the great history of this town.21952014-10-10T15:03:53.0875988Robert McMathThis will change the entire area, for the worse. Publicly used green space, a historically important battle site and a locally important fishing industry will all be lost.\r\nDespite all these important points, my major objection to the proposals is the underhand, secretive way the proposal has been handled. Clearly the feelings and opinion of local people do not count for anything. Is this the kind of Scotland we want to live in? I think not.21952014-10-10T15:52:25.8575989Nan BurnsI believe that there has to be a more suitable place for this to go. This area is used for families to enjoy, please do not spoil it.21952014-10-10T15:54:01.065990Elaine SunterAn energy park of the volume proposed should not be built so close to a residential area21952014-10-10T15:58:57.5775991Fiona RitchieSigned&shared21952014-10-10T16:15:17.0875992fiona schulte Apart from changing the whole coastal landscape and Industries ie fishing ,we have a small private day nursery directly opposite the planned area .Is this is a suitable position for under fives to play in.Clearly the care of East lothian local children is not in the mind of the develpopers and planners .Lets hope it is in the minds of those in the Scottish parliament. 21952014-10-10T16:41:16.5775993Ian Wright MalcolmWe have come to enjoy our walks, up and down the coast, plus the amount of outsiders that travels down through Prestonpans, Cockenzie & Port Seton to take in the beautiful scenery of our coast, and to have this taken away would be a disaster.21952014-10-10T16:49:38.955994Terry KirkwoodThis 'Energy Park' will be a death knell to a whole community, history and would leave a lasting legacy by the Scottish Government that people dont matter, history doesn't matter! I will not be bought that this project will bring jobs!!! It will cause financial ruin to all households in a huge area who will have no protection to the massive drop in house prices. That is just the tip of iceberg for the cataclysmic destruction to the Sunshine County of Scotland. There will be no Golf Coast Road, it will simply be an industrial coast! 21952014-10-10T17:18:06.945995Anna TinlineThis proposal is not acceptable to the locals. Thus should be listened to. There are very good reasons for this. 21952014-10-10T17:51:47.5675996Andrew HillhouseIt is shameful that East Lothian Council should even consider these proposals. They have shown an utter contempt for the areas which would be affected which is breathtaking. Surely, the councillors who have helped these applications on their way should hang their heads and shame. They will reap the hurricane.21952014-10-10T17:56:14.7535997Karen Campbell The community living here have so many positive ideas for our local area. Please hear our voices and help us plan a positive space & facilities for future generations. There is so much of historical & environmental interest here. To lose our coastline to this proposal, which belongs away from homes & communities, would be devastating to us but even more devastating to generations to come. What a disappointing legacy to leave. 21952014-10-10T18:07:06.945998Jane BallantineHow any one could consider such a development in the middle of a large community must be mad!!! They can't have any regard for the health and well being of that said community. If it goes ahead I will swap houses with whoever allowed such a travesty and see if they like their new environment.21952014-10-10T18:11:13.665999Donna RodgersI've watched the environmental impact on the coastline in Prestonpans for the past 48 years. Slowly the beach has begun to recover from years of mining, at least 3 species of amber endangered sea birds have returned to the area, dolphins have been spotted in our area, and the odd seal comes ashore now. My point is this - if the area has become healthier for wildlife, then it has to have become healthier for the people who live here. Dredging channels, and building industries which have an environmental impact on the people who live here is just wrong. We've had our share of heavy industry in Prestonpans, Cockenzie and Port Seton, it's someone else's turn now.21952014-10-10T18:21:19.056001Ian eeleswhy has nobody approached msp Fergus ewing and Scottish enterprise to explain their unauthorized actions?21952014-10-10T18:25:11.9276002Diane WhyteWe need to save our coast, keep our chimneys, save our beaches, keep our fishing communities, save our battle of prestonpans history, keep our only green space that we have (Greenhills) develope something for the local communities & the tourist trade, most of all though save our wild life we have so many different species in water, land & sky that use our area that will be lost forever!!!!21952014-10-10T18:57:27.836003kevin scottHorrendous proposal, killing a beautiful and stunning coastline, we will lose lovely areas for dog walking etc21952014-10-10T18:58:39.6136004Gill GlancyHorrendous, Never in a Million years should this destruction of our coast go ahead, :(21952014-10-10T19:18:14.3476005JOE DEVINEWOULD YOU LIKE THIS MONSTROCITY ON YOUR DOODSTEP?21952014-10-10T19:30:56.166006Gerard QuinnStrong in numbers united we stand 21952014-10-10T19:39:24.2376007Annie GordonLet common sense prevail over corporate greed.21952014-10-10T19:55:53.8536008J StrachanIn a conversation yesterday with a friend, we realised we had very few places in Prestonpans to socialise, take our families and friends, spend money! Why not create restaurants, leisure and play facilities, shops etc? It would create a lot more jobs for the locals and put money into local economy. Without destroying a historic site and our beautiful coastline. 21952014-10-10T20:03:41.5136009Stuart DuffThe proposed energy park is colossal and will divide the local communities of Prestonpans and Cockenzie. The local main road will close and traffic will be rerouted along smaller village roads which is both dangerous and inadequate. The increase in jobs will be offset by the loss of jobs and the impact on the local industries will be devastating and life changing to say the least. The proposals also include building on the historic battle of Prestonpans site where grave pits are located, the ground is sacred to their memory and the bloody battle the Jacobites fought, Once it is gone the history and asset will be lost forever and cannot be reclaimed. The green space is widely used by people from all over the area and afar and to steal it from the community is an utter disgrace and theft. Please please please consider the local community and the people who have lived and died in the name of Scotland, Cockenzie and Port Seton.21952014-10-10T20:06:04.176010AlyssaSave our coast!! 21952014-10-10T20:55:58.4676011Caroline WalkerMy son has done a huge project on John Muir last yeast. To destroy such a hoge part of out heritage by taking away the walkway would be a sacrilege. Not forgetting the horrendous impact this will have on a thriving seaside village. There's miles and miles of countryside that would be able to accommodate something like this without causing total devastation! 21952014-10-10T21:07:29.7876012Yvonne Reekie I really want the East Coast to remain a quiet and beautiful part of the country not spoilt by a massive industrial area which will ruin our quality of life ! 21952014-10-10T23:00:35.0636013John LyonConsent to use greenfield land for the onshore site for Inchcape windfarm so that the area can be used to light up the local area 24hrs 7 days a week 365 days a year to assemble wind turbines which are currently being made at Methil - at approx. 25 percent capacity doesn't make scense which ever way you lok at it.\r\n21952014-10-10T23:39:38.9736014Elaine AndersonThe scale of the proposed development is not suited directly next to a densely populated residential area.21952014-10-10T23:43:56.886015Andrea StewartI am passionate about East Lothian.and wish to see this stunningly beautiful area preserved for generations to enjoy. The people and the communities of East Lothian have a right to decide and determine what is built in their area. 21952014-10-11T01:06:37.536016Stuart HoldenThe Scottish people have recently found their voice but will the Scottish Parliament listen to that voice?\r\nthe vast majority of the people who live here do not want to find themselves in the middle of an industrial estate with their coast, their heritage and their livelihoods brushed aside. Listen to us!21952014-10-11T04:05:58.0276017Joan DicksonHave we not had enough of dirt & noise for over 40 years from the power station let us enjoy our beautiful coast and adjoining countryside in peace without another bigger noisier and uglier monstrosity on the doorstep!21952014-10-11T08:01:24.8836018Lynne killinLeave our east coast alone it is beautiful as it is!!21952014-10-11T09:05:28.456019April NelsonThe impact of this proposed development on the local communities appears to be of little consequence to those proposing it - probably because its not going to impact them personally. It does impact those of us who live here effectively cutting the communities off from one another with little regard for the impact this has on people who live here or the environment. Full proper consultation with a genuine desire to listen and act our views and concerns is urgently required21952014-10-11T09:07:42.656020Elizabeth BalfourI feel that this whole plan has not been open an transparent an the residents of East Lothian being forced to unite and fight to save the East Coast. All these communities have had a history with the coast, do we now forget it. 21952014-10-11T14:03:15.2176021language McneillDon't want this21952014-10-11T14:17:05.836022M GordonI agree with comments relating particularly to the development of extra ground for industry. This area is bang in the middle of residential villages which have worked hard to maintain their identities - particularly through fishing, mining and historical interests - as more and more housing development has developed over the last 20 years on more and more of their green spaces. I believe that part of the proposed site was previously earmarked for a new health centre. While that did not materialise, we need the site to be developed in such a way that it could benefit all the local people - for increased resources or for recreation. Most certainly, options such as this proposal, which would have such a devastating effect on the nature of our surroundings, must have full and thorough investigations only in consultation with the public concerned. 21952014-10-11T15:22:22.5576023Denise KeenThis proposed development would rip the hearts out of our communities and have a disastrous effect on our coast line and environment,21952014-10-11T16:29:45.7536024Lesley BaillieHad to sign this petition against the Energy Park. This will kill Cocknezie and Port Seton as people will want to move, there will be no passing trade and an eye sore to boot.21952014-10-11T18:44:07.626025Anne Elizabeth BaillieI was brought up in Prestonpans and have always been so proud of our coastline, please don't destroy it. It gives so much pleasure to so many.......21952014-10-11T19:45:48.1576026Mary CotterPlease preserve our coastline and our communities.21952014-10-12T00:44:02.6876027steven rentonThe proposal bt Scottish Enterprise for this site is a disgrace in its current form. It will destroy and divide three communities, pollute the area environmentally and sociably and strip East Lothian of its tourist status!21952014-10-12T10:50:14.3176028Ed BethuneThe notion that there has been adequate consultation regarding the proposed Energy 'Park' is preposterous, and those in Scottish Enterprise and ELC who would argue otherwise clearly have no respect for the communities involved. The consultation route which was embarked upon by the aforementioned organisations was merely a box ticking exercise with minimal advertising. Communities should not have to dig for information in the way that we have had to in this instance - the great irony is that the community themselves have initiated the vast majority of any consultation. Surely this is the wrong way round?21952014-10-12T12:12:57.0176029Noelle We don't want or need the largest energy park in Europe on our door step. It would totally ruin the coast and the skyline of Edinburgh which has world heritage status. The Forth would be polluted and all the good done to clean the environment over the past few decades put at risk. JOHN Muir walkway, oysters in the forth, nature reserves etc. It would be a massive carbunkle in the beautiful East lothian tourist area close to the capital. Very detrimental to tourism. The chimneys can be seen from the centre of Edinburgh including the Royal Mile and the castle. Do we really think this proposed industrial scar would promote Scottish tourism - a massive ugly industrial site on the skyline? 21952014-10-12T12:29:51.7976030Chris GreiveI use this part of the coast for walks with the family, it's open access coastal spaces that are close to Edinburgh (east) & would be spoilt by plans to ruin history sites & the fact this proposed 'Energy Park' would be bigger than the town itself.21952014-10-12T12:49:40.936031Jeannine MjosethClean water and a clean environment are the most important things the Parliament can protect. Without these, nothing else is possible or worth doing.21952014-10-12T12:51:12.6936032Cameron JayNot long in the area and I was actually looking forward to the removal of the old CFPS. I genuinely thought a project would be implemented to give the site a relevant and viable use for the local communities and forth, North Sea coast. A marina, yaught haven, coastal recreation and tourism site would be an amazing draw to people from all over the world to this ancient and historical part of Scotland. 21952014-10-12T19:30:23.0236033Louise WhitsonDo not destroy our beautiful coastline21952014-10-12T19:32:35.86034Rita Murray Against this proposal21952014-10-13T11:17:13.5136035Sheila LaingPort Seton is a working harbour and this would negatively impact on this small but crucial local industry. The adverse impact on surrounding historical sites is important. Our beautiful coastline would be decimated. Leisure opportunities on the sea for community groups like Boatie Blest would be reduced. 21952014-10-13T15:39:04.3736036Douglas FarquharLeave our landscape for everyone to enjoy21952014-10-13T15:50:28.846037Carl John BarberI will not see two towns and a large community torn apart and their environment and history ruined and lost forever. 21952014-10-13T17:08:15.2136040Paul smith Don't won't our beautiful coastline destroyed by an industrial estate take it elsewhere ! 21952014-10-13T19:05:13.9276042Sharon MalcolmThis will have a devasting effect to our expanding communities and to our marine life . Not forgetting our amazing east lothian coast . An industrial monstrosity to a massive scale bang in between two communities with no radius (mileage) for any failures i.e gas explosions etc Where is the humane side to all this ??? Many huge scale industrail sites are not built right in between a community area especially with one mile between two towns. 21952014-10-13T19:57:14.9136043Ross Armstrong Please don't replace one monstrosity with another!!21952014-10-13T20:13:03.16044Nichola CochraneAgainst this proposal21952014-10-13T20:17:17.6476045Mr and Mrs BrownThe green space is an important legacy to leave for our children. Many, many memories have been created and it's a shame that greed looks to erode them.21952014-10-13T20:38:34.386046Harry RobertsonThe communities of Port Seton, Cockenzie, Prestonpans and Tranent will be destroyed if this development is allowed to proceed. This must not be allowed to happen.21952014-10-13T20:38:38.4136047Laura BrashSigned with passion.21952014-10-13T20:40:19.7876048Mr Charles O'NeillDont want this monster so near to house Torness better site for it21952014-10-13T20:52:25.356049Clare MorganAlthough this has been an industrial area for many years, many families paid the price for this with illness in their loved ones like the coalminers. The energy park would further increase the industrial landscape which would again reduce the health and wellbeing of the large residential area that is here now. We only ask that we maintain the quality of life we have. We keep our historical areas and environment and wildlife. The community would like to be supplied with 'the facts' that make this industrial site 'a dream' for us. How many jobs? How many jobs will go to the local community? How will this affect the coastline - tidal - wildlife? If this goes ahead i have no doubt the affect will be dramatic and will last forever.21952014-10-13T21:40:20.0376050Clare-Ann McShane The area should be celebrated not decimated!! The coast on East Lothian is incredible and beautiful.21952014-10-13T21:49:05.2576051Angela ThomsonI grew up in prestonpans and lived in cockenzie 4 a few years., I love that coastline the wild life the people walking there dogs sayn hello and always friendly. It beggars belief 2me that you would try and destroy not just 2 communities but all the surrounding communities . Eastlothian has already served our time , we don't want our beautiful bit of land destroyed.its wrong on every level .make it into somthin we can be proud of I'm sure this can be achieved 21952014-10-14T06:16:44.656052Linda ArchibaldPlease reconsider this plan as it will do nothing for the well being of the local communities. I am not against progress and would be happy for another power station but not anything on the proposed scale. IT HAS NO PLACE IN A RESIDENTIAL AREA21952014-10-14T09:46:19.3376053Laurie BrettPort Seton, as a commercial fishing port is a scenic tourist site. The smaller Cockenzie harbour is also attractive to visit. Tourism is an important part of our community, which should be developed not discouraged.21952014-10-14T10:01:01.1176055Mrs. Marion DicksonOur fish business is at the Old Harbour, Cockenzie. Where exactly do we stand?21952014-10-14T12:54:49.4536056Frances LamarraThis area is ideal for development of leisure activities and associated businesses. Please do not disrespect a beautiful area and the vibrant community.\r\n\r\n21952014-10-14T13:43:58.666058Allan CampbellWe love Cockenzie and it's harbour , visiting as tourists several times each year . The proposed development has no respect for local environment .21952014-10-14T15:17:28.0476059Craig SmithCan't believe the negative response when there are no concrete plans in place. This group are robbing our children of a better future with a jobs boom that we will never get any other way.21952014-10-14T15:59:15.126060Stuart Fleming-CainTo lose the blight that is the power station and have it replaced by an Energy Park would be criminal. Cockenzie and Port Seton are on the coastal trail and this should be invested in the local community, tourism and future generations. Do not lose this vital coastal view to commercialism. 21952014-10-14T16:45:17.7036061Claire NossiterListen to the people who live in area. Listen to your consituants. Or in return when you want the people to listen to you it might go on deaf ears...councillors!!!21952014-10-14T20:13:44.0276062Pamela cormackThe way that this has been handled by the local council and Scottish enterprise so far has been disgusting. We are educated people who have for years taken an interest in our local community. To be treated as though we don't matter is soul destroying. We will lose thousands of ponds on the values of our homes if this goes ahead. Why not allow another industry such as hospitality to generate jobs as well as tourism in this area? Please do not destroy our lovely coastline with this monstrosity. We should be allowed choices about what goes into our local communities. If this goes ahead I for one will lose all faith in this government and question deeply whether it is the right government for our families future. Please listen to us 21952014-10-14T21:04:55.826064Frances LamarraThere is also a thriving and growing artist community in the area. Please help to encourage the diversity and enthusiasm of the local people.21952014-10-14T23:21:59.5036065Pat BerryWhy is our beautiful coastline and views across the forth being spoiled for ever. It's a sin.21952014-10-14T23:30:33.0576066John CockerellThis monstrosity will destroy the Heritage and the character of one of the most visited coastlines in the uk ! 21952014-10-14T23:35:42.0636067Rosemary ParkynThe proposal for a major industrial development in the middle of 2 residential areas is totally inappropriate. Prestonpans has been developed as a residential expansion corridor for Edinburgh. As part of this my estate has 500 houses plus flats immediately adjoining the proposed site. Within its planning consents it had 5 play parks specifically because this was designed as for families and it has a high percentage of children. In addition I choose my property location specifically to avoid proximity to heavy traffic roads due to asthma and cardiovascular issues but due to the constraints of movement of turbines etc it is proposed to divert the main road adjacent to the estate. Scottish Enterprise proposals would have a major impact on the residential environment and the whole nature of the coastal towns of Prestonpans,Cockenzie and Port Seton and divide the communities. If the situation was reversed this would be considered as retrospective planning and consent would automatically be rejected.21952014-10-15T00:05:48.5176068Maureen MatthewsStop this madness now. We demand Public Consultation NOW.21952014-10-15T06:08:56.046069Shazney-tsomething that the whole community could use should be built on the land . 21952014-10-15T17:01:09.3276070Sandra EelesWe need something to enhance our area. I personally will expect compensation for my property if this goes ahead. \r\n21952014-10-15T22:27:06.4876073Yvonne Reekie do not want the proposed wind farm to go ahead 21952014-10-16T00:15:43.366074Rosemary CrockettI fail to see the benefits of this to the near or wider community. A marina and Holiday flats for rent or purchase would fit in with area plus a site for housing the Prestonpans Tapestry. Wind farms? What about solar panels on all new houses and council houses. New houses on the doorstep of an industrial eyesore? Finally there needs to be more openness about this. 21952014-10-16T13:21:10.996075Thea CampbellCockenzie as a village will suffer the loss of most of its green space if this proposal goes ahead. This will be to the detriment of those who live there and also those who visit.21952014-10-16T18:20:39.856077Shirley BaileySo, all of East Lothian's Golf Coast along that route should be disbanded along with all the work that was done on promoting the John Muir Way. Bye-bye tourists! I think the idea of a Tate Northern would be more in keeping with the tourist theme of the county.21952014-10-16T19:00:01.0376078John GrahamWe do not want a cut off between Cockenzie and Prestonpans WE must keep the road open21952014-10-16T20:17:48.7876079Lorna WhiteA shocking proposal to turn the Garden County into an industrial bombsite. Tearing communities apart21952014-10-16T22:37:36.1176080Garry SchulteOnce again it looks as though the Council are trying to sneak through another ill conceived short sighted plan, riding rough shod over the people who have been living and working in this area for generations. 21952014-10-16T22:39:01.5376081Maj-Britt K StevensonIt is incomprehensible that such an energy park should get the permission to be built immediately next to where people live.Most people in the villages had looked forward to the end of the power station not for it to be replaced by an industrial energy park.21952014-10-16T23:58:07.226082Shauna Hendythis would be detrimental to Tourism , Wildlife and the way of life for local folk. 21952014-10-17T07:30:27.6536083Brad cassidyO no 21952014-10-17T11:54:02.2976084Arran Paul JohnstonThe communities around Prestonpans, Cockenzie and Port Seton have worked hard over the past decade and more to create a strong and positive identity and an energetic vision for their future. All this work would be trampled into the ground by these grossly inconsiderate proposals which utterly ignore both the community's wishes and the importance of this part of East Lothian's coast. They threaten livelihoods, a nationally important battlefield, valued green spaces and community assets, and disregard the nature, aspirations, and inter-connectedness of these communities.21952014-10-17T13:00:30.8576085Dave BeardsThe historic battlefield site has great potential to be developed for tourism, and is one of few green spaces left in the area.21952014-10-17T13:07:22.0976086Caroline RossI have lived with the power station for 45 years and do not want anything else in its place 21952014-10-17T16:16:44.0936087Derek StewartThis site is part of British History - and is unique ... To build upon it would be cultural vandalism - a selfish act that benefits only a few.21952014-10-17T18:06:02.1876088Colin hattersleyHistoric sites like this should be protected for future generations rather than sacrificed for short term profit 21952014-10-17T23:55:59.2676089Catherine Baillie Signed21952014-10-18T10:46:21.3036090charlenedont no 21952014-10-18T16:46:57.5236091Jean GrundisonWhy Cockenzie & Port Seton? This is a wee quiet fishing village - let's leave it that way!!!21952014-10-18T17:01:26.6476092Alan Magnus-BennettIt is important to the local community hereabouts to preserve the greenfield site in question for the benefit of all. The fact that it is a historical battle site of importance to the specific history of Scotland is all the more important. There is a brown site nearby under orders for demolition. It makes more sense to use this area for any further development associated with the proposed energy park.21952014-10-19T11:18:37.5936093Bill FentonFor over 20 years I have proposed the demolition of Cockenzie Power Station and proposed a massive all the year round Tourist and Commercial Park Development which would include a cruise liner terminal, My predictions are to employ long term many thousands of local people and not only revitalise this magnificent coastline but launch Tourism in East Lothian to new heights and stimulate the whole Scottish Tourism Industry. A sure fire winner. Scottish Enterprise take note, we need you to invest our money in such a project!21952014-10-19T12:47:00.5036094Richard McLean I'm all for renewable energy and redevelopment but there must be sites more appropriate than the site in question. I feel it'll have a detrimental effect on the surrounding villages and towns. 21952014-10-19T14:11:17.6476095adam patersonJust goes to show again. That the government don't care about the people of Scotland. As long as they don't live there....who cares! Shove your energy park21952014-10-19T16:18:07.1176096Helen Anne FosterIt is inconceivable that Scottish Enterprise and East Lothian Council should bulldoze ahead with plans for a large scale industrial zone separating Cockenzie and Prestonpans and close to local residents' homes with no consultation or regard to the people who live there. There is a sense of 'hidden' future plans including channelling of energy from Dunbar wind farm if it goes ahead. Also plans uncovered to extract coal gas from under the Forth by unproven methods. One can only assume this was planned when seeking approval for the gas fired power station. It didn't make sense to us at the time that the gas was going to be piped in from Russia. - More lies and hidden agendas. How about being up front and getting the local community on board as opposed to up in arms?21952014-10-19T16:27:38.0376097Margaret JohnstonThese plans would separate the three close communities of Port Seton, Cockenzie and Preston Pans, and threaten a lot of jobs in the area. 21952014-10-19T16:38:10.2736098Evelyn SchulteFar too much of our green space has disappeared over the years we can not let this go on. This an area steeped in history with spectacular views that will be spoiled with this development. Please don't let this happen.21952014-10-19T16:54:48.6636099Shona Bain shouldn't tamper with natural tides, directing water makes you susceptible to flooding. \r\nEfforts should be being made to enhance the coastal road route at the old site and the history of the area. 21952014-10-20T15:58:08.176100Alan CarterThese proposals will destroy the local community, heritage and amenity of this area. There is very little information on what might be included in the energy park other than Wind Turbine Construction. Potentially dangerous coal gas extraction may follow to power the gas fired Power Station which has already been approved and will create a restricted industrial zone within a residential area. These plans are being pushed ahead against the interests and wishes of the local community. 21952014-10-20T19:07:42.2976101Peter FairbrotherLet's do more to promote beautiful East lothian as an tourist destination. Let's say YES to protecting the enviroment, promoting our rich cultural heritage, and NO to these energy park proposals. 21952014-10-20T21:12:25.656102Helen HindmoorPlease could someone advise how to sign the petition on this site?! Can't work it out, thanks21952014-10-21T09:31:15.7276103ModeratorHelen Hindmoor - sorry to hear that you are having difficulty signing the petition. After you have filled out the name, email and town/city boxes and selected your country from the drop-down menu, you have to complete what is called a "captcha challenge". This is an additional security and anti-spam measure - you should see a box with text or numbers in, type the text or numbers you see in the box with "Type the text" in and click "Sign This" underneath that. Your signature should then be recorded. If you are still having difficulty then please email the clerking team at petitions@scottish.parliament.uk and one of the team will manually add your signature for you.21952014-10-21T14:46:57.9276104Bill FentonFor over 20 years now I have proposed that Cockenzie Power Station should be replaced with a huge "all the year round" leisure and commercial park covering the whole of the now defunct Scottish Power Site. This would utilize not only the existing marina and harbour facilities, but critically provide a cruise ship terminal as well. Links into Edinburgh would be via rail on the line which already exists and touring visitors provided with free passes to use. All the high voltage interconnectors and pylons would be removed from the area and the natural beauty of this coastline restored. A Tourist Growth Scheme to make East Lothian and Scotland proud. Several thousand long term jobs would be provided and add support to the planned Blindwells New Town complete with its own train station. Strikes me that Scottish Enterprise should be proposing such a Tourism Growth Proposal as opposed to a industrial site with a very doubtful long term future aside from the obvious negative impact on the existing long suffering communities of Port Seton and Prestonpans. Offshore windfarm manufacturing growth should be directed to the existing underused site in Fife to ensure full viability there.\r\n \r\n\r\nBill Fenton21952014-10-21T20:43:55.6376105Liam MorrisonRe signing the petition. The wording states 'text', the information can also include 'numbers', input the numbers and it should work21952014-10-21T21:18:37.476106Michael LangtonListen to the locals re their environment! 21952014-10-21T21:48:35.0076107Helen HindmoorThank you. Worked it out now! You need to click on petitions in the top left of the screen to then get the form up.\r\nI like your idea Bill Fenton, a much more positive use of the space for the local community & Edinburgh. Hopefully something like this would provide growth, jobs and another reason for people to visit East Lothian. My only question would be, is the forth deep enough at this side for cruise liners? I heard somewhere that this might be an issue.\r\n21952014-10-21T22:06:57.356108Y AddisonI find it incredibly difficult to understand the logic behind the proposals to create an energy park right in the heart of small communities. I do understand the need to meet the demand for energy, however there must be alternative sites which could be considered for such a development which are a more reasonable distance from residential areas. Whilst those alternative sites may mean building on open spaces this surely has to be a more feasible option. I appreciate also that the creation of jobs is important but would say that the impact of this development on the quality of lives of those living in and around Cockenzie has to take precedent over the few hundred jobs which may or may not benefit local people. The tourism related ventures which are being suggested by many would surely bring more sustainable, long term job opportunities to the area. I would ask each individual involved in the planning process to step back momentarily from what they are being asked to consider and ask themselves how they would feel if this energy park was being built in their community. 21952014-10-23T10:24:04.4436109I WhalenTHIS MUST NOT HAPPEN!21952014-10-23T10:34:25.9136110Christine IrelandAgainst21952014-10-23T11:38:54.3276111Ian GrahamPlease keep the green hills for future enjoyment21952014-10-23T12:50:31.326112Angela SneddenThis should not happen! Yes, it is not the same without the power station there. But I would rather it be left that way, than see an energy park in its place! 21952014-10-23T13:49:33.1636113Alan CookeThe Power station is an important visual navigation aid to sailors in the Firth of Forth21952014-10-23T14:17:19.5076114Simon GallThe decommissioning of the existing Power Station is real opportunity to return the coastline to it's near original state and invest in sustainable, locally supported developments particularly tourism. Crazy, crazy proposal!21952014-10-23T14:27:57.16115Raymond turnerWind farms. Should be at least 1mile from Coast . Iconic land mark the power station.21952014-10-23T17:12:43.0936116Martin HayesThis should not happen21952014-10-23T18:25:32.326117Wilna KnoxWhy would anyone want to destroy our landscape? And why won't anyone listen when other, more suitable options are suggest for the community. 21952014-10-23T22:25:25.896118Cassie GibbThe Coast will look horific and will bring house prices down. With an already decreasing poverty i fear that this could decrease. Also for environmental veiw it does not look to be that friendly to wild life or surrounding areas.21952014-10-24T08:14:57.5436119Linda MarshallI would love the area to be kept as lovely as it is and I remember as a child coming on holiday down here from the big city and it was so lovely and clean and green so I hope this does not go ahead. 21952014-10-24T11:57:16.746120Ruth DonaldsonI think the secrecy of this whole project has annoyed most people especially those who bought houses on the understanding that there was to be a marina on the power station site21952014-10-24T12:35:52.2876121Grant WatsonNot against the re-development of the site but agree that it should be restricted to the existing site boundary. The relocation of the coast road however is totally unacceptable.21952014-10-24T12:54:42.4576122Charlie HunterAny plans should be accessible to the public and stay in line with the EU Green Policy promoting renewable energy to lower the carbon Footprint and preserve the land. 21952014-10-24T15:48:25.6776124Bill FentonFurther to my recent postings. It is well worth reading on line about the existing Energy Park at Methil which I can actually see from my house across the Forth.\r\nI would particularly recommend reading about the visit of the Scottish Enterprise Minister in 2011 when opening a new road to the site and lauding the massive future of the park for the future offshore windfarm manufacturing base. This development site is actually owned by Scottish Enterprise who have invested considerable sums of our money in jointly developing it with Fife Council over the past few years. The existing docks on the site allied to the industrial development already there appear perfect for the job at hand. Why on earth then are Scottish Enterprise proposing another Energy Park at Cockenzie when Methil is only about 25% utilized.21952014-10-24T17:25:00.236125David MorrisonI am disgusted that residents are not able to vote directly on this matter. It is their homes and their lives which are affected after all. 21952014-10-24T19:27:33.956126Claire PembertonThis area is the start to a beautiful coastline which needs to be enhanced not destroyed. What will visitors to Scotland arriving at Edinburgh think of this eyesore never mind the poor residents who will have to live with it. It's our children's future at stake , think carefully21952014-10-25T11:08:36.2636128Nichola ClydeEast Lothian is the 'garden of Scotland' - let's keep it that way!21952014-10-25T11:50:17.8136129Scott clunieAs a father of four young children this is NOT what i want for our future generations!21952014-10-25T19:25:24.9676130Duncan PatersonPlease do not destroy our coastline, this proposal is disgusting21952014-10-26T08:47:42.586131Kenneth DonaldNothing against renewable energy but not to the detriment of local communities in any way.21952014-10-26T10:07:38.2276132Suzanna Marchant24-hour operation is just wrong for the locals21952014-10-26T10:12:53.656133Gillian McLeanI am very much pro-renewables but this proposal is madness and in completely the wrong place.21952014-10-26T11:39:40.7136134Diane McLeodproposed plan should be within existing Cockenzie Power Station footprint.21952014-10-26T13:33:30.9836135Matthew NicholasWe need a much smaller proposal within the existing site footprint which doesn't destroy the 3 Harbours community and open land and threaten our coastline and beaches.21952014-10-26T13:36:54.7276136Fiona lindThe coastline should be preserved and the views of the local community taken into account.21952014-10-26T13:43:16.146137Keith Kirby Please do not build this facility in Cockenzie, thank you.21952014-10-26T13:46:41.0636138Ann PatersonThe Energy Park plans will have a devastating effect on the local area and will effect property prices, local trade and the environment. The relocation of the coast road is unacceptable and the land should remain accessible to the public.21952014-10-26T16:58:25.4736139Margaret LynchIt is very important for this area to give great consideration to your proposals. This is an opportunity to improve the coastal area for East Loathian and particularly for Port Seton and Cockenzie. Richard Demarco's suggestion seems very exciting. The Tate of the North!! Scrape the Energy Park and think BIG21952014-10-26T20:21:53.9836140Robert marrTo much heavy traffic , not happy about the closing of the coast road.21952014-10-26T20:38:40.336141Kevin EelesClosing the link road between the communities would be a disgrace. Stop this madness21952014-10-27T10:59:20.976142Sylvia BennettThere is so much of our countryside being destroyed by ugly housing and wind farms to build on this coastline would be a travisty21952014-10-27T12:00:56.4536143Marion RobertsonThe overall benefits to the communities haven't been taken in to consideration at all. Only the benefits to the developers. The waste to this coastline is an absolute disgrace. 21952014-10-27T14:04:00.686144Florence archibaldI agree that this energy Park proposed for Cockenzie and surrounding area should be abandoned.\r\nThe power station has blighted the area of Cockenzie for 50 years and we deserve to have our Garden County to mean that. This proposal is horrendous.21952014-10-27T15:09:01.6876145frank hamiltonthis development is massive and will affect a huge area and numbers of people. smaller developments would be far more in keeping and be in keeping with the area.21952014-10-27T19:22:39.536146kevin rodgersplease keep our green hills green and do mess up our lovely village21952014-10-27T22:22:45.076147linda SneddonEast Lothian is under threat from development. It won't be long until it becomes indistinguishable as a county, and merely a suburb of Edinburgh. It's time to stop and consider what we are losing - BEFORE its gone.\r\n21952014-10-28T11:13:06.3276149Steve and Cathy Rowe A marina and tourist craft scheme would be much better suited to this location. The protection of the wildlife, and the wider amenity, along with the benifits to the local communities would be much better suited to this coastline. Thank you.21952014-10-29T16:16:25.7236150Gavin LawsonThe John Muir Way is a national treasure located in East Lothian, it must be valued and protected.21952014-10-29T17:10:31.9276151george patersonAs an architect I have a reasonable appreciation of how planning applications are made and granted. I for one do not care about how much planning gain a developer wishes to contribute to the area! We are very happy with the satus quo. No change thanks.21952014-10-29T20:00:54.636152Michael Duffout businesses are under threat also if the link road between prestonpans and port seton is closed, no passing trade can affect us all 21952014-10-29T20:13:25.716153Dorathea HiscocksWhen I came to Cockenzie 20 years ago they named\r\nit "God's Little green acre". If the Energy Park is completed this most certainly will not be true.\r\n21952014-10-29T21:06:10.0536154Karen Taylordredging would have a negative effect on the fishing industry21952014-10-29T21:13:51.636155Mrs G M A YorkThe public must be fully consulted over this proposal21952014-10-30T10:27:12.856156Michael keenanThese password are very very difficult to read and discourage people from online signing21952014-10-30T10:31:34.7576157Michael KeenanIt has taken many years to make this area very popular both for residents and visitors, and this outrageous destructive scheme will nullify all that immediately. Can't see Seton Sands Park remaining so popular21952014-10-30T16:00:41.2276158Marlyn MintoGiven Longniddry residents are resisting the housing development on agricultural land beside Longniddry station why not switch that to the power station site at Cockenzie and add in leisure and sports facilities. This would surely appeal to both villages21952014-10-31T08:38:01.6336159kathleen baindestruction of historical site, NO\r\nlight, traffic noise pollution21952014-10-31T10:28:03.1336160Valerie ForbesThe development of this site along the lines proposed would be disastrous for this area that is so important historically and ecologically. It would nullify the hard work that has gone into attracting residents and visitors to the area.21952014-10-31T11:44:09.96161Christine NolanI cannot believe they could ruin our beautiful coast with the monstrosity planned. It would be a crime to spoil our lovely coast for people, animals and birds. I'll do all I can to help stop it.21952014-10-31T21:19:47.0876162Liz BeckleyCommon sense tells us that the views of the local communities MUST be taken into consideration and acted upon.21952014-11-01T10:34:34.9576163Fi StewartEveryone needs to sign this petition and support keepourcoast.com before our environment and lifestyles are irrevocably changed for the worst21952014-11-02T13:35:05.376164john wheelanThe residents of this area should have the final say in this very important project. these are our lives and livelyhoods at stake21952014-11-02T17:32:45.6336165Margaret NisbetThis proposal could have a detrimental effect on the wildlife (e.g. waders and geese) and also on the local communities and tourist industry.21952014-11-02T20:03:03.36166Robert ritchieNo to park21952014-11-03T12:36:06.4736167David Ha,LINTON Fleming Are you mad ? There are other préxisting established industrial sites elsewhere so why spoil the East Lothian County by building That here ! Let's vote the people out who support this in our beautiful county !21952014-11-03T13:05:33.6936168Moira Fleming Can you believe those East Lothian politicians giving this the go ahead Lets find out who voted for it and let's vote them out ! Save our beautiful county21952014-11-03T14:06:55.2876169Sara RiccioA strong NO! Destroying local wildlife and scenery.21952014-11-03T17:06:05.416170RUTH BOWESOf all the places in Scotland with an industrial heritage do you think Cockenzie would be top of the list ? Lets put those politicians who voted for it out of office 21952014-11-03T19:16:43.9576171William Wallace I can't understand why you want to put a marina in an area which will split community's and make cockenzie a ghost town. House prices will fall and people have tried to improve their life's and you will take this away from ordinary hard working people in the community's 21952014-11-03T19:32:12.5976172Dr Patricia MacdonaldPlease abandon this proposal and restore the coast at this point to greenspace by the sea for the benefit of local communities and visitors to East Lothian. More jobs will be lost than gained by such a development in East Lothian as it is today. There were good reasons for the location of the power station on this site, but there is now no reason for its replacement, or for its footprint to be expanded, by another polluting and amenity-destroying industrial facility.21952014-11-03T20:07:11.1476173corrine jacksonNo21952014-11-04T10:28:02.066174MRS CADEAN BADRICKFor me and my family we prefer something more like educational for kids in the future.21952014-11-04T18:48:12.746175Julia Dianne Hewittsigned21952014-11-04T19:43:10.416176Dr Allan W BrownThere is already an 'energy park' at Leven, Fife, so it is difficult to understand why there needs to be another one located in the Forth. If the basis is for promoting and developing sustainable energy then why this has to be linked to the destruction of an area of the coast, as well as important greenspace, is perverse. 21952014-11-04T20:51:02.496177Gavin HalcrowI am opposed to the proposed industrial development on a scale exceeding the existing power station in such close proximity to residential areas.21952014-11-04T21:26:32.8176178Renate Millarno\r\n21952014-11-04T21:50:03.9436179William NessIf the site is going to be used for anything, make sure that it does not damage the surrounding historic sites or local beautiful coastline. Create something that is of benefit to the local & wider community - perhaps something that is educational or multi-use.21952014-11-04T22:31:01.6476180Audrey AllanCannot believe that we get rid of the coal fired power station and now these plans are being considered. Unbelievable but not surprising.21952014-11-04T22:55:26.1876181Sophie Tullochthe consultation period appeared to be non existent and plans so far advanced by the time they came to the community's attention that it smacked of duplicitiousness on those backing the project.21952014-11-04T23:29:03.7236182Morag KingThe most ill conceived idea I've ever heard. This will have an enormous impact on local ecology and should be rejected out of hand21952014-11-05T06:46:11.1476183Lucy JohnstoneThis is an unconscionable act by the council which will introduce fracking to an area without summary consultation. It is not acceptable. Nor is the selli g of licenses without consultation. The area is inappropriate for this kind of development. 21952014-11-05T09:32:47.3736184Raymond mcarthurNo21952014-11-05T09:34:15.4976185Alan Graham MacdonaldThis proposal destroys wildlife habitat in an area that requires urgent attention to wildlife survival21952014-11-05T10:35:12.4576186LindseyThrough this proposal the change in infrastructure means that a main road will be removed between cockenzie and port seton and Prestonpans. This therefore means we are left with one road access in and out of the village. This therefore will cause congestion especially in peak summer periods when the camps are busy with tourists.21952014-11-05T11:31:41.4836187sasha springDont extend beyond existing foot print...snd have a full public consultation. \r\n21952014-11-05T11:36:47.1876189Terence HegartyCompletely inappropriate scale of development for that site.21952014-11-05T11:44:58.6236190Eilidh NicolsonAll plans must be subject to full public consultation, there is a void of information on this proposed development.\r\n21952014-11-05T13:16:08.426191Julia HewittGood cause21952014-11-05T18:16:48.8076192david kilkerronce again it seems a community is being hoodwinked by its local authority21952014-11-05T21:40:15.2836193Stuart FowlerThis proposed development is inappropriate for the area and lack of public consultation is insulting. If this proposal goes ahead those responsible should hang their heads in shame at wasting an opportunity to improve rather than destroy the area.21952014-11-05T22:05:16.546194Andy MacraeA massive and inappropriate development which would blight the area\r\n21952014-11-06T12:05:20.776195Christine McIntoshI've just waved a minibus off in the rain - 9 Russian musicians heading north via the A83. It was hard to explain why and how their journey might take longer than their sat-nav suggested - it's a ridiculous situation to be in.22092014-11-06T20:15:56.516196Fiona FraserAll Roads in need upgraded22092014-11-07T10:06:11.186198CAPTAIN JOHN S. COLMANTHE TRANSPORT MINISTER TRIES TO TALK A GOOD GAME. HE URGENTLY NEEDS TO INSIST ON A FINAL SOLUTION MINUS REPEATED BOTCHED PATCH-UP ATTEMPTS.22092014-11-07T10:22:53.0736199Steven GirvanIf this was the main access route to the Scottish Parliament it would have been resolved by now. Spend some money in rural areas rather than always on your back door ministers!!! I had to endure over a 3 hour detour home last night due to the A83 & A82 being closed. How is the new bridge coming along by the way??22092014-11-07T18:50:10.086200Robert Keith ThomsonBuilding "shed" protection (as used in Austria, Switzerland etc.) in the areas threatened by landslips should be tried.It may be less expensive than many of the other schemes which have been tried or suggested. 22092014-11-07T19:11:09.8436201Neil AndersonI am disabled, having non- Hodgkins Lymphoma and Peripheral Neuropathy, and have to make numerous trips each year to hospitals in Glasgow and the Vale of Leven from my home in Tarbert, Kintyre. My condition means I am very sensitive to vibration. Every closure means at least an additional 50 miles each way. The level of pain I have to deal with is extreme at the best of times. A permanent solution is greatly needed.22092014-11-07T22:54:08.766202Michael WattsWhat happened to the feasibility study that was to be done? The Scottish Government is allowing a road to be used that is unsafe. It is amazing that no one has been killed. Is that what it will take? A bus full of tourists killed by thousands of tons of falling rock. Will it be like the notorious A74 that there had to be a certain number of fatalities before something is done? 22092014-11-08T15:39:31.6436203Paul AshtonIt has to be clear to anyone who has viewed the scale of the fence barriers against the size of the hill, that they were never going to work. We are overdue for a proper solution to this, possibly a tunnel. 22092014-11-09T16:36:24.1776204alex armstrongbuild a tunnel or impact roof allowing debris to fall down the mountain. the problem will to continue to get worse and will cost another x millions of pounds22092014-11-10T14:35:33.026205David McCallumIt has to be a tunnel. If you travel anywhere in Europe this is the norm. You will then in the winter have no need to grit or snow plough the road saving thousands of pounds on the roads budget 22092014-11-10T14:46:49.566206Anne McCallumA total waste of 8 million. Our Spanish friends just laughed at the futile attempts we are making to try and stop the landslides and said they should come to Spain to see how to resolve the problem.22092014-11-12T18:55:26.526207Jody PetrieI hope this works21552014-11-12T20:31:22.966209julie connelly Animals lives are just as valuable as human21552014-11-12T21:03:09.856210Catherine GeogheganAnimals are God's creatures as we humans are and should have respect and no-one has the right to harm them and should punished accordingly.21552014-11-13T14:02:52.9576211Annette HaighIt's time Animal cruelty was recognised for what it is - obscene and a sign of fractured morality. Like children animals have no voice so we must speak for them and protect their right to dignity and life! 21552014-11-14T15:58:29.0936224Irene morleyStop animals being abused now 21552014-11-14T18:28:53.9376225Mandy thomsonThe animal cruelty laws in this country are well overdue an overhaul .....a human who is capable of cruelty to a helpless animal has no place in society and should feel the full force of he law come down on them ! if such acts are ignored then society as a whole is a worse place for everyone ...ZERO tolerance . I also totally agree that animal abusers are without a doubt emotionally and morally disturbed individuals who are also more than capable of perpetrating crimes against other weaker humans both adult and child. Crimes such as this need to be thoroughly investigated and maximum sentences applied including psychiatric interventions. There is NO place in a CIVILIZED society for any crimes of cruelty toward animals ! \r\n21552014-11-17T13:14:27.2976242Aileen LowdonI believe in change, if it makes a difference. I will be sharing this with my family and friends! I cannot abide animal welfare being low down on peoples' priority lists! There has to be a stronger deterrent in the law & tougher sentencing for people who abuse animals! Already, another Chipperfield is under the spotlight, up in Aberdeenshire, for allegedly abusing wild animals. Tougher fines & prison sentences are needed. Best wishes Olivia x21552014-11-21T17:36:25.7536293Helen EllerbyWe need to punish animal abuser's to the full extent possible. We need severe punishment.21552014-11-25T10:29:41.4836308Jayme ThomsonThe Scottish Parliament please step up and do the right and humane thing here. Only good will come of it. Show the World the Scottish people have zero tolerance on animal abuse. It's been proven that those who commit animal abuse are most likely to commit crimes on vulnerable people such as children, disabled and elderly. These cowards deserve the highest punishment possible. Set the precedent for now and the generations to come by making a safer and respected Scotland for everyone.21552014-11-25T16:25:47.0736311Kimberley Drumgold Animals are innocent. We need to help them and be their voice. Its time to make a change! \r\n21552014-11-25T16:30:10.0576312Moira ThorburnAnimal cruelty has to stamped out. Tougher sentences required.21552014-11-25T16:42:26.6376313nadia khanTougher laws and sentences are needed and should be carried out in the courts21552014-11-25T17:02:59.9636314Debbie BerryThis petition is so important. Vicious people treating animals badly is a disgrace and a strong punishment is necessary to deter these people from doing it in the first place21552014-11-25T19:54:43.0436318deborah kilmartinAnmail have bloodin there viens and feel pain. If there can dose that anmail what next a child21552014-11-25T21:17:50.5436319Pat MallonAnimal cruelty needs to be stopped NOW.Catch and jail these low life's who think it is alright to hurt poor,defenceless animals and through away the key.It makes my blood boil because all our animals look for in life is to be loved and taken care of not to suffer at the hands of these morons.Please save our lovely animals NOW21552014-11-25T21:56:53.0976320anne colemannot before time! 21552014-11-25T22:52:32.5536324Kate haggerty Animals don't have a voice! We are their voice! Unfortunately as we cannot do same to the human that has harmed the animal then they need to be put away for a longer time than is currently handed out!21552014-11-26T12:29:54.896328Carolyn HastieAnimals are Gods creatures just like ourselves,they do not have a voice when someone abuses them we therefore need sufficient laws to stop these barbaric acts from happening,pretty much the worst punishment at the moment is the lowlife who do commit these acts are banned from keeping animals,or they get community service which is doubtful if they will even attend.we really need to get the message across that any animal cruelty will nt be tolerated in any community.21552014-11-28T09:47:01.0336332angela brownWhat ever they do to animals should be done to them21552014-11-28T18:15:26.516333Emma CoenenWhy should animal abuse not be treated the same as any other abuse?!21552014-11-28T21:06:26.56334Sarah Robb Animal need us to speak up for them. Tendered their rights. And to seek justice on their behalf. 21552014-11-30T23:51:14.0576335Wendy Addison1. Educate children. 2. Depending on severity of offence 5 years in jail. 3. Not emotional disturbance, a deeper malaise than that. Psychotic maybe.21552014-12-05T20:06:48.7976337peter patrick glancy campbell i am a war pensioner with council arrears of 1000£ my wife in care home, now trying buy second hand mobility car for her. the DWP say we do not qualify for mobility benefit 21912014-12-08T13:47:52.826338Siobhan McDonaldThis is a must, disgraceful what some people get away with21552014-12-08T16:43:59.626339Ross LinardiJust because animals can't talk doesn't give anyone the right to treat with any kind of cruelty.21552014-12-09T22:41:29.7676341Robert FraserI Concur!21552014-12-15T14:59:18.2036343Bernd VollnhoferTo my opinion this is an absolute must to do, as the population of Salmon in the last years shows a drastic decline. Considering all the factors contrbuting to this desaster, such as the polution of the oceans a.s.o. mankind must do everything which is in our hands to do, to preserve this wonderful part of nature. 22312014-12-15T15:41:47.346344Paul McMonagleSigned Ian, thanks22312014-12-15T15:54:42.916345Alex BarclayIt is about time this Listening Government actually listened to the people who know what is happening to our stocks and really care about our fish, keep up the good work and thank you Ian.22312014-12-15T16:01:43.6676346Andy RichardsonWell done Ian. Keep up the good fight!22312014-12-15T16:11:11.016347Stevie Munn Very important we don't lose this fish in the wild . 22312014-12-15T16:19:22.7036348Andrew HoggFor the sake of our last remaining salmon stocks please act now when you still can. It's not too late yet but given time and the continuation of current practices it will soon be too late. 22312014-12-15T16:21:32.7976349tom wallaceSalmon stocks must be conserved and I agree the govt must go a step further to protect a fragile species22312014-12-15T16:28:04.9636350Donnie Whiteford1st of April is "a start" but 1st July would be a big step forward. 22312014-12-15T16:30:47.9336351John Richardsonkeep up the good work about time something trying to get done.22312014-12-15T16:33:03.4276352Graeme Taylor, Aberdeen, SCotlandKeep up the fight Ian!\r\n22312014-12-15T16:41:33.1036353Craig wynessAs long as the nets are included I'm in22312014-12-15T16:41:35.66354Jock MonteithIt is a national disgrace that wild Atlantic salmon stock levels have been allowed to reduce to this level through gross mismanagement and commercial exploitation. We need to also fully back Orri Vigfusson at the NASF as his organisation is the only main reason in my opinion that there are any wild Atlantic salmon worth pursuing in the northern hemisphere at all these days. There are also very dangerous commercial netting threats currently reoccurring at the Greenland feeding grounds which requires URGENT addressing or it will be game over. For an industry that attracts £150 million per annum to Scotland from salmon angling alone it is truly remarkable that there has been such a lack of effective long term conservation management of the species. Tough conservation policies and effective ocean policing with the buying off of all commercial netting ventures from the feeding grounds to the river estuaries is what is required NOW and making it law that no salmon can be killed. This could easily (after 3 x 5 year cycles have passed) turn the industry into a 1 £billion annual revenue stream to Scotland with all the positive economic effects that goes with that kind of upswing and subsequent global angler recognition & demand.22312014-12-15T16:43:26.2576355Jonathan Mackereth we really do need to do everything we can to protect these salmon. They have given so many people so much over the years, it's time we gave something back. 22312014-12-15T16:43:48.9176356Artur Furdyna, TPRIIGWithout good conservation of wild population the end will be like with polish salmon, we,ve lost in 80-ties. 22312014-12-15T16:44:07.3076357Paul Stevenson Gd coz keep up the gd work 22312014-12-15T16:48:23.5736358paul smith We're all behind you keep up the fight.22312014-12-15T16:51:42.066359graham hamilton Signed and shared 22312014-12-15T16:52:00.876360Craig FlemingWe need to do all we can to save the runs of native wild Atlantic salmon.22312014-12-15T16:56:55.766361William Stuart This needs to be done now not in a years time it needs to be done now .22312014-12-15T16:59:10.1776362brian arnoldthe main spring run arrives in may on the deveron, the present measure doesn't go far enough.\r\n22312014-12-15T16:59:59.2576363Ken ReidDelighted to support your efforts petitioning Scottish Government to do more to protect our migratory salmonids. Internationally the Scottish Governments stance in supporting interceptors netting has seen us become the catalyst to encourage Greenland to increase their quotas in exploiting salmon. There is more than enough salmon produced through aquaculture to satisfy demands for salmon. Coastal netting must be and should be abolished as there are no controls on their exploitation.22312014-12-15T17:16:09.8876365Giles ChapmanIt is a sad state of affairs when Russia is doing more for Salmon conservation than Scotland.22312014-12-15T17:26:08.9176366Nick HillWell done,shame governments don't do joined up thinking !22312014-12-15T17:26:43.016367Sean Mcgarryvital and inspirational stance Ian. Let's hope we can be heard as one voice and take the steps required to protect this beautiful and beloved creature. 22312014-12-15T17:31:35.766368M.R.Oldfieldas over 90% of our salmon die at sea, shouldn't most of our efforts be concentrated there? However this is a good start.22312014-12-15T17:32:35.6036369constantine cartongood work ian22312014-12-15T17:41:49.546370Melville McDonaldWhilst recent efforts by Scottish Government to provide more protection for early running spring salmon are to be applauded, the proposals do not go nearly far enough to protect what is quickly becoming an endangered species. This species of salmon provides a huge amount of income to the Scottish Economy and it needs further protection to ensure its sustainability for future generations.22312014-12-15T18:05:54.736372brian finlaykeep up the good work22312014-12-15T18:07:48.4336373Munro reidSomething seriously has to be done. The Scottish government should rise to the challenge. 22312014-12-15T18:08:43.6976374Stephen Brennan Drastic measures maybe but shows anglers commitment to preservation of the species 22312014-12-15T18:10:15.796375Harris Reid Save these fish for the sake of future generations. 22312014-12-15T18:11:37.6876376Ian NealeGreat job Ian. It's a start in the right direction for the survival of our salmon.22312014-12-15T18:12:25.4476377Gordon MackenzieAll early running salmon need protection.22312014-12-15T18:13:19.726378Steven blacki would totally agree with donnie whiteford22312014-12-15T18:16:52.156379jondi laurence O Byrne Save our salmon 22312014-12-15T18:23:40.546380Kenny CarrGood luck with this, and hopefully will help what remains of the salmon stock.\r\nHope this applies to the nets too, or this is a worthless exercise. 22312014-12-15T18:40:05.2776381robert moffettA total catch and release is the way to go22312014-12-15T18:46:36.3276383Fabrice BerguesVery well done!!!22312014-12-15T18:46:52.4476384Pierre noelFor the fly fisherman, you also must stop killing salmon. I signed this last year only to see some of you posting your trophies on Facebook.22312014-12-15T18:52:27.5276385alan mooneyGood work Ian, maybe the fight against lousy salmon farms worth a go as this is a major factor. Wont hold much hope on that though22312014-12-15T18:56:41.5276386Jonathan JonesThis doesnt just affect scotlant as many of the fish netted will be heading to rivers further south. The scots goverment already supports the salmon farming industry, look what chaos that has brought to the west coast with the extinction of many salmon and seatrout runs. Does the same body want to be responsible for doing the same to the rest of scotland and many more rivers further south.22312014-12-15T18:58:18.7276387Tony Black1st of July will be better to help save a few early summer fish as well...22312014-12-15T19:00:58.256388Bill GreenWell done Ian22312014-12-15T19:02:17.6836389Gordon Pollockthe salmon need all our help right now it should really be C&R 100% all year round 22312014-12-15T19:03:10.2536390Michelle tucker-Vincent You've got this far Ian keep going. We need to protect these wonderful fish. 22312014-12-15T19:08:25.986391Robert D McKenzieWe simply cannot allow the decline of Atlantic\r\nSalmon to be the result of preventable human\r\nover-harvest.\r\nAnd we must use every conceivable resource to\r\nprotect their future existence22312014-12-15T19:11:38.76392Sebastian KrachtKeep still fighting Ian!!!22312014-12-15T19:15:27.6576393Steven MackenzieMost springers come after 1st April now so 15th June would be a target to aim for. Well done Ian. Steven 22312014-12-15T19:17:08.6876394adrian brown signed22312014-12-15T19:21:42.946395Andrew McRobbieits about time something was done to get the salmon numbers back up. Well done Ian keep up the good work. 22312014-12-15T19:21:43.046396David BishopKeep up the great work Ian! We are with you here across the pond! \r\n22312014-12-15T19:38:39.8876398Paul RichardsonGreat work all, share this as much as possible & urge all your friends to sign it so that future generations can enjoy this majestic species.22312014-12-15T19:40:37.796400James MckendryKeep up the good work22312014-12-15T19:42:47.236401David WilkinsonOne step at a time seems to be the best way forward22312014-12-15T20:00:55.1536402Rab LeesThis would be absolute common sense22312014-12-15T20:01:22.5476403jim.mcalorumkeep up the fight22312014-12-15T20:08:07.846404Geoff LittlerWe must fight at every opportunity to protect our dwindling stocks of precious wild fish. Power to you Mr. Gordon 22312014-12-15T20:08:30.3676405Jennifer Lindsay DavidsonGreat seeing conservation actually seemingly triumphing over wealth in this case - if only more of our extinct species had such good care takers as the fisheries across Scotland!22312014-12-15T20:12:42.96408Alan ScottPlease keep the pressure up as our Migratory Fish are under pressure from many sources22312014-12-15T20:15:25.1676409Chris Gallagher Little to late Scotland your greed comes before the conservation of Atlantic salmon and sea trout. Financial greed. No place for Commercial netting of our fish. Act now before it's too late, it's already showing for Scottish rivers. 22312014-12-15T20:20:47.8776410Janet SmithPlease support this petition and protect our salmon.22312014-12-15T20:21:54.9336411Alan walkerShould be 100%return22312014-12-15T20:23:35.9236412Janet SmithPlease support this petition and protect our salmon.22312014-12-15T20:35:40.096413Andrew SmithThere should be no killing of wild salmon till we have a proven surplus. And no mixed stock interceptors nets. Please cob sided buying the negs out22312014-12-15T20:52:18.4176414John GardinerNow is the time to try and get this done once and for all with you all the way Ian22312014-12-15T21:19:46.1436415THOMAS BARTONGlad to support your amazing effort. Keep it up!22312014-12-15T21:21:57.9176416Andrew PottsWell done again for another year Ian. You have my full support to all you're trying to do in this very worthy cause. 22312014-12-15T21:46:07.126417william.mcilroystop netting our salmon before its to late.22312014-12-15T21:52:56.2336418Johnny McMillanThis has got to happen. Keep up the good work.22312014-12-15T21:55:03.8136419Robert Wilson We must all understand the value before it's to late.22312014-12-15T21:56:17.2436420Callum ConnerKeep up the good work!\r\n\r\nSigned...22312014-12-15T22:07:30.46422Bert SchoutenThis year I fished the river Nith with 2 customers. It was beautifull and caught my first atlantic salmon. Only 33cm but it was pictured and happy relaesed. I hope i will be give. The change to meet this fish again at a bigger size. Tourist value of a salmon is worth a 100 times more than the consumer value... Be smart. Protect our heritage.22312014-12-15T22:17:32.0636423Philip blackKeep up the good work ian22312014-12-15T22:28:16.7136424con sheehangood man Ian22312014-12-15T22:37:24.5736425Jose GuliasGood luck Ian and keep up \r\ntill the end!!22312014-12-15T23:09:08.146426Matthew birdthis is a nationwide issue all over the UK . This season has been appauling and if action is not implemented soon it will seriously damage our migratory stock in the UK. If we have shorter seasons and use mandatory catch and release So be it , if there arnt a sustainable stock cutting reds our rivers will be empty . \r\n Well done Ian for standing up and making the first move in protecting our dwindling UK stocks \r\n Matt bird22312014-12-15T23:15:18.5736427Robbie LauderThis has to be done asap, let's get it sorted! 22312014-12-15T23:43:52.376428clint doig It needs to stop NOW 22312014-12-15T23:49:06.6676429Pearse McKernanKeep up the good conservation work, any progress at all is good, C and R is the future, i hope that this can be implimented into NI and ROI at some point when our government wakes up to this resource.goodluck22312014-12-16T00:16:52.036430Frank Myhre HansenI have visited scotland for many a springweek of salmonfishing. And would like to be able to in the future. The rural communities are dependent on this income, and it is of great cultural and historical value.22312014-12-16T00:22:19.5776431Ingólfur David Best of luck 22312014-12-16T01:15:18.876432Martin WoodlandPlease stop this MADNESS.22312014-12-16T02:25:32.6336435Karl Ómar JónssonThis killing is plain crasy. Stop it now please22312014-12-16T02:28:24.96436David MclaughlinThis needs to happen keep pushing forward 22312014-12-16T06:54:26.2236437Philip WalkerThe damage is being done at sea !!!!22312014-12-16T07:21:30.716438Ian M Sinclairenough of the sitting back and hoping it will be ok next year. The people who are in a position to make changes happen must stand up and get things done. 22312014-12-16T07:28:54.96439Nick HartYou have done a great job of keeping us all informed, thank you Ian. I hope you hard work pays dividends and the powers that be listen.22312014-12-16T08:51:13.776440Eddie SinclairIan I totally agree with this stand, hopefully many other people will as well.22312014-12-16T08:58:54.786441Ronan CreaneWe must protect our wild salmon, not for anglers or fishermen but because they deserve to swim.22312014-12-16T09:06:36.4236443Richard JohnsonThis destruction of wild fish has to be stopped!22312014-12-16T09:22:08.4176444Mark HamnettLook after the fish and they will look after us!22312014-12-16T09:23:43.1036445Ian HawkinsA moratorium on killing will help, but enclosed Salmon farming will do a lot more. It is time Salmon Farming was brought on-shore22312014-12-16T09:27:19.76446Timothy HillKeep it up Ian great work22312014-12-16T09:47:14.3976447Malcolm AndersonIan is doing a fantastic job and the more support we can drum up the better. If we can do our bit may be the powers at be can see how important the Salmon is to the Scottish economy and how concerned and passionate we are about saving them. Not forgetting its our passion for our sport, hobby and pastime. W 22312014-12-16T10:15:13.6036448simon neighboursomething must be done now let's hope it's not to late22312014-12-16T10:16:49.8876449Jim KitisWild fish populations are a blessing especially Salmon. We have no native Trout or Salmon in our waterways and FIsheries Western Australia have a hatchery and replace them in our rivers every year.\r\nFrom what I can deduce from the literature presented to me surely it would be better to work in harmony with the environment to ensure a balance that ensures a thriving fish population which would benefit everyone in the long term.22312014-12-16T10:19:14.2576450Ian DuncalfHoping that people will take notice and do something about it before it's too late 22312014-12-16T10:19:34.5276451Jordan Douglas Stop killing salmon 22312014-12-16T10:29:48.626452Selwyn CurtisIncreased netting quotas have had a major role in reducing catches of wild salmon to half their previous levels in one season! We CAN NOT let this become normal through poor government management. International cooperation is needed here urgently!22312014-12-16T10:38:04.9536453BRIAN DOIG people will take notice and do something about it before it's too late22312014-12-16T10:41:19.256454Marc HouriganPlease do something about this because if you don't it will be too late!22312014-12-16T12:06:49.2776455Marina GibsonStart taking action before we cannot turn back. 2 months will not make a difference to our supermarket shelves but it will to our rivers and fishing community. 22312014-12-16T13:08:31.0736457Craig NelsonPleas act NOW to save tomorrow .... Soon it will be to late22312014-12-16T13:22:47.4576458Hilmar HanssonGood job Ian...22312014-12-16T14:09:08.126459Colin WattersonConservation of wild salmon is far more important than the stupid schemes that threaten them.22312014-12-16T14:25:20.6836460Alan BrownleeLets make sure we protect and preserve this truly beautiful species. Its in our hands, For years illegal netting and other Butcher anglers have pillaged the grounds of a wonderful creature who returns only to keep there own future secure, Enjoy your fishing with Barbless hooks, But always return the fish, They deserve to survive.\r\n22312014-12-16T14:33:45.2436461Roger WalkerThe rod and line fishermen and women are not the cause here. They already return about eighty per cent of their catch. The Scottish Government must address the netting of salmon on the high seas and estuaries and take some positive action regarding fish farms and the explosion of sea lice numbers. My friends and I are considering looking elsewhere for our salmon fishing because we are so disappointed with the returns we have experienced over the last few years in Scottish rivers.22312014-12-16T14:42:48.46462Neil MoroneyGood luck Ian, something has to be done if future generations are to see wild Atlantic Salmon in our fabulous river systems.22312014-12-16T14:50:25.476463David Williamsplease protect the salmon stocks for the future generations.22312014-12-16T15:10:57.926465Chris ColhounGreat job Ian, glad to see someone trying to do something to save our beautiful Atlantic Salmon from the greed of man wipe them out completely.22312014-12-16T15:44:31.546466john millerDoes this include nets?22312014-12-16T15:47:29.1976467Gardar KristjanssonGood Job and Good Luck..\r\n22312014-12-16T15:58:30.1676468David FisherPlease do not wait until it is too late to save our precious wild river salmon stocks!!22312014-12-16T16:05:11.796469Derek WofindenThis fills me with complete disgust.22312014-12-16T16:40:48.386470Liam MooreGood luck with this! It is needed drastically!22312014-12-16T16:57:26.3236471Nigel MilsomWe must protect this precious resource22312014-12-16T17:20:38.796472Hugh Hunter GordonThe key to Encouraging a revival of wild salmon in Scottish waters is the elimination of all sources of predation until such time as the stocks have recovered. It is difficult to control wild predation from seal populations for instance. It is difficult to control human predation from other nations, Iceland fisheries for instance, but we can at least control our own. So ban killing of all wild salmon in UK waters, whether sport fishermen or nettings.22312014-12-16T17:32:46.0736473Anthony SmithWe are in grave danger of losing this iconic species and every thing possible must be done to save our salmon22312014-12-16T17:48:17.6136474Andy RamageThis needs every bit of support we can give.22312014-12-16T17:48:40.5976475Ed WilliamsAct now to do the right thing, or be it upon your heads for ever. 22312014-12-16T17:56:31.1476476les jury.Something really needs to be done to protect these fragile stocks.22312014-12-16T18:10:49.4476477Adam BrittonStop exploiting Wild Salmon. Let them return from the oceans so they can breed more again.22312014-12-16T18:14:41.766478Tony Andrews a Director ASTWell done Ian and S&TA. This is a step in the right direction. No one needs to kill a salmon or sea trout before the 1st of July. None of us will starve. If we have to eat wild salmon or sea trout we can leave it until after the 1st of July before doing so. Even the we should ask ourselves "is it really necessary to kill this fish?" The AST message to all anglers is "try to leave more fish in your river than there were before your visit. Think spawners!" TA22312014-12-16T18:23:30.656479David Shiels Stop all netting of Wild Atlantic Salmon.\r\nAddress the present Sea Lice debacle before it's too late. 22312014-12-16T18:26:43.0736480Sam Bremner Dose the Scottish government know there is more of Scottland outside Glasgow and Edinburgh 22312014-12-16T18:54:15.4736481brett richingssave wild salmon stocks22312014-12-16T18:59:48.336482Jeremy NobleSalmon need protection at sea too!22312014-12-16T19:13:29.696483David MoynaghIf we fail to take action there is no doubt whatsoever that salmon stock depletion will reach a stage where recovery of numbers will be an impossible task. We must act now.22312014-12-16T19:34:02.626485steve smithno means no for everyone. Also close ALL fishfarms for a 2 year period and allow all stocks to recover.22312014-12-16T19:35:21.0736486Andrew kerachermy family has been five generations fish merchants we used to get Tay caught wild salmon and sea trout in healthy numbers, then the Europeans found the feeding grounds and catch them wholesale before they can get back to spawn in the rivers, anything the Scottish government can do to stop this has mine and my whole families backing.22312014-12-16T19:37:29.0276487Kenneth BickI could not agree more with the aims of this petition. If the SNP are so hard done by with the allocation of funds by Westminster, how can they afford this?21912014-12-16T20:11:09.9476490Fred ParkerDo your best and I have posted what I feel and think on my Facebook page for all my friends to see.22312014-12-16T20:14:07.7436491Jeremy HopkinsNever seen so few salmon as this year.This is a good starting plan.22312014-12-16T20:18:21.5176492Paul WaterhouseWhy continue to persecute the rod angler's. \r\nIt's hard enough and expensive for newcomers to attempt to catch that elusive Atlantic Salmon. 22312014-12-16T20:39:35.736494Kenneth HanksAn essential requirement to preserve and improve salmon survival in Scotland.22312014-12-16T20:47:56.1036496Packie Mc DermottThis is a serious situation,Governments should be taking steps to protect what little stocks of wild Salmon that are left before it is too late.22312014-12-16T20:48:30.0936497José Borzicare for our world !!!!!22312014-12-16T20:56:22.0476498terry jacksonSalmon are struggling, numbers are down and they face an uphill battle, as a species, to make it through the next twenty years, give them a fighting chance and remove wild salmon from the commercial sector22312014-12-16T21:59:57.4636499Ian marshallWe need to take action now support Ian Gordon 22312014-12-16T22:16:39.6376500Michael CunninghamWell done Ian on promoting this Petition. 22312014-12-16T22:38:14.266502johnny sullivansave the salmon no more ocean neting 22312014-12-16T23:03:34.5576503Illtyd GriffithsThe numbers of returning salmon seem to be reducing every year. If an attempt is not made to halt this decline immediately the wild salmon will become extinct in the not too distant future.\r\n22312014-12-16T23:08:07.0276504Alister JackOur salmon stocks are in crisis partly due to human exploitation. They don't spawn in a deep freeze.22312014-12-16T23:14:04.656506Angela BarronPut long term sustainability ahead of short term profit, please!!22312014-12-17T00:40:33.846507Rich KnolesI'm a visiting angler, please leave me something to visit.22312014-12-17T00:47:10.126508Susan HodgesThis is an evil industry that is accelerating the tipping scale of the imbalance of the marine ecology. It must be stopped. Money cannot bring back orcas, wild salmon and balance once it is lost. They executives may have 5 or 6 cars and luxe vacations and multiple residences. So what. No wild salmon, no nothing. emperors of nothing is what they are creating. Stop this. 22312014-12-17T00:47:11.9536509Patrick Petiniot Keep up the good work. 22312014-12-17T06:27:45.8076510Robert Anthony SlezasHaving been involved in the setting up of the Lochaber area of Scotland's Fisheries Trust I find it ludicrous that all the hard work put in to it's creation should still be jeopardised by a small minority of greedy individuals who realistically show little or no profit from their activities, were anglers to claim their historic right to keep their catch they would be branded criminal. 22312014-12-17T06:28:24.8236511callum WhitmoreWe should stop fishing for a season every 5 seasons to let stocks improve22312014-12-17T07:08:27.796512Barry ChoppingThe time for action is long overdue\r\n22312014-12-17T08:01:38.016513John McEwanI have watched the decline in the Tay since I was a young boy - it's heartbreaking - hope this helps.22312014-12-17T08:07:14.1736514Chris Loftus This constant decline of stocks has to be halted and the trend reversed before it is too late.22312014-12-17T08:12:35.8076515Phillip JordanThe Scottish government must take steps to protect the resource of wild salmon now as it will be a tragedy if stocks become so depleted they become unsutainable. The wild salmon is an icon of Scotland and must be protected. 22312014-12-17T09:00:44.3976516Lloyd Garviei can't believe the Scottish Government issues netting licences for salmon and sea trout. Absolutely bonkers.22312014-12-17T09:13:09.9936517Colin SharpSoon all salmon stocks will have gone forever22312014-12-17T10:06:27.7576519robin vaseyNot only do I support the cessation of indiscriminate killing of spring salmon I believe that the review's recommendation of April 1st should be extended to 1st June as spring salmon are still entering their natal rivers beyond April and May.\r\nThe legislation must consider the financial impact of allowing coastal netting to continue on the rural economies. 22312014-12-17T11:05:59.8076520JOHN SIMPSONProtect the future runs of wild Scottish salmon.22312014-12-17T11:38:23.3836521Francis SandisonThe SG's proposal to prohibit the killing of salmon before April is inadequate and would preserve very few spring fish, some of which may be caught and killed later in the spring. I fully support the proposals in the petition.22312014-12-17T11:40:00.2736522Colin SharpSalmon stocks WILL disappear if we do not act22312014-12-17T11:42:39.9636523Bob BurbidgeIt is shear lunacy to allow the nets to continue the indiscriminate killing of salmon. The SNP wants to be a party of the Scottish People but when all the salmon are gone so will all those peoples jobs and lively hoods.22312014-12-17T11:52:45.986524David MclaughlinEveryone needs to sign 22312014-12-17T12:03:24.9336525Alfred PopeThe Scottish Government should ban all netting of Salmon and make it mandatory for all salmon fish farms to be sited on land.22312014-12-17T12:28:46.0276526Sandy Addisontime for action22312014-12-17T12:30:25.546527John BrownlieThere is a dire need to take action now. The message is clear.22312014-12-17T12:36:00.296528malcolm campbellMake it no Salmon to be killed before end of June as on Tweed bring every river into line and all nets22312014-12-17T13:22:41.096529Erin HunterBest cause I've ever supported by far!22312014-12-17T16:16:43.156530Regan littleLook after the fishing stock for the future!22312014-12-17T17:08:18.6376531Malcolm BrownAs a keen angler, and a lover of our Scottish countryside and Scottish rivers I fully support this petition22312014-12-17T17:28:39.2436532John EllicockWe must act to save the wild salmon22312014-12-17T17:36:12.4636533fergus glynnregrettable but essential step. Well done, Ian and keep up the good work22312014-12-17T18:02:21.7176534Peter Austin, MRCVSThe Scottish Ministers must note that while the numbers of rod caught salmon may seem substantial, the number killed is a small fraction in contrast to the net caught where 100% are killed regardless of their breeding potential. Most accept that the main problem of non returning salmon lies somewhere at sea and so Government should focus on filling our knowledge gaps in order that an effective protection programme may be instituted. We anglers are doing what we can to support the species at this state of current understanding and realise that we cannot object to Greenlanders killing large numbers when netsmen here do the same. In river predation by birds in particular must be significant and should be managed more effectively. I also believe that supplementation of migrating smolts with hatchery protected stock timeously released will significantly improve the chances of survival when running the gauntlet of whatever is waiting in the estuaries and the open sea. I know that some scientists have been led to believe in a contrary theory but I suspect their funding masters have influenced them erroneously. Again, only proper evidence based research will light the way forward.22312014-12-17T18:13:27.0736535David HarveyAs someone who is passionate about and returns almost all his fish I am completely appalled that netting of salmon- and open sea fish farming come to that, I am not against closed containment fish farming incidentally- is scandalous. If other species were so affected there is no doubt that such practices would be banned.22312014-12-17T18:49:18.876536brian murphy Increase the penalty for animal abuse 21552014-12-17T18:58:29.376537Eoin TrillNo spring salmon to be killed and make it catch and release after that. 22312014-12-17T19:18:28.766539Christopher Harry NobleNot for my benefit, but for those who follow.22312014-12-17T20:04:16.926540David HendersonI fished Dee 5 years after voluntary c&r was introduced and the difference was quite unequivocal.22312014-12-17T20:19:43.436541James Mc ErleanThis is a knee jerk reaction from a goverment who has supported and still allows the increase in salmon farming under the auspices of employment but actualy does not bring real employment to the table. See the Econimist December 2012. In its inability to manage netting it is now going to make the legitimate rod fisherman who has contributed to so many hatcheries and has abided by catch and release suffer even further. What about the tourist trade which is already reeling from the impact fromdeer decimation of the iconic red deer and are now getting the double whammy with the fishing. No wonder we voted to make sure you did not run the country!!!22312014-12-17T20:40:58.5576542Bjorn RyggHave been flyfishing in Scotland one week the seven last years and I'm delighted to see this petition coming. It's time for action and I hope we will get there in Norway as well.22312014-12-17T21:11:31.6036543Peter HenkWe must preserve salmon stocks and help save the tourist industry22312014-12-17T21:18:41.846544Sara KirkbyThis desperately need to go ahead to improve the future runs of salmon in the future22312014-12-17T21:35:52.5276545Neil StephenThe future is not ours to destroy we hold it for our children and future generations.22312014-12-17T22:40:04.8576547jondi laurence O Byrne Save our salmon, catch and release for future fishing 22312014-12-17T22:54:12.3076548Caroline GreeneI can't believe this situation has been allowed to get to such a desperate state.22312014-12-17T23:02:06.7836550Brian BarronShared22312014-12-17T23:24:06.586551Iain MorrisonThe punishment for disgraceful acts like this must be increased to fit the crime. 3 or 4 years for malicious acts of cruelty.21552014-12-18T00:00:26.6836552Graeme NiewiadomskiDoes this stupid government not realize what a valuable asset these fish are to the Scottish economy. Then again, suppose not. Total ban on netting would be the solution.22312014-12-18T00:11:38.096553brett richingssave wild atlantic salmon stocks 22312014-12-18T00:44:01.2136554Gordon MillsThe only way to do this with any measure of success, is to stop fishing for salmon for twenty years. Salmon fisheries boards have been messing about with them for way too long and achieved nothing, other than to make them practically extinct. Problem with salmon is it's a rich mans sport, and these "gents" will pay large to fish for them, and want to take them home for the table.\r\nA few years back I heard a tale of an English salmon angler who spent a very successful day on Loch Faskally. Three bars of silver, actually three baggots well on their way back to the sea.\r\nI was fishing for grayling a few winters back, on the Tay, at Stanley Mills when a gillie had a gent out harling for salmon. The gent hooked into a decent size kelt so the gillie landed the boat to land the fish. He was speaking to a passing couple with a dog, and offered them the kelt "for the dog". They turned down the offer and the kelt was released.\r\nThis was in a tidal part of the Tay so every chance the kelt made a full recovery. I reported the gillie to Dr D Summers, who carried out an investigation.\r\nTurned out the gillie was "only kidding".\r\nIf you fish for salmon, you are part of their demise.....22312014-12-18T00:47:56.1976555holly bennettI concur21552014-12-18T07:39:13.8076556Denise Johnstone Need to look after stock now for our future generations 22312014-12-18T07:42:41.1376557John kellyI agree with the netting being stoped but think maybee only fifty percent of anglers rod and line would be ok thank you johnk.22312014-12-18T08:00:10.4136558Steve BeddowsCommercial overfishing has already killed the majority of our coastal fish stocks, Protect our rivers...22312014-12-18T08:17:46.956559Geoffrey allenthis is disgusting, and they encourage the rod angler to return their fish. It is the nets that are reducing the fish numbers22312014-12-18T08:26:04.4376560Guy Gibson Action needs to be taken urgently.22312014-12-18T08:35:20.4636562Charlie TaylorIt is vital that fish stocks return again. Something has to be done!22312014-12-18T09:25:29.276563anthony DempseyGo For it Ian, thanks for taking this fight on my behalf22312014-12-18T09:32:59.346564colin papeWhy not bring all rivers, estuaries and coastal waters throughout the UK into line on the same date.22312014-12-18T09:37:31.5536565Gareth HeadlandRod and line anglers are returning alive most salmon these days,\r\ncoastal netting companies need to stop fishing or do the same to save the future of wild salmon.\r\n22312014-12-18T09:46:17.1376566Norman J DuguidThe very best of luck Ian.22312014-12-18T10:08:28.1836567Dave CowieKeep up the good work Ian, the poor salmon need as much help as we can give them.22312014-12-18T10:19:24.7976568David MortonAction certainly needed - let us hope common sense prevails. 22312014-12-18T10:50:21.1376569Garry WatsonEveryone has to help to make the change or our salmon will be fine for good 22312014-12-18T11:06:17.776570graham lovattI see no reason for any one angler, to take more than, say three fish per year.\r\nThat would be in the region of 20 meal portions, who needs more ?? A tagging system, as per Prince Albert Angling Socsiety of Macclesfield Cheshire, would be a help. Tags could be obtained from Tackle outlets ! or other convenient outlets, at a nominal cost to cover the supplier, and could include a small extra cost towards stocking funds.22312014-12-18T11:39:58.1676571John BucklandCrucial to conserve salmon:not only catch-and-release, but the careful management of the entire river system under ONE careful ownership,22312014-12-18T12:05:13.7376572David RitchieProtecting the rivers must only be the first step. On shore netting must reviewed. Then genuine international cooperation for the protection of migratory fish at sea.22312014-12-18T12:08:13.3076574Ross WoodHopefully this will raise awareness of the plight of the Atlantic salmon and go some way to maintaining future stocks.\r\n22312014-12-18T13:07:40.516575Sean FranklinPlus: Catch and speedy release. Keep the fish in the water where possible.22312014-12-18T14:03:07.0436577Ken CuttingThis species is clearly imperiled the world over. It is up to each of us to encourage localities throughout their range to do their utmost to protect this precious resource. It is my sincere hope that you will do what you can to save this magnificent species and return it to its abundant glory.22312014-12-18T14:49:25.2536578steven meechApply this to all countries22312014-12-18T14:52:51.8636579Nick SempleHopefully at last some real protection for salmon stocks will be introduced and enforced.\r\n22312014-12-18T15:25:16.4636580Malcolm HutonCurtail netting and cull seals on the east coast22312014-12-18T15:26:16.9436581Paul McNeill Keep up the road good work, not everyone isputting there fish back. They are the wons that shout no fih\r\n22312014-12-18T15:45:46.8276582Jody MacKay Seal cull on east coast and end the horrendous netting as well . Catch and release should be determined by each rivers numbers 22312014-12-18T16:08:37.1976583Rory AirdIf we want our children to be able to fish we must do something NOW22312014-12-18T16:19:17.766584Tim pilcherPlease ban the killing of such a valuable asset22312014-12-18T16:48:37.736585mr brian stewartscotlands salmon and seatrout fishing is one of the countrys greatest assets and should be protected and preserved above anything ,especially industrys like fish farming ,failure to do so will be complete failure for the various goverments that have been in charge and who have championed environmental issues .!22312014-12-18T17:38:22.4636586william bartholomewPlease look after this wonderful species, asset and iconic Scottish symbol.22312014-12-18T18:17:40.9036588David DickBetter late than never. Doing nothing is not an option.22312014-12-18T18:21:22.3276589Frank ClarkThis is only worth doing if as well as a rod ban on killing any salmon before the 1st July there is a total ban on any type of netting at sea or river mouths till the 1st July\r\nThis is only part of the solution much more should be done by the Scottish Government to help find the causes of the massive losses of smolts and salmon at sea and to be much more proactive in curbing over fishing of all species in the North Atlantic 22312014-12-18T19:19:33.3876590Manuel Lopez PereiraEstoy de acuerdo con todo lo que haga Ian Gordon en pro del Salmón Atlantico. Entiendo que es un gran benfactor en pro de la conservación de esta maravillosa especie.22312014-12-18T19:27:24.9236591Thomas Johnson-SmithExtrapolating from current data indicates that the Atlantic salmon will be extinct from British waters in 20 years time. This is the least we can ask for.22312014-12-18T19:42:59.5076592Mike PearceWe owe it to future generations of fishermen and women and the salmon specis to do all we can to protect them22312014-12-18T19:53:19.8536593Christine HallSo good that someone is being pro active and gathering support to help protect the salmon.22312014-12-18T22:06:14.9636594Ian StewartKeep up the great work well done on this long journey 22312014-12-19T00:36:53.16595Roger GearyThe only way to ultimately have a sustainable fish stock.22312014-12-19T01:53:47.096596Dr. h.c. Heribert HahneLook to the fishing regulation of BC Kanada - eg Steelhead:\r\nAnglers have to do something for the preservation of salmon: 1. single hook, 2. barbless hook, 3. keep only 1 fish per day, 4. stop fishing for the day of collection of a salmon on this particular river.22312014-12-19T04:58:52.2376597Jochen Moehr, M.D., Ph.D.I m a fly fisher in British Columbia, Canada, and I profoundly empathise with the plights of our Scottish friends - and even more so with the plights of the Scottish salmon. We have the same problems in Canada - for instance with the Skeena River Steelhead - and the same promising solutions. A lot will be lost - not merely for us flyfishers, but for the local culture, the local wild life and environment, and lastly for those who make a living on the attraction of fishing and wild life. \r\n\r\nThe solution is there! It just has to be followed. \r\n\r\nI fully support the recommendations and that "This must apply to both netting and angling."22312014-12-19T07:22:37.36599Graham BurnsIt has to be reduced. Thanks22312014-12-19T08:28:34.5576600Brian McManusAt last the problem is getting some recognition.\r\nCoincidentally, since the start of the Salmon Farms on the West Coast was just before the start of the downfall of the Salmon on the West Coast..\r\nWhy when the research into The Scottish Salmon Decline in recent years, was it conducted on the East Coast Only? The problem has not really affected the East Coast it is on the West Coast that the decline of the Salmon is making them near extinction quicker than ever? It only takes going into the local clubs of the West and ask to see their "Catch Returns Book", and you can see when the decline in numbers being recorded and it coincides with the start of the Salmon Farms. As the number of farms increased and spread up the coast the Salmon numbers decreased. Personally I don't see it being coincidental event.\r\nWe have known that the concentration of the Sea lice around the farms was an obvious problem to the Salmon that were entering the rivers of the sheltered sea lochs had to "Run the Gauntlet", of Sea lice ridden area around the areas of the Salmon cages, \r\nWith the salmon in the cages being 'fertile', and at the numbers of them getting released into the wild by storms etc, they were in turn breeding with the native indigenous fish and depleting the genetic build up of the off spring. This happening every year since. With the general integrity of the Salmon being depleted they cannot survive as well as needed like the true wild fish can and therefore once again a drop in numbers aand a weaker strain of fish in the rivers. It would be a very good idea if the Salmon Farms were to make all Salmon Triploids, ie, Barren, infertile and unproductive in the wild, thus any Salmon left to spawn will gradually breed out the genes of the Farmed fish. Farmed Salmon are being selectively bred for different qualities than the wild ones. They are being bred to be good survivors in the confined conditions where \r\nNo room left for me to finish my comment, \r\nthank you.22312014-12-19T08:59:22.546601Alan CummingsWe must take action to preserve our salmon stocks and can't procrastinate over this any longer.22312014-12-19T10:35:30.1376602Laurence Brown The income generated by visiting sporting anglers, like myself (ex-pat), must massively outweigh any income generated by netting to the Scotland's GDP. \r\nAfter a dreadful season like this year, if you don't do something to reduce the decline in numbers of fish in the rivers, you soon won't have a salmon fishing tourist industry!! \r\nHowever I do think fish farming is a probably a bigger threat to natural salmon & sea trout levels, but that's another fight! 22312014-12-19T11:32:28.5576603John MelvilleYes, I can get behind this, those poor unfortunates in salmon farms should be used instead. They are treated no differently from chickens, and whether you like the idea or not, some good can arise from the farmed Salmons plight. :)22312014-12-19T12:05:03.0536604William SmithIt is a bad day when our law makers allow law breakers to get away with non payment. You have lost my vote.21912014-12-19T12:19:35.396605Gregory DixonI fish and release Atlantic salmon on the rivers of northern NB and the Gaspe Peninsula of Quebec, Canada every summer from May to Sept. We are experiencing the same decline of this world class fish as other parts of the World and would do anything to ensure its survival. Without this fish there would be no work for a good portion of the working population as the numerous lodges, most of whom support catch and release, employee hundreds of guides, cooks, handymen, wardens, etc. It is a way of life for many, a great one I might add. Without this fish we all would be doomed to a life of misery. I remember each fish as if it was yesterday and the same joy comes to me at 60 now as it did when I hooked my first Atlantic salmon at 16. Please help Ian and his followers to ensure this tragedy does not befall your beloved rivers of Scotland. Sincerely, Greg.22312014-12-19T12:45:56.0576606Mark MahoneyThere has been much talk and little action over recent years. A full ban on the killing of wild salmon is only one measure. The second measure, that will upset the general public, is the reduction in seal numbers and river predators, as their numbers are out of control. The third measure should be the removal of all Salmon Farms within a minimum 20 mile radius of any river estuaries. We need immediate action across all areas for the stocks to recover22312014-12-19T12:46:42.5736607Brian D'Arcy ClarkIts doubtful that the decline in river catches is soleley due to rivermouth or coastal netting - deep sea trawlers must be responsible at least in part - but to kill the spawning few that evade all nets is clearly madness. The sooner this proposed ban comes in the better.22312014-12-19T13:12:39.1976608Nicholas William SmithAll netting on rivers in the United Kingdom should be banned!22312014-12-19T15:27:40.3236609william mairI commend you in all your efforts , well done keep it up . Jim22312014-12-19T15:29:10.9636610Colin mcfadyenSawbills must have a major impact on salmonoid juveniles in rivers,why is there not more done to control these birds!\r\n22312014-12-19T16:13:23.2636611David BrewCconservation of salmon at sea and their feeding grounds, together with protection of the wonderful rivers in Scotland is required . Let's not mess it up for the future. Stopping netting, pollution, abstraction of water , and limiting predators are feasible issues we can tackle. Let's keep the rivers a special places to visit. Act now.22312014-12-19T17:39:46.4476612Paul FisherI catch very few (only 1 in the last 2yrs) but this season I have hardly seen any never mind caught any , something has to be done to preserve stocks sooner rather than later. Later may be too late !!22312014-12-19T18:00:49.766613Charles JardineThe Resource is Finite and Precious. 22312014-12-19T18:20:01.546614Yvonne KellyShouldn't need to sign a petition for this to happen!!22312014-12-19T18:24:17.4176615Andrew SmithThere is no need to kill msw salmon before July or across the season. That applies to both anglers and nets. We need legislation to protect the bigger fish in our rivers all season. And mixed stock fisheries are something that makes no sense. We should be buying out the nets as part of a joined up programme.\r\n22312014-12-19T18:34:03.6376617kevin andersonshould have been stopped years ago22312014-12-19T21:34:39.876618Philippe Koehleri agree to sign with M. Ian Gordon22312014-12-20T00:31:07.9736619Garry BettridgeIn support of all Fly Fishers all over the world, protect wild fishes of all species because once they're gone, THEY are GONE!!22312014-12-20T01:03:19.766620Alan CoadThere is simply not a sustainable surplus on western European rivers to harvest. While rods and coastal nets are only contributing to salmon declines, everyone needs to do their part to save this precious species. Lets hope this effort extends to offshore netting and by catch also.22312014-12-20T10:50:19.5676621Peter HorsburghI'd echo the comment below: \r\nThe income generated by visiting sporting anglers, like myself (ex-pat, also), must massively outweigh any income generated by netting to the Scotland's GDP. After a dreadful season like this year, if you don't do something to reduce the decline in numbers of fish in the rivers, you soon won't have a salmon fishing tourist industry.However I do think fish farming is a(n) equal (robably a bigger) threat to natural salmon & sea trout levels, but that's another fight!22312014-12-20T11:31:49.7136622David LeaverI fully agree - the two other major problems are excessive seal numbers and intensive salmon farms. It is now almost impossible to find areas of the Hebridean islands without fish farms. A prior proposal to dart seals with a contraceptive to reduce numbers would be both humane and effective. Anyone going into loch scavaig on Skye to walk into coiruisk, will have seen over 300 seals at the mouth of the river!22312014-12-20T11:36:42.4576623James Garvieall fish to be released back to water !!22312014-12-20T13:22:51.8836624james campbellSigned22312014-12-20T17:00:37.136625Gareth jonesAs a tweed fisherman we have practiced catch and release for the last 10 years yet nets have decimated wild stocks, together with Scotland's inability to control fish farmed salmon and the approval of fish farm licences, how long before rod fishermen decide enough is enough and join me in fishing abroad, better rivers, better management and a lot cheaper.\r\nWake up as this is a point of no return, if we have not already passed it22312014-12-20T17:31:48.016626Howard EvansGive what is truly wild a fighting chance to complete its epic journey and fulfill its basic needs to survive.22312014-12-20T21:33:44.056627Neil McNeill 26 attempts later!22312014-12-21T01:05:45.3176628Darn MccroryDone22312014-12-21T12:45:18.8336629Colin McSherryAction must be taken now before it's too late , If this was Natterjack's or Eagles I doubt we would need a petition , Please act now!!!22312014-12-21T13:24:13.3936630Suzanne KellyIt is clear too many wild salmon, mature and young are being taken. I accompanied USAN on one afternoon's harvesting. it was astonishing to see what a vast area of water their nets by Montrose cover and how many salmon were clubbed to death on that one day. It is too much.22312014-12-21T14:35:56.5976631Tony KingTime to give the salmon a complete break a two or three year no kill policy for interceptory and river nets and for recreational fishermen will give a chance to see if any improvements are made. If the result is negative more drastic measures less tasteful to the Scottish assembly might have to be considered. They have done precious little to maintain one of Scotland's Iconic species. 22312014-12-21T23:50:29.196632danny hunterwe are the custodians of this planet there-fore we should take care of it and protect all creatures great and small !!22312014-12-22T07:16:54.7536633Manfred WiblishauserWell done, Ian - the netting in all rivers should be banned. Also all buildings who stop the way into the river for spawning. Save the Salmons!22312014-12-22T12:26:27.6636634Carlos Van Heddegemshould have been in place years ago and salmon farming properly controlled instead of being given substantial government grants.\r\nPriorities all wrong 22312014-12-22T12:41:31.456635DONALD MACKENZIESALMON NETTING IS HAVING A SERIOUS EFFECT ON TOURIST ANGLING AND THE INCOME THESE VISITORS BRING IN TO SCOTLAND22312014-12-22T16:24:17.5936636Dr David GrayWild Salmon in Scotland are under server pressure from habitat change, fish farming, netting and rods. For them to survive we, who exploit them, need to give all the help we can. Not killing the most endangered Spring fish by a moratorium until 1st July each year is a small concession in this direction. The presence of Salmon in Scottish rivers is a 'free' bonus to the community on which our way of life and many jobs depends.22312014-12-22T16:26:59.0336637Ken Bourne Well done .22312014-12-22T16:58:59.5976638john roythis is a problem that cannot be covered from a single stand point whether it be coastal netting salmon farming or natural predation the only thing that counts is common sense and common sense dictates without question that we let what little numbers are left return and spawn, to be a true angler sometimes means you have to sacrifice now for the future of our sport \r\n22312014-12-22T17:07:37.1136639René MazzocutFor the Salmen22312014-12-22T17:44:41.6436640Mark MelvilleTime to stop killing our increasingly rare and magnificent spring salmon once and for all. 22312014-12-22T17:50:42.636641John WhittakerKilling the spawning salmon is absolutely senseless, and selfish.22312014-12-22T17:54:54.636642Robert Deybadly needed22312014-12-22T23:18:49.3476644robert williamsonMy love is fishing,especialy salmon-and sea trout.My local river,forth and teeth which i have fished for 30 yrs are great but last 2 yrs very few fish,plenty of seals.any-way i will be there next season,best of luck with petition. Bob.22312014-12-23T02:11:44.0436645John Couttsthis has got to be the biggest wake up call ever22312014-12-23T08:48:57.986646david gawnetting in scotland should be banned .22312014-12-23T11:16:00.496647Stephen LodgeKeep up the good work22312014-12-23T11:17:10.076649David StylesStop talking and employing experts....just do it!22312014-12-23T11:20:04.856650Chris JamiesonI am only an occasional salmon fisherman but the trips to the Scottish rivers have been among the most memorable of my life. It would be a terrible thing for such a valuable resource as the wonderful Scottish Salmon to be prematurely depleted denying future generations the pleasures we anglers enjoy today. Accordingly, it is unfair to expect the net fisherman to bare all responsibility for any preservation initiatives and we anglers should be prepared to act also. It seems only fair as we are all in the this together. Lets give the fish a chance to regenerate.22312014-12-23T11:55:24.16651John Braithwaitefor the last 30 years I have spent4- 5 weeks a year salmon fishing in scotland \r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\nand if things do not improve I am going to give it \r\nup completely, the Salmon fishing gets worse each year.\r\n22312014-12-23T11:59:39.0336652Colin Moir William RobertsonSelf contained aquaculture systems must be the way forward - possibly Scotland could become a world leader in this pote4ntial new global industry and stop the sea louse problem and return our waters to their former state of pristine quality.22312014-12-23T12:18:28.2076653Malcolm McCreathAll netting of salmon should be stopped throughout the whole year, not just the Spring. If salmon runs continue to decline the loss of jobs in rural areas would be catastrophic. Much stricter control of fish farms is also urgently required.22312014-12-23T12:29:39.9576654Mike HardingYou ask to "read the two words shown in the box below" but they are numbers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!22312014-12-23T12:46:30.9576655Simon TylerAll netting should be banned in the UK and mandatory 100% catch and release for all us anglers including stopping worm and prawn as methods. We would know where we stand and it would be a consistent message.22312014-12-23T12:53:24.2836657Christopher GarrettHigh time for a move in this direction.\r\nFive years of abstinence is a small price to pay towards a larger and healthier stock.22312014-12-23T12:57:29.0036658Jack mawdsleyI fully support petition PE01547 and have been asking for such action to take place for many years.22312014-12-23T13:16:18.3336659andrew kingAnglers should do their bit and follow strict catch and release, and clearly netting in the estuaries and at sea must be stopped before the damage is irreversible\r\n22312014-12-23T13:27:55.6776660Stuart CullenI fish a Scottish catch and release only salmon river, the Little Gruinard, so although I live in England, I feel qualified to sign this important petition.22312014-12-23T14:24:13.4876661James JS BirtlesA great deal of income comes from anglers and if the netting continues the country will suffer not just from fishing revenue but all associated industries ie Hotels, clothing etc.22312014-12-23T14:46:05.8476662Dr William George JonesI believe the decline in wild salmon returning to Scottish rivers may be due to sea lice infestation of salmon smolts on their way out to feeding grounds in the Atlantic. The role of salmon farming at sea needs to be investigated in the decline of wild fish, and fish farming needs to be undertaken in a sealed or contained environment.22312014-12-23T15:19:04.16663Iain MurrayI have been fishing for 57 years and know the situation is now critical. We must act now while there is still time for nature to recover. Do not miss this chance - there will not be another and future generations will ask why we were so greedy when the salmon have gone. 22312014-12-23T15:47:12.86664William John SavageNetting policy must be reconsidered so as to reduce or eliminate it!22312014-12-23T16:13:22.976665Richard MosdellIt is a pity the Scottish Parliament doesn't take the threat of farmed salmon to the wild salmon as serious as the netting. And the Scottish rivers are not just the domain of the rich but something to be enjoyed by all and in so doing a living to a lot of people and not an insignificant amount of revenue to the economy of Scolland.22312014-12-23T16:14:48.5336666Geoffrey S HallTo help conserve the stocks of wild salmon this must happen & netting must be stopped22312014-12-23T16:29:21.9276668Philip ParkinsonThese amazing fish are far too valuable as a genetic resource for self propagation, and as source of socio economic benefit through rod fisheries. Let farmed fish supply the meat market, and let all rod fishing for salmon be 100% catch and release.. 22312014-12-23T16:31:04.636669barry claphamcomplete joke they is lots of jobs involved , and income to the areas were there is fishing. 22312014-12-23T16:36:46.626670Graham Yates Fly fishing for Salmon in Scotland is wonderful pass time. United action is required.22312014-12-23T16:42:42.4876671S R PENNINGTONbring farmed salmon on shore, leave the sea to wild fish ban nets totally22312014-12-23T16:54:02.2076672Barry FisherTo conserve the low stock netting must stop completely.22312014-12-23T17:18:47.1136673Mrs C. Stewart-Richardson The netting of the Salmon and SeaTrout is the main problem as because of this factor, there are many fewer fish to reach the rivers to breed. The anglers fishing on the rivers return the majority of the fish to the river so are not the main problem. It is the netting that should be limited. It has also been known for diseased farmed salmon to escape and to infect the wild salmon causing some to die and therefore leaving less to get to the rivers. For these reasons and the fact the ban would cause considerable unemployment, a ban should be carefully considered and the netting limited.\r\n22312014-12-23T17:20:59.246675Rex WilkinsonTo save something which is under such pressure is a natural action that should be taken. We must ensure that future generations are able to see such wonderful wild creatures22312014-12-23T17:27:31.0876676Mike BilsonCommon sense please! As an intelligent society we cannot stand aside and watch the environment be destroyed.22312014-12-23T17:30:08.5976677Matthew H. CalvertIn view of the rapidly deteriorating Salmon stocks it seems completely inappropriate for unrestricted killing of Salmon to occur. I agree that there should be no Salmon killing before July 1st by nets or rods and after that it should be severely restricted for nets as well as rods. It should be noted that most rods already return a high proportion of fish. 22312014-12-23T18:11:11.0176678Stephen HeyLand -based salmon farming using sustainable feed is the only answer to prevent lice and disease acquired in the estuarine and coastal environment.22312014-12-23T18:20:39.4276679Michael StirkIt is time that Scotland stepped into line with what England and Wales have been progressively doing over the last decade and cease all coastal netting forthwith as unless they do so their salmon rod fishing tourist industry will be extinct in 10 years time22312014-12-23T18:36:21.9576680Josceline GroveI support the petition22312014-12-23T20:44:28.0736681Mark RedmanStart to understand what you have and how valuable resource it is for you. Use it properly and it is there for life, be a fool and it will never come back22312014-12-23T20:58:32.916682Jenny MeadeMarine Scotland are still struggling to see the obvious that sea fish are drastically overfished by dredging. Hopefully the government will see the light to save wild salmon. All fish need a place to spawn, and time to grow to breeding age. THis planet will be destroyed if we don't SEE SENSE !!22312014-12-23T22:43:01.0976683Brian Scottwhy have we as humans hunted so many animals to near extinction then only do something about it when it's too late. Let's not make this the case with Atlantic Salmon22312014-12-23T23:08:22.416684John Mosesstricter control of salmon farms and their positioning22312014-12-23T23:14:05.4376685Peter MorrisWe MUST give the wild Atlantic Salmon a chance to survive.At the present rate of progress it won't and our generation will be to blame!!!22312014-12-24T12:32:40.2836686Ian CookeI firmly believe that this action is neccessary to protect an iconic species that is on the brink. For many years we have tinkered with the problem of falling salmon numbers and not really addressed the key issues. We know we have a major problem with salmon survival at sea so the very least we can do is ensure that returning salmon have the best possible chance of completing their life cycle whilst we continue to the science and investigations at sea to undersatnd just what is going on. I'm afraid that the loss of jobs in the salmon netting industry will come all to soon if we choose not to take meaninful action.22312014-12-24T16:24:01.6376687Michael AbbottStop coastal netting22312014-12-24T16:29:48.026688John SiddonsBan all coastal and river mouth nets and stop netting at sea for 5 years. Rod caught fish are not the problem !!!!!\r\n 22312014-12-24T17:07:26.5036689Simon BostockWe are seeing yet more evidence of man's endless damaging activities which threaten yet more this wonderful fish. We have the scientific research and evidence to know what to do. In this instance it is to limit the level of exploitation, especially by netting. Angling too must play a part. There must be no killing of fish by either method before 1 July each year pending evidence of a full recovery of stocks. I urge full support of this petition.22312014-12-24T18:51:02.996690Robin WhysallIn addition to this petition greatest effort must be made to prevent trawling salmon at sea. This must be the greatest cause of their demise than any other single factor.22312014-12-24T19:56:54.0476691Willam HartnettSalmon fishing in Scotland is a serious concern the fish are not in the abundance that they once were, predation by birds of the juvenile fish in rivers, feeding habits offshore, contamination from farm fish cages plus general diminishing fish population and then the outmoded netting practices are killing this natural phenomena\r\nthe Scottish government should encourage the ban and take action in regard to safeguarding this wild species22312014-12-25T00:08:08.3676692Richard FerrierThe future of the wild Salmon is in our hands, so act today and secure its future for all to enjoy, fishers and non-fishers.22312014-12-25T09:25:31.96693Brian FraserIn our area of Wester Ross the last nets man told me that he started fishing the nets just as the fish farm was getting started and admits he hadn't got a clue what he was doing and caught over 3.000 salmon. Ten years later he did know what he was doing and struggled to catch 300 fish that was in his opinion the effect fish farms had on the salmon and trout in Wester Ross. 22312014-12-25T09:56:49.9436694Patrick CowanIt has all been said many times before, and now it is imperative that action is taken22312014-12-26T11:45:11.7176695David WatsonPlease take action to stop the Scottish Government continuing to be the world pariah on Atlantic Salmon conservation.\r\n22312014-12-26T12:27:39.6736696Harold Tongeits the salmon by catch that is the ultimate destroyer of these, we need marine protection areas and passages where no fish can be caught and sold.22312014-12-26T14:49:48.0876697David CoshWe must give the salmon chance to run the rivers and regenerate.22312014-12-26T16:57:15.5936698Alex BarnesPlease sort this out before we have to put Salmon on the endangered species list.22312014-12-26T20:00:31.176700John L Papeall coastal netting should be banned22312014-12-26T22:19:25.216701Colin WestWith no quotas on salmon netsmen, they take unlimited numbers of salmon and seatrout . This, along with the damage done by sealice from salmon farms are placing an unsustainable strain on the survival of these wild populations. Protection for them is essential.22312014-12-27T10:09:06.286702Cecil John DuguidNot only must the coastal netting be stopped till at least the end of June the netting stations must have strict quotas to adhere to and a fish tagging system should be seriously looked into in the UK. Plus a international restriction of the plundering at sea of the food supply which all salmon need when they smolt. The food which is taken by the factory ships is not controlled in any way and this is used to feed Farmed Salmon, in the esturys which is causing pollution on the bottom and \r\n#sea lice numbers are NOT being controlled or dealt with. Which the powers that be are turning a blind eye to for a short time gain. As for hatcheries and all the talk from scientist,s about hatchey fish being inferior, the more fish that go to sea assuming they have food to eat when they get to the feeding grounds will return, the fish that do return cannot be that inferior. The Icelandic smolt rivers are doing very well from there progammes. Goverments please note it.22312014-12-28T02:53:07.786703James SD leachSimply not killing fish is only half the answer. More has to be done about the habitat22312014-12-28T13:43:17.2876704Jim McLanaghanWhilst this course of action is certainly required there also needs to be some action on salmon farming around the coast of Scotland as whole. The Government should take note of this!22312014-12-28T20:23:45.9836705Peter KeelingFish stocks are very low these days and anything to preserve the numbers.22312014-12-28T22:54:35.336706Stephen OttridgeThe Scottish Government need to act now to reduce the numbers of wild salmon being killed predominantly by both netsmen and through the effects of the aquaculture industry - as a matter of some urgency. Anglers, who play a significant part in supporting Scotland's tourist industry, are currently releasing in excess of 75-80% of salmon caught in the interests of salmon conservation. It is now time for the Scottish Government to lead by example in the interest of salmon conservation too as a failure to act now would be seen as being grossly irresponsible.22312014-12-29T10:21:38.346707Catherine HorganGreat idea, to slow down life is important as it will have larger benefits for the future, its one of our main challenges for our children, wishing all luck to all!22312014-12-29T16:17:17.3136708Linda MartinThe Atlantic Salmon is severely threatened. Game anglers on my local river are practising catch and release, taking fish only for "stripping" for breeding purposes, or abstaining from Salmon fishing altogether. Without an equivalent commitment from the net-fishermen, this magnificent animal may well become extinct. This situation has not been helped by the increase in the seal population, and the harvesting of sand-eels for fuelling power stations. Compensate the netsmen if need-be, but let us do what we can for the Atlantic Salmon and hope that it is not too late.\r\n22312014-12-29T18:05:34.3436709Hamish MackenzieI fully support this petition.22312014-12-30T23:41:49.816711Peter McDermottWe must do all that we can to preserve our salmon.This must include full on lobbying to the international predators of the Atlantic Salmon during its ocean life cycle. Both the species and its food source are being plundered to extinction. 22312014-12-31T10:11:53.5476712James Scott-ClarkeI hope the pollution caused by the fish farms is part of this. 22312014-12-31T10:13:36.4036713Stuart WrightThe Scottish Government should immediately stop all coastal netting if they want to ensure the long term viability of the salmon rod fishing tourist industry.22312014-12-31T10:26:34.0376714mark hussonwithout further control of netting, the latest generation of gillies, guides, river keepers, hoteliers, inn keepers, caterers, estate cleaners etc, will be the last. the relatively small number of netsman will have to be offered retraining.22312014-12-31T11:24:49.0136715Chris BowersI will never visit Scotland again until the Scottish Government takes positive action to conserve the wild salmon and sea trout stocks. Part of my holiday was to fish for these species, there is no point in travelling to Scotland just to play golf.22312014-12-31T12:41:53.2236716John AllenI will not be spending any more of my hard earned visiting Scotland until I see sustained action by the Scottish Government to redress the damage they have caused and continue to cause to wild migratory fishing.22312014-12-31T12:45:56.8376717Ann AllenI will never visit Scotland again until the Scottish Government takes positive action to conserve the wild salmon and sea trout stocks. Part of my holiday was to fish for these species, there is no point in travelling to Scotland just for the scenery you get see that in many other places and play excellent links golf courses.22312014-12-31T13:08:57.6636718Nicholas LeRougetelWe have a duty as custodians for future generations to protect all wild fish.22312014-12-31T14:14:43.9376719Colin Scott-DempsterWell done. All strength to your cause in working for us all. I have longer for some action in this vital battle against the Scottish Government's dire attitude and hypocritical stance,22312014-12-31T14:36:08.5436720Steve SmithLess Salmond and Sturgeon... more salmon! I wont be spending my money in Scotland until this lunacy stops.22312014-12-31T15:56:32.5636721Hugh BerridgeShould not similar restrictions be placed upon the killing of seatrout whose numbers have declined steeply over the last 30 or so years, and particularly so since 2000?22312014-12-31T17:53:09.1676722Charles van der LandeFollowing the decline in Salmon catches in recent years, I have decided not to return to Scotland in 2015 with my usual party of fishers.22312015-01-01T10:13:51.8776723Michael BulloughExcellent plan to save the salmon and the many jobs that go with the visiting fishermen22312015-01-01T11:07:01.8376724Lionel YoungIt is difficult to justify the very high cost of salmon fishing in Scotland when the catches continue to decrease year on year. This high revenue earner for the local economies will soon cease unless the Scottish Parliament acts decisively on the matter. 22312015-01-01T23:10:48.226725David CoatesThe Scottish Government should understand the value of salmon fishing to the wider community.22312015-01-02T12:41:04.766727Charles HomanFor over 25 years six keen fishers have injected many tens of thousands of pounds into the local economies along with many others. We have not killed a fish for a long time nor in the last few years hardly caught any! We request the Scottish Government to take urgent action to prevent the looming extinction of a beautiful wild animal. If there is no positive legislation to slow the demise of wild salmon in Scotland, then like like many others we will sadly follow our salmon fishing interests abroad. Very regrettable for us but more hurtful to the local communities and economies that game fishing supports. 22312015-01-02T13:05:30.126728Wolfgang LehnertGod will be safe the nice scottish nature, i hope!!22312015-01-02T13:30:51.8536729Patrick HoyI first learnt to love Scotland as an apprentice in 1951 and my annual fishing holiday is something I treasured. I find it hard to believe that those promoting such short sighted change are in the real world.22312015-01-02T19:50:28.2076730Richard VainerHow can you justify sticking a hook into a wonderful creature as a Salmon towing it around a pool and often damaging it in the release process.......rather than debasing it to the level of a mere toy it wouldd be far more honest to suspend fishing entirely for a period in tandem with proper predator control and a more honest governmental approach to the problem1 22312015-01-03T08:07:55.116731Alistair fergusonSoimple idea but high time it was put in forse22312015-01-03T11:39:13.9936732Simon EvansAlthough I live in Wales, I currently spend over 2,000 pounds each year fishing for salmon in Scotland. Unless numbers are protected at a time of record low marine survival there will be no reason for me to bring my money to Scotland. 22312015-01-03T11:40:28.5436733Duncan Gordon-ColebrookeThe Scottish Govt. has done enough damage already. Please let us stop them doing any more.22312015-01-03T11:40:42.0336734David WardApart from the control of netting and rod caught fish, there also needs to be control of the seal population which has got totally out of hand. When you see hundreds of seals sittiing on the sands in some areas and then do some simple maths to estimate the amount of fish they eat per day, it is amazing any fish make it into the rivers.22312015-01-03T11:41:01.0576735alan.roeThey also need to be getting rid of those vastly polluting Norwegian salmon farms of the west coast you notice that the Norwegian Government won't allow them in their waters!!!22312015-01-03T11:41:30.226736Gerald HallamWe need to increase the measures we take to conserve fish stocks and allow them to increase.22312015-01-03T11:42:27.2836737Callum S. S. HighetI have to say even though I have only been salmon and sea trout fishing for the last 5years, there is a noticeable decline in fish numbers entering the Scottish rivers and waterway systems. I am passionate about salmon fishing and would love to share future experiences with my children. However, I fear that the continuing of netting and killing of fish is not aiding any improvements to save our wild stocks. An additional thing to consider is the livelihoods of the ghillies who profession it is to put us as clients over the fish. If there are no fish, then less and less fishermen or women will be participating in this amazing sport. I have to say I personally have no interest in keeping salmon I catch. The satisfaction I receive from releasing a fish is worth more than its weight on the table. I do also understand that it is nice to have a fish for the table now and again, but when I see large hen fish being killed it really gets to me. Imagine all the salmon that could potentially have that DNA to grow big and strong.\r\n\r\nI would love to spend days fishing for salmon with my children one day which is why I strongly agree with this petition. 22312015-01-03T11:42:27.7536738Bob TurnerSalmon are far more valuable to the Scottish economy alive rather than dead.22312015-01-03T11:48:06.8936739Dale Robinson i won't be returning to fish in Scotland until something is done about netting 22312015-01-03T11:48:43.0476740Rich KnolesWild Salmon stocks are very important to me as a visiting angler. Surely the tourism dollars have a bigger impact on local economies. 22312015-01-03T11:52:58.6576741John RogersonRefuse to sign on this occasion. Associating rod anglers alongside nets is categorically wrong! Anglers are the Salmons only remaining 'friend' yet we always feel the full force of useless restrictions which only paint the false picture that the authorities care! Sorry.22312015-01-03T11:53:06.4576742Peter GavanPreserving and enhancing wild fish stocks must have a higher priority from this and future governments. The current neglect is similar to the delay in officially recognising the health dangers of smoking.22312015-01-03T11:56:13.4576743Martin WebsterThe situation is dire. Please take action to rebuild this vital element of your rich environment and to protect the livelihood of huge numbers of people dependent on fishing tourism.22312015-01-03T11:57:33.0036744Jamie LindsayThanks Ian. All the best22312015-01-03T11:57:55.086745Andy DICKSONThis is even more essential after 2014 seasons disastrous salmon run22312015-01-03T12:01:52.6576746IAN ROBINSONthe free run of wild Scottish salmon is an essential part of the Scottish Spirit and continued economic survival of the countryside22312015-01-03T12:02:39.7036747Christopher BruynsTourism or Salmon, Scottish Government that's what this is really about. You cannot have both ! Tourism and it's benefits will always win. Leave the fish alone ! ! !22312015-01-03T12:07:19.9876748Wilhelmina WilsonThere are so few fish about and a lot of jobs are at stake if netting started again. It is pretty bad without the netting22312015-01-03T12:07:44.5636749david hutchinsonlast year was the first for many years we did not visit Scotland as fish stocks have dropped at an alarming rate, before this we visited for 3 or 4 weeks every year, all netting must be stopped\r\nwe removed 2 nets and gave to keeper on our last visit .22312015-01-03T12:11:39.5176750John MangelschotsBeide the ban on netting, also a regulation for ecological salmon farming and a limitation on catching migrating salmon on high seas must be instaled.22312015-01-03T12:13:01.346751Anton PousarIf you're not up for the enviromental side, please take a look on economical side of salmon. Hundreds of anglers around the world, like me, come to Scotland just because of salmon fishing. You don't wan't loose your moneys. 22312015-01-03T12:13:42.7336752Ian BunchSalmon fishing is getting worse every year. It would be great to actually catch a fish in order to return it. \r\nThere are plenty of reared fish without depleting stocks of wild fish by netting. \r\nHope your petition works - good luck22312015-01-03T12:17:08.3436753John LeighWell done Ian Gordon a high profile fisher leading the fight on behalf of Fishers and Conservationists\r\nKeep up the good work22312015-01-03T12:18:49.146754John LewisYes, we must certainly deal with the problem of over-netting and other methods, but the Scottish Government and its agencies (SEPA, SNH, etc.) must also take a much firmer stance against fish farms with respect to sea lice infestations and the use of toxic pesticides, which scientific research has clearly shown to have disastrous effects on wild salmon both at sea and in spawning rivers close to fish farms. This is an acute problem along the whole of the West Coast of Scotland and its islands. I know because I live in this area of Scotland!22312015-01-03T12:19:29.226755Allan mcleod. Paphos Cyprus ex Arbroath ScotlandMy plan's were to come back to scotland fishing every year specifically on the North Esk,Tay and Dee. Unfortunately until the goverment take some actions and provide help for our rivers instead of throwing nets up for a few fishermen on the coast to profit from i will not be back. 22312015-01-03T12:20:34.3136756Nick MillardThe rivers become emptier as the years roll by. Such a pity for all those concerned in game fishing. Such a pity for the Atlantic Salmon essentially.22312015-01-03T12:26:15.0176757Suzanne KellyLast May I went out with USAN to see their salmon netting operations. I found it cruel but still better than the life farmed salmon get. Fish are trapped, hauled up and clubbed to death as they suffocate. They may only be fish, but they are assuredly sentient and they were terrified and they suffered. The bigger picture is the low number of salmon making it from the sea back into the rivers and happily the Scottish Govt agreed something needed to be done. Ian Gordon's petition was a success, salmon now can't be killed before April. He's now trying to push for a shorter season still. I am convinced that too many wild salmon are taken from the research I have done. The nets are massive we are no longer talking about the simple heritable right to fish, this is on a huge scale. 22312015-01-03T12:34:23.7076759RICHARD BRAMBLEHelp save dwindling wild Salmon stocks, let the fish run up the rivers to spawn, conserve what wild Salmon we have left for future generations, rather than netting what we have left for short term financial gains. No wild salmon means no fisherman and the loss of sustainable vital jobs and income to Scottish communities.22312015-01-03T12:34:56.0176760hector maclennanit might be possible to monitor the taking of wild fish by net by obtaining information about the availability of salmon at wholesale distributers such as Billingsgate. Trout and Salmom Mag reported that at one time the price in mid summer of wild fish at Billingsgate stood at £2 a lb suggesting a glut of fish and a netting bonanza as low rivers resulted in high concentrations of fish in netting areas. I suggest that it is just possible that all netting returns are not quite accurate! It might be possible to monitor their catch through available market statistics?22312015-01-03T12:37:04.966762Richard CollinsSecurity question impossible to read from very substandard photograph.22312015-01-03T12:43:10.656763Dr David William WallUnless firm action is taken we will find that wild Atlantic salmon become extinct. The coastal salmon nets need to come off as they have a devastating effect - as figures for salmon entering the rivers in 2013 and 2014 are now showing.22312015-01-03T12:44:40.4576764william felthamhope you win.22312015-01-03T12:53:21.056766carl ohrmanI have been forced to travel to oversea destinations to catch a salmon-- when i would prefer my money went to the Scotland.22312015-01-03T12:53:41.556767Andy morrisWhat's sad is that the goverment can spend millions discussing the future of scotland, spend millions on a swanky parliament building , spend millions discussing its green commitments and credentials but yet they cannot commit to clear obligations around the most sought after asset they have ever had the responsibility of protecting . The wild Scottish salmon is and hopefully will remain an opportunity for the Scottish parliament to lead the world in protecting this important fish that will always be synonymous with Scotland . The alternate strategy is to simply not act and the income Scotland enjoys from the salmon industry shifts to other countries who work harder to protect migratory fish. Lets all act now to repair the levels and protect the income for Scotland 22312015-01-03T12:57:47.9076768Rune Rudolf RunnerstromThink of the future. They will thank you for thinking of the wild Salmon.22312015-01-03T13:00:04.436769Robert BurkhardI will not visit Scotland until the Scottish Government move to conserve the wild salmon and sea trout. Netting spawning salmon is killing off, not fishing.22312015-01-03T13:01:50.6736770Keith RobertsonNetting is only one of the problems radical action needs to be taken before the scottish rivers are debunked of migratory fish.22312015-01-03T13:03:09.5336771Jeff HirstNetting contributes little to the economy and negates conservation of the salmon. Natural predators need to be controlled as well.22312015-01-03T13:03:47.4576772Nicholas Forman HardyWild salmon stocks are following a continual decline and the action of the Scottish Government not to accept the situation and to everything they can to try and protect this seriously threatened species is a disgrace and a blow to the Scottish economy in the Highlands. It is time they got their act together and behaved responsibly22312015-01-03T13:04:02.2376773sean nasonwe must do everything possible to protect future stocks.22312015-01-03T13:07:26.5636774sean nasonmy last few fishing visits to scotland have been so poor i will have to consider where to spend hard earned cash if things dont improve in a big way.22312015-01-03T13:10:54.9636775Matt HarrisThe future of local economies up and down Scotland as well as future of the wild salmon itself depends upon the Scottish government recognising that we must protect these fish by every means possible. Please recognise this and act immediately and decisively to save Scotland's wild salmon stocks before it is too late.22312015-01-03T13:15:14.226776John Richardsonmust stop all coastal netting immediately 22312015-01-03T13:16:45.9076777Gary Keys Good luck Ian Gordon, supporting you from Northern Ireland, keep up the fight. 22312015-01-03T13:26:01.7376778Jonothan CroftIs it not the time that Politicians realised that aside from the direct conservation of an endangered species, the economic benefits of Salmon conservation far out way the specific needs of nets man who can be compensated.22312015-01-03T13:27:05.6436779Jonathan EllerbeckHow long will it take to get the Scottish Government to realise the long term harm they are causing. The numbers travelling to Scotland are already dwindling. The impact on local economies, and therefore communities, will be far reaching. It's so sad to see a lack of response by those given the responsibility of leadership. 22312015-01-03T13:31:13.7376780charles auldThe combination of stopping coastal netting along with compulsory catch and release policy as seen on the Dee would transform salmon fishing in Scotland to its former glory22312015-01-03T13:44:13.5736781Christine IlesleyI would plead with the Scottish Government to safeguard and protect this wonderful wild species. Please look at what countries like Iceland and Norway have done to preserve and protect both Atlantic Salmon and the tourism associated with it. To allow netting to resume would be short term and foolish and would decimate both salmon stocks and the tourism industry. 22312015-01-03T13:52:48.5776782Mike HeapsGiven the disastrous year for salmon fishing in Scotland last season the Scottish Government must do all in its power to protect this valuable resource for the benefit of the economy22312015-01-03T13:56:51.196783Tom SterlingPlease act to protect this iconic species which is so much a part of what is the very essence of Scotland and Scotishness. Remember too, that all over the world, Scotland is perceived to be the home of salmon angling, the place where the sport was developed, so it must be in the forefront to protect this wonderful creature!22312015-01-03T14:01:19.1436784Stephen HeyKeep up the pressure!! Rod fishing is currently an underestimated economic resource if your a Salmond supporter!22312015-01-03T14:02:57.196785Noel KellyScotland should protect its treasures and The wild Salmon are such treasures22312015-01-03T14:08:03.86786Mark firthI believe Scottish Salmon to be at a tipping point. All sides must put away petty politics and unite in protecting such a precious asset, which should not be at the mercy of incompetence, petty jealousies, factional politics or intolerance. The ability and will is there to address this positively. Failure to do so will lead to condemnation of those who have the opportunity at their fingertips. There should be no sides In this debate. surely we all want the same thing. Scotland needs salmon. End of. 22312015-01-03T14:10:56.5336787Lauren KingsleyUnless netting is prohibited, the jobs, the tradition, the tourism, and the legendary sporting destinations -- will all be gone, and gone for good. Yet nothing compares to the certain loss of this magnificent wild creature that has been struggling against aquaculture and illegal netting all over the north Atlantic. Scotland, please be an example, please lead the world in smart conservation of a resource that in many ways has been part of your cultural identity. 22312015-01-03T14:26:38.3136788Robert D RichardSave the Atlantic Salmon from becoming extinct. Stop the coastal netting and help preserve a way of life.22312015-01-03T14:35:56.586789Michael BreneolAtlantic Salmon stocks are precariously low. Time to stop all commercial exploitation and angler retention.22312015-01-03T14:37:57.0976790nick pellattAs a kid growing up in Scotland i used to be taken with my Dad to watch the salmon leaping up the rivers ,it is one of the most beautiful sights from nature. These fish travel for thousands and thousands of miles across seas to spawn in the exact spot they were spawned themselves ... This is not about mans right to angle it is about preserving something that has happened for millions of years . Please give them a chance to do this for another million years the poor fish have enough to worry about with estrogen levels in the water ,pesticides ,pollutants etc etc . Thankyou and I hope you see sense on this issue and help preserve for future generations of BONNY BONNY SCOTLAND 22312015-01-03T14:49:36.2636791Geoff franks.Its obvious to anyone except it seems the Scottish Government. that all netting must cease. attention must then turn to the cleaning up of the farm salmon scandal. wekll we live in hope.22312015-01-03T14:50:47.5976792Michael DewdneyI would far rather there was a total ban on killing wild salmon throughout the season and that all fish should be returned with the exception of farmed escapees.22312015-01-03T14:57:05.2676793jondi laurence O Byrne Save our salmon, the time is now.22312015-01-03T15:05:30.7076794David CoshThe beat I fish on the west coast of scotland has dropped its average catch from 400 fish a season to 60 over the last 15 years. It is time the Scottish government got its act together or there will be no salmon left in Scotland22312015-01-03T15:09:27.0436795Jim NicholIt is u as the Scottish goverment who are killing our salmon by acting in a stupid and ignorant manor 22312015-01-03T15:13:44.256796mark hastingsI have signed this petition because across the world the home of wild salmon is Scotland - it is a natural tresure and it is a traversty that this iconic fish is under threat in its spiritual home. No kill before July will help but the Scottish government really needs to grip fish farming. Closed cages are essential otherwise juvenile fish will continue to pick up sea lice when leaving their home rivers and will then never return. Wild salmon in Scotland has its days numbered unless urgent action is taken.22312015-01-03T15:14:02.316797Bruce DoucetteThank you for allowing me to help support this petition,as an avid flyfisherman here in eastern canada we to are experiencing very low return rates to our rivers,and to help in stopping the off shore fishery is something that all governments need to examine.22312015-01-03T15:17:31.536798neil munrojust totaly agree with these measures hopefully maybe we can get back to the good old days were everyone can be happy, but that will not happen unless something is put into action22312015-01-03T15:18:50.586799George WatsonI have travelled to Scotland from the US each year since 2006. I come with from 1 to 3 companions to fish for salmon in the Highlands, staying a minimum of 2 weeks. We rent cars, stay in hotels, take our meals, pay our ghillies and for beat rentals....it gets expensive. Wild salmon are the lure that brings us here. We release the few we catch and hope that another angler will enjoy the sport of catching it later.\r\nA wild salmon is too valuable a resource to be netted and sold at the fishmonger, particularly when farmed salmon are very available.\r\nNetting these wild fish is economic suicide for Scotland. I con't understand why that is not as obvious to others as it is to me.22312015-01-03T15:20:37.6736800William ThomsonThe Scottish Government should hang their heads in shame for being the largest contributor to the demise of wild salmon stocks, particularly on the west coast of Scotland. All aspects affecting the species from netting to habitat and pollution must be addressed before it's too late.\r\n22312015-01-03T15:24:05.3776801Paul TregunnoWild Atlantic salmon are under serious threat. Urgent action is required now if future generations are going to be able to enjoy visiting Scotland to see or catch a salmon. Many local industries depend on the tourism the salmon bring to Scotland. All parties must play their part to protect and enhance existing salmon stocks, before it is too late.22312015-01-03T15:33:45.0336802Jacky Collenette If the runs have been poor for the last two seasons it makes every sense to ensure the maximum measures are in place to help re.establish a good number. This is best achieved by not fishing out what is potentially the Wild Salmon in such short supply.\r\nThis measure is a common sense approach to up the numbers which hopefully will spawn and keep the cycle alive and what a wonderful that will be.22312015-01-03T15:34:26.16803Eric Craig I fully support this petion it makes so much sense. 22312015-01-03T15:52:54.2176805Thomas ThomsonWe all need to work together to save our salmon22312015-01-03T15:53:11.1276806Peter YardleyI live just south of the border so believe that this will affect the river Tweed near me. All rivers need protection cause when the salmon are gone they are gone for good!!!!!!!!!22312015-01-03T16:05:40.0076807Brian ParkerUntil we have reached the point where we have sufficient runs of salmon up our rivers we should do as much as we can to protect them.22312015-01-03T16:19:56.1436808David DixonI love Scotland & this magnificent country will be very much the poorer in every sense if the gift of wild salmon is squandered.The relevant agencies know what needs to be done to stop exploitation & rod fishermen will play their part in carefully releasing any catches. We then need to properly address marine losses of anadromous fish.Please support Ian Gordon & the S.T.A(Scotland) in their sensible request.22312015-01-03T16:21:05.696809Nigel RowlandI have stopped visiting Scotland to fish preferring Ireland who make greater efforts to protect their salmon.22312015-01-03T16:33:15.7576810MICHAEL LEATHERthousands of jobs in Scotland are linked to the sport of salmon fishing.The vast majority of fishers are showing their support of their sport and the people employed by catch and release. For the Scottish Government not to listen to reason and therefore act in an equally positive manner is diabolical.22312015-01-03T16:34:00.276812David PorterThe nets should not be reintroduce until the fish stocks have vastly inproved . 22312015-01-03T16:35:40.1436813Joe AlexanderIt's way behind time to stop netting of any sort be it drift or fixed nets. Or will it be the same old story of politicians sitting on their hands doin nothing (again) until it's way too late when there will be nothing left to protect.22312015-01-03T16:39:30.1476814Andrew MacGregorCan anyone tell what happened to the report on salmon promised in February on opening day as response to Ian's campaign, guess data too sensitive to publish. I would certainly join any campaign or demo designed to embarrass anyone suspected of putting politics before wild salmon near Gordon in 2015 maybe? 22312015-01-03T16:43:21.1276815Eric MacdonaldI find it terribly sad that we have to organise a petition to persuade the Scottish government to protect the last wild Scottish salmon stocks.\r\nIn years to come what excuse do we give our grand children that our generation oversaw their extinction?22312015-01-03T16:47:39.9636816Sarah BarnesStop the exploitation of the wild salmon, we must act now preserve them.22312015-01-03T16:47:44.9076817Rob BrownfieldWhilst the Scottish Government tells us how important wild salmon are to tourism and the environment, they continue to contradict their own policies by extending netting seasons and quotas as well as encouraging salmon farming by Norweigen companies, telling us we need to expand farming to meet the demands of Japan. There appears to be no joined up thinking at all. I fully support a no kill policy.22312015-01-03T16:52:02.696818JEAN BARZINSAVE one of the last atlantic salmon stock .The runs are very poor everywhere in Europe.\r\n22312015-01-03T16:57:13.7976819Seamus NeeWild salmon are too valuable to be slaughtered by either nets men or anglers22312015-01-03T16:57:28.9576820Peter KeyserThe Scottish Government needs to show that it really is committed to saving the wild salmon stocks. I see few signs to date spelling disaster for rural jobs the rural economy and the health of our rivers.22312015-01-03T17:09:30.6276821James Miller RossWhy should we travel from Southern England and pay £2500 per week to catch and release wild salmon for conservation reasons when commercial nets are killing thousands of salmon with no quota controls in place. The nets will kill the Scottish salmon fishing tourist industry through pure commercial greed.22312015-01-03T17:10:20.7136822David Magill Salmon stocks everywhere are too low to contemplate any resumption of commercial netting. Mixed stock fishing is especially unacceptable for the obvious reasons accepted by Europe when formulating the salmon legislation and which persuaded the Irish government to cease drift netting 22312015-01-03T17:10:46.656823Dirk BarendregtDo not make pounds of of this living gold22312015-01-03T17:15:03.76824Willie SutherlandBeing a Ghillie for the last 10 years I have seen a steep drop in catches on the Ness in that time. My fishers are doing there bit having returned over 95% of salmon caught last year. They don't breed to well in the pot or languishing in the freezer and their survival is more important than having a tasty dinner.22312015-01-03T17:15:05.1576825Michael ColeIf this goes through what a retrograde step for salmon and conservation in general. Reduction in jobs with ghillies hotels river owners pubs tackle shop the list goes on. Short term gain LONG term loss22312015-01-03T17:20:35.2676826John GardinerIt is about time to stop the netting before its to late also a cull on the seal and goo sander population22312015-01-03T17:29:37.9276827Philip BurnhamIt is vital to control the in-river catch of Scottish salmon and to completely eliminate coastal netting of mixed stock salmon in order to preserve recreational salmon angling, which is so vital for the Scottish tourist industry22312015-01-03T17:44:47.6976828Richard JohnsonTime this practice was brought to an end! Should have happened years ago. The writing is on the wall22312015-01-03T17:48:45.4236829margaret anne evans, Bride of Yehashuah.Scotland leads in renewable energy. Please protect biodiversity and sustainable fisheries also. Thanks.22312015-01-03T17:59:44.0636830Kenneth AnnandThis petition is implying that anglers taking the odd fish for the pot are in some way responsible for the decline in Atlantic Salmon, which is nonsense. The last people we want telling us how to manage our Salmon stocks is the Scottish Government. They have, so far, shown a total disregard for wild salmon in Scotland, preferring instead to support aquaculture and netting. The fish farmers will be laughing all the way to the bank and signing this petition in droves. \r\nAny decision regarding killing salmon should be left to the individual river boards, NOT POLITICIANS who know nothing about wild salmon. \r\nThe biggest problem facing Atlantic Salmon is marine mortality, that is where attention should be directed. Not, to anglers or even netsmen, who could never make salmon extinct by their efforts, even if they wanted too.\r\nI shall NOT be signing this and would urge any thinking anglers to do the same.22312015-01-03T18:05:47.3476831david edward alan jonesPlease, please think before you permit the netting of wild salmon, particularly the spring fish. The rod anglers who visit Scotland every year, quite often three and four time in a season have all accepted and embraced catch and release. It would be an unmitigated disaster for the Scottish Government to allow netting again after such a long period. If we were talking about elephants, tigers and the like there would be an outcry. Please think again, don't have the demise of this wonderful wild creature on your hands for ever and a day.22312015-01-03T18:16:02.866832James Duffy The Scottish Government has persistently ignored all conservation measures self imposed by the angling fraternity and chosen to encourage coastal netting and fish farming without concern for wild salmon it's time it changed its attitude to conservation. 22312015-01-03T18:22:15.3476833Charles RatcliffeGive our migratory fish a chance22312015-01-03T18:24:32.556834James Duffy The Scottish Government has persistently ignored all conservation measures self imposed by the angling fraternity and chosen to encourage coastal netting and fish farming without concern for wild salmon it's time it changed its attitude to conservation. 22312015-01-03T18:28:42.056835DCM BlackburnIt is much better for the Scottish economy if rod fishing is preserved22312015-01-03T18:51:16.6436836David MairSOS (Save Our Salmon)!22312015-01-03T19:02:24.4576837Paul ClancyWe produce great standard farmed salmon,which carried out correctly will not damage the environment. Wild Atlantic Salmon have enough challenges to face with out this highly efficient method of fishing still being permitted22312015-01-03T19:26:24.0176838Michael smithmetting is a disgrace22312015-01-03T19:40:30.5636839Francis M B PalmerSomething needs to be further done to decrease the growth of Salmon farms, especially on the West coast. They destroy the fauna, and there is NO natural regeneration. I'm sure that you know the arguments.22312015-01-03T19:42:57.8376840behier guillaumeil faut dire stop aux carnages..........\r\nI must say to stop the bloodshed22312015-01-03T19:43:04.0636841Richard PersseHas my entry counted as a SIGNATURE?\r\nThere is no signing box!22312015-01-03T19:50:41.5176842Richard ThomlinsonThe farming of Salmon - and thereby sea-lice - in open sea cages is doing enormous damage to the wild salmon stocks on which the Salmon-angling tourist industry depends. Please move to compulsory closed-containment salmon farming ASAP. BTW, in case you are wondering, I write this as a carpenter, not a CEO!22312015-01-03T20:00:05.2736843Gerald SpiersWhen will common sense prevail from our government regarding wild fish management. 22312015-01-03T20:22:34.5476844Michael ReidDestroy the fish and you destroy many people's living22312015-01-03T20:30:24.8776846Allan DallasWe need to preserve the salmon stocks for future generations and secure employment. Farmed salmon satisfies the market requirements for fresh salmon. With the price of Salmon being cheaper that Haddock nowadays I don't understand where the market is for net caught fish.22312015-01-03T20:39:19.2836847David HardieIts a pity there weren't more MSP's that were Salmon Anglers22312015-01-03T20:50:33.4636848paul reayHope this gets sorted22312015-01-03T20:55:42.456849Robert FisherSalmon stocks must be protected for long term future22312015-01-03T21:46:50.5236850Alistair A KainIf we don't conserve the existing stock of Spring salmon by stopping netting on rivers and on estuaries over the next decade and allow these fish to spawn and replenish the stocks in our rivers then salmon fishing in Scottish rivers will be a thing of the past. Therefore Scotland will loose a resource and the Tourist Industry will suffer through many jobs being made redundant. Surely the Scottish Government would not wish further job losses just because a few netsmen cannot fish before 1stJuly and many people in the Tourist Industry will loose their livelihood because people will cease to come to Scotland to fish for Spring salmon in our rivers. Is it the policy of the Scottish Government that the few hold the many to ransom, if it is in this case Salmon Angling in Scottish Waters will no longer exist.\r\n22312015-01-03T21:53:35.6576851Peter Michael MaherMy wife and I were going to visit Scotland this year but I may rethink our trip if the Government is not forward thinking enough to ban the netting of Atlantic Salmon22312015-01-03T21:59:09.2076852Dr. Colin HowardTime is running out22312015-01-03T22:01:07.8476853Alan GreigThe Scottish Government must act decisively now to support this petition. It must also act decisively going forwards to protect what is an increasingly threatened resource. 22312015-01-03T22:17:13.986854Antony HoareI agree with the catch and release sentiments. Every River should do it and it has proven to be successful. However, the last two years............Global warming? Trawling? Netting?22312015-01-03T22:21:17.5636855David JonesAs someone who organises an annual weeks salmon fishing for a party of 10. We are concerned at the decline in fish numbers. In part this can be put down to exploititive netting. If our party is representative, we bring in at least £5k to your economy. This is at risk if we haave a repeat this season of the previous 2.22312015-01-03T22:33:15.696856Raymond PlourdeThe Scotish government should ban the net killing of all wild salmon - period and full-stop. Anglers should also be required to release all angled wild salmon - zero retention - until such a time as wild stocks have greatly recovered. To do less is condemnt the wild Scotish salmon to extinction. Smarten up!22312015-01-03T22:33:25.7676857Ronald McQueenThe Scottish Government should be ashamed of the way they have managing this wonderful resource by allowing these infested fish farms to operate in Scottish waters . The Norwegian owner and government have closed there own fish farms because of the problems to the salmon rivers. One just has to look at the problems in Chile the sea bed is completely void of life in vast areas and our coast line is going very quickly the same way.\r\nThe Scotish economy could make more with jobs fom anglers. The netting is just another nail in the coffin for the poor salmon.\r\n I hope that our New First Minister will see the light and change direction as it is not to late .\r\n For the sake of our rivers, the salmon and seatrout please think again!22312015-01-03T22:34:55.1136858Ian c arthurGet your finger out and save what's left of our salmon befor it's to late.22312015-01-03T22:41:54.5036859Ronnie PickenThe problems are well known, enough procrastination, time for a honest well thought through solution and get the job done properly this time.22312015-01-03T23:06:07.946860Laurent chevrotThe scottich government must stop immediately the fishing with net for protect the salmon run the next year the run was poor and it's necessary to take a measure for a good protection and preserve the fishing tourism in Scotland 22312015-01-03T23:09:02.7276861ian mallaghanscotland would be a far less place if these\r\nsilver summer visitors became\r\n extinct by a goverment who thinks nothing for the wellfair of this natural resourse only as a income \r\n by ofshore netting or salmon farms they should be held to account for what is going on and no way get away with this in2015\r\nthese wild salmon belong to future generations\r\nand we should do our best to protect them for the good of scotland and every other river that atlantic salmon run22312015-01-03T23:45:53.3976862Mark fortuneStopping the killing of early salmon I feel is essential if we wish to save the species. However, this is only the willfull killing of salmon. The Scottish government must take note of the mounting scientific evidence regarding the damage being inflicted by aquaculture otherwise our salmon will become extinct.22312015-01-03T23:45:56.9136863Elaine haywardHaving had 2 very poor years fishing for Salmon in Scotland it's now time to conserve stocks or we will spend our money else where !! 22312015-01-03T23:47:31.866864John R WhitfieldWithout control of the netting and habitat wild salmon will not exist in Scottish rivers and I for one see no point in paying to fish in rivers with no fish. I will take my business to a more welcoming country. 22312015-01-03T23:54:14.6676865Keith OatesThe reintroduction of netting will be a step backward for Scotland.It is against conservation principles and will result in job losses and economic decline in those areas of population adjacent to and dependent o visitors to rivers.22312015-01-03T23:54:16.6676866Dave DickThis appears to be a serious situation across the whole of the North Atlantic....political pressure needs to be brought urgently against those fishermen currently trawling salmon on their wintering grounds off Greenland and the Faeroes..in addition to the moratorium on rods and nets mentioned here.22312015-01-04T00:20:14.8136867iain marshallcoastal net fishermen need to make a living as much as the estate or beat owner of a river and to take away their livelihood without some sort of compensation Is wrong, in order to protect others livelihoods .If the truth be told some of the dearest beats on the river Tay do not adear to the Tay fisheries board regulations with total disregard as money is at stake, I do however support the protection of salmon stocks in Scotland and perhaps an amount of tags per angler per season would be appropriate.22312015-01-04T00:50:31.116868Siegfried DarschnikSotland is such a beautiful country which so much potetial for tourism angling, but sadly as well with too man people neither recognizing that beauty nor that potential and politicians still going the old industrial paths of more, more, more ..... no matter what22312015-01-04T01:22:35.726870Roger GreavesWe must respect animals.22312015-01-04T02:17:43.0636871Mr Greer Hart, seniorI am deeply concerned about the depletion of natural resources such as fish stocks, and in this case wild salmon in Scottish waters. A new attitude has to be adopted with regard to the commercial and sporting sides of using salmon. A thorough policy of conservation should be enforced. Future generations will have a valuable resource protected for them.22312015-01-04T03:31:47.86872James GreenSometimes hard decisions need to be made, and this is one of them. Preserving these fish is essential, not only to the recreational angling world, but also to the commercial netters, whose livelihood, whether they are prepared to believe it or not, is drying up too.22312015-01-04T07:11:15.0836874Lloyd GarvieThere seems little point killing wild sea trout and salmon for the price of their meat, when rod caught they are worth many, many multiples of that value. Add to that their declining numbers, and the Scottish Government's apparent support for netting is both perverse and wasteful.22312015-01-04T07:13:36.0336875Margit Steidlfishing the salmon youngsters in spring time will certainly extinguish these animals!22312015-01-04T08:49:11.866876Phil WildeI have given up my timeshare on the Tay and stopped regular trips to Dunkeld, Kelso and the west coast as the fishing is no longer reliable enough to justify the expense. I would return if I felt the Scottish government were approaching the problem in a proper joined up way.22312015-01-04T09:00:11.4576877Mike RollinsonThe Atlantic Salmon are an indicator species and their slow demise in rivers across the country reflects very poorly on our stewardship. As the multi sea winter fish return first, this petition for a ban on their killing before 1st July will allow these biggest fish, carrying the largest amounts of eggs and milt, the best opportunity to make the spawning reds and reverse this trend. Please make it happen.22312015-01-04T09:09:57.2076878Graeme ProudHow many more species are we going to allow man to destroy. Wild Atlantic salmon are one of our most unique species which provide a lot of opportunities to tourism.22312015-01-04T09:33:43.9876879Julian SheppardHaving fished the River Lochy for a number of years I have decided to fish elsewhere where fish are more plentiful and although I love the highlands years of fishing with no results by my friends and I have left us feeling that going to Scotland is a waste of time. If they are now going to start netting Salmon again I will never go back and invest my money in the local economy.\r\n\r\nThe Scottish parliament must be crazy.22312015-01-04T09:48:40.8136880Richard PeckWithout action by the Scottish Government a complete culture will be terminated irrevocably22312015-01-04T10:16:42.2836881D.A.Brown Coastal netting should not be reintroduced , do the powers that be realize what the loss of salmon angling would have on the Scottish tourism\r\n22312015-01-04T10:19:51.3636882adrian mcloughlinThere is plenty of waste already. we over fish as it is.22312015-01-04T10:32:10.0276883Guy Crawfordplease convince our politicians to help conserve stocks of wild salmon22312015-01-04T10:34:15.4336884Peter Rowland SmithI fully support the proposal by Ian Gordon to stop netting of Salmon and Seatrout. This should apply to all migratory fish rivers in the UK.22312015-01-04T10:36:22.1836885Tim HicksMy grandmother Isobel Mc Bride of Bute would be horrified to see the complete lack of responsibility in conservation of atlantic Salmon. one of Scotland's finest resources and an integral indice of the nations environmental wellbeing. I call upon the scottish parliament to do it's duty and take every step possible at home and internationally to bring this unique and threatened species back from the brink of extinction and into a state of burgeoning stocks for the future generations of Scotland to benefit from.22312015-01-04T11:00:40.2536886Jan PoulsenAs a Country with wild salmon on the run, you as a government should feel obliged to reassure this magnificent specimen of a fish, will survive in the future. The only way to do so is to guarantee the salmon freedom of way towards and into the Scottish rivers.22312015-01-04T11:07:17.6736887Robert FinneyHi Ian .Have you watched the video called salmon confidential on U tube .It paints a pretty gloomy picture for all wild salmon stocks. I would be very interested on your thoughts22312015-01-04T11:15:32.336888John D StandevenUnfortunately I feel the Scottish government is more motivated by the macho image they would like to generate for themselves, fuelled by the drive for Nationalism, and their dislike for rod fishermen, (especially those from south of a line drawn on a map) rather than on the cold empirical evidence that any scientific research will produce22312015-01-04T11:25:07.6936889Tom HalpinWe need decades more for wild fish populations to replenish themselves before net fishing and trawling can be allowed to resume - if ever!22312015-01-04T11:40:25.176890Mike DavisonCatch and release is vitally important for the protection and conservation of fish stocks. Salmon and Sea trout fishing is an important part of my life and I would like to believe that we could ensure that our future generations could experience this fine sport.22312015-01-04T12:06:10.5536891Jonathan MeyerAs a regular visitor to the Scottish borders I speak the local businesses and in particular the grilles, whose livelihood is endangered by this policy. For the sake of the local Scottish economy it is urgent that this policy is reviewed and dropped.22312015-01-04T12:17:17.756892John PearsA river caught fish is many many times more valuable to the local and national economy than a net caught fish. 22312015-01-04T12:24:33.0176893Dennis Greenerthe time past long ago for mandatory catch and relese, its time to stop knocking salmon on the head and maybe knocking a few politicians on the head to maybe see some sense of the situation: Anybody not in favour of 100% catch and realese are better off not fishing the rivers to the benefit of the Fish and the rivers. 22312015-01-04T12:31:29.7536894John BrownlieNo action, No fish, No anglers, No jobs. The rural economy facing disaster.22312015-01-04T12:59:49.2676895Mike ParkerFish stocks and the marine environment are so fragile, people need to understand the massive impact we are having on them on a global scale. This is one step to show that you understand and are doing something about it.22312015-01-04T13:24:09.0976896john gorehamA lot of the tourist trade relies on revenue from salmon fishermen which is already suffering from declining stocks. Although I much prefer Scotland I like many other fishermen will think strongly about fishing in Scandinavian countries that offer much better chances of catching fish which is what we pay for, which is a shame as Scotland has so much more to offer.22312015-01-04T13:45:44.5876897Ron moorePlease preserve your assets before it's to late22312015-01-04T14:05:22.0336898David higgsPeople should restrict themselves to eating farmed Salmon for at least the next five years, it wont hurt them and will help Salmon conservation.22312015-01-04T14:21:16.9076899Jean-Yves Simonno protection means no wild salmo salar anymore anywhere that's simply it22312015-01-04T14:30:02.336900Denis Halstead.As usual the sport fishing fraternity are bending over backwards to try to correct the destructive do not care attitude of Politicians. The damage is done at sea, lack of adult salmon on the feeding grounds produces opportunities for other species to consume the surplus food with the result of an ever decreasing supply for the salmon and consequently fewer and fewer salmon returning. This has happened with COD on the Grand Banks of Nova Scotia. The only hope for the Atlantic Salmon is to send more fish to the feeding grounds or we will lose them altogether.22312015-01-04T15:11:33.7076901Richard KingstonThe Scottish Government should stop all coastal netting immediately and make all rod and line Salmon fishing "catch and release". the Scottish Government should also insist that all salmon farming moves to onshore closed containment farming, thereby stopping the infestation and decimation of wild fish stocks. Finally, rod and line fishing on a Sunday should be allowed. The combination of all of the above would have a massive positive impact on fishing tourism in Scotland.22312015-01-04T15:27:17.8136902Peter KeelingIt is a scandal that there is still netting of salmon anywhere off our coast. The species has seen year on year decline and soon there will be no fish left to catch other than farmed. I have this year decided not to return to fish the Dee as stocks are so poor on that river now and the cost keeps on going up despite the problems. The industry is in its death throes and it is folly to think otherwise.22312015-01-04T15:53:18.9436903Gerard WattsRegardless of sporting activity, the very survival of the Atlantic Salmon is at great risk without urgent action.22312015-01-04T16:12:25.666904Laurent BonetatI think that I wouldn't come back to Scotland for salmon fishing if nothing is really done to save wild scottish salmon. The scottish government should prove that he wants to save one of most inconic scott's animals. 22312015-01-04T16:22:29.3836905Michael MartinThe fish farms have decimated the Salmon stocks and the resumption of netting will further add to the salmons decline so if you wish to have a future fishing tourist industry stop any moves to reopen any netting and move all the salmon cages from all river with a run of sea trout or salmon Catch and release can help but only it it is strictly enforced and that is not always the case due to lack of manpower within the enforcing bodies.A total ban on all rod caught fish and a tagging system as we have in Ireland can hinder the poachers considerably and massive fines for any one purchasing illegally caught fish can reduce the outlet for poachers to cash in..Proper river enhancement and a genetic stocking programe can work wonders on rivers where populations are threatened with extinction.22312015-01-04T16:51:07.3976906Alan SmithI cannot imagine the reasons for this lack of\r\njoined up thinking by Government.\r\nThe Welsh Parliament have made a similarly ludicrous decision and are allowing double tide\r\nnetting whilst exhorting anglers to return all fish.\r\nYou couldn't make it up!!! 22312015-01-04T17:25:04.2136907PJ LewisA limited period catch-and-release is a sensible precaution and ending netting for good is sound economic sense given the far higher value of rod caught fish relative to netted fish. But these measures should be accompanied by longer term measures to increase, not reduce the powers of those who know how to run Scottish Angling, which isn't Holyrood. 22312015-01-04T18:22:59.0476908Derek WofindenHaving seen salmon catch rates decline on Scotland's rivers, if Scotland's Parliament need to take drastic action sooner rather than later.22312015-01-04T19:42:28.5576909Francis Mildmay-WhiteThe wild salmon stock situation in Scotland is extremely concerning. The government needs to take action immediately before it is too late. 22312015-01-04T20:16:11.3536910Robert GarnettAll mixed stock netting stations and estuary netting stations should be closed until salmon make a sustainable recovery in all rivers in the UK.22312015-01-04T20:58:40.466911William de BurghIt just makes common sense. Without the ability to come back to the river to spawn there will be no future salmon. The species becomes extinct river by river. So please be smart and prevent all netting of salmon returning to the rivers.22312015-01-05T04:58:32.876912Packie Mc DermottScotland without Salmon,is 100 times worse than Scotland without it's Whiskey 22312015-01-05T06:18:02.336913PEYROT FrancisThanks, Ian, for your implacation.22312015-01-05T07:27:45.4876914Steen MortensenKeep up the good work in fighting agains netting for wild salmon and seatrouts. Live and wild salmon in the rivers is by far the best for all Scotsmen an brings value to you Country. 22312015-01-05T07:48:28.2536915david peasesalmon fishing provides such a source of income to Strath Glass. It would be a severe blow to so many people our catches continue to decline.22312015-01-05T07:52:34.236916Jim BumbyNetting is devastating our wild fish stocks. In 2013 the North east MSF nets killed more than 16000 salmon and 40000 sea trout, this is more than the recorded number of fish that run the Tees, Wear, Tyne and Cocquet in total! This can't be right. Many of these fish would also be destined for Scottish rivers. Consequently anything that can be done to reduce, and ideally remove, the threat netting poses to our wild fish stocks along both the Scottish and English Coast has my full support.22312015-01-05T09:21:14.7376917GRAHAM SALISBURYScotish Government has to regognise the true value of salmon angling to the Scotish economy 160 million PA and the hundreds of jobs it supports. How can it justify netting and a handful of seasonal jobs it needs to get its act together and quickly, we have booked no trips back to Scotland this year and are looking further afield. 22312015-01-05T09:23:08.366918Richard BrownAlthough I live in North Wales I fish in Scotland hence my signature on a Scottish issue.22312015-01-05T09:42:22.7676919Marcus LidsterThe stopping of all coastal netting will help the long term viability of the salmon rod fishing tourist industry. I also stopped holiday fishing in Scotland due to unreliable particularly sea trout fishing.22312015-01-05T09:59:42.7076920Nick WinterSalmon numbers are very low and this measure would surely help. Anglers are eternally optimistic, but if there really is no hope of catching a Scottish salmon, anglers won't come and that will be a huge loss to the Scottish tourism industry. I may not be typical but in my experience each rod-caught salmon must be worth at least 500-1000 pounds to the Scottish economy, and many or most are returned. Apart form the moral imperative to conserve these magnificent fish, even in narrow accounting terms it surely must be a no brainer.22312015-01-05T10:19:35.86921chris SutcliffeI seem to catch less and less fish (salmon and sea trout) year on year.\r\nMy visits to the rivers of Scotland as a result have diminished over time.\r\nI am concerned for the future of both salmon and sea trout - why should I bother going to Scotland if it appears that the Scottish Government is not bothered?22312015-01-05T10:20:06.7676922Michael Charles Gordon-LennoxThe petition as drafted must make sense22312015-01-05T10:27:13.866923Alan JonesIt may already be too late to stop the netting, but it is worth the effort to try and prevent all netting around our coasts and then to target other EU and North Atlantic Ocean offenders. Support the cause!22312015-01-05T10:29:49.9936924Alan JonesIn addition to the action on netting and rod catches, it is time that the EU and the Scottish government acted to reduce the number of seals around our coasts. It is only a matter of time that they will start to starve to death due to the lack of fish stocks.22312015-01-05T10:46:09.5176925Hans van Manen Absolutely right to organise this petition, salmon stocks are worldwide endangered. I come from the Netherlands, salmon is extinct there and it use to be widespread!!! 22312015-01-05T11:22:24.4236926Alfred George PopeAs a riparian owner I am extremely concerned about Salmon Stocks. I believe in 100% Catch and Release and the moving of all farmed salmon cages to land based farms. All Scottish netting must be banned until stocks recover. Also there must be a thorough checking of the by catch of pelagic trawlers.22312015-01-05T11:29:59.236927Alison AlstonOur wild Scottish Salmon are a precious and valuable resource that must be put before politics.\r\nTo not do everything to protect them is to let down Scotland's future. 22312015-01-05T12:50:26.0036928David HanburyI have at least 3 fisherman friends who go to Scotland every year to fly-fish for salmon. They are beginning to think seriously about not going in future, as the stock of salmon has sunk to such low levels. Hotels, ghillies, etc, will therefore lose much revenue.22312015-01-05T14:10:00.9036929Christopher EdmondsonIt is nothing short of a tragedy what has been done to the salmon.22312015-01-05T16:51:56.796930Jeremy SharpOne successful spawning gives rise to thousands of new potential fish. Why deplete already low stocks by netting?22312015-01-05T16:53:41.0576931Peter BroganTo avoid the future extinction of indigenous Wild Atlantic Salmon borne from Scottish Rivers, please put a stop to indiscriminate netting !22312015-01-05T17:10:02.2136932David CrawshawWhy when the Spring and early Summer run is almost non existent did you go for a 1st July date. The bulk of the run is after this date. I would have supported a date of one month later. The Dee "catch and release" of the last fifteen years has shown that even a total catch ban on a river has not been the answer. A look at their returns for the last five years shows that the problem is not with the angler but elsewhere, but the one who is paying the price in this new legislation.22312015-01-05T18:28:05.6836933Iain McKinnonI believe that in those straitened times, it behoves all local authorities to ensure that all unpaid Poll and Council taxes are collected. There are three prime reasons I believe for this...1) The tax avoider will have already benefited from the local authority services provided. 2) It is equitable as other residents will have already paid. 3) It is part of being a responsible member of the community. And if you want the right to vote, then surely part of that privilege is paying your just dues. 21912015-01-05T18:33:51.4936934Jean-Paul JaverzatIn the Dordogne river (France) we lost our last wild salmon decades ago. Efforts to re-introduce salmon from other rivers have failed. I've spent some time in Scotland: beautiful and friendly. It would not be exactly the same anymore if you were loosing your Salmon. Please protect your Salmon!!!22312015-01-05T18:54:34.8536936Jee Yul YoonI can't believe salmon industry trying to whitewash wild stock extinction. It acts like species and ecosystems unimportant and farming salmon are much better than sustainable harvests of wild populations. The nefarious fact twisting is disgraceful.22312015-01-05T18:56:00.2736937Guy HollisUsed to visit Scotland regulalrly to fish - seldom go now as salmon stocks have been destroyed by total lack of understanding and miss management by the Scottish Governemnt . They don't seem to understand their own country and what makes it function outside Glasgow and Edinburgh ! Oil is not the only natural resource! 22312015-01-05T18:58:30.1976938Kirsty ClarkI whole heartedly agree that under NO circumstances should the outstanding poll tax debt be written off - if it should be it is nothing but a big fat slap in the face to hard working, law abiding citizens. Should they write off the poll tax debt do they plan on reimbursing (in full) the people that actually paid this?! 21912015-01-05T19:06:47.9336939James Edwards I fish Scotland each year for Salmon, last year (2014) was perhaps the worst ever with hardly any spring fish showing, it is inconcievable that netting is allowed, especially when the angler is not even allowed to take just 1 fish. 22312015-01-05T19:29:33.376940Niall RiddellHow can we expect other countries not to net Scottish salmon, if we cannot put our own house in order22312015-01-05T19:41:01.6036941Michael LynchThe most amazing fish on this country, it is education needed not nets. The Wild Salmon are not ours to take, we must nurture them and look after them. That is our responsibility not netting them at river mouths or sea.22312015-01-05T20:22:57.5976942olivier allaisWith the end of wild salmon I look sadly at my trips in scotland and probably put an end to these ...22312015-01-05T20:46:46.4376943Daniel Hoda, SwitzerlandIn Switzerland, the Atlantic Salmon was elected as the fish of the year 2015. This is bad because only endengered species will be nominated for this election. One reason for the tragedy see Atlantic Salmon Documentary - Salmon Farms in Canada & Diseased Salmon - on youtube.\r\nIt is time to think about a lot of things to help this beautiful fish and his Pacific brothers to survive. I hope my sons and grandsons will have the opportunity to fly fish for the Atlantic Salmon too. Tight lines.22312015-01-05T21:31:39.5576944Matthias UphuesWild salmons are too valueable just to eat. Take your time and go fishing for one yourself! Enjoy nature! Best regards.22312015-01-05T22:01:54.8376945Dr Tom GibsonIt is very sad that Spring Salmon have almost vanished within my lifetime22312015-01-05T22:30:04.6036946John Noel HulmstonIt is vital that commercial fishing interests are not permitted to destroy game fishing. In Wales tourist fishing is worth over £150 million per annum - Scotland far more. Without a tourist trade many more jobs upon which many local folk rely for to make a living will be endangered. I, for my part, would not be able to bring fishermen to Scotland. No salmon in the rivers means no visiting fishermen!22312015-01-05T22:39:33.766947Stuart RobertsonWe need to preserve stocks for future generations, so that they can experience catching wild salmon in Scotland. 22312015-01-06T03:42:50.4476948Priscilla JuddIf you want to save wild salmon, make the fish farms move their net pens on land or far far out to sea. Stop feeding wild fish to the farmed fish because farmed fish are depleting wild fish. Where ever fish farms are located near wild salmon - the wild salmon perish. Look at BC, Canada. Look at Norway. Save wild salmon for future generations to enjoy. Fish farming does not own the ocean - we all share this planet. 22312015-01-06T05:04:25.0576949Paul C BoyleThe scottish national party has had no issue in passing continual trivial and unnecessary legislation to interfere in all aspects of individuals life and freedoms but are unwilling to pass any legislation which would have a overwhelming impact on the country's dwindling iconic sporting fish and it's far reaching and considerable economic benefits. 22312015-01-06T09:45:56.7236950Angus JohnstonIf anglers are asked to return fish then it is just common sense there should be no nets on rivers and a far harder control of trawlers if not then we are just flogging a dead salmon excuse the pun !!22312015-01-06T10:17:05.7076951Mike WillsThere is no doubt salmon numbers are desperately low and the consequences of doing nothing are unthinkable both in terms of the long term survival of the species in our waters and also the dire economic impact it will have if we fail to prevent this demise. 22312015-01-06T11:16:08.3676952Edward Byam-CookThe Scottish people are shooting themselves in the foot if they consider allowing netting of wild slamon to restart. The revenue for Scotland from Sporting fishing is far more than people realize, and it would be so easy to loose it for ever.We must all be sustainable and husband the countries scarce resources.22312015-01-06T12:24:38.166954John TullettNetting is no longer a thing that is needed nor required, there is plenty of farmed salmon with all the so called friendly Salmon Farms around doing NO harm. Economic benefits of a net caught Salmon against a river caught Salmon - doesn't take a member of Parliament to work it out or does IT ?? unless it's not their constituency22312015-01-06T14:07:31.326955Albert Donven, President , Club Saumon LuxembourgHow can the Scottish Executive be so foolish to kill\r\nthe "bird with the golden eggs" re. the salmon in Scotland ?22312015-01-06T14:34:05.7376956JOHN SIMPSONThe wild salmon needs protection\r\ncontinued high seas and coastal netting should cease asap.22312015-01-06T18:00:28.3176957Pat Kennedy Stop netting of salmon 22312015-01-06T18:05:54.8476958Beth MorrisonDisabled children are the most vulnerable and fragile in our society. Very often children with disabilities have great difficulty in communicating, many have no verbal language. The only way that our children can communicate their needs. For example I am hungry,thirsty,too hot,too cold,feel ill or in pain is through their behaviour. If staff ignore this, the child gets frustrated and all too often the response is to restrain, hold down or manhandle the child in order to control the behaviour. Sometimes, these little ones are pulled along or dragged by staff and thrown in alone to cool down rooms which are very often bare cell like rooms where they are left to cry or until the behaviour stops. The child's needs go unmet and often, as a result of the staff response, the child suffers bruising, scratches or other injuries. This is completely unacceptable. There is a difference between a disabled child having a sensory meltdown or resorting to behaviour due to communication difficulties and a typically developing child who understands what they are doing and are deemed in control of their behaviour. Sometimes mobile disabled children are restrained for extended periods in wheelchairs for staff convenience. These responses by staff are at best due to poor understanding or training, but very often used to punish disabled children and there is no accountability when this happens. We need to make sure that this barbaric practise is subject to very strict guidelines which are adhered to by staff. If they do not adhere, they must be held accountable. You cannot punish disability out of a child.22362015-01-06T18:44:46.36959Brian WittenWild salmon need to be protected, not netted. And watching them leap is a big tourist attraction.22312015-01-06T19:07:33.9776960Peter Morrison"This Government's ambition is for Scotland to become the best place in the world for a child to grow up. Recognising, respecting and promoting rights is essential if we are to make that vision a reality. This means making practical changes in order to ensure that children experience their rights on a day to day basis." Source www.scotland.gov.uk. Supporting this petition is the chance for the Scottish government to put their words into action and show that they are not empty rhetoric. 22362015-01-06T19:16:37.426962louise thomasThis is shocking22362015-01-06T19:18:53.1436963Linda shaw Absalutey a disgrace 22362015-01-06T19:29:32.9876964Lara AllanAll children should be treated fairly, equally given same opportunities have freedom, fun and given encouragement. Restraining and hard discipline is simply not acceptable. 22362015-01-06T19:33:55.3476965Lara AllanTreat all children with respect and dignity with no restraint stop restraining practices now.22362015-01-06T19:40:03.946966Gordon ClappertonAll netting of wild salmon needs to stop immediately to ensure the future existence of this species22312015-01-06T19:57:32.1136967Paige Morrison Stop Restraint on innocent disabled children22362015-01-06T20:03:48.2536968Bradley Jago Please support this petition!22362015-01-06T20:14:42.6336969Leeanne MacGregor Good luck with this xxx22362015-01-06T20:17:53.026970Jean Milligan No child should have to go through this22362015-01-06T20:18:08.4476971Roberto FraschettiI hope that the Scottish Governement approve the terms on July 1 for Net catch 22312015-01-06T20:26:06.6376972m brankinabout time these kids where protected what on gods earth give people the right to bruise kids like this if it was parents we would be charged what makes teachers any different they disabled kids not animals and deserve to be treated with respect and love xx22362015-01-06T20:26:34.2476973Siobhan ThomsonNo child should be restrained and definitely not restrained to the point where injury has occurred.22362015-01-06T21:11:44.7836975Denise vannetI have signed the petition as I have nephew who attends school & I am horrified at the thought of any kind of mistreatment too any child!!!!! These mums & dads are putting there kids into a place of what they hope is. Safe environment & going by the amount of stories press coverage this matter has gotten over the past while I feel the need too sign in the hope that things are looked into properly & that no kids are at risk at anytime & they recurve the best treatment as possible.22362015-01-06T21:13:12.166976Mrs Tamara Cudmore This needs to change there is no need of treating Children like this it is wrong .As parents aint allowed to treat children like this so it doesn't give teachers and helpers the right to do it .22362015-01-06T21:17:33.3636978annmarie russellthis shouldn't happen to any child 22362015-01-06T21:22:46.1376979Mandy FlemingAs a manager in the care sector, I understand that parents and families of those entrusted to us require a transparent service for their family member.\r\nHaving worked with adults who can challenge, bearing in mind, there is a reason for the behaviour, staff must be not only trained, but a review of their training undertaken. Lead people involved in managing teams of staff must also have an understanding of those being supported by their teams.\r\nHave we learnt nothing from Winterbourne, why are we allowing the abuse of any person that requires help in whatever form to continue.\r\nWould any decent parents happily stand back and not ask questions at the highest level should their loved one show any sign of abuse.\r\nThis petition should be heard at the highest level..22362015-01-06T21:55:29.3376980susan hughesdisgusting behaviour and shouldn't be allowed to happen to our children22362015-01-06T22:05:50.9876981Thomas cochranePlease only use properly trained people. 22362015-01-06T22:10:27.8176982Linda mcgregor. This is unacceptable, hopefully enough signatures to make it stop!22362015-01-06T22:11:38.496983Ally Dickson this is a form of bullying and must stop. End of...22362015-01-06T22:15:42.1476984Mrs Heather KnightI really urgevyou to take actiin and stop this kind of treatment to people, Next time one might not be so lucky, they could end up dead22362015-01-06T22:30:20.9976985Julie EllisonI'm truly stunned as a teacher in the UK that teachers and carers are allowed to 'handle' children without training. I have seen evidence that many children are being handled incorrectly causing unnecessary bodily harm. Please get people trained properly.....no training no handling. 22362015-01-06T22:39:55.9376987ellen pinkowskiStop this now 22362015-01-06T22:45:30.3476988sandra BurkeThis is totally unacceptable how dare a teacher do this to any child but to hurt a disabled child like this is disgusting. 22362015-01-06T22:47:53.1136990Paula ogilvieGet this stopped now, sickening. I on occasion have to use safe holds in my job but we are all fully trained and this is used as the last option and avoided if can be22362015-01-06T23:08:09.7176992Stephen Cardownie This needs to be addressed, these kids need help and encouragement not trauma22362015-01-06T23:11:13.1876993kim MacFarlaneitd an absolute disgrace that our children are meant to be in the "care" of these people yet there is no "care" going on...children with learning difficulties or disabilities need love, care and attention, not rstraint or abuse...this has got to stop...it is no more than bullying and that is not tolerated in everyday life...do something now!!!!22362015-01-06T23:15:29.36995Maria Manningif this is true, then it is barbaric and should be stopped immediately.22362015-01-06T23:16:22.696996Diane Cathcartwhy are we treating our children in this way?\r\nWhy is the government allowing this ?22362015-01-06T23:19:19.9276997Ian JonesProtect our wild Salmon now before they are all gone and lost forever.22312015-01-06T23:29:19.576999jane brownLong overdue ...would like to see statement of skill retention included.22362015-01-06T23:45:56.177001Mary L BentonEvery child matters, every child is precious and every childs needs to be protected. They are our future. Guide them, teach them, love them.22362015-01-06T23:53:31.9837002ivancohenplease stop restraint on kids22362015-01-07T00:49:10.57004louise rankinethis is barbaric and cannot be acceptable.i cried when i read it.22362015-01-07T01:53:16.8877005James Russell it should be stopped right now teachers and carers no longer have the right too abuse children in this way no more capital punishment was fased out yes ago when they got rid of the cain 22362015-01-07T04:21:43.3577006Craig Marshall This is a disgrace in this day and age22362015-01-07T05:49:15.3777007louie beard beaneyThat is disgusting thay have no right to tuch your child that is abuse i wudont let them do that to my child all thay are showing is bullying children makes me feel sick poor little children must be ferfihd .x22362015-01-07T05:50:48.627008Suzanne trainer some times a child being restrained can prevent them from hurting themselves but when responsible adults as abusing the right to restrain it needs to be removed 22362015-01-07T06:58:44.7877010Rupert LongsdonCommon sense must prevail here. Salmon is one of the treasures of Scotland and must be looked after. Have these people learnt nothing? I am staggered this is even being discussed. Is it not "Scotland forever" that people chant about not "Scotland just for today"22312015-01-07T07:42:18.0777011Angela Kerr When I was in Primary school, my headmaster wanted to put me into the local school for people with disabilities, my mum told him no & it was all because I have epilepsy, sometimes Scottish education sucks x22362015-01-07T08:50:20.057013karen simpsonSurely teachers and carers working in a schlol enviroment for disabled children should be trained to communicate with the child before using any form of restraint.22362015-01-07T08:53:27.5037014andy thomson Shocking treatment to a kid id want justice if it was my kid 22362015-01-07T09:23:05.437015Shona Mcgregor absolute disgrace, hurting people like this, young or old!!!22362015-01-07T10:01:22.5437016shirley websterthat's total disgusting how can any teacher do that to any child see if a teacher did that to my child i'd sue them & the school as this is child abuse in my eye's.22362015-01-07T10:05:07.5137018Janette MccubbinI think it's sick that disabled children or adults should be restraind like this22362015-01-07T10:16:27.5737019AmandA SmithKids should fl safe at school not bullied by members of staff its dusgusting and heart breaking in neads to stop 22362015-01-07T10:29:13.957020Margaret O'Neill This is so shocking and must be sorted, I no children can be demanding but they do not deserve this when in care. 22362015-01-07T10:36:56.97022geraldine pollock It is terrible this happens and your expected to believe to teachers but at end of the day who is going to lie the teacher that has put bruises on the child or the child that just didn't understand 22362015-01-07T10:44:24.6537024christina sorleyit is atrocious in this day and age that there is still this level of abuse going on. \r\n22362015-01-07T10:50:13.9637025ann smiththis is an utter disgrace my grandson is in a wheelchair and is at a capability Scotland school I would hat this to happen to him its a good school though x22362015-01-07T11:11:27.877027Rhiannon Thomas omg thus is so wrong .... Should never really happen\r\nif the person was handled correctly then restraint should not be needed !!!!!! 22362015-01-07T11:14:41.8877028Jen robinsonBudget cuts and undereducated untrained staff should be stopped. 22362015-01-07T11:23:11.0437030Jacqui LoweThis should never happen our kids have been failed by the system . Justice will be done 22362015-01-07T11:46:11.3877032Lynne MeechanThis is a disgrace !!!22362015-01-07T11:47:38.6877033mark norwoodwe salmon fishermen are all in this together let us help ian gordon as much as we can22312015-01-07T11:48:01.8577034James InglisNo fish to be killed before 1st July by netting or rod.22312015-01-07T11:49:06.1837035linda beveridgeI have been a carer for 15 years and I have been working with kids and disabled people and I have had care commission out a few times so if thay cant do the job thay sould not be with children or in the job that thay sould be doing thay must be very sick to do this22362015-01-07T11:49:32.8877036Tim RosselliI do not think that netting should resume in Scottish Waters in Spring again.22312015-01-07T11:53:15.2477037S mckeown This is happening far to many times. Our children are humans and not just numbers. With propr support and training this would not happen parents are coping at home with same behaviours why don't they ask the parents advice. 22362015-01-07T12:18:28.4177038Vicky KenyonThis story is horrifying. I am the mother of a severely autistic non-verbal 9 year old boy and I would be heartbroken if my son suffered this treatment at school, a place where we should be able to trust the staff to care for our vulnerable children. Appalling!!!22362015-01-07T12:24:27.7937039Pamela Batalla Should be cctv cameras around to the kids security and also to monitoring the staff performance not all the staff have the profesional vocation to looking after kids if they doing for the money obviously they not give a monkeys about the kids :(22362015-01-07T12:29:51.5537041Angela MoloneyAs a sister of a handicapped brother, I have watched for 30years, since my parents died, to make sure my brothers care was complete. But there have been several occasion when I have had to intervene and eventually remove my brother from his carers. Not enough is done in these cases. 22362015-01-07T12:33:57.7637042Eddie LynchPeople who work with children must understand and teach, anyone who abuses kids as described here I'm sure is a tiny minority but must be exposed and face the full force of the law. 22362015-01-07T12:36:04.6077043Eilidh lane Can't believe the lack of policies - very neglectful 22362015-01-07T12:43:13.737044Susan Lyall Im totally in disbelief that this kind of thing even happens in this day and age to young people , so wrong ! 22362015-01-07T12:50:18.1077045kerry ann davisThis is just awful..happened to my autistic son many times & he was chemically coshed to point of him feeling so drugged up he attempted suicide!! These vile so called professionals need to be held accountable.22362015-01-07T13:06:49.067046lee bairdI have a daughter with myoclonic epilepsy and severe developmental delay this behaviour from a teacher is a disgrace!!! Totally nt acceptable... 22362015-01-07T13:22:56.3777047John StrowgerHistorically spring salmon stocks have always been vulnerable, because of their life cycle and spawning habitat demands. In the light of dwindling stocks everything possible should be done to retain the genetic profile of this endangered form of salmon. Rod and line anglers are playing their part, but the activities of a few netting interests could totally undo all of their good work. No wild salmon to be taken before 1 July.22312015-01-07T13:43:39.3237048Ailsa McInroyRestraint should be the very last option available & only used after every other option has been proved unsuccessful .Proper training should be given to all staff who work with children who have special needs. Use of restraint should be documented in accordance with guidelines which need to be drawn up. If restraint is ever used it should be mandatory that parents are informed, have access to the documentation & can discuss ways with the staff of avoiding its use in the future.22362015-01-07T14:10:22.6677049Donella grahamThey should never be allowed to treat a child lime this disgusting behaviour and to leave the wee soul in wet clothing is dispicable i hope this goes to a newspaper as ive never heard of such ill treatment in a school someone needs to be responsible for this 22362015-01-07T14:12:45.0137050Moira HodgeIt is horrifying that children with ASD, dyslexia, dyspraxia and other hidden disorders are still been abused and ridiculed by the very people who should be nurturing and protecting them.22362015-01-07T14:21:19.7677051Tracy BrannanSigned and shared22362015-01-07T14:24:00.9037052L WilliamsonWe never knew treatment like this was common until we moved to Scotland. I am legally obliged to stand by and watch her soul broken daily, yet if I remove her from school im in the wrong!22362015-01-07T14:24:54.7377053Leighann glenThis needs to stop people that can hit children shouldn't be working with them 22362015-01-07T14:42:27.1077054Lesley Fleetwood Words can't describe how angry this has made me. This should never have happened and should not happen again x22362015-01-07T14:42:49.8237055Klaus JensenKeep up Ian. The salmon needs souls of fire like you!!22312015-01-07T14:44:52.377056Amanda carrThis need stopped today and people need charged for this22362015-01-07T14:57:17.927057louise eley Absolutely shocking!!!!!22362015-01-07T15:09:24.2937058ann mcintyreI am strongly against this sort of behaviour as it is all about providing adequete training and communication to avoid all this. Staff and management should all be trained.22362015-01-07T15:14:55.2137059Katy Dalethis is disgraceful and should be stopped, no child should be harmed ever and not in school by teaching staff. 22362015-01-07T15:43:46.987060Elizabeth wardAs an ex resident of Edinburgh who has now moved and lived in Lancashire for 14 years reading some cases of child abuse caused by restraining.I feel strongly of why any child can be treated in a such a way.I always thought in special schools the teachers had an extra quality to enable them to punish a child without restraining and bruising.shocking news to hear such stories.22362015-01-07T16:17:34.8237062John Olav OldrenGood work Ian :-) We all need to help the wild salmon stocks against all the threats.22312015-01-07T16:23:55.6977063jaiton prust kearnsStop this22362015-01-07T16:41:08.5937064Rosemary DowerIt is disgraceful that teachers are allowed to "restrain" children with special needs causing actual harm and are not held accountable for there actions. Making a child sit in there own excrement is child cruelty not a punishment. These so called teachers need re education as this is not acceptable by any standards!22362015-01-07T16:52:11.2077065Louise DexterThis is abuse, plain and simple!There is no excuse for this type of treatment for any human being.It needs to be stopped NOW!22362015-01-07T16:53:11.557066Denise Moorin Its wrong and it needs to be stopped straight away 22362015-01-07T16:59:55.2777068Stan HeadleyWhilst I have reservations re: catch & release, and I would prefer that spring salmon are totally unmolested by commercial and sporting interests, any steps taken to preserve these iconic fish in the face of total obliteration must be taken as soon as possible.22312015-01-07T17:09:56.7337069steph gellatlyDisgusting 22362015-01-07T17:11:55.367070paula craikAs a mother with a disabled child. I find this upsetting and disgusting that this child was harmed. It should be stopped22362015-01-07T17:20:41.3977072Mark BowlerWith the main run of spring salmon occurring during the months of April, May and June, the Wild Fisheries Review proposal of a date of April 1 for total catch-and-release by anglers falls short on protecting the spring fish to any great extent. Why not extend that date until July 1, which is more in keeping with England & Wales, which has implemented a total catch-and-release policy to June 16 for the past 15 years?22312015-01-07T17:33:53.767075Elaine Hendersonthis shouldn't be happening to anybody especially a \r\nDisabled child. As a mother of a disabled child I\r\nWould do time if anyone done this to my child or any\r\nOf my other children. It's against their human rights.22362015-01-07T17:58:15.877076Patricia WalkerThe same happened to my nephew and we need to protect the children who have no voice 22362015-01-07T18:03:35.2877077Kerry RyanThis is heartbreaking and sick!...signed and shared...best wishes you and your lovely son x22362015-01-07T18:07:45.5737078Jacky churchThere is no need for that to happen to any child teachers are Ment to look after the children not hurt them .22362015-01-07T18:08:21.857079Katherine Alexanderin 2008 my learning disabled brother was deemed to present challenging behavior by a carer who was unable to communicate with him. She withdrew from him after sedation contrary to his care plan. Under the effect of sedation and unobserved he fell down the stairs breaking his neck and leaving him paralysed. 22362015-01-07T18:25:12.3977081Gillian MeadAbuse pure simple and very ugly!22362015-01-07T18:27:00.637082Nicola Farrimond Still cannot believe no legalisation or a process to support children and their families as well as adults22362015-01-07T18:43:07.2077083linda MulhollandCan't believe this can happen in our schools it must be stopped now 22362015-01-07T18:46:04.7237084Helen Drysdale This is so wrong22362015-01-07T18:47:10.6937086Ian DrysdaleStop this now22362015-01-07T18:51:34.4437087Eve Crawfordif your not allowed to touch a child in schools, how on earth can this gbh be legal? This has to stop now and Criminal charges brought to those to did this. The law must change to protect the vulnerable and I urge parliament and Nicola Sturgeon to do the moral ethical and legal requirement to put an end to the abuse of the disabled. 22362015-01-07T18:53:29.037088Paul David WilliamsAgree with an extended ban on netting, but why not stop all fishing for four seasons to give the fish a chance. A reasonable cull of predators should also be introduced.22312015-01-07T18:56:18.9877089Kevin briggsHappened to my son ,trying to get something done for years ,unfortunately people don't seem to think there's anything wrong with treating disabled children like this will never let them care for my son again22362015-01-07T18:57:08.777090june mackillopThis is appalling. ...do something about it NOW!!!!!!22362015-01-07T19:19:05.7577094lucy clarkOutrageous that this sickening abuse is aloud to happen! My son is 4 with severe LD 22362015-01-07T19:27:27.2877095Joyce LothianSigned and shared, hope it all goes well for you and other families.xxx22362015-01-07T19:34:32.4737096Isobel mcginleyits really terrible this is happening to much to disabled people 22362015-01-07T19:54:28.7837097louisa doyleSo wrong and defo needs to be stopped 22362015-01-07T19:59:56.9537098Patsy BallantyneCruel to treat a child any child in this manner, they should be held accountable and dismissed from their position ..22362015-01-07T20:03:06.9677099Natalie Stevenson This is barbaric doing this to any child let alone someone with learning difficulties 22362015-01-07T20:36:14.247100Julie Taylorteachers need specialised training and support so they have the necessary skills to respond appropriately to children that have little or no verbal communication skills.22362015-01-07T21:24:31.987102vicki YeatsI am the parent of 2 children on the autistic spectrum and a psa in a primary school and would like to say I find it remarkable that if I restrained my own child in this way you would be held accountable by law, but not in a school. This discrepency in the law is barbaric.22362015-01-07T21:41:30.3477103Frances Brown We had a similar problem with the education board in Fife concerning our son who is on the autistic spectrum when he was only 4yrs old we I was told to get my husband to restrain my son put him in the car drop him of at nursery and leave him there needless to say this did not happen.. Best of luck because this is a terrible way to treat children just because they are a little different 22362015-01-07T21:55:03.0237104liz skinnerStop this abuse now 22362015-01-07T22:11:40.677106Christina McFadden It's disgusting and unacceptable to treat a child this way 22362015-01-07T22:12:48.0037107Margaret mcwilliams Stop this in our schools it's 2015 teachers should be trained to deal with this without restraining a small child. 22362015-01-07T23:10:17.977108Leighann bain I am a manager in early education and find this absolutely disgusting behaviour from a professional. I have never came across any legislation that states it's legal to harm a child in anyway no matter what. Also do leave a child sitting wet as punishment is an can act of child abuse in my eyes. I hope these people are delt with in the way they deserve.22362015-01-07T23:33:48.887109Helen Mckenzie Seems far to extreme and cruel. No child should be physically hurt!22362015-01-07T23:39:01.7677112Sven AxelssonPlease .....ACT BEFORE IT IS TO LATE 22312015-01-07T23:46:40.557113Chris WhelanAgree 100% Ian, 22312015-01-07T23:50:54.527114Stuart Paton This has to be worth a shot to try and save our dwindling migratory fish. Every fish left in the water has a chance of spawning and replenishing our stocks, nae redds in a freezer. 22312015-01-08T00:32:36.777118Diane Rennie In my experience the government sadly ignore any plea for help even in the most guenuine of cases and it has left me believing that we in this country do not matter. There are a lot of bottoms on seats being paid for lip service. I truly hope that you are able to rally enough peoples attention to change this barbaric treatment from adults who should know better especially in jobs of trust and care. I cannot see a link to take me to sign your petition so I do hope that you read my response to give me a link. Thinking of you all Prayers and hugs sent for you as you face this struggle for justice xx22362015-01-08T00:36:14.0377119Hayley BurnsSigned and shared...good luck xx22362015-01-08T00:56:09.057120Kathleen SantiagoThis horrific behavior has to be stopped.I worked with special needs children for many years,some who could become very violent and I have never hurt or left any child with bruises.I suggest you train your staff,in safely dealing with behavior problems.I might also add j am appalled by what was done to this innocent little boy.22362015-01-08T02:05:21.3637121Margaret DavidsonSafety and wellbeing of children has to be a major priority.22362015-01-08T02:11:26.417122Gillian Andersonhow many times does this have to happen before someone does something 22362015-01-08T05:24:53.3477123Karen mathiesonthis has disgusted me to the core. These laws need to change fast!22362015-01-08T06:31:27.37124Maureen Pay No child should have to suffer in this way , at the end of the day it is abide. The children are put into a place of trust to be looked after , take time and explain what you want the child to do , if they do not understand explain again .22362015-01-08T08:15:32.1837125laura macleodAbsolutely disgusting how any teacher feels they can put there hands on any child and call it restrain. Its bullying and overpowering a youngster. Plain and simple. My son has autism and if any teacher laid so much as a finger on him they would be sorry. If this was the parents that left all the bruises on there child and called it 'restrain' then am pretty sure social services would step in. So why is our government not stepping in to help. Children with a disability are amoung the most vulnerable people in society but yet this bullying from people they are ment to trust still happens... 22362015-01-08T08:25:18.3937127Louise Moore This is awful no child shud have to go through this at school.22362015-01-08T08:30:10.1437128sue buggeunbelieveable22362015-01-08T08:46:33.8837129linda colquhounShocking something should be done about this poor kids22362015-01-08T09:22:21.9577130Diane BodellDisgusting! Get this stopped ASAP!22362015-01-08T09:30:09.3477131Carol PakeA barbaric way to treat a human being. No understanding shown, just brute force.22362015-01-08T09:54:47.7977132Kathy BlackThis type of guidance already exists in England to protect the children and staff. Death by asphyxiation happens easily when wrongly restrained, is it going to take a death to convince Scotland to step out of the Dark Ages? Since obviously injury is already ok in their books.22362015-01-08T10:45:03.4037135bridget ann molloy this should be stopped and the people involved prosecuted x\r\n22362015-01-08T10:53:38.677136Maurice CahillMy 100% Support..!22312015-01-08T11:00:31.1837137Duncan FergusonKeep up the pressure, there aren't plenty of fish in the sea.22312015-01-08T11:41:26.987139lisia harveyTreatment like this is a disgrace it needs to be stopped before a poor child gets killed by these so called restrants!22362015-01-08T12:28:58.027140Associate Professor Keith McVillyIn Australia we have recognised this as a major issue and are implementing policy, guidance and staff development strategies to address this serious issue.22362015-01-08T13:19:41.5937141Kirsty DaviesReally hope this petition helps x22362015-01-08T13:26:10.1437143gayle blaneySigned.22362015-01-08T13:49:15.9977144Stephen vossshocking no matter who it is let alone a child with differcalties... they should have the same done to them and see what it feels like!!!!!22362015-01-08T13:54:09.3877145sharon ringsellDisguted 22362015-01-08T13:54:34.8937148Nicola Moranawful..22362015-01-08T15:55:53.147151Brian Nelson These places should be CCTV watching ever room in the place for the Protection of patients and staff alike,these people should be jailed.\r\n22362015-01-08T16:40:17.527152karen simpsonMy son was "restrained" on numerous occasion by members of untrained staff at his old primary school..needless to say nothing was done it was our word against the teachers....disgusting ! 22362015-01-08T16:52:03.527153Pauline McDonald Disgraceful!!! 22362015-01-08T16:56:16.137154Margaret Irvine Shocking 22362015-01-08T17:11:08.1477155tracy clarkAbsolutely disgusting should not be allowed at all with any child 22362015-01-08T17:15:58.057156Jan Collins Advice and education for schools on this kind of situation is needed.22362015-01-08T17:28:49.7837157carol campbellSigned xx22362015-01-08T17:36:12.8177158karen habershonI find this very disgusting in this day and age this is totally unacceptable i have a daughter with severe leaning disability and what they are doing in Scotland is terrible 22362015-01-08T17:46:24.8937160pascal duboisI'm very happy to contribuate at these save opération\r\nI'm the secretary of an anglers association on the Léguer river in Britanny, the third salmon river in France and I know salmon problems with profesionnals fisheries and I wish fishing with nets stop. It will be necessary that salmon will only fished with rod ansd only on fly rod, but I'm sure I don't see that alive.\r\nCongratulations for your fight22312015-01-08T18:49:21.6937161Pat Taylor I am disgusted that this could happen in the 21st century. It should be stopped and they should be charged with assault or GBH 22362015-01-08T20:11:11.8777163Maryanne Marshall shared ayrshire scotland 22362015-01-08T21:05:03.417165lorraine middletonAbsolutely Ridiculous not fit to be working with children22362015-01-08T21:25:53.2537166Carolyn Lindsay The Scottish Goverment must act on this. 22362015-01-08T21:28:56.57167Steph bleything in England people would not be allowed to get away with this so why is Scotland different. You can restrain either a child or an adult without marking them. I agree there are times when restraint may be required but not in the case stated. Why do they not have people with required training to look after sick children like this. Disgusting and shame in the staff for doing it or allowing it to happen. If a mother did it social services would be round in a shot!!! Take action strict action against this happening again in any situation.22362015-01-08T21:51:05.887168alesha brownHappened to my nephew police and social services questioned him but no further action was taken\r\n22362015-01-08T22:39:36.4077170Gillian RobertsonThis is a must for the law to change, this misuse of power is a disgrace. All staff should have proper training and the relevant values required to support vulnerable children, who require our support. In this day and age it is just not acceptable to use such force on a child who is probably scared and confused. Staff in schools and establishments should be using proactive approaches to support children, not reactive approaches to punish them. 22362015-01-08T22:57:43.637171Linda ClarkeSIGNED22362015-01-08T22:59:21.057172skye Marnie Disgusting 22362015-01-08T23:20:19.2877173Charlene Taylor nobody should be held or restraint enough to mark the skin, discusting esp by a teacher.22362015-01-08T23:41:47.557174Helen murray Awful to hear,both children and teachers need to be protected 22362015-01-09T01:36:24.3477176Elicia HillI am totally disgusted that this policy has been passed by government ,I myself along with my daughters had to learn how to cope wiith my husband whom suffers from epilepsy caused by a road traffic accident 21 yrs ago and I would never use brutal force on him as I can find other ways to keep him safe while in a seizure so im dam sure adults in the teaching profession can use the brain they were born with to ensure a small childs safety, so I want to get this policy under rule Now.22362015-01-09T02:16:04.4277177Leslie BrandI am the mother of 2 special needs sons22362015-01-09T02:55:20.1637178Stephanie ElliottThis needs to be stopped! There is clearly a lack of proper services in place to properly care for some of our country's most vulnerable children! I'm disgusted! There needs to be better care provided and a review on "restraining" polices in special education schools! 22362015-01-09T03:23:29.497179Sylvia wardThis needs to be looked into these children are sent there to learn not be mistreated or abused22362015-01-09T08:40:19.927180Fay Coupland this is disgusting behaviour no child should be treated in this way I have a five year autistic son and I would be fuming if my child was dealt in this way 22362015-01-09T10:06:23.4877182michaela thomsonAwful .. They shouldn't be allowed to get away with this. 22362015-01-09T10:20:24.997183Rosie MurchieShocking22362015-01-09T10:37:09.277184Stephanie JacksonDisgraceful! They cant get away with that!22362015-01-09T11:16:36.4577185Anita Wenham Discusting , Abuse 22362015-01-09T11:33:59.9437186Maggie BrownThese barbaric practices must stop - for goodness sake we are in 2015, not the dark ages!22362015-01-09T11:51:06.2877187andriena lawsonWhat would happen if I walked in there and "restrained" a teacher...I would be charged with assault..sickening!!!!22362015-01-09T12:34:53.8677188Douglas AndersonAbsolutely disgusting. The school and individuals must be held accountable and if the correct training isn't there it must be implemented.22362015-01-09T13:18:09.2877189emma wrightHope this helps x22362015-01-09T13:24:49.3037190katrina gillan (trini)Good luck ive left a comment on fb too x 22362015-01-09T14:09:54.797192Liz Bradydisgusted at the way these children are being treated.surely people working with these kids should have knowledge of appropriate handling of these poor kids.there just bullies22362015-01-09T15:08:21.3937194Donna EwingMy son with autism was treated badly in mainstream, took complaint thru Edinburgh council route then to Scottish Public Services Ombudsman who took a year to respond only to agree with council, 4 yrs on, still dealing with the behaviours and confidence issues caused by so called professionals!22362015-01-09T15:17:07.2437195Paula Tidmansigned, hopefully this will no longer happen22362015-01-09T15:21:42.2137197lisa hadfieldgood luck with your petition x22362015-01-09T17:53:06.7237199Eric GlaisterWe have a duty of care to the next generation, so they can enjoy what we have enjoyed for years.Lets not give up.\r\n22312015-01-09T19:16:28.417200Maureen TempleGood luck with your petition, hope you get a satisfactory result22362015-01-09T20:03:03.297201Arthur HewittAs a Health and Safety Practitioner and great-grand parent this is horrifying to see and I will give you all the support I can.22362015-01-09T20:41:55.8937202Margaret murphy they should hang there heads in shame 22362015-01-10T00:43:10.1277206Nicole devlin This is disgusting and should be stopped 22362015-01-10T00:47:46.8477207Etta BreaultChild abuse is never acceptable! 22362015-01-10T03:53:15.9977208Margaret SounessAbsolute disgrace that a child should receive these injuries whilst being restrained.22362015-01-10T03:58:35.667209Alex SinclairWishing you all the best as clearly something needs to be done about this.22362015-01-10T04:20:42.8977210lesley kaneI think it is disgraceful that they get away with things like this. They should get prosecuted for this but they don't. And also there should be the correct training giving out. This makes me sick to know what happens I. Some of not most of out schools today. 22362015-01-10T05:19:01.8937211helen macdonaldWhat a disgrace.the schools should be held accountable.signed and shared22362015-01-10T09:22:51.2077212terri aytonNever ever should this happen to a child....good luck22362015-01-10T10:47:59.0777214Kerrie carter Shared and signed aberdeenshire 22362015-01-10T11:03:48.1477215Eleanor Boyle Please sign. This cruelty has got to be stopped22362015-01-10T11:17:28.5677216Bernadette GuthrieThis is shocking and needs to be stopped!22362015-01-10T11:49:53.7037217jen meadowsI live in England and thanks to the power of facebook saw this. In England we have restraint trainging called TCI theraputic crisis intervention. It prevents over 50% of retraints occuring and gives save guidelines and yearly training fo staff. The fact that Scotland doesnt have this both suprises amd worries me. The stats from america show how dangerous uncontrolled resttaints can be especially for children. What needs to happen.for things to change. This is not something that should require a petition to be discussed22362015-01-10T11:53:57.977218paula jacksonThere does need to be some kind of way that trained staff have to restrain a child for there safety and for others safty ...22362015-01-10T15:20:09.1937221Melvyn Black Good luck and hopefully someone listens!! 100%.22312015-01-10T15:20:43.887222alan sheppardSupport22312015-01-10T15:21:19.327223Melvyn Black Good luck and hopefully someone listens!! 100%.22312015-01-10T15:40:18.4077225Dr. Jean RothbergThanks a lot for bringing this important issue up Ian! Thumbs up! 22312015-01-10T15:54:41.5677227Allan Robertsona very bad year for all. issue of more Licences to coastal netting stations the salmon stalks have a hard enough time on the high seas are they not on a protected speice list .\r\ngive the salmon a chance the guys on the rivers are doing there bit surely the government can at least do there bit22312015-01-10T16:05:12.4337229john tansley. (river avon fishing association )Regulation is needed at sea to stop migrating fish being intercepted at or on route to and from their feeding grounds.22312015-01-10T16:12:54.0037230Allan Robertsona very bad year for all. issue of more Licences to coastal netting stations the salmon stalks have a hard enough time on the high seas are they not on a protected speice list .\r\ngive the salmon a chance the guys on the rivers are doing there bit surely the government can at least do there bit22312015-01-10T16:16:50.17231Pontus Gunlyckehope this works!22312015-01-10T16:30:43.817232davidmartintenorGreat cause. Well supported. 22312015-01-10T16:44:36.4577233Dana W. McConkeyI fish the Miramichi, it's in big trouble. 22312015-01-10T16:47:22.3337234Thomas sheehanhas to be stopped on all coast lines 22312015-01-10T16:52:56.1777235Evelyn Ross This is shocking22362015-01-10T17:08:37.917236Dave HortonGet a grip! :(22312015-01-10T19:53:21.247238Catherine McLauchlan Stop over fishing22312015-01-10T19:59:00.8477239Robert CraigWe may already be too late but we must take every chance to save the species for our grandchildren.22312015-01-10T20:27:36.847240Brendan logueGood luck with it22312015-01-10T21:44:44.4577243Dave France Makes a lot of sense, well done Ian 22312015-01-10T22:21:56.557244Mark PattersonGreat cause, I give you my full support.22312015-01-10T22:34:53.3937245Gregory HooperNetting and killing spawning Salmon is too much pressure on the natural fishery.22312015-01-10T22:35:09.4977246jimmy marshallkeep up the pressure\r\n22312015-01-10T23:15:19.387249Mia PiperI've worked in special education in Hampshire, England and I'm proud to say this WOULD NEVER BE ALLOWED TO HAPPEN HERE! \r\n22362015-01-11T00:01:27.8177250alan jackson This is shocking and terrible... I know situations can be stressful and trying but their is no need for this22362015-01-11T00:01:58.5277251john stewartthis is a must for the future of salmon fishing. Surely the government know the value of this precious fish. 22312015-01-11T00:03:18.3637252Elizabeth SnaddonDone and shared22362015-01-11T01:33:49.247254Sonia Mclay In addition to this petition please consider the rights of children under UNCRPD .\r\nGuiding principles of the Convention\r\nThere are eight guiding principles that underlie the Convention:\r\n\r\nRespect for inherent dignity, individual Autonomy including the freedom to make one's own choices, and independence of persons\r\nNon-discrimination\r\nFull and effective participation and inclusion in society\r\nRespect diversity, Respect for difference and acceptance of persons with disabilities as part of human diversity and humanity\r\nEqual opportunity, Equality of opportunity\r\nAccessibility\r\nGender equality, Equality between men and women.\r\nRespect for the evolving capacities of children with disabilities and respect for the right of children with disabilities to preserve their identities.\r\nAmen 22362015-01-11T02:02:54.887255Philip sherwoodGood luck22362015-01-11T03:10:56.6977257elliot cooperas someone who has been restrained unethically in schooling I personally maintain that restrains should be used only when unavoidable. As opposed to how they are used now.22362015-01-11T08:36:27.917258Michael wardwe all have to place sensible restrictions on netting, farming and anything that effects our fish populations. If not there will be no wild stocks left worth talking about. It would be worth leaving some estuaries and rivers un fished for 3 years or more to allow natural regeneration, just a thought.22312015-01-11T08:49:20.1777259Anthony CurranSigned22312015-01-11T09:09:18.2877260Louise Taylor Make schools safer so our children ain't at harm22362015-01-11T09:27:29.2877261john tansley. (river avon fishing association )We need to tell every angling pal that we have to sign this petition now, before it is too late and past the point of no recovery! \r\n\r\n22312015-01-11T09:33:01.1077262geoff sanderskeep up the good work22312015-01-11T09:36:40.867263John CouttsUntil the reasons for the salmons poor marine survival are determined surely it makes sense to give the amazing creatures all assistance to reach their rivers of origin to spawn. I\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\nUntil the reasons are clearly established for the salmon's poor marine survival it surely makes sense for the amazing creatures to be given all the help we can provide to allow them to return to their rivers of origin to spawn. Coastal netting is indiscriminate and further depletes already low stock levels so must be eliminated at least for a reasonable period to give stocks the maximum chance to recover.\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n22312015-01-11T09:43:46.3477264Lisa SargantI hope the parents receive the Justice and answers they need. Hope those responsible are punished accordingly 22362015-01-11T10:07:25.027265Brian ParkerThe stocks of wild salmon in Briton should be protected as much as possible, to safeguard there existence. Anglers are doing there bit with catch and release. Until stocks of salmon return to heathy numbers no netting of these wonderful fish should even be considered.22312015-01-11T11:19:33.7077266diane rhodesThis is appalling in thus day and age that vunerable children are not getting the care understanding and help that they need shame on u all involved 22362015-01-11T11:53:01.7877270susan moseswell done Ian, the Scottish government need to stop all coastal netting to save the wild atlantic salmon from becoming one of the most endangered species on the planet. at the same time take a serious look at the marine pollution being caused by salmon farms in sensitive areas. closed or on shore containment should be a priority.22312015-01-11T12:22:58.4577271gary meldrumAgree22312015-01-11T13:12:39.917273Linda DonaldsonThis is an absolute disgrace kids with disabilities suffer enough in life without being tortured as well22362015-01-11T13:38:23.8337275Robert ThomasDear Scottish Pariament, through your continueing support for salmon farming and netting you and your opposite numbers in the Norwegian parliament are the biggest threat to the Atlantic salmon in the world today. Should the Atlantic salmon in its wild state become extinct in many previously prolific rivers then each individual member of your parliament must go down in history for some of the most stupid decisions taken in Scotland ever.22312015-01-11T14:23:23.1777276Paul mcneillit's an outrageous the netting to that goes on 22312015-01-11T14:34:09.3877277william bainAll the best22312015-01-11T14:52:32.7537279Robert JewelsStop all netting we put all salmon back till 1st July & many many more after July 1st. Be a sorry world with out salmon in it.22312015-01-11T15:39:15.2077281Gary JenningsNets should be banned here!22312015-01-11T15:56:22.887282William JollyEveryone has to play their part in the Recovery of our Spring Salmon, no matter how big or small that part might be.22312015-01-11T16:38:41.017283Hugh RussellI agree it has to be stopped behind you 100%22312015-01-11T16:53:04.247284Kenneth Adams Thank you for sharing abd bringing awareness. Hope this helps.22362015-01-11T17:14:37.1437285Jacqueline CampbellChildren will only learn in an educational setting if they feel safe and secure.22362015-01-11T17:19:29.3177286Sandy Hinshelwood Good luck with this.22312015-01-11T17:31:05.6937287David StevensonThe Atlantic Salmon needs all the help and improved protection it can get to improve the runs and Salmon to repopulate our rivers.22312015-01-11T18:10:33.497288William RutherglenThe guidance should apply to all Schools.22362015-01-11T18:25:18.1637289Brian WebbPlease save the Spey !22312015-01-11T18:51:36.617291David Brycethis is for a great cause. I agree with ian 100% on this.22312015-01-11T20:13:28.6877292William CummingLast season as bad as it was, it became even worse immediately after the netting commenced.\r\nJust take a look at the River Tay catch results, they dropped off as soon as the netting commenced.22312015-01-11T20:50:19.9977293Jim HinshelwoodAs a keen angler you have my 100% support22312015-01-11T21:04:09.7077294Julie HumphreysI am special need nursery nurse..i have a child with special needs and think that this is first class child abuse...ofstead need to be brought in step up guidelines.. If a parent did this to a child social services would be involved.It gives would be child abusers a free reign ..Disgusting22362015-01-11T21:21:38.9577295Mike ElrickAbout time the regal salmon got a better chance to breed to start n build up the stocks22312015-01-11T22:07:42.0177296Ian farr Netting of wild salmon should stop right now and all fish caught by anglers should be returned to the river 22312015-01-11T22:22:56.9577297andrew mcfadyenfor the sake of salmon numbers this should be stopped,it will help in the long run22312015-01-11T23:47:30.3337298james mootysigned22312015-01-11T23:58:06.637300geraldine CassidyIt's a disgrace that people can and r getting away with this abuse22362015-01-12T00:37:00.127301nicole marrHope this helps. 22362015-01-12T00:37:40.1777302john fraserShould be no netting at all in my opinion 22312015-01-12T08:17:45.277303Peter o'HaganFully support this22312015-01-12T08:34:28.9577304Markus KaaserIt's worth generating sustianalbe solutions for our atlantic salmon - a creature who can't speak for itself !22312015-01-12T08:41:34.447305Ines KaaserPlease preserve this creatures and their eco-system for our children !22312015-01-12T08:48:00.2937306John McBaini have a daughter who has epilepsy so I can empathise with you.22362015-01-12T09:23:15.2537307Miss Jeanette Mcallister Wish you all the best and support through this.. Absolutely shocking behaviour from someone that's meant to be a carer! 22362015-01-12T09:34:21.97308steven ritchieTime to act NOW,or time will eventually run out,,,,22312015-01-12T09:41:45.027309Murray Ogilvie The fish must run, simple!! 4 22312015-01-12T11:12:52.4737310Barbara CharlishGood luck and wishes for every success22362015-01-12T11:28:58.8177311sharon sneddonIt is a disgrace that any child has marks left on them 22362015-01-12T12:01:46.6437312eve richingssave atlantic salmon22312015-01-12T12:03:33.9737313Bill GrahamThis should extend to nurseries too. Have witnessed some appalling practices with no adequate complaint procedure22362015-01-12T12:51:50.8737315John CornfordGood luck!22312015-01-12T13:07:35.137316Carol PrattThere has to be full accountability & monitoring of staff practices. The disgusting abuse of our most vulnerable people has been allowed to carry on unchallenged for far too long.22362015-01-12T13:12:39.1437317William AlldisSalmon are the life and sole of fishing on my island and without them a large part of our economy will fail it has long been my belief that it is netting and catches at sea are a large part of our failing numbers not inefficient anglers who have as much fun not catching fish as they do when they are lucky enough to catch one or two. Keep up the pressure I will always do my bit.22312015-01-12T13:32:01.7377318David CattoSalmon fishing on the River Spey is of huge economic value to the whole of The Spey Valley. Income from fishers supports jobs directly on the river and indirectly in all the small businesses - hotels, restaurants, shops and service providers.22312015-01-12T13:45:31.5337319Florence Little If professionals were trained to understand why children are behaving in a challenging way - especially if they are autistic- and asked why rather than reacting to what then I have no doubt incidents could be significantly reduced and the use of restraint avoided,his would be best for all concerned.22362015-01-12T14:09:20.057320Margaret LoganYet another species under threat. 100% backing and the very best of luck.x22312015-01-12T14:41:58.667321Tracy lundieHopefully, this will be put in place without any real didficulty. Scotland most definitely want to ensure it is delivery best practice when supporting and educating our most vulnerable of children. 22362015-01-12T16:06:38.197322Michael StrawsonSupporting this cause is absolutely essential and I back it 100% 22312015-01-12T19:02:18.977324Frank ClarkThe lack of understanding by the Scottish Government has been woeful.\r\nRod fishers have curtailed there fishing methods and have adhered to a to a catch and release policy that has resulted in over 90% of salmon being returned Fishers and landowners have contributed large sums of money as well as time in improving the habitat of our salmon rivers as well as research . \r\nIt is therefore imperative that all netting both at sea and in the river mouth is banned. The netting companies contribute little and it is indiscriminate asall fish are killed regardless of size or gender22312015-01-12T19:38:45.4737325Maureen GrayIt must be made very clear that abuse of children under any circumstance is not acceptable in this society22362015-01-12T19:53:33.837326Linda McconaghyChildren shouldn't have to suffer like this.it is againstthe law for parents to hurt their children so why should anyone else be allowed. Am totally disgusted22362015-01-12T21:00:09.8937327Andrew PownallSomething needs to be done and you have my 100% backing in this matter\r\n22312015-01-13T00:00:22.0977330Stewart A RobertsoonWe need to conserve for the future, and start now.22312015-01-13T10:42:55.0377331Marie McdougallPeople with learning disability and autism can have challenging behaviour if they are in pain, constipated etc and this needs to be taken into account if someone has challenging behaviour22362015-01-13T10:53:36.3337332Janet Robertson 100% all the way, good luck 22312015-01-13T13:52:39.4437333Félix SANCHOTo all anglers, wildlife lovers and those citizens who firmly believe we have to guarantee the transmission of a better Earth to next generations:\r\nData on atlantic salmon catch between 1952 and 1995 show an 82% decline from rivers around Scotland. This suggests that all salmon populations are affected, regardless of river type or location, and salmon stocks in 129 Scottish salmon rivers may be categorized as endangered. Nets do not have the option, as we anglers do, of releasing captured fish, as retention of the catch is the aim. We shall not wait until it is way too late and launch all protection initiatives now. And this one can trigger a significant improvement in Scottish salmon populations.22312015-01-13T14:23:57.6577334James PainHopefully not too little too late22312015-01-13T14:39:31.7277336rab browngo for it 100 percent22312015-01-13T15:38:39.37337louise runcimanchildren need to be protected at all costs. Guidelines need to be put it place to keep everyone right but more so to keep these children safe!! 22362015-01-13T15:39:09.0677338lee wildersthanks 22312015-01-13T16:19:51.6437339thomas devine 100% all the way22312015-01-13T16:39:29.777340Jinty MorrisonIt is disgraceful that there is not robust policies & protocols in place along with unannounced inspections of all facilities for vulnerable people.22362015-01-13T17:00:45.3337341Theo BakelaarSave those beautiful fish. Don't kill them all. Have respect for them. Stop it.22312015-01-13T17:11:04.2877342Gerard mcauley100% all the way in this sad time, and fast.22312015-01-13T18:23:28.167343Simon KirkbrightWe have to protect the stocks now for the future or none of us will have any fish to catch.22312015-01-13T18:45:51.9037344James McKinlayGood luck with the petition. Hope you get the right result\r\n22312015-01-13T20:05:59.6237345bill hindmarshI just hope this works and the Petition is of such numbers that the Scottish Government acts on it . English nets should not be excluded.22312015-01-13T20:45:11.0377346Rodney J. DibbleLook after the sand eels and you look after the salmon!22312015-01-13T21:17:13.3337348Clare DooleyThis is relevant for all schools with additional need kids. Be they mainstream or not. This is wholly relevant to Donaldsons school and the issues they are having. These children need to be respected for the difficulties they have and understanding of the individual way they need to be managed to protect and secure them. 22362015-01-13T22:03:11.247350Kieran Ritchie catch and realise all the way :)) 22312015-01-13T22:38:23.3477351Joseph GreenwoodGood luck Ian.22312015-01-13T23:23:28.3337352James ArthurWould really love for my son to be able to enjoy the sport when he's older. Behind this 100%.22312015-01-14T01:04:28.357353Frank LysakI hope that this petition results in action by the Scottish Govt to put wild salmon higher up the agenda. It is important that stocks are managed to enable anglers to take an acceptable number of fish for there own consumption, this will underpin a very important element of both the Scottish rural economy and Scotland's tourism industry.22312015-01-14T02:57:10.167354Gary JohnsonPlease stop commercially fishing your salmon. We have the same thing happening in this country with our dwindling stocks of wild Steelhead and the impact istragic.22312015-01-14T07:14:12.9077355john graySomething needs to be done now 100% on your side22312015-01-14T07:27:32.6937356graeme howeNeed to take action now, later is too late\r\n....22312015-01-14T11:28:20.1937357Alex ThorburnIn 2015, would should not be resorting to restraining children unless as an extreme last resort. When I undertook teacher training, if you could not control your class, it was the teacher's failure. There do need to be guidelines but these should be rigorously policed to ensure that all children receive the dignity and development that they rightly deserve22362015-01-14T16:11:42.267358yasmin ayoubdisgusting. appauled i am . taking advantage of authority in regards to vulenerble.shame on them!!!22362015-01-14T16:57:14.0777359wanda creedWe need to protect our wild salmon runs...22312015-01-14T18:57:24.547360Jack EnoMakes common since to me 22312015-01-14T23:33:52.67361David WakefieldFully support immediate action on both counts in this petition. Cannot afford to delay for another disastrous season like 2014. Also essential that Protect Wild Scotland new campaign 'Safe Passage' which advocates moratorium on salmon farm expansion + 32km salmon farm free zone around river mouths receive fullest support from all who care about Scotland's wild fisheries future and the huge economic benefits available from well managed sport fisheries as opposed to unsustainable commercial fishery interests. Note also the plight of our bass sport fishing and measures proposed to make this a sport fishery only and ban netting + commercial activity.22312015-01-15T01:10:15.237363Hannah Fox Please can the higher authority regularly regulate thepolicy for the uuse of physical intervention in special needs school in Scotland this is terrible what had happened to this family 22362015-01-15T07:01:23.8537364Margaret Rose StewartTerrible but not surprised if this was my child i woukd have reported this to the police. This is child abuse snd sadly its not only physical but mental abuse. There was a case in England where a teacher and support assistsnt where charged for exactly this.22362015-01-15T08:40:35.3477366C CanavanAs the law stands, animals have more rights than children in schools. It should always be a last resort and never be used on children and most certainly not disabled children, without independent scrutiny of every single incident. An adult should have to defend their decision and conduct for assaulting a child.\r\n\r\nRestraint is very subjective: both chosing to use it and the amount of force used. \r\n\r\nNo-one without proper training should lay a finger on a child and yet they are manhandled dragged across floors, sat on and every incident does harm. The physical wounds may heal but not the emotional nor mental trauma which stays with them forever.22362015-01-15T09:03:08.9737367fiona havertyRestraining should really not be happening 22362015-01-15T10:19:37.087368John CouttsUntil the reasons are clearly established for the salmon's poor marine survival it surely makes sense for the amazing creatures to be given all the help we can provide to allow them to return to their rivers of origin to spawn. Coastal netting is indiscriminate and further depletes already low stock levels so must be eliminated at least for a reasonable period to give stocks the maximum chance to recover. 22312015-01-15T13:01:05.147370David E HallPlease protect these Salmon from extinction!22312015-01-15T14:04:28.527372Jessie TurnerCoastal netting must stop to allow stocks to recover. Anglers already put back a large percentage of their fish. On the Dee where a ban on killing all fish has been in place for 20 yrs, the rod catch of spring fish has been extremely poor in recent years. Therefore catch and release by itself is not the answer.22312015-01-15T14:43:33.667373karl holmesI fully support what your trying to do.22312015-01-15T15:59:43.167374Brett McLaughlinAll types of restraint should be abolished22362015-01-15T17:14:55.9677375Michelle FlynnEvery parent of an Autistic child needs to sign this petition. Absolutely disgusting that such vulnerable children could be treated so badly. 22362015-01-16T09:40:47.5877378susan purdieThere are no exceptions to restraining children, it simply should never happen.22362015-01-16T10:58:07.567380alyson huttonDisgusting22362015-01-16T12:18:59.4737381Maryanne McLaughlin I do not yet have children but god forbid I did and this happened to them it's a disgrace.22362015-01-16T14:38:41.9837382Alistair RossCould someone please explain in detail to me how charging a rod licence fee is going to help protect the Atlantic Salmon. I would imagine that most people who fish for salmon blank regularly. It is aldo the case that due to catch limits being imposed that most salmon caught are returned. So in my opinion there is no need to impose any more financial burden on the angling fraternity22312015-01-16T16:52:21.567384Willie McDonaldCatch and release has stopped an even quicker decline in numbers of fish spawning in Scottish rivers but netting,despite what Marine Scotland say is resulting in the killing of far more fish than in previous years particularly in times of drought. There has to be a realistic quota if netting is to be allowed to continue. There also needs to be some government realisation that current levels of predation are impacting heavily on juvenile stocks.There is too much protection for these birds and not enough for our extremely valuable atlantic salmon.22312015-01-16T17:54:11.0737387Charles JordanThis ban on all catches until July is absolutely ESSENTIAL. No possible good can flow from any other policy. None, and a very great deal of our heritage is at stake. It would be *utter lunacy* to resume catching. 22312015-01-16T19:52:34.4777388John H Nuttany sane consideration of the issues and the fact that 2014 was the poorest salmon season on record suggests that a five year total ban on killing salmon is the least we could do. Greed, greed greed even with fish stocks!22312015-01-16T20:47:02.287389Ed Kilgore MBEI find it disappointing that I enter Northern Ireland but your software puts United Kingdom whilst other entries seem to appear as England whilst N.Ireland and or Wales does not strange? I will be passing this to fellow angling club members who will feel undervalued as I do particularly as I have been honoured by her Majesty of the United Kingdom of Great Britain AND Northern Ireland. I await your reply with interest. Ed.22312015-01-16T21:19:16.167390John Whinray GarnettAll fish farming should be carried out in enclosed tanks on land to minimise the huge number of sealice produced by the open cage system at sea,and all mixed stock coastal netting fisheries should cease immediately.22312015-01-16T21:50:38.9877391William Hunter WatsonIt was I who submitted petition PE01494, a petition which called for Scottish mental health legislation to be amended in order to ensure that it is compatible with the European Convention on Human Rights. Many supporters of my petition provided me with information which made it clear that they or a loved one (sometimes deceased) had been subjected to ill-treatment. An inquiry would be invaluable in that it would demonstrate that there are no effective safeguards within the 2003 Mental Health Act. This implies that it is essential that the Act be suitably amended so that it complies with the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.\r\n22482015-01-16T22:32:36.6237392valerie smithDisgusting 22362015-01-17T00:13:34.0437393Caitlin meekI am honestly outraged at this disgusting behaviour. As a childcare worker myself I would never ever lay a finger on a child. Let alone a disabled child. They need full love care and attention.22362015-01-17T01:19:59.9737394Janette RobbComments from various bodies on my son's treatment- 'Barbaric', 'Cruel', 'Nobody should have to suffer like this.' But he did. 22482015-01-17T08:20:39.237396Lisa sabinThis is a brilliant cause we come to Scotland every year as my husband is a fisherman, he always puts them back because a life of a salmon is not an easy one and deserves respect. Netting should definately be banned.22312015-01-17T08:54:25.6577397Paul RichardsonI am a regular visitor to Scotland. It is the salmon fishing that brings me and the salmon need further protection or they will die out.\r\n22312015-01-17T10:10:16.0677399sheona charltonThis needs looked into asap for the protection of vulnerable young people.22362015-01-17T10:11:13.5137400clint doig Coastal netting must stop a.s.a.p i am a 100% catch and release so should use be .....22312015-01-17T10:33:14.9037401lesley BrycelandThis is very relevant to my autistic son.22362015-01-17T11:02:40.597402sandra harvey nicollGet the bullies out the school and let us help the poor wee souls if that was happening in the house we wud get our kids taken off us.\r\n22362015-01-17T12:29:57.377403Ed FiliceGood on 'ya, Ian. Let's hope we're not too late.\r\nBest regards.22312015-01-17T12:35:31.9837404Chris MalkinTime to get serious Scotland. Save the salmon!22312015-01-17T12:54:24.6537405Richard BanburyThe Scottish Government will be negligent in their responsibility to conserve Scotland's National Fish if they continue to allow commercial fishing with stocks at such critical levels. Commercial fishing can become viable once populations are restored to 1950's levels. The fad for plastic farmed Salmon will pass but this Government seems high on greed for the tax income it generates and seems to be doing all it can to precipitate the destruction of natural stocks and their genetic integrity.22312015-01-17T13:00:19.1677406Beth MorrisonPeople with mental health problems, learning difficulties and disabilities are extremely vulnerable. Everyone has the right to live in safety, free from abuse and neglect. 22482015-01-17T13:27:19.8177408Samuel leslie BoswellI fully support your petition and hope it is sucsesfull22312015-01-17T13:51:18.5137409Clive MitchelhillIt is imperative that we all support this and all other petitions designed to protect this magnificent fish. The evidence of the decline of our salmon is overwhelming and we all need to stand together to make sure action is taken to protect them.22312015-01-17T16:34:51.737410James Pearsongive salmon & trout a chance there a fantastic sport fish concentrate on on poachers,not netting22312015-01-17T17:16:35.1837411leona kiddThis needs to be stopped \r\n\r\n22362015-01-17T20:54:53.987412Christine Whitehead I think its discusting that a teacher is allowed to do this to any child never mind a child with a disability they should be charged with abuse 22362015-01-17T21:00:24.6837414Julie HowarthThis need to stop22362015-01-17T23:33:39.8437415john dumontSalmon are the united kingdoms king of fish, too precious to allow to be destroyed. tourism depends on it.22312015-01-17T23:45:34.1837417Sharyn GreavesA child should never be marked for any reason if his mum had done this questions would be asked teachers are meant to be trained very sad22362015-01-18T10:52:17.677419Malcolm BrownI fully support this petition22312015-01-18T10:54:57.3777420Julia SmithThere should be proper guidelines for staff, to help these vulnerable children feel safe and happy, while giving the staff appropriate and safe discipline techniques. This training needs to happen asap. 22362015-01-18T11:33:36.4477421Nicholas AllanAsk your self. How much is each wild salmon worth to Scotland. Hotels, gilly's, shops, etc.22312015-01-18T14:01:40.7137422Garry GreggThe economic model for Commercial Salmon netting is many times less than the Recreational angling one, and is much more sustainable!22312015-01-18T15:22:57.127423samantha reillyAbsolutely disgusting!!22362015-01-18T15:42:38.197424William BrownI fully support what you are doing Ian22312015-01-18T17:41:57.3537425Chris SalmonI support the petition , save our Salmon.22312015-01-18T20:16:18.97426GORDON HAGGARTcatch and release is the way to protect salmon and to ban coastal and river netting.22312015-01-18T22:44:21.4577427paul hodgsonThe nets need to stop to let the fish have a chance to breed and get the stocks back up to a good level its going on here on the rivers in the north east of England aswell to much netting going on\r\n22312015-01-19T08:42:22.1737428Tammy SuttonHope this stops no child deserves to be treated that way..22362015-01-19T09:05:21.3037429John GrandisonWell done to all of the people working in the background , fingers crossed 22312015-01-19T11:00:41.097430david loudensame here in n ireland the angler is paying for licence and permit and no fish in the rivers 22312015-01-19T14:38:10.067431Ian Daviesabout time a stand was taken. 22312015-01-19T15:19:12.6977432Alan John MadsenWhilst the proportion of fish killed by anglers is tiny in comparison to netting licences on their own are a blunt weapon. A total ban on killing before 1 July is a far more scientific approach. Taking a fish only after 1 July with strict licensing and limits on netting is a much better approach. This would enhance the angling and tourism industry and force the commercial netting industry to play their part in the conservation of stocks.22312015-01-19T15:45:11.7177433colin papeGiven the catastrophic decline in salmon catches over the past decade I believe that no salmon should be killed in coastal & estuary nets and by rods before 1 July throughout the United Kingdom and not be restricted to Scotland.22312015-01-19T15:56:42.0437434chris winsorI,ve fly fished for nearly 50 years and all sport has slowly declined and its always the paying angler who makes the sacrifices 22312015-01-19T17:10:31.457435Elizabeth Rossaction to stop the decline of wild salmon in the rivers is essential if Scotland is to continue to be a destination of choice for salmon fishermen and women. The industry is worth millions to the people from all walks of life who facilitate and support those who fish by rod.22312015-01-19T18:49:29.6237436Richard DuikerLeave your hands of our wild salmons otherwise there gone forever !!22312015-01-19T19:14:42.177437Mick PricePlease don't leave it too late to act .just look\r\nwhat has happened to our river Wye down here in England22312015-01-19T20:09:10.457438Paul PritchardTime for change!22312015-01-19T20:45:24.6537439John HickmanAll salmon and grilse should be returned to the rivers through catch and release to ensure they survival. All Netting for salmon should stop with immediate effect if we are going to stop this magnificent creature from becoming extinct.22312015-01-19T22:29:26.8737440Norman HallIf you close fish farms atlantic salmon may have a chance22312015-01-19T22:30:43.77441Jos WaceThank you Ian and the S and T A22312015-01-19T23:00:09.8237442Edward ThomsonSEA LICE are the biggest problem!22312015-01-20T15:45:30.4137443Nigel SwiffenAllow Salmon Hatcheries on the Spey, \r\nDredge the Spey mouth to allow the Salmon to run freely,\r\nReduce Seals in the estuary22312015-01-20T17:00:20.0537444Judith GillilandIf you Google my name, Judith Gilliland, and read my submission for the Petition submitted last year by Hunter Watson it will be clear why I support Andrew Muir's petition. 22482015-01-20T18:56:08.8577445sid knightI tried but kept getting the spoken numbers wrong22312015-01-20T21:37:21.777446Mark WilliamsNetting Wild Salmon to this extent when numbers have collapsed is madness. Please give the species a chance to survive.22312015-01-20T23:14:02.6277447Robert ClemenReduce the predators and a Lot more salmon will return into the rivers !22312015-01-21T07:09:56.747449Andrea greenThat's shocking no child should be treated like that22362015-01-21T07:30:22.6537451Marie June V. RamosParents persmission is needed before restraining a child..a consent form is neede and have to be sign as well22362015-01-21T07:39:55.4937457Cheryl DaleThis horrible abuse of children MUST STOP now! How does anyone with any intelligence think that this is acceptable to any child let alone a child with a disability. This is not right and must stop now.22362015-01-21T07:43:26.8577458Pamela Hadley I have a disabled son and I wouldn't like him to be treated like that.22362015-01-21T07:50:51.4577460Catherine WhitehouseThings like this must stop. Children, especially disabled children, should not be getting maimed at school. The teachers must be trained better so this doesn't happen anymore. Seldom does a child need to be "restrained" and if it is absolutely necessary there are ways to do it without completely traumatizing the child. 22362015-01-21T08:01:21.027461lynette smithIt is an absolute disgrace that this is going on in our society in this day and age. My son was also a victim too while staying in respite. Please lets hope this changes the law and protects our vulnerable children from being treated like this.22362015-01-21T08:05:48.137462Amber McBrideThis is not right we need to live in peace Nd they should not be allowed to do such cruel very wrong please end this now very sad 22362015-01-21T08:10:13.997466Mrs N ThomsonTotally disgusting!!!! 22362015-01-21T08:35:56.027467Paula longbottomWe have had to deal with this so sad that because of lack of understanding children have to suffer22362015-01-21T08:50:41.2877468Liz HardyI hope this barbaric treatment is stopped. These people are suppose to care for our children not subject them to such horrible treatment. Good luck with the petition.22362015-01-21T09:20:26.1537471Katie AkersProfessionals, please help our children as if it is your own child. Show love, trust, patience and encouragement. Not punishment.22362015-01-21T09:23:08.8177472Tracy cleaverShocking :(22362015-01-21T09:26:58.637473susan edmundThis is absolutely disgusting, no child should ever have to suffer any form of abuse, I thought this world was about ending child cruelty not encouraging it, children go to school to get educated not abused, my 15yr old son as been bullied his whole school life, by staff not other children but no one cares except for us (his parents) , we have fought the education every step of the way but to no avail. They always blame the child. All they care about is getting the attendance figures up, it's disgusting. I can't wait till my son leaves school22362015-01-21T09:31:24.4477475Helen toddThis seriously needs stopping no child should go thro this 22362015-01-21T09:46:08.5077476Jenny websterThis is appalling! - they are not animals ! They are children that need extra care & not to be made to feel frightened!! Omg this makes my blood boil as my son has severe learning difficulties & asd . 22362015-01-21T10:02:20.5537478lesley-ann bowers-bennettThis makes me Sick stop this now.22362015-01-21T10:25:28.9577479melonie smaleWhat a terrible thing to put kids through! Please stop hurting the kids!22362015-01-21T10:28:13.5077480Lesley McLennanThis is totally disgusting. We have a autisitic daughter. This bought tears to my eyes.22362015-01-21T10:31:09.1977481Belinda Derrick I cannot believe that anyone would put their hands on a child like this! Even more important I cannot believe that anyone would put their hands on a child with a mental illness. Do these workers do that to children without mental illness or is it just for the children who are mentally ill? Jesus Christ "Whatsoever you do to the least of these you have done also to Me!" 22362015-01-21T10:33:27.597482Juanita GallagherPlease sign and let's stand up for those who cannot stand up for them selves!!22362015-01-21T10:48:36.6537486Elaine Finnan Everyone should be treated with respect! 22362015-01-21T10:51:05.887488Simon Carnall Prone restraint causes positional asphyxia and can cause death . Also using control & punishers instead of teaching and proactive strategies to teach the person how they can meet their need without the use of behaviours . The child was communicate an unmet need through his behaviour and sadly no one was supporting 22362015-01-21T10:56:29.3977489Hayley Wingfield I have a severely decabled son if anyone did this to him they would know about it legal or not 22362015-01-21T10:59:38.9437490Sheila gwatkins It is horrid22362015-01-21T10:59:53.6637491Marion Ross Children with special needs should be treated with respect at all times.22362015-01-21T11:09:06.8977493Sally SmithChildren should be protected , not abused. 22362015-01-21T11:18:05.127496ashley haganLeave these poor kids alone22362015-01-21T11:29:34.6937497Shelley McWayneI allowed the same however, my sin was approx 4 & a half when I gave my consent\r\n\r\nI believe this was just the start of a catalogue if behaviours were triggered\r\n\r\nThe worse behaviour was clear defiance of adult authority \r\n\r\nI hope u get more signatures & I will be sharing also\r\n\r\nThank you22362015-01-21T11:31:10.137498Emma chamberlain autistic children don't need restraining they need understanding 22362015-01-21T11:33:33.1077499janice toppingSome people just need the money and the job theses jobs need proper care compassion understanding the disability and read there file from start to finish about there triggers and how to overcome these there's not enough training so the people inflicting this abuse are getting flustered as they don't know how to care for them properly. 22362015-01-21T11:48:13.677500Andrea Leibbest of luck and wishes22362015-01-21T11:48:42.927501Staci TramontThe abuse needs to stop!22362015-01-21T11:53:40.2237502belinda barnett-andreaI have a 10 year old son with Autism Thank you for being such great parents and fighting for you son and others22362015-01-21T11:58:46.7577503Jill Shaw My autistic daughter has come home with bruises from school too. I know how you feel.22362015-01-21T12:00:32.7237504Michael BookmillerStop being a bully!! That's what those so called care givers are, nothing more than bullies.22362015-01-21T12:14:37.8377505Samantha CanavanPoor, defenceless and innocent children being manhandled and physically assaulted!! An absolute disgrace!! This behaviour isn't acceptable anywhere else, so why here??22362015-01-21T12:19:04.6477506Colette WalshI am half Scots and have worked with children with learning disability in Scotland. I would never have considered teating chiildren like this. I am very surprised anyone would ill treat a child to such a degree as to leave bruises. Please change this situation.22362015-01-21T12:33:56.137510jan morgandisgusting these restraints need to be changed as too many injurys are being implimeneted through personal experiance always said they should not be so heavy handed 22362015-01-21T12:36:16.8977511gail manndisgusting22362015-01-21T12:49:33.917512Nicole CornerAs a mother of a child who has a disability, I was horrified to see that Scotland allows such barbaric behaviour. Particularly, by adults who should be trusted to keep children safe and nurtured. Please educate those who need to change the system, in order to protect innocent lives.22362015-01-21T12:52:16.9437514Debbie SAUNDERS I think it's discuting, something should be done about this.22362015-01-21T13:06:14.1137515julian millerchipthe salmonid species has inhabited this planet a lot longer than humankind, we have no right to exterminate them22312015-01-21T13:22:07.7837516Clare HansomThis is disgusting and should never have happened shame on those involved.22362015-01-21T13:28:44.297517Margie Rose That is child abuse. 22362015-01-21T13:29:45.9477518Caroline BenjaminHaving a child with Autism you worry how they are when they are not with you. School's are supposed to be safe. If the support workers don't know how to deal with any incident they should not be in a job like that. The whole point of courses etc is to give these people the tools to be able to deal with certain scenarios. Our children can't help the way they are. 22362015-01-21T13:29:57.657519Nikita HartleyAs a parent of a child who suffers with global developmental delay I would be horrified to hear of this happening to my child. I find it truly disgusting to hear it happening to someone else's, and not just to one! To find out this barbaric and inhumane behaviour is happening to other innocent children as well just leaves me dumbfounded beyond beyond belief!22362015-01-21T14:00:34.0377521Judith Carlislehave a handicapped niece can completely understand22362015-01-21T14:12:20.827522alicia barfoot With 3 nephews, all of whom have special needs I find it absolutely disgusting this type of behaviour is still allowed!!!! Seriously thought this type of treatment was against the law in this day and age!!!! 22362015-01-21T14:22:31.2077523Julia PickenpackThis is absolutely unacceptable behavior from ANYONE, especially in a professional manner! Disgusting, and I pray for the children and families affected by this!!!22362015-01-21T15:32:59.9277524frederick richardsonits all for our future generations and our chance to make shure that nature is preserved and do not take a chance that it might never happen22312015-01-21T15:48:48.9577527Emily M Williamsno one has the right to touch a child without their consent ever.22362015-01-21T16:28:18.2077528Janet Stachow We need to look after children not harm them as adults it us up to us to do the right thing while they are in our care22362015-01-21T16:59:18.0837532Rebecca ReadmanWas used.on.our 9 yr old . I was on school site and was told to go into school as is better without me he ran from them was assured they would call me back to them as heads said 4 times don't want him lifted22362015-01-21T17:28:45.6777534karen bonnerSigned and shared in perthshire.22362015-01-21T17:49:46.3737535janice allanThis barbaric practice cannot go on.22362015-01-21T17:52:26.4077536Katie Rafala no child should ever go through that especially children with learning difficulties. My son has special needs, learning difficulties and autism and if anyone dare speakers out of line to him I go mad at them.22362015-01-21T18:15:29.37537Iris Gillies I have a disabled grandchild and I would hate for this to happen to him or any disabled child for that matter. This sort of treatment is barbaric and will not be tolerated they should be named and shamed . Also a law against this sort torture to a child that can not do anything defend him or herself , something needs to be done NOW .22362015-01-21T18:17:35.667538linda mccroneWork in a few schools of special needs kids and seen this happen with my own eyes ! Shocking ! 22362015-01-21T18:21:40.67539Margaret WilliamsDisgusting hope there's a stop put to this 22362015-01-21T18:47:28.2077541Deb Withingtonno child should be harmed by anyone. Lawful restraints do not leave injuries.22362015-01-21T19:16:46.777545Jean LivingstoneI have a brother who is epileptic and has learning difficulties. He is an adult now and we have had many problems with social workers and cre system, etc. you have my sympathies and support all the way.22362015-01-21T19:43:25.4577548Mary DeatheIt's shocking to treat a young child in this way. 22362015-01-21T19:45:42.4877549Johnny McGarrityIt is a duty to ourselves and the future of the human race to protect and nurture our children , for they ARE the future . Love and compassion goes a long way . 22362015-01-21T19:56:02.6937551julia WordenUnacceptable\r\n22362015-01-21T20:14:27.7077552robert LairdMany years ago I lived in New Elgin in Morayshire and knew an Ian Gordon then. Just wondered if Ian had any connection with Elgin. Glad to sign your petition, but sadly domiciled in England these days, but recall many fine trips out after the Sea Trout on the River Lossie. Good luck with the petition.\r\nRegards\r\nRobert22312015-01-21T20:15:48.4837553Stephanie B RODRIGUEZI have no words other than this ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTS ME!!22362015-01-21T20:16:09.387554Jane JusticeIt's absolutely wrong and disgraceful on every level that a vulnerable child is treated in this way. It's an assault! This MUST change NOW!22362015-01-21T20:48:53.7077555Eric lopez This is a horrible act of cruelty. More teachers and carers need to be educated. I hope this comes to a stop no one should be treated like this. 22362015-01-21T20:58:40.4577556Maureen ClugstonChildren need love and understanding not abuse 22362015-01-21T21:09:02.7877558Olga MingleI can't fot the life of me understand why this can happen in this day and age information and strategies of how to work and care for vulnerable children. And if I may say, whose behaviours are through no fault of theirs.22362015-01-21T21:20:28.5077559Ava-Joan HackettThis is terrible and it should never happen to any children wether or not they have a disability.22362015-01-21T22:10:41.5637561Mary charlwoodThis practice is barbaric may I suggest team teach which is 95 de escalation and 5 restraint in an unharmful professional way.22362015-01-21T23:11:19.447566Peter AustinHaving only recently taken up salmon fishing I have missed the good times and in consequence seem destined never to take a wild one for the table. However, so many passionate anglers support this petition to do our bit to save the species and deny ourselves so hopefully setting an example that I feel Scottish Government is surely morally bound to follow. But maybe their morals have been corrupted and all we'll get are the usual weasel words and our efforts will be in vain. The netsmen kill all the fish in their nets and do nothing by way of conservation. We would all like to see a return to plentiful stocks and maybe even some bulging nets but we must act before the number of spawning fish falls below a critical level, i.e. now.22312015-01-21T23:13:28.497567Frances mccartneyTotally shocked that this is happening to children in care of professional staff, this has to be stopped asap.22362015-01-21T23:31:28.1977568Val smithMy son has autism they use calm hold as the say 22362015-01-22T01:25:47.5577574tracy calhounOur children should be treated with respect and dignity and basic human rights just like everyone else. We demand it.22362015-01-22T01:38:57.8077575sherry shelbournethis needs to stop omg\r\n22362015-01-22T03:14:40.367577Abigail ShattuckNo child should be treated this way. I have a child with Aspergers and this would not be tolerate where I live and shouldn't be tolerate anywhere else. I hope this petition helps make that happen! 22362015-01-22T03:56:42.5337578karen linkteachers are spose to be educated in the handling of our children,not abusive.my son had many problems in school,including being jumped weekly.when his friend showed up at my house one day during lunch to tell me my son was being beaten up again,we ran to the school n put a stop to it personally with police ,the principal, teachers nothing got done other then them trying to charge me with assult.get an attorney n sue the district. hurt them where it hurts\r\n22362015-01-22T05:22:35.1237580Eleane TweedlyIt is absolutely barbaric that staff, trained or otherwise, are allowed to treat children with disabilities like this with complete impunity. \r\n22362015-01-22T05:51:56.1277581Veronica MacLeanI am appalled my family historys country would allow such ABUSE SICKIN ME22362015-01-22T06:45:31.177583Linda WilliamsThis policy is so ignorant of the basic human rights of a child with a disability. I certainly hope the response on this petition draws enough attention to this inhumane policy and that it is corrected to be in line with other civil countries! 22362015-01-22T07:04:29.0737584Kevin Smithglad to help. I used to kill salmon for a living,providing great food to man. they must be saved. if the rivers die.. we die. think about it.22312015-01-22T07:50:15.2777585kellie barryThis is disgusting..... how dare anyone do that even to my child and hes in perfectly good health. This is barbaric and need to stop. The law need to change 22362015-01-22T07:56:57.3337586faye SheldonYou put your trust in teachers 22362015-01-22T08:16:59.7737587charlene mullanThis is disgusting.... I work with adults with serve learning disabilities and serve autism and never in this world do I ever ever feel the need to restrain a service user..... I have excellent traning and support to be able to deal with any situations... I beloeve this law should change in nortgern ireland its against the law to restrain anyone 22362015-01-22T08:32:23.817588Jessica FranklinI think it is disgusting that tje government allows this cruelty to our children. Our children don't deserve this. This society is rubbish and good on you for doing this .I am all for your support and I hope they change the laws because that is disgusting. 22362015-01-22T08:35:43.0477589janet whiteheadThis is barbaric something needs to be done to bring Scottish Laws up to date and until then all our English schools need to stop sending children up there22362015-01-22T08:36:14.1877590Jessica FranklinAll the best. I think this law is appalling. no kid deserves that.22362015-01-22T08:59:51.9377591Geri McDonnellI can't get my head around this. Children in mainstream education are safeguarded. Adults cannot lay hands on them or it's classed as assault. But vulnerable children aren't?22362015-01-22T09:36:51.37592Kim AlexanderTeachers who are not educated , experienced in special ed often think these children are just naughty. Special ed children need and deserve a calm , caring and consistent environment to progress. A child with Challenging behaviour should not be grabbed and bruised on the upper arms. Special ed schools in Australia know to hold children by the wrists and would never leave a child in their urine soaked pants. These children need a patient , educated and caring teachers. Please help to make changes quickly this is very distressing to know that it can happen at all. Thank you22362015-01-22T09:41:48.1537594Anthony SteelThis is one important cog in the wheel of improvement that should be done to our wild salmon stocks for the sake of the tourism economy.22312015-01-22T10:08:10.2037597Deborah HyltonnNo child should endure this barbaric treatment with or without a disability, this is what happens when you have untrained staff, someone has to be accountable, this must not be allowed to carry on.22362015-01-22T10:13:43.1377598Charles AllenThis problem is not just confined to Scottish rivers. a similar collapse has been experienced in Iceland in 2014. Government and the agencies that control these matters should listen to the experts and those who have dedicated themselves through their sport to the preservation and health of the salmon. 22312015-01-22T10:32:46.237599Barbara Friel there are ways to restrain without hurting or marking a child. There is Price training in restraint I worked with adolescents with mental health problems who sometimes needed restrained but these kids were not hurt or marked in any shape or form. 22362015-01-22T12:02:04.677601Richard HutcheonIn addition to over exploitation at sea by mankind, can something be done to reduce seal numbers in estuaries in times of drought?22312015-01-22T14:22:20.6577602Kimberlee BrandenburgI also have a special needs child and i am appalled at the treatment your child received. I hope my signature helps.\r\n22362015-01-22T15:51:52.457603Graham RaitI have fished the Deveron for over 60 years and last year was probably the worst. All the conditions were favourable apart from there being no fish. If the netting is not stopped soon there will not only be no salmon but there will no salmon fishing tourists either. Anglers will not pay for fishing, tackle and accommodation if there is very little chance of hooking a fish.22312015-01-22T16:14:56.0377604George HunterThe major problem is not within our rivers and the salmon angling fraternity. it lies with indiscriminate fish farm locations and what happens out at sea. Which sucessive governments have failed to deal with. if by releasing salmon over this period it does something to help great. 22312015-01-22T16:46:19.4337605janet kinseyNo child should be harmed.22362015-01-22T17:20:53.5777607ewan bellThe Scottish Government are directly responsible for virtually destroying salmon runs on the Lochy by licensing even more salmon cage farms along Loch Linnie and up the Sound of Mull amounts to culpable negligence,by government. Last years lack of fish running many of Scotland's East coast rivers is caused by a combination of negative marine factors , one of them is human exploitation which is something government can do something about . Do not play politics with one of Scotland's main tourist attractions 22312015-01-22T17:56:51.6237608Archie Stirling-AirdIt is time to take some action to protect this magnificent fish - without doubt one of Scotland's greatest natural resources.22312015-01-22T19:44:00.317609Charles McPhersonSalmon netting is awful, no prisoners taken and if it continues the species will be wiped out, all for greed.\r\nIt should and must be banned. Fishing has to be 100% "Catch and Return" also.22312015-01-22T20:38:36.7937610Anne HunterAbusive behaviour towards children, physical, verbal or otherwise should never be tolerated.22362015-01-23T00:46:31.8477612Sarah baker Sad 22362015-01-23T00:47:25.857613Anne Lawton what low type of human could abuse a little boy and leave marks like this on him, I'm disappointed in the Scottish government to allow this to continue22362015-01-23T08:29:53.7237614donna pageThis must stop now.Plz sign.22362015-01-23T08:53:28.0837616jodie greenI think it's disgusting how people and teachers bully children with or with any condition it horrible shouldn't be aloud to be teachers 22362015-01-23T09:19:14.1137617Jamie SmithUnacceptable to touch a child without permission22362015-01-23T10:25:54.387618Joanne MussonThis is absolutely discussing,and unacceptable!!!22362015-01-23T10:26:57.927619Carole McCaldinThis is inhumane and has got to stop!! 22362015-01-23T11:40:21.0837620nicholas hastieSalmon are an endangered species due mainly to the Scottish Government's lack of interest, i.e., netting at sea, removal of predators' both in the rivers & estuaries, seals, saw billed ducks, etc. damage to spawning beds by beavers, lice infestations from salmon farms, pollution, water abstraction from forestry & agriculture, etc., I am afraid that this is the same old store, of a species' about to be lost, due to mans incompetence & greed.22312015-01-23T12:15:25.8677621ken birdLets have action on this NOW before its too late !22312015-01-23T12:17:13.67622Sir George Forbes-LeithIf something is not done I fear that wild salmon will be as rare as rhinos in Africa\r\n22312015-01-23T12:56:49.6037623Angela BriggsI would like to see CCTV in all classrooms in all schools in every country & especially in special needs school's, no child should be treated like this & if teachers are doing their jobs, they would agree with this, as they would have nothing to hide. Our children are our future.22362015-01-23T13:02:29.777624Mr James FrenchThe netting of wild Atlantic Salmon should be banned completely, not just for a shorter season.22312015-01-23T13:36:39.077625Maureen Moore This is disgusting treating a child in this manner disabled or not cannot continue. someone needs to stand up for these kids as they can't do it themselves 22362015-01-23T14:05:25.5837627Jan OlssonThis is another example of us humans being stupid and short term minded. With the right political decisions it is not hard to make the salmon prosper...22312015-01-23T16:07:07.747629Pete NewellSustainability before profit.\r\n\r\nThink of the future, act now and show some backbone!22312015-01-23T22:38:26.1477631Diane EdgarNobody has thee right to abuse kids regardless of there ethnic or disability, it has to stop now and investigated so that abuse does not happen at all.22362015-01-23T23:27:12.1877632sharon morris-lathamIf you cannot treat a child with disabilities with care and compassion then don't work in that proffetion. It's not the child's fault they have disabilities. 22362015-01-23T23:43:00.8037633Mark crossThis is wrong & something needs doing about it...!!!!22362015-01-23T23:50:12.7877634Suzanne BosworthUsing such restraint and punishment on any children is cruel and unnecessary. High time the law was changed to protect our children from those who use the absence of legal protection to abuse their power.22362015-01-24T00:59:10.9737635Lauren thomasI work on a secure unit as a mental health support worker and my service users acts out daily and I get attacked every other day and we aren't allowed to restrain them unless there's no other option for their own safety and others. So why should a defenceless child be restrained. It's outrageous!!!!22362015-01-24T02:22:17.1577636Pauline mckayIf a parent had done this to there child they would be charged.22362015-01-24T08:31:41.0837637kim jonesThis is awful no child should be subjected to this type of abuse 22362015-01-24T08:32:45.4737638Mick PurdyFrom tiny acorns22312015-01-24T09:30:03.4737639janette barrieDisgusting22362015-01-24T11:02:06.0377640Andrew RyanIf action is not taken to rescue the treasured atlantic salmon they will be reducedvto extinction22312015-01-24T11:06:54.637641Martin GlennieSalmon are a Scottish National Treasure--don't waste them on the dinner table they are worth a lot more in the water waiting for a fly.22312015-01-24T11:11:21.17642Anita SmithWe need more salmon coming home to spawn22312015-01-24T11:18:22.7237643Andrew MacGregorSeems the Government report famously promised by then leader notably friendly to netters and fish-farmers in February 2014 for September 2014 actually has been published at notable low profile launch - so what is 'anyone' doing about it. Further report was S.Government stating it would take three more years to implement "too little too late"?22312015-01-24T11:19:30.6337644Eamon McgeeWill be going to Scotland to fish but if it's not reverse no point in spending my hard earn money to fish in Scotland if netting resumes, fishing is good for tourism more money will be spent on hotels, bed amd breakfast and shops alot more on netting.22312015-01-24T11:24:06.647645Ray JarmanThis will help to preserve the future of our wild Salmon for future generations.22312015-01-24T11:35:44.2937647Clive BrutonWe owe it to future generations to ensure the survival of this magnificent fish! Do not prejudice its survival!22312015-01-24T11:36:52.8177648Dion DochertyI would like to see all the netting of wild Salmon and Seatrout stopped for good22312015-01-24T11:55:45.3637649William LothSalmon fishing brings a lot more money to Scotland than netting - do what's best for business - let the anglers catch the fish and spend money locally.22312015-01-24T11:58:08.0077650William Gavin Telfer DunbarI want everything to be done to conserve the Wild Salmon stocks of Scotland. They are under threat from netting, both costal and at sea. Predators also need to be kept down. The Scottish Parliament has a central role and needs to listen to those who care.22312015-01-24T12:03:31.8337651Bob TurnerThe benefit to the Scottish economy is great for rod caught salmon, it makes no sense to jeopardise that.22312015-01-24T12:49:57.417652Donald W. HendersonWe must preserve our natural ecosystems. The Atlantic salmon is a vital and historic part of the cold-water river systems entering the North Atlantic. 22312015-01-24T13:07:13.717653Ewen BrodieThere is no other sensible alternative.22312015-01-24T13:10:24.67654Smets KoenGood luck !22312015-01-24T13:42:02.857655Ryland Thomas. Midland FlyfishersI can not conceive that any intelligent and responsible minister, wth no conflict of interest, can turn this down.22312015-01-24T14:02:48.3937656Sir John Lister-KayeThe principal predator is man, both directly and indirectly. This conservation measure is vital. 22312015-01-24T14:07:02.0677657William Storey Well done to all the time and effort Ian has put into this cause, as individuals we don't make much noise! All of the dedicated salmon fishing people who have come together have made a huge bang!!!! well done Ian 22312015-01-24T14:51:27.7077659Gerald Spiers Good effort Ian.22312015-01-24T14:55:54.0037660Leonard russellScotland has more wild salmon than any other country. Numbers are severely down. Why ruin this with netting?22312015-01-24T15:02:23.17661Jack WelchSalmon stock are a key indicator of not only the health of Salmon, but also the river system and Scotlands environment. Salmon must be protected to allow future generations to enjoy both fishing and seeing wild fish in the river systems. 22312015-01-24T15:20:08.5677663Tony Murphywe must stop the damage that is done by fish farms, and stop the wholesale harvesting of sand eels and crill22312015-01-24T15:52:07.137664Bruce NobleCrucial work Ian and full of gratitude and admiration for your persevering with this important cause. After a poor year on the rivers last year, the thought that netting would begin in the estuaries and surrounding coastline is ecological myopia and would certainly further damage fish stocks. Petition part two signed.\r\n22312015-01-24T16:14:53.697665Ian GourlayReduce the crazy-high numbers of grey seals around our coasts and the fish *might* have a chance - their numbers seem to grow year on year and I see this from my boat, it's not imaginings. Seals are extremely wasteful eaters - a bite out of this fish, another from another one....22312015-01-24T16:22:59.2377666Peter YardleyI can't think of anything more stupid than starting netting again. 22312015-01-24T17:07:14.0837667Richard John Nellescarry on the good work22312015-01-24T17:32:10.0977668Anthony EathertonKeep up the excellent work Ian people like yourself are few and far between and should be applauded by all of us over such an important environmental issue as this. I hope your dedication will achieve the desired outcome.many thanks Tony.22312015-01-24T17:32:24.2377669Joanna McKenzieI am sure that anybody that has the safe future of this iconic fish will support this petition.22312015-01-24T17:45:35.277671Hugh AdcockThe freshwater mussel is apparently in serious decline - if we are to believe SNH - and since the salmon and trout are part of their life cycle then perhaps we will see some serious action taken by our government to improve conditions for our salmon.22312015-01-24T18:12:57.9737674Martin JohnsonAfter a truly disastrous salmon rod fishing season on Scottish east coast rivers action is badly needed22312015-01-24T18:18:42.9577675Paul russellThe Atlantic Salmon as a species in now endangered. Act now.22312015-01-24T18:22:03.9577676Keith HyettIt beggars belief that the Scottish Government will not get the message that unless they do everything they can to protect the Atlantic Salmon there wont be any fish for the netsmen or anglers to fish for !22312015-01-24T19:16:48.7877677Alec ODonovanGood luck22312015-01-24T20:04:06.667678Lt Col Laurence White McNaughtTo restart netting early never mind at all is absolute madness when rod fishermen are returning the vast majority of all salmon caught. It MUST be sopped. 22312015-01-24T20:15:35.9577680adrian mcloughlinThe fish should be left for a time22312015-01-24T20:26:09.2877681Rhonda AndersonMy son is autistic also and this needs to come to a stop. So sad.22362015-01-24T21:21:00.0537682Vicente Gonzalez VegaThank you for your effort. At least you are not alone, as me. Here in the north of Spain we have very very great salmon rivers with about 2000 catches not many years ago. But now we kill every salmon who run up the river since may to july, yes, the best ,in rivers with 100 or 200 catches per year. But here salmon fishing depens of the votes. I feel alone22312015-01-24T21:43:15.2077683JOHN BRADEThe Human rights acts are being completely violated by this Tory Government and it would appear the SNP couldn't care less\r\nI know for a fact that people with mental illnesses from birth that are now middle aged are constantly being hounded to death under the Tories austerity measures they are sending these mentally ill people these W.&.P Medicals and of course failing them ALL They then have to appeal to a tribunal and win there case then after a few months the W &.P send for them to attend another medical then the back to the tribunals its back again just one big circle for these very poor vulnerable people?? But what most people don't know its completely illegal what this government is doing Under the Human rights acts it is illegal for any public body to "Persecute " an individual person. Its completely illegal to cause mental or physical Torture on a person.\r\nIts illegal to interfere with family life \r\n\r\nIts illegal to treat a person in a degrading humiliation manner \r\nMy question is what is the S.H.R.C about this\r\nANSWER NOTHING \r\nWhat is the SNP doing about this blatant human rights breaches \r\nANSWER NOTHING\r\nWhat is the Mental welfare Commission doing\r\nANSWER NOTHING\r\nI think they should all hold hands and together where busy doing nothing working the all day through22482015-01-24T23:09:48.4437684annette moore This is shocking how can schools get away with it. But if it was just an ordenary mother or father that done that to there child the social servises would get called and may end up losing your child. One rule for one and a diffrent rule for another.22362015-01-24T23:20:38.2237685Brenda lawsonWe face the same issues in canada22312015-01-24T23:43:01.137686Derek RutterIan, Trust that you will be successful with regard to the outcome, many thanks from all parties interested in the future of our Atlantic Salmon22312015-01-25T02:22:48.0677687gordon shannonAnother major problem is water quality.Scottish water continue to discharge water of poor oxygen levels into our rivers,that killed about 300 salmon in 2013 .Dalmarnock Sewage works need updated,and water quality needs to be checked by S.E.P.A on a regular basis 22312015-01-25T03:32:57.8337688Eddie SinclairAll the best Ian and tight lines for 2015. Wild salmon are a precious resource that should be nurtured for future generations.22312015-01-25T09:26:34.617689Jeremy SharpNetting salmon is as bad as killing whales for so called scientific reasons. When will humans realize that short term greed and financial gain is NOT sustainable?22312015-01-25T10:02:51.037690charles coulsonAdd authorisation to cull seals in estuarine waters.22312015-01-25T10:12:06.4577691Della simmonsAll children deserve to be treated with love as inderviduals stop creating more misery in the little lifes\r\n22362015-01-25T10:46:08.37692David WhitrenThe netting of Salmon is madness, with stocks as low as they are now, if the netting commences it will eliminate Salmon altogether22312015-01-25T10:51:50.697693Nancy O HanlonThere will be no fishing parties to Scotland if the netting commences.22312015-01-25T11:58:54.5677694Peter KeelingThe financial reality of salmon fishing is that rod caught fish create more than ten times the income to the economy than commercially caught fish. The detrimental effects of the devastation of salmon stocks is wide ranging, as it affects all levels of the food chain, substantially interfering with nature and will make any commercial salmon fishing speedily uneconomic due to the loss of fish stocks. It really is a no brainer. 22312015-01-25T12:11:28.0937695Chris HeapIt's time we got off our backsides and did something positive before it's too late!22312015-01-25T13:55:45.5837696Pauline johnsonAbsolutely disgraceful22362015-01-25T15:00:12.2677697Michael HayesThe basis for this petition is not only of importance for Scotland but is genuinely of European and Global importance. As a resident in Spain I feel very strongly on the importance of preserving this wonderful species for future generations.22312015-01-25T15:32:02.5937698Alan DruryI think it's about time people with decision making power began to listen before it's too later.22312015-01-25T16:39:39.417699Nicholas ZollOurs cannot be the generation that presided over the demise of the Atlantic Salmon. 22312015-01-25T16:50:42.537700Derek McKinnon CurrieFantastic keep the good work up.22312015-01-25T16:56:09.6737702Graham DunsmoreI know that runs of salmon are declining but are we remembering that most rivers were down to summer level or below for the biggest part of the 2014 fishing season? Only at the back end was there a decent run of fish. These low water conditions surely had an impact on overall numbers for last year.\r\nAlso, forgive me for stating the obvious, but if a salmon is caught and returned on say the 29th May then caught again on July 1st and killed, how does that help..? I do realise though that the longer a salmon is in the river, the harder it becomes to catch..22312015-01-25T17:33:24.037703Anthony Mark Chattawayall salmon fishers past and present as well as naturalists need to support this petition not just for our sport but for the viable continuation of the Atlantic Salmon as a truly native species 22312015-01-25T19:42:52.2037705Graham L M Sharp(Dr)It is a tragedy that The Scottish Parliament has displayed such an abysmal record on our environment - but they showed their contempt for these issues by re-calling Aberdeenshire County Council's Vote against Trumps plans for the golf course at Menie - The Dunes were an SSI - and rightly regarded as a unique European Habitat.They have FORM!!22312015-01-25T20:51:34.4577706Stephen PatersonWhilst we can do something about what is happening to the salmon in our rivers and around our coastlines we also really need to address the problems they are facing both at their feeding grounds and en route to them. 22312015-01-25T21:06:07.0177707Jim AndersonUnfortunately this gov does not listen to the public eg airgun consultation. No doubt they think everything can be solved by licences.\r\n22312015-01-26T00:23:29.7337708Brendan LoughMy family has netted the Tweed for over 100 years and in all that time the predators of the salmon,at all stages of life,were kept to an acceptable level.My family have not netted for 20 years but they still get back to basics and agree on the affore mentioned points.It could be implemented immediately and free of charge and might take a few years to bear fruit but it would.Also we hear all the time we can't control things at sea but we do have control of things in our rivers,part of the answer is in the excuse! Please do not leave it too late as each year goes bye our task grows larger and larger until it will be unretrievable.Of all the creatures on our island they are by far the most amazing,ask Mr. Attenborough which creature he admires most in the world! And we can't protect it!!!22312015-01-26T08:57:54.9237709Noel O BrienPlease do what you can to protect salmon stocks. It is vitally important to the tourism sector and to future generations22312015-01-26T08:59:58.367710Neil McAndrewsEverybody interested in conservation should sign this petition.22312015-01-26T12:12:49.2537713con sheehani like to see salmon in our rivers in years to come, the way thing are going that dont look likley22312015-01-26T12:45:23.757714David Abel SmithRiver rod and line salmon fishing is vital for the rural Scottish economy22312015-01-26T14:50:18.5777716John DuffI suffer from Clinical Depression and I feel that the Mental health services have failed me badly. I have nowhere to turn to and no answers to my questions. No one seems to understand the way I feel inside. Decisions are made without consulting me or giving me a choice. It is as if those in a position of authority appear to know what's best for me.I disagree very much.22482015-01-26T15:18:01.777717Shigenobu FujiiI think it's very good effort.\r\nPlease by all means accomplished.22312015-01-26T15:42:08.7237718Dr Carol McKenzie Protect wild salmon. I am sick of reading everywhere to each oily, Omega-3 rich fish that is only found in wild stocks. I also am fed up with the lack of wild salmon from Scotland in our supermarkets. I have had to stop eating Scottish salmon due to the very dangerous levels of mercury that is found in Scottish farmed salmon. Furthermore, when buying tinned wild salmon, the Omega-3 content has been cut in half esp from those salmon caught in the Pacific and North Atlantic. At the weekend, I was happy to see fresh portions of wild salmon available to buy at Asda but it cost £6 for 2 portions. This is double the price of our fresh farmed Scottish salmon, which is full of mercury and other pollutants. I suffered from early stage breast cancer over a year ago and ensuring our country - famous all over the world for its salmon, can supply me and my child with fresh wild Scottish salmon should be a priority for the Scottish Parliament. Why are we importing cheap wild salmon and paying double the price for it and only offering Scots highly contaminated farmed Salmon when we are surrounded by fresh water lochs, seaways and oceans? WHERE IS OUR WILD SALMON INDUSTRY? 22312015-01-26T19:39:24.0937719Lal FahertyAll Gorvernments in the North Rim need to act collectively on this issue . Before we lose one of the most important parts of our natural history22312015-01-26T19:47:58.0477720Catriona Allansave the wild salmon22312015-01-26T20:22:44.617721Leslie LyonsIt would be a tragedy if the decline is allowed to continue.Consider the salmon farming industry as a cause of the problem at sea.22312015-01-26T20:43:49.897722Helen WellsThey deserve it.22312015-01-26T22:15:25.57723John William FordAs an occasional Salmon Fisherman I am disturbed by the lack of fish caught in recent years. My fishing trips to Scotland are greatly valued due to lack of available time and finances and I feel that if the chances of catching are diminishing then I may need try different venues.22312015-01-26T22:21:23.977724Alice BaconPlease take a long-sighted view of this issue. The Scottish Atlantic salmon could be here for generations, could remain an iconic Scottish species, of whose conservation we can be proud. Or they numbers could continue to decline, one day to non-viable numbers. Let's not look back in decades time and wish we had acted more wisely. Let's be cautious, recognise their value and fragility. Please don't prioritise short-term economic gain, please think about the bigger picture. \r\nwith best wishes,\r\nAlice22312015-01-27T12:40:48.2077725gillian strachan Staff often have no understanding or know strategies to keep the situation calm . It's not an issue of control but how to keep an environment calm.I kid with social and communication skills that are impaired need protected not emotionally and mentally scarred for life.Restraint should be used as last resort and not cause staff have mishandled a situation.If this is used staff should immediately be retrained on strategies and actually use the correct strategies.My daughter was so upset to being restrained and that no one was understanding her.She was scared and felt cornered that a scared rabbit in headlights\r\n22362015-01-27T23:18:08.7537726Peter BarlowI have worked with and restrained young people in an institutional setting. \r\nLast resort too often gets edged out by heightened emotions. \r\nStrict guidelines and accountability are essential. 22362015-01-30T08:24:13.0377728Anna Williams this is adisgrace why is this aloud to happen are wee back in the dark ages No22362015-01-31T13:36:44.57730Fiona SinclairThis is an excellent and long overdue petition, and one which Autism Rights is happy to back, as it has long been a central plank of our campaigning that abuses do happen in Scottish schools and other institutions and parents have little power to prevent these happening. We think the recommendations in the petition are a good start, but that other measures, such as disability specific educational standards and open access for parents to their child's school or care facility are also essential. We put together Proposals for Autism Services some years ago, which are available to read on our website.\r\n\r\nI seconded a recent petition, on behalf of Autism Rights PE01494 Mental Health Legislation and have signed the most recent petition by Andrew Muir of Psychiatric Rights Scotland PE01550 Mental Health Act inquiry. Thank you to Beth for signing this. Autism Rights' written evidence to PE01494 is available through this petition's webpage. Autism Rights also submitted responses to the Scottish Government's \r\nconsultation on the Draft Mental Health Bill and to the Parliament's Health and Sport Committee's consultation on the Bill. We believe that the deficiencies of the education provided to children with Autistic Spectrum Disorders in Scotland contribute to challenging behaviour, which is then chemically coshed with psychiatric drugs, making both behaviour and health much worse in the longer term.22362015-02-01T21:04:42.977731Lisa Hogg I am really shocked by this. I have a child that attends a school for children with complex learning disabilities and I am gobsmacked there are no national guidelines on restraint. Who protects our vulnerable children as if parents don't have enough to worry about. 22362015-02-04T17:50:10.2977733Fiona KilnerThis is a cruel and barbaric practice that must be stopped.22052015-02-04T19:19:21.887734christine shekletonsir,madam please consider this very carefully as these collars are being used with folk for the wrong reasons on dogs also there is no reason anyone should ever need to use these on dogs what so ever, it is absolutely cruel for these to be used and they should be banned completely and any one caught using one on any dog should receive a heavy court fine. animals can not defend themselves we are the voices for animals and must be heard thank you very much from the bottom of my heart and everyone involved trying to stop this horrid item .22052015-02-04T19:43:34.5037735Roger Whymanshould be banned not encouraged22052015-02-04T22:21:17.7337736james butlerBan these vile tools, dog training supposed to be fun not painful22052015-02-04T22:41:04.7677737Fran parkinBarbaric , horrific ,unnecessary , should be banned , and anyone found using them should be prosecuted , how can anyone responsible justify there use!!22052015-02-04T23:07:01.9577738Kimberley McLeodIt's barbaric22052015-02-04T23:18:16.7537739RosiepompomThis barbaric cruelty must stop!22052015-02-04T23:23:05.637740RosiepompomBeing used to terrify poor animalss22052015-02-05T00:42:52.277741Jean wilsonThis is cruel and there is no need to use such evil items on any animal. Ban them now!22052015-02-05T08:38:30.287742Sue smithStop allowing this cruelty to continue 22052015-02-05T08:49:11.1277743Jacqueline AshworthTotally unnecesary!!!!!!!!22052015-02-05T08:56:47.9877745diana wardanyone who is an animal lover wouldnt have these in the first place22052015-02-05T11:16:56.637754Sheena ClarkPlease ban these collars. 22052015-02-05T11:42:02.8937755Judy Matthewsstop this inhumane training method22052015-02-05T11:52:21.6777756corrine combeShocking that this is still legal!22052015-02-05T12:03:50.197758sam combeStop the abuse 22052015-02-05T13:18:43.5977759IRENA PATERSONIT IS TIKME THAT DECENT, AFFORDABLE HOUSING WAS AVAILABLE TO PEOPLE WHO ARE DISABLED - INSTEAD WE HAVE TO STRUGGLE ON WITH WHAT WE HAVE GOT22552015-02-05T14:38:44.4737760John BurgoyneI support this22752015-02-05T15:34:42.7537761Ross StrattonThis Is A Awful To Know We Treat animals in this way they can be hurt just like us so we are the same in many ways how about we switch positions the you will be quick on banning it 22052015-02-05T16:46:21.3177762Kay connarFar to cruel to use22052015-02-05T20:25:01.1577763Franca Bruno ScotlandThe whole of Scotland should be designated a National Park. It's a civilised wilderness.22752015-02-05T20:46:44.4737764karen faircloughI fully support the ban of electric shock collars. These cause far more harm than good however the vibration collar is a different tool entirely causing zero pain or discomfort. These collars are VITAL for many deaf dogs to be able to lead a life off leash as they are meant to. These vibration collars are the source of their recall, keeping them safe. \r\nTo put the two in the same bracket shows ignorance and lack of reseach for these tools. 22052015-02-07T07:02:27.167767Boyd EvansBe wise and reuse brown sites, use grants to off set the differential cost to that of green sites.22752015-02-07T09:04:36.5377768William CummingsDisgraceful we have to petition for this22442015-02-07T10:12:29.1437769Robert MaundThis is long overdue and Scotland is missing a great opportunity.22752015-02-07T11:27:48.7877770Debra StorrParticularly keen to see a Marine and Coastal national park - but with careful consideration of any impacts on residents's livilhoods. \r\n22752015-02-08T15:38:16.7877771rizia robertsonShock collars are never necessary. Please do not go to any trainer who uses them. There are many qualified Force Free trainers in Scotland now who are well versed in positive training. If the ban goes through, I hope the outdated trainers who use them will either go out of business or take it upon themselves to be educated in all things dog.\r\nProngs and choke collars are just as bad btw22052015-02-08T21:06:34.167772Judith Maundevery one who treasures Scotland's landscape should support this strategy22752015-02-09T08:51:38.697773Keith MycockAction is required immediately before it is too late. Scotland is renowned for is landscapes throughout the world. The uncontrolled wind farm development is fast destroying its natural heritage, an increase in National Park status for more areas is vital to provide some safe areas particularly in the South West of the country such as The Stewartry of Dumfries and Galloway.22752015-02-09T10:50:45.1437774Shelley MorrisonPlease share this petition. We need to \r\nstop this barbaric way of training. The more people that are made aware the more people will sign the petition. Thankyou 22052015-02-09T12:58:25.57775Archibald and Sybil Simpson When Scotland gained its own Parliament in 1999 one would have thought that at some point, creation of more national parks in order to protect our exceptional landscapes would have been high on MSPs' Agenda. Sadly no matter the political party, this is not the case. In fact the current Government are rushing to destroy some of our iconic landscapes by overriding the opinion of the Scottish people as far as wind farm sites are concerned. 22752015-02-09T15:18:22.3177776Alastair McLeodI fully support the aim to create a National Park in this area for many reasons, but in particular to ensure that we set aside some areas that can be free from industrial wind factories and their associated environmental damage.22752015-02-09T15:36:35.1877777Trevor ProcterDumfries & Galloway seems to be the dumping ground for wind turbines destroying the landscape & needs protection.22752015-02-09T15:38:45.0637778Moira KennedyIt seems that areas of outstanding natural beauty are under more threat than ever with the proliferation of inappropriately sited wind farms. There is no structure in place to safeguard Scotland's prized landscapes, unspoilt coastal sanctuaries and wild landscapes. Given that Scotland is famous for exceptional scenery, it would seem that the protection that National Park Status may give is more critical than ever. 22752015-02-09T19:32:33.2537779holly reid-fosterIt is about for this, there are far too many times that the child is not treated fairly and that needs to stop, rather than incompetent individuals using what they see as an easy short term solution.22362015-02-09T21:01:08.4077780Kenneth YatesScotland differentiates itself by demonstrating that it cares for its people. Let's get this done.22442015-02-09T21:38:40.3937782David WhannelGalloway Forest should be up there, or down there, depending which way you look at things, a lot easier to make it the first fully accessible national park.22752015-02-09T21:48:44.757783Cecilie MackinnonNational Guidelines must be a mandatory code of conduct. 22362015-02-09T22:04:27.387784joe jacksonits the least that they can do for any veteran, infact more should be done to help veterans 22442015-02-09T23:28:03.6777785William CrawfordUrgent action is needed to save the beauty of our scenery and countryside from the destructive development of windfarms.22752015-02-09T23:57:23.5037786John GrahamOne area that craves protection is Glen Affric and Strathglass. Already partly within wild land it would benefit from being a National park22752015-02-10T04:14:35.4077787Alex wilsonI AM assets as being 82% disabled and for the last two years I have not been allowed to have a companion on my card because I don't have full rate DLA so my card is not used as much as I can because it is easier to use the car I have told Scottish transport I have full mobility on my war disability pension as a result of a gunshot wound when I was in the Falklands but they say it makes no difference as the rules say top rate DLA or attendance allowance is this fare to take it away after I have gotten used to having it\r\n22442015-02-10T09:54:15.647788John MayhewAs the Petitioner I hope that those of you who have commented might find it helpful if I respond to some of your comments. Debra Storr - yes, a Coastal and Marine National Park is one of our seven priorities - please see our 'Unfinished Business' report on the SCNP or APRS websites - there is a link to the report in the Petition. And yes, supporting local livelihoods in fragile areas is one of the reasons for designating National Parks. Keith Mycock, Trevor Procter and David Whannel - yes Galloway is also one of our seven priorities - please see our 'Unfinished Business' report - link given above.22752015-02-10T11:14:05.7077790Gabrielle HarringtonOne is torn between the need for a motorway connection with the Stranraer-Cairnryan seaport and the need to preserve the unspoilt nature of Galloway. I am unsure what National Park status would mean in this respect. However, if we leave this conundrum to one side, National Park status would, I think, be of overall benefit.22752015-02-10T11:45:45.5037791John MayhewAlastair McLeod - I'd be interested to know to which area you are referring, but thanks for your support. Moira Kennedy and David Whannel - the Scottish Government does not allow wind farms in National Parks, so if there were more National Parks there would be more areas set aside from such major industrial development. John Graham - yes, Glen Affric is one of our seven priority areas. Please see our 'Unfinished Business' report on the SCNP or APRS websites - there is a link to it in the Petition.22752015-02-10T12:46:38.37792John MayhewGabrielle Harrington - it would mean that any motorway or dual carriageway would have to be constructed to particularly high standards to minimise its landscape impact, but National Park status does not in itself prevent road construction. Also, although drawing the detailed boundary would be for a future stage, a Galloway National Park might not include much of the A75 corridor. It would be more likely to focus on the existing coastal National Scenic Areas or on the upland area covered by the Forest Park.22752015-02-10T12:53:12.057793Robert ReidBob Reid Retired Scottish Countryside Ranger I support having more National Parks where ever they are decided on. Any proposed Marine N.P. should include where it has a coastal zone Then its boundary should also include the watershed land which is within any designated.\r\nAlso that any Ranger Service for such NEW Parks should be ESTABLISHED as part of the existence Scottish National identifiable Ranger Service along with it National Identifiable Badge (building on 40 years of delivering a professional service), in the protecting our countryside and providing opportunities for the people of Scotland 22752015-02-10T13:07:50.7677794William McDermottJust having attended a conference on Protected Areas and catching up on the latest fact that Scotland is losing its biodiversity at a rapid pace, we need to get serious about proper conservation of our natural heritage. \r\nFundamentally, it is in mankind's own interest to expand the areas focussing on conservation of natural capital. Scotland is pretty near the bottom of the league when compared to other countries.22752015-02-10T17:10:32.1177795Peter OgdenThe landscapes of National Parks no matter where they are, represent icons of a country's identity,national heritage and sense of place in the world. Scotland's landscapes are no exception and their quality, diversity and the contribution they make to the nation's well being should be more fully recognised. \r\nAll nationally important landscapes in Scotland like their counterparts in Wales, are special places which must be safeguarded as they uniquely reflect our collective past and will undoubtedly help us play a major part in determining our future quality of life. They have an increasingly important role to play in bringing people and places together, are fundamental to our health and well-being, and are an important part of a nation's identity. It is critical that the value of all of Scotland's finest landscapes and the special role they play in everyone's life is therefore properly recognised and actively promoted in all levels of decision making both nationally and locally. \r\nIt is for these reasons that the Campaign for the Protection of Rural Wales wholeheartedly supports this petition\r\n\r\nPeter Ogden: Director \r\nCPRW \r\n10th February 2015 22752015-02-10T19:10:58.3437796derek HughesVeterans should be given this. The cost will be minimal in relation to other funding..ie foreign and social issues 22442015-02-10T19:17:20.3677797Nic BullivantNational Parks need a job to do, it's not just a gold star for being braw. There are plenty of jobs that need doing in Lochaber, Skye, Assynt. Then the jobs need doing, with the NP leading the way, not sitting back and 'enabling' other people to do them. The best way of doing many of the jobs that need doing is through a Ranger Service, part of the progressive Scottish family of Ranger Services, sharing their ideals and badge. More National Parks? bring them on, but learn from past mistakes!22752015-02-11T06:53:37.327798Hugh ToobyPart of this effort must be to address head on the elephant in the room of all UK National Parks which is that they are not, in contrast to the situation in virtually all other countries, owned by the nation. As ownership inevitably increases control this means that UK Parks are much weaker in what they can achieve in terms of conservation and rewilding. If we're serious about preserving these parts of our national ecosystem, which are vital for human wellbeing, then we need to grasp this nettle firmly and soon.22752015-02-11T08:15:41.3337799Stefano Gayfor an Italian who run away from Europe to British Columbia I can say that a greener Europe will be a better place for our kids in the future to stay. Politician... be smart....Enlarge more Parks area in Scotland !22752015-02-11T11:37:26.247800Wolfgang JabsA previous comment includes the need for areas of coast and the sea to be included in the call for more National Parks. Marine Reserves or National Parks will help to conserve seabed habitat and help to replenish fish stocks.22752015-02-11T12:57:16.8337801Robert ShieldsThe very least we can give for their service22442015-02-11T13:03:22.657802lynette mcgregorwe need this to help us look after our children22552015-02-11T13:05:18.627803paul galvintake the time to sign this22552015-02-11T13:33:45.9737804Catherine MathesonToo much power lies with Occupational Therapists who seem to suggest very few options for house adaptations. Hopefully, more accessible housing will help, but, even if this petition is successful, it won't help those who can't afford to buy a new house as many will still have to remain in unsuitable housing due to high rents for adapted accommodation.22552015-02-11T15:12:50.947805Christiaan W von Hesse-NassauEx Black Watch, as was my Great Grandfather. War veterans give much more than we can imagine.22442015-02-11T16:27:48.8777806Robert ThirdeWe lose control of our "wild and unspoilt" places at our peril. 22752015-02-11T17:35:17.8037807Neil bromilowAlthough we know we are fighting a losing battle against the signal crayfish if we do nothing we will achieve nothing.22792015-02-11T18:38:55.777808margarita williamsThe majority of Harris residents were for NPStatus for Harris. WE were robbed of it by lack of support from majority Lewis Councillors. The SNP Government then chose not to Support 22752015-02-11T22:05:52.67809Stephen PorchI agree with Mr Tooby's comment below. I think we would need to designate a huge area which connects the existing national parks, embracing it as an example of true conservation (i.e. rewilding). This would restore a vast expanse of lost habitats and degraded ecosystems in the heart of Scotland and provide a vital lifeline to the rest of the country.22752015-02-12T09:40:21.2777810James FentonThe Land Reform consultation provides an opportunity for considerably more of the wilder and remoter areas of Scotland to be designated as NPs, ideally under state-ownership22752015-02-12T10:07:53.987811dori jacksonland being spoiled scenically and, in many cases, ruined for food production which may be desperately needed in future. Small domestic windmills attached to individual properties should be a viable and compulsary alternative.22752015-02-12T11:07:55.9337812Robert Kevin ConnellScotland's landscapes are internationally precious but under the cavalier and ill-informed attitude of the Scottish Government to them - demonstrated by the proliferation of industrialised development, notably wind turbines - there is a danger that the tranquilllity, beauty and spiritual value of these landscapes will be lost. National Parks will provide a primary and effective instrument of landscape protection, allowing the deterring of inappropriate development, whether on a small- or large-scale.22752015-02-12T12:11:41.2177813Margaret TregearI have been a frequent visitor to Scotland and am heartbroken at what is happening to Scotland's beautiful landscapes. Turbines will never be able to replace conventional energy sources - all this destruction is pointless.22752015-02-12T12:15:20.2777814Iain AitkenShort sighted planning decisions mean that future generations will never be able to enjoy the landscapes we inherited unspoilt from our ancestors. We are only the custodians of our heritage for future generations. 22752015-02-12T14:48:51.157815Angus JackLong overdue. I can think of a few areas worthy of the designation, Harris, Assynt, Torridon, Small Isles to name a few!22752015-02-12T15:39:25.2337816Richard DixonI hope this works out favourably for nature and people interested in wilderness and beauty.22752015-02-12T15:45:52.6377817Darrel wilsonAmerican signal crayfish are ruining the tourism in our area which we rely on.\r\nFishing clubs used to come for weeks keeping our local shops hotels going now its all very minimal .\r\nCrayfish are a nenace turns a cheap hobby into a very expensive one22792015-02-12T16:14:15.9537818Kate SangerCome on Scotland it time to use positive support rather than control! it is time to stop holding down children because they are anxious,or in pain, or experiencing sensory overload, it is time to give your teachers the skills and knowledge to understand the function of challenging behaviour and what positive strategies can be put in place. It says something about us when we treat our most vulnerable in this manner, time for guidelines are long overdue.22362015-02-12T20:25:34.6537819David WhannelThe Galloway Forest would make a perfect fully accessible national park, only 2 hours from the UK's most popular with the potential for much more wildlife, particularly that which has been hunted to extinction, bring it all back here, in style.\r\nA larger area than just the Galloway Forest would be best, stretch it right out to include more of the borders, Peebles etc to draw in visitors looking also to visit Edinburgh.22752015-02-12T20:32:06.5377820Catriona MulliganHaving spent 30 years working in protected landscapes in England and Wales, I have no doubt that many more of Scotland's finest landscapes would benefit from National Park status22752015-02-12T23:19:39.7237822George F WoodMore National Parks\r\nLess Wind-Turbines & Less Solar PV !!!22752015-02-13T06:53:14.257824Brian TylerScotland has wonderful countryside. I have enjoyed it both within and outwith the existing Parks.Extending these would bring many benefits to Scotland and to its people. 22752015-02-13T08:45:11.0977825Peter LivingstoneI would like to see this movement go hand in hand with rewilding core wilderness areas22752015-02-13T08:57:33.3277826Andrew ShiellsLets hope the parks save us from any more useelss, ugly, wind turbines!22752015-02-13T17:13:14.4577827christina TAYLORWords fail me. 22362015-02-13T17:22:04.9737828Beryl LeatherlandScotland's landscapes and natural heritage are iconic and valued throughout the world. They are deserving of national Park status. In Norway, a country with a similar population to ours, there are over 10 NPs and they are designated for a variety of reasons and are valued for the contributions they make to national life, culture and the economy. it is time we emulated them!!22752015-02-13T18:02:19.7237829Christine Stringer MrsParents, or any other adult can be prosecuted if they smack or assault a none disabled child, so why is it acceptable to assault a disabled child ? Do the government think that disabled children are worth less than a none disabled child ? ?22362015-02-13T19:35:58.557830Claudia HasseAll of the North of Scotland should be considered WorldHeritage Site and given the right protection ,and the sooner the better !22752015-02-14T11:55:08.8377831Gill KorszanskiPlease protect our environment and health.\r\nEnough is enough22752015-02-14T11:57:21.2277832Roman KorszanskiSafeguard the beauty of Scotland22752015-02-14T13:54:22.7837833Francis William CarcasIt is absolutely ludicrous that the petitioner has been given only 9 days to get signatures on this petition. It smacks of an intention to dismiss the whole subject on the basis that there is insufficient support for the petition. Unless action is taken this problem is only going to get worse. The American Signal Crayfish is an invasive, non-native species and it is important that it should be at least controlled, but at best eradicated. Given enough time to publicise it, I am confident that the signatures would run into the thousands.22792015-02-15T10:48:59.567835Gillian FoulkesIt seems that the Scottish Government will not stand up for its landscape which is a very short-sighted view. If they really cared about Scotland this would not be necessary. 22752015-02-15T16:42:13.9777836sarah fellowsThis is shocking behaviour. My son is autistic, my son can show complex behaviour if he is worried or someone has shouted at him for something he didnt understand...There is not enough training on children22362015-02-15T17:47:52.747839Mary ZimmermanI hope u get this approved22362015-02-15T19:30:33.77840linda coleman All children should be free from distress feel safe and overall wellbeing should be of paramount importance.22362015-02-15T19:46:22.47841Peter FoulkesScotland's mountains and moorlands should be at the forefront of landscape conservation,not catching up. How about a 'Nationalised' Park so that its conservation is not at the behest of landowners?22752015-02-15T21:47:21.7877842Philip KerrThere must be an alternative means of planning which will not compromise the beauty of Scotland's landscape22752015-02-15T23:31:52.0877843MaryAnn McComb I am shocked & disappointed that there are no national guidelines on restraint. We need to b protecting our vulnerable children.22362015-02-16T08:09:25.337844Gail DuddridgeSigned22362015-02-16T08:55:31.9537845Maureen Moore This needs to be delt with instantly get your act together we voted you in so you work for the public !!!!22362015-02-16T10:44:59.377846ModeratorFrancis William Carcas - the petitioner is keen for this petition to be considered by the Public Petitions Committee at its meeting in Dumfries on Monday 23 February. Only one signature is required for a petition to be considered by the Committee, there is no required threshold for support. All petitions are considered on their merits and anyone may make a submission to the Committee.22792015-02-16T11:18:54.977847Richard BirdNot sure that I can support this petition. Whilst it is very good in principle the problem with National Parks is that the park authorities seem to think it is a reason to block all kinds of development. People live in National Parks and have the right to earn their living there. In particular I am talking about mineral extraction and point out that quarrying in areas now designated a national park is all but banned. This is not the way national parks should be governed. Note the recent ridiculous situation in Loch Lomond & Trossachs NP where the planning authority tried to stop the opening of a gold mine. Agreed no more wind turbines but mineral extraction should have a code of practice and not an outright ban. 22752015-02-16T14:27:22.1777848Christina FisherI believe we as a country should be pro-active in preserving native species and indigenous eco systems22792015-02-16T14:31:13.187849Christina FisherI can't believe electric collars are still in use and it was found to be nescessary to petition for their removal22052015-02-16T15:30:41.4977850Ian CrosbieSigned and Shared22672015-02-16T16:25:38.57852Alice RourkeFree trade in Scoyland22672015-02-16T19:24:30.7377853Ellen C ColemanIt is a disgrace the lack of adapted houses. I wholeheartedly support this petition.22552015-02-16T22:54:14.4177854Lyndsey Hayesevery child has a right!. No child should be subjected to this no matter what there personal needs are, there needs to be guideliness and training implemented here for staff to deal with situations with dignity and safety for all involved. 22362015-02-17T08:31:52.2837855Mrs Maria Emily DenyerRegarding a Marine and Coastal Park, I would like to see Tentsmuir Nature Reserve, N E Fife given consideration.22752015-02-17T09:00:53.8477856James HuntThere is no scientific evidence that trapping can be used to control or eradicate Signal Crayfish. Such an exercise would be futile and would increase the likelihood of movements of Crayfish to other catchments22792015-02-17T17:06:35.9637858Gillian LoughranAutism Eye magazine has a campaign 'Stop the Abuse of Chill Out Rooms'. We have evidence from whistle blowing teachers that this abuse is happening in schools right across the UK. Stop this abuse and protect vulnerable children. 22362015-02-18T11:27:38.167859Paul BradleyUnfortunately, there is no evidence to support a proposition that trapping can ever realistically be expected to eradicate a population of signal crayfish. Furthermore, there is no evidence to support a proposition that trapping can be any more effective in controlling American signal crayfish than attempts to control Japanese knotweed by cutting. The untrapped proportion of a population is broadly analogous to the rhizomes of Japanese knotweed, which it is widely accepted no amount of cutting will control.\r\n\r\nHowever, trapping of signal crayfish is not a benign activity, trapping activity is very likely to increase the risk that signal crayfish will be spread to new areas, whether accidentally, deliberately, or recklessly. Hence, there is understandably huge concern amongst game fisheries in Scotland regarding any proposal to trap signal crayfish.\r\n\r\nScotland will do well to look south of the border. Trapping in England has certainly incentivised a small and ill-informed minority to deliberately introduce signal crayfish to new areas, such as discovered by EA in the lower Lune catchment (Cumbria) in 2013. Removal activity has also increased the likelihood of incidental releases to new areas, whether by deliberate ill-informed release (such as occurred at Ensor's Pool SAC), dumping of unwanted catch (such as found by EA in the upper Lune catchment (Cumbria) in October 2014, or escapes during live transport from trapping sites (such as reported at Redwell Fishery, Cumbria).\r\n\r\nAt present, I'm afraid, the best that we can do is to minimise the risk that signal crayfish will be introduced to new areas. If there is an answer to this problem, it is most likely to be found by research scientists at the molecular level, and there is likely to be a strong case for additional funding of such research in Scotland.22792015-02-18T16:18:37.6477860Scott Bamford10% accessibility housing should be an absolute minimum when investing in a future ageing population. We need to be building infrastructure now for the future.22552015-02-18T20:56:44.6277861Kevin FauldsIf more people sign, then other people will have to listen...22552015-02-19T16:06:43.937862walter Wells PattersonGood Luck with the petition22552015-02-19T18:29:58.917863Bea HoldenCompletely in favour of the Galloway National Park which would cover the Merrick area, Loch Trool and Loch Doon. I live very close to this area and am involved in tourism. It would be very beneficial, especially as it would include the Galloway Dark Sky Park and Galloway and Southern Ayrshire Biosphere, plus the Galloway Forest Park. Along with the Wild Land designation this area has there is no other location like this in the world - it is unique. I also have experience of the Cairngorm National Park and have witnessed all the improvements and developments they have instigated and permitted. A National Park does not mean 'no' to new developments at all, rather they seem to encourage and assist in sustainable and appropriate developments.\r\nPlease support the new Scottish National Parks.22752015-02-20T10:19:40.9637864Ro BellJust do it - it is the right thing. This is Scotland, we believe in doing the right thing.22552015-02-20T14:07:40.2837865Tom Speirs (Ex Black Watch)Most worthy cause, just a pity the Government of the day hadn't implemented this already. 22442015-02-21T11:02:14.277867Ian DonnachieWould be of enormous benefit to the whole region adn add diversity to the National Park estate generally.22752015-02-21T16:56:43.3877868Shirley McHughI know people who have been trapped for over a year in their home because there is no ramp. It's time everyone has access to both the outside world and every room in their house.22552015-02-22T15:29:11.9137869Robert Hunterits not much to ask the government to give after what so many veterans gave this country22442015-02-22T18:02:55.2877870David HawkerGalloway and South Ayrshire has a Biosphere Reserve centred around The Merrick and Corserine Hills which would be ideal for the creation of the third Scottish National park. This already is an area for tourism and the local communities are very supportive of the present designation. It has the potential to create more jobs in the area and assist in the conservation of the most southerly wild land in Scotland. 22752015-02-22T19:36:21.9377871Jon ProctorParticularly concerned about dredging in coastal waters and its effects on Marine life. Also why we have to have pylons and not a sub see cable for electricity distribution across west coast.22752015-02-23T00:29:18.6077872Alastair RichardsonThe creation of Parks increases public interest and will encourage better management of our unique and beautiful country22752015-02-24T15:33:23.3737874Maureen McPeakIt is vital this petition is successful to enable disabled people to play an active part in their local communities and not be isolated in inaccessible houses or in residential care.22552015-02-25T10:18:39.0677875Michael DolanI think the National Park designation, makes people cherish and use their countryside and landscape even more.22752015-02-25T13:34:00.187876Alistair BeeleyI suppose the best way to preserve our wonderful landscape heritage is by creating National Parks, though they do need pretty robust terms of reference to achieve this. Certainly Inverpolly & the Cuillins Skye are areas that come to mind immediately but one could consider the entire western and northern areas of Scotland, including coastal and marine environments should be included22752015-02-25T16:57:48.747877james fenderI have waited 4years on a house or ground floor property and got refused several times saying not suitable for wheelchair 22552015-02-25T17:35:30.0077878Carol CareyIt's shocking that a country as beautiful as Scotland has only two national parks. 22752015-02-25T18:01:38.9737879Mark AitkenWe need to fully protect and support Scotland's stunning landscapes and seascapes. Further National Park designations will help this. 22752015-02-25T21:31:53.4777881Finlay CarsonI would promote as the ideal location of a marine and land based national park22752015-02-25T22:06:05.4437882Per BulloughScotland is claimed by many to have the finest landscapes in the world. We should be ashamed that these landscapes have so little protection.22752015-02-26T11:57:58.1477883Neil MacNaughtonScotland's amazing wild landscapes have suffered more than enough from from totally inappropriate developments, with no end to the push for so-called green energy. There is a monetary value to wild land as recent research has again confirmed. We must protect our scenic and wild lands for future generations and more National Parks would ensure protection of this valuable resource. 22752015-02-26T13:06:14.2737884philip maherHope this goes through.22752015-02-26T15:10:37.547885Bob McChristieagree totally22752015-02-26T15:11:06.687886Ian GibbWe used to be excellent with this, my late father was disabled and couldn't even obtain a disabled parking permit! Perhaps they thought he would grow another leg, having left his in Germany back in 1945.22552015-02-26T23:08:36.637887Kenneth W JohnsonTwo national parks, both inland does not reflect the diversity of Scotland's landscape. Other types of designation (SSSI, Regional Park etc.) do not give protection form encroachment and reduction of unspoiled land.22752015-02-27T12:12:40.547889andrea weedingMany thank-you's to the person organizing this petition, from rabbits every where, especially the 67,000 rescued rabbits in this country, enough's enough, the ignorance and cruelty needs to end for these poor, wonderful, creatures. Because they deserve better. Thank-you to the Scottish Parliament for addressing this important animal welfare issue too.22922015-02-27T13:20:01.357890Sandra HarveyMy house rabbits have given me endless joy over ten + years. Rabbits deserve to be well looked after, not stuck in a small hutch at the bottom of the garden to freeze or die of heat stroke. As pets rabbits are wonderful company and more than reward time and effort of their owner.\r\nBunnies deserve Better!!!22922015-02-27T13:20:25.5877891Louie b.Freethank you so very much for your consideration of this important , humane issue22922015-02-27T13:43:33.1477892LINDA BADHAMTHE LAWS NEED TO BE CHANGED TO PROTECT RABBITS AND ALL ANIMALS FROM HARM !! THEY SUFFER IN SILENCE.22922015-02-27T14:07:41.387894Mr Maurice McPhillimeyHope they accept this petition. . We need to protect the land for our children and childrens children. \r\n22752015-02-27T14:10:53.1177896Delores LowisRabbits should never be sold in pet shops. They are a delicate being who requires a very special home.22922015-02-27T14:23:08.7877897Lesley McCulloch I just think all animals should have rights and protection it's the least they deserve, they have no voice and no choice so we need to do the right thing for them22922015-02-27T14:42:49.357899Craig MelterThis is an opportunity to show the world you are more civilized and honorable than the US. Please act in support of bunny lovers and animal rights supporters of the world.22922015-02-27T15:08:03.137900Hazel Nicholls These beautiful animals have feelings and needs just as we do and other 22922015-02-27T15:08:29.5077901Annamarie gammonI believe all pet shops should have more rules set out to people when they want a pet rabbit, they should be asked if they have the room and time and space, and the money to spend on a pet rabbit.22922015-02-27T15:38:36.827902Sue HardieYes they are expensive pets. Just paid almost £90 for 2 injections.22922015-02-27T16:11:55.2437903Deborah CowanUntil there are no more unwanted animals in shelters, particularly rabbits, they should be unquantifiabley banned from being irresponsibly bred and sold to people who are unaware of the special needs that rabbits require to be cared for adequately. No animal should be seen as a novelty item.22922015-02-27T16:37:29.3377904sue petersvery worthy cause and needs to be supported enough rabbits and animals in general should not be sold in pet shops ever 22922015-02-27T16:44:51.7277905Ann Marie signed 22922015-02-27T17:26:07.3977906richie taityou need to also stop the selling of buns and other small furries in garden centres \r\n22922015-02-27T17:57:15.2877907LIINDA BOYCEthese little bunnies deserve much more compassion than what they get they are neglected and they don't deserve it they are so cute22922015-02-27T18:03:42.2577908dj powersplease sing!!\r\n22922015-02-27T18:18:10.6637909Samantha S ReevesRabbits are truly wonderful and inquisitive animals, they deserve these rights!22922015-02-27T18:45:40.5077910Jay EvansRabbits deserve as much help as any other pet, if not more. The amount of rabbits I myself looked after which were mainly due to neglect, should never have happened. These are adorable little creatures who are not meant to be children's pets and should not live in a small hutch down the bottom of the garden.\r\nGive rabbits the love, the proper food, the proper accommodation and a partner or two and you will find that they become your loyalist friend. Please help them, they desperately need it. 22922015-02-27T20:11:26.3977911Pamela BouldenThank you for caring. This is an issue close to my heart. 22922015-02-27T20:16:59.997912Rita MaleckiI also would like to see all hutches without runs banned. they rabbit needs to jump and run in their home. if they can't it's not big enough.22922015-02-27T20:42:09.717913Maggie AllinsonRabbits are so misunderstood, they are beautiful sociable little animals who make wonderful house pets - too many are neglected and spend their lives sad and lonely - bunnies deserve better!22922015-02-27T21:39:15.2577914Amy ShermanIts about time that rabbits and other smaller animals have equal rights as cats and dogs!22922015-02-27T22:49:57.2577915Bryony Darnell Come on Scotland! Rabbits should be on a par rights-wise with cats and dogs. They are fragile special creatures whose needs are often misunderstood. They need legislative protection - please help... 22922015-02-28T08:04:26.967916Julie GoldsackMany parents need to realise pets are not simply play things for children, and need the correct care and living conditions. This petition will hopefully help. 22922015-02-28T11:21:52.1637917Danielle Brinkleythis should be the case everywhere!!22922015-02-28T11:34:23.4937918karen foreyIt makes me so sad to see rabbits being neglected,people need to realise that they take a lot of looking after if they are to be healthy and happy,so many end up abandoned as owners cant be bothered,I have had three rescue bunnies,I adored them,please help us protect rabbits from any further harm.22922015-02-28T14:02:19.6937919Colleen FoxKeeping rabbits in little hutches is downright cruel. Rabbits need freedom to exercise and be rabbits.22922015-02-28T16:51:44.437920Rebecca LeeThis is so important because rabbits make wonderful pets. But they are less vocal than dogs and cats so need our protection more\r\n22922015-02-28T18:07:26.3377921catherine Irvine Stop breeders from breeding there are thousands needing homes from adoption centres 22922015-02-28T18:28:18.3677922Jacqueline Reevesa hutch is not enough22922015-02-28T18:52:19.187923nandalal prabhuI would like to see the rabbit hutches banned world wide. 22922015-03-01T02:32:54.1477924JACQUELINE MCKAYGIVE BUNNIES THE PROTECTION THEY DESERVE 22922015-03-01T07:16:49.5077925Bettina AshtonThis must end, rescues are heaving and people really are ignorant about the care and behaviour of rabbits. Show England their not taking action despite the public urging them too for years now, reveals how archaic and ignorant that DEFRA is too and that Scotland is knowledgeable and progressive.22922015-03-01T07:28:33.3037926Bianca DiazPlease listen!22922015-03-01T09:26:33.9477927Marion ThomsonNational Park status gives international recognition to our beautiful and diverse landscapes and it also offers opportunities to address the long standing need for better integration of rural policies and to demonstrate these in practice. The two designated National Parks are a 'good start' but need to be supplemented by representatives of other valued Scottish landscapes and habitats.Please bring on the work required to achieve this. I would also add a more local comment that I believe that the so called 'forgotten areas' of sw Scotland really benefit from such a designation. 22752015-03-01T09:27:11.357928Anne LeviWe need to cherish and protect our beautiful landscapes with more than just words.22752015-03-01T09:35:49.1777929Erica SarneyThe Scottish Government have allowed the ruination of huge tracks of land through wind farm development - save what is left for future generations.22752015-03-01T10:35:18.467930David WoodhouseIt is quite shocking for any sane person to absorb, that Scotland has the worst record in the whole of Europe on creation of National Parks,22752015-03-01T11:51:52.8837931lynn sedgwickI have a house rabbit and I've kept rabbits for most of my life. It's great to hear that finally it's being understood that rabbits have feelings and need lots of space and love.22922015-03-01T14:02:45.1777932Ian PascoeIt is ridiculous that Scotland only has two parks, one of which has part of what should be its core area outside its boundary. The Torridon area would be my first choice for a third park but there are several other areas with strong claims eg Glencoe.22752015-03-01T16:09:40.1337933Judith ParkerWe need to do this quickly before we spoil our beautiful landscape and lose archaeology forever.22752015-03-01T17:07:58.857934Andrew LeeIt's about time that Rabbits were afforded the same rights and protection that other domestic animals are afforded, widespread ignorance concerning their proper care and a lack of guidelines surrounding housing, toys and food leads to rabbits living (and dying) in extremely poor conditions. \r\nFailure to do something about this is nothing short of tacit complicity in the widespread neglect and mistreatment of these wonderful (but helpless) animals.22922015-03-01T17:49:05.3377938Mr and Mrs Andrew ToddWe need to act quickly before the whole of Scotland is just one big wind farm.22752015-03-01T19:46:36.577939Laura Watkinsplease22922015-03-01T19:58:41.1977940Margaret BradburneI have had pet rabbits for many years and they are playful,clever ,loving creatures.They need space and toys.At least 6ft to live22922015-03-01T20:11:31.4777941Joy WoodhouseHow can it be that when our spectacular natural environment is so vital to the rural economy here ,that we still have only two National Parks ??22752015-03-01T21:23:35.047942Louise BarberRabbits are suffering great cruelty and they are gentle, beautiful creatures. Please help stop their suffering. Please.22922015-03-01T23:36:38.827943Sadie DempseyRabbits are gentle, affectionate creatures, who love to be cuddled. They must be allowed freedom to exercise, ideally grazing in a secure garden. Sadly, when the novelty wears off, many are left to rot, all alone in cold, tiny hutches. Heartbreaking.22922015-03-02T14:26:54.6977944R G OLIVERVery necessary22752015-03-02T14:28:35.637945Carol MeiklejohnNo More wind farms in Dumfries and Galloway. Enough already.22752015-03-02T16:55:37.8677946Elizabeth MortonNational Parks are really important for preserving biodiversity and bringing joy into people's lives.22752015-03-02T18:37:52.8837947valerie nordbergI agree that rabbits, rats, mice, hamsters etc. get far less attention than larger animals so their need for protection is comparably greater. But all animals should receive the same respect and care in need.22922015-03-03T10:39:11.7277948carolyn foyYou wouldnt keep your dog or cat in a box why a rabbit pet shops and breeders need to educate buyers before selling on to un knowing owners 22922015-03-03T20:35:41.8037949John BurnsFor a country with such beautiful countryside and coast line ,Scotland needs to formalise its protection. National Parks are the international gold standard for recognising these precious areas. \r\nWhy not take a different approach with any new parks and link the products made, farmed or reared with that National Park, selling it as a gold standard of product.\r\n22752015-03-04T09:49:22.6937951Denise CookDumfries and Galloway has been the place I wanted to live and promote as a beautiful, unspoilt destination, with abundant wildlife and walking opportunities. The placing of wind farms has had a negative impact on the landscape, but what remains is well worth including in a National Park.22752015-03-04T14:11:26.3377953Peter ReillyHaving previousley sat on a Jury at the Glasgow high court, in session for a serious assualt offence, i must admit to being astounded at elements of some jurers reasoning or "interpretation" of the facts! This was some years ago and i still remember with unease, the differences of opinion pertaining to "proven facts" within the jury deliberation. Whilst i agree that the not proven verdict has its place for sure, we must also realise that members of the public, myself included, will often need professional guidance in such circumstances. I think it is paramount that the presiding Judge should have the power to provide additional "professional" guidance to any Jury. 22942015-03-04T16:16:33.077954Neil PorwolIt's time to do away with soft justice22942015-03-05T00:27:46.797955Evie Gordon-LongleyThose who have rabbit companions will tell you that it truly is the same as having a dog or cat companion. There is every reason to bring in laws to give rabbits protection. The powers that be could set a fine example for children to enable them to learn about compassion and responsibility. Please ask anyone who has creature companions to sign this petition.22922015-03-05T01:08:03.67956Robert HamptonWe all know legal proceedings can be complicated, but a fact is a fact and judges should have the common sense and ability to direct a jury as to what are cast iron facts with no room for misinterpretation.22942015-03-05T01:50:20.357957Judy A MakowskiAll animals need our protection from bad breeders, pet shops that don't know how or don't to take proper care of them. As a society we are known by the way we treat our animals, our children and our aged citizens. Please pass this. It could be the impetus all the world needs\r\n22922015-03-05T04:06:05.6177958Eric NelsonRabbits deserve good care and protection just as do any other animal in captivity! Thank you for ensuring all rabbits in Scotland will have these minimum protections and comforts. 22922015-03-05T04:28:27.3677959Cheryl GehrkeRabbits need and deserve the same care in their lives as dogs or cats. They are very sweet and good animals who have great personalities and can give love just as any other animal can. They suffer greatly when they are sold or given to someone who is not interested in their welfare and won't care for them properly. I would like to see rabbits banned from pet shops and from any other stress inducing place. I would like to see people getting rabbits take a course on how to care for them properly. Any one dumping a rabbit should be jailed and fined.22922015-03-05T10:18:51.8677960Alison PearsonHaving been involved with local rescue centres for nearly 30 years I am ecstatic about this petition, and want to see an end once and for all to animals being sold in pet stores and online.22922015-03-05T12:53:35.5877962Susan Petersvery outdated practice selling any animal from Pet Shops - should be banned 22922015-03-05T13:38:41.1337963Scott InmanThank you for stepping up and defending the rights of rabbits! Hopefully the rest of the world will wake up and join this movement. Makes me proud of my Scottish heritage!22922015-03-05T16:03:23.8177964Patricia CoraPlease advocate the below - we are all connected. 22922015-03-05T19:36:31.8037965Laura RaynorHoping for protection of voiceless creatures.22922015-03-05T19:44:10.5237967Lubna Nadia AhmadI love all innocent animals and don't want their exploitation to be continued for long. Hence, I protest against all kinds of torture against animals.22922015-03-05T20:27:17.8337968Cally MillerThings need to change 22942015-03-05T20:33:08.1977969Steve KeicherI believe an element of common-sense needs to prevail when a verdict is considered to be perverse. For example, those with a serious illness may take illegal drugs to relieve their pain and a jury would in my opinion be quite right to acquit (even although the law had been broken) however on the flip side a judge should have the power to refer cases when an acquittal is beyond the realms of reason, common-sense and just doesn't stack up.\r\n22942015-03-06T01:19:37.0537970Debbie PotterI have 7 and they are expensive to keep just like dogs. I am trying to educate people in my area not to buy bunnies for easter by writing a letter each year to the newspapers. Bunnies are more fun, clever and witty than cats but the poor rabbits are treated badly. Bout time people started to treat them with great respect! 22922015-03-06T10:55:04.8677972Alan Foggtime for a change in our system 22942015-03-06T14:03:22.5537973Gemma OrrockThis power should be implemented. 22942015-03-07T04:36:49.857975Effie VourisPlease stop breeding and selling rabbits in pet shops. If you don't have the time for an animal don't have one.22922015-03-07T09:26:23.687976Kenneth MacleodThe sewage sludge is not being sterilised by autoclaving to over 1000 degrees.Check Scottish Water,Holm Park ,Stornaway.22762015-03-07T09:30:42.0377977Bettina MitchellThe 3rd most popular pet needs help too can you sign to petition this?22922015-03-07T16:32:55.8977979Laura WilliamsUK government is not listening to the people when the statistics show that rabbits are the 3rd most popular family pet yet little protection is afforded them despite their status as 3rd popular family pet. The UK government needs to listen to the people's interests by acknowledging this trajectory in pet rabbit interest. If the people of the UK have taken an interest in a matter of consciousness then, naturally, so should the UK government.22922015-03-07T17:35:57.1177980Alan HughesJustice needs to be seen to be done. 22942015-03-07T22:35:59.17981james Hamilton Time for the System to be reviewed !22942015-03-08T18:18:06.187984Sharon hemmingsPlease people need to be educated on the needs of rabbits.its shocking how a lot of people don't care or have not got the common sense to fed and house them properly.Come on people wise up.22922015-03-08T21:06:10.717985Nicola BrownThis needs 2 change22942015-03-08T21:18:39.7437986Sarah Hunter We need to be these silent, beautiful animals voices. 22922015-03-08T22:16:22.7277987Karis BaynhamSomething need to be done to change the law and people should be punished for what they've done22942015-03-09T12:17:08.5677989Marianne Liekens***I LOVE ANIMALS***THEY HAVE THE SAME FEELINGS AND PAIN JUST YOU AND I***STOP22922015-03-09T12:27:14.967990Alan McLeanI strongly believe that by introducing (Perverse Acquittal) into the Criminal Bill Act it will provide a new platform and safety net for judges to have an element of control only where they think that the verdict is perverse, irrational. As we all know the judges has the final say on the law and the jury has the final say on the facts but we must ensure that there are sufficient control measures in place to ensure that our justice system is water tight. The Perverse Acquittal proposal will provide protection for victims and victim families as currently there is no victim appeal process of any kind in place in Scotland. Together we can make a difference, we can make our streets and communities safer places to live in. 22942015-03-09T15:19:22.0837991Alan McLeanI think that judges should have the power to provide guidance to jury's who are undecided as we must ensure that the scales are balanced correctly throughout the duration of the trial.22942015-03-09T15:25:40.6177992Alan McLeanThe Scottish Parliament has a duty to ensure that both the victim and criminal have equal rights as currently the justice system is geared towards the criminal, we need to ensure that equality is in place for everyone i.e. Appeal Process 22942015-03-09T16:52:22.217993julia thomson Hopefully justice will be done one day after your beloved families endless support for this campaign. 22942015-03-09T17:34:26.0237994Duncan SmithALL living beings are sentient creatures and deserve the same protection and right to life as any other. Man is the ONLY animal that degrades others.22922015-03-09T17:56:34.4737995Catherine steel Judges should have the power to provide additional guidance 22942015-03-10T15:23:06.0537998angela cooperI love bunnys easters on the way whats wrong with people still gods creatures 22922015-03-10T15:53:49.577999Fiona Wood rabbits deserve to be treat so much better than they do now. Stop the cruelty. 22922015-03-11T08:19:56.218000Stan PykeRabbits are the third most popular pet in the UK yet are the most neglected by legislation and knowledge. We need to support them in any way we can.22922015-03-11T14:59:14.6478002Kevin HowettWe have two National Parks focused on recreation & local business. There is a real need for a western seaboard Park right down the western side of scotland including the islands that focuses wilderness & conservation & to prevent continued damaging exploitation such as wind farms & poor land management based on outdated Victorian shooting estates. A wild land returned to its wild nature with free access for all for non damaging recreation & giving local business from sustainable environmentally friendly means. A land where the ecosystem is repaired enough to see once lost species such as Lynx & wolf help establish a thriving wilderness legacy we can leave for our children instead of damage & destruction. 22752015-03-11T15:20:46.188003Beverley DowVictims need more support22942015-03-11T15:41:49.7238004Joanne HullAs a frequent visitor to Scotland (and now a resident) I visited, and still visit, our national parks for their outstanding beauty. Having travelled the world, Scotland can, just, hold its own with the likes of Canada, Austria and the Himalaya. But, excessive development (power lines, turbines etc) ruin that raw natural beauty and this means other the other places mentioned are much more of an attraction to me as a tourist. I'd much prefer to spend my money at home but try taking stunning photos with man-made structures in the way. We have something so beautiful that it needs protecting for future generations and to show the world just what a gorgeous country we have. There are alternatives - hydro is a proven success and power lines can be buried and development can be done sensitively.22752015-03-11T17:00:06.1938005Margaret LuscombeIt is vital that areas in Scotland are protected for future generations.22752015-03-11T17:17:08.548006lisa mcleanWe need more control measures within the justice system...judges should have more control. If you a jury member were uncertain you would look for help and guidance. Give judges the power!22942015-03-11T17:55:40.968007ian wrigleyComposting with organic waste or anaerobic digestion, utilising the methane for energy, are acceptable and highly cost effective ways of generating an end product for safe application as agricultural fertiliser. These processes should generate a net profit in addition to disposing of the sludge in a hygienic way.\r\nTheres no excuse! \r\nOld, proven technology and profitable utilisation of the valuable nutrients locked into our "waste". The scheme which was causing the issue was a total waste of resources and a scam designed to take subsidies which shouldn't be necessary in ANY way. The end users of the products created by disposing of the sludge should be paying for the privilege.\r\nTHESE ARE VALUABLE NUTRIENTS USE THEM!!!! 22762015-03-11T18:07:31.968008anne smithrabbits have very specific dietry and environmental needs,many products sold as suitable for rabbits to eat are causing illness and death,housing that imprisons bunnies to a life of misery,all this amounts to cruelty and neglect which could be avoided by enforcing welfare standards...22922015-03-11T19:46:48.6478010david knighton Defo must be strong laws on knife crime so other familys do not suffer what familys are going throu now because of knife. DITCH KNIFE AND TREASURE LIFE 22942015-03-11T20:36:28.3978011Gerald O' ConnorI have spent most weekends in our wild places for the last 5 years, and can see the harm beeing done \r\nWe need to protect the environment and National Parks is a good way of doing this.22752015-03-11T21:43:13.468012Kim beggsigned 22942015-03-11T21:52:25.9278014chris nealThis is a great cause and must be supported22922015-03-12T08:43:29.1638016Neil CollinsAs a frequent visitor to Scotland, I would have no hesitation in saying that I believe it to be one of the most beautiful countries in the world. However, this astonishing beauty is currently threatened by many hundreds of planned inappropriate developments, particularly but by no means exclusively, wind farms, with damaging proposals currently in the pipeline across the whole country, from Galloway to Shetland. Yet, Scotland's natural beauty is surely its prize asset and one of its biggest tourist draws. It is imperative to act now to ensure that this beauty is not lost and can continue to be enjoyed by future generations.22752015-03-12T10:28:57.2878017Andrew WoolmerUse a Knife and expect to go to prison for Life.22942015-03-12T10:51:36.888018Gary DicksonWorth it in itself, but especially if it helps the industrialisation of remote areas with ever growing wind factories and mile upon mile of poorly constructed tracks to service them.22752015-03-12T10:55:05.3978019Jill FyfeMy family and I are behind you all the way Alan. We need justice. It won't bring Barry or my brother Paul back but it might stop this happening to another family. Jill x22942015-03-12T11:23:33.358020Abbie PattersonI think that it is not a case of how many NP's we have or would like, but what areas of Scotland do we leave out?22752015-03-12T12:58:07.5078021Robert WattSomething coastal?22752015-03-12T14:28:33.7438024michael fellmon the rabbits! They should have rights!!22922015-03-12T21:30:52.8978026Kenny Douglas Save the rabbits22922015-03-13T00:54:46.2438029Agnes Boogaard dieren moeten met respect behandeld worden en in hun waarde worden gelaten. animals should be treated with respect and dignity.22922015-03-13T09:52:03.5838030Theresa HeathIf dogs and cats have a form of protection this should extend to Rabbits as well.22922015-03-13T12:48:45.4778031Nanette LangstonI love rabbits! I don't breed them, or eat them! They are precious pets to me. I have loved, and cared for over 200 rabbits in 25 years! I enjoy making sure they are safe, and taken good care of, till they pass away on their own, or from old age. They are truely baby angels, and deserve good homes, and to be loved, not born to just die! Please, care enough, to make all animals safe...22922015-03-13T16:10:19.968033Dr Ivan BishopI'm off the opinion we need marine sanctuaries too. The West Coast is a treasure trove of animal life, beautiful Islands and unspoiled waters. Future oil-gas development there will need to be CAREFULLY managed but the Scottish parliament.22752015-03-13T16:52:08.18034Gerrie PurcellMarine conservation is prime concern. We must protect our coastal areas and special interest or habitat areas for our sea life. 22752015-03-13T23:12:28.3978035Jade harrisPlease, please, please make this happen for all the bunnies out there. It is ridiculous that pets shops are allowed to sell such small housing for rabbits! 22922015-03-15T06:28:13.968036Jai McLeanMy rabbits are a much loved & properly looked after members of my family. They live indoors. They also take up nearly all my spare time. People should be aware of exactly how much looking after a bun needs before obtaining one. Removing the sale of rabbits from shops would stop impulse buying & banning the sale of tiny hutches would mean people would have to obtain suitably sized hutches 22922015-03-15T15:47:59.5538037susan peterstime these prisons were put where they belong on a bonfire that's all they are good for22922015-03-16T00:40:23.3978038Amy stewart get those hutches banned!!! buns deserve better22922015-03-16T08:26:50.078039Alexandra SinclairSigned22942015-03-16T09:13:28.1338040Sonia GlassbrookIt is appalling that pet shops etc., sell ridiculously small hutches - rabbits need space the same as any other animal and more education is needed in keeping pet rabbits - they need plenty of garden space as well as a place to sleep!22922015-03-16T14:22:16.5878041Kelly MarshallSigned and will pass on to as many ppl as I can. Hope you get the change you are looking for x22942015-03-16T15:43:15.7578042Annabel ChowBan hutches22922015-03-16T18:39:17.7278045stephen mooreSigned22942015-03-16T19:47:50.9438048Angela Rennie signed xx22942015-03-16T23:47:53.798049Ruhi ThallonAnimals should not be sold like pieces of furniture. Give animals more rights against human bad behaviour.22922015-03-17T06:11:36.8038050Karen strachan Signed x22942015-03-17T06:13:15.468051Sandra MacarthurSigned xx22942015-03-17T20:14:54.68052Denise and Marc Pattiesigned by us both22942015-03-18T12:40:31.0378053Mr R A DansonMy family originate from Garbeg and I have many relatives still in the Drumnadrochit area. The industrialisation of this pristine area is a disgrace that will haunt our children and children's children for decades to come. Please help to save what is left of this iconic landscape.\r\n23022015-03-18T13:46:00.578055John CurtisLoch Ness and its environs are quintessentially Scottish and are what people travel from all around the world to see. To destroy this area, or any other in Scotland, with the dreadful sight os useless turbines and their support equipment, is absolute madness. 23022015-03-18T14:16:38.6978056sue petersdisagree with pet shops selling live animals of any sort should be banned like they did for cats & dogs22922015-03-18T15:26:10.2438057Gerry worthLoch ness and the surrounding areas are hugely important to tourism and windfarms are not what tourists come to see.23022015-03-18T15:37:40.0538058susan worthWorking in the tourism business around loch ness as I do, I can already see the damage being done to future tourism. its not this year or next year, maybe not even the year after that, but its the years after when its far too late that worries me. I fear a change in career and the closing down of our businesses certainty on the cards.23022015-03-18T16:36:12.1978059Karen RodenWe visit Scotland every year for a family holiday, but I think this may well be the last time as the situation with monstrous industrial wind turbines and the new pylon routes is an absolute disgrace. For 15 years we have visited to enjoy the stunning, unspoilt landscapes, but bit by bit they are being destroyed. To suggest this could happen in the Loch Ness and great Glen areas is totally beyond belief. What on earth are the politicians and landowners thinking?23022015-03-18T19:15:58.778060Louise Blakey, Tam RankineSigned by both of us as its a matter thats close to our hearts xx22942015-03-19T07:57:44.7238061David WhannelNo turbine that emits infrasound is safe in Scotland where we have the right to roam and set-up camp where we like - no published medical study has ever been conducted in the world despite the health complaints. Sub 20Hz infrasound can alter brain operating frequencies and is known to cause seizures in people with epilepsy, thus making vast areas effectively no longer accessible to disabled people, fully planned gross negligence.23022015-03-19T16:11:38.358063Douglas MoirThe Scottish Government is overseeing the systematic destruction of our greatest natural resource, our wonderful landscapes. For what? The Industrialisation of our land at lunatic costs to the benefit of few in Scotland and in the main to Investors, Shareholders and Firms far from our shores. It is a betrayal of our National Heritage by the very people who claim they are Nationalists.\r\n23022015-03-19T20:58:38.1978064Joseph Fleming LindsayI think it's time to stop this madness. The Scottish Government's ain appears to be to despoil the whole of Scotland, my country, your country, with huge electric turbines. They offer us the sop of payback money, which is really only our own money anyway. A lot of people are stupid enough to swallow this, and feed the SNP's ego, of being forerunners in the renewables race.\r\nA song was once written with the words "What aarcel of rogues on a nation". Our grandchildren may someday sing "What a parcel of fools in a nation"\r\nIt is time to stop this folly.\r\nJoe Lindsay.\r\n\r\n23022015-03-20T04:19:30.718065Alexandra ReynoldsIndeed a worldwide problem. We need to step into modern times and lines of thinking to curtail these issues NOW!22922015-03-20T04:34:39.798066Dolka Reyes Divine order restore now 22922015-03-20T06:40:29.9778067Keira StylesRabbits are very special animals who deserve a good life and love22922015-03-20T16:14:53.5078070olive laingi love my rabbit dearly, he is part of the family,he lives in our conservatory that,s his room,he has access to the garden.It's cruel to keep them locked up in a hutch or cage,they need lot's of room to exercise,run and stretch.People need a lot more advise and knowledge about rabbits before they get one, they need to be cared for properly.22922015-03-20T16:14:49.498071Marion beggWe need to be more assertive with the locking up of these and other offences. Give them longer sentences and less human rights in jail22412015-03-20T16:56:00.498072Patricia Carlson Please help rabbits. 22922015-03-20T19:02:53.5238073Alison PearsonDo not think it is a good idea to get SSPCA to oversee and enforce any regulations as they get a lot of money from stored like PAH Pets at Home.22922015-03-20T19:08:09.3978074Michaela ShawIts about time there was changes in the welfare of rabbits. Far to long have they been a Neglected pet often through lack of knowledge. New Laws should come in place for the size required for these athletic animals and the public need to be more educated on the welfare of Rabbits and their complex needs.\r\nSuch a cruel life many lead and its not necessary. 22922015-03-20T19:08:21.1978075Thomas HopkinsNo long Sentence for this kind of Horrific Cold Blooded Murder, It's got to be the Death Penalty.22412015-03-20T19:09:40.3178076mika duganIn my thoughts, love Mika xx\r\n22412015-03-20T19:38:25.1338078S Paterson life should mean life22412015-03-20T19:45:47.8038079Caroline Duffy LIFE SHOULD MEAN LIFE. 22412015-03-20T19:48:58.5538080David Marshallthere is too much emphasis on the welfare of convicted criminals with little thought for victims and their relatives. Early release for criminals should not be automatic - our soft touch justice system in Scotland needs an urgent rethink - now. 22412015-03-20T20:05:57.578081Amanda cooper Life should mean life.22412015-03-20T20:10:55.9778082Susan Lummis We simply must stop shops selling hutches based on what the Victorians used to keep farmed meat rabbits stored in! I have 2 rabbits and to look after them properly takes an awful lot of time and effort. If you think rabbits are easy, then you're doing it wrong. Education is hugely important but reforms would be a great step forward.22922015-03-20T20:23:55.7578083Helen LaycockPlease sign22412015-03-20T21:23:56.9278084stacey Fitzgerald The human race is disgusting more needs to be done to help these animals!22922015-03-20T21:34:45.5538085Fiona FraserLife should be the whole life sentence, murder has taken a while life not to mention the ongoing trauma and heartbreak for the family! 22412015-03-20T21:52:02.8038086scott duganAnybody who takes a life deserves to be taken off the streets for life. Re-ofenders should be given the \r\nlethal injection, be done with them...\r\nWaste of space, time and taxpayers money.22412015-03-20T22:00:09.048087Caroline Paterson Life must mean life far too much knife crime too many innocent lives lost We all must make a stancd NOW 22412015-03-20T22:51:31.4938088Sheila Campbell it's about time there was a major overhaul of the Justice System. It's a joke. 22412015-03-21T02:53:58.6938089gavin duffyLife sentence should meen life 22412015-03-21T09:20:21.328090anthony ahearneAll animals should have rights to a happy , healthy life!22922015-03-21T09:32:43.858091Elizabeth lochrie I agree to that. 22412015-03-21T09:56:11.6178093John McGowanSigned,God Bless.x22412015-03-21T10:02:29.3338094Roddie MainThis is the heart of Highland tourism do not destroy it23022015-03-21T10:40:30.3978095Isabel CampbellLoch Ness and the surrounding area should be saved from destruction by industrialisation caused by wind farms23022015-03-21T13:46:00.218096George HerraghtyThe Tasmanian Wedge-tailed Eagle is at the point of extinction due to wind farms. Recent research from around the world indicates horrific bird mortality rates:-\r\n\r\nSpain - 330 Birds per turbine per year\r\nGermany - 309 Birds per turbine per year\r\nSweden - 895 Birds per turbine per year \r\n\r\nWhen will the wind industry tell us the Scottish figures?\r\n23022015-03-21T15:27:07.9738097Mary YoungThis is a wholly inappropriate proposal in one of the most iconic areas of Scotland. We are custodians of our country's natural heritage and if the desecration of it is allowed to run rampant with proposals such as this, there will be precious little left to hand on to future generations23022015-03-21T16:05:41.798098William Hampson. There should be no early release, period. Serve a full sentence and behave get out, misbehave and get time added on. The incentive to behave is not getting time added. \r\n.22412015-03-21T17:34:03.2278099Susan Dudley (Kerr)My ancestors came to the US from Scotland. I have always wanted to visit the places they came from. I see pictures of Scotland now and it breaks my heart to see the entire country dotted with industrial wind turbines. I don't want to visit any longer.\r\n23022015-03-21T17:53:35.298100Aubrey MooreJohn Swinney (Deputy First Minister) has stated on an earlier occasion that " The Scottish Government wants to see the right developments in the right places and Scottish Planning Policy is clear that the design and location of any wind farm should reflect the scale and character of the landscape and should be considered environmentally acceptable".\r\nThis is neither the correct location or environmentally acceptable!! If any of these sites are approved then the people of Scotland should give serious thought to which party they vote for in the Scottish elections of 2016.23022015-03-21T18:07:59.5678101Harry AmeyThe European energy policy is a disgrace. Ordinary citizens trampled on the alter of misguided political dogma and subsidies which allow profit to come before people. Shame on you.23022015-03-21T18:27:53.3978102jackie langRabbits need at least as much care, time , patience and training as dogs. There's nothing more rewarding than having your rabbits running to you when you call their names and watching them run and chase at high speed, things they can't do if confined to a hutch.22922015-03-21T18:32:36.2438103Graeme SteelAs I'm signing this. There is no wind. It's good old reliable fossil fuels that reliably keep the lights on. What's the point of destroying our own environment for something that is so unreliable and expensive 23022015-03-21T19:06:16.858104John GrahamThis area provides one of the highest levels of Hydro in the UK but benefits little from it. We rely on Tourists and soon the level of wind farms will destroy the bulk of the visitors. When people go back on tell of what they experienced, numbers will dwindle and businesses will die. There will be no resurrection for Loch Ness and its environs. Just an example of how much damage national policies can cause. 23022015-03-21T19:35:21.1978106Ralph GodsallThere is something very special about the Great Glen. It is a national jewel that is cherished by many south of the Border and far away in central London. The highlands need to be protected from inappropriate development such as this and the landscape should be allowed to continue to breath of its own accord for the benefit of all who live in or visit the area for recreational purposes.23022015-03-21T20:12:17.1178107Elizabeth BlackburnOnce more we see an area of outstanding natural beauty being threatened. Any further wind farm developments add to destruction of our tourist industry and particularly in the loch Ness area. It is renowned throughout the world. To line it with turbines is vandalism and would contribute minute amounts towards producing green energy. The Scottish goverment should be protecting our beautiful country, not aiding further wind turbine intrusions.23022015-03-21T20:34:46.7578108fiona Winning Signed xxx22942015-03-21T21:02:01.0838110Lesley RawsonI have 2 rabbits who live in a 10ftx4ft cage and with an extra attached run so I feel it is vitally important this bill is passed.So we as a nation can stop this untold suffering to bunnies nationwide. 22922015-03-21T22:26:03.718111Melvin Grosvenormore totally unnecessary environmental vandalism by outrageous stupid ineffective so called save the planet useless developers scamming our cash with the backing of SNP politicians stop this madness 23022015-03-21T22:40:51.528112Elaine EastonFor the families of the innocent victims x22412015-03-22T00:23:34.4138114Duncan MacleanI say that both onshore and offshore wind turbine 'farms' have no part to play in modern electrity generation both here in the UK, and across the world...they absolutely do not...23022015-03-22T02:10:17.1638115Deborah PenderNo More Wind Turbines! It is a fraudulent money scam which does not provide the electricity the UK needs. Wind Turbines destroy thousands of birds and bats as well as ruining human lives when they are sited too close to homes and public places. Enough is enough! 23022015-03-22T02:23:49.6638116William PalmerWe have toured the Loch Ness area of Scotland as tourists, and find it magnificant. Wind turbines will destroy the tourism draw.23022015-03-22T03:13:03.248117Bradbury BlakeWe must stop destroying our natural and scenic treasures, whether in Scotland or in my home state of Maine, USA for feckless wind power that does absolutely nothing to reduce carbon or other pollutants. Wind turbines are the worst blight on the land!23022015-03-22T03:40:23.3678118Stephen WatsonWind power is nothing but a big scam and is unworthy of public funding for subsidies. Without subsidies and heinous mandates, wind power would never be built. Stop destroying Scotland, the land of my heritage!23022015-03-22T03:43:43.138119Dean BradburyA wind power project ruined my home region, the Lincoln Lakes in Maine, USA. I have traveled through Scotland, where my ancestors came from. Please stop ruining your beautiful land for useless wind power!23022015-03-22T06:31:43.638120Neil MacleodIt is now time to say 'No more onshore wind turbines in the Scottish Highlands' as they are against the wishes of the vast majority of people living in these scenic areas. 23022015-03-22T07:15:56.298121Keimpe BleekerWind energy is only business for investors or fools. The produced enegy is instable and the effective yield is so little that it is easier to cut back the share of wind energy in consumption. Last but not least the landscape and the living environment are ruined for a result that could be reached also through common sense.23022015-03-22T07:38:07.388122Colin CauderyIf this devastating scheme gets the go ahead the Scottish Parliment has lost all it common sense, people travel from all over the world to see its stunning landscape not turbines. Unfortunately we have the same problem in Cornwall with Cornwall Council being controlled by wind zealots that care little for the landscape. Keep this majestic area of Scotland wild.23022015-03-22T08:01:39.0878123KEN ROSSwindfarms destroy our beautiful landscapes.\r\nNone around Loch Ness!23022015-03-22T08:07:40.468124Sonia WhittingtonThe council have to look at the connection to the grid and all the roads needed to put in these turbines as this can be worse than the turbines themselves. To not do this is deceitful and begs the question of how much money is passing hands. There is one earth with limited resources if we carry head long destroying it for money there will be no world for our children or Grand children. We need to take responsibility for our actions .23022015-03-22T08:15:32.4138125Tom BakerI am still to be convinced that theses onshore turbines are economic in fiscal terms ( without the subsidies ) and also that they solve the carbon output problem when you consider production and installation. \r\nThe owners should be paid the basic going rate per KW, then we would see the truth.23022015-03-22T09:43:26.5238128Fiona McleanI support this Petition as I consider that this geographical area is being spoilt by these developers and landowners. I believe that were it not for the substantial financial benefits that these landowners and developers were to receive then they would not be undertaking this course of action. I for one have always felt privileged to vote at elections for the benefit of our culture, way of life and future etc. but until the SNP government reconsiders the harm that these developments will have then this is one vote the SNP won't have. These developments will destroy our tourism trade, our natural beauty, our enjoyment and pride of staying in this part of Scotland. We have enough developments - no more.23022015-03-22T10:16:23.2878129Kim TerryMany of our friends and relatives are saying they just won't bother to come to Scotland anymore. Let's face it, they don't come for the weather but it is the scenery that attracts people. The SNP are ensuring that it is slowly being eroded away. Perhaps they should leave their cosy desks in Edinburgh occasionally and look at the destruction they have caused and the adverse affects on families forced to live near these monsters they might have a better idea of what the people think. I am sure the polls the developers show saying that 70% of people support wind farms would show something very different if they were actually told the truth about the cost to the environment, the cost on their energy bills, the danger of relying on renewables and the fact that they do not help save CO2 at all. Moving from England to Scotland was the worst thing we did and combining wind farms wit the independence referendum has ensured we cannot sell to move back. Thanks!!23022015-03-22T11:02:14.4478130Rosalind Crosby It is so important that everyone signs this as we have a very serious welfare crisis and someone MUST now take steps to address this. Not doing something to protect rabbits, when there is such a great need, is tantamount to cruelty. Scotland, please take the lead. 22922015-03-22T11:14:07.4138131Caroline HobbsHere in Aberdeenshire,the rural landscape has become a counrtyside of wind turbines.To see the wilds of Scotland also despoiled is just plain criminal.Enough is enough and it is time to stop the building of any more of these useless structures anywhere in Scotland23022015-03-22T11:23:59.3338132Sue MorrisWe have been campaigning against Wind Farms for sometime now and fear that our objections are being totally ignored. The UK is supposed to be a democratic country yet we are very rarely listened to or the information received from various environmentalists, scientists, people who are having to live close to existing wind farms and the devastation this has caused are all been overruled by the money making aspects both to overseas wind farm developers and local and central governments. It is absolutely heartbreaking to think that our beautiful Loch Ness and Great Glen could be blighted by so many wind turbines. This brings in so many tourists each year to the Highlands, locals enjoy the outstanding scenery, both on foot, by car and by cyclists. Have any of the planners thought about the logistics and the impact this will have on the roads that will need to be created in order to reach these areas, the impact on our wild life and land. I strongly urge the people who are responsible for making the decisions on whether this goes ahead to use your eyes and your heart to see what you are personally allowing into our most precious land.23022015-03-22T11:51:15.5538133Mike HaselerNot one temperature dataset has warmed at even the lowest rate predicted by the IPCC in 2001. The models predicting warming have failed, they are not science and those pushing them are not scientists. CO2 is a plant food. Scotland where science and industry once flourished, should be amongst the most vocal against these birdmincers.23022015-03-22T12:09:26.2578135christopher davisIt really is pathetic that for the sake of a few individuals and investors, mainly from abroad, making huge profits at our expense, the whole of the Scottish tourist industry is under threat. When will this madness stop?23022015-03-22T12:25:37.938136Howard FergusonSome day soon somebody will ask why developers have paid massive subsidies to destroy the scottish landscape - put electricity prices up - and still fail to save the planet from climate change which is caused by natural occilations in the sun, the solar system , the earth and in the oceans. CO2 contribution to all of this is next to nothing.23022015-03-22T12:31:23.0538137Nicholas TaylorI have seen the views to the north from Sherrifmuir near Dunblane spoiled forever(from A9) --As this constituted the landscape of a large part of my childhood it is a deeply personal objection I hold ---and would not want others to be traumatised in this same way.(for an inefficient energy solution)23022015-03-22T12:46:52.278138Michelle MyersWe spent several years fighting a similar problem to be inflicted on our iconic butte. Element Power pulled out and we hope to get permanent protection.23022015-03-22T15:19:58.1178139Andrew ShiellsYou would think the SNP would be the party to treasure Scotland's heritage and landscape. Instead they seem to exist just to let mainly foreign speculators turn it into a massive scrapyard. How thick can they be?23022015-03-22T15:52:07.9138140Dave GordonScotland's landscapes have been abused for decades, if not centuries. Why does the Scottish Government hate Scotland's landscape so much that it would rather destroy it than heal it?23022015-03-22T16:10:09.3038141Peter HeatonDoes anyone want to see the Highlands of Scotland looking like a forest of turbines? There are plenty of other ways of " going green"23022015-03-22T16:35:52.858143vivian linacreFor all windfarm proposals we want not so much a moratorium as a crematorium!23022015-03-22T16:57:29.138144Andrew WalkerYou would think by now that the Scottish Government would have see what many other countries have seen & stopped destroying their heritage and areas of outstanding beauty with a fundamentally flawed and not carbon neutral technology. Woefully inefficient. Industrialisation of our natural landscape for an insane pledge of an impossible 100% renewable provision. The only true beneficiaries being the landowners and the subsidised energy companies. \r\nAll in all, an utter disgrace and abomination to be reaped by future generations. 23022015-03-22T17:49:03.2578145Robert HunterWe now live in the Scottish Borders, but for 6-years prior to coming here in 2014, we ran a B&B in Invermoriston, by Loch Ness. This experience made it absolutely clear that adding more wind farms in the area will have a seriously detrimental affect on tourism, which, by any measure, the area survives on.23022015-03-22T19:48:22.798146David HindeLoch Ness is a very special place that should be preserved in its scebnic beauty without the Intrusion of Monstous wind Turbines,which are fast blighting our Great Island.23022015-03-22T19:52:20.938147Jane BrewsterWe live 1000m from turbines we are having to live with their impact and have major concerns about our long term health.How can the SNP govt who claim to be working for Scotland and listening to the Scottish people foist this on our iconic landscapes and hard pressed fuel poor.\r\nNicola Sturgeon as health minister did not listen ,John Swinney Chic Brodie, Mike Russell, Pete Wishart and the rest all sidestepped the importance of secure energy supply and a duty of care to rural communities .\r\nThe lifeblood of our homes businesses and economy is too important to be reliant on intermittent wind. Fuel banks will be next scandal.\r\nIt all about money and power nothing green about destroying unique habitats or mincing birds and bats. Despite the rhetoric to win votes fracking will follow and trace the turbines saga.\r\n23022015-03-22T21:48:35.9438149james wattTurbines spoil the view, make an uncertain contribution to power supplies and with perhaps even more uncertain environmental credits.\r\nIf renewable power generation is the goal, surely exploitation of the Highlands' ample water supply with an investment in hydro-electricity plant would make much more sense and could result in new tourist attractions as at Pitlochry with its lake and salmon leap than destroying the Great Glen's attraction for tourists. \r\nQuestion: who will directly gain from windturbines ? The owners of the ground they stand on ? And how many of them are represented on the Highland Council ? 23022015-03-23T09:33:18.3838150James BrewsterThere are far greener ways to generate electricity than blight our landscapes with turbines. A new wave of highland clearances and a life changing impact on all residence of the proposed scheme's surrounding area.23022015-03-23T11:01:26.4938151steve darlingPlease set a precedent and stop this tsunami of wind turbines now. We have enough, we want NO MORE HERE. The potential impact on scottish tourism and environment will be devastating. Please make it significantly harder and less financially attractive for these carbuncles to be dumped on the beautiful highlands, before we can no longer call it BONNIE SCOTLAND23022015-03-23T11:00:27.528152Catherine NolanWhat are you thinking? How can you even consider spoiling such a unique and world renowned location with wind turbines. They are so ugly!23022015-03-23T11:04:33.358153Ian mureIf this proliferation of windfarms continues the cost to the population at large through the levy on household invoice will soon become intolerable. Add in the cost of lost tourist trade to the local economy and you create an impact from which the economy will not recover from for a very long time. Tourism has had a very large beneficial impact within the Loch Ness area which should not be economically challenged otherwise the cost of social care could rise substantially.23022015-03-23T11:03:27.9278154Brian Gregson When will people learn that windfarms are neither green nor sustainable and that the only reason they are being built at all is to attract government subsidies.23022015-03-23T11:06:42.028155wilma wheltonTourists who come to see our landscape will be disappointed when they see it has been industrialised. I grew up in Lanarkshire where the landscape was blighted with the residue of coal mining - "bings" of waste. In 25 years when the subsidies no longer apply will the Highlands be littered with lumps of decaying concrete and steel?23022015-03-23T11:58:22.7238156Simon John KirkpatrickI was born a Scot and visit several times a year, this desecration of one of Europe's last great wildernesses is criminal and must cease. 23022015-03-23T12:17:12.8178157Kim PolleyPlease don't destroy this piece of heaven for our children and grandchildren. We regularly fly over 21 hours, like many other Australians, to the Scottish Highlands to solely experience this special area. Its natural and built heritage as well as unique flora and fauna are precious and must not be compromised. 23022015-03-23T13:09:40.2238158Fiona BrownI am so so ashamed to have been one of a population who has allowed our wonderful beautiful country to become so desecrated - I feel so helpless, and apart from signing petitions I don't know what else to do to stop a few powerful, money-grabbing people from abusing their power and over-riding the wishes of so many dedicated people who love this country.23022015-03-23T15:58:29.548160Lizzie StewartCompare the long term impact on Tourism income in Scotland to the wind turbine income - why is this even being considered ?23022015-03-23T16:01:48.998161Bill PatonI am happy to support this petition, which if successful will benefit patient on Warfarin and \r\nmake their condition easier to manage.22342015-03-23T16:08:39.1478162Ian RichardsWind farms have a place in any well considered energy mix. What we face now is the industrialisation of our greatest natural asset, Scotland's unique landscape. The prostitution of our heritage by profiteering landowners and windfarm operators is shameful.23022015-03-23T16:39:31.6638163angelika smithThere is not one redeeming feature when it comes to wind turbines! They are a health hazard, they spoil the countryside, they kill birds and bats and they don't even generate enough electricity to make them economical viable. Nor do they save any CO2! It is a scam where only developers and landowners benefit from the subsidies!23022015-03-23T18:47:51.3678165Joan HoltYOU CANNOT DESTROY TOMICH OR THE GLEN AFFRIC THIS IS DISGRACEFUL. ONCE GONE\r\nITS GONE FOREVER.THE MOST UNSPOILT PRESERVED BEAUTY AND YOU WANT TO DESTROY IT UNBELIEVABLE IGNORANCE.\r\n\r\n23022015-03-23T18:49:11.498166Susan ChisholmAs a frequent visitor to the Highland Region with family in the area I am very against further such development. Wind turbines apart from being of dubious value from and energy production point of view are detrimental to this most beautiful landscape and have been shown to damage wild life and in particular bird life. This area also relies on overseas visitors and tourists to boost the economy, how can it make sense to damage the very thing people want to come and see and enjoy.23022015-03-23T18:58:07.0238167matt smithWind turbines have their place and can actually enhance some landscapes. They are a useful part of the generation mix. However, I believe that wild areas that tourists come to appreciate are adversely impacted and thus so is the visitor experience. The cost and impact of build, especially if habitat such as peat bog is destroyed, has to be part of the equation, along with opportunity costs of reduced natural beauty.23022015-03-23T21:10:22.9278168Eric GilroyThe desecration of wild land must cease, these infernal turbines are barely producing 40% of their rated output.23022015-03-23T21:42:20.7238169Tracy guppyplease help to make people realise rabbits need space and company22922015-03-23T21:42:38.1938170Isobel ScottA tribute to a lovely private humble lady who lived for her family and the church and who was a great friend to all who knew her - xx22412015-03-23T21:50:10.5078171Mike RogersWindfarms are inefficient.23022015-03-23T22:45:52.8678173Mairi Fraser Loch Ness and the Great Glen should and needs to be a protected area now and for future generations.23022015-03-24T07:00:58.6178174Debbie Boyle Signed x22942015-03-24T08:06:14.8038175Ann and Garry Sweetwe can only hope some much needed changes happen xx22942015-03-24T08:40:00.8978176Leslie Goodchildl live several miles away from Avonbridge in Brightons and the smell can be awful \r\n22762015-03-24T09:07:44.3678177Pamela SoperIt is crucial to preserve parts of Scotland, that will enable local people and industries to build on what is already a substantial tourist industry. Governments must look at alternative "green" energy sources that do not have such a direct impact on the landscape. Windpower is not as "Green" as we all are led to believe, and most certainly does not bring the wealth to the lcoal communities that is sometimes promised.23022015-03-24T09:08:15.1178179Mark Pilbeamthere are places and times for wind farms but not at the expense of wild life, countryside, local people, visitors and beautiful panoramas that will be forever lost !23022015-03-24T09:25:30.7578181Peter SmithEnough is enough. Stop the industrialization of our hills and glens. 23022015-03-24T09:27:43.278182Mark HodgsonFrom south of the border, and as an Anglo-Scot who loves Scotland, the policy of the Scottish Government in basing its revenue-stream on the income from North Sea Oil whilst blighting the irreplaceable beauty of its incomparable countryside with useless and expensive wind turbines in the name of reducing carbon emissions, seems to combine stupidity and hypocrisy in equal measure.23022015-03-24T10:05:16.3338183Graham HannahI am absolutely passionate about preventing the proliferation of industrial windfarms in wild places in Scotland. Wild land where no sign of man can be seen or heard is a very special resource. Quiet places where people can go and recharge the batteries of their soul.23022015-03-24T10:09:30.468184Brian A BellLet this government prove we live in a democratic society by holding a referendum on SNP energy policy. With Longannet closing down and windmills which provide a pitiful and insignificant quantity of power it can only be a matter of time before we suffer blackouts. 23022015-03-24T10:12:29.188185Lynda HodgsonPicture the scene: an early 19th century Highland crofting family driven from their home and livelihood by the greed of a rapacious landowner blanketing the landscape with sheep.\r\n\r\nFast forward to the 21st century. Highland residents' lives blighted by the greed of rapacious landowners shrouding the landscape with wind turbines. \r\n\r\nA stark parallel.\r\n\r\nBut worse! Not only lives destroyed, but also the destruction of the environment. Look to your history and weep.23022015-03-24T13:37:18.0538186sorcha ni aoidhePlease SAVE 23022015-03-24T14:14:13.718187Alastair Brookes As a life long Warfarin user I would urge as many people as possible to support this petition. 22342015-03-24T15:46:23.1938188Andrew WalkerIndustrial scale wind farms are the all too visible manifestation of a failed energy policy. Firstly, the public has been sold the idea that wind farms are crucial in the fight against climate change: this is not true because the amounts of CO2 saved are utterly insignificant in comparison with global emissions. Secondly, the planned closure of current coal and nuclear generation will mean that Scotland will need to import electricity from the rest of the UK in order to meet demand at times of low renewables generation, as predicted by the Scottish Government's own Expert Commission on Energy Regulation (July 2014). Thirdly, Scotland's tourism industry will be progressively eroded as residents and visitors vote with their feet and go elsewhere, appalled at the desecration of Scotland's beautiful landscapes. Fourthly, the environmental consequences include the loss of peatland, and the death of rare birds and bats.23022015-03-24T16:00:20.2738189Irene SmithThe existing planning system is biased towards the Scottish Government's policy of sustainable renewable energy - in effect, the opinions and wishes of those who submit their objections to wind farms are effectively being ignored, while greedy and unscrupulous developers and land owners happily trouser the huge grants available, paid indirectly by the population through inflated electricity bills. It seems like the Highland Clearances once more, with greedy landowners, riding roughshod over the needs and wishes of the people. This situation is quite shocking in a so- called democratic society, 23022015-03-24T19:04:24.638190Audrey LitterickI cannot believe what the Scottish Government is allowing to happen! Loch Ness is one of our most loved, most famous and greatest assets. People come to look at it because it and its surroundings are beautiful. The area is fast being destroyed and once the people stop coming to visit, they will not return. I and others like me have already abandoned parts of the Southern Uplands for holidays because they are an industrialised mess of turbines. Do not further destroy our highlands in the name of renewable energy generation (I won't start on the environmental sense, or lack of it of that). For heavens sake, no more turbines around Loch Ness - PLEASE.23022015-03-24T19:39:20.1478191Andrew HamiltonScotland is going to import more and more electricity because of wind farms. Our Government needs to start doing their jobs and ensure we have a proper power supply.23022015-03-24T21:31:17.5538192Isabel FairgrieveI have experienced the dreadful nauseating stench of this sludge while walking one of the core paths in the Lionthorn area with a friend. I never want to smell it again and trust this petition will end the practice. 22762015-03-24T22:43:41.8038193Ian DoigSigned x22942015-03-24T22:47:52.8178194Adrina WallaceFingers crossed this makes a difference x x x 22942015-03-25T03:26:32.9778195heather maxine barclayBring back democracy\r\n23022015-03-25T09:03:23.5878196GLYNNE GIANELLILoch Ness is Scotland. It must not be desecrated.23022015-03-25T10:04:58.5838197Caprice kernaghanSigning the petition 22942015-03-25T10:16:23.3038198jo chapman campbellthis madness of destruction must be stopped - we are ruining the planet, not saving it.23022015-03-25T10:52:48.3978200Marc loweSigned22942015-03-25T11:34:58.3678201STYLIANI AILAMAKII support your fight against the huge turbines in nature with high interesting.It is happening the same in Crete in Greece where the virgin and unspoilt environment gives a huge income through the tourism .23022015-03-25T12:23:59.828202Andrew ReddenI live in an area with a lot of wind Turbines. They are ugly, noisy and obtrusive spoiling the views in all directions. They do not benefit local employment. The only financial benefit is to the local landowner. One nuclear power staion could probably replace every existing and planned turbine. Prepare to be overuled by the government unless hundreds and hundreds of thousands sign the petition. Sign now.23022015-03-25T14:54:19.18203Roy MilneLoch Ness and the Great Glen are vital to our tourist industry on which so many people depend. Huge arrays of windmills will do nothing to attract tourists but will almost certainly do plenty to repel them. How can our Scottish Government be so thoughtless and obstinate, not to mention stupid?23022015-03-25T15:16:14.5378204Alan McLean( Do we have enough control measures within the current justice system) We do not have enough control measures, we need to look at the current jury system as this can be improved for example: Where a life has been taken through intent then the trial should consist of a panel of judges who will be able to accurately assess all information delivered from the prosecution and defence by utilising their life experience and skills rather than members of the public from the electoral role who more than often become very confused with too much legal information, this will also provide fairness and equality to both the victim and the criminal. We are currently living in an unsafe society and it warrants for the current Justice system to come into the 21st century with greater control measures.22942015-03-25T16:31:48.688205Nicola SomervilleSigned x22942015-03-26T01:25:18.9938206Ragnar Reutz HaakenstadThis is madness!! Visit Loch Ness many years ago and it is just one thing to say about windturbines around Loch Ness. We fight against windturbines in Norway, too!23022015-03-26T07:25:25.5538207Fiona MacAllisterOne of the most stunning area of scenery, i work in a hotel highly dependant on the Tourism industry. 23022015-03-26T09:07:05.8338208margery watsonEvery time I cross the border I feel as thought there should be a sign saying welcome to Scotland home of the windfarms!!!!!!!23022015-03-26T10:26:09.4938209John RobertsonThis desecration of our beautiful countryside has to stop. Generations yet to come will blame us for allowing the SNP to destroy our heritage and we need to do all we can to bring them to their senses.23022015-03-26T11:15:45.9138210Claire ArmstrongTourism is a main income for Scotland. Destroying all the Countryside, our views, & our enjoyment with 22 tons of concrete under each turbine plus the road scars littered all over the hills now is uneconomic & makes all Authorities involved Unfit for Purpose. So as a minimum ensure TOTAL protection for the entire Loch Ness areas from these horrendous & massive contraptions!! :-(23022015-03-26T11:29:14.748211Iain FinchamWhy do these companies insist on destroying our landscapes with these revolving monstrosities ???23022015-03-26T13:09:56.358212Kelsey Hamilton Signed the petition Adeline x22942015-03-26T14:09:44.9478213Jim JoplingHave signed your petition.22942015-03-26T15:37:37.1938214Anthony Ernest WilsonLoch Ness and the Great Glen are an extremely important tourist site and the landscape around it should not be blighted by Windfarms.If the building of windfarms continue there soon will be nowhere in Scotland that will be free of the sight of windfarms. It will have a great adverse effect on tourism which is important to the local economy .It will also have health effects for people living near them.23022015-03-26T16:51:45.6978216mike lewisSign x22942015-03-26T16:59:12.6338217Jamie ForsythSinged :)22942015-03-26T17:45:40.498219K GallagherTourists don't come to the Great Glen to see wind turbines, and residents are demonstrably none too keen to build or inhabit homes anywhere near them. Too many of our wild and beautiful places are already littered with these white elephants, so beloved of businesses for the massive public subsidies and faux green credentials they offer. I'm sick of wasteful, symbolic, public spending simply enriching corporate investors in lieu of a coherent energy policy. Turbines are all too visible reminders of scientifically illiterate politicians' pretence at saving the planet. Politicians who take wind developers' sales pitch at face value and make no attempt to determine the truth of the claims that they decarbonise energy production, or make significant contributions to local economies. Likewise they ignore any health detriment attributable to turbines. Holyrood or Westminster, 'left' or 'right', they're all in lust with marketization and eager to indulge tax dodging corporates. They're happy to construct their own alterative reality bubble, where evidence based policy doesn't get a look in, when people's votes can be more easily won with misdirection, panic spreading rhetoric, and irrelevant, unworkable, or counterproductive 'solutions'. And a supine media offers nothing much in the way of critique. Enough, already.23022015-03-26T18:51:27.7438220Fiona MartinSigned x22942015-03-26T19:04:05.528221John RadfordEnough is enough , no more wind turbines required in Scotland 23022015-03-26T19:50:29.578222Alison PetriePlease stop these turbines! We are battling at least 5 developments here! It's exhausting and makes trust difficult! Stop23022015-03-26T20:00:13.048223Andrew FinnimoreWindfarm proposals in the Scottish Highlands are threatening to ruin one of the most beautiful areas of wild country in Western Europe.\r\n23022015-03-26T20:36:42.078224Elizabeth darbyEnough is enough. We are surrounded by turbines here. No more needed..There are 1000 more in Planning process. Say NO to any more.23022015-03-26T21:55:58.8378225lisa munoz mccandlessSigned x22942015-03-26T22:55:28.8978226Ian CotterillWe are in danger of losing Scotland's wild land and the economic benefits and employment that we get from tourism. The decimation of our wonderful wild land must be stopped before it's too late.23022015-03-27T02:17:23.5078227Miriam RafteryWind turbines are horrible - they have despoiled many areas here with visual blight, noise, flashing lights and infrasound - don't despoil this famous and beautiful wild place I always wanted to go to Scotland but would scratch if off my list if they build these. 23022015-03-27T11:23:22.7738228Jolene ConnellI consider myself to be pretty switched on, no disrespect to those who have studied for years to become lawyers and judges but for normal people like me, having sat through a high court case, it's extremely difficult to understand the gibberish and riddles you talk in, jury's need guidance from the judge 22942015-03-27T11:45:53.1938229Leah RobinsonSigned x22942015-03-27T11:47:59.638230Gerard McGuireit is my legal right to walk on or near fields. I believe that being in the vicinity of where this sludge has been spread is a health hazard to both humans and animals.22762015-03-27T12:44:03.0078231Trudie LobbanVisit www.afa.org.uk for more information on AF and self monitoring\r\n22342015-03-27T13:39:03.298232David doohanI and my wife have spent many happy times travelling around the loch and the surrounding area. The wind farm at Farr was the result of an appaulling decision as have been the case with other approvals in this iconic and beautiful part of the Highlands. This vandalism MUST STOP.23022015-03-27T13:54:31.9138233Ernie SmartIf we carry on as we are doing Scotland will be infested with wind turbines. We will have no trees and a whacking debt.23022015-03-27T16:55:08.6638234patrick murphyjustice for Barry22942015-03-27T17:10:27.548235Judith CostelloThe while country doesn't have to be covered in wind turbines! Leave some places turbine free!23022015-03-27T17:47:14.1638236Michael James Cooper id like to see this kept the way it is 23022015-03-27T17:58:15.7878237Victoria BerrymanI have wonderful memories of visiting Loch Ness. If the wind farm goes ahead, I certainly won't ever return! It is too painful to witness the destruction of your chief tourist attraction - wide open natural (undeveloped) areas! Scotland used to be the place to go to escape urban pressures. As every new turbine goes, so this becomes less true.23022015-03-27T22:39:06.2738238martyn sharpeHow long does this madness go on before someone sees sense!! Is there any wonder politicians are held in such low esteem when they continue to destroy the landscape just to look green...23022015-03-27T23:54:23.68239James RoxburghSigned22942015-03-27T23:56:58.7578240Gill RoxburghSigned22942015-03-28T07:55:35.578241Diana GoodbournWe hope that Loch Ness and the Great Glen are very good sites and I hope they will survive.23022015-03-28T16:05:09.9738243Anna SargentDo not do irreversible damage to this unique place.23022015-03-28T17:11:48.0378244Maureen CaseI have serious doubts that the present planning situation is doing anything to protect this world famous and special area. I fear that the area will be ruined for both visitors and locals.23022015-03-28T17:22:32.468245Bernard CaseTo protect the remaining unspoilt Highland Region with Loch Ness and the Great Glen at its heart, a moratorium on all future turbine schemes is essential whilst an assessment on the impact is made.23022015-03-28T18:17:23.2238246Ian DaileyI find this situation alarming and it is clear to me that the SNP are clearly no friend to the environment nor to the people of Scotland and those of us who live abroad.23022015-03-29T02:40:12.438247vicky dallengerLoch Ness is an iconic part of Scottish heritage!!23022015-03-29T11:26:03.278248gavin duffyOffenders like this should never be released from prison 22412015-03-29T13:12:19.5378249Kevin WilliamsI cannot beleive the Scottish Parliament and Government are considering letting up to 500 wind turbines to be sited on land around Loch Ness, The Great Glen, Beinn Mhor ( nearTomich and Loch Affric). Did the Government not announce in June a new planning policy bannig wind farms in national parks and national scenic areas. If any of these wind turbines arer allowed to be constructed in Scot 23022015-03-29T15:10:20.3038251Deborah MasseyDon't sell your beauty Scotland, it is priceless !!23022015-03-29T16:57:42.3178252Mariusz BiskiIt looks as if wind industry was trying to continue to excercise its power on the Scots. There is, however, too much evidence concerning adverse effects on environment and human health. As this plague has already reached Loch Ness, it may just as well reach your backyard, the way it reached mine, one of those days. Consequences are cataclysmic. Don't you ever let them put up those monsters there! Your children will never forgive you!23022015-03-29T19:39:45.298253Ruth AdamsThis is a popular area for tourism. More than 15 years ago this was the first place to hat I stayed on holiday. The scenery was so breathtaking that it drew me back year after year until I could not longer leave such beauty and moved up to live in Sutherland in 2011. Since then there has been such an increase in applications for windfalls in areas of outstanding beauty. The question to be asked is will the area draw in tourists still when these farms blight the skyline throughout the Great Glen and beyond. Companies may offer the local communities community funding but how much more money will be lost to local businesses by tourists no longer coming to the area as it's too ugly to visit any more?23022015-03-29T21:07:29.6478254catherine irvine I agree that breeders should be made to limit the amount of bunnys they breed as most people buy them and then realise they are hard work you need a lot of time and patience and vet care and when people realise this they get rid of them its so sad22922015-03-30T01:10:35.388255William FraserWe already suffer from approval of far too many applications for construction of wind farms in areas quite unsuited to this type of obtrusive industrial development. We are fortunate in Scotland to have some of the finest remaining wild land in Europe - wild land that millions of others are happy to travel far and pay handsomely to see and experience. It is part of our heritage as Scots. Loch Ness and the Great Glen are prime examples of this. We have a duty to recognise their uniqueness and worth, and to safeguard them for future generations. For decades, many of our residents have derived their livelihood from catering for those who travel to witness the scenic grandeur we have to offer. This is likely to become an increasingly significant factor in Scotland's economic future. Accumulating actual output data for existing wind farms shows that their potential contribution to our requirement for renewable energy has been vastly over-hyped by those who stand to profit from their construction. Wind farms with projected efficiencies of 30% and over are being shown to struggle to reach even 20%. In the UK, they tend to produce most electricity at times when nobody needs it. We are all footing the bill for misguided subsidies that are inducing a flood of totally inappropriate applications for wind farm construction. Most are made by those whose sole interest is easy profit in the short term. They don't "do" long-term thinking. Someone else is going to have to do the long-term thinking required to safeguard our heritage. I therefore urge you to 1) Afford protection to the Loch Ness and Great Glen by designating it as a National Scenic Area 2) Recommend that a priority application is made to UNESCO for designation of the Loch Ness area and the Great Glen as a World Heritage Site 3) Take appropriate steps to discourage all wind farm developments in this area, and support the restoration of all sites therein damaged by wind turbines.\r\nWilliam Fraser BSc, MIMechE, CEng23022015-03-30T11:25:42.188256Steve LambThis is an area of outstanding natural beauty. Please leave it that way.23022015-03-30T15:11:09.6178257kathy bluefieldScotland has the last few wilderness areas and areas of outstanding natural beauty to be enjoyed not only by residents in the area but it is also a major attraction for tourism. Millions of pounds are spent by tourists and lots of businesses would not survive without the money which this generates.\r\nPlease leave this area free of ugly inefficient wind turbines.23022015-03-30T21:57:16.2238258James McComasThese developments represent short term gain for a few thanks to government subsidies against long term marring of the countryside for everyone - a very short sighted policy23022015-03-31T11:24:31.4938259Brian JaggerWindfarms are not the solution to our energy needs, they are inefficient and damaging to the visual environment. This proposal will bring questionable economic benefits at the cost of lost revenue from tourism to an iconic area of Scotland.23022015-03-31T11:53:21.8978260Kathryn SquireThe increasing industrialisation of Loch Ness and the surrounding landscape is unacceptable. Local communities have objected to applications for windfarms in the area in their thousands - and yet, the Scottish Government continue their drive for 100% renewable energy at the expense of the environment. How contradictory is this? I fully support the priority application to UNESCO for World Heritage protection.23022015-03-31T15:29:30.498261Sorcha Ni AoidheYes these are sites of International importance, icons and like the rest of the countries that are be desecrated by the wind industry it is time for the people to take a stand. This is not working...\r\n23022015-03-31T18:38:52.9138262Les O'BrienWe need this entered into the statute books to send a clear message to persistently violent criminals and to give the victims families a sense of justice.22412015-03-31T18:40:58.3978263Helen GardinerLife should mean life. Until you die. That's what they deserve if they take an innocent life22412015-03-31T19:06:02.078264Robert groveThis country depends predominantly on tourism and this government seems hellbent on destroying what people come here to see....it's great natural beauty. It has to stop now. Wind turbines are a monstrosity and a huge blot on our landscape. There are alternatives but greed blinds the politicians as it always has done! Save this beautiful country NOW while we still can!23022015-03-31T22:32:07.4738265mel randallenough is too much, would they be building these turbines without subsidies I dont think so\r\n23022015-03-31T22:49:30.1638266William SpaldingClearly, there are dangerous individuals who can slip through the net of the Parole Board. In cases where violence is involved, the punishment element of sentencing must reflect the crime and be seen as a deterrent. Being released after previous multiple violent offences shows it is failing to deter further offending and tougher measures are needed to protect society. The rights of the many must outweigh the right of an individual.22412015-03-31T23:21:14.3978267Eric DickisonScotland relies on tourists.\r\nI should know, I run a guesthouse.\r\nTourists come here to see Scotland's natural beauty.\r\nNOT WIND TURBINES.23022015-03-31T23:57:30.5538268Karen RodenWe have been visiting Scotland as a family holiday for 15 years and each year it has been getting worse, and it has now got that we think this will be our last year. There is NO justification for what these massive wind turbines and their attendant pylons, miles of access roads, sub stations etc are doing to Scotland's once stunning landscape. The Scottish Government should hang its head in shame.23022015-04-01T00:01:07.498269Harry AmeyA minority profit financially from a short term subsidy dependent business at the expense of the majority. A method of producing electricity that is inefficient, expensive, ecologically unsound and so intermittent that it will never be capable of replacing base power be that coal, gas or nuclear. All this whilst the health risks to residents are ignored. Shame on those in power who choose to continue with this disgraceful wind power fraud.23022015-04-01T00:51:01.9278271Karen WhartonWind turbines are intrusive, furthermore there are many doubts over their efficiency. Once damaged, Loch Ness can NEVER be recovered. I urge that this be designated a UNESCO world heritage site.23022015-04-01T04:44:45.4138272Butré Jean-LouisWind farms imperil wildlife and destroy natural habitats which have hitherto escaped the destructive powers of earth-moving equipment, concreting operations and other highly invasive human activities.\r\nThe negative effects of industrial wind turbines on people, landscapes, tourism, property values, wildlife, and the economy are widely understood and accepted. They are significantly altering Europe's natural and cultural heritage by their harmful effect on landscapes .\r\nIn France Mont Saint Michel have been saved from wind turbine's desater by UNESCO after years of battle\r\nNow Vezelay, Saint Savin,La Saline Royale, and all the most beautifull landscapes of France are under attack by the same promoters.\r\n Please stop ruining beautiful lands . Please save Loch Ness 23022015-04-01T06:43:05.6478273Jan EllisWhole life sentence with hard labour for violent offenders, even thats not suitable for these sort of low life.22412015-04-01T06:52:28.048274Stewart Gordon LIFE SHOULD MEAN LIFE!!22412015-04-01T07:26:23.5538275John CurtisThis endless, mindless, wanton destruction of beautiful Scotland must be stopped.23022015-04-01T07:56:28.18276Mark PawelekWind farms are not an economically viable solution for Scotland's energy needs. They provide unreliable, intermittent electricity. They damage the natural environment and take up vast spatial areas. There are far better alternatives.23022015-04-01T08:16:22.248277Mr. Andreas Marciniak" It's always about the almighty Dollar $$$$$$$$$$$$..The fact is ! There is no safe distance for wind Turbines, NOT GREEN, NOT CHEAP, NOT RELIABLE, and come with a very BAD side EFFECT on people and the ENVIRONMENT. there is Nothing GREEN about WIND TURBINES . SAY NO TO WIND TURBINES.23022015-04-01T08:29:53.358278Eddie FreemanSacrificing our natural heritage for multi-national company profits. They don't care, we have to. 23022015-04-01T09:44:35.9438280David BairdComplete and utter madness. Why is the Scottish Government letting this happen?23022015-04-01T10:49:39.968281Chris ParkI have no words.23022015-04-01T10:51:30.8178282Lorna PotterI've found a place I can call home, where I feel safe, where I feel my children are safe. Glen Convinth is only a few miles from Loch Ness and was a proposed site for a huge wind farm. Turbines are NOT the only green energy, money would be better spent on Solar Panels on Council Properties and Homes, not only would this help the environment but it would help families suffering from fuel poverty. Hydro Dams, we've got plenty of water and I know there's lots of people flock to Aigas each year to take pictures.23022015-04-01T11:00:53.7278283Mhari Drozdowska Out of date, not economical! Disgusting, depressing horrible giants, bad for environment, and health!! Completely destroy natural beauty. Think it is absolutely ridicules to even consider putting any windmills near Loch Ness, which is massively well known!! It's silly to put wind farms up any where!! 23022015-04-01T11:12:23.6178284Maureen WallaceIt's not just the visual impact of hundreds of turbines it's not fully understood the impact that construction of the turbines, the access routes and supply to the national grid make on the land. Due to the climate land does not recover for years you only need to look at any fire damage to the hillsides to see how long it takes. Turbines in their construction are not GREEN. \r\n23022015-04-01T11:40:45.468285Louise EvansPlease stop the destruction of our outstanding landscape and prescious environment!!23022015-04-01T12:12:56.1938286Andrew ShiellsThis plan is a disgrace. You would think the SNP by it's very name would protect Scotland, it's heritage and countryside. Not a bit of it. they're not in any way "green" - apart from behind their ears!23022015-04-01T12:57:46.298287Hector M RogersThe planet has been warming and cooling with ever changing climates throughout its existence (Green Planet C U P 1982) and will continue to do so whatever we humans do. There are other forms of less visually intrusive and more efficient renewable and green energy to which the resources currently directed to wind should be re-allocated e.g. wave, tidal and hydro and pusued energetically. There is also, so I understand, a widely available mineral (Thorium?) which is capable of producing non-toxic nuclear energy which is NOT suitable for weapons - hooray! This too shoud be investigated urgently.\r\nScotland's wild country and eco-systems is its 'Golden Egg' which should not be prostituted for political or economic ideals. 23022015-04-01T13:19:54.1638288J A RaperIf you wish to prosper don't destroy your assets23022015-04-01T13:40:33.278289John ScottIt's a source of embarassment to me whenever I have friends from abroad whom I take up north for a few days to enjoy the beautiful Scottish scenery. What must they think about us when they see us wantonly vandalising our unique landscape in the name of money. Because that's what it's really about. Shame on our politicians and industrial leaders who have let this happen!23022015-04-01T14:11:13.8338290Fiona GibbonsWhat are they thinking of?23022015-04-01T15:21:20.6638292Matthew YuillA LIFE SENTENCE SHOULD ME JUST THAT A FULL LIFETIME22412015-04-01T15:26:20.18293Catherine BayneIndustrial Wind developments are a manifestation of UN Agenda21 wealth transfer which are unsustainable without subsidies and have no place in a sane energy system.\r\n\r\nIndustrial Wind Turbines are environmentally, socially and economically destructive and are monuments to greed and gullibility.23022015-04-01T15:48:13.5078294Demagny JoelL'éolien industriel est une arnaque\r\nL'écologie de l'éolien est une arnaque\r\n\r\nIndustrial wind power is a scam\r\nThe ecology of the wind is a scam23022015-04-01T16:30:23.2438295zed yagloput yourself in the position of the offended and not the offender and tell anyone its not the correct decision...no room for liberalism when lives are being ruined by judges...do the crime do the time all of it....22412015-04-01T17:55:10.4938297Hilary BurdettThis absolute desicration of such a beautiful area & must be stopped now23022015-04-01T18:11:32.3838298Jane FraserWith strong family ties in this area of Scotland the on-going plans for more and more wind turbines are very alarming.\r\nI am a strong supporter of renewable energy but these turbines simply aren't fit for purpose. The technology is expensive and ineffective - our reliance on fossil fuels is not reduced in any way by the proliferation of turbines and the landscape (& the tourist industry) is seriously harmed by this creeping industrialisation.23022015-04-01T18:16:53.048299Roger StroudWhen is this madness going to stop? RIP Scottish scenery.It's not green - just GREED.23022015-04-01T18:25:00.1978300Helen ReevesMore evidence proving sustainability of Wind Farms WITHOUT government or any other subsidy is needed. More evidence proving Wind Farms do NOT affect wildlife nor humans nor the environment in any way is needed before any Wind farm is allowed to go ahead.\r\nAre Wind Farms truly, truly the way forward or they a short term solution to a very long term problem? Who will dismantle them and repair the wrong created by them? 23022015-04-01T18:47:18.0238301G SpeirsI am appalled at the wanton destruction of our 'wild and beautiful' landscape. All the efforts of the previous generation to save our green places are being destroyed in the name of 'green energy'. These areas will now be reclassified as 'industrial', so what happens once the wind folly ends???? 23022015-04-01T18:50:00.5878302Jo pageThe level of wind turbines proposed is completely unacceptable. Pure destruction of the landscape. This area should be protected.23022015-04-01T19:43:23.048303E GriffithsThe whole windustry is based on lies, deception and torture - yes, TORTURE. ETSU noise guidelines are designed NOT to measure the bulk of the noise emitted by industrial wind powered subsidy farms.23022015-04-01T20:44:13.2238305ian millerWind Turbines release enormous CO2 emissions in their manufacture installation & commissioning, totally out of proportion to that saved throughout their short lives, while utterly destroying our Scottish Natural Heritage.. 23022015-04-01T20:49:55.778306B GriffithsIf this goes ahead I will never go on holiday to this area again. I have loved it since childhood.. what utter desecration of a beautiful area. Unbelievable. Heartbreaking. 23022015-04-01T21:02:59.1938307andy leaderThis is vandalism.23022015-04-01T21:11:17.6638308Lynne barrieplease stop this it is a natural beauty spot 23022015-04-01T22:06:45.2578309Maggy ERNSTOur common duty is to preserve our heritage against swindle of wind farms23022015-04-01T22:23:19.5538310Marjorie GordonWind farms will spoil this beautiful area. Let everyone appreciate the beauty of this country and especially this tourist area, without the eyesore of so many wind turbines. How could anyone think this is right?23022015-04-01T22:36:58.3678311Fiona UrquhartThese Turbines have done nothing but torn communities apart and are ruining the last bastion of wilderness in Britain and Europe!!23022015-04-01T22:35:55.6938312Elaine KnellerThis area needs protecting, the wildlife needs protecting. Please stop the wind turbines.23022015-04-01T22:46:55.5538313Celia HobbsPlease stop this destruction of Scotland's iconic landscapes.We have spent nearly ten years fighting three wind farms and having won two now face another appeal next month. The wind farm proposals are three miles apart. There is something very wrong somewhere when the Councils have objected each time and the public have responded with a minimum of 94% against. I fear for the future of this country when local democracy does not count.The local people know the value of landscape to their well being and their tourism industry.The wind industry tried to maintain for years that house prices were not affected but now of course it has been proved they do. Similarily they say tourism is not affected. Of course it is - the Commonwealth Games and Ryder Cup will have masked the true figures this year. The Moffat study showed tourists a photo of a view from a hotel bedroom window with and without turbines. Over 60% said they preferred the view without.How can a nationalist Government destroy the country's greatest asset?\r\nPlease save what is left. I used to feel my heart soar when we left Moffat and climbed the Devil's Beeftub and know we were back in Scotland.Now I just feel sad as the turbines appear along the route. We have saved the Pentland Hills so far but it is in the hands of one man what this area will look like for the next twenty five years. 23022015-04-02T03:55:12.0078315Elizabeth RileyAs the daughter of a Scottish emigrant I was really saddened to see these "blots on the landscape" popping up wherever we went on our final pilgrimage "home" in 2014. My granddaughter came with us in 2008 when the pristine environment was pretty much unblemished, but she remembers very little of that trip. What will be left for her to see in her planned trip of 2020? It's heartbreaking! I realise we must stop polluting the atmosphere and move towards renewable energy but we must not do this at the expense of beautiful environments.23022015-04-02T05:18:59.6938316Butré AnickIt is a shame and a sham that the Scotish Parliament pretends\r\nto be ecologist , pretends to care about its land . Detroying "Lock Ness" with wind turbines is inconcievable23022015-04-02T07:13:06.18317Torbjorn ErikssonThe same sad song here on our treasure island, Holmon! www.friavindar.se23022015-04-02T08:15:08.3678318John StevenNessie will rise to it and protect her glen23022015-04-02T08:30:42.938319STRUAN STEVENSONTHIS IS THE SNP's REAL LEGACY FOR SCOTLAND - DEVASTATION!23022015-04-02T08:36:11.5538320Bea HoldenPlanning guidelines need to be overhauled urgently. Areas like this with high scenic value and important for tourism should not even be considered by developers. Guidance for developers needs to be clear that they will not be successful in this area.23022015-04-02T09:44:24.528321Elizabeth DunlopI object to my country being turned into an industrial park. Visitors come to Scotland primarily for the scenery,. Please do not destroy our greatest asset.23022015-04-02T09:52:46.0078322Margaret Hardingthese iconic landscapes appreciated by visitors and inhabitants for 1000s of years should not be desecrated by windfarms - which are environmentally destructive to birds, visually hideous and habitat destroying because of roads needed to be built and foundations to be put in which take up hundreds of acres of habitat and are not even able to operate in times of high pressure with no wind or too much wind and are cost efficient to the owners operators only because of subsidies and for no other reason.23022015-04-02T10:34:36.4478323Jean FriessIl est inconcevable et inadmissible qu'un site aussi emblématique que le Loch Ness soit sacrifié sur l'autel des énergies dites renouvelables : au nom de la protection des paysages, il faut sauver ce merveilleux site de la cupidité des opérateurs et de la stupidité d'élus qui , la plupart du temps, ne prennent pas en compte les paysages et la biodiversité dans l'élaboration de tels projets.\r\n\r\nIt is inconceivable and unacceptable that a site as iconic as the Loch Ness be sacrificed on the altar of so-called renewable energy: the name of landscape protection, we must save this wonderful site operators of greed and stupidity of elected officials who usually do not take into account the landscape and biodiversity in the development of such projects.23022015-04-02T10:41:32.7738324douglas hendersonLoch Ness is an important site for tourists and the great glen also windmills will destroy the features of the area the wildlife will also be affected 23022015-04-02T12:39:12.938325David WalmsleyThe steady ruination of the Scottish countryside and in particular areas such as the Great Glen by inefficient, subsidised turbines that enrich the few, create fuel poverty, will come home to roost when tourism and the income which flows from it ceases.23022015-04-02T13:09:03.468326Lenny CowiesonLoch Ness is a world renowned tourist destination why in the world does our government not protect this area ? These developments are fuelled by corporate and personal greed in pursuit of a dubious technology.23022015-04-02T13:31:26.8338327Lesley GreenI could think of a worse idea. Disgraceful that it has even been considered. The landscape would be completely ruined and tourists would probably avoid the area. 23022015-04-02T14:20:12.8978328Terry Andrews"You don't know what you've got 'til it's gone" - and if windfarms are allowed to bristle all over the Loch Ness surroundings, that's the chief appeal - gone for good. You can't manufacture wilderness. You can only respect and preserve it. Unless you think disneyfied "theme parks" a bigger draw?? 23022015-04-02T14:45:31.188329Katy InghamAbout time the exceedingly generous subsidies for these inefficient monstrosities ended, and people wake up to who is really financially benefitting from this environmental tokenism. 23022015-04-02T14:47:03.218330COLIN AITKENENOUGH IS ENOUGH - BUILD THEM IN THE CENTRAL BELT AND LEAVE OUR LAST REMAINING WILD SPACES ALONE.23022015-04-02T15:13:21.5538331John AlexanderWind turbines are inefficient and an eyesore. There popularity is based on keeping electricity generation in the hands of the big national suppliers. Protect our countryside and adopt other clean methods of electricity generation. 23022015-04-02T15:15:56.8038332Isabel CampbellWe must stop the proliferation of wind turbines around Loch Ness. Scotland already generates enough green energy to sustain itself.23022015-04-02T17:03:31.3378333Irene StewartThe scenery of wild Scotland is it's greatest asset. The damage caused by wind farms far outweighs the derisory amount of electricity they produce23022015-04-02T17:41:01.3978334John CrossanPrisoners should serve their full sentence at all times. Time should be added for bad behaviour not discount for would be "good behaviour".\r\n22412015-04-02T18:28:15.5678335Byron DaviesI am a tourist and I visit area several times a year, the Alps may now get my patronage in future23022015-04-02T18:53:17.578336anna wilsonWe test my child's INR at home and wouldn't like that to stop when he reaches adulthood.22342015-04-02T18:57:24.7578337Fabienne Chapuis Hiniplease, please, I beg you not to realize these foolish winpark witch are going to destroy these so beautifull place of nature with these marvellous lake. It is not worth it23022015-04-02T20:27:09.218338Karin ErikssonIt's a shame! Stop this madness now!!23022015-04-02T21:07:46.9938339francois guillotPLease just stop destroying our world 23022015-04-02T21:08:21.9138340Mrs L. HarrisThis is ridiculous that turbines could go on Loch Ness! What next, on Arthur's Seat? Loch Ness is often one of the first things many people who don't live in Scotland think of when talking of Scotland. Wind turbines are known to be NOT cost effective especially in the extreme temperatures we experience in the colder months when they simply cannot run due to no wind! Yes, Loch Ness should be protected from the scams that are wind turbine farms and any other such schemes that may come along. Please protect Loch Ness as it is for future generations -this is the least we can do.23022015-04-02T21:29:25.4478341Karen PanichLoch Ness and the Great Glen have much to offer tourists and this is a major concern. Without the beautiful scenery, I would be concerned over the attraction to this area by tourists, a major income for Highlanders. In addition, having lived there for 8 years, I would say, it is the number one attraction for living there. Will house prices be affected by such a big change? This will have a major impact.23022015-04-02T21:35:01.0078342alex mcleodWindpower development in UK is a monster out of control driven by the usual big business culprit....GREED and ablily assisted by the political puppets looking for a leg-up once they get the boot from Parliament23022015-04-02T22:01:04.8978343Neville RIGBYWind turbines are an unnecessary intrusion into the landscape which threaten to destroy the visual amenity and debase the natural beauty of the Great Glen. The tourism economy on which so many depend is being undermined by thoughtless and opportunistic development not only through wind turbines and the superfluous grid pylons that go with them, but unnecessary housing development both by speculative builders and greedy landowners cashing in on selling plots where there is no explanation for planning permission having been granted other than vested interest. The Great Glen needs to be saved from the shabby commercialisation that will become it's ruin.23022015-04-02T22:40:43.1638344Susan MurrayWindfarms are NOT the sensible way forward. We already have too many ruining the landscape. Loch Ness is particularly a spectacular tourist area which would be ruined by wind turbines\r\n23022015-04-02T22:51:09.7278345Mhairi BiggartThis is a great idea.\r\nPatients should be given the choice to manage their own condition. 22342015-04-03T01:04:00.298347Karen BancroftScotland is renowned for its natural beauty attracting visitors from all over the world. Tourism is one of Scotlands biggest earners. The Scottish Government funds public sector enterprises such as Scottish Natural Heritage, their purpose is to promote, care for and improvement of the natural heritage. Help people enjoy it responsibly. Enable greater understanding and awareness of it. Promote its sustainable use, now and for future generations. Why would the Government then eradicate their investment for the Scottish people and their visitors by allowing Scotland to have an Industrial Landscape? 23022015-04-03T06:02:03.4278349brian mayleLife should mean just that life with on parole.22412015-04-03T09:05:50.0678351tom JacobsI know civilisation has got to move on and adapt to the increased demand for energy but not at the expense of beautiful natural areas such as the Great Glen or any of the incredible areas within the Scottish Highlands. These areas have a diverse array of wildlife and habitats and once destroyed will never be the same again. We WILL regret destroying out countryside and special areas of natural beauty in the future if we don't fight to save them now.23022015-04-03T12:31:14.18354Dee BabinWhere IS the department of joined up thinking, to protect environment and our heritage. Who is able to stand up to this power-hungry, short-sighted , profit driven sector? The out-dated technology of these greedy people does nothing to support a sustainable future. I agree with what has been said below, but who is listening?23022015-04-03T12:44:39.5078355Ira FishmanPlease don't let others to destroy the natural beauty that is such a vital part of Scotland. These wind turbines are truly a blot on the landscape, and not just in Scotland. Moreover, they are not a proven source of reliable and cost-effective energy according to many scientists in the field. Though Don Quixote is known for his fictional antics in Spain, today he would certainly give Scotland a hand in an attempt to rid the countryside of these monstrosities that are already in place. Enough is more than enough. 23022015-04-03T12:56:50.3978356Rachel ConnorThis is not a 'green' development, this is simply 'greed' development at the expense of our iconic landscape, and our environment for decades to come. There are predictable serious effects on drinking water, wildlife and the people who call this land 'home' - ignored by our Government and disregarded as 'collateral damage' by the developers.23022015-04-03T14:06:53.18357Donald MacKenzieWind farms are subsidy engines and do not "save the planet". Once you take into account carbon losses from ground disturbance at turbine sites and access road networks they do not contribute to a carbon reduction. 23022015-04-03T16:22:57.2878359Keith CowiesonThe areas proposed for development are rich in iconic Scottish birdlife - golden eagle, osprey, hen harrier, black and red-throated diver, golden plover and curlew amongst many others. Birds and wind farms do not mix well - we know this from our own and other nations' experience. And then there is the visual blemish on a world-famous area of outstanding natural beauty. Finally, tearing up the peat covered hills to build tracks and windfarm bases would release significant quantities of CO2 - peat is one of the best natural sequesters of carbon. This is ill-conceived on so many levels....23022015-04-03T16:25:57.1638360Annette MansieOur daughter was born in Inverness, and we have always loved the highlands, and wind farms are unsightly.23022015-04-03T16:51:32.548361Chaperon du larret NataliaWhen will it stop?this kind of energie kills thousand of birds....I'm sick of it!!!!23022015-04-03T18:16:21.8378362Brian CherekThis plan will simply turn The Highlands into an industrial wasteland and destroy the amazing birds of prey of Scotland. The introduction of these wind farms would be a crime on a scale never seen in this country and would only line the pockets of certain individuals from the people who can least afford it, the public. The evidence worldwide now shows the hazards and risks associated with wind farms and their technology. It doesn't take a lot to look it up and read the facts for yourself. The Scottish government cannot say at a later date that they didn't know what the risks were as an idiot could find the evidence. 23022015-04-03T18:22:39.5078363Tom reidStop ruining our countryside with an inefficient source of energy!!!23022015-04-03T20:57:15.7278364Axel FRANKSummer 1978. It's one of my best souvenir... I had eleven years old...in travel with my parents in Scotland. It's pure and beautyfull... Something you can't remove off my mind and my soul....23022015-04-03T21:58:36.468365Jackie kellyYou go girl xx22342015-04-03T22:26:26.828366Stewart YatesThis is horrific. And not to mention absolutely absurd, to build so far from the point of demand! Why? Money. Big (subsidised) bucks for big business. No. Stop this. Please. You are destroying the very thing that Scotland is known for and admired around the globe. Stop this. Please. Enough. Please stop.23022015-04-03T23:06:19.7738367Nicola ReillyI fully support this petition and I urge others to sign up.22342015-04-04T00:17:19.468368Nicola ThomasI work in Govan, Glasgow, just along from the Shieldhall Waste Water Treatment Works. I live in Avonbridge, Falkirk. There is a constant stench from the Shieldhall Works, so much so that my colleagues and i have to hold our breath when we drive past. Regarding during the summer months I cannot begin to describe how horrific the smell can be, even inside my office building. I chose to live in Avonbridge so my family and I could enjoy a fresh rural life, within reasonable proximity to urban facilities. There is nothing like coming home to fresh air and fields surrounding your house. I am absolutely appalled that the Scottish Parliament is considering building a sewage treatment plant so close to our homes here in Avonbridge and Standburn. There is plenty of open space available in the central belt of Scotland, near the arterial road network where this could be built which would not affect people and their daily lives. I for one would seriously consider moving should these plans become reality. What right does the Scottish Government have to decide that we as tax payers have to put up with a regular stench, which I can assure you it will be. Perhaps we should ask them to come and garden in our village, hang their washing out or let their children play in our streets once it is up and running. 22762015-04-04T08:53:42.8978369Isabelle RineauThe advertising of baby bunnies as fluffy friendly pets suitable for children is totally irresponsible and most of the animals end up in rescues or abandoned in the following weeks when the novelty has worn off. Many others die of neglect. The rescues cannot cope with the number of unwanted animals in terms of space, time and costs. There should be a ban on the breeding and selling of rabbits and anyone serious about offering a good home should contact their local rescue.22922015-04-04T10:25:23.548370Brian TyrellI object to all wind turbines and the exorbitant cost and destruction to the environment and I belive the true fact are witheld, another man made disaster in the making, money over all else I despair.23022015-04-04T10:45:57.858371Michael John HallThe once delightful journey up the motorway from England to Scotland has been destroyed by uncontrolled wind developmets. How sad that this is spreading into even more scenic areas. The Scottish Government should hang its head in shame,23022015-04-04T11:04:41.8678372Ronald L HartA windfarm is proposed near Corsock, is there a campaign to stop it?23022015-04-04T12:08:22.6178373gail hendryYou are such an inspiration mary x22342015-04-04T12:35:11.8178374D PowellGranting permission for this outrage amounts to the triumph of ill-conceived dogma and ignorance over democracy and the landscape which makes Scotland unique.23022015-04-04T12:52:58.8338375Anthony TrewavasThe proposed turbines around Loch Ness indicate the madness that this government purveys as a generating policy. But then none of them are qualified to control something so necessary and complex as electricity supply. Two extra nuclear power stations would have obviated all these turbines but then no one in this government is competent to make any decision about nuclear power.23022015-04-04T13:03:50.5078376robert hoggWe have to stop the march of these wind turbines. otherwise we will not have any wilderness left in Scotland. Tourists come to scotland for the landscape not to look at wind turbines. Stop this now.23022015-04-04T13:55:12.1778377Anthony FitzherbertA PROPOSED VANDALISM OF A WONDERFUL AND TREASURED PIECE OF MOUNTAIN SCENERY TO SATISFY THE GREED OF THE DEVELOPERS AND THE PROPRIETORS OF THE LAND THAT WILL COST US ALL A FORTUNE AND DO NOTHING TO SAVE THE PLANET23022015-04-04T15:25:22.6978379Bruce ChisholmEnough is Enough - we must keep the countryside as countryside & stop repeatedly spoiling it. Make the area an NSA & once & for all resolve the matter protecting the area for future generations.23022015-04-04T15:36:21.0838380Erica SarneyI am disgusted by the blight on the landscape of wind farms in Scotland. I urge you to protect this area from devastation by wind farm development23022015-04-04T16:33:15.468381Alan JohnsonWind farms do not save the environment, they destroy it 23022015-04-04T16:42:18.858382Christian RIOLSActual wind farms are nothing else than big business threatening both ours landscapes, birds and chiros. We are also fighting against in southern France where are living so many large raptors and other living treasures !23022015-04-04T16:45:54.6638383john askeyWhat priorities do we have here when over 1 million people sign a petition to keep a so called celebrity but only just over a 1000 sign one to preserve one of the most beautiful areas in the world!23022015-04-04T17:22:46.1338384Lafarge YvetteCessez de détruire ces beaux paysages par des machines industrielles inutiles\r\n\r\nStop destroying these beautiful landscapes with unnecessary industrial machinery23022015-04-04T17:54:45.68385David W PottsThe SG should ensure that sensitive areas such as this are protected for the future. In the long term these developments will have a detrimental impact on tourism.23022015-04-04T18:57:47.9278386Sue SmithThis is tragic and, yes, it does make you want to weep. What a disgraceful destruction of an iconic Scottish landscape? And a sure way to bite the hand of tourism that feeds so many businesses :(\r\n23022015-04-04T19:14:59.328387Gloria McGuiganI feel that the snp obsession with wind turbines has already destroyed the natural beauty of our countryside and enough is enough - the tourists come to see the beauty not the turbines - snp are a disgrace23022015-04-04T19:35:40.3038388George F WoodThis historic site should not be spoiled by the erection of wind-turbines !!!.23022015-04-04T19:41:35.328389neil macleodLoch Ness is famous throughout the world and should not have its unique views spoiled by windturbines23022015-04-04T20:37:39.8338390Anne WhitePlease, please stop industrialising this beautiful country. As a frequent visitor to Scotland, I look on with dismay as more and more of your country looks like a wind factory, totally detracting from the reasons people visit. Please--STOP IT!23022015-04-04T20:55:10.328391Jean KedarThis is one of the most iconic areas in Scotland. Please keep it free of turbines!23022015-04-04T20:58:41.1638392Andrew KedarNo hideous turbines in this majestic scenery!23022015-04-04T21:10:16.2578393David leadbetterSubsidised wind power is a wholly discredited technology . The desecration of our natural heritage by the Current Scottish Government is a betrayal of the Scottish people. 23022015-04-04T21:12:24.298394Elaine Provan Please allow patients with lifelong conditions the opportunity to have a say in their treatment 22342015-04-04T21:16:36.438395Alex WintonWe need politicians with the courage to bring about a change that already exists in every other European Member State, and is enforced. Put the safety of the law abiding citizens before that of murderers, rapists and paedophiles, released back into society after committing crimes of a monstrous nature.\r\n\r\nPoliticians from every party should be forced to listen. We have had enough of these inflicting death and terror (at tax payers expense) as a result of unjustifiable lenient sentences. To all politicians, the message is simple, have the courage to protect the people you were elected to serve.\r\n22412015-04-04T21:28:24.6638396Nadine MatrulloIl faut respecter ces paysages extraordinaires et ne pas les polluer avec ces machines à fric !\r\n\r\nWe must respect these extraordinary landscapes and not pollute the money with these machines!23022015-04-04T21:35:45.7438397John Lennon I left Scotland a number of years ago and come from that area, I return every year and have brought many of my Australian who in turn took theirs. If these wind farms are allowed it will rob not only me of my return to Scotland by will rob tourism in the area, people will never again be able to see these glens in all of their beauty, it must not be allowed and the corrupt and inept politics should be held accountable by means of an inquiry to audit the approval process. Please Please for our and our fore bearers future don't allow this unnecessary greed to ruin these glens, we must all at least plead because protest is not working. 23022015-04-04T21:39:25.0078398Karen walkerEnough is enough no more in our countryside .. 23022015-04-04T21:54:52.438399Carrie Anne RiceGod Bless u..u always had a wonderful smile n always said hello and chatted away at work in international..... X x22412015-04-04T22:17:22.8838400Judi SmithLoch Ness and the Great Glen and a huge tourist attraction and bring in a lot of revenue for Scotland. Why,oh Why is this most stunning of areas being blighted be these huge ugly turbines. Why don't they put the blessed things in Wales, in the Peaks, on Dartmoor, East Anglia. It makes me so cross. Anything abhorrent - oh let's put it in Scotland. It's about time that attitude changed. 23022015-04-04T22:18:21.3978401Michael Smith Definitely should be stopped. 23022015-04-04T23:25:15.4138402John FeganI am hopeful this petition is successful as it will enable patients to manage their condition being involved in their own care 22342015-04-04T23:42:17.998403Shannon SwaabScotland with Loch Ness and the Great Glen is one of the last wildernesses and is a favourite holiday destination for people from the Netherlands. Please leave it as it is.23022015-04-04T23:53:37.9278404Alan EvansThe steady desecration of valuable Scottish landscape by wind turbine development is one of the most spectacular failures of the Scottish Government. It is time to call a halt to this especially as off-shore turbine development is about to commence on a massive scale.23022015-04-05T00:13:37.9138405Paul SimMy wife and I have spent many a happy week in the Highlands. We have recently returned from our latest 10 day trip, and the windturbines are getting more numerous. NOT just around Loch Ness. If they continue building, it will have a huge impact on the land, the people and wildlife. WE MUST conserve the Scottish Highlands for future generations...And not to line the pockets of the few.23022015-04-05T00:30:26.5678406Rosemary SherwinHave visited Loch Ness region on many occcassions and still marvel at the scenery. Please don't ruin it with these useless turbines that do nothing but ruin the landscape as well as slaughtering birds and bats.23022015-04-05T07:38:43.1978407Loretta EdmonstonI live near a windfarm that I tried hard to stop. The noise is unrelenting, our television, computer etc. are constantly interferred with and the effects of the infrasound,my main worry, are largely unknown.23022015-04-05T08:30:41.7738408Manjit RamHope I never need it but may it be available to those who do.22342015-04-05T09:19:48.968409Peter SwanWe have to find a way to save and generate our energy that does not continue to destroy so many of the beautiful areas of Scotland. We are rapidly turning Scotland into one giant windfarm.23022015-04-05T09:46:52.0238410David BromleyWhy this obsession with carpeting the country with wind turbines? They will never provide more than a small fraction of our energy needs not matter how many are erected. The environment loses out to big business yet again!23022015-04-05T10:09:18.4738411Gilbert NaudetI spent my professional live in energy studies. Wind power is not vailable from energy, enviromental and economy point of wiev, you can be sure..23022015-04-05T11:33:51.1638412Chris ROQUESsame problems here in " Baie de Somme"23022015-04-05T12:14:37.9278415Steve DavisonIt's almost unbelievable that the Scots would destroy one of the biggest tourist attractions they have by turning it into an industrial wind farm landscape. Politicians should hang their heads in shame.23022015-04-05T12:22:44.578416leslie john masonyou have to live in a town to appreciate what is in the country,do not spoil it with man made items23022015-04-05T12:43:47.548417Roger PirrieDisgraceful!23022015-04-05T12:44:15.2878418Geoffrey KolbeLoch Ness is a national treasure and should not be despoiled23022015-04-05T12:50:01.4138419Michael MilneIt can't come soon enough.22922015-04-05T13:19:52.718420Joani SIMONIl faut absolument cesser d'implanter ces engins de mort qui tuent les oiseaux, le gibiers, et les humains à cause des infrasons émis et dont personne ne vous parlera, mais moi je suis radioamateur.\r\n\r\nIt is imperative to stop implementing these deadly devices that kill birds, game, and humans because of infrasound emitted and nobody will talk to you, but I am amateur.23022015-04-05T14:13:38.1178421Michael mcdonaldPlease do not allow wind turbines to destroy the beautiful Scottish scenery. This great area that attracts thousands of tourists.23022015-04-05T15:21:35.968422Jacqueline Annette RovenskyAs a British Citizen as well as an Australian Citizen I am concerned about the encroachment of Industrial Wind Turbines into the environment, and especially where that environment is of important scenic beauty. Further the encroachment of these IWT's will not enhance the environment in anyway, they are unable to reduce CO2 and cause immense damage to bird life. They also emit a signature noise which is now recognised as infra-sound which causes health issues in humans with possible as yet un-researched distress to animals and birds. For Loch Ness and the Great Glen to be damaged in such a way will be recorded in history as a deliberate act of environmental vandalism, and those who sanction it will take their place in history as ignorant people with no understanding of duty of care to the environment.23022015-04-05T15:22:03.9738423Erica JonesAlthough I now live in Canada I was born in Scotland & lived in the Highlands until my mid-twenties.I still visit every couple of years & think this beautiful area should remain as pristine as possible-- scenery & wildlife habitat.23022015-04-05T16:50:46.68425Ann ChristieWhile I support the Scottish Government's drive towards energy independence, it always seems to be at the expense of iconic areas of our country. Why not around towns, where there are sufficient industrial areas that can absorb the impact of wind farms easily? Please leave the Great Glen and Loch Ness alone. These are vital to our tourism as they are, not polluted by yet more wind farms. 23022015-04-05T16:57:36.0378426lorina gardenWhy I will not vote SNP, how can they be allowed to ruin our countryside with these monstrous structures. 23022015-04-05T17:16:07.638427patricia LaederichThere are many places for windfarms. There is only one Loch Ness.23022015-04-05T18:40:11.6178428Guérin HubertSVP, laissez le Loch Ness intact\r\n\r\nPlease leave Loch Ness intact.23022015-04-05T19:18:38.1338430Vanessa Abdulla Think if the welfare of rabbits. 22922015-04-05T19:32:38.638431William J taylorFor almost all of my working life I have been. Professional aviator. For more than 20 of those years I worked for the small but very significant Scottish Airline 'Loganair'! In 20 x 4 seasons I have seen Scotland at its worst and at its best and, though an Irishman, have come to love it as much as any Scot. I have seen this country from a perspective that very very few will have enjoyed and I can tell you that the continued construction of these generating sites, of arguable efficiency, is a blight on the landscape and an insult to Scotland. The landscape of this beautiful country is being destroyed for a questionable gain and it is time to stop. Build these wind farms out at sea, but please do not desicrate one of the most beautiful countries in the world with what is an abomination!!23022015-04-05T20:16:31.468432Irene BondI will NEVER VISIT this area should it be industrialized in this way23022015-04-05T20:32:02.9278434Henrik SvanholmMore and more Danes are against windturbines because the politicians prefer to support the Industry instead of protect people from lowfrequent noise.23022015-04-05T20:36:02.5538435Nick CookeThis problem is compounded hugely by Scottish Government Ministers regularly approving appeals by wind farm developers against planning refusals from local Councils. The blind dogma being promoted by this SNP administration is fuelling the proliferation of wind turbines when their cost efficiency and environmental benefits are highly dubious in relation to wave or tidal power. The only real winners are the major corporate developers who can take advantage of the subsidies funded by us the taxpayers. It is a replication of the scandalous 'tax break forestry' regime of the 1970s and 80s all over again, and will have a similar end result. 23022015-04-05T20:46:59.5678436Etienne Meunierles éoliennes industrielles sont une escroquerie scientifique et financière\r\n\r\nindustrial wind turbines are scientific and financial scam23022015-04-05T21:40:38.188437Teresa KempWind farms destroy the environment. Create toxic lakes in China. Tons of concrete poured into the land. Steel production creating toxins. Decimating wild life, birds and bats. Negative knock-on effect to the sustainability of the eco-system. Negative health effects on the human population. Raises utility costs creating fuel-poverty. Lowers housing prices adjacent to the wind farms. Vast amounts of money goes to the developers, whilst the countryside is ravaged by building an industrial power plant. Most of the turbines cannot be recycled at the end of their life, and end up in landfill sites. Why are we destroying our landscapes for these inefficient machines? Come up with a better solution than this. 23022015-04-05T21:59:34.7578438Leeson CarlyleWindfarms are power generating stations. Nuclear fission reactors are power generating stations. Both have visual and environmental drawbacks. Just as exceptional care is taken in the planning of our nuclear power capability, so the same level of due diligence must be applied to our wind generation capability. I'm not intimating zero wind powered generation, but its planning should be centrally managed on a strategic scale.23022015-04-05T22:22:24.1478439David MortimerI am from Australia, have visited Loch Ness many times and have always been enthralled by its wild beauty. Environmental vandalism caused by the totally useless power generation that is wind farms, must be stopped now. 23022015-04-05T22:24:35.7578440Angus MaciverAt present the RSPB and others are surveying the population of Golden Eagles in Scotland. \r\nDoes the Scottish Government realise that large industrial turbines being installed in mountain areas throughout Scotland will cause a loss of habitat to this iconic species and no doubt over the coming years will cause the death to them and other large raptors like Sea Eagle, Osprey , Peregrine Falcon and Buzzard.\r\nAt the planning stage there is supposed to be an environmental assessment which will factor in the number of large birds expected to be killed at any windfarm within a 12 month period.\r\nWill the Scottish Government make available the figures of such deaths annually and if no one is counting, why not. It is a national disgrace.23022015-04-05T23:16:08.2238441Pat WellsTime to end the Scottish Government's planning dictatorship for wind farm developments. Time to look objectively at the science and develop policies which will GENUINELY reduce carbon emissions. Time to stop the large-scale destruction of Scotland's precious natural heritage with industrial-scale power stations in totally inappropriate locations. The SNP's legacy becomes more shameful with every wind farm approved by ministers.23022015-04-06T00:05:44.3038442Brian CrokerWise up people-Bloom Energy has pioneered an on site box 4" (100mm) cube that can provide sufficient electricity for a small house. Just increase the box size to meet greater need. God has overtaken our inadequacy & stupidity. Amen.23022015-04-06T02:04:39.3678444Janobai SmithLoch Ness, which is situated in the land of my forebears, was a highlight of my visit to Scotland. I am very sad to hear that there are now plans to build industrial wind turbines in this special place.23022015-04-06T05:02:49.6938445Martin HaylesI travelled through this area back in '87. Simply beautiful. To desecrate this area with Industrial Wind Turbines will, someday in the near future be viewed as a criminal act of intentional vandalism.\r\n\r\nI trust these criminals will be held to account as they know that windmills have nothing to do whatsoever in reduction of CO2.\r\n\r\nAlso, for nearly 2 decades CO2 output has continued to rise whilst warming has not.23022015-04-06T07:41:43.188446Graham AndersonHow can you all be so short sited. Our land is our heritage , once destroyed , it's gone forever. We have enough water in Scotland to put Hydro schemes in which don't destroy our landscape. It's just greed and money that is driving this suicide mission. Planners and government think about your grand children.23022015-04-06T07:56:13.188447Rhona ClarkHow do we exist when the tourist stop returning when they can only see the White monstrosities. They are noisy too. Horrendous.23022015-04-06T08:10:22.2878448John ChalmersI have a cottage in Tomich and for 60 years have spent much of my spare time Enjoying the wonderful scenery in the area which must be one of the most beautiful places in Scotland and a great attraction to visitors from many countries who have come to enjoy our cottage. Apart from destroying the beauty of the countryside these enormous turbines will destroy the tourist industry in much of Scotland. Please do not allow this dreadful threat to our landscape take place. Some things are worth much more than money. 23022015-04-06T09:12:54.1338450Brian SandisonPlease, do we really want the thousands of tourists who visit Loch Ness every year to have this view spoiled? They may not come back and even more importantly, they may tell their friends not to come. Please consider this urgently!23022015-04-06T09:12:27.5378451John TylerHave just visited Fort William & the Great Glen to find it stunningly beautiful. Surely the protection of this scenery should be the number one priority in assessment of alien structure applications.23022015-04-06T09:52:59.6638452Mark WhitlockIt a place of natural beauty, I have traveled many places in the world, but nothing as beautiful as this can be seen with your eyes, man will distroy the world.23022015-04-06T09:54:17.1338453Remko Stibbe - the NetherlandsI am shocked to learn that one the most beautiful and wild lands of Europe might be destructed forever because of this not well thought of windmill project. We love to come to Scotland and esp to this region. Well, not anymore if the windmill project will come into realisation.\r\n\r\nDid you factor in the costs of a much a collapsing tourism, not only for these regions but for Scotland as a whole? As a lot of people are combining visiting Loch Ness and the Great Glen with going to other places in Scotland as well? What about the costs of the scenery being spoilt?\r\n\r\nPlease re-consider this project.\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n23022015-04-06T10:12:43.7278454Jim Hutson.The hills will be scared forever with all the roadworks interlocking all the turbines. That in itself is an environmental disaster. One can only imagine the amount of money that will be passed under the table to secure this mess.23022015-04-06T10:47:40.9778456Richard HodgsonPlease don't kill the beauty of my homeland23022015-04-06T11:14:52.578457Pamela DobbieWe are now overrun with wind turbines here in Aberdeenshire. Please do not allow this to happen in such an iconic place!23022015-04-06T13:32:33.798458Larry LorussoLeave it alone!23022015-04-06T14:34:42.0878459David BryceIt would be a positive step forward22412015-04-06T14:39:15.388460Keith MacKenzieBeing from Inverness, I appreciate the natural beauty of the Great Glen. Cycling out to Loch Ness was mandatory for me, the peace, tranquility and unspoilt scenery are deeply imbedded in my memory and would like future generations of people to see as well as appreciate. I am in favour of wind turbines but their is a place for them, the Great Glen is not the place!!23022015-04-06T15:00:09.078461Shelagh D IwanowiczIt will be thirty years this year since my husband and I first visited Glen Strathfarrar and the beauty and unspoiled wild landscapes have drawn us back every year since.\r\n\r\nGlen Strathfarrar together with Glen Affric and Glen Cannich, the local people, their farms and businesses are a unique and wonderful example of how the two can live in harmony and be of benefit to each other and to the Scottish economy.\r\n\r\nThis proposed development will put an end to this and all in the area will suffer and tourism will decline too.\r\n\r\nI value the communities who work and live there. This proposed development will have severe impact on people and families, business enterprises, the treasured countryside and the tourism industry \r\n\r\nThis area of beauty & wild nature must be preserved for local communities and future generations.\r\n\r\nPlease listen to me and others who are against this development and protect this area from this development. This wild land must be saved for the benefit of local people, businesses and future generations. Also for people who travel from all over the world to visit the unspoilt Scottish Highlands.\r\n\r\nMany thanks, \r\nShelagh D Iwanowicz\r\n23022015-04-06T16:42:55.7438462Jonathan Wynne EvansIt is perfectly staggering that the Scottish Government is encouraging the devastation of the Scottish landscape heritage with these uneconomic bits of scrap while prating about looking after Scottish interests. Wake up!!23022015-04-06T16:44:25.6178463RD CONYBEAREWind turbine and solar farm construction has got out of hand. Companies are usuing limited resourses as an excuse to make huge profits regardless of the way these installations affect the local area.23022015-04-06T17:41:48.4138464Pascale RavéWinds turbines, ecological excuse or economic interests ? \r\nWill our kids have the same happiness that us like wild Scotland ? Who likes Scotland get up !23022015-04-06T17:42:49.998465John ClarkeDue to the insistence of the SNP to destroy our beautiful landscape with such eyesores, they will not getting my vote in any election.23022015-04-06T18:03:02.6178466Rod McLeodThere are far too many already, No More. The Scottish Tourist Board is very quiet with regards future Windfarm developments as they are concerned about their funding from the Scottish Government. Local people and tourists and people who care about the local environment and economy do not require anymore scars on the hillsides. An utter disgrace if this was allowed to happen.23022015-04-06T18:05:08.4438467Alan O'HaganEnough is enough. The people who are letting this happen to our beautiful country are idiots.23022015-04-06T18:25:54.8178469Vanessa SigsworthWhy isn't this a World Heritage Site? It's world famous - don't let them line theirs pockets and make it infamous.23022015-04-06T18:54:13.4478470EVRARD MICHELthose windmills are a plague destroying the most scenic landscape of earth as in our country in Auvergne23022015-04-06T19:07:55.3978471Irene CochranePlease don't ruin our beautiful natural area with wind turbines.23022015-04-06T19:34:02.188472donald MackHaving lived a large part of my life in the area i know it well and strongly believe this glen & local area should be free of this destructive commercialisation for later generations to enjoy & appreciate. this quick buck development should not be asllowed.23022015-04-06T19:37:03.828473Susan ChisholmI frequently visit family in the area and spend time in the hills enjoying the beautiful scenery.It makes not sense to ruin the very thing that visitors come to the area to experience. wind turbines are by no means proven to be efficient but are known to damage wildlife.23022015-04-06T19:56:24.998475chrissy de deckerWe lived in Scotland for 9 years very near to Loch Ness,and it's the most beautiful country for me!! it would be a great shame if those windmills go ahead !! There are so many other natural resources that Scotland can use!!23022015-04-06T20:14:45.1178476John ColeThere are not many true natural, unblighted, areas left so don't spoil this one23022015-04-06T20:55:58.9478477May McIntoshIn 15 years time when these turbines need repairs are we to be left with broken down wrecks littering our precious hills.\r\n\r\n23022015-04-06T21:26:12.1178478Wendy EdmondAlthough we live in Rutland now my husband is a Scot, we have lived in Scotland, and holiday in The Highlands every year. The proposed desecration of The Highlands beggars belief, and cannot be allowed to happen.23022015-04-06T21:26:30.5678479Gary DicksonIf my tourist £ counts for anything, then no more please! 23022015-04-06T21:49:43.8038480Kevin WilliamsThe Scottish Government announced a new planning policy banning wind farms in national parks and national scenic areas. They need to adhere to that policy and should be reminded of it, because it appears that in this instance they have conveniently forgotton it. If they put a policy in place they should stick to it otherwise how can we believe a word they say.23022015-04-06T22:39:37.7578481Calum Rettiewhy when we live in an island must the island be covered in so many of these unsightly structures? Surely harnessing tidal energy would be a far more efficient, sensible and aesthetically pleasing option!23022015-04-06T22:49:02.578483Alastair RuncieThe proliferation of wind farms in many beautiful areas of Scotland are complete waste of time effort and money. Furthermore they are a hideous blot on the landscape for which our SNP government must take the blame for their part in this environmental disaster.\r\n\r\nAlastair Runcie23022015-04-06T23:21:22.6178485MARY RuncieOur beautiful country is being ruined in the name of an unreliable intermittent form of so called "green energy"that despoils the land for miles around.The area in the south of Scotland has been turned into a giant industrial landscape,and it is now time to say STOP!The area around Loch Ness and the Great Glen is world renowned for it's beautiful landscape,so please do not ruin it for future generations.It makes me want to weep for our country and what is happening to it.Please listen to the opinions of experts with a relevant scientific background and not the ill informed,and stop this madness now.23022015-04-07T03:17:59.248486matthew morencyi live in southern ontario canada and come from a rural area now absolutely infested with wind turbines. THERE ARE NO MORE BIRDS!.To say the least this is disturbing. Inflicting that kind of changes along with blinking lights and noises that animals are sensitive to whether we are or not on Loch ness is criminal and irresponsible. btw i also live near power plants which now have higher emissions due to starting and stopping all the time to accommodate wind turbines.23022015-04-07T08:20:57.828488Albert RogersHas anyone considered the difficulty of replacing the coal burning that overwhelmed the clipper ships, with wind turbine energy that could not possibly power a ship to compete with the Cutty Sark?23022015-04-07T08:59:12.638489Louise ClaphamMore and more of our wild and beautiful places are being industrialised to the detriment of wildlife and people who love those wild places. This area is iconic, time to stop the industrialisation.23022015-04-07T09:09:49.18490Duncan TannahillYet again an iconic area of Scotland is being threatened with industrial vandalism to produce very high cost power. When will the government in Edinburgh ever learn and bring in legislation to protect our countryside in a fit and proper way?23022015-04-07T09:11:50.8678491Angus ThomsonThis is a ridiculous scheme in a terribly sited situation.23022015-04-07T09:17:30.3038492Ted VennWind farms are already destroying the natural beauty of the countryside, negatively affecting other businesses and threatening Scotland's tourist industry, and at the same time only survive on subsidies whilst working intermittently and generating about 30% of their maximum capacity.23022015-04-07T09:19:49.1178493Alexander BurnettPolice centralised, courts closed, fines uncollected and offenders either not jailed or released early - do the SNP have any plans to side with those who are law-abiding???22412015-04-07T09:26:01.718494KLEIN Denis from FRANCEScotland is known for her wild nature, amazing landscapes...how can we imagine the loch ness with wind turbines ...It'll be a disaster .\r\nDenis KLEIN 23022015-04-07T09:37:58.3978495Eric MacdonaldI think that this will destroy what is a beautiful part of Scotland,that I know very well.I may live in Aberdeenshire now but I belong to Invergordon and proud of it.23022015-04-07T09:40:10.8978496Yvonne McWhirrThere's a place for renewable energy and wind power, but the last few years have seen unprecedented developments that are now becoming a serious blight on our beautiful landscape. Iconic views such as Loch Ness, where I grew up, must be protected from such industrialisation. Beside which, when you look at the facts with wind turbines, they may be renewable, but their green credentials lack in so many other ways. I fear the SNP will disregard public opinion in order to achieve targets and convenient soundbites. Playing politics. Not governing our country. 23022015-04-07T10:45:42.5678497Antony EldridgeI bought a house in this area for the views and the general wildness of the environment. Please stop this industrialisation and communicate a clear message that the Scottish Highlands have been damaged enough.23022015-04-07T11:00:22.0078498Rachel BurgessI think everyone is agreed that renewables are a good idea but if they destroy what they have set out to preserve then they are a false economy. We all NEED wild places to escape to in this fast and furious world - what are we leaving for our children and grand children if we turn these glorious places in to industrial landscapes?23022015-04-07T11:17:32.778499Michel CAMUSWorse than DAESCH in Mossoul !23022015-04-07T11:58:18.2878500Willie ForbesIt is shameful that this destruction and massive industrialisation of our God given, world class scenery should be allowed in our beautiful land. The Loch Ness area is paying a heavy price for being outwith an arbitrarily designated area called a national park. Anything goes as far as development in our area is concerned.Our politicians have sold our birthright in the delusion that we are saving our environment. WAKE UP SCOTLAND, ONSHORE WINDFARMS ARE A MASSIVE CON! These ugly turbines are not saving our environment, they are destroying it! They are grossly inefficient. I have watched the turbines at the Farr Windfarm stand still for the entire months of January and February in 2010 - thereby producing NO electricity whatsoever for that entire period. The only beneficiaries are the already very wealthy absentee landlords and remote multinational corporations. These companies are even paid tens of millions of pounds to NOT produce electricity. How completely stupid. And who is paying the massive subsidies to these landowners and corporations - you and me through our inflated electricity bills. The poor widow on the 14th floor, the single parent struggling to make ends meet, the family breadwinner on a minimum wage and zero hours contract - all are contributing towards the increased wealth of these fat cat landowners and corporations. Only a nation of fools would allow such valuable, world-class scenery to be destroyed in this way - and that is what we have become. But no more - this deception, this destruction has to stop. When I look up to the hills I once loved I no longer feel pride, I feel shame. And it is a legacy of destruction of our precious landscape that we are passing on to future generations who will one day ask why the previous generation acted so carelessly, greedily and irresponsibly with our irreplaceable landscape.23022015-04-07T12:37:17.9938502Christine WallaceSincerely hope something will result from action as we will otherwise lose our wild spaces.23022015-04-07T12:53:15.8378503Leslie StarksUgly on a massive scale, kills avian life, makes wildlife and people sick, impotent energy. Wind turbines are the international insignia of greed, political corruption and propaganda23022015-04-07T14:01:20.968504Rosamund DevonshireThe point is:\r\nThis ecological lie shouldn't be going on anywhere in the world23022015-04-07T14:15:50.278505Valerie SVGLoch Ness is beautiful as it is. Let's not spoil it with Wind Turbines.23022015-04-07T17:38:37.1478507Rachel Witti have visited the area on many occasions and also have family living in the area. I just cannot believe that these turbines would be allowed to blight such beautiful historic scenery. 23022015-04-07T17:44:14.938508D Bainsuch complex animals yet sold or given to anyone who thinks they can care for them. pet supermarket chains place their sexually mature unneutered ex-stock rabbits in adoption pens in their stores and reduce the price or sell them for a donation thus giving rabbits away for as little as a few £'s to anyone without home checking to see if there is even proper housing & runs. rabbits need need vets that specialise in rabbit medicine and this is very expensive indeed. thousands upon thousands of rabbits live a miserable existence for their entire lives. time the government put a stop to it! 22922015-04-07T19:18:20.438509Ken Crocketit's not too late to save the Scottish landscape here.23022015-04-07T19:32:38.2878510John RichmondI'm not going back to south west Spain because there are so many wind turbines there.23022015-04-07T19:44:05.968511Chris WardThe systematic deranged vandalisation of Scotland's greatest asset - it's scenery - with this wind farm obsession, must cease.23022015-04-07T19:51:23.1178512Michel Gaudrystop the stupid Policy for energy developed Under the pressure of\r\n"green party" ... 23022015-04-07T19:55:47.6178513Violet, TandrageePlease stop destroying your beautiful country with these unhealthy, uneconomical, unwanted turbines.23022015-04-07T20:06:09.5878514Phyllis cooperThis is a beautiful and important area, and should be left alone. The birds and wildlife would suffer.23022015-04-07T21:31:30.8838516Evelyn IrvineIf you take a life you Lose the right to your freedom - for life22412015-04-07T21:54:52.18517Robert Gehr As a descendant of clan Gregor I feel a connection to Scotland, even though I live in the United States and sadly have never visited your great country.\r\nI am related to the great Robert MacGregor and must submit this 'signed' document in the hope of preserving the wild lands for current and future generations. \r\nIt is what Robert would have done...\r\n\r\nGood luck!23022015-04-07T23:11:44.328519Catherine WilliamsPlease don't damage natural habitats and beauty 23022015-04-08T05:51:23.18520Steve Dickison.Wind energy has already been proven to be an enormously costly failure. Why continue the destruction of the Scottish wilderness for no purpose other than to make a few people outrageously wealthy. This nonsense needs to stop now!23022015-04-08T07:14:40.9478521John FitzgeraldIt's time the ruling bodies got some sense of what they will lose if this continues. Don't think of "now" think of the future23022015-04-08T08:50:54.578523Graham MiltonDon't allow destruction of our beautiful lsndscape.23022015-04-08T11:29:39.468524Roslyn TurpToo much of our beautiful landscape is already blighted by such monstrosities. If we cannot protect our iconic Loch Ness I will despair.23022015-04-08T12:38:17.1478525Shona MackieThis is a beautiful area with low power demand, why not generate more power closer to the big cities where it's needed? A lot of them are close to the coast where we know that wind power generation is more effective. Or an even better idea, why don't we all just start using less?\r\n23022015-04-08T15:10:04.438526Adrian LewisThe wind industry exists only because of the largely unwitting subsidy from the public, who have been brainwashed into believing in climate catastrophe, for which there is no evidence. Despite rising CO2, there has been no global warming for over 18 years, global sea ice is the same as 30 years ago, and sea level is rising at about 1.7mm per yr, just as it has for the last century. Man-made global warming is a scam. 23022015-04-08T15:26:27.8338527Andrew ThomsonWhy oh why despoil such a lovely place? My USA friends cannot believe it, especially as many wind farms in the US are now derelict and no-one takes responsibility for removing them. Utter folly.23022015-04-08T15:27:33.0538528Ray MorrisonWhen it is gone, it is gone, what will our future generations think of us?23022015-04-08T15:54:16.3178529Bill BudgeIt really is time we take a stand against the crass stupdity of installing these structures in our beautiful country which is tantamount to vandalism.\r\nUnder the auspices of so called 'green energy" all that is occurring only because of massive subsidies.\r\nEnough is enough .. no more wind farms 23022015-04-08T16:36:18.0538530Pennie TaylorSurely it makes sense to empower people to self-care if that is what they wish? 22342015-04-08T18:28:57.4138531Matthew SmithWind Turbines have their place in a mixed generation portfolio, and can even enliven some areas. However, the Highlands are famed for their natural beauty and attract tourists from around the world because of this. We risk adversely affecting the economy. I believe hydro and tidal offer better 'base load' energy generation prospects.23022015-04-08T18:52:33.028532Sandra LittleThe citizens of Ocotillo, California, had no chance to stop the corrupt bureaucrats with their ridiculous wind farm plans. Sure enough, the unique and beautiful desert fell victim to this project! Big profit hungry corporations hide behind their "Green Power" mantra, licking their fingers cunningly as they receive subsidies. It's criminal how pristine landscapes, its vegetation and animals are getting destroyed in the name of "clean" energy! Fight for Loch Ness and the Great Glen, good people of Scotland! I sincerely hope you'll be able to save your national treasure from this madness!23022015-04-08T19:43:57.7738533Linda RossWind farms on this scale are no longer environmental ly friendly. \r\nLeave the Loch Ness area alone. 23022015-04-08T20:35:23.3338534Wolf DoleysReal monsters instead of Nessie? Incredible barbarism! 23022015-04-08T21:31:00.0538535Susan E DudleyDo not destroy this beautiful landscape any further with the folly that is industrial wind. It will turn out to be the biggest scam of the 21st century.\r\n23022015-04-08T21:42:32.9778536Jonathan HowellIf allowed to happen this will be destruction and pollution of a precious landscape on a monumental scale. There are far more efficient and controllable forms of electricity generation. This is the will of Scottish leaders and not of Westminster. Is Scotland prepared to suffer anything at any price to enable their leaders to prise Scotland away from the United Kingdom?23022015-04-08T21:43:52.718537Susan Jenkins, NannyThis is very wrong for environmental reasons.no fracking no windmills.23022015-04-08T21:43:42.248538Vivienne Kelly-KeaneIf you proceed with this you will go down in history as having destroyed your country for lousy money because wind turbines have been proven over and over again as being ineffectual, subsidy-grabbing monuments to greed and stupidity.\r\n\r\nYour country is your soul and you are willing to sell it forever to carpetbaggers.\r\n\r\nShame on you!23022015-04-08T22:47:55.688539robert m robertsdo not ruin beautiful views because you can! 23022015-04-08T23:15:06.6478540Ruth Reynolds (nee Cameron)This is a part of the world where many of us have roots. We planned on coming back to tour. Won't bring our tourist dollars to an industrial wind wasteland. We know it does not really save carbon since the power is not generated as needed and those profiting from the taxpayers are doing so only for money.\r\n23022015-04-08T23:48:57.2578541Louise feeGod bless all the familyxxx22412015-04-09T00:13:47.8678542Calum MackinnonIs No place sacred enough to say No to turbines, \r\nLeave Loch Ness alone n find somewhere else mor suitable......23022015-04-09T00:44:03.248543Allan MacdougallThis is not about 'saving the planet' or 'reducing CO2 emissions' - it IS about bloated, madcap subsidies paid to those who least deserve to receive them. \r\n\r\nIf all factors are taken into account, such as peat disturbance and the need to keep fossil fuels burning in power stations on tickover to cover for windless (or over-windy) days, then a carbon audit would reveal that more CO2 is emitted than saved during the turbine's 25 year life. This is the most outrageous form of destruction and vandalism I have ever seen committed on Scottish soil. It needs to stop - right now.23022015-04-09T09:04:43.3038544Miss Victoria Howell When it's gone it's gone! 23022015-04-09T10:32:23.6478545B Griffithsyet another part of the country that will be ruined if they go ahead with this. Is no-where safe from this madness?23022015-04-09T10:49:31.188546Stuart MurdochI'm all for developing green energy but these monstrosities have proven to be inefficient, short-lived and expensive and, in the meantime, they're ruining our landscape, causing health issues, devaluing properties and ruining our tourism industry.This march across our country must be stopped.23022015-04-09T11:18:55.68548john bamkinWind farms will not provide the solution to our energy needs. What they will do is provide huge profits for the manufacturers and line the pockets of landowners with no respect for the environment.23022015-04-09T11:46:46.5078549Paul CowellRabbits are both intelligent and loving. They deserve the same respect as all other living creatures on this planet.22922015-04-09T11:51:22.3038550Captain Alex GibbonsIts disgusting to read that many of our Beautiful British Iconic landscapes and coastlines are going to ruined by these eye sores . Please think again before they are gone forever. 23022015-04-09T12:38:51.9478551Nicki HughesRabbits are probably the most a used of all companion animals, and need higher welfare standards.22922015-04-09T14:26:23.9738553K. TaylorToo many rabbits are seasonal "novelty" pets who are kept in inadequate hutches, improperly fed and are severely neglected once the novelty wears off.\r\nIf cats and dogs were generally treated in the same manner, I am sure there would be a far greater outcry.\r\nAll animals should be treated with respect to their needs and not sold as seasonal or fashionable accessories by by breeders and pet shops.22922015-04-09T15:16:25.6638554J G DouglasThis destruction of our country by the industrialisation of our green belt must be stopped23022015-04-09T15:28:12.6638555Maria CameronThey are Killers of Avian life, Birds like Swans and Wedge Tail Eagles land ok, but when they take flight they bank and get chucked by the winds into the blades of these space age monsters , and the amount of concrete that has to go into the ground to enforce the structures is not in any way environmental once they are pass their use by date23022015-04-09T16:30:45.5378556Colin StuartWholly inappropriate to destroy the vistas in one of Scotland's most beautiful areas. 23022015-04-09T19:48:32.0878558Robert James RossOnshore wind turbines are ugly, not green (when the manufacturing and installation costs are taken into consideration) and only work intermittently when the wind is blowing benignly.23022015-04-09T20:44:53.7738559GeorgeFWoodWhy spoil such a beauty spot location ???23022015-04-09T21:26:19.528560kay lawrenceRabbits should never be bought on a whim. They can be expensive and time consuming pets that require commitment. They are also funny and endearing pets and should be treated with respect and care.22922015-04-09T22:01:19.6938561William FranzRabbit's have rights too.22922015-04-09T22:48:11.798562sarah haighRabbits lovely and sweet and should be cared for properly. Not neglected 22922015-04-10T09:34:54.6638563Alison alvyThe Great Glen and Loch Ness must be saved and not only because it is a popular tourist destination but also because of the enormous risks to the environment23022015-04-10T10:03:59.7578564Pat RaeWindfarm strategy has become a national disgrace, and a lesson in how to divide communities, con them out of their taxes, encourage greed in land owners, sell our heritage, and castrate our national agencies such as SNH, all for a few crumbs of financial benefit, and which never ever compensates those most affected. The Highlands bear the brunt and get least back financially from the rates charged, as there are still relatively few of us compared with the Central belt where the majority of demand is located. Overseas companies are the main beneficiaries. They must be laughing all the way to their banks. Whatever happened to project risk assessment by the developers? Non windy days, lack of grid availability. Try sending the compensation payments for those scenarios straight to where it is most needed in Highland Region, or if you must, use it to pay for more national grid routes south. Democracy is dead in the UK. So is common sense.23022015-04-10T10:36:44.138565Peter BrownMy son was stabbed 17 times and died on a rainy street all alone, Bring back the death penalty22412015-04-10T13:20:55.9778566David HindeIt is nothing short of an outrage that this is happening to our greatest landscapes & wild Areas & an area that depends on its Tourism Industry.Another example of the Greed of the Wind Industry.Stop this Now For us and our Grandchildren & beyond.23022015-04-10T14:17:03.9138567Lynne GrigorRabbits are not children's toys, easy pets or any less work than a cat or dog. It's time to educate people better to stop cruelty to rabbits. Too many rabbits are kept in small hutches by themselves and not able to display their natural behaviour. Dogs and cats are not sold in pet shops so why are rabbits?! 22922015-04-10T14:33:23.7438568brenda johnstonLife should mean life. 22412015-04-10T22:32:49.5338571Amanda kellyLifetime for a life. Don't deserve to ever be released.22412015-04-11T01:34:46.758572Anne Marie McFadyenI whole heartedly agree with this petition to the Scottish Government. It wasn't that long ago that people required to go to their surgery or hospital to test and manage diabetes, in all weathers. The Scottish Government need to to have faith and trust in the Scottish people, children and their parents, carers to self test and manage their INR. \r\nThe Scottish Government is focusing on the awareness, testing and management in overall health and wellbeing for the Scottish population, therefore give people and children on warfarin a chance to' gaun thersel' they deserve it.22342015-04-11T07:19:02.6878573Mickael FAUQUIER-MacDONALDDon't let them destroy such an heritage. Be the nation that stands against them.23022015-04-11T12:25:42.4938574Richard ParkesEven a born & bred Englishman like myself appreciates the beauty and character of Loch Ness and Great Glen. If Wind Farms really solved the Climate Change issues it may be different - mt thoughts GO NUCLEAR NOW23022015-04-11T13:57:39.8238575John TullochWhat on earth is "green" about this?23022015-04-11T15:11:08.18576Michael BrutonWind Turbines are a scam on the taxpayer. Massive subsidies involve taking money from the average family and enriching the already well off. Turbine subsidies kill real jobs, damage tourism, blight the countryside and damage the physical and physiological life of human beings.23022015-04-11T15:38:40.4778577Anne Marie McFadyenThis petition could make a tremendous difference to peoples lives. Self awareness, testing and management is definitely the way forward. 22342015-04-11T16:36:31.2538578John TullochHow on earth can this monstrous project be construed as "green"?23022015-04-11T16:44:05.7078579Kirsten PatersonSo sad that the wild land is being spoiled. The infrastructure associated with the turbines damages the land and will take generations to eradicate. I don't think it will entice many tourists to come once they hear about the ruined views.23022015-04-11T16:57:43.9938580Kelly Jackson God bless. ... 22412015-04-11T16:59:02.68581John TullochHow on earth can this monstrous project be construed as "green"?23022015-04-11T18:24:21.928582andrew taylorThoughts are with you22412015-04-11T18:35:01.278583Sit John Lister-KayeThis must be stopped. Tourism is our life blood. The Great Glen is a priceless asset to the Highlands. We must protect it at all costs. 23022015-04-11T22:44:24.7478584mary glenit is beyond belief that this is even being considered. The SNP government should be ashamed of themselves.23022015-04-12T01:43:37.3438585Kenneth EmpsonRetain the natural beauty and its pristine environment of the Scottish countryside for posterity. Stop any further plans to install the proposed wind farms.23022015-04-12T02:15:31.0278586george whytedead against all wind farms23022015-04-12T07:55:29.8938588Vincent O'HaraI do understand the argument for clean energy, however if we could would we not turn back the clock and save more of our forests? Once it's gone ........23022015-04-12T09:41:11.018590Joanne dixonNot only are these turbines damaging the environment they are also harmful to our tourism industry and especially a business like my self that relies heavily on tourism. Please stop these ugly icons from going ahead.23022015-04-12T09:43:05.9638591Peter WhalleyIs there not an offshore alternative?23022015-04-12T11:29:02.078592pat harwoodwill the SNP and Nicola Sturgeon take any notice of this petition and act on in, its a disgrace that parts of our beautiful country are being exploited by big business when it has been proved that these windfarms are really not making any difference to the power supplys available nor are they helping to make the country any greener23022015-04-12T12:22:13.4778594Jutta MaurerGermany lost his countryside and recreational value. Many People near this big machines are ill. Don't make the same mistake as the politician Germans.23022015-04-12T13:12:50.7738596Alan ChapmanStop this Vandalism!23022015-04-12T13:14:02.6178597Doreen WhittakerIt would appear that renewables etc wind turbines as they are known but are just power stations in the sky do not do much for our countries energy needs. The whole country would need to be festooned with these abomination to do the slightest bit of good. It's about time the so called Scottish Gov or should I say snp club listened to the majority of the people instead of ignoring us. But there again you only listen to your own followers who live in towns and cities ie Glasgow and Dundee .\r\n23022015-04-12T14:35:26.158598Gordon WebsterThe only way to save Scotland from the "Saudi of Renewables," and the Lights going out, is fairly obvious I would have thought.23022015-04-12T15:41:25.48599Deirdre StewartOnshore wind turbines are ugly, not green (when the manufacturing and installation costs are taken into consideration) and only work intermittently when the wind is blowing benignly.23022015-04-12T16:10:02.8038600Andrew ThurstonHow to destroy scotlands tourism industry in one quick step 23022015-04-12T16:34:46.688601lee GreinerStop ruining this beautiful country. 23022015-04-12T16:42:36.0938602Betsy DouglasThe Wind Turbines spoil our countryside plus they are ugly looking tourist come to see our scenery not these ugly looking thing dotted all over our countryside 23022015-04-12T16:57:00.4778603Bob Henderson Scotland has been ruined by unsightly wind turbines thay will never pay for themselves but have made fortunes for land owners. They are not even made in the UK. Stop the rot now!23022015-04-12T17:35:18.7638604stewart bartonanother of alex salmonds stupid ideas, cover all scotland with wind farms and destroy the tourist trade\r\n23022015-04-12T18:51:36.6638605Martha MarnochWe know here what windfarms are doing to this beautiful part of Perthshire. Enough is enough. 23022015-04-12T19:04:48.2738606Claire TreasurerDestroying this scenic area of Scotland with wind turbines is not a sensible idea and is just filling the pockets of greedy energy companies. There should be better ideas with regard to finding potential sources of renewable energy, for example tidal and wave power. 23022015-04-12T20:20:19.2278608John McDougallWhat a disgrace to put these wind turbines here. I have spent many happy hours in this area and cannot believe anyone would sanction this. 23022015-04-12T20:27:30.4938609Isabella McCall This has to be stopped ASAP\r\nOur countryside is very important and we won't \r\nhave these wind farms destroying it \r\nThey should all be pulled down, its a disgrace what people higher up get to decide if the people say no then bloody listen to us \r\nLoch Ness is very very important 23022015-04-12T21:50:51.068610Duncan McIntyreI am against wind farms in the Great Glen, which is one of our most precious assets and a huge tourist draw. We have here, in an urban area, three win turbines which were refused planning permission by our local representatives, this was overruled by Alec Salmond and we have them and can be seen for miles. Do not let this fate befall the Great Glen.23022015-04-12T22:07:01.658611Jim GibsonI am not against wind power per se but we need to be more careful over sighting. Some places in Scotland are more important as they are.23022015-04-13T05:09:05.468612Denise UTHOFFI have visited Scotland and his Beauties and was fascinated by the landscape. I did not see Nessie but I saw an extraordinary landscape worth to be conserved as it is for our children and Grand children !!!23022015-04-13T07:38:11.5538613Andrew HalcrowAnother example of destroying the environment instead of protecting it.23022015-04-13T10:00:01.6578616Brian GregsonOur natural heritage will be permanently ruined if this and other large scale wind farms are permitted. No, no and NO!23022015-04-13T11:04:15.688619sue scott dickinsWind energy needs continual backup by fossil fuel generators therefore is not "green", why sacrifice Scotland and Loch Ness to wind industry corporations and their political hangers on.23022015-04-13T11:47:31.9538620Liz PorterWhat a travesty to allow such eyesores to ruin such a famous and outstandingly beautiful natural landscape. Shame on your unadulterated GREED and at any cost! \r\nGREED ENERGY NOT GREEN! \r\n\r\n23022015-04-13T13:25:40.218621Judy AllanWind turbines are unsightly, potentially dangerous, inefficient and certainly not green or cost effective. The cost of their manufacture and delivery and \r\ninstallation is expensive and their temporary nature make them a waste of resources in the end.23022015-04-13T15:22:35.298622Bob HowIt's an absolute disgrace that wind farms are allowed anywhere in this beautiful wild countryside. It's not just the windfarms but the impact on local roads, the miles of new hill roads for construction and maintenance and the new power line routes, all of which disfigure the landscape, and which local people are powerless to influence. It must be stopped! 23022015-04-13T16:06:26.8738623Norrie FoxWhy spoil Natural Beauty?23022015-04-13T16:31:57.9078625Michael BremnerAnother feasibility study is needed. Balancing this unique area of national and international importance resources both environmentally and economically should be put to further scrutiny. 23022015-04-13T16:46:09.7438626Keith WebsterStop wasting taxpayers' money on this ineffective, punitively expensive barbarism. These things do not work as promised. They are a disgrace, as are the people who propose them and the elected and appointed officials who approve their construction.23022015-04-13T17:04:39.7738627AmandaThis would make things so much easier, especially when you may need to attend a clinic quure regularly but are delayed by the vast amount of new patients that need a much longer appointment time.22342015-04-13T17:19:46.6878628David ScottI live in Fort Augustus and am becoming surrounded by the Ring of Steel, i.e. wind turbines and Met masts. Give me Hydro and tidal power generation, not wind turbines trashing our wild land. Sleekit, greedy landowners and foreign construction companies see Scotland as a new Klondyke! Disgusting. 23022015-04-13T17:54:43.6338629Michael John JohnstonI sign this having sailed 16 times through the Great Glen on the Caledonian Canal.\r\n\r\nThe corrupt madness of throwing the public's money at private benefactors while despoiling the entire Scottish countryside must stop. NOW!23022015-04-13T18:03:23.5778630tina tylerTo destroy the scenic beauty of this fabulous area is criminal.23022015-04-13T19:19:20.2978631Margaret Elizabeth McPheeHow can you possibly think to destroy this beautifully stunning environment by sprinkling it liberally with wind turbines? This is a very special area of the world!! Don't ruin it!23022015-04-13T20:37:21.568632Christine McLevyThe Scottish government needs to stop destroying Scotland with these disgusting monstrosities23022015-04-13T20:45:27.4538634Ross Hoodwas just up there a week ago and it was amazing such lovely country side. I think out country has been destroyed enough with these eye sores without putting them near out most famous and attractive areas to tourists not only from their own country but from around the world. Shocking idea I can't believe these idiots are even considering it. 23022015-04-13T21:06:51.8038636Peter BennettWe live in Tomatin which has become an industrial hub for the generation of wind power and supporting infrastructure. Strathdearn is about to be saturated with pylons, power lines and substations. Scotland is already self sufficient with wind power subject to the wind blowing. With no plan "B" when power stations close be prepared for power rationing and power cuts. The Highlands have been destroyed by the greed of landowners and Government addiction to provide exotic subsidies to promote the desecration of our once beautiful landscape in favour of providing a surplus of power that no one wants. We will wonder in the future how we ever allowed all of this to happen. 23022015-04-13T21:32:08.5078637Chris ConnollyAt last! We've found the Loch Ness Monster. It's the Scottish Government! Stop the monster destroying our tourist industry.23022015-04-13T21:48:22.2638638D RiceEnough is enough. Too many landowners making too much money at too great a cost to the landscape.23022015-04-13T21:50:17.038639Donald RicePlease stop the spread of these badly sited wind farms before its too late. Scotland is famous for its unspoilt land - these wind farms are cutting off Scotland's nose to spite its face.23022015-04-13T22:40:22.8738640Alec KiddThe Highland Councils Guidance on Planning Applications is out for consultation now. The consultation Document does not specify Loch Ness or the Great Glen as a protected Area, I have sent extensive coment on this to them, please also get involved.23022015-04-13T22:52:40.2038641C. van de kerkhofI love it there but i will not visit again. Hope it will stay as it was before. We also loose lots of nice places and forrest here. Hope it stops very soon!!!23022015-04-14T06:12:19.328642John G R ThompsonThe natural beauty of the Highlands is being eroded by the proliferation of windfarms (wind factories).23022015-04-14T07:55:11.0138643Isabel M KilkennyAs a member of NAG (Easter Ross) I have been appalled at the number of turbines which have sprung up and are continuing to be approved or considered. Surely it is past time when the Scottish Govt calls a halt to the wanton destruction of the beauty of the Highlands which draws tourists to the area and decreases the amenity of those who call the area home.23022015-04-14T08:50:34.48644Mark WatsonProtect the natural beauty of Scotland. Creat national parks in the highlands !23022015-04-14T09:28:33.398645S MilneWe have the Beauly to Denny power lines that were constructed regardless of the visual impact on the scenery and now this. Why would people bother coming to Scotland anymore? It is becoming a completely industrial landscape and the natural beauty of the Highlands is diminishing rapidly.23022015-04-14T09:44:19.398646Fergus MouldFrom Meall Fuar-mhonaidh (2 km behind our house in Balbeg of Bunloit which sits adjacent to the Great Glen way and overlooks Loch Ness) we will be able to see nine of the eleven nearest windfarm developments. Then you can add in the pump-storage schemes ....23022015-04-14T10:19:19.038647David W EvansWhile welcoming a move to renewable energy, there are many less sensitive areas where wind turbines could be sited. The Scottish Executive should assert its powers and reject any further turbine industrialisation in the Highlands. 23022015-04-14T11:02:29.6038648Gillian HarrisThis would help those who have difficulties getting to and from clinics regularly ,promote independence and help people who require warfrin manage they're condition own conditions as hassle free as possible,it can be done for insulin dependant diabetes so why not for inr ?22342015-04-14T11:41:59.678651Arlene Caldwell 100% behind this petition! I debated this same issue over 10 years ago as a pharmacy student. Shocked that self-testing isn't readily available..22342015-04-14T12:02:49.6578652Archie Shaw StewartGiven that the combination of trying to generate electricity from wind in a remote (and beautiful) area and the problems of efficiently using the electricity over long transmission lines, this does not seem to be an appropriate scheme.23022015-04-14T13:25:04.5878653Dave ThompsonI was stunned when i learned how many more wind turbines were being planned in our area on top of the existing ones. This is one of the main tourist destinations in the country and it is being ruined for everyone by these carbuncles. 23022015-04-14T16:13:56.3678654Judith GillespieIt is vitally important that Loch Ness and the Great Glen, areas of outstanding natural beauty, are protected now and for future generations.23022015-04-14T16:20:15.48655John CurtisScotland is being steadily ruined by the ceaseless march of useless wind turbines across its most valued landscape. There will soon be no reason for anybody to visit what used to be a beautiful land. 23022015-04-14T17:05:49.58656Roger lindsayNo more wind farms. We have too many already and they have supplied not one bit of energy. NO MORE.23022015-04-14T17:27:02.0138658Mary MortHope this helps Donna and family 22472015-04-14T17:47:31.1638659Claire OHalloran I lost my very close cousin through an incident we still have barely any answers to. Family's need answers and they need more care for when they are going through such trauma! Change the laws and be heard just like our loved ones wanted us to do! 22472015-04-14T17:57:34.1238660Norman McNabScotland is a very small country with an outstandingly beautiful type of landscape which has a wild yet accessible quality that is internationally admired. It is probably Scotland's most valuable asset and a vital component of Scotland's biggest industry - tourism. \r\nThere is a growing international appetite for Scotland's scenery and frustration that its primary attribute is being destroyed by placing huge industrial windfarms within it. This destruction is truly wanton since wind is a particularly unreliable and difficult to control source of electrical energy and makes a negligible contibution to combating CO2 emissions while providing profitable subsidy income to power companies and landowners (often absent and foreign).23022015-04-14T18:03:02.038661Katie CunninghamNo explanation means no dignity for the deceased and no closure for the family. It's only fair that Police do all they can to find the cause. Also there needs to be more tolerance with young "binge drinkers" - we've all been there - bouncers etc should be more empathetic not angry - this would save more than half of disappearances that start on a night out! \r\n\r\nIt's broken my heart following David's story and seeing how hard his mother is fighting for what's right. Stay strong guys x22472015-04-14T18:11:54.0078662Elizabeth PatersonI think everyone should have the right to know the truth behind their loved ones death22472015-04-14T18:16:13.9938663Andrea McDonaldExcellent idea which will benefit so many people22342015-04-14T18:24:12.8838664Scott McCallum I feel all deaths in Scotland should be thoroughly investigated to establish the circumstances and provide closure for families who have lost a loved one. 22472015-04-14T18:39:27.6578665Diane ConnorIt is vital this changes! 22472015-04-14T18:48:01.2978666Gail robertsonKeep this page open.22472015-04-14T19:11:20.3538667Natalie AndersonSigned :)22472015-04-14T19:13:248668alistair mcdougallThis law must change.22472015-04-14T19:21:18.8278669jane taylorTime to change.22472015-04-14T19:39:05.298670Lesley Kinnear100% back this, i have a child on Warfarin who does home testing and did not realise that this does not continue when they reach adult hood.\r\n22342015-04-14T20:02:01.0878671Maria JanssonAbsolutely, the Police, forensic experts and other authorities involved should treat the loved ones death in suspicious circumstances as suspicious until proven otherwise, also when the evidence is not enough to point the cause of death as A)Accident, B) Suicide or C) Result of a Crime, the loved ones death should be open up on a regular basis and the DNA findings and other evidence ought to be put in register that have regular matches through the years to come! \r\n I lost my best friend and I have fought for soon to be 10 years with the family and we strongly believe that we have a lot of evidence that points to C) As a result of a crime. However we have up until now been denied to have her sudden and mysterious death in suspicious circumstances reopened and properly investigated. 22472015-04-14T20:17:08.8538672Amanda Donnelly Terrible that inquests are not held in Scotland of deaths are unexplained 22472015-04-14T20:26:43.938673Alexander CraigWind turbines should be situated close to large centers of population. The Great Glen is not an appropriate area for industrial electricity generation equipment of this type. 23022015-04-14T20:30:58.798674veronica beecher I really feel that there are already too many turbines in beautiful areas, contributing nothing to the environment . in fact maintaining these turbines cause more damage as well ,making the whole "green"image laughable. nobody will visit and Scotland and its people will be the losers. 23022015-04-14T20:34:20.7178675Malcolm mc DougallHaving been directly affected by the lack of this law being in place,God forbid it happens to yours,LOVED ONES NEED ANSWERS.22472015-04-14T20:42:23.4838676Nicola MaloyChange the law!! 22472015-04-14T20:42:53.068677Carol SmithI absolutely support this campaign to treat these deaths as suspicious until proven otherwise. It's the only decent option and what these unfortunate people deserve.22472015-04-14T20:45:47.1638678Catriona FraserWhat has happened to Scotland , it seems the whole country is up for sale and to hell with wildlife, plant life and anything else that gets in the way of making a quick pound. 23022015-04-14T22:07:05.298679Jennifer hasell Signed 22472015-04-14T22:21:41.8438680Anne MacdonaldThe value of the 'green energy' plan has to be considered against the value of the beauty of our countryside and it's place in the tourism industry.23022015-04-14T22:39:02.7638681pauline glenHope law is changed22472015-04-14T22:42:32.578682Ishbel DougansI Fully support this petition22342015-04-14T23:40:45.4938683Angela CampbellIn support of Donna O'Halloran's petition.22472015-04-14T23:43:31.9138684Gordon HaywardSome of the most beautiful landscape in Europe is being destroyed for a thoroughly discredited energy policy which benefits only landowners and developers, provides minimal employment and fundamentally, is economically flawed.23022015-04-15T03:38:12.2278685Wilma HowatFor Michael & all of the lost.....x22472015-04-15T07:54:10.578686Julie Matthewsgood luck Mary 100% behind you all on this its about time they listened to you. Maybe if they had already let you test then you wouldn't have had to wait as long as you have to try to get things fixed. 22342015-04-15T08:52:50.6978687Carolanne leisk nhs should make these meds more accessible to patients 22342015-04-15T11:30:15.4938688Jacqueline McCafferty Good luck22342015-04-15T11:42:04.7638689Caroline PeacockUrquhart Castle on the shores of Loch Ness makes this landscape very special to me because my family has ancestral connections with the Urquhart family. It seems profoundly sad that a landscape little changed in 1,000 years should be being devastated in the 21st century by the introduction of inefficient industrial structures. Who will ever forgive us for this?23022015-04-15T12:07:10.6178696Patricia StevensonI believe that everyone has the right to live there life's and that there should be no price on what it takes to allow that person to live a full life. All medications should be made available to everybody no matter where or when. Good Luck Mary I totally support your petition xx22342015-04-15T12:52:53.2038697Arlene RobertsonSigned in support of Donna22472015-04-15T13:13:54.9838698Lorna WatkinsVisited Loch Ness and the surrounding area last week (April 2015) and enjoyed the unspoilt beauty and magic of the loch and the legend of Nessie. Would hate to see any wind turbines in this area. It should be protected. There are plenty of sites that are more appropriate. Please don't spoil it for visitors from around the world and the friendly locals. 23022015-04-15T13:20:35.4538699Ash GraingerA sad reflection on our Scottish government indeed!23022015-04-15T13:37:41.618700Ruth Sutherland Signed , Donna xx22472015-04-15T14:48:09.9538701michele o'halloranthis page is not letting me sign it is only a thank you page \r\n22472015-04-15T15:28:13.7978702Murdo MorrisonWe must guard our inheritance to gift it to our inheritors23022015-04-15T15:36:36.8838703Margaret mcarthur signed donna xx22472015-04-15T15:37:59.5438704Tas ChaudryI think the Highlands especially Loch Ness and its majestic landscape beauty should not be ruined by the turbine development. PLEASE DO NOT DESTROY THE BEAUTY OF THE HIGHLANDS.23022015-04-15T16:37:40.3938705marymccrorieSigned Donna xx.\r\n22472015-04-15T16:42:24.6338706Mhairi McKennaplease consider future generations, we have had the joy of these glorious areas...23022015-04-15T17:29:33.3638708douglas watsonIn my lifetime in the Highlands we have covered every hillside with an invasive species of tree, flooded every glen with a hydro dam, now we have covered every hill with wind farms and finally joined it all together with a lattice of pylons with size of the Eiffle tower - all in the name of energy!!!!!23022015-04-15T18:48:08.6878710Yvonne RochfortSigned Donna xxx22472015-04-15T18:52:10.4278711Susann McGilvray This is too important an issue to ignore. 22472015-04-15T19:32:10.618712Dea Fairlie Signed x22472015-04-15T19:42:29.428714Irene McNicolsigned Donna xx22472015-04-15T19:49:32.7778715Alison Blairsigned xxx22472015-04-15T20:20:44.9638716Sandra ParkinsSelf testing saves everyone time and money and gives independence to the person taking warfarin.22342015-04-15T20:38:04.3238717Joan ChalmersSuch magnificent landscapes must be protected for our children & grandchildren23022015-04-15T21:05:49.3078718Irene McNicolsigned Donna x22472015-04-15T21:10:10.5138720Ryan DonkerAmerica is behind you.22472015-04-15T21:27:55.0078721Lee JamiesonAgree and signed xxx22472015-04-15T21:40:20.998722Briony Robertsonour beautiful and unique landscape must be saved from this wanton destruction building these useless monstrosities, the building of which causes more environmental damage than anything else done by man.23022015-04-15T22:26:46.5978723Tom StevensonA very worth while cause 22342015-04-15T22:55:17.358724Kate CassidyI have signed Donna xxx\r\n22472015-04-15T23:09:21.7638725Paul MarshallWind-farms spoil our beautiful countryside, only survive through subsidy and damage the quality of life those living nearby or visiting the countryside23022015-04-16T00:04:46.7278728Irene StewartThe pitiful amount of unreliable power generated by turbines is just not enough to justify this loss of wild land.23022015-04-16T00:17:04.3838729Moira Kennedy This makes me want to weep. It is a national disgrace. The SNPs energy policy is destroying Scotland aesthetically, financially and environmentally. Save Loch Ness from these useless, towering monuments to a ridiculous renewables policy.23022015-04-16T01:21:07.3078730jean clarkeGood luck .. I hope yous get what you need 22342015-04-16T08:51:12.5878732Winfried KleinAre we idiots to build this wind monsters?\r\nThis plants are only 1200 to 1400 hours a year working and when you need this energy it is missing!\r\nNearly all our politicians have no technical background und are technical idiots!\r\nW. Klein23022015-04-16T09:09:34.5878733Alison GardnerEnough is enough. ... Why do you insist on taking away one of the Highlands main means of capital..ie windfarms do spoil the scenery this having a detrimental effect on the livelihoods of this so work in the tourism industry, which in turn of course impacts on everyone and everything else in our area. Please stop the windfarms piping up everywhere in our area. 23022015-04-16T09:49:16.9338734angela crossleyEnough is enough ....23022015-04-16T10:06:54.3638735Elsie GiudiciI have signed ,Donna22472015-04-16T10:19:11.9138736marcel barberadon't make such a mistake ! please, preserve the land and the nature of Scotland.23022015-04-16T10:29:10.9438737Nikki StewartGood Luck !!!22342015-04-16T10:59:27.18738david evansAn absolute disgrace to destroy the landscape for the\r\nfinancial benefits of developers from an inefficient power generating system. 23022015-04-16T11:10:19.728741Mrs. E.M. EvansDO NOT destroy the area of LOCH NESS with such monstrosities for developers financial gain. It will ruin the surrounding countryside.23022015-04-16T11:32:41.1278742Carol BarronMoved here 9yrs ago, to live in a beautiful place. Yes we still have beautiful areas but also blots of unsightliness due to windfarms as we all can see will expand if not stopped. Tourism here is one of our \r\nbiggest industry. We need to protect not abuse Lochness and The Great Glen.\r\n23022015-04-16T12:53:09.1578743E.McHughLoch Ness and the Great Glen are national assets for Scotland that attract thousands of visitors per year to Scotland irrespective of the weather. These places bring money into the country and support jobs across Scotland. They deserve to be protected and promoted, not spoilt and damaged by windfarms. 23022015-04-16T12:56:54.148744Debbie McCrorie No families should be left with questions unanswered. Please change the law to make sure that this happens 22472015-04-16T14:31:06.638747IAN FRASERLiving in Inverness I think the industrialization of the Highlands is a disaster.23022015-04-16T14:38:34.3838748Fiona WherrettI had to start taking warfarin almost a year ago to help control my AF symptoms. I would love to be able to self-manage my INR, as the distance between my work and doctors makes it easier to take a half day off work on test day. Though I have a very understanding boss, with our workload and staffing, its not always convenient for me to be off. If diabetics can self-manage their tests, why can't those who have to have INR tests? 22342015-04-16T14:43:53.988749Mary YoungThere is something very wrong with a system which effectively makes victims, in perpetuity, of the families of those who die under these circumstances22472015-04-16T14:50:18.748750Doreen RobertsonGood Luck.22342015-04-16T16:37:40.3638751Tas GibsonThe world has gone made. I aml being made to suffer from the Kilgallioch wind farm 96 143.5 metre(480 ft) construction 2015.I ask the Government to guarantee this farm would not be a health hazard.... Guess what they refused! Now Lochness!23022015-04-16T17:29:10.6138752wendy nicolaoui have just returned from a holiday in cyprus and they too have taken on this wind farming big time. it looks awful and totally out of character with the landscape and has ruined the look and peace of local villagers as they are by no means attractive or neither quiet. put them in the sea not on land. plenty of wind out there!23022015-04-16T17:47:05.1878753Shellie CorreiaIt is cruel, and inhumane, to leave the loved ones of the dead, to grieve, never knowing why they have lost their relative or friend..22472015-04-16T19:06:32.158754Rosemary ferguson To the Scottish Parliament Cabinet, if England can do it why can't we ? 22472015-04-16T20:00:39.6278756Michelle Sheridansigned and will share xx22472015-04-16T20:09:03.7278757Jim O'DonnellI accept that alternative energy forms are necessary however reasonable judgement and consideration of Scotlands beautiful places should be a major facor in placement of windmill sites. Scotland PLC should think in long term monetary terms. Our country's reputation is built on our people and wild landscape. As marketing Scotland this is priceless and windmills are in danger of killing the romance of Scotland built up since Sir Walter Scott in just a few years. As a climber and walker I will be going abroad for my wild experiences first encountered in Scotland but now so rare unless this aberration is halted.23022015-04-16T20:55:02.578758Trisha TurnerSigned Donna.22472015-04-16T21:00:27.188759Jean ConnorSigned as I have adult children who think they too are invincible. RIP Karen Buckley. 22472015-04-16T21:23:55.358761steph wallaceSigned Donna.\r\nHeres hoping this can bring justice for many families xx22472015-04-16T21:50:13.798762Sarah Aitchisonplease change this law22472015-04-16T21:53:10.8678763M WilsonI am surprised to learn that investigations in Scotland do not follow the international norm. Time to change that, and fast!22472015-04-16T22:09:27.628764Siobhan McBurnieWould never wish this on anyone. Please take not government. Don't allow families to be heartbroken & not knowing!22472015-04-16T22:30:38.438765Sheena Oakes Signed, I really hope it does some good xx22472015-04-16T22:54:14.0678766Dawn philbinSystem stinks something be done... Xxx22472015-04-16T23:01:09.0138767Nikki perrycount me in hun x22472015-04-16T23:13:22.18768mhairi macgregor Signed22472015-04-16T23:32:19.4778770Jill Kernanso admire your determination to keep your work moving forward Donna, through everything you've suffered. The law MUST change. Questions MUST. BE ANSWERED. always, no matter the circumstance. 22472015-04-17T08:25:56.5078772Cally forbesI feel the people in charge of making decisions about these laws have never felt the unbearable pain of not knowing what happened to your child parents etc. This is a disgrace to leave people wondering and pondering on what's ifs their whole life. I am a full real director and see the first hand damage these situations cause on families who can't just bandage it up. I often wonder if this is a mo ey saving option which makes it even more horrendous. 22472015-04-17T08:51:51.6778773Stuart MacLennanAs with the majority of the proposal sites in the Highlands, this is a spectacular part of our country (and indeed the world) which has captured the hearts and imaginations of every local and tourist alike. I very much hope this will continue. Ruin it with wind farms and you would lose that attraction for ever.23022015-04-17T08:53:40.88774Denise WebsterThis is so wrong - not to investigate these deaths fully is like saying to the families their loved ones didn't matter!!! Please change this, give the families and loved ones some light at the end of their dark grief tunnel.22472015-04-17T09:51:04.5138775Haze LeithIts the beauty for Scotland that brings tourists here, who in turn help with our employment and finance. We are destroying this day by day. Plus how can it be green, when they are building big roads and driving heavy trucks back & forth to create these windfarms. Can't we use Wave energy more? \r\n23022015-04-17T09:52:13.0138776Chanseau AdelineI saw how wind farms can ruin some landscapes. The Highlands are one of the most stunning places in the world and it would be sad to change this with wind farms, especially when it can be used elsewhere. 23022015-04-17T10:55:37.248777Graham CrawfordGreedy landowners exploiting the subsidy system and despoiling a national asset , our environment and landscape23022015-04-17T11:12:46.5738778Lesley SilverAll loved ones matter. 22472015-04-17T11:56:08.6678779Kate ByrneIt's so sad that our natural heritage is being vandalised in this way. Removing these turbines when we wake up to what we're doing will cost far more than any benefits accrued, but as far as I can see the benefits are mainly to the landowners receiving the subsidies anyway, and the government servants obsessed with poorly thought-out targets.23022015-04-17T13:14:07.8238780Anne Brown haven't the family been through enough without having to fight the government for answers disgusting 22472015-04-17T14:47:24.9638781claire williamsIll thought out. Apart from devastating environmental damage, it will destroy a major tourist attraction and the income it generates for the country.23022015-04-17T15:30:17.78782Linda bowmanI my opinion the short sighted government are to blame for the widespread destruction of the wonderful landscape around Loch Ness and the Great Glen. by giving huge financial incentives to developers to build these awful monstrosities. What a legacy to leave for future generations!!! \r\n23022015-04-17T16:35:24.0778783Karol DomownikIf not for ecological teror connected with EU grants no fan would not exist in Europe.Good luck!23022015-04-17T18:59:41.248784Sue McAllisterIt's quite simple really.....if it was one of your loved ones, there would be no question!22472015-04-17T19:03:29.1638785Sue McAllisterQuite simple! If it was you or yours- you would stop at nothing! 22472015-04-17T19:39:09.8478786Donna O'Halloran This petition won't protect or even help our love ones who have passed in suspicious events but I sincerely hope it helps the families unfortunate to travel a tragic road like ours n the future.\r\n 22472015-04-17T20:50:01.7138787Peter FarringtonWhat is the point of pumping money into the promotion of tourism in the Highlands and Islands only to destroy the very landscape which attracts\r\nvisitors.\r\n23022015-04-17T22:15:37.888788J. BannisterThis is something I have worried about for years - especially the spiking of alcohol drinks in bars and clubs.. There have been many deaths across the UK of young people which I am sure have not been thoroughly investigated. Bars and club businesses are exploiting a young generation. There businesses are often run by people operating close to the borders of legality. Some may also be run by criminal gangs. These young people have no health and safety protection as would be provided in other places. We must as a society protect young people as they are extremely vulnerable. When deaths do occur they should be fully investigated.22472015-04-17T22:46:10.6538789Alexandra AllanI do self test. My GP has been very helpful and supportive. I purchased the Coagucheck machine myself and my GP prescribed the test strips. It makes such a difference being able to test my INR myself.22342015-04-18T07:45:42.9738790Allison WatsonThis is industrial energy. Does our government have any notion of the truth of some of these developments. 23022015-04-18T08:14:308791Fiona YoungSeems only right22472015-04-18T16:48:27.648792Iris Gillies Yes all unascertained, suicides and accidental deaths should be treated suspicious until proven otherwise . If they can do it in England to keep in standard with European laws why can't they do the same here . People need to know what has happened to their loved ones and know what really happened to them for peace of mind.22472015-04-19T09:26:28.038793Dr Bruce HobbsThe Government's energy policy is based on a misplaced ideology and the consequences are now coming home to roost. However, they still seem unable to change course. Damage for little purpose is all around in Scotland - perhaps this horrendous damage to the iconic Loch Ness will be a wake-up call - let us hope so.23022015-04-19T09:51:42.9338794Janet E PeeblesThere has to be some common sense re indiscriminate siting go large windfarms which damage our lovely countryside they are joy very effective in their output and their life span is short23022015-04-19T10:54:16.8538795IAN FRASERThis will be another disaster hoisted upon the people and land of Scotland by big business with no regard what so ever to the wishes off the majority.Even if local planning refuse applications the Scottish government will rubber stamp them with their blind following of policy. Having driven through the borders it is a total disaster.No other tourist country would contemplate such policies. Ian J Fraser 23022015-04-19T11:12:54.7578796Denise kennedyinvestigate!22472015-04-19T17:52:20.8138800Karen mcgrathDefinitely . 22472015-04-19T18:02:08.378801darren maloyevery one of these deaths deserves an inquiry and so do their families!22472015-04-19T18:43:19.1578802Andrena johnstone government should be ashamed of them selfs , all deaths should be investigated , let the families mind be at rest xx22472015-04-19T19:06:59.9438803edward godfreyI have made many trips to Scotland and noted the many wind farms disfiguring the landscape you really need to stop this now, or risk losing your income from tourism. they are a real blot on the landscape and I do not understand how this has been allowed to happen.23022015-04-19T19:13:07.7038804Valerie MoffatHow can anyone think this project is a good idea? I am fortunate enough to live by Loch Ness and the thought of what is proposed is quite horrendous. There are other green ways to produce electricity.23022015-04-19T19:16:43.388805John FlynnSurely in our Country we can treat all the dead with respect. Respect means going that extra mile to explain a death.22472015-04-19T20:40:43.0438806marion fitzgeraldThe need for renewable energy in the form of wind turbines should not be allowed to override the concerns of communities and the protection of our landscapes.23022015-04-19T22:25:19.1438807Carol Malcolm Law needs to change, admire your determination Donna x22472015-04-19T23:01:54.4978808samantha leatherThese families should be helped not hindered. They matter as do their lost loved ones, this change could at least help ease some part of their grief. Help make the change happen..!22472015-04-19T23:37:29.9038809Kirsty Gillespie Nothing stronger than a mother s love. This love is what has kept this mother going. So wrong that she has to fight for this, please change the law.22472015-04-20T00:05:17.058810Susan NormanAll cases need absolute answers to stop it happening again. 22472015-04-20T00:36:33.2678811Mungo GrahamWe need to balance being greener with preserving breathtaking wildlife that future generations can visit. It's such a shame how the places we want to protect are being damaged by the very methods that are being used to save them23022015-04-20T06:18:56.6038812Catherine DoyleOf course, everyone needs to have some sort of closure. Not knowing and wondering, I could not even imagine the pain the family must feel. \r\n\r\n22472015-04-20T08:45:15.978813Henry NunneyPreserve the beauty of Loch Ness!23022015-04-20T08:47:31.6378814James Haldane Think I've done it :) 22472015-04-20T09:20:36.5438815John MaclennanFurther proliferation of turbines is leading to the increased industrialisation of Loch Ness and its environs. Tourism is extremely important to the Highlands, the cumulative effect of these wind farms is going to have a hugely detrimental effect. \r\nLocal communities have sacrificed enough amenity for the existing developments - please do not short-sightedly allow further developments to go ahead and further reduce the value of the main asset that this area of the Highlands has - its unspoiled wilderness.\r\n23022015-04-20T09:53:39.4938816Doreen Forsyth This and many more families are unimaginably in turmoil wanting answers that must be answered please have a heart and change the law in order to help bring closure to their many questions. 22472015-04-20T10:34:42.618817Sherylann toyeShared and signed x22472015-04-20T12:54:43.4678818Fiona UrquhartThese wind farms are ruining the last bastion of scenic wilderness in Britain and Europe. They will not bring to the Scottish economy what tourism does and to ruin the jewels of our Scottish crown is both an inexplicably stupid and heinous act. Stop it now!!23022015-04-20T14:57:20.888819Patrick GraingerI live in Balnain, Glenurquhart just 4 miles from Loch Ness. The area surrounding my home has spectacular views of the Affric hills to the west and Loch Meiklie in the foreground. These views are frequently photographed by tourists who stop on the road side by our home.\r\nThe Forestry walks on the south side of the Glen attract many locals and visitors who climb to the top of the hills for panoramic views across the glen and beyond. \r\nThe proposed wind farm at Cnoc an Eas will intrude on all these views and substantially detract from the overall beauty of the area.\r\nAcross the Loch Ness area the numerous proposed wind farms will crowd the countryside with ugly and intrusive machinery, which is sure to result in less visitors to the area.\r\nIndeed, what will visitors think of the place that has despoiled by the turbines? Most will be horrified that we allowed our wonderful scenery to be ruined. And what will our children think of our generation that we cared so little about their heritage? We must stop these developments now !23022015-04-20T15:08:25.2638820Terry BatchelorI have friends in Scotland. We are supposed to be visiting next summer. I will not take my family to Loch Ness if it is covered in turbines. I can see those monstrosities here. This is an absolute shame. Destroying such a beautiful piece of the earth to fill your pockets. Turbines do nothing for the environment. 23022015-04-20T16:39:23.4038821Pam BurtonSigned. x22472015-04-20T18:43:51.3938822Jackie GummeI fully support enabling people to take control of their own health with expert support. Anticoagulation self-testing and or management has been shown to improve patient experience and control. 22342015-04-20T18:45:03.7078823Jacinta RyanI, and other tourists come to Loch Ness for its unspoiled beauty. It is known throughout the world, recognised when used ( due to its magnificence!) in film. How can you even contemplate desecrating such Beauty? Why would I want to brave the midgies to lay to arrive and see an eyesore instead?23022015-04-20T20:43:20.818824Marie McNultyScottish Govt. just doesn't care. A wreckless obsession with achieving reneweable targets at any cost, yet openly oppose fracking - joke!23022015-04-20T21:29:33.1238825Sandra WolfeIt is wasteful to pursue archaic technology such as this when better options are available.\r\n23022015-04-21T00:00:33.4778826MARY MCCRORIEThank you Donna, you are a credit to your David after what as a Mother you have gone through , working so tirelessly to help get justice for others.22472015-04-21T09:19:04.938827Lisa McCart Signed x22472015-04-21T11:16:39.8678828jason kylesigned\r\n22472015-04-21T11:26:20.4438829Pierre and Monque GUETHStop windmills!23022015-04-21T16:46:00.578832Kathy GreavesThese monstrous giant wind turbines are ruining our country, destroying our landscape, wildlife, tourism - for what? The 'saving the planet' mantra is a myth, put about by people who are making money on these massive projects, without caring for the environment or for people who live in their vicinity.23022015-04-21T18:15:10.5238833Jacqueline MartinIt is about time that the punishment fits the crime and people need to know it is not ok to go about stabbing innocent people and expect to get away with it 22412015-04-21T18:50:09.0278834yves duloc'ha real shame !23022015-04-21T19:15:51.5938835Elaine Beveridgesigned this, great awareness being brought to not only students but any young people x22472015-04-21T19:18:48.228836Alison SouthbyWhat is the matter with you people, when will you ever stop destroying the beautiful areas of our small island23022015-04-21T19:26:17.098837Suzanne Signed22472015-04-21T19:33:00.4478838Sheila MacFadyenDavids story and indeed, Donna and her family story broke my heart then and still does now. I hope and pray that what happened to David is investigated as it should be and that they all find peace. 22472015-04-21T19:34:23.5078839John WardPut the turbines next to the cites that use the power. Less efficient, perhaps, but huge savings on infrastructure. And wouldn't damage one of our major foreign currency earners - tourism.23022015-04-21T20:26:29.9778842Jessie allanAll deaths need an explanation\r\n22472015-04-21T20:33:43.6078843Barbara Ann MalcolmFamilies have gone through enough heartache without having to fight to ascertain how thier loved one died Too many young people are dying this way something desperatly needs to change.22472015-04-21T21:48:21.698844Janet BidgoodWake up Scotland! You have the most beautiful land and the planet won't thank you for filling it with concrete and steel. 23022015-04-21T21:51:548845Fiona Lesselsso many life take by people who reoffend it's a joke 22412015-04-21T22:03:24.428846Kennedy Hamiltonplease stop this spoiling of our beautiful wild country- we won't get it back. When the 'wind power' myth is exposed, and the subsidies are gone, these monstrosities will be left to decay whilst the profiteers move on to the next cash cow.23022015-04-21T22:46:13.278847Arlene Russell Signed x 22472015-04-21T22:46:30.3578848pauline glenXx22472015-04-21T22:49:01.6378849Janie MacdonaldSigned xx22472015-04-21T23:44:01.168850Ben Marshallrip22472015-04-21T23:51:26.578851jade reidamazing how donna is selflessly trying to prevent othwr people suffering the way her son did and how it affected his friends and family. x22472015-04-21T23:57:19.148852Michelle mcatamney Signed x22472015-04-22T05:57:00.278854Sally ParrisIf you put up wind turbines in either Loch Ness or The great glen you will spoil your tourist industry as people don't want to see unnatural eyesores in stunning scenery & also they aren't cost effective23022015-04-22T07:07:30.458855Jen BorekPetition signed. Good luck Donna22472015-04-22T07:12:50.8138856B GriffithsI'm sure this will do Wonders for the tourist industry. I for one will not be visiting this area any more if this goes ahead, who wants to go on holiday to see a landscape ruined by wind farms?23022015-04-22T07:19:57.8078857Darren Boland Signed x 22472015-04-22T07:21:12.2078858Clive WilmottThe spread of wind farms is endangering what it is that makes Scotland such a special place to live. There is hardly a mountain summit where the view isn't blighted. 23022015-04-22T07:25:56.5378859alan dransfieldWind Turbines must be stopped at all costs.Its only a matter of time before we need body bags.23022015-04-22T07:27:37.358860Julia HeyI believe that wind turbines would completely destroy this beautiful environment and would be a threat to raptors and bats which frequent this tranquil landscape.23022015-04-22T08:10:32.4538861Rachel MackemzieWe don't need windfarms blighting ever Scottish landscape. Please use some common sense n discretion when siting them.23022015-04-22T08:43:08.4878863Cath DiamondOf all the open land in Scotland, why there? Leave it alone please23022015-04-22T08:53:478864Andy ScraseIt is nothing less than a tragedy that Scotland is being descrecrated by windfarms in the pursuit of unviable energy policies that will result in high and unsustainable energy prices for no environmental benefit at all23022015-04-22T09:03:31.5138866John AngioliniI cant believe that the natural beauty of the Great Glen will be scarred with these monstrosities!! What idiot has proposed this and who is lining their pocket!!\r\nI am totally disgusted.23022015-04-22T09:10:39.828867Robert StalkerStay away23022015-04-22T09:15:16.0238868Howard DuthieThe Scottish Government is guilty of gross dereliction of duty if it allows such a monstrous injustice to be visited upon the country it is supposed to care for.23022015-04-22T09:21:24.698869Roberta McDougallTime for change22472015-04-22T09:21:55.2438870Michael WestmanI support fully this petition to preserve and restore the outstanding natural beauty of Scotland. Keep it turbine-free!23022015-04-22T10:04:07.698871Alun CookeGood luck. - They are a complete waste of time and money - (Wind Generators)23022015-04-22T10:07:07.5178872Margaret yerszChange is needed22472015-04-22T10:15:45.948873PETER HEPBURNMY FAMILY GIVER IT OUR FULL SUPPORT22342015-04-22T12:14:19.648875Alan MitchellWind turbines create Visual pollution. \r\nStop damaging beautiful Scotland23022015-04-22T13:00:06.4878876Mike HepburnFully support this petition to keep the natural beauty of Scotland. Too many wind farms already blotting our landscape.23022015-04-22T15:49:26.398878R. V. HEWETTHighland Council have published a Consultation Paper - Spatial Planning for Onshore Wind Energy in Highland.\r\nThe authors' of this document are aware of the Scottish Government's Commissioned (2008) on the Economic Impacts of Wind Farms on Scottish Tourism,but are unaware of its 'Satus' because this Commissioned Report is NOT referred to by either the Scottish Planning Policy document or the Scottish Government's online advice note on Onshore Wind Turbines. It (Consultation Paper) comes as no surprise that the Authors of this document have stated , ''tourism is not their main issue for revue'' It is quite clear that our Planners have no desire to see the Highland's tourist industry flourish.23022015-04-22T16:23:26.558879Kirsten NielsenWind turbines create Visual pollution. Stop damaging beautiful Scotland23022015-04-22T16:38:00.568880Lothar Hellwigwind-kraft is generally criminell23022015-04-22T17:20:56.988881Carol-Ann VAN BLERKWind Turbines are a complete waste of time which has been proven on numerous occasions, the desecration of our European Landscapes needs to stop and stop now!23022015-04-22T19:32:09.938883anish senanI support this petition. I don't think the money spent on wind turbines will be a waste. 23022015-04-22T20:48:02.1938885Bruce McIntoshA crazy suggestion that the insignificant contribution such a limited technology will make to energy generation in Scotland, should compromise the landscape as it undoubtably will.People who know our land from countries such as Holland and Germany I know cannot believe how shortsighted we are becoming.\r\nPlease stop this maddness!23022015-04-22T20:56:45.6478886Fiona ButcherFuture generations will never forgive you. They are old technology and an economic nonsense. Stop the destruction of Scotland's wild scenery by wind turbines.23022015-04-22T21:32:34.938887Gillian YoungThere is no way we are allowing this to happen, destroying our Nation & natural habitat with their industries, to send the energy down south!!! we already have Hydro23022015-04-22T21:35:03.9638889Mary Hemphill We are requesting the Scottish Government to update guidance notes to reflect the new guidance, as noted below which details warfarin self testing and or self management as a safe alternative. A National Service Delivery Model will ensure health professionals throughout our Health Boards are given time and resource to provide that patient centred care approach in line with the Scottish Governments 2020 Vision. The Scottish Government writes fantastic protocol on self management, with the self management strategy Gaun Yersel written by patients with long term conditions for patients with long term conditions. We are requesting the Scottish Government to stand by that commitment and support and cheer our difficult journeys as patients. We have worked with Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Board that has been well recieved and greatly appreciated.\r\nSIGN 129 makes the following Grade A recommendation Self monitoring and self dosing is safe and effective and can be considered for some patients.\r\nThe Royal College of Physicians Edinburgh Consensus Statement states that Anticoagulant control may be improved by near patient testing and engaging patients in their own care patient education should be supported at every stage and\r\nNICE recommends the use of some coagulometers by people taking long-term anti blood clotting therapy if they prefer and are able to effectively use this type of monitoring see guideline published in September 2014.22342015-04-22T22:02:04.2438890dawn stubberfieldMore needs to be done.22472015-04-22T23:15:04.9978891Jude lethamHope change will happen due to this petition22472015-04-22T23:38:51.5678892RONALD TUTTYTURBINES ARE NOT THE ANSWER, THEY ARE POLLUTING OUR BEAUTIFUL COUNTRYSIDE.23022015-04-23T06:16:00.1278893Tracy MyattTime for a changed is needed22472015-04-23T06:53:40.768894Amy Sullivan Change is needed , especially for closure for grieving families 22472015-04-23T07:25:51.4938895Richard Marillier, FranceYou have a lovely country, let's save our heritage and our landscape23022015-04-23T07:30:01.1138896Frank HillWind farms? What a joke, only people making money out of these are the landowners, Farmers and the people who pu them up. Blot on the landscape.\r\nAnd no they don't provide efficient power23022015-04-23T08:10:24.6478897Gail Mairwaste of taxpayers money, visual and auditory pollution, extremely damaging to physical and mental health. I'm a wind turbine refugee23022015-04-23T09:44:56.118898A P GlewNeed to leave some of the iconic landmarks clear, somehow don't think folk would be too pleased if this were for the Lake District or South Downs. There are plenty of wind farms up in Scotland already, don't need it to become a wind farm forest.23022015-04-23T10:03:57.1978899Danni HamiltonDont distroy our beautiful landscape 23022015-04-23T10:10:28.828900Wolfgang TempelTwo years ago they wanted to build five 175 m high wind turbines near our little village. We've organized an election and so two-thirds of our entitled-to-vote population decided against the project. \r\nI wish you the most success for this petition.23022015-04-23T10:28:42.558901Heinz FRIESI trust that with the wisdom and foresight of its politicians, the necessary steps will be taken to save Great Glen and Loch Ness from an uncertain future and thus potential health - and environmental threats are kept disregard.23022015-04-23T12:42:07.818903David Patrickthis is a shocking despoliation of the beautiful Scottish landscape & our heritage for future generations. 23022015-04-23T13:43:59.938904Silvia SchlosserSave this wonderful Part of the World23022015-04-23T16:49:40.768905Evelyn HaydenPlease, in the Power of the Precious name of Jesus Christ, who with His Father created this pristine country, please do not destroy it.. Too many of us now are suffering because our governments allowed these things to be erected much too close to our homes.23022015-04-23T19:12:18.5538907Pieter HogeveenStop this insanity..23022015-04-23T19:33:27.298908Peter StickerA alndscape and ecosystem unique within the UK which can and should be saved for future generations23022015-04-23T23:10:48.498911Angela CampbellEvery life is precious and should be treated as such.22472015-04-24T00:29:57.0938912Pat HelmeThe planning system isn't fit for purpose in the case of these industrial scale developments. In many cases local people don't want them, local councils reject planning applications but they're over-ruled by 'Edinburgh' with no further right of appeal. Scottish Natural Heritage's work on strategic landscape capacity assessments for wind energy and mapping of wild land areas is dismissed by Scottish Ministers - they have another agenda and it's not Scotland's 'natural heritage'! Follow the money. . . 23022015-04-24T13:39:51.5138914nancy campbellchange is needed\r\n22472015-04-24T13:44:15.2978916mrs alison mcacnngood luck guys.22342015-04-24T18:08:38.4278917Keira MackieLots of love x22472015-04-24T19:49:35.1938918Sharon McGachyAdmiring your spirit and drive, good luck, hope you achieve what you are pushing for.22342015-04-24T20:41:56.388919Lesley sharpLet's make this happen now x22342015-04-24T21:19:40.1238920Julie SimpsonAs a long term warfarin patient I have been self testing while living in England for the past 7 years. I was very surprised and disappointed to hear that this was not recognised as a option when I recently returned to live in Scotland. Self testing is much more convenient for many patients and must be less burden on the Nhs. I'm strongly in favour of this petition. 22342015-04-24T23:50:26.068921lynne joycegood on u mary x u such an inspirational woman x x x 22342015-04-25T09:25:29.3978923Karen mcgrathRidiculous you dont case less but if it where you lot them the story would be different. Get moving and do something!22472015-04-25T10:39:22.6038924Ann Fergusson Hume Jack Disappointed that Scotland does not adhere to European Law this needs urgent attention 22472015-04-25T12:06:40.938926Teresa mcgachyYour a fighter Mary ,you'll win good luck,our lady of Lourdes will help you xx 22342015-04-25T23:24:52.5438927Chris CampbellWarfarin patients should be given the option, and even encouraged to self-test. Making these test devices available, will free-up valuable time for GPs and hospitals, and remove the need for patients to travel, in many cases under difficult conditions, especially in winter.22342015-04-26T10:47:33.0638928Kelly Mclean - Glasgowevery life is precious and every and every family need closure xx God bless 22472015-04-26T10:56:21.3238929Jennifer hasell No parent should need to go through. This 22472015-04-26T11:50:12.18931Amina HussainNothing more coveted than life. Nothing more necessary than knowing how that life ended, if you're the one left behind22472015-04-26T12:22:48.198932Bernard KennedyI do hope it is successful and that someday those affected can find peace following thorough investigations. This change must be adopted to keep us in line with the rest of the western world where suicide and accidental deaths are treated separately. 22472015-04-26T13:07:58.6638933June O'Donnell Change is needed 22472015-04-26T14:43:28.0738934Kerr BrandUnexplained death needs to be investigated. 22472015-04-26T16:10:03.5778935Marisa Stevenson Change needs to happen , help stop this happening to anyone else . 22472015-04-26T20:03:59.098937Angus RiddellChange is needed 22472015-04-26T20:07:05.248938Susan coatsPetition signed22472015-04-26T22:08:03.528941Neil McIntoshRequires review and change. Clearly inconclusive at present and not just. 22472015-04-26T23:14:02.9238943Lyndsay BlairLife is precious22472015-04-27T01:30:37.378944Jennifer DanielsI'm signing this because I'm a friend of Susie-David's Godmother. She is a grand lady and I care for her very much. I hope good comes from this. TY22472015-04-27T02:30:23.758946Doreen Forsyth Change needed ASAP 22472015-04-27T06:06:19.198948Gayle PatersonThe law needs to be changed, everyone deserves closure and this poor family, like many others, still have none. 22472015-04-27T07:49:26.5738949Jean BrownAfter 34 years of unanswered questions . prison suicide proven neglect preventable. Within the systm time for answers and Justice for a vunerable young kad ..my Brother. I welcome a new investigation . his avoidable death still traumatised by his Death.So many more after even after the recommended changes..investigation is absolutely needed. .22472015-04-27T12:39:59.9278950Anthony trainerlets do it22472015-04-27T13:21:04.9638951geraldine hoganPlease please help find david\r\nPlease help find david \r\n22472015-04-27T18:41:01.6878952Connie DeaconIts a pleasure to sign this, xxx22472015-04-27T21:40:01.6138955Peter inglis The law should get chance.get changes ass ppl family's want answers to what has happened to your family member 22472015-04-27T22:03:33.918956Julie stevens Heartbreaking 22472015-04-27T22:35:06.4238957Una DohertyGlad to support22472015-04-27T23:10:31.1538958Louise Burns I hope this family find answers soon. Change the law and enable this family and the thousands of other families the opportunity of closure !!! 22472015-04-27T23:52:24.028959Donna O'Halloran It is a great shame that the petition has been so slowed down by links that break if copied from anywhere other than this page, the wrong message being issued if code box hasn't been filled and last but not least the fact that if anyone shares after signing it's the thank you page that is shared :( really disappointed as I strongly believe all these programming snags have seriously restricted the number of signatures. Many thanks to all who persevered and succeeded in signing! Special thanks to all who tagged and shared xxx22472015-04-28T09:40:31.5738960Chris GillA worthwhile goal with clear benefits, I wish you every success in this campaign.22342015-04-29T12:39:59.428961Elizabeth Marrsmy mum had a triple heart op and as a result is on warfarin. Whilst it wouldn't be for everyone it should be an option to self test. It means the elderly who can't do it themselves have more care and attention when they do go as the able are doing it from home x 22342015-04-29T15:22:04.2638962Thomas Bradfordto self test is a great idea saves surgery time for somebody else who might be more needy of the nurses time22342015-04-29T16:01:28.448963Clair ferguson Petition signed! 22342015-04-29T17:08:28.928964lyndsey williams patients should be given the right to self test themselves. This will give the nhs staff more time to other stuff, will also means less travelling for patients22342015-04-29T18:12:49.9038965Andrea McDonaldI am a nurse and Mary Hepburn is a friend's sister. I think this would be so worthwhile for so many people22342015-04-29T21:09:21.8678966Evelyn IrvineWe need a delivery model to give patients control over their condition.22342015-04-29T21:38:55.8078967Zoe SweeneyGive people the right to make their own decisions and right to support22342015-04-29T22:47:41.7978968Angela TaylorCannot see any good reason why this is not done immediately 22342015-04-30T10:01:56.6178969William PertI started self testing over a year ago, now save time not having to fit in appointments around work. Gives peace of mind when on holiday. I would recommend self testing. Good luck with the campaign.22342015-04-30T13:02:54.758970Alan McDermottLife should mean life. 22412015-04-30T13:17:01.448971Claire CochraneLife should mean life22412015-04-30T14:00:33.9078972Kenneth MurrayAgree wholeheartedly.22412015-04-30T14:15:29.988973Anthony kilanowskiLife means life 22412015-04-30T16:41:19.58974gary hare Thoughts and prayers with the family 22412015-04-30T18:06:34.4878975Thomas DohertySelf testing should be allowed to take place ASAP! 22342015-04-30T18:49:51.2378976David RonaldThoughts are with you22412015-04-30T20:35:06.9278977Debbie dargieIf you breach someone's human rights, you should have all of your human rights removed! I don't understand why there is a petition for this, surely this should be common sense? Hopefully this will make the people in charge sit up and try and change things. 22412015-04-30T20:48:37.728978Mary Fergusonlife for a life.\r\n22412015-05-02T23:14:08.6278980Hugh HardieCommon sense must prevail - self testing now22342015-05-03T20:58:46.3838982David PattersonSelf testing enable patients to have better control of their INR and therefore less likelihood of sustaining a stroke. \r\nIt also facilitates a wider approach to stroke prevention for the patient by including BP monitoring and activity monitoring 22342015-05-03T21:06:59.9578983Dawn Roberts Patients should be given the right to self test.22342015-05-03T21:09:49.7538984Robert P DickieI agree that self testing should be available 22342015-05-03T21:58:44.198985Margaret KaneGood luck with the petition hope they pay attention22342015-05-28T14:24:46.3138986Gerard ClarkOn yer sail!23442015-05-28T14:29:03.5278987james phimisteryes!23442015-05-28T14:38:52.5778988Eleanor haigIt's time to start sorting things out ,will make independence that little bit closer 23442015-05-28T14:39:15.928989Shona mcdougallGo George!23442015-05-28T14:50:25.5838990bruce andersonFreedom to all scots23442015-05-28T15:42:56.7478991Dave Nairn at Freedom SailingThe Scots Red Ensign has and will always be flown from yacht 'Saorsa' in both Scottish and foreign waters. Even if this petition is unsuccessfull we will fly our Scots Red Ensign in contravention to the UK's Merchant Shipping Act 1995. I reject the claim and do not believe this is disrespectfull to sailors who have previously sailed under the British ensign. AdditionalIy, I do not agree that it should be the Queens decision to decide which flag is flown from Scottish vessels and think that its time to dissociate the 'royal' family from theses issues. This change is a necessary first step in the voyage to change the perception that sailing is an elitist pastime or occupation. 23442015-05-28T15:49:42.188992Craig jardineThe Scottish ensign is hundreds of years old. We want it back. Who made it illegal?\r\n 23442015-05-28T19:26:50.0678995Steve LaughtonNo one would object to an English Ensign and in effect, this is what is used as an Ensign for the Royal Navy. For this reason, it should be lawfully permitted for the Scots to use a Red Ensign with the Saltire in the quarter for civic or merchant use.23442015-05-28T20:49:56.1178996John KeatingI might be English but don't hold that against me. Fully support this petition, if it isn't successful, do it anyway. I don't remember electing Liz Windsor, so I don't see why she should have any say in the matter.23442015-05-28T22:23:00.648997stuart thomas allisonI feel this is an important issue that Scotland flag should be in place of the union jack 23442015-05-28T22:32:14.648998MARY VASEYWell done guys Scotland forever aye 23442015-05-28T23:33:26.158999terry howsonfor my sailing friend so that he can sail under the scottish ensign23442015-05-28T23:41:15.7439000Ewan MacArthurTo be a Nation Again \r\n23442015-05-29T07:24:41.9139001John RushworthI think this will only serve to confuse. I really don't understand why this gentleman currently wears such an historic ensign in contraventation of the UK Merchant Shiiping Act 1995. 99% of us are quite happy to abide by the rules and observe discipline as suggested by the UK's accepted organisation for leisure boaters. The RYA. Indeed why should those of us that wear a special ensign such as an undefaced blue go to the trouble of paying for and obtaining a warrant. There is currently no place for a Scottish Ensign unless of course this petition succeeds. 23442015-05-29T08:43:58.4879002Gilbert Roy RossWe should be recognisable as Scottish not just British when afloat.23442015-05-29T09:19:28.5879004Anne DunlopExcellent petition, and long overdue.23442015-05-29T09:22:02.3279005Anne DunlopExcellent idea and long overdue. Saor Alba!23442015-05-29T09:42:58.249006margaret burnsOur identity must be preserved on the seas and land e must stand up for our heritage always\r\n23442015-05-29T10:13:08.869007Gil McCurdieTime to bring back all that we recognise as Scottish and reclaim our identity23442015-05-29T10:17:24.3839008Robert M MacLeodAt long last,thank you George23442015-05-29T10:29:45.169009Douglas ThomsonSailed solo round world 1999-2002 flying Scottish Red Ensign. Only 2 English yachtsmen objected. 23442015-05-29T10:50:24.6039010Peter Wallace Aye, about time too 23442015-05-29T11:24:42.3739011Donald GilliesScotland and her true heritage must be restored.23442015-05-29T11:49:00.7339013Alan James Magnus-BennettMy father served in the royal Navy during WW2 and would have been proud to sail under a Scottish Ensign as well.23442015-05-29T12:38:56.089014William GrayFREE US\r\n23442015-05-29T13:22:41.3339015Danny WatkinsMy dad was Merchant Navy - I will ask him to sign this too.23442015-05-29T13:36:28.529016James HumeThe Scottish Maritime Flag should restored to all Scottish Shipping 23442015-05-29T16:35:41.249017Tommy Walker aka Thomas WalkerFreedom..23442015-05-29T16:58:59.139018Donald MacdonaldI'll put one on my mirror dinghy!\r\n23442015-05-29T18:02:58.7079019Reeni Kennedy-Boylebe great to aflotila of these when passed23442015-05-29T18:30:09.199020Norman Martin MNMShipmates wishing to see restoration of Scottish merchant navy ensign.23442015-05-29T18:31:23.7539021JANETTE CAMPBELLAny thing that woud keep our heritage in view for other generations!\r\n23442015-05-29T18:39:32.4579022Robert Dennis this flag should be proudly flown by Scottish Mariner's . ( at the moment it means in British nautical circles ' my ship is dead in the water ' ) time to promote this flag throughout the world as our naval flag , Alba Gu Brath.23442015-05-29T19:07:15.1139023Bill Watkins. (Ex MN)I would be proud to sail under the Red Mc Duster.23442015-05-29T19:08:49.919024daniel cainOf course Scotland should carry it's own flag on its own ships in its own waters it's only fair. 23442015-05-29T20:12:35.639026Jimmy WaughIt is time to assert our identity as a nation state23442015-05-29T20:20:10.889027Louise StephenWestminster like to keep their traditions so why shouldn't our seamen have their's. 23442015-05-29T21:33:22.7879028katya savageWe need to take our nation back before it is destroyed .Alba gu Brath ! \r\n23442015-05-29T22:13:37.89029Anne MacGregorI agree The Scottish Maritime Flag should restored to all Scottish Shipping23442015-05-29T22:28:56.4279030Russell HamiltonAnother small but significant step to Indy\r\nSaor Alba23442015-05-29T23:52:17.4579031Alicia Murray Yes the Scottish Ensign should be flown on Scottish shipping.23442015-05-30T00:36:51.889032Thomas friar if it's a Scottish boat or ship it should have saltire. 23442015-05-30T08:56:58.279033moira morrisonoverturn the illegal status, it's outdated.23442015-05-30T10:02:09.529034Duncan DewarI wholeheartedly welcome this move to restore our historic Ensign.23442015-05-30T15:50:27.9739035Wilma McEwanI would also like to hold a Scottish passport ,see our Saltire flying from every town ,and as the petition says see ships with our ensign23442015-05-30T16:39:49.2879036Alan DunlopI have flown my SCOTTISH red ensign from Canada to Trinidad. It was well received everywhere except for a few English boats23442015-05-30T18:14:09.5039037Peter CroweNot only was my father a Master Mariner but as a 'bone fide' Scottish History graduate, I'd love to see the pre-1707 Scots Red Ensign having a formalised legal sttus for vessels registered in a Scottish port or for vessels owned by Scots who wish to use it.23442015-05-30T18:49:43.3339038David NairnVessel registration should be a devolved matter and Scotlands interests with respect to Merchant Shipping Act 1995 need to be reexamined. 23442015-06-04T18:00:43.7239039Hugh PatersonShip registration for all vessels registered in Scotland should be a devolved issue, the UK register of ships is in a mess for an Island Nation.23442015-06-11T01:02:29.5639048Frankie KuGood luck!23332015-06-11T14:59:09.5039049paul mowatSeconded.23332015-06-11T19:32:43.9739050Alison Waugh Absolutely agree. Too many lives destroyed by vindictive contact disputes. Contact.should only be restricted or denied if there are strong, genuine reasons why this would be in the interests of the children. The system should not encourage or condone adversarial behaviour.23332015-06-11T19:44:35.2839051Sara brownI think the social work department have to many rights 23332015-06-12T15:17:44.559052Karen kinleySocial workers playing god with people's life,they have so many rights 23332015-06-13T07:38:59.7079054Ashley wilson Couldn't agree more with this.23332015-06-13T10:36:14.8979055Mandie Wilson yes ! Two many people play God with there kids and think about there slfs rather there child ! No one should be stop from seeing there kids unless they where a risk to the child! Tht is a different matter but just because the parents relationship is over doesn't mean there relationship with there kids are ! Two many kids are involved in this and it's not right ! Both parents should have a say and see there child ! People should stop making these poor children feel like there in the middle of there parents business so unfair ! And the parents who put there kids through this should be stopped ! 23332015-06-13T16:50:16.9879057Darren TowillEqual parenting... Why is one sided ? Dad's have feelings and hearts ..we love our children to. And they love us as much 23332015-06-13T16:53:20.4879058Sharon McAllisterThis should of been put in place years ago x23332015-06-13T19:17:45.059060Louise Reddell Children need both parents where both parents are deemed fit. 23332015-06-14T01:22:40.779061Yamin ZakariaIt is obscene that the resident parent. which is usually the mother, can simply deny all contact to the father, its inhumane. Law needs to change so that both parents by default have access to the children, unless its varied by a court order. 23332015-06-14T08:54:23.389063Kathleen AndertonI think mothers who block access should be given three chances to comply with a court order allowing contact to their childs other parent, if they continue to block access then they should go to prison. Too many children are being emotionaly messed up. Children want and need both parents to grow into well ajusted adults. The only restriction being if either parent is a danger to the child23332015-06-14T10:36:47.639064Jennifer kennedyCompletely agree, resident parents should be stopped from dictating contact arrangements with non resident parents. The current system enables resident parents to falsely accuse non resident parents of abuse to access legal aid. Even when child protection investigations are conducted and are unfounded. The current system causes huge inefficiencies and wastes resources within the legal system, police, and social work services. There needs to be more joined up partnership working amongst these services to stop these situation progressing which is ultimately failing children in this country. The current system contradicts every peice of legislation that underpins the rights of children and makes a mockery out of the justice system.23332015-06-14T22:37:28.029066Lydia Reid Imagine being a child\r\nYou go to bed at night your Dad reads you a story He has already given you your supper and bath\r\nAll is normal \r\nWhen the child wakes up in the morning They are no longer allowed to speak to their Dad or of their Dad\r\nWith no real explanation this child has been removed from Dad granny grandad and Aunts uncles and cousins \r\nTheir whole life as they know it is destroyed \r\nTheir Dad is not allowed to buy their favourite crisps Not allowed to read to them cuddle them or pick them up from school \r\n\r\nAll of a sudden this person and people the child loved have gone \r\n\r\nHow would you feel if this happened to you as an adult \r\nHow do you think a child feels \r\nWhat kind of affect do you think that has on a child \r\nIf you believe this is an exaggeration go and speak to just a few families disputing contact \r\nChildren need consistency and security if they are not to be damaged \r\nIt surely is simple common sense that the life of that child will stay more secure with a simple explanation and continuance of contact with both parents unless their is a genuine reason to stop contact for one parent 23332015-06-15T15:25:29.2079068Alan LeeYour comments are extremely valuable.. \r\nIt is extremely sad that as a father, I have to fight to see my child, sad I have to petition the government for change, sad for my kids...\r\nIt is not in the best interest of the child that they don't get to see their father or mother and extended family.\r\nI understand the Scottish Government has no plans to change the current law, however, I hope to get as many signatures as possible and push for change.\r\nChange not for me but for my children.\r\nI want to thank you for your comments and signing the petition. Please share the petition and ask your family and friends to sign.\r\nThank you from the bottom of my heart.23332015-06-16T13:46:43.3339069Clive B ScottEnsigns bearing the Union Flag are seen by Europeans as identifying a boat from England, Australia or New Zealand. The purpose of the ensign is to identify where the vessel is from or registered. My boat is registered in Glasgow and I was born and have lived my whole life in Scotland. We are constantly being asked why we fly "the English flag". From this season my boat will wear the 1707 Scottish Ensign (currently in Scandinavia). There is no reason why Westminster should not devolve this issue to Holyrood.23442015-06-18T19:09:36.4579071Tam DewarThis would be a very good use of the Scottish Government underspend.23352015-06-19T12:27:37.7879074alan grantUntil we eliminate poverty altogether I support this motion.23352015-06-19T17:29:55.9579075gavin ritchieIts really sad how one parent can be so harsh towards a person they loved at one point in time and for there own hatered towards the other stops a father seeing there child and also go to the lengths of going to court to see there own child. As adults are we not supposed to be the ones teaching our children moral guidance when a child is involved in these disputes what must they think. As a person who is just about to go through this process very soon I believe any help to make the process faster is fantastic as the bond between father and child is just as important for the childs well being as that of mother and child. And lets all be honest its the childrens well being thats important not a grudge held by the mother towards the father.\r\n23332015-06-19T17:33:52.2539076Eric TarkingtonFamily courts and social services simply cannot spend time or money in amounts that match the difficulty of trying to predict who will be the better single parent. The country already spends more than it can afford on the job of unjustly taking parental rights from fit parents, causing untold terror and grief to their helpless children, and devastating the family financially. Equal parenting is what children need according to the convincing research, but decisions are based on Victorian Era bias, instead. Until the day when we can stop this evil, the sole custody system should at least enforce its own rules.\r\n\r\nThe law should demand fines based on mother's income or significant community service or both for every incident of access withholding by a custodial parent. Children's lost access time should be compensated twofold at the noncustodial parent's convenience. At the third or subsequent incident of access withholding within a year, the noncustodial parent should have the option of taking interim custody of the child while the system considers a permanent change of custody. These provisions are feasible as changes in law.\r\n\r\nThe government should stop corrupting custodial parents by awarding legal aid in custody disputes only where there is an allegation of domestic abuse. False allegations are quite possibly doing more damage to more children than actual abuse in families -- we don't have the research to know. Family courts and social services should first do no harm, and they are failing that standard miserably in this and other ways.23332015-06-19T19:09:41.4239077Nicky John sevenoaksI think every father should have the right to see there children unless there a rapist towards kids 23332015-06-19T20:05:57.8639078Alan CherryAs the necessity of food banks, in my view, is in part to do with government welfare legislation, it is right that the government should have a part in offsetting the effects on the people affected by the legislation.23352015-06-20T09:04:04.499079lorraine kingthis day and age food banks is a disgrace there should be no need for these the worlds 3rd richest country the eton boys separating the rich from the poor its poor wee weans who are having to get up and go to school hungry and there mums not being able to wash there clothes and when the scottish winter bites well thats another story shame on this lot how they can sleep at night is way beyond me evil to the core\r\n23352015-06-21T14:19:38.2879080Helen RodgerMy food bank at Hillington Park Church keeps running out of food. Please help if you can.23352015-06-22T08:46:02.6779081Alasdair MacKenzieI flew one on my boat in Loch Lomond when I had it several years ago and there is a small commercial operator in the Clyde area whose boats have been flying the Scottish Red Ensign for a couple of years now. Best if it's official, but it doesn't have to be if you are only sailing in home waters.23442015-06-22T12:40:35.339082Lorraine RodgerTrussell Trust data + anecdotes are heartbreaking. 23352015-06-22T12:44:34.9439083Murray LeithI fully support the submission of this petition and request that the committee forward it with the utmost degree of urgency to the Scottish Government with full support. As a regular contributor to foodbanks, it is disgraceful that a government should underpsned its budget when people are literally running out of food. This is Scotland in the 21st Century, we should act like the people who say we are.23352015-06-22T15:24:32.529084John KielyI have flown the Scottish Ensign for a couple of years now, mostly on the Scottish west coast and Northern Ireland.\r\nAlways gets commented on.23442015-06-22T15:39:53.6139085Brian RobertsonThe Red Ensign is as foreign to me as the Red Sickle of Russia. It does not represent my Country nor my beliefs. I am a Scot and I wish my Ensign to represent the country that I hold dear & would not wish, as so often happens to be asked why I am flying the English Flag on my vessel.23442015-06-22T15:44:09.0679086Nick JenkinsFoodbanks have become an essential service in an era of ideologically motivated austerity. The Scottish Government has committed itself to mitigating the most severe aspects of this programme (e.g. the bedroom tax). I urge the Scottish Government to continue this work by using its underspend to feed families living in extreme and socially unjust poverty.23352015-06-22T17:46:40.3179087John DuncanI fully support this petition to reintroduce the Scottish Ensign on an informal or voluntary basis. If passed can we please have the correct shade of blue!23442015-06-22T20:17:29.6439088Madhu AthavaleGoing to buy a red ensign and flyt it proudly hoisted on a very high flag pole for all to see. Maybe if Cameron looked up at the sky, he will see it as well.\r\n\r\nWake up can for David.23442015-06-23T00:32:56.089089George A. WebsterWe are a nation, we have a Parliament. Our shipping ought to have the right to fly our historic ensign - and we ought not to be having to ask a Parliament based in another nation, in which our representation is that of a minority, for permission to do so. However, should such a petition be rejected it will be one more straw on the camel's back of this dead Union. 23442015-06-23T10:16:43.3639090Jim McLaughlinI'd like to know how we ended up with it in the first place!!...Must have been part of the "Carve-up"!23442015-06-23T11:24:17.2879091Robert DuffHelp us retake our National identity.23442015-06-23T17:46:14.199092Eilidh HewittGlorious to see red ensign flying23442015-06-23T19:30:52.979093Brian Cavanwill there also be a Blue Ensign version of the Scottish Ensign for Royal Sailing Clubs in Scotland to fly23442015-06-24T16:03:20.339094Rosemary GrahamI fly the Scottish ensign on my boat with pride!23442015-06-25T18:30:07.2879097David MorrisonI think its the correct flag for a Scottish boat to fly,shows your identity at a glance.23442015-06-25T19:07:51.169098bernard burnett elliottSCOTS WHA HAE23442015-06-27T11:59:05.359099kathleen dalySigned23492015-06-27T12:04:32.3979100Stacey McElhinneyWell done Jordan. Xx23492015-06-27T16:24:26.3979101Ian McGregorI have reservations about governments funding foodbanks. Governments should render foodbanks unnecessary. However, we start from where we are.23352015-06-28T11:22:59.279102Bill MairThis step completes the repeal of Thatcher's section 28.\r\n23492015-06-28T12:22:42.5179105Dave WattGreat idea - having been brought up in an era where homophobia was the norm I'd like the kids of the future not to carry the same bigoted baggage I've spent all these years shedding.23492015-06-28T12:51:51.279106gerard GalbraithIts about time people23492015-06-28T13:45:13.9739107Joshua BrownStatutory LGBTI+ education is sadly lacking and a necessary step towards rooting out all forms of discrimination in our schools and wider Scottish society. No form of discrimination is acceptable. Scotland must use education to clearly and consciously tackle discrimination against the LGBTI+ community, just like it very rightfully is required to do regarding impairments, race, ethnicity, religion, etc. Eduction is one of the most effective ways we can instill a lifelong commitment to human rights, diversity and equality for all. Let's build on Scotland's achievement of equal marriage and ensure dignity, respect and human rights for every person in Scotland. Support statutory LGBTI+ education in all Scottish schools. 23492015-06-28T14:23:18.9579108Gavin RolloFly the flag of the former Royal Scots Navy with pride !23442015-06-28T16:05:04.1439109Paul FraserLGTBI people are more likely to suicide when bullied23492015-06-29T08:58:53.8139110Ian McleanIt's time some of the people in judgement of these cases got some background info from friends and neighbours. The men fighting to see their kids are doing it because they love them no other reason.23332015-06-29T09:05:18.5039111Lindsay JohnstoneJealous bitter females who flaunt the court and social work systems time and time again...breaking numerous court orders, making false allegations against the father (with no evidence may I add) ongoing emotional abuse towards the child and being obstructive at every opportunity should be made examples of! There needs to be a shake up in the law and the system as a whole as there are thousands of fathers out there who are being pushed out of their child (s) life for no reason. Time and money wasted on courts that could be better spent on the child....isn't that "what's in the best interest for a child" to be able to spend time with both families (and extended family) of both parents...not just the mothers! Time for a change! NEVER GIVE UP! MOTHER DOESN'T ALWAYS KNOW BEST in situations such as these ones!23332015-06-29T13:43:42.499112Donna HughesSo pleased to hear you are doing this.It is long overdue.23492015-06-29T15:00:23.0979113Aileen Mitchell StewartI was appalled at the statistics of how schools are failing to provide a safe, welcoming space for LGBTI+ young people. In 2015! As a liberal-minded, tediously heterosexual pensioner I was astonished that this situation could still exist today. I had naively assumed such bullying, casual verbal discrimination and non-acceptance had long gone, apart from the few bone-heads who, sadly, will always cloak their own fears behind abusing others and belittling difference. I am flabbergasted that schools are not addressing this. Religious beliefs should never be allowed as an excuse for failing so many young people at a difficult stage in their lives. To fail to address this issue is to fail as a school. Full stop. We urgently need legislation to ensure that all schools fully educate and wholly support their students whatever their sexual orientation or identification. Please act now to prevent even one more vulnerable young person feeling unsupported and marginalised in this way. \r\n23492015-06-29T17:11:31.39115Ken CouttsThis is a no brainer, all power to your elbow23492015-06-29T20:11:15.5039116Alan LeeOn the day of my birthday, I don't even get to see my kids. Where is the justification in that??23332015-06-29T20:20:59.9879117Leeanne stevenson Inspiring piece of writing and this would help young kids understand a lot better. X23492015-06-29T23:26:32.6279118marion mcmillanthis is definitely a move in the right direction. 23492015-06-30T08:45:00.9579119Ashley Husband PowtonScotland, lets set an example to the world here!23492015-06-30T18:02:56.339120DAVE FORDA GREAT IDEA! WHEN WE FINALLY HAVE OUR OWN NATION WE WILL NEED IT FOR OUR SCOTTISH NAVY.23442015-06-30T18:49:39.529121Kymm monkhouseIf you have a son its hell to watch women using kids as tools 23332015-06-30T19:12:03.589122Claire Gallagher I think it should be in schools as the lgbt community should be protect and be taught about as well23492015-06-30T19:59:08.169123Rhiannan girvanIt's about time! Sitting through a science lesson with not one refract to homosexual couples was no help at all 23492015-07-01T09:55:54.2879124Karen McNicol If only this had been done years ago it would have saved so much more heartache!23492015-07-01T20:32:48.359125Alba Mooney Not until LGBTI issues and topics become part of the curriculum, will there be full inclusion and understanding that we are as "normal" as heterosexuals... and that ours issues are just as important... 23492015-07-03T23:09:13.3639126Nicola Lawsonthis is so so so soooooo important !!!23492015-07-04T11:49:02.89127John McMillanMy Father used this Flag for many years after he died I have used it for the past ten years and will continue to do so.23442015-07-05T01:26:14.1139128Lesley-AnneEvery vessel based and registered in Scotland should fly the Scottish Red Ensign. It used to be our flag indicating the origins of our ships and so it should be again. It should never have been stopped from flying after 1707!23442015-07-05T08:51:55.0339129Colin HamiltonGreat idea!23442015-07-05T15:11:20.979131patrick rolinkevery citizen in our Nation deserves fairness and equality, without exception !!23492015-07-06T00:19:56.639132Alasdair H MacinnesScottish yachts should be able to fly a Scottish red ensign23442015-07-06T13:54:43.059135Aimee McDonald This is such an important thing\r\n23492015-07-07T17:28:50.3639136Margaret W WallaceWe need Help23352015-07-07T19:16:39.729137Ben OwensEducation is the key to stamping out homophobic, biphobic, transphobic and intersex-phobic bullying. Education is the key to creating a fair and equal society. It is vital that a progressive and positive representation of LGBTI issues are taught as part of the compulsory Scottish Education curriculum 23492015-07-08T14:07:04.279138Robert MacKenzieThis is a great idea. Anything which helps to distinguish and emphasise our nation is a good thing.23442015-07-09T15:39:01.3479139Freda BirrellI am calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to convene a roundtable discussion on the safety of HPV vaccines with medical and scientific professionals from both sides of the debate. Many young girls in the UK and in many countries worldwide have become ill following HPV vaccination and this serious issue needs to be addressed. I do hope that Edinburgh will take the lead in the UK and discuss this at a scientific level.23652015-07-09T19:08:50.8639140Caron RyallsI urge the Scottish Parliament to lead the way in the UK by backing a roundtable discussion on the safety of HPV vaccines as called for with this petition. My daughter was healthy and active prior to her HPV vaccination nearly 5 years ago, but since her vaccination she has been extremely ill and her life changed beyond recognition. In those 5 years we have struggled to find medical professionals with the experience and knowledge to accurately assess and diagnose her. The way she has been treated has been scandalous, her education has been decimated and her future is very uncertain. We have no way of knowing if she will ever work full time and tragically we have no guarantee that she will not develop cervical cancer. If I could turn back the clock I would because I believe the risks with the HPV vaccination far outweigh any estimated benefit. Currently, the risk are very real, with families living with the consequences but the benefits are pure speculation. This surely cannot be right.23652015-07-09T22:02:53.5039141Dee WaterhousrMy daughter was a super fit healthy young woman playing sports at least 3 times a week. Within a couple of months of completing her HPC course she started having fatigue nausea and abdominal pain. Within 6 months she had an unusual faint with a very fast pulse. Initial referral to children's services were very poor. Eventually she came under the care of a very caring cardiology consultant. She has had every investigation you can think of and we have been informed we may never know why she has symptoms of dizziness feel faint not there feeling abdo pain and now recently nausea. She has been diagnosed as reflex syncope an autonomic condition no control over her heart rate and blood pressure she takes cardiac medication to try and control her symptoms but it is slow process, it is heart breaking to watch our 15year old daughter missing out on her life she missed being a bridesmaid for the first time school has been a challenge every day wheysuddiyou are using a wheelchair and finally missing her prom as she didn't feel well enough she is 16 in August and what should be a milestone and celebration will be a quiet affair as she just can't face celebrators she is so exhausted all the time . If we as parents had been properly informed and made aware what was happening to other young women WE WOULD NEVER HAVE AGREED TO THIS VACCINE AND SHAME ON THIS GOVERNMENT FOR CONTINUING WITH THIS PROGRAM AND COVERING UP THIS SCANDAL 23652015-07-09T23:04:13.2539142Jennifer AllanThis vaccine is expensive, causes more adverse effects than all the other vaccines put together, does not protect from all cancer causing HPV strains, and is UNNECESSARY, since pap smears are far more effective in prevention of cervical cancer. PLEASE stop risking our lovely teenage girls' health with this vaccine. Other countries have banned this vaccine or are considering doing so.23652015-07-09T23:17:16.0339144Anna WatsonIt still remains just a theory that a virus causes cancer, so putting girls at such risk is shocking. I do hope new debate and evidence can be shared as soon as possible23652015-07-09T23:28:51.2839145Norma EricksonHPV vaccines are not safe for everyone. This has been clearly demonstrated in every country where they are used. The only way to identify those most at risk for serious adverse reactions is to conduct open and honest scientific discussions. Society cannot afford to let their young healthy people continue to be put at risk for serious injuries, perhaps death, for a promise of positive results 15 years down the road. Please seriously consider holding an open discussion on HPV vaccine risks so the true risk to benefit ratio can be determined. Don't allow your young people to play HPV vaccine roulette.23652015-07-10T06:41:58.89146Susana lozanoNo a la vacuna del papiloma. No papillomavirus vaccine23652015-07-10T07:36:06.5379147Karen smyth I fully support this petition. My daughter was injured by the HPV vaccine Gardasil. It has totally destroyed her life and impacted heavily and extremely negatively on our entire family. My daughter has emtremely poor health, no schooling and no social life. She is 17 yrs old and was vaccinated nearly 5 yrs ago. She's getting worse not better and the medical people who caused the problem are doing nothing to put it right. It's got to stop before any more lives are destroyed. 23652015-07-10T07:43:23.69148Elizabeth Grace FilbyScotland can and should lead the way on this, since Westminster has failed to do so. 23652015-07-10T08:00:16.0379149Sam Sharman-DunnOur daughter became very unwell with PoTS and CFS following the HPV vaccine (Ceravix). It has devastated all our lives. We urgently need a full investigation into the safety of these vaccines before more girls are injured. Please help us.23652015-07-10T08:26:34.0039150Marie SmithMy daughter had the vacinnation in the first year they were offered. Since then she has experienced recurring sore throats, swollen glands and worryingly sore knee joints. She was tested for glandular fever and swine flu at one stage but nothing was positive. She is now 22 and continues to have aching knee joints and swollen glands. 23652015-07-10T09:20:03.6439151Helen Huitson My daughter had the gardasil vaccine October 2013 and reacted immediately and has been extremely ill since ! She only had the first dose and now has chronic illness 23652015-07-10T10:35:40.999152David RiddellMy daughter was injured by the HPV vaccine and has been in and out of hospital since getting vaccine in January before she had vaccine she had never been in hospital.23652015-07-10T10:48:53.6739153shireen RobsonMy Daughter is unable to walk and suffering from blackouts limiting her ability to concentrate, following the HPV vaccine (Gardasil) she received at school. This has completely changed not only her life and ability to achieve her own life goals but has had a large impact on our lives. I am committed to discovering why this has happened and wish for further investigation into the matter. 23652015-07-10T11:05:32.6279154Andrew AsheAttending a Catholic high school in Lanarkshire in the early 2000's, I experienced narrow mindedness and homophobic views from the teachers which legitimized the taunts of fellow pupils.\r\n\r\nNo action or omission, however how subtle should reinforce homophobia or transphobia in schools. That's what refusing to teach about sexuality and gender identity does and it needs to end. 23492015-07-10T12:29:52.89155martina haudeOur daughter is 15 and is very unwell due to having the HPV vaccine in 2013. Her illness is very disabling and she as gone from a sporty child to being unable to walk and have a normal life like her peers. She can not attend school daily and we feel as parents that the HPV vaccine needs to be looked at asap 23652015-07-10T13:19:41.9739156Susan HartHere in the Scottish Borders we have come across teachers who identify as LGBT but are too scared to be out. We have found teachers who believe that clause 28 still exists. We have heard of schools who actively discourage any LGBT education. It seems to come down to individual heads as to whether or not the school is inclusive of LGBT education. 23492015-07-10T15:44:01.419158Ifet LawrenceMy 15 year old daughter had 2 out of the 3 Gardasil injections, and has been very ill since. She has missed 2 years of school and barely leaves the house now. This vaccine has changed my daughter's life. Before the vaccine she barely even got a cold. More needs to be done to look at the effects of of the affected girls because at the moment no one is taking any notice.23652015-07-10T15:54:52.5679159Dunc MackayA child requires both parents in their lives. Sick to death of seeing, reading and first hand, the child being used as a weapon to try and hurt by woman who flaunt and play the courts to hurt good dads! Now I have no doubt that there are certain scenarios where extra contact should be assessed but 90 percent of the time, lack of contact is out of spite purely to hurt. Time to get the law re-assessed and appropriate punishments put into place for those that break contact. I also fully support the reducing of legal aid, another system that is in place to fill other people's pockets with cash and allows this nonsense to continue.23332015-07-10T17:21:36.1439160Christina GarveyI had my first episode multilple sclerosis following a routine Hep B vaccination for travel as a teenager more than 20 years ago. I was not correctly diagnosed until 10 years later. All vaccines need to be looked at. There is no one size fits all - sadly.23652015-07-10T17:45:48.979162CHELSEA ST. IVESI was affected by the HPV vaccine. I now have a chronic idiopathic swelling disorder that affects my life every day. I have had to quit jobs because of it, seen many doctors, to no avail. 23652015-07-10T17:59:10.0379163Steven ScruttonMy grand-daughter refused this vaccine, and was given a hard time, not just by doctors (who said nothing about the known dangers of the vaccines - they have been known about for a very long time) but from her teachers. One teacher asked her "why are you so special?". She was upset for a time, but I am delighted she was strong enough to remain firm. The HPV Gardasil vaccine is the most damaging to health of all vaccines, and that is really saying something!23652015-07-10T18:02:27.9879164Nina Bjelogrlic-LaaksoI am a neurologist from Finland. \r\n\r\nMass vaccinations with Cervarix were initiated in our country somewhat later (i.e. in autumn 2013) than in many other countries so we have not seen the SAE cases until lately. So far, our health authorities have received 31 SAEs out of which two has been reported by the undersigned. \r\n\r\nThe problem is that most of the colleagues do not know of the risks related to HPV vaccines and, therefore, it does not necessarily come to their mind to ask their patients' vaccination history. Consequently, SAE reports are done only occasionally. That was the case with two of my own patients, who came to my office for a second opinion. Having a close look at their medical history it became very clear to me that the causality to the preceding Cervarix vaccinations was in both of those two cases (according to the criteria set by our health authorities) at least probable (if not definite). The causality can be considered definite, if the mechanisms that have been described in the literature are generally accepted to explain the cascade of events leading to serious symptoms (including sometimes even death). \r\n\r\nI had a meeting a couple of days ago with our national health authorities, who do believe (like their foreign colleagues) that that benefits outweigh the risks. During our discussions it became obvious that the safety signal has been recognized and that our authorities are following very carefully the situation. So an open scientific discussion would be warmly welcome also from the Finland's perspective.\r\n\r\nNina Bjelogrlic-Laakso, MD, PhD23652015-07-10T18:23:48.39165Juan Andres ElhazazMy daughter suffered various illness after the second shot of Gardasil. so we had to suspend the third. She a first year with very little energy, lack of concentration and vasculitis and allergic reactions to a lot of different things. Her immune system was very affected. after years of efforts and care she is now very close to normal.23652015-07-10T18:25:39.0379166Jennifer GuldinI was severely injured by the set of 3 series Gardasil vaccine nearly 4 years ago. I have experienced things like debilitating nausea, stroke-like symptoms, tremors, just to name a few. I have missed out on so much of my life and my 6 year old daughters life as a result of this vaccine.23652015-07-10T18:28:26.6479167Louise Kuo HabakusIt is almost impossible to change medical and scientific consensus, and prevailing practice. There are too many powerful forces that are unwilling to concede that an issue is deserving of greater scrutiny. For the sake of our children, and for all of us, we must speak out. There is so much at stake -- integrity of the physician-patient relationship, confidence in public health directives, human rights and civil liberties, corporate accountability. These foundational principles and values serve to define who we are. It starts with a willingness to speak out for our most vulnerable, including babies, children, and mothers.23652015-07-10T18:52:17.889168Tracy D WolfMy daughter suffered encephalitis that caused her serious brain damage and uncontrollable seizures. She has been suffering for the past 8 years after getting the HPV shots. She had to spend most of 2008 in the hospital. She has to wear adult diapers, She had to get a VNS implant to try to stop seizures (it doesn't work) When I filed her injuries to VAERS here in the USA I saw that over 100 other injuries were associated with the 3 lot numbers that my daughter got. I meet people everyday who have also suffered because of the HPV shots. Please put a stop to the senseless suffering. I would give anything to go back in time and refuse those shots for my daughter.... her life would be so much different. 23652015-07-10T19:09:51.4879169Julie MooreMy daughter had cervarix vaccine back November 2009 before this date she was a healthy young girl as medical records will show, she now lives with chronic pain and a permanent headache. She frequently uses a wheelchair and walking stick. she has had to give up university and her dreams of becoming a lawyer. 23652015-07-10T19:12:19.8479170Neil DallimoreMy kids attend a Catholic school and their sex education is restricted (thus far) to a man and a woman God. My son won't hear how his life, his loves, his romance is equal or how any family he forms is normal. \r\n\r\nWe need this for true equality. Past equal marriage. Past dealing with the hate speech. We need this so our children learn true equality.23492015-07-10T19:13:48.6479171fiona mackenzieMy daughter now almost 16 has had 1.5 years of ill health since her vaccine. She missed 1 year of school and still doesn't attend a full week often. She has lost all reflexes, has off and on chronic sternum pain, dizzy spells, low blood pressure, nausea, chronic sleeping problems, along with other symptoms. I could go on and on all day. However what is most clear is the effect this has had on her life. 23652015-07-10T20:58:27.699172Sandy LunoeQualification as a pharmacist (in Edinburgh) provided me with a sound basis for further studying of pharmaceutical products. For the last decade my special interest has been vaccines. There are so many interesting aspects involved including technical aspects in connection with manufacturing, pharmacological, immunological and hormonal issues, contraindications, adverse reactions, interactions, synergistic toxicity and more.\r\nVaccines are extremely interesting to study. However, the more I have learned about them the more often I conclude that the list of unanswered questions seems to grow even longer.\r\nHPV vaccines are certainly no exception, in fact it appears that there are even more unanswered questions than for many other vaccines.\r\n\r\nFor the sake of the many who have become ill after these vaccines, for all who question their safety and for the sake of potential recipients of these vaccines it is imperative that the questions be seriously addressed.\r\nI strongly support that there be a roundtable discussion between medical professionals and scientists from both sides of the debate to consider the safety of the vaccines. It will surely be fruitful for all and certainly for potential recipients of the vaccines. \r\n\r\n\r\n23652015-07-10T20:59:50.1439173lisa stanleymy daughter has been ill since having this injection, she has suffered since jan 2012,she has suffered with many problem from breathing problems and chronic pain and fatigue, she has dropped out of school and can not cope with day to day activities. this has turned a health young girl who loved life into a disabled child who is struggling to live. i support a meeting of scientists to meet at Edinburgh to investigate this - from both sides of the debate, this injection needs to be stopped.23652015-07-10T22:37:56.8639176Sue HillMy daughter had the HPV (cevarix) in 2012. Prior to this vaccination she never had time off school and was never ill. She was healthy happy young lady who enjoyed riding her horse everyday and was a bright student at school who was expected to get A's & A*'s in her GCSE's. Her health has steadily deteriorated to the point where she was unable to go to school for the 5 months prior to her exams. She has no social life and she cannot ride her horse due to her illness. I am disgusted that this has been allowed to happen to so many girls. Why isn't something being done to help our girls and stop possible damage to other girls and boys before it is too late! 23652015-07-10T22:53:53.4579177Janette RobbI strongly support this petition. \r\nI have read with increasing alarm, the stories of chronic illness triggered by this vaccine. One size does not fit all. Young lives are being destroyed by a vaccine whose efficacy is unproven. We must take heed of the actions of other countries which are listening to the cries for help from affected families. I sincerely hope Scotland can set an example of good practice and concern for our younger generation.23652015-07-11T00:32:43.7539178Tracie Toler MoormanThis vaccine wrecked my previously healthy child's life. It all began in 2012. We have fought hard to find the proper care to undo the neurological and autoimmune damage done. It's been a very long and arduous path and 3 years later, we still aren't whole. I firmly believe that there is a reason that certain people are predisposed for injury. Research into subpopulation of injured girls and boys is so important but to date, no one seems to care. Perhaps this will be the answer the parents of all the victims have been hoping for?23652015-07-11T02:51:38.19180Rosemary SpohnThere have been too many deaths and injuries from the HPV vaccine compared to the very small benefit it provides. There is no epidemic of cervical cancer in young women. This vaccine is unnecessary and dangerous. It is ruining young lives and needs to be pulled from the market. . 23652015-07-11T02:52:58.9739181Debra NicosiaMY daughter has been suffering from the gardasil vaccine for 8 years. She will be 30 this November no he started off with heart palpitations, memory loss, confusion, regressin, syncope, numbness, tingling, inability to walk, hyperthyroidism, hashimotos disease, lost her hearing, neuropathy and now has cancer. Papillary carcinoma which is very aggressive. She has been suffering and is disabled. Her life will never be the same. 23652015-07-11T03:33:05.5039182Jennifer M BalesterMy daughter was also injured by hpv vaccine23652015-07-11T05:06:22.869183Emily TarsellIn 2008, my previously healthy 21 yo daughter Christina died suddenly within 18 days of her 3rd injection of Gardasil, Experts have determined that she died from her Gardasil injections. The vaccine has caused deaths and devastation worldwide. Please protect your youth and have hearings to weigh the evidence as they have done in other countries. A fair hearing to protect the lives of your youth is critical. Thank you.23652015-07-11T07:40:34.19186martin colohanMy daughter got her Gardasil HPV vaccine on 22nd September 2014 and has been seriously ill since then .She is 14 and this vaccine has destroyed her quality of life and needs to be investigated!!.23652015-07-11T10:06:41.119189Margaret cameronMy granddaughter was a fit active 16 year old until she received the Cervarix vaccine. Five years later, she is registered disabled and has multiple health problems.23652015-07-11T12:42:23.479190Sheila LaBellDaugherty has been suffering for 8 years with numerous auto immune issues caused by the gardsil vaccine. Research is finally out there proving this. Protect your children from this. 23652015-07-11T12:45:20.3179191Catherine WeitbrechtI fully support this petition and I am looking forward to the results of the proposed round table talks on this Experimental vaccine. I sincerely hope that Scotland will pave the way for a full and open review of this vaccine. I am a member of Irish Vaccination Awareness and we have been campaigning for full information on this vaccine to be distributed to parents as well as asking our Immunisation Board here in Ireland to suspend this vaccine until a full review of its safety and efficacy is carried out. From our research into this vaccine according to the producers of this vaccine the risk of Serious Adverse Events in the two week period after administrating this vaccine was .08% . This is 800 girls per 100,000 the rate of cervical cancer is 9 per 100,000 23652015-07-11T13:35:02.9579192Bruce William ThompsonAny is too many but with HPV vaccines the numbers have become obscene and are very obvious to any who will open their eyes & minds.23652015-07-11T13:45:23.7679194Steve HinksOur daughter had an immediate adverse reaction to the Cervarix HPV vaccine in 2011 and has been severely disabled, suffered constant pain and missed 4 years of school. The NHS in England deny the vaccine causes serious side effects and only offer psychiatric treatment but also refer parents to Social Services and make wild untruthful accusations of Fabricated or Induced Illness (FII).23652015-07-11T14:35:00.419195Dominic O'HaraDundee Against Welfare Sanctions campaign is also calling for the Scottish Government to immediately cover the financial losses of welfare sanctions imposed on people claiming welfare. Stop hunger now. SNP Scottish Government put your money where your mouth is!23352015-07-11T15:28:21.669197Andrea HerlthI am the mother of a Gardasil injured 17 daughter. My daughter has been chronically ill since receiving the 2nd dose of Gardasil on Dec. 2, 2013. She has been unable to attend school since January, 2015, and the quality of her life and health has been greatly diminished due to the adverse reactions to the HPV Vaccine. I support the roundtable discussion at Edinburgh to consider the safety of the HPV vaccines in greater detail. This is critical to those who may receive the vaccine in the future also to those who are already experiencing life-altering adverse reactions post HPV vaccine. Thank you for your time and consideration.23652015-07-11T15:45:32.479198Richard DunnMy granddaughter has been diagnosed with ME and POTs, both arising immediately after she received the HPV vaccination. Before this she was perfectly healthy and physically very active.23652015-07-11T16:11:54.3139199Karen DanielsPeople should be warned about this injection .Poor Ellen has really suffered since.23652015-07-11T16:23:13.589200Monica Ballesterosour 14 year old daughter was severely affected in their health after receiving at his school the second dose of the HPV vaccines, it takes more than a year without being able to walk.23652015-07-11T16:57:01.229201Hilary ButlerThe problems with Gardasil and Cervarix are rampant throughout the world, entrapping so many trusting parents, whose biggest shock will come when the medical system shows totally callous disregard to both parents and children, leaving them wandering crying in the wilderness.\r\n\r\nSince the medical system is mostly in brutal denial at the problem, it's time for them to be held to account, and parents to be heard somewhere, where a door won't be slammed on their backside as they are labelled Munchausen's by proxy parents.\r\n\r\nHopefully, this meeting would be a start for UK parents to be taken seriously.23652015-07-11T17:45:57.1779203Monica Ballesterosour 14 year old daughter was severely affected in their health after receiving at his school the second dose of the HPV vaccines, it takes more than a year without being able to walk.\r\n23652015-07-11T18:12:46.89204Heidi ReeblePlease stop this madness, Denmark has a tv docu that showed all the pain this vaccine causes - with absolutely NO benefit whatsoever. !!!\r\n\r\n23652015-07-11T20:21:59.69206Loyola meirelesFortunately I learned about vaccine damage in 2004 when my second child suffered adverse reactions to vaccination, subsequently I researched the HPV vaccine when it was offered to my eldest daughter in 2013, there is not a single piece of published research that would convince me that the side effects of vaccine are worth the risk. People need to start critically analysing the risk of vaccine vs the risk of the disease. Unfortunately most people lead their chosen likes lambs to the slaughter, which I'm ashamed to admit I did also all those years ago.23652015-07-11T22:21:20.5039211Joanna SpaczynskaMy daughter had the gardasil vaccine September 2012. It has totally destroyed her life. My daughter has poor health, no schooling, no social life, no sport She is 16 years old. She sleep 15-16 hours and she still tired. 23652015-07-11T22:44:17.8179212Alicia CapillaMy daughter was seriously injured by Gardasil. She was four months in hospital and 42 days in Intensity Care Unit. After that she was on a wheel chair for six months. She was diagnosed with ataxia, hemiparesis due to a postvaccination illness. She had severe seizures, which doctors could not treat.\r\nSpanish Health Authorities did not help us at all. We have to pay the treatment of our daughter. Nowadays, we are asking Spanish Health Authorities to investigate the adverse reactions to find treatments for the injured people. \r\nOn behalf of the health of thousands of affected girls around the world a serious debate must be open to evaluate the benefit-risk of the HPV vaccines.\r\n23652015-07-11T23:13:56.229213Siobhan BerginThis vaccination knocked the stuffing out of my daughter who was a strong, healthy and resilient prior to vaccination . Her symptoms were immediate and intense and long lasting. I have another daughter who I refused to give the vaccination to because of my other daughters experience and I think that other parents need to know that there can be long term consequences and reactions to this vaccination.23652015-07-12T00:14:55.419214Kelly Morgan My 15 year old daughter had this vaccine two years ago now ,, since that horrible day my perfectly healthy daughter has been having uncontrolled seizures daily her grades at school have sufferd as her attendance is 57% ,, please donot let the blood of a young girl be on your hands thankyou23652015-07-12T00:25:29.0039216Bev PattendenSerious side effects caused by HPV vaccines are worldwide. Every nation needs to investigate for themselves and save their young people.\r\n 23652015-07-12T01:17:45.2079217Emma LewisMy daughter had the cervarix vaccine. About 6 months afterwards she had joint and muscle pain, low energy levels, dizziness nausea. Her school work suffered as did her self esteem. She hasxa diagnosis of fibromyalgia but our GPS and other medics refuse to admit the kink between the vaccine and her symptoms. We need answers and we need to stop this vaccine affecting any more of our children! !23652015-07-12T04:09:34.9439219Dr Sherri TenpennyIt is extremely important for the Parliament members of Scotland to be part of this discussion. You have not been told the truth. Save the children of your country from the travesty of this vaccine. Thank you.23652015-07-12T04:16:16.9579220Susan CroninMy daughter received the 3 Gardasil injections in 2007 and became very ill after the 3rd dose. Eventually she was diagnosed with having a very rare autoimmune disorder called Adult Onset Still's Disease. It has been almost 8 years since her vaccination and she is still suffering and she takes many medications to control her illness. I wish I had been less trusting and more cautious of the medical and scientific professions who decided that our daughters needed this vaccination. I didn't realise that our daughters were participating in something that is still experimental and not even necessary when you consider that our cervical cancer rates are quite low. This vaccine was supposed to lessen the morbidity and mortality rates from cervical cancer but instead the medical and scientific profession has now INCREASED the health burden on the country by INJURING all these young girls. Many of these girls will suffer this health burden for the rest of their lives. It will affect their future prospects of marriage, having children, their dream job, etc. Please investigate this vaccine, we need to be heard, not dismissed as anti vaccine radicals.23652015-07-12T04:53:42.4739221marlena CarrilloMy daughter has had serious reactions to Gardasil. This vaccine has effected her physically, emotionally, socially, & academically. She went from healthy and happy to chronically ill to the point she can not attend school regularly. 23652015-07-12T05:08:02.139222Mark SmythBrothers sisters unite.23492015-07-12T05:45:38.89224Chris WilliamsThis vaccine was never properly studied. We need to BAN the use of it before one more person is injured or killed by it! 23652015-07-12T05:59:54.4879225Donna ChapmanMy daughter has suffered since she had HOW. The school was informed that she was not to have it but they have it to her anyway. She had suffered strong abdominal pains. .. She describes as being stabbed. After many many tests and trips to emergency her pains are still unexplainable. This only happened after this vaccination took place. I'm hoping it has not destroyed her chances of carrying healthy children through to childbirth let alone other problems23652015-07-12T06:10:26.3139226tony coundThis is a crime against our children and grandchildren...this is urgent23652015-07-12T07:31:02.0039227Yvone ScoullerPlease invite representatives from both sides of the debate from Australia to attend23652015-07-12T08:42:05.7539228Deborah RosenI am an American citizen with no official capacity. My words may be unwelcome in a foreign government. Yet I feel I must share my experience with Gardasil: it was a mistake with possibly horrific consequences which I do not wish to see others suffer.\r\n\r\nI enlisted in the US military in 2009, shortly after the US approval of Gardasil, and the series was offered to me during my initial training. With no research, simply the blind trust and assurance of doctors, regulators and government all stating "it's safe," I accepted it voluntarily.\r\n\r\nWhen I arrived at boot camp, I had a clean pap smear. After the first two shots in the sequence, I left training with an "inconclusive" pap result to meet my unit and finish the last five months of deployment with them. While deployed, I received the third shot, finishing the series. Upon return from deployment, I was immediately informed that I was overdue for my pelvic exam. The pap results for this were abnormal - and precancerous. I was placed on immediate monitoring for cervical cancer - something no woman in my family has ever had.\r\n\r\nI have now lived in fear of for four years, and will continue to for the remainder of my life. The ultimate irony is that, if I do develop cancer, it may well be from my choice, based on incomplete information of the risks and and with no previous risk factors, to take a deliberate exposure to the virus said to cause cervical cancer.\r\n\r\nNo woman should have to live in this terror, nor should anyone risk injury by any vaccine without full information. I maintain that the denial of full information, including that of the real risk-to-benefit ratio of a vaccine and mortality and failure rates, constitutes nothing less than unethical medical experimentation of the sort banned internationally by the Geneva Conventions. \r\n\r\nPlease, do not allow your people to become unwitting victims of a medical establishment gone insane.23652015-07-12T10:05:08.0839229Grace Dasilva-HillIt can not coincidence or parents paranoia that so many female teenagers are suffering various syndromes and illnesses after receiving the HPV vaccine, for some even death. This needs to be investigated, so please consider this petition seriously. We owe it to our next generation. Thank you\r\n 23652015-07-12T10:42:04.7879230Frank PlunkettSocial issues cannot be met with mass vaccinations of very dubious quality......This only enriches the manufacturers of such things, and only serves to help society slip further down the slope.23652015-07-12T11:29:19.5639231Helen Kimball-BrookeI know of teenagers in France, Spain, the US and the UK whose lives have been destroyed by the HPV vaccine. Vaccine Injury courts in France have acknowledged the link between this damage and the vaccine in at least one case. Knowing that only an estimated 1-10% of such adverse effects are reported and a great many not acknowledged by the authorities, the number of cases must be substantially higher. This is tragic and must be investigated.23652015-07-12T11:47:04.3479232Penny HuxtableThe HPV vaccine is a complete lie, children are being injured left right and centre. My daughter Chronic fatigue and eczema. It has to stop and she was never promiscuous. This vaccine us not safe and a complete disgrace!23652015-07-12T11:58:22.8339233Rosemary MathisMy daughter was injured by the HPV Vaccine Gardasil. She missed her 8th grade year of school. We have met with the US FDA regarding this vaccine. The US Government owns the patent on the vaccine and will not pull it from the market and admit wrong doing as they will be partially responsible for approving it. It is a horrible experience to see a healthy young girl become disabled after receiving a vaccine. The vaccine is not necessary and should be pulled from the market until further research is performed and the parents of the thousands of girls injured across the globe voices are heard.23652015-07-12T12:39:05.89235Shannon IsaacMy poor daughter collasped and suffered from getting the HPV shot..she was taken to the ER and got asthma which she did NoT have proir to the vaccine23652015-07-12T13:20:17.5039237Laura priceMy daughter because unwell after the first dose of the HPV vaccine in 2011. Now more than 3 years later, she is still unwell and diagnosed with ME and undergoing testing for POTS. She has been doing part time education, limited social activity and lost a lot of friends. This vaccine is the worst decision I ever made in my life. 23652015-07-12T13:23:25.7679238Mary O SullivanSince receiving 3 Doses of Gardasil my daughter has on going health problems from headaches, eczema, fatigue, just a few of her symphtons.\r\nGardasil a total nightmare which has changed our lives and no support from doctors. 23652015-07-12T13:33:23.7679240Kirsty HunterMy daughter suffers from permanent nausea and regular bouts of severe dizziness and vomiting. This began after she received the HPV vaccine. I strongly feel that it has caused my daughters ill health and feel that a meeting with professionals to discuss issues that have been raised following vaccination, is essential.23652015-07-12T13:35:50.919241Anna AndersonHaving seen the devastating effects after this vaccination with several clients, a talk is the very least you can do for these families and young girls who have had their lives turned upside down. Please don't stick you head in the (financial) sand.23652015-07-12T14:09:45.6939243Elizabeth JenksA friend of mine's daughter developed PANDAS after HPV vaccination and has battled to control it ever since. What God has made let no man put assunder. RN- will never provide nor receive vaccines again as I have come to believe they are bio-weapons.23652015-07-12T14:55:24.9279244Michelle FisherIt has been three years and my daughters life has not been the same since the HPV vaccine. We need to stop this madness and prevent any future children from being injured and living a life of anguish.\r\n23652015-07-12T16:21:40.619245Eileen SinclairMy daughter is anaphalactic to latex I do not believe this vaccine should have been injected into my daughter.23652015-07-12T23:34:47.169248Andrea WestMy daughter suffered serious illness after taking her first Gardasil injection. She had severe anxiety with devastating panic attacks, lost 12 pounds in 8 days, had severe muscle spasms, and couldn't sleep. We had to take her out of school for half the year. Our doctor treated her for adreanal shut down and saved her life. She is recovering but still has frequent headaches. Please consider the risks of this drug23652015-07-13T04:13:13.4579249Sarah o NeillI strongly believe that both my daughters have had auto immune problems triggered by receiving Gardasil, this has had life changing problems for them both on weekly medication . Would not recommend this vaccination to anyone.\r\n23652015-07-13T08:22:10.199250Jenny RedJust one shot of this evil vaccine rendered me bedridden for 2 months and gave the nastiest headaches and muscle spasms I have ever experienced.23652015-07-13T08:52:32.8179251Debbie WashingtonMy Daughter had been given the cervarix vaccine without my knowledge, at school.. I found out she had the vaccine as she had a panic attack ( first of many) on New Year's Eve and we had to leave the party.. This was so unlike my daughter who was a very confident child. She has since suffered from bad unwanted thoughts, self harm, mania and now developed an eating disorder. My daughter is obviously not the worse case, but is effecting her life. I asked my daughter why she had the vaccine without informing me? She said " all my friends were having them so why not me" I would think gillick comitence is an absolute farce with young easily led teenagers. My daughter was not competent to read a leaflet she was given, let alone make such a vital decision about having a vaccine which has now been proved to be life threatening in some cases. \r\n23652015-07-13T09:09:47.2839252Dave McGuireSince the medical & scientific professional community are in agreement that Gardasil is safe and that in your statement you have included figures which are unsubstantiated (the alleged "deaths from Gardasil" have never been proven to have been associated with the vaccine and the numbers of adverse reactions are from reported events and not verified events) I would suggest that this petition is founded upon scientific illiteracy and paranoia. I would say good luck with it but I don't wish the anti-vaccine lunacy that is infecting North America to find its way over here. 23652015-07-13T09:19:37.2079253Jenny HeywoodThe HPV vaccine has never been tested against a real placebo. There is no high-level scientific evidence that it has prevented a single case of cervical cancer.23652015-07-13T10:03:05.8179254Catherine O'DriscollThis vaccine has nothing to do with the creation of health. Its benefits are not proven. Its side-effects are horrendous. The HPV vaccine was developed by the American government's NIH - is it concerned with eugenics?23652015-07-13T10:20:55.2879255Kathleen DuncanMy daughter was once a young heathy cheerleader. Beauty pageant queen, and a personal trainer. She loved life and was very active with a promising career ahead of her. She received the gardasil shot and her heath rapidly declined. She ended up in a wheelchair not able to walk for two years and her immune system was shot. She still cannot live a normal life. She can't drive, work, or live a normal life. She falls all of the time and it is all that she can do to get a shower and eat without being exhausted. She gets sick all of the time because her immune system is shot. Gardisil has ruined my daughters life. 23652015-07-13T11:07:59.7679258Frances LawrenceSince receiving the HPV vaccine my grand-daughter and her family have had two terrible years because of her physical and mental disabilities. She is no longer the happy, care-free girl she once was and can only attend part-time schooling. She cannot be left on her own and suffers panic attacks.23652015-07-13T13:12:43.669259Irene BoldtOur 13 years old daughter was a healthy girl 1,5 years ago. She is extremely tired all day. Lying in bed most of the day. She is rarely in school, doesn't see any friends, her stomach does not work at all, she has a severe headache every day, she has constant pain in the abdomen, she is dizzy and experiencing weakness, her body shakes, she is cold all the time and many other symptoms23652015-07-13T15:18:59.8939260Melanie SparkesAs a RGN - nurse in general practice - I have never, nor will ever recommend this vaccine to anyone. The research ( or lack of it) in relation to safety, efficacy & relevance shows this vaccine should never have been approved to give to the public. It is unproven as a vaccine, and based on a very doubtful hypothesis that HPV causes cervical cancer - really ?! Stop this vaccine NOW. The only people that are benefitting from Gardasil & Cervarix are the vaccine makers - no one else.23652015-07-13T15:43:11.7879262Crystal ButlerMy daughter has been ill for nearly 2 years due to gardasil. She had one dose and has been suffering from many different symptoms too many to list. Her worst symptom is paralysis she has been diagnosed with periodic paralysis and her body becomes paralyzed at random times of the day happening 1-3 times daily and lasting anywhere from a half an hour to 3 hours. Please stop this vaccine so others do not have to go through what our families and so many other families have to go through...23652015-07-13T17:56:01.8979264doug gibbIt is shameful that the snp choose to use Scots misery for their own political ends when they have the power to raise taxes and could end austerity tomorrow.23352015-07-13T20:09:47.9579267Lucija TomljenovicThere is ZERO evidence that the HPV vaccine can actually prevent cervical cancer. On the other hand, we have good evidence that this vaccine can trigger death and disabling autoimmune diseases in some individuals\r\nIn view of the above, the 2nd question that needs to be asked is whether the HPV vaccine is better and safer than already existing methods for treating and preventing cervical cancer? The answer is NO. Again, mainly because there is no proof of long-term clinical benefit, plus the fact that unlike the HPV vaccine, Pap smear and electrosurgical excision procedures used to remove pre-cancerous lesions, do not carry the risk of death nor disabling autoimmune diseases.\r\nThirdly, even if proven effective against actual cervical cancer cases, the HPV vaccines will not decrease the incidence of cervical cancer beyond what has already been achieved via Pap screening programs. \r\nBottom line: estimating benefits versus risks in the case of HPV vaccination is a matter of common sense. There are no proven long-term benefits, the vaccine is not better than existing methods of preventing cancer, while it carries the risks which these other methods don't. \r\nWhy continue exposing healthy girls to unnecessary risks?\r\nLucija Tomljenovic, PhD\r\n23652015-07-13T20:51:15.7539268Fiona SinclairScottish Government policy permits professionals to bypass parental permission and leaves children open to pressure from those with vested interests in vaccination. Children of 12 should not be taking such important decisions on their health - they are open to manipulation and have neither the maturity nor knowledge to make decisions like this without the guidance of their parents. All medical procedures will adversely affect a proportion of the population and informed consent is crucial to upholding human rights.23652015-07-14T10:23:28.669271Sarah HarrisonSo many young girls are suffering as a result of this vaccine and most of them probably don't even know that this is the cause of their health issues. I feel there are probably thousands more teenagers out there that havn't even been diagnosed. My teenage daughter has suffered considerably as a result of this vaccine and we have been fortunate enough to find help in order to improve her health. This vaccine must be banned before it ruins thousands more innocent healthy lives.23652015-07-14T10:39:14.9579272Emily Berry My cousin was a young fit healthy active young girl and has now been effected by this horrible vaccine. \r\nShe is now on the reliability of crutches and a wheelchair. I urge people not to have this vaccine. 23652015-07-14T10:59:20.419273Nicola Watson My daughters has constant muscle pains, joints locking, nausea and severe headaches for last 3 years ! No or little education diagnosed with CFS and undergoing tests for POTS and Fibromyalgia all this since having vaccine.23652015-07-14T15:53:50.499276Monica BallesterosI am the mother of one of the affected Colombia in Bogota damage the health of the girl of 14 years after the second dose of HPV vaccine is now unable to walk after eighteen months of suffering is present.23652015-07-14T16:53:17.4439277Carol MappThis is definitely a problem that requires medical and scientific research on the various symptoms, problems, and disease protocols. The damage and responses have been overwhelming. Please lead the way to help these patients and future patients.23652015-07-14T17:49:58.169278Bruce SutherlandFoodbanks are a symptomatic of a failed Welfare system which under this Tory govt has been changed and cut for the worse. I agree that SGovt should in short term do something help these people who have fallen through the widening cracks in the system. Every Scots priority should be to campaign for Scotland to be given its own Welfare powers to make changes for the better, direct funding Foodbanks is in the long term unsustainable. There should be no need for Foodbanks at all. I want to campaign for that. 23352015-07-14T18:12:08.8179279Christina Berry-McIntoshOur daughter Ellen swam at county level but since having the HPV vaccine she finds it difficult to just get into a pool.\r\nShe has just been diagnosed with Pots.\r\nHer teenage years have been taken away from her.23652015-07-14T20:47:36.0039281Kim RobinsonOur previously healthy and vibrant 11 year old daughter received one jab of Gardasil on September 2 2010. Within days she complained of fatigue headaches abdominal pain and nausea. Soon her symptoms began exploding and involved most systems in her body including neurological nervous system joints eyes ears adrenals and thyroid to name a few. The vaccine injured her immune system and she suffered from multiple active infections and viruses that were chronic for years and did not respond to normal treatments. She has been unable to attend school since April 2011. The pain levels were horrendous and she spend most of her time in bed trying to cope with the pain and other debilitating symptoms. Doctors were unable to diagnose a vaccine injury despite the fact that her symptoms matched those reported by the vaccine manufacturer as adverse reactions and started within days of receiving the vaccine in a previously healthy child. She was bounced to many specialists and the multiple ER visits were useless. No one could help her yet every doctor was adamant that Gardasil was not responsible. My daughter was left to linger in pain living the life of an elderly sick person instead of a vibrant child and teenager she should be. Without proper treatment, she began developing multiple autoimmune diseases. There are so many like her throughout the world. It is truly a worldwide problem affecting too many children, girls and boys. Please convene a roundtable discussion on the safety of HPV vaccines with medical and scientific professionals from both sides of the debate to truly investigate if HPV vaccines are truly safe for our youth.23652015-07-15T06:57:47.2879282Gordon MckieIf the legislation is in place why not enforce it simple23332015-07-15T07:14:03.0679283Tarah GramzaMy daughter received Gardasil and has been diagnosed with Anti phospholipid disorder after her platelets all but disappeared. All other labs showed a reaction to something and all she had was the vaccine. Now she has horrible headaches and a lifetime of issues related tonAPS. Please don't let other girls get this awful vaccine. Please test it better. 23652015-07-15T07:25:47.39284Anne McKayMy daughter, who was bright and sporty has suffered with POTS symptoms since she received the Gardasil vaccine in November 2014. It is a life changer, affecting her health, her social life and her schooling. This vaccine has affected too many lives - an investigation is urgently needed.23652015-07-15T07:26:50.1479285Dr Renate KleinThe HPV vaccines have brought so much misery to so many families around the globe that they need urgent attention. I commend the Scottish Government to investigate these unnecessary and dangerous vaccines.23652015-07-15T07:57:57.0379286Jennifer AllanTo enlarge on Dave McGuire's comment:-\r\n"The medical & scientific professional community are in agreement that Gardasil is safe and that in your statement you have included figures which are unsubstantiated ."\r\nPerhaps Mr McGuire should have pointed out "the medical & scientific professional community" are NOT all in agreement about the safety of HPV vaccines, but of course, those persons who are employed by or sponsored by the hugely profitable vaccine manufacturers, are naturally 'in favour ' of protecting their livelihoods and profits.\r\nAs for the "anti-vaccine lunacy' in the United States. Some persons might regard the recent passed and proposed legislations to force EVERYONE children and adults to receive all vaccines, or risk criminal prosecution, to be 'pro-vaccine lunacy', against the 'human rights' laws to protect medical informed choices for ourselves and our children.\r\n\r\n23652015-07-15T09:19:36.1279287shana sterling My 19year old daughter passed away after receiving the hpv series gardasil. ..her immune system attack itself...july 15,2012 was the hardest day of our lives when we let our daughter go..23652015-07-15T10:23:37.2679288Susan AmitMy daughter has developed serious health issues which mean she cannot attend College and has just had to give her up her distance learning University course due to her inability to concentrate, please ensure no more girls suffer like our family has.23652015-07-15T11:20:04.4579289Cynthia bradburyMy granddaughter is extremely ill and has been since 20 minutes after vaccination 23652015-07-15T21:14:59.89291Annette Joyce HallMy daughter Billie Jo has been harmed by the Cervarix vaccine in 2011. I am so angry as she was such a healthy and happy young girl until she had the HPV vaccine. Now she is a very sick young girl and was not able to go to school. There is no one within our NHS who are able to help these young girls, they prefer to believe that these health issues are all in their head. My daughter does not have a mental health disorder but was harmed by the Cervarix vaccine. Please let this meeting take place in Edinburgh to discuss the safety of these vaccines and also to find a treatment protocol which will heal them all.23652015-07-15T21:21:50.1279292Magnus A. L. MullinerDear Sir or Madam, \r\nI often remind my clients, Why wait to become disabled, do something about it NOW.\r\nScience will always prove many sides to an argument and as always it depends on our present mindset or beLIEf and or values on a given topic. \r\nLet us discuss vaccinations overall - None or Zero have been proven to be 1. Safe and or 2. Effective. \r\nSo why are we still pushing them onto our babies and young?\r\nHave we lost our minds or are we still buying into BS - BeLIEf Systems promulgated by mainstream media, our dis-ease management system and or governments?\r\nIf you do just a little due diligence on any vaccine I highly recommend Dr Suzanne Humphries, Dissolving Illusions, you'll discover how we the public have been mis-led and mis-fed fictitious, false, manipulated, poorly researched statistics and lies about them.\r\nHere is a beautiful MOMENT to WAKE UP and STOP it right NOW please for the sake or our children, your children and so on.\r\nIt's a nice idea but when you go back to 1797 and Edward Jenner's findings you'll realise where we started to go wrong... and we're still doing it NOW.\r\nThank you for listening.\r\nA quick reminder that health, just like peace and happiness is an inside out job.\r\nLet us begin now.\r\nYours in health and in happiness\r\nMagnus Mulliner23652015-07-16T01:36:29.389293Ann BeckMy granddaughter has been badly effected by this vaccination. Before was a very fit girl excelled at sports but was transformed into a very sick individual.23652015-07-16T07:34:24.2079294Lauren MacCallum The more people know, the less they fear. 23492015-07-16T08:45:36.6279295Sherrel HallidayMy daughter was 13, bright, active and sporty until she had two Cervarix vaccines in Sep and Nov 2010. What followed immediately: headaches, dizziness, stiff arm, loss of pallor, swollen knees, dragging her leg, low blood sugar, muscle and joint pain, stiffness throughout her body severely affecting her mobility, sensitivity to light, screaming with pain, fatigue, sore throats, no strength, hip pain, hips clicking, unexplained shaking, no feeling in legs, sense of heaviness, loss of appetite, production of protein, urine infection, nose bleeds, mouth ulcers, feeling sick, stabbing pains in back, chest compression, multiple visits to A&E, keyhole surgery for appendicitis with peritonitis, infections, staggering, emotional, tingling sensation in face, spasms in legs, extreme exhaustion, couldn't stand on her own two feet, couldn't dress herself, couldn't feed herself. A week in hospital for intensive physiotherapy, regular physiotherapy and hydrotherapy sessions. Scans. Diagnosed with Arthralgia. Diagnosed with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome which she still has as at 16 July 2015.23652015-07-16T10:54:13.779298Linda AllenMore investigation must be made by the drug companies into the side effects of this vaccination.23652015-07-16T14:25:04.3939300Mark HamptonAs someone who has not only seen his neice's life utterly devasted by this so called vaccine, but also the terrible anguish of those who have lovingly but exhaustedly supported her 24 hours a day...... for nearly 7 years! I can only hope that sense prevails and the horror this substance inflicts, finally comes to an end. \r\n\r\nIf it takes sitting around a table in Edinburgh to make this happen then perhaps, finally, the old adage (and the pro HPV mantra) 'that you can't make an omelette without a few eggs being broken' will no longer form part of their rationale (warped excuse).\r\n\r\nThe ratio of 2,500 young people being affected, out of every 100,000 injected, is both immoral and inhumane. \r\n\r\nIt needs to be stopped. 23652015-07-16T14:39:08.4239301Nicola BenderMy daughter since having the HPV vaccine has been suffering with pain, numbness, giddyness, severe migranes and headaches, stabbing pains in stomache, legs neck breathlessness, fatigue, pain in chest. Our doctors have put this down to Chronic Migranes however we now believe these symptoms on a perfectly healthy girl have happened since the three vaccine injections. However we were unable to link the symptoms to any event until the recent media coverage of a possible link with the vaccine and they relate to her.23652015-07-16T16:19:23.169302Lia CostaI hope with all my heart that Edinburgh will become the centre of excellence for this scientific meeting to discuss the safety of the HPV vaccines. My daughter Lara was harmed in 2009 by the Cervarix vaccine and is only now starting to be better by homeopathic treatment. Please do not shut your eyes to the harm that is being caused to many teenagers around the world. Let Edinburgh hold this meeting please.23652015-07-16T16:26:48.7539303Lara CostaI was harmed by the Cervarix vaccine and would not wish anyone to suffer the way I did. Like many other girls I lost a lot of education. Someone has to recognise that there is a serious problem and before any more teenagers are harmed please hold this special scientific meeting at Edinburgh to discuss the safety of the HPV vaccines.23652015-07-16T20:23:33.8339305Dawn PainterThis must be looked into -it is close to my heart as my gorgeous 17 yr old Niece has been affected by this drug - \r\n drug companies have a lot to answer for - 23652015-07-16T20:58:35.029306Pete McElroyIt is a scandal that the policies of the Westminster Government have made food banks a necessity and it will only get worse when the measures in the budget take effect. The Scottish Government should do all in its powers to protect the poor against Tory policies designed to protect the wealthy and attack those without. Welfare should be devolved to Holyrood.23352015-07-16T22:11:57.749307Kristin ClulowIn 2008, I received 2 of the 3 doses of the Gardasil vaccination. I suffered a severe adverse reaction, and almost died. I still experience the side effects of this daily, although am grateful to be alive. It is time that someone investigated this vaccine before it harms countless other young people.23652015-07-17T12:12:18.589308Danielle GregoryI have been privileged to meet Kristin and watch her move with guts and dignity through her vaccine damage. Please protect your citizens by objective investigation of these interventions. 23652015-07-17T12:38:02.8939310Heather LinesI know, personally, of several girls in Australia, who have suffered permanent brain damage as a result of the vaccine.\r\n23652015-07-17T13:59:23.1479311Jodi RobertsonMy friend Kristin almost died because of an adverse reaction to this vaccine. I had the vaccine before she was affected. I still vaccinate my children but I will not encourage them to have the HPV vaccine until the makers take responsibility for the adverse reactions & make changes & do proper clinical trials to ensure the safety of the vaccine.23652015-07-18T08:30:18.5839313Laura colebournmy daughter started having seizures after this vaccine, and was shortly afterdiagnosed with epilepsy.23652015-07-18T08:51:27.7539314Iain LeeHow many vaccines have gone throught a double-blinded, placebo controlled trial ? How are vaccine manufacturers not liable for causing vaccine damage ? Pharmaceutical companies are in the business of maximising profits, NOT curing disease.23652015-07-18T10:07:30.8939315Karen WeatherheadMy daughter was aged 13 when injured by cervarix, she went to school on the day of the 1st jab her usual energetic self, she came she'll of herself and in so much pain. In brief sport was Rosie's life, she represented sutton twice in the London youth games winning gold and silver in swimming, Rosie played in premier league football , played Sunday league netball, and represented her school in just about every sport she could. That all changed that day, we had to push her around in a wheelchair. Rosie is turning 20 this year and still suffers daily, please somebody listen to her plight and of all the other injured teens.23652015-07-18T12:33:33.6139316Gretchen Heather ThompsonMy son has lived with a horrible Hpv vaccination injury since 201123652015-07-18T15:00:48.919318Jenny ScottMy 13 year old daughter was effected April 2014 after her second shot. I once had a very healthy active daughter. Now she lives with constant pain. I just don't know where to start the side effects to this vaccine has been horrendous. It all started with head pain constant headache,extreme fatigue, sore eyes, vomiting, severe abdominal pain, where for 3 months couldn't lay down to go to sleep was sleeping upright on couch, 20 silent seizures, dizziness, & then her legs starting collapsing underneath her & was dropping items, we have a long list of Doctor visits to no avail & now gone down holistic route. More recently we have a diagnosis of Lyme & co infection so back seeing another Doctor that apparently lay dormant & once Gardasil is given it triggers it. This is just a brief description so many more symptoms. She has missed a lot of school & now we are homeschooling. This vaccine is horrendous pointless & poisonous. I feel I wasn't informed enough & I can only hope this will be removed from the market its destroying so many families & is a huge financial burden. I only hope one day my daughter recovers fully...23652015-07-18T15:46:08.869319Nicole VanderbeekI experienced serious adverse reactions to my first and only HPv vaccine in 2011 at 23 years old. My adverse reactions bargain two days after the vaccine, I was bedridden with terrible pain and flu like symptoms which only worsened as time went on. I have spent the past four years working to heal my body, relying on my mother and husband for full support. This vaccine has changed my health and life forever and not because it has protected me. I live in chronic pain every moment of my life, with continuous health fluctuations although I am grateful for the progress I have worked hard to make. It has cost us thousands and thousands of dollars out of pocket and I hope and pray you take our please serious. This vaccine is so dangerous and deadly and the serious health side effects it is creating on our population will not be able to be undone.\r\nPlease further your discussion and seek those who have experience injury first hand to tell you what can happen. Thank you.\r\nNicole Vanderbeek23652015-07-18T16:16:39.369321Kerrie standing This vaccine needs to be withdrawn with immediate effect my daughter has had her life ruined by this vaccine and we must pull together to stop what we've suffered happening to other innocent children23652015-07-18T20:52:47.279323Amanda EmbreyI would dearly hope this meeting could take place to raise the awareness needed to recognise what terrible damage the HPV vaccination has done to huge numbers of girls all over the world. My daughter has been severely ill since receiving it. Previously healthy. She has been diagnosed with chronic fatigue syndrome, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome and vaso vagal syncope and is in pain for a high percentage of the time and suffers headaches and migraines. She is housebound unless another adult is with her but most of the time the multiple conditions render her unable to go out anyway. She 20 yrs old and has been like this since she was 15 following the vaccination. We are desperate to find a treatment to assist her to lead a somewhere near normal life. 23652015-07-19T04:09:39.169324Tabatha SwensonMy daughter was injured from this vaccine. Watching your child sick, unable to function like a normal child, and cry because she is sick and hurt is the worst thing ever. All this happened after she received this vaccine. It needs to be gone...for the safety of others. 23652015-07-19T12:40:53.5979325Deborah R ClarkThe damage caused by this vaccine is real, the benefits speculative. Please safeguard your citizens from unnecessary this harm.23652015-07-19T18:09:05.0179327Kiva MurphyThis Vaccination is pure evil and poison it has destroyed my daughters life......!!23652015-07-19T20:38:47.1779328Ann Elizabeth Carlisleit should not need a petition of the Scottish Parliament to carry out something so needed if they used common sense. Get your fingers out and do this request Asaph.23662015-07-20T21:31:59.139333Linda HainingPlease allow this discussion to take place in Edinburgh. Our daughter Laura's health problems commenced after the Cervarix vaccine. She has suffered severe prolonged headaches and muscle twitches with chronic fatigue and pain in her joints and muscles. She has skin problems and numbness and tingling in her fingers. Laura's memory and ability to think and concentrate has been affected. She became to ill to complete her university course and had to give up work and driving her car. She has been housebound for almost two years and has suffered bouts of depression. This has been devastating as we cannot prevent the loneliness and loss of friendship and social experiences caused by her dreadful illness. 23652015-07-20T21:56:38.5179336Cheryl Cavemy daughter was one of the first girls vacinated with this poison nearly 7 years ago, she still to this day has to take a concoction of 5 pain killers\r\njust to get her through the day,how many more girls have to suffer before something is done? 23652015-07-20T22:36:36.059337Anne LawlorI know I am not a Scottish citizen but hope Ireland may follow if this petition is successful. best of luck23652015-07-21T01:10:04.3979338Manfred BrownIn addittion to the high number of serious adverse events following HPV vaccination, independent science even raise fertility concerns. Gambling with future generations health and ability to reproduce, how can this not be a matter of national security?23652015-07-21T02:43:57.3979339Irene GiffWhy is this being allowed to go on? How much more proof do you want!!23652015-07-21T07:00:19.699341Nina bartonTotally against this vaccine - the girls that suffer say it all23652015-07-21T08:18:28.3939342Wendy ZiinoI am against the use of this vaccine as I have watched a friends daughter suffer from the side effects!!!!23652015-07-21T19:32:55.139345Kev Hill My daughter has been ill ever since having this vaccine. The safety of this vaccine needs to be checked to stop further girls & boys getting injured.\r\n23652015-07-21T19:52:19.5039346Frances JonesHope this petition is a success. A lot needs fixing in Scotland with rail travel . We have a perfectly good station but hardly any trains especially on a Sunday. Two carriages appear on a Saturday when young folk are queuing up to go to Glasgow terrible!!23662015-07-21T21:05:44.369348Marion DewI am shocked to discover this vaccine is causing so many illnesses in young girls. It has to stop23652015-07-21T21:48:03.89349Karen fowlerim against this vaccine as ive watched my daughter suffer for the last two years since she has had it 23652015-07-21T21:54:18.7839350Gayle Dickson Please take this seriously. Our future generation are being harmed, perhaps irreparably!! My daughter had suffered for five long years and there's still no end in sight! 23652015-07-21T22:05:28.6739352Jo ReadEvery single case of a sick girl post vax should be followed up. We need to set up clinics for this like they have done in Denmark23652015-07-22T02:16:40.639354Becky GoinsThe Gardasil HPV vaccine injured my daughter. She has been sick for 4 years.23652015-07-22T09:57:30.1739355David BirrellAccording to Cancer Research UK 2008 there were just under 1000 deaths per year due to Cervical Cancer. This works out at just under 3 cases per 100,000. Half of those deaths were in ages over the age of 65, and half of those were over the age of 80, sad as these results are. \r\nThere are around 3000 new cases of cervical cancer per year, so this is around 9 cases per 100,000.\r\nPap screening could prevent much of the above cases without there being any serious adverse reactions.\r\nFor the first time, Merck has disclosed what may indeed be close to the true rate of serious adverse events young people are suffering after the use of Gardasil and will probably continue to suffer if they consent to using Gardasil 9. According to the Gardasil 9 package insert, the following percentage of serious adverse events were collected during follow-up, up to 48 months identifying the new Gardasil 9 vaccine at 2.3 per cent and the Gardasil vaccine at 2.5 per cent of serious side effects which is 2,300 cases per 100,000 against 2,500 cases per 100,000 for the Gardasil vaccine in use today. \r\nAccording to the FDA a serious side effect must fit one of the following criteria: death, life-threatening, hospitalization, disability or permanent damage, congenital abnormality and birth defect, or the requirement to intervene to prevent permanent impairment.\r\nIs this data real or am I missing something that makes this vaccine benefits outweigh the risks.23652015-07-22T15:05:54.6939356Toshie, IKEDAI am the Secretary General of the network for HPVV (Cervical cancer Vaccine) injured people in Japan. The number of the victims registered is about 400 since the network started in 2013 (3.25).23652015-07-22T15:29:54.4579358Teresa Robinson The HPV vaccine has devastated my daughters life. We have been living in this hell for close to 3 years. She has went from active carefree teenager to living with chronic pain Lyme disease and neurological issues and wheelchair bound for a year. This has stolen precious years from her she\r\nCan never get back!! It is devastating mentally emotionally and financially. 23652015-07-22T16:37:18.949359Kelda WhiteStatistically the risks from this vaccine outweigh any potential benefit. 23652015-07-22T17:57:43.1279360Richard mooreOur daughter was injured by the cervarix vaccine she had in 2009 to this day she is still suffering with chronic headache, pain all over her body, sickness, feeling dizzy, anxiety and the list goes on before this vaccine she had nothing wrong with her as doctors notes will prove. We are not anti vaccine but please do your research before allowing your daughter to have the HPV vaccine.23652015-07-22T20:40:07.5379361Anne McAllisterWell said Doug Gibb x23352015-07-22T21:26:17.559362jane clay For a dear friend and her brave daughter 23652015-07-22T21:58:21.1439363Wendy BloomfieldMy daughter has been unwell since she was 13 she is now 19, these should have been the best years of her life, but since the Cervarix vaccine her life has been miserable. Please consider what this vaccine is doing to these young lives, something needs to be done and soon.23652015-07-22T22:15:53.389364Liesje CochranePlease take this seriously, these are our children we need to protect them NOT harm them,23652015-07-23T01:19:37.2539365Beth MorrisonMy daughter was given the HPV vaccine along with other girls from her year in 2009. A handful of these girls became ill with flu-like symptoms within weeks. It was totally debilitating. At the time, my daughter was in peak physical condition and at a vocational dance school dancing around 20 hours a week. She became so ill, she could barely get out of bed in the morning. She missed so much school, she dropped out of some of her highers. Doctors said it was post viral fatigue. Her friend who had the same batch of vaccine was in a similar state. With great difficulty my daughter battled to keep dancing and studying, she forced herself to get out of bed and was on a reduced timetable for many months. The other girl stayed at home on doctors advice and within the year dropped out of school. I would honestly say that for some 2 years, my daughter struggled with extreme fatigue. Even now, some 5 years later, she still has less stamina than she used to have. I am convinced this was as a result of the HPV vaccine I thought I was doing the best thing having her vaccinated for her own protection Her dancing career was affected very badly as she now has painful joints and has severe knee problems I am happy to be contacted for further info23652015-07-23T21:22:42.2679368Sophia Sadler I have become severely ill due to this vaccine. From being very active and working a lot to being bedbound23652015-07-23T21:34:07.919369Patricia WhiteMy daughter was given the HPV vaccine 2009 - 2010. I used to call her my 80 yr old little lady as she was in so much pain. She became quite forgetful of everyday small things. She could not explain why. She was tested for glandular fever in November 2010. Test came back negative. Now she is still in pain and forgetful. She has verbally been diagnosed with Idiopathic Hypersomnia. Extensive tests have been carried out and have now been analysed. She is waiting for an appointment to see her specialist to discuss the results. She has reminder lists and diaries for everything. She struggles with exhaustion and pain. She can sleep 22 hours a day. She takes medication to help keep her awake. Since she was 9, she wanted to join the RAF. On her 13th birthday, she said 'I can join the air cadets now". She is still with them now. The HPV vaccine has robbed her the chance to ever join the RAF. PLEASE someone do something to stop this happening to our children.23652015-07-23T23:41:11.2839370Lynn ChildsHPV vaccine needs not only to be scientifically and seriously questioned, but needs to be eradicated off the planet. The Vaccine only caters for one strain of the virus, which is not the main virus that creates cervical cancer. If any vaccine damages only one person, there is absolutely NO excuse that that one person should be damaged or killed for life for the 'good of others'. And 'for the good of others', there is no way telling the horrible effects this vaccine will have later on in their lives - like miscarriage or getting cervical cancer down the track. The untold permanent damage and death among young girls from this vaccine around the world speaks for it self. Stop using human beings as guinea pigs. What the drugs companies are doing is a criminal act and should be jailed.23652015-07-24T22:13:03.669371Jane SmithIt is not until you start to look at the side effects of this vaccine and the amount of reports, evidence, comments from parents, desperation about debilitating illness and even reports of mortality that this whole issue surrounding Gardasil that serious alarm bells start to ring.\r\nSurely there must be enough evidence for a Public Enquiry at the very least.\r\nWe are uncomfortable questioning the Medical profession and then ultimately the pharmaceutical industry. It is far easier to accept that they have nothing but our interests at heart. The doctors themselves are convinced, as are the whole educational systems. Schools, clinics, governments and countries, that for world health, immunizations are paramount. ANY side effects are justified for the greater protection. But the whole immunization issue has to be addressed, surely! \r\n Important questions have got to be asked.\r\nIs this Gardasil immunization effective, this is apparently not conclusive. This seems ridiculous.\r\n The aluminium adjuvant used causes massive side effects. Are the public aware. Autoimmune Inflammatory Syndrome, Acute Disseminated Encephalomyelitis, many auto immune diseases, seizures, gastric problems, Narcolepsy, links between autism, also cognitive function.\r\n The list goes on.\r\nAre the public aware of the financial payments to doctors practices for using Gardasil.\r\nReview immunizations, we do need them. Research an alternative to aluminium. Face up to the facts.\r\n\r\n23652015-07-24T22:53:58.359372kerry tremblewe have a right to choose to protect our children they do not belong to you and you need to remember this....23652015-07-25T04:39:29.2239373Elizabeth HartHow many children and their parents are being properly informed of the low risk of cancer associated with the HPV virus and the possibility of waning efficacy or type replacement with the use of HPV vaccines, and the implications this may have? It is my strong suspicion that in many instances legally valid consent is not being properly obtained before this medical intervention and that children and their parents are unaware that they are being used as guinea pigs for this still experimental vaccine product. The long term consequences of this vaccine product are as yet unknown.\r\nIn a recent media article about HPV vaccination and adverse events epidemiologist Dr Tom Jefferson, a global authority on vaccine trial evidence associated with The Cochrane Collaboration, says the HPV vaccine's benefits have been hyped and the harms hardly investigated. Dr Jefferson notes the reason for introducing vaccination against HPV was to prevent cancer but he says there is no clinical evidence to prove it will do that. He says we have to tread a very careful line, weighing the potential benefits and harms that a vaccine may cause. With HPV, the harms have not been properly studied.\r\nThe article notes Dr Jefferson is highly critical of the drug company funded clinical trial data that is used to justify the use of mass vaccination and adds that pharmaceutical companies may hide negative results deep in their trial data and hugely inflate the benefits. Dr Jefferson says it is extremely difficult to publish anything against HPV vaccination. Vaccines have become like a religion. They are not something you question. If you do, you are seen as being an anti vaccine extremist. The authorities do not want to hear side effect.\r\n\r\nReference: Just how safe is the cervical cancer jab? More and more families say their daughters suffered devastating side effects from the HPV vaccine and experts are worried too. UK Daily Mail, 3 June 2015.23652015-07-25T08:16:30.919374Steve HinksHow many children and their parents are being properly informed of the low risk of cancer associated with the HPV virus, and the possibility of waning efficacy or type-replacement with the use of HPV vaccines, and the implications this may have? It is my strong suspicion that in many instances legally valid consent is not being properly obtained before this medical intervention, and that children and their parents are unaware that they are being used as guinea pigs for this still experimental vaccine product. The long-term consequences of this vaccine product are as yet unknown. 23652015-07-25T12:52:07.8479375Julie JonesMy daughter was injured in 2008 by cervarix. She was diagnosed with anti-NMDA Receptor Encephalitis. She spent 8 weeks in hospital and 3 months in a brain injury rehab unit. She had a relapse last year and spent another 2 weeks in hospital. She suffers with fatigue, memory loss and epilepsy. This vaccine isn't going to win this battle as long as I have breath in my body23652015-07-25T16:16:15.3339376Margaret KellPlease listen to the people whose lives have been affected by this.23652015-07-25T16:37:49.949377Laura HainingCervarix vaccine resulted in having to give up my studies and part time job. I am also no longer able to be active as I used to be. Has had big impact on life 23652015-07-25T16:56:25.9739378Thomas CookHello Alex. Understand your frustration, but unless you get the UK government to change the PRM regulations, then Scotland can only make recommendations or make it part of the next franchise agreement like the scottish Saltire livery, but don't expect much as not all of the ScotRail fleet has the Saltire livery.\r\nScotRail only lease the trains and cannot make changes to the vehicles without the lessors agreement and only if they pay for it.23662015-07-26T10:25:12.999379Sharni DavisNy friends sister suffers and illness still to this day from this injection. Need to raise awareness!!23652015-07-27T12:01:38.5839380Akemi KobayashiSo many young women suffer from a bad health condition . And many teenagers are absent from school .The common factor with all these young people is the HPV vaccine.Cervarix vaccine is the murder vaccine .No more HPV vaccine . No more HPV injection.23652015-07-27T15:02:53.979381MRS JEAN MATHIESONThis not only devastates the lives of young girls but also their families. I've watched my lively active granddaughter become housebound and her parents not knowing where to get help from. so sad23652015-07-28T20:44:25.949382Jonathan Yaniv Ben AvrahamThis is the 21st Century. If we can't teach the future generations about the history of LGBTI+ rights, and equality struggles, we are failing them. In our society there are LGBTI+ people all around us, we don't hesitate to accept them as friends, partners, in our homes and even churches, synagogues etc... So why in our schools? We constantly talk about combatting issues about inequality or prejudice. Why can my friends and family not learn about safe sex, same-sex relationships, same-sex families and more? Why must they be deprived of what I only discovered later in life? Why must we neglect their growth in interpersonal and comunity development. Allow our future to be all inclusive. We can't stop homophobia if we don't teach people what it means to be part of the LGBTI+ community. We dream for a day where there is no LGBTI+ community but an all-inclusive-general community. People should not have to justify their sexual orientation and claim to one specific community when there should only be one. The way forward, the way to get to that all-inclusive-general community is by educating the future generations correctly and solidifying the fact that same-sex relationships are natural and perfectly healthy.23492015-07-28T23:19:36.869383Michel MercierMy daughter past after Gardasil. So many girls are sick in Quebec after Gardasil. Please do something about this.23652015-07-28T23:22:55.2679384Lisa EriczonI came home from work to find my daughter dead on my bathroom floor. She had her 3rd Gardasil vaccine 40 hours earlier. As her mother I know it was the vaccine that took her life. Her autopsy showed her cause of death as unknown.23652015-07-29T14:07:36.249385Denise MeltonI had a granddaughter that lost her life to Gardasil. She was 17 years old and had the third shot of Gardasil just two days before her mother came home from work and found her dead. This case has gone through the court system and the Vaccine Compensation Board settled before the judge could rule on the case. It was a sure case that she died from the vaccine. It is hard to imagine that this and other vaccines for the HPV virus are still on the market knowing the hundreds of our children that have died and those that have harmful adverse reactions and are living with new medical conditions after receiving the vaccine. \r\nPlease take into consideration the thousands of families that are living with the knowledge that a vaccine has caused irreparable damage to not just one member but all the family as a whole.23652015-07-29T15:07:34.089387Ryan McNaughtonThis campaign is a fantastic way forward! Having met with the guys launching and looking to run the campaign, it is clear that they have the ability to push this all the way through. I am proud to be a supporter and campaigner for his campaign. As a young person who has personally gone through a lot in my life and seen a lot in both my personal and professional career, I whole heartedly believe that a fair and fully inclusive education system is the only way forward in tackling inequality and showing young people that being LGBT is not something to be scared of or embarrassed of! Well done to everyone involved in this campaign! 23492015-07-29T23:33:21.4739388dave parkerWhile i don't disagree with vacciantions i do feel more information needs to be given to parents to increase the overall clarity of the process23652015-07-30T12:14:37.949389Sean QuinnGrowing up, I was deathly afraid of my sexuality. I knew there were gay and lesbian people, but I was still frightened of the reaction I'd get to coming out. I went to Catholic schools with pretty cursory sex education which was focussed on straight relationships.23492015-07-30T14:44:12.7079390David NairnFoodbanks are a disgrace to humanity!23352015-07-30T15:03:58.9739391Kiyoko KITAGAWANo way!!!23652015-07-30T16:50:07.589392Wendy CroftIt is not only handicapped and blind people who suffer, it is us who have all our faculties as well but those who cannot see or function properly need the most help. It is a basic necessity for all.23662015-07-30T23:13:56.8979394Sean ClayFor my niece and her on going battle 23652015-07-31T00:44:15.9239395Rhona l Hershel God bless those effected23652015-07-31T20:39:00.339396Maureen BivardWe are globally over vaccinating unnecessarily,and this sadly is a warning.Lets heed it.23652015-08-01T10:25:02.5639397Dian LomaxMy daughter had the first cervarix injection in October 2011. She became unwell but I just assumed it was a virus. She had the second injection a month later. With in two days she developed big open sores on her forehead and in her scalp and swollen glands. She developed fatigue, nose bleeds, hair loss, dizziness, tummy aches, feeling sick, weight loss because her appetite disappeared, food intolerances, heavy painful periods. The doctors told me the vaccine was fine and her symptoms were just a coincidence. She was finally diagnosed last year with chronic fatigue syndrome and ibs. She spends a lot of time asleep, she's missed a lot of school. She's poorly a lot. She can sleep up to 20 hours and still feel exhausted and unwell. The fatigue can get so bad she's unable to speak at times because it's too much effort.23652015-08-02T10:06:32.4439400John KayMore staff assistance necessary at most stations23662015-08-02T10:11:40.2839401Anika VassellWhy would you not want to discuss and investigate this? Our children are depending on you to make the right decision - quickly!\r\n23652015-08-02T21:42:18.449403Heather RotheryMy cousin's daughter has been badly affected by her vaccine which was Cervarix23652015-08-03T08:49:22.359405Bill HardmanHope the petition does well Alex. Hope we meet up soon. Miss your presence in meetings.\r\n23662015-08-03T14:45:24.059406Ann Glendinningsigned and shared23762015-08-03T20:46:04.3179407Derek HainingWe have had to watch the devastating effects the Cervarix vaccine has had on our daughter. She lives with chronic pains in her body and limbs, has muscle weakness, fatigue and memory problems. She has had to give up so much and our family life has completely changed. Please allow this discussion to take place to prevent the same happening to other families. 23652015-08-03T22:20:09.5839408Glen WhyteI think, its the best interests for people with the conditions, where it keeps them safe23762015-08-04T10:18:20.479409Sheila CozensIt is distressing to know that well-intentioned actions can cause harm. Well done to this group for taking action to raise awareness and draw all together such that vaccinations deemed as required can be checked for safety and the information passed on that all can make as fully informed a choice about whether to go with vaccination - or not.23652015-08-04T11:01:52.2879410Tom WightmanWe need to be able to keep our kids safe.23762015-08-04T11:13:29.1779411Catrina RoseThis could change so many lives for the better, its shocking this hasn't been changed before now!23762015-08-04T11:16:06.6479412Ian Tasker STUC Assistant SecretaryThe STUC Disabled Workers Committee believes more needs to be done to make Scotland's railways and other forms of public more accessible to disabled people. The Committee supports this petition as being an important step in the right direction toward the aim of more accessible public transport for all disabled people, ensuring travellers with visual impairments can travel safely and with dignity. 23662015-08-04T11:18:31.0839413Terry AndersonWe need to make travelling by rail more enjoyable for everyone - these measures proposed by Alex Scott would help.23662015-08-04T11:28:05.8339414Ann LandelsBeing in a car park with an Autistic child can be rather dangerous especially if you are struggling with shopping, a small space some distance away from the store and an unpredictable child.23762015-08-04T11:34:40.9579415Amanda smithTry living a day in their world and it'd be mandatory. 23762015-08-04T11:56:05.529416lyndsay taylorSigned and shared23762015-08-04T12:22:50.0039418Richard Palmer Msp should try a short period with an autistic child and they would get a better come on this when we need snp help the less privileged 23762015-08-04T15:49:47.669419louise mckenzieevery day is a constant battle with authorities. Just please make life a wee bit easier for us for once in your lives. Mp's continually kick down the very people who elected them into power. its all take and no giving back.23762015-08-04T16:42:41.779420Beth MorrisonMany children who have complex needs but are mobile are "virtually unable to walk" because they are unable to go anywhere alone reliably, safely or in reasonable time. Some children simply sit on the ground and refuse to move and some have major sensory or behavioural challenges which make using public transport extremely difficult. It is unfair that these kiddies are being denied access to the higher rate of mobility which in turn means they lose their blue badge. I hope this petition is successful.23762015-08-04T17:28:40.9579424Erina SonodaI've suffered from harmful side effects by the HPV vaccine which is Cervarix.\r\nIt's so painful for me and my family.\r\nMy mother is crying every day.23652015-08-04T17:55:36.3639425Frances StedmanSigned and shared23762015-08-04T18:40:44.6139426tony thainPlease recognise them23762015-08-04T18:51:01.3179427Jan KerrThis is ABSOLUTELY essential. Life is difficult enough! 23762015-08-04T18:53:27.4879428Ian Macleod My son has no awareness of cars or traffic. Parking somewhere safer is a necessity. 23762015-08-04T19:59:47.889429Janis CuthbertSigned and shared 23762015-08-04T20:39:30.249432Terri Robertson Signed 23762015-08-04T20:45:14.249433margaret oconnorParents that have children with autism downs syndrome should get a blue badge automatically as you would if it was an adult 23762015-08-04T22:08:22.7379434krysia mulvihillMy child is in this category of disability. He is liable to run off into the road and has no sense of danger. He needs space around the car as he will bang the door into adjacent cars.23762015-08-04T22:29:05.7839435Lorna GrayI have a granddaughter with autism along with mobility problems. She needs a blue badge to allow her to get as close as possible to where she needs to go. She uses a wheelchair and is only 5. Children deserve the blue badge just as much as adults. Please consider this. 23762015-08-04T23:00:16.139436Shirley Anderson I have 3 children with autism a blue badge would make our lives so much more easier 23762015-08-04T23:08:53.279437Angela porterMy son was refused blue badge as he doesn't get high mobility, ye has hyper mobility in all his joints which cause him pain and to tire very easily. 23762015-08-04T23:41:12.9239438Judy WilymanThis vaccine has not been proven safe, effective or necessary in preventing cervical cancer and its many side-effects far outweigh its use because pap screening with surgery has proven to be an effective (almost 100%) prevention for this disease. Inappropriate surrogates that have been used in the clinical trials to make claims about the efficacy of this vaccine. This vaccine is not cost-effective and it is causing significant illness in the population. 23652015-08-05T00:10:03.9279439ellie christieexhausted parent with 5yrs old son who refuses to walk has autisum crys that his legs are always sore23762015-08-05T02:26:08.4279440Amanda McDougall A child having an autistic meltdown brought on by sensory overload is at that mention I'm time crippled by the experience 23762015-08-05T07:39:47.419441Margaret wardrope Why take away something so simple that can make a big difference to how children are treated\r\n23762015-08-05T10:03:42.6139443Janette DochertyIts not a matter of age its a matter of safety 23762015-08-05T10:24:59.9579444Anne Marie Lynas My daughter is Autistic and this would be a great help as car parks are a scary place for us both!23762015-08-05T11:53:58.7079445Lorna jenkinsI defiantly think all these children deserve a blue badge as I struggle with my nephew who is 8 with Down syndrome and feel a blue badge would help him greatly23762015-08-05T11:58:58.059446Margaret mccannMy grandson is autistic and a blue badge would make a big difference 23762015-08-05T12:12:40.389447Ray mcannWhat a difference this would make for my autistic grandson 23762015-08-05T12:30:59.5679448Elizabeth McDonald As a parent of a teenager with autism ADHD and a and a significant learning disability , just because his mobility isn't affected doesn't mean he is safe to walk any distance ,educate yourselves instead of pen pushing !!!! 23762015-08-05T12:58:21.359449Lynne farnanKeep blue badges23762015-08-05T13:03:01.1779450Samantha jones We should have the same law as everyone else instead of taking away from children who need this 23762015-08-05T13:54:17.499451Gillian Gartshore I'm a single mum to a 9 year old with ASD. Parking and walking the distance to a shop can be awful, he runs, and also drops to the ground. A blue badge would help and take the fear away from my son and myself. 23762015-08-05T14:00:16.669452Laura coplandMy son has autism and we have just been refused a blue badge. Little thing can make our life easier and safer.23762015-08-05T14:26:50.7679453Lorraine MarshallMy son has autism and getting him from building to car can be hectic, frantic and dangerous as he panics or can be overwhelmed and wants to run, he is strong and impatient. 23762015-08-05T15:57:54.3979456Lisa mcareaveyWould be so much easier for outings as they are the most stressful times23762015-08-05T16:50:30.9879457Jan nobleThe car is my safe place. If my 3 yo kicks off, or throws himself on the floor, or slips my restraint I am scared what might happen. I am therefore restricted to going out with my husband to help me keep him safe. Please allow us to park closer so when he explodes I can keep him safe and retreat to a safe place without having to crosss a busy car park too. It's not pretty, its not dignified, it's not right. If he was a pensioner with bouts of collapsing in roads or anywhere we'd have a blue badge .23762015-08-05T17:28:56.139458rab houstonwhy has this not been done already ?23762015-08-05T17:32:33.4239459justin Bradley Terrible 23652015-08-05T17:40:26.3639460Elaine mcdonaldI have three children 1yr, 4yr and 7yr old the two oldest have high function autism. Not the easiest of tasks to go out doors. And struggle every day worring of all three of their safetys. Being calm and listening at anytime are things my kids find very difficult to do, more so when change ro routine. 23762015-08-05T17:48:18.6739461Victoria SwanWe would be lost without our's when it comes to going out with our son, having a blue badge keeps him safe.23762015-08-05T18:18:12.0979462Eileen JonesMy grandson has Autism and other disabilities. It is discriminatory that children and adults with mental disabilities cannot get a blue badge. My daughter was refused one for her son who is getting harder as he grows for her to control and she finds it hard to get out with him yet people who can actually drive themselves about get them. So unfair. 23762015-08-05T18:23:47.7079463Elizabeth McIntoshMy grandson has autism and has no sense of damage and needs a safe place in which to enable his parents to help him out the car23762015-08-05T18:23:58.9279464Stevie Barber Anyone in this situation knows how dangerous it is. If ever there was a case to change the rules, this would be one. This is about safety rather than convenience. Please change the qualifying criteria.23762015-08-05T18:32:31.5179465anne marie price I tired for a blue badge last year as my 12yr with asd and sensory problems was refused as they said he can walk life is very stressful as he will not do public transport or walk any distance.23762015-08-05T18:58:51.089467Claire brannanMy son has autism and had no sense off danger, i was refused blue badge twice and couldnt believe it. If my son was out alone he wouldnt last 20 minutes on the street.23762015-08-05T20:14:13.5039468Fraser McKenzieI have autism myself and yet I have no benefits at all. No PIP, no free bus pass, nothing.23762015-08-05T21:20:57.5039470Siobhan fotheringham This should be a basic human right for disabled children, having raised a child with autism and having a downs syndrome niece. It's hard to carry an autistic child that refuses to walk another step for what ever reason, I know at forty my back is destroyed making working each day harder and harder. Downs children often have a lot of health care needs appointments and should be able to travel in ways they are comfortable and with little stress in their journeys. This is essential not optional. The right thing needs to be done! I suggest challenging any mp to live a few weeks in the life.of an autism or downs family and question the necessity of a blue badge for their children! 23762015-08-05T21:48:09.0679471Tace DonaldsonMy son who is 10, has Down's. We currently have a blue badge as oh HR for DLA (after fighting as it was lowered recently!) I was unaware he would have automatically been given one at the age of 16, not sure what happens differently up to that age?! Discrimination most definitely 23762015-08-05T22:50:32.779472Kate Sole My daughter had the last HPV vaccine in September 2014 within 5 minutes her hand swelled and went purple after many visits to A&E and seeing a pain consultant they diagnosed CRPS in her arm in the February 2015 it went to her other arm and then to both her legs she is now on painkillers having physio and seeing a neurologist she is very tired and wiped out of she walks to much or is on her feet to long it is horrible to see her like this she was a dancer that danced everyday and was at competition level and has had to give this all up.They need to make this vaccine safer so other children are not affected like my daughter.23652015-08-05T23:13:05.69473Mrs A Mackay Children with DS who have low mobility require a badge to assist their parent(s) to gain a closer parking spot for hospitals but more so for everyday functions. To have a space closer with more space is so useful when trying to manage a special buggy and a chair and having a typical space hinders the needs of your child. 23762015-08-06T00:17:27.39474Lynne MilneThis is such a common sense thing for the government to do for our kids. As a parent of a child with autism, and also as a support group leader, i am aware on a daily basis of how important the blue badge is to families struggling so much already with the isolation and restrictions these conditions bring.23762015-08-06T06:37:09.169476STEPHEN CHRISTIE Fully believe that given Scotland has remained part of the United Kingdom that all children with autism and down's syndrome should have exactly the same entitlement as those living anywhere else in the UK. The safety of children should be put first not the potential cost saving that can be achieved by the government. 23762015-08-06T09:02:42.639477Isabella McTaggart this is heartbreaking this government needs to give its self a good shake and realise how much they are making life impossible for the families...it's not as if they get them for nothing they have to pay so the government is winning again they should be ashamed of themselves23762015-08-06T13:53:34.2879478nigel painMisleading statistics used to introduce a costly and unsafe vaccine. The risks of this vaccine outweigh the benefits. The effects on too many of our precious healthy children are life changing. This truly is a scandal especially when there are other ways of combating the awful disease that is cervical cancer without harming non infected girls to do so.23652015-08-06T19:16:38.8179479Patricia De MeyerI have a daughter who was injected in 2010 with gardasil. During that year she developed constant stomach aches, doctors couldn't find anything wrong with her stomach and told us it was just stress. However, later on the stomach aches subsided and she had headaches everyday that sometimes were so bad she had to stay home from school. After the injections her mood also drastically changed, she used to be such a happy child, but afterwards she was tired all the time, was depressed. She also complains of dizzyness a lot. We need to warn other parents to save their children. We can't consider the risk acceptable because every child matters.23652015-08-08T22:19:15.9439482Zoe Tennantthe government can make cuts elsewhere, no one asks to be born with a disability and we need to look after the vulnerable in our society. PIP is not working and the vulnerable are suffering for bureaucratic issues, allow families to care for their children and keep their blue badge. 23762015-08-09T11:24:12.729483Willie RutherglenAnother boot being put in to our lives - DLA, SDS, ASL...... It's assault by acronym.23762015-08-10T14:55:21.9279484Lorraine McKenzieour son is 28 and has Autism and Learning Difficulties - he briefly received a Blue Parking Badge when at school but when it was time to renew his request was rejected and we have never succeeded since!! He cannot leave the house unaccompanied for safety reasons and a Blue Badge would make a HUGE difference to our lives.23762015-08-10T20:50:22.0679485Marcia EdwardsMy son has Down's syndrome, I used to have a blue badge, but on the lastly application for DLA this was taken away. My son who is nearly six has no sense of danger and therefore when out I always have to hold his hand. This is a nightmare trying to get parking near a hospital for the numerous appointments I have to take my son to. This would make such a difference if I had a blue badge.23762015-08-14T19:09:51.5379490Frank PlunkettVaccines only benefit those who sell them and those who adminster them.....Lety all responsibility for the damage they cause fall onto the shoulders of said people......Avoidable conditions require education, not untested toxic chemical cocktails.\r\n23652015-08-14T22:41:41.8339491Bodil FjellangerHave received advice that persons with geneotype 11-3-52B should avoid Gardasil (1% of the population). There are several whitleblowers that have tried to warn the public. This vaccine is furtermore a huge issue in both Denmark and Japan. Besides, the EU has recently issued an investigation of the vaccine in relation to two specific conditions.23652015-08-15T12:51:41.3339492james swainMy question is why do they not have this already!!!!!!!23762015-08-16T15:15:45.8939494Norma Gonzalez, USAI feel for the moms and their children, who wanted protection and were misled. It bothered me that when I refused the chicken pox vaccine, our pediatrician gave me legal reasons to apply it (the school will ask for it, etc) not medical concerns, and when I refused the HPV vaccine being applied to my other son, the pediatrician gave me a little panflet so I could be "informed" and there was not a word in it warning about the smallest side effect. This needs to end!! Our children are not your experimentation money making field!!23652015-08-17T11:49:20.89495Paul FlarryThis is another typical government rule which actually saves nor costs them anything as the applicant is the one who pays and the level of mobility has nothing to do with the requirement to keep our children safe.23762015-08-17T13:05:35.8179496Fiona Jenkins Instead of trying to help parents with special needs it seems the government is making life harder shows how uncaring and out of touch this government is !!23762015-08-17T13:39:50.199497Ian Townsendbecause 'evidence-based' means just that. Looking at the evidence.23652015-08-17T13:55:36.1739498Lynne GautonI am parent of a child with Down's Sydrome and our Blue Badge is a godsend for us. We are in the process of renewing ours and am dreading if it is not renewed as it will make life so much harder for us. Life is hard enough without taking more away from us.23762015-08-17T17:10:47.3139499Hilary Jean Lawrenson A child or Adult with disabilities who has medical problems should have a badge purely for the hospitals.\r\nBut having Downs syndrome does not necessarily mean that person needs a Blue Badge as they can be physically very able. When you see people without the use of limbs and restricted to wheelchairs struggling because they cannot find a space in supermarket car parks or struggling to pay for tickets with machines they cannot reach or paying for hospital parking then these are the people that need those spaces.\r\nI was one of the founder members of the SDSA and had to fight for many things but now see much misuse. think the words Basic Human Right\r\n is also misused.23762015-08-17T21:09:18.119500Phil ThompsonThere is no evidence the vaccines work but plenty of evidence they are harmful. It fills me with hope that the Scottish government have not been corrupted by big pharma and will look at the real evidence about vaccines and the harm they do.23652015-08-17T22:42:45.3939501Marie Watsonwill make such a difference and give people confidence while travelling.23662015-08-18T07:55:17.6739502Douglas ChapmanThis issue is not about whether Down's children can walk a certain distance but whether they can walk independently and without adult supervision. For parents or carers the safety of our young people is of great importance and relaxing of the current regulations would offer a level of security that young people need and allow them to travel safely to shops, sport and entertainment venues etc which helps them to live independent lives and enhances their sense of well being.23762015-08-18T09:31:41.169503Gabrielle StewartThe College of Occupational Therapists support this petition in relation to equity with PIP on the grounds of personal safety. This should apply to all children under 16 if there is a personal safety aspect to their condition whatever that may be.23762015-08-18T10:00:01.369504Katy Redford-TraynorThe safety profile of this vaccine is shocking! Young girls have been serious disabled and some have died due to this vaccine. It is also not proven that this vaccine prevents cervical cancer and it has been misleading thousands of parents to portray it as such. All in all it appears to be another profitable vaccine but with an horrendous safety record. It needs to be removed from the schedule to protect our children! 23652015-08-18T22:38:48.749506Heather FotheringhamPlease include Adults with Downs Syndrome23762015-08-19T23:37:14.3639507Iain AndersonThis is about the safety of our most vulnerable citizens, those of all ages who need help because they do not see the world around them as most of us do and need support at all times. 23762015-08-21T06:28:32.669508Shari Smoker Serious independent studies need to be done with all vaccines. But In the case of the HPV vaccine there is no proof that it will in fact prevent cancer. It has caused horrendous injury to young women including bringing on early menopause, which then prevents these young women from being able to have children. People Should not be mandated to take vaccines that hold such risks. 23652015-08-21T07:26:50.9279509Alison BarbourMy daughter's blue badge was removed because she can walk. This puts us at considerable risk when walking near traffic and curtails the outings that we can make. (We did not have higher rate mobility allowance but had a blue badge for several years .) It is difficult enough to try to ensure safety and a good quality of life for disabled children. Scottish society has some way to go in being inclusive to those who are different. Please provide blue badges for all citizens who have a disability which prevents them from understanding the concept of personal safety.23762015-08-21T13:37:24.0639510Joyce CranePlease consider including children with Down Syndrome and Autism. The challenges that these families deal with on a daily basis could be helped if they were included. I frequently drive 200 miles to help with childminding my little grandson who has Down Syndrome. This allows his parents to work and pay their taxes etc. I take him on outings and being able to park closer to venues would be a great help. He can walk but tires easily and has no danger awareness and is pre-verbal. We need our Government to demonstrate empathy towards our most vulnerable citizens. 23762015-08-21T18:07:49.2679512Helen DrakeMy daughter received this vaccine in 2010 and suffered bad side effects and was then diagnosed with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome shortly afterwards23652015-08-21T19:46:11.619513Edward hinksMy little sister has been through years of hell, this needs to be addressed now.23652015-08-21T19:48:51.7879514Charlene hinksLittle sister has been through hell, more investigations are needed. 23652015-08-24T12:44:17.5339515Elizabeth H ScottWhy isn't this done already? It just makes sense!23662015-08-25T15:04:21.9579516Kevin O'ConnorI am the father of a 3 yrs boy who has Down Syndrome. As other people have mentioned, children with DS tire easlier and If I am out shopping i then need to carry him and the shopping back my son back to teh car. he is too big for my wife t carry and we don't have the benefit of support our families, it's just me and my wife. As we know all 3 years disoby mom and dad and go off and do their own thing. Not been able to park nearer to a location, will casue continued problems. I do have to ask though, why are we able to issue mobility buggies to people who appear to be in ill health, from perhaps a life time of smoking drinking etc and can walk, but choose not to and are in control of their environment. Where as a child who has been born with DS, and isn't in control of his environment and can be become extremely unpredictable is potentially loosing the valuable option of a safer parking. Please rethink this. 23762015-08-28T06:55:48.6139517Dawn WhittakerThis is clear discrimination.23762015-08-28T08:59:53.1939518Franck BergeretCome on, bring in common sense, they should have priority over other able kids when it comes to welfare cuts, this will make such a difference to those children and their families. Please.23762015-08-29T19:55:36.919519Angela kaneHopefully the Goverment will see sense and understand that having this Bluebadge can help Children like my son with autism hurting himself or others as he can walk but has no sense of Danger.23762015-09-01T10:45:20.169520Gordon DunbarThis would no doubt enhance the rail infrastructure in Central Scotland and make for easer access to the capital for Clackmannanshire.23822015-09-01T11:54:49.7379521Robert McAndrewSeems like a sensible idea to me23822015-09-01T12:29:41.169522Craig DuncanUndoubtedly a benefit to local communities, commuters and leisure tourist travelers. Stirling Alloa Dunfermline corridor needs this.23822015-09-01T17:33:48.5979523Geo StewartThis would be a great benefit to the local villages, especially Kincardine.23822015-09-01T17:44:16.499524Katrine PatersonThe line is there so the cost needn't be expensive.\r\nIf heritage trains can use the line, there is no excuse for not allowing a regular passenger service to Alloa. \r\n23822015-09-01T18:04:35.7679525Allan BellIt would be a massive boost to the area\r\n23822015-09-01T18:14:42.2539526Mr Ian DoodsWould love to see this happen and also from extending at Alloa through to Kincardine is build the Clackmannan platform.23822015-09-01T18:19:21.39527Linda CrowWould like to see a station back in kincardine so I can access Fife, alloa, Stirling Glasgow edinburgh23822015-09-01T18:29:34.0339529Raymond Melville The money has already been spent reopening the line from Stirling to Kincardine for coal trains, so sensible to get value for money by continuing its use for passenger traffic. Continuing passenger service on the line to Dunfermline would also be sensible.23822015-09-01T19:41:45.3139530irene condie This would be good for commuters between fife edinburgh and glasgow23822015-09-01T21:09:19.139532James running They should be23762015-09-01T22:35:13.0679533Trish millarabsolutely, less traffic, less stress and an additional income to the rail network rather than the petrol Giants 23822015-09-02T02:06:46.869534lewis sweeneyReally hope it all goes well for the people it will help, they spend enough keeping it looking good so why not let people see all that hard work up close, also it will help so many people out on their travels. I would like it if i needed it and plenty of people need it, id do it in a heartbeat. 23822015-09-02T03:53:45.1739536James Gibson I hope it brings more tourists to the area23822015-09-02T06:51:03.9239537Craig SeathAfter the infrastructure upgrade carried out on the lfreight only line from Alloa to Longannet and the existing rail line (which is already used on occasion for passenger trains). This would appear to be too good an opportunity to miss to give people living on he Fife Circle and those of West Fife villages to access public transport more easily and allow full access to Stirling, Alloa and Glasgow for a relatively minimal cost.23822015-09-02T21:18:58.8979539Denise CannonIt seems to be so obvious as to what needs to be done here and yet as with every other aspect of these childrens lives, parents have to fight so hard to get the support and resources that can make such a difference to both them and their parents. I myself have an autistic son and the journey has been made so much more difficult thanks to bureaucracy. The people at the top clearly have no idea what it means to have a child with additional support needs such as autism or Downs Syndrome. They should try walking a mile in the shoes of the parents who do!23762015-09-03T00:07:33.059540Fiona Colsto Having a link from Stirling or Alloa would allow me to visit Fife and treat the grand children to a day out in a train. Im sure more people would use it too.23822015-09-03T00:26:49.4739541Suzanne BosworthExcellent and sensible idea, using already existing infrastructure and opening up the Central Belt. Let's do this!23822015-09-03T10:04:03.0039542Alan PaulUnless you have access to a car, getting to Stirling from Fife is a pain in the backside. Providing this link is a 'No Brainer'.23822015-09-03T10:45:17.9739543Grant RobertsonExtend Glasgow-Alloa service to Dunfermline by ths route, and on to Edinburgh. Gives benefit of linking the west Fife villages to the rail network, and Fife to Glasgow too.23822015-09-03T11:26:03.059544Gordon HunterWith programme of rail re-openings continuing, the fact that west fife village residents currently have no Public Transport choice but to choose the bus and that a operating single track is about to have to have no regular traffic east of Alloa station - then the justification is clear and simple23822015-09-03T11:36:00.4879545Colin CookThis is a long time coming. As the coal industry no longer exists and Longannet sadly disappears, the role of these villages changes and it is commuter belt territory now. Additionally, the rail links would attract visitors to the area and thus help boost the local economies. It's a no brainer. And, as a long term commuter, I can vouch for the health impact of the current transport offer to Edinburgh and Glasgow. It's no good.23822015-09-03T12:34:03.7239546John Emery-BarkerWith the closing of Longannet, this gives an ideal opportunity to improve travel for the small villages of West Fife, especially those like Torryburn, Newmills, Low Valleyfield and Culross who are currently bypassed by the buses to Glasgow and the west.23822015-09-03T16:25:44.9579549James WatsonThe line is well maintained and there are handy points for stations or halts which could be easily turned into Park and Ride car parks. This would open up expansion for the West Fife Coastal Villages and a \r\nnew and exciting route between Fife, Stirling and Glasgow. Also bring on the reopening of the route north between Edinburgh, Dunfermline, Perth and Inverness.It should never have been closed in the first place. 23822015-09-03T19:03:46.9279550Scott BamfordAn excellent idea and investment in the area. The Alloa Stirling link was proven to be a complete success and should be expanded apon.23822015-09-03T23:14:20.8939551Joyce Armourgood luck Martin23822015-09-03T23:47:49.839552john mcclureI hope that it will be used by the general public.23822015-09-04T06:29:20.2679553Robert dennisIt is a transport link that would improve the infrastructure of West- Fife Coastal villages .23822015-09-04T07:35:43.6739554James PatersonHaving travelled over the line on a rail tour it is more than capable of handling passenger traffic.Opening it up for such use would add to the growing rail scene in Scotland with the opening of the borders railway.Leven and St. Andrews the next target?23822015-09-04T11:15:28.139555William LambIt would certainly open up travel options in the Fife and Clackmannanshire area and onward travel to Glasgow and Edinburgh 23822015-09-04T20:56:42.4579556James KempIt would decrease traffic on the roads, bring jobs to the area, help people travel from Dunfermline to Stirling & vice-versa that would not otherwise travel amongst other things. Very scenic route too!23822015-09-05T14:01:24.999557David CockburnI think it incredible that there is no direct rail link from Fife to Glasgow. This link would establish an important route that would prove popular and sensible.23822015-09-05T20:50:16.8479558Tim GreenToo many cars are commuting into Glasgow and Edinburgh. A passenger service will revitalise West Fife and at the same time reduce carbon emissions. Win win. Please put a halt at Culross . This needs to be combined with making Longannet a European Centre For research and development for renewable energy. Please don't let the passenger line be dependent on Cluff's plans for UCG.A passenger line makes sound economic sense.23822015-09-06T08:56:54.8339559Anas HassanI think this is a fantastic campaign and a fantastic idea that I am 100% in support of. In the wake of the Borders Railway being revived, the case has already been made for enhanced rail services, serving our rural communities and villages across Scotland.\r\n\r\nAnd in this case especially, it makes complete sense to link Clackmannanshire to Fife. Such a link is long overdue!23822015-09-06T16:11:49.7839560Mark youngAs a Train Driver who used to drive this line a few years back before moving depots it would be a great asset to the people in West Fife and a welcome addition to the Scottish rail passenger network23822015-09-09T07:17:05.9279561Debbie YoungHaving 4 children on the spectrum, 2 of them severe, a blue badge would make such a difference to trips out, The 'invisible' disabilities are every bit as real as the visible ones and should be treated as such!!23762015-09-09T23:07:36.2539562Fariha GetlawiThe Blue Badge significantly helps families in need. Would be an outrage to take that away from them. Taking that away would prevent the child from going out on trips conveniently and safely!!23762015-09-10T23:22:45.479563Nadia rahi I live in Glasgow and my boyfriend is from fife . He has told me many story's of his childhood with his parents there and I know why he loves it as much as I do . It's a beautiful , well kept , pleasant town and I have taken a lot of people there to visit it . I was chatting to a local there and he was saying how they have no post office or shops and railway brought tourists in but he told me of this closure and I was so disappointed to hear this to happen to our beautiful country . Please do not let this happen we should be proud of our country and make use of what we have and our memories and keep our country running 23822015-09-12T13:15:23.389564Barry KeillohWest Fife is badly in need of investment particularly in light of the Longannet closure. This would attract business to the area and create jobs giving the area a boost.23822015-09-12T13:41:07.1479565Audrey Margaret WattThis would open up a valuable rail link through the Fife villages and beyond.23822015-09-12T13:49:55.5339567Chris McIntoshWould be great to get both this and the Levenmouth canpaign both connected to the Fife circle.23822015-09-12T15:04:23.639568moira morrisonwe need this link for growth. the sooner the better for a progressive Scotland.23822015-09-12T17:41:26.1439569Bob BrownSG - please take a serious look at this please. Could be good for Fife and the Central belt. 23822015-09-12T17:56:06.3979570Jane Simons - BrownBadly needed, good luck!! 23822015-09-15T08:02:28.669571JEAN HEPBURNTHE COMMUNITY OF BARRHEAD DESERVES A NEW HIGH SCHOOO,SO THAT THE CHILDREN CAN FLOURISH AND MEET THEIR POTENTIAL23952015-09-15T08:10:23.3139572Matthew HepburniI went to Barrhead high, the children deserve a new school23952015-09-15T08:24:36.4439573Matthew HepburnCommunities flourish when people have good quality facilities. Barrhead deserves better23952015-09-15T08:23:59.6279574Nichola williamsOur children are in desperate need for this funding to be released so they can get there new school instead of the crumbling building that they are in the now23952015-09-15T08:42:57.5379575Lindsay QuinnThe treatment of student's and teachers at Barrhead High School over the building of the new school is diabolical! They should have moved into their new school at the start of this school year. Now we're being told that funding to start building the school has been frozen. Barrhead High school at present is unsafe! Our children deserve to be educated in safety, with the same amenities as the children in the more affluent areas of East Renfrewshire!23952015-09-15T08:57:19.7539576Jacqueline RadcliffeOur children and community need the new school to encourage our children to reach their full potential.....if government want our children "to flourish' then give them the resources they need to do it.....23952015-09-15T08:58:31.6439577Nicola gray Barrhead high is in a terrible state of disrepair our children deserve to work in a clean safe environment which is certainly not the case23952015-09-15T09:36:47.9239578Mandy haywardI attended Barrhead High 1983-1989 (I think) and it's a disgrace that the fabric of this building has barely changed. It's an embarrassment to now be sending my son to the same wreck. It's time for a new build!23952015-09-15T09:48:11.9579579Alyson Connell In order to close the attainment gap, all school pupil should be afforded the same opportunities. Barrhead High School pupils are being educated in a facility which is an extremely poor state of repair and cannot afford to wait any longer for the new school they were promised and which should have already been open by now.23952015-09-15T09:58:17.0339581Janet CampbellEast Renfrewshire, a place to Grow. Not since the building of a new Barrhead High continually gets put back! The current school should have been knocked down years ago. The building is unsafe, the young people are at risk, the moral in the school is very low and is affecting how our young people learn23952015-09-15T10:05:35.2879582Ann HornA new Barrhead High School is well overdue.\r\n23952015-09-15T10:32:04.499583Shoma MazumderEqual opportunities for ALL the young people of ERC is not being realised with the failure and delays in building this new high school. ERC need to get the finger out and do what they have promised these youngsters and to fulfil their pledge in making ER a place where young people can acheive their potential, regardless of social background.23952015-09-15T10:31:09.699584Claire stevensonPlease release money for new school it's old and needs to be replaced not fit for purpose 23952015-09-15T10:37:22.3339585Carol ShawWe need more schools for our kids 23952015-09-15T11:07:16.6439586Archie DouglasGreat idea to have a petition . Could I suggest that it is brought to the attention of the media. For example the Barrhead News, the Evening Times and even the East Ren news letter that is published by the council. 23952015-09-15T11:50:48.69587Debbie blair The children of barrhead deserve a better school please release the funding. 23952015-09-15T11:54:31.369589johnny elliot Barrhead deserve a better school. 23952015-09-15T12:16:19.229590Anne Walkermuch needed in this area. ERC and Scottish Parliament must look at solving this problem23952015-09-15T13:01:05.5179591Elizabeth TurnbullThis school was needing replaced when I taught in it 20 years ago. The children are the future of our town and country and deserve a good working environment23952015-09-15T13:20:17.559592Diane wilsonits our kids future!! Please sign and share 23952015-09-15T13:35:23.1779593Aileen EasdonBarrhead High needs demolished and replaced with a new school. This has been going far too long and action needs to be taken before an accident happens like what happened in Edinburgh when that young girl list her life. I am certain both East Renfrewshire Council and Scottish Government font want that on their conscience. 23952015-09-15T13:34:45.589594Noeleen ElliottThe Children deserve a modern school building23952015-09-15T13:40:15.859595Kara Mansfield My daughter is in P6 and will be attending Barrhead High when she leaves primary. She has Albinism which means she's Partially Sighted and also has Nystagmus and Photophobia. I want a safe and comfortable School to be ready in time so she can be happy ano confident. New build Schools always have better lighting which would make her feel comfortable and not have to deal with sore heads. At her current school they had to upgrade all the lights, install new blinds, fix a lot of the crumbling stairs and paths etc so she would be safe. Shocking that Barrhead is one of the last towns to get a new school. 23952015-09-15T13:40:30.979596Cecilia BradleyThis is getting beyond ridiculous now, these children in Barrhead High School need a new school building as soon as. Built in 1967 it has done it's job and for the health of all children and adults who spend many hours there each day the new school MUST be built!23952015-09-15T14:07:44.5839597Nicola WinningThe government need to step in and release the funds to commence the building of this school. It is scandalous that children & staff have to be in an unsafe environment which is not conducive to learning.\r\nDoing nothing is NOT an option! 23952015-09-15T14:55:00.669598Allison RankinOur kids deserve a new school as the school hasn't changed much since I attended in the 80's!!23952015-09-15T15:33:51.339599jenny douglasour children in Barrhead should have the same access to a 21st century school as do their colleagues in other parts of East Renfrewshire. Please put your rhetoric into action regarding raising attainment standards and make it more achievable for pupils and staff by giving them the long promised new school that will provide the best possible learning environment.23952015-09-15T16:22:31.919600Stewart GrayI left this School in 1978 and it's not changed. I travel all over Scotland and see what's out there. Fantastic new facilities in every County. Time we had a proper modern School for the Community.23952015-09-15T17:43:13.8179601Stuart CluckieIt is disgraceful that politicians are stalling on building a much needed replacement for Barrhead high, whilst allocating funding of £11 million for a new primary in Newton Mearns. Barrhead has been short changed once again.23952015-09-15T18:05:37.3639602Alan SmithDon't write off the children in barrhead they need a new school to make them a better pupil. 23952015-09-15T18:06:45.5979603nicola byarsThe children deserve a new school that they can be proud of saying they attend. Not much to be proud of of the existing building!! Its ancient and in much need of demolishing!!23952015-09-15T18:16:05.2239604Linsay Hazelton We need a new school for our children.Ileft Barrhead High in 1985 and it was in a state of disrepair then,our children should have a new school now!!!23952015-09-15T18:20:35.9739605June Cunninghamlong overdue, for the sake of the pupils please release the funding for the new school now.23952015-09-15T18:24:04.0379606Mrs Elizabeth Rennieour children deserve a more up to date school the one they have is falling apart the kids deserve better xav been out this school 29yrs and it not changed x23952015-09-15T18:50:05.5679607Sharon SuddingThe current school is in a terrible state of disrepair as it was supposed to be demolished 3 years ago. Our young people deserve an environment fit to learn in. 23952015-09-15T18:49:42.6279608Mark GorrieUnfortunately the history of East Renfrewshire Council when dealing with local schools isn't great. I think the word incompetent springs to mind.23952015-09-15T19:13:38.029609Carolanne AndersonThe school needs replaced I attended barrhead high and it looks pretty much the same as when I attended and I left the school in 1989 my daughter is due to go there Aug 2016 but I am in 2 minds to let her go due to the state of that school 23952015-09-15T19:58:14.9439610kelly wilsonThe environment staff and pupils work in is of vital importance to boosting morale which, in turn, improves confidence and enthusiasm to learn. Barrhead High pupils deserve the right to reach their full potential.23952015-09-15T21:28:08.7379611Claire HendryThe children of Barrhead deserve to be educated in a facility that is fit for purpose. This new build has been promised for years and finally approved after a costly legal battle, only to be put on hold again pending approval by the EU. The interior and non existent sports facilities are quite frankly a health hazard. My husband started at the school in 1981 and very little has changed 34 years later.23952015-09-15T21:40:21.4579612Nikki WinningThe Scottish government must release the funds to start work as soon as possible. It is scandalous the children & staff have had to wait this long to be educated and to work in a safe environment. \r\nWhilst more affluent areas in ERC have decent secondary schools, our children seem to have been forgotten about.\r\nAs the government's latest document states all children are entitled to a decent education. Our children's education is being sadly affected by the monstrosity that is the current Barrhead High School.23952015-09-15T22:14:52.4739614Leeann smithBarrhead need this school23952015-09-15T22:27:01.5039615Anna-Marie PeacockThe young people of Barrhead need this desperately.23952015-09-16T00:44:31.0379616Kirsteen AllanThe people of Barrhead have already waited far too long for this school. To have an indefinite delay owing to local authority ineptitude is unforgivable.23952015-09-16T07:05:56.8479617Julie InglisSo much investment in other schools in ERC, a new school for Barrhead is long overdue. Current facilities - particularly sport are a Disgrace with leaking roofs, rotting windows and general state of disrepair.\r\nThe new school has been long promised, the children and future generations of Barrhead need a school fit for purpose and capable of supporting the needs of the local community.\r\nNew houses are being built all the time in Barrhead yet the education infrastructure is not adapting to the increased needs.\r\nBoth East renfrewshire council, the SNP and Labour Party must accept responsibility for this unacceptable delay. You have delivered empty promises to your constituency. The new school has had fanfare for 3 years yet no progress in actually starting to build ! It's time to act and ensure you have equality throughout East renfrewshire education facilities and deliver the new school the children of Barrhead need and deserve.23952015-09-16T08:04:42.029618Jacqui Martin Barrhead is in desperate need for a new high school and has been for several years. The existing building is not in an appropriate state of repair to allow our children to excel in their abilities. The facilities in other high schools within East Renfrewshire far surpass what is currently offered in Barrhead. Barrhead children should be given the same opportunities. 23952015-09-16T08:41:01.2539619Mark McConwayLong, long overdue and badly needed for all the reasons mentioned in the petition. Would re-invigorate the economy of West Fife.23822015-09-16T09:07:38.6139620Elizabeth weiri left Barrhead high in 1987 my daughter has attended this school and my son is currently there nothing has changed in the 28 years since I left its a disgrace when u see what some others schools look like prisoners have better facilities than the pupils 23952015-09-16T09:27:03.8139621Claire Hendry The children of Barrhead deserve to be taught in a safe & fit for purpose school. The building and sports facilities are disgraceful. My husband attended from 1981 and not much has changed since then.23952015-09-16T09:47:16.389622Tony CaseyThe delays & excuses need to stop. 23952015-09-16T10:10:05.3139623Kirsten JeansThe current Barrhead high School is inadequate. There has long been a discrepancy in the distribution of the budget in educational establishments in East Renfrewshire, with Barrhead being overlooked.23952015-09-16T12:26:58.4579624Jayne McKieThe Scottish Government need to release funding for the new Barrhead High build ASAP (A new school which should already be standing! East Renfrewshire Council should be moving mountains to assist with this after their initial blunder on the intended site. Having attended this school nearly 30 years ago nothing has changed. Only further deterioration. The current school building is rotting. I can't imagine how the pupils can tolerate this environment never mind thrive in their education. Setback after setback has been extremely disheartening for past and present teachers, pupils and parents alike. This project needs to have priority and is owed to the town of Barrhead.23952015-09-16T18:37:34.5979625Grant DuncanHIURRY UP23952015-09-16T20:29:18.949626Xian ParrWe have to treat everyone equally, which we cannot do by prioritizing already perfect, pristine schools over Barrhead High, which is falling apart. How can we be expected to learn in such dreadful conditions?23952015-09-16T20:35:29.2379627Gillian Campbell In a world where parents will not always be there to encourage and boost the confidence of the young schools fill the gap. Whether you believe that this is morally right it is an unfortunate truth. They do not need to be the most 'blinged' out technologically but they do need to be inspiring, warm, safe and fit for the future of education. If we can instill into the young people now a need for education in all walks of life they will in turn pass this value onto their own children. This cannot happen as easily in a building that is simply not fit for purpose regardless of the professional efforts of the teaching staff. 23952015-09-17T09:20:03.7379629James CowansLibraries are an essential resource for pupils to learn research skills which is intrinsic to the new National courses N4 - N7. Do not be foolish do not cut this wonderful resource from schools.23972015-09-17T09:25:55.249630Jessie Linardi NicolChecking books in and out is not the essence of a school librarian's profession any more than completing reams of paperwork is the essence of a lawyer's. \r\n\r\nReplacing qualified librarians with library assistants is akin to replacing qualified teachers with teaching assistants - assistants do not possess the theoretical and practical knowledge needed to deliver either service. And being paid an assistant's salary while stumbling through this lack of knowledge can only confound matters.\r\n\r\nPlease pay attention to the research and the repeatedly-demonstrated value of having a high-quality library service with a professionally qualified librarian on-site. It is a necessary long-term investment that will benefit all (financially and socially...).23972015-09-17T09:51:45.4879632beverley TurnerI have been privileged to spend 30 years putting books into the hands of young people at Annan Academy. Retired then yy full time post now part-time. Not good enough Children need independent access to books so that they can make their own discoveries. 23972015-09-17T11:22:49.5339634Kevin MarrLibraries and Librarians don't just exist for young learners. They are central to the community. 23972015-09-17T11:44:08.979635Jane MurphyOur school librarian is an essential part of our school community. There is no doubt that losing our full time school librarian will have a negative impact on our pupils' experience of school. It is shameful that many committed and professionally qualified people are so undervalued.23972015-09-17T11:47:38.7839636Ally BellWith less and less parents reading, where do we expect our children to get access to free literature23972015-09-17T11:53:39.369637Elisabeth HensmanI cannot praise too highly school librarians especially those in Glasgow in the 1960's and 70's who gave me do much help and encouragement with learning and instilled in me the love of reading. This also applies to public librarians. As we lose more and more public services the role of the school librarian becomes not only paramount but essential. My childhood librarians were friends and mentors and helped me discover so much for myself. But I needed their guidance to put me on this path. Today at 61 I am never without a book to hand (a real paper book) and still learning and still in awe.23972015-09-17T12:03:15.7239638Rachel McCabeRetaining School Libraries and professionally qualified Librarians is vital to bridge the literacy gap between pupils from economically deprived communities and those from more affluent areas. The School Library is at the centre of all literacy work in a school and the loss of this free resource would cause untold damage to Scotland's school population.23972015-09-17T12:05:49.639639Kirsten ScottIt is number crunching taken to the extreme to de-value the contribution school librarian's make to the eduction of secondary school pupils. Furthermore, it is incredily short sighted that those in power believe that only teachers can facilitate the learning of young people in full time education in terms of their literacy, numeracy and health and well being skills. A professional school librarian, degree educated, can offer so much in support of the curriculum. It is laudable that school librarian's are seen as a soft target. Reading for enjoyment or information is crucial to a young person's development for life. Teachers do not have the time and some do not have the inclination to prioritise this. School librarian's do.23972015-09-17T12:11:57.5639640Charlie FletcherSchool libraries open minds and expand horizons. \r\n\r\nStory - 'Vitamin S' - is an essential part of who we are as humans, not least because it allows us to imagine who we could be at, our best. \r\n\r\nLibraries dispense Vitamin S - for free, for all, without prejudice or favour. \r\n\r\nThat's the reason they're the heart of a good educational system. 23972015-09-17T12:15:02.479642Claire WithersAs an English teacher I would be lost without my school librarian. School librarians are vital in helping build literacy skills as well as instilling a love of reading that will last long beyond school years. \r\nI cannot imagine working in any school where there was not a professionally trained librarian working there everyday to support both staff and students alike.23972015-09-17T12:26:11.4579643Pam MacKayAs a visiting teacher I was very aware of the value and the quality of support given by the Schools' Librarian service. I have been amazed at the enthusiasm for, and interest in, a school library, from students I would not have seen as keen readers. The quality and imaginative nature of support offered by these Professionals was clearly vital to the literacy of these children.23972015-09-17T12:35:33.19644Eleanor GordonSchool librarians are not a luxury or optional extra.They play a central role in the education of our children in the sense of 'leading out' a love of books and learning.23972015-09-17T13:00:52.3779645Karen Diane WilsonSchool libraries and especially the librarians, are so integral to the school I cannot contemplate this resource disappearing. It is essential for the support of teaching and learning especially die to inclusion policies.23972015-09-17T13:02:53.7539646Kirstin LambI believe that school libraries and the qualified librarians who staff them are essential to improving literacy in Scotland. 23972015-09-17T13:50:03.6739647Becky MaclennanI would really like my school library to stay open because if it gets closed i wouldn't get access to computers or free books. Also its a quite area in my school to do homework and read books. 23972015-09-17T13:55:24.249648Ian MunroIn the face of continuing concern regarding literacy rates in children, the last thing we should be doing is contemplating a deterioration in our school library services.23972015-09-17T14:03:59.389649Jeannie MurrayIn an age of decreasing book-reading by young people, isn't it essential to maintain as many school libraries as possible?23972015-09-17T14:12:30.059650Amanda FullertonAnyone who has ever been in a school must be aware of the invaluable service provided by school librarians in fostering interest in books. In this time when such an emphasis is placed on literacy and numeracy, it is crazy even to contemplate reducing the provision.23972015-09-17T14:37:37.669651Chris LuntSurely the socialist, anti-austerity SNP government isn't going to allow Scotland's school libraries to suffer this fate? 23972015-09-17T14:44:43.0839652Jack McKaySchool librarians offer a vital public service in increasing the literacy levels in our young people and community. 23972015-09-17T15:05:42.029654Lucie MillerIn order to have en effective, broad education for every child it is fundamental that each school has access to a well-equipped, updated library.23972015-09-17T15:33:00.8139655Roy GillSchool libraries are a vital resource to encourage literacy and foster a love of reading and learning. They also provide a safe space within schools for many pupils. They should be encouraged and supported fully. 23972015-09-17T16:06:25.4279658David BarrieIt's a no-brainer really... a national strategy for school libraries which recognises the vital role of high quality school libraries in supporting pupils' literacy and research skills.23972015-09-17T16:17:18.7079659elizabeth mckinlayAs a former teacher I fully support keeping our yp engaged in reading.23972015-09-17T17:01:13.6139661Elaine CartneySchool libraries & professional librarians are vital, not only for promoting literacy, but for encouraging independent thinking and openmindedness. Students can develop research skills,and access information, without pressure, relevant to their own interests and concerns.One area where this is perhaps particularly useful is when considering career & course options. There are social benefits, too, with students of all abilities, backgrounds & age groups mixing freely in a non-judgmental & safe environment.\r\n23972015-09-17T18:33:31.7839662Elizabeth bentleyI know school library provision in Scotland has been the envy of school librarians in England, and a beacon of excellence. It would be tragic if this were lost.23972015-09-17T19:18:45.029663Helen RussellThe value of school libraries and librarians in providing a safe space for our young people cannot be understated. My own life would have been immeasurably poorer without the school library and the guidance of an inspirational librarian.23972015-09-17T20:05:38.139664Rosemary StablesAs Head of English in a school which closed down its library, I know what a devastating impact this had. I also know what a difference the restoration of our library has made.23972015-09-17T20:41:21.5039666Linda BroganBadly needed for the Scottish economy would improve the tourism23822015-09-17T20:53:15.6139667Ashley PeaceBadly needed - travel to Edinburgh from this part of Fife is highly impractical unless taking the car.23822015-09-17T21:05:45.6939668Andrew GivanI wish this petition every success. It's about time the tide turned and school librarians get the credit they deserve and get funded properly. They are astonishingly committed and creative people who inspire and support pupils every day. Make full-time school librarians statutory in every school including ASN schools - that would be something for Scotland to be proud of. 23972015-09-17T21:20:42.19669Michelle ActonEven with the technology available today, nothing beats being able to sit down and peruse a good book. It is still a great way to learn and ensures children aren't stuck to their computers, laptops and phones. Some traditions should always remain.23972015-09-17T21:28:52.0039670Derek HotchkissYou can't improve literacy and cut back on the library service23972015-09-17T21:46:32.19671Lindsay MoffatLibraries are not a luxury in schools. They are sanctuaries, resource centres and the beginning of a love of literature. If we want to improve literacy and engage children in reading, libraries are a necessity.23972015-09-17T22:18:13.9439672Cathy FordeAs a Scottish writer for young people I have witnessed at first hand in schools throughout the country the formative influence the school library and its staff play in the lives of children. They are crucial.23972015-09-18T06:27:29.3979673Frances CampbellI attended Barrhead High School in the 1960's....on the old site on Barrhead Main Street....I remember the excitement buzzing around at the time when the existing one was being built....custom made....modern and so forth.So now it's time to rebuild to provide our young people with a 21st state of the art school to allow them to achieve their goals.23952015-09-18T07:08:02.0839674Dr Gavin GallAn essential resource for raising the attainment and achievement of Scotland's youth.23972015-09-18T07:16:16.6739675Lari DonAs an author who regularly visits schools, I see the amazing work done by secondary school librarians, giving pupils confidence and opportunities to read at a time when so many young people stop reading. So I believe that pupils' right to a full-time professional librarian, and all that a librarian does for their current educational attainment and their future relationship with reading, should be protected at a national level. Wihout that protection, school library services are too easy a target for councils under financial pressure. 23972015-09-18T07:37:29.89676sandra websterlibraries are so important in tackling poverty. Giving access to a wider world. When I was growing up I had access to books and a quiet place to do my homework. I want the same for everyone\r\n23972015-09-18T07:54:51.9739677Caroline crawfordPlease take a serious look at this. It seems wrong to. Spend money on trams in Edinburgh (although from a different source of funding it's still taxpayers money) while towns throughout the country do not have a basic rail link into the cities. 23822015-09-18T08:27:26.5339678Helen BarleyOur school libraries are a vital resource and are built in to literacy across the secondary curriculum. To lose this resource will be to the detriment of literacy for all pupils.23972015-09-18T08:30:17.1139679Marion ThomsonSchool libraries are, for some, the only opportunity some children have to access the world of books as well as accessing resources, IT and the greatest resource of all- the hard working and friendly school librarian!23972015-09-18T08:31:58.869680Janet ColquhounSchool libraries and professional school librarians not only provide access to ALL with books, great knowledge and enthusiasm to encourage reading for pleasure and improve literacy skills. They also provide an invaluable opportunity to teach information skills in a world where we heavily rely on online information. CfE has reintroduced research assignments back in to senior exams and pupils (and teachers) need information professionals to support them to achieve the best they can. As the provision of school libraries and school librarians is clearly dependent on your postcode many are losing out.23972015-09-18T09:53:37.89682Mark GilroyAs a History teacher, I cannot fully express the vital importance of having access to a facility such as the school library. Across the curriculum, the school library has provided invaluable assistance in a number of regards, with particular reference to assignments at N5 and Higher level. Without the frontline services provided by the school library, my pupils would have been severly limited in their capacity to complete an importance piece of coursework which at Higher level counts as over 30% of the grade. \r\n\r\nLearners deserve the chance to achieve their full potential and the removal of the school library would have a negative impact on the attainment of Scottish youngsters. Indeed, we would be breaking our core remit as facilitators of learning and our moral perogatives if we could not provide such a service. Teaching is about affording youngster the opportunites they deserve, not stripping away core support structures in the delivery of thier education.\r\n\r\nI am sure that the Scottish Government will realise that this is not simply a cost cutting exercise,it is one which could have a hugely detrimental impact on all of our youngsters. It is the responsibility of the government to ensure that that libraries stay open, for the benefit of all.23972015-09-18T09:58:23.729683Hanna DidcockWe were lucky and I had he absolute pleasure of working with an amazing and inspiring librarian at my last school. She is always there supporting pupils and staff, looking out for their well being, listening, caring and offering solutions. It's ridiculous that she's had to fight for her job, while trams are built and ECC continues to spend on things it doesn't need.23972015-09-18T10:06:41.69684Sandra McNicolRetaining and investing in school libraries is vital in preventing the current decline in real literacy standards. Losing library provision is profoundly short-sighted and damaging to our young people's learning. Having a librarian meet individual needs, as a guide and consultant is invaluable. We need to put books and other resources into the hands of our children in their early years and beyond. They need to be helped and guided so as to be able to access reliable information. 23972015-09-18T10:18:30.8979685Hugh McleanThis would be an appalling retrograde step for our country. It is not economics. It is cultural vandalism.23972015-09-18T10:56:23.249686Kevin ClarkSchool libraries stimulate and feed curiosity. They are about more than books. The many good librarians encourage, support, stimulate and mentor the young learners to make sense of the wide array of material that is available for both knowledge and entertainment. This must continue to be encouraged. \r\nI have no link with the library service or publishing world. I'm just an ordinary parent who sees the very real positive impact of the school library service. We can't lose this.23972015-09-18T11:26:45.6779687Liane MarshallOur school needs our Library. Our school needs our Librarian. There is no valid argument that any Council can make against these statements. With these proposed cuts they are going to be complicit in the dumbing down of future generations. That could never be considered a legacy to be proud of.23972015-09-18T12:12:30.279688Akash SinghWe love and need our libirian23972015-09-18T12:16:28.6479689Abubakr AbidI hope mrs monday keeps her job.23972015-09-18T12:16:30.919690Donald ClarkKnowledge is Power !23972015-09-18T12:22:41.169691Sandra Gray McGruthetReading is the life blood of intelligent human beings. Closing libraries stultifies young minds.23972015-09-18T13:29:42.9739692David RobinsonClose a library, close a thousand minds23972015-09-18T15:14:38.6939694Reuben GallagherI love my school library, I don't know where I'd be without it. 23972015-09-18T15:59:53.6779695Emma Stevenson We need libraries in society to expand out knowledge 23972015-09-18T16:52:44.7879696Suzanne mullenLibrary's are important to children's education 23972015-09-18T17:00:10.4279697vicky byrneLibrarys should never be shut down 23972015-09-18T17:55:21.0179698Mike NewmanOur High School and Community Librarian recently retired and has not been replaced, so now there is no qualified librarian on site. This is such a retrograde step. Libraries and librarians provide quality access to information which cannot be adequately replaced by internet access and Google searches.23972015-09-18T18:05:14.8979699Katrina KellyAt the moment the only provision for our school library is 3 days a week with two different librarians who themselves are spread across several schools. This valuable resource is unavailable to pupils for 2 days.23972015-09-18T18:33:45.6139700Jeannie ThowInformation should be readily available in schools every minute of the school day. There should be a librarian available to assist pupils to access this information. This is a basic requirement for a good secondary education.23972015-09-18T19:10:44.6439701Ivor J. SanterFor many children the school library is still Pandora's box.23972015-09-18T20:36:58.2379702Joan MacLellanMy daughter is deaf and attended a mainstream school in Edinburgh. She found the library to be a source of support as well as information, and a quiet place to study. It was invaluable, and I'm sure is just as valuable to other students and staff. Keep our school libraries !23972015-09-18T20:44:24.2239703Margaret Forrester All those books and the quiet to read them ....\r\nFifty years ago now! \r\nEnhance and expand. Close books and you close imagination.23972015-09-18T20:45:37.6279704Carleen ParryLiteracy skills are key for Curriculum of excellence...The school librarian at Eastwood High, Newton Mearns engages and supports every child with their individual learning needs to help them achieve their very best . Miss De'arths library is the hub of the school and East Renfrewshire Education department may save money by reducing head cound but the education standard offered would certainly be a poorer place.23972015-09-18T21:12:58.1479705Stuart GrahamAs a Principal Teacher of English in a Secondary school, I know first hand the importance of reading and and good access to literature. Librarians are absolutely vital in helping to support young people with their literacy skills and helping them navigate the vast arrange of texts and sources they need to use. Our librarian is central to our school and highly valued by staff and pupils alike. To lose such a position would be a huge, short sighted mistake and a great irony given the Scottish Givernment's commitment to raising standards of literacy.23972015-09-18T21:50:23.5679706Gail WilliamsSchool libraries are a vital resource. 23972015-09-18T22:08:51.089707Carolyn FisherWhat sort of message are we sending to our young people if we close their school library? 23972015-09-19T00:42:59.2879708Catherine KingWhat would be the point in giving every child in Scotland a Library Membership, then actively support a reduction in skilled staff delivering that service? Time the Scottish Government follows up and supports children when they need us most.23972015-09-19T09:33:59.229709Katie DialloWe need to learn the lessons of history so not to repeat our mistakes. We need our libraries! 23972015-09-19T12:01:21.0039710Sharon Brady-Wardropethis is badly needed traveling to Stirling or Edinburgh is very difficult which means you end up taking the car! Not environmentally friendly at all! 23822015-09-19T12:26:51.8639711Anne ElibolSchool Libraries are the Heart of all schools.By closing them down you are denying children the right to learn to read,enjoy reading and learn the skills of research through books.Shame on any council or Head that feels this is the right thing to do.Also having access to a qualified Librarian is also essential in teaching children those skills23972015-09-19T14:59:39.39712Margaret DelusseySchool libraries and librarians are vital. There is no reasonable or rational argument for closing them, or cutting back on librarians.\r\n 23972015-09-19T17:19:25.139713Beverley CraigLibraries give us free access to knowledge and learning.23972015-09-19T21:17:49.859714Rhonda Wheate The library is one of my favourite places in the world. If libraries are properly funded, and curated by knowledgable, trained, enthusiastic staff, the sky is the limit - You get a knowledgeable, enthusiastic nation!23972015-09-19T22:26:24.249715ruan peatEvery study has shown a society with better literacy has a better society, but school are not supported to have library's and librarians, we are the specialists that need to help promote, support and spread literacy and the a love of books.23972015-09-20T10:34:02.2839716Helen MeloneI think there needs to be a national strategy - too many local authorities are dumbing down their school libraries and reducing librarians' hours. Government needs to act quickly to stop this from happening. School librarians are doing an amazing job teaching young people how to access information and research. It is such a shame that this resource is being lost as all these cuts are taking effect. Please do something now to stop this.23972015-09-20T14:47:49.6739717Lesley WorkmanTo create a real culture of literacy we need a librarian at the heart of schools to inspire young people to read.23972015-09-20T17:27:33.5039718Paul FoleyWe depend entirely on visitor numbers at Culross Palace and were experiencing a steady decline in numbers from 2008 until last year. This year, we had 1000 extra visitors and this would have been even more with decent public transport links. There is no direct bus to Glasgow or Edinburgh and travelling takes far longer than it should. The local community would also benefit hugely from the ability to travel for work as non-car owners have very few options at present. With the impending closure of Longannet Power Station, this could be the difference between long-term stagnation and a fresh start for the entire area.23822015-09-20T18:30:50.1279719David olearyThis is needed!23822015-09-20T20:26:44.0839720G. GhatorayAbsolutely despicable to get rid of school Librarians. Our school Librarian is much more than just the Librarian - she covers so many other remits and the pupils love going to our library. Politicians and councils must be utterly mad in what they are doing - I pay my taxes and want to be heard not just brushed aside in a feeble attempt to save money. Why not cut down on the unnecessary staff in the directorships of education authorities with their colossal salaries instead of picking on the low paid?23972015-09-20T21:39:42.3979721Nancy DavisMy school library helped me progress from being a junior reader into much broader interests. It felt a very accessible place to explore new interests.23972015-09-20T23:25:14.949722Christopher J GreenI suffer from glucoma and have had to give up driving. I travel to Scotland by train to Scotland and Inverkeithing haded for Culross23822015-09-21T08:17:50.6479723Cleo JonesSchool Librarians make a real difference to children's lives, they are able to help close the gap by promoting reading for enjoyment, which it is evidenced that children and young people who read for pleasure do better across all academic subjects. I have worked in this area for for over 25 years and we are now looking at the decimation of services across Scotland without there being an overview from Central Government who say that Literacy and closing the gap are the most important things that we can give young people and yet they are presiding over the loss of these valuable services. A review now is essential to make sure that young people don't lose access to these valuable services and people.23972015-09-21T10:09:13.6479724Liz DouchLibrarians are invaluable members of every school community who do so much more than their remit suggests. How does the government expect Literacy in young people to improve when thy are considering paying off those who are primarily employed to engage young people in reading?23972015-09-21T10:09:16.2539725David SuddingI believe that using a library, developing the skills that are required to fully use a library are essential to a childs development in Scotland. Don't consider the short term savings, but the long term cost to Scotland if we have children who don't have access to a school library.23972015-09-21T10:18:18.029726David SuddingIt is very clear that Barrhead High School is no longer at the same standard as the other East Renfrewshire Secondary Schools. As a school where the staff and parents have worked so hard to improve the achievement, ambition and attaintment of the pupils they require a building that is fit for purpose. I'm always worried when a country finds hundreds of millions for it's members of parliment to work in a truly amazing environment but it's young people are getting educated in an environment that is now sub standard. Must be difficult for the decision makers to look the pupils and staff in the eye.23952015-09-21T10:22:34.249727D StevensonSchool librarians play an invaluable role within schools and they should not be made redundant in an attempt to cut costs. It is unrealistic and unreasonable to expect 6th year pupils and teachers to run school libraries. 23972015-09-21T12:05:21.7539729Victoria SutherlandThe school librarians are an invaluable service within our schools and have led the way in my local authority designing a researching skills topic that staff and pupils use. This has provided teachers and pupils with a resource that enables all pupils to access the new CFE curriculum and enable them to achieve a high standard of success. They cut down on the time taken for pupils to access research materials that are integral part of the new courses and to lose them would mean some of more disadvantaged pupils would be worse off. They host homework clubs and other extra curricular activities and it is inexcusable to think that 6th year pupils or staff have the expertise or time to run this crucial service.23972015-09-21T13:37:56.749730Ted EasdonSchool libraries & librarians are ESSENTIAL to education.23972015-09-21T17:22:23.3979731C CooperOur school librarian is responsible for getting my son to read books. This has had a very positive impact on his English, not only in that subject but also in improving all his written work. She has created a nurturing environment in the school library and by getting to know the pupils has been able to recommend books and organise interesting literary events such as author events and the CILIP Carnegie Shadowing Scheme. This has instilled in my son an enjoyment of books which I believe will continue to enhance his education in the future. I hope that all school pupils will be able to have access to a fully qualified librarian now and in the future - a great asset to our schools.\r\n23972015-09-21T18:13:27.6939732Joyce McleishOur school librarian is one of the best resources we have. Her knowledge of her subject and our needs in the various subjects is superb. We cannot lose this valuable member of the school.23972015-09-21T19:25:12.8979733Stephen McDonaldThe falling literacy rate amongst young people in Scotland has been well documented of late, and so the decision to implement cuts on the school library service across the country, hugely detrimental to the attainment of children at any time, seems incoherent, bordering on negligent. The acquisition and application of skills is currently high on the Scottish Government's educational agenda, as seen in the roll out of Curriculum for Excellence - for this to be fully realised school libraries must be protected from cuts to staffing.23972015-09-21T21:45:34.1779734Kevin McGlynnWe need more rail beyond the 'central belt'23822015-09-22T08:40:38.389735Roger GriffithSchool librarians are an integral part of a school and do far more than people will realise if they have not seen them in the school context. Using senior pupils to replace them is not a functional or sensible suggestion.23972015-09-22T08:57:00.8179736Alison MackSchool libraries are a vital resource for our young people and should be staffed by a fully qualified librarian. In our school the librarian is invaluable as a resource and fully support and is involved in the learning being taught in our school.23972015-09-22T10:49:37.2539737David RobertsonI great resource to have and a useful additional space for children to study if they have difficulty finding that space at home.23972015-09-22T15:41:03.9239738Sheila MillerA professionally trained school librarian is a valuable resource to teachers and pupils equally. They are equipped to guide users to properly evaluate educational resources both online and in hard copy format. Their experience and knowledge cannot be replaced by Google and Wikipedia. The attack on school libraries by educators looking for an easy target to save money is short sighted. Our society will be poorer if their demise is allowed.23972015-09-22T16:02:22.7379739Lesley HamiltonMy children were introduced to books from birth. Not every child is so lucky. If a love of reading is instilled early, the child has a gift for life.23972015-09-22T16:40:31.059740Gemma OrrockBooks not bombs or banks. 23972015-09-22T16:50:47.4279741Finlay MenziesIt may seem rather surprising but without my school library I would never have pursued my career as a professional golfer!23972015-09-22T17:03:32.5679742Allison BrisbaneSchool libraries are sanctuaries, magical places where children can read unconstrained by academic demands. The right school librarian with the right book at the right time in a child's life is truly transformational.23972015-09-22T19:07:06.4579743Michael Kerins author storytellerI passionately belive in the importance of schools' libraries - ... A great and nobel Scottish tradition should not be cast aside.\r\n23972015-09-22T20:16:51.3179744Rachel CairnsWithout my school librarian I would have no idea how to write a dissertation. School librarians are huge assets to Scottish schools.23972015-09-22T21:41:01.559745S McWilliamlibrarians are vital in a school, they encourage reading to our children 23972015-09-23T10:38:27.749746Patricia LogueSchool libraries are a must, they encourage children to read.23972015-09-23T11:38:02.859747christine TriayIf resources like this are to be cut then how can we say we are providing good education for our young people. A Library as we all know is a rich resource especially in a secondary school as it provides important back up material for regular study as well as help for all kinds of pupils and especially if the librarian is creative as ours is. Authors are brought in to school , slower pupils are given better chances , youngsters are encouraged to read in this day of ict and some have their capacities for writing developed. A very short sighted and foolish act to close a school library.23972015-09-23T12:02:58.2079748Susan KennedyLibraries and librarians are vital resources!23972015-09-23T14:06:43.6139749Rosalind BirdThe school library services are vital to education. They not only provide the books for background reading, but can provide a wealth of other resources to facilitate better learning. Without them, children will miss out on wonderful learning experiences.23972015-09-23T14:10:00.2679750Elizabeth Anna Mullins Schools need this valuable resource23972015-09-23T14:11:25.3479751Susan ConwayLibraries help to address social and educational inequalities.23972015-09-23T14:27:19.3639752Richard BrookingBoth my children attended Barrhead High in the 70's and 2 off my Grandchildren will shortly be moving up to High School. I live near the School and pass it every day. The general decline in the structure of the school is apparent and it's time ERC got their act together23952015-09-23T14:55:19.2679753E Allan A Library - especially staffed by a librarian as active as ours - is an incredibly valuable resource, particularly in a secondary school.The professional knowledge and the resources amassed by librarians help pupils at all levels, from Advanced Higher students to S1 book groups. Authors are brought in to school , we have a Reading Champion in Cathy McPhail, youngsters are encouraged to read for pleasure as well as academic study. A very short sighted way of cutting spending.23972015-09-23T15:55:49.5039754richard david williamslearners should have equal access to a qualified school librarian ....THERE GREAT !!!!!!!123972015-09-23T22:37:23.5179755Karin Doig From babies to older generations library's and librarians are a strong asset to our learning . I am a childminder and regularly attend Rhyme time sessions with all my young children which brings their speech on leaps and bounds.23972015-09-24T11:10:09.3339756Lee DottI feel very strongly that all schools should have a library and librarian to support teaching and learning.23972015-09-24T11:44:32.669757Lesley ParrIt's children and libraries! Shouldn't need a petition!23972015-09-24T12:14:32.69758Murray HamiltonYou cannot expect to provide a quality education in schools without a library and skilled librarian. This is a massive step in the wrong direction.23972015-09-24T14:28:05.389759Aileen WilsonThe school library is at the heart of every school and crucial to the learning of all our young people. Without the guidance and support of our school librarians to encourage the development of our young minds we will be seriously failing our young people for generations to come.23972015-09-24T14:26:07.5339760Anne ThompsonEvery child should have access to a well stocked school library run by a librarian. This will help to educate and inspire children and enable equal access to literature and information for all. 23972015-09-24T15:21:16.3339761 Frances Vaughan, ScotlandI was a school librarian for eleven years and I am proud to have helped many with literacy and research skills. KEEP THE LIBRARIES.23972015-09-24T17:29:11.3939762Alison BowdenSchool libraries and school librarians are a vital part of how we educate our children. We simply can't lose them or see that service diminished. 23972015-09-24T19:12:25.6739763Iain McRobbieScotlands schools are being starved of funding and resources, many have already lost their libraries it's time to stop the rot and to fund schools properly.23972015-09-24T20:34:35.499764Dolores DevlinI took the time to read article and understand issues.\r\nI shared a similar article yesterday,so why when I have bothered to submit an email address, has this ( my ) signature been rejected?23972015-09-24T20:46:34.5339765Judi Rumbleas a former school librarian whose last school (after I retired) sold off all the books and turned the library into an extension of the computer room, I want all school children to be able to use a good school library with a professional school librarian in charge. They deserve it.23972015-09-24T21:12:24.1739766Audrey GilliesThe school library is a place for students to work where they wont be disturbed by disruptive eejits and where they can meet other students to discuss issues they have. Some may not be able to complete work at home due to familial problems so giving them a safe place to work is important and shouldn't be taken from those who rely on it. I know our school library played a part in helping me get to university as itvwas a quiet study area where i could exclude myself from the chaos of the common area and actually get work done. As well as getting some good tips from the librarian herself! 23972015-09-24T21:53:34.0179767MICHAEL GEORGE BURKEwell done keep up the good work23822015-09-25T06:38:23.2379768Ellen HughesMany children only have access to school libraries and this is great starting point for encouraging reading and interests.23972015-09-25T08:24:49.4579769Laura LangThe school library service is absolutely vital to the life of schools. Our librarian is one of the most valued member of staff that we have and our library runs so many worthwhile and life enhancing events for our young people.\r\nIt is a resource that just simply cannot be removed, wake up everyone, fight for all young people to have access to such an amazing service!!!!23972015-09-25T09:23:07.1139770James McFaddenLeave the librarys! We need them for our education.\r\nTh library's are a great service to schools becaause they help pupils and teachers to learn and to find more information on projects and it helps the pupils to read things they wouldn't usually read. I think the library's should be left alone because they help us pupils understand things we wouldn't normally know, its a good resource to pupils and teachers.23972015-09-25T11:00:08.1739772Aileen CameronSchool librarians can endorse literacy skills and teach research skills to enable pupils to become better learners. They can show pupils where to get reliable information and teach them to judge where to get reliable information to help with schoolwork, homework and life!23972015-09-25T12:33:49.6439773Cliff Van DortLibraries and Librarians have a wealth of knowledge and skills to pass on to learners, losing the library would only be a detriment to the students, teachers and community. Greater investment and recognition of libraries and librarians is greatly over due, they should be treated fairly along side teachers, effectively used to deliver the curriculum especially in the areas of information use and information literacy - skills increasing in importance in all aspects and areas of life. It will also relieve the pressure on teachers, helping them to provide better education possibilities to their students. Look at the success and effect many Librarians have brought to schools not just in the UK but across the world, don't be short-sighted, its not all about the money.23972015-09-25T19:58:12.9279774Paul CorfieldIt should not have come to this petition.. The council should know that there is extensive subsidence in the schoom gym. 23952015-09-25T20:02:03.8639775Shona McMurranMy 14 year old already attends Barrhead High School and my youngest will go next year. The school is falling apart. A hazard to all pupils that attend. A more up to date school will help all children concentrate better and progress. They deserve the best in Education that they can. 23952015-09-26T09:22:27.749776Hilary PetrieSchool librarians have the opportunity to provide support to all school pupils to learn core information handling skills and to support literacy. A professionally trained librarian offers a fantastic support to teaching and learning for both pupils and teachers. This resource should be available to all our learners - not dependent on their postcode or the size of their school. In terms of literacy the school librarian is best placed to know about new young people's literature as well as to encourage and support reading.23972015-09-27T10:59:21.9739778Enid ForsythI'm a librarian (worked in the health care sector where folks get pretty good access to the literature) and would like to see kids in school continuing to get access to the skills of librarians as well as to stock23972015-09-27T13:50:56.169779Claire WrightA crucial resource for our schools23972015-09-27T15:34:05.339780Denise Robertsonsave our libraries23972015-09-27T15:48:04.6439781chris flemingthe internet has stopped our kids from going to research things in book form , it is also giving the kids option to copy and paste instead of learning them to write , also the books are a lot better than the films so we need the libraries to get kids to read books before the films ...and libraries also give access tot hose who cannot afford internet and faxes etc save the libraries23972015-09-27T15:58:53.1479782Daniel SowsberyEdumacation for the WIN23972015-09-28T10:18:28.39783Dewi ThomasSocieties need libraries, I don't need to write War and Peace to explain the obvious reasons why....23972015-09-28T11:30:30.7239784Lawrence MarshallAs I see it, two options spring to mind for running such a service. A Glasgow, Stirling, Alloa, Kincardine, Dunfermline service. This would probably terminate at Dunfermline Queen Margaret, beyond which are loops which will enable the train to reverse out of the way of other traffic. This could also be extended to Cowdenbeath to reverse if timings allowed. Another option is to reroute the Edinburgh to Cowdenbeath terminating service to Alloa and then via Stirling to Glasgow. This would be achieved via reversal at Dunfermline Town rather than by building, as some have suggested in the past, a chord bypassing Dunfermline Town.\r\n\r\nAs for where stations should be provided between Alloa and Dunfermline, Culross certainly springs to mind. I leave it to the councils and others locally to determine where other stops should be.23822015-09-28T17:23:37.1779785Michael EllisTo think that we've come to a point where we have to sign a petition to save libraries and \r\nlibrarians, seems ridiculous to me. Of course we need libraries, you crazy fools! 23972015-09-28T19:27:51.1479786Robert HorneThe Town of Clackmannan would also greatly benefit from a passenger platform. This was raised as part of our recent Community Action Plan prepared in partnership with the Coalfields Regeneration Trust.\r\nWould be really good to get some direct community benefit out of this line now that the freight is going to stop. Dont forget about us !!!23822015-09-28T19:33:37.729787Doreen MillerMy son started primary 1 in August. The school bus drops off around 0840hrs. He is in the playground with one other p3 child alone. No staff on duty till 0850 in playground. I wouldn't leave him alone anywhere else. After complaining bus now comes a wee bit later and we don't rush out the door! As an ex police officer involved in Dunblane I can't believe that this lack of supervision is allowed.23052015-09-28T21:01:51.2079790Wendy PalmerOver the past year, while dropping my own daughter off at school I have 1. Aided injury, 2. Stopped a 4yr old wandering off school premises, 3. Stopped a child running into the road to retrieve dropped money and 4. Broken up some bullying. This is the reason I wont allow my daughter to be unsupervised in the playground prior to school. I strongly believe that schools should be given resources to provide an appropriate level of supervision for those children who's parents devolve responsibility for their safe arrival at school. 23052015-09-29T12:00:28.669791George WilliamsonThis page is really frustrating ... Too much hassle just to sign a petition ... Don't think I'll be revisiting any time soon ...23972015-09-29T12:36:43.779792Sheila PerryThis area of Fife is not currently served well by public transport - other rail lines are opening - why not this one?23822015-09-29T14:30:22.9439793ModeratorFAO George Williamson. Sorry to hear about your frustration in signing petitions. We'd be happy to add your signature to this (and any other) petition for you. Please email your details to petitions@scottish.parliament.uk. Thanks.23972015-09-29T16:47:22.8139794Zandra StuartMy 4 year old and 8 year olds are dropped off school transport at 8.40 in the morning, it is an absolute disgrace to think they will not be supervised. My children are never left alone at any other time why does authorities think it is right to be unsupervised when our children are under there care at school where it's supposed to be a safe environment! What tragedy needs to happen before someone listens to us! 23052015-09-29T19:36:48.7079795elizabeth oatesI thought every school has a duty of care from the time the first bell goes until the home bell. Who else would be responsible for the children at this time?23052015-09-30T08:46:11.39796Mrs A WatsonI truly believe that all schools deserve a full time Librarian. With the many distractions of games consoles, social networks, texting and talking on mobiles, children today are inundated with more and more technologies. If we do not ingrain the pleasure of books at an early age, instead of handing a two year old a I Pad we are socially excluding them from the pleasure of discussion. Many children today are locked away in their rooms interacting on social network sites, games consoles or mobiles. They are losing the skills to interact socially with other people.\r\nEvery school in the country deserves a Librarian to encourage children and parents to enjoy the pleasure and relaxation from being able to read a book, newspaper, magazine, graphic novel or even a cereal box. 23972015-09-30T14:16:16.9579797Shirley MillerI work in a school and the library is very important and useful for my classes. If it was not in existence then it would affect the education of the children in my school.23972015-09-30T17:27:29.249798Sheena BeckThis would be a great asset to this area of Fife.23822015-10-01T08:51:53.6939799Mairi Therese MitchellI work in this Secondary School and the Librarian and the Library are integral part of the 'Learning - Literacy, Research' etc. of the pupils.23972015-10-01T12:42:43.169800Clare CampbellThis would greatly benefit the lives of all my family and friends in West Fife23822015-10-01T14:26:54.589801Garry Campbell This would not only benefit the local transport services, it could be a welcome boost for tourism. 23822015-10-01T16:00:40.2839802Elizabeth McKay, Children's AuthorI can hardly believe that in 2015 we are even having to discuss this. Schools contain books, books are found in libraries, libraries are accessible to all children, therefore all children have equal opportunities to read, learn, enjoy and imagine.23972015-10-01T17:17:43.5339803Colette DugganSchool Libraries are a vital part of our children's education which should be about leading out, not just putting in - to paraphrase Miss Jean Brodie (who I met in a book).23972015-10-01T22:55:27.1439804john scott School is falling apart I would build just one high school in barrhead but make it a lot bigger just shut st Luke's because that school is the same its falling apart because councils won't fix the repairs 23952015-10-02T09:42:40.3139806Anne PattersonI am a teacher in a secondary school and our school librarian is invaluable - she promotes reading and literacy through her knowledge and skills. She has encouraged and inspired many pupils to pick up books, join debates and improve their research skills.23972015-10-02T14:41:03.8479807Elizabeth MellorA library outranks any other one thing a community can do to benefit its people. It is a never failing spring in the desert.\r\nAndrew Carnegie, industrialist, philanthropist and SCOT.23972015-10-02T17:02:22.479808Irene McConnachieEducation is the key to a child's future. Each child should be able to access the same standards and quality of education as their peers. This is clearly not the case for the children of Barrhead High where their environment and facilities are not fit for purpose. Come on SNP put your money where your mouth is especially when it has just been announced that you have underspent your budget last year by £347M. 23952015-10-02T17:33:47.0979809Sue RobertsWe have a brilliant school librarian who is worth her weight in gold - not just for providing a rich and stimulating supply of books but for her enthusiastic and knowledgeable support of a wide range of subjects. Librarians are a crucial investment in our children's education - and that means their (and our) future.23972015-10-02T22:03:23.979810gina joyceschool libraries offer such a fantastic service to teachers and schools23972015-10-03T08:15:13.9279811Abigail WilsonThis should absolutely be the case - there could be 4 year olds getting off school transport with no supervision. We should be waiting for something terrible to happen before this is changed. I would be in serious trouble if I left my 4 year old unsupervised so that absolutely shouldn't be the case where they are dropped at school - to save a few pounds! 23052015-10-03T20:15:00.3139812David RoscoeReading is so important for our youngsters and for some this is their only access to books!23972015-10-03T21:10:39.2079813Margaret Campbell BellA qualified School Librarian is essential to support teaching and learning for the benefit of the pupils and staff.23972015-10-03T21:22:48.9279814william lawrieSchool libraries are a vital part of our childrens education23972015-10-04T18:18:02.1139815Nicola dalgarno There is also breakfast clubs so yes in my opinion there should be school attendants supervising 20 minutes before school 23052015-10-04T21:14:03.7239816Lorna Ann SullivanThe library and the librarian are essential in maintaining a varied approach to research and learning. Everything possible should be done to retain this facility.23972015-10-05T15:23:23.2079819Alison VaseyThe school librarian is not a teacher and therefore youngsters have a person on site who can be more approachable. 23972015-10-05T23:06:43.1279820Tricia CassidyThe school was done over 30 years ago when I was there didn't think it would still be there for my kids 23952015-10-06T09:57:27.5979821Pauline RushFor almost a decade Labour Councillors have used the promise of a new Barrhead High to obtain my vote. Other schools in the East Renfrewshire catchment have been replaced and still our children are attending a school which is a crumbling wreak. Enough excuses, enough false promises! Barrhead children deserve better.23952015-10-06T21:18:00.7539824Diane wilsonThis is our kids future -\r\nThis school hasnt changed since i was there over 25 years ago !!! 23952015-10-07T11:54:29.729825Lesley KellySchool libraries should be properly resourced. In secondary schools they should be open until 5pm to offer somewhere for pupils to do homework, to provide support, to assist with research etc.. This will help to close the 'attainment gap' - a key priority of the Scottish Government. 23972015-10-07T13:52:08.749826Paulene GrantWe have this facility already in West Lothian and can't quite imagine dropping a young child off at the school gate with no adult supervision. Assumed that this was normal... Cannot believe it is not in this day and age! 23052015-10-07T17:18:40.0839827Marion McGunniglePhotos of the crumbling Barrhead High will be collected and posted online.23952015-10-07T17:40:23.0839828Anne WilsonPrimary 1 children up 90 children are left with one PSA to supervise them for around 1 hour each day. Where else could this happen i adult to 90 children ratio and how do their parents feel about this. In large open spaces too. We need to get his sorted as this is so unsafe and so unfair on the single adult trying to look after them.23052015-10-07T21:20:59.2879829Brian ChaplinMakes sense to me to link routes and towns, this being another good example23822015-10-07T21:44:35.7379830Chris BartonUnlike the new Borders railway the new service needs to be fully electrified from day 1 as UK currently has a disroportional diesel dependence vs continental Europe.23822015-10-07T21:57:28.8939831Elisabeth Joan Wright Black GarrettI have observed first hand the value of the school librarians in Scottish schools. Although not specifically classified as teachers, they do, however, work in concert with teachers and provide essential guidance and tools for students allowing them to complete assignments in a timely manner. Scottish school libraries continue to generate unique programs tailored to preparing students for success in the classroom. Please continue to support this valuable asset to the Scottish education system.23972015-10-08T00:43:48.529832Ron Mc LeanThis should have been do years ago, why should people have to go Haymarket from Stirling and Alloa to get Fife, when there is a direct route making easier,trains can run from Glasgow Queen Street to fife via Stirling and Alloa , so get on with it Transport Scotland and Scottish goverment.23822015-10-08T08:50:13.8479833Angus StewartThe railway is there use it23822015-10-08T15:03:56.9279834Mary DohertyIf the government is hoping to 'close the gap' in attainment levels it seems preposterous that they think schools don't need librarians. For pupils who are not fortunate enough to benefit from support and resources at home the school librarian has a huge part to play in 'closong the gap'.23972015-10-08T15:14:41.2079835G HughesLibraries are absolutely vital in raising attainment in both primary and secondary schools. They are central to high quality teaching and learning and must me fully staffed and maintained if Scottish education is to progress.23972015-10-10T12:33:01.979837John McGhieI fully support this petition. There is a long and very close relationship between the two countries which should be fostered. I lived, for a few years, just outside Kingston in an area by the name of Stirling Castle. Amazing! 24192015-10-10T18:29:12.1739838William McLeanGreat idea24192015-10-11T09:44:41.749839Joanna StebbingsAt our school-Children are the responsibility of the parent until the bell goes and children should not be dropped of early unless a parent stays. However I do agree with supervision of children who get the school bus-maybe school bus times should be altered. Who is going to pay for supervision before school starts?23052015-10-11T10:17:51.639840Sharah HandyI'm a Jamaican and living in Scotland and I believe this should happen. Build a positive relationship between the two countries as we go forward and try to make a positive change. 24192015-10-11T14:27:16.119841Angela DohertyPay up for the sick way you treated these human beings24192015-10-11T20:37:56.839842Grant RobertsonFor the sake of some track remodelling at Alloa station, and some fairly minor track & signalling upgrades between Longannet & Dunfermline, the existing Glasgow to Alloa service could be easily extended to Dunfermline or on to Edinburgh. Extra stations along the route could then be built. No need at all for the new & costly "Charlestown Chord" that Fife Council support, this need 2 new junctions and a bridge over Grange Road in Dunfermline, why divert services away from Dunfermline, the biggest town on the route? Existing signalling at Charlestown Junction allows trains to access either platform at Dunfermline Town & reverse to Edinburgh. Services could either be Glasgow - Stirling - Dunfermline, Glasgow - Stirling - Dunfermline-Edinburgh, or more imaginatively Glasgow - Stirling - Dunfermline-Leven 23822015-10-11T23:25:44.1279843Debbie GrayThe school has been classed as unfit for purpose a new school MUST be built to secure a good education with the proper facilities for our children to flourish in the future. The government have to release the funding and quickly. 23952015-10-12T11:05:51.559844Debbie JackI just find it unbelievable that this history is so untold in Scotland. As a teacher I feel this history should be taught in schools . It is a shameful history that we should understand and own in order to learn from it and now be proud to be a country which would fight against such a world. Many school children learn so much from the Malawa experience in school. Imagine how much they would understand the world by having such positive links with Jamaica. 24192015-10-12T13:34:19.1439846Margaret WestSchool libraries offer an crucial means to empower young people to becaome good citizens. They spread culture, open minds and offer tools which can be used throughout a person's life. 23972015-10-12T19:29:39.3779847John CawleySchool libraries and librarians are priceless resources. A library is a learning resource, a social space and an irreplaceable and invaluable doorway to a wealth of cultural riches. 23972015-10-12T21:18:06.7839848Morag WattI am the daughter of the Rev. William McGhie who designed the Jamaican flag with the Saltire. I loved my childhood on the island and am so proud of my dad's contributions to Jamaica.24192015-10-13T00:00:13.4739851Jane Ann ListonThis would plug an important gap and lead the way to establishing a west-east Glasgow-St Andrews rail corridor via Stirling, Alloa, Dunfermline and Kincardine.23822015-10-13T08:33:20.5839852Audrey SutherlandSchool libraries support pupil development and help raise literacy and attainment. Both are critical for the economic and social well being of Scotland. School libraries and school librarians support the development of independent lifelong learners by teaching information literacy skills and providing access to a wealth of information and knowledge not readily accessible elsewhere.23972015-10-13T08:35:16.0039853Jerry BrranniganLocal councils are being forced to run down their libraries, dispose of trained librarians and 'share' trainee librarians - schools are meant to be a safe place of learning, how can this be possible when access to books are being refused.23972015-10-13T09:35:00.0179854David-John PittsSchools are places where we as children, and the more we learn and have access to knowledge the better scoop we as people can grow. In a time when there is a multimedia, books still have a place, they can inform, they can teach but more important they can help a child learn and understand in a way that the internet can't.\r\n\r\nTo cut or reduce this service, is irresponsible and damaging every single child ability to grow and learn.23972015-10-13T09:55:55.059855Vimla RandhawaThe school library is heavenly sanctuary of any school. The heart and soul of all learning environments. 23972015-10-13T11:48:47.8979857R LewisHaving grown up in Scotland with a Jamaican parent, I learnt informally about the deep historical links between the two countries. It is time that this history should be told. Scotland has benefitted so much from Jamaican blood and soil. We must uphold the nations values of justice and compassion and strengthen these links for positive development and change.24192015-10-13T19:34:18.6279858carolyn Hargestthe school library is important to help kids value reading and for a lot of extra activities it provides23972015-10-13T20:37:56.529859Mark RussellThe school library should be the heartbeat of learning for all pupils across Scotland. Our passion for learning, our passion for promoting literacy and our passion for our school community make us the right profession for helping to close the literacy gap. 23972015-10-13T23:22:39.339860annita charltonneighbour of John McGhie in kingston jamaica24192015-10-14T01:03:57.8139861Joanne Meneceur Worrying. 23052015-10-14T07:31:30.9739862Dorothy Dwyer The historical evidence is overwhelming. This union is a must.24192015-10-14T07:56:47.3139863Margaret SmithIs a vital tool for the children's Higher education and needs to be staffed by librarian .23972015-10-14T20:05:26.699864Kieran C MurrayThis is a very serious matter, Scottish Government, u urge you to do the right thing and give back and help empower the people of Jamaica to overcome the serious hardships they are now facing. Scotland is a very wealthy nation, and can well afford to assist in whatsoever way can help. One love. 24192015-10-15T10:06:10.419865Anne InglisAlmost my whole working life was spent as a school librarian, a job which I loved and which I knew had an impact on thousands of school pupils. The only negative element in my job was constantly having to justify my role and the existence of a role in a school which focuses exclusively on literacy at a time when our country so needs that focus. How short sighted can our government and councils be ?23972015-10-15T10:05:05.9879866Jayson Smith - Softlink Europe LtdI work very closely with a large number of libraries across all sectors, as a result I get to see first hand not only how you all enrich people's lives but also the immense struggle you face in defending your budgets and in some cases the basic need to have a library. \r\n\r\nIt is great to see you all coming together to take action and raise awareness. I may not be able to join you in person but I hope a signature helps towards making a difference.23972015-10-15T10:19:33.7239867Philip KingscottI wouldn't be the person I am today without the opportunities my school library gave me.23972015-10-15T10:33:30.3139868Christine IrvingSchool libraries and librarians are essential for lifelong learning and are at the core of the CfE. They play a key role in literacy across learning - critical literacy and information literacy.23972015-10-15T17:40:46.8179869Thomas BreslinAs a former Head Teacher in a deprived area I am very aware of the importance of a qualified Librarian. I am shocked at the way the service has been allowed to deteriorate and indeed is being targeted for further cuts.23972015-10-15T22:10:57.2239870Ryan VanceAside from being places to learn both within and outside of the curriculum, school libraries can be safe zones for children. I say this from experience. During breaks, before roll call, after the final bell has rung but before the staff have gone home, school libraries provide somewhere to go for kids who need somewhere other than the playground or the lunch hall or their own homes, and often the library staff are the guardians of these safe spaces. And again from experience - it's not the kids who are doing alright who need these sanctuaries. It's the ones already at risk. The bullied, the anxious, the awkward, the loners, the kids who haven't yet grown into themselves. Cutting library funding won't just harm young people's ability to learn, it will remove an emotional and psychological support network from those who need support. Libraries are not just books, they're people - and we should support that as best we can, not cut away at it.23972015-10-15T23:04:16.6739871Anne BaconFor some young people the school library is the only place they have access to real books.23972015-10-16T10:16:41.6739872Scott ThomsonThe library was a huge part of my school life and was a vital resource for so many areas. 23972015-10-16T12:03:31.5979873Jim DartnallUrgent attention required on this subject because most of or river banks in Moray are affected.24222015-10-16T12:45:28.9739874Margaret ButlerI thank God for this initiative. It is long overdue. I pray it will have outstanding success.24192015-10-16T13:00:53.339875Felicity BramwellEffective School Libraries teach essential research skills and promote enjoyment of reading without which education is ineffective.23972015-10-16T13:42:10.7079876Gilllian McNeishThis should have been done years ago to stop these invasive plants.24222015-10-16T14:11:15.6939877Roland ColeGreat idea and worthy of support. Will benefit both peoples. Maybe a documentary in support and outline case?24192015-10-16T14:24:56.9739878Mark RussellFor many young people today the library is a place of learning, and with a librarian who is fully qualified, it enhances their learning experiences and opens up the world of literature and information skills required for the knowledge economy of the modern world.23972015-10-16T15:59:34.89879Brian McGillschool libraries are a vital support for learning for all teaching departments and an important resource for pupil research even in these days of internet access as a librarian can provide expert help in directing pupils to the relevant areas.23972015-10-16T18:17:29.059880Ann MurrayNational government does need to ensure proper funding for schools but let's remember that it is local authority education departments and schools themselves that will choose this cut over other options - a test of the value they place on reading, research and information management skills.23972015-10-16T20:35:18.6939882graeme leestime to clean up all the rivers in Scotland, make them excess able to fish and walk. These plants are making the River banks un -usable 24222015-10-16T21:52:25.3339883MARGARET E. AndersonI am appalled that particularly Giant Hogweed has been allowed to get so out of hand in this area, and commend Innes Community Council for submitting this petition.24222015-10-18T08:22:38.089885Hazel HerdThis idea will benefit both the people of both countries.24192015-10-18T11:36:53.9879886Jennifer AllanDemocracy in Scotland has been sidelined, since political leaders no longer listen to the people they serve.23082015-10-19T16:27:35.389887Paul KeebleA small step toward addressing a huge injustice, rather than recommending "moving on".24192015-10-19T23:42:17.229888David StrachanThe Scottish Government need held to account. They just pay lip service to the importance of education to our children. Is it any wonder education standards are falling under this government when the facilities are so poor. Nicola Sturgeon talks about how education is such a priority, well it is time to deliver for the kids of Barrhead high.23952015-10-20T10:24:34.059889Catherine ShearerI believe that the nation if Scotland has closer links to Jamaica than any of nations that we have already \r\nestablished as Priority countries.History is \r\nconclusive in supporting this claim. I believe that Scotland would have much to gain if this partnership was established. As has previously been said,our school children would benefit from projects with Jamaica such as those already established in Malawi. These projects are of great moral value for the young people involved. These young people are the future of our nation.24192015-10-20T15:38:22.7239890Gary CollinsIt is vital that this proceeds23952015-10-20T21:09:19.0179891Thomas StrachanAnother fine mess initially caused by East Renfrewshire Council not listening to the public23952015-10-20T23:13:24.449892Derek CassidyLet the Scottish Government demonstrate it desire to be different as a country , and where better than our local communities and with our youth . So come on it is too long overdue let Barrhead get a new high school fit for the 21st Century 23952015-10-21T13:42:43.9579893Janet KiddThis would let owners of pets killed on the roads know that they hadn't just strayed. It's awful not knowing what happened to a much loved pet.23862015-10-21T19:12:57.3639894Maureen Brodie Yep I totally agree. 23052015-10-21T22:44:46.389895Michael REIDEradicate Invasives24222015-10-22T00:59:52.419896Rehab AufOver the past few years, the Scottish people have spoken in every occasion to make decisive decisions e.g. referendum, MP election...etc. However, their vote, although decisive, is inadequate to have their voices heard. There is a growing need to know what concerns the Scottish people in the streets, before they are in grieve trouble. It is with such civil movements, their voice can be heard. Given the higher interest in politics, specially for younger generation, a civic forum will find better support from the public, perhaps to maintain its funding later on. The timing is important now to give a a full chance for the Scottish people to be heard.\r\n\r\nI quote Mr Salmond statement in the last election: "The Scottish lion has roared", so your parliament ought to provide every opportunity for the voices of the Scottish people to be heard via this forum and similar opportunities.23082015-10-22T18:58:59.1479897Julie CarmichaelIm not sure the definition of "pet" how much extra time would it take cleansing to scan all "roadkill".23862015-10-23T16:17:24.4879898Alastair G KennedyThere is no doubt that prompt action is required to ensure INNS are tackled across Scotland. Some voluntary attempts have been made but these have been mostly in small areas and very often towards the mouth of a river eg River Spey. Unfortunately such work is largely ineffective as re-seeding occurs when seeds are transmitted, mainly by water, from further upstream.\r\nMost burns, rivers and waterways are now badly affected - mostly by giant hogweed and little effort is made to change the situation. Obviously hoping this work gets done voluntarily has not worked.\r\nOne really wonders where non-action is leading and what state the countryside will be in and how many people will feel the very painful and ongoing effects of these plants unless legislation is set in place to ensure landowners destroy INNS at source.\r\nLegislation should give authority to the appropriate bodies which should be tasked with starting work with landowners at the headwaters of waterways, overseeing the eradication of INNS on such land and working downstream so that no further waterborne re-seeding can occur. \r\nLegislation also requires to be strong enough that it is not less costly for landowners to refuse to do the work on eradication.24222015-10-25T14:48:15.9879899Margaret C. McConachieThe rapid spread of Giant Hogweed has been worrying me for years. 24222015-10-26T08:10:11.5039900John DuncanJamaica has a lot to offer that simply does not grow in Scotland. Scotland can provide education, renewable energy expertise and a gateway to Europe.24192015-10-28T15:23:18.3139901Quintus FarrellThe skin piercing and tattooing regulations impose an unnecessary burden on my business and do not appear to improve safety or efficacy to the profession or for the public at large. 24302015-10-28T18:23:33.69902Will Leschen Whilst I think what you are doing is a good thing speaking honestly Im not sure if it will have that much impact on the Scottish parliament and associated civil servants - since Scotland historically has v strong link with Malawi as its main developing country which it wishes to support - originally through Stirlings Jack McConnel - I think they are unlikely to dilute the aid and support programme they send to Malawi for other countries - With respect I would suggest its far better to effectively use your time and resources in building more specific and focussed beneficial linkages between the two countries - also to look to build stronger more effective and beneficial networks with and between 1st 2nd 3rd generation Jamaicans living in Scotland - also with their fellow countrymen and women back in Jamaica.24192015-10-28T22:08:55.8779903Yasmina FerriganAcupuncture is not a permanent piercing & it stimulates healing & promotes health.24302015-10-29T12:14:51.919904Claire MarcelloAccredited acupuncturists are qualified practitioners and are vetted before being added to the register. Tattooing for instance does not require such qualifications, and poses a greater risk, due to the permanent placement of ink under the skin. Piercing inserts and implant or source of infection and at a deeper level of penetration than acupuncture needles. \r\nMy personal experience is that acupuncture has treated me for chronic pain, stress, anxiety and fertility issues as wel as IBS both safely and successfully, and where conventional medicine could not. The practitioners deserve recognition for their expertise.24302015-10-31T00:55:44.559905Lansana BanguraThis petition is well over due and I hope that it will bring much needed action this problem which if not taken will create the country side a no go area. They are dangerous I say this because I have experienced their debilitating effect every summer for well over 18 years. I can assure you it is not pleasant. 24222015-10-31T18:31:32.2379906Ruari WilsonI am kept in very good health through regular sessions with my acupuncturist - I trust him totally and know that he meets high professional standards24302015-11-01T07:07:43.279907Graham CampbellI am supporting this effort as Chair of Flag Up Scotland Jamaica because Scotland and Jamaica are already sister and brother nations. The blood sweat, toil and tears shed by Jamaicans in chattel slavery bondage over 300 years created the the commodities (tobacco, sugar and cotton) that made Glasgow and Scotland rich. This is about recognition that Scotland owes Jamaica a huge debt of gratitude that it can make amends for by helping to develop Jamaica's economy and society now. For example better, health, transport, educational, cultural and trade links, will begin to redress the economic imbalance. We could also be recognising Jamaicans as a more central Scottish diaspora nation. This petition starts that process rolling.towards a day when the efforts of enslaved Africans and oppressed Caribbean colonial subjects are fully and transparently acknowledged.24192015-11-02T10:43:51.889908John PintoWe need a formal International body, which includes former slave-owning nations in Europe and North America, to address the damage caused to the Caribbean and Americas to formalise long-overdue reparations to countries concerned. I lived for 4 years in Jamaica and saw the legacy of Slavery's effect on the present day there, and in Haiti and Cuba. The Scottish Government should push for creation on an International body to right this civilisational wrong.24192015-11-02T13:08:02.639909Kevin G McGheeThis has to be looked at and excepted. Many years ago I asked the former SNP Andrew Welsh to look into this, hopefully it will now be sorted.24302015-11-02T17:44:08.1139910Isobel Ganderton I hope that this is looked into and actioned for those it affects.24302015-11-02T20:23:30.369911Rhian WrightThe charges Edinburgh impose on acupuncturists aren't based on anything specific (that we know of). They seem to have pick a numbers out of the air. It should be based on transparent reasoning.\r\n\r\nHow can there be such a vast difference between what one local authority charges compared to others24302015-11-04T00:02:37.5179912Denise Violet StewartThe BAcC membership should be sufficient. It covers all criteria. 24302015-11-05T16:38:30.779913Tom MinogueThere is a need for civic forums as the existing set up with local authorities is too political party orientated and community councils are a mixed bag and can be too easily dominated by special interest groups influenced by developers.23082015-11-16T11:38:32.669916Naheed McquadeMy daughter Shaheen has been left devastated by losing Zach however she is absolutely committed to helping other mums, to avoid the same heartache she will live with for the rest of her life. 24482015-11-16T12:39:00.949918Aisling O'BoyleI hope that the government will take note of this petition. To see friends go through this absolutely heartbreaking experience when a relatively simple test could have prevented this makes this even more devastating. I urge everyone I know to sign.so that this can be prevented from occurring again. \r\nMy love and thoughts are with Zachs mummy and daddy hope they can change things in his name xxxx 24482015-11-16T13:10:13.1439919Zara MalikThis is a great thing to do in order to prevent it from happening to other people. 24482015-11-16T13:10:31.7539920Tricia BradyWorda cannit express thr pain felt whrn a baby dies . If this can be dedected while still in the woom then the government must act x24482015-11-16T13:17:18.1439921michelle murrayTo lose a baby under any circumstance in heartbreaking and life changing for everyone involved. This however could be easily prevented by a simple test. This needs to be a standard free test for all pregnant women so that these little people have a chance at life. 24482015-11-16T13:52:00.69922Alison mitchellSuch a preventable tragedy 24482015-11-16T14:14:30.8639923Georgie GallacherSuch a tragedy that so easily could have been avoided if this test was done 24482015-11-16T14:19:45.3179924Charlene Logan It's so easy just do it give these babies a chance. X24482015-11-16T14:27:19.1139925Theresa McWilliamsHave no idea why this is not routinely offered to mums to be. Babies lives are put at risk for a few pounds. 24482015-11-16T14:42:35.3979926Claire mcmonagleXxx24482015-11-16T15:00:59.7379927Joanna McGrawAs a mother myself I feel strongly that this should be offered to all pregnant mothers as the loss of a baby is completely devastating. Anything that would prevent the loss of any child should be considered compulsory to ensure the safe delivery and life of our children.24482015-11-16T15:27:13.1139928Laura kyleAll mothers should be offered this No parents should have to loss a baby24482015-11-16T15:30:57.2539929Ann moffatI feel very strongly about this please save all babies 24482015-11-16T15:35:01.3339930John tuna pierreLove you guys!!xx24482015-11-16T15:37:26.4239931samantha higginsevery mum should be tested! 24482015-11-16T15:43:30.3939932Jackie keanEvery mother should be tested I was tested and I had it with my first but it didn't show up second time round my baby had the antibiotics at birth which saved his life X 24482015-11-16T16:07:52.2079933Kim hunterXxx24482015-11-16T16:32:16.1939934Paul Gallacher X24482015-11-16T16:33:13.2239935LyndownieTime for a move in the right direction , too many now 24482015-11-16T16:37:30.749936Carol Ann Little It's about time this was done! 24482015-11-16T16:34:50.479937Tina molloyThis should be routinely offered especially to avoid such tragedy. Good luck X 24482015-11-16T16:35:18.7079938Carol Ann Little It's about time this was done! 24482015-11-16T16:39:24.2539939Esther HunterIt is imperative that this test should be offered to all mothers immediately. There is nothing worse than losing your newly born baby - no pain is greater. Don't let Shaheen's little baby's death have been in vain! 24482015-11-16T16:45:50.999940Lorraine BettleyShould be offered to all mums during pregnancy and before labour. Not doing this screening has devastating consequences. x24482015-11-16T17:58:49.4579941Donna Kellie This has to become routine checked 24482015-11-16T18:36:09.089942Maureen O'ConnorNo parent should have the devastation of losing a child because a simple test wasn't offered. 24482015-11-16T19:53:19.0839944Elizabeth lightbodyThis a something that can be prevented should be given to everyone help save a precious life24482015-11-16T20:22:44.4439946Claire Aitken It is imperative that all babies should be tested x24482015-11-16T20:20:52.89947Alexandra GilmartinAcupuncture is not an 'alternative' therapy and is now considered mainstream, backed up with a growing evidence as to its efficacy. It should be considered medical, and therefore should be exempt from the licensing fees.24302015-11-16T20:40:54.1439948Joe conoboyThis should not need a petition but should be a matter of due course. Having my own grown up children and now grandchildren I cannot understand why we can allow a baby to die when it is so preventable. No cause or monetary value can ever be an excuse for allowing the death of a baby or any other human being for that matter24482015-11-16T21:14:27.0979949Kathryn MclarenPlease stop these unnecessary deaths. Every baby is precious.24482015-11-16T21:22:48.7539950David DevineThere is no reason why pregnant mothers should not be made aware of the dangers of group b strep. This change must be implemented urgently to stop any more mothers having to suffer what Shaheen is currently suffering.24482015-11-16T21:22:31.8139951Rebecca Adam Should be on offer for every mum to be!24482015-11-16T21:37:02.3339952Demi walker X24482015-11-16T21:45:02.9739953Dem Watson X24482015-11-16T21:54:15.9739954Lorna GoodwinI was told I had tested positive for Strep B after being discharged from hospital with my 1 day old baby. I don't want any parent to experience those feelings of terror.24482015-11-16T22:31:14.2079955Gillian Telfer Should be an automatic offered to each mum24482015-11-16T22:31:56.2239956Laura McEwanThis test should be made compulsory during pregnancy. I only knew about it through another mum but so many women don't know and it can be the matter of live and death. Why play games with the lives of innocent babies when it only costs £11 each. 24482015-11-16T22:35:07.169957Laura McEwanEvery pregnant women should receive this test during pregnancy and shouldn't need to ask for it. we are playing with the lives of innocent babies for a mere £11, how can that be justified!? Someone needs to open their eyes 24482015-11-16T22:37:06.619958Lynsay garvieI went into labour 7 weeks early and was tested to find out I had strep b which could be passed on at birth. Every women should be tested for this 24482015-11-16T22:40:50.7379959Marion MacLeodEvery pregnant woman should be made aware of and be routinely tested for Group B Strep.24482015-11-16T23:14:31.3139961Nikki Geddes I was positive with lily n they didn't give me the antibiotics until 50 hours after doing the test, when I'd been in the hospital for 7 hours already ........I had to then beg to be tested with belle n thankfully was clear. It's scary!24482015-11-16T23:21:17.619962Danielle Walkerxxx24482015-11-17T07:06:57.6779963Charlene foster This should be offered to every pregnant woman what's more than important than saving a baby life with a simple test ? 24482015-11-17T07:06:29.3939964Carrie TownsleyNo family should have to go through the pain of losing their child when the cause is preventable!24482015-11-17T07:38:53.4739965amanda mcqueenThis should be done to give new born baby's a chance to start life .24482015-11-17T08:00:16.199967George Morton Scotland has a history with Jasmacia24192015-11-17T08:17:02.9579968Nicola Steven Xxxx24482015-11-17T09:28:05.869970Lynn Rendles Xxxxx24482015-11-17T09:33:55.6439972Lynn Rendles Xxxxx24482015-11-17T09:44:13.9739973Francine sharpe A very brave and an inspirational woman in my thoughts 24482015-11-17T09:45:15.6279974Amanda williamson1 child losing a life is enough. A simple test is enough to prevent this heartache and pain 24482015-11-17T09:48:41.69975Lyndsay mcmanusXxX24482015-11-17T09:48:46.479976Kelly Hamilton too many baby's life's are lost! This test should be done!!!24482015-11-17T09:55:13.8479977Heather FindlayDecisions need to change and babies lives need to be saved nobody should have to experience the loss of a baby because of the lack of a straight forward test! Xxx24482015-11-17T09:55:25.449978Lyndsay mcmanusXxX24482015-11-17T10:04:42.6139979Laura brownI had strep which was passed to my daughter..resulting in her getting meningococcal and septicemia . Horrible . Let's get these simple tests sorted out ..no one should have to lose a child xxx24482015-11-17T10:02:55.1279980emma slikeXxxx24482015-11-17T10:09:37.5379981Roxanne TurnerGood luck and best wishes to all who have felt the heartache from this sad story. 24482015-11-17T10:06:58.839982Julie kellyX24482015-11-17T10:17:50.3179984Stacey Foy Xxxx24482015-11-17T10:15:24.2079985Mags Thomson Xxxxx24482015-11-17T10:15:25.4239986Kirsty Stewart xxxxxx24482015-11-17T10:19:41.029987Jacqueline freemanX xx24482015-11-17T10:21:06.669988Jade Robertson xxxx24482015-11-17T10:24:51.8179989Angelina TalloIf something is preventable I am heartbroken that parents have lost a precious baby to this when could have been avoided! Everyone sign and pray no one else will suffer such an ordeal xx24482015-11-17T10:29:31.1939990Scott buntingSomething so small can make a massive difference!24482015-11-17T10:55:32.3779992melissa greenThis should be giving to every pregnant woman and to help give babies a good start x24482015-11-17T11:16:38.2879993Lisa cassidyXxx24482015-11-17T11:17:43.5039994Stephanie rileyXxxxxxxx24482015-11-17T11:41:01.089996Paula sharkieXx24482015-11-17T12:07:57.669997Sheena BlackmoreA simple test that will save lives.I have had experience of this through my grandchildren and is so unnecessary to put people through this horrific time with their children.Luckily ours pulled through but not always the case.24482015-11-17T12:46:08.669998Janette Simpson Everone of my friends please sign this x24482015-11-17T12:53:15.9579999Maureen VerrecchiaSo sorry for your loss xx24482015-11-17T13:09:46.14710000Nicole fraserKnow one deserves to go through the pain of losing a child 24482015-11-17T13:23:13.78310002Stephanie mclellan Sorry for your loss x x 24482015-11-17T13:28:43.9910003Claire HendryI only discovered I had Strep B following the birth of my 2nd child. A very young midwife happened to read through my previous notes and found it in there that an infection swab taken at first birth showed strep B. However during my 2nd pregnancy I was never told I had tested positive for this. Following delivery myself and son were both given antibiotics by this quick thinking nurse and thankfully he was ok. However I should be made aware of this. \r\nI'm really very sorry to hear about your son Zach xx24482015-11-17T13:31:33.64310004PAULINE GRAHAMplease can everyone sign this24482015-11-17T13:40:46.0510005Louise scottI had this with my son. its terrible that something so simple could save lives n that not very many people know about it . I didnt have a clue what it was and i dont think many people do . Please sign this and save a life and parents the heartache . Sorry for your loss and well done for trying to help others xxx24482015-11-17T13:49:10.37710006Christie greenfieldHas to be a check put in place for babies life's too precious 24482015-11-17T13:54:04.0210007James McAuley God bless u wee man xxx24482015-11-17T13:58:00.06310008Julie AtkinPlease ensure all pregnant women are checked for this.24482015-11-17T14:24:59.97310009Annetherese McFarlanePlease screen all pregnant women as a standard procedure24482015-11-17T15:05:02.7210010Sandra BURROWSTo read that this was preventable was totally shocking. This has to be a routine check.Thoughts are with those devastated parents.24482015-11-17T15:44:50.73710011Candice Wark Thinking of the family. Such a shame for the loss of this baby. X24482015-11-17T16:07:41.110012Rena weirAll pregnant mothers should be screened, this is a heartbreak for parent to go through . My family's thought are with this young couple.24482015-11-17T16:26:47.92710013Margo RichardsonThis story brought me to tears and no parents should ever have to lose a child, especially when it could have been prevented xx24482015-11-17T16:27:03.1110014Elaine McAteerSo sad to hear this Shaheen. This test should be compulsory.24482015-11-17T16:45:01.6610015Lorna NelsonI had this with my youngest daughter and had never heard of it before lucky this was picked up later in my pregnancy as I had recurring urine infections but this should be checked as standard, lucky I was give antibiotics during labour and my baby girl was fine.24482015-11-17T17:31:46.9910016Sean McQuadeMy baby nephew was took away from us because of something that couldve been prevented. Let make sure no family has to go though what my family has!! 24482015-11-17T18:27:21.75310017Nicola mcwhinnieMy heart goes out to you i really do hope this makes a differrnce and they make the changes x24482015-11-17T18:30:27.28310018Leanne McGraw My son had strep b and was on a drip for over a week in intensive care baby unit. He was fine after that ... but I didnt know much about it or realise how dangerous it was till this happened to my son x scary times x he made a full recovery and is a fine healthy 5 year old now. X 24482015-11-17T18:35:28.86310019Lee HughesI'm carrier of Strep B and didn't know until I had my daughter. We were very lucky that she took I'll before we left hospital and was treated with broad spectrum antibiotics straight away. She's now 17 and there's not a day goes by that I realise how lucky I was to bring her home. Please help other mums to be to bring their babies home. Xx24482015-11-17T18:38:33.53310020Sharon JohnsonSo sorry for your lose, I hope your petition is successful xxx24482015-11-17T18:43:57.2210021Claire JohnstonThis simple test should be given to all mums to be!\r\nReally proud of you Shaheen for highlighting this campaign. You should have never had to say goodbye to your angel x x x24482015-11-17T19:04:51.89310023Michelle KaneSo sad for your loss. This test must b compulsory. X24482015-11-17T20:06:49.2710024Jacqueline MorganWe lost our son Patrick 20 years ago ,2 years later our son Callum was born at 12 hours old he was diagnosed with Strep B he fought the fight never the less was touch and go,he was lucky..\r\nIt is paramount for all pregnant mums to be tested for Strep B keep fighting this cause.24482015-11-17T20:19:14.44310025Myra stevenson God bless xx24482015-11-17T20:45:10.6110026Cheryl dollin No parent should have to go through the heartache of losing a child like Shaheen Craig & so many other couples have. Especially when it is such a simple swab that could prevent these devastating consiquences. Time for things to change! 24482015-11-17T21:02:32.53710027Sandy morrisonWorked with craig in London at t2a was heartbroken when I heard about what happened so sad this test should be compulsory24482015-11-17T21:13:46.3310028Laura RileyXxxxBaby ZachxxxX24482015-11-17T21:25:00.1110029LISA RobertsonMy son was born with group B strep and rushed away from us and kept in ICU for weeks. They left me for 5 days with no waters. Maybe they wouldnt have if theyd knowen he was at risk.24482015-11-17T21:40:16.22310030Sam Nesbit Poor girl & boy havin to do that when this could have been preventable for all the test costs!! Joke so itis such a we happy content looking baby just shows u if The nurse would have swabbed the girl would this hav still happened?! 24482015-11-17T21:46:18.81710031Leeann LennoxI was told late on in my pregnancy I was a carrier for this , we were lucky our baby girls bloods came back clear, no one should have to endure the horrendous suffering you have both been through, let's get this law changed. Sending lots of hugs to you both and your family xxx24482015-11-17T21:51:27.5510032Joe ThomsonChanges must be made now !!!24482015-11-17T23:01:30.42710033Michael MacLeodMy wife had this in both pregnancies, treated for it during labour with our first baby but it was only picked up just after birth with our 2nd. We were so lucky, many aren't. This test should be routine and every pregnant woman should be made aware of group b strep. 24482015-11-18T04:55:27.45710034Kathryn ScottNo parent should have to go through this nightmare when it can be avoided so easily! What a brave family for trying to stop this tragedy happening to someone else.24482015-11-18T07:33:51.89310035Avril NisbetThis simple and cheap test should be compulsory. There are quick, easy tests that can be done at very little cost to the NHS. You cannot put a price on a babies life. No excuses.24482015-11-18T07:57:43.9410036lauren darrochNo parent should have to go through this for something that is so inexspensive and takes seconds to test for. X24482015-11-18T10:06:14.56710037Natalia owensI had Strep B when I was carrying my little girl. They didn't read my records until after she was born. She got rushed away to get antibiotics into her system for 3 days. It could have been prevented if Wishaw General read my records before I even got there. There's a lot of people who have this infection. No one should ever go through this heartache x24482015-11-18T13:15:19.4710039nicole Glackin i think all pregnant woman should get the strip b vacation am pregnant my self and would hate if he took ill couldn't bare to lose him24482015-11-18T17:04:29.7710040Lynn Stevenson It such a simple test. Surely testing is more cost effective than having newborn babies seriously ill and in high dependency for weeks? Or worse.24482015-11-20T05:03:07.51710042Agnieszka JohnstonSo many tragedies should have been prevented! Not asking for much..just a simple test! 24482015-11-20T08:34:14.25310043Clifton WicksAs a practising acupuncturist with over 20 years experience of private practice and 9 years in the NHS, with a Master of Science Degree from the University of Wales, I regard it as totally unreasonable to be treated differently from other similar health professionals, e.g. physiotherapists, chiropractors and osteopaths in the matter of licensing. This discriminating and demeaning anomaly deserves to be corrected forthwith .24302015-11-21T17:03:49.110046Helen MurrayIgnorance is an Evil weed. Which dictators may cultivate among their dupes. But which no democracy can afford among their citizens. 23082015-11-25T14:17:37.22310047christine sloanA Degree Course in Acupuncture includes thousands of hours study and should not be compared to a skin piercing businesses.24302015-11-25T15:47:23.0510048Maureen BurrowsAs chairperson of Lennox Community Council which covesr Fochabers to Portgordon by Buckie in the North East of Scotland the subject of Hogweed is constantly on our agenda and we feel we are fighting a losing battle trying to contain it. It is a huuge problem on the banks of the river spey.24222015-11-25T21:26:50.67710049Lisamarie Buchan All pregnant woman should be tested for this not asking for much...24482015-11-26T03:53:08.9110050laura mcinultyCan't beleive this isn't already being done to be honest! Change is needed!24482015-11-26T08:36:07.1910051Emma mcclenaghanUr doing amazing shaheen!! Totally in awe of ur strength xxx24482015-11-26T09:03:24.810052Margaret Anne McNaughton This is something that needs attention our friends list s gorgeous little boy as s result off this not being carried out. It's he was only two weeks old and no one should ever lose their baby over it24482015-11-26T10:59:51.44310053Mike BlackA simple test to save a life, its a no-brainer really. Why would we not do this ? It may be statistically a low risk but obviously has a very high impact when it does happen. 24482015-11-26T16:12:15.01710054Mechelle CrichtonGSB has to be tested for in ALL pregnant women prenatal and postnatal to ensure no more precious lives are lost. Follow the lead of other countries and invest more money in research and raising awareness! 24482015-11-28T00:33:55.64710055Lydia Reid The test must be cost effective but even if it is not it is not a price any baby should have to pay \r\n\r\nThey have a right to our love and care but also to our protection \r\n\r\nThis test is a must \r\n\r\nI am sure Scottish Government will listen when the case is put to them 24482015-11-29T00:26:49.25310056Nora Lennon God bless you hen wonderful what you are doing xxx_24482015-11-29T06:43:16.42710057Stacey Kane I believe that no mother should go through the headache of loosing a child especially when it could be prevented. This should be undoubtedly carried out no questions asked. So proud of you shaheen for the awareness your raising in order to stop this happening to anyone else xx24482015-11-29T07:45:06.97310058June DudgeonThere is the vaccine available to prevent this why not use it to stop further loss of our future Generations. 24482015-11-29T08:13:39.03310059Julie BrownThis test should be gave automatically. No babies lives have to be lost. X 24482015-11-29T08:17:35.31710060Amanda mccallum In total awe of your strength and courage to help in the future to prevent others enduring the pain u have suffered loosing your beautiful baby boy! You are a true insparation to any parent mrs. Lots of love x24482015-11-29T08:23:46.92310061Eileen ewingNobody should have to suffer the loss of a child especially when there is a simple test to prevent it!! 24482015-11-29T08:47:39.03710062Elanor LochoreThis is very close to my heart my oldest son who is now a healthy 7 year old thank the lord! was born with group B strep and after 9 days of antibiotics he got better but this should never have to happen to our babies one simple test can save lives or save then from permanent disability.24482015-11-29T08:48:31.81710063Linda Doris All mums to be should be tested for this if their bab's life is at risk. 24482015-11-29T09:18:10.70710064Audrey watsonWe need more awareness24482015-11-29T09:26:54.62710065Angela wilsonI teach pregnancy and baby classes and have had so many ladies thankfully tested and antibiotics given. We cannot lose another precious child. Sleep well little one xxxx24482015-11-29T09:38:17.22310067Victoria withersHow amazing and courageous of you to share your story, no one.should ever go through what you both have. Stay strong and your gorgeous boy is guiding you from above x 24482015-11-29T10:04:29.81710068Karen HuttonEach baby born deserves the best care this country can provide. Scotland prides itself on being proactive however in the case of Group B strep we are relying on testing during labour and reacting. A test during pregnancy is the only solution to saving lives. Please stop this happening to families who deserve more from our government.24482015-11-29T11:11:00.8310070margaret mary faganno parent should ever have to go through this one simple test could save a lifetime of heartache24482015-11-29T11:15:04.81710071lee montgomeryi dont know enough about this and would like to learn more about it24482015-11-29T11:53:19.36310072Elaine Lindsay My heart goes out to you. My son was also born with Strep B and is only here today thanks to a very experienced auxiliary nurse who thought that he 'just didn't look well' and initiated further tests. He then spent a fortnight in hospital , a week of which was in intensive care receiving treatment. Had it not been for this nurse, I would have taken my son home like you, untreated with likely fatal consequences. Other countries test pregnant women , so should the UK . Please sign x24482015-11-29T12:01:43.00310073Glynjs WhiskerThis story made me cry and feel angry that our NHS do not give information regarding a simple procedure which should be carried out to save a pecilus baby's life should be done - money is given to other countries to help them and as much as i may agree and disagree to a certain extent our funding should be given to NHS helping our own by doing the test 24482015-11-29T12:21:21.31710074june craigNo child or family should suffer this - a result of false economy. Step up to the plate, Ms. Sturgeon and take note.\r\n24482015-11-29T12:27:52.0210075nicole Glackin am writing this petition because am having a baby soon in a have never been offered the b strip vacation it should be offered to pregnant 24482015-11-29T12:53:06.03310076Alex StampI was lucky enough to find out i had group b strep due to another test issue so knew i had it but yes this should be a routine test without fail across the uk 24482015-11-29T13:46:02.42710077Michelle ChristieThis is shocking and could have been avoided poor family left devastated 24482015-11-29T14:03:45.17310079Dawn GilfillanI found out last week I had group b strep only because I went to the doctors with another problem . Angers, upsets, sickens me to think that if I didn't go to the doctors I wouldn't have known. I hope everyone signs this and this gets done on every pregnant woman to prevent it happening again! 24482015-11-29T14:16:27.59710080Brian KennedyA simple test that could save a life and a family from total heartbreak. it should be made available to everyone. 24482015-11-29T14:24:46.7410081Geraldine owensA simple 2 sec swap test could have prevented the loss of this baby and the heart ache of his parents. I had no idea of this until I read shaheens story. Why would this test not be done for every expecting mother!!! Make this test a necessity for all expecting mothers 24482015-11-29T15:21:48.89710082Caroline Singleton It's common sense to do this 24482015-11-29T15:26:25.81310083Nicole Maria Anderson you are doing fantastic shaheen. I am with you 1 million % on this. this test should be carried out at all times x24482015-11-29T16:44:48.2710085Emma ScottYour story is devastating, but very inspirational that you are able to think of others during your grief. So sorry for your loss. 24482015-11-29T18:27:55.95710086Carol DochertyWell Done for sharing the awareness totally needs to be done you need something positive to come from such a tragedy you are such a strong Girl x\r\n24482015-11-29T21:29:12.9110087Adele souterMy son was one of the lucky ones who survived this, but nobody should have to go through this especially when it can be prevented so easily. I was tested for my latter pregnancies which was great and an easy test! Everybody should be tested routinely x24482015-11-29T21:35:58.7410088Siobhan ShannonAbsolutely heartbreaking! No petition should be necessary, should be tested its a no brainer!!24482015-11-29T22:32:35.69310089Lorna TaitEvery pregnant woman should be tested to save other babies dying unnecessarily. So sorry for your loss, thank you for being incredibly strong & trying to help others xxx24482015-11-29T22:51:13.95710090jacqueline rossi am sorry for your tragic loss.we were very lucky that a swab during labour identified the risk and we were recalled back to the hospital and our son was put on precautionary antibiotics and his bloods monitored and we had a god outcome and our son iz now a strapping 10 yearold . if the midwife had not taken the swab, we may have had a very different ending. my thoughts are with you and i wksh you well in your mission.xx24482015-11-29T23:06:22.23710092Linda greigSo nice to see people trying to do some thing about strep b. I feel so strongly about this . I am a carrier of strep b which wasn't a problem with my first son.\r\nI lived in Bermuda a where a simple test was done antibiotics at birth not a problem .after a move back to Scotland a midwife that couldn't even perform a proper strep test ( on my request) my little born was born with infection thankfully I had the knowledge of strep and shouted this out while on the operating table. I feel for bad gorgeous your family. Keep up the great work xccc24482015-11-29T23:19:27.48710093michelle mctaggartThis I something I feel very strong about I did get tested and my son was fine but i knew i had it so things where good for us i know this is not the case for everyone's family xxxx24482015-11-30T00:15:54.4110094Gillian scpttI feel strongly about this as my daughter might not have been here if I hadn't insisted on a test while in labour! Turned out I did have it and luckily she received intravenous antibiotics right away. 24482015-11-30T00:35:50.4710095Katrina O'DonnellWake up and do something about this. Make the change and ensure noone needs to go through this horror and pain again. \r\n\r\nShaheen I don't know you. I'm extremely saddened by your loss. God bless. X24482015-11-30T10:26:46.70710097Karen KellyI was very fortunate to have randomly been tested and diagnosed with this. It should be available for everyone before and everychild after as even though mum may test negative my friends baby tested positive after she was born24482015-11-30T14:33:12.72310098lynn muirheadI had a random test for Thurs and it came back with strep b so I was luck because I made them re test me at 36 weeks. I received antibiotics b4 Beith and my bay boy was clear. We r 1 of the lucky ones.24482015-11-30T16:04:16.4110099Maureen Anne MclellanIt is a joy to be able to help any mother and child from distress.24482015-11-30T16:22:57.39710100Samantha jamesWe are one of the lucky families, I was tested for strep b at the beginning of pregnancy and it came back clear. At 37 weeks I went into labour with my son it was a difficult birth and once born he wasn't breathing they got him breathing and then tested him. He had strep b the hospital didn't even put him on antibiotics it was only once we got home and I rang my family GP he came round with the medication. As a precaution I was put on an antibiotic drip during my next labour. \r\nA test could so easily be done once the woman goes into labour and then she can be put on an antibiotic drip if necessary. There is not enough awareness yet there are so many preventable, senseless deaths in the uk every year. This needs to change right away. 24482015-11-30T18:24:19.20710101Mary McBrideMy wee Grandson was born on June 24 in the same hospital. He developed meningitis while still in there through strep B but luckily survived. The baby who died is the Grandson of a friend of mine and the family are devastated. A baby's life against the cost of a test, how could there be a choice in this. Every Mum should be tested.24482015-11-30T19:55:29.53310102Karen McConville I demanded one at 37 weeks as it had shown in a smear test several years before . I was told I didn't need one but insisted and it showed positive. Was given IV Antibiotics during labour. 24482015-11-30T20:08:05.56710104rosemary sommervilleGovernment should be ashamed that this is not a routine part of anti natal care!!!!24482015-11-30T20:30:24.3310105Lindsay Fearn I'm a paeds nurse & have seen the devastating consequences group B strep can cause. I demanded tested in both my pregnancies but this should be routinely offered to prevent needless deaths. 24482015-11-30T22:29:09.0210106Geraldine kearneyA had baby boy who died with group b strep24482015-12-02T12:31:11.56310107Emma MacArthurI think it's appalling that this is not a routine part of care. Heartbreaking to think how many precious little lives have been lost when it could have been prevented.24482015-12-05T00:45:42.3510109Jacqui Rossresults from a swab taken during labour had my baby boy readmitted and on precautionary antibiotics within hours of us being sent home .we had a happy outcome.without that test it could have been very different .24482015-12-05T09:28:48.64310110Maureen BurnettMy daughter very luckily discovered she had Strep-B 3 months before giving birth in October resulting in IV anti biotics during birth to prevent passing to her lovely son. There by the Grace of God 24482015-12-05T09:37:39.95710111Jackie Cowe Yet another example of our overstretched nhs having to cut corners and put lives at risk. I've never heard of this but would absolutely have demanded to be tested if I had. 24482015-12-05T10:50:35.70710113jane kerra loss that should have and could have been prevented. a loss that changes life's forever...heartfelt sympathies for loss of your gorgeous precious baby baby boy Zac x24482015-12-05T18:19:41.53310115Theresa Thomson100% agree with this small test that can save lives and stop parents having to go through there worst nightmare\r\n24482015-12-05T23:28:49.5810116Fiona carlinThis is absolutely terrible that any mother should go through this when a 2 minute swab can save so many baby's 24482015-12-06T03:31:41.81710117Jaclyn draperI was a carrier of this and only was tested due to being ill. This is scary for any mum to be and even worse if you don't know anything about it.24482015-12-06T09:45:40.6610119Jacqueline clarkI think This is disgusting why it's not a regular check with ever pregnancy all these poor Babies losing there little life before it's even begin for one little swab and it could have all been sorted 24482015-12-06T10:40:13.23710120Samantha Cummins Our daughter was a lucky little madem. They caught it early and was treated fast. To many people don't have a clue about it. I didn't until the midwifes kept telling me I had group b but I was clueless until our daughters breathing was rapid and shallow. She was rushed to Aberdeen maternity neonatal. The scarest thing in her little life. As a parent no one should go through that pain and emotional time of the unknown. Rip to all the little group b angels 24482015-12-06T12:20:12.1910121Margaret MartinThis test could have saved a beautiful baby's life ,please make the test routine in anti natal care for all mother's.24482015-12-06T13:47:24.7210122Louise Shaw With you 1 million %24482015-12-06T14:18:49.28710123Rosemary Bradley My heart goes out to parents who have lost there babies a simple test can avoid all the heartache 24482015-12-06T14:51:49.86310124Claire MahoneyShould be available to all pregnant women in GB.24482015-12-06T15:38:39.34710125Amanda smithFor Lacey gbnf x24482015-12-06T15:40:35.31310126Lisa Helen Stewart Absolutely heartbreaking this needs to be done.24482015-12-06T15:42:52.75310127kathleen foyStrep B testing should be an automatic procedure. But with the government we have, we actually have to sign a petiton, this is important!!! Please sign \r\n24482015-12-06T16:28:39.08310129Gill Cunningham Why oh why would we risk the life of a healthy baby for the sake of £11 - all mum's should have this test done as a routine part of their care!24482015-12-06T17:47:43.94310130Elizabeth Bolger This is such a sad story and the test MUST be given to every woman to stop this terrible illness killing more babies .24482015-12-06T18:27:10.09710131Val IrelandNever heard of this possibility. Surely a test should be done or at least tell the parents so they can arrange for a private test!24482015-12-06T19:07:33.28310132Christine PratleyThis test should be done worldwide, but let's start with Scotland24482015-12-06T19:17:03.19310133Amanda CrossSo sad . Why do families have to go through this when it can be prevented .24482015-12-06T21:56:36.3510136Karen Thomson I had this but I was lucky. It could've been a whole lot different. Please sign as it's so important!24482015-12-06T22:25:27.17710137Liz O'KaneThis is so tragic that something which can be prevented with a simple swab isn't available routinely in all pregnancies. The nhs should provide this to show that hey literally do everything in their power to deliver babies safety.24482015-12-06T22:25:38.87710138Lauren QuinnAll of my love to every family affected by this, such a sad heartache. Please make the change for the test to be compulsary for every woman in labour. I cannot imagine the pain this causes to every family affected by this. Everything possible should be done to ensure this cannot continue to happen. Rest in peace every little angel that Group B Strep has so cruelly taken from their families x24482015-12-06T22:25:54.31310139Pamela clark Should be mandatory on every child born xx God help the parents and help then raise awareness it might not bring there child back but will help others xx24482015-12-06T22:51:21.48710140Linda mccreadieYet another potentially fatal condition which can be tested for and dealt with. My son died due to vasa praevia which is also not screened for routinely. If the Scottish government are serious about reducing stillbirth and neo natal death rates, they have to introduce screening for both these conditions. Babies are dying needlessly!!!!24482015-12-06T23:04:51.3510142Natalie smith this is so tragic and sadly won't be the last time a life is lost due to this preventable infection. Other countries in Europe and Australia routinely screen pregnant women. We should be doing the same. I was shocked when I was informed of this ten years ago whilst working in children's intensive care. still can't believe we are n't screening. How many more babies have to die? My heart goes out to all those families that have lost their child. 24482015-12-06T23:27:26.81310144Catherine QueenGod Bless,what a beautiful wee soul\r\nThis should be routine!24482015-12-06T23:46:18.20710145margaret somervilleI had my youngest son in USA in 2006, they routinely test for strep B before delivery. So sorry for your loss.24482015-12-06T23:56:27.19310146Ashley Ellwood No parent should loose their child due to carelessness and £11. I'm discusted and heartbroken. 24482015-12-07T00:17:09.83310147Geraldine McCormackI had a bad pregnancy but was lucky enough to find out before I delivered my baby that I had group b strep I had no idea what it was when I googled it after the nurse told me I froze with fear as this was my first baby was terrified I would lose her but I feel everyone should be tested for it could save so many lives & help stop the devastation that losing a child brings. 24482015-12-07T01:50:46.4110148Jennifer CaldwellI am a Scottish mum living in Australia. My baby was born here in Australia where this test is routine. I can't believe this mother and others have had to go through this heartache when the test is so simple. Please make it compulsory in Scotland.24482015-12-07T03:14:01.3810149Elanor lochoreI am so sorry that another baby has lost his life to the infection. my first baby was diagnosed with group b step 2 days after birth he was born by c section but because I had been in labour for 25 hours he had already contracted the illness but luckily after 9 days of antibiotics he was fine .we are very lucky & thank God daily for saving our baby.our I was swabbed at 36 weeks pregnant with my second son I did not carry it although my son was a planned csection he got antibiotics a day later as he was showing signs so to be safe they just gave him them to help put my mind at rest.our babies don't need to die or be born with disabilities over such a simple test.NO FAMILY SHOULD HAVE TO GO THROUGH THIS.24482015-12-07T03:53:09.73710150Michelle OgborneSo sorry for yourloss, all of you. I hope you get tye result your hoping for x24482015-12-07T05:16:27.81310151Lesley OrrI have a son born in sept 2015 and paid for the step b test, it's should be routine for sure. 24482015-12-07T06:26:11.5810152Isabel Parker I am a grandmother and in this day and age think it's ridiculous that this is not done as a routine check save our babies.24482015-12-07T06:46:14.33310153Andrina PatersonTo think a simple swab costing £11 could have saved baby Zach. This should never be allowed to happen again.24482015-12-07T07:13:30.61310154Charlene richardson Shocking that a simple test could save lives24482015-12-07T07:11:42.37710155Leeon HeyNo one should be losing a child in this cruel way. Please consider the £11 test for every mother. 24482015-12-07T07:23:30.20710156Angela Mcgreskin This was only detected in one of my sons as he had a sticky eye and it was swabed straight after birth and he was luckily treated. But until then I knew nothing of strep b and was totally devastated when told about it and how very ill he became. Yes on I had another child but until I asked about the risk of having again and wanting tested, which happened and I got antibiotics before the birth and he was tested straight away. If I hadn't asked though I would have ran the risk of it happening again. All woman should be tested! When it carries such a risk to the health of your child or even their life.24482015-12-07T07:53:20.78310158Niall Kenneth Barclay Awful what parents need to go through before the people in charge consider something. 24482015-12-07T08:40:43.25310159Kimberley barkerThis is a terrible no women should ever have to go through this the nhs seem to be cutting more and more corners.it has to stop 24482015-12-07T08:38:15.8310160Dawn RobertsonToo many babies being lost to this. Should be standard test24482015-12-07T08:58:00.110161Jennifer HendersonSimple cheap test that could prevent such tragedies. I would even have paid myself for these tests to be carried out24482015-12-07T09:09:04.53310162Ailleen CassidyThis happened 2 me 23 years ago and its still happnin now ,,,I lost ms baby girl ,,,the pain never leaves u ,,,sore24482015-12-07T09:20:52.5210163AnnMarie SneddonI was tested for strep b 4 weeks before my baby was due but only because I had a history of it in a previous medical. There was no sign of any from my swab (which I had to do myself...) This is a bacteria that comes and goes - I was so worried it would return in the 4 weeks before my boy was born - however they did not check again! I was fortunate but there are so many cases where people are not. I am so sorry to hear of your loss and hope the government takes note.24482015-12-07T09:24:20.3510164Jacqui PirieNo baby or family should have to go through this when it can be avoided x24482015-12-07T09:24:43.0510165Claire Gallagher These tests should be made routinely !!! 24482015-12-07T09:31:52.6110166Claire DicksonI'm sure given the option all parents would happily pay for this, so they can't fob it off, saying the NHS can't afford to pay for it. 24482015-12-07T09:55:35.4410169Mrs Helen Rundell So sad that this is still allowed to happen. I am also a carrier of strep b and this was fortunately discovered when I was pregnant with my first son and I received antibiotics during labour and my son was delivered healthy with no complication. This was 15 years ago and at the time the midwife very much played the situation down, but it so happened that at the time coronation street had a storyline about a baby who died from this which lead me discover the seriousness of strep b. I also discovered that 1 in 5 woman carry this and could not understand at the time why it was not routinely swabbed for. I was lucky that they discovered this in my case and now have 5 healthy boys. The fact that this test only costs £11 makes it even worse. This has to be made a routine test!24482015-12-07T09:57:49.76710170Teresa BakerI had never heard of it few days after delivery they told me I had it I asked would baby have got it they said no. Wee girl was sleepy not feeding, unsettled 10 days old I was told she had it. I was handed a leaflet about it why hadn't I heard of it before. I was extremely lucky that nothing bad happened to her. Every pregnant women should be entitled to this test my heart goes out to all that lost their little angels xx24482015-12-07T10:02:32.4410171Janice LaurieA new healthy baby is the most precious gift a parent can receive. To have this life snatched away so unnessisarily is unbearable, especially when a simple inexpensive test could have prevented death and heartbreak. Make resting compulsory to prevent more needless deaths.24482015-12-07T10:15:46.03310172Suzanne Mcdowell I am shocked to hear we don't test for this! I got tested at 38 weeks here (Australia) as its maditory. I tested positive and was treated at delivery. At least offer it to be payed for.24482015-12-07T10:16:54.78310173Jackie MackayI had Group B strep when I was pregnant with my little girl and only managed to get 1 lot of antibiotics as my baby came so quickly but luckily after 24 hr obs, she was fine. Hate seeing all these babies losing their lives to this awful illness, when it can easily be prevented!!24482015-12-07T10:21:51.42710174Maxi McMillanAllow parent's to at least know all the information and even if it's to pricey allow us to pay for the tests.24482015-12-07T10:23:00.76710176Helen keenanIt is so devastating to lose a baby I think it's diabolical that this test can be done during labour and isn't even offers .24482015-12-07T10:33:59.4410177Patricia RamsayI think that these tests should be done routinely and that no baby or family should have to go through such pain unnecessarily 24482015-12-07T10:37:01.810178Melanie BennettI am so sorry for your loss, it breaks my heart to think of your child in pain before passing. I contracted bacterial meningitis as an adult and was very lucky to survive. I'm so terribly sorry that your baby didn't , preventative tests HAVE to be introduced and quickly. No mother should ever have to suffer the pain of losing her child. Thoughts and prayers are with you xx 24482015-12-07T10:39:16.0810179Sian KilgourThis should test should be given to all expectant mothers. I had to fight to have this test done with my second child even after my first born died (could have been prevented) through pre clampsya. No parent should have to bury there child x24482015-12-07T10:48:44.72310180Elaine McCulloch I am so so sorry for your loss and can't believe how many things the NHS don't do for parents and new borns, I had Strep A and got Necrotizing Fasiitis after c-section also could have been prevented with simple antibiotics, huge love xx24482015-12-07T10:53:11.78710181Aileen LeckieMy niece had this happen to her baby but was lucky they found it quite quick. 24482015-12-07T10:57:41.2210182Margaret Campbell My baby girl ended up in hospital at 10 days old with group b strep meningitis. We were lucky that it was caught and treated quickly and after a 2 week stay in hospital getting iv antibiotics she was able to come home with us. I am acutely aware that our outcome could have been so different and I am so sad for those who were not so lucky. X24482015-12-07T11:00:28.3610183Sophie ThorburnNo parent should ever have to go through the devastation of losing their child especially when it can be so easily prevented. I'm so glad I read about this when I was pregnant and asked to have a swab done, luckily I never had it but I never knew anything about strep b until I seen a similar story to this, had I never read about it and never asked for a test my situation could have been heart breaking but I feel so lucky and blessed to have a healthy, happy baby girl. I'm so very sorry for your loss and I send all my love to you, I would sign this 100 times over if I could, good luck with the petition and I really hope things change and every mother is made aware of this and is offered to be tested! 24482015-12-07T11:04:48.69310184Helen Donaldson20 years ago my son was given antibiotics as a precaution the moment he was born for another reason and I was told two days later that they had discovered the strep B and having the antibiotics had saved his life. No mum should have to go through losing their baby when it is preventable. 24482015-12-07T11:24:53.31710185Ashley KellyEveryone should be swabbed before labour. X24482015-12-07T11:46:16.6610188Lorraine MacIsaac£11 to the life of ur baby.....I Wld pay it myself if it meant spending the of my life with my child.....the choice Shld b there. 24482015-12-07T11:43:23.06310189J Macdonald I heard of a similar tragic story which led me to get tested privately. My results were positive. I was given antibiotics during labour and have a happy, healthy baby girl but it terrifies me that it could have went the opposite way if I hadn't read that story. 24482015-12-07T11:59:40.72310190Faye PritchardHope this is changed and more babies can be saved by simple swaps 24482015-12-07T12:13:50.08310191Linda HamiltonMy granddaughter had to be taken away soon after birth and given IV antibiotics for the same reason Luckily she survived This despite the fact that my daughter was told that she would be given antibiotics during her labour because of a chaotic ward and the midwife not heeding my daughters warnings that the birth was imminent it left no time for the antibiotics to be given Mother and baby had then to endure an unnecessary separation and the anxiety regarding the baby's health Andvthe worst part ? She was 17 years old yesterday ! Have they learned nothing in that time???? I am so sad for you no mother should lose her baby ever , but because of incompetence is too cruel May God bless you and keep your little one safe 24482015-12-07T12:16:29.2410192Kirsten EvansAs a mother of 2 little boys, I am incredibly sympathetic towards any one who has lost their baby due to this awful infection. Anything we can do to make this a mandatory swab for every women during labour, the better chance we have of preventing so many women and their families go through such a devastating cicumstqnces. Every life counts, and the more lives we save the better. 24482015-12-07T12:15:04.9110193Kirsty MartinSuch an easy way to save many lives, a must for any expectant mother ! 24482015-12-07T12:19:03.70710194Lyndsay Dickson This is a joke. That poor mother and all the other mothers that have lost their children. This should be a compulsory test given to all pregnant women. Reading about this really upset me and made me feel for all those parents deviated for their loss. 24482015-12-07T12:23:42.25310195Patricia brown I have just found out I am pregnant for my first time and could no amagin the heartache this mother must be going though I'm really sorry for ur loss and thanks for bringing this to people's attention xx24482015-12-07T12:26:15.78710196Pauline Gilchrist If this swap costs too much, at least give parents the option to pay themselves as I'm sure they would 24482015-12-07T12:32:02.0810197Julie morrison This need to be sorted it a joke NHS spend your money in other stupid things but can't help or babys24482015-12-07T12:40:52.810198Donna Sawers My friend was diagnosed with this during her pregnancy and got giving antibiotics when she went into labour. Thank god her midwife picked this up!24482015-12-07T12:54:42.17310199N.McilearOnly £11 pound to be swabed sure all mothers would pay that themself just to make sure there baby was safe and healthy, everyone should be tested 24482015-12-07T13:02:40.610201PATRICIA HOWDENeveryone should be swabbed24482015-12-07T13:14:24.0810202Jennifer WilsonI am so sorry for your loss of your beautiful son. And thank you for being so brave to try and stop this ever happening again.24482015-12-07T13:23:09.67710203Skylar storrieThe nhs should offer this to every mum goig into labour and should also raise more awareness so tragic things like this don't happen.24482015-12-07T13:26:30.86310204Mrs J PlumbBecause no newborn baby should suffer from life-threatening infections that are preventable, and would be prevented in other developed countries. It's time we in all parts of the UK caught up.24482015-12-07T13:26:32.0510205Lauren beagleSuch a simple test to protect your unborn. It makes perfect sense that it should be offered to all! No others should have to experience this tragic loss.24482015-12-07T13:32:08.78310207Gladys MontagueThis is something that should be done automatically for every woman in labour.24482015-12-07T13:37:13.6610208Elaine CadgerThis should be a routine part of care, so little could save a lifetime of heartache. 24482015-12-07T13:38:54.9110209Gemma Koca This should be discussed during your pregnancy by care givers and you should be offered this test. Most women would be happy to pay for the test themselves, I would. 24482015-12-07T14:06:31.59710211Christine mctavishI cannot believe that such a simple test could have saved a babies life and a family from heartache. I strongly agree that this should be a compulsory part of nurses and doctors procedure at the onset of labour. How many more people have to suffer before something Is done. Hope this makes the difference that's needed. 24482015-12-07T14:19:28.1310213Michelle frewNo mother should lose there child when a simple test can b done. We are meant to protect our children and everyone has a responability to do so 24482015-12-07T14:32:08.26710215Kirsty Davidson As a mum of 3 I was never made aware of this during any pregnancy. A simple, cheap test that could save the life's of newborns. This should be part of routine antenatal care.24482015-12-07T15:18:53.2410218Karen MurrayI can't imagine what you are going through , especially when this could have been prevented. God bless your little angel , sweet dreams little one. Xxx24482015-12-07T15:24:22.31310219Kelly JeffreyA child is priceless, preventable infection for a little as £11, there would less premature angle wings. I know if I was asked to pay, I would, without even thinking about it. 24482015-12-07T15:46:09.48710220June ThomsonThis is such a simple thing. If cost is an issue, offer it to those who want it, at the cost if necessary. I would rather pay the money than suffer the loss of a baby.24482015-12-07T16:01:13.6310221Catherine quinn There should be test for this infection as soon as admitted to labour ward if not before 24482015-12-07T16:11:53.72310223Caroline fergusonI feel strongly about this24482015-12-07T16:35:46.9710224Julie O'Shea I was tested during my first pregnancy for something else but the lab results showed strep b so was given the antibiotics during labour. And again during my second labour. I can't imagine what could have happened if hadn't got the test. The test is given in Canada so why not here? Some of my friends have also had it so it is more common than we think. But with all the tests they currently carry out why can't one more be added 24482015-12-07T16:42:21.810226Margaret priorNo parents should have to lose children...if this can be prevented by a simple test ..please make it available to all.24482015-12-07T16:56:20.81710227Mary jane wilsonMy daughter had this to but was given antibiotics and baby and mum were fine.24482015-12-07T17:06:14.51710228Valerie FieldhouseI'm disgusted to learn that a cheap simple test could avoid a devastating and tragic loss of a newborn baby!\r\nWHY? \r\nYET MORE CUT BACKS!!24482015-12-07T17:13:28.17310229Katrina beggsEvery pregnant woman should be tested in pregnancy for strep b it could save a lot of lives 24482015-12-07T17:18:30.84710231Linda GrahamWhat is £11 compared to a child's life and the anguish this causes? Even if the NHS decides that they cannot afford to offer this test the parents should be given the option to pay.24482015-12-07T17:24:06.9710233Sandra MacLeodI had GBS with my second child, and also with the 3rd. I was never checked during my 3rd pregnancy and as a result my little boy spent a week in SCBU. We had a very fortunate outcome, but there are plenty more who are not so lucky. It is such a common thing, why shouldn't every woman be checked for it in later pregnancy.24482015-12-07T17:29:44.1610234Stacey Kennedy I only found out I had it due to a slight bleed in later pregnancy , if it wasn't for that I would har had know idea and the outcome could have been very different 24482015-12-07T17:33:21.03710236Ashley robertsonI feel that if they are testing for down syndrome that isn't life threatening then group b testing should be mandatory24482015-12-07T17:30:26.6110237Grace burnsI agree 24482015-12-07T17:41:03.25310238Morag GostelowThis test should definitely be routine. My third son was rushed into hospital at 10 days old with suspected meningitis, he is 21 now and he is a fit and healthy young man, but nothing was really explained to me I was told it was just down to a virus, reading this poor girls story has chilled me as things could have ended so differently. This test should definitely be added as part of routine care. 24482015-12-07T17:50:13.48710239Bev kirkcaldyI feel strongly about this\r\n No parents should ever need to go through this. 24482015-12-07T18:00:47.5510240Cheryl hodder Please make this routine 24482015-12-07T18:00:39.1610242Lynne gillespieMy daughter had this when she was two days old. Thankfully she made a full recovery 24482015-12-07T18:13:35.89710243Sophie WhitakerI'm pregnant with my first child and would like to thank Shaheen McQuade as I first heard about this from her Facebook post unfortunately I wasn't able to comment on it for some reason. I would like to express my deepest condolences to you and your family I can't imagine what your going through. I am thanking you because you may have saved my unborn baby's life, there is no way to thank you enough however I would like you to know that you have made a difference.24482015-12-07T18:24:41.97310246Christine McMillanI can't believe that such a simple and cheap test is not administered, preventing such unnecessary pain and loss. Please rectify 24482015-12-07T18:25:34.810248Lesley ODonnellShocking when u realise how quickly this test takes!24482015-12-07T18:33:07.4110249Kasha MountThis needs to be addressed properly. When we test so many people for illnesses and infections that are self-limiting, have no long term effects, and can't actually be treated, in the name of.infection control, there should be a more robust approach to the issue.if infection during labour. The test should be routinely offered, and if not there should be a valid reason why it isn't common place.24482015-12-07T18:34:22.17310250Holly storyI think everyone should be tested for this i am lucky enough to have had this picked up on at 6 weeks pregnant !! So know to tell midwives immediately !! No one should be put at risk not being tested for this when it can cause your baby so much harm ! 24482015-12-07T18:43:39.0510251Avril LintonSeems such a simple & low cost test to save lives. There should be no doubt that it should be routinely carried out.24482015-12-07T18:44:31.39710252Patricia Cameron I really hope something gets done about what happened to that lady's baby as that could of been prevented with a simple test they tell you not to eat certain foods not to smoke or drink and something as simple a a swab test could of saved the little incident babes life.24482015-12-07T18:48:20.4110253Chirsty Sterry I had a scare five months pregnant with my second child and that's when I found out I had this and was also the first time I had even heard of it and for you to lose a baby from it it we should be made aware and tested with every pregnancy! Losing a lot of blood with my scare was the most scary emotional thing I have ever went through but I count my lucky stars it happened as I was out on antibiotics through a drip for my full labour and now my daughter is a happy healthy four year old. It could of been so much different. 24482015-12-07T18:49:47.5810254Nicola pollockA test for something else revielled I had this in my first pregnancy. Due to this my daughter was fine and I was tested in all 3 of my other pregnancies and am very blessed all babies were fine. Have never understood why this isn't routine tested. RIP all the little angels. My sympathies with all your parents xx24482015-12-07T18:52:28.50310255Bergdis Wilson This test should be mandatory. Scotland should introduce this test not least to show that Scotland has the best health care service in the world. Don't let the child mortality rate go up because of a saving on a simple test, not to mention save the great grieve of many parents.24482015-12-07T18:53:26.0510256Susan crawfordPlease stop this happening to anyone else. £11 is nothing compared to the cost of a life and the shattered life of those left behind. X24482015-12-07T19:06:44.4110260Karen McMathShocked to hear this is still happening. My son developed this, but thankfully survived due to excellent nursing staff in Rottenrow Maternity Hospital 24 years ago.\r\n 24482015-12-07T19:07:01.25310261Ryska WatkinsTo lose a healthy baby in this way is unforgivable. The NHS should make this test compulsory. If they think they haven't got the funding I am sure parents would happily donate what they could24482015-12-07T19:09:45.81710262Sara MacMillanA simple test costing £11, it defies logic that this isn't saving lives already. Please stop any more tragic preventable deaths.24482015-12-07T19:12:00.09710264Kati taylor£11 for a test that could save a life and stop families enduring such heartache is a small price to pay! 24482015-12-07T19:18:15.22310265Lynelle drainHeartbreaking loss that could be prevented! X24482015-12-07T19:29:38.00310266Hazel Borthwick For as little as £11 per test lives could be saved with this simple test. 24482015-12-07T20:00:43.810268alexina mcfadyenI do not understand why this test is not given to mothers.Is it the cost to the N.H.S. surely the cost of the ambulance that takes your sick child to the hospital is a lot more expensive.I send my heartfelt sympathy to all the parents who have lost their children and pray to God the government will listen.24482015-12-07T20:07:19.4110269Richard Pender No mother deserves this simple24482015-12-07T20:08:33.19310270Ann Marie MacLeanI was one of the lucky ones. GBS should not be claiming lives - end of. 24482015-12-07T20:15:02.33310271Angela NobleThis should never happen when there is a safe easy test to prevent such devastating heartache with the loss of a child get this sorted now.24482015-12-07T20:17:36.92310272Elizabeth LynchPlease do something...NOW. You have to start listening to those affected and help. Knowing this test only costs £11 is just heartbreaking! Sad to think its not mandatory, like it is in other countries. Time for changes.24482015-12-07T20:27:21.86310274Lisa kingmoney for evreything else including War but no this isnt in place! #disgrace 24482015-12-07T20:32:00.0510275Karen PalmerNo parents should have lose their children over a condition that is so easily avoided by way of a simple test 24482015-12-07T20:36:37.98710276Fiona McLeodSo so sad for you. I am in tears. I hope you succeed in making the change for all others.24482015-12-07T20:38:58.4110277Tracy swandellsWe can't let babies die and families go through he'll when there's an easy and relatively cheap solution. 24482015-12-07T20:52:38.50310278Lynn Stewart Should b done for all 24482015-12-07T20:59:36.98710281Barbara GarthNo parent should ever have to go through this tragic event, especially when it is so easily preventable, shame on you NHS24482015-12-07T21:04:50.0510282Jean HendersonNo parent should have to experience the loss of a child when a swab could prevent it !!!!24482015-12-07T21:02:31.20710283Kate Smith Hi my daughter is now 10 years old and i am very lucky that i found out that i had group b strep as i was taken into hospital a week before she was born due to bleeding and got tested for this. If i hadn't have had that scare my baby girl would probably not be here today. She was given antibiotics along with myself during labour and after she was born she was taken to pedeatrics for 4 days to make sure she was fine. I was very lucky but i know many who wasn't. Im sad to here that hospitals will still not offer this to pregnant woman. You should have a choice to get tested as its a baby's life that at stake. Xxx24482015-12-07T21:06:08.98710284Kerry-Lee West I lost my baby girl at 26weeks and found out that I have group b strep! A simple swab could have saved my baby, and many many others 24482015-12-07T21:13:09.03710285Sarah HomerMy waters broke 9weeks early so they tested me to ensure it was my waters and found that I had strep b, they gave me antibiotics during labour to ensure it didn't pass to my baby although he was 7 weeks early and had to be in high dependency he is healthy and here I hate to think if my waters hadn't broke i would never have know and he would of been at risk, this test should be compulsory I'm was very lucky24482015-12-07T21:20:11.4910286Katie Murray Thank goodness this didn't happen to my baby. Such a tragedy and shocking that this is preventable. I'm so sorry for your loss and wish you good luck in your campaign.24482015-12-07T21:20:17.78710287Amanda Thompson I also am a carrier of strep b. I only found out during my miscarriages when I had a swab. Thankfully when I had my 2 youngest I had antibiotic during labour. Even if they asked every woman to pay for this test would be better than nothing. 24482015-12-07T21:21:17.31710288Kathleen elliottMy heart goes out to you, it is unimaginable the pain you must feel for the loss of your son - I wish you every success in your petition and hope one day you find peace xxx24482015-12-07T21:18:06.73710289Kelly banksNo parent should have to go through this. If a simple swab can prevent this happening to another family then I say provide them and give us women the choice to have it.24482015-12-07T21:22:19.3510290Fiona BellI had group strep b throughout my whole pregnancy. Luckily it was picked up early and monitored. I received Iv antibiotics during labour and both myself and my son were perfectly fine. 24482015-12-07T21:21:28.20710291Julie PardoeI tested positive for GBS for each of the 4 swabs I had taken. The midwife gave me the final swab pack and asked me to swab myself in the toilet. Surely if they are happy for expectant mothers to carry this out themselves, they should make it routine testing for all pregnancies.24482015-12-07T21:26:19.8810292donna fraserI also lost a child to strep. I defo think thus test should be compulsory. 24482015-12-07T21:29:22.83310294Lynne ThomIt was discovered I had this during my first birth. Thankfully my baby and I were given antibiotics and he's a healthy 15 year old now. 24482015-12-07T21:33:41.2210298Gillian MuirNot Acceptable 24482015-12-07T21:36:01.50310299Karyn Psyl-ThomsonI am 35 weeks pregnant and haven't been made aware of this at all, seems like such a simple test to do to prevent something that can be fatal.24482015-12-07T21:36:28.37710300Sarah MunroCome on get on this and save little babies lives... It's a no brainier!! To many babies die everyday due to negligence from our govermants and health care including mine!! Babies lives should never be a cut back... Or part of a budget!! 24482015-12-07T21:37:09.9410301Margaret MclarenNo child should be lost to this disease when a simple test is available... cost should not be factor in saving lifes24482015-12-07T21:42:59.310303joeanne Bennett So sorry for ur loss x 24482015-12-07T21:39:55.12710304Julie HarronThere's no need for anyone to suffer this when a simple test can prevent it. 24482015-12-07T21:44:49.44310305Alex DunnSigned in memory of Mason and Eden24482015-12-07T21:48:37.70710306Chloe philipParents should know about this24482015-12-07T21:46:05.59710308Stuart GurneyMy wife and son were affected by this very same infection. Surely a simple test should be standard practice? My wife and son are both now healthy and happy but others weren't so lucky. They deserve this change.24482015-12-07T21:47:19.9710309Juliane SchroederI was asked if I had Strep B during pregnancy but I was not sure as I was never tested. I was told that if you are positive you are getting treatment. However, if you don't know you don't get any treatment or testing. This is a big mistake and oversight. Why risking the lives of newborns and causing so much devastation and heartache? I would even pay the £11 for it but it needs to be offered in the first place.24482015-12-07T21:53:07.08310310Jean LoveNo parents should have to lose children...if this can be prevented by a simple test ..please make it available to all.24482015-12-07T21:53:37.17310311Debbie bryanEven if the nhs or government do not wish to cover the cost of this test which should be a matter of routine please give parents to be the option of paying for this service. Thank you.24482015-12-07T22:00:09.0210312Claire mcmonies No babies should to be lost to something which can be easily prevented! 24482015-12-07T22:01:19.0510313Tricia Clark Please introduce this test ASAP. X24482015-12-07T22:03:47.310314Ashley Watson No mum should have to loss a child, but to loss one when it can be prevented is unacceptable I'm sure if the government cant afford to pay the £11 for the test that every pregnant woman would pay for the test themselves they should at least have the option surely!!!!!24482015-12-07T22:01:20.26710315Ricky HendersonA very important issue that recently affected very good friends of mine24482015-12-07T22:01:33.51710316Stephanie sinclair I demanded a test for strep B... And glad I did as I had it. At no point in my pregnancy was I told about strep B by any health care professional, which is disgusting as it is so dangerous and can kill new born babies. It's a cheap test and should be made available to all mums to be on the NHS. 24482015-12-07T22:06:44.0510318Leanne nelsonfortunatley for me i knew about strep b and the implications and was able to make an informed choice about the delivery of my baby. This shouldnt be determined by any one health professional24482015-12-07T22:10:41.9110319Vicki NicollThis is simple test and can prevent so many tragedies.24482015-12-07T22:12:32.31710321Susan Hepburn A simple thing which would make a huge difference 24482015-12-07T22:10:25.9710322Fiona FaganI can not understand why the NHS and Scottish Government will not allow this test to be conducted on every expectant mother it is so heartbreaking to lose a child when a simple £11 could save a life 24482015-12-07T22:15:44.5210323Kellie Livingstone I have 5 children and 4 of my pregnancies resulted in the boys being born at 37 wks, both of us required antibiotics and 2 of my sons required scbu. More should be done to offer pregnant mums this simple test. 24482015-12-07T22:14:55.4710325Jayne McDougallMake this test available to all 24482015-12-07T22:19:15.4910328Stephen westHere's hoping someone takes note of this worthy petition24482015-12-07T22:17:21.1910329Sarah Smith Please make this test available it will save lives.24482015-12-07T22:22:10.19310330Suzanne clarkMy son contracted this at 8 days old. \r\nIt was a miricle he survived then & still does every day of his 17years \r\nIt left him with severe brain injury, & various life threatening medical conditions. 24482015-12-07T22:20:55.45710331Rona carsonPlease help all mums and wee babes from this moment on thank god wee Isla survived this and our thoughts are so much with the families who have lost their wee babies24482015-12-07T22:21:55.6110332Louise ConnorI had strep b lucky it was picked up in a urine sample near end of pregnancy and me and baby were given antibiotics that were needed.my partner and i were so stressed about this till after the birth. So sorry for anyones loss or complication due to not knowing they have this, support this petition 100% .x24482015-12-07T22:23:27.0510333Alison MacRarThis should not be happening in this day and age .24482015-12-07T22:26:44.67310334Winnie walkerPlease make this test available to ever pregnant mum and try to eradicate needless infant deaths24482015-12-07T22:27:05.3310335SALLY BURTON THIS TEST SHOULD BE A STANDARD TEST GIVEN TO EVERYONE24482015-12-07T22:28:20.1910337DonnaBrown A must, to save life's, no parent should ever!! have to bury a child.24482015-12-07T22:32:47.5210338Eilidh ShawI had it and didn't know until a few weeks after giving birth, only knew when I was tested after not healing after stitches. I was lucky as it didn't get passed on to my baby. A simple test before giving birth would have meant my baby could have been given antiobiotics to prevent any complications. I was obviously one of the lucky ones.24482015-12-07T22:34:12.9110340Sandy SmithI found out by accident the day I went into labour that I had group B strep, and very luckily received antibiotics. How easily that could have been a different story. I had never heard of it, nor was warned of it. With my second pregnancy I was tested because I had it before, and was found to have it again. That something so easily detectable and treatable is not compulsory is scandalous. No parent should lose a child like this, just heartbreaking. I would happily have paid for this test, if that's what the problem is. Children are so precious, about time the Government made this part of ante natal care without delay. 24482015-12-07T22:39:00.2410341Laura Anderson I'm so sorry for your loss. A well worth petition24482015-12-07T22:36:00.1110342Lyndsey CrawfordEvery test which can be done to help prevent such tragic circimstances to happen should definetly be talked about more and every mother should have the choice to get these tests done especially if they can save babies lives 24482015-12-07T22:41:58.97310343patricia higneySuch a sad story. Just a simple swab could save all that heartache.x24482015-12-07T22:43:38.06710344James ReidFully support this, children are meant to outlive heir parents. Hope this gets the governments attention. 24482015-12-07T22:42:53.53310345Linda McmillanI am so so sorry to hear of your precious loss ,but hopefully its not in vain and through your precious sons short visit he will save lots of other precious baby's and he will return once again . You are very brave as your little boy is . Xx24482015-12-07T22:54:25.03310347Dace stutane My 2 children are fine but I feel sorry for the parents who has lost their children. I wasn't informed that something like this could happen and I hope that other mums get enough information in future. 24482015-12-07T22:59:31.06710349Yvonne Todd Should make this a standard routine test 24482015-12-07T23:04:23.69310350Fiona sinclair Why is this test not routine for all mothers to be? Such a simple, cheap test to save so much heartbreak! 24482015-12-07T23:02:04.98710351Sandra Hepburn Both me and my baby nearly died due to step B24482015-12-07T23:04:06.810352Lynsay McDade This should be compulsory testing 24482015-12-07T23:07:46.42710353Gillian MonkI was one of the lucky ones. The docs knew I was strep B carrier - this tragedy should never have happened when it's something so easily and cheaply preventable. 24482015-12-07T23:08:04.56710354Kerry johnstonThis baby died and a simple swab could have saved him. Heartbreaking 24482015-12-07T23:08:28.4910355Elizabeth WeldonEvery expectant Mum should be aware of this test and it should be routine for every Mum before delivery!\r\n24482015-12-07T23:08:46.5210356Heather LoganThis is terrifying! I carry GBS and I had absolutely no idea just how serious this can be when passed on to your baby. I was given antibiotics during labour but only because I knew I was a carrier. There were no routine tests done. My heart goes out to all those who have lost a child due to GBS. Testing should be offered to all pregnant women.24482015-12-07T23:13:07.7710358Christine CurzonI was told i had strep b after giving birth to my son i thank god he didnt have it. Until this id never heard of it how many babies need yo die before a simple test is provided or offered to buy ourselves. 24482015-12-07T23:12:05.0810359Julie Scougal This test could have saved this baby's life so why wasn't it offered? 24482015-12-07T23:18:51.8810361Laura Coyle Truly devastating I hope you win this and changes are made. Warmest hugs xx24482015-12-07T23:18:57.45710362Laura wallingtonFortunate in my first pregnancy after a routine swab test the group B strep I was carrying was detected and my baby was fortunate enough to recieve antibiotics directly after birth as a precaution - my question is even if the NHS couldn't afford to swab pregnant ladies why don't they give women the opportunity to pay themselves to be tested? I no for a fact any mother would pay such a small price for the sake of their babies well being! - rip baby Zach taken far too soon xxx24482015-12-07T23:15:34.87710363Catriona StrachanSo sorry for the loss of your beautiful boy. Hope this petition will help prevent the same heartache happening to others 24482015-12-07T23:16:13.810364Natalie Richardson More needs to be done about this and give wonen the choice to be tested. 24482015-12-07T23:20:57.310365Jennifer Mcfarlane I want to sign this petition but it keeps telling my email address is invalid!!!24482015-12-07T23:20:36.98710366Lyndsey begley I was swabbed during labour, however I was only told 10 days later that I had strep B. I was never given antibiotics and I'm still not sure of the symptoms to look out for. My baby is now 5 weeks and I worry everyday about him. I don't think enough support is given at all.24482015-12-07T23:28:58.9110368Elaine McSporranNo parent should outlive their child. Especially when it CAN be prevented. 24482015-12-07T23:47:32.86310372Joan Proudfoot Please make this available 24482015-12-08T00:07:06.9410375Louise McCartani didn't show signs of this with 1 st child but did with 2nd. i luckily had staff who spotted it and gave me iv antibiotics straight away. i was very ill but my daughter was fine because the staff were fantastic. i agree that this should be an option for mums everywhere. 24482015-12-08T00:09:41.5810376Hilda OwenMy stepdaughter had this as a child and was very lucky to have survived. Surely the safety of a child is worth £11?24482015-12-08T00:16:16.53710378Jenna Milne This should be mandatory!24482015-12-08T00:14:06.00310379Lynn OKeefeWhist I petition the Scottish Government to offer this test freely to all pregnant women, if the NHS still refuse to pay for this test, Ministers should ensure there is a facility which offers all women the test for the small fee involved. Who wouldn't pay £11 to ensure the safety of their unborn child? So, please either fund the test or at the very least raise awareness in hospitals and ensure all women can choose to pay for this test themselves.24482015-12-08T00:17:15.2210380Jacqueline TregidgoSo sorry for the loss of otherwise healthy babies because this isn't being made a commonly used procedure to test for the infection.. It should be offered to all pregnant women!24482015-12-08T00:17:29.73710381Lynne bowie This should be compulsory for every pregnant woman.it could save many life's.x24482015-12-08T00:20:33.310382Barbara murtagh This test is a must. No more little babies to suffer senselessly.24482015-12-08T00:22:14.03310383Megan MarshallThis is such a devastating story and the fact it could have been prevented, you get so many tests done while pregnant I don't think any parent or parent to be would have any issues with an extra test that could have saved your babies life. You are a very strong woman for trying to make a change and prevent what you have had to go through. Your beautiful baby boy will always be with you and I hope the bhs make the change and introduce this to all hospitals 24482015-12-08T00:24:18.4710384Lisa hodsonI I had group b strep and was given penicillin during labour, thank god everything was ok and my gorgeous baby boy is thriving, I think it's absolutely disgusting that pregnant women are not screened for this, it's a simple swab that can save children's lives, doing this will end a lot of unnecessary heartache for many parents!24482015-12-08T00:27:32.14310385Emma WrightFar too many people are affected by this. Time to make a change. 24482015-12-08T00:29:03.6610386Kathleen DowningLet's make this happen24482015-12-08T00:30:46.75310387Craig Hailstones Can't imagine the pain of losing a child. We need to realise the importance of where we spend our money. This simple test should be mandatory 24482015-12-08T00:33:03.20710388Gillian GemmellNo parent should have to go through this. I strongly support this cause. Everyone should be tested. I have a 3 month old baby boy and cannot imagine the pain to these parents for something that could have been prevented. 24482015-12-08T00:33:37.03310389Fern MontgomerySo sorry for your loss, maybe it's time that substandard 'free' health care is abolished and charges etc come in, to provide decent health care. 24482015-12-08T00:58:00.06710390Lorena Fernandez-OviedoPrevention and early screening to avoid more inocent lives be taken by thi kind of meningitis.24482015-12-08T00:54:36.64310391Jane McKennaFor Jamie x xx 24482015-12-08T01:12:07.7210393Grier TaskerThis simple test should be given to all women in labour.24482015-12-08T02:18:40.9110394wendy blair X24482015-12-08T05:02:05.2210396Victoria DevlinThis should be an essential procedure carried out for every mother to ensure that her beautiful baby has the best chance to survive.24482015-12-08T05:35:06.4110397Clare CollinsA tragedy and so preventable. 24482015-12-08T05:55:08.53310398Catriona NicholsonMy son was born in England (prematurely) I was told that I was a carrier & would be given IV antibiotics during labour - I remember every 4 hours shouting for my antibiotics to be topped up! The staff were very understanding & the Consultant I had was fabulous held my hand when he told me & explained side effects of having the antibiotics, there was also lots literature in the ward regarding GBS. I spent a long time crying & thinking 'why me' but then 'why anyone'. I have been very fortunate my son is now 13 & it's is thanks to the wonderful consultant who delivered him and the staff in SCBU St Mary's Hospital in Pool. Every mother should have the care and also the compassion that I received. Please make this a standard test during ante natal appointments. 24482015-12-08T06:05:11.8510399Anne WallaceThis should be a complusary test...save all babies!24482015-12-08T06:11:07.1310400Beth Craig My daughter and grandson had this infection should have been prevented 24482015-12-08T06:10:13.31310402Laura Kirkham No new parent should have to lose their child over a simple inexpensive test. \r\nMake it standard that all pregnant ladies are tested for group b strep. 24482015-12-08T06:23:42.7710403Alison murphyI was lucky I was due a smear test just before I fell pregnant & strep b was picked up so as soon as my waters broke I was to get IV antibiotics, however the birth of my 1st child happen all in the space of an hour & I just made it to hospital in time for her to arrive into the world so we got kept in for 3 days & monitored very closely & thankfully she was fine. 3 years later I was due my smear again & just after it I fell pregnant again with twins, again strep b showed up & I was in a panic about it & kept voicing my concern about how important it was to get antibiotics when my waters broke just like I was advised last time, only this time round no one seemed concerned which made me really anxious & worried as by this point I'd obviously read a lot about strep b & it's consequences. My twins were born & again thankfully they were fine. I cannot begin to imagine the hurt pain & anger these poor mothers must have inside them that a simple test could have saved their babies life but also the hospitals need to take the condition seriously too when they do know a mother is carrying strep b24482015-12-08T06:34:19.0510404Lauren DarbyCan not believe this simple test is not offered it should be made compulsory ASAP!! 24482015-12-08T06:45:08.09710406Claire CowanI found out during my first pregnancy that I was a carrier of Group B Strep. This was only found by luck through a urine sample as it was suspected I had a urine infection. I'm glad they found it but a swab should be routine. I had antibiotics with both my first and second pregnancies during labour and my third child was born via c section. Please introduce swab test for this.24482015-12-08T07:07:55.20710408Helen Atkinson I feel extremely strongly about this matter because I am one of the lucky ones. I found out only weeks before my son was born that I was a carrier of GroupB Strep, and only because I had had a bleed. Even with the antibiotics my son ended up visiting the special baby unit...I can't even begin to imagine what would have happened if I hadn't bleed. Is it really worth risking a life and the trauma of a lost baby for the sake of a quick test and some antibiotics...I don't think it is. 24482015-12-08T07:09:34.14710409Karen miller Nhs are always trying to spend money at the end if every financial year why not include this in their budgets?24482015-12-08T07:10:44.9710410julie swordSigned24482015-12-08T07:14:54.76710412A Waugh Very sad x24482015-12-08T07:24:28.47310413Michele Boyd Something needs to be done now so that no other parent has to loose a child like this when it could have and should have been prevented. 24482015-12-08T07:24:44.51710415Jill SingerI asked last minute to be tested for this after a friend of mine advised me she had a very sick baby. So glad i did as it turned out I had it. Luckily I asked an was given antibiotics. Everyone should be given the choice to be tested even if it means self funding. To be jonest i dont know any mum out there who wouldnt pay for this test.24482015-12-08T07:36:46.37710417Julie mckeePlease give this test to all new mums!24482015-12-08T07:38:01.70710418S BlackburnNo parent should have to lose their precious child because of a simple test. It devastates lives and how can you let this happen is beyond me. Do the test or tell mums and let them pay. I bet they would if they knew about the danger24482015-12-08T07:41:58.09710419Laura mckenna Lives of precious little baby's should not be put at risk to save a few pounds this should be available to everyone and even precaution taken to ensure the baby and mothers health 24482015-12-08T08:01:31.9110421Gary Trench Another example of cuts leading to sheer negligence and heartbreak.24482015-12-08T08:06:47.1610423Diane buchanPlease change the fact that this dimple test is not done in pregnancy. . It could save thd lives of lots of babies.. This affects too much people 24482015-12-08T08:12:27.5810424Claire WattersMoney shouldn't be an issue when it comes to the lives of people. I'm sure if mums to be were asked they would pay the £11 themselves for peace of mind...I sure would 24482015-12-08T08:21:22.5510426Franca Clarki too had Group B Strep and only found out because i lost a baby at 20 weeks and they did many tests to see if they could find out why which is when they discoved Group B Strep. So when my rainbow baby was born, he was given antibiotics straight away and tested for it. Luckily for me he was ok but for many it isnt. 24482015-12-08T08:22:54.83310427Mel NardiPlease please do more swabs during pregnancy and labour and please gives parents the choice to pay for the antibiotics! It's 2015 babies should not be dying from something easily preventable. 24482015-12-08T08:21:05.5510428Jill MaxwellMy daughter contracted this terrible illness when she was 6 weeks old, she was extremely ill for several days, thankfully she pulled through. But this heartache could all have been prevent if this new screening process was put in please for all women during pregnancy. 24482015-12-08T08:28:28.47310430Lucille EslerMy daughter now 22 was very ill at 14 days old, they diagnosed pneumonia, bronchilitis and RSVP, she almost died. Luckily after 2 weeks in intensive care she got better but was left with a lot of health problems and in later years learning difficulties which they said was because of the lack of oxygen due to her illness as a baby. \r\nWhen I fell pregnant again 12 years later, for some reason they swabbed and found out that I carry Strep B which I had never heard of. During my labouri was given antibiotics and when my baby daughter was born she was given antibiotics to treat any strep b present. Thankfully she was fine. When I found out the test was a simple as a swab was very angry, surely a babies life is worth that.24482015-12-08T08:26:50.95710431Karen Cameron Nhs - please do the right thing & make this change - inform every expectant mother of this possibility. Even if mums gave to pay in the short term ...this must be done xx 24482015-12-08T08:31:02.73710432Sharon Tritschler My daughter stopped breathing with a couple of hours of being born. She lives to tell the tale but it was group B strep and was given antibiotics and was on a breathing monitor and in an incubator. This was back in 1995 and people have tried since then to petition for strep B testing. This needs to change and mothers need to be tested. Prevention is better than cure. 24482015-12-08T08:36:19.45710433Nascera AdamsYou can't put a price on a life! Doesn't matter how much the simple but life saving test costs, it should be mandatory for all pregnant women. #whyguess x24482015-12-08T08:38:44.92710434Katrina potterMy heart goes out to you this should never have happened . Something has to be done nobody should ever go throu this is so tragic x24482015-12-08T08:39:31.53310436stacey thomsonHad my third baby 6 weeks ago, she fell ill the day after we got her home and was readmitted for three days and given a course of iv anti biotics, i had no clue i had GBS as didnt with my other two children we were lucky to have her checked straight away and she is fine now but i have read so many heartbreaking stories which could clearly be avoided if this test was offered routinely. Please make it available to all expectant mothers.24482015-12-08T08:44:54.34710437Margaret GibbHad my first baby 43 years and might have expected this simple test not to be available then but in 2015! An absolute disgrace-make it available now!!24482015-12-08T08:57:40.56710438Alexander WhytockIn 1995 our son Graeme died during birth. Cause was group b strep. A simple test and course of antibiotics for mum would have helped prior to birth. Let's prevent other parents facing the deep dark abyss of the death of a new born.24482015-12-08T08:54:43.98710439James rutherfordThis should be compulsory 24482015-12-08T09:00:05.610440Rebecca wattMy daughter caught ecoli in the womb during labour and spent 2 weeks in scbu she is now 7 and I know how very lucky I am to have her. Definitely needs to be swabs done for every pregnant women before labour.24482015-12-08T09:00:20.64710441Lisa MacCallumThis is devastating no mum should have to go through what this women had to.24482015-12-08T09:05:14.92710442Brenda StephensI tested positive for GBS 11 years ago with my 1st. It's completely beyond me why this isn't a standard test. And sadly I'm left wondering just how many more will die before someone in power actually sees sense. 24482015-12-08T09:04:47.3610443Susan MacnaughtonHow heartbreaking for parents who lose a child this way, when it could so easily be detected and prevented. My doctor tested me in my 3rd pregnancy and found strep b, so I was given antibiotics. But it all happened purely by chance and because I had a doctor who was really 'on the ball', so I was very lucky. I do believe this should be a routine test and parents-to-be should be fully informed.24482015-12-08T09:11:45.58310444Stephanie hunterThere is no question about it. I believe every possible safe test should be carried out if it may save a baby or a mothers life. It's just devastating that little angels have to go to sleep for people to be aware of this or take action. 24482015-12-08T09:11:49.97310445Rachel AshMy son contracted Step B, but they tested him immediately after he was born. He was checked regularly and we stayed in hospital for 3 days to ensure he was ok to go home. Reading this, I'm so grateful to the medical staff at Peterborough Hospital, but so devastated for this family who could have their gorgeous boy with them today, if this simple procedure was carried out. Please stop these unavoidable deaths happening!24482015-12-08T09:11:47.64310446Lynsey RitchiePlease make this test standard practice! Not to is both shortsighted financially and irresponsible with precious young life to say the very least.24482015-12-08T09:12:05.9710447Anne adamsI fell very strong about this.24482015-12-08T09:16:03.4710448Debi LalleyI asked to be tested for group strep B whilst at one of my routine midwife appointments following hearing so much about it through family and social media and I'm so glad that I did! I tested positive and so had the antibiotics in labour that I needed! If I hadn't been made aware of the condition, I wouldn't have known and things could have turned out a lot differently! Something needs to be done and group strep B should be a routine test that ALL pregnant woman should get! Why guess?? When you can save the lives of so many beautiful innocent children! 24482015-12-08T09:19:02.95710449Sandra McCabe This is heartbreaking. That a simple inexpensive swab or test could save babies life's. And a lot of parents probably don't even know it exists! 24482015-12-08T09:22:52.56710450Catherine NcAlinnThe NHS need to introduce these test as mandatory.\r\nNo need for further suffering and neath if inocent babies. 24482015-12-08T09:26:00.14710451Amy youdsSo sorry to hear this and for your loss of your beautiful little boy x24482015-12-08T09:25:13.34710452Sally HughesI also feel very strongly about this , its so cheap and easily carried out .24482015-12-08T09:30:20.92710453Clare Hyndman I lost my beautiful baby girl at 41 weeks, she was beautiful. She picked up group b in usero. I never was tested and despite reporting low movement and that something wasnt right, my little girl died in distress. Had it been picked up, we might have her with us now. Please help, please provide tests and save lives x24482015-12-08T09:30:50.36310454Susan WelburnI watched my daughter go through hell when one of her twins was diagnosed with Strep B and he was in intensive care in a coma for 2 weeks . This should not be happening in 2015 . I had 3 children and had never even heard of strep B till it happened to my family. Please Please Please NHS agree to give all pregnant women this swab . No one should be putting a price on a life. It should be routinely done.24482015-12-08T09:34:50.5210455Elaina ThomsonI am pregnant with my 2nd child and have never been informed of group b strep through this pregnancy or my previous pregnancy. 24482015-12-08T09:36:25.0510456ruth metcalfeThis test should be done on every mother expecting a baby I can't believe in this day that this isn't being done to prevent this even if the cost is to much for the nhs each parent would pay for this test to be done 24482015-12-08T09:35:15.73710457Natalie Atkinson This test definately needs to be mandatory 24482015-12-08T09:39:40.39310458Gillian wrightThis is a heartbreaking story which could of been prevented.. NHS THIS SHOULD BE MANDATORY 24482015-12-08T09:39:57.23710459Carolynne Huntermy 6 year old Daughter has lived with the horrific consequences of this infection since birth. Sadly I was screened but protocols weren't met to prevent the infection manifesting in to EOGBS and she has been left with severe Cerebral Palsy and respiratory disease. I do believe if routine screening had been in place protocols for management of my care and she would have been practised more efficiently and she would be growing up a Healthy Child. 24482015-12-08T09:47:01.2410460Liz green My grand daughter had it but was lucky all mums should be tested 24482015-12-08T09:47:13.7710461Denise HarveyThis simple test needs to be available nationwide.\r\n24482015-12-08T09:47:17.08310462Kathryn Winsborough I am very surprised that strep b is not already routinely tested for. It is a silent infection with very real risks. I will be sure to check up on the progress of this cause.24482015-12-08T09:47:39.7210463Sophie SargissonMy first child was seriously ill at birth due to strep b. Thankfully she is ok but has significant scarring on her brain. We still dont know how or if it will affect hervas she grows up. I wasnt told it was strep b though so when I was pregnant with my son I read a story that sounded similar to mine and had my notes dug up to find it was. Thankfully we received antibiotics. Im so sorry about baby zach and tge hundreds of other babies that have to suffer from this easily preventable infection.24482015-12-08T09:53:04.2410464claire veldonI could have lost my precious baby girl if the nurse hadnt been so vigilant. This tests needs to be compulsary!!24482015-12-08T09:53:06.06710465Sarah aldermanMy heart goes out to you and your family. In 2007 2 hours after my daughter was born, a midwife walked past my bed took one look at my newborn daughter and said this baby doesn't loom right, she then took her in her arms and ran to the neo unit where they found she had b strep, put her antibiotics 8 days later she was discharged, I thank god for that midwife everyday, had she not spotted she didn't look right we would have lost her. For the sake if £11 for a simple straight forward swab that I firmly believe should be routine in all labour's anyway as b strep is on the rise, I think the government need a firm boot up the backside, to stop this kind of unnecessary heartache repeating itself and at the very least let mum decide if she wants the test and pay for it herself I'm sure no one would refuse it!! Raise awareness and spread the word that this can kill if not caught.24482015-12-08T09:53:47.26710466JOANNE DRAYSONI nearly lost my daughter and grandson in June due to overlooking strep B infection thankfully it was picked up after cesarian and treated24482015-12-08T10:00:43.50310467Sarah mclellan These tests should be mandatory!!!!24482015-12-08T10:00:27.64310468Shona Bowman This was only discovered by chance when I had my third child and I was lucky enough to be given antibiotics during labour - but having had 2 previous children this was unknown to me and a large percentage of the population carry strep B . 24482015-12-08T10:05:28.31310469Margot douglasi feel your pain come on nhs get ur finger out £11 is not a high price to pay for a childs life to save a mother the heartache of burying her baby step it up \r\n24482015-12-08T10:14:40.72310470Veronica Highet The swab for testing for group B strep is part of antenatal care for all pregnant ladies in Australia so I do not see why you are not doing it in UK, you are not a third world country.24482015-12-08T10:13:14.310471Katie Farrell I think if the NHS are not offering this mothers should get the option to pay the £11 for this service. 24482015-12-08T10:19:43.310472Sharon McArthur This is something that doesn't need to happen with a simple swab,it must be devastating to lose a baby especially when so easily prevented.24482015-12-08T10:25:18.14710473Marie reidThis is something i never heard of, such a simple test that would save families having to go through and live with such devastating consequences, this needs to be made a mandatory test that all pregnant women have the choice of having 24482015-12-08T10:23:10.28310474Fiona williamsonNo one should have to go through the loss of a child when it could have been prevented. Come NHS screen mums to be and save lives. 24482015-12-08T10:32:19.2410476Melanie StewartSmithI think that if it is a cost related thing that is stopping this being routinely offered to mothers then at leat they should be given the option to pay for it themselves and im sure no mother would hesitate to pay such a small amount, to keep the precious bundle they are about to give life too.24482015-12-08T10:37:49.39710478Susan GregoryThis appalling. Yet another lost life due to an eminently preventable illness. Shame on the NSC and the other blockers - hope they can live with themselves and the fact that others are paying for their intransigence24482015-12-08T10:41:25.72310479june beckThis was picked up in my daughter during pregnancy. I thought at the the time that all pregnant women were given the test, but now think it must have been tests for kidney problems that unearthed it. I can't imagine my grand daughter not being here. If this test isn't done routinely, that has to be changed immediately for every mum to be in Britain24482015-12-08T10:45:11.4110480Adele herronI think this should definately be a routine test . A lot of money is wasted on treating drug and alcohol abuse so why shouldn't newborn babies and mothers be tested to prevent such heartbreak and needless loss of new life . 24482015-12-08T10:42:29.06310481Stacey TewI've had two babies and in neither pregnancy was aware of this or the consequences. Innocent lives do not need to be lost. Especially with the world we live in nowadays24482015-12-08T10:44:03.09710482Stacey Johnstone If we can find the money to go to war we can surely find the money to save babies lives by making this a routine test for every pregnant woman. 24482015-12-08T11:04:17.3510485Catherine O'NeillThis should not be allowed to happen a simple test could have prevented it 24482015-12-08T11:04:33.36310486Joanne FarrellThe NHS should introduce this as a mandatory test. Why put us and these poor babies through so much unnecessary heart ache and pain.\r\nEducate mothers as I for one knew nothing about it until it affected my son.24482015-12-08T11:09:50.39710487JenniferhamiltonI am so sorry to hear you lost your lovely wee boy can't amagine what you are going through my thoughts are with you and your family24482015-12-08T11:11:38.95710488Donna Crighton Feel very strongly about this, please make this available to everyone, could save so many lives!24482015-12-08T11:14:26.2710489Kirstie Shuker All pregnant women should be educated on this awful infection. Midwives should be informing women of Strep B so that gives them the choice to purchase their own private test. I have just received mine in the post and I'm waiting until I am 38 weeks to swab myself and get it sent back to the lab. It's all worth it for a life!! So sorry about your little boy.24482015-12-08T11:14:55.58310490Catriona ToddThis needs to be mandatory test. No parent should go through the loss of child in this preventative way. 24482015-12-08T11:15:44.0510491Claire SproulI had a swab with my first son, but went into labour to fast to get the antibiotics so he got a cannula in to administer them to him, for some reason it happened the same way with my second but with having preeclampsia at the end of my third I was given intravenous antibiotics so grateful for the simple swab, I also don't understand why it's not offered to all pregnant women as standard24482015-12-08T11:17:07.0510492Jemma cotton I to had group b strep, but thankfully my baby survived, I would no doubt have paid that minimal amount to make sure he didn't have to endure it 24482015-12-08T11:25:39.08310493Moira McKenzieWe should be doing our very best to prevent infants from dying - especially if there is an easy way to detect if the mother is carrying Strep. I have two babies myself and nieces and nephews and if anything happened to them my life would be ruined. No mother should go through the pain of loosing a child. £11 is nothing and I'm sure most people would even pay for it if they were advised and asked - I certainly would. My sister in law had this with her first child and never knew till after my nephew was born - luckily everything was okay but it could have been so different. 24482015-12-08T11:24:04.37710494Linda wardI am so so sorry to here that son passed away you must be very angry . Sending lots of love .24482015-12-08T11:37:41.44310498Kim LoweI got tested nearly 7 years ago with my first daughter and had it so had antibiotics when in labour,however ended in traumatic emergency c-section under general anaesthetic. Heard alot more about Strep B and wanted testing but wouldnt test when having my son 2 years ago,crazy why not! Planned normal c-section as felt safer option due to previous complications but the strep b was in the back of my mind too. Need this simple test to be available to everyone.24482015-12-08T11:47:41.4710499Charlotte Lancaster This is something I hold close to my heart! My son at birth had meningitis and now has life long disabilities but I was lucky and got to keep my baby which I am forever greatful for! Hope this NHS finally get their act sorted and provide a cheap and simple test to stop our babies suffering! I'm sure people would mind paying the £11 for the sake of their unborn babies if the NHS are so tight they won't make it free!24482015-12-08T11:52:25.37710500Wilma constableFamily history24482015-12-08T12:08:54.72310501Amy MoneyDisgusting this test is still not compulsory when it's taking little life's and preventable by a £11 test!!24482015-12-08T12:12:51.810502Louise Carey Omg so wrong I have 2 kids 5year old and an 8 month old and I would even pay £11 to get swabbed b4 having child such a sad thing to happen for sake of a few quid I didn't no it existed.24482015-12-08T12:17:01.9110503Karen RixI have just had my baby daughter and found out that I had Strep B when I went in to hospital to be induced\r\nI had had a uti 2 wks previous but what I was appalled by was the fact that for over 2 weeks of having found out that I had Strep B NO ONE contacted me to tell me\r\nAnd also I was informed that I would have antibiotics put up 2hrs prior to my delivery \r\nBut I had my daughter in 8 mins and was unable to have the antibiotics put up\r\nWe had to stay in hospital due to this to see if my daughter had any of the symptoms of Strep B\r\nI think it's disgusting that Mums go thru so much during labour and not to have the swab for Strep B is just amazing that the government can put a price on a baby's life\r\nTry spending the money in the right places where it IS needed\r\nIt's just Greed Greed Greed all the time with this Government\r\nThoughts and prayers are with u and ur little angel xxx24482015-12-08T12:22:02.70710504Mary Ann LaveryMy daughter is due her baby in February can she request this test ? I would feel much more at ease if this test was standard practice RIP baby Zak 24482015-12-08T12:27:53.9410507Pauline BlackPlease don't let this happen again.In what should be one of the most happiest times, end so tragically.24482015-12-08T12:32:21.2410508Karen modlinMy daughter was the same she tried telling hospital about it and they wouldn't test her, she had her baby but was lucky that baby was ok, she went on to have another baby and had an emergency c section she was told she had strep b and if baby was born natural both baby and her would be dead, they never tested for the strep until after birth luckily dr had sense to know something was wrong24482015-12-08T12:29:24.89310509Helen LivermoreIt's a small price to pay to save a child's life. The Scottish government needs to comply with UK health and safety law on patient safety to minimise the number of avoidable deaths.24482015-12-08T12:34:11.59710510Donna kerrIt is imperative that all mothers are tested our precious grandson contracted this and was very ill and spent over two weeks in hospital and the stress that mum and dad went through was heartbreaking stop this now24482015-12-08T12:41:18.110511Roger LivermoreWe in Scotland have no independent body making sure that the quaility of healthcare is good enough. And no regaualtor making sure that that patients are safe. We only have NHS Scotland's Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) which is not acceptable. The rest of the UK has independent bodies, We need them too. \r\nPatients by law are required to be protected from cross-infection as far as possible (HSWA 1974 and COSHH) but NHS Scotland and HIS refuse to recognise the law. We only have guidance. 24482015-12-08T12:43:07.70710512Sarah VassIf the government clawed back the money that is spent in treating foreigners. But no they would rather rusk the lives on innocent babies than spend £11 for a swab. I would pay the £11 to get it do e but you should have the option.24482015-12-08T12:48:24.53310513Sharon bainWho could argue the point that this £11 test should not be compulsary ! 24482015-12-08T12:57:16.31310515Emma pardinesHis is heartbreaking news, to lose a little baby life go a simple & inexpensive test. It should be compulsory in all nhs24482015-12-08T13:20:16.31310517Cheryl McDonald This is a heartbreaking story. I cannot believe a simple test could and can prevent this. It's a no brainer and all pregnant woman should be tested for this! \r\nCheryl 24482015-12-08T13:24:23.7710518Christine LoveMake this simple test complusory.24482015-12-08T13:34:56.610519Alexandra HendersonThis needs urgent action by the Scottish government!24482015-12-08T13:34:24.0510522Amanda Benson This test should be compulsory for all expectant mothers throughout the UK. I was a lucky one who had a swab due to cramping and bleeding in early pregnancy and it came back positive for Group B Strep and I had antibiotics in labour, my daughter was born healthy, had I not had this test the outcome could've been so different. 24482015-12-08T13:44:53.95710525Anisa Kazmimy heart goes out to this mother. This simple test must be made compulsory.24482015-12-08T14:04:37.25310526Gemma LyallThis should definitely be a manditory test for all pregnant women. It is not fair to those many families that have lost babies due to this horrible infection.24482015-12-08T14:16:56.81310527Carolann barlasThis is so tragic and i cant begin to imagine how these parents are feeling. This test must become routine in all hospitals24482015-12-08T14:33:59.53310529Claudia Maria Macfarlane as so often action, by the government needed24482015-12-08T14:50:39.12710533Christine ByrneI myself am a mum of two and was until now completely unaware of this. I would gladly have paid the £11 or more to have this swab done.24482015-12-08T15:23:51.53310536Ann HamillWhilst I have not had to part with a baby boy, my son (age 25 yrs) passed away over 8 years ago. There is NO mother who has had to cope with the separation from her child who will not be moved with compassion for Shaheen and others who have had a similar experience. \r\nTo think that £11 could have saved baby Zac's life is just ridiculous and the NHS should be ashamed. \r\nMy prayer is that raising awareness of this in the Scottish Parliament may change things for the better. All the best. 24482015-12-08T15:26:33.1610537Cara BurnettPlease save mother's from this horrible headache and save the beautiful babies that haven't yet lived life24482015-12-08T15:42:15.20710539Bridget farrellMy heart goes out to you and other woman who have lost their precious babies..\r\nI was lucky enough to be diagnosed with group B strep when i was 18 after going to the doctors with cramps i was swabbed and a couple of days later told i had strep.B.\r\nI have never heard about this and when i fell pregnant with my little boy i told my midwife and she stuck a big sticker on the front of my notes, how this is not routinely checked is beyond me!\r\nA silent deadly killer which is easily stopped...\r\nEveryone must sign this .x24482015-12-08T15:47:15.5810540Cheryl AlexanderA simple and cheap test that could stop many tears and heartache. Please sign this petition.24482015-12-08T15:49:59.12710541Amy CowinsI can't imagine the pain this family has gone through...action needs to be taken immediately. 24482015-12-08T16:02:35.0210542Nikki MacDonaldThis is such a terrible story and to think a simple test could have prevented it. I was lucky enough to have been tested for thrush near the end of my pregnancy and they picked up that I had group B strep. To think about what could have happened if I hadn't went to the doctors that day is just terrifying I really hope\r\nThis test is made compulsory!!!24482015-12-08T16:01:33.1110543Christine SteinerI was born and raised in Scotland l was a nurse in Aberdeen maternity hospital l move over to the USA where l have continued my career l want to support this petition as at the hospital l work we routinely test mothers for GBS and if it's positive we treat them profolactally and during labour we also keep the baby on a protocol for 48 hours keeping a close watch on them with increased vital signs if they show any symptoms we treat them as well. This prevents any unnecessary deaths that could be prevented by a small test starting with Mummy 24482015-12-08T16:10:37.92710545Charese BrookesI had this with my baby boy. Luckily I had swabs done but that was only due to discharge which I ask for a swab but otherwise I don't think I would have had one. So I'm thankful to myself that I got checked. 24482015-12-08T16:17:12.50310546Alison ClarkThis story is heartbreaking and unfortunately it takes something like this for action to be taken. This should be compulsory.24482015-12-08T16:22:17.0510547Kerryann doyleI think this should i had it when i was pregnant 24482015-12-08T16:51:28.86310550Sandy RobertsonThere is no question that this shouldn't be compulsory!24482015-12-08T16:53:20.9910551Morag TowndrowI'm an intelligent well-read relatively affluent grandmother of five living in an area of the country where widespread deprivation already affects perinatal death rates. I had never heard of this tragic problem or its preventability. We must do something!24482015-12-08T17:01:29.92710552Caroline Davidson Signed hopefully no other person has to go through a loss of a child fir £11.0024482015-12-08T17:10:10.0510554Margaret GreigNo baby should die No mother should go through this pain get it done24482015-12-08T17:08:59.45710555Samantha wessonMy daughter was born on the 31st July 2015, and because of the lack of testing I was unaware of what lay ahead. When my daughter was born she was very poorly and couldn't breath well... she had such a rough 14 days to her life. However we were lucky she pulled through but many haven't.. It's time to test!! 24482015-12-08T17:29:25.58310556Aline AdamsA young midwife picked up Group B Strep on my day-old son. Since then, all my children were given antibiotics at birth, however I dread to think of the outcome had it not been identified with my first. x24482015-12-08T17:37:12.25310559Debbie KreisederI'm so sorry to hear of your sons passing. My daughter too developed meningitis but fortunately survived because her neonatologist started her on antibiotics prior to a positive spinal tap. My OB stated I wasn't swabbed because I had 2 previous normal deliveries so he felt it wasn't necessary. No parent should have to go thru this very preventable tragedy . It should be made standard for every woman to be tested every pregnancy . I'm truly sorry for your loss and can't imagine the pain.24482015-12-08T17:43:47.1110560Irina Macdonald Government please make action...24482015-12-08T17:45:05.00310561Tanya BarrI had to literally fight to get this test whilst I was in labour and eventually a midwife listened and got me tested. Good job someone listened as it turned out I had GBS and needed Antibiotics immediately. My baby and I were in hospital for 1 week together due to GBS but Thank God someone eventually listened to me.\r\nI don't understand why this isn't tested for routinely! 24482015-12-08T18:04:02.44310562Janice MountThis is so Heartbreaking xx24482015-12-08T18:01:17.98710563Stacey Gibson I think this should be made a legal requirement that all pregnant woman are tested for this at the early stage of labour my partners big brother died of this at a few days old it is preventable and should not be allowed to happen 24482015-12-08T18:05:05.5510564Charlene HennersI believe strep b is the reason my baby boy contracted meningitis and septicaemia at just 7 days old. We were very lucky not to lose him. For the sake of £11!!!!!!!24482015-12-08T18:28:56.8510565Elizabeth Macgregor My niece is a nurse and she knew about this and asked to be tested and found out she had strep so her son could have been affected if she had not asked , in this day and age it should be a routine test24482015-12-08T18:30:55.62710566Melanie Waters One of my cousins twin boys caught Strep B. He was in hospital for weeks on life support.\r\nMy midwife that me when I asked for the test, that the government can't justify the cost of the tests. It's ridiculous. \r\nMy midwife is great and has said that if I'm experiencing "abnormal discharge ", then they can test me. You can get a home test kit which is around £40. I know we shouldn't have to, but if it saves my babies life then it's worth it. 24482015-12-08T18:50:15.22310567Kerry ThomsonI have friends whose previous babies have been seriously ill due to Strep. A simple test could have saved much heartache. 24482015-12-08T18:52:06.6910568Amanda braithwaite I'm so sorry for your lose and could never know how u feel thoughts r with u, my daughter is pregnant with her second child and has strep b I didn't realise how serious it was xxx24482015-12-08T18:58:52.1310569Jan KirkwoodDon't risk more lives please test24482015-12-08T18:56:58.62710570Leanne Mccooke My first son had this when he was born he was swabbed for it along with myself and I was not informed what it was, I just took it that this was the norm so I'm only realising by reading this now exactly how dangerous strep b is... so yes every mother to be should be swabbed and told the information needed to avoid any loss. 24482015-12-08T19:01:27.28710571Katie Williams Fortunately I had a swab when pregnant due to discharge. I'm so thankful as otherwise I would not have known about risks involved. It should be compulsory for all mums to be.24482015-12-08T19:01:53.59710572Karen RodgerI am a carrier of Group B strep and nearly lost my first son. He fought hard and survived but has Asperger's syndrome. Please stop others from the pain of something so easy to test for and prevent. 24482015-12-08T19:02:36.89310573Sharon muirThis should have never of happened, the poor parents and little baby, NHS cutting corners as usual, this should be routine, RIP gorgeous boy xx24482015-12-08T19:03:51.62710574lLisa SheppardMy Grandaughet had this 24482015-12-08T19:09:16.45710575Susan Myers campbellDevastating I nearly lost my wee girl threw a doctor saying it was just a viral she'd be fine . She was rushed to yorkhill same night mengicoco septasimia . They gave her 24 hours . She survived . They should swab mothers if there is a chance of saving baby's . Look what this poor mother has to go threw . 24482015-12-08T19:11:26.87710576wendy Guecem This is a terrible tragic story, so sorry for your loss, I can't imagine how you must feel. I will pass this story on. Take care xx24482015-12-08T19:21:43.9110578Abbie Sweeney X 24482015-12-08T19:30:55.8810580Tracy JohnsonI found out I had GBS when I was pregnant with my first child, I was very lucky I had a friend who I confided in after I suffered with constant discharge-I had absolutely no idea what it was and have never heard of Group B Strep, she strongly suggested I ask my GP for a swob test, I had to pay for this myself but I will be forever grateful that I did! When I had my second child, I mentioned it to my midwife who said they don't routinely check for this and I was absoultely shocked that 3 years later women were still not being informed of this deadly infection.. 24482015-12-08T19:34:54.70710581Sara FarrellThis needs to be checked & tested to save life's. Heartbreaking to hear that £11 can be the difference between life & death. 24482015-12-08T19:34:46.7210582Laura Mckenzie Everyone should be tested x24482015-12-08T19:41:01.22310583Joe costelloSuch heartache can easily be avoided with such a simple test 24482015-12-08T19:43:13.1110584Jayne HeppinstallAbsolutely heartbreaking this test should be offered to all preganant women with no excuses whatsoever!24482015-12-08T20:02:47.11310585l matthews Tezt should be routine anti natal care24482015-12-08T20:00:15.64310586Deborah iveyMy daughter and granddaughter had this and were both in hospital for a month, a simple swab could have prevented this,what cost a life!24482015-12-08T20:14:32.95710589Jenna McGettrickThis is a truly heartbreaking story and I'm sorry for your loss. It's sad to think that deaths like this are completely preventable with a simple test and would save the lives of young babies. This test should be compulsory or at least routinely offered to every pregnant women.24482015-12-08T20:19:03.25310590elizabeth brownI think this test should be done to all pregnant mothers its heart breaking to lose a baby I know I burried 2 in the space of a year 24482015-12-08T20:19:21.1910591Lyndsay McKenzieI was told I had Strep B when my waters broke early but given no information. My daughter arrived at 34 weeks and we were very lucky. No parent should have to go through losing a child. 24482015-12-08T20:23:15.67710592Kelly yuleI had a swab confirmed group b strep. I was advised that I needed Iv antibiotics 4hours prior to delivery. I was petrified of the outcome when I started to get contractions. I called the hospital who said just carry on labouring at home,it sounds like your doing fine. I went onto full blown labour very quickly, ended up in an ambulance and had an emergency section but thankfully my boy didn't need antibiotics. I was given them in theatre. My boy is now 2yrs old. More should be done. 24482015-12-08T20:22:40.34710593Sarah ConsidineSo very important. Please make this normal practice.24482015-12-08T20:27:09.25310594ben mendozaMy son had bacterial meningitis at 3months old most scary time of my our life thankfully he pulled through but I'm so sad they don't test u from birth I defo and singing this no parent should loose a child in the way u did 24482015-12-08T20:29:15.1910595Lisa johnstoneWe have had an infant death at three days old due to strep in my immediate family and are devastated, I demanded to be tested, the midwives did try to put me off and were not keen, but I put my foot down and so glad I did. Think it's rediculous that all woman are not tested. I hope this changes sooner rather than later. 24482015-12-08T20:33:35.39710596Corrie jefferyVital for all expectant mothers, huge heartache can be avoided easily.24482015-12-08T20:46:12.33310598Julie BranniganAbsolute must24482015-12-08T20:59:16.5510601Morven Gordon-DuffI had to beg to be swabbed for this, and was group b strep positive for my second child. I was given iv antibiotics during labour. My son still fell ill 10 days later with viral meningitis and I dread to think that he could have also had bacterial meningitis had I not been tested. It's such a simple test and it could be so easily made mandatory 24482015-12-08T20:56:49.6610602Claire mitchellI had group b strep but found out through swab around 6 months pregnant after going to doctors about discharge. I therefore had the antibiotics during birth. My understanding of gbs is that I may not have tested + for it just before my labour, yet the policy is to go ahead and administer the drugs. Surely it would be best to test all close to due date.24482015-12-08T21:00:12.1110603margaret todda think every pregnant woman should get this done 24482015-12-08T21:07:24.5510605Louise BurnsBeing pregnant brings parents a lot of worries and can be an anxious time, having this test could be one less thing to worry about and as I am 17 weeks pregnant just now I can only hope it comes into play before my baby is born. 24482015-12-08T21:11:21.810606ELOUISE PEACE X24482015-12-08T21:19:41.7210610Leah McalindenThis should be cumplosary for women who are expecting a baby, it's to save a life so please make this compulsory!24482015-12-08T21:23:29.89710611Rachel BurgoyneI can only hope with all my heart this petition makes a difference. My daughter had Group B strep but thankfully the hospital caught it. My heart goes out to this mum who has lost of her beautiful baby boy 24482015-12-08T21:24:42.9710613Criscelda GarciaGBS test should be compulsory to all pregnant women and mid wifes should be thoroughly trained to spot early stage symptoms. 24482015-12-08T21:31:24.7410614Clare McGownThis should be compulsory or at the very least an option during pregnancy. I had to pressurises my doctors to have one during mine. No angel baby should die due to this. Love to anyone who has suffered as a result. 24482015-12-08T21:28:19.45710615Elizabeth CookSurely a little swab to save a baby's life should be made compulsory 24482015-12-08T21:34:57.89710616Alana Hunter My nephew contracted group B strep as a baby. A simple test could stop so many families suffering!24482015-12-08T21:37:16.06710617Teresa Mccatty I am sorry to hear of your loss and hope that they now bring in the testing for all mum's 24482015-12-08T21:38:37.17310618Sarah inusa My little boy also had Group B strep and passed away on 14th August at 5 days old after my waters broke early. It's such an awful thing and if swabbing can save lives then it should be done 24482015-12-08T21:43:01.50310619Annette BarberWhy are the government not funding this fundamental right for all pregnant mothers to protect their unborn child, it is disgusting that for a small price of 11.00 this is not happening that a life is not worth that much 24482015-12-08T21:48:11.4910620Barbara Lavender I agree no women should have to go through this it is ridiculous to loose a baby in this way 24482015-12-08T21:48:43.4110621Sandra Ward-BarberWhy can't the government invest in our NHS more a simple test to save so much heartache24482015-12-08T21:53:06.1610622Sue AndrewsIt is heartbreaking that any child could be lost for lack of a simple and inexpensive preventive test.24482015-12-08T21:57:30.1610623Gemma hardacreThis is so scary and breaks my heart, it should be compulsory.24482015-12-08T22:02:49.81710624Gemma WhannelThere should be clearer guidelines for healthcare staff and pregnant women, tests should be compulsory. This story is heartbreaking and made even worse by the fact that it could have been prevented 24482015-12-08T22:02:42.03310626Nicola BrownThis should be tested on every mother in labour. If it isn't on the budget, I would pay this myself. What a terrible tragedy that it isn't routine. Heartache for a lot of mothers who have lost their baby when it takes only seconds to swab... 24482015-12-08T22:06:33.28710627Clare Jennings I am so sorry to hear all the sad stories - all devastating and traumatic.\r\nI found about at 10cms dialated via a midwife running into the delivery suite with a post-it note after 2 days of labour to say I had Strep-B. I had an emergency section and my son spent 2 weeks in NICU fighting infection.\r\nI shudder to think it could have all gone so very tragically wrong if it hadn't been for an amazing midwife who thought to take a swab the night my waters broke - if it wasn't for her I might not have been enjoying a beautiful two year old boy today! \r\nWhen I've shared my story, I'm always shocked by the sheer numbers of other mums who have been in a similar situation - in just a small number of friends, the ratio is alarmingly high! \r\nI love the NHS - there must be a way to address Strep B screening and give it the profile it needs! 24482015-12-08T22:08:21.5210628jackie dohertyTragic in this day & age24482015-12-08T22:10:41.61310629Lucy burdenI am very lucky I was told I had group b strep In time and my baby was born healthy I think a lot more needs to be done and a lot more restart hand awareness is needed 24482015-12-08T22:10:54.19310630ashley hodge I have signed this because I was lucky enough to find out I had strep b during my pregnancy and also a few years previous to fallin pregnant I took viral meningitis. So o know how ill it can make u and how lucky I was and wish u luck with ur petition 24482015-12-08T22:11:00.4910631Kerr FalconerI was shocked and extremely sad to read about this case. I hope the Government act quickly on this and make new policies to ensure we have no more unecessary losses. No baby should ever lose it's life and especially when it can be prevented ! Please keep us posted and never give up the fight24482015-12-08T22:23:08.310632Linda MalcolmI was lucky...Excellent care at the Rottenrow 18 yrs ago. Heartbreaking to hear despite advances in healthcare of the avoidable losses families endure.24482015-12-08T22:26:34.06710633Linda SaulI believe all pregnant women should have this test 24482015-12-08T22:27:17.9410634Alison Mcgregor Defiantly test should be done as it can be devastating consequences if not!! 24482015-12-08T22:35:29.86310635Paula WilsonI have had group B strep in both my pregnancies and as a carrier I am worried that it might affect my 3rd pregnancy as there is no reason to test me unless I have an infection. 24482015-12-08T22:33:09.4410636amy profitPlease put a stop to this !!! 24482015-12-08T22:36:54.97310637Hilary ConnorI am so shocked that this issue was never mentioned at any antenatal class or hospital appointment I attended. If I was aware I would without a doubt got a swab. This woman's horrendous experience that no one should go through. Especially when it can easily be avoided. My heart breaks for anyone affected by this. 24482015-12-08T22:38:46.310638Joanne PracockI am so saddened to hear of your needless loss. This is tragic. You are doing such a good thing by fighting for this in your sons memory. God bless you and your beautiful boy . I really hope the NHS listen. X24482015-12-08T22:39:01.69310639sarah jacksonFirstly I am sorry for your loss.secondly even if the tests had to be paid for I think most women would still have them if the risk of not swabbing is explained. My love to all the family's and little angels.24482015-12-08T22:39:35.86310640Julie lammimanThis test should be mandatory!! I had it when I was pregnant with my first child, it was scary to think of the consequences should I have not been treated for it, which couldn't be done till I was in labour. 24482015-12-08T22:41:16.86310641Beverley RobinsonThis simple test should be performed throughout the UK and Ireland as a routine. 24482015-12-08T22:48:30.26710642Cathy Gallagher All women everywhere should have access to this. I just hope Scotland leads the way, as usual.24482015-12-08T23:03:14.5510647Pat ClintonThis swab test should be done routinely. My midwife took a swab when I went into labour a month early. By the time my baby was born. swab had been sent to lab, awaiting results. She was whisked off to special baby unit straight away & spent a week there. Without that swab & early test results, she could so very easily and quickly have died. Seven months later she contracted bacterial meningitis, which was linked to Group B Strep. The swab test, quite simply, helps saves lives. 24482015-12-08T23:00:04.1910648Yvonne McLeodFor the lack of a simple test... 24482015-12-08T23:06:43.14710649Lisa AitkenThis is preventable. Why is the test not routinely being carried out? Protect life! 24482015-12-08T23:07:08.33310650Katy Tracey I had a swab and it confirmed I had strep b .. I was very lucky and my baby boy with born happy and healthy ... Let other mums be aware of this ... So sad xxxx24482015-12-08T23:15:57.09710653Sarah robertsonA mum never gets over loosing a baby.24482015-12-08T23:22:39.89310654Ainsley MartinYou cannot put people through this pain & heartache when it is so preventable at such a small price. 24482015-12-08T23:26:11.75310655Nicola LyallI am so sorry for your loss and I really hope people in high places will pay attention.24482015-12-08T23:27:33.6110656Sarah palmer Rip beautiful baby boy xxx24482015-12-08T23:32:34.310657Debbie StewartEvery woman should have this done it should be the same as every other test they do in pregnancy. I had it with my little girl and only by chance they found it because I was bleeding they had to swab me if they had not it could have been a different story. This needs to be taken seriously.24482015-12-08T23:39:14.14310659Lee Anscombe I remember 2 weeks after my youngest daughter being rushed in to hospitals they thought she's may have had menagitest lucky it turned out not to be and our daughter was quicky on the mend , x24482015-12-08T23:39:34.810660Saran McGrathGod bless you. Signed and shared. So so sad :( x24482015-12-08T23:46:41.59710661Wendy NisbetI didn't know about this and feel it's essential that mums to be are taught about ways to prevent these tragedies and given chance to be tested.24482015-12-08T23:53:13.17710662Diana petixThis is shocking and so sad that a simple test would have saved so many babies, disgusting. Strep b is so common and swabs need to be given what is going on. Xxx24482015-12-09T00:07:17.2410664Daniell Holmes Knowing someone that has lost a babie through this and now my daughter is pregnant ,I would love my daughter to have the test just for reassurance x24482015-12-09T00:17:48.9710667Nikki peacockIts sad that in this day and age they are not making this a routine test at the beginning of labour . . A beautiful baby boy lost all for the sake of a 60 second swab at £11 absolutely heart breaking and my heart goes out to the couple can never imagine your pain . . Your doing a wonderful thing trying to change this and your little angel will be by your side all the way so proud of his mummy and daddy . . Rest in peace angel xx24482015-12-09T00:25:28.22310668kerry algieI didn't know this could be how some values can get meningitis and I've got two boys, I will be mentioning this in my future pregnancies for sure. My heart goes out to you and anyone else who suffered this dreadful and painful loss xxxxx24482015-12-09T01:00:58.4110669Leanne alawiI carry group b strep and with my second baby was told I would not automatically be given antibiotics I would not even be given a swab test !!! It is horrendous that this goes untested in uk and it is tested for in a lot of other countries such a simple test!! I made sure I got tested again and sure enough it was there in second pregnancy but I would have been left without antibiotics if I hadn't insisted on a swab test disgusting !!!24482015-12-09T01:39:21.70710670Sarah GilbertI'm speechless after ready what happened to this mother. No one should have to go through this pain and heartache for want of an £11.00 test. This story is something you expect to hear on a charity TV advert appealing for aid to 3rd world countries, not 2015 Scotland 24482015-12-09T03:47:20.87710671Philippa MillerI realise that this is a petition to the Scottish Assembly but I am English and live in England. I fully support this petition in Scotland, but also believe that it should apply in England and the rest of the UK.24482015-12-09T03:54:22.75310672Philippa Miller (again)I feel even more strongly, having read hundreds of comments. I am not a mother, and don't think I will be, but I still find it horrific that children are lost for the sake of a relatively cheap test. Is there a UK campaign to raise money for future mothers in difficult circumstances to have this test and have the infection treated? If so please point me in that direction. If no one can think of one I will look into it and begin one.24482015-12-09T05:13:02.81310674Anne MarpoleThis should be a routine test, it is in the U.A.E. 24482015-12-09T06:47:23.19310675Daniel Martin FairbairnMy good friends lost their first child to this, and it devastated them. I have two children of my own and watching my friend carry his sons coffin in his arms was a terrible feeling. This tragedy needs to be avoided, and can be avoided. 24482015-12-09T06:52:54.95710676Kayleigh nolan No mother should lose their child if a test could prevent this cause of loss should be done routeinly at every woman's labour! 24482015-12-09T06:57:37.78710677Carla Batstone I was so lucky to find out I have group b strep but only after 3 horrendous miscarriage so in a way if I hadn't of had them I could have also lost my baby boy so terrible poor baby and mummy my thoughts are with her xxx24482015-12-09T07:08:52.47310678Carol DochertyHow much is a babys life worth £11 ?24482015-12-09T07:09:57.2410679Margaret Hatley A simple test is all it takes to save a little child 24482015-12-09T07:14:23.2210680Janine weirI'm sure alot of women including myself wud even opt to paging for the swab tests themselves...so sad and soo preventable24482015-12-09T07:18:29.3510681Andrea StoneThere are too many avoidable baby deaths, this is so easy to avoid and I would have thought relatively low cost....well it is low cost when you consider the cost of a life 24482015-12-09T07:16:41.64310682Catherine TomineyWe have the worst rate of mother and child death in Europe joint with Greece & Croatia. Care has regressed since my experiences in the 80s and it wasn't great then!24482015-12-09T07:32:40.0510683Katie FletcherDue to a family member having Group B strep I was luckily informed about this after discussing with my midwife she informed me to go ahead and buy the test (£35 online) I was happy to pay this as it's worth every penny they say to test from 37 weeks, I had a bacterial infection towards the end of my pregnancy so the midwife sent swabs off and asked for them to test for the Group B Strep while they were testing so in the end I didn't have to pay privately, I had strep B so for me this is so important! keep signing xx24482015-12-09T07:34:21.89310684Sean CarneySigning for my sister in law24482015-12-09T07:40:22.70710685Alison HallShocking story. To think that this little boy could still be with us today if only a simple swab had been taken. How awfully sad.24482015-12-09T07:58:00.34710688Adriana HannaWhy on earth and in 2015 is this not being done £11 to save a beautiful little life..They have plenty of money to line there own pockets and I'm sure every mother as there that tight if offered a test would pay for it..Give mothers an option at least and tell them about this simple test...24482015-12-09T08:00:18.62710689Gemma LessellsAs an ambassador for the Meningitis research foundation who has campaigned tirelessly for the bexsero vaccine, I don't understand how that can be approved and yet an £11 swab is denied to mothers. There is nothing scarier than being told your child has meningitis, and I ca n only begin to imagine the heartache of losing a child. This needs to be addressed immediately! Just as no child should die from a vaccine preventable illness, no child, or mother should have to go through this illness which can be detected through a simple swab. Introduce it as a matter of routine immediately! 24482015-12-09T08:05:10.92710690Doreen BontemsI am so sorry for your loss. Heartbreaking and well done you for doing what you can to ensure this simple test is carried out on all mothers to stop this happening to other families you are so brave. Take care. Doreen24482015-12-09T08:06:21.53710691Laura tomanI have been affected by strep b and can understand but to have lost a child over a simple swab is unimaginable. Fortunately I was one of the lucky ones an detected strep b threw a utility during pregnancy so once I went into labour I was put on iv antibiotics an then once my little boy was delivered he was given the same. I sincerely hope changes are made and this is made compulsory. 24482015-12-09T08:04:58.48710692Lynda CoulterGod bless ! \r\nI knew I had strep B when i fell pregnant . I told midwife and consultant but fell on deaf ears !! Told on discharge that my daughter should have been given antibiotics but just to keep an eye on her !!!!! Luckily she is now 9 weeks and well . Terrible that families should have to go through this worry or devastation . Petition signed xxx24482015-12-09T08:08:31.78310693Nora cavanagh I have 2 daughter hopefully going to have children why aren't we swapping essential government it's our future generation.24482015-12-09T08:16:12.39310694Mark Douglas I want to help as I lost my little daughter six years ago and I don't want to see more women suffer like my wife did for years with depression,they say time is a healer'well it's a long time and I will never stop thinking about what might have been.24482015-12-09T08:27:39.8510695Amy taggart I also wasn't tested and my little girl was lucky however I was not as I developed septicaemia and was in hospital for a month and very lucky to be here but this could all be prevented with a swab24482015-12-09T08:35:13.6910696Ann LandelsWould be inexpensive and so easy to diagnose this either during pregnancy or during labour. The heartbreak must be devastating.24482015-12-09T08:40:20.4410697Cheryl lacriarde I had group b strep and passed it onto my son. St georges hospital in tooting refused to induce me, so I gave birth 51 hours after my waters broke, the hospital told me that my son may have menangitis, it's a shame we have to sign a petition for the nhs to carry out a vital test to prevent such a tradgedy24482015-12-09T08:45:26.64310698Valerie AikmanThis is shocking that it is something so simple to be done to avoid such a tragedy. 24482015-12-09T08:53:21.39710699Linda Johnston This test should be a matter of routine, so many people unaware of the danger strep b can cause and the devastation it brings to the family's involed when their child passes away. Scottish Parliament have to make this test complusory.24482015-12-09T08:54:49.28710700Felicity MaddisonI recently found out that I carry Group B Strep and only because I had a swab due to recurring thrush during pregnancy. I am disgusted that it is not a routine check. Instead the government is so busy trying to shove the flu jab down everyones throat when there are plenty of reasons not to have that! I asked midwives why Strep B is not tested for and the only reason I got was that it comes and goes and Iy would be a nusence to test every single time. Not good enough. I will be insisting upon antibiotics during labour as the risks are too high not to. 24482015-12-09T08:55:53.78310701Sarah Ingram I feel dreadful for this poor family and desperately sad that his death was preventable by a simple test. Please let's make this part of the birth cycle to prevent others suffering so cruelly. 24482015-12-09T09:07:26.310702Theresa GordonRoutine Swab tests for strep B should be carried out to prevent this ever happening again. This story is heartbreaking.24482015-12-09T09:11:03.95710703Angela bowkett This is such a sad story, let's hope some good comes out of it, this should b a routine test. So sorry for your loss.xxx24482015-12-09T09:21:43.89310704Grace CoyleThis should be compulsory in Ireland too.....24482015-12-09T09:31:54.98710705Paola PacchianaIt should be compulsory24482015-12-09T09:33:40.31310706karen grahamMy daughter carried strep B on my first grandson and was born not breathing,thankfully they brought him bk but was in intensive care had to have a lumber punch,we went through hell,but just a simple swab on mums can prevent that happening!!24482015-12-09T09:44:36.6610707Mary Elizabeth CurranThis is heartbreaking such a beautiful little baby and to think £11 would have saved his life if the test was compulsory. No other parent should go throu the pain and sorrow this couple have experienced. PLEASE MAKE THIS TEST COMPULSORY IMMEDIATELY. IT COULD BE YOUR FAMILY NEXT.24482015-12-09T10:13:03.23710709Jacky Ackerman If this is so easy, I cannot understand why it isn't compulsory . This needs to be introduced now!24482015-12-09T10:17:38.4110710Tricia queen I an currently 31 weeks pregnant and i gave group b strep only found out because i had swabs done for thrush and bacterial vaginosis or wouldnt have known i jad this please hust test on every pregnant lady could save lots of lives .24482015-12-09T10:31:12.4910711Angela DixonI am so sorry to hear of your devastation and loss. Signed and shared xxx24482015-12-09T11:04:42.48710715Jordane BellI think is something that should be taken serious. Read about a woman who lost her little boy all because the NHS didn't give her a simple swab that could have prevented the death of her beautiful bundle. I can only imagine the pain of losing a child, but to know it was preventable must be even more heartbreaking. Shame on the NHS, this should be compulsory!24482015-12-09T11:43:38.0810718Jamie McIntyreIt was picked up in my wife when first boy born. They knew about it for our second boy and gave her antibiotics. Why not swab and give everyone a chance. 24482015-12-09T11:56:29.59710719Michelle chapmanSomething as simple as a swab to save a babies life and a mother's heartache for life 24482015-12-09T12:05:27.51710720Sharon EcclesNow petition the government and NHS England 24482015-12-09T12:15:48.6610721Gemma TrestainSigbed on b3half of all women to ensure any carrying Strep B but are unaware can be safe in the knowledge that they will necer lose their child because of it. Can bever imagine the pain of losing a child.24482015-12-09T12:21:04.37710722Catherine Manfield As a mum that has Group B Strep, that was discovered in my 3rd baby when I went in to premature labour at 24 weeks, they said that Group B Strep can cause premature labour. It was frightening luckily enough they managed to stop my labour and she was born full term, I have gone on to have 3 more babies but have been monitored and given the antibiotics in labour. I strongly believe that mother should be offered the choice to be swabbed in pregnancy. 24482015-12-09T13:05:29.58310725Sharon talbotNearly lost our precious grandson to this disease, we were lucky others won't be24482015-12-09T13:45:03.14710727Becky O'Connor My baby boy was born with the help of forseps , they took a swap of my placenta as I had been unwell during labour, I had strep b, baby aand I were put on antibiotics and kept in hospital for a week , fortunately my baby was fine. I totally believe we should all be tested during pregnancy to prevent anything happening to our beautiful babies . 24482015-12-09T13:57:06.58310728Susan ChadwickMy daughter nearly lost her little girl, my granddaughter because of strep b, the midwives tried to tell my daughter that her baby had mucus when she started making grunting sounds so my daughter believed this to be so. Luckily me and her dad knew that there was something wrong when she brought her home and phoned an ambulance. She was rushed into intensive care and three doctors were working on her and she was only one day old and fortunately her life was saved so our hearts go out to Shaheen and her family over losing this little boy so please please make this swab for pregnant women compulsory.24482015-12-09T14:15:19.8310730Elizabeth StroudMy great nephew had exactly this condition. Fortunately he survived but it was touch and go for a few days. It was a nightmare for the parents and the rest of the family. My granddaughter has had a little boy 3 weeks ago exactly the same medical condition the test was done and all precautions were taken.24482015-12-09T14:53:57.110733Natalie Spencer I am in utter shock about this and yet it is another appalling thing to happen on behalf on the NHS. This should be done as a routine check or people should be aware that they can at least have it done as an additional cost of £11.00. No woman should ever have to experience the loss of a child especially if it could have been prevented by such a simple test and treatment to prevent it from happening. 24482015-12-09T15:52:21.8310734Julie AtkinsonI went through the same although I was lucky and my son survived. A simple test would have prevented all the heartache, for the sake of a small cost, which as an expectant parent would have happily paid myself, let's somehow prevent this devastating illness.24482015-12-09T16:26:49.78710736Sharon AlexanderI have strep b and never understood what it really ment till I had my son. This is so dangerous. All preg woman should be tested for this so it stops unnecessary deaths or illness. Thankfully ma son was born by csection. Hope this goes threw. 24482015-12-09T16:30:27.92310737Laura hollandHope this is tested for routinely never understood why it isn't.24482015-12-09T16:41:17.4410738Leighanne allen I always had sb wen pregnant with my last baby. But I was lucky enough he didn't get it. Even tho they knew I had it they still didn't give me what I needed and now cos off this my boy always ill with colds and ect. I think they should ask pregnant women of they wan it and if they have to pay then I'm sure they will just to be on the safe side 24482015-12-09T17:33:01.34710739Alicia JaxkmanThis is a no brainier!! Carry out the test as routine!24482015-12-09T17:44:53.98710741Zena wardMy grandson almost died from this infection, He contracted meningitis, he was so ill at two weeks old, but thank God he survived.24482015-12-09T19:04:58.20710742Lucy RobertsI am truly sorry for your loss as a mum of two I cannot comprehend how this must feel especially when it was not necessary...my heart bleeds for you. I have signed your petition and hope to God it works then maybe the English system might change also. All the best xx24482015-12-09T19:10:31.28710743Cassie PashThis brought tears to my eyes as I read this awful story. I have a little boy just two weeks older and I cannot imagine what the parents of this previous baby are going through. This must be change. What a beautiful baby and lost so suddenly from something that is so easily prevented. No more babies lost to this :( 24482015-12-09T19:16:56.7710745tara mohammadI was diabitice with my son, thanx to God i been checked in Bradford hospital , and I was clear from it24482015-12-09T19:17:32.0210746Ros DuffyThe NHS should make pregnant Mums aware of the possibility of bacterial meningitis being present in their bith canal, which could be passed on to their newborn baby. Offering a test which I think people would be willing to pay for, if not possible on the NHS, sounds sensible and the right way to go. Losing a baby in this way is unacceptable if easily prevented. We are in the 21st Century, not the Dark Ages. 24482015-12-09T20:22:40.84710750Angela MooreIt is imperative that this is made a priority, I was with my daughter throughout her labour and it was horrific to witness what this does and the consequences it has ... I was very lucky but I nearly lost my daughter and my grandson because no-one checked or asked any questions, it can also result in miscarriage, please help to spread awareness of this killer infection, thank you24482015-12-09T20:29:06.1610751heidi fitzpatrickI had heard of this however as a mother of 5 and a grandmother of 9 one sadly born too soon that the nhs is failing children not only ones that get to live for a short while those that never take a breath because they are not old enough to warrant any care. Every baby to its mother no matter how long on this earth is precious .24482015-12-09T20:31:22.23710752Eden Milne I was lucky enough to have this test during pregnancy and found out I was a carrier. I reckon the only reason I was tested was due to being a type 1 diabetic. I was so grateful to be a c-section in the end but no mother should ever have to experience this and the price per test is pennies considering the consequences. I hope this goes through. 24482015-12-09T21:19:46.33310753susan mcgraneI was diagnosed with group b strep at 34 weeks when I went into early labour. Its a simple swab test that has the potential to save lives. I would even happily pay for it myself. I hope everyone.signs this petition. I am so sorry for.your loss. 24482015-12-09T21:19:55.4110754Sarah DouglasOh gosh...but you are an amazing mummy to fight for other mummy's in the hope other babies are saved. Thank you for being an amazing mummy. God's grace is sufficient!! Xx24482015-12-09T21:30:51.4910756Hayley woloszczynska This isn't something that we should wait for, this has to happen now. Live is so precious and it shouldn't be taken away so carelessly. NHS please do the right thing, get every women tested 24482015-12-09T21:37:50.36310757Alison WelchThis really upset me,please make the changes to avoid this devastation happening to anyone else.24482015-12-09T21:44:28.17710758sylvia newboldHi im just writing because no mother should lose their child, their child should be the one who out lives the parents. Its horrible that the heath visitor should of known the signs and should of called an ambulance straight away, if the health visitor didn't know then every health visitors should go through training every year so it doesn't happen again, also the staff at the hospital should of offered the swab and mentioned it at least especially to a new mum who hasn't got a clue of what is out their to help the mums and the unborn child just incase their might be any complications in the pregnancy and during labour. To loose a child the parents wont be the Sam again because its heartbreaking to loose a child that you carry and protect during the pregnancy and the parents also have to protect and take care of the child cuz they carnt look after themselves and for all that effort and love just vanish just like that it is heartbreaking, also the parents will blame themselves for it even when its not their fault its a parent thing it will never fade away to protect the child it will always be their, so yh i agree that that should be the law to do that so it wont happen again 24482015-12-09T21:50:39.9910759Susan windeler Omg how sad please let them see this swab is so needed24482015-12-09T21:52:30.53710760Louise MelvilleI feel this is very important and life changing 24482015-12-09T21:55:12.5810761Chloe canningI feel very strongly about this, I had a swob done for something else and found out I had group b strep. My labour was so quick I didn't have chance for a section or antibiotics. When my baby was born she was treated for this and kept in hospital. But I always think if I had hadn't that swob done I would never of know and what could of happened. This needs to be a routine check, babies losing there life's for the sake of a simple swab test!24482015-12-09T22:09:29.75310764Laura WigginsSimple test and prevention is what we seek to do 24482015-12-09T22:17:46.4410765Patsy DavisI had group b strep in pregnancy, and in labour I was never given the antibiotics for it but I'm so lucky that my little girl is healthy and here with me. But all pregnant women should be tested for it if it stops a mother loosing there child and a baby loosing it's life why not? 24482015-12-09T22:24:31.8510766Linda malone This should be made compulsory for all pregnant women. As I have witnessed first hand with my niece what a devastating effect it has on family's knowing a simple test could have prevented the loss of her beautiful son .24482015-12-09T22:31:17.26710767Roxzannah MacDonaldI feel so sorry for this poor mum. Luckily it was discovered I had the infection in my urine a few weeks before my daughter arrived and therefore I had the necessary antibiotics in labour to protect her. It really really breaks my heart to think this poor mum has had to experience the loss of her child because of something that could have been prevented! Please please do something to prevent this ever happening again!24482015-12-09T22:41:58.6910770Emma DomingoThis is such a life saving test. I found out about it while I was in labor and it was too late for me to have antibiotics. The following days after my son was born were the scariest of my life. He spent a week in the special care baby unit and had to have introvenus antibiotics 3 times a day. Luckily he was fine after the tests came back. He is now eight. With my daughter I was prepared and had the test.24482015-12-09T22:49:36.0510771natalie hawkesI too feel more should be done to prevent any more babies becoming ill or potentially dying from this nasty illness. I'm a carrier of strep b but didn't find out I had it until pregnant with my youngest son. I infact carried it with my eldest son but had no knowledge of this until I was given antibiotics while in labour with my youngest. Just so glad and thankful that my eldest son was ok. I'm carrying again and will again be given antibiotics during my labour. Every woman deserves the right to know and swabbed during labour it would certainly reduce the infant mortality rate due to strep b.24482015-12-09T22:55:18.53310772Natalie ThomasSo sad, I'm deeply sorry for all mothers who have lost their babies to this illness. \r\nThank You for sharing as I like many other women have never heard of this! I'm 7 months pregnant with my second baby and will definitely be asking about this at my next Midwife appointment and when it's time to give birth.24482015-12-09T23:08:15.8810777Janine rice I have a 10 month old son and had group b strep while pregnant luckily I had been tested as I kept thinking I had kidney infections so was giving antibiotics while in labour and delivered naturally and my baby boy is healthy and well i think every pregnant woman should be given this £11 test as it would save so many babies lives 24482015-12-09T23:06:33.20710780victoria foxI can't belive this is not available to women in Scotland I was born and breed in London an know for a fact this test is on offer in England. Should us women not be given an option to buy a test at the lest to save the heartache your put family's under strain for no reason at all you should be ashamed of yourselfs24482015-12-09T23:22:21.56710781sandie Roughley My best friends list they're daughter during labour to an infection. .it was horrendous to see them grieve for they're baby girl when a simple test can save so many lives. Is a no brainer! !!!!24482015-12-09T23:28:58.610782Kayliegh TargettThis test should be routine so no parents have to go through the heartache of losing their child to this infection. So many lives could be saved. It needs to be a routine test for every pregnant woman. NHS don't fail other families, learn from this and help. 24482015-12-09T23:34:52.03310784cindy gunthorpeThis is a compulsory test in Australia an should be world wide.why let families suffer the sorrow an lose when they don't have to24482015-12-09T23:49:07.4410786Deborah Wright This shouldn't be allowed to happen again 24482015-12-09T23:56:21.2710787Lorraine Thompson Should never be aloud to happen s life is priceless 24482015-12-09T23:55:19.4110788Sinead LorimerShocking. I have never heard of this and I have had 3 kids. Thankfully I must not have Strep B but to think what would happen if I had and that it could be prevented especially for a test as little as £11 is crazy. This needs to be addressed. 24482015-12-10T00:00:51.3810789Liz Templeman I can't understand why this is not standard procedure. So sorry for your loss, you are a brave couple, your son would be so proud x24482015-12-10T00:44:13.4110790Charlene torranceI'm shocked and devistatied to learn that this is happening to so many new mums and babies when it can so be prevented for a couple of mins to take a swab.24482015-12-10T01:06:29.86310791Autumn Sullivan All women should be tested at very first antenatal appointments. Will be in contact with my midwife first thing for details on being tested! Truly heartbreaking story24482015-12-10T02:09:04.25310792Amarie O Doherty This should be available to every woman in the world regardless of risk, I'm so sorry for your little boys loss and all the woman who have lost children to this x24482015-12-10T04:42:31.4410793Linzi kerrAs i sit here bf my 10 week old i couldnt imagine life without him or his big brother and my thoughts have been with out and your family since i read your story. You havevan amazing little angel and he will be so proud of you and Daddy. For such an inexpensive test to be unavailable readily is just utter selfishness on the Governments side and they have lives on their concsience because of that. I really hope things change. Good luck and my prayers with you. 24482015-12-10T06:25:53.56310794Chantal burnsI think this is a very worthy cause. I feel this should definitely already be a routine check.24482015-12-10T06:53:51.7410795Katie Barrett So sad everyone needs to sign this. £11 to save a life.24482015-12-10T06:57:58.33310797Michelle BrownWhen I was pregnant with my first child I went into early labour at 23 weeks due to what the Dr's believe to have been an infection from a blood clot cause from a bleed during early pregnancy. I had some swab tests done which afterwards showed I had Group B Strep. Devestatingly my son was born sleeping but had this not happened and if I had gone to full term would he have survived birth after coming into contact with the GBS infection? I am now pregnant again and all my health carers know I have Group B Strep it has been noted on my notes with a big GBS sticker which im very glad about and have been told I will have antibiotics during labour. It saddens me though to think that I had to loose my first child in order to hopefully save my second. If it's too expensive for the NHS to offer all women a simple swab test for GBS then surely they could charge women for it. I'm sure if all women were truly made aware of the possible Devastating effects of this infection women would more than happily pay for how ever much it costs to have the test done. Least they would know they did everything they could to protect their baby. However I do believe it should be madatory and free on the NHS and should be done, I know the infection comes and goes im aware of that but testing a few weeks before a women is due to give birth would surely prevent so many deaths and so much more money being wasted on antibiotics and medical help being given to these sick babies if it was just detected sooner and prevented in fhe first place. 24482015-12-10T07:05:24.4910798Christine JeffreyThis test should be made a routine test to prevent this happening again.24482015-12-10T07:21:52.94310800Sean ButlerI lost my first born after he only lived for 30 minutes. This had nothing to do with meningitis but I know the pain of losing a child. Anything that can be done that saves even just 1 life it surely worth the cost. 24482015-12-10T07:46:14.9710801linda kelsallPlease sign this petition unnecessary deaths occurring all because procedures aren't in place 24482015-12-10T07:55:12.2710803Tessy RoperThis broke my heart this morning. My daughter was born in June this year, and due to an infection and a lot of complications she was born by emergency c-section and I was put on an anti-biotic drip when I arrived at the hospital. Due to a swab taken about a week before she was born, I received a letter stating that I did have group b strep a week after we returned home from hospital with our healthy baby. I was shocked as I had never even heard of group b strep. I was initially upset about all the complications I experienced during labour but I now know that it was a blessing in disguise and it probably saved my daughter's life. We were very lucky.\r\nI cannot come to terms with how little awareness there is of this subject and that there are tests available for just £11 which anyone can purchase. To me this comes close to neglect, as we could save babies lives simply by raising awareness of the infection and the importance for mothers to get tested.24482015-12-10T08:25:26.75310804Rosie SprakeI feel very strongly that there should be more information on this extremely common condition that is found in roughly 22% of all women and yet unless like me, my sister and many others, they happen to detect it incidentally people are non the wiser to the existence of it and the great risk it inflicts on your unborn child.\r\nMy heart goes out to all mothers who have endured this terrible tragedy and wholeheartedly support this petition. I will pray for the little angels who suffered.24482015-12-10T08:36:42.75310805Diana OwenThe Scots showed that they have a voice in the referendum.Use it to lead the UK and Ireland now by being the first Parliament to save these otherwise perfect babies,who should have had a long and lovely life.Scarred parents are no substitute.Even if the mother has to pay for the test it should be offered.24482015-12-10T08:47:35.76710806Wendy hingston My daughter carries strep b and has now had 3 children one was in special care when born due to this but survived so she had antibiotics with the other two. My heart goes out to all those who loose their babies when something so simple can change the outcome xx24482015-12-10T09:14:31.1610807Jade mcgillMothers should be definitely tested for this.24482015-12-10T09:53:22.9110808Keeley bowdlerI feel very strongly about this as my little cousin nearly Lost his life to this and seeing the affects it has is heartbreaking I also have my own little boy on the way and think a simple test should be given to prevent other parents going through this 24482015-12-10T10:42:43.01710810Leanne HardyI am currently 6 months pregnant and the thought of this happening absolutely petrifies me! This should be something that is done with every pregnancy and I fully back this petition. Sending all my love to every family affected.24482015-12-10T10:47:36.4710811Nola FitzsimonsI too had Group B Strep during pregnancy. This was only detected by chance as I had a swab taken as I experienced some bleeding. I believe this is tested for as standard in the US and feel very strongly that it should be here too!!!24482015-12-10T10:50:07.53310812Marian O'ConnorIt should be compulsory right across the NHS, or if crying about funding, parent would gladly pay £11 to have this test done. I know I would!!!24482015-12-10T10:58:01.310813debbie drain I have had a baby and have never heard of this how devasting and can be stopped so easily !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! surely they are accountable 24482015-12-10T11:00:40.51710814Carol bunceSave our babies 24482015-12-10T11:00:51.53310815Alison CuthbertsonI feel so strongly about this.Iam so sorry for all the parents who have lost their babies to Strep B.I was 1 of the lucky 1s and it was dedicated in my baby.24482015-12-10T11:15:03.33310816Lynsey mcinally No one mum should need to suffer this especially when it can be prevented by a simple text24482015-12-10T11:22:43.2410817Kirsty ChealI have had 3 children & have never heard of this but had I been offered the test I would have had it as I think every mother would. Even if not available through the NHS due to costs I am pretty sure all mothers would pay the £11 to have it done. I think it's awful this is not done something so simple could save the lives of many, not just the baby but the heart broken parents too24482015-12-10T11:29:57.14310818Alana smithTo many needless life's lost put the information out there24482015-12-10T11:51:04.17310819Kirsty Cole i think this test should have been done a long time ago, I had group strep b which was detected early enough to give me the chance to have a c section. This could save so many babies and heartache for the families that go through it unknowingly.24482015-12-10T12:23:09.19310820lynda bartleSo sad hope your petition makes all government and NHS officials make this happen xx24482015-12-10T12:39:24.610821Violet WhiteMy grandson's life was put at risk due to this condition not being dealt with properly. Very important everyone is aware of this threat to babies. 24482015-12-10T12:45:55.14710822Laura BeattieMy eldest daughter contracted GBS septicaemia and meningitis in 2010, thankfully she survives but many do not which is a tragedy for a preventative measures can easily be taken24482015-12-10T13:16:48.39710824Tracey quantrell I think women should not even get a choice. They should do this swab automatic durin their labour.\r\n\r\n24482015-12-10T13:38:24.64310827Jen ForsythAn incredibly important cause. I nearly lost my nephew due to this back when he contracted at one day old in July. We were incredibly lucky he is still with us and has not suffered any debilitating effects. Given the severity, I find it incredible there is not more awareness and that such a simple detection is not routine.24482015-12-10T13:42:51.1610828Jeanette M DowIt's not that long ago when expectant mothers were routinely swabbed for Strep B during their antenatal care in Scotland........shocked to see they no longer do it! I was definitely swabbed in my last 2 pregnancies 9 and 6 years ago! Bring it back please!24482015-12-10T13:46:59.33310830Debbie ChewNo parents show have had to go through the stress & suffering of finding out afterwards that a simple test could have saved your beautiful baby. How many more mistakes are going to happen. These are children we are talking about, little lifes. Please help & stop this from happening. A test should be given to every pregnant women.24482015-12-10T13:50:28.00310831Julie GidlowI discovered that my son was exposed to this during labour, one week after his birth when a midwife turned up unexpectedly at my home to tell me. In my child's case it didn't develop into meningitis, but it was the first time I had ever heard of it, and he was my third child. It should be screened for as a matter of course!24482015-12-10T15:44:09.14710836Emma McLeodWomen should be screened as standard. No mother should ever have to go through this when a simple test and course of IV antibiotics during labour could have prevented it. 24482015-12-10T18:36:29.69310837andreas scott my family members have suffered from this and people need to be made more aware 24482015-12-10T18:49:05.59710838Michelle hallI totally agree it should be compulsory as my daughter-in-law had it too but it was found when she was 27 wks and had the antibiotics in labour 24482015-12-10T19:09:33.70710840Sarah charity Dickson I was told this test was optional and cost over 30 pounds. But was relatively unimportant so pretty much advised against it. Ridiculous. They offer a test for downs syndrome The result of which in the worst case produces amazingly different people, not testing for strep! loss of life 24482015-12-10T19:06:57.42310841Angela LeeFor the sake of £11.00, it should be introduced immediately. No mother should ever have to bury their baby. God bless x24482015-12-10T19:15:27.8310842kirsty Patrick So sorry to hear about your wee boy Zach, I found out I had group b strep wen this done a swab thinking I had an infection. Every expecting mother shud hav this, all the length of time it takes to do. 24482015-12-10T19:46:24.81710843Virginia NewmanMake this swab a compulsory check to save a new life. I cannot imagine how these parents feel with the loss of their baby through something so easily prevented. My thoughts and warmest regards go out to all of those people who have suffered 24482015-12-10T19:48:29.0810844Fiona CraigBring it back!!!24482015-12-10T20:50:01.610845Julie wesolyIs that the cost of a new life24482015-12-10T21:11:46.06310846Claire JamesThis would be a good idea to have at the beginning of labour 24482015-12-10T21:34:21.6610847Julie BreenIt beggars belief that this relatively cheap test is not administered as a matter of course. Please God the law is changed to ensure the health and safety of newborn babies. 24482015-12-10T21:36:40.14710848Lindsey CummingsI was advised the reason I wasn't offered this test through the NHS was because it was to expensive to test every expectanct mother! If there's no family history or previous illness it's not mandatory! I would have happily paid for the test, regardless of cost! I only found out about it because a friend told me! Women need to be informed about this test and offered the test for free or at cost! 24482015-12-10T21:42:44.83310850bena hoganI was shocked after a family member and her partner had to go the terrible loss of thier beautiful little baby due to this terrible but yet such a simple procedure God bless those going through thier losses 24482015-12-10T21:50:16.44310851MRS LYNDA WHALENA swapthat is all it takes to save a babies life.Each lady should be told about this and be entitled to getting it done.24482015-12-10T21:47:25.87710852Natasha McGimpseyI'm very sorry for the loss of you beautiful little baby. Thank you for being brave enough to fight for this in the hope that future mothers won't have to experience your pain x 24482015-12-10T22:20:09.3810853Amanda PlaistowAnything to prevent baby and infant loss should be made aware of even if we have to pay for it ourselves!! 24482015-12-10T22:20:44.0210854Nicola TaylorTo loose a child must be devastating, but to then be told that this could have been prevented with a simple swab must be heart breaking!!\r\nThis is terrible so many children have lost there lives. 24482015-12-10T22:54:50.42710856Leanne WilsonI feel so strongly about this matter! Is is life saving therefore without question this test should be carried out and all pregnant women should be well informed. We are 'letting' babies die which is heartbreaking.24482015-12-10T23:07:03.70710857Amanda LumsdenMy daughter carried this during pregnancy and it was only picked up by chance\r\n24482015-12-10T23:17:51.310858Teena mulleyI gave birth at the leic General.. 5weeks early I went in to labour.. I suddenly had a temperature during giving birth.. And my baby was not breathing when born.. He was taken into special care unit.. The midwives didn't explain what happened until we found out he got strep b.. We was both given antibiotics.. But after a few months I realised just how serious it was.. But when I was on the ward 5 other women also had the same problem.. I'm sure there is more.. I'm so sorry for your loss.. But it's brilliant what you are doing.. As I tell everyone to try get tested. 24482015-12-10T23:24:45.11310859Nichola davyIf mothers are told about this im sure 99.9 would actually paid them self out of there own money to prevent harm or death to the baby. Awareness and advise cost nothing 24482015-12-10T23:30:51.9110860sam gibsonWhile I understand all the £11.00 add up to create a big bill for the NHS the tests should be offered for patients to pay themselves. Who would say no to the opportunity to save your babies life for £11.00.24482015-12-10T23:42:31.3610862Marisa MitchellAbsolutely horrifying to hear that the NHS do not have this in place already. It does not cost a lot to swab for this. Just imagine how many lives would be saved from a simple swab. 24482015-12-10T23:48:24.14310865Sinead cooney I believe the hospitals could do a lot more 24482015-12-10T23:50:20.12710866Mrs Brenda ClarkeSomething so cheap and easy to obtain should be automatically available to all pregnant women to eradicate these deaths.24482015-12-11T01:31:49.51710867angela taylorMore has to be highlighted about this to make parents aware of how serious this can be and how easy itis to prevent it 24482015-12-11T04:22:37.9410869Jennifer CampbellPlease make this effective test compulsory prior to birth.24482015-12-11T06:17:59.78710870Maria Caraman So sorry to hear what happened to your little one. \r\nI discovered by an accident that I carried GPS, had no idea of the meaning of this before as know one tell you anything about it. Luckily me made it through, who knows what would have happen if would not insisted to have a swab, and felt very unwell at that time 24482015-12-11T06:18:19.45710871Pauline O'Haire All pregnant women should be tested for Strep B during their pregnancy. I myself had Strep B during my last pregnancy and passed it on to my twins who were born very premature at 26 weeks. The NNU picked up the Twins had it with in hours and they were treated immediately with antibiotics through their IV drips. No child should have to be born with this as it can be simply detected by an NHS test costing just £11.00. 24482015-12-11T06:23:24.6110872Tanya OliverSigning this on behalf of friends who have just been through a difficult few weeks after the birth of their baby girl. Thankfully everyone is now doing well and they can be a great family. 24482015-12-11T07:24:56.01710873Heidi Palmer This swab for group B strep should be routinely taken. I was lucky that a random test showed that I carried this and was offered the correct care in my labour's. No one should have to endure the loss and devastation when it can simply be prevented. 24482015-12-11T08:54:43.86310874Louise MiddletonA safe and affordable practice not being practised!! Save luves not money!24482015-12-11T09:18:39.62710875Clare KeenanThis should never happen to any family a simple swab is all that is needed24482015-12-11T09:31:32.70710876Samantha SmithNot just for Scotland but all of the U.K. 24482015-12-11T09:54:03.7210877yvonne bowes To safe more babys24482015-12-11T10:16:29.50310878Pam NicollI'm currently 38 weeks pregnant and would happily pay for a Strep B test24482015-12-11T10:31:34.92310879MARION THOMSONIt is just common sense to test saving families from devastating consequences.\r\n24482015-12-11T11:34:06.6110880Margo JarvieDefo get it done!!!!!24482015-12-11T14:14:15.1910882Karla Fitzpatrick This is utterly devastating !! Anyone with a child and a heart for that matter should sign this takes 2 seconds snd potentially could help save little babies just like this is the future !\r\nR.i.p beautiful boy x\r\nPLEASE SIGN !!! 24482015-12-11T15:08:02.03710884Suzanne McBride Feel very strongly about this 24482015-12-11T15:40:33.9410885Amie TolsonI cannot begin to imagine how this mother and her family are feeling. This is absolutely heart breaking, that poor little boy and his family have suffered so bad for something that could have and should have been stopped. It is utterly shameful and disgraceful that women aren't swabbed during labour it's one simple swab that costs £11 which would save innocent beautiful little lives. It's not as if the swab would be a great effort anyways, midwives could practically do two jobs at once whilst doing an internal they could also do the swab it's not rocket science. I truly hope this petition gets to where it needs to be babies and families don't deserve this torture because that's exactly what it is.....torture, something a mother and father have to live with forever, picturing in their heads of what their innocent child would look, sound, smell like, what they would be when they grow up and the feeling of being the proudest parent in the world when their child would have reached all their milestones......... These parents won't have all those because of one £11 swab. The NHS ought to be ashamed. I hope this family get some sort of closure and my heart goes out to them all and to all other parents and their children have suffered from this......your all so so brave.24482015-12-11T17:05:23.39710887Trish NewcombNo parent should have to go through that and then find out a simple test would of prevented it24482015-12-11T17:08:38.11310888laura bell I had a traumatic experience with my beautiful daughter who luckily was okay in the end!!! Xxx love and prayers to everyone's children that didn't survive xxx 24482015-12-11T19:17:07.6910889Judy JonesA swab would have saved my grandson's life.24482015-12-11T19:32:31.6910890Lesley CookThese tests should be routine, I carried strep b but thankfully my girls were fine as I got antibiotics during labour 24482015-12-11T21:10:46.48710893Sarah DeyThis unfortunately caused the loss of my friends child, I hope to never see this heartache again from something so preventable with a simple test24482015-12-11T21:16:44.2710895Rebecca BartellUtterly devastating. No words!! Such a beautiful little boy. Sleep tight little angel. We shall all fight for you x24482015-12-11T21:21:34.06710896Rebecca woodhousethis is a must and I don't know why this isn't done anyway!!! My son had meningitis at 7 weeks old and nearly died, luckily I have a happy ending but to all the poor families that go through such a heart breaking time, this needs to happen to stop all the devastation people go through!! 24482015-12-11T21:44:50.4410897kirsty mahony No one should have to go through this. It is SO unfair and this could have been prevented through Group B Strep testing and awareness. 24482015-12-11T21:48:44.95710898May Hamilton This is just wonderful Zach will be so proud of his mum and dad .I knew as soon as I saw his picture it was Zach beautiful little boy .24482015-12-11T21:53:31.50310899Danielle MarshallSo sorry for your loss I belive the mid should do this swab everywhere xx24482015-12-12T01:26:43.8810902Donna YoungI strongly agree that this test should be done and if it was done on Shaheen her adorable baby son would still be here with us. RiP little fly high with Angels.24482015-12-12T04:17:04.64310903Kirsti HarrisonI am so Glad to see more people fighting against this.I too lost my first born son to this horrific infection 4 years ago and the pain will live with me forever. Praying this will help in the battle of save so many lives and saving so many parents from dealing with this heartache. Something should have been put in place by now and it sad that it takes so many children loosing their lives for people to listen, Good Luck xxx24482015-12-12T07:23:46.69310904Charlene Conroy I was hospital while I was pregnant with my 3rd child I kept on have contractions at 28weeks so doctors checked and did swabs and only then did I find out I had b strep if I hadn't gone to the hospital that day I would have never of known.This should be tested on every pregnancy for the safety of the unborn baby's.24482015-12-12T08:09:12.50310906Rachel BullPlease make these rountine24482015-12-12T08:19:21.3510907Jemma Goodridge This should be all over the UK not just Scotland 24482015-12-12T10:08:08.89310908Lisa neillFeel very strongly about this 24482015-12-12T10:21:41.56310909Kim graySigned let's hope it happens x\r\n24482015-12-12T11:53:16.9910910Alexandra Clarke QuinguaNeeds to change fast24482015-12-12T14:35:06.97310911Caron blairNo parent should have 2 lose a child .The test should be compulsory no parent should have 2suffer for the sake of £11 that is absolutely disgraceful 24482015-12-12T18:02:02.70710912Karine zaksPlease sign . Even if this test saves one life. Bacterial meningitis is one of the worst baby and childhood diseases . We need to do everything to stop it. I am really sorry for your loss and no words can describe your pain. Our little boy has bacterial meningitis but he is one of the lucky ones but has been left with severe hearing loss from this terrible disease . Obviously a small price to pay but a reminder everyday of what he went through x24482015-12-12T19:48:27.2710913Eleanor HennigeSo upsetting! People should be informed 24482015-12-12T21:56:39.47310914Kimberley manvilleI feel this should be basic testing and should be done!24482015-12-12T22:27:58.56710915Denise FlaxmanMy daughter is due to have a baby in July. I never knew about this preventable risk. I hope something can be done to change this for future mothers to be. 24482015-12-12T23:04:48.11310916Jean Anne MitchellThe devastating loss of your precious baby is heartbreaking and changes your life forever. What cost is attached to a baby's life? Surely in 2015 this simple lifesaving test should be undertaken as a matter of routine. Too many precious babies are dying due to Group B Strep leaving lifelong headache for young families. This must be addressed by Scottish a Government as a matter of urgency as these baby deaths are absolutely avoidable. Please don't be responsible for more baby deaths. Cut through any obstacle and sanction tests for everything mother.\r\nI am so sad for these parents.24482015-12-13T00:44:49.48710918Trish HardingSuch devastating consequences which can be avoided by a simple test. Surely this should be part of a standard pre-natal assessment??24482015-12-13T02:31:58.87710919Leanne van Berkum I almost lost my 1year old daughter to an accident which could have been prevented in a Soft Play Area a month ago. I still feel utterly frustrated now by the pain she's still suffering but blessed she's still here. I'm so glad you are raising awareness, I had no idea about this swab. Thank you. I'm also raising awareness and have a petition about soft play areas. I know it's very brave to do something positive. Your whole life ca just change in an instant! My heart bleeds for you all, it's such a waste of a life, such unnecessary unhappiness. God bless your baby boy. 24482015-12-13T09:23:31.56310920linsey mccallumI hope this goes a long way. My heart goes our to all the people who have suffered. God bless24482015-12-13T12:26:01.03710921Teresa HarkinThis is a terrible tragedy and I hope this petition helps God Bless 24482015-12-13T18:57:08.5510923Ruth SweeneyMy Granson developed this condition hours after he was born, a heathy weight, 8lbs 10, my daughter had no idea she was a carrier for this virus and if he hadn't had a very switch on doctor look him over and get him immediately into special care then we may have lost him X so sorry to those who were not so lucky X this should be a routine test for all mums! 24482015-12-13T21:13:30.51710924Kerry RousellGet this compulsory - im gob smacked that we dont do this already!!!thoughts are with the family and beautiful baby boy x24482015-12-13T23:56:32.2210925Jennifer TimminsThis is unbelievable that an 11pound test could have saved this baby, however i think this should be carried out in all of great britain not just scotland.24482015-12-14T12:15:20.67710928Angela wrightWas never aware of this test but for the sake of a babies life all mums should be tested!24482015-12-14T12:54:29.610929Owen SmithThis tragedy could have been avoided with this test, costing just a few pounds. It must now be compulsory UK wide.24482015-12-14T15:25:36.4910931Annette McDonnell Can't believe this is not routine!!! Our NHS needs to be improved. No mother should have to go through this heartbreak x24482015-12-14T16:38:31.94310932Natasha McseveneyI think this tragedy could of been avoided and I think the parents need answers.24482015-12-14T18:59:15.810934Cheryl dickiI completely agree that this should be tested anything that could save a child's life is worth testing . X24482015-12-14T20:41:40.3310936Claire Gallacher Such a a simple and easy test to do to save the pain and heartache this family and many others have suffered, parents shouldn't have to go through this, so sad, thoughts are with you's all and wish you's best of luck with your petition, your so inspirational x 24482015-12-14T21:13:10.3310937Sadie princeDrug addicts are given methadone at no cost. Get a grip Government act now.24482015-12-15T05:24:22.42710941Nakiita HayesThis is standard in the US and it needs to be standard everywhere!!!!24482015-12-15T13:54:00.23710944Michelle Ireland With my last pregnancy I had Group B Strep. It was only discovered by accident, I had to get antibiotics a hour or two before I had my gorgeous girl then I got to take her home. Her smile is the best thing a child could give to her parents and I dread to think that could have happened to her and I would never have seen her again. She was my forth pregnancy and in all the time I have seen midwives very few of them have mentioned group b strep or its dangerous consequences. There is a smallish bit in the ready steady baby book given at first appointment, not enough if it's taking children away from the people that love and cherish them though. All that is needed is a simple test and antibiotics to ensure that the children of tomorrow get to brighten up Scotland with their smiles. Please help this happen.24482015-12-15T19:33:42.9710945Ali BellNurses would love to be able to do this and their hands are tied... Please don't let anymore babies die... Sending love to Shaheen and Craig and their families xxx 24482015-12-15T23:54:17.19310946Emma hunt All it takes is a test this should be told to every pregnant woman & should have it done. I really feel for the family who have lost their little baby boy through this, absolutely heartbreaking 24482015-12-16T00:33:24.89710947Aoife AllisonThis should be Mandatory end of story. 24482015-12-16T10:45:13.9110948Jacqui Goldie I'm a practising midwife and strongly believe every pregnant women should be screened for strep b infection . There's an argument about the cost ,but over the years I have seen a lot of money being spent on unnecessary tests . This is have devastating consequences if not discovered in time come on Scottish government prevent babies becoming very ill or worse .24482015-12-16T11:08:09.26710949Stephen Toman Why leave it to chance? We were lucky that it WA stumbled upon when checking something else.24482015-12-19T14:32:41.3910952Catherine McDougallWould save a lot of heartache if this was mandatory money and time waste on paperwork and administration could go towards the cost24482015-12-20T11:11:53.37710954Nicola brennanI lost my beautiful baby girl to this awful infection. Terrible to think it can be avoided for 11 pounds. 24482015-12-20T14:50:55.7510955Debbie mclellanMy heart goes out to the family they are doing a good thing to prevent this happening to another family xxx24482015-12-20T23:17:56.3910958Ann Rooney Why has this not been sorted ..no baby should be at risk ... ...we should be at the front when it comes to risk of life 24482015-12-23T02:31:09.79710959Brian DalySurvivors have been given very little by Government. Now they want to take away our lifeline the Service . The NHS model hasn't worked in the past why use this model again......24662015-12-23T19:34:10.04710960Janine RennieThe ICSSS service has saved lives and is a model that puts survivors of abuse at the centre. It would be a travesty of justice for it to go24662015-12-23T21:58:02.7210962Jillian GrayThe survivors do need this service for Incare and without it will be a huge loss. This service is important for people who have suffered or suffering sexual abuse in care. 24662015-12-24T06:57:36.3610965Carolann smillieI was lucky enough to have the treatment for Group B strep when I was having my son. I cannot imagine what you are going through when it could have been prevented. God bless you xxxx24482015-12-24T07:33:41.3610966Alexandra O'Brien Support this cause it's so important 24482015-12-24T07:43:29.1410967christine patersonI hope this wee boy is the last to lose his life due to mummies not getting a wee swab taken !24482015-12-24T08:37:17.79710969Patricia AndersonDon't let this happen to another beautiful young family24482015-12-24T08:46:46.7510970Diane StewartUntil this article I was unaware that Group B Strep was so common in pregnancy and babies, and will such fatal results. Surely this test should be a routine part of pregnancy procedures. \r\n24482015-12-24T08:51:20.3910971patrician boyleI am sorry for your loss my daughter is having a baby our first grand child and I was just speaking to her about your plight last night and hopefully this test becomes compulsary as no mother should have to go through what you and your partner have I hope you are successful in your fight to have this test available God bless x24482015-12-24T09:08:32.40710973ali McMurrayMy heart goes out to the parents. It is devastating that in this day and age a simple little test is not done to prevent needless pain suffering and death. X24482015-12-24T09:26:42.54710975Jamie BradleyGod Bless the family, hopefully common sense will prevail and the test will be made available to protect our future new borns.24482015-12-24T09:38:51.6410976Pauline Collins Mums to be should all be screened for Group B Strep24482015-12-24T09:36:38.76710977Julie ScottI had strep B info when pregnant with my second child. Luckily I found out I had it and was treated during labour. I didn't know anything about this infection before. I feel there should be more media campaigning to make everyone aware of the effects of this awful infection in a newborn baby. 24482015-12-24T09:45:20.8910978Victoria BegleyI really hope this makes a difference. No baby should die when this could haven been so easily prevented.24482015-12-24T09:42:36.1110979Sara price I was texted positive for group strep at 16 weeks and wasn't informed until I got\r\nDischarged from\r\nHospital and we ended up back in as our son wasn't right luckily our boy Is fine and all you get off the nurses is its not that dangerous yet people loose their baby's through it so the sooner something is done about it the better because it's heartbreaking to carry a child and then loose that child because something was missed and shouldn't of been missed 24482015-12-24T10:09:10.1110981Emma MayCannot believe in this day and age this simple test is not routine????? 24482015-12-24T10:15:55.6110983lyndsay maxwell shaheen darling we havent spoken since high school in biology. i was really sad to hear about your son i have 3 children and i dont think i would manage if anything happened to them. i trully hope the best for you hen xx24482015-12-24T10:23:15.8610984Sara Brown I lost my son at 6and a half months old through cot death this could have been avoided which is really sad god bless you are baby and your mummy n daddy xxx24482015-12-24T10:28:22.59310985Lorraine Blairas a carrier of strep B, my son and I were lucky it was diagnosed and both had antibiotics. Please make this test routine. 24482015-12-24T12:25:02.18710986Susan mckinlaySo terrible this has happened.hopefully signing this petition will do something about this24482015-12-24T13:51:45.9710988Neil HendersonFeel strongly about this as my Wife found out she was carrying Strep B after being hospitalised with a kidney infection. Had she not had the infection we would not have known and a quick sample was all it took to find out. This could have potentially been very dangerous for our daughter had it remained undiscovered. 24482015-12-24T14:22:34.37710989Stacy Burns My heart goes out to this family, no one should have to go through this! This should be a mandatory check on every woman who is having a baby! Think it's amazing that someone is trying their hardest to put a stop to this happening to anybody else! It's heartbreaking! 24482015-12-24T17:03:23.48310990Ruth Terrysilent killer so sad24482015-12-24T17:05:11.7810991Gillian thomsonTragic. When a tragedy like this can be avoided, all must be done to make sure it is.24482015-12-24T17:59:47.51710992william thomsonThis test should allways be available before labour to prevent this happening ever again,so sad...24482015-12-24T18:17:00.01710993Samantha Greeni completely back this, I myself carry Group B Strep and first found out by a swab that was taken while in hospital during my pregnancy with my first born (over 9 years ago). Due to the complications and severe health issues this can cause, every pregnant lady should be tested during their pregnancy24482015-12-24T19:01:02.79710994Peter KelbieThis service is more important now than ever before the government had a duty of care and protection in the past and they failed in all areas to protect millions of victims who were in care. The government is still failing so many today. But I have seen that this is indeed an highly important service and in 2016 to 2019 this service will become even more important for ex care clients of Scotland. 24662015-12-24T20:04:09.2510995Pete Stubbings 18 years ago our son was born and within 2 hours was critically ill for i4 months. Things haven't moved on have they. Desperately sorry to read this. With love, Pete 24482015-12-26T16:59:41.7811000Caroline RobertsonI passed this onto my son and he was in special care for a number of weeks, my son is now 14 years old ...one of the lucky ones, my heart goes out to the families that have suffered a loss due to this, the comments are heart breaking X24482015-12-26T20:15:39.20311001Ross HallidayI hope that this petition can help change the system.\r\nHeartfelt sympathy to this family and to all other parents who have lost their child to this. \r\n 24482015-12-26T23:03:56.18711002Jaci Steele-Curran My heart was breaking reading your story and the loss of your baby boy. Hope the Scottish government take action. 24482015-12-28T16:38:10.62711003Fiona BuchananPlease start to test routinely for this.24482015-12-28T17:58:32.95311004Martin ClarkDo the right thing and stop anyone else going through this awful suffering. Thoughts go out to the family and all involved, hope this gets the desired result.24482015-12-28T20:00:08.32711005Alison McDonald More needs to be done about this!!24482016-01-01T17:54:39.59311006Linda BrodieThis charity provides real support for survivors. some of whom are the most vulnerable of society.24662016-01-01T17:56:35.26711007Karl BrodieThis is something I feel passionate about and do not want to see it taken away.24662016-01-04T21:58:52.29711008Heather FordThis service is vital not only to survivors but also to families. Families are left to carry as much of a burden caused by the past abuse.24662016-01-06T09:40:57.12711009Elspeth WhiteI know first hand how important this service is. I was asked by a survivor about to start getting support if he would be abandoned if the service disappeared. He has nowhere else to turn and needs this vital support. 24662016-01-06T12:13:13.84311010Cath TaylorI am currently supporting many survivors within ICSSS who feel that they would struggle to cope if the service was changed. They have stated that they would feel abandoned again. 24662016-01-07T19:21:41.7511011Aisha Scott HamiltonThis dedicated service has been built and developed over several years and encompasses not only direct service users but multi strand affected parties thereby maximising the outreach potential. The complication of access to or cessation of this vital dedicated service would, I strongly believe be an extremely myopic decision. The fallout for survivors regarding years of trust building, a safe place, and continuing support, plus future potential users, would be catastrophic. Please think this through in the long term.24662016-01-07T21:58:58.42311012Caren ChristieICSSS is valuable and a much needed support network for survivors to access and talk about their individual experiences which is vital. Replacing this with a signposting service will inhibit this process and leave many vulnerable people with nowhere to go for support. 24662016-01-08T12:24:42.3611013james mcdermottI have the right to receive this service.Removing it is a failure by Govt Duty Of Care and Breach of my Human Rights as a Vulnerable Adult.24662016-01-08T13:19:0811014yvonne forsythWithout in care survivors . Survivors would b lost in a world of their own . In care survivors give the survivors what they need. Understanding . Hope n counciling for as long as u may need it. N most of all reassurance . In care survivors must carry on for the next generation who will need their help. 24662016-01-08T20:55:59.09311015Joseph GrahamThe ICSSS is a lifeline for survivors it is essential to survivors wellbeing it should be funded and maintained it is an essential part of helping survivors to cope and survive their trauma having used this service I cannot praise them enough for their past help and continuing help they have never abandoned me.24662016-01-09T03:40:35.20311017Gordon WilsonI need this,who where can help me!!!24662016-01-09T09:21:16.92311018claudia BetancurIt must be kept, load of people are and would be still benefited by it !! Life is hard enough for those affected and they must have this support for as long as they need it !!24662016-01-10T21:52:01.29711019Sylvia YoungThe trust and confidence survivors have built in the service over the past years speaks for itself and is underlined by their deep concern that this service would not be available for other survivors in the future.24662016-01-12T13:20:25.06311022Ashleigh RonaldThe service has and is benefitting alot of individuals. To change the service would be detrimental to these individuals and could trigger similar feelings of not being heard whilst in care. 24662016-01-12T14:57:14.76711023Gordon JohnstoneThe staus quo must be kept for the benefit of present day people who are using the service where trust has been built up by repretation and can be passed on24662016-01-15T16:06:23.20311024Andrew BarkerFull closed containment is, additionally to control of sea lice, vitally important to stop the massive numbers and disastrous consequences of escapees from fishfarms cross breeding with wild salmon. e.g 16,000 fish escaping from Carradale in June 2015.24722016-01-16T08:16:34.45311025Robert WhiteI believe that sea lice is the main cause of the decline in West Coast salmon & Seatrout stocks. Other factors such as PD in salmon farms is part of the problem. Control of farming salmon is essential if recovery is to be possible. I do fear that action might be too late for some seatrout systems. Loch Maree being the classic example. 24722016-01-17T13:00:43.12711026Anthony JacksonI fully support this petition and urge the Scottish Government to make changes to this industry which has decimated our wild Salmon and Sea Trout populations, no more excuses - it is blatantly obvious!24722016-01-17T17:07:31.87711027Tony AndrewsMost independent scientists on both sides of the Atlantic Ocean agree that the massive scale of open mesh salmon farming in inshore waters is causing serious problems for wild Atlantic salmon and sea trout. It would be wrong to downplay the effects of genetic introgression that occurs in rivers, such as the Balgy, where 'swamping' by escaped farmed fish occurs. Sea lice certainly pose the most acutely risk requiring urgent action, but we must not ignore the insidious impact of introgression from escaped maturing adults and from pre smolts escaping from badly maintained cages in fres water lochs. Salmon farming as currently practised in Scotland is simply unsustainable. If inshore salmon farms were required to monitor their effluents in the same way as terrestrial farms do with livestock it is doubtful whether the industry could continue as it is at present. TA24722016-01-17T20:25:56.48311028Angus Macmillan DouglasVery happy to support this important cause.24722016-01-18T08:47:06.23311029Ewan KennedyI have signed the petition and hope that it is accepted by the Petitions Committee in due course.\r\nPreviously I submitted comments on behalf of the saveseilsound campaign group, of which I am the secretary, to the RACCE Committee when it was taking evidence on the Bill that led to the recent Act.\r\nI also read the reports on the hearings and was extremely concerned at the scientific evidence presented to the Committee on behalf of the industry.\r\nI would welcome the opportunity to make a submission to the Petitions Committee, either in writing or orally, regarding the menace that sea lice present to our wild salmonids.\r\nFinally please note that I am not connected with S&TCS in any way and have never in my life attempted to catch a wild salmon or salmonid. My concern is purely with the threat to our wildlife, the environment and ultimately the local micro-economies from a global industry. 24722016-01-18T09:11:21.07711030Brian FraserPerhaps it time the Scottish Government to put a founding package together to help fish farming go to closed containment. 24722016-01-18T12:03:42.15711032mark vincenta had the lease on the loch mare hotel for 21years the fishing was ruined by sea lice24722016-01-18T13:47:52.2511033Corin SmithI signed the petition today. I would recommend that anyone who signs the petition also leaves a comment confirming it as well.24722016-01-18T16:25:08.23311034Maj(retd) M StannersI grow weary of the innumerable investigations and scientific probes into the reason for the decline of our salmonids. The analogy of Nero fiddling whilst Rome burns leaps to mind here.I have fished for salmon for 50+ years and at no time has the decline been more catastrophically pronounced since the introduction of salmon farming on the West Coast. The situation does not need another long awaited report by a team of fishery biologists to come up with an indefinite answer, meantime our salmon are being wiped out. An example on my doorstep is the beautiful little R Lael running into L Broom which now probably falls into the category of being destroyed by a salmon farm. That is another unique strain of salmon particular to this river lost, lost forever, having come through since the last ice age, now destroyed. I have caught most of the salmon I am going to catch, my fears are for the generations following me, will they have to visit an aquarium to see what a real salmon looks like because too many interested parties could not see the wood for the trees.24722016-01-18T17:30:55.68711035John BruceI witnessed the collapse of Loch Maree sea trout catch, 1200 to 12 in one year, due I believe to sea lice, certainly not due to me!24722016-01-18T19:35:31.95311036Katie JamesAs I understand it, sea lice affect humans as well as the fish. Animal and fish husbandry and welfare should always be very high on the government agenda.\r\n24722016-01-18T19:54:26.20311037STUART ROBERT LANGThe Scottish government should hang its head in shame at allowing this toxic industry kill our wild salmon.24722016-01-18T20:06:38.65711038Peter murrayGross environmental pollution on an industrial scale endorsed by the Scottish Goverment. A national embarrassment.24722016-01-18T20:10:46.01711039Kevin GilmourPetition signed.24722016-01-18T20:13:46.34311040Robert BrownSalmon farming has been causing major harm to wild fish foe many years it now needs to be moved away from sea and put onshore24722016-01-18T20:18:47.82711041Benjamin LeverThe use of West Coast sea lochs for salmon farms has had a hugely detrimental effect on wild salmon and sea trout stocks, whilst I appreciate that there are jobs involved, the positioning of these farms is a serious wildlife crime and would command far greater publicity if it were more widely known the benefit to wildlife ecosystems the presence of wild salmon and sea trout play in the rivers and burns the should inhabit. 24722016-01-18T20:24:1311042William Campbell We have to do all we can to protect our wild salmon..24722016-01-18T20:22:57.1111043george d slatertime to get this sorted24722016-01-18T20:45:36.79711045Barry GallagherIt's time to stop ignoring the evidence , and to start taking action before it's to late , life is hard enough for the Atlantic salmon right now !!24722016-01-18T20:42:01.31311046Martin RobsonSigned on 18th Jan 201624722016-01-18T20:49:44.15711047Stephen Brennan All anglers must unite to stop the blight of salmon farms in the sea and their negative impact on the environment, now is your chance 24722016-01-18T20:59:46.31311048Stuart BrabbsLand based aquaculture options should be explored before it's too late for wild salmon and sea trout on the west coast.24722016-01-18T21:15:05.56311049michael loyother countries are banning fish farms as they can see the affects it has on wild stocks24722016-01-18T21:35:27.12711050Kerry Hardy This industry needs to be heavily regulated by independent and unannounced inspections.\r\nThis self regulated industry is killing off wild salmon and seatrout for the past 30 years. This must stop24722016-01-18T21:37:58.15711051William rankin Help salmon before there is nothing left 24722016-01-18T21:43:37.59311052Pat Kennedy All salmon have to get back to their spawning grounds let them have a free run to their rivers. 24722016-01-18T21:53:37.92311053James SmillieI signed petition today\r\n24722016-01-18T22:02:36.0311054John DartThe legislation must be tightened up as it has been for creatures farmed on land. "Out of sight out of mind" must not be allowed to persist. We have to campaign for closed containment systems to replace the current methods.24722016-01-18T22:16:51.09311055Elizabeth-Ann BrennanHope the outcome is successful 24722016-01-18T22:14:30.54711056Kenny MacIverBetter late than never, assuming Scot Gov care about our seas and the valuable wild salmon and sea trout angling sector.24722016-01-18T22:23:27.07711057calum geddesFish farms are ruining wild fish stocks in turn costing jobs in rural communities 24722016-01-18T22:40:22.7511059David Ballingall Signed and shared for others to do the same. 24722016-01-18T22:51:12.4711060john mitchelllets hope the goverment act sooner than late24722016-01-18T22:52:56.42311061David AinsleyNo other industry would be allowed to pollute the sea with chemicals and sea lice. The technology to solve these issues and bring an end to the shooting of seals and disturbance of cetaceans by acoustic 'seal scarers" is already available. We must move the industry to closed containment.24722016-01-18T23:45:17.3911062janette galbraithOur wild salmon have survived for millions of years - do we want to be the generation that destroys them ? If not then support this petition !24722016-01-19T06:21:57.6411063Stuart McArthur These farms should be onshore regardless of the cost.24722016-01-19T08:07:18.98311064alan mooneyPersonally i have no faith with the scottish government on this issue as the chinese yen appears more important than this iconic species, salmon farming in its current form is not sustainable!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!24722016-01-19T08:47:29.76711065Kenneth Haughan FreshwaterSalmon farming has so many plusses that it is vital that is vital that it becomes truly sustainable and quickly. We need much tighter controls and severe sanctions as per Norwegian model but also huge incentives to become closed container. 24722016-01-19T08:52:53.92311066John RossAs previously mentioned it is Loch Maree that is the first place that comes to mind. It could be transformed back to its former glory. 24722016-01-19T09:55:29.2211067Brian WilliamsHigh time something was done to help protect the wild fish instead of pandering to big business.24722016-01-19T10:10:35.18711068Graham BarnesI have been following this topic for more than 30 years since I lived and worked in Uist. I'm now convinced from evidence from all across the Northern Hemisphere that fish farming of salmonids must be hermetically sealed from the environment which they currently share with wild salmonids. This complete separation can only be achieved by legislation. The time has come for the Scottish Government to bring in strong legislation to make that separation happen. The situation is urgent that Scottish Government does not have the luxury of waiting for other nations fall in line ... if necessary the Scottish Government must lead the way and do it NOW.24722016-01-19T10:16:38.1411069kenny murraySeriously needs addressing before wild salmon are a thing of the past in West coats Rivers.24722016-01-19T10:28:30.1411071Geoff franks.The evidence of harm by fish farmis to the salmon and sea trout is overwhelming. Stop them now!!!24722016-01-19T10:34:56.06311072John Wilson This issue needs to be resolved for the benefit of all interested parties.24722016-01-19T10:34:55.2211073Kenneth CarrPlease do something about the sea lice explosion that is harming our wild salmon stock - sign up guys24722016-01-19T10:45:47.95311074Richard SagarHaving fished the Border Esk and Annan for nearly 50 years we had very large amounts of sea lice returning on Sea Trout shortly before the major decline of sea trout numbers in the late 90's early 2000's.24722016-01-19T11:36:07.45311075Antony AthaIt is extremely important that this issue is tackled sensibly by all parties24722016-01-19T11:51:52.18711076Ian JonesThe weight of evidence cannot be ignored, salmon farming and the plague of sea lice that it produces devastates migrating salmon and seatrout smolts. 24722016-01-19T12:04:3911077David BrewRe locate them on land. 24722016-01-19T12:16:08.9711078Peter LyonsAbout time!! Just need to deal with the seals, mergies, goosanders and bumbling scientists and we might be getting somewhere at last.24722016-01-19T12:19:23.62711079Stuart GrahamSigned24722016-01-19T12:19:35.4711080John lynchInstead of the exec handing subsidies to the ff industry why not invest in land based farming. This type of farming is no different fron agricultural farming. If farmers pollute then the get fined or jailed. If they use illegal pesticides ditto. Just because ff is out of sight DOES NOT absolve there environmental and legal responsibilities. The industry needs to become a good neighbor and co habit with the angling industry which is in its self a cornerstone to local economies.24722016-01-19T12:28:25.54711081Christine Strain, ScotlandGreat idea.24722016-01-19T12:29:41.29711082John SmithHows about I stick 10 blood sucking leaches on you and see if you survive a year24722016-01-19T12:31:03.15711083Paul RouseThe scientific evidence over a considerable period demonstrates the farms have a huge detrimental impact on migratory fish and the ecosystem. It is critical that serious, meaningful measures are taken directly. Fish farms must not be allowed to continue in such an un regulated 'wild west' fashion.... killing off the wild Western Scottish salmon and sea trout populations.24722016-01-19T12:40:27.56311084Kenneth HanksWill anything ever be done that is not just for the benefit of the salmon farming industry24722016-01-19T13:25:30.8911085Paul JonesResponsible use of precious environmental resources must become a requirement of this \r\nindustry. It has shown it will not do that voluntarily and to make politicians act to compel action, when they have for so long ignored our lobbying, will be hard. But if not now, when? Good luck.24722016-01-19T13:36:02.57711086george renwickEveryone knows about the sealice problem affecting our wild salmon .\r\nBut the government try to keep it covered up !!!!!!!24722016-01-19T14:16:15.6111088Charles HarmanI have seen the decline of salmon and sea trout stocks in rivers I once fished on the West coast of Scotland, in Ireland and also in Norway. The common factor in every instance is the location of salmon farms close to the river mouths. In all these cases, the reduction or loss of the recreational fishery will inevitably have led to the loss of local jobs and income. And In spite of efforts by the salmon farming lobby to deny it, the overwhelming weight of scientific evidence points to a causal link between fish farms and the decline in wild fish numbers. I travel to Scotland at least twice a year, spending money not only on the fishing itself, but also on local accommodation, food and drink etc. At present I only fish rivers on the East coast of Scotland. I would love to return to the West coast, but it is very unlikely that I will do so while stocks of migratory fish are in their current state. It is long past time for salmon farms to be relocated away from the mouths of rivers that support runs of migratory fish - and preferably to an onshore, closed containment system.24722016-01-19T14:50:01.48311089alex richmondLet"s hope this gets some attention from SG when they finally admit catch and release is not the answer24722016-01-19T15:03:53.90711090William Logan Finally, S&TCS believes the evidence supports the need for a renewed focus on moving to full closed containment of farmed salmon production in Scotland, with complete 'biological separation' of wild and farmed fish. I totally agree but will Scottish government have the courage to make it happen? 24722016-01-19T15:13:44.42311091greg price Its an outrage this has gone on so long, someone is reaping rewards , sadly its not our natural river stock!\r\n24722016-01-19T15:23:40.48311092Ed DixonOnce the Kings and Queens of the River have been sacrificed in the name of commerce, they can never be replaced. 24722016-01-19T16:12:32.68711094Gary EcclesGood luck24722016-01-19T16:38:20.31311095Henry GilesFact: sea lice kill wild fish, especially clouds of lice that attach to young sea trout migrating in coastal waters, also smolts out to sea. Help to stop the rot.24722016-01-19T16:43:43.0311096Charles JeffreyIf there was such a thing as Health and Safety for salmon these fish farms would have been closed down ages ago. CLEAN UP YOUR ACT or CLOSE DOWN !!24722016-01-19T17:57:06.34311097MARK EYREWild fish have their place and so too do farmed, but not the same place.24722016-01-19T18:32:41.2811098Jamie HyslopSalmon farms should be land-based - no excuse for open cage farming - the technology exists24722016-01-19T18:52:26.56311099Barrie MattersonThis issue needs to be dealt with urgently to save wild species and protect the Scottish tourism industry.24722016-01-19T19:06:16.3611100Henry ThompsonPlease put an end to this environmentally damaging dirty business24722016-01-19T19:29:23.15711101Martin WebsterWhy is business allowed to make money by causing serious damage to one of Scotland's most precious natural assets? Move to 100% onshore closed containment within 5 years.24722016-01-19T19:30:22.57711102Alan McRobbTime this government woke up, smelt the coffee and admitted that they have turned a blind eye to the abuses of the aquaculture industry for too long.24722016-01-19T19:38:00.07711103Steven CooperStocks have been depleted by these farms with excessive lice and also escapees diluting the wild genes of the native salmon24722016-01-19T20:05:10.65711104James walshFish farms wiping out wild salmon stocks24722016-01-19T20:01:55.07711105Peter LyonsAbout time too. Now just the seals, mergies, goosanders and bumbling scientists to deal with similarly. Some hope.24722016-01-19T20:16:28.95311106Neil UptonThe sea lice problem of Salmon Farms is a blight on the character of all who refuse to believe it has had no effect on the wild stocks of salmon and Seatrout.its time to act and act decisively.24722016-01-19T20:43:12.95311109Graham StrachanWe have watched the desecration of our wild salmon stocks for long enough!24722016-01-19T21:11:08.20311111James WilcoxThe insanity of marine-based salmon feedlots must end24722016-01-19T21:10:32.26711112Rachel CarmichaelSomething needs done now to protect the future of wild salmon before its too late...something should have been done sadly long before now but pound signs are more important it seems.24722016-01-19T21:16:43.70311113Steve BrownIt's time the Scottish Government looked at the bigger picture and stopped focusing on short term financial gain, the west coast rivers in particular have been devastated by the effects of open cage salmon farming!24722016-01-19T21:14:46.62711114Russell BoydI fully support this petition and urge the Scottish Government to make changes to this industry which has decimated our wild Salmon and Sea Trout populations.24722016-01-19T21:35:25.48311115Gareth BourhillThis has went on too long and impact on wild migrating smolts has been known and ignored by governments because they wil not stop further farms and blame kin river explotation.just look at marine Scotland's proposed categories of salmon rivers and you have a simple answer all West Coast rivers are Cat 3 and this is where Al the farms are compared to Cat 1 rivers on the East coast where there are no farms24722016-01-19T21:39:21.82711116Mr Lawrence Crompton-Howe It is a international disgrace that Scotland promotes a national product that so dangerously harms its own natural resources.\r\nNow is the time to end the carnage that is caused by the Farmed Salmon industry and this must be done quickly to rebuild the integrity of Scotland and the Scottish Government.24722016-01-19T21:43:42.3611117Cameron ChapmanPrecedents are set in Canada where corrupt practice led to ecological disaster. \r\n\r\nThe Government in Canada was forced to admit that the scientists who expressed their concerns about Government practice, were correct. \r\n\r\nI hope the levels of subterfuge and corruption in Scotland will not prevent us from saving this Iconic World Treasure, the Atlantic Salmon. 24722016-01-19T21:46:58.8911118Paul McgeochThanks it done hopefully something will get done now24722016-01-19T21:52:23.32711119Paul McgeochThanks it done hopefully something will get done now24722016-01-19T22:01:37.01711120Matthew CashinOur legislators have a duty and responsibilty to protect our natural heritage for our children.24722016-01-19T22:27:54.26711121Ray o connorGovernments go on about how rod and line fishermen must put fish back and not harm fish stocks then sit back and watch big corporations go on a mass killing sprea in the name of profit 24722016-01-19T22:50:26.07711122Mark Colman Long overdue, and the denial of it has been criminal and hypocritical by this Government. 24722016-01-19T22:52:28.34311123Donald RiceWe laws to force the aquaculture industry to publish farm-specific lice data. Until then, we have no chance of improving the current disastrous situation.24722016-01-19T22:59:15.51711124Brian WrightPlease stop poisoning our marine environment and endangering our wild natural fish.24722016-01-19T23:16:00.54711125Mick BellI very much doubt whether Scottish politicians care at all.....24722016-01-19T23:31:28.2811126Simon FttonThe Scottish government should be ashamed by its lack of action to protect a vital natural resource that is probably worth more to its economy than Norwegian owned battery farms.24722016-01-20T08:43:12.7211128John bellWe should as much as we can to help one of the best fish in the world, every little bit helps 24722016-01-20T08:47:43.98311129John lawsonA national disgrace that we allow these Norwegian fish farms to pollute our oceans and kill our young wild salmon. Why are the people charged with protecting our seas and rivers not acting ..The science is already available showing these farms are killing our wild fish...24722016-01-20T08:53:22.59311130Ed MaudlingWould you allow a floating intensive pig farm in your sea lochs? Time to move to close containment on land 24722016-01-20T08:59:01.92311131John BinnsWhy won't you listen to the obvious. John Binns24722016-01-20T09:41:22.2811132Andrew William donaldTime to protect our wild stocks.24722016-01-20T10:30:32.42311133Allan W. Berry.My own Petition PE96 failed to lead to a credible scientific inquiry, highlighting the fact that political control of marine environmental science in Scotland ensures Scotlands largest marine polluter is under protection by government. 24722016-01-20T13:20:14.6111135ritchie campbellStop blaming anglers for the demise of salmon stocks24722016-01-20T13:34:35.51711136Brian LoveringIt is appalling that the damage resulting from uncontrolled sea lice populations in salmon farms has been allowed to continue. If this problem was occurring in respect of any land based agricultural activity there would be 'uproar'. Unfortunately, because the major consequences are arising at sea and are not immediately obvious, those in position to address the issue seem to have adopted an 'out of sight,out of mind' attitude'which is TOTALLY UNACCEPTABLE. In future years, the problems arising from improper controls on aquaculture (both the sea lice problem and other issues) will come to be seen in the same light as the problems that arose from the improper controls on the use of DDT and other pesticides in land based agriculture in the 60's and 70's! Please demonstrate some responsibility and act now.24722016-01-20T13:47:32.87711137Bob BurbidgeThe Scottish Government should show true leadership and pragmatism and force the filthy fish farming industry into closed containment farms and save our dying Scottish and Welsh salmon and sea trout from extinction in our lifetime. 24722016-01-20T13:52:36.7511138Kenneth ReidThere is a place for aquaculture but not at the expense of the wild environment and the impacts it delivers. get them onshore in closed containment and really create more jobs by revitalising the west coast of the country where stocks have collapsed over the last 20 years. revitalise communities and improve quality of aquaculture products.24722016-01-20T14:03:54.59311139Bill JonesAbout time something was done. I have seen natural salmon stocks decline over the last 3 decades, and I am convinced this is mainly due to sea lice infestation of smolts going to sea.24722016-01-20T14:03:49.93711140Peter WilloughbyAppalling that this is taking so long to resolve when the evidence is so clear24722016-01-20T14:13:17.84311141Barry JamesonIt should be absolutely clear to the Scottish parliament that much tighter regulatory measures are needed. That does not me that the Scottish fish farming industry would be put in danger. However with the general decline in runs of wild salmon and sea trout over many years this dangerous and unnecessary additional hazard , if allowed to continue , could create an effect that would be impossible to reverse. That would be tragic and is completely avoidable. Please act NOW.24722016-01-20T14:19:23.4711142David MahonyThe only answer to combating the SNP aversion to taking action to stop company practices that should not be permitted and would not be allowed in the foreign companies home waters is to do research proving that the revenue and employment generated by preserving wild fish coupled with a rearing industry using the highest standards would exceed the present revenues and jobs. Appeals to respect the environment and other non monetary aspects are likely to continue to be a waste of time-fund research as did the Tweed Commissioners ,Orkneys and no doubt others 24722016-01-20T14:23:27.34311143Robert BrewerTo allow the current situation to continue is criminal and is a massive shortfall of the powers that be.24722016-01-20T14:34:55.26711144Paul Haworth With out imeadiate action fish stocks will be near wiped out and take decades to regain numbers ! Take action now ! 24722016-01-20T14:51:24.12711146Carl Stones For it to survive it must be controlled 24722016-01-20T14:59:27.42311147Jim DayWhen is Dr Aileen Macleod Going to start been our environment Minister, and Look after our environment. 24722016-01-20T15:01:00.1111148Caspian FawcusThe wanton neglect and destruction of our wild salmonids is criminal, short sighted and nothing short of a disgrace. It is high time the future of all our wild fish was put before short term monetary gain. Aquaculture and wild fish can both be accommodated with a little foresight and governance, please act before it is too late.24722016-01-20T14:59:14.56311149Allan SeftonSea lice pollution means the west of Scotland marine environment is the most polluted in Western Europe. Publicity about this could greatly harm the tourist industry just as it has hugely impacted on recreational angling visitors.24722016-01-20T15:03:39.31311150Dr John SmithsonIt is essential that the Scottish Government deals with the issue of environmental destruction by salmon farms. Sea lice levels are out of control and statutory regulations are being ignored. The West Coast economy is already suffering grievously.24722016-01-20T15:07:58.48311151William HowellBeing a born and bred scot I am appalled the government can see no further than aquaculture and will not be satisfied until aquaculture wipes out the natural species of sea trout & salmon. Angling has and always would bring more jobs and money to Scotland than aquaculture ever will. Not surprised when we are governed by two near extinct species Salmon & Sturgeon. Time we had some real people who listen.24722016-01-20T15:10:06.01711152Pat Kennedy Salmon farm is a dirty industry and is no good for the wild salmon it has to stop 24722016-01-20T15:17:49.92311153ian ThorpeShould land based salmon farms be encouraged, maybe by the Scottish Government offering subsidies or other incentives to Companies moving the farms from sea lochs to the land?\r\nLand based salmon farms are more environmentally friendly as sea water pumped in can be cleansed of impurities including sea lice before it is returned to the sea.24722016-01-20T15:24:30.4711154John HamiltonClosed Containment would be the best answer, possibly converted redundant oil tankers?24722016-01-20T15:25:24.8611155John AC MartinOne just needs to look at the statistics on healthy salmon stocks. There is a strong correlation between rivers in the West of Scotland with decimated salmon stocks and the location of high density salmon farming. Repsect our marine environment for our children's sake and avoid a dead sea. 24722016-01-20T15:31:33.17311156Mike MilliganWe must take action now before it is too late24722016-01-20T15:29:26.511157Martin MolyneuxWe will not be coming up to Scotland spending our hard earned money again until something is done.24722016-01-20T15:37:12.87711158Jeremy G H MackrellI have stopped traveling to fish for salmon in the Scottish rivers due to the serious reduction in numbers of fish.24722016-01-20T15:35:54.01711159OLIVIER DEVICTORPlanet Earth is a combination of natural ecosystems and man continues to destroy them .\r\nIt is time that for the future of our children that we start to repair our wrongdoings. Salmon farming as it is practised today is very wrong.24722016-01-20T15:43:52.8611160Matthew CalvertThe SNP government seem to be in denial about the adverse consequences of fish farming due to lice. I hope the petition stimulates some useful action from them.24722016-01-20T15:45:23.57711161bob Heddleeven the sea trout in orkney are sometimes covered in lice,so presumably some die when young\r\nThe number of salmon farms and the associated disease and filth always seem to increase\r\nIm surprised that M&S Waitrose etc don't say something about this24722016-01-20T15:46:27.7511162Derrick CooperIf we don't do something who will, time to act befort it's too late.24722016-01-20T15:55:13.15711163Anthony SwannellI have been very disappointed with no fish over the last few years fishing on the South Esk. Presume this is due to the factors you mention and not my ineptitude.24722016-01-20T15:55:57.79711164jeremy hemmingI am amazed this action hasn't been pursued earlier24722016-01-20T16:03:51.84311165Mike DicksonIt is beyond belief that this state of affairs can be of any political advantage. This must be dealt with before we lose one of our most primeval species, along with countless others before. Man has a dreadful record of selfishness!24722016-01-20T16:04:32.90711166Allan CuthbertInland factory farming, as being used in Canada by native Canadians is less damaging to the environment and equally profitable. Farming in teh sea is now unnecessary and damaging to teh environment24722016-01-20T16:16:35.57711167Peter MorrisVital that action is taken now otherwise already low stocks will be wiped out with no return. Enforce the regulations. If not what is the point in having them!24722016-01-20T16:19:04.1111168Graham FeildenI will not fish in Scotland until there are proper controls on salmon farms24722016-01-20T16:20:46.3911169Thomas LowesAn eco system that took millennia to develop can be destroyed in only a few months, please support this petition.24722016-01-20T16:26:34.62711170Ian Winstone Long overdue.24722016-01-20T16:31:39.1411171Harold David HillTerrible infestations in Loch Torridon24722016-01-20T16:33:21.84311172Michael BlackWe must act before it is too late.24722016-01-20T16:33:47.29711173Roger BisbyI have seen the sea lice problem in Sutherland first hand. It really needs to be sorted.24722016-01-20T16:33:52.7211174Tony Ingle-FinchI recognise that the salmon farming industry as and must continue to be s vital part of the Highlaands & Islands economy. However, the industry must be sustainable and regulated accordingly.24722016-01-20T16:35:24.29711175John Stephen FaithPlease support this vital initiative for the preservation of the wild stock of Salmon, being such an important element of the Scottish highlands economy 24722016-01-20T16:42:02.511176Peter Lennie"the wildlife of to-day is not ours, we have it in trust for those who follow us " from King George VI24722016-01-20T16:38:17.48311177Gordon CoshAction is required urgently to conserve wild salmon stocks in Scottish waters.24722016-01-20T16:45:31.87711178Mike GraceLike Whisky, Wild Salmon and Trout are the very essence of Scotland - No Salmon, No Scotland!24722016-01-20T16:47:43.68711179Guy AdamsAs someone who spends a great deal of time (and money) travelling to Scotland to fish, and whose visits help keep Scottish people in jobs, I sincerely hope the Scottish Parliament acts before it's too late...24722016-01-20T17:00:26.1111180Patrick GibsonShow some courage by doing what you know is necessary to protect wild salmonids24722016-01-20T17:03:04.43711182Rob PitcherIt is vital that necessary controls are put in place to reverse the damage being caused by large scale salmon farming to our wild stocks.24722016-01-20T17:08:19.82711183Cai WilliamsThis is yet another example of Man's appalling selfishness.24722016-01-20T17:12:15.43711184John LynchOne of the most amazing spectacles us humans can observe is the migration of Sewin and Salmon,I feel so sorry for those that have not observed this miracle! Anything that endangers it even alters and disturbs those wonderful fish,has to be a crime against humanity if it denied our children from the pleasure of such an amazing event! 24722016-01-20T17:24:54.07711185Rodney TimsonSave our wild salmon before it's too late.24722016-01-20T17:31:00.7211186Peter KeyserAgree with Allan Cuthbert - the way to go must be land based fish farming. It is more expensive and needs a sponsor (the Government?) but what price the environment?24722016-01-20T17:31:17.87711187John Robinssea lice thriving around Fish Farms have decimated the wild salmon and sea trout stock of too many rivers. Please take action. 24722016-01-20T17:32:11.34311188Jeremy HendersonPlease listen to what we are collectively saying to save our wonderful salmon stocks that are now dangerously low. We need to understand that the dangers are largely man made and are widespread not just from fish farms.24722016-01-20T17:45:05.37711189Calum MacRaeI worked in the salmon farming industry for some years before leaving it because I was disgusted and horrified with the industrial use of pest control chemicals and the sea lice issue. That was over 35 years ago and nothing has changed. I have followed this issue since then and what has become clear is that money matters to politicians the environment does not.24722016-01-20T17:46:20.3611190Roger WilliamsI spend considerable money angling in Scotland. My Spring visits are over as from 2015 because of no salmon in the river. Autumn will follow if trends continue.24722016-01-20T17:51:20.82711191Mick newmanWe must protect of fish 24722016-01-20T18:03:37.0311192Elizabeth LeitchIt is vital that action be taken immediately otherwise all wild salmond will be wiped out. Enforce the Regulations.24722016-01-20T18:18:15.2811193David NattressI live to close to Milford Haven to remain complacent about what is happening in Scotland.\r\nGive the Welsh Government half a chance to give the go-ahead to a proposal for net farms in Welsh waters and they will take it.24722016-01-20T18:28:40.4711194Seamus CondinSame problems here in Ireland. 24722016-01-20T18:53:24.40711195Ivan HargreavesThe SNP seems to see no value whatsoever in Scotland's natural heritage. They seem happy to lose it if it means they can claim to be providing jobs in isolated places. There's a saying that you don't know what you've got 'til it's gone. Well, the wild Atlantic salmon, that most enigmatic of all wild creatures, has almost gone from the rivers of Scotland, and the SNP don't care about what they're about to lose.24722016-01-20T18:50:19.62711196Mike HarrisonIt's about time we sorted out the Scots with their abuse of the salmon and trout waters!24722016-01-20T19:05:23.01711198Bob CoxWhen dealing with DEFRA expects nothing unless it has apolitical advantage to their minister, fisheries management is not something that they understand! 24722016-01-20T19:24:11.5311199Roy PeakerIf the Scottish government's past record is anything to go by, they will not want to listen to bringing any legislation to bear upon their salmon farming industry.24722016-01-20T19:33:55.0311200eck sneddontime people in this country stopped turning a blind eye to this problem.too many do-gooders protecting seals and increasing fish farms poor anglers get the blame for taking one for the pot.24722016-01-20T19:37:38.98311201John CouttsThe aquaculture industry has effectively wiped out serious game angling from the west coast of Scotland and is in dire need of regulation of the kind which persists in Norway.24722016-01-20T19:40:46.18711202Bruce StenhouseWhat appalling neglect. Is it a case of "English Money Spoken Here"?24722016-01-20T19:43:24.17311203Nicholas JamesThere is massive potential in wild Scottish migratory fish. Any farming that damages this is shortsighted and short changing the Scots environment and by long term cultural and financial detriment.24722016-01-20T19:54:50.5311204mike ashwinGreat work and long overdue. NW fisheries know only too well the damage to migratory stocks negotiating these waters. Wild healthy river stocks is a prize worth fighting for. 24722016-01-20T19:59:26.2511205Pete lawsonAll salmon farms by Salmon containment on land \r\nAll wind farms off shore not on the hills 24722016-01-20T19:58:00.32711206Gareth Homfray-DaviesEnd the rhetoric. Time to act.24722016-01-20T19:58:27.18711207Geoff Hardy I cannot believe that we have reached a state of affairs where it is even necessary to resort to a petition in order to get something done.24722016-01-20T20:17:23.84311209alan roeThese Norwegian fish farms need reining in they are destroying native fish by virtue of the biopolution they create24722016-01-20T20:27:04.04711210MICHAEL PILGRIM TAAITTThe transfer of sea lice to wild Atlantic salmon from fish farms must be contained. Norway's preventative measures is a good lead to follow.24722016-01-20T21:05:44.511211Niall MorrisonLong overdue!\r\n24722016-01-20T21:16:35.40711212John GreenThe future for Sctland's wild salmon is in the hands of a government who regards farmed salmon as been more important than the wonderful heritage of natures majestic salmon 24722016-01-20T21:20:48.7811213William FindlayAll fish farming should be done in closed cages on land to fully protect the enviroment24722016-01-20T22:03:29.45311214Tam mcdonaldBan fish farming as they decimating wild salmon stocks for years 24722016-01-20T22:01:13.90711215Kenneth Barry MaylorFish farms off the west coast of Scotland have completely ruined the west coast rivers and lochs of their wild salmon and sea trout.\r\nThe amount of female sea lice present on farmed salmon is far in access of permitted levels and is a disgrace.\r\nThe farms also prohibit the safe passage of salmon smolts from Europe and the the UK and many fish do not even reach their feeding grounds due to the impact of sea lice. The Scottish government should be ashamed of allowing fish farms to continue to destroy habitats on the west coast which doesn't just affect migratory fish but complete ecosystems.24722016-01-20T22:03:48.59311216Anthony ReesI may not live in Scotland but the long term effects will be felt all around the UK for mans greed.24722016-01-20T22:08:27.57711217John RushThe damage done by fish farms is known to all but ignored by politicians. Please save our wild migratory fish. Bring back the anglers and jobs to Scotland. 24722016-01-20T22:13:22.84311218drummond shawplse control salmon farms 24722016-01-20T23:29:47.32711220Anthony RobertsThe warning signs in the form of the ever diminishing stocks of salmo salar are flashing ever brighter, and unless urgent action is taken NOW it will be too late.24722016-01-21T05:07:58.23311221Stevie MunnDon't lose our wild fish. Fish Farms should be on land not sea. Less damaging to the environment. 24722016-01-21T06:56:32.15711222Shona MuirTime to step up and save one of Scotland's most iconic species. 24722016-01-21T09:18:38.34311223Francis Sandison This is far more urgent than Wild Fisheries Reform or catch & release.24722016-01-21T09:20:54.4711224Stephen BarkerSalmon farming needs far more stringent regulations\r\nto protect the wild trout and salmon,we must act now before it is to late24722016-01-21T10:06:27.62711225Paul DavidsonThe infestation of juvenile salmon and sea trout must be controlled immediately, it has been ignored for far too long by the Scottish Government.24722016-01-21T10:20:18.56311226Angus SutherlandHow much longer must we wait before positive action is taken? Many rivers in the fish farming catchment have little time before their salmon and sea trout stocks become extinct24722016-01-21T10:21:23.31311227John D SmithSalmon can be farmed much more safely than the open cage system in use at present. The method currently used is devastating to wild salmon and it is morally wrong!24722016-01-21T10:23:07.9711228paul bristowWe all understand Scotland's desire to earn additional revenue from its great history and tradition of wild salmon fishing but offshore fish farming is killing the golden goose and bit by bit the public is waking up to the fact the salmon farm industry is causing huge environmental damage. This is a fact made far worse by the knowledge that on shore closed containment salmon farming would with a basic filtration system remove all the environmental problems and in doing so allow Scotland to position its product as a premium environmentally safe food source. So rather be dragged kicking and screaming by public pressure and EU rulings in to phasing out off shore salmon farming be proactive, be smart, get ahead and move now to onshore closed containment farming. 24722016-01-21T10:25:04.5311229Nick WinterThis problem has been known about for years. Effective action is long overdue to protect our wild fish.24722016-01-21T11:06:25.57711230Rob BakerScotland, get your act together before its to late !24722016-01-21T11:12:23.0311231Martyn RixThe damage caused by sea lice from salmon cages to wild sea trout and salmon has been know for many years, and it is a scandal that no action has been taken before. 24722016-01-21T11:26:01.42311232chris atkinsonI cannot imagine that a salmon farmed from the sea is worth anywhere near the same value as one caught in rod and line to the economy.\r\n\r\nSince the decline of Scottish salmon, I have taken to fishing Ireland, where on average I spend around £1500 a year directly into the Irish economy. I am sure Ireland, with bought out nets, will be happy to take up Scotland's slack. Lets hope they wake up before its too late for the Scottish pleasure fishing industry24722016-01-21T11:45:03.0311233MATTHEW CLIFFORD PATONTHINGS ARE TOUGH ENOUGH FOR WILD SALMON ,LETS NOT EXPOSE THE EVER DWINDLING WILD SALMON TOWARD THE HIGH CONSENTRATIONS OF SEA LICE CAUSED BY ANY FISH FARMS ANYWHERE.24722016-01-21T11:58:30.40711234David CarrickIt is time that government officials got their heads out of the sand and sort these problems out before the damage is irreparable.24722016-01-21T12:03:29.1111235George HolmesIt is very important that we do everything possible to protect the Atlantic Salmon\r\nand every efforts must be used to protect our salmon24722016-01-21T12:34:02.81311237John FordVery pleased and thankful for your initiative here in trying to protect our environment from rampant commercialism. Well done!24722016-01-21T12:48:49.79711238Graham Moffat They must take action now before it is to late 24722016-01-21T12:46:16.7211239Wendy HalliwellI am in support and very much hope that actions will be taken soon before all the stocks have disapeared and vanished forever24722016-01-21T12:50:40.67311240Chris HeapIsn't it time we had a body looking after fisheries interests which is detached from DEFRA. Such an organisation should be like the HSE and be able to deliver truthful outcomes rather than political clap trap!24722016-01-21T12:53:30.98311241Richard BanburyThe lack of action by the Scottish Parliament to protect these native species from this threat is a national disgrace. The technology exists to farm these fish in closed systems. These sea loch farms are also potential "reservoirs" for disease and escaped fish are genetically damaging if they interbreed with the native fish. The price of farmed salmon sold in supermarkets does not reflect the true cost when the environment is taken into account. It is not sustainable. Also damaging is the source of the fishmeal used to feed them. Wild Salmon convert more efficiently.24722016-01-21T14:13:25.01711242Lewis ShandWith the proposed catch and release situation about to be implemented in a major part of the Scottish landmass, it is critical that the approach to salmon conservation includes each and every party involved in the species demise. I have no doubts whatsoever that the salmon farming industry has had a major role in fish decline, and should be willing to comply with measures to reduce sea lice infestation on salmonoids at all stages of their life cycle. The fact that there are regulations and these are not being enforced is just not good enough. 24722016-01-21T14:41:47.70311244Richard EspAction should be taken now before all Salmon will be wiped out24722016-01-21T14:43:15.7211245Anson MacAuslanThere is plenty talk of the jobs that fish farming supports (and they are important) but no talk of all the jobs that have been lost because there are no wild salmon to catch in the rivers of the West Coast. We need to find a solution that suits both industries.24722016-01-21T14:48:56.1411246Calvert McKibbinThe Scottish Government is presiding over the destruction of much of the west coasts migratory salmonids through their neglect to allow excessive livestock of sea lice and hence equally destructive treatments to take place24722016-01-21T15:18:07.81311248Hans-Peter Ickemeyermove fishfarming out of the sea to in land facilities24722016-01-21T15:26:03.37711249Clive MitchelhillThis has gone on for too long now and it is about time something is done about it.24722016-01-21T15:41:5911250Ian S RankinPerhaps with an election looming anglers could use their vote to encourage action. Scientific studies and reviews appear to have made little impression on the decision makers. 24722016-01-21T15:44:31.87711251Diana Tym (nee Chapman)That this has happened during my lifetime makes me feel extremely sad. My grandchildren will have no reason to go to the beautiful wild places in pursuit of the noble salmon which I have had the pleasure of during my lifetime.24722016-01-21T16:05:36.95311252David BlackburnAS A REGULAR SALMON FISHERMAN IN THE NORTH OF SCOTLAND AND AWARE OF HOW MUCH BUSINESS IS GENERATED FOR THE LOCAL ECONOMY AS WELL. 24722016-01-21T16:09:49.59311253Paul NeedhamSea lice are causing a real problem to the wild salmon stock, it's time to take action before its to late! 24722016-01-21T16:42:25.43711255john osbaldestonSome people won't be happy 'till we've wasted the World !!24722016-01-21T17:01:43.7511256Lord CrickhowellFormer Chairman of National Rivers Authority. Strongly support24722016-01-21T17:04:01.43711257David PatersonThe present Scottish Government have been paid plenty from salmon farms to lobby on their behalf.\r\nIts time they made amends and started to police the salmon farmers and not the anglers.\r\nThe government must act now and force the salmon farming industry to use enclosed tanks, the cost to be met solely by the salmon farming industry, or the fish farms forceably closed down on conservation grounds\r\nBut the present scottish government dont have the courage.24722016-01-21T17:11:39.29711258David SherriffsThis problem has gone on for far to long, we all know what sealice have done to salmon & seatrout stocks I hope this petition will confront the SNP with how fish farms are being managed24722016-01-21T17:12:23.70311259Donald AllanLong over due that the Scottish government stops putting profit and trade alliances before our natural resources. Very similar blinkered approach as the government of British Colombia, Canada. Denial of the scientific facts that fish farming is seriously damaging juvenile smolt runs.24722016-01-21T17:45:08.32711260Edward Steele-WilsonAll sea, loch and estuary based fish farms that have caused the sea lice infestation and contamination to salmonid species should be closed immediately. Only those that will practice closed containment land based fish farms should be licenced to operate.24722016-01-21T17:46:11.8611261Malcolm ThorneThe Scottish politicians are the only ones to blame. They have no concern as they will still have their fat pensions even if wild Salmon disappear from Scottish rivers. The politicians will lose Scotland's Salmon fishing which is a huge part of its tourist industry. So enforce regulations.24722016-01-21T17:54:40.82711262Bryan HerbertIf we walked down the street with a dog with ticks nowhere near the level that are on wild fish around those salmon farm's we would pe prosecuted and banned from owning animals. But because no one in the public sees the extent of the problem no one in power takes any notice24722016-01-21T18:10:17.82711264Keith FishwickDo not go on holiday to Scotland,they where also netting salmon in the north Atlantic last spring,what a disgrace.Bow your heads in shame.24722016-01-21T18:14:01.7511265Brian Wilson If this was the cause of swine flu,bird flu or foot and mouth disease it would be quarantined by the government's vets but nothing ever happens to these farms they harm all the sealife for miles around them 24722016-01-21T18:15:14.65711266Simon P. HicksThis issue has been kicked into the long grass for too long & we need to wake up to the consequences of not addressing the issue before it's too late.24722016-01-21T18:29:41.79711267Sarah DolmanPlease consider other vulnerable marine species too, including marine mammals, in strengthened legislation and controls, such as monitored use of strengthened nets and eliminate use of shooting seals and acoustic deterrent devices that exclude porpoises from important coastal habitats. 24722016-01-21T18:34:2111268ANTHONY MARTINI am pleased to see that the Scottish Government is taking steps to restrict netting along the East Coast estuaries24722016-01-21T18:56:50.04711269Robert Whinray GarnettIt is essential that salmon farming deploys onshore contained tanks as soon as possible to limit the increasing numbers of sealice and the increased use of chemical pesticides to control them.24722016-01-21T19:25:11.06311273Richard StronachI am a strong believer that there is no scientific support for the salmon farms and that the only reason that they continue is because they make so much money for the government and the few individuals who own them. they are raping our land and seascape lets let common sense prevail for once and stop salmon farming.24722016-01-21T20:05:29.73311274Robert MacDougall-DavisProper regulatory controls need to be in place and the government agency responsible for the inspection and enforcement of the required regulations must be properly resourced to carry objectively and independently regulate all salmon farms in Scotland effectively. It is very short sited not to give wild salmon and sea trout the protection they so badly need.24722016-01-21T20:10:39.6411275ANDREW ROSKELLSalmon farming is out of control, drastic measures need to be taken to protect wild stocks of salmon, and Seatrout.24722016-01-21T20:13:54.9711276David Hewetson-BrownHaving been salmon fishing for 40 years we have seen the dire effect of salmon cages in estuaries.24722016-01-21T20:16:35.62711277jock woodyou must act now to save whatever fish we have left soon our Ayrshire rivers will be devastated. 24722016-01-21T20:24:50.93711278John ClarkMeaningful effective action on sea lice and use of toxic chemicals is long overdue. The industry continually flouts the European Rules relating to environment. More jobs could be created if wild salmon were allowed to flourish. 24722016-01-21T20:41:08.2211279Mike ChristieWe have to preserve them for our children and grandchildren.24722016-01-21T21:00:26.56311280Philip LewisThis problem has existed now for years with successive governments simply parroting the fish farming brotherhood with the mealy mouthedsidestep of "no conclusive scientific proof". Please explain the absence of almost all sea trout and pretty few salmon on any of the west coast rivers.24722016-01-21T21:07:00.6111281David D JonesPlease wake up that land of sturgeon and salmon!24722016-01-21T21:11:58.29711282david groveif a salmon had black and white stripes on its head it would get all the protection required, but it hasn't, its only a fish and the majority of our population care about it even though its worth millions to the economy as a sport fish.24722016-01-21T21:15:48.3911283Paul CrossI live in north wales and travel to Scotland to fish for Salmon a couple of times each year, but in the last 10 years the numbers have fallen, and the decline in the last 3years has accelerated. The Scottish Government has done little or nothing to help the leisure industry but has always supported the Fish Farm managements, even though their profits all go abroad.24722016-01-21T21:19:02.511284Ian DyerAs is often the case, the calculable cost to the environment is not considered against the short term economic benefit to man. The Norweigans are developing on-shore fish farming, where environmental impacts are significantly reduced. Controls on sea-lice should be suitably controlled in order to protect delecate wild fish stocks.24722016-01-21T22:12:44.12711286Tony MairWhat is the role of lice in the food chain?\r\nI have no problem with farming any species so long as healthy sustainability is guaranteed. By the way, farmed salmon do not taste so good.24722016-01-21T22:13:08.2511287Mark McCloyForeign countries are profiting from bad farming practices whilst are wild stocks decline !\r\nClosed containment must become the only acceptable practice.24722016-01-21T23:47:36.87711288Richard WaltonThe only real answer is to move to the close containment system on all salmon farms in the UK. Yes the industry will resist and yes farmed salmon will become more expensive, but it should be no part of our role in these islands to provide cheap protein to China. 24722016-01-22T07:21:57.01711289Hans van Manen Inform the Scottish government this action is not only about Scotland but for Europe. We in the Netherlands travel to Scotland to enjoy the countryside and nature. Salmon is an essential part of that. Please make wild Salmon existence possible for the future and their generations!!! 24722016-01-22T08:58:47.43711290ian batesthe fish farming around the canary island has all but gone broke ,now all we have is rotting fish farm pens ,the farmers should have to place large bonds to cover clean up and disease as the sea belongs to us all???24722016-01-22T08:55:22.51711291Edward de Vere HuntThe desperate decline in salmon and sea trout is obvious to see for someone who takes interest in the welfare of rivers. Unless an all out effort is made to protect these ancient fish,regardless of who need to change their practices. \r\nHumans have become the cancer of the earth,intent on destroying its host for a quick profit,regardless of the future long term costs. 24722016-01-22T09:27:05.68711292Gary DaviesAct now before its to late.Like always the UK is always years behind the rest.24722016-01-22T09:27:55.48311293Andrew SayerLand-based farms are not allowed to discharge dangerous waste into the sea - so why should fish farms be able to? Fish farms should be land based, in contained units.24722016-01-22T09:37:22.59311294john ellis danielit is time the effects of over intensive farming methods, both on land and in the sea, should be identified. protocols and procedures to identify and implement corrective mitigation activities should be established. 24722016-01-22T11:01:43.20311296Robert barberit needs sorted quickly24722016-01-22T11:17:50.62711297Chris HorsmanSurely this is industrial pollution, it must be dealt with.24722016-01-22T11:32:52.06311298Paul WhiteWild salmon are underwater unlike seals, badgers and foxes, so their plight is unseen by the general population. As long as there is farmed salmon on the slab in Tesco etc the majority of people can't see a problem. Action is needed!!!24722016-01-22T12:58:21.67311299john weirThe west coast of scotlands salmon and sea trout stocks have dropped by nearly 80% in the last 25yrs since the introduction of open cage fish farms, fresh fish caught in ayrshire rivers have been shown to have seriously high levels of sea lice attached which river trust scientists have claimed would have killed the fish in a number of weeks had they not moved into fresh water so if this is the case with adult salmon what chance does a smolt have, something has to be done now!24722016-01-22T13:04:22.1411300Peter John BoultinUntil such time as the "marine" problems are identified and addressed i believe that proven actions to preserve fish stocks should be implemented ie Hatch and release rather than catch and release.\r\nFact. Rivers such as the Clyde, Tyne, even the Thames were sucessfully rejuvinated.\r\nBioligists keep preaching catch and release will provide sustainable stocks yet the Scottish Dee over 20 years has seen no evidence to show these methods will sustance a species under increasing pressures for a multitude of reasons, marine, seals, fishfarms etc. In contrast the river Carron maintains a good run of migratory fish with the use of its hatchery.\r\nSurely this proves that employed even as a realatively short term compromise hatcheries have a useful place in protecting these iconic creatures.24722016-01-22T13:20:56.3911301Ian Gray Something needs to be done to help with the wild salmon population. 24722016-01-22T13:55:41.73311302Richard IngsThe Scottish economy is the loser. I go abroad for my annual fishing trip now as I do like to actually catch fish!24722016-01-22T16:44:04.9711304Iain BlackWe must try and stop trawler fishing for Salmon inour inshore waters and reduce the population of saels24722016-01-22T17:00:59.23311305John WalkerI refuse to eat farmed salmon and I urge all others to do likewise. Farmed salmon is not a sustainable food source and productivity should be dramatically reduced. You should not be able to buy a whole salmon for a few pounds in a supermarket.24722016-01-22T17:56:39.98311306Keith WilliamsThe culture of denial in the aquaculture industry and Scottish Government needs to stop. The scientific evidence demonstrating the primary cause of salmon and sea trout declines in the west is overwhelming and action is required now.24722016-01-22T18:03:24.31311307Robert SherriffI can be in Alaska quicker than driving to Inverness per Salmon caught it is so reasonably priced I will still go to Scotland but not as often although if there were a few more Salmon I would not need a passport wake up Scotland you are losing a fortune!24722016-01-22T18:05:20.4711308Andy WrateTime for democracy to rear up and bite those farms who, if land based would be subject to far more stringent regulations, and the politicians who are supposed to foster best practice.24722016-01-22T18:23:46.48311309Tony EspleyEconomically and environmentaly this makes sense.24722016-01-22T21:33:43.29711311Tam Andrew Time to act24722016-01-22T23:05:45.34311312Terry CousinFor many years a couple of friends and I fished in the northwest of Scotland, where there used to be excellent spate fishing fir migrasstory fish. not any more: and it was smolt rearing in the Storr Loch, Leathan , that ruined its excellent reputation for producing wild trout of a high average weight. In my opinion, permission to rear salmon in sea lochs was like issuing a licence to kill wild fish.\r\nTerry Cousin24722016-01-22T23:04:45.5311313Tim HicksThe Scots parliament cannot claim any loyalty to Scotland whilst they encourage the decimation of Scotland's ecology. For Scotland's sake wake up and have some responsibility.24722016-01-22T23:39:37.73311314David ShawLoch Maree,Loch Shiel,RiverEwe,RiverAilort,River Sheil just a short list of once fantastic sea trout fisheries. Loch Maree perhaps the best sea trout fishery that existed in Europe that was an anglers Nirvana and one time employed the services of twelve boatmen.Today you will never see a boat out fishing for sea trout because they are not there. Sea lice levels from salmon farms in Loch Ewe have all but destroyed the runs of sea trout in this most special environment. I haven't even mentioned the iconic Atlantic salmon a wildlife species that is as much a part of the Scottish landscape as any other iconic species. We must protect these special and economically important fish as well as our marine environment for future generations. 24722016-01-22T23:49:05.15711315Richard AllenI have seen the sea trout fishing on Loch Eilt destroyed by sea lice resulting from fish farming cages located in the sea off the river Ailort.24722016-01-23T03:03:07.93711316John RichardsonI lived in Scotland for over forty years and during that time fished extensively for salmon and sea trout. If I were still resident there I would be deeply ashamed of the lack of environmental concern and action shown by my Government.\r\n\r\nThe time for discussion and debate is long past. Action, not empty words, is now required of Scottish Ministers.\r\n\r\nPoliticians and farmers (even marine based ones) are nefariously short sighted and oft-concerned with short-term gain. Were I and my grand-children still based in Scotland I would be fearful for their environmental birthright. It is unthinkable that they would be unable to enjoy game-fishing as I had done over forty-odd years. 24722016-01-23T07:54:44.2811317Mark fortuneMountains of evidence of the damage being caused by sea pen aquaculture. You must act24722016-01-23T11:47:57.3611318Brian SawyerLong overdue, salmon fishing in Scotland has been ruined24722016-01-23T14:56:02.29711319Iain MacdonaldI now spend my money abroad as my home water on west coast Scotland is destroyed by pollution from the fish farms. Total government turning a blind eye, and now no wild fish. I want to spend my money in Scotland, I love to fish in Scotland, but our Government allowing an industry to continually kill off all our wild fish makes it impossible for me to holiday and spend my money there. This is so sad as the west coast of Scotland is the most stunning part of North Europe, but the moment you peel back the outer layer we find an ocean full of pollutants, no wild fish and millions of sea lice parasite heaven. And the sad sad fact that everyone knows this problem and no one does anything other than cover it up. I love my country, and the nature is one reason I love it. How can any minister who represents the people can allow this to happen. Is it £ £ £24722016-01-23T15:00:53.07711320Euan McgrandleGreat to see the most destructive influence on marine conservation finally getting a petition to control the damage it causes.24722016-01-23T17:50:11.9711321Andrew MaryniakWe all need to take action NOW to save this extraordinary species!24722016-01-23T20:51:14.51711322Craig WilliamsonMore needs to be done to protect our migratory fish at sea!24722016-01-23T21:31:03.95311323Walter gilchristtime Time to control sea lice on fish farms and to cull seals a cormorants or soon we and generations to come will not see salmon24722016-01-24T09:11:50.1111324Alasdair Iain SmithSince the introduction of salmon fish farms on the Wesr coast the sea trout and salmon numbers have been drastically reduced due to massively increased numbers of sea lice brought about by mismanagement at the fish farms. 24722016-01-24T11:51:52.34311327Paul RobinsonGood science from Norway, Canada and other countries, as well as the UK, has proved beyond reasonable doubt the dangers and impact of salmon farming to wild salmon and seat trout. There are remedies available that would safeguard wild fish stocks without jeopardizing the salmon farming industry. Please take effective action ASAP.24722016-01-24T12:43:59.3911328Robert CooksonV Good Idea, lets hope the Scotish Government does something. The salmon is in great danger in the medium term which would be disastrous.\r\n\r\n24722016-01-24T13:25:10.8911329Kenny Jonesi am 21 years of age, and recently been introduced to Salmon fishing by my father, we go every year to Fish, but each year less and less salmon are being caught. The wild salmon population is decreasing, and needs saving. 24722016-01-24T16:01:3511330Keith DunbarThe Closed Containment technology exists now so there is no excuse for open net marine cages. The indudustry is in a mess and needs to egt up to date.24722016-01-24T18:12:21.40711332Hugh ReevesI used to go to Scotland to fish but I now go to Norway so I can actually catch something.It would be great to return to Scotland even with the midges!24722016-01-24T19:52:54.20311333Malcolm BondThe Scottish government's biased attitude towards the salmon-farming environmental vandals, and against the proper protection of wild salmon and sea trout stocks, is an absolute disgrace.Anyone with an ounce of commonsense will know the predominant reason why the wild populations on the west coast have plummeted in the past 15 or 20 years is the infestation of sea lice fro farmed fish. Open-cage farming needs to stop, NOW.24722016-01-24T21:25:28.1111335john leckieThe government should be ashamed for the blatant denial of this problem24722016-01-24T21:58:19.17311337David Caddiswho says the salmon stocks are in danger from rod and line anglers the point is they have decided this without a proper river survey and while we in some parts of Ayrshire have been told to have this forced on us rivers like the Doon and the Girvin have not also very few of the east coast rivers have also not been told to have it so is it one law for one and not for others that's what we are talking about not just the catch and release its unfair, laws are meant to cover everyone not just some also the rod and line angler does not do anywhere near the damage getting made out like netting or fish farm menace funny how the west coast has most or if not all fish farms and that's the place that they say has a shortage of sustainable salmon it's all nonsense24722016-01-24T22:45:40.42311338Victor Maurice PayneI agree with Mr Boultin-- we must try to rejuvenate river stocks. It worked on the Tyne and in Ireland and we must give it a chance on all depleted rivers.24722016-01-25T00:00:13.23311339Danny Jonesbeing the future of salmon fishing, being only 21 years old, and have been fishing for the last three years in Scotland Iceland and Norway. However the fishing in scotland has deteriorated each year and this is because of the salmon farms. Its really sad as scotland is such a beautiful place, but as a fisherman i want to catch salmon and feel i need to start going else where. These salmon farms need to stop.24722016-01-25T09:58:38.70311340Derek CoullA worthy cause, but why not kill two birds with one stone here, and go further to Include the legal catching of the North American Cray Fish, before Scotland suffers the same problem being experienced in the rivers south of the Border. Or does that have to go to a petition too. 24722016-01-25T11:54:49.87711341Ryan JonesAs a young fisherman at 23, growing up and learning to fish in Scotland gave me some amazing memories, it's such a shame if this carries on I won't be able to take my children in the future to Scotland and teach them to fish in the same spot my father taught me.24722016-01-25T13:06:46.48311342Fiona BerrymanThere is a place for wild and farmed salmon, but wild is best.24722016-01-25T13:30:42.7211343James McGrandleIt's apparent that this SNP government only pays lip service to saving the Iconic salmon. From the outcomes of the WFR it is apparent that the only area of wild salmon predation which is even being reviewed is that carried out legally by humans. For those who enjoy eating salmon the only means open now is to buy farmed salmon which not only increases the profit these companies make, the SNP government also takes their cut. 24722016-01-25T14:29:54.12711344David campbellgoing to southern ireland for most of my salmon fishing now24722016-01-25T15:49:28.1111345Kevin CorderyActin is needed NOW or it will be to late!!!24722016-01-25T16:00:01.9711346Derek HarwoodI and most of my fishing friends no longer visit Scotland for salmon fishing, and will continue going elsewhere to Ireland where fishing tourists are treated with respect and a valuable asset to the economy. The Scottish government treats fishing tourism with contempt in turning a blind eye to all of the problems caused by salmon farming.24722016-01-25T19:04:44.79711347george slaterlets get this going24722016-01-26T00:29:35.12711348Steven Blackley Shocking it's been left to get this bad the number of salmon in the river nith are pathetic now it's serious 24722016-01-26T10:05:49.2811349Raymond KnightThe west coast rivers have already lost most of their salmon and us tourists will not go there.24722016-01-26T12:57:24.2211350Charles Rangeley-WilsonWild salmon and sea trout are a vital part of Scotland's heritage on which thousands of Scottish jobs depend. It's high time the Scottish Government acted to protect them.24722016-01-26T13:21:21.3611351Chris PearsonSalmon stocks must be protected before wild stock numbers suffer catastrophic failure24722016-01-26T13:50:07.59311352Malcolm BrownNegotiate a close down of one of these open mesh salmon farms for a given period of time then monitor the enviroment for improvement, or move them to a land locked site 24722016-01-26T14:24:12.59311354Garry evansNo more scotish holidays, if cuddly mammal were involved action would be taken24722016-01-26T14:47:22.95311355Simeon DisleyIt would be in the best interests of all of Scotland, not just fishing people, if this issue was sorted out.24722016-01-26T15:03:34.1411356Tom DuttonSalmon farming is hugely damaging to the migratory fish which are one of Scotland's most valuable resources. When I lived in Edinburgh I regularly petitioned my local MP on the subject who showed little interest. Scandinavian countries have far more restrictions on salmon farming yet we let Scandinavian companies farm salmon on the Scottish cost with insufficient regulation where they damage Scottish native fish.24722016-01-26T17:50:13.1111357Dr Hamish Willsoun AitkenI own a cottage in Wester Ross on the shores of Loch Duich and have personal experience of the harm that the salmon farm on the loch is causing.24722016-01-26T18:39:11.6411358Moira CampbellThis petition has to be taken seriously to protect wild salmon! 24722016-01-27T08:20:4811359Dick FrancisWhen will the Scottish Government wake up and do something positive and fast to hopefully save the wild salmon runs into Scottish rivers? A first step and a positive one would be to ensure that the salmon farms have a very strict and tightly monitored control of sea lice numbers around the farms. 24722016-01-27T10:45:03.7811360Godfrey HoldenThe value of Wild Salmon and Sea Trout to the Scottish economy in terms of income and jobs far, far outweighs that of the fish farming industry. Wise up politicians please!24722016-01-27T11:31:54.93711361Graham HartIt's all politics and nothing to do with the environment. These people are not interested in the environment only business. Things will only change when it's too late. That's when there are no salmon in the rivers and thousands out of work in rural areas. Maybe in years to come there might be a stocking policy in place. I'm not holding my breath.24722016-01-27T17:47:39.42311362Richard John de VilleAction is essential to ensure the future of wild Salmonids.24722016-01-27T18:08:29.12711363Hazel Hoggan Salmon need to be free from beasties. Scotland need beastie free fish. So do I24722016-01-27T19:36:57.29711364Simon CollierGiving the difficulty that wild salmon are facing from fish eating birds in the rivers, polution and overfishing via drift netting and other intensive fishing practices then additional stress on the population from lice by badly managed fish farms and poor legislation is disappointing and should be addressed!24722016-01-28T07:46:08.6111365Andrew John SinclairWe must preserve the good things that Scotland has to offer and not pollute it's Lochs with chemicals.24722016-01-28T10:21:48.54711366Shane MaloneyYour fight is our fight.....everyone needs to shout in support of our ancient pescapalian buddies against the invading Scandic Frankenfish !\r\n24722016-01-28T10:49:05.09311367Richard SheltonSea lice from the intensive cage culture of salmon have crippled the wild sea trout and salmon populations of West Highland Scotland. Furthermore, the use of dangerous chemicals in the bath treatment of lice on the farmed fish seriously threaten the larval and even adult survival of lobsters, prawns and crabs. Firm remedial action is long overdue.24722016-01-28T12:49:05.34311368abigail s mainlandNorwegian fish farmed salmon is sold as "wild Scottish" fish. Given the level of disease, anti-biotics to counteract this, and general pollution in the sea loch farms, I personally avoid eating this at all costs. The whole industry needs to be cleaned up and stronger legislation introduced to protect our food chain and truly wild fish ..24722016-01-28T13:42:40.1411369John wallaceMigrating salmon from irish rivers use the same water channels and so the problem is not just confined to the Scottish salmon. It's time for the governments to think further than the ' fast buck'.!!24722016-01-28T17:46:51.511370Johanna MackenzieWill the common man I ever taste wild salmon again? Salmon farming methods polute our waters and produce toxic fish.24722016-01-28T17:58:12.67311371Julian CharringtonThere is a parallel with anti-biotic and chemical "over use" on salmon and on us humans. The fish managers and our doctors have got to reign back or together we are doomed.24722016-01-28T21:56:40.0311372J.P. FoleyI fully support ALL Efforts to Save and Stabilise ALL Wild Salmon Stocks in British & Irish Waters.24722016-01-28T22:29:38.87711373Emma McDowallThere are less and less salmon and sea trout running up river each year and I feel that the lice in the open sea cages has a lot to do with the falling numbers .24722016-01-28T22:43:12.511374Alexander MaloneSalmon deserve our help. The angler on the river gets persecuted, yet the problem lies elsewhere. More needs to be done to protect the future of that amazing fish.24722016-01-29T06:19:37.98311375John F. RobinsSuccessive Scottish Governments have acted as international fishmongers flogging factory farmed salmon on behalf of the mainly Norwegian farm owners. They have refused to control the filthy plague of pollution and parasites these farms create and they have sold our natural heritage, including much of our marine environment and the creatures which inhabit that environment, for a few rural jobs which will soon disappear as overproduction of factory salmon (fed on scarce wild fish stocks) has caused the price to collapse. If only politicians could see further than the next election.24722016-01-29T12:02:02.92311376Marlyn HalesI know there are very few wild salmon in Scotland from personal experience and fully back this petition as I believe the premise to be well founded. As an addendum, I believe the reason Norway didn't join the EEC, was to protect its fisheries.........24722016-01-30T15:51:57.92311377Alastair Hume MBEWe must do all we can to protect our wild salmon stocks.24722016-01-30T17:45:28.54711378Ian HayIt is essential that wild salmon stocks are protected, to ensure that this species does not become extinct.24722016-01-30T18:35:42.7811379Edward Catton-OrrCopied from a fellow protester these words sum up my feelings exactly! Successive Scottish Governments have acted as international fishmongers flogging factory farmed salmon on behalf of the mainly Norwegian farm owners. They have refused to control the filthy plague of pollution and parasites these farms create and they have sold our natural heritage, including much of our marine environment and the creatures which inhabit that environment, for a few rural jobs which will soon disappear as overproduction of factory salmon (fed on scarce wild fish stocks) has caused the price to collapse. If only politicians could see further than the next election.24722016-01-30T20:30:11.6411381alan mooneyI would echo mr roberts comments! 24722016-01-31T10:09:28.95311382arto meririnne There is few left,should we try harder to save them 24722016-01-31T16:07:45.81311384Andrew Croft People need to be made aware of the damage that salmon farming causes to wild salmon populations. Not only from sea lice infestations but also escapee farmed salmon breeding with wild salmon. Which is diluting the genetic integrity of wild salmon. A farmed salmon is nothing more than a mutant.24722016-01-31T20:03:31.12711385Andrew L GilchristWhat reason do fish farms give against closed confinement? There is good evidence it works in Canada successfully.24722016-01-31T20:57:10.93711386Matthew birdAgain due to mans greed to profit from playing god with the life of salmon we have now created a bigger problem which is threatening the wild fish stocks with unacceptable levels of parasites which great our wild fish upon their return into the estuaries they were spawned in \r\nDo we really need to support supermarket salmon which is full of fat and damages our wild stocks from which carries a greater financial loss to the local economy than salmon farmers understand ......24722016-01-31T21:38:23.82711387Prof Andrew ShorthouseThe Scottish Government seems indifferent to a declining wild salmon stock, and the deleterious effect on recreational fly fishing and the local employment (ghillies, shops, hotels, B&Bs, self catering etc which it supports. Much of this is in more remote areas desperately in need of income. Fishing in Scotland is deteriorating to such an extent that fishermen are voting with their feet and getting a better deal abroad24722016-02-01T01:23:42.45311388James LeachHaving seen the damage done to Pacific salmon due to intensive Atlantic salmon farming on Vancouver Island, I strongly support restrictive measures on this industry.24722016-02-01T09:02:42.84311389Glyn WilliamsPlease do not allow Salmon fishing to disappear before our very eyes. Scotland and Salmon fishing go together for at least they did. Think of all the businesses that depend on it. It beggars belief that the Scottish government might just allow this to slip away.24722016-02-01T10:25:35.37711391jonny ShawOn "my" river government have to re-visit 1950s water abstraction plant & see how it could be re-worked to allow early run fish to re-use the redds then completely cut-off24722016-02-01T13:11:29.04711393Eddie welshSomething needs to done now before its to late24722016-02-01T13:34:28.54711394Darryl campbell This industry needs to take resposibilty for its actions and be hels accountable they cant keep turning a blind eye and damage the wild stocks over revenue similar things happen with our rivers all to often polluters get a slap on the wrist after causing millions of pounds worth of damage something needs done or there wont be any wild salmon left 24722016-02-01T13:31:42.67311395Tom MilneI only hope our elected politicians take note of this serious subject and if they don't do nothing thats with their respective powers then they let themselves and our country down.24722016-02-01T14:52:14.62711398gereint mortimerThis needs to be addressed before its too late24722016-02-01T16:36:19.87711399Nick HartWhy are our fisheries so poorly protected? It is about time governments across Europe, especially those so close to home, placed common sense before greed. When it comes to wild Salmon & Sea Trout stocks I am afraid there is no buy now pay later!24722016-02-01T18:54:17.65711400Alasdair SmithIt's been shown in loch Roag that after it had an organised sea-lice control in place that sea trout numbers increased considerably. 24722016-02-01T19:07:09.8611401James MairTime this issue was addressed in a serious manner, you only need to look at Norway and Canada to see the serrious implications of doing nothing24722016-02-01T21:56:18.40711402Jeff Mckeenif only MSPs of the Scottish Parliament could for once realise how much damage has been done to west coast salmon and sea trout stocks by Norwegian owned fish farms.24722016-02-02T07:16:40.20311403Connie RobertsonScotland should be protecting this very special visiting resource. To allow easy pickings for large commercial companies to net salmon at mouths of rivers and stop single fishermen fishing is a bit of a nonsense. 24722016-02-02T17:42:59.3611404Lawson DeveryA Wild Fishery Review with salmon farming deliberately omitted from the agenda clearly showed the Scottish Governments position. Please, please, please stop buying farmed salmon in support of this excellent petition.24722016-02-03T10:53:49.48311406Alexander Reidwiith the presence of sea lice and all those seals at Newburgh estuary we'll have no wild salmon left.24722016-02-03T19:12:07.84311407Martin TolhurstFish farming is not going to go away so it makes sense for the industry and conservationists to seek ways to work together. The measures being sought under this petition are in the spirit of cooperation and the fish farming interests are best served by mindfulness towards the wild fishery interests and not just to commercial imperatives.24722016-02-05T13:22:05.5311408James percyWell done for this petition 24722016-02-05T19:19:57.7811409Martin JohnsonIt's high time 'best practice' salmon farming methods were used, i.e. totally enclosed cage systems, enclosed lagoon or lakes (e.g.as in Canada) or further offshore for dilution of impact.24722016-02-05T22:56:27.23311410richard bibbypollution parasites &toxic chemicals including in the fishes flesh are the problems.24722016-02-06T07:45:38.51711412Carol PilsworthPlease listen to your electorate. We want to protect our wild salmon and our Scottish Lochs from being polluted.24722016-02-06T09:05:30.4711413Thomas McGregorLeave improving rivers such as the Clyde alone and in the safe hands of those who have looked after them for more than a hundred years. The biggest threats come from the sea where the wild stocks are plundered by commercial fishing and smolts killed by sea lice that prosper around fish farms.24722016-02-06T09:06:45.70311414Ray HudsonTime is running out fast to save our Salmon - so please get on with it24722016-02-06T09:53:10.70311415John MosesThe clock is ticking for the survival of wild salmon on the west coast. We need action NOW.24722016-02-06T11:49:27.511417Barry Gibson How long will it take before the realisation comes home that radical reform is required to preserve wild fish stocks!!24722016-02-06T11:55:31.93711418william chisholmwell done for this petition, much needed.24722016-02-06T12:23:11.95311419rory maguireEstuary netting should be a major concern in protection of the Atlantic Salmon and Sea Trout stocks.24722016-02-07T15:23:51.1411421Lewis GibbonsBy the time you've taken "time to consider the issue" they'll all be dead. 24932016-02-07T17:19:59.81311422Les WallaceScotland is not proving to be a progressive country when it gives in to reactionary elements who have a very restricted view of what our country should be.24932016-02-07T19:14:20.93711423Mark JohnstonI am deeply concerned by the action of local landowners in the slaughter of these important wild animals and the inaction of the Scottish government that allows this persecution to continue.24932016-02-07T19:38:31.98311424Claire WotherspoonI was shocked on hearing about this since, if nothing else, it will directly lead to horrendous suffering. How on earth does this 'take time to consider'? How can our government be so callous?24932016-02-07T19:39:55.76711425Sylvia MellerPlease make the beavers a protected species! 24932016-02-07T20:29:13.9711426Louise RamsayBeavers have been successfully introduced to dozens of European countries. The have been established in the wild for many years inScitland. The Tay population has been shown to be of the right species and disease free. They are hugely popular and bring many benefits. The small number of farmers who have problems need to encourage more biodiversity on their farms and should use use mitigation where possible and certainly not be given the freedom to shoot them at will, they are protected under the habitats directive and its long past time protection was applied here.the current delay is bad for farmers as well as beavers as it allows them to destroy the reputation of farming in the eyes of the public.24932016-02-07T20:44:33.51711428Mike HambletIts possible that influential land-owners have persuaded ministers to allow them time solve the issue in their own way. There needs to be a legal action over this.24932016-02-07T22:24:39.70311429Julie Anya GuthrieI fully support this petition. 24932016-02-08T09:55:09.98311430William JodrfellDelighted to support such an important petition24722016-02-08T13:57:25.81311431john braithwaiteIn order to preserve stocks ALL netting for salmon should be banned, and on the main east coast rivers it should be fly only24722016-02-08T14:07:48.43711432Arnold SlaterFarm salmon sea lice destroying wild salmon and sea trout stocks,will destroy game angling tourism and Scottish jobs.24722016-02-08T16:02:24.68711433george younger kennedyPleased to support.High time Scottish Government took some real action to control the fish farming industry.24722016-02-08T16:10:10.1111434David John WatsonHere in the SW of Scotland salmon and sea trout numbers have plummetted over the last decade. It has been long established that parasitic lice from Fish Farms have destroyed the majority of smolts passing out to Sea but more recently I have seen returning adult fish plastered with sea lice. There is only one source that could be responsible for this.\r\nThe cause is obvious and the solution - closed containment- is sensibly achievable.\r\nIt is hard to believe that a Government which purports to represent Scotland is presiding over such an environmental, social, and economic disaster.24722016-02-08T16:54:50.17311435Joan JordanTime people in responsible positions acted responsibility!24722016-02-08T20:48:46.6411436Rose EvisonIt is time the Scottish Government decided - they have had plenty of info and 3 options put forward as requested by Scottish National Heritage. Given the UK has signed up to the relevant EU directive, and the Tayside beavers fulfill the conditions for being a reintroduced native species, and the beavers are an asset for flood control, biodiversity, and tourism, and there are well known methods of dealing with them in places where they become a nuisance, it is time to make them legal and stop illegal inhumane killing.24932016-02-09T10:40:31.43711437Paul RamsayBeavers have been successfully introduced to dozens of European countries. The have been established in the wild for many years inScitland. The Tay population has been shown to be of the right species and disease free. They are hugely popular and bring many benefits. The small number of farmers who have problems need to encourage more biodiversity on their farms and should use use mitigation where possible and certainly not be given the freedom to shoot them at will, they are protected under the habitats directive and its long past time protection was applied here.the current delay is bad for farmers as well as beavers as it allows them to destroy the reputation of farming in the eyes of the public.24932016-02-09T11:20:23.1111438Chris Townend, UKPlease ensure the beaver is protected by law.24932016-02-09T18:46:41.40711441Nick Charlton SmithThe evidence has been available for some considerable time. Excessive numbers of Fish farm Sea lice are killing our native salmon and sea trout - and effective control is required. The precautionary principle should be paramount in any decision making by the Scottish Government. Commercial pressure from the fish farmers must not be permitted to prevent effective controls to ensure the survival of these iconic species across Scotland as a whole. 24722016-02-10T10:38:35.59311443Andrew WildbloodIf government continues to dither over this issue it will be too late and our ancestors will rightly asked 'how was that allowed to happen'. Given the volatile nature of the oil market, a responsible government should be looking more carefully at preserving other local and sustainable valuable natural resources.24722016-02-10T13:17:37.8911444Philip McWalterFish farming is destructive to the environment unless fully contained and preferably on land where it can be totally monitored and overseen easily.24722016-02-10T15:29:57.48311445Carol GilbertCruelty should never be tolerated.24932016-02-10T16:01:00.79711447D W Roxboroughthis has been going on since the 80's with out any intervention , it's about time that this was addressed,before any other regulations i.e. current reform, takes place D W Roxborough24722016-02-10T16:36:08.37711448Iain MacdonaldWith a little thought and investment, the lice issue can be dealt with. On land farms is one of many options. For to long the lice, and disease issues are swept under the table. This is not an illusion, we can stop this madness now before we wipe out our entire species. Angling and the farming industry can both survive if we act now. Does anyone want to see more evedence in the decline of wild fish the likes off what we see on our West Coast rivers.24722016-02-10T17:44:41.98311449David WalkerUntil Salmon fish farming is moved on shore in full closed containment there will always be huge problems for wild Salmon24722016-02-10T18:04:16.09311450Alex TaylorBeavers do great good for our country, please ensure the law protects them!24932016-02-10T19:15:52.18711451Stewart CameronIf the Wild Fisheries Review and the map showing the category 3 rivers hasn't stirred some form of doubt in the minds of our politicians managing our environment i dispair. With any luck China will be producing their own farmed salmon soon and the industry will become unsutainable and wither.24722016-02-10T20:47:22.90711452Caroline GettinbyThese are a successfully reintroduced species, one we previously exterminated to ours, and local biodiversity's cost. This delay in taking a decision on their legal status, would appear to be in response to the few large landowners, rather than the greater groundswell of opinion that they should be protected in legislation. The good that retaining, protecting and managing their populations within statutorily set guidance from Scotland's appropriate regulators, would significantly outweigh limited and localised negative effects. Until a decision to protect the Beavers is undertaken, they may be subject to cruelty and abuses which should not be tolerated by the Scottish government nor the nature conservation agencies in Scotland. Full and urgent support should be given to back the implementation of legislation to offer full protection. 24932016-02-11T00:29:43.82711453Eric R wardleThere will be no salmon river fishing if the Government do not sort this out. A big loss of jobs tourism etc.24722016-02-11T09:25:28.93711454Andrew Moorewe must do everything possible to protect our native fish stocks, and particularly the genetic diversity of wild salmon and sea trout. Wait and see is not an option unless we want to see the failure of our wild fish as a pot6ential consequence. As a minimum we should be setting the standard for good practices, rather than lagging as at present.24722016-02-11T14:30:52.51711455Robert MitchellSea lice kills everything after a short time. Just look under the cages.24722016-02-11T19:07:34.95311456Mr Kenneth Barry MaylorThe Scottish government do not appreciate the damage done by fish farms to wild salmon and sea trout stocks and whole river systems have been wiped out.\r\nThe sea bed below the cages is completely devoid of life other than female sea lice the number of which are astronomical and a complete disgrace.24722016-02-12T14:19:07.8911459Richard CollinsIn the SALSEA project pity they were unable to undertake tracking of the migration of smolts from the point of leaving their native rivers into the marine environment. As far as I know the theory that smolts from SW Scotland and indeed NW England migrate through the W and NW Scotland fish farming areas has yet to be substantiated. But very expensive to undertake, I guess !24722016-02-13T13:11:24.1111461Tom CastleSurely the scientific evidence that irresponsible fish farming is destroying wild salmon runs is now irrefutable. Time for action before it's too late!24722016-02-14T19:42:28.54711463James Russell FranceThis problem is also affecting Cumbrian rivers.24722016-02-15T08:16:31.09311464Pierre RumeauI'm fortunate enough in not having this problem were I fish in Scotland (the Dee). But, having fished for seatrout in Ireland for the last thirty years, I saw them disappear where cages were installed with the few remaining being lean and overinfested. I had to change my holiday location to find some still healthy populations.\r\nRegarding the remote populations of the West Coast, considering what happened to the aquaculture in Chile, what will happen if the wild populations of migratory and coastal fish disappear, if the aquaculture is not sustainable any more and there is no transfer funding from dwindling petrol benefits? Would tourists still visit or would they prefer the sun of milder places?24722016-02-15T19:14:52.32711465Chris DawbarnI have had personal experience of a good west coast salmon fishery being ruined by the effects of farmed salmon.24722016-02-16T00:32:06.62711466Bob SmithI personally am disgusted at Scotgovs reluctance to provide protection for this creature. We, Scotland, are fast becoming a killing zone for everything that the country has to offer. Raptors being wantonly culled with no real protection or penalty, by-laws being introduced to inhibit our enjoyment of nature (Loch Lomond) and now this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The govt have a trial with the beaver and blatantly allow over £2m of public money to be shot out of the water because of the NFU being unwilling to look for other solutions other than lethal to meet the challenges of the beaver. They were part of TBSG and SBT, they have let their part of the bargain slip. Shame on them, shame on SNP!!! 24932016-02-16T10:11:2111467Neal MallettThis is a known and irrefutable problem that needs action now24722016-02-16T14:08:46.70311468David SandfordFurther to Pierre's comments, now that Salmon Farming is being better "controlled" in Connwe are 24722016-02-16T15:19:46.07711469Owen EverettI'm very glad that this petition has been launched. The research by ForcesWatch and Quakers in Scotland highlights the five main areas of concern very clearly - action is undoubtedly needed to increase scrutiny, guidance and consultation on these armed forces visits.24972016-02-16T15:45:15.43711470Jams RennieSalmon farms through uncontrolled sea lice populations are destroying Scotland's wild salmon and sea trout runs.24722016-02-16T17:39:20.2211471Chris TunnicliffeRestoring sustainable populations of wild salmon and trout, together with protecting their traditional migratory runs in both Scotland and Wales, has to be a priority for the Wildlife and Fisheries departments of both these countries as so many other species depend on their condition and availability for their own sustainability.24722016-02-16T17:45:18.87711472Gordon mackieWas surprised and very unaware at the level of this involvement .24972016-02-16T17:42:40.9711473Kim SawyerLice infestation is a recognized killer of migrating wild salmon, grilse, smolts and seatrout. Some measure of control must be introduced. 24722016-02-16T18:27:21.5311474Heather RobertsonBeavers have been proven to be a bonus to our environment and must be protected.......and the cruelty against them is totally unacceptable 24932016-02-16T19:25:44.34311475Peter Floyd-SpongHaving spent some time reading Fisheries around the country, part of a Oceanography degree, I feel that there are too many unanswered questions over farmed salmon to be sure adequate protection for our wild stock. Though yet to partake myself in salmon fishing in Scotland, it is and hopefully will remain a major source of income for Scotland, especially if the people decide to leave the Union.24722016-02-16T20:04:41.98311476Sila Collins-WaldenI'm delighted about this petition!! I hope there will be a good result!!24972016-02-16T21:06:16.8611477Tony ReaWake up Scotland and protect one of your greatest resources, both historical and from the point pf view of depleting tourist income. Why are you not protecting your wildlife ?24722016-02-16T21:57:07.1111478Clare PhillipsWe are heartened that currently our local schools are not involved in armed forces recruitment. We pray that this continues and extends throughout Scotland.24972016-02-17T08:25:14.4711479Brian MoffatSupport vital24722016-02-17T10:06:53.2811480Simon evansI organise parties to travel to Scotland to fish for salmon. I used to take a week on the west coast and one on the East. I no longer fish on the west coast (river Aloirt and Loch Eilt). This is costing Scotland £2,500 a year24722016-02-17T11:35:30.23311481Rupert Leigh-WoodWhy does Scotland have such disregard for Wild Salmon? Very sad.24722016-02-17T14:10:03.92311482Zoe MartindaleNature healing nature until it impacts on man made fisheries, forestry and farm crops. Hope the right decision is made for the environment.24932016-02-17T15:11:50.2211483Jen BroadhurstOur children ought not to be groomed to kill anyone elses children. Please stop this indoctrination of young minds.24972016-02-17T15:25:44.9711484Helen BlackburnOther careers don't get this kind of access to schools. The armed forces shouldn't get preferential treatment.24972016-02-17T15:29:06.81311485Colin ArcherThis is important work. Bravo.24972016-02-17T15:42:19.8911486Ian CalcottMost Scottish salmon farms are Norwegian-owned. Why are regulations here less stringent than on Norwegian fish farms? More infamous policy decisions by the SNP Government ?24722016-02-17T17:38:00.82711488Alastair McIverIn my opinion, this does not go far enough. Armed forces visits to publicly-funded schools should simply not take place, and it quite terrifies me that they do.24972016-02-17T18:30:33.2211489jacqueline pattonleave nature alone.......everything is here for a reason..maybe we need to assess the human population24932016-02-17T19:22:08.87711490Robert ThompsonI fully support this petition. This subject has been an on going concern and worry for me during the past thirty five years I have been working in secondary school.. It is high time for a full and open debate about what is being permitted and what is not being permitted in our schools.24972016-02-18T08:55:05.59311492John Brook RileySince 1985 I have witnessed good improvements to the Upper stretches of the Aberdeenshire Don, however the general trend of salmon catches are down. While this river does not suffer from salmon farming issues, it is like all others seeing the effects of by catch with the makeral and herring fishery. I do hope we can see progress to reduce this adverse effect.24722016-02-18T09:51:45.0311493W WhitbreadThe negative impact of sea lice from salmon farms stretches far beyond the west Highlands and Islands. 24722016-02-18T10:13:50.67311494Owen EverettI should have added that I am the Education Worker at ForcesWatch, and was involved with the research behind the petition. See the ForcesWatch website for full information on the research.24972016-02-18T16:47:58.34311496James BidwellThis is so important and we all need to do something before it is too late24722016-02-18T17:31:06.98311497Bidge GrahamThe level of militarisation in our society is beyond the pale. It cannot be allowed to pervade school life. Recruiting minors to the military is immoral and the UK is the only EU country that does it.\r\n\r\nTo my mind this petition is only a starting as I firmly believe no armed forces visits should be allowed in our schools. However if implemented it would be a start.24972016-02-18T17:31:44.1111498Robin DavisAm against all MoD visits to schools, colleges and universitiies24972016-02-18T17:54:14.2811499David BurtonI saw a badly fungal infected salmon on the Frome in Dorset in mid January. Not sure if this was sea lice related, but it was a sorry sight to see and clearly something needs to be done.24722016-02-18T21:24:30.34311500Diana DowerI am deeply worried about the lack of balance in forces visits to schools. Parents and guardians should definitely be notified before a visit by any of the forces. Any visit should be balanced by a visit by a severely wounded member of the armed services. It is particularly of concern that youngsters who have not done well in school are likely to be recruited, especially those from areas of high unemployment. We do not wish our children reared to kill others.24972016-02-18T21:41:53.3611501Wendy Erskine AnderosnThis is an utter disgrace. No one else would gain entry to schools to brainwash children. This nonsense of 'see the world and learn a trade and help people' is disgusting! Quakers should be doing a lot more than they have done so far in this nature.24972016-02-19T15:39:58.07711504Simon JacksonPhilosphy and ethics must be taught in schools or children will not be making an informed choice. The need for balance in education would require an equal number of school vists for Peace groups including Quakers. Parents most certainly should be consulted and given the literature that supports these military visits in advance. The existance of the Militaty Covenant must also be explained, and the financial inducements offered to the councils that sign the covenant.24972016-02-19T16:02:26.37711505Hilary ParkeBeavers can potentially make a valuable contribution to the Scottish ecosystem: integrated with more tree planting they can help prevent major downstream flooding by helping hold water in upper catchments, BUT they urgently need protection from random hunting.24932016-02-19T16:21:30.65711506Thomas PringleDisappointed that it has taken so long for the government to make a decision. All the information has been provided and other European countries cope well with managed populations. There is no point in granting permission if the population become unviable due to unregulated control. By untrained parties.24932016-02-19T17:22:2011508ian cochraneOur education institutions must remain De-Militarised Zones. Protect our children from the armed forces "child catcher" initiatives.24972016-02-19T18:04:43.82711510Dr. Morag Josephine GrantI am both involved in research into war and the military and a child rights activist. I am deeply concerned that the UK government continues to ignore appeals by human rights organisations, including interstate organisations, to fully uphold and respect the spirit of the Optional Protocol on the Convention of the Rights of the Child with regard to the age of recruitment of children. As a researcher on war I am also deeply concerned that children and young people are not being informed about the realities of warfare, and that the UK government is relying on young people who have not yet had the opportunity to access this type of information, as opposed to older people who have had more opportunity to understand the implications of a military career. The Scottish Government cannot stop this practice, but it can ensure that Scottish schools are places where children are educated about causes of war and the possibility of alternatives to war, and it can help ensure that every child leaving school has excellent chances for training and for a fulfilling career in whatever field, and that joining the Army should be a conscious option and not just the only route open to them. Young people who are thinking about a career in the Army need to be able to make a fully informed decision. We owe this to soldiers and to their loved ones and have to ask grave questions about our society if we are not willing to make sure that recruits understand absolutely what potentially awaits them. 24972016-02-19T19:00:09.90711512Ian FordFollow the lead from so many European countries. Bring back the Beaver and let it rewild Scotland naturally. Ps your capcha audio and visual is almost impossible!24932016-02-20T10:05:45.92311513Kerstin PhillipsI strongly agree that parental written permission are required each time, not one permission to cover a whole academic year.24972016-02-20T10:45:53.93711514Miss Sarah Louise TaddeiOn attempting to share this petition on facebook, I found that the link to facebook doesnt work. Pls rectify this asap.24972016-02-20T11:16:27.9711515Robert SandisonHalf of Scotland's farmed Salmon come from Shetland .The wild sea trout and salmon are near extinct in Shetland now.\r\n 24722016-02-20T14:17:55.43711516John R NewallSince 1956 to date I have fished various west coast rivers from Campbeltown to Tongue primarily for sea trout with occasional salmon caught. In the early years of my endeavors I could more or less guarantee catching a sea trout every time. The collapse of the sea trout population in our rivers coincided with the advent of these fish farms and scientific evidence supports this. If this unbridled expansion is allowed to continue in a few years there will be no sea trout on the west coast. Surely our natural resources are more important than the profits of a Norwegian company. 24722016-02-20T18:00:01.84311517carol grantBeautiful creatures leave them be24932016-02-20T19:03:10.37711518Ann MacInnesPost traumatic Stress and other disabilities and physical and mental illness are increased after time in the Armed Forces, especially when the people come from poor areas. \r\nI know this is not what you will tell the children, but it is what they and their families have to live when they come home-if they come home .24972016-02-20T23:47:06.4711519Dave RedwoodImmediate action, if not already too late, must be taken. The current situation is a Scottish disgrace.24722016-02-20T23:59:52.51711520Ian EckersleyThe west coast fisheries of Scotland were beautiful freshwater and marine environments supporting large runs of Salmon and seatrout providing some of the best fishing in the world. It supported many jobs in hotels shops, gillies and the supporting infrastructure. For any government to allow the destruction of these pristine environments is unacceptable and an urgent change of policy is required to control salmon farming to ensure the marine environments and the fish and crustaceans they support receive the protection they deserve. Hopefully if fish stocks return then jobs will also be created therefore helping the local economies and communities.24722016-02-21T10:24:37.6411522David Abel SmithThe excreta from farmed salmon must have a serious adverse impact on wild salmon wanting to enter Loch Etiv on their way to the the River Awe24722016-02-21T11:54:40.09311523ANDREW HINDWE NEED TO ACT NOW BEFORE IT TOO LATE24722016-02-21T19:25:35.2211524Jetro Lappalainen"the greatness and moral progress of a nation can be judged by the way its animals are treated"24722016-02-22T08:52:39.37711525Joseph WallsI do not feel it is appropriate to encourage young people at such a influential age to join the army before they have even experienced life.24972016-02-22T11:20:02.95311526Mary WoodwardI am very concerned that the MoD would appear to be targeting schools in deprived areas where there is little other employment and generally poor facilities, and offering the prospect of employment and training without necessarily informing young people of the risks involved and the constraints around leaving once they have 'signed up'. There should be employment and training opportunities which don't involve joining the armed forces.24972016-02-22T14:29:25.43711528Adrian Price'Re-wilding' is a hot conservation term. To ignore this aspect about Wild Salmon is to ignore conservation. Sea lice are a menace and poorly run fish farms are an environmental disaster. 24722016-02-22T15:08:50.43711529Brian Stewart Can we possibly beat vested interest?24722016-02-22T16:23:02.17311530John AllenSomething that should also be addressed via the EEC providing we remain members24722016-02-22T16:38:03.57711531David ForrestThese fish are ruining the stocks of wild fish when escapees interbreed with wild fish. They are also not good for human health as they are full of chemicals.24722016-02-22T17:01:50.29711533Lyall OwenPlease make every effort to sustain the salmon stocks24722016-02-22T17:25:13.73311536d.coshsea lice have destroyed the west coast of scotland rivers already24722016-02-22T17:37:41.31311537Warren SlaneyI worked on a Marine Harvest fish farm and used Nuvan to rid sea lice from sea caged fish. Horrendous stuff but most lice simply dropped off and floated away, to attach to wild fish. 24722016-02-22T18:32:54.65711538john shipley the Scottish parliament has had plenty of opportunities to do something about the salmon farming debacle and done have done about it. They just do not care .It is criminal..24722016-02-22T19:10:19.2511539John CouttsSerious action needs to be taken now to control this problem before it is too late.24722016-02-22T19:10:52.67311540Mark BroughtonWe need to get behind this petition whether we fish or just like our rivers.24722016-02-22T19:43:1311541John RichensHow can the Wild Atlantic Salmon, so synonymous with Scotland, be treated with such contempt by the Scottish Government ?24722016-02-22T20:13:28.84311542HAMISH LINDSAYthe test is hopeless virtually unreadable!24722016-02-22T21:36:25.6411543Anne RadoParents and guardians should not only be consulted in advance about these visits, but should also be invited to attend - and comment if they wish.24972016-02-22T21:40:56.84311544Mark WhiteheadIt is disgusting that salmon farming uses the ocean like a rubbish dump and that wild salmon smolts become infested with parasites due to salmon farming in our estuaries. We have to save our wild salmon which are at critically low stocks. Wake up Ministers and bring Marine Harvest etc to heel so they stop pollution and infesting our natural resources for greed and averice24722016-02-22T22:06:28.98311545D.JebsonThe decline of fish in the Ribble Catchment has been going on for years. Despite increased hours of input of fishing I have not had a fish ( Salmon) for three years. On our eight miles of water on the tributary of the Ribble which is the Hodder a single salmon was caught. No further stocking is allowed by the E.A and the future looks bleak compounded by the devastation of the redds by the recent floods. We live in hope that in 2016 will see an improvement. If there is it will not be because of human help. 24722016-02-22T22:22:03.67311546Anthony StuartWe need action now not when it will be to late24722016-02-22T22:41:10.82711547Mark ChapmanThis issue is already a major problem in British Columbia. Please don't let it happen in the UK!24722016-02-22T23:08:10.29711548Stephen DrageThe sea lice problem exists everywhere open pen salmon farms are. It is a problem worldwide. Salmon farms need to be taken out of the ocean and placed in land based, closed containment facilities.24722016-02-22T23:44:53.20311549Andrew. Williams Have fished various rivers in Scotland for last 29yrs. The rivers have progressively got less migratory fish, noticeably since the appearence of salmon farming.24722016-02-23T03:32:22.81311551sam mcfadzeanBeavers are an important part of the ecosystem they belong here, leave them be24932016-02-23T07:49:42.56311553John R CheethamIt's disheartening to see nature being treated like this\r\nOur planet is precious, it's about time we started showing it more respect than we do!24722016-02-23T07:53:14.92311554Nick GoughI visit the west coast of Scotland near Oban every year, and have been doing since 1963. As a teenager I would catch plenty of fin nock and the odd sea trout. Once salmon farms were installed in the local sea loughs, sea trout have all but disappeared. I have not caught one for several years. We must do something to protect these 'nomads of the tides'24722016-02-23T08:44:33.15711555DON REIDBig business rules,not o.k.24722016-02-23T08:46:17.82711556Bruce StanleyI think that more must be done to prevent ALL types of pollution. Salmon runs are decreasing, beaches are health risks, whales are dying, etc.. Enough is enough!24722016-02-23T09:26:55.31311557D. Theakervery good program on Alba blaming the sea lice for killing salmon and sea trout on the west coast rivers.24722016-02-23T09:37:23.29711558charles cooper4 salmon fishing holidays booked in Scotland this year. Assume helps local indiginous communities employed rather than aquaculturists from New Zealand and itinerant Polish workers. All paid for by Norwegian cash as they're banned from polluting their own coastline.24722016-02-23T10:48:17.4711559Peter MosleyWonder if an organised boycott of farmed salmon would be effective?24722016-02-23T16:10:13.56311560Alastair StobartHigh time the S NP did something constructive\r\nRather than blaming others24722016-02-23T16:16:58.87711561Bryan HollinworthThere is no doubt that there has been an exponential decline, in West Coast Sea Trout catches since the introduction of Salmon Farming.\r\nWe must 'all' endeavour to protect this wonderful species.24722016-02-23T19:23:00.68711562Andrew KeltonThe public management of the Scottish salmon farming industry has been, and continues to be, worthy of what used to be called a 'third world country'. The Scottish industry began as a free-for-all and giveaway of Crown Estate seabed. It expanded without any controls for sensitivity of location or size limits on individual facilities. It has been allowed to rubbish, without actual argument, 30 years of scientific evidence demonstrating the causal link between farm sea lice infestations and the wild salmonid demise all along the west coast. And it has been protected throughout from public scrutiny under the guise of commercial confidentiality. Surely there was (and is) a better way.24722016-02-23T21:27:16.90711563Euan Myles Aquaculture does not make any sense .\r\nTaking wild fish from the other side of the world to be dumped in to a Sea Loch in Scotland to feed and produce Sub Standard fatty Salmon and befoul the local environment and kill Sea Trout with Lice Infestation so bad wild fish stand no chance \r\nLoch Damph and Maree are now nearly devoid of Seatrout they were plentiful until the Farms they were the Best Sea Trout fishers in Europe but sold down the river for a quick buck . \r\nIf this evidence was listened to years ago we could of saved the west coast from these ravages 24722016-02-24T09:49:04.15711564Iain Freeman Salmon cannot be claimed to be responisibly farmed unless effective legislation is put in place to drastically reduce the sea lice problem. 24722016-02-24T12:59:51.31311565Marian HaraAlthough not resident at the moment I agree with the idea that there should be more balance and tranparency as in Wales.When I was in school in Glasgow we had military activities in the school which I found very unpleasant. As I live in a country which is moving toward more overseas military activity I am increasingly concerned about how children may be targeted, especially those from lower income families. I expect the Scottish government and education authorities to tread very carefully on this issue.24972016-02-25T14:11:15.23311566John WarkI agree with what has been said in Fly Fishing and Fly Tying magazine. Something needs to be done about this issue.24722016-02-25T16:51:41.95311567Derek RutterAs per Andrew Flitcroft's, Editors Letter in the March 2016 issue of the Trout & Salmon. Dr Aileen McLeod may bring about some sanity to the Scottish Governments lack of understanding of the plight which the wild salmon face, Day In & Day Out,when endeavoring to enter Scottish Rivers. Let us all hope that at last there is a Scottish Minister for the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform who has a grasp of the situation and is prepared to act on it.24722016-02-25T21:18:01.06311568Geoff MaynardOkay, we need farmed fish. But put them in closed systems where they can be controlled and problems contained.24722016-02-25T21:49:00.31311569Gareth jonesThe damage is done , legislation is only effective if effectivlely monitored ie one fish farm recorded 1 escapee, he saw it with his own eye.\r\nFished Scotland for 40 years killed3 fish and I am the bad one??????24722016-02-29T12:45:20.3611570tony martinwe could do with another petiton by 38deg to call for an end to under 18 recruitment. We are only country in europe that allows it i think,. It should be classed as abuse of children. Then we will see sparks fly.24972016-03-01T12:55:39.20311571Daniel BeanIn the wake of climate change, the nationwide reintroduction of beavers can no longer be a consideration, it is essential. The Government need to fully consider research not just undertaken by the SNH, but also Stirling, Exeter and other Universities and groups. As for conflicts with farming, farmers need to be educated ways of mitigation such as that in America and Europe , which don't involve killing beavers. I think a revue of current farming practices and upland land management is also due. I am not suggesting replacing these practices with conservation (as some conservationists may imply), as they are essential, but they need to be modified in such a way that they are more environmentally sustainable, notably many more trees are required in our uplands, and some lowland areas may need to be allowed to return to wetland. Please look at the research of Duncan Halley, it presents Scotland and potentially the rest of the UK with very realistic modifications to the uplands which would still allow sheep farming, grouse and deer shooting etc. However, subtle changes would be required to allow both woodland regeneration and these industries to continue (namely fewer deer and grouse being required to be shot). In addition, it has been found, that in South west Norway, not only are the estates more environmentally sustainable, harbouring more wildlife and trapping more water (which helps mitigate against flooding), they have more industries which have stemmed from having woodland. whilst a typical Scottish estate may only have deer stalking and grouse shooting, a SW Norwegian one will have deer stalking, grouse shooting, several wood cutting industries and more . As a result, despite a SW Norwegian estate probably being much smaller than the average Scottish estate, typically they employ 12 people, whereas a Scottish shooting estate may only employ around 4. Please read into Duncan Halley's research, it is a solution which will benefit landowners and conservation.24932016-03-01T13:07:25.29711572Steve BrownIt's so important to give nature all the protection we can, and to work with it to ultimately protect the environment 24932016-03-01T13:27:57.23311574Robert Goodrick We as a Nation have a moral and ecological obligation to protect and return this ecologicaly valuable species back into our environment. 24932016-03-01T14:37:49.18711575Lewis GibbonsDo it before they're all dead. 24932016-03-01T15:49:59.04711577Peter StevensPlease lead the way for England!24932016-03-01T15:53:32.09311578Mike HamblettBy delay the government are responsible for more deaths. Sickening lack of care.24932016-03-01T17:46:36.90711579Peter CreechOver 60 successful reintroductions in Europe, hugely beneficial for many of our native species and, via wildlife tourism, a major asset for fragile rural communities.24932016-03-01T19:03:50.92311580Ted OakesAll the evidence suggests beavers stop flooding, improve water quality and are good for the larger economy. 24932016-03-01T23:21:52.8911581Marilyn SansomIt is quite reprehensible that the Armed Forces are spending OUR taxpayers' money to promote a world for war, especially if there cannot be a counterbalancing view of peaceful ways of ending conflicts.24972016-03-02T18:04:53.1411582Yvonne. EarlChildren need educated on cons and pros of armed forces24972016-03-02T21:33:0011583Geraint MatthewsThere's more than enough evidence available that proves the vast number of benefits that the presence of beavers bring. Do the right thing and safeguard their future. It will benefit Scotland massively.24932016-03-03T00:51:21.29711584Jane Cartney Long term vidence proves that presence of beavers contributes to positive flood management. The Scottish Government has spent long enough prevaricating over this issue. Beavers should be afforded official status and protection immediately.24932016-03-04T09:39:28.23311586H. MackieThe increase in biodiversity since their introduction is enormous. They are fascinating to watch, and local teenagers are aware of their significance. They also encourage more visitors to this remote area, significantly helping local businesses.24932016-03-04T13:34:12.18711587Hugo RaineyBeavers can help prevent flooding by keeping water higher up in catchments. Given the cost to Scotland's towns (and to other parts of the UK) in recent months from major flooding, Scotland could reduce flooding of houses and save money on expensive dredging by increasing upstream prevention of run off, which includes allowing beavers to slow down water run off. Protecting beavers will therefore have a beneficial effect on government expenditure and on people's houses. This must be better for Scotland than an unlikely and minor risk to a few landowners' fisheries.24932016-03-06T10:55:20.59311588Eileen McCannI have just watched beaver trapping and relocation in the US. Killing beavers should be illegal, at worst we should relocate, but they help with flooding so this should be subject to an environmental audit.24932016-03-06T15:40:47.57711589Hazel RoperHow can the families grieve & move on without at least some answers regarding these deaths.23932016-03-06T17:15:35.7211590Alastair McIverThis does not go far enough. In my view, Armed Forces visits to schools simply shouldn't happen.24972016-03-06T21:32:34.90711591MALCOLM nICHOLTHIS WAS SUPPOSED TO HAVE BEEN CHANGED IN 2010 AFTER NHS TAYSIDE FAILED MY SON WHO WENT ON TO COMMIT SUICIDE AGED 2223932016-03-07T00:19:36.82711592Margaret PeacockI understand that local authorities are very short of cash for education, and may therefore welcome a military contribution to the school curriculum, especially the exciting outdoor activity which needs expensive equipment. This is an easy opportunity for military infiltration for the purpose of recruitment, implying a satisfying career but ignoring the moral considerations, the mental risks to immature brains, and the very real physical risks.24972016-03-07T08:23:53.0311593Ingo SchuderScotland is known for its great wildlife. that's why many people go there!24932016-03-07T08:52:24.98311595John MilesThese mammals are worth a lot of money to tourism and river management.24932016-03-07T11:58:47.18711596Owen EverettThanks for the great comments everyone. Please carry on spreading the word about the petition, and about the events in Scotland next week to raise awareness about the issue - see the ForcesWatch website for details.\r\n\r\nTony: such a petition exists! Search '38 degrees + armed forces recruitment 18'. \r\n\r\nBest wishes,\r\nOwen\r\nForcesWatch Education Worker24972016-03-07T12:40:33.42311597Ellen ColingsworthThere should be no visits to schools by the armed forces. School age children should not be influenced to make decisions about their role in war. At the very least, it should not be a glamourised, sanitised view of the actions of the armed forces. 24972016-03-07T13:44:20.26711598Michele GunnAs a Quaker and a pacifist, I find it ethically unacceptable that children should be presented with publicity for a career in the armed forces as a "normal" career. Joining the armed forces is specifically committing to either directly killing other human beings, or assisting in the killing of human beings.It also, by the same token, commits to being killed. I doubt if those who present the armed forces as a career would spell out - or be allowed to spell out - these realities. Further, children under 18 should not be considered mature enough to take on the implied risks of taking other peoples' lives, or of losing their own.24972016-03-07T14:53:01.04711599K. HawBeavers are wonderful and hard working elements of our native ecosystems, and should be welcomed back with open arms!24932016-03-07T21:22:51.7811600Ray DoneganWe , the "clever" co- occupiers should invest our considerable resources in consideration of the right off ALL to go- exist . And don't forget the tired scared humans , bobbing about in the Med , or wherever, ALL24932016-03-08T08:58:38.4711601jim chestnutthere are 2 sides to every coin and the reality side of a career in the military is every bit as important to a young person as the gloss24972016-03-08T14:06:19.79711603Gordon HolmIt would be a travesty if the bears were not accepted back as part of Scotland's wildlife and ecology.24932016-03-08T15:17:14.2811604Margaret BoudrAWouldn't it be great if our armed for es were used to help people in other parts of the world instead of killing them in stupid wars and hence creating problems for years and years to come.24972016-03-08T16:08:13.29711605Sheila DorsettBeavers bring so much to the environment and benefit all of us. Let's protect them.24932016-03-08T17:53:36.67311606Kareen A RennieI do not want Scottish children signed up by the UK Forces and used as cannon fodder!24972016-03-08T20:34:26.2511608Gisela CreedThe armed forces should not be allowed anywhere to "advertise" or "recruit" in our schools24972016-03-09T12:10:06.511609Jean Clark i lost my son to suicide 11 years ago he was attending a clinic in our home town a normal hard working married man with two lovely children and i will never understand what made him do such a thing his treatment didnt do much for him but i hope this petition helps outhers 23932016-03-09T13:21:43.87711610Eddie CarrollGo onto the Veterans for Peace website and learn.24972016-03-09T20:03:31.92311611Claire EasingwoodAs a retired teacher, I feel strongly about the way in which the Armed Forces exploit impressionable teenagers with their distorted version of what it will be like if they join up. I always opposed such school visits and fully support this campaign.24972016-03-09T21:59:01.9711612Catriona ScrivenThis is a significant opportunity to reinstate beavers to Scotland24932016-03-10T00:45:38.34311613Graham Peter KingI think that recruitment of those under the age of 18 should end. I consider it wholly inappropriate for military recruitment and what is effectively propaganda to be promoted in schools. Further, until this practice ends, I believe that parents should be given ample (previous term) advance notice of any planned visits by armed-forces personnel, to allow informed consultation and discussion among parents and school staff. Parents should have an option to withdraw their children from such activities (the school should provide suitable alternative arrangements) and children themselves should be told they may opt out if they wish.\r\nThe content and style of any presentations should be made wholly transparent and on the record. Ideally pacifist and other non-belligerent groups should be given opportunity to present balancing viewpoints. \r\nThe presentation of armed forces material should include open discussion of the consequences of war, including civilian and troop casualties and ramifications (maiming, death, post-traumatic stress disorder, difficulties in social adjustment back in civilian life) - some case studies would be useful) and also of the considerable protests and controversy concerning UK military involvements overseas.\r\nChildren should not be treated as a captive audience to harness for war.24972016-03-10T20:17:07.93711614James MillsAs a society we are too open to the propaganda pushed by the Armed Forces and the government. Our soldiers are being now being dubbed ''heroes'' by the government as a way of reducing criticism of their foreign policy catastrophes .24972016-03-12T15:42:40.01711618joyce MinnisI do not aprove of chiildren being influenced in this way24972016-03-12T15:50:27.6411619James JohnstoneThey should not be allowed in schools especially more so in poor deprived areas, As some of the kids see this as their only chance of escaping poverty and the only chance of getting a job!! hiring kids as bullet catchers for the rich mans wars!!24972016-03-13T08:50:07.68711621Sally TaylorI think beavers are beneficial to other wildlife in Argyll, in particular.24932016-03-13T14:11:34.32711622Roxanne O'NeillChildren attend school, not only to learn, but because they are legally obliged to be there. They have no choice in what they are exposed to, they are a captive audience. Children deserve better than to have their time when they should be learning about the world, co-opted by recruitment officers looking for fresh young meat for wars these children have had no say in starting. It feels tantamount to grooming.24972016-03-14T17:36:31.2511623Patrick BealeyI support this petition 100%, on the basis that the provision of one-sided information to the young people in our country is irresponsible. There will be those, swayed into making a career in the forces and finding a very different reality to what they were led to believe. Those people, not a few in number, will be bitter, they will feel let down by those who should protect young people from unfair presentations, etc. We can do better, and please God, we will do better.\r\n\r\nIn love and peace, Patrick24972016-03-15T09:26:52.6111624jennifer broadhurstunable to sign petition due to a server error please fix\r\n24972016-03-15T09:39:20.95311625Rosie KaneArmy recruitment operating in places where children seek support and education is unethical. Masked within the promises of "training" " travel" "driving license" etc are the facts that children are being selected and groomed to kill. Children from working class areas are most vulnerable in the current economic climate. The lack of work and training housing and a decent future leaves many feeling that the forces are the way out of hopelessness and the MOD know this. The promise of food, bed , training and wage should be guarenteed without putting weapons in children's hands and hate in their minds. Please protect our children and let them learn about peace as opposed to bring conscripted into illegal wars. 24972016-03-15T10:18:14.67311626Rosie Kane Allowing army recruitment officers into our schools is effectively abuse. Children in poorer communities are most vulnerable and in the current economic climate where work and training are limited it's easy to convince a child that they will access these rights via the armed forces. Children are not told by recruitment officers from MOD that they will be exposed to hate and horror and imperial wars. It us not explained that in return for the training , food, wage etc that they will be expected to become involved in the slaughtered of other children. They are not told about the cuts in MOD funding which leave front line vulnerable to injury and death. Instead children are promised a future that should already exist outside military service. Teach our children peace, diplomacy, understanding and care. 24972016-03-15T10:47:30.8611627Moderator@ Jennifer Broadhurst - thanks for your comment and letting us know about the error you're getting when trying to sign the petition. We've asked our IT team to look into this for us. Please accept our apologies for this, we'd be happy to add your name to the petition for you. If anyone would like their names added then please email us via petitions@scottish.parliament.uk.24972016-03-16T22:17:28.48311629David ButcherI am most disappointed that the Scottish Government have delayed for so long and have not had the courage to act in a positive manner. I am seriously considering withdrawing my support for the SNP.24932016-03-17T16:40:16.67311630Paul CochraneIn a democracy, our Armed Forces are crucial but the joining of the organisation must be accompanied with real facts and not the glamorous and silky PR festivals that happen just now.24972016-03-18T13:04:45.32711631Alex ThomsonI agree that the Armed forces, especially because of the hypocritical situation involving Syria, the situation in Iraq and other middle eastern countries, should not be asked to come to school in an attempt to glorify camaraderie when it is just following orders even though the orders may be morally wrong!\r\nIn a society where we preach that violence is wrong but yet our government still favour war, its hypocrisy at the highest level!24972016-03-18T14:31:54.5311632Pete GregsonPlease sign - to change the NHS for Good!25272016-03-18T15:41:20.70311633kevin FergusonPartnership has failed eg bullying levels stubborn at around 15 percent waiting lists debacle and iMatter not rigorous enough. We externally audit clinicnal and financial governance why not staff governance too?25272016-03-19T16:36:08.48311634John CouzinThere is no place for the military in our schools, most kids are not fully aware of what war actually means are are far to young and easily influenced the glossy propaganda of the recruiting personnel. The smooth talk of training, travel and adventure never includes dead or maimed bodies, trauma or the suicides of ex-military. If they want to talk to people, they should be obliged to tell the full story, with facts and figures of deaths, injuries, backed up with graphic photos of what war is all about. They should not be allowed to peddle their sanitised version to drag the un-informed of our children into their nightmare of violence and death. 24972016-03-20T20:00:23.8611635Genevieve OrrI work at a school which has decided to include the cadets as a curriculum 'choice'. I query where the choice lies, when educationalists are encouraged to embark on recruiting child soldiers, as there is funding available for such ventures, targeting youngsters from a deprived background, who feel they have no choice. 24972016-03-21T15:20:58.06311637John NolanI am husband of an NHS emplyee who has formally whistleblown an incident involving the escape of fumes endangering an ongoing baby clinic. The report was tendentious, misleading and demonising of my wife. She now faces a so-called Stage 3 Dismissal procedure, simply a procedure twisted in order to help the board rid themselves of a troublesome, bu justified whistleblower. She would be happy to contribute her details and any other assistance to the petition before Holyrood.25272016-03-22T11:07:33.68711638Peter GregsonLocal Government needs fixing. Please sign25282016-03-22T11:09:03.2811639Peter GregsonHelp shape a world that we would want for our kids25302016-03-22T12:55:49.29711640Dr John Wallace HintonScottish democracy demands that the be accountability in all public services. This petition makes reasonable proposals to help ensure protection of Scottish Health Service staff and patients.25272016-03-22T15:19:10.09311641Denise MarshallTo be honest, I would like to see even those who live within the zone also charged, if only to encourage them to use more sustainable forms of transport around town such as bus or bike, though would be willing to accept it as a last resort if it was the only way to get locals onside. Reducing vehicles in cities, by whatever means, make them more friendly to everyone!25302016-03-22T18:36:16.26711642Dave du FeuI don't agree with every detail of what is said here, but definitely support the principle, and obviously the details would be debated in Parliament if this went forward, so I am very happy to sign.25302016-06-01T15:19:39.5611644Donald BartyThis is LONG overdue25192016-06-01T15:30:31.5311645Elizabeth RoddieBadly needed25192016-06-01T15:50:40.3811646Emma Campbell-TaylorThis will make it a better and safer road25192016-06-01T15:51:07.59711647George kirkIf this road was in England it would have been done years ago it's long overdue to much traffic on it 25192016-06-01T15:52:37.8511648Stuart CassieLocally Industry, lobs, tourism and future expansion of those all suffer due to the slow and dangerous road, the A75, winding its way through Dumfries and Galloway. Adding dangerous " accident waiting to happen" 3 lane areas does not help the traffic flow or reduce the likelihood of an accident, it increases it. The west of the Region would greatly benefit from a better road link. It would make it easier for goods to be shipped too and from the West which may encourage business expansion. Tourism would also benefit by making it easier for people to visit the area. Medically, Dumfries to Stranraer is 75 miles which takes 90 min on a good day. When Everyone gets sent to Dumfries Hospital the Transit time needs to be lower not just for the patient but for Family to visit as well. Currently we are closer to Ayr hospital or even Glasgow.25192016-06-01T15:59:00.9411649Mark AllisonThe A75 is long overdue upgrading.it would make a substantial improvement to local companies and secure jobs in the region if the 75 was dual carrigeway , it would cut the time between stranraer and the border in half.25192016-06-01T16:33:51.24711650Haig Kirk Former resident of Annan, and regularly visit the area to see family. Totally agree the road should be upgraded. 25192016-06-01T16:36:28.77311651Angela ScorerThis road is used by locals, tourists and for freight distribution. It is a vital link and should be treated as such. At the very least I believe the road would benefit from an increase in the maximum speed for heavy goods vehicles and average speed cameras such as have been implemented on the A9. It is my understanding that the EU are willing to pay half the cost of the upgrade, clearly they understand how important this is. If the referendum result is to remain I would hope the Scottish Parliament would do the right thing and move forward with major improvements to this road. 25192016-06-01T16:51:30.57311652Beverley Learmonth In the interest of safety, tourism it is vital this road is upgraded to open up the forgotten part of scotland25192016-06-01T17:08:57.98311653Pamela Hughes This road needs to be upgraded to dual carriageway urgently. It's dangerous.25192016-06-01T17:43:57.44311654irene goodrumThis is several decades overdue.25192016-06-01T18:18:00.74311656Susan JacksonUpgrading of the A75 to dual carriageway is grossly overdue and essential for the amount of traffic this road carries every day 25192016-06-01T18:34:52.24711657 Iain Campbell I have attended many incidents on the A75 over the years, it now needs up upgrade to better serve the region and the traffic.25192016-06-01T19:27:40.76711658Ron Orr Time to also bypass the last two villages that a major euro route passes through. Time residents of Springholm and Crocketford had there quality of life improved, instead of constant threat from speeding HGV'S. 25192016-06-01T19:30:30.98711659Peter FordAs a "Euro-route" the A75 is grossly inadequate for the volume of traffic it attracts.25192016-06-01T20:05:25.9611660Mrs Diana Mc Cormick I've lived here all my life and this a horrendous road to drive, badly needs upgraded 25192016-06-01T20:17:22.55711661Jacqueline HenryMake it happen as soon as possible please.25192016-06-01T20:51:46.73311662Dave SingletonThe A75 is a danger to all that use it especially in the west of the region as it would appear we live in the land of the forgotten and are expendable!\r\nSpeed up the process lets have it done asap!25192016-06-01T21:20:53.0211663Donald McHarrieSooner the better!25192016-06-01T22:00:24.1511664Simon Hayes With such a large amount of traffic this road SHOULD be upgraded for growth development and more importantly safety! 25192016-06-01T22:03:33.33711665John Henry If this was the main road into Edinburgh it would have been upgraded long ago 25192016-06-01T22:37:14.01311667Colin HarrisonThis road is long overdue an upgrade and the dual carriageway is the way to go. I used to work as a lorry driver In Scotland and I've seen incredibly dangerous overtaking tactics used by other lorry drivers on the A75. Parts of it are not suitable for the amount of traffic that use it. Too many unnecessary crashes, too many deaths.25192016-06-02T00:04:11.2611668Geraldine EwanI agree with the statement below.\r\n25192016-06-02T00:35:18.79311669Lynden McCraeThis is the main route to Ireland. This road is far too busy to be single carriage way and needs upgrading.25192016-06-02T07:34:46.66311670Nicola Fouldsit is essential this upgrade takes place, it will make it safer, easier, quicker and better for the economy because of better transport and will encourage more tourists.25192016-06-02T07:50:11.60311671Chris AlviI live just off the A75 between Gatehouse of Fleet and Creetown. This is a Priority Euro Route carrying a very high volume of traffic including freight, tourist traffic, farm vehicles and local traffic. There are numerous accidents on the A75 , including fatal traffic accidents, because the road is not designed to cope with such heavy traffic. In addition, the condition of the road surface, particularly between Castle Douglas and Newton Stewart is simply disgraceful. It reflects extremely badly on the Scottish Government that such a major route has not yet been upgraded and is so poorly maintained.25192016-06-02T10:00:27.90311672Anne LeviThe state of this major highway is dangerous and a disgrace to this country. We use this road daily and it is deteriorating fast. Action needed quickly to prevent more accidents, foster tourism and give relief to the local population!25192016-06-02T12:11:09.93711673Rosemary WatersAs a tourist, we use this road and are very suprised at its condition. People may use it once but I'm sure many are put off of using it again, which has a knock-on effect on tourism.25192016-06-02T12:18:40.8611674William MosesThis road must be dual all the way.\r\n\r\nA75 puts the people of the south west, which is a fragile rural economy full of entrepreneurs, and the people of Ireland at a major disadvantage to the majority of the country.\r\n\r\nThe A9 has been less busy for decades, and is being dualled all the way...25192016-06-02T13:15:41.02311675iain clarkthe area would benefit greatly from better transport links.25192016-06-02T13:16:50.49311676Helen McLeanThis area has lost so much business wise and we rely heavily on tourism now this road is a joke! Not even the fact that it should be a duel carriageway but the pot holes from Stranraer to Dumfries are horrendous. This is supposed to be a main euro route to Ireland but it's no better than a countryside B road........in fact the B roads in Northern Ireland are better than this!! We are continuely forgotten about in this most beautiful part of Scotland it's well overdue that this was sorted!!!!!!25192016-06-02T14:47:57.58311677Ian McColmLiving in Stranraer I work in Northern Ireland all week hauling trailers to and from the docks at both Stena in Belfast and P&O in Larne, the road infrastructure in NI is set up for the haulage industry, it is dual carriageway or motorway from both docks. Why is the Scottish government dragging their heels the A75 should have upgraded years ago, haulage firms need good infrastructure to survive as does the ports and towns along the route.25192016-06-02T16:08:26.2511678Aubrey ChathamOne has to go with the flow, further delays means (which is happening now) traffic congestion resulting in more unnecessary accidents,time and motion is the name of the game, frustration must go25192016-06-02T16:52:16.14711679Keighley McCathieDriving from Newton Stewart to Gatehouse of Fleet on average 5 or 6 days a week, it is bewildering to me why it has taken so long for the A75 to even be considered as a dual carriageway route. Transport Scotland should be ashamed at the state of the roads, various sections of the road are not for for purpose right now. Invest some money and give us the basic right to drive without fear of needing to see a mechanic every few weeks!25192016-06-02T18:25:19.8311680Gabrielle HarringtonWhilst we do enjoy a peaceful area without the intrusion of fast traffic, this is the main artery linking the mainland to N. Ireland, carrying a lot of heavy goods lorries as well as tourist traffic (not forgetting us - the locals - who have to travel to Dumfries for hospital visits etc.). Its up-grade should have priority.25192016-06-02T18:45:32.22311681JN SteeleThe A75 is a difficult road to make progress on, and with the restricted speeds of necessary HGV traffic slowing the flow it frustrates other road users ( cars, vans and motor cycles ) This then encourages even experienced careful drivers to attempt over takes where they would not normally.\r\nUnfortunately the introduction of continuous duel carriageway would cut the revenue stream to Police Scotland thereby making the likely hood of it ever happening remote. 25192016-06-03T06:43:37.46711682ann fitzsimmonsthis should have been done years ago25192016-06-03T10:28:25.11311684John Stuart BrownThis road is busy, slow and dangerous. It at least deserves parity with the A9 and should be upgraded as soon as possible.25192016-06-03T14:47:51.911685Richard McLean After being stuck behind a wide load Lorry on serval occasions for 30 miles the road would definitely benifit from a upgrade 25192016-06-03T19:15:28.11311686Eric StewartThe A75 as a Euro Route is an absolute disgrace, the pot holes in a car are really bad but on a motorcycle could be lethal. It really mus effect the economy of Dumfries & Galloway, especially in the west and also the North Irelenad economy. 25192016-06-03T21:08:58.33311687Andrew Hastie For too long the region of Galloway has suffered through poor investment in it local jobs and has felt the very poor relative within Dumfries and Galloway. Help demonstrate that the southern most area is important and not a drive through place 25192016-06-03T23:12:22.6311688Hilary RobinsonI travel the A75 regularly between DG and NI. Parts of it are a pleasure and parts are a nightmare. Please consider upgrading it.25192016-06-03T23:33:08.53311689Joyce C FarquharAberdeen to Ellon has taken over 30 years to get a dual carriageway. Don't let us wait this long for this road to be upgraded. \r\n25192016-06-04T06:23:27.58311690J GallowayThere's so many near accidents due to lack of overtaking lanes and volumes of traffic.25192016-06-04T07:08:03.10711691Thomas DockertyDrivers on this road doing the speed limit are frequently tailgated and overtook in an increasingly dangerous manner with little enforcement during the evenings from police. Combined with the number of heavy freight on this road and it's amenity to bad weather, it is an accident waiting to happen and something needs to be done. The road surface is poor and gritters often blast your vehicle at close range with no chance to safely get out of the way. As a major route it's time to act now.25192016-06-04T07:39:54.4211692Jane Anderson As well as being a local route this is essential for the economic infrastructure of this region. This road still has tractors holding up lorries making their way to the motorway. What century are we in? Take a look at the road between the M6 and the irish ferry at Anglesey to see how it should be done. More help for southern Scotland please. This country does not begin and end at the central belt.25192016-06-04T10:43:23.99311693Sandra GormanI've seen many near misses, it would be a small price to pay to improve safety and to invigorate the economy of the rural economy. The current transport infrastructure is scant across the region with trains only from Dumfries and Stranraer (not through the region) and infrequent buses which are being reduced further. The A75 can be a nightmare to drive with many slow vehicles - a duel carriageway is essential.25192016-06-04T11:44:06.1611694Michael anthony mcdonaldThis should have upgraded to dual carriage at least twenty years ago if this road was in England it would have been done no doubt about it main euro route its a fig race and very dangerous road as there is is not enough overtaking opportunities and people get so frustrated stuck behind lorries for miles on end this causes more accidentsas people are rushing to catch ferries.25192016-06-04T11:45:06.9411695Colin Fisher I have seen so many near misses on this road. Drivers become frustrated with slow moving lorries or agricultural machinery. There are many blind corners. Improving the infrastructure would surely improve the economy of the area.25192016-06-04T14:35:28.04311696Robert phillips We definitely need something 25192016-06-04T20:32:06.7811697Marie BradshawAs Dumfries is our nearest main large town, the route really does need to be made safer for us. It's a main roadway for large wagons and heavy traffic, sometimes becoming frightening to drive amongst....make our road safe for all by making it a dual carriageway please.25192016-06-05T14:35:50.92311698Trevor SheppardMy family have to travel to Dumfries quite often and find the A75 quite unacceptable a a main route.25192016-06-05T18:35:24.55711699Stuart MurrayThe A75 should be added to the A9 increased 7.5t speed limit trial, with SPECS along its course in the meantime. Holyhead has and Heysham is getting their upgraded, dualled roads, which have taken considerable volume of freight off the North Channel. The A75 needs major investment, upgrade and speed limit increase to protect both the North Channel crossings and the local economies along the A7525192016-06-05T18:49:15.711700Frank McCutcheon It should have been a dual carriageway from the beginning. After an accident on the bypass near the A701, it took me nearly 4 hours to get home. That was 2 miles away. Any accident the whole town comes to a standstill.25192016-06-05T19:00:01.5411701Andrew OrrThis is a major route which needs and deserves to be upgraded to duel carriageway 25192016-06-05T19:51:00.20311702Carole LloydMain atririal road to West coast Scotland and main ferry link to Ireland, still routed through villages with donkey cart meandering roads, nice for the tourists to travel but highly impractical in the 21st century scheme of things....time to move SW Scotland forward25192016-06-05T20:04:41.52311703Kathy HamiltonTold when moved here 34 years ago that they had been trying for more than 20 years, so to say it's overdue is an understatement, it feels like it's been passed over on the road list of priorities at every turn. So I think it's about time it went to the top of the list and remained there. 25192016-06-05T20:54:50.4611704Rhona DickieEveryday I witness so many near misses on this road, 25192016-06-05T22:35:09.24711705John Mckie As a truck driver and also a local lad that lives on the A75 this would be great for the traffic as it would reduce accidents and travel time 25192016-06-05T22:35:53.05311706Iain ClarkThe road is not fit for purpose the pitiful 3 lane overtaking area's with cycle paths in the middle of nowhere are laughable but as I understand it was a EU requirement to get the grant crazy25192016-06-05T23:03:44.2611707Michael HoweAs mentioned previous the Carrutherston upgrade should have been duel carriageway. Long overdue25192016-06-06T03:23:46.66311709Alastair Orr Ewing Improved infrastructure is one of the first steps necessary to Improve the economy of the area. So desperately needed in this forgotten corner.25192016-06-06T07:58:12.1711710Lorraine RobertsonLong over due !25192016-06-06T08:42:48.94711711Scott loganThe A75 no fit for the traffic that's on itevery day , I'm up and down to the ferry, it's a nightmare with overtaking traffic , time for duel carriage now25192016-06-06T09:47:33.18311712Dr John RamwellThis busy and dangerous road must be made safe25192016-06-06T15:41:39.811713Dorothy KingThe villages of Springholm and Crocketford have been subjected to traffic blight probably unprecedented any where else in Scotland.Houses sitting right on the roadside with speeding traffic night and day and the largest percentage of HGVs apart from the A74 which is now motorway.Utterly barbaric.Bypass needed now and preferably dualled.25192016-06-06T19:16:40.26711714ann munnits a diabolical road that connects ireland to england. it would appear that no one in the scottish government cares about people who live and have a business in the southwest of scotland. time something was done about it.25192016-06-06T19:39:00.59711715Martha Jane McMathMuch needed development .25192016-06-07T00:52:13.48711716Richard Morris, this idea seems to be quite rational, it also might not be as compassionate towards the mentally ill as the medical profession may wish to be.For example, some people die or get a mental illness as a result of medical intervention, and being mis diagnosed, mis-prescribed, over-medicated with harmful drugs, or as a result of other medical mistakes ( the so-called "iatrogenic illness") People may go to hospital for a minor surgery, which is botched and then requite heavy pain killers, and develop a dependency on pain killing drugs or substitute such as alcohol. Should people who are thus addicted to alcohol be refused a liver transplant?\r\nAlso, some people self-medicate for mental illnesses such as schizophrenia with nicotine from cigarettes. Both nicotine and alcohol are carninogens that contribute to much disease and early death. Should smokers and drinkers all be refused medical treatment, or should they just help to pay for it from higher taxes on their drugs of choice?24752016-06-07T18:35:10.47311717Paul Fairbrass Many times I have travelled on the A75 from Ireland. To be honest. It's a disgrace, dangerous and unfit for purpose. When I here of incidents on this road it doesn't surprise me,. When traveling to the UK I mostly travel through Wales, why. It's safer. Upgrading this road would bring more revenue to the local economy through more tourists,willing to travel on a safer road. 25192016-06-07T21:30:35.70711718Craig McgowanTime for Upgrading ASAP. The roads a disgrace 25192016-06-08T07:07:58.2511719Mandy Curtis This road must be the most dangerous Euro route in GB.25192016-06-08T07:35:15.5511720Patricia CorrieHeavy HGV and logging lorries plus Cairnryan Ferry traffic combines to make this a dangerously busy road. 25192016-06-08T12:49:32.1611721LYDIA REIDOK so this petition should stop all folk who get treatment for a sexually transmitted disease\r\n \r\nDrinkers - who are given a recommended limit and do not stick to it\r\nSmokers Well we all know about cigarettes \r\nWomen who fall pregnant - we have birth control\r\nBirth control - we know we can avoid all sorts by not having sex \r\nChildren who over eat \r\nPeople who get injuries by playing sport - that is by choice\r\n\r\nI could if I wanted be even more silly \r\n\r\nAbout as silly as this petition 24752016-06-08T13:03:08.39711722FGH SmithThis is basically a country tourist road not a so-called Euro-route.25192016-06-08T19:50:18.99711724Wilma FinlayUpgrading the A75 to a dual carriage would be of major benefit to both the economy and the safety of the citizens of the region25192016-06-08T19:57:03.3911725Edmund WigramI have travelled this road many times, having lived in the region since 2005. This is the main trunk road from England to Ireland and it is disgraceful that the UK Government have not instituted an upgrade. The A77 is the main trunk route for Scotland to Ireland and this too needs an upgrade. Both routes carry heavy goods vehicles in large numbers and because they are subject to reduced speed limits the car traffic is frequently overtaking and sometimes taking dangerous risks out of impatience and frustration.25192016-06-08T20:21:57.33311726Raymond OwenThe Scottish Government has made the A75 even more dangerous by lowering the max speed for HGVs 10 mph lower than in England and Wales25192016-06-08T20:38:53.11311727IAN WILSONSafer roads for Scotland ! SNP never listen to anything outside Glasgow Good luck25192016-06-09T19:00:10.611728gordon bellit is long overdue and should be made a dual carriageway for the amount of traffic25192016-06-10T01:38:49.07311729RuthI use the A75 on a regular basis living and working in the Castle Douglas Dumfries area. My home is in Northern Ireland so not only do I use the A75 route for regular trips home but my family frequent the route on visits across. I have had first hand experience of the dangerous manoeuvres attempted particularly by lorries and the frustration of lengthy tail backs amongst freight traffic. The constant dreadful patchwork jobs of the endless potholes makes the journey exhausting, dangerous as people severe to avoid the craters in the road surface and inflicts terrible damage to vehicles and tyres. \r\nI work in the Scottish tourism industry within Dumfries and Galloway trying to encourage more people to visit the region and as such a main route, the A75 is an absolute embarrassment to what is a beautiful part of Scotland.25192016-06-10T23:58:25.8811730Robert Marks (Dr)Interesting idea, and obviously thought out. I wonder if you could really call it a PRIVATE company with only the Scottish Government(? sic) as shareholder?\r\nI used to be a research chemist and know the cost of drug development is enormous. Perhaps you could clarify if the Scottish "government" which is not sovereign would be allowed to do this even if it wanted. I think it may lie beyond it's powers.25332016-06-12T21:32:24.92711733lisa dochertyI am.fed up doing the polices job dealing with traffic post accidents as a road traffic investigator left to deal not.my job seen many deaths and many accidents not reported so stats incorrect 3 crashes last week 2 reported one not it had to be upgraded the road is appalling and dangerous and I watch artic lorry drivers and car drivers using mobiles and drive with one hand it's ridiculous and my house is less than to from.A7525192016-06-13T20:58:48.73311734Mark BradleyI live in Crocketford and along with Springholm are the only two villages on the MAIN A75 EURO ROUTE not to be bypassed. I have witnessed first hand the size and volume of some of these lorries nowadays and the speed at which they travel through the villages. We are subjected to noise and air pollution which is a great start in life for the young children who attend Springholm Primary School who are subjected to this every time they are in the playground. Surely it's not asking much for the safety and quality of life for the villagers to be improved by providing a bypass and upgrading the MAIN A75 EURO ROUTE, come on the Scottish Government and prove that you do actually care about the people of Scotland. 25192016-06-13T23:27:55.06711736Deborah mcgrorty We need this service \r\n25022016-06-14T22:25:02.07311737Darren YoungMore needs to be done to address this issue. Mental Health has always been on the backburner and never taken as seriously as physical health. Thankfully all the parties represented in the Scottish Parliament now realise this and had taken a stand to improve mental health services at the last election. We now need them all to come together and deliver on these promises.25022016-06-15T18:24:36.01711738Carol harley We need more help with mental health issues 25022016-06-16T20:58:18.78711740Kay Stephen My Mum suffered from mental health problems.25022016-06-16T23:25:20.29311741Diane StewartThird sector orgs compliment the NHS and can support people with reduced mental wellbeing and assist in reducing waiting lists permitting people who require a medicall input to be seen by professionals. Many people do not require medical input and benefit from support within a community framework. 25022016-06-17T14:21:03.95711742Ray TaylorIt should not be a postcode lottery ticket to whether you receive quick and relevant treatment for mental health issues. It should be standard practice made available throughout the country.25022016-06-18T12:50:42.15711743Stephen Chapman It's beyond belief that trucks are still regulated to 40 mph on a 100 mile journey from a major European port, it's time for change! 25192016-06-19T00:02:52.02711744William milliganPut more funding into mental health to many old and young people are suffering it should be a priority 25022016-06-19T18:26:08.5511746K BownEven if it isn't dualed on the A75 , even the two lane & one lane system would be a great improvement25192016-06-19T21:53:35.09311747Dean MadillI left my job working on the mainland mainly because of this road..it has to be the most depressing single carriageway in the UK.25192016-06-19T22:41:29.05311748Eugene Mc Elroy I have been travelling on A75 on a weekly basis & it a ridiculous 90 mile journey in a hgv,it's very stressful on a hgv driver,A55 is a pleasure to drive compared to A75,night driving has a huge impact on the driver health,people get very aggressive driving behind a hgv at 40mph,if the A75 was a motorway it could take 20 minutes off our journey times each way which is 40 minutes,l though we are trying to make travelling more enjoyable & efficient 25192016-06-19T23:31:12.70311749Shona MacgregorSomething needs to be done its a very busy road25192016-06-20T00:04:55.09711751Chris youngI work in Castle Douglas I travel from Dumfries. Why does all the heavy traffic have to go through Crocketford and Springholm is absurd. Please change this and help everyone involved.\r\nThanks25192016-06-20T11:17:46.68311755Linda KinniburghIf waiting times for physical problems were as long as the waiting times for mental health issues there would have been a revolution by now. Please pass this petition on to friends and family and encourage them to sign up. 25022016-06-20T17:16:39.08711756Carol-Ann BlaikieIf people who desperately need help get it sooner rather than later, it might reduce, suicide attempts, self harming, depression, and crime.25022016-06-20T21:50:44.5611757Ashley GrantBest of luck boys! X25192016-06-22T06:50:40.9811758Barry wilsonI travel this road twice a day to Dumfries leaving at 6 am so bang in lorry time and the near misses and just general risk to someone life isn't worth it 25192016-06-22T07:40:31.29311760Janet Turnbull I live in Dalbeattie in Dumfries and Galloway and trying to visit family in Stranraer is a nightmare, especially when the lorries are heading for the ferry to Ireland. Getting caught up in that traffic can sometimes add another 45 minutes onto your journey. NIGHTMARE 25192016-06-23T18:26:25.19711761Andy robertsWell overdue. Would make the road a lot safer. Frequent user of a75. From west midlands. 25192016-06-24T17:06:57.83311762Gordon McGheeWe have to improve the care in mental health and waiting to long for a first consultation can be damaging to health.25022016-06-25T19:50:51.92711763Brian Kennett Surely it is the time to upgrade this vital route. It is a nightmare of a road and many friends coming from England to visit us are horrified Mostth the time it takes to get to us in Wigtownshire. \r\nTheir reactions must typify what a great number of people must think and be having a detrimental effect on tourism in Dumfries and Galloway. 25192016-06-26T14:46:55.51311764Wendy GrantI totally agree the A75 should be dual carriageway, if not all of it, sections would be better than a by-pass. I live in Springholm, and I feel a by-pass isn't an option, as for the local buisness would suffer, even have to close. Great move by these youngsters for setting up this 'dual carridgeway' petition, many thanks guys!25192016-06-28T10:20:02.5711766m smith So if someone with sensitivity moves into the flat downstairs, you have to walk on eggs shells in your own property, that bill would run rough shot over a hundred years of (the average reasonable person ) case law, hopefully it will get short shrift.25462016-06-30T07:10:04.59311768Carol HattonA family member has sound sensitivity amongst other disabilities.25462016-06-30T12:53:55.64311771Craig Thomson Update \r\n\r\nThe Council will not put in sound insulation, as it's too expensive. I can't afford it either. The council's solution was to move me but the waiting list is 15 years long. I thought about claiming myself homeless but I'd probably be classed as "Making myself intentionally homeless" don't know what to do. Ear plugs and ear defenders together don't help as I'm so sensitive I can still hear it and still can't sleep. I've tried sleeping in a tent in the back garden but this doesn't work well in winter as I got the early stages of hypothermia. 25462016-06-30T18:35:58.25311773Meg DanishGovernment bodies should respect the differing needs of a diverse society. People with differences in sensory processing perceive things either more or less intensely than the average person. What the average person can or cannot perceive has no bearing whatsoever on this reality. For this reason, Mr. Thomson's individual need regarding his greater-than-average sensitivity to sound should absolutely be accommodated. 25462016-07-01T15:14:45.44311775Julie bradyI live with an autistic family member so I know how sensitive autistic people can be to certain sounds, sights and textures. More needs done for autistic people.25462016-07-02T07:01:35.8511776Gillian ArmstrongDone, good luck x25462016-07-02T11:56:35.53711778Craig ThomsonMy petition has just hit the 100 signature milestone, thank you from the bottom of my heart to everyone who has been signing. I am extremely grateful to you all.25462016-07-03T13:49:41.17311779Philip CarsonAs a Dumfries & Galloway resident originally from Northern Ireland and regular ferry user, I know only too well the problems and dangers with the A75. This is a major road linking parts of the UK together and I call on the Scottish Government, Northern Ireland Executive, UK Government and given the importance of the route to the Republic of Ireland, the Irish Government to work together to upgrade this arterial route.25192016-07-03T13:59:49.31711780Fran MilneAs a major route to the Irish Ferries, a dual carriageway is long overdue. There are too many large lorries for the road in its current state.25192016-07-03T16:45:09.4311781Daniel SherretUpgrading the A75 would be beneficial in various ways for the region, country and road users.25192016-07-03T17:08:41.211782Carolyn MearsEveryone needs to sign25192016-07-03T17:47:59.65711783Thomas ArmstrongLong past its 'best before' date. Unsafe most of its length Gretna to Stranraer.25192016-07-03T19:36:15.96711784Annie TaylorAs another person who suffers from extreme sensitivity to sound I recognise the importance of this petition.25462016-07-04T06:59:10.83311786Phil ScorerBy not upgrading it, you will knowingly cause further casualties.25192016-07-04T08:37:49.11311787GrahamNo use fussing over the EU when it takes hours to get around Scotland. Lets get internal trade going first.25192016-07-04T08:39:54.20711788FrancesAt last, that road is dangerous and very slow.25192016-07-04T17:37:12.20311790Gillian Tosh I know many people that suffer from extreme sensory issues and really struggles to manage every day things that most of us take for granted. Some sounds that we find annoying they find them painful. Could you cope with ear piercing noises day in and out that gave you severe head and earaches and multiply these sounds to at least 3 times the level. We deserve all to be treated with respect and to pass this as if it's not an issue is discrimination to human rights 25462016-07-04T18:34:29.2111791Terry CullenThis is a nightmare road which costs lives25192016-07-04T18:53:10.8711792diana carsonIncreased safety as well as a huge boost to local and west coast links across D&G would bring necessary income and development to local and national businesses.25192016-07-04T19:03:41.14711793Clare foster Mental disabilities are overlooked by everyone. This needs to change. 25462016-07-04T19:12:01.411794Jackie McConnellDangerous road with many stupid turnoffs which force late braking. Needs to be DC.25192016-07-04T19:29:26.4711795Deborah SolleyTo me this is a no brainer and most definitely long overdue. It is quite simply a matter of investment to allow real growth to happen in this region. It is scandalous that freight and business travellers must traverse such an outdated potentially dangerous road network. The lack of infrastructure in this region has been holding our development back for decades. Time to embrace rural economics and stand up for commercial social and tourist reasons to make connections and communications current and not reminiscent of the 60's!!25192016-07-04T20:03:06.3811796Jude Weddell Like the A9, the A75 is one of the main arteries for moving goods and people around Scotland, it is ridiculous that it is still largely single carriageway.25192016-07-04T20:16:48.11711797Mike WilliamsI know what it's like to live with sound sensitivity. A family member has Autism and I am also sensitive to loud noise. This can cause a great deal of anxiety and it is discriminatory for councils not to act against noise suffered by those sensitive to noise.25462016-07-04T20:27:31.5211798Amanda Jane Good luck, hope your petition gets you what you need. Happy to support you25462016-07-04T20:50:15.99711799Barry Nicholas ThomIt is way long past time that the goat track that is a euro route, the only one without dual, and the main contact with northern Ireland was dual carriageway, even the passing places are a jock two lorries block most of the passing places, causing great frustration. It is only because of speed cameras that there are not more people killed each year on the goat track!25192016-07-04T21:07:02.1411800Stephen MacdonaldIf Ireland was off the South coast of England, it would have been dual loaded many years ago...25192016-07-04T23:19:23.4811801margaretThe A75 is a euro route however it is not fit for purpose we need a dual carriage way along its whole length.25192016-07-05T02:05:09.5811802David PhillipsConsidering the port, tourist, domestic D&G business and commuter traffic this is a badly congested road that leads to frustration and some of the most reckless overtaking I have seen. D&G's transport transport link both by road and train are shocking and need improving.25192016-07-05T07:03:55.23711803Wendy ThomasWe travel the toad regularly taking our children to visit their birth mum. We may not live there but this road is often travelled.25192016-07-05T10:08:38.4911804LornaShould have been made dual years ago!25192016-07-05T13:40:58.2311805PhilSpringholm & Crocketford, the only 30 MPH sections of the A75 and in theory the slowest points of the 90 mile road, are overdue a bypass and have been given the brush off by politicians both from the Scottish and U.K. government for more than 25 years. If the villages had a low bridge (like Dunragit) to slow the traffic or from a movement of traffic point of view, the inconvenience of a recent fatal accident, a by pass may have been built. It is the seemingly invisible damage that having diesel HGV's thundering through the village, noise to tail that is destroying property and the health of the residences. So I support the call to dual the A75 as long as Springholm and Crocketford don't miss out again if money is spent on the road. 25192016-07-05T14:25:27.52711807Andrea BilbowPeople with neurodevelopmental disorders such as autism and ADHD often suffer with extreme hypersensitive hearing. This means they can hear sounds and noises others cannot hear. It also means loud noises will be hugely amplified for them and in a housing situation will cause sleeplessness, irritability, depression and from personal experience, suicidal thoughts. The failure of the council to rehouse a family member or insulate their flat led to them having a breakdown and having to seek psychiatric help. This is an unacceptable situation and should be addressed. Reasonable adjustments need to be made to allow people with disabilities to enjoy living in their own homes.25462016-07-05T17:14:36.0111808Robert Mcculloch The traffic is outrageous for just 2 lanes25192016-07-05T18:18:05.36311809JohnIn full support of the, Dual the A75 campaign. It seems ridiculous that it isn't already. But also, while we're at it, can we address driving standard in the region too?As this is as much a cause of congestion as the state of the road. The epidemic spread of the "40 or under" club is getting ridiculous.. Driving everywhere at 40mph (even in 30mph limit areas) queuing up behind tractors making it impossible to overtake even on the few long clear straights there is. On the few stretches of dual carriageway there is, using the whole stretch to overtake 1 tractor, then hitting the brakes again just after... It's painful...25192016-07-05T19:01:38.08711810Charlotte HenryPlease help decrease noise levels by providing for people who have special needs like soundproofing rules and requirements and housing needs.25462016-07-05T22:21:43.75711811Geraldine JoshiWe need better roads on this route and also trains25192016-07-05T22:25:31.28711812Anantrai JoshiThe road link is poor and covered in pot holes. It needs to a be well maintained dual carraigeway to stop people getting stuck behind tractors and lorries. A railway line would also ease commercial traffic and wear and tear of the road.25192016-07-06T04:42:28.47311813Christine We are soon moving back to D&G so we want quality roads like here in NZ!25192016-07-06T07:47:28.37311814Sheila gloverAt present.the A75 is not equal to the volume of traffic that it is required to take.\r\nIt is major route and a dangerous one to drive carrying all Ferry traffic and large haulage. By today's standards it is an antiquated stretch of road.25192016-07-06T15:10:24.59711815sue campGood luck25462016-07-06T15:18:12.72311816Jim ButcherSurly with a new hospital being built in Dumfries and not nearer Stranraer priority must be a fast road between the two.25192016-07-06T20:26:42.9811817Rae smithStop discriminating people with disabilities25462016-07-06T22:57:49.1311818Yasmin RaphaelPlease implement practical solutions such as soundproofing floors as standard practice in shared residential buildings, and raise awareness in relation to the suffering caused to people with conditions causing noise sensitivity. Also bring in more compassionate legislation to help people more quickly who may have loud mentally ill neighbours, so that both parties don't have to wait many months for action to be taken by a mental health assessment team.25462016-07-07T22:35:13.6911820Mrs C McKeanWe have waited 30 years for a by-pass for Springholm and bought our house on the strength of it. Good luck with the campaign, the A75 presently is in a shocking state. It would make total sense to have a dual carriageway!25192016-07-07T23:18:58.1811821David ReeksLet's make a change25462016-07-08T12:26:41.44711822F.Milligan.happy to petition for this long overdue upgrade to the A 75.25192016-07-09T11:38:04.65711823Lorraine CranImagine being able to hear your neighbours speaking in your house. Imagibe never getting a good nights sleep and so feeling at the end of your tether. This was what life was like for my brother due to his heightened hearing ability a facet of his autism. The resulting stress may have contributed to his heart failure25462016-07-09T18:51:07.40311824Sandra Parkerthe A75 needs to be dual carriageway all the way to Cairnryan , its a lot busier than I have ever seen the A925192016-07-10T14:37:29.1611826Matthew Rolfe It needs done ASAP so DG council get something done about it please 25192016-07-11T10:40:22.82711827Craig ThomsonThank you to everyone who has been signing. We have reached the 200 milestone. I am very grateful for your signatures and supportive comments :-)25462016-07-11T15:01:36.13311828Sandra GormanDualling the A75 is essential for the area - some investment in the economic future of this forgotten corner of Scotland is very overdue.25192016-07-11T16:04:12.37311829Doreen mcmaho I use A75 every day ..and it would be great if it was upgraded..as the amount of deaths on this road is horrendous.25192016-07-11T16:23:48.25311830Stuart DrysdaleSooner rather than later, can't believe it hasn't been done already. Doing the upgrade will save lives 25192016-07-11T16:42:34.53711831Clare mcmillanThis road is a disgrace and dangerous to all users and not at all suitable for the the HGVS that travel on it.25192016-07-11T16:43:08.00711832Wendy SingletonMaking the A75 into a dual carriageway will save many lives as too many die due to bad road surface, sharp bends, and impatient drivers stuck behind slow moving lorries.25192016-07-11T16:57:39.86311833Calum TroupDangerous road!25192016-07-11T17:06:14.411834Maureen BallAn A75 upgrade is long overdue!25192016-07-11T17:07:23.7611835Logan SteeleThe game bird shooting industry have had enough time to get thier house in order and have consciously chosen not to.25982016-07-11T18:04:23.65711836Colin WilsonThe A75 desperately needs to be upgraded to dual carriageway.25192016-07-11T18:38:34.79711837Wilma EvansBypass road at Dunragit is great should be like that all the way.25192016-07-11T18:50:22.73711838ThomasThe A75 requires a Major upgrade25192016-07-11T19:20:09.47711839Kevin b murrayThe quicker the better. 25192016-07-11T19:49:20.60311840Crina MihetToo many people have lost their lives so this project should become a priority for the Scottish Parliament.25192016-07-11T19:54:14.74711841Daniel MihetThis is not a luxury, it is common sense and in the long run will become an asset for the region, it will change people's lives, it will facilitate access to fundamental services like D & G Royal Infirmary, Fire Services, etc. 25192016-07-11T19:59:53.54311843Miss Shona H GilmourI am a daily user of the A75 and where possible I avoid travelling at peak times(when boat has docked!) This is due to heavy volumes of lorries travelling in a convoy and there is very little possibility of over taking safely. Also I have on occasions pulled over to allow the heavy goods vehicle's to pass! Yes sitting at 60mph with a lorry sitting on your rear bumper is not funny! The A75 has a high volume of traffic and it still has vast areas which are like country roads and not wide enough for the vehicles of the 21st century, please consider our pleas. 25192016-07-11T20:30:19.56711844Pat corrieAn upgrade is long overdue. Springholm and Crocketford are the only 2 villages not to have been bypassed.25192016-07-11T21:05:31.82311845John BrookI agree that the A75 needs a serious upgrade but is a dual carriageway achievable. Having driven down it a few times recently I would have thought that alternate direction overtaking lanes (such as the Dunragit by-pass) is a much more cost effective solution as long stretches have a wide enough verge.25192016-07-11T21:10:12.42711846Tracey Riley I hope this petition works for you and you get what you're after from it, I've also shared this link so I hope u get the signatures you're needing.\r\nAll the best xx25462016-07-11T21:36:20.45311847Drew SloanA75 upgrade to dual carriageway should be a strategic SG priority to promote economic activity in SW Scotland.25192016-07-11T22:56:12.78711848martin appletonthe A75 needs to be dual carraige its strangling the economy of south west scotland through poor transport links, and need a urgent upgrade from stranraer to the M625192016-07-11T23:10:36.3511849James ClarkHow about doing the A77 as well. The sheer amount of HGV's on both roads is terrible.25192016-07-12T06:53:46.0611850Margaret NwvinsThis proposal is long overdue. The A75 is not only a major transport route, it can become matter of life or death for patients having to travel 75 miles from Stranraer to our nearest major hospital in Dumfries25192016-07-12T07:29:26.01711851Tricia PattersonI am 42 and even my late father would say the A75 badly needed upgraded to dual if not motorway! This road is no longer fit for use it has claimed far too many lives and destroyed too many families. I didn't realise that by the time a road gets upgraded it is already 10 years out of date! I learned this when I worked for a Civil Engineering firm back when they were upgrading the A74 to M74 I was young and even then it shocked me. Our roads should be safe and well maintained it's 2016 for goodness sake but yet we still live in the dark ages..why do we pay hefty taxes etc..HOW MANY LIVES DOES THIS ROAD HAVE TO CLAIM BEFORE SOMETHING IS DONE?25192016-07-12T09:57:49.70711852Karen DunbarEvery time my family travel this route there's always an incident, needs sorting asap25192016-07-12T11:07:08.85311853AndyThe industrial slaughter of our wonderful wildlife, both legally protected and otherwise, by the shooting industry has to end, it is a national disgrace that shames us.\r\n25982016-07-12T11:17:47.1611854M. WalshThere is no reason not to regulate this form of hunting. Licencing it, as fishing is, seems to make sense. I suspect it only avoided this in the past because of class bigotry. Usually, it's the very wealthy who shoot birds and the poor who fish. 25982016-07-12T12:17:18.911855Donald McPhillimyAbout time.25982016-07-12T12:20:16.8711856Helen SmithThis kind of legislation is long overdue. We urgently need to have better laws to protect our raptors, mountain hares and other moorland wildlife. The current situation is a disgrace.25982016-07-12T12:20:52.3711857Ben Darvill Change is necessary as the status quo is unacceptable. Licencing seems worth a try and is a more moderate step than an outright ban.25982016-07-12T12:49:58.2811858Adrian Stapleton The killing of any wildlife for sport is wrong really 25982016-07-12T13:14:49.96311859ClaireScottish wildlife, specifically beautiful birds of prey are being killed to enable gamebirds to be kept alive long enough to be shot - this is senseless25982016-07-12T13:31:08.90311860Liz RollingsRaptors were here before driven grouse shoots. Shooting game for fun is not acceptable by any civilised society and trapping so called pests, harming the environment is in no one's interest .25982016-07-12T13:40:59.20311861Peter NashWhilst not living in Scotland I am appalled at the increasing numbers of birds of prey being caught, poisoned, trapped and killed in both Scotland and England by so-called guardians of our countryside. We must all act together to do all we can to stop these cruel and illegal practices. 25982016-07-12T13:41:43.16311862M. RannerTime to regulate this shooting and ensure that not only the gamebird shooting but its effects such as bird of prey persecution and mountain hare shooting are stopped and incorporated into the regulation that Estates and game keepers must comply with.25982016-07-12T13:58:54.27311863Ed GLENWRIGHT For years the unregulated shooting estates have caused widespread habitat destruction and furthermore persecuted any other species that threaten grouse. The industry (I use that term loosely) needs radical changes forcing upon them to eliminate widespread wildlife crimes. At the moment as it stands the nearly extinct Hen Harrier is a national embarrassment. There is no space in a civilized society for the killing of any wild birds including grouse. 25982016-07-12T15:08:55.95711864Anne DickIf shooting estates will not stop persecuting birds of prey voluntarily - then someone must stop them!25982016-07-12T15:21:55.56711865Yvonne WatsonTime to get houses in order, we need to stop senseless killing of these wild animals 25982016-07-12T15:35:57.50711866Ron MurrayWe MUST move forward with regulation leading to banning of all raptor and game bird hunting by any means.25982016-07-12T16:23:01.96711867P EdwardsReform is long overdue - how bleak our so-called wild areas have become - burnt empty hills and empty skies. All to support the interests of a greedy minority..25982016-07-12T16:47:08.50711868Simon TuckerThis is hugely important. The shooting industry is currently a hive of illegal activity and environmental vandalism. It must be properly controlled. As usual, Scotland should show the rest of the UK the way.25982016-07-12T17:47:09.43711869John MPosterity will judge us culpable if we don't get this right.25982016-07-12T17:51:49.0811871j entwistlemake scotland look beautiful not dead no more extinction of species25982016-07-12T18:03:50.5111872John BlackThe hunting industry have had considerable opportunities to deal with the widespread issues of illegal activity and environmental damage caused by some estates. Whatever efforts they may have made to resolve this have been ineffective and a regulatory framework with proportional enforcement and penalties for staff and owners should be now be implemented to mitigate and reverse the damage that gamebird hunting is causing to Scotland's natural heritage. 25982016-07-12T18:24:43.83311873Adam CraigThis nonsense goes back to the Victorian period when rich idle aristocrats and others bought these estates (many of us say stolen) which resulted in the mass extermination of birds of prey etc. Its time to put these people in their place and bring about a huge restoration ( particularly forestry) of our country.25982016-07-12T19:08:27.42711874Mrs E M E PollockPlease make this road safe!25192016-07-12T19:22:36.3111875Kenny KortlandOn the grouse moors south of Inverness I have found, and continue to find, numerous examples of bad and illegal practices. The estates show a flagrant disregard for the law and the public interest. It is an utter embarrassment to Scotland. \r\n25982016-07-12T19:22:58.9211876Catherine DuncanIf any Raptor is found killed , the estates should loose their license permanently, 25982016-07-12T19:53:34.9811877Peter HarrisonTime to stop this minority of people wandering round the countryside with guns in pursuit of their sick sport and making "no go areas" for the rest of us,25982016-07-12T20:11:45.14711878G WalkerGame shooting causes so many damaging impacts and yet it has no regulation. Self-regulation has failed time and time again, what have good estates to fear?\r\n25982016-07-12T20:30:09.98311879tom rossNot against game bird shooting,but the illegal shooting of any protected species must stop and these people must be the same as us,live within the laws of the country25982016-07-12T20:42:54.70311880Nicola PenfordGrouse moors are sterile killing fields and the imposition of a minority elite sport on a landscape scale is not acceptable 25982016-07-12T20:58:59.41711881Nick CarterScotland's chance to lead the way again.\r\n25982016-07-12T21:10:52.35711882Nick MoyesVoluntary measures to manage moorland for grouse shooting and for protected birds species have clearly not worked, and birds of prey in Scotland continue to be unlawfully shot and poisoned. Many disappear on moorland estates that are managed intensively for shooting. A licencing system seems a fair approach to ensuring compliance with country laws, offering a clear and obvious penalty for shooting estates if evidence of crimes against protected wildlife are both demonstrated and proven.25982016-07-12T21:15:14.16311883Michael demainAll they have to do is stop breaking the law, stop killing birds of prey25982016-07-12T21:18:04.92711884Julie BellAngus is a beautiful county, yet its hills are scarred, its wildlife 'managed' by brutal methods, walkers hounded by gamekeepers and biodiversity is but a dream. My heart breaks when raptors, mountain hares, harriers and the land itself are sacrificed in a scorched earth policy for grouse and pheasant. 25982016-07-12T21:59:03.79311885Ian FordWhy is no-one researching impact of Pheasants in Capercaillie habitat? Almost every forest has Pheasants and there will surely be a high risk of disease transfer amongst other risks.25982016-07-12T22:19:16.98311886Shiela HowatLong overdue for the amount of traffic, especially HGV vehicles.25192016-07-12T22:26:11.3211887Shirley BroganThose involved in the gamebird hunting have no interest at all in cleaning up their act. Therefore legislation will have to be pursued whilst we still have some wildlife left. 25982016-07-12T23:09:03.7811888Richard EbbsWhat happens in Scotland affects raptor numbers in the whole of the UK.25982016-07-13T02:05:33.81311889Robert YatesScotland is missing out on the enormous financial benefits that wildlife tourism would provide.\r\nThe shooting fraternity repeatedly tell us that the Scottish economy would collapse but for their shooting estates. The truth is that they monopolise great areas of land, employ very few people and persecute our wildlife to extinction.\r\nIt's time for change!25982016-07-13T04:08:51.7511890N FindlayGreedy landowners cannot be allowed to continue to destroy hill land habitats and wildlife for short term gain. Enough is enough.25982016-07-13T06:13:05.0811891Michael CavanaghI would support a complete ban on driven grouse shooting as well as the slaughter of mountain hare25982016-07-13T07:29:49.3911892MaryI may not live in Scotland, but as a visitor to see wildlife there, I contribute to the economy, and have a just right to have my views taken into account.25982016-07-13T08:07:10.92711893David ForsythI walk regularly in the Glens of Aberdeenshire and Angus as I have done for some 50 plus years and can testify to seeing our countryside move to a monoculture of driven bird shoots to the detriment of all and anything that is thought to be impinging on the profit of this industry. The land is being scarred also by the abundance of roads being built. In so many places the land now has an almost urban waseland feel to it. This must stop now if our future generations are to know and enjoy anything of the Scottish countryside and its heritage25982016-07-13T08:14:55.5211894Simon BrookeThere are no large natural moorlands in Scotland. The natural treeline is above the top of our highest mountains, and Norway, further north than us, has forest above the peak of Ben Nevis. We've lost our forest because we've lost our climax predators, but muirburn and other destructive practices related to 'game bird' management prevent the recovery of upland forest.25982016-07-13T08:36:18.911895Andy LawsonAs a very regular hillwalker, I frequently stumble across snap traps, snares, larson traps, etc. on grouse moors - some with dead wildlife. I have come across dead foxes piled up (possibly caught by dogs) and have been approached suspiciously on a number of occasions and questioned as to exactly where I was going, where I had been, who I was, etc by gamekeepers. I have found animals strung up as an apparent deterrent to other animals. I have also found suspicious carcasses left out within cage taps which may, or may not, have been poisoned. It is time Scotland sorted out this problem of estate owners and gamekeepers having almost free reign to kill whatever they desire in the name of grouse management. Two areas that are worst for traps are Strathdon in Aberdeenshire and the Scottish Borders.25982016-07-13T09:10:26.01311896Alex MilneThe environment minister has made it clear that due to the employment it provides, she is willing to accept the destruction of raptors, mountain hares and other species that go hand in hand with the so called sport and the people who are employed with it. This is not acceptable to me.25982016-07-13T09:14:20.68711897Karen Allan Rewild Scotland, properly!\r\n25982016-07-13T09:55:37.84711898Ronnie GrahamI have absolutely no problem with game shooting where it is done sustainably and without the persecution of raptors and protected mammals. But it's time for change especially on Scotland's grouse moors. 25982016-07-13T09:59:34.05311899Julie ChildsThe UK's remaining countryside and wildlife needs urgent protection. It's important in its own right and we also owe this to future generations. It isn't our to destroy!25982016-07-13T11:01:12.74711900Chris BarberI know from discussions with many keepers and those involved with shooting, that there is a significant antipathy towards many raptor species, and that with some, there is a level of arrogance towards the legal protection system that is unacceptable. I believe a licencing sys\r\ntem would be a fair way forward for all parties.25982016-07-13T11:15:13.92711901Lyn Ibbitson-ElksI visited Speyside in early April, and we visited the area where a vast no. of mountain hares had very recently been slaughtered. I had a lovely time but this was the only area where we saw nothing - no mammals, no birds. Nothing. It was very sad. In total I saw one mountain hare, a dot on a hillside. It makes no sense to me why anyone would want to end the life of a beautiful creature. The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. (Edmund Burke)25982016-07-13T12:21:21.28711902George MurdoI spent quite a few years living in the Angus Glens and was outraged by some of the practises I saw. I came across lines of snares that had not been checked for months with the dried up fur and bones of animals still present in the traps. I found a similar situation existed with spring and fenn traps, some placed legally and others illegally. The burning practises also left a lot to be desired as they ignored both the weather conditions i.e. wind strength and direction which often resulted in fires going out of control and fire engines called. They also often ignored ecologically sensitive areas which were supposed to be a part of the protected environment. In addition, given both the history and the fact that many bird of prey territories continue to be unoccupied, it appears that raptor persecution continues basically unhindered. Licensing would ensure adherence to democratically sanctioned laws which applies to our country, with penalties commensurate with the offence. Voluntary adherence appears to have failed and we are now at a critical level as far as hen harriers go, and might also be approaching a time when mountain hares are also endangered. If no law breaking on behalf of the shooting estates and lobby is intended then I see no reason why they, also, should not support this petition. If they do object one must wonder why?25982016-07-13T13:13:40.89311903Tracey SmithLet's get the moors licensed and independently monitored. This way the shooters can carry on their sport and their conservation measures, monitoring can be carried out to make sure they stick to the rules and licenses can be removed if they break the law. At the moment too much native wildlife is destroyed in large numbers to keep alive one alien species that is just going to be shot and make the land owners a lot of money . Surely this is a win win situation for everyone25982016-07-13T13:45:29.7911904PeterI visit the uplands around Speyside to walk for recreation and I witness first-hand the awful effects of grouse moor management wherever I go. The landscape is empty and impoverished as far as the eye can see, devoid of life and scarred by burning, road building and fences . White markers pinpoint countless grit stations and I come across more mechanical traps than I do wildlife of any form. It seems inconceivable that this barren land should be part of a National Park. A desperate situation that is getting worse and something has to change. I live in hope we might see a meaningful response to this petition.25982016-07-13T14:03:04.8711905Mark JardineAs the main artery between Northern Ireland and the UK, we must ensure that traffic is able to flow freely and the artery does not become blocked.25192016-07-13T14:19:44.54311906Eoin MckeeverA dangerous road with lorries having to sit at 40mph for 100 miles. Drivers become frustrated and take unessessary risks.25192016-07-13T15:04:40.1611907Jonathan StoneI am told that Scottish signatures are much more welcome than those from other parts of the UK. Although currently living in Wales, I am Scottish by birth and expect my signature to be given full weight.25982016-07-13T15:15:58.96711909Mr Greer Hart, seniorI am a member of the John Muir Trust, Scottish Wildlife Trust, RSPB donor, Butterfly Conservation, Buglife, Plantlife, Scotland for Animals, Animal Concern Scotland, Badger Trusts, CPRE, and along with friends own land on which we protect Hen Harriers, Buzzards. This has given me plenty of knowledge as to what is going on in our Scottish countryside and in the rest of the UK. I am also a member of many international conservation and animal welfare organisations, which also has given me a world view of the cruel and deleterious effects of hunting on a beleaguered wildlife, of which many face extinction. The killing of Birds of Prey has shown just how lacking in concern our whole law enforcement and judicial processes have shown, with a feeble response to the poisoning, snaring, trapping and shooting of any creature that may affect grouse numbers. There is also the anomaly of large areas of land in Scotland being owned by outsiders (individuals, companies, syndicates), who have treated the environment of Scotland and the rest of the UK, as a playground for blood sports. The claims made for being good conservationists by shooting estates is nonsense, as are their being important employers and providers of wholesome food. I am sure that, if given the chance and the resources, there are plenty of experienced and well-qualified people and organisations, who could draw up a national plan for the Scottish countryside, involving its restoration and in creating better paid employment rather than the seasonal and poorly paid ones at present. A great explosion to turn Scotland into a massive attraction for humane tourism, and employment in industries that would add higher value to the economy For too long, the hunting stranglehold has held Scotland and its politicians in a vice grip, making them reluctant to change, using egregious and excessive powers of persuasion to influence what can live and die on the landscape. 25982016-07-13T15:26:42.78311910Bruce BuswellSo much of the landscape looks like a patchy heather desert as a result of burning. It's so far from natural in the National Parks25982016-07-13T15:53:26.29311911Fiona ClarkIt's ridiculous that there are 2 villages between Ireland and the Continent that vehicles have to travel through and the are both in Dumfries and Galloway. For the main Euroroute that's neither safe or right.25192016-07-13T18:22:26.6411913Geoff SimonsThe effect of raptor persecution and the sale of game meat with levels of pesticides and lead potentially well above the legal limits for non game food affects people on both sides of the border.\r\nI hope that the Scottish Government take note of sound scientific research and the continuing illegal persecution of raptors and the continuing faliure of the game shooting industry to effectively regulate itself to come to the correct decision.\r\nI hope that the British government soon review their policies in England as well!25982016-07-13T21:34:24.27711914AmandaI'm sick of hearing how the rich are killing our wild life . Yes ours , we share this great country with and it all deserves a safe home . Rich killing our fox are birds of pray just so thay can shoot or ripe it up . I say NO MORE25982016-07-13T22:52:34.73311915mark hillIn the UK you need a game license available at main post offices why people just jump on a band wagon with out doing any research is unbelievable 25982016-07-14T06:39:00.79311916Matt brakeI live in new Zealand where we have a fish and game bird license. This seems to work very well and all party's are happy. All proceeds from the license go back into the well being of the sport ie protecting and or inhancing breeding habitat. Works fine and is a very small cost for a year's worth of fun.\r\n25982016-07-14T08:26:57.47711917Mark WardNeeds sorting!25982016-07-14T09:27:08.51711918JohnnyBirksI visit Scotland frequently for both work and holidays, and I value its wildlife, and especially its predators. There is an urgent need to allow protected predatory birds and mammals to thrive in the absence of illegal persecution linked to game shooting.25982016-07-14T09:31:17.56311920Alison GreggansLong overdue and imperative for improving a habitat that's fit for a whole suite of wildlife not just a single species, shot to line pockets of societies elite.25982016-07-14T09:40:36.52311921Fiona GuestA licensing system should be welcomed by all, managing land for game is, as we are often told by interested parties, a skilled profession. Skilled professions that impact on a wide range of people should be happy to be licenced and to have their professionalism endorsed. Those who do not behave responsibly should have their rights restricted. A licencing system would provide a framework for this and ensure that the species of plant and animal found on sporting estates that do not directly benefit the estate have improved, reasonable, enforceable protection.25982016-07-14T09:54:38.6511922Anna MacfieGamebird hunting is a bloodsport and should be licensed to control persecution of red and other grouse as well as the wild raptors which naturally prey on them.25982016-07-14T10:12:49.14711923Rose WilliamsVital for the future of Scottish wildlife. I visit Scotland frequently and value it's wildlife greatly. However finding dead raptors and other wildlife in areas of shoot is terrible and something must be done soon to redress the balance.25982016-07-14T11:34:07.78311924Lorna RamsayShocking! Good luck!25462016-07-14T11:42:25.28311925alan millarI hope you get the help & support you need a.s.a.p.\r\n25462016-07-14T13:50:33.83311926James IrvineThere is an urgent need to allow protected predatory birds and mammals to thrive in the absence of illegal persecution linked to game shooting.25982016-07-14T14:29:31.32711927Thomas David DickThe issue of criminality on scottish shooting estates is a blot on the whole of Scotland's reputation...this is the very least that needs to be done...it also needs to be enforced, truly without "fear or favour", as a matter of urgency.25982016-07-14T18:54:08.55711929Eileen McCannWe need to shift from indulging the rich and impoverishing the environment, to providing a rich and diverse natural environment for the many. Time for this to end now.25982016-07-14T21:01:45.38711930Sorcha MackayMy son has sound sensitivity and so I understand this is a genuine serious issue. Good luck. 25462016-07-14T22:59:19.69311931Matthew CrightonThis needs to be done to bring Scotland into the 21st century25982016-07-15T07:33:08.98711932Gary WattBarbaric and serves no real purpose.25982016-07-15T08:40:18.31311934Scott RogersA licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland is absolutely essential. This small, and highly privileged sector has too long been allowed to regulate itself, despite disgraceful evidence showing a direct correlation between gamebird hunting and the illegal killing of birds of prey and other highly vulnerable species within Scotland. Licensing would increase accountability within the sector and allow for effective enforcement for crimes against endangered species. There should be no tolerance for the senseless killing of birds of prey, and the gamebird industry's complicity in the destruction of these birds has proven that they are unable to abide by even the most basic conservation goals. 25982016-07-15T09:16:32.3311936Colin LambI strongly believe that Scotland's birds of prey and wildlife should take priority over the practice of hunting of gamebirds and regulations should tightly control the practice and reduce the impact that it has to a minimum. 25982016-07-15T10:03:29.55311938Black SheepKilling raptors is inexcusable - greed and ignorance are to blame. Education has failed - now is the time for tough legislation and enforcement.25982016-07-15T10:20:14.411939Richard MorrisToday a country that is famous for leading the world in human rights, France was attacked by terrorists.Shame on them. France legalized ACI in 1810 becoming the world leader in human rights. today, Scotland and other countries that still make ACI a crime, lag behind in the field of human rights. Please vote to make difference.25412016-07-15T10:24:37.93711940Gordon HolmRaptor killing on game estates is currently at scandalous levels25982016-07-15T10:29:30.13711941Gail StirlingRaptors are essential as part of our healthy ecosystem. Our Government has a duty to protect all of the rich and diverse wildlife that our beautiful country is so famous for.25982016-07-15T10:41:14.1211942Ric LanderSelf regulation is not working.25982016-07-15T11:03:29.26711943Paul CoulthardWildlife Tourism brings significant income to Scotland and raptors are high on visitors' "Must see" lists. Illegal persecution of these magnificent birds damages this sector, quite aside from breaking the law. Bring in regulation - it is long overdue.25982016-07-15T14:31:26.05711944Bruce WilsonKeep fighting!25982016-07-15T15:33:25.54711945Ranald Nicolson MathesonI recently handed in a dead buzzard to the Police HQ in Dingwall, it appeared to be a suspicious death. They still, after six days, have not taken a statement.25982016-07-15T15:36:04.7411946Debbie ShepherdBan immediately25982016-07-15T16:19:17.96711947Stuart GrahamThis is an area which is long overdue more rigorous oversight and regulation. Licences should be revoked where malpractice is found.25982016-07-15T16:26:21.91311948Gregor DavidsonMon the Raptors.\r\nClever girl.25982016-07-15T17:27:00.08311950Donald StevensonNot a crow, raptor or gull to be seen in upper Glen Isla on a recent visit25982016-07-15T17:51:51.80711951Diane LittlejohnLong overdue. These are magnificent birds, why shouldn't they be able to survive without persecution.25982016-07-15T17:59:12.4111952Steven blackleyI shoot regularly but even I can see that SOME big estates need to sort them selves out and they ruin it for the ones that do it the right way 25982016-07-15T18:04:12.83311953C. McLeodSadly, the continuing level of wildlife crime and mismanagement of our uplands show that a new approach is needed to encourage estates to adopt legal and sustainable management practices. 25982016-07-15T19:23:35.94311954Lawrie KingWhy destroy such beautiful birds for the sake of a few people who pay to shoot other birds?25982016-07-15T22:46:46.6611955Mick MarquissOur moorlands in Scotland are too precious to be trusted to narrow vested interest. We need proper regulation to protect the public interest.25982016-07-16T10:54:17.1311957Michael GrovesTime & time again we read of illegal activities by those involved in the game bird shooting industry with little being done to deal with those crimes. This outdated so-called sporting pursuit which only survives on the destruction of other wildlife needs to be regulated with appropriate sanctions available to keep it within the law. 25982016-07-16T11:39:39.90711958Amy BrownPlease stop this, it seems like no matter how many times these people are caught and evidence is produced they just continue to flout law and decency and continue along their merry (murdering) way.25982016-07-16T14:17:08.47311959Tim AspdenRaptors are often at the top of the food chain and may therefore give an indication of ecosystem health. Scotland's wildlife is not only intrinsically valuable but contributes to rural economies and has an ambassadorial role for the nation.25982016-07-16T16:27:57.83311960Jack RiggallLong overdue. I await the result of this petition with interest.25982016-07-16T19:48:33.56711961Ann InghamWe have the same problem in Wales. I was lucky enough to see a pair of Hen Harriers passing through heading for safer territory.25982016-07-17T00:00:38.58711962Frances JonesPeople tell me their dogs have been poisoned eating bait put down for birds of prey in big shooting estates near Dunbar25982016-07-17T09:18:24.0811963Raymond Henry HoggGame shooting interests have surely had more than enough time to put their house in order regarding raptor persecution. How much longer do we need to watch the continual flouting of wildlife legislation by a privileged few?25982016-07-17T09:38:22.48311964Jacqui WelshThe way the land is managed by Game Estates is not acceptable in a modern Scotland. Moor burning is terrible for the environment and their attitude to wildlife is unforgiving and unforgivable.25982016-07-17T09:44:29.02311965Ciaran CroninLike any industry with the potential for significant social and environmental damage, the shooting industry needs to be regulated for the benefit of ALL the people of Scotland. You have a wonderful, beautiful country with warm hearted people and incredible wildlife - you dont deserve the stain of the widespread and illegal killing of birds of prey and other species. 25982016-07-17T09:53:55.6911966David JonesIndustrial farming of our uplands denies a place for key wildlife species and must be curtailed.25982016-07-17T10:29:58.91311967Christine NicolettiI suffer depression, anxiety and panic. I live in Glasgow. I recently had my medication changed and am struggling with side effects. Anxiety through the roof. I have struggled with depression, anxiety and panic for many years. Was on another medication until in began to fail in March of this year. Then the search for a different medication started.25022016-07-17T10:49:57.35311968Phil ShawThose committing wildlife crimes - and their employers - should not be permitted to continue hunting. A licensing system would help achieve what voluntary measures have patently failed to do: to eliminate raptor persecution in Scotland. 25982016-07-17T20:29:24.53311971Colin NormanIts the LAW25982016-07-17T21:48:22.93311972Michael StewardDriven shoots disturb all manner of wildlife. Any animal that may be considered a predator could be killed on the drive, or location of breeding site recorded & come back later to control the predator. Birds of prey are also sometimes shot flying over the guns intended for grouse. This "Victorian Sport" is out dated and should be stopped. 25982016-07-18T09:47:15.68711973Claire SmithGame it's shooting is a business and should be subject to regulation, with consequences & deterrents in place to prevent environmental damage occurring. I work with several excellent estates in Perthshire whose reputation suffers when persecution continues on other estates. Licensing should help raptors and estates and increased transparency should increase trust and working relationships between estates, conservationists and the wider public.25982016-07-18T11:14:52.87711974Frank hughesIts about time something was done to save our wild \r\nLife.25982016-07-18T13:46:03.211975Alan ShortDriven grouse shooting,for the pleasure of killing, seems completely incompatible with most modern views on the need for empathy with and respect for wild birds and animals.The Scottish government needs to investigate alternative economic uses for upland grouse moors with a view to banning this activity completely.25982016-07-18T16:11:08.89311976James ReynoldsSome estates have made great strides in terms of cleaning up their practices and 'going straight', and should be rightly commended and recognised for their efforts in this regard. But there are still many that continue to undertake illegal activities in pursuit of ever larger bags, particularly of driven grouse. Those who do this are still of a significant number (certainly significant enough to have negative national population-level impacts on some species such as golden eagles and hen harriers) , and their actions tarnish the industry as a whole. Regulation of the sort proposed here would provide a simple solution to this problem. Those estates which operate within the law have absolutely nothing to fear. At the same time such regulation would provide a rapid and significant boost to the industry's image - something of which it is in dire need. Indeed, the industry itself should surely welcome such proposals as a progressive step to improving public trust and its working relationships with many other sectors that have an interest in good custodianship of the countryside.25982016-07-18T16:29:29.611977Sandra M TaylorIt's time that game shooting is subjected to regulations as some estates seem not to have conservation interests in place at all. To an outsider it seems as if there's a lot of cruelty in estate management these days and it has to stop.25982016-07-18T16:50:15.6511978james mcguiganabout time!!!25982016-07-18T17:16:50.02711979Andrew SandemanThe vast majority of European countries require estates to be licenced - why don't we? Is it because we are the most 'feudal' country in Europe?25982016-07-18T17:31:41.27711980John McInnesIt is essential to stop raptor persecution on driven Grouse moors. A clear financial deterrent or custodial sentencing must be applied to persistent offending estates, their owners and appropriate staff. Licensing monitoring and review on an annual basis should be done and offending estates be subject to licence loss if found to be involved in raptor destruction25982016-07-18T18:01:54.3311981Mark Wright.Good move done for rapter group you have my full support.25982016-07-18T18:08:27.76711982Yvonne SlaterI am opposed to all hunting, but if people must for sound reasons then it should be tightly regulated and controlled.25982016-07-18T19:29:35.1411983R Stuart CraigWhy can the people concerned in policing the Estates not get satisfaction when lawbreakers are brought to court....can justice be bought??? 25982016-07-18T21:50:18.11311984John MansonAll responsible Estates should have nothing to fear, and should benefit in the long term.25982016-07-19T06:25:24.43711985Erica HudsonRegulation is needed to protect wildlife from irresponsible and malicious acts.25982016-07-19T10:02:25.85711986Valerie ForbesOver the last 10 years I have noticed a decline in variety of species and fall of numbers of each species when I have been on bird and general nature walks in the Lothians and Borders. Some further conservation measures are needed and monitoring in the most affected areas. Good and well managed Estates have nothing to worry about under stricter licensing laws. 25982016-07-19T14:41:44.57311987Claire Druett Please do. 25982016-07-19T20:43:34.4211989Allan BrownThis is the 21st century yet huge swathes of the Scottish countryside are misused for the continuing Victorian pleasure of killing for fun which has major impacts upon other wildlife that dares to impact upon this so-called sport, as well as other environmental consequences. Such activity needs to be strictly controlled and the promoters of it educated as to how to better use their land for the benefit of a greater range of wildlife and the tourist benefits this would bring to local economies. A shooting for fun based economy is no longer acceptable.25982016-07-19T21:40:39.62311990Vicky ColeI have seen so many images of slaughtered Mountain hares, Foxes and even Lynx and Eagles, trapped, snared, poisoned or shot to keep the preserved landscape of the shooting estates, which receive a lot of subsidies yet often devastates the wildlife which attracts tourism and maintains part of the great reputation of this country. Many have been impressed by the recent actions of politicians here to maintain the Hunting Act yet still wildlife is persecuted for country sports, something has to be done to counteract this25982016-07-19T22:19:24.0111991Steven blackley As a keen shooting man and bird ringer I think it's time some of the shooting fraternity come out of the dark ages it's ruining all the good work the decent people who manage shoots do 25982016-07-21T07:33:32.3711993Alexander KeithMake a voluntary licence a condition of receiving state (including EU) subsidy. The estate has to provide evidence of compliance with conditions and provide evidence of their efforts to improve biodiversity and offset negative effects of shooting land management. Have a system of random inspections. This move is long overdue.25982016-07-21T09:02:27.3911994Paul HaireLong overdue. Get it done Parliament.25982016-07-21T09:13:09.40711995Sandra KeithEnough is enough. 25982016-07-21T09:50:05.23311996Stuart WilshawThe time for talking is over, time to walk the walk.25982016-07-21T12:32:16.24711997Duncan Orr-EwingRegulation of gamebird hunting in Scotland to protect the public interest is now long overdue. This would simply bring us into line with common practice in other European countries.25982016-07-21T18:30:21.2611998Adam CraigIts time to take this country out of the Victorian era and have a modern look at how our countryside is run. For too long a small percentage of our population have powers and control away above their numbers. Namely landowners and farmers. We pay huge amounts of our taxes subsidising this group and it is time that the rest of us are heard.25982016-07-21T20:36:52.0411999David ParkinsonSad thing is that money talks. Grouse shooting brings in millions.25982016-07-22T07:42:15.19712001Steven GillespieSustainable rural development can never be achieved in Scotland until land is in the hands of communities rather than the landed elite. Hobby landscapes are no longer acceptable and land owners should be charged for preventing a range of ecosystem services that could benefit society. A license system is a good start.25982016-07-22T09:03:33.8812002Maria Dawn Hemingway Politicians need to be aware that the general public care about wildlife and look to them to ensure it is maintained and protected.25982016-07-22T10:42:48.5912003G ChronowiczTime for decisive action.25982016-07-22T11:40:13.5112004Stuart RiversRaptor persecution and indiscriminate poisoning persists on and around shooting estates.Self-policing clearly doesn't work, it is time for licensing and closer monitoring of estate practices.25982016-07-22T14:51:48.49312006yvonne AllanI was seeing a psychology senior charge nurse weekly for severe depression. The service was cutback. Now if lucky see him every two weeks. I am lucky to have these appointments. I know other people who are waiting months for first appointment. 25022016-07-22T14:52:03.53712007Megan McKeracherWe need to do more about eradicating the stigma that still surrounds mental health and really push for the promotion of charitable organisations within communities to help people receive some form of support while on these lengthy waiting lists. I volunteer for a local mental health organisation and we all do our very best in helping people stay connected within their community, which is so important for those who are isolated. I have also my own lived experience of mental health and I was very very fortunate to have a great support network of family, friends, work and therapy to help me manage my mental health, but what was most important is that I was the final piece of the jigsaw in order for me to get better, because I wanted to. It's really quite sad that people who are in complete despair with their mental health condition that may not have the support of family, work or friends, therefore become isolated and do not know how or where to look for help. Help those people by doing our bit and share our lived experiences through charitable organisations and give them self belief and empowerment to manage their mental health condition and to not lose faith in the NHS or private sector services who are trying their best to reduce the waiting lists.25022016-07-22T16:01:18.08312008Nick MurbyIt is so important that mental health services improve in Scotland, especially in young adults. The benefits of this can also influence the whole of society, not just the individual. This then leads to a happier, healthier society generally.25022016-07-22T16:27:33.0212009Mr W WatsonDelighted to support this cause.25982016-07-22T16:57:53.86712010steve macsweeneyThey say a wild salmon is worth £5000.00 to the Scottish tourist industry. What price would you put on protected birds? A handful of grasping landowners benefitting at the expense of the country. Does that remind you of anything Scotland?25982016-07-22T17:47:36.2512011Wesley Amadeus GlockSupporting this man...25982016-07-22T18:19:22.66312012Adam CraigGet rid of these things and the criminals that deploy them.25982016-07-22T18:41:41.30312013Janet CrawfordI required support two years ago, local mental health charity were amazing.25022016-07-22T18:53:19.71312014Helen mitchellPeople need help and support much quicker than they do right now so many lives are lost due to the wait for an appointment.25022016-07-22T18:56:04.96312015HarryAs an environmentalist and hillwalker for forty years, I am alarmed at the acceleration I witness in the industrialisation of our countryside. \r\nBulldozed tracks, not marked on any map, extensive muirburn, drainage channels are all symptoms of this. A less obvious, but equally pernicious result of gamebird 'hunting' is the persecution of any species not regarded as game. I use parenthesis as I do not recognise an activity where the quarry is driven toward the guns as 'hunting'. This is merely amusement park coconut shy shooting, mechanised slaughter, on a grand scale. An entirely abhorrent pastime that should go the same way as bear baiting, cock fighting and throwing Christians to lions.25982016-07-22T22:13:35.83312017Sandra ScottTime to hit these people where it hurts, in their pocket. The SG must take action to protect our wildlife25982016-07-22T22:41:32.65312019Elaine glenKeep mental health services available. We need them. Simple as that. 25022016-07-22T23:38:28.6912020 catherine duncanWhy should other species of mammals be killed for the benefit of the shooting fraternity e, g stoats weasels, raptors foxes , everything that threatens a shoot25982016-07-23T00:13:07.44712021Liz BalharryIf our uplands were a rich and varied landscape for wildlife with industries attracting high wages and water holding abilities which prevented flooding downstream, and someone suggested replacing this type of land use with what we know today as driven grouse shoots ........it would be greeted with cries of derision and hoots of laughter. Until we get rid of driven grouse shoots we will not be able to release the potential of the uplands to bring benefit to the many rather than the few....25982016-07-23T00:40:11.3412022Keith BlakeYou Have To Do More.25022016-07-23T01:25:26.6412023Arno BreedtI also have major sound sensitivity, I know how frustrating it can be to deal with people who just don't understand. I truly hope somebody does something for you soon.25462016-07-23T18:08:01.3312024Brian SuttonIt is appalling that these people who pander to a pastime supported by a tiny minority feel that they can get away with crimes that the vast majority of people find abhorrent. If traps are found on a shooting estate the estate should be closed for a minimum of a year ad heavily fined.25982016-07-23T18:43:39.15312025Mark WrightAll because it's unseen, it doesn't mean it's not there. 25022016-07-23T19:49:36.14712026tom rossWe have to live by the laws of the country,so should these people25982016-07-24T03:21:54.6512027Jeanette PenderFully support this extremely necessary action.25022016-07-24T09:41:40.60712028D ConstantineThis issue needs to be more prominent in the media so that more of the general public are aware of these awful crimes.25982016-07-24T09:48:10.54712029Ian BellVERY long overdue25982016-07-24T11:20:25.712030Stephen HeathTime to get tough with the shooting industry a prison sentence is well overdue!25982016-07-24T12:19:52.56712031Douglas MalpusAfter the estates have dined and wined some Scottish MP's to get over their conservation lies then illegal traps are found to show their real intentions. Illegal poisons are in use. Shooting, trapping and poisoning of protected species is rife. It must be stopped. If the shooting industry cannot stay within the law then they must be banned.25982016-07-24T13:47:13.06312032Anna McOustraIt would be a good start to controlling game shooting \r\nWhy is it a new pheasant shoot, with hundreds of birds released, where they haven't been before, and this is not regarded as "change of use" and the landowner does not have to apply for "planning" consent? So no mitigation plan has to be done to evaluate the effect on the existing wildlife in the area.25982016-07-24T13:57:50.98712033DAVID JEWELLIF THESE TRAPS ARE FOUND ON THESE ESTATES THEN SUBSTANCIAL FINES SHOULD BE LEVIED25982016-07-24T22:43:16.68312035William BarberRaptors need protection.25982016-07-24T23:18:15.53312036David StewartNow has got to be the time to implement vicarious responsibility25982016-07-24T23:21:52.87312037John AdairLicensing of shooting is long overdue.25982016-07-25T08:48:29.65312038Nick HillStop killing beautiful creatures25982016-07-25T11:31:22.89712039Grace McCarronWe need to protect our wildlife. Nature is our future! Please stop this atrocity.\r\n25982016-07-25T11:54:35.03712040Joe CooperLicensing has proven successful in other countries and should be adopted for many situations such as this in order to better establish a sense of importance and security both for the sport and protected species involved. 25982016-07-25T12:37:15.15312042Shannon LlewellynDegradation of uplands, and persecution of native species, for the enjoyment of a tiny minority of people really should be a thing of the past, and this would at least be a start.\r\n25982016-07-25T15:10:29.65712043Ian johnstoneSupport this so much as I've got mental health issues and gets ignored by government and health professionals as well.25022016-07-25T18:33:26.6412044Angel LangMy son has Autism and is sensitive to sounds.I hope me signing this petition helps to resolve some issues25462016-07-25T19:17:41.70712045Tony WesleyWe need to protect our Raptors this shooting of them must stop25982016-07-25T22:30:49.93712046Maggie KI sign a declaration to this petition. I want changes made to help others batteling mental illness 25022016-07-25T22:50:00.01712047Louise HislopThis is a worthwhile cause and closer to a lot of people than you may think. Well done angela25022016-07-25T23:19:15.7412048Ruth mccutcheonIt is amazing what you are doing so many people out there that don't think about everything that goes on with people around us raising awareness to this is honestly amazing well done x25022016-07-26T09:12:01.3912049Brian WhitemanThe murder of other creatures that we share this planet with, is a sad indictment of the human race.25982016-07-26T11:32:27.5812050Gina MSo many ppl going through this and getting no help. Things need to change and sooner rather than later.25022016-07-26T11:51:54.612051Mark Brain They can't be allowed to do whatever they like any longer. Killin g national treasures to pander to rich playboys.25982016-07-26T12:23:44.68312052Mark HensonProtecting the natural predators MUST be part of any land management scheme.25982016-07-26T17:46:50.9512053Brian RobertsonLicensing of hunting is absolutely necessary to help reverse the current situation of wildlife crime going unpunished. Any estate or individual who carries out their duties in a lawful manner have nothing to fear from this proposal. Wildlife crime exists because there never has been, nor ever will be, sufficient resources to police shooting estates. A new system of sanctions must be devised and a licensing system could be a major role in achieving this.25982016-07-26T19:15:28.41712054Paul MurfittI go to Scotland 3 weeks per year to see birds such as Golden Eagle & Hen Harrier so please do not let them go extinct.25982016-07-26T20:10:44.28312055Margaret AdamsThe future of the planet is more important than how much money is made in Grouse shooting25982016-07-26T21:38:28.1212056Michael ThorntonScotland has one of the most unregulated game management systems in the world and a disgraceful history of illegal raptor persecution on grouse moors. Surely it's time to change this and introduce greater regulation. 25982016-07-27T11:41:12.7112057Eilidh McNabThe game industry has proven that it is entirely unable or unwilling to self-regulate it's activities - the time has definitely come for mandatory regulation.25982016-07-27T14:33:54.16712058David CandlinNo shooter has the right to make a beautiful Raptor extinct to me in my own country! long jail terms are needed for the owners as well as the keepers! WE WONT GO AWAY!25982016-07-27T16:04:16.79312059Shaun WellsTime for Scotland to lead the way.25982016-07-27T17:58:45.8712060Joseph Anthony FlemingAs a native born Scotsman, I am saddened by the criminal activities of estate owners and their employees who persistently break the law relating to birds of prey25982016-07-27T18:09:17.07712061Joseph FlemingBirds of prey will continue to be illegally killed until legislation is in place which makes estate owners vicariously liable for the actions of their employees who are instructed to kill birds of prey. A licensing system with the power to revoke such a licence if terms and conditions are breached is long overdue.25982016-07-27T19:32:01.49312062Philip CoxI have just read of the finding of illegal traps in Cairngorm National Park, why has the lease holder not had its licence immediately revoked?\r\nCome on Scotland get your act together25982016-07-27T23:39:39.9512063T C KingThe protection of all raptors is essential. The legal system much be more robust with larger penalties affecting the Estate owners as well as the keepers. 25982016-07-27T23:43:31.4512064lynn gardnerMental health affects us all need to b able to get help25022016-07-28T00:07:01.87712065Chris MoorhouseThey're all as thick as thieves, no point asking the law to get out there and catch the evil wrongdoing gamekeepers,they're too weak to confront the bad guys.25982016-07-28T07:35:18.23312066Neil BielbyThe grouse shooting fraternity have been breaking the law with impunity and destroying Scotland's natural heritage for too long.25982016-07-28T14:13:12.8112067Bob & Val SmithToo many vested interests.\r\nMSPs should declare whether they go gamebird hunting.\r\nTime and time again hands are thrown in the air in dismay but nothing is done.\r\nEffective legislation is required.25982016-07-28T15:20:34.9912068mac cookI was appalled when pictures were posted on Facebook showing all the mountain hares that had been killed up near Cairngorm.25982016-07-28T16:07:27.85712069Peter HeranI regularly bird watch in Scotland it's a great place to go but the destruction of birds of prey is making avoid some places I do not see the necessity for it. It may ultimately put myself and other from visiting Scotland (although England is not perfect) with the resulting loss of income to many Scottish enterprises25982016-07-28T23:38:57.63712071Valerie CampbellOur wild heritage should be used for the benefit of all creatures.25982016-07-29T04:49:24.22712072Dougy FraserHope this petition works as these estates need to be controlled. Feel sorry for the grouse too, poor birds.25982016-07-29T09:46:35.74712073Roger DillworthWhy in this day and age do some weirdos still think killing creatures is a sport? Certainly all bird shooting areas should be licensed as all people who engage in this carnage should also pay a high price for a licence. After the Dunblane massacre and others guns were taken off the streets, ownership of certain weapons was made illegal, it's about time ownership of all guns was made illegal, after all isn't there something really perverse about a small section of society getting some sort of knee trembler out of killing birds?25982016-07-29T10:24:35.53312074Michael BrookesIn May this year we had a wonderful holiday in Scotland spending a week on Coll watching your beautiful hen harriers which have been all but exterminated due to driven grouse shooting in England. In order to prevent this abominable criminality in Scotland and to maintain a wildlife refuge for us to continue to enjoy in Scotland we are offering our full support to this petition.25982016-07-29T10:25:59.99312075Colette RobertsonScottish raptors are significantly reducing in population size due to inhumane, selfish and completely unnecessary interference by humans. The people involved in this persecution held to account for things to improve.25982016-07-29T11:55:34.5912076Graham CooperThe protection of all raptors is essential. The legal system much be more robust with larger penalties.25982016-07-29T12:01:12.85712077Graham CooperThe Grouse shooting fraternity have been breaking the law with impunity, punishments need to be increased.25982016-07-29T12:53:23.63712078Michael SagarStop killing wildlife.25982016-07-29T14:06:15.19312079C WhiteHuntsmen are evil, Scotland deserves to be rid of these estates where they get away with murder.25982016-07-29T14:46:19.39712080David BroadheadI am increasingly alarmed by the spread of gamebird deserts in Scotland through over-intense management.25982016-07-29T15:20:24.8812081Roger FavellI am appalled that there are still people in the British Isles that think it is acceptable to kill raptors that have been protected for 60 years. It's about time the majority of the people in this Island that do not approve, stop it. If it eventually leads to the outlawing of driven Grouse shoots & loss of jobs so be it! It's time to take a stand.25982016-07-29T20:16:49.58312082Brian WaiteThis of shooting and killing wild animals for sick pleasure and emotion felt when they squeeze the guns and watch the victim fall, is nothing less than obscene. Yet humanity has the arrogance to call itself the highest form of life on planet Earth, but history shows orterwise25982016-07-29T21:00:54.39712083Alexandra KeithThe protection for raptors is a legally binding law. The protection needs to be reinforced against those who feel they are above the law. 25982016-07-29T23:48:53.93312084margaret GalbraithWe need biodiversity to maintain a healthy ecosystem and protecting all raptors from persecution is very important. Warnings are no longer good enough and fines aren't tough enough. 25982016-07-30T10:24:30.52712085Jennifer M CameronBirds of prey are an important part of the eco system. Gamekeepers are destroying what can be enjoyed by many, for the sake of the few. We need a balance.25982016-07-30T10:37:07.43712086Pat LawrenceHave always been totally against grouse shooting. It's disgraceful how many grouse and indeed pheasants, having just been bred for the 'glorious 12th' are released to just die in our country roads. Disgraceful 25982016-07-30T10:38:35.51312087Gordon McKayWe need to protect our upland moors and raptor species against irresponsible estates and managers now.25982016-07-30T15:43:50.6812088S peerIt's time we put Nature first over the profits for a few wealthy land owners.25982016-07-30T16:11:57.4512089Irene SmithIllegal raptor killing has absolutely no place in a civilised society - the Scottish Government must act to control gamebird hunting through legislation. 25982016-07-30T17:50:05.43312090Louise RamsayI feel very strongly about this. We have an exceptionally unregulated game shooting sector in this country and it results in serious damage of much of our land. We need to try regulating this sector to prevent further environmental damage and public harm.25982016-07-30T17:54:20.35712091Louise RamsayThe game shooting industry needs to be regulated and licensed here as it is in other European countries and in the USA. Certain practices, especially excessive muirburn and illegal persecution of raptors have been damaging our land and wildlife for a decades and recently the situation has got worse. It is time to get this situation under regulatory control. 25982016-07-30T23:18:52.2912092Toby Green Disgusted that in this day and age we have to petition to stop illegal persecution! Makes me angry to be forced to do this to stop a minority from "enjoying" themselves slaughtering our upland birds! 25982016-07-31T09:34:05.36712093Jon MercerPersecution of raptors by shooting interests continues to be a blot on Scotland's environmental credentials. Even our national bird is not exempt from the self-serving interests of the shooting lobby,25982016-07-31T11:03:54.4112094p palmerthe young from Scottish bred Hen harriers come to visit us in England each winter. I would hate to lose them as we have already lost our breeding birds due to English persecution and the inadequacy of English law enforcers. Scotland Please set an example that will show how progressive you are and how you proudly you value your wildlife. English Parliament has failed us, please do not fail Scotland too.25982016-07-31T12:43:37.7212095Adam OgleyThis people need stopping. 25982016-07-31T15:25:17.1212096SUE HURSTThe killing of any bird is a total anathema to me 25982016-07-31T19:31:21.1212097Leslie ScottLicense shooting estates in Scotland.25982016-07-31T23:44:17.53312098matilda shadboltIt is essential to protect these magnificent creatures.25982016-08-01T02:29:04.2912099Jill HadfieldThe ruining of the countryside that should be shared between the us all and our wildlife, just so the few can have a nice day out. Absolutely disgusting.25982016-08-01T13:06:40.6312100COLIN DOUGLASI fail to see the pleasure and entertainment that some people seem to derive from killing things for sport. These so-called sporting estates are missing a trick making money out of killing wildlife when so much more can be made from wildlife tourism. The thrill that can be had from seeing an osprey stooping and pulling a fish from the water sure as hell beats that of a few brace of grouse lying dead on a kitchen table as far as I am concerned.25982016-08-01T15:34:03.25712101Richard MorrisThank you to all the people involved in organising the petition, including Scottish Parliamentary staff and to all those who signed.25412016-08-01T20:27:04.32712102Fergus CrystalHigh time everybody is made aware how much gamebird shooting adversely affects wildlife. It's time shooting clients were made aware of the harm their insistence on large bags causes. Shooting clients include royalty, boy band members and big business. They should all know what harm they cause when they are invited on a 'day'.25982016-08-01T21:09:37.9312103Janice MermikliI feel strongly about this subject and would like to see the end of illegal killing of game birds in Scotland. (Ideally, I would like to see the end of all blood sports). These magnificent birds of prey belong in the majestic Scottish countryside. Please let us preserve them as well as we can. 25982016-08-02T13:03:22.9112105Mike FieldPlease protect these beautiful wild creatures from these despicable types who set illegal and barbaric traps. Like many below I would also dearly love to see an end to all game and blood sports - it is a ridiculous, elitest activity for the privileged few and one which has no place in a modern, compassionate and civilised world.25982016-08-02T15:17:07.5512106JOHN RAINEYThey would leave nothing for us to marvel at - I hope that they come to their senses25982016-08-02T16:25:33.5312107Douglas McKeanIt is long overdue to control wayward land owners25982016-08-02T18:43:30.59712108Paul CroftI am not against gamebird hunting as such, but illegal persecution of birds of prey is disgraceful as is the culling of mountain hares. There also needs to be regulation on stocking levels of non-native birds. The numbers of red legged partridge and pheasant that are now loose in parts of Perthshire all year round is ludicrous and they are very destructive in both gardens and countryside. Self regulation is obviously beyond the ability of the industry and some form of legislative framework needs to be introduced.25982016-08-02T20:08:17.90312109Andrew StewartI would like to see this end, how has it come, that a sport played by the elite decimates the wildlife. Golden eagles have been in retreat across Britain and now only exist in Scotland. It fills me with absolute rage that people can kill these glorious creatures to protect a vile sport which occupies the few in this country, while these birds inspire the many and probably bring more into the economy! It is a no brainer the government needs to act now!!!25982016-08-02T20:32:55.51712110Gwen Grant CliffordWe never learn from our mistakes these birds have a vital role to play in the Eco system. A thing of beauty must NOT be destroyed at will we must manage ALL forms of hunting.25982016-08-02T22:24:34.2512111Phil HydeIt about time alternatives to the slaughter of native Scottish wildlife was discussed. The mismanagement of moorlands by the grouse shooting fraternity needs to be put under the spotlight for what it is - environmentally devastating.25982016-08-02T23:03:18.96312112Kenny KortlandI am a resident of Daviot, South of Inverness. The scale of illegal persecution of Scotland's protected species in this area is massive. This statement is based on my own observations on the grouse moors in the area. Even more importantly, the land is being severely degraded by the associated management. 25982016-08-03T07:32:04.26312114David AshfordHunt shooters are animal terrorists who should, like their dogs, be brought to heel!\r\n25982016-08-03T08:03:29.1912115AshtrothThe birds were here long before us,just because you've bought the land the Wildlife cannot be owned,nor do you have the right to kill it.25982016-08-03T08:27:51.42712116Don S FergusonI used to volunteer with the Forestry Commission as a Warden at the Huntly Peregrine Wildwatch where there were lots of Red Squirrels these were a great source of entertainment and amazement too.25982016-08-03T16:40:01.39712117DougoutcanoeThe game bird shooting industry is proving time and time again that it has not improved since the Victorian era when raptors were legally classed as vermin. It is now time to bring this archaic industry into the 21 century or better still close it down for the cruelty it inflicts.25982016-08-03T16:54:16.08712118Dick GlasgowAs a former Gamekeeper myself, I know first hand how much illegal raptor persecution went on behind the scenes & was widespread & I fear that little has improved since my time. I have no doubt that crimes that come to light are only ever going to be the tip of the iceberg & feel very strongly that a more forceful system must be implemented as a matter of urgency, to prevent rogue Keepers & their employers from treating our precious Birds of Prey with such little respect. In the C21st our raptors deserve far better treatment.25982016-08-03T17:41:08.2812119WaltIF gamekeepers and estate owners cannot stop persecuting birds of prey on gamebird shooting land then we must revoke licensing for gamebird shooting on all estates where indescriminate poisoning, shooting and disturbance of birds of prey nest sites. Follow the rules to protect these magnificent birds of prey or loose the right to shoot game.25982016-08-03T20:25:18.30312120Gregory McShaneI have recently written to several Scottish ministers on the issue. The recent discovery of illegally set traps on Invercauld Estate (on the other side of the glen from Balmoral) shows how a so-called 'respectable' shooting estate can try to get away with wildlife crime while putting on that sweet, innocent face so many of the Scottish Estates (and the Gamekeepers Association) put on. Time to licence estates - any wildlife crime, lose the licence: lose the licence for the estate - not the 'owner' (for a minimum of five years) and no guns to be allowed on it. Likewise gamekeepers must be licenced and, if convicted of wildlife crime, lose the Licence to Practise - so they'll not be able to work as a gamekeeper - for life.\r\nTime we Scots took some action!25982016-08-03T21:34:35.12712121MikeWe want to see wild species living in their natural hsbitat for all to enjoy. Not control of nature for the entertainment of a few!25982016-08-03T21:46:40.28312122Mike ForsythIt is important to highlight to clients and owners the damage that is being done so everyone can work together to solve this appalling situation\r\n25982016-08-04T06:11:11.61712123Mike w Sullivan For over40 I have been holiday img in Scotland and have witnessed the Decline of HARRIERS in the Moorland areas of Scotland .This year only ONE was seen .Theif has to be a Very Big Problem which is causing this Decline ? ?A Major Survey needs to be carried out to ascertain What is causing the Decline of HARRIERS .I am a Brtd Watcher and changes like this are very Noticeable over such a long period .Thank You .25982016-08-04T08:25:19.88312124Cameron McNeishI'm becoming increasingly concerned at the "management" of grouse moors for sport shooting to the detriment of everything else. In particular the increase in the shooting of raptors have become deplorable.25982016-08-04T08:44:49.5912125Ron Greerit's time to move out of the Victorian-Edwardian era25982016-08-04T08:47:33.74712126Eileen HolttumI have been a hillwalker for 40 years. In the last 5 years I have seen increasing extremely inappropriate upland land management measures to increase grouse numbers: these numbers I believe have a natural rise and fall over the years. Measures I've seen include eradication of mountain hares over large areas, and intensive and ugly deer fencing and shooting out of deer over whole estates.25982016-08-04T09:06:54.9412127jezkempstonI.m concerned about the environment ... and I'm vegetarian25982016-08-04T09:26:46.512128Pat KelsallSustainability has to be the watchword and our environment is straining under so many impacts - shooting estates are not environmentally diversive as the end all is rearing birds to be shot. These estates need to find other means of income.25982016-08-04T10:03:22.7112129A RossI am very unhappy with the level of wildlife crime associated with gamebird management and the lack of progress being made to prevent it. Incidents such as the first east coast born white-tailed eagle in 200 years mysteriously disappearing on a grouse moor in 2014 is an example of the shooting industry directly preventing pioneering conservation work. The lack of accountability and transparency in this case has furthered my support for stricter licensing. I am also concerned about other potentially negative and poorly understood management practices such as heather burning. I support regulated licensing in order to better address the environmental impact of gamebird hunting and ensure the landscape is managed positively.25982016-08-04T10:39:18.71312130Julia HoweWe need to protect wildlife and their habitats.25982016-08-04T10:48:52.96712131Melvyn GreenhalghI am a regular visitor to Scotland , to observe the bird life that I am unable to see in England. The track record of these shooting estates with regards to wild life crime is appalling. Something has to be done to bring these criminals into line with our society standards. If an outright ban is not possible, some form of licencing must be introduced.25982016-08-04T10:50:53.29712132Margaret PonsonbyThe wildlife of Scotland must not be slaughtered to benefit a few landowners.25982016-08-04T10:56:15.12712133John EdwardsIt is a culture that needs severely restricting at least where birds are bred, shot out of the skies in the name of sport. For some it is part of the culture and it has to stop. In the name of this sport the environment is being changed and native non-sporting species not only lose their habitat, but their lives as well. The criminal process is far too slow and is loaded in favour of the killers.25982016-08-04T10:59:29.57712134Nicola Callisit should be banned completely but I suppose state regulated is a good first step to preventing these estates killing what they like to protect their home grown grouse to be shot on their land!!25982016-08-04T11:12:36.75312135Philip ButlerThe landscapes created by grouse shooting are an appalling desert of patchwork burning, a practice that does nothing but harm to the environment. Add to this the lack of accountability for wildlife crime, notably raptor persecution - many estates have beneficial owners based in tax-havens and they simply cannot be traced. It is time this sick activity (killing animals for fun) was registered and regulated. Land registration needs to be stiffened as well, so that those reponsible can be traced and held to account.25982016-08-04T12:23:22.4512136Ken MichieRaptors are part of our natural environment and must be given priority over those who take pleasure from killing for sport.25982016-08-04T13:58:32.112137Roger CottisIt is regrettable that our indigenous wildlife, not only wild birds suffer at the expense of non-native species (pheasants). We need radical changes in an unregulated countryside. 25982016-08-04T14:42:42.20312138Susan StewartThis is a small step in the right direction 25982016-08-04T16:03:50.66712139Kath ToddI have every support for sustainable which is a legutimate part of integrated land management and when well run supports our biodiversity25982016-08-05T06:57:34.89712140Caroline Time to change 25982016-08-05T10:45:47.92712141RossGame bird hunting has and is continuing to destroy our fauna and flora. It is out of control, unregulated and those involved in it are free to carry out whatever misdemeanours against raptors and other predators. They are systematically destroying the natural environment.25982016-08-05T23:29:21.7812143PaulThis legislation is long overdue. How is it that the Scottish government wildlife policy officer does not have an ecology but a business degree? No wonder how wildlife is suffering.25982016-08-05T23:45:11.53712144Barbara McMillan Not before time, we have waited, not patiently, for a long time. Now is the time.25982016-08-06T11:56:41.49312145Craig MorrisonGamebird hunting should be outlawed never mind be licensed. The Scottish Government are weak and are as guilty as their counterparts in Westminster in pandering to wealthy land owners.25982016-08-07T09:57:01.6412146Frank McKayThis is the time for wild life,not gun fodder25982016-08-07T12:40:44.80312147Zoe van Zwanenberg This is an important step in the right direction 25982016-08-07T17:01:16.35712148Mrs Sheila williamsonstop it25982016-08-07T17:21:11.27712149Gerry HoustonAs is often the case and is further evidenced in this instance, self regulation and doing the right thing are often unhappy bedfellows.25982016-08-07T17:32:37.2212150Robert ClarkeSave our wildlife.25982016-08-07T18:21:18.72712151Michael Boyle-RonaldsonHunting Raptors should be banned25982016-08-07T21:52:19.45312152John MansonI think the hunting fraternity are a law unto themselves and it has been going on to long. Regulation should help.25982016-08-08T14:15:54.31712153Jane PayneGood luck with this petition, The killing of any creature for fun is abhorrent25982016-08-09T00:04:40.89712154Moira Gibson I fully support this position25982016-08-09T09:30:07.08312155Graham CapperJust do it...25982016-08-09T13:40:39.8312156Dr Stephen TemperleyIt should have been proposed and ratified decades ago25982016-08-09T13:47:34.72712157John CanteloA minimum requirement to stop wildlife crime.25982016-08-09T14:00:19.10312158Mr Greer Hart, seniorMany, many humane people are fed up with the shenanigans of the Government and those who shoot birds for sport. Time has come for greater public control and for politidicans to take heed. Time it was shown that greater economic benefit would accrue if our landscape, now used for shooting on, were to be used for more humane activities to create a better and more reliable employment structure for such rural areas, and ending the boast that the shooting estates give so much to the economy. Those that can toe the line and not kill wildlife, would of course, be exempt. Just stop breaking ghe law and conforming to the wishes of many and leave Birds of Prey and Mountain Hares etc alone.25982016-08-09T14:09:52.37312159Simon TuckerVoluntary arrangements have not worked: wildlife crime is rife on these estates. Licensing, with clear minimum targets for predator levels (weasels, stoats, foxes, as well as birds of prey) are essential. The killing has to stop.25982016-08-09T14:40:38.93712161stevet macsweeneyI support this petition25982016-08-09T19:50:06.18312162Roger Danielsthese "people" who kill for the fun of it are sick.25982016-08-09T22:11:31.6412163Paul ThompsonI cannot understand why some people get pleasure by killing!!! 25982016-08-10T13:29:44.2512164Becky AustinFully in support of this petition.25982016-08-10T18:48:26.1912165Alexander William Leslie JossI am not at all against game bird hunting per se, but it should only be carried out strictly within the laws in force which ban persecution of raptors. As self-regulation in gamebird hunting estates is not working, a state licensing system needs to be introduced.25982016-08-10T22:56:25.8812166David StewartThis must be a case to implement vicarious responsibility25982016-08-11T08:10:04.4712168Mark CantLandowners need to be be taken into account should they be found guilty of systematically abusing commonly recognised conservation measures & laws.25982016-08-11T08:34:21.66312169Lesley hughesI do not agree with any ganebird hunting whatsoever. There is not a single situation where this is acceptable. 25982016-08-11T08:57:47.3912170John CanteloThis is the minimum requirement if we are to stop wildlife crime and stop criminals being given public subsidy.25982016-08-11T09:21:20.01312171Rob Ballinger"Glorious" sick 12th tomorrw sigh25982016-08-11T09:26:02.9112172Pauline09It's time this outdated "sport" was consigned to the history books. It is a black cloud on Scottish heritage!25982016-08-11T09:53:04.53312173Mark JohnstonAs a teuchter and as a near neighbour of grouse moors (for the last twenty years) I have seen no decline in the persecution of wild animals by the employees of the estates. The same illegal practices I saw first hand in the 1970s in the Angus Glens continue to this day and the hills are now far more intensively managed and more of a monoculture than I have ever seen them before. Elsewhere in Scotland there are better examples of grouse moors being more sensitively and sensibly managed. These estates would have no difficulty complying with licensing conditions but it strikes me that until there is enforced licensing, those with the worst records will have no incentive to change.25982016-08-11T09:53:24.83712174Sue Brodie Please licence game bird hunting to protect our raptures25982016-08-11T09:58:03.60312175Martin TurnerA good reason for pushing on with the land reform agenda.25982016-08-11T10:09:50.95712176anne bourneThe greed of these shooting companies is beyond belief, to the extent that nothing else should exist should be allowed to exist on the moors, even the most precious and endangered wildlife, who might take a few grouse out of the millions they breed25982016-08-11T10:12:27.7712177Liz FreitasIt seems that money making of a few is more important than protecting the natural heritage for the many. When will we wise up? 25982016-08-11T10:15:16.9112178Pete YoungerPlease urgently introduce severe penalties up to estate forfeiture.25982016-08-11T10:21:16.3712179NJ CassidyCloser regulation of grouse moors clearly needed.25982016-08-11T10:22:57.55312180Ashsuch great birds... these guys with money should be protecting them for the future of their children...25982016-08-11T10:39:25.2812181dennisLand owners clearly connected to the very people who should be prosecuting them. Stop this killing of wildlife for profit. stop any land subsidies.25982016-08-11T10:51:49.56312182phil crennelltime for humanity to grow up25982016-08-11T10:58:16.2512183LesleySWhy do people want to kill living things, there are better ways of proving what a good shot one is.25982016-08-11T10:59:38.39312184Andrew McCuaigThe current legislation has been an abject failure. It's time to get a real grip on this issue.25982016-08-11T11:08:54.49712185Hedd angharadBetter laws and regulations should be made for game shooters, plus harsher penalties! 25982016-08-11T11:21:01.9512186Susan HuntonI strongly agree with the idea of licensing - it will not stop some but I feel that it will raise awareness, not only of the illegal killing of raptors, but also the importance of these magnificent birds to our wildlife surroundings. On a personal note, I find it quite horrifying that some of the birds are poisoned or trapped causing painful deaths to these beautiful birds - please help25982016-08-11T11:36:10.81312187Camelia LeveridgeI support this petition.25982016-08-11T11:38:22.07712188Ros McDadeWe can't let this carry on, please protect our beautiful birds of prey.25982016-08-11T11:56:32.02312189Sheila MeadowsIconic birds, they must be protected, the Highlands is their home....25982016-08-11T11:58:34.91712190Martin FinniganI support this petition and agree with the four points set out below25982016-08-11T12:00:15.98712191Frederick BatyWhy is Scotland missing from choice of country?25982016-08-11T12:03:38.97312192Gordon WilsonWe need a solution that will definitely deter killing of raptors. If there is no such deterrent then ban the activities that estates think they are trying to protect.25982016-08-11T12:11:38.64312193RobertMankind can't live without nature, so please show it some respect for all our sakes.25982016-08-11T12:15:48.7412194Ernie ScalesFor far too long income has ruled this argument and Fergus is still making sure the 'value' of shooting to the Scottish rural economy is highlighted. A proper balance needs to be struck between shooting income and tourist income. Without its iconic wildlife will tourists still visit Scotland in number?25982016-08-11T12:16:27.8812195MandyHaving just returned from Scotland and having seen the Osplets it is saddening to think that these beautiful birds together with all other raptors have such an uncertain and dangerous future thanks to the rich, greedy people who hunt. This has to stop now!25982016-08-11T12:24:42.7112196SeanRaptors are part of our ecosystem and should be respected by us all. Shooting is a sport for the few and although considered important to the livelihood of some it is no excuse for destroying our native species.25982016-08-11T13:04:53.64312197Sidney BurnettFor million's of years all these animals existed side by side in perfect harmony . One day and I hope it's soon mother nature is going to shrug mankind off the planet like the cancer he has become.25982016-08-11T13:08:19.9212198Suzanne simpsonPlease, we beg you. Please do something to stop the persecution of our wildlife. You can make a difference. 25982016-08-11T13:09:49.14312199Jan montgomeryShocked by the knowledge of killings of raptors to facilitate game bird shooting. Love our wildlife!25982016-08-11T13:19:51.5612200Suzanne simpsonPlease do something to protect our wildlife. 25982016-08-11T13:21:38.6612201KarenI am fortunate to go out to work each day as a wildlife tour guide, this includes watching golden eagles, sea eagles, hen harriers and buzzards. Raptors are majestic birds and still a rare and wondrous sight. I have a responsibility to educate the public on their importance both intrinsically and as part of the wider food web, and really explaining just how rare and special it is that we are seeing these birds and the negativity that still surrounds them. We have come a long way through country-wide extinction, the plights of reintroduction and now we must fight to end persecution. 25982016-08-11T14:56:03.74712202Roy Clarkelivestock reared for the shooting fraternity must NOT have priority over our native wildlife. Please bring an end to the illegal persecution of our Raptors and other wildlife. Say NO to Grouse moors. 25982016-08-11T15:03:40.8512203Andrew LaneA good idea. Grouse moors should be consigned to the 19th century. 25982016-08-11T15:11:16.612204Sylvia CollingwoodI cannot understand the mentality of people who actively kill these fantastic birds all because they might take a few grouse chicks - surely a drop in the ocean compared to the thousands of birds that are reared all for the "sport" of game shooting.\r\n25982016-08-11T16:06:05.21712205John GayEnvironmental management of the red grouse sporting areas must promote a sustainable future for the terrain and communities. Sporting estates need to be held accountable for their methods.25982016-08-11T16:39:02.7312206Alan HiddlestonLive target shooting just sums this up £££££25982016-08-11T16:51:21.53712207jane eadesHelp Scotland restore the forest, revive the biodiversity and farm sustainably with genuine wildlife protection. 25982016-08-11T17:09:31.6812208James Condliffe I saw a golden eagle for the first time close to the Invercauld Estate. Unacceptable that such a fantastic creature could be put at risk for so called sport. Nature is all ours to enjoy and respect 25982016-08-11T17:13:09.1512209Jane FinniganSave the beautiful golden eagle!25982016-08-11T18:10:22.7512210Chris WattThere is still an alarming rate of birds disappearing mostly around Grouse driven moors. It is time a system was put in place to halt illegal behaviour and save Scotland's most iconic birds of prey.25982016-08-11T18:36:26.45712211Steve HarrisI visit the highlands of Scotland regularly and frequently to enjoy the magnificent natural environment. The criminal persecution of raptors and other natural predators of grouse is a huge concern to me.25982016-08-11T18:37:01.6612212Lisa WoodWe have a moral duty to protect our environment for our future.25982016-08-11T18:50:13.91312213KENNETH JOHNSTONEAs a keen mountain biker and roamer of the hills I have experienced this type of driven shoots in the Highlands...I strongly object to the unbalancing of natural wildlife and the heavily scarred countryside be by burning or increased scars by land rover access tracks25982016-08-11T18:51:17.87312214John MooreI like to go to Scotland specifically for the wildlife and am seriously considering alternate destinations if this persecution persists, I no longer holiday in Cyprus or Malta for this reason.25982016-08-11T19:11:03.11312215Brian LazzariThe only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. Do the right thing, and protect those who cannot protect themselves be it human or animal.25982016-08-11T19:18:20.74312216Judith ReadBirds should not be bred for slaughter and worse still involve the eradication of species of indigenous wildlife. Licences should be taken away away and the organisation closed down if there is any infringement of licence.25982016-08-11T19:43:12.50712219Douglas Robertson I have serious concerns that a blind eye is being turned toward raptor persecution in this country and would like to see licensing in place with a burden of proof on those applying to demonstrate conformity before issue. This may also further pressure government organisations tasked with protecting our environment to take their role more seriously rather than folding before land owners using illegal traps.25982016-08-11T19:47:21.69712220PeterIllegal. immoral and destroying our children's inheritance. The rest not printable25982016-08-11T19:54:45.7812221Sylvia KempYet more barbaric killings, and still no prosecutions, It is about time the Scottish Government took some real action against and not just lip service.25982016-08-11T20:03:23.1212222Sylvia KempThe Scottish SNP Government needs to do something about these barbaric killings and not just lip service.25982016-08-11T20:17:49.45712223Irene WilliamsonIt is a disgrace for people to be getting away with crime against wildlife and not being properly dealt with.25982016-08-11T20:19:55.71712224James UnderwoodI'm not against people exercising their legal right to hunt or the right of those who provide their sport. I want to see an end to the illegal practises that seem to be associated with it. Protect Scotland's natural heritage for the generations that will follow ours.25982016-08-11T20:46:39.8212225Alistair J MacKichanThe correlation between the killing of large raptors and driven grouse moors is to be expected. I lived next to such a grouse moor, visited each year by German businessmen for their pleasure. They employed gillies to suppress predation on the grouse. While the raptors are the top of a food chain, that food chain is not confined to grouse, and more diverse land use would favour them just as well. The wealthy who invest in Scottish moorland for shooting are limiting the enjoyment of the Scottish landscape by the Scottish people, and limiting the development of rural infrastructure. The Holyrood government needs to look again at Land Reform.25982016-08-11T20:51:50.41312226Bernadette Griffiths This has to stop we are in the 21st century not 19th, if we don't protect them who will?????????? 25982016-08-11T21:58:40.93312227Claire Gordon Very concerned by the news today from rspb that eight golden eagles have gone missing over intensely managed grouse moorland. Tighter regulation is urgently needed.25982016-08-11T22:05:13.1112228Alice As ever the rich hunters are 'protected from prosecution' by their cronies to facilitate the incomes from grouse breeding and shooting (cruel in itself!) so our beautiful wildlife suffers needlessly in the name of profit for exclusive rights etc. It sickens me and like minded 'ordinary' working taxpayers. Makes me so angry as I'm powerless to change anything25982016-08-11T22:11:07.0812229Calum DavidsonPlease consider a total ban as this is such a crucial issue on many levels.25982016-08-12T06:25:44.22712230Rupert PyrahThe illegal killing of protected species continues unabated. The shooting industry has shown itself incapable of self-regulation and there is no alternative to regulation by the Scottish parliament.25982016-08-12T06:43:30.63712231DAVID BRODIEAppalled at our greed and destructive nature in the UK and across the globe. Sharks, Tigers, Rhino, Elephants - the list is endless25982016-08-12T07:01:20.90312232FenbbieUnbelievable!25982016-08-12T09:15:00.8412233JanIt's important to work with countryside interests of course, BUT they have to realise they have a wider responsibility than their own commercial interests and it's now so serious and so obvious the law is being broken that strong sanctions must be applied. Licences must be revoked if raptors are killed - that's the only way to force compliance with the law.25982016-08-12T09:15:23.74712234Hazel HerdThink about the bigger picture and the impact and damage caused by the grouse shoot. It is unethical. Go shoot some clay pigeons, not live birds. 25982016-08-12T09:28:24.71712235Carolyn Hastingsi have never understood why someone would want to kill game birds (or any other living creature) in the name of sport. given the environmental issues surrounding this activity, the death toll of the animals living on the cleared moors, plus the illegal killing of other endangered birds ... this 'sport' needs controlling25982016-08-12T10:03:33.66312236Hazel VeitchShocking that so much damage is caused & cost involved for this so called 'sport' for rich folk.\r\nPlease protect our wildlife and stop this now25982016-08-12T10:17:30.8812237Wildlife & Nature-Loving CitizenPlease, government, care as much and more for the precious wildlife and nature of the whole of the United Kingdom, as your pay packets and fatcat pension pots and expenses allowances, and maybe the Citizens won't find you as appalling, or too toxic to be selected at the ballot box.25982016-08-12T10:19:28.08312238Wendy HartHow come guns dictate the lives and deaths of our wildlife? 25982016-08-12T10:23:20.6812239Frank WatsoThe people responsible for such actions are committing crimes against the planet.25982016-08-12T12:06:58.0512240Christopher PatrickHaving worked as a gamekeeper I know the pressure from employers to maximise game bird numbers. The onus should be on landowners to ensure wildlife is protected and be punished if it isn't. If the landscape cannot support commercially viable numbers of game birds then it shouldn't be licensed for commercial shooting. Licensing is the most rational way of managing the unnecessary persecution of wildlife that, in the eyes of the shooting community, competes with their desire to overpopulate then decimate game birds.25982016-08-12T12:18:34.1812242Chris BettsOne has to ask - are the police genuinely under-resourced to deal with this, just ignorant - or complicit?25982016-08-12T12:37:21.612243Mike BoyceI know that the grouse shooting industry brings in much needed revenue to country areas, but surely there's room for these majestic birds in our skies too25982016-08-12T14:01:24.85712244Lawrence SuttonBirds of prey must be protected. The full force of the law should be used to stop these people killing them.25982016-08-12T14:52:41.83312245Wendé Anne MaunderThe Scottish government has a responsibility and duty to protect the majestic birds of prey that make their home and breed in and around the game parks. Please make sure that these beautiful creatures are valued and given the full protection they obviously need from those who would destroy them.25982016-08-12T15:11:52.05312246Sandra Morrish Now is the time to look in to all the destruction of wildlife that goes on because of Grouse Shooting as well as environmental destruction . We can go on allowing Raptors, Foxes Hares and all manor of Wildlife that are needlessly killed purely for just existing on the same Moor as the Grouse . You do not have the right to destroy life to line your pockets you do not have the right to deplete populations to line your pockets you do not have the right to destroy the moors to just fill them with just with Grouse these Moors are a place to support many types of wildlife and it is not your right to decide what exists there no right at all it is a natural habitat and should exist as one . 25982016-08-12T16:07:42.2812247Veronica LiddellThose in favour of grouse shooting claim it supports many jobs. Don't think the rearing and shooting of birds for pleasure should be praised as a job creation scheme.\r\n25982016-08-12T17:03:00.39712248Connie StanleyLandowners know this is happening, and let the gamekeepers take the blame.25982016-08-12T17:06:37.2712249Dr Dermot J O'BrienA most glorious member of our faune and irreplaceable. Please protect it.25982016-08-12T18:03:25.21712250Anne Harwood-StamperIt is time to stop the persecution and wilful destruction of a protected species. It will not stop until prosecutions are made on the perpetrators who are both known and pleaded guilty. Let the natural order of animals remain to keep Scotland beautiful.25982016-08-12T19:06:43.75712251Judith KelmanGolden eagles are a spectacular and special part of Britain's wildlife. They should be encouraged, not discarded in favour of shooting another species25982016-08-12T19:53:50.65312252Lennox MackenzieThe time is long past for the Scottish Government to enforce a gamebird hunting licencing system for our moorlands our moorlands and to revoke these licences where raptors have been killed or mysteriously disappear along with their tracking devices as in the recent past. If such systems are good enough for other countries in Europe then they must be perfectly acceptable here in Scotland. The Government must act and not be intimidated or held to ransom by these 'landowners' 25982016-08-12T22:09:33.2812253christopher james dobsonApply the law equally to everyone. Simple25982016-08-12T22:48:18.05312254Tim Addinell Golden Eagle is an iconic bird. I invite you to consider the statistical likelihood of 8 satellite tagged birds disappearing in one small area or the tags ceasing to transmit in just one small area in just 5 years ( bearing in mind eagle longevity). Then consider whether just possibly the birds- all 8- might have been illegally killed and the evidence "removed". Then consider whether licensing might just possibly be appropriate. Your conclusion?25982016-08-12T23:11:52.55712255Professor Phillip EvansAll raptors should be protected by law. \r\nNarrow commercial interests destroy the benefit for the Nation. 25982016-08-13T11:37:08.64712256Frederick Anthony LewisThe Scottish government has already set a good example with the vicarious liability legislation. Introducing a licensing scheme would continue to set a good example to the rest of the UK.25982016-08-13T11:59:42.53712257Allyson SmithI don't want to be one of the last people to say they have seen eagles in the wild. These magnificent birds need to be saved. Illegal killings must be investigated and prosecutions must take place.25982016-08-13T12:07:51.47312258paul noakesthe shooting industry has showed it cannot abide by the law so must be regulated in oder to protect Scotland's iconic species25982016-08-13T12:29:53.46712261SandyEnough is really enough. Today the petition to ban driven grouse shooting reached 100,000 signatures and it is time to regulate all game bird shoots. I have no problem with hunting for food. Driven shoots are not about that. Who is going to eat two dozen brace of lead filled birds fed medicated grit to keep ticks at bay? Raptor persecution is a blight on Scotland and how it is seen elsewhere. Sneaky Scotsmen stamping on Goshawks they've trapped to keep the often non Scottish laird happy so that people can pay an inordinate amount to shoot birds they won't eat. While people starve. If our glens can recover from the heather burning, open them up to everyone so we can see recovering populations of Eagles and Harriers. Maybe introduce an Alpha predator that can keep Deer population under control?25982016-08-13T12:32:04.38712262Mick RenderPlease protect our wildlife, they have as much of a right to live as we do.25982016-08-13T12:50:05.37312264Alan PetrieThese morons are criminals who break the law with impunity. Ideally we should ban gamebird shooting 25982016-08-13T15:05:28.2212265FionaPlaying with and influencing Nature is a game we can never win. Chosen to ignore it and thinking we are superior is futile.25982016-08-13T15:31:48.2412266Darrell SymondsGod will Punish these people25982016-08-13T15:44:24.19712267Derick EvansHunting game birds must be regulated to protect wildlife in particular raptors from persecution. Thank you.25982016-08-13T15:48:47.0512268Carol McKinlayThere is no place in civilized society for the killing of wildlife for pleasure. Let's do the right thing.25982016-08-13T15:49:31.97312269Ian BriggsIf the killing of protected species continues the perpetrators must be held accountable. Ban gamebird hunting or have a strict licensing system that would include imprisonment if not adhered to. The law-breaking & irresponsible management of all forms of hunting, must not be allowed to continue no matter how much this industry puts into the economy.25982016-08-13T16:00:15.82312270Tony DuckettWe should be safe guarding our wildlife for future generations 25982016-08-13T16:10:01.07312271David Ellisonit is mainly the over wealthy, such as merchant bankers etc that promote this private pleasure, they need to be made to pay for the protection of these persecuted species25982016-08-13T17:12:17.0212272Andy McNabProtect our birds of prey..\r\n25982016-08-13T17:25:06.5712273Bruce BuswellI live in England. I come on holiday to Scotland, three times already this year, again next month. I like walking, mountainbiking and seeing wildlife. I see the part-burned heather moors as semi-desert for the benefit of few who come from far away, just for the shooting.25982016-08-13T17:37:50.25312274tony driverAll killing of wildlife and driven game should be totally banned as it is in India....just murdering for fun....25982016-08-13T17:43:21.45712275Andrew ParsonsIf it gets going in Scotland we may have a better chance in England and Wales25982016-08-13T18:29:10.51312276RyanLet's create and enforce laws based upon scientific facts (not assertions) that improve our ecosystems25982016-08-13T18:52:15.00312277walter innes#BeNice - regulate, then ban.. 25982016-08-13T20:04:46.4512278MARK MCGHEEit is time to regulate this industry, the majority will be law abiding, however, licensing should bring the others into the fold. Price the licensing so that the new bureaucracy is funded by this fee.\r\n25982016-08-13T20:10:29.74312279William BrameThis INDUSTRY not SPORT relies on the MASS DESTRUCTION OF AVIAN and MAMMALIAN competitors that share the same environmental habitat as the so called "Sport" species. These SPECIES are not the playthings for certain but creatures that evolved on this planet far before our own species and as such should be treated with the respect and reverence that they deserve from our so called civilized and intelligent selves.25982016-08-13T20:14:06.0612280Fiona Watters This is not acceptable.25982016-08-13T22:34:33.98312281Thomas David DickThe so-called "tradition" of gamebird hunting in Scotland is actually an unregulated, out of control mess which relies on the criminal slaughter of supposedly protected birds and mammals. The present situation brings shame on our country. The people who own shooting estates and those who manage them show nothing but contempt for the laws and opinions of the vast majority of the population.Compared to the destruction still being caused to our countryside the imposition of a licensing system is a comparitively small but urgently needed step.25982016-08-13T23:14:51.34712282david jenkinsI disagree with taking life for fun25982016-08-14T07:54:53.20712284Jo MullettPlease protect your best asset, the natural environment. Ensure all biodiversity is protected not just the things that get shot by a few but ecotourism brings in more benefits for the wider economy & community not just estates owners.\r\n25982016-08-14T09:03:56.52712285Kay FoxThere's a magic about visiting Scotland and awwing wild Raptors 25982016-08-14T11:20:22.712286EHThe game bird hunting in Scotland has demonstrated that it is unable to remain within the law, as evidenced by it's trapping and poisoning of birds and other predators. Snares are also a danger to humans. The time has come to take this issue seriously and, given the lack of engagement from this industry, licensing appears to be the only way forward. Licensing is entirely normal in most industries and this must include the power to prevent landowners from shooting and landowners should take responsibility for employees (paid or otherwise) who break the law. Should the law be broken I would expect fines reflective of the profit made from a years' shooting, and repeated offences should involve prison sentences for both the employee and the employer. Only this will be a meaningful deterrent.\r\n 25982016-08-14T11:34:20.45312287Andy DeightonShooting estates have come to believe that they are above the law. They are not, and this petition will help to drive this point home.25982016-08-14T13:03:20.62312288Mike DowsttPlease let these magnificent raptors thrive.\r\nLaw makers, please do more. Much more to protect our wildlife from these evil mindless killers.\r\nPlease increase the sentence for those convicted.\r\nPlease increase the protection and prosecution resource of the Scottish wildlife. 25982016-08-14T16:35:00.32312289BlytheSadly, this petition doesn't go far enough. We already have legislation to protect our wildlife and for decades the shooting industry has blatantly ignored it. Licences will make no difference. The shooting industry has had decades to prove it can police itself and work inside existing laws and failed. A compete ban is the ONLY thing that will save Scotland's iconic species and allow our nature tourism industry to thrive, an industry that sports ten times the number of people alleged to depend on shoots.25982016-08-14T16:37:49.04312290J BurnsThis destruction of wildlife in the name of sport for the wealthy has got to stop. I live in the area and the few jobs that shooting supports are on the whole minimum wage or seasonal. Shooting is not supporting the local community.25982016-08-14T18:48:48.612292Robert BoltonIt's about time serious action was taken to stop the killing of these majestic birds. Why are the satellite tags missing from the dead birds? Unlawful persecution. 25982016-08-14T19:15:22.97712293David SmithThe Scottish Government quite rightly supports grouse shooting and see it as part of its long term tourism strategy. This was confirmed recently by Minister Fergus Ewing. It is valuable to rural communities and must not be damaged by cumbersome and unnecessary regulation. It's all very well for townies to pontificate on these matters, but country people need to earn a living and the SNP government quite rightly support them. well done to them! 25982016-08-14T23:20:41.612295Tim ManderThe persecution of raptors (who hunt to sustain their life and not for personal gain) by those in the pursuit of financial gain (through grouse shooting and the like) should not occur. The raptor needs to eat to live and the game farmer raises grouse to kill for sport. If the game farmer cannot live with, or is not prepared to live with, the occasional loss then licensing is the necessary and correct way forward. 25982016-08-15T03:14:02.28712296Terry BoydWhat is so obvious to some seems so difficult to understand, for those with no peripheral or forward vision. Today's "sport" is tomorrow's environmental disaster. Balance can never be achieved without licensing, as a minimum.25982016-08-15T08:01:05.58312297Ben douglasThe killing of white hares in Angus is deplorable, along with hooked beak slaughter, the price we pay for a few wealthy morons is horrible25982016-08-15T09:02:36.22312298Gary TrewAs a frequent visitor to Scotland, it's difficult enough to see eagles without gamekeepers killing them. They need to get into the modern world.25982016-08-15T09:48:03.22312299MICHAEL O'DONNELLPENALTIES FOR BREACHES OF LAW FOR KILLING OF PROTECTED SPECIES MUST BE TOUGHER AND APPLIED! SUBSIDIES FOR LANDOWNERS CAUGHT SHOULD ALSO BE WITHDRAWN25982016-08-15T10:20:58.36312300Val KeebleHow great would it be if humans could evolve beyond the point where we kill and maim living things for fun?25982016-08-15T10:39:53.80312301David CameronI disagree in principle to the incorrect management of land and the persecution of raptors for the facilitation of the sick indulgence of killing animals!25982016-08-15T10:54:56.2112302Catherine A NorvalSigned25982016-08-15T10:58:16.11712303Grant DonaldsonI call on the Scottish government to stop sitting on the fence and do the right thing for wildlife instead of pandering to landowners who ignore the law and public opinion and insist on killing wildlife in pursuit of profit.25982016-08-15T11:21:28.3412304Alexander BoonThe persecution of wildlife on moorland is totally unnecessary. The effect that raptors, mountain hares, weasels, polecats etc, has on grouse is minute. If you have to keep shooting, leave the others alone, they don't cause you any problems.25982016-08-15T12:04:15.51312305Ken CairnduffA national shame where the benefit of the many is compromised for the benefit of the very few.\r\nThis type of "sport" belongs in another era altogether.\r\n25982016-08-15T12:28:31.30312306phillip harveyI feel more consideration and regulation is required to control this blood sport25982016-08-15T13:25:22.8412307James MeasonPerhaps the RSPB should become the RSPB......protecting only SOME birds. Let me give you an example. The Hen Harrier project in Orkney has been very successful..but at what cost? The Red Grouse population has been decimated. Other small moorland birds have also seen their populations decreased. Birds of prey populations are not an accurate indicator of the general health of our moorlands. Also country sports play a big part in keeping our countryside alive. Many people who live in the countryside and in the Glens look with horror on the proclamations of the city based people of good intentions. In short birds of prey matter but so do the people who work in our country and on our moors. RSPB please present an honest argument instead of playing with the emotions of hose who should be presented with a bigger picture.25982016-08-15T13:33:00.98312308Alexander AdamsThe shooting of hares on the grouse moors to reduce tick numbers is ill thought out. Killing the hares will only reduce the number of hosts available for the ticks and result in an increased numbers of ticks on the grouse.25982016-08-15T14:10:41.4412309Lyn Ibbitson-ElksI visited Scotland for the first time this year. What a beautiful country, I have been missing out. I had a wonderful time and hope to visit again soon. We drove through the moor where the mountain hare had recently been wiped out, there had been a horrific photo on twitter of a trailer full of beautiful but dead white hares and a group of not very nice people posing in front of it. Sadly the moor was silent and devoid of any birds or mammals. Scotland has an abundance of unspoilt places with stunning scenery and wildlife. Natural habitats contain such a wealth of wildlife - there was nothing natural about the empty moor! Here's hoping you do the right thing...25982016-08-15T15:47:16.6412310brian cosnettethe game bird hunting industry should be run like any other business and be scrutinised and comply with any relevant laws and regulations pertaining to it.\r\nHSE regulations for instance which bear huge influence on the workings of the construction and civil engineering industry, should be coming down hard on the game preservation agencies, as should the animal welfare authorities.25982016-08-15T15:55:5312311Tim WatsonMost commercial activities have some form of regulation, fisheries, agriculture, it's part of business life in a mature democracy. Why not gamebird hunting too. Commercial fisheries in the southern oceans require mitigation measures to prevent albatrosses, petrels being caught on longlines-why not mitigation measures to prevent illegal bird crime in gamebird protection-doesn't sound too radical does it?25982016-08-15T16:24:07.84712312stephen tylerThis must stop. It just cannot be allowed to continue any longer. Punishments at the moment are way to lenient and really need to be revised. Time to dish out proper sentences.25982016-08-15T17:09:56.7912313carol bretonthis cruelty to all our wild life must stop now there are no excuses for what is happening.25982016-08-15T17:22:37.5112314Jennifer BairdI'd prefer it was banned and made illegal but regulated is a step in the right direction I suppose.25982016-08-15T18:45:01.86712315Susan Montgomerie It's no coincidence that the majority of raptors are killed on land managed for blood sports. This must be stopped.25982016-08-15T23:01:56.2312316Alan DavisBan all so called field sports25982016-08-16T09:45:03.20712317J MarshallBanning of all 'feild sports' is not the sensible option. This is. Be a realist and not a dreamer. This is the way forward...25982016-08-16T09:48:11.05712318J MarshallBanning all field sports is the answer. Be careful what you wish for. This is the best option. Be a realist and not a dreamer. Sign this25982016-08-16T10:24:34.95312319Norman SmithI consider the killing of any animal for amusement (it is not sport) to be immoral and would prefer that it did not happen. Licensing and control is a step in the right direction.25982016-08-16T11:02:53.55312320John PattersonWe need to be protecting wildlife for future generations and the welfare of the countryside... not slaughtering it!25982016-08-16T11:35:29.4712321Sally UttingThe illegal killing of rare birds of prey on grouse moors needs to be stopped!! 25982016-08-16T12:29:04.0412322EBWith the industry showing no acknowledgment of its issues, utterly refusing to change or shun its members who do not abide by the rules, action simply must be taken.25982016-08-16T13:00:11.96312323Andrew Davies.I would like this needless killing of wildlife to stop before its to late.25982016-08-16T13:49:15.96712324Linda WilsonKilling birds to protect birds to kill for fun. Game bird shooting one of the most destructive and selfish acts perpetrated on our countryside and on our wildlife. A hobby for people with a few quid maintained by illegal activities. 25982016-08-16T18:22:42.8112325Jonathan WallaceSystematic persecution of birds of prey by game-shooting interests has continued for far too long and threatens the survival of viable populations of some species. \r\nIntroduction of a rigorously enforced licensing system for game-bird hunting would be a significant step forward in bring to an end this persecution which has no place in a civilized country.25982016-08-16T18:23:01.35712326Roy LeaderMore folk visit Scotland to enjoy looking at the wildlife than visit to slaughter it, if you want us to keep visiting you need to ensure that the wildlife is not being culled to provide habitat for a single species.25982016-08-16T18:25:27.43712327Sherry JonesI just spent two weeks traveling all over Scotland. It is such a beautiful country. The landscape and wildlife are the country's most important assets. However, I was surprised that more is not done to protect the natural beauty of the country. As a foreigner, I am a little hesitant to comment on your affairs but I urge you to protect what you have. It is unique and rare.25982016-08-16T19:03:35.6912328Vanessa Woodward Ban all field sports25982016-08-16T19:26:07.1212329Morag RansonI think that this licensing would move us towards a better stewardship of our raptors for future generations.25982016-08-16T20:14:55.56712330Amanda MillerA licensing system for gamebird hunting is the only way that Scotland has a chance to secure the future of Golden Eagles and hen harriers..25982016-08-16T20:23:19.12312331Kenneth BellShooting any animal simply for pleasure has no place in a modern society25982016-08-16T20:33:13.51712332Iain MacDonaldIf 10 golden eagles disappear off the GPS tracking system in the same area, will this "co-incidence" be tackled by licensing - I hope so!25982016-08-16T20:39:47.80312333Calum MurrayThe blinkered view by some in the shooting industry, about the killing of protected predators (like our birds of prey) on grouse driven moors makes any chance of ceasing illegal activity a mere dream by the majority public. Regulating this industry through licensing is surely a positive step towards stopping many law breakers in the industry before we lose some of our most iconic wildlife forever. If laws are not being broken, then nobody need worry about such an act being passed in parliament. If they are, those criminals will be recognised.25982016-08-16T21:05:16.1312334Colin WearnPlease end these needless deaths.25982016-08-16T21:06:36.63712335GrahamPlease act in favour of wild birds25982016-08-16T21:22:31.2312336Caroline WellsWe can't go on letting wildlife be exterminated with no scrutiny.25982016-08-16T22:06:05.96712338Marjan HouptJust stop..25982016-08-16T23:57:43.13712340Mike HamblettWould the Scottish Government make an attempt to compile a list of raptors and wild animals killed by the shooting sector. This might hasten a decision on licencing of organised (murder) shoots.25982016-08-17T00:25:45.48712341Pauline greenhalghIf landowners and shoot organisers refuse to put thei house in order and let the wildlife that is native thrive and breed ... In many cases they are not doing this in fact just the opposite in killing everything that should be present on a grouse moor. Those who are killing wiping out competing species should be removed from working in this industry.25982016-08-17T06:38:47.91312342Les WallaceLicensing is a step forward, but a full ban needs to be considered.25982016-08-17T07:24:55.98312343Terry PickfordThis legislation is long over due, recent and past history tell us the shooting community are unable and unwilling to throw away their outdated Victorian ways when it comes to how they treat protected birds of prey.25982016-08-17T07:43:08.53312344Dave JThe illegal killing of raptors is having a major effect on tourism in the Highlands. Act now or count the cost when it's too late.25982016-08-17T07:43:42.73312345Fiona If Europe can do it then so should we! It's all to do with money and the so called 'sport' of shooting 25982016-08-17T08:04:17.9412346Shelagh Maitland The law must mean what it says and be implemented fully 25982016-08-17T08:41:49.112347Diane BartlettWe need a Labour government with Jeremy Corbyn in power to put a stop to this, he will not cower down to the shooting lobby and big business as is happening now.25982016-08-17T08:52:43.49312348Jeff ClarkeAs somebody who works as an ecologist and wildife tour leader in Scotland, it is starkly depressing to see first hand the damage done to the environment by the Grouse Shooting industry. It needs regulating now!25982016-08-17T09:38:5312349Karon HickeyFinancial gain should never be more important than an evenly balanced environment. Humankind should be acting to protect and sustain native species of flora and fauna, not wiping it out for its own gain.25982016-08-17T09:58:07.5212350Susan WattsI don't live in Scotland, but I visit and stay in your wild places, and I love to see the extraordinary wildlife. Please protect it. 25982016-08-17T10:15:50.47312351Linda Brownlie I'm signing this because I care about the wildlifes welfare. 25982016-08-17T11:50:32.9112352Nigel JonesUntil I saw the Countryfile program, I was not aware of the methods used. So, as a frequent walker in the Scottish Highlands and having encountered a very unpleasant and unreasonable English grouse shooter living there, I fully support the idea of greater regulation and abandonment of the 'driven' method.25982016-08-17T13:24:57.5812353John SmartBuilding an economy on the destruction of natural habitat, solely to facilitate the enjoyment of a few privileged individuals, is neither sustainable, nor in the interests of the majority of the population. Rearing harmless creatures, for the purpose of mass murdering them, solely to facilitate the enjoyment of the same few privileged individuals, is disgusting and vile. 25982016-08-17T15:18:02.28312354Richard GillinghamI have visited Scotland on holiday in recent years, in the hope of seeing a Golden Eagle in the wild, but without success so far... It grieves me to think that it is believed 40 eagles have been killed illegally in recent years without any prosecutions. This gives the impression that the Scottish Parliament is not serious about eagle protection...25982016-08-17T15:21:45.6912355HRKI am not convinced that licensing will work but ever an agnostic I suppose it has to be tried. If it works fine, but the proof of the pudding is as they say in the eating or rather a substantive increase in successful breeding attempts by raptors. If it fails then it is evidence in terms of those who would seek to stall the protection process from being strengthened in England. Scotland leads the way through Vicarious Liability, here's wishing you well with licensing. Appreciate that its probably too simple but remove all public subsidies until public benefit can be evidenced? Those subsidies can be used to police the licenses which should not be able to be side-stepped or derogations easily obtained. 25982016-08-17T16:28:25.0712356Denis M. WilsonOur Scottish hills are a man-made wilderness which it is high time to reverse.25982016-08-17T17:19:53.5312357Christine mckinnonUse the normal trackers on the birds but also use an internal tracker, like a microchip, then even when the external ones are removed and destroyed you can still find the bird, also increase the penalties, the gamekeeper is sacked, and loses his licence so he can't work as a gamy again, and the landowner is fined in proportion to his income, the bigger estates, who regularly kill badgers, and raptors with snares and poison, pay a say, 20 percent of their income fine, there are inadequate tracking devices and inadequate penalties, that's why it happens, c25982016-08-17T18:04:18.46312358Peirs HamptonIllegal killings of Raptors must be stopped all together but especially when it is done in the name of rich land owners profit margin.25982016-08-17T18:12:16.0712359Fiona DeaneDiversity of nature involves all that live in it. We must care for the voice less. 25982016-08-17T19:43:10.75312360Richard StubbsI hope sincerely we can make a difference25982016-08-17T20:24:41.10712361Hans SmeetsThis has to stop by proper legal restrictions and maintenance. It can't be that a few rich people spoil wildlife only for their fun and thereby taking away the enjoyment of wildlife from everybody.25982016-08-17T20:51:53.6412362Roger FavellI am disgusted that in the 21st Century that Golden Eagles are being persecuted. My conclusion is that Grouse shooting should be banned. The Game estates have had 50 years to get their house in order, they have failed so a ban is the only answer.25982016-08-17T20:52:01.7212363Helen EldridgeThe death of these magnificent, beautiful birds leaves me feeling literally sick. And poisoning is such a terribly painful death. Britain is supposed to be civilized enough not to do this kind of thing. Please do whatever is needed to halt this cruel practice.\r\n25982016-08-17T21:05:58.812364STEWART TAYLORThe increasingly intensive management of our uplands is in urgent need of regulation. Red grouse are not the only species found in this ecosystem. The ongoing killing of hen harriers and other birds of prey linked to grouse moors also needs addressing. 25982016-08-17T21:37:44.75312365Rosemary AtkinsA licensing system for driven grouse shooting is long overdue. Far too many raptors have been killed to justify that the status quo continues. The game shooting industry claims that it regulates itself but, if so, then it's not doing its job properly, if at all.25982016-08-17T21:43:02.9112366Rob Ballingernot only the persecution of birds but also hares, stoats, badgers, foxs or anything that threatens the grouse HAS TO STOP!25982016-08-17T23:25:36.23712367Jane MasonGamebird hunting (especially driven shoots) rely on the cruel and often illegal persecution of many species of wildlife, but especially protected birds of prey, to help produce the artificially high numbers of game birds. I find this really shocking - medieval behaviour. It's high time that participants were monitored and made to comply with the law.25982016-08-18T01:21:37.58312368Ann GrayWe have a beautiful and delicate planet. Some human impact cannot be helped and we are learning, such a pity that a selfish few have to spoil things for the caring majority.25982016-08-18T03:13:25.23312369Margaret WattChange is necessary. We live in a time when more than ever, animals and land need protection from outdated entitlements. Time to respect and protect our fellow creatures and the land.25982016-08-18T07:36:07.23712370Roger Hughes Enough is enough - it really is time to regulate this industry. 25982016-08-18T08:08:53.16312371Karen Lawson Please protect one of Scotland's greatest assets, it's wildlife and our national bird. 25982016-08-18T09:21:17.34712372Max RussellOur natural heritage should not be destroyed for a barbaric plaything25982016-08-18T09:38:58.36312373mr.a.j.williamsthe killing of our birds of prey , which the whole british public should be able to enjoy , are being killed by a selfish minority to satisfy their lust for killing25982016-08-18T10:08:57.63712374Noel MurrayWhy do these privileged few continuously break the law and have no fear or respect for the consequences. A barbaric past time at the expense of exterminating a species of raptor. \r\nA rich few that clearly show they are untouchable.25982016-08-18T10:26:29.77712376christine nelsonIt just makes sense. Protect OUR wildlife.25982016-08-18T10:26:49.3412377Tom MilneProtection of these rare birds needs to be made more addressed laws changed to ensure greater protection with severe punishment not token punishment taken to its maximum limit. 25982016-08-18T10:40:38.65312378MaryAlso consider the impact of microscopic bits of lead from lead pellets in the environment and in the game you eat.25982016-08-18T11:04:03.11712379suzanne frenchI am signing this because I think it is very important to our eco systems.25982016-08-18T11:52:28.612380trevor edewhile the majority of the hunters are the well off,and have influence,its going to be an uphill strugle.also the majority of people living in the uk couldnt care less.25982016-08-18T12:59:21.3512381phil crennellTime for change, Killing for fun has to be weird and wrong.25982016-08-18T13:53:19.9612382Joanne paterson the shooting of grouse by wealthy cowards is outdated and abhorrent . The hills and moors are for everyone and this legislation is long overdue. 25982016-08-18T14:03:36.68712383John LawsonLet's manage the environment for the good of every creature25982016-08-18T16:07:52.0912384Martin KiddsTime to put an end to the shameful persecution of magnificent birds of prey and other wildlife. This would be an important step towards that and could show Scotland leading the rest of the UK.25982016-08-18T16:46:45.5712385Jason SmithHow long will those involved in gamebird hunting take to get their house in order? The Scottish Government needs to start imposing harsh penalties until these unnecessary and illegal killings of birds of prey is finally stamped out for good. Surely it is known who the culprits are. If it isn't sorted out quickly there won't be any raptors left to protect which I am sure is their intention. Therefore, as a start, a gamebird licencing system should be introduced immediately with even harsher penalties for any infringement imposed as soon after the event as possible. No second chances. Any authority should have a path to being able to get licences invoked if it is deemed a suitable route to getting this problem sorted out for good.25982016-08-18T18:29:57.21312386Barry PriceI am not Scottish, although my mother was born in Glasgow, but I live in the town which is the HQ of the RSPB and am a member along with my wife.\r\n\r\nIt saddens me to know that there are selfish individuals in Scotland who feel it is their right to illegally destroy magnificent birds of prey to protect nothing but the shooting "rights" of the rich and powerful. Scotland, you are better than that - you can introduce legislation which penalises the landholder(s) where illegal killing of birds of prey takes place. Please do it.25982016-08-18T18:45:54.2612387Fred ChrystalStricter sanctions must be imposed for crimes against our birds of prey. Sadly it is very difficult to bring prosecutions against the perpetrators. Sporting estates must bear the responsibility for their staff and the law must do its part by ensuring that those brought to justice are sentenced in a manner that will act as both a warning and deterrent. Surely it is possible for sporting estates and raptors to exist together. 25982016-08-18T19:53:00.5512388Anne AddisonI love to visit Scotland and your superb wildlife. Please now prohibit the killing of raptors by providing the necessary licensing and legislation. Thank you.25982016-08-18T21:00:12.15312389Robert BullockIt's about time that the Scottish Parliament actually did something about the continued irrefutable persecution of eagles and other raptors on shooting estates.25982016-08-18T21:38:04.4412390Barry JordanLets hope the environmental authorities get behind this proposal with enthusiasm25982016-08-18T23:09:14.18712391Gary Agarthis lucrative money making industry for the chosen few, must be told that their gain doesn't justify persecution of something that takes so little of their ill-gotten profits 25982016-08-18T23:25:00.7512392adam HudsonHow many cases of persecution of protected, yes that's 'protected' species do you need to see before you finally make an attempt to uphold the law? Now is the time25982016-08-19T06:49:36.51712393Sophie WellsWe need action from our government and wicket responses from our Police. What is happening to our raptors is abhorrent and we need strong signals from those in authority. Stop letting the estates laugh in all our faces!25982016-08-19T08:24:07.69312394CharlotteKilling animals for 'fun' is unacceptable and must never be condoned so the government should do what's right and ban it outright not just license it.25982016-08-19T09:43:52.54312395PaulaNicola Sturgeon behaves like she wants to save the world. Perhaps she could start by showing more compassion for non-human animals in her own country.25982016-08-19T09:53:11.37712396Nikki BrannanLet's protect our beautiful wildlife and stop needless cruelty. 25982016-08-19T10:34:40.77312397DawnI think it's about time the wildlife was left alone while it's still around to be called wildlife , if things carry on in this world wether it be game birds, birds of prey elephants etc in the future animals and nature will be just stories told of what used to be , humans are just messing things up for the planet 25982016-08-19T10:49:48.8812398Roger MorrisThe killing of any wild animal under the heading of 'sport' is barbaric and cruel.25982016-08-19T10:55:15.0112399Sue adamsOn a visit to Scotland on my honeymoon had the rare opportunity to see a golden eagle. I want to visit and see this bird again. \r\nNeedless killing of birds of prey must stop. We must find a balance. Regulate the hunters with strong actions if rules are broken. We can't loose any more of our wildlife ! 25982016-08-19T11:09:57.39712400James DavidsonI believe that this world would be better if there were no humans as all we have done is ruin the planet25982016-08-19T11:27:56.12312401Linda Marie NelsonScotland is a rare place for Wildlife, Plants, Trees Mountains, Rivers, Lochs and Seas. There is no room for Sport Hunting of any kind. Please leave this fine example of wilderness for observation only!25982016-08-19T11:29:53.47712402Jane AldousThe laws on gamebirds shooting need to be urgently redrawn because too many raptors and other wildlife species are being killed unnecessarily out of sight of the police and other regulators. Wildlife crime demeans us all.25982016-08-19T14:03:42.4112403Robert HayThis is an important issue and licences should be required.25982016-08-19T14:14:20.4412404Peter A T WrightI deplore the effects of driven grouse shooting on the landscapes and related ecology of Scottish countryside.25982016-08-19T14:39:29.3812405Christine DeManuelScotland's rare birds are a great attraction to visitors and unique to you, they must be realistically protected to maintain a safe future for them.25982016-08-19T14:48:22.72312406caroline phibbsI live adjacent to a shoot and they shoot all the wildlife, foxes, birds and even pet cats. Deer are not touched as the game keeper's wife likes them.25982016-08-19T14:48:50.74312407geoff akersthe recent disappearance of a number of golden eagles and a hen harrier on a particular grouse moor, when all their tags stopped working around the same time can be no coincidence. Stop this barbaric "sport" now for the sake of all our wildlife25982016-08-19T14:49:47.5912408HeatherPlease sign this petition, too many of our raptors are being killed illegally.25982016-08-19T15:02:02.0712409Jacqueline McKayThere is no room in a so called civilised society for cruel hunting of gamebirds or any other wild animals in Scotland. These are sentient beings like us who deserve protection from harm. Why can't these depraved hunters with all their cash to burn, spend it on charitable and sustainable causes. There are plenty poor people around the world that need help now.25982016-08-19T15:04:00.94712410Cliff BradshawGrouse Shooting has been shown without any doubt to cause considerable damage to the environment. It also contributes to the destruction of birdlife and other wildlife protected by law! It is an out of date "sport" which in a more enlightened age should be banned like fox hunting has been. 25982016-08-19T15:17:11.13712411Elaine BlackAll Wildlife need protected 25982016-08-19T15:31:25.02712412Lorraine SherryBarbaric ancient ritual no longer tequired in the 21st centuary!!25982016-08-19T15:35:27.15312413Damian MaynardShould a species face its decline for the sake of money and profit? \r\n25982016-08-19T15:46:27.60712414Peter A T WrightI deplore the impact that the management of grouse moors for driven grouse shooting purposes has on their ecological and landscape qualities.25982016-08-19T16:03:06.84312415harry coles IT IS MORE IMPORTANT IN THE SHORT TERM THAT ALL TYPES OF POISON , SNARES , TRAPS ETC ARE BANNED TOTALLY 25982016-08-19T16:12:45.7512416paul allenIts about time we put an end to the Killing of Birds Of Prey.25982016-08-19T16:32:52.09712417Edward JacksonI live in England, but enjoy visiting Scotland to enjoy the hospitality, the wildlife and the landscape. Time and time again I read how your (our) raptors - especially those tagged with satellite trackers - 'disappear', with no explanation, many of them over estates where gamebirds are managed for shooting. A strong, enforceable and rigorously monitored licensing system should ensure land management is sustainable and that the laws to protect raptors and other species such as brown hare are adhered to. Severe penalties and revoking of licences must be available to curtail the wanton destruction of wildlife for the profit of the few. Scottish Government - I hope you will please listen, consider carefully and act. 25982016-08-19T17:07:00.58712418Wilma SummersThe image on your web site keeps jumping about making it very difficult to complete the petition. That apart I detest shooting for sport and hope like fox hunting it will doon be banned altogether25982016-08-19T19:42:19.85312419Dr Ulrich LoeningBirds of prey are noble creatures that deserve our respect and admiration. They do little damage to game birds in practice. And those game birds like woodcocks who are wild and not cultivated also deserve greater protection25982016-08-19T20:06:38.31312420Ian MurrayThere is really no need to kill for sport25982016-08-19T21:00:40.7712421Christina CorserNo more killing of birds of prey. No more shooting of wild life at all by gun crazy idiots. It's time to leave behind the shooting habit for good.25982016-08-19T22:20:36.22312422Michael Thornton We need to stop this senseless killing and protect our wonderful birds of prey. 25982016-08-19T22:46:09.64712423Jeffrey Slocombe Enough is enough, this illegal slaughter of these highly endangered magnificent raptors has to stop !!25982016-08-19T22:53:01.6512424Wesley Weld-MooreTaking away our heritage and denying us the \r\nopportunity to enjoy what should be25982016-08-19T23:07:32.27312425Michael SagarStop killing wildlife to make money.25982016-08-19T23:18:33.68312426Elizabeth SaundersIt is time to bring an end to the blatant flouting of the law regarding the illegal killing of birds of prey.25982016-08-19T23:37:33.04712427Alan SlomanSo many raptors are killed by shooting estates who are determined to wipe out competitor species to their monoculture of grouse. Until all estates are properly licensed this will continue, to Scotland's eternal shame.25982016-08-19T23:59:27.85712428chloe cunninghamits about time killing was wipped out before our bird of prey are!!!25982016-08-20T07:53:41.2912429k.lymburnGreed!25982016-08-20T08:48:53.90712430Mike BaxterThe illegal killing of birds of prey and other undesirables by the grouse farming community is a disgrace and something must be done. 25982016-08-20T09:29:06.73312431Sandra StrathieScotland can do better than this! 25982016-08-20T09:43:14.34312432Hazel EngelWhilst hillwalking, I have seen traps designed to entrap small animals and find this quite despicable. I feel in this day and age, it is inappropriate for the rich and bloodthirsty to see the shooting of grouse and pheasants as sport.25982016-08-20T09:54:49.21312433LildilA licence will only work if it can be policed and removed if laws are broken. Too many people have been cautioned rather than prosecuted over wildlife crime, even when found guilty with evidence. If the few who are breaking the law are not appropriately punished and prosecuted we end up with many people & a great deal of wildlife suffering.25982016-08-20T09:59:31.0812434Derick EvansI would prefer it if Driven Grouse Shooting was banned but if not licensing would help to stop persecution of raptors, mountain hares and other predators that live in Scotland.25982016-08-20T10:19:16.45712435Dan Livingston Birds of prey have MORE rights to hunt than a bunch of bloodthirsty morons with shotguns have. They talk business or boast how much MONEY they have, thinking they're the great hunters, just because they stick on some green wellies and tweed. Can they not share the world with these birds? Don't raptors especially eagles kill more rabbits than birds? \r\nLET THEM LIVE, AND STOP WORRYING ABOUT A FEW QUID LOST TO THE TRUE INHABITANTS OF THE COUNTRYSIDE. 25982016-08-20T11:03:06.66712436Roy TurnbullGrouse moor management, by burning and draining land, minimises its carbon sequestration potential and its capacity for water retention. It is therefore inimical to two major challenges posed by climate change: to reduce CO2 emissions and to mitigate against the risk of flooding.25982016-08-20T11:52:03.60312437Geoff BusbyThey can't keep killing raptors!25982016-08-20T12:13:18.06712438Susan WardGreed before the welfare of our wild animals - it has to stop!25982016-08-20T12:56:02.3812439Susan BeereWe all need to take responsibility for the protection of wildlife. In this case the slaughter of wildlife for the purpose of increasing the population of grouse on the grouse moors of Scotland to enable the rich and privileged to take part in the sport of shooting grouse for the financial gain of the landowners is totally unacceptable and criminal. 25982016-08-20T13:19:54.08312440Brian CordingleyArguably grouse shooting causes much harm to grouse and many other animals. Perhaps shooters could be persuaded that it is possible to enjoy shooting activities that cause much less harm to animal life and which would be more socially acceptable (and cost a deal less money).25982016-08-20T14:56:41.16712441Phil brooks Absolutely disgraceful to let a species die out for the sake of gaming 25982016-08-20T15:06:33.55312442Jane McArthurKilling wildlife, whether protected or not, is just not acceptable in order to further a shooting business.I ask : would it be acceptable for me to commit illegal acts to further my business?25982016-08-20T15:54:53.64312443Charles HopperRemember the (bad) 'things' we hear about through the media is really the tip of the iceberg. It's time to act and I'm proud that Scotland are not afraid to lead the way!25982016-08-20T17:13:55.21712444Emma MontlakeThe game bird industry needs to be regulated in such a way that the public interest of the many, who want to see a diverse natural world thrive, is set against the self interests of the very very few who have commercial interests in seeing our raptor populations decline. 25982016-08-20T17:45:35.18312445carol bretonall types of animal cruelty really needs to stop now.e.g birds of prey do we really want a planet without these lovely birds i do not think so.25982016-08-20T18:12:56.2812447Peter EtheridgeAnything that stops this stupid slaughter is welcome25982016-08-20T18:47:59.77712448Pamela O'DonnellIt is totally unacceptable and cruel to trap other creatures just to keep game bird numbers high. The countryside does not belong only to these game birds. Barbaric, and must be stopped now!25982016-08-20T18:54:22.5912449Mark McManusPlease do something positive about this inexcusable vandalism of our national wildlife. It matters not how you dress this up, at the end of the day it's all about money and removing a natural species for the sake of killing another for fun. 25982016-08-20T19:12:27.51712450John KingLet nature do what it does best25982016-08-20T19:30:40.44712451Terry StockPlease protect our raptors. They need our help. Many are threatened especially our Hen Harriers. .These beautiful birds do not have a voice. We need to use ours on their behalf. 25982016-08-20T20:02:15.25712452Tim robinson when i come to scotland, i expect, want,need to see birds of prey.25982016-08-20T21:00:46.4312453Penny MasonThe public is watching for the government's response - we know self-regulation does not work, do something about it.25982016-08-21T04:09:38.53312454Simon GhilksTime to protect our natural heritage from a selfish few25982016-08-21T07:25:40.71312455Kevin HartSave our raptors please25982016-08-21T08:23:51.22312456Jill ReadLicensing was not something I had thought about before but now I have I'm amazed that any activity that involves killing, guns, dogs is not licensed. High time this is put right.25982016-08-21T08:35:07.36312457Tarun IngvorsenThis needs to be fixed now!25982016-08-21T09:19:06.35312458DougGrouse shoots belong in the Victorian era and have no place in the modern world - and no place in a modern, forward looking Scotland.25982016-08-21T10:26:55.58312459Kenny KortlandClear need for this. 25982016-08-21T11:15:51.4212460Dave KiddOwners of Grouse moors and shooting estates should be held legally liable for the actions of their employees e.g. Gamekeepers. Killing raptors and other predatory birds and animals, to maintain a business, hence a profit, is a crime against nature. As such it is a crime against the population of our country.25982016-08-21T12:20:28.98712461Thomas Plant I have had the pleasure of spending time on some great estates that do not illegally kill native wildlife. These estates are at a disadvantage while the playing field still allows illegal activities to continue. 25982016-08-21T13:56:12.78712462Bruce TaylorEnough is enough. Theland managers have been given their chance to reform, been examined and found wanting. They must go. New managers with more modern ideas required to maximise the benefit that indigenous wildlife brings to the economy.25982016-08-21T14:44:37.88712463Dr Ian DuncanThe illegal persecution of raptors in Scotland is a disgrace and an affront to Scotland's reputation as an environmentally caring country.25982016-08-21T16:08:38.05312464dean higginsplease sort this25982016-08-21T16:40:51.88712465Pam WadcockThe beauty of wildlife is that it is free to live a natural existence. Why do some humans not understand this?25982016-08-21T18:32:19.05712466Lynn BeveridgeDisgusting this is accepted as a "sport" by a lot of ignorant people!!25982016-08-21T20:20:48.2312468susan flemingTHIS ABUSE OF OUR NATIVE WILDLIFE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED!!!!25982016-08-21T20:42:32.3112469Philip PlummerThose breaking the law should be made accountable,25982016-08-21T20:47:33.04312470Catrina BarrettThere are shooting estates that manage to run their shoots without killing important wildlife so why not all25982016-08-21T21:00:25.65312471Jill Beaton InvernessIt's a barbaric act that will wipe out some of our most beautiful species of birds that will be lost forever. Live and let live.25982016-08-21T21:50:04.33312472Gill ReidThe current situation is barbaric, we must support our wildlife not kill it so some people can kill more grouse and pheasants. The situation is getting worse, there is no understanding.25982016-08-21T22:46:07.95312473James HennesseyLicence these shoots now and help safeguard our raptor population.25982016-08-21T23:29:55.53312474A HalesThose running grouse killing now need you to regulate them, they have shown they can't do it.25982016-08-22T00:22:06.79312475Steven Feather The persecution of so many different species so that people can shoot Grouse is completely unacceptable and it needs to stop.25982016-08-22T01:37:31.89712476Margaret LaidlawWhy are we killing these wonderful birds that share same right as we do to live freely on our\r\nbeautiful planet? Lets appreciate them, not slaughter them!25982016-08-22T08:16:45.4612477Ron TurnerNo more Shooting25982016-08-22T08:47:01.03312478Simon hockinThis disgraceful, arrogant and irresponsible approach to the clandestine " management" of shooting estates, completely against the wishes of the vast majority of the Scottish people, has been allowed to continue for far too long. It is well past due that government should take proper responsibility for Scottish wildlife where land owners have consistently shown that they cannot. License shooting estates and ensure that this licensing is contingent on land management practices that befit a modern, progressive society 25982016-08-22T09:13:09.18712479John HighamI think the killing of wildlife or raised and then released animals needs to be carefully regulated to avoid cruelty, suffering, and associated environmental effects. Thank you.25982016-08-22T09:55:46.94312480Juliet RobinsonThis has to stop, now!25982016-08-22T10:31:14.512481S Aindow Game hunting is all about status and profit - why should we sacrifice our beautiful wildlife for such base reasons?25982016-08-22T10:35:18.6912482Jason BirchIt's sickening in this day and age that the killing of our birds of prey is happening for sport and money, it has to stop. 25982016-08-22T10:35:48.81712483Bruce BuswellI live in England. I visit Scotland several times a year and would like to move there. I'd like to see mountains and moorland and their ecology better cared for.25982016-08-22T11:07:24.86312484JenI've signed this but I can't see how licensing is going to make any difference. As we've seen, policing of grouse moor crimes is almost non-existent and the licence cost will be of no consequence to such a big business. Let's hope the petition at least makes some ripples.25982016-08-22T11:21:19.96312485Robin S PerryNot only should all gaming estates be licensed but far, far stiffer penalties should be introduced for this unbridled slaughter and I'm not talking about financial penalties, rather long custodial\r\nsentences for both gamekeepers and estate owners and stewards.25982016-08-22T11:24:59.63712486Michael WhitehouseIt is abundantly clear that Raptors in Scotland need protection from grouse moor owners. This is a step in the right direction.25982016-08-22T11:41:59.85312487David WelchEstates that behave responsibly should have nothing to fear.\r\n\r\nHowever the over-zealous efforts of many to keep people off their estate ground brings suspicion that wrong practices are occurring, when they are not.\r\n\r\nLast night at 7.30 pm I drove down a track I have been using without problems for 50 years, only to bring out the laird of Park and a separate party of two gamekeepers.\r\n\r\nThe laird claimed the track was private even though it led to the village smithy now no longer extant. The same estate has a road with a private notice leading to the village graveyard that has many graves still tended.\r\n\r\nThere ought to be a law prohibiting false claims and display of private road notices.\r\n\r\n25982016-08-22T12:03:41.50312488Allen RycroftThe sight of a Hen Harrier or GoldenEagle in flight is something the next generation are not going to see. This petition has to succeed to stop the killers destroying a lot more of natures wildlife. If a raptor is killed on landowners estate, a right to shoot should be suspended for a period, then a then a total ban put in place for a second offence. The landowner would take more care to ensure illegal shooting didn't take place on his land.25982016-08-22T12:10:33.15312489Caroline CampbellI don't think that any form of killing any living creature can be classed as a "sport!" It's about time we evolved and stopped this cruelty and only then can our beautiful raptors live and peace and in balance with nature! X25982016-08-22T12:12:37.34712490Alan CranstonI support a full ban on driven grouse shooting. But if licensing comes first, so be it, but it must be independently run and it must be driven by outcomes. Right now the challenge is better enforcement of current law on wildlife crime (and licensing will only increase that challenge). It is essential that the Scottish Government show commitment on enforcement immediately. We have had too much denial and procrastination for too long.25982016-08-22T12:43:25.3312491Marion WestonControl is needed and a firm line taken, for example removal of their license, if persecution of birds of prey if found!25982016-08-22T12:55:35.66712492Sheila BaxterRich people killing wild life for fun has nothing to do with preservation.25982016-08-22T12:59:25.61312493Juliette EllisAgree strongly that licensing (and enforcement) must improve on the current situation.25982016-08-22T13:54:41.13712494Linda FisherI think that all game bird shooting should be licensed so that if any shoots or their gamekeepers are found to have killed raptors, their license to shoot can be revoked. This is the only way to stop the indiscriminate killing of our birds of prey, as these people seem to think themselves beyond the law and are allowed to get away with it.25982016-08-22T14:03:08.00312495Elisabeth RitterThere should not be any bird- hunting at all!25982016-08-22T14:05:57.76312496Cath Jenkinson Birds like this are already becoming rare ,why let anyone shoot them is beyond me. This is yet another cruel sport,please don't let this happen.25982016-08-22T14:48:44.8812497KarenThe whole system could switch to a photography based safari hunt...with hen harriers being the highlight.25982016-08-22T15:05:01.112498Jacqueline BurnsSurely the grouse moor owners are capable of raising enough grouse for both birds and shooters.25982016-08-22T15:26:19.0312499Paul careyI don't know which is worse. the callous cruelty of the perpetrators or the indifference of the authorities.25982016-08-22T16:20:09.3612500Paul ChandlerThis should be consigned to history where it belongs25982016-08-22T16:20:44.45312501Ken BillingtonScottish Government should control game bird hunting and shooting industry.25982016-08-22T16:28:19.6612502Angela Scott- hendersonStop before its too late.25982016-08-22T16:32:25.44712503DebbieScotland is such a beautiful country that can only be enhanced by not permitting the extinction or unlawful extermination of such iconic raptors such as the hen harrier, golden eagle, sea eagle.25982016-08-22T16:39:55.8212504Frank CooperWhen will authority recognise the importance of wild life preservation is more important than the ghastly needs of the wealthy few.25982016-08-22T16:44:16.13312505marta falco-ainleyits really sad that we cannot get any honesty with DEFRA. DEFRA appear to support the Countryside Alliance and the shooting industry and landowners who are seemingly supported by the police.25982016-08-22T16:47:41.97312506Anne RyanLet's stop this illegal, barbaric murder.Patience and cooperation with these senseless thugs is not working.25982016-08-22T17:13:20.98312507Ian InnesBarbaric 25982016-08-22T18:08:35.00712508John WalshI am not a Scottish resident, but I often holiday there to enjoy the wildlife. If the Scottish Government were to ignore such a call to at least formally regulate gamebird hunting through licencing, it would give a clear message that my, and other eco-tourists', interests, are not a priority to the way the Scottish countryside is managed.25982016-08-22T18:28:26.45712509Katharine HoranThis industry needs to take responsibility for its impact on our environment.25982016-08-22T19:32:16.60712510Patrick TaylorLicensing schemes work well in other countries, why not Scotland? Any responsible estate would have nothing to fear from such legislation.25982016-08-22T20:04:03.112511Thomas SimcockSomething needs to be done to regulate the pheasant and grouse shooting industry, as it is getting out of control and it is having numerous severely damaging impacts, not least on Scotland's image and reputation.25982016-08-22T20:13:37.53312512Elizabeth HarveyOne of the main reasons I tour Scotland is to see raptors, Ospreys, Golden Eagles, Hen Harriers etc. If no raptors I shall go somewhere else.25982016-08-22T20:32:03.85312513Jacqueline Smithwe are more than the sum of our parts25982016-08-22T20:32:21.36312514Patricia TrickerKilling, except in self-defence, is unacceptable.25982016-08-22T20:56:11.86712515Rob MGrouse management is outdated and destructive.25982016-08-22T20:57:22.30712516Faye simsThis needs change. 25982016-08-22T21:32:41.5312517Sharon HopkinsWhy can't people take up another hobby, one that doesn't involve the killing of wildlife for fun? 25982016-08-22T21:53:18.70312518Suzanne KellyA complete re-think of the commercialisation of our countryside at the expense of 'inconvenient' species including our raptors is long over due. This is a good place to start. The lack of balance in Government environmental groups is noticeable - let's get people with conservation backgrounds equally represented with landowners, fishing interest and hunters - because clearly the balance is in favour of commercial interests and biodiversity is noticeably suffering.25982016-08-22T22:55:16.2912519Lee JohnsonWhen the government are licensing the Badger cull to save cattle from BTB even though there is masses of evidence to the contrary. I don't hold much hope for the raptors when there is so much money involved and influential people involved who own the land. Money talks and always will. Hopefully someone in power will help the wildlife as it is our "The intelligent Species apparently" responsibility to help them.25982016-08-22T22:55:53.24712520Tim GulsonThe hunting community insist on referring to their business as an industry, like any other industry it must be regulated and subjected to regular inspection and audit. This can only be achieved by a licencing and independent scrutiny to ensure that their activities remain within the law.25982016-08-22T23:10:33.98312521Linda JohnstonSomething needs to be done to better protect species as they're clearly being persecuted now.25982016-08-22T23:10:48.12312522Daniel DennisAbsolutely disgraceful. Acknowledge and take action 25982016-08-26T08:20:48.83312523Colin DotchinTo many bikes being stolen throughout all this country something has to be done 26092016-08-26T10:12:36.39312524Tam LoudenI've seen youths on stollen bikes literally hundreds of times when you call the police nothing gets done I don't call the police anymore as I know I'm waisting my time the only way to stop this is to use another method of catching them we should just knock them off the bike as they know the risk they are taking stealing the bike in the first place but our government is to scared to do that in case the little thief hurts them self if they thought they risked being knocked off the bikes they might think again about stealing it in the first place but even when they are caught the punishment is crap so they just keep doing it they put innocent people at risk with the way they drive the bikes on our streets if I drove my bike like that the courts would through the book at me so why not them they are all laughing at our judicial system Scottish government get your act together and get this problem dealt with26092016-08-26T13:32:33.21712525John waughI know lots of people that have had bikes stolen including me. And find its not treated as a serious crime 26092016-08-26T17:41:41.78312526Raymond CameronI too have encountered this in and around the Dumbarton area.26312016-08-26T18:11:42.50712527Euan Daly This is so important and must be heard!26092016-08-26T19:23:58.8612528Natalie Marshall My brother is a biker and had his bike stolen a few years ago by someone under 16. Due to his age nothing was done about it. Theft is theft no matter what age the culprit is. The legal age for criminal culptibility in Scotland is 12 under the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010. So why should under 16s get away with motorcycle theft???26092016-08-26T19:45:10.5712529john rennieIt's time action was taken to deter the people from stealing motorcycles. Stiffer penalties are required.26092016-08-26T23:42:17.412530John JohnstonThe fundamental problem is the youths know that there is no legal consequences.26092016-08-27T01:16:03.99312531Steven Grimley It is now beyond a joke and requires immediate attention to stop this growing problem 26092016-08-27T01:31:57.7612532John Graham This has now got to epidemic and becoming more brazen. Police need more resources to tackle the known individuals and deal with thefts by minors and organised groups .26092016-08-27T11:15:20.61312533James flemingFar to many bikes being stolen and not just for riding in the fields this is stolen to order and will continue until more is done 26092016-08-27T11:15:23.72312534Joseph LairdMotorcycle theft is a massive corrupt business and has never been given the attention it deserves there use to be a dedicated car crime unit within the police which related to car theft a unit with the same dedication should be given to motorcycle theft these people operate with impunity they operate without risk and as usual the public pay.26092016-08-27T16:40:30.14312535Willie WilsonMy F650GS stolen from outside home last year. Found on other side of Edinburgh 10 days later, minus several parts.26092016-08-28T09:00:57.5212536David James DonovanMotorcycles are a significant form of transport for many people going about their personal and occupation, theft is a dreadful thing and every effort should be taken to prevent this. I know the Scottish government is cash strapped according to Nicola but I am sure addressing this problem will earn her a good few browny points26092016-08-28T10:34:30.95312537Dylan CampbellSince iv started riding about a year ago iv heard around 8 bike thefts from friends.26092016-08-28T14:42:16.00312539A cI've lost count how many times I've seen youths with no helmets on riding bikes. \r\n\r\nI've had one bike stolen. I recovered it after two weeks of me going out, not the police, unfortunately it was burnt out..\r\n\r\nI think it's easier to say how many haven't had bikes stolen.\r\n\r\nI also want to point out the non stolen off readers and quad bikes that rip round the estates. I'm not saying outlaw them. But they should made to have ins and follow the same rules ifrhey ride them what is on road.... Or they should have to push them to the bings. 26092016-08-28T15:42:20.46312540Nik oconnor Thieves need dealt with properly by the courts 26092016-08-29T08:31:16.87312541Martin Pennycook This is an area of crime that has not had the resources but behind it. The police know the culprits but the courts do little to assist the battle. We had the bikes of both of my sons bikes stolen earlier this year. 26092016-08-29T10:57:40.41712542christopher jonesI have a new born baby and the trouble we find is cars parking on the pavement and you cannot get past so you need to go onto the road to get past 26312016-08-29T15:08:54.33712543Derek CalderI myself have been a victim of motor cycle theft I feel like many other bikers that there should be harsher sentences for the thieves. They don't care about invading your property or the trauma that people feel let alone the financial costs to the victims 26092016-08-30T11:10:37.97712544Jimmy YoungAny changes need to tackle the real crimes of bikers and not the easy hits such as small number plates targeted by many Police forces. 26092016-08-31T08:39:26.05312545Stephen Gillie The way it is delt with has to be more strict to prevent this happening 26092016-08-31T08:54:18.53712546Stephen CorriganAbout time these crooks get the book thrown at them. Good hard working people are at a loss when these thieves go unpunished or let off with light sentences. The sooner they get dealt with in a robust manner the sooner all the others will take note.26092016-08-31T11:02:08.78712547Stuart Halley Seen youths on stolen bikes with and without helmets riding throughout Edinburgh. Worst of all are the bikes stolen from campsites and B&B's. Foreign plates are common amongst the stolen ones. Had my bike stolen in April.26092016-08-31T11:17:37.85712548James HendersonPolce Scotland are failing to protect motor bikers.26092016-08-31T15:27:43.8612549PaulAs a chinese delivery driver in the pilton area,i see these young lads risking there lives on a daily basis.26092016-08-31T15:48:13.63712550Graham DunnDoes the Scottish Government see this as an issue ? Are they willing to act on the petition and fund Police Scotland accordingly. 26092016-08-31T15:57:25.8812551John DuffyCourts should increase penalties.26092016-08-31T16:50:49.2112552Gordon McLuskieWe need to stamp down hard on motorcycle thieves 26092016-08-31T18:35:44.16712553G BathgateI had my GS1000 stolen years ago and never got it back my mate had his XS850 stolen and fortunately got it back I had an attempted theft of my CB750 F2 as well. Motorcycle theft is getting out of control and it needs stamped out!26092016-08-31T19:35:41.4512554jim Thomson I have seen youths riding 4 times with no helmets. My friend had his bike stolen and I fought the 5 youths smashing his bike up, I took pictures and informed the police but to this day no questions or request for pics have ever been asked of me. I know of minimum 10 who have had bikes stolen. This is becoming a game to these kids and they know the police will do nothing as its dangerous to peruse them. 26092016-08-31T20:45:07.22712555James QuinSomething has to be done or there are going to be vigilantes out there 26092016-08-31T21:22:15.34712556david flynnhad my scooter stolen\r\nsee a few friends bikes stolen\r\nseen kids dozens of times riding with no helmets 26092016-09-01T00:40:27.36712557Andrew Johnston i had two Stolen Bikes drive past me in pilton , No helmets on and hoodies up ! 26092016-09-01T22:42:24.29312558WarrenI regularly see stolen bikes and scooters around Craigmillar, and both my parents and Parents in law have stolen bikes running up and down their streets at all hours of the morning nearly every night. The police never attend. I cannot risk taking my bike anywhere, so rarely use it as a result. I can't park it outside my house for fear it'll be taken. What a way to live.26092016-09-01T22:45:57.85712559Peter Cook3 bikes stolen & 1 attempted theft of a bike in the space of 2 weeks from my work place.26092016-09-03T08:55:43.2912560Ellie CaseNothing much changes. This happened to my Father- in 1972!!!!!!!! 26092016-09-03T20:48:11.49312561Jonathan Candlish Brother of Thomas Candlish had two bikes stolen and seen two chavs in ski masks in gilmerton with no helmets riding stolen red Ducati 26092016-09-04T23:40:31.2912562RichHad my £5000 bike stolen this week, the thieves had it in their possession for longer than I did. I owned it for 48 hours. It has been recovered but the police relapse was awful and I know it wasn't their fault. The fact that the team who deal with these "don't work weekends" is unbelievable. They cannot control this situation if he system doesn't slow them to and this needs to change.26092016-09-05T09:48:57.3412563David green Let's get these scumbags of the streets 26092016-09-05T10:12:36.1112564Shuggie HoskinsPlease take notice of this we need to stop these criminals stealing our motorbikes they are our pride and joy. 26092016-09-05T10:41:45.06712565Amanda SaundersonThe Police may have their hands tied about chasing them but they know who they are and where they live. 26092016-09-05T10:48:06.92712566Jock StewartHad my motorcycle stolen in Edinburgh from a CCTV monitored car park and yet nothing seems to be able to be done. A trawl through social media gives a pretty good idea of the groups involved with this crime wave.26092016-09-05T11:06:52.74312567Aldo WetschLaws have to change from protecting scumbags to protecting law abiding citizens who pay the taxes that ultimately keeps the system going. I for one am sick and tired of hearing about their rights, what about my rights?26092016-09-05T12:28:18.1912568Nick Atkinson I've had 1 bike stolen from me and was on finance and now in debt and seen idiots riding with no helmets 26092016-09-05T12:40:57.86312569Dean BurtIt's not right we work hard for our bikes too have them just taken away 26092016-09-05T13:51:12.6412570Kenny rodger Sock off goin up town and getting past at a red light by some hoodie on someone elses pride and joy26092016-09-05T14:02:54.59312571CliffHad several bikes stolen over the years.26092016-09-05T14:11:55.37712572Aaron Fong Signing to help reduce motorcycle theft. 26092016-09-05T14:23:46.03312573Liam Urquhart I really feel for the guys and girls that had their pride and joy nicked it's really shocking that someone that low who do this. 26092016-09-05T15:16:43.3612574Peter Webster Iv had 1 stolen 1 attempted 2 neighbours nit so lucky. Seen a few can't recall how many over the past year. 2 friends had bikes stolen in the last 3 months26092016-09-05T15:17:22.3712575trishIts a joke that something isint being done but I have also noticed they don't do much about housebraking breaking into garages ect too in my area. Ive known of the police having a chance to catch them and they didn't show till 30 mins after the burglars left. Good luck with petition.26092016-09-05T20:57:33.7512576Tim MitchellI came to Edinburgh for the day and had my bike stolen, police are aware of who's behind it all but are powerless against them, and the criminals know amd exploit this. While we were out looking for our own bike we saw a stolen bike wheelie past a police car through a red light and the police just sat there! We shouldn't be protecting criminals!26092016-09-05T21:19:49.18712577Rebecca robertsonHad them cut across the front of me (and four lanes of dual carriageway in pilton) riding stolen bikes into the flats, no protective gear and no regards for other road users or pedestrians.26092016-09-05T21:50:32.0512578Russell If the police don't have the resource or can't be bother at least don't punish those who chose to do something about it themselves. 26092016-09-05T21:52:21.88312579RayLaw needs to be updated to prosecute and detain underage criminals for adult crimes old enough to steal bikes old enough for 6months in juniorl jail 26092016-09-05T21:58:59.58312580Anita Peeblesfriends helmets were stolen in Edinburgh26092016-09-05T22:30:09.86712581Jonathan Edinburgh is getting to be a no go area for motorcycle S even tourists are getting there bikes stolen not a great advertisement for Edinburgh or Scotland26092016-09-05T23:48:42.1912582KennyHad my bike stolen from work in Edinburgh, luckily they didn't manage to start it and I got it back but this was right next to a rail station and in broad daylight with cctv cameras all around.26092016-09-06T00:03:33.35312583Paul AlexanderThe police are powerless and they know it. Time for some serious changes, people will end up breaking the law to do whats right !26092016-09-06T00:05:14.7912584Paul Alexanderdisgusting we are powerless 26092016-09-06T09:26:54.4512585Jamie andrewsSomething has to be done to stop thieves stealing people's pride and joys I.e their motorbikes without consequence26092016-09-06T12:11:07.1612586Thomas Beckett Had a attempt theft police did 0 26092016-09-06T12:40:53.36312587Paul Sutherland I had a car stolen and the same night the intended to steal on or more of my motorbikes as the keys were in the driveway. I believe they got disturbed or or I would've lost them as well. 26092016-09-06T13:14:33.11712588duncan baillieI want more policing and action to stop motorcycle theft in Edinburgh and prevent further theft. Nowhewre near enough is being done.26092016-09-06T13:48:22.812589Allan Bagley This has gone far enough the bike theives just pick and choose what bike they want to steal, without fear of being caught. The police need to do the job we pay them for and stop this edidemic.26092016-09-06T14:37:56.6812590 Duke of ArgyllThere is a serious spate of motorbike thefts in and around Ediburgh which is not being addressed by the Police. I for one refuse to take my bike to our capital city! Please sort it out ASAP. 26092016-09-06T16:16:29.53712591sri26270If the law insists we pay for our license, tax, insurance, we should be protected by the same government for doing everything to be legal on the road.26092016-09-06T18:51:52.35312592Scott Kelly Not enough been done by the police.! Had my bike stolen over 2 months and heard nothing back at all . But came \r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\nand turned my house looking for weapons because a said a would make the thief's pay for it ... no justice ataw 26092016-09-06T18:59:54.49712593Barry shaw These idiots need stopped 26092016-09-06T19:39:23.34312594Anthony kildayI lived in pilton and other areas in Edinburgh where bike theft of rife, so have witnessed on many occasions young boys riding stolen motorbikes very nice and expensive bikes that were clearly not bought. Have seen them riding at majorly high speeds with no helmet nothing but a hood to protect identity and the fact of no protective gear the police will not pursue they know this and use it to their full advantage of this. If things don't change soon people will just take matters into their own hands. That is not a threat that is just a hard fact. People pay good money and work hard for their machine and will end up paying a premium on the insurance as this will surely have an effect, all to have their pride and joy stolen from them! 26092016-09-06T19:44:18.84712595Tony kildayHave witnessed on more occasions than acceptable young boys riding high power motorbike at majorly excessive speeds with no helmet, as they no the fact that no protective gear no chase! This needs to change and change fast before people take matters into their own hands. That is not a threat just a fact! People work hard for these bikes and they get stolen and nothing done about it because the hands of the police are tied on this matter. These scumbags know this and take full advantage of the situation. 26092016-09-07T11:33:12.8712596Mo Do something about it now , we work hard to pay for our bikes for some scum ned to steal it ! 26092016-09-07T13:18:35.07312597Martin hedgesI had 2 bikes stolen . The police said that they wouldn't chase after thieves. Why not!26092016-09-07T13:21:21.08712598LYN SMITHSomething needs to be done. It's just going to get worse.26092016-09-07T14:13:08.07712599John Witherspoon. If something isn't done. The Bikers will cure the problem!26092016-09-07T15:36:27.8512600Mark hawkinsUntil inocent people are killed nothing will b done. The media needs to highlight this then something might get done.26092016-09-07T16:34:35.07712601VRTwo thefts occurred within a year of each other with arrests (tracked). My bike was kept by the Met for forensics. Two weeks later I am told the chaps got away because there were no witnesses. Their finger prints all over the bike was apparently there because they "were just admiring the bike". I was told they had been previously arrested for bike theft - but got away for same reasons- no witnesses. Seems to be a flaw in the judiciary system. Third bike theft.... I gave up. Owning a high end bike in London is risky because the thieves know they can get away with it. We definitely need to address this issue. 26092016-09-09T22:14:24.5812602craig spencepolice are useless there is no point calling them as they will not get ur bike or the little people hoo stole it 26092016-09-11T13:06:44.7712604Steve mortonPolice should be embarrassed. There to protect us? Too scared to do what is needed. Genuinely feel us bikers are better at their job. I regularly catch them around. Very obvious. Perhaps a need for biker gangs to come back and sort this out.. That's the direction it's going. Inform the police but don't expect satisfactory service. 26092016-09-12T21:14:37.62712605Ben Cropp My bike was stolen today from my work in South Gyle 26092016-09-14T16:05:35.8412606Jody BrownA young lad was stabbed to death in Essex yesterday whilst he was trying to defend his moped from getting stolen. This has to stop! 26092016-09-14T20:36:20.28712607Neil Timlin I use them but not all the time can't afford them 26322016-09-14T20:37:50.7712608karen whitehead Just trialed one brilliant 26322016-09-14T21:25:12.21712609Donna burnsThis improves type 1's health and will prevent longer term issues that cost the NHS more. Also more cost effective when testing with test strips more than 8 times a day. 26322016-09-14T21:41:45.43312610Tricia BreslinMy son has the freestyle libre system and his control is gradually improving, he is testing more, has less episodes of keytones present since using this but it is no more expensive than some of the tubs of strips provided by the NHS. This system is critical for my son to stay alive as he was dying before my eyes26322016-09-15T14:50:06.21312611Frances GrayIt's my understanding that it is illegal in Scotland to park on the pavement.26312016-09-16T11:43:54.73712612Alison MarshallPeople should be able to cross the road easily.26312016-09-16T21:54:36.49312613Angela McBurney Please help 26322016-09-16T22:39:28.54712614Matthew GawnI'm a GP with type 1 diabetes. I'm self funding this item presently and encouraging any patients who can afford to do so to do the same. I have benefited significantly with a reduction in my HBA1C from 61 to 44 in 6 weeks. I am not an advocate for global access as the cost is akin to testing 17 times daily with current testing systems. However with motivate patient selection this is certainly a worthy item to be considered for funding. With more companies come into the market, more substantial funding into the market can only reduce the cost. 26322016-09-16T22:52:57.3612615Bill CornerDiabetes is a growing health issue and hopefully this petition can assist progress to improve the serious problem.26322016-09-17T10:10:09.94312616Rory MalcolmMy son-in-law is a Type 1 diabetic and uses a glucose monitor - but he's very fortunate to be able to afford that. It's making a big difference to his every day life both as a husband and a father, as well as an employee. It seems crazy that someone with coeliac disease can have food on prescription but a type 1 diabetic can't get a monitor!26322016-09-17T10:29:10.55312617Angela Lewis I'm worried for the safety of others and too many kids in accidents including deaths. I understand police can't chase youths on these moter cycles but track these kids down when there not on them is an option. Inforcement of asbo's and educated parents that are none the wiser has to be an option to. We have Community Police officers working in local housing offices which I'm sure they do there best but stricter policy's need to be put in place. 26092016-09-17T10:50:47.712618Rebecca CampbellMy amazing cat was brutally killed last night by the motorbikes and dirt bikes going around the Muirhouse area last night and it has left my family heartbroken this has got to stop26092016-09-17T11:45:11.812619James Yule in St Andrews they park on the pavement even where there are double yellow lines 26312016-09-17T13:15:48.29712620Lisa WrightMy neighbours cat was killed yesterday because of these youths they have no reason to be on them on the roads and pavements, it won't be long before a child is hurt26092016-09-17T19:48:51.9612622LeishaSomething needs to be done to stop these teenagers, proper punishment. Someone innocent is going to be killed not to mention the property that is damaged.26092016-09-17T22:00:26.69312623Mikey banks Far too often I'm seeing youths riding bikes with no protective gear and I'm not in Edinburgh. When I do visit EDINBURGH it's a common occurrence seeing stolen bikes and scooters. 26092016-09-17T22:11:02.38312624 Sha donalsonSick to death of hoodlums day and night on stolen bikes 4 big bikes tonight someone's pride and joy...children almost being mown down as they ride the pavements. .almost cause collisions..old enough to steal a motorbike or car then old enough for police to chase and to hell with the consequences 26092016-09-18T08:49:17.9812627Morag MacdonaldHope the campaign is successful!26322016-09-18T09:14:59.82312628Andrea sommervilleWe r also self funding this saving the nhs a fortune its a essential piece of kit26322016-09-18T10:37:52.93312629Rhona LawsonGreatly needed!26322016-09-18T10:40:21.58712630Jennifer FergusonSomething like this, which helps those with diabetes, should be available at no cost to the patient.26322016-09-18T11:30:01.4212631Audrey MacnabSigned26322016-09-18T12:29:13.32312632alistair macneillLet's hope they listen and do right by all diabetes sufferers26322016-09-18T12:29:50.8512633GraceSigned26322016-09-18T18:23:40.10712634Alison MarshallEveryone needs to be able to cross the road easily. 26312016-09-18T18:52:39.8912635EilidhFind a cure 26322016-09-18T20:50:12.72312636SarahThe issue isn't so much the frontline police, it's the budget preventing long-term initiatives, health and safety gone mad, stopping them chasing them, and finally the courts and social work doing nothing to sort them out. 26092016-09-18T21:31:00.66312637Barbara GirvanThis would make a huge difference to the lives of diabetics. 26322016-09-18T22:00:41.85312638Kay macallisterBreaks my heart to think of my little 5 year old granddaughter having to prick her finger at least 4 times a day for the rest of her life26322016-09-18T22:26:41.24712639Alexander MacDonald Even if it was for under 18 that benefitted from this it would help younger ones a great deal. Please help these wee heroes 26322016-09-19T11:52:19.70312640Theress SemplePlease make this available on the NHS!26322016-09-19T14:07:26.2412641kieran bryson i see where you are coming from as my gran is in a wheelchair and she has to go down her road just to get to a dropped down curb and even then it can some times be a way down the road before she can get to the place she has to get to but anyway i hope more people sign26312016-09-19T18:42:31.8612642James C KeenanIt appears a small price to pay to alleviate pain and discomfort particularly for young sufferers and their parents.26322016-09-19T19:09:43.80312643Robert SharkeyI've been type1 for 38 years and finger pricking up to 6 times a day, this device would be a massive help in making testing easier.26322016-09-19T21:31:08.72712644JohanneThese monitors need to be given on the NHS. Diabetics go through enough & if this can help then... I'm in favour. 26322016-09-19T21:49:39.93312645Heather ThomsonIf it can't be prescribed to everyone with type1 diabetes, please consider it for children at the very least. 26322016-09-19T22:34:38.61312646Lisa .26322016-09-19T22:35:37.55712647LOUISE BEVERIDGE Should be compulsory - no question!26322016-09-20T07:21:30.97712648Sheila macinnesThis should definitely happen26322016-09-20T07:42:15.8512649Donna The cost for my son is actually less than the test strips as he tests 10-12 times a day. 26322016-09-20T09:35:28.27712650DeniseHow many more victims does there have to be?? Cant even walk along water of leith with my young children in a fear they could be run down bybsome idiot on a stolen bike26092016-09-20T15:57:03.68712651Yvonne GardnerAll the best with your petition.\r\nDiabetes needs to be monitored carefully why should folks with type 1 diabetes have to pay for essential equipment? 26322016-09-20T17:23:23.40312652Margaret OliphantDespite having no hypo awareness I have been refused funding for a CGM by my health board which leaves me in a dangerous position and self-funding would be too expensive for me.26322016-09-20T18:24:24.36312653Susan Henderson My son is Type 1 diabetic and this would also greatly help him as he has an insulin pump. 26322016-09-20T20:20:13.8512654Symone kerrMore has to be done about youths stealing bikes and joyriding in edin. Pets being killed is bad enough but what will your answer be when it's a person, more likely a child or older person. Take action now please before someone dies. Tough sentances and more powers for police to intercept and arrest. Marshalling at the moonwalk was dangerous because of them. Riding on pavements with no lights on at high speed.26092016-09-21T11:53:38.95312655Gordon RobertsonIt's not just motor bikes, the same crowd from Pilton and Muirhouse are breaking into houses to get the keys to steal the owners cars. It's only a matter of time before they crash one of these cars into some poor pedestrian. The police and the Courts are powerless to stop them because the current Government will do nothing as they are only interested in one thing!!26092016-09-21T12:51:14.6512656denize fordPlease let this be for all type 1 not just those on a pump. \r\n26322016-09-21T15:57:15.4112657Gillian McKennaOur 2 year old was recently diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes and we cannot quite believe this extremely beneficial aid is not available to patients. The benefits to keeping T1 patients safe and healthy would be invaluable.26322016-09-21T16:54:35.27712658Louise JohnstonPLEASE!!!!!!26322016-09-21T17:47:39.39312659Jackie BuftonWe all need to support this cause26322016-09-21T18:26:54.612660Hazel HamiltonDiabetes has become so common, more research is much needed and monitoring sensors should be readily available26322016-09-21T20:04:25.1612661Laura DochertyX26322016-09-21T20:53:54.76312662Lynn piper Should be given on prescription26322016-09-21T21:10:56.70312663Amanda McCronemy husband is diabetic and this would make a massive difference in controlling his diabetes 26322016-09-21T21:12:08.84312664Darren McCroneWould make a big difference in my overall care as a type 1 diabetic. 26322016-09-21T21:17:44.20312665Sarah youngWhy is this not readily available. Drug addicts everything they need and it is self inflicted.Some of the People who suffer from this condition never had a choice.26322016-09-21T21:27:33.70312666Karen Bennett Great idea, should definitely be rolled out for all diabetics26322016-09-21T22:41:54.29312667Stephen I have been a type 1 diabetic for almost ten years. I've been paying for the freestyle libre CGM for almost a year and it's made a huge difference to my life. When you look at the cost for the blood glucose testing strips, if a diabetic is testing as frequently as is really required to have a good handle of their sugar levels, a CGM system isn't really any more expensive. It makes life much easier too. 26322016-09-21T23:12:10.4712668Kenneth MackayEssential26322016-09-22T01:16:39.4712669Wilfar MathesonDiabetes sufferers have to pay £1200.00 a year to buy this technology, it improve their quality of life and give them greater control over their blood sugar monitoring26322016-09-22T09:39:07.9712670Alfred WildPlease make this available.26322016-09-22T10:05:40.58312671Alexandra JonesMy daughter and son have had T1 diabetes sine they were both 3, now hitting 30. Blood testing can be done 4,5,6,7 or more times a day. Being able to test this way will make such a difference to them26322016-09-22T10:44:45.71312672Jacqueline Taylor Good luck with your petition 26322016-09-22T10:47:49.3412673Linda SinclairThis is so important to help people manage their diabetes and ensure their long term health26322016-09-22T11:29:35.4112674David CampbellCalling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to make continuous glucose monitoring sensors, such as Freestyle Libre, available under prescription to all patients with type 1 diabetes.26322016-09-22T12:26:19.52712675Stephanie HendryThe benefit of these sensors far outweigh the costs. Moreover, long term would save the NHS money. 26322016-09-22T14:32:12.85712676Clare NeillHelp these people have more control of their lives.26322016-09-22T15:28:45.9912677Diane JohnstonThis would help so many diabetics please make this available 26322016-09-22T18:08:46.2512678Amanda Harris Please support this cause 26322016-09-22T18:18:58.06312679David BennettA common problem that often doesn't get the support that it should.26322016-09-22T18:42:47.92312680Catherine WhiteVery important this is looked at. It will make life so much better for people with type 1 diabetes 26322016-09-22T18:53:59.98712681Glenn mckenziePlease get these sensors on prescription. 26322016-09-22T19:05:04.22312682Graeme Wilmington Type I diabetes is prevalent within my family and a constant glucose monitor would absolutely help my family's quality of life. Please listen. 26322016-09-23T06:28:09.2712683Jo HunterPlease consider this it could make a child or adult a huge difference to their life.26322016-09-23T14:42:00.38312684John WallaceGP with special interest in diabetes. I feel this could be revolutionary in improving sugar control in some of our most vulnerable diabetic patients.26322016-09-23T22:27:36.2512685Ann-Marie MacaskillLet's help if we can folks 26322016-09-25T22:08:11.47312686Isla AndersonSurely this should be available free. Cost should never come into people's health and wellbeing 26322016-09-26T07:50:4912687Gail JoycePlease consider funding to make this available on NHS.26322016-09-26T21:21:24.81312688MelissaPlease - this would make my little girls life a little bit easier! 26322016-09-26T21:34:25.3812689Ann-Marie NicolsonMy son and daughter are both Type 1 and to be able to keep an eye on blood sugar levels with this would make a massive difference to their lives. Good luck with this petition.26322016-09-27T14:36:44.15312690Hilary RossMy daughter hates pricking her fingers every day with needles she also has injections several times a day, this would make life a little better for her, I live with 2 type 1 diabetics and if this makes life a little easier for them then so be it..26322016-10-01T22:16:22.94712691Duncan McIntoshHad my garage broken into 3 times and despite chains and locks they got the lot. Police not interested. This needs to change to make theives realise their behaviour is affecting thousands of people and costing lots of stress and expense for decent hard working people. They even stole my children bikes and motorbike gear. seem to know they won't get caught so don't care. 26092016-10-03T21:19:33.32312692 Norrie Spacey It is getting beyond a joke where cars are being allowed to park, corners, double yellows, bus stops etc and the police turn a blind eye26312016-10-03T22:56:45.9312693Tammy See lads on bikes everyday without helmets on disgusting 26092016-10-03T23:02:51.52312694AnnoyedSick of seeing these kids stealing bikes, sick of hearing them racing down the parkway, sick of seeing posts about people's bikes being dumped and set fire to down the beach. The police have allowed it for too long, needs to be addressed. They need real penalties or are we all to live in fear? They're all killing people's cats by running them over now too. Where are the police? Oh that's right, handling petty crimes in Barnton, etc. 26092016-10-03T23:15:28.8412695Kim whyteStarts off targeting poor defenceless animals then what next? They will kill someone if they aren't stopped! 26092016-10-04T00:08:45.2212698Fiona raeIts time to take these monsters of the streets. Their human rights should instantly be revoked & any force should be used. They steal these vehicles (weapons) & get on them knowingly breaking the law. This needs to happen before they kill someone other than themselfs. Helmets or not..26092016-10-04T00:33:27.612699Sara Martin Something needs to be done. These people are hanging around in a large group, riding motorcycles around our streets and local park like maniacs scaring young and old. Attacking people and hurting animals. This is our community and we should all feel safe but we don't. We can't sleep because of the bikes racing round til some days til 3am. It's affecting everyone. Enough is enough. 26092016-10-04T01:25:02.9512700PaulinaI see these guys on motorbikes every single day, sometimes even 3 of them on one bike with no helmets on, only the balaclavas covering their faces. It is not safe to even go for a walk in the evening around the area. Just a nightmare! Especially when considering the fact that they ride on the pavements with high speed. 26092016-10-04T07:03:04.58712702sheila dunbarhow many more are goin to b killed before u do somethin about this 26092016-10-04T07:04:14.54312703Wendy cleary This needs to be dealt with soon 26092016-10-04T07:44:36.12712704Grace Walker Dangerous to public safety \r\nNeeds to be stopped ASAP ! 26092016-10-04T07:46:38.92312705Penny I am scared for my kids as the teenagers are not bothering about any thing or anyone. They are even going on the paths out side my garden. My daughter was crossing the road when the crashed into the caravan. Something has to be done! 26092016-10-04T08:03:53.67712706William WalkerTheft of any kind is wrong but when it encloses violence as well 26092016-10-04T09:02:10.21312707NatashaThis has to stop, the laws have to be changed because they know there can be nothing done to them unless they actually kill an innocent which will happen, its not juat motorbikes its cars too.26092016-10-04T11:49:45.1312708TraceyjeansThey are round my area evety night I've seen lots and helped the police with identity of some off the people and still nothing done 26092016-10-04T11:57:06.89712709Linda mcveySomething really neefs to be done26092016-10-04T13:29:49.93712710VikkiFar too many kids getting hurt with motorbikes 26092016-10-04T17:42:10.12712711Anne_Fraser Something needs done NOW26092016-10-04T20:35:34.66712712Scott CownieBecause these devices measure continuously, it makes it much, much easier to catch a rapid drop in blood sugar long before it gets anywhere near being dangerously low. For a diabetic, that is priceless.26322016-10-04T21:03:48.15712713Susanne Malcolm It's only a matter of time before another families life's end in a tragedy 26092016-10-04T21:25:34.06712714Belinda OrubuAs a member of Pilton community I have noticed how much lawlessness is prevalent with the youth on motorcycles and nothing being done.26092016-10-04T22:22:04.3712715JamieConstantly see motorbikes drive up and down the road outside our flat in Muirhouse area, doing stupid speeds and are presumably stolen.26092016-10-05T15:37:59.72312716Betty StevensonSomething needs to be done before another youngster is killed.26092016-10-05T17:31:33.54312717Margaret OliphantI have been type 1 diabetic for 40 years and no longer have any warning signs of hypos which is extremely dangerous but I have been refused funding for a CGM despite the serious situations I have been in and paramedics being called out several times to get me out of life threatening hypos26322016-10-05T19:42:49.67712718Nicola Zani MacDonaldThis needs to stop, the police actually need to do something about this. 26092016-10-06T18:55:01.8612720john macgregorChurch appointees have no relevance in modern Scotland.26342016-10-06T19:33:16.75712721Alistair McBayThis is a constitutional anachronism and a front to democracy, exploited by the churches for their own advantage. Long past its sell-by date26342016-10-06T20:12:42.91712722Sean DoddsSchools should be secular.26342016-10-06T21:49:02.57312724Graham Barrie Religion has no place in education 26342016-10-06T22:14:52.62312725Coel Hellier, Professor of Astrophysics, Keele UniversityReligion still has too much automatic privilege in the UK. Non-religious people should have equal citizenship and equal status. 26342016-10-07T13:18:53.74312726Neil brownReligious representatives have no place on Council Education Committees.\r\nReligious observance has no place in schools.26342016-10-07T13:56:58.6112727William MeikleIt is totally unacceptable that some positions\r\non CECs are reserved for representatives of religion. 26342016-10-07T17:06:52.49312728Robert WilliamsonI feel very strongly that education should be secular. There should be separation of church and state. Children should be educated together in a secular environment of reason, not separated along religious lines and indoctrinated into whatever religion their parents happen to follow. I believe that Scotland's future as an integrated society where people work and live together in peace depends on separation of church and state and secular education for all. Tax payer money should not be used to create segregation. \r\n26342016-10-08T14:14:57.13712730David Simpson1. No. 2. Yes, but as non-voting advisers. 3. No. 4. Yes. 5. Don't know. 6. Publicise issue. 7. I cannot see how appointing more non-elected members could redress democratic imbalance. 26342016-10-09T13:26:33.21312731Elias James WhitelawNo unelected authority or body not directly subject to a government body should have any possible influence on eduction.26342016-10-09T20:02:49.28312732Jim wilsonWith over 50% of Scots claiming to have no religion why are the religious allowed to have a misappropriate amount of influence?26342016-10-09T23:01:41.23712734Angela SharkeyThis is a matter of life or death and should be considered an essential Type 1 Diabetic monitering tool kit essential. Great invention takes the stress,anxiety and the right to every individuals LIFE 26322016-10-10T12:12:12.34312735Wendy HarrisLive in England but support this petition . If Scotland is enlightened enough perhaps England will follow 26322016-10-10T20:28:52.08312736Lisa PattonDemocracy in our education system. 26342016-10-12T08:43:11.1412737Tony WilliamsThis barely scratches the surface of the privileged place religion has in society. Nothing less than total separation will do. No tax breaks, no charitable status.26342016-10-12T09:12:56.81712738Chris whiteBigotry under the guise of religion is still bigotry & has no place in children's education within a multicultural Scotland in the 21st century.\r\n\r\nUnelected privilege to a minority religion is against democracy and of no educational value.\r\n\r\nReligion is to science & knowledge what alchemy is to chemistry & astrology is to astronomy.\r\n\r\nIt's not the iron age & we've evolved (pun intended).26342016-10-12T10:44:47.95312739Dawn GylesIt seems crazy that this was ever allowed to happen.Everyone should have to be elected. That's called fair.26342016-10-13T15:54:17.2312740Norry PasswayI don't think anybody should have an automatic right to a place on an Education Committee simply because they are a representative of a particular religion. Why should they? What has religion got to do with education in general? 26342016-10-13T19:10:50.00712741Jane NapperReligion should have no place in education in a secular country.26342016-10-13T19:30:25.312742Frank StevensonIf Churches wish to participate on local education committees they can support their members to stand for election and let democracy prevail. The current position is out dated, undemocratic and needs to change. 26342016-10-13T21:49:31.00712743Ross HapperThere is no place for religion in a modern democratic country.26342016-10-14T12:58:59.1812745John WarburtonUnelected religious members on education committees! It's the 21st, not the 19th century.26342016-10-15T00:44:13.39712746John Arthur TurnerChildren need to learn how to discuss,with peers, open ended questions. They should not be deprived of the hard task of developing their own ethical concepts supported by well reasoned arguments and evidence.26342016-10-15T05:09:07.45312748Robert LindsayI see no reason that representatives of a religion should be accorded any favored status or influence in shaping the course of education, simply for the fact that they hold to a faith that requires the suppression of their faculty of reason.26342016-10-15T08:13:59.2612749Richard LeslieTime to remove the interference of all religious organisations from the daily life of schools.26342016-10-15T21:47:48.04312751Megan CrawfordNo religion should ever be privileged over others, nor the non-religious. Scotland deserves better. The Scottish people deserve equality in their education.26342016-10-17T14:43:10.0512752Jack CollSecular matters should be just that.26342016-10-17T22:38:31.0612753Martin MarleyIn the 21st Century, it is preposterous that unelected religious members should sit on our education committees. If we are truly a democracy then we should remember that the majority in Scotland claim to have no religious affiliation.26342016-10-19T19:28:11.45712754paul widdopReligious ethos should be left at the school gate!!26342016-10-20T04:34:25.34312755Norah SpeirsThe education system should be not influenced by any religious denomination having a say in how children are educated as it takes away the fact that many people have chosen not to have their child or children follow any specific religion as they have either chosen not to follow any religion or have chosen to let their child find their own path when they are ready to .26342016-10-20T18:24:59.39312756Daniel OrtizIts a shame I have to do this on behalf of the Scottish Secular society...26342016-10-22T11:57:28.79312758gerald robertsonI find it totally abhorrent that in this day and age we are still accomodating religious thought designed to brainwash another generation of our children26342016-10-29T08:02:18.6212761Gail Addis If Scotland is really 'progressive' it would enact this.26342016-10-30T10:04:57.04712762Willie Ross This is an anachronism. This is the 21st century. Let the children make their own minds up rather than the brainwash of myth and legend.26342016-10-30T15:47:05.4212763James McKennaRemove ALL religious influence from schools.26342016-10-30T15:50:10.4512764Agnes Boyle McKennaRemove ALL religious influence from schools NOW !26342016-10-30T17:40:03.5312765Andrew Downie PhDWhen the education system perpetuates this notion of developing children as Critical Thinkers why do we still have religion in schools especially when they are not allowed to analyse it CRITICALLY. Where does one religion have any more evidence, or any for that matter, that it is more credible than any other mythology? We live in the 21st century not the 12th.26342016-10-31T12:30:35.512766Gavin hunterNo religion in politics please, it's time we stopped letting ancient mythology trump science and research.26342016-10-31T23:18:59.3412768Ruth Law GregoryHas our government the courage to stand up to the entrenched interests of the established churches?the present situation is an offence to the democratic rights of those who hold non-creedal views on religion.26342016-11-01T14:07:23.78712769Janet BriggsAs a Unitarian for some 50 years, I should like to see Education separated from Religion, so no mandatory religious representatives, but rather consultation as appropriate.26342016-11-02T02:31:30.21312770Heather WilsonThis is certainly a concern for us all, in a modern democratic country which we aspire to and which by and large, the Scottish government works hard at ensuring that Scotland progesses in all areas if society. Education must be progressive, and must not cling onto any old fashioned, antiquated ideas of how our young be educated. Religion should be a choice, especially in schools. Children are not there to be indoctrinated, committee members should be elected on merit, with an emphasis on a modern inclusive education system. This anomaly has to be challenged and changed to reflect the equality in education, that is required in vastly important decision making processes. 26342016-11-02T09:28:35.83712771Clive BriggsI believe that spirituality is important and that the variouse faith groups each have much to offer. Education should teach children to think for themselves and provide a start to the teaching of a large selection of the different faith groups in our society26342016-11-03T08:15:35.58712772Kenneth James BruceUnelected and represent only a minority of the population of Scotland. 26342016-11-04T18:17:47.60712775Margaret CameronAll positions on Council Edication Committees should be contestable and all members democratically elected.26342016-11-06T14:03:28.6512777Muriel MackenzieAbout time the Isle of Lewis! Got into the 21 century! Stop the churches ruling our Island!! 26342016-11-06T14:10:10.13712778DRD WoodwardReal leadership steers safe passage through uncharted places ... time to leave the dark ages behind.26342016-11-06T21:27:13.3512779David M. KielyDo please leave the theocratic option to Iran and similar primitive nations. Scotland deserves better.26342016-11-06T21:28:47.6512780Ruth NortonDemocratic representation is required for other governing bodies and is a fairer approach.26342016-11-06T23:18:35.1812781Doug ClarkThere are thousands of distinct religions, all claiming to hold the ''truth''. Hence, at most one of them can be valid. Religion is important to those who choose freely to subscribe to it, but intellectually vulnerable children are not in a position to make such a commitment. Religion should be taught by experts outwith the school environment and in appropriate environments. There should be an age of consent for religion.26342016-11-07T05:12:18.84712782Amanda DarlingReligious morals belong in the church, not imposed upon anyone outwith that.26342016-11-08T14:50:42.2212783Jamie Caldwell We need buses back into public ownership. Private Bus services don't work, 26572016-11-08T16:14:44.26312784Brian BroadleyLive in a rural area regular user of buses. service is deplorable. Recent 30 mile round trip to deliver a document took three and a half hours.26572016-11-08T16:34:33.20312785Stewart DanielsBusses are better publickly owned26572016-11-08T17:55:48.93312786 Barbara irvineAll professionals in Education, Social Work, Health, CAMHS etc need to keep themselves updated as is infact a legal requirement of their professional development and registration. Training from outside agencies especially in the Highlands due to geographical area and distance to central belt. \r\n26922016-11-09T00:26:00.5212788Maria Pereira Is time for the Scottish government do more for the kids and teenagers with PDA received the right treatment and they're families had all the support they need, this kids need education not be kick out of the school because the teachers don't know how treat the kids with PDA.26922016-11-09T01:40:48.07712789Anne-Marie GavinPlease sign this petition and support the campaign 26922016-11-09T07:28:15.88712790James SwanBuses should be a service for people 26572016-11-09T08:16:11.62712791Anne MoodyPDA recognition is imperative for all the children and adults with this condition. Schools, health care, social workers, government and especially the families who have to cope with this condition on a daily basis.26922016-11-09T08:52:46.58712792Helen FergusonParents should not have to fight to get what is a basic human right to be educated. GIRFEC don't just say it DO IT.26922016-11-09T10:09:33.9612793AMANDA BROWNGIVE POWER BACK TO THE PEOPLE26572016-11-09T15:02:11.32712794yvonne whitefordwe desperately need to get rid of first bus26572016-11-09T15:48:55.06712795Annette McKenzie I am Britney's mum please help me change this law so no other mother father siblings go threw what we are 26952016-11-09T16:07:31.35712796Lisa KingHopefully this will save other families from going through the heartache that Britneys family have had to go through x26952016-11-09T16:08:34.35712797leeanne the law should be changed no child should be given this without parents consent or being advised 26952016-11-09T16:17:17.8112798Brenda mcgeown Such a beautiful young girl ! Shame on the nhs! Rest in peace 26952016-11-09T16:41:15.06312799Liz Fildes Change the rules to change someone's life26952016-11-09T18:52:26.34312800Dylan MageeAm signing this potision because I believe the law needs to change I lost my friend after taking pills. it's time we change the law before anyone else's heart is broken.26952016-11-09T19:27:19.2712801Jennifer FergusonThis should have been del with a long time ago but why has it took so long and now we have lost life's through this 26952016-11-09T19:30:54.86312803Clare greigShould be over 18s with parental consent 26952016-11-09T20:43:28.22312805Linda TorranceMental Health issues need to more open and none more so than involving parents for all under 18 year olds in Scotland26952016-11-09T21:44:37.87312807Laura Cunningham Agree completely with this, as a mother of a daughter I would want to know if she was given an kind of medication this could have been prevented!xx26952016-11-09T21:54:37.2812808Angelina The law needs changing and quick to protect young children and parents of going through what tjosb poor mother and family have... as a parent we should be informed no matter what... 26952016-11-09T21:56:06.98312809Jillian Cumming Years and years iv been trying to gain help for myself and 2 out of my 4 children within services , in actual fact over 2 decades for myself and 14 and a half years for my oldest daughter (now 18) who has also slipped through the net! After 3 years of fighting every professional going we've finally been given a date for ados at end of this month for my other daughter who is 14 and a half and hasn't been in mainstream over 3 years.. Inverness Highlands are lacking in professionals experienced in this type of Autism and will pass the buck to parenting issues, I have been trying to educate those involved in my daughters CSP as they are literally clueless. .. We need help and we need it fast! I know at least 20 people personally who are struggling to gain any support from services , It's shocking what these ppl who are suppose to be helping us are failing our children's needs!26922016-11-09T22:38:12.00712810lainy mccartneySigned xx 26952016-11-09T22:50:01.75712811Joanne FaircloughShocking to hear your story, keep strong and good luck x26952016-11-09T22:53:15.47712812Annemarie Penrose I think it ridiculous that doctors can prescribe medication to children without notifying the parents 26952016-11-09T23:08:26.17312813Danielle Get this law changed 26952016-11-09T23:10:15.70712814Mirand Totally agree help can only be giving 2 0ur loved ones if wee no 26952016-11-09T23:16:53.0512815Michelle frielAt aged 16 a child can not buy cigarettes or alcohol but can be prescribed mental health medication without parental knowledge? Something far wrong here26952016-11-09T23:23:01.15312816Pamela BoyleThis should never haappen this needs to be changes26952016-11-09T23:26:45.86312817Tracy WardOverdoses of this magnitude are not only fatal but can be life changing for the individual & families even if prevented from going all the way to suicide, these prescriptions should never be handed out in large doses to kids or anyone due to the mind bending properties in the pills themselves, please stop prescibing them to kids26952016-11-09T23:30:06.74712818Anne smith walker So sorry for ur loss and good luck xx26952016-11-09T23:35:17.76312819Pauline GibsonI can't imagine this happening to a family, but I would be doing the same thing.... Eighteen is a better age for making decisions, but I would suggest that they meed to give them a prescription per day as it is to risky.... 26952016-11-09T23:38:32.55312820Shirley fraserAbsolutely agree26952016-11-09T23:41:53.83312822Aline Roberts I can't believe this could happen !! What a Hell they have put you all through my prayers are with you x26952016-11-09T23:42:50.33712823Pam Cummings This is just heartbreaking and totally avoidable!!26952016-11-09T23:44:43.8212825Joyce BennettPlease stop this irresponsible attitude of our medical professionals 26952016-11-09T23:49:05.56312826DonnaDon't let this happen to another family26952016-11-09T23:54:11.9612827Pearl irvineI have a young granddaughter I would hate for this to happen to her or any young girl I have signed the petition I also want to say I'm so sorry for your loss and I hope your petition is a success!26952016-11-10T00:00:54.74312829Jeannie mundieHope to god this gets sorted dont want another kid to go through this 26952016-11-10T00:12:38.35312833Angela CarrickYoung people are among the most vulnerable members of our society and at an age where everything seems bigger and scarier to them. They don't have the life skills to deal with these tremendous emotional issues. As adults, describing how you feel is difficult enough, to a child it's 100 times harder. Although I fully agree that at 16 yrs, young people have rights as individuals, in cases such as mental health, if the child is though to be at risk, then the medical profession have a duty of care and with the consent of the young person, parent's SHOULD be notified in order to give emotional support and to enable appropriate supervision to ensure the chances of suicide is lessened. 26952016-11-10T00:13:58.96312834April Blanton I support this petition because I have children and they should not receive medication without my consent.26952016-11-10T00:16:11.9412835SusanThinks needs 2 change26952016-11-10T00:28:40.7812838Jean 16 is too young to be left with major decisions on your health, parents must be involved 26952016-11-10T00:35:55.83312839Jamie mckee Britney. Lest. We. Forget. 26952016-11-10T00:45:50.2512840Chelsea mckean I'm so sorry for your loss my thoughts are with you and your family at this time 26952016-11-10T01:11:06.36312841NicolaSorry for your loss26952016-11-10T01:14:00.73712843SIOBHAN BROWN DOCTORS SHOULD NOT BE ALOUD TO GIVE UNDER 18 YEAR OLDS MEDICATION WITHOUT THERE PARENTS KNOWN AS PEOPLE SAY WE ARE MENT TO BE ABLE TO TRUST THE HEALTH PROFESSIONALS BUT THEY COULD HAVE AVOIDED THE DEATH OF THE YOUNG GIRL IF THEY HAD SPOKE TO HER PARENTS ABOUT GIVEN HER THE MEDICATION 26952016-11-10T01:29:24.58312844Sharon dorran Definitely I think it should be 18 to many young life's are taking away far to young...26952016-11-10T01:53:53.5112845Angela costelloIt's a pure shame that the parents don't get told about the medication that is given to there daughter or son. It's wrong. Please hope this action takes place immediately. 26952016-11-10T03:50:47.61312846Rosey mazzoncini fergusonI hope this goes throw as britney was my niece and the loss we all feel will never go away love an miss u loads britney xx26952016-11-10T08:23:30.01712847louise think it's ridiculous that the doctors give children at that age high medication and yes children there only 16 they might be an adult but every parent should have the right to be informed in what there children is taking up to the age of 18 that's the way I see it .26952016-11-10T08:31:11.98712849Lynn sherlockSigned26952016-11-10T08:47:05.35712850Karen KaySigned Good Luck with the outcome26952016-11-10T09:07:05.8712851Ashleigh fogg Personally I think it's terrible that this little girls parents never got told their daughter was suicidal scares me being a mother that this could be my child. It's wrong I totally agree with this petition. Xx26952016-11-10T09:20:58.71712852MarilynGod Bless you darling Annette and I wish you much success in your quest !\r\n26952016-11-10T09:24:46.20712853Katie Gilchrist I have suffered mental, emotional, sexual and physical abuse in my youth so mental health is very close to my heart! Something has to change as young people have no idea that the devastating reality of a wrong decision can change everything in a split second. I was one of the lucky ones. Best of luck with your campaign and my love goes out to all the family's involved. 26952016-11-10T09:29:06.4412854Caitlin cusackDon't think people under the age of 18 should be given any medication without adults permission.26952016-11-10T09:38:41.1712855TrishaKids at 16 should NOT be classed as adults when it comes to medical conditions26952016-11-10T09:56:57.3512856Lizz taylorTotally for this ,lost two adult kids to suicide so with this totally xx26952016-11-10T09:58:05.39312857GillianHeartbreaking...rip young girl xx26952016-11-10T10:03:19.812858Angela bairdThe law must be changed under 18 they are still kidz n parents need to be able to help n support them26952016-11-10T10:27:29.52712859Bryan PorterIt's not a lot to ask!! 26922016-11-10T10:33:13.05312860Una WalkerBring buses under local control 26572016-11-10T10:33:17.43312861Wendy GrahamWholeheartedly agree with this and I'm so sorry for your loss xx26952016-11-10T10:33:23.1812862Fariha ThomasPublic transport should be for the benefit of the public, not for private profits. we need buses to be regulated so that they can meet the public's needs26572016-11-10T10:51:34.7512866Amanda Wilson Parents have a right to kno anything under the age of 21 ma believes expecially with mental health how can wee help if we don't know, 26952016-11-10T10:59:41.48712867Jimmy Cloughleythis is the right road to go26572016-11-10T11:38:36.16312868Amy miller I am signing this in behalf of my cousin that recently took her own life. Myself and family members want they law changes to benefit other people in the same situation as my cousin myself , family and others would like the law changes to guarantee no more people will suffer for as long and as much as my cousin did and for other in the same position as her.26952016-11-10T14:08:37.3812870Mirren sarah I've lost my friend due to medicine of high doses. People need to realise the confidentially is okay but none when depression is not ok. 26952016-11-10T16:13:30.19312871lesley keddieI am so terribly sorry for your loss, this is awful and should never have happened :(26952016-11-10T17:50:45.71312872M GallacherWe need buses back into public ownership. Private Bus services are far too expensive. Pounds before people is their attitude 26572016-11-10T18:31:15.8712873Colin davidsonRich get richer the poor have to walk26572016-11-10T18:55:29.60712874Jenny Douglas In Dundee pensioners and others are basically unable to leave or get to their homes after 6pm. Workers cannot get to work early in the morning. And for those in rural Perthshire it is impossible to get to Ninewells hospital where patients are usually taken. Enough is enough, people before profit, buses need to be taken back into public control. If profits can be made which obviously they are this could be reinvested into improving transport.26572016-11-10T19:08:24.77312875DianeSo sorry for your loss x26952016-11-10T19:21:32.22712876Phil Kirshner Bus deregulation was always predicted to be a disaster when it was implemented in 1986. The bus companies are allowed to cherry pick the financially lucrative routes and leave local authorities to subsidise the socially necessary routes using public money which is paid to the very same bus companies. The reality of Thatcherism and Tory idiology.26572016-11-10T19:59:54.35712878JanParents should be made aware so that they can also look out for danger signs. Only a few days to a weeks supply should be given to patient then they can return to chemist for further supply. Ultimately though Parents should be kept in the loop concerning mental health and care of their children to prevent such a tragedy like this from happening.26952016-11-10T20:35:10.75312879J SmithI'm saddened for your loss, and totally understand your concerns. This is why I've signed your petition.26952016-11-10T21:47:33.8212880Maurice FrankChange of operator on the 63 Gyle-South Queensferry was a good example of a council intervention on a supported route, which I was part of the local pressure for. Let's have that as the model for regulation, and not the old monolithic National companies that covered much of Britain until 1986.26572016-11-10T22:46:54.7812881Lisa MontgomeryI finish work at 4.45pm and I don't get home until after 5.30pm due to the ridiculous bus times & lack of them. If I drove it would take me 10 mins in a car, but I don't drive & the road between both town is a country road with little or no footpaths26572016-11-11T05:06:17.93712882Liliana I'm very sorry for this horrendous tragedy in loosing your little baby girl. I pray that with time you get to feeling better and that this petition helps somebody else's child. May she forever RIP and the Lord accepted her with a lovely embrace.26952016-11-11T06:08:04.95712883Gillian oliverMy heart goes out to all of you it is disastrous what has happened i for one will be doing anything to help26952016-11-11T06:13:27.13312884Heather Gale While we recognise 16 is regarded old enough to marry etc it is still too young. \r\n\r\nIf cannot hand out only a few pills at a time then under 20 should be supervised because 16 is still a child no matter how it's and the child is perceived \r\n\r\nTo be honest anyone suicidal should not get more than couple days supply then reassessed 26952016-11-11T06:16:06.10312885Linda Elder Good luck and I hope this petition makes people stand up and listen before anymore young life's are taken.26952016-11-11T07:27:39.78712886NaomiI am so sorry for your loss xxx26952016-11-11T07:52:51.63312887Sarah Cuerden The law needs to change re the distribution of high levels of prescription drugs to anyone with suicidal thoughts, as well as notifying a family member or close friend regardless of the patients age. 26952016-11-11T07:54:56.11712888Gillian smith Sorry for your loss.. agree should have been told 26952016-11-11T08:03:00.6212889Zoe taggartSo sorry for your loss, you are such a strong person. I totally agree with this petition, it's scary how this goes on without a parents knowledge xxx26952016-11-11T08:57:48.18312891Pamela HuttonHeartbreaking...so sorry for your loss. May this petition protect others in the same situation. Much love xx26952016-11-11T09:16:55.26712893Willie Lawson Nationalise the buses and the trains to run for the people not for profit 26572016-11-11T09:28:39.21712895Anthony NarlochFingers crossed that the petition manages to reach those in power. The loss of a child, any child, is a loss too great. You have my prayers, best wishes and sympathies during this troubling time.26952016-11-11T09:29:48.6412896Connor BeatonPublic services should be run for people, not for profit. Public ownership of buses would bring down fares, and eventually open the way for introducing free public transport - a measure tried and tested in many European and US cities which supports families on low incomes and helps people move from expensive and environmentally-damaging cars onto public transport.26572016-11-11T09:31:27.67712897Louise dolanSo sorry for your loss x26952016-11-11T09:48:52.7212898Amy FortunaI totally agree! X 26952016-11-11T11:39:14.08312901Sue mcnameeHundred percent behind this to many vunerable kids out there need there parents support26952016-11-11T11:48:03.65312902Sheila BryceIf we lose our bus it means that pensioners (of which most of this village is) will have to walk 8mls round trip for doctors, pensions and food. Its bad enough that they cut the service and now we cant get to hospital appointments without take two or three busses. 26572016-11-11T11:57:49.27312903R PayneSuch an awful story, I'm so sorry. I can't begin to imagine what you are going through. 26952016-11-11T12:54:06.97712904Lesley Frame The bus service in my area is appalling. I live 8 miles from Glasgow Cross but it takes about 1.5hrs to get there by bus. Therefore I don't use the bus. Also East Kilbride does not have any connection to Buchanan Bus station, unlike other Lanarkshire towns. There are really poor connections within the town to get to the hospital. All the buses go the same way. Again I live just over 1 mile from Hairmyres Hospital but would require 2 buses. This doesn't even address going between Lanarkshire hospitals. Again all the buses go the same route. Finally there are poor connections for the whole town to use the bus to get to either of the train stations. This is why people still have to use a car. In essence, the bus service does not provide a decent, comprehensive service for the whole of the town. 26572016-11-11T13:52:26.8212906Gayle IrwinBasic rights. This should not have to happen to get more help and awareness. 26922016-11-11T14:10:55.89312907Allan woodSigned as i believe childrens health is more important than saving cash. Help our kids. 26922016-11-11T14:25:13.50312908JakeWould this not increase those under 18 refusing to seek help as their parents would be informed. Confidentiality is sacrosanct in General Practice and those like myself, who choose to seek help at a young age would have been discouraged if their parents were told exactly what was happening. Mental health is stigmatized and anyone seeking help should be able to do so without fear of others knowing what medications they are on as long as they are competent to make their own decisions. 26952016-11-11T14:39:15.93712909Sarah So so sorry for your loss.. I hope this petition wins as I would hate to think my children could be on strong medication or have mental health problems without my knowledge. Keep strong .. Sending love and prayers take care xx 26952016-11-11T15:50:38.62312912Ross sibbaldGive PDA the recognition it should..! 26922016-11-11T16:01:39.6712913Katie de Voy100% agree26952016-11-11T16:14:25.5912915Fiona FrenchYoung people are at particular risk when taking mind-altering prescription drugs. They need to be protected. Far too many have died. 26952016-11-11T17:15:13.56712916Peter MabonWe need better bus services, I'm in Kilmarnock and have seen our services cut, cut, cut, especially the smaller services that don't make much profit.\r\nPensioners and the disabled really need their transport links.\r\nRegulate the buses now.26572016-11-11T18:08:14.51312917Nikki scanlan100% agree 26952016-11-11T18:38:55.31312918NicolaGod Bless x26952016-11-11T18:49:35.69312919Teresa Fitzgerald Helping to raise awareness 26922016-11-11T19:34:33.05712920Joan martinGIRFEC !!!!26922016-11-11T19:48:43.7812921cody durnfordThis is so sad! Rip beautiful girl x26952016-11-11T20:15:28.1412924Claire MuirIt is illegal to force treat and a minor does not have to make decisions without parents. There is too much conflict of interest to leave children at the mercy of people who work for drug companies whilst paid by the NHS. This makes them untrustworthy and therefore requires parental consent, particularly if the child wishes to refuse treatment. No treatment in mental health is medically necessary. Drugs are not the answer and children should learn Nancy Regan's advice "Just say NO!"26952016-11-11T20:30:52.7512925Robert Sims About time Scotland recognise this 26922016-11-11T20:38:05.8512926Fiona smillieAbsolutely neccessary26952016-11-11T20:40:39.0512927Cheryle weir Good luck fiona. Xx26922016-11-11T21:28:55.08712928Lesley dykesHelp our kids!!26922016-11-12T00:00:43.0812930Georgina It's digusting that Dr's feel they can offer drugs to kids mentail health is a big problem an were your mind is not in healthy way all the time hence y loads of people overdose wich young people just as likely or if not more will try to. I think parents should be informed so we know what's going on wiv our children an maybe Dr's should able to send us on a course so that kids an parents can open up to each other. least if us parents know then we can help our kids an I don't think drugs should b given out freely I think Dr's should try a course of councelling an then get the councilers oppion an then it should b discuss wiv parent a the parent should have the final say26952016-11-12T01:26:39.12312931Geraldine ClarkPDA PETITION TO THE SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT-COMMENT\r\n\r\n\r\nMy daughter was the first child in Scotland to be diagnosed with PDA by Professor Newson in 1998. The clinicians at my local CAMH worked with the experts in Nottingham and gained a profound understanding and knowledge of the techniques and resources required to help my daughter. My local Consultant Psychiatrist put in place a support package where my daughter was helped through a combination of attending the CAMH one day a week and the local education authority took on board the advise from the specialists (after much hard work) and my daughter was supported in her local mainstream school by a full time special educational needs assistant til age 15. As a result of the early recognition of PDA by professionals and the correct support package my daughter went onto University to study English, Creative Writing and Journalism. She now owns and runs an internet horror channel. I am extremely proud of her, these children have unique talents and with the right support they can achieve so much. At the time of her diagnosis we were told that many of these children end up in prison or secure units or at best working a half day a week in Tesco. I implore The Scottish Government to promote a wider acceptance, awareness and recognition of PDA . My daughter is living proof that through the correct early assessment, diagnosis and treatment of PDA and the utilization of the correct education and handling guidelines these children can go on to achieve a successful outcome. Please support this petition by Patricia Hewitt and Mary Black so that children with PDA in Scotland can receive the appropriate services and treatment they so desperately need and rightly deserve to become happy and fulfilled individuals like my daughter.26922016-11-12T04:27:02.5312932Philip Travis this has to stop before its to late for others 26952016-11-12T08:09:15.89712934Ginny GibbsHope this succeeds26952016-11-12T10:01:41.50712935Liz REIDFORD So important that as many people as possible sign good luck abs God bless 26952016-11-12T10:25:27.67312936ian massonplease get this passed asap as consultation with and consent from a parent or guardian before prescribing medication to treat mental ill health if the patient is under 18 years of age should have been arranged years ago26952016-11-12T11:26:14.2912937Richard mcdade As a youth worker I strongly agree parents or gaurdians consultations should be a minimum requirement in the process of medicating young people especially when mental well is at further risk by such direct interference therapy as body chemical managmemt26952016-11-12T12:20:45.31312938Elle hanton 100% agree with this 26952016-11-12T13:38:53.56712939Carol BuchanTotally 100% behind u on this cuz.....no parent should have to go through this 26952016-11-12T13:48:33.25712940Paula WebbPDA is an Autism Spectrum Disorder. There has been recent Research that clearly shows that Early Diagnosis and Intervention is the key to children affected with PDA achieving their full potential in life. Children with PDA need to be assessed, diagnosed and their medical, social and educational needs met.\r\nTherefore, unless Professionals are TRAINED to recognise and diagnose this complex and challenging condition these children will continue to be forgotten and misunderstood by professionals.26922016-11-12T15:27:55.53712941christina mazzoncinilaw needs to be change my niece would still be here today if hur family new what she had plsxxxxxxxxx26952016-11-12T15:52:58.55712944Angela McEnroe-Kelly Awful...God bless x \r\nKids in crisis need parents support with depression too even if they do the realise it themselves x26952016-11-12T16:34:14.09712946Angela It's all very well recognising and diagnosing mental health, however it doing the next step which is support, counseling and understanding these diagnosis that people have, Especially if our children have it. 100% agree. 26952016-11-12T17:11:36.3712947Susan Owens They give these pills out like sweets time to change that 26952016-11-12T18:27:49.2412949Robert. ThomsonKeep in public ownership26572016-11-12T21:03:32.13712951J. StewartKeep doing the right thing, Scotland!26922016-11-12T22:24:05.25712952Stephen QuigleyI'm sick of using First buses here in Falkirk but I have no other option because they killed off virtually all competition from independent operators! I want our buses back into public hands! Privatisation is not progress!26572016-11-12T22:39:24.612953Liam fergusonMy local services have been decimated over the years and I've never been consulted or informed until the negative changes are posted at the bus stop.26572016-11-13T00:51:26.77712954Liz hicksIt should never had happened what a waste off a young talented beutiful young life 26952016-11-13T00:52:53.60312955Tony stott The law needs to be changed RIP Britney xx26952016-11-13T08:31:09.7112956Alice McCullenExtreme demand avoidance as a result of extreme autistic anxiety is a dreadful burden for a child and their family. All need informed help, the earlier the better. This keeps families together, prevents crises that can lead to ATU admissions and worse. Professionals need to engage with this horrible condition - Scotland can lead the way26922016-11-13T10:45:56.93312957Christine MacVicsrUntil the whole thinking on psychotropic drugs changes we will continue to have these tragedies. England has had an enquiry into the use of benzodiazepines but Scotland seems to be under the thumb of the drug companies. Other countries are recognising the risks and many concerned physicians have voiced their views, only to be reviled. Are our loved ones' lives worth nothing to those whose only concern is making money?26952016-11-13T10:54:58.29312958Gail BannatynePlease support these children and give them the access to the same opportunities as others. Thank you.26922016-11-13T11:44:58.72312959Fiona RitchieI agree26952016-11-13T13:38:11.31712962Lesley mcshane Think the law should change it could chap ur door at any time some people think no wit will never happen in there family but it could after all it happened to brittney family 26952016-11-13T13:51:11.6112963Laurence EcclesI think most people would agree that it is morally reprehensible for private companies to be making a profit from providing an essential public service.26572016-11-13T14:23:57.56712964janet gastonTotally agree26952016-11-13T14:31:54.82312965Kelly cairnsAgree completely with this, as I think it's ridiculous that Doctors can prescribe medication to kids without notifying the parents.26952016-11-13T14:36:00.65312966Lyndsay GodfreyDone. Good luck. X26952016-11-13T14:37:49.04312967Anna Kennedy OBEThis is a much needed service to support families and individuals affected.26922016-11-13T14:51:03.2112968Carlie Morris I'm signing because I believe this tradegy could of been prevented if her parents knew the risk x good luck xx26952016-11-13T16:01:09.9612970Fiona Jordan 100% agree26952016-11-13T19:07:21.91312971Louisa cavanaghSo sorry for your loss xxx26952016-11-13T22:56:20.87712972Kelly rooney 100%agree 26952016-11-13T23:39:39.60312973Yvonne finnieBehind you 100%26952016-11-14T08:25:18.70312974Nicola Forsyth100% agree26952016-11-14T08:51:25.5112975Jane SherwinPDA is a distinct and recognisable diagnostic profile within the autistic spectrum that requires a differential diagnosis due to the different interventions that are successful. Without greater understanding, awareness and recognition by professionals many children who present with the cluster of symptoms are often left unsupported and misunderstood. At worse they are subjected to the wrong interventions which only serves to exacerbate the situation for the whole family and completely crush the child. The correct diagnosis can lead to a shared approach across all settings and much improved short and long term outlooks. It really is time that health professionals stopped ignoring the validity of this complex condition. 26922016-11-14T09:18:50.5312976David EyreIn my area of East Lothian, First Bus decided to pull out with just six weeks notice. If it hadn't been for the publicly-owned Lothian Buses coming in to set up new services, we would have been in real bother. Now the fares are cheaper, the buses are better and we're getting a late night service. Buses should be regulated, but they should also be in common ownership.26572016-11-14T10:25:01.66312978Natalie McCrindleI have witnessed at first hand the challenges and the personal resilience required to parent a child with PDA, early diagnosis is vital to ensure families are provided with support when they need it.26922016-11-14T10:34:46.05712979Heather Smith Medicalising children should be a last resort.... So many other options are available. Parents can help.... Yey only if they know 26952016-11-14T10:36:16.60312980Mrs MacdonaldWe really need to recognise the disasters that result when parental control is removed - this should completely give parents back their right to parent their beloved children without this state interference except in cases where children are in danger. 26952016-11-14T11:03:09.96712981Laura Mathieson Totally agree, Behind you all the way. 26952016-11-14T13:59:50.33312983Carol parkesA 16 year old is a child, and, one who has mental health issues is particularly vulnerable. They need support and guidance, and should not be prescribed such drugs without the knowledge of a parent or guardian, who can provide ongoing support at home. 26952016-11-14T14:21:11.6512984Helen cairns Sad sad story 26952016-11-14T15:08:37.06312985CarolineI have signed this petition and I sincerely hope that it brings the outcome that we all desire and that is we all agree that a 16 year old is a child. But...the Scottish government may not listen to us as they lowered the voting age to 16 so as far as our government is concerned anyone age 16 is an adult. Good luck and I sincerely hope that the Scottish government listens to us and by changing the legislation regarding 16 year olds and recognising that they are still children tragedies such as this will never happen again.26952016-11-14T17:24:44.53712986Susan WallsThe charity I work for have been providing information and support to parents who call our information line, and many parents have expressed their frustration with the lack of recognition, the lack of proper support for families with a child with PDA syndrome. We signpost parents to the best support we can find and we supported parents to attend a workshop to understand the condition. Parent's feedback they found the information on the condition was relevant, good to have peer support from other parents but trying to find appropriate resources and services that recognise and can support children, young people and their families, was their major challenge. 26922016-11-14T19:27:37.25712988Sophia Prescott Good Luck Annette! I hope you are successful. This could possibly save the life of someone else's child.x26952016-11-14T19:57:22.84712989Michelle batesThis has to be sorted and fast its so wrong what happens to this poor unaware mother knowledge is everything it does save life's 26952016-11-14T22:51:16.04312990MarionNo parent should be left in the dark about their child. Under 18 and vulnerable. The parent should be informed. 26952016-11-15T05:40:24.27312992Anna McCallieTotally agree x26952016-11-15T08:19:03.57712993Lindsay McdougallBeing a mother this terrifies me 26952016-11-15T09:53:17.62312994Sarah NormanTragic overdoses tragic taking of your own life can be stopped children should not being given medication without parents knowing and agreeing to what is happening especially under the age of 1826952016-11-15T10:27:19.96712995Susan boydI would not want my child on antidepresants26952016-11-15T11:03:55.92312996Willie RutherglenPDA is one of a number of conditions that have a massive impact on children, particularly in their early years, that there is insufficient awareness of and support to those affected. The impact and consequent costs in later of failing to recognise and address these needs is immense.26922016-11-15T11:43:21.16312997Ken BuddNext stop, bringing the rail service back into public ownership26572016-11-15T13:07:22.8712998Jennifer Mccleary Being a mother of 3 scares me everyday26952016-11-15T13:15:30.8412999Maureen graham GOOD LUCK annette no mother should have to go throw loosing a child u could be saving someone life's what ur going good on you hunnie xxx 26952016-11-15T14:21:52.00713000Lillias Harper Totally agreed! 26952016-11-15T14:43:56.74313001Hayley harveySigned again as I wasn't sure if my name was down, good luck and I hope you get the result you're looking for x26952016-11-15T14:54:07.03713002Jackie KerrParents have a right to know if a doctor prescribes medication to any child under 1626952016-11-15T16:22:50.83313004Michelle shannonBeen following Britneys story from day 1. I totally agree that parents should have te right to know what medication there kids are receiving. You have my backing 100%. Sending u love xxx26952016-11-15T16:57:52.47713005Tracey connorToo many young lives lost and parents not having the chance to help them x26952016-11-15T17:02:36.00713006Fiona BarrConsultation is surely a way of testing local opinion so more sensible to consult before making a decision.26762016-11-15T17:13:14.1713007Jonathan ArnotThe vulnerable, the elderly and disabled must be cared for equally and with ease of access to benefits and care packages\r\n26762016-11-15T17:38:09.9713009Jacqueline brannan Hiya I support you one hundred percent doctors should not be allowed to prescribe young teenagers any drugs so sorry for your loss 26952016-11-15T17:47:35.7213010Nicola Mccormack Singned and good luck26952016-11-15T17:50:04.06713011Scott Hope this doesn't happen in future and should never had happened in the first place26952016-11-15T17:59:42.34713012Stacey Wood-EverettTotally agree if someone over the age of 18 informs a doctor they are having sucide thoughts there prescription is issued weekly. Why was your daughter issued the full prescription for a month when she told them this. Hope you get some answers x26952016-11-15T18:03:56.62713013Lesley Support britneys mums plea xx26952016-11-15T18:15:10.42713014Paula Louise mcSigned again! Good luck & stay strong 26952016-11-15T18:16:28.4113015Susan AndersonGood Luck 26952016-11-15T18:24:12.09713016Kerry marie burke Totally behind you with this annette xxx26952016-11-15T18:25:43.64313017LiliasTotally agreed26952016-11-15T19:01:34.7913019Rosaleen QuinnSorry for your loss and good luck. I support you 26952016-11-15T19:24:40.1413020Theresa Ritchie16 is not mature enough to left responsible for taking such medication. 26952016-11-15T19:52:02.61313021MarianneThis is gorgeous a good cause. Everyone please sign this petition. This rule needs changed. 26952016-11-15T19:58:36.3613023Margaret CooperAgreed & signed26952016-11-15T20:38:36.41713024Sharon Burns (PACT For Autism Glasgow)I couldn't agree more with this petition. 26922016-11-15T20:59:31.01313026Laurissa HowardSigned, good luck I hope they take notice of this x26952016-11-15T21:07:58.5913027Pamela McGroarty Hope you are successful with this agree this is needed26952016-11-15T21:15:04.12313028Fiona JenkinsPlease ensure public consultation before any changes to the vulnerable groups 26762016-11-15T22:06:27.39713029Marie PearceDon't let older people be prisoners in their homes if there is no decent public transport.26572016-11-15T23:13:26.93313030Kirsty Rest in peace Brittany x26952016-11-16T00:33:40.6813031Andrew GarrettStrongly agree 26952016-11-16T01:42:14.62713033Lee CameronLong overdue!26922016-11-16T03:43:53.9213034Andrea Heartfelt sympathy to you and your family and I agree 100% too many vulnerable children these days who need more help than just medication. 26952016-11-16T06:31:50.16313035Danielle Jata-HallSome countries will diagnose PDA and others won't - this means that it is like disibility discrimination. If your born in one post code you will get support, but by another you are left fighting to clear your name under 'parent blame'. It is a national disgrace 26922016-11-16T09:48:02.51713036Nicola Downie I think that it's ridiculous that CAMHS can recognise PDA in selective areas and not in others. Families cannot access services or support without a diagnosis resulting in struggle and crisis. Children often miss years of education and lots of positive opportunities due to the lack of understanding and support. PDA needs recognition EVERYWHERE as an autism spectrum condition. 26922016-11-16T10:11:37.3513037Laura So sorry for ur loss I agree as a mum of 5 26952016-11-16T10:11:41.0713038Leigh MacdonaldWe live PDA every single day. Experts have recognised PDA traits in my partners son but our local NHS don't recognise this condition therefore he goes without a diagnosis or support. Changes need to be made 26922016-11-16T10:28:28.2913039Anne Fisher This has to recognised by the nhs in scotland by consultants they are failing in providing a service for which families are straining to cope & this is recognised in england & wales by consultants & help is being given 26922016-11-16T10:56:09.48313040Kellyann berney I have mentioned this to professionals many times with regards to my son who has ASD. 26922016-11-16T12:33:24.40313041William LynchThe intransigence and lack of consultation by the our Integrated Joint Board of the Argyll & Bute Health & Social Care Partnership is astonishing. The government who set up this process must put governance rules in place and then monitor to ensure compliance. There should also be consequence for example replacing any board which does not comply with the governance rules26762016-11-16T12:39:55.0613042Jody mckenzie Totally agree with Annette, no child should be giving medication without a parent knowing 26952016-11-16T12:55:25.09313043Freda MarshallWhile a "one design fits all" approach is necessary for the creation of any system of service delivery, it is far too often forgotten that the recipients of the service are individuals with individual needs and the right to take decisions about their own health care themselves. Consequently open consultation and scrutiny should be considered a basic human right.26762016-11-16T13:42:42.08313044Shannon MacleodGoodLuck xxx26952016-11-16T13:51:07.97313045Gillian McGuireTotally agree26952016-11-16T14:09:56.33713046MorganLet's get justice for britney and her family once and for all 26952016-11-16T14:24:52.21313047Amanda Downie PDA is devastating to families and creates so many blocks for children with the condition, resulting in them being misunderstood by people, including health professionals. They deserve to be recognised and supported! 26922016-11-16T14:41:43.54313048Charlene AdamsonSigned, with you all the way Annette xx26952016-11-16T15:03:48.18713049Barbara Joanne BiggersWay too many dangers with this. They may not know other medications involved if purchased at a different pharmacy.26952016-11-16T16:17:59.2613050Kim Horn Any illness should be recognised and supported! 26922016-11-16T16:24:20.7713051Eileen LeaThe I J B should not have been making decisions without consultation PLUS it is imperitive that they have at least (1) person with a medical background26762016-11-16T16:43:07.7813052Connor Stewart Signed, such a sad story but may Britney rest in peace xx26952016-11-16T17:25:51.9213053Jean MoffatDementia patients can be too complicated and demanding for a non professional volunteer service.26762016-11-16T17:32:13.14713054Alice ChurchI disagree with a health code lottery26872016-11-16T19:28:23.4713057David MackenzieWhy does everything have to be privatised26572016-11-16T19:36:27.3513058Alex StewartI can't remember the last time I used the public bus services due to the unreliability of services, the frequency of buses, the route number changes and most importantly the cost of journeys! I have purchased a small car and now drive everywhere I need to go, I get there on time and when I want and the cost over the years that I have been doing this has actually been more cost efficient, reliable and time saving! I will Never use public service buses again until they change things for the better! Come on "HAUD THE BUS"26572016-11-16T19:42:34.40713059Elaine LeggetAs someone who relies on the bus services to get from A to B I am very happy to support this petition26572016-11-16T19:50:08.89313060Angela StewartMy son was only 17 when he hung himself , he had previous history of self harm , drug use and depression . I found out he was sectioned to Leverndale hospital after he hung himself , luckily found by a friend in time , only as said friend tracked me down and called me . My son also jumped in front of a train which was on record . Only because his friend contacted me did I help my son try to regain a semblance of life . My son always knew we were here for him but he didn't want to be a burden , didn't want to disappoint . I support any cause that may keep a young person alive .26952016-11-16T20:38:11.46313061Ellen GardnerI am shocked that a young vulnerable girl who was honest with her GP was given such strong medication and a whole month's supply. I believe parental involvement would have saved this girl's life, please let this be the first step to save future lives.26952016-11-16T20:47:02.66713062James Hartthe no:4 bus no longer runs here in Aberdeen causing dificulty in traveling direct.26572016-11-16T20:53:06.93313063john matthewsits first bus that need to stop running family companys of the road. s.n.p need to put money in to it and make a praivite company ran bye them 26572016-11-16T20:53:35.713064David KellyWorst thing they did was privatise the buses. If we want to reduce pollution we need more buses so we can use our cars less.26572016-11-16T21:01:54.5613065Ian McArthurThere's a real need for the bus services to be regulated, the bus service to the village I stay in is dread. One an hour and it stops at 10 to 6 in the evening, when I was younger it ran till after 11, now, unless you drive up here you're stranded here till after 6 the next morning. 26572016-11-16T21:03:23.54313066Kevin Mchale This is just like the railways put them into private hands and these companies are not interested in people .26572016-11-16T21:05:54.57713067Kenny MooreIn Edinburgh we have the best bus service in Scotland and it must be protected.26572016-11-16T21:24:36.67313068Robert LennoxBring back the buses please26572016-11-16T21:28:41.93713070Jacqueline Hunter Fife is dominated by Stagecoach whose bus services are dreadful, very expensive and do not always turn up whereas at other times they're utterly unpredictable due to how late they run. Government, please do something!!!26572016-11-16T21:29:44.8613071Nadine x Good luck xx26952016-11-16T21:30:11.1413072Kevin SingletonI am a first glasgow inspector and in my opinion regulation is a must I have no doubts about that, we have to provide a better and more frequent service for our customers 26572016-11-16T21:35:00.4713073Bruce JavesA public service should benefit, and be accountable to, the public. End of.26572016-11-16T21:43:21.813075Lesley CochraneIn Renfrewshire McGill's are the main bus company and they are forever pulling buses from scheduled routes especially the 757 Glasgow airport bus. Their drivers are also adept at cheating conncession card holders that have a companion card by charging for concession and companion when there is only a concession passenger travelling. 26572016-11-16T21:55:56.3813076John TaylorWe need to keep the bus service for the community.26572016-11-16T21:56:40.4913077James Brown I live in West Lothian where First Bus have a monopoly. They run services to suit themseves or not. We cannot depend on the bus service in our area. 26572016-11-16T22:04:37.67713078ilona brandwijkI think it is important that the government understands that not everyone has a car and that they need to make a stand against those companies, such as first bus, to tell them if they will not provide a good service for those dependent on that, for both going to work as personal use, they will have to pay back the subsidies. especially the cutbacks in rural areas is absurd and beyond comprehension\r\n 26572016-11-16T22:19:24.4313079Henry DumiganI fully support this petition 26572016-11-16T22:28:40.69713080Elizabeth MarrPrivate companies rob the public.26572016-11-16T22:29:26.07313081Diane LemaitreOcular melanoma took my mother's life when the spread of this was not detected until it was too late. An MRI scan could have saved her life by giving her the treatment she needed early enough26872016-11-16T22:41:21.8413082Sharon DalyGood luck. My heart breaks for you xxxx26952016-11-16T22:45:13.8413083Chrissy GowerParents of children with this problem really need more support. 26922016-11-16T22:57:41.54313084Julie morton It's so important for everyone to have mri regular to detect early mets x ultrasounds are useless if ocular melanoma spreads to liver ect would and could be lifesaving for us .. unfair some get and some don't... 26872016-11-16T23:02:26.79313085Clare daviesFully support this petition.26872016-11-16T23:14:13.57713086alan sidawayI am in my mid 70's and get fed up waiting for buses that never come26572016-11-16T23:17:46.15713087Scott CraigPublic transport should never be in the private sector. 26572016-11-16T23:23:42.3913088Edith Grant I have spoken to a lot of people who have kids are on low income are struggling to pay bus fares as it has increased. The Lothian buses and other bus companys are more concerned about there profits, not for the public in Scotland . 26572016-11-16T23:23:54.7513089douglas cavenJust recently Stagecoach buses in Dumfries going to Glasgow and return have decided to put in buses not suitable for disabled people as all seats are upstairs bar 2. Not suitable for wheelchair users or people with walking disabilities. What can be done?26572016-11-16T23:26:43.28313090evelyn cavenBuses cold and uncomfortable due to poor suspension and no seat belts. Drivers are pushed to limit by breaking speed limits on roads to make their timetables and makes journeys more uncomfortable. Could this be one reason for not using buses both from a comfort and also a safety issue.26572016-11-16T23:27:34.2213091Thomas wilsonThe consultation process is a sham26762016-11-16T23:51:57.3813092margo DAVID I PAY £118 PER MONTH FOR A ZONECARD. WE HAVE NO BUS SERVICE FROM pAILSE x to todholm and hunterhill after 8pm. i work shifts and often have to pay for a taxi, on top of zone card at least 10 times per month. im a women in her 50s and have to walk along dark roads to get home, a mile away26572016-11-16T23:58:49.4613094Lesley SutherlandAs a frequent bus user I think it is very important to protect and improve bus services and to encourage the use of public transport. Local authorities having the power to regulate bus services would make that easier.26572016-11-17T00:01:50.613095Jacqueline MccullochPublic transport is an essential service and should not be in the hands of private companies out to make a profit. 26572016-11-17T00:12:48.113097Heather coxI lost my son to suicide26952016-11-17T00:33:55.32313099Anthony tottenMy teenage daughter had to stop workong in a job she liked and worked hard in at the back o hills industrial estate at the raploch stirling as first bus stopped the service route from stirling to glasgow via denny after 6 pm in the evening, and subsequently is now unemployed due to the bus service routes being taken off the road. Such a shame when they say that the young dont wana work and they want people to use public transport at super inflated prices which they know most people cant afford but have no choice.\r\nI would personally like, along with lots of family and friends, to see the bus services regulated by the local councils in every authority throughout Scotland, and i think they can all take a leaf out of lothian buses and tram services in edinburgh..such a credit to scotland's infrastructure even tho it took a fair bit of time to put in place ..26572016-11-17T00:36:07.29313100Maureen foyThis needs to be stopped26952016-11-17T00:36:32.74313101Aleks JurczykPublic transport in Glasgow is among the very worst I have used in anywhere in the world. A huge contributory factor to the appalling service we receive is the private ownership of these services. In order to have a service that is fit for our city we must bring our bus services back into public ownership as quickly as possible.26572016-11-17T00:41:10.6213102George Bathgate I would like to see West Lothian run by Lothian buses instead of first bus. Lothian buses run a well maintained fleet of vehicles compared to first bus.26572016-11-17T02:29:35.8713104Lauren mckeeThe parent or guardian has a right to know which medication there dependant is on .. it is there responsibility to look out for these kids ... they are kids until they are roughly 18 even at that some are a little less mature than others so no matter what the parent or guardian has a right to know .26952016-11-17T05:03:45.47713105Shirley Lewis Public transport needs to be sorted out and updated 26572016-11-17T05:16:31.71313106Gary PatonI live in Dalry, Ayrshire and the first bus to my work in Stevenson is 07.13. This is not acceptable!!26572016-11-17T05:27:01.48713107Kenneth McewanThe bus services in Coatbridge are an absolute disgrace there are no local buses after 6 in my area26572016-11-17T05:51:07.26313109ThomasTylerThe Bus service in Shetland is poor enough already we cannot afford to loose any more of the service.26572016-11-17T06:31:54.21713112Stephen Thomas Far to few far to expensive, cheaper and easierto run a car. 26572016-11-17T07:11:32.9313114Irene mckirdyLet's support a good cause26872016-11-17T07:34:36.33313115Tanya HennebryBus prices are scandalous and First Bus should be held accountable. In Dumbarton they are the only bus company as the other independent companies got pushed out like McColls, McGills.\r\nI am just back from Perth Western Australia and our MSP & MPs could learn a lot from how their not only bus services work but their public transport as a whole.\r\n\r\nLower your prices First Bus26572016-11-17T07:37:41.4913116matt lauchlandue to poor service people in our area now look on owning some form of transport as essential , if working in Glasgow or further afield bus only takes one route , before privatisation we had bus service covering various routes giving access to 3 main hospitals serving Glasgow and Lanarkshire ,none of these are available now ,either car required or various change of buses to get to these important destinations. 26572016-11-17T07:39:01.27313117William GreenBuses should be in common ownership, because it puts the public first with cheaper fares and better buses, also can provide a top class service! 26572016-11-17T07:47:47.9913118Jane TurlandFor patients with Ocular Melanoma it is the only option for precise detection of liver secondaries early enough to offer some intervention to prolong life26872016-11-17T07:48:55.5713119William GreenBuses in common ownership produces a bus service which is second to none! I am a bus driver for Lothian buses and was recently working at first and the gulf is massive! If you want to be proud of your bus service it's the only way!26572016-11-17T08:17:23.81313121Rodh MilneWhere I stay, we don't even get reliable buses, ie. they break down frequently. Also the last bus from the city of Elgin leaves at just after 1800 hrs which means getting a taxi for the ten mile journey home.26572016-11-17T08:34:11.10713123Elizabeth Reilly Where I stay we have one bus per hour26572016-11-17T08:37:52.19313124Robert McLellanUnite could have done this in 2012 for all Renfrewshire but as usual said a lot, promise a lot and done nothing letting paying members down member total disgrace.26572016-11-17T08:40:2913125colin george bruce mackaybus services are crucial specially in rural ares26572016-11-17T08:41:30.47313126Sally WatsonPrivate bus operators are becoming less and less accountable. Last month First Bus in Glasgow withdrew the 4A from Kelvindale, leaving a whole community with no bus service. They refused to budge despite over 3,000 people signing a petition and representations from local councillors and MSPs. It's essential they're regulated or they will continue putting profit before people.26572016-11-17T08:43:54.94313127Philip ConnellyServices through my local area have been severely curtailed making it much more difficult for non-motorists to travel. It is especially hard on vulnerable people who have become more isolated. The population of my local area has increased but the bus service has become poorer. 26572016-11-17T08:44:03.72313128Sally WatsonRecently First Bus in Glasgow withdrew the only bus service in Kelvindale, leaving a whole community with no bus access. This despite over 3,000 people signing a petition and representations from local councillors and MSPs. It's essential they are regulated, otherwise they will continue putting profit before people and no one can stop them.26572016-11-17T08:44:33.48313129John Thomas ReillyNot before time someone took the lead on this having worked in first bus for the last 8 years i have never known working conditions for our members to be so bad with drivers safety being put at risk by a total failure of this company to meet their license requirements .\r\nHaving spent 2 hours trying to get from Caledonia depot to East Kilbride on Sunday night i totally understand the anger of the public unfortunatley the drivers are at the front end of this anger and ignorant staff managers have a couldnt care less attitude to what is going on.\r\n26572016-11-17T08:58:52.2513130Anne NewlandsWould love to use the bus more but there just aren't many going at a suitable time and the price is ridiculous compared to other areas. Lower the price increase the availability and lets us see what happens. 26572016-11-17T09:06:58.25313131Nigel Gordon DaviesFrom my address you might think what is he on about. Like a significant minority I rely on lifts or the bus to get about - whether for shopping, meeting family and friends or visiting my GP.\r\nThe main local bus operator in Fife has in the past 3 months slashed routes in Sth Fife, pleading lack of public subsidy. The truth is brutal - Stagecoach are a business and do not provide a public service 26572016-11-17T09:07:15.313132Mark McErlaneGreenock has become a Wild West Town with only one main provider of buses who can then decide all timetables to suit the taxi busisness which the same family own 26572016-11-17T09:07:52.19713133Jim ListerMy City, Glasgow, has one of the lowest rates of car ownership (not a bad thing) yet the highest bus fares of any UK city, that can't be right. Why can't the Lothian Buses model be adopted?26572016-11-17T09:22:14.2313134Raymond McDonaldBorn of a half decent idea, now greed has taken over so nuff is enough. Lets take back control because people are the power. 26572016-11-17T09:26:40.21713135Yvonne DuniganCan't believe you can't get a bus from Cumbernauld to Edinburgh......26572016-11-17T10:02:46.2613137Patricia McQuillanGlasgow is one of the most deprived city's in Europe yet it has one of the highest bus fares in Europe it's a dis grace I have been fighting with first bus for years about their services and fares.26572016-11-17T10:08:57.57313138Jock LonsdaleKeep our buses alive26572016-11-17T10:23:57.4513140Jacqueline QuinnMRI scans are extremely important in detecting early metastatic disease in those with Ocular Melanoma, enabling patients to access life prolonging treatment.26872016-11-17T10:25:53.9913141James Davidsonwe all need public transport26572016-11-17T10:26:23.98313142Dave StylesNo wonder people don't use the buses. They are run for profit and not service, at the convince of the operator, not the client.\r\n\r\nThis is a service for people that don't have their own transport, it is not a luxury or a perk it is requirement for sustainability within Scotland. 26572016-11-17T10:34:04.75713143RODERICK NEIL BRUCEI am one of the Scottish Bus Group Drivers who suffered and lost Pension because of Privatisation, all the operators now are interested in is profit. Margaret Thatcher gave them a licence to print money.time to get Buses back into Public ownership26572016-11-17T10:34:31.1413144Stewart DanielsBus fares are a rip off26572016-11-17T10:53:40.37313147david smithBus services and the industry has been in a mess for years.Bring them back under public control.26572016-11-17T10:59:49.9113148Jenny KempPublic transport should be affordable and accessible for all. Regulation and common ownership are both means to achieving a system that works for everyone and isn't profit driven. 26572016-11-17T11:18:58.92313149Donna ClarkMy Area Aberdeen has the highest prices a shocking service & we are never consulted on changes to services.We get poor quality.26572016-11-17T11:26:27.27313150Stuart JohnstonOnly one bus from Bo'ness to Edinburgh and back, leaves Bo'ness at 06:30 then Edinburgh at 17:30. Monday to Saturday. Bo'ness is 20 miles away and a population of around 16000. Most residents who depend on public transport for commuting or a special day out feel totally isolated26572016-11-17T11:40:32.61313151James KennedyThough I am on a good bus route, the problem I have with the buses is that 4 buses arrive with in one minute of each other and if there are a lot of passengers waiting for different buses sometimes the bus you are waiting on runs past the stop26572016-11-17T11:42:16.05713152colin vernallThe phrase bus service is a misnomer, what happens involves buses but in nothing resembling a service. It's largely a lottery as to how reliable or otherwise the so-called service is, and the cost and disproportionate increases, exclude too many and are simply a way of boosting profits.26572016-11-17T11:42:16.89713153Trevor EastonAs a very frequent visitor to Scotland for both work and leisure, I have seen the key role public transport plays both in the remote areas and the centers of population.\r\nTheir environmental, social and economic importance requires the security given by common ownership26572016-11-17T11:42:19.19713154DONALD Mc DONALDStop the Management rot .26572016-11-17T12:05:40.80713155Vivienne Sutherland Give them the treatment that they need and hopefully stop the number of deaths multiplying 26872016-11-17T12:12:47.5613157Stephen DeansIn the Bonnybridge area, the bus services through our village have been cut by First Bus repeatedly over the last 10 years and more. The service is threadbare, as are most of the buses which are 15 - 20+ years old.26572016-11-17T12:34:42.41713158ParveenIf we all get together and send this petition to everyone we know to sign, then we can have this stopped !! We must not let them get away with it. This is wrong and we should not stand for it !!26952016-11-17T12:36:03.01313159Margaret ReynoldsI would take a bus if fares were more reasonable but I am actually cheaper taking my car.26572016-11-17T13:17:28.3313160pamela munroEveryone should get every treatment possible 26872016-11-17T13:23:42.45713161margaret cochrane (Unite member)When government allowed the private bus companies in and funded them the bus service to most especially in outlying communities declined dramatically \r\nAlso adult and childrens bus fares are far to high and for people on low wages who have to travel to get work this is a big part of their outgoings \r\nScottish Government needs to address this issue \r\nits a sad reflections that Westminister seems to be addressing this but we are not ?\r\n 26572016-11-17T13:36:43.67713162John mackenzieBring bus services back to common ownership. Many current private license holders are ripping us off. I would also question the current license system 26572016-11-17T13:44:17.86313163John Middleditch Time to get buses integrated with trains and ferries to form a proper integrated system.26572016-11-17T13:50:05.11713164thomas lawThe lack of consultation ignores the legislative process and health improvement Scotland should be enforcing this26762016-11-17T13:53:23.32313165Lesley Rodger I live in Dunblane which is currently undergoing an face lift with new pavements, plants and sculptures being added to the village center. However, Stirling Council had taken off two local buses in the last year which leaves us with a bus service every 2 to 3 hours. My feeling is that Councils are not recognising and prioritising the needs of the local community and that the utilities and departments within the Council are not doing a bit of 'joined up thinking'. If the Government are looking for the public to reduce their carbon footprint and take social responsibility for their way of living then this needs to be backed up by Government and local councils by providing a regular transport and bus service.26572016-11-17T14:45:36.29713166Stephen GibsonHaving recently visited London and seen how the bus service is working there it highlights how poor the service is in some parts of Scotland.26572016-11-17T16:00:52.5713168Robert DonnellyI worked for my local bus company for over thirty years since the day it was council run, In the council days it did not matter about profit it only run the Buses for the people. \r\nSince the Buses were Deregulated the cuts to staff and services are phenomenal it runs Buses purely for mass profit.26572016-11-17T16:06:39.9313169Charlie MooreLothian Buses has the template: Good wages for bus staff, Low fares for passengers, good buses and reliable services. 26572016-11-17T16:48:36.06313170Jeanette walkerMy daughter has this rare cancer and she had her fellow patients in Scotland deserve the same procedures as others in England and Wales. They should NOT have to fight for these scans....26872016-11-17T16:49:22.88713171Brian Nessour bus service was withdrawn after a few weeks notice and Stagecoach told us they didnt care if we have no way of getting in or out of the village for shops, Doctors etc. If it had not been for a private company coming in we would have been stranded26572016-11-17T16:50:42.65713172stella carringtonI am right behind this issue buses are rubbish we need buses to run for the benefit of the people not shareholders26572016-11-17T17:38:56.89313173Gail Fauldsmgills buses in renfrewshire not only have a monoply but there fares are way to high26572016-11-17T18:35:05.93313174Janet ClaffeyI agree that parents or guardians of 18's and under should have the right to know what medication their children have been prescribed especially when there is mental health issues. I'm sorry for the loss of your daughter & wish you good luck with your petition. x x26952016-11-17T19:32:36.5213175Margaret DuncanThe buses in dundee have gone from bad to worse do not serve the people in dundee anymore i find it too errible i live in st marys and work up at Ninewells hospital and have to walk down to downfield in all weathers to get the bus to work because they rerouted the circular buses.26572016-11-17T20:30:04.5913176Veslyn McLean This should absolutely not be allowed26952016-11-17T20:51:24.7213177David WilliamsStruan Lodge is where I was born in 1946. I feel strongly that this building should continue to be used to help the people of Dunoon.26762016-11-17T22:12:19.18313180Sylvia AndersonBuses for people not profit. 26572016-11-17T22:20:44.04313181David CurrieAs an ex bus driver I have first hand experience of working for a company like Stagecoach, for passengers and the drivers, mechanics and other workers, it was always profits that came first, before passengers the workers or good reliable services.26572016-11-18T01:52:19.3713183Debbie Paton Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure NHS Scotland recognise patients with Ocular Melanoma and enable them to receive enhanced MRI scans with contrast of the liver in an attempt to detect early metastatic disease.26872016-11-18T02:48:21.00313184David Wardgood luck with this26922016-11-18T04:12:44.713185Magda AngPublic Transport should not be profit making as the public depends on it for everyday transport. Take it away from profiteers back into public ownership please.26572016-11-18T06:59:43.8513186Janet ClarkeSo so sad please sign this n hopefully prevent anyone else havin to go thru this heartbreaking tragedy xcx26952016-11-18T09:22:18.4613187Val Johnston Bus network is essential for growing city and support to diverse population 26572016-11-18T10:44:26.92713189Marian NorrisExtremely important that the public is consulted before a decision, Particularly important with the kind of geographical problems of access we have to the NHS. 26762016-11-18T11:48:02.7813190Robert Downiewe need public service transport26572016-11-18T13:36:34.26313191Don StewartIt is important that children are provided with the funding promised in the official publications, I.e. for all 3 year-olds therefore should be from their 3rd birthday and therefore fair for all.26842016-11-18T14:47:10.91313192Andrea FloanEveryone has the right to treatment26872016-11-18T15:02:38.97713193Anne DruganA small pres shld have been given and an adult informed then a further app at gp with an adult!!!!!26952016-11-18T15:07:32.07313194Bobbie ClarkThe recent changes to the bus services in Dundee run by National Express have gone from bad to ridiculous and hit the elderly and disabled s\r\nin particular. \r\nThere is certainly no element of public service involved.26572016-11-18T16:18:38.67713197Margaret MeyerI would very much welcome this as the loss of srrvices is quite distressing26572016-11-18T16:36:54.33313199Matthew CrightonPublicly-managed public transport is essential if we are to de-carbonise and ensure out towns and cities are good to live and work in26572016-11-18T17:23:48.79713201George MeechanIf a train is late they get a fine the Bus companies should be the same.26572016-11-18T19:21:21.07713204james daviesPutting under 18s on powerful psychoactive drugs with or without parental consent should be classed as a criminal act26952016-11-18T19:50:26.9113205Isobel TaitPublic transport should run in the interest of people and their communities, not for profit.26572016-11-18T21:26:36.6413206StephI experienced issues with the current criteria as I work full time, I had to rely on family for childcare I could not afford to pay my entire wage on childcare costs and my daughters 3rd birthday was September which ment we had to wait until January before she could attend, I felt she was more than ready to attend and start socialising with other kids. I find this very unfair as some children can start before they turn 3 and receive funding but others can't depending on their birthday. 26842016-11-18T22:18:17.22713207Mrs HamiltonMy son will be 3 years and almost 5 months before we receive a funded place. Fully support the petition.26842016-11-18T22:27:59.2613208Beth Broadley Give these pt's what they are legally entitled to,all people deserve the best 26872016-11-18T23:05:45.93713209Peter Lavellewe need the busses foe our day to day lifes26572016-11-19T03:19:51.75313211Bill ScottTime for people to come before profits.26572016-11-19T10:40:36.31313212Gary Psychiatry seems to have not made any real progress to look after lives much better . Though . younger generation people have no proper safety net . with issues such as having to rely on responsible parents . though also suffer possible poverty, lack of genuine healthy wage employment, being given housing unable to get on the mortgage property ladder, though sadly lack awareness of not being scammed and suffering financial distress . Mental Health care should be taken care of from . Soteria Project . CCHR . Stepping Stones Across the Spectrum . 26952016-11-19T11:25:37.55313213maryanne mcmastwrhope you win and get the justice ur daughter and yous deserve R.I.P ANGEL xx26952016-11-19T14:25:12.95313214charlotte stelmaszuki agree as a parent. i would want to be notified if my child was given medication under the age of 18, especially with regards to any mental health issue....Good luck in your campaign.26952016-11-19T20:50:37.86313215Gill HallI too lost my daughter in 2014. She was over 18 but at uni on her own. I think that if the doctors are prescribing these drugs to young people they should make sure a parent or guardian is aware that their child has been given these dangerous drugs. \r\n26952016-11-19T23:45:38.43313216A-J McGrogganNeeds to change. Totally agree. 26952016-11-20T01:32:46.68713218Rosina quigleySupporting Brittany's family26952016-11-20T01:49:37.67313219Margaret McNab Good luck hunni, the law needs to be changed sooner rather than later xx26952016-11-20T02:46:17.61713220Michelle CloneyHelp these sufferers and give them some peace of mind. 26872016-11-20T03:18:28.68313222SharonI totally i am on this medication but small dosage 10mg 3 times a day for panic attacks i have recently had but if was one of my daughters under 18 i dam right would want to know what my gp was giving them z26952016-11-20T04:50:22.72713223Cheryl HowardTreatment saves lives! 26872016-11-20T07:38:38.28313224Derek ScottIs it just a simple matter of re-regulation? Or do the councils not need budgets (ie funding) and management skills to meet public expectations? Many of the private companies raise or borrow money to invest in new vehicles. Will the councils also offer bus workers better pensions and other pay terms and conditions?\r\n\r\nBetter regulation also needs to extend to restricting car use, for example return journeys made by single drivers on our major roads, which add to the traffic congestion so many of us experience. Governments, national and local, have failed us with inadequate traffic regulation.26572016-11-20T10:07:34.23713225Angela BellFully support a good cause.26872016-11-20T11:14:04.46713226TraceyThey wonder why there is so many young deaths as GP should contact next of kin if they have any signs of mental health so they can help along side the doc xx26952016-11-20T11:30:1513227AnneSo tragic and potentionally avoidable.26952016-11-20T13:42:53.4913228Connor McNicol-DayLet's bring back public control of our bus services in Glasgow, much like they do with Lothian Buses out in Edinburgh. It would also be nice to have the old Glasgow bus heritage colour scheme instead of those horrid pink and purple coloured Barbie buses! Safe to say, I definitely prefer Lothian Buses to WorstBus as someone who frequently visits the capital.26572016-11-20T17:04:34.00313229samantha campbellplease do the right thing 26872016-11-20T18:07:10.7313230KG Read Low fares are the only way to encourage use of public transport26572016-11-20T18:10:08.44713231Jackie TraynorEarliest detection of metastases is imperative to our lives. We are relatively small in number compered to other cancer types, but our lives are just as important26872016-11-20T19:00:17.813232Chris ReidThe bus services in our rural areas are being continually cut. For some people it is their only method of transport and this is making them more socially isolated and at risk or being unable to access the basic requirements of everyday life such as getting to the bank, doctors, dentist and being able to go for shopping. It's time that this was reviewed before any further decline sets in.26572016-11-20T19:44:41.86713233Robert BurnettAll MPs and MSPs should be given a bus pass rather than travelling expenses.26572016-11-20T20:16:45.15313234Cathy MatthewsEveryone should be entitled to good medical treatment. 26872016-11-20T22:04:50.76313235Lewis Weston Scotland should adopt the same standards of diagnostic criteria as we have in England ... we are a \r\nUnited Kingdom!26872016-11-20T22:32:25.2813236Donald Macdonaldabout time too26572016-11-20T23:11:21.86313237Anita CramerMRIs are imperative to detecting metastasis before it's too late.26872016-11-21T00:19:41.79713239lissa hendrenTreatment should be available 26872016-11-21T01:07:52.75713240Yvonne Good luck 26952016-11-21T06:42:13.89313241Ellen ParkerCan not believe this great care home is going through this again, my mother was cared for and looked after by a great team of staff till the very end they care for all there residents very lovingly treat them with dignity which makes the residents and staff a happy family unit. YOU CAN NOT CLOSE THIS CARE HOME26762016-11-21T06:57:58.17713242Terri robsonCancer screening is the most vital preventive action that can be taken. Catching cancer early should be Scotlands and the rest of the UKs priority. All the best Jennie 26872016-11-21T07:21:59.27313243Yvonne Signed with u all the way on this Annette xx26952016-11-21T07:55:07.54713244Chantelle FranceI agree no medication for kids under 18 yrs old without parents consent.26952016-11-21T08:07:24.1413245linda Bowden Signed and this needs to be sorted 26952016-11-21T08:36:06.1913246Tracey GrantThe direct bus service from Bridge of Don, Aberdeen to Aberdeen Royal Infirmary was the Number 4, this has been replaced with a number 8 & 9, the journey time has doubled and causing misery to workers at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, a previous 30 minute journey now takes a full hour with the new route, First Bus are a disgrace!26572016-11-21T08:37:22.3313247Kelly Mclean Hoping and praying this law is passed to ensure the safety of our children in the future Xx26952016-11-21T08:46:12.813248Peter McKennaEveryone with Ocular Melanoma should have equal treatment no matter where they live26872016-11-21T08:49:12.1313249Bryan AllanWe build the buses in Falkirk District and must have one of the worst services in Scotland. Get them fixed!! 26572016-11-21T09:16:44.30313250Sue holder Please action needs to be taken before someone else loses their child xxx26952016-11-21T09:42:43.0913251Stephanie sheppardThere isn't enough help out there for the young ones. It's well past time that the NHS put more into helping them26952016-11-21T09:50:53.7813252Mery DanielReliable and regular bus services are the veins and arteries of a civilized country body...vital. Do not block them with budget or service cuts and cause a STROKE!26572016-11-21T10:15:56.6713253Rebecca Mcgeachie Due to the nature of the condition and the structured design of the current education system, we are finding there are no suitable placements for this group of children on the Autistic Spectrum 26922016-11-21T10:28:01.40313254Susan MoodyIt is imperative that this condition is recognised as part of the Autism Spectrum, without the PDA signpost people spend years trying strategies that exacerbate the child's anxiety and lead to crisis point. All children are entitled to adequate and efficient support by law! Unfortunately for those with PDA this does not occur and is not only an infringement on their human rights it has a severe knock on effect to parents, siblings, teaching staff and anyone else who is in contact with these children. Parents try their best but we simply cannot do this alone!!!26922016-11-21T13:43:15.7613255David GreigBuses are essential to many as their only means of transport, but they need to be integrated with other types of public transport so that journeys can be efficient and meet the needs of the public.26572016-11-21T14:35:46.59713256Janette drewThis should never of happend to beautful young lady x lets make sure no othere family has to go through wat this family has \r\n26952016-11-21T14:38:27.5513257PM BaronAny attempt to diminish such services would rebound upon those championing such a cause as there would unwelcome publicity in all media.26762016-11-21T14:54:59.87713258Tracey GrantFirst Bus Aberdeen withdraw the Number 4 bus service which took me to work at ARI from Bridge of Don in 30 minutes door-to-door and replace with service numbers 8 & 9 which now take a full hour each way!!! Unbelievable.26572016-11-21T15:16:52.75313259Christina Houston They defo should have medication to under 18s if there sick! 26952016-11-21T15:42:37.72713260kirstyThis could be any of our kids. They are in a generation where they are young and impressionable and I don't class my sixteen year old son as an adult, far from it xxx26952016-11-21T16:06:49.6413261Catherine nelsonI am signing this patron as I think the law should be changed regarding prescrition giving to children for mental health 26952016-11-21T17:01:50.61713262Iain GallowayI am a stage IV ocular melanoma sufferer and know that this type of scan saved my life by picking up the cancer spread early, certainly I've had three good years clear since! I also run the European ocular melanoma patient group, MPNE Ocular, and have spoken to numerous oncologists (importantly, ones who specialise in dealing with metastatic spread of this particular disease) who unanimously agree that MRI scanning is the most appropriate for checking for cancer spread. It is certainly the option they would choose for their loved ones. 26872016-11-21T19:49:00.63713263Joanna DallasEqual opportunity for ocular melanoma patients to access life prolonging treatment can only be achieved if all patients have access to MRI scans. The current system is creating a postcode lottery, that people south of the border are winning (one of whom is my husband). I feel so lucky he has access to regular MRI scans and want Scottish patients to have the same.26872016-11-21T21:30:07.0413265Sammi Fingers crossed xxxxx 26952016-11-21T21:49:11.12313266Michael duffyTransport in this country is aful and it is all down to politicians who care about the public all they want is there big fat salary none of them are any good 26572016-11-21T22:28:34.26713267Anne MoodyMy grandson has PDA, despite the governments talk of GIRFEC my grandson has no formal education. My daughter has had to fight for all the help she should have had as standard. PDA has been recognised by the Autistic Society so why does our government not. All teachers, health professionals, social work any anyone who works with children with special needs have to be made aware of this condition. Different strategies have to be used for these children. Educate Educate Educate.This condition not only affects the child but the parents, siblings and everyone in contact with the child. These children are often mistaken for being defiant but I can assure you they are not. Anxiety plays a major part, Fight or flight, Hurting others and their self and many other reactions too numerous to name. Please help these children and families. \r\n26922016-11-22T01:55:41.39713269Andrew LindsayNo child under 18 should be prescribed any type of medication without a parent or guardian being present or having a consultation with said doctors or any medical person.26952016-11-22T02:51:03.1413270Courtney Devine Doctors shouldn't be giving that amount of medication to young people who have mental health issues, anxiety etc if people have problems transfer to a specialist or something DON'T give them so much medication, because people can have panic attacks or forget that they took their medication and take more it has to stop now !!!!!!!\r\n26952016-11-22T06:02:26.33313271Alastair CassellThe buses in Glasgow are a disgrace - they desperately need regulation, rationalisation and integration, along with the rest of the city's transport network.26572016-11-22T08:00:39.2113272Anthony McCutcheonThere used to be a bus service which came into Cardowan and this is no longer the case. I Myself have stopped to help old ladies with shopping bags climbing a steep hill. Bus companies dont care about service26572016-11-22T08:22:19.41713274joanne Finnegan A health service can save money and extend a patients life by using an MRI to detect cancer at an early stage when there's a better chance of treatment working. An MRI is seen as best practice.26872016-11-22T08:22:38.5913275Helen JefferyPeople in town can't travel to work and study from Bo'ness as there is only on bus in the morning and one back at night catering for only 9 - 5 workers. I have had to turn down work in Edinburgh. People who moved recently to Bo'ness which was described as a commuter town are having to constantly wider moving house. There are hundreds of extra single occupancy cars passing by the main road from me travelling to Edinburgh. This situation has been going on for over 2 years and is totally unacceptable.26572016-11-22T08:22:56.2613276Robert JefferyIf you want a public bus service sign this petition.26572016-11-22T08:39:06.57713277Marie MacleanWe need and deserve good public service transport26572016-11-22T09:23:35.53313278Elizabeth LennonI believe early detection through MRI scans can save the patients sight26872016-11-22T09:51:36.9613279Michaela McleodJustice for Britney!!26952016-11-22T10:15:54.78713280Grant milneI visit Bo'ness and a bus service would be of benefit. 26572016-11-22T10:18:39.80713281Louise Mccusker Hope this law is put in place terrible a family has had to suffer 26952016-11-22T10:23:28.613282Suzanne DyerGood luck26952016-11-22T11:24:59.81313284lisa brownThis should be sorted asap before more kids r affected 26952016-11-22T12:39:27.54313285James CliffordThis is important to be done without delay. Early detection is the only defense against this disease.\r\n26872016-11-22T12:52:38.2313286Karen QuinPills being prescribed by GP were clearly not the answer in this case, there should be much easier and quicker accessibility to professional help. A review of procedures is urgently required.26952016-11-22T16:15:57.2813287Christina HoggThis is crucial as early detection is the most important factor in helping someone.26872016-11-22T17:20:15.3613288Ricky Sherriff-ShortEffective bus services are key to avoiding social exclusion, more vulnerable people are isolated due to poor or non existent bus services due to no longer been profitable. Public transport should be to connect communities not isolate them 26572016-11-22T17:23:51.11313289Ricky Sherriff-ShortPublic transport requires significant redesign to make it more effective. A bus service from Troon to Kilmarnock takes an hour when you can drive in 15 minutes. More & more services are been withdrawn leading to isolation & poor connections with communities 26572016-11-22T17:51:42.36713290Susan FergusonGd luck and all the vbest I hope yous get this petition so that other kids and families are not affected 26952016-11-22T17:55:07.66313291Olivia SmithGood luck xxx 26952016-11-22T18:02:02.25713292Steven Gorman Signed, terrible waste of a young life, totally agree, mental health issues should be shared between gp and parents 26952016-11-22T18:17:17.81313293Charlene mayneThanks to annette i can now have a little hope26952016-11-22T20:35:32.33713294Margaret trettNo one deserves to go what Annette or Britney went through everyone should sign this then no other parent will go through this 26952016-11-22T20:41:31.1513295Keileih CookThe NHS attitude towards mental health us so poor its a joke. This SHOULD NOT have happened!!! X26952016-11-22T20:46:37.74713296Catherine ForrestWithout the link between Boness and Edinburgh I will have extreme difficulty commuting to work. I will need to rely on a bus to linlithgow then the train. This will increase my outgoings and add additional time onto my journey. Boness should not be cut off from our capital city where a high percentage of the boness population work. 26572016-11-22T20:47:36.5113297Stephen DallasEarly scans should be available as steps are being made to be able to 'manage' metastatic disease in early detection. Scots patients should have these scans as early detection can prolong their lives in a meaningful way. 26872016-11-23T09:27:03.7513299Melanie keoghHope this gets soughted x26952016-11-23T09:48:47.3913300Steven Mullen I am I bus commuter and think first bus services are way beyond terrible, lately this has become more notable with cancelled and delayed buses being the norm. Why first bus still have control of most of Glasgow transportation is beyond my comprehension. Time for the Glasgow transportation to be taken back into council control.26572016-11-23T11:11:50.6213301Laurie KahnMy mother and brother both died of ocular melanoma, which when it metastasizes goes to the liver. Please if you can prolong life with early detection, you should use those resources. I am so sorry that patients have to resort to petitions to get the care they need.26872016-11-23T12:51:37.15313306Laurie CrumpI am a college lecturer and have worked with a PDA student this academic year and last. It was only towards the end of his first year studying with us that his condition was properly diagnosed, and he therefore did not benefit from any properly targeted extra support or appropriate arrangements. That he was able to complete the year and come through all the assessments is a tribute to the extraordinary perseverance of his mother, and the many sacrifices she made, to ensure his attendance. \r\nNow there is some properly targeted support in place, in the form of subject-specific one-to-one tutorials, he is making really significant progress. However, the support is only possible because his mother is paying for it every week. It is another example of the lengths to which she is prepared to go to give him every possible chance of success. If more support of this kind could be funded, as it surely should be, it would make a tremendous difference. I absolutely support the efforts to raise awareness of the syndrome, and hope that all relevant organisations will recognise the importance of investing in strategies which actually work.\r\n26922016-11-23T14:43:22.44313307Michelle ThompsonGood Luck xx26952016-11-23T17:26:03.40713308Jean H IrvinePDA awareness supporter26922016-11-23T21:08:36.35713309Heather mcardle Struan Lodge provides and has provided a valueable service to our community caring for some of our most vulnerable family members. The care and attention they receive is essential for their wellbeing. This is a service Dunoon needs now and in the future to take care of our loved ones.26762016-11-23T21:30:06.97313310D youngRip brittney u didnt deserve this26952016-11-23T23:42:56.95713312Colin FergusonThere are certain services that cannot be trusted in the hands of the private sector...transport is such a service.26572016-11-24T06:09:18.65313313EleanorAs a sufferer of mental health I don't know where I would be now without my family. Too many young people are taking their own lives as a result of mental health. I believe that with parents knowledge and the correct treatment there could be less26952016-11-24T14:56:19.34713315Jo GumbsAll cancer patients should be allowed screening to detect disease as early as possible. Whilst there are no centres of excellence recognised in the surveillance of ocular melanoma, I feel patients wishes on the modality of scanning should be recognised.26872016-11-24T15:33:08.4613316Morag HendersonWe need cheaper, regular bus services, covering all areas including industrial estates. If they want to reduce cars on the road they have to have a fit for purpose service, and stop penalizing those that do not drive26572016-11-24T22:46:19.7313318Angela HamiltonPlease don't bury your head in the sand on these things. Science and technology are uncovering new genes and conditions all the time. Please read the research and do the right thing to help families in need. With extra learning suppprt these kids will positively contribute to society as adults.26922016-11-25T00:24:12.24313319margaretI am truly for the loss of your child, I can't imagine what you and your family are going through, my thoughts and prayers are with you 26952016-11-25T06:17:38.16713320Janet GarlandOcular Melanoma patients in Scotland should be offered regular MRI scans to check for metastasis which is prevalent in this condition and type of cancer. It is offered in other parts of the U.K. Not to provide MRI as routine is discriminatory to OM patients in Scotland 26872016-11-25T07:41:48.89713321Bob Riley My friends daughter has PDA syndrome, this condition needs support to the families and needs acted upon now.26922016-11-25T09:40:06.69713322Susan SmithI live in Edinburgh and feel very lucky for the excellent Lothian Bus service that enables me to get around the city easily. However, as soon as I go outside the city that all changes. My parents live in Bo'ness and the reduction in the number of buses between Bo'ness and Edinburgh is ludicrous, especially considering there is no train and the bus service to Linlithgow or Dalmeny is also infrequent. I echo Catherine Forrest's commments below - Bo'ness should not be cut off from the capital. It is not just workers, retired people are also stuck if they don't have access to a car. We should be encouraging people in Scottish town's to go car free, not make it impossible for them to live without one.26572016-11-25T10:15:53.9513323john smithAs far as the bus companies are concerned Bo'ness seems to be the lost world. Service to Edinburgh is now virtually non existent. There used to be a service to the Hospital at Larbert but now it requires two buses followed by a 6 minute walk.26572016-11-25T10:32:17.713324Jessie SmithI am dismayed at the current attitude to public transport . We are not encouraged to visit towns and cities by car and are now left stranded by punitive bus scheduling particularly in relation to Bo'ness where our bus services have been radically hit. Please do something about this.26572016-11-25T10:35:09.65313325Allan DuncanMake it easier to use buses especially on a sunday26572016-11-25T18:20:33.1313326Helen SmithIt used to be possible to get a bus from Freuchie to several different places. Now buses are re-routed from the New Inn Roundabout onto the road through Kettlebridge, not even leaving alternate buses through Freuchie. This means my elderly neighbour who uses buses all the time, faces a journey of around 2 hours minimum to go to Cowdenbeath, and there are other places which are now inaccessible. Disgraceful.26572016-11-25T18:46:55.94713327Honor OsborneThere are so many ways this could have been handled....medication NOT being the kneejerk first instance.....counselling or CAMHS ...peer support.....RIP Britney xx xx 26952016-11-25T19:38:30.4913328Ross AllanThe fragmentation of public transport services, especially in remote areas, has only gotten worse with privatisation. The only way to ensure consistently reliable public transport for all is to bring it back fully into public ownership.26572016-11-25T20:12:23.7113329Steve EganTwo and a half hours on a bus from Whitburn to Edinburgh is scandalous 26572016-11-25T22:46:43.1213330Linda LangfordThese people affected by PDA need help. Time to do something now.26922016-11-26T00:27:11.07713331Pam CurrieI've lived in a rural part of East Ayrshire since June - still not sure if there's a scheduled bus at our road end or not! Use the X76 from Auchinleck to Glasgow and it's appalling - 2.5 hours tonight, over an hour of which was standing outside in subzero temperatures in Glasgow & Kilmarnock.26572016-11-26T16:57:58.51713333Robert MillerI find it difficult to understand why we even have to petition, for anything that can detect a disease and prolong the quality of a person life, it that not what the health service preaches. People should be given every opportunity when it comes to their health26872016-11-26T20:43:43.87313334Patricia obrien No parent should have to bury their child,this should never have happened, every one please sign this petition. 26952016-11-26T20:47:46.29313335Lissa hendrenScans should be done asap 26872016-11-26T21:59:11.0213337Craig jamesStagecoach buses in fife are appalling and the services are seriously disjointed. In glenrothes if u want to.go from.the train station to collydean you have to change buses at the bus station. That's just a small example. They are expensive. Their buses are grubby both outside in inside. Their express buses advertise plug and USB sockets. They never work. The WiFi hardly ever works. Fife has lost is identity on the buses. And now we are just part of a big group that is more profits oriented rather than focusing on what the passenger needs. Way too expensive for what should be a 15,20 min journey stagecoach charge over 3.00. For a journey that is 1 hour and 20 minutes on a lothian bus it's 1.60. Stagecoach frankly are a rip off. 26572016-11-27T04:10:31.3813338TiffanyThe way GPS treat metal illness is terrible, this should not have been aloud to happen, thoughts go out to the family xx26952016-11-27T15:37:26.56713339Kay McLucasI agree, I don't think any child should be able to be prescribed drugs without the consent from the Parent-Guardian if the child is under the age of 18. Children do not know how to make proper choices. 26952016-11-27T16:06:29.4313340Johnny Britney appeal 26952016-11-27T18:18:08.71313341Evan FitzsimmonsC'mon, get on!!26572016-11-28T09:32:04.15313343Moira Johnston Don't understand why this is not in place already people who are suffering need this 26872016-11-28T10:49:24.05313344Anne-Marie GavinPlease support this cause 26922016-11-28T15:10:42.84313345Charlene Under 18's need to be protected when they are in a vulnerable mental health state. \r\n26952016-11-28T16:41:17.1813346Robert GreensheildsSick of paying thru the nose for journeys that begin with the bus not appearing or brakes down and you miss train connection then on way home have the bus run past me due to being overcrowded. \r\nTime Firstbus got their act together and remember. The people have had enough of you cutting back schedules.26572016-11-28T17:39:20.67713347Tegan Watson Friend and supporter of individual with this diagnosis.26922016-11-28T17:43:37.8613348Robert StirlingThe infrastructure of Public Transport has been whittled away to such a standard cars have exploded onto our roads to the detriment of our towns and villages. Until action is taken our roads will come to a complete standstill26572016-11-28T20:50:49.2513349Nicola HendrenScans should be available 26872016-11-29T15:46:16.92313350Wendy DoranIf Scotland take the lead, recognise this as a condition, perhaps England will follow! There's still no diagnosis or training across the schools, and standard autism strategies don't work with those with PDA! 26922016-11-29T18:07:22.76713351Judith HydePlease help26872016-11-29T18:33:17.66713352Laura Kerbey BSC(Hons) PGCE PGCSE NPQHIt is essential that PDA is recognised to ensure that children, teenagers and adults with the condition get the support and understanding that they need. Without this support the mental health of individuals with PDA is at severe risk. PDA also has significant impact on families and is causing family break down and crisis. It is essential that the condition is not only recognised but that a wiser understanding of the condition is spread throughout educational and care settings too. 26922016-11-29T19:20:41.81313353eddie hotchkissIt makes sense26872016-11-29T23:19:37.7313354Kirsty AndersonThese scans could make a huge difference to patients. 26872016-11-30T06:49:48.5813355Anna LyonsChildren are being failed by the lack of understanding of this condition. Their parents are desperately trying to help them. Please support.26922016-11-30T22:50:43.1213356Colin jacksonAs a fellow sufferer who lost an eye in July I can't understate the importance of M.R.I s for our continued wellbeing 26872016-11-30T23:13:06.02713357Peter RobertsonGreenock buses are a disgrace. McGills have terrible suspension that shatter old people's hips, and they are the only company because for some reason the powers-that-be hand everything to the family business that started on the profits of organised drug dealing in Greenock. And the Glasgow bus that used to go to Kelvindale has been scrapped. It's a posh area, but not everyone owns a car up there. I know people who have been ploughing money into that route for over 20 years, and now they have no bus at all.26572016-12-01T06:18:59.08713358Susan SmithMRI scans with contrast are vital. Without one my husband's metastatic ocular melanoma would not have been found at an early stage.26872016-12-01T12:11:44.68713359Barbara Ann StewartScans are essential.26872016-12-02T01:39:36.35313360Diane This has to be sorted26952016-12-02T07:26:46.85313361CourtneyI'm a 16 year old girl and I would hope that if I was in a vulnerable state the doctor would inform my parents or get my parents consent! good luck!! X26952016-12-02T12:36:37.9913363David HeriotThe Bus Service in South Queensferry is a Disgrace26572016-12-02T14:04:39.2313364KarenPLEASE. Same cancer same help...26872016-12-02T16:10:37.54313365Alan HeatlieNo smart-card system, price per mile on the Borders network over twice that of Lothian Buses. Tickets from cancelled rail system not valid on Borders buses....the list goes on and on! 26572016-12-02T17:05:58.1613366Gillian ParsonsEqual healthcare throughout the U.K. Is needed26872016-12-02T19:05:59.53713367Johanne BlakeFair treatment for all in the UK\r\n26872016-12-02T20:17:42.71313368Valerie mcewen the law needs to change before it happens again26952016-12-02T21:02:29.7513369Fiona MacDonald It's outrageous26762016-12-02T21:18:56.17313370Shelagh VincentPlease help these patients26872016-12-03T00:47:08.79713371Susan WilsonSouth Queensferry is a rapidly expanding town and has had a poor and more expensive bus service than other parts of Edinburgh for the 22 years I've lived here - This needs to change urgently 26572016-12-03T00:59:09.9713372Alasdair FraterSurely thorough consultation with the public before decisions are made will result in a more refined outcome suitable for the community.26762016-12-03T01:17:1413373Margaret CooperI live in Bo'ness and our access to a decent bus service is non existent !!!! We have no service from here to Edinburgh ....it takes me almost 2 hours to get there as I have to go to Linlithgow to get a bus. Linlithgow has a bus for Edinburgh every 20 minutes.....the bus company won't even reroute one of those buses through Bo'ness. 26572016-12-03T11:06:15.8313374Paul CraggsHopefully this will decrease the extortionate bus fares in Aberdeen 26572016-12-03T19:14:55.28713376Billy AdamsonLothian busses best in Scotland cheapest fares best busses and best terms and conditions for employees , run by the people for the people not profiteers . 26572016-12-04T00:17:01.84313377Greig WrightPut the customers & the Staff before Fat Cats. Delivering a service that old & infirm peoples depend on is a moral imperative. Having public transport trusted again & spoke of fondly by the household will help ease road congestion, pollution & generate jobs too. A no-brainer unless you're an economist.26572016-12-04T01:34:13.64313378Barry Gale I am not a parent but I was Primary Carer to my mother who had dementia. She died in hospital under a Compulsory Treatment Order in February 2016 after spending 2 years in hospital on the authorisation of doctors and social workers, against her wishes and mine. Despite being her Welfare Guardian, an experienced Primary Carer and her Next of Kin, I was excluded from caring for her and from any meaningful involvement in decisions about her welfare. \r\n\r\nI support this petition because I believe parents, guardians and next of kin should be involved in making decisions about the welfare of their close family. This should happen in all circumstances except when the patient is over 18, objects to family involvement, and there is no possibility that the patient is mentally disordered.\r\n\r\nThe reason is that family have extensive experience and objective knowledge of the patient, which should inform any decision about medical treatment. Such information cannot be reliably obtained from a short consultation with the a patient who may be suffering from a mental disorder. Family members also have a very personal interest in the patient as a member of that family, and need to know what medical treatment is being provided so that the family can support the patient's recovery.\r\n\r\nThe exclusion of family from decisions about medical treatment is contrary to respect for family life (Article 8). It undermines family life and is thereby detrimental to society. 26952016-12-04T11:14:35.1913380MargaretI agree doctors shouldn't be allowed to prescribe these strong anti depressant to young people without an adults consent 26952016-12-04T11:22:00.76713382PeterWe are a United Kingdom It should not matter were we live treatment should be equal26872016-12-04T23:32:36.62313384Kalpna Kotecha Strongly agree with this petition26952016-12-05T12:52:36.91313385Laura MacDonaldAs a Glaswegian bus user, I am in no doubt that Lothian Buses provides a customer-focussed service that is cleaner, more efficient, cheaper and easier to access than the services I have used in Glasgow. I am in no doubt this is due to the difference ownership and the focus on users rather than profits.26572016-12-05T13:55:52.1313386Kenneth HigginsThe local bus service has doubled the fair after taking over from last service provider. Its just as cheap to get a taxi26572016-12-05T14:06:20.79713387Ira MacPhailI am a student living in Yoker due to low rent prices and I have a great difficulty moving around the city and especially to and back from the University. I can only use the bus for my transportation and there has been numerous times the buses do not arrive at the time scheduled resulting to many delays. The time of wait is sometimes so long that it could be dangerous for a female at night waiting at remote bus stops. Please there is an urgency for change.26572016-12-05T14:26:40.313388Carol LekstutisThis test is the most important test to have every 6 months 26872016-12-05T15:05:27.68713389Philip GoldieTypical of 1st Glasgow busses, today I waited for 40 minutes for a bus that should be along every 10 minutes. I watched 3 buses with the same route number travelling n the opposite direction all travel within 3 minutes of each other. After the 40 minutes had elapsed, the same 3 buses arrived within 1 minute of each other at my bus stop. The whole journey from where I live to the city centre takes half an hour. 1st be fail to properly organise it's routes, this never occurred with SPTE running the service. End profit makes G for the owners of this shoddy company and hand the buses back to be properly run for the benefit of the people. 26572016-12-05T16:57:11.90713390Gordon MurrayIt's time to return Scotland's public transport sector back to public ownership. We want regulation for the privately owned transport sector in the meantime.26572016-12-05T18:29:52.61713391Lilith Levine My heart goes out to you and your family 26952016-12-05T19:07:59.61713392Linda RiddockWest End of Glasgow bus service totally inadequate...Used to be brilliant...Why??26572016-12-05T19:10:19.88313393Mel JamesI know a family who have had no support at all with pda. The children have been recognized with pda but have no diagnosis due to this condition not being formarly recognized. Over the years the children have been ridiculed by teachers and parents alike. It was to others blantantly obvious that these children had difficulties and anxiety problems but no educational supports had been supplied. They have been let down so many times...such a shame as both boys are talanted individuals.26922016-12-05T19:48:59.57313394stephen murrayGlasgow's buses are a disgrace - they should be taken under public control, as Edinburgh's are.26572016-12-05T21:14:14.73313395Alasdair KellyDue to health I am not someone who can jump in a car and go where I want. I have to plan where I travel to by public transport. Regulation is something that would solve many problems.26572016-12-05T23:19:41.59713396clare greigThe law should be 18+ with medication being handed out or with parental consent to under 18s agree 100%26952016-12-05T23:19:50.2213397gemma clawsonSending all my love to Annette Raymond and Kids Xx 26952016-12-05T23:23:29.30713398Rachel Davies I think if any person has sucidal thoughts and expresses this to anyone that being a medical professional or joe bloggs then they should alert the ones close to that person so they can help or be on high alert.... what happened to Brittany should have never happened ! RIP BEAUTIFUL LITTLE LADY, you gained your wings way too early.... sending lots of love xxxx26952016-12-05T23:23:34.32313399Michelle Mcatamney Children shouldn't be prescribed any drugs without consent of their parent!26952016-12-05T23:26:24.7313400Charlotte boyleI think all children under 18 should be getting parent consent before the doctor giving any medication. They shouldn't be aloud to give medication to under 18's. 26952016-12-05T23:27:18.1213401Hayley dymond I don't think drugs so be subcribed to teenagers without parents permission if the child is under the age of 18 26952016-12-05T23:30:10.31713402Melodie MotiUnder 18's should have consent of parents or guardians if a doctor prescribes medication relating to a mental health issue. They have a duty of care.26952016-12-05T23:30:49.49713403carrie McGregorGood luck xx26952016-12-05T23:36:23.83313404Charlene HI agree with you 100% with a 14 year old daughter myself I would hate to think she had been given something like this from our gp without my consent. 26952016-12-05T23:42:37.46713405Laura MccaffertyShocking kids in such a vulnerable state of mind can be handed what this lovely young girl was x26952016-12-05T23:43:52.37313406Vikki Hindley Imagine if it was your child! 26952016-12-05T23:51:34.09313408Pauline MoriartyWe need to ensure that all practitioners are specifically trained in suicide prevention....The correct word usage and refusal to risk enabling anyone to take their own precious life, through prescribing enough drugs to do so, is surely a priority in terms of law changes....Must this wait until it is your daughter? Bless you Britney and bless you, Jenna....( my 13 year old daughter, who also ended her own precious life, in a different manner...)26952016-12-05T23:56:11.83313409Katrina oconnorShouldnt have happened i hope justice for this young girl gets served 26952016-12-06T00:04:53.4613410Kimberly kirkwoodFly high queen b X26952016-12-06T00:08:36.54713412Leigh mcmaster This needs to be changed under 18 still children 26952016-12-06T00:12:10.60313413kelly davies very sad that a beauiful young 16 year old has lost her life if her parents new maybe things would be different an any parent would think the same x26952016-12-06T00:35:33.25313415kirsten.Britney appeal, rest easy princess x x26952016-12-06T00:39:58.33313416marion mcmillan glasgow needs to get back to a service that was provided for the people by people who knew the meaning of common good. 26572016-12-06T00:52:10.60713417Danielle HutchesonTotally disagree with the no parent consent. It has cost far too many lives!26952016-12-06T01:14:16.23713418Virginia Under 18's NEVER can be prescribed without their parents consent!!!!!26952016-12-06T01:23:32.5913420Arthur FosterHave previous experience of mental health issues so therefore more than happy to sign. Really hope this petition gets the recognition it deserves 26952016-12-06T02:19:41.4813422Angie Girvan As a person who suffers with mental health issues I truly believe that tablets are not a solution and more needs to be done to support and guide people to realising that talking to someone and having support of family and friends is vital to help understand the daily issues of dealing with feelings and thoughts. Family or a trusted individual who can help support should be a necessity. Dealing with all the stress especially at such a young age should not be done alone and especially when starting or taking any antidepressants. Mental health support in this country is unbelievably atrocious. And the amount of young people taking their lives is a shocking truth that tablets and a 5 minute appointment with a GP is not the way deal with it at all! 26952016-12-06T02:31:39.53713423Jobeth Boyle Justice for Britney 26952016-12-06T02:40:57.3413424ChloeI don't think children under the age of 18 should be allowed to take pills 26952016-12-06T02:46:44.73313425christina reynoldsVulnerable children must be protected 26952016-12-06T05:06:19.81313426kirstie mcallister sleep tight britney xxx 26952016-12-06T06:51:28.39313427Kelly McCullochGood luck 26952016-12-06T07:02:37.28313428Aileen A doctor should never prescribe a child such a prescription without consulting their parents first the law NEEDS to be changed x26952016-12-06T07:10:19.5313429Janie addieGood luck x26952016-12-06T07:12:35.79713430Samantha Forbes I think it should be stopped giving pills to young girls with depression 26952016-12-06T07:50:55.7413431andrina currieIf kids come to you with suicidal thoughts why would you add fuel to the fire and give them tablets that give you even more suicidal thoughts just doesn't work.26952016-12-06T08:11:25.5313432EvieSo sad 26952016-12-06T08:39:52.15713433Arleen Robinson Good luck xx26952016-12-06T08:57:03.5713435DebbieI agree no child should be given tablets without the parents knowing .26952016-12-06T09:14:44.79713437Michelle masseySupporting u annette26952016-12-06T09:34:46.4213439carolineneed parental consent till 18 26952016-12-06T10:09:44.22713440Richard lowryFair treatment26872016-12-06T10:21:04.41713441SharonAs a mother of a 17 year old son, I would like to be informed if he was prescribed any strong and life changing medication. 26952016-12-06T10:27:22.11313442Susanparsons Every one read and sign26952016-12-06T10:32:20.3913443Liz hicksIt shouldnt have happened far to imature at 16 to make such a huge desicion26952016-12-06T11:13:06.83313444Anne TaylorWhat is the point of giving free busses to pensioners if the bus stops running26572016-12-06T11:38:19.0413445Carolann gillespiePlease help this family26952016-12-06T11:54:30.19313447Jade RitchieAt the age of 16 no child should be prescribed medication like that without someone else knowing. 26952016-12-06T12:07:02.69713448Lesley Anne GreenawayNo child under the age of 18 should be prescribed medication by a GP without the consent of their parents.26952016-12-06T13:22:50.8213449Margaretann Mcarthur I honestly think doctors should prescribe the correct medication to youngsters who need help with mental health care without their parents consent under the age of 18 as it would save so many life's and help them in the future if it's dealt with early26952016-12-06T14:26:09.56313450Catherine macinnes I think children under 18 Nedd to be protected 26952016-12-06T15:31:15.49313451Jennavulnerable children need to be assisted with mental health medication. 26952016-12-06T17:37:39.63713452Elizabeth CochranBeing an under 18 myself I totally agree with this petition. I have many mental health issues and wouldn't know what to do if I got given tablets and felt low. This needs to be stopped 26952016-12-06T18:37:07.23713453Alison Maclennan Hope you get justice for Britney xx26952016-12-06T19:54:35.80713454Suzanna Webster RIP sweetheart x26952016-12-06T19:57:10.34313455Suzanna Webster Signed RIP sweetheart xx26952016-12-06T20:34:23.33313456cassandra smithI feel that parents should definitely know everything there child is being proscribed at all times,at certain young ages I feel children don't know and understand the damage that can be cause due to taking pills that are well out of there league!!! Hope this helps bring a stop to under age prescriptions!!26952016-12-06T20:55:13.73713457Karl McAreaveyFirst Glasgow buses are dirty, smelly, always late and very very often do not turn up, I have quite regularly taken over 2 hours to get home for what should have been a 35-40 minute trip as 3 buses in a row haven't turned up. I call their helpline and complain at least 2-3 times a week but they couldn't care less we need to get rid of these money grabbing greedy robbing rich fat cat directors & share holders and run the buses for the public. They should be cheap and regular and if need be run at a loss for a few years until people feel confident enough to use them and get out of their cars, until then you will not convince the majority to leave the cars in the drive or garage.26572016-12-06T20:57:37.22313458Tracy donoghueMental health is a huge issue for under 18. It needs to be treated at all ages. 26952016-12-06T21:04:12.74313460Prof Essi VidingTogether with colleagues we have conducted research into PDA showing that it is distinguishable from typical autism, as well as conduct disorder. Individuals with PDA have a specific set of symptoms and challenges and require unique support that is not currently readily available. More research into this condition is also urgently needed.26922016-12-06T22:39:07.34713461Megan DorisIt should be allowed 26952016-12-06T22:40:13.34713462Dylan Keeping someone with mental health issues without help could cause a problem26952016-12-06T22:57:20.36313463Ashley DrippsScans need to be done ASAP. Needs to be detected early. 26872016-12-07T00:22:31.76713464Sheila bensonNo child should be given medication with out there parents knowledge a hope this gets changed before someone else has to got through this.26952016-12-07T07:55:50.813466Emily GreenwoodEveryone should be allowed help, no matter what their age is 26952016-12-07T09:05:33.45713467Aimee brown Good luck Xx 26952016-12-07T12:26:14.02313468Ellen Stewart (Secretary of C.C.)We have had a number of challenges with First Bus. Our former MP was involved in keeping the No.64 bus in our East End area of Glasgow. No service on a Sunday or after 7pm during the week. SPT had to arrange for a bus to service the area on Sunday & in the evenings.26572016-12-07T13:22:53.73313469Fiona MannGlasgow needs to be better served by public transport . Deregulation has isolated some outlying areas , and in central areas buses are vying for passengers.26572016-12-07T15:05:27.23313471Patricia HewittTo understand PDA you must first have a good understanding of Autism Spectrum. It has been my experience over the years trying to find answers for my children's behaviour that there is an endemic failure to recognise and diagnose Autism Spectrum. The understanding in CAMHS is shocking. The strategies and policies we have are not worth the paper they are written on. There was no early intervention. Lack of investment and training in mental health services by governments is to blame.\r\nSupport to my family has been virtually non-existent, leaving us past crisis point. It's left my children with preventable mental health issues, a failed education, social exclusion and ongoing undiagnosed issues years later. For my family and so many others it's too late. The damage is done.\r\nHad the awareness of PDA been available, and it was formally recognised, the horror story my family has encountered was preventable. It has been proved by the early intervention of a child in 1998 PDA strategies do work.\r\nWho will take responsibility for my children? Who will care for them 24 hours a day, 7 days a week? They require specific PDA strategies. Normal Autism strategies do not work. Phil Christie and Ruth Fidler, the world's leading experts, emphasise "listen to the parents". So many lives have been destroyed. Scotland, make an inspirational decision and formally recognise PDA. That will set the precedent for the rest of the UK, then the world. 26922016-12-07T16:51:11.96713472Elizabeth HuseineIt's important26952016-12-07T18:18:44.86713473Ali coxx Done. Hope this helps x26872016-12-07T19:23:33.87713475Kelly CosgroveGood luck xx26952016-12-07T20:12:08.26313477Priscilla Aitcheson I have been to see my own Msp on this very matter. Our children deserve for their disability to be recognised and treated as such. We parents are fighting for our children's lives. 26922016-12-07T20:14:22.8413478Darren Burgess I support Annette and hopefully this will be passed.26952016-12-07T20:35:13.1213479Joy McCreadySupport our kids26922016-12-07T21:33:23.47313480Kelsey Stillie Really hope something is done about this. Rip Brittany xx26952016-12-07T22:15:04.1813482Megan RIP Britney 26952016-12-07T22:22:59.41713483Debbie Campbell As all children develop at different stages I don't think that children should be able to get their hands on medication that could cost them their life as children are forgetful and think they know best sometimes they need the guidance from an adult to help them please stop letting these children grow up faster than they need to and as a mother I have taught my children that they should never keep secrets this is encouraging secrets and deception within families I just think on every level this is wrong children are children no adults so there for they don't have the mentality to make big decisions for themselves I understand everyone needs someone to talk to that isn't family that's fine but when it is something this serious surely medication is not the only help that could have bn given? This young girl has lost her life and it is the nhs that r to blame someone let her down big time now this family has to suffer this girl is only a year younger than my daughter and the thought that my daughter could have access to do something like this to herself is frightening I believe children need to b allowed to grow up n not forced to so let the responsibility lie with the parents not the children such a sad story to see and my heart goes out to this family I really hope this petition helps them xx26952016-12-07T22:31:5113484Janice Why is there not a law to say under 18s need an adults consent to receive medication 26952016-12-07T23:34:34.313486janeann mcewan i have suffered from depression as a young age and i no medicine can be so dangerous in the hands of people with mental illness specially under 18 26952016-12-08T00:43:20.96713489Michelle Graham Very privileged to have attended a PDA workshop recently. It's imperative that it is recognised, so correct strategies can be put in place 26922016-12-08T08:49:13.3813494Anne lockhartChildren under 18 should never be giving medication as strong as this without notifying parents.26952016-12-08T09:15:22.30713495Michelle DrakePDA is one of the worst disabilities as it is completely misunderstood and hidden as a result children suffer immensely and families are at breaking point! This has got to stop! These families need a lot of support and understanding to help raise their PDA children so they can become fully functioning adults, the social return would be 10 fold. The education system is at a loss with this condition and teachers are not given the tools or expertise to manage these children. The key is knowledge !! 26922016-12-08T09:38:21.0113496Lynne LiddleNeed to make more people aware of this26922016-12-08T10:04:19.51713498Helen Williams I fully agree that parents or guardians of young adults under 18 with mental health issues should be involved in their care and made aware of any treatment given to them.26952016-12-08T10:10:21.0313499Laurence KellyVery important for this to gain recognition.26922016-12-08T12:22:08.36313500Khloe KendallSigned really hope this works you could potentially save thousands of other young people's life's! Best of luck Annette Xx26952016-12-08T12:44:54.33313501EmilyI dont think a child should be prescribed meds without consent from a parent or guardian 26952016-12-08T13:50:59.5113502Kathleen O'BrienThese tests are standard care in the US to monitor the the growth of existing tumors and to detect new ones to determine the correct treatment and to \r\nmonitor the outcome of that treatment. This rare disease is deadly requires me to have them every three months now. Scans and excellent treatment have kept me alive with metastatic liver cancer for three years. The people of Scotland deserve the same chances for surviving as long as possible with the proper standard of care, anything less in irresponsible and cruel.26872016-12-08T15:02:02.8713503Nancy swan I don't think any child should go to a doctors and be giving medication under the age of 18 without consenting the parents 26952016-12-08T16:34:39.98713504Daniel mccannI am 100 percent behind this petition26952016-12-08T18:22:38.92713505Amanda Mclauchlan After having issues myself. And now as an adult I completely agree with this petition. 26952016-12-08T18:30:25.48713506Michael mcgowanI don't think any child under 18 should be able to be prescribed drugs without the consent from the parents. 26952016-12-08T18:37:37.1113507Maureen Although a lot of 16-18 yr old are independent Some especially vulnerable need support or someone to take care or have knowledge of their needs. This would prevent tragic cases26952016-12-08T19:05:14.39713508gillian stewartSupportis required as is recognition of this condition. It is real and affects so many families. 26922016-12-08T21:24:33.65313509Erin fowler Hope she is Is resting in peace so young taking so early had her full life a head of her 26952016-12-08T22:14:09.33313510Hayley salmonSigned.. so sorry for your loss xxx26952016-12-08T22:51:26.4513513Alan KarasBus services in Glasgow are not joined up, far too expensive, old busses & services finishing at 7pm. Not good enough 26572016-12-09T13:01:32.17713516Craig HannanThe bus service from my area is disgraceful , often up to three scheduled buses in a row don't turn up. I have sent numerous complaints only to receive a standard letter with no improvements made. There is no other choice to win hdraw my custom and choose another company. I had cheaper bus travel subsidised through my work but service is so bad I now pay extra to get the train.26572016-12-09T13:19:47.22713517Mrs S DyerWe live on the outskirts of Glasgow and have one bus that comes into our estate. The timetable changes constantly as does the route and is, at best, a half hourly service. We need a better, more reliable bus service with more choice. Lothian Buses is the model Glasgow should follow.26572016-12-09T13:49:49.0313518Cheryl DugganThere should be a level playing field for all children to receive funding at the same time. If the cut off is the term following their 3rd birthday, everyone should wait. If only local authority nurseries can offer places that discriminates against the working parents who need full day care and all partnership nurseries who take children before they are 3. Their money is needed to pay staff - local authority are government funded, so our children should receive the same payment from government. Parents at our nursery can't understand why their children are treated differently - neither can the staff.26842016-12-09T16:50:20.84713519Fiona MontgomeryBetter public transport is life saving, contributing to improved health and wellbeing and to tackling climate change.26572016-12-09T18:48:00.42313520R McKayIt's clear that bus services in Glasgow are no longer fit for purpose. Near enough constant cutting back of routes, curtailing of service hours, and rising prices are having a seriously detrimental effect on people's lives. 26572016-12-09T19:11:34.83313521Pat BaillieBus routes contribute to air pollution in city centre. The present transport system is run for profits not for passengers. We cannot address these issues until buses are taken back into public control.26572016-12-09T19:46:17.21313523Caroline KentMake this vital service available in Scotland \r\nWe are all part of the UK ....! \r\n26872016-12-09T20:01:59.73313524Barry Gale The Lord Advocate is an Officer of the State. Such a person could not be an impartial judge if the alleged crime involved a government employee or a branch of government. 27192016-12-09T22:41:40.59713526Ruth CampbellWe have just had another vicious round of cuts in Glasgow leaving large areas without a service26572016-12-10T00:55:08.06313527NeilIs this the dictionary definition of a travesty of justice? I thought the Law was there to protect victims and their families, not to humiliate them?27192016-12-10T02:17:27.04313529Clare I myself have suffered depression and ptsd for many years since i was 15 actually. Doctors prescribed me with flouxitine 20mg at 16. The side effects were unbearable at times migranes stonach aches the lot i had. Yet year by year i wemt back they kept saying it takes time. So as the years went by i realised so did my childhood i had alot of memory problems and didnt remember things that happend either a week or evan a day before ! Yet doctors said it was short term but it most certainly was not ! My moods wete still as bad evan though my parents tried to keep am eye on my i was very very good at hiding my feelings i had many many suicide attemps myself thats how low this medicine got me it made me worse ! After 6 years my medication was finally changed but i had to go through the withdrawls from flouxitine which was now 60mg i was on a day i feel this certain medication should NOT be prescribed to anyone let along a child im hoping myself to start a petition for it to be removed rip Britney fly high x26952016-12-10T10:23:36.1513530Robert DunnThe law at present is does nothing for the victims. Or the grieving relatives.27192016-12-10T13:08:10.4113534Elaine lochrieDaughtet of mr james lochrie firstbus glasgow bus driver killed 27192016-12-10T17:24:01.5813536Isabella WattThese families deserve justice27192016-12-10T17:35:11.07313537Bill BurgeIf it's good enough for Edinburgh, then it's good enough for Glasgow. 26572016-12-10T23:25:27.5813540Carol WatsonEquity for all children.26842016-12-11T12:03:40.4613541Mary HowieChanging the law would be a deterrent 27192016-12-11T15:14:52.26713542Andy HiggisonMy over 60s bus pass is one of the many subsidies bus companies rely on. This public money should not end up in the profits of private hands, but should be invested in the common ownership of a public service that is fit for the needs of the people of Scotland.26572016-12-11T19:38:15.7213543Sue BaxterThe strategies for working with youngsters with PDA are not the same as those usually used for ASD. It is important that this becomes more widely known.26922016-12-11T23:03:59.43713544Fiona MartinComputerised timetable on bus shelters hasn't been working for months no explanation. Ridiculous price hikes and no stopping these increases used to be excuse was fuel increases cannot justify when price is so low. Reduced service during school holidays public holidays yet still expected to pay same price for monthly ticket and now for some reason we seem to be getting single deckers at peak times ( No 57 ) and standard excuse every time buses don't turn up and more and more cutting bus routes which are not profitable regardless of ageing population in some of these areas (withdrawal of No 45 bus through Sighthill being an example).26572016-12-11T23:11:35.35713545Glynis jacksonTotally agree, children under 18 shouldn't be prescribed drugs for mental health problems with their parents knowledge 26952016-12-11T23:19:29.04713546Lorna HowieI'm all for confidentiality but there comes a point when intervention is necessary. How devastating for a parent to find all this out when it's too late. These young oeople often just need to be heard, not drugged up. Please prevent this from happening again . 26952016-12-12T08:37:45.35713549Andrina currieSave our kids change the law.26952016-12-12T18:01:32.44313550Jacqueline A Alexandersad day if they close this - its needed by the community and its residents.26762016-12-12T18:27:35.25713551L TocFamilies and people deserve justice especially since the Bin Lorry disaster in Glasgow was turned down. 27192016-12-12T20:28:36.2613553Rachael KerrSomething needs to be done to save other young people! heart goes out to britneys mum and others who have lost a child or family member to suicide26952016-12-13T13:53:17.3213554Cat hunterStop!!!!26762016-12-13T14:54:26.95313555Branislav SudjicA very bad idea, it would allow all sorts of abuse of the system27192016-12-13T17:10:02.21313556Jessica MasonThanks to everyone who signs- the more signatures it gets the higher the chances of the petition succeeding!\r\nOn that note please also share as widely as you can on social media and with any groups that might have an interest.26702016-12-13T20:55:09.31713558Catherine sneddonBusses in Bo'ness are so expensive I very rarely use them...£7.80 for an all day ticket between Bo'ness and falkirk £6.90 a return... we in Bo'ness don't get to take advantage of first bus £15 weekly ticket £4.50 day ticket for the Falkirk area... Bo'ness is the only area not included in this!!!! 26572016-12-13T22:27:37.37313559Angela RankineI work as a care assistant in a nursing home if i work at weekends i don't have transport to go to work or come back from work i need to get taxis .26572016-12-13T23:25:13.01313560Evelyn CampbellBuses in my area only run every half hour between 9:15 am to 6:45 pm Monday to Saturday. No service Sunday or public holidays and had no service for 4 days Christmas weekend and again New Year weekend last year. No competition.26572016-12-14T00:01:58.45713561Catherine GreerThis home is needed for the residents & makes a difference to the quality of their lives.26762016-12-14T13:21:04.7413562Wendy LawrenceFirst Buses are filthy, subsidised, do not run on time and my services have been cut from three routes to one. Vital infrastructure should be owned by the people.26572016-12-14T14:14:35.32313563John walkerMy sister has this type of cancer and started this petition to secure help for herself and others26872016-12-14T15:37:14.25313564Bruno BaumgartnerBuses, but also Ferries, Trains and Air service to Islands, should all be taken out of private ownership and grouped into one Ministry, Ministry for Public Transport and has a seat in the cabinet. The uncoordination for exemple on Isle of Arran is legendary. Each quango is just looking for themselves and the grapeline has it, that some quangos don't even speak to each others. 26572016-12-14T16:11:07.73313566Heather reillySupport you all 100%.Parents should be notified.16 you are still young.26952016-12-14T18:36:25.0113567Graham HaddowI know little about PDA but I know a friend who has battled very hard and has hit many brick walls in her efforts to have her daughter assessed and finally diagnosed as having PDA. I also know very little about Harlequin Ichthyosis (look it up) or Scoliosis of the spine, conditions which are rare but very visible and receive a very sympathetic and supportive response from people. PDA is a non visible condition with symptoms displayed through behaviour and as such does not receive the same sympathetic, supportive response....with blame often placed on bad parenting for the condition, rather than acknowledgement of good parenting for managing the condition.\r\nPDA is a recognised condition and as such children and families should have the necessary understanding, supports and resources which are required to manage this condition. 26922016-12-14T23:33:15.12713568Helen JefferyThere is only one bus from Bo'ness to Edinburgh in the early morning and one returning at 5.30 pm. Monday to Friday only. People who work or study or want to go to Edinburgh to out with these times have very lengthy and expensive journeys! Disgrace!26572016-12-15T00:03:22.2713569Margaret sutherlandI have a grandson 17 years and a 16 year old granddaughter, and I would be horrrified if they were prescribed medication without their parents knowledge26952016-12-15T12:03:51.86313571Education Law Unit, Govan Law CentreThis is a great opportunity to raise awareness around PDA and to ensure that professionals have the best training to recognise PDA and to support children who have been diagnosed with PDA in their education, ensuring that they can access their education in an efficient manner.26922016-12-15T15:39:39.78313572Tracy mcburnieSigned X mental health problems are on the increase and we need better ways of dealing with it instead of drugs .26952016-12-15T16:42:42.65313573Kristin BarrettIn our area, we are fed up of badly maintained buses, which sometimes make horrible grinding noises, and occasionally (like this year) even go on fire!26572016-12-15T16:52:26.84313574TOM NISBETDEREGULATION ALLOWS A FREE FOR ALL WHICH IS USED TO BOOST PROFITS AT THE EXPENSE OF SERVICE TO AREAS IN MOST NEED OF HELP!26572016-12-15T18:11:54.7313576Mike SmithIt doesn't bode well that the SNP are financially supported by Stagecoach owners. The SNP Conference has consistently voted for re-regulation but the Executive overrode the decision. Let's hope this time it's different but as so many at the top of the SNP are not bringing this forward or even supporting I'll not hold my breath. Prove me wrong! I'd be delighted! 26572016-12-15T18:19:38.713578Ellie HarrisonI'm so pleased to be see so many signatures and comments on this petition.\r\n\r\nWe must join together to get the Scottish Government to take this issue seriously. \r\n\r\nIndividual complaints to First Buses do nothing! Below is an extract from the frustrating exchange I had with a 'Customer Advisor' at First last summer, which motivated me to start campaigning! Together we will win this :D\r\n\r\nOn 28 July 2015 17:06, Ellie Harrison wrote:\r\n\r\nDear David,\r\n\r\nThanks for your response to my complaint about the discontinuation of the 42 bus route.\r\n\r\nI appreciate that this route may have not been running for some time now, but I have only come to need it now that I am injured and unable to cycle to work.\r\n\r\nI am afraid it is not acceptable to claim that the route had to be stopped because it was 'not commercially viable'. Public transport should be about providing a service to citizens and not about making a profit for private companies. And, indeed, it should be the most vulnerable in our society (those injured, disabled or those with low incomes) who it primarily seeks to serve - not the opposite as in the case in point.\r\n\r\nThe discontinuation of this route, along with all other West - East routes (as detailed in your response) is just another good reason why Glasgow's bus contracts should be withdrawn from First Buses and taken back into public ownership under direct management of SPT instead.\r\n\r\nIf you are unable to take my complaint further and to reinstate these essential West - East routes, I will begin a campaign to kick First out of Glasgow, so that we can finally get the comprehensive and affordable Public transport system that our city deserves. Mark my words.\r\n\r\nYours sincerely,\r\n\r\nEllie Harrison26572016-12-15T18:31:44.64713579Claire CalderThe SNP claim they are a people's party, yet bus deregulation, Scotrail franchises etc all prove that the SNP ARE the tories! Buses MUST be regulated to keep them in check and RAILWAYS MUST BE NATIONALISED!26572016-12-15T18:39:07.2113582David YoungI'm a non-driver, and over the past 30 years I've watched the steady decline of bus services in Scotland. \r\n\r\nLonger journeys. Fewer, less frequent services. Painful fare rises. Dirty, decrepit, ageing vehicles. Or new ones that simply aren't fit for purpose: basic, utilitarian models that would be just about okay on an airport shuttle service, but certainly aren't designed for the long rural journeys on which greedy operators run them. \r\n\r\nSo it goes on. And I'm just glad that I live in a city (Edinburgh) where there's still a degree of local accountability, and a measure of pride in running decent local bus services (and modern, comfortable buses) for the public good.\r\n\r\nThis is what we should be aiming for in Scotland and throughout the UK. An enlightened government would make it a priority - for environmental reasons, for social reasons - and I believe such a policy would enjoy widespread support.\r\n\r\nSo how about it?26572016-12-15T18:57:09.1413583Linda Allan So sad such a young life wasted....heart goes out to parents... Change this so no family have to go through what this family have such tragic circumstances R.I.P x26952016-12-15T19:26:09.18313585William FeatherstoneWith every Scottish Local Authority now making Cut's to their Budgets, it is clear that any Private Operators will decrease the level of Publicly Run Services should their Grant Levels fall.\r\nThis is why the Public MUST demand a fully funded Public Passenger Network of both Buses, and Train Services to be maintained at a level that suites The Passengers needs, and NEITHER any lower levels of Services that maybe suggested by Private Transport Companies, or by Council Executives, without consulting The Public at Large.\r\nWe should also EXTEND the use of more Public Service Travel in the future, and not less.. 26572016-12-15T21:10:47.35313586Mary CluckieAs a teacher, whilst I do consider PDA to be a distinctive trait in some children with ASD, with a specific diagnosis of PDA becoming possible I would hope that children are enabled to access the support they need rather than be taught in provisions geared towards the needs of children with more typical autistic traits which are the opposite of the needs af a demand avoidant child.26922016-12-15T21:34:57.2813587Angus DoyleUnregulated private bus companies can never provide the comprehensive service that all communities in Scotland need. In Glasgow, where so many rely on public transport, a TfL-style system is the only sollution, ensuring that unprofitable aren't neglected and that public transportation need not 'compete' with food and fuel as a daily expense for the city's poorest residents.26572016-12-15T22:17:11.03713588Denis hawkinsRe nationlisle without compensation 26572016-12-15T23:31:36.22313590Connie BryantPlease look into these issues of such he importance to parents, whereby Drs are not sharing this kind of information, so that parents can try do something to prevent these things happening and give them the chance to communicate with there chidren over any issue they may not be handling well, it may prevent further suicides in young people.26952016-12-16T05:17:17.47313591Angela MCallAny form of ASD needs more awareness. The amount of children waiting for a diagnosis and the length of time it takes is ridiculous.26922016-12-16T16:59:19.2913593Hilda SmithOnly becoming aware of this now but describes my grand daughter exactly, she has already been diagnosed with ASD but this explains so much more. Quite sure it would help if all authorities were also aware.26922016-12-16T17:26:06.1213594Neil LennoxWhenever I venture out of the Edinburgh area I'm astonished by the poor condition of the buses and the high fares. 26572016-12-16T18:05:27.31313595Tam McColl"Haud The Bus !"... nationalise it.26572016-12-16T18:25:14.8813596Lynsey kerrMy son is 3 on 11 Jan 17 and I have been paying for childcare since he was 3 months and have to continue paying until April. Misses the cut off by 11 days I find this very unfair 26842016-12-16T18:52:16.69713597Chris ByrneI'm lucky enough to be able to use the excellent service run by Lothian Buses. All people in Scotland should be able to travel in clean, efficient, frequent buses like those in Edinburgh and the Lothians.26572016-12-16T19:44:32.15713599Daniel McGivern.Firstbus are not working for the people who need buses to get around, it's all profit with no thought of services after 18:00. The sooner a new bus company starts providing much needed services the better.26572016-12-16T20:28:26.00713600Eddie Cassidy It's essential that public transportation is run for and by the local authorities. Only then will we have a service that meets the needs of the users not the shareholders.26572016-12-17T00:45:21.95713601Katrina CaldwellA publicly run national bus service that serves the population rather than seeking to increase profits as its sole imperative is needed in a small nation with both geographical and social challenges to a vibrant, sustainable economy that puts people not profit first26572016-12-17T00:59:58.4513602Allister HarlandThis is not the way children should be treated its society that should be aware that the children think different 26922016-12-17T06:38:30.2813603Robert BoyceDon't let britneys death be for nothing 26952016-12-17T10:45:23.36713604Craig LewisPublic transport should put people before profit. We need local democratic control of a coherent and integrated system. Not a system determined primarily by the private sector values of shareholder returns and profit maximisation.26572016-12-17T12:18:00.4913605Alan MatthewsThe busses I get to where I live can leave you waiting up to an hour if you need one after 6pm. In the winter time this is sheer misery.26572016-12-17T14:02:24.5913606Alice ConwayHow can we help our children if we do not know what is going on? I strongly support this petition.\r\n26952016-12-17T15:58:04.85713607Scott DicksonForgetting the regular poor bus services, let's also look at Xmas and New Year timetabling - as companies increasingly require Boxing Day and 2nd January working at the least - not only do we see no service on Xmas day and New Years day, but impossible to get anywhere before noon on the day after - along with a Saturday service with the remainder of the fortnight surrounding. It is exactly the people who NEED a bus service that tend to be required to work these days (low paid, retail etc) and as service providers it is up to these companies to take responsibility for their timetabling.26572016-12-17T17:01:58.97313608Louise dicksonTotally agree with this why should doctors be allowed to give drugs to young adults at 16 when the law doesn't recognize them being adult till the age of 18 26952016-12-17T21:55:54.813609Jean I agree that no child should be giving prescription drugs, X\r\n26952016-12-18T13:15:13.49713612Ian todNeeds sorted26572016-12-18T14:15:16.16313613kevin columba gallagherTheir service is abysmal. They turn up sometimes.\r\n26572016-12-18T14:30:03.9913614Fairlie Gordon At the moment my local service (364) is every 90 mins 26572016-12-18T17:02:36.3113615Forbes WatsonThe Buses from East Kilbride to Glasgow City are disgusting, the fares are very high just to go down to the town centre, they are never cleaned especially the windows you can't even see out them , the Drivers are a mess very untidy, intead of having McGill and First Buses, there should be more such as Stagecoach , now they were the best they were knocked out when the First Glasgow Bus came on the seen - never mind the trains they could not run a train and they cannot run a bus. very angry .26572016-12-18T17:14:58.28313616Grant LattoIf you enjoy a journey on a clapped out, expensive irregular bus controlled by a rude, maniacal and angry driver, then First bus is for you. \r\n\r\nMe, I go out of my way to avoid them at all costs. 26572016-12-18T22:09:51.02313617Joseph McIntoshServices are a disgrace!26572016-12-18T22:27:20.02713618Mark McCabeFirst Bus offer an expensive and unreliable service to bus users. I would love to see buses across Scotland, England and Wales to be nationalised as well as the railway.26572016-12-19T04:19:59.3813619Amy EllisNo one should be aloud to be given and type of drug or medication especially under the age of 18 unless with a adult! 26952016-12-19T16:37:18.4913620John mccollAt night as you go home from work and miss the 80clock bus have to wait to 9 o'clock for the next one wot if you have children's and old people as it get cold at night some time as 9oclock bus not turns up have to wait 10.oclock for next one were the train run a better than the bus 26572016-12-19T17:01:00.67713621Carole O'Brien Over prices. Filthy buses. Rude staff26572016-12-19T18:53:32.5213622Alison GrayThe lack of a proper bus services is turning my hometown into a place where you cannot survive without a car. It is difficult or impossible to get out in the evening or on a Sunday. And the prices are eye-watering. Lack of movement is bad for peoples personal lives and for the economy and so many people depending on cars is bad for the environment. Come on Holyrood, take care of your country!26572016-12-19T22:58:07.25713623Jay WakefieldI find buses extremely stressful and if I did not have my consession card, the fares are so high (and you don't even get change) that I'd sooner pay a bit more and take taxis (if I could afford it). Buses do not run on time, sometimes even drive past a stop with people waiting there, and First's attitude of putting profits before people is I believe reason in itself that the buses and trains need to be brought under public ownership.26572016-12-20T00:17:30.39313624Nicholas BarbierWhy are the Scottish government against putting the interests of the people before the interests of First Group and Stagecoach? It's not because they provide a quality service.26572016-12-20T05:09:07.2813625Amanda RoyI lived in West Lothian where the main provider was First and they were hopeless. Now live in Edinburgh where Lothian are streets ahead. First use buses of the vintage I went to school in and I left school 35 years ago - enough said. 26572016-12-20T05:27:5113626Lynne MuirheadI cannot imagine how difficult everyday life and especially trying to learn at school, must be for youngsters with PDA syndrome , every day of their lives. 26922016-12-20T10:57:33.14713628Robert Scottdecent public transport should be a basic human right.... and having recently seen my own local bus services cut I realise that is not the case in Scotland.26572016-12-20T13:41:39.70313630Agnes FoxI O pay £94 for a 10 week ticket on first bus but end up paying fare to another company when my bus dosnt turn up. First bus are a joke.26572016-12-20T15:36:36.8613632Diljeet BhachuGlasgow bus services are a nightmare - late, expensive, dirty, overcrowded. The whole country should have the level and quality of service Edinburgh get through Lothian buses. 26572016-12-20T16:48:51.10713633Heather WalkerReregulation is vital to rural communities26572016-12-20T17:01:19.90313634James Grahamin our small communities we need the buses to be reregulated again, as so many of us are now dependent on them as our families are no longer in the area due having to move away for employment.26572016-12-20T17:53:56.75313635juliehelen haggartI live in a small village which relies on public transport our village used to have a bus link to glasgow Stirling and Dunfermline we now have a bus to kilsyth severly depleted please regulate a decent bus service and regulate our buses 26572017-01-10T12:18:33.33713638Jessica MasonThanks for all the signatures so far, remember to share as wide as you can to make people aware. There's been a piece in the Fife courier and on Tay FM so far too which is great.26702017-01-11T13:01:27.20713640Peter SansomI hope this is a success. Apart from the biodegradable angle I would like to see less of these cups lying about as litter27052017-01-13T11:47:09.42713641James WardIt is a fundamental right access to Justice27192017-01-13T13:34:28.9213642Harry HillAfter the evidence that has been collected it makes sense to change the law 27192017-01-14T19:34:39.27713645J CIt is depressing to see discarded cups littering the streets, particularly in places like Edinburgh and Glasgow. A tax on plastic cups (like 5p charges on plastic bags) I feel would be a good idea, but legislation should also be expanded to include a tax on other take-away food carriers, like polystyrene take-away chip boxes, which can harm the environment.27052017-01-20T16:21:17.6113646Greg FullartonThis was wrong a decade ago in the Firth of Forth, the current plan in the Moray Firth is wrong. We need prevent our environment and economy being damaged by these ill thought out plans and ensure that Port are accountable to their stakeholders in the future and not themselves. 27292017-01-20T19:46:57.47713647Tom ForbesWe consider The Moray Firth as important as The Firth of Forth27292017-01-21T06:57:44.68313648Mary BowersProtected species and SACs should not be exploited to fund business ventures in this way.27292017-01-21T09:09:44.42313650Debbie WartnabyPlease help us stop S2S transfers in the Moray Firth, a habitat rich in important wildlife. The environmental damage that will happen if something goes wrong is to terrifying to contemplate27292017-01-21T09:22:28.6913651Iain FairweatherThe oil transfer process is not risk free. The environment and wildlife must be safeguarded. The tourism economy is threatened simply by the visual intrusion of tankers on the seascape, never mind the after effects of just the odd minor spill. Not worth the risk!27292017-01-21T09:39:21.73713652Julie CampbellThe potential for a disaster is very high. We should be looking after our natural habitat as there isn't a lot left.27292017-01-21T09:48:51.05313653Edward AndrewsThere are two issues here. there is the environmental one about where it is proposed to have Ship to Ship Transfers. \r\n There is also a wider one about the constraints on the activities of a Trust Port and the behaviour of their officers. 27292017-01-21T10:06:35.4613654Ruth DarwinThis is a beautiful area which is extremely important environmentally. It is also an income for scotlands tourist industry. You wouldn't want it happening on your doorstop27292017-01-21T10:11:18.35313655brian mckenzieonce again money is more important than the enjoyment so many people get from the wild life in the highlands .we are not going to let this happen it only takes 1 spill we had it with the brear 27292017-01-21T10:13:28.99313656Chris WilmshurstPlease do not let them ruin the Moray Firth, the tourism,ecology and conservation.27292017-01-21T10:14:32.13313657Lindsey DickensThe Moray Firth is such an important area for marine wildlife and tourism which is important for employment. We cannot risk destroying the area.27292017-01-21T11:00:15.2213658Patsy GoodsirTime the powers that be started LISTENING to the people who really care about their environment and our precious and unique wildlife27292017-01-21T11:02:31.2213659KaraOur marine wildlife is so precious and already suffers enough disruption from the ships and industry we have now on our seas, there is a safe alternative at the Nigg jetty where STS transfers have taken place for the last 30 years - safeguard those jobs. I want future generations to know we realised our environment is priceless and protected it against those that seek short term financial profit against the wishes of the people who love our land and seas. \r\n27292017-01-21T11:22:54.28313660Frances FauldsPlease put an end to this madness now!27292017-01-21T11:24:37.53313661Paul ChaplinI believe that allowing ship to ship transfer in the Moray Firth runs the very real risk of destroying a fantastic marine habitat and a visitors haven for years to come following a leak. It does not make economic sense for the wider community only for CFPA and they should be made to listen to local people who would be affected by their potential actions .27292017-01-21T11:33:06.2413662KarenShip-to-ship just a disaster waiting to happen. Definitely not worth the risk. 27292017-01-21T11:36:13.94313663Yvonne LauranceAn oil spill in Cromarty Firth would be a disaster for wildlife27292017-01-21T12:10:17.7613664Leslie MitchellAny activity like ship to ship oil transfer, particularly in an area like the Moray Firth poses a danger to large communities of people whose livelihood depends on tourism, as any spillage would have a devastating and long lasting detrimental effect on the already fragile economy of the area. The Moray Firth area is already suffering from the effects of sewage pollution due to the dual affect of increased population and out of date sewerage treatment plants. \r\nThe tidal flow of the Moray Firth is not sufficient to disperse the existing pollution levels being pumped into it. Oil transfers of any kind poses a risk of spillage and as sure as eggs is eggs, a spillage will happen. Who is going to "pick up the tab" when this happens??\r\nThis area depends heavily on tourism. Tourists bring millions of £'s to the area. An oil spill in the Moray Firth would kill tourism and it would take years for this to recover.\r\nI have not even mentioned the effect a spill would have on the wildlife of the area but it goes without saying that an oilspill would have devastating consequences for the Dolphins, seabirds and fish of the area.\r\nWhoever came up with this bright idea of oil transfer in this area is devoid of all common sense. I doubt that it is even justified commercially.27292017-01-21T12:12:22.4813665John Ross I could probably write a small book on the reasons I'm utterly against this. ... here are a few... I fear oil pollution. The view will be ruined. Light pollution is a problem even now. Disturbance to dolphins etc etc etc 27292017-01-21T13:57:28.19713666Barbara A KeaneNo ship to ship oil transfers27292017-01-21T14:05:09.1213667David brownHope you succeed our wild life is precious.27292017-01-21T14:17:43.70713668Isobel McAllisterPenny pinching can't be allowed to endanger the environment. There is no planet B.27292017-01-21T15:16:12.3113669Mary ChaplinWe own a B&B if this goes ahead it will damage our growing tourist industry27292017-01-21T15:22:23.20713670Councillor Craig fraserThe coastal communities of the Cromarty and Moray Firths have come together to oppose this OPEN WATER AT SEA ship to ship oil transfer license application. This application if allowed to proceed unchallenged benefits no-one other than the PoCF. Many local environmental tour enterprises will be irreparably damaged and even forced out of business. This also includes B&B's, hotels, guest houses, pubs, local stores and souvenir shops. I encourage as many people to sign this petition this is the wrong plan in the wrong place.27292017-01-21T15:38:56.8213671Helen HowisShip to ship tranfers were not allowed in the Forth so this should be the same27292017-01-21T15:44:25.91313672Julian FryerFull support27292017-01-21T16:14:14.18313673Val Parrya total obscenity to even consider an act such as this27292017-01-21T17:07:25.60713674janice frasership to ship oil transferes pose a threat to local wild life27292017-01-21T20:02:41.0513675David ShepherdTransfer of oil in the Firth poses an unacceptable risk in such a valuable biodiversity area.27292017-01-21T20:19:50.10713676Terry FraserThis proposed plan is wrong. Study the area and see how dangerous this could threaten our wild life e.g. Dolphins, seals etc. It will affect local businesses to the point they will need to close. Tourism will disappear etc etc etc!! Please stop this happening it's to risky!27292017-01-21T22:26:41.35313677Iona HampsonI strongly disagree with the proposed ship to ship transfer27292017-01-21T22:36:40.45713678Charlie BlackToo risky to wildlife and fish in the Moray Firth. Nairn beach would suffer too in an oil spill with devastating effects on tourism.27292017-01-21T22:56:32.31713679Colin MathesonAn I'll conceived scheme that has little regard for the environment or those living next to the Moray Firth27292017-01-21T23:26:19.6113680Alison Footitt Please save our coastline. 27292017-01-21T23:52:09.75713681Valery KirbyAll the points put forward by Cromarty Rising have shown that this proposal is absolutely wrong.27292017-01-22T02:03:39.2313683susan lairdNo ship to ship oil transfer please.27292017-01-22T04:29:17.49713684M.DaviesThere is enough pollution in the sea already. The devastation that an oil spillage brings needs to be avoided at all costs not given rise to more "accidents" we have enough endangered species without letting this become a regular threat to already diminishing species in what was once a beautiful balanced environment. let alone the Threat to Local economies that are reliant on clean oceans27292017-01-22T08:40:36.07313685Hamish Clark Any risk, even if it is a very small risk is not worth taking in such an environmentally sensitive area.\r\nNairn is a town which is well know for its beautiful beaches and is popular with tourists which is very important to the local economy. To have huge tankers sitting in the inner Moray Firth would spoil the views and also the noise from their engines would be annoying. The tankers which sit there presently can be heard on still nights and interrupts our sleep.27292017-01-22T12:20:57.1813686Linda BissetShip to ship oil transfers should not take place in environmentally sensitive locations as it could pose risks to wildlife and local economies27292017-01-22T12:21:37.66713687john robertsonThis proposal of ship to ship transfers is ludicrous !\r\nWhy would anyone in their right mind put a beautiful environment at risk of devastation ? Is corporate and personal greed more important ?? 27292017-01-22T13:50:13.19313688Spencer JulianThe whole of the Moray coast will suffer due to the direction of the ocean currents if there was a fuel spillage or leak.27292017-01-22T13:53:46.53713689Maria RushtonOil travels. Any spills affect all of us.27292017-01-22T14:00:38.6813690David freemanNeed to stop this sort of behaviour by self appointed gods, it's time to bring an end to these self effacing self interest, bodies from not having to answer to anyone in particular and a cross party board of MPs in parliament approving the selection and appointments of these directors and chairman they have far to much power for self enhancements and for the benefit of their friends. Their pay scales and bonuses should also be set by an outside body with the books for these organisations coming under similar oversight.27292017-01-22T16:08:41.1813692Councillor Craig fraserIt has now been confirmed that the PoCF has been directed to withdraw their current ship to ship (at sea) oil transfer license application and submit a new one. I respectfully suggest that as this license benefits no-one the PoCF should take notice of the experts, Maritime and Coastguard Agency, and the communities of the Cromarty and Moray Firth that have been opposing the application for over 12 months and withdraw the application totally. I would like to think that common sense would prevail and the PoCF drop the proposal completely. In the absence of any statement to the contrary I would urge objectors to continue opposing the application.27292017-01-22T16:31:21.69713693stacey gormanMammals-Dolphins are the 2nd most intelligent animal on the planet. Why would you endanger the only ones we have in Scotland? For Oil? Selfish if you ask me...27292017-01-22T16:43:45.23313694William fraser milneI do not want this to happen to our coast line. As we have a lot of wildlife around about us. And we should protect them as much as possible.27292017-01-22T16:47:12.01313695Eleanor TilleyWe need to protect the dolphins and other wildlife27292017-01-22T16:59:23.37713696ChloeThere is too much wildlife in the area27292017-01-22T17:01:08.03313697DannyThe wildlife needs protection 27292017-01-22T17:02:46.42313698Chloe The wildlife should be protected 27292017-01-22T17:11:57.40713699Lynn BirchThis proposal is wrong, an oil spillage would be a disaster to the fragile marine environment and tourism industry27292017-01-22T17:18:46.1913700Alastair Field I am against ship to ship oil transfers in the Moray Firth and any other environmentally vulnerable areas in Scotland 27292017-01-22T17:29:29.4113701Eric CraigRisks outweigh the benefits27292017-01-22T17:38:37.00713702Andreas SchulzI have a 4 start B&B and this ship to ship would hurt my business and danger that guests don't come anymore . so I'm against this ship to ship transfer ... Thanks a lot Andreas Schulz27292017-01-22T17:51:47.31713703Caroline BrayI come to Scotland to see the amazing wildlife both on land and at sea. The value of the environment is beyond any financial amount and it must not be put at risk of pollution through accidents during ship to ship oil transfers. We all have a responsibility to care for the oceans and the creature that live in them.27292017-01-22T18:00:42.0713704Loriana PauliYes, I believe that environmental legislation should prevent ship-to-ship oil transfers in environmentally sensitive locations?\r\nYes, I do agree that ship-to-ship oil transfers pose risks to wildlife and local economies?27292017-01-22T18:15:09.61713705Claudia It seems to be a time where in various places on our place real people power is grown more and more successful. Long may it last27292017-01-22T18:39:16.12313706Verity WalkerI cannot believe that parliament or the Marine authorities are going to permit the Port of Cromarty Firth Authority to risk damaging our marine environment in order to make a £750K per annum. Are our dolphins worth that little to our Highland economy? Our little community café relies on a clean beach and a natural 'feel'. There are enough tankers out there already. Please help POCF look for alternative means of raising the investment they need in their cruise port, such as an Oil Rig Platform and North Sea Oil visitor centre which would attract tourists from Scotland an all over the world.27292017-01-22T19:26:24.3513707Jennifer Rossa It's outrageous to even consider this if you take into account the risk of possible damage to the environment. Companies just don't care, it's all about more!!! 27292017-01-22T20:58:59.12313708Gill SmithWe need to ensure that the fragile ecosystem of the sea is fully protected.27292017-01-22T21:39:34.99713709Sandra Good Do not do this protect our environment 27292017-01-22T21:42:10.08313710Kevin Goodwin We went to see the dolphins last year and going again this year. My partner loves them. It's good for Scottish tourism eco friendly style. If there is a chance of even 1% of oil spill think better and say no. Not to mention traffic and water noise. These dolphins are unique to Scotland not to mention othe wildlife. Scottish politicians seem to be clever and care unlike cronies in London. Please do the right thing!27292017-01-22T21:47:34.77313711Patricia connellWe should protect our waters27292017-01-22T22:03:16.0713712Matthew RoseThis is a poor plan in a wholly inappropriate location.27292017-01-22T22:08:01.3913713Gill JohnsonWas the centre of a recent 3 night stay in Inverness. Damage this and you damage tourist spending.27292017-01-23T00:10:12.92313714Jane Kellyit's important to achieve a balance between economic activity and conservation. Short term and short sighted options shouldn't be taken which put profit first whilst disregarding the potential to cause harm to sea life and the surrounding environment.27292017-01-23T00:23:16.9713715Jane DervishI believe it is our duty to save the environment of our dolphins we have to protect them, all too many wild life are being threatened to extinction due to mans actions, we must take fight for them, their survival depends on it....... 27292017-01-23T01:07:13.69713717Irene RossI am very unhappy that these sort of applications can be pushed through by the uninformed few members of a Trust of a Port Authority, without a Local Council having the full implications of the negative effects of such an application before them while making their initial decisions, and on the final decision of one remote Westminster Minister. All this, against the interests of the local environment and the views of it's surrounding communities is completely unacceptable in my opinion and I ask that the Scottish Parliament take every step possible, within the law, to protect our precious shores, ecology, wildlife, tourist industry and employment against this negative, careless profiteering for short term gain, type of application.27292017-01-23T06:55:55.52313718Ian Williams This is a preventable tragedy in the making, the Scottish government must stop this now.27292017-01-23T08:12:20.38313719Lily ByronPlease prevent ship to ship oil transfers in the inner Moray Firth. 27292017-01-23T08:28:47.93713720Duncan Murchisonspoil area of natural beauty27292017-01-23T08:43:01.2213721Jacqueline GovierThere should be no ship to ship oil transfers, the potential hazards to wildlife, the environment and the local economies are enormous. Such risks should not be taken. 27292017-01-23T08:43:56.76313722Sheena ThompsonI really do not understand why this ship to ship transfer is even being considered in the Moray Firth and why we are risking the beauty and environment of the area at all.27292017-01-23T09:28:34.4613723Edward BamberThey always say it's safe until it goes wrong , then there's no way back, 27292017-01-23T10:26:22.38713724Debra SymsPlease think hard about allowing ship to ship oil transfers in the Cromarty and Moray Firths. Do we really want to risk the habitat of the marine animals that live in the firth, apart from the dolphins which bring a huge amount of interest from tourists to the area, we have recently had visits from humpback whales this past month. It would be criminal if ship to ship oil transfers were to go ahead and spoil one of the few remaining natural areas of Scotland. If oil leaks happen and the shores were awash with the bodies of dead dolphins and other marine life it would be a huge disaster to the local community and taint the image of Scotland. People come to the Highlands and Islands to enjoy it's natural beauty and wildlife, please don't risk spoiling our beautiful environment for future generations and the creatures who inhabit it. 27292017-01-23T11:07:17.1113725Diana SidawayAbsolutely believe this should not go ahead.27292017-01-23T11:07:24.69713726Iain Alistair Carlton BrownThe risk is too great to take.27292017-01-23T12:19:13.73713727Alan barronCommon sense must prevail to ensure that ship to ship transfers of oil never happen in our beautiful firth.27292017-01-23T14:12:38.98713728Francis D.McWiLLiams.It is my understanding that should there be a Major Oil Spill then the Highland Council could go Bankrupt?27292017-01-23T14:34:24.07713730Eve McEnallyI have been coming to the Moray Firth for the last 20 years to see these magnificent dolphins in their natural habit. Please ,please ensure that you do not allow any chance of pollution and harm to their environment!27292017-01-23T14:54:20.4413731William ForrestI believe that ship to ship oil transfers should be prevented in coastal waters and that environmental legislation should be of such clarity that this will nullify any need for UK applications for such initiatives in Scotland's coastal waters. In this scenario, permissions will be made a redundant process, saving a lot of time and money and securing the nstural world of wild life and securing the fish industry from oil spill disasters.27292017-01-23T15:42:05.66313732Mrs.Dale WallacePlease please leave this beautiful part of the U.K. alone. The dolphins are a huge tourist attraction (we come here every year, and have got to know a lot of the locals over the years). it never ceases to amaze me how many people come and stand on the shores for hours on end, hoping for a glimpse of these majestic creatures. Please don't take that away.27292017-01-23T15:43:15.99313733Jenni milliganThere is too much at risk to our beautiful environment and dolphins and whales for this to be allowed to go ahead!27292017-01-23T18:01:44.41713734Audrey Johnston It is extremely important that we take steps to protect our shores and wildlife. 27292017-01-23T18:12:51.46313736Jackie GormanShould not be allowed27292017-01-23T18:38:41.20313737George BrownThere a safer way to transfer oil. Much safer.27292017-01-23T19:48:34.19713738James McPhersonThe threat is also from the discharge of ballast water in tankers which contains alien species 27292017-01-23T21:07:58.0513739Fiona BallAny risk of environmental damage is not worth considering - stop this lunacy! 27292017-01-23T22:14:23.0813740IndraThe Scottish environment is much of what makes Scotland an attractive tourist destination. We have some of the most beautiful areas in the world, and some of the most unique ecosystems. These need to be protected from our industry. As a Green leader, a firm commitment to this endeavour is required.27292017-01-23T22:46:41.92713741Sheila MurisonYou must protect our environment and wildlife from the risk of spills and pollution.27292017-01-23T23:03:04.36713742M MackintoshImportant to preserve a natural haven,as yet unspoilt and not yet polluted. A haven of wild life and beauty27292017-01-24T08:22:27.09713744Paul ChaplinDon't let this go ahead, nobody but CFPA want this to happen27292017-01-24T09:43:49.09313745vickyDo not allow this27292017-01-24T10:27:32.113746Jean FrewWe need to stop this....the environment deserves our protection 27292017-01-24T13:00:15.33713747Jane LancasterWhy? 27292017-01-24T15:28:56.9413748Steve BramwellThis issue is so important. It challenges Scottish Government to show that it cares more for the environment than the prospect of a paltry profit at any cost. Come on Scot Gov show us that you really do care27292017-01-24T17:19:29.1113749Laura HanslerThe potential here for a catastrophic environmental disaster to our prized coastline can never be underestimated, there is the potential to wipe out completely ecosystems and generations of sea mammals!\r\nScotland is not a dumping ground , nor an experimental site for the UK !! Ban ship to ship transfer27292017-01-24T18:37:15.7313750Elizabeth A NoonShip to ship oil transfer should be prevented by environmental legislation in locations which are environmentally sensitive.27292017-01-24T19:03:24.40313751Diane MiddlewickOur environment is precious, we must take care of it. Enough of it is being destroyed as it is.27292017-01-24T19:58:20.0413752Wendy LambieShip to ship oil transfers will put wildlife including the dolphins at risk.27292017-01-24T20:09:43.38313753Dee Webster I can't bear the thought of what might happen if this is allowed 27292017-01-24T20:13:40.24313754Mary BromilowTo allow ship to ship oil transfers in a location such as this would be environmental vandalism.27292017-01-24T20:50:01.70313755Nancy AndersonPlease do not risk further pollution in this special silly sensitive area27292017-01-24T21:13:21.7713756Jennifer LuscombeUnbelievable to even think about It! \r\nProtect the dolphins27292017-01-24T23:06:41.62713757Saille MawsonI do believe that environmental legislation should prevent ship to ship oil transfers in sensitive locations. They do pose a risk to wildlife. Any risk in this unique location is unacceptable. I live by the coast in an area where untold damage could be caused by any pollution both to wildlife and the tourism it attracts in this area.27292017-01-24T23:08:37.84713758Alan AitchisonThere has to be environmental legislation in place, backed up by appropriately heavy fines, including imprisonment, to protect environmentally sensitive locations from ship to ship oil transfers. Ship to ship oil transfers pose enormous risks to wildlife and local economies. This is the first time I have engaged in a campaign such as this, but as a former wildlife photographer and person taking part in beached bird survey, I have seen the horrific effects of pollution on our environment.27292017-01-24T23:15:31.6913759Robert SweeneyShip to Ship must not be allowed because of the effect it could have on the environment if an accident did happen.27292017-01-25T08:49:09.71313761Arthur BirdDo not allow this to happen. This is the wrong plan in the wrong place. 27292017-01-25T08:56:16.99713762Ted Murray Calling on Scottish Parliament to vote this crazy, unnecessary scheme down. 27292017-01-25T09:16:21.29313763Helen munroWhy risk damaging a beautiful part of Scotland which is home to dolphins which the local economy depends on for income from people coming to enjoy all we have to offer here ? 27292017-01-25T11:09:35.7313764Edmund Bewley I was instrumental in bringing a successful prosecution of a shipping line for illegal discharge of tank washing by reporting them when operating a scheduled flight near Wick. Transfers are potentially hazardous should be prohibited.27292017-01-25T17:00:26.1913765Debbie CPlease don't let this area be risked by ship to ship oil transfers. I'm a regular tourist to this area which generates significant income to this beautiful area. Please, please don't jeopardise it27292017-01-25T21:04:14.7813766Rob HolderWhy would anyone even contemplate risking the destruction of such a delicate marine environment? And why are the Highland Council not fighting this!? ££££££27292017-01-26T11:41:50.38713767Elzbieta Wojcik-LeeseIt is vital for us to make sure that our waters and the animals that live there are protected. I visit Black Isle regularly and it's a privilege to watch dolphins (and the sea itself) there.27292017-01-26T12:13:15.86713768David Williamson.There are some things that money can't buy. Scotland' natural beauty is sacrosanct. No ship to ship oil transfers. Too much at stake to risk an accident!!!27292017-01-26T12:26:54.41713769Janet Kewleyadam Our marine life must be protected and never face the threat of ship to shore oil transfers27292017-01-26T16:07:29.34713770Robert MansonDolphins are not the only sea life in the firth. There are migrating Atlantic salmon feeding the River Ness, Nairn, Findhorn, Spey etc. and are critical for wildlife, many jobs and so on. Additionally there are mackerel, cod, pollock, ling, crabs, lobsters ate. It is sheer madness to even contemplate ship to ship transfers.27292017-01-26T16:34:37.8813771Hugh WebbMyself and my wife have visited the Cromarty Firth many times to watch the dolphins and all the other wildlife that can be seen in this area. Please do not let this fantastic environment be destroyed.27292017-01-26T19:48:31.78313772David MillerPlease do not allow this to go ahead.27292017-01-26T20:41:57.59313773Carol gray samuels Don't risk it .. one error could destroy the environment for yrs yrs if not permanently 27292017-01-26T22:44:48.54713774Barbara LindsayUrging the Scottish Parliament to do whatever they can to put an end to these proposals & protect our environment and dolphins from the risks these proposals pose.27292017-01-27T05:13:05.9913775Ian brunskillWe holiday up there quite a bit and love going to watch the dolphins at chanory point this could quite easily end in an environmental disaster which would ruin a beautiful part of Scotland.27292017-01-27T09:55:23.9913776walter innesto borrow a quote - the pockets of a few, should not come before the good of the many...27292017-01-27T12:54:43.9913777Kathryn SonleyI do not believe that this delicate ecosystem and beautiful environment should be endangered by risking ship to ship oil transfers. \r\nIt poses too big a risk and and should be prohibited in environmentally sensitive areas.27292017-01-27T17:37:07.94313778Craig MaddockWhy risk the future existence of our wildlife for financial gain for a few people now?27292017-01-27T18:53:28.9413779Margaret SmithPlease do not risk spoiling this beautiful area of my fathers place of birth.27292017-01-27T19:19:06.61713780jacquiechoose jobs, choose marine life, choose oil transfer ships tied to the shore, choose NO to STS in the Cromarty Firth!27292017-01-27T21:27:20.75713781Mary doonanProtect precious wildlife27292017-01-27T23:01:55.86713782Nigel ShapcottIt is about time the Scottish Government stood up for the people who would be adversely affected by this ill thought out proposal if implemented. It is frustrating to see the "big boys" with all their resources try to trample on the Cromarty Firth and Inner Moray Firth communities. 27292017-01-28T08:24:30.7913783Laura MansonWhy should our beautiful local area be threatened by this ship To ship transfers when the trust port board could provide a safe environment on shore.\r\n27292017-01-28T08:28:56.64313784Karin NicholIf you don't care for nature (which you should) think of all the people depending on tourism. Keep on destroying the beauty tourists come to see, it will stop them coming. Simple maths.27292017-01-28T10:30:34.29313785Frank MacKenzieI spent many years in the Moray area before I became an expat & settled in Thailand. If they want to do this type of operation, may I suggest somewhare down south like near the Isle of Man. The moray economy is very stable I beleive27292017-01-28T11:22:49.3313786Lorraine CranPlease do not destroy the habitat of dolphins fish and birds. It would be a crime27292017-01-28T11:59:22.38313787Neil MeldrumThe potential for a leak in this Beautiful seascape \r\nIs too much Please get it stopped before an environmental disaster 27292017-01-28T12:50:29.79713788Ian WilliamsIt is with a great sense of disbelief that there people who are determined to destroy a natural balance, shame shame on them.27292017-01-28T15:31:50.25713789Alison MacdonaldCompletely inappropriate application that if it goes ahead has the potential to inflict devastating damage to the Moray Firth ecosystem which in turn impacts negatively on local businesses and individuals reliant on tourism. The economic benefit to the community from tourism far outweighs the economic benefit to the community of ship to ship oil transfers. Even without an oil spill. damage to the local ecosystem will occur according to expert testimony, and combined with visual, light, noise and air pollution when ship to ship transfers take place is bound to impact negatively on tourism in the long term. Trust ports were set up to serve regional and local interests and therefore Trust Port boards need to be transparent and accountable to regional and local stakeholders and operate to the benefit of the region as a whole. 27292017-01-28T16:33:07.6713790Karen mackI am opposed to anything which endangers our environment and can damage our economy\r\n27292017-01-29T08:30:32.113792FionaOur dolphins are more important than the financial savings!27292017-01-29T09:38:45.42313793John Glen Lloyd StewartIn these routine functions there is inevitably risk. cannot believe this is even contemplated due to risk to wildlife, holiday activity, non industrial shipping, coastal fishing, migration of salmon and risk to beach rating plus enclosed nature of firth waters as opposed to open sea dispersal of any contamination. 27292017-01-29T10:07:43.2313794Diana PullinThere should be Environmental Legislation to prevent ship to ship oil transfers in environmentally sensitive locations, especially those with established Wild andMarine life. Ship to ship oil transfers always pose risks to Wildlife and local economies, neither acceptable to Cromarty and surrounding areas. We need to be moving away from dependency on fossil fuels, fast.27292017-01-29T10:49:47.21313795Grant StewartThis plan is from the Donald Trump business school!\r\n \r\n27292017-01-29T11:32:35.34313796Margaux DoddsThe area planned to allow these transfers is of significant environmental importance and the area surrounding the Port Authority designated area is protected by law. Even if no oil spills ever occur, during normal operations, noise, potential threats to the marine environment from ballast waters being dumped, the increase in boat traffic and size and the emission of hazardous gasses during transfers, all have potential to impact on the wildlife, marine environment, local residents and businesses. Ship to ship transfers have been taking place in Nigg for decades, there is no reason why this could not continue and there is no reason to expose the area to the dangers of ship to ship oil transfers at sea. The devastating impact on the environment and local economy is not worth the risk, with no-one standing to benefit from this arrangement but the Port Authority - adding nothing to the local economy and could potentially cost jobs. There is literally no worse area that could have been picked for transfers at sea to take place and I believe they should be shelved, and the Port should use the existing facility at Nigg.27292017-01-29T14:17:48.7913797Graham. VineThere is a perfectly satisfactory jetty based ship to ship facility inside the Cromarty Firth, where waste water discharges from tankers can be treated before release into the sea. There are NO waste water treatment facilities available for ships anchored in the Moray Firth, and all waste water and discharged ballast water, complete with it's foreign parasitic organisms , can only go direct into the waters of the Moray Firth. \r\n\r\nThe Moray Firth is not merely the home to it's own subspecies of bottle nose Dolphins, but is also the "Highway" for migrating wild salmon returning to the Ness, Nairn, Findhorn Lossie and Spey salmon rivers. Once contaminated by foreign parasites, these will be there for ever as they are not capable of being removed. This could devestate, or destroy the wild salmon native to these rivers. 27292017-01-29T14:33:41.40713798Corrina Godsman This is too great a risk to take. The damage could never be undone. 27292017-01-29T14:44:13.01713799MarkstevensJust NO27292017-01-29T19:02:01.89313800Paul AardenBetter safe than sorry! Don't let it happen, please!27292017-01-29T21:56:43.79313801Lorraine EwingI go here every year for my holidays and cannot believe they are going to do this. Please stop it x\r\n27292017-01-29T22:40:39.23713802Frances TilbrookMSPs should be aware that the Port Authority keep stating that they have safely been undertaking ship-to-ship transfers for years. This is disingenuous (to put it politely). The transfers have been within the calm waters of the Cromarty Firth, with both ships made secure up against a jetty with all facilities including ballast water treatment. Why can't they continue using this facility, rather than their incredibly risky and potentially disastrous proposal?27292017-01-30T10:09:14.48313803Lindy CameronAn extraordinarily inappropriate proposal. There is far too much irreparably at risk if it goes ahead. \r\n 27292017-01-30T10:12:43.7813804HelenProtect our wildlife!27292017-01-30T12:00:06.84313805Judy RevellPlease help to prevent ship to ship transfers from happening here. 27292017-01-30T12:14:16.81313806Loreine ThomsonThe Nature Conversation Scotland Regulations 2004 give full protection to Dolphins, as does the Habitats Directive. The Scottish Government must grant an EPS Licence if ship to ship oil transfers commence in an area of high conservation such as the Moray Firth. The Scottish Government should, without any equivocation, refuse to grant such a licence as they will be in breach of Scottish and European legislation.\r\n\r\nCromarty Firth Port Authority is gamekeeper turned poacher and the Scottish Government should apply good governance and not allow CFPA to be the approval authority, who allows ship to ship oil transfers within its own harbour jurisdiction, applicant, and principal financial beneficiary. An independent arbiter should be nominated by the Scottish Government to assess whether the financial reasons being put forward by the CFPA are valid, whether an alternative location such as Nigg Jetty is more suitable, and whether there are any IROPI which could be applied. CFPA cannot evidence lack of bias, conflict of interest, financial incentive, or IROPI,\r\n\r\nhe Maritime Coastguard Agency are not permitted to reject CFPA's Oil Spill Contingency Plan and can only keep returning it until it meets their regulations and requirements, which must include compliance with the Marine Scotland Act 2010 and Marine Consequential Provisions Order 2010, Scotland National Marine Plan, and the other regulations I have already mentioned above.\r\n\r\nRegardless of whether MCA grant a ship to ship oil transfer licence, this does not discharge either of them from their duties under Scottish and European legislation.\r\n\r\nThe devastation to the marine and coastal environments are beyond price. The damage to the coastal communities in terms of Tourism, beaches, employment, scenic and visual beauty and landscape will mean the death knell in terms of economy to everyone who lives along the Moray Firth and in the Highlands in general. Our environment is priceless.\r\n\r\n27292017-01-30T12:17:51.95313807David ThomsonTo spoil the scenic beauty of the area with parked tankers, noise, oil wash and spillage, ballast and bilge waste would have a devastating effect on the tourism necessary to maintain the local economies of the area.27292017-01-30T13:00:19.97313808ellieI don't agree with the petition because ................ 27292017-01-30T13:05:06.11713809Jimmy Anderson I think that this is a very pleasant idea as this helps protect my cat from eating the litter that is left on the ground 27052017-01-30T17:50:52.25713810Jessica WolffThe implications of an accident are too harmful to the environment and the community.27292017-01-30T18:50:50.24713811Francis D.McWiLLiams.Correct me if I am wrong but the UK and Scottish Governments and All Council's have signed up for the Bioversity Plan?.27292017-01-30T19:56:39.6513812Chris WhittinghamWhy do we let greedy people destroy the things we love. What right does this company have to do so. I say NONE, well not in any fair society. So let us play fair and reject this dangerous proposal. Let us speak out for the environment, the sea and it's creatures and for the future visitors to this naturally beautiful coastline, it's about time we did before it becomes to late. For me saying NO is the moral and decent choice. NO SHIP to SHIP TRANSFERS.27292017-01-30T22:53:23.2213813Jane cameronScottish parliament - dolphins don't have access to email - help them....27292017-01-31T00:01:41.2613814Sandra RossPlease keep our dolphin and other sealife safe27292017-01-31T06:45:21.2713815henry Mckenzie JoihnstonI sign as the widower of a direct descendant of Cromarty's famous Hugh Miller who has contributed charitable donations to Cromarty and her people and believes this to be a very important issue.27292017-01-31T09:30:05.62713816Denise ChappellWe implore the government not to go ahead with this proposal. Our wildlife needs continued nurturing not dismantling, particularly in this environmentally rich area.27292017-01-31T09:34:32.95713817Colin DunnThis is a completely inappropriate proposal for this location. Quite aside from the ecological issues that the application has failed to consider properly, the proposal threatens to seriously damage over £200million of local business which relies on the the area being clean and safe, and being perceived as such.27292017-01-31T09:46:29.63713818Laura Whateley Such a beautiful part of the country where the economy benefits from the dolphins. Why risk this with ship to ship transfers. It's a ridiculous proposition. 27292017-01-31T15:36:37.9113819ClarePlease don't do this, an environmental catastrophe would be too awful to contemplate.27292017-01-31T15:44:04.25313820John DickinsonIt's so depressing that we have to have petitions like this. Clearly those in power are not protecting the environment, but are keen to promote big business at all costs.27292017-02-01T07:19:37.31313821Mairi Duncan Why ruin this beautiful part of the world with the threat of a catastrophic oil spill! Completely unnecessary! Think about the environment for a change Scottish Government! 27292017-02-01T09:55:19.41713822Paula CraibOur precious wildlife must be protected. 27292017-02-01T15:53:12.8813823Kate McArdleI am very worried about this proposal as the negative impact is far reaching and financial gain seems small. Constant noise (much louder than we have already from tankers and rigs) light pollution (no night sky left at all) odours - maybe, visually not pleasing for natives or visitors, then the potential negative impact on wildlife is huge and who will pay for spillage.....27292017-02-01T16:14:37.55713824Donald VassAs well as the potential damage to local wildlife and the natural environment, there is also the negative impact on tourism in this beautiful area of Scotland to take into account.27292017-02-01T18:00:02.8213825Denise Waddell Who in their right mind would even consider this proposal in such a beautiful stretch of water 27292017-02-01T19:18:03.3513826Lesley briantBallast water, noise and pollution - let alone oil spills, will destroy the Moray Firth marine environment for ever27292017-02-01T20:10:45.86713827Mary KingWhat cost to the Moray and Cromarty Firths if the Scottish government allows ship to ship oil transfers. It only takes one spill to devastate one of the most beautiful regions of Scotland, ruining the environment for wildlife, in particular the bottlenose dolphins, and the tourist economy.27292017-02-01T22:30:44.40313828Reg Stuart Unbelievable how this government & politicians are hell bent on destroying the Scottish landscapes & views with industry & especially here with the resident dolphins & other such wild life. 27292017-02-02T08:26:45.46313829Shona The devastating impact oil spills have on the environment is not worth the risk.. simply put, avoid the possibilities of it happening. Prevention is cheaper, safer and happier! Please make the right decision. 27292017-02-02T08:37:20.1313830Eileen FraserLet's not take unnecessary risks for our wildlife. Keep them safe.27292017-02-02T16:07:27.82713831Simon ArnoldTotal lunacy to proceed with these plans in such an important ecosystem for vulnerable wildlife and local tourism.27292017-02-02T18:22:07.4213832Sharon EscrittIt is our duty to protect wildlife27292017-02-02T20:21:20.17713833EllenWe need to conserve and protect our wild dolphins and other wild animals from harm of any description27292017-02-02T21:20:39.79713834Morag ForsythDoesn't need a major oil spill to impact Nairn and the Moray, with the present tanker moored opposite Nairn at present, we're subject to noise and fumes. And the current light pollution from the rig and ships. Also this whole Firth region on both sides depends on tourism, especially wild-life tourism. 27292017-02-02T21:55:52.213835Cathy TrainOil spill in other parts of the world have had catastrophic effects on both the environment and wildlife- Please don't let it happen in Scotland. Any risk even minimal is not worth it.27292017-02-02T23:45:19.4513836Pauline BoyleIt would be a travesty to let these waters become polluted.27292017-02-03T09:04:46.84313837Mary doonanMust protect all these wonderful creatures from man's greed27292017-02-03T10:28:05.30313838Michael TurrianiPlease come clean on our water!27292017-02-03T11:00:08.71713839Elizabeth WattPlease protect our precious wild life27292017-02-03T13:15:38.9713840Michael EllisonThe wildlife resource of the Moray Firth is a world asset that will provide pleasure for generations to come. It should not be destroyed by get rich quick shipping companies transferring oil in the Firth. 27292017-02-03T14:07:26.89713841Sharon SonhurstWe must protect our seas from pollution & for the marine life to survive, this has a major environmental impact on the whole world we must save our planet from being poisoned. Prevention us the best cure. We have the technology to find a suitable solution to prevent pollution.27292017-02-03T15:17:07.96713842Evelyne AdamsonThis atrocity should never be allowed and I hope the government will stop this happening, is an event that's waiting to happen and our beautiful dolphins and other sea mammals have to protected by law27292017-02-03T15:45:38.36713843AlasdairA bad idea. Wholly unnecessary.27292017-02-03T18:46:18.10313844D QWe must protect the environment and the amazing wildlife that lives in it, so it is safe for many generations to come - not support short-lived human business interests. You wouldn't do a number two in your own bath but yet these companies think it is okay to risk polluting the habitat of many marine creatures, that benefit our lives hugely by their existence. The seas are precious! Wake up!27292017-02-03T20:55:47.8413845Kathleen Dobson They deserve a life!!27292017-02-03T20:58:35.46713846Peter dobsonThese animals deserve a life!! 27292017-02-04T09:50:41.77313847Mary Clouston Our area in the Moray Firth should be a protected for all sea life , Dolphins are so important to mankind and to the well being of any part of the world.Don't destroy nature as that will destroy all humanity- it's not " money or your life ?" It's about looking after and caring For Our World !! 27292017-02-04T11:04:02.00313848Sheila struthI live in a coastal town and feel strongly about this issue even though it's in Scotland which is still a part of the uk27292017-02-04T16:15:36.58313850Angela FindlayI am astounded that this may go ahead, ALL the animals including the Whales and Dolphinswill be affected, this could mean the end of all life in this area when an oil spill takes place and it's not an "if" it is a "when" as an accident is inevitable27292017-02-04T23:47:38.5513851Thomas Leslie MarshallIf ship to ship oil transfers are inappropriate in the industrial seaway of the Forth how much more inappropriate are they in such an environmentally important, vulnerable and beautiful seascape as the Moray Firth with its vital importance to the tourist industry which is the economic backbone to this part of the Highlands and a vital heart of the local ecosystem. 27292017-02-05T00:12:45.6613852JulieLeave nature at peace ! Do NOT put it at risk !!27292017-02-05T06:20:31.4313853Anna S. KingPlease introduce legislation to prevent oil spillage. Please introduce further sustainable power sources than hydro-carbon based ones, e.g. P.V. Panels on all new-build as standard. There must be sensible balance between humanity and Nature, for the benefit of all, not just profit for a few.27292017-02-05T11:29:03.7113855Ellen MaxwellAs an accommodation provider with 2 cottages I am devastated that our wonderful beaches and wildlife will be put at risk. Tourism is vital to our economy and it will be devastating to put it in such jeopardy27292017-02-05T20:43:30.79713856Liz GouldWhat a stupid, dangerous idea !! The wildlife in this area is second to now & to take a risk like this is foolhardy at best 27292017-02-07T17:41:24.84713857david buxtonlet's keep what we have27292017-02-07T23:04:13.13313858Anne BrownThis must not happen the potential for disaster is obvious27292017-02-08T07:22:05.30713859Sandra KennedyTo spoil one of the most beautiful parts of Scotland would not be how anyone would want to be remembered!27292017-02-08T12:15:57.47713860JAMES MURRAYThe Scottish government have NO INTENTION of scrapping the Highland board. This a mischief making exercise by an ex labour M.P. who once voted for higher fuel prices for the highlands when he was in Westminster.27312017-02-08T13:17:26.65313861Elaine WaltonLosing HIE and it's knowledge and understanding of the rural nature of the Highlands- especially the "tyranny of geography" would leave my area exposed to the Central belt agenda which while\r\nImportant for that area can be largely irrelevant to rural areas. I have seen this dichotomy when working with Scottish Enterprise. \r\nI worry about the potential negative impact on the University of the Highlands and Islands. At this time when the European funding that has enhanced life in the Highlands and reduced depopulation is at great risk, losing the people with knowledge and particularly the focus on the needs of the Highlands\r\nIs to use the vernacular- completely mental. \r\n27312017-02-08T13:24:17.5813862Norman MacAskillWell done, Maureen.27312017-02-08T13:28:40.4413863Cameron Macdonald The needs and culture of the Highlands are not the same as south and Central belt .we need local knowledge and skills not Central Goverment or should I say Central belt Goverment short changing the Highlands and Islands 27312017-02-08T14:57:28.73313864jane stuart smithHIE has played a vital role in the regeneration of our remote community.27312017-02-08T15:50:14.78313865Angus Macleod Stop the centralisation, move more jobs to where they are most needed, the West Highlands and Islands.\r\nThis is like the Highland Clearances 21st century style27312017-02-08T16:36:19.47713866Damon thompsonEven more need to go for independence!27312017-02-08T17:29:45.5313867Archibald DrummondLeave well alone.27312017-02-08T18:38:54.02313868IRENE GILLESPIEThe northernHighlands and Islands have distinct needs and priorities requiring seperate attention.27312017-02-08T19:13:33.613869pamelaa munroI don't agree with this proposal27292017-02-08T20:00:29.22313870Davy OrrThese dictators are just going to do what they want.27312017-02-08T20:24:56.9913871Elaine RossPlease do not move everything down to the central belt27312017-02-08T21:05:15.37313872Donald ReidKeep Hie LOCAL27312017-02-08T21:35:39.9813873donald andersonThis a punitive and vindictive and unnecessary tax that must be stopped.27402017-02-08T23:27:55.99313874Thomas HarperShip to ship oil transfer was not allowed in the Firth of Forth. Why would it be ok for the Moray Firth? The risk to wildlife and the environment is too great to allow this to go ahead.27292017-02-08T23:39:48.82313875Ross GilliganAs a former Highland resident, I find the decision of the Scottish Government hugely short-sighted, ignoring the district role of HIE and HIDB previously and symptomatic of a worrying trend towards centralisation by the current SNP administration.27312017-02-09T07:01:28.17313876Pat KennedyI didn't vote for devolution from Westminster so that everything could instead be controlled from Holyrood!27312017-02-09T09:29:26.25313877Alasdair JoyceWe have a Scottish Parliament that claims to be looking after Scottish interests, and all they are interested in is business and banging on about independence. Come on, do your job for once and protect the Scotland you claim to care so much about. 27292017-02-09T09:36:00.20713878Alasdair JoyceWhat an irony! A Scottish parliament, elected on the bandwaggon of de-centralising power from Westminster, now wants to centralise power in Edinburgh instead! No surprise really, but what about local people deciding on local issues? 27312017-02-09T12:38:51.37313880Susan HopkinsonGiven the centralising agenda of the SNP government it is essential that HIE retains its regional independence to use its local knowledge and focus to further the interests of the Highlands.27312017-02-09T15:08:14.34713881John PhillipsAs a lifelong mariner I consider the proposal to undertake ship to ship transfers of crude oil in the inner Moray Firth to be totally irresponsible, posing a severe risk to local wildlife, fisheries and other activities which support the local economy.27292017-02-09T18:03:32.52713882Jackie NewtonPlease keep decisions local 27312017-02-09T19:27:13.85313883KENNETH GROOMEach area has different requirements and different needs, Centralisation does not understand these and is uneconomical 27312017-02-09T19:34:24.9313884Neil MacleodKeep the Highlands and Islands separate from the Central Belt.27312017-02-09T22:52:15.89713885Diane LunanI feel strongly that we need to protect our wildlife and environment and that our government should be at the forefront on our behalf. Am feeling disappointed as well that we have to resort to petitions. It appears to a have taken a year to have rooted out any public response from our government, but I hope that recent comments in the media mean that they are keeping their eye on this threat to the Moray Firth and will take the lead in protecting our environment.27292017-02-10T07:41:07.62313886Simon NobleI live in Nairn. Until Cromarty rising brought this to the attention of my community council I knew nothing of these STS transfers. It is dreadful that the port authority claimed to have consulted widely and not encountered objections when I and the rest of my community are directly affected by the proposals and the risks.27292017-02-10T09:09:28.4913887Bruce FarquharI would urge everyone to sign this petition we need action now27292017-02-10T10:18:14.65713888Gordon RossWe have had changes already that realy haven't worked, like Police Scotland, emergency call centres,\r\nHowever centralisinglass Funding for enterprises \r\nWill only result in even more money for the central belt, so it's completely outrageous to allow this to go forward in any shape or format. 27312017-02-10T13:10:46.6813889Alasdair Morrison Surely the SNP will heed this cross-party effort to halt further ruinous centralisation. 27312017-02-10T14:27:01.2413890Debra DorransDogs are domesticated animals who have the right to a warm and safe place to sleep, good food and clean drinking water. They also, very importantly require the companionship of a human as they are very social animals and to treat them in this manner is just inhumane and uncivilised. I would call upon the Scottish government to outlaw this barbaric practice right away. Please do the right thing. 27542017-02-10T15:16:49.8113891Wendy AddisonPuppies for profit is a disgusting and immoral concept. Breeding bitches who live in small spaces to produce puppies which are taken away and then the poor things are impregnated again.The shelters are full of unwanted dogs, mistreated dogs, starving dogs, injured dogs, abandoned dogs, etc.etc. Go to a shelter or a pound if you want a dog, or buy from a reputable breeder.27542017-02-10T15:48:00.51713892Iain Fairweathership-to-ship oil transfers pose unacceptable risks to wildlife and local tourism economy27292017-02-10T15:59:20.6913893Cllr Dr Stephen ClacksonWe must stem this relentless drive towards a centralised Scotland. Government Scotland seems determined to centralise the country to such a degree that Scotland will end up resembling a large county, with one police force, one fire and rescue service, one education authority ... Scotland will have been reduced to Scotshire. 27312017-02-10T16:43:20.913894Simon GilesOn the subject of big business, just think Scottish Government for one moment what this could mean not just to the environment but to the local area and its tourism....you cut off your nose to spite your face if you approve this.27292017-02-10T16:59:31.60713895Janet SmithI contacted DEFRA in London about three weeks ago regarding my fears about the number of dogs coming in from Eastern Europe and would have been just as well talking to one of my wee dogs. I said that the requirement for quarantine should never have been abolished. We had a natural barrier being an island. The six months could have been reduced to say, two. I do not trust pets passports as I know someone who informed me he bought one from a vet in France when he brought his dog through from Kuwait - a country which has rabies. also said that there should be more stringent checks done as pups are being brought in in the boots of cars. These unscrupulous people do not or are not interested in the danger they are putting all our family pets in. DEFRA did not appear to be interested in anything I had to say.\r\n27542017-02-10T18:08:43.91313896Y RossWe need controls. Place to protect dogs and puppies and indeed ourselves, puppy farmers produce sickly puppies and if anything comes fro abroad to them and is not vaccinated it could be lethal27542017-02-10T18:13:16.1613897Will CoullNot only is the potential for disaster enormous but the process of this oil transfer will impact the environment and the local wildlife as well as the local population with the invasive 24hr noise alone not to mention low grade pollution from tank discharges. 27292017-02-10T19:24:18.64713898Agnes LawsonShow the rest of the UK&I the way in stopping puppy farming and removing the abusers of their financial I'll gotten gains to pay for the rescue of these animals.27542017-02-10T21:03:11.59313899P SquireI support this petition because I think we need to do more to protect animals.27542017-02-11T03:26:27.08313900Jeanette bradburyThis must be stopped right now do something for God sake 27542017-02-11T09:45:51.413901Nikki HarveyPlease stop theses cruel greedy people27542017-02-11T11:39:46.3313902Carol GrahamBan and lock up these illegal puppy farmers 27542017-02-11T11:42:53.313903Arthur JonesIt is an iniquitous tax, unfairly discriminating against people with fewer means, and it takes little or no account of a house-holders needs, possessions, interests, family visits accommodation, or anything. That politicians, many of whom have more than one house, should promote this sort of thing is a total disgrace and outrage. Shame on them!27402017-02-11T13:20:12.11713904Jacqueline KingLet's think about the future, shall we? So many plans, such as this one, are short term with awful long term effects.27292017-02-11T13:25:40.4713905GERRY MULROYBan the import of dogs under the age of six months to the UK . Compulsory microchip with the breeders unique number checkable on a national register . Make it an offence to publish an ad ANYWHERE without the the breeders unique number .27542017-02-11T14:34:00.64313906Gordon RossThe snp think that running everything from the central belt is better for the Highlands big mistake,\r\nThe police are now one big mistake,\r\nThe emergency call centres are another big mistake,\r\nSo now thay think running are businesses from down the road is going to benefit us ? Another big mistake,27312017-02-11T15:17:34.5413907Dawn McKeithSupport this petition fully27542017-02-11T17:52:06.6313908Thomas James BradshawWrong place for STS transfers more appropriate sites already avaliable 27292017-02-11T20:18:17.14313909Peter Fletcher Hie has enabled me to locate my music studio business in the Isle of Lewis. Without their support and local expertise I would not be here. The challenges faced on the islands are complex and localised and a focus on overcoming these challenges is critical to the future of the islands. Hie brings that focus and anything that diminishes that could be incredibly detrimental to the islands. 27312017-02-12T20:22:01.2213911Caroline MorrisKnowing the area and the weather conditions that can prevail the possibility of an oil spill must be greater that 50%. \r\nWe are losing too much of our pristine and natural heritage to risk anymore being lost just for profit.27292017-02-12T20:28:52.95313912David MorrisI have visited this area several times and was impressed by its pristine condition. Any operation that could case irreparable harm in the area should not proceed especially given the weather in the area is not conducive to a safe transfer of oil from ship to ship. We are humans and we make mistakes and in this case the resulting damage could be catastrophic27292017-02-12T21:10:13.42313913David ChiffersIt is absolutely imperative that the Highlands retains an independent voice and is not sucked into the determination to control every aspect of the nation from the central belt.27312017-02-12T22:33:33.7313914Morag Forbes The Moray Firth should not be spoiled like this.27292017-02-13T17:05:45.3213916Jacqueline CrillIs the Scottish Government all words? This is really terrible. How can anyone even think of allowing something that might have such long term effects on marine life - and the fishing industry therefore.27292017-02-13T19:39:02.97313919Bill MartinScottish Government lets keep Scotland beautiful and listen to the people who love this land of ours. \r\nNO SHIP TO SHORE OIL TRANSFERS\r\n27292017-02-13T19:58:42.64713920Liz BroumleyThis will not bring any economic benefit to the local community and risks both economic and environmental catastrophe.27292017-02-14T10:53:37.1313921StephenAn excellent cause and one that Government must address to stop us being buried under a mountain of waste!27052017-02-14T11:55:34.28313922Alan TissimanThis is a very sensitive area indeed. Great care must be taken and risks avoided.27292017-02-14T19:44:28.09713923Howard DavenportA full environmental impact assessment should be undertaken prior to a decision on whether to go ahead with these operations, as with most other onshore or offshore developments. 27292017-02-14T20:20:27.413924Richard NewmarkI don't trust the operators of these oil transfers to behave responsibly. Offshore spills can and will easily be hidden from authorities.27292017-02-14T20:28:50.11713925Gillian MacYes I see them littering all over I think a small charge for a cup may help but unlike bags this is not the same thing, as a bag you can bring to put things in from home, a cup to get coffee etc is different. I think a small amount given on their return to the shop may help say 2p if you give back your cup, again though most people who dispose of these cups are walking around the streets drinking the contents, so would be unlikely to go back to where they bought it or a chain orcafe shop where they bought it. Perhaps give discounts on drinks to people who bring their own cup is one small thing, but not always practical. Maybe drop of a large bag of disposable cups and get money in return like aluminium.27052017-02-14T20:32:49.38713926Clive MooreFuel Transfers at sea always cause spillage. In the Inner Moray Firth this would be irresponsible, dangerous and the worse of all options available.27292017-02-14T21:46:08.68313927Gordon RossAn accident waiting to happen, if this crazy request is granted. Driven by pure greed.27292017-02-14T23:08:47.0413928John N HartS2S transfers in this environment is not the best idea for protecting the environment.27292017-02-15T07:29:04.20313929Jennifer NalderIf these transfers were to go ahead the north of Scotland would be ruined beyond belief.Denying that a leakage would never happen is not the truth it is only a matter of time.Pay attention parliament and support US !!!!!!!27292017-02-15T07:34:14.17313930Frank WinstonHere we go again! yet another centralisation project for this government where it is absolute in it's demand for control of everything in Scotland 27312017-02-15T09:57:16.98713931Ian NalderTo place the dolphins and our amazing coastline at risk is quite simply utterly unwarranted. Oil transfers between ships can only be achieved under strictly controlled conditions and these can only be achieved under supervision such as applies in port.27292017-02-15T14:37:35.29713932Marie (Mary) CruickshankNairn's main industry is tourism of which I am part. If this ship to ship transfer goes ahead and there are oil spills - that is going to kill our tourism and the ecology of the area. Not only that but do tourists, who enjoy the seaviews and walks along our beaches, really want to view a lot of huge tankers? I wouldn't! That smacks of the oil vessels off the coast of Singapore and Sentosa Island! The sea smells of oil, it isn't pleasant to bathe in and the views - horrendous - why do we have to put up with this as tourism is our main economy in the Nairn area? I am a tour operator (and do B&B) and send lots of tourists to stay in Nairn from all over the world - I persuade them to come to Nairn where we have wonderful sandy beaches and clean air - is that going to last? I certainly hope so or if not, then I will have to send clients to other parts of Scotland where there are sandy beaches and no oil pollution nor queues of tankers waiting for their ship to ship transfers!!27292017-02-15T15:41:30.06313933Christine BriggsSurely one of the most important things Scotland has to offer is the relatively clean environment. Even with extreme caution accidents happen. Please prevent this by not allowing S2S transfers.27292017-02-15T17:20:57.5313934Blair CruickshankWe do not want another tragic oil spill like the Alaskan tragedy some years ago which adversely affected the wild life.27292017-02-15T17:46:40.59713935Joanna NowickiSafeguarding our environment should always be a first priority.27292017-02-15T17:53:02.84713936Marie (Mary) CruickshankWe do not want this "facilty" or eyesore out in the Moray Firth to view from Nairn. Oil spillages like in Alaska and a killer for local tourism and our local economy. We need tourism in the area and this will ruin it - especially if there are oil spills and smells polluting our shores. No thank you!!27292017-02-15T17:55:17.7313937Sue-Ellen WelfonderKnow and love Nairn, have (and do) visit regularly. Please do not let this happen. Thank you. 27292017-02-15T19:19:52.75713938LizziStop puppy farms please27542017-02-15T20:44:19.78313939Mike Cruickshank I can't believe they are even contemplating this ridiculous idea. It's a disgrace 27292017-02-15T20:55:28.99713940Susan goodwinI am being charged bedroom tax 27402017-02-15T20:57:02.04713941Susan Goodwin This is punishing the vulnerable people 27402017-02-15T21:16:09.83313942Linda Duncan Make internet sites responsible for paying substantial tax on adverts selling pups or ban them altogether 27542017-02-15T23:27:56.43713943Maria Madigan Puppies should be nurtured and given the best start in life not torn from their mothers at a young age, unsocialised and uncared for, and their mothers bred from relentlessly.27542017-02-16T06:04:07.9813944Aurora A MataCoastlines all over the world need our protection! The good of the seas is essential for our survival.27292017-02-16T06:57:50.07713945Pam HartjeHaven't the oil companies screwed up our oceans and beaches enough?!?! Our world enough?!?! Don't they know that transferring oil from ship to ship is DANGEROUS?!?! They should be doing everything they can to insure that our oceans, beaches and lands are protected from the oil spills and leaks that always seems to happen no matter what they do. To me it seems it's a VERY BIG RISK to be transferring oil from ship to ship and should be STOPPED AT ALL COSTS!!! 27292017-02-16T07:06:52.65713946Pam HartjeHi again! I forgot to add that if the oil companies want to say accidents don't happen just ask the people who live and work along the Gulf of Mexico in the US about how they feel about little or no chance of an accident and oil spill!!!27292017-02-16T09:14:20.31313947Janette Wales Thos has been allowed to go on for far to long something should be done at government level. Bring out a law that stops this illegal and often cruel practice which is done only for greed. Chip every animal with breeders name as well as next owner that way it would be easier to trsce these people.27542017-02-16T09:19:00.50713948Kathleen Baptie Stop this vile practice now. Lock up the perpetrators. 27542017-02-16T12:22:00.35313949Gillian KirkpatrickPuppy farming needs to stop, it is extremely cruel, produces very sick puppies and adds to the amount of unwanted dogs abandoned. Ban imports under 6 months and have full tracability through microchip from the breeders.\r\n27542017-02-16T16:44:07.83313950Howard DavenportA full environmental impact assessment should be submitted to Marine Scotland, and open to public review and comment, prior to this type of proposal being given approval, as with other offshore developments.27292017-02-16T17:33:32.21313951Susan BurnsBreeding should be conducted in a responsible manner by those who have the animals best interests at heart, not the interest of their wallet or allowing litters through irresponsible ownership and failure to neuter. Animal ownership should be a privilege not a right and should have appropriate protections to prevent farming of canines. Further, backstreet breeding and crossing of breeds does nothing but introduce undesirable traits into one animal. Crossing dogs with little knowledge of breed traits is asking for trouble both in the animals mental health and physical issues. Pups should be homes with homechecks, vet and vaccination certificates and full breeder back up. If breeders were as responsible as most rescues we would not require nearly as many rescue spaces.27542017-02-16T18:22:53.06313952Jane CoxIt's about time animals were treated with respect. The Scottish government should lead the way and ensure protection for these dogs and puppies.27542017-02-16T19:23:06.35313953John DolanWith Nairn just 4.5 miles south of one of the proposed anchorages any oil spill could be catastrophic for Nairn's beaches and local economy - and for those east of us. This is a totally inappropriate location for crude oil ship to ship transfers.27292017-02-16T21:40:08.1813954Anne Arkless I hope something else can be done to stop these greedy cruel people. 27542017-02-17T10:13:27.08313955Joanna MayThe risks surely outweigh any possible benefits to the local area and its outstanding beauty...27292017-02-17T12:29:31.39313956MoThis area is supposed to be a tourist area, that is what the Moray Council keep telling us and the Moray coastline is definitly going to be affected. So stop sending mixed messages.27292017-02-17T16:04:26.5813957Maggie MarshallThese dogs are not even afforded the same welfare standards as farm animals. Greedy profiteers are ONLY in it for the money and do not concern themselves with health and welfare.27542017-02-17T18:12:46.70313958Nadia Soto de Gray I hope the cruelty stop27542017-02-17T19:28:43.57313959Katie This horrible abuse must stop.27542017-02-17T20:59:30.61313960Liz ShawThis is not a new problem, it needs to be addressed, come down hard on the ones caught. Its cruelty of the most vulnerable - it needs to stop.\r\n27542017-02-18T00:51:45.11313961Ian MoorhouseAll for this group and it's cause! If it help stop these so called puppy farm and breeders that don't no enough to breed these dogs! 27542017-02-18T07:44:07.56713963Maria McGuinness Hope this has hodd results as something is finally done for theses innocents.\r\n27542017-02-18T08:06:45.42313964Helen PhillipsWhen will the local councils realise dogs are companion animals and should never be 'farmed' but should be kept with human company as pets. Breeding without regard to living conditions or health including mental needs is utterly inhumane. 27542017-02-18T10:41:51.4813965Joan McEwenAnother nail in the coffin for locality, community, empowerment and self-determinism from this government.27312017-02-19T01:37:53.71313966gwen jarmantoo many puppy farms, poor dogs being over bred all for greedy breeders that dont give a toss about the dogs welfare27542017-02-19T08:59:51.63313967Sue WATSONThe current situation for dogs and puppies in the UK has become deplorable. It is a free for all for anyone who wants to breed puppies simply to make money. There are no concerns for the puppies welfare, nor for the breeding dogs. There are no standards in place to make sure that only sound, healthy, well adjusted puppies are bred from sound, healthy, well adjusted dogs by people who are regulated and have only the best interests of the dogs and puppies at heart. At the moment dogs and puppies in the UK are seen as an income by many unscrupulous people.27542017-02-19T20:14:11.04313968Lisa eland These are living frightened souls for God's sake, do the RIGHT thing27542017-02-20T11:16:02.32313969Lesley JonesThis is cruel and barbaric, animals are living breathing creatures that deserve love and respect, they are not money boxes.27542017-02-20T13:15:32.62313970Gaynor Mountfordwell what can you say to the scum which breed and breed these poor animals , when will someone say enough is enough , my heart is broken every time i see a broken dog which only wants to give love to us , \r\n27542017-02-20T13:24:58.66713971JacAbsolutely NOT acceptable in a civilised society. No thought for the welfare of the animals but all about making money. Needs to be stopped dead once and for all and if ignored then very harsh penalties put in place to deter others trying to make a quick buck out of misery. 27542017-02-20T13:35:09.7513972Susan hunterWe live in a world where dog rescue organisations & charities are busting at the seams with rescue's looking for homes. To breed dogs in disgusting conditions is wrong & these facilities need shut down as they are no more than jails for dogs who havery done nothing wrong.27542017-02-20T13:46:44.12713973Wayne Easton More action needs to be taken against persons that breed for profit alone and don't care about the welbring of the animals concerned. A slap on the wrist does not change behaviours. Nor do paltry fines. 27542017-02-20T15:26:39.313974Carol ParkesFor the sake of all these abused animals, please do the right thing now.27542017-02-20T16:13:39.8713975shona farquhari think this is awful, puppy farms really make me angree the state some puppies and their mums are having to live in, its all about money as usual not the well being of the animals. MONEY GRABBING. 27542017-02-20T18:56:41.6113976Averill RossIt's cruel to use the dogs as a means of cash. Many of them have a litter every year until they can hardly walk. Conditions that they are kept in are hurrendous too . 27542017-02-20T19:26:55.84313977Joanna BeckleyI really hope this greed stops- lives do not equal money. Shame on them 27542017-02-20T19:49:26.85313978Louise mcgregorThis needs to STOP !27542017-02-20T21:35:54.43713979S SkinnerAnimals are suffering for human greed and that is totally unacceptable. 27542017-02-21T00:09:05.12313980Tracy FeeneyWe need to stop this trade, the poor dogs where these puppies come from are literally bred to death...27542017-02-21T06:58:59.86713981Maria McGuinness Come ob Scottish Government. Somethjng must be done fgr these innocents.27542017-02-21T12:47:30.73713982Mark Robertson Time to get this problem sorted 27542017-02-21T20:58:16.15313983Debra DorransPlease do what you can to stop this vile practice 27542017-02-21T23:24:13.0813984Gillian SPuppy farming flies in the face of animal welfare. Inscrupulous breeders cause endless suffering to dogs and puppies, many of whom have short, horrifying, pain filled lives. Please do not allow puppy farms to operate in Scotland.27542017-02-21T23:31:42.56313985martinstart telling people you know and pass it on ,i found the petition by chance,27402017-02-22T00:15:14.88313986Elizabeth GibsonThese farms need to be stopped. These people are only in this business to make as much money as possible and to hell with the consequences. These poor animals cannot be allowed to suffer any more. Please do something about this a.s.a.p.,\r\n27542017-02-22T07:32:19.49313987Muriel JohnstoneThere are enough dogs in Scotland needing homes, you only need to visit rescue centres to see them along with the volume euthanised daily. Breeding for profit is cruel, unnecessary and down right irresponsible.27542017-02-22T09:45:31.21713988James Dryburgh I have worked all my life and have paid more than enough taxes.They should be chasing up the wealthy tax dodgers instead of the more vulnerable people.27402017-02-23T15:49:33.0613989Davy MaclellanRespect the outcome of previous referendum27732017-02-23T16:44:35.10713990Noreen HardingI agree with comments below. I further suggest that there should never be another referendum. We already have a country and we are not oppressed. 27732017-02-23T16:52:28.29313991Colin StrongI am coming from a different angle to the petitioner. I voted to remain. I believe Brexit will be a disaster, but see no point in compounding 2 disaster (Devolution and Brexit) with a third!27732017-02-23T16:56:54.7113992Donald MacKenzieIf we never have another referendum on ANYTHING it will still be too soon. The 2014 referendum was divisive and deeply unpleasant, with Yes groups mobbing Better Together stalls, videoing all who approached. Intimidation never reined in by leadership.27732017-02-23T16:59:09.98313993Colin StrongI voted the other way from the petitioner in both Referenda. I see no point in compounding 2 disasters (Devolution and Brexit) with a third (Separation)! 27732017-02-23T17:00:06.6713994Mrs Janet PickingThe SNP need to concentrate on the present problems of Education, NHS, Police and economy rather than tearing Scotland apart with another referendum on independence. We were promised the last referendum would last a life time, please keep to that promise.27732017-02-23T17:31:29.20713995Andrew ShearerI was YES in 2014, I will be NO in an early INDYRef227732017-02-23T17:55:01.4913996Christopher JackBest interests of Scotland would be for Scottish Government to wait until brexit fully happens before deciding on what options there are for our future. Don't think a third referendum will be well received by large swathes of the population. We are a sensible, canny people. Let's wait and see before making an informed decision.27732017-02-23T19:18:43.7213997Andrew HomesI voted for independence but democracy said otherwise. 27732017-02-23T19:52:53.54713998Ewan HectorWhether I voted no or yes during indyref is irrelevant. What is relevant is that all of us want to see a better Scotland. One that is fairer for all, one in which there is justice, one in which there is no-one living in poverty, one in which all children have the same opportunities for education, one in which people can be seen in a timely manner by medical services. Indyref cost the tax payer £15 million - money that should be spent on our ailing education, health, social and police services. If Sturgeon was serious about her desire to create a better Scotland, she should focus her attention and finances on these very real issues. She should follow the democratic process and accept the result of indyref. Thus far she has ignored the no voters in the SNP's promise to make the referendum a once in a generation decision. That is not justice, and a discredit to no voters.27732017-02-23T20:52:27.71713999Alison OrrI may not entirely agree with David Robertson's reasons for setting up this petition, but I do believe we will fail to gain independence if there is a referendum in 2018 and that the issue will be dead for another generation. Please wait until Brexit is complete, it can only aid the independence cause.27732017-02-23T21:20:06.17314000Yvonne Molinari Please stop the puppy farms27542017-02-23T21:30:54.51314001Richard TallachIf Nicola Sturgeon lost a second independence referendum would she wait a generation before demanding a third. Having referenda every few years on this question would rightly make Britain and the British government a laughing stock and is an utterly foolish way to run a country.27732017-02-23T21:33:39.06714002Ann KellyDogs are domesticated pets ...not baby making machines!!! All of these farms should be closed down asap...27542017-02-23T21:37:17.98314003TMStop puppy farming! Our dogs are our life's!27542017-02-23T21:47:17.11714004leigh morrisDogs and puppies are not stock animals , they need a home environment and individual attention , Large numbers can not get this attention . \r\nSocialisation is very important in the early life of a pup . When this is not done correctly, it effects the rest of the pups life . 27542017-02-23T22:06:11.78314005Jacci leitch Bannatyne Dogs are pets not production robots 27542017-02-24T00:06:32.45714006myra turnbullPlease do not allow this barbaric treatment of dogs27542017-02-24T00:50:07.0114007Margaret NeilThis cruelty needs to be stopped now.27542017-02-24T02:36:52.04714008Janetta FairbairnDogs are not animals which can be bred in bulk. Rearing puppies needs individual care, attention, careful feeding and very importantly,socialising. This cannot happen in a situation where you have more than a couple of litters being raised at any one time or less than one carer per litter. Female dogs need a good active social life between rearing litters and should never be expected to have more than three litters in a lifetime and never more than at least one year apart. Just scratching the surface of reasons for the banning of bulk breeding dog establishments. Please consider legislation to prevent these businesses from continuing to cause misery to so many vulnerable animals. 27542017-02-24T06:06:01.96714009ShirleyThere are enough dogs in the world many of whom need rescued. Dogs bred in puppy farms are not pure bred KC registered. They are badly treated and spend their lives having puppies in terrible conditions. Female dogs should have no more than 3 litters. STOP this cruelty and severly punish offenders. Dogs are family not factories27542017-02-24T08:15:54.75314010Mandy MortonWe need a legal definition of Puppy Farm27542017-02-24T09:40:38.6114011Bev PirieWe don't need or want puppy farms.27542017-02-24T11:44:12.32314012Donald Roderick ShellI agree with this petition. 27732017-02-24T11:53:32.98714013Eileen GardCruel in every way27542017-02-24T13:21:05.20314014Joyce MacDonaldThe cruelty and neglect involved in puppy farming is totally unacceptable and abhorrent. If you must get a puppy, go to a reputable breeder. Or even better -RESCUE!27542017-02-24T13:27:05.73314015Derek McPhailScots are canny, we wait for the right time. I voted a hearty Yes in 2014 - I won't be voting Yes again until we're on a stable footing. We've waited 300 years - what's another 3 or 4? Maybe by then we'll know if the EU is going to get out of its current crisis or not. So let's just wait and see, and concentrate on our own problems as we do so. That is why I support this petition.27732017-02-24T14:22:36.01714016Ian CampbellThis 2 nd referendum must be stopped or there will be violence on the streets.27732017-02-24T15:33:22.87714017Seonaid MacLennanThere are enough problems with NHS, Education, our Economy etc., within Scotland. The Scottish Parliament now need to spend time with these problems at hand, without being distracted by another lengthy campaign. I voted with SNP for independence in 2014 but can't understand why they now want to be controlled by Europe.27732017-02-24T15:54:49.8814018Irene DavidsonPlease stop puppy farming a d reduce animal suffering 27542017-02-24T16:33:51.6214019Audrey EwingI thing we need to sort out Brexit first.27732017-02-24T18:31:43.16714020Brian GriffithsRegardless of whether one is for or against Scottish Independence, we need at least a couple of years breathing space after the triggering of Article 50 to establish exactly how Brexit is going to impact on us and also what shape the EU is going to be in following national elections in member countries. I think at this point it will become very clear where our destiny lies.27732017-02-24T19:15:16.7214021James kerrScotland 27732017-02-24T19:54:52.92714022A R GreganFurther referendum campaigning will be divisive, expensive and deter business investment into Scotland. The once in a generation referendum of 2014 is the settled will of The Scottish people under the terms of the Edinburgh Agreement.27732017-02-24T21:05:12.29714023Tracy boylesThis must never be allowed27542017-02-24T21:27:40.6914024Helen Yadh Stop this puppy farming now. ,,, Just pure abuse of animals. ££££££ before Animal welfare. Needs to stop now. 27542017-02-24T21:51:00.42714025JamesNo more division.27732017-02-24T23:20:23.28314026Timothy R PuntisI am wholly in favour of a further independence referendum.\r\nI reject completely the reasons given in the petition's Background Information for delaying or cancelling any planned referendum on independence for Scotland.\r\nThe Brexit vote and also the election of the Republican Trump government in the USA make independence for Scotland more urgently needed than we could have imagined at the time of the last referendum.\r\nI do not think that any promise or assurance understood as having been given about waiting a 'generation' could have validity in the vastly different world order that we now have.\r\nI have no doubt that the efforts of the Scottish Government to improving NHS Scotland, Scottish Education and the economic wellbeing of Scotland will be continued if we have another referendum or not, and this task will be better achieved in an independent Scotland.27732017-02-24T23:21:52.75314027Timothy R PuntisI am wholly in favour of a further independence referendum.\r\nI reject completely the reasons given in the petition's Background Information for delaying or cancelling any planned referendum on independence for Scotland.\r\nThe Brexit vote and also the election of the Republican Trump government in the USA make independence for Scotland more urgently needed than we could have imagined at the time of the last referendum.\r\nI do not think that any promise or assurance understood as having been given about waiting a 'generation' could have validity in the vastly different world order that we now have.\r\nI have no doubt that the efforts of the Scottish Government to improving NHS Scotland, Scottish Education and the economic wellbeing of Scotland will be continued if we have another referendum or not, and this task will be better achieved in an independent Scotland.27732017-02-25T08:03:29.17714028Dave Pierson The five freedoms don't mean anything to these puppy farmers by allowing them to set up surely it is condoning breaking the law 27542017-02-25T08:32:13.8914029Alison KalotkaAs a former SNP voter who read and Saw through Alex Salmonds nonsense in the "Scotland's Future" white paper I am disgusted with the party! They area showe of petulant children who, because they didn't get their own way, shout Indy at every opportunity!! The country is in ruins, the parallels are there to 1930s Germany, as well as 1970's Northern Ireland! We no longer divide on religion (a good thing!) but we are divided on Union and Indy! Ms Sturgeon has made a mockery of MY country and does not speak for me! She speaks for a minority of Scots. The sooner the SNP or Sturgeon is ousted the better!27732017-02-25T13:36:16.51314030Michael Moir We were promised that this would be a once in a generation referendum and we simply ask that that promise is kept.\r\n\r\nI can imagine the furore from the Separatist Regime, if the result had went the other way in 2014 & those No voters then had immediately began campaigning for 'another' referendum! 27732017-02-25T13:51:45.2814031Kate RosindaleWould be happy to never have another independence referendum and for SNP to lose power and dwindle away.27732017-02-25T13:59:15.51314032Jennifer Hastie Scotland already voted to remain in the UK, we said No to the Snp's independence. Since the end of 2014, the Snp's threat of a second independence referendum has been damaging Scotland's economy, businesses, investment and prospects. There is no majority support from Scots for another independence referendum. Talk of a second independence referendum must be removed until the serious economic decline Scotland is in shows signs of abating. 27732017-02-25T14:55:41.4614033Heather Palmer Scotland doesn't need more diversions from the important issues. Scotland voted to reason part of the United Kingdom and the Scottish Government have to respect that fully. 27732017-02-25T14:58:25.0714034Fiona TaylorScotland had a Referendum, and the result was No to separation from the UK. We don't need another one. 27732017-02-25T16:57:41.84314035Donald Ogilvie AdamsNo more referendums.27732017-02-25T17:03:30.03314036Alex Holt I object to a second referendum 27732017-02-25T19:41:00.4614037Irene Forrest Thank you and God bless you for this !! \r\n27732017-02-25T19:57:03.1514039Chris HaxtonI believe there should never be another referendum for at least a generation.27732017-02-25T20:14:32.5914040Cale christie We don't want puppies made illegally27542017-02-25T21:11:27.814041Robert McConachiFed up with the same old same old. Concentrate on the services you're abusing IE police, health, education etc etc.27732017-02-25T21:42:06.72714042LI would say leave it for a generation as promised. Too divisive and bitterness from 2014 still remains. 27732017-02-26T11:13:56.79314044Iain GallThe uncertainty the 2014 referendum had cost Scotland dearly, a second one puts off any foreign investors for a good time to come. Scotland is subsideised £1,200 each year and scotlands deficit is the fastest growing in Europe. How on earth can any realistic argument be put forward to separate? Scotland was bankrupt 400 years ago as a baron, uncivilised country wrapped in civil war. In that time Scotland has flourished due to the union and I say that as a proud Scot but a loyal Brit. 27732017-02-26T16:05:26.14714045GeorgeNo referendum27732017-02-27T10:38:09.08314046Sandra SmithThe country needs stability. Stop trying to divide the country and cause strife and confusion amongst us. United we stand divided we fall. We do not wish to be governed from Europe. We want a United Kingdom.27732017-02-27T10:55:49.5414047Lynne Denise BushAll dog breeding should be licensed and regulated to stop overbreeding and indiscriminate breeding27542017-02-27T10:58:43.77314048Irene RobinsonThere is so much cruelty now time to clamp down and harshly against these so called human beings27542017-02-27T11:33:51.76314049liz SanchezPuppy Farms have no place in civilised society!\r\nThey need to be shut down immediatley.27542017-02-27T11:40:52.714050liz sanchezPuppy farms have no place in civilised society. This cruelty needs to be stopped. There re enough dogs in need of homes without abusing others for mans finacial greed.27542017-02-27T13:28:12.40314051Vyrnwy Sleat Stop the pain and hurt these animals go through for illegal profits 27542017-02-27T13:30:14.12314052Kevin BakerWhat is the cost to the Taxpayers for dog wardens, Vet fees, Kenneling etc, no dogs should be bred while animal shelters are overflowing27542017-02-27T14:25:03.89314053Margaret ColbertPlease stop allowing puppy farms to operate there are too many unwanted dogs in all rescue centres27542017-02-27T14:36:38.1514054PrimroseThe world does not need puppy farms, have a look at the issues surrounding the existing ones and ask if this is something that should allowing.27542017-02-27T18:45:38.3214055Bill PerrieI voted for an independent scotland and still want independence but agree with the petition that now is not an appropriate time for another referendum.27732017-02-27T18:54:33.55314057Jacqueline Deaton I think we should ban all breeding , unless they are working dogs or rare breeds . To many dogs waiting in rescue centres . I believe they have done this in other countries . So much cruelty going on , I found it so upsetting . I have a ex breeding dog , and it has taken her two years to settling in my house but what is so upsetting she still coward down when I go to pick her up , bloody horrible , feel so sorry for her , all I do is treat her with love and understanding , love her so much 27542017-02-27T21:24:20.33314058Carol ParkesYou have seen how cruelly these poor dogs are treated and still you allow it to go on. WHY? We need you to justify this. What we don't need is more puppy farms27542017-02-27T21:50:12.28314059Lisa ShortThousands in rescue centres weep and die while others are being created in puppy farms, outrageous 27542017-02-27T23:37:32.9714060Linda CameronBearing in mind the number of dogs destroyed every year, why permit these deplorable cruel establishments to pump out more puppies, just to make the owners wealthy?27542017-02-28T00:49:54.77714061sandra bakerthis cruelty to animals must be stopped.would you want your dog to be treated this way?these people are getting away with terrible cruelty.it needs stopping now.imprisonment and heavy fines and a ban from keeping any animals for life.27542017-02-28T19:20:39.76314062Alex wat Why want the be ruled by Brussels when we can stay in the country our fathers fought for and not full fat cats pockets in brussels27732017-02-28T19:24:31.68314063Alex wattWhy want to be ruled by Europe when we can stay in a union with our closest allies 27732017-03-01T08:01:02.84314064David NorrisStop stirring up hatred of the rest of the UK that feeds Scotland27732017-03-01T15:02:51.22314065GERRY MULROYThe scourge of puppy farming is widespread here in Ireland . Any action taken against the puppy dealers in particular will have a direct impact on Irish puppy farmers as their main market is the UK .27542017-03-01T19:29:26.22714066DerekForget a referendum and progress with governing this country properly not spending another £xxxmillions unnecessarily.27732017-03-03T18:03:01.47714070Samantha leeThese new cuts are a clear indication that Westminster has not turned its back on austerity and even more cuts to come and once again the victims will be those least able to cope.\r\n\r\n''This government keeps turning its back on those who deserve support and help but the SNP will continue to be the only effective opposition at Westminster - and we will continue to be a thorn in the side of the Tories.''27402017-03-04T12:00:01.93714071John ChapmanThe Highlands and Islands have needs, difficuties and interests which are not generally shared by the rest of Scotland.27312017-03-04T16:55:00.0914072Marie SpencerIt's about the westminister government, were getting all the money that is owned to the public purse, from all the corporate companies that have not paid any taxes, and leave the vulnerable and those in need alone!\r\n27402017-03-04T20:14:57.6614073c costelloPuppy farms should be banned 27542017-03-06T08:05:39.72314074Janice HeathIf people insist on buying puppies and create the demand, there should be rigidly enforced high standards, which are policed. Failure to uphold the statutory standards should immediately mean closure of the business,heavy fines and imprisonment.27542017-03-06T16:25:25.85314075Andrew PearsonUtter nonsense. Unionist propaganda at its worst.27732017-03-06T19:44:27.72714076Carol KalkowskiDont think this is a lawful tax bedroom tac seems ti have been made up by the Romans lol 27402017-03-07T22:34:48.5714077Gwen CameronCentralisation means control. This has been evident from day one. Control of our entirety and services. Control is considered their strength even though they are incapable of running these departments.27312017-03-08T13:37:47.55314078Alessio GentileSo its fine for hetrosexuals who participate in anal sex to donate blood, but not gay men? This is absurd and is a ban based on bigotry, not science 27582017-03-08T14:32:06.46714079Lindsey LaingEnd the ban!27582017-03-08T14:53:30.5314080Aileen McKayHow is this not already a thing? 27582017-03-08T17:41:55.00714081John Michael Dargue.27582017-03-08T17:44:14.60314082Jess MasonThere are already vigorous checks in place to ensure 'clean' blood, sexual orientation and gender alone should have no impact on assessing risk. It would be nice to see Scotland take the lead in modernising blood donation regulations.27582017-03-08T22:23:42.98314083Leeanne McSharryIt is the right thing to do27582017-03-09T08:56:29.32714084Duncan CassidyCan the Scottish Government please stop trying to deflect from the poor job the SNP are doing in running this country, continued talk of a second referendum is only serving as a smoke screen and the first minister should really get on with doing her job. A second referendum is not welcome.27732017-03-09T09:59:43.10314085Lisa AlexanderAs it stands heterosexual people answering the questions truthfully may not be answering them accurately. They may be unaware of past sexual partners drug use or if they have had sex with the same sex but are answering the questions to the best of their knowledge. The blood is rigorously tested before use anyway so why are LGBT+ excluded? Back in the 80s it was thought only gay men carried and transmitted HIV. We now know this to be false. Carry out more stringent tests on samples where the donor has ticked "yes" don't exclude them completely27582017-03-09T17:17:15.7714086John Murtaugh Local councils should not permit licenses and heavier fines should be given to them 27542017-03-11T17:42:43.1914087Sue BagleyBreeding should be regulated and monitored to ensure it is done responsibly and not for purely for financial reward27542017-03-11T17:48:44.4714088Shona Hutchison Bloods are checked anyway so why discriminate 27582017-03-11T18:26:47.69314089Charles collingsRespect the result of the 2014 referendum result and concentrate on running Scotland. The last thing we need at this moment in time is another devisive referendum.27732017-03-12T15:23:33.04314090Nadia ReidThe Scottish Government are becoming complacent in regards to the needs of the Scottish people. Nicola Sturgeon has only one agenda, independence! Ineffective opposition is only facilitating this. Who will address the really issues facing this country? Education, Health...27732017-03-12T20:25:25.24314091mikesort out your mess before trying to divide us any more27732017-03-12T20:29:07.38314092caroleI have not recovered from the trauna of the last referendem so do not want another.27732017-03-13T08:16:29.08314093Vicky hylton Should be harsher punishments for puppy farmers it's disgusting and cruel STOP THEM 27542017-03-13T12:21:22.77714094FraserWhat a great idea, another referendum costing millions based on pitiful gripes. Makes perfect sense to call a referendum because of Brexit. Wailing on about how it's going to be the end of the world as we know it and the solution? break ties with the rest of the UK with whom we do circa 3x more trade with than Europe! Genius.\r\nDo what's best for Scotland and spend your time improving education, health and emergency services.27732017-03-13T13:13:13.33714095ErincroftIf the Holyrood vote again for a once in a generation referendum on Scottish independence, I hope they will abide by the EU recommendations on voting.\r\nThe EU have published recommendations on the rights of EU citizens who have exercised their rights to free movement. They wish for constructive ways for EU citizens living in another EU country to fully participate in the democratic life of the EU by maintaining their right to vote in national elections in their country of origin.\r\nAs , it appears , any future referendum will have been triggered by the SNP wish to remain in the EU, it is hoped that they will abide by the recommendations of the EU.\r\nAll scots who live in the EU , but specifically in the rest of the UK. should have the right to vote. For these first generation scots, it is their country of birth and their families often go back for many generations.They should not be disenfranchised and treated in a negative manner purely because they have exercised their rights of free movement.27732017-03-13T13:13:22.20314096Cameron PurdonI fully agree with the reasons behind this petition. And if there ever is another referendum (sincerely hope not) then all Scots should have a right to the vote! 27732017-03-13T13:33:33.6614097William EadieThe government in Scotland is a one trick pony, Independance at any cost and to hell with services. The evidence is there in declining health, police and education services. Poor economic performance far worse than the hated Tories in England.\r\nAll nationalists should commit all of their wealth and property, as well as that of their families, as evidence of their belief in Independance. I f Scotland goes belly up then they should lose everything before the public who will suffer disproportionately.27732017-03-13T13:33:34.314098William EadieThe government in Scotland is a one trick pony, Independance at any cost and to hell with services. The evidence is there in declining health, police and education services. Poor economic performance far worse than the hated Tories in England.\r\nAll nationalists should commit all of their wealth and property, as well as that of their families, as evidence of their belief in Independance. I f Scotland goes belly up then they should lose everything before the public who will suffer disproportionately.27732017-03-13T14:41:56.39314099AlanNo one voted to remain in the EU without the rest of the UK or for any of Sturgeon's proposals, so this referendum is built on a falsehood without any mandate.27732017-03-13T14:54:07.5314100Jean Mclean It's disgusting how these poor babies are treated no need for it 27542017-03-13T15:43:33.28314101GrahamIf we are forced into another unwanted referendum the PM must take control of the details includong timing. My preference would be THIS OCTOBER. Don't give the SNP time and oxygen to peddle their untruths and divisive rhetoric. If they are so sure of their case let them put it to the electorate now.27732017-03-13T16:10:32.21314102ArchieDear Mrs Sturgeon, I am a Scot born and bred and I am proud of my heritage. I personally don't want to see Scot's becoming second rate citizens in their own country whist the Scottish Nation Party provides Jobs, Housing, Healthcare and Social Services to foreign migrants whether they be from the EU or elsewhere in the world. I voted NO to Scottish Independence and Yes to leave the EU. Should there be an Indy2 Ref I will vote NO again. Nicola It's time to put all this nonsense behind you and get on with fixing the mess we are in. NO Not in my Name Nicola. 27732017-03-13T16:16:49.94314103PhilipA referendum during the Brexit negotiations undermines the UK government's position in those talks. We may well have to suffer ourselves for the damage we cause. To force such a vote when the Brexit terms are not resolved is political opportunism and not in the interests of the Scottish people. At the very least we deserve to know what we are voting about. It would also be a good idea if the questions of currency and fiscal deficit were answered were properly answered in advance if we must have another of these socially divisive campaigns. 27732017-03-13T17:10:00.2214104Violet d hayForget independence get on with running the country Education and NHS a mess you have had 10 years to sort this out27732017-03-13T18:32:27.6814105johnForget a referendum, lets have another election for Holyrood!!27732017-03-13T18:40:42.5414106MichaelThere's more incentive now more than last time, to remain part of the UK. When I originally heard about the possibility of indyref2 just after Brexit, my emotions dominated and I wanted to vote 'yes'. But then I engaged my brain and figured that we A) do not want another expensive, bitter, divisive political mess detracting from other more important issues and B) rUK really needs Scotland, and Scotland needs rUK more than we need the EU.\r\n\r\nThere's more incentive now more than during indyref1, for us to remain part of the UK. Please Scotland.27732017-03-13T18:47:58.37714107Jonathan InnesA second referendum is a complete waste of time. After all the reason being given is we are being taken out of Europe. If you had won the first time round we would already be out of Europe. The economics are even worse now than they were two years ago. A complete waste of time and money. Instead I would ask our elected representatives to get on with their day jobs and look after the areas that they are supposed to in the Scottish government 27732017-03-13T19:00:22.9814108AliceWhy do we need one. It was already decided in 2014 does Sturgeon not understand the outcome of that vote. I would be a big NO. Forget about going down in history Sturgeon and do some work for Scotland 27732017-03-13T19:01:51.71714109michaelwe must stick together27732017-03-13T19:40:00.01714110AndrewScotland has never been a member of the EU. The U.K. has and it voted to leave. Stop using Brexit as an excuse for something you were going to do all along at any cost and get on with running the country. If you can ever come up with a sound fiscal case for independence then maybe we would consider a second independence referendum.27732017-03-13T21:19:34.21714111Nick GodwinIt was to be once in a generation - that means around 30 years, not 3.\r\n\r\nYou can't just keep on having referendums until you get the answer you want. That is not democracy, it is harassment, tantamount to bullying.\r\n\r\nI hope people signing will also sign the UK e-petition on the same lines, number 180642. \r\n\r\nSearch the web for: "UK e-petition" to get the UK gov petition website,\r\nthen on the page search box: "Scottish independence referendum"\r\n27732017-03-13T21:42:22.36714112John CaldwellThe current justification for IndyRef2 is flawed, in my view. SNP have been working towards this. Two problems with it: 1) We voted on Brexit as UK, not Scotland. The whole 'Scotland voted to stay' narrative is misleading. 2) A referendum on the basis of ties to the EU is not genuine independence. 3)It's too soon after IndyRef1 4) It's divisive at a time when the UK needs to pull together. 27732017-03-13T22:18:35.9914113MargaretWe do not need to hold a money spending referendum to decide what we already voted on in 2014. Once in a life time to stay in the UK 27732017-03-13T22:41:18.69714114Archie MillerOne vote was enough, what a waste of money that we haven't got better spend on the NHS.27732017-03-13T22:45:16.33714115A MillerWhat a waste. Money be better spend on the NHS27732017-03-13T23:19:12.21714116Richard HorrellScotland does not need another another Independence Referendum, we had that in 2014 and NO won! 27732017-03-14T07:34:11.4914117john jamiesondont let this women destroy my country27732017-03-14T09:44:05.83714118John M NobleBe proud to be Scottish AND British. Do not risk the future of our children and grandchildren. NO to IndyRef2.27732017-03-14T10:45:05.22714119Marjorie CombeThe result of the referendum vote in 2014 was to remain as part of the UK, so there is no need for yet another one!27732017-03-14T11:04:46.77314120Steve SouterMy vote to remain in the UK and leave the EU is not a mandate for indyref227732017-03-14T12:14:47.74714121Stephen BartonGet on with the day job. 27732017-03-14T13:12:44.22314122Lenny GillespieMy vote to remain in the UK and leave the EU is not a reason for indyref227732017-03-14T13:18:30.91314123Lenny GillespieMy vote to remain in the UK and leave the EU is not a reason for indyref2, get on with the job.27732017-03-14T14:40:28.2114124Lynne BevilacquaIt is about time that the powers that be stopped ignoring the Animal Welfare act and took action against the terrible cruelty inflicted on theses poor bred solely for profit. Licensed breeding establishments should be policed on a regular basis and any shortfall be punished with a lifetime ban for keeping any animal. There is no need for these establishments in a civilised society.27542017-03-14T15:01:12.23314125Neil MacleanThe Scottish Government should engage in what we're paying them to do.27732017-03-14T15:19:37.06714126Alexander StewartMy vote to remain in the EU was not a vote to leave the UK27732017-03-14T15:22:01.7414127Tim TrumperAlthough living in America, I have studied over a ten-year period in Scotland, remain a British citizen, and should I ever return to live in Scotland, wish to do so where politicians respect the will of the people, keep their word, and sow unity rather than further division. 27732017-03-14T16:28:59.40714128Iain LauchlanNo more referenda, constitutional change needs to be negotiated by experts and then voted on by our representatives27732017-03-14T16:45:00.45314129John Thomas EastonStop the obsession Keep to the promise of 2014 and help get the best deal for all. Do the proper day job.27732017-03-14T16:54:24.34714130alexis aitkenThis greed for money at the cost of abuse and cruelty must be stopped.and made illegal.27542017-03-14T17:04:07.3614131A PaigeGet Nicola Sturgeon out of Scottish Politics. The Union of the UK it is more important than a Union of the EU States 27732017-03-14T17:12:49.8814132Gordon GrahamPay attention to what Jim Sillars has to say. 27732017-03-14T17:32:18.35314133Kareen SmithI do not want a second referendum but if we are forced to have one then it should be after the Brexit conditions are clear. Only then can we make an informed choice on what kind of Britain we would be voting to stay in or leave.27732017-03-14T17:52:52.43314134Margaret BellGet on with governing Scotland properly for once and use the new existing powers granted to Scotland 27732017-03-14T18:24:41.7514135Jill StephensonThe whole Scottish separatist 'case' is fraught with uncertainty. A referendum will not make it any clearer.27732017-03-14T18:56:04.9914137jillian mccallumScottish and English Welsh Irish fought side by side some died together to make Britain a better place to live. She rather be apart of the corrupt eu than be apart uk. Brexit only excuse for Sturgeon and crew to carry out their racist polices.27732017-03-14T19:51:52.29314138Kate EllisAs half Scottish living in England, I have visited Scotland for 70 years and always viewed it as my second home. Yet during the Scottish referendum I did not feel comfortable in the country. Scotland will not survive on their own, and the 'Brave Heart'\r\nSNP should get real and support the UK. So I would hate to see another Scottish Referendum.27732017-03-14T20:42:49.92314139Kate CampbellThey DO NOT speak for the people of Scotland! Am sick of the division they are causing in this country. Meanwhile education, health et al are going to the dogs because of their OBSESSION with independance. Wish they would be quiet!!! All the SNP are doing are DESTROYING Scotland. Shame on them !!!27732017-03-14T21:20:04.57314140Robert MellishDon't destroy Scottish prosperity27732017-03-14T21:22:41.1814141Alan BatemanThe electorate of Scotland unanimously voted to remain in the U.K. The uncertainty of the last referendum was stifling to business and investment and suggestion of another refurendum will cause the same effect again, most likely worse with the added background of Brexit which we, as part of the UK must abide with. Any suggestion that the EU will welcome an independent Scotland into the fold is folly and will never happen as this, firstly as this would set a precedent for Catalonia, the Basque region, etc, etc. And secondly whilst we are a proud and noble nation what exactly are we brining to the table. With oil revenue through the floor (and basing and entire economy on a single volatile industry was never very smart in the first place) what do the SNP propose a basing our economy on this time? Banking and finance, not the most endearing track record in that field. The suggestion from the SNP that there is just cause for a second refurendum is in my opinion misleading. In summary a second refurendum would be damaging for business and investment. We are just recovering from the divisive antagonistic and adversarial first refurendum. Please respect the will of the people, get on with governing Scotland and leave it a generation as promised27732017-03-14T21:43:50.71714142Brenda Morgan-KleinYou do not rerun a referendum in less than 3 years. that is not democracy27732017-03-14T21:46:11.79314143Brenda Morgan-KleinYou do not rerun a referendum in less than 3 years because you do not like the result. Scotland needs greater certainty and good governance now. 27732017-03-14T21:51:09.32314144Mark EdwardsThe Scottish Government should devote more time to the issues they have been given power over. Let BREXIT happen and then see where Scotland stands! Between now and then the Scottish Government should deal with the othe issues of Scotland and show that the SNP is not just a 'one trick pony'. 27732017-03-14T22:01:02.57714145ClaireNo referendum unless Scottish Election held and SNP win a majority. I voted remain and don't appreciate my vote being hijacked. I want Brexit and the UK to be a success. 27732017-03-14T22:05:20.01314146PETER PETERSENSNP agenda is not in the best interest of Scotland27732017-03-14T22:06:29.85714147RaymondI dont want to swap a 300 year union built by Scots & the pound, for unelected Brussels billionaires and the Euro.\r\n27732017-03-14T22:14:59.1114148Bruce flockhart I am British 27732017-03-14T22:37:13.06714149Andrew IlliusThe SNP has no right to use my vote to remain in the EU to take Scotland out of the UK27732017-03-14T23:04:35.9314150Angus Murdo MurrayNo material change since binding 2014 ref.27732017-03-14T23:14:29.41714151Torquil MacLeodNo with heart and head - Remain with head. UK will always mean more to me than EU if you force me to choose. 27732017-03-14T23:18:32.30714152Andy HMy choice was to stay in the UK Union last time, it will be the same next time and the next time after, and the one after that, the one after that, the one after that ...ad infinitum..... Prove that you idiots can actually govern..and then only then might you be able to sway me...but until then you are just playing at it and thus prove the point that you will never be grown up enough to Govern..the SNP only speak for 46% of the electorate that bothered to turn out to vote in 2016...you do not have a mandate to speak for Scotland27732017-03-14T23:21:39.52714153Rory Macgregor No meant NO!27732017-03-14T23:27:18.8714154Keith JacksonWe don't want a second referendum 27732017-03-14T23:28:29.214155Keith JacksonWe don't want a second referendum 27732017-03-14T23:39:35.82714156Susan MacOnce in a generation, you said. How can we trust anything you say if you go ahead with another indyref? The Brexit thing is not an excuse. 27732017-03-14T23:56:02.09314157Geonot until after brexit and then only uk citizens to vote,lets hope the council elections in May show a drop in snp votes.27732017-03-15T05:17:24.28314158Elliott LeeThe call for another referendum is a way to cover up the fact that SNP is failing to do the job they were elected for.27732017-03-15T06:09:52.10314159Ross McNairneyThe country needs a government not a pressure group. 27732017-03-15T06:21:02.06314160Fiona dryburgh Education is a disaster. That is a priority. The country is divided enough. We don't want another referendum at this time. That money could be better spent elsewhere. 27732017-03-15T07:45:20.89714161Colin page As a person both born in and always lived in the UK and belived that when as a democratic process has been gone through and a answer has been found we should stick to it and with it what ever the outcome. We as a devolved nation voted to stay in the UK for the forsee able future (in our life time ).\r\nSo as with Brexit which I am against we suck it up and get on with it whatever the Lord has for us. 27732017-03-15T08:23:42.1614162Brian PilmerOur first minister should remember that first and foremost she is a public servant, and employee of the people of Scotland. What she is doing is NOT in our best interests. There are far more important matters that require her time and energy.27732017-03-15T08:35:56.34314163Lynn CharltonI can not believe this is still allowed to continue.27542017-03-15T08:52:40.914164BRSG should not be seeking another IndyRef at all. Using Brexit as reason for separation from rUK is against the will of Scottish people.27732017-03-15T09:04:33.12714165teresa coxrespect 2014 vote and democracy27732017-03-15T09:24:35.93314166Carole mckeown Leaving UK to be governed by eu is not independence 27732017-03-15T09:37:31.65714167Allan PatersonI expect, as promised, the threat of thiis divisive Nationalist push for a second independence referendum to be abandoned for at least a generation27732017-03-15T10:03:00.52714168B RossEven If one agreed that a referendum was required which I certainly don't holding it before the outcome of the Brexit negotiations are complete and indeed how trading with the rest of the world develops in the years beyond is defies logic and is irresponsible. I object to my vote to Remain being hijacked by the SNP to claim independence is the solution.27732017-03-15T10:09:33.47314169AnonymousBoth sexes, regardless of sexuality, are at equal risk of becoming infected with something that could later affect their ability to give blood if they have unprotected sex with an already infected partner. Despite this, certain members of the LGBT+ community are not allowed to donate even though these members are more than willing to donate blood.27582017-03-15T10:29:22.40314170PhilFocus on the things that matter, not the SNP's own agenda that disregards the pressing concerns of the Scottish people.27732017-03-15T10:37:19.07714171John RobertsonSheer opportunistic madness. Disgraceful attempt to hold the peoples of the UK to ransom. Ashamed to call myself Scottish for the first time in my life. The SNP have shown the can't be trusted with the good of the nation.27732017-03-15T10:53:32.37714172Janet YatesStop being so short sighted. Look at the huge number of problems we have. We can't afford any more distractions at a time like this 27732017-03-15T11:27:52.1314173Greig ThomsonIt was promised that the previous referendum was a once in a lifetime - yet another broken promise from politicians. What is the point of gaining independence, just to surrender it all back to Brussels?? Nicola is showing sure signs of megalomania. What is there about "No" that she doesn't understand? It's a simple enough word for even the SNP to understand. This is not doing Scotland any good. Last ref, there were millions of pounds of investment just waiting to be transferred out. The English would probably be glad if we got independence, as they would be glad to see the back of us, and I don't blame them.27732017-03-15T11:28:51.2114174AnjiAlex Salmond divided the country in what was promised to be a 'once in a generation' vote. He then threw his toys out of his pram and left the country in disarray when his bid to become the Last King of Scotland failed. Sturgeon has threatened the Scots almost daily that she would hold another referendum if she felt the circumstances warranted. This referendum is not about Brexit, which is just being used as an excuse for Sturgeon to call for another vote. It will divide the country yet again, place yet more pressure on the UK during the, what for me is already unwelcome, Brexit negotiations. If Sturgeon had obtained any guarantee that Scotland could remain in the EU if it leaves the UK, there would be some justification for the vote, but that is the opposite of the reality, with Spain adamantly denying an independent Scotland any kind of preferential terms of entry. Additionally, the economics are even worse than under Salmond, who lied to us over oil revenues. This exercise is either intended to shake up May, forcing her to attempt to negotiate continued EU membership for the devolved nations, or is a last-ditch attempt by a frustrated Sturgeon to obtain the only goal of the SNP and the glory that would accompany such a feat if successful. Either way, the Scottish people are not best served by this move.27732017-03-15T11:43:52.52314175David lockieThere has to be a second Independence vote to much has changed and if it's going to be a hard brexit there has to be vote wither people like it or not!27732017-03-15T12:19:21.96314176Iain CusatorNo Indy Ref2 should be done until we know what the out come of Brexit entails & how Scotland will be effected.27732017-03-15T12:41:00.40714177PULLENOnce in a life time !27732017-03-15T12:44:11.37714178Michael BoggustIt may not be ideal for the UK to leave the EU but Scotland must surely be better off as part of the UK, with whom most trade is conducted and much closer cultural and social ties exist, than as part of the EU and separated from the UK.\r\nI am not in favour of Scottish independence.\r\nI think that our government representatives, both Scottish and UK, should postpone Brexit and all other non urgent problems,and encourage governments worldwide to get together and co-operate on implementing urgent and effective action on mitigating the effects of climate change.\r\nThis is an ever more immediate threat to the existence of our civilisation. Greenhouse gas emissions must be significantly reduced, action to do that should have been taken fifty years ago. It will soon be too late to stop runaway global warming and totally catastrophic climate change. Emissions are still at record high levels, leaving it any longer to drastically reduce them is foolish in the extreme. That is if anyone wants our civilisation to still be in existence beyond this century.27732017-03-15T13:57:55.6514179Richard CuthbertThe vote in 2014 was conclusive. The United Kingdom is more important to us than a union with Europe.27732017-03-15T14:17:48.2314180Steven OrdRacism, Religious intolerance, Sexism and Nationalism --- YUK. All Imaginary human boundaries. There is a good reason the German's band Referenda - smart people.27732017-03-15T14:25:44.00714181John Copeland For those who do not know already, there is also a petition at the United Kingdom Parliament web site against holding a second Independdnce referendum which I have completed too. 27732017-03-15T14:27:26.02314182John Copeland For those who do not know already, there is also a petition at the United Kingdom Parliament web site against holding a second Independdnce referendum which I have completed too. 27732017-03-15T14:57:34.77714183Eileen WhitsonWe have had enough time to fight back against these constant calls for referendum.snp most incompetent government in the history of uk.27732017-03-15T15:03:40.84714184ASCHey Nicky, Ye need tae dae yer sums hen, Scotland voted to remain in the UK. The UK voted to leave the EU. We dinny need an IndyRef2 and we dinny need you spending all that money on another time wasting referendum. We awe fed up wi you politicians telling us what WE want. Try listening tae US fur a change. You and Alex had your chance in 2014. Time to move on lassie. 27732017-03-15T15:06:19.7714185dee reidPuppy farms are cruel and the only person who benefits is the monster breeding and selling at the expense of the poor animals. It needs to stop NOW 27542017-03-15T15:17:28.70314186Robert KellyWe held a vote.27732017-03-15T15:27:08.42714187Ursula CraigThere is no mandate for a second referendum from the Scottish people it is just SNP's desire for independence and is not in Scotland's best interest.27732017-03-15T16:20:07.2614188Keith ReevesWe have had the "once in a generation" referendum. There has been no significant change since then, as Nicola sturgeon does not want to be part of the EU anyway. Please get on with the real work of government.27732017-03-15T16:23:11.10314189Janis ReevesThe economics just don't add up. The largest deficit in Europe, and larger than Greece. this should be the focus for the SNP27732017-03-15T16:28:29.46314190Tom ScottThe Scottish people voted to stay in the UK in 2014. You can't keep asking the same question till you get the answer you want. That's not democracy that's obstinacy. It's time the Scottish government respected the democratic will of the Scottish people and got on with the day job.27732017-03-15T16:42:48.40314191Stewart GormleyUnited we stand devided we fall27732017-03-15T16:45:36.07714192John A. HillsonThe Scottish Govt is supposed to govern Scotland, not to seek to continually divide it. So far we have a failing education system, an NHS in crisis, a screwed up Police Force, a Justice system that is a joke, continual complaints re transport, and a Finance Minister who when he adds 2 + 2 gets a different answer each time.27732017-03-15T17:11:49.23314193Alan DicksonUse leaving EU as an excuse but refuse to commit to rejoin... any excise will do. 27732017-03-15T17:29:52.75314194Patricia PowellGet on with running the country.\r\n\r\n27732017-03-15T17:30:07.97314195Helen CuthbertAnother referendum will be a waste of time and money.27732017-03-15T17:41:52.67714196Jim FerrierThere is absolutely NO reason for a second referendum so soon after the last. The Scottish Economy is a shambles (similar to that in Greece) with no prospect for recovery. Somebody tell me WHY we should want independence !!!! - there is NO sound reason(s) to go down this route.27732017-03-15T18:38:52.84314197Nora Fox This has to stop27542017-03-15T18:48:58.21714198David ThorntonShould also demolish puppy out buildings27542017-03-15T18:50:47.96714199Charles ShepherdI am tired of the Scottish Government saying that they represent the majority view of Scotland. Why can they not accept the majority view of the public in two referendum on Independence an a UK vote on "Brexit". 27732017-03-15T19:04:08.34714200Russell EdwardsIf independence supporters do not accept the last referendum result then any subsequent independence referendum result cannot be valid either. The SNP have said 'Independence transcends everything' - says it all really.27732017-03-15T19:10:34.59714201Anne RossThe last vote on independence was in 2014. This is just sour grapes. Just get on with the day job and stop making Scotland look stupid.27732017-03-15T19:13:16.86314202Jan RossI don't think we should break the union. I think Scotland is better off as part of the UK.27732017-03-15T19:13:52.3314203Agnes HoskinsAn other distraction to cover up lack of good government for all the people of Scotland27732017-03-15T19:19:36.8814204Frank HoskinsYou are not speaking for the people of Scotland , only the SNP who are only part of the the people of Scotland 27732017-03-15T19:22:01.89314205Jan RossI don't think we should break the union. I think Scotland is better off as part of the UK.27732017-03-15T19:23:06.89314206Agnes HoskinsAn other distraction to cover up poor government27732017-03-15T19:28:07.61314207Richard RossWhat another absolute waste of time, energy and more importantly money. 27732017-03-15T19:52:55.16314208SueStick to the Once In A Lifetime promise. Ask Mrs Sturgeon to stop talking about it as I am sick of hearing her say it every five minutes. We voted NO.27732017-03-15T19:57:20.0114209Alasdair StewartCalling for a second independence referendum seems opertunistic at this time. I have no respect for the SNP party for not accepting the referendum for a generation. Your words mean nothing apparently. How can you be trusted? Nicola and all her MSP should not be spending their time on rerunning this and concentrate on education, and the economy. Please then I may regain some respect.27732017-03-15T20:05:40.85314210D. MacWilliamPlease concentrate on the job of government instead of pursuing personal political aims.27732017-03-15T20:17:11.52714211Alan BuchanWhen will the SNP listen to the people, NO MORE INDYREFS ! You cannot even do the day job far less run a country.27732017-03-15T20:34:16.51314212Jean ParkSNP government needs to get Scotland working, crime and punishment to be fit for purpose, appropriate adults for every child in Scotland is unworkable financially, we can't even care for the children who are vulnerable under social work criteria at the present time, education, NHS, employment needs immediate attention of government. The Scottish people have spoken WHY don't this SNP government LISTEN?27732017-03-15T20:59:48.31314214Janice buchanI voted to stay in the uk , and also to leave the Eu, \r\nSnp are not listening. They do not talk for Scotland,\r\nI'm Scottish and proud to be British, no Indyref 2 needed. Get on with the day job Snp your time is running out in Scotland.27732017-03-15T21:02:03.78314215Ian WiddowsAlthough I now live in Gloucester, I lived in Scotland for 3 years and still frequently travel there for my work. My Company has premises in Scotland and Gloucester. This proposed referendum is unnecessary and divisive, this is a time for the UK to be pulling together. Any independence for Scotland will make it very difficult for the UK to undertake business within the country. Many of my work colleagues do not want to have a referendum on independence.27732017-03-15T22:02:33.85314216Paul CauchiCan you please get on with dealing with the important issues that affect Scotland rather than obsessing about independence 27732017-03-15T22:25:13.21714217Euan GalbraithThe SNP yet again misconstrue and misrepresent the silent majority who do not want a further referendum or Independence. Many people like me voted to remain in Europe but do not want Independence.27732017-03-15T23:50:30.31314218Jacquelyn MacfadyenMy vote to remain in the UK and leave the EU is not a mandate for indyref2. We have more trade with the rest of UK than we do with Europe.27732017-03-15T23:52:46.5514219Gordon McKelvieNo need for another referendum. The country is divided enough with too much economic uncertainty 27732017-03-15T23:54:29.42714220Gordon McKelvieNo need for more division. 27732017-03-16T08:00:52.7814221Amanda FergusonStand by your word - the SNP agreed that the independence referendum in 2014 was a once in a generation event.27732017-03-16T08:18:55.7114222Lorna CarpenterWhen is a referendum not binding? When the SNP demand a recount! It's unfair that we go through another expensive vote when the people clearly gave their opinion last time. Economically a poor move to vote again27732017-03-16T08:26:10.02314223Simon PayneTHe Scottish Govt should get on and do the "day job", not wallow in grudge and grievance politics. The economics of independence look disastrous, time to put the Scottish people first, not simply the SNP.27732017-03-16T09:20:10.10714224Donald parkGet on with governing Scotland and stop wasting time and resources on continually asking the same question until you get the answer you want. Serve the people who voted for you, not yourself.27732017-03-16T09:27:18.20314225James Forrest CunliffeThe Scottish people do not want another referendum, we want the government to get on with the job of governing.27732017-03-16T09:33:46.3414226Stuart McTavishHow do you prevent people telling lies in your petitions and what is the fine and punishment for people (or owners of machines) caught propagating the lie(s)?27732017-03-16T09:36:06.43714227Tom McGibbonActing against the interests of the Scottish people - economic illiterate27732017-03-16T09:45:24.31314228Marie hebdenGet on with the job you are getting paid to do and start listening to what the Scottish people want27732017-03-16T10:10:21.2214229Alasdair MacLeodSNP government should focus more on domestic issues. Let 's put IndyRef 2 on hold for a few years. 27732017-03-16T10:15:48.11714230Mike WicksPlease do NOT ignore my No Vote, and please do no NOT hijack my Remain Vote!27732017-03-16T10:26:43.02314232George GrayPlease concentrate on sorting out the mess you have created since you have been in power - 10 years now so you cannot blame any one but your own incompetent party - I shudder to think what state we would be in if we had voted for independence !27732017-03-16T10:46:09.55314233Alex MacfadyenStart focusing on doing you job for the entire country instead of harping on about this. We had the vote, and we decided to stay.27732017-03-16T10:55:29.13714234David DonaldsonMy vote was to be in the United Kingdom.what happened to Democracy???27732017-03-16T10:56:54.6814235Jacqueline BarkerLeave it alone and spend the money you would waste on much needed NHS and education support in Scotland27732017-03-16T11:14:58.79314236Gilbert McArthurDo not want ruled by Germany27732017-03-16T11:40:44.40714237Brian CoullThe Scottish Parliament should concentrate on the current issues that require to be addressed such as the state of the Health Service Education. 27732017-03-16T12:08:57.92314238RitawilliamsIt's disgraceful how it goes on I don't knw the government in all country's should b doing somethg as its way out of control the sufffeing 27542017-03-16T12:47:55.27314239Mrs Pauline BrineThere are so many dogs in rescue waiting for living homes. So many dogs are PTS whilst waiting. There is NO NEED to breed so many dogs in such a barbaric way. 27542017-03-16T13:01:31.88314240sharon willsonrescue don't breed .simple27542017-03-16T13:22:23.63714241Pamela SmithWe have already voted to remain in the UK.27732017-03-16T13:32:07.7814242D MackieWe already decided this two years ago, don't need to do it again.27732017-03-16T14:01:02.92314243Mr Jim McDonaldindependence means independent not part of EU i have voted SNP for over 25 years i will Vote NO if it Keeps us in The EU and many of my Friends and colleagues say they same thing, NO TO the EU 27732017-03-16T14:51:14.07714244PAT ADAMSI BELIEVE WE WERE TOLD THAT THE INDEPENCE REFERENDUM OF 2014 WAS FOR AT LEAST A GENERATION WHY ARE WE BEING SUBJECTED TO THIS NONSENSE AGAIN.27732017-03-16T14:54:05.29714245GERALD ADAMSThe country is sick and tired of the division and argument. Get back to what you were elected to do.27732017-03-16T15:08:18.39314246BrianI voted to stay in Europe but in no way should my vote be used to try and justify a second independence referendum at the very least until we know what brexit means to us in real terms. We can then judge what is best for Scotland if independence we would need to know the consequences of going alone to compare27732017-03-16T15:16:32.02714247Elizabeth Patrick Over 2 million of us voted to stay in the UK just over two years ago surely we deserve to be listened to.27732017-03-16T16:58:24.16314249Vivienne Bowen We have just seen puppy farming at its worst here. Breeder got away lightly should be jailed. 112 Dogs vanished no one will say where. Protect these innocent animals and Stop Puppy Farms. 27542017-03-16T17:29:11.16314250Alison WCan you please get on with what you were elected to do rather than spending every minute trying to divide our country with every ounce of energy you possess. You are sinking our ship.27732017-03-16T17:32:53.03714251Hillary WoodrowCould the SNP government please update the country with what they have achieved and stop telling us what they want to do!27732017-03-16T17:35:23.0614252James CookThe last referendeum was decisive and presented as a once in a generation vote. That is the settled position and should be respected.27732017-03-16T17:41:50.27314253Neil WoodrowThe finances of Scotland are not in a good place. How could we afford to leave the UK and join the EU? The SNP must make sure that the financial implications are understood by all, how the country will be financed and the impact this will have on us, should they receive sanction to proceed, we can't have another brexit. We need to be very clear on what we are voting for and the impact.27732017-03-16T17:52:41.72714254Ian MitchellPut this all off until after the 2021 election when things will be clearer and the outcome of these elections will demonstrate whether there is public support for independence.27732017-03-16T17:55:35.9214255Elaine VeitchIt is without doubt that while every day 1000's of dogs are put to sleep that anyone would allow the non stop breeding of more dogs. It does not make sense for a 'business' to have a serious amount of differing dog breeds having litter after litter 1000's upon 1000's of puppies while we have so many in rescue unless the people who support this have their fingers in the pie. It has been proven time and again that the dogs are living in squalour making 1000's of pounds for the breeders so they can live in luxury. We need to look after the dogs that are in rescue and stop this disgusting trade! 27542017-03-16T18:17:20.0814256Lesley DudgeonNo to adding chloramination as this is at present untested and no data is available.\r\nSafe drinking water should be at the top of SW priorities and adding ammonia to combat taste without addressing the health concerns is not acceptable. 28092017-03-16T18:24:13.814257Emma LewisThere should simply be a blanket ban on any breeding of animals classed as pets until all shelters are empty. Utterly disgraceful that dogs, cats, rabbits etc are continually bred for money when the exact same types of animals are being abused, abandoned in rescues.27542017-03-16T18:32:32.84314258Annette NessI voted to stay in the EU but accept that the majority of the UK did not. I object to the First Minister using my vote as an excuse to further her own political ends27732017-03-16T18:45:52.19314259Lynda Bleasdale Stop all puppy farming27542017-03-16T18:48:13.3914260Norrie DudgeonIt is very concerning that Scottish Water is only concerned regarding the taste and smell of the new water supply and their answer is to add more chemicals in the process of chloramination which does not address the problem and is surely not the answer to all the health complaints that have developed since the change over to the aquifer. There is presently no known independent evidence that Chloramination is safe and has in fact been banned in several States in the USA. Scottish Water need to rethink their plans, step up and deal with the serious concerns expressed by their customers in Badenoch and Strathspey.28092017-03-16T18:50:45.2414261Tim WithamI was born and raised in England and I can say with confidence that the English elites have only their own interests at heart in maintaining this lopsided union. Only a relationship between equal British nations is best for all on this island. Only independence for Scotland can deliver this27732017-03-16T19:51:14.68714262Alison RendallSo many babies used and abused 27542017-03-16T20:16:28.9514263Colin HewittMy voting no last time had very little to do with EU and everything to do with finance. My position hasn't changed27732017-03-16T20:40:37.52314264Elaine SpenceWe have voted NO already. What part of the word do you not understand27732017-03-16T20:48:59.06314265Margaret Murray As the snp government campaign for indy2 who will be running the country?27732017-03-16T20:59:57.5214266Simon NorrisThe majority of the people of Scotland do not wish a second referendum, so the SNP government should not being trying to force one on us.27732017-03-16T21:07:41.60314267John M LaingBorn in Aberdeen, I have seen the world as a Ship master, lived briefly in England and now long settled back in Aberdeen. I am proud to be British and Scottish so please resist this incompetent Separatist Government making fools of us all.27732017-03-16T21:26:37.12314268shez bradyPuppy farming must be banned, abusers must receive prison sentences and bigger fines. Puppy farming is extremely cruel and totally unnecessary it's a vile disgusting money grabbing so called business . please STOP the abuse and cruelty. 27542017-03-16T21:36:11.7814269Gavin HoggEnuff please....now get on and do your job properly and shelve this obsession, it's hurting us all.27732017-03-16T23:50:21.78714270Alan PilcherNo future referenda on Independence please, the people have already spoken, its a shame the SNP will never ever listen.27732017-03-17T07:29:57.56714271Jennifer McLaughlinScottish govt should concentrate on saving the Scottish NHS and sorting the mess that is Scottish Education.27732017-03-17T07:34:57.80314272Shaun PearceThe socially progressive policies enjoyed in Scotland is possible because Scotland is part of the United Kingdom.27732017-03-17T08:43:14.00314273Judith ReidI am always concerned about how water Regulators carry out their research and very concerned that a whole village have grave concerns. As a huge advocate of drinking plenty water I was very concerned that the people of Kincraig, a village close to where I live, have huge issues and it is not being taken seriously. I fully support them in their quest to "make safe"!! 28092017-03-17T08:46:10.53714274Judith ReidHuge concerns into drinking water in a village close to where my family and I live. These concerns raised must be looked into and concluded. 28092017-03-17T08:52:37.04714275Alan FergusonWhy Can't they accept the will of the Scottish People. I only voted for remaining in the EU to prevent another independence vote.27732017-03-17T09:20:17.0814276Mal DrysdaleGet on with the day job that you are being handsomely paid for and stop disrupting and dividing the country.27732017-03-17T09:53:29.97714277Julie macdonaldThe water in my house smells and tastes vile28092017-03-17T10:07:34.1414278Rhona WhitePlease give us back our lovely fresh water not the chemical laden one we have to endure28092017-03-17T11:06:06.4614279SAIThe SNP need to learn to accept the Scottish people's decision in the last "once in a lifetime" referendum instead of blindly following their own agenda.27732017-03-17T12:25:17.39714280Jacqueline SweeneyShould stop campaigning for independence and get on with running the country and respecting the result of the 2014 referendum. Some of us actually DO want to leave the EU, but not the UK - do what you're paid to do, not what you want to do!27732017-03-17T13:15:06.9514281Colin JackMy vote to remain in EU WAS NOT a vote for a second referendum.\r\n\r\nLet's not waste another £16 million in administration costs alone holding a second one!!27732017-03-17T13:17:55.76314282Colin JackThe SNP keep saying it's votes and not opinion polls that count. We already had a decisive vote against independence . Utter hypocrisy.27732017-03-17T13:41:13.48314283bill patonproud to be Scottish\r\ndelighted to be united.27732017-03-17T13:45:19.0814284David LeadbetterWe have suffered poor drinking water in my area (Strathspeys for a number of years . I have no trust in Scottish Water and believe an independent quality assurance persecuted be is essential 28092017-03-17T14:22:22.56314285KateRight now there are far more pressing issues than independence. I voted against this in 2014 and feel it is far too soon to do this over again just to prove a point. Concentrate on our strengths, let the United Kingdom work as one to get through the Brexit negotations. Trying to split the country is not going to help in any way.27732017-03-17T14:23:44.01714286Elizabeth HarveyI am a proud Scot, who is also proud to be British. I do not wish an independent Scotland and am ashamed at the way our country is portrayed to the rest of the world. They should carry on with her day job and stop playing politics with the majority of Scottish voters who wish to remain in the UK and are willing to adhere to a democratic policy.27732017-03-17T14:33:57.76714287Andrew DlugoleckiTime for some statesmanship, not opportunistic gambling with the nation's future. Leaving the UK\r\nand spending years in the wilderness trying to get trade deals while the Scottish budget is drastically overspent is not my idea of 'best for Scotland'!27732017-03-17T14:52:29.8314288Wendy PatonI'd be really impressed if the SNP would take measures to aid the ailing Education System, Health Service, Criminal Justice System, Police etc. I voted to remain in the UK as I am proud to Be Scottish but proud to be Great Brit - part of the UK. So Snips nip it in the bud, engage brains before putting mouths into gear and fix the mess you have made of Scotland before you turn it into the largest Sinkhole in the World.27732017-03-17T15:07:29.25714289D ClarkRegardless of another IndyRef - we are NOT automatically getting into EU - will the SNP please respect the 'once in a generation' IndyRef vote from 2 years ago - that was the democratic will of the Scottish people.27732017-03-17T15:22:56.19714290Sissi SundbergAny country not taking actions to protect animals should be ashamed! 27542017-03-17T15:48:55.60314291Derek RiddickWhilst I would prefer never to have another referendum, if there is to be one it should be after we leave the EU and be based on outcome of what settlement with UK would be and requirements for EU re-entry if that is being promoted27732017-03-17T15:51:49.3414292Derek RiddickThe Scottish Government needs to get on with its day job and demonstrate it is competent to run the country before it should be allowed to request another referendum. So far they have failed the people of Scotland27732017-03-17T16:38:41.2214293Jane Griffiths We voted to be part of the U.K. The uk voted to come out of the EU. As 5million of the 65million population of the U.K., we do not have the right to overturn that decision.27732017-03-17T16:54:42.47314294Jane WillsPuppy farms should be banned and only legitimate breeders allowed to breed from pedigree dogs not cross breeding. Far more should be done to encourage adopting rather than buying puppies and dogs.27542017-03-17T17:38:21.8714295Archie WestwoodI am sick of SNP claiming to be speaking on behalf of the Scottish people. I am Scottish and I voted to remain in the EU, but the result of that referendum was to leave the EU and I have accepted that. I resent SNP using this outcome as a pretext for seeking a second Scottish independence referendum. result of that referendum was to leave the EU and I have accepted that. I resent SNP using this outcome as a pretext for seeking a second Scottish independence referendum. 27732017-03-17T17:39:24.07314296Christine WestwoodThe SNP want separation from the rest of the UK (actually from England) at any cost. They are utterly fixated with that objective. They hate the Tories and they hate Westminster. They are not interested in what is best for the people of Scotland. Never mind that an independent Scotland would start off with a deficit of £15bn (equivalent to 9.5% of its GDP), with oil revenues collapsed (falling from £1.8bn in the previous year to just £60 million in 2016) and high public spending. The Fraser of Allander Institute, an economics thinktank at Strathclyde University, has stated that closing a 21% structural deficit (as at 2016) would need rates of economic growth for Scotland not seen in current lifetimes. The SNP has no idea what currency would be used by an independent Scotland. They should concentrate instead on fixing our broken education system, which used to be one of the best in the world.27732017-03-17T17:41:04.3414297Yvonne Blunt-MackenzieOur economy is being destroyed by all the uncertainty this creates. 27732017-03-17T18:05:19.46714298Jane AngusI have no confidence in the present situation regarding the taste and pleasantness of the ligued which comes through the pipes28092017-03-17T18:14:3414299David MorrisonIf we cannot have another referendum on the Brexit issue what is the justification for a second independence vote. Do the Nationalist continue with their demands for further referendums until they get the majority they require?27732017-03-17T18:40:05.28314300Michael BroadleyThe SNP accuse Westminster of not listening to the people of Scotland. Maybe they would if the SNP did it as well?27732017-03-17T19:43:28.14714301Ruth GlynnNo referendum required I voted on this topic already and I feel this is a waste of resources 27732017-03-17T19:52:59.47714302Ian mcmanusThe snp are totally obsessed with independence and jump at the slightest excuse to try and achieve their only goal. It almost like Nero fiddling while Scotland smoulders27732017-03-17T21:53:25.0114303Angie GilmourIf a company that prepares food to eat were to add ammonia to it to make it safe for eating there would be an uproar, but it seems to be acceptable to add it to our drinking water. Then theres the effect the water is having on people's skin, it must be costing the NHS a fortune to supply people with various creams, ointments and bath additives to help with skin problems thanks to the chemical laden water that Scottish Water is giving us.28092017-03-17T22:05:15.29714304Scott ThomsonLet's see the SNP's competency to run the day to day affairs of Scotland before we decide on a new referendum. There's a small matter of a black hole in our finances!27732017-03-18T00:12:35.32714305James DUNCANA referendum is a pointless waste of money until (or unless) there is clarity on whether or not Scotland would remain a full member of the EU and the currency to be adopted.27732017-03-18T00:59:27.31714306Nicholas CookI am sick and tired of the SNPs grievance politics. "Once in a Life Time". They clearly lied and will do anything for independence. The SNP as a party do not accept democracy unless they get the result which they want, this worries me as this is the attitude of a dictatorship not a democratic government .I view the SNP as extreme nationalists who endanger our democracy and I am not surprised by their present tactics. They have no regard for the Scottish people and even less regard for our nearest and dearest neighbours. Independence at "ANY COST" is their mantra. Divide and Conquer is their game plan. BEWARE27732017-03-18T07:31:44.01314307Lynn RennieI voted to remain in the EU however I have to respect the result. Ms Sturgeon does not speak for me and I don't want her using my remain vote as a sign that I want another referendum on independence. I thought education was going to be a priority. Our education system is failing our children. Please get on with running the country and do the job you are paid to do.27732017-03-18T10:24:39.88314308Eileen OliverSNP will ruin this Country. They are happy to separate from our nearest neighbours and be joined at the hip with a dysfunctional EU.27732017-03-18T18:01:47.00714309Donald parkWhat is the point of getting out of the UK before we know the deal for Brexit. It just might be a lot better than we could negotiate as entry terms if we were independent.27732017-03-18T18:08:08.2614310J ParkWondering why the SNP November 2016 questionnaire results sent to Scottish public was not published?27732017-03-18T19:34:54.81714311Ian BrownThe SNP made brexit demands on the UK government that where unreasonable and unachievable to allow them to stake a claim for a second referendum, the Scottish public need to get wise to them.27732017-03-18T20:27:58.6714312M RussellI don't want another referendum at all. I would prefer to see the Scottish Parliament running the country instead of following their own agenda which is not what the people of Scotland voted for. If they can't do that it's time for a change.27732017-03-19T09:39:59.2714313Ian StewartThe Scottish Government should be concentrating on running the country, that is what they were elected to do, not to pursue constitutional change. Mind you we should not be surprised given that they have broken manifesto commitments within six months of being elected.\r\nManifesto - We will protect the Forestry Commission\r\nSix months in office - We will disband the Forestry Commission27732017-03-19T09:55:01.22714314Marie Therese HayesI totally agree with earlier comment. The SNP need to prove they can govern a country first. So far they have failed. 27732017-03-19T11:54:00.89714315Kenneth McWilliamI see on a daily basis the problems Scotland is not addressing and this Govt is too entrenched in Independence to focus on the real issues we face.27732017-03-19T13:48:03.00714316Callumthe last referendum was a once in a generation event. 2020 isn't the timespan of a generation but is better than 2018.27732017-03-19T14:36:45.0114317David DunbarThe last referendum was divisive and we are only just beginning to rebuild. I think the government need to focus on the day to day governing of the country and not waste huge sums of money on a 2nd referendum and use that money to support vital day to day services.27732017-03-19T16:06:51.8214318John O'NeillWe had a referendum in 2014 d this current SNP government is refusing to abide by this DEMOCRATIC decision reached then. They do not speak for me nor the Scottish People as a whole and I am livid at the way they continually go on about this. It seems that any excuse would be valid in their eyes for another referendum asis in this case with Brexit. There is no indication of how an independent Scotland would finance itself. We would be a third world country. They have had ten years in power and the country is in a mess. The police and fir service have been cut to the bone. How many of us can say they have seen a police officer walking their streets in the last 10 years. Education is a mess as is the NHS. All on their watch. This SNP administration has taken its eyes off of the day job just look at the first minister's own constituency of Govanhill. What a mess it isn't in. 27732017-03-19T16:28:49.82314319Calum DudgeonHave to buy bottled since the Aquifer was built.28092017-03-19T18:08:52.94314321Fiona MacLeodWe voted in a "once in a generation" referendum. The vote was to stay in the UK. That should be honoured. There should not be another referendum. 27732017-03-19T21:40:14.91314322Lindsay maclure The threat of this second referendum is holding scotland back..everything is on hold..just such a shame for the people here as so much uncertainty 27732017-03-20T09:25:36.76314323Clara Hayes Scotland has incredible pure water, don't let Scottish Water experiment with our drinking water! 28092017-03-20T09:59:08.12714324Andrew McGarveyRespect the democratic voice of the Scottish electorate who said NO!27732017-03-20T10:33:46.4214325Keith GrahamThe issue of Independence was decided conclusively in 2014. Another divisive referendum is neither needed nor desirable. The SNP Government is not covering itself with glory at the present time and needs to show that it is capable of running the Country properly before even contemplating holding another referendum.27732017-03-20T16:40:36.87714326Murdo Macrae Ammonia has become most undesirable in cosmetic products, so why on earth is it being added to our drinking water! 28092017-03-20T20:14:25.24714327Paul HastingsI never thought I would ever buy bottled water, Scottish Water have destroyed the cleanest tap water available and forced upon us an overly chemically treated water supply that is completely unwanted. They should be forced to revert back to original supply and explain why they have wasted so much money in some sort of whim. Why would we accept even more chemicals added to the very poor quality water we receive now.28092017-03-20T20:21:42.34714328Jamie StewartBring back Loch Einich water 28092017-03-20T20:45:44.93714329M.Banks"The People of Scotland" spoke in 2014 and they said NO!!!27732017-03-20T21:06:10.84714330Una Campbell-MacdonaldBrexit means Brexit, we have to get on with it. No means No, we have to accept it. What a shame the SNP can't rebrand itself as the Scottish Nice Party\r\nand get on with governing Scotland properly. 27732017-03-20T21:27:21.75714331Helen Bainbridge The DWQR don't appear to have taken on the concerns of the Badenoch & Strathspey Residents. chloramination is not the answer to the current problems. Water quality is poor resulting in an increase in the number of people with skin problems. I am now having to use steroid creams due to eczema which I have not had for 30 years. We are using bottled water to drink, and we are now on our third kettle since the new WTW opened. 28092017-03-20T21:28:21.3714332G. InnesThe SNP appear to be so obsessed with wanting independence that it is causing an unhealthy divide within Scotland. They had the vote in 2014 and the vote was to remain within the UK. SNP should to accept the vote and move forward concentrating on the other issues that need addressing. 27732017-03-20T22:00:39.42314333Dawn McwilliamIt makes me ill drinking water from the tap now, when I was born & brought up in Grantown leave it the way it was!!28092017-03-20T22:26:48.71314334Rosemary MooreHow can you vote when you don't know what you are voting for27732017-03-21T07:23:49.6714336Michael RostantThe SNP Government needs to get on with sorting out the very significant problems within Scotland before even contemplating another referendum.Also, holding another referendum without any idea of the outcome of the Brexit negotiations is just irresponsible.27732017-03-21T08:59:43.15314338Joe rayHow can the SNP trully know what the people want, they surmise every one wants another referendum thats not the case going by talking with others who have had enough off this nonsence going on in the name off the scottish people27732017-03-21T10:20:26.2114339Diana WebsterThe Scottish government needs to focus attention on improving the Scottish economy and demonstrating competent government before pursuing another divisive referendum. The SNP's record on education, the NHS (both fully devolved, so can't be blamed on Westminster) and promoting economic growth is poor and increasingly visible.27732017-03-21T11:29:29.12714340Gwynneth bromley They shouldn't need to do anything to water to make it safe, they should have left it well alone and continued from the old natural supply28092017-03-21T12:05:38.5514341JeanetteIt is the will of the SNP to hold another Indy ref not the majority of Scottish people. Even some SNP voters don't want it as they only voted SNP due to the demise of Labour in Scotland and it was against their upbringing to vote Tory. The Brexit result must have been like manna from heaven when the country voted out of the EU. Let the 2014 vote stand and get on with the important issues of governing Scotland. 27732017-03-21T13:18:16.73314342donald beatonThe SNP should concentrate on governing the country properly which they are not doing at the moment. Is it their wish to divide scotland and don,t they realise that most of our trade goes to England and this would be put in jepordy if we were independent.27732017-03-21T13:32:12.8214343LynnThis barbaric treatment of these poor dogs need to stop now. It's a money making racket, there's no love or respect for the poor dogs.27542017-03-21T13:53:09.214344stuart pennyget on with GOVERNING the country, not forcing your personal agenda down the throats of the Scots people27732017-03-21T13:57:36.47314345Charles CoulterSNP have no right to say they talk for the people of Scotland they do not talk for me and many other.27732017-03-21T14:46:12.25314346gwen jarmanwe all must work together to stop all puppy farms,,,\r\n27542017-03-21T17:06:53.32314347Maggie LawsonLived in Badenoch and Strathspey area all my life and I'm appalled at the quality of our water now. We used to be able to boast about how good it was to drink. Now I'm ashamed to say I buy bottled water! 28092017-03-21T17:21:01.20314348Flora Macdonaldwhy is the SNP giving priory to independence when they should be running the country - I will always be a No voter.27732017-03-21T17:58:11.22314349Willem de Jong Complaint: I have to filter the water to stay healthy. Without proper filters my digestive system becomes disruptive.28092017-03-21T18:23:46.39714350John HutchisonNo to 2nd referendum27732017-03-21T18:31:19.08714351Philip TrussellThere should be no further referendum in the near or medium term. The last one was advertised by the then First Minister as a once in a lifetime event. It would serve Scotland better if the Scottish Parliament focused on governing the country rather than seeking ways to get a further referendum. I question whether the SNP would allow a second referendum if the one in 2014 had resulted in an exit choice !27732017-03-21T18:49:40.43314352Maria cruickshankI wear black clothes for work when I get changed you can see the dry skin on the inside of them where it rubs off, im on my third kettle as they go disgusting with all the residue and it's costing a fortune in bottled water, I'd rather have my dogs drink out of puddles than my tap.28092017-03-21T18:56:33.60714353Susan GregoryWe voted NO. Leave it there.27732017-03-21T20:04:29.7614354Ronald PageI totally agree with the sentiments expressed. Another referundum will simply create divisions in Scotland. We need to be united and together in seeking a better Scotland NOW.27732017-03-21T21:51:40.03714355ACHear my voice loud and clear. \r\nI am Scottish and I say NO to IndyRef2.\r\n\r\n 27732017-03-21T23:25:23.34714356Elaine WelshAs a mother I would much rather the Scottish Government concentrate on the job they were elected to do such as sorting out the embarrassing mess that Scottish education is in!27732017-03-21T23:33:12.92314357Ian RobertsonTwo days spent debating an issue that was done and dusted in 2014 allegedly for a generation. Pity the Scottish Government don't take matters such as education, health, social care as seriously. What a shameful waste of taxpayers money. Sick to death of the SNPs constant whingeing and carping against Westminster when the mismanagement and squandering of public money is their responsibility!27732017-03-21T23:37:58.72314358Rhona WelshExtremely angry we are to be dragged through another corrosive referendum. This can be nothing but harmful to the people of Scotland not to mention the massive waste of money - money that could be used for the issues that REALLY matter to the Scottish people!27732017-03-21T23:45:00.69314359John McAllisterThe Scottish Referendum created a slowdown in economic activity and investment which the country can ill afford if it were to happen again. The decisive 'once in a generation' referendum result should be respected, and the energy, passion and focus of those in the Scottish Government should be centred around improving the lives of those who live in this great country. \r\n27732017-03-22T00:45:42.6414360patricia oboyle yes i agree further referendum independence should be delayed27732017-03-22T07:57:25.75314361Joan LynnIt seems to have been entirely disregarded by the Scottish Parliament that the question on the EU referendum ballot sheet was a question regarding the UK's membership in Europe. This seems to have been totally disregarded by the SNP. I also find it totally hipocrtitical that the First Minister is using the lack of information coming from Westminster regardiing the details on Brexit but does not seem to be able to give the Scottish people details on Independence. Now is most definately NOT the time to even think about Independence.27732017-03-22T09:55:53.96714363Hugh CameronIt appears to me that the SNP want independence at any cost and that they will sacrifice the economic health of Scotland to achieve their aim.\r\nThe SNP is not really interested in the EU (they have equivocated on this subject before) but they do see this as an opportunity to push for a second independence referendum. And that barely three years since their once in a lifetime commitment at the last vote.\r\nThere is clearly no desire from the wider Scottish population for yet another referendum excepting those blinkered nationalists.\r\nScotland has significant health and social care issues and yet the SNP are solely focused on breaking up the UK.\r\nSNP - Get on with your devolved responsibilities!27732017-03-22T10:57:38.41714364Innes GrigorThe issue of Independence was decided conclusively in 2014. Another divisive referendum is neither needed nor desirable. The SNP Government is not covering itself with glory at the present time and needs to show that it is capable of running the Country properly before even contemplating holding another referendum.27732017-03-22T11:04:43.47714365robbieWe will, I take it, in the event of Indyref2 succeeding, be having ScotEuroRef1, being such a major constitutional event in our new nation?27732017-03-22T11:08:10.38314366Jim WaughAnyone with any doubt of the misery caused to dogs by irresponsible breeders needs to be taken to see it with their own eyes - they'll never forget. It will remain with them forever27542017-03-22T11:59:50.95714367Bill Kidd MSPPuppies must be raised and cared for in a loving environment and the public shouldn't buy a dog from a dubious background. 27542017-03-22T12:10:42.2214368Susanne crayton Please stop this cruel trade. It is often linked to more serious crime. More needs to be done. All breeders should be vetted and require a license 27542017-03-22T12:25:16.4914369Jacqueline Ferris-WoodsThe exploitation of dogs by puppy farming MUST be stopped. In total agreement with unique numbers for breeders and puppies. There must be traceability.27542017-03-22T12:47:45.71314370Tina cottonAnyone not taking action to protect puppies and their parents should hang their head in shame and get more higher sentences in prison. Also a forever ban on not owning pets not just 12 months. This needs stopping NOW27542017-03-22T12:51:22.44314371Tricia TaitThe cruelty and greed has been exposed ...these hell holes must be confined to the history books and a very shameful history it is!!!\r\n27542017-03-22T13:10:12.10314372jean frewWe were promised by the SNP that the previous referendum was a once in a generation referendum even though the previous First Minister has lied on air by denying he said this. If another referendum is to take place it should be after the next Scottish Parliament election in 2021. 27732017-03-22T13:13:48.32314373HeatherThis just needs to stop.27542017-03-22T13:30:34.3914374Samantha BradyJust think for a minute of what horrors the breeding dogs life's are like, locked up 24 hours a day, often in darkness, often diseased, no exercise, no love or care, encased in a living hell, barely alive - just producing litter after litter of deformed & sick puppies! Then ask yourself, is this right? Is this fair? Would we allow this with children? The answer is no! Its not right or fair!! Why are we allowing this trade to carry on? The public buy blindly, feeding the torture but the councils & kennel club know what they are licensing, they are just as bad as the evil greeders! Please stop this circle of evil & help the thousands of dogs & puppies that are suffering purely for mans greed!27542017-03-22T13:36:03.43714375Alexander W DuncanAs an 80 Year old, having lived through WW 2, I know that we need to stay together in the U.K. which to me was the 1st "Common Market". We do not want to break up the Armed Forces, nor have to finance a seperate Home Office, Foreign Office with all the Consulates etc. Nor have to pay the Old Age pensions to all Scots both at home and abroad. If we leave the UK we will lose out on all Royal Navy Shipbuilding work, and Uk Defence work, which may force companies to move south. Having 32 Years of experience in the Defence Industry, being within the UK gives you Category One direct access to the M.o.D.Tendering. Outside the UK you are Category 2 at best. If we become seperated from the UK, my experience with the Lord Donaldson Enquiry, convinced me that Orkney and Shetland would apply for Brittish Protectorate status in line with the Falkland Islands. etc. This would change the defination of Territorial Waters. If Scotland joined the E.U. not only would we increase our population, but also exacerbate the housing crisis.due to Immigration. Scotland has the longest coastline in the UK, and a land border with England. Given the problems in Eastern Europe, will the Cross Border Trains have to stop at Berwick and Gretna, will the British Transport Police still have a status in Scotland ? This to me is just a snapshot of the questions that would be raised with Independence, to me it makes Brexit seem just that little bit easier, it's together for 310 Years against 40 odd. There are so many things we just take forgranted, such as the time system i.e. GMT and BST. Without Scotland the then UK to opt to change to Central European time i.e. GMT plus 1 hr, with a further plus 1 Hr during the Summer months. Something we called Double Summer time during and just after WW 2. To me by definition the SNP are a one issue Party that will take any perceived opportunity to achieve Independence come hell or highwater. We entered the Common Market as the UK. so we should leave as the UK.27732017-03-22T13:44:09.0314376Lesley JonesPuppy farming by back street breeders is cruel and barbaric. Unwanted puppies are being bred by dogs that are not fit to have puppies. Rescue dogs are in the millions needing homes. Ban these money grabbing, cruel, vile people making money out of animal misery. 27542017-03-22T13:56:01.56714377Stanley Jackson Puppy farms are abhorrent, breeding for money rather than benefit of the dogs, batches and puppies.27542017-03-22T14:04:11.86314378Joanne DwyerPuppy farmers are only in it for the cash and don't care about the animal's welfare . Adopt don't shop 27542017-03-22T14:14:52.44314379Jessie Preston Young DuncanI would prefer that the Scottish Government to get on with the day job and not spend time and money trying to unravel the U.K. The 2014 decision should stand for, as Mr Salmond agreed, for at least a generation. To me the First Minister is trying to make a name for herself in History, with complete disregard for the consequences.27732017-03-22T14:30:25.20714380Elise BlackToo many back yard breeders out there just keeping dogs constantly in litter for money, this needs to be stopped 27542017-03-22T14:50:39.19714381Michael adamsonWhen will we scots realise the present Scottish government is running our countries economy into the ground let's get them and the greens out of thr scottish parliament.27732017-03-22T15:01:20.0114382AngiePlease stop!27542017-03-22T15:05:48.13314383Rosie DowerIntensively breeding dogs for profit is unethical and abhorrent. The welfare of the dogs seems to be of little importance and councils and governments who licence these establishments should be ashamed of themselves.27542017-03-22T15:09:08.68314384Jeff ButtressOur dog wont drink tap water. I have to clean filters in taps, washing machine and showers every month to clear the crap out of them. Not acceptable28092017-03-22T15:19:41.07714385Graham ScottThe SNP are bleating on about the Conservative party are ignoring democracy by refusing a second referendum at this time. What about the democratic votes in the last "once in a lifetime" referendum that decided that Scotland should stay part of the UK. Are the SNP applying there own version of democracy to suit their own aims? \r\n\r\nPerhaps they should focus all their efforts in running the country efficiently rather than all the bluster and tunnel vision being demonstrated by the First Minister!27732017-03-22T15:31:07.84314386Sheila Mackayour water is rotten -tastes rotten and smells rotten and I firmly believe what we are expected to hydrate ourselves with is in the long term going to gave a detrimental effect on our health .28092017-03-22T15:35:00.87314387Maureen WoodhamsPuppy farming is cruel!!!27542017-03-22T15:37:46.9214388Sheila MackayScottish Water have assured me my tap water is fine --- it tastes rotten -smells rotten and I firmly believe drinking the water is going to have a detrimental effect on health in the long term.28092017-03-22T16:18:00.28714389FRASER NIMMOA vote was taken regarding a Scottish referendum in 2014 - the result being that Scotland wanted to remain part of the United Kingdom. We do not need another vote at this time, there are too many other important matters requiring the attention of our elected representatives ....27732017-03-22T16:54:55.72314390Scott ForrestThe SNP cannot just keep calling for a independence referendum each time they are not happy with UK government policy which we Scots all agreed to except once not so long ago. 27732017-03-22T17:13:44.82314391Louise McNeillNow is not the time to be focussing on a second independence referendum. I'm disappointed in our First Minister. We should stand together as we have done for the past 300 years. \r\nwhen I moved from England to Scotland, as we share a common heritage and felt I was still living in my country. Now when the SNP say the will and voice of the Scottish People must be heard they obviously are not representing me. There are many Scottish people living in the rest of the UK27732017-03-22T17:25:42.99314392Mellissa SheldrakeNo more puppy farms27542017-03-22T17:29:48.84314393Wendy Wright This barbaric practice needs to be stopped.27542017-03-22T17:39:59.6514394David ROutlaw puppy farms, punishable with minimum 4 year sentence, lifetime animal ban enforced by a further 8 year sentence 27542017-03-22T18:02:56.9814395Helen BlackburnThis has got to STOP!27542017-03-22T18:17:03.36314396Mrs Julie Ann PritchardI have lived in the area for 10 years. When the water suppl changed I became unable to drink the water as had constant stomach ache. I have a permanently itchy scalp and dry skin. I get really run down as if I have flu like symptoms when I drink the water with dark black shadows under my eyes, feel washed out and have to sleep.Never feel like this when I do not drink the water. I feel poisoned when I drink the water.28092017-03-22T18:40:50.16314397Lynne CameronA second referendum should not be allowed, this should be at least a once in a lifetime vote. The EU angle is purely a ploy to push for a second vote. We should work to strengthen the union. 27732017-03-22T18:49:43.75314398Sandra AndrewsI think the Scottish Parliament should get on with sorting the many problems in the country.27732017-03-22T19:53:19.76314399robert copelandI do not want another referendum 27732017-03-22T21:33:05.7314400Claire WhyteNot only do we now have to buy bottled water as the taste is horrendous and I will not have my 2yr old drinking that many chemicals. But our skin has suffered also and if it's doing the same to our bodies as it's doing to the appliances in the house then heaven help us!28092017-03-22T22:04:12.36314401Louise Brown Thousands of dogs in rescue puppy farming is cruel only serves to line the pockets of animal abusing morons!27542017-03-22T22:09:15.4614402James ArnotThe democratic will of my and our Country was decided a "Generation" ago in 2014. Ten years of SNP mismanagement of particularly, our education system, and other public services are not being scrutinised properly. Much better to shift the attention on to an issue that has been already decided. 27732017-03-22T22:21:40.2514403Scott SeckerThe SW figures don't add up. I lived in Aberdeen for 40 years and never had a problem with limescale. Moved to Kingussie and it's a nightmare. Yet SW figures suggest the Aviemore supply has less limescale. Something isn't right. I do not need to elaborate on the skin condition I fell with as soon as I moved here. \r\n\r\nSW need to learn to listen to their customers. 28092017-03-22T22:42:28.25314404John hoggScottish water your day will come, you'd better have answers 28092017-03-22T22:49:58.1314405Jacquelyn JachontowThe government show be responsible for enforcing legislation. Puppy farms should be closed down and any breeders should follow strict guidelines. They should also not be allowed to have so many dogs being breed from.\r\n27542017-03-22T23:06:14.47714406Kirsti McIntyreAs much as puppy farming just ghastly, educating the people who drive the business and buy a puppy in this way is quite possibly more important! The BBC Scotland Programme was a great eye opener! 27542017-03-23T07:16:02.414407Nicholas CookThe SNP do not respect democracy and that is a danger to our society. The SNP want independence at any cost at the expense of the Scottish people and have no respect for the other countries within the United Kingdom. Damage was caused to our economy when we had the first referendum and more damage will now occur with this proposal for Indie ref 2. At present would I set up a business in Scotland and invest money (I dont think so) but I might consider moving my business else where.Scotlands economy is lagging behind the rest of the UK due to the actions of the SNP.27732017-03-23T07:21:23.4914408Deborah Macphersonpull the people together - not apart.\r\nScotland is a wonderful country enhanced by being part of the UK27732017-03-23T08:32:48.57714409Norman MacdonaldWe have already said NO and whilst this may not satisfy everyone believe the democratic process should be accepted by all. 27732017-03-23T09:06:42.64714410james campbellTo be honest, I do not think a referendum should be called at any time in the near future, as it is leading to great division in our people.27732017-03-23T10:06:31.0714411MATTHEW HAMLETTThe Scottish Government should get on with their jobs instead of wasting time and energy focusing on what is clearly their only ambition - Independence at any cost. We live in a democracy and it is about time the SNP respected the fact, both in relationship to Brexit and Scotland's own vote to remain part of the UK27732017-03-23T12:41:51.87714412Mark CunninghamThe SNP has to respect the Scottish referendum and the Brexit referendum - they should be concentrating on sorting Scotlands economic and social problems rather than focusing 100% on dividing an island with great institutions and history.27732017-03-23T16:28:51.02714413June O'HenleyA very worthwhile petition covering all employees and volunteers who work within NHS - Scotland. 28262017-03-23T18:11:04.4314414Malcolm InnesBy continuing with her obsession over a second Referendum SNP has to be doing untold damage to any prospects of overseas investment in our Country.27732017-03-24T09:50:49.28314415Angus O'HenleyIt is essential that everyone involved in offering care and support to would be patients, anywhere within the Scottish NHS will be given maximum protection from potential assailants and allowed to deliver the care and service they provide.28262017-03-24T14:03:51.31714416Iain HayesIt's high time that we raised the issue of water quality vs profit for the scottish water supply. 28092017-03-24T16:43:18.32314418Jim BarclayI don't see the point of separating from the UK when two thirds of our exports go to the rest of the UK probably mostly to England.\r\nIf in fact we could doing better on our own it is still not a reason for separation. The idea of a union like the UK is to support one another. there is strength in unity.\r\nI think the 1st Minister should work and support the UK parliament to get the best deal in the negotiations with Europe.27732017-03-24T19:08:54.40314419Brian GriffithsIt is a disgrace that NHS workers should have to put up with such abuse.28262017-03-24T21:39:57.6314420Alexandrina filshillI object to a referendum before Brexit negotiations are complete and on the basis the 2014 referendum was conclusive27732017-03-24T21:44:44.92714421Frank chalmersI object to a referendum before Brexit negotiations are complete and on the basis the 2014 referendum was conclusive27732017-03-24T21:52:20.1314422Danny MorrisonThe People of Scotland voted in 2014 to remain in the United Kingdom, accepting the responsibilities as remaining a part of the union. personally I am against a hard Brexit but we should respect and accept the decisions made by the union we decided to stay in.27732017-03-25T09:21:28.81714423Joe leeThe water from my tap tastes aweful!28092017-03-25T09:29:16.37314424Val AllanScotland has so many issues to be solved . Education , Police and economy , it is time the Scottish Government concentrated on the job they were elected to do . 27732017-03-25T13:46:27.5114425Mark PeadOne Flag, Four Nations, Three Hundred Years.\r\n\r\nLet's keep Britain Great by staying together.27732017-03-26T11:12:56.28714426Rex SircusThe quality and taste of drinking water to my home has deteriorated significantly since the switch to water from a new pumping station at Aviemore. It has a smell and taste of chlorine on a regular basis and in order to mask this the authorities plan to add ammonia to the water. In a recent notice they have advised us that if we have pets we may wish to contact our local vet for advice and guidance. This is because like humans many animals have also displayed a similar distaste to the new water supply. This has include my own dog who has refused to drink it on regular occasions when the chemical content is all too clearly high. It distrurbs me greatly that the water company's response to complaints thus far has simply been to deny the concernes of the public, repeating their statement that the water is safe to drink. I attended a meeting with the company last year and was not satisfied by the response of the company representatives, including their science expert. Continuing to pump more chemical filled water down our pipes which used to carry a very different and better supply from Loch Einich cannot be acceptable for reasons of good taste, odour and most importantly for the health od those people and animals relying upon the supply from the Aviemore pumping station. I therefore support this petition.28092017-03-26T11:19:25.14714427Geraldine SircusThe water has a terrible smell - some days what comes out of the tap smells like the swimming pool. Our dog will not drink the water we put down for her, and this has affected her other food which we used to add water to. The water is undrinkable without adding juice to give a bearable taste. 28092017-03-26T17:06:18.40314428Douglas AlexanderWe live in a democracy, there should be no indenpendence referendum until 2024 at the earliest. Remember the 'once in a generation' statement from Sturgeon herself27732017-03-26T17:12:18.52714429Ann AlexanderFirst Minister Sturgeon needs to do the day job before she has any thoughts of the second referendum. She talks a good game, but leads a country that poorly managed thanks to her policies.27732017-03-27T08:28:16.4614430Karin MeyerWe are UNHAPPY with the water quality of Aviemore, especially now the taste is hidden by using ammonia. My husband is unable to drink tap water, his stomach gets upset. All the good bacteria left in his stomach will be even more destroyed by ammonia. Scottish Water is listening, but not HEARING wat we have to say in this valley. Please let NHS come in and be involved. We should treat what causes illness, not treat symptons which will stay and will cost us a lot of money. Chloramination is banned in most European countries, I am sure you are aware of that. Only UK and Spain use chloramination.28092017-03-28T09:20:24.8314431Williams How on earth is Scotland going to pay for all the benefits NHS education pensions etc. Without the help of the rest of the UK? Most of our factories are closed and there are very few jobs on offer for our young people. 27732017-03-28T16:58:38.25714434Morag BrownWe do not need another divisive Referendum. We were told in 2014 that this was o once in a lifetime. The SNP are obsessed with only Independence at any cost and not doing the job they are paid for. Our country is in chaos and people are suffering daily while they pfaff around spending monies that should be used to help constituents. Shocking. People have shown that they do not want another Independence referendum. \r\n27732017-03-28T17:40:39.85714435Evelyn QuateUnited we stand, divided we fall. Sturgeon and the SNP are only interested in independence and getting their name, infamously, into history books.We voted in 2014. Respect the outcome. This is a destructive party, hell bent on destroying a beautiful country, pitching people against each other for no other reason than her childhood dream. They needs to grow up and govern the country and do the Job she over paid to do. The last thing Scotland needs is another referendum, we are sick of it. This is the same party, had they won in 2014, were taking us out of the EU anyway. They change their minds depending on which way the wind is blowing or what side of the bed they got out of. Let's deal with Brexit. 27732017-03-28T18:23:13.5414436Beryl CampbellNo Scottish Referendums for 20 years27732017-03-28T19:12:31.63314437Deborah Macpherson I wish the party could think about other issues instead of just being hell bent on breaking up the UK. We are much better together.27732017-03-28T19:37:28.4214438Alan CSurely waiting until brexit gives Scotland the opportunity to make an informed decision between U.K deal and independence. The push for referendum prior to this shows Nicola Sturgeon is scared of the outcome, which is why she pushing for referendum. 27732017-03-28T21:49:10.614439Alice CorbettOur main focus should be on Brexit, we have already given our answer to a referendum and it was NO !27732017-03-28T23:25:41.87714440John PatonGet on with running the country and stop looking after your own self interest27732017-03-29T12:03:46.82314441MarySort out education, policing and the economy. Wait and see how the UK changes after we actually leave the EU and then let people vote if you really want a vote. 27732017-03-29T13:54:01.37714442Slobodan PetrovicSNP will regret calling another referendum.I am personaly sick of hearing their inability to accept results of last referendum. My MSP don't present majority in West Lothian where people voted against independence. SNP will soon go to history and will become irrelevant force in Scotland.27732017-03-29T14:49:52.77714443Alison InnesThe rates are an additional charge to nurseries which will not help them offer more places for children in Scotland if costs keep increasing28132017-03-29T15:07:32.46714444Kerry robertson This will put many nurseries out of business28132017-03-29T16:03:58.83714445K.McLemanNurseries need the space for our children's benefit, it's crazy they're being treated the same as other businesses 28132017-03-29T19:31:06.68714446Margaret kindnessStop this second referendum its a waste of money. Lets see what happens in the next 2 years. Spend the money in scotlands nhs schools 27732017-03-29T20:42:35.49314447Natalie MckelvieIt is totally unjustifiable and going to make early years childcare impossible for parents to afford if employers are forced to rise the fees.28132017-03-29T20:52:15.18314448Catriona MacRaeThe government cannot expect childcare providers to offer 'free' childcare if they are not receiving there full rate - it is not sustainable!!28132017-03-29T21:44:25.39314449Sharon FairleyThe Government must work with the private Early years providers and make childcare affordable. Abolishing rates , fairer Funding , along with being zero VAT rated would make a huge difference. 28132017-03-30T10:18:21.2714450natalie robertsonwe moved to the area seven months ago since moving we had to buy bottled water as has tap water has strange taste and all family members six in total have now got dry patchs on there bodies which have only just appered28092017-03-30T11:08:24.18314451George SimpsonWe had vote the vote was no. No means no 27732017-03-30T12:25:38.36714452kerry robertsonThis is unacceptable. My rates have gone up by 81.5% to £14700028132017-03-30T14:32:11.40314453julia sherrattThe SNP over the last 10 years have shown that they are incapable of running our country using the already extensive powers devolved to them. Hence the economy is running a 10.1% GDP deficit, borrowing is at an \r\nunsustainable level and monies are being wasted by ineptitude, schools and the S.NHS. are floundering. It therefor follows that Independence under the SNP would further bankrupt us. Forget about calling for ANOTHER independence referendum and hold a Scottish General Election NOW. Let's get rid of the school yard tantrums of bigots ( definition: bigot a hypocrite, a person who claims to have certain moral beliefs but whose behavior doesn't match those belief)27732017-03-30T16:16:52.30314454Catherine KirkpatrickI developed skin problems nearly 2 years ago after 60 years of perfect skin.i blame the water for this28092017-03-31T09:30:51.6714455Anne RaineyWe had a referendum in 2014 and don't need another one.get on with the day job.No referendum27732017-03-31T10:03:48.23714456Joel Prentice A massive amount of 'No & Remain' voters have been misrepresented to justify this bogus process for another referendum.\r\nThe political system in Scotland has been hijacked, Holyrood is fast turning into a white elephant, a farcical waste of time, money and effort. What purpose does it serve, other than chasing the narrow aims of a single divisive agenda?27732017-03-31T10:05:47.1914457Ian FeeneyThis rise will either affect the viabilituy of nursery businesses or will pass on to parents such as myself who are already stretching to pay the fees for good qaulity nursery care. This seems to contradict the governments aims of finding more and better childcare to allow parents to go out to work.28132017-03-31T11:49:58.6114458Ajay NandaThis increase makes no sense! Council nurseries are full & parents need quality private nurseries. Increasing their business rates will directly adversely affect children's quality of care! 28132017-03-31T15:17:37.34714459Verity MutchA generation should mean a generation. MS Sturgeon is totalling ignoring over 50% of the Scottish electorate and needs to move on and concentrate on the day job27732017-03-31T21:00:36.78714460R.WilliamsPlease you people in Scotland stop FM from ruining your country with her obsession for another referendum27732017-04-01T19:33:00.78714461Sara PaulWhile I am concerned about the effect of the tap water on the immediate health of the community, I am also concerned about the long term effect of chloramination. 28092017-04-02T01:16:41.5914462Todd Bartley Although I have been born and bred in England I believe that we must remain united. I think Scotland play a big role in terms of LandmassEconomyTourism Military \r\n\r\nI also think that if Scotland leave the UK we will loose our global power status. Furthermore I think if Scotland votes for independence their economy won't be stable without lots of loans if the EU,that's if they successfully obtain membership. I was very glad when I saw Scotland voted No 2 and a half years ago and I think Nicola Sturgeon is breaking her once in a life time statement 27732017-04-02T10:16:05.32714463keith jollyHad enough of referendums Nicola has lost the plot and not listening to the Scottish people27732017-04-03T17:45:25.33314464Alistair McKelvie Childcare Businesses such as Nureserys are a first step education and social development of our youngest children. There facilities should not be liable to taxes such as BR , Vat, etc etc.28132017-04-03T18:14:05.24714465Pamela Anderson I think it's ridiculous putting up prices. 28132017-04-03T18:48:08.23314466Gemma ScottWe have to buy bottled water and have done for years as the water tastes awful.28092017-04-03T18:56:37.61714467Emma MillerI am half Scottish, half English. I was born in Scotland but was ordinarily resident in England prior to my degree in Edinburgh. Neither Student Awards Association for Scotland, nor Student Finance England will finance my Diploma in Legal Practice. Should I not be able to raise the £7000 with additional living costs my degree in Scots Law will be rendered useless in the pursuit of what it was intended. I fully intend to remain in Scotland and to contribute to society, but may have to reconsider this. I feel as though I am being punished for living in England prior to my degree.27922017-04-03T21:27:17.47314468Hazel HomesNursery Fees are expensive enough and if business rates go up, fees will likely go up too. It's not fair on the working parents.28132017-04-04T11:16:46.4914469Amanda EdwardsThe increase in rates has high potential to make childcare unaffordable for working families.28132017-04-04T14:20:42.85714470S. Lorimer This is going to cripple small business holders.28132017-04-04T15:05:07.814471Ninahow we will be able to pay for a nursery then?? almost whole of my pay is covering nursery fees anyway....28132017-04-04T17:44:14.59714472J.PaulNursery fees are already extortionate for working parents,this increase in rates will mean nursery fees will be increased to help cover rates. 28132017-04-04T18:26:56.07714474Amy DreweryIf business rates increase for nurseries they will simply put the increase onto us, we spend nearly a whole wage on fees as it stands but can't afford not to have both incomes, we can't afford an increase28132017-04-04T18:38:36.56314475Jennifer KerrThis cost will have to be passed on to all the working families who have also just received council tax increases and increases to our electricity rates. 28132017-04-04T19:32:00.0714476Lesley My nursery fees are double what I pay for my mortgage. Please do not make us have to pay any more in order for us to return to work!28132017-04-04T19:59:24.90314478Grant DavisI was skeptical about this but now find my children and some friends have also developed skin rashes. How can this be acceptable in the UK?28092017-04-04T20:30:53.92714479TristanPeople won't be able to afford to go back to work. Small businesses will vanish. 28132017-04-04T20:49:49.44314480Michala BradshawChildcare is already a huge cost for working parents. To incur further tax costs will stretch families further making our cost of living less affordable and potential to work less of an option. 28132017-04-04T21:39:25.10314481Kathryn SuttieThis increase will make private nursery care unaffordable for working parents, and undermine early years' education for children. 28132017-04-04T21:59:06.78314482Norma McFarlaneSave these small businesses they are vital to our families28132017-04-05T02:09:54.92314483L.WThe proposed increase in rates will result in nurseries increasing their fees therefore childcare will become unaffordable for working families, resulting in families having to give up work as they will not be able to afford the child care to allow the parents to work and provide for their family. Like many working parents the vast majority of my salary is spent on nursery fees. 28132017-04-05T07:29:01.47314484Laura BrahamIncreasing expenses for nurseries and childcare facilities will just mean that those increases will be passed on to families already struggling to meet high childcare costs. In addition, already low paud nursery staff will suffer as wages would be unlikely to rise as a result and nurseries woukd find it even harder to afford resources. Again this cost would be passed to families either directly through fees rising or through needing to fundfraise or pay for additional resources or services for their child. 28132017-04-05T07:56:49.0414485Rebecca McLeanEverything must be done to keep childcare affordable to provide families with options about going back to work if they want to. 28132017-04-05T08:14:26.05714486Margaret Malcolm Good childcare from the earliest stage will determine the future potential of the child. Helps parents return to work without fear for their child. It must be affordable. 28132017-04-05T08:42:59.1914487Paul MorrisHave been on bottled water for 2 years now - will not even use it to brush my teeth28092017-04-05T10:06:07.3314488Denise Camilleri Child care fees are high enough, this is just going to put childcare fees higher and further effect working parents 28132017-04-05T14:31:35.9614489alastair carruthhow did the Scottish Government not see this coming??!!28132017-04-05T17:27:10.29714490HelenSoon parents wont be able to work due to rising costs in childcare as their fees will probably increase to assist business rates impact. 28132017-04-05T17:29:38.40314491gus carnegieWhy are there no MSPs or councillors on the board of Scottish Water. There is no democratic link between consumers and the company. Also there is no one on the board with experience of a large number of consumers. 28092017-04-05T19:29:15.34314492Patricia HewittI moved to Scotland nearly twenty years ago from England and have watched the horrendous decline in services . I have had first hand experience of the shocking state of CAMHS , the NHS and Education System. The SNP only interest is Independence. They have turned Catholic and Protestant , Scots and English against one another. I have never been a member of a Political Party in my life but after the inspirational support I have received from the Lib Dems I have joined one now . They do care about Scotland . SNP hang your heads in shame . We would have been bankrupt we decided on Independence, with massive loans . Brexit is being used as a smoke screen to cover up the truth about Public Services . Anyone's fault but the SNP.27732017-04-06T01:14:15.79714493LYDIA REID I could never wish harm to the people of England but neither do I believe that we must stay in a union that is keeping Scotland from growing and improving \r\n\r\nGood luck to you but we must take our independence 27732017-04-06T03:46:01.55314494Jonathan BruneauA stated and key Scottish and UK Government aim is to increase the standard of preschool education and make child care costs affordable. Headlines talk about 30 hours of 'free' care (not possible at present funding rates). It's an example of government underfunding and manipulating the sector for its own ends. In addition, nurseries are the play thing of education and care regulators who impose top down requirements, often changed annually, which impose unsustainable costs on nurseries (think the requirement for all staff to be in training and Managers to achieve a BA, all for the same low wages!). The net result is a loss of considerable experience and a new staffing compliment mainly under 25. All the 'Mrs Doubtfire's' have gone or will leave once illconceived regs work their way through the system. Preschool care cannot offer its services at affordable rates for parents without a cohesive government plan which involves itself, HMRC, the local council, the regulator (CARE Inspectorate or Ofsted), education providers etc. Presently, all the above organisations exact 'their pound of flesh' from the sector through taxes, charges, regulation etc. The increase in Council Taxes for the sector (on some sites by 100%+) will need to be passed on to parents putting further pressure on affordability and the viability of an already much manipulated industry. Universal Preschool creates the citizens of the future. It sets them on the right path in life. However, it cannot be provided privately at a level affordable to ALL without government subsidy. This should be joined up, cohesive and not constantly tampered with by government individuals, groups and organisations who have not 'joined the dots'. If you want a glorified child minding service because your aim is to get people back to work then regulate it accordingly, concentrating on care not education. If you want care, education and higher standards the industry needs more funding not higher taxes!\r\n28132017-04-06T09:55:08.94714496LynseyThe water in Kingussie has been really poor28092017-04-06T09:57:51.08714497Gordon LawrieWater taste in the Cairngorm national park, one of the jewels in Scotlands tourist industry, is awful, especially in the badenoch area.28092017-04-06T10:19:28.00714498robyn donaldsonas i working parent i struggle with nursery fees as it is with out it going up any more28132017-04-06T11:50:51.07314499Kirsten PhillipsI already spend the best part of my salary on childcare. My child's nursery is fantastic. If I can't afford nursery then my husband or I will have to give up work and become another statistic of Benefits Britain28132017-04-06T11:56:19.5214500Vicky mcdowellAny increase in cost greater than 5% will make working not worthwhile. 28132017-04-06T11:58:27.914501Louise plattWorking families can not afford a price rise in childcare.28132017-04-06T12:30:17.6214502Elizabeth HoggIncreased demand on the childcare sector has already seen a massive financial setback, business rates are just another nail in the coffin. Something will have to be done soon before we end up in a real medley from which a return will be highly unlikely and too late.28132017-04-06T13:19:09.89714503B DevlinInconsistent approach to the delivery of childcare in this country. No consideration to the business owners or parents who have to pay the fees.28132017-04-06T13:42:04.06714504John-PaulIn no uncertain terms, this is a joke. Tax nurseries and indirectly, tax working parents (Because that's who'll pay for this). Put nurseries out of business, pushing up prices and making it impossible for some people to work, and reduce families' disposable incomes.\r\n\r\nGenius. Nice one. "Right kids, no more 5 a day, I'm afraid it's square sausages for breakfast, lunch and dinner.28132017-04-06T13:47:57.83714505Marjorie RobsonExempting Private Sector Nurseries from Business Rates would certainly help businesses to ensure future sustainability in the face of the challenges of 1140 hours. At the present moment the fees for non-funded 0 - 3 year olds are effectively subsidising the 'funded' 3 and 4 year olds in our Nursery because the local authority does not pay the actual cost of our Early Learning and Childcare provision. 28132017-04-06T14:12:23.27314506John T LauderMy average rates increase across my business is in the order of 75%. How can the government justify such a hefty increase when the whole city is currently struggling to make ends meet! this is a disgrace!!28132017-04-06T14:28:55.24314507Suzy H84.5% increase in commercial rates today, also to factor in pensions and living wages increases all without increasing fees to ensure I have a full nursery!28132017-04-06T14:45:25.9214508Marion Barker It makes absolutely no sense at all to increase these rates which along with other rising costs will force some nurseries to close at a time when the government wants to increase the provision - this will not be possible without private nurseries. Quality early years care and education is already far too expensive for most families in this country and the only way for private nurseries to survive is to pass the cost onto parents - many of them will not be able to afford this. This will be the end for many settings.....how does this benefit the children and parents who will struggle to find care , or the nursery staff who will loose their jobs. Please reconsider this before the sector disappears entirely 28132017-04-06T15:12:12.34314509Pamela GordonThe government need to help working parents with affordable childcare, putting up business rates only makes the whole cost of childcare worse as the increase in rates will need to be moved onto the end users which are the parents28132017-04-06T15:38:54.63314510Iain ArthurMy partners entire part-time wage covers nursery childcare, something we deem a vital part in our child's development. I believe the scale of these increases to not be proportionate or necessary. It will effect our position with nursery education. 28132017-04-06T15:40:20.27714511Anne SmithHow are we supposed to offer affordable childcare if our rates are so high?28132017-04-06T15:46:42.27714513Amanda Wallace DavidsonAs a small nursery owner, whose business rates are more than doubling, this is going to have a significant effect on our business. On top of the economic struggles we are experiencing right now in Aberdeen and the north east of Scotland due to the oil crisis, many businesses in my area (including nurseries) will find it very difficult to continue operating. Factor in that we are not allowed to claim back VAT like other businesses, and our maximum number of customers (income) and minimum staffing levels (our biggest expense) are tightly controlled, the only way we can increase our income is by passing on the costs to the parents and increasing fees which will make it difficult for families to afford. 28132017-04-06T15:53:58.2114514SharonThe amount of rates is horrendous, make childcare affordable, putting up rates will be filtered back through childcare fees to parents, making it harder for parents to afford childcare. I currently pay £150 per week and earn a fraction more than this!28132017-04-06T16:43:50.63714515LizScandal picking on child care28132017-04-06T16:46:58.9414516Hazel Farquhar The Scottish Government are really letting working parents down! 28132017-04-06T17:25:49.81714517Irene TudorThe only people not making the minimum wage will be the owners of the small private nurseries28132017-04-06T17:28:12.14314518Frances ArmitHow can we operate a nursery business under such constraints as this. As a private nursery we are not subsidised by the government and cannot meet the challenges at the moment.28132017-04-06T17:42:15.55314519Sandra DohertyPrivate nurseries are under enough financial pressure without having to pay out even more in BR. The Government need to do something now to stop this happening .28132017-04-06T17:44:38.28714520clive kempThis 'Tax' on children's education needs to be abolished.28132017-04-06T17:49:20.9314521LindaThe central government is pushing up business rates but the deputy first minister's promise of free childcare is pushing up the fees. 28132017-04-06T17:53:28.2414522Imogen willIf our nursery is forced to close I will not be able to work. I'm self employed so my business would fold. . How dose this help the economy?28132017-04-06T18:15:23.40714523Claire MorrisonI thought the government want people to work. If I was unable to afford childcare then I would be another unemployed person in society and I personally need to work for my wellbeing. I am contemplating having another child however if childcare becomes unaffordable then this undoubtedly will not be a possibility for me 28132017-04-06T18:36:13.8414524Nicola HamiltonIt just doesn't balance well for all parties. Childcare needs to be affordable and of excellent quality. By doing this small will struggle and even close meaning parents choices for the best nursery is limited. Some of these small nurseries are excellent and it will be a loss for children, as we all know the early years are vital in shaping their future. 28132017-04-06T18:41:26.31714527Laura nisbet Nursery schools do a great & are not able to pay staff enough for what they do 28132017-04-06T18:53:36.55314528Christine shand The business rates increase will impact on the families with regards increases in fees which will put a strain on the future of children's education if they can't afford to sent their children to nursery and there is also a real possibility that jobs could be lost as a result of trying to meet these preposterous demands. End these rates NOW!!28132017-04-06T18:57:57.3514529Stacey MylesMy partners Nursery had the rates increased by 170% meaning the monthly requested payments are financially unmanageable without increasing fees and effecting families. 28132017-04-06T19:05:16.5814530Teri DevineThe increase in rates is ripping the heart out of every town, city and village across the country. Small businesses cannot survive with the increase of business rates. I have had this years notification to increase my nursery premises rates by 170% which will in turn have to mean a restructure of fees for families. 28132017-04-06T19:08:17.3314531AmandaHow are small private nursery's that are not government fund going to be able to provide affordable childcare.28132017-04-06T19:34:39.6314532Amanda Steven The private nursery where we send our son has been hit and think it's a disgrace. They need more support as this has an effect on children's education long term. I have already written a complaint to Scottish government regarding the free childcare system which is a shambles and doesn't consider many factors. Working parents rely heavily on private nurseries as the service provided is far more than the council nurseries in many ways. 28132017-04-06T19:41:04.80314533Kerry Allan This is not acceptable given that many many "small businesses" make far more profit than nurseries which the cost for many parents is the make or break for returning to work after having children. This should seriously be re considered. 28132017-04-06T20:10:14.92314534Susan MackieFamilies are already being crippled by fees this will just make it worse at a time where more than 50% im most cases of salary is already going in fees 28132017-04-06T20:29:42.07714535Deborah TaitOur water tastes chemical and my girls, who are teenagers and have never had skin complaints, have both developed eczema over the last two years.28092017-04-06T20:50:19.214536MelissaHow does this help families that try to work!28132017-04-06T21:05:40.08714537StuartMaybe the SNP should get a grip of this rather than chasing unwanted referendums.28132017-04-06T21:07:37.3514538Joanne Expecting nurseries to pay a 140% increase in rates is ridiculous 28132017-04-06T23:43:37.8214539Lisa SangsterOne parent will not be able to work due to lack of childcare because it will become unaffordable, staff will lose their jobs & local businesss & communities will therefore suffer. Such a shame for business owners & staff who build up years to succeed with qualifications & experience, for it to end because of business rates... 28132017-04-07T06:54:26.72714540Mrs Christine AndersonThese rates are ridiculous, how are we as parents expected to return to work when it will be impossible to put our children to nursery due to the fee's being even higher than they already are. I thought the government we suppose to support people returning to work, not to make It the most difficult thing to do. IT is absolutely ridiculous.28132017-04-07T09:23:12.7614541Crawford collinon top of increased wage costs , company pension increases this could be the final straw 28132017-04-07T09:46:16.79714542Carol BurnsSHOCKING 28132017-04-07T09:49:39.56314543Catherine GroatStaff could lose their jobs as owners could be forced to close as they cannot afford these crippling rates.28132017-04-07T10:35:22.11714544Gillian CampbellNurseries are vital for parents returning to work and this rate increase is going to cripple them28132017-04-07T11:10:19.10714545S. StopperOur private nursery has stated that they have a 50% increase in rates. This level of rate increase for nurseries cannot be absorbed by them and will have to be passed onto the working parents which may result in it being no longer viable for both parents to work for many families. Alternatively many nurseries may be forced to close leaving parents without childcare. One nursery in my local area has already announced that it will be closing at the end of June due to the recent rate increases. I am sure there will be more.28132017-04-07T11:26:54.49714546LindaThis will make childcare unaffordable and take away parental choice. Leaving only local government nurseries and not enough spaces.28132017-04-07T11:36:25.48314547Jessica van LieshoutIncreasing business rates will affect nursery fees, resulting in increasing costs for parents28132017-04-07T12:44:50.50714548Fred EvansAnother stealth tax on the parents who have to pay for these increases!28132017-04-07T12:54:34.63314550AnonIf this results in an associated increase in nursery fees, then we will need to revisit whether it still makes sense for my wife and I to both be working. It may make more financial sense for one of us to stop working. Doesn't seem to jive with the government's promises around affordable childcare and encouraging working families.28132017-04-07T13:09:33.79314551KevinAn increase in 3% last year and an increase in 5% this year. The price of child care is already ridiculous! Some people don't even get a salary to live on as much as I pay in child care! Where does it end!28132017-04-07T13:17:59.8114552Donna ChristieThis is closing businesses and making returning to work uneconomical for parents. 28132017-04-07T13:21:24.714553SarahSoon Mothers (and some Fathers) will have to stop working as childcare is becoming very unaffordable.28132017-04-07T14:37:46.33714554Julie BilslandNursery fees are crippling us at this current time28132017-04-07T14:42:17.1514555Alex JohnstonNurseries are not like other businesses and regular business rates should not apply to them.28132017-04-07T15:26:05.6714556Gayle millarRenfrewshire nurseries have been in discussion with Scottish government since the announcement of the 1140 hours. As a private provider we will not be able to operate and be in partnership with our local council Tender-ship (if you can call it that!) when we rely so much on wraparound costs to operate our business . 28132017-04-07T15:44:23.61314557Ailsa PuckrinChildcare and Education should be exempt from rates without question.28132017-04-07T15:50:18.36314558Alan WallaceIt is unacceptable for the Scottish Government to expect small businesses to be able to afford the huge increases in rates especially as the nursery business is so heavily regulated and cannot reduce their staff numbers without affecting the number of children they can accept.28132017-04-07T16:00:21.614559Vanessa Childcare is already far too expensive. 28132017-04-07T16:05:10.6314560RhonaAs a private nursery provider we are already struggling against the rates that the council provide, this is yet another step to make our job harder28132017-04-07T16:35:00.1514561C G WoodNursery fees are extortionate as it is so to add an increase in the business rates to these establishments ultimately means it has to be passed on to the families as an increase in the fees which is proving difficult to justify and very difficult to pay.28132017-04-07T16:40:16.99714562Frank AnarfiThis will undoubtedly impact on early child education, which is a key manifesto pledge of SNP. So reconsider please. 28132017-04-07T16:47:43.58714563Beverley Notman Any increase in rates is going to be difficult for everyone. The small business and working families 28132017-04-07T16:53:18.52714564Suzanne CampbellNursery fees are expensive already and parents are going to have to take the hit for these business rate increase28132017-04-07T17:12:3014565LucyNursery fees are high enough for working parents. If you put the rates up there is a good chance our fees will increase.28132017-04-07T17:34:28.62714566Emma Childcare is already a huge cost for working families so increasing prices will force many parents to stop work.28132017-04-07T17:37:39.31314567Lorna B MackayI am so concerned and upset with the water quality here. We moved to this beautiful part of Scotland just over a year ago and for the most part, suffer from terrible skin problems. I am just so dismayed with this situation, skin problems have a huge negative impact on quality of life. The consequences will indeed be costing the Health Service a great deal.28092017-04-07T17:58:59.58314568ColinThis is going to drive small businesses to the wall Crazy28132017-04-07T18:23:07.20714569Lyndsey ClarkPrivate nurseries are a crucial partner in the delivery of early years education in Scotland. It is in the interests of all that these vital businesses are supported to deliver their contribution to society and that they are able to cover costs and pay a living wage to staff and invest in their properties and gardens as learning environments for our young children. 28132017-04-07T19:54:54.23314570Kelly cunninghamHow will anyone be able to pay for nursery? It's a struggle as it is 28132017-04-07T20:29:53.214571Donna GairnsWhile I am all for small businesses paying their way and contributing through rates, I believe that private nurseries should not be included in this. Without good reasonably priced childcare, the economy will suffer as it will be far too expensive for parents to work! And since local authority childcare doesn't have the capacity or flexibility to provide childcare for many families it's down to the private sector to do this. 28132017-04-07T21:11:33.3714572Nicola koszowskiChildcare will become too expensive for most families who can just afford it at the present time.28132017-04-07T21:20:32.9514573Graham McEwanDo the right thing for the benefit of the kids.28132017-04-07T21:25:08.3514574LynseyWith 2 children in full time childcare if this forces our nursery to increase fees I may be forced to give up work. Nursery fees are our highest monthly outgoing at the moment.28132017-04-07T21:41:23.8914575David Burke The rising cost of child care is a scandal, 28132017-04-07T21:44:11.88314576Daniel CheshireStarted Getting Skin Problems about 2,3 Yrs ago very itchy red patches can pop up any where no family history of eczema or any other skin complaint 28092017-04-07T21:45:38.4614577Jean brodieShocking28132017-04-07T21:58:33.0514578Anne CheshireLived here all my life water used to a pleasure to drink not any more and what this stuff growing in my kettle only seen this on holiday in England never here what's going on 28092017-04-08T07:36:36.65314579Debbie HaldenSupport for nursery 28132017-04-08T08:45:09.64714580JulieOur nursery fees are one of our largest out goings if they increase I will have to stop working which is then one less physiotherapist in the nhs28132017-04-08T09:01:07.99314582Stuart macdonaldWhat the Government are doing is outrageous, considering families struggle enough as it is to work and keep their children in safe learning environments, whilst they do.28132017-04-08T11:51:12.57314583Linda DavidsonWorking parents are vital to the economy. Extra business in Scotland is shameful, it leaves nurseries and other businesses to increase rates which many parents can't afford, working parents receive little help as it is. Please do something to stop this rise or you will be pushing working parents to stop working and claiming benefits, that will really help the economic status of Scotland..28132017-04-08T16:08:29.72314585Nicole wheatleyThis will only discourage English students from wanting to study the Scottish LLB and puts them at an unfair disadvantage. 27922017-04-08T16:48:35.08314586Gordon DownieI really think the Nursery Rates should be reduced significantly.28132017-04-08T21:18:30.41714587Katie SutherlandChildcare should be a priority. It's an essential, not a luxury for Scotland's economy28132017-04-09T08:41:42.6114588N J CookeEnd this racist discrimination against English students.27922017-04-09T11:11:35.28714589KathyNurseries will c!ose and this will mean mums and dads will have to give up working because of no child care. Unemployment figures will rise as a result28132017-04-09T23:32:41.5914590PhilipIt's absolutely key for child care to be affordable. Important for equality and crucial for family budgets and peace of mind.28132017-04-10T07:06:13.87314591Kenneth ArchboldIm sure the SNP will continue to produce excuses for not allowing this to happen but we have to try to end this discrimination.27922017-04-10T09:00:59.77714592Judith rankinI think it's a disgrace that early yrs in nurserys is potentially being compromised because of greed. 28132017-04-10T09:12:28.81714593sylwiaWhy sector who allows parents to work and women to be in employment is punished at the end . Only private nursury right now providing care for little one which suits working families and children . 28132017-04-10T11:29:31.01314594Victoria yet again taxing the people who contribute to society and the economy to make up for the people who won't and don't 28132017-04-10T11:53:07.9414595SindraYou are giving the perfect reason as to why parents are actually better of staying home and not working and collecting benefits - How does this benefit society, or even more how does this give a child the best start in life??!28132017-04-10T13:24:34.98314596Mhari RobinsonIf you want to tackle equality look directly at what you can do to make childcare in Scotland more affordable for women. Please do not make childcare more expensive - which is exactlywhat this increase in rates will do. 28132017-04-10T13:30:57.13314597Steve mckenna This is crippling small buissiness and will have a adverse effect on childcare services 28132017-04-10T13:42:15.21314598Dan TredinnickUnaffordable.28132017-04-10T14:30:53.63314599Roberta TaylorAs the owner of a nursery employing 40 staff, the increase will have to be passed to the parents etc as we are just surviving at the moment and cannot afford this increase.28132017-04-10T17:04:20.72314600Wendy MilneOverheads kill private nurseries. Monies need to be spent on improving rates of pay for nursery staff. 28132017-04-10T17:52:04.6614601Pamela BlackEducation empowers - gives us opportunity, inspiration and equity for all - this is our future - your future - your legacy ! 28132017-04-10T20:21:38.92714602DeniseShocking to yet again increase childcare costs for working families! The rates go up fees go up to cover! How can Edi have such a big jump?28132017-04-10T20:32:59.81714603Gill MacAskillDisgraceful - nursery fees are heavy enough.for parents 28132017-04-10T20:37:54.96714604VeronikaI can not see any logic in increasing business rates for the nurseries...It is a social sector. There are Business rates reliefs for disabled, for charities, etc. Why, when there is such a gap between wraparound childcare available and the demand for it - there is no relief for those, who do provide this service, who do look after children and giving them a best start in their life, whilst their mums and dads are working with a peace of mind and pay their tax?28132017-04-10T21:04:05.20314605Jaffar HamoudiChild care costs in the U.K. are already the highest in the western world so hard pressed workers no parents can't afford another rise. The Scottish government needs to urgently step in to prevent this unfair which many hard pressed working parents can't afford. 28132017-04-11T07:42:48.88714606Carol StirratFees are expensive enough as it is. It hardly makes it worthwhile working. 28132017-04-11T08:46:17.13714607Russell MainThe early years of child development are so important, we put our kid in nursery two half days because of this despite it being very expensive. For rates to go up because of where the school is located is terrible and not considering that it's a nursery shoes the system is broken28132017-04-11T09:04:59.05314608Sine MunroNurseries are incredible expensive to run and therefore the cost of using them is already on the brink of being unaffordable. It already costs £100 a day to send my 2 to nursery and we have a modest income. Any increase to nursery fees would mean that I would be forced to give up my part time business to care for my children at home full time. That can't be good for the economy! 28132017-04-11T12:16:42.1614609Maureen moir Unaffordable , will have to be passed onto parents fees . Ridiculous 28132017-04-11T12:33:54.5114610Lyndsay GrantGiven the Scottish Goverment is pushing for more emphasis on childcare development and an attempt to cut down on alcohol consumption, I am at a complete loss to understand why licensed premises are being given preferential treatment with their rates being discounted, yet childcare establishments in general are facing massive rises in rates. As a small business owner this will have a detrimental effect on my business. Clearly the Scottish Giverment is not prioritising childcare education!28132017-04-11T12:43:20.5914611Gary AndersonGiven the Scottish Governments pledge to be the best place to raise children it is telling that pubs have their rates capped but childcare providers who educate the future of our country are subject to huge business rates increases. This will have to be passed on to parents who already have to pay a lot for childcare.28132017-04-11T13:22:08.18714612KatieSignificant fee increase passed to parents this year due to business rates increase. This makes it very difficult to working parents. Even on a good salary it makes me question whether it is worthwhile continuing 28132017-04-11T13:38:47.78714613Catherine GeeDon't make my child care costs prohibit me from continuing to work.28132017-04-11T14:03:50.72314615Janet McDonaldThe rising cost of the business rate is scandalous, this will affect working parents if the fees are not affordable28132017-04-11T14:40:53.05714616William The government cannot provide universal nursery provision through the public sector but wants to tax more heavily the businesses providing the childcare provision that the Scottish economy desperately needs. \r\nBizarre government. 28132017-04-11T14:53:58.714617Linn ElderThis is a tax that will punish working parents, when the nursery fees are already at a level when working often doesn't make financial sense. 28132017-04-11T16:03:03.8814618TOKONI STEVENSONTHE PROVISION OF COST EFFICIENT CHILDCARE IS DIRECTLY RELATED TO THE PROPERTY TAX ASSOCIATED WITH CHILDCARE FACILITIES. cHARITIES PAY NO COUNCIL TAX BUT NUSEREYS SERVE THE WORKING POPULATION AND FAMILIES28132017-04-11T16:05:16.06714619PAUL STEVENSONCHILDCARE COSTS NEED TO REDUCED TO HELP MOVE TOWARDS BETTER EMPLOYMENT UPTAKE AMONGST PARENTS28132017-04-11T18:12:12.53714620Rebecca GossNursery fees have already risen substantially to accommodate (albeit extremely important) living wage and national minimum wage increases and also pensions auto enrolment costs. Parents simply cannot afford to pay more for hugely expensive childcare and it makes no economic sense in the longer term to have people having to absent themselves from the job market for extended periods purely on basis that they cannot afford childcare. 28132017-04-11T19:26:13.0814621Lorraine GillespieOne of our nurseries has seen a 100% increase in its annual rates bill. Unaffordable. Will need to be passed onto parents in full.28132017-04-11T20:03:30.6914622Richard Watsonit makes no sense whatsoever. More parents will not be able to afford nursery fees meaning nurseries will suffer as well as parents. We'll see more single income households which means any gains made by bumping rates will be lost to diminished income tax from families.28132017-04-11T20:36:01.77714623Catherine WilsonIt's all about education - so said the SNP !!!!!!\r\nHow is this huge increase supposed to help ? 28132017-04-11T21:00:19.52714624Paul WilsonThis yet another tax raising issue to pay for the Government (SNP) policies aimed at securing votes from lower income families using promises than they cannot afford, at the same time putting smaller succeesful businesses at risk. Costs are passed on the hard working middle class families who are already experiencing high taxation than other parts of the UK. 28132017-04-11T21:25:20.09314625Colin JohnstonThe proposed rates hike is excessive and will threaten the viability of nurseries. Good quality nurseries are already at a premium. They are responsible employers, valuable educators, and dedicated carer's. They provide a service that enables parents to participate in the economy with peace of mind. They have a greater than face value and their loss would have implications for many.28132017-04-11T22:50:37.68714626Kerry McNeil The resulting increase in nursery fees will mean it is not worth many parents going to work! All this chat about increasing free nursery hours in direct contradiction to this28132017-04-11T23:10:31.87314627Sarah IstedChildcare is unaffordable as it is. You want parents to go back into the workplace but you make it impossible for nurseries to run sustainably, to a high standard with no money?28132017-04-11T23:21:44.85714628myra andersonUnaffordable28132017-04-11T23:25:31.40714629Caroline HamidWorking parents struggle to pay for the best child care possible. This change would lead to severe hardship for many. Or 1 parent staying at home to take care of the child and due to only having 1 salary would likely be entitled to income support. No savings there. Only hardship and stress for all. 28132017-04-11T23:55:11.85714630CdI am not earning after childcare and transport fees as it is.. please stop any further increases , we the squeezed middle can not cope! I will be forced not to work 28132017-04-12T06:50:16.69714631Megan BraithwaiteWhile I understand the govt has provided provision for free childcare for 3 & 4 year olds in Scotland, in reality this is not accessible due to oversubscription, lack of facilities who run this and the completely unworkable 3 hours a day over 5 days being offered instead of flexibility (or offering 2 7 hour days) which would allow mothers to actually return to work. So privately funded nurseries are all that's left for working mothers and these are already ridiculously expensive, meaning what little wages I get is almost all taken by nursery fees. Raising this would make it even more prohibitive and seriously lead me to reconsider whether I can afford to work. Please don't do this, or enable the funded place to be more useable and universal instead.28132017-04-12T07:41:0214632Sara-Jane MackayThis is not only crippling for small businesses but will have a knock on effect on childcare costs for working families.28132017-04-12T07:43:53.56314633Emily WilliamsIf the increase is passed on to parents, it means that parents will be effectively priced out of the workplace. 28132017-04-12T08:29:22.03714634L FlemingTo increase the rates on nurseries is to directly tax the working family, l was under the impression that this was not what this Government was promising?28132017-04-12T09:35:3214635StaceyShocking!28132017-04-12T13:35:48.23714636Rizwan SaeedIncrease will have to be passed to working parents. We deliver a key service that allows parents to go work and provide a better quality of life for children. Day nurseries should be either exempt like schools or at least substantial relief should be made available28132017-04-12T16:35:10.45714637Irene BaillieMy petition so I have to sign 28232017-04-12T16:51:31.55714639Sukanya nagarajan I wish her petition should be considered and she should be given justice. As a good friend, I would wish her to stay strong and hope for bright future waiting ahead28232017-04-12T16:54:04.0714640Julie-Anne wightman The law needs to change so people can live there life's without feeling threatened and and worried if anything might happened to them and not love a life of fear 28232017-04-12T17:08:23.94314641HelenGood luck Irene, after all your hard work I hope you receive the support you deserve. 28232017-04-12T17:16:07.5114642Eileen BrownAbuse of any kind is intolerable. It can take many forms. Mental or psychological can in fact be worst.The abuser can seen likeable charming and considerate but changes behind door. Physical abuse is evident. Not so mental. Need to be greater support and protection for victims, urgently. 28232017-04-12T17:29:13.07314643sarah macraeTo stop ppl thinking it's ok to send abusive texts and thinking that there isn't any consequences 28232017-04-12T17:36:04.37314644sarah macraehope this works so people dont think they can get away with sending abusive texts and get away with it!28232017-04-12T17:50:05.5814645Lynne KirbyHope you get loads of signatures Irene 28232017-04-12T18:27:10.8614646KennyGood luck with it!28232017-04-12T18:34:51.63314647Alyne DuthieMost neuroscientists no longer subscribe to the view that antidepressants correct any kind of serotonin imbalance and yet GPs are still keen to promote this view. Side effects from psychoactive drugs like antidepressants and benzodiazepines can lead to chronic ill health and too many of us struggle to find the help we need to taper and in the withdrawal period after. Recognition for the severe symptoms that can arise in withdrawal from these drugs which can be both brutal and protracted lasting in some cases months or years is long overdue. The medicalisation of the problems of society is causing untold harm to thousands and it is time we placed greater value on alternatives to this medical model. 28452017-04-12T18:37:52.97314648Sharon CarterGood Luck! 28232017-04-12T18:39:19.91314649Billy McClellandGood luck on this Irene, hopefully it's successful and protects others so they don't go through what you had to.28232017-04-12T18:41:22.16314650Karen HootonThe government want the best place to grow up to be Scotland, that means having good quality childcare (they are our future workers after all), fees parents pay should go on paying the staff a good wage to provide exceptional care not more money for the government. 28132017-04-12T18:52:08.7914651Nathalie LavalleeI have been injured by benzo long term use and withdrawal. 36 months off and still disable..\r\nThis must stop!28452017-04-12T19:06:14.91314652Jennifer JacksonKnow there's SO many out here suffering like myself due to benzos and the lack of knowledge on how to safely taper off of them.I have been in complete bedridden hell since coming off of them cold turkey.Was unable to even read or write for months or process words people would say to me.I had 100s of insane symptoms from head to toe.I feel brain damaged by it and i can't believe they don't warn people about these drugs!28452017-04-12T19:07:53.71314653Gary Skriba I've lost the best of 21 years to benzodiazepines always taken as directed. I was never warned about the horrible danger of taking it longer than 2 to 4 weeks. I am still very much disabled 45 months after ashton taper. This needs to stop! 28452017-04-12T19:16:12.16314654Lindsay LauermanSigned28452017-04-12T19:32:47.05714655Tracy StewartHere's hoping this is successful28232017-04-12T19:38:53.65314656Rachel HewittFor many families nurseries are the only option to allow parents to work and earn money to keep their families afloat. The cost is already so high, sending more than one child is not a viable option as it would negate many salaries including my own. Childcare facilities should be exempt of these extra charges.28132017-04-12T19:39:34.214657AidaI've been hurt by Xanax, Klonopin here in the US. Still tapering in April of 2017. 28452017-04-12T19:52:29.49714658Chloe connellSigned28232017-04-12T19:59:43.76314659Lee-Jane BrashGood luck Irene.28232017-04-12T21:29:52.21314660Maria clarkThe law needs to change, good luck Xx28232017-04-12T21:31:44.76714661CarolynGood luck x28232017-04-12T21:33:54.2214662Ann proudfootGood luck 28232017-04-12T21:38:30.15314663Georgina Jones I was prescribed zopiclone sleeping tablet for five weeks and became dependant and it took five months of hell to wean off28452017-04-12T22:19:53.55314664F WallaceI object as the increase will be passed onto parents.28132017-04-13T03:24:05.714666Jan Murphy These are dangerous drugs. I was prescribed a Benzo for sleep by a pulmonary clinic nurse. \r\n The pamphlet from the pharmacy only said may cause drowsiness or dizziness. I didn't even stay that was a benzodiazepine or the fact that dependency with her and that would be so difficult to get off this. My life has changed because of this nasty drug. I never took more than prescribed, actually less than prescribed. My withdrawal had been difficult and painful. 28452017-04-13T03:58:22.7414667Linda FredrickAs a provider of Wellness Coaching and Recovery services I can attest to the fact that many physicians are freely prescribing highly addictive prescription drugs to individuals for minor issues which could be addressed with much less problematic options and without providing the proper due diligence such as addiction education or medication safety plans. \r\nAfter individuals have found themselves in the shame filled position of being addicted, scared and embarrassed, these same physicians are dumping them with an attitude of blame to the patient and unwillingness to be a part of the solution to the problem they created- claiming insufficient training. This must stop. Good people, good families and good communities are paying huge prices in blood and pain while others are benefitting financially. 28452017-04-13T08:37:45.4314668Scott mcclure People's lives , regardless of age, can be destroyed by any form of bullying or emotional abuse . Stricter laws on such things would go some way to Irene receiving a little justice 28232017-04-13T08:44:32.25714669Mairi GrantAll the best Irene 28232017-04-13T09:28:54.8914670Fiona FrenchI have sustained a brain injury as a result of tapering off the benzodiazepine, nitrazepam after forty years of taking it as prescribed for myoclonic epilepsy. I now realise that most of my health problems over the past 30 years were in fact side effects from that drug and not depression. \r\nI no longer require antidepressants after 40 years consumption as prescribed. I no longer have epilepsy. Having consulted my GP and three consultants I now realise that no doctor is willing to acknowledge in writing that my brain has been damaged as a direct result of benzodiazepine withdrawal. Some flatly deny it has anything to do with the drug despite there being no other possible explanation. I have instead been diagnosed as having depression or ME CFS or neurological functional impairment all of which serve to mask the real truth of the matter I find this totally unacceptable. Government advice to patients like me is to consult your GP. Historically benzodiazepines were prescribed to millions of patients in the UK despite mounting evidence of their addictive properties and now the same has happened with antidepressants. It is now imperative that appropriate services are provided for patients seeking to withdraw from these potentially harmful drugs to avoid long-term damage to their health. The real question is why was this situation allowed to happen again and why the lack of transparency regarding the damage done by both classes of drugs? \r\nWithout such transparency the extent of the damage can be denied by medical bodies and government alike and patients are kept in the dark about the potential harms of these drugs on the brain and central nervous system.28452017-04-13T09:39:44.2214671Suzanne CostelloThe cost if childcare is already prohibitive to many meaning people either can't afford to work or work to maintain their profession with very little pay during the first few years of their children's lives. This cost will be directly passed on to already struggling working parents.28132017-04-13T09:57:18.98714672Tracey OwensNo-one has to take this sort of abuse and no-one should be allowed to get away with it! 28232017-04-13T16:09:31.40314673Greg WhiteAs a psychotherapist with twenty years experience working with folk on psychiatric medication, I can safely say that the only thing these drugs serve in the middle and long term, is a co-dependent relationship with 'other' and as such a medical rebuttal of the medical vow to 'do no harm'.28452017-04-13T17:35:46.87714674JULIE GAMBLEI WOULD LIKE TO SEE THIS EXTENDED TO THE PRESS28232017-04-13T17:41:20.47714675Lorraine mcilwraith I'm right behind you Irene28232017-04-13T19:38:42.9314676Helen GroveMy pocket rocket. I'm so proud of you, for what you've been through and the changes that you'll bring.28232017-04-13T22:12:11.2914678Shonagh TerryI believe that good nursery care is a modern day necessity but the cost is rising all the time. It's not a viable option for many and if this goes ahead it will mean many families will feel the short term cost of mothers giving up positions altogether as it becomes economically untenable, nurseries closing with the loss of skilled nursery nurses, long term financial loss through mothers dropping out of employment and losing career advancement and employers losing staff. It's effect on the economy is also not to be underestimated as a factor here. Its a no win scenario all round.28132017-04-13T22:27:08.28714679Barbara VandeputteDeath by suicide ,Benzo withdrawal syndrome driven.28452017-04-13T22:45:50.7614681lucy mclarenChildcare costs mean that my take home pay is minimal. A rise in costs which could be passed on to parents would result in it not being viable for me to continue working. 28132017-04-13T23:50:05.14714682KatePlease inform and support people taking and tapering from benzodiazepines and antidepressants and their loved ones! It took a year before I even realized that it was benzos causing my terrifying symptoms. Then it took another year to find someone to help me taper off of them. Most doctors didn't even believe it was the benzos, others knew but, didn't want to or know how to help. 28452017-04-14T05:23:15.31314683Lofty AndersonBullying and abuse is the sign of an insecure weak entity..... It's in no way condonable and those responsible need to learn a lesson..... They can't grasp how it affects and alters people's lives..... 28232017-04-14T07:31:00.25314684NancyThese types of medications need to be closely monitored. I wish my doctor would have known that taking xanax, (I took it as perscribed) for seven years is a very dangerous thing to do. There have been many people injured. Many people have lost everything, their jobs, homes, families, dignity and self respect. Just to name a few. The drug companies know these drugs a harming people. They do not care, as they are making millions upon millions of dollars off of these drugs. Please help people who have been harmed by these drugs. So others do not have to go through what we have and suffer! 28452017-04-14T09:18:38.42314685Laura I've been prescribed an antidepressant for minor work stress. After stopping it, I got so ill that I had to stop work, my hobbies, could barely leave the house. My symptoms are similar to what people with traumatic brain injury experience. I lost my income, the state benefits ran out because no doctor is willing to give me a proper diagnosis. All of this because I trusted my GP to be well informed and not to prescribe dangerous medication. 28452017-04-14T09:23:56.81714686Chris EvansI have been through something similar, though in another part of the UK. The law must be amended to confront this sort of harassment, it does damage people's lives.28232017-04-14T15:46:41.91314689DoloresI've been in benzo hell for four years now, as my symptoms began shortly after being prescribed Ativan. I cannot believe that doctors keep prescribing this sh*t. It's decent for a couple of days, but after that its talons dig deeper into the brain, creating all sorts of havoc. The problem is that usually no one knows what's happening until the damage is done and they want to get off the drug. Shame on doctors for prescribing benzos without compunction!! "Do no harm" is NOT the case with these drugs. And many don't recognize this. They don't know how to taper a patient, yet they certainly know how to prescribe. This is dead wrong. We cannot be left to fend for ourselves. Many of us have spent our finances because we can't work. We have lost family, friends, hobbies that we once had, our lives battling this.This can't be happening ANY LONGER. PLEASE HELP!28452017-04-14T19:04:08.814690Clare ClarksonI believe that due to social media and modern technology, this kind of abuse will increase in the future. Changes must be introduced now, to protect others.\r\n28232017-04-14T19:14:58.09714691Julia SariI was prescribed a cocktail of two antidepressants and two benzodiazepines when diagnosed with anorexia nervosa at the age of 21. I trusted the field renowned expert who had given me hopes of recovery but failed to mention the well-known risks of such 'medication'. Needless to say that I became physiologically dependent without even realising it. I did manage my way out of eating disorders, resume my studies and graduate from University, but hit with 'medically unexplained exhaustion', I once again had to ask 'what is wrong with me?'. I finally questioned the medication I had been on for a decade and decided I had to come off it. Now 34, I have been tapering for over two years and a half, and have yet to go. Adding to the burden of the stigma of mental illness and psychiatric drugs, I have found no validation from medical professionals. I am on the most alienating and debilitating journey of my life with the sole support of an online community. How can this be? Sadly, my story is far from unique and can't bear to think that I will not be the last one to go through an ordeal which could be prevented through better awareness to the dangers of benzodiazepines and antidepressants. As for people who wish to withdraw safely from such drugs, dedicated support is much needed. Drug misuse organisations are absolutely not adequate for people who have become physiologically dependent on drugs taken as prescribed.28452017-04-14T21:47:18.51314692Maria lavery Good luck 28232017-04-15T00:12:34.9514694Davie ReynoldsThis change will positively affect the victims of an increasingly prevalent crime. Petition signed28232017-04-15T17:48:42.09314696Sammie DysonSigned petition 28132017-04-15T18:02:28.53314697Diane Dunsmuir I am a patient that has had significant side effects and withdrawals due to Ativan.28452017-04-15T20:07:24.47714698Katherine bailley As soon as possible 28232017-04-16T08:47:15.3414699Nick ClarkNurserys should not have to pay ridiculous high rates as they are so important to the local community. Why doesn't this government realise that if people cannot work they cannot pay their taxes and have to rely on benefits, the knock on affects are huge. It's do very expensive already.28132017-04-16T16:25:24.83314700Anthony RAJAKANIThis increase is going to affect small businesses28132017-04-16T16:27:47.8514701Douglas KnoxI hope that if the Scottish Government can introduce a business rate cap for pubs then they can offer a cap to nurseries which are doing so much good for delivering Scottish Government objectives. For example pre school education and helping the SG make Scotland the best place to bring up young children. \r\nNurseries cannot afford business rate hikes without passing them on to parents which in turn will make child care even less affordable.28132017-04-16T16:29:29.4914702John DoigGood luck. Surprised that this kind of behaviour is not already punishable by law. Time to change that I think.28232017-04-16T18:11:23.73714703Briony FisherSnp need to get this sorted or many women will have to give up work because nursery fees will be so high, they're already too high! 28132017-04-16T19:10:28.0514705S wintonThis rise in rates for nurseries is outrageous it will obviously be passed onto parents as businesses are unable to absorb such an outrageous increase. The cost of childcare in Edinburgh is already too high. The government want to encourage people to work but how can they when childcare is so expensive. Surely it is more important for rates to be capped for nurseries who provide education and not for pubs which are purely for pleasure28132017-04-16T20:26:04.18714706Bryony SmithSmall businesses such as nurseries, can't absorb these huge rises and therefore the cost will be forced onto parents, through increased childcare costs. Childcare costs are already very high, and to pass on the cost to parent, isn't fair. The rates should be reduced, not increased!28132017-04-17T07:10:13.09714707Julie DuffyFreezing nursery rates is important for working parents. We already spend £800 per month and could not afford any more. This would result in a potential loss of job.\r\nUltimately it could result in more people asking for benefits due to lack of work. 28132017-04-17T08:52:34.72714708Sonia RutherfordIt seems ridiculous to have policies which directly contradict each other - trying to boost early years provision with various funding initiatives while at the same time increasing nursery overheads to make this harder. This isn't just illogical and a blow to working parents - it's a waste of money for taxpayers to implement contradictory policies.28132017-04-17T09:17:52.75714709M SummersThe cost will no doubt be passed onto parents and this discriminates against those who cannot afford to absorb the additional cost. 28132017-04-17T09:49:09.66714710Karen cameron I completely object to the business rate increases for Scottish nurseries as this will be partly passed onto parents! 28132017-04-17T13:09:08.90314711Lynn Gaffney Nursery rates are already high enough. They can surely not increase anymore as they will be come unmanageable for lots of families. 28132017-04-17T13:53:05.65714712Joyce rutherfordThese increases are a disgrace for nurseries already under pressure to supply excellent facilities for our country's children28132017-04-17T15:55:53.34714713Laura Katie Lea woodGet this sorted28132017-04-17T15:57:26.7714714Richie wilkesThis is unfair to people who wish to continue with career28132017-04-17T18:02:59.45714715Paula Benzodiazepines need to be banned!!its a world wide epidemic growing fast.way to much suffering an no support to get off this poison 28452017-04-17T18:36:31.4214716R FallsBullying in any form, should be dealt with.28232017-04-17T19:38:21.4714717Nick Challoner Good wishes with the petition Irene 28232017-04-17T20:30:00.52714718KathyAfter taking these drugs as prescribed to help with insomnia for over a decade, I can't believe the absolute horror my life has become over the last 7 months. After tapering off this med the way my doctor told me to (actually a little slower because my throat closed up completely and I had to hold my dose for several weeks) my body went into complete shock. The pain I am in daily is immeasurable. I have actually lost the ability to walk without the use of another non-benzo muscle relaxer due to klonopin use. I was later told by other doctors that my muscle issues probably wouldn't be so severe if the doctor hadn't pulled me off the drug as quickly as she did. Doctors need to take accountability for the dangers of these drugs, allow patients to taper at their own pace, and acknowledge the damage these drugs have done to thousands of individuals, even when taken EXACTLY AS PRESCRIBED. 1 MG daily for 11 years, didn't up my dose or abuse it in any way. I now suffer because many doctors don't want to acknowledge that serious withdrawal effects can last months, or in some extreme cases, years. I want my life back!28452017-04-17T21:48:59.8914719Maria Lavery The impact of emotional abuse using any communication modality, including text and email, must not be underestimated. It is bamboozing that in English and Scottish law view burdens of proof so differently. Irene - well done for highlighting this anomaly! 28232017-04-17T22:18:16.05714720Shirley MacintoshLong overdue.28232017-04-18T09:36:43.3614721Samantha Campbell CaseyThis will directly impact on parents as the cost of increased business rates will be passed onto parents. Nurseries provide an essential service to working parents and also provide valuable pre school education. The costs are already high and should not be forced to be higher by this changed. Reduce or abolish the rates for nurseries. 28132017-04-18T12:36:03.25714722G ButcherIt seems that the nursery fee system is giving something with one hand and then taking it back with the other, the net effect of increasing business rates (that will inevitably increase the daily fees to parents) means we don't actually receive any government help towards nursery costs. This has a direct effect on how people can live their lives and the extent to which they can add to their family. It's heart breaking really.28132017-04-18T12:40:51.52314723Pamela McGowanThe cost of childcare is already prohibitive: the majority of my monthly salary already goes towards my son's nursery fees. This rates increase will be passed onto parents, and many of us will be forced to consider whether it pays to be in work or not. I don't want to be forced into giving up my hard-won career due to the inevitable price hike. Nurseries should be exempt from this increase, which is in direct contradiction to strategies aimed at getting more parents in to work.28132017-04-18T12:49:38.07714724Andrew BrownUnjustified rise in rates that significantly impact on nursery provision and working families. 28132017-04-18T14:03:09.69714726ruby ahujaIncreasing business rates will negatively impact affordability. 28132017-04-18T14:41:43.32314727DominikaThe cost of childcare is alredy above minimum wage and is creazy high! 100% of my salary is going thorwards childcare cost. Average full time childcare cost is over £1000 per month per child! If the fees are going to increase a lot of people who presently struggle to pay it will not be able to afford it and will be force to stop working. This will only increase unemployment within parents and benefits claims...28132017-04-18T17:14:46.4714728Alexander SutherlandThese new rates are a double Mammy whammy especially for the less well-off providers!\r\n28132017-04-18T17:45:37.89314729Julie BeanThere needs to be something done to help the victims for a change!28232017-04-18T17:46:16.5514730AnonI am a highly educated and very experienced healthcare professional. My two kids' nursery fees are already so high that they completely wipe out my earnings from working full time. I often wonder why I bother. Why do I miss all this precious time with my kids for literally no financial benefit? To make matters worse I work at an NHS hospital where I have to pay a small fortune to park my car. I feel like I'm being bled dry, financially and emotionally. Please, please don't make life even harder for working parents by pursuing this policy which will lead to further rises in the cost of childcare.28132017-04-18T18:09:28.89714733Kaitlin CarmichaelGood luck!28232017-04-18T20:16:49.3714734Debbie Rennie Innocent people shouldn't have to live life in fear of anyone. 28232017-04-18T21:55:02.1814735Steve FarquharWithout suitable alternatives on offer private childcare needs to be made more affordable and accessible for working families. This would have multiple knock on benefits for all parties involved - families, nursery businesses and the government. A price increase is completely contradictory to this so all those opportunities to do the right thing will be lost.28132017-04-19T07:06:41.72314736Toni HarrisComing off antidepressants gave me worse withdrawals than coming off diazepam. I found tapering just pro longed the withdrawals. I had to come off & go cold turkey as I developed tardive dystonia in my neck muscles after just 1 year of of taking several different antidepressants. I have been off them 8 weeks now & still getting terrible withdrawals. I wish I had never touched the them, they don't even work, in fact they made me worse. 28452017-04-19T09:54:50.91714737Margaret WatsonThere needs to be protection for people from this.28232017-04-19T10:12:56.99714738lesley browneThe cost of childcare is already prohibitive: the majority of my monthly salary already goes towards my son's nursery fees. This rates increase will be passed onto parents, and many of us will be forced to consider whether it pays to be in work or not. I don't want to be forced into giving up my hard-won career due to the inevitable price hike. Nurseries should be exempt from this increase, which is in direct contradiction to strategies aimed at getting more parents in to work.28132017-04-19T16:13:45.43714739Gordon CalderThe rate rises will feed thro to working parents, the nurseries will have to pass on the increase in one form or another. Electoral suicide Comes to mind.28132017-04-19T18:14:12.65714740Tom lockhartGood luck irene. hope the laws change.28232017-04-19T19:56:53.83314741Alison blackThis seems unfair & Could make private nursery even more expensive resulting in less families being able to afford this way of child care .28132017-04-19T21:13:34.1114742Andrew BuchanI find this utterly shocking and disgraceful to target hard working families in the manner they are doing,\r\nDisgusting!!!!!28132017-04-19T21:20:40.67314743Margaret StrattonI am pleased to see someone has taken the initiative here.28452017-04-19T22:26:46.6514744Donna There needs to be more protection on this and also non harassment orders. Because it seems nothing gets done to the people who breach acts, and the victims feel even worse 28232017-04-19T23:07:58.1414745Rosie ElliotIt is ridiculous that the Scottish Government talk about and write a Blue Print that continually talks about affordable, quality childcare, and still cripple us with the high cost of rates. We should pay no rates and pay our quality staff the salary they deserve. We need highly motivated, quality, effective staff. Nicola Sturgeon needs to take this on board before she introduces 1140 hours. Private nurseries will be out of business. Well done to our Scottish Government!!!!!!!28132017-04-20T13:50:23.92714746Lorraine MenziesI try my best to keep nursery fees as low as possible for parent's. I also believe staff are the most important part of a quality nursery and deserve a decent salary. Increase of rates will have a detrimental effect on parents having fees increases and staff salary affordability. 28132017-04-20T13:59:40.8514747Greta MulhallOur daughter is paying exorbitant nursery fees for our two granddaughters in Edinburgh...she cant afford them now so any increase wd be devastating.28132017-04-20T14:10:07.17714748MarieIt's about time people are held to account for their actions...28232017-04-20T14:23:05.9614749Michael PowellGrossly unfair and unhelpful28132017-04-20T14:23:08.2614750Elvera GeenCost of childcare is already prohibitive. High quality childcare should be accessible to all.28132017-04-20T15:01:19.4214751Jennifer CampbellRates are a huge monthly cost. It would be good to reduce this. Costs are handed down to Parents. With increased pre-school in 2020 there will be many private nurseries closing unless we get some help.28132017-04-20T15:04:03.7514752Linda PiriePrivate nurseries are hit hard in that unlike other businesses they CANNOT claim back VAT, they are rated higher than schools and to be suddenly faced with a massive hike of 84% is absolutely diabolical considering the government have taken many other (extremely profitable businesses) totally out of rates. It is hard working families who need full day care and it is them who will be faced with increases in fees. The government want people to work, so they should support childcare to be affordable and not TAX TAX TAX those who are working hardest to give their children a good home and family life . Private nurseries should be exempt from Rates and be made zero rated for VAT to support Good Quality affordable childcare. 28132017-04-20T15:05:09.15314753Karen RiozziI have a nursery in a rural area and keep my fees as low as possible. I have increased them only twice, for a small amount, in the past six years. I am very conscious of the struggle it is for parents to cope with rising costs. I find it a real struggle as well as my costs have kept rising at an alarming rate compared to my charges. The rates have been particularly crippling. I am at the stage where I have to decide to drastically increase the fees or just give up, which won't help anyone. The local authority also took funding away in favour of the state nurseries. My parents are waiting to hear about the Childcare Account that Nicola Sturgeon promised but it now looks like this won't be happening until 2020, which means another three years of parents missing out. The whole thing is quite demoralising.28132017-04-20T15:24:47.7114755Leanne MutchPrivate childcare is already expensive without these excessive rate rises. I thought the idea was to do more to help working families, not penalise them!28132017-04-20T15:46:07.1214756Gary HarrisonThis increase will have to be passed on to parents causing an increase in childcare costs. This will not help working parents and clearly will result in some giving up employment due to the increases as will not be financially worthwhile staying in employment.28132017-04-20T16:11:22.90314757Kellie Macleod Parents cannot afford higher nursery fees. It becomes unsustainable to work. Working parents pay taxes already so need to stop being hit twice!28132017-04-20T16:38:50.79714758Lucy Increasing the overheads faced by private sector nurseries undermines the 'principles of quality, flexibility, accessibility and affordability' that informs the Scottish Government's vision for transforming early learning and childcare, as set out in their Blueprint for 2020.28132017-04-20T17:55:04.9914759Alana FarmerI cannot believe that with the government's drive to close the attainment gap and increase childcare provision that they would not abolish the rates for nurseries altogether. \r\n\r\nThese monies do not cover refuse collection which is an additional cost or water usage. We are being hit harder than ever whilst trying to make childcare more affordable.28132017-04-20T18:38:06.9614760RachelThe cost of childcare is already expensive and with this increase a lot of hard working parents will have no option but to give up work so they can look after their children as nurseries will no longer be affordable. Cannot see any logic in this increase.28132017-04-20T19:04:49.38314762Lottie m Working parents are all ready paying enough for nursery fees which I believe are perfect to the level of care on offer without these businesses having to pass on high rates in the fees surely care provision in Scotland should be supported not punished! 28132017-04-20T23:29:22.18314763Tammy DavisChanges need to be made. Well done for standing up. 28232017-04-21T02:12:22.45314764Nicola MooreSigned28132017-04-21T09:18:18.00714765Evelyn Jones Where is justice 28232017-04-21T09:19:21.4414766Pauline DoveThis is a vital issue which needs to be addressed so that the use of these drugs and the unprecedented number of people taking them is not perpetuated by misunderstandings and re-prescribing for dependency. Medically Unexplained Symptoms is an unacceptable patient blaming exercise, for what has happened here and will only serve to exacerbate the number of people diagnosed with "mental illness - somatic disorders" whose symptoms can easily be explained as the effect of these drugs. This diagnosis needs to be removed as the convenient "excuse" it currently represents. 28452017-04-21T09:20:43.5814767Evelyn Jones Innocent people shouldn't have to live their life in fear looking over there shoulder . 28232017-04-21T09:23:58.2214768Lorraine richardsonThis needs stopping people need to live without being in fear 28232017-04-21T09:33:51.67314769Saima KiyaniI tootally agree that nurseries should not have this rates increase28132017-04-21T10:05:13.5614770Ruth DewarAt a time when the private sector nurseries are under extreme financial pressure, support by abolishing or radically reducing small business rates is essential in helping maintain viability. The private nurseries sector is an essential element in the government's plan to roll out the doubling of funded hours in the early years. Unless such financial support is given many small businesses may not survive the transition.28132017-04-21T10:41:41.7714771Sachi YamabeI am 6 years antidepressant-free and 55 months benzo-free. Withdrawal symptoms continue to be physically and mentally unbearable and unrelenting. Whether the brain and CNS damage I have sustained is permanent is equivocal. I never imagined doctors would ruin my health and then turn their backs.\r\n \r\nI was first prescribed Ativan for IBS by a family doctor 27 years ago and was never warned about any dangers. After abruptly stopping this drug many times over two years, I had worsening and new unexplained symptoms. I was eventually sent to a psychiatrist, misdiagnosed with Depression and , prescribed Zoloft and clonazepam. I was lead to believe the drugs were correcting a chemical imbalance. When I learned I had Celiac Disease, I changed my diet, felt a bit better and decided to come off the drugs once and for all, Zoloft first. For two years, unmasked benzo withdrawal, tolerance and interdose withdrawal was misidentified by the psychiatrist as Zoloft withdrawal, until someone perceptive, in an online support community for AD withdrawal, asked if I was on a benzo. I started researching, raised the dose and symptoms reduced. It was a shocking revelation. I took the Ashton Manual to the psychiatrist expecting recognition and support with a taper and it was suggested I explore my anxiety. He stopped helping me. \r\n \r\nThe dangers of benzodiazepines have been well-documented for 60 years! And we now know the same about antidepressants. Doctors, pharmacists, the medical community, policy makers, governing bodies, and governments have a moral responsibility to protect and help victims of this global iatrogenic medical disaster. Please, do what is right. 28452017-04-21T17:47:22.25714772Rachel Sutherland If nurseries are to be supported, an increase in business rates goes against this. 28132017-04-21T20:44:54.1714773Jo maunder The councils are getting richer 28132017-04-21T22:11:47.0114774Gaynor reidthis it's a disgrace , especially when we are trying to promote early years learning .private company struggle as it is usually small company's trying to do there best. If we lose these valuable childcare providers the government will really struggle to get the new increase child care hours proposed as there will not be enough Nursery's to provide this.28132017-04-22T08:43:51.87714775Elaine SagarTaking away rates and enabling us to reclaim vat on purchases would help towards the losses we face from the fixed government payments for our hourly rates 28132017-04-22T11:34:28.814776Pat Blair We need to protect innocent people at all costs28232017-04-22T12:50:07.78714777Martin CampbellWorthy of review of this scots law. 28232017-04-22T14:56:12.99714778.Margaret StewartKeep up the good work28232017-04-23T15:20:36.37714779PrzemekIt will affect nursery prices and us, users,after all. We will have to pay more for nurseries. More and more people will take a decision not to work and live on benefis as It will be a better deal than sending children to nursery. Is this going to be goverment strategy?28132017-04-23T16:03:40.0314781AnneAt 23 I had so much hope, I was from a working class background and the first child to go to University ( Exeter ) I also trained as a Teacher. The state funded my education. I went into teaching full of vision and hope. I also got married to my childhood sweetheart at the age of 20 having met him at sweet sixteen. After a year in teaching I got stressed because I was being bullied by my headteacher......also by 23 my Teacher husband was not quite so patient with this stressed individual. One day I had a full blown panic attack and went to the GP...he gave me some ' Tablets to take my headaches away' and muttered a condition called anxiety and depression....whoopee I was not going crazy this stress thing had a name....he also said I might benefit from talking to somone...This seemed an Excellent idea.......The someone was a consultant Psychiatrist...much older than me and oh so kind........but he too upped my headache tablets ( later I found it was Ativan ) and added some betablockers and anti-depressents....oh the heaven of the fog......I was able mutely to exist...did not talk much or have sex but hey....I even got away from the evil boss....so age 26....New job.....maybe wanting babies I tried to stop taking my headache tablets.......Oh No the panic attacks returned......I might be going crazy again....But the nice psychiatrist kept talking to me hell he even hugged me and told me he loved me oh and those headache tablets just kept a coming......Meanwhile my husband started to stand over me to make sure I took the Pill. He was not thinking about babies.....age 28 he abruptly left me and then divorced me on the grounds I quote persisted in the notion of being a mother despite being on Tranquiller Also more of MY unreasonable behaviour was due to the fact he was denied his conjugal rights .........My libido was out the door.........The kind Psychiatrists reaction to me being left an overnight tripling of the Ativan dose....which I have to fess did enable me to c28452017-04-23T16:15:26.414782Annecrawl into the classroom.......so after spending a fortune of educating me and enabling me to become a teacher WHY through no fault of my own did I lose my marriage and was unable to truly fulfil my considerable potential. I was lucky enough to meet someone else who loved me and he has stood by me for 25 years as I have battled benzo addiction and since 2005 Anti-depressant addiction though I have not been clinically depressed since 2009. I was shockingly discriminated against by the police and the courts who illegally got hold of my medical records in 2010........a tale of woe indeed.......This must not blight another person's future...I class myself as lucky my brain does function,,,but how I mourn for what could have been.......Maybe I could have been a headteacher or a politician.......Benzo addiction does severely limit career options......I have never claimed any state benefits and have paid taxes for 35 years....WHY will the GP NHS or Pharma companies not even allow me a tapering kit, liquid medication to help with withdrawal let along informed advice and support. Thank God for all the wonderful signatories above........SME ( A subject matter expert through self educatation and 32 years of lived experience.........28452017-04-23T18:00:30.72714783Lynn WhiteCommon sense should apply here. 28232017-04-23T18:54:22.6814784Dorothy BairdI'm a psychotherapist working out of the Human Givens approach and often see people who are suffering from difficulties that could be directly attributed to the antidepressants they've been prescribed. Often they've been given the medication to help with difficulties in life, such as anxiety or bereavement or trauma. It is far more effective to help the person develop skills to work through these difficulties, or to resolve previous trauma than give pills which can disempower them. When they try and come off the pills, their symptoms reappear, so the GP ups the dose, rather than attributing the return of symptoms to withdrawal. Much more needs to be done and I hope the Scottish Parliament will look at more empowering and effective ways to deal with mental health problems as well as offering support to those who unwittingly find themselves in the grip of withdrawal. This is not a gripe against GPs who are overworked and have only 10 minutes and huge waiting lists for counselling services. If the pills actually work, why are there so many people with mental health problems? 28452017-04-24T16:15:59.96714785EilidhCycling and walking must be designed into projects from the start. Designing for cars or trams first, then trying to squeeze in pedestrians and cyclists leads to poor solutions. 27632017-04-24T16:37:39.6714786Margaret MalcolmThere is a need for more Nursery provision. Much of this will come from the private sector and a rate increase is likely to curb expansion28132017-04-24T22:38:12.78314788David MIt is most cost effective to design and build the solutions for people who walk and cycle at the same time as we design and build the solutions for people who drive. If we are to fight the obesity epidemic and tackle climate change, we must encourage more people to choose active travel. This is the most cost-effective way to do it: design it in from the start.27632017-04-24T23:18:18.3514789John ChivallScotland faces serious challenges in tackling the growing burdens of preventable ill health, social exclusion and declining town centre economies. Transport policy lies at the intersection of all of these. Until road design meets the needs of people without access to private motor vehicles, we will continue to see avoidable deaths from air pollution, obesity, diabetes and car crash trauma. Until people find it safer, more convenient and more pleasant to shop locally than to drive to out of town retail developments, our town centres will continue to wither. Until communities suffering high levels of deprivation have reliable, safe and well maintained walking and cycling links to areas of employment, people will continue to need to spend too much of their income running a car in order to access jobs and shops.\r\n\r\nWe know from the experience of countries like Denmark and the Netherlands that by putting solutions for active travel at the centre of be developments, it is possible to enable people to lead more active lives, spend money locally, avoid polluting the air we all breathe and reduce the unacceptable death toll that we currently suffer on our roads.\r\n\r\nIt is inconceivable that in the 21st century we are still designing roads that discourage travel by the most sustainable, healthy and economically beneficial modes of transport. I would even go so far as to say that is an immoral waste of taxpayers' money to keep subsidising through capital expenditure those who choose to drive private motor cars at the proven expense of our health service, justice system and small businesses.27632017-04-25T06:38:02.1814790AndrewThe Transport Minister's words about active travel are hollow and meaningless when projects like Sheriffhall get their already meagre cycle lanes slashed between consultation and final single option27632017-04-25T08:44:05.55314791Sally HinchcliffeAbsolutely agree - and not just for transport investment. No new school or hospital should be built without also building safe cycle routes to it. Look at the new Dumfries hospital, where cyclists and pedestrians will have to cross a 60mph road without a crossing\r\n27632017-04-25T08:54:58.21314792Cris ThackerIt's a positive start but we need more bike paths everywhere, not just around sherrifhall 27632017-04-25T09:41:21.07714793Phil JonesWe need well designed infrastructure to really grow cycling as an active travel activity. Perceived danger is a major barrier to those that wish to cycle. Decent, joined up, safe cycle lanes are a must if you are serious about achieving 10% modal share. Money spent on cycling will pay back far more than that spent on roads. Social, economic, environmental, health and so many more areas will benefit. Please build cycle paths, paint on a road doesn't work. Thank you. 27632017-04-25T11:15:46.67314794Rachel Fraser Signed28132017-04-25T11:21:07.70314795Jackie ArchaibaldAt a time when the private sector nurseries are under extreme financial pressure, support by abolishing or radically reducing small business rates is essential in helping maintain viability. The private nurseries sector is an essential element in the government's plan to roll out the doubling of funded hours in the early years. Unless such financial support is given many small businesses may not survive the transition.28132017-04-25T11:56:45.8514796Peter BrownCycle lanes beside any new.upgraded road or rail project should be mandatory. should have been done for the Tweeddale rail link.27632017-04-25T12:22:45.05314797Neil macPhersonI urge all cyclists and interested parties to sign this petition as only with continued pressure on politicians can we achieve the changes in political attitudes and infrastructure that we need to reverse the dominance of the car in our transport system.27632017-04-25T13:21:43.90714800GR MackieWith so much uncertainty currently prevailing in the sector and help to minimise price increases for families is essential. The building rates and the long standing VAT issue would be a great sign of support from the Scottish Government for our businesses. After all, did someone up here not say they want the best start for our children in life??28132017-04-25T13:25:07.65714801Jane BurridgeSustainable transport should be higher up the agenda.27632017-04-25T13:31:28.6114802Richard RussellWe are struggling with recent huge increases in Minimum Wage and Living Wage - 2 in the last year, but many over the last few years - and other costs which are spiralling - power, waste removal, etc. \r\nA large Rates bill could tip us over the edge.\r\n\r\nAs a small business, we are presently exempt from Rates - RV just within the band - and we are extremely worried by yet another mandatory cost coming into play.28132017-04-25T14:44:36.05714803Steven FergusonAbolish Business Rates for nurseries... the UK already carries the most expensive childcare costs on Europe.28132017-04-25T14:48:53.71714804Fiona HamilSupport the reduction or abolishing fees for small businesses 28132017-04-25T15:38:39.14314805Nichola McCannWithout private nurseries, the state nurseries couldn't handle the number of places required. To possibly lose many private providers because of these rates will have a huge impact. Either council's will be required to absorb the additional fees parents are forced to pay to cover it, or the nurseries close and children will go without provision.28132017-04-25T17:41:55.97714806EmmaRate increases lead to fee increases, loss of profits to those trying to keep fees down, rises in tax credits claims, lowers the rate of parents seeking full time employment and so on and so forth. Abolish the rates or freezing or significantly reduce them or you risk rising costs I'm other areas of the budget28132017-04-25T18:10:47.24714807Mark FisherThis is scandalous and barbaric. If this is modern healthcare you can keep it.28452017-04-25T18:33:01.6114808Abigail suttie Shocking 28132017-04-25T18:56:26.1714809Urszula Kozak I say NO to nursery rates28132017-04-25T19:14:34.4914810John DonnellyThe Pedal on Parliament rides on the weekend of the 22nd and 23rd April, with over 5,000 people attending in Aberdeen, Edinburgh, Inverness and Glasgow, demonstrates there is a demand for this.27632017-04-25T20:14:20.21714811Caroline BerrieTrying to balance full time work and a mortgage with childcare is becoming increasingly difficult and and reduction in childcare costs woukd help.28132017-04-25T22:10:31.05714812John curranYou're a wee battler Irene and you absolutely deserve this to go through. Well done ,it'll help so many more people in future. Xx28232017-04-25T22:46:24.72314813Kathryn EganI'd have a lifetime of things to comment as the damage has occurred over a period of more than half my life. The damage is organic in origin as in physical impairment and remains to this day as I fight to regain a life. I'd comment more but actually I'm to darn sick while going through the withdrawal from these, which I now refer to as toxic chemicals. How long before recognition and received help? Will it take as long as the thalidomide travesty did? This is more than equally as devastating and more than equally occurring in its numbers affected. 28452017-04-25T23:06:06.72714814Leanne McGoffSigned28132017-04-26T09:29:03.2314815Linda PatersonAbsolutely shocking that my rates have trebled. This will have a very detrimental effect on my business. Also no notification was given on this until a letter was received advising of new rates. Rates and VAT should be abolished for nurseries.28132017-04-26T10:19:44.16314816KiranReading the other comments I don't feel i can add much to the already sterling arguments made here! \r\nAll I know is that if Scotland is to have any kind of respectability in the world we need to be seen as a leader of innovation, development and inclusivity. Active travel is a great way to boost Scotlands image as a clean, well thought out county. Currently Scotland lags behind other European countries, and is more in line with the English. But we can do so much better than the English! Invest in cycling for a better future!27632017-04-26T11:00:43.5114817John MillsTheres only one thing that needs to happen, first before anything else take away the power that allows psychiatrists to forcefully poison people, and after that happens, nothing anyone says to power over anyone with their opinions, poisons imaginings matters, that's the bottom line, all the argument ,all the despair, all the tears and all the sadness, cant be imposed on anyone, by anyone, everything else is an argument because of that, one law, every government in the world, gives these people, legislates that they can, thats got to go. and then when thats gone, every psychiatric facility in the world has to open turn, one of its three or four, your mad, Im gonna poison you wards, whether you want it or not, into a re education, withdrawal, recovery ward, first for the street drug psychosed their turning into lifetime neuroleptic junkies, when their not even supposed to have drugs for what they are suffering, from, for up to, ten days full sleeps, and only if they havent slept can they only be given sleepers, and of course for all the sad poor people they have traumatised and turned into debilitated drug addicts for their own profits and egos, but first thing first, take away the right to drug, and replace it with the right to refuse. end of story, because all the stories and all the arguments hinge off that happening.28452017-04-26T11:52:50.65714818KATNeed a national strategy for long-term development of cycling and walking infrastructure and organisations with resources, expertise and authority to deliver. 27632017-04-26T20:23:56.1314819Henry WhaleyThe Edinburgh Bypass is a huge barrier to active travel. It is straightforward to build into the designs a direct and appealing cycle and walking bridge. This should not take a petition to be included.27632017-04-26T20:51:05.44714820Lauren McdadeMy childcare is already double my mortgage. Stop penalising working parents.28132017-04-26T20:58:31.2314821Katrina WilsonI support the petition 28132017-04-26T21:34:42.56714822FergusBy increasing business rates for nurseries this additional cost will be passed on to parents to pay for childcare costs. We both work and have very limited family support so rely heavily on nursery childcare. This is yet another cost which hard pressed families will have to soak up, diminishing disposable income and affecting local spending into the economy! 28132017-04-26T21:56:17.7114823Caroline Linnie Signed 28132017-04-26T22:37:49.89714824Claire chaffeyShould not be tolerated, anytime. 28232017-04-27T04:47:43.34314825Laura BarronIf the government wants people to get back into work after having a baby then a reduction in childcare costs is essential to make working worthwhile !28132017-04-27T09:14:26.65714826Ian MunnAll our scenic areas should be protected, especially from wind farms which blight the landscape!28582017-04-27T09:18:02.92314827Elaine baillieRaising child care cost is just going to cause less people returning to work as they will only be working to pay for child care and be no better off 28132017-04-27T11:24:10.1514828M.K. StyllinskiThis is the most shameful exploitation of the Scottish Countryside by energy companies. The official data on the viability of wind farms in Scotland - both in terms of its effects on health and economics - is highly contestable. 28582017-04-27T11:42:53.08314829Maria Vati As parents who do not have family around we rely heavily on nursery to look after our child while we are at work. More importantly, having the option for nursery allows us to go to work and contribute to the society. I do wonder how parents will feel if their salary just about covers the fee for the nursery. Would u or other parents want to go to work.28132017-04-27T12:31:05.88714831Kirsten Kininmonth Over 10 years we have paid tenths of thousands of pounds in childcare, with no help what so ever due to both working. If costs rise more this will become even more difficult. Working families will once again be squeezed.28132017-04-27T12:48:51.78714832Iain H ScottPlease protect this beautiful country that we live in from further industrial wind developments especially in the Scottish Borders area who are seeking to make this most unspoilt and largely unknown part of the country into a national park. 28582017-04-27T13:33:58.93314833Alice McAvoyOur beautiful landscapes are to often being destroyed with huge detrimental impacts on landscape and our wildlife and much of which is not fully understood.28582017-04-27T13:43:45.9814834Joyce C FarquharPlease stop desecrating our beautiful country. 28582017-04-27T14:38:27.28714835Alison HewatNurseries are an essential part of being able to work when you have children below school age. It is nonsensicle to increase the costs of running them when you are trying to encourage parents to use them. The Government should rethink this policy. It would be better still if they abolished the rate for essentials rather than increasing it.28132017-04-27T14:51:40.26714836Jenny ScobieOur environment is vitally important to us human beings.28582017-04-27T15:55:55.9714837Douglas MoirOur countryside was one of our greatest assets, yet politicians have seen fit to industrialise it with wind farms that provide intermittent energy and cannot be controlled to provide energy when it is most needed between the two daily periods of 'peak demand'. It is very sad that the 'people' are the one's who are fighting to protect our heritage.28582017-04-27T16:28:57.53714838Geoff MooreI was recently in Italy. Like us, they have national parks as the top landscape protection. Next down they have regional parks, equivalent I guess to Scottish NSAs. Most of the Italian area which I visited was a regional park and there are numerous large signs where you enter it to publicize it, whereas Scottish NSAs have little or no recognition on the ground. This should be addressed.28582017-04-27T16:46:12.08314839Gillian Arnott We need to protect Scotland's landscape and unique wildlife before it's too late 28582017-04-27T18:15:33.05314840VaisakhAll support from India for this noble cause28452017-04-27T18:32:00.1814841Kim TerryThe landscapes of Scotland are being decimated with the onslaught of expensive and useless wind farms. When driving into Scotland from England on the M6 motorway you are now 'treated' to the sight of more ugly wind farms and the thought 'Welcome to Scotland' takes on a whole new meaning. The surrounding hills are becoming full of ugly turbines and the natural beauty of Scotland is rapidly disappearing. The SNP is guilty of ruining what was one of the most stunning countries in the world and they obviously don't appreciate what other people see in Scotland. Shame on them.28582017-04-27T18:45:43.27314842Nicola ElliotI for one could not afford to have the cost of childcare increase! This would impact negatively on my ability to retain employment and family life. Support and encourage parents to remain in employment surely... 28132017-04-27T20:08:46.64314843George HerraghtyBiomass, biofuels and wind farms are destroying wildlife habitats at great speed, yet they do not produce any environmental benefits at all. They are remedies that are worse than the illness, and should be abandoned immediately.\r\n\r\nThe World Council for Nature does not condone the destruction of nature in order to, supposedly, 'save the planet'. If indeed the planet is at risk, it is from the corrupt alliance of 'green' charlatans, subsidy-sucking speculators, and politicians. Together, they have created a monster which is causing more devastation worldwide than there has been in five thousand years of civilisation. 28582017-04-27T21:15:54.68314844S AtkinsScotland is being ruined by this short sighted pursuit of wind energy which is ruining the landscape. The tourist industry will be decimated.28582017-04-27T22:06:08.5214845Angela lamontIt is utterly disgraceful that our beautiful landscape is being defaced by The Scottish Government. What is wrong with you people. 28582017-04-27T22:09:12.34714846Lyndsey WardThe industrialisation of some of our finest landscapes by industrial wind, pylons and substations is the most abhorrent destruction. Access tracks snake up hillsides and huge swathes of Scotland are now ruined. The cost to our environment, wildlife and rural people is immeasurable. The cost on our energy bills is a disgrace. With no proof wind will reduce emissions and the fact it can never give energy security it is astonishing that the destruction has been encouraged by the Scottish Government to the detriment of so much and so many.28582017-04-27T23:17:45.59314847Hazel ApppletonI am ashamed that this government has allowed our beautiful Scottish countryside to be industrialised by these monstrosities called wind turbines! It has to stop! It's shameful! 28582017-04-28T08:24:33.03714848John Jeremy McCallThis year will be first time in 10 years I'm not visiting the Highlands, because I am fed up with looking at wind turbines marring a once stunning landscape.28582017-04-28T08:42:58.29314849Willie ScobieConsultation is too loose and leaves it to the forst industry to decide whether it carries out any consultation with the communities and those most effected by timber extraction. It needs to be regulated and made mandatory to carry out consultation . One way of doing this to make it compulsory to demonstrate and evidence that consultation has been carried out when applying to the Licencing Authorities for a licence to extract timber.28432017-04-28T08:53:54.74714850Willie ScobieCommunity consultation must be made mandatory. It must be regulated but more important, legislation must be introduced to take away the 'voluntary' consultation element. 28432017-04-28T11:17:01.55314852Grace FenwickWhilst forestry is a commercial enterprise it should not expect cash-strapped councils to pick up the expense of reinstating damaged public roads resulting from forestry extraction. The voluntary code allows forestry companies to flout their responsibilities. Many roads used a small and unsuitable for the heavy traffic and the volume of forestry extraction on-going at present across southern Scotland is phenomenal.28432017-04-28T11:30:30.89314855Anthony DaltonLoch Awe is unique in its landscape character & historical context. It is already ringed by several windfarms detrimental to the landscape & tourism. \r\nWe destroy such unique areas at our peril - if more windfarms are built it will imperil that landscape, which is fully deserving of NSA protection.28582017-04-28T11:38:52.6514856Graham BissetThere is no case for affording special treatment to employees of NHS in Scotland and they should not be afforded separate legislative protection.\r\n\r\nThe government of Scotland already has the tools to deal with assault and its focus should be on tackiling all crime at source and ensuring that enforcement is by Police Scotland effective and efficient.28262017-04-28T15:27:04.8714857KMillerOut of all the options for improving sheriffhall Transport Scotland chose the 1960s car based solution, despite the fact the a workshop they held with stakeholders concluded that the best option was an off line solution, that allowed the existing alignment to be used for segregated active travel under the A720. This demonstrates where Transport Scotlands priorities lie perfectly.27632017-04-28T16:38:36.0214858Brian NisbetChildcare fees in Edinburgh are already more than the Scottish Average. Business rate increases will only make it harder for private nuseries to operate and maintain a good standard of care. If these rate increases are then passed on to working parents it will make it more difficult to stay in full time employment. 28132017-04-28T17:30:39.4814859Brian SalvonaA safe route by bike at this location is overdue27632017-04-28T19:37:06.2814860Estelle My mother overdosed on her psychiatric medication and died. Passage of time makes no difference to the grief I continue to feel. More holistic healing support much needed for people in distress rather than horrific toxic drugs !!! 28452017-04-28T19:48:35.06314863George HerraghtyWind farms are now visible from more than 60% of Scotland!!!\r\n28582017-04-28T20:01:54.87714864Lesley Stuart-GammieWithout private nurseries, hundreds of thousands of people simply would not be able to work.28132017-04-28T20:57:00.20714865Ian WallaceRoads are a disgrace. We pay road tax same as all drivers but do not have good roads as they have in ALL other areas of Scotland AND England. Maybole needs a BYPASS before a disaster happens!!! I hope your conscience's will bother you if it does.28432017-04-28T22:14:30.29714866Aviva Sheb'aI have witnessed the serious delltrimental effects of psychiatric medications on dozens of people I've known over more than forty years. The problem seems to be growing rather than diminishing. Thank you for taking on this challenge, Scotland. I hope your petition leads to success there and in the rest of the world. There is a place for medication, but ubiquity is not it.28452017-04-28T23:04:05.2314867Jackie StantonPlease include the anti-psychotics too?\r\n.28452017-04-28T23:11:23.4814868Ann marcosI was prescribed drugs to treat so called mental health that caused me serious side effects. 28452017-04-29T00:02:56.75314869Paul ChambersThe proposed increases are unreasonable and make child care unaffordable. This goes against the aims of the National Improvement Framework.28132017-04-29T01:19:17.37314870Martin McManusPsychiatry is rotten at its core and standard psychiatric practice leads to drug dependence through creating a chemical imbalance, worse outcomes for people than non-treatment, the stigmatising of normal distress, more jobs created for psychiatrists and their affiliates, more physical health complications and huge profits for the pharmaceutical industry. 28452017-04-29T02:35:14.89714871Janet HarveyWhen nurseries have no alternative other than to raise fees in order to balance their finances how can parents afford to have children properly looked after in order that they both remain in employment . At the moment often one parent merely remains in employment in order to pay just their childcare to ensure they remain in employment When fees are yet again hiked they will not be affordable and parents only option will be to give up their employment or put themselves in a dept loop crisis they will not be able to survive just to feed cloth and keep a roof over their head. Logic is unemployment figures will rise How can that then help the overall balance of the governments finances ? 28132017-04-29T05:16:53.3814872Sandra CairnsI had to watch my husband die slowly and in a sad manner as he deteriorated after being forced onto depo antipsychotics for years rather then address the severe ptsd he had developed after a bad fall and near death experience he suffered in a work injury. It is time to stop allowing governments certainly in the commonwealth using psychiatric drugs to destroy people they have wronged rather then compensate them or get them back to prework injuries conditions. When the medical profession works hand in hand with pharmaceutical companies and allow themselves to be used as a weapon against society it is time for that society to stop them28452017-04-29T05:53:52.78314873Bradford HutchinsonThis petition tells MY STORY, too! I call it "IATROGENIC NEUROLEPSIS", and it's the untold PhRMA (U.S.) scandal of our time. I was given clonazepam (Klonopin") .5mg., 3x day, with a "2-level", or "2-tier" taper down, as a long term goal.(.5mg.3x, .5mg.2x, .5mg.1x...) This was after 20 yrs. of multi-psych drug\r\ngiven, sometimes against my will. I also became, and remain, alcohol-free. My recovery went slowly, but very well, with always the goal of re-employment and FULL independence off disability pension. I almost completed college work. The "system" here in the USA is VERY broken, despite what media and medics would have you believe. While MY STORY is also told in this petition, there is much more, and worse, besides. So PLEASE consider favorably this petition. I endorse it FULLY. 28452017-04-29T07:34:31.2114874Ben PalmerMy particular concern is the state of the roads where forest tracks join, as well as these areas of roads needing repair, much of the damage could be avoided if the forest tracks were laid with tar about two truck lengths into the forest, it is the stones from the forest tracks that cause the problem on the roads.28432017-04-29T12:02:31.38714875R.ConnorSo much of Scotland's landscape is not designated as NSA, but is critical to our economy in attracting tourists. Why is the Government destroying this to line the pockets of Developers who are mostly based out of Scotland. Our land needs protection and the public needs a right to appeal what is ruining our landscape sanctioned by this Government to allow commercial gain in the guise of saving the planet.28582017-04-29T12:39:14.64314876VanessaI know how dangerous antidepressants are, especially for young people. I am lucky that my daughter was in a residential unit for the many months that her so-called professional doctors insisted on her taking these drugs. Once she was able to get off them, 2 years later, she has made incredible progress. The system is dangerous!28452017-04-29T13:39:27.43314877Shannon BebbI have suffered similarly in the US. Please lead the way in stopping these horrific practices.28452017-04-29T14:54:05.05314878SonjaFree from all mental medications for 7+ years28452017-04-29T22:06:47.27714879Linda WhittinghamWe have experienced this first hand, noisy machinery working until all hours, single-track roads torn to shreds, historical stone bridge badly damaged, mud and debris left on roads, and wagons which are clearly too big for this type of road. I did report this to the council who made sympathetic noises but then did absolutely nothing. The road is barely passable now with huge potholes - who knows when, if at all, it will get fixed. Why should us taxpayers have to foot the bill for repairs when the timber companies are making huge profits at the expense of local residents. Great time of year also to be doing this - lambing season when there are ewes and lambs loose on the moors! It is time this was regulated.28432017-04-30T09:04:41.2414880Edward Corscaden Very sad, tragic state of affairs. Money talks. Health care is corrupt28452017-04-30T11:51:55.49714881Tracy DavidsonNo company or organisation should be "allowed" to run rough shed over any individual or community regardless of what perceived benefit there is to economy, environment etc.\r\n\r\nThis practise needs to stop and regulations put in place to ensure this no longer the norm.28432017-04-30T20:35:50.76714882Bea HoldenIt is imperative that other beautiful areas of Scotland are given this designation to protect them from inappropriate development. In particular in south west Scotland which has always appeared to be the forgotten part of Scotland but which has some stunning landscapes.28582017-04-30T21:10:13.41714883Kevin LawsonThe best way to protect Scotlands scenic areas is to halt all further wind farm development 28582017-04-30T22:11:02.5314884Sharon wallaceThis should have been passed years ago. Too many people have suffered. Well done Irene for doing this. I hope that you find peace and happiness again x28232017-04-30T23:30:26.77314885Fred AbbeDeveloping poisons and forcing them into people's bodies and calling it health care is a crime against humanity. The individual's right to refuse must be honored . There is more pseudo science in psychiatry then the world can stand. 28452017-05-01T11:12:41.35314886James MylesThe government have said they are dedicated to help working parents with childcare costs, but by increasing the Rates for nurseries they are indeed increasing the childcare costs as nurseries will have to increase their fees in order to break even28132017-05-01T11:12:56.99314887Ted PorterI have been noticing no potholes on my recent countryside travels and do not believe the government should waste resources on this minor problem when we have bigger things to think about. Peace out28432017-05-01T11:14:00.5714888TeddyPI think you are wrong my friend28432017-05-01T13:54:09.04714889Renae BellI would like to see a fully linked cycle line throughout midlothian and into Edinburgh. It's a massive barrier for anyone considering cycling for their commute. It is also integral that parents can more safely encourage the next generation to cycle. 27632017-05-01T14:03:03.62714890James MageeI do not think that any private individual or company should have the right to Destroy large parts of Scotland. 28432017-05-01T14:04:33.06314891Mrs Natasha E RogerHaving Twins and working this is going to cause a huge complication for us and our whole family due to simply not being able to afford childcare. Help those who want to return to work after having a child and the tax income revenue will go out allowing bigger budgets to go towards the sectors most needed by communities.28132017-05-01T17:26:04.5714892Irene AdamsonI totally agree with this petition the damage these holes are doing to our car etc is a disgrace28432017-05-01T22:12:20.6414893Irene AdamsonThe roads in Dumfries and Galloway are disgrace for a euro route28432017-05-01T22:34:00.89314894Julie PettyIt is vitally important to protect an mantain areas such as loch awe. 28582017-05-02T07:30:42.85714895Christine TurnerLoch Awe is a place of natural beauty an d should be preserved as such.28582017-05-02T08:45:30.8514896DebbieAs working parents, nursery is a vital part of our children's childcare. The increase in business rates hitting nurseries is far too big. Nurseries will be forced to increase their charges which in turn will force some parents to give up work and pull their children out. Not only do the children and parents suffer but in turn it will mean there is less tax and national insurance being paid into the economy.28132017-05-02T09:27:43.3414897Holly HunterAs a single parent trying to work from my son being 11 months old nursery fees going up have made it very difficult for me. In a country where we want to encourage people to work a lot of people can't because of how expensive private nurseries are.28132017-05-02T10:17:05.28714898Robynhaving to weigh up whether it is worth my child having social and educational skills, and me going out to work... can barely make ends meet as it is! where is the motivation or encouragement?!28132017-05-02T10:25:42.13314899Grant ChisholmAbsolutely appalling to raise business rates when small businesses are struggling so much to stay open now. We need to support our community shops when there is so much online competition.\r\n\r\nThis will also severely got my 18 month old boys nursery which I find absolutely appalling when all I want is for my boy to learn and grow in a safe environment but may not be able to if we cent afford fee hikes to cover business rate increases!28132017-05-02T11:29:34.91714900Yvonne CookThe rate increase for nurseries, is terrible. Private nursery fee are so expensive already & raising the fees will end up costs the parents more, I am already struggling to pay two sets of fees & make it worth while to work if they increase any more I will have to give up work which I am not wanting to do.28132017-05-02T11:56:34.94314901Jenny TerrisPrices have already been raised, raising them further is not productive and will make more parents reliant on benefits. The government need to help parents not hinder them further by increasing prices!!!28132017-05-02T12:08:56.19314902David WhiteCycling and walking are rightly seen as an important part of the solution to the major problems of inactive travel (eg. poor health due to poor air quality and sedentary lifestyles, and their costs to the NHS, and of course climate change consequences). However, is it reasonable to encourage cycling when it's so dangerous, due to so much motor traffic? Ways must be found of discouraging car use. Many motorists who would like to cycle, stay in their cars as they can see it's so dangerous, thereby ensuring it remains dangerous. We can break this vicious circle in Scotland.27632017-05-02T12:44:45.17714903Vivien GassertThe proliferation of wind farms is turning the country into an immense industrial factory. NSA's have to be increased to protect what countryside we have left. One only has to look at\r\nthe staggering number of turbines from the Central Belt to the Borders to see the devastation of our countryside, fauna and flora. 28582017-05-02T14:02:48.95314904Peter GrayLoch Awe's stunning natural scenery should be protected for now for current and future generations.28582017-05-02T14:26:01.09314905Nicola SlaterRising childcare costs actively discourage parents returning to work. This government should be looking at ways to encourage women in the workplace. Council run nurseries do not provide the hours required to sustain a 9-5 job and leave parents with only private nurseries as an option28132017-05-02T14:28:42.90714906Nicola Rising childcare costs actively discourage parents returning to work. This government should be looking at ways to encourage women in the workplace. Council run nurseries do not provide the hours required to sustain a 9-5 job and leave parents with only private nurseries as an option28132017-05-02T16:25:37.5814907Susie BarstowLoch Awe is a unique and beautiful area that deserves special protection. Already the area has undergone change due to the building and ongoing maintenance of a number of windfarms, for example. Further windfarm or other large scale development should be discouraged in order to preserve the natural beauty and the wildlife of the area for future generations. 28582017-05-02T17:44:15.60714908ChristinaDrugs are terrible and addicting. It ruins both quality and quantity of life.28452017-05-02T20:35:38.02314909Rhona KnoxIt is very important to protect more of Scotlands beautiful and unique landscapes via expansion of the NSA designation scene. Loch Awe is a favourite place of mine and deserves to be officially deemed a NSA and protected accordingly.28582017-05-02T20:37:35.75314910Kirsten DavieNursery fees are already expensive and to raise them higher is going to have a negative impact on everyone. I thought the Government wanted to get mums back to work for society but this is not going to support this. Nursery Fees are already like mortgage fees and more..they should be decreasing and subsidised not increased. It should be all about a healthy work life balance where both kids and parents benefit from this structure.28132017-05-02T21:33:47.0914911Cornelis van ReinThis is an area of truly outstanding natural beauty and a very rich history, a tourist attraction since the railways opened up. Preservation is of paramount importance for now and for posterity. Nature has provided a truly wonderful gift and it must be treated as such. Scotland must remain beautiful. The Loch Awe area is truly awesome.28582017-05-02T22:05:11.5214912Bill GeakeThere are many far less wonderful places that are also windy. Loch Awe is a hidden gem and must be protected.28582017-05-02T23:36:32.10714913Colin MillerWe need a cycle path around Edinburgh and in to Edinburgh. This means crossing the bypass at several points. Please factor this in to the Sherriffhall Roundabout, and other key points along the A720 to enable cycling around the City and not just in and out of it.27632017-05-03T09:16:18.3914914Farina TavasolianIt is really unfair for nurseries that they do not even grant funding, new business etc28132017-05-03T10:25:14.6814915Donna NeilsonI have just returned to work from maternity leave, the pressure of leaving your baby at nursery is hard enough but to then be met with increasing costs is a struggle to a lot of parents including myself. I don't have family near by so nursery is the only option if I am to remain in work. 28132017-05-03T12:20:01.75314916John MacleanIncreasing business rates for nurseries seems counter-intuitive to the notion of investing in the future of our children.28132017-05-03T13:06:21.6214917Amanda hamiltonSigned28132017-05-03T15:02:13.87314918Martin CasselsCommunting from Newtongrange to Edinburgh each day you start to notice many potential cycle paths and footpaths that were in the design but dropped. Option B for Sheriffhall isn't the right choice. Also, why is there no footpath on the road running from Lothianbridge to the Tesco roundabout and onward to Dobbies? Looks like the idea was there but only enough funding for the corners a the roundabouts until you get onto the path proper near Dobbies. Not even having a footpath is crazy and dangerous, people have to walk along the (rough) grass verge at the side of the road every day on a national speed limit section of road. It scares me to think about it everytime one of my kids says they are going to walk to Tesco, and the thought of them cycling is even worse. I do it daily but it's not a confident experience. Start catering for people who are trying to keep costs down, reduce emissions and fully support active travel!27632017-05-03T17:47:30.45714919Liz WennIt is not just antidepressants and benzodiazepines that cause medically unexplained symptoms or MUS. Adverse drug reactions, ADRs, from many drugs are swept under the carpet because, in my view, ADR reporting procedures and the MHRA are not fit for purpose. Doctors routinely fail to report side effects to the MHRA, perhaps they are under pressure not to report. The rate of reporting is shameful, for example, a GP, on average, may only report an ADR twice in their career. \r\nThe psychiatric diagnosis of MUS represents an appalling dumbing down of medicine. Doctor error and lack of training, testing restrictions and testing error, Hickams dictum rather than Occams razor, rare diseases and presentations, unknown and poorly elucidated diseases, these are no longer given due consideration when patients present with MUS. I am sure that drug ADRs represent a major cause of MUS, and MUS patients risk more horrible side effects if they are put on antidepressant medication to try to treat their supposed functional or somatization disorder. \r\nThe UK government and NHS England are encouraging the diagnosis of MUS across England and factoring it in to NHS funding and commissioning to deliver their efficiency savings via cuts to outpatient clinics and investigations such as radiography. They are promoting cheap, rather than good quality and ethical, CBT psychotherapy for these patients via the IAPT programme to achieve savings to the NHS of almost eight times the money spent out on the CBT programme. It is claimed that half or more of outpatient appointments are due to MUS, an idea of the scale of savings that the government may have set its sights on. The Medical Establishment is keen to extend this Orwellian model to Scotland, Wales and N. Ireland and so effect privatization of the whole NHS by the back door, as desperate patients pay for private consultations to find the true causes of their MUS. This IS a NATIONAL SCANDAL.\r\n28452017-05-03T21:09:29.01314920Brian BurnettLoch awe is a gem and deserves special protection. I used to live close to the Lincolnshire Wolds that has ANOB status. If the Wolds are deserving of protection and I believe they are, then Loch Awe certainly is28582017-05-03T21:47:36.08314921Graeme WalkerWe need a cycle path in to Edinburgh. This means crossing the bypass at several points. Please factor this in to the Sherriffhall Roundabout,27632017-05-03T22:27:18.4314922Elizabeth JonesTotally agree28432017-05-04T08:06:51.03714923Merry CitoliI have a similar organization here in the U.S. and would be interested in getting a petition going here as well. We offer support services for people tapering off these meds and who are in recovery.28452017-05-04T09:25:13.07714924Anna BlythThe roads in Dumfries and Galloway such as the A702, the A712 and the A713 are totally unsuited to the heavy traffic forestry extraction requires. It is now unsafe for ordinary road users to drive, cycle or walk these roads. Forests were planted over 60 years ago with no upgrading of roads in preparation for forest extraction. These roads were built for traffic of 100 years ago - horses and carts with occasional motorised vehicles - not massive timber trucks!28432017-05-04T09:25:49.2214925Jennifer DownieSuch high increased rates from nurseries will result in increased rates for parents. This will result in childcare becoming even more unaffordable. Nurseries should be exempt from the rate increase to make them remain affordable 28132017-05-04T16:09:05.2114926Rachael ParryAny increased costs to the nursery will be passed onto the parents. This will limit the access to private childcare that parents with full time roles need to support their employment obligations, and is completely counterintuitive to the scheme of offering increased childcare support. 28132017-05-04T16:36:41.95714927Neil SeddonMy youngest leaves this year however this is still unacceptable.28132017-05-04T17:52:55.25714928benzogirlBenzos, taken as prescribed ruined 15 year of my prime life. Something should be don about this dangerous class of drugs. Yikes! It's horrible.28452017-05-04T19:12:02.0414929KirstenI am now dependent on antidepressants and was given a new erroneous diagnosis of schizophrenia after the doctors took me off an antipsychotic too quickly which made me develop withdrawal psychosis despite taking it for OCD and having no previous episodes of it. Doctors are too quick to prescribe drugs and too negligent in their rate of discontinuation of meds.28452017-05-04T21:48:48.78314930June HallNo more turbines !!28582017-05-05T10:32:22.93714931Soili TakkalaWe have a corresponding withdrawal group for SSRI users in Finland. Our main focus is to provide peer support for those struggling with withdrawal symptoms. Gradually, we are also trying to draw public attention to the problem and bring about a change in the public health system.I wish best of luck to your campaign and hope to co-operate with you around these issues in the future!28452017-05-05T12:02:45.47314932R CoxHaving been harmed by these drugs (inappropriately Rx for a non mental health condition) I'm happy to sign this petition and raise awareness of the issues described. 28452017-05-05T23:22:47.65314933Lianne Millar The increase in costs is severe and is a significant factor in my youngest not attending nursery as planned. Simply unaffordable. 28132017-05-07T10:54:41.93314934David O'NeillIt is impossible to deny that there are other worthy candidates for NSA status in Scotland. Lough Awe is a typical example of where there should not be obvious industrialisation. The introduction of movement to these otherwise still landscapes will also have far reaching negative impacts.28582017-05-08T11:53:29.0314935EuanI believe we should protect nature from all infrastructure projects.28582017-05-08T13:19:33.88314936Sam With the continuous increased rates for my nursery as well as others, it will result in increased childcare rates for parents. This is going to result in childcare becoming even more unaffordable. We are education providers and there is already much pressure on us to deliver a great service and educate our children but we should be exempt from the rate increase to continue to remain affordable for parents and therefore their children still receive great education. 28132017-05-08T14:45:10.8314937Karl PipesAwe means Ohh!, not Uggh!\r\nProtect our scenic areas Scottish Government, stop trashing them for the sake of blind dogma!28582017-05-08T15:22:16.46314939Marion BrownPlease may I draw attention to recent online publications. Search for Alliance Scotland Viewpoint 'Is is time for the Scottish Government to be Realistic about antidepressants' published 4 May 2017. Also The Guardian UK articles and research survey about long-term antidepressants 6 May 2017. 28452017-05-08T17:11:53.0714940Frank Mortimer This road is long overdue an upgrade and would greatly improve the local economy all money spent on roads in central belt and A 9 is very good but South of Scotland has been left behind.28562017-05-08T17:19:23.8214941Cathie Branson We deserve a road that is fit for purpose. Duelling the road from Ayr to Stranraer will improve journey times and safety. Businesses and travellers between Ireland and Scotland will be encouraged to use the road and bring much needed work and investment to the area.28562017-05-08T17:21:25.92714942Helen CoulterWe use this road regularly as we have a caravan in Stranraer. This road needs upgraded.28562017-05-08T17:22:18.64314943JohnWhat started off as a way to make someone a quick buck with the sale of a car is now being used as a concealed weapon. All that damage and death caused with no due process got old decades ago.27632017-05-08T17:46:49.8214944David GarrettI travel to stranraer to see family a lot and i have noticed the a77 from ayr to stranraer is definitely not fit for the volume of traffic travelling on that road.28562017-05-08T17:56:07.77314945Carol MaxwellDread going on the A 77 every time I use it, road is not fit for purpose.!!!!28562017-05-08T18:03:24.20314946Margaret BrutonWe use this road regularly and it is not fit for purpose. Neither is the A75.28562017-05-08T18:03:53.37314947Anne CampbellAbout time the forgotten and ignored corner of Scotland gets decent roads, they are atrocious at present and unsafe. The worst roads in Scotland.28562017-05-08T18:07:11.18314948Catherine FrankI travel the A77 frequently and have grave concerns 1) that the narrow single-carriageway creates frustration which increases the risk of dangerous driving 2) that the maintenance of the surface is poor, with rainwater creating floods which then create potholes. Avoiding these can cause accidents, and non-avoidance can damage tyres and suspension (personal experience) 3) our corner of Scotland is becoming increasingly dependent on tourism, but the road is not conducive to encouraging visitors. It is certainly not fit for the amount and size of freight vehicles that use it d) if the road is closed for maintenance, or in the event of an RTA, the diversion is inadequate, long and even more dangerous. Emergency services would be detained long after the golden hour and this could lead to more loss of life.28562017-05-08T18:12:48.65714949John CampbellI would like to thank everyone who have helped the A77 Action Group. I have been trying for over 30 years to improve the A77 road and with this Action Group I now know at last we are getting there28562017-05-08T18:16:44.5114950Shelagh WattRegularly visit my son who works in Stranraer. This road which accesses two main ferry terminals between Scotland and Ireland shames Scotland. Successive governments have ignored the needs and the safety of people in this corner of Scotland. It has also ignored the needs of tourists and haulage traffic. It needs upgraded as a matter of urgency.28562017-05-08T18:44:43.01714952Margaret NevinsThe high volume of commercial vehicles alone warrants an A77 upgrade to dual carriageway. For private vehicles and motorcycles, the A77 and the A75 is currently a safety hazard.28562017-05-08T18:48:52.22714953Susan Macdougall The A77 is in a dreadful state whether heading north or south from Ballantrae where I live . It simply is not well maintained but as well as that there are long stretches that have never been upgraded and are still easily recognisable from photographs from the 19th century , never mind the 20th. 28562017-05-08T19:17:34.16714954John OrrThis road, blocks inward investment in the South West. Its dangerous and totally unfit for purpose.28562017-05-08T19:18:07.2914955mark hornei commute from girvan to prestwick 5 days a week and this is well overdue in my opinion for safety and to encourage more tourism in the area.28562017-05-08T19:55:47.91714956Tommy This road is not fit for purpose \r\n\r\nWe have better back roads in Berkshire than this A road \r\n\r\nThe Scottish Government need to stop cutting out the south west of Scotland and spend some real money on the transport network 28562017-05-08T19:57:17.55714957Alan JohnsonThis road desperately needs more dual carriageway.\r\nIt's the most dangerous road in Scotland28562017-05-08T20:08:45.96314958Mrs Linden HuntIt's time the government woke up to this vast problem on the west coast28562017-05-08T20:09:09.60314959Kevin Scobie The A77 is long overdue to be upgraded to dual carriageway. Slow moving HGV'S cause other road users to take unnecessary maneuvers on blind bends or where they shouldn't. Being a main thoroughfare form the central belt to the south West, this needs addressed as a matter of a urgency. 28562017-05-08T20:16:16.7514960Robert HuntThe condition of this road is not fit for the amount of traffic that use it on a daily basis to and from the ports at cairnryan it's in urgent need of an upgrade28562017-05-08T20:31:55.50314961Marjorie McGhieThis road desperately needs to be upgraded it is not fit for purpose any more as it is carrying more traffic than it was designed for all major towns should be bypassed egMaybole Girvan not to mention the numerous villages Minishant Kirkkoswald & Ballantrae 28562017-05-08T20:34:12.0214962Moira MacdonaldShow some respect to this corner of Scotland & upgrade the A77 to dual carriageway.\r\n28562017-05-08T20:40:44.4714963Malcolm SmithBusiest ferry port in Scotland and connected to the rest of the country by single carriageway. A great start could be made to this by making the Maybole bypass, due to start in the next year or so, dual carriageway. Overtaking lanes do nothing but increase frustration when you have a load of ferry traffic on the road. The additional expense would be well worth the effort28562017-05-08T20:45:13.514964David HowieI travel the A77 three or four times weekly it is in a terrible state .28562017-05-08T20:50:14.47314965Jeanette Miller This should be done asap28562017-05-08T21:15:30.83314966June HesterThis road is a disgrace and is long overdue this important upgrade for safety of all road users.28562017-05-08T21:44:08.8214967Jackie nishThis road is long over due an upgrade. Is has boat traffic from both port at cairnryan which can be very busy. We need this to help reduce the risks of accidents.28562017-05-08T21:46:45.1514968Robert S C JessThe A77 should dual all the way to Stranraer.28562017-05-08T22:06:14.18314969Carol Graham The A77 requires an upgrade urgently.. So many accidents and incidents involving pot holes and Maybole being the worst to pass through.. 28562017-05-08T22:17:54.36314970Mr William westellWe have to go Stranraer and ayr, parts of the road to Stranraer have had temporary traffic lights for years. No one seems to bother about repairing or upgrading the road. To much slow traffic takes a 60 mph down to a 30mph making drivers become impatient and causing accidents28562017-05-08T22:21:16.37314971Geraldine Ewan This road is not only unfit for purpose but is dangerous. Furthermore, Dumfries and Galloway has appalling transport connections and cannot be expected to improve its economy until this is addressed.28562017-05-08T22:26:30.4114972Stuart Telfer The volume of traffic, hgv in particular is now a total and utter outrage. Never seen anything like it. Quality life in our small village of Kirkoswald being hammered. And nobody cares. The value of revenue gevratued by fuel and road tax must be reinvested to make this fair. 28562017-05-08T23:10:53.56714973Jamesy The A77 is the main artery linking N.I & Ireland with Scotland and it has been forgotten about for too long in favour of road improvements all over Scotland. Let's get the A77 upgraded and put on a par with the rest of Scotland and let the SW Scotland reap the economic benefits that will follow.28562017-05-08T23:15:57.39714974John FairleyWe need a safer more up to the job road system from Ayr to Stranraer patching those potholes is not the answer.Do it and Do it Right for Scotland 28562017-05-08T23:50:26.57714975Margaret McCrorieThis road is a disgrace., I use it everyday and it is constantly being patched up to be full of holes again months down the line. The amount of traffic on this road is extremely heavy and size not appropriate anymore, it's so full of twists and turns not really designed for the double decker lorries that now travel this road I have actually witnessed one of these lorries practically lying on its side in a ditch as it's toppled over going round a bend!! Time to upgrade 28562017-05-09T02:19:22.23314976M ThomsonThe A77 is notorious for the amount of road accidents claiming lives of families. Frustration, careless driving, to overtake lorries, tractors... the list is endless, just do it, build it. The volume of traffic demands it.28562017-05-09T06:57:16.60714977Calum wilkieI moved away from this area 17 years ago and the road was not fit for purpose then but to move back 17 years later and find it even worse is just not acceptable28562017-05-09T07:16:29.9214978Angela KoehlerUpgrade A77 to duel carriageway is long overdue. It is badly needed to feed the ferries on the shortest sea route from the UK mainland to Ireland.28562017-05-09T07:21:03.60714979Philip Watt This road is a disgrace. Long overdue for upgrading. 28562017-05-09T07:40:28.67314980Kathleen McBrideThis road is horrendous, especially with the amount of traffic that use it.28562017-05-09T07:57:18.92714981Elaine LawsonLived in Stranraer most of my life, this road needs upgraded for people to travel anywhere.28562017-05-09T08:06:20.1614982Tom ScottI have travelled the road for 50 years and it is in the poorest state ever, rutting,potholes, poor visibility due to poor grass cutting and in general poor maintenance scheme. Poor maintenance since Private Contractos have taken over !!!!!!!!!!!28562017-05-09T08:12:11.0214983Angela WilsonOver the 26years of driving up and down this road the deterioration has been extensive. The wheel rims that have been damaged. Suspension broken. Fear of being thrown off direction by a pothole or patched up road. This road needs attention. 28562017-05-09T08:28:37.2914984K Donnelly We deserve a road that is fit for purpose. Duelling the road from Ayr to Stranraer will improve journey times and safety. Businesses and travellers between Ireland and Scotland will be encouraged to use the road and bring much needed work, tourists, investment to the area. A77 should be dual carriage way from Ayr to Stranraer. 28562017-05-09T08:33:04.69714985Alison O'BrienSouth Ayrshire deserve better roads , there are many accidents in this part of the A77 it needs upgraded.28562017-05-09T08:45:19.51314986Allan Bagley The road is a disgrace28562017-05-09T09:29:31.0914987Ian MunnThe condition of this road is a disgrace and those purporting to look after it should be ashamed of themselves! The fact that the road has been allowed to deteriorate to the current level demonstrates that the Scottish Government has 'no vision' for South West Scotland!28562017-05-09T09:34:11.7514988Stuart ClachanWe use this road every day and it is now normal to meet cars coming at you head on through dangerous overtaking. There is a lot of agricultural activity near us which means there are a lot of tractors driving slowly that frustrates drivers into taking dangerous risks.28562017-05-09T09:43:10.3314989Eileen Bryantthe road is a disgrace, this is the main ferry route to Ireland and was never designed to carry the heavy traffic it does today28562017-05-09T09:53:29.36314990Tommy The road is shocking needs redone 28562017-05-09T10:05:10.76714991Lea-Anne ValdrighiPlease make our High Street safe for citizens to use. 28562017-05-09T10:06:36.20714992Laura BellFor the safety of our kids this is a necessity. The High Street is far too dangerous. 28562017-05-09T10:17:26.8314993John FenwickThe road is no longer fit for purpose, it is in poor condition, is populated by convoys of trucks and slow moving farm vehicles, with long stretches where safe overtaking of anything larger than a car is impossible. This makes it not only economically crippling, but highly dangerous 28562017-05-09T10:20:54.814994Suzie Phillips Roads are a disgrace 28562017-05-09T10:23:51.92314995Willie ScobieThe A77 is in a perilous state and requires a great deal of investment to deal with all the potholes. It is dangerous and ready to subside putting lives at risk. Please sign the petition calling on the SNP Scottish Government to put the necessary investment into the A77. 28562017-05-09T10:25:36.27314996Maurice Mcchristieits about time it for a motorway on the A77 it help car drivers truckers going up and down the A77 eny now has divine this road that its lick it can be a nightmare \r\nlong overdue an upgrade of this scale south of Ayr28562017-05-09T10:27:45.8314997James Hewitt I fully support the campaign for a bypass through my home town of Maybole. The sooner this gets done the better. This road has been neglected for years and it's a miracle that no pedestrians have been killed in Maybole high street28562017-05-09T10:36:26.77314998gwen jarmanabout time,, the traffic going through Maybole is terrible, long overdue28562017-05-09T10:39:06.5514999Mhairi McKennathe road is a perilous stage slipping into the North Atlantic and Loch Ryan. The number of pot holes a disgrace. We are a forgotten corner of Scotland....we are attempting to bring visitors and work to the area, let us have a decent link to the rest of Scotland, England and Northern Ireland.28562017-05-09T10:46:42.3415000JoanneTo prevent over development in the area 28582017-05-09T11:32:02.4415001Ian WallaceWe are treated like second rate citizens regarding our high street in Maybole. We pay the same road tax for vechicles as everyone else but have dreadfull dangerous roads. People using our pavements on the Main Street risk their lives with the size and volume of traffic. 28562017-05-09T12:20:41.42315003Kevin mccreadieThe A77 had hundreds of thousands spent on specs systems cameras in ayrshire. These cameras have not reduced the accidents by deterring speeding. They have simply caused the A77 to become a 40mph stretch of frustration. No implementation of passing places or crawler lanes which are urgently needed given the level of haulage and agricultural traffic now using it. Maybole is now critically needing a bypass as the Main Street is a constant bottle neck when HGV's park to unload.\r\n\r\nThis is crippling the economy of the southwest of Scotland and the opportunities it can offer. It appears forgotten about with dual carriageway only available north of Ayr. Please please please sort this mess. 28562017-05-09T12:41:42.58315004John hopton Just get it sorted, its dangerous and don't want any more lifes lost28562017-05-09T12:57:37.5715005Marion BrownLook online and on i-tunes for the 'Lets Talk Withdrawal' new podcast interviews with James Moore - based in UK. These interviews are entirely relevant to this petition.28452017-05-09T13:32:20.59715006James stewartTerrible road unfit for purpose28562017-05-09T14:46:27.19315007Robert FarrenAs an owner of two small nurseries we can accommodate up to 100 children at anyone given time. As a business we try to keep our costs as affordable as possible. Considering the minimum wage has recently increased again and now this vast increase in non domestic rates. I feel a result of these two recent increases we will seriously have to consider passing these costs onto our parents due to the margins in profit not making the business profitable any more. This potential increase in fees will either make our service unaffordable for many and as a result some parents may have to remove their children from childcare. There will ultimately be a knock on effect which could result in the closure of many small nurseries. \r\nWith the increase in funded places in 2020 to 1140 hours, If many small businesses have been forced to close how will there be enough provision to cater for almost doubling the funded places. There is a strong possibility that there will not be enough partnership nurseries still in business in order to provide the 1140 when required. 28132017-05-09T15:07:31.7915008Karen McinallyI use this road regularly to visit family. It needs serious attention. I don't know how many times i have met other road users head on! Disgraceful really.28562017-05-09T16:37:10.94315010Stevie LewisIt is a major scandal of our times that people continue to be prescribed drugs which have been proven to have limited benefits and frequently worsen the original symptoms. In additional those effectively poisoned by these drugs are neither believed nor supported by the medical profession or the public at large. This needs to change.28452017-05-09T16:40:24.56715011Arlene McAvoyAs someone who regularly travels to Scotland via the aforementioned seaports I am appalled at the state of a road which for many is their introduction to Scotland. The road is dangerous and portrays how the current government are dismissive of the needs of the tourist industry on such an arterial route.28562017-05-09T16:42:27.7415012Jamie hamiltonTo many people have lost there life's on this road 28562017-05-09T16:50:32.3815013RobertDisgrace of a road for one of the biggest gateways out of United Kingdom28562017-05-09T17:33:21.9515014Alex mianI dread the Ayr to girvan road when I go to visit my mum. Worst part of the drive, the road surface is terrible and not a lot of places to pass slow vehicles such as tractors.28562017-05-09T17:36:29.57715015Shan Murray UPGRADE LONG OVERDUE 28562017-05-09T17:43:02.50715016Liz McIntosh We need to protect our beautiful country28582017-05-09T18:04:26.54715017Marlene HarrisI feel sorry for people who travel on this road every day28562017-05-09T18:56:13.66315018Adelina SlavinNot only is Whitletts Roundabout dangerous the whole of the M77 and A77 should be upgraded to motorway standard from Glasgow to Stranraer. It just makes sense. When you sèe the transformation it has made since the M80 was uograded linking tge M9 to the north and the M8 to the east of Scotland you wonder South Ayrshire and it's links to Ireland you wonder why it has taken so long to capitalise on the opportunities it could bring. It's not rocket science! 28562017-05-09T18:56:45.915019Bill Bennis Road no longer fit for purpose. Can not cope with the volume or weight of vehicles provided from boat traffic. 28562017-05-09T19:32:54.29315020MelIt's about time something gets done about this part of the A77. The small villages are becoming dangerous with the amount of traffic. Please do something before there is a serious incident.28562017-05-09T19:49:55.67315021David MartinFrom Maybole originally, interested in seeing SG plan for all road developments and where A77 upgrade fits in. I do believe the A9 dualling is the most important upgrade and it isn't due to be finished until 2025.28562017-05-09T20:18:18.72315022Patricia FergusonThis is the main aerterial route from Ayr to the ferry port at Cairnryan and is single carriageway. Due to the heavy volume of various vehicles on this road it has become extremely dangerous We need a fit for purpose infrastructure urgently in this area.28562017-05-09T20:28:02.03715023Jean ScoularSurely this region deserves an upgrade to dual carriageway considering the amount of traffic it carries travelling to and from the ferries. The road as it is a total disgrace, full of potholes and dangerous.....where is all the money going that motorists are paying at the pumps, vehicle tax, insurance tax, mot's...... Its obviously not being spent on the roads! 28562017-05-09T20:42:31.40315024Peter J GordonAs an NHS Psychiatrist who has worked in Scotland as a Consultant for over 15 years I want to offer my full support for this petition. Recently at a Cross Party Group meeting held at the Scottish Parliament it was stated that 'depression is under-recognised across all age groups' and that 'maintenance treatment has a good risk-benefit ratio.' This was said without acknowledging that these statements cannot be made with absolute certainty. I have found that my profession in Scotland seems to resist evidence of experience and at the same time prioritise the opinions of experts. Potential for Expert Bias (one): There is evidence that establishes that senior Scottish psychiatrists, who have provided expert input to Scottish Government strategies, and who have been involved in developing National prescribing guidelines, have had significant financially-based vested interests. Potential for Expert Bias (two): It is worth perhaps pointing out that Scottish Psychiatry has been traditionally orientated around biological determinants of mental health. Like myself, many academics have concluded that Scottish psychiatry lacks real-world, pluralistic breadth to the science of the mind and brain. Across the border, in England and Wales, the approach is far less reductionist. This includes the involvement of experts whose interests are not solely focussed on the bio-medical determinants of mental health. I do prescribe psychiatric medications including antidepressants but I am concerned, that despite what we are told by the 'experts' that prescribing in Scotland is hardly "conservative". 1 in 7 Scots are now taking antidepressants. Appropriate and informed prescribing is what we seek where there is open discussion about the potential benefits and potential harms of such treatments. This and an honest consideration that for many medications we cannot be certain of long-term effects.28452017-05-09T20:52:02.92315025Brian MorisonThis is nothing more than a tax on vulnerable parents and children who are already struggling to pay their nursery fees as the rates increases will inevitably have to be passed onto parents as childcare business are already closing down due to high cost.28132017-05-09T21:40:49.53715026Clodagh mcgreehanAn emotional prision is bad enough without the serious side effects and chronic illness that these meds cause. Limited opportunity for whole self recovery28452017-05-09T21:58:29.1215027Tara mckinneyWhen driving on this road I passed a car that hit pot hole that threw up a stone and I ended up needing a new windscreen the road is a disgrace !!!28562017-05-09T22:07:55.5115028Gwen barclaySeriously needing attention, so many pot holes, landslides, too much heavy traffic to from ferry ports and too many accidents ....... 28562017-05-09T23:52:23.96715029KimMy 20 year old son has been misdiagnosed and has been abused by extreme polypharmacy for years. He is now trying to come off them but the psychs and GPs don't really know what they are doing. I had to pay for an American psych to help but still he is vomiting, his head feels like it's being crushed etc. We haven't even started on the anti depressants yet. These actually change the structure of the brain and the cognitive functioning. They are handed out like Panadol but are really hard to taper off, especially if the Drs don't know what they are doing. We need more independent testing on these drugs NOT testing done by big pharma! 28452017-05-10T00:29:57.1615030Kenny skillingDual carriageway over due. 28562017-05-10T03:39:04.6115031Ann Cassidy This road is clearly not fit for purpose! 28562017-05-10T07:06:06.65315032Peter J GordonAs an NHS Psychiatrist who has worked in Scotland as a Consultant for over 15 years I want to offer my full support for this petition. 28452017-05-10T08:12:02.5315034Professor John ReadOur survey of 1800 antidepressant users, the largest ever, found that one in four were addicted and 55% experienced withdrawal symptoms when trying to stop or reduce. \r\nRead, J et al. (2014). Psychiatry Research, 216, 67-73.\r\nMeanwhile the drug companies and Royal College of Psychiatry insists they are not addictive. This is a repeat of the years if denial that benzodiazepines are addictive.\r\nAnd antidepressants are no more effective than placebo for about 90% of people. Yet one in ten people (1 in 7 women!) are prescribed these drugs every year in UK.\r\nAntipsychotics are not addictive but cause diabetes etc and shorten life span, while beating placebo for about 20%.\r\nADHD drugs are also problematic and yet are being increasingly used on our young children.28452017-05-10T09:03:05.5915035Jennifer BroadleyAs GP's time is more limited and drug companies marketing practices become more attractive, the patient is increasingly at risk - especially in relation to mental health treatments. I've seen children as young as 12 on anti-depressants - confused, struggling to make sense of their world, and now on mind-altering medication - it's not the answer and it's genuinely not safe. There are fast, effective, up-to-date therapies out there. Let people help people ... in a natural, kind, non-addictive (and non-big pharma) way.28452017-05-10T09:41:08.61315036Carolyn YatesThere is so little investment in infrastructure around Stranraer it's about time that changed. 28562017-05-10T09:57:04.0215037Catherine McDowallThere's more to Scotland than just the central belt.28562017-05-10T10:02:15.5215038Chris GreenAnd also dual the A75 to Gretna and the M6 since the railway was closed due to a lack of any long term strategic thinking. 28562017-05-10T10:42:46.10715039Heather GoodareI was on antidepressants for five years. They only did me harm. Subsequently, on my recovery, I trained as a counsellor. I had 13 years experience of work in this field, mainly with cancer patients. Research needs to be done on the links between mental and physical illness. Psychotherapeutic care can, I am sure, prevent much physical illness.28452017-05-10T12:25:42.49715040John Harvey Shocking that this road is in the state it is and that this amount of traffic is aloud to pass through so many small villages and towns. I cant believe how little crawler lanes there are between Ayr and Ballantrae with all the ferry traffic the road is basicly 40mph and in my opinion this is why there are so many accidents. People taking risks as they get frustrated with slow moving traffic.28562017-05-10T12:32:30.88715041Carol lightbody I travel up this road at least once a month to visit my mother in fife and my son and his family in Hamilton and I am getting FED up with the state of the road up at least till Glasgow. I have ruined at least 2 tyres due to hitting pot holes and on one occasion an alloyed wheel the same way. You get enough out of me with my road tax so PLEASE put it to good use 28562017-05-10T14:13:56.91715042Sharon robbIt's about time this main a77 was changed, there are lots of accidents on this road, how many fatalities has there to be before anything is done28562017-05-10T17:20:23.05715043Helen McLeanThe A75 and the A77 are long over due an upgrade the surface is deplorable, the accidents are unnecessary and totally avoidable! It's like traveling on B roads.....I have traveled in Ireland where their B roads are in better condition than this main Euro route! We are totally ignored and forgotten about in this most beautiful part of Scotland that many have not discovered or will do if we can't get visitors here safely!28562017-05-10T21:42:23.26315044Martin BartosGetting Active Travel infrastructure backed by national policy important, backing it with additional resources is vital at a time when Councils are in financial difficulties maintaining the infrastructure they have. We want good infrastructure people will use, not the cheapest option which might tick a policy box handed down centrally without an extra penny. 27632017-05-11T01:45:01.21715045Brian WallaceThe road is an absolute disgrace, between Girvan and Ayr especially. If it was down south it would of been a bypass years ago. #forgottensouthayrshire28562017-05-11T09:57:08.4115046Michael CampbellIf the 'powers that be' need further confirmation of the appalling state of that series of lumps, ruts, patches and pot holes that they like to call roads. I suggest they travel lying flat on their backs in the rear of an ambulance from Stranraer to Dumfries along the A75 like I had to do last year. Although I'd had a heart attack, the only time I actually felt ill was during the awful ambulance journey. I travelled up the A77 on Monday to Ayr and it's getting worse.28562017-05-11T10:14:11.0215047Hae ok LeeWhen I was visiting Loch Awe, I was mesmerised by the wonderful view of Loch Awe. The unspoiled scenery! Please preserve Loch Awe from wind turbines.\r\nI love Loch Obha , proud local people told me this is Loch Awe in Scottish Gaelic.28582017-05-11T10:39:04.10315048Andrea McDowallI live in maybe and the big trucks pass through the high street having to stop if they happen to meet at same point , trying to pass each other also sometimes at high speed . Accident waiti g to happen .\r\nAlso local farm vehicles on road that causes traffic build-up and having bypass would help stop this . Badly needed .28562017-05-11T11:10:37.93315049K VaughanIf this road was better I could provide supply teacher cover to Girvan Academy who frequently go without staff because of location and the transport links to there28562017-05-11T11:42:09.7215050annie borlandi use A77 from Girvan to Ayr every day for work and the road is now not fit for purpose due to the amount of large hauliers constantly using it28562017-05-11T12:58:19.6115051Karen maxwellThe A77 needs upgraded urgently. It is a forgotten part of Scotland's infrastructure which has has a high volume of traffic on it. Something has to be done. 28562017-05-11T13:11:26.56715052Emily StairInvestment is urgently needed in the rural parts of Scotland and outside of the Central Belt. This is an opportunity for South West Scotland and Scotland as a whole. It is long over-due!28562017-05-11T14:52:27.4115053Allan Trebblethis beautiful country should remain for all to enjoy.28582017-05-11T15:27:27.72715054Lorraine McFeeTo protect the beauty of our natural landscape and wildlife from unsightly development Loch Awe should be a designated NSA.28582017-05-11T16:46:36.87715055helen murrayHappy to support this ....28582017-05-11T16:47:25.04315056Steven mayallThe forgotten corner of Scotland needs both major so called A roads upgraded..NOW!!..should have been done years ago..faitalities and near misses on a daily basis..28562017-05-11T16:54:53.28315057David HunterI would like to add that a good length of the road referred to in this petition has also been subject to average speed cameras long before any other area in Scotland. While this is a very effective method of attempting to control the speed of vehicles using the road it also results in everything being generally slowed down to the speed of the slowest road user. This very often leads to frustration of drivers. The move to impose an enforcement lead solution without sufficient accompanying engineer support (ie enough suitable passing lanes) is in my opinion unacceptable and discriminates in the extreme against users of the road and in particular people who live the area and have no choice but to use the road.28562017-05-11T18:05:51.16315058Jim HoltThe A75 is desperate for upgrade also! The time has now come to stop talking, having useless meetings and public enquiries, get the diggers out and start the work tomorrow!!!28562017-05-11T18:15:58.54315059Patricia Ann HoltIt makes obvious sense to upgrade the A77 south of\r\nAyr to the ferry ports to dual carriageway.The A75 would also be improved by upgrade to dual carriageway.28562017-05-11T18:28:14.3115060William SmithPlease leave the mountains and hills around Loch Awe as they are, no more wind farms, the area should be left unspoilt for future generations.28582017-05-11T19:18:55.61715061John DicksonThis proposed road improvement is long overdue, and should proceed immediately, before a major accident occurs.28562017-05-11T19:30:04.52315062Alan MODRATEUpgrade to A77 requires serious consideration to enable the South of Scotland to prosper instead of being the forgotten backwater of Scottish politics where investment in the area is non existent. 28562017-05-11T21:07:25.06715063John MccomarckPeople of the world stop voting for globalist or soon your environment and you will soon perish.28582017-05-11T21:46:00.80715064Karon sheppard This road needs urgent attention ! It is dangerous ! Stranraer is being cut away from rest of Scotland ! 28562017-05-11T21:53:06.57315065Diana Mc Cormick It's time something is done 28562017-05-11T22:58:32.36315066John Miller.Loch awe is the jewel in Argyll28582017-05-12T08:14:40.65715067Heather steelFar too many times I've had my son in the car and people have overtaken in silly places. Lorries are qued up sometimes. Nightmare of a road between that and roadworks due to landslides 28562017-05-12T09:04:49.85315068tessa knottlong overdue for better roads in this area28562017-05-12T09:57:00.14315069Mary McCormackTotally agree.28432017-05-12T10:08:57.815070Marie BradshawWhy does this beautiful part of Scotland always seem to be missed when money is being spent? Our roads need upgrading so EVERYONE can use them safely....28562017-05-12T12:51:03.54715071Stephen FarrollThe repair work to the landslip just north of Cairnryan now needs to be prioritised to remove the traffic lights that have now been in place for too many years now! 28562017-05-12T13:51:43.0515072Elizabeth Clark Let's get roads sorted28562017-05-12T15:33:29.0715073Tony rose This should of been done years ago . I am up and down both A77 and A75 for work purposes from ayr . The roads are a complete mess . Girvan to stranraer is a shambles . Maybole is ridiculous no town should have that volume of traffic going through it . 28562017-05-12T15:54:35.21715074Ian rennie Travel this road often badly needs major repairs or a bypass as it's damaging cars 28562017-05-12T22:54:47.55315075Carol PettingaleI travel to Stranraer frequently to visit family and the roads not fit for purpose, downright dangerous.28562017-05-13T01:03:15.53715076Lorna MorrisAn upgrade would benefit the local economy, tourism, improve links with Ireland, ensure the safety of the public in Maybole.......the list is endless. The present road is dangerous!!28562017-05-13T06:25:02.50315077Nick MetcalfeScotland is one if not the most beautiful country in the world let's just leave it as it is28582017-05-13T06:49:58.9915079David WhannelEvery death on this road was the Scottish governments fault. 28562017-05-13T07:15:01.74315080thomas campbella dual carriageway upgadre on this stretch of road south of Ayr is well overdue especially gvien that there has been many times now thta l have been diverted around the back roads to get to Cairnryan bcz of landslips28562017-05-13T07:18:18.80715081thomas campbellits definitely need to be upgraded to a dual carriageway as l ahve been diverted numerous times bcz of landslides on my way to and from Cairnryan.28562017-05-13T08:35:29.9915082Iain RitchieRoad no longer fit for purpose!28562017-05-13T09:56:56.68315083Frederick GallowayMuch needed and long overdue28562017-05-13T11:25:36.08715084William h f kerrThe traffic using this road during the day is mostly HGV and commuters ,then the huge amount of tourists heading to and from Ulster is on the increase,plus the withdrawal of the ferry from Troon to Karen only increased the volume on the A77,28562017-05-13T13:47:14.7815085Thomas KerrThis road is long overdue an upgrade, due to the amount of lorry's buses and cars going through Maybole andGirvan. 28562017-05-13T13:47:56.21715086William CampbellThe road is a disgrace you have to dodge potholes all the way . And traffic lights that have been there for ages i think they have been forgotten about . I am up and down this road very regular . 28562017-05-13T17:59:56.5315087Barry Our houses are suffering..shaken to the foundations every day.28562017-05-13T20:18:55.1615088Janice MayallWe may have chosen to live in this area scenic and serene. However, centralisation of services, work commitments and some shopping experience is the reason for travelling the A77 and the A75. God help us all.... It is a nightmare journey. Please make these roads fit for purpose and safe to drive on. Maybe it would also encourage visitors to visit the area28562017-05-14T14:31:35.1315089Stuart McKenzieSheriff Hall roundabout is the scariest place I've ever cycled around - you really do dice with death everyone you go round it on the road. Crossing as a pedestrian is just as life threatening. If government is serious about healthy life style choices then it must help facilitate alternatives to the car27632017-05-14T18:38:28.01715090Sue Garrett Get it sorted niw28562017-05-14T18:58:43.74315091Val McClymontConnect Stranraer and the ferry ports with the rest of the country through road links that the central belt enjoy...we ARE part of Scotland!28562017-05-14T19:45:58.06315092T.R. McMurtrie As a motorcyclist this road is a deathtrap.28562017-05-14T20:17:01.9515093Kenny DrysdaleAn unacceptable situation in this day and age, considering infrastructure in place for smaller towns and communities up and down the country. This road is our lifeline. And damaging to vehicles. 28562017-05-15T08:36:27.55715095Phillip HamiltonThe condition of the A77 is a disgrace. The road between Girvan and Ayr lacks overtaking lanes and results in large groups of vehicle travelling, at best, at 40mph leading to frustration by many drivers. The average speed cameras are a total waste of money which would have been better spent on improving the road.28562017-05-15T09:05:03.84715096Colin McIlrathI am absolutely blown away that this wasn't done years ago - now that the Troon crossing has closed and all P&O crossings moved to Cairnryan this road has doubled in traffic especially heavy good vehicles and coaches ...28562017-05-15T09:05:11.09315097Linda Thompson This a77 is badly needing updated with the amount of traffic is on it especially when both boats come in 28562017-05-15T09:17:26.22315098Stuart telferGovernment generate a fortune in road tax and fuel tax. Come on!!!!28562017-05-15T09:39:29.50315099Billy McDougallThe road is a disgrace for the 21st century, it takes 1 and half hours to drive from Stranraer to Ayr a journey which should take 1 hour28562017-05-15T09:43:44.815100Carolyn HastieWe frequently travel this road as we visit our Daughter in Glasgow, we dread the journey from Ayr to Stranraer as the roads are a Disgrace, for the amount of Traffic using the A77 it is long Overdue being Upgraded28562017-05-15T10:49:35.06315101Ian J CarlileLong overdue. This is an extremely busy road which carries LGV traffic to and from the Ferry port. Maybole High Street was never designed to cope with this amount or weight of traffic. It must be started and soon. 28562017-05-15T11:48:32.03715102Julie SomervilleTravel from Stranraer to Girvan regularly and the potholes and road surface are terrible, never mind the traffic lights and long diversions when it's closed at any point.28562017-05-15T12:54:42.70315103Anne BowmanNeeds upgrading to make it a safer road before there's more accidents and death's28562017-05-15T13:23:53.45715104Alex Bennett Upgrade the road as well as fix the potholes in all roads 28562017-05-15T14:18:35.5315105Jean ScoularThis road is a disgrace, full of potholes.....with 2 ferries operating from Cairnryan this road should have been upgraded years ago. Where does all the money go that is collected from vehicle tax, ins tax, tax on fuel? Certainly not spent on the roads!28562017-05-15T16:55:46.315106Peter LeatherOne of the most beautiful areas in Scotland should be protected for many generations to enjoy28582017-05-15T17:39:39.0915107Elizabeth BrownThis beautiful area should be protected for the enjoyment of all28582017-05-15T18:47:52.06315108Jamie BeamishIt would be unforgivable to put such bolts on this stunning landscape. When hydro would be a better energy option.28582017-05-15T18:53:38.42315110Julie BeamishI run a B&B on the side of Loch Awe and having canvassed views of visitors it is clear they see wind farms having a totally negative effect on the landscape. 28582017-05-15T21:42:28.67315111Rachael McBurnieBadly needs fixed 28562017-05-15T22:10:33.84315112Craig HunterConstant road works on this road repairing the mess the trucks make of the road, this road was never designed to take this amount of heavy traffic, stop wasting money fixing it and build a new road.28562017-05-15T22:31:18.91315113Diana Mc Cormick Long overdue 28562017-05-15T22:54:48.5115114Gillian How many more lives will the A77 claim due to poor road conditions , land slips and eager drivers trying to make the ferries 28562017-05-16T10:50:33.44715115Ben HerschellThe A77 is also the road most people go to get to the 2 Cairnryan ports so dueling would help these people immensely28562017-05-16T11:49:34.83715116Nicola converyThis road is very busy especially when travelling to carnryan for the ferry and you are stuck behind tractors, lorries etc people start over taking on corners putting other road users in danger a by pass need to be put in in place from Ayr to Stranraer avoiding the towns and the A77.28562017-05-16T12:02:47.6615117Stuart BaileyI get nervous on Sheriffhall in a car never mind a bike. If a new roundabout is to be put in place then suitable infrastructure for, not only cyclists, but pedestrians too needs to be considered.27632017-05-16T12:18:29.24715118Bruce ThomsonDo something about Bathgate please, almost zero for cyclists.27632017-05-16T13:54:30.1915119JamesThrough no fault of my own, I was hit by a car the Thursday before Christmas while commuting to work on my bike. This was not at the Sheriffhall roundabout, but at 'Murder roundabout' in Bathgate (also known as Boghall roundabout). I don't believe the driver who hit me was being malicious, just careless while driving on a road not designed with cyclists in mind. If we want to get more people cycling, we need to make the roads safer27632017-05-16T13:59:50.9915120martin muirThe A77 puts people of visiting this area of Scotland28562017-05-16T15:03:54.76315121Nicola Holland The A77...a road built for horse & cart not cars and lorry's!!!28562017-05-17T08:46:56.74315122Sebastian LisiThe most disgracefully neglected A road in UK28562017-05-17T09:58:43.25315123Jeanette Miller Long over due time to act now 28562017-05-17T10:18:50.21715124Nick StaceyNot only the A77 but the A75 should also be looked at, both are long overdue for a proper upgrade. 28562017-05-17T14:21:03.97715125Peter HillI think we have to do all we can to help ourselves and others get better treatment for this disease.28042017-05-17T14:24:58.80715126Jean Renwick ForsterTesting is abysmal and treatment is non existent. Costing my husband and I a fortune for private treatment out of our pension.28042017-05-17T14:30:56.69715127Mr William Gallowaythe a77 is a death trap the it is at the moment\r\n28562017-05-17T14:32:45.35315128Jules DubThose infected with Lyme Disease (Borrelia and coinfections) are being neglected. People are left disabled, unable to work, to contribute to society, losing their relationships, financial status, quality of life. You MUST do something to change this. Lyme Disease is a fast growing illness, which has reached pandemic levels. \r\n\r\nThe UK now have an APPG, more needs to be done in Scotland - Ticks don't recognise borders, migrating birds allow them to travel.\r\n\r\nI am a Scot, my family originate from the Black Isle. So whilst I reside in the UK I have family and friends who I visit in Scotland.28042017-05-17T14:35:03.20315129Sylvia McCulloch The route between ballantrae and cairnryan is not fit for lorries. It's a nightmare driving when meeting traffic28562017-05-17T14:46:45.4815130Lorraine MurrayI've been failed due to the inaccuracy of the current NHS, nhs Drs failed to spot the signs and I was misdiagnosed with cfs. Also failed by Infectious disease as they failed to recognise my symptoms. I was forced to get a private specialist and send my blood abroad to specialist labs which indeed returned positive with Lyme and several other co infections Babesia, Ehrichliosis and Bartonella. I pay for all my treatment which has resulted in thousands. I feel badly let down!28042017-05-17T14:57:51.80315131Julie VarleyI'm a cancer patient, travelling the A77 many times. My driver has to allow 3 hours to travel 110 miles, at least, and that's each way. They are many of us doing this, each time we need a test, consultation or treatment. The amount of potholes is ridiculous and tortuous after major surgery. Basically, South West Scotland has sub standard roads, I've seen 2 lorries trying to get round tight bends, at the same time. It's a major route for tourists and freight, making their way South or to Northern Ireland. I used to work on the passenger ferries, at the information desk where many people came to complain about the roads. What could I do? Sign a Petition!28562017-05-17T14:57:56.6715132Hazel cloyThis is a terrible road and seriously needs upgrading28562017-05-17T15:09:01.6715133William grahamSurely this route is not fit for modern day function. 28562017-05-17T15:15:30.7515134Dave WalshI was one of the "lucky" few who tested positive for Lyme through NHS. Unfortunately basic treatment didn't cure me . NHS does not recognise Chronic Lyme. It took private treatment and a number of years to get into remission28042017-05-17T15:24:47.11715135KimAbsolutely shocking that road. I used to live in ballantrae. The road was one of the reasons I moved. Spent a lot time on the back round due to roadworks and accidents.28562017-05-17T16:10:29.24315136Rob FallenNeeds to be taken more seriously and better treatment available to those suffering Lyme28042017-05-17T16:56:45.11715137Lorraine murrayWe desperately require the government to improve training for gps in Lyme disease to spot the signs earlier. We also need improvements of existing methods of testing. Treatment needs to be improved as someone with a few days infection to 20 years of infection are receiving the same treatment. Research shows we are also not testing for other known bacterial species and parasites that can be acquired from the same tick bite, thus leaving patients still sick with a chronic infection. I know as\r\nI'm one of them. This needs changed as a matter of urgency! 28042017-05-17T17:00:24.29715138Kathryn WalkerTo leave people with a serious, crippling disease with no medical care is a human rights' abuse. 28042017-05-17T17:11:49.2315139Moira RaffanLorraine was misdiagnosed by her gp with chronic fatigue & being a really fit athlete now reduced to a mobility scooter, please update your Lyme test & gp awareness on signs & symptoms. \r\nI am a Paramedic & I phoned & discussed Lyme with one of our gp's who admitted he new very little other than the British medical health guidelines & his belief was once treated by antibiotics & your cured. No fault of the gp better education is what is needed in local surgeries all through Scotland 28042017-05-17T17:19:09.2515140Jacqueline kiddTravel this road every day to and from work it's a disgrace there is always traffic lights but within a couple of days road is as bad as ever28562017-05-17T17:26:42.3315141Scott Raffan How many more cases before the government act on this serious illness.28042017-05-17T17:28:05.9115142Elizabeth SinclairI think that parliament should do something about this as the system does not seem to work very well surely the slcc should stand up and admit their failings .28732017-05-17T17:50:01.37315143Andy Horse As someone who has had their life ruined by Lyme misdiagnosed for twenty years, far too late to treat effectively, mind and body destroyed. I wouldn't wish it on anybody. I first asked for a test in 1996, to be told ' no Lyme in Cumbria ' again and again, now I have to jump through dwp ideological hoops again and again to receive a pittance to be exist on, sometimes wish I weren't here. Don't get Lyme, and most doctors are clueless and nhs treatment protocols wholly inadequate, so trust your instincts if feeling unwell. Good luck.28042017-05-17T18:05:34.53315145Mr Edward J LawsonLyme disease is increasingly common in Scotland and is still not seen as the significant health risk it is. The costs of ignoring this growing problem are likely to be huge.28042017-05-17T18:13:13.96315146Barbara Anne CattI have a cousin with Lyme's disease and wouldn't wish it on anyone. It appears to be poorly diagnosed with little attention yet affects many, and some severely. Something ought to be done to raise its profile and hopefully this petition will do that.28042017-05-17T18:47:20.15315147Christine RobertsonCome and travel to Ireland.28562017-05-17T18:58:23.79715148Sandra NicolMore research should be carried out to seek a cure or find more effective treatment for sufferers.28042017-05-17T19:38:17.815149Susan CrosthwaiteThe road is incredibly dangerous with holiday traffic and heavy goods lorries28562017-05-17T19:46:52.1315150Carol roySigned28042017-05-17T19:47:00.64715151David BowlerMore support and government funding into this28042017-05-17T19:50:56.0815152Eric WilsonThis road is a main artery (along with the A75 ) to Ireland and upgrades to both are long overdue with huge amounts of freight coming and going from the ferry ports at Cairnryan.28562017-05-17T20:54:06.06315153Anna WoodWe urgently need better detection, knowledge and treatment of Lyme disease, as well as recognition that it can become chronic. I got infected in Scotland I believe 42 years ago. I only found out I had Lyme disease 2 years ago, having had many years of a useless ME diagnosis, lots of detrimental treatment by doctors & wholesale ignorance. Some of us believe we are in the grip of a hidden Lyme epidemic, with Lyme being wrongly diagnosed as ME, CFS, fibromyalgia & even MS. It is also playing a role in ALS & Alzheimers & some of its associated infections may be contributing to autistic spectrum disorders. Infected ticks are on the increase. I have since passed on my disease to my daughter in utero. Please help stop the unnecessary suffering.28042017-05-17T20:55:52.515154Billy OliverI have been pursuing the lack of funding through MSP Brian Whittle. We wrote to Transport Scotland Chief.\r\nHe replied, since 2007 £43M has been spent on the A77. This year £2.1 M was spent at Cairnryan Landslip and a further £900K is to be spent resurfacing at Minishant & Maybole.\r\nI replied that £43 M was for the full 91 miles of A77 not South of Ayr and that was over a 10yr period when Symington Boggtoll at a cost of £22m was completed. I compaired the £900k resurfacing expenditure to A9 works at 9 different locations completed over the same 10 year period which went into the hundred million marker and the A9 work in Preparation today at eleven separate locations upgrading to dual carriageway at a cost of £3 Billion, this is for one road only, they already have huge expenditure on M8, Forth Bridge, A96 and have asked for an explanation. All cost's and info were taken from Transport Scotland website and Audit Scotland website, go and have a read, it would give you the boak the amount of money being lavished up the East Coast and central belt and no sign of stopping. 28562017-05-17T21:00:25.42315155Malcolm Macgregor Maybole by pass approved when I at primary school over50 years ago still not happened and the road down to Stranraer long been a disaster 28562017-05-17T21:07:56.09715156Lorraine heron Terrible road, with far too many closures 28562017-05-17T21:32:38.2515157Scott raffan Government need to get there act together 28042017-05-17T21:32:55.1615158George TaitScotland needs more NSAs to assist our vital tourist industry. They help to highlight and protect unique areas like Loch Awe which is after all, the longest freshwater lake in Scotland28582017-05-17T21:54:38.1115159Joanne thomsonLast January I had a bad car accident in the a77 it badly needs a bypass before any more life's are lost 28562017-05-17T22:04:27.6215160ErinThis is vital to the area of Stranraer and further west and makes it feel even more remote and isolated than it already is as it deters visitors. 28562017-05-17T22:15:51.03715161ROSAMy friend was not diagnosed on time and her symptoms were ignored for a long time. Now she is suffering the consequences and her quality of life has been hugely affected.28042017-05-17T22:16:55.32315162Diana LeyMore detailed research into Lyme Disease is vital. This is a very complicated Disease & the old bacteria has developed so much it can hide itself.28042017-05-17T22:36:38.4315163Christopher CoganIn my case NHS tests and Dr's spotted my Lyme disease 10 years ago. But because of their lack of knowledge on treatment I wasn't given a strong enough or long enough course of antibiotics until I was very ill. By the time I received intravenous antibiotics the Lyme Disease had reached every where in my body.\r\nWhen your struggling to be a normal person and the infectious disease consultant says " there's nothing else we can do for you" does leave a alfa male in bits, without much hope of feeling part of society again.28042017-05-17T22:46:14.19715164Elvira Elena Garcia-AlvarezI support this petition!28562017-05-17T22:47:53.6715165Margaret GellatelyThe A77 is a total disgrace and in no way meets the needs of this area. Nothing seems to matter south of Glasgow. 28562017-05-17T23:16:55.8315166Carol pertWith living in an area that ticks are very commonly found I find it quite scary that people are not knowledgeable how dangerous they can be. More awareness is most definitely needed also the medical knowledge and treatment need to be brought to attention of local doctor practices especially in areas where Lyme disease can be contracted 28042017-05-17T23:55:51.08715167Joanne McCullough Professionals need more training 28042017-05-18T01:01:57.11715168Anita Butcher I have declined since my NHS test in 2007 inaccuratly came back negative. I was misdiagnosed with Fibromyalgia and I'm now in a wheelchair with dibilatating arthritis and now need a liver transplant as it's been severely damaged by untreated Lyme disease and Co infections. I have since tested with Armin lab4 and I have 7 bacterial infections and 2 viruses. My life has been taken from e due to NHS inaccurate trsting methods. The pain daily is unbearable, please update testing. It will save the NHS millions if testing was accurare I would be able to see my young son grow up. I will die in the next 2 yrs due to not getting a simple course of abx in time. The NHS have robbed my son and many others of thier Mums, Dad's and family something must be done.28042017-05-18T01:25:18.29315169Elaine Houston Murray I have had this disease for over forty years. Failed by doctors and specialists and left to find out about Lyme disease alone while chronically ill.28042017-05-18T06:46:36.2915170Simon JacynaI am concerned that the prevelence and severity of this disease is so poorly recognised by doctors and the public.28042017-05-18T07:35:20.20315172Colette Arthurson Medical knowledge poor among GP's28042017-05-18T07:35:24.5315173Jo Fergusson Equality28042017-05-18T08:13:21.09715174Miss Carol swordSomeone I know has been diagnosed and is still going through treatment for Lyme disease but has had to go to Washington in the states for specialist treatment.28042017-05-18T08:27:39.00715175SinkMy sister has been thoroughly let down with the provisions, if you can call them that, for the testing and treatment of tick bourne illnesses. She's made local and national media with her bee sting therapy, which seems to be helping. 28042017-05-18T08:29:39.61315176shirley fergusonOur roads are a disgrace, and is putting lives at danger.28562017-05-18T09:09:36.21315177Fiona Culbert My teenage sons health and education has been devastated by Lyme disease. Every step has been a fight for diagnosis and "treatment ". Two years since the nhs highland wrote lyme disease a ticking time and yet it is still there is no coherent strategy on awareness, children (and adults) are being sent out ill prepared on outdoor activities not knowing the risks of tick borne illness Diagnosis is a lottery and treatment even more so. Tick borne illness is a health challenge here to stay so why don't the Government and NHS Scotland face up to their obligations to those enjoying Scotlands outdoors? ?28042017-05-18T09:34:25.24715178Valerie DuchartIt is sad in this hi tech era that tests show up as inconclusive and doctors tell you to live with it. If a disease is known and named it should be treated so do more research and stop going on about costs.28042017-05-18T10:34:08.96315179Jim cartnerI travel on this road to go to Stranraer and have been for years? Why is there a bus stop in the middle of nowhere? Why is something not being done to get this road upgraded it is a disgrace! 28562017-05-18T11:14:30.73715180Adam CalderwoodThis road is a disgrace 28562017-05-18T11:17:27.87715181James MellorThis is an iconic area welcoming visitors and residents alike to Argyll and should not be spoiled!28582017-05-18T11:56:27.8815182Scott Raffan How would you feel if it was your family that was affected 28042017-05-18T12:23:22.57315183Liz bamfordShould be more awareness within gp practices giving early diagnosis and treatment and more funds for research28042017-05-18T14:52:08.32715184Morag Black Something must be done now ! 28042017-05-18T15:18:50.8115185Carol Gibson Road is ridiculous considering the amount of traffic especially heavy freight using it28562017-05-18T15:25:45.5315186David marshallHow many more landslides will it take before someone is washed down these hills and cause carnage yet again 28562017-05-18T15:36:50.25715187MattIt always begs belief seeing the traffic from Ayr Hospital almost down to Sandyford Roundabout. Every. Single. Day.\r\nPeople cutting in, lorries inching by. People stuck for miles. What an attractive place to live.\r\nThere are 5 roundabouts already within a few miles. And they want to build another near the 2700 housed proposal that is the SE Ayr development? Are they joking?28562017-05-18T16:25:17.36715188Christine andersonIt is a terrible disease and taccurate testing is vital. 28042017-05-18T16:44:33.07315189JOHN HILLI am very much pro green energy and carbon reduction and genrally am supportive of turbines. However, on this occasion a balance between need and preserving the natural is required. This is an ill conceived location and will spoil an area of natural beauty and importance. There are other options I am sure, has offshore for example been considered ?28582017-05-18T17:09:35.31315190George RosieI think testing should start ASAP28042017-05-18T17:22:00.18715191AnneHave to drive that road every day !! Traffic lights for the last 2.5 years pot holes every where please get it sorted .28562017-05-18T17:35:53.7515192Ann Maher We Lyme disease Patients need Accurate testing, adequate Treatment for an adequate length of time 28042017-05-18T17:48:40.42715193Friend of ClaireNot a sufferer but a friend has been treated very badly, dismissed by her GP and spends every day fighting for treatment while she progressively gets sicker. Not right and she's not alone in her suffering. Disgraceful.28042017-05-18T18:01:08.42715194ANGELA LUCASI HAVE BEEN FAILED BY INADEQUATE LATE TREATMENT & SUFFERED FROM PATRONISING DISBELIEF BUT FINALLY, RECENTLY, OBTAINED A POSITIVE TEST RESULT FROM PORTON DOWN MANY YEARS AFTER INITIAL NEGATIVE NHS TESTS. SADLY CHRONIC LYME , WHICH I BELIEVE I STILL SUFFER FROM, IS NOT RECOGNISED.28042017-05-18T18:59:37.99315195PashaMy strength to your arm!28042017-05-18T19:11:28.89315196Sue Couper Scotland appears to be behind other countries in diagnostics and treatment and inferior to the USA and the continent. The awareness by the government and medical professionals is abysmal.28042017-05-18T19:41:40.715197W LivingstonHad the bulls eye rash 35 yes ago. Had many problems since but only found out what rash meant 2yrs ago. Tested twice with ELISA, both negative. Infectious disease consultant said I didn't have Lyme. Now having neurological problems, GP referred me to neurologist. 7 month waiting list. The NHS does not want to know.28042017-05-18T19:44:08.3115198BabsBoth roads in and out of Stranraer need sorting, they were alright 30 years ago but now with so much traffic it's dangerous!!!28562017-05-18T20:02:24.6115199EDITHDone28042017-05-18T20:06:26.1515200Robert SavageThis is long overdue and will reduce speed and save lifes if the road is improved. 28562017-05-18T20:24:37.0515201Andy LogieSurely in this day and age there should be better understanding of this disease in this country28042017-05-18T20:49:30.3515202David MollisonI think more should be done to help the medical profession identify Lyme disease. Also more need to be done to help prevent it28042017-05-18T20:49:41.62715203GillianPender The British assays for detection of Lyme are currently inappropriate and not sensitive enough. Tests in USA and Germany are much more thorough and sensitive. Further, Lyme causes many other acute and chronic disorders. My friend's 22year old son was bed bound, so severe are his symptoms and they HAD to get private clinical treatment to get any relief for him. 28042017-05-18T21:53:58.1115204CorrineThere are many suffering due to the NHS inadequacies in testing and treatment 28042017-05-18T22:06:48.4115205margaret grahamWorst road in Britain\r\n28562017-05-18T22:29:51.4915206Jane MeekSo much has already been lost. Please help to save what is left before it is too late.28582017-05-18T23:16:40.9115207Carla StachuraI would like to visit a beautiful, quiet, natural place without turbines! They are horrendous and a blight on the countryside!28582017-05-18T23:21:39.04315208Morag DowieLong overdue not safe 28562017-05-19T00:53:30.6515209RICHARD RoachIWT in this area would be terrible28582017-05-19T01:50:59.99715210Jutta (Northern Germany)For visitors to the Scottish countryside, with their beauty and silence around Loch Awe and other places, it is terrifying to imagine that this is soon to be a thing of the past. As tourists, we are not looking for ugly, noisy wind turbines that kill Avifauna and make people sick.\r\nThis wind power hell we have everywhere in Germany and we hope that the Scottish fellow citizens and nature will be spared so that we continue to have a place to escape this hell in Germany at least temporarily28582017-05-19T07:13:56.33715211Butre Jean Louisand cultural heritage by their harmful effect on landscapes and historic buildings. \r\nwind farms imperil wildlife and destroy natural habitats which have hitherto escaped the destructive powers of earth-moving equipment, concreting operations and other highly invasive human activities.28582017-05-19T08:16:17.415212Megan BarkI was involved in a head on collision on this route and so lucky to be alive but my life will never be the same.28562017-05-19T08:21:02.09315213James BarkMy wife and I were both in a head on collision on the A77!. We are two of the lucky ones but would canvass and fight for upgrade as it has totally changed our lives.28562017-05-19T08:25:52.315214Amanda HenryShocking to watch the folks of Maybole on the pavements whilst lorries are but a few inches off them driving at speed! Not to mention the horrendous driving all the road to Stranraer. This road is not fit to carry the amount of lorries headed for Ireland without endgering lives 28562017-05-19T08:38:18.67715215Jacqueline Nish Long over due. With all the traffic on the A77 it's time it was upgraded to duel carriage way.28562017-05-19T09:15:33.5715216jacqui butterworth30yrs of this illness and sick of the attitude of Uk NHS doctors28042017-05-19T09:26:59.41315217Linda Pyatt The road works are constant but little improvement is apparent. \r\nPot holes are a nightmare cars swerving to avoid them including myself, when the deep holes fill with rain the depth cannot be determined, therefore a potential serious accident waiting for bikers either cycle or motorbike. \r\nDo we really need more deaths and life changing accidents before something is done?\r\nWe are all aware of financial cutbacks, but at what cost, somebodys loved one, you or I perhaps.28562017-05-19T09:31:48.86715218Henry RiddochThe IDSA (Infectious Diseases Society of America) guidelines for the treatment of Lyme disease used in the UK by NICE deny the existence and treatment of the Chronic form of Lyme disease and are not fit for purpose. They have been challenged many times in the USA, and were last year removed from the Clearing House for Treatment Guidelines and have been replaced by the guidelines generated by ILADS (International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society) which acknowledge the existence of the chronic form of Lyme disease and give diagnosis and treatment guidelines. for all forms of Lyme disease.\r\nI have suffered from Lyme disease since first being infected with a tick bite in the early nineties, but UK doctors still deny my chronic Lyme diagnosis and try to tell me I have ME, and refuse treatment. I now travel to the USA at my own considerable expense for consultation and treatment., but there are many who cannot afford to go overseas for treatment who are left high and dry by the medical profession in the UK who have not had adequate training in the diagnosis and treatment of Lyme and are working under a strictly enforced set of guidelines from NICE which are outdated and not fit for purpose28042017-05-19T09:47:08.43315219Hammy mcmillan This government and previous ones have spent the money in the north and central belt scandalous 28562017-05-19T11:10:03.3215220Jenny O'DeaI think they should consider T cell testing as part of a Lyme diagnosis, antibody testing is not always adequate. They use T cell tests for TB as the antibody tests are inaccurate (according to the world health organisation). There are many alternative tests on the market - until they do away with antiquated 2 tier testing many patients will continue to be missed & treated too late, allowing a more complicated illness to progress. We need more open minds instead of closed agendas...28042017-05-19T12:24:58.29715221Clive StaceyI have been travelling from Southern England to Loch Avich for over 30 years, at least once, sometimes three times a year. It is without out a doubt unique and beautiful even by Scottish standards and needs to be protected urgently. 28582017-05-19T12:38:47.5515222Thomas O'Grady Wake up this is a massive problem in Scotland 28042017-05-19T12:52:30.73715223Marshall Rosenthal"Renewable" energy schemes must never be allowed to blight National Scenic Areas. Wind power is a particularly pernicious form of this and must never be allowed to expand onto NSA's.28582017-05-19T13:07:08.61715224Margaret McCrorie This road is a disgrace its also terrifying when driving home or to work on this narrow twisty road with double decker lorries swaying round corners, Actually saw one lying in the ditch coming home from work outside my village (Kirloswald) the road carries too much traffic now to be single lanes. 28562017-05-19T13:18:27.47715225Mark MagielseI contracted my Lyme on a cycling trip in Scotland in September 2015... never seen any warning - notice, otherwise I would have taken antibiotics after the tick-bite28042017-05-19T13:23:57.47715226Isobel Macfarlane Pavements need to be attended to also. I have to use a mot ability scooter to get about and holes in pavements are a disgrace.28562017-05-19T13:35:15.22715227AMGI travel this road between Stranraer & Glasgow from 8 to 12 times a month & have done for 6 years ...... the decline of the road surface & the increase in 'near misses' caused by driver frustration in that period is incredible ! The quality of the road for the amount of traffic using it is nothing short of atrocious...... infact it is downright DANGEROUS !! 28562017-05-19T13:40:25.68315228AMGIf the A77 between Stranraer & Ayr was something you could purchase from a shop, you'd be well within your rights to return it under the sale of goods act as 'unfit for purpose' ........ because it's just that - it's neither safe or suitable for the amount of traffic using it !!! 28562017-05-19T14:07:21.6115230IreneDon't be fooled by the Wind Weasels who sell and profit from this intermittent,unreliable, devastatingly-expensive form of energy. Do your homework and learn what a devestation these are to humans, animals, birds and the natural environment. Shame to ruin the beauty of Scotland for the benefit of the few 1% who will benefit and are probably off-shore companies. 28582017-05-19T15:02:58.47715231David MuirThe islands of the Uists have the greatest number of recorded cases per capita with more than 300 times likelihood of contracting the disease than generally elsewhere in Scotland. Many are long-term sufferers of Lyme disease and while prevention is key, implementation of improved treatment protocols is essential in combating this debilitating disease.28042017-05-19T15:04:26.83315232Ali FraserConsidering this road serves two main ports and the volume of traffic that uses it not only commercial but tourism , its time those in power bring this road up to modern day standards not a horse and cart track which it is currently akin to in places .28562017-05-19T17:52:48.07315233Shirley RisdonWhen you consider that the A77 is the only road from the ferry going north, for traffic from the whole of Ireland, it is a total disgrace. If there is an accident between Stranraer and Ballantrae causing the road to be closed the detour is via Newton Stewart and takes for ever. It is about time for an upgrade.28562017-05-19T17:54:06.04715234Emma Nutbeen Better testing, research and treatment is desperately needed. At present only those that are affluent or fund raise can treat this condition and those that can't are a burden on our much strapped NHS due to repeat hospitalisation. Not waking up to Lyme is a huge false economy.28042017-05-19T20:19:40.61315235John BannisterRoutine testing and diagnosis seem to remain an afterthought in some areas, whereas generally the Highlands and Islands populations are more likely to present with symptoms, given the acute risk factor of their living environment. Apocryphally, this should be taken more seriously by health professionals than appears to be the present case. 28042017-05-19T20:58:30.64715236Stephen Roger DyerDespite mounting scientific, peer reviewed evidence to the contry, NHS Scotland continues to peddle three misnomers. Firstly, negative serology means you do not have Lyme. Second, short term antibiotic therapy is adequate to handle all Lyme infections (and hence deny chronic Lyme). Thirdly, consider the presence of co-infections is of little or no importance. 28042017-05-19T21:15:28.67315237KennyIt is time for the power brokers to stop making excuses and start delivering for the people & industries of South West Scotland. A lot of The businesses that use and rely on the A77 are on their kness and road improvements would vastly help to give these communities the much needed boost in terms of economic regeneration that improved road infrastructure would help bring. I am not even going to mention the road safety benefits it would deliver.\r\n\r\nCome on we pay our taxes in SW Scotland and deserve a fair slice of the cake.28562017-05-19T21:28:36.16715238Hugh forrestI travel this road every second sunday there is more potholes than there is decent road surface,passing places are non existant ,and the volume of traffic using this not fit for purpose road is totally unacceptable28562017-05-19T22:46:39.37315239Alyson FisherI have travelled this road for the past 13yrs whilst commuting to work as a staff nurse at Ayr Hospital. The road is certainly not fit for purpose and is in very poor condition with landslides and potholes. I have lost count of the number of times the road has shut due to accidents, land slips, roadworks which involves a hefty detour round the back roads which is particularly unwelcome at the end of a twelve hour shift. I have had quite a few " near misses " probably caused by drivers becoming frustrated at being stuck behind lorries etc and rushing to catch the ferry. Something needs to be done to make this road fit for purpose and able to cope with the high volume of traffic it deals with on a daily basis! 28562017-05-19T22:52:27.1415240David SheilFor what are supposed to be main Euroroutes our government should be ashamed. We badly need some support and funding to bring the A77 and A75 up to a reasonable standard. 28562017-05-20T00:28:09.10715241Bruce BuswellThough I live in England, I believe I have a right to comment. I visit Scotland as often as I can afford. It may be that I caught my Lyme Disease in Scotland over thirty years ago.28042017-05-20T09:50:26.62715242Katherine MacleanMy husband is a deer stalker, I am a horticulturist. Also friends affected with Lyme's. Deeply concerned. 28042017-05-20T09:54:34.45715243Murdoch MacleanHelp move this forward.28042017-05-20T10:30:23.44315244Elizabeth WilsonI was one of the lucky ones to be tested and given treatment early. I'd a gut feeling I'd Lyme and although I'd no red ring my GP tested me. Others are not so fortunate.28042017-05-20T10:46:20.915245David McNicollThe condition of the road is appalling. Just repairing the road surface and removing the seemingly permanent traffic lights would be welcome progress.28562017-05-20T13:24:09.79715246Andrew PrenticeThe prevalence of ticks carrying Lyme disease has increased dramatically in the past decade. It now carries a substantial threat to people who work and visitors who enjoy their leisure time in the countryside of Scotland making reliable testing and treatment of this disease a primary target for the medical profession, backed up with a public awareness campaign.28042017-05-20T14:46:11.99715247Mel FowlerPlease, please,please do something about this awful disease.28042017-05-20T20:38:58.55315248Sally NewtonI frequently seem to know more than the doctors who are doing their best to treat residual Lyme's effects. \r\nI am better off than many others who struggle to get any support or treatment. \r\nTests are a joke and the way Lyme disease is reported leads to a huge underestimate of numbers of people affected.28042017-05-21T15:16:57.15715249Alison MacleodGPs need to be educated in clinically diagnosing this disease from presenting symptoms following a known tick bite. They also need to have better guidelines about correct doses of antibiotics to ensure the infection does not persist. Patients presenting with symptoms should always be treated as the consequences of developing Lyme disease are so debilitating and life changing. The public must be made more aware of these risks. Clinical diagnosis is particularly important given the unreliability of current tests. In addition Infectious Disease departments need to be aware that the disease can be transmitted in a short space of time ( in my case 30 minutes ) and ticks do not have to be attached for 24 hours which is the advice which is currently being given to GPs, who may then fail to treat. 28042017-05-21T16:08:48.78315250Nicola SealAt present, Lyme patients in Scotland are treated appallingly. Misdiagnosed, told it is all in their head or just a virus, given a short course of antibiotics then sent on their way. No consideration is given to the persistent nature of the bacteria or the fact many have coinfections which complicate the clinical picture and treatment. If I hadn't been able to pay for private antibiotic treatment I'd probably be dead now. 28042017-05-21T16:15:09.63315251Alison MacleodGPs must treat symptoms following known tick bites with the correct length and dose of antibiotics as the consequences of not doing this are so extreme i.e. another sufferer from debilitating lyme disease. GPs must be trained to diagnose clinically. Infectious diseases must get their advice to GPs correct ie. that ticks do not need to be attached for 24 hours to pass on infection. Improved testing is essential given the unreliability of the current tests. The public must be made aware of how to recognise symptoms and what to do to stop lyme disease. This is vital as tick populations increase. 28042017-05-21T16:31:12.79315252Greta Gallandy-JakobsenPlease don't destroy your wonderful country with these useless and dangerous machines. Everybody knows, this technology is a big mistake. It will cost a fortune to remove all the turbines after a rather short time. Think about your great history. 20 og 30 years are nothing compared with that. To plan the country's future must be done in a quite different way. Think of 200 years instead. Who will live in your country and how? And then look back. What have these destructive and dangerous turbines done for the Scottish people? Nothing. It was only a obsessice idea to "save the planet" , but only the investors' and industry's pockets were saved from being empty. Please look at your wonderful old landscapes and see, how they would be spoiled with this industrial rotating structures and how your own rural people are suffering from this.28582017-05-21T18:45:08.49715253Alina BurnsStop ignoring this awful chronic disease!28042017-05-21T18:48:24.98315254Lorna BramleyTick bite in Scotland 1996, NHS Positive test two months later. Two weeks antibiotics and then no more treatment on NHS even though I deteriorated slowly for 20 yrs. Unacceptable.28042017-05-21T20:14:02.74715255Jean BowmanWe need to keep beautiful areas, just that! We'll get more from tourism, keeping our area beautiful. Industrialising the area will lose us business and very likely cause ill health to residents, a fail fail !28582017-05-21T20:18:19.14715256Mark Herridge I have chronic Lyme disease and it's killing me, mainly through ignorance and the unwillingness of medical experts here in England to even consider helping 28042017-05-21T20:51:32.38715257Michael CAINThe land does not require any more structures28582017-05-21T20:53:02.31715258Vincent QuintWe have been several times in that area. I can't immagine that someboddy thinks about building these windmills. Thats crazy! Don't do it !!!!!28582017-05-21T21:00:29.10715259Bill MillerFeels like you are driving in a third world country at times when trying to negotiate the numerous hazards presented to you on this road. The upgrade is now long overdue and the residents and indeed all users of the A77 need this to happen now before more sorrow and heartache occurs on this so called A class road.28562017-05-21T21:02:20.2415260Tony BramleyAs a (retired) research endocrinologist I am appalled by the poor, unreliable tests for Borrelia and co-infections.28042017-05-21T21:51:06.96315261Diane MillarDon't want another eyesore28582017-05-21T22:08:00.45715262Ian Purves This is so important. Ticks and their diseases are becoming more and more prevalent. We send our youngsters out hill walking etc, these diseases will affect their lives forever if not treated properly! 28042017-05-21T22:31:06.72715263Margaret GralewiczLymes is becoming an increasing problem in Scotland - something that is life changing for this affected. We need to do all we can to be up to date on both prevention and treatment. 28042017-05-22T00:15:31.03715264James M CrookIt seems hard to believe that someone would look to ruin the unique landscape of Loch Awe by erecting huge wind turbines. People travel from far and wide to enjoy the Loch and it's amazing views, and the introduction of new wind farms would severely threaten this.28582017-05-22T05:58:04.15315265Bert van ReinIt is unbelievable that a beautiful and historic nature reserve can be sacrificed to monetary gain. Shameless and disrespectful!28582017-05-22T12:16:07.6915266Sonia moylesG.p s need full training on Lyme disease. I along with many others have had a long and hard fight to get this disease recognised. It's about time it's given real recognition 28042017-05-22T15:07:08.01315267SarahIt is unacceptable that we don't have better education of doctors and testing methods for a disease that is so disabiling if not treated correctly early enough. Less than 3% of GPs have taken the RCGP course on Lyme disease and the 2 tier testing relied on in this country is shown in research to be around 50% accurate. Missing cases has too large a cost both to tax payers and the individuals whose lives are impacted by this dreadful disease. 28042017-05-22T15:50:29.21315268Hugh TrenchardBearing in mind the ticks are all around us in great numbers it is essential that there is effective treatment 28042017-05-22T16:55:41.50315269mary jeffsThis is a problem which is only going to get worse and needs to be addressed thoroughly.28042017-05-22T17:23:04.6815270David Cairns Used the A77 regularly to Ayr and Irvine for the last 25 years. And disgusted with the lack of improvements over the time, also more recently the lack of maintenances I.e. Potholes left for months before receiving attention. Wigtownshire will never fully got the tourists it deserves until the A77 and A75 have massive investment. I am a retired person with no business interest but feel for the people who do. NOW is the time for action...28562017-05-22T17:26:15.22715271elaine Curtis An upgrade is urgently needed 28562017-05-22T17:48:21.63715272Greg Hamilton Need to find more information about it for people working in the outdoors. 28042017-05-22T18:17:25.21715273Brian PearsonIn the 21st century it seems ridiculous that Lyme Disease cannot be satisfactorily detected because the medical profession are not adequately trained. The downstream effects of Lyme Disease can be horrific and life-changing and yet, if detected early enough, the disease can be nipped in the bud. 28042017-05-22T18:20:35.65715274Linda LincolnHaving known at least 2 people affected by this disease, testing and treatment need to be positive and effective.28042017-05-22T19:03:26.03715275Vaida GrahlLyme disease are more common and more dangerous than doctors think. We need to raise public awareness of the issue!28042017-05-22T19:03:31.77315276Susan WawrzyniakThe condition of the A77 road is appalling,it is long overdue an upgrade the residents and indeed all users of the A77 need this to happen now before more sorrow and heartache occurs on this so called A class road.28562017-05-22T19:09:57.08715277Emma miller The roads are a disgrace in neeed of repair and upgrade land slips and roads that have had temp traffic lights for over a year. How there has not been a serious accident from Stranraer to Ayr I will never know seriously needs money spent on them. Pay road tax for our cars to get wrecked on the huge pot holes the roads abroad are in better condition 28562017-05-22T19:25:40.02715278D McInallyBeautiful place best left as is please28582017-05-22T19:36:34.7315279Dominic RidgewayI totally agree with the need for better testing and awareness of tick-borne diseases, not only in Scotland, but the rest of the UK and other countries, especially as we welcome increasing numbers of visitors from all around the world.28042017-05-22T19:36:54.7615280Anna KeirLyme disease is life changing for anyone that becomes affected, it needs to be positively identified quickly and treated accordingly.28042017-05-22T20:47:52.36315281Dianne JamesGood luck with your campaign. This corner of Scotland is always being forgotten.28562017-05-22T22:33:21.3815282Fiona Spicer . This is incredibly important to the ports on the A77 and Euro routes and employment of the surrounding area . The road is in an appalling state of repair for a A class road and never seems to be repaired . It's a disgrace! 28562017-05-23T00:58:06.99715283Kathleen BatyThis road is very dangerous at various points. Under viaduct before Minishant big lorries are in centre of the road. Last week a sheep any lamb were at the side of the road on the grass verge. I came off the A77 to find a farm to report it to. Unlucky at farm cottages But slowed down a police car who said they would attend to it. animals still there at 6.00 when returned south. We came off the A77 again and found lovely lady who said they had been in and out for days. Three days later a strong fence has been erected28562017-05-23T07:11:43.59715284Jacqueline RileyThe initial failure seems to be at GP level. A member of my staff went to her GP when a tick bite left the telltale ring but had to insist she was tested for Lyme. The delay in then getting the result could have caused further problems. Antibiotics should be given immediately rather than delayed until the test result is known.28042017-05-23T08:31:17.9615285Campbell FrameThere is not a day passes when their is not a set of traffic lights on this road how much money is it costing us in a year to fix this road, if this was in England it would me a motorway it's a mean trunk road28562017-05-23T10:50:49.23315286John ElcockIt is imperative that health professionals in Scotland are equipped with the right training and resources to ensure quick diagnosis and effective treatment of Lyme disease and associated tick-borne diseases.28042017-05-23T10:52:50.31315287Joyce JacksonWe know so many people whose lives are affected by this disease. More needs to be done to improve current research, testing and treatment.28042017-05-23T10:52:51.29315288Robert DicksonLyme Disease is becoming a real issue and is something about which we all need to know far more.28042017-05-23T11:02:26.3315289Richard BushWe're all vulnerable!28042017-05-23T12:04:05.28715290Janice DicksonRaising awareness and the steps to be taken if you are one of the people bitten is extremely important.28042017-05-23T13:18:04.6615291Mark DuchampLoch Awe is an unspoiled, beautiful area where golden eagles may be seen flying. It needs protection from unsightlly and bird-killing wind turbines. In California, over 3,000 golden eagles were killed by wind turbines over 25 years.28582017-05-23T13:23:49.8515292John MacKintoshI have seen lives ruined by tick-borne disease. I urge all MSPs to address this issue with urgency.28042017-05-23T15:15:09.64715293AgnesPlease, please can we have a bypasss at Maybole28562017-05-23T15:37:22.55715294Cameron RougvieThe preservation of natural areas is both the duty of the common man and the government, Scottish heritage is for everyone, both ourselves and for nature itself. 28582017-05-23T19:14:41.03715296maggie thompsonMy husband's blood test was positive for the Lymes disease. He endured one month of anto-biotics.28042017-05-23T22:26:27.12715297Alice WallaceI have seen the devastating effects on a friend and neighbour. It took years to diagnose her and she did a lot of research herself. She suffered for years. Not acceptable. 28042017-05-24T08:24:09.79315298Eunhi evansWe have destroy many places by greed of human activities which should at all cost to prevent and reserve if possible.28582017-05-24T10:08:57.01715299graham worrallI see a great deal of joint problems amongst crofters. There is no LD monitoring. I am very worried about my grandchildren playing on the hill28042017-05-24T11:33:39.87315300JOANNE DRAYSONI enjoy visiting Scotland and have family there so although I may not live there at present I recognise the importance and priority this petition should be given. Particularly as I was infected in 2003 and still struggle with my health due to Doctors incompetance at treating Lyme Disease.28042017-05-24T18:22:01.78715301Elaine MachaPlease be responsible about this and wake up28042017-05-24T19:58:56.47715302Mary WallaceOur Rector's daughter has been very ill for at least 10 years, she was bitten when she was ten and still lives in one room in semi darkness.28042017-05-25T03:07:05.54715303MuffyI know 3 people with late stage Lyme disease. In all 3 cases diagnoses were errors made by the medical community...use of an unreliable, less expensive test, and the denial of the possibility of Lyme disease resulting in no testing at all! Get with the program and give this incredibly debilitating disease more attention in every way possible!!28042017-05-25T04:13:02.88715304J carsonThis is a Maine trunk road being used on a daily bases by boat traffic else where in the uk to and from docks the roads are dual carriageways plus 50 mph + . As Scotland is part of Britain to the a75 should be 50mph for hgv as well like English A roads 28562017-05-25T12:10:23.3415305Stewart LanglandsMany places were considered too remote or difficult to come under pressure from development so did not need protection. This is no longer true and a process of protecting beautiful and scenic areas needs to be updated.28582017-05-25T12:25:47.54715306Peter ScottThis would be an opportune time to review the effectiveness of protection and management arrangements for NSAs and the areas covered by these.28582017-05-25T12:36:32.7415307Rosemary HoweDo not ruin the beautiful countryside for a huge innefficient useless wind factory covering hundreds of acres.28582017-05-25T13:19:11.74715308Ross AndersonWe not only need more NSAs to protect our landscape we need more National Parks28582017-05-25T13:30:49.1815309Trevor KyffinLoch Awe and its surrounding area is blessed with the kind of natural rugged beauty that is fast disappearing from other regions of the UK. As a frequent visitor to this wonderful, peaceful area of Argyll, I beg the Scottish Parliament to urgently review and update the process for designation of National Scenic Areas, in particular to include Loch Awe.28582017-05-25T13:49:31.15315310Charles PaxtonAll developments within these beautiful areas should be appropriate in terms of scale and outline and should not mar the attractive skyline nor threaten the wildlife and peace of the resident and visiting population. Ideally developments should harmonise with the existing landscape features, natural and cultural, and be in keeping with the traditional land use and useful in terms of job creation.28582017-05-25T13:50:32.1415311Pamela BrownIt would be a total tragedy to spoil in any way the natural beauty of the countryside around Loch Awe. This whole area needs protection from any further infrastructure projects. 28582017-05-25T15:50:53.2215312KATHLEEN WEETMANWe are also in danger of our last remaining scenic space in Airdrie, North Lanarks. A developer wants to build all over the last snippet of Greenbelt. NO MORE GREENBELT GRAB .Our government needs to have Land Protection Orders similar to Tree preservation orders and listen to the people, the community councils and save it for the future .28582017-05-25T16:46:08.46315313Anne GrafThe camchatka test is too long and complicated. I'm 75 years old, and had to try twice to complete it -I almost lost patience and didn't bother completing, though I had wanted to add my name to the petition! Surely you can devise and easier but still foolproof way of seeing if I'm human?28582017-05-25T17:17:49.0915314Sandra wolfeI am concerned that the world is choosing to create garbage to litter the landscapes in the form of industrial wind turbines, undermining the health and well-being of the residents (people and ecology). I am concerned about the poison these industrial wind turbines produce that permeates the land and also poisons the social infrastructure. I am concerned that practicality has been abandoned for a frivolity of such a destructive sort as industrial wind turbines.28582017-05-25T17:21:38.84315315George HerraghtyThe Scottish Government have allowed wind industry multinationals to trash the finest landscapes in Western Europe, to the extent that wind farms are now visible from more than 60% of Scotland!!! (Wildland Research Institute Sept 2014)28582017-05-25T18:58:11.57315316Lesley Alison SpiceI have seen first hand how the medical professionals dismiss this disease and try everything else. Also the tests in this country are completely out of date compared to the testing in the USA. 28042017-05-25T19:30:32.68715317Anne Dee WasonAt present this road is very dangerous and totally unfit for purpose. It is too narrow and prone to accidents st various black spots that requires more help than reducing speeds and average speed cameras can accomplish. This will increase the traffic between Ayrshire and NI and encourage economic links for the area. 28562017-05-25T19:54:08.9915318Carolyn millerMore publicity needs to be given to the effects the disease has on people who are unfortunate enough to catch it. More research needs to be done to improve the treatment of the disease.28042017-05-26T06:35:49.16315319Mike Sullivan .Tourism needs a Wild Land Areas ,that's why as a family we have Holidayed in Scotland for over 40 years .28582017-05-26T11:14:02.95315320A.WilsonThe Scenic,and unspoilt areas of scotland should be left untouched for visitors and future generations to enjoy28582017-05-26T18:00:38.93315321John GayLyme disease is becoming more prelevant and its consequences are serious.28042017-05-26T20:17:59.50315322Will GlennWe need to protect our natural places even more now, what with climate change gaining strength.28582017-05-26T20:19:38.97315323Jean WrightI caught lyme in coventry uk so i know its everywhere28042017-05-26T22:21:09.1215324Blandine VueI suffer under windfarm infrasounds, one other and important reason not to build them in you beautifull country, the whole european country sides are getting distroyed!28582017-05-27T06:01:21.77315325Wendy s. LeggePlease listen to everyone's cry. This is a cry for help. This is the new Aids. It's already worse than Aids will ever be. No one listens but trust me, this can be given to your unborn child. I gave it to both of mine. Cosmopolitan magazine Nov 2014, says it is an STD.28042017-05-27T09:57:30.5715326Shonagh PotterFailure to diagnose Lyme disease or the prevalence of misdiagnosis leaves patients with inappropriate or inadequate treatment.\r\nYou cannot cure Lyme with a prescription for paracetamol.\r\nYou cannot cure Lyme with graded exercise.\r\nYou cannot cure Lyme with Cognitive Behaviour Therapy CBT.\r\nNAH blood tests are completely inadequate. It is recognised that perhaps up to 60% false positives or false negative results.\r\nA false negative seriology results in no treatment for Lyme.\r\nA false negative seriology result may result in inappropriate treatment for a misdiagnosis.\r\n\r\nA false negative blood test result can result in no treatment and a "time wasting attention seeking" label.\r\n\r\nEven patients with positive seriology can be abandoned by NHS after NICE guidelines treatment.\r\n\r\nHistory of tick bite. Symptoms of infection. Should elicit a prompt and adequate protocol. Reliance on blood test results or a "wait and see" response is not acceptable.\r\n\r\nPatients with chronic Lyme Disease deserve to be treated with professional compassion and respect.\r\n\r\nThe NHS failure to adequately respond and treat patients can devastate the lives of patients and their families. \r\n\r\nNot everyone can afford private treatment. The NHS is supposed to be there for all.\r\n\r\nThe NHS should be there for Lyme patients too.28042017-05-27T13:58:05.61315327Kathleen HendersonI agree there needs to be better testing, treatment in the uk. My son is a year after rash and bites and still being denied treatemnt by nhs and getting worse in pain and not able to work not eligible for ESA or DLA as has no diagnosisso has been forced to live back with parents at 30 years old andreliant on goodwill of them to buy lifes essentals. This has caused major depressions and medics happy to say he has antibodies but thie is ususal depsite having had 2 posistive testse in germany and england. He is in constant pain and chronic fatigue only to be told its depression. Lyme info tells this story hundreds of times. Please listen and change the NICE policys now not next year.28042017-05-27T23:35:51.02315328Graham FyfeNever been affected, and hopefully going by the history of UK NHS attitude towards it hopefully never will be. Lyme disease seems to be behind many 20th century terminal illnesses. I dont think this will make any difference as UK is centuries behind compassion and awareness towards human care,28042017-05-28T09:13:51.60315329Sally Patricia Makinson Protecting quiet and beautiful natural areas is essential for mankind's sanity. Most people need somewhere like Loch Awe to recharge their batteries for the hustle and bustle of everyday urban life. Once lost it will never be restored. 28582017-05-28T11:01:57.25715330archie brockThere are areas of Scotland where it is just not appropriate to build large scale renewable projects. There is a danger that we are now in danger of harming the positive image of Scotland as a country of great scenic value and a fantastic natural environment. It is surely time for the Scottish Government to put protective legislation in place.28582017-05-28T13:19:36.84315331Jacqui butterworth30yrs of this illness -nothing but denial from NHS doctors-disgraceful treatment28042017-05-28T18:16:23.86315332BEverley SpriggsPlease can you look at the inaccurate testing, no treatment or acceptance that this disease exists. I am a current sufferer and have no treatment for this dibilitating disease. All I did was go for a walk to keep fit one day and was bitten by a tick. 28042017-05-28T20:12:48.615333Catriona McCallHorrible disease28042017-05-28T20:38:55.49715334Rachel HicklingThe can be a terrible condition and can seriously impact a life. 28042017-05-28T21:25:58.2715335Emma BlackwoodX28042017-05-28T21:45:53.1515337Paul mackinThe fact a petition is needed just shows enough is not being done.28042017-05-28T23:04:46.17715338Scott GibsonPlease please please stop giving consents for the development of wind farms in our beautiful highlands and focus attention on other forms of renewable energy sources which do not harm the natural landscape such as hydro and wave power. We are ruining our natural landscape for the living and for those yet to be born.28582017-05-29T08:52:19.2115339Susanna wilcoxThere are fewer and fewer unspoilt areas in the British Isles. Please consider this area as one of them and protect our heritage.28582017-05-29T10:25:03.07715340Melanie NicollI have developed serious food allergies with a history of repeated tick bites considered by mainstream health professionals as a potential cause. I know of several other people in Scotland similarly affected. More research into this is needed.28042017-05-29T10:46:25.23315341John KeaneThe A77 is a vital route of both business and tourism between Scotland and Northern Ireland. In its current condition it is quite simply unfit for this purpose and represents a real impediment to trade and tourism alike. In many parts the A77 is in fact unsafe for both users and those citizens living nearby. 28562017-05-29T12:30:43.1415342June RavenWe have to oppose the aggressive planning this area based mostly on a quest for money by business people who do not live here. 28582017-05-29T14:13:21.79315343Tess DoigIt is too bad that the lowlands of Scotland are being invaded by wind farms, but to keep pursing this one in the most beautiful , unspoilt region is unthinkable.28582017-05-29T14:15:14.7315344James William ALSTAIR HILLTHE CURRENT PLANS AND INSTALLATIONS OF WINDPARKS WILL LEAD TO A DISASTROUS LOSS OF AREAS OF NATURAL BEAUTY. This will end tourism or at least hit tis industry seriously in the long run. In the mean time many of Scotland's iconic birds will be decimated.28582017-05-29T17:05:29.67715345Peter and Pauline CarruthersWe were residents in Taynuilt from 1989 to 1999 and then Kilchrenan overlooking Loch Awe and its environs from 1999 to 2007. We consider the outstanding quality of the landscape fully justifies classification as a National Scenic Area.In our opinion it matches the beauty of some of Scotland's existing National Parks.Many people, both locals and visitors, will consider protection for this landscape is long overdue. 28582017-05-29T18:16:22.57715346Richard GreenIt's high time these roads were upgraded to cope with the traffic and growing economy 28562017-05-29T18:45:16.48715347DT Wall&Mrs MMWallWe have visited this area on a number of occasions for its utterly impressive beauty and wildness. Although the local economy must be sustained we hope that due regard will be given to maintaining this breath-taking environment.28582017-05-29T22:32:22.06315348Lesley MillerMy daughter and her partner have spent 10 very difficult months due to the health Impacts of Lyme disease and the lack of diagnosis and care provided by NHS medical staff. In desperation they have had to seek help from a private specialist, who wth the help of a European test centre confirmed within 5 days what they had suspected themselves, that they had Lyme Disease. We are all now anxiously hoping that they can still be treated effortless ectively. It is utterly unacceptable that there is so little awareness or effective action being taken at a governmental level to ensure this disease is being tackled. 28042017-05-29T22:45:43.86315349Lesley MillerIt is utterly unacceptable that this disease is not being addressed effectively by government. After 10 months of repeatedly attending their NHS Gp and consultants, in desperation my daughter and her partner paid to see a specialist- who with the help of a European test centre confirmed within 5 days, what they had suspected themselves, that they had Lyme Disease. We all now anxiously hope that treatment will be as effective as the testing...28042017-05-30T15:45:06.19715350John Anthony PhillipsAnything which protects wild, unspoilt landscape from industrial depredation and leaves it to be enjoyed and savoured by residents and visitors must be supported.28582017-05-30T15:50:39.63715351Alan HoptonIt's all about the money. There are reliable, sensitive tests available in other countries and they should be available here. How many people are walking around with CFS and other symptoms not knowing it's Lyme infection? Co-infections are another serious issue. 28042017-05-30T16:22:39.90715352Lisa GlazeEven in a hotbed of ticks and Lyme disease (I personally know 3 people with it) the GPS are still saying it is rare and are unwilling to test for it even when you have the classic bite with ring around28042017-05-30T18:20:56.51715353Hazel brannigan Too little information on this and very little public awareness 28042017-05-30T19:16:49.215354Stephanie FindlayIncreasing the number of NSA sites should be increased across Scotland. Fundamemtly we still have the power to protect for good our environment of thriving habitats and forrests some of which are considered to be ancient forrests. This means the land has changed very little over time in these areas and there's much knowledge to be gained in respect of that from various aspects of study from medicine to history and all else inbetween. To actually allow for these unspoilt areas to come under threat of destruction would literally be robbing people the knowledge to be gained from these parts and a great loss of natural environment which Scotland is renowend destroy our reputation of our beautifully land untouched by modernisation which people pay a lot of money to see from around the world definetly further destructive acts on the environment will effect our tourism so why do that when lots of money is to be gain for not doing anything to our land just sit back let folk climb the hills and how glens. We should be forefront on environmental movement and considered further protection and better enforcement to those caught doing wrong as well as funding for studying areas of importance and better management of forestry, environmental sites and heritage sites too. 28582017-05-30T19:35:51.70315355Geraldine Robertson I contracted Lyme Disease two years ago and had real difficulty getting help with this as my bloods came back with a false negative. Thankfully my doctor was really helpful and was able to give me the support I needed. Doctors and Nurses need more info to correctly diagnose especially as the number of Lyme disease suffers increase. 28042017-05-30T19:57:45.71715356Morag GiblinMy stepson has suffered severely from Lyme disease and the resulting after effects. It is having a huge long term affect on him and his family. 28042017-05-30T20:54:22.36715357Peter ClinchI've had friends get Lyme's and spend more and more time removing ticks from myself and my family. With the importance of outdoor pursuits in Scotland and the increasing prevalence of ticks, this is important for public health.28042017-05-30T20:55:40.52715358Doreen McKnightThis test needs to be readily available.28042017-05-30T21:10:07.93315359Jane JonesGiven the serious health implications it is vital That medical professionals, in particular GPs, are up-to-date in their knowledge & training about Lyme disease i.e. able to diagnose 28042017-05-30T21:56:58.0815360Kerry MainA debilitating and life changing disease that is not taken seriously by health professionals and insurance companies. More has to be done in terms of testing and diagnosing. 28042017-05-30T22:41:46.0415362Sue Graves Let's get Lyme disease sorted! For the sake of gardeners, foresters and those who just love the Scottish countryside.28042017-05-30T22:49:12.1515363AwThe growth in tick born disease is concerning , skills to detect and treat illness associated with tick Bourne disease us important. I spend a lot of time in Scottish mountains, as do many if my friends. And for the impact they cause, verses the cost of treatment, thus seems a no brainer. Please do something about this. 28042017-05-31T00:56:17.46315364Jacqui BarkerI became ill after a tick bite. My gp yested me for limes and the result came back as negative. \r\nFour years later and instill haven't got to the bottom of why I am I'll.\r\nI'd like a better test in the UK. I'd like to have myself re- tested to rule out limes 28042017-05-31T07:08:42.64715365Lan Garrod I regularly visit Scotland to get away to wild places not to see large scale human development blight the landscape. I am not alone in this feeling that Scotland is a special place, please protect as much of its wild space as possible for all of those that love to visit or will visit in the future.28582017-05-31T09:30:26.1315366Ian MorrisonThis effected my wife last year. GP clueless on first visit. She had to explain in detail along with symptoms. First blood test returned negative. She insisted second blood test 6 weeks later as symptoms and rash persisted. Bloods returned positive. Antibiotics mostly cleared it, but GP stuffed up on duration, so end result unknown.\r\n\r\nFound a feeding tick on our son yesterday. Visited another GP, clueless, who had to look it up on a computer in front of us. He then tried to appear as though he then knew what to do, but was clearly bluffing and waffling.\r\n\r\nBoth cases we even saved the tick in question. Test on actual ticks seem common abroad, but not in GB.28042017-05-31T10:49:31.00715367Sam PhillipsI visit Scotland several times a year, in particular the west coast which I think is the most beautiful part of the UK. I believe the designation of this part of the country as an NSA would protect the landscape and its value as a tourist destination. 28582017-05-31T10:54:53.1815368Neil GilliesTook a long time for me to be diagnosed. Nobody seems to have much of a clue about it. It was wrongly diagnosed as a fungal infection at first. Then I had a chunk cut out of the bite site so that it could be tested....weeks and weeks and weeks passed before a German doctor in hospital diagnosed it correctly :-(28042017-05-31T15:18:10.24715369Ruth WiegratzI was failed by the NHS. I got lyme disease in April 2010 and my bullseye rash was misdiagnosed as ringworm by my GP. In November 2010 I was finally tested for Lyme disease on NHS and it was positive. I was very ill with awful neurological, arthritic and cardiac symptoms but was only given two weeks of oral doxycycline then a break and then two weeks more when my symptoms didn't improve. My symptoms never went away. I should have had a longer, uninterrupted course of antibiotics (probably Intravenous) but I was discharged from infectious disease ward at Edinburgh Western general, even though my last blood test 4 months after antibiotics was positive! They did not, and still don't, have any idea how to treat me and others in my position and most GP's and specialists do not like discussing Lyme.\r\n\r\nI have suffered all of my twenties. My life has been stripped away. I have had two operations on my hips. Given up most of my hobbies, social life and career.\r\n\r\nThis has to be sorted. No one should have to go through this! It is a disease on the rise and Scotland needs to step up and start tackling this horrendous, life-stealing disease. 28042017-05-31T17:53:36.04315370ElaineIm having to send my blood to Germany which is expensive but necessary . I think GPs should routinely ask patients who present symptoms of lyme if they have been bitten. Now most folk have phones any bites tick or otherwise take evidential photos.28042017-05-31T19:38:48.69715371Linda LawsonWorth while cause28042017-05-31T20:43:55.50315372Thomas p'grady10 years of lyme when will I get decent treatment here in Scotland?28042017-05-31T21:28:11.94315373Eve ReidBeing outdoor enthusiasts with three very small children, it is very worrying to think that they may not get the correct treatment if bitten and infected by a tick. Myself and my husband are aware of the consequences and can make the choices for ourselves along with the knowledge to express how we feel. My children can't do this.28042017-05-31T23:24:16.115374AnneThe A77 as it currently stands is unfit for purpose given the volume of traffic, private and commercial, which use this carriageway on a daily basis. It is crying out for upgrade.28562017-06-01T00:41:32.2515375Linda pirieThis is really important that we support this campaign as Lyme disease is debilitationg and very often goes misdiagnosed for years in sufferers \r\n28042017-06-01T05:03:41.44315376Linda Munro 12 years on from first falling ill and being given a diagnosis of "post viral fatigue" my daughter is still suffering from chronic Lyme. It was 3 years before she was shown to have spirochetes in her blood- not through an NHS test- the system is flawed and needs to change. 28042017-06-01T09:41:08.44315377Sally ProeI have been misdiagnosed for over 20 years, now I have had a private diagnosis of chronic Lyme my GP doesn't want to know. The disease is bad enough without having to put up with a health service in denial. Tired of being fobbed of, private health care it is then! I have to work to afford the care which puts extra strain on me which exacerbates my symptoms, well done gmc, NHS - not! 28042017-06-01T11:06:08.86715378Trevor HarrisonThe state of the A77 south of Ayr is a disgrace. Although its the only route from Glasgow to the Ferry ports at Cairnryan it's not in the central belt so isn't in Holyroods list of things to do and probably never will be28562017-06-01T18:28:18.30315379Mary SmythHusband diagnosed in 2005 got treatment for 1 month, living now with symptoms due to late diagnoses' dropped foot, nerve pain, fatigue & a cancer diagnoses, went from very well to very sick, nobody knew what was wrong until he was hospitalized for almost 7 weeks!28042017-06-01T18:55:35.1615380David CrawfordNow with average speed cameras, we have lorries traveling in convoys wich are heading from Girvan to Ayr on the northbound carriageway where there is only one safe place to overtake, the climbing lane at Turnberry. However, there is no safe overtaking place southbound.28562017-06-01T18:59:51.78715381Andrew RussellWith planning permission now given to new housing developments east of the current A77 bypass. It is essential for the current bypass to be completely dual-ed around Ayr, since we are already experiencing hold ups, pollution, and frustration before the developments even start. In addition the Whitletts roundabout needs either an over or underpass. Stop talking about it and get on and do it. 28562017-06-01T21:54:29.21715382Tina AmblerI work in the forestry industry and recognise that more research and awareness of Lyme Disease is needed. 28042017-06-01T23:08:05.10315383Jim StoreyAlthough I live in England my daughter and grand children live in Scotland and I would like to think that this would be available for them.28042017-06-02T01:12:08.49715384DianeIt's a very treatable ( curable) condition if caught early. In order to catch it early, every doctor and preferably every citizen needs to understand how to recognize symptoms. Better yet, how to avoid tick bites in the first place. A powerful public information campaign is essential. 28042017-06-02T08:01:48.115385Fiona ReidHad some whacky symptoms after multiple tick bites last year. It took a bit of persuasion to get the GP to take me seriously and prescribe antibiotics etc. I was lucky as I'm aware of Lyme so argued my case others are not. It's a horrible disease and more needs to be done to make sure it's taken seriously by the medical profession and correct treament given. 28042017-06-02T08:27:04.22715387AlyUpgrade needed ASAP28562017-06-02T09:33:41.3215388Ian knightLong overdue initiative28042017-06-02T10:52:21.0615389George WadeI travelled this road on Thursday morning in heavy fog and felt that a dual carriageway would have been a safer option. Returning back on Tuesday I felt forced to take the longer coast road due to the speed the lorries were travelling at when coming up behind me28562017-06-02T12:58:05.9615390Angela DeanLyme disease is devastating if not caught quickly. We need urgent training for recognition of it, and early, effective treatment.28042017-06-02T18:25:14.57715391Bev GrayI have NOT visited Scotland recently after many years of visiting due to the increasing destruction of the unique views and lonliness of the Highlands with wind turbines. I have just visited Iceland, beautiful....and no turbines in sight. Beautiful28582017-06-02T18:53:58.81715392Don S FergusonPlease take control of this easily preventable problem28042017-06-02T21:41:10.3715393Peter alexander The a77 is a terrible road . It should be classed as a B Road not a A. from Ayr south is shocking. Worst road in Britain if you ask me!28562017-06-02T22:56:14.64315394Janet Khan-MarnieMy GP was great and treated me immediately last year, but others are not so lucky to have a well informed GP. Is there a vaccine? I'm sure my dog is vaccinated against Lyme Disease, what about a human vaccine too?28042017-06-02T23:07:42.89715395AnonToo many places of natural scenic beauty in Scotland are being overrun with wind farms. Increase the number of NSAs to protect these areas from having wind farms constructed to preserve what is left of our beautiful countryside.28582017-06-03T06:29:30.23715396David McMillanAs we leave Europe we need better connectivity within the UK.\r\nThis part of Scotland has always been badly served with road connections despite having 2 major Ferry Ports to NI.\r\nThe improvements made already, although welcome, have been inadequate and have not tackled some of the worst parts of the A77 (or the A75).\r\nBoth of these roads require to be upgraded to meet the demands of safety, reliability and the commercial\r\n use of the road. 28562017-06-03T08:30:25.8315397Hugh Thomson Worst road in Scotland one of tge busiest as well not fit for purpose 28562017-06-03T11:11:46.915398Jessie JolliffeEssential for everyone's safety28562017-06-03T11:24:55.16315399Lyn costleySome stretches of the road are extremely dangerous to drivers and residents alike. 28562017-06-03T11:56:40.7815400Christine BarkerBit by a tick in 1970 huge and I mean huge Bulls eye rash on back of leg ... I was 18yrs of age not one GP I went to had a clue what it was .....\r\nI am 64 yrs young now and it's ruined my life totally .\r\nWouldn't want anyone to suffer like I have Glandular Feaver M.E. CFS Migraines Joint stiffness Fatigue Depression Memory loss 28042017-06-03T12:28:22.3915401WilsonUpgrade needed To make safer for all road users 28562017-06-03T12:31:26.59315402David BillingtonKeep your forests, they can soon go !28432017-06-03T14:01:23.31715403Heather CameronAs regular users of this road visiting our son in Scotland we would welcome any upgrade.28562017-06-03T14:02:16.32715404CathyI travel this route regularly to return to my family home in N. Ireland. Anything to improve the drive to and from the port would be helpful, especially in the winter. I hope parliament will seriously consider this petition and help save time and lives. 28562017-06-03T15:22:58.91715405John Nicholas DietzI am a regular user of the A77 and fully support improvements to the safety of the road. The recent introduction of additional speed cameras was a retrograde step, in my opinion, as it made the journey even more frustrating for users. \r\n\r\nWhilst I am not convinced of the need for dual carriageway for the whole route the A77 requires significant sections of dual carriageway to allow passing of slow moving vehicles. At present there are about 47 miles of road and only about one and a half miles that are good for overtaking from the west of Ayr south to Stranraer. Half of this is due to crawler lanes on the steeper hills so you can still get caught behind slower moving vehicles.\r\n\r\nThe road also requires a large number of bends, some of them very tight, to be removed or bypassed as these regularly result in people slowing to speeds under 30 miles per hour in some places and large vehicles crossing double white lines as they struggle to negotiate them. Bypass every town or village would be good too and why Maybole has not had a bypass for decades now is beyond me. I'll have retired before this all happens at this rate.\r\n\r\nI have been a regular commuter to Stranraer for two and a half years and can't believe that there is a semi-permanent set of traffic lights for slope investigations north of Cairnryan on a major route. This has now been joined by another set south of Girvan, is it 5 months now?\r\n\r\nHopefully some improvements will be made sooner on what is a major route but a bit of a joke. I work for a global company and visitors are amazed that it takes two and a half hours to drive from Glasgow Airport. We regularly also have visitors that either refuse to drive the road or will not drive it in darkness.28562017-06-03T16:33:48.91715406Mrs L MillarRoads going both north and south are in need of a major rethink - and the sooner the better. 28562017-06-03T16:36:14.08315407Marie Robertson It's long over due for an upgrade 28562017-06-03T16:47:13.9315408Michele McQuillan An upgrade on the A77 would make all the difference to this journey, especially when travelling with children28562017-06-03T18:43:58.5615409Tanja Lowesigned28562017-06-03T19:21:46.31715410Norman McAllisterA77 Ayr to Cairnryan too small for volume of traffic to N Ireland and back particularly since there is a heavy concentration of large commercial vehicles.\r\nRoad flooding also often closes the road which is the Mail route to Cairnryan port.28562017-06-03T19:46:06.78715411Mark OgilvieTravel to cairnryan every other week an the roads are not built for the heavy traffic, will cause more deaths. Even the A77 need to be dual carriageway to the port....28562017-06-03T22:12:16.36315412Isobel BurnsAs we travel to Belfast by Stena Line to visit family frequently, the A77 needs to be updated as soon as possible for safety reasons so many lorries travel on this road likewise to catch the ferry.28562017-06-03T23:35:22.41315413Nick MetcalfeScotland is one if not the most beautiful country in the world, please keep it that way. A NSA would keep it that way particularly the Western Highlands28582017-06-04T00:25:59.10715414Gail MunroLong overdue!28562017-06-04T11:59:05.815415AdamHaving travelled on this road last week I feel it would be much safer for all vehicles and persons using it to have it dual carriageway for the majority of the A75 28562017-06-04T15:43:52.50315416Agnes PetkeviciusTravel this road few times a year when going to Ireland Whilst dome improvements have been made, more needs to be done. Heavy traffic including lorries etc have been held up due yo accidents and witnessed some very dangerous driving due to drivers being impatient 28562017-06-04T19:07:42.8115417Les BatesAntibiotics useful treatment but there must be more that can be done and other treatments28042017-06-04T19:22:37.6215418Alison McMillanIf the upgrading of A77 does hopefully go head is it worth considering having traffic lights situated around Holmston Roundabout as some users currently using it do not understand the concept of not entering the roundabout unless the exit is clear, making for gridlock at busy times of the day? Similar to that on Whitlettts Roundabout perhaps - although with better lane organisation!!28562017-06-04T21:30:42.23315419Geddes MurrayScottish Government must approve this as it can devastate families and lives through no fault of their own. Improve testing and bring it up to date, GP awareness, treatment etc. 28042017-06-04T21:44:44.315420Caroline joseyIt is well overdue and the government need to realise this is a serious disease.28042017-06-04T22:10:30.115421Kirsty smithI have had Lyme disease and co for ten years and the bus say there is nothing wrong with me! Disgusting!!!28042017-06-04T22:21:25.72715422Dawn lowrie With the pounding this road takes from ferry traffic it is in desperate need of an upgrade 28562017-06-05T10:26:50.53715423BEverley SpriggsPlease please do not cover this up. 28042017-06-05T13:55:19.26315424Pamela McAllisterThis road is long overdue for upgrade South of Ayr and essential for much needed tourism. 28562017-06-05T14:12:37.23315425SadieThe conditions on this road are horrendous. The road surface is so bad it must be beyond repair. With all the extra summer traffic as well as the usual lorries and buses it is even more dangerous than usual and normally it is a very scary road. Upgrading this road is imperative 28562017-06-05T15:02:38.55315426Steven MAfter driving from south of Dublin to Larne on the great roads of Ireland it is frankly embarrassing that the connection in the other side is so poor.\r\nNeeds upgrading so badly28562017-06-05T15:48:23.99715427David F H SmithNever seen the number of ticks there are presently - climbed for 65 years and worked all over UK (Mountain Instructor Cert holder)28042017-06-05T15:51:10.24715428Bryce WeirThe volumes of traffic currently experienced on this road together with the numberer of cars seeking to join at right angles with traffic already travelling at speed render this road in its current state a positively dangerous route28562017-06-05T16:42:44.615429Elvyn HaighLoch Awe is an area frequented by visitors who wish to view the unique landscape. Visitors come from Scotland and abroad and include cyclists, walkers, fishermen, nature lovers and general tourists. Any spoiling of the landscape would deter from this natural habitat. I live alongside the loch and witness these visitors. I also work with the Kilmartin Museum and talk to many visitors in my role there.28582017-06-05T19:58:22.70715430Christine Parker My daughter has fought Lyme disease for 9 years. She has had to spend thousands on treatment and has several other co infections . We don't have the money to keep this up and she, so brave and determined has to struggle every day with no help from nhs. It is time to recognise how many people have Lyme, improve testing and treat the co infections. The tests used at present are not accurate and many people seem to be diagnosed as having ME or depression instead. I know several people who have a family member with Lyme disease . And none of them have been helped by the NHS where doctors admit they know nothing about it. Sufferers need to come together to bring this problem to the attention of everyone 28042017-06-05T20:13:03.02315431Anita BranniganStop this desecration of our natural heritage28582017-06-05T20:39:24.58715432Stuart YoungI am happy to support a petition for more NSA's but more NSAs will reinforce the pressure on areas equally deserving of real protection from windfarm activity. What is needed is a Government which respects and protects Scotland's countryside and people, not one wedded to a renewables vision doomed to failure and already coming apart at the seams28582017-06-06T00:50:09.59315433Steven Brown I work near LRP and travel 20,000 plus miles every year, picking up work colleagues along the A77 , in my opinion the roads aren't up to the job when it comes to the requirements for the increasing road traffic and infrastructure, the HGV lorrys can add an hour or two on my three and a half hour journey , if a lorry has a flat tyre, which has happened many times from my past experience , this alone can cause miles of cars to be stuck.28562017-06-06T07:36:47.53715434James mcrobertsPlease help us sufferers28042017-06-06T09:04:34.02715435Guy GlencrossAlthough resident in NI I was born in Glasgow and schooled in Stirling then Rannoch. I lament the destruction of a landscape for the few that will forever change what the legend of the Scottish country side is to all who have seen it. Wind turbines are the most inefficient generators of electricity ever devised and any industry still reliant on subsidy 20 years after roll out is manifestly ridiculous. 28582017-06-06T09:27:13.90315436Patrick DevlinNo to anymore wind powder and spend money on important matters.28582017-06-06T09:31:05.9215437Joanne McCullochVery important. 28042017-06-06T09:43:57.9215438Siobhan Browne Protect the delicate eco systems.\r\n28582017-06-06T09:45:38.7215439Siobhan Browne Protect delicate eco systems 28582017-06-06T12:14:52.5815440ColinLast summer I had the dilemma of seeing a foreign tourist in Scotland with a textbook 'target' mark on their leg, indicating an infected tick byte. I feel I should have warned the person, but they spoke little English, and I wasn't confident that even if they visited a doctor or hospital, it would be taken seriously. I only hope they were aware of the danger, and saw a doctor as soon as they got home. 28042017-06-06T12:51:45.915441Andrew WhiteIn the same way areas of North West Ireland - Donegal - are at risk from major infrastructure projects28582017-06-06T13:06:00.24715442Neil LawnWas diagnosed with stage three Lyme 7 years ago. Horrible disease, always at Doctors with various ailments which can't be explained, very frustrating!! The medical profession has to take this more serious and give adequate treatment after being diagnosed.. 28042017-06-06T17:52:05.21715443Veronica Johnstone This is bigger than aids, cancer combined. Ignoring the problem doesn't work. 28042017-06-06T19:07:56.0415444Jonathan TheobaldI suspect the harm caused by driven grouse shooting - the destruction of legally protected wildlife, increased flooding, CO2 emissions and so on - is substantially greater than any economic benefits to local communities.\r\n\r\nThis study would offer an excellent opportunity to establish the facts. 27982017-06-06T19:13:03.13315445Grace FenwickWe live in SW Scotland adjacent to a large swathe of spruce plantation which is full of roe and red deer. Last week I pulled out 7 ticks after a stint in my garden so they are prevalent.\r\nLast year I spoke to my local practice nurse about ticks and she assured me that she'd never heard of ticks bothering humans...only animals...which offers much reassurance. Training is vitally important in view of this!!28042017-06-06T19:30:28.30715446Susan Gassaway I hate the "moon scape" that grouse moors produce. Barren of 90% of wild life. I hate the way so many RADIO COLLARD raptors are killed or "disappeared". 27982017-06-06T19:41:06.07715447Bob MorrisThis is an important subject that should have been fully assessed a long time ago. If the driven grouse industry have nothing to hide them I'm sure they will embrace it. We shall see.27982017-06-06T20:01:16.8615449Vinh Burton SmithThis is an initiative that has my complete support. I am a local resident and feel strongly this beautiful area qualifies for the designation of National Scenic Area.28582017-06-06T20:06:37.95315450Peta Burton SmithThis very beautiful area undoubtably qualifies for the NSAs and can only benefit from the environmental protection this designation may confer. \r\nI am a local resident.28582017-06-06T20:25:00.67715451Karine GeorgianI believe the scenic and environmental qualities of Loch Awe are so exceptional that they should be recognised in the area's designation as a National Scenic Area. In particular the area should be protected from invasion and visual intrusion of inappropriate industrial installations. 28582017-06-07T10:36:29.64715452Pauline greenhalghDriven grouse shooting needs to stop altogether. The landowners cannot be trusted to take care of their areas properly they do not respect the land, the wildlife, nor the surrounding areas. They have emptied and ruined huge tracts of Scotland - this cannot continue. They are ruining the country pandering to the few and ignoring the rest of the population who wish to live or visit there. Doing this is bad enough but doing it so a few can kill a wild creature is about as backward as it gets. We should be ashamed that this activity is happening. And it not only affects us in this country but other parts of the world too - loss of habitat and diversity robs everyone world over. If the landowners were protecting the real residents of the land - the native species and not burning heather then it wouldn't worry me if they shot birds bred for that purpose which are then eaten.27982017-06-07T10:37:16.615453steven mountainplease ban driven grouse shooting27982017-06-07T10:38:52.38715454Mr G.W Stewart and Mrs J M StewartWe owned and ran two hotels in Arisaig, then Oban for a total of twenty years.\r\nTourism is the life blood of the Highlands with visitors coming to enjoy the coastline and the wonderful countryside. They do not come, we assure you to view wind turbine factories. \r\nWe urge you to designate Loch Awe and area as a National Scenic area. 28582017-06-07T11:38:54.62315455A lamontMust be stopped.28042017-06-07T12:43:52.79315456Matthew Stone I have no opposition to shooting per se, or to the individuals who shoot. However i vehemently object to the inappropriate, illegal and damaging management practices that clearly impact and define the limited distribution of raptor species across the UK's mountains and moorland habitat. Further facts are required to breakthrough and dispel myths that potentially will redefine the industry and its management practices. I believe shooting can exist alongside raptors, but not as an intensive and competitive industry driven on delivering bigger bags. Changing the economic model here is key in a way that ceases to encourage intensive and persectory management practices. Key to this change are the facts, including financial, so lets be informed and get workable solutions and avoid widening debates where denial vs call for outright ban are not getting closer to a resolution.27982017-06-07T12:52:51.0715457Alex. S. MilneAn independent review is certainly needed. Our country is being prevented from developing ecotorism due to the antics of those stuck in the 19th Century. Enough is enough.27982017-06-07T13:03:42.72715458Robert MossGrouse shooting may well have the potential to be an economically and ecologically sustainable land use. Heather moorland is certainly preferable to alien conifer plantations or rushy, overgrazed sheep ranchland. But the current objective of management is too often short-term, aiming for maximum grouse bags with little thought for the ecological and long-term economic consequences. Indeed, grouse management today seems to include well-documented and blatant criminal activity involving the illegal killing of predators including raptors and pine martens. The attitude seems to be that the relevant law is an ass and should not apply to the class of people who indulge in this sport. An authoritative review of potential land uses in the uplands is well overdue. It could well benefit us all, including a reformed grouse shooting industry.27982017-06-07T13:17:02.71315459Caroline Hamilton McAdamNative wildlife, including mountain hares, golden eagles, hen harriers, wildcats, pine martens and red kites, is either openly killed or disappears in areas where driven grouse shooting predominates, all in the interests of a very few whose aim is to kill grouse. These birds are fed on medicated grit which gets into the water supply and the land is artificially controlled in the interests of the guns. Driven grouse shooting is an anachronism and has no place in modern Scotland. 27982017-06-07T13:18:33.27715460Nicola CallisWe can no longer allow grouse shooting to continue without knowing the impact it it doing, not only on our environment but also to all other wildlife on driven grouse moors. 27982017-06-07T13:32:36.84715461Terry PickfordAbout Time. At last the truth may now be exposed, opening the myths of driven grouse shooting for all to see.27982017-06-07T13:34:41.3815462Nigel RabyIts about time this shambles was tidied up!27982017-06-07T13:41:53.515463Adrian TaylorDGS is not economically and morally viable. Please end this Victorian pastime now. 27982017-06-07T14:08:46.70715464Douglas MalpusWe have long needed a study of the economic harm or benefits of grouse shooting in the UK. The owners and shooters say that there are great benefits, I don't believe them.27982017-06-07T14:18:10.6615465Thomas David DickGiven the clearly spelled out facts on the detrimental effects of the management of driven grouse shoots on many species of predatory birds and animals - government and NGO reports over the last several decades and continuing reports of illegally killed raptors on these moors - there would have to be an overwhelming case for benefits to the social and economic welfare of this country. So lets see that independently investigated. Including other possible regimes for these areas.27982017-06-07T14:47:03.8215466John HarrisonIt would make Scotland an even better place to visit if raptors were not persecuted.27982017-06-07T15:54:01.34715467Angela PeatLoch Awe is definitely a candidate for an NSA. It is relatively unspoilt and needs to be protected so that it stays that way. 28582017-06-07T16:22:02.44315468Alex. S. MilneDriven grouse shooting is underpinned by the criminal behaviour of its employees and employers, and has ravaged large areas of Scotland. The figures of benefit provided by the industry are clearly illusory. I'm sure that there are many other land uses which could provide greater employment and benefit to the economy, given the ending of criminality.27982017-06-07T16:31:31.72715469Peter ShearerIt is certainly time we had some verified information to base decisions on.There are serious questions about the economic benefits of driven grouse moors,as well as the suspected cases of wildlife crime.27982017-06-07T17:14:14.36315472Jim KnightI am not against all field sports but managed grouse shooting is an intensive and destructive land use that occupies far too much of our uplands. This represents a severe waste of natural resources. I support the study27982017-06-07T18:08:43.2315473Paul Edwards Time for this national scandal to end.27982017-06-07T18:47:21.32715474I Fulton We need a better solution to ensure quicker diagnosis & more effective treatment 28042017-06-07T19:14:00.20715475Kirsteen McCulloch This road is long overdue being upgraded.there have been far too many road deaths caused by bad drivers on this road.28562017-06-07T21:43:26.1815476Andy PatonGood luck. Driven Grouse Shoots have a proven record of wildlife persecution but little prosecution, it is time for this to change and the agenda of the industry to find a new direction.27982017-06-07T22:45:19.70315477Dave BallGood luck with this, things need to change27982017-06-07T23:15:55.46315478Ian ChristianOur natural world is a far more important resource than the money brought in by the barbarity of the blood sport known as grouse shooting 27982017-06-08T08:39:41.41715479David BrittonI visit Shetland (where no Grouse shooting) and the Scottish Highlands every year. Also Orkney every few years. About 100 pairs of Hen Harriers on Orkney but very few in the highlands. No voles on Shetland so they have no breeding Hen Harriers for a good reason.27982017-06-08T08:46:22.66315480Tom MoonI would like this to include an assessment of the environmental impacts as well as the economic assessment. 27982017-06-08T10:44:20.5115481G MooreThis well over due, have been driving it for 15yrs and it is 1 of the most congested , I have ever driven . There is too many HGV drive through this town 7 days wk. It is so annoying. 28562017-06-08T11:01:10.7615482Martin DoddSomething has to done to stop this, so I am happy to help with signing the petition27982017-06-08T13:51:25.96715483Louise AlbanThe situation is similar all over the UK, with Lyme disease present but not sufficiently understood or acknowledged by the medical profession. My daughter was bitten at 20 and symptom should have stimulated diagnosis and treatment but did not. 7 years later she is still ill and in treatment with a US doctor. 28042017-06-08T15:16:34.30315484Sharon BenthinI have been suffering with scores of very painful symptoms and fatigue for over 10 years now following two very nasty insect bites. The symptoms are all the same as those related to Lyme Disease but I have tested negative, after one initial blood test. My GP will now no longer entertain the idea of Lyme Disease but I am 99% sure that I have got it! It's totally disgusting that the Medical Profession seem to think that it doesn't exist! I am almost disabled of late and can hardly leave the house but still cannot get any doctors to take me seriously and stop prescribing antidepressants etc!28042017-06-08T21:09:24.94315486Shona Helen Gilmour This road is a disgrace. I have just returned from a lovely trip around Loch Lomond, Glencoe and the Cowal Peninsula even the Rest and Be Thankful was pothole free. Then we joined the M77 onto the A77 and we both said "we must be getting closer to Home!!!" It is time Transport Scotland took their heads out of the tar and did something about this 'goat track!'28562017-06-08T21:13:13.6715487Oliver ClanfordIt's about time the environmental impact of this intensive form of land use is looked at in detail. For too long, vast swathes of our uplands have been controlled by a very select band of people pursuing a very limited range of activities. I'm sick of having the look of our landscape dictated by the actions of a tiny minority of people. 27982017-06-08T22:23:57.47715488Ina SempleBetter testing procedures required in the UK to allow the correct diagnosis to be made. Too many people being misdiagnosed when medication could be administered.28042017-06-09T05:56:21.49715489Lynn kyle This is a forgotten road in a forgotten part of the country with a high volume of traffic. Not only is it unsafe, it is not maintained to any sort of degree. It is a disaster waiting to happen.28562017-06-09T12:39:20.8815490Rory GafneyI know of someone who suffered Lyme disease for years without diagnosis. 28042017-06-09T15:34:10.22715491Betty LeeGrouse moors do not comprise good biodiverse habitats.27982017-06-09T16:57:21.43315492David NicholsonThe general public need increased awareness, together with the medical profession need to understand the symptoms. 28042017-06-09T17:35:47.3215493Susie skilling I'd like to know why my domestic abuse divorce was dragged out by the ex constantly refusing what he was due, 13 long years 4 month of legal aid he had to continue his control, why did no one question it.28732017-06-09T17:50:01.0115494Mike DalesI've had Lyme disease twice. The first time I had it the first doctor I saw said that I'd probably had a hair pulled out of my leg and an infection had got into the follicle, so he prescribed some weak antibiotics. I didn't take them and thankfully the second doctor two days later correctly diagnosed it.28042017-06-09T18:23:07.33715495Crawford LindsayI am curious as to how much actual benefit we get out of grouse shooting as the environmental damage can be quite severe. Also raptors have a strange habit of accidentally ending up dead on some Highland Estates and that is bad for Scotland's image as a green country.27982017-06-10T08:30:07.8515496James GrantBare hills in Scotland is not the natural order. There has to be very good reasons to maintain them like this. Shooting is not one of them.27982017-06-10T09:07:03.07315497O BartonThe vast areas of land taken up by this land use could be used far better for our society and for our natural heritage. 27982017-06-10T09:31:12.15315498GrantWe take precautions but need the back up28042017-06-10T11:19:22.96715499William DonachieA very long overdue petition! Away with the bald, burning hills! If some people still want to hunt grouse then let them but make them work for their bags rather than enjoy an artificial mass slaughter.27982017-06-10T12:35:05.74315500Christine RussellI spent several days hill walking in a remote area of Scotland which had an office and a ranger, something to do wth countryside etc. My husband and I removed about ten ticks each after each day. We asked if there was Lyme disease in the area and were told that three of about 80 locals had Lyme disease. We were absolutely horrified that there was no leaflet, warning posters or anything at all about the danger. In contrast holiday accommodation we rented on Jura had a prominent notice and a leaflet about Lyme disease. I know that for anyone involved in making a living in tourism the acknowledgement of Lyme disease might be seen as having a negative affect on the attraction of an area, it must be the duty of all involved to be honest about the danger.28042017-06-10T15:04:56.74715501Margaret WardMaybole bypass has been on the agenda for about 50yrs. Mayboles night street is dangerous and an accident waiting to happen. Forgotten Town. Glasgow to Stranraer is the main route, you would think this bypass would be priority due to the dangers of same and the poor road conditions. Needs addressed sooner rather than later.28562017-06-10T16:05:40.70715502Kenny Cairnie50 miles of the A77T south of Ayr is quite possibly the most neglected TRUNK road in SCOTLAND and successive custodians should hang their heads in shame.\r\n\r\nTime for the current custodians to step up to the mark and put matters right by committing to the investment it truly deserves to bring it in line with other trunk roads in Scotland.28562017-06-10T17:19:10.10715503Rose FarmerWe have visited Scotland in the past specifically to see its fabulous birds, just love Golden Eagles. Won't go again until Scotland has stopped the persecution on Grouse Moors. England is no better and I won't go to parts of that either. Unbelievable this is the 21st not the 19th Century!27982017-06-10T21:05:28.2815504Gillian KenneyA dangerous road ...not fit for purpose ...needs urgent attention...needs to be upgraded allow safer travel for all who use it .A MAJOR Need for dual carriage status ..and bypasses Maybole and Girvan28562017-06-10T21:53:36.65315505john SNEDDONMy friend took advantage or releasing funds from his pension in order to receive treatment in the USA......£20K later he has had some successful treatment to reduce the symptoms but it is clear that much more should be on offer from NHS Scotland to help alleviate the horrible symptoms that Lyme disease presents. I sometimes think that the SG does more to help malaria sufferers in developing countries than it does to help Lyme disease sufferers in Scotland.28042017-06-11T04:33:06.66715506george coburn This road is well overdue some major upgrading \r\n\r\n28562017-06-11T11:01:42.89715507Tracey IrvingSigned. Totally unfit for purpose and is not conducive to the economic growth of the south west of Scotland. It's a road of death and will continue to be until imperative upgrade.28562017-06-11T11:20:54.38315508John FairleyCan we just get brought into the 21st Century with a road network that's fit for purpose28562017-06-11T12:08:39.9215509DerekThe road surface is terrible at present lost count of the numerous potholes between Stranraer and Ayr. \r\nThe streets of Maybole are not wide enough to cop with the hgv passing through. 28562017-06-11T20:01:51.92315510Annette BlainThe A77 is a disgrace and more money has to be found to upgrade this road. No more talk of independence when we have a main road as bad as this one. Spend on this road now and save lives as this is an accident waiting to happen28562017-06-11T22:28:14.4915511Amy VintThis road requires some serious upgrading. It is a major road connecting various communities as well as the main route for large trucks going to and from Ireland. What we also need to address is the sections of road which are not being monitored by average speed cameras and being used for racing. There have been several accidents and unfortunate fatalities. 28562017-06-12T07:38:00.22315512Alan McLachlanStage one commit to regular pot hole filling and resurfacing.\r\nTwo: Deal with issues relating to stability of sidings\r\nThree: Bypas for Maybol and Girvan \r\nFour: more passing places28562017-06-12T10:15:00.32315513Gilbert SummersTime that folk spoke up and made efforts to stop this environmental degradation, seen especially in the Eastern Highlands, carried out on behalf of and for the benefit of a small clique of (Tory) landowners.27982017-06-12T12:32:37.6115514Gail HodgsonPlease help this group of people struggling because of inadequate testing28042017-06-12T13:09:06.2115515Rev Arrick Dempster WilkinsonAs a Senior citizen, whose wife has had 4 strokes amd is paralysed and unable to speak, I regularly have to follow the ambulance to Ayr Hospital if my wife needs to be transmitted. The nature of the traffic outside our front door (which is straight onto the A77) is such that it has taken more than 20 minutes to exit the driveway, due to the average speed of vehicles often reaching a (measured) 60 mph, and vehicles using Ballantrae as a straight where they can do whatever speed they like, whenever they like, day or night. This includes lorries, cars and motorbikes. I was recently involved in an accident at Glenapp Church when a motorcyclist attempted to pass the car I was travelling in on the inside, despite the fact we had been signalling for a left turn from before the blind corner with a concealed entranceway to Glenapp Church - both of which are clearly signposted. These are just two examples of the hazards of the A77. - I could list at least another dozen or so examples. It is truly a disgrace to the visitors who come from 28562017-06-12T15:45:40.73715516Anne ThomasIt is very concerning that the number of red kites on the Black Isle seems to be falling due to persecution. So many small tourism ventures now rely on wildlife such as birds of prey and dolphins. It is time this was recognised rather than always listening to a small number of landowners who are degrading the ecology. The number of traps for small mammals on such land should also be investigated. 27982017-06-12T16:21:24.4915517SandraMaybole is desperately needing a bypass before someone is killed 28562017-06-12T16:26:03.05315518Eleanor Juckes I was bitten by a tick whilst on a family camping holiday in the summer of 2013. We were camping in Kirkpatrick Fleming, Scotland. I have been diagnosed with Chronic Lyme Disease and have struggled beyond belief for almost 4 years to get a diagnosis or treatment by the NHS. I thoroughly believe that more awareness of this disease, not only in where and how it can be contracted but how to diagnose and treat this, long term is absolutely essential. 28042017-06-12T17:03:25.83715519Annette DaviesArchaic testing! No sense in raising awareness of Lyme Disease if tests are so poorly diagnosed and if they are detected people are not treated sufficiently to eradicate symptoms 28042017-06-12T17:07:54.24315520David TurnerThis road provides a hi-safety risk and is a constraint on business growth between U.K. SCOTLAND &NI28562017-06-12T18:33:08.91715521Kathryn WalkerThe health care for Lyme Disease in Scotland is woefully inadequate. Those affected are often forced to go abroad for treatment. Scotland, as an established innovator, could be at the forefront of providing effective Lyme Disease treatment. I had hopes of moving to Scotland but can't as - as a chronic Lyme Disease sufferer - my medical needs could not be met.28042017-06-12T19:31:07.47715523Natalie dugdaleI was bitten in Surrey whilst camping, things need to be done to stop this epidemic. It is not fair to have inadequate testing and no treatment. This is an extremely debilitating disease. Once you have lyme your quality of life is over. It affects every part of your body which is why it's so hard to diagnose. Each week you may end up at the gp with something else wrong and it makes you appear as though you are mad! I have been ill for nearly 3 years and have become almost bed ridden and house bound! It's time government woke up to the realisation of how unfair Lyme is. No one who it bitten has self inflicted this therefore they deserve help with treatment. Please don't ignore us any more we need support adaquate testing and treatment available to all. 28042017-06-12T19:47:12.53715524Lesley MorrisIn full support of the petitioner in determining what the benefit of grouse hunting is and what negative or even positive effects it has on the environment. 27982017-06-12T21:51:41.11315527Rev Arrick Dempster WilkinsonI live in Ballantrae with my wife. She frequently has to be taken by ambulance to Ayr Hospital. It took us, last time 20 minutes just to get out the driveway due to the volume of traffic heading north, mainly lorries. I have a speed measuring app on my phone and most of them were doing between 60 - 70mph in a 30mph limit. I have had water sprayed over the house by a lorry heading southward - the far side of the road - yet we have a reasonable sized garden to the front. The state of the road reflects its usage with more potholes than an "A" road should have. I was recently involved in an accident at Glenapp Church entrance from the A77 when, despite the fact that we were signalling to turn left, and that it is a marked concealed entrance, a motor-bike struck the passenger door as he was attempting to pass on the inside. All of these examples are from the last 3 months and we have lived in the house for nearly 5 years. Ballantrae has both elderly people walking on the pavement but having difficulty crossing the road, and children from the local school who live locally, encoutering the same problem. Action is needed, and what is proposed in the petition is reasonable. But increased maintenance of the road, speed cameras in the villages would help a little whilst plans for the coberting the duelling A77 into a dual A77 from whitletts to Cairnryan would also help greatly.28562017-06-12T22:57:02.0215528Vicky BurfordMy son has been ill for 10 months after becoming unwell in Tenerife. We have been passed from pillar to post, dr to dr with no support or help. Turns out following 10 months of my own research and the help of a private foreign dr that my son has tested positive for Lyme. If my son had been treated properly in the early stages of the disease he could have been cured completely. As it is, my son has suffered for nearly a year, missed out on a whole year of school and has very little chance of being completely cured. If Lyme disease and the dangers of under treating it was understood by NHS practitioners, so many people (and children) would be spared a chronic and lifelong life limiting illness. Not to mention the emotional strain of not being believed!28042017-06-12T23:45:04.27715529Cynthia BrumbaughNot only is affordable testing and treatment necessary, it is imperative. Lyme Disease is teaching pandemic proportions and we must do everything possible to help those afflicted as well as find a way to prevent it. This disease hurts everyone including society as a whole. Those afflicted are unpredictable workers who often lose their jobs as a result. Losing jobs puts a strain on social services and many with Lyme Disease are then denied benefits from greedy governments which only causes homelessness and more social strain. Profiteers whether MD or Naturopath take advantage of desperate patients and charge exhorbinate fees for treatments and promises and trust me, the treatments bring out MORE symptoms and make the sick - worse. Unfortunately to kill the bacteria you will have herxing and I'd rather herx and be done with it and attempt to regain my life then drag out treatments and prolong the agony. There HAS to be a better way for us all. Let's work on finding solutions.28042017-06-12T23:53:00.76315530D JessopThe NHS is failing me. I had to beg for antibiotics after months of late lyme type symptoms. They made a big improvement but didn't cure me. I now have a four month wait to even see a neurologist and haven't been referred to a dermatologist even though I have both types of symptoms. Only one GP has even considered Lyme but says she knows nothing about the conditions it gives. The other GPs have dismissed the idea out of hand despite ongoing symptoms. Many and varied blood tests all reveal nothing!28042017-06-13T05:13:31.18315531Belinda RigbyGovernment are wasting so much money. I have been sent to so many specialists and had so many tests only to be discharged. Cardiology, rheumatology, neurology, endoscopy, urology...etc etc WAKE UP! WE NEED LYME SPECIALISTS! 28042017-06-13T09:46:12.0615532Grace FenwickI live in south-west Scotland beside 200 acres of spruce plantation which is full of roe and red deer. The roe come and sleep in our garden and I have regularly picked off ticks after doing some gardening. I spoke to the practice nurse a few years ago about ticks and Lymes disease. She assured me ticks don't affect humans?!! She is the SENIOR practice nurse. Obviously a serious course of education much needed!28042017-06-13T09:58:07.18715533DianeIn totalagreement with this petition,time for the Scottish Government to make a stance,show the rest of the UK that we care about our wildlife and natural habitats !! Far too much of the Highlands is left barren,rather than green and luscious,and for what ??? Tourists love our country, as do we Scots, they don't want to see land bare,dull,lifeless.The persecution of our BoPand other wildlife needs to stop, leave the land to grow,to flourish,plant trees, make it beautiful again !!! 27982017-06-13T10:14:13.65315534Al WoodcockInteresting to read here that we have 10-15% of the world's blanket bog, when the pro shooting brigade tell us how 70% of the world's moorland is in the UK and that they're protecting it. They don't mention that it's being 'protected' at the expense of blanket bog by cutting and draining it!27982017-06-13T10:14:29.98715535Nicola SealLyme is not rare it's underdiagnosed. The current testing misses around 48% of true cases. The treatment offered on the NHS is woefully inadequate- this is a persistent bacteria and it needs long term treatment with combination antibiotics and antiprotozoals where there are protozoal coinfections. If I'd stuck with the NHS I'd be dead or severely disabled by now. We need infectious diseases consultants to open their minds and start reading the latest primary literature on Lyme and coinfections. It's not a simple infection easily eradicated with a month of doxycycline! But it is treatable and patients can gain a good quality of life back again. 28042017-06-13T10:45:22.41315536Carol SmithI live in the W Midlands but travelled throughout the UK as a child. I have been ill all my adult life (40+ years). No testing, no proper diagnosis, just left to waste my life. My own research and private testing showed Lyme and other infections. Treatment has made a big difference. NHS test was negative and my GP refuses to help, although he can see, and acknowledges, that I am a lot better.\r\n\r\nWe need better testing and we need to emphasise the effect of this illness on the country's bottom line. Wasted money on pointless NHS appointments (cardiology, rheumatology, ID, etc, etc), wasted money on benefits for those too ill to work, wasted money as people work part-time or not at all and so pay no or lower taxes, wasted money on training for people who cannot pursue careers (yes, this happens to NHS employees - who have cost thousands to train and are then too ill to work). This illness is costing the country millions.28042017-06-13T11:20:30.16715537Catherine DavidsonI was diagnosed with Lyme disease last year in the Victoria hospital in Kirkcaldy in Fife Scotland but I go untreated as I was given antibiotics from hospital only to have a doctor at say catherine it's not Lyme disease, and they took me of the antibiotics so I only had three days on antibiotics, I need help I am ill , I had the antibodies for Lyme, but with it not being treated now I live in constant pain my throats is all sore my neck burns up my face swells , my joints hurt and swell up, my hands are so sore I do not know where to turn I need help , please help me , I was bitten 5 year ago 28042017-06-13T12:36:32.97715538GillI hate that grouse shooting still continues at the expense of the wonderful wildlife in Scotland. It is the wildlife that has drawn me to Scotland for holidays for many years and hopefully more to come.27982017-06-13T12:47:23.92315539GORDON JAMES WANLESSi live on edge of richmond park ...where many have caught lyme disease#\r\n28042017-06-13T14:24:21.98315541tim donaldsonA separate dual carriageway would help to split leisure and business traffic leaving the ferries and heading North on the A77 towards Glasgow. The leisure traffic could use and enjoy the existing road with its splendid panoramic views across the Firth of Clyde while the business, commercial, haulage traffic would be able to flow at a higher speed on the dual carriageway more safely than it can with the current setup.28562017-06-13T16:28:03.81315577M.OliverMy daughter was bitten last year by a tick- she had a rash and immediate awful symptoms. She has literally begged the NHS for help, but they either don't know what to do or when she failed to be cured they then cast doubt that she had it despite a clear history of increasing symptoms from tick bite, use of wheelchair after three months, and awful suffering. The attitude she has been subjected to is appalling, verging on the contemptuous. Before the bite she was a trouble-free patient interested in a healthy lifestyle. She has even had it implied that she is making it up. She is not the one who is making things up-\r\n those who say that lyme disease is rare and cured easily are making things up. Something must change. I want my daughter to receive care and treatment she is entitled to expect.28042017-06-13T18:34:18.64315578Craig McDickenThe road can be treacherous at times especially during rush hour. I've actually been struck by a lorry on this road in Maybole - I was on the path ! Worst road in Ayrshire by far. 28562017-06-13T20:17:00.01715579J LinesI have had hundreds of ticks over the years whilst being outdoors in the highlands of Scotland. Luckily I haven't caught lymes disease but a few of my friends have, and it could have been prevented if it was diagnosed sooner by their GP's. And more should be done in making people aware of the problem and for GP's to take it more seriously. 28042017-06-13T21:29:06.05715580John Martin The decline in birds of pray is shocking especially hen harriers this is not just isolated to Scotland. England as well. This needs to be done all over the UK.27982017-06-13T21:42:57.71715581Mike cooperWe need a scientific investigation to conclusively prove or disprove the disadvantages of moorlands being managed solely for grouse shooting27982017-06-13T22:48:42.3915582Norman Brown A77 is an accident black spot .28562017-06-13T23:06:09.86315583Rhona QuarmI live on the A77 in Maybole on Cassillis road. My house has damage which I do deliver is due to the rumbling vehicles. It is 20 mile an hour speed limit yet very few vehicles bother to stick to 30 let alone 20. A flashing traffic speed limit light would help I believe as it dos in Minishant and Crisshill. \r\nI have on too many occasions nearly been hit by traffic as such narrow streets and I live at the bottom of Redbrae where artic trucks swing out and have almost hit me or vehicle as I try to reverse into my drive way. \r\n\r\nMaybole has some stunning buildings but the street is too dangerous to walk up it. Let's home something can be fine before somebody is killed. \r\n\r\nThanks 28562017-06-13T23:37:02.115584Eileen HookThis road is a main road for traffic to catch the Ferries to Ireland. It is badly in need of up grading due to the volume of traffic on a high risk road28562017-06-14T08:16:27.49315585Mark VeaterThe management of uplands solely for grouse shooting is a national environmental scandal which has been ignored and even promoted by successive governments pandering to vested interests. A wholesale change is needed, based on science, and the welfare of all users of the upland environment. The squeezing of this habitat as a result of climate warming makes it even more urgent. 27982017-06-14T12:29:27.96715586frank hamiltonstatement sets out clearly that facts need to be established and fully verified.27982017-06-14T18:51:11.9515587Johnny RuskThis is the main road artery between the great cities of Glasgow and Belfast, yet at Maybole, this becomes a single track if the supermarket lorry is parked up! Not to mention the local school children who dice with death every lunchtime as articulated lorries pass within inches of them.28562017-06-14T19:00:21.82715588BenA motorway with hard shoulders and service stations is what is required . M77 should be extended down to Cairnryan 28562017-06-15T10:37:45.61319790Walter McCallWe have needed this upgrade for too many years28562017-06-15T11:01:54.30319791MICHAEL GILLIEPLEASE SORT THIS TRUNK ROAD BEFORE THE DEATH TOLL RISES EVEN MORE AND FIFTY MPH FOR TRUCKS SAME AS PERTH TO INVERNESS PLEASE 28562017-06-15T11:13:33.86719792paul de vosall improvements to these roads are life saving truck driver for Royal Mail NI28562017-06-15T11:44:45.38319793Stepeh PayneAs a business, we use the port 5 days per week. Any upgrade to the road network for smoother flowing traffic must be supported. 28562017-06-15T12:14:15.21719794Graham marshallHeather burning wipes out loads of small mamals its about time we moved on from these oldie world pastimes cruel use of land they get away with driving new roads into our wilderness in order to facilitate easy acsess for partys of shooters the elite few they use OUR LAND for there murderous activitys27982017-06-15T12:28:44.5819795Sheila MacdonaldAfter 4 years of a multitude of symptoms I have been diagnosed by private testing. GP's took my symptoms seriously but as the NHS test was negative, they had difficulty in knowing which speciality to refer me to. Investigations included innumerous blood tests, eye examinations, referral to Maxillofacial Surgeon, Neurologist (private due to 10 month waiting list in NHS Highland), Infectious Diseases Consultant and Physiotherapist and two admissions to A&E. This has had a hugely detrimental impact both physically and emotionally. An adequate blood test for Lyme will be more resourceful for the NHS as well as meaning quicker diagnosis and appropriate treatment for patients. 28042017-06-15T12:50:13.04719796Diane GilmoreWe have two major ferry ports just outside Stranraer at Cairnryan, Stenaline and P&O! Tourism is one of our main incomes in the area. If our roads are not upgraded we wont get the continued traffic as the roads are now a danger to anyone travelling on them due to landslides and major pot holes. Please help this forgot, beautiful part of Scotland!28562017-06-15T13:04:35.90719797Patricia DeucharThis is a vital service and should NOT be cut!!!28562017-06-15T13:28:25.10319798William GillespieAt long last we are moving in the right direction for the time being ! Maybole is the perfect example of an accident waiting to happen. I have seen the pedestrian crossing giving you the green man to cross and articulated lorries driving on through.28562017-06-15T14:37:15.68719799Robin NicholAs soon as possible 28562017-06-15T14:39:17.01719800MicheleThis is a major route for traffic to Scotland & England from Northern Ireland, but it has not had the investment in infrastructure to reflect it & the towns along the route were never designed for the volume both commercial & other traffic that uses the route.28562017-06-15T15:39:34.9919801Alexis PiperThis road is dangerous. If it was your Gran who had to walk on a path of just 37 inches with lorries speeding past , you would soon do something about it not wait over 50 years28562017-06-15T17:23:35.58319802George MurdochMany claims have been made as to the economic necessity of driven grouse shooting being a necessity for the continuing viability, both economic and environmentally, of our uplands. Little has been said as to the inhibiting economic effects of being so heavily dependant on one industry of of the huge cost to biodiversity that intensive management practises that driven grouse shoots now appear to demand. It is only fair that the Scottish public are given the true facts of the matter so they can be included in how the decisions are made regarding our countries future. 27982017-06-15T19:37:52.78719803Kim SwanDefinitely needed keeping Scottish ports viable28562017-06-15T20:06:00.3219804Diana Mc Cormick Long overdue we are a forgot corner 28562017-06-15T21:42:06.38319805Susan GoodeHate to think wildlife is being lost, particularly birds of prey for the sake of shooting driven grouse27982017-06-15T21:44:44.1819807CATHERINE BRANSONTransport Scotland We need better roads in Dumfries and Galloway.Now28562017-06-15T22:49:26.56319809Davie fae BridgetonGood luck in your venture28562017-06-16T11:13:16.2124408susan flemingABUSE OF OUR NATIVE HABITATS & WILDLIFE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED!!!27982017-06-16T11:23:44.3324409James McAdamIt is like a third world road.28562017-06-16T13:09:01.34324410DavidBlasphemy law has no place in modern liberal united society.28792017-06-16T22:00:43.93324411Antonia Gordon It is essential we test properly in line with other countries such as Germany. 28042017-06-17T08:22:19.6824412Claire Ryan Heatley No one should be left unsupported and at sea to navigate a complex illness without adequate diagnostic aids, treatments and understanding. Well done for raising awareness on this.28042017-06-17T17:25:06.5828631Norman E ThomasI have had many tick bites over the years and contracted Lyme disease on one occasion which was promptly diagnosed and successfully treated, in part due to my own awareness but because my GP was also aware and sympathetic. I have friends who have not been so fortunate and have had years of denial from medical professionals and shamefully inadequate treatment from the NHS. Awareness needs to be raised in both the public at large and medical practitioners. Thank you for the opportunity to raise the issue.28042017-06-18T11:32:58.75733259Jannine HarrisEven though I have tested positive for Lyme and had some treatment, more could and should be done to improve my health and others like me. 19 months after the worst of it and I'm fortunate to be back to about 60% of my post Lyme self. As I say, more could and should be done.28042017-06-18T12:05:19.89733260Janice SmallAnd for doctors not to be restricted and afraid to treat beyond recommended guidelines. 28042017-06-18T12:25:48.02733261Ian rennie The road from Ayr to Stranraer is we'll over due a face lift duel carriageways is badly required 28562017-06-18T13:01:47.70333262Pamela MichaelsonIt is not just sad, but horrifying to see the lack of accurate diagnosis, and adequate treatment given to your people.\r\nYou must change this.\r\nPlease.28042017-06-18T15:14:05.36333263Michelle Let's open up south west Scotland 28562017-06-18T16:12:31.27333264Gail Murray This bypass has been long over due!!! Every day I walk up Maybole High Street I get anxious with how close the huge HGVS etc are to us pedestrians to try and get by another vehicle!! And the 20mph speed limit is a waste of time due to idiotic drivers not sticking to the speed limit. And the kids that have to cross the A77 to get to Carrick Academy. I had to stop traffic 2 years ago at the top of Maybole High Street to help a woman who had got knocked down. Even when I held her hand I had huge lorries and a car transporter managed to make sure they got by us with inches to spare!!!!28562017-06-18T16:17:21.9833265Kevin mccalmontIn this day and age to have roads like this to a major port is ridiculous.28562017-06-18T17:07:52.76333266Lesley KnightMyself and my son are chronic Lyme disease sufferers with severe neurological symptoms. We and hte thousands of others need appropriate help.28042017-06-18T17:55:14.4633267anne connollyAction is required as soon as possible to diagnose and treat those affected by Lyme Disease.28042017-06-18T18:52:58.5933268Gillian MasonI have been ill now for almost 20. Years! I had no knowledge of ticks and neither did the doctor when I went to see her after being bitten in Richmond Park in London. I had a bullseye rash which was expanding everyday, I explained to her that it did not itch or hurt in anyway, just that I was concerned by the ever increasing rash. The Doctor gave me an antibiotic for 7 days. I never thought anymore about it until recently hearing and reading about the illness called Lyme Disease. Then I realised this has been the cause of my ill health for all these years. If there was better testing and more knowledge regarding this dibilatating disease, it would help the poor patients who are suffering and also help the funds of our NHS by helping them get better so as they can once again lead full and productive lives.28042017-06-18T19:17:28.4733269Stan DuncanThorough research please27982017-06-18T19:30:36.84333270Calum AbernethyMore time and money needs to be invested in further research into this debilitating disease.28042017-06-18T19:37:40.78733271WCheesmanIt,s meant to be a Euro Route, but it is hopeless. 28562017-06-18T20:03:06.25733272Veronica hamiltonLong overdue28562017-06-18T20:37:18.0433273Sally ProeI too am a sufferer it's about time something was done about Lyme. Sick of being sick.28042017-06-18T23:42:24.8533274Karen Anderson I have just driven down the A77 from Ayr to Stranraer and cannot believe the deterioration in the road. 28562017-06-19T00:07:45.46333275Garry ThomsonExtend the m77 further down then go dual carriage all way to cairnryan28562017-06-19T02:11:13.433276Donald McHarrieWe are the forgotten and ignored corner of Scotland, think about the 30mph urban limit dropping to 20mph and without bypasses how much longer journeys would take on A77 with all its other problems. Dual Carriageway would allow the HGVs to legally travel at 50mph, cars can do 70mph So it now has become a priority to upgrade this road and to bypass as many villages and towns as possible.Thank you everyone who has signed it and commented.28562017-06-19T05:44:58.08333277Julia MacDonaldTravel this road regularly and the A75 each day - both are absolutely horrendous roads. Life in your hands stuff, between potholes, subsidence, and lack of passing places. Convoys of 12-20 articulated lorries. Road signs hidden by dirt or trees, falling trees, and lack of grit when it's freeing. Pathetic traffic lights, a slippery road sign near Kilphin for 2-3 years without actually fixing the problem. Awful just awful and both roads equally as bad.28562017-06-19T12:35:10.4733278Ruhi ThallonWe really need to stop this barbarism called 'sport'. Scottish Gov is letting its people and voters down. It's about time you stood up to the 'landed gentry' it is YOU we vote for to govern us not them. Look after the land and our wildlife properly. Tourists would much prefer to see these native animals thriving than the land scorched and wildlife decimated. 27982017-06-19T23:13:45.6333279Elizabeth Lindsay My son got Lyme disease after doing his duke of Edinburgh award age 16 . We had to eventually to go privately to get treatment as he wasn't getting anywhere on the NHS . Lyme disease is so debilitating and very difficult to treat . More needs to be done ! 28042017-06-20T08:49:14.40333281LisaI personally know three people with Lymes disease who live near me and yet when I asked to be tested on one occasion after a suspicious looking bite I was told by the GP that it was rare and not to worry about it - no test28042017-06-20T10:25:39.63733282Angelica Mainland After 7 months of all these horrible symptoms and having 4 positive tests of Lyme disease GP deny treatment as they never saw a tick bit. Now I need to travel abroad to get treatment by specialist that knows and understand the illness even I am base in London. GP's and even specialist in tropical illness doctors lack of information about Lyme and co-infections. And my understanding there is not a specific test for it in the UK and 21 days of antibiotics are not enough to get ride of the borrelia or co-infections specially if you have had it for more than 4 months. 28042017-06-20T13:49:49.77333283Jill Gardner 8 years sick before I went private after doing my own research. The treatment I've received from GPs prior to this is appalling. Made to feel a nuisance and a hypochondriac. \r\n\r\nI was given an NHS test eventually but I knew at that point it would be negative due to the test not being sensitive enough for chronic infections. Despite. A positive private test, my god and neurologist refuse to connect my symptoms.\r\n\r\nI went from teaching up to 30 hours of fitness a week to often struggling to climb stairs. I've lost my career and my confidence in the NHS. Now I'm financially ruined by this, struggling to make any money and have no treatment plan. As the Drs suggested to start with, just live with it! I am deceststed at the loss of my life and the future is unknown. 28042017-06-20T19:44:42.16733284Derek lindsayI think we need better testing ,treatment research and education into this debilitating condition . The NHS if failing thousands of very ill people. 28042017-06-21T07:04:01.19733285John ButterfieldThe wanton destruction of Scotland's upland ecosystems at the hands of grouse moor managers casts an ugly shadow over Scotland's reputation as a wildlife tourism reputation. 27982017-06-21T08:56:17.26733286Paul LewisThere is a long overdue need to get some objective facts about the real value of this activity. And compare this against the value of other activities, such as income associated with wildlife tourism.27982017-06-21T09:29:25.2333287Keith BallardNeed consider carefully the economic losses from having moorland depleted of wildlife as a result of the land and wildlife management practices carried out (some illegal) in order to sustain the breeding of high populations of grouse for shooting.27982017-06-21T09:38:41.29333288Joe WinstanleyA review into the economic impacts of grouse shooting is long overdue - any responsible Govt is surely obliged to accurately inform itself, and the public, as to the externalised costs of any major land use. 27982017-06-21T10:00:51.62733289David ParkinI have long been alarmed at the damage being done to Scotland's uplands by the Ill-founded management practised by some of its owners. This study must address the perceived wisdom of rotational muir-burn and intensification of grouse management on the status of alternative wildlife such as eagles, falcons, harriers and Mountain Hares.27982017-06-21T12:35:07.19333290Eileen FrostIt is hard to justify this so called sport, as it is for the priviliged who unfortunately have little interest in the environment. They just enjoy killing.27982017-06-21T13:10:45.05333291Dennis PattonKilling for sport is primitive. Stop the slaughter. Stop the barbarians. 27982017-06-21T16:06:00.6233292karl freemanthe news about this problem is very well known.there is no shying away from it.it is a disgrace that it still continues in this modern world.even the americans think it's stupid.it need to stop completely for the sake of the world.27982017-06-21T16:19:55.09333293Jim HallAt a time when we should be more conscious of our carbon dioxide emissions (eg turn gadgets off standby, etc), why must we witness the hills go up in flame every spring when a heather moorland and peat bog can trap more CO2 than a tropical rain forest?27982017-06-21T18:40:39.37733294Mark MclaughlinTicks and Lyme disease present a serious and growing threat to public health. Proper research and action is desperately needed.28042017-06-21T22:43:55.3833295KirstieI had a tick bite in South West Scotland in 2012, I was treated for Lyme disease in 2014. Here's hoping for better understanding, testing and treatment in Scotland and all over the UK, to end the suffering and disregard for so many Lyme disease patients. 28042017-06-21T22:49:53.89733296Paul FisherThis is 2017. Blood sports are not a tradition, they are a relic.27982017-06-22T01:19:23.84733297Diane FergusonThere is no definitive test for lymes disease in the UK, there is a test available in places like Germany. I would like to state how dissapionting and frustrating it is not to have a definitive test in the UK as there are so many people living in countryside areas where ticks and limes disease is common and a huge problem. Please provide this test in the U.K. When you are able to diagnose someone with lymes disease you are often putting their mind at rest as many of the symptoms of lymes mirror some more serious life long neurological conditions. In diagnosing someone you are then giving them ability to seek the correct treatment which in turn allows them to take charge of their lives and recover from the condition.28042017-06-22T05:25:14.92733298Lisa Donaldson Funding for research and treatment for such a complex disease is imperative and Now! 28042017-06-22T05:54:10.48333299Pilvikki InnamaaI am asking why the medical community are in denial of Lyme Disease?28042017-06-22T08:17:24.87733300Pauline Deuchars We need better awareness of symptoms, treatments and research on this disease, until a friend got lymes disease I had no idea how serious it was, or that you got it from a tiny (and they are smaller than I thought) tick, more awareness on these little critters and what they look like, and how to remove them safely would be good also. 28042017-06-22T08:35:05.94333301Stephen Charles WebsterOne of the benefits of driven grouse shooting, we are often told, is the promotion of healthy populations of birds like curlew, lapwing and golden plover. Here in the outer Hebrides we have thriving populations of all these birds and many others alongside thriving populations of raptors including hen harriers, and no driven grouse shooting. 27982017-06-22T09:47:11.90733302Nonie HorsmanProper independent research and open debate - we all need healthy moorlands for recreation, ecosystem services like clean water and flood reduction, nature and wildlife - benefits to all 27982017-06-22T10:25:49.20333303Alison MccaffertyPlease help towards changing the law to help people of public victims of companies and have a fair balance where we can have help of the police too instead of just having to go to ombudsman. We are victims of business alike everyday! We sgould not be ignored as some of the actions can turn your life upside down and we have to spend months trying to sort things out where a lot of companies get off with too much! While if you where to be the one to cause any damage to the business theft etc the police are involved right away it becomes a crime right away and we are told to go and get legal advice its a civil matter.\r\n\r\nPLEASE SIGN TO CHANGE THIS LAW SO CONSUMER VICTIMS HAVE THE SAME RIGHTS AND TAKEN SERIOUSLY!!28732017-06-22T11:53:11.7233304Nell NovakWhat should have been a lovely hill walk last week was ruined for me by having to pass dozens of shooting butts. The thrill of seeing a family of baby grouse, and the distraction display of the mother was more than tinged with sadness and despair at the thought of what awaits that family in a few months time. Tourists must surely come away with the same impression. Such barbarity for the privileged few is a blight on our beautiful country, which is worth so much more than that.27982017-06-22T13:16:45.72733305Leo barclayIs this going out to all G.P,s ? It is vital to test more thoroughly and raise awareness. 28042017-06-22T17:14:29.2833306anthony Bolton About time this disease was consigned to history 28042017-06-22T17:18:25.3933307Michael BREFFITI have two friends who contracted Lymes disease some years ago they were both very ill for some time and still suffer from powerful muscle aches which may be a side effect. I do not think enough is done to raise awareness nor improve testing and treatment.28042017-06-22T17:20:02.02733308Ian A DuncanI am aware of an individual who died as a consequence of diagnosis and treatment being too late28042017-06-22T18:57:50.0233309Pete rolloSpend on research now to avoid enormous suffering and medical costs into the future.28042017-06-22T19:17:30.633310Colin KerrI have been treated for Lyme Disease twice but never tested for it.\r\nI'm told it is very hard to detect and have been given all the signs to look for which are the same signs for a great variety of other problems?28042017-06-22T19:22:37.02333311Alex HuttonToo many ticks and not enough medical awareness. 28042017-06-22T20:56:25.10733312Alexander PrestonInvestment in research required, loosen deer stalking red tape. Allow a tag system for the public on all forestry commission ground 28042017-06-22T21:07:21.7433313Hunter WatsonI have submitted this petition in the hope that it will be instrumental in persuading the Scottish Government to legislate to make it unlawful for care homes to conceal antipsychotic drugs in the food or drink of care home residents. That happened to my mother after she entered a care home. She had dementia and the administration of those drugs to a people with dementia greatly increases the risk that they will die early or have a stroke. I would be a prime candidate for surreptitious sedation for two reasons: I would be assessed as being agitated because I would be unable to remain seated all day and would be most unhappy if, like my late mother I was locked inside the home. The other reason is that, like my late mother, I do not take medication so it could only be administered surreptitiously since care home residents, unlike those in mental health hospitals, cannot be held down and injected with drugs against their will. It was such considerations that caused me to begin campaigning but in the course of campaigning I learned more and more about what is wrong with current mental health and incapacity legislation and how people are suffering and even dying horrible deaths as a consequence.28852017-06-22T22:29:51.4833314Mrs Claire Patricia MuirThe Act is currently illegal. See UN General Comment No 39. Forced treatment is against the human right to refuse treatment. Therefore the act is not human rights compatable as per Scotland Act.28852017-06-23T09:07:56.59733315June ArmstrongWider education and awareness in the recognition of the symptoms is imperative for prompt, appropriate treatment.28042017-06-23T09:49:23.16733316John AllanI know too many fellow Keepers and Deer Stalkers with this cripling desease28042017-06-23T09:55:53.4633317Robert Brown SmithAs a part time deer manager and game shooter, I am in the countryside and handling deer very often. Over the years I have been bitten by ticks on numerous occasions and have been prescribed antibiotics by my doctor as a precaution after he noticed a tick removal site which appeared infected. 20 years ago the doctors dismissed the possibility of Lymes disease as they thought it very unlikely to be a problem.28042017-06-23T10:49:07.25333318Rosalind MacRaeI have had Lymes so fully support more awareness.28042017-06-23T12:16:54.6433319Dr Peter J. Gordon(1) As an NHS Psychiatrist working in Scotland for the last 25 years I fully support this petition.\r\n(2)Mr Hunter Watson states in this current petition, that a previous petition, PE01494 was closed without discussion and that "I was informed that Committee agreed to close my petition as the consequence of an instruction from a senior official or civil servant." Given the recent review of the Scottish Parliament and concerns that Scottish Government may not have been as effectively held to account as it should be, I would suggest this serious matter is looked into and the findings shared publically. This is a serious matter and it should be established if the Civil Service Code of Conduct has been followed.\r\n(3) My petition PE01493, A Sunshine Act for Scotland was closed 15 months. It had public support as established by the SHC consultation. Yet there has been no public update from the Scottish Government in 15 months. This would seem to be a further example of the Scottish Parliament failing to hold the Scottish Government to account.28852017-06-23T12:23:14.9533320David RamsayMy wife contracted Lyme Disease 10 years ago and it changed her life adversely foever28042017-06-23T21:34:39.99333321Barry Gale I have signed because my mother was confined in hospital for the last 2 years of her life under a Compulsory Treatment Order. She died because the hospital and social services refused to allow her to regain mobility after a successful hip operation, and refused her physiotherapy and an examination by a specialist. The Mental Health Act was used to remove her from my care without any assessment of risk or of my ability to care for her. The Sheriff Court awarded Guardianship to the Local Authority because I was opposed to her being locked up in hospital. Her wishes to live at home in my care and for me to make any decisions which she could not make, were ignored, as was her vehement opposition to the Council being appointed her Guardian. I appealed both decisions to the Court of Session, because they were not based on law and evidence but on the opinions of a psychiatrist and social workers who were determined to place her in institutional care and refused my offers of compromises and my requests for assessments. Both appeals were refused. \r\n\r\nScotland claims to be a champion of human rights, and to have world-leading mental health legislation. Instead it gives psychiatrists and social workers the power to deprive the weak and helpless of their liberty and, in cases like that of my mother, of their lives, instead of allowing them to have control of their own lives. 28852017-06-23T21:57:15.6233322Christine MacVicarAll transcriptions of tribunals sould be provided free of charge.\r\nWhen a psychiatrist makes a statement to a tribunal, I.e. Patient has been jailed for sexual assault, they should be required to prove this by giving police records, dates etc.\r\nLives are ruin by unscrupulous psychiatrists.28852017-06-24T07:45:10.32733323Shaun O'Grady Just left in agony and to die 28042017-06-24T13:56:41.49733324Paul BratermanIt is an insult to whatever gods there may be to suggest that they need legal protection from being insulted28792017-06-24T15:16:00.89333326Debra TorranceA modern, future thinking Scotland shouldn't be a haven for canned hunt enthusiasts. We must thoroughly investigate the real benefits to the environment and wildlife of traditional hunts and shoots in Scotland. Incorporated into the investigation should be the overall welfare of domestic and wild animals as well as the impact on our landscapes. 27982017-06-24T18:05:53.29333327DarrenTime to halt this outdated intensification and control of our uplands. Stop killing native wildlife to kill game. 27982017-06-24T19:17:37.58733328Julie StebbingsDriven grouse shooting is hugely damaging to indigenous wildlife and the environment. These factors must be taken into account as they have knock-on economic effects. Also, I believe many driven grouse shoots are owned by people who do not pay tax in this country - this has to stop!27982017-06-24T19:24:38.55733329AIDriven grouse shooting is an utterly unnecessary.27982017-06-25T04:50:43.81733330Elizabeth BatesI hadn't known much about this disease and the seriousness until now. Please increase awarenesd28042017-06-25T13:05:40.60333332Lesley McDadepeople with a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia do not necessarily need to be medicated. It is about knowledge not clinical need and consultants need to have the ability to get expert advice from a wide range of specialists rather than saying " I believe ... you are paranoid schizophrenic". That belief in itself may be lacking in knowledge and experience and put a lifetime cosh on someone who is perfectly sane. With this diagnosis "knowledge" is as important as not everyone is pyschotic with this diagnosis and it takes 2 years to go through the system before a person can say no to medication and get their life back. The stigma associated with this diagnosis is also horrendous.28852017-06-25T15:14:06.80733333Nicholas GibbQuite honestly, we as a country are blinded by all the rules and regulations governing the land and wildlife of this country! We protect and or ignore so much of what is bad or harmful for or to us. And forget about the devastation we are really creating. For every action, there is a reaction! So it is important to look at the big picture, which we rarely do! We need to do far more in the eradication of the tick, or at least improve control etc. DDT had its dangers and or hazards, but helped control so many nasty's. The modern equivalents are equally as dangerous with horrible side affects that you have to question some of them. We need to protect ourselves, but also the wildlife that is needed to feed the predators, whether they be humans, birds of prey, lions and tigers or whatever. 28042017-06-25T19:12:57.09733334Emma Golding With no treatment from the NHS, how can we get better? I can't support my family because I'm to ill to work more than part time. We are broke and nearly broken... Not a nice way to be.28042017-06-25T20:31:40.3433335Kayleigh Reeves Please sign. This is a very important issue 28042017-06-26T18:08:49.6633336Gwen TookeLyme Disease needs to be recognised so those individuals can be treated.28042017-06-26T18:50:05.49333337Anne TaylorMy GPs know next to nothing about Lyme. My first diagnosis was while on holiday in Germany, from a tick bite received 3 weeks earlier from my own farm (Aberdeenshire). The second bout of Lyme was 2 years later, from another local tick bite. My GP was asking me what treatment they should give me! NHS tests for Lyme are notoriously inaccurate and need to be improved. Tick populations are exploding, and can be found in parks, gardens as well as in 'wild' places. The disease is debilitating, but with the correct treatment can be managed or put into remission. Let's make Scotland a world leader in Lyme identification and treatment! 28042017-06-27T03:01:38.15733338Jane RubensI have been aware of Lyme Disease for over 10 years. I have seen the characteristic bullseye rash on a friend who didn't have long term symptoms of the disease. However another friend didn't have the rash but has been having the symptoms of the disease for 5 years approximately. There needs to be more public awareness of the disease, how to avoid tics, what to do should you find a tic has bitten you, more GP and health professional training about treating the disease, more research in to effective treatments and more public education about how people's lives can be affected by Lyme's disease. I applaud this campaignto bring attention to the problems and issues to do with this disease whih can be so debilitating.28042017-06-27T12:26:49.64733339Polly MurrayMy husband has chronic Lyme disease and we are keen that testing and research is put at the top of the agenda. At the moment unless you have the bulls eye rash, or a positive blood test, you cannot get treatment. We know that one third of cases do not get a rash and that up to 75 percent of Elisa blood tests give a false negative. That results in a lot of people routinely being told "Its all your head" and having their lives ruined. Scotland leads the way in the UK by doing the "right thing" - please let us mark a new chapter and show the rest of world we are putting aside opinions, political or medical, and start tackling the problem of Lyme at its roots.28042017-06-28T09:18:04.63733340Lyndsey Emmett-LiddleThe natural habitat and behaviours are not being respected by this unnecessary cruel practice 27982017-06-28T10:00:06.70733341Gill MitchellI'm signing this petition for the four breeding pairs of hen harriers. We must do something before these beautiful birds are killed.27982017-06-28T11:26:55.68733342Jim BryceMore research, better GP training\r\n28042017-06-28T11:50:29.0733343ANNE GREIGAllowing the legal profession to wade into Mental Health and now dominate hearings protecting the Doctors Authorities Government and Police is the objective, as they are the ones paying their fees There is no proper protection for the mental health patients young or old Proper hearings before an independent impartial panel all documentation transcripts etc available to patients and their families to challenge the diagnosis Mental health laws in Scotland are open to corruption by unscrupulous people in every Profession it is time accountability was the main priority in mental health laws28852017-06-28T13:35:19.4333344Alison Taylor It is vital that this petition is circulated amongst teachers, school suppprt staff and parents across Scotland. We can close the gap and raise attainment for all. Please help by signing and sharing.28692017-06-28T14:58:07.82333345Annie HowarthDreadful disease. I know several people who suffer and have the most debilitating symptoms. It's dreadful the way Lyme patients are treated.28042017-06-28T15:12:40.133346Sue LloydI am familiar with research and case studies that have been carried out into the effectiveness of synthetic-phonics teaching. Every time synthetic phonics has proven to be more effective than the mixed methods. When we changed our method of teaching, in the 1980s, to what is now known as synthetic phonics our average went from 102 to 110+ on the standardised Young's Reading Test. Improvements, similar to this, have been replicated around the world. It is a great mistake to ignore the research mentioned by Anne Glennie. I provide details of the research carried out, in the section on 'Preventing Reading and Writing Problems'. I urge you to be accountable and use research to guide your teachers. 28692017-06-28T15:47:09.84733347Jean KudybaInsect borne illness is a worldwide epidemic with many emerging consequences no county can continue to look away from. Please do the right thing and help all those who suffer the debilitating effects.\r\nGod bless your efforts.28042017-06-28T15:49:05.17733348K baldwyn I was failed by the NHS in spite of a very clear tick history. They chose to believe inadequate, not fit for purpose blood tests, in spite of me & my family informing them of the issues surrounding these tests. I contracted Lyme Disease whilst camping in the Scottish Highlands twenty three yrs ago. Previously I was a extremely fit, working mum to two young children. Doctors told me that I could not get Lyme Disease in the UK, I would have had to have visited America. I had not been out of the country!\r\nThe two tier system is ridiculously outdated & misses many cases of genuine Lyme Disease. It is plagued by false negative results ensuring many hundreds go on to be misdiagnosed & mistreated, left disabled & chronically ill with no help, guidance or support system in place for them or their families.. 28042017-06-28T17:15:18.60733349Prof Tom BurkardI have always advocated the use of standardised cloze tests at 7+ as the most effective means of ensuring that decoding skills have been adequately taught. The Phonics Screening Check has not won the confidence of teachers in England, nor does it make them accountable. Parents need to know if their child is making adequate progress in learning to read, and the Phonics Screening Check--which is often administered by teachers who are opposed to it-- is not well understood by parents.28692017-06-28T17:17:59.26733350Francesca GreenMy sister has explained this to me. I whole heatedly agree with it!28692017-06-28T19:52:47.61333352Margaret Burnsliteracy is the backbone of our education system. As teachers we have to get our children hungry to learn. As they enjoy success using phonic based learning for reading their hunger and enthusiasm grows and they want to read more. It strikes me that proven theory has been trumped by politically whim 28692017-06-28T20:33:35.91733353Chris Corrigan It is really important to base decisions on real evidence which a study of this kind would provide 27982017-06-28T20:40:13.40333354Alistair McGowanIf such a project were to be funded, I think it is imperative that scientists and land-managers from other countries with similar upland areas are involved as observers and to bring examples of how things are done elsewhere.\r\n\r\nAs a part-time outdoor leader, I would like to see far more attention paid to the outdoor industry in Scotland. Such roles can be combined with others in the rural economy of Scotland and would offer potential alternative employment to gamekeepers.27982017-06-28T20:54:32.0333355Tom FittonI am signing this because driven grouse shooting is destroying native wildlife. The hen harrier is almost extinct across the UK because of this practice. 27982017-06-28T21:10:36.01733356Andy OliverLong overdue. We need to find out the facts about the impact of this highly specialised and exclusive form of land management thatactively prevents natural regeneration and persecutes protected species of raptors and other birds, and mammals.27982017-06-28T21:31:11.17733357Sally WestwoodHen harriers need our help. They have no voice. 27982017-06-28T22:42:02.8433358ffawful treatment and diagnois\r\n28042017-06-28T23:22:20.17333359Katherine Brookhouse3 in my family with Chronic Lyme lives devestated. We have spent a fortune. Research needed urgently to find a cure for what is an HIV like illness that causes immune suppression. This is a slow death for many and rapid for some. Non treatment and denial is a human rights violation 28042017-06-28T23:30:11.96333360Janine HulleyI am signing this petition as i believe that the negative impact of DGS on wildlife and the environment far outweigh the economic benefits. The destruction of vitally important habitat and the ongoing persecution of protected BOP on grouse moors, are clear indication that conservation and protection are failing. 27982017-06-29T00:37:35.27333361Elizabeth RobinsIt is disgraceful that Scotland, the home of the influential longitudinal Clackmannanshire study, has still not appreciated and implemented synthetic phonics for its beginner readers. Your current falling literacy results are disastrous, many children have been unnecessarily rendered semi-literate meanwhile, and going forward the country is now unnecessarily behind the eight ball in improving its international literacy standing. 28692017-06-29T02:10:42.87733362Mark HillWe need to do something now before it's too late!27982017-06-29T07:08:46.54333363Gena BlaxterDriven grouse shooting has nothing to do with'conservation', it is simply exploitation at the expense of our many other natural assets. It should be banned.27982017-06-29T07:36:03.7533364Geraldine A MillarThis is the only way to continually improve outcomes for Scottish children research reflect and where necessary adjust our learning and teaching 28692017-06-29T07:43:59.7233365Celeste Musgrave Scottish Schools should join the trend being seen in most English speaking countries 28692017-06-29T08:41:13.52333366Francesca GreenMy sister has explained this to me and I agree whole heartedly with it!28692017-06-29T08:41:16.87333367Alison McMurtrieThe effective teaching of reading must be the most cost-efficient way to reduce some of the social ills that plague so many societies. Why is it that there is this reluctance to properly fund and support teachers in how to successfully teach all children to read!28692017-06-29T09:28:52.5233368Geraldine CarterGrowing evidence over the past two decades has demonstrated the effectiveness of Systematic Synthetic Phonics for all children, particularly for the vulnerable and those in areas of poverty. A logical method that obviates necessity for expensive 'catch-up' and dramatically reduces the huge costs of illiteracy throughout society.28692017-06-29T12:30:55.37733369C. Wilson-GreenThis has to be done before it is too late27982017-06-29T15:06:24.4633370Andrew MuirThe Mental Health Act is very unfair and someone can easily be treated for a mental illness which they do not have. The medication can shorten someones life by 15 to 20 years. The Act has led to many injustices. No one including the Mental Welfare Commission will investigate individual cases. There are no effective safeguards. \r\n\r\nI would like a fresh investigation into several experiences. After examining these experiences it will become clear that the Act needs fundamentally changed or repealed as recommended by the United Nations, also included in the Conservative Party manifesto & Queens Speech in 2017.\r\n\r\nThe following statistics are damning \r\n50 p c of people in retrospect thought forced treatment was wrong for them\r\nPeople taking psychiatric medications die 15-20 years earlier \r\nNo professional has ever been charged with making a false statement on a document\r\n78 people die each year whilst being compulsory treated\r\n98 p c of Mental Health Tribunals agree with the psychiatrist \r\n44 p c of emergency detentions are illegal.28852017-06-29T20:05:27.30333371Anne WylieIt is extremely important that teachers are trained in and have complete knowledge and understanding of teaching literacy from early level to first and beyond. This is crucial since literacy permeates the curriculum and future learning and progression. 28692017-06-29T21:11:21.92333372Lynne BinnieThis needs urgent attention to close the poverty related attainment gap. Numbers of children identified with dyslexia is on the increase. In many cases this is as a result of appropriate learning opportunities and lack of knowledge in the teaching profession with regards to how to teach children to read and spell. 28692017-06-29T23:17:28.80333373Maggie DownieI worked for 10 years with children aged 11+ with reading difficulties. All but a tiny handful would have had no problems had they been taught systematic structured phonics from the start instead of 'mixed methods'.. The emotional cost to them of 'failure' was very high. It is deeply unfair to children to let them suffer in this way when the solution is so simple.28692017-06-30T11:34:02.88733374Debbie HepplewhiteI fully support this petition and I will also support any official enquiry in any way I can if called upon.I implore those in political and educational authority in Scotland to get on board with the wealth of evidence that, in reality, is also common sense. The English language in its written form has the most complex alphabetic code in the world. Research AND common sense shows that this code needs to be taught explicitly, systematically and rigorously for best effect for all children, regardless of their individuality. It is the SAME alphabetic code and phonics skills they require regardless of context. In addition, of course they need a rich spoken language and to be steeped in as much appropriate literature as possible. This is expressed very helpfully through the Simple View of Reading model (Gough and Tumner 1986), the model promoted in Sir Jim Rose's internationally-renowned independent review (2006) and subsequently adopted as a 'useful conceptual framework' in England. The 'multi-cueing reading strategies' where these amount to word-guessing can be enormously damaging for some children and they are not supported by research findings. Teachers should be educated fully in research-informed reading instruction - and they are not. Perhaps some are - but Anne Glennie can provide evidence aplenty that this is not the case in Scotland - having worked with thousands of teachers through teacher-training through the years. Further, her training has been cancelled by some in educational authority and then headteachers in Scotland have contacted me in consequence as they wish to pursue their professional development in reading instruction. This is a shocking state of affairs. Having been a primary teacher, special needs teachers, and primary headteacher leading to becoming a phonics and language programme author, along with being a teacher-trainer, and can provide a huge amount of experience and evidence about the differences that teachers make when well-informed. 28692017-06-30T11:49:21.9433375Eilidh McNab Some very pressing questions desperately need answered regarding the economics of grouse shooting. It is definitely time for this study.27982017-06-30T14:48:57.35733376Robert W Sweet, Jr. President, The National Right to Read Foundation, Strasburg, Virginia, USA. WE COMPLETELY SUPPORT Anne Glennie and her effort to provide the excellent training for teachers in reading instruction. Teachers and children will benefit. 28692017-06-30T21:24:22.11733377Jackie GrayI believe a fair study is needed to justify the loss of other wildlife.27982017-07-01T09:41:55.57733378J PrestonSome very important questions on tourism and flooding prevention downstream.27982017-07-02T04:15:09.75333379Dr Marion de LemosI fully support this petition, which reflects the views of the scientific community in terms of the research evidence relating to how children learn to read and the most effective way to teach them how to read.\r\n\r\nDr Molly de Lemos\r\nPsychologist and Educational Researcher\r\nAustralia28692017-07-02T14:52:43.31733380Sarah asome I am a U.K. Trained teacher who was not given the skills to teach literacy effectively. My daughter isn't being taught correctly innAustralua either. 28692017-07-02T16:08:37.8433381Joyce HawkinsI worked with Anne 2 years ago as she led a course locally. Since introducing SSP There has been marked improvement in reading ability. Recent tests have shown P2 children reading between 1 - 3 years above their age.\r\nI support Anne Glennie regarding this petition.28692017-07-02T22:09:10.18333382P JIn Pennines we have suffered floods and loss of wildlife, particularly Birds of Prey, in huge part, due to the way land and wildlife is managed (or mismanaged) for Driven Grouse Shoots. I love Scotland and particularly visit to see wildlife such as birds of prey in the wild. It's just wrong to allow this destruction of Scotland's fragile ego-system and beautiful wildlife like the mountain hare.27982017-07-03T08:24:09.33733383Sir Jim RoseWe know more about the teaching of reading than ever before as a result of robust research to whiich Scotland has contributed significantly in the past. It would be a great pity if Scotland did take full advantage of that.28692017-07-03T15:54:37.42733384Elizabeth Nonweiler, Teach to ReadI began teaching children to read by encouraging them to use a mix of methods, like those now in the Scottish Curriculum for Excellence, which is to use knowledge of sight vocabulary, phonics, context clues, punctuation and grammar to read with understanding and expression.\r\nMany years later, I was introduced to a synthetic phonics programme and began to use that to teach young children to read. The difference was astonishing. The children learned to read faster, more accurately, with better comprehension and with more enjoyment and pride in their achievements. As well as being thrilled, I was upset that I had taught in a far less effective way for so long.\r\nNow I do what I can to make sure other teachers know how to teach reading effectively sooner than I did. Some teachers in Scotland already know, but their voices are not well enough listened to. Some of the best research into how to teach reading came from Scotland.\r\nI hope the Scottish government listens now and makes sure all their teachers know how to teach reading well, as soon as possible.28692017-07-03T18:50:53.34733385Coral George Based on world wide research and pupils' results, Synthetic Phonics is the most direct route to teaching reading and writing in English.28692017-07-03T21:32:42.58733386Jamie Stephenson Having this law still on the books is an embarrassment to Scotland 28792017-07-03T23:07:23.7433387Megan CrawfordThis law serves no benefit in today's society.28792017-07-04T10:43:50.26733388John TrainorShameful that Scotland has not done something about this stain on the legislature!28792017-07-04T11:43:22.10333389Lorna WalterThe results of the Clackmannanshire project led to all English schools receiving phonics training so come on Scotland do the same!28692017-07-04T12:08:13.1933390Jennifer MorrisonThe literacy of children in Scotland needs to be address there has to be an intervention now.28692017-07-04T12:21:12.2133391Loraine bertolini I agree that literacy in all schools secondary and primary is not at a present standard schools should concentrate on the basics in all aspects of schools 28692017-07-04T14:32:50.98733392Professor Kathy RastleThis is a very important initiative for literacy standards in Scotland. There is now a substantial research base demonstrating the effectiveness of systematic synthetic phonics on the initial stages of learning to read. It is vital that all children benefit from instruction informed by the strength of this research base. 28692017-07-04T15:54:09.49333393Robert W Sweet Jr, President, The National Right to Read Foundation, USAFor several decades the National Institutes for Child Health and Human Development have been sponsoring quantitative research in how children learn to read. More than 40,000 students were tested and evaluated over a period of at least 25 years. The conclusion is that all students need direct and systematic instruction in the alphabetic principle, that systematic, synthetic phonetics instruction is essential if a student is to become a proficient reader. For the past half century multiple studies worldwide, have come to the same conclusion. The Report of the National Reading Panel in the U.S. concluded that direct, systematic, early instruction in phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary development, fluency and comprehension are all necessary components of a good reading program. Brain imaging studies also confirm the physiological necessity of proper instruction if students are to become proficient readers. These findings are consistent with those conducted in England, Scotland, New Zealand, Australia, Canada as well. Anne Glennie's training program is consistent with the findings of reading science, and the conclusions of decades of carefully conducted quantitative research studies world wide. Scotland can continue to be a leader in reducing illiteracy by supporting Anne Glennie's training program for teachers. You are fortunate to have her expertise and dedication to the children of Scotland!28692017-07-04T16:48:37.53733394Donnchadh MacGuaireTha an obair seo air leth feumail and da chuid airson Foghlam tro mheadhain na Gaidhlig ri foghlam annam Beurla no canan sam bith eiloe.28692017-07-04T20:16:23.85333395Catherine QuinnI support this.28692017-07-04T20:30:18.2333396Geraldine CarterIn England, Australia, US, Gov Committees have concluded that Synthetic Phonics is the most successful way to teach children to read. House of Commons Select Committee 2009 also confirmed this finding. Thousands of papers,articles from esteemed academics and leading supporters of ResearchED and RRF have endorsed the robust evidence-based SSP research. The minority of academics promoting Analytical Phonics, or a mixture, have contributed to steep decline in Scottish literacy. Decoding, a foundational skill of reading, has been downgraded with dire consequences particularly for children from areas of poverty. An emphasis on 'real reading' before basic skills are embedded has also damaged the progress of struggling readers.28692017-07-05T14:19:19.06333397Rosemary Dolan Pakistan has justified its treatment og atheist blogger on the basis of blasphemy laws in western countries. 28792017-07-06T15:41:22.33733398Valma AdamsOur young people face a dark future in an already crumbling education system. Allow teachers to teach, but train them wisely and allow them to the methodologies that will benefit society. A change should be beneficial for those who give as well as those who receive. 28692017-07-06T16:07:05.04333399Christopher JollyScotland has been a world leader in the past in education, and specifically in synthetic phonics through the Clackmananshire study. It is very sad this is no longer so, and it undermines the ability of the next generation in the country.28692017-07-06T23:29:36.58333400Juli HarrisHuge swathes of land set aside for this Victorian pastime of the wealthy and connected. Surely there are better ways to protect land our animals and environment?27982017-07-06T23:32:50.2133401Jane KiddLet's re-green the Highlands27982017-07-07T00:01:46.8733402Margaret KJustification for loss of natural habitat and other wildlife27982017-07-07T09:26:30.6833403Angela JordanI have used a synthetic phonics system to teach struggling readers one to one for one hour per week and have raised their reading age by up to 4 years after 35 sessions.28692017-07-07T14:45:16.72733404Alistair Donald Charles HarleyBlasphemy laws, even if rarely used retain the potential. They are reactionary and regressive and an affront to freedom of speech and conscience and thereby to democracy itself. Scotland, the home of the Enlightenment, should set the lead in enlightened and progressive legislation and end the capacity to prosecute for blasphemy.28792017-07-07T17:24:02.5333405margaret walkerGoshawk viewing platforms could add, to the list of birds of prey. 27982017-07-07T22:18:34.25733406Linda MooreIt's time that the many who love the countryside are listened to above the few who want to destroy it.27982017-07-07T23:44:16.7733407Elaine van den AkkerThis is important stuff.28692017-07-08T00:46:06.3133408Lynn WallaceI have been using systematic explict phonics teaching successfully with previously illiterate children with 100% success. It is the best antidote to poor self esteem I have seen in 20 years of teaching28692017-07-08T04:10:38.57333409Chiara Essential research-based knowledge is being lost in education and far too many teachers leaving university now no longer possess essential understandings of children's learning, instead requiring to follow pre-designed programmes that may not always be appropriate for the children they teach or enable children to learn the concepts being taught with understanding. This is the case across teaching, in both numeracy and literacy. We were once seen as a world-leading country for education, this is now no longer the case. We need to return to knowledge based teaching by ensuring that students leave university with ample knowledge and understanding of children's thinking and learning trajectories and how they can support this as teachers. Better systems could also be put in place to ensure that this learning continues in schools such as mandatory additional time out of class for teachers to participate in research -based CPD opportunities and self-study to support the development of research-based practice.28692017-07-08T15:19:53.5233410Sarah Bradford67% of wildlife on Earth has disappeared since the 1970's - a study into this unnecessary activity is more than essential.27982017-07-08T16:27:13.1433411Iain BuikToo many Government subsidies are being leeched out to these minority buisnesses, who have their own means of financing, greater scrutiny of public money must be done so that a better way of funding agricultural interests and for the benefit of wildlife and protection of habitats from destruction, or for "sporting" reasons.\r\nThe driven grouse moor owners have shown themselves as barbaric, and unwilling to admit their shortcomings, Persecution of Raptor Species is no longer tolerable, the outdated methods have been exposed as a sham and no justification for it.\r\nI call for a reveiw and overhaul of this alleged Industry 27982017-07-08T19:23:29.9633412Louise Raine HantmanPlease help these endangered birds!27982017-07-09T09:52:34.3133413Tahira SheikhI am a systematic synthetic phonics trainer living in Pakistan. This approach of teaching has helped so many teachers to teach correctly and so many children have benefited with good reading & writing skills here. I am surprised to hear of a decline of literacy standards in Scotland's schools, considering that the Clackmannanshire study was done there. I thought they knew better!28692017-07-09T15:51:12.54733414Eileen MeaseyThe Clackmannanshire study inspired me to organise SP teacher training in a small island in the Caribbean. Since the study showed how well SP works, why would you not do it?28692017-07-09T20:17:10.85333415Ann EllisI strongly believe that all wildlife should be allowed to thrive not be killed at the expense of a single pursuit 27982017-07-09T22:07:55.97733416Simon NeachellLet's end this cruel industry and turn the spaces into national parks.27982017-07-10T15:09:28.17733417Duncan Young Yeah i agree27982017-07-10T22:25:31.42333418Tom MacDonaldDriven grouse shooting is not an economic or cultural asset, but an unhealthy obsession that suppresses our natural heritage, wildlife and also rural economies.27982017-07-11T08:02:14.65733419Tim PuntisVery important that these harmful laws removed.28792017-07-11T10:51:38.86733420Karen WalkerI live in a beautiful part of Perthshire and my neighbours are the beautiful grouse that come in to the garden every day. All types of shooting are wrong in every way. This should be stopped immediately. The elite seem to think they have the monopoly within our country and can do what they want. There are always consequences to their actions. These so called traditions should stay in the past as they play no part of a modern society. 27982017-07-11T20:14:54.16333421Iain CampbellOnly theocracies require blasphemy laws. 28792017-07-11T22:10:00.6333422Ian AnglesWhich god were you meaning?28792017-07-12T00:29:54.34333423Alexandra Campbell The value of driven grouse shooting appears to be grossly overstated. No breakdown of the figures has been given, to my knowledge. The number of people directly employed in this sector cannot be significant since it is made up of gamekeepers as permanent full time staff, and then a number of seasonal part-time staff working as beaters. \r\nThe estates might also employ staff as housekeepers, cooks, cleaners etc for any shooters staying on the property in the estate but again this is seasonal work. \r\nAdditional maintenance work on the estate is likely to be contract work. \r\nIt is difficult to see how these relatively small FTE jobs and payment from guests or of shooting rights amounts to the millions of pounds quoted by landowners as income from grouse shooting. 27982017-07-12T19:31:53.8233424CpCome on Scotland. You take the rights, privileges and monies from the EU, so about time you respected human rights, and that include the freedom of speech. Scrap the blasphemy laws and get Scotland into the human rights revaluation 28792017-07-14T11:02:07.59733425Peter TeesdaleThis issue has to be addressed as I am shocked by how far standards of literacy have fallen. I travel extensively and see how other nationalities children are so far ahead particularly in languages, the sciences and maths. The government have got to invest in the necessary skills so that teachers can teach effectively with a passion and our children are not disadvantaged in what is now a very connected world. 28692017-07-17T19:55:14.47733427Helen McDadeI applaud Bill Welsh's relentless commitment to trying to get the issue of increased autism and auto-immune problems in Scotland into the public eye. we must keep raising the issue and a truly independent commission is long overdue.29002017-07-18T16:23:55.54333428Pat LeeDemocracy is not served by allowing failed candidates to be guaranteed a seat through the the List system. Time to close this undemocratic loophole. 26532017-07-18T17:19:42.6333429Alan Morrison The Additional Member System is a fudge and needs to be replaced. I think we should go to STV with Robson Rotation to prevent alphabetical disadvantage. Splitting the current regions into 4 with 4 MSPs per new constituency would retain the local link would give a similar number of MSPs as we have at the moment, but happy to have that looked at by the Boundary Commission26532017-07-18T20:22:29.65333431Michael BibleSave the raptors, and the grouse. 27982017-07-18T21:28:30.21333433Paddy HanrahanOnce again our wildlife are being exterminated for the money, and that's the Grouse also let's live in the 21st century not the 19th and abolish all these foul evil blood sports 27982017-07-18T22:59:02.8533434Jonathan TheobaldMy regular visits to the Highlands are made much less enjoyable by the systematic destruction - much of it illegal - of mountain hares, hen harriers, eagles, and anything else that might threaten the size of a grouse bag.\r\n\r\nI accept that the countryside needs to be economically viable. But with wildlife killed on such a scale, a financial study would help all concerned to understand what is at stake. 27982017-07-18T23:03:15.44333435Bob MorrisIt is essential that claims made by the grouse shooting industry are fully assessed since claims often appear to be exaggerated with little or no empirical evidence.27982017-07-19T14:13:36.07733436Richard AlexanderOur politicians must be elected on merit only and the public must have the ability to reject them when they fail us. No more sneaking in via the back door and gatecrashing the parly. 26532017-07-19T15:06:35.0533437Ian FouldsI do not want party apparatchiks in my Parliament as they do not benefit the people of Scotland. They only benefit themselves and, generally, the unionist parties26532017-07-19T15:07:47.5233438Liz Whiteprime example is the unelectable Murdo Fraser the man no one wants yet he is there bold as brass lording it over the people.\r\n\r\nThings need a right good shake up.26532017-07-19T15:09:31.03733439Robert Grahamlong overdue26532017-07-19T15:15:25.78333440Lesley McGilvaryThis system saw my local community deprived of an excellent hard working msp and needs this change it is undemocratic and ignores the votes of constituents this hold those in elected office to account for their performance.26532017-07-19T15:31:45.7933441Pam McMahonThe Scottish Parliament electoral system was set up by the Labour party of the time in order to ensure a unionist majority. It does not reflect the voting intentions of the Scottish electorate, and so is basically (and intentionally) flawed. \r\nCertainly.candidates should not be able to stand for both, and those who do stand for list seats should not be paper candidates, costing taxpayers' money for by-elections when they are accidentally elected and refuse to take their seats. Is the Electoral Commision the weak and wobbly rubber stamp it appears to be? Of course it is, and I support this petition to tighten up the electoral process in Holyrood.26532017-07-19T16:02:31.02733442Carol JardineThe regional list system is abused on a regular basis. If the electorate don't vote for you then you shouldn't be given a seat in Parliament. Or if you do gain a seat, it should be rewarded with a much lower pay scale.26532017-07-19T16:08:01.49733443Robert TraquairThis is an extremely unfair voting system whereby the electorate are literally ignored when they have decided that the person put forward for election has NOT performed or acted in their best interests , instead we have many FAILED MSP's FORCED on the electorate due to party politics and in total CONTEMPT of the electorate and their democratic choices . This is an abomination perpetrated on the Scottish electorate with sub standard rejects only interested in securing continued access to a generous salary26532017-07-19T16:15:45.47333444William HendersonAny review of the current system of election to the Scottish Parliament could usefully include an examination of the prominence given to the political party itself. Democracy, ideally, does not include formal parties which are fundamentally a continuation of an old feudal structure of society.26532017-07-19T16:25:40.88333445William HendersonAn affront to freedom of expression. Let's be rid of this pre-medieval oppresive legislation.28792017-07-19T16:28:52.6833446William L E HendersonRemove this symbol of pre-medieval oppression - an affront to the right of free expression.28792017-07-19T16:32:04.02333447liz GrayRestrict the list too two terms only.\r\n10 year's is more than enough time to show the electorate what kind of contribution can be made and be elected \r\n\r\n26532017-07-19T16:58:06.50333448Leslie RobertsAny voting system must be where the party with the majority of votes have the majority of seats.26532017-07-19T17:59:50.7733449David BruceWe are by now aware why the PR system was chosen for the Scottish Parliament. I believe the candian system would give a better snapshot of how the electorate are spread across party votes.26532017-07-19T19:28:39.7733450Dougie LockhartEven reformed as suggested, the list system allows political parties, not ordinary people, to select MSPs. \r\n\r\nThat is disgraceful and unacceptable - d'Hondt in *any* form must go.\r\n\r\nI know STV has problems (all systems do) but if we were to use the same system for local and national elections then voters have a chance of learning how to use it. And I could vote for the SNP candidate of my preference instead of holding my nose, hoping for the best against all evidence, and just voting SNP.26532017-07-19T21:21:37.96733451Sheryl HepworthUnless the system is altered to a fairer type, SMP's should only be allowed to stand twice on the list and no more! If they aren't good enough to be elected by the voters then they shouldn't be able to hold a position for life as is the way now.The list system should be replaced so that the Unionist parties are not able to stand for the list every election and thus contaminate our parliament and receive an unearned income as they do not represent their constituents or Scotland.26532017-07-19T22:13:08.44733452Agnes AlexanderIf you don't do enough to convince or please the electorate then there should be no alternative route for you to grab a nice little earner. This corrupt and undemocratic system must be scrapped.26532017-07-19T22:23:26.6533453Tracy Dunnachie Unfair system 26532017-07-19T23:49:19.33733454Hugh GrayI have signed the petition as I am in agreement with the general principle. However, I can see a case for constituency candidates being nominated on the list, provided they are not the sitting candidate or have previously been the sitting candidate. This could help to ensure that possible new talent would not be blocked from progress in their career. I would also like to see a stipulation that list MSP's are restricted to serve for one parliamentary session only and can only stand as a constituency candidate thereafter. 26532017-07-20T09:35:53.3433455John CoatsIn short this system is just not democratic or representative.26532017-07-20T09:58:49.3933456AnnaGood idea26532017-07-20T11:12:37.10333457Alan BeveridgeHere's hoping but turkeys don't vote for xmas26532017-07-20T11:42:04.74733458Irene GrayThis STV electoral system is proving to be undemocratic and needs to be changed.26532017-07-20T11:48:57.4533459Sydney PatersonCandidates should have a choice whether to stand on the list or FPT but not both. Or change voting system to full proportional representation.26532017-07-20T11:52:01.53333460TerryVoters need clarity, this is precisely why voters feel disenfranchised with a system that allows this and many other manipulations to happen26532017-07-20T13:13:47.3233461Alexander MaxwellI agree that constituency candidates should not appear as a list candidate. I also think that any list seat awarded should be in the area where the votes were cast.\r\nWe also need to have a look at the security during an election. The last few elections and referendums have shown areas open to misuse. We also need to stiffen the punishments for those persons found guilty of electrol fraud.26532017-07-20T13:18:21.41733462Dave CormackAbout time this abuse by professional politicians was stopped. 26532017-07-20T14:00:30.07733463JAMES ROBERT C SMITHUNELECTED! BUT GETTING THE BENEFITS,SUCH HY SALARY,PENSIONS AND ALL WITH TAX PAYERS MONEY.26532017-07-20T14:04:54.48333464Christine SmithHope this works so we can undo this mess that Labour made when they changed the voting system to keep the SNP out26532017-07-20T14:27:07.6633465Eddie LeeA good start but I would like to see a complete review of all our many voting systems. The systems in operation need to be better publicised and explained to the general public. 26532017-07-20T14:58:48.7933466George ClarkIt is simple democracy.26532017-07-20T15:04:55.14733468Kate MalcolmsonWe live in enlightened and ever changing political times.\r\nIf the list system was ever suitable in the past, it most certainly needs reviewing now.\r\nWe, the voters want to be able to put candidates of our choice... in position democratically.We most certainly do not want candidates who have been rejected at the ballot box.\r\n26532017-07-20T15:37:33.21733469Brian TraynorI would prefer to see Scotland as an option in the country drop down list.26532017-07-20T15:40:38.52733470David WhyteThe use of the List to continually ensure candidates rejected at the ballot box become MSPs is an abomination of democracy and a perversion of the will of the electorate. A limit to the amount of times an individual is elevated by the List must be set. Serial rejects at the ballot box must not have undeserved influence over constituency elected MSPs. 26532017-07-20T16:32:32.3533471Eileen Charity I'd like to see them reformed so that the people actually get what they vote for. I also feel there should be more information available on how the systems work, it's scary how many people are unaware. It should also be included in our education systems currently being reformed makes it a great time to do so.26532017-07-20T17:16:15.65733472Brian HendersonIf you stand as a msp,your name should be removed from the list. The list should be for up and coming new candidates.26532017-07-20T17:44:18.6133474Annmarie PalmerCandidates should only be allowed to have their name included on one list. No duplication.26532017-07-20T18:25:31.3733475Gordon GallacherThe existing system is fairly close to proportional, but can be improved (STV would be better I think). But it's a scandal that candidates who have been rejected on the constituency should be able to get in on the list. They should have to choose.26532017-07-20T19:32:00.92733476david barclaya person should either win or lose a seat not get in via a technicality.\r\n26532017-07-20T20:32:00.38733477Janette Willet . I think the list should be a way of introducing new MPs into the government . Not a way to get rejected MPs in through the back door .26532017-07-20T21:13:34.1933478Christine SchofieldSystem has to be re-vamped not fit for purpose. Too many list MSPs get seats year after year who have not been voted for. Needs an overhaul.26532017-07-20T21:21:20.70733479Rosemary SmithWhy do most of the politicians now have university degrees but no passion for change? 26532017-07-21T08:06:06.21733480Tony ConnorI feel the listings should only allow you one chance to enter the SP then thereafter you strand only through the constituency system.Possibly only use the listings for a first attempt to enter parliament 26532017-07-21T09:43:52.3833481ronnie andersona affront to democracy when any political party can choose who they want to represent the people.26532017-07-21T10:29:03.77733482Andy RobertsonIf a candidate has been rejected by the voters, then no way should they be allowed into the Scottish Parliament by the back door. If the public don't want them then they should not be there.26532017-07-21T10:51:00.5333483Raymond Reid The list system is so wrong,it was devised by has been politicians that were afraid of losing their seats,the only people that should be elected to government are the people that are voted for democratically by the people not .26532017-07-21T12:59:30.87733484Francis NapperIt cannot be good for society to be represented by politicians who fail to be directly elected time after time. Who do they represent ?26532017-07-21T22:58:10.59333486Joan CampbellThis petition is very important to make people aware of what is happening to our precious vaccine injured children. They should and will not be forgotten29002017-07-21T23:52:39.4733487Louise An independent safety commission is needed now more than ever, with over 20 vaccine doses scheduled by the time a baby is just 4 months old!!! AND NOT ONE SAFETY STUDY ON THE SCHEDULE!!! It is completely unacceptable.29002017-07-22T01:15:42.70733488Valerie AchillasSTOP THE MANDATES. THE INSANITY OF VACCINES FROM BIRTH TO DEATH. LIFE TIME CUSTOMERS OF THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY. FATALITIES, INJURIES, LIFE-ALTERING DNA, ANIMAL SUBSTANCES INJECTED, THIMEROSOL, FORMALDYHYDE, ON AND ON. #NOMANDATES29002017-07-22T03:48:47.58733489Doreen Wonderful, keep asking, keep petitioning until our leaders hear us.29002017-07-22T07:24:20.47733490Jennifer AllanNumbers of children with autism, bowel disorders and ADHD have hugely increased in recent years. This correlates with the policy of administering multiple vaccines in one 'shot' and also adding more and more vaccines to the child schedule. 29002017-07-22T08:57:34.9433491Marina Clement Thank you Bill Welsh for helping to get this issue addressed. Our health and freedoms are constantly under attack by those willing to sacrifice us under the guise of public health. The people that have taken time to do their own research into this issue are leading the way to protecting us from the lies and corruption that are entrenched in the establishments that are creating pharma customers from cradle to grave. 29002017-07-22T09:32:02.33733492MoniekPlease do Your research, you can't not longer denie that there are so much children with troubels after vaccinations29002017-07-22T10:01:50.1633493Tracey Hadley My daughter is vaccine damaged 29002017-07-22T10:02:40.62333494Legend Manvaccine is big corruption29002017-07-22T10:47:24.1633495Magda TaylorA truly independent vaccine safety commission is very long overdue. Meanwhile more and more cases of long-term conditions are increasing in our child population. And yet nothing is being addressed or investigated...instead more vaccines are being introduced! This will not result in a good outcome for a healthy population at all. Please take action on this serious matter.29002017-07-22T10:56:39.78733496Arjen PasmaVaccination, an assault to mankind.29002017-07-22T11:24:53.38333497Vanessa SchaffelerThis is long overdue...chronic health issues, ASD and autism is increasing day by day. We know that vaccine components are neurotoxic (eg aluminium) and that they have an adverse effect on the brain and, from research already done, we know that aluminium from all sources is deposited in the body, including the brain. Increasing a child's vaccine schedule year on year without consideration of the safety aspects is sheer folly. Any existing safety research has been done either by the manufacturers themselves, or by government bodies with a huge vested interest, both financial and to protect the 'vaccine program'. We need independent researchers to look at this issue objectively.29002017-07-22T12:26:33.01733498Jackie FletcherI support an in-depth investigation into the safety of all vaccines. Too many toxic substances.29002017-07-22T12:33:58.92333499Mel Kelly Rotarix not required - all aluminiums and pig DNA not required - are any vaccines safe - I don't think they are any more - especially with the Rotarix vaccine being approved that babies don't even need - children getting strange polio like illness only after the Scottish Government say line up our children for flu shots - 29002017-07-22T13:31:00.9333500Grace fosterIt is NOT acceptable to be injecting babies and children with thimersol or aluminium directly into their blood streams they are NEUROTOXINS! 29002017-07-22T14:33:03.5933501Teresa HobdayA good first move29002017-07-22T14:40:12.3433502David mcgrathVaccines can do damage as well as good29002017-07-22T16:03:43.3533503Jason The ONLY reason NOT to establish a safety commission is if you KNOW that vaccines kill and you want to hide that fact.\r\n\r\nAnyone else would want to know exactly what are the dangers of these chemicals and their role in the mass ill health of the country.29002017-07-22T16:15:06.62333504Laura QueenAll parents should be willingly given access to medical inserts of vaccines to inform them of all potential side effects and ingredients that make an individual vaccine up. This would ensure that they are given the opportunity, their rights of freedom to make an informed choice of what is best for their child instead of governments, pharmaceutical companies and medics dictating to parents that they must vaccinate their children. It is a parents right to choose wether to vaccinate or not...no one else. I fully support a truly independent commission into this swept under the carpet issue.29002017-07-22T16:49:13.76333505Louise TollinThank you Bill Welsh for supporting all Autism families and for raising the awareness in parliament.29002017-07-22T16:59:55.92733506Karin VrijdagSolidary with this initiative!29002017-07-22T17:13:23.58333507Andrew YoungerMore and more people are understanding the NHS, is a pro big pharmaceutical cash cow fronted by sales people guised as medical professionals. 29002017-07-22T22:59:49.69733508HanneIt is time for the truth to be told and recocnized. The children of the World are suffering due to vaccine injuries, and it is time to stop and make the guilty be held accountable. 29002017-07-23T06:20:37.8733509Jennifer Horne-RobertsThe Great War against unsafe vaccines continues,29002017-07-23T08:40:51.05333510Rosalind cookThe is esentail to humanity 29002017-07-23T08:55:26.45333511John DuncanWe need an independent commission on vaccine safety that is transparent and that does not confer under the table.29002017-07-23T15:18:15.75733512anne closeAs a retired nurse I am extremely concerned that Bill Welsh should succeed in his petition. 29002017-07-23T15:19:13.53733513anne closeAs a retired nurse I am extremely concerned about this issue.29002017-07-24T11:27:49.66733514Neil SpenceThe MMR study that 'proves' this vaccine is not linked to autism is unreliable. Many parents have evidence that their child was developing perfectly normally until they received this triple vaccine and can show videos demonstrating an immense change in the personality of the child, sometimes within hours of the vaccine, often in the following few days. I work as a homeopath and treat many people for vaccine-induced damage to their health.29002017-07-24T12:09:53.03333515Christopher Craig Hunt LawWe need to make the democratic system of voting more fairer and equal.26532017-07-24T12:33:58.1333516Gregor Spalding Its not right for candidates to effectively loose and get in the back door. That's not democratic. 26532017-07-24T17:38:55.23333517Anna GrayMeasles is a benign childhood disease. Studies show proper nutrition stop virus from replicating especially vitamin A and C. Autism is permanent brain damage caused by vaccines. Look for autism in unvaccinated populations which are harder and harder to find and this no coincidence.29002017-07-25T06:06:13.45333518Donald ScottIrrespective of your own personal view I'd like to think everyone would agree to ensuring parental choice on vaccination takes precedent over the government of the day. Lobby groups with surplus cash can be quite persuasive?29002017-07-25T15:56:58.01333519Sylvia JardineThe list as is now should not have anyone on it that stands to be voted as MSP. The regional list candidates should be each voted in by the public.26532017-07-25T16:23:19.11733520david murdochneed to make our democracy representative of the people not a party. \r\n26532017-07-25T16:49:59.52733521Sylvia ForrestCruel traps have no place in a modern Scotland27672017-07-25T16:50:59.19733522LisaThese traps are completely horrific! There is no justification for them being used on any animal. 27672017-07-25T17:00:50.9833524Frances ButtonThese traps are barbaric, should not be tolerated in the 21st century. Keep wildlife safe, say no to killing.27672017-07-25T17:08:45.07733525Andrew PlattJust listen 27672017-07-25T17:26:28.87333526Margaret Ann EllisWhy would anybody wish to inflict this cruelty on any living, sentient being. Take a moment to imagine the fear and the agony. Please stop this inhumanity.27672017-07-25T17:36:51.6933528Paul AllenI hope they put a stop to these Traps especially if they are used for Birds of Prey.27672017-07-25T17:42:36.76733529Hilary These traps are inhumane & we have no right to inflict such a slow, painful & unselective death on any animals 27672017-07-25T17:51:37.56733530GrahamI've seen these products causing similar problems in the US, pictures of several small birds attracted to the insects and stuck to the glue traps. Please ban the unnecessary sale of these. 27672017-07-25T17:54:42.4133531Karen AllanI wasn't aware of these - absolutely disgusting!27672017-07-25T17:55:46.20733532Catherine Bentley Heartless cruelty27672017-07-25T18:00:08.47333533Kathryn Daniels We must do everything we can to stop this being sold27672017-07-25T18:02:48.8833534K WrightBan these horrendous things!!!27672017-07-25T18:04:24.00333535Michael StewartStop the sale of these terrible things27672017-07-25T18:07:00.83333536Jeannette EllwoodA disgusting and cruel practice no civilised country should use27672017-07-25T18:10:53.3533537Deirdre stewartDisgusting cruel and unneccesary27672017-07-25T18:11:33.98333538PaulineThey should be banned - horrific. 27672017-07-25T18:12:15.19333539Pauline PeckhamThese traps are inhumane and trap creatures like birds ondiscriminately 27672017-07-25T18:14:20.54733540Elena RolinsonThis is inhumane and inappropriate in the 21st century27672017-07-25T18:14:51.96733542Derek McCall These traps are far too indiscriminate. They trap species they are not put out for. Therefore they trap creatures that cannot possibly escape from them. Creatures innocently flying into them. 27672017-07-25T18:16:05.12333543Keith RyanInhuman, cruel things.27672017-07-25T18:18:50.91333544Linda Holland These things are a real hazard to birds, bats and other small wildlife let alone horrendous for the insects they catch...just because the USA use them doesn't mean we here in the UK would tolerate such a barbaric method27672017-07-25T18:19:09.70333545Chris CornishEvil27672017-07-25T18:21:56.72733546Roy williamsThis reminds me of the cruelty that happens on the Mediterranean islands, why would anyone use these glue traps.27672017-07-25T18:22:36.42333547Mike ClearyThese glue boards must be banned.27672017-07-25T18:29:52.47733549Joy SnelgroveNo creature should suffer in any way.27672017-07-25T18:30:27.19733550Jan CooperAnimal suffering for man's pleasure is a true abomination. 27672017-07-25T18:38:16.09733551Carole Godfrey To cause any animal such a slow, terrifying death is inhumane and should never be allowed. 27672017-07-25T18:46:51.46333552FrancesThese are horrendous and so cruel. They must be banned27672017-07-25T18:47:35.5233553john harrisonglue boards are indiscriminate and barbaric27672017-07-25T18:50:20.79333554Nick PopeI can't believe this practice occurs in modern day Britain. It has to be banned.27672017-07-25T18:51:43.40333555ElenaThis is a random and barbaric device. No place in the 21st century27672017-07-25T18:52:11.8833556Iris dawsMust put a ban on these glue boards. First I've ever seen or heard off them. How cruel. It's just awful. 27672017-07-25T18:52:12.1333557Iris dawsMust put a ban on these glue boards. First I've ever seen or heard off them. How cruel. It's just awful. 27672017-07-25T18:53:54.33333558Samantha Hudson This is absolutely appalling. Please, please ban these awful things. I'm horrified that this is allowed to happen in the uk. It's barbaric. 27672017-07-25T18:55:15.69333559Carol soarsDisgusting things 27672017-07-25T18:55:46.5633560Susan hunterThese traps are going back to the stone age. They are killing birds and animals they are not meant to target. If something has to be killed do it swiftly and humanely27672017-07-25T18:56:07.80333561Sandra Williams This is barbaric and must be stopped. 27672017-07-25T18:56:23.2733562Fiona CampbellDisgusting. Ban them. 27672017-07-25T18:58:00.24733563Judy BrookerThese traps are an abomination. Ban them immediately!27672017-07-25T19:00:28.633564David WhannelIf I see anyone using these I'll tie them to a railway line 27672017-07-25T19:05:52.30333565KeithThese things are inhumane and should be banned.27672017-07-25T19:07:10.5933566Lesley ElliottA terrible inhumane practice . Catching bats is illegal. Who monitors this? 27672017-07-25T19:07:13.17733567Wendy ClarkVery cruel. This needs to be banned now.27672017-07-25T19:08:15.96733568MelPlease ban these vile products27672017-07-25T19:08:41.47733569Natalie HomerDisgusting things-make them illegal-ban them-27672017-07-25T19:11:31.8533570antonia savvidesplease stop these inhumane products 27672017-07-25T19:13:08.65333571Irona WestonThis is very cruel and shouldn't be allowed.27672017-07-25T19:14:45.69333572Paul DayWho in the right mind had the stupid, crass idea of coming up with these horrendous, indiscriminate glue traps ? What on earth where you thinking ? 27672017-07-25T19:17:24.32733573Susan CoxBarbaric27672017-07-25T19:17:26.18733574Robert PenningBarbaric 27672017-07-25T19:18:30.24333575Dee GovanBats are protected species - this must be illegal!27672017-07-25T19:19:43.84333576June LeckPlease ban these glue strips they are deadly27672017-07-25T19:20:32.87333577JulesWhy would anybody use something so badly thought out and kill innocent animals! Who are the idiots manufacturing them!27672017-07-25T19:20:51.47733578carol fosterso sad27672017-07-25T19:21:07.0433579Jane Disgusting and inhumane 27672017-07-25T19:26:30.3333580Richard whitehouseGlue traps shoul be illigal to all but licensed pest control companies. Horrendously cruel27672017-07-25T19:36:40.78333581Dean PowellThis cruelty to our wildlife must not be allowed. Making profit off the back of killing wildlife is unacceptable. Ban these traps and boards.27672017-07-25T19:38:18.59733582Alison ReidThese are inhuman to animals and must be banned27672017-07-25T19:43:52.27733583Alice BaynesThere is absolutely no need for this product. For it to be causing such unnecessary suffering to animals accidentally caught by it is shocking. 27672017-07-25T19:48:12.41733584Carol Elrick This is barbaric 27672017-07-25T19:49:58.74733585Peter VinceI'm astonished that such barbaric devices are in use in a modern society :-(27672017-07-25T19:52:13.4433586The great unnamed Barbaric Scotland! We should stick the company that makes these on one!27672017-07-25T19:55:59.0533587Oliver ClanfordIt's 2017 not 1890. 27672017-07-25T19:57:16.18733588Dave PeckThese traps are so cruel and kill indiscriminately. They need to be banned.27672017-07-25T20:01:21.21733589sharronAbsolutely horrendous things27672017-07-25T20:03:07.32733590D Maddock-BrownThis practice is immoral and causes so much unnecessary suffering.27672017-07-25T20:03:07.76333591D Maddock-BrownThis practice is immoral and causes so much unnecessary suffering.27672017-07-25T20:16:46.67333592S SpikingsSurely indiscriminate traps like this should be illegal. C'mon, stop selling these truly awful thigs.27672017-07-25T20:16:48.73333593Sandra coylesBarbaric 27672017-07-25T20:18:12.98333594Suze PopeThis is inhumane and should have been banned years ago. We do not have enough wildlife for these horrors to wipe out more sending them to a slow and painful death - disgrace to anyone buying them!!!!\r\n 27672017-07-25T20:19:30.7533595Aileen This is the most disturbing and disgusting type of trap I have ever seen I don't know how they feel this is the best way to get rid of pests what a horrible horrible way to do it why not just set a trap that animals can get into but not out but can be set free agin somewhere safe this makes me angry to think the suffering this is causing animal that become trapped 27672017-07-25T20:25:54.0833596pamela frostCruel27672017-07-25T20:28:06.59733597Jean ThatcherThese things must be banned immediately27672017-07-25T20:29:50.70733598Helen HarveyA very cruel way to catch any animal27672017-07-25T20:30:31.25333599Anne DaviesShocking traps have no place in 21st Century Scotland27672017-07-25T20:32:28.67333600Sally Hendry I think these mats should be banned there is no need to be cruel to any animal 27672017-07-25T20:34:56.45733601Philip AlvesIt seems absurd that these traps are perfect legal to buy especially as they could do so much harm if they fall into the wrong hands.27672017-07-25T20:35:42.62733602Sharon Finnerty Ban these evil glue traps27672017-07-25T20:36:50.47333603margaret moranYou must stop this utter horror, and FAST.27672017-07-25T20:36:58.72333604lorrainecrawleyplease stop this barbaric practise 27672017-07-25T20:37:22.34733605David AndersonFind it hard to believe that traps of this nature have any place or justification in a civilised society.27672017-07-25T20:40:46.73733606Jackke GillespieThis product needs to be banned as must contravene Euopean Law for proected species and the Wildlife and Countryside Act27672017-07-25T20:42:37.6933607Jean Gidman So cruel, our wildlife needs to be protected. 27672017-07-25T20:43:23.59733608AnneThis is barbaric and has no place in our progressive country27672017-07-25T20:43:53.92733609Helen chadwick I cannot believe that in an age of such scientific advancement we came up with such a Stone Age barbaric pest control. Disgraceful 27672017-07-25T20:49:06.25333610Stuart BrownIndiscriminate in their killing. They need to be banned. 27672017-07-25T20:50:07.92733611Suzanne StormBan these barbaric stickers!!!27672017-07-25T20:52:00.64733612Karen Watt These are horrible things. How cruel 27672017-07-25T20:54:17.06733613Susan Wressell What a barbaric slow torturous way to die, they are more humane ways to catch unwanted vermin without killers by them or other animals unnecessarily 27672017-07-25T21:06:23.44333614Fiona McAllisterAbsolutely barbaric and disgusting. You have to question what kind of mind would even think this is a good idea, let alone one that is incapable of thinking it through to the pitfalls of sheer cruelty that have been evidenced to this petition's committee.27672017-07-25T21:07:48.3533615Christine bundockI have seen these horrid traps in action and they are not Humain.27672017-07-25T21:10:12.4333616Natalie BoormanI am shocked that such cruel devices are on sale! 27672017-07-25T21:10:27.52333617Yvonne RijsdijkWhich stupid person invented these horrible things. He should be glued on it and let him hang for a few days!27672017-07-25T21:12:08.19733618Jennifer HogganMost of us are humane, some pitiful examples are inhumane. Please, let us move toward what is morally correct. 27672017-07-25T21:15:58.10333619Vince GoodridgeThese traps are a menace to wildlife. They must be banned from sale and use quickly. Animals are dying 27672017-07-25T21:19:02.74333620Fiona GuestTrapping wild birds and bats is already illegal and so these, inhumane, indiscriminate traps, which have appalling bycatch possibilities should logically be banned27672017-07-25T21:19:15.41733621Fran SevernDisgusting system, should be banned evrywhere!27672017-07-25T21:20:23.71333622Grace LyonDisgraceful abuse and totally untargeted.27672017-07-25T21:26:59.7633624George BrownThe use of glue traps is a disgraceful way to treat animals and those that do should be ashamed.27672017-07-25T21:29:32.1533625Leslie SpurlingLet us take the lead in this matter within the UK.27672017-07-25T21:30:31.2333626Sarah price These are cruel and inhuman, and harm the unintended wildlife. Ban these! 27672017-07-25T21:33:27.233627Margaret toolePlease ban these cruel traps27672017-07-25T21:37:46.49733628Victoria ChalkeThis is an inhumane and dangerous way to trap animals & risks also trapping people's pets27672017-07-25T21:41:46.8433629OlgaPlease end the sales of these barbaric glue traps. Doing so equals no more needless animal suffering.27672017-07-25T21:45:45.57733630Kate MacLeandon't perpetuate this evil practise27672017-07-25T21:49:48.3133632Lorraine Whiteno animal deserves this end to its life.27672017-07-25T21:50:03.13733633Rose SewellBan the sale of these horrendously cruel glue traps27672017-07-25T21:55:02.34333634Darren JamiesonTotally disgusting. Absolutely revolting to sell this.27672017-07-25T22:03:08.93733635Fiona MacEachernAny trap that randomly catches any animal (and not just a particular type) should be banned.27672017-07-25T22:04:26.43733636Kerrie FergusonBan these items now!27672017-07-25T22:05:30.01733637Lorna BurnsThis is a disgusting thing to do to innocent animals and birds, destroy all these traps NOW27672017-07-25T22:05:54.18733638Jane RimingtonThese traps are horrendous, cruel & completely unnecessary.27672017-07-25T22:08:59.4733639David BellThis is cruelty at one of its worst ,please stop the manufacture of glue traps, 27672017-07-25T22:11:57.53333640Janet PalmerDreadful to think that these are legal in the UK in C21st! Disgusting. Please ban. 27672017-07-25T22:12:48.1433641Paul Skerritt I can't believe that this goes on, ban this now.27672017-07-25T22:19:41.92333642Paul Skerritt Pure evil27672017-07-25T22:21:51.333643Alex BarclayI am disgusted to see these rejected candidates sitting in our Parliament against the wishes of the electorate.26532017-07-25T22:22:40.34733644Vivienne Sambrook These traps are totally inhumain, they should be banned many years ago in any civilised country. 27672017-07-25T22:24:37.87733645Julia ReadI'm really shocked that this is a thing in the UK and sincerely hope they will be banned as soon as possible.27672017-07-25T22:24:52.4433646Jessica whitworth Absolutely barbaric and disgusting 27672017-07-25T22:27:34.76733647Julie GoodmanThese should not be used, its killing wildlife not the vermin its supposed to catch, they then die a slow and painful death, these need removing from\r\nsale NOW27672017-07-25T22:30:52.81733648Natascha Please stop this heinous practice 27672017-07-25T22:33:40.6633649BobThese things are cruel and inhumane27672017-07-25T22:35:12.17733650Susan KellyI am shocked that something so barbaric is not illegal in Scotland.27672017-07-25T22:38:16.58333651Juls mitchellInhumane and no place for it in this country27672017-07-25T22:49:10.25733652Anne DavisBarbaric for any creature caught in this medieval contraption. Shame on Scotland !27672017-07-25T22:53:14.80333653Amanda Lester This cruel behaviour Should be stopped!!27672017-07-25T22:58:05.58333654Rebecca AshmoreI'm a 25 year old English Animal and Wildlife lover, with a passion for animal and wildlife rescue, my dream is to rescue, rehabilitate and release wildlife around the world, helping conservation and teaching people about animals and how they can live in harmony with them.\r\nGlue traps are disgusting, they are cruel and inhumane, I gladly signed this petition as I want an end to the use of them.27672017-07-25T23:00:19.89733655AbbyThis is pretty horrific. Ban them .27672017-07-25T23:02:43.5733656Eleanor DrageThese traps should be banned 100%, there is no reason to use anything but humane rerelease style traps. Animals only become pests because people take away their natural habitats to build houses, shops etc. What an awful way for an animal of any kind to die.27672017-07-25T23:03:26.9633657Lesley butterworthThese traps are inhumane and should not be allowed in a civilised country.27672017-07-25T23:08:15.35333658carol hodgsonban them crurl \r\n27672017-07-25T23:12:44.72733659Louise BartonAppalling cruelty27672017-07-25T23:19:48.43333660Dorothy SharkeyShocking devices.27672017-07-25T23:20:19.71333661Nancy KennedyBan glue traps in Scotland.27672017-07-25T23:21:45.94733662Alison johnsPlease ban these cruel traps 27672017-07-25T23:23:43.35333663MazzaThis is an outrage and we have to do everything we can to outlaw the sale of these items. 27672017-07-25T23:27:27.0933664Katherine Janio This should be banned throughout the United Kingdom. This is a horrific piece of equipment which is doing more harm than good. Please ban it now.27672017-07-25T23:28:38.9833665Rosemary LaidlawOur environment is precious, we are responsible for protecting the flora and fauna that inhabit our beautiful country. It is imperative that our actions stay true to the character of Scotland. These traps are outrageously inhumane. Ban the barbaric treatment of our wildlife. 27672017-07-25T23:29:54.07333666Graham ShepherdWhat does the RSPCA say about this?\r\nWrite to your MP27672017-07-25T23:30:09.0133667AnnaDisgusting and cruel !! A ban is a must !27672017-07-25T23:40:26.23333668Emily BatesWe don't have the right to put any animal through this torture! I'm crossing my fingers and toes that T-Rex's will come back and put you in your place! 27672017-07-25T23:41:56.6733669Carole RobinsDreadful to use such awful traps. I thought anyway bat were a protected species! 27672017-07-25T23:46:29.5633670Jo Frances MatthewsThese traps are inhumane on every level. Please ban them. 27672017-07-25T23:56:34.51733671Fiona CampbellCruel, indiscriminate torture must be banned.27672017-07-25T23:57:11.54733672Heather fosterThese traps are horrific, horrible and should be withdrawn from sale and banned\r\n27672017-07-26T00:10:37.20333673Iain DavidsonThe fact that these exist is bonkers.27672017-07-26T00:12:43.533674Lauren MossThese are absolutely horrific things.27672017-07-26T00:12:56.48733675Anne Robertson Ban these cruel glue traps please 27672017-07-26T00:27:33.36333676Louise down This is disgusting, I've only ever heard of flypaper and even that's cruel, I actually gather flies up and release them, but for any creature to die slowly like this is just nasty, this invention should never have been passed for use public or otherwise and now should be banned. Being a human being does not give us the right to destroy any other living beings habit or take their lives, from the smallest bug to the great elephants of Africa we do not own this planet Xxx27672017-07-26T00:35:31.92733677Sarah spakeGlue traps are a death trap for birds and butterflies!27672017-07-26T00:56:11.80333678Neil McNeillThese traps are disgusting and have no place anywhere I can think of when they are catching beautiful innocent creatures which die a horrible death!27672017-07-26T01:18:43.5133679Peter lucasIt is illegal to to trap interver or harm any wild bird in the UK27672017-07-26T01:25:35.8733680Beatrice BrinklerI really cannot imagine My Scottish Government allowing this . I place My Trust in You . Thank \r\nYou .27672017-07-26T02:35:12.29733682Kerry Down This is one of the most besgusting sites i,n ever witnessed . If this is Scotlands idear of ok . They better look around them . Not a great leasen to be sending there young 27672017-07-26T03:50:59.84333683heather goesselthese glue traps are a danger to many other flying creatures27672017-07-26T04:44:17.3533684Claire GilbertThese traps are a disgrace27672017-07-26T05:34:22.5733685Katy hodgsonCruel method of catching prey.\r\n\r\nThe fact it does not select makes it abhorrent27672017-07-26T06:00:24.71733686Susan GilvearThese glue traps are dangerous for wildlife as they are indiscriminate to whatever is caught or flies into them causing great distress and harm 27672017-07-26T06:28:57.48333687Karen Page Please ban the use of glue traps. Unbelievably cruel 27672017-07-26T06:50:25.70733688Anne ThomsonDefinitely need to be banned27672017-07-26T07:00:00.66733689Christine PeddefI have signed so many petitions against glue traps and nothing seems to change. Man's inhumanity to animals is infinite!27672017-07-26T07:01:13.33333690Lorna QuornPlease take action to ban these barbaric means of animal torture27672017-07-26T07:03:47.00333691Angela LongWhat a barbaric practice. There is no place for this in a civilised world where we should know better!!27672017-07-26T07:08:35.8133692Mary JessopThis is cruelty at it worst, to catch birds and bats, who do no harm to anyone is terrible, we have to stop this thing being sold, as soon as possible.27672017-07-26T07:35:18.12733693Eileen NicholsonI cannot conceive that these even exist, considering their indiscriminate nature.... anyone using them is some kind of sociopath as far as I am concerned.27672017-07-26T07:41:45.77733694Nina LingardStop this horror27672017-07-26T07:49:14.84733695Christine HayesDisgusting banned immediately can't believe you can buy such cruel things.27672017-07-26T07:50:29.29333696Stephen MartinI can't believe this is going on in Great Britain!27672017-07-26T07:52:09.4133697Margaret Fleming Thankfully I haven't seen anything like this but definitely prefer never to witness such a cruel thing27672017-07-26T07:59:32.86333698paul midwoodI was shocked to learn that such inhumane and indiscriminate glue traps were used in Scotland. I urge the Scottish Parliament introduce a total ban to protect our wildlife from such cruelty.\r\n27672017-07-26T08:13:42.3133699Susan JohnsonSigned & posted27672017-07-26T08:16:10.26333700Elaine DownieThese fiendish traps must cause extreme cruelty 27672017-07-26T08:19:33.08333701Meg EdmundsCruelty beyond belief. What a painful death these beautiful creatures are suffering. I'm appalled. 27672017-07-26T08:26:07.92333702Lorraine de Courcy RichieBritish wildlife needs our support not our glue traps.27672017-07-26T08:29:02.09333703Dolores Shackleton This is not acceptable. Wildlife are already struggling to survive without these morons who think this is okay. Without our wildlife we have no future27672017-07-26T08:37:59.6633704Mrs Catherine AppsThese traps are barbaric and must be banned\r\n27672017-07-26T08:39:19.70733705Elizabeth Doughty This is a dreadful trap for any creature and is barbaric. It should be banned. 27672017-07-26T08:39:32.9733706John PorterNo comment needed27672017-07-26T08:41:29.1933707Elizabeth Doughty Please ban this barbaric contraption 27672017-07-26T08:47:55.4833708Christine Johnson It's barbaric and these traps should be banned27672017-07-26T08:54:47.44333709Juliana TeixeiraCruel way to die. They must be banned27672017-07-26T08:55:12.31733710PAULA LLOYDCan't believe anyone would be against this ban, it's common sense to support the ban.27672017-07-26T09:03:06.93333711LibNot needed 27672017-07-26T09:05:37.87333712Tracy MillerThese should not be readily available and should be banned as they indescriminately trap live animals who then die a long slow death which is inhumane and has no place in the progressive country of Scotland 27672017-07-26T09:12:23.60733713Sidney BurnettCan't believe the depths man's cruelty can sink to to destroy the planet27672017-07-26T09:15:38.9533714Jane BThey need to be banned completely, everywhere.27672017-07-26T09:24:18.65733715RainbowThis need to be done in the whle of the UK!27672017-07-26T09:26:33.26733716Christine HillThese traps are just not acceptable. They need to be banned.\r\n27672017-07-26T09:28:52.43733717MarilynShocking. Totally unacceptable.27672017-07-26T09:32:23.42333718Mrs Frances ScottThis is barbaric and cruel and shows how low humans have sunk.27672017-07-26T09:39:52.23733719Jan ColeCruel and indiscriminate. Please make them illegal.27672017-07-26T09:41:02.1933720ZenaTotally inhumane 27672017-07-26T09:42:54.98733721Eleanor CallaghanIt is utterly horrendous and must be stopped.27672017-07-26T09:47:59.42333722Ailsa StrattonThese traps are so inhumane and cause such suffering. We must legislate to protect our natural wildlife against their use.27672017-07-26T09:48:20.0833723vivian hitchingsit is absolutely inhumane to use paste board traps.\r\n27672017-07-26T10:04:19.33333724TJA DaltonPlease remove these traps from the market urgently. I do not even believe they exist, let alone that they are on sale in Scotland or anywhere. This level of torture of animals is completely unacceptable.27672017-07-26T10:06:12.69333725Kelly brooksTerrible 27672017-07-26T10:21:11.133726Elizabeth BottWhy use glue traps ?27672017-07-26T10:25:28.0733727john patersonThese should definitely be illegal.27672017-07-26T10:31:24.71333728Lorraine Reese These should be banned everywhere not just Scotland. We need all the wildlife for sustainable life cycles including ours please put a ban on them 27672017-07-26T10:32:02.1233729Andrea OsborneBarbaric27672017-07-26T10:52:22.7333730adam jonesPlease respect all life. This is cruel and unneunessar.\r\nAnimals die in cruel circumstances. They are not pests, respect all creatures.\r\n27672017-07-26T10:54:58.29333731Helen Lacey Ban them 27672017-07-26T11:06:43.96733732Karen Osterberg These traps are medieval in the cruelty and suffering they inflict. There is absolutely no excuse to use anything so arbitrary in its methods. They should be banned and recalled immediately. Bearing in mind all bats are protected there is photographic evidence of bats trapped and (ultimately) killed with these devices. I hope the government will do the right thing and respond immediately. 27672017-07-26T11:07:28.1733733KatieI'm amazed and disgusted that these still exist in Scotland, a forward-thinking country that has an abundance of incredible wildlife. 'Pests' or wildlife, these traps are in humane. Although I would like to see a UK wide ban, not just a ban in Scotland27672017-07-26T11:12:53.2833734Karen Osterberg These traps are medieval in the cruelty and suffering they inflict. There is no reason to use a device so arbitrary in its method. There is photographic evidence of bats being ensnared and as they are a protected species this is in direct contravention of the law. They are horrible devices which should be banned and recalled immediately. I hope the government will do the right thing. 27672017-07-26T11:14:51.40733735Christine KnightThe glue sticks are lethal to natural wildlife & pets. Use more humane products to kill rats27672017-07-26T11:26:06.06333736Fabia MoonThese must be banned, I saw bats in some of those shots. Bats are a protected species, at least they are here in England!! 27672017-07-26T11:33:03.48733737Clair LudgateThis is barbaric and must stop NOW27672017-07-26T11:42:14.4433738Jan SmithSo cruel and unecessary - do we live in the dark ages? Ban these vile glue traps.27672017-07-26T11:42:25.56733739Roxanne WilliamsNo animal should ever have to be treated this way :(27672017-07-26T11:48:43.75333740Mr Paul Harvey This practice is cruel and sickening and has no place in modern society.27672017-07-26T11:49:19.14333741Shan FrostPlease please stop this for the sake of our wildlife! 27672017-07-26T11:53:15.8833742David CarterThe use of glue traps should be banned immediately. They are cruel and barbaric. 27672017-07-26T11:57:20.6333744Jackie SmithIf it is unanimously agreed that any animal must be killed, then use a far kinder and more immediate option than this glue on card practise which is cruel, unnecessary and causes a long drawn-out death causing the animal great prolonged distress.27672017-07-26T12:04:48.05333745Jackie SmithOnly painless methods of unanimous uncontested deaths of animals ought ever be used, this is animal abuse and must not be tolerated as it is cruel and abusive27672017-07-26T12:10:35.39733746Roberta SpoonerThis is one of the most obscene things I've ever seen and it should be banned immediately!27672017-07-26T12:13:50.1833747Heather mcfaul I think it's discusting what these glue traps can do , they should be banned 27672017-07-26T12:33:40.2933748Joni phippinRank. Wtf is wrong with humans? Stop this27672017-07-26T12:53:14.23333749Rebecca MakepeaceThese traps are shocking beyond belief.27672017-07-26T12:57:29.88733750Maureen Stevensseeing the pictures of the pain these traps cause to animals, not just flies and insects, is heartbreaking and the sale of them should be banned without hesitation.27672017-07-26T13:00:05.85733751HannahSick. Get them out of here!27672017-07-26T13:03:20.18733752Philip Friston-ReillyThese traps are indiscriminate and if bats, a protected species, are being caught and killed then the people who set these traps are breaking the law if it were to happen over here.27672017-07-26T13:04:15.05333754Tracy StorrierCruel and barbaric I 27672017-07-26T13:15:29.28333755Claire Roberts This is barbaric 27672017-07-26T13:17:43.33733756Juli The illegality of these traps means the government must take this seriously. Wild birds and bats cannot be captured this way, by law. Please make the change.27672017-07-26T13:23:57.4333757Dawn BlakeHadn't heard of this trap until now. Why would anyone not have thought of the unneccessary pain, trauma and death for these poor animals. Makes me very unhappy. 27672017-07-26T13:45:08.79333758Jane peacockThese glue traps trap and kill all sorts of wild life including some endangered species. They must be banned.27672017-07-26T13:46:05.74733759alexander fergusonget these banned27672017-07-26T14:22:45.76733760pete holmeshunt the hunters with a glue gun27672017-07-26T14:33:19.5533761Jo PBTime to think beyond the immediate. Kill animals and humans will die. Simples.27672017-07-26T14:51:50.81733762Kay tompkins Ban these indiscriminate glue traps. 27672017-07-26T14:55:37.7833763Lizzi WaltonI cannot believe this is allowed. The means to kill maim capture wild birds. We must protect all wild animals not slaughter.27672017-07-26T14:59:07.533764Paul DolanThis is barbaric, stop this cruelty now.27672017-07-26T15:15:48.81333765Julie portGlue traps are cruel, they need to be removed now27672017-07-26T15:36:14.80733766Hamish MitchellWhat a disgusting indiscriminate and cruel way to treat randomly passing creatures. Birds, cats, rodents, endangered species. All at risk.27672017-07-26T16:04:20.11733767carole greenThese traps are so cruel and do not differentiate between the creatures they catch27672017-07-26T16:26:48.59733768Paul HughesGlue traps are barbaric and have no place in a 21st Century society27672017-07-26T16:30:27.6633770Robert PenningBarbaric 27672017-07-26T16:30:39.77733771Angela IllingworthHeartbreaking and unnecessary. Need to be banned.27672017-07-26T16:33:57.4133772AlessandraWe must catch animals in a humane way if needed- not like this!!!!27672017-07-26T16:44:09.96733773Mandi lewisI'm appalled that someone thought these would be useful, innocent and also protected species (bats etc) are being cruelly killed by a slow death or having to tear parts of themselves away from the glue. I'm very shocked these were made. 27672017-07-26T17:01:56.72733774Katharina HaimelI really loved this coumtry, but now I will not go there anymore till this stops.27672017-07-26T17:08:34.98733775Sandra MclartyThat is absolutely horrendous & so cruel, I hope all glue traps are banned 27672017-07-26T17:22:14.39333776Sharon DixonPest control for the lazy and inhumane! Any one uses one cannot have a concience! 27672017-07-26T17:34:31.0633777Catherine Hazell How awful and cruel these can be when the unintended animal is stuck!! Stop selling NOW!27672017-07-26T17:41:55.78733778Vera BohlenThis is a truly horrible death. Please help stop this.27672017-07-26T17:42:17.8433779Denise FarrellThese traps do not discriminate which animal they trap. They cause untold suffering to any animal that gets caught and it's just cruel. 27672017-07-26T17:43:59.8433780John Dunnett SCUM27672017-07-26T17:45:00.61733781LorrainePlease put an end to this barbaric practice27672017-07-26T17:50:31.47733782Peter ElfordNo part of a civilised community27672017-07-26T17:55:09.4233784Alan RomanPlease ban glue traps27672017-07-26T18:21:22.89333785Janet CathcartCruel and unnecessary surely more humane methods could be used. Not sure why they're being used at all.27672017-07-26T18:23:4133786GerryDreadful and unnecessary27672017-07-26T18:24:16.8933787Bridget GanderFeeling horrified and sickened.27672017-07-26T18:26:10.3933788KateHow are these even for sale?? 27672017-07-26T18:27:15.8633789LORRAINE WALSHThis is a barbaric way for our wildlife stop this now27672017-07-26T18:35:14.28733790Kim OveringtonI found a Starling who had fallen victim to one of these despicable traps. We tried everything to try to free him to no avail. The RSPCA euthanised him ..... such a sad waste of s little life27672017-07-26T18:38:42.89333791Lesley SmithFor any living being caught in these horrific glue traps it is absolutely horrific. They need to be removed and never sold again anywhere. 27672017-07-26T18:39:54.7233792Margaret LoveThese glue traps should be banned. They cause unnecessary pain and suffering to all animals and are very cruel.27672017-07-26T18:52:06.77333794Amanda Hate these traps 27672017-07-26T18:58:40.61733795Sheila NorrisCan't believe these are still legal in the 21st Century! Some birds from here in the IOM fly across to Scotland - you are potentially killing other people's birds. Stop!27672017-07-26T19:19:47.52333796Gina ChronWhether the vicim is a bird, mouse, bee, wasp, or other insect, these traps are inhumane and should not be used. Please ban glue traps in Scotland. 27672017-07-26T19:21:53.97733797Felicity CarusThis is horrific! What's the point ? 27672017-07-26T19:32:31.72733798Nerys ChildsIt is very wrong to harm animals.27672017-07-26T19:38:33.35733799AnnieThese glue traps are horrifically cruel, they sre not only cruel to the intended victim but they kill all wild life indiscriminately...and it's a slow a painful death. Whoever thought this vile trap up deserves to be trapped and left in it.27672017-07-26T19:41:21.40333800Ann BealWhat terrible cruel traps, surely whoever designed these have serious emotioanl and mental issues and needs help. It inflicts pain and suffering on all creatures not just the poor creatures it was designed for.27672017-07-26T19:44:09.96333801kevin laneWhat is wrong with you people?27672017-07-26T19:53:36.90733802David Alexander StevensThe use of these cruel and indiscriminate glue traps must be outlawed!27672017-07-26T20:02:46.43733803James T McKayNo need. 27672017-07-26T20:04:10.46733804Billie WealleansUnnecessarily cruel27672017-07-26T20:07:50.4533805Gail copePls stop this animals suffering27672017-07-26T20:12:05.6933806Sheila northUtterly barbaric, appallingly cruel, these glue traps must be banned now. 27672017-07-26T20:32:56.45733807CarolineIt's barbaric to let a bird suffer in this way27672017-07-26T20:54:41.58733808Sylvia RobertsI saw a mouse caught on one of these traps the first day I started work and have never forgotten it. It was squealing and pulling its skin off. There was no way of rescuing it apart from ripping its skin off. It was awful 27672017-07-26T20:54:45.67733809Ruth Mc DonaldThis is disgusting, pleas get rid of all of these traps, animals should not suffer like this27672017-07-26T20:59:40.4933810paul noakesthe are incredibly cruel and totally indiscriminate killing anything that touches it including a multitude of protected species27672017-07-26T21:45:18.93733811C AndersonThese traps are unnecessarily cruel and should be banned. There's just too much of a risk for the wildlife. 27672017-07-26T22:02:41.333812Hannah Mccall Wrong in so many ways! We do not need to trap animals and especially not in this way. Rid this cruelty. 27672017-07-26T22:24:42.28733813Robert MackayI thought these traps were already illegal, why aren't they?\r\n27672017-07-26T22:31:10.20733814Neil Armstrong Indiscriminate and cruel, these must be banned.27672017-07-26T22:38:54.8533815Lisa Burgess I'd like to glue the people who set these traps to aboard & leave them out in the wilderness to die a slow, painful death. See how they like it! 27672017-07-26T22:47:45.91333816Tim CowleyWe have to behave better than this. These traps do not discriminate and are therefore a risk and dangerous to innocent wildlife. 27672017-07-26T22:50:56.88333817Margaret Stedman This is despicable!! Perhaps nailing the perpetrators feet to a board might give them some idea how it feels!27672017-07-26T22:59:49.0733818Ian DobsonAbsolutelt disgraceful927672017-07-26T23:04:29.38333819Clare parry These traps are crule and unnessacery27672017-07-26T23:18:56.9833820mark evansIf we cannot recognise the casual cruelty we inflict on animals, we have no hope of recognising the less casual cruelty we inflict on fellow human beings. Such attitudes as this to the natural world is a symptom of a psychologically sick species, and the cause of further capacity for cruelty.27672017-07-26T23:20:24.96333821Lesley MenziesHorrible cruel things should be banned 27672017-07-26T23:24:45.5633822Daisy BroadbeltHorrendously cruel traps. They need banning. Just awful :'( 27672017-07-26T23:44:29.96733823ELIZABETH BONACCORSOI do believe the MMR is linked to Autism by my own personal experience with my daughter. 29002017-07-27T00:00:40.04733824SuziThis is animal cruelty 27672017-07-27T00:02:59.51333825Saul macpherson It's sick and cruel 27672017-07-27T00:26:10.50733826Gillian Westland Please ban this horrendous trap!!!!!!!!!!!! Utter cruelty!!!!27672017-07-27T01:25:54.99733827Denise FarrellTotally disgusted to see these traps which cause slow agonising death to any animal caught in it on sale in Scotland. This is barbaric and not acceptable27672017-07-27T01:31:13.6233828Craig HughesGlue traps are inhumane, cruel and unnecessary. Their sale and use are opposed by the SSPCA, RSPCA and PETA. Get them banned.27672017-07-27T03:38:16.89733829Cameron CoventryThe Scottish Government should ban such outrageously cruel devices.27672017-07-27T04:35:47.3633830Lindsay NeilThere should be a time limit on shoe ins using election lists due to resignations, deaths etc. In any case it should not be a party prerogative but on votes cast only.26532017-07-27T05:11:32.86333831IanIt is unbelievable that such terrible things should be available and being used in modern Scotland or elesewhere in the UK27672017-07-27T06:53:08.76733832pamela normanThese are barbaric & incredibly cruel. Stop them!\r\n27672017-07-27T07:24:38.99333833Joanne LatimerThese traps are cruel and unethical. Animals should not be made to suffer for our convenience.27672017-07-27T07:49:19.85333834Karli ThomasI was shocked to discover these traps and glues were used in NZ, and relieved that our efforts some years back led to their ban. All countries should follow suit. The suffering these traps cause is utterly unacceptable and there are plenty of more humane solutions.27672017-07-27T08:00:36.8433835Jill ReadI'm horrified that these are being used. They are inhumane.27672017-07-27T08:09:02.12333836lis allan what a disgusting thing to do is to use those vile traps to torture whatever is caught in them .lowlife human beings that set them .27672017-07-27T08:09:51.74733837Susan BirdIt's barbaric and cruel, it makes this country as bad as Cyprus etc.27672017-07-27T08:20:59.34333838Zoe PhillipsI had no idea these death traps could be bought so easily. Please put an end to this and protect our lovely wildlife.27672017-07-27T08:39:43.65733839David MoorThese traps need to be banned immediately27672017-07-27T08:46:35.89333840Chris WillsNever seen these before. How absolutely disgusting and inhumane. Might be an idea to contact the shops that sell them. 27672017-07-27T09:11:33.33333841Abbie PattersonDoes the Wildlife and Countryside Act along with the EU Directive not come into force here where birds that are all protected and more so bats which have an EU protection on them not come into force with this type of pest control?27672017-07-27T09:57:25.7633842Joe Cuddy MBEAn appalling and unnecessary item that has no place in the world. BAN IT!27672017-07-27T10:10:03.68333843Linda MenziesThese traps nead to be banned right away27672017-07-27T10:13:00.93333844Graham CannyCruelty against wildlife - the bar gets lower every year. Stop now.27672017-07-27T10:40:19.25333845Ljiljana HolmesWhat a cruel and nasty way to murder animals. It needs to stop. Now. 27672017-07-27T10:46:56.45333846Valerie RooneyPlease ban this cruelty. Absolutely disgusted at this inhumane practice.27672017-07-27T11:02:51.78333847bee wilsontotally cruel27672017-07-27T11:05:21.33333848Sandy CrookesHow inhumane and barbaric! Hard to comprehend\r\nThat 2017 products like this still exist! Ban this!!27672017-07-27T11:32:18.69733849alan leeGlue traps a are slow torture to any animal or bird that happens across them,pets included.Ban them now.27672017-07-27T11:59:36.2633850JaclynThis is a disgusting method and should be banned immediately.27672017-07-27T12:16:45.9533851Caroline P Hopewell A cruel and vile abuse of sentient creatures!27672017-07-27T12:27:16.51733852Peter CooperHow barbaric! What a stupid way to catch birds. Who ever allows it must have a birdbrain them selfs. How can you expect other countries to change when we have outdated practices ourselves.27672017-07-27T12:36:01.47333854Daisy Cooke This is barbaric. BAN THEM!! 27672017-07-27T12:37:52.15733855TeresaBarbaric evil need to be banned 27672017-07-27T12:44:47.87733856Jeff WhitworthI cannot believe these traps are still available and being used27672017-07-27T12:46:55.1633857Elizabeth HutchinsonThere is absolutely no justification for using traps like this.It's inhumane & causes untold suffering. 27672017-07-27T13:04:50.2733858Mandy ScottSeriously? In this day and age 'anybody' finds this sick torture device acceptable?!!!27672017-07-27T13:09:08.31733859Carolyn LeeBarbaric.27672017-07-27T13:44:35.6533861Amy JacobsTorture!!!!27672017-07-27T13:45:29.96333862rosa adamsTorture,slow and painful -- How can we consider ourselves civilised if we condone this practice.27672017-07-27T14:09:18.57733863Michael BibleCruel & barbaric. Please stop. 27672017-07-27T14:12:26.67333864Susan HarrisThese are totally barbaric and should be banned immediately 27672017-07-27T14:18:38.15733865Matthew ReynoldsThese are horrific, prolonged and agonising methods of so called "pest control". Do some research and you'll find there are far more options available that don't involve death. 27672017-07-27T14:26:50.67333866KellyBarbaric and cruel 27672017-07-27T14:27:22.07733867Amy BremnerSickening and selfish. No regard for nature. 27672017-07-27T14:29:02.533868Sonia RussellThis is cruel and barbaric! This has to be stopped as to intentiay make any animal suffer is the most lowest thing anyone can do!! Stop this now!!!27672017-07-27T14:50:55.5733869GILLIAN SMITHI am disgusted that these glue traps are used. They need to be banned immediately. The poor animals trapped must have died in agony.\r\n\r\n27672017-07-27T15:02:01.133870David WalkerCruel & horrific, should have no place in a civilised society.27672017-07-27T15:02:37.50333871Lee SalmondThese glue traps are cruel slow end for any animal27672017-07-27T15:17:23.80333872Dawn osguthorpeTragic sad and barbaric that as a culture we have so little care and love for animals. Ban glue traps with immediate effect is the least the Scottish Parliament.27672017-07-27T15:36:09.9233873Tracy BrightenWe see images of wildlife suffering in barbaric glue traps in Mediterranean countries where animal welfare is a low priority. But Scotland? I'm deeply shocked. Humane traps can be used for mice. Glue traps must be banned.27672017-07-27T15:40:09.8733874RogerTotally unnecessary, must be banned.27672017-07-27T15:48:58.27733875Teri WorthingtonGlue traps are barbaric and there is no justification for their use.27672017-07-27T16:00:46.54733876Alice McmillanCruel27672017-07-27T16:18:31.26733877Susan ForsythThe sooner the better. Shameful to use these traps.27672017-07-27T16:55:58.42333878Dirk de troyer Stop with glue traps. Its cruel 27672017-07-27T17:17:45.8833879Kari BruheimThis is cruel. Please stop.27672017-07-27T17:33:05.40333880Karen BondTotally not humane in the slightest, bit disgusted by the sale of these27672017-07-27T18:03:30.0633881Shane Cruel and uncalled for 27672017-07-27T18:08:58.87333882Lucy KellyGlue traps are horribly cruel, and they kill a lot of nontargetted species. Please ban them now!27672017-07-27T18:13:01.67333884Jane DaltonWildlife is under attack from humans in so many ways. Please eliminate these horrendously cruel and unnecessary killing devices. 27672017-07-27T18:19:26.79733886Allie Hayes It sadly never fails to amaze me what cruel contraptions and unbelievably things are for sale online and shockingly also in stores ? These are cruel and there has been no thought or consideration for how many innocent animals & birds ect that can and will be affected and killed by these awful traps ! Please please take these off sale from everywhere and lets get them banned forever !!! 27672017-07-27T18:27:52.2733887PaulIndiscriminate and inhumane. Ban this. 27672017-07-27T18:34:33.81333888ZMCNABNo animal needs to die in such a slow, cruel& barbaric way in 2017. The traps will not discriminate which animals will die. Scotland needs to lead the way in cruelty free animal welfare in all areas27672017-07-27T18:54:32.91333889Rosemary JonesI didn't know these existed and am appalled that they are permitted to be used. Utterly unnecessary and grotesque. Get them banned!!\r\n27672017-07-27T18:58:39.86333890Tony WebberThis is barbaric and has no place on this planet! Whoever decided to use this disgusting piece of equipment should be locked up for very long time\r\n27672017-07-27T19:04:45.00733891Darren Tunmore Absolutely disgusting. Ban it!27672017-07-27T19:05:17.6333892Sabine BatternayAbsolute horrific, the manufacture and sale needs to be outlawed straight away!27672017-07-27T19:13:23.36733893Christine JacksonCruelty is not the answer, there must be a more humane way of dealing with this ,it might take intelligence tho !\r\n 27672017-07-27T19:32:53.04333894Christine NightingalePlease abolish these traps27672017-07-27T19:47:09.8433895gail cope pls stop this27672017-07-27T19:50:37.40333896George McBurnieCruel and outdated not required27672017-07-27T19:59:23.90333897Renate AnderschThis is insane and criminal irresponsible towards innocent birds and animals. 1) it must be banned to sell it in shops freely. 2) There must be strict control over the use and where it is been used. 27672017-07-27T20:06:06.96733898CAROL THOMPSONEven animals we consider to be pests are sentient (as recognised in law). Any method used to reduce their numbers should be humane. 27672017-07-27T20:11:32.26333899Jessy KadmaerDevilish .... 27672017-07-27T20:14:31.89333900TaraDisgusting and a very inhumane way to capture innocent animals.27672017-07-27T20:18:40.333901Peter StanfieldParliment surely you don't want this ?27672017-07-27T20:20:08.56333902Nicola beaumontThese are disgusting and should be available on the shelves.27672017-07-27T20:20:47.3633903Nicola These are disgusting and should be banned.27672017-07-27T20:25:11.62733904NolaThis is sooo cruel, painful and frightening, please ban glue traps27672017-07-27T20:37:55.94333905Ann Garwood-MaxwellThis is horrific!27672017-07-27T20:42:21.50333906Scott MacDonald These products are horrific & they kill everything that comes into contact with them. They are brutal weapons against all wildlife! 27672017-07-27T20:51:22.59733907Roy RobertsonThis is an obscene way to murder any animal27672017-07-27T20:53:43.1833908Jacqui cooperJust terrible, so cruel, please stop this.27672017-07-27T21:23:18.233909Marie MellorBarbaric and unnecessary 27672017-07-27T21:45:41.04733910Roslin DolanBarbaric practice on innocent birds and animals27672017-07-27T22:04:15.3133911Margaret Goddard This barbaric practice must stop now27672017-07-27T22:06:49.8333912Paul MolloyIn Scotland it is a scandal that candidates, parties and referendum results that have been rejected should be able to represent the voting majorities view, changing at the ground level may help in correcting the system all the way to the top.26532017-07-27T22:12:17.28333913Samantha HuntI had no idea anyone would use something so barbaric. Shameful.27672017-07-27T22:12:33.4233914Susan Roberts How anyone can think this is a humane way to sort out a 'pest' problem these days, defies belief. This is barbaric, indescriminate and must be stopped immediately. 27672017-07-27T22:13:02.98333915LusendaNeed to be removed from sale. Disgusting!!!27672017-07-27T22:16:42.51733916Jean cliftJust cruel27672017-07-27T22:16:48.28333917Samantha HuntI had no idea anyone would or could contemplate using such a barbaric trap. Shameful and disgusting27672017-07-27T22:26:51.8633918RachelThis is awful!27672017-07-27T22:27:30.03733919Elizabeth LongoPlease Ban the use of Glue Traps on Bats!27672017-07-27T22:34:41.97333921Catherine StrongIndiscriminate and cruel. These should be banned.27672017-07-27T22:35:24.59733922Sue MaySo cruel. 27672017-07-27T22:36:34.50733923Caroline LeaThis is a really cruel way to deal with "pests". Even a rat doesn't deserve a lingering death like this. We're supposed to live in more enlightened times and these cruel, indiscriminate traps don't belong in it.27672017-07-27T22:36:41.84733924Iris GribbenCruel!!!!!27672017-07-27T22:36:50.0233925Alexandra Campbell Glue traps are extremely cruel, indiscriminate and require more attention than most people are willing to give to avoid extreme pain and suffering. They should be made unlawful immediately.27672017-07-27T22:44:43.97333926John GaleThis is simply wrong, outrageous, I'm appalled and it must be stopped.27672017-07-27T22:51:47.133927Grace perfitt This should be banned. Poor animals. 27672017-07-27T22:56:51.33333928Sandra MayTotally unnecessary cruelty27672017-07-27T22:59:20.7933929Hennie BeavisWhy must we create such terrible things to cause so much pain and suffering. Taking a life is wrong. 27672017-07-27T23:00:52.4633930Maria Cunningham Really barbaric should be definitely outlawed !!!27672017-07-27T23:16:19.7933931Dr Rob WiddicombeMedieval and barbaric. Incredible they are still legal. Shame on anyone using them. 27672017-07-27T23:35:27.38733932Joyce harkinWhat a cruel and inhumane way to die!27672017-07-27T23:52:59.12733933Rebecca scottThese have no place in our world. Surely we do enough to animals without adding this awful, slow, agonizing death to the list of cruelties we inflict upon those that share our planet but inconvenience us at the same time. 27672017-07-28T00:08:45.78333935Nicole Morrison These things should never of been invented they are inhuman and very dangerous to other animals 27672017-07-28T00:11:54.93733936Josephine WilsonThese glue traps are abhorrent, cruel and so unnecessary. They should be banned!27672017-07-28T00:20:45.9133937Gail DalbySo cruel and barbaric27672017-07-28T02:30:25.23733938Gail FormosaMercy towards animals not violence 27672017-07-28T02:32:57.0233939Joy WebsterKilling animals at all is a disgrace to any counrty. Doing it in a harmful and barbaric way is pathetic. Animals feel pain, fright, hunger & thirst just like humans do. 27672017-07-28T04:07:15.6333940Diane McMahonHorribly cruel. 27672017-07-28T04:51:33.80733941S. KnapikSame thing happened this summer here in Canada. At least one major retailer voluntarily removed them from their shelves but they shouldn't be produced or sold - at all! 27672017-07-28T05:53:25.56733942Elaine thomasThis is barbaric please ban this it's such cruelty!!!!27672017-07-28T05:56:24.58333943Kathy SimonikThere is No Need To Use Such Barbaric Methods. It is Torture. Plain And Simple. Show Some Humanity. Do You Have Any?? Prove it. Ty.27672017-07-28T06:40:48.46333945Audrey WallaceBarbaric and open to abuse and inappropriate use27672017-07-28T06:41:01.71333946Mike BucklandUtterly indiscriminate killing of our natural fauna27672017-07-28T06:43:34.69733947Kim scottAbsolutely no need for these. There are plenty of humane ways to deal with pest control. 27672017-07-28T07:22:05.37733948Molly Sharrett There are more humane ways to handle "pests" than glue traps. Let's get rid of them please. 27672017-07-28T08:16:35.0733949KerinaSeeing the images of this product disgusted me27672017-07-28T08:48:57.49733950Wendy I am disgusted that these evil traps are still sold in today's society when most animals are endangered and struggling to survive. Stop it now. 27672017-07-28T09:03:24.23333951Margaret MacdonaldGet rid of these horrible things.27672017-07-28T09:08:37.0333952Selina Woolcott These are ghastly and indiscriminate- they have no place in a modern compassionate society 27672017-07-28T09:22:39.0533953Eloise Balfour Please let's get these banned, disgustingly cruel.27672017-07-28T09:23:43.92333954Libby Anderson Extremely inhumane traps, even "pest" control companies acknowledge this. Strongly support Let's Get Mad for Wildlife representing all sentient wild animals. 27672017-07-28T09:31:22.11333955Shaun Gilbert Cruel, and barbaric. Completely thoughtless in its development! This needs should NOT even be available!27672017-07-28T09:37:33.333956JennyBarbaric and cruel , get rid of these now 27672017-07-28T09:40:38.33333957JanetWe must not destroy our wildlife 27672017-07-28T10:06:37.75733958Maureen HackettGlue traps must be banned they are cruel and a terrible way to die.27672017-07-28T10:16:32.0433959C Ives Barbaric27672017-07-28T10:31:25.17333960Jan Groom BE ASHAMED OF THE HURT AND PAIN AND CRUELTY THAT YOU CAUSE BY ALLOWING SUCH BARBARIC THINGS!!!27672017-07-28T11:34:17.2933961Gilly BI am absolutely appalled that these traps are being used in Scotland.27672017-07-28T12:22:45.70333962Kelly mackay Barbaric cruelty at its worst outright ban is the only answer!!!! Disgraceful 27672017-07-28T12:28:32.78333963Nikki JonesSo many thoughtless people out there who have no regard for the horrendous suffering caused to animals. Truly barbaric. 27672017-07-28T12:36:45.70733964E MiddletonI fully understand the need for pest control, but these traps are horrific. They do nothing to humanely kill an animal - anything small caught in it physically pulls itself apart to escape, and dies of resulting traumatic injuries. They also make for a slow and painful removal for larger pets and humans, particularly children. There is no reason for these to continue to be sold when so many more safer and more humane pest control options are widely available.27672017-07-28T12:46:05.7733965Rachel A HydeShocked to see this sort of thing being sold these days. I hope they are not on sale anywhere else in the British Isles either.27672017-07-28T12:56:12.47333966Marla OBrienThat's disgusting and horrific!!! 27672017-07-28T13:09:45.91333967Mich MolyneauxThese traps are inhumane and discriminate, they should be banned immediately27672017-07-28T13:27:58.6233968Suzanne VogtThese traps are a menace and indiscrimanately kill anything and everything.27672017-07-28T13:27:59.94733969Peter sherwoodThese traps should be banned worldwide, they are completely indiscriminate and unbelievably cruel27672017-07-28T13:28:19.47733970Birgit ElonenWhy do you have such horrible traps27672017-07-28T13:39:23.88733971Sarah DaceyThe pain and distress that these traps must cause far outway any reason to want to use such a barbaric thing! 27672017-07-28T13:41:10.04333972Gill BowieBARBARIC this is killing some of native protected species and should be outlawed.27672017-07-28T13:50:33.77733973Isobel macGregorDisgraceful should be banned immedistely27672017-07-28T13:54:16.9233974Malcolm Matheson These traps should be banned ASAP.27672017-07-28T14:01:11.0633975Karen Benton-roseBarbaric beyond belief 27672017-07-28T14:04:05.8133976Julie Marshall This is shocking who in their right would such an indindiscriminate vile thing 27672017-07-28T14:26:43.01733977Tina MichelakisStop met deze horror vallen. Dit is afschuwelijk dit is onmenswaardig / Stop these horror attacks. This is awful. This is inhuman.27672017-07-28T14:30:49.8333978Yvonne It's very sad to see wildlife suffering such a horrible death these things need to be banned 27672017-07-28T14:40:48.9933980Antoinette TrebusBarbaric, cruel & abominable.27672017-07-28T14:42:21.7433981RogerWhy ?27672017-07-28T14:50:08.633982Eunice JohnstonThese things are beyond horrific. They must be banned forthwith. Scottish people are not savages. 27672017-07-28T14:51:30.56733983Ina Gerhold Stop this27672017-07-28T15:07:12.1833984Richard DannThis is indefensible, It is the sort of practice allowed in uneducated societies.27672017-07-28T15:15:12.27333985Barbara CassidyThis is an inhumane method of "pest control"and needs to stop.It is torture.27672017-07-28T15:15:17.86733986Debbie MacmillanGlue traps are horrendous, deadly and should never have been invented! :(27672017-07-28T15:16:24.7933987Manuela van Hall please ban this cruelty!!27672017-07-28T15:18:32.41733988J DohertyAbsolutely disgusting practice and should be banned forthwith.27672017-07-28T15:24:53.1533989Astrid LabanThis is horrible! 27672017-07-28T15:35:55.82333990Sonia hector jones Vile things should be banned everywhere!27672017-07-28T15:51:52.5333991Carmel AshbyThis is inhumane. Please stop the sale of these hazardous death traps.27672017-07-28T15:54:30.46733992Chris WoodrowThese traps are barbaric and cause unnecessary suffering to wildlife.27672017-07-28T15:54:57.7533993Christopher EvansTime to ban the cruel use of glue traps !!!27672017-07-28T15:57:10.48333994Ina MacphersonSo so cruel I could not use the fly traps in the green house.\r\nWe have no right to subject any creature to such treatment27672017-07-28T16:11:14.70333996Molly MasonIts quite sickening the devices manufactured to cause misery, mutilation and starvation to animals isn't it time to think about humane methods this is after all supposed to be a civilized country 27672017-07-28T16:12:37.73733997Tara lesterPlease stop this cruel nonsense. 27672017-07-28T16:14:56.17333998Lynne Millerick Please remove sticky traps from everywhere!... They sell them in pet shops in Brighton so they must have them in other towns and many vermin control company's use them also.. Please stop this inhuman cruel form of trapping... PLEASE...27672017-07-28T16:15:49.34333999Valerie PeachUnbelievable - one could say medieval but that would be wrong - these creatures are not killed for days but left to struggle and starve to death - get real Scotland this is unacceptable27672017-07-28T16:20:36.90734000Nadia foxSo very cruel. Please ban these traps27672017-07-28T16:31:56.20734001Patricia ShaveBarbaric practice, should be outlawed immediately...27672017-07-28T16:34:07.4434002Mariette van veenToo cruel! 27672017-07-28T16:38:23.8834003A McDonaldThis trap is designed for all wildlife and not just for Rats. BARBARIC in deed.27672017-07-28T16:41:01.334004Isobel Knoxwhat a horrible way for sentient beings to die. These traps do not discriminate bewteen vermin and other animals in any case. \r\n27672017-07-28T16:47:27.41334005Ruth KenyonHorrible, barbaric and nasty. My pet Jasper Hamster occasionally gets out of his ball and takes himself for a walk. He's as much a rodent as a mouse (or rat) is and would die horribly too.27672017-07-28T16:48:57.7734006Natalia D.This is not the way to treat innocent animals. This needs to stop now. We should be stewards of the creatures of the earth, not destroyers.27672017-07-28T16:53:23.86734007Elaine Absolutely no need for such a barbaric ending to so many innocent animals 27672017-07-28T16:55:20.50734008Bernadette KervickThis is not the way to deal with unwanted pests. They should not be tortured to death. Obviously other wildlife are falling foul of these archaic traps. Please make them obsolete and prove you listen to the people who care enough to take the trouble to bring this to the attention of those in power who can make a difference. 27672017-07-28T17:32:00.49734009Wendy HolfordWe need to protect our wildlife so please sign 27672017-07-28T17:48:59.23334010Ruth GreggBan this evil disgusting stuff. 27672017-07-28T18:05:29.79734011Tania CieslerWe must give our fellow inhabitants the respect and care they deserve, we have to start using our brains to plan for a decent environmental future27672017-07-28T18:07:20.6134012Tom HallidayIt is galling that politicians who stand for a constituency and are defeated, are then elected through the list system, this allows parties to have the same candidate standing in two elections for the same position, this situation could be quite easily resolved by having a constituency list and a regional list, no candidate can appear on both.\r\n26532017-07-28T18:17:03.20734013Jutta ChristofUNFASSBAR!!!/INCOMPREHENSIBLE27672017-07-28T18:26:06.9434014Lori GwynnPlease share to get this hell hole shut down27672017-07-28T18:26:42.4134015Diana Moorevery cruel....slow death. unnecessary and inhumane27672017-07-28T18:32:08.86334016Lisa Lawson Awful! 27672017-07-28T18:35:11.20734017Janice Partington This HAS to stop now! !27672017-07-28T18:45:54.6834018Susan E Sharpcompletely unacceptable \r\n27672017-07-28T18:53:45.55334019Lindi GreenGlue traps are totally inhumane. Please stop selling them.27672017-07-28T18:57:08.7134020James GrauYou should only be able to stand for a constituency seat. Not both Regional List. Get rid of these dead beats. 26532017-07-28T18:57:52.47734021John ScottThese traps cause pain and suffering that no animal should endure.27672017-07-28T19:12:55.2334022Jamie HowkinsI'm disgusted to be in a society where this moronic trap is made. Disgraceful27672017-07-28T19:16:06.0934023Catherine MeechanIts so cruel there is no need for this,how do you think the poor animal feels.27672017-07-28T19:18:16.2634024Derek SimpsonSo wrong on every level!27672017-07-28T19:29:32.0934025Leigh Brownsmith They're absolutely horrific! Get them banned and off the shelves. They're awful! 27672017-07-28T19:50:48.1434026Helen ArtonThink this has to be the worst invention ever!!!! Massive collateral damage by the looks of it! 27672017-07-28T19:57:59.12734027Sharon CorbinTheee are cruel slow torturous deaths and should be outlawed!27672017-07-28T20:30:29.9934028Debbie Wheelhouse Long slow, painfull daeths for any poor creature who just happens to cross their paths. Come on scot.gov show you actually care and ban these cruel traps and set an example27672017-07-28T20:37:26.3834029Rosemary ThomasCruel beyond belief27672017-07-28T20:42:54.94334030NickiThis is barbaric and I can't believe people buy these things they should not have the option ban them27672017-07-28T20:45:24.97734031WenI certainly hope this petition gets submitted well before September - like RIGHT NOW, PLEASE!27672017-07-28T21:01:22.80734032Yvonne JonesUtterly disgusting!27672017-07-28T21:12:28.5134033Jody LovattThis is barbaric and completely disgusting - poor creatures! 27672017-07-28T21:19:55.38734034Anja KniesThis has to STOP NOW!!!!27672017-07-28T21:21:52.6234035Jim TaylorUtterly disgraceful that these CRUEL death traps should be sold. The seller should be prosecuted as well as those who use them.27672017-07-28T21:36:51.0634036Lydia pyunHuman species need to stop seeing God 's creatures as enemies. We are to be good stewards to them, not murder them for convenience.27672017-07-28T21:50:54.7534037lyn sawkinsThese are cruel.I 27672017-07-28T21:54:01.89334038candice tharphorrible inhumane27672017-07-28T22:03:01.1934039Hazel EarlSuch a cruel fate for any creature - 27672017-07-28T23:02:11.0934040KaneThis is unnecessary and it causes great suffering. Please stop this. There are kind ways to keep animals out of your home and to put them back where they live.27672017-07-28T23:23:03.13734041Elizabeth PaytonBarbaric... Worse than lime sticks used in Europe. What on earth is the thinking behind these awful things. Must be banned now.27672017-07-29T00:40:01.5434042brice madhoMA FAMILLE ET MOI AIMONS LES ANIMAUX ALORS NOUS SIGNONS/MY FAMILY AND I LOVE ANIMALS SO WE SIGN27672017-07-29T04:48:01.13334043Ellen PriorNo glue traps!\r\n27672017-07-29T05:50:04.28334044April KonyuA society is defined not by how it treats its peers but how it treats those it see beneath them. all life is precious and deserves respect.\r\n27672017-07-29T06:04:43.84734045Amber WilliamsThe glue traps must be banned. Abuse is never acceptable.27672017-07-29T08:17:36.5134046Michelle RawsthorneCruelty has no place in a civilised world. 27672017-07-29T08:34:17.86734047Jo Ann TurnerThese traps are cruel, resulting in painful, slow death. They also can kill non-target species. No place for these in the 21st century!27672017-07-29T08:58:43.07334048Jean Skeenwhy would anyone think this is acceptable and sell them?27672017-07-29T09:45:54.59734049Sabine ThielBan glue traps now! It is barbaric! No animal deserves to die a painful death!27672017-07-29T09:55:23.75334051Sandra BakThese traps are cruel! Wildlife suffers. This is not humane! These traps must be removed from stores.27672017-07-29T09:58:42.19334052Rose JonesWho on earth would think that these are in any way humane and what kind of person would use them. If they are not available then people who have no thoughts other than their own selfish needs could not do such horrendous damage...27672017-07-29T10:03:12.74734053Erica SarneyWhy would any government allow this hideous killer of wildlife to be sold? All sales and imports should be stopped with immediate effect. \r\n27672017-07-29T10:10:35.72334054RichardUnbelievable. Why?27672017-07-29T10:11:47.8834055jacqueline tweatsThis is so cruel 27672017-07-29T10:26:25.2234056Joanne BartonThis should be banned - so cruel!27672017-07-29T10:31:50.84334057carol humphreysthis is disgusting27672017-07-29T10:39:12.35334058Fran Davies What are you? 27672017-07-29T10:40:32.6534059Jakki Absolutely awful, why there are more humane ways to deal with vermin that does not trap innocent animals and birds. Please make this illegal x27672017-07-29T10:43:36.43334060Neil HowesBarbaric!27672017-07-29T11:12:16.9634061DebbieThere are more humane ways to get rid of pests, why are things that are so cruel still allowed to be sold. Barbaric & unacceptable. 27672017-07-29T11:12:57.15334062Diane DavisThis practice is barbaric.27672017-07-29T11:41:34.44734063K roweIt is disgusting and cruel27672017-07-29T11:54:29.82334065Beverley CrankshawAbsolutely disgusting behaviour against defenseless animals.\r\n27672017-07-29T11:58:33.734067Richard ThewlisGlue Traps are completely unacceptable in any civilised society. They cause extreme unnecessary suffering.27672017-07-29T12:02:09.7434068Jean Lutwyche No thought given to what impact on other wildlife these traps have! Unbelievable!!!27672017-07-29T12:04:32.32734069 Marjorie Pennington This is a cruel and indiscriminate trap and should be banned. If the government is trying to encourage wildlife they are going a funny way about it. Also it destroys the balance of nature.27672017-07-29T12:18:3534070Nadine Baldwin Stop this critical practice 27672017-07-29T13:04:09.05334071PaulineThere is no place for these barbaric traps in Scotland. We need to be leading the way forward for animal welfare and that includes ALL animals!27672017-07-29T14:09:23.7834072Alan OrgillGlue traps are THE most barbaric traps on the planet and should be TOTALLY illegal (together with ALL traps)! It is that simple.27672017-07-29T14:15:32.72734073Jean Stewart#what a sick, twisted idea.....this is barbaric and cruel and should be banned. Please make these illegal27672017-07-29T14:20:43.08734074Margaret pearson.This is absolutely apaling. People who use these have no heart. 27672017-07-29T14:23:34.8734075Violet vynerI am disgusted that these glue traps are allowed to be used when they are so indiscriminate in what they kill and in the long drawn out cruel death a creature has to suffer once trapped in it. There are more humane traps out there so ban this 27672017-07-29T14:35:49.22334076Colinthese should be banned in the whole of the UK, as a nation of pet lovers, we the people are applauled27672017-07-29T14:56:23.07734077Karen SmithAwful27672017-07-29T15:56:47.12334078Robina BignellAppalling!! Totally I humane and barbaric traps! Stop using them now...27672017-07-29T16:32:37.5234079Harriet RycroftBarbaric, indiscriminate, unnecessary. 27672017-07-29T16:46:48.55334080Ian LogieDo it by the rules unlike our neighbors26532017-07-29T16:51:45.5634081Liz FarrI was aware of this some years ago in the Birmingham area for illegally trapping finches of all kinds. These are lethal to passing animals outlaw them and stop them being used to kill innocent animals 27672017-07-29T17:00:24.66334082Jason MacGilpThere is a pressing need for a full parliamentary review of the system of electing MSPs to our Parliament.\r\nAllowing failed constituency candidates to be elected via regional lists is anti-democratic and reduces trust in the electoral process, and gives political parties more power than citizens.\r\nI wish to see a new system based on Single Transferable Votes, with constuency MSPs only, no regional lists. This would improve accountability, create smaller constituencies more relevant to local communities and would make all MSPs work harder to understand and reflect the needs and priorities of their constituencies.26532017-07-29T18:06:18.02334083Annalies Barbaric, please put a stop to this. 27672017-07-29T18:06:27.23734084EileenSo cruel27672017-07-29T18:57:56.01734085Samantha bakerAbsolutely disgusting no living thing should be made to suffer like this 27672017-07-29T19:23:53.1634086Chris BalchinThis is on par with the methods used in the Mediteranean27672017-07-29T19:27:18.0634087Jackie OsbornDisgraceful that our taxes are being used to pay the wages of people in the Scottish Parliament who haven't been voted in directly by the electorate. Whole system needs reform 26532017-07-29T20:26:11.8434088Allison fitzpatrick This is disgusting and cruel. 27672017-07-29T20:55:01.34334089Ian RidingIndescriminate killing...even protected species are being killed by these barbaric traps and thus must be banned. 27672017-07-29T21:43:31.4734090Rona BeswickWhat a slow and painful way for any animal to die. Shameful!27672017-07-29T21:46:37.99334091reza hemmatzadehSTOP selling this glue which gives a cruel death on animals and all libing beings. please please STOP selling this cruel death material\r\n27672017-07-29T21:46:54.8634092LynneAppalling stop these being sold 27672017-07-29T22:15:26.20734093Ingo GentschThats cruel and dirty27672017-07-29T23:00:11.42334094Lynn porterAll traps should be humane27672017-07-29T23:02:31.81734095Priscilla C Miller This is cruel and barbaric. 27672017-07-30T00:06:00.2334096Marion FriedlYou´re welcome, the main thing´s that my signature counts, greetings from Germany!!!27672017-07-30T00:23:38.4234097Sian JenkinsThese cruel things need to be banned!27672017-07-30T00:50:44.71334098William WinslowCandidates you can vote for should not be on the list. That way if you fail to make the grade by not being voted in then that should be the end of the line until next election.\r\n There should be a limit to the terms that a list candidate may be selected from the list. 26532017-07-30T01:07:11.2434099Angelika KlebsStoppen Sie sofort diese unendliche Tierqual/ Stop this endless animal suffering immediately! 27672017-07-30T01:16:21.32734100SueShocking treatment towards animals!!! Surely there's more humane ways, instead of torture 27672017-07-30T01:54:00.80734101Paul ahmed We used to use these in work horrible things27672017-07-30T02:09:52.83334102Annette HarrisAm outraged that these glue traps and boards exist. Shame on the prople who use them. All forms of animal cruelty must be stopped.27672017-07-30T02:13:51.634103L brownWhat an awful way to die!!! Pest or no pest 27672017-07-30T03:49:52.1234105Liz AmerAppalling ..... very sad27672017-07-30T06:02:32.14734106Vivienne DoldenPlease ban these sadistic traps.27672017-07-30T07:17:53.534107Simon Boxhall-JamesGet a grip, they are living creatures, just like us27672017-07-30T07:22:22.1534108Kirsty Proctor sort your lives outs27672017-07-30T07:34:17.74334109Linda FordyceThese traps are indiscriminate and cruel. Ban them immediately.27672017-07-30T07:50:41.46734110YvonneSurely such a barbaric method of killing animals should not be allowed in the 21st century Scotland? 27672017-07-30T08:38:23.3734111Elizabeth BirkettI can't believe these horribly cruel traps are on sale in our country! Please ban glue traps - it is no way to treat ANY animal.27672017-07-30T09:28:42.95734112Fran WalkerA painful death is not the way for any pest control. Make these traps illegal.27672017-07-30T09:32:07.95734113Anne Langan These glue traps are barbaric. Their use must cease27672017-07-30T09:40:17.31734114Justin WalkerThese pest control methods are indiscriminate and inhumane, I'm surprised that their use is legal. 27672017-07-30T10:35:29.4834115Scott BradyIn order to stop 'job for life syndrome' and to ensure fresh blood flows into the chamber I suggest that a person may only serve one term as a list MSP.26532017-07-30T10:47:11.76334117Shelagh brazierWe should have more humanity than to use these27672017-07-30T11:09:50.43734118Tracy WingThese traps are barbaric and unneccessary27672017-07-30T11:26:27.09734119Carole SteeleIt is against Gods law . Cruelty on any level.. especially deliberate and targeted on the defenceless animals we are supposed to protect.27672017-07-30T11:54:55.11734120Lisa BrennanDespicable cruelty, how can these be sold in this day and age?27672017-07-30T12:24:41.24734122Sheryl HepworthExtremely good petition. These traps are cruel and not needed. 27672017-07-30T12:27:39.10734123Amy TThis is not the right way to treat animals - unwanted or not! 27672017-07-30T12:34:17.65334124Wiktoria This is disgusting 27672017-07-30T12:49:14.84334125Coral WilliamsThis is sad and sickening. How cruel to glue creatures to boards so that they have a slow, painful death.27672017-07-30T13:00:39.18734126joseph shepherdthis is how Tory and labour kept a hold of many areas in my opinion.Parties should not be allowed to manipulate results.If the people reject a candidate that should be that\r\n26532017-07-30T13:10:58.76734127Brian DruryShould be illegal in all the British Isles27672017-07-30T13:23:41.31734128john fergusonI agree fully with the petition and hope it succeeds.26532017-07-30T13:30:50.25334129Darren BurkinThese traps are inhuman and shouldn't be on the market. 27672017-07-30T13:49:20.33734130Sylvia TaylorAnything that causes ANY creature unecessary suffering should be banned !27672017-07-30T14:09:21.4834131Lauren SchultzThis is sick and inhuman....who ever designed this made a sticky pad capable of killing any any everything. This isn't right...27672017-07-30T14:19:57.934132Sarah McKimPlease ban these cruel and indiscriminate traps.27672017-07-30T15:02:13.75334133TriciaEnd all animal cruelty27672017-07-30T15:09:35.78334134Rona RendleDon't turn your back on the needless suffering of many animals. You know it's wrong and you have the power to do something about it - then do it!27672017-07-30T15:23:42.634135Elizabeth Not right. There is no need for this 27672017-07-30T15:29:22.3534136GilHow was this ever allowed to be manufactured?27672017-07-30T15:43:21.64734137candice tharpstop these cruel traps27672017-07-30T16:55:31.1134138Shirley ClementThis is so cruel. Never heard of it before.\r\n27672017-07-30T17:19:46.2734139Donald PatonI wrote to Donald Dewar about this at the time. It is ludicrous that the "list" consists of people nobody voted for. Despite the notion of beaten candidates having been rejected by the electors, many have stood and amassed considerable support. Far better that the list consist of people in order of votes received than party placemen who could be anyone. Indeed many party nominees would never get elected otherwise.26532017-07-30T17:26:13.25734140William Habib SteeleWhile I'm not living in Scotland at the moment, I am still committed to the welfare of my country. I have been concerned about the injustice of constituency candidates also appearing as list candidates. The injustice of this seems very clear. I wish that candidates be required to chose to be either constituency candidates or list candidates.26532017-07-30T17:37:37.9634141Sheila YurtPlease ban glue traps for animal safety! 27672017-07-30T17:50:40.38334142Marlene ArthurViolation of human rights needs to cease. Too many patients medicated without being made aware.28852017-07-30T17:50:47.77334143Nivelais Martinestop à ces horreurs de pièges/\r\nBan these horrific traps! 27672017-07-30T19:16:32.47334144wessang moniquehorrible !!27672017-07-30T20:10:26.8734145Robert BondI didn't realise glue traps were still legal here.27672017-07-30T20:15:12.234146Sam DorsettThis is just beyond cruel.27672017-07-30T20:48:56.92334147W mackinnonNo need for this kind of cruelty for any animal. Pest or not.27672017-07-30T21:21:44.16334148Chris lambrouHorible practice27672017-07-30T21:23:54.39734149RSAnd get rid of snares too!27672017-07-30T21:24:34.74334150Anne TweddleSee these for sale a few days ago and was very concerned about how cruel they are.27672017-07-30T21:24:41.7434151hilda delgadoIs very cruel use of glue traps....27672017-07-30T21:25:36.19334153Nicola CallidStop this barbaric action now27672017-07-30T21:26:40.66334155Jillian simpsonI know I'm from Lancashire but I needed to sign as it is horrible 27672017-07-30T22:01:57.0934156Liz Crawford It's an extremely cruel death. Please stop this.27672017-07-30T22:04:26.96734157Richard ThomasThis type of pest patrol is inhuman and unacceptable in 201727672017-07-30T22:14:00.82734158Jean EndeanNo proper comment other than absolute disgust towards these barbaric people.27672017-07-30T23:34:09.99334159Luke deveyI would lile to vote against this because why should a animal go through pain like that what for.27672017-07-31T00:04:48.04334160Teona Dorrien-SmithNo animal - pest or not - should suffer such cruelty.\r\nHow was such a vile thing ever approved in the first place? Who was responsible? Ban glue traps at once.27672017-07-31T00:17:10.57734161Jade lapiereThis is cruel and heartless way to kill!!!!!!!!27672017-07-31T00:22:00.79734162Sue RossPlease ban this dreadful form of "torture" 27672017-07-31T01:36:48.88734163Erren MichaelsGlue traps are obscenely cruel and in addition to their targetted victims often trap birds, cats, even endangered bats. They must be banned.27672017-07-31T01:38:16.75334164Amy SelbyThese traps are barbaric and result in a slow painful death for anything caught in them - they must be banned.27672017-07-31T01:47:44.1634165Sue pthese glue traps are barbaric and need to be banned!! 27672017-07-31T02:28:58.06334166Lisa sadighi These traps are obviously cruel and inhumane. They cause a torturous and slow painful death. This is ban the sale of glue traps.27672017-07-31T04:00:09.9334167Ina Glue traps are a horrible way to die! This need to be banned.27672017-07-31T04:18:02.06334168Dari LangoneWhat happened to humanity? 27672017-07-31T06:42:09.0634169Diane Moore Barbaric! Everyone is up in arms when an act of animal cruelty is publicised and yet these inhumane, cruel things are still on general sale. They need to be banned immediately27672017-07-31T06:48:45.6834170DEBRA wilsonThis is so cruel - it needs to stop immediately!\r\n27672017-07-31T07:04:21.65734171Hayley ArcherNo need for this horrible torture method. This needs to stop.27672017-07-31T07:23:45.11334172Janice FrohnsdorffSo cruel and barbaric....please ban these 27672017-07-31T07:57:30.28334173iryna komarwe need stop do bad with enimals27672017-07-31T08:13:18.7634174Kathryn WilliamsBan glue traps, now please.27672017-07-31T09:48:47.65734175Grant BrownI completely agree with the petitioners premise that constituency candidates who lose out in elections must not be allowed in through the back door by way of the lists. I also agree that list candidates must not be predetermined in a ranking system. But I would go further and suggest that list candidates can only hold positions for a maximum of three parliaments before being automatically deselected and forced to become a constituency candidate to retain their position as an MSP. 26532017-07-31T10:56:32.58734176Rita HumphreyThis is absolutely disgusting & inhumane!!27672017-07-31T10:57:00.4334177Willie MillerThe system at present is not satisfactory as it allows candidates who were effectively rejected by the electorate to gain a position via the back door of the "list". That's no better than ennobling a failed candidate to the HOL to beat the national voting system.26532017-07-31T11:05:37.6934178Larry CosgraveThis is insane to allow these catch anything idiotic traps to be legal. Stop it now, shameful for a country to allow this uncivilized abuse.27672017-07-31T12:27:20.78734179Paul GriggsVile. People should be prosecuted for using them.27672017-07-31T12:40:44.1434180Linda LariviereThis is sadistic and should not be tolerated by a civilized country. Ban these torture traps now.27672017-07-31T13:04:05.00334181Brenda mackayBarbaric27672017-07-31T14:04:33.63334182Anne hawkinsThis is disgraceful27672017-07-31T14:50:27.29734183Theresa FryBarbaric27672017-07-31T15:48:39.74734184Pamela Hansonstop glue traps27672017-07-31T17:32:34.56734185Moira frewThis is indiscriminate and disgusting.27672017-07-31T18:27:42.39734186Owen GallagherThe present system allows candidates who have been rejected by the electorate to remain in post. I am unsure which system should replace the present be but it is clear the present set up in unsatisfactory.26532017-07-31T18:57:03.99734187corina duchiSTOP!27672017-07-31T19:23:22.1334188Sharon prior Yes they should be banned 27672017-07-31T21:14:03.0334189Karen Richards These glue traps are so evil and want banning who ever invented these evil traps wants locking up 27672017-07-31T21:16:46.82734190Angela Paquette Ban these awful traps now they're damaging the animals 27672017-07-31T22:35:24.12334191Glenys Steedman I thought we lived in a civilised country, obviously Scotland is not.27672017-07-31T22:42:37.6534192Suzanne BraytonInhumane27672017-07-31T23:01:45.2734193claire owensThere is so much cruelty to animals in this world,it has to stop.Animals contribute so much to our happiness and should be loved and protected.Please help them by signing the petition.\r\n27672017-07-31T23:14:05.4634194Debi AllanTotially barbaric & sick27672017-08-01T00:29:45.2934195Joan RooneyI don't understand why something so cruel would be available. Ban them NOW!!! 27672017-08-01T09:32:53.27334196Theresa RoseThis is so cruel I am horrified that the people involved are not stuck to the ground themselves!27672017-08-01T09:40:11.79334197toni mcewanthis is 2017, why are such barbaric and cruel 'traps' still available? 27672017-08-01T14:12:42.6234199Vicki LloydsmithHumans never fail to shock and sicken me! We are the most primitive and horrible species on the planet!!27672017-08-01T15:34:29.3834200Ratree Petchphraprasert Cruelty 27672017-08-01T15:36:36.41334201Josephine AustinWhat horrendous cruelty, beggars belief that they are legal and definitely should be banned.27672017-08-01T22:14:31.51334202Rosemary EdeI can't believe these were ever allowed on the market, vile things and need to be banned immediately.27672017-08-02T12:55:02.3134203Peter KellyI would add that all party leaders must stand in a constituency seat and not sneak in the back door26532017-08-02T14:09:12.25334204Paul GriersonPerhaps the number of times one can stand on the list should also be examined....26532017-08-02T15:10:13.37734205George S GordonBeing able to use the list as an insurance policy does not seem ideal. However, the main issue for me is that list candidates cannot really be rejected by voters if the party keeps putting them forward. As it stands, voters don't really know who they will get from a party's list at the time of voting. I agree with the petitioner. Or perhaps there should be a limit on how many times a candidate should be allowed on a list.\r\nI'd also like to see electronic voting used, which would help stop confusion about how the AMS works by guiding the voters. I'd also use an electronic system to force voters to rank all the candidates in the local elections.26532017-08-02T15:37:44.48734206Fiona SinclairI have signed this petition on behalf of Autism Rights, whose campaigning work has resulted in the completion of a Scoping Exercise, with a view to a review of the Mental Health Act. We took a full part in this Scoping Exercise, and hope that the Scottish Government will commit to a review of the Act. We campaigned for several years to end the inclusion of people with Learning Disabilities and Autistic Spectrum Disorders within the provisions of the Mental Health Act. This effectively means that disabled people can be treated, simply for being disabled. A recent Mental Welfare Commission census found that 42% of men with a Learning Disability who are receiving forced treatment do NOT have a diagnosis of mental illness. With the additional problems of misdiagnosis of people on the autistic spectrum, there is a very great danger of the current legislation to people who are on the autistic spectrum. It also has to be said that, on the basis of the almost wholly industry funded research into mental health, that both the diagnostic structure of mental illness and medical necessity of the use of psychotropic drugs are extremely questionable.\r\n\r\nIt is grossly irresponsible, in the light of the evidence, to continue to force anyone, let alone the most vulnerable people, to take some of the most toxic drugs that are available.\r\n\r\nPlease refer to the Autism Rights website and to the articles written for Newsnet Scotland by myself, which I believe have persuaded the Scottish Government that change must happen.\r\n\r\nAutism and the madness of the Mental Health Act and We should face up to the madness of the Scottish mental health system\r\n28852017-08-02T18:22:33.9334207Kevin PedenI also believe some limit should be imposed on how many terms a list MSP can sit.26532017-08-03T01:54:56.72734208Thomas ValentineI believe that no person not directly elected should sit in parliament or present themselves as an elected politician. For each party a leader, deputy and maximum two party spokesmen should be elected under a party ticket. If they gain a percentage share of the vote but no constituencies the parliamentary votes should be cast by the party leader or deputy. No additional members should appointed because they have not gained the direct approval of the citizens to sit in parliament.\r\nI do not think individuals who have been repeatedly rejected by voters should bypass democracy through personal connections. It is a corruption of democracy.26532017-08-03T10:42:15.834209Anne MunnI agree that if a candidate is rejected on a constituency vote, it overturns the democratic will of the voters if they then can still gain a seat through the AMS. There was considerable outcry from Scottish parliamentarians when a defeated candidate at the recent general election was then given a seat in the House of Lords -- same thing? Numbers of MSPS should also fairly reflect percentage share of the vote26532017-08-04T09:13:18.0534210Anne AtkinsonI hope there can be changes made 28692017-08-04T20:11:37.04334211John MartinA modern day lime stick how are they legal?27672017-08-07T14:42:17.83334212Jon PrestonThese devices cause unnecessary suffering and should be banned immediately.27672017-08-07T22:44:06.63734213Christine HarmerGlue traps are hideous things and need to be banned everywhere.27672017-08-08T00:08:06.08734214Caroline Palmer Bird lime was outlawed years ago. How is this different?27672017-08-08T01:13:34.9134215Neil FergusonIn addition, list MSPs should not be allowed more than two list terms in total during their careers. Two terms should be enough to prove their utility to the electorate. After that, they should be required to stand as constituency MSPs. \r\n\r\nThis would also provide a steady flow of new MSPs and help prevent the Scottish Parliament from becoming a Westminster-style cosy club for time-serving Establishment members. 26532017-08-08T13:47:19.60734216Allan KingWe're asking other nations to stop this.....lead by example. ....so so cruel.....where's the RSPCA on this.....this is cruelty to animals !27672017-08-08T13:53:14.48334217Gus RoutledgeEntirely unnecessary bits of environmentally harmful stuff. No sound reason not to get rid of them. 27672017-08-08T14:12:59.66734218David HaighHorrible things the sooner they are banned for good the better 27672017-08-08T15:51:58.51334219Faith BorkowskyGood luck!!\r\n28692017-08-08T16:24:14.0134220Ian kirkIndiscriminate and inhumane. \r\n27672017-08-08T18:23:51.27734221Lyn LucasCruel and unnecessary 27672017-08-08T20:18:48.77734222SusanI can't believe that these have been allowed to become a "normal" item for sale in stores. Absolutely disgusting, and hope all countries ban them. There is no need for this method of trapping, especially when it's indiscriminate and catches so many other species that aren't "pests".27672017-08-08T20:39:08.16334223Richard Banham How can we criticise the horribly cruel Spanish practices when Scotland is at it !!!27672017-08-08T20:57:51.84734225Chris ThomasIndiscriminate and cruel. Ban them now.27672017-08-08T21:48:38.70334226Scott RogersGlue traps are an abhorrence. These devices have no place in a modern Scotland, or anywhere else for that matter. I strongly urge the Scottish Parliament to ban the sale and use of glue traps immediately.27672017-08-08T22:02:22.53334227Susan DownsThese traps must be banned. They inflict cruel and barbaric pain and are used to cause awful deaths to our precious wildlife. 27672017-08-09T08:50:59.17334228Ann BoydBan these cruel contraptions27672017-08-09T20:41:05.41334230Fiona freshneyHuman beings, a species with an unfortunate tendency to think up the most hideous ways for other animals and each other to die!27672017-08-10T13:36:33.6734231Carole NicholsonThis cruelty needs to stop NOW. Why on earth are they still being sold?27672017-08-10T13:52:21.3634232Steve georgeAbsolutely no need for such cruel things27672017-08-10T14:13:03.97334233Linda EllisPlease please ban these horrible products27672017-08-10T14:17:28.08334234Sylvia ForrestNo place for these cruel contraptions in a modern, forward-thinking Scotland.27672017-08-10T15:29:30.07734235Hazel HogganHorrendous way to die.27672017-08-10T15:41:22.6434236Bobby FlomerfeltBAN GLUE TRAPS EVERYWHERE GOD'S ANIMALS. OR MAMMALS WERE NOT GIVEIN TO US TO DESTROY27672017-08-10T15:43:09.04734237Sandra Pledger. Disgusting 27672017-08-10T15:56:44.56334238Jeff lockeshould be banned throuhout the uk27672017-08-10T15:59:43.17334239David RocheInhumane, unnecessary and completely indiscriminate. These should not be allowed anywhere27672017-08-10T16:24:12.43334240Phil Cunningham No difference between this and the illegal liming that goes on abroad27672017-08-10T18:21:29.23334241Helen RobertsPlease support this petition, this shouldn't be happening 27672017-08-10T18:45:42.7634242Caroline Farrow Why?!? Why use such an awful device that brings such pain and suffering? Ban glue traps!27672017-08-10T18:57:19.79334243Gary JohnsonBan this now.27672017-08-10T20:47:00.8434244monika olsenWith wildlife suffering soo much,just because of a few high paying persons can shoot grouse, it is not acceptable. Other birds and animals are important to keep natures balance in order. Entrappment and the cruelty involved..is NOT acceptable. Please stop this madness!!27672017-08-10T20:51:35.46334245monika olsenPlease stop these cruel and vile practices, its bad for the balance of nature. Hen harriers are so low in numbers now, its critical. Traps are to be banned please, they serve no purpose in todays society!27672017-08-10T21:19:39.9634246Sarah Williams These are the cruelest thing invented27672017-08-10T21:47:11.73734247Mike ArnoldBarbaric.27672017-08-10T22:07:12.5234248Jill MoshosI cannot believe these things are being used.\r\nThey are barbaric and must be banned. 27672017-08-11T06:46:06.9634249Michael CasingenaAwful things. Please ban them.27672017-08-11T08:00:30.46334250Debi mawby Stop these glue traps! 27672017-08-11T09:47:05.8934251Saul McIntyreHow something so cruel and indiscriminate can be freely sold is an outrage27672017-08-11T13:00:51.30734252Janine HulleyGlue traps are appallingly cruel and should be outlawed.27672017-08-11T13:52:17.27734253DerynThis is horrific & barbaric.\r\nNot only a ban on the use of this but the makers should also pay a hefty penalty 27672017-08-11T15:39:55.68734254ErnaHorrific cruelty27672017-08-11T15:59:47.15334255Mark StuartIt has to stop now, we need to do the decent thing and outlaw this awful, barbaric behaviour.27672017-08-11T18:38:14.50734256LYDIA REID My point is simple A company selling a vaccine wants to sell the vaccine\r\nOur children are just too precious to take their word for whether they are safe \r\nToo many are not and allow vaccines that may help the majority while harming quite profoundly a smaller amount of children\r\nWe need at least to look at the results of the research and maybe even do the research before use 29002017-08-11T18:50:27.4934257LYDIA REID My point is simple A company selling a vaccine wants to sell the vaccine\r\nOur children are just too precious to take their word for whether they are safe \r\nToo many are not and allow vaccines that may help the majority while harming quite profoundly a smaller amount of children\r\nWe need at least to look at the results of the research and maybe even do the research before use 29002017-08-11T19:00:48.99334258LYDIA REIDThese traps are cruel and unnecessary \r\nScotland should ban them 27672017-08-11T20:29:06.33334259MagsThese are as bad as snares, both horrific deaths for any animal. Even rats - they may be seen as vermin but such horrific traps ensure a painful death for them.27672017-08-11T21:45:56.98734261Barry Gale I agree that candidates who have not been elected should not be admitted to Parliament. I do not see why Regional MSPs cannot also be elected through explicit choice on the ballot paper.26532017-08-11T21:51:14.40734262sue jordanThey MUST be banned, what a terrible and cruel slow death for any creatures.27672017-08-12T06:15:29.50734263John Martin These traps are obviously cruel and indiscriminate 27672017-08-12T09:20:23.3434264Allan ChardA disgusting practise, it must be stopped.27672017-08-12T09:23:04.29334265Allan ChardA disgusting practise which must be stopped.27672017-08-12T10:24:54.1334266Lindsey PrescottBan these indiscriminate, cruel contraptions that cause a cruel, long and painful death. 27672017-08-12T15:37:55.81334267Julie KetleyThis is barbaric and upsetting and simply not acceptable.27672017-08-12T16:41:42.60334268Voirrey PaeslerGlue traps must be banned. 27672017-08-12T19:48:22.4934269w. leaThese glue traps are extremely cruel. Why should an animal have to suffer like this. They also catch non-target species so not effective. This is a horrible way for an animal to die and human beings should know better than to use them.27672017-08-12T23:02:05.40734270Philip HeathThese indiscriminate traps must be banned to stop innocent animals dying a long painful death.27672017-08-12T23:17:03.0834271Jean MorrisOur wildlife is suffering enough with all the killing 'legal' and illegally, this stuff needs to be banned now!!!!!!27672017-08-13T09:03:31.33734272Karen HaywoodGlue traps cause a slow and agonizing death to many creatures. They must be banned.27672017-08-13T22:32:02.2434273Jane FraserPlease ban these traps27672017-08-14T10:52:33.62734274JULIE CHRISTIE-GAMBLEI agree with the Petitioner 100%.\r\nThe system is allowing candidates to be elected to the Scottish Parliament by a collection of 2nd, 3rd, etc preference votes rather than votes for the candidate of their choice.\r\nIt is also allows Parties to manipulate 'The List' by ordering candidates, they know may not be elected as Constituency MSPs, to gain a seat.26532017-08-14T22:23:20.27734275Chris mcNaghtenWe need to respect our wildlife27672017-08-14T23:59:00.95334276Christine LloydOur country should have no part in such barbaric cruelty - must stop.27672017-08-15T04:40:46.87734277David WilliamsNo I'm not Scottish. But opposing animal cruelty should know no boundaries. 27672017-08-15T10:23:58.94334278Yvette ChoptyThis practice is incredibly cruel and mist be stopped. How would you like to be tortured until a slow death comes your way, with no way to free yourself?\r\nGive your tunnel-visioned head a shake!27672017-08-15T13:56:04.7434279Carl connPlease stop this indiscriminate barbaric practise.27672017-08-15T14:00:09.7234280Tim ReaPlease ban these products and save our wildlife27672017-08-16T10:54:05.0934281Marcella D'GamaDisgraceful27672017-08-16T16:08:22.75734282eileen flettno need for traps of this nature. They cause untold suffering and inflict this on our wildlife indiscriminately. Please take these out of circulation for the good of our wildlife.27672017-08-16T16:22:59.18734283Suzanne StormBarbaric glue traps, for goodness sake ban these. Do we never learn! 27672017-08-16T16:27:34.2234284martin austinCruel, this needs to be banned27672017-08-16T16:35:19.54334285monika olsenBan these horrendous glue boards!!!27672017-08-16T16:35:56.06334286Judy HallidayBarbaric and indiscriminate slaughter of anything that it catches. How can educated people use these27672017-08-16T16:41:09.11334287NatalieI can't believe such products are even being sold. Totally cruel & inhuman!27672017-08-16T16:41:15.81334288Sandra Williams There is no place fir this sort of barbarity 27672017-08-16T16:42:12.36334289Ceili Smyth-BatesHow can this barbaric trap be allowed?? It is so inhumane & cruel. What a way to these innocent animals to die! It needs to be banned ASAP!27672017-08-16T16:51:36.73334290Marina MarlerDon't allow innocent creatures to suffer in agony. Beautiful creatures being slowly killed by cruel glue traps. Get them banned. 27672017-08-16T16:53:09.48334291David WittThey cruel and should never be on sale so lets get rid of them know.27672017-08-16T17:13:53.9334292S Andrew Not enough wildlife left! To be indiscriminately killing like this! Barbaric! 27672017-08-16T17:24:49.33734293Michelle Jane brocklebank Please stop these glue traps they are heart breaking 27672017-08-16T17:25:22.02334294Anne Rice-JonesShameful that such indiscriminate death traps can be used. 27672017-08-16T17:33:47.9134295Kathryn Greaves indiscriminate barbaric practise.27672017-08-16T17:34:37.5134296sonia laurensAlready banned in several countries . Please do the same 27672017-08-16T17:39:46.91734297Kirsti mcintyreCan't think of a more inhumane way for indiscriminately killing animals. Who even patents these things? :-(27672017-08-16T17:41:56.47334298marlene thomas barbaric27672017-08-16T17:50:01.47334299Marina McClerryPlease ban these cruel glue traps that can lead t a slow death of many animals.27672017-08-16T17:59:54.14734300Sandy MacLennan Horrific!27672017-08-16T18:00:56.93734301JacquiThis is a despicable tragedy. It needs stopping NOW! 27672017-08-16T18:28:29.7334302Stephen BerryThe things companies do to make money leaves me speechless27672017-08-16T18:36:45.7334303KirstHow would you like it if you were starved to death and in the process the flesh ripped from your body as you tried to escape? Sick and twisted devices. Cruella DeVil would be proud...27672017-08-16T19:04:03.5734304Tracy MartinI'd love these to be banned throughout the whole of the UK - they're barbaric!27672017-08-16T19:08:54.4334305Debbie godingI cannot believe these are legal, totally horrific27672017-08-16T19:10:42.97734306Katie HallPlease ban these awful traps. It's clear that they cause a great deal of pain and suffering to any creature that becomes trapped. 27672017-08-16T19:11:06.634307T DaviesIt is unbelievable that something so abhorrently cruel is allowed to be sold in the UK. 27672017-08-16T19:11:12.91334308Debbie godingThese must be banned, they are Horrific 27672017-08-16T19:35:32.3434309Patricia cooperPlease stop this barbaric practice 27672017-08-16T19:38:02.88734310JohnCruel inhumane suffering contraptions, could the makers of this think of a slower way to kill our wildlife? ?27672017-08-16T20:05:06.02334311Kathy BerruAn absolutely barbaric thing to use, this cruel thing must be stopped, Its 2017 not 1656!!!27672017-08-16T20:08:21.534312Sue GriffinDreadful and shocking27672017-08-16T20:09:50.43734313John R. ChallisSave out wildlife 27672017-08-16T20:14:10.35334314Anne GregoryIndiscriminate cruel and barbaric and has no place in a civilised country.27672017-08-16T20:29:45.03334315Carol FrayneIt is so unnecessary to use these strips. They don't discriminate and it's a barbaric way for any animal or bird to die. These animals and birds suffer greatly and there's no need for this method of pest control.27672017-08-16T20:47:43.6334316Andy BarnettThis method is totally discriminatory.27672017-08-16T20:55:31.0734317Gillian jacksonThere is no place for these barbaric cruel traps in these modern times27672017-08-16T21:09:33.25334318Mairi MackenzieCan't believe anyone could find this acceptable. Soul destroying, horrific reflection of the human race.27672017-08-16T21:25:05.36334319pam stathamSo So Angry that these traps are being sold cannot believe people are buying them or shops selling them. hope they are banned soon.27672017-08-16T21:25:51.03734320pam stathamBan them27672017-08-16T21:35:48.7134321Nick DanielsThese traps are terrible and must be taken off the shelves now..!27672017-08-16T21:38:04.17734322Nick DanielsThese have to be taken off the shelves now..! 27672017-08-16T21:52:15.74734323Karen WithersGlue traps are barbaric27672017-08-16T21:54:54.79734324CindyTotally cruel and unnecessary 27672017-08-16T22:02:25.18734325THOMAS COUGHLANthis stuff is inhumane\r\n27672017-08-16T22:04:00.97734326Alison GardnerSo cruel to have animals die a slow death. Please ban the sale of glue traps. It's so barbaric27672017-08-16T22:29:49.22334327Beverley LoxtonCruel barbaric 27672017-08-16T22:44:16.94334328 Carol FraynePlease stop this barbaric way of killing pests! There really is no place in our world today for them to die a horrible death and products should not be used which capture other animals and birds. No animals or Birds need to die a slow painful agonizing death. Shame on those who still support this method. You need to stop! Thank you.27672017-08-16T22:45:19.8834329LydiaThese traps are completely inhumane, time to relegate them to history where they belong.27672017-08-16T22:45:23.25734330Mrs Alison NormanBarbaric method and indiscriminate 27672017-08-16T23:02:41.3234331Jane DykesSo very cruel. Sickening to think about it. 27672017-08-17T00:53:19.3234332Cheryl WeaverGlue traps should be banned they are cruel and barbaric, wildlife should be protected not killed.\r\n\r\n27672017-08-17T01:07:43.834333Cheryl WeaverGlue traps should be banned they are cruel and barbaric. Wildlife should be protected not killed.27672017-08-17T03:08:32.08334334Felicia WilliamsThis must be stopped 27672017-08-17T05:54:54.2334335Josephine WilsonGlue traps are very cruel and all sorts of creatures get stuck and die! No animal should die in this nasty, barbaric way!!27672017-08-17T06:01:09.234336Josephine WilsonGlue traps should be banned, they are cruel and indiscriminate. No animal deserves to die in such a nasty, barbaric way!27672017-08-17T06:30:50.7334337Beatrice BrinklerAnother disgusting hazard for wildlife , what genius thought this one up ? \r\n 27672017-08-17T07:09:21.4934338Andy Bridges Please ban theses products they are so cruel and the animals they trap suffer they are vile 27672017-08-17T07:40:48.66734339Kay KellyHow was this ever legal? 27672017-08-17T07:45:00.58734340Adam Samson These traps are indiscriminate and cruel, they need to be banned as soon as possible.27672017-08-17T08:49:06.06334341Valerie RawlinsonI am horrified that such a progressive nation as Scotland allow these tortuous traps.27672017-08-17T09:21:53.7934342Stuart Williams A disgusting product that should have no place in any country 27672017-08-17T09:43:24.24734343Viola KimmelDisgraceful that such glue traps are for sale.27672017-08-17T10:25:58.01334344Fiona TrappeThe links to share the petition are not active27672017-08-17T10:38:59.2734345Cilla MillnerCruel and unnecessary 27672017-08-17T11:09:20.39334346Mhairi MathesonUnbelievably cruel and indiscriminate.27672017-08-17T11:55:30.07334347Jane PayneThese are so indiscriminate and can cause so much suffering27672017-08-17T12:17:41.89334348sue smithplease ban these products and stop this barbaric practice forever27672017-08-17T12:19:14.84734349Mary BainI have seen the most sickening images of non target species caught on these abominable things. They should be illegal.\r\n27672017-08-17T13:19:40.33334351Kathleen gibson This shocked me Scotland come on Scotland this is shocking27672017-08-17T16:02:07.4234352Donella Duffjust another vile inhumane trap, which causes so much suffering!27672017-08-17T16:07:10.2234353Paula ToogoodCruel and cause suffering that can be avoided 27672017-08-17T16:16:10.40734354Muir Houstonthis cruelty has to stop!27672017-08-17T17:26:01.0934355Julie Dawson Please ban this, its inhumane, and vile...27672017-08-17T18:27:53.15734356Emma partonPlease ban 27672017-08-17T18:48:36.33734357Corinna SmartPlease ban these product they are too harmful to wildlife. 27672017-08-17T19:08:02.52334358FrankExtremely disgusting cruelty to whatever is trapped please ban them.\r\n 27672017-08-17T19:18:54.96734359Julie This is barbaric!! All the poor creatures getting stuck to it and perish !!! Why is this allowed?? Disgusting !!27672017-08-17T20:47:24.7134360Gwen PHILLIPSHorrific and disgraceful. These traps must be banned.27672017-08-17T21:47:44.6734361Judy WallisTo allow creatures to die a slow and painful death is inhumane.27672017-08-17T22:53:17.77334362Helen MasonAbsolutely shocked that this kind of practice is legal and free to any person to do, unbelievable, so where does that leave the legislation that is supposed to make it illegal to kill or maim most species of birds and hedgehogs for instance? 27672017-08-17T22:54:13.434363Denise LiebmannThese must be banned everywhere!27672017-08-18T07:26:15.48734364Diane JonesPlease ban these products and save our wildlife from such a cruel slow death !27672017-08-18T08:06:04.2234365June BroxsonThis contraption is so cruel to all our wildlife and should be banned immediately.27672017-08-18T11:49:51.06334366Mary BartlettThis is a dreadful thing to do to the poor wildlife, please put a stop to it...27672017-08-18T13:31:17.99734367Thomas MathiesonThis is barbaric and indiscriminate killing. Ban them, please.27672017-08-18T14:00:56.9734368J T alexander Constituency or list one or another not allowed to stand on both.26532017-08-18T14:31:13.48334369Rosanna BradleyThese traps are horrible! enough said.27672017-08-18T17:21:56.5634371Ann ForbesAgree with first comment .26532017-08-18T17:50:46.89334372lis buggThese need BANNING - no animal deserves this27672017-08-18T18:04:02.28334373Tom ForbesThere should be no list candidates26532017-08-18T20:06:16.634374Wendy Prince If you ever heard a rat screaming in agony as it tries to chew off it's own feet in an attempt to free itself from a glue trap you will know why the sale and use of these things should be prohibited. 27672017-08-18T20:42:49.91734375PaulI can't believe these horrendous things exist. And that someone out there is content to makes money from all this suffering. I hope they reap what they sow.27672017-08-18T20:48:04.1534376Philip BeggPlease help us stop this horrific business it's simply cruel 27672017-08-19T09:16:33.55334379Caroline HunterCruel & indiscriminate27672017-08-19T11:26:13.7634380TracyThese are cruel, barbaric killing traps which endanger everything from a tiny vole to owls, cats, frogs tee, etc. All life is precious, so why treat it like this27672017-08-19T11:40:28.80734381Caroline WellsThese things are monstrous instruments of torture and should never have been invented. 27672017-08-19T12:06:46.04334382Jacqueline Barnett Awful cruel products, leaving animals to die a slow horrible death,we are better than this27672017-08-19T12:10:09.79334383Jennifer GodsmanThis is not acceptable. Nor are those horrendous metal traps. Both should be banned immediately. 27672017-08-19T12:13:48.07734384Kate FisherI am appalled to hear traps that can inflict such a slow painful death to wildlife are accessible to the general public where they can fall into the wrong hands and be used to inflict intolerable cruelty on wildlife. Clearly the act of doing so is illegal. So why on earth are thes traps freely available? 27672017-08-19T12:39:07.00734385Julie BanksInhumane and unnecessary 27672017-08-19T13:15:54.55734386Yvonne WatsonHorrid27672017-08-19T14:54:19.05334387Karl busseyYet again, man inventing something that gets\r\n 'rid of pests ' when all in all it is man who will ruin the world we live in !!27672017-08-19T15:41:43.6434388Jeff ClarkeRegulate the use of these traps properly. Preferably ban them.27672017-08-19T18:54:58.52734389Suzanne Barbaric ! 27672017-08-19T20:06:00.6134390Jennifer ButlerThe pain and suffering these ghastly traps would inflict cannot be justified on any terms. The sale of these is outrageous and must be stopped immediately. Please will the Scottish government take action by banning their use and imposing heavy penalties on anyone caught using these.27672017-08-19T20:52:42.54334391Cara MolloyUnnecessary cruelty for an already declining wildlife population.27672017-08-19T20:55:45.5934392Cara MolloyUnnecessary cruelty for an already declining wildlife population!27672017-08-19T22:38:03.24334393GailWhoever thought up this awful scheme to kill animals, birds, insects indiscriminately must've a sadist, as well as the committtee who passes it. Please stop this at once.27672017-08-19T23:22:11.35734394Paul CoombesBan immediately please ..... wrong in so many ways!!! 27672017-08-20T12:58:28.1334395Christina StockwellTo my mind it is obvious that this horrendous trap would catch any small creature, and I cannot understand why any manufacturer would think it was a good idea. They need to be banned, there are lots of humane traps available, or call in pest control. Please let's stop this cruelty27672017-08-20T22:08:32.91734396KatieThese are a vile contraption. No reason to have these for sale. A form of torture and a slow unneeded death27672017-08-20T23:21:13.4134397Katherine andrew Disgusting 27672017-08-21T07:23:39.74334398Jennifer PunterWhat a cruel product that results in horrific suffering! Ban it immediately!!!27672017-08-21T13:38:51.83334399carol its disgusting \r\n27672017-08-21T14:06:14.75734400Leah As if I thought the human race couldn't get any lower. This is vile. Do we need to loose 99% of wildlife before we realise that everything lives for a reason and has its own place in the eco system?! 27672017-08-21T14:07:54.2134401pete holmesHOW CRUEL IS THIS27672017-08-21T14:23:18.934402Tony smithLet's not let greed keep these beautiful animals suffer this way any more27672017-08-21T14:24:17.80734403SueLowest level of human cruelty 27672017-08-21T15:03:04.45334404julie mcquillanVery Cruel and inhumane27672017-08-21T15:44:02.80334405Diana BilneyI can't believe in 2017 and in this country this is legal. I'm ashamed to be English. :'( 27672017-08-21T17:23:13.69334407LOEUIL REGINE I love all animals and sign petitions for their protection and also Wildlife .27672017-08-21T17:32:23.14734408David BredenBarbaric, needlessly cruel27672017-08-21T17:35:10.67334409Ginette SNELL I am against any kind of cruelty.27672017-08-21T17:40:36.4634410Terry E OliverPlease ban the use of these barbaric archaic & very cruel clue traps. We the human race need to life more at one with nature & wildlife.\r\nThank you. 27672017-08-21T17:46:03.8234411Marie toddHow much lower can the human race go?27672017-08-21T17:50:38.48734412Jacqueline Abbott So inhumane.27672017-08-21T18:55:42.2534413Eunice JohnstonThese things are beyond horrific. What kind of mind came up with this? 27672017-08-21T19:40:54.2434414Barbara EllenThese traps are too cruel for ANY kind of wildlife. It's hard to grasp that they are still allowed. Please outlaw them immediately. 27672017-08-21T23:21:37.98734415Susan HydesVery cruel27672017-08-22T00:17:56.30734416Jordan dyeAnimal cruelty 27672017-08-22T01:01:51.43734417Dawn Smith These are incredibly cruel and dangerous to wildlife and domestic animals too.27672017-08-22T02:03:51.66334418KelseyJust disgusted how in 2017 we still have these things!! They need banning!! 27672017-08-22T10:51:44.28334419Heidi Anna SalicitesHelp ban the cruel use of glue traps!!!!! this is NOT HUMAN!!!\r\n27672017-08-22T18:51:11.734420Michele DashwoodI had words with one of my local shops as he insisted on selling glue traps! I politely made it known to the shop owner and everyone else in that shop what I thought of glue traps and people who sold them and that I would never return to that shop again if he continued to sell them. I hope they did the same. Disgusting things should be banned x27672017-08-23T00:04:14.2234421Paul AlbrechtsenWe're suppose to be a nation of animal lovers, this is a joke, ban it!27672017-08-23T00:20:31.06734422Trevor Gibson-PooleBarbaric!\r\n27672017-08-23T01:15:26.27734423SandraThis is horrid :( there are other more humane ways to deal with pests or unwanted animals just ban this PLEASE !! I've worked in charities that help and protect animals from this cruelty..27672017-08-23T01:15:27.32334424SandraThis is horrid :( there are other more humane ways to deal with pests or unwanted animals just ban this PLEASE !! I've worked in charities that help and protect animals from this cruelty..27672017-08-23T06:53:46.04334425Phil WoodHorrific means of being cruel to defenceless animals get rid of now please.27672017-08-23T20:11:17.99334426Caroline Woodman-McGuiganPlease stop this....27672017-08-24T09:57:42.81334427DanielleIt's wrong to harm animals in that way. I'm not veggie or vegan but I still care about animals and they should not be harmed like that!27672017-08-24T16:21:13.91334428LukeVile things how anyone can make these is beyond me!27672017-08-25T16:07:17.33334429Kate BlairThere is no excuse for the production and use of such inhumane traps 27672017-08-26T14:15:43.54734430Zoe BSo inhumane. Should already be banned! 27672017-08-26T17:46:56.87334431T minnsThis is Dreadful. How more inhuman could it be27672017-08-28T10:34:30.41734432Will TonerThe use of these traps is cruel please ban them.27672017-08-28T11:10:21.59334434Terry Barlow Candidates should be limited with one choice Constituency or List26532017-08-28T15:12:29.12734435Myra BrodieWe need a country run by the people we vote for, not the also rans 26532017-08-28T15:24:11.91734436Charles McKinleyThis a backdoor for failed politicians within a party clique to keep a job26532017-08-28T22:35:50.05734447Lesley RussellAll traps should be banned. Please ban these awful things. 27672017-08-29T00:27:02.81734449Scarlett Ohara BAN !!!!27672017-08-29T01:19:06.51734450Barbara Le-TallecWhen is all this cruelty going to stop! These traps must be banned. The suffering these poor creatures must have gone through is horrendous.27672017-08-29T22:07:56.36734451Victoria mchugh Please stop this horrific cruel act on animals, absolutely barbaric 27672017-08-31T10:13:42.59334452Alexandra Francis Inhumane and not necessary! Needs banning, it is endangering protected wildlife and house pets and also it's a painful and a slow death for rodents and any animal that becomes stuck! Ban ban ban 27672017-08-31T23:23:34.26734453Rachael Brown An unacceptable form of pest control, causing unnecessary suffering. Technically a crime but for some reason legal? This needs changing.27672017-08-31T23:30:36.6734454Mia SewellThese are barbaric and inhumane27672017-08-31T23:53:56.50334455Catherine lloydBeyond cruel. This must be stopped immediately.27672017-09-01T01:05:29.49734456Juliette EllisGlue traps are inhumane and should be banned.27672017-09-01T01:06:36.5934457Juliette EllisGlue traps are inhumane and should be banned.27672017-09-01T01:23:11.65734458Georga Absolutely vile disgusting way to trap wildlife, has to be banned immediately! 27672017-09-01T01:57:41.5234459Jackie BaxterWhat an horrific way to die - so inhumane! These have to be banned now.27672017-09-01T03:05:36.57734460Linda ClearyBarbaric27672017-09-01T06:17:44.44734461Penelope BeniansI can't beleive the cruelty of this practice.27672017-09-01T08:45:50.36734462Mark StevensThis kind of thing would have been appalling in the nineteenth century, never mind today. Show some humanity and ban glue traps.27672017-09-01T08:48:05.77334463Richard Boon Cruelly on humane and pointless27672017-09-01T08:49:00.5634464ElidhI am appalled that Scotland, of all countries allows such barbaric practices.27672017-09-01T09:23:48.734465Lisa CunninghamHow would humans feel being stuck dying a slow painful death panicking no way of escape. Why should innocent animals suffer at the hands of humans who have taken over the planet.27672017-09-01T09:57:13.98734466Mrs S Kimmhow barbaric , all these poor animals whats wrong with people . this must stop 27672017-09-01T10:22:59.3834467Jen NelsonI have seen these horrible things in action, when we lived overseas, they are incredibly cruel and inhumane...this has to stop.27672017-09-01T10:43:48.19334468Anne Toddwhy would this not be banned? absolutely cruel and unnecessary. ban it now.27672017-09-01T10:44:33.41334469Mary WilsonIf the manufacturers of these evils aren't aware of the cruelty potential in their products, they should be MADE aware, if they DO know, they should be shamed into abandoning them,and their 'products' should be boycotted by Society.27672017-09-01T13:29:47.3134470lynn watretSo many UK endangered species get caught in these like bats, slow worms natterjack toads etc, they need banned, doing more harm than good definitely not humane traps!27672017-09-01T14:50:49.5334471Rebecca I can't imagine what they go through stuck to this. Makes me want to cry! 27672017-09-01T17:41:28.17334472DS CaseyThese awful things have no place in the world.27672017-09-01T19:38:11.0634473Sylvia JacksonThis is a cruel method and it needs to be banned, it is inhumane and prolongs suffering.27672017-09-01T20:13:36.2134474Lynda Evans This method is so cruel .We should not be killing any animal just because we can .Where has all the compassion & empathy gone .UK is supposed to be an island of animal lovers .Looking at some of the terrible things done to them I'm finding it hard to believe .27672017-09-03T17:41:37.66334475Reynolds Please sign, we need to stop these horrible traps, they are so cruel.27672017-09-03T18:34:37.09734476Nick HughesI cannot believe such a product is allowed in the marketplace in the first place.Horrific !27672017-09-03T18:52:02.7234477CarleyDisgusting, humans are vile 27672017-09-03T20:01:08.434478Jacqueline Smith Don't see the point to glue traps.cruel & barbari27672017-09-03T21:09:05.2934479Lynsey Barbaric they need to be banned 27672017-09-03T21:17:45.08334480HeatherWe are above this as a nation. These traps are medieval.27672017-09-03T21:17:57.8434481Kayleigh This needs to stop its barbaric 27672017-09-03T21:32:41.72734482TThese glue traps are inhumane and indiscriminate ban them for good .27672017-09-04T06:56:43.53734483Gillian SneddenWhat a hideous and inhumane way to die. Please stop torturing animals in this way.27672017-09-04T08:12:12.23334484AngelaHorrific and barbaric. This is the 21st century isn't it?27672017-09-04T08:52:57.75734485Pete BurginCatching all types of creatures in this way is obscene.27672017-09-04T11:47:39.5934486liz KnoxAbsolutely disgusting. What else can I say. The mentality of the people thinking up these cruel traps is beyond me.27672017-09-04T15:50:59.83334487Lisa Travis Enough exploitation causing terrible suffering to animals!!!!!!27672017-09-04T19:43:51.1634488Hazel MilliganThese must be banned and soon to stop more innocent animals from suffering! 27672017-09-04T20:48:57.65334489Delicia BurnellPlease stop this.27672017-09-04T20:50:26.29334490Lynne MilesAll sorts of animals are getting caught in these traps. They really are cruel and should be banned.27672017-09-04T21:36:38.23734491Jackie WhitePlease do the right and noble thing....ban these barbaric trapping methods.27672017-09-04T22:42:08.18334492Alison ReesNo justification for these.27672017-09-05T12:48:43.0134493Barbara Irvine My child who was aged 7 was taken from me by SW due to his behaviour at this time he was undiagnosed ASD and PDA. He was placed in a residential unit some miles from home and I was told if I didn't put him back he got home once when he ran away or theybwoukd take my other 2 older children who have no issues from me. Chikdrens hearing they were going to place him out of area and I was actively seeking help from all agencies to help my child and my family get an assessment. Which at that point was being blamed on my parenting. We then had a CSO hanging over our heads for over a year and when we had it taken off of us the first severe meltdown he had the SW said damn we no longer have the CSO. I continually have my child being placed out of area hanging over me. 29172017-09-05T15:03:05.74734494Maggie MellonI am a qualified and registered social worker. I know that there is much good work which goes on which is appreciated by children and by parents, but I have become aware of serious lack of recognition of the rights of parents and of children and of lack of accountability for actions taken which damage children. Risk aversion permeates the system, but does not include recognition of the huge risks of removal without good evidence. Children may be removed from home on a 'temporary' basis and without grounds having been accepted or proved for many months. this is very much 'verdict first , trial afterwards' for the children and their parents. the use of risk of emotional abuse as a reason for the removal of children is increasing and is a very subjective and difficult judgement. The rate of removal of children in Scotland is higher than in any other country of the UK. We need to ask if the children's hearings are qualified to make the decisions that they do, and that there are insufficient legal safeguards. Therefore I support the need for an enquiry. I know that other social workers share my views, and would like to present evidence with them and also from parents about their experiences to the Committee29172017-09-05T15:05:43.0634495Maggie MellonI agree that there are serious grounds for concern about procedures as currently operating, and about the legal safeguards for children and parents within the current framework. I would like to give evidence to the Committee along with other social workers who I know share these views, and also evidence from parents about their experiences and those of their children.29172017-09-05T16:05:50.16734496Pauline McMullanSome mothers with mental health problems are treated like they are criminals by Social work there is a complete lack of understanding. they are too quick too remove a child without offering suitable support not caring the short and long term damage they are doing to the child or the parent. In meetings they have often made up there mind about a situation before you even go into the meeting. I am a Gran who reguarly looks after my grandaughter through a court order and Social work always take the side of the father even though they dont know and dont care enough of the full story and I feel I am treated like a criminal for having an opinion. i am given no support whatsoever for this role.29172017-09-05T18:13:52.35734498Beth MorrisonI think this is a worthwhile petition and cause\r\nChild Protection in Scotland appears to focus on the family as if there is no other form of child abuse happening outwith the family home. We have GIRFEC and The SHANARRI well being wheel which measures outcomes. We also have The Named Person and the sole focus is on what is going on within families. However if there is an allegation against a professional whether that is about an incident happening in a school or any other council or government operated service, there is rarely ever any accountability. Child abuse is Child abuse, no matter where it happens or who is the alleged perpetrator. If an IRD is held and a family member is the accused then the family have no representation. Instead, it is health, education, social work and Police who meet and make all the decisions, the family are locked out. You try and accuse a teacher for example, of abusing your child you are still locked out of the IRD process often without any statements from the family being taken by Police or Social Services. Yet Education will still be represented and things just don't seem to go any further. Why is that? its all wrong. Abuse doesn't always happen in the family home.29172017-09-05T20:00:09.23334499Jane Lindsay The most vulnerable children in our society deserve proper and fair treatment to date we are a long way off protecting them. Therefore an urgent review is needed29172017-09-05T21:08:23.77334500Karen Mckeown Service has to start support parents not putting more obstacles in there way. 29172017-09-05T22:14:29.92334501 Patricia HewittI wholeheartedly agree with every aspect of the Petition . I am another parent with ASD - PDA children who the system has totally failed . It was myself a parent who recognised ASD issues where so many Professionals failed us . My children have been denied an Education and Childhood , not one of the Autism Stratagies in place has been effective . The Scottish Autism Strategy , GIRFEC , Education Laws , early intervention , not worth the paper they are written on . I was abandoned by my SW , she was very nice but totally clueless on Autism Spectrum . Because my eldest son could not engage with an Autism Charity we were told there was nothing further they could offer . My parentening skills were questioned , I was offered Parentening Classes . One child was handcuffed by Police after a meltdown . Yet after one meltdown the only people who would help were the Police and Ambulance Service . CAMHS didn't want to know , SW on call fobbed us of to GP following morning . Some of my PDA friends have had children removed or threatened by unprofessional SW or the Children's Panel . Parental blame is rife , we do an amazing job with so few resources . Hence as Main Petitioner the Petition PEO1625 evolved . We need to raise awareness of PDA and get the recognition and support to parents and their children . As I said in our Petition " The only system that works effectively in Scotland is the System to cover up the truth " .\r\nNamed Person should be abandoned , it is unworkable . We need a system that works to keep families together and provide support we desperately require .\r\nOne of my children , a very intelligent young man will spend his life on benefits , the other due to an inspirational team at Edinburgh College is now doing a HND Music course using PDA Stratagies , the first student to do so .\r\nI can't afford a QC to fight the system when people act totally unprofessional and are dishonest.\r\nEnough is enough .Parental blame must stop NOW29172017-09-06T08:15:05.2734502Charles Rose Deff agree this needs to be done 29172017-09-06T11:14:32.73334504Gill StewartSome child.protection officers have been overzealous recently without gathering truthful information. Families have been unnecessarily torn apart and this needs to be addressed. I understand the importance of putting the child first but not on misinformation and not at the expense of the whole family.29172017-09-06T22:05:28.1634505A. KellyThis scenario is playing out across the UK. There is appalling targeting of special needs families by social services. Zero understanding of autism, tick-box mentality which is damaging and harmful, disability discrimination against autistic mothers. Families ripped apart for no reason. Even when they don't ask for support, they are targeted just for fulfilling their parenting duties regarding EHCPs (England). LAs break the law routinely. Families traumatised, schools can do no wrong but parents falsely accused for sniffing the wrong way. It has to change. The public monies being spent on this travesty, the damage to people, the resources taken away from actually abused children by misusing it on innocent families is disgusting.29172017-09-07T16:33:17.69734506Colin YoungThe safety of the child is paramount and a much more robust, consistent and honest method must be found for gathering all the evidence before demonising parents and shattering the trust between parents and children - once it has been destroyed it can never be fully re-established and everyone suffers as a consequence. The time has come when this whole area of child protection requires to be reviewed and radical changes made as soon as possible.29172017-09-08T07:39:42.17734507Janet WilsonI offer my full support to this petition. My children have been subject to Child Protection Plans for two years and both sons have had virtually no meaningful education during this time. My family has been broken by the system, my husband (who has AS) is now homeless and lives as a guest at a friend's house and my eldest is in a residential unit for people with mental health issues. My youngest is isolated. These are not good outcomes for any Child Protection case.\r\n\r\nThe family's needs with respect to autism and related issues, have been sadly overlooked.29172017-09-08T09:23:11.90734508Anne SpeakeI witnessed an incident when 2 young children were taken from their beds at midnight. Even though the Police and Social Worker were very compassionate, this should never had happened. When the parent and grandparent got very upset as any one would, later on they were considered to be very aggressive. Both of these people were very loving and wanted to do what was best for the child.\r\nBoth children in my opinion, have additional support needs that have been unrecognised. I have worked with Pre School Children with Special Needs for 30 years. This must not continue as it is, otherwise these children will be a lost generation.29172017-09-08T18:24:42.10734509Barry Gale I do not have experience of child protection, but I do have experience of adult protection. The system is not the same, but the attitude of social workers and the Scottish Courts is the same. My mother with dementia was locked up in hospital for the last two years of her life and died there. Our family life together was destroyed. She had been well looked after by me and wanted to remain in my care, but social workers and their psychiatric colleages insintuated that I had ill-treated her and placed her life at risk. Although there was a hearing of evidence, the Sheriff ignored what she did not agree with and awarded Guardianship to the social workers against my mother's wishes.. \r\n\r\nI agree with the petitioner that judicial decisions are made on the basis of the opinions of medical and social workers, and not on the basis of evidence and the law. The burden of proof is placed on the accused. When I defended myself the Sheriff accused me of being self-serving. \r\n\r\nI have no reason to believe the system is any fairer in child protection. This needs to change. 29172017-09-09T13:06:26.55334510Derek CunninghamAbout time. See are a total disgrace the way they treat decent families... I could name and shame the social workers who removed a child from his family for disagreeing with social worker... The corrupt egomaniac social worker told the parent. 'You have had your child removed for your attitude to authority and for disagreeing with policies'.. My family have personal experience of this corruption and ill treatments and misinformation and disinformation provided by egomaniacal social workers. 29172017-09-09T13:21:03.2634511ANNE GREIG Having been through this Shambolic System fortunately we, my daughter and I came out the other side eventually others were not so lucky My daughter was awarded criminal injuries in Scotland\r\nWe moved to england and the whole thing started again with protection officers in Scotland driving it behind the scenes It took four years in the high court in London to eventually to stop the madness this petition is necessary to review the whole system is totally useless on every level and needs to be overhauled and those in charge made accountable29172017-09-10T18:22:15.24734512James A MackiePanel members of a Children's Hearing are volunteers The only training they get is the States idea of protecting children Faced on the day and asked to make a snap decision on a document giving a social workers opinion with absolutely no resort to having to give evidence to prove the allegations Children's Hearings have the power to remove children from families for anywhere between 12 months and a life time In a child death families get counselling and support allowing them to come to terms with the event For those families were the child is taken by the State especially where the child is then force adopted families have no closure or support. Many parents ended up with serious illnesses including diabetes, depression and heart attacks brought on by the system Many children who were forcibly adopted against their family wishes suffer severe trauma in later life when they eventually discover the State took them from their natural parents and put them up for adoption An article that appeared recently should be borne in mind by all in child protection Dirty dishes prove I feed my family A full trash can proves I clean up after them Messy floors means I let my children have fun A pile of unfolded laundry means I keep my family in clean clothes A wet bathroom floor means my kids took a shower. To social workers next time you walk into my house and see a mess think twice before you judge us If you came over to see us come on in If you are coming over to see my house, please make an appointment29172017-09-10T18:28:54.90334513James A MackieIn newspaper articles Government spokesperson said We have recently refined the system to keep it fit for the future The Scottish Parliament concluded a review of the Children's Hearing system reforms of 2013 and concluded the modernised system is working well. The families want to know who led the review, what the remit was Who were contacted and took part Were parents, families and even children interviewed or asked to contribute Government should be looking at the statistics 1.5 per cent of children in Scotland are in the child protection system, 0.38 per cent at home 0.557% in foster care or up for adoption 0.4 per cent in other community placement and 0.148 per cent in residential care In 2016 0.46 per cent of children aged four and under were on the child protection register 102 unborn children were on the register In 2015 16 6683 children were in care With a daily cost of £160.00 per child day the £390 million could be better spent helping parents and families keep their children at home There are bad families where the children will be safer in care However, the system accuses every family of being bad parents and children will be better off removed to another place of residency 29172017-09-10T18:36:37.74734514James A MackiePublished statistics 23 per cent of the adult prison population have been in care 25 per cent on the street have a care background Care leavers are 4 or 5 times more likely to commit suicide in adulthood 25 per cent of care leavers were pregnant within a year of leaving care 36 per cent of 19 year olds looked after at the age 16 were unemployment not in education or training Still Our Children Briefing for House of Commons Report Stage of the Children and Families Bill 2013 A study of 15 and 16 year olds under CSOs published by the Scottish Childrens Reporters Administration shows women had 30 per cent physical health issues and 60 per cent mental health problems 20 per cent had both mental and physical health problems 8 per cent of men had physical health problems and 32 per cent mental health problems 81 per cent of young people had problems with education 40 per cent of women had used drugs and 43 per cent alcohol 36 per cent of men had used drugs and 23 per cent alcohol 60 per cent of young women were victims of sexual or physical abuse 35 per cent victims of sexual abuse or offences 37 per cent victims of physical abuse or assaults and 18 per cent had been physically and sexually abused 26 per cent of young men had been victims of physical abuse or assault29172017-09-11T11:08:28.24734515Pauline McwalterI am signing this petition as this wholr system needs a hugh overhaul. Parents of kids with asn could and can fall victim to the current practices just because they require support to bring up societies most vulnerable children. I also very nearly ended up there my self because of my daughters needs 29172017-09-11T12:24:12.49334516W. Hunter WatsonI am most concerned that the evidence is not properly tested before a child is removed from his or her parents. A few high profile cases demonstrate that there are instances where it would have been in a child's best interests to have been removed from the parental home. However, in general children do not do well if they are put into care and that is something to be avoided wherever possible.29172017-09-11T12:46:38.5134517sarah Malone everyone stand as one againt social work 29172017-09-13T08:18:41.15734518Ian DunnI am particularly concerned for the small bird and mammal population as well as the security of the native wild cat conservation programme. This approach has been implemented in other countries in europe to similar ends.28832017-09-13T09:44:07.12734519Gabriela PenicheThe system of pet neutering and registration similar to the Australian one can bring a multitude of benefits. Having a pet equates to a lot of responsibility and just as dog owners are expected to have dogs under control not causing nuisance to neighbours or the public, and to some extent have a grip on unwanted litters, there are similar things that can be achieved with the domestic cat population. Cats roam around on their own and as pet owners we can't control what they hunt, or where they go, but we should be able to control the damage they can cause to the environment. By neutering them we help the wild cat population and limit the number of homeless unwanted domestic cat litters. \r\nBreeding animals should be a responsible act and a breeding licence would help with standards and welfare.28832017-09-13T09:47:19.01334520Allan Bantick OBEFor wildcats to retain a viable population in Scotland it is essential that the flow of fertile domestic into the wild is stopped. Domestic cat owners can contribute hugely to efforts by Scottish Wildcat Action to save the wildcat by having their cats neutered. Even better, they should have their cats micro-chipped and vaccinated at the same time.28832017-09-13T16:18:02.5934521Alice BaconAs a general practice vet I am only too aware of the feral cat population crisis and the health problems associated with this. Also, with an MSc in conservation vet medicine I am very aware of the ecological consequences of high feral cat population density, including the near extinction of the Scottish wildcat. Mandatory neutering all of pet cats with outdoor access would be a huge step towards taking responsibility for the impact of our pet cats, and improving the health and welfare of both pet and feral cats.28832017-09-13T16:56:29.98334522Dr Keri LangridgeI trap feral cats for neuter and release in both a professional capacity (as a Project Officer for Scottish Wildcat Action) and as a volunteer for my local Cats Protection branch. Once you start looking, you find that feral cats are everywhere. Their welfare standards are often very poor, particularly in large colonies. Disease can be rampant. There is an endless cycle of tiny young females struggling to cope with yet another litter of kittens, most of which will die through exposure, starvation, or predation. It is heartbreaking. TNR (Trap Neuter Return) can be an effective method of feral cat control, but it will only be effective in the long-term if we turn off the tap and stop the influx of cats into the countryside. And there is a very simple solution that is best for everyone - best for the cat, best for the owner, best for the countryside, best for wildcats, best for feline welfare everywhere, and best for all the charities that spend all their time and money and manpower endlessly neutering and trapping and rehoming. The very simplest argument I think you can make is that up until this point, for decades and decades, animal welfare charities have poured their resources into campaigning and educating the public to make the right decision themselves, i.e. they have to convince people and rely on attitude and behavior change. They have undoubtedly had a huge impact - and yet we still have this huge problem. There is a percentage of the population that you never reach. And so neutering should be compulsory, because it NOT being compulsory clearly isn't working. So lets give it a try! And if micro-chipping were also compulsory, it would make it far easier for anyone conducting TNR to determine whether a cat is owned or not. So even if it would be difficult to enforce, it would make Trap Neuter Return far more efficient and be an invaluable tool for those trying to work to reduce feral cats in the countryside.28832017-09-13T18:39:24.72334523Professor Brendan CorcoranI support this petition fully. It is in fact the exception not the rule that most cat owners elect to neuter their cats simply to avoid the inconvenience of having unneutered cats in their home. It makes perfect sense to extend to all cats not intended for breeding. The larger picture in Scotland would be to protect the wild cat population. It is remiss of us in the developed countries to criticise those in poorer countries for failing to protect their large cat populations if we can't even act to protect our own. The Scottish wild cat is as important as any of the large wild cats to biology and conservation and in fact is under greater threat than many of the iconic big cats that so engage with the public imagination. If we fail to save the Scottish wild cat, we cannot then complain of the threat of loss of threaten cat species elsewhere in the world.28832017-09-13T19:07:08.0834524Liz RollinsonNeutering pet cats will limit the number of unwanted litters of kittens and minimise the suffering of animals with poor health and nutrition. It will also safeguard the future of the iconic Highland Tiger!28832017-09-13T19:29:58.9934525Shirley Simpsonplease protect Scottish Wildcats28832017-09-13T21:41:02.10734526Louise MaloneIt is rong moraliy and impartially needing a over hall as the hall system it out Date and as a parent my self and have gone throw it all my self is horrible thay mack u feel like your a prisner and it all you and nevr the dad ect but pepel need to know how your kids name person is for the day find out ir having a kids ect .29172017-09-14T07:21:47.1134527Anne MacInnes It is vital that the domestic cat population is controlled to ensure the survival of wildcats, and help the numbers of wild birds that are currently being decimated 28832017-09-15T18:41:11.52334528G. McNeishVery outdated system, overworked social workers with too much control29172017-09-17T16:39:06.54334530Sir John Lister-KayeThis parliamentary action is long overdue and a vital adjunct to Scottish Wildcat Actions efforts. Cats are out of control in Scotland and we need to act now. 28832017-09-17T21:15:53.09334531John MacleodI agree that the child protection system and the actions of the authorities needs to be reviewed. Far too often child protection procedures are being implemented on the basis of suspicion and innuendo, and sometimes false information, without the evidence being tested in law. I have been ninvolved in supporting a family that have been at the receiving end of such actions for over 4 years now and the process still continues. It seems that it will not come to and end until the youngest child reaches adult age. Many procedures and conditions are being enforced on a voluntary basis under threat of seeking statutory requirements that would involve putting children in foster care. An independent inquiry is urgently needed. 29172017-09-18T08:32:43.11734532Edmund PalmerThe feral cat population in Scotland is a very major welfare challenge, and threatens the native Scottish wild cat population with extermination28832017-09-18T13:24:59.92734535Antje MoltonI agree that the domestic cat population needs to be controlled, but I would be totally against a cull. Chipping and neutering is an absolute must, and any responsible cat owner would have no objection to it, I am sure.28832017-09-18T13:47:27.91734536Gill HulmeI own cats myself and see at first hand the impact they can have if uncontrolled. This seems a very sensible measure in view of the large feral cat population to protect wildlife in general, as well as for the well-being of the cats themselves.28832017-09-18T14:19:10.07734537Duncan McKenzieI believe, as an owner of two neutered and micro-chipped cats, that it is every cat owner and potential cat owner's responsibility to ensure the welfare of any animal is paramount. That includes neutering, micro-chipping and ensuring all vaccinations are carried out. If that is cost prohibitive then serious consideration should be given to owning a cat. In addition the Scottish wildcat is critically endangered and the compulsory neutring of all cats would make a huge difference to their survival for future generations to enjoy. It would also ensure people looking for a cat can source them from a reputable breeder and they will have the piece of mind that the animal is healthy, from good stock and therefore should not result in unneccessary vet bills, outwith the norm.28832017-09-18T16:17:27.12334538Mr David James CatchpoleI have had 4 cats in my life and if one is not there to care and nurture them then do no have any at all as we do not own them we care for them for all our benefits.28832017-09-18T17:09:08.89734539PeterWildcat population needs to be protected - so do populations of birds in our towns and cities: currently hammered by the domestic cat population.28832017-09-18T18:06:29.82734540Dee GovanThere are too many domestic pets in this country and if there is conflict between wild animals and \r\npets we should ALWAYS be taking measures to prioritise protection of our wildlife and wild spaces. 28832017-09-18T21:42:59.49334541Amanda RoyI volunteer for Cats Protection, raising awareness of neutering and chipping and actually believe microchipping should be mandatory for cats as it currently is for dogs. 28832017-09-21T22:29:22.61734542chelleyWe need to be neutering and returning feral colonies of cats. Most cats out there started of as someone's pet. A responsible owner will chip there cat, but if the details aren't registered or kept up to date it's useless.\r\n28832017-09-22T12:04:46.0134543Shirley OttoThank you for this initiative. The wildcats and birds in our urban areas need to be protected28832017-09-24T14:28:48.2134544Catriona LairdAlthough I live in England I was brought up in Scotland and still have family there. I care both about the plight of the Scottish wildcat and the general small wildlife population. I feel everything must be done to protect the wildcat but early neutering will also protect cats. It's been shown to be a quick procedure which has fewer side effects when performed early in kittens. I suspect the legislation will be difficult to enforce but cannot any good reason not to try.28832017-09-24T17:43:11.73734545Andrew SwalesPheasants next? I hit one on the A7 last month, it did £150 damage to my car but even though someone bred and released it I can't go after them for compensation.\r\n28832017-10-01T15:43:57.33734546Lyn FlandersBeen involved in at rescue and TNR for 30 years. Neutering is of extreme importance and the only answer to the world over population of cats. I do not believe in breeding at all. Neutering every cat is hopefully bound to result in less cats in need of help although it will never end but reduction in numbers would benefit cat welfare charities.28832017-10-02T22:57:5634547LYDIA REIDSorry no 2 \r\nI believe it is healthy to neuter and release cats \r\nThey do as mine did and move inside if ill \r\nWhat I object to is some of the stories of cruelty that I have heard of to keep feral cats away from our wild cats \r\nCatching in cages and leaving them to die is unacceptable \r\nTo catch neuter and release maybe even in a different area is fine\r\nI accept the wild cat must be protected 28832017-10-03T23:28:53.39334548Kathleen Chipping and neutering will only work if the humans cared about their cats. The Scottish wildcat needs to be protected and it is only humans that can make sure of this working. 28832017-10-04T19:24:14.79734549Raymond F CarlinPlease consider this petition to alleviate suffering in both the feral cat and less well cared for pet population. \r\nIt will also help safeguard our native wild cat, bird, small mammals and other wildlife.28832017-10-06T12:29:01.1734550ColinThere is no excuse for anyone keeping un-neutered cats unless they are in the business of breeding cats, in which case they should value their animals too highly to allow them to wander. \r\nWidespread neutering is justified on both animal welfare and conservation grounds. The practice would drastically reduce the number of unwanted kittens left in cat shelters for rehoming, the incidence of fighting and disease in free-roaming pet cats, the problem of feral & stray cats, and impacts on wildlife including the endangered wildcat. \r\nMicrochipping of cats would allow lost cats to be returned to their owners, and by enabling cat owners to be identified, would encourage a responsible attitude towards their pets. \r\nThe proposals would help reduce pressure on overstretched animal welfare charities, and although there would likely be an overall reduction in cat numbers, it would potentially create more business opportunities for responsible licensed breeders. 28832017-10-08T14:37:58.10334551Brian Clark PatersonI live in a small hamlet of 12 houses in the Carse of Gowrie and one of my neighbours cats which was not neutered had in excess of 20 kittens which were left to roam wild looking for food and shelter. The kittens became a nuisance and would dash across the road in front of traffic and fouled our garden and twice took food from the BBQ when my back was turned. The lady who had the cats eventually relented and agreed to the Cats Protection League rounding the kittens up to neuter them and arrange for them to be re housed some way away from the hamlet. Thankfully things are now back to normal and we only see the occasional kitten thanks to the iniative of the CPL. Brian & Val Treetops.28832017-10-09T10:29:37.44334552Karen KirklandAfter 26 years of cat rescue I cannot stress enough how important this is.28832017-10-09T19:29:52.3734553Carl Macdonald Act should be reviewed29162017-10-10T13:57:15.87334554Peter BerwickSuch an important program...left in checked the population will reach truly miserable proportion ... facing the problem and acting now makes sense.28832017-10-10T20:50:21.6434555Nik RosserThe act should be reviewed29162017-10-11T10:45:58.81734556hugh patersonI've had a similar problem a submitted a petition29162017-10-11T12:39:29.7734557Derek C RiddickI have experienced difficulties with title registration and consider the methodology beinf used which does take dimensions for existing title into the new title to be fundamental and potentially faital flaw in the current system. I understand the diving force is the current Scottish Governmet's drive to punnish large land owners via taxation or similar actions 29162017-10-12T12:51:34.29334558Roy DennisAt present, I think the prospect of saving the Scottish Wildcat is in the balance. This is a serious conservation issue so the action, such as proposed, is essential and overdue.28832017-10-15T18:27:09.5434559David SequinI think its a good idea it keeps cat population under control & stops your going missing .28832017-10-15T18:41:57.3134560Donna MoranRecently I had two pregnant cats that visited daily at first I didn't feed them. But soon realized that they were in fact pregnant and would still visit daily or they stayed hidden under the decking and felt safe. I have a two year old daughter and didn't feel right about leaving these mums out to have their kittens. So I contacted west fife cats protection. And they took them in. They each had four kittens each. Now the same situation could very easily have had a totally different outcome had I not been able to get the help needed for the stray mums. I am now a foster mum for cats. And shocked at how much cats protection and organisation's like them have to deal with on a daily basis. 28832017-10-16T11:21:27.77334561Neil KirklandLast week we picked up four 4-week old kittens found under a bush. Someone left them there to fend for themselves. Tomorrow we are getting a three day old kitten, the young mother killed the rest of the litter because she was confused and frightened all because people did not have their cat neutered. Also last week picked up a 8 year-old unneutered male with a large wound , think how many kittens he has been responsible for over a period of 8 years. We need to act now before its to late.28832017-10-16T12:03:31.8934563Gillian McNeishOnce again children are pawns and rolled out to make social workers look good.29382017-10-16T19:57:11.17334564Maggi AllanEssential program for ecological and humanitarian reasons. 28832017-10-16T22:15:21.86334565Miss SCOTCATThis has to do with animal welfare and conservation. It is a sadness when those who want to help families who can not or do not neuter their cats are constrained by the lack of powers to enable those agencies to enforce neutering. SSPCA cant help, apparently, as they consider it's not "cruelty" to allow cats to reproduce without regard to welfare. For those who DO have neutered cats, it is terrifying to witness the territorial fighting with impostors. And for those who do not keep cats, it is a challenge when scavenging ferals raid their kitchens and join in their al fresco dining uninvited! Farm animals have more protection that domestic cats do, as neglect, lack of feeding, and failure to manage husbandry can see a farmer prosecuted. I would not seek to criminalise, but if there were legisllation in place to empower those such as Cat Protection organisations and SSPCA to remove, treat, neuter and re-home ferals without a consent, it would alleviate the unnecessary suffering to the unwanted and un-cared-for cats, and the actual nuisance that their uncontrolled and unmanaged breeding causes to other animals and neighbours28832017-10-17T01:13:42.3134566Kathleen These very special puss cats deserve the beet in life like our Scottish wild cat. They have no voice themselves so it is up to us to put their case forward for the powers that be to listen. Which I really hope they do this time. Purrs28832017-10-17T19:45:03.36334567Rhona GordonAs a Scottish cat rescue charity (Fife Cat Shelter) we spend most of our time rescuing and neutering cats and raising money to do so. We offer a much discounted price to owners on low incomes to have their cats neutered to try to reduce the number of cats , there are too many cats and too few potential owners. If we did not have to divert the majority of our time and funds to neutering, we would hope to have time to inform people of the importance of neutering and the potential spread of life threatening disease through un neutered males . Micro chipping is a valuable resource for reuniting cars and owners and part of the responsibility of ownership.\r\nNeutered cats are healthier cats and we desperately try to stop annual abandonment of pregnant cats or cats with kittens. Encouraging people to have their cats neutered and not to see litters of kittens as potential money earners , is essential.28832017-10-18T10:03:29.00734568Lynne EllisAlthough not living in Scotland I have lived there many years and have family there. It's similar problems here. People do not take responsibility for the welfare of other species. Cats are left to breed and this is unfair, kittens and cats abandoned. breeders need to take more care and all animals licensed for breeding, a large program to help get neutering done. To prevent cruelty. Chipping and neutering is something which needs to be addressed and forced, and help for those animals in poor families. Ignorance is a problem here too. Charities would have more to spare on helping cats in need. The wild cat needs protecting. I was a cat rescuer in Scotland and remain one here now. Regards L. ellis\r\n28832017-10-18T10:06:07.30334569Lynne EllisAs a cat rescuer formally in Scotland for many years and now here, this programmer needs to start as soon as possible. 28832017-10-18T11:11:53.03734570Louise Welshthe children are traumatised enough without that.29382017-10-18T15:41:31.14734571Marion SmithThere are more than enough cats, those that are already here deserve care and attention. It is irresponsible as a career to allow your male to procreate willy-nilly or female to have a succession of unplanned pregnancies. 28832017-10-18T16:46:15.40334572Louise Malone I am one off menny mum's in Scotland and England targeted as a result off partners in the past and now it all on me as a mum not the dad it not fair to kids to have to be left so tromatisd in the end off the metting my little boy how may have a.d.h.d or on the ortistick spectrum is changing at time but to have to put all ur atensh in to the kids at the hearing u can't fucase on the panel members so plez look in to it all it morally and palitaclky rong on so menny leaves.29382017-11-02T18:56:14.83734575Ruth Poolplease ensure that there is more consideration given to assessing those with mental health problems. I have ahd to support my 35 year old son financially for 4 years since he was sanctioned and couldn't face the trauma of re-claiming benefits or the appeals process due his mental health and anxiety issues. He was considered fit to work when clearly he was anything but fit. He has been and still often is suicidal. 29252017-11-03T10:27:20.71334576Philip creeWe recently had my PIP payments and my husband's carers allowance cut because my gp is no longer in the practise, so when the dwp asked for further info no-one sent any. As a result our housing benefit has reduced, our wtc will reduce and we were already 500 a month worse off. I have a serious incurable illness, not cancer but an illness with no cure, been trying to set up a community interest company to support others in our situation but as soon as we're making headway, our megre financial support is stripped away. If I work a little to stop myself from going mad my money gets cut. Not in respect box what I've earned, it just stops for self employed workers this current system gives no support. I'll appeal and fight in court as usual and they'll dismiss me and my life again. It's been 15 years I've been going through the same Shit whenever I get sick.29252017-11-03T18:04:42.54334577linda garciaIt is an absolute scandal that parents and children are being evicted from their homes in a prosperous country putting families into substandard B & B's and temporary accommodation is also scandalous\r\n29252017-11-05T11:27:04.75334578Marilyne Ruth KubathScotland is a country in her own right and as such should be included in the country name list.29252017-11-07T12:05:12.08334579George PottsRanger Services across Scotland are a national asset and as such are worthy of a national strategic approach. Please take this opportunity to learn more about the many and varied roles Countryside Rangers have in connecting people with their local natural environment and promoting Scotland's many scenic areas.29532017-11-08T19:41:21.68734580Beverley ClarkeSince the removal of ring fenced funding from SNH for Ranger Services in Scotland, there has been a slow erosion and removal of Rangers through cutbacks and lack of support. Ranger Services have become the easy target for budget savings as their value to an authority, service or organisation is not fully appreciated or been replaced by volunteers. Additionally the professional role of a Ranger in Scotland has suffered a de-valuing due to budget cuts, changes in job descriptions and lack of training opportunities being offered to Ranger staff. Scotland has a history of being World pioneers for conservation work and Ranger Services through founding SCRA and IRF and it would be so sad to lose all we have achieved.29532017-11-08T19:54:31.68334581Alison AbercrombieI support the need for implementing this framework. I have been a ranger for the last 10 years in Dundee and have seen and experienced first hand the cuts to Ranger Services. Dundee City council have gone from 6 full time posts plus 2 seasonal posts along with support from colleagues in the urban ranger service to 3 full time posts. We can no longer deliver the same service. We have adjusted what we do time and again to try and mitigate the effects but are now at breaking point. We are on the brink of becoming ineffective in what we do through no fault of our own. Rangers are a knowledgeable and pationate bunch and their loss will be sorely felt in the years to come. 29532017-11-08T20:00:03.28334582LorneI'm not sure that enough people appreciate and understand importance of the work of our Countryside Rangers - we should be investing in the natural environment and those that look after it.29532017-11-08T20:00:09.10734583Alison AbercrombieI support the need to implement this framework. I have been a Ranger for the last 10 years with Dundee city council. Our team has been reduced from 6 full time staff, 2 seasonal staff and support from a fantastic urban ranger service to 3 full time posts. We have tried to adjust what we do over and over again to try and compensate but we are now at breaking point. We are at the stage of becoming ineffective through no fault of our own. Rangers are passionate and knowledgeable people whose loss will be greatly felt in Scotland in years to come. 29532017-11-08T21:09:56.71334584Roger Powell From being a Nationally defined Ranger Service, underpinned by the duties as defined by the CCS and then SNH, a system envied by other services around the world, we have gone to a fragmented system, with many Rangers having essential duties removed from them and, as a result, a deterioration in much of our important Countryside areas.29532017-11-08T22:20:02.12734585Heather This needs supported for public health reasons. 29532017-11-08T23:10:13.18334586CallumIt is known that, annually, £1.4 million NHS money could be saved on prescribed drugs for temporary mental health issues (e.g. stress, anxiety, some depressions) if people were prescribed a walk or other activity in the countryside or local country park - the few remaining rangers could provide this service to help folk out, to seek the healthy revitilisation. But more, not fewer, rangers are needed. The cost versus the national savings on health services is minor.29532017-11-08T23:45:48.53334587Allison GreigAs a Senior Countryside Ranger, my team of Rangers in Glasgow has gone from 14 full time equivalent posts in 2009 to 8 FTE posts in 2017, this has been through 'natural wastage' ie. no backfilling of vacant posts as result of cost savings by our employer. We have not had seasonal ranger since 2009 and thendof the grant aid provided by SNH. This ring fenced core funding was essential to keep this money flowing to ranger services when this was removed so was the security of ranger posts in local authorities. there is direct correlation.29532017-11-09T00:59:28.85334588Niall LobleyAs a former Ranger and Chair of SCRA I cannot place enough support behind this petition. I now work in Canada, and through working in Canada and being aware through the International Ranger Community of the work that Rangers do in Scotland, I can with experience to support this, firmly state that the way in which Ranger Services evolved in Scotland, and were until 2008 was a globally recognised model of best practice in engaging communities in greenspaces. There is no other system as good, in terms of delivery and in respect to public value for money that Rangers were when financially supported by SNH. Recognising that this system is no more, every effort should be made by policy makers to ensure that the replacement system should evolve to be as strong - or stronger than the mechanisms in place to support this vital public service before 2008. The past decade has demonstrated that the practice now being adopted is not only weaker, but is progressively undoing half a century of being a global leader and eroding the superior system Scotland enjoyed and its place as a leader in greenspace delivery and management through its Rangers. Please act on this petition. Listen to the public note the passionate way that members of the public responded to proposed and now implemented changes to Highland Ranger Service. Look at the numbers - see how much was delivered for so little investment - nearly 300 staff were supported across Scotland for less than 2 million GBP a year from SNH. Look at the losses since 2008. Look to SCRA to help inform how the next generation of Rangers can be supported, while we still have the ability to learn from those Rangers, now nearing the end of their careers that have given so much. Listen now to the passion of young Rangers entering a profession that is lead by their dedication as to how to mould a new method of supporting local delivery with national coordination fit for the next 50 years - repair the losses of the past decade.29532017-11-09T08:08:07.12734589Tracy LambertPlease support our Countryside Rangers, they are vital for so many services that include health and wellbeing, maintaining relationships with schools to encourage children to use outdoor space and looking after vital environmental greenspace as well as the wildlife in them.29532017-11-09T09:19:29.10334590shayna gibson nobody cares29162017-11-09T13:48:46.38334591Jo KingFor 7 years now i have struggled to gain full time employment with any ranger service. I have even gone back to university to study countryside management. But i know when i graduate that there's no guarantee that i can gain a job. Budget cuts have hit the ranger services hard. Support is needed!29532017-11-09T20:40:06.0634592Michelle MI completely support this proposal. Rangers are essential for the natural and cultural heritage and health of our country and without them the country would be a poorer place. They work with people of all ages, abilities and ethnicities, getting people into the Countryside, providing environmental and cultural education and helping to protect Scotland for future generations29532017-11-09T21:52:13.83734593John Lang WilsonCountryside Rangers provide a vital function in educaton and conservation29532017-11-09T23:46:46.05734594Katrina RobinsonVital job taking care of the countryside and much more!29532017-11-10T09:34:13.7734595Gavin FinbowI support the framework as I firmly believe that Ranger Services provide important and key policies of the Scottish Government including health and well-being (physical and mental), social inclusion working with deprived communities, enhancing the natural and cultural environment for future generations, and economic development through land management. Ranger Services provide a wealth of knowledge and information to the communities of Scotland equipping folk with the tools to enjoy and understand the environment, sowing the seeds of the future, Scotlands Future.29532017-11-10T10:43:25.85334596Nigel FranklinCarry on doing the great work.29532017-11-10T19:41:52.6334597GlenIt's a vital part of the network and should be supported 29532017-11-11T17:08:57.5834598John Shawplease review29162017-11-12T21:18:31.4234599Barry BurnsCommon Sense will surely prevail \r\nB.Burns29162017-11-13T14:53:08.87734600KimWe truly need to ensure that we balance our natural habitat , for now and also future generations. maybe more volunteers ? 29532017-11-15T07:19:11.28334601Richard For a country that prides itself of the wild and rural areas it seems only fitting to demonstrate this commitment to protecting it.29532017-11-15T11:27:28.10334602RennieCountryside rangers are the cornerstone of accessible outdoor learning...they protect species and habitats, they work with people of all ages, abilities and backgrounds and are vital in protecting wildlife and public access - they act as teachers, conservationists, land managers, development officers, machine operators and so much more but get little recognition or reward and it's high time this changed and the profession was recognised and supported on a par with professions such as teaching.29532017-11-15T19:22:30.2634603Mhairi DonnellyThe State of Nature 2016 Scotland report states that Scotland has a chance of reversing biodiversity loss but is this so without the Ranger Service. We are a country who pride ourselves on the value of our natural environment and our economy depends on it for tourism. Without the people to manage, conserve and interpret the natural environment it looses its value and worth.29532017-11-15T22:07:20.51734604Claire Countryside rangers do an amazing job of creating and improving habitats for nature, then encouraging people to learn about and enjoy the natural areas around them. 29532017-11-16T09:08:34.4734605Anna BrandThe people who help to maintain our places of beauty where we can get close to nature are absolutely essential. They do exhausting and essential work in all weathers to ensure we can spend sunny weekends or days off enjoying these places. 29532017-11-16T12:04:45.0434606Ewen CameronCountryside Rangers do so much. They help farmers by explaining why dogs should be kept under control, help everyone by explaining how the countryside works and explaining how we all depend on nature, they help the economy by providing and maintaining visitor facilities for local people and tourists, they help the environment by managing and protecting wild places they improve health by holding events to get us active in the outdoors, they providing volunteering opportunities so we get the chance to help improve our countryside, they support our children in schools and elsewhere with educational support and projects. They are not a luxury. In cities and the countryside they are a mainstay of Scotland's modern society and a vital part of our wellbeing. And no I'm not a ranger, just someone who appreciates them for the national treasure they are.29532017-11-16T21:12:26.2134607Stephen GuestGermany seems to go against human rights in my dass and the dass oft my whole family29162017-11-16T22:25:39.07734608Jacqui Fleming The rangers provide a grass roots service which is overlooked and the importance of which underrated (by some). They are vital in enhancing participation and increasing knowledge of our environment and preserving our green spaces. This should not be another service that is cut to save costs. 29532017-11-17T14:27:19.3934609Dougie StewartAs the owner of a business which organises walking holidays in Scotland, I've been depressed at the gradual rundown of the Rangers Service in several local authorities. Dumfries and Galloway is particularly bad. My company has had many complaints about poor signage and maintenance on the western end of the Southern Upland Way, leading to two European agents taking the route off their programmes. As every walker spends about £1k for a 7 day visit, the loss to the local economy far outweighs any apparent savings in cutting Ranger services.29532017-11-17T16:25:23.8934610SimonVital service for the conservation of our countryside and in the education of all be it young or old. 29532017-11-17T20:21:34.43334611Andrew GrantVital service in an environment threatened by climate change 29532017-11-17T20:49:01.56334612TOMMY MCMANMONRanger Services tick all the boxes for a healthy, educated Scottish population. Why would the government let things slip like this?!29532017-11-17T23:31:48.11734613John WalderWildlife in Scotland needs all the help it can get, including direct monitoring as provided by the CRS29532017-11-18T21:51:43.3134614Lynnette BorradaileRetaining, enhancing and sustaining our natural heritage is essential to the health and well being of al this country's citizens, Rangers play a key role and are essential educators in helping people enjoy and understand the natural world - an entitlement every pupil in Scotland now has and every teacher is responsible in delivering, and few have the relevant skills that Rangers could share with them.29532017-11-19T17:12:44.54334615Elaine FraserAs parents we support as much as we can our adult children( and we know many who can do ) Although they are in work ( low paid) do not want them to have to endure the humiliation of this current barbaric system . How can we not when we remember a time when social security system provided a safety net so we know the difference and how things should be done. Many have no other support but we must all stand together and fight this.29252017-11-19T18:05:19.8834616Donald ThomasA uniform service across the country will enable equality of access to the whole Scottish population. Some people need support and encouragement to take much needed exercise in the outdoors. Ranger services can also coordinate volunteer contributions to estate management.29532017-11-19T18:34:52.3234617JackieOur environment requires protecting, conserving and enhancing. The ranger network represents the boots on the ground in this challenge and requires financial & material support. Squeeze the network dry now and it would take years (decades ?)to re-establish. 29532017-11-19T20:16:36.17734618David AllanI'll pay more Scottish income tax if the population at large first know how damaging UC is to our fellow citizens who experience the need to access benefits. 29252017-11-20T08:40:16.12734619SheenaDelivering a strategic framework would look at the needs for the whole of Scotland and address the inequalities there now exists in provision of Scotland's Ranger services. 29532017-11-20T09:46:17.04334620Lisa FordRangers are desperately needed in a world that is increasingly detaching itself from the natural world. Rangers are an important link to help people take ownership and care about the world around them.29532017-11-20T11:21:54.6234621KatyThe Highland Council Rangers do some incredible work with kids. This is a vital service to ensure our young people continue to treasure our natural heritage.29532017-11-20T17:06:20.48334622Gabriele Rice-GrunertRanger Services do much of the ground work in habitat management and in interacting with children and visitors in our parks and protected spaces. They are the linkage between people and nature providing interpretation of complex processes and functions happening in the outdoors and benefitting all of us. They are a vital part of delivering biodiversity duties that rest with local authorities. Instead of losing more and more of these services, we need to strengthen and support them as this framework proposes.29532017-11-20T19:38:32.18334623Susan DaviesThe Scottish Wildlife Trust employs a number of full time and seasonal rangers to undertake both practical management work, ecological monitoring and to support awareness raising and educational work. Ranger roles make an important contribution to delivery of national outcomes and priority steps in the Biodiversity RouteMap especially around creating healthy local environments and connecting individuals, schools and communities with these. The Scottish Wildlife Trust supports efforts by SCRA to , creative solutions to the problems of reduced resources, and fresh commitment to delivering the framework for countryside range services in Scotland.29532017-11-20T21:40:57.57334624John K Campbell The Country is heading in the right direction with its countryside pursuits. This is not the right time to cut back on staffing. You should be adding staff and bring in more visitors not turn them away or wait to the last minute and find more staff on demand. A good Boy Scout motto BE PREPARED.29532017-11-21T00:23:21.0634625Rhonda ReekieUniversal credit and recent benefit sanctions against disabled persins a shameful attack on our poor and weak 29252017-11-21T16:12:00.4634627Dr Elspeth StirlingCountryside Rangers Services carry out a crucial role in protecting our precious natural environemnt and in the education of of our communities, including young people who will be the stewards of the future. They have irreplaceable knowledge of our wildlife and wild landscapes, and are ideally placed to connect people with their wild natural heritage. I belong to and help run a number of voluntary wildlife orgainsations in Scotland - and wholly support the proposal that CRS's should have adequete resourcing to enable them to function and develop fully. The loss of experienced staff has left notable gaps in Scotland's conservation endeavours. 29532017-11-22T12:45:08.79334628Colin InverarityThe Ranger Services throughout Scotland provide a valuable service in educating our children about their local environment, managing and protecting areas of our countryside as well as monitoring the wildlife present. Continuing with these cuts year on year risks irreversible harm to threatened species and our environment and will have serious impacts on what sort of country we pass on to future generations if we don't start doing something about it now.29532017-11-22T23:20:37.39734629Derek JacksonLooking after and caring for the countryside makes a huge benefit for the health of our environment, habitats and creatures and in no small way the people who visit. It needs to be managed and cared for and the rangers service is a cost effective way of achieving this29532017-11-23T11:01:18.52334630Eddie PalmerI fully support this petition, as the very good reasons for not further diminishing the ranger service in Scotland have been very ably set out. The Ranger service everywhere in Scotland is essential for being a crucial 'eyes and easrs in the countryside. I am involved in volunteer work to try and combat wildlife crime, and rangers are essential in the partnership in this fight. The reductions in staff have been disgraceful and dangerous29532017-11-23T17:29:33.37334631Ceri WellsRangers perform a valuable service which is often underappreciated. They have a genuine love and concern for the wildlife and the wild areas that we tend to take for granted and work very hard to maintain and promote its upkeep, public interest and diversity. They are are essential part of our country and coastal areas.29532017-11-24T16:10:13.5734633Kate OdlingThe Rangers Service contains experts in many areas including biodiversity, flora, fauna, land management, public involvement and understanding. They oversee volunteer groups, undertake National flora and fauna surveys, contribute to our knowledge of the British countryside and educate local residents from Primary School age to mature adults through talks, guided walks and workshops. This enormous range of tasks is possible because of the dedication of the Rangers and their team-working strategies so that expertise is shared. To maintain the countryside in a healthy condition for the future a detailed knowledge of the area is crucial for effective management. \r\nThe Rangers are a cost effective way to achieve a natural environment that is diverse, sustainable, healthy and accessible for the recreation and enjoyment of the public. Cuts would lead to the exponential degradation of the natural environment that would have degenerative repercussions over the years29532017-11-24T17:54:15.14734634Helen MurrayI drive around the university area of Edinburgh frequently and some bikes have no lights, cyclists wearing no reflective clothing. This has to be tackled as well as helmets28872017-11-24T18:49:03.75334635Gordon MillerThe Scottish model is used as an example of good practice in ranger services in Europe and further afield. As our environment experiences more and more threats rangers are at the front line in environmental education and monitoring change in our countryside, if protected areas are to mean anything then we need to strengthen their protection not diminish it. Scotland can be a beacon of good practice in how we react to any negative changes\r\nInternational Ranger Federation\r\n29532017-11-24T19:32:08.67334636Fran BurgessThe Rangers Service provides such a valuable service to the environment and the community. In E Lothian they coordinate an especially active volunteer initiative which allows the community to participate and learn about conservation, and make a valuable contribution.29532017-11-25T09:41:30.65734637Alan PreeceThis profession provides so many cross cutting social, economic and environmental benefits at an excellent value to the public purse. Reductions in their number has always led to the rise of both short and long term impacts that are expensive or impossible to rectify. Please implement this strategy.29532017-11-25T17:05:10.49734638Margaret AllanEast Lothian has a great team of Rangers who do a fantastic job. I volunteer for Path Maintenance working alongside some of the Rangers in country and coastal areas. It is essential that we keep the Countryside Ranger Services in Scotland.29532017-11-25T23:21:04.98334639Kenneth MauleRangers are 'eyes and ears', guardians, teachers and so much more. We need care for our countryside, especially as Brexit is looming and many environment rules will be ditched.29532017-11-26T12:42:50.06334640william bruceRangers work in rural areas. The Scottish Government should be supporting such an important aspect of rural life, which benefits all citizens of the country.29532017-11-27T13:26:23.60734641Donald McHarrieA cyclist using a helmet is like a motorist wearing a seat belt! So it should be compulsory to wear a helmet while cycling seems logical! 28872017-11-27T13:48:06.40734642Fiona ScobieShould be compulsory as it could save a life !!!28872017-11-27T13:56:31.10334643John MacInnesAs an educated person and health professional, could you please explain why the countries with compulsory cycle helmet laws, are also those with the highest cyclist casualty rate whereas countries with low cycle helmet use have the lowest cyclist casualty rates? 28872017-11-27T14:23:11.81734644CAROLE REARDONYes should definitly be law 28872017-11-27T14:45:36.7834645Moira MacdonaldAlso wear hi-vis garments.28872017-11-27T15:18:53.4134646Catherine SykesHelmets should be compulsory on all roads 28872017-11-27T16:55:30.13734647Colin elliott No age limit all types of bikes 28872017-11-28T08:44:27.54334648Margaret KendrickI would prioritise hi-vis garments as being seen clearly may prevent an accident but using both items is sensible28872017-11-28T15:59:03.27734649Rod Mitchell I do not support this at all. Like skiing, wearing a helmet makes sense and gives protection to one's head (up to a point), but it should not be mandatory or compulsory. It is just sensible and parents should encourage all children to wear a helmet from the first time they step onto a bike. It will then be second nature (like wearing a seatbelt). 28872017-11-28T19:24:49.19734650Marjorie ClimieRangers do a great job in the countryside and they are a very necessary addition to rural life.29532017-11-28T20:27:56.9134651Sandra McNeilHi Viz & helmets28872017-11-28T20:30:39.64734652Malcolm LiddleWhy do all of the countries with very hgh bike usage rates have hardly anybody wearing helmets?28872017-11-28T21:25:28.43334653Alex Reid The service does good work 29532017-11-28T21:48:02.3634654Thomas WarnerAs a volunteer I have worked with Rangers on several Estates. They play a very important role and help make Scotland accessible 29532017-11-29T13:51:11.16334655Emily Sanderson Rangers are vital for supporting education, wildlife monitoring, countryside access for all and are a crucial source of knowledge of the intricacies of our natural world. 29532017-11-29T15:51:38.9434656Catherine Edwards It's important to have rangers in place to be able to educate, protect, understand the changing land uses, maintenance, all of which were once done by local councils who because of decreasing budgets has reduced funding over the years and it's time the Scott government stepped up and sorted out a proper framework to enable the ranger service to carry on with a better structure nationwide not just local level. 29532017-11-29T16:44:20.7834657Scott ChristieEssential, invaluable! 29532017-11-29T17:47:35.42334658Nicky SandersonCountryside Rangers are knowledgable, skilled and enthusiastic communicators and thus a vital link for interpreting our outstanding environment. As a Blue Badge Scottish Tourist Guide I have encountered their excellent work on many occasions. Tourism and education would be the poorer without them. 29532017-11-29T18:08:39.22334659Tricia Ronaldson Have used the Ranger service with young people for many years and the hands on learning and self esteem building has been amazing. This service is invaluable please save it29532017-11-29T20:47:52.8434660Caroline andersonPlease save the ranger service they do amazing work 29532017-11-30T08:38:58.95734661Douglas RuffVisitor enjoyment equals more money spent in villages. Generating VAT and Jobs. This sector should be at the forefront of a government trying to describe USP to foreign and domestic investment. The Ranger services also monitors species, helps remove invasives, pathwork making accessibility possible and education. 29532017-11-30T09:23:48.18334662Ian JoyceThe Curriculum for Excellence lays great store in helping children become informed individuals. The role that Rangers play in this process is priceless.29532017-11-30T09:43:13.21734663Helen ColeIt is vital to maintain a strategic approach to delivery of these services.29532017-11-30T13:33:35.44734664William L BennettRangers are a vital part of providing informed access to the environment. for many children a Ranger is the key to encouraging the protection of our wildlife and wild places.29532017-11-30T13:39:56.4534665ruth hexterhow short-sighted do the authorities want to be. less services now means less money later for all stakeholders including b&b, hotels, food, pubs, outdoor shops, petrol stations, public transport the list goes on29532017-11-30T14:34:13.95734666Iain BruceI agree on the principle that cycle helmets should be worn by youngsters using bicycles etc. However, the various experts from manufacturers, professional cyclists and even evidence from countries where bikes are much more in use must be consulted before passing this as a law.\r\n\r\nThe biggest issue is that the road traffic around Scottish cities, towns and in rural areas need to be isolated from cyclists by introducing proper lanes which are not directly beside motor vehicles.\r\n\r\nOur current infrastructure around Scotland needs to be vastly improved, with better facilities and safer routes the number of cyclists will increase. Obviously the elements and weather conditions are out of our control, but if people are made to feel safe and encouraged to cycle then it will benefit towns by reducing exhaust emissions and congestion.\r\n28872017-11-30T14:36:59.80334667Chris LewisI am a regular visitor to the Scottish Highlands and Sutherland in particular where I stay for around 2 weeks every year (and have done since 1987). The Scottish Ranger Service was invaluable when I was first getting to know the area and should be continued so that others can benefit in future29532017-11-30T16:48:29.7734668E. McAlpinePlease support our Countryside Ranger Services who have the knowledge and experience required to make sure we can continue to enjoy our countryside and wildlife to the full. 29532017-11-30T17:01:18.49734669Helen Gunn Rangers are very necessary to the countryside 29532017-11-30T17:19:16.85334670M KnightsThese are the green jobs of the future do not cut them do the opposite expand them29532017-11-30T19:23:45.51734671Debra GunnThe everyday work of the Countryside Ranger in supporting an expansive variety of institutions and individuals providing an irreplaceable understanding of our own countryside makes it difficult to see how this could be maintained in any other way. In fact it could not be replaced and would be a loss to all. 29532017-11-30T20:55:43.76334672Anna CanningVital service!!29532017-12-01T10:41:22.5534673Richard Ian GregoryRanger Services provide magnificent value in their role helping to conserve protected landscapes by building local community and wider visitor support and involvement, running environmental education programmes and carrying out practical in-the-field management work. Their cost is tiny in relation to the value of the work carried out. 29532017-12-01T11:59:44.82734674Corinna GoeckeritzRangers play a vital role conserving, enhancing and interpreting our natural heritage in rural and urban areas alike, and making these areas accessible to people. As part of their educational remit, rangers enable people of all ages and backgrounds to (re-)connect with nature, contributing to people's physical and mental wellbeing.\r\nA strategic approach to the delivery of these services is critical to ensure Scotland's rangers can continue to make these vital contributions to society, enriching our experiences of natural heritage, and benefitting the Scottish economy.29532017-12-01T18:01:27.62734679David ListerDon't risk squandering the years of experience built up in the Ranger Service: the country (side) would be a poorer place without it.29532017-12-01T18:40:32.56734680Carol BrownThe rangers on Isle of Arran are worth their weight in gold!!29532017-12-02T01:37:31.15734681Helen RoweI support implementation of the national strategic framework for Countryside Ranger Services in Scotland to maintain consistent excellent standards of delivery they provide across the country. The work that rangers do contributes significantly to many government priorities in areas such as education, health and tourism, as well as protecting our environment to benefit wildlife and people. Without this national recognition, ranger services are vulnerable to further cut-backs that will impact negatively on our communities and visitors.29532017-12-04T06:21:34.16334682Robyn smythProud to sign this29532017-12-04T11:17:29.42334683Laura The Rangers provide an affordable, fun connection between people and nature. We need to be doing more to instill a sense of responsibility for our planet in our children. The work of the Ranger service is priceless.29532017-12-04T11:23:37.04734684Dave SmithThe Rangers are an asset to our National parks and Countryside.29532017-12-04T17:51:37.5434685James BrownhillThe Rangers provide a vital link between what's happening "in the environment" and desk bound administrators, and also ensure the best "visitor experience".29532017-12-05T08:59:03.46334686Lynnette Countryside Rangers are an essential link between our natural heritage and people. Research shows green space is significant in physical and mental health and wellbeing. Rangers facilitate people's enjoyment, personal relationship with and care for the natural heritage and wider countryside. Rangers are on the ground, know their patch, protecting the natural heritage from irresponsible behaviours by developers, farmers and members of the public, and encouraging responsible management. This strategic framework needs full implementation, or watch NHS costs rise!29532017-12-05T11:22:29.49734687James DavidsonEvery one should sign this29532017-12-05T11:49:31.64334688Alexandra PrescottRangers are the intermediary between the public and the wild - speaking and caring for the wild so that the public can enjoy it29532017-12-05T16:45:10.02734689Iain McIntyreThe Rangers keep an eye on our local environment. The experience and local knowledge they have would be very difficult to regain if it was ever lost and the enthusiasm and knowledge they provide to our children is invaluable.29532017-12-05T18:04:38.54734690Sam ChristophersonOur Rangers are a unique knowledge base. They are essential part of outdoor learning education for our children and are essential to protect and look after Scotlands natural landscape. Which is one of the most valuable assets we have.29532017-12-05T20:45:01.92734691Ian Harty The rangers provide considerable unseen community support and communication and are a valuable asset. 29532017-12-06T09:13:27.76334692Molly PageCountryside rangers provide an essential service in not only protecting Scotland's natural heritage but educating the next generation to appreciate the environment and how to.look after it if.29532017-12-06T14:40:10.0234693Andy CloquetCountryside Rangers can often be the first contact people have when they go to countryside parks, engage in conservation projects and have links with the outdoors through schools' outdoor learning programmes. CRs are thus a vital link and also contribute to overall 'healthy lifestyles' necessary to improve out Nation's health.29532017-12-06T21:16:14.13734694Jeanette FitzhughThe rangers are essential to the preservation of our countryside29532017-12-07T17:33:15.99334695Hilary SwiftIn this day and age where the population have become so detached from the natural environment, we need to safeguard our countryside rangers in order to protect the invaluable service that they provide.29532017-12-08T15:08:46.1234696Steve EdwardsCountryside Rangers have the capability to enrich the experiences of people enjoying the countryside and urban greenspaces, so it is sad to see them disappearing as fast as the wildlife they try to protect and interpret.29532017-12-08T17:26:00.9534697Celia NyssensI'm strongly against this proposal, I believe it would deter many people from commuting by bike or just cycling around town casually, myself first. Cyclists can judge whether a helmet would protect them or make them feel safer, but I see no value in making them compulsory. The main threat to cyclists comes from cars so the car, taxi, and bus drivers are the ones who should be the target of a national information campaign. A low-hanging fruit would be to stop people parking on cycle lanes all over town. And I echo other comments: better infrastructure is also crucial to improve the safety of cyclists and encourage more people to cycle. The impact of such a proposal should be carefully examined before changing the law, surely the Government doesn't want to reduce cycling in favour of cars, that would be a setback for urban air quality, public health, and climate change.28872017-12-08T18:10:23.73734698Linda McFarlaneMy local authority refused to prosecute under the 1980 water Act. We get lots of Boil water notices29732017-12-08T22:16:03.64334699Charles WoodwardRangers are multi-talented individuals who are well respected by our population as educators, facilitators and guardians in our countryside. Additionally they contribute to Scotland's economy, health and environment. Just look at the many 'Social Return on Investment' reports produced in recent years.29532017-12-09T22:44:45.15734700Andy WilsonThe invaluable service that countryside rangers provide must not be overlooked.29532017-12-09T22:56:21.99334701LynnetteCountryside Rangers are a key strategic link between land managers, the public and our natural and cultural heritage and countryside, covering aspects of responsible access, interpretation, physical and mental health, educating people of all ages and capabilities in enjoying, monitoring, understanding and conserving Scotland's great outdoors. As the practitioners on the ground they are essential - they know their patch and have an enormous range of skills, passion for conservation, and specialist knowledge to share between themselves informing the network of Ranger services in Scotland, UK and internationally.29532017-12-10T15:44:41.01734702Tim SayerMore than ever, as our environment is threatened, we need people there to help people engage with our countryside. 29532017-12-10T19:16:33.49734703Lewis Provan Countryside Rangers will be the first people out of anyone who will protect and conserve your local parks and local wildlife species. 29532017-12-10T20:33:53.7134704Duncan StevensonCountryside Rangers have an important role in introducing,interpreting and managing Scotlands natural heritage and landscapes to all. Providing opportunities to be healthy and contribute to conserving what we have are what countryside rangers do with great success. A strategic framework will help maintain and develop this into the future.29532017-12-11T12:33:00.55734705Pippa Garrard Hebridean Whale and Dolphin TrustThe Hebridean Whale and Dolphin Trust strongly supports the need to implement the national strategic framework for the network of Countryside Rangers in Scotland. The Countryside Rangers have an important role in enhancing and protecting Scotlands natural environment and cultural heritage. HWDT works closely with Countryside Rangers across the west coast of Scotland, who provide vital local support to our organisation, by supporting us with our education, engagement and research programmes. The Rangers directly deliver hundreds of events and school projects, working with people of all ages, encouraging outdoor learning and engagement with the natural environment. In addition, Countryside Rangers are renowned for their local knowledge and connections within the community. HWDT believes that collaborations with the Ranger Service are pivotal to the success of our programmes as they support us at each stage of our work, from planning and advertising, to delivery and reinforcement of conservation messages. In addition to inspiring people to value and protect our natural environments, the Ranger Service also contribute whale and dolphin sighting data to HWDT. They also encourage the public to engage in conservation and biological recording programmes at their sites, generating valuable data, for monitoring internationally protected species, by reporting their wildlife sightings. HWDT joins the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association in their concerns that the cutbacks in public sector expenditure, loss of knowledgeable and experienced managers, and the pressures on the remaining Rangers is putting at risk this national network built over fifty years. It is therefore crucial that the Scottish Government recognise the value of our Countryside Rangers and take action to protect and strengthen this important service.29532017-12-11T16:18:31.95334706Thys SimpsonMany good comments I agree with have already been made. Looking outside Scotland, as we have too at times, to other countries such as Norway, Sweden, Finland etc. There are examples of where a lack of a national approach on such matters has had a negative effect long term. There are positive examples, for example Sweden, where a national strategy put in place many years has had a positive affect for all including visitors. We can surely learn from others? 29532017-12-11T20:15:03.11334707Mark WilsonCountryside Rangers' work is right at the interface between conservation and the community. With the right people, and given adequate resources, the value to society arising from the work that rangers do is tremendous. 29532017-12-12T08:45:22.2934708Brian MartinA significant proportion of Ranger effort provides guidance and reliable information to the next generation, given the current crises in many environmental and ecological sectors, we cannot afford to be without their input.29532017-12-12T09:08:16.1234709Roger CroftsCountryside Rangers are the most vital component of outdoor education and learning and contribute to the fulfilment of the Curriculum for Excellence and to healthy activity out of doors with substantial health benefits. The Scottish Government and SNH need to provide more funding for this service to deliver educational and health benefits.29532017-12-12T11:05:03.1534710Chris GledhillI strongly support the need for implementing the national strategic framework for the network of Countryside Ranger Services in Scotland.\r\nCountryside Rangers are highly skilled and motivated individuals providing in many cases a range of multi disciplinary skills who enrich the life of thousands by acting as an invaluable interface between the people of and visitors to Scotland.\r\nThey provide a range of wide services and activities that help the Scottish Government and local authorities meet their objectives in terms of healthy living, social inclusion and the conservation of of Scotlands wonderful natural environments ranging from our National Scenic Areas, National and country parks to local initiatives in our urban areas.29532017-12-12T11:09:17.93334711Marina PiperThe countryside ranger service provides a vital link between policy and delivery on the ground. I work with a number of different organisations to create a network of green spaces, flood resilient towns, enhancing biodiversity for better quality of life, strengthening economies and communities - none of this is possible without rangers on the ground to help educate people locally, to engage with all age groups, to explain what is happening and how things work, to simplify and deliver a common theme on the importance of enjoying, protecting and enhancing our resources. This helps to highlight that so many things are interconnected and that we all play a part.29532017-12-12T11:16:32.9734712Claire Hudson-LivingstoneThe Rangers provide a diverse and infintely valuable service, from environmental protection to education. They are part of the team who will ensure not only that the our historic and picturesque countryside is managed in a thoughtful and dynamic way, but that the next generation also value it for the future. 29532017-12-12T16:51:36.4834713Nicola PenfordI teach Countryside Management and our students often go on to ranger posts, enabling them to encourage a range of people to get outside and improve their health and well being, as well as teaching an understanding of the environment. With David Attenborough and Blue Planet 2 getting record audiences there has never been more evidence of the demand for environmental education to address the problems the planet faces.29532017-12-13T10:30:30.49734715JanetWe need to invest in the countryside more than ever before. Scotland needs control over our own revenue and all tax raised in Scotland so that we can afford to pay for our ecoverse and people to be safe.29532017-12-13T15:00:03.56734716Edith MacQuarrieMy husband worked as a countryside ranger as part of his career. Now more than ever we need those who can engage groups with the natural world29532017-12-13T18:06:32.2834717PeteRangers are very important in getting a wide range of people involved in our natural environment. Without them many people would not have the opportunity to learn about our countryside which would be to the detriment of future generations and the environment we all rely on.29532017-12-14T09:24:15.76334718Richard MearnsTo quote Dr William Bird: "Our connection with nature must become an essential component of healthcare, education, planning and community development. If we don't build nature and wildlife into the very fabric of our society, we will fail to stem chronic diseases, high stress and associated poor mental health." (BBC Wildlife, Aug 2015). Countryside Rangers are ideally suited to provide that educational link with people and wildlife.29532017-12-14T09:38:35.2334719andrew mackenzierangers are invaluable to actively engage people in first hand involvement and enjoyment of the outdoors - which is the first step to caring about it!29532017-12-14T11:20:21.10734720Neil TheodoresonIt is very important that we have a nucleus of professional, well balanced, ambassadors to encourage as many people as possible to make use of the wonderful natural environment we have, regularly and responsibly in the wide range of activities possible.29532017-12-14T12:44:06.49334722Jenny LockhartI agree that better infrastructure will help reduce injuries to cyclists. However, someone can come off their bike for a multitude of reasons (related to the cyclist, a car or local infrastructure) and if I am about to smack my head on a concrete road my common sense tells me I would like to be wearing a helmet than not. Professional cyclists wear helmets - why are we different? It also sets a good example for future generations. 28872017-12-14T16:02:54.06334723Nic BullivantI am signing this petition as a show of support for our Countryside Rangers and the great work they are doing right across Scotland.29532017-12-14T17:27:36.8234724PatRangers are a key part of engaging people with nature, particularly now that many people seem to be losing touch with the natural environment. 29532017-12-15T16:49:44.92734725Lesley ForbesWithout countryside rangers there would be no parks to attend and no education for the children 29532017-12-16T08:39:58.6434726Trevor Robertson The Ranger service are a fabric of the Coast and Country side. Which should not be unpicked.29532017-12-16T08:46:10.0334727MariaScotland has some outstanding natural habitats, don't lose them. My sister is a ranger and does fantastic work engaging the local community. Protecting and promoting wild spaces should be a priority.29532017-12-16T10:15:13.4534728MaggiIt is amazing how little most people know about the natural world, and it is therefore vital that there are people who explain and interpret it to safeguard the future of our beautiful countryside 29532017-12-17T00:59:19.07334729HeleneRangers are essential for myriad reasons and can do much to educate and support people's enjoyment of the natural world which we much protect.29532017-12-17T11:39:58.57334730DouglasYes, must be supported, and more funding plus more posts provided. I have been a volunteer in countryside access for many years, and value the support of Access Rangers. Some Councils are reducing Ranger Service, which is not a good move. Public is encouraged to be more active in the outdoors and there is a need to provide good support for this, via Ranger Services. Rangers deal with incidents where access is threatened or blocked. Their expertise and presence is necessary.29532017-12-18T00:49:18.17734731Rum RangerWe need Rangers to interpret the natural world for the general public, engage them and connect them with it! How else will we get the message over, that nature needs conserving? And that nature is essential to people?29532017-12-21T07:57:57.9634732B GrovesI agree in principle, and do personally wear my helmet 95% of the time. However I don't want to fear a fine if I don't.\r\n \r\nI also agree that those under 16 should be required to wear a helmet. \r\n \r\nWhy put a law on the books that would not truly be enforced anyway, as we do not have the resources. Awareness and perhaps a helmet campaign to provide helmets to those that feel that can't afford them seems a better use of time and resources in my humble opinion. \r\n\r\nHowever I do applaud the consideration this matter is being given. 28872017-12-22T12:43:09.11334734Darlene LacombeHopefully this is achieved and hopefully Canada will follow suit\r\n29442017-12-22T13:03:32.33334735Eris HilburnAs a patient with hidradenitis supprativa access to specialized doctors is of utmost importance to my care and well being. Because this disease effects betweem 1-4% of the population, many physicians that are not trained in a specialty are unable to give proper care and understanding to this little known disease.29442017-12-22T13:54:49.68734736LouiseHope this is put in place xx29442017-12-22T13:58:05.49734737Sharon boydHope this happens for all suffers29442017-12-23T07:19:48.84734738Steve BaxterIf there was a specialist clinic my daughter might still be alive today !!!!!29442017-12-23T10:37:30.70734739Bente Villumsen Propel with Hidradenitis Suppurativa in Scotland should have the same possibilities as we do in Denmark. 29442017-12-24T11:27:29.25734740Claire WarrenHope Scotland gets a clinic to help battle this disease29442017-12-27T15:05:28.08734741Martin Stafflingerwww.akne-inversa.org 29442017-12-28T12:29:32.3534742Anita Stunell In support of family and friends abroad 29442017-12-29T08:48:45.7234743Stuart RobertsonHaving specialists who know what they are dealing with and know how to treat illnesses that affect your life in horrendous ways is surely a good thing. A lot of gp's don't know much about anything.29442017-12-30T14:21:43.38734744Fawn Griswold As a patient myself and living with Hidradenitis Suppurativa since the age of 9 there is a real need for specialized clinics, doctors and public awareness around the world. 29442018-01-03T22:31:18.2334745Janice BernacchiA range of Help and support for sufferers is needed as is an earlier diagnosis 29442018-01-05T11:10:16.5734746NualaIn been through lots of areas consistency is a problem in treatment29442018-01-05T20:59:44.00734747Lorraine kerrThere's all sorts of help and support for other conditions why not this. It's as bad and painful for these sufferers please think about opening a clinic to help ease this condition.29442018-01-06T15:59:58.49734748Moira Mae UnderwoodAs a patient who has suffered with Hs for many years I know how important it is to get timely help. If this terrible disease is caught early enough it can be manageable. However, if left it can cost the economy so much more in lost work hours, increase in benefit use and increase use of primary and secondary care.\r\nIt is time HS sufferers are given the care and attention we deserve! 29442018-01-06T16:20:27.57734749Jane Roberts Have suffered with this awful condition for 32 years. We need a specialised treatment centre that has doctors nurses etc that know all about HS. 29442018-01-06T16:25:37.8334750Donna McKibbens A dedicated treatnent centre for those of us with HS is a necessity. Few health care professionals are not aware of the condition at all...patients and health carenworkers need more information help and access to local dedicated centres. 29442018-01-06T20:15:06.8334751Bill McCaffertyplease subscribe to this petition29442018-01-07T22:53:23.30734752Vivienne kerrI hope it raises more awareness for health proffesionals who still don't have a clue and have never heard of HS !29442018-01-08T16:25:54.85334753Mairi breckonMore needs to be done to highlight and treat this horrible skin condition that robs you of your life.29442018-01-08T19:37:50.69734754Pamelia Longboth my daughter and grand daughter plus a close friend have HS and I feel stronglyt that not enough is being done to help people suffering from it. x\r\n\r\n29442018-01-15T15:40:04.26334755Declan GardnerScotland needs private water!!!!!29732018-01-16T15:33:10.15334756ANNA MURPHYIn 1972 I set up the renal failure service for children in Scotland and developed it until my retirement in 2006.I have no hesitation in saying that by far the most distressing times for me was when I was faced with treating children with haemolytic uraemic syndrome.Many of these children were seriously ill with life threatening disease.The very sad fact was that this illness can be caused by bacteria present in contaminated water.I believe that it is imperative that the children of Scotland are not exposed to contaminated water.\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n29732018-01-16T17:09:20.3234757annavmurphyFRCPCH,FRCPGlasAs a consultant paediatric nephrologist I set up the renal failure service for children in Scotland in 1972,working in the field for over 30 years.During that time,the most distressing thing for me was being faced with children severely ill from haemolytic uraemic syndrome.This illness can be caused by bacteria in contaminated water.I believe it is imperative that maximum effort is taken to ensure that children in Scotland are not exposed to contaminated water.29732018-01-17T12:18:33.7834759THOMASHAWGOOD29442018-01-17T12:26:38.7534760THOMASHAWGOOD29732018-01-26T20:35:19.02334764AndrewwilsonWell done jimmy good luck 29442018-01-27T16:47:51.96734765Lyn LennoxMy daughter (in Scotland) has this debilitating, horrendous condition and the support and public awareness of it is non existent. Do something positive for the sufferers of whom there are many29442018-02-02T20:28:47.0734767Paula PeacockAs a twin Mum with premature babies this affect me. Please help us. 29072018-02-02T20:42:30.57334768Deborah MacLeodTwins are twice the cost but receive only half the financial and non-financial support. 29072018-02-03T08:02:15.16734769Mrs BI completely agree that more support is needed for families of multiples. Having had a singleton before the birth of my twins, I felt so much more isolated after having my twins. I felt as though I was left to it with no health visitors etc understanding the struggles some multiple parents can face. 29072018-02-03T08:40:55.94734770AimeeI think this is a very important petition. Multiple births are increasing and affecting more families. The support given is not sufficient and results in financial difficulties and hard decisions being made. Many mothers of multiples would love to return to work but are unable to as the cost of childcare is double that of a singleton. This means there is a huge disadvantage to parents of multiples. In many cases childcare is costing the same per hour as the hourly pay rate of the parent. In order to allow more parents to return to work, the government should be supporting parents of multiples. Although there is a cost to this, long term it means more families will be able to return to work. The advantages afforded to children in childcare has already been noted by the government, hence the implementation of free hours, unfortunately this rarely benefits households with one working parent and so puts children born as a multiple at a disadvantage and unable to access these services. I think this petition should be thoroughly discussed in order to offer some financial parity to the benefits parents of multiples are entitled to, to bring them in line with those that parents of singletons receive. As multiples are born at the same time, they should get the same amount of child benefit. The amount of maternity pay and leave should be increased to take into account the number of children born in each pregnancy. Multiple pregnancies are more likely to results in premature births. This means babies more babies are born earlier and are more likely to spend time in hospital, in NICU or SCBU. This means that parents do not get the same bonding time at home as parents of term babies do. In these instances the length of maternity leave should be looked at. Multiple pregnancies are higher risk and maternity leave is usually taken earlier than a singleton pregnancy. This can mean less maternity pay, if they are on sick leave when the pay is calculated. Yet another disadvantage.29072018-02-03T10:47:09.434771Kim MackayMy twins turn 3 on 9th March meaning they miss April intake for funding, I'm now possibly going to loose my job completely as I cannot afford to pay to put them both to nursery for the next 5 months until their funding begins. \r\nIt baffles me as to why people on benefits, who sit ' home doing nothing & not working get funded nursery care from the age of 2!\r\nI want to work, I strive from my career & it's something I'm passionate about but I'm not able to work to my full potential as it's just not worth my while due to high nursery costs. \r\nThis is so back to front & needs to be dealt with. 29072018-02-03T16:29:05.55734772Jennifer BlackOur twins were luckily born full terms but although the experience has been amazing and we are very blessed it has also been very stressful. The financial implications are very significant. I wasn't entitled to the surestart maternity grant because I work part time (earning very little) and we have a 3 year old. Although our babies were very healthy they were small so like most multiples spent some time in hospital, which eats away at paternity leave. \r\nAny support for parents of multiples makes an immense difference - particularly those whose babies are premature though. 29072018-02-03T20:42:09.68334773Anne KellyAs a parent of one child I have found many difficulties with being a new Mum and the support that you receive financially and emotionally. I do not believe it should be the same if you have multiple births as it is more than double the work. Everything is so much harder and the financial implications are huge to a family for day to day living. The government should be supporting families with multiple births in a way that enables them to all children the best start in life. As a teacher it is about getting it right for every child from birth and this should be considered when taking into account financial and emotional support for multiple births. 29072018-02-04T09:41:12.2334774Louise SearsonExcellentt idea, very little additional support when you have more than one baby xx\r\n29072018-02-05T07:37:52.79334775Alyson Kirkland 100% support from me. I delivered our boys early after a struggle with twin to twin transfusion syndrome. They were born at 34 weeks and spent 19 days in hospital. In that 19 days we spent a fortune, going back and forward to be with our boys. I was unable to drive after my ceasarean, when my fiance went back to work (he did this as we couldn't afford to have him off the whole time they were in hospital and he wanted to be able to spend some time with his first babies when they arrived home with us. 29072018-02-05T08:06:13.95734776Lyndsey Birrell PalmerAs a mum to triplets plus a 2 year old, we really struggled with things, particularly in the early days. We especially feel that longer paternity leave would make a huge difference as 1 parent to 3 new born babies really is a struggle. We were lucky that the triplets only spent a fortnight in hospital, but that was the fortnight of paternity leave over and we struggled after that. So to parents of multiples born more prematurely, this is even more of an issue. 29072018-02-05T08:41:52.1534777Michele Foran Is child benefit in its current form based on ability to reuse equipment etc in the case of multiple children (assuming that you have singleton births) or is it based on what the government believe is adequate support for any family regardless of number of children? I would be interested to hear if anyone knows.\r\n29072018-02-05T08:43:33.9134778Donna Birrell My sister & partner hav triplets & a toddler so feel quite strongly about this subject 29072018-02-05T10:51:56.2334779Denise mcanshthere needs to be more help and support for families \r\nand parents of multiples. There are so much more different challenges and aspects to having multiples that are not considered and catered for in current laws and legislation. 29072018-02-05T11:21:12.35334780Michelle InnardThis is a great idea and I totally agree. I have a five year old singleton child and was able to go back to work part time no problem but with my seven month old twins there is no way I can go back to work so the financial implications are huge. Good luck I hope you manage to get some success with this x29072018-02-05T13:18:30.81334781Julie McLeanI agree. It seems like inequality, almost as if families are penalised for having a multiple birth. It's quite different from having two singleton births, because that is a choice. \r\nChild benefit is money for the child's needs. I can understand why I get less for my second and third - they can wear their big brothers clothes. However, someone with multiples has to buy both at the same time. 29072018-02-05T14:00:16.71334782Lisa KellyAs a mum to 3 year old ID twin girls we have found it hard financially. My husband had to take a career break as the childcare costs were phenomenal!! Everything is double the cost. It was not a choice to have a multiple birth29072018-02-05T14:50:12.4834783alan mcfarlaneMy Son's wife had twins and it was a traumatic time for her physically.\r\n29072018-02-05T22:00:27.30734784Kerri JusticeAgree that twins or more is totally different to 2 single births and the rights and entitlement for maternity, child benefit etc do not refect the costs associated with having multiples. Maternity leave starts earlier than with single which reduced time spent with children to return to work. Child benefit for not cover cost of their being a requirement for more than one of everything. I would like to see it changed to provide better support.for those who have multiples. 29072018-02-06T15:25:47.57734785Archie KirklandBackground information puts the case accurately - worthy of consideration and support29072018-02-06T19:08:18.29734786Fiona Beattie I could not have gone back to work without the free child care given to me by my parents\r\nI am 100% behind this and the cost of having two children at the one time is huge. 29072018-02-08T20:02:36.62334787Karen ReddyCould not agree more with this petition. Parents of multiples are clearly hugely disadvantaged by the current system and that should be addressed. 29072018-02-09T10:25:31.0234788Brenda craigHaving twins or multiples is harder than single birth and should be helped accordingly 29072018-02-09T12:49:21.7934789Catherine MartinHaving twin grandsons I see the difficulty their parents have getting nursery care. It's very expensive trying to get them into nursery and trying to get back into work. Some legislation is needed to help parents financially .29072018-02-09T18:21:25.29334790Lesley McAllisterCould not agree more with this petition. More support should be avalible both emotional and financial. 29072018-02-15T15:13:05.26734791Laura Sommerville I have twins and I am more than aware of the financial difficulties that has to be addressed 29072018-02-15T19:42:36.434792Rosie WinchWhen I go back to work the nursery fees for my twins mean that I would only have £20 of my monthly salary left. 29072018-02-15T20:22:59.0434793Tracy BurkeHaving had premature twins the emotional impact is great and believe more support emotionally & financially cannot be underestimated29072018-02-15T21:50:31.50334794Paul KestertonGo Jen29072018-02-15T22:41:01.15334795AnonI would like to see more help with childcare costs for nursery under 3 or free hours allocated earlier for those with twins. Even with childcare vouchers or taxfree childcare the phenomenal cost of having 2 children under 3 at nursery means it's not financially viable for most women to return to work.29072018-02-15T22:52:42.234796Sandra logan As mother to triplets I totally agree more financial support given its a real struggle.29072018-02-16T07:22:33.78334797Rebecca TaggartI am a mum of twins on low income, why should my second twin get less money because he came out of me 7 minutes after his brother, it makes no sense! 29072018-02-16T09:07:57.5834798Gioia HendersonBoth children require the same provisions as they are growing up. However by giving one less money than the other both are considered by this financial implication to be less important than one child. This causes financial and emotional complications for parents. Perhaps if multiples were given the same provisions the would be considered equal and welcomed into society. 29072018-02-17T09:45:48.52334799Fiona Free hours for multiples would help so much. No matter what your financial status, not just for low income families. As a working family we feel penalised for working and having to pay for expensive childcare. 29072018-02-25T08:43:14.54734800Fiona AndersonI think there should be more maternity benefits when it is a multiple birth. I also feel the mother should be given longer paid maternity leave. There is a lot more expense with a multiple birth. 29072018-02-25T13:27:27.11334801Kelly YoungI was fortunate enough that my twins were born just over 3 weeks early however there are a high number of multiple births where the babies are born very prematurely. The time spent in hospital takes up most of your maternity leave which is quite sad. I had to start my maternity leave a lot earlier than I would have if i was having just the one baby. I was absolutely exhausted and could not make the daily commute to and from work. I would like to see more financial support given to families of multiple births. For example, we were not entitled to the health in pregnancy grant as we were not claiming any sort of benefit. Just because we are not entitled to any other benefits does not mean we have an abundance of money! I am not expecting the government to pay for me to look after my babies but I just feel that all the guidance, rules and criteria are all based on one baby being born at the one time. 29072018-02-27T09:55:47.40334802Sam SeddonI had to stop work earlier than I wanted due to getting so big and uncomfortable I was unable to work. So I have already started my statutory maternity pay and had my first six weeks at 90% before I have even had my twins. And I can only afford to take 5 months off work which is already worrying me. Some extra financial benefits should be put in place to help multiple mums and release some pressure. 29072018-02-27T10:39:29.72734803Claire The physical, emotional & financial burden on families is significant. It cannot be compared to the a person having a second or third child. This needs to be recognised. 29072018-02-27T11:11:39.30734804Debbie StaniforthMy twins were born almost ten weeks early and my Maternity leave started on the day they were born. We spent 2 months in hospital. I should have been on anual leave before maternity started. I had planned to finish work earlier than most with single pregnancies due to the strain on my body. I think slightly longer Maternity leave for multiple pregnancies would be a great benefit. 29072018-02-27T11:40:37.21334805LorraineMothers of twins, triplets or more are at a higher risk of suffering from post natal mental health issues and depression. The pressure and struggle of day to day life with multiples is hard and more support with free childcare hours would be a massive help. At the moment nursery for twins is in excess of £75 per day and that is with a discount. Longer maternity leave and greater financial support needs to be addressed. 29072018-02-27T12:00:07.62734806Lisa McshaneAgree totally woth everything said. I was on basic maternity afyer having my twins and it wad terrible 29072018-02-27T21:27:36.70334807LinziWhilst I was fortunate enough that my twins were born at 37 weeks and therefore did not require additional medical assistance there are a high number of multiple births where the babies are born prematurely and long hospital stays are needed. As a result a great deal of maternity leave can be spent in hospital. In addition, paternity leave often needs to be taken from the date the babies are born therefore partners are back at work before the babies are home.\r\n\r\nPersonally, I had to start my maternity leave earlier than I did with my first singleton baby, as I was physically exhausted and uncomfortable. This meant that my maternity pay started earlier than I had initially thought. I think its also important to address the financial implications of having multiple births. The maternity pay, benefits on offer are no different to those having single births and whilst I intend to return to work there is no discounts or additional support on offer in regards to childcare and nursery placements. 29072018-02-27T21:48:42.30734808Leanne As a Mum of twins born at 29 weeks, I understand all two well the struggles, emotionally and financially of having twins. My company maternity pay had ended whilst my children were still in hospital and lost out on 2 months of maternity leave whilst they were cared for in neonatal.29072018-02-27T22:02:08.634809EmmaBeing a mother of twins I strongly feel double statutory maternity leave should be offered in comparison to a single birth in terms of time and money. 29072018-02-28T16:51:59.63734810Audrey McLayMy twin grandsons were both 8 weeks early. My daughters and her partners maternity leave started on the day they were born.By the time the boys came out of special care there was hardly anytime left. They were left with a huge financial burden ..Even the cost of baby items was expensive. ie Their twin buggy was £1400 alone. 29072018-03-01T14:02:05.72334811Moira ShemiltHaving witnessed first hand, a gerrymandered council executive where the largest party has the smallest voice...I heartily endorse this petition.30162018-03-01T14:37:15.21334812Sharon Coull Definitely agree. 29072018-03-01T20:52:58.44334813WendyMultiple births are (generally) not through choice, where as singleton births are. Thus there should be more benefits available to those of multiple births.29072018-03-28T16:01:02.35334814Susan ReillyThis would actually help residents look after their homes as opposed to being worried about doing the slightest improvement, alteration or renovation and being charged £200 a time.29642018-03-28T16:03:05.7334815Susan ReillyThis is a truly unnecessary cost for residents who simply want to look after and improve their property. 29642018-03-28T17:53:57.66734816Sandy WelshWhat is fair for one should be fair for all in a democracy.29642018-03-28T19:23:01.6734817Liam MasonTo quote a local authority planning dept on developments within a conservation area: "it's better to ask forgiveness than permission". If that's the reality, then the rules are broken.29642018-03-30T06:38:01.29334818Dr. Keith N. StewartIt would be very unfair to have a planning application fee for a Listed Building or a Building within a Conservation Area. As a B-listed building owner I am very aware of the substantially higher costs of maintaining a Listed building. I am particularly concern that if such a fee were applied to those within a Conservation Area this would only lead to developments, improvements and maintenance that would simply be carried out without any reference to the Local planning department. The number of conservation areas that have been completely compromised by such an approach is sadly all too common in Scotland. Built Heritage in my view is seen as a low priority within Local Authorities' - if that planning fee was to have a positive effect on improving built heritage it may have some merit. Sadly I fear that the introduction of such a fee would make no difference to the inadequate resourcing of Built Heritage at the local level.29642018-03-30T08:37:55.0234819Roger Boyle A consultation with planning with verbal approval fooled by an email confirming it.29642018-03-30T08:39:55.5334820Joan CoverleyI live in a conservation village on the Moray Coast. I had my house painted last year, no change to colours or anything, but I wasn't even aware that I should have applied to the LA to do this, and pay £202 for the privilege of maintaining the property. Since ignorance of the law is seemingly no excuse but lots of people must be unwittingly breaking the law, then it is not good law.29642018-04-02T13:22:44.47334821Derek SmithResidents of the garden suburb should not have to pay for planning permission to make small changes to their properties.This is an outdated and unfair practice.29642018-04-02T22:02:27.38734823James WilliamsonTo deny or charge a householder from say a patio or shed or a decking area or a small summer house is surely an infringement of their equal rights. Furthermore the only way this would be enforced is to rely on neighbours reporting each other to their local authority29642018-04-04T09:45:58.12734824Michael PatersonAgree with the rationale of the request29642018-04-04T09:55:58.92734825Michael PatersonAs a member of the committee I agree with the rationale of the wording of the Petion29642018-04-08T23:46:23.80334826Louise HunterVery unfair29642018-04-23T21:10:14.64734829Ann ForbesI fully support this petition .\r\n I have contacted Carol Monaghan MP's office to inform of this petition (in case she was unaware). \r\nI hope you are aware of the tremendous contribution \r\nshe made at Committee in Westminster on this important subject .\r\nIn short , if you want to know what I think about the points mentioned below (and beyond) just ask Carol Monaghan MP who is hugely informed .\r\n30502018-04-25T18:02:27.25334830Richard ValleePlease end the discrimination against ME patients. \r\n\r\nNot a single country has found the courage and will to do so. This is something that will be historical once it happens. Be on the the right side of history.30502018-04-25T18:11:14.73734831Yvonne Cassidy I would just like to be treated like an normal human who is I'll and not have people or doctors looking at you as if you are lazy ...for more funding and understanding of this cruel disease30502018-04-25T19:06:56.21334833Fiona CulbertCompared to England ME CFS support is worse than appalling. I have watched my family members health, education and future be devastated. A fight to be suagnosed, the current NHS Scotland guidance is disregarded. There is no offer of treatment as there are no specialist resources (nor plans for any) in Scotland. Too ill to attend school, my children told repeatedly "no education unless in achool", no tutors, online curricular provision, 14 plus colleges or cute "no isolation" robots for us here. Just forgotten...30502018-04-25T19:13:05.434834Caroline CecilSomething desperately needs to happen NOW for ME sufferers - there is basically nothing for us, no treatment, no support, no empathy - it's like we don't exist. 30502018-04-25T19:24:31.0634835Maureen McIntyreFor me, the top priority by far is funding for biomedical research. We need to know the cause and, hopefully identify effective treatments for M.E. to enable us to return to leading active, productive lives.30502018-04-25T19:32:32.12334836Louise Ann McAllan I was recovering from ME and was pushed into Graded Exercise Therapy. It made me bed bound and still doctors consider me 'difficult' because I refuse to do more of it, when I know it will harm me. We need everything outlined in this petition, we deserve the same level of care and treatment as other diseases.\r\n30502018-04-25T19:33:26.2834837Janet SylvesterThere is a desperate need to support people with ME in Scotland. The fact that there is only one specialist nurse (in Fife) and no hospital based specialists at all is shocking. The Scottish Government should provide funding to the health boards for specialist nurses in each area (as it does with MND) and provide ring fenced funding for research into this terrible illness that is affecting so many lives. The funding it provides should recognise numbers of people with ME and the huge impact it has on their lives.30502018-04-25T19:35:09.6434838Nicky DelaceyPlease please please can we have done proper research, support, care and effective treatment for so many people affected by this 30502018-04-25T19:45:43.12734839jacqueline millerIf you already know it is bad or wrong, and do it anyway, you commit a sin difficult to redress.30502018-04-25T20:41:44.7934840Jackie Richards GPS and other health professionals need to be educated more about treatment and care of ME patients. 30502018-04-25T20:49:48.3234841Helen LoveMy family member has ME and this would benefit her greatly. 30502018-04-25T21:01:04.02734842Gregory CockrellIf Scotland wants to be a world leader. Here is your chance. Look after the downtrodden. 30502018-04-25T21:30:07.7834843Carol Ann McGregorI have been missing from my life for 25 years. I was bedbound for 7 years and for the rest virtually housebound with a 3 month period I was able to go out regularly. Please look ok at the biomedical evidence via the ME support organisations, revoke the current guidelines on Graded excercise (GET) and Cognitive Behavour Therapy that sees Myalgic encephalomyelitis as a psychosomatic illness and therefore ignores our symptoms. Too many suffers have deteriorated because of them. Please instead fund high quality bio medical research and appropriate treatments that are based on individuals symptoms. I want my life back so I can peruse my dreams. Please help. 30502018-04-25T21:36:49.15734844Karen ShanklandMy family member suffers with ME and I have watched him suffer for many years. I have tried to support him with the emotional challenges of his illness and the very poor response from his GPs and practice nurses in relation to his condition. There are many times they have made him feel he is wasting their time and that there is nothing wrong with him. He has not had good support at all and I have felt genuine despair and concern for him. Even the DWP were awful after he had to be medically retired. ( Thank goodness for an occ health doc knowing all about ME).\r\nI hope the Scottish Government take this petition seriously and do something that will make a difference.30502018-04-25T21:57:37.98734846Ann GammackPlease take action to help people with this devastating condition so that they are no longer missing from society.30502018-04-25T22:24:10.8234847Aidan McEvoyThis affects a member of my family in Dumfries. Her treatment has been inadequate for many many years. A review is the minimum these people deserve. 30502018-04-25T22:32:40.5734848Amanda HamzaI have fibromyalgia with chronic fatigue, during my worst I needed help to do everything but I am thankful to be doing well at the moment. 30502018-04-26T06:57:22.92334849Shona ForresterKnowing children that are affected by this condition l do hope this petition can begin to make a difference to those in desperate need of help 30502018-04-26T07:00:50.80334850jane Mcnamara Despite offering support and advice I ultimately feel as a Gp I am unable to offer patients what they need - a secondary care specialist service which is multidisciplinary for diagnosis and management. 30502018-04-26T07:27:35.19734851Arlene HaydockI have suffered for years with ME. Been disappointed that there is very little know about this illness and no help provided to deal with the symptoms. 30502018-04-26T08:16:56.5334852Alison CormackI have had ME for 6 years, am registered disabled, unable to work, have to use a wheelchair when outside and not able to look after my children for more than a few hours. At my worst I am reduced to shuffling around the house. There are so many serious and horrible diseases in the world which have medical staff to help them. Having no Dr to go and see is sole destroying.i am living on benefits with no end in sight, there is nothing more I want then to be back at work and to be a useful member of society. I just want to go for a walk.30502018-04-26T09:25:55.16734853Nancy Wilson I have Fibromyalgia ME my life is limited although I can manage it's a fight to stay upright and keep going . I was medically retired I was a Midwife that made me sad but I couldn't work any more .x\r\n30502018-04-26T11:11:14.14334854Mary RossThis is a much misunderstood condition and needs more doctors and practitioners to take it seriously. More research and understanding would be a good starting point and give some hope for those suffering 30502018-04-26T11:21:08.00334855cait ni cadlaigI have ME I also have Fibromyalgia .The 'fibro' affects me at times more than the ME But at times both kick in and it is excruciating in terms of pain and exhaustion ,Why is there no treatment (up to date) for either .Also people who have the above -as they get on they will also 'collect' other ailments along the way to further disable a person .I have 12 diagnosis including cancer But except for my GP i get hardly any treatment .Most is tried by me as I hear about of various 'treatments' But I am getting worse???30502018-04-26T11:52:34.95334856Kate Chaplin I know someone with ME in Scotland, near Inverness) whose gp doesn't believe him! Intense day and age! With all the ev there is idence there is. And the millions round the world suffering! Please help!30502018-04-26T12:49:55.05334857Jocelyn TurleyAs an M.E. patient of 9 years (with more severe symptoms & disability in the past 4 years), I understand first hand, the desperate need for greater research, education & more effective treatments for this truly devastating disease. Without these in place, tens of thousands of people in Scotland alone, are continuing to feel neglected and in total despair. Many, like me, are mostly housebound & some are even taking their own lives. So, so much more needs to be done for us all. Many patients are still being treated with great levels of ignorance within the medical profession, with doctors still referring patients for Graded Exercise Therapy (GET), etc. which is potentially extremely harmful for patients and NOT an effective course of action. Please allow for much needed discussions within Parliament in the hope of change! Thank you. 30502018-04-26T12:51:30.14734858Emma edwardsPlease support this30502018-04-26T12:59:52.44734860Chris AffordSupport for ME patients is much needed and long overdue. It would be a real statement of intent were the Scottish government to become the first in the world to appropriately fund biomedical research into ME and to provide compassionate care for ME patients30502018-04-26T13:03:39.35334861Norman Mackenzie A member of my family has suffered ME for nearly 30years now & doctors still have no idea how to treat this disabling disease 30502018-04-26T13:05:15.47734862Claire Ryan Heatley The old model of treating the patient and the myriad of complex systems involved in this condition in isolation will not address the condition as it needs to be addressed. Using a whole body, root cause , integrative approach and not simply ignoring or chasing symptoms which is what we have at present 30502018-04-26T13:47:29.21734863Patricia DavisCBT and GET do not work and do harm to people with ME. Please remove them from treatment guidelines, and provide proper patient support and research funding.30502018-04-26T13:53:12.20334864Simin Ghatineh We need proper biomedical research 30502018-04-26T14:31:51.7434865sue m.I know there is no treatment, but support of the same kind as delivered by Marie Curie or Macmillan nurses would be very appropriate.\r\nProperly trained professionals to come to the sufferer's home, assess needs and sort them out, help with paperwork and claims forms and reduce all the stress and exertion these things cause.\r\nWithout causing distress while there.\r\nExisting with ME is very hard work, we can't cope with the extra burdens.\r\nAnd a public apology from the government on how we've been treated in the past would help to reduce stigma which is another huge and unneccessary burden.30502018-04-26T14:43:06.22734866Helen HylandToo many lives have been wrecked by this cruel illness. One ME nurse for the whole of Scotland is woeful. These people need support - urgently. 30502018-04-26T14:46:28.7934867JOSEPHINEI sign this petition for all future M.E sufferers. In the hope that one day, stigma will be replaced with hope of an effective treatment. Sick at 12, now 42: Waiting to start a life... This is, mere existence.\r\n30502018-04-26T14:49:38.77334868Rob DaleyPresent understanding by GPs of the challenges of ME sufferers is disgraceful. Lack of appropriate understanding and wider support mechanisms is adding to pressure on GPs as well as increasing suffering of ME patients and the impact on their families.30502018-04-26T15:08:02.69734869Mandy Singhscotland lead the way! 30502018-04-26T15:28:06.12334870JoThis is essential...it took me over 15 years to get a proper M.E diagnosis....and I had to pay for a private consultation..as NHS G.P's would not believe me.30502018-04-26T16:23:03.0234871JulieHelp needed all over the UK. Could Scotland be the leading light? Others may follow. 30502018-04-26T16:24:39.44334872Barbara LeesI live in England. A family member was born in Scotland.\r\nI have ME.\r\nI have Scottish relatives who have friends who have ME.\r\nI hope that both devolved and UK governments will take notice of the scandalous situation for ME sufferers and their families ie failure to take on board the physical nature of this illness, failure to drop adherence to the PACE trial ideology, failure to offer adequate support to patients, failure to fund biological research commensurate with the number of people affected and the severity of their illness and disability.30502018-04-26T16:35:44.77334873Barbara LeesI would like to see improved care for people with ME in Scotland.\r\nI would like to see evidence that the government accepts that the PACE trial has been discredited in the light of its many methodological flaws and in the light of the re calculation of its results following recent disclosures of its data.\r\nI would like to see a medical speciality take on responsibility for this illness and address the accumulating scientific research on its biological underpinning.\r\nI would like to see funding for research into this illness commensurate with the number of sufferers, the severity of the illness and the degree of disability it causes.\r\nI would like to see services which are responsive to the needs, including domiciliary services where appropriate.30502018-04-26T16:37:48.83734874Sylvie JourdanPeople with M.E need to get real treatment. GET and CBT (based on fake illness beliefs) at best do not work, at worse are very harmful. We need doctors who will treat and look at each symptoms (a lot of us develop or have co-morbid conditions that aren't diagnosed and could be treated (this would help at least, even if the M.E isn't going away). Please help us, fund biomedical research and educate. 30502018-04-26T16:57:37.74334875EstherThis a terible disease please help us!30502018-04-26T17:09:43.35734876L.HunterME-CFS is a terrible ailment and I am completely left to my own devices with it. My GP is so overworked, she doesn't have time to read up on the recent research on this illness, so she is of no help to me. There is no one to turn to for advice.30502018-04-26T17:13:26.9834877L.HunterMy GP is overworked and received no training about ME-CFS at medical school. She does not have the time to read and catch up on the recent research about this ailment. I am left to my own devices, with no medically qualified person to ask for advice. There is no ME-CFS specialist in Scotland, not a single one.30502018-04-26T17:31:30.73334878Sharon LeitchMy friends daughter is affected by this awful condition - it is heartbreaking to see what she goes through everyday - she has a right to an education like every other child and this would be life changing for her and her family 30502018-04-26T17:49:31.06334879Rhona LaingPeople are suffering and nobody cares 30502018-04-26T19:37:33.67734881Jane Moodley Please research ME30502018-04-26T20:26:49.49734883John GrantLocal dedicated M.E teams in each trust30502018-04-26T20:41:49.0434884Helen I hope petition helps 30502018-04-26T20:45:56.2234885Rosamund Lee-HarperI have had ME for 10 years. I am not aware of any me nurse in Surrey. I see an immunologist every 6 months..I have had carers and care agencies nobody has heard of ME. Its staggering the lack of knowledge about the condition.30502018-04-26T20:49:24.3334886Christie LovePlease help those who need it so desperately.30502018-04-26T20:59:25.1934887Melanie meston Signed and shared 30502018-04-26T21:06:58.68334888Pauline RossIt is totally heartbreaking how little research money is available for ME....also the lack of knowledge and understanding by the medical profession is astounding !!30502018-04-26T21:15:05.90334889eileen munroPeople have t stop dying or being put under mental health care due to lack of proper medical care or deliberate misleading facts. 30502018-04-26T21:26:29.93734890Kim foxonPeople with M.E. desperately need support and action now!30502018-04-26T22:35:44.91334891Toni HiggsMyalgic Encephalomyelitis is as devastating as Multiple Sclerosis, Parkinson's Disease, AIDS and Cancer yet it gets treated by psychologists who believe that it's psychosomatic despite the fact that the World Health Organisation classified it as a Neuro-Immune Disease way back in 1969. \r\n\r\nThis is not on. People who are affected the most (housebound or bedbound) are effectively being left to die and that needs to change.30502018-04-26T22:42:56.7534893Richard ShorterHow can it be right that such a severe illness can have no money spent on research when the first thing we were told was that the cause was unknown and there was no known cure. Surely it is time to start finding answers?30502018-04-26T22:54:33.5834894Sandra Wilson-GreeneAll aspects of general health should be represented whithin our NHS and there should definitely be a specialist within all recognised areas of health. 30502018-04-26T23:08:34.51334895KatrineTogether we will change the world30502018-04-26T23:27:36.30334896Peter RussellIdentification may have improved, but the lack of initial recognition is part of a very inconsistent pattern of care. Treatment depends on universal recognition of the nature of the illness, and the acknowledged therapy uniformly applied30502018-04-27T02:09:35.99334897alan tippingwhy is it advantageous for governments to ignore the truth when it comes to complex diseases. these diseases will not just go away and become someone elses problem. open your eyes to more than 60 years of medical data.30502018-04-27T07:45:52.14734899Erica EelePlease invest in biomedical research and support programs for people with MECFS, similar in scale to support programs for people suffering other major diseases such as Parkinsons. Funding must be commensurate with the disease burden.\r\n\r\nYour efforts must particularly address youths with MECFS. MECFS is now the largest cause of long-term sickness absences from school among UK youths, according to Dr Elizabeth Dowsett who conducted the largest epidemiological study of its type.30502018-04-27T08:01:45.52334900Ann CourtneyPlease treat us with digity30502018-04-27T09:15:51.65734901Hannah GrundyI'm signing to help my friends and family in Scotland that have either been affected by this illness or could be in the future and in the hope that Scotland could lead the way for other parts of the UK to follow suit30502018-04-27T09:55:12.91734902maralyn hepworthThings MUST change. It ruins not just the lives of sufferers, but their families to. 30502018-04-27T10:09:16.19734903Anna PrattGET should never be prescribed as an efficient treatment for any stage of M.E. and I am shocked it still is !! CBT on the other hand did help me but it was taylored for M.E. and run from a M.E. specialist centre in Leeds, come on Scotland where is the support for your people !! 30502018-04-27T10:13:50.90334904Brenda Young Please help m e sufferers and other disabilities.30502018-04-27T10:51:12.11334905Dorothy McNicollME sufferers are desperate for research into the causes and treatment of the disease. Let's have some real action now.\r\n30502018-04-27T12:46:30.77334906Angela HolmPeople are suffering so deeply with so little hope in Scotland. Professionals need to be informed and we must stop the harmful recommendations currently in use. 30502018-04-27T13:01:19.07334907Kim FoxonPeople. With M.E. desperately need support and funding for appropriate treatment!30502018-04-27T13:52:09.48734908Alison OrrPlease refer to the International Consensus Criteria for a proper definition of what ME is. Please use Invest in ME, a charity run by volunteers which has been doing amazing work on bringing international researchers together.30502018-04-27T15:16:27.01334910ann birdswe all need proper treatment for this vile evil illness..30502018-04-27T16:27:02.8134911JannikWithout research for ME hundred of thousands people will die the next years due to no treatment or wrong treatment (e. g. GET).\r\nEveryone can get this disease at any time and only about 3% get health and there previous power, a lot of will be nursing case.30502018-04-27T17:02:57.25334912Emma GardnerVital that funds are allocated for research and appropriate support is given to M.E. patients. \r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n30502018-04-27T17:40:46.8634913FMPlease take action soon.30502018-04-27T17:43:48.78334914Teresa Kavanagh mckie A member of my family contracted ME in her teens now 27 yrs old and confined to a wheelchair as classed as too severe to be treated with conventional methods etc pace tests , it's effect upon whole family are extremely testing & I am her main carer on extremely low wage for 24:7 care daily living assistance needs please make this condition more recognisable in GP & parliament as it's not just being alittle tired or all in mind it's biologically proven to be a physical condition effective by every fibre of the individuals life 30502018-04-27T19:01:18.17734915Linda McMillanFor 17 years I suffered in silence because the medical professionals in my area ignored my symptoms and diagnosed me with depression. I felt very let down and confused because I knew I wasn't depressed. I did my own research and discovered I had all the symptoms of M.E.CFS and in 2015 I finally found a GP who listened and I got my diagnosis after my 2nd visit. Why does it take so long for people like me to get a diagnosis and be believed by the medical profession? More money needs to be poured into educating the medical profession on hidden illnesses like mine. More money needs to be available for research into the cause and cure of this debilitating illness. This is no way to live. Also it should be made easier for those of us who are unable to work to claim benefits and not be put through these degrading, embarrassing and very stressful capability for work assessments. Even the form filling is very stressful for us. Please please please take this petition seriously and provide us with some hope of a better future. Thanks 30502018-04-27T21:36:22.08334916Bonnie Ruggiero I have MEand I'm from the United states. I've been suffering for 23 years. We so desperately need funds for research, disability for patients who can no longer work. Home health aids, health insurance that covers ME. Education for doctors and public. Were dying please help us.30502018-04-28T05:43:41.23334917Leonie wattIts shocking the lack of treatment people have had in this day and age. About time wrongs were righted. 30502018-04-28T06:10:53.98734918Brenda marshallI would like to see more care for people with ME in Scotland 30502018-04-28T10:21:15.22334919Sarah CockrellWe need more hands on support. We need GPs to be trained in it. We need it to be taught correctly at medical school- especially including the differences between general chronic fatigue, fatigue, chronic fatigue syndrome, and ME (with cardinal symptom of post exertional malaise) distinguished between. Too many people are living a life of the living dead. This has got to stop. The disease burden is greater than many other diseases yet it is ignored - massively increased funding for research is imperative and urgent!30502018-04-28T10:37:57.89334920Suzanne If Scotland lead England no Ireland will follow\r\nFingers crossed \r\n8 years bedbound\r\nMissing my life 30502018-04-28T11:14:14.60734921CJThis is an extremely important petition to sign. I have had ME for the last 3 years. My GP recommended me GET(Graded Exercise Therapy) which made my condition much much worse! And now they have put me on an 18 week waiting list to see someone for CBT(Cognitive behavioural therapy).This is too long to wait, as ME is causing me severe depression. We need to work on the care provided and the research into this evil disease!30502018-04-28T11:54:25.92734922Helen SmithIn 30 years of ME, regrettably doctors, while in my experience empathetic have no idea how to find a care pathway for this disease. Cancer treatment has left me worse off but at least the surgron was honest enough to say he did not know enough about ME. Time for change expired a long time ago when the cross party group ceased to meet.30502018-04-28T13:08:28.37334923Carol Mathieson I would definitely like to see very much improved treatment and care for people with ME in Scotland.30502018-04-28T13:11:32.434924Miriam ConnorSeven years of ignorance has robbed a family member of her mobility and self esteem. First do no harm... NHS funds wasted on trying to prove it is anything but her diagnosed conditions. ME, POTS, MCAD. 30502018-04-28T13:20:15.16734925Lucina AlwynI have suffered from this devastating disease for 21 years and it has ruined my life. Yet no treatment on horizon30502018-04-28T13:40:10.234926J kellyWe need medication like m.s patients get , why are we not treated the same .i have been battling for many ,many years. Not listened to , not taken seriously . It just is not good enough . GET is a joke, meditation , people being condescending and telling you what to do who do not have a clue .30502018-04-28T14:06:31.6334927Patricia BrownThere millions suffering from ME all over the world. We need help NOW. Some are dying and others feel like they'd dying in pain. The fact that Scotland has NO specialist help is appalling. 30502018-04-28T17:39:06.23734928Sandra DillonI think the Scottish Government should be doing more to help fund research in to a cure or treatment to help all those affected by this terrible illness. In not doing so they are failing over 20,000 scottish people 30502018-04-28T17:59:38.94334929Richard BrownGovernments worldwide need to wake up to the fact that this illness is real. It doesn't kill large amounts of people but it wrecks millions of people's lives both sufferers and family members.30502018-04-28T19:15:53.67334930brenda bergerMy family member suffers from me in scotland30502018-04-28T20:45:43.74734931Angela MillerWe need to move treatment forward. 30502018-04-28T20:54:32.01334932Dale Newlands I think it is time that the Scottish government funded clinics and a centre of excellence for Me in Scotland 30502018-04-28T21:08:47.87734933Beryl ArmstrongI gave know friends and colegues diagnosed with ME as far back as 1990 and this needs to be recognised as one needs extra support and care in Scotland the whole of the UK and funded.30502018-04-28T21:38:08.00334934Denise NevillPatients must be listened too \r\nChange is needed now 30502018-04-28T22:25:09.60734935Celia BowhayThis disease needs serious research funds .30502018-04-28T22:29:14.82334936Michaela SandersAs a patient of this illness, the suffering is indescribable. The fact we are overlooked because of how sick we are - unable to protest and raise awareness, is a cruel cycle with devastating consequences that needs to end. Where is the humanity around the world when it comes to our illness? Please please help us.30502018-04-29T00:20:32.734937Morag Thornton People suffering ME need to be acknowledged \r\nThey need an official diagnosis so they can be taken seriously \r\nPeople with ME need support to live with their condition 30502018-04-29T10:04:29.67334938Irene. I'll now over 30 years we appear to be going backwards in treatment and acceptance 30502018-04-29T10:49:07.09734939Diane SmailScotland needs more help with M.E, more medical staff, more recognition and support for sufferere's. 30502018-04-29T12:18:06.43734940Elena GimsonDue to the lack of professional care and told to just push through by doctors a member of my family went from mild to housebound.30502018-04-29T20:54:47.90334942Sarah GriffithsM.E. sufferers are treated criminally and if it was any other serious disease there would be an out-dry. M.E. is a multi-systemic, neurological, mitochondrial disease that destroys lives and yet people are left to cope alone, with Doctors and government showing no care, understanding, compassion or empathy, which is shameful and disgusting. You wouldn't dare treat any other desperately ill people so monstrously.. 30502018-04-30T12:35:19.3434943Ann ForbesPlease speak to Carol Monaghan MP who has an excellent grasp of this subject.\r\nPlease recommend that GET and CBT therapy be discontinued .\r\nPlease ensure that all NHS Health Board Areas will \r\n(not can) appoint the services of ME Specialists\r\nfor the approx. 15,000 people who suffer from this condition .\r\n30502018-04-30T20:47:38.22734944Sarah McIntyreME just appaling. Are there any alternative treatments that work? 30502018-05-01T02:10:46.97334945Kristin Stempf de VargasStudies have found that ME places a greater burden on those afflicted with it than do many of the most serious diseases of of our time including schizophrenia, cancer, stroke, multiple sclerosis and Type I diabetes. This alone should motivate improved care, treatment and income support for people with ME in Scotland.30502018-05-01T08:56:24.55334946Sheila Wilson Stop GET it's left me 90% bedridden 30502018-05-01T11:46:39.84334947Rebecca FrenchI was first diagnosed with ME in 1998. Since that time I have had no specialist care for the condition. I am housebound and unable to access basic healthcare services such as the dentist or Women's Health checkups. I live under the shadow of benefit reform, currently there is no way for me to purchase a much needed bath lift, and no provision of funds for it. I fall through every crack in the system, alongside the thousands suffering with this life sentence in Scotland.30502018-05-01T17:30:48.33334948Muriel MackenzieI will always sign petitions for neurological conditions 30502018-05-01T21:37:14.17334949Pat Moncur Scotland has a very good record for good health care and research, but we do need to do more for me sufferers 30502018-05-02T10:10:04.48734950Christine BerryI have suffered with M.E. for 23 years. I've been through a really bad time for the past two years. I only have two good days a month. I am only too glad to help others suffering with M.E. in any way I can30502018-05-02T10:11:01.6934951Christine BerryI have suffered with M.E. for 23 years. I've been through a really bad time for the past two years. I only have two good days a month. I am only too glad to help others suffering with M.E. in any way I can30502018-05-02T10:11:38.6134952Marco CattaneoA member of my family is affected by this terrible illness, which needs to be recognised as such by governments, health services and the medical profession30502018-05-02T10:13:00.42334953David McguinnessWe need to be as one30502018-05-02T10:14:06.86334954R L BradleyId like to see an improvement in care and treatment of all ME patients worldwide. Start in scotland and show the world how cool you scotland is!!30502018-05-02T10:14:48.65734955Emily BurnsAs a doctor and a scientist who has worked in biomedical ME research it is clear to me that a review is urgently needed. Not only have many legitimate concerns been raised regarding he evidence base for GET CBT but furthermore there is mounting high quality data published from reputable institutions such as Stanford University, that show immunological abnormalities in ME patients. These findings are in keeping with phase II data suggesting targeted immune modulation (Rituximab) maybe be an effective treatment for some patients with ME. When the social, economical and personal costs of ME are so high to continue to ignore this changing understanding is wasteful and harmful. 30502018-05-02T10:16:45.62734956Pam KentI would like a similar petition to be presented to the English parliament.30502018-05-02T10:17:56.25334957Lavinia CapognaSolidariety with M.E patients in Scotland30502018-05-02T10:20:03.7434958Gill HarrodPlease give appropriate support to ME suffers. Making them exercise can cause worse pain. More research into this condition and training is badly needed.30502018-05-02T10:20:54.9934959Alex CheungScotland could lead the way for the rest of the UK to find solutions to this very debilitating chonic condition. Fresh thinking is urgently needed.30502018-05-02T10:21:53.89734960Raymond Henderson Urgent reviews of this debilitating illness required to help us ME sufferers 30502018-05-02T10:24:54.00334961Arthur B. RankenI am an activist for the Australian Government to fund research, treatment awareness and publicity into this this shocking destructive and depressive health condition that is maiming so many in our community30502018-05-02T10:28:55.36334963Marian AndersonM.E. deserves a break! Not enough research, no treatment or cure. Failed management strategies have been harmful to people with such a serious illness such as CBT and GET).\r\nPlease make serious funding a priority - research, compassion, treatment urgently needed for a late group of patients who have been ignored for too long.30502018-05-02T10:30:53.634964Nicky DelaceyPlease let us have recognition, support and an effective treatment nationwide for people with cfs me 30502018-05-02T10:32:10.92734965Julia ReidJustice for people with ME means a fair allocation of funding commensurate with the burden of disease in research, medical and disability support services, advocacy, and actual effective treatment!30502018-05-02T10:36:13.33334967Sharon goodwin This suffering as gone on too long . We need help .30502018-05-02T10:39:22.66334968Lyn BowmanCongrations on this initiative.30502018-05-02T10:41:32.91334969Laura Stecklerdesperately needed!30502018-05-02T10:41:58.4634970Edwin ThwaitesScotland has an opportunity to be the world leader in ME research and care. Take it30502018-05-02T10:43:30.72334971Sam PearceI was born in UK but moved to South Africa when I fell ill with ME 25 years ago as I could not access benefits and was crippled by the cold climate30502018-05-02T10:49:46.52334972Susan GrundyA member of my family lives with this debilitating condition which is still very much misunderstood. More research into the causes of a condition that affects so many young people destroying their lives. Support and therapies that help them to tolerate the condition will alter the quality of their lives a thousand fold.Please support this petition.30502018-05-02T10:55:38.27334973Christine KnottAmerican researchers have found something in the plasma are shutting energy cells down. The UK are way behind in their approach to this debilitating illness. Please sign the petition.30502018-05-02T11:02:57.47734975Keith Bradbury I am a sufferer of 33 years30502018-05-02T11:11:18.63734977Jonathan MyallWould be so good for Scotland to take a lead but would be good for the UK as a whole too30502018-05-02T11:17:22.46734978Brendan W RobinsonWhy has this vile disease been left for only the patients and their families to deal with? Where's government help in medical research and care giving? There should be an inquiry into why. \r\nI suspect those accountable are the psychiatric community for hijacking the illness as in their realm, knowing full well it was all along a physical disease. And also the health insurance industry who were too, bank rolling the top psychiatric researchers to fudge results in order not to pay out millions in patient claims. They blamed it on the patients minds so they didn't have to pay out. I'm sure thats what happened. \r\nBut for years there has been proof this is a biological disease that has destroyed peoples lives, while all the much needed funding went to those criminals 30502018-05-02T11:19:39.82334979Fred Vintner30+ years of my life with this condition and healthy politicians have little interest or curiosity about how one in a hundred and fifty of us are missing from their constituency or the wider world. Because we are invisible - the condition is invisible.30502018-05-02T11:23:00.96734980Penelope EvansM.E. is a very debilitating illness affecting thousands of people.Funding for medical research must be allocated to try and find a cure. The current recommended medical advice for ME sufferers of graded exercise ais positively harmful for patients, and CBT denies that the disease is neurological as accepted by the World Health Organisation. Treating the illness as being psychological merely compounds the diffiulties faced by those suffering this terrible illness. 30502018-05-02T11:26:03.07334982Ruth WiegratzI've suffered long enough.30502018-05-02T11:30:17.66734984Michael FieldA member of my family has been diagnosed with a MILD degree of ME.. When I see how even this level of the disease has so badly affected her life, my heart goes out to all sufferers of this most debilitating condition.30502018-05-02T11:35:28.62334985Roseann AirensI have had M.E. for almost 20 years. We need more research into this misunderstood illness and support to help us adjust to the limitation we now have to live with. With more research we could hopefully get some treatment and eventually find the cause or even a cure. Without this funding we are left to struggle with no adequate care or support. Please sign this petition to help many others like me. Thanks30502018-05-02T11:38:00.70334986BettyGet rid of the harmful GET and CBT program. Many people are permanently disabled because they did this program! Fund ME its a debilitating illness. More needs to be done to ensure people are not forgotten and left languishing in their beds. 30502018-05-02T11:38:49.81334987Deborah CauserPeople with ME want justice and ethical science.30502018-05-02T11:38:54.3434988Terri Ana ScottI am a ME & Fibromyalgia patient and more of these ccentres are very much needed. 30502018-05-02T11:45:43.59334989Alyse Lopez-SalmEvery disease that debilitates like this one does deserves ample research!30502018-05-02T11:48:1634990Donna smith I v had ME for 13 years . 30502018-05-02T11:50:41.32734991Amy HouseA member of my family has been living with ME for 10 years. Support and treatment of this condition is needed.30502018-05-02T11:53:27.82734992Marilyn WallmanI have had ME or CFS for 20 years without any helpful advice or treatment from the NHS. I survived with the help of proficient complementary therapists but I had to give up a well paid job to get well. Scotland is missing out on utilising the brain power of very knowledgeable, qualified and bright people. 30502018-05-02T12:06:31.75334993Cecile MacLeodI was diagnosed with ME away back in 2003 by Monklands Hospital and then again in 2004 by Glasgow Royal Infirmary. But like most people I believe I was suffering from ME for many years before that. I had to give up work and try and concentrate on 'getting better'. Unfortunately after trying all manor of things, I am still the same. In the twenty years or so of having ME there has not been the same awareness with the public and medical profession as other 'silent' diseases. Not only do we need funding but we need awareness. We are more understanding of depression and how thank can't be seen. Why are we alone with this. We matter too! Not only do we live with this day in and day out we have to grieve for a life we may never have back again. We also have to deal with the non believers. We don't get accepted for benefit payments. We have to work out who is trying to con us out of money with promises of a cure. People with ME don't want to have ME!! We are the forgotten people. Enough is enough. Sadly we are too ill to fight for our rights. We need help to get help. How sad is that. Let Scotland lead the way. Do us proud Scotland. We are your people too. 30502018-05-02T12:08:45.84734994Suzanne Enough my life is gone\r\nFrom active fitness instructor to dance teacher to 8 years bedbound\r\nDo you really believe am lazy or just tired!!! 30502018-05-02T12:09:25.5534995Eveline Virginia WebbI first became ill in Scotland 35yrs ago_what an absolute godsend a centre of expertise would have been Still today it is needed even more!!!The suffering that is endured by individuals that have this horrible illness must be recognised&addressed!!30502018-05-02T12:17:52.3534996SuME offered an opportunity for medicine to explore new avenues, and develop care partnerships with patients, who have been let down by an out of date model30502018-05-02T12:18:09.67734997Ana SempleIn 2002 the Chief Medical Officer for Britain said ME Chronic Fatigue Syndrome is a serious and disabling illness. In Scotland we still do not have any dedicated medical provision for most patients after diagnosis.30502018-05-02T12:19:33.87734998Mrs Mary H YoungIt is vital theft research is done into this dreadful debilitating illness. A member of my family has suffered fir the past six years,our GP practice have very poor perception and can offer no ongoing assessment or appropriate treatment to help with the constant pain and struggle in patients daily lives.30502018-05-02T12:22:10.03334999Dorothy RadleyI wish to show solidarity with Sottish ME sufferers by signing this petition. I would like to see improved care & treatment fir people with ME in Scotland. Scottish government should provide full support for people with ME as they do for people with cancer. The burden of this disease on Scotland is immense. I would like to see Scottish government funding on a par with the burden the disease has on Scotland. I have lived a living death with this disease for 30 years and I am still living the nightmare.30502018-05-02T12:25:17.6635000Claire Armstrong-BrealeyI have had ME for over thirty years undiagnosed and diagnosed, we are still no further on. This illness is a killer. 30502018-05-02T12:26:50.39735001josie mintoWe have all suffered being ignored for long enough, time for action. I've been moderately affected from childhood & am now 71!30502018-05-02T12:43:48.69735002LeighScotland has lead the way in so many health issues before - please lead the way in this too by providing proper research, education and care. So much suffering could have been prevented if medical professionals had been taught about this condition and how to treat it - and importantly, how not to treat it. The same happened with MS years ago! 30502018-05-02T12:47:56.4335003LeeAnn BoydI suffer from this illness, and it is devastating. I had to leave my successful business career, and can now barely socialize. It takes all of my energy just to take care of myself, and I must lie down alone with complete quiet for hours every day. This is not living, this is staying alive. I never complain about my illness but the lack of healthcare and research we receive for a common and devastatingingly disabling illness is a human rights crime. I have been sick for 18 years.30502018-05-02T12:49:15.02335004JanetSomeone, somewhere within the recognized healthcare hierarchy needs to stop the institutional attitude of ignoring of this illness in the hope that it will go away. It won't. I have been hanging on to hope for 25 years and cannot get those wasted years back. Please try to prevent this happening to others.30502018-05-02T12:50:29.9635005Elyse Silverman JackI'm barely able to type this because of what the illness has done to me. No one should be without the option of real medical help no matter where they live. Everyone has the right as a living human being to be treated with respect. We are all God's creatures, even if you don't believe in God, ALL of our lives matter so need to be cherished no matter the circumstance. We have a duty to each other to help one another & that is exactly what the government is supposed to be doing, period.30502018-05-02T12:52:11.7935006Anthony FryerME is a physical illness which is determined by symptoms including Post exertional malaise. Graded Exercise Therapy is not acceptable30502018-05-02T12:57:03.41335007Margaret TurleyIt is a hidden illness that needs help30502018-05-02T13:01:52.77735008Ewart ShawI'm signing this because someone dear to me has had ME for ten years. It's a devastating condition, poorly understood, and many people with ME have been treated very badly by politicians, psychiatrists, and the NHS in general.30502018-05-02T13:03:58.24335009Rebecca MartinI want to see research being done and new treatment established for those suffering from ME. I want there to be specialists to be brought to scotland to train doctors on effective treatment options. Training for primary care doctors and specialist to refer out to. this need is immediate. let's step up to thee cause. 30502018-05-02T13:10:33.46335010KirstenI've had such a tough time with this illness and could really do with a break. Please help us. 30502018-05-02T13:18:14.735011Abigail MartinGiven the number of sufferers of this disease it is unacceptable that research is not funded and patients continue to be dismissed as it being a psychological problem. 30502018-05-02T13:33:02.24735012Andy VennemanAs a care giver for someone with ME-CFS I urge you to help get these people their lives back by supporting in anyway possible the research needed to solve ME-CFS.30502018-05-02T13:43:39.51335013Ginette NeaultI have the disease since 1990 and I understand you.\r\nI pray for all who have this disease. Courage!30502018-05-02T13:45:26.82735014Ginette NeaultHi, I have the disease since 1990. I understand you. I pray for you. Courage! 30502018-05-02T13:52:40.07735015Mary WakefieldI have had ME for 23 years, therefore fully support this Petition30502018-05-02T13:55:17.3335016Bjarke LauritzenJustice and equality in treatment for ME patients around the globe!30502018-05-02T14:14:38.67735017John AmodioA member of my family is of Scottish descent and has had her life significantly constrained by this devastating disease, as has millions more. One of her deepest desires is to visit Scotland. Your research could be the difference in making this happen for her and millions others. 30502018-05-02T14:20:42.42735018Carolyn MoserUntil I saw the documentary Unrest on Myalgic Encephalomyelitis I had no idea how serious this condition is. It literally steals their life away and the lives of their families who must care for them. The only way to discover the best treatment is research, research and more research. What does not work is graded exercise therapy GET and cognitive behavioral therapy CBT. This is a disease not a mental illness. Stop prescribing what doesn't work. Be part of the success in finding genuine medical treatment. It is so critical for the people who live in these daily prisons.30502018-05-02T14:21:27.7135019Sarah MastersIt is critical the the medical and scientific communities around the world take this illness seriously and fund research for hard science to determine the underlying causes of this illness. For those afflicted the condition is a prison or worse. Please take time to learn more about the illness and find funds for research and care. Two useful places to start are the award winning documentary UNREST and the website of the Open Medicine Foundation in California, a group initiating and funding progressive scientific research. Please, please look carefully at the issue. Sarah Masters, family member of a 30 year old whose life is being stolen by this illness.30502018-05-02T14:29:32.1335020trace newtonThe chaos surrounding diagnosis and treatment affects people who don't have M.E. too! I was diagnosed with it and as a result no further investigations were made. Turns out I probably had premature ovarian failure and a variety of inherited conditions. Had I not been diagnosed with M.E., I may have been able to access necessary treatment a lot earlier. Misdiagnosis of M.E. has adversely affected my physical health.30502018-05-02T14:32:02.8235021Jackie My dad has ME took it over a year to be diagnosed. I want him to be able to live life freely and enjoy my wedding this summer. 30502018-05-02T14:39:20.30335022kayleigh kavanaghthis disease is horrific. before ME I was an active overachiever with big plans and all the energy in the world. If i put my mind to something, nothing could stop me. Unfortunately it was this same determination that led me to push and push my body, combined inaccurate information about exercise helping this illness - it doesn't the biomedical evidence proves it makes it worse, see dr Sarah Myhill's book "Diagnosis and Treatment of Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and Myalgic Encephalitis Second Edition: it's mitochondria, not hypochondria". that led me from mild to moderate ME to being Severe. I have now been severe for over 5 years, 6 this September. unfortunately, my story isn't unusual, a lot of patients followed incorrect and dangerous medical advise that led them to become much worse, then we are repeatedly told that we are the problem. we did this to ourselves, we wished this on ourselves, it is our faulty thinking that is keeping us unwell. the only insane part about this situation is that with ample biomedical proof showing there are lots of physical things going on, these studies still aren't being funded and what little money there is keeps going to psychology. It is embarassing. I currently live in stirling. it is a beautiful city and I see why the scottish are so proud of their country. but they are failing a large community of their people. and unless more biomedical research is funded, even more people will disappear and become a part of the "millions missing" whilst they, like me, lie sick in bed, wondering why are we having to fight this battle alone and what can i do when i struggle to lift a cup to my lips, to move my limbs, to think a cohesive sentence. we need more funding for research, we need more help with housing, we need to be a priority on housing lists to get us into suitable accomodation, to get doctors who understand this disease, not who believe the incorrect spiel spouted by pace trial authors&the media with an agenda true science doesnt lie30502018-05-02T14:39:54.13335023Carrie McCullochA family member was unable to sit his GCSEs because of ME and has been bed or housebound for the last 3 years. His friends have gone on to higher education, make friends, work and form relationships while he is stuck. This is a horrific disease that robs people and their families of their lives.30502018-05-02T14:52:15.49335024Karen DodsworthHealthcare professionals need to be educated on how to treat ME patients without actually (albeit unintentionally) making them worse. Also any harmful treatment e.g. GET should be discontinued immediately. The research to prove that it is harmful and the effects of PEM (post exertions malaise) have been in the public domain for long enough for it to have filtered down to the medical profession to act upon it. Guidelines urgently need to be created for all those involved in any aspect of care of ME patients. I've lost count of the number of times I've been told ME? I don't know anything about that! by medical professionals. 30502018-05-02T14:59:08.16735025Rachel EwuloyeThis is a real illness that is very debilitating. Let's help raise awareness and sign this petition.30502018-05-02T15:09:34.9835026Melissa Adkinson ME is real. It can strike anyone at anytime. It can happen to you or someone you love. Please help those affected by doing more research and providing community supports. Their lives depend on it.30502018-05-02T15:13:48.2635027Kirsty WhiteME is a hugely debilitating illness, with no treatment and little support. Investment in ME research and care would assist people who are suffering, to get their lives back. It would also boost the economy as hundreds of people, could begin their working lives again.30502018-05-02T15:18:20.18335029Jennifer CaldwellI am in the US and have ME. It has devastated my life. Healthcare professionals need to be properly educated about the seriousness of this chronic neurological-immune disease that effects multiple systems. Our governments need to invest millions of dollars into research. The economic burden to society is billions of dollars and something needs to be done to develop treatments and give these struggling patients and their families relief. 30502018-05-02T15:19:13.35735032KirstyME is a hugely debilitating illness. Investment in research and care would allow people suffering to get their lives back. It would further be an investment in the economy as this would allow many people to return to or begin their working lives. 30502018-05-02T15:33:33.26735033Marcia Complex symptoms need joined-up medical approach, so a ME Center for Excellence makes sense. Need immunologist, geneticist, cardiologist & endrinologist, allergy-aware dietician, & those with understanding of non-synergetic medicines too. Neurobiologist with Lyme Disease expertise. Dental aspect also needs addressing. Rheumatology for Fibromyalgia etc. 30502018-05-02T15:42:36.45335034Marie MeikeHave Myalgisk encefalemyelit and hope for treatment every day30502018-05-02T15:56:10.83335036Jennifer MarsPlease help us!30502018-05-02T16:00:40.7735037Linda HobbsI have had ME and then Fibromyalgia for the last 30 years and it has completely changed the way I have to live my life. My heart goes out to all those sufferers around the world in a similar situation. People look at you and think you look OK, but they have no idea of the suffering pain and fatigue that we live with every day. It is like having severe flu every day. Extra funding into research, more training for doctors and health care professionals and specialist care for patients, as well as discontinuing GET and CBT exercise treatments would be extremely beneficial. I strongly urge the Scottish government to vote in favour of these changes, to help people with this dreadful condition, who are so often overlooked.30502018-05-02T16:04:15.00335038Victoria LangleyI am signing because I went to physio 5 times and only one physio knew knew what ME was. I am seeing them for arthritis but need care to fit. My last ones opening sentence was ok well first thing we need to do with you is cardio. I sat there and went, is that meant to be a joke? Can I just check that you have read my notes and what I am diagnosed with? she said no. I proceeded to say ME and that cardio would 100% put me in bed ill, her reply was why? whats ME? I said ok end of appt! 30502018-05-02T16:06:47.17335039CarolME is a life-altering, severely debilitating illness that can often be invisible as sufferers cope behind closed doors. While healthy individuals get on with their lives e.g. work, socialize, go to school, have children, etc. those with ME are often in a darkened room, day after day, year after year barely functioning. Please support this devastating condition so we can figure out what causes it and find the cure. 30502018-05-02T16:12:40.75335040Mike SawatskyIt is time to step uo and help the people that have been ignored for so long while ignoring all the neurological damages of prescriptions. It is a little embarrassing to have them ignore patients when pharamceuticals have been linked to brain injury and it is only ignored. The numbers are staggering and the incompetence is a little too much to stomach30502018-05-02T16:23:22.7735041Alan Christopher Creaser,The Best of health & luck to sufferer's worldwide!!... :)30502018-05-02T16:23:37.74335042Sonia CantellowImportant to get our voice heard and make positive changes in Scotland.30502018-05-02T16:29:46.3835043Kathe V. BrownLeave the CBT and GET behind with the leeches, the 21st century medicine demands real treatments, not quackery.30502018-05-02T16:38:07.38335044Alison KnockerThis is a devastating disease made all the worse by ignorance and lack of appropriate treatment. My family member has already wasted several years of a budding career - let's try to understand the causes and find effective treatment. 30502018-05-02T16:40:46.19735045MariaME is a terrible illness that strikes so many. People like myself end up extremely ill & bedridden. Please assist the many people suffering by providing research funds and medical care,30502018-05-02T16:47:40.24335046Elizabeth RossI have Fibromyalgia and the GET practice needs stopping for this too, as it does not work. I wish we had the same in the UK. I hope this petition is successful.30502018-05-02T16:58:24.56735047Sandra Ferguson I am one of the millions that this disease has robbed of everything good in life 30502018-05-02T17:17:02.23335048Kim BoehmWe would like to see improved care for ALL ME patients in the UK. It is so important to see a change.30502018-05-02T17:47:26.20735049Lisa WhitePlease don't make parents choose between a discredited therapy that will cause their child harm, and losing custody of the child they love. That shouldn't happen to anyone. Put yourself in their place and have empathy.30502018-05-02T17:56:34.73335050Suzanne BeaudoinKeep the good work30502018-05-02T18:05:17.66335051Pippa HurleyI have been suffering M.E. since I was 15. For 45 years indeed! It never goes, you simply get better times than the norm if you are lucky! My life has pretty much passed me by, having been sapped for nearing 5 decades, and now suffering different life eroding medical issues, I am looking forward to it ending! The (English) government at Westminster do not care, never have, about the hundreds of thousands of us suffering here and have NEVER done anything to help! You could at least show them up by doing something in Scotland!30502018-05-02T18:16:18.81335053Cari WilsonPlease put in place doctors who are aware of the issues surrounding ME, and the need for suitable support all over Scotland. 30502018-05-02T18:22:09.8635054Jill SummersWe need better diagnosis. A test to diagnose the condition rather than a system of ruling out. 30502018-05-02T18:34:41.58735055Michelle McKinnaSo many children, teenagers and adults suffering with this daily, missing out on too much in their lives. 30502018-05-02T18:45:51.82335056Anne McBride I've had ME for 25 gruelling years. I've lost the career I loved,the house I loved and so so much of my life30502018-05-02T18:50:37.15335057Anne McBride I've had this gruelling illness for 25 years \r\nI've lost the career I loved, the house that I loved and so so much of my life. Please help30502018-05-02T18:59:45.13335058Tony ButterThese sufferers need our help now!30502018-05-02T19:03:30.2935060David HowieA worthy cause.30502018-05-02T19:12:57.02335061Rachel WilliamsThank you ME Action for creating this petition. ME CFS is an illness that is incredibly under funded and under researched. It affects a number of people and we can't help but feel currently the condition has not been taken seriously. I was diagnosed in August 2013 aged 23. I was told by a neourologist, 'I don't know what is wrong with you, so I will have to say it's ME CFS'. That is the state that we are in right now. No real diagnosis, little funding into what ME is and what causes it. More importantly, how to treat or manage it. GET and CBT are the only 'treatments' offered to us. CBT can help people come to terms with the illness but it is not a treatment. GET in most cases causes more harm than good. On the back of this, the lack of research and medical help means our illness feels like a stigma. Please support us, help us, because my goodness it's been long enough and we need all the help we can get! 30502018-05-02T19:18:34.37735062Jane Hill. Support for sufferers in Scotland is greatly needed. 30502018-05-02T19:36:29.76335064Julie ClarkeME suffers need a lot of help as it is a invisible disease but it causes such misery and pain 30502018-05-02T19:36:46.48735065Diane GilmoreMore research and help needs to be available to people that suffer from ME. Difficult to diagnose, lots of people with it but their doctor does not believe in it!30502018-05-02T19:46:40.31735067Clive MeikleThis illness can be debilitating. It affects thousands of Scottish people and yet there is no funding for either their care or for research into treatment or cures. Please help by allocating funding specifically for this illness, both towards research and effective care. Awareness raising should also be undertaken by government to help the issues of those affected be better understood the the wider public. 30502018-05-02T19:51:20.06735068Dorothy FraserNeed more NHS boards in Scotland providing specialised help for people with M.E30502018-05-02T19:56:16.45335069Frances McCartI have several dear friends who suffer severely with ME and some are constantly worried about their universal credits and their interviews.30502018-05-02T20:01:54.31335070Katrina BlankI've suffered from ME since falling ill to Malaria in Uganda 6 years ago. Though I hold a degree from the University of Michigan as well as a Masters in Leadership, I can not hold a job because of this illness. ME is a global health tragedy that has been neglected for centuries. Please help alleviate suffering (and consequential suicide and disability) by helping us find solutions to regain our well being. Those with ME in Scotland desperately need you to invest in their futures by allocating funding toward research. 30502018-05-02T20:08:50.7135072Thom Jackson-WoodThis is a great opportunity for Scotland to be a trailblazer for pioneering biomedical research into ME - at this stage, any progress made anywhere in the world is a massive leap forward for people like myself whose lives have been put on hold by ME.30502018-05-02T20:22:27.1935073Estelle McNeillIt is a very prevalent illness and it needs so much more awareness and funding than it has. Sufferers like myself need much more information, support and understanding than we get at the moment. 30502018-05-02T20:23:39.3335074Brett At 25 I've suffered for the past 3 years. My illness has derailed my goals of going medical school, and has left me severely limited even in the ways I can provide for myself. When I first became ill my own GP, after a lengthy workup, attempted to explain my symptoms as nothing more than depression. I persisted in my search for a diagnosis, and more importantly treatment. After many doctors and being evaluated at the Mayo Clinic here in the states, I finally left with enough evidence to show there was a substantial physiological cause for the symptoms I was having. I was diagnosed with ME CFS. With all of the issues I have face since becoming sick, the worst of all was the profound level of invalidation and dismissal that I faced. It brought me to the brink of questioning my own sanity and nearly taking my own life. If a cure or viable treatment is never found for this debilitating illness, at the very least my fellow sufferers deserve the validation and acceptance that comes with better disease recognition and provider information. 30502018-05-02T20:27:58.9335075Rebecca WixeyLets finally get some decent research done in this hugely important area30502018-05-02T21:04:01.5635076Lynsey MurrayInvest in research for M.E30502018-05-02T21:18:40.38735077Magdalene RoseBest wishes for Scotland folks from Maritimes, in Canada. First ME CFS Conference happening this upcoming weekend in Montreal!30502018-05-02T21:23:07.835078Lenore B OsterPlease try to help these people who are afflickted with this disease. Our family member has it and she just becomes worse every year. 30502018-05-02T21:33:43.77735079Jean YounisOne of my very best friends suffers from ME and is bedridden for more than 20 hours per day. Her life has been changed forever and will never be the same. If she didn't have a loving family member who stands by her, I believe she wouldn't still be alive today.30502018-05-02T21:35:51.86335080Clare MayThis utterly debilitating illness is ruining lives. Please help. 30502018-05-02T21:36:38.36335081Ellen Major Please help its so important30502018-05-02T21:44:06.59735082Saskia de WitAs I am not a resident of Scotland or even the UK, I can't tell how to spend your tax money. It is just so needed, that I support and raise my voice for this cause. It is in great need for intense research to understand ME and help the ones who see their lifes passing by in isolation and despair as a result of ME30502018-05-02T21:49:01.8935083Saskia de WitI raise my voice to support ME research to seek solutions for this disease of isolation, pain, despair30502018-05-02T22:19:08.16735084RwillamsMuch more help in this illness is needed I knw lovely girl who is ill and they need more done to help them debilitating for patient and family soul destroying 30502018-05-02T22:36:39.9935085Tina funded Research must be done for ME. There so many sufferers suffering in silence.30502018-05-02T22:56:33.95335086Robert TintiThe Scottish people suffering from Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) have been neglected for too long. Therapies such as Graded Exercise Therapy (GET) and Cognitive Behavioral (CBT) are known to be harmful to ME patients. I support further research and better care for people suffering from Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME).30502018-05-02T23:14:52.18335087Jennifer AndroesI am an ME patient in the United States and know that we need to bring much more awareness to this horrid disease, in all countries. It is crippling, life-shattering and many of us have lost all ability to earn an income, participate in life socially and with our families or even perform the basic survival needs to care for ourselves properly. As we have brought light, compassion and assistance to other illnesses such as MS and polio in the past, it's time to do the same for ME. Thank you. 30502018-05-02T23:18:49.3635088BjornMore money too ME reserch30502018-05-02T23:42:32.80335089David ChestersM.E.sufferers have been deliberately ignored and little has been done in research to help them, this appaling situation must be corrected.30502018-05-02T23:46:27.1435090Caroline WynnMy dearest hope is for us ALL to be acknowledged. And the appropriate research and care is provided.30502018-05-02T23:46:54.9235091John MooreWe are suffering out here, please help!30502018-05-03T00:26:05.09735092Courtenay YoungWe can do this - we can make a difference!30502018-05-03T00:44:32.64735093Season CrooksThis petition should also be circulated around the world including Canada!30502018-05-03T00:59:21.6335094Christine A. ShandroHaving been sidelined by ME for the past 25 years, I can attest to the profound impact it has on its sufferers' lives. Patients NEED every possible support.30502018-05-03T01:31:49.6635095Anna PostonThis is a cruel disease, made worse by the lack of understanding and NHS support. I have watched it devour a loved one. We have spent so much precious time, energy and resources fighting this disease like shadow puppets with little guidance. Please help to empower those enduring this illness with knowledge and support so that they can become their whole selves again. 30502018-05-03T01:41:44.32335096Penny KennedyPlease do the right thing and help these ME sufferers. Do no harm. 30502018-05-03T02:04:22.22735097Enid HobsonNeeds to connect up with day of action millions missing May 12.30502018-05-03T03:06:20.44735100Michel LeeDue to the uniquely multi-symptom, multi-system nature of this disease, research in this area is likely to inform understanding of other complex autoimmune and neuroimmune conditions. Advances in therapeutic avenues is also likely to have broad applications. 30502018-05-03T03:56:35.62335101Catherine Gross New research shows ME is a systemic break down of the body on a macrocellior level. Look forward to research done in the new facility inScotland and hope they lead the way. 30502018-05-03T04:33:18.65735102Isabel SukkarM.E. sufferers do not bring this illness upon themselves. Why then, should any M.E. sufferer not be taken seriously by the health system. 30502018-05-03T05:00:56.1635103Andrew BurgessPlease take this opportunity to lead the way in showing the UK how to respectfully care for people with M.E. using biomedical scientific techniques and research. The NHS is increasingly falling behind the rest of the world by maintaining an outdated psychology-led attempt at treatment which is ineffective at best - deeply harmful at worst - and undermines the realities of patient's suffering in the eyes of GPs and hospital consultants nationwide. I've lost 20 years of my life and know there are many who have lost even more. We M.E. patients desperately need somewhere at a governmental level to take a stand and show the rest of the UK how to genuinely help us rather than ignore or even belittle our daily fights. Large strides are being made in understanding the physical causes of M.E. symptoms around the world in places such as America and Norway, yet the Westminster-led priorities of the NHS throughout the UK continue to ignore this biomedical research and leave patients facing a wall of ignorance. Please help.30502018-05-03T05:01:03.5735104Jacqueline WilsonME patients need all the help they can get. We have been neglected & ignored for far too long! ME is a hugely disabling disease, & we need hugely improved treatment & care on all levels. More funds should be made available for research into this terrible illness which takes so much from the ME sufferer. Please help us!!! 30502018-05-03T05:39:51.07335105Tom KaardalA member of my family has suffered for 12 years.30502018-05-03T06:17:04.59735107Sarah Osborne I have ME. I live in Wales but support this initiative 30502018-05-03T07:48:49.82335111Heather TierneyA member of my family has ME and the lack of treatment and support she has received over the years is just shocking. The condition should receive the same level of funding as other life long conditions. The impact this condition has on your life is immense yet the others available are so limited.30502018-05-03T08:09:52.5935112Lindsey Patrick We need health care to understand this condition 30502018-05-03T08:31:36.40735113A.M.LaneI am signing this on behalf of a family member wrho has had M.e. for 7 years now and nothing seems to be being done about it ,all our governments in the Uk should be putting more money into research and treatment of this illness30502018-05-03T08:39:49.65735114Amy KeetonI've been living with Myalgic E for a decade now, and know all too well what it does to a person's life. Sending my love and support to MEcfs patients in Scotland!30502018-05-03T08:55:02.75335115Don FraserImportant that help & recognition is given to sufferers, not just in Scotland but world wide.30502018-05-03T09:19:55.39735116Michael PostonI am affected by ME. The best treatment for me turned out to be a respite in warm climate with a carer. I am now well on the road to recovery. The mindfulness based cognitive therapy helped as well in providing me with the skill to identify exhaustion and crashes at an early stage. Allowing for rest and pauses before it is too late. But every sufferer is different. More active research would be nice. Better protection in the workplace and less pressure from the welfare system would aid a recovery.30502018-05-03T09:28:09.9835118Mrs Irene GallacherI have a relative who has suffered from this illness for a long time and was not able to continue working.\r\nAfter receiving sickness benefit for a short while did not have the energy to go through the process of proving to the Benefits Agency their entitlement to benefit when it was stopped.Has now lived without the benefit that I personally think they were entitled to for some years now.I think that people who suffer from ME are treated like lazy people and this could not be further from the truth\r\nIt is a totally misunderstood condition and it is about time that it was investigated in more detail by the health authorities..30502018-05-03T09:46:32.96735119Helene LockwoodA member of my family has suffered with M.E. for many years so have to give support to all, wherever they may be30502018-05-03T09:48:55.3135120Christopher SpaldingWe need much more research into this condition.30502018-05-03T10:35:30.36335122Phil MurrayImproved care & biomedical research for people with MECFS must be a priority for the future. Actiono is needed now. 30502018-05-03T11:23:05.80335124Nancy Wilson It took 20 years to get a diagnosis of Fibro ME 20years of pain fatigue Fibro fog this should not happen to anyone.30502018-05-03T11:24:59.0135125Alison CaldwellI have had M.E for 23 years and hope not to die with it. I'm 62.30502018-05-03T11:25:24.2635126Lucy BI have many friends who are living with ME in Scotland who would benefit from access to specialist care.30502018-05-03T11:48:13.63735127Rose Ann-marie SlavinI am Scottish but moved to England as a child. I have had ME for 8.5 years. I now realise 2 of my family members had it but was never diagnosed correctly. One of my family members died at 61. I don't want to follow her! \r\n30502018-05-03T12:21:32.3635128Claire PrideauxI have ME. I've lived with it for decades. The fact that governments have ignored us and worse, forced treatments on us that harm us is a travesty. 30502018-05-03T12:38:29.2235129Iain GillA member of my family has had ME for over 20 years. I totally agree with the petition. I recently had 12 weeks chemotherapy and each day I observed that my family member was suffering more than I was. Cancer is well funded, and I don't grudge that but ME needs serious money to find a cure and to correct the lack of understanding of the illness.30502018-05-03T13:48:46.51335132Eilidh HewittI was struck down with severe ME 30 years ago it came like a bolt from the blue. Then I was profoundly shocked to find that I was to be denied any kind of care or treatment. Ostracised by family and friends due to lack of validation of this disease life was grim and became a daily effort to survive in the teeth of all the misery and pain of it.\r\n \r\nPlease fund proper research and care for ME patients. It is not cost effective to promote harmful therapies like GET and GET related CBT. Patients could possibly be saved from long term damage if the right advice was given at the start.\r\n30502018-05-03T13:56:27.4235133Jeff SumidaIn the first few years, doctors didn't believe me. They said that if you aren't going to exercise, then I can't help you. Or Think positive, it helped my other patients. Finally, my second infectious disease doctor. said I have Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and there is no pill, no cure. But he got me into the Stanford Medical program. Only a short drive away.30502018-05-03T15:04:52.66335134Suzanne ChadwickIt is really INSANE that anyone would think that this disease could be fixed by behavioral therapy. INSANE! How about checking out scientific evidencw, such as www.survivingmold.com and doing the proper labwork and treatment? Shame on you for killing people!30502018-05-03T15:37:19.68335135Catherine VelezI'm 53 years. I have ME for 30 years. My hope is to have a treatment or a cure. 30502018-05-03T15:39:43.0335136Clare Chalmers.So many families have been abused by unlawful data sharing. Practitioners remain confused to this day and still abuse the law. Who authorised this? Why was this allowed to happen against the data protection act of 1998? Why have the ico not informed organisations they gave out unlawful information in the first place? It has been left to families to correct organisations and bring them back in line with the law. It is not good enough. We deserve answers and those badly affected should be entitled to compensation.\r\nThis must never be allowed to happen again.30142018-05-03T15:43:09.82735137Catherine VelezI'm 53 years. I have ME for 30 years. My hope is that I can have a treatment to give relief or a cure, and the same for all the millions of patients in the world.30502018-05-03T16:03:55.23735138Ms. K. StewartI love Scotland and while attending school there I was in the beginning stages of fibromyalgia, later being determined by court proceedings and the input of several specialists to have CFIDS (the term used for M.E. at that time). It has now been\r\n 54 years that have finally seen me almost entirely bedridden, bankrupted once due to the cost of treatment and medications and now I would give most anything for others not to spend their lives waiting for help and recognition the way I did. I also lost a husband, who could not handle just watching the levels of my pain. Don't do this to your citizens, your neighbors, your family members. I've lived in Edinburgh and know you can do a better job there -if you choose to- than is possible in the U.S.A. Please take the opportunity to aid in global awareness while helping your own people. Many thanks in advance & best wishes for what you can achieve there, Sincerely, Kate Stewart 54 years a patient of these so-called invisible diseases.30502018-05-03T16:31:34.95735139Debby SmithAs a former Scot living in Canada afflicted with this condition, I support the three petitions to Parliament. 30502018-05-03T17:52:58.57735140Elizabeth LairdThere are many people living with this condition, but would greatly benefit from treatment. I have several friends whose lives would be transformed by getting the right treatment for this condition. It is long overdue as the diagnosis is widespread!\r\n30502018-05-03T18:00:33.37735141Tristram Llewellyn JonesThis whole slippery business of extracting personal information needs to be comprehensively stopped.\r\n\r\nWhy not have consent based public services that actually provide what people want instead? \r\n\r\nThat would be a much better proposition for all concerned.30142018-05-03T18:39:54.03735142Julie CrampinI have had ME for 25 years. I support my fellow sufferers wherever they are.30502018-05-03T19:25:40.4835143Ms karen priceThis is such a debilitating disease, I was diagnosed with M E in 2001 but now I am awaiting an mri scan as lumber puncture was inconclusive to be now checked for M S , just shows the similarities, both indescribable.30502018-05-03T19:44:00.3935145Tricia MME is a serious and debilitating illness that deserves serious research funding. Patients have been in desperate need of treatment and support for decades. 30502018-05-03T21:30:22.04735147Jo Bruce I have always been a supporter of the NHS but the biggest barrier I have faced, apart from ignorant employers who break the disability discrimination act left, right and centre, is my GP. Not just one but 3 over ten years. I always worked and paid my taxes and I had no idea that stories like the ones we tell could happen. Do happen. In this day and age it's scary how quickly you become a non person. As a professional these people were my peers, now they speak to me as though my IQ has dropped, 60 points and I'm little more than a deluded scrounger. At a time when I have needed my GP to be 'on my side', I have found myself working alone to manage my condition. 30502018-05-03T21:54:58.61335149Ann Higgins Care for the unfortunate people with ME30502018-05-03T22:27:41.63335150Catherine StirtonWell done for highlighting this issue and for standing up to the Scottish Governments half baked attempts at deciding a viable policy on this issue. They have caused untold misery with their actions and distress to children and parents they are supposed to be protecting.\r\n 30142018-05-03T23:09:01.4535151Angela BarnardSigning on behalf of my friend who is suffering from ME-CFS. I have watched her decline and am humbled by her resolve to continue on fighting. More needs to be done for this people suffering from this disease.30502018-05-03T23:15:30.51335152Jennifer MurrayI'm not a citizen of Scotland, but as someone who was a productive citizen of the U.S. until I became ill 22 years ago, I urge you to recognize that finally funding proper investigation of this disease is necessary not only for the good of the suffering patients, but also for health of your country. 30502018-05-04T00:00:43.56735155Anna Maria Woynillowicz KempI lived in Scotland for one and half years. The medical professionals need to be much more aware of current research about Myalgic Encephalomyelitis and be aware of medical protocols for treatment. As well, they need to have the knowledge to support persons with ME as they work towards receiving appropriate disability pension and long term disability through private insurance companies.\r\nScottish Government funding needs to be aware of the severity of ME and compensation must be commensurate with the disease burden.30502018-05-04T04:12:16.6735156S Lauryn Douglass HaydenThis is a terrible disease with a viral basis. Numerous US studies have shown the biological basis for compromised metabolism and multi-system dysfunction. I know this disease well as I have it. I have lost not only my health, but a successful career, financial security, social, community and most of my persnal life because of Myalgic Encephalomyelitis. I used to climb mountains, run, bike, dance and revel in a good life. ME has the position MS once had. Again, the latter is a disease I know we'll as a member of my family died from MS complications. At onset in the 1960s, MS was wrongfully associated with neurosis and other useless and harmful opinions were held about the illness, possibly in part because many affixed were women. I urge you to move forward with research, treatment and all other necessary efforts to reduce the suffering of Scottish residents with ME. I am fortunate to be a patient at a clinic in my own city, and although there is currently no cure for ME, I am benefitting greatly from what help clinic experts can offer me.30502018-05-04T04:59:08.235157DS George-JonesPlease find a treatment for ME. It is a human rights issue. We are tired of suffering in silence.30502018-05-04T05:29:57.7235158Elizabeth EdwardsPlease help.30502018-05-04T06:38:15.62335159Tamara AndersonIt is necessary and remains without cure and mainly impacts women and we will become lost without the research. The longer people suffer w ME the more likely to develop other illness amd depression. Lives are being lost!30502018-05-04T08:56:43.75735160Myrtle LittleI have had ME for 20 years, it makes me cross and sad about people and especially children not being believed and punished for having it. This has to change30502018-05-04T09:34:48.6535161Kathleen Anderson Please put more research into ME!30502018-05-04T12:15:57.8335162Martin DillonThe present treatment options for people will M.E.are almost non existent and often harmful. The approach from G.P. vary wildly. Say to little to them they don't do adequate investigation and often suggest anti - depressants. Show to much insight and ask for the adequate tests and they question your mental health. Often it's that bad. 30502018-05-04T12:47:18.06735163Ruaridh PringleI've had ME for 30 years, since I was 18. During a relapse over the past 2 years (following 14 relatively good years when I'd recovered to around 70% functionality) I was horrified to find that treatment for, and of, ME patients had got not better, as I'd assumed, but far worse, with the attitude amongst available medical professionals almost universally that 'it's all in the mind'. ME utterly destroys lives in the cruellest way, reducing highly motivated, active people to cognitively and physically crippled ghosts (many of them in constant pain). Yet it is *still* misunderstood or not taken seriously by the only people sufferers have to turn to. As a result, sufferers battle to access any of the kind of support and safety nets that other sufferers of crippling diseases have access to, despite the degree of suffering and disablement having been shown to be generally worse (e.g. compared to MS). ME sufferers are currently invisible, being left to die without help, unless they are lucky enough to have very supportive and understanding family and friends (because sufferers usually exhaust their reserves just trying to get through the day, there's usually nothing left for things like socialising, meaning the first thing ME robs you of is friends). This is a bafflingly unfair and counter-productive: the lack of support, research and understanding is preventing sufferers recovering or stabilising, and (DWP take note) decreasing their productivity. This *has* to change.30502018-05-04T12:51:03.28735164Kay MearsFrom a UK patient.30502018-05-04T13:31:05.15335166Sidney LockwoodIt is high time ME suffers where recognised as a disability and the Government should accept the need for recognition and financial support. They have acted like "Robin Hood" but in reverse, by reducing payments allowance's to those persons with ME who are unable to work and in need of support whilst increasing their own income. (A case of "Robbing the Poor to pay the Rich") \r\nI will not vote for the Conservatives again!.30502018-05-04T13:47:02.65335167Robert Mac Have lived with M.E. for 30 years \r\nDespite the scientific medical breakthroughs over the years ........Many patients are treated as if they have imagined their selves ill ? Hard to believe even in regressive Britain ....what terrible harm this causes people .......\r\n30502018-05-04T14:56:46.02335168Sue WaddleTwice as many people have ME as have MS. Why is there no government funding of biomedical research into this condition or specialist services for patients?30502018-05-04T15:23:27.47735169cait ni CadlaigIf such a center is set up It should include those of us with Fibromyalgia or in many cases ,as is mine .I have both There are many similarities30502018-05-04T16:59:46.30735170Lesley DohertyThis is woefully underfunded and under supported.30502018-05-04T19:47:13.03735172Maggie Taylor Treatment for ME is very patchy with little understanding of the condition. This has to change. 30502018-05-04T20:43:39.01335174Sofia GurovichI'v been sick with ME for 29 years , the disease is progressive , bed confinde , no treatment . wish there was more humane approach to patients like I. we all need urgent help . 30502018-05-04T21:19:43.1935175Christian Bayne I find it impossible to manage my illness let alone get better, when the current consensus is ' M.E.is not really a real illness'. Due to this attitude there is no biomedical funding of M.E. in Scotland, there are no specialists and none of our GPs are trained on it. This is medical neglect. Scotland must change it's attitude to M.E. and live up to it's reputation as a compassionate, forward thinking society. ANOTHER SCOTLAND IS POSSIBLE! 30502018-05-04T23:01:08.05735177Paula Jackson I've had ME for 7 years. It has changed my life hugely. I cannot work. I can't take a walk down the street. I can't climb stairs. Before I got ill I was an academic exceller, I got a prestigious scholarship to study my masters at University of Oxford. I now struggle to read or drive or concentrate on things. I used to dance every evening (ballroom and Latin dancing) and was an active member of society and my church. I travelled overseas. Now I couldn't walk out of an airport. 30502018-05-05T06:27:20.43735180Ian MeikleNot before time!!!30142018-05-05T11:43:42.1635181Andrew Mcquade More research needs to be done to help people live a normal life 30502018-05-05T13:07:13.02335182Matthew WoodwardI've had M.E. for 25 years, since I was 13. M.E. is a seriously debilitating disease that isn't taken seriously by GPs unfortunately. It means you haven't got the physical strength to do ordinary activities that people take for granted, like going to get shopping or even cookin, cleaning activities for the most severely disabled. Since M.E. doesn't get serious support from Government level organisation, people are left living in the dark with only the few closest family to help them get by.\r\nAnd GP are not prescribing sick notes after the Conservatives whitewashed to power under David Camoron.\r\n\r\nPlease find it sensible and imperative to take M.E. seriously and let's get something doing about it!\r\n\r\n30502018-05-05T15:27:57.46335183Marie HarrisThe Named Persons Scheme and GIRFEC clearly violates the Human Right to a Family Life, free from State interference, and MUST BE STOPPED !30142018-05-05T16:06:28.34335184Christine LaennecA member of my family, now 20, has had ME since age 13 and is mostly bedbound at this point. We desperately need research into ME, and effective treatment for people with ME, in Scotland.30502018-05-05T16:08:38.535185Sheena BeatonPlease consider more research and appropriate treatments are vital30502018-05-05T17:56:33.1235186Edmund GarrodME a Serious illness that affects all life aspects requires vast support for all affected.30502018-05-05T21:16:27.23335187Marian CowieAll power to you30502018-05-05T21:56:18.61335188DOROTHY O'DRISCOLLA member of my family has been ill since the age of twelve. She has spent thirty years in pain. Pain from her numerological illness and pain from the cruelty inflicted upon her by society. Sufferers need hope, which this petition could bring, please use your powers for the good of humanity.30502018-05-06T04:43:57.07335189Steven McLaughlinThe suffering the State is imposing on we the people will no longer be tolirated with the HAMMER of the SCOTS 30142018-05-06T10:37:37.12335190Emma HendersonI was referred to the ME clinic in Edinburgh in June 2017. I have still not been given an appointment. The system of care for ME patients HAS to change and HAS to better serve us. It is society's loss if it doesn't and is just senseless.30502018-05-06T16:51:45.58735191joke de reushelp\r\n30502018-05-06T19:46:25.06335192Alison AbbottWe definitely need to have this situation remedied as soon as possible so that sufferers & their families are looked after.30502018-05-06T23:07:11.43335193Denise HillEnough is enough. We've tried it your way and it doesn't work. It's time to listen to us now. Please give us the respect we deserve and the help we actually need. Thank you.30502018-05-06T23:39:09.14735194anne macgillivrayME finds people lost and forgotten. Strange things happening to you body ( after year of going to the dentist all of a sudden injections make you feel sick ???) When getting a diagnosis it's ,,, you have Me !! Get in with it. The emotional impact of not being able to work or read a book or even have the energy to get out of bed. It's not on that in 2018 this kind of head in the sand attitude exists. We need answers !!! 30502018-05-07T04:15:47.79335195Julie EvansI have been living, what a strange word, with this horrible disease since 20002. It has taken my job, my education, my clean nice home and my beautiful yards, rose garden included. My love and prayers go out to everyone who is battling these and family and friends that have to watch as our bodies are ravaged.30502018-05-07T08:34:15.7635196Catherine spink-whiteGiven the subjective opinions of many of the people involved I find the named person totally and an absolute danger to children and families alike30142018-05-07T11:37:56.6635197Helen SmithIt seems we are going backwards instead of forwards as one would hope. I have had M.E. for 30 years. Initially it was diagnosed by a very astute GP who recognised the illness as M.E. and promptly referred me to a leading neurologist in the field, now retired unfortunately. Having gone through most of my M.E. years self managing my illness at great cost (I have probably spent in excess of £30K) I found myself in difficult terrain, twice having cancer, and with doctors while very dedicated had no knowledge of how any treatment I received would affect me, badly as it happens. I do wish that medical science would get the technical ability to give some credibility to this illness and get to grips with relevant help for M.E. patients who are just living day to day in a void. 30502018-05-07T15:11:05.53335198Kitty landersMuch research needed and a recognition of the sickness30502018-05-07T16:05:47.99335200S.almondThis is a very dibilitating illnesses people need more support.30502018-05-07T18:19:52.4635201Eilen VollanIt's time to end the abuse of ME patients, and spend more money on biomedical research. 30502018-05-07T18:33:08.7835202Gerry FarrellShona Robison, you are sitting on your hands. Where is the funding for research into M.E.? The Scottish Government's inaction is unforgiveable.30502018-05-07T20:41:24.2235204Cameron VaskéThis is a worthy cause, and one which I believe the Scottish government is well-equipped technically and morally to handle.30502018-05-07T21:35:09.1535205Karen duncanI just want to live my life, not watch others live as I disappear.\r\nI want to work, not fear I will loose my job to this illness. Not fear I will loose my home to this illness. Not fear I will loose my friends to this illness. Not fear I will loose my husband to this illness, or my family, or my dignity. \r\nI want to dance, and garden, and write, and play with my children. I want to cook dinner. I want to walk in the park. I want to see my friends. And, yes, I want to do housework!\r\nI am not lazy. It is not in my head. I am ill.\r\nPlease help me to be whole again. Please help us all!30502018-05-07T23:38:17.18335206Lorraine Deacons I've had ME for going on 12 years . It's becoming much harder to cope with . We need funding for research and better support from doctors and nurses who are still ignorant to this disease . It's soul destroying and heartbreaking suffering in silence. 30502018-05-08T07:46:18.51335207Patricia Hewitt.I totally agree and have seen evidence first hand of this happening , myself included . I was the main Petitioner of PEO1625 re Pathological Demand Avoidance where Parental Blame due to poor parenting is the norm . Children taken into care , families destroyed due to malicious accusations amongst Professionals . Families left past crisis point due to an appaling understanding of the Autism Spectrum by so many .By my experience and so many others Educations Laws , GIRFEC , and the Wellbeing Wheel and not worth the paper they are written on . GIRFEC is certainly not happening and is in breech of Human Rights .30142018-05-08T08:44:32.97735208George McCannSouth Lanarkshire Council deliberately broke DPA and Councillors Code of Conduct and nobody cares, South Lanarkshire Council are as far away from GIRFEC as possible to the point they seem to think it means Getting It Right For Every COUNCIL.30142018-05-08T08:50:17.94735209Paula Heron I have had M.E for 16 years and severe M.E since 2011 and we still have to fight for medical staff and the world to believe this is a serious debilitating illness that steals your life from you. There still isn't the support, awareness and help that we deserve. So many sufferers like myself are housebound and bedbound and we are supposed to just accept it and get on with it! Other serious illnesses get the funding, awareness and support, so why can't we! They can't even decide on a proper name for it and continue to name it chronic fatigue syndrome and it's so much more than just fatigue! I don't live in Scotland but do have fellow sufferers that do and so I am signing this petition to shoe my support. M.E is a life sentence with no chance of parole, please help us to be heard and stop #millionsmissing 30502018-05-08T13:03:35.93735210Robert McCormick Have survived 30 yrs with this illness \r\nFeel awful right now \r\nThe UK is going backwards when it comes to healthcare \r\nM.E. is a multi - faceted complex illness & it is a physical illness ( that's why CBT & GET are worse than useless as a treatment , also having no medical benefit at all to M.E. patients ? Yet the British illness deniers insist on a non treatment .......Can,t even guess at the harm the medical profession is inflicting on patients with M.E. 30502018-05-08T13:08:27.99735211Kirsty GuilfoyleIt took ten years and £1000 in private fees for me to me diagnosed, which for someone who has never been able to have a full time job was very difficult. This was after years of being told I was depressed and needed exercise, or that my symptoms were health anxiety. This advice undoubtedly made the symptoms progress & the medical community need to take responsibility for what they have done to people. please help us. 30502018-05-08T13:56:16.64735212Vivienne Agar Sowter I have two members of my family with ME CFS and it has destroyed their lives, including their ability to access any meaningful education and interrupting their normal teenage social development. There is currently no effective care, treatment or cure available for ME CFS. The statistical prognosis for children with ME CFS is approximately 25 percent of sufferers become completely bedridden in adulthood and about 6 percent spontaneously recover. For the remainder, the symptoms persist and fluctuate to a greater or lesser extent throughout life. \r\n \r\nFor the approximately 250,000 patients in the UK suffering from ME CFS, there may be many more undiagnosed. Over the last 10 years less than 5 pounds per patient per year has been invested by the government in research. It is unsurprising then that there is no effective care, treatment or cure available with this level of investment. Consider the progress made with the treatment of AIDS, which in the nineteen eighties was a death sentence, where now because of the investment in research for a cure, sufferers can now look forward to an average life span of 64 to 65 years, constantly improving treatment and increasingly, a complete cure. This has only been achieved through significant investment in research. \r\n \r\nWith proper investment, a cure will be found and just as with AIDS, the benefit to society will outweigh the cost.\r\n30502018-05-08T14:32:58.62335213Marie Mccann Full review to highlight failings is overdue30142018-05-08T17:04:16.35335214Denise hoggBoth my children had free instrument lessons. My father also taught brass instruments in various schools. Don't think should only be available to those who can afford it or are fortunate enough to have musician on family30482018-05-08T17:56:56.54735217Jacqueline GrimleyIn West Lothian we are fighting for fairness in school music tuition. It will be disastrous for our children's education today and in the future to stop music tuition in schools. Our local council thinks no one will notice if they do this bit by bit but they are so wrong ! Our children deserve fairness in education and should be given the opportunity to be all they can be, instead of having the amazing gift of music taken from them, denying the future of their untapped as yet talents. I urge everyone to support this petition for the sake of this countries future generations. My children are having their aspirations destroyed today because of shortsighted ignorant local councillors who were elected as representatives of the people but who now appear to care little for the people. 30482018-05-08T18:19:16.42735218Jill JohnsonMy family member was abandoned by Occupational Therapy after not being well enough to do graded exercise. Abandoned by the welfare state as cannot attend interviews or best represent herself because of her condition. Health professionals and Social Security have no clue or training or facilities to understand, care and empathize with children and adults with CFS-ME. Please don't forget about the sufferers and help make their lives have quality and just to be recognised that they exist. There are no specialists or facilities in Scotland.\r\n Who is going to help The Missing Millions?30502018-05-08T18:21:48.73335219Emma CairnsI benefited from free musical tuition as a child and the fees for my children have just doubled to 100% recovery whatever that means. This will be the death of music education in my area and will likely set the precedent across Scotland. This must stop now!30482018-05-08T18:25:12.3935220John Leitch Charging for Instrumental instruction was tried before in South Ayrshire and was an unmitigated disaster. The scheme cost as much to administer as it raised and despite the lessons from history the present administration is headed blindly down the same path, driven by political dogma!30482018-05-08T18:45:03.99335222Ellen Smith The arts are just as important in the curriculum as any other subject group and in my experience (having taught music in various ways in schools) instrumental tuition in particular is vital to developing a multitude of skills in young people. If Scotland has ambitions to have one of the best education systems in the world this should be an option. Qualifying equality cannot exist without investment. 30482018-05-08T18:45:37.435223Ann NessBoth myself and my son received free instrumental lessons and we both continue to play and perform. Music inspires teambuilding and creativity and enhances intellectual ability and confidence. 30482018-05-08T18:57:54.78335224Caroline WilsonAs a parent in Clackmannanshire, I have 2 children currently receiving music tuition and they have been for years. The increase to £524 puts our family in a very difficult position, do we stop both children attending, to we allow the one who has studied longest to continue, do we stop them attending another activity (which will make little impact as Boys Brigade is £1.50 per week and Scouts is £3 versus £17.54 for a music lesson of 30 mins shared with other students). As a volunteer for a youth orchestra I have witnessed music turn around the life of students, I have seen them growing in confidence, working with and appreciating others and also improving in other academic areas. Scotland should be blazing a trail in Education, we should be settling trends, we should be equipping our young people with skills to out-think machines, be creative, artistic, and mentally & emotionally superior - music has the power to help with education on all those fronts. Rather than rapidly axing music & the arts from across our nation, we should be turning around education by using music. 30482018-05-08T19:02:13.46335225Moira RossRetrograde step in charging for music and disgraceful cutting back on Instrumental Music Lessons in school.30482018-05-08T19:06:59.55735226joyce f.Come on Scotland, the world looks to you.30502018-05-08T19:08:52.55335227Tracey LloydI am appalled to read that the cost of group, mixed lessons in Clackmannanshire is the highest in the country. I am a professional musician and trumpet teacher at the Royal Northern college of music raised in Clackmannanshire and my career would not have been possible without free instrumental lessons. Music should be for everyone, not just the privileged who can afford to pay.30482018-05-08T19:09:56.2635228Jim PrimeCurrent research indicates that playing music assists understanding of mathematics and physics. I am a member of Deacon Blue (keys) and UWS lecturer. I made my point as guest of BBC Scotland Grant Stott. Short minded and arrogance from councils given the green card by Scottish Government to do what they want. What is the point of YMI if you then ask folk to pay once they are hooked on playing. That's like giving kids a drug then making them pay for it!!!!30482018-05-08T19:13:55.71335229Miriam KacmarskaKeep music tuition affordable in Clackmannanshire!30482018-05-08T19:14:00.32335230Morag ShawMy son left school last year in Dunfermline to continue studying music. He had the opportunity to study cello from Primary 5. We paid fees up until 4th year. We struggled to pay the fees and pay for the supplemental orchestras he then went in to play with. We made the effort as he had an aptitude for music and on the whole wasn't very academic. If funding is withdrawn or increased there are pupils who may excel in music who will miss out. Not all pupils are suited to traditional academia and will not get a chance to find the thing that may be their forte.30482018-05-08T20:01:24.81735231Susan Burns ElinsResearch has shown the benefits of musical tuition in terms of brain growth and development. Should this opportunity be restricted to those who can afford to pay for it? Clackmannanshire has significant areas of deprivation and children who live here are now to be further disadvantaged.30482018-05-08T20:13:33.28735232Jo HadokeMusic education is a must, a sign of a civilised society. Please ensure access for all continues, the benefits are lifelong.30482018-05-08T20:22:03.44335233Emma MathiesonI learnt clarinet at school and found the lessons invaluable. I played in the school band increasing my confidence and social skills. I would like all children to be afforded this opportunity. 30482018-05-08T20:25:47.55335234Margaret RobbChildren should be encouraged and supported to play musical instruments30482018-05-08T20:28:42.11735235Susan Cowan As someone who benefited from music tuition, I feel that it is very important. Music is a release for me and is proven to help children concentrate on other subjects. Also, not all children are academic. Music is proven to be important to well being.30482018-05-08T20:41:30.835236Shona donnellyWholeheartedly support this petition30142018-05-08T20:52:24.33335237Kenneth BrownThanks to having Free tuition when I was at school I was given the opportunity to learn a brass instrument. From here I have gone on to have a career as a professional musician as a performer and educator. 30482018-05-08T20:55:11.1235238phil greenlead the way and westminster will follow ! ME is a biomedical disease and patients need appropriate support and research - NOT MORE HUMILIATION FROM THE STATE AND ESTABLISHMENT SHRINKS !30502018-05-08T21:00:01.50335239Bill CaseyWhile protecting children is important, this legislation uses these real concerns as an excuse to require us all, adults and children, to give up our rights to privacy and autonomy, and give the state unwarranted rights to intrude into our private family lives.\r\n\r\nThis is just another step towards the erosion of the family unit and reduces our children to nothing more than a state-owned commodity.30142018-05-08T21:01:20.35335240Claire WilsonCreativity is the key to future adaptability. Discipline and dedication is key to skills for life and skills for work. Music tuition provides both. Free music tuition provides this for all, inclusion for all to gain the skills to develop and foster their creativity, dedication, discipline and mental wellbeing. 30482018-05-08T21:10:44.40335241Susan PughI wish my granddaughter to be able to continue to play the saxophone and improve her musical skills.30482018-05-08T21:32:58.5135243John Hinckley Without any reference to Arts and Crafts we breed a desolate nation. Another catastrophe in the offing driven by pathetic thoughts from politicians who should know better. 30482018-05-08T21:36:05.57735244David DicksonMusic tuition for all regardless of ability to pay should be viewed as a right not a privilege.30482018-05-08T21:46:02.65735245Phillip LambLearning a musical instrument should be available to all children of all ages regardless of means or background.30482018-05-08T21:46:17.03335246Alistair McGregorChildren benefit so much from music and it is totally inclusive for everyone regardless of physical ability. Hopefully the Scottish Government sees the benefits and behaves like a socially just Government.30482018-05-08T21:48:38.5535247Sheila ClarkeMusic tuition is a very important service provided by councils. It gives children and young people the opportunity to engage in the Arts and promotes creativity. It encourages self discipline and provides enjoyment and a means of relaxation. Music is a way of closing the gap as it does not discriminate between those who have and those who have not. My own son benefited from this service and as a result still plays violin as part of an orchestra. 30482018-05-08T22:11:34.73335248Sheena JardineMusic is vital to society and for a child, it has been shown time and time again how music education lifts a child's academic results and also boosts self esteem, confidence and life skills. With a little research it would become clear that learning a musical instrument or singing should be a vital part of education, another vital subject alongside maths.30482018-05-08T22:20:00.18735249James Cruickshank Instrumental tuition directly benefited my ability to progress in the field of engineering. Problem solving, focus, ability to identify patterns, teamwork etc. are all everyday skills improved by music tuition. 30482018-05-08T22:43:09.10335250Sarah HoustonSounds great! Take the lead, Scotland!!!30482018-05-08T22:52:08.70735251Sandra BamberI sincerely believe that learning music in schools is as important physical education. Scotland has a rich history of mur and singers, who wouldn't have become successful or discovered their talent for music, had they not received the opportunity to learn music or to play an instrument of sing, at school. Young people have enough stresses in their lives today and music is a wonderful medium to alleviate anxiety and stress. I therefore think stopping teaching them to play an instrument will be detremental.30482018-05-08T23:19:26.24335253Petrea CooneyThe benefits to free instrumental tuition need no justification 30482018-05-09T00:11:47.0335255Anne MacAskillI am sure this has been petitioned for before, but it is imperative that children are encouraged to make music and that it is available for all, regardless of their background.30482018-05-09T05:52:34.17335256Katie CameronMusic is a fantastic way for children to express themselves!30482018-05-09T06:00:58.9135257Neil Smith Ex Professional trumpet player in many orchestras , London west end , Jools Holland etc ... started at primary school in east Ayrshire... this is so important please make this happen 30482018-05-09T06:46:09.7935258Irene KennyA cultural necessity30482018-05-09T06:52:22.77735259Ann LindsayMy son is 12 and has missed out on this opportunity because of the cost. It breaks my heart, he so desperately wished to learn any instrument. 30482018-05-09T07:06:49.96335260Kirstin sharpMusic is such an important lesson and should not just be for those that can afford. So much research shows it helps attainment in other areas by playing an instrument 30482018-05-09T07:21:45.8135261Linda DallasMusic has been proved to raise attainment. As closing the attainment gap is one of the government's priorities it is not logical for instrumental services to be drastically cut as every region has seen!30482018-05-09T07:22:49.5635262Gayle McCutcheonWe pure and simply CANNOT discriminate in this manner. ALL children should be able to have music lessons without their parents or guardians having the worry of how to pay for them.30482018-05-09T07:26:23.35735264Kat Neill Please keep music instructors in schools 30482018-05-09T07:31:52.63735265Alison Murphy"When words fail, music speaks." Hans Christian Anderson30482018-05-09T07:42:34.6435266Carol Ann HedleyMusic can change lives as playing an instrument helps the education of a child never mind a hobby for life that allows sharing and playing together. Therefore the mental well being of the child into adulthood helped. Many of the pupils go on to have wonderful careers and enrich their families, communities, nationally and internationally with wonderful music. 30482018-05-09T07:48:01.9735267Steven Mead Think of all the wonderful musicians who benefited from music education in Scotland. Think about what you are losing, for a couple of generations. So sad, please think again 30482018-05-09T07:51:23.0835268David fraserMusic tuition and playing an instrument provides huge opportunities for children, it helps build confidence, learn about discipline and structure, children get the opportunity to meet people they would not normally do. Losing music tuition in schools would be a tragedy, and to the detriment of society 30482018-05-09T08:05:10.87735269Andrew McGarvaMusical education is a right for everyone 30482018-05-09T08:05:33.7235270Pauline KeanA member of my family currently is receiving lessons at a school in Paisley and I hope this continues. 30482018-05-09T08:30:35.93735271Rona ChisholmInstrumental tuition at school enriched my life. How can paying for this help close the attainment gap? As with most sports, instrumental tuition must be free at all state schools in Scotland.30482018-05-09T08:36:48.23335272Philippa ChandlerAccess to the arts at an early age should be accessable to all, despite family income. 30482018-05-09T08:38:46.66735273Danny AldersloweWith rising austerity there is rising poverty for many and rising wealth for a few. In rural parts of Scotland we are witnessing some affording private tuition,or receiving a wide choice at their boarding schools, part sponsored by us. With the rise of mental health reflecting varying pressures on any families,learning music is a therapeutic art that gives many young people, a skill,focus, distraction even from things going on round about them.Please make this available to the many.30482018-05-09T08:41:44.12735275Lesley Steven Music is a vital part of child development and should not be restricted to those who can afford to pay for it.30482018-05-09T08:53:14.93335276Margaret TrusdaleWe must allow ALL children free music tuition - should not just be for the financially better off! Surely that goes against what the SNP stands for???30482018-05-09T08:54:43.03335277Anne BunemannMusical instrument lesson should be available to all children, music is such important part of the human being, don't let it fade out.30482018-05-09T08:55:42.60735278Sara melvilleI got free violin lrssons at primary school - as did about a third if my class in P3 onwards. My life would not have been the same without that. There are so many important skills and sharing experiences made possible by offering free music tuition to young people. It is unreasonable to exclude those who cant pay from access to music - its so good for the soul and wellbeing with all the pressures life brings. Dont start me on the importance of art...30482018-05-09T09:05:48.60735279Christopher HelsonThe evidence demonstrates that learning a musical instrument improves cognitive ability accross subjects.30482018-05-09T09:23:23.4235280Anne Marie HaughanI owe my career as a music teacher to the free instrumental tuition I received from 1966 to 1974 Renfrewshire schools music provision of tutors , orchestras, concerts and band camps. Life long friends made too. 30482018-05-09T09:42:46.66735281Elizabeth SwainsonThe introduction & subsequent increase in charges for Instrumental Instruction in the local authority where I work and where my children attended school has seen the opportunity to learn an instrument gradually become available only to those with money. The positive impact on all aspects of a young person's life is well documented. It is imperative that lessons are free to enable every child the chance to impact on their life long education. 30482018-05-09T09:45:36.0735282Mary JohnstonMusic stands at the same level in education as numeracy and literacy. Maybe even above. 30482018-05-09T09:48:30.335283Rebecca McGaugieThe proposed increase in instrument tuition fees in Clackmannanshire is quite ridiculous. This will put instrument tuition out with the means of a large \r\npotion of school children and is a way to stop \r\nindividual instrument tuition by the back door. To \r\ndouble the cost in one year is scandalous and needs\r\n to be reassessed. We all understand services have\r\n a cost but to effectively remove music tuition from\r\n children when it has been proved time as again that\r\n this can improve attainment in all areas of education is short sighted and ill conceived. \r\n30482018-05-09T09:54:31.7635284Kathy Chappelle Music is very important, how it is delivered and taught is so very important. It would be fabulous for all children to experience the power of Music regardless of the ability to pay . 30482018-05-09T09:56:07.3435285Katie MclartyI recieved free music tuition at school and ended up joining a jazz band which led me to go on tour with them around Frace and Germany, lifelong friends and memories made. This would not have been possible if I did not receive this tuition as we would not have been able to afford it 30482018-05-09T10:17:46.7135287Gordon JenkinsHad I not been provided with an instrument and free lessons at school, I would not have been able to have a career as a professional solo cornet and trumpet player in the Royal Marines Band Service ( for 9 years ) or a career as a professional brass instrumental music teacher ( for 27 years), as my parents would have been unable to pay.30482018-05-09T10:29:46.41335288Kate SmithChildren can often express themselves through music and can be a form of release Can be esteem building for children who may not be academic30482018-05-09T10:31:21.48335289Ali Ferguson Music is one of the few things in this world that is capable of bringing people together...the more accessible it is and the earlier it is taught the better.30482018-05-09T10:47:33.92335290Karen BanaghanSo unfair that children can only get lessons if they have parents who can afford it.30482018-05-09T10:57:00.17735291Gill HunterFree Music Tuition should be a national right for all regardless of household income, not random depending on location, and local authority budget. 30482018-05-09T11:01:29.95735292Ryan McBride I am, what I would regard as, a successful musician, in that music is my living, and that I make a regular income from it. This would not be the case had I not benefited from a free music education via a vibrant music service. 30482018-05-09T11:09:43.75735293Julie NicollI received instrumental tuition as a teenager in Fife and as a result I still play and perform regularly in a brass band. The impact music has had on my life is immeasurable - it teaches a range of transferable skills which are vital in the work place as well as providing enjoyment.30482018-05-09T11:50:44.0535296Alison RussellI received free percussion lessons at secondary school in Perth. I am a contemporary of the now very famous Evelyn Glennie: I am just an amateur. That said, I did a degree in music from a highly regarded university, and, 30 years later, still play regularly with classical ensembles all over Scotland. My life is enriched through music, and so iit is for those who come to hear us play. Without that tuition, my life would be poorer in countless ways. Music teaches us so many life skills: concentration (for extended periods!!), teamwork, listening, commitment. It's something that is shared by humanity whether one plays or listens. We cannot, as a civilised society, discriminate against those children from families without the financial means - or understanding - of the value of playing a musical instrument.30482018-05-09T11:56:36.9535298Clare ChalmersWhy on Earth was the data protection act overridden & ignored? Who gave the green light? Why will SG not release the legal advice they were given at the time? Why did the ico promote this illegal activity? Will victims get an apology, compensation?\r\nWhy has it been left to citizens such as myself to hold organisations to account, enforcing the law changing what they promote on websites and in practice? This should be the responsibility of the ico. They should have ensured organisations were made aware their original advice was unlawful especially following the SC ruling but failed to do so.\r\nOnly an independent public inquiry will address these questions and more if you wish to rebuild trust in the system and move forward.30142018-05-09T12:19:34.0735299Helen MinshallI give my full support to this petition. I would not be a professional musician and music educator now if I had not received free instrumental tuition in Ayrshire. 30482018-05-09T12:40:44.28335300Philip SawyerThe educational benefits of music tuition have been proved many, many times.30482018-05-09T12:57:30.83335302lynne grayBoth my children have played an instrument. It is so good for their confidence. Both are involved in the music department at there school.30482018-05-09T12:58:45.04335303Patriciia couttsI hope my grandchildren will have same chances to learn a musical instrument free like I did.30482018-05-09T13:27:39.13335304John ScottMy son is now a professional musician. He had private tuition. But his school provided him with exceptional musical education and allowed him to use his chosen instrument (accordion) to enable him to achieve his Advanced Higher in music. All school children should have the right to have free of charge musical instrument tuition.30482018-05-09T13:32:19.34735305Lesley MairMusic belongs to everyone. Children have an innate ability, regardless of academic achievement, and need to be encouraged in creativity which, as has been proven countless times, enhances every aspect of learning. 30482018-05-09T13:37:44.05735306Craig DawsonNo gluten, no dairy, no carbs is the cure.\r\nSwitch to a ketogenic diet for a month and see the difference. \r\n30502018-05-09T13:52:15.17735307Carol Mason Music teaches so many other life skills: socially our kids are retreating into screens. Music opens opportunities 30482018-05-09T14:19:06.77335308Frances CarvillEvery child deserves to have access to music tuition. Don't let children be excluded because of how much income their home has.30482018-05-09T14:28:1735309Gill RitchieMusic is good for the soul - everyone should have the opportunity to play, regardless of household income.30482018-05-09T14:54:23.83335311Rosemary Rutherford Music is an essential element for creative development and prepares young people to realise their potential in all aspects of their life. It offers learning how to listen and be present. 2 critical skills for everyone no matter what road they take for economic sustainability. 30482018-05-09T14:58:32.3535312joyce cattanachMusic lessons are not "free" they have been paid for by our tax system and they MUST remain so, free for all at point of contact in our schools.30482018-05-09T15:05:24.05335313Vicky KeirMy daughter now serves with the Royal Marines Band Service. Her instrument skills were developed through instrumental tuition in school. She is a shining example of where school instrument tuition can take a person. Without it she quite simply wouldn't be there. 30482018-05-09T15:07:08.02335314Tom PatersonI would like my granddaughters to get the same musical tuition that my daughter received.30482018-05-09T15:35:55.19735315Veronica DavisFree tuition in school for those who wish it is a must. Not many parents can afford private tuition now and early access to music can open so many doors and bring huge benefits to ALL children. It should not be restricted to only those whose famiies cn afford it.30482018-05-09T15:49:24.56735316Norma MalcolmI was lucky to get the chance to learn to play the flute at secondary school and became a founder member of the Edinburgh Secondary Schools Orchestra. What an experience that was and I think more children should have this opportunity to enjoy music.30482018-05-09T15:52:09.66335317MAUREEN MCGARRY-O'HANLONHow many times do we have to go through this rigmarole? Music Tuition and Instrumental Study improves academic performance and it develops confidence and personality.30482018-05-09T16:06:52.10335318Callum RaeSome of our best musicians developed both their talent and love of music in the Scottish school system. To remove this vital opportunity for future generations is nothing less than cultural vandalism. Charging for tuition removes the opportunity for those on low income. Keep it free.30482018-05-09T16:09:58.1835319Robbie MayWhy should musical instrument tuition be treated differently to any other educational topic? Our young people should be offered free instrument tuition at school.30482018-05-09T17:22:48.72735320Jamie CampbellGiving every child a chance to get some musical tuition is very important, as it can enrich their life, and give some the chance to consider music as a possible career30482018-05-09T17:25:03.11335321Chris CombestStudy after study proves the importance of music the lives of developing children. Beyond that, music is a cultural identity unique to each country. Preserve the traditions and cultural importance of a musical vocabulary, please. 30482018-05-09T17:29:18.18335322Nicolette Girgis It seems very wrong that mainly children of wealthier parents will be able to have music lessons! 30482018-05-09T17:49:05.18335324Claire CaseyDon't take such an amazing opportunity away from children.30482018-05-09T17:58:37.21735325David KilpatrickThis is more than important. It's almost as vital as reading and writing, and helps with so many other subjects from maths to arts. Schools should have music teaching staff, in addition to peripatetic specialist teachers. 30482018-05-09T18:24:30.9835327Andrea CopIntroduction to a wide range of instruments at an earlier age will help to break down the social class structure. Not everyone is a violinist or pianist. Whilst recorders give easy inexpensive access to making music, finding an orchestral instrument that suits the child is inevitably limited by the means of the parent of their own interests. Free tuition is essential but so is the need to open the horizon of the full range of instruments available. Could orchestras in Universities or other partnerships provide access taster sessions?30482018-05-09T18:32:46.32335328Hazel YoungerThis is not just about providing the same opportunities to our children which we had ourselves, it is about helping to nurture well rounded individuals who have acquired valuable life skills which will stand them in good stead for the next 70 or 80 years, no matter what they ultimately choose to do with their talents.30482018-05-09T18:36:57.4435330David EdesIn their current form Scottish Canals are unaccountable to their users.\r\nI also believe the Board of Scottish Canals should have a representative from each of the Canal user groups 30022018-05-09T18:37:56.62335331Aileen WhytockThe music instrument tuition my children received at school had such a positive effect on them. It increased their self confidence and improved their learning in other areas. Please don't deprive other children if this opportunity.30482018-05-09T18:48:22.5235332Lesley HerdMusic is a universal language and like any language requires teachers and students to pass on and learn the skills needed to make music. It should be accessible to all, regardless of background, social standing and ability to pay. Music should be a level playing field, with hard work, talent and determination being the only criteria for access. Free for all and as important in a curriculum as maths, English language.30482018-05-09T18:51:32.8535333Karen ScottMy daughter has had the amazing chance to learn violin, which we would never have been able to afford otherwise. 30482018-05-09T19:00:36.9335334Carol JarvisMusic helps develop so many other skills, from team work, to discipline, to maths, to languages, to a sense of achievement. Why should it be treated any different to any other subject? About time people recognised how useful Music is in all walks of life!30482018-05-09T19:04:50.22735335Karin frenchThis should be available to all pupils which it isn't\r\n. Kids with ASN don't get the opportunity 30482018-05-09T19:15:19.57335336Elizabeth KleinFree music instrumental should be free to all children as other subjects on the curriculum.30482018-05-09T19:16:32.0435337Shyvonne McNivenOur children love their music and instruments. We are a working family of two parents but would not be able to afford this as an extra cost to our income 30482018-05-09T19:27:35.0535338Ian Donaldson Music should be a free part of the whole school experience 30482018-05-09T19:46:11.52335339Aura MurphyMusic brings people together, is a language that crosses borders, helps children learn AND improves concentration and can aid relaxation when studying, travelling, socialising..... why is it not seen as essential?30482018-05-09T19:58:32.41335340Katherine McinnesCouldn't agree and support this petition more as if someone shared information regarding my children without my consent I would definately have something to say about it. These acts have an impact on family's lives and health and I've witnessed it. 30142018-05-09T20:02:20.3735341Diane HainingI learned to play the cornet and the bagpipes when I was at school, yet I have had to pay for my son to learn the drums. Bring back free lessons and we might just see some more school.pipe bands pop up.30482018-05-09T20:14:21.00335344Lesley HerdMusic is the universal language and tuition should be available to all in schools regardless of whether parents can afford to pay. Social skills, cognitive ability, teamwork, the list of benefits is endless. 30482018-05-09T20:15:29.25335345Kathleen SmartChildren of all ages and abilities music is a way to express their feelings 30482018-05-09T20:18:47.98735346Doreen McAllisterThis is a a wonderful course but should be free for all as education, music brings joy to everyone .30482018-05-09T20:33:32.1335348Lesley Herdmusic tuition should be free and accessible to all schoolchildren in Scotland regardless of social background or financial status of parents and guardians. Learning to play music improves social interaction, student confidence, concentration and cognitive skills - why is the country being so shortsighted?30482018-05-09T20:34:42.2735349Deborah ThomsonNot all children are academic. Music helps the brain stimulation in different ways. Music is great help for Mental health and well being. It can relieve the stress that young children have to endure these days. 30482018-05-09T20:37:52.60735350Maura gallacherMusic can break through emontional and learning bariers that the normal school academic cariculam fails to achieve.30482018-05-09T21:35:31.7135352Margaret YoungWe need to give support to children to secure a future in Music in Scotland.30482018-05-09T21:50:05.27335353Clare Lawrence My son was given this opportunity at school and 5 years later is still doing it and plays in a brass band who for three years running are the Scottish Champion, he has choosen Music as one of his subjects and hopes to go on to do Music higher as well, we are not a musical family and would never have thought about giving him this opportunity, so important that it is available to all children.30482018-05-09T21:52:37.76735354Margaret-Jane Yardley Definitely should be free as part of cirriculum.. Unfair that parents who can't afford lessons children suffer. 30482018-05-09T22:04:42.97335355Alison GreenI had free lessons at school.Doing music and playing an instrument was so beneficial for my self confidence and self discipline.Music lessons should be available free of charge to all children.30482018-05-09T22:14:24.91735356Amanda GreenWe all need the chance to learn to play instruments! It should not be just for those who can afford to pay! Music is everywhere, in everybody's everyday life.\r\n\r\n30482018-05-09T22:15:26.7735357Alexa MinnieMusic and instrument tuition should be made available to all. It enhances education generally, increases cultural awareness and emotional awareness, enhances social skills, enhances confidence and gives future adults a form of self care and free therapy to fall back on when times get hard in adult life....maybe a fee extra pounds spent at primary school will save at least the same amount in mental health costs later in life.30482018-05-09T22:26:18.97735358Alyson ConnellWhile I understand that it may not be possible to provide the music lessons completely free, the charges levied by some local authorities are making music an elitist subject and all but impossible for some students to consider taking at Nat 5 and above. This is yet another area of the curriculum where the attainment gap should be closing but is, in fact, being wilfully allowed to widen. 30482018-05-09T22:32:24.5435359Heather RinaldiAccess for all is essential no matter what your family income!!!30482018-05-09T22:38:39.62335360Claire McCallumWould be shocking if our young people lost out on this opportunity, should be available to everyone. 30482018-05-09T22:46:35.41735361Craig CaffreyShort but sweet. Ridiculous that this is even in contention. The world was built around music. 30482018-05-09T22:46:56.63335362Craig CaffreyMon the music30482018-05-09T23:05:32.3135363Fiona OylerAs a parent whose children had music tuition in Midlothian, I fully support this petition. My daughter now sings in the a chorus having her interest in music nurtured at school.30482018-05-09T23:23:51.535364Karen BowmanI have shared with as many musicians groups and orchestras as possible as this petition has to be supported by people who know the direct benefit of learning to play and make music together. Hope tha the Parliament will get a strong message that musical education opportunity must be free based in on talent not income. Scotland prides itself on free higher education and growth in free nursery places. As others say research shows that learning an instrument (including singing) has powerful benefits beyond the skills needed to play. Big Noise Raploch based on La Sistema showed community benefits. My husband (Aberdeenshire) and son (Edinburgh) both learned violin at school and went on to play and learn in making music with others as adults and both say that it taught so much more teamwork and languages and self esteem and confidence just a few.30482018-05-09T23:35:24.67335365Bethany GallowayWithout having my free saxophone tuition from Primary 5 all through school, I would not be studying at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland today. We need free tuition to suit the needs and wishes of all learners. Every child deserves the chance to learn a musical instrument, and securing free tuition for this would open doors for 1000s of children. 30482018-05-09T23:44:43.4835366Louise MitchellMy daughter has played violin for 5 years and now this might be taken away from herdue to having to pay , discusting, , so much for encouraging our kids. 30482018-05-10T00:29:45.6435367Jan hendersonWe have a chance to keep music tuition open for all children in our schools and not just for those who are lucky enough to be born to families of means . Please consider making it illegal to progress to further class divides in Scottish society.30482018-05-10T01:48:27.24735368Sharon RobertsonMusic is the route to all life stories, it helps children adjust to certain areas of their lives and it brings joy. They need to have music to learn how to play instruments and sing to give them rhythm for other areas of their lives. I don't want to see this stopped it is imperative they have this in their lives and it helps with mental ill health and well being. 30482018-05-10T02:08:49.62335369Rosemary DeSierviI've had ME CFS for 37 years and it has severely limited my livelihood and ability to live a connected social life. I am mostly housebound, but encouraged that we are now recognizing the disease medically and may be able to fund research to find a cure. I am lucky to have access to Stanford University doctors. I encourage you to do all you can for this horrific condition which takes away one's uel" for living. ME patients have been suffering long enough. Patients need your support and funding.30502018-05-10T03:03:04.8835370Rebecca ChaudhuriMy sister and I were fortunate enough to have been able to study instruments at a time when tuition was free. We couldn't have done so otherwise. This enabled my sister to become a violinist and teacher, who is now also bringing music to orphans in Cambodia. I was able to teach my son to play music, from 7, before he could take lessons at school. We know the link between music and academic achievement, but being able to put an instrument or ensemble or bands on a CV, thanks to free tuition, might be the difference between getting a job and not, for a youngster applying with no previous experience. 30482018-05-10T07:34:23.68335371Sabinefingers crossed for compassionate progress!X30502018-05-10T09:12:14.37735372Diane GilmoreMusic is very important from a very early age. We must keep music alive in our schools.30482018-05-10T09:25:42.44735373Wayne SutherlandShocking piece of legislation that clearly breaches the human rights and privacy of every family in scotland . We need a full public inquiry to find out why the govt are so keen to disregard our human rights despite the supreme court ruling. 30142018-05-10T09:36:39.11335374Lisa McCormick teacher incomes are already covered through the schools budget. What happened to allowing children to be able to express themselves through music which has been proven over and over again that it helps their confidence and brings them on socially. I have 2 kids and would be struggling for the 2 of them to be able to do this as I also have other bills to pay30482018-05-10T10:09:44.02735375Elizabeth BirkettArt, music and dance are so inmportant for kids to get a well balanced education and some light relief from academia thus leaving them refreshed to go back into their Maths, language and science classes.All of these subjects enhance the other subjects as they also contain maths and language. All kids should have the chance to learn and instrument - preferably Ukulele! 30482018-05-10T10:12:53.1735376Elizabeth BirkettAll kids should be given the chance to play Ukulele! It relieves stress and makes you happy!30482018-05-10T11:41:03.49335378Sharon MurraySome children will not be academic and music will be where their talents lie. Every child should be given the opportunity to flourish. 30482018-05-10T12:15:30.16335379Scott McDermottMusic is an extremely valuable asset to a child's development. They learn to express themselves and also get the chance to perform thus enhancing their self confidence. The list is endless but I believe that it should be free for every child throughout their schooling.30482018-05-10T12:17:16.29735380Elizabeth McKenzieMusic is a very important part of education to encourage the future love of music. Many children would not have the opportunity if charges are implemented.30482018-05-10T12:48:49.63735381Fiona Anderson As a child I received violin lessons at school. This offered me many opportunities throughout my life. Please keep offering music.30482018-05-10T12:56:08.58335382Fiona Anderson Free music lessons at school in Scotland opened many opportunities for me both in Scotland and in Canada, social and professionally. I was able to pass my knowledge on, teaching in a primary school. My parents would not have been able to pay for private lessons.30482018-05-10T13:21:15.49335383Sandra FoxShould be no different to other subjects at school!!30482018-05-10T13:42:19.94735384Madeleine CampbellAll children should be given the opportunity to experience music through playing musical instruments and the chance to experiment with different cultural instruments30482018-05-10T15:39:51.79335385Ann CalderInsulting, intrusive piece of legislation30142018-05-10T15:57:09.9235386Douglas MontgomeryFree instrumental tuition could be the answer to deprivation, vandalism, drug addiction, alcoholism etc It keeps ours bairns occupied here in Orkney and it is the safest place to grow up in the UK.30482018-05-10T16:02:03.8935387David moir It would be a sad day and a step backwards not to offer children the chance for a musical education 30482018-05-10T17:23:09.43335388David Alexander BrownThis is long overdue.30022018-05-10T17:39:25.32335389Caroline RalstonEvery child should have the chance to play music regardless of houseHold income30482018-05-10T17:45:39.29335390Janice Eckersley\r\n\r\nbefore all this I was fit and healthy before that always on the go and working and going to the gym and then everything stopped.i was 49 I am now 58.\r\nMy life since then has been put on hold. I do go out for a day out with my husband but after a day out for a few hours then I am in the house after for days or bed as exhausted and I have so many different symptoms I never know what I am like day to day.30502018-05-10T18:25:04.89335391Paula Mulvaney My children receive tuition in bagpipes, we live in Scotland it is part of their heritage. Please keep our musical traditions alive through our children or bagpipes will simply die out 30482018-05-10T18:55:22.3535392James DykesBridges need repaired, so locks closed due to lack of funds. Yet, as usual,the people at the top creaming off substantial, salaries,pensions & benefits. Great need for more accountability.30022018-05-10T18:59:15.19335393Joyce DykesTypical, government passes a service to the private sector who run the business for the benefit of themselves rather than the users. 30022018-05-10T19:40:47.2735394Carol-anne Murray100% 30142018-05-10T19:42:57.75335395Ian HowkerEssential not only for the Lowlands Canal but for all of Scotland's inland waterways to adjudicate on conflicts of interests in Scottish Canals activities.30022018-05-10T19:56:08.8935396Martine Scott The wide benefits of musical tuition are invaluable and should be available for all.30482018-05-10T19:57:57.80335397Janet GriersonMusical education has inestimable value on so many levels. Every child should be able to access it easily.30482018-05-10T20:05:24.67335398Angus Jackgreat work, there really should be a third party available to customers of Scottish Canals to escalate complaints to. They are a law unto themselves...30022018-05-10T20:07:14.65735399Angus JackGreat work, there really should be a third party to help resolve disputes between Scottish Canals and their customers. Especially as there are so many unhappy customers. Scottish Canals are a law unto themselves...30022018-05-10T20:13:22.73735400Liz DrifeAll children should have the chance of music lessons not just those who can afford them. Empower our new talent!30482018-05-10T20:31:01.5635401omar zaman I suffer from me cfs for a while there's no treatment there's no medication no one cares they don't see it as a threat when it is I can't leave the house or room some times you feel trapped when you cannot socialise or be normal 30502018-05-10T20:35:42.40335402Angela MorelandLearning a musical instrument opens children up to culture, concentration and developers the brain in different ways. If only wealthy children get this opportunity it makes the gap between rich and poor worse.30482018-05-10T20:39:03.89735403Joe Sutherland! I can't imagine my life without music and it all started in free music education and instruments when i was at school in Scotland. Started when I was at primary school in Dunbeath, i can still remember playing the recorder and the poems and songs we presented on stage in Wick. Music was part and parcel of every school I attended in Scotland (7!), my brothers and I went on to be founder members of the local brass band while we were still at school and played for years afterwards, i played in orchestras, played in concerts across the UK, Albert Hall et al, played bass guitar in local bands in local pubs and clubs in Scotland and wrote some of the music we played. It really helped me with my maths and my confidence - i am not a pro, i still play and write music for my own fun, you dont have to be to be a pro to enjoy music, if i might add to that old adage - keep music live, keep music free in education.30482018-05-10T20:47:25.36735404Tom MurkinCan't believe that Scottish Canals have let the lowland canals deteriorate to the extent they are now effectively closed until further notice. They need holding to account, and to uphold their statutory duty to maintain the canals for navigation. 30022018-05-10T21:05:35.08735405Donna RodgerMusic tuition, like art, dance & drama are essential for creative & social development. No child is the same and they all have strengths and excel in different subjects. Music tuition should be available to every child, not just those with a better income. Too many cuts are being made in education. 30482018-05-10T21:16:30.09735406Lisa FordMusic is so important. It impacts on so many ways of learning. We need more , not less. 30482018-05-10T21:20:15.91735407Jennifer BennettI have trained, lived and worked in Scotland and though I live in the UK, these issues affect us all over the world. We need research, recognition and above all treatment!!!30502018-05-10T21:22:59.88735408Stuart hendersonThe way the Scottish canals have been run into the ground is a disgrace 30022018-05-10T21:30:30.31735409Kirstin GilmartinI strongly believe that music tuition should be free - important for child development 30482018-05-10T21:39:26.59335410Barbara SloanI have several friends who suffer from ME. Research into treatment is vastly Underfunded. Please, Scotland, make a difference!30502018-05-10T21:51:03.44335411John BellThe canal was running better before 2012, in my opinion the reason is the management at Scottish canals have priorities that does not involve boats moving on the water, they would rather boats were static homes30022018-05-10T21:57:02.60735412Tony SwainsonAs an ex professional orchestral player still teaching at the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland I enjoy following the careers of many ex students of the RCS and the old RSAMD in Europe and the rest of the world as well as here in the U.K. working as soloists, in orchestras or in teaching positions. I foresee the time coming soon where the influence of the Scottish musician in orchestras, concert halls and music institutions around the world is no more as a result of the shortsighted decisions being made right now by those in a position to make that difference.30482018-05-10T22:02:44.6735413Fiona eastopI would support this as my children are benefitting from this. Evidence indicates that music helps wellbeing, social interactions, and benefits other academic areas too.30482018-05-10T22:12:45.32735414Kenneth bakerGlad to put my name to stopping this filthy rubbish30142018-05-10T22:14:55.39735415Sharon Mcdonald In a world full of technology, the joy, peace and contentment of playing a musical instrument should remain available to school children. It's something real and that aline is invaluable. 30482018-05-10T22:14:55.37335416Isobel DoyleIntroducing fees for music tuition will deprive many children of this fabulous opportunity. Playing an instrument will become an elitist activity. This is very wrong. 30482018-05-10T22:18:49.89735417Gillian GallagherMusic is so important for ALL children and not just to those who can afford it! Music provides life skills. Let's get music tuition back to the way it used to be FREE!!!! 30482018-05-11T00:10:37.42335419Nigel Ewenmusic is undervalued in childrens education. Please keep offering music30482018-05-11T01:00:10.39735421Louise NicolsonTotalitarian nonsense. The State does not have our childrens wellbeing at heart, but is blinded by its own Power. Disgusting waste of resources at the taxpayers expense. Scotland calls for responsibility and accountability .30142018-05-11T06:36:10.55335423Liz StrongMusic tuition in schools should be available free to all whatever their financial position. There is a real need for the educational, emotional and social benefits that music brings to all ages but especially the young. How dare we justify bringing back the 'have and have nots' system back by offering discounts etc in special circumstance. Once again making parents the bad guys for not being able to afford for their child or children to continue with their chosen music tuition. How much talent will go to waste because of this!!!!!30482018-05-11T07:05:31.98735424Heather BrownFree lessons gave me the opportunity to start learning an instrument and from there, developed a passion for music and purse it as a career. 30482018-05-11T08:40:07.66735426Nichola McPaulI have suffered from ME for the last six years. It has had a devastating impact on my life and my familys lives. I am no longer able to drive no longer and able to work. I have not been able to leave my home unattended and without being pushed in my wheelchair since November 2012 and my husband has become my career. Most heartbreakingly of all I I have not been able to be the mother to my little girl that I should be able to be. The level of knowledge and understanding and support of this condition by the NHS is practically non existent with just one specialist ME nurse based in Dunfermline for the whole of Scotland. That is despite there being over 20000 people in Scotland suffering with this devastating disease. This HAS to change. 30502018-05-11T09:05:47.48335427Cameron JayIf I hadn't had the option and the encouragement to become involved in music I doubt I would ever have become the musician I am today. I have worked all over the world, in numerous genres, recorded with artists of the highest calibre and on award winning and Grammy nominated albums. All this from habing the chance of free music lessons throughout my early education. 30482018-05-11T09:23:18.03735429Stella McCracken Music is a universal language. It is a way of expressing ourselves. It commands discipline which is a great learning curve for children and gets them involved with so many projects.it is so essential to keep these lessons and opportunities open to every child.30482018-05-11T09:48:57.2635430Jamie ThomI'm a Scot who lives abroad. Free musical tuition was a massively important part of my education and inspired me to have the confidence to perform, not just music but in front of any audience for any purpose. This part of our children's education is vital. 30482018-05-11T09:50:19.1535431Ken NairnThe Education (Scotland) Act 1872 suggested that "All children aged from 5 to 13 years were to attend. Poverty was not accepted as an excuse"\r\n\r\nUnless the term education is taken down to its narrowest form then it is imperative that children with musical talent, from any background in Scotland, are able to have their talents developed without reference to the wealth of their parents.\r\n30482018-05-11T10:29:01.99335432Julie BedellThe u.k canals are a vibrant living historic monument and should be preserved for all to enjoy . 30022018-05-11T10:39:31.9735433Kathy RussellWhy are Scotland closing navigations? England, Wales and Ireland are thankfully restoring them!30022018-05-11T11:21:55.48735434Ros CurwoodThere is good scientific research that absolutely confirms the claims of this petition. Every other subject taught will benefit, and the mental health issues that cost so much heartache will reduce. 30482018-05-11T11:33:35.89735435Jacqui barbet-shieldsI am signing this as i have ME 30502018-05-11T11:39:03.58735436Lisa JohnsonLearning music improves maths, confidence, self esteem, team working and so much more. It should be available to all children.30482018-05-11T12:38:20.60735437Karen DufourThrough my local authority I received free instrumental lessons which provded me with the ability to progress to study performance at the RSAMD (now RCS) and become a professioanl musician. I now perform and work in the cultural industry contributing to the Scottish econmy. It all began as a result of a fantastic Local Authority Instrumentsal Music service. Don't make it "Those who pay to play". 30482018-05-11T13:05:08.98335438Steve EganMusic opens so many doors to attainment so it is important that the Scottish Government not only supports the aspirations of young people, it funds them.30482018-05-11T13:22:49.47335439angus cochranemusic has many benefits including buiding up good team spirit and youngsters involved are less likely to be involved with gangs 30482018-05-11T13:26:06.0235440angus cochraneinvolving the youth in music takes them away ferom being involved it gangs and petty crime30482018-05-11T14:44:22.9735442Marion Duffythe government is supposed to be dedicated to reducing the poverty gap, and social inclusion. Put your money where your mouth is!30482018-05-11T14:58:47.835443Sue BaxendaleThe research done on the value of music in schools is absolutely compelling - playing and performing music both individually and with our peers increases our communication skills, numeracy skills, emotional development, ability to socially connect, and sense of well-being. It should be offered to every child, regardless of social demographic or financial circumstances - children grow through play, through creativity, NOT by being clamped to a desk sitting tests to meet academic targets! Do not make these cuts, not now, not ever.30482018-05-11T15:01:54.37735444Nicola FoxUnderfunded, not acknowledged, time for change!30502018-05-11T15:57:21.07335445Kim Smedley-Williams I think when I am the one educating medical professionals and support services about what my illness there is something fundamentally wrong with the system. I should not have to be the one to teach them how to help me. 30502018-05-11T16:45:54.15735446Jennifer GrayI have been fighting ME for over 7 years and have had very little support and advice from the first day I went to tell the doctor of my symptoms to this day after been diagnosed 5 years ago. My M.E. has relapsed and I went to my doctor for advice, support and some reassurance but all I got was an offer for a letter for a week off work. I rejected, I want to work and I would love something that would help me do that 30502018-05-11T16:54:03.6135447Emily LearmontPlease help people with ME. This is a terrible condition to suffer from. It effects people of all ages and ruins their education, careers and family lives. It is ridiculous that there should still be stigma attached to it. Please help to find a cure.30502018-05-11T16:55:42.83335448Alistair McCorkellSad we should have to petition for music in schools in the first place. Music is such a big part of many peoples life.30482018-05-11T17:18:14.63335449Iain StreetAt the present time, BWS are unaccountable to their users, and appear to have forgotten that they are a Navigation Authority, and not a property development company. A Waterways Ombudsman would go some way to restoring the balance.30022018-05-11T18:05:35.1735451Christine calvertIn Dumfries & Galloway we have to pay. My children paid for int 2, higher and adv higher also my sons lessons for adv higher were through video conference- shocking 30482018-05-11T18:19:40.78335452Fraser HarrisMusic is not just about being able to plan an instrument or appreciate. It is a valuable learning and development opportunity that allows young people to find more out of life than just academic subjects. Please keep this opportunity.30482018-05-11T18:40:58.84735454Finn CarsonAlthough I live in Ireland I want equal care and recognition the world over for ME and anyone suffering. I have suffered 16 long years took the best years I had and still no cure or reasonable care in Ireland alone. So we have to start somewhere. Why not here. 30502018-05-11T18:42:50.00335455Adelene Hutchinson Children are going to miss out on a wonderful opportunity to learn music , play an instrument . Which could lead too so many opportunities . 30482018-05-11T18:44:44.4935456Melissa Campbell As a child I received violin and recorder lessons at primary and secondary school. This led to my school being able to have an orchestra which an invaluable experience to cherish. Many children find themselves through music and art and is fundamental to our learning through expression and to understand emotion. \r\nPlease give children a chance through an educational setting of something that might otherwise pass them by. 30482018-05-11T18:49:47.635457Caroline MilneThe waterways are part of our heritage and an amenity we cannot afford to neglect.30022018-05-11T19:22:49.41735458Martha CroninThe bridge closures are costing us thousands of pounds to get our home to its mooring in Auchinstarry, this is unacceptable.30022018-05-11T19:43:49.65335459Amy WallaceAs a local music teacher having received free Music tuition, I strongly feel this is an opportunity which should be a right of every single child regardless of background or financial situation! 30482018-05-11T19:48:08.90335460Alison HutchisonMusic tuition does not discriminate so please don't take the choice away for all our children's to have that experience of learning music. It is such a great skill to have and can help many people that are not as well off to feel like that they are someone and included.30482018-05-11T20:09:26.70335462Louise HunterBoth of my children received music tuition (strings and brass) starting in Primary school through Perth and Kinross Council and later Stirling Council. They both then went on to play in school orchestras and independent bands. I believe this tuition had a major impact in their development in lots of different ways. It horrifies me to think that future generations may not have this wonderful opportunity!!!30482018-05-11T20:31:24.4435463Ola Watson Playing a musical instrument improves many cognitive skills including concentration, as well helping to improve maths and language ability. Learning music to exam or concert standard requires extreme attention to detail, perseverance and sometimes courage. Performing can be a superb confidence builder. \r\nPlaying an instrument in a group is likely to develope social skills and maintain good mental health. \r\n\r\nThe music industry in britain brings in a lot of revenue and supports tourism and other leisure industries. \r\n\r\nUnlike many other school subjects, music tuition often results in a life-long love of playing and listening to a music, enriching activities that benefit not only the individual but the whole community. \r\n\r\nWhen instrumental lessons are restricted by finances the life of the school suffers. \r\n\r\nRestricting instrumental tuition is a false economy in my opinion as a private instrumental teacher. During twenty years of teaching I have seen how much even the least musical child can enjoy and benefit from learning an instrument. It is a self- esteem builder, outlet for self-expression, gateway to the arts, teacher of self- discipline and patience teacher and crucially develops listening skills. In an increasingly visual and fast-paced world the importance of the latter can't be overstated. I get children who begin lessons who barely understand the concept of listening! They noticeably become more resilient and willing to engage in difficult activities requiring practice and patience. No other activity I know of has so many benefits to the individual and to the community. 30482018-05-11T20:38:39.22335465Carrie BoaxAs the President of the Scottish Brass Band Association and an advocate for giving all kids the opportunity to make music, I am fully aware of not only the educational benefits of learning to play an instrument but have witnessed first hand the social, emotional and health benefits it brings. Please give sport and music parity in our schools and I promise you will create a healthy and stable Scotland! #giveourkidsthechanceplease!30482018-05-11T20:39:30.20735466Ola Watson Removing free instrument lessons would make scotland a less equal society. The benefits of instrumental tuition extend across all areas of the school curriculum and often result in life-long music participation. 30482018-05-11T20:43:04.7735467Gordon MunroAs a beneficiary of free instrumental lessons in School, I must support this petition. Without this opportunity, I would not have become the professional I am today. 30482018-05-11T21:32:54.07335469Jane CombeI am a sufferer for last 13 years sadly30502018-05-11T22:34:05.88735473Sylvia HoggThings need to change! A member of my family has suffered with ME through her teenage years and has had to give up on many life goals. She receives no support of any kind. More is done for other illnesses that have a lesser impact on everyday life and that do not last for life. Action is needed.30502018-05-11T22:45:14.68735474Ernie ConnerMusic enriches the soul.30482018-05-11T22:55:56.61735475Dr Karen E McAulayChildren whose parents can pay will get by, but for all the children whose parents can't pay, they will lose the chance to learn a vital skill which also helps with other aspects of their education. And latent talent will go unnoticed. This must not happen!30482018-05-11T23:21:44.93335476Mark DixonNot only did my experience with instrumental learning at school provide me with great fun and lifelong friends. it provided me with a conceptual levs with which to view many other aspects of life.30482018-05-11T23:33:42.735478Neil CooperWithout free tuition my niece would not have appeared in this video and more importantly would not be a shining example of the talent that can only be nurtured without a fiscal barrier to entry. 30482018-05-11T23:46:21.7435479Robert YorkeMusical education is a massive boost to "general" education. Investing in music is a fantastic educational investment. 30482018-05-12T00:44:39.07735480Avril Joneskeep free music tutition30482018-05-12T00:47:39.7835481Margaret.S.ColtmanMusic is such an important subject,that should be part of the curriculum for all children & be free of charge.I was lucky enough,as were my children,to be taught a musical instrument in school.So much is gained from this experience & fond memories to last a lifetime.Please don't deprive the next generations,\r\nof this precious gift.These cuts aren't necessarily the right ones to make.Think again before these choices are made,it's too important.30482018-05-12T02:42:36.22735483Aaron MartinA totally fascist move to control the population and manipulate individual families. Tyrannical!30142018-05-12T05:03:57.59735485John HamiltonThis is the start of a serious issue for our country. \r\nMusic enhances and provides the soundtrack to our everyday lives, what will happen when there are not enough musicians left to provide that soundtrack?\r\nPlease reconsider this appalling policy and give everyone the opportunity to improve their own lives and enhance the lives of others.30482018-05-12T05:28:02.5235486Andrew Bone As a person who lives on a boat on the canal I feel as if I have no say about the environment I choose to live in and that Scottish canals are in decline 30022018-05-12T05:48:09.2635487Dr. Keith N. StewartThis some what complex disease has devastated the lives of far too many individuals. As some one who has worked in Immunology and Cancer Medicine for over 40 years I think we really need to see a complete change in treatment modalities for ME. This will only happen if research focus and research funding is greatly increased for ME .30502018-05-12T06:40:21.7535488Imke HendersonSo many vital life skills can be learned through learning to play an instrument and playing in an ensemble. It can make a huge difference for a student's30482018-05-12T07:00:46.75335490christina milarvie quarrellaccess for all children to music and learning within can change lifes30482018-05-12T07:27:44.7435491Graeme GassFree music lessons can provide enormous opportunities for children to access an activity which can develop inherent talents which may lead to career and employment possibilities. At the very least it may provide a new hobby or interest which can instill a great deal if personal enjoyment and satisfaction.30482018-05-12T08:33:31.17335492Ciara McCutcheonYour income should not determine whether or not your child is able to play an instrument 30482018-05-12T08:36:34.98735493Michel LhombreaudDown with big government!30142018-05-12T08:44:50.62735496Anita woodsMe and my family have been victims of this .... It was, still is and will always be absolute torture to live with. \r\nKnowing there's more families than just us going through what we're going through sends shivers down my spine.\r\nThe people who ruined our lives must be held responsible for what they did.\r\nMy kids lives are ruined! :(\r\n30142018-05-12T08:46:41.26735497Tom ReillyCouldn't agree and support this petition more as if someone shared information regarding my children without my consent I would definately have something to say about it. These acts have an impact on family's lives and health and I've witnessed it.30142018-05-12T08:49:54.75335498Richard LoupThere is never justification nor excuse for bad new laws. NHS Scotland waiting time guarantee, anyone?30142018-05-12T08:53:46.00335499Bill GoodallAlthough I am in my sixties and my children are thankfully old enough not to be affected by this draconian scheme, I still feel it important that any right thinking person should speak out in fierce opposition. I would urge fellow citizens of all ages and backgrounds to make their views known. 30142018-05-12T08:54:58.36335500John Barrie SaundersAn approach from any Named Person to my family would give rise to further social division through a somewhat frank exchange of views - not advisable.30142018-05-12T08:57:32.45735501Gerard mc VEIGH Legislation that needs to be challenged,intrusive # .30142018-05-12T08:57:55.64335502Andrena CrawfordShocking piece of legislation.30142018-05-12T09:02:29.1135504Benjamin KeayIf it wasn't for free music education I wouldn't be doing and studying what I am. Why should younger generations miss out on the opportunities we had as a child.30482018-05-12T09:12:32.2735507Laura RileyThe Government should be held to account for a nasty piece of authoritarian legislation which should never have passed on to the Statute book.30142018-05-12T09:13:41.64335508Brian Rattraythis disgraceful NP situation needs to be binned & the SNP held accountable for all failings 30142018-05-12T09:13:43.9935509William jonesLong overdue30022018-05-12T09:14:39.1335510Derek FoxJust to add my support in getting this distasteful legislation put to bed for good.30142018-05-12T09:18:30.56735511Ian MeiklejohnInterfering Nanny state30142018-05-12T09:19:31.33335512angela gavinIntrusive piece of legislation. I want reassurance that information has not been shared on my family without my consent.30142018-05-12T09:22:55.4335513Anne RaeGovernment flying in the face if pubkic opinion.. again30142018-05-12T09:27:08.03735514Bill JarvieSurely this will be the beginning of the end for this utter totalitarian nonsense, and the typical product of this 'wee pretendy parliament'?30142018-05-12T09:27:25.78735515Catherine AndrewsThe doggedness of the SNP to push this legislation through regardless is frightening and they should mot be allowed to get it through30142018-05-12T09:27:26.16335516Marjory BissettShocking this was allowed to happen at all30142018-05-12T09:29:55.2135518Andrew PointerThere does need to be an independent inquiry into the GIRFEC and Named Policy section of the CYP Act was passed, when it was patently obvious to all that it was contrary to the Data Protection Act. Our MSPs and government lawyers, local authority lawyers, and the Scottish justiciary all failed to competently scrutenise the legislation before it was passed by Holyrood. And some councils are still citing unlawful guidance (Ken MacDonald's 2013 letter) about data sharing to their staff to this day. 30142018-05-12T09:32:46.44335519Bruce LuffmanThe SNP Government talk about a power grab by Westminster with regard to Brexit, yet this proposed legislation is a blatent attempt to to get total central control and treading all over our family rights. 30142018-05-12T09:33:51.21335520Jean P A GiustiThe Scottish government has no right and no democratic mandate to intrude on the lives of families with their proposed GIRFEC scheme and is behaving in an exceedingly authoritarian way not unlike totalitarian regimes. They need to sort out the NHS and allow families to bring up their children without unqualified and unaccountable state spies causing unnecessary disruption to their lives. 30142018-05-12T09:37:37.78735521William McDowellAs a concerned grandparent I find the whole idea abhorrent.Big brother spying on not just the children but whole families.30142018-05-12T09:39:42.47735522Kirsty HolmesI have several close friends who suffer from this debilitating condition, time for this to be recognised and funding made available for research into its cause and treatment. 30502018-05-12T09:40:07.8535523Betty CosgroveSo much for data protection!30142018-05-12T09:42:12.35335524Maurice FrankAll ways known from experience to any person, of getting it wrong for a child, have an automatic right to be aired as evidence.30142018-05-12T09:45:25.52735525Eileen StuartThis needs to be thrown out now30142018-05-12T09:48:10.13735526Susan NelsonThis is very scary stuff. I have no responsibility for children. I wish to protect all families and professionals. Let us have no more of these off the wall unsolicited unauthorised and unsupported proposals. 30142018-05-12T09:50:31.1835527Drew GivenIt's the parents duty to guide, teach and care for their children not the governments, the government want interfere in every situation in families life.30142018-05-12T09:58:48.71735528David BryceThe Governments proposals are totalitarian30142018-05-12T10:03:51.7635529Myra PendrichIm completely against this Named Person scheme.30142018-05-12T10:05:56.91735530Alisdair MorrisonTruely shocking proposals. These are a gross intrusion on our privacy.30142018-05-12T10:10:12.9535531Muriel LeithDisgraceful that the Scottish government are still trying to push this through in spite of massive opposition.30142018-05-12T10:10:30.32335532David HepburnIsn't the sharing of personal data without specific permission a breach of the new data protection rules?30142018-05-12T10:10:44.79735533Mary Murphy Intrusive legislation which undermines family life and parental responsibility 30142018-05-12T10:10:51.02735534David CraigThe arrogance of the Scottish government in ignoring public opinion on this issue leaves me dumbfounded.30142018-05-12T10:15:13.52735535Barrie CooperExcellent petition - the Scottish Government have no right to share individual's data.30142018-05-12T10:17:20.5335536John RavenYet another example of the process whereby when one or two instances of undesirable behaviour come to light it leads to massive, highly intrusive, legislation having extremely damaging consequences for all, not least the actual targets of the legislation. Governments seem to have assimed to right to impose on all (via such things as criminalisation) activities they deem to be good and right regardless of the wishes of those concerned and the many undesired and undesirable consequences of their actions.30142018-05-12T10:18:32.12335537olive aitkenas a disese it is so very underestemated.30502018-05-12T10:19:05.88735538Norma SmallThis must be an independent public inquiry 30142018-05-12T10:21:59.51735539colin milneIts the big brother knows best mentality.30142018-05-12T10:25:02.87735540Gerry HaddrellTotalitarian legislation with the sole purpose of government control over your children.30142018-05-12T10:30:44.0635541Myra BlairScottish national party's stubborn stupidity. Total disregard for the people who are affected by this and as usual not an ounce of common sense. Bad legislation and not of benefit to children or parents.30142018-05-12T10:31:18.31335542Katrina DavisI have suffered from ME for six years (since I was 14). Changes have to be made when treating those with ME. Please recognise that not only this impacts physical health, but also mental health. 30502018-05-12T10:31:39.1435543Michael KellettThe state does not own me or my children or their personal information. 30142018-05-12T10:31:39.29735544Colin SutherlandCant believe the staggering arrogance of the Scottish Governments representatives in this respect, who appear to believe they are above the law, refused to consult with anyone other than those whom they thought supported their narrow views on their proposed and inadequate NO2NP legislation then ignored the requests of our Supreme Court to provide the vital, missing and still outstanding information required verify and demonstrate the legality of their whole process, before everything went quiet, This enquiry is the minimum the Scottish electorate deserve.30142018-05-12T10:34:03.7535545Fiona McKemmieIncredible that this is still ongoing. There are areas in Scotland where the Named person scheme is being trialled and still children have died. 30142018-05-12T10:51:5335546Rob SmithSheer arrogance from a failed government !30142018-05-12T10:55:04.84735547Frances BannisterThis should not be ignored30142018-05-12T10:55:31.0535548Margaret LawsonPlease put a stop to the Scottish government infringing our human rights and sharing our personal data30142018-05-12T10:58:14.59735549James WestcottAppalling piece of legislation that does not recognise the importance of the parental and grand parents rights. It's about time this government gets to grip with the lack of control of children's homes. How does the government equate the massive failure of government inspectors to protect our children in care homes and non-starters schools.30142018-05-12T10:59:21.6635550Findlay MacDonaldI have written to my MSP a few times regarding this intrusive legislation but the SNP has been determined to plow ahead with it regardless of public opinion. The SNP attitude is "I am right and your opinion does not matter". It's a pity we have such extremists in government with such a serious and damaging agenda. 30142018-05-12T11:05:17.2135552William Bell ScottFrom personal experience of visiting Hungary, Czechoslovakia (as was), Romania and Ukraine regularly (1971 - 1998), these unlawful efforts is going further than Communist Governments went in seeking to have State control and ownership of our children, and children's children.30142018-05-12T11:09:06.34735553Bruce Mainland What are they think is going on that they keep forcing this destructive legislation through illegally in some cases30142018-05-12T11:11:10.4335554Isobel MacIverReally glad to see that this petition has been launched for a Public Enquiry as many people are being duped into thinking this legislation has the best interests of families and children at heart, when it blatantly does nothing of the kind. \r\n30142018-05-12T11:11:46.1835555Natalie LushThe Scottish Government should not be emulating the Stasi. Support should be available on a demand and need only basis, not on a forced and intrusive blanket basis. The nanny state causes more harm than good and this proposed legislation violates basic human rights for privacy and dignity. There must be a boundary between the private and public world we live in. These boundaries are blurred all too often as it is. Children should have the option to talk to a trusted adult if they require to do so, but foisting it upon them is just setting them up to believe they are not in control of their own lives and their ability to access or decline 'help'. Also putting this pressure on services and professionals who are already under great pressure to do their core job, will create other issues along the way. Moderation is the key here. Cannot quite believe in this day and age anyone is proposing to take something to such extreme lengths - disgraceful.30142018-05-12T11:15:45.6335556Peter KirkwoodBig brother approaches and I do not like it.30142018-05-12T11:16:18.8535557David JarvisA good (?) example of the "nanny state".30142018-05-12T11:16:45.17735558Elaine McSpaddenI believe that consent to share and data protection will be breached.30142018-05-12T11:19:30.19735559Colin McLeanSince the introduction of Curriculum For Excellence the school syllabus is systematically destroying the extracurricular development of transferable, employable skills and CONFIDENCE. It's neither wonder the snowflake generation won't try new things and give up too easily. They're not being given the opportunities in school so don't LEARN how to. Teachers are at their wits end. Curriculum for Excellence is a farce. Music tuition MUST be maintained and CFE should be scrapped. 30482018-05-12T11:21:44.56735560Irene Madden Music for everyone. 30482018-05-12T11:31:39.10335561Sarah Paterson Music benefits children's overall achievement and self confidence, it shouldn't only be an option for the wealthy. Look at the bigger picture to see the long term benefits to society please.30482018-05-12T11:40:22.4335562Nikol Morrison The scheme has obviously been in the works without families knowledge due to trial areas. If this is in fact the case than the breach of law has already been made and those involved need to be held accountable. Our rights as parents need to be protected a d we need to be fully informed at all times about what information is being shared concerning our children and ourselves. 30142018-05-12T11:46:27.3235563Steve HarrisonRead Huxley's Brave New World and Orwell's 1984. There is your answer as to why.30142018-05-12T11:49:07.51335564Alan MurrayHints of dictatorship inspired legislation. Perhaps Scotland is a trial run for EU wide implementation.30142018-05-12T11:50:04.05735565Greig ThomsonThis is typical of the type of dictatorial government we have come to expect from the SNP. It reminds you of the present state of Turkey. Just imagine what they would be like if we got full independence!! 30142018-05-12T12:00:38.5335566Leo LanahanProfessionals have been misled about the powers in the various pieces of legislation for safeguarding including GIRFEC and Adult Supportand Protection30142018-05-12T12:01:45.68335567Donald CAMERONThis legislation legalise the potential sharing opinions that are defamation of character or out right lies by government bodies without the separation of power. And to cap it all, without your knowledge or oportunity to set the record straight.\r\nSmacks of a totalitarian government uninterested in achieving natural justice. \r\n\r\n30142018-05-12T12:12:44.535568Rosemary de la PorteWe must have better resources in Scotland to support the 20,000 sufferers, more biomedical research is needed and this illness, or spectrum of illness, needs to be regarded with the seriousness it deserves. Too often we're brushed off and left to suffer, it's cruel to ignore a large group of patients who are genuinely ill. My symptoms began in November 1974, obviously I only know that retrospectively as at time thought I just had a nasty virus and would recover fully, I never did but luckily I was only mildly affected until I was 42, 19 years ago. I leave the house very occasionally and always with help, my usual state is housebound. Without my husband and grown up children I would have given up years ago but they help me to keep going and to maintain a positive outlook. I feel that life is passing me by, I'll be regarded as elderly before I know it, where did my middle years disappear to? I can't regain them so I'd love to be able to enjoy what remains of them without suffering afterwards for trying. We really need help and understanding, please listen and do something to change the situation. 30502018-05-12T12:36:08.54735570Mrs Jill M RowanThis is totatalitarian tyrrany. It is the thinking behind this system that one has to question. A full enquiry must be carried out immediately. 30142018-05-12T12:36:47.79735571Marnie Tindale I am a person who is proud to be Scottish but the astonishing fact that in my amazing country we do not have a ME Specialist makes me ashamed! ME suffers far too many people, help and support NEEDS to be available and Scotland needs to wake up and realise this!!!! 30502018-05-12T12:39:03.6635572Derek LivingstonThe SNP's Named Person, data sharing on families and GIRFEC policy is a gross invasion of family life and also of the individual. Children are being used as a vehicle by which the state can spy continuously and affect the lives of all of the people who have children in Scotland. \r\n\r\nAlso there is significant evidence from local authorities (education) that poorer families and those reliant on the state for benefits are affected significantly more than the rest of the population. Hence in practice it is a mechanism to control peoples thoughts, words and actions by the state.\r\n\r\nThis is the type of policy that one would see in a dictatorship or in a novel describing life and events in a dystopian society where the people are completely controlled by the state..\r\n\r\nThis policy is prone to corruption by the state and it's apparatus, which has already being proven to be the case as recent case studies and evidence have shown.\r\n\r\nIn short, if this is implemented by the SNP then it must become their equivalent of the Poll Tax policy in the peoples' eye.30142018-05-12T12:44:18.7535573Christine ListerI agree, Shocking piece of legislation that clearly breaches the human rights and privacy of every family in scotland . We need a full public inquiry to find out why the govt are so keen to disregard our human rights despite the supreme court ruling.30142018-05-12T13:02:38.9635574Shaun Donnelly Another invasion of our privacy 30142018-05-12T13:08:05.47335576Alexander MckeeMy children are my responsibility,to teach manners , morals and to discipline. I have tried to raise them as decent citizens and if they ever should break the law l would expect them to be punished accordingly , but what l do not expect is to have the freedom of choice to make those decisions 30142018-05-12T13:10:50.25735577Catherine MonagleI was advised by ME consultant in London to move back to Scotland to be nearer my family, as my health was deteriorating rapidly. Since taking her advice, I have been left to die. Nobody has a clue about ME. I have been totally let down and 'abused' by the knowledge and attitudes of GPs and hospital doctors.30502018-05-12T13:29:37.08735579Robina UrquhartWorried about the future of my grandchildren.30142018-05-12T13:44:58.71335580alex wilsonThey do this in countries that have poor human rights records so the government can know everything about the population, And this idea gets information thru the back door, all in the name of children30142018-05-12T13:45:00.4335581Nicola McleanA lot of parents will not be able to afford this and children will miss out30482018-05-12T13:47:02.5935582Dorothy AlexanderA member of my family has suffered from ME for over half his life. For the last 7years he has been completely bedbound a "living death" , unable to communicate or concentrate for 22 hours out of every day. He has barely enough energy to eat and and attend to toilet needs. There is no treatment, outside support or hope of a way out of his daily liviing hell. Why as a civilised society do we continue to ignore and deny the existence of ME and all the many forgotten victims of this cruel disease. We need action now! \r\nDorry Alexander30502018-05-12T13:48:09.82735583Ian LinklaterWhile it is not the worst piece of ligislation that the SNP Party have rammed down our throats while they have been in Government, it is certainly the most intrusive and contra legal. Clearly the dogma which stimulated the act is flawed but what is certain is that the lawyers who drafted this stuff need replaced30142018-05-12T13:58:45.63735585Thomas McLaughlinRidiculous unwanted, unwarranted, and undemocratic proposal from people who clearly care nothing for the Scottish people. I suspect there was a deal struck, or a favour being done for EU connections, their style of operation and bloody mindedness. Yes, hold those responsible to account.30142018-05-12T14:00:26.66735586Gordon McKillopThis is typical of politicians who are elected by the people and then ignore individuals views when legislation is proposed which is intrusive, demeaning to parents and insulting to the intelligence of families.30142018-05-12T14:22:13.1135587Violet JohnstoneThey haven't managed to "get it right" for those children who desperately need help - what chance is there of them "getting it right" for every child. 30142018-05-12T14:27:08.9235588James A MackieThe Petitioner is absolutely correct. Some of the points are raise in Petition No 1673, recently debated and continued by the Petitions Committee. This legislation is a reason why 1.3% of children Scotland , 11500, children are in care not at home. Child protection breach articles 3, 6 and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. In one case confidential criminal intelligence given to Police Scotland was repeated verbatim to a mother three weeks later. In child protection Core Group Meetings are attended by individuals from up to 9 or 10 different organisations all discussing individual families. Any official can claim they have privileged information to discuss. The families are forced to leave the meeting until such privileged information is discussed. Children attending school with marks caused through general play or even attending NHS services can be interviewed in private without the knowledge of their families and parents by social workers and police. From those interviews information can be shared with other organisation officials with the end result children are removed from the family home and placed in care. Absolutely no attention is paid to the serious emotional and psychological trauma caused to children and families by such actions done allegedly to protect the child from abuse and neglect. For those families trying to defend themselves in a system that is based on opinion, possibilities and probabilities, it is almost impossible to prove your innocence. In asking for a Government enquiry, one should be insisting that any such enquiry should be formed from individuals completely divorced from the subject under investigation and should include trained Human Rights lawyers advocates. A good example of stacking an enquiry is the current Independent Care Review due to complete their review in 2020. Government enquiries are made up of individuals organisations with a vested interest in keeping the status quo.30142018-05-12T14:37:56.84335589Rina Solomon3 of my family members have the disease- please help support recognition, research and treatment of this very debilitating disease.30502018-05-12T14:43:25.92735590Christine SmithGlad to support your stand against this proposed legislation30142018-05-12T14:45:25.89735591Charles RathboneI feel very strongly about my government interfering with MY parental rights. Mr Swinney just give it up.30142018-05-12T14:46:47.635592Margaret P RobertsonLenin,is alive and well in the SCOTTISH Parliment!!!!!\r\nIt's not what the people want, but only the select few.\r\nPLEASE do something constructive for once and improve our education which has become worse in the last ten years, and don't forget the roads!!! What do u all actually do except cost us money. Fed up SCOTTISH PERSON30142018-05-12T15:21:21.5435594Marcello MancusoPlease address this debilitating illness. 30502018-05-12T15:28:11.04335596Leanne GrayI have seen first hand the problems this causes..... And families lives ruined beyond belief... something needs to be done about this.. 30142018-05-12T15:32:19.96335597Caroline DevlinOur children have not consented to having their data collected. I fear in the future their information could be shared with other agencies and even employers to hold against them. This surveillance society is out of control. 30142018-05-12T15:57:49.7335598Carla BI was diagnosed with CFS in 1986 after contracting the Epstein-Barr Virus. I live in the US but I am of Scottish decent. This is a horribly debilitating illness..please be a lead in world wide collaboration and support! Thank you for what you have done, are doing ..the time is now!30502018-05-12T16:38:56.4335599Maureen Knox Hate this legislation, don't trust services now with information sharing. Big brother is overly involved in everything. This is just uncalled for!!!!!30142018-05-12T16:51:24.58735600Jeanette ScottThese Scottish Government bullies must be stopped.30142018-05-12T16:53:49.89735601S Caroline SharpFully support this petition, this piece of legislation disregards parents'human rights.30142018-05-12T17:01:33.6835602Ian MillerExisting agencies have an appalling record of failure in the protection of children who are known to be at risk!30142018-05-12T17:06:44.91735603Lynda EdwardsHas failed miserably where it has been introduced and the government needs to keep it's nose out of personal and family business.30142018-05-12T17:11:30.32335604Gordon HinksConfidentiality is a fundamental right of every person and we need to keep it that way. Our private details need to be kept private, this is not a nanny state.30142018-05-12T17:16:39.98335605Douglas WalkerIntrusion into families private life.30142018-05-12T17:32:46.46735606Stephen JonesA musical education is money well spent and should be available to all, whatever their financial background 30482018-05-12T17:35:22.23335607Brian K. WrightAny information that is shared behind an affected or interested party's back is immoral, unethical and contary to public interest and public accountability.30142018-05-12T17:59:08.39335608Margaret Robertson Not only does the cost of lessons need to addressed but also lesson duration and quality assurance. Let's deliver a quality service to produce quality musicians who understand musicianship, and, in my field of Traditonal Music, protect our heritage and indentity. 30482018-05-12T18:23:55.33335609Johanna GeddesMore should be done for M.E., it is sad to see how a member of my family can not enjoy the normal day to day activities all his friends can. Why is so little being done for those who suffer from M.E.30502018-05-12T18:26:50.75335610ConnyPlease invest in research so that the symptoms of ME-CFS patients all over the world can be reduced and our lives become worth living. We are missing from our lives and it can hit anyone at anytime. Even YOU or YOUR family! As with many ME-CFS patients I was young, active and in good health when the flu (proably EBV) hit me and I never recovered. Even though there's a right for participation for people with disabilites, with this disabling disease we don't get the medical care needed and we cannot take part in life. Please be so kind as to helping us become active members of society again by investing in ME-CFS research and treatment. We need help NOW!30502018-05-12T18:28:45.75335611Michael DenholmThe SNP led Scottish Government is becoming more right-wing by the day. Democracy does'nt fit in with nationalism!30142018-05-12T18:30:30.0235612caroline boucherhad this years ago never really got over it now have fibromyalgia . im sure its all linked . . we need specist doctors that will actually listen to us30502018-05-12T18:32:49.14735613Michael DenholmThe SNP led Scottish Government is trampling over democracy. Nationalism does'nt tolerate debate or anything resembling discussion. 30142018-05-12T18:48:08.6535614John HuntThe named person scheme is a waste of public money and would damage family relationships.30142018-05-12T18:53:06.27735615William howard kirkControl is NOT IN THE REMIT OF GOVERNMENT even less in a jumped up regional council30142018-05-12T19:01:04.74335617Leslie jones. Nanny state at its worst. An insult to parents and an erosion of their rights. Scrap it. 30142018-05-12T19:01:47.44735618Johnny McCloskeyWe'd like some answers please, as to how much personal data is being shared under GIRFIC & especially the Named Persons scheme, which has had pilot schemes running in certain areas & councils are applying NP as if it's already legal.30142018-05-12T19:09:18.79335619Jamie Robertson A most intrusive , dangerous price of legislation with the potential to have catastrophic implications when not done correctly by someone who misconceived a problem when none is there 30142018-05-12T19:14:13.62335620Peter ClementsIts time this pernicious piece of legislation was consigned to history. The Judiciary has stated its not viable, the public have no faith in it and the waste of funds trying to justify it are obscene. Dump this anti family nasty SNP vanity project.30142018-05-12T19:39:34.6535621Jacqueline Tait I feel very strongly that the Scottish government be held accountable for their actions especially so when this legislation is not even legal. Unfortunately there appears to have been some appalling examples of abuse of power that should rightly be addressed.30142018-05-12T19:42:40.43335622Sharon boydHope this gets done30502018-05-12T19:49:34.4835623Ro BellI would not wish this even on the Health denying Scottish Tories. \r\n30502018-05-12T19:55:23.4535624Alexander WilliamsonI am quite capable of making decisions regarding my children, do not WANT a third party interfering.30142018-05-12T19:59:05.26335625Graeme PearsonFor the greater part of my life I looked forward to SNP getting into power for the Scottish People. They started well and appear to have lost their way. I no longer support their ideas. They have let themselves and Scotland down. There is no sense to this legislation and they are certainly no longer listening to those who put them in power.30142018-05-12T20:08:29.57735626FionaThis condition steals lives, from sufferers, spouses and partners, parents, siblings and children. Everyone around is affected. Some become carers, some lose the sustained input of those they love. Sufferers deal every day with unrealised or slowly realised potential, although the dedication and determination of the many I have known and the one for whom I am a carer amazes me. It is time to step up and put resources into answering the baffling questions raised by this hitherto largely silent epidemic. Please let Scotland lead the way!30502018-05-12T20:12:33.05335627Carol DiplexcitoAppalled at the waste of resources and public money being spent trying to enforce this insulting and offensive piece of legislation.30142018-05-12T20:16:07.57735628Revd Philip PattersonWe are all now being contacted by companies who need to seek permission to hold our data under the new European guidelines. It seems ridiculous that Government agencies involved in Named Person can somehow circumvent this legislation and hold data without our permission.\r\n30142018-05-12T20:25:17.91335629Mhairi Barker We need recognition, respect and care. ME is an immune system fault which is most likely leading to mitochondrial disease because it is being left untreated. Mito is easily prevented by a special combo of supplements, but it is irreversible and fatal. I pray for change. Amen. 30502018-05-12T20:35:37.3235630Jan MunroeHuman rights of both children and parents being disregarded.30142018-05-12T20:38:23.6235631Pat moncurPlease we need more research into this 30502018-05-12T20:43:33.24335632Ann Macfarlane We are supposed to live in a democracy where the public are served by politicians, education authorities, health services, etc, instead our servants are imposing the authority we invest in them to rob us of our dignity and lord it over us. This type of behaviour is nothing less than Communism imposed upon the masses. Remember we are your masters, and not your servants. You are appointed to serve us, not appointed to take orders from Marxists and make us your minions. \r\n\r\nMarxism comes in the guise of doing good for in this case children. You need no other powers to protect children, and breaking up and persecuting families is not the way to protect children. \r\n\r\nCareful observation of children for bruising, signs of neglect, consistent signs of abuse, bad hygiene, should identify a suffering child, but the fact teachers, doctors, social workers have been negligent in their duties, lied to by deceitful adults, fooled, is not a reason to impose an overseer to every child, to pry, misinterpret, show bias, or be deceived like authoritive figures who have failed the few children in the past. \r\n\r\nThe real reason for this disgraceful legislation was to change the nature of serving the people into monitoring and controlling them to be in subjugation to sinister political forces, l believe. \r\n\r\nAction should be taken to prevent this abuse from ever happening again where privacy of individuals within families has been violated even to the point of persecution of those victims. Legislators must protect our citizens in the future. Compensation and apologies to all victim families must be delivered. I demand no less than a proper civilised reaction to this matter instead of silence on the issue, l demand accountability. 30142018-05-12T20:45:43.6935633Joan Deveney Lot more needs to be done for people suffering from this ailment 30502018-05-12T21:14:47.90735634Ann McGookinGIRFEC and the Named Person Scheme always caused me concern when I worked in education. I have taken a keen interest in the NO2NP campaign and believe it should be scrapped. I support this campaign.30142018-05-12T21:39:08.78335636Margaret Stocksno more intrusion into the family, please\r\nparents are the best carers fir their children except in special circumstances which are already addressed 30142018-05-12T21:42:54.3735637Francis MurphyA very badly thought out piece of legislation. Politicians need to be held to account for wasting public money on this whole shambles. 30142018-05-12T21:59:18.35735638Douglas WilsonBoth the Westminster and Scottish Parliaments are becoming too authoritarian, thinking up new legislation which infringes on the freedoms and responsibilities of parents. They are creating a state of intolerance in society rather than increasing tolerance. Sadly democracy is decreasing in our country as MPs do not represent the views of their constituents but vote mostly with the whip. It is absolute arrogance that the named person scheme is still on the agenda.30142018-05-12T22:20:59.3635639Donald BalfourPlease scrap the Named Person legislation before it is too late!30142018-05-12T22:29:29.84735640Christian FlatscherAct of terror against families.30142018-05-12T22:36:56.95735641Morag Waterson A member of my family suffered from ME after glandular fever. For years doctors told her there was nothing wrong with her and it was all in her mind. This has to stop.30502018-05-12T22:57:29.63735642Lorraine Alexander I am absolutely disgusted that the Government disregards the morality of sharing information without consent of the persons involved. A public enquiry should be the least they can do to provide answers. 30142018-05-12T22:59:57.7135643TJD ErskineI wish they would listen to the people for a change instead of trying to railroad legislation which has been rejected by so many.30142018-05-12T23:06:23.64735644George McPherson Once again this useless so called Goverment not listening to those people with intelligence who say No to another crazy piece of Legislation.\r\nLet us hope somebody brings up the Charge of no c\r\nconfidence I the present so called Goverment and we get rid of them.30142018-05-13T01:54:38.20335645Sue Bedford-VisserWaterway users feel let down by Scottish Canals on many fronts and have real concerns about the future for navigation - already seriously compromised - which is an essential component in keeping canals alive. 30022018-05-13T04:49:11.11735646Michael Young This proposed legislation smacks at State CONTROL 30142018-05-13T05:36:58.48335647William HughesPotentially a very intrusive piece of legislation put forward by an incompetent Government who want to be a law unto themselves!30142018-05-13T06:55:27.6835648claire cruickshankmusic contributes a staggering amount to a child's education and health. It should be accessible to all, regardless of parents' ability to pay. 30482018-05-13T07:45:44.62335649Jayne SmithSupporting someone I know whose daughter has this & to support research to help find a cure or better treatment. 30502018-05-13T07:53:36.56335650Douglas BoxallScottish Canals have.a duty of care and they are accountable for their actions (Or lack thereof)30022018-05-13T07:58:55.39335651Clare davisMusic is also a post code lottery in Scottish schools 30482018-05-13T08:05:28.56735653Helen Ingham I have ME and extremely lucky I have probably one of the best consultants in the country. Everyone should be entitled to the best no matter where they live and the condition is still met with doubt mainly because people doctors included do not understand it30502018-05-13T08:15:18.5835655Andrew DavisMusic is so very important for children as it helps stimulate creativity and important brain connections that are important for adult life30482018-05-13T09:09:28.15335657Karen EwenFunding is badly needing to research this debilitating disease. 30502018-05-13T09:10:42.5135658JOHN DIDSBURYJust another nonsensical edict from the SNP Government as they continue their aims of controlling the lives of Scottish citizens. By all means resources must be targeted towards the protection of children at risk i.e. genuine risk by a Named Person for every child in Scotland?? Just for the record, quite apart from her devoted parents, our granddaughter has at least 4 devoted Named Persons i.e. her Grandparents. Who could ever care more for her welfare, happiness and interests than us. We do not want nor will we accept a nominated Named Person. 30142018-05-13T09:32:13.535659Margaret Mawdsley This is a ridiculous and no need for situation.\r\nThe children who really need help will be overlooked. Most parents are capable of looking after their children. This is an unnecessary situation\r\nFor teachers and all concerned.30142018-05-13T10:13:49.09735660Andrew Littlejohn tMusic Tuition should be free for children in education . Local Authorities should not be given the right to double the cost of music tuition to suit their own budget. Music benefits children on so many levels, and across the country children could be affected mentally if their chance to thrive st something they enjoy doing is taken away from them.30482018-05-13T10:15:01.44335661David ForemanShocking badly written piece of legislation, even when initially challenged over the fundamental flaws those running the schemes hubris put them in direct conflict with parents.30142018-05-13T10:45:25.75735662Dawn DunlopMy children are unable to participate in music tuition due to the cost. With the cost increasing, it is now impossible. 30482018-05-13T11:08:13.68335663George MonroNanny state gone mad30142018-05-13T11:16:51.79335664Alisha Gilroy It is clear, no matter your stance regards to this NP scheme, our human, parental, and family rights are slowly but surely being reduced and undermined! 30142018-05-13T11:27:29.82735665Sandra SmithMy sister and I received free tuition at school which my Mum would not have been able to pay for so if we hadn't had that we would have missed out. Now I pay for my 3 children's lessons and although they are much cheaper than private lessons it is still a big financial commitment for me. \r\nFree lessons would open up world's of opportunities for children.30482018-05-13T11:30:07.4735666Shirly Dyson My son is not an academic child, however, music has opened a new possibility for him. He is currently working towards joining the Royal Marines Brass band and has achieved grade 7 for his euphonium.30482018-05-13T11:39:01.90735667Ron HallidayKeep up the fight against this intrusive and badly thought through measure30142018-05-13T11:44:54.78335668Ken MichieI've suffered from ME for over twenty years and ,in that time, have never been given any hope that a cause or treatment will ever be available.\r\nThere are now thousands of us in Scotland with this horrible illness and it's way beyond time that proper research was put intothe cause and treatment of this devastating condition.30502018-05-13T11:57:45.51735669Gordon BauwensThis whole issue by SNP smacks of Big Brother - a typical left-wing "solution" to every problem i.e. the State always knows better than the parents. Much more sense to concentrate on targeting resources for those children known to be most at risk rather than spying on and treating every parent as child abusers and criminals. 30142018-05-13T12:01:48.53335670Angela Hannah As a parent of a young musician in West Lothian about to start her higher year we are saddened by the situation locally. It sad to think that children in the future will not have the fantastic introduction to music she has experienced .The only way IMS to continue longer term is for it not to be deemed a discretionary service by the Scottish Goverment.30482018-05-13T12:10:21.9935671Priscilla Ann GrahamThis illness is devastating. It is severe, disabling, ant at times deadly. I have suffered for 9 years every single agonizing day. The pain never leaves me fully. I operate in pain that would keep an average person home. Imagine having the flu everyday yet have to do all the things you normally do with a smile on your face. Doctors say we can work, some doctors say there is nothing wrong just because there isn't a test for it and it's not being taught to them in school. Please support those who have this illness by taking action on this matter. We feel as though we are dying every day of our lives. Due to lack of support people feel hopeless and are more prone to suicide. 30502018-05-13T12:23:02.75735672Steven MunroEducation is about so much more than academic achievement. Equality for access to the arts is fundamental in a cultured society.30482018-05-13T12:33:09.64735673David BirdVery long overdue. Oligarchy comes to mind in respect of Scottish Canals30022018-05-13T12:46:49.60335674Rebecca WattMusic has been a big part of my life through lessons in school and music centres out of school and I have met so many life long friends because of this. 30482018-05-13T13:07:05.0635675Rosemary HannahThis is one of many issues that comes up on the helpline over & over again in our area in Ayrshire. Parents are distraught when this to their attention. We definitely need an independent public inquiry.\r\n30142018-05-13T13:32:10.3335676Maria kean I think it is a travesty that the cuts always hit the music department so many children will suffer due to this surely the cuts can be made elsewhere .30482018-05-13T13:47:36.0235677Adele higginsI would love to see more care and consider action for people suffering M E and more education for the general public , to many people think M E sufferers are lazy or have a phychiatric problem30502018-05-13T14:35:36.35335678william spencethe government has got its people way wrong here. Interfering in parenting - in a low tax economy where the government offers its people little - is a giant leap too far. 30142018-05-13T14:43:2135679Andrew SmithGreat idea, keep pushing for this30502018-05-13T14:54:16.68735680Stephen McLarenWe need to re-evaluate our priorities as a society. Some things are worth it for their own ends.30482018-05-13T15:07:54.8335681John GibsonScottish Politicians are pandering to a Marxist Masonic hate cult. We need our constitution and common law rights more than ever. 30142018-05-13T15:14:08.59735682Sheena ShovlinA member of my family has been suffering with ME for the last 4 years, a bright, hard working vivacious girl with a zest for life has become a shadow of her former self. She has had to reduce her days at work, rest when she is \r\novercome with fatigue. If she has plans for an evening or afternoon out with husband or friends, has to rest up in the mornings to prepare for the event. Often the next day she is exhausted. Now way for anyone to "live" their lives. Support and recognition for this illness is much needed.\r\n30502018-05-13T17:04:07.59335683Ruth MorisonI have had ME for 22 years, as little is known about it now as it was 22 years ago. This has to change. There is so little research & it can literally be life changing & yet it has largely been ignored. It is time for a change!30502018-05-13T17:30:59.08335684Kathy Collins Music is an essential part of the curriculum! 30482018-05-13T18:28:34.1535685Mo McCluskeySupreme court ruling is being so blatently overlooked..a full public enquiry should be ordered. SNP clearly think they are above the law.30142018-05-13T18:44:24.70335686Kathleen FraserThe effort of volunteers and money from various sources in the millennium to open the canal should not have been in vain 18 years later30022018-05-13T19:01:26.6135687Anne Grant Too many people close to me are suffering from this awful illness.More research and help is definitely needed for the people affected by this 30502018-05-13T19:43:35.43735688Gwen CameronThis is all about control. SNP have an issue with the individual having any say in their own family. Not one of them has an inkling about how we bring up our children. With a number of so called lawyers on this administration you wonder about how they get it all quite so wrong. I thought this was a free country or is it only as long as SNP are in control of our every movement. SCARY VERY SCARY30142018-05-13T19:45:40.31335690Eric CameronNo trust in this administration30142018-05-13T19:58:21.9535691Susan Jane SimpsonPeople MUST know what information is being held and shared on their children30142018-05-13T20:17:35.39335692Caroline MastersOur local music service is a shadow of its former self after county council cutbacks and early retiring of amazing leadership. It still hasn't recovered 3 years on and continues to dwindle. When will our education department realise that music is a multi faceted skill that actually ENHANCES Stem subject performance!? If they are so hell bent on children's data being better than Taiwan then they should be investing in it, not removing it. Short sighted acts like this will have long term consequences. e2illAnd don't get me started on the revenue brought to the UK by our creative industry. This will surely suffer in years to come.30482018-05-13T20:19:57.9935693Michelle BurnsideMy daughter plays French horn and we have to pay the fees as we work , think it should be free to all pupils, we struggle to pay it sometimes, but don't want her to stop it, as she loves it. So we end up working extra to cover the fees. 30482018-05-13T20:30:00.6335694Ted DitchburnI just cannot understand how a worldwide storm of concern and debate can arise over information harvested by companies using social media apps as has (rightly) happened with Cambridge Analytica and Facebook aggregated private information. Yet the far more dangerous step of a Government embedding a more extreme version of this, with all the powers a state possesses, is not being more widely discussed and debated openly.30142018-05-13T20:50:36.85335695Nicola-jane Brown Where's the Curriculum for excellence in this decision?! Studies show that music helps behaviour, maths, social skills and confidence. 30482018-05-13T21:01:44.2635696JimMacPhieWhy can Scottish Government not see the STUPIDITY of their action!!!! \r\n30142018-05-13T21:14:59.00735698Shell EyInstrumental music education is a long term investment not only in the individual, but in society.30482018-05-13T21:17:36.18335699Emma Malins Do more research for ME30502018-05-13T21:20:19.0335700Linsey KirkpatrickUnnecessarily obtrusive 30142018-05-13T21:22:23.73335701Louise Tindall I have suffered for over 2 years and been unable to work for most of this time. There needs to be more research and recognition of this terrible illness.30502018-05-13T21:23:22.7435702MaggieMore funding for research needs to be available so a cure can be found for this disease.30502018-05-13T21:23:42.735703Helen MinshallMy musical journey started with free brass lessons at Ayr Academy. My parents couldn't have afforded private lessons for me, so without those free lessons I'd never have been where I am today. I've worked for many years as Head of Brass in a music service, and I now have a happy and enjoyable life as a freelance musician, and Musical Director of the Lancashire Youth Brass Band. I'm supporting this petition because I want other young people in Scotland to have the same opportunities that I had.30482018-05-13T21:53:29.3335704Carol KerrAll children should have access to free tuition as it can set their minds free and make opportunities for those who may otherwise struggle in the academic life30482018-05-13T22:06:52.0335705David Armstrong The full millennium link must be safeguarded !30022018-05-13T22:23:31.20335706Any VaughanME, CFS and fibromyalgia and all need to be fully researched and better resources available to those suffering. The current system is unacceptable.30502018-05-13T22:26:40.92735707DeniseI have had M.E. for 31 years and seen little progress in understanding this devastating disease. Enough is enough. We've tried it your way. Now it's time to listen to us. Please give us the respect we deserve and the help we actually need. Thank you. 30502018-05-13T23:13:31.29335708Catherine McCormackAbsolutely shocking breach of privacy. 30142018-05-13T23:22:25.40335709Heather MooreAs a trained musician who was fortunate enough to have free instrumental tuition throughoutmy schooling in Canada before going on to study French horn at university, I cannot express strongly enough how access to instrumental music lessons changed my life. 30482018-05-14T02:41:11.93335711Sandy CoffinMusic brings people together, all around the world. Learning to play a musical instrument opens and opportunities that every child should have access to. It builds skills far beyond music - discipline, listening, creative thinking and more - and those skills are the ones most sought after by employers in every field. Keep building on Scotland's music education excellence!!\r\n30482018-05-14T06:46:00.13735712Harry LightWe must keep the pressure on in order to remove this wicked legislation.30142018-05-14T06:51:32.51335713Stewart MalcolmI signed the petition and I am 100% behind this protest against this invasive legislation30142018-05-14T07:10:43.5835714Kenneth Mccormick Please ensure that music remains part of our culture and life that empowers education to capture all 30482018-05-14T07:13:30.43735715Martin BarnsdaleMusic is the first language. All children deserve the opportunity to learn an instrument or sing.30482018-05-14T07:48:17.7735716Linda CipollaI have ME. It took 15 years to diagnose because no one believed me. Of course in those 15 years I became disabled in a way that might have been alleviated if I'd been acknowledged, diagnosed and treated accordingly. Doctors are in the dark because of lack of funding, so many others will be cursed like I was with being discriminated against and minimized to the point where suicide seemed the only Rx. \r\nPlease fund REAL ME research, not GET and CBT.30502018-05-14T08:11:38.38335718Elizabeth Paton Music is invaluable for children to learn. It encompasses maths, de coding and language as well as team work and leadership. As a mother of a child with asd I feel music should be used. 30482018-05-14T08:54:11.18735719Eleanor ShawCanals are our heritage both in engineering, industry, immigration and history and should be promoted more in tourism, school curriculum just as much as Robert Burns etc. 30022018-05-14T08:57:31.23335720Tom FindlayVery poor legislation, very poor judgement from politicians, very poor accountability and very poor response to court rulings.30142018-05-14T09:30:07.9935721iain scott johnstonA totalitarian piece of legislation which must be rejected.\r\n\r\n30142018-05-14T09:49:25.7235722Susan kerrIt'sRead on to learn more about the benefits of music education.\r\nIt improves academic skills. ...\r\nIt develops physical skills. ...\r\nIt cultivates social skills. ...\r\nIt refines discipline and patience. ...\r\nIt boosts self-esteem. ...\r\nIt introduces children to other cultures. ... a part of learning for our children 30482018-05-14T10:18:23.79335724William ArmitageIt is difficult to comprehend what the Scottish Government hopes to achieve by blatantly interfering with the normal nurturing of children in the family home by loving parents and by doing so seriously diluting the states efforts to detect and care for vulnerable children when dysfunctional families fail them. 30142018-05-14T10:53:19.2635725Allan TaylorScottish Stasi! Why don't they stick to fixing the problems with education, the NHS, or our crumbling road network to name but 3.30142018-05-14T10:58:14.3735726Kevin TurnbullIts a very sad day if this happens. Children need music in their lifes, its a social thing, can keep them of the streets, make them more confident, belonging to a group, brass band, or even taking it futther to a job.\r\nI wouldn't be in the job i am in now if it wasn't for the music lessons i had at school.\r\nI am a Musician in the Armed Forces 17 years and counting. My parents would not have been able to afford these lessons.30482018-05-14T11:09:11.735727Dadscare CharityThis was meant to be so much more and to be honest we were keen to start with but as we watch how this information now gets used and abused at childrens hearings its worse than useless! One aspect that troubles us greatly is the use or sharing of data thats totally fabricated against the interest of families and children, there are zero counter balances to false data sharing and no right of appeal, at childrens panels all over Scotland they can say whatever they like as nothing is recorded other than the final desicions which childrens services know will never come back to bite them, its a scandal and the policy must be stopped before many more children are taken into care fulltime for no-good reasons. This now clearly the reason Scotland has the highest rates for children in care in the western world and something has to be done and very quickly?30142018-05-14T12:13:07.90735728Russell HobsonAgencies have been disregarding the human rights of parents and children for years due to central government led use of GIRFEC. A full public inquiry into its implementation is long overdue.30142018-05-14T12:25:19.49335729Alex vidlerIt should be free for every child30482018-05-14T12:50:26.93335730Jenna MainAs I write this comment on Mental Health Awareness Week, it seems pertinent to comment as I sign this petition. It is highly dangerous to allow local authorities the power to strip what will 100% be a lifeline for many young people across Scotland. Instrumental music lessons may be the one thing that a young person actually looks forward to during their school week. Instrumental music lessons may provide a safe space for a young person to grow, develop, learn and find themselves. Instrumental music lessons may be the one hook that keeps a young person safe and free from danger. Instrumental Music, could be the one thing that an adult uses, from a positive experience in school as a hook to save themselves later in life. Equality, inclusive, quality instrumental music lessons should not just be for the privaledged few. 30482018-05-14T12:56:35.0635731Ruairidh Iain BuxtonThere have been charges for years in highland, therefore there should be no reason to cut it. It is a viral part of education. Having received both fiddle and highland bagpipe lessons myself, I would find it a real shame to lose the opportunity for others in the future 30482018-05-14T13:05:00.46735732Myles McEachanI feel like this is a subject that has been overlooked for so long. This disease effects so many and they go untreated because there is not the medial knowledge, and that has to change. I know so many people effected by this disease, and they need help. The government has to do something about this, the NHS has to do someonthing about this. They need their lives back. 30502018-05-14T13:14:58.64735733Catherine FishSadly friends from New Zealand have cancelled their trip in the Forth and Clyde canal owing to uncertainty and are visiting a Germany instead. More loss of tourism money!30022018-05-14T13:21:55.28335734Emma MorrisonMy family member suffers from Chronic fatigue and the amount she struggles to do basic things that I take for granted is amazing. What is more amazing is the fact that she still manages to get these things done despite the fatige.\r\n\r\nThis disease needs far more looking into as it can be life destroying.30502018-05-14T13:25:51.8235735Kirsty Aitken Music should not be overlooked as an important part of our children's education and development. 30482018-05-14T13:28:40.57335736Ingrid HendersonMusic plays a much bigger role in young peoples' development than just learning the instrument itself. It helps develop confidence, cognitive skills, a way to express themselves, a work ethic, social skills and so much more. Making music and the arts available to all children is essential to the well being of our society. 30482018-05-14T13:32:18.37735737Cathie FarrenTo charge parents for their right to plan an instrument is in my opinion disgraceful. \r\nMy 3 children all had the opportunity to play an instrument. Today both teach. Without that opportunity that won't happen. I could not afford to pay for lesson s then so this will certainly have a knock on effect for children who would want to play and whose parent can't afford the fees.30482018-05-14T13:40:59.65335739Nicholas RynnTthe implementation of GDPR will make data sharing a total nightmare. Any named person will have to be trained in ad aware of the massive implications of handling sensitive data. Key issue is who will insure named persons. 30142018-05-14T14:03:09.7135740Craig MuirPlease taken the funding under the Scottish government... The education provided by the music school is open to all pupils of The country, via audition selection...a marvellous course... that requires Scottish government support.30482018-05-14T14:04:41.6435741Alison Carberry Every child should have the right to instrumental tuition, not just those whose parents can afford fees. This is all so short sighted!30482018-05-14T14:34:41.37735742Janett murphyplease help,those who suffer from tcondition30502018-05-14T14:42:55.23735743Tom MartinGiving children the possibility to have free music tuition does more than give them a technical skill. It opens out wonderful social connections that often are way beyond what the family circle can provide. Moreover the benefit it also massive where non academic children get into music. It becomes a vehicle to great achievement and confidence that otherwise would not be delivered by the core curricula. Cost to the taxpayer is minimal when set against the benefits to society and if Politicians care for the future of Scotland it must reverse the policy. Here in Ayrshire we have had a wonderful conveyer belt of professional teachers who have given great service to the community and our children. South Ayrshire should be ashamed of contemplating this step and those councillors who support it, have no place taking a penny for their time in the Council. 30482018-05-14T14:46:39.4235744Duncan RennieChildren are enriched by arts and music. Healthier minds, happier young people. Simple and obvious. 30482018-05-14T16:56:47.94335745Jennifer AtkinsonWDC are charging for instrument hire rather than tuition and so will take the stance that tuition is still free.30482018-05-14T16:57:33.45335746Margaret KeillarAs a social worker in C&F for more than 20 years I find this piece of legislation most uneccessary ,intrusive and damaging to family life It is I'll thought out and dangerous It is likely to divert strained resources from the most vulnerable children and there will inevitably be a rise in children being failed In addition what sense does it make to have 16 and 17year olds who can leve school ,get married and vote still requiring a named person The madness needs to stop 30142018-05-14T17:00:40.59335747Deirdre AndersonThe benefits of learning a musical instrument are lifelong and as a society we will do future generations a huge disservice by preventing free access. 30482018-05-14T17:19:57.06335748Liz DentonHave been fighting for years to prevent house building on the last remaining bit of the battlefield fron the Battle of Bothwell Bridge. Very limited bit of archaeological investigation carried out several years ago. Some artefacts found and given to South Lanarkshire Council for safekeeping. The don't know where they are. Seems to me that greed threatens to take precedence over history. People died for their beliefs and it is appropriate that this is acknowledged properly. Think of the battlefields and memorials in France for World War victims. Just because battles were fought a long time ago does not mean that the victims should be forgotten.30032018-05-14T18:39:46.98335749Stella Jamieson I've been ill for far too many years - approaching 18 years - without any treatment. As a result of severe ME I lost a successful career 11years ago. It's like ME sufferers are being ignored by the medical profession and being left to die. I want a life before death. Now is the time for ME sufferers to be listened to and treated with dignity and respect. Now is the time money was made available for extensive biomedical research to find what exactly is causing this horrendous neurological disease and lead us towards finding effective treatments and a cure. 30502018-05-14T18:46:32.42735750Karen Cardy Music should be accessible to all children, regardless of family income.30482018-05-14T19:21:42.79335751Sheila mckenzieThis is just not right sounds just like dictatorship to me.30142018-05-14T20:17:32.49735753Gillian McNeishMore governmental takeover from the parents.\r\nTypical communistic style of control.30142018-05-14T21:50:01.44735754Chris RossMusic is a huge education in so many different disciplines. And an international language. All children need this opportunity to grow. 30482018-05-14T21:50:40.98735755Paul FoxIf the government continue to ignore the will of the electorate then we have an equal right to ignore their illegal(in the proper sense) dictats. If we don't we will simply become their prisoners. It is that important. They cannot ask us to be 'law' abiding if they are not.30142018-05-14T22:03:35.6235756John Munroe Worryingly autocratic. Horrid and unnecessary intrusion into family life and values. 30142018-05-14T22:27:37.11735758Donna PatersonI have read the at risk ideas that you government want teachers to put children under Risk assessment, an untidy room, late for school etc \r\nGet a grip.\r\nMy child is at more harm in school than anywhere .30142018-05-15T00:35:11.19735759Andrew WellsMusic opened my mind to great pleasure please don't take it away from the children.30482018-05-15T00:35:23.5435760Andrew WellsMusic opened my mind to great pleasure please don't take it away from the children.30482018-05-15T06:48:02.87335761Linda CarpenterChildren have always been given free music lessons why do think there is so much talent around theses days 30482018-05-15T07:12:24.65735762Jacqueline WemyssWould be such a shame to see this go !30482018-05-15T07:54:42.0935763Ken BlackwoodWithout free instrumental tuition ,music would not have been an option for me.Tragic what is being allowed to happen.Ken Blackwood ex Assistant Principal horn Scottish Opera and Royal Scottish National Orchestra.30482018-05-15T09:21:40.71735765Stan wilsonVery important!!!30482018-05-15T09:40:03.66735766Ian Howe'All governments' should be funding the Medical research in to 'ME'...People are being left alone and isolated with this dreadful illness. Politicians should be ashamed.30502018-05-15T10:10:17.7435767Natasha ErskineSo happy that this awful intrusive law was never legalised and there should be an enquiry for sure, with bringing the responsible parties to account! 30142018-05-15T10:51:08.25335768Julianne RobertsonMusic is an essential part of education. Removing the barriers to accessing this can only benefit our children.30482018-05-15T11:21:21.29335769Ian ProvanSince 1996 (22 years ago), when I was diagnosed with ME, there has been little progress made in acknowledging the nature of the illness. Despite the World Health Organisation classifying ME as a neurological illness, my experience in seeking medical help has not been positive and can be summed up by one doctor exclaiming: "ME - that's the is it or is it not illness". 30502018-05-15T11:48:54.5535770Ross WalkerCuts like these are so short sighted and narrow minded. It's impossible for every child to an academic and if you take away the opportunities for them to explore other areas like music then you are denying them the same rights as said academic children.30482018-05-15T12:33:24.28335771Laurence RobertsonThis is a shocking piece of legislation - snooping on children and as importantly, parents. There has already been a teacher (named person), who was responsible for 200 children, prosecuted for pedophilia. How many more named persons out there. Nobody, except parents, have any right to share information or snoop on children. Disgusting attitude from a Nationalist Government who are using this information for their own ends - and indoctrinating young people with their appalling political policies! 30142018-05-15T12:55:13.5235772Iain RichardsonVital on so many different levels.30482018-05-15T12:56:11.77735773George KirkpatrickIt is undermining the roles of parents. There already exists legislation to cover abuse by parents.30142018-05-15T13:11:44.3435774Andrew PeacockThere are privacy laws for a reason. If this was the private sector, there would be outrage from govt.30142018-05-15T14:40:49.5135775Karen ShanklandI witness my family members terrible suffering with ME. It is a dreadful neurological illness. For many years his GPs failed to diagnose him and failed to treat him with dignity and respect. He didnt get any support. He had to give up a talented career. It took a psychologist at a pain management clinic to diagnose him and inform his GP. \r\nThere needs to be a massive sea change in this country towards ME. GPs need mandatory expert training. Properly funded research is needed urgently and new treatments and of course a cure need to be delivered as soon as possible. 30502018-05-15T15:09:32.7935776J B Caulfield It is vital that legislation re listed battlefields is laid down NOW30032018-05-15T15:14:38.1435777Linda McChleryWe need more research and funding for ME, and specialists in Scotland! We need doctors trained to understand it, diagnose the illness and treat patients correctly. GET and CBT is not a treatment for this illness! It's causing harm to sufferers. We are just left to deal with this alone. ME needs to be recognised as a serious illness, and as a serious disability when people can't work. The stigma around ME must be changed through education, so it is recognised as the serious neurological condition it is.\r\nThe government need to help and provide treatment and support for sufferers of this dreadful illness!30502018-05-15T16:21:27.70735779Charles FarrenI was educated in West Lothian specifically in Brass. Played professionally, still play at the highest level and by day tutor in another authority. Please think long term rather than short!30482018-05-15T16:30:12.97735780mrs senga shirewe really need a public inquiry as this govt disregards our human rights as concerned parents and grandparents. keep up the fight as this is very important for the privacy of the future generation.30142018-05-15T19:05:03.40735782A P JohnstonI agree that legislation is essential to the long-term protection of our historic battlefields, and would urge the parliament to take the matter seriously and seek a workable framework for safeguarding sites which once lost can never be recovered.30032018-05-15T20:05:01.13335783Joyce NewtonVery important part of education.\r\n30482018-05-15T21:34:43.94335784Colin Whitehead I would like to put forward my support to more assistance to M,E silent suffers we unfortunately have in Scotland as to my knowledge there must only be one or two nurses to care or check on thousands of m.e conditioned patients unfortunately have. Please amend a bigger and better infrastructure to help the m,e surfurers we have .\r\n\r\nKind regards Mr Whitehead\r\n30502018-05-15T21:44:17.39735785Margaret Forrest I learned to play the flute through free tuition at school in the 1970s and still love to play the flute. Please keep instrumental music tuition free for our children and inspire future generations of musicians.30482018-05-15T21:57:23.72735786Joanne GillespieFunding needs to be made available for research into treatment for ME as those who suffer from this dibilitating condition deserve to be invested in to return to living a fulfilling and pain free life30502018-05-15T22:03:37.44735787Anne ClementsSufferers of ME are left to manage their condition by medical profession for the most part. The NHS is an organisation to be thankfulfor but unfortunately not if you have ME. 30502018-05-15T23:41:24.86735788Jane patersonMusic has been our life for the past 6 years. One of my family members went on to study music. Please do not take this away from children. Music is a fundamental, you only need to see the talent in west Lothian.30482018-05-15T23:48:05.135789John Squires-Evans Do not make music elitist! \r\n#musicforallclasses30482018-05-16T00:36:16.0935790Jan HendersonMusic enriches the soul. Every child deserves the opportunity to learn and play if they want to 30482018-05-16T02:57:48.53335791Michelle WilcoxPlease help! 30502018-05-16T08:12:39.5335792Lynsey AlexanderMedical professionals must learn to understand the fluctuating nature of ME. I have had relapse remit pattern since 1994- never reach30502018-05-16T08:40:40.1235793May McAllanPlease find a treatment for a member of my family, she has been missing from her life for 7 years. She was a talented primary school teacher and now spend much of her time in bed with terrible symptoms. I want to see her being able to get treatment and get better. 30502018-05-16T08:42:24.39335794Claudia RosenhanEducation is about the rounded person, and music serves as an important pathway into understanding.30482018-05-16T08:48:42.49735796eric poynterMusic was my first love\r\nAnd it'll be my last\r\nMusic of the future\r\nAnd music of the past.\r\nTo live without my music\r\nWould be impossible to do\r\nIn this world of troubles\r\nmy music pulls me through...lyrics from John Miles song Music....so true \r\n \r\n\r\n 30482018-05-16T11:40:08.2535798Julie ParkesAfter 11 years of the attitude is you need to learn to live with it and one day your body will snap out of it. I've now given up expecting my GP to do anything other than the occasional blood test and prescribing a few tablets. Its a complete waste of both our time even attending. This is a very isolating illness and more investment and education is required by all medical personnel30502018-05-16T11:54:50.1335799Therese StewartAction at national level is needed. Contrary to a substantial body of public opinion, many local authorities do not regard proper musical education as deserving of financial investment. For many parents, music cuts proposals have given an eye-opening insight into the workings of local 'democracy'. In the absence of wider support, IMS remains in danger of being killed off.30482018-05-16T13:11:40.34335800laura kobineI whole-heartedly support the free provision of music lessons in schools in Scotland.30482018-05-16T13:25:24.54335801Sarah HoughtonI've been ill for 22 years. I am now housebound and struggling to walk. I cannot even qualify for PIP as the DWP struggle to accept ME. I'm in a living death. All I want is to know why my body doesn't seem to work and to either get better or improve as much as possible. Please help.30502018-05-16T14:41:25.10735802Helen DochertyDisgraceful piece of legislation!30142018-05-16T15:32:43.22735803Clarissa CheongScotland has a thriving music scene and it wouldn't exist without the opportunities offered to children in school. Many families cannot afford Private tuition, my family was one of them. I was offered Double Bass lessons in Primary school, continued through secondary and now at 36, have been playing in bands since I was in my 20's. I have a whole friendship group and network that has developed through connections in music. It has shaped who I am and more importantly has been my go-to when I have felt my mental health decline. I now train early years practitioners and childcare workers and always emphasise the absolute necessity of music in children's development. It doesn't stop in the early years and to remove that opportunity would only be another thing helping to widen the increasing attainment gap. 30482018-05-16T15:47:27.1235804Helen KerrThis proposed legislation has all the hallmarks of a totalitarian state30142018-05-16T15:53:14.735805Elizabeth Miller ClarkeI think that it is vital to preserve sites of historical interest for future generations. 30032018-05-16T16:03:37.0435806Clarissa CheongNot all parents can afford private tuition, my parents included. Music has been shown to support mental health, development and will help close the attainment gap. I benefitted from free tuition in school and it has had a huge impact on my life. So vital to continue offering these opportunities. 30482018-05-16T16:54:43.11335807Craig AngusSo important!!30482018-05-16T17:13:15.14335808Andy NisbetOnce it's gone it's gone.30032018-05-16T18:10:13.40735809Jill BerrettI became ill with M.E 30 years ago after being hospitalised with a viral illness. I have tried just about every type of treatment that exists, both traditional and complimentary, spending my family savings, and have not recovered. If I pace myself carefully I can get out most days, but can walk and do very little and I am in constant pain. I have had hardly any help or support from the NHS. I had to give up my career in law, and just about every activity that I used to enjoy- walking, climbing, playing badminton, being active in political and community groups. M.E affects every aspect of my life from the simple act of cooking a meal, to arranging to go to the Theatre or on holiday as I become exhausted by activity even when carefully planned. It is a scandal that there are millions of us missing our lives and that money is not being spent on proper research that would lead to treatment. 30502018-05-16T19:53:40.3135810Gillie WhittleOur family member suffers much pain and isolation. It is time that ME was taken seriously, and more effort was made to find a cure30502018-05-16T20:00:33.6435811Stuart SimpsonGiving our children the chance to experience music through learning an instrument or being part of a choir is so in portent for their overall development in the society where many are put in front of the TV to entertain themselves, until they are old enough to play games on a tablet. By the time they are 20, they will need "tablets" to cope with life and glasses because they have ruined their eyes. With music, it expands and exercises the brain, eyes and stimulates the soul. Please support this important education.30482018-05-16T20:02:19.6735812Jeni MorrisonChildren are happy when they are making music. 30482018-05-16T20:22:21.51735813Lesley GrahamI have struggled for over 40 years with little or no help and not even a diagnosis till recently. Members of my family are starting to have some of my symptoms. They can not and must not have to endure what I did. They deserve help now. It's too late to help me, but it's not too late to help them, which in turn will help me knowing they won't have to suffer like I did, alone. PLEASE, Help me to help my kids!30502018-05-16T20:54:10.22335815Cordelia ONeillMusic and the arts are crucial in so many ways. Access for all is vital. Help all children enjoy themselves and reach their potential30482018-05-16T21:03:12.3235816Jeanette McGuireDelighted to sign this worthwhile petition 30032018-05-16T21:31:18.08335817JOHN MACFARLANEThis sinister legislation should be done away with.Just another example of inept Government .30142018-05-16T22:56:16.13335818Douglas Gillespieabout you and your family, which is precisely the sort of thing a dictatorship would use to find it if you are a loyal follower or not. 30142018-05-17T08:46:50.55335820Catherine AshenfelterStop ruining the lives of M.E. sufferers with Graded Exercise and unhelpful CBT.30502018-05-17T09:49:49.43735822Onora Ni ShuilleabhainI have been ill for over 45 years. As well as the tremendous difficulties and losses for me myself, my training and talents have been lost to society. I have had to live with rejection and disbelief and virtually no help from the medical profession. While there is now a body of research showing the physical basis of ME, a massive and purposeful attack on the cause or causes of this life destroying illness, using all the resources of the state, is badly needed. People are still falling ill every smonth and every year, and losing their health permanently to this \r\nappalling disease. Please act to conquer this scourge with proper research and funding focussed on diagnosis and ultimately the right treatment. 30502018-05-17T10:38:52.54735823Mary ChapmanI first received a violin at primary school aged 8 yrs. I was encouraged to continue and now aged 75 I enjoy playing Scottish fiddle music most weeks of the year. Learning an instrument is a gift for life.30482018-05-17T11:48:52.77335824Paul JohnstonMy daughter has come on leaps and bounds thanks to school music tuition. It should be able to all, not just those who can afford it.30482018-05-17T11:53:39.7635825Carol Ann McGregorhave been severely effected by ME for 25 years 7 of which I was bed-bound and the remainder mainly housebound. I was shocked when I moved to Scotland that there was no ME specialist in the West of Scotland and in fact only 1 ME nurse in Fife and that there has been no funding for research into the illness has been in Scotland. I like the many thousands of other sufferers want our lives back, \r\n\r\nMy divorce maintenance* has ended, and as I have another 4 years until I retire, I for the first time in my life, will need to apply for unemployment benefit: ESA. It is my understanding that being disabled due to M.E, as it is deemed a psychosocial illness, I will have difficulty getting it. I receive indefinite DLA at the higher rate for mobility and use the money to pay for taxis and a boot mobility scooter. I also receive the middle rate for care which I use to pay for care. However I am aware that having ME and a musculoskeletal injury, being transferred to PIP, will not be guaranteed. I feel very concerned.\r\n\r\nWe has been neglected, too long.30502018-05-17T12:58:22.23735826L WatsonI've had CFS for almost 30 years. My entire adult life has been taken from me as I fell ill at 17. I have never had a chance to live a normal life, be what I wanted to be, have a partner and a family, all the things that most people take for granted. I've been treated appallingly by many doctors and consultants and the nearest CFS clinic is over an hours drive from my home(local on was closed down) so I couldn't attend if I wanted to. The clinics only offer CBT and GET which in patient circles are very well known to cause damage to sufferers. Many of my friends have been made substantailly and permanently worse from being pushed into such programmes. I'm mostly housebound, unable to care for myself, unable to see friends or family for the most part and still face disbelief, ignorance, arrogance and disinterest from the medical profession which is absolutely disgraceful and unacceptable. Something needs to change, and change is needed NOW!30502018-05-17T14:35:33.20335827Iain Macfarlane I strongly believe this subject should be protected and kept in Scottish schools. They are the new tradition and heritage, look after them! 30482018-05-17T16:40:11.51735830Angela ProssI fully support this petition, the distress this has caused to some families is sickening and the effects are still felt by some to this day.They cannot be allowed to get away with this any longer. Thank you for standing up for families and their rights. 30142018-05-17T19:50:33.0935831Peter CoullThis should never have left the room girfec is an Orwellian nightmare. A previous parties ideals of a bygone era.30142018-05-17T20:15:41.40735833Steven CraigFree music tuition gives youngsters a chance to get into music especially those less fortunate whose parents can't afford it. Being part of a musical group teaches a lifeskill, how many young people involved with organised groups get into trouble ? very few. We don't charge for sports we should not be charging for music tuition, every youngster deserves a chance to experience music through learning and school is the correct place to do this.30482018-05-17T21:03:53.72335834donna closefor the many families who have been ignored and abused by the very people who are meant to uphold child protection and the law 30142018-05-17T21:20:49.0635835Eric WilliamsonLet parents bring up their children Not governments. Are the SNP trying to get a Sturgeon youth movement started?\r\n30142018-05-17T21:21:35.9635836Andy SummersMaintaining music tuition and orchestras within schools is critical for the nourishment and plurality of education and learning within the Scottish education system.30482018-05-17T21:39:42.7335837Scott HoatsonAn unacceptable loss. 30482018-05-17T21:55:59.835838Ken DochertyIt seems to me that the pilot programmes were illegal. 30142018-05-17T22:45:53.7635839Graham LangI think John should go he is passed his sellby date30142018-05-18T06:48:31.6535842Andrew kerrState snooping at its worst, methinks there is a more sinister reason for this legislation.30142018-05-18T08:10:29.68335843June CraigToo much history going under the bulldozer. Let's save what we still have.30032018-05-18T10:06:16.76735844Marjory RobertsonYes, I agree that it is vital that legislation is laid down now before any further inappropriate developments can go ahead. Our nation's heritage needs to be protected for future generations.30032018-05-18T10:12:01.18735845Lucy Wilson I had no idea the damage GIRFEC can and does do until now. The agencies that use it to hide behind to gain access to families private history and share it with whom ever they choose is shocking. I had this naive idea that there was no issue with GIRFEC if you had nothing to hide but I was astoundingly wrong. GIRFEC needs to be scrapped ASAP.30142018-05-18T10:39:52.67735846John McGowanLearning music not only gives young people a skill for life but supports their learning in other subjects.30482018-05-18T13:43:36.63335847Cameron MarrIt's a disgrace the way the arts are being constantly sidelined to make way for the 'three Rs'. What do you think people will be reading and writing about, eventually?! Nothing new, that's for sure. 30482018-05-18T14:32:11.8335848Ron BrownConcentration, perseverance, teamwork, public performance - just some of the many challenges and benefits attached to musical tuition. By giving children the chance to learn music, not only do we ensure talent is spotted and nurtured, we also help the next generation develop into more rounded individuals.30482018-05-18T16:24:24.28735849Craig McGlashanFree musical tuition not only benefits children's education greatly but provides an excellent outlet, particularly in rural areas where there are not a lot of other options for entertainment.30482018-05-18T18:13:58.83335851ALISON GREIGMusic, along with art & drama is vital within our education system. Not all pupils are academic and it's subjects like music that can unlock potential in so many. For it to not be available to all, free, is to risk many children being lost in a sea of academic expectations. Education speaks about the 'whole child'. Aesthetic subjects are immeasurably important. Please don't limit what they can achieve. 30482018-05-18T23:01:49.54335853Robert BurnettAll children should have an entitlement to free music tuition.30482018-05-19T07:48:29.8935854Hamish DouganThere are many children who thrive in other subjects as a result of having music instruction which gives them confedance and leads to doing well.30482018-05-19T09:28:52.57335855Kenneth Knowles No brainier. Music must remain a crucial part of a varied ciriculum and a childs development.30482018-05-19T09:49:17.20335856Fiona DownieMusic is so important. Make it free for all kids to learn.30482018-05-19T09:51:38.9735857Roger J HardmanWe should be protecting the heritage of our history for future generations.30032018-05-19T09:54:11.29735858Eileen MorrisI was born and brought up in Bothwel l and the remaining site of the battle of bothwell bridge is one which should be preserved and not lost forever to developers who have developed the rest of the village.30032018-05-19T14:03:50.4135859Ian CoombsThere should be no need to encroach on historic sites. Our history is important.30032018-05-19T14:31:16.8435860John McmorranWe need to preserve these historical sites, I would urge everyone to sign and save more unaffordable homes being built. 30032018-05-19T14:33:29.58335861Gavin GrieveProtect our village30032018-05-19T14:38:49.47735862Gavin GrieveSave our heritage30032018-05-19T16:09:02.0535863Hilsbeth Avril ClarkThese battle sites are sacred to the memory of the men who fought and died on them.It is sacrelege to permit building on them.Imagine in years to come taking your grandchilden to a housing estate and trying to explain to them the battle of Bothwell Bridge? These sites our national heritage and must be preserved.We forgo thst at our peril30032018-05-19T16:09:30.9435864Sharon PatonOf course. These are historic sites where people died. 30032018-05-19T17:18:26.51335865Alice FlatmanMust be kept! 30482018-05-19T20:37:29.33735866John ReidRespect the views of the people of Bothwell 30032018-05-19T23:44:25.72335867Margaret CrossOur country our history leave it alone, we fought and died for 30032018-05-20T01:12:55.535868Greg StobieFuture generations have to be able to stand on the place these events actually took place in order to feel emotionally connected and completely understand the significance30032018-05-20T06:59:34.23735870Janice crawfordPlease do not change this historic village anymore, we are losing all of our histories sites in favour of new housing.30032018-05-20T08:43:14.07335871Christine cameronPeople who live on water have no rights except to be taken to court for eviction. The Scottish government could rectify to protect boaters living on water 30022018-05-20T09:15:43.4235872Colin GordonMusic teaches focus to many children.30482018-05-20T09:46:50.12735873DOROTHY GILMOURI have been living with ME for 9 years and I am currently housebound but I have never given up hope of recovery. Each time I do 'recover' I am struck down with the illness again and I am left in an even worse condition. One of the hardest parts, especially in the beginning, is feeling the need to justify my position to everyone around me because I look so normal. Why would anyone think that a person would fake having this illness when you lose so much. It's not only the person who has the illness who suffers, it's all the family who are affected. More research, understanding and help is needed. There is private help out there from private clinics like the Optimum Health Clinic in London who will provide free literature to try to explain the illness but the cost of becoming a patient and of following their protocol is prohibitive for most people. Please, please help us who suffer. And for those who suffer, never give up hope.30502018-05-20T10:04:54.94335874Pierre PotelHad a Water Ombudsman be present over the last 4 years, the Canals wouldn't be in the poor state they are in now...\r\nForcing the organisation to fulfill its' statutory duties is highly necessary.\r\nThe boaters desperately need a third party to overlook and arbitrate unsaftisfactory behaviour from Scottish Canals.30022018-05-20T10:17:09.47735875Marianne Louise DuncanInstitutional bullying with no one being held accountable.30142018-05-20T10:18:52.3235876Jim GellatlyMusic is a huge part of our culture and the opportunity to learn should be open to all.30482018-05-20T11:47:26.1935877Christine SouthgateThere are many failings of Scottish canals. Most complaints and feedback go ignored or unsatisfactorily answered. When Scottish canals were part of the wider British waterways the complaints procedure allowed issues to go to someone in British waterways England to be considered. although this was still part of British waterways it was someone outside the running of the Scottish waterways. I do not believe it is necessary to have someone outside Scotland as long as they are outside Scottish Canals. The fact that there are no private marinas and no competition for Scottish canals has led to increased fees with reduced services For example we have just see price rises in mooring fees but they have just issued notification that access to services are been reduced in many cases to two half days a week for services such as pump outs. This creates an environmental and potentially human rights issue.\r\nWe are in desperate need of ombudsman to ensure fairness and encourage accountability.30022018-05-20T12:39:29.65735878Helen hindleyWe desperately need money for research and treatment. We want our lives back.30502018-05-20T15:45:39.76335880Margaret MitchellThis is being forced on Scotland by obstinacy of Mr Swinney. The will of the people is being completely disregarded. 30142018-05-20T18:04:19.03335881Jen McLeodA critical service to well rounded development of young people. Must be retained!30482018-05-20T18:15:31.66735882Wilfred John Alexander WilsonIf we allow developers to but sites for their property projects we will denude our communities of their historical heritage and future generations will not forgive us for cultural vandalism.30032018-05-20T20:53:56.1235883Helen DalyPlease help end this suffering30502018-05-20T21:24:02.62335884Deborah TaylorWithout free instrumental lessons, I would never have been able to afford to learn. Because of them, I was able to attend the RCS (RSAMD) and go on to become a Music Teacher. Everyone should get that chance, for free. 30482018-05-20T21:56:14.62735885Dave SextonPlease fund research into this terrible illness that not only can kill, but affects the extended families. 30502018-05-20T22:38:49.77335886TJ Elliott Music should be accessible for all not elitist. It has been proven to support academic success as well as boost confidence team skills and it will break my daughter's heart to stop after lessons practice exam prep and performing at school youth orchestra and community events. Removing creative outlets for young people is extremely short sighted and short term thinking and will hurt those already struggling disproportionately hard as well as wasting talent I've witnessed at concerts from hardworking young people and adult volunteers.30482018-05-21T09:50:04.79735887Wendy Dawson-YoungScottish Canals have shown themselves insensitive to the needs and concerns of boat owners, particularly with regard to maintenance of the canals in a navigable condition and the provision and pricing of moorings (over which they hold a virtual monopoly). An independent Water Ombudsman would give all canal users the right to be heard.30022018-05-21T10:21:15.73735888Jonathan MarksI see the named persons scheme as a direct infringement on our personal privacy. It should be scrapped and those involved taken to task 30142018-05-21T13:21:06.37335891Jan Cumberford- millerI used to keep my ponies for many years in the covanatars field Bothwell and my dad wanted to buy it and sign document to say he would never sell to build houses on it however then many years ago there was so much politics sadly. We stayed in Lang side road bothwell with a back gate from house in to field would be awful if builders were to do anything to this historic place and history.30032018-05-21T14:01:59.36335892Frank BoltonIt is vitally important that we preserve these sites for the future. Children need to be aware of our history nd these sites contribute greatly to the enhancement of the learning. To visit a site where hundreds of years earlier our ancestors stood gives meaning to the history.30032018-05-21T14:54:59.21335893Gavin GrieveProtect our history30032018-05-21T15:05:41.35335894Marguerite Hunter BlairArticle 31 (2) "States Parties shall respect and promote the right of the child to participate fully in cultural and artistic life and shall encourage the provision of appropriate and equal opportunities for cultural, artistic, recreational and leisure activity"30482018-05-21T18:41:09.1535896Beverley SchofieldI am one of several businesses who have been forced to give up trading on Scottish Lowland Canals due to the poor treatment received from Scottish Canals. As a sole trader it was impossible to challenge the arrogant, dismissive and inefficient actions of this organisation, even before navigation was halted. A water ombudsman would have been invaluable and addressing this.30022018-05-21T19:49:54.70735897Michael McColganIt is vitally important that we preserve these sites for the future30032018-05-21T21:58:55.09735899Muriel ForsterHistorical Battlefield Sites should be preserved for future generations to fully appreciate their country's history30032018-05-21T23:17:35.37735900sarah OConnellPlease help me to have hope that some treatment will be available in the future for this awful illness. My children are surviving with half a mother.30502018-05-22T09:13:06.8335901PATRICIA MURPHY I cannot believe anyone would think of charging children to play music in schools!\r\n30482018-05-22T11:35:09.20735902Scott CowanThe soon to be implemented GDPR places potentially eye-watering penalties on anyone breaching their privacy rights. The bill currently in parliament allowing for class action law suits in Scotland is good news for parents . I predict GIRFEC ..Named person will be the first act challenged under this new right by parents who will band together to hold the govt to account in court . \r\n\r\nAs the Supreme Court have already ruled the info sharing provisions unlawful under the old more lenient DPA the outcome is inevitable . And the govt can look forward to some eye-watering compensation claims as a result of their refusal to listen to the genuine concerns of parents .\r\n\r\nThe Scottish Govt are meant to work for us and they are not above the law.30142018-05-22T12:00:22.65735903Douglas McDonaldPlease help and show your support for the many people this terrible disease effects. 30502018-05-22T12:18:20.97735904Thomas A MagillThis is Stalinist policy and completely unacceptable30142018-05-22T13:42:05.03735905Kevin LittleWhat i find staggering about this whole girfec-named person scheme is the govt are simply not listening to anyone but the charities who support this act. And to think its cost us "the taxpayers" more £61 million so far (not counting the legal costs). In these times of austerity this in itself is a criminal waste of public money on an unlawful scheme that has been thoroughly discredited with ordinary families .\r\n\r\n\r\nThere must be a full independent public inquiry. We want to know .... who's idea it was . Where has all the money gone. Why the govt are still allowing local councils to breach the law inspite of the supreme court judgement . And also the Scottish ICO in allowing councils to breach the DPA when they have no authority to do so. \r\n\r\n\r\nWe parents have no confidence in the govt and we demand a full public inquiry.30142018-05-22T15:57:43.7135907Nathan LaffertyIt is very important to keep the history alive, especially for younger people like me, who would not get to experience and see where historic events took place30032018-05-22T16:05:30.27335908Kim FoxonPlease we DESPERATELY need help and support other than GET & CBT30502018-05-22T17:00:05.48335909Ian Wallace .What were they thinking when they drempt this one up? A named person -an agent appointed by the state- who can access any information that they think -might be relevant- on not only the child but all associated adults ? Are they having a laugh? \r\n\r\n\r\nThat effectively means that my medical or financial info can be accessed by a school teacher for no lawful reason. In any other civilized society this would be regarded as totalitarian and a massive breach of privacy . But in Scotland its seen as making the country the - best place in the world to grow up - As compared to what communist China, Iran or maybe North Korea? \r\n\r\nIt is outrageous for any country that considers itself a liberal democracy that respects human rights to even contemplate anything like this. There now has to be a full public inquiry into this entire scheme including who drempt it up and who will benefit from it financially. If the govt have nothing to hide then they should have nothing to fear .. Should they ? 30142018-05-22T22:08:06.34735910K Mcmichael Had free tuition not been available to me back in the 90s the whole trajectory of my life would have been forever altered. Brass Banding has moulded me into the person, friend, volunteer, charitable trustee & professional I am today. 30482018-05-23T03:28:35.37735911Niamh KanePlease help us live again not just exist out of sight on horrific pain day after day with no hope30502018-05-23T08:42:11.19735913Rocco Monaco We need change I pay a lot off money and I get nothing back\r\n\r\n29942018-05-23T09:58:23.39735915James WatersChildren gain so much from the inspiration of music and instrumental tuition. Not just pleasure, but self-discipline and team working. So much more important than much that is learned at school30482018-05-23T10:16:17.72335916Drew WhiteVital sites of historical interest are protected for future generations.30032018-05-23T10:18:09.44335917Alasdair KellyThe continual underfunding of instrumental music services in Scotland is robbing our children of one of the most rewarding and life enhancing experiences we can offer them. The sustained study of an instrument over many years, supported by a specialist instrumental teacher, develops the whole person. This is not just a matter of giving kids a new hobby to try out. Learning that real ability and achievements only come after many years of hard work is a lesson that can only be learned through experience. Perseverance and resilience are qualities that every child needs to get through life, and it is the job of education to develop these qualities every bit as much as we develop knowledge and understanding. 30482018-05-23T10:23:15.3535918Christine CatherLocal people want to develop enterprises on canals but are being refused by the waterways. Why? There is done bus or prejudice and it is opposite to the stated mission of including communities fairly with our canals. Too many barriers for true community engagement.Time to empower Communities at canals30022018-05-23T12:17:32.10335919Louise TerryAbsolutely agree in this day and age - long overdue.30022018-05-23T13:12:57.2535920Peigi piperPlease consider this as every child should be entitled to this independent of wealth 30482018-05-23T15:44:07.42335921Hugh Mc CormickWe secure the future by holding the past30032018-05-23T16:49:10.9535922Terrie huttonThis needs changed to loose a child is unimaginable.x30472018-05-23T16:51:51.5335923Hilary SmartHope plenty of people sign this.30472018-05-23T20:30:44.76335924GordonWonderful cause. Best of luck Michael 30472018-05-23T22:22:30.85735925Graham BFrom a fellow Daddy, Highlander and Bear. 30472018-05-23T22:23:49.48335926Stevie Docherty No parent should have to pay to bury their child this should be the least of the worries 30472018-05-24T01:48:25.22735927Julia ReidThe harmful neglect of so many people with thus terrerrible disease must stop. We deserve a fair share of resources to support us and to find trestments and hopefully a cure. 30502018-05-24T03:56:03.52735928Diane MartinME is a serious medical condition that takes away any quality of life for millions of people. It needs to be treated with the seriousness of cancer and MS30502018-05-24T05:46:40.9835929Ketra WoodingIf I'd received good advice about how serious ME CFS is then I wouldn't have ended up living in a nursing home for the past 5 years.\r\nBut because I've been in a nursing home and had a lot of support I've been able to slowly improve and can now handle some light and noise. \r\n\r\nWithout proper support and care from the government MECFS patients will continue to be a huge drain on society.\r\n\r\nTo learn how to help patients without causing harm check out the Australian health professionals in After Unrest - Ketra's Story, now available on YouTube.\r\n\r\n30502018-05-24T08:18:00.38335930Lucille PeatMusic lessons are priceless!30482018-05-24T08:18:22.2235931ANN ELSBYThis ilaw is only required for children at risk but on the whole parentts know best30142018-05-24T08:37:19.87735932SusannaWe urgently need solid biomedical research to support recognition and treatment of this life-sapping disease. And no more CBT and GET as treatments.30502018-05-24T17:17:30.7535934Judith GrahamLifesaving- go Petition!30482018-05-24T18:00:03.36335935Alasdair MathersWe've had to outback in charges after having stopped because our Coincil budget is under o much pressure . Councils need more money 30482018-05-24T19:37:08.66335936Colette o brienLet's fund ME research and the aim is to get MEsufferers back to life, work and off disability.30502018-05-24T19:43:16.61735937Greg IrvineGood luck mate.30472018-05-24T20:03:54.86735938Cheryl BroganThank you for raising awareness on this, shocking that this is even the case.30472018-05-24T20:07:58.8435939Penni BrownMore research please30502018-05-24T20:32:30.7835940Jack WhyteTotally in agreement with stated objectives30032018-05-24T20:44:16.45335942Paige ShepherdMichael you inspire petiole everyday. Keep fighting. We are all behind you! Xx30472018-05-24T21:48:53.86335943ClairBest of luck Michael x30472018-05-24T21:57:14.30335944Carolyn BlairHaving benefited from no funeral costs for our son I think this is a great idea. Takes away a lot of the financial burden.30472018-05-24T21:59:44.26335945Sharon BarbourIf there had been charges for music tuition when I was young I would never have Had the opportunity to learn the skills which helped mould me as a human being. It can help teach structure and teamwork, creativity and discipline, social skills and integrity. I also remember that our school was given donations in return for our bands playing concerts so surely the funds can come from that! 30482018-05-24T23:14:53.41335946Elysia WilsonMusic tuition is more than a subject it ticks the boxes of so many of the capacities in the curriculum for excellence agenda AND the closing of the attainment gap which is the priority of the Scottish education service. There is so much evidence to show us that those that have music tuition on average do much better in exams, go on to higher eduction and have better coping stats goes, leadership skills and mental health! As a singing teacher I have seen this in action over the years. It would be unfair to take this away from the next generation as music for all works!! 30482018-05-25T08:29:02.9935947Christine Steel Not every family can afford these fees for music lessons at school. Some kids have fantastic musical talents and should be allowed tuition free at school as it has always been. 30482018-05-25T08:48:05.85335948Ian RoylePlaying music in schools is character building and develops social skills. For the more musically gifted children there is also the opportunity to prepare for a career as a professional and the British music industry earns billions of pounds every year. 30482018-05-25T13:05:39.93335949Ken MurrayScotland has an outstanding, even unique, musical heritage. It is up to us to pass this on to future generations. I encourage the Scottish Government to properly fund music education for all children30482018-05-25T13:54:56.6335950LYDIA REIDI absolutely believe no parent should have to worry over the financial aspect of burying their child \r\nI have been in that position and was lucky enough to have a Father in Law who understood and had my son put into his family plot \r\nThe feeling that my child might have to go into a public plot where you cannot put any headstone or even a proper recognition of where your child lies is just so devastating \r\nTo be forced to cremate your child instead of burial because it is cheaper should never happen\r\nSo yes we need a funeral fund\r\nMy worry tho is this \r\nScotland has limited funds\r\nThe balance of our funds go to Westminster \r\nI am among the people who say \r\nFund this\r\nFund that \r\nLike all folk I have a list \r\nIs it all realistic \r\nMaybe tho we should look at the cost are their really that many children that die in our country now 30472018-05-25T14:10:32.06735951LYDIA REID Scotland but more important Scotland's children have a right to their own history \r\nIf we build over our history it is gone never to return \r\n30472018-05-25T14:13:27.44335952LYDIA REID Scotland but more important the children of Scotland have a right to their own history \r\nWe are only the custodians \r\nOur MSPs are only the custodians \r\nIf we build over it it is gone never to return 30032018-05-25T16:03:51.1435953Pauline JewettBoth Culloden battlefield and Kiliecrankie are integral to our history. There are plenty of other places to build homes or holiday cabins. On the bodies of my ancestors is NOT the appropriate place. If the Scottish government does not protect these areas from development, they will lose a lot of support from Scots and those of Scottish origin 30032018-05-25T16:12:57.31335954Simon Childs My daughter has finally been diagnosed with M.E 3 weeks ago. Still trying to make sense of it. 30502018-05-25T16:16:56.03335955Donald McLarenI received free tuition both from School and The Boys' Brigade. If I had not learned I would not have had the chance to participate In the Ystad Tattoo in Sweden. Travel to Belgium, France, Denmark and Greece to play in various musical events.30482018-05-25T17:23:08.49735956stella brennan as i had friend who loss her first baby in 1960s to see her pain at the time was so upsetting then to pay to bury her was to sad \r\n30472018-05-25T18:13:54.64335957Nicola mHoping every signature counts well done Michael xxx30472018-05-25T19:08:00.69735958Janet McArthurIt has been made abundantly clear to the people of Scotland that they are being herded into a global, communitarian dictatorship, facilitated by the EU, and our Dear Leaders are prepared to ride roughshod over privacy and family life for the purpose of control. We do not consent.30142018-05-25T19:10:55.4535959Naomi Burgessgood research cannot come soon enough. Sufferer for 38 years.30502018-05-25T20:48:55.44735961Paul SmartBattlefields are war graves and should be full protected and respected.\r\nStop selling off Scotland to the highest bidder.30032018-05-25T20:56:54.2635962Steve kessonWe must secure vital historical sites for our future generations 30032018-05-25T20:58:39.4835963Diane FeliceI've had severe ME for 27 years, bed bound and totally unable to work, get married or have children. Please increase funding for this horrible disease!!30502018-05-25T21:01:04.9835964Deborah BruceI was 19 when I first became ill. I am now 55 years old. How many other illnesses are neglected for this long. At this rate of progress in terms of financial support for research into M.E.and in patient care for M.E. sufferers I doubt if I will live to see a cure, real recognition for this illness, or supportive health care for M.E. Scotland is failing us. 30502018-05-25T21:03:16.07335965Dot Menzies HoldenWe need to safeguard places like the Battlefields and not allow them to disappear gradually under housing or roads. They are an extremely important part of our history, much of which is no longer being taught in our schools, and we need to ensure that developers do not take advantage of this lack of knowledge to build prestige developments they can sell for exorbitant prices.\r\n 30032018-05-25T21:07:42.02735967Christine MacFarquharThe loss of a child is dramatic,without the added worry of affording to bury them.\r\nGood luck with the petition 30472018-05-25T21:14:37.8135968Dougie KinnearProtect our heritage and history from profiteers.30032018-05-25T21:28:27.0635970KATHLEEN WEETMANIt is imperative that legislation in Scotland is changed in order to allow communities to have an equal say with developers in planning situations. Equal Right of Appeal will be required as will proper consultation with local people inclusive of developers and local council members who represent the people. Centralisation of legal power in a Minister is not appropriate unless a plan is of specific National Importance. No builds on Historic Battlefields ,archaeological sites and GREENBELT 30032018-05-25T21:39:1135971Linda SchultzI hope the powers of government will choose to protect glorious Scottish historic sites for the future of tourism, and the education of future generations!30032018-05-25T21:45:40.65735972Jeanette Newell Loss of a culture should not be repeated by a disregard of historical sites for financial gain30032018-05-25T21:48:18.53335973Donald BrundageHistorical battlefields should be protected for future historians and to help teach future generations understand our history. Nothing like standing in places such as Culloden and absorbing the sacred vibes.30032018-05-25T21:53:07.40735974Vivienne Patterson Profit before an area of historical significance is a disgrace and a shameful reflection of general apathy of the masses30032018-05-25T22:01:46.73735975Heidi Christiansen Historic sites should be preserved for education and remembrance. \r\n30032018-05-25T22:14:05.4135977Brent ReidenbachSave these locations now before the sacrifices of so many are merely a footnote in a history book and forgotten as fast as one can turn the page.30032018-05-25T22:16:37.30335978Susan MurrayHistorical sites are our heritage and as such should be protected for future generations.30032018-05-25T22:42:34.30735979Pauleen GreenThe fees for music lessons have risen higher than inflation. I know the good these lessons have for children as my daughter plays flute and my son should be able to have the same experience even thought their is a 7 years difference between them.30482018-05-25T22:56:37.9335980Joy BoothbyWar Graves must be protected from being sold and used to build upon!! Graves are sacred territory especially when men were killed trying to protect the \r\nTerritory!30032018-05-25T23:03:04.7335981Jean hepburnMusic is as important as any other subjects 30482018-05-25T23:11:27.68335982Gregory NunnI am a Ferguson and Whitelaw, 2nd generation in America. Those are my ancestors in the dirt. That is my blood. It is but a small space. Leave it be.30032018-05-25T23:14:55.18335983Gregory NunnWhy take this small space, filled with the bodies and blood of my ancestors, and make money?\r\n30032018-05-25T23:18:59.93335984Heather LeckieThis is a war grave and historic battlefield. It should remain undisturbed.30032018-05-25T23:22:11.8435985Catrina Pickering Do not let Culloden and other historical sites be desecrated for the sake of financial gain. 30032018-05-25T23:36:45.87735986Ian MacDonaldHistoric Sites must be preserved.30032018-05-25T23:42:34.82735988Margaret LangI cant beleive that this is something that we need to petition government about. This should already be protected land, all battlefields need to be preserved, no other country worth fighting for builds on their historical battle ground. The world is watching, let our Scottish Government show that it is proud to protect its history, its identity and its people.30032018-05-25T23:43:21.87735989Monica PayneOur history is what makes us who we are.30032018-05-25T23:45:51.15735990Andy FairgrievePlease act now on this to protect our heritage 30032018-05-26T00:08:46.56735991Annette Webster The world is also watching dont let big business demolish a sacred national treasure. 30032018-05-26T00:08:47.67735992Annette Webster The world is also watching dont let big business demolish a sacred national treasure. 30032018-05-26T01:34:37.79735993Alistair Hamilton To honour those people who had fought and died for a cause of their own personal identity, I deeply think that needs to be safe guarded.30032018-05-26T03:41:31.9435994marion mcmillanthis is long overdue. 30032018-05-26T04:06:47.6835995Cathy DubeProtect historical sites for future generations. 30032018-05-26T04:59:39.62335996Jenny McWilliam We look to our History to help secure our future.\r\n\r\n30032018-05-26T06:25:49.96335998Dianne CoxImproved care and understanding of this .\r\nMore undergraduate teaching to medical students.\r\nMore and total education to local gps. The situation in Australia is dreadful and it seems no better ib Scotland.\r\nPeope that are house bound can not get the trearment they so badly need. 30502018-05-26T06:45:04.99735999Lora J Miller I hope that when my small grandchildren visit Scotland someday that they will find Culloden Battlefield much the same as today. A gravesite and memorial to our Scottish ancestors that has endured the test of time.30032018-05-26T08:01:09.0436000Alex KinnearPreserve the past, it shapes the future.30032018-05-26T08:57:55.65336001Hanne Reke HELP30502018-05-26T10:01:57.35336003David Gordon Aitchison Disgusting to build on war graves. The councillors that voted in favour should be ashamed of themselves and some of them with good highland names I hope they hear thier ancestors . 30032018-05-26T10:16:19.1236004Lorna murdochThis is so needed, we were blessed in that the funeral directors we had for our daughter paid the majority of the bill but not funeral directors do this. It is hard enough to organise and pay for a funeral for an adult by a child is so emotionally different. Having help there to cover costs, wholly or partially is such a weight lifted. I totally support this petition in every way. 30472018-05-26T10:36:53.1436005Karen DoyleThese battlefields are historic and sacred and should be preserved always.30032018-05-26T10:55:25.42336006Kathleen GalbraithThese sites are our history and must be preserved, not built on30032018-05-26T10:56:37.28336007Kathleen GalbraithThese Historic Battlefields should be preserved, not built on30032018-05-26T12:09:29.0636008A J SimpsonMusic has no boundaries, race, faith, culture, language and should be available free to all children who wish to learn at school as part of their education package.30482018-05-26T13:22:05.57336010Per-Ragnar JatkoThe preservation of battlefields from the Scottish history is important, both as a way to attract tourism as well as a important reminder of the proud Scottish history. To allow development on historical battlefields is just another part of the English colonization of Scotland.30032018-05-26T13:58:24.72736011Wendy Maclennan ME is a misunderstood disease with not enough help for those who are suffering daily. More funding is needed to give the care and support and research for those suffering from ME now and those who are not yet diagnosed. 30502018-05-26T15:38:59.8736012John-Paul NellanyThat is a sacred piece of Land.Should show more respect for our fallen Hero's.Wouldn't like it if someone built a house on my grave.Disgusting.30032018-05-26T16:42:27.97336014Ruth KennedyWe must stop this from happening it's beyond belief that this can be allowed..30032018-05-26T17:07:59.55736015Franziska FeistNo peaceful future without peace for the fallen30032018-05-26T17:39:06.74736016Deirdre Murray The effects of this illness are devastating and not enough research is going into finding cause and cure. Both the Westminster and the Scottish governments should invest in this.30502018-05-26T18:12:35.81336017Kelly Parks Millions of ME sufferers want to get back to being contributing members of society. We desperately need research and treatment.30502018-05-26T18:47:06.19336018John McCulloch Scotland Battlefields must be protected for future generations to learn our History 30032018-05-26T20:18:57.84736019Jo CantWe need to value our sites and our history to preserve it.30032018-05-26T20:36:22.72336020Wendy Maclennan More research and funding is urgently needed for ME. Currently it is a misunderstood disease and people are judged as lazy or using it as an excuse. It is a horrible disease and all suffers want us support and better reasearch in the hope if funding a treatment that works for them. 30502018-05-26T22:16:17.61336022Angela Hester Still suffering with ME, a truly life limiting, cognitive impairmaring, painful condition. All help will be welcomed by its sufferers.30502018-05-26T22:28:28.9136023Andrew Dalgliesh Brave men died for this land protect it to honour their memory 30032018-05-26T22:41:52.136024Kate reidPlease stop and think about what you are going to destroy30032018-05-26T23:25:11.49736026Will CosterOnce these sites are gone they cannot be replaced.30032018-05-27T00:01:41.00336027Pamela F GrayPreserve the past to secure a secure the future of Historically Important Sites 30032018-05-27T01:45:16.2836028William Fitzpatrick For the grace of God please think again, This is sacred land to Scotland. 30032018-05-27T10:01:14.44336029Bryan P KeastSNP manifesto for the last election was to provide every child in Scotland with the opportunity to play a musical instrument.30482018-05-27T11:02:07.4436030Andrew lawsonA sad day when givernment gives the green light in destroying history for small profit.30032018-05-27T13:50:21.74736032Linda Harper PopePlease show respect for the brave men who died and were buried on this hallowed ground. 30032018-05-27T14:12:03.67336033Andrew DuncanBlatant disregard towards historical sites. There should be no new buildings on battlefields etc. How are we going to keep these places for future generations to study, if there's no regulations to prevent new builds?30032018-05-27T14:54:29.7736034Keiran Anderson-BlakeHistoric Battlefields should be preserved at all costs!30032018-05-27T16:40:17.08336036anna soitWe need your help30502018-05-27T16:58:27.72336037Jim HamiltonHistory is important not only now but for future generations30032018-05-27T18:04:43.23336038William PatersonBattlefields and their environs- as well as being of historic importance- should be treated with the same reverence as maritime war graves30032018-05-27T19:09:55.08736039Kelly ShawSuch a misunderstood chronic life changing condition30502018-05-27T20:40:45.05736041Lisa McMasterMusic is beyond price. It can teach us so much and help us develop so many skills, including those commonly required by employers, such as time-management, creative thinking, deep listening, detailed analysis and self-expression. It is so important to preserve music services for future generations, not just for the development of the above-mentioned skills but also for the joy of being part of something larger than ourselves.\r\nPersonally, my own life trajectory would have been very different without access to music lessons and ensembles provided by my school and the local authority (Birmingham).30482018-05-27T20:41:29.92736042Denise McWattA vital service for all children 30482018-05-27T21:08:00.9836045Joy Gardner BoothbyIf we donot protect these sacred grounds they will be lost forever what are we teaching our children how important history is when we do the opposite and destroy such things!!!!30032018-05-27T21:32:38.5936046Karen Lowson This is disgusting every child should have the chance to play an instrument.30482018-05-27T21:46:01.32736047Mary turnbullWe need to respect our history and those who died fighting for a free Scotland .30032018-05-27T23:06:17.99736048Donna SylviLearning a musical instrument can be rewarding & helps with learning other subjects. Children should have this choice just like other subjects. 30482018-05-27T23:44:36.20336049StephenmcpheeSuch a great cause I know only too well the cost my son's funeral was 1300 after plot and funeral service costs and I struggled for months too pay it all 30472018-05-28T00:28:57.1836050Barbara HouleYes I agree. Look at what has been done to Dundee. It is important to preserve our history.30032018-05-28T02:12:49.64736051Kathleen Dalethere should be a non-negotiable municpal law against developments on designated battlefields and gravesites that have nothing to do with preserving the site.\r\n30032018-05-28T06:57:03.23336052Dorothy FraserThe debilitating symptoms experienced by M.E sufferers is robbing people of their lives. M.E support and care and understanding is urgently needed in Scotland. 30502018-05-28T08:44:49.53736053Mr MelvilleEnough of this deliberate enforcement of the class divide.30482018-05-28T08:57:04.27336054Alfie McQuade I have been there a few times, and it really gives you an eerie feeling knowing all those brave men died on that site trying to protect there heritage. Taken away by people who don't care about remembering history's diabolical episode's that were forced on the Scots. 30032018-05-28T12:01:05.21336055Cameron JayWhen society finally realises that artistic education and more specifically exposure to music at a focused and personal level it will probably be too late. Let's try to change to course of history now before it's too late. 30482018-05-28T12:29:31.7136056Michael AndersonHugh's comment is spot on. \r\n\r\nWe secure the future by holding the past\r\nHugh Mc Cormick\r\n15:44 on 23 May 201830032018-05-28T12:58:35.50336057Elizabeth mcintyreA distressing time as it is. No parent should have debt to add to their distress30472018-05-28T15:00:05.95736058Robert Alexander HigginsToday I am member of the all volunteer, Middle Georgia Concert Band, in Macon, GA USA. I got free music lessons at school, ( back in the 70's and 80's ) and I am sure my parents would not have been able to support myself and three siblings easily, if at all, if they had to pay for us to learn to play our instruments. Music should be a part of every school curriculum, this is an opportunity to learn a life skill that brings people together, of all classes and back grounds, and should not be restricted to the wealthy or to those kids who have parents more willing to sacrifice than others. ... Please consider this petition. Thanks, Bob .. 30482018-05-28T17:30:22.34336060Anthony Courtney The thought of this right being taken away from any child let alone those who would otherwise be unable to afford it is outrageous. 30482018-05-28T17:35:31.5136061David FrameI fully support free music tuition in schools. Music is an artform, it reaches far beyond intrumental training. Its a lifechanger for the good.30482018-05-28T18:08:35.5336062Rev Shuna DicksThis should be an across the board policy. Families in the midst of losing a child should not have to worry about costs. 30472018-05-28T20:36:00.29736063Lauren MMy instrumental tutor - was a ray of light to me. I would never have had opportunities to learn about jazz or discover other instruments had it not been for him and his colleagues- who let me spend my sixth year of studying Music at school learning about what they did. They gave me confidence and they encouraged me more than anyone did in terms of Music. They add life and colour to sometimes otherwise full extra-curricular opportunities and they give their own time generously and willingly to see talented young musicians reach their potential. So many of us would have given up on ourselves without this commitment from them.30482018-05-28T20:41:01.7436064Sheila InnesMore support important people who are suffering.30502018-05-28T20:42:11.64336065Siobhan McCartneyEvery child regardless of their financial background deserves the life changing opportunities that music tuition provides. This is not an elitist pursuit but one that can change lives in ways far beyond our comprehension. A lost musical generation and a cull on our cultural storytelling would be a price too high to pay!30482018-05-29T01:35:02.21736066Lisa LambersonWhat happens in one country affects all who suffer from this debilitating illness around the world. We are not lazy, crazy, or stupid...we want our lives back. We need help.30502018-05-29T02:23:41.8836067lorraine vanceLeave historical sites alone for future generations please!!30032018-05-29T03:13:52.71336068Margrete MansourYou deserve the best30482018-05-29T06:26:55.3136069Valerie McEvoyMy family member is seriously ill with M E. for which she receives no treatment whatsoever from the NHS. Can this be right? And when will things change? ( If ever.) Or will she go the same way as Merryn???30502018-05-29T07:34:01.72736070Sam CrowtherIt is bad enough to be so seriously ill for a number of years, but the medical neglect and lack of understanding is appalling. CBT and GET are very damaging and harmful for people with severe ME, and yet we are pushed to comply, or be seen as resistant to treatment. The evidence for such treatment has been fully discredited, and still we are harmed by this. Even if medical professionals are unable to help treat ME, a first step would be to stop blaming patients and causing more harm. We do not need specialist ME clinics that push harmful and unproven treatments, as England has. Please stop clinging to the psychosocial model, it is not supported scientifically and there is no excuse for continuing to pursue this area of research. People are dying. Please learn to do better, to understand ME, and to at least do no harm.30502018-05-29T10:20:55.5336071Stephen DuffyHas the government learned nothing? Culture is not an entitlement. It is a basic human right. 30482018-05-29T10:51:33.23736072Fergus HallI would not be who I am today without the instrumental tuition I recieved as a school pupil.30482018-05-29T11:30:33.0736073Charlene Bereaved Mummy30472018-05-29T12:16:49.41736074Louise McAllanI was on my way to recovery but GET made me severe. I went from walking before GET to being completely bed bound. Now I use a wheelchair. I was told I had a psychiatric problem, and forced out of bed in hospital which made me have a seizure. This has to stop. Stop GET and CBT and fund research for people withe ME. PLEASE. 30502018-05-29T15:07:36.38336075Manuela FathIt's such a great place to feel history. We were there last year and our 8 year old son was totally interested. He asked a lot and we answered him. Such a place needs to be protected.30032018-05-29T15:35:32.60336076Petra Nobes It's such an important place of Scottish history. It must be protected.30032018-05-29T19:01:26.27336078Jan KupkaIt is a historical place. Never should a place like this to be used for commercial aim. There are more possibilities to bring tourists for holiday to Scotland. Nobody should build tourist accomodation near to historic places. If you intend to visit Scotland as a tourist, you must have enough time for visiting. Otherwise we will have shuttle service an short distances between tourist accomodation and historical places in a couple of years.30032018-05-29T19:27:14.7136079Raphael WallfischMusic is one of the greatest gifts to civilisation, we cannot afford not to take it seriously It is vital to offer every opportunity for the next generations to learn, appreciate and enjoy music!30482018-05-29T20:19:34.8136080Caroline McKayMusic and the Arts are all part of being human. Stop targeting the easy options. Shame on you!!30482018-05-29T20:22:38.236081Caroline McKayMusic and the Arts is part of being human. Stop targeting Music Services, shame on you!!30482018-05-29T20:38:45.78336083Cassi Gillespie Yes30482018-05-29T20:57:41.8336084Alison Mitchell Free music both instrumental and singing has been so beneficial to all 3 of my children. My son at University now teaches guitar and plays the bag pipes at major events. My daughter started at East Renfrewshire choir and has now progressed to the National girls choir of Scotland and Scottish Opera. Without East Renfrewshire choir her talent may well have been lost. My daughter continues to play the drums through the school.30482018-05-29T20:58:34.70736085Lesley Gatheral I benefitted from free violin tuition for 10 yrs at school. I have had to pay increasing fees over the years for my children to learn their instruments, a skill which has proven to be linked to increased academic attainment. Now our council is threatening mixing S1s in a class with S6s!! Please stop this happening and bring back free instrumental tuition. What better way for the youth of today to be spending their time - certainly beats walking the streets getting up to no good!30482018-05-29T21:29:27.12336086Karen RileyGood luck30032018-05-29T21:41:14.91736087Angela DuffyMy best friend went from being an active half marathoner runner, a dedicated full time teacher and life and soul of our social circle to being completely debilitated by this condition. It is very real and has a huge impact on not only the sufferer but their family and friends. My best friend wants to work, to contribute to live her life fully again, but she is not well enough. Like any other person who is ill she deserves support, medical and emotional. She has been suffering for over 2 years and has had to justify why she cannot work, she lives to a strict timetable of tests and sort activity, which include 2 minuet phone conversations. She cannot look at screens, cannot read books and can not tolerate back ground noise when we do talk on the phone for 2 minutes. She is ill, like many others like her she needs the compassion and support of caring NHS and government. 30502018-05-29T21:43:50.80736088Lisa Gibsonlosing a child is hard for any parent without adding money worry to this. I know as most parents would be eternally grateful that this stress and worry was taken from them30472018-05-29T21:49:48.59336089Amy Dalrymple Music education should not be the preserve only of those who can afford to pay. As well as its intrinsic value, music education strongly supports wider improvements in social and educational outcomes. It fosters cooperation, concentration, supports language learning, and connects the emotional and intellectual parts of our brains. The benefits last throughout our lives. 30482018-05-29T22:50:14.0236092Jason Ratcliffe Having been thorough this I cannot think of a more distressing time. This policy should be across the whole country to help make the hardest time slightly easier. 30472018-05-30T00:18:33.11336094Alia Mobarik Music plays such a vital role in boosting self esteem, improving academic performance and introducing children to different cultures. 30482018-05-30T04:39:23.83736095Christiane DupuisPlease, stop this disgrace and show some respect.30032018-05-30T05:42:04.56336096Susan LittleThe music instrumental service is far too valuable to lose. The only opportunity that some pupils may get to experience an instrument should not be taken away. 30482018-05-30T06:49:03.85736097Rachel HyslopResearch has shown that pupils studying music achieve better in all subjects. This should not be reserved for those with the ability to afford lessons. In the year of the Young Person and with the National Improvement Framework focussing on Equity, Musical Instruction should be free to ALL pupils receiving it.30482018-05-30T06:51:28.16736098Rachel HyslopResearch has shown that pupils studying a musical instrument benefit across all areas of the curriculum. In the Year of the Young Person and with a focus on Equity in the National Improvement Framework, it is vital that the Scottish Government stop charging for music lessons. 30482018-05-30T07:17:06.6736099Syl HoughtonA site of such historic import needs to kept as it has been for centuries. It already has an impressive visitor center and restaurant. Any more would ruin it. 30032018-05-30T07:39:16.3536100Andrew BurnleyJust attended the Whit Friday contests in Saddelworth and was amazed at the amount of young players of a very high standard, these musicians would not have been there if it wasn't for free tuition in school, music gives children so many skills in life that no other subject can.30482018-05-30T07:44:53.67736101Aurore VautierThis site is a true historical sanctuary that should not be contaminated by buildings or facilities for tourist, agricultural or other purposes... If the government is elected by the people, it must not forget that it acts in the name of the people and for the people and that this people, by this petition, claims loud and clear that it is absolutely against this decision to desecrate Culloden. A historic place but also a cemetery where thousands of people are resting. These people deserve the respect of the Scottish Government. Without these men and others before them, there might be no more Scotland as we know it30032018-05-30T08:19:30.7336102Coleen HopeMusic has so many benefits to education and social and emotional skills and should be available to all equally. 30482018-05-30T08:30:30.60736103Iain CodonaSo much talent is being left on the shelf. 30482018-05-30T09:26:17.58336104Paul AustinMuch needed funding and support for ME patients to improve quality of life30502018-05-30T09:37:39.42736105C jordanSurely the benefits of music to children's mental health and wellbeing have to be a high priority 30482018-05-30T10:03:17.29336106Shaheen RashidEvery child should learn a musical instrument. The benefits are amazing!30482018-05-30T10:25:26.80336107David YoungPlease support ME patient's adequately. We need ro do more for these people to aid there treatment and help more to recover.30502018-05-30T10:40:32.58736108Karen Raleigh 20 +years suffering this life changing condition , no help , no compassion ,just ignorance and disbelief \r\nI know so many people also suffering but lately I personally know young teenagers who are so wiped out and waiting for a diagnosis . These young people are desperate and need effective treatment , I certainly cand stand the thought that they will have to suffer the ignorance and stigma that this condition has had to bare , we need faster diagnosis and treatment NOW .30502018-05-30T11:27:28.72736109Ann BewickPLEASE help people suffering with this life changing and debilitating illness. We need your support urgently. Show the world you care Thank You.30502018-05-30T11:32:01.3936110Petrina McTear My children all benefited from this amazing 0portunity in east Renfrewshire30482018-05-30T12:09:49.3836111Iain Petrie Music tuition of any kind is as important to a child's development as Maths and English, often more so.30482018-05-30T12:35:48.62736112Phil Cunningham MBELike many petitioners here, I also owe a huge debt of gratitude to the instrumental tuition I received at both primary and high school levels. Same applied to my late brother.30482018-05-30T14:22:22.57736114Samantha Campbell I have a very close friend suffering from this illness and there is very little known about it and how to treat the illness. More needs to be done to understand and cure this illness and treat patients 30502018-05-30T15:18:38.44336115KATHLEEN STUARThorrendous idea. Smacks of big brother control.30142018-05-30T15:43:37.55736116Groud Jacques What à pity ! Only to make money 30032018-05-30T16:41:59.9536117Jenny Kemp The EIS, Scotland's largest teaching union, fully support this petition. We are facing the gradual extinction of instrumental music services, and with that,the loss of education provision that Scotland should be celebrating and extending. \r\nIM Teachers provide excellence, but where's the equity when 'who pays, plays'? It's time for everyone involved in education funding to 'Change the Tune' and invest in instrumental music. 30482018-05-30T18:17:55.80736120Yasmine BushThis is the typical Marxist agenda. Ignore democracy and the majority of the people. Just do as thye Globalist masters bid.30142018-05-30T18:41:50.24736121Bernadette McClenaghanMy children receive state funded music tuition. Private lessons are not affordable by all. Are we saying musical tuition is only for those who have money??? Surely not. Surely all children should have the same opportunitues. Isn't that what this government is all about?? 30482018-05-30T19:00:19.64736122Marlies Blackwood This should be an opportunity open to all not just the wealthy in society. Tuition is just one of the expenses parents face with children pursuing a music career or experience and by taking that away more will be able to enjoy. Many parents are put off by this expense and we are now missing a whole group of potential stars. 30482018-05-30T19:16:37.11736123Kevin Donnachie An insult to Scotland and the true patriots that died on Culloden if this is allowed to happen.30032018-05-30T19:26:43.2336124Lee fosterThis a sacred battlefield and history and the sacrifice of those buried there should be the priority and memory not the pursuit of profit and greed.\r\n history is more important than money and when I speak to my kids about our nations history I don't want to take them to show them a housing estate where a sacred battlefield and burial once was. Maybe one day our history will come before profit. 30032018-05-30T20:18:23.96336125Gary Clarkson These sites are part of our heritage30032018-05-30T20:36:28.50336126Neil DownieI am supporting this petition because I am appalled by the consideration of current planning proposals for Culloden Battlefield.30032018-05-30T20:43:14.87336127Lynne DochertyIt is so important that all children can access free music tuition . As well as educational benefits it also helps with mental health 30482018-05-30T21:42:43.81736128Dr Fiona-Jane Brown, AberdeenBattlefields from whatever period of history are WAR GRAVES and should never ever be developed or built upon. 30032018-05-30T22:00:23.80336129Beverly Niland Preserve all Historical sites from Building on them30032018-05-30T22:13:42.07336130Elizabeth GrantMy children were very fortunate to study music in schools and I think It's an opportunity that should be available to all school children.30482018-05-30T22:17:55.84736131suba meHwbGJC Major thankies for the article.Really looking forward to read more.30502018-05-30T23:35:07.48336132Stewart GrayPut simply, a child or young person's opportunity to learn a musical instrument should be determined solely by that individual's passion, interest, or curiosity. To do otherwise would be a travesty of social justice, with children from poorer backgrounds - as usual - being denied the opportunity to broaden their horizons, explore the arts, and develop their own creativity. Engaging with something so positive as music-making can have a transformative effect on young people's lives. It gives them a sense of achievement and personal satisfaction. They feel valued as a member of an active musical community within their area or school. It promotes positive engagement in learning, and is hugely supportive of wellbeing (especially mental and emotional). I offer my full support to the campaign to secure free instrumental music services in local authorities across Scotland.30482018-05-30T23:57:31.48736133Allen HendersonIt is ridiculous that with a history the likes of what Scotland has, and the attraction that History has throughout the World, that we need to resort to petitioning to try and protect the sacred land that our forefathers fought so bravely to protect. Please STOP all this NOW and never let it rise ever again. 30032018-05-31T07:07:59.17336134Canon Mel LangilleA great cause. Apologies if I have already signed...sometimes I lose track. No deceit intended. 30032018-05-31T07:39:02.64736135Graeme CockburnMusic is such a big part of the lives of everyone in Scotland, be that classical or traditional.\r\nIt is vital that this important service to the pupils and ultimately the community is not lost - I petition you to make all efforts to keep this for all our young people.30482018-05-31T07:55:00.95336136Roddy SimsonFree musical tuition is a vital part of young people's education and should be available to all regardless of social class or income30482018-05-31T08:31:44.70336137Louise McGregorMusic is a huge part of any child's education and should be offered and available for all and not just those who can afford it.30482018-05-31T08:36:48.90736138john FerrieIf getting it right for every child does indeed lie at the heart of Scottish educational philosophy then this must also include opportunities for young people to engage with creative and artistic interest which are independent of means. I believe music tuition to be invaluable in adding to the rich tapestry of cultural life in Scotland. 30482018-05-31T08:48:20.3636139Jurgen MacGregorIt would be a great shame for Scotland NOT to preserve Culloden and the surrounding areas where good scottish jacobite soldiers died for the freedom and independence of Scotland. The government should pay respect to what happened there. If it is all about money then start thinking about how all visitors around the world who had lost ancestors there will be thinking of the actions of selling out national history.\r\n\r\nYours J. MacGregor\r\nGermany30032018-05-31T09:00:35.88736140Fiona MorisonIt is widely accepted that learning a musical instrument is beneficial to development acrisd the curriculum. Instrumental lessons should be free for all who would like them 30482018-05-31T09:26:16.8936141Educational Institute of ScotlandThe EIS, Scotland's largest teaching union with over 50,000 members, fully supports this petition. We are facing the gradual extinction of Instrumental Music Services, and with that, the loss of education provision that Scotland should be celebrating and extending. That cannot be allowed to happen. The development of a 'who pays, plays' culture is a travesty. It's time for everyone involved in education funding to Change the Tune and invest in instrumental music. 30482018-05-31T09:27:18.50736142George McCaigTwo generations of family have benefited greatly from Music Tuition in school.30482018-05-31T10:00:36.47336143Jacqueline BlackwoodI was brought up in West Lothian. I played percussion all the bands minus the string orchestra and I wouldn't have had instrumental instruction not been free. I left school to study music at college, however decided to go straight on to a career in the Armed Forces as a Musician... 15 years on I am most grateful to my tutors and West Lothian music services for giving me the opportunity to have my career. I have just recently left the regular Army to join the Reserves (also as a Musician). I have travelled to many different countries, played in the most beautiful concert halls and theatres and met some of the most amazing people. In Afghanistan we were tasked with tutoring the Afghan National Army Bands which to date is the most rewarding accolades I have participated in... To bring music to repressed souls who didn't have any instruments until we donated some from the School of Music because music is against the law - a gentleman had been using a Trombone which was decrepit to say the least as he'd had to bury it under his house for fear of the Taliban discovering it. Is it then fair to remove a free service from the countries where we hold our music (apparently) in high regard? My Mum and Dad were not claiming benefits but with everything else they had to provide I would have probably had to take the hit of not having musical tuition if we'd had to... My Dad (like many other parents had to work many hours of overtime so that my sister and I could have the things we wanted (neither of us flashy just to add). I didn't have a clue what I wanted to do with my life after school but when music came along I went with it and knew that it was all I wanted to (and to be fair at the time could) do. Please rethink this. 30482018-05-31T10:17:57.87336144Andrew McGarvaScotland has a rich heritage of producing some of the most talented musicians - many of whom would never have been able to access lessons if there were charges. This is too important to be ignored - our culture is identified through our music. 30482018-05-31T11:25:35.97736145Anna LudwigI am a certified music therapist. Without my free instrumental lessons at Biggar High School throughout the 1980s I would not be where I am today and life would be considerably less interesting.30482018-05-31T11:41:08.45336146Orlaith PayneThe ability to play an instrument, to read a piece of music and to understand the meaning behind a piece of music is vital to a child's learning and cannot be removed from school. 30482018-05-31T11:58:38.64336147robert cairnsYou have my support in any way to stop work around or near Culloden Battlefield.30032018-05-31T12:15:24.6436148Heather Edward HendersonAll Scottish Heritage should be protected even if the cost is high.30032018-05-31T12:27:56.70336149Jill AndrewWithout instrumental tuition at school in P&K I'd never have had so many opportunities. playing with PYO and Perthshire Brass opened up a whole new world to me and helped me both musically and also in so many other ways by boosting my confidence and affording me opportunities to see places and meet people I'd never have met otherwise. I made friends for life. I still play and help run a community orchestra in Edinburgh. I doubt we'd exist if it weren't for the opportunities free music tuition gave me and others.30482018-05-31T12:38:19.48736150Matthew DonnachieIt really is becoming shameful that the general public are forced to object to quite obviously wrong decisions over building on sites corrupting our national heritage 30032018-05-31T14:25:12.72736151Lindsey PatrickA member of my family suffers from this and has gone since she turned 12 Scotland do not have virtual education and we were put through the mill where officials did not believe her condition so much more needs fonexto help 30502018-05-31T14:30:21.3736152Ellen BogieMusic was the thing that made me equal despite my physical disabilities. This opportunity should the right of all children 30482018-05-31T14:30:41.1236153Suzanne RitchieThe benefits of playing and performing music - for mental health, confidence, friendships, skills development, mental dexterity - should not be the reserve of those who can afford it.30482018-05-31T14:33:46.9336154donna close..informed choice...\r\nwhen parents and families have their human rights removed by a gov then we will demand an inquiry\r\nwhy..37yrs in nhs practised as mho and a named person.. you ignorance and arrogance towards families has not only broke families but cause distress and harm30142018-05-31T15:07:11.70336155Mairi MacKinnon This is a site of huge historical importance and should be protected at all costs!30032018-05-31T15:56:39.53736156Gavin DuffyCreative industries are becoming more and more important as automation grows.30482018-05-31T16:31:28.6236157Michael MarcinczakWe saw the fields in 2006 ... a wonderful journey in Scotland ... These historical important places should be protected. 30032018-05-31T16:57:42.48336158Flora AlexanderA friend's daughter, in Scotland, is suffering from ME.30502018-05-31T17:04:20.5336159Anne Kinnell Wilson We cannot afford to allow access to music tuition to become an elitist privilege when it should be a fundamental right and need for all Children. \r\nFOR THE MANY NOT THE FEW!30482018-05-31T17:10:07.30336160Kevin DobieMusic is essential and should be valued far more highly30482018-05-31T17:19:36.81336161Patricia BrownI've suffered from M.E. over the past 25 yrs.30502018-05-31T17:38:43.35736162Rebecca SearsCure ME. I've suffered this for over 60 yrs.30502018-05-31T17:41:15.11336163Cole StewartEvery child or young person should be allowed the opportunity to learn an instrument.30482018-05-31T17:51:55.21736164David WortonGovernment can ramble on about equity all they like, let's see some action rather than pointless equity funds.30482018-05-31T18:05:31.64336165Georgina Thacker In a society where we are recognising mental health issues for children, we must hold on to the areas where children develop self esteem, music is proven to help with mental health and this will help in the long term for other services.30482018-05-31T18:32:25.02736167Val CooperThe ability to learn to play a musical instrument should be available to all children, regardless of financial status. Music promotes amongst other attributes, patience, passion, commitment, team building and confidence in our children, key skills for a well balanced adult life.30482018-05-31T18:52:36.39736168Iain lambieMusic, releases tension, uplifts body and mind and needs to taught and widely available to support relaxation, stress relief and depression for children in an ever more stressful and expectant society. What next? Remove physical education?30482018-05-31T19:10:59.05736169Eric WilsonAs a retired Adviser in Music, Dumfries and Galloway, I am shocked and saddened that the present generation of children are being so disadvantaged compared to those of their elder brothers and sisters. In Wigtownshire alone we could form orchestras, bands, chamber groups, etc.Now we are down to one lady teaching brass.What has become of our proud musical tradition. I do hope this petition will not fall on deaf ears!30482018-05-31T19:14:08.46336170Morag HunterAs a retired primary teacher I saw how important music was to my pupils in giving them confidence and sheer joy.30482018-05-31T19:15:32.3236171Morag HunterAs a retired primary teacher I saw how important music was to my pupils in giving them confidence and sheer joy.30482018-05-31T19:28:09.45736172Lucinda ByattThis is an essential and long-overdue review into the funding of research into ME which offers the chance for Scotland to become a beacon of excellence in this field. It is also an opportunity to increase specialist care and support for those affected. 30502018-05-31T19:45:06.9536173Louise LenaghanMusic is in our core. Everyone should be able to experience and appreciate music in all forms including musical instruments. 30482018-05-31T19:56:32.87336174James Douglas Clark Both my children have greatly benefited from music tuition. I've been very lucky to have been able to afford this but money should not be a deciding factor as to whether a child has the opportunity to learn a musical instrument 30482018-05-31T20:09:07.0436176Marisa Giannasi The creative arts cannot become an elitist subject and this decision will make it so. Music and art has been a healthy outlet for young people for years. Not only that but leads to jobs in many fulfilling creative fields. This is not the industrial revolution, we are able to support music and art. It is disappointing to think that an emphasis on STEM subjects (which is commendable) should be at the expense of something so important. 30482018-05-31T20:10:37.60336177Marisa Giannasi The creative arts cannot become an elitist subject and this decision will make it so. Music and art has been a healthy outlet for young people for years. Not only that but leads to jobs in many fulfilling creative fields. This is not the industrial revolution, we are able to support music and art. It is disappointing to think that an emphasis on STEM subjects (which is commendable) should be at the expense of something so important. 30482018-05-31T20:21:38.94736178Carol GuthrieThe music instructors at my school do more than just teach music to the children- they bring joy, nurture hidden talents, build confidence as well. Parents of my pupils have said that they will not be able to afford to pay tuition fees and that they will withdraw their children from lessons when fees commence. Those losing in poverty have the most to lose here.30482018-05-31T20:29:48.71336179Leanne Kennedy-BinghamNo parent should have to go through the unthinkable however sadly until further research answers the question of why our children die we should make it as easy as possible for bereaved parents to begin to grieve. Paying for a child's funeral is an added stress that no parent should have to deal with on top of the trauma of the death of their child. We thankfully did not have to deal with this though others I know have. My family and I give our full support to Michael McGuire with this petition30472018-05-31T20:36:57.9936180Lynne PrydeTotal disgrace that there are charges for children to learn to play a musical instrument. Music should be free for all!30482018-05-31T20:40:25.35736181Jacqueline KayOur children have a right to music education. NO to music cuts.30482018-05-31T20:43:21.01336182Kelly Anderson Music is vital, it enhances a child's learning. It teaches them to read another language which is universally used. It should be encouraged and enjoyed by all. 30482018-05-31T20:43:56.93736183Derek Manson-SmithMy son received free tuition and the loan of a cello at his state primary school in the 1980s, which he continues to benefit from.30482018-05-31T20:50:03.0636184Andrew DickieThe current state of affairs is nothing short of appalling and I believe if anything meaningful is to come of this, music tuition must be removed from the control of local authorities altogether. Constant funding threats and the downwards trajectory of provision in terms of equity has decimated services throughout the country and the relentless blame game between LA and government is neither dignified nor productive. If we in Scotland deem the equitable provision of the opportunity to play an instrument without financial penalty important, then we must pay for it - indeed we need to evaluate and quantify the positive impacts widely quoted. Parents need to galvanise across the country to lobby for this provision not only to be free but actually extended beyond its receding fringes..30482018-05-31T21:03:03.13336185Marilyn Rutastop to destroy your heritage!\r\nit's a shame and it's totally disrespectul for Scottish history30032018-05-31T21:03:22.6536186Donna McLachlanScottish Heritage sites should be protected without question30032018-05-31T21:24:02.48736188Dennis Hamilton No child should be financially excluded from this unique form of self-expression. Free for all who wish to explore their musical talents and appreciation.30482018-05-31T21:42:26.8136191Joseph TaylorMusic is important for everybody30482018-05-31T21:43:56.64736192Kayleigh Bohan This is horrific - please don't make music the sole right of those who can afford it. I was lucky enough to have free music tuition at school and it was hugely important to my confidence, social skills and public speaking and presenting. It was also a lot of fun and made me less afraid of taking risks later. This is reinforcing inequality in a massive way. 30482018-05-31T21:58:33.20336193Alexander BuchananI have a musical background because tuition was free and this has been a very important part of my life.30482018-05-31T22:03:25.1836194Katrina EvansI have suffered ME for nearly 5 years. It has affected my whole life. 30502018-05-31T22:07:08.2936195Catherine WoodwardAll music should be free for everyone! 30482018-05-31T22:25:16.1236196Ayse BakI'm a teacher, and feel strongly this is so wrong, to many cuts in the wrong areas and in education. 30482018-05-31T22:28:57.56736197Stephen BrennanI had brass lessons at school, and it inspired a life-long passion for music, including a decade singing with the RSNO chorus. I really believe this should be available to my own children and all others.30482018-05-31T22:31:34.3136198Ann McGuiganDon't let this brilliant opportunity only be available to kids whose parents can afford it.30482018-05-31T22:40:01.34336199Paul HewittUtterly disgusting that the big boys think they can build on a site that blood was spilled on. It's a war grave. Consider abandoning this crazy idea!30032018-05-31T22:40:30.9636200Tammy CooperSave our History!30032018-05-31T22:43:18.45336201Paul HewittDisgusting that the big boys think they can build on a site that is more or less a war grave. Consider abandoning such an idea. Absolute madness!30032018-05-31T22:52:38.38336202Catherine CalderMusic instrumental tuition should be free to all pupils and not just be available to the wealthier families. The SNP keep telling us they introduced free education for all so how can that be when they are responsible for the decimation of this educational service. Hang your heads in shame!30482018-05-31T22:55:22.58736203Maggie FernieAll children must be given the opportunity to experience music tuition. 30482018-05-31T22:56:31.436204Jilly Burns Music lessons and the opportunity to play on school bands underpinned my entire school experience and achievements and made me who I am today.. you30482018-05-31T23:05:17.50336205Barbara StuartMusic has a beneficial effect on both the musician and the audience. Apart from that children learn a lot of other things apart from learning to play an instrument.30482018-05-31T23:07:07.9336206Ann Edmonds Music is vital to the wellbeing of all, to the cultural landscape of our country and to deny children access to being taught music is disastrous. 30482018-05-31T23:24:15.03736208Caroline WilsonIf we wish to be an innovative, creative country, we need children who can think and function via many different modes of communication and use their brains in many multi-faceted ways. Music helps to embed these things, improving academic learning in other areas and improving mental and emotional wellbeing. We as a nation need to be at the forefront of education.30482018-05-31T23:34:07.50736209Tila MorrisMusic tuition is precisely what every child in Scotland needs as part of closing the attainment gap. Removing music tuition is like publicly advertising a belief that music is only for the privileged and the wealthy. Scotland has a rich heritage of music and access to tuition. We should cherish this with pride and recognise it's value in all asepcts of learning including language, reasoning, memory, coordination and health and wellbeing. Save music tuition in our schools.30482018-05-31T23:37:38.57736210Linda Beveridge Signed for the sake of my children and the future of music...learning to play intruments has had such a positive effect on my life, many years after leaving school. 30482018-05-31T23:37:53.22736211Kirsteen wrightPlease start understanding the need for the arts in general for all.30482018-05-31T23:44:23.47736212Lyn Marshall As a parent of a child who received free brass tuition at secondary school and who 15 years later still plays in an award achieving brass band this tuition was crucial. The legacy of removing the free tuition will have repercussions in generations of the future! 30482018-05-31T23:46:29.97736213Eilidh ClementsI have had M.E. for the past 8 years and have lost my twenties. My potential has been wasted because I am living with an incurable illness. There are over 20,000 people with ME in Scotland. I am aware that £90,000 has been invested by the Scottish government towards research and that cuts mean that difficult decisions have to be made in regards to spending. However I have to be worth more than £4.50! ME has to be understood and cured and there needs to be more investment to do this. I deserve a better quality of life than what I have just now. I want to be a part of and contribute towards scottish society. I want my life back. 30502018-05-31T23:54:29.1536214Julia McGroryIt is not just about learning to play an instrument when a child takes music lessons. They learn so much more along side that skill, focus, concentration, listening skills, teamwork and confidence to name but a few. By restricting access to music lessons by adding a financial cost that some parents may not be able to meet, may deprive a child of the opportunity to learn those skills that enable them to meet their full potential. 30482018-05-31T23:58:30.4336215Angela Morlotti It is important that pupils have the choice to learn how to play musical instruments at school.30482018-06-01T00:23:58.71736217Katherine SchofieldHaving a child in Clackmannanshire schools, the cost increase is unaffordable and will be devastating to the music service. Whilst I understand pressure on public sector funding, it is foolishness to make music unaffordable. The evidence of benefits to children are strong 30482018-06-01T00:36:03.1736218Margaret SmithThe arts are equally important as STEM subjects. Music tuition should not just be for those who can afford to pay 30482018-06-01T00:51:27.47736219Mai LawrenceThe creative arts are an essential part of a child's education both academically and emotionally. In the present climate of soaring mental health problems among young people we should recognise the benefits of musical participation in all forms. 30482018-06-01T01:11:12.3336220Andrew DuncanIt's imperative that Scottish battlefield sites are preserved for the education of future generations. We cannot allow further desecration of battlefields to happen. The development at Culloden being allowed to go ahead was a disgrace - and we can never let anything like this happen ever again...30032018-06-01T02:55:38.30736221Robin ChristDestroying historical battlefields is a crime in itself. They need to be preserved to educate the future generations so nothing like that ever happens again. It's sacred ground!30032018-06-01T02:55:40.436222Diana TaylorThe arts, and music in particular, play a very important part in a childs education. More free lessons should be made available not less.30482018-06-01T03:55:39.28736223Donald McVicarMusic is classless and can be inspirational for all types of children30482018-06-01T04:20:19.38336224Emma NewtonState education is supposed to be free and CfE is supposed to offer young people a wide range of outcomes and experiences. At present, the government is simply not fulfilling this commitment. Having such an elitist policy, where money rather than talent drives decision making is unfair, and also rather short-sighted. We only need to look to the arts funding in rising economies such as Venezuela to see the massive impact instrumental tuition can have on quality of life and learning. To develop our young people within the four capacities, change is needed now! 30482018-06-01T04:31:16.88336225Alan MarshallThis is such sad news! Expressive Arts in all forms provide children, who perhaps are not always academic, an opportunity to shine. To find their voice. To celebrate their talents and skills. To take this opportunity away or limit it somehow is just incredibly sad and fails children. Education should help children find their talents, whatever that may be, and nurture them. 30482018-06-01T06:43:28.19736227Ellen Larson Davidson I am grateful for the music lessons I received growing up at my school in USA (small rural school district) where most pupils were in the school band. Music is important to learning and life. 30482018-06-01T06:47:25.82336228Diana ReevesAll three of my children have gained immensely from their music tuition received in school. It has given them confidence to perform and has shaped their lives by allowing them to become the people they are today. No other area of the curriculum could have supported my previously shy and timid children to overcome their fears in this way and to become the happy, music-led and confident people they are today. It is unlikely they would have been able to take part if there had been a charge for this tuition.30482018-06-01T06:55:07.57336230Janie ScottMy child plays cello at school and goes to a school within an area of deprivation. I am very aware of the small numbers learning an instrument and I believe that it is currently completely out of reach for the majority of families. This does not sit well with me and it seems to me that only the middle class children get this opportunity. When I was at school everyone got a chance to try regardless of income. Opportunity needs to be given to all to learn an instrument and not just those who can afford it. 30482018-06-01T07:27:50.8336231Gemma LittleI was thought basis guitar and it was the best experience throughout my high school life, away from books and numbers. No child should be disadvantaged or miss out on the opportunity to learn an instrument because of their financial background. 30482018-06-01T07:51:46.53336232Amanda MacQuarrie The wonder and joy of playing music is something all children deserve to have access to, not just those whose parents can afford it!30482018-06-01T07:59:49.5236233S ClemsonMusic has been proven to be one of the few things that uses many different areas of the brain, so is a valuable asset to help children with learning in general. Not all children are academic, some are creative, some have technical skills etc. Also this means children who may be gifted but whose parents can't afford music tuition will miss out and a talented person who could be successful will miss the opportunity. All children should be equal, and given the same opportunity regardless of their home situation. Music is also therapeutic for many and can help emotionally and mentally. 30482018-06-01T08:09:04.27336234Anna Quinn CooperPlaying a musical instrument gives young people a way too express themselves in a different way.By being able to learn an instrument young people can develop not only their musical skills but their confidence. 30482018-06-01T08:09:25.92736235Ashley BrandonI would never have been able to study at RCS if I did not have the free tuition to get me on the starting blocks, this opportunity should be available to all future generations30482018-06-01T08:14:00.36736236Sarah PatersonThe benefits to children (and therefore to our society) of learning to play an instrument are many and varied. Confidence, self esteem, social skills etc and it music has been shown to increase attainment in general. It is such a life skill. It should be available to all, not only those who can easily afford it. So much talent will go undiscovered and so much joy will be missed without access to free tuition. A reduction in children playing would in time mean a reduced service and lack of orchestras.30482018-06-01T08:39:31.8736237Evelyn Irvine Music tuition is so important to the cultural futures of Scotland and should be freely available to all children 30482018-06-01T08:42:12.13336238Alison NobleThis is a most important cause. Everyone loves music, young and old30482018-06-01T08:47:52.9236239Margaret RobertsonMusic in its general form, of any genre, has been proven over and over again to give so many benefits to health and wellbeing. In traditional music, Scotland has its own world music giving identity to our culture and heritage and therefore to us as a nation. This should be championed, nurtured, protected and encouraged for free at every turn! 30482018-06-01T09:03:34.09336240Karen KellyMy Kids get so much out of their instruments and I can barely afford the tuition for both. I certainly could not afford to pay for private lesson. Free lessons would ensure Inclusion.30482018-06-01T09:08:36.88736241YVONNE FADDESChildren should have free tuition 30482018-06-01T09:22:44.81336242Madeline SpokesScotland has always been a country of musicians. We currently have an extreme lack of teachers and need investment to train more teachers to be able to teach a new generation of musicians.30482018-06-01T09:24:00.6136243Molly McGaviganI taught in secondary schools in Scotland (not a music teacher). I saw what great benefits music tuition brought to pupils and how the performances and achievements impacted very positively across the school. This was particularly true for those pupils who were not considered "high achievers". A very backward step to cut back on free tuition. Please do not do this.30482018-06-01T09:44:08.15736244Marjorie WhiteHistoric Battlefield sites are war graves to be respected.......not building sites.30032018-06-01T09:58:23.75736245Paula Wilson My son has recently started playing Violin. As a low income family we have been fortunate that this year we were able to get funding from a charity to pay for his lessons. However as our council have plans to increase his lessons astronomically over the next 3 years to over £800 there will be higher demand for funding so less people will be able to receive it. Some children are not as able academically and arts are a way for them to learn and feel included, so cutting music, drama and art classes is really not getting it right for every child, is it?30482018-06-01T10:06:51.47336246Brendon McQueenScottish History and sites of historical importance should be protected especially those considered war graves30032018-06-01T10:07:21.47336247Marjory McGhieWith the current mental health issues in young people it is essential to increase the opportunities for learning how to play a musical instrument. 30482018-06-01T10:11:37.0736248Sharon OllisMusic tuition enables children to access something they may never have been able to outwith school.It gives them many opportunities to progress and become involved in the wider musical world. I would be greatly disappointed if this service was withdrawn. It would be much more accessable if it were free. One child in my class could not participate as her parents could not afford it. What a waste of talent!30482018-06-01T10:13:27.61736249Annette JohnstoneBenefits children in so many ways, building confidence, opportunities to travel and meet people. Both of my daughter's played in school bands and if it wasn't for free tuition these opportunities wouldn't exist.30482018-06-01T10:25:41.21336251Maura LeeMusic tuition was provided to me as a child and I am glad it was possible. I believe music can only enhance and improve a child's life.30482018-06-01T11:13:42.0336252Michelle Macpherson As a child who benefited from musical tuition in school i would love it still to be available for my children! \r\n\r\nI gained so much from it. Ability knowledge confidence xxx 30482018-06-01T11:35:32.44336253Marti MorrisonOnly in Scotland would such audacious plans see the light of day. For way to long now, those who seek gold has dictated our Nations path rather than what is best for us all30032018-06-01T12:06:20.9536254Fiona CampbellWould also like to see that the instrumental services offer a full range of musical styles - folk, jazz, classical, rock and pop as you get benefit from all of them!30482018-06-01T13:22:14.54736256Anita Napier On this land, and it's surroundings, lie the final resting place of the fallen after the battle of Culloden. Under no circumstances should any war grave be disturbed, disrupted or moved. This our National Heritage and has a major place in Scotlands history. Any attempt to change this should be dismissed with all speed and authority30032018-06-01T13:51:25.436257James McKenna A total of £90.2m is being invested into Stirling and Clackmannanshire by the Scottish and UK governments.\r\n\r\nThe £45.1m from each government is part of the City Region Deals, which are designed to drive economic growth.\r\n\r\nThe investment will support a new International Environment Centre and a new Aquaculture Innovation Hub.\r\n\r\nIt will also help develop tourism and culture, and fund a £2m digital district and the creation of digital hubs in Callander and Alloa.\r\n\r\nThe Scottish government also announced an extra £5m of funding to deliver a new business park at Kildean and to support the next stage of development of proposed new infrastructure at Callander.\r\n30482018-06-01T13:57:18.63736258Kerrie KeenAll children deserve the chance to receive musical instrument lessons free of charge. To exclude children from poorer households is not right. GIRFEC should apply to every child, not just the ones who have money30482018-06-01T15:17:14.17736259Darren YoungHow can we GIRFEC by putting up barriers to education? How can we ensure equity for ALL young people, regardless of their circumstances? So many young people are going to miss out and the skills and confidence they will gain will be lost.30482018-06-01T15:33:58.59736261Ewing LauderAs a violin I now despair at the cultural wasteland that the UK has become. In my experience, classroom music has become music appreciation coupled with an endless procession of X Factor wannabes strumming basic guitar or finding a few simple piano chords. How have we arrived at such a state where 80,000 people turn up to to Wembley to watch a guy strum an acoustic and Noel Gallagher is the self appointed barometer of musical taste in the UK. We need to show our children that there is so much. much more to music.30482018-06-01T16:11:44.35736262Maggie aitkenA confident and successful culture is one that recognises the benefits of music and arts generlly in economic social and personal bases.30482018-06-01T16:19:12.85736263Betsy BarkerI was a music specialist...all music should return to all Scottish schools30482018-06-01T16:20:17.1736264Betsy BarkerNothing more important than music in the world...every child deserves the chance to sing and play.30482018-06-01T16:21:3636265Anne CochraneMusic is a wonderful gift to offer a child and helps with so many other subjects.30482018-06-01T16:32:23.74736266Leigh WoodI believe in getting it right for every child and closing the attainment gap, I feel this does neither of these things and makes music an exclusive for those who can afford it. 30482018-06-01T16:42:11.23736267Stephanie Gaffney Pupils need positive ways to explore their creativity. Learning an instrument can provide focus, drive, develops discipline and allows pupils to experience success. They can develop a host of transferrible skills through solo performance and performing with others. Music can also help with young people's mental wellbeing. I am a teacher within NLC. I studied music at school under hugely talented and inspiring tutors. I want all my kids to have the same opportunity to explore music as they do sports and core subjects. 30482018-06-01T16:49:33.6636268Ian GariochI learned to play piano (badly) when I was 45 years old - much too late. It has given me endless hours of joy. Children should learn to play a musical instrument - it gives them pleasure for the rest of their lives.30482018-06-01T17:22:52.58336269Frances CampbellThis would be fab. I would also call for the EIS to ban Scottish schools to take in private music instructors, especially when the local authorities have an music instrumental service. Instrumental instructors should be equal to other teachers and be enrolled into the GTCS.30482018-06-01T17:33:12.0136270Deb MurphyThe men that lie beneath the ground of any battlefield have given the ultimate sacrifice to their country. It should always be considered hallowed ground. 30032018-06-01T18:22:36.0636271Alissa SymeI am saddened that we have to fight for something that all children should have access to. The benefits are immeasurable and it sickens me to think this is going to be taken from them 30482018-06-01T19:13:25.81736273Senga Dunn This is a valuable service and must be kept. 30482018-06-01T19:25:49.80736274Denise YoungDeserves support30482018-06-01T20:33:48.2536276Mrs. Elspeth McDonaldOnly wealthy families will be able to afford tuition. Children in Scotland being deprived again. 30482018-06-01T20:41:50.00336277Kerry McKinlayI would not have the current life that I value more than anything were it not for children having the right to free instrumental tuition. 30482018-06-01T20:44:24.92736278Palma AllanArticle 12 UNCRC Education. Children's participation takes on a special dimension in the area of education. \r\nEducation should give children the opportunity to develop their talents and abilities to full. It should not cost money as this discriminates against families who cannot afford it.30482018-06-01T20:56:29.37736279Mrs. Elspeth McDonaldChildren from poorer families are once again being deprived of an essential part of their education. It will take us back to only the wealthy can have a musical education and a musical instrument.30482018-06-01T21:00:35.64336280Mr vincent mcdonaldMusical education, musical instruments and tuition should not only available to better off families. Scottish children deserve better. 30482018-06-01T21:22:12.5736281Dale FinlaysonAccess to music tuition should not depend upon ability to pay for it. Nor should it be an "extra" or alternative to the core curriculum - it should be part of it. 30482018-06-01T21:36:14.2636283Sandy McIntosh Music must continue to be in the curriculum for excellence 30482018-06-01T22:35:29.1936284Iben McMillanI feel music is a very important part of everyones life whether they can read music or just listen to it. I feel that children gain great intelligence whilst learning to understand a musical instrument as there is so much to learn. I believe every child should have a chance to learn an instrument as a talent like this should never have to be hidden because of money.30482018-06-01T22:52:55.8236285Lorna McGheeScotland should be proud of providing free music education and instrumental lessons. We cannot allow it to be turned into a privilege for well-off families only. Think of the success of the El Sistema program, in terms of the social welfare of children, as well as their musical skills. I am grateful for the start I received in both academic and instrumental music at Largs Academy, Ayrshire. Thanks to the musical education that was available to me at an early age, I am now principal flute in the Pittsburgh Symphony, USA. Please keep music accessible for all of Scotland's school children! To do any less betrays Scotland's egalitarian heritage, which is a beacon to the world. 30482018-06-01T23:08:57.52336286Laura CondieI was lucky enough to receive musical tuition throughout primary and secondary school. This was not only about learning to read music and play the instruments, it was about learning to interact with others and being part of a team. These are invaluable lessons for all children, and music touches everyone. Try watching a film without the soundtrack- loses everything. I made friends for life through my music educational experience, and whilst I did not pursue it as a career I could have, and many of my peers did and they are now the educators of the future generations. This would not have been possible if it was not a free service. Are you going to distinguish other extracurricular activities, eg sport, art, drama? Ridiculous that music is being targeted.30482018-06-01T23:24:57.99336288Nigel MunisamyI benefitted from this and had a complete career as a tax paying musician30482018-06-01T23:28:29.18336289Mark NolanThis is absolutely essential to preserve Scotlands Musical heritage and its world leading reputation Thank you30482018-06-02T09:00:30.30336291Avril Evans Keep music lessons free the benefits for everyone are real and important. Life is so stressful for so\r\nMany nowadays this is one way to keep lives happy 30482018-06-02T09:14:10.27336292Francis CummingsGiving children access to good quality music education and the experiences that inevitably follow is one of the most life-enriching gifts we can bequeath to the next generation. 30482018-06-02T09:23:33.27336293Ciara BradyMy local area has charged for lessons for several years, however I am originally from South Ayrshire, and have signed their petition to prevent the fees there. Would be delighted if we could in fact have fees abolished across all of Scotland! 30482018-06-02T09:25:31.1836294Lesley NicollTuition should definitely be free to schoolchildren30482018-06-02T09:25:44.37336295Alison KemiIt should be available to all children regardless of their background. 30482018-06-02T09:34:18.2536296Annette JohnstoneChildren from all back grounds should have access to free musical instruments, not just the privileged few. 30482018-06-02T09:45:20.60736297Lynn Meldrum Music changes lives. Gimlet children keep changing their lives for the better30482018-06-02T10:06:52.64736298Stuart McKinnellMusic tuition should be maintained as part of school tuition 30482018-06-02T10:08:15.29736299Leslie Katharine ThomsonAll children, regardless of their parents' ability to pay, deserve the oportunity to learn a musical instrument. I was lucky because my parents could afford piano lessons for me. I want that for all children. 30482018-06-02T10:14:02.26736300Katharine ThomsonAll children regardless of their parents ability to pay should have the oportunity to learn a musical instrument. I was lucky because my parents could afford my piano lessons. All children should be able to explore the world of music that has meant so.much to me for all of my life. 30482018-06-02T11:20:39.76736301Sophie McewanWithout free instrument tuition I wouldn't have done so well in my music exams or have been as prepared as I was with the lessons for my exam. If I had to pay I wouldn't have done anywhere as well as I have with my music as my family wouldn't have been able to afford lessons for me. They should be free so all children who want to can have lessons as music has a large impact on children and teens and playing an instrament can help with stress and anxiety. I say this as a teen who studied music all through high school and someone who is studying childcare and knows just how amazing music can be. Playing an instrument was an escape for me during my exams and helped me reduce my stress and anxiety levels.30482018-06-02T12:07:48.19336302June hawthorneEverything I know about music came from my primary school music teacher... and I know a lot! I think all kids benefit from having music in their lives from an early age... it should be s right, not a privilege or postcode lottery!30482018-06-02T14:10:06.86736303Colin WrightFor many kids music is as important, if not more so, than history or PE. 30482018-06-02T15:31:04.9736304Elizabeth Muir free education my foot. what about the young talented musical children .a disgusted tax payer 30482018-06-02T15:56:56.86736305Vari Higgins I loved learning music at school, it gave me lots of joy and taught me about the importance of practising at something to improve upon that skill and also determination to get things right. Music is a very important release from the everyday stresses of life and access to it should not be determined by the wealth of the family. 30482018-06-02T16:14:18.19736307P BrylkaMusic tuition can be costly and with people's varying circumstances and financial situations, it's not always possible to provide this opportunity for your children. What a shame where there is a natural talent or real passion for music that can't be developed because of cost. 30482018-06-02T16:42:58.70336308Daniel Suleyman BolatFree music tuition would be life changing30482018-06-02T17:12:46.1636309Mary MuirMusic often brings out the best in our young people.30482018-06-02T17:24:52.14736310Craig vickeryMusic is interlinked with many meta skills. Teamwork, communication and commitment as well as others 30482018-06-02T18:44:21.79336311Rabea McGhieAll children deserve the chance to learn an instrument free of charge. To exclude children from poorer households is not right. 30482018-06-02T18:46:03.736312Alex McGhieAll children should have the chance to learn an instrument, regardless of their background!30482018-06-02T19:13:56.19336313Reginald ShortHaving been taught to read music and play keyboards as a child I recognize the enjoyment this has enabled me to have from music throughout life and I wish for all to have this opportunity.30482018-06-02T19:16:58.4936314Marion ShortOur son has continued to enjoy making music ever since receiving tuition on tenor horn in primary school.30482018-06-02T19:26:38.7736315Debbie ClunessPlease do not it iswrong on too many levels. It is a therapy for many and a route to a better life. Please do not30482018-06-02T19:37:58.2636316Suzi HunterWhy is this even being questioned. A wonderful opportunity for children and young people to learn,improve and enjoy Music..Every child should be offered. Proven to enhance Health & well-being in people. Great talent to have.GIRFEC. Are we really doing the best for every child.\r\nMake the MUSIC instruction RIGHT FOR EVERY CHILD 30482018-06-02T20:53:16.67736317chris mccoytheres plenty of places to build unnaffordable housing so why choose a historic battlefield where dead people are, its plain disrespectful30032018-06-02T21:06:45.7636318Willie HunterHaving been a part of brass banding for nearly 40 years, where free tuition was for everyone. You develop as a musician but also as a person. I've met lots of great friends throughout the years and played in fantastic bands. To compete in the national finals for your country is amazing. Just like sports but funding is more available than what is given to the arts. Free tuition for kids of all backgrounds should be offered at all times. Whether this petition falls on deaf ears but with the amount of people i know that will sign this and share, should hopefully give food for thought. Do the right thing for future generations of musicians and allow free tuition.30482018-06-02T21:20:35.3236320Susan Saunders For some kids this is a lifeline for social development.....disgusting that it is not going to be provided free of charge 30482018-06-02T21:31:10.3236321Alison SinclairMusic tuition should be free and administered through the education system and not Highlife as The Highland Council have moved to. There should be musical and cultural elements within the educational offering. 30482018-06-02T21:56:40.13736322Peter ThorntonThere's currently no uniformity of provision or charging across Scotland's local authorities. The young people of the country deserve equality of access. The benefits of learning to play an instrument extend far beyond just the acquisition of musical skills and last a lifetime. If Sistema Scotland is so valuable and beneficial, why isn't it freely available to all?30482018-06-02T22:22:57.25736323Ceridwen HeaneySo sad to see what's happening. We should be providing as many opportunities as possible to kids. Music has huge value - I hope this trend can be reversed.30482018-06-02T23:06:19.80736324Gillian BallMy daughter started music lessons only this academic year and is really showing promise. Without free lessons that potential will be lost as we cannot afford to pay for these lessons. Music should be free for all not just those on benefits30482018-06-02T23:24:19.40336325Elizabeth SutherlandNo child should be deprived of a chance to study an instrument simply because they cannot afford it30482018-06-03T10:42:16.46736328Robyn MacKenzieAll childrens right to have access to music. It is so good for them\r\n30482018-06-03T11:53:26.52336329Colin CluerOur kids should be entitled to education to further all their talents and potentials . This is the thin end of a wedge . 30482018-06-03T14:14:07.93336331Bernadette O'HareMy children were lucky enough to have free music tuition & learned to play 2 or 3 instruments each - this is a wonderful interest for young people30482018-06-03T14:42:27.2836332Valerie BairdLearning the violin free of charge as a child taught me to love and enjoy music throughout my life. Coming back to the violin in old age is a joy.30482018-06-03T15:10:12.45736333Geoff Colemanmusic tuition should be a core part of the curriculum, just as sports such as football are. It is iniquitous to consider charging for tuition in a subject that helps people contri8bute to the cultural life of the country.30482018-06-03T15:44:37.63336334Mary McKenzieThis gives children who might not have the chance to know if they are capable of being a musician.30482018-06-03T15:58:44.66736336Janice Galloway Music is one of the most important subjects a child can experience have for the development of strong bonds and collegiality. It bonds human beings. 30482018-06-03T16:11:23.52736337Gill McGowanMusic is such an important part of my life and I owe it all to the skills I learned at school learning to play the saxophone. It taught me to read music, work as a team in a band and developed great lung capacity so it gave me physical fitness too! I would never have been able to afford weekly lessons from P6 to the end of my high school education and I managed to achieve Grade 6 performance due to these lessons. Everyone should have the right to this type of education which has given me such joy and provided me with many skills others in my career path don't have, allowing me to book more work. It's imperative that free lessons continue for children. 30482018-06-03T19:10:30.14736338Morag DuffyMusic should be available at all levels in all schools it is proved to improve well being confidence and self esteem and it is fun.30482018-06-03T21:26:53.36736341Ruth JenningsWhen GIRFEC was first introduced, different people were claiming themselves as named person. A health visitor, GP and nursery head all claimed to be the point of contact. It was total chaos for our family! We were voluntarily involved with Social Services as we needed support and all they did was make us out to be bad parents and interfered in our lives (they later had to apologise and compensate us). We had a health visitor who said she was named person and made comments like "Why is your son wearing odd socks?". Suffice to say they were never allowed into our lives ever again. 30142018-06-03T22:00:44.51336342Christy Salter This is hallowed ground and the resting place of those who fought for their county. Stop developing 30032018-06-03T22:13:05.23336344Annemarie DunbarHow can you possibly condone desecrating Cullodon Battlefield ?! #dotherightthing30032018-06-03T22:16:44.57736345Sonya McNaughtonThis battlefield and the brave men buried there needs to be respected and left untouched. 30032018-06-03T22:31:24.14336346Gaul Ann StuartPlease do not let them take this symbol of pride be taken away. We are in awe our ancestors who fought bled and died on many Scottish battlefields. Please preserve them. 30032018-06-03T22:38:13.03336347Catherine LiderthDon't destroy an important part of our history.30032018-06-03T23:09:23.7436350Theresa GarrisonPlease consider the timeless history that this battlefield illustrates. People all over the world visit Culloden Battefield to feel Scottish history. 30032018-06-03T23:12:11.47736351S Cheatwood - Pybas I can't imagine why this would be a good idea. There should be an established buffer area to stop encroaching. Families deserve access to loved ones and time to remember 30032018-06-03T23:12:40.19336352Heather carlsonThis is a sacred place for those fallen to be mourned. Please to not desecrate this sacred ground for unnecessary development. As a visitor, I want to honor and respect your history not see it destroyed.30032018-06-03T23:15:30.0736353Pamela VogtSave Culloden Battlefield for the dead30032018-06-03T23:31:47.1536354Kenny MackenzieWhy is it always music art and pe that get targetted?\r\nFor some pupils these are the only thiings they can shine at and taking them away deprives these pupils of their only chance to succeed and feel good about themselves. Think again.30482018-06-03T23:34:21.10336355Valerie MartinellAbsolute outrage to build anything on battlefield or burial grounds. Do these developers know where their ancestors are buried?????30032018-06-04T00:23:3436356Marlise PerkinsThis should be a preserved heritage and historical site. It is, in fact, a graveyard of our ancestors, and these men all deserve to rest in peace, don't they?\r\n30032018-06-04T00:29:59.1936357Sandra BrownColloden is a sacred place - a battlefield and a graveyard. I cannot understand how anyone could consider desicrating this historic place30032018-06-04T00:37:07.37736358Ann KurtDaughter of a proud Scottish warbride & a Canadian soldier. I was "made" in Scotland when my parents wed and then born in Canada when my mom came to join him. Stop messing with my country before I get to see all of it !30032018-06-04T00:50:02.1636359Leslie C Martinof the Clan Macleod of Lewis. 30032018-06-04T01:11:53.85336360James Ian EmersonPreserving Culloden and the surrounding area that has already been determined as a historical site, portions of these Land's should not have been sold to begin with. It should be preserved and honored has the sacred grounds of our ancestors who gave their lives for freedom in Scotland.30032018-06-04T01:54:41.1736363Kari AcostaPlease do not change this historical place.30032018-06-04T02:48:43.8536365Sharron Trowbridge Culloden is your heritage . Remember the men that have fought and died for your country. This is there home now 30032018-06-04T02:54:42.5736366Melissa Newhall I am a descendent of Scots who fought at Culloden. Please save this historical land. It is hallowed ground. 30032018-06-04T04:07:27.8936367Deborah McQuerrey GowPlease keep this sacred site sacred.30032018-06-04T04:36:05.70736368Debra Cummings I agree that it is vital that legislation is laid down now before any further inappropriate developments on any battlefields as listed on the Inventory of Historic Battlefields 30032018-06-04T04:56:03.58736370Laurie Hadfield History is beautiful, sad, painful and glorious all in different ways everywhere around the world and more and more of these places are being destroyed for many different reasons. Please, please don't let this be one of them.30032018-06-04T05:15:23.80736371NADEGE MERLEAs in all countries, the duty to remember must exist. We must not forget that without these deaths during all these confrontations our present generations would not be here. Let's not forget them! And what better way to preserve these places.30032018-06-04T06:51:42.00736372Christina McFarland-HelmsCare must be taken to preserve history. History forgotten, will be repeated. Lest we forget.30032018-06-04T06:56:06.936373Elaine BoyleThe final resting place of anyone who fell in battle, no matter what battlefield, no matter what country, should be considered hallowed ground and should be forever undisturbed.30032018-06-04T07:00:19.13336374James Alexander A Nation was slaughtered here! What would it say if an SNP Government to allow this to happen? There are many other suitable sites available for development in this relatively remote area of Scotland. 30032018-06-04T07:07:29.94736375Barbara Fraser Culloden should be preserved and respected just like any other British war grave at home or abroad. 30032018-06-04T07:55:43.20336376Adrienne CurryMusic is essential to children's education and development. Too much is already being removed from school curricula!30482018-06-04T08:36:17.51336377Donna McIvorHistory should be preserved at all cost and above profit.30032018-06-04T10:28:59.14736379Holly WarrenIt is a disgrace to imagine.30032018-06-04T11:39:23.936380Patti JohnsonSo sad when the thought of money outweighs the desecration of a historic site. If the construction goes forward, may the spirits & ghosts of valiant warriors haunt the residences30032018-06-04T12:02:34.48736381Roger DavisThe long term benefits, to students and their communities, of music tuition in schools are well established, and are far greater than the short term costs. To end this free service would be a huge loss to society.30482018-06-04T12:24:41.2836382Moira GrayI believe that all school children at state schools must have a right to free music tuition and have access to the instruments - if their parents can't afford the tuition they can't afford the instruments either.30482018-06-04T12:33:49.80336383AL Ledingham Music should be available at all levels in all schools as it is ESSENTIAL to develop life long skills for our pupils. 30482018-06-04T12:51:00.71336385Diane LyonWith all the special interest groups pushing their own agenda, if we continue to give in, we will no longer have any history, pride, or self awareness. My thoughts go to all of the historical places destroyed by despots, hate and now greed. We need historical sites for our children as well as ourselves to remind us of our mistakes and victories. 30032018-06-04T12:52:12.98736386Meagan WiedmeierThis historic site should be preserved! 30032018-06-04T13:05:16.01336387Linda EarwoodAll historic sites should be preserved for future generations to learn about their history and what sacrifices were made for their country!30032018-06-04T14:44:32.17336389Matthew SampleyThere should be no development at this location unless it honors the fallen on both sides. 30032018-06-04T14:54:48.41736391Mark wilsonEssential for wholistic development30482018-06-04T14:54:55.29336392Karin Bruenggel I don't live in your beautiful Scotland, but somehow my heart is telling me that I have to go there one day. So this saving of Cullodens battlefield is very important to me. You have this magical place, where many fought and died. It has to be remembered for the futur generations! You can't build houses there! Remember, what past generations did, tell your story to your children, grand children. Make them proud of their heritage! Please! Keep those historical places save! Thank you for listening to me! 30032018-06-04T16:04:23.15336395Julie WolfHistory is a precious thing.A very delicate thing. We must do all we can to preserve it. If the future generations can't learn from previous times, they are doomed to repeat them.30032018-06-04T17:56:12.24736396Callum JohnstonPlease change this30482018-06-04T18:10:25.236397Mrs Nan KillickMusic should be free for all children, it is vital for their education.30482018-06-04T18:48:11.0536398Catherine woodcockMusic tuition is about co-ordination , problem solving , listening and co- operation with others as well as developing musical and spiritual ability - every child should have this opportunity regardless of financial background 30482018-06-04T18:53:45.76736399Peter McCalisterMusic is more important to children than most people realise30482018-06-04T18:54:42.84736400Karen BelknapPlease preserve my heritage!30032018-06-04T19:16:37.636401Teri PorterMusic is vital for development and growth 30482018-06-04T20:20:49.74736403Denise SmithIt is so wrong on every level , Parents are meant to bring up their children not governments . Just who do they think they are !!!!!\r\n30142018-06-04T20:28:06.07736404Janet McArthurNamed Person, with or without (I would say it's impossible to operate without) the illegal mining, recording and sharing of personal data without knowledge and consent is simply a vehicle by which Totalitarian States, following the One World Order agenda, may exert control over families and nations and instigate oppressive regimes. There can be no alternative to removing Named Person from the Children & Young People (Scotland) Act 2014. To allow it to remain there would imply consent. I do not consent.30142018-06-04T20:34:04.28336405Marissa Watt Children should have the right to free music in schools. Would be an utter disgrace to remove it. It would be letting down some children who are musically gifted as not all parents can afford extra costs. 30482018-06-04T21:00:50.33336407Carole withersI think this a step too far30142018-06-04T21:37:56.94736408Jai McDowall Music is Life. 30482018-06-04T21:41:36.19736409Jean DineenYou live in a country so full of history. Do not let it slip away due to commercialism. 30032018-06-04T21:45:26.24736410Matthew Duncan Invest in out children's future 30482018-06-04T22:00:20.99736411Laurie CrumpWe need it for the short and long-term health of our country!30482018-06-04T22:24:48.90736413Elizabeth Elaine DyerI have heard music festival organisers voice their concerns too.This is as important as core PE in schools, where are Scotlands future performers and musicians going to come from if they are not given these opportunities in our schools. We need to fight for this.30482018-06-04T22:41:48.92736414Christine MacMasterMusic tuition should not be elitist. It builds self confidence, helps pupils to understand that hard work and dedication has many rewards. It opens up opportunity, especially to our most disadvantaged pupils. The impact of the decisions made now will not be felt until it is too late. Scotland is known for its creative talents that often spring from early school experiences. This should not be squandered!30482018-06-04T23:43:36.60336416Sinead Lammie I live on Clackmannanshire, my 8 year old daughter has just been robbed of her opportunity to continue to play the violin, having just sat her a Grade 1 exam, due to the imposition of a profit-making ) not just full cost recovery) hike in the cost of her GROUP school lessons which now cost more than private 121 lessons!! This is now completely unaffordable! I am totally disgusted by the complete disregard that our local council have given to the importance of affordable and accessible music tuition for all pupils, not just the select few who can afford! What right do they have to make music tuition an elitist? For the few and not the many? Shame on you Clackmannanshire!!30482018-06-05T00:30:08.53336418Avril McKenzieTotalitarianism is a political concept where the state recognizes no limits to its authority and strives to control every aspect of public and private life wherever feasible.\r\nA perfect description of Scotland under the SNP.30142018-06-05T06:29:31.50336419Grant GoldingCouncils throw lots of money into sport for fitness what about music for mental and emotional fitness!30482018-06-05T08:00:58.95336420Angela O'HaganMusic is a big part of life. Discouraging people to play and enjoy music by charging for lessons will affect many many people.30482018-06-05T09:36:42.48336422Judith MillerMusic tuition should not be limited to those who can afford it. Many talented and gifted children will not be given the opportunity to nurture their natural talent, as their families may not be able to afford private tuition. Musical instruments and tuition are a big expense for most families.\r\nmpst 30482018-06-05T11:46:31.7836423Fiona BlackExpressive Arts education in this country is at serious risk. I could not have trained as a music teacher and orchestral performer if I had not received free tuition in the 1980's. I came from a council estate and made it to the Conservatoire. Give this generation the same benefit. Music is becoming elitist again because only those that can afford it can have it. Look at Bloom's Taxonomy, Expressive Arts is at the top. 'I'm not a robot'....where would we be without drama, art and MUSIC. It doesn't happen by magic, it takes years of practise and dedication and fulfils EVERY ounce of Curriculum for Excellence. Musicians were hundreds of years ahead of CfE. It is an outrage that authorities have been allowed to obliterate or cut their Music Instructor Service. 30482018-06-05T11:58:33.20736424Dianne CunninghamChildren should always be given an opportunity to excel themselves at a subject or topic at school and not have to pay in the process for this privilege30482018-06-05T13:57:15.736427Gerard GordonWe must support and secure this enriching, creative, engaging, creative, stimulating and all round life-enhancing experience for all. Music.30482018-06-05T14:01:18.18336428Gerard GordonWe must support and secure the future of this enriching, creative, stimulating and life enhancing opportunity. Music, for all. 30482018-06-05T14:38:11.3636429David DicksonMusic is fundamental to our culture and learning it should be a right, not a privilege.30482018-06-05T16:21:14.40736430Rev. Brian J. Maurig, Jr.My ancestry includes links to the clans Jamieson, Macbeth, Galbraith and Gunn and I feel a strong connection to this heritage. I vehemently believe that to allow the desecration of such a sacred site would be unconscionable. Please, in the name of all that is Sacred, stop this from happening. Preservation of this site is crucial.30032018-06-05T16:38:2136431Emily KitzmillerSo many historical sites have been lost in America. Your country is rich in it's history, and Culloden battlefield is vitally important to teaching your people about it's past. Please, do not lose this important site to developers. 30032018-06-05T16:49:52.31736432Scott McDermottI truly believe that every child deserves free instrumental music lessons.30482018-06-05T17:12:27.4636433Stella KellyMusic is an essential part of learning that should be open to all not just the privileged.30482018-06-05T17:22:39.83736434Margo LathamMy daughter loves playing her musical instrument but it is costly for us especially having 3 children 30482018-06-05T18:29:16.1136435Laurie Anne CarrMy son received his first year of playing the violin free in P4. He went on to play it throughout his education and it definitely enhanced his education and life chances. He has just finished S6 and going to study maths. He did his music higher and achieved an A. I think that music is vitally important and should be available to all. Our Scottish culture and economy depend of this.30482018-06-05T18:52:25.06736436Isabella McNaugtonIt is right for all children in Scotland to have free music tuition30482018-06-05T19:37:31.5136438Kelly Devine My ancestors fought and died on battlefields all over the world. Destroying these historic sites is a horrendous way to honor their memory, and the causes they fought for. 30032018-06-05T20:29:04.53336440Pip wilkinsMusic is so important to everyones mental well being and helps learning and communication skills30482018-06-05T21:57:54.6436441Heather GrieveMusic is an outlet for many so fundamental to mental wellbeing 30482018-06-05T22:18:36.53336442Jenni Finlay Please allow free tuition!30482018-06-05T22:22:27.78336443M BallantyneThere is more to education than just academic subjects. Music is a lifeline to people as are books. 30482018-06-06T00:49:53.3536444Allison MeekisI am not Scottish, I grew up with an aunt that had come from Glasgow and she taught me all about the battle of Culloden. Please do not let greed take over history, people must remember what happened so future generations can learn the history. 30032018-06-06T06:52:15.85336445Jonathan FlemingAffordability must not be a barrier to music tuition. Musical ability must be nurtured, not turned into a luxury.30482018-06-06T08:14:0436446Paul Wickham Music is so important and must be protected.30482018-06-06T09:29:37.49336447Pat FieldEducation must be for life, not just for employment.30482018-06-06T10:27:00.45336448Patricia strainMusic can change lives, it is great for both the mind and soul. Do not deny the next generation this opportunity of self expression. 30482018-06-06T11:45:22.10736449alexander thomsonDelighted to support this initiative. Absolutely appalled that the rich gift of music is being curtailed by the withdrawal of funding for pupils. All good wishes for the cause of free musical instrument tuition.30482018-06-06T13:46:30.38736451Alsn ShearerThis is something I feel very strongly about.Music and the playing of is essential for any childs\r\neducation30482018-06-06T15:05:32.86736452Patrick BarryAny attempt to charge children to learn ANYTHING is cultural vandalism at best and wilful ignorance at worst.30482018-06-06T15:34:53.76336453Anthony SpencerAs a retired instrumental teacher, I have seen the life changing effect of children learning to play an instrument, giving them self confidence, self discipline and the ability to work in a team.30482018-06-06T16:08:59.836454Angela ShannonI have 9 grandchildren and they are at school in Glasgow. In secondary school 2of them are learning to play the drums and I don't think they have to pay. So I think it should be the same for all,Scottish Schools. Music is a powerful thing and should be available to all children free. My son learned to play the bagpipes at Hillpark in Glasgow and it gave him all sorts of different opportunities, there was no cost then30482018-06-06T19:29:28.96736457Shirley-Anne McDonaldIn Highland, most schools cannot afford taught music sessions at all in school time. So if children don't have tuition they are left not learning or participating in any musical activity.! It is widely reported that music can help symptoms of many issues kids have and calm, comfort them - sometimes completely changing their mood and behaviour for the better. Please give our kids a chance to fulfil a better life.\r\n30482018-06-06T20:02:38.75336458Mick CookeMusic has brought me so much, including my livelihood, all because of free music lessons at school.30482018-06-06T21:17:55.76336459Terry AndersonMusic and art to me are about inclusion and enjoyment. Having an opportunity to enjoy both should be a part of young peoples life within a properly resourced Education system. 30482018-06-06T21:26:30.95336460Rick BamfordAs a life long learner, I remember not knowing where to begin, and not having access to resources. I would not wish that for youth and children in this day and age. Music still is a large part of my life, and I am only beginning to scratch the surface. IT DOES NOT NEED TO BE LIKE THAT FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS.30482018-06-06T21:29:13.06336461Aileen LawsonEvery child should have access to free instruction on playing an instrument I missed out as my parents could not afford it 30482018-06-06T21:41:49.78336462Gav JacksonMusic is essential, not a luxury and music lessons should be free for children.30482018-06-06T22:31:59.9336464Giles PerringThis is fundamental - it has be part of every child's education to be given every opportunity to play music. It's about more than art, money or learning. It's about understanding and enjoying a core human social activity. 30482018-06-06T22:35:40.6836465Cameron JayWhen the sums are done and the equations are complete and the history has been studied and the genetics have been verified, only then will we realise that music is the most powerful medicine, tonic, release, energy and answer that we have been looking for. If you deprive our youth of the arts, you might as well deprive them of air. 30482018-06-06T22:55:18.4836466Vicky AdamsMusic education is something everyone should be able to access not just those that can afford it 30482018-06-07T03:24:49.39336467Mrs Mary MichieOverall music can give kids confidence especially if they are not so good at maths, English etc that they wouldn't get, but it also gives kids from working class an opportunity to follow a dream of further education and employment within the music world. My child plays flute and is extremely gifted, he has just completed his second year a RCS and I have found that at least 90% of the other kids come from wealthy families so the instrumental program give all kids the chance30482018-06-07T06:54:33.5336468Lee McDowallAs a music teacher, I have now seen a decline in the uptake of musical tuition after the introduction of tuitions fees. I hope these fees will Be thing of the past30482018-06-07T07:13:16.26336469Pamela AdkinsMusic at school is a powerful medium, creating well rounded, well balanced future adults. Bands, choirs, productions are sociable and a team. Most importantly MUSIC IS THERAPY!! In this digital, pressurised society young ones are in - give them ALL a chance to be HAPPY!!30482018-06-07T09:13:44.8936470Helen CrossmanMy daughter who is 35 still benefits from these early years of tuition. She enjoys playing in an amateur orchestra and my family and friends enjoy attending the concerts twice a year. None of this would be happening without these early years of free school tuition.\r\nEnjoy30482018-06-07T09:18:29.22336471Alex McGhieMusic should never be priced out of childrens' reach. 30482018-06-07T09:19:56.15736472Carly BlainYes free lessons as everyone should get a chance & music is great 30482018-06-07T09:20:56.0536473Dr Roger CullI strongly support free music tuition for Scottish schoolchildren. It is essential for life.l30482018-06-07T09:28:59.03336474Fiona AlexanderThe Scottish Government has already seen the huge benefits of free music lessons over many decades and more recently with the success of Scottish Sistema. Children, their families and whole communities have been given a chance to thrive. It is not just about creating the next generation of musicians. It is so much bigger than that. Learning an instrument gives a child a means to express themselves, boosts their confidence and increases self esteem outside the narrow confines of the academic curriculum. Even if all you care about is exam results, learning an instrument has been shown to improve those too. It is a win win situation. The long term cost of not investing in this generation far outweighs the cost of instrumental lessons. Please do not allow councils to make these decisions to charge for lessons or axe teaching when you in Government know it to be wrong. 30482018-06-07T09:30:36.36336475Adam nicholI want my children to have as many opportunities as possible when they go to school and to be able to explore as many possibilities without being restrained by a budget!30482018-06-07T09:42:20.39336476Laura FifeMusic is so important. 30482018-06-07T10:37:21.91736477Lorna Tilsley Free music turition should be retained otherwise playing instruments becomes a thing only the well-off can do. All children should have this opportunity.30482018-06-07T12:52:59.4236479Simon ThackerI am a professional musician who would not be in this career at all if not for free lessons in a state school. The all round educational benefits of music at school level are widely documented and innumerable, going beyond mere league table metrics and module credits, perhaps partly explaining the ease with which councils are getting away with these cuts, and lasting a lifetime. Are we content to sit and watch while practical involvement, understanding and appreciation of music becomes the preserve of the affluent? While other countries leave us behind....Scotland is already the only European country I can think of with no conservatoire in its capital city...? The gradual decimation of music tuition is both inexplicable and an unforgivable abdication of the responsibility of a fit for purpose education system. Every child should be guaranteed a one to one lesson, let alone the pathetic non or under provision of some councils. Having groups of mixed ability for 30 or 40 min lessons is itself short changing the pupils. It is clear that only by legislating can the proper provision be guaranteed. As the bedrock of our cultural wealth and future, I hope all members of the Scottish Parliament understand the severity and urgency of this situation and will act accordingly.30482018-06-07T17:43:14.61736481Mary WatsonThis would be excellent, all children should have the opportunity to learn an instrument and expand there life opportunity. 30482018-06-07T18:33:18.8436482Robert YorkeI benefited from free instrumental tuition, and it had a massive benefit to the rest of my education. It should be free so that the opportunity is open to all. 30482018-06-07T21:01:58.64336484Moray HamiltonMusic is so incredibly valuable both in its own right and as an aid to other subjects. Please, please, please see the big picture and think long term. All our children deserve this opportunity, not just the affluent. 30482018-06-07T21:02:03.36336485Mrs Jennifer Langrish I think it's extremely important to preserve our history for future generations. If legislation is given to build on one site, where will it end!30032018-06-07T21:32:26.25736486Alexander Murray GowansMy parents could not have afforded to pay for tuition. The free tuition I was given at school was life changing for me in a very positive way.30482018-06-08T07:35:16.30336487J millarThere should be consistency across Scotland. We need to pay. Music is fantastic and a great learning opportunity and a skill that never leaves a pupil. It's too valuable to lose.30482018-06-08T08:32:27.7536488Margaret SmithIf it had not been for the free lessons I am in no doubt that my family could not have afforded me the this opportunity. When it came to having to purchasing your own instrument this was hard enough. I since went on to read music at university with performance as a part of it. I continue well into my thirties to play in a local concert band and thoroughly enjoy it, using this connection to bring live music to the older person residential care home O work. Please reinstate free lessons and fund this activity properly.30482018-06-08T08:42:21.03336489Lucie MillerMusic should be promoted instead of taken away from pupils' lives!30482018-06-08T09:48:28.7336490Gavin WelshIt is so important that music tuition remains free for every child in Scotland. 30482018-06-08T10:23:22.63736491Cheryl Stirling Totally disgusting decision by West Lothian Council. Once again the poorer paid workers children are being penalised. 30482018-06-08T12:13:24.0136492Scott D WhitefieldFree instrumental tuition echelons me achiev my dream of being a violinist and teacher. I have used all the skills I learned in violin lesson in all the roles I have had from retail, management, Learning and development and much more. 30482018-06-08T13:14:43.03736493Mick CookeA musically literate and creative population is what I believe is needed to survive this coming period of change!30482018-06-08T13:25:52.11736494Pauline ShearerMy son was given the opportunity in 2012 to take up chanter in primary school and then became a world champion in 2016 with his Schools Pipe Band. He would not have had such amazing experiences and have such a love for music and especially playing bagpipes had it not been for this school tuition. 30482018-06-08T16:27:46.5336496Mary TraynorThink it is terrible that parents have to pay for music tuition, after all music is a universal language30482018-06-08T17:37:33.2936497Beverley HartI am Scottish but now retired to Spain. Music was taught to me for free and should still be the case.30482018-06-08T17:45:52.9836498Lesley GormleyCannot imagine how sad it would be to have a time when music tuition is not affordable for the majority. The opportunities that will be missed are unimaginable and so shortsighted.30482018-06-08T21:50:41.40336499Julie GilmourPlease save our music tuition!30482018-06-08T21:51:59.9836500Leanne KnightWhy destroy the best instrumental service in schools in the world??30482018-06-08T22:05:56.35736501Jill hubbardMy daughter went through a difficult time and music helped her through it and she loves playing instruments and expressing her emotions through music. Please do not take away her chance to keep doing this. Music should be available to all.30482018-06-08T23:14:58.1836502David LowLike so many others, I benefitted hugely from a musical education from primary school onwards. Playing the violin gave me discipline, pride in performing, social confidence in an orchestra family and challenges that proved incredibly satisfying when achieved. It bothers me greatly that future generations will be denied this education. It is not a luxury and should be available as a core subject.30482018-06-09T06:30:56.25736504Lynsey CombeI was given the opportunity to play an instrument at school, I would never have been able to do this if my parents had been charged. We need to continue teaching our children if today or there will be no musicians in the future! 30482018-06-09T08:47:17.7636505Phillip LambMusic is a perfect media for all. Playing is interacting with others, gives a sense of achievement, teaches discipline and can help with academic learning, particularly in maths. Please invest in children's future wellbeing.30482018-06-09T10:09:08.136506Joanna Whittington Every study that looks at the impact of learning music on attainment across the curriculum shows that music has a positive effect on every other subject. If the Scottish Government wants to reduce the attainment gap it should make music compulsory and invest in IMS nationally.30482018-06-09T10:36:03.3736509Mhairi SmithI went to a comprehensive school in Gorbals in Glasgow during the 70s. Sir Alexander Gibson visited my school with his orchestra. Whilst I had no talent for playing an instrument(tried to teach me recorder in primary school) I was left with a lifelong love of music and it greatly enriched my enjoyment of all things creative.30482018-06-09T11:07:12.5636510Kirsten DuncanBoth my children receive musical tuition at present and have benefited greatly from this. 30482018-06-09T11:40:01.11336511Susanne CoulterAll children should have access to music lessons no matter what school they go to30482018-06-09T12:17:47.23336513Suzanne SeniorMusic instruction is provided in schools during the school day and therefore should be free of charge, without a reduction in the service. Would Councils allow this situation arise with regard to Maths or sciences? I think not! 30482018-06-09T12:26:59.07736515Wendy WatkinsMy late husband was one of Europe's leading trumpet players. His father and his grandfather taught in schools and at the university in Reading. The costs of music tuition are such that parents just cannot afford the instruments, either to hire or buy, and we will lose our place as leading the world in musical talent unless something is done to address the problem at grass roots. Music is the international language, let's not shut the book on it please!30482018-06-09T13:17:47.17336516Gordon JamiesonWas taught brass in the late sixties and it has been part of my life always. 15 years with the Black Watch military band and other brass and wind related groups. It was a great start in my life.30482018-06-09T14:18:51.30736517Elaine BrownGIRFEC seems to be forgotten when it comes to music. Please give music parity of esteem with so called academic subjects. Music contributes to the Scottish economy , if it has a workforce to support it30482018-06-09T14:27:17.04736518Marjory BissettI have been supporting the music department of my local school for several years because of cuts and fees.some talented young students would have been unable to continue with their studies because of he fees. The new fees are over £200 which is a disgrace30482018-06-09T15:09:31.80336519George WilsonI suspect that East Lothian Council are not being open with the public about their plans and that worse may yet come to light.30482018-06-09T16:29:07.55736520Robert BurnsScottish Goverment,wake up smell the coffee this is very important let the kids have free music tuition.30482018-06-09T16:57:49.26736521Elizabeth HaineyChildren should be encouraged to learn a musical instrument or be involved in music from the earliest of their primary school days and must be encouraged to learn and take part. All of this should be an inclusive part of the school curriculum30482018-06-09T17:01:17.72336522David CurrieI had world-class music teachers and world-class access to fantastic music resources when I was at school. Please don't deny what I had to the countless children who also deserve world-class opportunities and world-class teachers like I had. 30482018-06-09T18:59:46.6336523Gavin Strathearn This is about so much more than reducing tuition costs. It opens the door to a creative outlet that many will not have been aware of. It helps to stimulate other areas of the brain which boosts academic learning which makes for more confident youngsters.30482018-06-09T19:10:11.15736524Catherine RollandCulloden and the surrounding area is a war grave & should be protected. There are plenty other sites for house building, cannot believe that the Culloden site was given planning permission. 30032018-06-09T19:29:52.83336525William Marr We demand free music tuition at all schools and colleges.30482018-06-10T00:49:52.81336527John MacDonaldCulloden has to be protected by The Scottish Government.30032018-06-10T04:51:56.1536528Anne FlemingThese battlegrounds should be hallowed ground.30032018-06-10T07:56:46.37336529Yvonne Percival The battlefields not only hold huge historical value but they are also war graves, & as such sacred. Please protect these sites to help preserve our history & the memories of those who died there.30032018-06-10T10:09:53.33336530Fiona NightingaleDiscouraging youngsters who are engaged in creative, collective, stimulating and character-building activity? Society needs those youngsters. Let's not build barriers in Scotland.\r\n30482018-06-10T14:30:12.53336532Kirstie HowardEvery child have the opportunity to become a band geek. 30482018-06-10T14:31:13.6636533Norma WilsonMy niece plays violin at Whitburn Academy and is member of West Lothian Youth Orchestra and recently got the opportunity to travel to Germany with them to liaise with the German Youth Orchestra and they will be coming to Scotland next year to do the same, this has been going for 13 years and gives kids amazing experiences, This is West Lothian council run please keep making us proud to be a county who cares.30482018-06-10T15:57:20.82736535John IrvineI got to learn several instruments whilst playing for the local BB band and my time at school. It does help you in so many ways, 30482018-06-10T16:33:23.7336536Mary Hutchison Music improves academic achievement 30482018-06-10T17:40:30.23736537Joseph M. Borg-CostanziMusic, Philosophy, History, Mathematics and the structure of languages should all taught at school from an early age.30482018-06-10T17:41:51.81736538David FrameThe video says it all. Its not just an instrument...its life long streetwise multifunction learning!30482018-06-10T18:52:13.07736539Hugh McGarrigle My daughter was given the chance to learn the violin in primary 4. She loves it and is now part of the local schools strings orchestra. Every kid should be given this opportunity.30482018-06-10T19:27:41.2236540Catherine ClarkOf all things to cut this is one of the most stupid...music enhances everything else it has been proven that it helps with all other subjects\r\nFor goodness sake stop going backwards30482018-06-10T20:11:48.1536541Alison SweeneyInstrumental music is so important - 30482018-06-10T21:48:22.53736542Donald MacKenzieThere are lots of empty field that people can build on. Do not sacrifice our history for the sake of profit. Indeed, there is profit to be made from history. For goodness sake, preserve these sites.\r\n30032018-06-10T21:56:32.11736543Morag connellPreserve our heritage and sacred space30032018-06-10T22:27:54.02736545David DonnellyThese places are of historical significance and councils should not have the right to give these builders the right to build on recognised burial grounds . It should be a separate Scottish government agency that has control of all ancient Scottish battlefields.30032018-06-10T22:30:28.79336546Andrew BraesMusic is so important to Scottish culture and identity 30482018-06-10T22:40:51.76336547Gordon Bickerton Music has been proven to give children confidence. It should be mandatory in our education system.30482018-06-10T22:51:12.536548Grace DunnOur history is important and we must learn from it and retain it, especially today. I am only now aware of the lack of Scottish history taught when I was at school.\r\n30032018-06-10T23:03:43.69736549Anne WattAny building is sacrilege30032018-06-10T23:54:40.00336551Gail ToppingWe should be preserving our history for future generations and respecting those who lost their lives in battle. Please do not allow developments like this to proceed30032018-06-11T00:40:26.4736552Rosina CargillI am fed up of my Scottish Heritage and History being slowly chipped, chipped, chipped away. In the words of Cicero "To be ignorant of what occurred before you were born is to remain always a child. For what is the worth of human life, unless it is woven into the lives of our ancestors by the records of history?" \r\n30032018-06-11T02:05:12.49336553Florence GardnerI think it is important that Scottish History is preserved and respected . This site is part of our history and important to Scotland 30032018-06-11T02:36:34.73336554Angela Morlotti Our ancient battlefields, final resting places, must be protected and respected. Put a stop to house builders and land developers trying to build on them.30032018-06-11T06:34:02.93736557Stephen Aitcheson This must be stopped. Our messsge must be loud and clear- we will not allow you to trample over our history any more than you have been trying to do wthin your skewed political and selfish mindset- an effort which has been on the increase since 2014. We are not stupid, neither are the graves of our fallen yours for vanity projects and dirty money.30032018-06-11T07:18:08.61736558Anne CurranHistorical sites must be preserved for future generations\r\n30032018-06-11T07:39:44.46336560Caroline Crawford They fought for us now we should fight for them30032018-06-11T07:43:09.8436561Lesley SmithSurely there are other fields suitable for building on nearby - why detract from the landscape and atmosphere of one of the most significant battle sites in Scottish history? Pure greed. 30032018-06-11T08:10:37.71736562Peter clark My son had a great musical education at school 30482018-06-11T09:47:00.8536563Ninian FergusA disgraceful, and politically motivated abuse.30032018-06-11T09:48:59.2936564elaine robertsonScottish heritage in all its aspects must be protected from these money grabbing conglomerates.30032018-06-11T10:48:52.95336566Sandy MorelandI was given free brass music tuition in Dundee in the 1950's. James Easson then in charge of music in Dundee Schools provided me with an opening into a world which shaped me and my future life in a very significant way. It opened doors to me not just in music, but forming connections that allowed me to be successful in life. It would be very sad if young people of today, especially those who could not afford music tuition are deprived of this life changing involvement in music making. 30482018-06-11T10:55:48.62736568Susan SmithThis ground does not belong to us who are here nowWe have no right to obliterate the past It must be revered and protected for future generations We mustnt forget the past 30032018-06-11T11:52:49.2936570Caroline Sewell It is so important to protect instrumental music provision in our schools. Protect instrumental music and protect jobs for music teachers! 30482018-06-11T12:55:34.4436571Keith Ellwood If you want to build on this sacred ground then you'll have another dead body there. Mine. Only killing me and thousands of others will you get to build there and that's not going to happen. 30032018-06-11T13:21:18.536572Roy William JamesMusical education should be made available free of charge to all schoolchildren. Surely it´s a basic requirement and links to many other disciplines.30482018-06-11T13:31:57.36736573Elaine Wilson All children should have access to music lessons not 30482018-06-11T14:22:07.60736575Fiona TaylorMy daughter was fortunate enough to secure a place on Dundee's Youth Music Initiative guitar tuition from P5-7 and has subsequently received tuition throughout secondary school. She also plays as a member of Dundee's guitar ensemble and has taken part in workshops with several renowned artists. She's going into S6 and is embarking on Advanced Higher music with a view to studying for a music degree. None of this would have been possible without the free tuition given or the hard work and dedication of all her tutors.30482018-06-11T14:26:08.82736576Jean McMillanMusic is so important. There are children who are not university minded but have a great talent for music and this should be encouraged at all costs. Music has so many genres and paths to follow.30482018-06-11T14:30:27.02336577Caroline GormanThe importance of music and the opportunity in schools to learn an instrument, can not be underestimated. Not just for art & culture etc but for well rounded learning for all young people. Music is therapeutic and enhances & influences so many other parts of children's education, training and learning.30482018-06-11T15:26:27.39736578Phil ScottPlease listen to your people and stop the desecration of our war graves.30032018-06-11T16:53:59.8736579ALIX GAULDIt's a graveyard of spirits that must not be consumed by greedy investors who only see money and not the history.30032018-06-11T17:22:44.58736581Colin BeatonIts illegal so this needs to be stopped. Goverments shouldnt dictate to parents when they cant even do good for thier own30142018-06-11T17:25:17.98736582Charles millerIn support. 30782018-06-11T17:28:03.80736584Shona Mccarthy I fully support expediating the release of loved ones bodies to their families 30782018-06-11T17:29:58.6836585Karen-Ann RobertsonIn what is already a horrific time for families they should be able to lay their loved ones to rest as soon as possible. 30782018-06-11T17:41:44.37736586Linda WrightAny battle cemetery I've ever visited, be it WW1 WW2 or Culloden,deserve the quietness of the surrounding environment. It's very difficult to evoke that same feeling of deep respect for the fallen, if you can't hear yourself think because the Number 10 bus is dropping off the screaming weans from school. I'm not too sure I'd want the ghosts of angry Jacobites stomping through my luxury pad.30032018-06-11T17:50:13.2336589Jonathon OKeefeIts about time the current dictatorship, sorry, government, are held to account.30142018-06-11T18:06:30.78736591Hazel mclaren Let families lay their loved ones to rest. Bad enough loosing someone never mind waiting months or years to grieve properly30782018-06-11T18:11:44.08736592Nicole BurgoyneI hope this helps other families in Amanda Digbys situation. please change the law to be the same as England and Wales.30782018-06-11T18:18:21.9636593Alexandra Manson Please help these families they are suffering enough by their loved ones being murdered 30782018-06-11T18:20:12.4336594Patricia WardI live in the area that is the highest priced local authority at £524 per child. Music helped my daughter after a bereavement. It helps mental health which we all know is an increasing problem for our young people. It gives confidence and raises self esteem. It helps kids with additional needs to flourish. When kids flourish it flows out into all subjects. Let's get it right for EVERY child.30482018-06-11T18:27:35.55736595Anna JohnsonHope this petition is successful. Thinking of you and your family! xx30782018-06-11T18:32:03.336596Graeme Campbell I received free music lessons and it opened a wide range of opportunities and helped develop me as a rounded person. I see the benefits in the school I teach in through the Sistema programme and feel this must be continued and developed not reduced. Music brings joy and a focus which is transferable to all aspects of life.30482018-06-11T18:57:42.2436598Catherine MaguireFamilies suffer enough, please help them heal.30782018-06-11T19:03:05.8236599Fiona robertsonI was given free brass tuition at school. I was amazed that by the time my daughter was at school there was a fee introduced. Its a shame that so many children will miss out on being part of music culture due to being unable to pay the fee. 30482018-06-11T19:18:47.55736600Norval BarclayThis might be their only chance. 30482018-06-11T19:40:56.31736601Mike wells Time to get in line with common sense procedure30782018-06-11T19:53:09.68336603Chris RobertsonMusic tuition should be freely available to all and not be purely for children from a more advantaged background. 30482018-06-11T20:17:25.69736604Honor OsborneThis family and others like them, including my own some 30 years ago deserve to lay their belived to rest after they have been torn from their lives - the protection here seems to carry the perpetrator not the victim.30782018-06-11T20:20:39.98736605Grace MacKinnonThere are children who will fall through the net because their parents will not be able to afford the tuition. That child might be the next Nicola Benedetti, Nigel Kennedy, Harry Christopher, Andrew Lloyd Webber. IMI's have done a wonderful job in our schools throughout the years I was teaching, giving freely of their time in lunch hours, at school concerts, for fund raising. Individual Music tuition should be free, that service has produced wonderful results and given children, who may never have discovered their talent, an opportunity to flourish in music. It also provides them with a creative skill which will give them pleasure throughout the rest of their life. 30482018-06-11T20:23:58.0136606Beryl Searle Music brings a rounding to education , It enhances life and connects to many other subjects including maths. Not all children are academic but could really shine at music, giving them a purpose and confidence.. 30482018-06-11T20:35:52.48736607Karen hughes Because these families have been through enough!30782018-06-11T20:45:38.74736608Marlene Halliday Knowing our history is important. Being able to visit historical sites and see the actual places where significant events in that history is essential. Culloden could be developed but as a historical site sensitive to the resting place of those killed on the battlefield, not as a housing development. 30032018-06-11T20:48:07.8136609Elizabeth Hendry Signed 30782018-06-11T21:36:46.04336610Anne DickieAllow family to bury their loved ones 30782018-06-11T21:40:43.1736611Karen Campbell Done 30782018-06-11T21:54:18.77336612Rhoda rutherfordSigned !!30782018-06-11T21:54:26.25736613Sandra BonnerFamilies should be allowed to bury loved ones30782018-06-11T22:08:54.86736614Melanie GaleI hope it can be changed, families need to say goodbye and time also to arrange 30782018-06-11T22:28:18.24736615Lorraine PatersonThis should be reduced to allow the family to let their relative rest in peace. 30782018-06-11T22:38:52.8136616Moira Creber I agree bodied should be released to family asap.30782018-06-11T23:03:27.26736617Tracy LundieI fully support, the request that changes are made to allow victims of violent crime to be laid to rest as soon as possible. Small changes should be made in the legal process to allow this while ensuring the fair trial guidelines. 30782018-06-11T23:40:33.3836620Robert nixonYes all scotlands battlefields are sacred grounds.for the people who died ther.30032018-06-11T23:50:48.28736621Anne Gale It's difficult enough for families after something tragic happens to a loved one without having to wait months to lay them to rest 30782018-06-12T01:18:32.09736622Tracey coghlanThis is just torturous for the family, the law needs to change and fast.30782018-06-12T01:34:04.9936623George BellI was lucky, my father was a shipyard worker who loved music and paid for music lessons for my brother and me. Changed our lives and gave us a lifelong legacy of music and pleasure and communication. Music is as essential as all other airts and pairts of education. Give all children the benefit of a life time and promote music in schools through out their formative years. Thank you for the opportunity to support this30482018-06-12T04:15:56.21736624Lisa SaloThey shouldnt prolong the anguish of having to arrange the funeral so long after the tragedy. The family should be allowed to bury them as soon as possible so they have a place they can go to mourn them in peace30782018-06-12T04:59:59.81336625Morag Crichton At least let them lay their loved ones to rest \r\nGod bless them 30782018-06-12T05:43:05.36736626Debbie LaydenDone30782018-06-12T06:05:52.66736631Julie SteelAll children should unquestionably have the opportunity to be taught and enjoy music, free of charge, as they do all other subjects. Music effectively helps improve Wellbeing plus it enables children to explore many of the Experiences and Outcomes underpinning our Curriculum for Excellence such as resilience, team work, becoming confident and individual learners. Children also have fun through music!30482018-06-12T06:08:20.6236632Louisa DarraghChildren should be able to get free music tuition in our schools. Music is so important to their development. It is a fundamental part of the curriculum and such a specialist field that we need peripatetic teachers to train our children.30482018-06-12T06:33:20.98336633Paula FrameFunding required30482018-06-12T06:38:47.7836634Gillian Campbell This is a shocking amount of time for a family to wait 30782018-06-12T07:02:35.17336635Michelle InglisRemoving or reducing such a service will disadvantage communities. Music is the basis for arts, science, mathematics and literature. By removing it, you are reducing a strand of learning that is vital in many children. 30482018-06-12T07:25:49.22736636Lauren AdamsThis would make music become more popular in the current day30482018-06-12T07:39:39.99336637Margaret campbell Yes30782018-06-12T08:27:05.5536638Ian Greig Music inspires more life skills than any other subject. 30482018-06-12T08:28:19.75336639Janet Donaldson-ElderBuilding on any historic battlefield site is an abomination. There are human remains on most if not all battlefields and to ignore those and what they mean is not acceptable. This is desecration and I keep hearing about the possibility of building on various sites more and more. There are many empty building and other sites, leave our history alone.30032018-06-12T08:36:20.93736640Philip WardMusic is language, art, science, maths, dexterity, stamina. Music is a simple way to improve so many skills at once. Music is everything.30482018-06-12T08:39:26.7536641Mark Quentin StephensonMusic needs to go back onto the schools teaching ciriculum because it allows young people not only to learn about playing a musical instrument but it is a necessary part of teaching them the skills of how to interact and identify with others no matter what backgrounds or cultures people come from. It also biulds self esteem and self expression and helps individuals deal better with their own mental health. 30482018-06-12T08:46:37.27336642Michelle ThomasNobodies loved one should be lying in a mortuary for 5 months, family need somewhere to lay their loved one to rest as quickly as possible and to have somewhere more pleasant to visit their loved one.30782018-06-12T09:56:18.37736643Katie DunlopIf it wasn't for free school lessons 25 years ago I wouldn't have had half the life I've had and met so many wonderful people. More importantly I really believe the ability to read and play music helped with my Dyslexia and ADHD including my ability to focus and concentrate for long periods of time.30482018-06-12T10:17:19.28736644Christine Shaw Done 30782018-06-12T10:24:03.78336646Dorothy MCcormickNo change should be made to the excellent service we now have Rural areas need to have as good a service as Urban areas. Why change something that is working??30722018-06-12T11:48:10.93736647Bernadette mcquilterDone30782018-06-12T12:01:44.1636648Helen McCrindleThink with modern technology, families shouldn't have to wait so long for their chance to say goodbye.30782018-06-12T12:31:08.5236649Daniel DominickThe history of the applcation of this legislation in the pilot areas is horrendous. \r\nThousands of children in need of support being failed and 2 toddlers actually dying, where it is believed the NP pilot actually contributed to the failures to those children. \r\nI could go on writing flaws on this legislation, but lets be honest here everyone knows just how twisted this legislation is. \r\nWhen a law is described by 3 law lords of bein totalitarian and our assembly elected political leaders still try to push it through, well I'll say no more30142018-06-12T12:32:48.4636650Christina MontgomeryIf we continue to deny children access to free music education, within a generation or two there will be no musicians to play for our celebratory events.30482018-06-12T13:04:07.80736651Davina felsteinTo lose a dad is horrible enough but to lose him to murder before his time and of no fault of his own, means you can't say goodbye properly. I have personal experience of the issue raised by the petitioner. it's been 5 months and I still have no idea when i can lay the father of my son to rest30782018-06-12T13:56:13.67336652Anne MacAskillInstrument tuition should be open to all and not just those who can afford it.30482018-06-12T14:53:16.1536653Debbie kerrAll children should learn a musical instrument 30482018-06-12T15:44:18.17336655Lesley RobbThis amounts to state control of our children and has no place in a civilised and free society. The majority of parents are perfectly capable of raising their children without state interference . Scotland under the snp is fast becoming a dictatorship.30142018-06-12T16:31:02.75736656Andy SaundersSelf discipline, creativity, self confidence, team work, generosity, motor skills, mathematical and logistical brain functions...learning an instrument consistently over time brings clear benefits to all of these areas. If we genuinely want to plan for a brighter future for all, then free music tuition in school is a cost-efficient, effective way to do it.30482018-06-12T16:45:42.94736657Christine DickenI benefitted greatly from free school music lessons, associated band and orchestral opportunities in Ayrshire during the 80's.30482018-06-12T17:11:18.43336658Leighann mckenzie Release this poor man's body the family's been three enough30782018-06-12T17:26:11.99336659Michael Docherty Music is wonderful and all children should be given a chance to show there hidden talent.30482018-06-12T17:55:28.6636660Catherine Docherty God bless 30782018-06-12T18:03:33.3636661Iain CulrossMusic tuition should be right for all children, not just a luxury for a privileged few30482018-06-12T18:59:03.24336662Jason Ferguson This policy has no place in a free and democratic society.30142018-06-12T19:19:27.99736664David AnnandIt should be a right. Music is a potential career for many talented Scots.30482018-06-12T19:29:00.29336666Patricia collinsI think that the belief that one shoe fits all is very nieve. The nhs and social work integrated care is falling apart. The bigger surgeries in the Argyll and bute area are on their knees unable to cope. I think the quicker an actual consultation is done rather that the supposed one the better. Thr rural practices currently offer an excellent service. Leave alone30722018-06-12T19:43:18.62336668Margaret BrrownellMusic makes memories. It takes us back to our childhood. Introducing music lessons in school offers children an opportunity to learn music which they might not of had. \r\nMusic is the food of life, for the sake of our children please give them free lessons and let them play on.30482018-06-12T20:01:45.5536670Louise Fotheringham Music tuition is so much more than music... Maths, team work, respect, tenacity, taking instruction, problem solving. Scottish children should be allowed the opportunity to experience the wonders of music tuition without having to pay, otherwise it reneges to only being available for the elite. 30482018-06-12T20:15:45.336671Julia Elizabeth BielskaNo thank you for complete state control of families.30142018-06-12T20:34:14.56736672Geoff MenzerGood idea30482018-06-12T20:47:43.55336674Tony WoodsI have just completed 24 years in military music. Without free lessons at school this career choice would not have been available to me. This needs to be a matter for central government to ensure fairness throughout. Keep it free!!!!30482018-06-12T21:06:09.9536676Emily MacEachran Both my Children received Free Music Tuition at school, My Daughter played in Both School Orcherstra and University , And My Son is still playing Drums 30482018-06-12T21:07:20.21336677Liz Crossley Both my children play an instrument have for last 5 years . We as a family can not afford the more than doubled amount Clackmannanshire council are asking . I am not asking for free but a fair approach for my family and the next generation of musicians.30482018-06-12T21:10:11.85336678Kim MurdochEvery young person should be given the opportunity to access musical instrument tuition free of charge. 30482018-06-12T21:11:34.66736679Marita GormleyMusic has the power to transform lives. Music instruction should be free to all young people regardless of background.30482018-06-12T21:12:10.96336680John McFaulds I was given the opportunity to play the sax wjen I was 11. I'm 29 now and still play in bands and have excellent knowledge of music even though im not a professional it's essential that it's kept available to all30482018-06-12T21:23:23.54336681Michelle McCabeMusic tuition gave me so many life skills (problem solving, endurance, perseverance, independent thinking and working towards goals both personal and collaboratively to name but a few) and the resulting ensembles I was able to join developed confidence and communication skills but more importantly, growing up in a poor area of North Lanarkshire, it gave me a safe place to be away from all the peer pressure to go down a different life path. Being a school musician had a positive influence on my other subjects at school too, not least because it improves your mental health and without free tuition none of this would have been available to me. Yet here I am, a hard working, tax paying, happy member of society. Give every kid a chance in life. Music improves everything. 30482018-06-12T21:25:56.8136682Neil WilsonMusic has value that cannot be simply reduced to a need to save money. It's equally as important as math, language and science.30482018-06-12T21:30:37.10736683John Neil KitchenerScottish Canals seem to ignore their statutory obligation to maintain navigation along the lowland canals, preferring to squander their money on excessive salaries and perks for senior staff and investing in egocentric projects which do not benefit the canals. An independent ombudsman will provide a check on the activities of Scottish Canals and ensure that they carry out maintenance to guarantee that navigation will be maintained along the length of the canal.\r\nThe current closure of a number of bridges on the Forth and Clyde Canal is a serious indictment of their misallocation of funds and their maintenance strategy.\r\n30022018-06-12T21:43:59.5636684Peter Barlow There's ample evidence that music, especially from a young age, results in better learning in numeracy and physical sciences. As well as fostering collaboration and teamwork - and leadership skills.\r\n\r\nMusic? Stupid not to.30482018-06-12T21:55:42.70736685Mollie KerrPlease stop charging for music tuition. East Lothian Council passed charges today after admitting to no consultation with service users.30482018-06-12T22:07:12.83336686Tommy SharkeyThis is a basic right. We all benefit from music. We can't continue to 'throw things out the hot air balloon'. Build a fair society!30482018-06-12T22:07:46.53736687Phil Pirie My music experience start at primary school in 1971 and continues till today playing in brass bands. We cannot lose our music and arts heritage. 30482018-06-12T22:07:50.25336688Donna Hutchison Agree30782018-06-12T22:08:11.9436689Katharine ElwisMull and Iona are in desperate need of adequate GP provision. Help us now before there is a tragedy.30722018-06-12T22:11:07.25336690Norman RobinsonI believe that music is a vital part of life and should be encouraged in all children and adults.Free classes give all children the chance to explore their abilities and communicate through music.30482018-06-12T22:11:13.5236691Caroline SmithMusic is central to the culture of Scotland, and should not be available only to the privileged few.30482018-06-12T22:19:03.1636692andrew mcdowellMusical education should be made available free of charge to all school children.30482018-06-12T22:31:28.05336693Emma Holmes A cut to these services is counterproductive and so hard to reverse. In my working week as an instrumental teacher I cover everything from full class delivery of raising attainment projects through to preparing advanced students for exams and indeed university and conservatoire entrance. Instrumental tuition often has to begin at primary school in order for children to reach such advanced levels: a cut to music services cannot be reversed overnight, or when budgets improve! A cut means the loss of delivery to thousands of pupils, no more expert input into raising attainment,and the loss of bands, orchestras and ensembles at all levels, and a situation in which a cut made in a moment would require input for nearly a decade to bring through advanced students.30482018-06-12T22:31:40.11336694John LallyMusic enriches everybody. Give everyone the chance to make music.30482018-06-12T22:33:57.38336695Mr Andrew Jones The land of Scotland is steeped in history. There should be no development on historical battlefields on Scottish soil. It is more important to preserve the memory and the history of this great land than to profit for few. 30032018-06-12T22:37:38.4636698Jacqueline CampbellHaving 4 young children who have all started music tuition, love it and show aptitude, you are now forcing them to give up as I cannot afford 1000 pounds per year and we are not entitled to your discounts. 30482018-06-12T22:37:44.52336699Martin Morrison Show some pride. Have some care. Learn to respect the past. Please30032018-06-12T22:39:22.28736700Judith PaleyMSPs were very supportive when we were campaigning at council level. We have avoided harsh cuts but had to accept fees which will be hard for many families. We hope MSPs continue to support the campaign- make music a statutory service and fund accordingly. So many benefits for all economy, mental health, education. 30482018-06-12T22:43:23.6236702Neil Gillies The charges have already had a devastating effect. Remove charges immediately! 30482018-06-12T22:46:47.52736703Susan KelsoMusic is a unique way of buiding confidence, self esteem & inner resilience - giving this opportunity to all children in Scotland is a great way to support wellbeing, provide community, leadership & good citizenship skills. 1 in 4 children live in poverty in this country - many families without free tuition would not be able to participate. 30482018-06-12T22:51:25.7936705Katie BaconMusic tuition should be made available to all children who have an interest in the subject, I feel so lucky to have been able to access free tuition when I was at school. 30482018-06-12T23:01:27.1836707Cairn RobertsonTo exclude children from a musical education due to financial circumstance is in no way in keeping with the Scottish Government goals to close the poverty related attainment gap. 30482018-06-12T23:07:25.21736708Adelaide CarlowWhy should the opportunity to express oneself emotionally, and develop self-confidence through musical experience be afforded only to the privileged few? It is a wonderful, positive thing in our world- it should never be exclusive.30482018-06-12T23:11:54.38736710Anne LindsayLearning and appreciating musical instruments are not and never should be, a luxury of the few. Much is gained by learning to play an instrument and it should never be regarded as a chance only for some to learn , but for everyone.30482018-06-12T23:34:34.20336712Graeme SeawrightThe local authorities should be spending our money on things our youth need. Music tuition is vital and should be available to all school pupils. Some families are not so fortunate and cannot afford do dish out money for something their children need. Music tuition should be free for all school pupils and the local authority should be investing our money in that. Enough said30482018-06-12T23:36:20.12736713Pamela SoencerI benefitted enormously from having the opportunity to learn a musical instrument at school from P4, so much so I choose teaching Music my career. In my 26 years of teaching I have seen on a daily and weekly basis the benefits that Music brings to children. It enables confidence to be built, determination and perseverance to be developed, enables team work but most importantly provides a friendship group for many children who would otherwise be left out be their peers. Music is a lifeline to many and breaks down barriers. The Big Noise project is a shining example of the importance of Music in society. Let all children have this opportunity and experience. 30482018-06-12T23:38:05.8636715Ciara WebbThe Sistema project in Raploch speaks for itself. The research shows better outcomes not just for the kids but for their families and communities too. Musical instrument tuition should not be the preserve of the rich. It should be available to any child who wants to learn.30482018-06-12T23:39:59.53336716Jim HayGreat cause to support 30482018-06-12T23:44:31.82736717Lorna MurrayEvery child should have the right to access free music tuition. Children have diverse skills and should be able to pursue the development of musical skills in an equal manner just as they do maths, English and other academic subjects. Young people from all sections of society need to be able to play an instrument if they are to study music at a higher level. This must not be available only to those who can afford it. They must have equal opportunities.30482018-06-12T23:46:49.68736718Alyson ConnellMusic, a core subject in S1 and S2, is now not a choice for Nat 5 for those students whose parents cannot afford any music lessons until the point at which they become free. Those pupils face a huge disadvantage compared with their more affluent peers as they have to learn 2 instruments from scratch in 2 years. It adds a stigma to the subject by making it elitist when music should be accessible to all.30482018-06-12T23:54:25.92336719Alyson ConnellMusic is now an elitist subject. Those who cannot afford private lessons on top of the extravagant fees being charged by some councils face learning 3 instruments from scratch in 2 years and face a significant disadvantage to their more affluent peers in what is a core subject in S1 and S2. Affordability should not be a factor in subject choice and music should not be stigmatised as elitist.30482018-06-13T00:49:00.41336720Jane Corrigan Very sad and short sighted as music enriches lives and reaches parts that other subjects don't! A lot of kids respond to music that maybe don't do well in other subjects and it is not fair to take those opportunities away from our young people who are the world of the future. All kids should get music tuition and options. 30482018-06-13T01:09:55.12336721Jacqui cottonA step towards totalitarianism. Try focusing on health, education, etc all the areas suffering under SNP control. Just leave families alone, the state is a lousy parent30142018-06-13T05:52:22.06336722Kathleen DoyleMusic is so important.30482018-06-13T05:56:36.64336723Bill ScottPoor children should not be denied music tuition. Education should be free.30482018-06-13T06:19:08.27336724Allison McIntyreMusic is important as academic studies and should not be considered a luxury, 30482018-06-13T06:30:43.7436725Sarah Ball This will be the only opportunity many children will have to play a musical instrument and will see the disappearance entirely of school orchestras. 30482018-06-13T06:51:22.4336726Morag Malcolmmusic tuition is so important. Music formed s huge part of my upbringing as my Dad was a tutor. Through this it was not only about the music but it taught discipline, friendship and good team building. Invaluable I would say.30482018-06-13T06:57:14.27736727Maureen BinnieMusic instruction is a vital part of school curriculem for those many pupils interested and indeed talented. Music lessons in schools cannot supply the variation of music alone. The added bonus being music instructors supply out of school activities, weekend music camps and concerts, all building on confidence30482018-06-13T07:17:24.2336728Anne Douglas Music is vital therapy for some children it needed in today,s society more than ever 30482018-06-13T07:44:40.40736730Alan HannanMusic education ought not to be available only to those who can afford to pay for it.30482018-06-13T08:00:56.05336731Helen AndersonHow short sighted the Government pundits are. Untold mental health benefits being thrown away. \r\nDirect contravention of their own GIRFEC policy SHANARRI principles.\r\nSpend more on the arts in schools and society will reap a myriad of blessing.30482018-06-13T08:01:10.78336732Catherine McLaughlinI agree that music lessons should be free30482018-06-13T08:04:07.03336733Leah HamiltonMusic changes lives - it's not just something that's "nice" to have, it's as vital as the air we breathe.30482018-06-13T08:16:52.00736734June Chedzey Everyone should have a chance 30482018-06-13T08:27:14.3236736Lindsay DixonMusic tuition is important in the lives of so many and many would be unable to access thia if this decision is carried through. Playing a musical instrument develops the working of our brains, confidence, has positive health benefits and encourages creativity. Things every child should have access to. 30482018-06-13T08:39:01.8236738Natalie ReidThere are children who may not be good at maths or English but great at music, they need the opportunity to discover this. 30482018-06-13T08:58:03.88736742Talia Goldberg GellerFrightening to think a government would want so much control over families 30142018-06-13T09:35:40.31336748Ciara McCumiskeyLearning to play an instrument in school was the most valuable thing I was ever taught and was something we would never have been able to afford if it wasn't free. Don't take this away from the kids that will follow me. 30482018-06-13T09:51:17.61336749Gill clarkKids deserve the chance to play music and if gifted pursue a career without financial obstacles 30482018-06-13T10:16:49.64736750Jeanne SowinskiI have benefited from free tuition many years ago at school in Glasgow (Bellahouston Academy) and went on from.there to write and produce music,lyrics shows etc..within every person there is a hidden gift we should promote this and if it is music free tution is a much needed start30482018-06-13T10:26:12.19736751Michael J LINDA great shame the Government are even thinking about this. Not every child is musical, but every musical child deserves to be fully supported, free of charge!30482018-06-13T10:31:52.25736752Eilidh CameronMusic tuition should be free for all pupils. Charging pupils for school music tuition limits participation and denies access for pupils for more deprived backgrounds. 30482018-06-13T10:35:18.3236753Andrew PeacockSharing private data should not be allowed without approval. It goes against every principle of data protection.30142018-06-13T11:21:15.8636756Pat FieldThe person educated only to be a functional robot in the workplace is forever alienated from what it is to be fully human. And they are alienated from the workplace too because their education is out of date by the time they get a job. Creative education isn't an option, it is more essential than anything else on offer.30482018-06-13T11:44:15.2736759Tom StringfellowExtremely short sighted thinking. 30482018-06-13T12:44:05.54336763Helen LawsWe need our practice. Rural GP's are a necessity.30722018-06-13T12:54:40.26336764Hugh MundayAbsolutely no to sharing of data. What a prospect totalitarian state. No thanks.30142018-06-13T13:10:26.2836765Aileen GemmellMusic can inspire, encourage, comfort, and raise or quieten spirits ...learning to play an instrument can allow self expression and offers a channel to express emotions and feelings. This offers a wide range of personal channels to match personality traits. It also teaches beat, rhythm and self discipline regarding tone, volume and listening skills.30482018-06-13T13:17:39.73336766Steven BarrScottish Government are a joke with some of the recent changes they are making!!!!30482018-06-13T13:47:25.03736767STEVEN MCDONALD Learning music is as important as learning a language such as French or Spanish. It is a language in its own right. Music and drama and other performing arts are legitimate future career options for children and should be accessible to all regardless of the income of parents. 30482018-06-13T14:07:02.8236768Anne Maria RennieThis legislation will be abused and are opening children to predators.30142018-06-13T14:37:33.68336771Julie YorkstonMusic is a very important part of education and families should not be charged for it. 30482018-06-13T14:45:32.15336772anne bellMusic is very important to the soul do not take children's opportunity away from them to learn the love of music \r\n\r\n\r\n30482018-06-13T14:52:15.60736773Jodi Macdonald Music is great for all aspects of development and can provide so many opportunities30482018-06-13T15:05:4036774Julian AugleyThis is not a hobby, musical education complements other educational activities, including maths, and also can provide a sense of achievement which is vital to continuing education after school. Music must be free to all30482018-06-13T15:08:56.29736775Dave DonnellyIn a time when people are communicating more through social media, playing music can give children, who have grown up in a world where talking to someone means connecting with them on a digital forum, the chance to develop interpersonal skills essential in the workplace and in life generally. The satisfaction of working together to achieve a common goal, not to mention the benefits of being able to develop mental focus, pattern recognition, listening skills and appreciation of different cultures, is invaluable.30482018-06-13T15:26:15.1636776Holly ScrimgeourWithout free and accessible music education, I would not have been able to achieve all that I have benefited from with having that experience. I have performed all around Scotland, achieved an Honours Degree in Music, and through various inter-related roles, got to my current position within University Governance. \r\n\r\nMusic taught me discipline, courage, determination, dedication, never to judge myself by other people's standards, and to work to achieving something that I wanted to do. Music is not a "soft subject", it is a life skill. 30482018-06-13T16:28:05.57336781Jai RitchieI find it disgraceful that government are tryin to take music tuition away from young people as it gives many people (myself included) a sense of purpose30482018-06-13T16:39:46.11736782Aileen MarshallAs a music educator, I have experienced at first hand the very positive benefits of music tuition in schools for children of all ages and backgrounds. Not just those who make a career in music but all who take part learn life skills that never leave them.\r\nMany get & give pleasure by continuing their musical journey as a hobby in later life too.\r\nHow much poorer all our lives would be without the joy of learning, sharing and hearing live music!!!30482018-06-13T16:42:05.52736783Norma TaskerOur family have all been fortunate in being involved with being in school orchestras, choirs etc .they have gained immense pleasure and friendships through this involvement and continue to do so into adulthood. Every child should be able to experience this same fulfilment.30482018-06-13T17:17:37.98336785Mary ClarkDone30722018-06-13T17:21:41.06336786Priya MacdonaldI receive instrumental instruction in school, and have done for seven years, and think that it is a fantastic service. I am absolutely devastated that we now have to pay.30482018-06-13T18:27:19.4636787Tracy Ibbotson So important to teach all kids music. Plato was right ! 30482018-06-13T18:28:59.38336788Audrey McAllisterI was fortunate to be educated in Scotland. This included free instrumental lessons which led to a career as a professional orchestral violin player. Please keep the standard 30482018-06-13T19:26:32.39336789Laura Conneely Music education is such a fantastic thing to have and these cuts are gonna price out a lot of people that could really benefit from it. I hope we can look after the future of music education 30482018-06-13T19:38:40.95736791James Brown Music lesson should be free it's good for children and it is a good way to use money 30482018-06-13T20:05:04.44336795Gesina MeyerMusic tuition shouldn't only be for those who can afford it.30482018-06-13T20:53:43.63736798Kay SharpI was given free bassoon lessons when I was 11 - 18years old. I also was offered a scholarship to lease -buy my own instrument. I am now 49 and still play the bassoon (same one). The life experiences I have gained by this has made it the best learning I have ever received. We need to give everyone the opportunity to play an instrument.30482018-06-13T21:32:44.9136799Vicki Vivian-CooperI was lucky enough to enjoy free musical tuition while I was at school. It opened doors to new friends, lots of fun & memorable experiences such as playing in the Glasgow Royal concert hall, on a boat cruising down the River Seine & Paisley Abbey to name a few. 30482018-06-13T21:52:41.56736800Jennifer DunnI am in support of this petition30482018-06-13T22:25:21.41336803Rosie mackay The arts is just as important as science. 30482018-06-13T22:34:12.7936805Cluny StrachanDon't cut the money change the way we teach connect, reach community and develop new ideas and hope.30482018-06-13T23:16:29.23736806Rebecca Duncan -SkeltonMusic makes confident citizens. It has to remain free so children can express themsevles. 30482018-06-13T23:18:05.0836807Bill JarvieAs one who was instrumental in the re-opening of the Forth & Clyde Canal, 17 years later I find having a boat on same a complete farce when despite having the 'good fortune' to be moored at Auchinstarry, on the 'summit reach', and thus able to enjoy some cruising despite the enforced bridge closures, now I find I can no longer risk leaving my mooring because of the large volume of weed, and our recently 'upgraded' weed cutter cutter again being out of commission.30022018-06-13T23:24:39.4436808Dawn NelsonIt is a sin that children have to pay fees for music lessons. Why are they not deemed as important as the academic subjects? Some children may be gifted at those but there are others who are gifted in the arts such as music drama and art. Not forgetting those with additional support needs who benefit greatly from music. If we don't stop the fees it will only be the elitist who will be performing. 30482018-06-14T00:22:49.2636809John MackayHaving been involved off and on in trying to ensure the canals were reopened to navigation and more made of what is potentially wonderful resouce for 42 years I am greatly concerned at the state that they have been allowed to fall into when they offer a tremendous opportunity both for leisure and business opportunities. Hopefully a waterways ombudsman would help the active waterways users, communities and business liaise with the new management in a far more positive way than previously30022018-06-14T04:44:36.56336812Audrey FarleyI find it utterly unbelievable that when we are challenged by the government to reduce the poverty attainment gap and provide excellence and equity that we would contemplate removing free music tuition! Shameful idea. 30482018-06-14T06:10:14.12336813David EdesThe Caledonian canal seem to operate a if your face fits system .certain people seem to get anything they want st the expense of other Canal users 30022018-06-14T06:43:44.1736814Fiona McKinnonNot only instrumental tuition. Music education. Vocal and choral training are important too. Singing together has so many physical and mental health benefits. Playing and or singing together in a band, orchestra or choir encourages team work, resilience and dedication. All qualities we would like our future generations to have. 30482018-06-14T06:52:07.62336815Debbie MeehanMusic improves learning across all subjects and is of educational and cultural value. Charging for lessons disadvantages poorer students and increases the education gap. 30482018-06-14T07:13:09.9936816Michael BarronWithout tuition in schools, we will lose generations of musicians.30482018-06-14T07:17:39.59736817Dr Paul Max EdlinThe transferable skills that musical learning affords are clear and research demonstrates that music education is a huge asset for individuals and nations. Thus music education is a sound investment and any forward thinking government should ensure it. Additionally, music education should not become the preserve of the affluent. That would lead to a divided society. So... set the best example and demonstrate how much better Scottish education can be! 30482018-06-14T07:49:49.52336819Margaret Trainer Maybe 2 completely independent Post Mortems for murder victims will help resolve this.30782018-06-14T09:59:31.79736820Isabel TaylorMy daughter had free tuition at school and went on to have a successful musical career, and has been able to pass her knowledge and skill to others.30482018-06-14T10:21:54.5936821Sarah HoustonAs a teacher and a parent, I see the myriad of benefits that instrumental tuition brings to our children's lives. School curriculum is overloaded and too much is expected of primary school teachers, already, so the loss of this instrument tuition would steal very real opportunities from the young and this is unacceptable.30482018-06-14T11:35:31.3136822Jenna BellThis needs to change! 30782018-06-14T13:07:05.3836824Jim SharpStop the Quango !!!!!!!30022018-06-14T13:38:43.05736826Caroline FinnWhy not charge for maths instead? Music tuition has fantastic benefits for brain development. In a state school we should not be charging for things like this.30482018-06-14T13:56:33.05336828Willie DuffyFree access to music and other arts are essential for the personal development of all our young people. Restricting this is a false economy.\r\n30482018-06-14T15:12:57.71736830Rob SmithMusic tuition essential for all children. Should be free in all schools.30482018-06-14T16:35:53.63336832Mia letts This needs to be done .it's heartbreaking how we can not lay him to rest .30782018-06-14T17:41:58.00336833Ella Wilson Education should be free no matter what it is 30482018-06-14T19:57:00.39736835Kayla McKinnieI feel it's important that everybody has the same chances to learn at school (including learning an instrument) and this stops people who don't have lots of disposable income from having the same opportunities.30482018-06-14T21:13:07.65736836Elise Wilkinson I think it is just disgraceful that children are going to have to pay for instrumental lessons. Because of this many children are going to be unable to afford it, and although children with benefits are still obliged to free lessons and the upper class are able to afford it it leaves the middle class unable to continue in learning to play an instrument no matter how talented they may be. 30482018-06-14T21:16:25.42336837andrew doublethe caladonion canal has become very dangerious for the ocanioal boater due to the passenger higher boats doing up to 15knots in canal if this is aloud to carry on it will erroud banks and destroy canal as they have no other interest than to make as much money as possable30022018-06-14T21:23:33.8836838Rosie LindsayFree music lessons enrich the lives of young people who need it the most. 30482018-06-14T21:32:23.56736839Julie ShannonNo family should have to suffer indefinitely before burying a loved one30782018-06-14T22:20:47.19736841Carrie ReidPlease keep free music tuition. Vital. 30482018-06-14T23:11:21.61336845Gerard DohertyI am from a working class background. My musical education was free. I would not otherwise have been a professional musician. This opportunity should be available to all young people. 30482018-06-14T23:12:00.45736846Lynne ClappertonMusic tuition charges imposed to school pupils is short-sighted and detrimental to the mental health of our children. Music benefits people in SO many ways and should be part of the school curriculum and available to ALL. Hard working families are being hit once again with additional expenses at state schools. This will stop SO many children developing or even finding their talent. NOT all children are academic and music is a very, very valuable tool to help good mental health especially in teenagers.30482018-06-14T23:14:50.1336847Erin cairney I completely agree with the younger generations to get free music lessons as it has always been, I disagree with the fact that the musicians with a passion and use music as a way to deal with issues should be paid for.30482018-06-15T09:36:07.13336851Janette ScottThis is absolutely shocking. So many talented youngsters will lose out because of this, the council could find the money in other ways. 30482018-06-15T09:54:35.65336852Graeme MurrayAccess to music tuition is also linked to the economy, tourism and quality of life, which is certainly the case in Shetland.30482018-06-15T10:07:39.37336853Rosie Lawson I recieved free music tuition in East Lothian for 7 years. These lessons taught me much more than simply a musical skill. Through lessons (both one-to-one and group lessons) my confidence in myself and my abilities rose. I learnt to aim high for myself and that through hard work and commitment, I could reach my goals. This attitude transferred itself outside of my music lessons and into the classroom and my home life. I strongly believe that my 7 years of brass lessons have shaped who I am now. 30482018-06-15T10:50:16.7736854Andrew J ClubbLearning a musical instrument improves learning ability in other subjects30482018-06-15T11:47:39.4136856Marion CursiterMusic for togetherness, discipline, joy etc for the persons whole life.30482018-06-15T11:58:00.89736857Mary BradleyMusic is so important for all of Education.I cannot play anything but I saw the benefit of music lessons given to many of my pupils in the primary sector.30482018-06-15T12:56:27.73336858CONNER E H IRVINE Yes I fully agree. 30782018-06-15T13:16:24.83736859Sheena MacPhee Music is the fabric of our society. There is such a lot of emphasis on the CfE in health and wellbeing and access to musical tuition could greatly contribute not only to intellectual and emotional development but to self esteem and an ability to cope with anxiety. These are just SOME examples of why it is vital to keep investing in this area of the curriculum otherwise this generation will suffer.30482018-06-15T14:34:46.336860Kevin SmallAll state schools should have free tuition 30482018-06-15T17:08:30.62736861Fiona AndersonI received free music tuition at school which allowed me to develop a number of transferable skills - this should be available to all children in Scotland. 30482018-06-15T17:09:41.24336862Grace Boockholdt History is sacred!30032018-06-15T17:45:27.90336864Connor CranstonFree tuition has got me interested in music, and has kicked off a passion that will remain in my life forever. Taking free tuition away means that kids lose out on this opportunity, as I know I would not have found this passion had it not been freely available. Scottish education has historically been the best in the world, so keep it that way. Music is for everyone, not just the wealthy30482018-06-15T17:55:43.13336865Fred RutledgeKeep the historic sites in good order, not under concrete. Thanks.30032018-06-15T18:04:21.2836866Susan ThornborrowI was fortunate enough to have learnt to play the saxophone, flute and recorder as a child. It has been great for my confidence, discipline, team working and social skills. My parents were able to provide this experience for me it would be brilliant if the same opportunity was awarded to all children in Scotland.30482018-06-15T18:12:37.19736867May CurryMy Grandchildren have attended music for several years and given time outwith school. I believe tuition should be for all not for those who can afford it and those who will receive free places. There must be places for all who want to learn.30482018-06-15T18:22:32.91736868Emma BahlMusic should be accessible to all not a luxury only available to those who can afford it. 30482018-06-15T18:39:28.95736869Michaela ForestiWithout free music tuition in school I wouldn't be playing an instrument now 30482018-06-15T19:18:21.71336871John McMullenPlease don't make music only available to those who can afford to pay. Its too important and should be the right of all children.30482018-06-15T19:19:38.10336872Hannah Dickson Access to music tuition should not be dependent on whether you can pay!! It is as important as physical activity like sports and academic subjects and should be regarded as such by being offered with no cost attached!!30482018-06-15T19:28:48.91736873Emma MathiesonI received free music tuition at school and benefitted in many ways from this. 30482018-06-15T20:47:28.3536876Paul GunnionI am not musical, but I regret giving up my own piano lessons, as a greater degree of musical knowledge would have enhanced my love and enjoyment of all the music I enjoy. The two oldest of my five grandchildren are good musicians, in the pipe band movement, and my three younger grandchilden may have musical skills, but they need the opportunities to find out, and learn. This is why I am supporting this petition. 30482018-06-15T22:09:24.03336879Adrian RobertsonPlaying and performing music is a serious, viable career option and should be encouraged in pupils who have that as an aspiration in the same way STEM subjects, English and languages are. Playing music is also of incredible benefit to children and young people in terms of self-worth, self-confidence, teamwork, decision making and emotional intelligence. Scotland and the UK has an incredible track record in providing the world with music of incredible quality and worth in all genres and removing the skills the structure of learning the subject develops will impact on a multi-billion pound industry. If you don't know how important and far-reaching music is in your lift, try spending one day not listening to any. (that would mean no TV, radio, mobile phones etc)30482018-06-16T02:54:14.57336880Melanie BrickleyWe should have the courage to put music and the other arts in to the curriculum as core subjects, benefitting\r\nall children from year one. Music has many elements which encourage and improve learning and creative development.30482018-06-16T08:29:13.0136882Anne Marie Vance Wouldn't be where I am today if it wasn't for my free music lessons30482018-06-16T08:34:04.86336883Gail AddisWe have to give our children every chance in life, and access to musical instrument tuition should be available to all, regardless of their ability to pay. 30482018-06-16T09:10:11.7636886Anne WhittakerLet this not be a country where access to something as important as music is dependant on income.30482018-06-16T11:00:41.30736887Ian HowkerWhat epitomises the dysfunction of Scottish Canals could perhaps be summarised by:- At a meeting of Canal users about price increases for berthing charges, the public spent 2hr 15min telling anecdotal evidence about the (1), the poor service given, (2) the way in which money is wasted, (3) the poor way in which problems,identified by canal users, are dealt with, (4) the way in which canal users are treated by canal staff. I would argue that the users represented an even spread of socio economic adults. It is my understanding that this had happened at all the 3 canal meetings. I think there is a huge case for an independent, Water Ombudsman.30022018-06-16T14:02:09.8536888Mrs Marjory ProwAll children should have free music tuition. There are probably lots of talented children out there whose parents couldn't afford to pay the fees.30482018-06-16T15:18:53.04736889Sandy MathesonFree instrumental provision for children is crucial in a healthy society. We should be doing so much better.30482018-06-16T17:56:32.70736892Deborah MackFor a lot of children this will be their only opportunity to learn an instrument if families can't afford private tuition. There are so many other benefits to music and learning an instrument which should be part of standard school curriculum.\r\n30482018-06-16T18:26:12.6536893Catrina BrownI want my child to develop in music but i already have a tight budget and dont qualify for benefits..This is going to be a struggle and I may need to stop my child from lessons.30482018-06-16T20:04:17.41336895David SmithFundamentally, this is a question of equal opportunities. Music tuition should not become the preserve of the rich, those who can afford music lessons. Politicians constantly lambast musicians for music being elitist - here is an opportunity for politicians to do something to make music equally accessible to all classes of society.30482018-06-16T20:06:17.33736896Lewis ClarkeMusic is at the heart of Scotland, dont let it die out30482018-06-16T22:18:56.35336897Torbjorn Hultmark Music trains the brain, body and mind possibly more than any other pursuit. It develops and helps to sustain cultures. The ability to play a musical instrument fosters discipline and mental dexterity. It helps people into employment in countless work areas such as business, medicine and finance (and, if the are VERY lucky, in music). It helps people out of loneliness. It can develop a strong sense and knowledge of history. It creates physical and mental wellbeing. It fosters understanding and respect between people of different cultures. It helps cut the NHS bill. It is inexpensive to run. It is expensive NOT to run. Studies have shown that music tuition and the cultural industry pays for itself many times over. A developed and strong arts culture is the defining sign of a civilised society. 30482018-06-16T22:53:42.80736898Kirsteen A GrahamMusic - instrumental or singing - improves everything. Listening, learning, enjoyment of life and play - all these things are better with music.30482018-06-16T23:06:45.35736899Hannah HarpurI agree, the families the peace they need to heal as soon as possible 30782018-06-16T23:42:30.31336900Kathy GostickThe ombudsmen could ensure the best representation of the fragmented users of the canals to ensure the better management of them by Scottish canals particularly that the Forth & Clyde canal is re- opened to sea to sea navigation as required by statute and government grant conditions.30022018-06-17T00:39:24.91736902Alyson CampbellI feel that this is such an important learning opportunity on so many levels and it will disproportionately affect those pupils from less affluent backgrounds and they are the ones who may benefit most from the life skills of learning an instrument and being part of a band bring. 30482018-06-17T08:08:23.71736903Maggie ScottA disgrace that this is happening. Music tuition should be free for all. 30482018-06-17T08:49:04.57736904Ryan m Connor This is so important. It should never be cut...30482018-06-17T09:03:53.03336905Caroline CasselsFree music tuition should remain. Having to buy an instrument can already be a deterrent, but having to pay for tuition is definitely not going to help those most in need financially, who may have an undiscovered musical talent and who will never discover it because of the money issue. School should give opportunities not be a place where they are stunted.30482018-06-17T09:13:29.2136907Kevin Wickham Should be available free.30482018-06-17T09:17:08.84736908Vicki MurrayI would never have made it through my school years without my connection to music. The tuition and attending many orchestral and choir camps,tours etc, gave me as a shy, introverted girl skills, confidence and joy that I've carried with me my entire life. I've also see this with my own children and have watched family and friends develope fulfilling careers from this tuition also. Absolutely invaluable!!30482018-06-17T09:17:56.73736909Lisa BurnsLearning a musical instrument is so much more than just learning an instrument. It teaches our children discipline, patience and resilience. The choice should be available to all children and should not depend on where they live or how much their parents have to spend.30482018-06-17T09:24:53.22336910Glenda McFarlaneChildren should be given every opportunity to learn in every way possible.30482018-06-17T09:27:08.81736911Jacqueline KayI was fortunate to receive free instrumental tuition in school and went on to study music and have made it my career. Cuts to this service would mean many children missing out on learning an instrument and all the benefits that go with it. My children barely receive music lessons in school from class teachers and the specialist only visits P4 for a 12 week block. Music is an important part of the curriculum and the teaching of music and instruments must continue to be available to ALL students. 30482018-06-17T11:03:18.86336912Louise BrownFree instrumental music tuition is 100% needed in all schools. Not every child is academically bright some shine musically30482018-06-17T14:08:56.44336913Scott McMillan This is better than any computer game, and teaches kids a discipline...30482018-06-17T14:48:09.40736914David RobertsonI benefited from my music tuition in School, so did my wife and our children. This must continue.30482018-06-17T15:53:14.07336915Rachael Devanney I was lucky enough to receive free violin and voice lessons in school which were not only immensely enjoyable but improved my self-confidence, self-awareness and concentration. As a current History and Modern Studies teacher I cannot highlight enough the value of free musical tuition for pupils in schools, particularly in areas of deprivation and also in schools where sporting success is highly recognised and awarded (all skills are important, confidence is built in many ways!). Musical tuition in schools must continue to be free to access and in those areas which already have charges they must be kept minimal. 30482018-06-17T19:07:47.92336916David wilkesFree music tuition for all young people30482018-06-17T20:35:54.68736917Myles MarshsllI think it is very sad that music is effectively being withdrawn from schools, or at the very least being made financially challenging. Music is a factor in brain development and to see it leave or become unavailable will be detrimental to the education system. 30482018-06-17T21:27:42.46336920Ian ThomsonThe joy and experience of playing an instrument with your friends should be available to all, not just those with the available funds. 30482018-06-17T21:54:19.77336921Yan Yan Bowiemusc brings more than just academics to the world. To not have free instruction in schools today would be a great shame to the culture of Scotland. 30482018-06-17T22:05:11.46336922Barry McGowanGive kids an opportunity without placing their parents into financial hardship. 30482018-06-17T22:05:17.02736923Derek Turnbull X\r\n30782018-06-17T22:14:03.3736924Isabel PattenAll children should be given the opportunity of learning music and not all can afford to pay. I'm sure there are many good musicians and teachers who started with free school lessons. 30482018-06-17T22:19:27.27736925Martyn Sharpe As a boater with a long term mooring on the Forth and Clyde Canal I trusted Scottish Canals to protect the fabric of the canal, and the have failed to do so. We need an independent voice to ensure the waterway is preserved for future generations . We need someone who cares to save the canal from falling into dereliction. If no action is taken then there will be no boats on the canal. Why pay exhorbitant mooring fees when there broken bridges in every direction. How on earth did Scottish Canals allow this to happen...30022018-06-17T23:50:19.11736928Carmel StoneyKeeping music instruction free and available in schools is vital. Ive witnessed the performing arts overall receive less funding and support over the years despite the positive impact it has on children and despite a vast global industry that offers careers and opportunities to those who gain knowledge and qualifications from a curriculum that offers music and the arts. A very backward step. Shame on the Scottish government if it cannot see the damage this will inflict on our childrens futures. 30482018-06-18T04:35:03.0336929Ian MorganLosing a loved one is horrendous and very difficult, especially when it's a traumatic death. Family and friends need time to be able to plan their loved ones funeral, without causing any more pain and suffering than is necessary.30782018-06-18T06:51:29.5536930Isabelle McCraeHaving been taught piping at school myself I feel it very important to carry our culture and heritage on into the future with the younger generation. Highland dancing should also be offered as a lesson in schools too as that is also a very important part of our culture.30482018-06-18T07:49:54.4536931Sarah-Jane LintonIn pursuit of a true meritocracy, children should be musically educating without prejudice.30482018-06-18T08:20:28.70336932Madeleine HewlettMusic is just as important as any other school subject and should be available to everyone 30482018-06-18T10:32:38.03336933Marie MurrayA great opportunity for all.30482018-06-18T10:55:19.6236934John curranLet's save free education in our schools.30482018-06-18T14:30:12.37736939Juliet WilberforceIf you allow free music tuition you increase the numbers of citizens of Scotland of the future with resilience, inner confidence, team-working skills application, desire to succeed and be the best they can be, ability to attend to minute detail, and more. Music does more than sport. Please see sense.30482018-06-18T14:52:09.8836940Linda HaggartyThe gift of music is a wonderful thing. Learning music is amazing 30482018-06-18T15:06:50.6336941Anne ParkerMusic education and playing an instrument has proven benefits for all areas of living. It should be made available to all.30482018-06-18T16:01:41.44336943Kate WeirMusic plays a very important part in the lives of all humans from birth to death. Instrumental music services should be a given freely viable for all, not a lottery or for an elite only. All of the arts are being fragmented and Scotland should lead the way in ensuring they are restored and promoted.30482018-06-18T16:05:28.8236944Debi GlioriI strongly oppose the proposed charges for music tuition in schools. My daughter would not be studying music at university were it not for the free tuition at school. Very few families can afford this extra expense, especially in these straitened times. Art and music are rights, not privileges.30482018-06-18T16:54:53.0336945Catherine TaylorWe need music 30482018-06-18T17:04:58.41336946Lynn wilson9 kids in oyr school play... parents cannot afford to pay this fee... kids make up a band in school.. take children away no band!30482018-06-18T17:38:39.70736947Jillian LaughlinChildren should be encouraged to learn a musical instrument regardless of financial background, it can help them relax, gain confidence. All of this should be an inclusive part of the school curriculum30482018-06-18T18:20:45.49336948Louise MarshallI am very often referred to as "Scotland's National Piper" in the media, due to all the high profile events I perform at worldwide promoting our Scottish music, heritage and culture. I wouldn't be fortunate to be in this position if I hadn't been given free music tuition in my state school in the seventies. I think it is shocking that paying for tuition is even being considered in state schools in Scotland.\r\nI will be at the Parliament tomorrow, blasting out my bagpipes and will be heard!\r\n\r\n30482018-06-18T19:25:49.48736949Lorraine CushwayEvery child in Scotland should be able to learn to play an instrument. We should encourage children to take up a musical instrument not discourage them.30482018-06-18T19:28:28.92736950Jennifer Downie It is vital that children be given the opportunity to play a musical instrument. It can enhance their lives enormously and provide alternative career paths for some. It would be a travesty for funding to be cut for music and the arts. 30482018-06-18T20:42:22.22336953Sid PomperFree instrumental music services is a perfect way to grow music capable persons in Scotland. 30482018-06-18T21:29:33.85336955Kieran YoungInstrumental music should not ever be an income driven opportunity. Music is the one of the only options children and adults have to share in a teamwork experience, working in an exceptionally unique and educational setting. Music is the ONLY universal language - in a time where Scotland is reaching out to the rest of the world, we should be broadcasting loud and clear the talents of ALL of our young people for everyone to hear.30482018-06-18T22:10:56.73336956Linda LeggettPlease reassure us that our excellent medical practice will continue to serve us without change. 30722018-06-18T22:16:26.37736957Louisa GawnEvery child should have the access to musical education and the opportunity to learn a musical instrument and their families wealth or lack of wealth should not get in the way of this. Music has always been a huge part of my life and that started at school in Aberdeen with free musical tuition and the free ensembles alongside this. Countless studies have shown the benefits to a child's whole education if music is also a part of this, the benefits are felt throughout the whole school and in the wider community. Scotland has a fantastic heritage of music that we are in danger of losing if fees are imposed on the individual. I would love it if the Scottish government took the lead on this and showed the rest of the country that it believes music in schools for every child is a right, then hopefully other governments will follow your lead.30482018-06-18T23:00:59.2436958Maureen lundyMusic is essential for many different parts of life helping learn other subjects relaxation and expressing ourselves easily30482018-06-18T23:29:33.46336959Michele GuadagnoliCulloden should be kept intact and complete as a historical site with such important history30032018-06-18T23:36:55.18336960Thelma IngramWhen your nearest A and E is 50 minutes away by car and not accessible by public transport. GP surgeries in rural areas and small towns need very good staffing of the main medical professions so we are secure medically in rural areas and remote communities.30722018-06-19T00:00:07.4236961Nakki GoraninIt is morally and ethically wrong to build on or by a development on the blood and bones of people who fought for political rights and the privilege of having the right to choose their own religious faith... Regardless of where you live we, as world citizens, must respect those who fought for the right to have dignity and freedom.30032018-06-19T09:12:14.37336963LoisMonica MackayAll of my children played instruments at school and I have grandchildren that play instruments too. But sadly I see that some countries are stopping music lessons. How sad and misguided. The benefits outweigh the cost.30482018-06-19T09:15:40.01336964Isla SkinnerAccess to the valuable experience of learning an instrument is a vital aspect of excellence in education. Don't let it be the province of the affluent elite.30482018-06-19T13:18:33.9136968Janet RutledgeMusic is fundamental to children's learning, as well as instrumental to their mental health. As Plato said "Music is a moral law. It gives soul to the universe, wings to the mind, flight to the imagination, and charm and gaiety to life and to everything." 30482018-06-19T18:21:33.65336972Lucy McNaughtonMusic is a way to express yourself and if this is taken away then children are not given this right. 30482018-06-19T20:37:14.30336974Diane BrownWithout free music tuition in school, myself and my brother would not have been able to access music tuition which was inspirational and provided so many opportunities for us. Both of us going on to gain degrees in music! As an instructor you see the cuts being made and the impact it has on families. Why should children have limited access to music which is part of the curriculum. Classroom teachers are fantastic but they cannot single handedly teach all instruments, each instrument has its own set of complexities and this art is dying..if we don't teach our next generation on musicians where will we get our next generation of orchestral players, jazz musicians or in fact instrumentalists for any genre...\r\nNot to mention the benefits from research studies in to the impact music has on raising attainment, the social impact of joining together to perform or the positive impact music has on health and well-being. 30482018-06-19T20:48:29.08736975Tracey ConwayAs a Singer Singing Teacher Choir leader and a new mum Im desperately sad that this opportunity is not available to everyone who would like it. Music has carried me through life in work love and play\r\nIt not only give you a well rounded education it teaches you transferable skills and is socially inclusive Money or the lack there of shouldnt stop children experiencing Music30482018-06-19T22:15:12.1136977Kathleen McArthurYes I agree to both options below.30782018-06-19T23:01:19.36336978Jane Hasler Please give the future generations of Scotland the chance to learn music and an instrument - I never learned to read but the joy of learning to play a guitar and sing is priceless to me. Imagine if every child in Scotland and the Uk got to learn to read music properly and play - along with our genes and musicality - what an amazing future unfolds for all 30482018-06-19T23:05:21.4936979Jane Hasler I never got to learn music or play an instrument by reading music a regret I will hold to my dying day, but I did get taught the guitar at school\r\nThe joy that opened was priceless. Please give the future generations a real chance of learn i music and an instrument - the richness that will bring to them and their communities is worth billions 30482018-06-19T23:19:31.85736980Maeghan BanksI think music should be free as any other extra curricular activity in school time. 30482018-06-19T23:43:00.27736981Norma AmiesAll children should have access to music free of charge.30482018-06-20T00:52:14.86336982Catherine fultonThis also happened to my pals brother and i feel really strongly about this 30782018-06-20T05:14:51.8236983Mandy PatonArchaic part of the law,must change.30782018-06-20T08:11:14.00336984Paul RussellGood luck with your campaign Amanda, I hope you get to lay your brother to rest soon.30782018-06-20T09:19:36.46736985Ian Barnesonce facts evidence have been gained to keep secure the society then the human in question must be released to the family loved ones.30782018-06-20T09:20:39.60736986wanda GillespieThis law has to be changed to bring us in line with England and Wales . At a time when families are going through tremendous trauma it is cruel to add to their burden. In this time of digital technology there is no need to keep families waiting to bury their loved ones.30782018-06-20T10:40:40.36736988David PhillipsI'm sorry for your loss Amanda, I read about your petition on BBC news and 100% agree the law should be changed.\r\nDavie.30782018-06-20T11:17:08.68336989Joyce BowieAs soon as possible30782018-06-20T11:18:58.53336990Lynn McveyPlease allow bodies to have a 2nd post Morton and then be released to their family so a funeral can take place.30782018-06-20T14:26:19.136992Bernard Manson It's awful30782018-06-20T14:28:25.80336993Alexander Miller Shocking30782018-06-20T14:29:43.74336994Alexander Scullion Awful30782018-06-20T15:41:50.16336995William McNeilSigned30782018-06-20T15:55:30.73736996Jacqueline RadfordI think this is very important to all the family's in this situation to have closure and put there loved ones to rest as soon as possible. 30782018-06-20T16:30:37.68736997Kevin WoodburnAnother shocking example of the system letting scottish families down. Post mortem rules again. The judiciary must listen to the public they are there to serve. Scandalous,Let this family grieve properly. 30782018-06-20T17:32:30.81336998jasmin gordonplease allow them some peace and closure by allowing them to lay him to rest.30782018-06-20T18:37:26.6137000Jenny LongFamilies of murder victims should be able to make funeral arrangements for their loved ones as soon as possible should they wish to.\r\nI would support the idea of a second post mortem to be carried out independently. 30782018-06-20T19:27:41.41337001Michele Burns This has to be changed to allow families to grieve for their loved ones 30782018-06-20T21:55:47.64737006david stewartperhaps some common sense and sensitivity should be applied for families in these positions30782018-06-21T08:32:45.8237007Stacey Wood-EverettI totally agree the law in Scotland needs to change as families are not let grieve properly after the horrific deal of murder as they cannot Bury their family member until the accused legal team say they can. My childhood friends brother was murdered they were lucky as his body was released relatively quick but still longer than if it had been over the border in England or Wales. 30782018-06-21T08:54:34.35337009James Stevenson GrantHaving returned from a holiday in Uzbekistan my awareness of the necessity to protect historic sites has been greatly increased. They are a legacy which should be protected for future generations. 30032018-06-22T07:29:43.92337010MAUREEN Welsh Please sign30782018-06-24T08:35:29.43737012Tiegan Kilcullen Yes I do agree , bereavement is painful enough , this is just prolonging the suffering of this family .30782018-06-24T10:47:08.59337013Lynda philpS support30782018-06-25T05:59:16.53737014William Allison It is time for the boy to rip30782018-06-27T08:03:06.32337016Joan Morgan At present we have excellent medical care from our local surgery, which we cannot afford to lose due to our relatively isolated location.30722018-06-27T08:44:27.1837017Mary Braithwaite160 people live on the isle of Luing. We have an excellent local GP surgery, and believe the new GP contract will impact negatively on the delivery of health care. Many older folk do not have a car, and there is already too much pressure on voluntary car driving taking folk to the surgery and Oban for appointments. The new GP contract MUST be rethought where rural and remote surgeries are concerned.30722018-06-27T08:59:13.84737018Phyllis MalcolmThe concerns of rural medical practices are more than echoed by their patients who rely on them to provide their service in an efficient and patient centred manner. Alterations to this successful model do not make sense 30722018-06-27T12:11:27.89337020Norman BissellThe new GP Contract fails to take account of the needs of rural and island patients and will worsen the provision of health care in these areas. There should be a different formula agreed within the new Contract that applies to rural and island GPs to enable the current excellent level of service to be maintained. The public meeting held on the Isle of Luing in March 2018 was the largest in living memory and indicates the serious concerns amongst island patients about this issue.30722018-06-27T12:52:47.68337021Nigel IngsWe live on an island and are currently provided with unsurpassed all-round primary care by the practice on the adjacent island. Routine tasks, vaccinations, dispensing, repeat prescriptions are all carried out in one place. The possibility that these services will be taken away and centralised in Oban, at least an hour's travel away is horrible to contemplate. Those without the capacity to drive will be critically disadvantaged. At present our community is well able to look after the modest transport needs entailed in getting to the GP, but finding someone to drive you to Oban will be problematical. Our wonderful GPs and Practice nurses do everything from routine blood tests and vaccinations to rapidly setting up specialist appointments. Nothing will damage the Scottish NHS and its reputation more than pressing ahead with changes that will be highly detrimental to remote and rural populations. Not everyone in Scotland lives in the Central Belt - and we're all voters!30722018-06-27T13:28:57.1137022Zoe FlemingI have a long-term condition and require prescription medicines daily and cannot always drive 20 miles to Oban if the nearest surgery cannot supply. The health matters of a small island community cannot safely be catered for from facilities a ferry ride and a 20 mile drive away. \r\nThe whole island community is really concerned about this development, as half the community is over 60 and others approaching that age.\r\n\r\nWe request that this whole approach to remote rural and island communities is re-thought with proper consultation, not just open meeting consultations 20 miles away in the evening when we have no vehicle ferry.30722018-06-28T18:37:26.35337023Linda LeggettIf our GP services are not rural-proofed, I would find it hard to get to the hospital for routine procedures. This journey would take an hour as opposed to 20 minutes to our surgery.30722018-06-29T09:37:37.96337024Martin LeggettI am self employed on the island and would lose money and work if I had to travel to hospital for routine procedures that are currently carried out at our excellent local medical practice. 30722018-06-29T09:44:17.74337025Linda Michelle LeggettWe have an excellent service provided by our local Easdale Medical Practice, which will be compromised if rural proofing our surgery does not happen. There are too many people especially elderly folk, who would find it very hard to get to appointments at hospital and with an ageing population, this problem is only going to worsen.30722018-06-29T16:43:23.64737027Bruce MacDougallI know that Theresa May will refuse but we don't need her approval.30792018-06-29T17:00:15.41737028Alison DowNow is the time!30792018-06-29T17:04:51.91737029james strachanwe need to go independent now \r\n30792018-06-29T17:05:29.35337030Robert MackayLets get external vigilators in this time, appointed by EU not Westminster, different company, no vested interest!30792018-06-29T17:15:39.1237031Alison DowWe must stand up for Scotland now! 30792018-06-29T17:18:39.24737032Indycar Gordon Ross (indigo)Time has almost run out. We must vote soon or lose our parliament our devolved government and our entire country to a far right foreign power.30792018-06-29T17:34:41.09337033Alison DowTo support our desire for Independence asap. Free from the this one sided and unjust Union30792018-06-29T17:36:29.2537034Jillian EastwoodI believe that the UK government has never had any intention of allowing Scotland to ever be incharge of their own destiny as they are well aware the lies they have told about subsidising Scotland is in fact the opposite and they actually require all of Scotlands resources to be able to survive Brexit. Scotland is big enough, rich enough and strong enough to be successful in their own right, and this unequal union needs to be brought to an end before they completely bring this country to its knees along side them.30792018-06-29T17:57:55.1637035Kevin PenneyIts time for Scotland to cut out the political cancer that is Westminster. A new referendum run in, and counted in Scotland in front of witnesses, with Postal votes verified please!!!!30792018-06-29T18:04:39.31737036Barry Morrison For the sake of this country and for future generations please call this before it is too late it is our last chance I think30792018-06-29T18:21:53.3537037Raymond Reid I formally signed this petition because I want my country of Scotland to be free and INDEPENDENT from England and Westminster rule.30792018-06-29T18:23:53.92737038Agnes Reid I believe Scotland should be free and INDEPENDENT from England and Westminster 30792018-06-29T18:51:43.1837039Dale handy I believe my country would benefit me and my family and everyone else in Scotland if we were independent. I see and read every day how Westminster treat our snp and our people off Scotland with total disrespect and contempt ..scotland is wealthy and a believe our parliament could do better thing for the sovereign PEOPLE of Scotland 30792018-06-29T19:45:00.54737041Fiona Glasgow Save us please!30792018-06-29T19:47:08.34737042Lorna Black We need reassurance that we can use and maintain any sections we need to, for the right of Scotland and it's people, including Section 3030792018-06-29T19:52:39.14337043Fiona Davidson Bring it on30792018-06-29T20:04:27.20737044Margaret BurnsWe need our country back NOW30792018-06-29T20:32:46.99337045ricky milnei want to get scotland free from the opreshion from the uk30792018-06-29T21:18:44.2537047Joseph Douglas This is my Country and I want Scotland to control it.30792018-06-29T21:26:11.18737048Helen fluckerScotland is a nation and deserves to be in charge of her own destiny. She is not and has never been a region of England. Brexit has made it imperative to break the union with England. 30792018-06-29T21:52:21.3637049Mary JenkinsI truly believe Scotland is capable of being a very successful independent country! One that I want to live in! 30792018-06-29T21:57:40.50337050Gail MacKinnon I want to see a second referendum 30792018-06-29T21:59:10.3337051Joseph Douglas I demand a move forward to Independence Now30792018-06-29T22:03:59.47337052LYDIA REID This ia what everybody wants but at the right time 30792018-06-29T22:06:51.33337053Jim OlihantScotland only wants to be like any other NORMAL COUNTRY and control its own affairs and be in charge of its own destiny. by ending Westminsters Rule.30792018-06-29T22:31:16.7137054Michael morrisWe're ready\r\n30792018-06-29T23:13:48.62337055James. StephenScotland should be. Independent. Governed by Scots for scots30792018-06-29T23:28:25.3937056Robert AdamsIndependence ASAP.30792018-06-30T01:23:14.4937057William KerrI fully support this petition, the Scottish people have a right to call for this.30792018-06-30T10:44:58.5237061Robert Sloan Our parliament is being devalued and disrespected. We are in a dictatorship and not a union of equals. If WM deam the the Scot Govt is pushing to far it is their job to negotiate via coperarive work rather than taking their dictatorial stand. This is certainly not a democratic strategy!30792018-06-30T11:01:21.7937063John Keenan McCueWe were well warned that this would happen during indy ref 2014. 30792018-06-30T11:50:19.09337064Andrew D Doyletime for change,,Scotland must prevail...30792018-06-30T14:06:29.72337065Bruce MoneyIn my view it is essential that Scotland breaks it's ties with Westminster, and the corrupt self-serving politicians who operate there, and becomes independent, if it is to flourish and reach its potential.30792018-06-30T15:57:24.54737066William Milligan Go for it30792018-06-30T23:51:27.65737067Diane DavidsonReally annoying that I had to put UK as my "Country"\r\nNormally refuse to do that but have made an exception.30792018-07-01T00:13:15.59737068Eric NelsonScotland needs to be independent now 30792018-07-01T01:02:28.37337070Mary CavinPlease give us the opportunity to become an Independent nation again.30792018-07-01T10:02:22.70737071Dougie BendallNow is the time.30792018-07-01T10:27:44.70337072David Jack Before brexit30792018-07-01T10:42:16.92337074Terry WallsIn light if the debacle which is Brexit, and the impending erstanding of Scotland, we must now become Independent to ensure our continued national identity.30792018-07-01T10:52:12.7937075Susan Swanson Scotland needs independence now 30792018-07-01T10:54:46.94737077ian mcneilRequire another mandate30792018-07-01T11:06:57.54337078Edward ReidFully support independence. Our parliament is under attack.30792018-07-01T11:09:53.8837079Andrew Robertson Scotland This is a necessity for democracy to be effective 30792018-07-01T11:11:14.1637080Chris C.HoodCan'you come soon enough30792018-07-01T11:15:20.4237081Andrew Barr This is needed so we can take steps to right some wrongs, lead to a better future with governance from those that work for the people. 30792018-07-01T11:24:35.55337082David Tyrrell Time to act 30792018-07-01T11:27:40.3637083Tina CairnsFaith Over Fear30792018-07-01T11:31:44.1537084Mark Whitelaw Unchain Scotland from the last tyranny of the Empire. 30792018-07-01T11:36:10.86737086Thomas friar Give us a new referendum as we are Scottish and the vow was a lie 30792018-07-01T11:45:3637087Jo Walls Time to leave before we sink in the brexit ship 30792018-07-01T11:53:30.89337088Susan Copland An independent country is normal 30792018-07-01T11:55:53.2637089GARY BEAVISGet us out of Westminsters corupt rule 30792018-07-01T11:56:31.28337090Andrew McNellyHold the referendum asap30792018-07-01T12:01:52.737091Brian ReidI support the petition PEO1700 the Parliament of Scotland is sovereign by the people for the people 30792018-07-01T12:03:47.97337092Anne HillWe need independence 30792018-07-01T12:05:03.13737093John BarryWe desperately need Independence before Brexit 30792018-07-01T12:19:32.6337094Catherine KerrUpwards and onwards to freedom from Westminster and independence for Scotland30792018-07-01T12:21:41.53737095Isabel CooneyScotland must be given the opportunity to decide its own future.30792018-07-01T12:28:07.48337096John Hughes Let's go for it big time and let's make it stick this time 30792018-07-01T12:37:11.99337098Bryan Mclean Scotland needs another referendum on independence 30792018-07-01T12:38:33.03337099Ian taitOnwards and upwards30792018-07-01T12:42:42.9437100Allan Stevenson It's now or never,let's stop wasting time and call it.. 30792018-07-01T12:55:54.47337101James RennieRise and be a nation again30792018-07-01T13:06:29.72337102kate macleanimportant step forward to independence from terrible southern decision-making30792018-07-01T13:08:57.9937103Julie BrownPlease make it possible on the drop down list of countries to select Scotland and not have to select UK. I'm surprised this hasn't been resolved30792018-07-01T13:15:07.637104Jean maclarenWe must have our say30792018-07-01T13:22:16.07737105Donna SweeneyNeed out of UK union sharpish30792018-07-01T13:30:27.1837107Jacqui NicholThis NEEDS to be done. The Scots are a proud people and willing to work and make our nation a stronger and more stable place to live30792018-07-01T13:56:23.22337108Wendy WatsonWe need to be an independent country. I believe Westminster lied and cheated with the original vote30792018-07-01T14:07:29.75737109Johnny wilsonFully support anything to do with independence that' gets Scotland away from the corrupt west monster30792018-07-01T14:07:56.69337110Marion PlunkettThe promises made by the UK Government's elected members to the people of Scotland in 2014 have been proven to be, at best only marginally met and at worst, entirely false.\r\nBREXIT being forced upon Scotland, despite our overwhelming majority to remain in the EU is a constitutional breaking point.\r\nThe UK government seeking & obtaining Royal Assent for BREXIT whilst there is an ongoing legal case over the Continuity Bill just makes an absolute mockery of any claims that Scotland is an "Equal Partner" in the "UK" and is a clear indication of how that particular court case will rule...it WON'T be in Scotland's favour. \r\nThe UK Parliaments denial of a decent debate is another affront to democracy. The lack of ANY clear, concise information about the BREXIT negotiations at Ministerial and Public levels is gravely concerning. Given the utterly disgraceful treatment of Scotland by the UK government since 2014...the Vow, Smith, Sewell, BREXIT etc, our "partnership" within the UK context is no longer valid.\r\nScotland is a country not a region.\r\nAs a Scottish citizen, I am asking for the Scottish Government to begin the process of securing the necessary paperwork required to authenticate a referendum on independence for Scotland.\r\nThank you.30792018-07-01T14:08:57.69337111Andrew Quigley Scotland needs to be able to protect it's self and it's people.30792018-07-01T14:11:03.11737112Elaine McLeish I have a supporter of independence 30792018-07-01T14:11:30.3937113Jane CondieI voted yes the last time and I will be voting yes this time30792018-07-01T14:13:22.37337114Agnes StevensonWe need to get independence sooner than later we can see what is going to happen to our people if we don't 30792018-07-01T14:13:26.08337115mick mcmailsaor alba30792018-07-01T14:29:47.4437116Angela HazardThis must happen30792018-07-01T14:34:52.88337117Jason Coogans Scotland needs its independence #inde230792018-07-01T14:38:56.86337118Gary ScottI support this petition30792018-07-01T14:45:37.5937119Mhairis StruitheanSigned and shared30792018-07-01T15:05:50.17737120Andrew GordonAye please30792018-07-01T15:09:51.91337121Donald ShankieWe demand the right to choose30792018-07-01T15:11:12.45337122Janet CroallFree Scotland!30792018-07-01T15:11:36.93737123Donald ShankieEach nation deserves the right to choose its own destiny30792018-07-01T15:18:20.3937124Dorothy RussellNo comment30792018-07-01T15:19:33.18737125Arran laurence I agree with this petition 30792018-07-01T15:21:31.95337126Dorothy Russell No comment30792018-07-01T16:15:17.77337128Alexandra Bryden\r\nTo ask the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to seek a section 30 order from the UK Government to enable it to bring forward legislation in the Scottish Parliament to hold a second referendum on Scotland's independence from the United Kingdom30792018-07-01T16:54:42.90337129David Cairney We must be free from Westminster and the disaster that is brexit 30792018-07-01T17:25:58.13337130Craig mungallAye30792018-07-01T18:26:07.88337131James Stewart Wallace Independence is the only way forward for Scotland. \r\nTo think otherwise is to deny the truth. 30792018-07-01T18:48:35.57737132Mary StevensonFor Scotland to survive, we need our Independence30792018-07-01T19:18:57.7337133Fiona WatsonWe need this in place so that once we know the terms of brexit we can make an informed decision for scotland30792018-07-01T19:41:08.97337134Sandra DolanProud to help 30792018-07-01T20:00:31.65737135Calum WalkerEnough is enough. We are not served by Westminster, it's time for self determination!30792018-07-01T20:08:48.58737136Mairtin GardnerFor an Independent Socialist Scotland30792018-07-01T20:18:20.35337137liz mcpheeI ask the Scottish parliament to seek a section 30 order as I believe that a second referendum is long over due .30792018-07-01T20:20:57.12737138Barbara BalfourI want Scottish Independence ASAP.\r\n\r\n30792018-07-01T20:22:18.337139Donna rafferty Please please please we need this done and dusted before it's too late!30792018-07-01T20:24:21.86337140Heather HuntWe need to tell Westminster that we want our Freedom and we will not be silenced30792018-07-01T20:26:02.2737141Kenneth MacKinnonGo before the end of this year.30792018-07-01T20:32:06.60737142Barbara BalfourI want Scottish Independence ASAP.30792018-07-01T20:32:21.93337143Mr Brian MacDonaldThe sooner the better. 30792018-07-01T20:34:25.96337144KIRSTY Greig Nc30792018-07-01T20:49:32.11737145Suzanne Forbes_MurrayScotland is a forward thinking caring country we should and shall be free of Westminster 30792018-07-01T21:14:21.33737146George dunnLets get this section 30 order put in and leave 30792018-07-01T21:23:07.20737147Deborah ReillyScot Gov already have a mandate to call another indyrefbut I am happy to sign30792018-07-01T21:24:46.99737148Edith O'DELLWe need to get out freedom for. Westminster30792018-07-01T21:38:17.89737150John McIntoshWhen Scotland becomes Independent ____ I'll be back !!!\r\n30792018-07-01T22:18:22.69737151Janette MacRaeI have signed this petition as I believe democracy in Scotland is at risk & we need a referendum to decide our future. 30792018-07-01T22:27:55.66737152Laura HaughtonSoon as possible, we need this30792018-07-01T22:45:05.73337155Sharon GovanThis is a must and absolutely necessary!30792018-07-02T00:01:54.84737156Evelyn Milligan It has never been more important to leave the uk\r\n It has never been in our interest and with brexit our powers will be eroded. Mundell and his 3000 civil servants should have a wasted journey. We need a vote before brexit. 30792018-07-02T00:14:11.0237157Alex QuinneySelf government for Scotland, by the Scottish people.30792018-07-02T00:31:51.4337158Gina Singleton Livingston SCOTLANDLet this be the start of Independence30792018-07-02T01:24:45.18737159Alan ReillyPlease believe this is right.freedom.30792018-07-02T03:16:23.8137160donald fraseri for one will vote for a section 30 order30792018-07-02T05:48:00.03737161Susan BrownScotland urgently needs independence to survive.30792018-07-02T06:43:11.29737162Alex brownThe will of the people30792018-07-02T08:29:44.4837164Scott Richardson, AustraliaSaor Alba30792018-07-02T10:37:52.11337165Tooti CadzowWe live on the Island of Luing and it already takes us a ferry ride and 25 minutes drive just to get to Easdale Medical Practise. if it all went to Oban it would be incredibly difficult for the elderly and carless people. It is hard enough trying to get people to live on the Island and our numbers drop yearly PLEASE do not exacerbate this.30722018-07-02T12:25:44.59737166Elaine DeighanFreedom30792018-07-02T17:09:58.3437168Jean sommervilleFirst class Scotland Supporter 30792018-07-02T18:30:08.91337169Angus fergusonSooner the better30792018-07-02T19:19:57.0237170Ann BallingerChoosing an optimum time for this please 30792018-07-02T21:11:36.63337171Henry GreigI look forward to this transpiring. I hope in my lifetime. 30792018-07-02T23:32:07.2637172Thelma BanksWe must have a section 30 order.30792018-07-03T15:00:39.58337173Angela McLeodShould this "Contract" succeed, there will be a huge added cost required for helicopters to outlying areas.30722018-07-03T18:13:27.71737174Anita King We need this ASAP 30792018-07-03T20:50:45.77337175Ann BowesScotland needs independence.30792018-07-04T14:50:58.1537176John Goodwin LindsayAt the last referendum people were cofused by a lot of mis-information from the better together campaign wich has clearly been shown to have been wrong.30792018-07-04T15:53:30.76737177Linda Donnelly I am Scottish born and sovereign I am also European 30792018-07-04T17:17:54.98337178Marie SpencerI believe it is paramount that a section 30 is sought, for the people of Scotland to maintain links with the EU and to have control over our own futures.30792018-07-04T17:40:58.39737179Donald MacaulayWe ARE a country!\r\nWe ARE a sovereign people!30792018-07-04T23:22:05.9537180Gary ThomsonA vote before brexit30792018-07-05T06:35:09.2337182derek grayIt is of great concern that Westminster has and wants more control over Scotland.\r\nEverything positive we want to achieve as a nation relies solely on our independence before Brext.\r\nA new section 30 order is only 1 of many options we should look at including a vote in hollyrood to dissolve the union wirhout a vote being put to the public.\r\nI wholeheartedly trust my SNP government to act in my interests and will support whichever option they persue.30792018-07-05T09:08:35.92337183Kelly ReidScotland needs a second independence referendum and we need it urgently!! 30792018-07-05T10:11:21.88337184Sandra v eelesWe are already sovereign and just confirming it to the average public 30792018-07-05T22:33:46.8437185Gemma WellsAs a home owner on the Isle of Luing I truly believe that the service we currently receive from the local doctors is outstanding, and the new GP contract would without a doubt have a negative impact on this. There are a large number of elderly residents living here and they should be able to feel safe in the knowledge that they will be well looked after. That does not mean having to start travelling further afield or feel that they have been abandoned. Therefore there needs to be special consideration about the impact the new GP contract will have on rural and island communities like ourselves.30722018-07-05T22:44:34.37337186Carole WellsThe new GP contract is not appropriate for those of us who live in rural and island communities, as it does not continue to deliver the current standard of service we receive. Currently our local area is well looked after by a team of professionals who never fail to make you feel safe and well cared for. The changes that would need to be made if the new GP contract came in to full swing would threaten our health and well being.30722018-07-05T22:44:34.73337187Carole WellsThe new GP contract is not appropriate for those of us who live in rural and island communities, as it does not continue to deliver the current standard of service we receive. Currently our local area is well looked after by a team of professionals who never fail to make you feel safe and well cared for. The changes that would need to be made if the new GP contract came in to full swing would threaten our health and well being.30722018-07-07T09:41:44.57737188Alison MacleodIt has been more and more challenging over the last ten years to recruit GPs to remote rural areas like Applecross. This new contract may well make it impossible. The erosion of medical support to remote rural areas is going to reinforce the existing trend of depopulation, which we, as communities, are fighting so hard to resist. 30722018-07-09T01:03:41.2437189Frances McKiePlease also examine constitutional history since 1707 to confirm sovereignty of Scottish People in asserting our right to hold a plebiscite or referendum and to declare independence when a majority support this through manifestos of political parties in an election.30792018-07-09T19:44:37.18337192LYDIA REIDIt is hard for most people to understand the need to bury our loved ones\r\nThe thought that our relative is lying with no respect in a morgue is hard to live with \r\nOn the other hand Police Scotland have a job to do \r\nRules have a reason \r\nIt does seem that an independent Post Mortem could be carried by someone from England Ireland or Wales \r\nThey have no agenda \r\nI doubt they would cost more \r\nIt would allow the defense of any person charged to feel they have achieved an independent Post Mortem \r\nIt would allow the family to bury their loved one \r\nThe defense could carry out any tests on the resulting blocks and slides resulting from a post mortem \r\nGood luck to this family\r\nI hope this works out for you 30782018-07-09T21:54:50.56337193Darren GrayTime for action.30792018-07-09T22:17:39.18737194Bob MackayThe incompetence of the UK Government is staggering and worsening as the weeks go by. Scotland must be allowed to choose its own path.30792018-07-09T22:18:00.00337195Mark R Whittet Scotland's Independence Referendum Party\r\nwww.SIRP.Scot30792018-07-09T22:19:17.95737196mark whittetScotlands Independence Referendum Party30792018-07-09T22:30:37.0237197David CowanAlthough I have signed this petition, I think that the Scottish government has the right to declare independence from what is now clearly a failing UK government.30792018-07-09T23:01:48.58337199Alison DowThe time has come! Scotland is big enough, rich enough and too sensible to stay in the Union!30792018-07-09T23:20:29.85337200Colin Hamilton Independence yes please the time is right 30792018-07-09T23:24:24.11737201Linda BairdYes30792018-07-09T23:26:51.0937202philip mcfarlaneour day has come30792018-07-09T23:45:04.82337203David StevensonFault in the petition - the UK is not a country, let alone the country of Scotland I live in!\r\n30792018-07-10T00:32:30.34737204Susan MorrisonNow IS the time!30792018-07-10T02:23:21.81337205Lynn DaviesAlthough I am English-born, and a resident of England, I passionately believe in Scotland's right to self-determination. The reality is that Scotland could do so much better as an independent nation, and while England continues to go down the dead-end road of vicious neoliberalism, Scotland's best chance to save itself - and set an admirable example - to break free from the colonialists of Westminster. The sooner the better.30792018-07-10T02:40:53.45737206William KerrI support this action30792018-07-10T08:10:45.87337207Andrew QuigleyWe Scotland as a Nation need to be free to make our own history!30792018-07-10T09:55:54.23737208Carole BroadfootWe can't go on any longer with the tory goverment30792018-07-10T10:21:56.2837209Christopher Bruce They will be slow\r\nThey will say no\r\nBut we'll explain how\r\nIt's going to be NOW. 30792018-07-10T10:58:46.19737210Dorothy PooleWe need Independence as soon as possible, we don't want to be apart of what's going on at Westminster. There clashing it as British, which it is not. We must urge for the right as sovereign people of Scotland to choose what type of government we want.30792018-07-10T11:13:38.10737211Florence Gardner Please hold Indy 2 Before Westminster totally destroys Scotland .30792018-07-10T12:04:25.6737212Chic conroyWE DESERVE TO BE A FREE COUNTRY.30792018-07-10T12:54:42.1337213Ronald McGregorIndependence a must for Scotland.30792018-07-10T13:11:26.94337214Dale handy I believe Scotland would prosper being independent for the good of the people of Scotland 30792018-07-10T17:20:44.77737216Mark ConnerNo victim of murder or their family should be left in limbo like this. Two independent post-mortem examinations can be carried out ASAP and the results passed onto the PFs office and to any defence lawyer when a person is charged. The victims body should be released to their fsmikieuthin days. 30782018-07-10T20:17:02.1937217Geraldine DiversI am not afraid of hard work , get the date right and its game on. However please make sure you use the media you combat as much of SNPbad and lies about too wee etc.30792018-07-10T21:07:49.67737218Jackie Clark We need to be free of the Tory government asap - to build a better life for future generations in SCOTLAND! Brexit will reduce our chance to do this.30792018-07-10T21:25:42.65337219Gordon LeePlease, before its too late!!30792018-07-11T10:56:14.9537220Thomas HarveyWe need our independence now before the TORY drag SCOTLAND into quicksand the way they are with the rest of BRITAIN please give us OUR vote for independence 30792018-07-11T13:37:30.03337221Dr Patrick MulcahyThe current GP funding formula in Scotland hugely discriminates against rural practice Is not fit for purpose and needs urgent modification 30722018-07-11T22:44:12.29737222Matthew RalphI urge the Scottish Government to call a date for Indy ref 2 we're all ready just waiting on you.30792018-07-14T11:08:10.7937223Catriona TrottKnowing someone who often needs urgent medical attention I value the services of our local GP surgery. Without these services many people would not countenance living here.30722018-07-14T14:11:13.96737224Gail GreigThe current contract may help some urban areas to establish multi-disciplinary teams, along the lines rural practices have had for years. But asking health boards or HSCPs to organise them means they will never be part of the real primaryn healthcare team as they will have a centralised, acute-sector culture. They will never be nimble enough to be truly primary-care oriented around our needs as individual patients. And the current formula only works for larger populations where the worried well constantly beat a path to GPs, who tend to over-refer to their consultant hospital colleagues, and thus spend a lot of time writing letters rather than providing hands-on services to patients. The plans will fragment an increasingly fragmented service, making General Practice a boring and even more frustrating job. Please, give Rural GPs the means and respect to do the job many have always done, providing high levels of continuity of care, working with colleagues they know and trust (and frequently employ) to help rural patients receive accurate diagnoses, have personalised treatment plans, and avoid hospital admission wherever possible. Rural GPs are used to looking after and overseeing care for patients with complex needs. Rural patients are used to that approach. Rural patients largely consult when necessary and can be more resilient because the service has been so good, although poorly understood in larger towns and cities, by both Health Boards and the BMA. If the kind of practice described here is what the contract is trying to achieve, try supporting rural GPs, particularly those with GP community hospitals that still work (and are not geriatrician outposts) to see how interesting and fulfilling this type of practice can be for GPs, and how good it can be for patient outcomes. Then we might start to see the tap of never-ending unnecessary referrals to secondary and tertiary care turned off,thereby improving working conditions for consultants,reducing iatrogenic harm30722018-07-17T18:15:21.3137225Brian HeatonI have been using my local GP survey for the last 15 years and have always received a great service. The new contract threatens the service we receive and for the 1st time in 15 years I have concerns about the healthcare in our area. Rural communities need to be looked after.30722018-07-18T08:22:38.74337227Mark LilleyI agree that families of murder victims should be enabled to make funeral arrangements for their loved ones as soon as possible.30782018-07-18T12:33:57.15737229Anne Elizabeth HughesUsing a formula as a basis for funding to cover such a disparate population is almost inevitably going to be biased. In this instance I fear that it is rural areas that will suffer.30722018-07-18T16:44:24.0937230Gemma Cruickshanks Let families lay a loved one to rest so the can grieve 30782018-07-23T15:24:03.41337233Cheryl MckenzieWell done Nathan, together we can change the law xxx30202018-07-23T17:34:57.74337235Yvonne CookHappy to help Nathan Sparling change this law.\r\n\r\nX30202018-07-24T13:05:50.1837236Anne RoyDespite the clear wish of the Scottish people to remain in the EU, we are, once again, being ridden over roughshod by Westminster in its lemming-like and xenophobic obsession with controlling immigration. Scotland *MUST* have independence if it is to survive the post-Brexit financial and legislative debacle, and it is imperative that we Scots gain the right to self governance. 30792018-07-24T21:07:08.79737237Anne TaylorGood luck30202018-07-25T11:38:03.35337238Maxime Blake I support this 30202018-07-25T14:12:32.10737239Anne-Marie MckaySo important for children to access support. Learning young children how to express how they feel instead of them bottling their feelings up inside. One day it's too late, core beliefs, the rules for living adopted to support core beliefs will break down if the correct intervention is not available to them from a young age. 30702018-07-25T14:13:19.2537240Susan harleyWhen you are an adult you are sensible enough to make that decision 30202018-07-26T11:15:49.7737241Donnie SteeleWe have a duty to help and protect the health and welfare of our children.30702018-07-27T10:45:08.68337242Lynette MimiecThe need is very evident in Primary Schools. Primary aged children and their families must have access to services too. 30702018-07-27T20:35:35.02737243Marilyne KubathAll children deserve someone to listen to them.30702018-07-27T22:22:07.137244Jane Davidson Our young people deserve this 30702018-07-29T00:29:25.75337245Jen McConvilleDefinitely a priority to support young people30702018-07-30T07:54:42.97737246Lesley Margaret Emerson Having worked for place2be in 2 different schools for the last 2 years, I am aware of the amount of children in need of one to one counselling, but because of the amount, there are children who are not receiving it. These are the children who are at risk of going on and having bigger issues in the future. We can't help every child but we can make a huge difference. Why is this not available for every child? If it was it would be more 'normal' and more acceptable for everyone.30702018-07-30T14:30:20.62337247Tracey CampbellThis is a very valuable and important factor to be considered for school children and worthy proposition 30702018-07-30T22:12:24.01737248Lynn KennieThese services are severely under resources, 4 month waiting list so I had to go private and travel over 1 hour.30702018-07-30T22:42:11.3837249Alex Cochranewe need out of this union NOW!30792018-07-30T22:55:23.43337250Jason KirkGive us the vote and we will deliver Independance 30792018-07-30T22:56:42.5737251Angela WilsonThe promises made were not kept and as a people and country we deserve better. 30792018-07-30T23:04:21.94737252Scott ArchibaldThe time is right 30792018-07-30T23:05:22.737253David ThorntonThe YES groups around Scotland are ready.\r\nWe must stay in the EU\r\nPlease call indyref2 30792018-07-30T23:47:13.38737255Linda BairdEnough is enough, take back control.30792018-07-31T00:03:38.46737256Gillian GreenshieldsI strongly urge the Scottish Government to start the process for a second independence referendum before the Westminster Government drag us into a gutter with them30792018-07-31T06:54:47.34337257Janette Bolton Indy ref 2 please I will not stand by and allow the UK government to toss my families futur over a cliff.30792018-07-31T07:33:45.15337258Graham Jones I think Scotland and her people have the right to self govern herself without being dictated by a foreign UK Government. That does not stand up for the people of Scotland. Scotland is BIG ENOUGH, SMART ENOUGH, RICH ENOUGH 30792018-07-31T09:56:22.04737259Gordon IzattWe are all ready to take to the streets to secure a better future for Scotland outwith the grasp of Westminster30792018-07-31T13:03:19.7737261Gillian GriffithsEarly intervention is the key to preventing the escalation of mental health difficulties in children and young people. The only way to do this effectively is by providing all pupils with access to trained counsellors within their school.30702018-07-31T14:51:03.44737262Oliver JarvisAs a therapist and former teacher, I have seen first-hand the benefit that such emotional support has for young people and the knock-on effects this has on their engagement, motivation and emotional development. I have also seen how difficult it is for teachers to enthuse students who have other more pressing emotional difficulties on their minds and the effect this has on their grades and performance. Scotland has been at the forefront of many important developments and I believe that this may be another one. I hope, if this is implemented, that the rest of the UK may learn from your progress.30702018-07-31T15:18:31.24737264Christine HardmanThis is essential on all levels... Children are the future. Surely it makes social and economic sense.30702018-07-31T17:59:26.47337265Robert BlackTime to dissolve the union and allow Scotland to join the world of nations as an equal partner 30792018-07-31T18:01:48.737266Crawford Robertson We as a country need this30702018-07-31T18:45:43.34737267Gerry ParkerNow is the time!30792018-07-31T19:43:27.45337269Nigel LloydDay after day evidence surfaces of how Westminster wants Holyrood gone. The Scottish people need your action to protect them 30792018-07-31T19:44:42.2237270Elaine LloydFor the future of my children and generations to come I want them to be afforded the right to free movement work travel and education..The Tory WM Gov are not looking after the nation Indy now please30792018-07-31T19:45:24.31337271Donna glackinI want a sect 30 order i wish Scotland to be allowed another independence ref 30792018-07-31T20:13:59.4537272Anita Napier It is the clear wish of the people of Scotland to remain in the EU and gain independence from the constraints of Westminster rule. Use the mandate and lead Scotland into a better future 30792018-07-31T22:00:31.51337273Lorraine StoddartInvesting in our young people is investing in the future of our country. We have focused on securing a good physical health check and support system, and with more that we're discovering and learning about mental health, it's time to work on this aspect too.30702018-07-31T22:27:55.2537275Angela WeirIf the Scottish Government is serious about being an ACE aware nation we must provide appropriate resources to our young people to help break the cycle. 30702018-07-31T22:47:40.03337276christine thompson about time too,long overdue30702018-08-01T07:32:05.5637277Fiona FraserSupporting young people may stop the problem escalating to a lifetime of mental health issues. They need and deserve our support. 30702018-08-01T09:01:42.25337278Agnes Kelly Yeo We need to do this for our children's future30792018-08-01T09:09:22.34737279Jane MorganThis would be so beneficial for our kids who have suffered trauma 30702018-08-01T09:23:40.42737280Vanessa BlackmoreThis type of work is too important for the well-being of our future generation to ignore. It is not enough to rely on the goodwill on volunteers to do this valuable work. Counselling and psychotherapy is a skilled profession and qualified therapists deserve to be paid properly for their work. 30702018-08-01T10:11:45.51337281Jane Aziz Sadly this is a necessity 30702018-08-01T10:44:28.537282Liz HendersonThe need for emotional health and mental health support in school is increasing year on year. Access to trained counsellors in schools is an essential support not only to pupils but to the pupil support staff in education. It has been shown that even a short course of support from a counsellor has helped pupils reflect, build resilience and refocus on their education, friendships and family life.30702018-08-01T10:46:12.90737283Marilyne KubathPlease stop the pain of mental ill health at the earliest possible time. No more pain inflicted children becoming throw away adults.30702018-08-01T11:55:42.35337284Amanda dorward This is so important to try and catch at a early stage intervention is the key 30702018-08-01T13:48:27.3637285Graeme W TurnerDespite the clear wish of the Scottish people to remain in the EU, we are, once again, being ridden over roughshod by Westminster in its lemming-like obsession with controlling immigration. Scotland *MUST* have independence if it is to survive the post-Brexit financial and legislative debacle, and it is imperative that we Scots gain the right to self governance.30792018-08-01T13:59:02.08337286George ValiotisThis means a lot to those of us who have had to build our own families. Its important to have our family recognised. 30202018-08-01T14:50:12.41737287Gillian EdwardDefinitely needs to be done sooner rather than later.30702018-08-01T15:17:49.63337288Anna Richmond Personally I'd like to see this put in place.30702018-08-01T15:19:11.7537289Hugh MacLellan750 signatures were collected in 2017 by concerned members of the community and tourists in the rural community of Laid who were not able to access broadband. Tourists had the same experience in other rural areas which they found to be unacceptable. The very people who this petition represents are unable to sign this petition online as they do not have access to broadband and are therefore disadvantaged.30892018-08-01T16:26:21.31337290Ken MacLean Rural communities separately need REALISTIC broadband speeds. We need to keep people in our rural communities for work and this would go a huge way to assist in this.30892018-08-01T18:09:29.27737291Duncan F MacGillivrayWe need some real improvements for the autism community in Scotland, not vague nonsense!30992018-08-01T19:00:50.14337293Norman Morrison I holiday in Durness which has minimal internet speed and a lot of people who require faster broadband. 30892018-08-01T19:19:33.72337295Suzanne Macleod The Scottish government needs to stop writing these children off they are capable of contributing to society if supported correctly.30992018-08-01T19:23:44.637296Anne CasementPlease help this very worth while cause 30992018-08-01T19:57:55.27737297Elizabeth Parker I hope this petition is taken seriously and acted on in full. Its not good enough to try to care for children there needs to be statutory guidelines of what that actually means.30992018-08-01T20:09:23.65337298Catherine Byrne These Kids are new Generation We need to Nuture and Prepare and Teach us the way Forward.30992018-08-01T20:46:29.53337299Vivienne DoakPriority for our young people & their future.30702018-08-01T21:17:15.13337301Joanna mccollAgree30992018-08-01T21:57:36.63737302Caroline cummingsPlease help 30992018-08-01T21:59:25.71337303Karen Herbison Children are luckier if diagnosed with Autism young. Having worked with children with ASD for many years I knew the signs.other children and adults aren't so lucky 30992018-08-01T22:04:25.52737304Paul HaggertyGot many friends with kids with wide ranges of autism in this country, something's wrong and has to be addressed.30992018-08-01T22:36:38.04737305Diane Jess Everyone in Scotland counts, everyone deserves the chance to succeed whatever their disability. Everyone counts..30992018-08-01T23:12:16.11737306Angus MacLellanRural areas should not be at the back of the queue.30892018-08-01T23:20:57.437307Gary Macdonald Having experienced my childs school lack of proper support re mental health issues and CAMS batting \r\nkids back to the schools counsellors are much \r\nneeded. 30702018-08-01T23:44:19.93337308Janette RobbI wish something could be done for those OVER 25 years of age. So many are trapped within adult psychiatry where knowledge and experience of the condition seem sparse. Nothing but drugs available - and they make things worse - causing psychosis and other unwelcome side effects. It's a desperate situation.30992018-08-02T01:30:28.74337309Richard BurgeYou're still related to your family as an adult.30202018-08-02T07:45:50.18737311Claire GilbertEarly intervention has shown to be effective in many aspects of development and therefore therapeutic intervention should be prioritised for our young.30702018-08-02T11:22:14.43737312Claire GallacherRead & signed30992018-08-02T12:00:36.17337313Lucy Sumsion This support for young people who are autistic is desperately needed and long overdue.30992018-08-02T13:38:22.21737314Mirjam UrferI support this.30202018-08-02T14:46:06.2137315Sharon MoirAccess to mental health support in school is crucial, young people are suffering, and the system is letting them down badly, our government should now step up to show Scotland will give every young person in school the access support and tools they need to overcome emotional and mental health challenges, which far too often comes too late, if at all, and this is detrimental to their health. We need to come together to fight for this, to fight for young people in school, and to stand up for their rights, and ensure no one slips through the net, or gets left unsupported. We need this change now.30702018-08-02T15:20:41.15337316Gina HeywoodYoung people in Scotland need and deserve this support. 30702018-08-02T16:00:13.25337317Linda McHaffieThis cannot come quick enough for our young people. This is needed asap not only in secondary schools but also in primary schools.30702018-08-02T16:39:04.1537319Angela BediEarly intervention makes sense emotionally, educationally and financially. These children are our future30702018-08-02T19:29:36.1437320Allan CraigThis is vital and would change many people's lifes. If you want a society that is caring for those that really need help then this would make such a difference30992018-08-02T19:38:38.70337321Carolanne Morgan Definitely priority for all of our children. 30702018-08-02T20:47:52.5137322Joan HaganNoting 30992018-08-02T20:59:42.18337323Linda JacksonIf an autistic child is in mainstream school, the school should cater for their needs. They should be part of a classroom setting so that they can participate in their schooling. They might lack in social skills but if the school don't encourage them to join in, things will not improve for them. Help them don't hinder them.30992018-08-02T21:08:15.09337324Caroline DempsterShould be able to express commitment to adopt people over 18 in law and in public.30202018-08-02T22:03:08.84737325Charelle SadlerAbsolute joke that it takes so long to get a diagnosis .30992018-08-02T23:24:44.73337326Michelle Henderson This has to be a priority.30702018-08-03T00:03:39.53737327Janet MacgillivraySigned30992018-08-03T01:21:31.14337328Mel Hanvey This is music to my ears!! Something i have been passionate about for many years. Every school and every pupil should have access to a counsellor. It would address the increasing epidemic of poor mental health our young people now face. 30702018-08-03T08:31:28.74737332Eric BowieEveryone has the right to the same opportunities, just because some need additional support does not mean that they should be excluded from seeking those opportunities. 30992018-08-03T09:52:44.58737334Jeniffer PatonFantastic cause and so relevant with the amount of pressure put on school children these days30702018-08-03T10:42:18.45337335Stella kellyMany young people need support.30702018-08-03T11:40:11.15737337Angela ThrussellMany children need this extra help and support and the opportunity to talk to someone who can help them find their way30702018-08-03T12:40:58.84337338Norma MartinThis support is needed in all schools30702018-08-03T13:01:44.3737339Dougie Milton Please30992018-08-03T13:28:08.8237340Arthur WisemanThis directly affects me and my family, please sign up to the petition. Thank You30992018-08-03T16:49:52.237342Emily Jamieson As a GP who often sees kids struggling there are very few options available to support them through a tough time. CAHMs is overwhelmed and not able to cope with those who really need their services. For many earlier in school support would avoid unnecessary worsening of their mental health and then referral to a stretched service. 30702018-08-03T17:37:01.96337343Stuart WhitbyA direct fibre connection may not be realistic to deliver to every household in Scotland in the proposed timeframe. I would suggest a minimum acceptable download speed (at a shared exchange) be agreed and implemented by that time to prioritise the worst affected areas.30892018-08-03T18:44:47.24737344Linda DickScottish government will not disappoint.30992018-08-03T19:19:27.34737345Lynn WilsonChange is neeeded30992018-08-03T19:29:01.6337346Susan GillIt is hard to believe that this support is not already in place. Scotland should be ashamed of its performance in this area30992018-08-04T08:15:20.5137350Linda Mcphee There is no help for children with school avoidance issues, everything is a fight daily and now that school attendance officers have been removed , there is no hope.30992018-08-04T09:45:58.76337351pamela mctaggartthere needs to be counselling available to all school children in order for them to know that they can talk to someone about what they are feeling and thinking without fear of judgement or ridicule, and that they don't have to try to cope alone30702018-08-04T10:12:04.77737352Elaine HunterEarly support and intervention is essential and crucial in assisting young people. 30702018-08-04T10:27:03.9837353David anderssonFor the beter of family and children 30992018-08-04T21:05:29.7337355Lisa Donnelly This is something that should be done for all autistic people and children. I have spent years going through the system that is not fit for its purpose.30992018-08-05T00:06:47.31337356John CameronUSA has fiber optic armoured cable done all over there vast country as standard 20 years ago why is the ukso far behind ? This is fact as I was on ship that installed it all up the west cost 30892018-08-05T00:45:00.86737357Elaine mcguire Autism needs better recognition and support for children and young people 30992018-08-05T20:23:58.03737358Cicely McCullochAs a relationship counsellor and grandmother to 9 children who are or will be educated in the Scottish state system, I am keen that they should have the benefit of a school counsellor should they need. I know the value of counselling.30702018-08-05T22:30:46.6237359Alice DonaldsonLet our voices be heard30992018-08-06T00:28:52.61737360Christine FraserI was born and brought up in Laid. My father and forefathers all belonged to Laid. I hope to return soon, however the ineadquate broadband service is making it more difficult for this to happen as its vital for me to have a good broadband service. Laid needs people like me to return to the hamlet for its survival30892018-08-06T08:26:20.15337361Edward FowlerThe Autism Strategy has failed the autism community. We have to have stringent measures in place for it to work. 30992018-08-06T10:58:52.00737362Mrs Antonia Cardyplease help our children by putting all the right things inplace and not make familys suffer having to fight all the time 30992018-08-06T12:11:25.1837363Irene BirtwhistleStaff in mainstream schools do not understand autistic children's needs and they feels like they are an inconvenience to everyone. Change is needed fast. The future looks bleak.30992018-08-06T12:57:04.1437364Valerie BeveridgeAnything to assist the folk of Laid.\r\nBroadband is a necessity to life and where this is for needs every essential aid to make folk stay, survive and communicate from that isolated area.30892018-08-06T14:33:05.46737365Jacquie McKenzie Valued service which can make a major input in the lives of our young people. 30702018-08-06T16:48:19.65737366Richard OlverThis is a really important early intervention initiative for our children's mental health.30702018-08-06T19:23:57.3837367Gillian ToshIt has been damaging to autistic children's wellbeings to have people unqualified to access them. They have suffered with mental health issues due to having unqualified staff not recognise adhd,autism or PDA and punishment instead of support.PDA needs to be recognised by more professionals. Not recognising PDA can damage their health and parents can be blamed by school and social services 30992018-08-06T19:44:30.4337368Sue M Harperfully support this30702018-08-06T19:45:15.83737369Hilary Mckelvie We need to supplier this and make more changes 30992018-08-06T22:15:26.02737370Shona PeelYoung people deserve the best!30702018-08-06T23:24:36.61737373Shakeel AnsariHelp for our children helps prevent otherwise avoidable and adverse repurcussions for society30702018-08-06T23:38:06.66737374Joy HarrisI am a counsellor working mainly with adults but also sometimes with children and I believe that providing counselling in schools could avert later difficulties. 30702018-08-07T13:20:54.95337375Craig WaughAll children need supported by family, friends and occasionally professionals.....30702018-08-07T14:56:35.51337376Angela cunninghamThis is a must for all ages. 30992018-08-07T15:45:43.92737377Christina clarkAlways needs support happy to help30992018-08-07T17:26:32.17337378Catherine RobertsonHaving provided counselling to both children and adults, I have firsthand seen the impact of early intervention in ensuring children are not left with the emotional and physical impact of toxic stress in their adulthood. Countless adults are left unnecessarily dealing with the consequences of not having received adequate support during their childhood or adolescence. There is no good argument against making sure all children have the right to access support for their mental health as and when they need it. 30702018-08-07T17:59:50.72737379Janice RobertsonNo use claiming caring about mental health issues and at the same time destroying the jobs of those already involved in helping children with problems.30702018-08-07T18:34:15.68337380Seonaid McGinnI want all students to have access to trained councillors at school. 30702018-08-07T19:05:32.45337381Fiona RichThere is a shocking disparity in services between one school and another and one council and another. We are failing our next generation unless we can ensure that they grow up with equal opportunities to receive mental health care and support. Only then will we overcome generational trauma.30702018-08-07T21:22:11.95737382Lara cameronWith so much evidence on the growing issues for young people and mental health there are simply not enough resources to ensure wellbeing and provide support for those at a developmentally vulnerable time. I support any process to develop these services, both as a parent and a GP30702018-08-07T22:54:45.88337383Lesley LeishmanWaiting time for assessment is far too long.Once diagnosed the fight continues for the right amount of support within the classroom.Too many children being failed and denied the right to be educated within an environment to suit their needs.30992018-08-07T23:33:54.32737384Ruth MillerThis is such a shame for the children and their families people should not have to fight for this daily 30992018-08-08T07:39:21.1937415Robina QureshiSupport our young people ! 30702018-08-08T09:35:59.78737416Mairi MacNaughton After working in an Employee Assistance Programme for six years I be came very aware of the amount of adults who would have benefited from early intervention....add they suffered long term anxiety and depression and lacked skills to cope in their adult life. Access to coubselling forcecery child in schools is not just a wise decision, it is an essential decision. I am now working in an organisation so I can contribute to early intervention but more needs to be done. 30702018-08-08T09:46:04.79737417Laura Allardice There is more and more evidence emerging to link Mental and physical health and well being Mental health should be give the upmost priority in the school years as core to all other development 30702018-08-08T10:10:47.87737418Linda Mcgilvary The lack of services affects families 30992018-08-08T12:25:40.4537419Liz LawI think that counsellors should be paid. It could be used like the employee assistance programmes that firms use. The reason is that the long term impact on the child, the resources used to follow up and mend later costs would be reduced. In addition it would enhance our Scottish Culture and develop emotionally intelligent youth.30702018-08-08T16:11:47.2437421Rae CarmichaelWe shouldn't have to petition, our young people deserve any support required. Hopefully this will help to ensure they receive it\r\n30702018-08-08T16:37:19.84737422Hayley ChandlerI know how much this helped one of my good friends when he was young and think it should be available to all.30702018-08-08T21:18:45.35337423Caroline bairdI fully support this petition, young people deserve the best services30702018-08-08T22:52:15.2137425Graham CairnsThe waiting is far too long more needs to be done30992018-08-09T12:21:39.58337429Rebecca PfisterAs a counsellor working with children and young people I believe that access to trained (and PAID!) counsellors in schools is vital to insuring that future generations in this country mature into somewhat well functioning individuals. I support this petition 100%30702018-08-09T17:48:44.0237430Fiona Muirhead Having known of a few Scottish school age children who have cut their lives short, this has to be a priority to offer such a fundamental health service at schools. 30702018-08-09T21:51:15.98737431Lisa FrenchI would like to become a fully qualified Cousellor in the next few years to help young people with any issues that may rise for them.30702018-08-09T23:55:42.56337433Linda McClymontWe need help and support the children. They need someone they can go to who will listen to them with any issues they have. There is so much pressure put on children now. 30702018-08-10T08:26:39.00737434Lorna McIntyreThis is an essential requirement for young people today. The sooner this is implemented, the better. 30702018-08-10T08:39:16.86737436Jaclyn AndrewsWith mental health issues rising, this is an absolute priority. 30702018-08-10T08:40:26.88737437Alison JuddAccess to counselling is critical for school pupils both in addressing present mental health and emotional issues and in preventing mental heath problems in the future. As someone who has benefited from counselling and a former mental health nurse I wholeheartedly support this petition. 30702018-08-10T09:13:02.45337438Lois Simpson This service is a crucial one for children who need this support. 30702018-08-10T10:26:53.49737439Emma McCluskeyOur children need this......30702018-08-10T10:58:19.82337440Lee DavidsonSo many emotions experienced by our young people, some are easy to explain some not so much. This is the most important stages of their lives and they need the help and encouragement to help understand their emotions and build up resilience while learning to thrive. They deserve someone to be there and to be willing to listen and help them identify what is going on. Teach them self love and acceptance give their feelings and emotions validation. Be that person for them, you could be the only one who listens. Thats what makes the difference. 30702018-08-10T11:19:53.82737441Helen McLaughlin There are many vulnerable children in our care for varying reasons. Teachers do their best to support them however they do not have sufficient time or possibly do not have experience to deal with the ever increasing numbers of children who are crying out for support and teach at the same time. Counsellors need to be available in schools to do this. Please do not add counselling to the never ending list of what teachers are expected to undertake. 30702018-08-10T11:49:36.78737442Tracey MillarOur young people, in all areas need access to support. The amount who are turning to self harm etc is heartbreaking x30702018-08-10T13:50:10.94737444SANDRA GRANT.As a foster carer I am appalled at the lack of support and counselling that there is in schools for children. Every child deserves the right to be heard.30702018-08-10T16:03:42.3237445Leanne McLooneIf the Scottish Government truly want to raise attainment then the correct therapeutic services should be available and easily accessible within schools to support children in ways the class teachers are not trained or qualified to do. Many children living with ACEs and Learning needs suffer poor mental, emotional well-being. Trying to gain access to agencies such as CAMHS is like trying to reach the pit of gold at the end of a rainbow. Children and young people need fast access to services when the need arises, 6 months later is TOO LATE. 30702018-08-10T18:32:06.54737446Dr Catherine JuryAs a medic working with children J have seen first hand what a difference the right support at the right time can make. Counselling can be an invaluable and cost effective intervention.30702018-08-10T23:02:23.94337448Karlyn Ronnie Plaxe2be has been a Godsend in our primary school! Trained counsellors support children with emotional and mental health issues from the age of 7 ! Parents can access counselling in relation to all sorts of issues including domestic abuse, drug abuse , all sorts of aces support. They advise staff , provide strategies for teachers and communication between parents. \r\nMore and more kids need help !30702018-08-11T08:06:51.95337449Mary McCannHelp in time saves lives. 30702018-08-11T13:26:04.87737450George GairAutistic people have a lot to offer but just need the openings and chance to prove it30992018-08-11T13:27:40.76737451Karen MackintoshWith proper support and back up autistic people can contribute to our society30992018-08-12T08:13:35.7337453Valerie Woodcock The poor coverage in many rural areas makes working from home impossible The elderly in these communities don't have access to friends and family as those living cities.This is discrimination and provider's should be prosecuted 30892018-08-12T08:42:54.97337456Yvonne AlexisThis has been a long-standing issue which requires a speedy resolution 30892018-08-12T10:09:05.82337457Colin MackenzieWe live under 2 miles from a high speed internet enabled town yet our broadband speed is borderline usable. In the past 6 years the speed has dropped significantly and BT advisors say this is because the existing copper lines are possibly degrading and there are no future plans to repair them, and no timetable can be given for when they will be replaced by fibre. There are just a handful of properties up our glen and, although many like us are modern day businesses, I suspect we will be amongst the last to be upgraded.30892018-08-12T10:43:58.14337458Tanya Anderson It's about time these forgotten people in rural areas have the same type of facilities as the city folk do30892018-08-12T21:07:33.71737459Jacqueline Whiteplease get it sorted, locals and working visitors are badly in need30892018-08-13T11:15:46.9737460Lesley MurrayThis is very important for keeping up tourism 30892018-08-14T15:41:04.68337461Tracy thomasI understand age restricts adoption even though they want it the law refuses :(30202018-08-15T13:38:44.99737462Paul ByrneIt needs to be sorted out with clear penalties for failure to deliver within agreed time frame30892018-08-15T18:32:45.04337463Sybil NorrieInclusion for all is law. Which means more support is required in all schools to meet pupils needs. 30992018-08-15T21:15:06.09337464Mark LeightonMy driveway was dug up to lay fibre but not for me! I am running a business on 0.3mbps.30892018-08-16T11:53:15.31337465denise millenthere is a great need for children to be given counselling in schools.30702018-08-16T13:56:25.70737466Kathy Chappelle We should definitely look at working with charities who use volunteers trained in listening. \r\nListenwell Scotland being one! 30702018-08-16T16:43:48.79337467Gail TunnahManish exchange has not been upgraded and therefor ANY BT broadband is not available (and subsequently any competition). We are therefore stuck with expensive satellite systems.30892018-08-16T17:08:35.31737468LYDIA REIDMost folk abhor cruelty to animals but if you do not know it exists how can you even abhor it Also we have many species in Scotland in danger We need stronger methods of detecting and harsher punishments 30302018-08-16T17:51:06.6937469Kathryn GooseI think that there is a great need to have counselling available in schools. It can save lives. Children's lives.30702018-08-16T18:53:34.0137470John ButterfieldWith the Cairngorms National Park being as bad a wildlife crime scene as any English National Parks it is time to make detection and conviction of those involved more straightforward.30302018-08-16T18:59:15.52337471Les WallaceA very timely and extremely well informed and set out petition. Well done Alex!!30302018-08-16T20:53:55.2837472Roman DepaulitteHelp our children help themselves. 30702018-08-16T22:22:49.17737473robert grahamYES 30302018-08-16T22:32:24.7437474frank hopkini agree with all your suggestions..Stop All grouse shooting!!!!30302018-08-16T22:49:51.46337475LesleyAnne CouperI had to fight tooth and nail to get any sort of help for a family member.\r\nThey are autistic with no language. They have been discharged a number of times due to lack of funding and staff.\r\nThere is also no aftercare for the family and carers of autistic people. They are given a diagnosis and left to deal with it.\r\nA health visitor has only been involved twice with the family member since they were born and didn't believe the family when it was explained about their concerns about them being autistic. The family member had to continue to contact paediatricians and services until they finally got them monitored over 6 months before diagnosis.\r\nIf early intervention is the key then why do the services not take family members seriously when they express their concerns?and from the moment they start to take notice the process of diagnosis can take months to a year\r\nMore awareness and more experienced staff are needed as more and more people are being diagnosed 30992018-08-16T23:29:53.12737476Ian HopkinsWe've all heard the saying "seing is believing ". It's time the courts accept this!30302018-08-17T09:00:18.14337477Mark LundGreat petition...(I will read it later...I'll sign anything supporting this cause).30302018-08-17T09:45:47.19337478Martin MacGregorWhy this is not provided, is a complete mystery to me. We need to support our young people, to grow and develop into health and mature adults30702018-08-17T12:03:52.73737479Simon PughIn times of massive environmental threats, we need to do everything to protect our vulnerable habitats and the life they harbour.\r\n\r\nAnd we need to do it now, before it's too late.30302018-08-17T12:15:50.4137480Peter HerbertThe criminal animal slaughterers laugh at the present penalties and judges and magistrates must be made by fresh legislation to take these crimes more seriously.30302018-08-17T12:27:55.8637481Brian Minshull It is a crime that countryside crime so often goes undetected and even if it is detected, that it is rarely successfully pursued and appropriately prosecuted. Act now.30302018-08-17T12:36:38.12737482Fiona ThomasMore has to be done to stop the rampant wildlife crime in the British Isles.30302018-08-17T12:47:38.41337483Pauline GreenhalghYes to any and all suggestions.30302018-08-17T12:55:04.1537484Jeff ClarkeWe must all do more but governments especially have a duty to protect our biodiversity and abundance of nature. Stop the explotation of the environment to justify killing for fun. Ban Driven Grouse Shooting. It is the principle cog in this machine of destruction.30302018-08-17T12:59:36.33737485Mark FanshaweShocking..30302018-08-17T13:06:13.56737486Alice RosePlease protect our wildlife! They are attacked from all sources! 30302018-08-17T13:07:45.94337487Jan ColeIf the shooting industry wants to survive, it has to learn to work with, and conserve, wildlife. This mass destruction of wildlife and habitats for the benefit of a rich minority has to stop now.30302018-08-17T13:30:25.13337488Peter FindleyVideo evidence is precisely that. It should be admitted regardless of the type of crime. The law is clearly discriminatory and should be amended.30302018-08-17T13:45:01.57737489susan flemingABUSES & CRUELTY AGAINST WILDLIFE WILL NOT BE TOLERATED 30302018-08-17T13:59:27.04337490Katharine McEwenRoundly agree!30302018-08-17T14:02:10.8637491Tony CartwrightBan burning Heather and grouse shooting30302018-08-17T14:24:19.65737492Geoff Busby It's time criminals were prosecuted for wildlife crime 30302018-08-17T14:44:35.1837493Antje MoltonYour suggestions make sense. No more Grouse shooting.30302018-08-17T14:44:43.27337494Paul SpeakYes, increase penalties. Yes, accept video evidence, however obtained. An amendment to the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Act could easily facilitate this. Evidence is evidence and should not be ruled out by CPS, a Court must see the evidence.30302018-08-17T15:05:16.94737495John Leitch This situation regarding the open and total disregard that these people show both towards our wildlife and our laws protecting them is a travesty. The Scottish government must take action NOW 30302018-08-17T15:13:58.437497Linda KinniburghI pay a fortune for satellite broadband because I am too far away from the exchange. My neighbours a mile away are getting fibre broadband installed and will be paying a third of what I currently pay for a much faster service. Rural communities should be in the same position as cities and towns.30892018-08-17T15:41:35.6437498Joan PringleThis is great news...hope it gets passed , wildlife gets a raw deal in Scotland 30302018-08-17T15:49:47.42337499Stephanie ClarkSo few successful prosecutions, video evidence ruled inadmissable & in those few cases a conviction is obtained penalties are derisory.Please Protect our remaining wildlife!30302018-08-17T15:50:15.84337500Mark McConvilleEnough is enough. Certain organisations and individuals are literally getting away with murder. My full support here. Ban all blood sports. 30302018-08-17T16:09:16.8337501Catherine Hobbs we demand action !enough is enough 30302018-08-17T16:46:52.38337502Carole LeighWe must remind ourselves we are not the only species that matters. We need to protect ALL of our wildlife.30302018-08-17T17:06:30.63737503Val KnowlesPlease protect our wildlife. If not for us, for our grandchildren. Let them have the chance to see and hear the animals that we love so much.30302018-08-17T18:05:58.1937504Arthur AngelJust NOT necessary to kill these magnificent birds.30302018-08-17T19:35:45.35737506Kevin HowettFar larger fines and custodial sentences are required to prevent wildlife crime, which appears to be endemic in current land management of our Uplands. All evidence, in any format should be admissible in court cases. But there also needs to be far greater protection for all native wildlife to prevent the killing in the name of land 'management'. 30302018-08-17T19:40:27.09337507Donna ClarkIf we dont help kids deal with the pressures that they are facing now we are going to end up with a whole lot of adults that need far more help for far longer which in turn will cost a whole lot more sick pay PIP etc etc Spend to save30702018-08-17T20:17:56.7137508Mary McCannSo many young children cannot cope with pressures either at home or in schools. Not enough is being done to protect them. Help is required on an ongoing basis now and in the future. 30702018-08-17T21:31:42.4737509Phillip SmithPlease respect wildlife by enforcing laws.30302018-08-17T21:40:54.39337510June CurryGrouse shooting is barbaric it must stop. I agree with the suggestions.30302018-08-17T21:43:29.87737511Stewart LoveAll wildlife crime penalties should be increased to 3 years. Evidence from video cameras should be allowed in court.30302018-08-17T22:03:44.337512Sharron Jones I agree that the penalty should be increased to 3 or more years & to the use of covert cameras. 30302018-08-17T22:45:46.02737513Victoria ColdmanStop killing30302018-08-17T22:53:10.5937514Joyce O'HaraOur precious wildlife must be better protected.30302018-08-18T01:58:47.6337515Steven McLeanThe wildlife crime penalties currently in place are not a deterrent and need to be drastically increased in order to be effective.30302018-08-18T07:46:21.20337516Katie BennettAutism can be a hidden disability. Please give the support that is needed30992018-08-18T09:11:26.93337518Andrew WildmanWhen is the Scottish parliament going to wake up and realise that the majority of the people that put them there are sick and tired of them allowing the amazing wildlife of Scotland to be killed just to appease a hand full of people, they aren't the ones that gave the MP's their job it was the people, so listen to them.30302018-08-18T09:20:14.85737520Wendy millarThis will open doors and give opportunity to young adults with autism. 30992018-08-18T10:52:42.82337521Clive Ramage Killing our rarest wildlife to protect farmed animals that are kept in wild places (so that the rich few can have their sport) is moronic. It needs to be stopped now!30302018-08-18T12:11:48.04737522Ben HartmannI agree 30302018-08-18T13:40:07.23737523Ms Morag C JamiesonGetting it right for every child should include autistic children.30992018-08-18T14:40:01.3437524Alan PetrieBan all grouse shooting immediately. The benefits to wildlife and the environment are vast. It will also encourage eco tourist which is a much bigger money spinner and requires no subsidies.30302018-08-19T07:32:48.60337527Colin ThompsonMy village only received superfast broadband last year after being promised it for a half a decade at least, so I know how frustrating this is. even now the service is sporadic at best.30892018-08-19T14:18:18.95737529Dana CampbellALL SCHOOLS SHOULD HAVE THE CORRECT CARE FOR CHILDREN ON THE SPECTRUM OR WHO NEED ADDITIONAL NEEDS IF THE SCHOOL CANT PROVIDE THE EXTRA CARE THEY ARE NOT BIDDING FOR THE CORRECT CQRE COMPONENTS NEEDED AND OBVIOUSLY ARE MOT PUTTING CHILDREN FIRST!30992018-08-19T14:50:46.37337530Karen ProctorSuch an important issue!30992018-08-19T15:21:24.33337531Donna McCrackenThis is disgusting. If a child has a need of support to be in full-time education then it should be met. These children are the future, they need help now to achieve all they can. 30992018-08-19T16:12:12.1737532Emma Fraser Unacceptable. No excuse. Fix this now. 30992018-08-19T16:18:3937533Peter LogieThis needs to be brought in urgently. There should not be a two tier system.30992018-08-19T16:29:51.41737534Annalise WainwrightWith Council budget cuts threatening school staff budgets there is a real threat schools will lose valuable classroom support staff to assist teachers and support autistic pupils. This must not be allowed to happen. Education and health are areas that should never be disadvantaged by budget cuts. Ever.30992018-08-19T16:59:09.68737535Victoria Beavisa family member already misses out on school because of the lack of support. If it decreases anymore it would be pointless them going to school. 30992018-08-19T17:49:14.2337536Paul FisherWe love Scotland and spend much time and money there, but we go for the wildlife that you are destroying. Stop killing our wildlife.30302018-08-19T17:53:47.02337537Dr Mark G. TelferIt is important that raptor persecution and other wildlife crimes are tackled seriously and this is an essential step.30302018-08-19T20:22:09.6137539Caroline BlackstockThis is of paramount importance and school is an ideal place to provide this support to young people. \r\n30702018-08-19T20:33:27.9737540Karen LiddleThis is so important. Mental health issues are crippling our society right now and we need to help young people improve their mental health before the situation gets even worse.30702018-08-19T20:34:41.78337541Kaleigh mckechnieIt's disgusting that there has to be. Petition for this when the number are so devastatingly high. This should be done! Help our children.30702018-08-19T21:01:33.91337542Diane ClowWith all the evidence surrounding ACES there should absolutely be counselling available widely in schools and universities ...all our young people deserve this support ! 30702018-08-19T21:06:31.9737543Marie OwenCounselling in schools can helps kids at an early stage, learn how to deal with mental health issues. Saving time and money in the future by helping people to deal with issues before they spiral out of control to more serious issues and problems 30702018-08-19T21:22:24.1637544Jen PatonSad to say i have been in this position, and i was made to feel it was my fault that i was being bullied,and felt that there was only one way out of that situation. Thankfully i had a tiger mum on my side. Proper support is definitely needed in Schools.30702018-08-19T21:35:40.05737545Catherine HeffernanOur children need more help30702018-08-19T22:00:53.06337546Betty LeeDriven Grouse Moors. The owners receive obscene sums of money from taxpayers to create a monoculture for grouse and to 'control' predators ie cruelly destroy our much loved golden eagles, hen harriers and others of our best remaining wildlife. There is no justice as the powers thay be cannot or are unwilling to enforce the law. Criminal activities continue and I personally am sick to death of hearing on a daily basis about illegally slaughtered birds and mammals dying unavenged. The sooner the British public wakes up to this disgraceful state of affairs the sooner Driven Grouse Shooting will be banned!30302018-08-19T22:23:18.837547Heather HarrisonMental Health of young people is our future 30702018-08-19T23:02:26.58737548Sharon MacmillanWe need to stop the stigma of mental health for the young and old. You go to a doctor when your physically unwell and it should be the same for when your mentally unwell aswell30702018-08-20T02:15:55.45737550Mr Greer HartI did my hunt sabbing many years ago, and was horrified by the thugs hired by the fox hunting fraternity to intimidate young and non-physically intimidating people. What we experienced was a collection of blood sports types that should have ceased to exist in the modern era. The Scottish Government should not stop playing games and listen to the majority public on animal welfare issues, and stop backing the supposedly great contributors to rural employment shooting estates, when it has been well-shown that more is to be gained from conservation work and re-establishing the natural environment of Scotland and the rest of the UK. No ethically fit Government should condone anachronistic blood sports, which are guilty of criminal practice when they defy the laws governing the protection of birds of prey, and other vulnerable creatures. Who honestly believes that their gamekeepers are custodians of the countryside, and that foxes and badgers enjoy being hunted or baited? The penalties for such crimes are derisory and we have a prosecution and judicial response to those who have offended, which is limp. It is obvious an good ole boy system exists, just like the Deep South had. Modern video and drone evidence should be given more credence, but we are really dealing with obstruction here. The humane among us must keep up the pressure and inform more of the public about the lack of proper application of the law with regard to what goes on in the countryside. More people should be joining some or several animal welfare and conservation of the environment organisations, giving them more muscle to effectively challenge the constipation that exists with our dilatory politicians and forces of law and order.30302018-08-20T07:29:02.23337551Grant MaclaughlanTime to take the mental health of our young people\r\nas seriously as we take sex education. 30702018-08-20T07:48:02.63737552Brian RobertsonThere can be no doubt that this aspect of Scots Law makes a mockery of any claim that we take wildlife conservation seriously. 30302018-08-20T08:26:54.16337553Mairi MacIver Schools need specialist people to support mental health. Teachers can't do it all. 30702018-08-20T08:51:30.44737554Fiona Wilson There should be provision in every school to provide counselling or help.30702018-08-20T09:50:10.95737555Debbie DonaldGood broadband is an essential part of modern infrastructure. Without fast, fit for purpose broadband rural communities cannot function in terms of business, communication, kids doing homework, video-conferencing, and everyday essentials for modern living. One issue which is regularly forgotten is that we need internet for TV and radio as we get no terrestrial, satellite, DAB, FM, AM signals because of the hills. We are discriminated against by all providers, and forgotten about in most debates.30892018-08-20T11:23:19.93737556Sharon mowatSchools need qualified individuals that can help with their support. There is no support for children's emotional well being which should be changed. As children go through a lot of emotionals especially if they have been bullied or have additional support. Provide support for these children so they can feel more at ease and build on their confidence. 30702018-08-20T11:50:20.14337557Moira O NeillGood mental health is vital to provide a conducive learning state.30702018-08-20T12:02:44.87337558Debbie JacksonAs a society we all need to take responsibility for the mental health of our community including providing support to young people in a variety of ways30702018-08-20T12:08:02.67337559Julie GatensChildren cannot access this kind of help for themselves. It is outwith their resources. If we care about the future of our society it is imperative we start with our children's wellbeing, by enabling them to discover their own resilience and connection. 30702018-08-20T13:07:41.2137561Jillian BainA family member self harmed and threatened suicide, age 11. A hard and lonely time. Mental health services for children need support right now. 18 mth waiting list for help via CAMHS in my area. Awful.30702018-08-20T13:56:31.2737562Frances Maria Macdonald It is more common these days with the pressure of SATs etc, that children are suffering with mental health conditions, so having counselling in schools is a good idea 30702018-08-20T14:13:50.63337563Eunice DuffEvery child and young person needs an education these children are being let down by the system constantly needs are not being met urgently needs rectifying\r\n30992018-08-20T14:28:08.89337564Geraldine Cairney Support for children's mental health is so important. 30702018-08-20T14:34:57.44337565Clare ChalmersIt is becoming very clear, Austin children are being failed, GIRFEC should be totally scrapped and services targeted for those children in real need of help. ASN in Schools is a postcode lottery, mostly a disgrace, not to mention the failing CAMHS.\r\nAustin children need more resources, better understanding of their indidual needs, some parents are turning to Home Education as an alternative, we really need to do better for these special children.30992018-08-20T16:24:50.83337566marilyn wemyssThis is vital now as it is obvious our young people need someone within a school who they know they can go to confidentially who is a fully trained counsellor.30702018-08-20T17:58:54.54737568Steve WebbIt's about time the government focus on increasing the speed for rural users.towns and city dwellers have super fast speeds with money's being used toake it even faster. Whilst rural people suffer slow speeds,512kbs in my case.struggle to watch the iPlayer. I'm on box 3 Ardersier. Mobile, SIM card internet is not cost effective for a family who will consume the data limits in days. We are penalised for living in a beautiful part of the country.30892018-08-20T18:33:10.06737569Stephanie western Not allowing people the support they need in their education, puts limits on their future. Invest in our education and in all children even if it does cost a bit more and they will have a more productive future. I have experienced my child not being supported and it leads to mental health problems and low self worth. Different not less! 30992018-08-20T18:34:36.8937570Pamela oneillThis service should be mandatory in schools. I work in student support at a college and we see many students who are let down by the provision in school. This could help prevent mental health issues escalating and is much needed. 30702018-08-20T19:24:39.65337571Sonia cooperSigned+shared x30992018-08-20T20:58:07.03337572Sian RobertsWe must support our young people. 30702018-08-20T21:06:02.32337573Elizabeth GallowayOur young people are the future let's treat them with respect and listen to them especially when in need.30702018-08-20T21:07:59.24737575Louise PeatThere should be trained professionals in all schools to council the children and young people as a parent whose child needed help on mental health issues it is definitely required. 30702018-08-20T21:24:36.4237576Julie ScanlonMental health support in schools is more important than ever. Do not let these kids down.30702018-08-20T21:33:34.70337577Connie Lillie Counciling Services are needed in secondary schools to support children and prevent serious mental health problems not being addressed with the right support. 30702018-08-20T22:22:26.0337578Hazel LeithBroadband not good on outskirts of Ardersier and it really should be. 30892018-08-20T23:20:05.97337580Karen MillarThis is a vital support mechanism in a modern forward thinking school and without it we are breeding dysfunction and lack of care30702018-08-21T05:33:41.30337581Sabrina duncan No1 should be left out. Ridiculous along with what some1 else has commented. Girfec should include children with disabilities 30992018-08-21T07:51:00.437582Leanne DunnThe soon this changes the better for all those being failed.30992018-08-21T10:16:42.28337583Jim McMillanThis is essential for rural areas where much more work is done on p.c.'s from home or rural businesses.30892018-08-21T10:23:36.0837584david smartAs a GP I can see how important this service is with a huge increase in anxiety and mental health issues with young people.30702018-08-21T10:24:52.37337585John DickieCounselling should be available.Mental Health is a big label , but counselling is about well being, physical and mental and encouraging students to be their best 30702018-08-21T10:46:22.7537586Prof. Andrew HartThis seems an entirely necessary development for the holistic care of our children, and matches developments in NHS care of children and adults. I am sure it would further serve to reduce lifelong behavioural problems and enhance individual welfare, societal integration, and community. It would free teachers to give more to the kids, and help destigmatise child and adult psychological and mental health issues, which remain a major unspoken burden on society and GP workloads.30702018-08-21T14:37:40.14737590Laura Cave-Magowan I feel early intervention is crucial. Counsellors should be available in primary and high school education. The presence of a invaluable service can also lead to the normalisation of mental health diagnosis allowing stigma to be lessened and more young people being able to step forward and ask for support. 30702018-08-21T14:42:40.67337591Russell CrichtonI strongly support this proposal. 30702018-08-21T15:24:04.4937592Fiona MorrisonThe pressure on our young people is immense. Let's help them develop their resilience and good self-care tools to help them live a full and satisfying life.30702018-08-21T15:26:29.7937593William BruntonAll schools should have counselling to help any children and staff 30702018-08-21T16:59:00.2437594christopher plattOur children's mental health should be considered equally important as their physical health.30702018-08-21T17:52:37.68337595Elona LoweWi if is terrible in our area, can hardly download anything30892018-08-21T18:45:08.2737596Darren FraserIn this day and age surely broadband should be available in all rural areas ,30892018-08-21T18:51:05.5237597May McNicolBroadband is as important in fact more so in remote rural areas. Please help us. 30892018-08-21T21:14:31.55337599Carol SmithAll School pupils young person's should have immediate access to a counsellor 30702018-08-22T04:55:17.37337600Rosemary Peacock1.5mb is not good enough for this day and age. BT dont care at all. We are a new build and the right cabling should be installed during the build30892018-08-22T14:04:18.34337602Fiona CulbertLeaving the Autism Strategy to the interpretation of local authorities has failed to meet autists and their families needs. Support is a postcode lottery and therefore is neither equitable nor fair, if it takes legislation as with the integrated partnerships of health and social care. Too many autists are failed and I want a future for kids is this "fairer Scotland " 30992018-08-23T11:34:26.14337603Ian FosterBring everyone into the 20th century!\r\nWe are so very far behind so many other countries in Europe, never mind South Korea.30892018-08-23T12:25:09.88337604Catherine Cowie M.Sc. (Counselling) MBACPAs a Person-Centred Counsellor in private practice, my client base includes young people of secondary school age whose carers feel they have no option but to access my services, given that standard provision on offer to them has not met their needs, due to long wait times for CAMHS services or by being offered ad-hoc pseudo-counselling sessions delivered by well meaning but inappropriately qualified and experienced staff (e.g. schools Guidance Staff). \r\n\r\n\r\nThe carers of my clients have, given inadequate alternatives, have chosen to budget to pay for my services. Not all families are in a position to do this, and indeed why should they have to? Fully qualified counsellors embedded in all Scottish schools would address an imbalance of need and access to support.30702018-08-23T15:28:03.4737605Miss Rhona PeetI whole heartily support this petition. For to long there has not been enough done to prosecute or find the offenders30302018-08-25T18:41:54.41737608Kerry BottomleyThis is an essential need in schools as the mental health crisis grows among young people.30702018-08-25T22:28:32.6637609Ashlie McVey The need for trained counsellors or Psychotherapists in schools has never been more prevalent. Our children need specialist support as soon as possible as we are now seeing young 20 year olds enter into therapy more often as they simply cannot cope with the daily pressures of life. Teachers have many roles and responsibilities and due to cuts have enough to do, in addition to that this is not their area of expertise. Early intervention is paramount, ie primary school and mental health awareness has to be introduced sooner than later.30702018-08-26T12:25:00.4237611Allison CowieOur broadband is terrible, the connection is not strong and cuts off regularly30892018-08-26T18:00:44.2837612LYDIA REIDI have concerns about this petition \r\nA high number of the people signing this petition are not from Scotland 30302018-08-27T12:55:01.19737615Anne Wilson We call for parity of esteem between children's mental and physical health. Given the difficulties in accessing CAMHS provision, the length of waiting times and the fact that most children will not be accepted for CAMHS services, it is vital that children have ready access to support in schools. 30702018-08-27T15:13:04.07737616Ila McEwanTalking point with locals how awful Broadband is!\r\n30892018-08-27T16:08:20.53737617lisa mackintoshwe mived to england as the highland council was failing a family member so much they were becoming deppressed 30992018-08-27T21:45:52.40737618marina vowleskids for various reasons need help with dealing withtrauma or issues...fully support this.30702018-08-28T08:29:11.0337619Lynne ParbrookCouncillors will help all the school community which will in turn help the wider community. 30702018-08-28T09:37:19.42737620Barbara Irvine Mental health is absolutely no less important than physical, social etc \r\nThe amount of stress, anxiety felt by children is on the increase. However more could be done with teaching in the classroom in regards to what can calm, awareness of emotions, how to deal with emotions, more playtime rather than in class. Children have less and less physical activity which promotes mental health and more time in the class on academic work. \r\nWe are ending up with a society of very young people with serious mental health issues before they even leave education 30702018-08-28T09:37:35.88337621Karen YoungAll children should be helped from an early age. Its proven early intervention can help. Give our young the chance to thrive and have a future in this world. it will save the Goverment in the long run. 30702018-08-28T09:41:20.1837622patricia donoghueEvery school, college and University should have a fully qualified counsellor. 30702018-08-28T09:44:01.4337623ruth gouldit's obscene. our countryside is taken under the control of keepers who frequently are found to be persecuting other wildlife to an extent that endangers their species. the death is in terrifying noise and danger, it isnt a guaranteed a quick kill, it's excessive, violent and disrupts actual natural life30302018-08-28T10:45:45.0537624Marguerite Hunter Blair Play ScotlandArticle 29 UNCRC says that a young person's education should help their mind, body and talents be the best they can. Counselling needs to be an integral part of every school so that all children can achieve their potential.30702018-08-28T10:54:21.53337625Vanessa TaylorThis is really vital for our kids. It's not good enough to simply raise awareness of mental health issues if this isn't backed up by essential services. Let's not let Scotland's children down. 30702018-08-28T12:21:57.737626Robin WallaceWe need a proper deterrent to wildlife crime and animal cruelty. 30302018-08-28T12:50:12.67337627Dennis HollinghurstScotland's Government must make greater efforts and pass stronger statutes in order to reduce and hopefully eliminate wildlife crime.30302018-08-28T14:32:09.59337628karen mauirea family member goes to a high school on the isle of skye. before that they were at a primery school.on the isle of skye.We as a family feel they and other pupils like them have been constantly let down by the education board and profesionals.We have been trying for years to get them the help they need.30702018-08-28T15:44:05.63337629Pauline Goodwin The corruption of judges etc in prosecution of these law breakers is shameful 30302018-08-28T15:53:21.88737630Val SalmonAs long as the consequences for killing wildlife are small fines and suspended custodial and not reflective of the cruelty and environmental damage involved these people will continue committing wildlife crime virtually immune . Hit them hard in the pocket , make sentences a minimum 12 month custodial and strip them permanently of gun licences . The environmental value of wildlife is without question priceless 30302018-08-28T16:38:03.7237632Niloufer Soudagar This is the one if the best investment schools could make for young peoples wellbeing. Follow Wales example of counselling in high school and other forward thinking areas. 30702018-08-28T17:10:04.08337633James AlbayaIts a sad reflection of our current laws that tghey have become use less because they are no up held and prosecutions are rare and NEVER fit the crime We need action now while we still have some wildlife to save - because its got to such a sorry state.30302018-08-28T17:42:55.6237634Ian CurrieLarge parts of the Scottish countryside are virtual wildlife free zones due to barbaric outdated land management traditions . It has to stop!30302018-08-28T18:33:48.62737635Barbara MilliganEven 3 years is modest for some of the cruelties perpetrated.\r\n30302018-08-28T18:41:13.0837636Joyce MarriottHigh time the tariff for these crimes was updated. The fines and punishments are a joke.30302018-08-28T18:48:59.81737637Derek HaggertyAll creatures deserve respect!30302018-08-28T20:03:11.7537638nikki brannanplease increase the penalties for persecution of out wildlife. we need to protect not persecute30302018-08-28T20:10:13.84337640Lucy SearleIf people are caught mistreating and killing wildlife they deserve the full force of the law. Crimes against nature are abhorrent and have no place in a decent civilised society - any punishments must reflect this.30302018-08-28T20:12:56.65737641Paul Edwards Penalties must be tougher otherwise there is no deterrent.30302018-08-28T20:19:40.09737642Ernie ScalesAll wildlife crime should be subject to the same minimum and maximum penalties the term to be decided in court. AND the use of video evidence whether filmed overtly or covertly should be admissible in court. Covert filming may be the only way to catch criminals in the act.30302018-08-28T20:32:27.36337643Debbie Wheelhouse It's time the cruelty stopped!30302018-08-28T20:58:04.4937644Catherine CameronWildlife crime is increasing in Scotland and currently both the enforcement of existing laws and penalties fail to deter wildlife criminals. 30302018-08-28T21:43:11.10737646Sarah Hynd It is essential that our young people should have the support they need to cope with with the problems of our modern world. This should certainly start as early as possible and must be available in our schools.30702018-08-28T23:22:57.7637647Heather RyceWhy would anyone not agree with this??30302018-08-29T00:56:34.00737648Tracy BrightenScotland has such a diverse habitat for wildlife, still offering wilderness that isn't found in the rest of the UK. Scotland's Government has a responsibility to protect this unique habitat and wildlife from illegal activity. Penalties for wildlife crime must be tougher and video camera footage used to secure prosecutions.30302018-08-29T02:44:51.2837649Jacqueline KyleDo the landowners not realise the imbalance they create by killing raptors? We need stronger legislation and more severe penalties for the criminals who interfere with wildlife.30302018-08-29T06:25:20.12737650carol taylorWe should see a precedence for others to follow30302018-08-29T06:38:54.70737651Lesley KellyHaving this in place could save lives.30702018-08-29T07:50:20.23337652Dawn RennieThis service is desperately needed. Working in schools for 25yrs has proven the need for this to me. 30702018-08-29T07:58:25.97737653Andrew HyndSo important, so obvious...30702018-08-29T09:00:17.6537654Jean BellOur countryside is largely controlled and wrecked by the shooting estates and interests. They damage the environment by slaughtering indigenous and migratory birds, fish and mammals. In doing so they not only put our future in jeopardy but they reduce opportunities for eco and wildlife tourism which should be an important part of our economy. The feeble and limited penalities for wild life crime indicate that the government still puts the interests of the wealthy above those of the general population and the environment.30302018-08-29T09:31:26.98337655Andrea GoddardYou have my total support on this. By increasing the penalties to at least a 3 year jail sentence wildlife crimes will be then classified as serious. Covert cameras can then be placed by Police Scotland in order to detect any suspected wildlife crime, which is vital. Additionally any video evidence showing a wildlife crime taking place should be deemed admissible by the courts, as it would be when any other serious crime is filmed.30302018-08-29T11:33:03.737656jennifer broadhurstAccess to counselling services in schools is urgently needed, with kids self harming, experiencing greater and ever present pressure to succeed because of government austerity and unwillingness to adequately address this problem is storing up massive issues for not just this generation but many more to come. It's time we worked to creating a happier world where each child is vauled for being them and not what position they can support the school to get on the league table. Invest in our children properly by ensuring our councils are funded properly to have supporting staff in place.30702018-08-29T13:04:40.99737657Janice LawsonFully agree with this..wildlife crimes may be taken more seriously with a stiffer sentence...this is long overdue30302018-08-29T13:16:40.21737658Marriyah AslamIts a must for modern life30702018-08-29T14:33:56.7137659ranald leaskBird watching and countless other country pursuits add millions of pounds to the rural economy. Quite apart from the appalling cruelty of those who kill and maim animals, the economic advantages of protecting animals in the wild should also be noted. Thus, increasing the penalties for those guilty of such crimes would benefit all in society, other than those intent on evil.30302018-08-29T14:54:25.18337660Patricia martinTime justice was done30302018-08-29T16:52:22.8737661Antonia HyndIn an increasingly challenging world, children need additional support30702018-08-29T19:53:13.4137662kirsty henry-kanyumivital, in the current climate. 30702018-08-29T21:59:43.8237663marjorie fentonThis is an issue that can't be ignored .I lost two people dear to me .Please get something done it's shameful the lack of help x30702018-08-29T22:08:38.2137664Lynn hynd So important to get help directly and quickly from a safe place which you can access everyday. 30702018-08-29T22:13:02.69737665Craig Tait So important for us to enable our children to be healthy and happy in themselves 30702018-08-29T23:48:39.4337666Belinda JohnstonI think it is vitally important to allow pets in housing of all kinds, especially when people are facing challenging transitions. Pets help people to cope with invisible and visible vulnerability, hidden disability, and we need to support these life enhancing and often life saving friendships. They also save the NHS an enormous amount for money, (conservatively estimated in the UK as 2.45 GBP billion annual savings due to reduced GP visits, something that we can not afford to ignore30742018-08-30T01:49:33.97737667Stuart mcLeanEssential to all schools at all ages30702018-08-30T05:19:09.61737668Sharon BradleyThis should be allowed as pets are as much of the family as people are30742018-08-30T08:27:52.4437670Tony WardAs research shows, being split up from your pet can be like losing a family member.30742018-08-30T14:19:01.12737671Professor Marie FoxThis is a vitally important human rights and animal welfare issue that it would be fantastic to see the Scottish government taking the lead on.\r\n\r\n30742018-08-30T14:39:19.78737672Fiona WilsonAs a counsellor and systemic therapist I frequently see the needs of young people and the impact of these on resilience and long term prospects if not met. We need to intervene early if we want to make a difference to the lives of our future generations.30702018-08-30T15:16:15.48337673Neil Moore (CEO PETAL Support)We believe that it has been proven that early intervention with counselling works and is crucial for the development children in Scotland. \r\nWe suggest that a life-long strategy for children, with early interventions will ensure better equity, education and future life opportunities for children and young people to become Scotland's better equipped adults of the future.30702018-08-30T15:23:07.2637674Dawn MacNeil More needs done at a preventative stage across healthcare and this would make a significant difference to our young people 30702018-08-30T16:31:43.7937675barbara williamsthanks30702018-08-30T17:53:12.68337676lynn bellIt would save money longer term and early intervention & support 30702018-08-30T20:58:52.22737677Nicola HolmesBecause of the rapid rise in mental health issues in young people (including those in secondary AND primary education) a counselling service in every school is vital ...if our govt is serious about tackling this issue 30702018-08-31T11:59:17.73337678jane russellThis is vital for the future of Scottish children30702018-08-31T12:12:58.15737679Joan Kevan Totally support this petition , the wanton destruction of wildlife is shameful .30302018-08-31T15:02:14.41737680Alan RaleighI have seen the benefits of School Counselling for myself in the U.S. - it is far better for individuals and society generally to provide immediate support than to deal with the consequences later.30702018-08-31T18:15:21.9437681Angela HollierA very worthwhile service desperately needed by young people. Let's make it happen in the year of young people. 30702018-08-31T18:25:54.34737682Rachel ONeillPlease set this up. It is crucial for keeping our children healthy. 30702018-08-31T19:22:22.46737683Ruth ReavellMy pets are my family, impossible to live without them. I would rather be homeless than give them up.30742018-08-31T19:39:33.20337684Colin BroughAs a foster father of twenty sons that have come though our education system, my greatest single battle has been emotional support for my children. The stress on our CAMH's system could be eased by local support in school. 30702018-08-31T20:01:55.42337685Mr. Stelios DEVERAKISGood luck in this venture of reform of current law and practice.30742018-08-31T21:04:00.85737686Eileen WylieWe so desperately need this service, I have personal interest in a counselling service, I am aware of a young person who is having a difficult time at the moment, a trained counsellor at their high school could make all the difference, also, I lost my son partly due to depression, if young people had access to a counselling at school, I am 99% sure many suicides could be avoided. PLEASE, let this happen. Thank you.30702018-08-31T21:13:51.98337687Stewart LoveAgree to wildlife crime penalties being increased to 3 years or more and to covert cameras being set out to catch wildlife criminals and being used when these criminals are brought to court.30302018-08-31T22:21:57.08737688Chris BatchelorThe land owners who employ these criminals are nothing more than supporters and facilitators of organised crime, and as the criminals are armed they should be taken far more seriously by police & courts alike. Any & every method of getting evidence must be adopted. 30302018-09-01T00:00:54.31737689chris hawkinsOrganised crime is now well established in the peace and tranquility of a British landscape. Unseen, un-recorded and commonly ignored. Increasing Wildlife Crime penalties to 3 years or more will begin to turn the tide in favour of what the people want "Wildlife Crime has to stop !" Good luck with the petition.30302018-09-01T04:25:31.32337691Margaret DochertyPets give therapeutic benefits for people. Providing the individual is capable of looking after a pet.30742018-09-01T08:24:06.18337692Abbie Mitchell-Luker Teachers should not be expected to take on this responsibility but they are being left no choice. 30702018-09-01T11:24:41.17737694Bruce WilcoxGood luck. Essential service30702018-09-01T11:44:09.64737695Katrins Evans Please review30742018-09-01T11:46:08.61737696Janet MccurdyI agree30742018-09-01T12:59:27.1637698Jackie allenA pet should live with its family.30742018-09-01T13:58:27.02337699Helen McLachlanEarly intervention will save much heartache and trouble later on. It makes sense.30702018-09-01T14:04:24.07337700Donna Muir This is a much needed service as school is one of the main causes of a lot of kids mental health issues 30702018-09-01T14:44:24.39337701Alice TierneyA desperately needed service.30702018-09-01T14:46:15.7237702fiona NicholsonI am currently facing eviction as I wont give up my dogs who are my only family and my only reason for continuing to get out of bed each day to face pain and poverty and disability. I was forced and harrassed before into losing my dear pets, and 2.5 years later am still receiving medical treatment for the devastating effects of that loss, which is far worse than even the closest bereavement. Dogs are not 'pets' they are family, they are the vulnerable children of their human parents and that is the strength of the bond. Please show some humanity and stop persecuting those of us who dearly love our animal babies.30742018-09-01T16:51:39.26737703Kevin KibbleTime to put an end to wildlife crime 30302018-09-01T17:08:48.2137704Steve HarrisIt cannot be right that a criminal escapes justice when a video recording, the integrity and reliability of which is proven, shows them breaking the law. The law is an ass if it frustrates justice.30302018-09-01T19:17:05.1537706John CalderGenuine video footage should be taken at face value, whether taken deliberately or accidentally. 30302018-09-02T10:26:23.49737707Sheila DorsettI agree to both increasing the sentences and also the acceptance by courts of the video evidence. 30302018-09-02T12:17:57.68737708Angela stocksAnimals, pets are the life blood of some owners30742018-09-02T16:55:42.21737710Laura Kerbey Ensuring that children and young people with autism are diagnosed as early as possible will ensure they are able to access vital support and interventions. All children with autism have the right to receive support, therapy and interventions to allow them to reach their full potential in all academic settings. The impact of NOT\r\ndiagnosing and supporting has a significant impact on mental health, education and in turn the economy. 30992018-09-02T23:01:06.12737711Keith DonnellyI agree that video evidence should be admissible as evidence in a crime.30302018-09-03T07:33:16.43337712Sarah ReillyWish everyone would sign30302018-09-03T09:22:36.6337713Harris KeillarVideo evidence should be allowed in all cases of wildlife crime. The estates are happy to photograph us - as at Glen Turret or via other remote monitoring devices as in Glen Lyon. These estates depend on subsidies which we as tax payers pay, so they should be subject to much greater control. 30302018-09-03T10:05:48.42337714Hannah AndersonSo important. This WILL make a difference & will postively affect every area of society. Also economic benefits as these children's will grow in to better cared for membets of society and reduce strain on NHS mental health services in the future.30702018-09-03T12:06:45.43337716Susannah Gravestock This service would make a huge difference to so many.30702018-09-03T12:38:27.91337717Angela PapaliaSupport this petition 30742018-09-03T15:10:27.12337719Rona GrantDesperately needed as the mental health of our young people continues to deteriorate30702018-09-03T17:33:40.99337721Judith Dennis I support this completely. I know of a sixteen year old with a learning disability (suspected PDA) who has an fourteen month wait ahead for Ads diagnosis and no chance of PDA recognition in their area. As an adopted and once looked after child in the system since birth they deserve better than waiting lists and lack of clarity. Please help us move forward. 30992018-09-03T18:58:41.8437723Tom MasonOur children are your future30702018-09-03T19:55:27.52737724Catherine McKayTotally and utterly essential for the future of our children and young people30702018-09-03T20:17:28.48337725Diane mcallister 100% agree 30742018-09-03T20:44:17.31337726Ruth BlairMental Health issues are on the rise and cause significant morbidity. Helping children will strengthen them as adults. The service desperately needs to be improved. 30702018-09-03T20:49:01.38737727Jo O'DonnellAs a counsellor I can see just how desperate schools are to have more regular mental health support and counselling available30702018-09-03T21:33:22.64337728Nancy KennedyPlease support the right of pets & owners to live together in rented or supported accommodation.30742018-09-03T22:26:59.6537729Gillian ToshI know of a young person who was failed for years and punished instead of supported in primary school. They are still suffering trauma due to them not using PDA strategies despite being asked and the parent being told they were.By own notes they clearly show they weren't. The parent had to remove the young person for last 6 months as her mental health was suffering.Refusing to support is abusive 30992018-09-04T02:51:12.137730Yvonne gittens It's unfair for people that have to give up on a family pet a pet is family I have 3 dogs I would not live without them they make my day and keep me company so I strongly believe in this petition 100%30742018-09-04T19:57:20.84337732Jane BinghamThis is so important to so many people ... and pets. 30742018-09-04T22:09:39.20737733Mary BetteridgeWildlife crime penalties should definitely be increased to at least 3 years. The police can then set covert cameras to detect suspected wildlife crimes. Wildlife crimes should be treated as seriously as any other crime and any video evidence should be determined in the law courts.30302018-09-05T11:24:37.09337734Karen IndooAllowing responsible pet owners to keep their pets with them would benefit human and animal welfare. It would provide more choices for families and enable people to access affordable accommodation more easily and would help to reduce levels of animal relinquishment.30742018-09-05T11:26:17.3637735Patricia HewittThe Scottish Autism Stratagy is not fit for purpose . Education Laws worthless . My family like tens of thousands of others are in Crisis due to a dreadful lack of understanding of the Autism Spectrum, PDA is still a Post Code Lottery even after our Petition to Holyrood . Specific Stratagies must be used . Many are without a suitable Education or any viable support . Mental Health issues are endemic due to the lack of early intervention and recognition . We need change NOW . 30992018-09-05T21:06:11.44737736Sandra SaavedraPets helps people with their love and company. I have ALWAYS have pets only 1 time for a very short time I was without the company of a dog because I sold my house and I was renting and they did not let me have a dog with me. So I do understand and you as an owner need to make sure that the place that you are renting does not g set damaged by your pet, an as an owner of a renting house that is what I request from my renters.30742018-09-06T11:49:56.59337737Mr Jonathan P TylerThat the very symbol of Scottish wildlife, the golden eagle, along with other species such as the elegant hen harrier, seem to be at risk from certain sectors of the grouse moor owning community is appalling. There have to be more convictions with heavier penalties to bring this culture to an end.30302018-09-06T12:55:27.41737738Stuart WhitbyIt's an open market for renting. If landlords know that they're losing business because renters won't stay there without their pets, it's up to them whether they want to change their policies to improve their business. \r\n\r\nThere should be no need to legislate on this issue in this form.30742018-09-06T15:34:25.76737741Hazel Newcombe People are distressed enough in these situations without losing their pets too 30742018-09-06T17:55:51.12737742Felicity CollinsPets are our family and we need them with us 30742018-09-06T20:06:06.75737743Angela MounseyIt is essential that evidence taken by video cameras be admissible in Court. \r\nI also think a much harsher penalty of 3 years imprisonment together fines and with a removal of licences should be applied.30302018-09-06T20:15:43.03737744Pete RowberryThe illegal persecution of our birds of prey is but one of the abominations of the driven grouse shoot. A study has shown that it is not economic unless large scale eradication of predators takes place. Even the Mountain hare falls victim to gamekeepers and the dead bodies are just dumped in "stink pits". A farmer would be prosecuted if he disposed of his dead stock in this way. End this abomination now. 30302018-09-06T20:21:21.08737745Jenny SylivantCThis is a cause that is close to my heart. It is so heartbreaking for families and pets to have to give their pets away in order to have somewhere to live. Pets are family to most people, and they deserve to be allowed to stay with the families that love them and have a place to live too.30742018-09-06T20:30:43.29737746Sue Taylor It's been proven that pets enrich lives and can help the sick and elderly why would you ever rob people of that these pets are family and are just as important 30742018-09-06T23:06:17.95737747Alison GriffinI've been fighting the system since my family member was 18 months old and will be 5 in November. My family member is still undiagnosed with austim or ASD, still waiting for ASD assesment. It's taken me over 2 years to get an appointment with incontenence team for their chroinc constipation. The system meant to help and support our children is drastically failing them. My family member has just started mainstream school and they are doing all they can do but without a proper diagnosis there is only so much they can do 30992018-09-06T23:26:22.86737748Donna DickI initially felt lucky that my family member, aged 3, had an early diagnosis of autism spectrum diagnosis. However finding a lack of intervention available to them at a young age was dishearting and sad. Despite research and studys showing how effective this is. I was left trying to figure out interventions and pay privately for everything to ensure they had the best possible chance to be the best he can be and hopefully be able to attend mainstream school. However again on researching school and support available I am left asking what will happen when he has to go to school, how and who will support him, will they be trained and understand his needs? Will he be safe? Why is ABA not supported in Scotland however it is everywhere else in the UK? It is cruel not allowing these unique children to be the best of themselves.30992018-09-07T05:37:56.84337749Alistair MacKinnonNeeds action, yesterday.30992018-09-07T14:28:16.80737750Angel MayFor many of us, our pets are our only family. They make us healthier and happier. We all need more of both!30742018-09-07T17:13:08.28737751Elizabeth WelchPets are part of the family & should not be parted at the most vulnerable time of people's lives. 30742018-09-07T22:23:40.12337752Denise YoungPenalties far too lenient. \r\nDog breeders need much more policing and severe penalty .30302018-09-07T22:31:23.84337754Denise YoungIt is vital that broadband coverage be available to all in Highlands and Islands .30892018-09-08T09:18:12.78737755Nancy Webster This needs to be recognised earlier than it is at the moment. These children need to be taught how to deal with there own needs and they need help to do it30992018-09-08T19:47:27.32737756charles coulsonI have two lines to my house. Both have a BB speed of 2.5 mbs(on a good day) for which BT charge me full fee of about £80 (for the two) per month. This is ridiculous. We have two lines enabled to allow more than one member of the household to stream video at the same time.30892018-09-08T20:00:17.96737758David McMillanDownload speeds listed not as vital as upload speeds for rural business30892018-09-08T23:30:57.98737760Liz ScottVideo evidence should be admissible30302018-09-09T07:56:26.1537762Ron Reidfibre is 300 yds away, but totally inaccessible - how does that make sense ?30892018-09-09T10:25:16.21337763James Barrett While our exchange is equipped for fibre broadband. It's is over 2.5 miles away. That phone line serves at least 30 properties. Today as I write this our download speed is 1.25mbps. Unless better infrastructure is put in place this will always be the case. But because the exchange has been upgraded this will be deemed good enough. IT IS NOT.30892018-09-09T12:46:37.21737765Lindsey ShirleyOur broadband speed is only 2.8 and often even less than this. It is very slow and cuts out completely on a regular basis.30892018-09-09T12:57:29.04737766Tracey TannerFailure to provide support for those on the spectrum with PDA, is discrimination30992018-09-09T14:57:34.7837767bruce buchanimproved broadband speeds are essential for rural economic and social development.30892018-09-09T16:39:24.93737768Ruth AuchterlounieAutistic people do really well when they can begin to understand themselves. Accurate timely thorough assessments can be incredibly helpful at helping families access the best support, much of which is in the voluntary sector30992018-09-09T18:22:28.62337769Christopher ShirleyAlthough the companies advertise high broadband speeds, the reality is that old telephone wires degrade the signal so if you live a distance from a 'cabinet' or exchange you will not receive a satisfactory signal. Fibre to the premises is the only solution and this will require significant investment to provide satisfactory broadband to rural areas.30892018-09-10T07:35:23.24337770Pamela Griffin A family member has been awaiting an assessment for ASD for some time. The family has been given no indication as to the time scale other than being told that there is a "lengthy waiting list". The family member displays all signs of PDA yet the family has been informed that Highland will not assess for PDA. The family member is living with constant anxiety and their education is suffering and home life is a real struggle. Professional support and recognition of PDA would make such a difference to the family's lives and would provid a fantastic supportive framework for the family member's school to work with. 30992018-09-10T09:19:41.30737771Fiona ClubbWe are on satellite broadband which gets us by. What is worse, is that Openreach are doing away with our landline service. Soon we will have no phone either. Mobile reception is poor and satellite phone is a difficult medium due to signal delays. This government likes to talk about equality but it sees no need to enforce the practicing of it. Our service is being withdrawn as the urban service is being enhanced. I understand this is an economic decision but surely there must be someone in government who knows someone in telecommunications who knows someone who specialises in solving the problems of minority citizens.30892018-09-10T10:35:26.337772Jolene KiddellEveryone should have a decent connection in the day and age30892018-09-10T15:03:28.4337773Grant DuguidThe petition is laudable, but communications is a reserved matter for Westminster, this petition needs to be sent there. Westminster gives close to £1Bn to Openreach to fund "hard to reach & uneconomic places", instead it feathers its nest, and MPs are powerless (or useless) in getting them to stick to the spirit of that monumental grant30892018-09-10T19:27:08.51737774Joyce GibsonWe are on Marrburn Exchange and access a speed of only 0.4Mbps. We were advised that we would be in the R 100 programme by 2021, meanwhile we are restricted to BT being our only provider. Which provides a minimal service inefficient to download or use any of the other options which the majority of households enjoy. We are neither a remote rural area as the closest Fibre Optic is only 2.5 miles from us. 30892018-09-10T20:41:36.6237775David RodgerI agree with the aforementioned questions.There could only be positive results from the measures as I hope they will act as a deterrent because if doesn't we may as well say good bye to our beautiful wildlife .Also why aren't more of you signing this petition what on earth are you scared of would you rather these rural criminals had their way cause if they do we may as well go " hillwalking " on the moon.30302018-09-10T23:45:21.9937776BreeTaitPets are like children to us we are responsible for them for their lifetime it is cruel to make people give up their beloved pet just because of unnecessary rules!30742018-09-10T23:52:57.02337777Bree TaitThe law must be strong enough to to deterr as well as punish to help poor animals who are at the mercy of very cruel and file people! Protect our animal better!30302018-09-11T08:19:34.18337779Jackie BuckhamI run a small medium term letting business based near Dunscore DG3. Most of my clients are in business and need a fast powerful broadband connection to be able to work. They complain about the abysmal speeds which make their work impossible and this in turn is affecting my business and also means less visitors bringing money into our area.30892018-09-11T08:33:19.32737780pam coombesPeople often end up in rented accommodation through circumstances not choice. To be parted from a beloved pet can cause severe depression.30742018-09-11T13:12:27.7337782Kerrey-Lyn MitchellAs a stay at home parent living in rural Scotland, I spend most of my day at home, and the internet in a life line to the wider community. It enables me to keep in touch with other parents, and access amenities that others in cities take for granted. \r\nDue to our location our access to fast internet is very patchy, and when it is not available, it leaves those of us living in rural areas vey isolated. \r\nBroadband should be considered a priority for all rural areas with in the UK30892018-09-12T19:06:49.53337783Anthony Jardine All children and young adults that require additional support should be given the best chance of an educational and all the support the Scottish Government can give them. 30992018-09-12T19:43:07.07737784Lynne CarsonI am signing this petition as members of my family are on the autistic spectrum 30992018-09-12T21:07:49.83737785Evan Conway Please share please.30992018-09-12T22:08:30.84737786Rosemary KaneSigned30992018-09-13T08:10:08.39737788Lisa Donnelly A family member of mine has had a shocking time going through our system and has now closed themselves off from all family. They have not seen or spoken to some family members in almost 3 years. They are a broken individual. 30992018-09-13T09:23:41.2437789R.McCarthyMore needs to be done to help children with autism in schools.30992018-09-13T09:54:00.5237790William HendersonA family member of mine has ASD. Been trying to get social work assessment since Oct last year and been told may still be more than a year before they have time! 30992018-09-13T17:53:20.51337791Tracy McCartneyChildren with Autism are getting missed all too often and it has to stop30992018-09-13T19:05:30.21337792Calum BoydonIt's vital that animals are also given rights and not discriminated against by private landlords and agencies . This would sort out the housing crisis as so many have been forced to rely on social housing because they can't take their pets onto private rent property's. 30742018-09-13T22:51:32.7937793Elizabeth PollockMy family member is autistic, but they have all the traits of PDA and it was barely mentioned at their assessment. We are able to cope with their PDA but more training needs to be given in order to support PDA traits30992018-09-13T23:03:50.33737794Linda McpheeLack of support and understanding is having a negative impact on children and families , we need better professionals, and also public awareness and education and support 30992018-09-13T23:15:08.0937795Johan PearsonI am convinced that my family member has pda which is not diagnosed in Scotland or properly understood up here in Shetland. Due to the school not understanding or meeting their needs , they are home schooled. More support, awareness and training is needed in schools.30992018-09-14T00:01:14.11337796Sharon Grant Families need action and not false promises. So many families are at breaking point and so many children and young people are being failed. We have a system which frankly isn’t fit for purpose. I had to fight for my family member for 9 years before they were diagnosed, nobody listened and was failed miserably, while I was fighting to secure a school place to get them the support they so deserved & needed I had to start the fight for another family member who is now diagnosed with ASD with PDA. I’ve had to fight not only for what we currently have in place but to have their needs recognised because it’s seems easier for certain professionals to say PDA isn’t recognised even though they were diagnosed through NHS. I had to take legal action for their needs to be recognised, to secure a school placement and to gain a Co-Ordinated Support Plan, so far I have avoided 2 tribunals. Sadly our story is all too familiar and the same stories are repeated throughout our Country. Our children/young people & adults deserve so much more. PDA needs firmly put on the agenda as it’s very much a postcode lottery.30992018-09-20T15:09:00.75337798Margaret GilmourWould save lives31222018-09-20T16:06:10.31337799Anne DuddyThis could save a lot of people as the faster you can restart the heart the better chance the person has to survive 31222018-09-20T16:26:22.96737800catherine greigit could save someones life.31222018-09-20T16:41:11.6437801alison mccaffertyagree!31222018-09-20T16:58:04.9337802Alison PurssellEarly intervention saves lives before paramedics arrive be it CPR or use of a defibrillator to save the life31222018-09-20T17:10:03.44337803robert hamiltonbadly need them .31222018-09-20T17:23:21.5337804Jean CarrollThese can help to save lives31222018-09-20T17:45:42.99337805Sharon Arthur Would help to save someones life xx31222018-09-20T18:05:03.0937807Rosemary orr Would help to save someone and are badly needed 31222018-09-20T18:12:26.96737809Christine cunningham Really need these in all public places and schools to help save lifes31222018-09-20T18:12:39.45737810Liz McNulty This can save lives if they are made accessible 31222018-09-20T18:56:15.0437811Annette Nicholas Essentially live saving equipment needed.31222018-09-20T20:12:09.45737812John orr One signature is one step closer to saving a life 31222018-09-20T20:41:11.28337813Elvira. McfadyenHopefully we can get this in all places to save ppl life's x31222018-09-20T20:51:46.22337814Madeleine brislandWould help so many people and save so many lives31222018-09-20T20:51:57.16737815May KellyGood luck31222018-09-20T20:53:09.89337816Claire DoigI think these should be accessible everywhere because it dosent cost much to save a life \r\nbut to lose a life it costs a lot \r\n31222018-09-20T21:02:18.40337817Teresa Murray I agree they should be put in all places to be used when needed to save lives.31222018-09-20T21:41:58.9837819Joanne lamond Please provide this life saving equipment.31222018-09-20T22:41:43.36337820Gerard deveneyDefibrillators should be a legal requirement for all local authorities. End of. 31222018-09-20T23:23:19.54337821Irenelaverty Should be a legal requirement a valuable life saving piece of equipment 31222018-09-20T23:36:40.3437822NICHOLA ROLSTONShould defo be a legal requirement 31222018-09-20T23:46:19.51337823Angela winton Defibrillator should be a legal requirement for all authorities without a doubt. X31222018-09-21T01:22:51.33737824Tracy Mcalinden A valuable piece of life saving equipment31222018-09-21T08:05:44.65737825Helen blairThis is a no brainer, this is a life saving device and should be as legally required as fire extinguishers.31222018-09-21T08:26:29.09337826Steph mooreWhy are they just petitioning to have them on buildings with a large footprint ? They should be everywhere regardless of building size ! These lifesaving machines should be everywhere ! I know the location of most of the PAD'S in my town it's up to people to educate themselves on this 31222018-09-21T10:55:08.05737829Lynne RowanWe need these in all schools and public places, to save people's lives.31222018-09-21T11:31:43.1837831Angela Cowan We need to help raise awareness on how important Defibrillators are 31222018-09-21T11:42:12.3637832Frances bestCan save lifes,great equipment31222018-09-21T13:21:48.97737835Declan orrThis petition should be going through because I belive that defibrillator in public and private school and sports Center will be a massive impact to our community and other communitys over the country31222018-09-21T15:59:24.7737838Jennifer jonesI am a first aider and there are definatly not enough people out there that know how or why to use a defibilator. Its such a simple thing that could save a life. 31222018-09-21T16:35:15.72737839Beth Quinlan They need to be put every where it is an essential life saving bit of equipment 31222018-09-21T17:01:26.10737840Ingrid RobertsonTHESE ARE VITAL TO SAVE LIVES31222018-09-21T18:35:21.36737842Hale ArmaniI have been to flats when I was on District Nursing training, the smell of urine soaked carpets and dogs faeces were apppalling,most probably penetrating through floor boards. That is the only reason why I think Landlords do not allow pets!30742018-09-21T19:26:04.6137843Sam TurnerHave been through the same challenge lost family member to heart failure 31222018-09-21T22:12:26.74337844Margaret Long This petition must be passed for all public places to have a Defib 31222018-09-21T22:50:07.6737846Gillian Atkinson This is a vital piece of equipment. We hear more and more of people who could have been saved if this equipment was available there and then. You cannot put a price on a life. 31222018-09-22T10:39:23.17737847dee donworthI have car stickers. Love Scotland. Stop killing the wildlife !30302018-09-22T10:44:46.7637848jonathan david GrantIf someone commits a crime they must be punished for it.to kill wild animals for gain is a crime against GOD30302018-09-22T11:01:58.2337849George MurdochThe fact that an individual can be photographed committing a crime and this evidence cannot be used in court because the beneficiary of the crime must consent to its use is ridiculous and must be terminated.30302018-09-22T11:14:53.71337850Patricia ScalesNot allowing covert video is ludicrous. No-one would commit a crime if they knew a camera was recording it, they'd just wait or commit the crime elsewhere.30302018-09-22T11:31:31.3937851Les WallaceThose involved in Field Sports that claim they detest wildlife crime are perfectly free to sign as well - how many have done so?\r\n30302018-09-22T11:44:45.37337852Amber hall A life saving equipment which should be placed in all schools and public places! 31222018-09-22T21:05:38.92737853Agnes Whiting.All those who try to destroy the woodlands should be jailed for more than three years.30302018-09-22T22:50:49.00337854Judith Jones Prosecute the persecutors30302018-09-23T03:58:34.70737855Glen BorrillIt's time that murders of animals are treated like murders of humans.30302018-09-23T10:38:50.97737856Debbie RileyWe need to protect the deminishing wildlife we have left. Those who do not respect our wildlife need to be accountable in a way that they take warning. 30302018-09-23T22:50:17.72337858Elaine Ferguson If it helps save a life then it's all very worth it 31222018-09-23T23:25:14.24337859Mandy Brown These should be all round public places and especially schools .31222018-09-24T13:38:03.2237860HelenmooreThey should be available every where when needed 31222018-09-24T23:11:53.43337861Phyllis McNeilShould be in all public places 31222018-09-25T05:12:10.7837862John Taylor Land ownership has become to closely associated with freedom to persecute increasingly rare wildlife with no meaningful public sanction. This must change in short order.30302018-09-26T14:14:26.29737863Beth MorrisonPE01548 National Guidance on Restraint & Seclusion has been in the parliamentary petitions committee since Feb 2015. We have collected almost 600 family stories of children with additional needs being hurt, injured and traumatised by the inappropriate use of restraint and seclusion. There have been various criminal investigations in the past few years and not one has resulted in any kind of accountability. Families are told that because their children are non verbal or have extremely poor communication skills, they cannot be interviewed by Police and they cannot be cross examined in court. Even when there is medical, photographic and other expert witness reports, families are told that the absence of their childs witness testimony means that it is impossible to reach the standard of evidence required to bring these cases to court. This means children who are injured due to abuse in schools and childrens services are being denied the access to the criminal justice system because they have no voice. Children who have limited communication skills and have tried very hard to tell Police what has happened are considered "not credible". Anything those children disclose to trusted adults (even teachers and social workers) are "not admissable". If we had CCTV cameras in schools this would make any accusations of abuse easier to detect. It not only protects our most vulnerable children, it protects the staff from false accusations. 31342018-09-26T14:23:30.70737864Marcello MegaI'm a journalist and have been writing for years about children being abused physically in schools, with photographic evidence to support the stories, yet staff get away with it all the time. Cameras in schools, care homes and anywhere else where vulnerable people spend a lot of time protects both the vulnerable people and the staff, some of whom no doubt fear false allegations or being tarred with the same brush as a brutal colleague. Cameras will keep people safe and protect staff from being wrongly accused. It's a win-win situation.31342018-09-26T14:54:13.71337865Tomas ManganielloIs there enough commonsense for this to work ?31342018-09-26T15:06:37.11737866Allan ParrisDont see this being a problem if you have nothing to hide, this is a good idea as it will protect the child..31342018-09-26T15:17:36.49737867Helen Gillespie Vegan diets are well documented to be the most healthful diet available provided they are balanced as all state provided meals should be. They can play a part in both prevention, alleviation and reversal of some of the leading chronic health problems faced by the country and that put a burden on the health and social care system.\r\nFundamentally, veganism is a protected belief system under Human Rights and Equality law and all vegans should have access to food in accordance with these beliefs. 31152018-09-26T15:19:11.88737868Barbara Bolton Plant-based food is for everyone. This is a minimum first step that the Scottish Government can easily take. 31152018-09-26T15:38:13.71737870James Boyle Public authorities need to take provision of vegan meals more seriously. The rights of vegans are protected under law and more people will be prepared to try vegan foods if they are easier to try. 31152018-09-26T16:01:59.98337871Helen KeenanScottish Government to bring forward legislation to guarantee plant base options on every public sector menu to protect the rights of vegans and for our health the enviroment n animals thank you31152018-09-26T16:11:18.67337872Nicola ross100% agree there should be cameras to stop this from happening to ANYONE !!!31342018-09-26T16:12:20.0837873Mairi PatersonChildren should be aware what they are eating and if they choose to be vegan then meals should be provided for them31152018-09-26T16:19:24.37737874Shona MitchellAgree31152018-09-26T16:39:07.4937877James DoddsNon-Vegan can eat Vegan. Vegans can't eat non-vegan31152018-09-26T16:44:11.6337878Winifred AndersonYes I agree that cameras should be place in these areas.31342018-09-26T16:57:18.49737879Victoria laing davis Offering balanced vegan option meals should be something that all public sector buildings promote.\r\nEncouraging and supporting the public to make healthy and ethical choices31152018-09-26T17:38:17.03337880Elizabeth Reilly Something is needing to be done about this situation asap. Put themselves in the place of a parent with a child at these schools! Bet something would get done straight away! 31342018-09-26T18:14:33.61737881Heidi NealIf a child's testimony can not be used in evidence then these cameras are imperative if we are to ensure that we respect the rights of children31342018-09-26T18:19:33.66337882Amanda SykesVeganism is a protected characteristic, so should be accommodated31152018-09-26T18:42:48.4837884Julie GoldsackVeganism is a way of life committed to ending the suffering and violence endured by all animals for consumption and the demand for meat and other by products. A lifestyle choice based on profound beliefs and commitments, just like religion, and as religious beliefs and lifestyle choices are respected and catered for in our society, then I firmly believe that veganism should be offered the respect and tolerance. 31152018-09-26T18:51:36.21337886Michele FoxA matter of justice for all animals, non-human and human.31152018-09-26T18:55:21.80737887william smithif i ever have to go to hospital, i would hope that my dietary requirements would be met.31152018-09-26T18:55:43.91337888Laura SeymourThere should always be a food choice everywhere 31152018-09-26T19:24:36.3437889Vida ColvinPersonally I would have preferred CCTV evidence to be available rather than the awful lies school staff told to Police during investigation of assault which was believed over a child and parent. \r\nChildren NEED unmonitored and non-sensitive areas covered by CCTV for their own protection particularly in corridors and around abhorrent seclusion rooms to provide evidence that staff caused injury to a child which happens a lot and often does not relate to any restraint policy. The abuse in schools goes on as Police report no intent. Unmonitored CCTV would provide evidence of intent as children are not accidentally injured some of which are horrific.31342018-09-26T20:07:59.11737890Alison BrewsterIt is ridiculous that Vegan options are not included as standard on menus. Public sector should represent the public - in all aspects of services - stop this discrimination now.31152018-09-26T20:16:27.50337891Deborah WicksVeganism is a protected belief and as such public bodies have a duty to provide vegan alternatives where a vegan alternative exists. They also have a duty to support the development of vegan alternatives so they can fulfil their obligations fully and not use this as an excuse. 31152018-09-26T20:25:50.44737892Irene dollinNo child should ever have this done to them \r\n31342018-09-26T20:26:13.61737893Rebecca FrostThe food served in hospitals is not what people want and there is little to no facilities for vegans and when people are recovering from serious illness they need to eat31152018-09-26T20:47:22.86737894Samantha BrownNo child should be treated in this way!31342018-09-26T21:53:08.25337897Diana BoyleI am not vegan however I believe everyone has the right to be able to choose what they want to eat and these choices should be made available in public sectors.31152018-09-26T21:57:58.45737898Debra DorransThe rights of people who are vegan must be respected. It is discrimination if they are not able to get something to eat that is respectful to their beliefs31152018-09-26T23:09:54.31337899Hazel McArthurEveryone should have the choice to eat vegan food, everywhere! Especially in hospitals!31152018-09-27T04:16:55.30337900Marcella vassLong overdue 31152018-09-27T06:08:31.89737901Nicola KiddIf Scotland is going to be inclusive it is imperative that plant-based food is available in all public sector buildings and services. 31152018-09-27T07:06:34.9737902Alistair MacleodScotland has world leading targets to reduce co2 emissions and this change will enable the huge number of people to support this through choosing vegan food. 31152018-09-27T08:15:40.74737903Nola ONeillPlease, at a time when we should be getting the best food to heal, ensure we can have vegan options. I would not want the anxiety of being in hospital made worse by not being able to have my normal diet.31152018-09-27T08:17:56.2637904Leanne AitkenSo easy to provide good vegan options. Just do it.31152018-09-27T09:07:48.8637905Joy SloanIt seems wrong not to be able to buy vegan food at a hospital 31152018-09-27T09:33:30.137906Caroline BarrI had oral cancer and was denied a Vegan option PEG feed. This was against my plant based diet choice! 31152018-09-27T10:06:02.85337907Gillian ReidShocking, this needs to stop31342018-09-27T11:48:48.74337908Louise RamshawI urge the Scotland to ensure vegans are catered for at every public institution. This is not only a Human Rights issue but also a welfare, health and environmental issue. 31152018-09-27T11:58:08.65337909Philippa SimmondsThis would be a great initiative for the Scottish government to take. When I worked in hospitals in Glasgow I was amazed at the poor quality of the hospital food- high in salt and fat, low in fresh vegetables and fibre. Good nutrition is one of the foundations of good health, yet if we can't provide these options in our healthcare institutions how can we lecture people on eating healthily at home? This initiative is important both in terms of non-discrimination and in terms of public health, and would be a progressive, forward-thinking move for Scotland.31152018-09-27T13:09:11.0537910Tòmas MacAilpeinThis would be a fantastic step forward for healthy and more environmentally-friendly eating. It would cater not just to vegans alone but would be an option for most people.31152018-09-27T13:10:09.5837911Lauren I PhilpI'm a hungry vegan.31152018-09-27T13:19:26.58737912Lorna Flanaganplease hear us31152018-09-27T14:18:27.34337914Gillian Ferguson Yes I agree with this, public sector menus should be inclusive.31152018-09-27T14:41:42.2237916Tommy KellyThis should be mandatory as vegans we have human rights like anyone else as it is an ethical stance against all forms of animal exploitation,with food being one of them and really hope this is put into practice for vegan options in all public sector menus31152018-09-27T15:32:16.11737917Adam DruettPlease respect the right of every individual not to want to intentionally harm innocent creatures.31152018-09-27T16:11:35.6137918Caroline SimpsonI agree entirely with the reason for this petition.31152018-09-27T16:19:38.07737920Kyle GibsonIf we were to have menus that only served vegan food I'm sure there would be an outcry from people saying they deserve the choice of meat. Can't have double standards.31152018-09-27T17:46:22.32337921Elizabeth MayI think its time People, and especially Animals have a voice on this planet. And for the Improvement of the human diet, for the future generations of children, to change to a plant-based life style.31152018-09-27T18:51:47.78737924Daniel BrownIm vegan and I know how difficult it can be to find a vegan option when limited to one place to eat. This action would ensure there is always an option available in public sector locations and encourage other establishments to offer an one too. I believe it is only fair that everyone should have the option to eat. Most importantly it could have a real impact on reducing the number of animals subjected to cruelty.31152018-09-27T19:18:21.14737926Margaret StewartI believe it is very important to offer vegan food in all areas of catering. Inclusive Scotland ?31152018-09-27T19:24:07.88337927Ann HarveyPlease let this happen31152018-09-27T19:48:13.99337928Gerard McDadeMenus never state " animal mince and tatties " so why not supply our dinner schools with nutritional soy mince which tastes no different and doesn't come from tortured animals.31152018-09-27T23:58:01.06337929Tracy TaylorAs a non meat eater I would like to see healthy vegan options in the public vector as current options are very limited.31152018-09-28T04:16:59.0837931Kay MeechanProtect these vulnerable children 31342018-09-28T05:52:24.8937932William RendleDear Scottish Government. Please provide Vegan Food we can all be proud of in all public spaces. \r\n31152018-09-28T08:17:04.42737933Lorna Laverick As a vegan who has been in hospital a lot (childhood cancer and side effects) I find it impossible to have any decent nutritional vegan meal in the hospital. I would like to see big changes in this.31152018-09-28T08:38:01.8237934Justina PliuskeviciutePlease introduce at least one option of healthy vegan option in Scotlands public institutions.31152018-09-28T08:49:31.2337935Theresa Cummings This is our of order and should not happen to anyone31342018-09-28T08:57:33.4237937Christine ShearerI couldn't eat anything for the full two days I was in hospital when I had my baby as there were no vegan options at all. Family members don't use the cafeterias in school as there are no vegan options for them to choose. 31152018-09-28T09:02:44.12337938Daniel DoyleThis is what a good charity and this family does to help other children in life by having a fighting chance in there life that Jayden couldnt have rest in peace wee man love n miss u loads31222018-09-28T09:50:50.7237941Margaret gilbertA family member can only have baked potatoe and beans or. Chips and beans for her school meal31152018-09-28T10:40:21.5937943Donny mcintyrePlant based diet is necessary to sage the planet and also shows a verse empathy with other living beings - espially higher mammals whose emotional complexity is similar to our own.31152018-09-28T11:01:19.32737944Claire McCarthy With 9% of the population being vegan it is discriminatory not to offer vegan meal options in public places.31152018-09-28T11:19:10.3137945Susanne FrankeWe need such a petition for Germany, too. Thanks for the initiative. Your paving paths!31152018-09-28T11:36:56.3637946Barbara BoltonVegans should be provided for in all of our schools, hospitals and prisons. We live our lives in a way that recognises the right of other animals to their own lives, the right not to be used as resources and killed. That moral conviction is protected under law, but is not currently being respected in our schools and hospitals. Food suitable for vegans is inclusive, can be enjoyed by everyone, can be healthy, nutritious and tasty, is better for the environment and sustainability and can be cheaper. It's a win, win for all. 31152018-09-28T11:47:53.9937947Don Nicholass-McKeeIts not too much to ask, just make the vegetarian option a vegan one, easily done.31152018-09-28T13:06:54.9837948Rachael Cooper-BohannonIn the interest of equality and inclusion we need to move forward but also from an ethical and environmental stand point, even if people aren't vegan eating more plant based foods is better for us and the planet.31152018-09-28T19:58:22.08737949Pamela buddyYes I agree cameras should be put in these places to protect our vulnerable children 31342018-09-28T21:26:38.137950Cheryl dickI believe cameras should not only be in these schools but in a lot of places for the protection or loved ones deserve .31342018-09-28T21:30:00.50337951Eyleen CocksPlease don't let it happen to another child31342018-09-28T21:44:52.1537952Shirley watsonI fully agree they should be cameras 31342018-09-28T21:46:19.8837953Aino LeskinenVegans have the right to wholesome plant-based food in public sector cantines, as veganism is protected under the human rights and equality law. \r\nA vegan food option is often healthy and suitable for everyone. Especially in schools education of healthy eating at an early age can have a lasting positive impact and catering for vegans in all public sector is a step forward towards a more compassionate and sustainable society.31152018-09-28T21:53:19.4637954Vicky websterCameras should be installed in all schools to safe guard every one31342018-09-28T22:02:11.55337955Joan OrdAn appropriate diet in accordance with a patients moral belief system is a basic right! 31152018-09-29T07:43:22.87337956Maureen Williams Defibrillators should be readily available in every large public building. It should be part of the essential medical kit . Numerous lives could and will be saved if these are in as many locations as possible. 31222018-09-29T08:39:52.67337957Linda HARGIETo avoid stress & separation anxiety akin to bereavement for both tenant & pet.\r\nDiscourage the cultural notion of "disposable" pets. \r\nRelieve burden of rescue centres. 30742018-09-29T09:07:34.74337959David Smart We have a duty to help the world to be a better place for ALL creatures. Educating people and promoting healthy lifestyles is paramount to a nation's standing.\r\nI believe that being a vegan is the future for mankind 31152018-09-29T11:26:42.24337961Lindsay Gibson A vegan option instead of vegetarian would meet more needs. You may be surprised by how many people choose it! 31152018-09-29T13:01:50.1837962Stuart WhitbyIf you choose to restrict your diet for ideological reasons, then making vegan options a legal requirement also brings with it the requirement to include Halal and Kosher foods on every public sector menu every day, and undoubtedly others.\r\n\r\nIf you have special requests then these can be put to the catering staff at the time, who may or may not be able to meet your requests. Otherwise, like those who eat Halal or Kosher, be aware that your ideology is likely to impose restrictions on you and bring your own. \r\n\r\nPolicy in this regard should be market driven, not ideology driven. If it's profitable then it will be put on menus.31152018-09-29T19:08:49.87337964Andrew PalmerAlthough not a vegan I think vegan options should be more available to allow healthier and more sustainable food options31152018-09-29T19:50:46.18737965Helen BrittonWe need to be inclusive of everyones needs it isnt difficult provide vegan and vegetarian options, particularly when we are trying to reduce fat, sugar and processed foods in diets, additionally introducing vegan diets would show children and adults alike how easy and tasty it is 31152018-09-29T20:27:48.69737967Marian GordonHelp the environment, better healthy options to reduce obesity, ethically and morally correct to provide choices for all31152018-09-29T23:09:10.15737968Sandra Strathie Better for us better for animals and better for the planet . Vegans should have the right to have the food they want 31152018-09-30T05:48:13.9937969Sarah GibsonJust make the veggie option on a menu vegan, not hard operationally. Eating less meat & dairy surely links in with current health and environmental goals? 31152018-09-30T08:21:36.6237970Julie Rennie Yes I agree cameras should be put in place to support kids and also staff 31342018-09-30T08:30:25.09337972Teresa BuchanDefinitely! Plant-based, varied food options are so much more nutritious and healthy than foods containing animal products. In Scotland we are already doing a great job at trying to tackle obesity, childhood diabetes and other diet-related issues through the reduction of sugar, sugary drinks and alcohol awareness. It only makes sense to start looking into the nutritional benefits of whole plant-based diets in order to improve public health. \r\nWith Scotland also being a country on the forefront of renewable energies, zero waste campaigns and other environmental aspects it is also time to acknowledge the negative impacts of animal farming for what they are. While you can argue that Scotland has its largest amount of farming happening outdoors - i.e. cows in the fields etc. - it is still necessary to remember that most people purchase processed foods and ready meals and it is sadly a fact that most products available containing animal derivatives do not contain local animal-sources but factory farmed, often even from other countries, i.e. pork imported from Denmark etc.. The environmental impact of meat and animal products should not longer be ignored as it's the highest contributor to greenhouse gasses and as population grows this issue is only going to grow. \r\n\r\nA very important topic and I hope that the Scottish government will take thorough measures in researching those facts and getting priorities in order. 31152018-09-30T12:16:37.1737973Ruth HaweFood free from any animal ingredients is the fastest way to save the environment and resources and to improve public health. Vegan food is also a protected belief system now so provision must be made with vegan food available in every institution.31152018-09-30T12:51:07.20337974Vivienne HughsonFor inclusion and choice,vegan options are essential and better for the planet (and animals!)31152018-09-30T14:18:38.16737975Conner ArmstrongAn important step forward for the environment, animal rights, and human health.31152018-09-30T14:49:07.68737976Linda websterVegans should have more choice we are the ones trying to save the planet the animal's and the future for other generations31152018-09-30T14:55:24.00337977Ashby McGowanIt needs to be easy for people to get vegan food I public places and venues31152018-09-30T15:19:20.00337978Allison Robertson As a vegan working in the NHS, the menu at work is improving for vegetarians but incredibly limited to vegans. The only thing I can ever eat is a baked potato with beans....everyday. I always take my own food to work with me.31152018-09-30T17:42:25.74737979June Harrison Animals and humans are equal we are all sentient beings sharing the planet and they are not ours to eat but to be cared for 31152018-09-30T18:10:07.6737980Nikola HauptI am not vegan but I strive to consume ever fewer animal products for sustainability and more importantly from a sense of ethics. Vegan diets should be supported. 31152018-09-30T18:40:59.3837981david mclaineIt will introduce the idea that animals suffer so that they can eat meat.31152018-09-30T19:03:48.4637983Adrienne EganPublic Sector menus should have menus that carer for all. People who are not vegan or vegetarian may prefer to go for a healthier vegan option and should be given the choice. 31152018-09-30T21:26:50.67737984Delia GallagherA family member has to be dairy free for medical reasons and it is always difficult to find reasonable food choices for them so this would help, things like vegan pizzas or sorbets and vegan ice cream would be good.31152018-09-30T22:47:07.6837986James DoddsNon-Vegans can eat Vegan, Vegans can't eat Non-Vegan31152018-10-01T11:21:17.90737988Miss Eyleen CocksPlease sign petition, don't let it happen to another vulnerable person.31342018-10-01T11:32:30.8637989Brian Mckechnie Yes I agree the cameras should be put in place to prevent this from happening 31342018-10-01T11:43:06.26737991Elizabeth lightbodyThink this should be done especially where there is kids involved can also be there to help teachers safety 31342018-10-01T12:06:45.10337992Fiona prattThis needs to be done to protect our children in asn schools.. 31342018-10-01T12:08:31.22337993Joyce Campbell Everyone deserves choices31152018-10-01T12:25:50.64737994Elaine McCondochie I am absolutely shocked that in this day and age that a child can return home in a state like that, with no way of being able to hold anyone accountable.31342018-10-01T13:48:42.41737995Jacky birchvegans usually have very strong moral and ethical reasons for not eating or using animal products so it is correct that they should be offered a food source suitable to their beliefs.31152018-10-01T14:47:22.82337996Sheryl Opsahl Not only does a plant based diet promote better health, 8t teaches children kindness & compassion to all species31152018-10-01T17:50:26.19337997Jacqueline ClarkA worthwhile petition.31152018-10-01T17:51:33.69337998Mae ScottIncreasing number of vegans who shoud have access to vegan meals31152018-10-01T18:03:41.3237999Liz bridges Time for change 31342018-10-01T18:57:42.22338000ROBERT Adamson I think people beating young kid's maker me fell very sick 31342018-10-01T19:52:56.2138001Yoginee GokoolFully agree. This is so important. Vegans are aware of the benefits of plant based diets for their food intake, in fact, just for health they perhaps subsidise a lot of lifestyle based issues burdening the NHS.31152018-10-01T22:11:03.5138002Elizabeth Mcdonald Having witnessed a family member go through an assault at his ASN school and then listened as the staff lied and protected the abusers ,this has to stop NOW 31342018-10-01T22:58:17.0838004paula maddeneveryone, should have an option 31152018-10-02T04:34:39.68738005Mary Mcquillan Shocking that this happens in this day an age31342018-10-02T05:45:46.52738006Katrina.lennonShould be fitted in all schools nursery and retiring homes31342018-10-02T09:59:36.41338007Catherine GoldieI think it should be mandatory in every school. It is a different world we live in now and we must do whatever we can to protect our children, our family, our friends and our Teachers. What this young girl went through is unacceptable and the sad thing is she is not the only one but hopefully through this petition she will be the last.31342018-10-02T10:57:24.17338008Emma Wilson Having a vegan option in schools will introduce kids to the idea of veganism at an early age, providing them with the option to make their own minds up about what they want to eat. Choosing vegan is about so much more than animal welfare - it is also a choice for our health (especially important in young kids) and for our planet, which is slowly dying largely as a result of animal agriculture.31152018-10-02T16:13:31.51338011Michelle CuninghameBeing vegan is a protected characteristic in the Equality Act (2010) under beliefs. Every child, young person and adult should not be discriminated for their choice not to discriminate between species, just as those with religious beliefs would be catered for. Choosing to be vegan should mean we are catered for, the same as all others with dietary requirements.31152018-10-02T18:16:49.96738012Wendy FinnieIts about time children were offered a varied healthy diet and a vegan option daily would also cover the children who also are vegetarian . It is cheaper and healthier.31152018-10-02T20:37:55.4438013Barbara UsherThere is a widespread agreement that a plant-based diet is a healthier option. Our children ought to be given positive encouragement to eat healthily. A move to a vegan option would benefit children, animals, and future taxpayers who will spend less on the NHS. 31152018-10-02T21:36:06.21338014Petra GriffinPeople should not have to starve because they are in hospital or have to go into residential care. They should have their beliefs respected and their diet catered for.31152018-10-03T11:34:17.77738016Chris PreeceAnyone, vegan or non vegan, should have the *option* to eat a plant based meal31152018-10-04T07:27:18.62738017Andrena Jane Tyler It would not only safeguard the children but also the teachers. We should be promoting open visable trusting towards our most vulnerable tberfor it should be openly used like cctv on our streets to aid the safety of all.31342018-10-04T08:20:11.61738018Johanna Gowie100% Support this after a family member was injured at school31342018-10-04T10:20:32.73738019Dominic FrancocciSounds good!31152018-10-04T10:51:15.2638020Hazel willoxThe introduction of cameras would protect staff from false allegations as well as all children including those who are most vulnerable.31342018-10-04T11:35:51.51338021Mhairi Parlitu No child should be restrained or hurt while in school especially children that have any sort of disability. 31342018-10-04T14:51:43.57738023Stephen BalfourVeganism is not a dietary choice, its a belief that we should not subject animals to unnecessary suffering. To not cater for vegan diets is therefore no different to any other forms of discrimination.31152018-10-04T15:48:44.89738024June TeghriSo shocking for this to happen, so I think all schools and Nurseries should be fitted with CCTV.31342018-10-04T19:14:38.86338025Gillian ToshA family member was subjected to restraint and exclusion within school. They were locked out of class as strategies to manage autistic and adhd behaviours. They needed support and were often punishment for adults getting their support wrong .Clear strategies were ignored and could have prevented the trauma they suffered.Cameras need to be installed to keep kids safe from unlawful practices.It also keeps staff safe from any untrue accusations due to other staff members 31342018-10-04T22:17:43.60738027Clare ChalmersWe have the technology these days, why not use it to protect the vulnerable and those who work with them for prevention and safety of all? 31342018-10-04T23:57:32.238029Alexis McGhee-kasraviA family member is at nursery and the catering department have refused to provide and the head of facilities has advised the nursery to stop providing alternatives, it is being fought and this will help.31152018-10-05T10:44:09.56338030Sue WilliamsIf you can supply halal meat, then surely you can supply Vegan food to people whose beliefs prevent them from doing harm to any living creature.31152018-10-05T11:58:47.5838032Natasha LowBeing a vegetarian or vegan you should be catered for in school, hospital or nursing and care homes. People shouldn't have to go hungry because they don't eat meat.31152018-10-05T12:01:27.8738033Audrey AndersonChildren should know the torture animals go through in the meat and dairy process!!!! All for the sake of their palette.".31152018-10-05T12:33:38.9738034Jonathan Hill It is unfair that veganisim is not recognised in social or medical environments when ever other dietary needs seem to be recognised.31152018-10-05T18:42:29.41338036Rachel Gillespie It is a protected belief system which everyone can eat and enjoy. Also, proven health benefits and increasingly popular.31152018-10-05T19:41:40.51738037Caroline brown providing vegan food should be easy as anyone can eat it 31152018-10-05T22:44:40.2638039James Boyle People who are ill should not have to face the additional burden of eating food which they identify as the product of an abusive industry - food which may also make them feel unwell, both physiologically and psychologically. 31152018-10-05T23:28:00.8438040Angela lamontVegan food anyone can eat but Vegans cannot eat any food, therefore should be catered for 100%31152018-10-06T00:22:13.09738041Vicki Lines We need to cater for all dietary requirements, whether they be based upon physical, religious or ethical reasons. It's also healthier and cheaper than some meat based options.31152018-10-06T00:36:00.63338042Joyce FraserWe should be promoting a more plant based diet for the planet and animal welfare sake.31152018-10-06T08:42:15.5838043Jen DrysdaleA plant based diet should be avaliable for all. No-one should have to put stuff into their bodies that they don't feel is of benefiT to their health and wellbeing.31152018-10-06T08:44:11.72338044Rachel BellWhether for reasons of health, allergy or person choice, vegan food Must be made available to those who need it. This really shouldn't even be in debate.. it's just comments sense. If animal products make me ill, why should I be forced to eat them when I am in hospital?! 31152018-10-06T09:07:33.97738045Jennifer GibsonAll vegans deserve the right to a plant based Neal if they are in n hospital etc. It isn't fair that we are not accommodated for. It's also beneficial to people for their health.the environment and for animals who have the right to live.31152018-10-06T13:22:17.52338049Christine ShearerI couldn't eat anything for the full two days I was in hospital when I had my baby as there were no vegan options available at all.\r\n3 family school age children can't use the cafeterias in their schools as there are no vegan options for them to choose from, one is eligible for free school meals as they are in primary 3 but they miss out on this as there isn't any vegan food options.31152018-10-06T23:27:27.48338050Donna ballThere is no downside. It's good for the earth and for the consumers. Not depriving anyone just more inclusive. No reason why it shouldn't be the case.31152018-10-07T08:46:09.59338051Pauline DaviesNon animal food options should be the norm and not treated as the unusual. Vegan options are simple to offer.31152018-10-07T14:31:05.15338054Lori gardinerMore and more people are turning to a vegan diet and they should always have a plant based option31152018-10-08T08:39:01.14338056Wendy hoggCause they are human beings and have as much right as anyone else has 31152018-10-08T10:02:00.01338057Gerard McDadeWe must ensure that we provide healthy alternatives especially in Schools and hospitals etc. 31152018-10-08T11:11:40.8538058Mrs Yvonne Simpson Vegans like to eat out too, nine times out of ten there is one option, it's not really good enough 31152018-10-08T12:35:20.37338060Paula MossThis is essential that this happens, to build towards a kinder more caring compassionate society, it's a win win for everybody.31152018-10-08T14:44:48.87338061Maureen Martin with Zola All children should have the choice of Vegan food31152018-10-08T21:17:07.40338062Lynne LeslieOld age comes to us all! Take note. 31392018-10-08T22:47:52.71338063Lynda Frame Agree with Donna: There is no downside. It's good for the earth and for the consumers. Not depriving anyone just more inclusive. No reason why it shouldn't be the case.31152018-10-09T08:50:07.9738064Morag RobsonIt's all about choice31152018-10-09T11:10:34.73338065Alastair Stables Plant based nutrition is the way forward for our health, the wellbeing of the planet, and for a more compassionate society.31152018-10-09T12:41:44.92338066Jacquie PerrieI agree with this action, as causing suffering to any living being is wrong and unacceptable! Eating animals is unhealthy for humans and the planet! I wish for a kinder world! The meat industry are liars, and we are dishonest with our children about where their food comes from!\r\n\r\nIts the right thing to do!\r\n31152018-10-09T15:39:18.89738067Lesley LeishmanDisgusted at the whole Education system at present.Children with Additional Support Needs are being failed massively and this needs to stop! 31342018-10-09T18:31:49.96338068Sandra Strathie Cater for everyone 31152018-10-09T21:36:02.75338069Alan Murdoch It is important to cater for everyone31152018-10-10T08:51:02.05338071Russ HayleyVegan food is the healthiest food choice so it should be provided by hospitals and public sector places. All about choice in the 21st century.31152018-10-10T08:51:29.03738072Keiran reid I think that meat will soon be a thing of the past when people realise the flavour and never-ending supply of veg and vegan options it is all about choice but we are brought up with an attitude to eat meat \r\n31152018-10-10T09:40:39.38738074Sharon Hunter We all should have a choice in hospitals, prisons, school and all other public places, it is our right. 31152018-10-10T13:38:42.0338075Alison Riley It's time people realise that being Vegan is so important for our future. It benefits our health, the environment and is a more compassionate way to live your life. It might seem like a big change or an extreme diet but it really isn't that big a deal once you get used to it. 31152018-10-10T13:57:58.8938076Natalie RossFreedom of choice 31152018-10-10T16:02:57.15338077Margaret Macgregor Let's do our bit for the planet and all life that shares it31152018-10-10T16:41:08.70738078Callum McCrindleEveryone should have a choice of food ..Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal,Non Halal.... Actually represent the needs of the people!31152018-10-10T19:35:12.55738079Stephanie HowarthYoung people should have the same dietary choices as adults. They will not feel different from others if it is available on the menu. 31152018-10-10T21:49:37.21738080Emma SnellgroveIf people are vegan, this option should be available to patients. 31152018-10-11T06:14:28.53338081Anna MaddrickThe future is vegan31152018-10-11T11:16:50.2638082Michael QuinnIt's all about Freedom of choice.31152018-10-11T12:47:14.17738083Tracey Russell A vegan option absolutely should be available to all and children should also be taught about where their meat comes from and the devastation the meat industry has on the planet.31152018-10-11T13:01:17.4638084THOMAS WHYTEEasily available, cruitly free, vegan food should be available on every public sector menu. Lead by example. 31152018-10-11T13:58:30.03338085Margaret McClenaghan I enjoy vegan and vegetarian food and we are not harming animals31152018-10-11T14:31:20.01338086Pamela buddyThis has got to stop wee need to keep our children safe 31342018-10-11T22:03:10.82738087Denise England We have just been informed that we have 12 years to turn back the tide on climate change and that to save the planet one of the most essential things we all need to cut back on meat and dairy consumption. 31152018-10-12T08:27:27.54338089David GibbonThe future is vegan.31152018-10-12T09:05:25.50338091Sylvia RussellApart from anything else. cottage hospitals ease the pressure of bed blocking in acute hospitals31392018-10-12T11:45:21.50738093Sean David MacLeodI strongly support this petition, for the benefit, health, and wellbeing of all my fellow Scottish citizens.31152018-10-12T11:48:24.60338094Sean David MacLeodI strongly support this petition, for the health and wellbeing of all my fellow Scottish citizens.31152018-10-12T12:24:30.1538095John CollingsWe have to protect the environment and by choosing a vegan option people can reduce the impact the livestock production has on the world.31152018-10-12T15:21:04.9138096Moira LindsayAnimal farming causes a large percentage of CO2 emissions which are causing climate change. 31152018-10-12T18:53:06.1638097Eileen BairdIn view of the evidence of health benefits in preventing and reversing heart disease, cancer and diabetes, a vegan diet in schools and hospitals would improve health and save money. Benefit to the environment is also hugely important.31152018-10-12T21:43:56.1538098William MilneEmployees in the public sector and pupils in schools should be given the opportunity to choose food which is free from animal products.31152018-10-13T00:35:12.7138100Karen MacdonaldIt's common knowledge that the meat and dairy industry is having a devastating impact on the planet so it makes sense to have vegan options in all public sector buildings. We all deserve choice in life. 31152018-10-13T10:23:53.7738102Diane PageWhy would you not want to give a child the choice of a healthy and cruelty free alternative?31152018-10-13T18:40:45.75738104George Whyte It's easy buying and cooking vegan food and you know what your eating.\r\n31152018-10-13T20:52:56.22738105Samantha WildeWe are the future!31152018-10-14T07:42:29.87738107John whitelaw Times have changed , a plant based diet is the was forward for a cruelty free better environment and population 31152018-10-14T12:30:26.6238109Shirley KobielaNot everyone can or wants to eat meat and you'd think that by now (2018) the choice would already be there ?!\r\n31152018-10-14T21:19:39.138111Lorna Flanagana family member is vegan and does not have began choices at high school. Giving vegan options is not only good for health, but for our planet.31152018-10-14T22:05:18.86338112Karine DavisonI am not vegan but believe that all people should be able to access food that suits them. 31152018-10-14T22:14:57.42738113Karine DavisonI am not vegan but believe that all people should be able to access food that suits them. 31152018-10-14T22:22:06.2538114Lucia scottI'm trying my hardest to be a vegan (current vegetarian) but it's so hard when there isn't any options anywhere, especially Dumfriesshire. 31152018-10-15T06:23:18.9338115Sarah Buchan I work in schools and can tell you the menu options are appalling! These kids have meat available to them daily, and no doubt consume again when they get home. This is unhealthy. Even schools which have vegetarian days, everything is made with cheese. Who else knows about the dangers of casein? We must do better. For our children and our planet.31152018-10-15T10:41:50.4338116Yasmin Taylor I thought our education system was meant to be inclusive? A family member is at primary in Glasgow and can not have a school meal as they offer halal and the achool is nut free but discriminate against veganism as they have no vegan options. This is backward and not acceptable 31152018-10-15T10:42:44.0638117Ian DonnachieSomeone close to me is still managing in her own home, but she's one of the lucky ones. There needs to be as much support as possible for the elderly at community and local level. 31392018-10-15T10:51:11.6438118Jane Holman This should be standard practice by now. 31152018-10-15T11:55:29.11338120Fiona ReillyAs someone who follows a vegan diet I would love to have more healthy vegan options available in the public sector. Thank you!31152018-10-15T11:59:52.05738121Isobel GroomTeaches children to care about animals, the environment and health. Schools need to take the health of children more seriously and a plant based diet is one of the most effective ways to help a variety of issues 31152018-10-15T18:32:38.95738124Sanna BurnsI work on the NHS and cannot get a dairyfree vegan meal - and I have seen patients struggle to get a goo meal. Hospitals should be a place of healing, not where unhealthy processed meat is served. Seeing quorn on the menu was a good move for vegetarians but those of us with egg allergies or who are vegan cannot eat it most Quorn products. Choosing a vegan option would make a meal suitable to most - even those with religious dietary needs.31152018-10-15T19:00:34.86738125Carol Wright-MilneIt's a human right, not to eat meat or animal by products. Also research suggests a healthy option. Cheaper, better for environment so why wouldn't it be added to menu's?31152018-10-15T19:17:36.6838126Norma ParkerSome of us a vegan for health reasons so there should always be an option available. 31152018-10-15T21:59:23.01338128Tanya JewellVegan options should be available everywhere but particularly in situations where there is a focus on wellbeing - ideally in those situations it would be the only option! Everyone should have access to natural plant based foods and vegans should never be left with no cruelty free options.31152018-10-15T23:06:13.9638130Dawn HoltI think this is a great idea. A vegan meal can be eaten by everyone else, there are now lots of tasty vegan meals that vegitarians & carnivores might enjoy for a change.31152018-10-15T23:25:52.0138131Kay DuffyVegan food is Economically viable, environmentally stable and no need for murder. 31152018-10-16T07:30:25.25338132Susan EstrellaThis is a great step forward. The vegan lifestyle is a huge improvement for human health, the health of our planet, and of course, for those poor innocent animals who do not want to be our property or our victims!!!31152018-10-16T08:22:34.96338134Sandra HigginsIt is everyone's right to eat food that has not cost someone else their life.31152018-10-16T08:54:49.23338136Liz GaultNo child or person should be made to eat animal products or go hungry.31152018-10-16T09:24:39.87738137Derek HaggertyVegetarian and vegan waters are on the rise and must be catered for31152018-10-16T11:56:00.36738138Bernard Burnett ElliottVeganism is the future.31152018-10-16T14:45:30.71738139Jane ScottMore care for the elderly in their own home is important to keep them there in the first place rather that them ending up in hospital - not just bed blocking but being vulnerable to hospital acquired infections putting their health at further risk .31392018-10-16T17:14:57.19338141Margaret Scade Schools should have the option for vegan food 31152018-10-16T23:30:50.1538143Tammy SchelbachProviding plant based food should be considered as necessary as providing food that does not contain allergens such as gluten, lactose, shellfish and nuts. 31152018-10-17T08:45:39.9338145Kim McAllister Animal products cause suffering, health issues and death. Put plants on the menu and health back into our diet. 31152018-10-17T10:40:54.54338146Elizabeth Burley I have been a vegetarian and vegan for 45 years because we love animals and dont need to eat them to be healthy. There are lots of delicious foods out there which doesnt involve animals suffering. 31152018-10-17T21:21:49.41338147Pamela CuthbertI can't eat animal products so when I go into hospital I will be dependent on them to supply me with vegetarian food. I don't believe in killing animals. 31152018-10-17T21:28:47.638148Rose Anne MainWe should be encouraging all our children to eat well at school to learn how to eat well throughout life, if whole swathes of children are not catered for we discriminate and end up with them eating junk to have something to satisfy their hunger. Feed all the children well.\r\n31152018-10-17T21:48:02.74338149Deborah WitterickPlant based meals should be readily available especially in hospitals where good nutrition aids recovery31152018-10-17T22:47:45.838150Jan LuitinghWhether we like it or not, the future is plant-based. It's healthy, it's guilt free, its tasty, it's cheaper, and it's good for our planet! The tide is coming! Veganism is growing fast! Have the vegan option available everywhere. It's just fair to the public!31152018-10-17T23:35:17.24338151Susan ClarksonGreat idea! Restaurants think that by offering one vegetarian dish on their menu is okay, unfortunately most are overflowing with cheese. Not only unethical but unhealthy also.31152018-10-17T23:35:54.1238152Susan ClarksonGreat idea! Restaurants think that by offering one vegetarian dish on their menu is okay, unfortunately most are overflowing with cheese. Not only unethical but unhealthy also.31152018-10-17T23:46:53.57338153Mel CrowtherVeganism is a humane choice which should be respected and catered for31152018-10-18T01:45:19.3738154Shari KaneGiven Scotlands push for a healthier nation, this move can only help in the bigger goal. This initiative would be a simple step towards ticking many boxes31152018-10-18T03:40:28.99738155Margaret FarrowGood for everyone.31152018-10-18T09:45:09.09738156Elaine Robinsonvegan options should be available everywhere in all establishments 31152018-10-18T14:05:10.22338158David PritchardVegan food is easy to prepare, nutritious, tasty and most importantly nothing was killed to make it.31152018-10-18T16:30:37.5638160Linda DevlinI'm not even a vegetarian, but support those who are and there should be a choice. People should be supported in being vegan and those meals should be nice. It's not hard, if I can do it for vegan friends, then anyone can.31152018-10-18T16:31:09.738161Linda DevlinI'm not even a vegetarian, but support those who are and there should be a choice. People should be supported in being vegan and those meals should be nice. It's not hard, if I can do it for vegan friends, then anyone can.31152018-10-18T18:00:40.33738162Curtis TackieAs prevoiusly mentioned, this is very sustainable and vegan options should be made available because of the increasing number of people becoming vegans. 31152018-10-18T19:25:11.55338164Petra PaleocrassasVegan options gives everyone a choice. Nobody should feel excluded. Furthermore, veganism needs to become mainstream. We need to take stock of what's happening to this planet.31152018-10-18T22:25:27.52738165Michael YiasemidesIt is important to offer vegan meals so that people can more easily avoid the unnecessary killing of animals for food, so that each person is more able to take steps to reduce their environmental impact (animal agriculture contributes more greenhouse gases than the entire transportation system), and so that people have more control over their health.31152018-10-19T08:02:2238168Jordie RugglesCheck out any of the following\r\nDominion \r\nEarthlings\r\nCowspiracy \r\nWhat The Health\r\nFood Choices31152018-10-19T08:34:49.24738170Anita Kofod Wonderfull news. That children Can be part of helping to STOP animal abuse and cruelty. And tat the same time help the World the Earth their own Healy too. Win win win ThankYou31152018-10-19T08:36:34.47338172Anita Kofod Wonderfull news. That children Can be part of helping to STOP animal abuse and cruelty. And tat the same time help the World the Earth their own Healy too. Win win win ThankYou31152018-10-19T08:46:38.73338173Joss Mayer Not everyone wants to eat animals or animal products. 31152018-10-19T08:50:22.7438176Clare SparkesProviding Vegan meals should be made priority. Veganism has been proven to be the best diet for this planet. Changes need to happen Now!31152018-10-19T08:57:57.2238177Ginette SNELL Plant based food is healthy, good for the planet, would eradicate third world poverty and starvation and avoids slaughtering and cruelty. People are on the path to self distruct.31152018-10-19T09:22:18.18338180Corrie MackenzieI think having healthy plant based meals available in the public sector would encourage more people to eat healthy which in return would save the nhs millions. 31152018-10-19T09:22:43.9138181Leah CouttsEveryone deserves to have vegan food available to them. No one should have to compromise their ethics or go hungry. Given the positive benefits for animals, the environment and human health, public services should be promoting plant-based foods. 31152018-10-19T09:27:53.8738182Joanne royPlease provide vegan meals 31152018-10-19T09:52:47.20338183Joy Sloan It is far better for your health and the planet to eat vegan food. 31152018-10-19T10:01:43.91338184Stella SmithIt is only right that vegan options are available - for the rights of those that choose to follow this compassionate, environmental & health-based diet...and for the rights of animals. Everyone should have the option to make the best choice for their health, the environment & the animals - especially when at work, or in hospital, or in other public institutions.31152018-10-19T10:54:22.24338187Joanne WrightI am a vegan and I would like to see more plant based options in public places. \r\nI would also like to see other people have non meat options in the hope that they will reconsider eating meat. I feel plant based diets are more healthy too. 31152018-10-19T11:23:54.64338188Emma SweetmanIndividuals who can't consume the body parts and products of other sentient beings due to their ethical and nutritional reasons should most definitely be catered for. It's more economically viable, has great potential for profit, provides healthy options and promotes inclusion within communities. Not to mention the public sector could very well see an increase in interest regarding their organisations due to this inclusion, nearly 10% of the population eats strictly plant-based or identifies with the moral standpoints of veganism. It's 2018, get on board Scotland :)31152018-10-19T11:26:09.86338189Lynn HoldenBy not allowing people to choose a vegan based diet is against their rights and equal opportunities.31152018-10-19T11:51:20.38338191John LugoGet rid of cardiovascular disease in the country. Make food sustainable and safe.31152018-10-19T11:58:57.80738192cheryl bush45% of world pollution caused by animal agriculture. Time is now to educate and give humans options as to how they can be part of the awareness of global warming. Time, is running out. 31152018-10-19T12:26:05.94338193Kirsty MelvilleA vegan meal can be eaten by everyone. It can be made healthy, nutritious, tasteful and cheaply so why not have it as an option? 31152018-10-19T12:44:31.75738194Shelley PetlanskyWatkinsEverybody should have access to healthy and planet friendly plant based food. It just makes sense. There is no way I would eat an animals flesh, eggs or secretions. 31152018-10-19T12:56:55.8638195Lisa BensonPlant based meals should always be encouraged. For health, the environment and for the animals.31152018-10-19T13:15:27.7438196Linda BrooksI would like to be able to eat the next time I am in hospital as a lactose intolerant vegetarian. 31152018-10-19T13:25:17.47338197Dalton HaverlandThere is no good argument against veganism. Childr en should be made aware of the choices they are making and how to choose the right alternative if neccessary, for example most children are unaware about the human population being almost entirely lactose intolerant, having been brought up on dairy and unfamiliar with the effects it has vs. an alternative.31152018-10-19T14:36:27.7538198Ruth elhamadPls provide vegan meals 31152018-10-19T16:00:18.64338199Shanasy BrattBy adding vegan options, you aren ot only helping people choose healthier options but also offering more humane and environmentally-sustainable choices!31152018-10-19T20:01:00.08338202Joseph SharpLike slavery exploitation of non-human animals must end.31152018-10-19T22:24:53.71338204Rachel Livapulu Plant based meals have been scientifically proven to be better for our health and the environment and undoubtedly better for those animals. Vegan food can be enjoyed by everyone31152018-10-20T01:27:49.17338207Paul Hildred Plant based foods are cheaper, healthier and better for the environment as well as being a morally justifiable option.31152018-10-20T04:57:23.90738209Adam DruettThe suffering of others shouldn't come infront of the fleeting stimulation of 1 meal. Please respect that. 31152018-10-20T08:53:31.00738210Jacinta WaddellVeganism is a cruelty free and healthy way of living. Everyone should have the right and the option to eat plant based if they choose. The world is changing and the law needs to catch up.31152018-10-20T10:45:49.1238213Jacqui SneddonSchool menus do not cater for Vegans.31152018-10-20T10:47:37.08338214Sandra GordonHealthy and better for future generations plant based diet 31152018-10-20T13:25:03.16738216Jamie McAuslinShould also be put together with nutrient density in mind as vegan does not nesseserally mean healthy by default.31152018-10-20T15:27:16.4438217Sheila McFaddenVeganism is ethical, healthy & better for environment. We're on the right side of history, and yet too many restaurants offer no vegan options or not enough.31152018-10-20T19:28:10.14338218Eric ChanHope everyone have a Healthy Plant Foods instead of Meats, as your know it is easily for digestion, it takes less 24hours from mouth to digestion. It take Over 48 hours for the meats eater.\r\nHope everybody have a Good Health.31152018-10-20T19:47:33.5238219Karen jamiesonI was overnight in Forth Valley Hospital. No vegan option. Ended up with 4 small new potatoes and boiled cabbage. 31152018-10-20T20:40:30.58738220Simone GarciaTo respect the rights of all animals is the best indication of being civilized. Giving more options for vegans is promoting compassion in society and this is EVOLUTION!31152018-10-20T23:40:21.05338221Johnathan Eldersa family member does not eat meat and has an alergy to dairy. They are not school age yet, but once they are they will require healthy option that they can eat. An option which could most likley be enjoyed by fellow pupils31152018-10-21T07:37:19.6938222Rachel MitchellLack of vegan or even vegetarian options during my school years left me severely malnourished and underweight. I had to starve myself over lunch times and because I depended on free school meals and came from an impoverished background, I suffered greatly. Lack of adequate and healthy nutrition from my schools has affected me my whole life.31152018-10-21T08:29:38.8738223Gwen NelsonIf people can have special diets provided because of religious beliefs then they should also be provided because of ethical beliefs.31152018-10-21T09:55:43.7438224Jaine Hollis-watsonAs a teacher, it upsets me that any children who are or may want to go vegan are not able to get a school meal 31152018-10-21T11:21:07.06338225Lennie Philip I do hope this petition is successful. In this day and age it's disgraceful that vegans are not catered for. W31152018-10-21T12:01:53.41338226Carina Sutherland The canteen at the University I work in are doing OK., but still some days there is nothing healthy to eat. 31152018-10-21T13:34:00.47338227Fiona FletcherBetter for animals, people and the world.31152018-10-21T17:03:03.55738229Ciara KielyAs a doctor working for the NHS, I frequently hear from vegetarian and vegan patients that their options are limited, uninteresting and often repetitive - and have heard of vegan patients being offered plain potatoes or toast as a meal. In addition, I find the options for vegan and vegetarian staff are no better. The evidence is abundant that a plant based diet offers numerous health benefits (as well as having a major positive environmental impact) - therefore we owe it to members of the public, including patients who are in need of good nutrition during a period of illness, to offer adequate plant based options. 31152018-10-21T19:43:07.7538231Jacqueline CummingGood petition31152018-10-21T22:24:14.55338233Barry KyddIf you really do want to promote healthy eating, then numerous Vegan options are the only way. 31152018-10-22T22:27:59.85338235CAROLINE LEANot everyone wants to fill their stomach with dead flesh.31152018-10-22T23:09:38.87738236Scott Waterson Providing a vegan option will create a better learning environment for young people who choose a vegan life style and will encourage other to reduce meat consumption. 31152018-10-23T08:28:15.71738237Valerie ThomsonChoice is crucial31152018-10-23T15:07:53.51738240Therese StertenI think it is extremely important to allow people the choice of an ethically and environmentally sound meal. 31152018-10-23T17:04:33.27338241Laura ChepnerPlant based menus are better for people, the environment and animals. It is an absolute no brainer.31152018-10-23T17:11:53.39738242Lisa HarrickI feel excluded from doing what others take for granted like eating out because I don't eat meat or dairy. At a time when caring for the environment and other species that share our planet is paramount, it really is time veganism was normalised and catered for in mainstream society. 31152018-10-23T20:55:35.4438243Julie DawesI have a few friends who are vegan and they very often struggle to find something to eat from a menu or from a buffet or sandwich style lunch. 31152018-10-24T08:38:35.76738245Heather GowansTake animals off the menu. At least give us an option using no animal products please. 31152018-10-24T12:20:46.80738246Laura MorganBetter for everyone and everything in every aspect. 31152018-10-24T12:21:39.57338247Matthew HarbFor decency 31152018-10-24T12:26:15.87738248Mariana de OliveiraPlant based foods is a right. For our health, for the animals and for the future of our planet31152018-10-24T12:27:41.8138250Jasmin Gagliardi I sure do vegan options animal and earth and human friendly all for positive change in this universe we really need it! 31152018-10-24T12:28:36.76338251Amber Collins Being vegan is the healthiest way to live. Also causes the least harm to the planet and the animals. 31152018-10-24T12:31:48.9238253Leanne ThomasFantastic!!! Do it for health. Do it for the animals. Do it for the environment. Do it for a better future for all. 31152018-10-24T12:54:30.32738257Suzanne Stecka I agree with this petition 31152018-10-24T13:01:38.38338259Lori SchefferWe need to help save the planet and the animals. Reduction in animal consumption should be the way of the future. Not only to help with climate change and destruction of the Earth but has many health benefits. A more compassionate planet and all lives matter is important to many.31152018-10-24T13:02:23.8538260Olimpia StoroniThe environmental problems we are facing need to be solved also by the change of our diet habits. It's important that the government gives signals of this changement by supporting plant based diets.31152018-10-24T13:02:27.1838261Clare sewellWe all habe rights to eT what we choose 31152018-10-24T13:02:39.4938262Lauren Crowe Having a vegan option is an ethical and healthy choice. A choice that everyone should be available to31152018-10-24T13:05:30.75738263Karim El-SamraEveryone should have an option in line with health, sustainability and compassion. Getting death disease and destruction off our plates is a no brainer. 31152018-10-24T13:06:40.39738264Laura RileyI absolutely wholeheartedly agree with this. School is a wonderful place to start educating on the health benefits of a plant based diet. It is better for health, the environment and the animals. Vegan choices should always be available 31152018-10-24T13:08:41.1538265Martin Ojedait's necessary to impulse a change in society for the wellness of all live on Earth.31152018-10-24T13:09:08.63338266Julia HarpurThis is extremely timely after the IPCC report, we need systemic change, and encouraging reduction of meat, dairy, egg consumption is a step in the right direction.31152018-10-24T13:09:39.7138267Katie whiteThis would be a great step in the right direction and also a statement of being with the times. Which is a good look for any organisation or individual 31152018-10-24T13:27:31.30738269Jesse GerhardWill benefit millions of animals, children, and the planet31152018-10-24T13:35:00.14738270Shweta Govilaturn vegan 31152018-10-24T13:35:21.60738271Jan WebbA win win for all, healthier people, environmentally sustainable and cruelty free. The world needs to change! 31152018-10-24T13:39:33.66338272Joyce LambieI don't see why vegan meals can't be available everywhere31152018-10-24T13:39:51.6338273Laura Middlehurst Providing the option to eat a plant based diet to those in your facilities, allows people who chose to eat humanely the ability to feed themselves according to their beliefs. Thank you for allowing us our freedom to chose. You are leading in the world. Congratulations for opening this discussion 31152018-10-24T13:40:41.43338274Anuragini Hulk Shiddat This is the best step to save this planet. To end Animal Oppression. #FutureIsDefinitelyVEGAN 31152018-10-24T13:44:11.50738275Cambria MartinEnd the suffering! Create a better future. 31152018-10-24T13:44:39.85738276Morgan Lee As a vegan I believe that the more vegan options available to people will create more of an awareness. An awareness to how incredible vegan food is, and that great, wholesome yummy food can be eaten with out any animals being harmed. 31152018-10-24T13:51:56.13338277Rajan Vohra.31152018-10-24T13:52:47.23338278JOELLE SALAMEThank you Scotland for taking the lead in this matter I hope all Europe will follow your example. 31152018-10-24T13:55:22.10738279Michael SmithWe live in a time where we do not need to eat animals to thrive and be healthy. Hospitals not having vegan options is complete irony! 31152018-10-24T13:57:23.46738280Grace KingThis is so important and if it happens Scotland will be leading the way in the world, towards compassion.31152018-10-24T14:00:11.5738281Priscilla C Miller I agree with all the comments and have nothing more to add \r\n31152018-10-24T14:03:50.63338282Rajan VohraPlease provide plant-based options on every public sector menu every day for our health, the environment and animals.31152018-10-24T14:35:50.0338286Pema sangmoHope and pray for happiness and equality for all form of living being from my deepest heart.31152018-10-24T14:39:20.5338287Simon PrueHealthier, more environmentally friendly but most important- compassionate31152018-10-24T14:43:12.3838288David MilneThis is a fantastic cause! Please make it a reality! 31152018-10-24T14:48:33.89738289Cherrell OllierouThe best thing everyone can do for the animals and the planet is to GO VEGAN. We only have 12 years to reverse climate change, going vegan is the best decision you can make to help save the planet.31152018-10-24T14:51:58.61738290Joanna ZelayaThe U.S. government is killing us by making us eat animals protein and processed foods. We are sick and obese in this country. I support this initiative from Scottland as it is immoral to feed citizens for greed even when that very food is killing its citizens. I urge you to protect the Scottish citizens by incorporating plant based foods. This is a Great first step! 31152018-10-24T14:53:53.53338292Kathryn PottsMeat is listed as a type 1 carcinogen by the World Health Organisation, and dairy is a food designed for young calves. \r\nVegan options need to be available everywhere. 31152018-10-24T15:16:14.9838293Raleigh koritzAll living and breathing animals Aren't food\r\n31152018-10-24T15:19:56.64738294Paula AtherillThis is so important. Many times people are unable to get a meal in public establishments because of the lack of knowledge and options for vegans. Lots of young people are vegan, it's extremely important for schools.\r\nVegan diet is proven to be more healthy, this will have a huge impact on health levels in general and help to reduce many conditions, particularly cholesterol levels, heart disease and diabetes.31152018-10-24T15:35:46.52338295Mike IzonIn a western society where obesity is reaching epidemic proportions, where animal products have been shown to have a direct effect on diseases like cancer, we should give a plant based diet option to all.31152018-10-24T15:52:36.1738298Mandi Payne Human Rights Act 2010 recognises vegans rights ! Therefore by not giving a meal choice you are denying them their human rights !!!31152018-10-24T15:53:41.1738299Emily JonesBetter for your health. Better for the planet. Better for the animals. Sustainable, typically cheaper than non-vegan options and inclusive!31152018-10-24T16:03:11.69738302Brian CheesemanPlease be the first country to institute this policy. It is the healthiest and most environmentaly responsible diet. I would encourage my own city government to do the same if it works there. Thank you people of Scotland for putting this measure up for debate.31152018-10-24T16:05:25.29738303Mary UrenIn light of recent predictions on climate change and the benefits of a vegan diet, this would be a tremendous step in the right direction, showing the way for the rest of the UK and the world.31152018-10-24T16:12:56.3338304dianne hendryA family member can not eat in school as they refuse to eat innocent animals or drink their milk 31152018-10-24T16:21:11.65338305david hendrysave the innocent animals 31152018-10-24T16:21:23.7738306Debrah McCabeThe entire world needs to change the way we eat to protect the environment. Good plan Scotland.31152018-10-24T16:26:41.42738307Summer Weiler A Vegan diet is much healthier for our children. The way we use animals must stop. For the sake of our planet, our health and of course the innocent beings, that are tourtured in factory farms for the sake of our taste buds. We are the generation to stop this insanity and protect our planet. Lets be on the right side of history.31152018-10-24T16:47:08.47738309Becky pierceIf we can live a life without causing cruelty to others then why would we not31152018-10-24T17:02:53.56738312Peggy MerrimanThis is an important initiative that should be implemented world wide for our health, the planet and of course the animals.31152018-10-24T17:04:08.27338313Alice MelissaChildren should have access to healthy, cruelty-free food. Animal products are known to be the cause of our top 14 chronic killer diseases and processed meats are Class 1 carcinogens, so the only responsible thing to do here is to provide healthy plant-based vegan options at schools. We are facing mass extinction due to animal agriculture and the only way to save our planet is to all become plant-based vegans. It's a no brainer! Can't believe that our education system has taken this long to wake-up...they are supposed to be educating our children yet they don't have a clue about nutrition, climate change and ethics towards animals. 31152018-10-24T17:06:24.3338314Shell pearceMore vegan food should be available in all public sector restaurants and takeaways 31152018-10-24T17:10:18.8838315Sara Jane SimkinPlant based diets have been shown through extensive research and study to be the healthiest and most ethical diet for humans and our environment. Plant based diets should already be available since we as humans, are herbivorous by nature and thrive better on plant based diets. Plants heal and are nutrient dense. Meat and processed products harm our bodies, the animals we uneccessarily slaughter and the environmental impact it has is devastating. 31152018-10-24T17:28:23.63738318Terry D ScottPlease consider this it is for the health and benefit for all, send a message to the world, be a leader and not a follower, Leave animals off your plate, stop killing animals for our greed and taste buds, it is not sustainable, thank you for taking the time to sincerely consider this.31152018-10-24T17:29:50.99738320pria orthHow amazing SCOTLAND !!\r\nTo consider paving the way for the future of our planet earth. \r\nI wish I lived in a country with such fore thought for our world. 31152018-10-24T17:31:57.93338321milana orthHow amazing SCOTLAND !!\r\nTo consider paving the way for the future of our planet earth. \r\nI wish I lived in a country with such fore thought for our world. Your impact on climate change shows the rest of us what is possible \r\nSo much respect for your country31152018-10-24T17:35:46.96738322Pablo fueguelChildren should have the choice to eat plant based or animal based diets31152018-10-24T17:37:38.2838323David McshaneI'm not vegan myself but I do have dietary requirements due to ill health and some. Of the best alternatives to. Meals I have found to be vegan and I would opt for those plant based options if they were available 31152018-10-24T17:38:24.1838324Conner HughesThis will be good for the health of the Scottish people, an animals corpse isnt food or healthy to eat.31152018-10-24T18:18:15.5838327Alison SimoneAwesome!! It needs to become a part of everyday life in order for it to become the norm!!31152018-10-24T18:27:58.95738329Caroline laitMore humane and healthier options needed now!31152018-10-24T18:37:17.90738330felipe oliva girardiHealthiest food should be available!31152018-10-24T18:45:20.1838331Emily BrauerEveryone should have a choice to eat vegan no matter what the circumstance 31152018-10-24T18:45:32.8538332Rebecca SarahPlantbased food is healthier and better for our planet. People should not be forced to eat innocent beings, let us have a choice.31152018-10-24T18:45:33.4338333Daryl HarperI agree that there should be vegan options available for any child or person that requires these. Hey should have a mandatory vegan option for all the children to select if they wish. 31152018-10-24T19:00:21.07338334Danielle Miller I really wish the United States would lead the March on this but I don't believe we are so it would be great if your country could I think it would definitely make you a more attractive vacation destination for vegans around the world31152018-10-24T19:04:53.2638335Lynette AllsopLead the way for the British Government to follow 31152018-10-24T19:29:12.638337Cathy Kelly Vegan meals should be available for children 31152018-10-24T19:48:51.538338Stephanie caruthersIt's time to give kids fresh good not processed foods that cause harm to a kids health and adults. You are seeing a standard for many others countries. 31152018-10-24T19:52:07.02738339Billy HutchinsonGoing vegan saves human lives, non-human lives, and the planet itself. Eating animals is neither necessary, natural or normal. Science and facts support this.31152018-10-24T20:04:57.88738340Valerie GreenVegan food can be enjoyed by all. It's scientifically proven to be healthier. More importantly it saves the animals.31152018-10-24T20:37:13.65738341Nicole Lindsay It is the best thing for the health of people and the planet. 31152018-10-24T20:40:59.83738342Kelsey GreenThis is awesome! Thank you so much to whoever started this petition! 31152018-10-24T20:41:34.88338343Victoria WadhamsThis is essential opportunity that must be seized. It is one of the most positive ones you can make for the health and wellbeing of both planet and people.31152018-10-24T20:41:50.88338344Frances Gudgethis requires common sense well as compassion31152018-10-24T20:59:20.03738347Jasmine dickersonPlease make this important change and step in the right direction of ending animal exploitation! As a disabled vegan hospital meals are soo important and soo often I'm unable to eat a proper meal in hospital! 31152018-10-24T21:06:51.56738348Katherine LawesVegan option is a,fantastic option because it won't just be great for vegans but also dairy and egg allergies and also a wonderful option for kids who do not want to eat any meat etc for a meal at school.31152018-10-24T21:11:06.25738349Judy StathopoulosWe must become better versions of ourselves!\r\nStop the slaughter of our fellow earthlings. 31152018-10-24T21:29:01.45738350Sharon HunterI feel.this should have been made law along time ago.31152018-10-24T21:35:10.6538351David j MacDonald The SNP are a progressive party lets show the world we are .31152018-10-24T21:51:57.83338352Robyn HughesNa31152018-10-24T21:59:25.46738353Susan Atkins More and more people want to choose a healthier cruelty free option which is also helping the planet 31152018-10-24T22:05:42.72738354Kelly DonaldsonNumerous studies have shown that plant-based food is healthier than those containing animal products. But regardless of this, EVERYBODY can eat a vegan meal - so why not just put it on the menu, so nobody is discriminated against?31152018-10-24T22:07:48.05338355Mike ChangPlant based and vegan meals are a pathway to a healthier, and more sustainable way of life, and most importantly, cruelty free. Vegan options FTW.31152018-10-24T22:09:14.18738356Owen Williams Scotland I believe in you .31152018-10-24T22:12:46.05738357Angelika PiechaczekIt is healthier to not to eat meat or to drink milk. The animals suffer in the industries, we need a kinder world.31152018-10-24T22:16:55.01338359Daina SilcoxWish this is worldwide!!! GO VEGAN 31152018-10-24T22:17:53.7538360Emilia HaraI hope there will be stop of slaughtering of all those innocent animals one day. 31152018-10-24T22:21:56.90738361James HootPlease watch a film called Forks Over Knives. The fact that we are serving steak, bacon, and eggs to heart disease patients is irresponsible to say the least, if not reprehensible and sick behavior. The ways that we have let the animal agriculture industry slither into every part of the health sector are reprehensible. Please: do the right thing and not only make plant-based meals an option but make them mandatory. You will see happier, healthier patients and insurance companies that spend less money trying to heal the sick. \r\n\r\nAfter you watch Forks Over Knives, please watch Cowspiracy and Dominion. After that, use your voice to influence positive change in the world and fight for the change that we so desperately need right now. 31152018-10-24T22:42:05.65338363Laris Cooper Yes to vegan meal options on every public sector menu! 31152018-10-24T22:48:07.23738364Kelly Ann MeacockThis would be amazing.A vegan way of life is so much better for us, for the environment and of course for our beautiful animals.No animals should be killed for the sake of our tastebuds31152018-10-24T22:50:27.6338365ALISON SuggittYou can change the UK with this positive action. 31152018-10-24T22:52:48.21738366Thomas DobsonVeganism is better for everyone - our health, the environment and those poor animals imprisoned in those death chambers we call slaughterhouses!31152018-10-24T23:02:07.12338367Michelle Goodburn Please make vegan options available, not only for current vegans but to encourage healthier, cruelty-free living.31152018-10-24T23:06:50.47338368Tina SinnPlease make this possible so other countries like Germany will follow the great example!31152018-10-24T23:26:42.8338369Jan Birrell-Bathgate Vegan diet is a healthier option for humans and the environment as well as avoiding exploitation and unnecessary suffering of other species 31152018-10-24T23:37:02.41738371Leonie Elizabeth GoodeOne step closer.... 31152018-10-24T23:51:38.99738374Laurie HoopingarnerPlant based meals are so much healthier for the individual, the animals and the bigger picture - the whole world!!!31152018-10-24T23:58:17.38738376Meghan DizonIt is only fair for their to be a vegan option at all major institutions. People should have a choice to not eat animal products and still have a delicious meal. Aside from basic human rights, it will also help our environment to support a plant-based diet.31152018-10-25T00:02:45.12338377Mich Schepers Why would you not31152018-10-25T01:08:11.9738380Angela AlexzaA whole food plant based diet is the healthiest diet!31152018-10-25T01:32:06.1238381Evie KayThis is the way forward, for the planet, animals and our health.\r\n31152018-10-25T02:12:55.06338382kris robertsHopefully this goes through, so other countries, including my own can follow the lead! 31152018-10-25T02:50:25.17338383Carol MerrickIt is ridiculous that in this year, this is not a option31152018-10-25T04:55:31.56338384Taylor TheggieHealthy vegan plant based foods should be available to everyone. The environmental impact of animal agriculture is devastating our planet. 31152018-10-25T05:47:01.84338386Steven ManuelIt's better for our health, for the environment, and most importantly for the animals.31152018-10-25T06:06:18.35738387Amber Corney All countries should do this!! 31152018-10-25T07:13:42.75338388Laura Antonakakis A growing number of people are wanting healthy ethical food. Not everyone wants to eat dead animals. 31152018-10-25T08:16:56.18738389Beverly WardWonderful idea31152018-10-25T08:21:01.3138390Nicola KettlewellPlant based is healthy for people the planet and it doesn't harm animals. 31152018-10-25T08:56:58.5738392Jay LuoA plant-based diet is the only diet proven to reverse and prevent our leading killers. \r\nUnless we want people to be sick, there's no reason to not include healthy and cruelty-free options.31152018-10-25T09:43:34.68738393James ThompsonFor sentient souls, for health, for the planet. #vegan \r\nThere is zero refuting the fact that a vegan diet is far healthier than one with acidic corpses and animal products. Be the first country to adapt to what will inevitably the norm in our future. 31152018-10-25T10:46:02.12738395Paul Ross DenningScotland could be a leader in terms of providing exploitation-free, environmentally-friendly, and healthful meals at the institutional level and can only make our country stronger. I absolutely support the action proposed by this petition!31152018-10-25T12:22:16.08738397Therese McGheeChildren absorb information from an early age and learning some basic first aid is a knowledge they can carry with them for life. 31292018-10-25T12:34:24.6538398Mia wignallAnimals need a voice, vegans are thier voice!!!31152018-10-25T13:45:19.64338399Amelie Crawshaw We live in a world in which over 150 billions animals die annually, and it needs to stop. Each person counts to saving 100's of life's and people should have the right to choose so, with this petition we can be some of the first to make this happen across the entirety of Scotland. Not only liberating animals from suffering but vegans, vegetarians and those of ethnic groups that choose to avoide animal products. Thank you. I am personally forever grateful. 31152018-10-25T13:49:35.99338400Taylor RenfreeThis will not only benefit the lives of millions of children, by helping them live a healthier lifestyle, and not the slaughter of animals. But it will also help save this earth. This is the best thing you can do. 31152018-10-25T13:58:49.31738401Amelie Crawshaw We live in a world in which over 150 billion animals die annually due to the meat industry and it needs to stop. Each person counts to saving 100's of life's and people should have the right to choose so. This petition allows us that right and I am personally forever grateful. Thank you.31152018-10-25T14:25:28.12338403Anna BurnettVegan options should be available to everyone where food is available, especially in schools so a healthier more environmentally friendly, cruelty free option is available to all.31152018-10-25T15:53:53.2438405Chloe KingdomLeading a vegan lifestyle and eating a plant-based diet is the single solution that we need to implement on an institutional level in all countries in order to combat a myriad of critical issues that our world faces today. Of these, eating a plant-based diet can directly and radically impact on the number of animal murders and instances of animal exploitation and brutality experienced in the animal agriculture and aquaculture industries. By choosing to provide children with the opportunity to eat plant-based meals, children are taught that violence is not an ideal that this society will strive for any longer, and that there are options available which enable us to opt of perpetuating it. Furthermore, we have a duty to provide children with the most nutritous foods that are derived from the healthiest sources. Plant-based foods are the best source of food and are devoid of trans fats, saturated fats, cholestrol and animal protein all of which are clinically proven to cause a number of chronic medical conditions, such as diabetes, heart problems, osteoporosis, obseity and cancer. Furthermore, a plant-based diet is the single best solution to solving issues that are currently contributing towards our climate crisis. We must provide children with the opportunities and knowledge to save lives, save the planet and care for their health. Providing them with plant-based meal options at school allows them to do this. 31152018-10-25T16:08:50.00738406natalie mccallBrilliant idea!31292018-10-25T16:20:05.22738407Jackie Murray So glad to hear this, about time 31152018-10-25T16:37:36.05738408Jennifer TrelkaIt's the right thing to do for our health, the environment, the animal's, and the planet.31152018-10-25T16:58:14.77738409Anna MarkeyThis would be great for the animals, human health, and the environment.31152018-10-25T18:49:52.3438411Kathryn JonesWe need a huge reduction globally of animal agriculture as it is the biggest cause of climate change. Providing a healthy, tasty vegan option in schools would be a fantastic positive step. Education is key, kids need to be told about the damaging impact of meat, dairy and egg consumption on the planet.31152018-10-25T19:55:58.41338412Sophia AllenAbsolutely phenomenal idea! Should be mandatory everywhere. 31152018-10-25T20:07:18.91338413Shiana Noorani-Smithas a Scottish vegan\r\nyes!!!! 31152018-10-25T20:10:14.05338414Razan KarimVegan is the future. Be on the right side of history.31152018-10-25T21:00:59.37338415Denise Cruickshanks Definitely 31292018-10-25T22:38:4538417Brittany furstDo it!!!! This is an amazing chance to make a major positive change in green house gas emissions.31152018-10-25T22:42:53.07338418Gavin PennycookWe need to ensure there's no loophole which allows the 'vegan option' to be just a baked potato filling. \r\nI don't mind baked potato and baked beans once in a while, but it's all too often the only vegan option on menus!31152018-10-25T23:12:38.45338419Theresa BurgerRegardless of whether the whole poplulation agrees with plant based food, there should be the option for people who require this diet just as there is an option for people with other dietary requirements. Furthermore plant based foods are scientifically proven to best support a healthy disease free life.31152018-10-25T23:13:18.338420Caroline HarrisonAs a teacher, I believe that we must make improvements to school meals by including plant based options on menus in order to improve the health of our children, to become a sustainable nation and to align our moral values with our actions.31152018-10-26T00:07:42.50738421Monique DobellHope Australia follows suit31152018-10-26T00:11:57.00738422Gloria KirkpatrickSlowly transforming the world for better health and love of animals.31152018-10-26T00:13:12.26338423Jessie Reiff Choose compassion. This would be a major step in introducing children to not only healthier food but also an eco friendly, non violent lifestyle 31152018-10-26T00:29:59.77738426Bailey BayneA vegan diet is tremendous for human health, the health of the planet and the health of our planets animals. 31152018-10-26T01:26:35.4938428Emily EdwardsPlant-based foods are the best for the planet and human health.31152018-10-26T03:48:30.3738430Nitin JainEveryone has right to be compassionate cruelty free and healthy31152018-10-26T04:56:11.6938431Haley DimeckIt is irrisponsible to not provide plant based meals, for health and environmental reasons. 31152018-10-26T05:26:43.81738433Lorena LanitiGoing plant based has not only proven to be healthier and better for humans to eat but it helps reduce our carbon footprint. Eating meat and dairy is affecting deforestation, ocean dead zones and pollution. Everything we need, protein, calcium, omega 3's, vitamins, minerals etc ALL come from plants. And of course we can't forget one of the most important reasons to eat plant based.. the animals. Billions of animals are being suffocated, abused, starved, mistreated and killed just for our taste bud and convenience. Plant based is healthier, and morally the right choice. 31152018-10-26T06:33:34.62738436Louisa MarshallThis is an amazing opportunity to teach our children more about health and humanity. 31152018-10-26T06:38:08.46738437MARIA JOSELIN TEJERA MARREROLike Shanasy Bratt wrote By adding vegan options, you aren ot only helping people choose healthier options but also offering more humane and environmentally-sustainable choices!31152018-10-26T06:42:40.65738438Rosie VanI hope that the next time I am in hospital, there is a plant based option so I dont have to drink or eat dead animals31152018-10-26T06:43:39.6638439Tracey HillThe world should follow in your footsteps - well done !!!31152018-10-26T06:54:53.2738440William WorthyEveryone deserves to have access to a cruelty free meal. 31152018-10-26T08:19:18.39338441Eileen IsaaI think humans who are in prison, hospital or school have the right to continue their eating habits.31152018-10-26T08:32:35.39338442Karoline MiddelI think at least there should be an option for vegans available everywhere. Veganism is proven to be better for your health, for the environment and for the animals, veganism is the future:)31152018-10-26T08:38:44.35338444Marko BeckerThe absolutely right and necessary thing to do if you care of future generations and a healthier society.31152018-10-26T09:02:54.66338445Claire WatsonAlthough strictly, I am not vegan, I have a lot of allergies including dairy, eggs, nuts and shellfish and whilst at school, there was not a lot of options for me for school lunches. If vegan meals were an option it would make it much easier as then the only thing I would have to worry about would be my nut allergy. Now when eating out, I always go for the vegan option as it makes eating out so much easier. 31152018-10-26T09:24:27.43738447william donnellyi strongly support school children being given the opportunity o save a life.31292018-10-26T09:34:36.15738448Sara McBrideBrilliant, very sensible petition! For our health, the environment and animals. 31152018-10-26T10:15:57.2838451Catriona StevensonAnd please can that option not just be a baked potato with baked beans! Plant based food can be so exciting and diverse, and should be represented as such.31152018-10-26T10:56:12.1738456Lisa HellerVegans should have available options31152018-10-26T11:03:05.60738457Cynthia CamachoEveryone deserves the option of compassion 31152018-10-26T11:06:10.38338459Andy ClarkWith more people switching to a plant-based diet & as veganism is a protected philosophical belief, healthy, nutritious plant-based options on all public sector menus in Scotland and the rest of the UK is now the logical step forward. As with the smoking ban, minimum alcohol pricing and other legislation it would be great to see the Scottish Government take the lead on this issue. We are at the start of the curve. The revolution will be veganised.31152018-10-26T11:25:09.9438460Stephen Mcbride Better for animals. And better for us31152018-10-26T11:57:05.638462Paul Reza Yes. a family member is vegan. Its the future 31152018-10-26T12:09:00.97738463Susie HearderSo important for human health, the health of the planet and also to reduce cruelty and violence.31152018-10-26T12:11:20.6838464Susie HearderSo important for human health, the health of our planet and to reduce cruelty and violence31152018-10-26T12:16:48.81338465Emily HerringI certainly agree with the action called for in this petition. The institution of vegan meals within all public domains will not be of harm to anyone, but rather, of great help to all in ways from health to small business growth. 31152018-10-26T13:47:48.32738466Ben Lyman Considering the latest IPCC report and considering that animal products cause many times more carbon emissions than plant based food, I'd say that this is a moral obligation for the sake of the entire planet. 31152018-10-26T14:06:07.6438467Christoph BradePlease follow the lead of Portugal. I've just spend some time in Lisbon and the law over there has transformed the food scene. The majority of restaurants are offering tasty vegan options now, too. Because it became normal in the public sector.\r\n31152018-10-26T14:35:09.17738470Marta navarroPlease please please feed your children in a proper way, to avoid obesity, diabetes and other types of cancer ! 31152018-10-26T14:37:22.84738471Steve MelimBringing children up to eat more plant based in this day and age is the only way forward.\r\nThe future is vegan and people need to wake up!31152018-10-26T15:35:44.52738474Brian BarnesProviding a plant based option is good for all as vegetarians, meat eaters and vegans can all choose it. Helping sustainability, health and animal welfare.31152018-10-26T15:37:16.57338475Michael PetriA vegan diet is a compassionate, healthy and environmentally responsible dietary choice. The government should ensure those who wish to follow this diet are supported. Veganism is on the rise globally and even many non vegans choose animal free meals for some of their meals. Options should always be available. If this were an issue of religion there would be no need for debate, options would be provided. That approach should also apply for ethical stances.31152018-10-26T17:12:05.85338478David CarterFor the health for the planet and for the animals vegan options need to be available in all public sectors!! 31152018-10-26T17:27:37.238479Natalie Swan Encourages a more plant based diet with health benefits and reduces environmental damage caused by animal farming . 31152018-10-26T18:19:31.9938480Danielle LiFor the health of our children, please make this possible!31152018-10-26T19:23:56.10738482Lisa BarrettAbout time. 31152018-10-26T19:37:48.98338485Alan GordonThis should be annual at all school ages as many health professionals and others needing to do CPR have to update and refresh annually.31292018-10-26T20:14:39.6338486Daniela Middleton Plant based food spares animals the suffering and in-humane killing. It is a healthier way of living and one has a smaller footprint on earth. 31152018-10-26T20:31:07.4638488Michelle HeathLet this be a pillar for all countries to follow suit. 31152018-10-26T20:52:59.15338489Agustina lisaHaving a vegan option in every institution es a huge step foward for everyone, not only is it extremely helpful for us vegans but anyone can enjoy a vegan meal. Not only that but its usually cheaper, healthier, better for the enviroment and over all, it is whats right for the animals, the planet and ourselves. 31152018-10-26T21:00:41.18338490Tracey WrightAt a time when we should be encouraging children and to come together and support each other to reduce mental health issue's and social isolation.30902018-10-26T21:30:40.06338491Mr William WhiteWe need to evolve and that includes evolving how we eat.31152018-10-26T22:29:31.5138494Katie CruikshankA vegan diet is healthier, more sustainable and compassionate towards animals. It is time to respect those who are trying to do and be better by providing meal options that are in line with these positive values.31152018-10-26T22:56:20.12338495Fiona McAuliffeThe destruction of Earths resources and the exploitation of sentient beings should not be mandatory. Humans should have the right and opportunity to live a compassionate life a leave less of a footprint on the earth.31152018-10-26T23:04:29.5638497Sarah BrownA whole foods plant based diet reduces risk of Cardiovascular diseases and also has the smallest ecological footprint on the environment 31152018-10-26T23:59:20.94338500Robert Braine Vegan options need to be mandatory in the 21st century if we are to call ourselves a civilised society. Forcing vegans to eat dead animals or animal products is nothing short of barbaric.31152018-10-27T00:07:57.7938501Nicole PatelIt is healthier for people, kinder to animals, and saves the environment all at the same time.31152018-10-27T00:16:37.94338502Katiana SchreiberEVERYONE DESERVES TO EAT HOW THEY WANT31152018-10-27T01:16:14.56738504Claudine DeGiacomo Yes please provide Vegan options everywhere31152018-10-27T02:18:43.86738506Tyrel CowlesI wish that the U.S. would have the right sense of mind to attempt to mandate vegan options in our schools, hospitals, and other institutions. So much cruelty is on the plates of people here in the states. I hope that we can make a small difference we this petition to make progress in changing the mindset on what "food" should normalized. Obviously real food that isn't enslaved or bound to suffering. 31152018-10-27T02:45:31.6438508Hannah pidgeonMeat is murder 31152018-10-27T03:05:19.538509James CottonPlease watch the film Earthlings and tell me if you think our kids would witness any compassion from where their current meals come from. This is your chance to be responsible and set a global example by offering healthy alternatives as proper health and safety. Not just for the students but for the better of humanity and our overall environment.31152018-10-27T03:33:31.80338511Rachel HambrookAllow people who do not consent to animal cruelty the opportunity to have vegan meals provided31152018-10-27T07:54:30.71338514Charlotte linnet This could be a major break through and other countries could follow 31152018-10-27T11:59:36.57738516Kirsteen Watsonbrilliant idea and should be compulsory, there are some kids leaving school with no qualificatins or certificates. but to leave with a cert in knowing how to save a life would be fantastic31292018-10-27T16:44:00.75338518Mary FinelliPromoting plant-derived food in place of animal products is a great public service as it is better for human health, animal well-being, and the environment. 31152018-10-28T00:27:41.4638520Charlie Fitzgerald No one should be forced to go against their beliefs, or go hungry especially as veganism stems from a consciousness of welfare and environemental issues.. 31152018-10-28T07:18:52.0738521Susan Fabrican Everyone will feel better then act better after a vegan meal. 31152018-10-28T07:56:21.7638522Sharon LlewellynWholesome nutritious meals without harming animals should be the norm in a civilised society. They should be provided for those who do not want to be complicit in unnecessary abuse and violence. The world should be vegan. 31152018-10-28T08:00:43.44738523Sharon LlewellynA civilised society should be delivering wholesome nutritious food that is violence free as the norm. A civilised society would have this without special petitions asking for it. 31152018-10-28T13:59:38.46738524Lyn Sullivan Veganism is the only way to save our planet, end cruelty and abuse to animals and improve our health. However, vegans are not fairly represented when it comes to food choices and this simply has to change 31152018-10-28T14:33:18.57738525Jacquie Clapperton It's difficult enough to get vegetarian options! I'm sick of microwaved mushroom risotto. 31152018-10-28T16:45:00.56738526Annette RushThis needs to be an option. Vegetarian options can still contain milk and eggs and many have allergies to this aside from the ethical reasons. 31152018-10-28T17:04:32.64738527Sue ShawGoing vegan is the single largest change anyone can make towards cutting climate change and something that should be encouraged as part of a healthy diet. It's a small step to make the current vegetarian meals on offer vegan. A small step that saves the lives of countless animals.31152018-10-28T17:57:19.57338528Adele LundieThis is a great idea! It should be compulsory in every school in the country. 31292018-10-28T20:31:03.65738529Louisa VlahosVegan meals are healthier, environmentally friendlier and cruelty free31152018-10-28T21:51:46.75738530Jacine Clark I am a volunteer with St Andrews First Aid and I teach CPR to young people. I believe we can save many lives by including basic first aid in all primary school curriculum.31292018-10-28T22:58:10.1438531Lisa vaughYes everyone deserves to get a healthy non meat diet31152018-10-29T08:07:30.08738535Audrey JamiesonNo animal should die to provide food31152018-10-29T09:40:05.9438536Michelle AllenVeganism is a healthy, cruelty free diet that is gaining in popularity. Vegan foods should be available to everyone who chooses the vegan lifestyle.31152018-10-29T09:52:41.0238537Christine SommervilleChildren should not be deprived of life saving education and skills which are crucial to their life-long learning. We need to create a nation of lifesavers who have the confidence and ability to actually step forward and do something to help others. 31292018-10-29T10:09:48.80338538Ezmie McCutcheon Mosquito Devices violate the human rights of children and young people. They are inhumane and must be banned. 30902018-10-29T10:31:05.91738539Catherine HardwickThis is such a good idea for so many reasons.31152018-10-29T13:09:18.53738540Patricia Fumagalliit is high time the whole world offer a vegan option. sorry, vegan should be the only one. united nations already stated we will need to switch to a plant based diet for sustainability issues. we vegans are just speeding up the process31152018-10-29T19:21:18.438543Jane McManus More people are making vegan choices therefore must be given this option. 31152018-10-30T05:27:11.8338544Karrie Ann HarveyPeople feel better after eating a plant based meal31152018-10-30T08:22:14.45338545Margaret MacKenzieI think this is a great idea, more so as there are so many young carers these days looking after parents with illnesses.31292018-10-30T08:44:23.06738546Duncan Struan RobertsonExcellent idea, 1st Aid should be second nature to everyone as early in life as possible!31292018-10-30T08:45:00.8338547Maxine KnaggEveryone should have the choice to eat without cruelty.31152018-10-30T09:16:16.3538549Linda HarkessSt. Andrews First Aid are a very important learning community for schools and adults, training can be a life saver31292018-10-30T09:23:16.7738550Lyn ForrestI think this is a brilliant Idea. Wish they had this when I was at school31292018-10-30T09:27:30.0238551Ruth TownsendThis is a great idea. I wish I had had that opportunity in primary school.31292018-10-30T14:27:43.40338553Andy BrownThis is the time to acknowledge the world is going vegan and there's a responsibility to be part of it.31152018-10-30T15:08:23.31738554Eugene Rubuls Vegan options must be everywhere 31152018-10-30T18:18:35.36338555Jillian HannahGoing vegan is the only right choice for the animals, for your health, and for the environment.31152018-10-30T18:22:46.06738557Alan PorterVegan options should be available.31152018-10-30T20:29:59.31338558Neil SmithSigned because people who don't want things that come from other animals to be included among things they actually want to eat exist. More and more of us everyday. Were going to need some recognition sooner or later.31152018-10-31T00:14:13.87338559Elaine Thom Anyone working with children should be trained in paediatric first aid.31292018-10-31T07:13:57.32738560Alysyn HeathVegan options should be available everywhere but definitely required in Hospitals where their nutrition content would greatly improve the chances of a quicker recovery and Schools where looking after our children should be a priority.31152018-10-31T08:16:23.7138561Elaine ThomsonWhy not it should be your choice 31152018-10-31T10:09:08.9438562Keith StarsmeareHealthy. Good for the environment. Just do it!31152018-10-31T11:50:39.59738563Julie Blair I think this is necessary for vegans31152018-10-31T17:30:25.15738567Rokaiya AliThis is an opportunity that should be introduced to kids in primary school. It would provide them with the skills and practice that allows them to save someone at home, school or elsewhere in a potential life threatening situation. It is knowledge that is invaluable and we should be introducing it to young children to better educate our population. 31292018-10-31T21:08:16.0238569Mhairi McKeanVeganism is about social justice and ending the ownership, exploitation, torture, and murder of sentient beings. People should not to forced to participate in this violence by limiting their choice of vegan food - veganism is about compassion not exclusion.31152018-11-01T07:51:07.18738570Patricia Mckinlay Find it hard to find anything to eat when out and about 31152018-11-01T08:04:19.7238571Miss Toni TwiggI agree with the ban i have been affected when younger it was not a very nice experience i also cried.30902018-11-01T10:25:42.25338573Ronald BinnieAs a healthy, cruelty free diet that is not only an more ethically progressive way of life but long-term much more sustainable. As such vegan options should be made available to all.31152018-11-01T10:39:30.138574Lorna Routledge Please put a stop to this. These are sentient beings.31152018-11-01T10:41:44.35338575Margaret EastonToo many animals are slaughtered31152018-11-01T10:44:31.9638576David ShevelsThough not Vegan (I'm pescatarian) even I find it hard at times to find non-meat options. I would like to see them far more readily available.31152018-11-01T10:55:45.5438577john patersonEveryone should have the choice to eat without cruelty.31152018-11-01T11:16:18.2338578Jennifer MoirPeople should have a choice, particularly at public run places. 31152018-11-01T12:17:38.03738579Alison KennedyThe more plant food we humans eat the fewer animals are destroyed to feed us.31152018-11-01T13:35:42.7538580Samantha Dawn Animals are not commodities and their lives are as precious as ours. Killing to allow people to eat is just sad and unnecessary.31152018-11-01T14:15:10.32738581Ron WoodPlease help vegans to have more choice and in dfoing so help the environment and animals. Thank You31152018-11-01T15:11:55.92738583Ann MooreThe more vegan products the better. Everyone has a choice. 31152018-11-01T15:29:08.79738585Elisabeth StevensonI want less animals to be slaughtered needlessly when there are other options.31152018-11-01T15:37:36.2238586Martin ThomasHumans have no need to eat Animals 31152018-11-01T16:26:01.538588William MilneAt least 7% of us are vegan and this number is set to rise. We and our children deserve food options in public sector catering.31152018-11-01T16:46:22.5838589Sallie Ann WrathAlthough not a vegan I do believe in freedom of choice31152018-11-01T17:03:06.8438590Jacqueline HarkinsDo it please!31152018-11-01T18:49:15.8438591Caroline MorrisThere should be more options and opportunity to eat without cruelty31152018-11-01T21:29:54.84738592Catherine JadavFor food sustainability, the environment and animal welfare, we need to eat less animal products and more plant-based food. It is therefore essential to have at least one, and preferably several, entirely plant-based options on public menus.31152018-11-02T00:12:33.05738594Christine BurnsNeeds immediate action!31152018-11-02T07:25:35.94338595Karen OsterbergBy exchanging just one meal for a plant free meal it would reduce the environmental cost enormously, give people the opportunity to try a quality vegan option and for those of us who are vegetarian with dairy intolerance we would greatly appreciate this. 31152018-11-02T10:48:48.78338596JEN TAYLORFor peace on earth 31152018-11-02T11:19:46.2538597CHELSEA CARBERRYPlease encourage more healthy choices on menus in public places. God dave our planet and animals31152018-11-02T12:25:03.05738598Tracy CollinsVeganism is a really great idea It positively impacts your health and the environment, not to mention being far kinder to animals. Its a win win and should be encouraged and supported.31152018-11-02T21:01:00.61338601Caitlin Murphy Please respect our wishes to not eat animals! 31152018-11-02T22:31:33.9538604andy simpsonits about time vegans had a menu option31152018-11-02T23:58:37.02738605Mairi Lynnpeople must have this choice.\r\n31152018-11-03T00:12:30.79338606Gavin JenkinsonFirst Aid is vital life skill.\r\n\r\nIt's must be taught from a young age, as you will not know when you will need to call upon it!31292018-11-03T14:27:01.67338609ludovica moreschiniThis petition is proof of a new mentality that we need to make real positive change!31152018-11-03T15:55:47.9238610Gill BannisterPlease support this, it will encourage more of us to be more mindful of our menu choices.31152018-11-03T23:49:21.87338611Mark SimpsonDo we really want educational institutions where you can't even opt out of harming an animal at lunchtime? 31152018-11-04T08:17:06.3238612Lesley BrownlieWhile I agree cameras are much needed sw remain unfit for purpose 31342018-11-04T08:50:27.8738613Lorna Matthews It's time! Our planet can't cope any more! 31152018-11-04T09:33:44.95338614John David SmithThis is not only around allowing vegans the freedom to live out their beliefs in public places. This is also about supporting healthy choices. Unwell patients in hospitals need access to healthy and nutritious food to allow them to heal and get well. The best source of this is plant-based nutrition. By supporting adding "vegan" food to public sector menus, this too will be made possible. 31152018-11-04T12:18:39.0438615Angie WaddellPlease respect our wishes to not eat animals, Simple!31152018-11-04T18:27:42.88738616Belinda Carr Of course there MUST be a Vegan option. Options - more than just one Vegan option!31152018-11-04T20:51:20.1738617Claire DouglasOptions is all we ask31152018-11-04T21:43:22.33338618Sharon wiener-ogilvie We need to encourage people to eat plant based food in an effort to conserve the environment 31152018-11-04T22:25:47.8438619Gail StirlingIt is all about the right of choice, animals choose not to be killed and people choose not to eat them.31152018-11-05T03:37:12.2638620christine bainits about time vegans had a choice of food likr non-vegans do31152018-11-05T07:50:52.1738621Sally CollisVegan ian is very popular now and is the right way for our health and the planet do choice must be made available 31152018-11-05T10:26:14.98738623Arlene RaeburnYoung children learn and absorb information in an intuitive way. To teach these skills early will give them confidence to help in situations where in the future, they may just have been bystanders. I dont think they will be frightened of confronting injuries or symptons of illness if they have an understanding of the body and its functions. I believe it will cascade to others in the childs environment (parents, siblings,friends) through their natural desire to talk and share information. Children and young peole will grow in confidence.\r\nThis teavhing may also encourage ypung people to consider a career in medicine, nursing or allied professions.\r\nThe teaching and learning can and should blend with estabished learning situations within the curriculum.\r\nTeachers can and should be encouraged to work with the St Andrews association to make this happen across Scotland.31292018-11-05T14:22:00.9138625Anita ElizarMore tasty vegetable options instead of meat-heavy dishes everywhere!31152018-11-05T16:02:39.89738626Susan Hall There has a been an gradual uprising of people choosing a vegan lifestyle. As more people become aware of the torment and suffering of farm animals they have shifted over to a more plant based diet and therefore should be given the freedom of choice 31152018-11-07T08:42:50.9338635Alexander BloyThis is a life skill that should be taught at school from a young age 31292018-11-07T10:13:08.24738636Allison CarruthersChildren tend to pick up skills quicker than adults so the sooner they learn these skills the better it will be for them in future life.31292018-11-07T13:53:40.76338637Jo LambHorrified to learn of these devices! The health implications alone are enough to warrant them being made illegal. Who knows what the long-term effects are on our children! 30902018-11-07T21:54:30.48338638Sarah StringerGreat idea kids who goto scouts brownies learn 1st aid so be great to expand on this to all kids31292018-11-08T15:52:12.61338639stevie courtneywithout a doubt this should be as integral as any other subject in a schools curriculum.31292018-11-08T16:05:16.59738640Robert ThomsonYes 31292018-11-12T00:39:24.4938641peter duffythis is a must31292018-11-12T12:18:26.5938642James HillIts madness that this isn't already done. The Heartstart stuff in Glasgow is a poor substitute.31292018-11-12T12:52:12.3938643Debbie CarrChildren are amazing at learning new skills from a very young age and in turn this could help them & others 31292018-11-12T13:12:50.9438645Gail CurrieFirst aid should be part of health and well-being ...for some it saves lives and pupils like the one mentioned can do just that...SAVE LIVES31292018-11-12T15:15:23.67738646Joan CosgroveGood luck. Support you all the way31292018-11-12T15:44:38.60738647Donna BuchanThis is such a no-brainer. How could being more educated about something so important not be a good thing?31292018-11-12T16:10:04.68338648David gould Everybody should learn it 31292018-11-12T16:30:20.61338649James HanlyAbsolutely31292018-11-12T18:56:22.84338650Julie-ann Mcglinchey Absolutely!! 31292018-11-12T19:56:46.91338652derek hallI work for south Lanarkshire I visit schools voluntarily teaching water safety first aid CPR IF you want info or help please contact me31292018-11-12T20:01:04.91338653Catherine BuxtonCrying out to be done31292018-11-13T05:09:30.81738654Kevin MillarIt is an essential life skill to have.31292018-11-13T06:38:50.3838655Alison ClarkNot everyone will use language BUT everyone will need fitst aid at some point. 31292018-11-13T07:57:21.09338656David CalderGreat Idea!\r\nHas this web-page been linked to local school intranets?31292018-11-13T08:24:44.37738657Kenneth UrquhartCertainly. Children love taking responsibility and solving problems, especially doing so for adults. And goodness knows adults are very good at creating problems. 31292018-11-14T12:15:25.53338660Irene ClimieI have been training oiur Scout Group,which includes Beavers from age 6. ALL have enjoyed this and managed it. Should be compulsory in all schools.31292018-11-15T00:17:17.2838661Lisa Duffin Giving kids basic first aid in school could give someone the best chance to survive And save kids from more truma not knowing what to do in that situation 31292018-11-15T20:29:03.7438662Lyndsey baxtera family member is petitioning to parliament that First Aid should be taught in all primary school kids , due to family health issues they have been taught First Aid and also knows CPR . \r\nI definitely agree that this should be made compulsory 31292018-11-15T23:57:18.82738663Janet Young This should be compulsory in all schools 31292018-11-16T21:47:59.8238666Tricia TaitYes it should be 31292018-11-17T16:01:20.24738667Audrey hallThis training should be mandatory for all school teachers31292018-11-23T08:15:11.4638670John hallOf course they all should 31292018-11-23T09:02:01.46738672Josephine campbellWell done u must be so proud and hope ur well now xx31292018-11-26T21:35:00.03338674Jane MacLachlanNo awareness of ILD until family member diagnosed with condition.31602018-11-27T16:26:22.14738675Alexander Ross Friend of person who has disease 31602018-11-27T19:42:24.9138676Ivy DoddsIt took a long time before I was diagnosed as having a lung condition. If I'd had a chest X-Ray sooner I feel my fibrosis would have been diagnosed long before it was. An earlier diagnoses would possibly have meant I would have received the neccesary treatment, I would have been able to continue working and my life would not be as restricted as it is now. Consultants do a fantastic job, but if patients are referred too late it is harder for them to treat patients. I have never smoked. Early diagnoses would prolong lives and perhaps save money. Specialist ILD nurses play a vital part in helping patients manage their illness. More nurses would also support consultants in the improvement of care. 31602018-11-27T20:06:45.5138677Adrienne CinaNo awareness of of ILD until neighbour sent link to this petition.31602018-11-27T22:12:21.9338678James MacLachlan No awareness of ILD until diagnosed31602018-11-28T14:12:01.26738679Alexander Neilmakes common sense to do this 31292018-11-28T21:00:53.238680Mrs. Catherine McBrideAll children should be first aid aware31292018-11-29T10:31:16.22738681Jean JamesI think this would be of benefit to all of us31292018-11-30T19:37:37.65338682Andrew HyndThis ultimately can only be a good thing, think of the many lives that could be saved in the future.31292018-11-30T21:46:34.41738683Paul JonesI think this is agreat idea as kids pick things up so quickly plus they could dral with a situation themselves31292018-12-01T08:44:35.7738684Jo CowieIt makes complete sense to teach this early as it will save lives. It will also help people NOT to panic in an emergency.31292018-12-02T19:58:43.23338685Andrew Grainger I completely endorse the petition for government funding to help raise awareness and better inform people about interstitial lung disease.31602018-12-03T10:32:25.19738689Elaine DaviesIt is very important that we train our teachers and pupils first aid.31292018-12-03T23:05:09.55738690John Stephen burns Time we saved more lives and we should start at an early age 31292018-12-04T09:18:19.6938691Stuart AndersonIt's a horrible desease ,l have ms that's a stinker to good luck with petition ,SNP government should be doing more to help 31602018-12-04T13:16:19.9738692Margaret Kilpatrick It's a horrible disease and definitely needs funding to raise awareness 31602018-12-04T19:30:28.0838693Chloe WhyteThe mosquito device is a clear breach of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, which the Scottish Government has previously stated they are keen to implement.\r\n\r\nNot only does it degrade and exclude young people from public spaces, through painful frequencies that reinforce age old stereotypes around 'youths', but it can also affect people of any age who have particularly sensitive hearing or sensory issues. \r\n\r\nOne of the best things about Scotland is how welcoming and open we are to all members of society, backed up by our most recent hate campaign, our freedom to roam etc. If that's the case, why shut out some of our most valuable citizens from participating fully in society?30902018-12-05T10:58:50.5738694Jean WatsonThis is a horrible creeping isolating disease that can affect anyone, even non smokers. It restricts and shortens lives. There is no cure. Increased awareness and early diagnosis is essential to ensure appropriate help and any treatment that is available.31602018-12-05T20:19:10.12738695William Lawson Unaware of this condition until friend diagnosed with this condition.31602018-12-05T23:33:20.88738696Thomas BradfordFamily member had this illness for 6 years. It's horrendous to watch someone deteriorate and know there no betterness. 31602018-12-05T23:45:28.32738697Allison BradfordFamily member passed away from this illness.More awareness would be beneficial to help others with this debilitating disease. 31602018-12-05T23:49:26.06338698Jean NivenFamily member sadly passed away having suffered from this awful condition.More needs to be done to bring awareness of this condition. 31602018-12-06T11:52:08.33738699Frank TonerIt is vital that there is more public awareness of ILD and support at home. Well done to the petitioners for raising this important issue. 31602018-12-06T14:46:13.47738700Kerrie SpeirsNeed to start raising awareness of this debilitating disease 31602018-12-06T15:56:12.51338701Marina-Jane Juel-BeerI'm well over the age these devices are aimed at and they are painful. It's not always possible to avoid them, I've found myself avoiding travel though Aberdeen after they stuck one in Aberdeen train station, and then outside union square it's self.\r\nWhat damage are they causinv to small children who's parents don't realise they devices are in operation?30902018-12-07T18:22:27.73738703Sandra GrieveIncreasing awareness of the disease and research to detect and treat it early can make a huge difference to the person and to their families. 31602018-12-10T20:15:06.12738704Anne MorrisMore needs to be done to support people with this devasting disease ! Sadly lost our mum to PF .31602018-12-12T15:54:22.69338705Doug Chasei would prefer to close them all and only be allowed to use land based tank systems..............31352018-12-12T16:01:28.8538706Chris RickardClosed system with full water treatment is the only way our salmon industry can survive long term. Wild populations are already at fractions of historic levels due to lice infestations directly as a result of salmon farming.31352018-12-14T12:07:56.79338707Ewan KennedyThe only way for aquaculture to go forward without wrecking the environment is by moving production on to land, which enables capture of waste, eliminates disease and removes the fish from sea lice31352018-12-14T17:50:41.15338708Helen TroupI may live in Englnd now but I grew up on the Fifth of Forth. Seals were my introduction to the wonders of the oceans and Britisk wildlife. We have populations significant at European and world level. It is our duty as a country to protect these animals and put their interest above the commercial. Salmon farming damages the enviroment. The fish are raised in unhealthy unnatural conditions. We have to our priorities right.31352018-12-16T21:21:20.838710Joan GrechIt would be too expensive not to implement closed containment - very similar to killing the goose that lays the golden egg. \r\nQuality food products are expensive - the market understands this and the consumer often welcomes it when it is as a result of quality and high environmental and ethical standards. 31352018-12-17T21:43:26.11738711David AshfordThe closed containment idea has been canvassed for many years by the Skye & Lochalsh Environment Forum of which I am a Trustee.31352018-12-19T05:36:57.12338712John Childswon't buy till this industry is better regulated31352018-12-19T11:52:01.3738713John AitchisonFish farming with open nets is inherently polluting. The industry says it would be too expensive to capture its waste and dispose of it responsibly but there are already viable alternative methods in use in Norway so the economic argument is probably being overstated. It is simply cheaper to dump waste in the sea. This is contrary to the 'polluter pays' principle, to which the Scottish Government is committed. Fish farming brings some valuable jobs to coastal communities but they will not be sustainable if the polluting methods used by the industry harm other jobs, for instance in creel fishing and tourism. It is time for Scotland to lead the world in showing that fish farming can be done sustainably and responsibly. If it does not, coastal communities will withdraw the industry's social licence to farm fish in waters that are shared by all.31352018-12-20T21:34:22.33338714Ann KeenanThis practice is reprehensible!31352018-12-21T18:04:38.2138716Ian DobbScotland should lead not lag. This proposal takes Scotland from backward (in salmon farming) to leading in one step. 31352018-12-22T09:10:20.07738717Chrystine VernonI support this petition31352018-12-22T22:49:40.41738718Hazel McCaldenWhen someone is diagnosed with a terminal illness support should be there inmediately. People are left to fend for themselves while dealing with the trauma of the illness itself and being told they don't have long to live.31602018-12-23T05:07:39.9938719Adele SimpsonI had no awareness of this disease until a friend posted the devastating story of her mum. Definitely more awareness needed.31602018-12-27T11:37:05.31738720Iain Collins I agree with petition to save our seas 31352018-12-28T10:28:46.88738722Iris NeumannWe have the obligation of treating the animals and our planet earth with respect and make NO damages anymore31352018-12-30T13:55:5538723Martin WoodsAlthough I see this is a viable income for locals I believe it should be managed in an environmentally friendly manner and wildlife such as seals should not be targeted when their food source is harvested rather than naturally raised.31352018-12-30T22:56:38.6838724Helen winchesterIt's time the Scottish government acted against animal abuse especially after they went to Westminster to stop fox hunting 31352019-01-01T14:48:49.20738725RICHARD J WESLEYSo much damage has already occurred. not only to wild salmon through sea lice, but to once pristine waters. Anyone that has seen the devastating damage to sea floors through overfarming but also threats to seal populations where controls seem unenforced. Please protect our environment before it's too late!31352019-01-01T16:15:07.83338726Franz Grimleygovernment MUST act on this.31352019-01-02T15:30:05.2838727Graham TembyOur seas need as much help as we can give them to restore them to health.31352019-01-02T22:11:38.42738728Brenda StokesMy dear husband died of I.P.F. last month.During his illness I had to research myself for any material help which was always given but not offered.It was a relief when he was admitted to Hospital where he was given expert care.31602019-01-03T20:40:10.64738729Ruth MorleyThe Salmon farm industry is destroying our beautiful sea. The excess feed, fish waste is covering the bottom of our sea, destroying any wildlife that had lived there. If farmed salmon is needed than a closed containment system needs to be used. I really don't care if it is "to expensive to be used", they will put the extra cost onto the buyer anyway & yes they may have to pay for it first, but they can take it out of there profits. We have a duty to look after our country whether it is above or below water, both our very beautiful, but if we don't look after it now it will become barren. Our wildlife is already effected by salmon farming, increase in sea lice & from the pollution that fish farms do including netting etc. etc. We need to look after our wildlife now. 31352019-01-03T22:23:26.138732Mark SwainFarmed salmon is too cheap and more expensive salmon would pay for closed containment, saving the seas and wild salmon and sea trout and possibly less deaths and diseases in the farmed salmon and nobody loses jobs or profits31352019-01-03T23:29:53.8938733Joanne RussellI started with lung disease in my 20's and wasn't diagnosed until 38. So much damage was done in that time that I will now require a lung transplant as this horrible disease progresses. 31602019-01-04T05:37:37.08738734Suzanne ramageThis really needs to happen 31602019-01-04T06:59:58.14338735Andrew burns ure Vital support is needed .31602019-01-04T07:51:15.2938736Louise Baird More help and awareness needs to be put towards this illness my beautiful bestie has it and its sad to see her struggle some days 31602019-01-04T09:52:48.5138738Lorraine Empson So many people suffer in silence with this illness but it's time to raise awareness off it and get the help the people who suffer from it 31602019-01-04T12:14:41.76738739Gary rankine\r\nNeed to start raising awareness of this debilitating disease 31602019-01-04T13:32:34.04338740Ewan G KennedyTo Marine Concerns argument I would simply add that because open net fish farming causes environmental damage that can easily be prevented by close containment its continued use is illegal under the precautionary principle, which has been adopted as part of our domestic law.31352019-01-04T22:00:32.3538743Angela RowlandsCould Reserch be done on the possibility of aquaponic system for farmed fish oviously it would have to be salt tolerant vegetables for sea based systems. However, rainbow trout could easily be grown in such a system with a wide verity of vegetables. 31352019-01-05T14:14:17.6638745Jean UrquhartThis would appear to be a practical solution to a really serious problem that could, in time, see the end of salmon farming. At a stroke it addresses solution, seal culling and will help to protect the wild salmon. To say nothing of lice containment.31352019-01-05T14:47:12.68338746Sarah EnoLocal environmental problems and damage are my main concerns but the mining of other fish stocks as feed and colourants and additives used in production are horrifying. Even growing vegetable oils as feed will take land away from good plant based human food. We have got to change our diets. I don't buy or eat salmon, even organic. Almost as bad. 31352019-01-06T06:17:31.85338748Huw Edgar EvansAct now it may all ready be too late. Many if my friends have stopped using Scotish salmon and visiting Scotland for fishing.31352019-01-06T13:16:51.55338750Ian CookeThe salmon aquaculture industry has had ample time to introduce improvements to salmon production that eliminates environmental degradation and high dependency on chemicals that this industry has a world wide reputation. The improvements necessary have not been forthcoming and the industry is striving to increase production levels in Scotland. Disease continues to be an issue and the industry mortality numbers are in excess of 20%, many many tons of carcasses have to be disposed of. It's time for the Scottish government to set a timetable whereby the industry has to move over to closed containment methods of production.31352019-01-07T11:12:05.2338751Robert BrownTo act as if no damage is being done is totally unacceptable and this must end now .31352019-01-08T16:19:10.74738753Katherine Suzanne BrayWe have only one planet. We have to look after it.31352019-01-12T09:39:27.67738756Karen Chapman We must stop trashing our planet.31352019-01-12T13:10:0338757Hazel HogganAs a Scot I love the natural wildlife snd and strongly believe it must be protected & kept as nature intended. 31352019-01-13T20:07:59.18738758Libby AndersonIt is scandalous that there is not a single close containment salmon fish farm in the UK or yet any plans for such. SEPA told me.31352019-01-14T09:44:34.0138759Susan OsbornIf we allow Salmon farms to grow using open nets we will lose our claim to have pristine waters on the West Coast of Scotland.31352019-02-06T18:13:05.58738761Barbara Irvine Mental health for adults is diabolical to non existent. Totally not fit for purpose 31522019-02-06T18:50:17.6438762Michael mckeown Something needs to be done to help people struggling with mental health problems and help for their families 31522019-02-06T19:27:53.64338763Alison Melville Because people deserve to have the help they need.. 31522019-02-06T22:47:59.56338765Claire Coyle Mental health service is ridiculous!31522019-02-07T08:37:46.838766Richard GroganAction now. Too many people being let down, too many needless deaths31522019-02-07T09:26:11.07338767Lynne ShoreySo sad this had to happen, where was the help when it was needed31522019-02-08T16:17:55.86738770Jeanie dunsmore More help needed \r\n31522019-02-08T17:17:36.40738771Anne roartyIt takes everyone to stand together 31522019-02-08T19:14:35.90738772Marie Donnelly Our kids need help ASAP before more die from suicide! 31522019-02-08T20:27:06.77738773Jo pateToo many young people taking their own life31522019-02-08T21:13:10.23738774Lee Anne MahonSo sad this affects a lot off people and devastateds families, there should be more mental heath centres that people can attend when needed 31522019-02-09T06:20:09.81738775Beverley DickI have been somewhat been In Receipt of torture psychological Neglec abusy to my Human Rights breaches and criminal. Intent from Nursing staff of a psychiatric hospital.I am not getting any Justice to the Torture and abuse I had to Endure as a Patient.31522019-02-09T12:09:54.64338776Shannon BrownLast year my 16 year old brother committed suicide -he had the hardest life growing up and family was very important to us all. In 2014 our papa died, now when I say he was our papa he really was our dad he had been there from day one helping mum bring us up. Then a year later our mum died in her sleep and Callum tried to save her, unfortunately she had died well before any of us were able to know. Callum was so young and tried to act to strong and brave to get his family members threw it. Unfortunately without any help from any professionals we just had to get on with things and in 2018 it got a bit much for my brother and he sadly ended his life. \r\n\r\nThis needs to stop - we need help31522019-02-09T20:50:15.9838777Sharon mckeown The mental health service is failing everyone from our young to our orderly. More needs to be done. How many preventable deaths dose there need to be before adequate help is available. 31522019-02-09T21:10:40.73338778Amanda MclarenI have been fighting for 4 years since losing a family member to suicide because of failings on the system the assessment process isn't fit for purpose and it is filled with loopholes to which staff are never held accountable for their failings things need to change doctors need to believe people who go for help and stop treating them like they are attention seeking and believe them 31522019-02-09T22:00:49.84738779Racquel FerrierDrastic changes are definitely needed. Domestic staff seem to be able to understand patients better than qualified doctors & nurses. Shocking standards. Disgusted at the treatment a family member received . 31522019-02-09T23:13:21.55738780Aileen Heenan Too many people being let down when they are crying out for help, things need to change31522019-02-10T02:25:10.0338781Kenny Selbie It's vile and disgusting the lies the conspiracy the incompetence and it reeks of corruption top to bottom imo allegedly from the very top to the bottom in NHS Lanarkshire 31522019-02-10T10:50:06.7338782Sandra smallMore needs to be done for mentalhealth31522019-02-10T17:37:45.7638784Michael mckeown Not enough help for people with mental health issues 31522019-02-11T01:46:57.03338785Carol Cullen To many people are not getting the right help with there illness 31522019-02-11T14:02:26.3738786James PaulinFull support to Karen with this. The NHS do not listen. I had issues back in 2012, so nothings really changed since then. 31522019-02-11T14:11:46.90338787Lindsey RobbI support this petition because I feel that too many people are suffering from mental health problems and the supports are not adaequate to meet current demand. A review would bring all evidence together about service provision and statistics which could then inform an open debate about the issues faced in Scotland 31522019-02-11T15:18:05.5238788Kay MillanHow often does this need to happen before mental health services become fit for purpose? 31522019-02-11T15:35:14.3338789Fiona WherrettThe whole health service is in need of review and reform. It won't do just to put more managers in! Considering the tragic cases we hear more about every day, I'd say that more than just a review of mental health care is the most important - total reform is needed to give us the 21st century healthcare we should all have. The sooner this is done the better. My sympathies are with the families of those who have died.31522019-02-11T15:42:45.26338791Christine GreenOur experience in 2013 when a family member died was equally bad. Poor support for them and no support for their family post suicide. 31522019-02-11T15:43:57.09738792Alexander FordThe Government talks the talk, but my experience of mental health teams shows they don't care one bit. Mental Health service needs a full review to make it fit for purpose.31522019-02-11T16:45:59.64738793Susan CorbettToo many lives being lost needlessly 31522019-02-11T16:47:51.02738794Paul SmithI was the same year at High School with Luke, I literally read this today on the bbc website and it was the first time I had found out Luke had taken his own life and was saddened by it as he was always a good guy through school and whenever I bumped into him after we left I think because mental health is no longer a stigma and people are getting help they need the funding, training and staff arent available. More definitely needs done to help everyone involved in this. Im sorry to both your families Karen and Gillian for what you have went through and hope your petition gets you the closure, help and to ensure no other families have to suffer what you have.\r\nRest in Peace Luke and David.\r\nPaul31522019-02-11T16:52:43.44738795Gail VickersPeople need access to emergency psychiatric help when they are in distress. Too many deaths.\r\nLove to see mental health Education in schools too.31522019-02-11T19:06:40.83338796Kate Younga family member took their life in September 2018. We feel they were let down by NHS Scotland. V similar story with no consistency of care, lack of support when in crisis, discharged with no adequate care plan in place, lack of communication between all the relevant departments. Culminated in them feeling dis-believed and unsupported. They were so tired and distressed by this point with so much energy taken up trying to get the help and support they so deserved. They no longer knew who to turn to. 31522019-02-11T19:11:38.5338797duncan dowieMental health help for Men in Scotland , what is that , you have a better chance of going to the moon, so sorry for your loss, I was lucky and sought out private help .31522019-02-11T21:28:13.69738801June McGowanI lost my husband to suicide in September 2018. He too had sought help from the NHS in the weeks prior to his death. He was suffering terribly from severe anxiety and depression. We definitely need a review of mental health services to ensure people like my husband receive the appropriate care they deserve.31522019-02-11T21:33:10.3338802Jane SayerResources for mental health are underfunded and stretched to breaking point. Too many people are asking for help and being denied. Better care is needed and more quickly. 31522019-02-11T22:05:09.94338803Adele McMeekinMental health services failed my brother nearly twenty years ago and the Mental Health Commission said lessons would be learnt from his death. It is so sad to hear twenty years on this is still happening. 31522019-02-11T22:33:07.68338804Katrina Lambert To many people let down by the system 31522019-02-12T10:05:27.12738806Geraldine McCormackThere's so many people out there who need and want help but feel there is nothing available to them31522019-02-12T15:58:30.67338807Gillian McMasterChange is needed now. My husband completed suicide in 2015. NHS Ayrshire & Arran MH Services had a chance to help him but failed him and our family. Their process and procedures are inadequate, with no accountability. 31522019-02-12T16:32:58.5338809Gillian KingSadly the world.we live in is causing far too.high rates of mental.health.issues across.the.board from.young people up to adults ... as the biggest killer of young men why are so.many people.being so let down and left to die??31522019-02-12T17:49:42.9838811Pauline MallonChris's House has done more than the NHS in the years the charity has been here... Lost my Dad, his friends Chris Hands and Peter Court, recently my brother from another mother, Murray aged 16... 3 other KIDS tooks their life in Wishaw within the months of Murray AND there has been more since!!! 31522019-02-12T17:52:29.79338813Brian McArthurThere isn't a proper Mental Health Service in Scotland full stop what we have as a so-called service is nothing short of a disgrace.31522019-02-12T18:06:08.93338814Mrs muriel mcconnellChildrens mental health has a 30 week waiting time.31522019-02-12T19:17:13.0438815Melissa MCCLUSKEY This service desperately needs reviewed 31522019-02-12T19:19:21.30338816Suzanne MacRaePeople are not receiving the right help on time. Something need to be done immediately.31522019-02-12T19:35:40.44738817Allison LoganPolice should also be trained on how to deal with this type of thing. I know of a situation when someone went missing with the intent to commit suicide. The police kicked their door in and charged the person for a new lock and for police time! 31522019-02-12T20:20:58.68738818diane dukeA family member spent 5 years in hospital they let they out took them of their meds they went ill and stabbed me and is now very ill in prison mental health turned them away numerous times .31522019-02-12T21:59:17.3138820Norma StrideToo many hurdles for people to get help!! Too many forms to fill in. Disgusting!! People are put off asking for help!!!31522019-02-12T22:11:10.338821Jane McGeorgeSocial media, tv and life in general is full of stories about people losing the will to fight mental health. More needs to be done to help before it gets any worse. 31522019-02-12T22:46:52.6338822Derek DavidsonMental health is a huge expanding issue in Scotlsnd......the appropriate support and assistance must be provided to keep people safe from themselves31522019-02-12T23:19:25.10338823Annemarie ruiz Yes to many ppl being let down through mental health have helped many of ppl with simillar situations in some profesionals dismiss it as if its nothing 31522019-02-13T13:16:21.51338824Sarah McGrathMy family currently has complaints in with the NHS and also SPSO.We have had a horrific 2 years. A close relative was repeatedly arrested whilst asking for help at A&E. This happened 20 times before she was sectioned eventually after 5 weekends in the cells and several court appearances..She was also fobbed off,as were we.'She can help this' and 'there's no sign of mental illness' were frequent refrains.It's an utter disgrace and has to change.31522019-02-13T15:19:15.93738825Fiona French Mental health services must be reviewed in Scotland. Patients clearly cannot get the help they need and many are being harmed as a result. Psychiatric drugs are widely prescribed and many are being unnecessarily harmed as a result. The focus on supporting young people and preventing long term mental health issues is very welcome but this is only one section of the population. 31522019-02-13T15:22:22.0838826Michael Needham Hopefully there will be changes and life's can be saved. 31522019-02-13T17:58:12.1938828Craig ORourkeIt's become all too common to read and hear about NHS failings throughout Scotland. Mental health is very important. I am currently fighting my own battle to be heard about poor service and care. A full review of Mental Health services throughout Scotland needs to be done as soon as possible. Vulnerable people need help instead they are just being ignored and let down by mental health services.31522019-02-13T19:22:59.4538829Josephine Docherty I am aware of both adults and children at their wits end as they've been unable to access mental health services, one situation was a child having to wait 11 months to access CAHMS. Resources are being continually cut and this is resulting in the loss of life when people see no way out, but suicide. Their poor families are left distraught and no doubt left with mental health issues themselves. More support is required. 31522019-02-13T21:18:21.238830Catherine Matheson My son spent many years in the care of adult mental health services, before succumbing to his illness six years ago. Inpatient services have now been removed completely from Angus and I believe my son was failed terribly by Care in the community.31522019-02-14T07:45:03.04738831Val Herbert A countrywide review is needed as the current system is letting families down accross the board, not enough support and long waiting lists when urgent crisis care is required. 31522019-02-16T01:48:43.5138835Christina McCallumMy son took his own life in October 9 days after being discharged from hospital which he should never have been. Twice within a 10hr period he was taken to hospital as he was suicidal only to be told to go visit his own doctor. He never made it to the doctors instead he took his own life.31522019-02-19T14:45:10.62738836Jon HudsonGood luck guys. Respect\r\n31522019-02-19T19:58:18.77738838Gillian ToshSo many being failed with support that then causes mental health. a family member has had from age of 6 because of being bullied to comply instead of supported with autism, PDA and adhd.It is a disgrace. The education system has alot to answer for and professionals that know the issues and ignore them as just as bad 31522019-02-20T07:52:53.76338840Gareth LowndsI'm a serving Police Officer. I mean no disrespect to either organisation as they try there best but neither the Police more so particularly and the NHS are not equipped to deal with MH Issues. The Police aren't medically trained. There aren't enough RMN or facilities. I've seen or heard too many of my fellow colleagues committing or attempting to commit suicide. I've been to so many suicides that will haunt me and last me a lifetime. The Government need to take stock just cos it isn't happening to them and or they can use private healthcare the wider public aren't so lucky. The Government need to take action now and flood the NHS with money for MH Issues as this is the next big disease.31522019-02-20T13:53:15.51738841Michael Needham Really important that this is looked at as could save lives and help people. 31522019-02-23T19:04:56.90738842Marie LarkinThis abuse needs to be addressed publicly and properly. The abusers need to face up to what they have done and be punished correctly. This abuse cannot continue to be ignored. 31102019-02-24T17:57:57.3838843Clare ChalmersThere should definitely be an inquiry into this issue. Many parents are coming forward with unacceptable stories of abuse that has gone unrecorded and unchecked for too long.\r\nChildren often have no legal remit, particularly those vulnerable children that require the most care and attention.\r\n31102019-02-24T19:20:32.87738844Mandy MitchelmoreYes an urgent enquiry- a family member has been secluded and restrained - we knew nothing about it until a young girl with autism wrote down what she saw. Being a teacher I trusted the teachers who were looking after my family member- 3 years of degrading isolation- unexplained bruising and them witnessing violence has left them traumatised. Apparently it was part of their day and no big deal- no respect at all fir young people with complex needs- accountability fir those that make these decisions and enact them without any care to the impact should not bend allowed to work with young vulnerable children: \r\nEveryone in these settings will cover and corraborate until their is a culture of acceptance of abuse - nobody will speak out because they fear for their jobs and repercussions- councils fear for their reputations before what is just and right. 31102019-02-24T21:19:59.53738845Beth MorrisonWe definitley need to look at the way children, particularly very young children or children with additional support needs and disabilities are able to disclose abuse. Children whoo have limited communication skills or are non verbal which is often the case when looking at abuse of disabled children are discriminated against because in the absence of that child witness testimony, I have been told by those extremely high up in Scotlands criminal justice system that the standard of evidence cannot be reached. Even if there is medical, photographic and even expert witness reports, the way the law stands right now means that no prosecution will be made if the child cannot be interviewed or is deemed to lack the mental capacity to be interviewed. Even worse is that anything those children try to disclose to adults they trust (parents, teachers or doctors) is considered "hearsay" and is not admissable. Families are telling me that they believe staff in schools are robustly protected by councils and the state. If children were being physically harmed at home, parents would be liable to prosecution. We urgenty need to to look at the accountability of staff in schools, right now, it certainly feels as if there is none. 31102019-02-24T22:03:25.5738846Gillian ToshIt's disgusting that children are not being protected.Things still need to change.31102019-02-25T03:06:00.1338847Pauline Kinsman No abuse should be swept under the carpet, no matter the perpetrator. 31102019-02-26T00:44:17.83338849Colin Watson I would like to help or get involved\r\nMy father was badly failed in wishaw General. He took his own life.\r\nHopefully here back I would like to share my experience hopefully I can help. 31522019-02-26T11:56:32.36738850Marlyn FraserMy experience of adult mental health services was totally negative and heart breaking. My heart goes out to people who need to access these services when they crash and burn and to the families who have to support them with no support.31522019-02-27T16:35:57.7238851Heather tyreChildren are vulnerable and must be protected31102019-03-03T18:47:09.7138853Findlay WilsonA leaflet is not enough for people who are struggling to cope. Medical practitioners are required urgently countrywide who can help. The waiting time for those needing assistance is ridiculous.31522019-03-03T19:38:31.5638854isabel barrGood luck with this31522019-03-03T20:06:28.75338855William Hamilton Absolutely tragic.31522019-03-03T20:11:25.47338856Ailie murphy Media and campaigners have rightfully pushed for Mental health to be highlighted now deal with it!! And properly 31522019-03-03T20:24:15.4138857Gary RowePlease address this issue. We as a collective continue to let people down.31522019-03-03T21:01:29.4538858Michael OHareMy experience of the Mental Health Service wasn't really great. \r\nHaving suffered depression, anxiety and panic attacks, the waiting times were horrendous and ended up borrowing money to see a private counselor, which actually didn't help my problems at the time. More needs to be done upfront nowadays because the rate of suicide is only going to rise.31522019-03-03T22:26:13.31738859Kelvin MartinMy personal and professional experience is one of dismay, dismay at the lack of core services available to those suffering from mental health related illnesses. There is a lack of mental health hospitals which in turn hampers the work that can be done and is required to successfully treat someone. I also believe there are a number of people suffering from drug induced mental health issues who should be treated in drug rehab centres, thus leaving mental health units free for those who require intensive treatment at the time of crisis. The other anomaly in the system is the disparity in approaches from different health boards, taking those suffering from mental health crises to accident and emergency departments is not only insensitive but unconducive to reducing unnecessary patient time for those who require physical care for acute conditions. Those with mental health conditions should be taken to dedicated hospitals, politicians need to stop talking up investment and start progressing this critical issue by listening to families and patients. More staff and hospitals are what's needed!!!! And now.31522019-03-03T23:06:18.4538860Anne Higgins Done 31522019-03-04T02:38:08.72738862Lyn ConnAdult mental Health services are not adequate in Scotland. I feel badly about people needing this service.31522019-03-04T08:27:06.74338863Bodil McCaskillServices are very poor and the drugs given by GOs are hit or miss with many having dreadful long term side effects. More funding is needed for CBT, Mindefulness and counselling 31522019-03-04T12:01:15.79338865MARGARET WHITE Mental health is an illness if you haven't suffered it some people don't understand..31522019-03-04T15:32:37.7938866Sharon hossackFamily member has to wait over a year that could be 12 months to late31522019-03-04T23:10:39.91338868Lee-Anne KingMental health in this country is joke no wonder people are at breaking point when they can't get the help they need til it's too late. We go from having a exceptionally poor children's mental health service going into a worse star of affairs when you are an adult. It's time.for change and excuses to stop, waiting lists to be reduced significantly and appropriate help for everyone even those with diagnosed neurological disorders and not to be booted out the other side with no help and the excuse it part if your condition. This needs to change and end.31522019-03-05T06:53:19.5538869Lorraine Noble-Thompson Needs for young people is overlooked .. 31522019-03-05T08:42:51.37338870Jackie Waddell This is a life or death service . I have had mental health issues all my adult life. It is not always taken seriously enough.31522019-03-06T08:08:32.39738871Stephanie Cowper It's real and it effects everyone 31522019-03-06T17:26:37.7938872Suzanne moranMore needs to be done !!31522019-03-06T21:37:11.49738873sarah frenchits discusting that this is still happening Why???31102019-03-07T09:55:18.5138874lynn Bennett NHS, Mental health in this country is disgusting its like in the old days when mental health was swept under the carpet nobody wants to know or care. Our world has changed in so many ways and many people are suffering anxiety depression the GPS do not care or understand mental health issues. A proper team needs to be involved. with all mental health problems. 31522019-03-07T10:30:19.86338875Mary speirsThere is a serious epidemic in young people having mental health problems due to low self esteam and unreal expectations of how life should be as portrayed thrpugh social media. This needs to ne addressed urgently nefore more of our ypung people fall victim and suffer. 31522019-03-07T10:48:21.28738876Laura DuguidSomething had to be done 31522019-03-07T14:18:09.8638877Lorraine BowmanHearing so many people taking there own lives. Mental health issues are the new silent kille31522019-03-07T15:44:11.33338878Karen Glackin Mental illness needs to be recognised before its too late too many cover ups Mental Health issues Do exist31522019-03-07T16:11:12.2138879Nichols BannonJust feel something drastic has to change within our society with regards to the mental health act . Losing too many young people. Clearly something isn't working . 31522019-03-07T18:36:23.07338880Lynn DavidsonSo proud of you for taking this forward to Parliament and facing up to your demons. 31102019-03-07T18:43:07.8838881Martin DavidsonWell done Maryanne! May you find justice for yourself and others.31102019-03-07T23:44:29.38338882Stephen ShawThink Again, keep talking. 31522019-03-08T09:49:02.64338883Samantha FarrellNeed action now.31522019-03-08T11:07:26.70338884Sarah McBrideThe Mental Health Service in Scotland is currently not fit for purpose. Too many vital links are broken, wrong information recorded, resulting in readmition, promises of help made several times- broken twice now. 31522019-03-08T18:34:48.86338886Jill RobertsNo more cover ups31102019-03-08T19:14:19.46338887James Fyfe Let's put a stop to ruining people's lives for the sexual gratification of sick adults 31102019-03-08T23:25:57.35738891Gary Cameron Harkins I'm embarrassed that nothing has been done but after the Celtic Boys Club abuse scandal and the SNP doing nothing I'm not suprised that someone has had to start a petition. Children should be protected no matter what.31102019-03-09T11:18:33.1538893John ChapmanFully support this petition31102019-03-09T11:32:55.95338894Malcolm HankinsAs an abuse survivor myself, I agree that there should be an inquiry. There should not be any member of staff from any school involved in the inquiry & most certainly no men.31102019-03-09T11:40:22.90738895Lynda GreigLet's stop the abuse of children so we can stop trying to fix broken adults that we let down 31102019-03-09T22:10:31.50738898Jim EllisChildren should be protected 31102019-03-11T10:05:42.20338899Christine TodMental Health Services MUST be prioritised!!! Poor mental health is an increasing concern and education is needed to end the stigma which is attached to it!!! It is an invisible and very debilitating illness.31522019-03-12T12:47:13.7338900Angela GilliesA vast overhaul of mental health services is required in Scotland.31522019-03-13T18:19:04.48338901Ricky GroganListen to the people!31522019-03-15T13:44:45.82338902Scott MurphyFrom experience it feels like the NHS and social services are failing those most in need and things are only going to get worse. A full review of all mental health services is needed.31522019-03-15T14:55:00.99338903David merchant In my work I deal with people who struggle with mental health issues every day. This should be a priority.31522019-03-15T15:45:00.71738904Eddie manners The Scottish government did to address this serious issue 31522019-03-15T16:05:26.50338905Caroline & Peter Murray & David Ramsay SeniorDavid Ramsay lost his life due to NHS failings.\r\n\r\nWe, as a family, have been torn apart by this. our daughter, Gilly, has fought tirelessly and managed to get an inquiry into NHS Tayside Mental Health Services.\r\n\r\nWe have met with Karen and heard from others across Scotland and are aware that these failings are not unique to Tayside (although it is our view that clearly there is something far wrong at Carseview Centre, the volume of deaths says it all).\r\n\r\nWelldone Gilly & Karen31522019-03-15T16:32:41.2438906Patricia HewittI wholehartly agree with this Petition . State Schools must be investigated . Those who were abused must be provided with support . So many lives totally wasted due to the closing of ranks and systems that should have protected the child being ignored .We must have laws that are effective in the case of mental and physical abuse . 31102019-03-15T20:05:48.63338907Tracy CostelloThe mental health services are over stretched and the NHS and the government needs to do something to improve the situation the waiting list for counseling in Dundee is very long .31522019-03-16T17:09:17.6638909Karen FlynnUnder GIRFEC and UNRC when have a legal and moral obligation to protect our children. He also have an obligation to support the survivors of abuse and also ensure that perpetrators are stopped from every having the opportunity to repeat their actions.31102019-03-16T21:58:53.7638910Alan ParkerThe inquiry should go ahead, without question. Where there is evidence of abuse, it should be thoroughly investigated and the abusers held to account. The Scottish Government has a duty to initiate this first step and empower people who deserve to be heard.31102019-03-17T14:22:03.70338911Alex RamsayI think patients are turned away due to lack of funds. And why would that be? After all it is NATIONAL health! So why are the problems experienced more in Scotland???31522019-03-18T07:07:06.38738912Lisa NicolFully support31102019-03-18T07:36:54.29738913Sean ConnorDoctors and nurses are guaranteed their salaries for turning up for work. What guarantees do the people.have? I think an overhaul is needed ASAP!31522019-03-18T15:57:46.98338914George GilchristPetitions like this really shouldn't be necessary, but as they are, more than happy to support31102019-03-18T22:22:48.67738915Adam WilsonCAMHS has worked and there is clearly an argument that increasing funding to ensure the service copes with increasing demand will help the service to meet outcomes and reduce waiting times.\r\nHowever, there is a clear need to ensure the support needed by those who are suffering can easily receive the help required in a timely and familiar environment. Dumfries and Galloway Council Youth Work Services are helping to meet the non-educational needs of young people in schools as some Pupil Equity Funding from secondary schools is used to fund services which are similar to that of youth work.\r\nThis funding has helped to ensure that young people are assisted and if needed signposted to relevant organisations including CAMHS. It has also helped to ensure early intervention in mental health cases. While the initiative is fairly new it is helping to change services for the better.31522019-03-20T12:21:16.68338916Helen RossPlease support this very important cause31522019-03-22T14:07:36.99338917Mary MilneThe law of corroboration, deemed insuperable by law lords themselves excludes the majority of victims access to justice. Reform of corroboration is urgently needed to remove artificial barriers to the prosecution of CSA & rape. Only 12% of reported rape prosecuted in Scotland & the main reason given is the corroboration test.31102019-03-22T16:01:37.85738918John McCormackWe are on a journey towards zero tolerance and full transparency. Abusers have to understand that there are no institutions immune from investigation.31102019-03-25T08:15:29.738920Fiona prattFully support .31102019-04-05T16:13:18.11738923Adrienne AdairThe camera would be helpful as there to much violence in the hospitals at least the staff will feel safe and patients 32322019-04-05T18:32:55.04338924Nicola Rathmill To protect patients and staff.32322019-04-05T22:15:41.47738926Alex WallaceLet's give all Frontline and theatre staff body cameras to protect them 32322019-04-07T12:52:49.25338927David PeacockAnyone at work should be free from violence and be home safe. The front line nhs workers are no different. If it stops or curtails violence in either direction iam happy to sign this position. Sad that it has come to this though .32322019-04-10T16:43:21.78338928Adrienne Adair These would benefit staff and patients 32322019-04-10T19:22:21.5938930Elizabeth Robertsonshould be compulsory in all areas of health care32322019-04-11T19:06:19.36738931Sharon McDermott Would be great for staff and patients would cut down violence in the workplace paramount for safety 32322019-04-14T20:26:40.06738935Marian Mitchell A proper review of the stay put policy is long overdue.32152019-04-15T15:27:15.24338936John macdonaldIt's human nature to flee danger,and I don't think this has changed whether it be high rise flats or garden shed.32152019-04-16T16:32:17.338937David GibsonTighter regulations are needed to ensure another tragedy does not occur. Stay Put is not sufficient!32152019-04-16T16:36:32.9638938David GibsonStay Put policy is not sufficient. Tighter regulations need to be adopted to ensure another tragedy does not occur32152019-04-22T12:31:19.538939Elaine shane Staying put has been proven NOT to work and i lt is naturally human nature to flee. I feel there should be instructions on every floor and people are explained and helped to even have some sort planned routine in a controlled way as possible to get as many people out of the building . But people should not be told to stay put and perish ! 32152019-04-23T10:42:58.35738941Grace WallaceThese cameras are needed 32322019-04-29T20:01:42.99338942Lorraine CrawfordThese cameras could provide the guilt of an assailant and also provide innocence if being accused of an assault.32322019-04-30T05:56:35.07338943Grace Wallace Well over due32322019-04-30T06:00:08.7638944William MurrayNeed them in the work place definitely32322019-05-02T20:51:40.07738946Margaret rolloThis should have been done year's ago 32322019-05-13T18:11:15.00738947Julie YorkeUsing beavers to help alleviate flooding is well proven. The landscape changes by beavers also increases habitat and biodiversity, so is a positive on a number of fronts 32112019-05-14T10:42:03.25738949Carol YoungWe need to protect these wonderful resources such as Geilston Garden. Tourism is a major asset to Scotland but tourists need something to visit or they'll go elsewhere. Celebrate our national treasures!31542019-05-14T10:55:53.52738950Bob MurrayGeilston Garden is a small property but it is a real gem and of of immense value in this location, where the only other NTS property is the Hill House. I would recommend that the NTS consider the issue of a joint ticket for Geilston garden and the Hill House to encourage visitors to the area to take advantage of experiencing both sites. NTS has not covered itself with glory since it took over thgeilston Garden - now is the time to abandon any thought of selling it and to invest in the house as well as the garden.31542019-05-14T11:00:27.35338951James Stuart CASTLENTS were bequeathed property and provided money to uphold its condition I perpetuity, (in Trust).\r\nI understand additional finances may be required so adopt the English NT system of developing Holiday lets. The USP for Geilston would be Gateway to the Highlands, (also a Waitrose nearby for supplies).31542019-05-14T11:14:04.1438952Carol HaydenGeilston Gardens are a wonderful place of colour and calm for locals and visitors of all ages. Please preserve them.31542019-05-14T11:51:02.4438953David EvansI sign this petition31542019-05-14T12:57:30.65338954Janet Grant Delighted to read of this interest in smaller, neglected, at risk properties. Great that this is so much more than targeting one property,31542019-05-14T15:28:48.20338956Lynne DevineI'm particularly interested in work being done in Angus.32112019-05-14T16:42:15.48338957Kati ByrneGeilston Gardens and its amazing kitchen garden is the most consistently interesting NTS site I know, you can go again and again and find something new31542019-05-14T18:47:05.56738958Valerie FisherI love Geilston Garden and have visited ever since it was opened by NTS, and on open days when Misses Bell and Hendrie owned it. Recently I have enjoyed painting workshops in the garden. My grandchildren enjoyed the mini beast Easter hunt recently.31542019-05-14T18:56:10.0538959Mary GrayNational Trust should not be seeing it's remit as to attract tourists. They will lose their base if they forget their real purpose. Loss of Geilston and neglect of valuable properties like it and Hill House would be unforgivable. They were never meant to be commercial assets but as IN TRUST for posterity.31542019-05-14T18:56:41.0838960Michael FisherProvision was made for the upkeep of Geilston was made in the original bequest by the owner. It is certainly immoral and unethical to close the gardens, and may be illegal. Also that action would deter many people from leaving their assets to NTS. The publicity would be very adverse for the NTS.31542019-05-14T19:06:28.31738961Janet GibbThe National Trust for Scotland should be ashamed of themselves for allowing this wonderful place to be treated so badly ! We need to keep this open for all visitors to enjoy as its benefactor intended it to be used!\r\nThankyou31542019-05-14T20:45:09.17738962Claire GroverPlease please please do everything to ensure Geilston Gardens stays open- it is simply the most stunning garden and should be preserved and be invested in. It is under threat and would be a catastrophic loss to Scotland.31542019-05-14T21:22:59.31338964Andrew Thompson More natural and riparian woodland in the denuded headwaters and flood plains of our rivers would intercept heavy rain and slow the flow of runoff so reducing the risk of downstream flash flooding. Farmers are being encouraged to manage watercourses by installation of 'leaky dams' to hold back water and slow flows. This work costs time and money and requires continuous maintenance. Beavers, now reintroduced and protected in Scotland would do this work for free. Instead, short sighted politicians are giving licences to even more short sighted farmers to exterminate beavers from their land. Get real Scotland. 32112019-05-14T21:26:00.84338965Fiona LockhartThere is a tremendous opportunity for the NTS to work on Geilston and the Hill house as a joint ticket. Little has been done to market them together so far.31542019-05-14T22:30:05.8738966Jo Ann TurnerBeavers slow movement of water, and are a real benefit forfloodbmitigation + prevention. Also, tree roots absorb masses of water. More trees.\r\n\r\nmore beavers! Also, why do we allow communities to.build on flood plains??? Recipe for disaster. 32112019-05-15T06:12:01.61738968Tracey StanwayWhy reintroduce a species just to then kill it? Typical humans. History is never a teacher to some.32112019-05-15T10:54:37.21738969Gwenneth IrvingA wonderful green space with lots of potential for development e.g. Restoration of the house to attract more tourists. Treasured by the local community. It needs to be protected for future generations31542019-05-15T13:57:54.15738970Sheila McNeillLosing any Trust property especially at Geilston with so few others within easy travel distance having regard to the carbon footprint and so well looked after deprives a local community of a very welcome and valuable asset for own education and enjoyment and also as a tourist attraction.31542019-05-15T17:06:16.19738971Louise RamsayI very much agree with this petition. I have been campaigning for beavers for years and have them living yards from my house. I am very well aware of their incredible capacity to contribute to soft engineering solutions for the prevention of flooding at a fraction of the cost of concrete barriers which has been researched on our land by Stirling University. As climate change progresses we need creative and regenerative solutions to the problems it brings which also reduce emissions and sequester carbon. Concrete does the opposite and its use should therefore be minimised. \r\n32112019-05-15T17:53:44.24338972Christopher PackardI support the petition31542019-05-15T18:39:42.27338973Paul RamsayIt is high time that SG took natural flood alleviation more seriously. The disgraceful killing of the supposedly protected braver should stop. The licensing process should be reviewed and priority given to mitigation and translocation.32112019-05-15T21:56:01.85738975Jean MurdochI visited Geilston Gardens with three friends today. We all loved walking in the beautiful grounds. It would be even more enjoyable if the house were open to the public. I am anxious that the National Trust continue to maintain this property enjoyed by visitors from near and far. It would be a great loss to the local area and to visitors from other parts of the country and abroad. It gives so much pleasure to young and old. Family members have learnt so much from their visits to Geilston as well as having fun playing in the grounds!31542019-05-15T22:29:35.89338976Conner lakePlease do not cull the population of beavers they are a sorely needed returning native!32112019-05-16T00:18:56.338977Christina GrayTHIS SENSELESS DESTRUCTION OF NATURE HAS TO STOP NOW !32112019-05-16T07:28:55.39338978Jean Alison CoatesTotally wrong that the future of this lovely garden is under threat when money was left for its future by the owners.31542019-05-16T11:31:12.6338979Sue ForsythI would like the N T to continue to support Geilston Garden31542019-05-16T17:50:28.3338980Mary RobinsThe gift of Geilston gardens to NTS was endowed with three million pounds to support house and gardens. This money has been appropriated by NTS into their general funds due to a technicality. This is morally wrong and should be reversed.31542019-05-16T18:18:15.72338981Thomas MorrisonThis is a beautiful garden and should be supported by everyone.31542019-05-16T19:44:00.19338982Katy CoxallStop all cruel practices. Beware all cruel people.32112019-05-16T20:40:38.60338983Elsa BurgessThese gardens are a treasure to the area.\r\n31542019-05-16T21:15:33.04738984Christine HandsA fantastic local garden 31542019-05-16T21:54:50.138985Carol Moore Save Geilston 31542019-05-16T23:14:06.7238986Allison JonesSimply appalled that beavers were given protection from slaughter one day yet at the same time permission granted for them to be culled and their homes demolished. 32112019-05-17T06:57:10.79738987Elizabeth LambertGeilston is a much loved garden by the local community. It also attracts many visits by tourists staying in the loch lomond area or travelling around Scotland. There are numerous ways that National Trust can increase profits from visitors to Geilston rather than closing and losing this and other National Trust tourist attractions vital to the Scottish tourism strategy.31542019-05-17T07:04:51.2538988Lisa Chapman There are so few places in the area that are sufficiently accessible for young children to run around and explore, while looking and learning about plants and wildlife. Geilston was a weekly treat for members of my family when we lived in the area. It provided a space with sufficient size and variety to return to throughout the season - to watch the vegetables growing, the apples ripening in the orchard. I also watched my family members roll down the bank in the walled garden many times with friends laughing. It would be such a shame that other little people miss out on that pleasure!31542019-05-17T09:29:43.26338989Brendan Traynor Geilston is a great asset to the area and should be kept open.31542019-05-17T20:04:05.87338990Fran scottThis tranquil gem of a garden deserves to be kept open, as the lady who donated it to the Trust, along with a large endowment, expected to happen.31542019-05-18T13:26:13.38338991Gerard CairnsThe National Trust should be using the money left to them by the owner to invest in this garden and to retain it for the future 31542019-05-18T18:13:15.03338992chris mooreThis is a beautiful garden and estate and we need a variety of places like this. The Trust has a moral obligation to work with the local community to keep the garden open31542019-05-18T18:51:37.49738993alana ingramI have several concerns about the threatened closure of this Geilston Gardens not least of which is the breach of trust towards the benefactor Miss E Hendry who in addition to the property bequeathed a significant sum of money which whilst not legally tied to the property, due to Miss Hendry's untimely death, was nevertheless retained in a separate fund to support the Gardens for many years. Around 2017 this fund was quietly subsumed into the NTS general funds and moves then made by the NTS to close the property due to an unsupportable operating deficit.\r\n\r\nIn relation to tourism, Geilston Gardens is one of the few NTS in the west of Scotland and has the potential to demonstrate the social development of the area with links from farming, military involvement, trade and shipbuilding. It also forms the first link in the chain of Glorious Gardens of Argyll and Bute promoted by Visit Scotland and is indeed one of the most accessible by public transport and has good disabled accessibility.31542019-05-19T23:21:01.40738994Michael FisherI understood that provision had been made for upkeep of the estate. If NTS do try to dispose of the property there is a strong legal case for these monies to be released. NTS simply pocketing them would surely be amoral and possibly illegal.31542019-05-22T09:27:15.82738995Jeremy WatsonI am a NTS member and regular visitor to Geilston Gardens31542019-05-22T09:49:52.25338996walter sneddenhappy to support this petition to keep these gardens and the history surrounding them31542019-05-22T16:22:00.34338997Stuart Probst This would have a massive negative impact on my enjoyment of an incredibly beautiful island, but more so on the island residents. It makes no economic sense 32712019-05-22T16:40:39.89338998Jan DunlopIt is another tax on living on an island32712019-05-22T17:12:31.24338999Ms Jane KindlenStop unfair parking charges. Car parks on islands are a crucial link to island life. Introducing charges would be an unfair tax on islanders & visitors to island communities such as Iona, Mull & Ulva.32712019-05-22T17:27:00.88739000Jacqueline DalyIt's a disgrace that A &B council are considering charging for car at port carparks we have no choice but to use these Car parks when going to get shopping NoOnan which we need to do as there is limited shops on Mill also the bus doesn't go to every ferry32712019-05-22T17:33:01.21339001Miss Lynsey BlandKeep this lifeline service free for Mull residents. This is so important as islanders need access to the mainland!32712019-05-22T17:48:13.85739002Helen MacLeanCar park at the Isle of Mull ferry terminal are an extension of the main road either to or Iona.32712019-05-22T17:55:11.5339003Katharine ElwisThere has been no meaningful or comprehensive impact assessment. Life on an island is completely different to life on the mainland and that should be carefully researched before swingeing measures like this are introduced.32712019-05-22T17:58:38.5639004Heike Timm Living on an island is already expensive. Parking should be free for everybody who lives on Mull. 32712019-05-22T19:00:44.25739005Mark SheldrickParking is essential for disadvantaged islanders. Ferry travel is expensive hence parking should be free.32712019-05-22T19:04:31.11739006Gordon BruceThe charges proposed are ridiculous and will deter visitors who are absolutely vital to the local economy. 32712019-05-22T19:27:50.13739007Gary CutlackParking charges would hugely increase the cost of going to the mainland for clinic appointments for us, also leading to messy and dangerous dumping of cars on the roadside around the terminal. 32712019-05-22T19:51:48.6739008Linda DevlinThis is an unjustified tax on islanders.32712019-05-22T20:21:19.48739010Kes GrantAs a person with disabilities my car is my life line. Also I travel to Iona regularly and the car park on Mull is essential for those visiting or staying inn iona where visiting cars are not allowed. 32712019-05-22T20:26:58.09739011Elizabeth DelafieldI love to visit Mull and Iona with family. These parking restrictions and charges will make it difficult to do so.32712019-05-22T20:35:45.1639012Moira Copeland Islanders NEED FREE car parking 32712019-05-22T20:41:57.839013Paul Burke Totally against these parking charges 32712019-05-22T21:02:35.16339014Hilda IbrahimOur Ila day community relies heavily on tourism. s cars are restricted on the island, visitors see to leave their cars at the ferry port and so rely on being able to park.32712019-05-22T21:03:26.08739015Peter DevineIona is a national treasure and a world centre for history and worship. This move is cheap narrow minded exploitation and will harm the economy. 32712019-05-22T21:06:13.05339016Ed CrozierPlease support this petition . It will help support real jobs in the local community's that it would affect . Also protect the negative impact on tourism . In itself a significant source of inward investment .\r\n 32712019-05-22T21:08:46.0139017Ewan KennedyThis is a pure stunt to raise money for the council at the expense of local businesses and residents.32712019-05-22T21:11:15.49339018Christina LordOutrageous plan to impose charges on Mull residents parking in the Craignure car park, plus charges on tourists parking in Fionnphort to visit Iona. This will have a massive impact on Iona businesses and residents of Mull who obviously have numerous imperative needs to visit the mainland on many occasions, and need to be able to park in Craignure. These charges are yet ANOTHER reason for people NOT to live and bring business to the Isle of Mull. 32712019-05-22T21:19:32.27739020Julie WardNot notice so far has been taken by argyll and Bute Council to the local community's objection to the TRO. 32712019-05-22T21:21:54.1539021Scott BruntonThis will have a massive effect on local businesses and tourists may not travel having to pay these ridiculously large charges. We have friends on the island and of staying for few days will now cost alot more than usual. 32712019-05-22T21:31:30.74739022Andrew youngDisgraceful and shocking from councillors, shame on you do the decent thing and stop it32712019-05-22T21:31:46.99739023Sue AndrewsThis petition should receive the greatest attention from the members of the Scottish Parliament32712019-05-22T21:35:25.239024Gordon D StevensonAs a regular visitor to Scotland I find paying for parking absolutely distasteful. It's expensive enough to travel and stay so keep your hands off this small free benefit!32712019-05-22T21:41:02.8139025Pamela GidneyI volunteer on Iona. I couldn't afford to do so if I had to pay to park in Fionnphort for several weeks. 32712019-05-22T21:46:42.48339026Margaret BrannanThis is disgraceful 32712019-05-22T22:03:39.0639027Andrew KirsopParking charges would make the expensive cost of running a vehicle even more excessive than it already is living on an Island.32712019-05-22T22:24:25.39339029Tom stilesMoving to Mull in August, and will be using ferry to commute.32712019-05-22T22:37:10.86339030Frances menmuirI think locals should have a free pass for parking32712019-05-22T22:39:58.639031Paul BellwoodA family member and I have been regular holiday visitors to the Island for many years. We know enough about life there to have an understanding of the serious impact some of the proposed parking charges will have on the residents. As a tourist I would accept any charges, but it's wrong to impose them on the residents.32712019-05-22T22:51:13.45739032Margaret FitzsimmonsMany people have to travel to hospital appointments in Oban and beyond using public transport once off the ferry, but because public transport does not meet every ferry many will drive to the ferry and leave the car there.32712019-05-22T23:10:18.66339033Andrew David Howarth This will destroy all the businesses and the island. So when holiday makers or people who work on the island decide to come over they are going to have pay an absolute fortune, and will put people of from coming to such a beautiful island. Think twice before acting that is what my family always told me but let's hope you think twice before acting32712019-05-23T01:23:13.58739035Mairi MacKinnonPlease safeguard and improve all parking at island ports to protect the fragile communities living there.\r\nIt is very important to protect and improve the tourist industry to these islands which is an essential part of there livelihood. People need to be able to find a place to park at ports or they won't be able to travel on the Ferry..32712019-05-23T01:32:15.21339036Donald MacFadyenLifeline services ,Tourist industry ,Community growth all need good parking at Island ports. Excessive parking fees could have a serious detrimental impact to already fragile communities.32712019-05-23T06:43:36.03339037David TaylorThe island of Mull is my escape from such things as parking charges , please leave it alone 32712019-05-23T07:26:57.9339039Jennifer BeachamIntroduction of parking charges will be an imposition on those living in the area and a deterrent to visitors. 32712019-05-23T07:27:47.69739040Christine BlackI holiday in Iona about 5 times a year. Parking charges would be devastating as we are not allowed to take the car onto Iona. 32712019-05-23T07:36:51.46339042Clare SandersThe impact of this would be enormous for islanders- it needs to be re-considered.32712019-05-23T07:41:49.32339043Anne HoggLeave the car parks alone.32712019-05-23T07:50:15.87739045Professor Robert BowmanMy late father and family did huge work for tourism & transport on Mull. Not only can I see this proposal is ludicrous and discriminatory to islanders who need to leave transport at the ferry. But I am certain he would be against it again as a further example of a disconnected council interfering in matters beyond their capability, knowledge or competence. 32712019-05-23T07:55:58.98739046Mary GriffinIt is very important to protect and support the uniqueness of island life in places such as Mull and Iona. 32712019-05-23T08:32:20.20339048Steve JackAn outrageous and unsustainable proposal!32712019-05-23T08:34:31.79339049Joe BenbowIslanders need this essential free service but visitors and tourists should expect to contribute towards amenities that islanders pay towards in their community tax32712019-05-23T08:46:08.72339051Joy WilkinsonWe love Mull and don't want to see parking charges put people off visiting such a beautiful place. The island economy needs visitors!\r\n32712019-05-23T08:48:37.84739052Campbell CameronLittle Consideration for Island life effects of parking regime charges is being shown here in Argyll and Bute. Revenue income generation blindness is evident. 32712019-05-23T08:59:29.38739054Chester GoudieThe people of the Islands rely on the ferrys for every thing and being able to park when going to the mainland, and for visitors , no visitors no livelyhood.32712019-05-23T09:21:39.72739055carol franklynThis is purely a money making scheme by the councils and will have an adverse effect on both businesses and residents alike. 32712019-05-23T09:23:37.31339056Andrew RamsayThese free car parks are vital to the island. It's a tax on using the ferry as a foot passenger. It's also a tourist tax for all the people that park and join tours etc which are vital to the island community. This is a money making exercise by a council that are out of touch with island life. 32712019-05-23T09:32:56.5839057Donald JackVisiting the Small Isles for work and family connections it is necessary to be able to park for several days at a time. Given that these islands are not suitable for many vehicles and special permission is required to take vehicles there, it is essential for locals and visitors to be able to park at ferry terminal in Mallaig. 32712019-05-23T09:45:01.839060Colin.George MacleanEasy soft Target! Penalised because of where you live. Tourists will be puzzled, they've already paid substantial sums to be here AND visiting businesses will not return, will they?32712019-05-23T10:03:51.28739061John MacPheeanother unfair tax on local motorists.32712019-05-23T10:07:00.08339062Alison JohnstonThese planned high charges will badly affect the local economy in an area where living costs are already high. Working against government subsidies to keep a resident population on the islands.32712019-05-23T10:29:06.1539063Richard West On Mull not all ferries are served by public transport. A visit to Oban for medical appointments which can be of indeterminate length can result in a return ferry that is not met by a bus. Taxi fare to Tobermory is unaffordable.32712019-05-23T10:32:10.58739064Alan SlaterOnce again the motorist is seen as a cash cow to be milked for as much as they can32712019-05-23T10:40:15.16739065Susan KnoxIt's hard enough to live on an Island but to put charges on for folks who need to leave their cars at the ferry port to come over for appointments on the mainland is diabolical.32712019-05-23T11:09:03.13339066Ian WilsonAbsolutely ridiculous 32712019-05-23T11:11:47.39339067Linda LittlewoodIt is not possible for most people to use ferries without the use of a car, so charges at any level become punitive in a large number of unavoidable circumstances. Islanders have no choice at all in where they park when accessing ferries, this is not as it would be on the mainland to go to appointments at hospital as just one example. Any charges have disproportionately negative impact on people, making it more difficult for people to be here.Surely this is what 'island proofing' is all about. 32712019-05-23T11:33:28.69739068john craigIt makes journeys off the Island to hospitals etc very expensive 32712019-05-23T11:50:16.18339070Dirk GrutzmacherIt will make it very difficult for people to stay on the Isle of Iona for a week or so. The programmes in the various centres run typically for such a period.\r\n32712019-05-23T11:57:36.08739071Mirren GreenI am not resident on Mull or Iona, but spend a significant amount of time on the latter every year. Parking charges of this order will make it too expensive for me to do this in the future, and doubtless have a massive affect on the local communities. Please please reconsider! 32712019-05-23T12:01:36.90739072Chris JenkinsIt is bad enough for visitors, but punitive for islanders.32712019-05-23T12:05:41.77739073Marilyn LavertyI travel to ferry to Oban on bus but would still have to pay to park in Tobermory car park to enable me to leave car take shopping up hill, or take a taxi, adding more expense from my meagre state pension. 32712019-05-23T12:14:53.8139074Heinz TollerEncourage people to use public transport by providing free parking at key points.\r\nReduce additional costs for people living on islands.\r\nBe guided by the letter and the spirit of Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 and uphold the law!32712019-05-23T13:01:39.9439076Alison MacdonaldI have a family member who is a resident of Iona and I travel regularly by car to the island to stay.I strongly resent the charges - which I would have to pay for a week or a fortnights stay. I understand that I would then have to go back each day to pay the daily fee, incurring also the ferry costs. What if the ferry wasn't running - would I then have to pay a fine aswell? This is an outrageous charge and it would force people to park in places where charges are not applicable and cause a problem in the street surrounding the ferry terminals. Whats the point of reducing the ferry costs to encourage tourists and then slap over the top parking fees. - This thinking is not joined up.32712019-05-23T13:52:11.0139078Sarah EwingIntroducing parking charges will have a clear detrimental impact on all islanders and will impact on tourism and additionally sends a very negative and unwelcoming message. People will just try and find alternative places to park which will be dangerous and will cause upset to islanders affected.32712019-05-23T14:20:11.7839079Stephen Glen-LeeThe parking chargers are going to prevent the council employees from attending, significantly endangering the quality of the provision in the school. 32712019-05-23T14:33:17.98339080Annie WarwickWe often visit Iona. We must travel there on foot. So, our car has to be parked for the duration of our stay. 32712019-05-23T15:02:08.85739081Sarah MacdonaldDesperate cash grab by a Council renowned for its atrocious decision making practises and financial mismanagement. Our island communities and economies are much too fragile to go imposing thoughtless, poorly researched plans like this. All this does is highlight the problems within the Council and make us all think more closely about those who supposedly represent our interests.32712019-05-23T15:21:40.3939082Susan DaleIt will increase the amount of car permit applications to Iona32712019-05-23T15:37:05.7239083Mike DruryThis Council initiative is morally unlawful particularly when much of the land car parks stand on in Mull were once gifted to the "People" on the Ross by the Dukes of Argyll. \r\nThis is anti Tourism and against the true values of Island Life and their people. 32712019-05-23T15:37:50.28339084Ora ThomsonFrequent visitor and hoping to move nearbye . 32712019-05-23T16:00:20.3839085Simon PlumptonAs a visitor to Mull and a former Island resident I can totally understand why the people of Mull & Iona are against charges to car parking on the Islands. The fact that car parking has been free for our stay has been very welcome. In our case it has meant being sensible about our parking fir as long as we needed and not parking for the sake of it because it is free. I would be hopeful other visiting feel and act the same. I can understand that for residents the charging will cause untold issues. A day trip to Oban might mean a ferry parking charge of £9+ for an appointment etc All in all I would say that keeping car parking free is the way to go. The Islands are almost unique in their approach UK wide, something that makes the place even more special than it is. 32712019-05-23T16:01:36.8139086Martyn HowieThese charges will penalise those who wish or have no choice to leave their vehicles at the Ferry terminal. Argyll and Bute should be looking at measures to promote tourism not dis courage it. Whilst car parking charges are already levied for short term parking at Fionnphort long stay has always been free and should remain so people either visiting friends, relations or staying in hotels or guest houses have no choice but to park on Mull as visitors are not allowed to take cars to Iona. The usual cry is to use public transport well great you try it from NE Scotland where I live...it will take you two days to get to Iona and involve going to Aberdeen Glasgow and Oban involving a bus and two trains before the ferry and bus to Fionnphort try that with food for the journey and your luggage. A staying guest is a paying guest who spends money in local businesses why would you want to penalise them all they do is feed the parking meter to the detriment of local businesses\r\n 32712019-05-23T16:23:40.03339087William CampbellIf the Scottish Government agrees to "island-proof" the transport infrastructure, I trust steps will be taken to ensure that the socially disadvantaged in Argyll and Bute will not suffer the consequences of the council having yet another way of compensating for the cuts to their budget taken away.32712019-05-23T16:32:07.28339088Norman McNabI'm not against a reasonable charge for day trippers to Iona. However the charge proposed is unreasonable and totally wrong for those living on Iona, or spending a holiday on the island. The scheme needs to be implemented with yearly permits for residents and weekly permits for holiday makers and people involved in extended visits associated with the Abbey etc. Charges should be reasonable and not set to penalise residents of Iona and their visiting families.32712019-05-23T17:13:37.59339089Malcolm King I lived on Iona for three years and know how essential free parking on Mull was to island residents 32712019-05-23T17:43:37.5639090Josephine AustinNo charges. Please! 32712019-05-23T18:00:22.5239091Julie Ann FrancisFor longer stays on Iona, this would be a travesty...32712019-05-23T18:16:06.06339092Bruce BlackadderParking charges would mean having to leave my home of 47 years and go live on the mainland. 32712019-05-23T18:27:56.22739095Wendy MacManawayOur Island depends on access from Mull. Key workers from Mull already pay a daily ferry, to have to pay parking as well represents a dramatic pay cut for them. We rely on tourism and this gives the wrong message to visitors, Running a business on an island incurs many additional costs, this is recognised by the Scottish Islands Bill. Please put the bill into action and oppose this parking tax.32712019-05-23T18:31:23.7639097Elaine HosieCharges will have a detrimental effect to the life of islanders and to tourism32712019-05-23T18:51:09.42739098Lilah FordMany people that stay at Iona would not be able to afford to pay charges for a weeks stay32712019-05-23T19:21:07.82739099Meryl Masterton I suffer from essential tremor and strongly support any action that heightens awareness of it. Also I support any treatment that proves effective in lessening the symptoms. 31562019-05-23T19:28:09.42339100HILARY BROWNthis is such a negative high impact for no forseeable benefit or gain most importantly for the local island community. for visitors like myself it has a negative outcome. It will encourage people to randam park in places wholly unsuitable and with probable safety concerns. this is just a stealth tax on all users and has no viable credit for its inception.32712019-05-23T20:32:30.63339102Mairi DunningsPublic transport is very limited, only serving a small part of the island. Island living is more expensive than mainland living and over the years much effort has been made to retain the population. Charging for parking in the area will add yet another cost to residents who do not have access to services available in many other areas of Scotland or Argyll. It does just not make economic sense and the only benefit will be that Argyll & Bute Council generates more revenue but that will be offset by the costs incurred to manage the schemes. It is effectively a council tax that will have a much greater impact on those on lower income. Car ownership is a necessity for most rural dwellers and people who live in these areas require to prioritise running a car over other economic choices.32712019-05-23T20:44:38.02739103Steven GrantThe Scottish Government, through strangulation of Council budgets, are creating a huge void in infrastructure spending for maintenance and replacement. This vacuume is now reaching an acute level by which Councils are having to resort to indirect taxation by placing charges on the few. This is unfair and will deeply impact tourism local communities and economic development.32712019-05-23T21:13:11.17339104Marion brownFree car parking is essential to island life.\r\nThese charges will have an adverse effect on both islanders and visitors32712019-05-23T21:22:56.96339105Claire MelvilleUnwelcome and unnecessary costs that islanders and tourists can do without. Will cause parking chaos at peak times as people will try to park elsewhere. I'm sure the council can get the extra income elsewhere or not at all. 32712019-05-23T22:31:06.77739106Katie HagmannAs someone who travels to a friends family home on the Island every year sometimes bringing furniture and items that can not be purchased locally, it is essential to be able to access the Island. \r\nAnother option to consider would be to allow ALL cars on the Island. Either let ALL people park their cars at their accommodation or allow free parking at the ferry port. \r\nI know the vehicle restrictions are important and I believe they should be upheld therefore the only sensible option is to allow people to park for free. \r\n32712019-05-23T22:47:27.739107Helen BrownFamily visit leaving cars on the mainland as rely on us to drive them around the island. This means the cars on the island are reduced ferry car spaces are not needed. 32712019-05-23T23:56:49.4639108John EastonPlease support32712019-05-24T02:19:45.3339109Scott Bowman A ridiculous charge for tourists and locals with no thought about the impact to businesses or livelihoods. Places restricted time pressures on people and shortening the time people would stay within the wider are, so far that it would negatively effect all types of commerce. The opposite is required that dwell time increases and time locally extended. Silly stupid. 32712019-05-24T06:07:48.6939110Steve DouglasThis is an extremely unfair tax specifically on island residents in order to use lifeline services. It will not significantly affact visitors. There are other fairer ways to raise income for the local council , such as a small landing tax for All. OR exemptions should be made for permanent island residents on their main address ( not second homes or holiday lets) 32712019-05-24T06:32:22.48739112Izzie Forbes-HurstPlease don't do this - don't put these lovely places out of the reach of visitors, and threaten the livelihoods of those who live there. 32712019-05-24T07:46:55.87739113Graham HendersonThere is no need for this. Deterring tourists and locals from various places. No one overstays at a car park. One of the attractions of the island is a relaxed atmosphere - this seems as a tax on visiting. Not impressed. PLease leave things as they are.32712019-05-24T07:59:14.05739114Graham Smout As a regular visitor to Iona and Mull, usually for a week or more at a time, I recognise the imposition of charges for long stay parking will impact negatively on residents and visitors in the region. It is bound to lead to problems with local people when visitors try to find a place to park and end up outside their homes. \r\nAs a suggestion local residents should be entitled to a free long stay parking permit in designated parking areas. Visitors staying for up to a week or more should be able to purchase a long stay parking permit valid for one, two of four weeks at affordable cost. 32712019-05-24T08:35:13.56339117Anne CameronFor many, cars are the only means of transport to their ferry port. Ridiculous to impose parking charges. Unfortunately, motorists are easy prey for charges. What do we get for our Road Tax?32712019-05-24T08:36:02.58739118FrancesParkThis will kill the Islands as tourism will drop. Also for the people who live there, how is that going to work? Ludicrous and robbery32712019-05-24T08:46:34.90739119Linda PreciousWe visit the island on an annual basis. The expense to get to the islands is enough without having to pay for parking as well.32712019-05-24T09:02:01.7339120David BrownCharging complicates and makes life difficult for all users. Compliance will need supported which is also costly. 32712019-05-24T09:21:09.3239121Mrs Patricia Murray WilliamsThe ferry is a life line service for Mull and the car parking charges would cause great difficulties for many islanders.32712019-05-24T09:38:49.62739122Duncan SmallmanHaving lived on Easdale Island and been over to Mull and Iona for work, the charges for locals and visitors alike are ridiculous and damaging to the local economy. Sends the wrong message and easily harms the iona tourist industry 32712019-05-24T09:40:06.0439123Barbara WhiteNot every ferry has connecting public transport, therefore thare are occasions when you HAVE to \r\ngo by car.32712019-05-24T10:37:45.13339125Denise Campbell Living off Scotland mainland is expensive enough .. transport cost are high . Charging for parking residents cars is punitive on inter island routes .. 32712019-05-24T11:48:03.839126David HortonTravel to the islands is already costly. This can only reduce tourism.32712019-05-24T12:03:00.83339127Bernadette GibsonAs regular visitor to Mull and Iona Having to pay to park my car for a full week would put me off visiting.32712019-05-24T12:33:02.22339128Stephen Rowan The impact on people and families with low income or receiving benefits who live on Mull & Iona would be significant as they need to reach health and other services on the mainland. By top loading the existing additional costs of living in remote island communities, Argyll & Bute Council would be scoring an own goal if these changes were introduced.32712019-05-24T12:46:00.9939129Sarah Mair I am totally against the suggestion to introduce parking charges at Scottish Island Ferry Ports. Parking at ferry ports, should not be charged for as there is no alternative for residents and their visitors and the many thousands of tourists who use these. In particular such parking is needed for those islands such as Iona where visitors vehicles are not permitted This is an abuse of the monopoly held by local authorities. I understand it may also be necessary to return to parked cars on a regular basis to 'top up' daily or weekly charges which would then incur ferry costs on top of the parking charge. This is against the spirit of policy which encourages tourists and visitors. The nature of public transport to and from these islands is such that it could not cope with the additional passengers and would simply push the parking problem further back in the transport chain and on a local basis onto surrounding approach roads and ground. 32712019-05-24T12:53:12.6339130Peter WilliamsAs parking is part of our lifeline service, charging for it would cause some people a problem32712019-05-24T13:05:29.25739131David WestAs a frequent visitor to Scotland and the Isles I object strongly and great sympathy to residents who rely on these ferry services32712019-05-24T14:30:13.7239132Jackie Dudley Listen to the residents they are the ones who know.32712019-05-24T17:21:27.22339133Jan MillsWe have a car park at Rye harbour which is donation only - that is as far as parking charges should go in any community - but especially in areas where tourism plays an important role. 32712019-05-24T18:18:13.01339134Sheila McLeesThis will deter many visitors from the islands as the inhabitants are very dependent on people visiting and generating much needed income. It will also impact on essential services such as healthcare.32712019-05-24T20:18:12.83339135Sue ThornleyGeilston Gardens is an important member of the Glorious Gardens of Argyll and Bute, a marketing group working to promote West coast gardens for over 20 years - it would be a shame to lose these gardens.31542019-05-24T23:29:20.23739136Alison Fleming I live on the island of Jura so use the Caledonian MacBrayne ferry service from Islay to Kennacraig. The costs of travelling to the mainland and back are already prohibitive. Please do not make this worse by charging (or allowing charges to be levied by others)local people to park at Port Askaig, Port Ellen and Kennacraig ferry terminals.32712019-05-24T23:33:53.9339137Hazel Mariesplease share and sign this.Ferry ports should always be exempt from outrageous charges.32712019-05-25T03:45:22.92739138Catherine JonesImposition of the proposed charges would clearly cause serious financial and social hardship to people on these islands. Please reconsider.32712019-05-25T10:25:26.94339141Jean Anne howellsToo high a daily charge. 32712019-05-25T11:09:41.84339142iain morrisonI support this petition.32712019-05-25T11:41:05.90739143Sarah mauritzen Yet another hair brain idea to charge locals and tourists to boost the councils revenue. Have you thought of the consequences of implementing these charges and the negative impact to the local economy of the islands. 32712019-05-25T11:55:13.5239144Lynn MacKenzieAs an Islander myself, who does not at present get charged for parking, I would be very concerned if this practice spread. It would devastate our community as we only have a passenger ferry and must leave our cars on the mainland.32712019-05-25T12:41:44.63739145Jane Cameron To penalise islanders by charging for parking at ferry ports will impact on people moving to islands if getting on and off is made more difficult. It's not as if any revenue received will remain on the island. \r\n\r\n32712019-05-25T16:10:04.7539146Ian GrantTourism in the smaller isles such as Iona generally involves travelling as a passenger, leaving your car at the port. This charge will wipe out this tourist trade.32712019-05-25T19:38:55.24739147Antonia Nelson I am a regular visitor to both Mull and Iona and I think this charge would affect how long people would spend on Iona and an would also be an awful disadvantage to those islanders who need to leave cars at Craignure. 32712019-05-25T20:53:45.7439148Ian TibbettsThe vast majority of car park users at Mull ferry ports are residents who need to get to these ferry services for the island to be viable. Further to the blatant injustice of the additional burden on islanders, it will surely lead to unsafe parking on verges and a substantial increase in the need for parking controls and administration of penalties which would wipe out any benefit.32712019-05-25T22:10:05.71739149Doreen WilkinsonAs long as permanent residents do not have to pay, visitors should expect to have to pay for parking, they will have to in their home areas.32712019-05-26T11:17:39.42339150Susanne HallI am an NTS member and regular visitor to Geilston Gardens. I love this property. The gardens are a delightful haven of tranquillity.31542019-05-26T12:34:35.9239151Chris EmmettI'm a regular visitor to Iona and rely on free, long term parking.32712019-05-26T21:57:45.50339152Allan GordonClearly since most people cannot take their cars onto Iona the cars have to be parked at Fionnphort. It seems very unreasonable to charge a daily rate for this.32712019-05-27T08:12:31.03339154Tim crickThese punitive parking charges are clearly discriminatory for those travelling to Iona, who have no option to take their cars to where they are staying on the island. It amounts to a major new tourist tax, as well as a significant additional tax on the local population as it is non-avoidable. It completely undermines the ethos and good work of the RET scheme32712019-05-27T11:02:29.68339155Walter DunlopParking charges, apart from all the other good reasons why they should not be introduced, will also encourage more applications for cars to be taken on to Iona32712019-05-27T11:04:22.3739156Janet JardineFerry car parks are essential and should remain free on small islands where public transport to ferries is not an option for those living off the beaten track.32712019-05-27T16:41:53.739157Donald CameronAccess to our countryside should not be "wealth dependent". Indeed our Parliament has been striving for long enough against the exclusivity imposed by many rich landowners. To impose excessive parking charges mostly affects those who can least afford it .. and ironically those who would benefit most through having access.32712019-05-27T17:49:59.47339159Nick HolmesAn unjust and unnecessary poll tax on Mull islanders.32712019-05-27T19:52:23.539160Alison WotherspoonAs a regular visitor to Iona and Mull I have signed this petition to support the islanders who need the parking facilities so that they can access ferries. It is not always possible to use public transport. Charges will also make it more expensive for me to visit Iona as I stay for a week.32712019-05-27T21:46:54.3439161Sam GibsonNTS member and occasional visitor to Geilston. Feel that roadside direction boards would help to warn intending visitors of exact entry point. It's a busy road with fast traffic and you can be too late to turn in. Might improve 'footfall' numbers.31542019-05-28T11:04:20.76339162David SmithParking at all ferry ports and hospitals should be free, people have to travel to work plus visit elderly and unwell relatives32712019-05-28T13:28:43.1839163Andrew MorriceI have been a regular visitor to Iona and Mull for years and have recently worked as a GP in Appin and Lismore. Islanders and those providing their services already face significant costs and logistical challenges in undertaking routine life and work. Adding parking charges will simply make life more difficult but not improve parking availability since visitors will not mind paying. \r\nCosts for islanders who routinely keep a car on the mainland or a larger neighbouring island would be prohibitive. \r\nthis is an astonishingly ill-conceived move. 32712019-05-28T16:43:02.79739164Peter O'Loughlin Terrible affliction, should be dealt with appropriately 31562019-05-28T16:47:32.79739165Susan scottThis is needed31562019-05-28T20:25:52.67739166Donna KinnearI think more awareness and treatment is needed.31562019-05-29T07:29:41.9939168Lucy gloverI strongly support raising awareness and helping sufferers31562019-05-29T09:45:09.30739169Ana McKillopAny help should be made available for this treatment to reach whoever needs it31562019-05-29T11:03:13.48339170Emma Stroud Please make this a possibility for people who suffer every day.31562019-05-29T14:21:13.839172Carol westDo you want folk to avoid parking in town and not spending in local.shops. it will be the death of local.buisnessrs32712019-05-29T14:55:29.9339173Mary FitzpatrickPlease grant this equipment.31562019-05-29T17:42:39.26739174Tomasz ParczewskiA member of my family suffers from it 31562019-05-29T21:18:15.96739175Dean SnellThis is unacceptable on a life line route for the local population. This will also impact the visitors to the Isle of Iona by hitting them with extra fees to the cost of their holiday. Totally unacceptable and the whole parking charges issue should be dropped and never heard of again.32712019-05-30T08:58:59.68339176Alison Broomhead Living in a rural island fringe area is expensive enough and more time consuming than mainland regions - a further cost to inhabitants will serve only to depopulate islands.32712019-05-30T14:52:16.0539177Hamish McKenzieI agree with the idea of keeping open smaller and vernacular properties and gardens31542019-05-30T16:19:08.29339178Seonaid BakerA stunning garden, especially during the spring and early summer. A joy to walk round the woodland too. An oasis of calm. Shameful if it were lost.31542019-05-30T17:16:07.47739180Susi McDonaldIt feels ridiculous to even consider charging for parking at ferry ports.\r\nThis is essential for islands and lifeline service.\r\nThere should also be free or very low cost parking provision in Oban for those using CalMac ferry services to encourage where possible for people to be able to travel without a car to the islands.32712019-05-30T22:54:05.58739181Andrea fisherAs the parking bays by the post office and shop in Fionnphort have got parking ticket machines attached, Argyll and Bute Council are already charging visitors and for parking their cars. The longer term parking space (which is a badly maintained piece of ground) should stay free as an alternative to the ones at the front.32712019-05-31T04:37:43.6839182Phala Kay BowlesGALATIONS 6:732112019-05-31T10:04:34.89339184Gemma SkillinMy country's public transport system is nowhere near reliable enough anywhere to merit parking charges being rolled out. On islands like Iona it's unfathomable and cruel.32712019-05-31T10:25:27.52339186Senga AllanParking charges which penalise local communities are wrong32712019-05-31T12:24:31.72739187alana ingramGeilston is the first link in the chain of Glorious Gardens of Argyll and Bute promoted by Visit Scotland. It is possibly one of the most accessible by public transport and has good access for those with mobility problems.\r\nThe NTS has few properties in the west of Scotland and these shoulf be preserved and promoted31542019-05-31T17:23:01.4739188Steve SmallThis is a disastrous proposal that hasn't been thought through properly. It will have a desperate effect on the islands of Iona and Mull and their fragile economies, I urge Argyll & Bute Council to to stop and think about what you are proposing and the harm it will inflict.32712019-05-31T22:32:25.04739189Joy CrickAs a rgular visitor to Iona to stay with family, I drive and would find the parking charges at the ferry port would make visiting even more difficult and expensive.32712019-06-01T14:19:42.75739190Linda Peeling We have been holidaying on Iona yearly since 1986 sometimes twice a year and hope that parking remains free, actually travelling from Norfolk is quite costly in itself without having to pay to park this could for some be the thin end of the wedge. 32712019-06-01T17:20:15.539191James PeelingThis would seriously affect the number of people visiting the remote islands.32712019-06-01T17:51:52.839193Andrew BirchThe car parks are the lifeblood for islands community tourist trade and should be available free to all to encourage visitors to the islands so therefore benefiting everyone.32712019-06-01T18:47:15.02339194effie Robertson this must prove a great disincentive to tourism, a major source of income for the islands, as well as being a burden , one might say an unfair tax, on those who live on the islands32712019-06-01T22:46:26.439195Dorothy Sterling It would be wrong to introduce car parking charges at island ferry ports. I speak as a visitor and holidaymaker - the charge would have a considerable impact on our travel expenses. However I have particular sympathy for the islanders who have to travel for medical and family reasons and who have no choice about where they leave their cars. Please think seriously about the impact this decision would have on so many people. 32712019-06-02T11:18:19.6639197Christine RoseAs a regular visitor to Iona in early spring this would cause us a serious problem. Often when we are on Iona we can't get off for stormy weather the boats are cancelled so we couldn't get off to top up any charges. The worry about this will stop visitors to Islands and affect the livelihood of islanders. 32712019-06-02T14:52:32.4539199Rob JonesThis will impact greatly, on the Island community, by increasing the cost of going to an appointment in Oban as a foot passenger on the ferry and leaving the car in Craignure car park. The cost of an annual pass is totally prohibitive.32712019-06-02T18:33:32.50339200jon claytonI object to vagaries for the previously free car park. It will impact considerably to holidays on iona and to those who live or own property on the island but choose to leave their cars on Mull.\r\nTherefore not only would it be a considerable extra expense but it would surely lead to more cars on the island. 32712019-06-03T15:37:24.02339202Joanne MorrisAs a regular visitor to Mull and Iona I know that the parking charges would definitely deter many visitors and therefore have the opposite effect of helping to finance the area. 32712019-06-03T21:45:36.3739204Olivia BirchGemstone gardens is a little gem and attracts many tourists and with The Hill House is the only NT S attraction in the area.31542019-06-04T10:02:14.22739205Stephen RawLooks like A&B Council want to actively discourage visitors.32712019-06-04T10:13:21.49339206Andrew FlockhartThe introduction of charges for parking at island ferry ports will discourage me and many others from visiting the islands32712019-06-04T10:19:35.19739207Flora LeckieThere are few gardens of such quality, peace, and beauty in this area and it would be such a loss if it were to close. I agree that signage should be improved from the main road.31542019-06-04T21:46:43.90339208Nicola ReynoldsI am very concerned about the major impact these charges will have on the island communities of Mull and Iona where the ferry is their lifeline. Our visits to the islands helps to boost their economy as well as enabling them to to access facilities that re readily available to those who live on the mainland. Also the amount if will cost to visit for a week will mean a lot of people will decide not to visit Iona in particular. 32712019-06-04T22:24:55.67739209Wilma McMillanBeautiful gardens in a wonderful setting. What a lovely tranquil resource. NHS need to remove threat of closure.31542019-06-05T08:24:14.9539210Jennifer Fitzgerald My family regularly visit Argyll and Bute with to visit family. We often arrange to meet friends and family at the garden as it is a great community space for children to run around in. The vegetable garden is most amazing and I love looking and buying the fruit and vegetables that will not grow in Australia because we do not have enough rain. It is a real asset to the community. 31542019-06-05T08:37:43.31339212Janet SmithGeilston Gardens are a real gem, a quiet tranquil space which all can enjoy. 31542019-06-05T10:00:32.37339213Anne SturrockParking charges will be to the detriment of the local community in the short and long term. People like me will think twice about visiting at all. If I had to get the service bus over Mull I couldn't stop en route for coffee or lunch or detour to enterprises in the island. 32712019-06-05T19:10:04.37339214Elizabeth GrahamHave considered cancelling our NTS membership.31542019-06-05T21:24:32.67739215Caroline AnnesleyThe Gardens at Geilston need to be retained to comply with the wishes of the Donor and needs of the area, and very distinct asset for the NTS.31542019-06-06T01:01:58.0239217Lilly FitzgeraldIt is my intention to travel and view this beautiful place. I benefit, therefore, in all sorts of ways. If that opportunity is not available, then I lose but so does Scotland because you won't get the economic benefit of tourism and neither will Scotland benefit in terms of perception of attracting future tourists. Short-sighted view by the government having long-term consequences on Scotland, locally and globally!31542019-06-06T07:12:56.71339218Rhona DickGeilston Gardens are a beautiful example of mature gardens and one of the few such properties that can be accessed by public transport making it a valuable resource in the west of Scotland.31542019-06-06T11:18:45.09339219dianne gopeeThe NTS could learn from NT England. Far more organised, know how to attract visitors and are much more inclusive31542019-06-06T12:24:43.17339220Jean Cook The action of the NTS Trust in not fulfilling the intentions of the benefactor, will, and indeed should, cause anyone considering donating to NTS in the future, to think very hard about whether the organisation can be trusted. 31542019-06-06T13:35:47.25339221Jen SwiftParking charges exorbitant. The whole affair has not been thought through. We are dependant on our ferries and being charged huge accounts to park for the day near the ferry port is ridiculous. As a for fire fighter I can forsee access issues on the main road as people will park there rather than pay the parking fees 32712019-06-06T14:33:39.46339222Anthony RandellBeavers provide important benefits in managing downstream flooding, also improving riparian diversity.\r\n\r\nI believe that the benefits beaver's provide as landscape engineers is much greater than localised crop and timber disruption. \r\n\r\nEurope has successfully managed beavers where they were causing problems for man years, using a variety of humane measures, including moving them to more suitable habitat.32112019-06-06T14:54:46.9939223Nic Broomhead I do not agree with imposing parking charges as space is limited enough and will add excessive costs to already expensive trips to the mainland.32712019-06-06T19:27:59.60739224Anne McCannThis is likely to discourage people from visiting Iona. On every visit I spend money in the local gift shops so it will adversely affect the economy of the island.32712019-06-06T20:35:44.95739225Stephen ThomasI've been coming and staying on Iona for the last 22 years, so have made so have made considerable use of the free car parking facility at the Iona Ferry. At £9 per day it would add a not insignificant cost to an 8-day stay on the Island. It would be very detrimental to both the tourist economy and to the economics for residents32712019-06-06T20:40:05.20739226Christine HendryTo close an NTS property in a popular tourist area so close to the Loch Lomond National Park, seems a retrograde step by a national heritage organisation. 31542019-06-06T23:37:56.09739227Vanessa AndersonThis sounds a realistic and viable option. It would also require stringent law enforcement against persecution of the beaver population. 32112019-06-07T12:40:44.40339228Mary Tacchi I think Geilston is a great asset to the West of Scotland which needs more tourists and the garden is fantastic.31542019-06-07T17:10:46.74339230Colin BallThese carparks are part of lifeline ferry services. People have no choice but to use them if travelling by ferry for any purpose, including for essential medical appointments, and visiting children boarding in Oban. The consultation process has been completely flawed. The island of Iona was excluded from formal consultation entirely. The result of these charges is that Mull and Iona are likely to be a less attractive place to visit. 32712019-06-07T18:10:08.12739231Rev Peter SearI am a member of the Iona Community. When visiting Iona I have to leave my car at Fionnphort car park. I understand that poor internet access on Iona will necessitate having to take the ferry from Iona each day in order to pay the parking charges.32712019-06-07T18:13:35.28339232Sarah DinwoodieUnintended consequences. Knock-on effects to Iona island business resulting from tourist behaviour (choosing not to visit or stay on Iona), with likely loss substantial revenue for the local economy and council (more than could be gained from parking fees at Fionnphort).32712019-06-07T19:26:20.32739235Stewart BlackledgeParking charges will be detrimental towards the businesses on Iona. Asking people to return daily to renew their parking, whilst not having a weekly charge for people who are in residence for a week will discourage people from staying on Iona. It will also be detrimental to the campsite as it will limit those who are able to camp people with families. 32712019-06-07T20:33:28.9639236Elizabeth DelafieldAs a regular visitor to Mull and Iona, these charges would make it very difficult for me and my family to visit the islands.32712019-06-07T20:59:07.08739237Mike SmallThis is a shambles which will cut off a whole community and cause havoc at Fionnphort. This doesn't make any sense.\r\n32712019-06-07T21:05:43.13739238Patricia LivingstoneI am a Member of the Iona Community who visits Iona regularly staying on Iona and helping in the Abbey as Musician. Earlier this year, over Easter i stayed for 11 days. The parking fees proposed are prohibitive, making trips very costly. ..and when staying for longer periods just impossible. Please reconsider.32712019-06-07T22:41:17.939239Mary DuncansonWhen I visit Iona, I'm usually going for a few days. As you require a permit to take your car on to Iona, I've always left it at Fhionnphort. The cost for parking would be prohibitive plus the fact there would be a need to come over every day to get a new parking ticket incurring ferry fares. 32712019-06-08T07:23:41.5839240John GourlayLots of people going to Iona? This must be stopped! Making everyone pay this kind of amount is a sure way of destroying the businesses on the island. Did the council ask the islanders about this?32712019-06-08T07:54:22.3839241Peter MarshallThese suggestions appear to take no account of the needs and situation of those who live and work on the islands, nor on the impact of businesses that need visitors. Penalising island residents and visitors on Mull and Iona so severely appears to be a particularly regressive and ill thought out scheme.32712019-06-08T11:06:13.58739242Rita BrownBeautiful garden house thatcould be utilised better and be a source of income A smallgem that should be valued31542019-06-08T13:04:16.75339243Sally Mair Introducing parking charges at ferry ports will increase dependence on a bus service which is already inadequate for local use. The added cost to a visit to Iona is not insignificant. In addition, while I am on my way to and from the ferry I regularly divert and visit cafés and shops. If I am on a bus I will be unable to do this. If I do not drive across Mull, where should I cease to drive and leave my car? The train service is complicated and inadequate, the bus service does not meet my needs. If I do not Park at the ferry port what should I do? Those avoiding charges will simply park on the narrow roads and risk causing obstructions. This is a bad idea 32712019-06-08T13:59:21.6539244Jennifer Ann WrightI am very concerned about the effect this will have on the islands income, especially since not every ferry is met by a bus, I waited 2 hours in Craignure last time I visited with very little to do. If staying on Iona for a fortnight this would be an extra £100 to an already expensive trip.32712019-06-08T21:29:50.80739245Peter PhillipsIt seems clear the local Council bodies are not aware of the tremendous task that is being undertaken on the island of Iona.\r\nIt seems oblivious to the thousands of people who go to the island seeking education, spiritual rejuvenation and friendship. The local Council does not appear aware of the ground breaking work being done on the island, season after season. To make the suggested parking proposals will inevitably lead to total disruption of the rhythm of life on Iona, so causing a breakdown in the economic life of the island. In my view this will then have an affect upon the Isle of Mull and the wider community.\r\nPlease keep the status quo. 32712019-06-08T22:47:56.20739246Nancy LivingstonI am an Iona Community Associate and fully support this petition. I have come to Iona every 2 or 3 years for the last 20 years. The proposed parking charges would have a dramatic effect on those of us coming to the island. I believe it would significantly damage tourism on Iona.32712019-06-08T23:55:07.1439247Sue ElliottWhen staying on Iona for any length of time anyone wanting to leave their car at Fionnphort would need to daily get the ferry which is not at all practical. Without a car, visiting places off the bus route would not be possible and small businesses in these places would suffer. 32712019-06-09T00:32:26.4439249Jillian Moore MBECharges at the islands of Scotland will certainly prevent my family from making our regular trips again.32712019-06-09T08:13:14.2139250Ewan Aitken The parking charges as proposed for Mull will kill the economy of the island and for Iona as well. It would clearly be possible to have some kind of charge which allowed for over night and multiple night stats which was affordable, bringing in some income, rather than what is proposed which will do devastate the economy that it will in the end mean very little, if anything, comes in. 32712019-06-09T08:56:46.2339251Liz KerrFantastic Gardens bringing visitors to the area, supporting jobs and opportunities.31542019-06-09T15:02:51.56339253Pamela StevensonI am an NTS member of many years. Have enjoyed visiting with family members. It's easily accessible and a safe place to visit with young ones31542019-06-09T17:29:39.9139254Janet Brown For those working seasonally on Iona, the Fionnophort carpark makes the difference between being able to visit friends on Mull or being very restricted. Many homes and places of interest are a long distance from the bus routes and the numbers of service buses mean longer walks are not possible. As others have stated, visitors would not get around and island enterprises would suffer.32712019-06-09T19:36:41.839255Catriona Rousselparking charges will badly affect the islands and will deter tourist. 32712019-06-09T20:24:59.82339256Helaine RossIslanders need tourism for their livelihood. Surely it will cost the country more financially to support them through unemployment benefits if they find they are unable to earn a decent wage. The Scottish government should be encouraging visitors from all round the world to come and see our beautiful country and, in doing so, help contribute to our economy.32712019-06-09T20:40:39.87339257David NormanAge and disability prevent use of public transport and so parking charges in car parks, on top of other travel costs would put a visit to Iona out of my reach. This would be a form of discrimination32712019-06-09T20:46:52.35739258Ann NormanHigh car park charges could adversely affect Iona's economy by deterring tourists from staying on the island for a week or more. Also it would discriminate against people of lower income, 32712019-06-09T21:14:40.28339259Mary-Clare WatkinsThe introduction of car parking charges is certain to have a detrimental effect on the economy of Iona32712019-06-09T21:30:14.8539260Christine Polhill You cannot have considered adequately the effect on the islands if you persist in making these charges. For example when you stay on Iona there is often no signal to be able to make a call to update the daily charge, and this would be true for both tourists and residents. The very high nature of the charges would deter some who come to stay for awhile and make it impossible for others, and be an obscene charge for residents who cannot take their car onto Iona. Please drop this plan. C. Polhill 32712019-06-09T23:02:59.48739261John PolhillBasing any kind of system on Mull that depends on communications technology is a recipe for disaster. 32712019-06-09T23:27:29.22339262Warren BardsleyI am a regular visitor to the island and have numeorus friends there. This ruling will result in considerable hardship and should be withdrawn immediately32712019-06-10T06:51:15.7939265Juliet Horwood As a regulator visitor to the Iona Community, this would seriously impede my ability to stay on Iona. When I visit I would always contribute to the Island economy in pubs, shops restaurants etc. How would Iona survive without the tourists and visitors especially to the Abbey and Community.32712019-06-10T09:01:44.02739266David ColemanI need to bring equipment for presentations on Island. Parking charges would make this much more problematic.\r\n32712019-06-10T09:48:24.9139267Elizabeth MurphyA very worthy cause!31542019-06-10T15:09:50.50739268Joan JonesAs a former member of the Iona Community's staff working on Iona, may I point out that seasonal staff do not have permits to take their cars across to Iona, and even if they did there is no parking space on the island. They need to leave their cars at Fionnphort all the time they are working on the island - in some cases three years - and parking charges would be totally unaffordable32712019-06-11T12:59:36.7639269Anne SearAs a visitor to Iona I know how important tourists are to the island's economy. High car parking charges at ferry ports would deter many visitors and have a huge detrimental impact on the economy of Iona and other islands. For many visitors, public transport is not an option.32712019-06-11T18:05:35.82739270Mark AlecockSo our life line service to the mainland to buy food and supplies will get now get more expensive. We're finding it impossible to book a car onto ferry most weeks as we don't get priority bookings as a resident. So we park and shop as foot passengers and you now plan to charge us to park. Shocking!\r\n 32712019-06-11T18:53:00.15339271Emma AlecockIntroduction of parking charges would have a significant negative effect on our family life. The car park at Craignure is a life-line for our family, allowing us to travel to Oban as foot passengers to obtain vital provisions and access important amenities. This is particularly important given that it is becoming increasingly difficult to book our car on the ferry unless planned months in advance. Instead of promoting island life and encouraging families to live and work here, this is yet another example of introducing increased costs and more hurdles and barriers to island life and totally flies in the face of the islands bill, the intent of which is to protect us from unintended harm. The car park at Craignure is used almost exclusively by islanders and essential tradespeople and not tourists as tourists will bring their car across and drive around the island or will arrive as foot passengers if they intend to use public transport. In addition, removal of the lorry park will cause displacement of vehicles as this is in constant use by tradespeople and local businesses. 32712019-06-11T22:46:42.54339273Nancy SomervilleI strongly object to the proposed parking charges on the Isle of Mull. \r\n\r\nAs someone living just outside Craignure, who did without a car here for almost 18 months, I can testify as to how difficult it is, especially out of season. Although bus services on the island are reliable they are infrequent and do not cover the whole island. Also they do not meet all ferries. Consequently, many residents have no choice but to use their own transport to access the ferry terminal at Craignure and for shopping in Tobermory or Fionnphort. \r\n\r\nAccess to medical treatment is of course another difficulty, unless you are lucky enough to live in Tobermory or in one of the few villages with a doctor's surgery. Also, I believe most islanders attend dental surgeries and opticians in Oban. \r\n\r\nIn other words, the car park in Craignure is a lifeline for residents from all over the island, using it to park while in Oban for medical or dental treatment, vet visits or shopping. Few if any visitors use it, as Craignure tends to be a place they pass through on the way to somewhere else. \r\n\r\nFor pensioners, a concession return on the ferry is one pound forty pence. The proposed car parking charge would increase this to at least five pounds forty pence, and more if medical appointments at the hospital or dentist (or vet) took longer than an hour. \r\n\r\nAlso, although not directly affected, I cannot make sense of the proposal to have the only lorry park on Mull in Bunessan.\r\n\r\nI do not believe that these proposals could have been checked with the Scottish Government's Islands Bill. In fact, it appears that whoever drew them up knows nothing about Mull or island life! They are the equivalent of expecting people in Oban to pay a toll to leave or enter the town! \r\n\r\nPlease throw these proposals out, or at the very least carry out an islands impact assessment. 32712019-06-12T13:27:59.62739274John M Sutherland-FisherWe have similar problems on the east coast where Highland Council is planning to welch on undertakings not to impose charges in public carparks in small towns which will destroy the viability of shops in these lifeline communities32712019-06-12T14:37:14.5739275Sonya Wratten This will make it very difficult for young people, children and visitors to stay on Iona as a place of spiritual sanctuary and pilgrimage. 32712019-06-13T01:14:40.97739276Rebecca SmitThis needs to be granted31562019-06-13T06:44:05.7339277Jackie KerrI have two close relatives who have this and my Grandfather also suffered31562019-06-13T09:20:10.33339278Clair Nichols Because people with tremor see this as a better option than the current expensive and invasive treatments that are offered. 31562019-06-13T13:27:09.88339279Sue RawlingsThis will be a disaster for the islands - why reduce ferry costs ann then add parking charges? The islanders need visitors and the residents need a reasonable cost of living. This will really hamper both economics and lifestyle for Iona and similar islands.32712019-06-13T13:49:08.57739283Carole Eaton Please grant this equipment, so people have a better quality of life 31562019-06-13T18:51:17.01739285Garry WestonThis would greatly help a family member who was born and lives in Scotland31562019-06-14T10:18:47.20339286ROBERT N macleodI own a hotel and this will impact our guests making travel more expensive. Local people will be impacted for mainland travel. Councillors were not I. Possession of all the facts.32712019-06-14T11:19:36.8239287Tony mcleanGoing to add a lot of money every time we go across for shopping. And also if we go on holiday we can not leave our car and use public transport to he airport. It will be cheaper to drive to the airport and park there.32712019-06-14T11:19:58.33739288Katriona Fox LloydI think this is a very poorly thought out proposal. Anyone having to leave Iona and Mull for work, business reasons, hospital appointments and treatment are going to be seriously disadvantaged compared with people living on the mainland. The public transport timetables do not always fir with the ferry timetables, meaning that people must use cars to travel throughout the island. 32712019-06-14T11:54:34.0939290Anne RobertsI visit Mull but driving a small camper van will make parking difficult for me with the new rules. I'm afraid that this year's already booked stay may well be a test and a last visit. We spend a fair few hundred pounds on Mull. They need visitors for the local economy 32712019-06-14T12:01:12.54739291Margaret Campbell For Iona residents needing to cross this is grossly unfair... for pilgrims staying on Iona, this becomes a huge additional cost which, when deterring, would cause real problems to the economy of the island. There has to be some solution worked out with the people of Mull and Iona. 32712019-06-14T12:16:17.52339292Valerie Owen I live on the island and would make it much more expensive for shoping and hospital visit this would be another tax on the islanders and effects shops hotels and tourism .32712019-06-14T12:19:34.1839293Margaret BruceThe impact on local people who need to travel and park in order to work is untenable. These are the very folk who serve the community and also staff the services that bring in money from tourism! This cannot be seen as fair!32712019-06-14T12:20:29.57339294Bruce BlackadderIf the charges are imposed it would be cheaper and easier to take my car to Oban rather than use bus from Tobermory then ferry. 32712019-06-14T12:36:56.79339295Rebecca Gallagher These charges are not about helping with the current infrastructure problems on the island and are only going to intensify these issues.32712019-06-14T13:03:22.45339296Maureen DehanyAny parking charges will have a devastating effect on the community on Mull and Iona and this proposed order should be quashed immediately32712019-06-14T13:16:27.8339297Doris HargreavesWe live on a steep hill in Tobermory, and as an OAP I need my car to get my shopping, prescription and post office.32712019-06-14T13:36:35.7739298Avril LoweCharges for parking in the Ledaig car park (Tobermory) will displace cars and campervans to the Main Street, which is already overloaded, and to residential areas, making life difficult for residents.32712019-06-14T14:23:25.4539299Alicia Hendrick I am unhappy that Argyll And Bute Council have not considered the impact these charges will have on our fragile communities 32712019-06-14T14:31:20.4839300JoanMackay This ruling should be withdrawn it will destro Mull and Iona.32712019-06-14T14:37:56.26339301Mary MacgregorFull traffic management plan required. 32712019-06-14T15:02:33.1139302Gillian Wilshire Making island living more expensive .32712019-06-14T15:20:31.0839303Eugenie ThomassonThis TRO is going to make living and working on Mull near to impossible. A family member commutes to Oban on the ferry for work and the car park in Craignure is literally our only choice, I also rely on the free car parks for my business and there appears to be nowhere for commercial vehicles to park anywhere, except Bunessan! It is ridiculous and makes the Council look like fools, especially the Tro for Tobermory, the town will be a shambles.32712019-06-14T15:37:48.11739304Kathryn Dyer SimpsonAs a resident of Mull, my 'lifeline services' will be much harder to use. Absolutely disgraceful that a corrupt council wants to raise money by making it harder and even more expensive to make Mull our home. 32712019-06-14T15:46:29.25739305Michael HoganAs a Mull resident, who works on Iona for part of the year, I know how disruptive this proposal will be. Car parks are essential for those going to Oban for health appointments (I have two in the next 28 days) or for those who currently stay on Iona but don't bring their car across as it isn't 'needed'. What a bizarre situation that will be created where Iona residents will find it cheaper to bring their car onto Iona than to leave it parked up in Fionnphort! Of course this is precisely the type of decision that the 'Islands Act' was designed to prevent! \r\nThe whole process has been organised to avoid any island input. So, Iona was deemed not to need consulting because all the car parks were on Mull, the decision was taken at a meeting rather than a hearing which meant it could take place in Oban and, for similarly spurious reasons, our community representatives were refused any opportunity to speak at the meeting. This meant that the only 'objections' the councillors had in front of them was a 'summary' of objections which the officers prepared and which was incomplete, inaccurate and partisan. I'm not able to comment on the legality of each of the actions taken by the officers but it is clear that the aim was to ensure that local communities were silenced and to ensure there any vestiges of democracy were removed. 32712019-06-14T15:46:54.97739306Felicity HansenI am a resident of Mull. Public transport is very limited here. It will be much more expensive for me to make shopping trips and trips for medical appointments if I have to pay for parking. I get a concessionary fare on the ferry but the effect will be more than cancelled out by the parking charges.32712019-06-14T15:58:33.19739307Alan JackA family member and I are both retired teachers, having taught almost all of our working lives on the Island of Mull. Due to a number of health conditions, we require to travel to hospitals in Oban and Glasgow. Due, at times to lack of suitable ferries, we require to spend a whole day in Oban or even an overnight stay in Glasgow. Unlike people living, for example, in Oban, we already incur a cost to attend these appointments. Are we to be further penalised because we live on an island?32712019-06-14T16:00:35.41739308Anne MacLeanDone32712019-06-14T16:00:41.66739309Allyson LangthorneWe are penalised heavily for living on an island. Parking charges will increase the already expensive cost of living on Mull. 32712019-06-14T16:10:59.85339310William ArthurIt has been acknowledged that there is a need for some form of parking restrictions at certain locations on the Isle of Mull but to impose such draconian regulations without adequate consultation with those involved is truly undemocratic and lacks understanding. Come forth from your ivory towers you officials and councillors and listen to the people of the islands.32712019-06-14T16:44:24.539311Jeffrey Moore, As an islander, I and family members have to visit the mainland for hospital appointments and have to leave the car at the port, some times for a couple of days. In addition, if visiting Glasgow or Edinburgh, it is more practical to use public transport, which means leaving the car at the port.\r\nIn general, people will park in inappropriate places to avoid charges.32712019-06-14T16:55:0339312Shelagh MedicAs visitors to Mull and Iona in our motorhome I am shocked and disgusted that we will no longer be able to park in Tobermory or for the Iona ferry. If this goes ahead myself and the majority of motorhome owners will be forced to stop visiting, this will have an impact on a lot of island businesses from campsites to shops. If we are not welcome please put a notice In the media instead of punishing the islanders32712019-06-14T16:57:02.92339313Mairi RobertsonCan't believe you give us RET then charge us parking fees.Robbing Peter to pay Paul32712019-06-14T17:05:09.81339314Alexander McLachlan This would surely hurt tourism , and therefore the local communities , stupid greed ridden idea \r\n32712019-06-14T17:54:11.24339315Maureen Smith I could not afford the parking fee \r\nWhen going to the Mainland which \r\nIs frequently. 32712019-06-14T18:13:47.43339316Alan DayI have no objection to paying a parking fee as a tourist, but it is unreasonable to expect the islanders to have to pay. Provide a free permit for islanders that is funded by those visiting the island.32712019-06-14T18:24:17.65339317Rosie Swinbanks the Scottish Islands should always be given added consideration before decisions are made 32712019-06-14T18:43:58.57739318Avril LoweParking charges at Ledaig car park will displace vehicles to the already congested Main Street, or to residential areas, which will impact on residents. There are safety issues with emergency services needing to navigate the main st.32712019-06-14T19:35:55.61739320Hugh Mac InnesA huge NO to parking charges32712019-06-14T19:54:40.9839321Peter HennessCrazy idea, all the surrounding roads will be blocked with camper vans in the summer and the locals will be out of pocket all year long!\r\n Isn't the land owned by the crown anyway?\r\n32712019-06-14T20:04:06.32339322Donald Scott People who live in remote island communities have enough challenges financially and physically without having interference from remote legislatures adding to the problem. 32712019-06-14T20:37:30.6439323Jean WilkinsonIt's expensive enough living on an island. If I need to leave the island I leave my car in the ferry car park but & cannot afford to pay this unfair tax on island residents. 32712019-06-14T21:13:35.70739324Jane menziesThis has been rushed through by the council without them seriously considering the financial effect on the residents. 32712019-06-14T21:35:02.52339325Josephine Austin If heading to Oban for a hospital appointment this is unexacceptable additional cost. 32712019-06-14T21:35:11.91339326Iain ForbesNot fair on all levels.. 32712019-06-14T21:35:28.139327Jane AllanThe tariff of £9 per day is extreme. An hourly rate at reduced rate would be more acceptable but no charge for Iona residents.32712019-06-14T21:40:15.69739328Mandy EaglenThe proposed parking charges will create considerable disadvantage to islanders and to businesses on the island. It is disgusting and shameful that a full island impact survey has not been carried out.32712019-06-14T21:42:09.74339329Denise reganThe council of Argyll and Bute have not listened or have any idea how this island works between the pier at craguire and now the car park fees how do they who do not even live here day to day trying to make in the season enough money for the year when winter is so quite. We mull have not been listened to at all and I feel all of mull should boycot and refuse to pay, how on earth can a worker pay £9 a day and then we're is that extra money coming from its a disgrace and Argyll and Bute should be taken to court over this if we mull took these councillors to court I'm sure we could win 32712019-06-14T21:57:37.27739331Lynne NobleThese parking charges are a tax on island residents. The introduction of RET on the ferries means the ferries are full & we have no choice but to park car to go to hospital app etc. We only have one main food store, which is expensive & will no have to pay to park to do essential shopping unlike mainland who have free parking cheap supermarkets. \r\nBanning camper vans from the car park will force them to use the main st causing dangerous congestion & even close the road. Last year the Main st was blocked for over 40 minutes when a delivery lorry & large camper van were going in opposite directions & could not manoeuvre past each other, with the billed up of traffic one side had to reverse the length of the street .\r\nThis proposal is a short sighted plan by money grabbing council voted in by councillors who are not elected by our Island & have not had the foresite to investigate the situation before voting. \r\nWe have been final given RET on the ferries only to have the benefit taken away by parking charges.32712019-06-14T22:05:39.04339332Michelle Erskine on behalf of The Aarskog Foundation.As a Rare Disease Charity, our patients and families come to Mull regularly, many travelling from across the UK and others from neighbouring Islands or as \r\nfar as the US. Our families would find it unaffordable and not financially viable for them to spend\r\n any time here. Not all disabilities are visible in our Rare Disease community! This proposed TRO will have a huge negative impact for us.32712019-06-14T22:13:13.48339334Barbara AtkinsonI have visited Mull & Iona fir 13 + years .\r\nThis scheme would impact on the whine community of both islanders and visitors \r\n. 32712019-06-14T22:16:10.1739335Karen BassHaving lived on Iona for 4 years I am concerned of the hardship this will bring to many, possibly cutting off transport options for some.32712019-06-14T22:46:41.64339336Iain Wardhaugh Find the money elsewhere 32712019-06-14T23:05:52.50739338Alexander MacaulayAn Island tax. We go on a ferry from Craignure. What choice do we have. The councillors involved must be identified and ousted at the publics earliest opportunity. 32712019-06-14T23:36:24.46339339Tim DawsonThese charges will make life really difficult for islanders, particularly those going off island for several days. Many living in the SW of Mull have to use their cars to go to Craignure because there's not a bus for every ferry. Without a car ferry delays can leave one stranded.32712019-06-14T23:38:26.41739340Linda DawsonThis is going to hit islanders hard, particularly those needing long term parking at Craignure and Fionnphort.32712019-06-14T23:54:33.6239341Susan BattyI holiday on Mull & support the ferries, local shops, pubs & cafes please don't drive the tourists away as this would be detrimental for all of the above. Also please take into consideration the devastating effect this would have on all the people who call Mull their home. 32712019-06-15T01:22:01.58339342Morven MacLean Its ridiculous, our town will not cope!32712019-06-15T02:51:12.76739343Denise Regan I find Argyll and Bute council a disgrace to be the cause of destroying people's businesses whom have worked for years Totally wrong in how you all have conducted yourself in ignoring the Isle of Mull 32712019-06-15T07:50:00.77739344Kathryn MaccallumThese are islands whose economy is dependent on Tourism . With Calmac struggling due to an elderly fleet and now charging an exorbitant charging fee tourism and local businesses will be affected . I thought all the Pirates had left the West Coast but I see they have a base at Kilmory . 32712019-06-15T08:22:11.53739345Val slavenLife line for the islanders snd to the economy. Locals should have petmits especially when working and vital supplies will increase its like anothet tax .32712019-06-15T08:26:05.25739346Angus StewartAn ill-considered ransom operation that will exasperate our problems. 32712019-06-15T08:37:35.52339347Ruth Harvey Please reconsider these proposals which appear discriminatory and could have an intensely detrimental affect on island life.32712019-06-15T09:34:58.45339348Brian JonesI am a resident of Mull and feel that the Scottish Government will have let their citizens down if this is not addressed. The amount of support given to the islands in the past will count for nothing if these charges are enforced. It is a LIFELINE issue.32712019-06-15T10:16:31.8239349Andrew TomisonThis charge overnight will make a day trip on foot to oban for most of us 3 times as expensive and no doubt in thd short term cause traffic congestion on the roads in Craignure until the roadside is made no parking as well\r\nThis decision should be reversed32712019-06-15T10:54:37.64739350John WilshireHow on Earth are we as pensioners expected to pay to park our car at Craignure when goig to Oban for Hospital appointments etc.have never heard of this horrendous idea on any other Island.32712019-06-15T11:17:25.21739352Julia Jeffree£9 a day is extortionate and will cause real difficulties for people who choose to cross on ferries as a foot passenger and need to leave their car at the terminal for several days.32712019-06-15T17:22:09.24739354Tracey Campbell Disgusting behaviour from Argyll and Bute Council it should be thrown out life is hard enough on the islands 32712019-06-15T19:15:09.18739355Helen StaceThe islanders of Mull and Iona have presented copious evidence re how bad this is for the islands and it has been totally ignored. Shameful!32712019-06-15T20:09:28.31739356Kirsty BlackhallAs a resident of an island i can safely say that it would be a disaster for all islanders to have to pay for parking at ferry ports. If we need to go to hospital, the dentist or opticians we have no option but to use the car parks available. We don't choose to park there for fun. We need these car parks in order for us to access the same health are facilities as the residents of mainland Scotland. 32712019-06-15T20:12:15.5539357Mrs Wendy LloydAs someone who works from home but has to travel on and off the island for work quite a bit this will seriously restrict my travel options already managed under a tight budget. This is a very counter intuitive idea if wanting to boost island economic activity. 32712019-06-15T20:12:54.48739358Shelagh Reade Island life.. it is different to Mainland living and Argyll and Bute Council should know this. Will be detrimental to all the businesses on Mull and Iona.32712019-06-15T21:51:05.19339359Shona StirlingTotally ridiculous idea ,will cause more problems than it will solve ! 32712019-06-15T22:21:09.63739360Sally CleggNot only will the parking charges deter tourists but they will seriously affect locals. The plan is ill considered and very possibly unworkable. Shame on A&B council.32712019-06-15T23:19:16.28739361Moira MacGilp Westlandplease help us to prevent these unfair charges being imposed on us by A&B council who have not listened to our objections and the reasons 32712019-06-16T11:21:57.24739362Iain Mackenzie As volunteer it worries me that we will struggal to get our vehicals parked if we get a call out! We already struggal for parking as it is! 32712019-06-16T12:01:31.03339363Susan SpreckleyIsland life has its difficulties and sadly the council seems to be hell bent making life even more difficult. I fail to understand why car parking charges are being forced on a community that clearly does not want or need it. 32712019-06-16T14:45:07.03339364Sally Millerintroducing these charges will significantly affect both locals and tourists in a detrimental manner32712019-06-16T15:49:19.1139366Ronald FergusonSupport for lifeline services is crucial for island communities.32712019-06-16T18:17:55.04739367Eileen Bright As regular tourists to the island I expect. To pay for parking. However I think it is so wrong to expect people who live and work on the islands to pay. 32712019-06-17T08:35:11.54339368Deborah Harper We are regular visitors who have a property on the island, we support the community fully and think these charges are disgraceful. The island is becoming a victim of its own success!32712019-06-17T10:00:18.10339373Mary CorbettParking charges will have a massive impact on our fragile island communities. People trying to survive on lower incomes will find visits to Oban impossible. We already pay so much more for our basics of food and fuel due to cost of delivery. The parking charges will affect tourism and everyone will try to park elsewhere to avoid paying, resulting in parking chaos and dangerous situations. The council should be trying to support us, not damaging the delicate balance of our economy.32712019-06-17T11:35:59.99739375Sheila McraeThe charges at the car park at Fionnphort are unfair as visitors must park there as they cannot take them on the ferry 32712019-06-17T12:00:56.18739376steve daviesI have to go off island a lot to attend appointments and on many occasion stay overnight and the parking cost would be prohibitive.32712019-06-17T13:58:25.06339377Ruth CameronI am a native of Mull and Just because I do not live there anymore I want to support the ones that do ,as I know things like this ludicrous scheme will bring to islanders. Governments have not idea the impact will have especially when tourists are involved as well .People will just stop coming and then where will thing's be . Are the government going to subsidise locals for loss of earnins! I don't think so . Every decision that is made has an impact on everyday island living which can be hard enough without these do gooders trying to get brownie points!32712019-06-17T13:58:45.09339378ANNMARIE WELLSMy family live on Mull and will have a detrimental affect on their lives.This charge is an outrageous tax on the people of Mull and should be cancelled forthwith.32712019-06-17T14:16:20.839380Ruth CameronAs a native of Mull i know the impact this will have on the island and the people that live there messing with there everyday lives, it's disgusting and the so called powers that be have not got a clue!\r\nSomeone is obviously trying to score Brownie points here are they not !32712019-06-17T14:26:27.2439381Laura woodDoes the government not get that the more they charge for parking and fairs the less people will come visit leading to poverty in the area and business closures32712019-06-17T14:41:10.86739382Stan MacMillan These suggestions appear to take no account of the needs and situation of those who live and work on the islands, nor on the impact of businesses that need visitors. Penalising island residents and visitors on Mull and Iona32712019-06-17T14:41:53.67739383Jacqueline DalyDisgusting behaviour of the Argyll and Bite councillor s Living on Mill is already a lot more expensive than the mainland and to pay 9£for parking is disgusting when we have no other choice32712019-06-17T20:24:59.33739384Christian MacleanTravelling to Iona by public transport us impossible for most people in the Highlands. I live relatively close to Inverness but the bus timetable to Oban means that it is impossible to reach or return from Iona in a day. My brother runs a successful eco hostel there, and I often work on Iona. I have no option but to travel by car. This move penalises people who don't have other options but more importantly, will put off tourists already concerned at the high travel costs to get there. His will impact directly on islanders struggling to run businesses in a remote rural location.32712019-06-17T20:25:28.9939386Elspeth MacArthurAs a grand daughter of Iona I appreciate, and strongly support, the need for the islanders to be able to sustain their livelihoods - threatened by this completely unthought through proposal. 32712019-06-17T20:52:08.4539387Ann Evans It is already more expensive and more difficult when living on an island and any hospital appointments etc will mean an much greater cost for people who can ill affford ir32712019-06-18T08:14:38.02339390Hylda MarshWe have a shop at on the Main st with 3 staff who all drive and live out of town.32712019-06-18T09:24:16.06739392Steve HankinsonThese extra charges can have a drastic negative effect on visitors and the community. We need to show a welcome not another cost.32712019-06-18T13:14:11.5839393Karen HowdenDetrimental to local trades and businesses, including day trippers. Further increases costs for locals to live on an island. 32712019-06-18T15:46:25.04339394Helen DewarA sure fire way to ensure the island population dies off in record time.\r\nYet another reason for young people with families not to live here. Not only is there no housing for people wanting to move here but now the people that do live here are being charged to come to work every day or to do their shopping. \r\nWhy spend a fortune on surveys asking how to encourage young people to live and stay in Argyll and Bute and then give them less and less reason to want to. Ridiculously bad management.32712019-06-18T18:05:02.7639395Stuart DavidsonA total lack of consideration by the council in terms of Islander Impacts that demonstrates why the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 was required !\r\n32712019-06-18T22:32:21.2639396Jo HollandThis is an ill-conceived idea and will bring much harm to so many people who depend on tourists for a living.32712019-06-19T00:12:18.06739399Kirsty FisherRidiculous! 32712019-06-19T00:36:55.79339400Jana McLellan The suggested parking charges would have a very negative impact on our fragile island community. Already we have fewer tour bus groups and fewer cruise ships coming to Iona and last year the island economy was 10% down.. Visitors are not allowed to bring cars to Iona, so they have no choice, but to leave their cars in Fionnphort... It would have a huge financial impact on seasonal staff as well. For hospital- and other appointments and to visit our children in Oban Highschool we have to sometimes take the car and leave it in Craignure. The busses don't connect with all the ferries- especially not in winter time... \r\n32712019-06-19T01:49:58.14739402Mike SeymourThis may be seen as a convenient revenue generator but no one is thinking it through.. The Impact to every day supplies and food stuffs let alone local port business affects the islands inhabitants first and secondly The travel and tourism\r\nof essential visitors to the region. \r\nI have worked in travel and tourism for many years handling national tourist boards here and abroad and seen the 'turn off' effects of parking charges. 32712019-06-19T06:19:58.02739403Jayne Charnock This decision if it goes ahead will decimate a fragile community 32712019-06-19T06:38:12.4239404Michelle Mcewan Outrageous decision by councillors to vote this into action. If allowed too ago ahead, I am convinced it will have a devastating affected on the Islands economy and Place a further strain on islanders. 32712019-06-19T07:48:48.47339405Jane Fowler These changes will have a drastic effect on locals and visitors alike. At a time when we want to boost the economy in rural areas this is a very negative step to take. 32712019-06-19T08:14:29.8739406Mary DuncansonAs a regular visitor, I often stay for a few days. Apart from adding to the cost of my stay, I would be expected to come over to Mull from Iona on a daily basis to pay the daily parking charge incurring further expense with a daily return ferry fare. These charges are ludicrous and will have a detrimental effect on the island economy 32712019-06-19T08:30:03.239407Iain Thomson The parking charges are not good news for the island. It has become a cash cow for A and B council. 32712019-06-19T08:52:32.37339408Diana GrahamUnfair tax on Islanders to be able to live their lives 32712019-06-19T09:09:41.97339409Sandy MacQueen Parking charges at ferry ports will harm visitors and locals alike and damage island life.32712019-06-19T10:10:46.83739410Ruth CameronSomeone is looking for brownie points again! and obviously have no idea how this will affect everyday living on an island it's disgusting!32712019-06-19T10:33:55.8639411Duncan FindlayWe need to promote the island as a wonderful place to visit. This will put visitors off and unfairly punish residents.32712019-06-19T10:39:06.51339412Marie O'BrienIt is appalling that the increase in charges will potentially prevent visitors to the Isle of Iona as well as being a further stealth tax on those who live there. I would urge a rethink on this as a matter of urgency and that the decision makers serve the people the say they represent.32712019-06-19T10:45:39.98739413Kate HinchliffeSolo visit in 2016...will not visit again because of charges32712019-06-19T11:55:41.05339414Kirsty FisherRidiculous charges that will harm a rural economy.32712019-06-19T12:55:18.51739415Sarah Dorrian Please listen to the island community on this one, they understand the impact better than anyone and would be the ones who have to shoulder the negative impact these proposed charges would bring. Changes should benefit a community and if they are telling you this would be a bad change, please listen and act on their voice. Elected parties ought to be representing the community.32712019-06-19T14:42:37.0139416Duncan FinlaysonThe Scottish Government must appreciate that allowing these charges to go ahead, at ferry terminals, flies in the face of all their initiatives to encourage tourism in rural areas.32712019-06-19T15:25:46.28739417Anne CrosbyDisgracful attitude by the council.32712019-06-19T17:37:08.03339418Liz WilsonStop this nonsense and think about the bigger picture.32712019-06-19T22:34:16.7939419Maggie ThomsonPlease drop this utterly ridiculous plan!32712019-06-19T23:30:33.4439421Susan Ann FairbairnCharges will make life difficult for long term Iona residents.32712019-06-19T23:44:28.03739422Marion BrownPlease think about locals who already struggle to make ends meet.32712019-06-20T10:23:27.5539423DONNA BROWN ITS GOOD TO SEE SOMEONE PETITION ABOUT THIS OFTEN OVERLOOKED CONDITION. I HAVE PERSONAL EXPERIENCE OF THIS AND AM STILL FIGHTING FOR PROPER TREATMENT DESPITE HAVING A 10MM ADENOMA31172019-06-20T21:01:40.90739425Frances Anne NixonVictims often go unheard, ignored, die or suffer life changing effects. They often do so unnecessarily as many know of their plight but say and do nothing. 33102019-06-21T10:25:04.42339426Frances Anne NixonTotally agree with petitioner. Education to raise awareness should be part of our national curriculum. 33072019-06-21T10:42:06.20739427Frances Anne NixonWithout legal knowledge the fine details of background are beyond my full understanding. However, what petitioner asks for seems very reasonable to myself and is summarised well in the last paragraph of the petition which I support.33032019-06-24T11:28:13.58339429Karen SmithEssential Tremor is the most common adult movement disorder but there is little awareness of it. 31562019-06-24T12:19:25.4739432Allan Bagley Signed and shared 31562019-06-24T12:42:39.15739433Ian StewartHelp those who are disadvantaged31562019-06-24T12:50:47.3539434Peter J. FANNINGThis is a very worthwhile petition that I support wholeheartedly.31562019-06-24T12:53:06.36739435Nicola Mirk a family member has this condition 31562019-06-24T13:36:58.4239436Rosalind Donnelly This needs to be put out there 31562019-06-24T13:40:25.85339437Kathryn Faulkner All illnesses deserve attention and treatment 31562019-06-24T14:08:24.04339438Alison Cuthbert Tiny amount of money required for such relief for sufferers of this condition.31562019-06-24T15:48:59.71339439Susan M ForbesIt is important to raise awareness of essential tremor in Scotland and to provide up to date research based treatment for those diagnosed with this condition. The more treatment options that are available the better for patients concerned. 31562019-06-24T17:09:35.52339440Thomas Harvey Please give the equipment so people can have a better standard of life 31562019-06-24T18:29:03.55339443Hazel WrightThis would be of Benefit to family members as it would appear to be a hereditary condition through a common Grandparent.31562019-06-24T20:30:29.09739444Norman MackayShould be available to all 31562019-06-24T20:42:19.08739445fiona WylieSo much wasted money on Brexit and wealthy privileged - please give some thought to those who have illness and poverty - to enhance their quality of life. Our NHS is incredible - lets not destroy it but hope it may be funded to provide Essential Tremor equipment. Thoughts to the family xx31562019-06-24T20:49:39.0439446Ray Smith Please grant this equipment so anyone effected can have a better quality of life31562019-06-24T21:00:06.5139447Anne Mitchell I support this 31562019-06-24T22:10:42.0539448Mrs Melanie mcginnesI work for NHS Scotland and have a colleague what has severe tremors and would benefit as well as many others for this in Scotland.31562019-06-25T00:15:51.45739449William RyanThis needs to be granted it's a no brainer 31562019-06-25T07:42:52.20339450William Martyn If the NHS, save 30k because an invasive operation is surplus to requirements, surely £10k as an investment for everyone. 31562019-06-25T12:21:17.88339451Trish Chappell Myself and family memebrs live with this condition. I am on long term medication which helps but other family members cannot take the medication and their tremor is so bad that it is very difficult to even take a drink from a cup. They could benefit from treatment if this machine was purchased and hopefully it would enable them to carry out all activities of daily living, independently.31562019-06-25T15:51:50.42339452Laura IrvineHaving spoken to someone who suffered frm this condition for a long time and who fought for treatment, it seems that raising awareness could alleviate a lot of suffering AND reduce costs in the long run.31172019-06-25T18:24:13.88739453Keith Davidson I've had an essential tremor for more than 10 years and it has a massive impact on my life at work and at home. Anything that can help I'm all in favour off.31562019-06-25T19:00:47.0939455Ronald CaiePromoting a worthwhile cause31562019-06-25T19:42:38.31339456Donald MacDonaldPlease make this available so people can have a better quality of life.31562019-06-26T10:58:56.80339457Jackie FarrellI too have Essential Tremor for over 45yrs and understand the daily difficulties and a need for this disorder to be taken more seriously with FUS as a treatment. I raise awareness of this neurological disorder and also Support group coordinator for National Tremor Foundation 31562019-06-27T00:04:12.2939458Charlotte Cassidyi agree with this 100%. i lost my dad to suicide when i was 2 years old, then when i was 17 my bestfriend took his own life. And me myself has tried to take my own lifeI but i believe if we were taught about our mental health it would have helped sooo much. Maybe if i knew the signs to look out for before now i could have helped my friend. I recently completed safe talk and i would recommend it for anyone 15+ as there is so many young people believing suicide is the only option. Its time we gave them understanding and knowlege and Hope about their mental health as it's just as importnant as their physical health. 33072019-06-27T00:33:59.65339459Suzanne oharePlease invest in our youth 33072019-06-27T10:54:06.37739461margaret dundaspleasure to sign31562019-06-27T11:26:15.30339462Karen Mckeown The amount of suicide is unacceptable. It time the government started to listen and give our youth a chance. I urge the government to carry out a full review of the mental health services. For more awareness is school starting from primary school. Enough is enough and action is needed. 33072019-06-28T12:14:05.4739463James A MackieThis Petition applies to child protection procedures . Applications to take children into care are not made under oath therefore no action can be taken against them when there is hard evidence that the submission misleading information and lies. 11500 children in Scotland are in care because of the total lack of accountability. Social work records are full of negativity, deliberate misinformation and lies, records that families cannot challenge. These records remain for the life time of the family and are reused many times. Childrens Hearings have no training or powers to take action when they are presented with lies.33112019-06-29T10:13:59.85739464Margaret-Anne MacArthurThank you for this petition to Educate and raise awareness and and that help and support us available.33072019-06-29T11:24:45.85339465Judith EasthamI agree that it is important to raise awareness of Essential Tremor it affects thousands of people. Impacts on their daily lives and in severe cases prevents them from working.\r\nAwareness could be achieved through the media, TV , Radio, Newspapers and magazine articles. Also National Tremor Foundation pop up stalls at public events.\r\nIt would be greatly beneficial to Scottish ET sufferers to have a focused ultrasound scanner available in Scotland.I feel it would be a way forward in delivering good treatment for Scottish sufferers.\r\nIt would benefit the patient and NHS, the patient would not be required to travel to London,( the only focused ultrasound scanner to the best of my knowledge in the UK) traumatic in itself, they would also remain under the care of the Scottish medics responsible for delivering their treatment. The Scots medics would not be reliant on a report, they would have total control of the treatment delivered to their patient.31562019-06-29T13:31:13.60739466Maria PakpahanThe world need to support this petition as the youth are everywhere.The Scottish Parliament can start this effort and must do so.33072019-06-30T15:30:19.48339467Edna WillaimsonUrgent support is required for young adolescents who struggle with issues in life. Please please make a difference!33072019-07-01T00:13:53.65339468Claire Campbell More needs to be done to prevent suicide33072019-07-01T07:28:38.78739469Joanne DonaldThis could save lives. What could be more important or worthwhile? Incorporate into the curriculum and give young vulnerable people much needed early intervention 33072019-07-01T07:55:06.60339472Alison ClarkeWe need this done urgently, to help stop this epidemic stealing our loved ones.33072019-07-01T10:48:07.32339473Karen Hannigan It is time to take action. We need to support the next generation. Services should be readily available and waiting times need to be drastically reduced. 33072019-07-01T16:31:12.30739474Harriet Noden We must help our young people and stop this epidemic of suicides 33072019-07-01T17:18:01.339475Helen FlanniganSomething needs to be done and quickly as it is getting way out of hand. Every suicide opens up raw wounds for families left behind. We relive that day all over again.33072019-07-01T18:15:30.52739476Jody stevensSomething has to change, our young people deserve more support, they need more support. Being put on waiting lists where there is no indication of time before being given the help they so desperstely need after opening up and asking for help is a devastating 33072019-07-01T18:26:06.21339477Lucia ScottThis, unfortunately, does not surprise me. To put things into perspective, the cost of giving someone therapy compared to lifelong medication (If suicide did not happen) is probably a lot less in the long-term. This is is something that the health services don't appear to look at. I have been through the system myself and I don't have faith in the way they treat mental health sufferers. The medication is great most (not all) days and this appears to be me for life now. 33072019-07-01T20:23:01.53339478Fiona Mclaughlan I am really upset that so many of my friends children are taking their lifes like this we have to do more to and think that it is cocaine they are taking and think that a large percentage of the kids are dpressed because of it the government has to step in and stop needless lifes being destroyed in such a small area 33072019-07-01T21:02:59.4339479Fiona Lawrie Time for change time to talk time to listen and most importantly time for action.33072019-07-02T13:15:59.0139480Tracey O'ConnorMake sure the kids who then grow up into adults know.\r\nTheres always someone to talk to.\r\nNobody should feel alone.\r\nSoo important.\r\nThis could save a life. 33072019-07-02T19:16:10.45739481Maria HoughtonThey have to put there money where there mouths are33072019-07-02T21:40:24.66339482Janice fordSomething needs to be done before another young person takes their own life 33072019-07-03T22:04:47.9839483Melissa Cowan Too many kids taking there own lives there needs to be more help out there drop in centres opened 24 hrs 33072019-07-04T04:27:48.3839485William mitchellNo words 33072019-07-04T06:48:08.05339486Susanne YoungUrgent action is needed, this is becoming a horrific epidemic33072019-07-04T07:06:35.38339487Kerri starkThis needs attention. To many people have died because of their mental health 33072019-07-04T09:55:22.63739488Mary flanniganAn information service like this will save lives and allow young people the chance to discuss suicide openly 33072019-07-04T13:19:01.33739489Karen CherryI support the very worthwhile needed cause 33072019-07-04T18:50:49.85739490Jackie Robertson Needs urgent attention too many suicides 33072019-07-04T22:48:29.539491Joy MitchellA more comprehensive approach must be taken. Suicide is not always or even mostly as a consequence of a diagnosable mental health condition. Being bullied, shunned and ignored, lacking sense of purpose and seeing no positive future, are all reasons behind suicides especially in young people. This is not only a mental health crisis, it is a societal disaster.33072019-07-05T01:22:39.239493Tracy hallHow many more young people have to die?33072019-07-05T08:15:37.8839494Louise springIt is time suicide stopped being seen as a rare act that only happens to other people and dealt with as the common and often preventable close to leading cause of death in some demographics that it actually is. People stick to the former as suicide makes them feel distinctly uncomfortable - the way to change that is open discussion and the reduction of stigma. 33072019-07-05T15:02:01.54339495Mairi Patterson It's more people we need to invest time and provide confidentiality for young people with suicidal thoughts and other problems, I've been there myself but never had any help like this and I've made it this far. People need to know when they talk, we'll be there to listen.33072019-07-05T15:21:06.5339496Edith Gray MackellarUrgent action needed33072019-07-05T16:43:16.93339497Lizz HigginsSomething needs to change URGENTLY!!!33072019-07-05T19:48:24.339498Grace Gracie There should be no delay in actioning this when there are lives at stake.33072019-07-05T20:56:43.4539499Fiona Ford My daughter took her life 4 weeks ago through society and the NHS failing her again something had to be done urgently it's became an epidemic so sad the amount of children and young ones taking their own life's 33072019-07-06T00:58:57.06339500Barry GaleI have experience as a Party Litigant in Mental Health Tribunals, the Sheriff Court and Court of Session. I felt that my evidence, arguments and research were not taken seriously because I did not have professional status. For example, I cited case law regarding the treatment of opinion evidence from expert witnesses ('The Ikaria Reefer'). The court said that I had misunderstood the case law, but did not explain what the error was and what the correct interpretation is. It stated that there was no merit at all in my case. Only one of the 3 judges on the bench wrote the decision, although I had paid for the time of all three. In another hearing the Sheriff Principal asked my opponent, the solicitor for the Mental Health Tribunals, what was the correct interpretation of the law which I was citing, rather than consult the legal handbook for the Tribunals.33032019-07-06T06:50:50.68339501Suzanne Dunbar How many more lives must be taken? Educate and show people support 33072019-07-06T07:18:54.2839502Beverly Cornbill This is urgent 33072019-07-06T08:59:54.1739503Peter Mitchell Its soo sad that soo many of our young men and women see suicide as their only option..More help is needed to help tackle the causes and provide support to prevent our kids young friends ending their own lives.33072019-07-06T10:49:37.3239504Davina LockhartUrgent action required33072019-07-06T12:05:25.50339505Danielle PollockMental health is not dealt with properly, and we need to focus more on it, we lose too many people to suicide, young and older, we're not doing enough to stop this.33072019-07-06T14:56:58.77739506Maureen cathcartOur young people are crying out for help, please listen33072019-07-06T17:03:30.60739507Daniel James gallacherProvide a mandatory mental health first aid course for all education sectors. 12 hours minimum 33072019-07-07T00:58:12.25739509Jacqueline NisbetLost a very close family member to suicide so am right behind this campaign.33072019-07-07T09:28:25.32739510Michael RichardsonThis is absolutely crucial. Far too many young people become victims of suicide33072019-07-07T13:09:13.62739511John Brown Prevention and awareness will save lives. 33072019-07-07T15:07:24.0839512Terry MccullochPlease make this a priority,, as I believe we are in the middle of a suicide epidemic, and it's heart breaking to see broken families and friends left with no answers. 33072019-07-07T20:02:34.09339514Sarah Simms I lost my beautiful son Ben to suicide in August 2018 it has destroyed me more help information and awareness around suicide and mental health is a MUST 33072019-07-09T14:33:07.84339517Eunice BrownPlease..this is happening to too many young ones these days...hear them and help them... 33072019-07-09T22:37:52.76739518Kevin RushfordThe self-right to litigate and defend disputes is a fundamental right and should exist for all without the inherent bias, prejudice and exclusion that exists to date. There is a misconception that solicitors & advocates know what they are talking about and this is more pertinent and observant when matters are technical and outside the knowledge of the legal profession. Solicitor & advocate fees are an extortion and thus prohibit access to justice substantively. The legal monopoly by the few against the many must be overthrown, over-ruled and abolished as the legal profession are subsidised by an annual SLAB amount of circa £150 million. Which other industry gets such a charitable hand out?33032019-07-10T07:00:04.43339519Julie Carr Too many young people especially men are losing their lives to suicide and we need to make sure support is available to stop this happening 33072019-07-11T00:36:27.739520L.M.GreenAn absolute must to build trust of council within community. Nothing to hide... so be transparent, let the constituents decide...33172019-07-11T12:06:25.94739521Gemma HaughToo many young people are crying out for help. Support is a must to stop this from happening. 33072019-07-11T12:15:06.24339522cheryl fordSave lifes33072019-07-11T12:47:31.2539523Gayle Slowey The lack of provision for support in Mental Health for our young people in Scotland is shocking. It is also extremely difficult to access the services that are currently available. The government needs to wake up and take a good hard look at the issues affecting our young people.33072019-07-11T14:09:42.44739525Pamela LawToo many lives are lost to suicide, more support is needed to help. 33072019-07-11T14:55:01.9139526Louise WelshHuge lack of awareness and huge reluctance to learn about it or even accept the existence of PDA. Honestly, it has been like I've used a swear word in polite company when I've said the words "pathological demand avoidance." I have had to handle professionals who should know their jobs with kid gloves, referring obliquely to demand avoidance and inviting them to use strategies that I personally find helpful for family members (ie pda strategies!). Eventually they see for themselves that pda strategies have the best chance of success but much distress for family member could have been avoided if they'd just been on board from the start. A PDA toolkit would be useful if it legitimised PDA in the minds of these professionals. They view me with suspicion, like I'm overprotective and asking for special treatment for family member. Well, perhaps I am but for good reason - they need special treatment in an unfriendly world and the team around them should provide that for them where possible and not shuffle their feet and change the subject. Teachers have been particularly averse to pda strategies saying things like "we don't believe in pda we treat all our children as individuals." Involvement must come from people with PDA themselves, adults, teens and children, and their parents and siblings. Also please involve Yvonne Newbold who advises on SEND VCB (violent and challenging behaviour). PDA does not cease to exist just because some teachers and social workers are afraid to step outside of their little comfort zones. 33182019-07-11T15:07:54.17339527George McCannFamilies need a proper diagnosis so proper support can be implemented and not the current one size fits all.33182019-07-11T16:13:43.1139528Lynne ShoreyVery little training and knowledge of professionals in the Borders33182019-07-11T16:35:39.62339529Beth MorrisonWe need this approach in Scotland to make sure that education staff have the right tools, skills and expertise in understanding behaviour as a means of communication for children with PDA (Pathological Demand Avoidance). The strategies involved in supporting kids with PDA will help all children but children with ASD conditions and PDA are most in need. At the moment, staff lack the expertise to understand the physical, emotional and sensory challenges of these complex children and resort to methods of control like exclusion, restraint and seclusion in an effort to "manage" these children. This is a reactive strategy and it does not work. The child is always seen to be the "problem" when actually the child is communicating distress due to unmet needs. Instead staff must work pro-actively to avoid distress and anxiety happening in the first instance. Happy children with the right support do not challenge. Well done to the ladies for bringing this to your attention, our children deserve this.33182019-07-11T16:44:55.7839530Elizabeth YoungsonSigned33072019-07-11T16:51:02.56739531Lynne mckenziePda needs to be recognised all over and supports given and training on it. 33182019-07-11T17:43:40.1239533Moira Byers Woman should have the right to decide about our own bodies 33212019-07-11T19:28:22.7539536Fred bumbleI really want you to take heed of disabilities and to involve those with All disabilities. I want you to include us in your policies and take our needs into account. PDA is just as important while at present, authorities can't even understand and involve those with ASD!33182019-07-11T20:35:54.8739537Caroline Cunningham Awareness saves lives33072019-07-11T20:46:59.6239538Kirsten StadeA woman has a right to have her uterus removed, no questions asked! It is not anyone else's business. It is absolutely incomprehensible that any woman, let alone one suffering this much, would be denied necessary medical treatment. 33212019-07-11T23:53:33.3539539Christin Starling1. Yes\r\n2. Awareness that PDA is a real condition, better understanding of it, and tools for both parents and professionals. \r\n3. Psychologists, therapists, adults and children with PDA, and parents of children with PDA. 33182019-07-11T23:56:47.94339540MAURA LEEplease ensure parents and carers are involved as we are the true experts!33182019-07-12T01:13:41.80739541Jane GriceHave not managed to get a diagnosis via NHS as was told it is not on their list of conditions.\r\nTeaching those suffering and their relatives how to manage the condition, and general understanding.\r\nThe toolkit should be developed by experts and those with the condition and their carers.33182019-07-12T08:14:28.6339543Sandra NicollThis is happening much too often to our young people and is heartbreaking for all involved33072019-07-12T10:56:12.57739544Jo Gillespie Free Country? The Right to Choose must be there. 33212019-07-12T12:40:37.16739545Luz Mery Rueda PinzónDebe primar la salud del paciente.33212019-07-12T13:57:12.42739546Tanya jewellFemale incontinence is a problem that has been normalised and accepted. With education early on women will be able to prevent potential future incontinence but this is such a taboo subject nobody is talking about it. Get the information out there early on xx32912019-07-12T16:44:22.57739547Joan Beattievery worthwhile campaign, saw it on breakfast TV this morning, info needed for all women not just new mothers32912019-07-12T17:25:06.14339548Silvia Palma1) Yes - took a long time to get the right help (repeating same story, not being believed, being forced to try wrong strategies and then blamed for them not working). Still being told "to be firmer" with family member even though they have a diagnosis. Even if people know the diagnosis, they don't understand what that means in practice. What teachers learn about handling children has exacerbated problems as it seems to be the opposite of what works for kids with PDA\r\n2) Better understanding and acceptance of how PDA affects people (rather than constant judgement on how its someone's "fault"). Correct strategies at an earlier stage would have saved a lot of heartache (as well as time an money for the system)\r\n3) Best strategies I use tend to be from PDAers, parents and a few skilled professionals (those with direct experience of correctly supporting PDA'ers)33182019-07-12T20:03:07.9139550Rachel McWattieAs there is no official diagnosis of PDA in Scotland it is often talked around rather than directly. As a professional working with Autistic learners in the education system, I often use the term anxiety driven need to avoid demand. If diagnosis was clearer it would allow the Ed psych teams to lead training and education and increase confidence in discussion, which would undoubtedly improve the outcomes for these young people.33182019-07-12T21:36:01.14339552ANNE COMRIEHaving children over 40 years ago at which point post natal classes in hospital after birth gave new ,young mums all the help and advice and instructions required. Current problem is no such post natal care seems to be available. This situation is really quite scandalous. Our health care has deteriorated in this area as in so many others. Surely post natal care should be part of pre natal care. AND certainly should not just be a leaflet in a box. Saddened by this regression of care.32912019-07-13T02:43:19.9739553Lesley J WalkerAll too many women think that leaks after childbirth are to be expected and tolerated without realuzing there is a lot that can be done and reliance on pads is not the only answer.32912019-07-13T08:19:04.3539554Ceri lloyd All of them absolutely appalling ! Needs to be recognised in DSM 33182019-07-13T08:29:01.4939555Kenny DrysdaleI am very concerned that there is no register for children, no method of assessment, no level of attainment required, and minors are being denied access to education and a basic human right. 33162019-07-13T09:27:41.6439558Dr Ruth Jones PhD MCSP This is really important to help women stop being incontinent and ensure they're assessed. sometimes the pelvic floor can work too etc. 32912019-07-13T12:58:40.5339561Esmée van VeldhovenI've been fighting for a hysterectomy for three years now, I'm 23. People keep telling me "to understand the doctor's perspective" but this is not a matter of different perspectives: it is a gender issue. Refusing a hysterectomy because of someone's age or the risk of them changing their mind about having children later is paternalistic and sexist. We're stuck in an outdated system that still puts fertility above a woman's actual well-being and it's time to change that. There is a great paper on the ethics behind this: Sex in Medicine: What Stands in the Way of Credibility? by Mari Mikkola. \r\n\r\nStay strong! Good luck with everything!33212019-07-13T14:20:40.35339562Julia Grant If its recognised early kids know it's not shameful or embarrassing to suffer from this debilitating illness. Save our kids before it's too late33072019-07-13T16:32:48.71339563Lesley LeishmanSomething needs done.Too many children and young people being failed by the system.33182019-07-13T20:04:28.0139564Drew Smith Suicide and in particular teenage suicide is becoming an epidemic. All assistance including education must be given to stop anymore suicides.33072019-07-13T21:43:51.65339565Elizabeth JohnstonWe need to help young people to be able to talk about what is going wrong in their lives and know that there places for them to go 33072019-07-13T21:47:19.85739566Samantha YoungMore needs to be done for vulnerable people suffering33072019-07-13T23:42:42.07739568Isabel McCuethis is a very serious matter and needs the Government to really look at it and act33072019-07-14T00:16:50.9439569Geraldine kearneyTo many young people within or society taking there own lives33072019-07-14T00:40:02.97739570Gillian ToshBy recognising PDA it has changed a family member's and family's life. They are finally supported in education.Recognising this earlier and giving compulsory measures to put support in to education system mental health issues could have been avoided and the stress it caused on the whole family. Another family member has also suffered due to the lack of support and I can not get them the support they need because they struggle to trust people now as feel let down. Our family were badly let down and nothing can change the damage it caused.It could be different for others with understanding and correct support \r\n\r\nI'm not sure there is enough understanding from local professionals.Few understand but the clinical psychologist my family member has seen that understands alot should be involved and those that show they can work well with PDA strategies \r\n\r\nSome parents have a good knowledge and obviously those with PDA themselves 33182019-07-14T07:49:30.34739571Thomas Newmann Everyone has a place on this earth. 33072019-07-14T08:26:41.41339572Fiona LaffertyMuch more help and info must be available 33072019-07-14T09:23:20.12339573Moira LoveWe must do all we can to prevent these unspeakable tragedies33072019-07-14T11:18:09.71739574Lee ArnoldLack of awareness and ignored due to funding its over looked. Our kids need help at a early age disgusting when mps claim for second homes expenses payrises etc then cut out budgets when we need it. Should be ashamed of themselves lining up there own pockets. 33182019-07-14T12:06:30.19739575Rebecca BlackProfessionals who support the families of children with diagnosis of PDA need to know more about this condition and the impact it has on family relationships. Funding to support the parents of children would support child and adult mental health and well-being in Scotland.33182019-07-14T14:20:35.85739577Brooke saxby Keep on going! 33182019-07-14T14:27:59.60739578Fiona BrookI can only imagine what you must go through Megan. Having had ovarian cancer and spent a spell in a gynae ward I have so much sympathy for women with endometriosis. The infantilising way medical staff talk about 'preserving fertility' without any engagement with patients as adult women who might not want children, is abhorrent. You're doing such a good thing.33212019-07-14T18:41:39.53339579Ruth Craxton1) It took 5 years and 3 referrals to eventually get an inaccurate diagnosis of ASD, which was then expanded to 'with extreme anxiety and avoidant behaviour'. Despite family member's PDA having been made a 'finding in fact' at the Court of Session in 2018, they are STILL not supported and not one of the professionals involved in their 'care' have any understanding let alone knowledge of PDA. It is pathetic.\r\n2) how can a professional possibly adequately support a person if they have no understanding or knowledge of the person's condition? So, obviously, having a toolkit would help. Help and support that is rooted in understanding and knowledge of PDA would be incredibly beneficial. Help and support that is not based in PDA is incredibly detrimental and has life long negative consequences.\r\n3) adults with PDA should be at the centre of developing the toolkit, along with professionals who have direct experience in managing PDA.33182019-07-14T19:13:00.92739580Carly stewartTo any professional.Please support familys with children or family with pda just like any other type of autism.The pda community are in crisis and desperatly need support from the nhs and and many other professionals. 33182019-07-14T20:13:1639581Mandy MitchelmoreFamily member has suffered dreadfully due to undiagnosed PDA. They have a complex and rare neurological condition and epilepsy and has always showed strong characteristics of PDA. Being without a diagnosis of autism of any description till they were 16 has meant that they have been misunderstood for 10 years in education. Hated, demonised, secluded and restrained- we are heartbroken. We were told by CAHMS that they cannot diagnose- but we can use strategies for PDA- to support them- their new school has saved them by adopting this approach but the scars remain. Respected and now a learner they are understood. CAHMS- use an American diagnostic tool that is inflexible and rigid- it doesn't recognise PDA- Nobody can give family member back those years and the stress they and us as a family endured- I welcome this diagnostic toolkit and urge the government to get children's services to get up to speed. 33182019-07-15T00:47:09.00339582Fiona Tunilla These ladies are amazing advocates of every family touched by PDA. with their wealth of experience it should be automatically passed.33182019-07-15T06:56:53.65739583Margaret TaylorIt just makes sense to enable sentient human beings to be able to live better, pain free lives. 33212019-07-15T10:27:08.39339585Amanda FotheringhameMore and more, children are using social media to deal with their problems and seek knowledge, guidance and acceptance, instead of verbalising their needs, concerns and troubles. We need to TALK, they have to know its not 'uncool' to TALK to someone..that its okay to not feel okay sometimes, and that it's okay to VOICE those feelings. Verbal social skills, are becoming non-existent and not the 'norm' which is worrying. How many children and even adults, would rather text or email or 'google' to get answers rather than ask ? Education and speaking about MH is imperative. In schools AND at home !33072019-07-15T11:46:50.94739586Elaine HolmesGreat initiative Elaine! \r\nScottish Mesh Survivors Group support this 100%32912019-07-15T13:39:10.40339589Tracey TurnerFamily member has pda, it's very difficult for specialist to work with this condition let alone help families. There are not any fully qualified people working with this condition and there should be more available for families. I also think pda groups should be planned when families can come together and share the pressures of pda and maybe someone that is qualified in this area. In Rotherham we are all learning together it isn't always helpful and strategies can run out. 33182019-07-15T14:18:13.03339590Michelle Graham Crucially important individuals, families and teachers are in crisis 33182019-07-15T17:14:59.68339592Claire Mooney I support this petition 100% and the ministers should start listening to the petitioners who are active dealing with PDA and are the experts on this matter. 33182019-07-15T19:22:49.8139593Melissa CostinI am British Citizen living in New Zealand. A family member has a private diagnosis of PDA. I strongly urge there be more awareness and resource for this condition of mind. I fully support this petition. 33182019-07-15T20:02:2139594Fiona hardiePlease roll out the diagnosed of pda. I believe family member has this infliction. However it's not being accepted in Inverness. 33182019-07-16T09:00:09.33739595Jayne Scollay Human rights have been taken away! No one should be put into isolation. We are failing so many with disabilities 33182019-07-16T11:49:24.8339596Caroline McCallumSeems ridiculous and arbitrary that an asset, which cannot be sold, should be treated as an asset to fund social care services. 32672019-07-16T16:49:18.6539597Catherine WorrallPlease acknowledge and support appropriately33182019-07-16T17:10:25.01739598Janette Maciver A family should never be forced to sell their family home. This is an exceptionally unfair policy. Hope you get lots of signatures. 32672019-07-16T17:10:25.0639599Louise mc brideThis is vital .......to educate is to save lives 33072019-07-16T18:13:45.66739600Christina macritchie I support this petition 100%32672019-07-16T18:18:37.20739601Michael Keenan Suicide is not an illness but a choice made by an ill individual who wants to cease their own situation 33072019-07-16T18:37:22.0639602Stephen GrayPersonal experience suggests lack of awareness of this contain in CAMHS Scottish Borders and YPU Edinburgh as well as teaching staff and social services33182019-07-16T20:17:08.1639603Pauline Grigor Support this as we been supporting many families in Borders with PDA Profiles.....Education on this and strategies to help families will have a positive impact and ensuring the best outcomes for families 33182019-07-16T21:42:33.54739604Catherine AfrinThis is very unfair 32672019-07-16T22:32:56.4639605George FarlowThis sounds like the worst sort of land grab. Crofting retains people in remote areas. Councils are not supposed to be adding to their asset portfolio but encouraging community development and repopulation of remote and rural areas. There is no long term benefit to a regional council for continued centralisation or allowing further holiday houses.32672019-07-16T22:47:40.83739606Joan CoverleyI think this is a great idea and the timing of the baby box is perfect. \r\n\r\nI find it shocking that we are currently seeing advertising on TV where the young mums refer to leakage being normal. \r\n\r\n\r\nI will maybe complain to ASA about that. \r\n\r\n\r\nIn answer to your questions, I don't know how we can assess the true scale and costs unless some research is done. \r\n\r\nI suspect that embarrassment and being busy are the main barriers preventing women seeking help.\r\n\r\nI think the information should be encouraging. It should recognise that some people have a problem but that while fairly common, it is not 'normal'. They must not be made to feel like a 'failure'. \r\n\r\n I seem to recall that (40 years ago) I followed diagrams in a book, with descriptions of what you should be feeling. Communication experts will know how to present it for today and I think that humour, which you referred to, is important.\r\n\r\n\r\nI wish you well in this important work. \r\n32912019-07-17T05:38:44.74339607Gayle MooreMore needs to be done 33072019-07-17T07:03:30.98339608Anne clewerI hope they let his daughter out and back at home 33182019-07-17T10:22:55.539609Maggie MacdonaldCroft houses and crofts are given and built with a view to passing on to ones child .Council selling them means more air bandb available and lsland will be depopulated32672019-07-17T11:04:52.00739610Catherine RussellHope you will be successful 32672019-07-17T14:00:41.8639613Murdo Fraser Well done John for pursuing this . Hopefully common sense prevails here.32672019-07-17T15:05:21.54339616Denise Murphy This really needs to be put in place all over the UK as thousands of children are not getting the help they desperately need & just being labelled naughty 33182019-07-17T16:25:59.01339617Amanda Crozier I've fought for years with doctors,CAMHS,teachers etc since family member was very young and now a teenager they have been in 2 secure units.I really think they have P.D.A33182019-07-17T17:39:13.86739618Angus MacleodWorthy cause32672019-07-17T21:11:07.67739619Murdo FraserWell done John .32672019-07-17T21:11:54.45739621Anya RaeTotal lack of understanding from professionals regarding this diagnosis 33182019-07-17T21:22:50.6839622Angela mcfarlane This is very important to many people and children lives please sign33182019-07-18T00:13:53.54339623Veronica DaSuch a simple exercise to teach, that if practised regularly every day can really help to prevent the embarrassment and discomfort of stress incontinence32912019-07-18T09:18:32.74739624liz macwhinneyWe need to widen the conversation on suicide and get the message across that suicide is never the answer.33072019-07-18T09:34:36.18739625Rhian keenan I think this is not just something that may help. this is an essential kit to support kids that are being currently failed in the system . a family member is being let down in their current school , there is nothing in place for them to follow . There needs to be clear guidelines on how to support children with PDA , that schools and professionals must follow regardless of whether PDA Is recognised in that area . \r\nParents should be listened to , not dismissed . Collaboration is needed between the education system , medical professionals and parents to achieve the best outcome. 33182019-07-18T12:28:57.0739626Kenny MitchellDepopulating the island by robbing possessions is morally wrong. Yes I understand the funds have to come from somehere but does that mean the person who worked all his life loses everything he worked hard for leaving nothing for their loved ones and the person who didnt work a day in his life and has no possessions is completely covered NO QUESTIONS ASKED. 32672019-07-18T18:44:24.94339630Paula CurranCats need the same recognition as dogs who are hit by cars, cat owners need this now31922019-07-18T19:18:32.14339633Tracy Swandells It causes families no end of sadness and upset when a pet goes missing. It will.not be the news they want to hear, he that their pet has been knocked down but better knowing than continually searching for it for months. 31922019-07-18T22:36:09.2339636Dillip Kumar PatnaikIn recent time, there were few vandalised incidents happened in Edinburgh Hindu temple and gurudwara.31842019-07-18T23:15:33.8639637Dilip SharmaEducate people about worship and tell them that the worship should not be related to religion.31842019-07-19T01:23:20.17739638Catherine JamiesonCats should be given the same status as other domestic animals and important pets31922019-07-19T06:35:58.35339639Sumit GuptaYes, their has been several instances of hate crime in the Edinburgh Hindu Mandir and community centre. To avoid it in future better security arrangements as well as support from the government is required.31842019-07-19T06:54:15.41339640Joyce MacdonaldEvery cat is a family member31922019-07-19T07:11:06.28339641Lynn MillarI wholeheatedly support this petition31922019-07-19T08:51:15.98739642Subhash Naha-BiswasI support the petition31842019-07-19T09:42:27.01739643Kate BellewIf Scotland wants to be a leading country in tackling the climate and biodiversity crises then this would be an excellent positive step forward. 32902019-07-19T09:42:53.1739644Kate KirkwoodUN Sustainable Development Goal ... End hunger, achieve food security and improved nutrition and promote sustainable agriculture.\r\n32902019-07-19T09:54:52.30739645Daniel BrownI agree wholeheartedly to taking forward this holistic and integrated approach to the food production, the environment and public health.32902019-07-19T10:15:57.5639646Abhishek Singhsecurity funding for temple31842019-07-19T10:54:07.1939647Catherine a sneddonLack of awareness and so called professionals not listening to parents cries for help.\r\nThere needs to be a full dementia overhaul of the mental health services and PDA should be recognised throughout. 33182019-07-19T14:03:41.03739649Lorraine MarshallThis would be a positive step to help awareness and educate support workers and carers33182019-07-19T14:07:53.75339650Lorraine MarshallFood is a necessity, not everyone has the means or support to have access to food. It is a human right .32902019-07-19T16:36:12.59339651Philip ChristieBorn and raised in Scotland, staff to 2 cats31922019-07-19T16:50:54.3439652Susan WallsThe more our politicians, professionals and the general public are informed and understand PDA, do something about it, then the more our children, young people and families in Scotland will be understood, properly supported and included in getting it right for children - development of a PDA toolkit will put policy into practice.33182019-07-19T17:15:41.82739653Vicki RobertsMy cats our part of my family & I would want to no if anything happened to them 31922019-07-19T17:35:25.87739654Amanda GarrattyThank you for all your organising. Let's hope that it makes our fur babies safer.31922019-07-19T17:51:02.91739655Tarang ShelatAll places of worship need to be safe, free from violence and threats. Any funding available to secure the building should be given to all faiths.31842019-07-19T18:49:32.71739656Nancy MacAskillUnfair to take a Croft tenancy from a family who have wanted to or already passed on to family which may have been in family for generations 32672019-07-20T08:03:46.95739659Margot russell Cats owners deserve the same respect as dogs owners. Cats are just as much a family member as dogs31922019-07-20T11:40:27.79339660Deborah lawsonTime to get real...so many children are under the radar and nobody cares. Their supposed guardians can say what they want and do nothing...nobody is checking to s33162019-07-20T12:17:05.78339662Shona ScottThis is desperately needed...for everyone and not only those battling a mental illness.33072019-07-20T12:45:30.33339663Debbie AngusOur kitties are not wild animals and deserve the same rights other pets have. All animals do. If anything happened to our boys, I want them back home with us, not in a ditch.31922019-07-20T12:50:53.35739664Mrs Clare ChalmersI think the Care Commission should be called to give evidence over recent reports of unlawful restraint and seclusion. Too many children have suffered as a result, we need to ensure change takes place as quickly as possible so that all practitioners, schools and organisations understand how best to treat children and fully respect their rights. 33182019-07-20T13:42:20.4739665Michael DuckWe need NHSE to stop sending vunerable people into hospitals. This has to stop 33182019-07-20T13:52:00.339666Sam DuckMA family member deserves better and has done nothing wrong. 11 years of their life locked away and family were not fighting then they would be in for many more years. This has to stop33182019-07-20T18:50:16.8139667Sheena WeirSo important 33072019-07-20T19:42:47.56739668Fiona MurrayDefaintly a lack od understanding PDA or recognition in my area so kids are left to struggle and can not be assessed for it so no support and training takes place. \r\nIts needs to change PDA should be diagnosed in all areas..33182019-07-20T20:02:46.58339669Susie Perkins Family member has severe challenging behaviour 33182019-07-20T22:19:16.36339670Patrick McIntyreDone,xxxx33182019-07-20T22:28:51.75739671Edith BryceThere has to be more done, our kids are poorly and nobody is doing anything. It's ok to not be ok , it's a great message but it doesn't help. Get more mental health councillor available, make it known where they are and maybe we can stop these poor kids from thinking that death is their only way to deal with what their going through33072019-07-20T23:08:14.6539672Charlotte DowdsDesparetly needs research and more support right now.33182019-07-20T23:54:46.27339673Nicola Nash I had to move away from moray area due to the mis treatment of family member. This needs looked at on a massive scale, esp when counsellors call for 'these kind of children ' to be put in 'special schools '33182019-07-21T07:32:59.80739674Diana Vettraino Please save our kids, its our duty.33072019-07-21T09:38:20.9839675Kathleen HoodMore help should be readily available to vulnerable young people before they think of taking this most dreadful of decisions 33072019-07-21T09:41:35.939676Pauline mapplebeckI agree with this petition31922019-07-21T10:35:13.17739678Lyn Mason Everyone needs to be well informed so that children get the best possible help. 33182019-07-21T10:58:36.8839679Jillian Dick Act now......... tomorrow is too late!!!!! 33072019-07-21T11:20:38.21339680Elizabeth JohnstonGod help all our young people33072019-07-21T11:48:51.1539681Rakesh SoniSecurity is necessory 31842019-07-21T12:02:51.6239682Ann JohnstoneWithout proper diagnosis of what mental health services refer to as a behaviour profile of autism PDA specific support does not get provided. Family member has already been threatened with exclusion for not coping in a mainstream school in North Lanarkshire but cannot get a place in specialist provision which would enable them to progress according to their abilities as they have no places for all the children who require a different setting to mainstream, another catastrophic Scottish Government policy to presume mainstreaming when some children simply cannot cope there but are punished for their condition affecting their behaviour there. Shame on this Government.33182019-07-21T18:28:17.15739684Mandy MitchelmoreFamily member suffered seclusion and restraint due to a lack of diagnosis- trauma and a lack of understanding.33182019-07-21T20:26:04.23739685Himanshu TripathiTemple security need to be beefed up so that we feel more secure.31842019-07-21T22:06:42.2539686Emma Mitchell I hope this Petition goes through. 33072019-07-21T23:21:43.91739687Rose Connelly More needs to be done to save young lives33072019-07-22T11:16:02.37339691Reetesh Setiain complete support for the petition31842019-07-22T12:15:36.63339692Stefanie HarmsPlease please support these children & families 33182019-07-22T12:32:57.9339693Julie forrest Could benefit many families 33072019-07-22T14:20:18.7939695Shivendra DubeyI support this petition for the Review of hate crime legislation and security funding in Scotland31842019-07-22T17:01:47.239697Cath WallaceWe have children starving in this Country, this must STOP now.32902019-07-22T17:17:11.24739698Bernadette PacittiAs a school teacher, I am seeing an increasing number of young people struggling with their mental health and attempting it or unfortunately being successful in their attempts. There needs to be more done to help these young people.33072019-07-22T17:21:14.3439699Zoe Lawrence Vital this is passed as could save lives.33072019-07-22T17:53:48.06339700cait ni CadlaigPeople did without access to enough food Its as simple as that So therefore it must be written in Statute as a Human Right to have an absolute right to food.32902019-07-22T18:01:32.20739701Marion craigThis is vital for all young people 33072019-07-22T18:14:11.8539703Denise WaltonGood Food Nation with a 'bad food economy' ?? It doesn't stack-up. Making good food fairly produced accessible will drive a Good Food Economy without depleting essential and finite resources. 32902019-07-22T18:34:20.47739705Jane RubensI am signing this petition because I believe the right to good food is a basic right I would like to see that everyone in Scotland has. What I am not sure about is whether legislation can make it happen or whether it is the best way to make it happen. Food banks may be necessary these days but I think it is a retrograde step for the poor to have to go to a church or a public building to get free food. This seems especially true when there is so much food wasted, often by people who have plenty more food or more money to buy more food when some of their food is out of date or no longer appetising. How we sort all of this out seems way out of reach to me. I hope you can come up with helpful concrete plans to make the right to food a legal requirement in Scotland.32902019-07-22T19:17:17.4539706Emma WhithamWe need to stop prioritising food for export and start dealing with basic human rights, like good, healthy nutritious food right now for people in this country.32902019-07-22T20:47:53.83739707Lorraine BuchananThere are too many young people committing suicide. Something needs to be done to prevent this.33072019-07-22T21:04:18.32739708Mrs Julie WilkinsonIn this day and age no one should be short of good food and access to help to provide and prepare it.32902019-07-22T21:39:27.5239710Edward AndrewsIn a just society everyone has access to food. In a caring society this food is nutritious and will lead to better health outcomes\r\n32902019-07-22T21:52:25.03339711Pauline Howieson Time for action to help these poor families. 33072019-07-22T22:00:00.5539712Julie Baxendale This could be a life saver 33072019-07-22T22:33:23.16339713Nicola HinesThey should certainly be exempt.32672019-07-23T07:08:37.61739715Samantha BlackEvery woman should have the right to choose what they do with their body. 33212019-07-23T08:30:59.66339717Christiane McKeownTo have enough good food to live a healthy life which allows a person to live to their full potential is a human right, this has to be enshrined in law32902019-07-23T08:54:15.20339718Gemma Barton A family member took their own life, and these young people need to know how to get help and support. 33072019-07-23T09:14:31.09339719Kirsty DicksonI have lost a much loved cat to a hit &run accident, made worse by someone thinking he was theirs and not getting him scanned so we looked for him for days before their cat came back and they realised their mistake. This could have been avoided had the driver reported the accident. 31922019-07-23T10:05:04.67739720Anne MilneWe all need food, and for the benefit of all, including the economy and the NHS, we need food that is healthy and accessible for everybody. 32902019-07-23T10:20:41.39739721Murray GrahamWell done on all you efforts with this, a cause worth fighting for!32672019-07-23T12:14:11.36739722Carolina CunninghamMy beloved cat was hit by a works van. They just drove off, a wonderful neighbour took it apon herself to take my cat to the Vet, unfortunately Misty didn't survive. I will always be grateful that she gave him a chance and he didn't die alone. 31922019-07-23T12:19:13.63739723Emma InglesWe recently lost our beloved Sky after he was hit by a vehicle. He managed to make it into our garden before he passed away but if they had just stopped and taken him to the vets he might still be with us or at the very least he wouldn't have had to suffer. Dogs have to be reported so why not cats. Sky was bigger than my dog aswell. 31922019-07-23T13:37:02.4439724Fiona mathiesonYour body your choice. If its harming you and you don't need it to live then you should have the option of removing whatever is hurting you. Pretty simple. 33212019-07-23T13:42:11.83339725Vijay KumarAgree with Puneeth as it's an important aspect of public safety.31842019-07-23T16:21:11.46339726Pauline Grigor - Borders Additional Needs Group SCIOBANG SCIO is a charity based in Scottish Borders with over 60 families and a membership of over 250. We have been contacted by families living in Borders with children on PDA profile, and we have 1 confirmed PDA adult. Families are contacting us in crisis with lack of support form health, CAHMS. There are no strategies in place to support the children Unmet needs within this context to the child and thier families is having a significant traumatic affect on the families. We introduced PDA trainign in 2018 and had limited uptake form professionals and there is a significant lack of awareness of PDA profile. Families are isolated and powerless with no support,the result is leaving children being punished for non compliance and often the police are called , the resulting trauma to the child and thier families breaching many disability and equality acts. This must be tackled as a matter of urgency 33182019-07-23T16:38:24.9839727Howard wilkinsonMoving toward a universal opportunity\r\nRegarding healthier food32902019-07-23T19:59:58.35739729Miesbeth knottenbeltThe right to food enshrined in law is the only serious way forward. Please consider doing the right thing whilst we have the opportunity. Thank you.32902019-07-23T21:22:39.0739730Dr. Mrs. Elizabeth Bola OgunlanaEvery person has a right to eat healthy food. In a loving society, access to healthy food should not be difficult to come by. I appeal to the Scottish Government to make the production of healthy food a priority.32902019-07-23T21:52:15.1139731Kerry MorrisTime for action33072019-07-23T21:54:21.56339732Lilian Macdonaldshould be exempt for sure32672019-07-23T23:12:39.1839733karen mckennai have lost a few cats over the years to hit and run drivers. i volunteered with Inverclyde Cat Rescue for nearly 10 years and i had to deal with some horrifically injured and deceased cats during that time. They say its illegal to cause unnecessary suffering and cruelty to an animal but hitting a cat or any animal with a car and not stopping should fall into that category. It should be make a criminal offence 31922019-07-23T23:27:35.2939734Morag AndersonTena culture suggests women should wear pull up nappies or pads at their wedding, festivals or at the gym and this is acceptable? Anything that supports women deserve better should be promoted.32912019-07-23T23:59:11.5839736Karen NeilElaine, Asa member of Scottish Mesh Survivors, I whole heartily back you. \r\nBut I have voiced this many times,we should be educating our Teenagers. We give Sex education,pelvic floor exercise should be include then,too. \r\n32912019-07-24T01:17:28.91739737Anne mitchellHelp support kids with this profile as lack of diagnosing and understanding means these kids are passed from professional to professional n back again with still no support which from personal family experience know this has a very serious probably long lasting affect on these kids mental health 33182019-07-24T07:02:31.8839738Arlene WoodsThis needs to go through - do this for the families!33072019-07-24T09:06:58.60739739Donnie MackenzieWe need to look after the most vulnerable people better. The homelessness, poverty and starvation that goes unhelped damns us. 32902019-07-24T10:24:59.54739741Margaret MiltonSuicide awareness could save lives33072019-07-24T10:33:55.6139742Sue FrostExcellent idea!32912019-07-24T11:01:21.21739743Euan RobsonIt would be both ground breaking and positive if the Scottish Government was to move on from conventional wisdom and adopt what the petitioners request33182019-07-24T11:06:36.71739744Euan RobsonIt would be a great step forward if the Scottish Government broke with conventional wisdom and did as the petitioners request.33182019-07-24T12:53:58.56739745Eva mcfarlane Getting over food inequality will help people get out of the vicious circle of poverty that is worse health and ability due to lack of money 32902019-07-24T14:21:51.77339746Michael BillsA legal right to food and water is long overdue.32902019-07-24T14:36:18.8739747Karine PolwartInformation about pelvic health should be available to every woman post childbirth. Squeezy app is great. But just knowing you're not alone and that physio care and specialist advice exists would be a good start. Lack of attention to it, and unnecessary shame, ruins lives and costs money down the line. 32912019-07-24T15:37:19.35339748Patricia davidson This could help our youth open up about their feelings 33072019-07-24T19:28:22.99339749Christine NancollasChildren withPDA are high on the spectrum of autism and their anxiety expresses itself bu screaming and hitting because they are afraid Children have been abused with this condition by excluding them and putting them into solitary confinement which exarcerbates their anxiety Teachers and people working with these children need to have special training in how to help these children Local authorities have got to start being realistic and helpful in funding their needs33182019-07-24T19:45:37.5339750Margaret Sheridan Stress in incontinence is not normal, get the message out there!!32912019-07-24T22:23:17.339751Catherine McDonaldNeed something to help our young people33072019-07-24T22:40:27.8539752Louise donnelly Something needs done 33072019-07-24T22:40:45.139753Claire LambWe lost a lovely cat called Rainbow. Then two years later our new cat was injured but she managed to get home. It was a long process of getting her better but she pulled through. We just wish Rainbow had had that opportunity because we would have done everything in our power to help her.31922019-07-24T23:34:14.67739754Helen Campbell If it saves one life its worth while 33072019-07-24T23:47:22.13339755Danilo CarranzaWe cant survive without food. We cant live with dignity without safe and accessible affordble food. We continue to struggle for the right to food in our country and support the struggle of other peoples worldwide. 32902019-07-25T01:51:20.5139756Wilma kerrEveryone need help at some point in life going through difficult time 33072019-07-25T02:29:25.4239758Susan HysertTime to take action and help those who would have huge benifit from this service 33072019-07-25T06:19:46.6439759Margaret BaileyI believe that access to food and water is a basic human right and should be incorporated into Scots law32902019-07-25T07:04:06.1339760Elizabeth JohnstonThis needs to be taken far more seriously than it is now33072019-07-25T07:25:36.57339762Abigail boutcherI have done assist training at cope in drumchapel and know how important mental health awareness is with working with young people . I supported young individuals with trfs for 7 years . 33072019-07-25T08:00:06.10739763Helen brittonWe need people to know how to ccess help. But we need more services and investment for people to access. Its terrible that people are so desperate, we need action now33072019-07-25T08:21:20.44739764Ian TurnbullPDA is a known condition within the Autistic Spectrum, yet some health professionals refuse to recognise or diagnose the condition. This results in no support for the person or their family. This has been the case with family member. Even after getting a private diagnosis, health professionals within my local authority area, still refuse to recognise that it is a condition. Consequently they refuse to provide any meaningful help to them or their parents.33182019-07-25T09:50:21.5339765Elaine CurrieEven if this helps only one person that would be amazing33072019-07-25T10:08:30.40739766Michelle BalfourA family mmeber is Autistic & their mental health is very poorly. They tried to take their own life in January 201933072019-07-25T10:15:03.62739768Dawn LloydFood raised in a humane and environmentally friendly way is essential.32902019-07-25T10:33:09.1939769Léa WinterGreat initiative ! Thanks !32902019-07-25T10:44:08.639770Paul DownieThis is the type of issue law making should support. It's about creating a world where every individual has some basic human rights! To eat nourishing food being of utmost importance within that framework. Please support!32902019-07-25T10:50:59.28739771Gill BirdWe need highest possible animal welfare standards. 32902019-07-25T12:02:31.04739773Carol fosbrook My cat is microchipped along with lots of other cats and I would like to know if my cat has been involved in an accident.31922019-07-25T12:28:58.14739774Elaine Hodgson Something needs to be done the figures of suicide are extremely worrying. 33072019-07-25T13:07:30.35339775hazel mcmanusThere is at the moment not enough support for young people facing mental difficulty's, this could be a potential life saver. Suicide seems to be at an all time high amongst young people and its utterly heart breaking.33072019-07-25T14:16:47.83339776melnnie fyfeWould you ever believe people are starving in the year 2019? this is REAL LIFE. 32902019-07-25T14:47:23.939778Gillian NewmanHighland Children's Forum have heard from parents and from professionals working with children on the autism spectrum who have also had Pathological Demand Avoidance. To support such children the intervention can seem counterintuitive to "normal" parenting or child care. It is so important that both parents of children with PDA and the staff who work with such children have the right training and that the children get the right support. 33182019-07-25T14:53:24.99339779Lynne RossiniOur basic needs which are stipulated human rights are being denied. 32902019-07-25T17:17:06.15339780Roslyn McGilvrayStop suicide 33072019-07-25T17:17:15.32739781Radhika BhaleraoThe hindu temple needs complete security, as there has been incidents of theft and trespassing. Serious security measures are required by the Law to curb such incidents. 31842019-07-25T18:45:39.3539784Diane BrierleyCats are no diffent to dogs when it come to RTAs. So many people walk dogs without leads now they are a traffic hazard. Cats deserve better compassion & legislation!31922019-07-25T19:51:02.4439785Paul Rooney Far too many young persons taking their own life. I hope thos helps.33072019-07-25T20:09:31.34739786Fay CostelloLet's put an end to another injustice in Scotland!32902019-07-25T20:21:30.88339787Linda Ricouard pI am supporting this petition, as I think if you hit a cat...you should check on the animal, even if it is dead...you should take it to a vet so they can see if it has a chip...then the owner can be notified, so they have closure. And if it is alive, if you get immediate help then has a chance of recovery, and not to be left do die a slow painful death.31922019-07-25T21:42:19.7239788Ankur sharmaWe feel insecure sometime going yo temple..pls address this concern31842019-07-25T23:02:06.2139789Jon ShortToo many lifes are being lost due to lack of Support or someone to turn to.33072019-07-25T23:23:54.07739790Amanda RoyEveryone should have the right to healthy food at reasonable prices. 32902019-07-26T06:36:33.75739792Sally Wallace This needs Action now33072019-07-26T08:14:17.91339793Claire FenlonHelp just now seems not to be readily available33072019-07-26T08:20:59.69339794Sally CadgeOur exceptional little rescue cat was hit by a car in our quiet road a few weeks ago. No one stopped. She dragged herself home but her injuries were too severe and we made the sad decision to have her put to sleep. She was 3 years old , she brought us so much joy and loved every minute of her life. It would have meant so much to us if the person had stopped and helped. More awareness is needed. We are devastated but we will offer a home to another rescue cat when we have mourned our sweet Ada. 31922019-07-26T08:59:26.21739795Marie CampbellHope they get enough signatures33072019-07-26T09:01:07.4239796Jane ShevlinFairly produced food should be available at affordable prices for all. It is a fundamental humagh right.32902019-07-26T10:27:09.91339797Elizabeth TaitAll people have right to food.32902019-07-26T10:47:45.57339798Annetta McDowallWe need to help everyone starting from childhood about thoughts emotions and how our brain works.33072019-07-26T11:35:54.70739799Tracy CampbellI know myself how suicide affects people, young people need to know this isn't an option33072019-07-26T11:41:21.89339800Lisa ReidI have experienced a lack of awareness, acknowledgment and support from healthcare and education professionals. This has resulted in a lack of reasonable adjustments for a family member, causing them increased levels of anxiety, symptomatic behaviour and even school refusal. 33182019-07-26T17:03:16.6839801Andrew FraserWhile one may have every sympathy with a cat owner's loss, one might also remember that cat owners do not appear to take any responsibility for their cats' behaviour and the nuisance they are to their neighbours. I, for one, am sick of cleaning up their filthy disease ridden stools, and having to dispose of the broken bodies of the birds they wantonly kill. I fail to see why the death of one of those murderous animals should be reported to the police. They've surely got more than enough to do. 31922019-07-26T19:25:11.10739802Fiona fordMy daughter just turned 18 took her life these young kids are getting turned away when needing help something has to be done to stop all these young people thinking they have no one to turn to and get the help they need it destroys not only these young people but also tears families to bits the pain is unbelievable 33072019-07-26T19:55:08.51739803Alan GordonOur population deserve to have their right to food enshrined in law. 32902019-07-26T20:30:55.17739804Wendy LaingShould indeed be mandatory in schools, you just need to look at the statistics to know that! Look after our kids mental health. 33072019-07-26T21:47:05.5639806Beverley Searle Access to food and shelter is the most basic requirement of human wellbeing. 32902019-07-26T22:19:18.5539807Andi jacksonMy much loved cat Wilma was hit by a car in August last year, the driver didn't stop, neither did the next three or four cars, thankfully one did, there was nothing that could be done for Wilma but I am forever grateful to the man that took his time to find who she belonged to, the person that hit her I hope karma comes for you, there was no way you didn't see her, you obviously just felt she was worth nothing.... You couldn't be more wrong. \r\nCats are very much a loved family pet and deserve recognition as such, no pet should be let to die like that, the laws need to catch up with the times, listen to the people, protect our pets.....31922019-07-27T00:47:52.46339808Marion craigNeed more done to support metal health33072019-07-27T05:15:01.61739809catia SantosThe medical and education system need to learn and acknowledge PDA as a diagnosis and special needs\r\nit is hard to believe that diagnosis and treatment is not being given or acknowledged when a child has PDA or symptoms of it early diagnosis support and adjusted interactions can make a huge difference to that child's whole life from education to lifestyle to socialising the longer it is left unrecognised and unmanaged the more children that will suffer great perils in growing up and adult life. \r\nIt would benefit nor only the patient and family, friends but school peers and teachers as early acknowledgement and support can mean the difference between a child who does not fair well in education, life and employment also when needs are managed and supported early it will make a huge difference in preventing further harm and difficulties for all involved especially the patient because without support, understanding and adapted interactions the damage, confusion and emotional damage PDA causes will cause numerous other issues, struggles and needs for the patient and those around them. \r\nLet's teach, understand and accept PDA so that the future can be brighter and happier for so many undiagnosed, misunderstood and lost patients and families. 33182019-07-27T09:27:57.65339810Michelle Lockhart Save a life33072019-07-27T09:36:29.7539811Hema SolankiHate crimes - Put an end to this31842019-07-27T09:41:35.65339812Jan Roberts For all the legislation crofters have to adhere to, at cost, there should be some form of protection. 32672019-07-27T09:53:04.68739813Mairi macleodHope this petition is successful in bringing to end families being robbed of crofts that have been in their families for generations . \r\n32672019-07-27T11:16:59.63739815Suzanne Moran More help needed please 33072019-07-27T15:07:08.8139816June laffertyHopefully will help someone33072019-07-27T18:24:12.91339817Lesley mintonMake it law you have to stop if running a cat over 31922019-07-27T20:11:25.83339819Pamela Balfour Please allow cat owners to be made aware31922019-07-27T21:01:33.5939821Sudeep SakalleI support the petition, the promise and intentions must match actions. 31842019-07-28T08:27:31.9739824Danielle Jata-HallThis is great what you are doing for other vulnerable families, thank you and keep up the good work 33182019-07-28T09:32:42.83739828Gourav ManchandaIn complete support of this petition31842019-07-28T10:28:05.9439830Ramchander DugyalaI support this petition for the review of hate crime legislation 31842019-07-28T10:55:02.16339831Doreen Hayes PDA or Pathalogical Demand Avoidance does exist and can be diagnosed as those of us with children who present PDA know. No longer will we accept a non diagnosis of PDA. Why are the professionals reluctant to diagnose PDA Could it be that we the parent.grandparent. carers of these children have more knowledge of PDA than the professionals. Makes me wonder. 33182019-07-28T11:28:58.94739832June LaffertyI hope this helps33072019-07-28T12:32:27.20739833Susan Morrison Great idea. I wish this advice had been more widely available when I was a new mum! 32912019-07-28T13:07:37.8539835Hal OslerHaving had two children I was really surprised that issue was not discussed at all prior to birth & not really focused on after birth. For long term health it is really vital 32912019-07-28T16:51:04.52739837Samantha LavinMany owner have cats as part of their family and one day they disappear, they never come home. People never give up hoping that their pet will return and deserve to know what has happened.31922019-07-28T18:55:21.14739838Peter dunneA menber of my family took his on life. And i wish i was there to help him.33072019-07-28T19:15:27.8139839Denise MacLean It is essential that stress incontinence in new mums is recognised as a public health emergency and contributes to post natal depression. Organisations like Tena continue to make huge profits from NHSS when the problem can be addressed at clinic. 32912019-07-28T22:04:43.839841Naomi Foster AitonThere is a suicide epidemic in Scotland and it is devastating families. The government need to make changes and fast. 33072019-07-28T22:14:13.7739842Ann-Theresa Togher My daughter died by suicide Oct 2016. . 1 Month before her 21st birthday ,young people need all the help & support available to help and encourage them positively in their young years 33072019-07-28T22:18:43.78739843Jane wardlswFor all the pain these families are going through! And in living memory of my brother Brian Cassidy x\r\n\r\n33072019-07-28T22:30:28.28739845Emma WailesSomething needs to be done to help people suffering with mental health, good for you raising awareness & making a difference xx33072019-07-28T22:46:35.02339846Lauren Bogle People need more help more guidance and reassured 33072019-07-28T22:46:41.24339847Layla Mcmillan For the future of all our babies33072019-07-28T22:50:59.46339848Sonia ewanI am a cat owner although as far as i know i haven't lost a cat to being hit by a car, there has been so many that i have known or seen, think its wrong that its not repored like other pets and there as important too. 31922019-07-29T06:52:05.71739849Christine Storrie Time to make a difference 33072019-07-29T06:59:30.3639850Measures should be made in schools to prevent this terrible thing from happening Maria Callander33072019-07-29T07:04:01.7439851Amy brownMore must be readily available for those people at the lowest point in their life. 33072019-07-29T08:14:30.98339852Liz SweatThis could prevent so many beautiful people dying when help could have been given. 33072019-07-29T09:10:30.11739853Alice NajafianI really hope this petition goes through. A much needed campaign to help our youth of today and in the future. Raising awareness through education in secondary schools with more funding is desperately needed now. \r\n33072019-07-29T09:21:32.4339854Margaret TonerWe all need to do what we can to help get better Mental Health Awareness out to everyone but young people in particular.33072019-07-29T10:03:06.19739855Laura GormanMore help is needed.33072019-07-29T10:12:14.46739856Graeme McKechnie We all need to do what we can to help 33072019-07-29T11:44:36.04339857Eleanor McIntoshMore help more staff more information less loss of life33072019-07-29T11:56:43.35739860Bill ChisholmIt is high time those suffering from this disorder received the care and services they deserve.33182019-07-29T12:12:53.6239861Jemma BurnsMental Health Awareness is paramount x33072019-07-29T12:59:31.45339862Kirsty macneilHighlands 33182019-07-29T13:44:24.3239863Caroline MuirheadAs manager of a multi arts venue where we have a sharing shelf, a lot of my time is spent on dispersing free food for the local community. It is unfair that cheap food is predominantly unhealthy packed full of fat and sugar. This has a negative impact on families and communities as well as being a huge burden on the NHS. Let's rethink healthy food options for children and promote and support more 'grow your own' initiatives. Let communities think about how best to utilise local community gardens and green spaces so that growing your own food becomes a normal part of life. Healthy food must be accessible for all which needs to also include things like encouraging less meat eating and raising awareness around other healthy options like pizza ovens being available to community groups so kids and families learn to make their own. Understanding where our food comes from and educating people on how it is processed will help people make better informed choices. 32902019-07-29T14:30:52.62739864Rashmi MishraEnough is Enough 31842019-07-29T14:57:47.02339865Janet AinsworthEveryone has the right to good nutritious safe food..no one should go hungry32902019-07-29T15:28:58.61739867Eileen Gallacher Mental health needs to be dealt with ASAP 33072019-07-29T16:20:07.88739868Amanda MaguireIt is imperative that PDA is recognised! 33182019-07-29T16:55:47.89339869Margo McGeochHelp and support needed33072019-07-29T17:50:52.0639871William KellPeople have a right to a good healthy food supply at a reasonable rate and should be able to afford it. It would help to tackle some of the obesity issues on this country of people could afford good quality cheap food as opposed to overpriced processed foods which are bad for us 32902019-07-29T18:11:48.98339872Robyn Miller A must for the future! Changes need to be made.33072019-07-29T18:13:42.84339873Veronica HealyThere must be more help provided to help the children who are our future33072019-07-29T19:07:10.2439876Sinéad GrahamThe slashing of Mental health services, not just in scotland but UK wide has to stop. Not enough nurses and Psychiatrists to cope and GPS have basic training. More needs to be done so people can get the help they need far quicker than they currently get it. 33072019-07-29T19:10:24.139877Mary ThomsonSuicide awareness needs to be discussed more especially with kids in high schools, please make this happen. 33072019-07-29T19:11:17.39739878Kelly ramageMore help and support needed x33072019-07-29T19:24:51.58339879Grace OwensFrightening the scale of the Mental Health crisis in Scotland. Young people especially need support now. 33072019-07-29T19:25:41.58739880Cara HatrickFor all our children it is ok to not be ok33072019-07-29T19:25:46.66739881Janet McAulay Can affect anyone 33072019-07-29T19:27:55.2139882Grace OwensFrightening the scale of the Mental Health crisis in Scotland. Our young people need support now. 33072019-07-29T19:29:38.27739883Janice Duncan More needs to be done 33072019-07-29T19:34:29.29339884Iain Murray This is a massive problem for families and should be addressed immediately and brought to light and not swept under the carpet.33072019-07-29T19:40:52.9839887Lennon duffyThe issue is becoming more important these days for a reason , get behind it!33072019-07-29T19:42:13.54339888Margaret StuartMore support for mental health awareness 33072019-07-29T19:42:17.8739889Miranda CampbellWe need to help 33072019-07-29T19:45:17.96739890Iain Murray This should be brought out and addressed and not brushed under the carpet any longer 33072019-07-29T19:48:26.21739891Claire Urquhart More needs to be done. \r\nThis is an issue close to my heart 33072019-07-29T19:59:09.23339892Taylor brown Suicide should be more frequently talked about 33072019-07-29T20:01:08.46339893Joanne kilpatrickPlease sign 33072019-07-29T20:16:20.18739894Elizabeth MartinHopefully something will be done to stop young people taking their one lives33072019-07-29T20:31:38.2739896Margaret wattBetter education and more awareness of this problem can only benefit everyone.33072019-07-29T20:33:02.56739897Catherine morganMore help is needed right now33072019-07-29T20:41:53.03739898Teresa wintersMental health awareness needs to be spoke about in schools.33072019-07-29T21:12:39.69739899Angela Dixon Definitely needs more awareness and help for young people 33072019-07-29T21:18:59.6239900Linda AlexanderMore help is needed. Getting so many lives ruined by this 33072019-07-29T21:20:41.21339901Collette Sibley More help & signposting is required on this hard subject of mental health & wellbeing 33072019-07-29T21:44:37.0939903John Ralston On the anniversary of former Motherwell FC player Paul McGrillen. Suicide can affect any number of people from sportsman, celebrity to teenage schoolkids. We all need education.33072019-07-29T22:09:02.1139904Lee ann brysonThey should more help out there 33072019-07-29T22:11:05.06339905Leigh wilson More help is needed especially for men so they feel able to speak out 33072019-07-29T22:53:23.69739906Angela ScottMore support and awareness is much needed to prevent so many young people taking their own lives. It is so sad to see in this day and age.33072019-07-29T22:58:06.99739908Jamie whoteJust do more! 33072019-07-29T23:00:58.66739910Allyson McNaughthopefully this is a step in the right direction to get as much help as possible for mental health and awareness especially for the younger ones who are in need 33072019-07-29T23:22:48.85739911Angela ThomsonSomething defo needs done about this, happening far to much these days.33072019-07-29T23:39:27.15739913Anne Marie KeenanThere are too many people feeling that suicide is the only way to solve their problems. We need more awareness to show them that help and support are available33072019-07-29T23:45:23.17339915Pamela McMahon Mental health awareness education needs to be done with all, but most importantly the young men of our country33072019-07-29T23:46:42.1939916Jill McCannA better understanding of mental health is key to hopefully make a difference to those suffering and their families. It's OK to not be OK. 33072019-07-30T01:00:36.49739917Amanda GreenAnything that can help prevent more people suffering in silence. 33072019-07-30T02:03:21.6639918Joy OBrienHelp should be so much easier to get and people should never be embarrassed to ask for help. Thank you Naomi for helping to bring this subject out in the open. God Bless you33072019-07-30T05:37:49.78739921Jhoola Sharma I support this petition 31842019-07-30T05:45:27.2139923Fiona Harley Suicide in young males is unbelievable we need change ASAP33072019-07-30T06:31:46.93339924Kirsty MitchellMore needs to be done. 33072019-07-30T06:43:56.3939925Vicky Waddell People suffer in silence it needs to stop33072019-07-30T07:15:51.70739926Patricia MartinThis is getting to be an epidemic so tragic and worrying something needs to be done A.S.A.P.33072019-07-30T07:57:38.88339928Calum Iain MacleodWell done Iain for raising this shameful matter and taking it this far. Hoping that things go the right way and that the crofts and houses are left with the families who have worked them for many years, and indeed, many generations32672019-07-30T08:25:04.32339929Christine hamilton We need to support our youth 33072019-07-30T08:36:22.82739930Diana Vettraino Sombody has to take notice before its YOUR family!33072019-07-30T09:08:37.22339931Simon MacfarlaneWe need a human tights approach to access to healthy and nutritios food. We need to eradicate food poverty and the reliance on food banks by redistributing wealth. 32902019-07-30T09:12:31.69339932Simon MacfarlaneI support a human rights approach to food. We need to tackle food poverty and the reliance on food banks through redistributing wealth. 32902019-07-30T09:13:49.31739933Sarah WhyteYoung primary age family member has undiagnosed PDA. They have an HFA diagnosis but classic PDA has a wellbeing plan that was written and includes PDA strategies but both mainstream and their specialist placement don't call it that or mention it and a member of staff told family member that it didn't exist when I had explained it to them to help understand them and their presentation. The plan is not followed and neither school used the strategies. This ended up with family member being restrained and secluded on a daily basis which was not recorded or reported to family other than on the odd occasion. Family wrote to the QIO and Head of Educations services and the schools and Ed Psych and they only received a few lines in reply from the school two days later. There was no acknowledgement of what happened. Currently they are providing much better support and family member is no longer being restrained and new teacher is applying PDA strategies well. As a result they get on much better but not able to join the mainstream class. Family member has days where the demand avoidance is too great and they refuse to attend but listening to them and respecting that means the rest of the week goes more smoothly.33182019-07-30T09:16:11.34739934Lesley ReidWe need to do what we can33072019-07-30T09:58:24.05739935Ellie CaponMore focus and attention is desperately needed and to make a lot more people aware 33072019-07-30T10:02:27.19739936NATHANI SRINIVASULUProtest hundus31842019-07-30T10:10:29.91739937Deirdre shakespeare I signed this as I support your petition of PDA toolkit which may help practitioners know how to manage children with PDA so that families like yours aren't torn apart through injustice, blame and failure to appropriately support and diagnose.\r\nI hope when the Scottish government agree to your petition it will then become a nation wide toolkit for not only Scotlands children but children in N.Ireland, England and Wales. 33182019-07-30T11:36:59.88339939Maria HoughtonSomething has to be done 33072019-07-30T11:38:44.02339940Lorraine MastersonSo sad that people think this is an answer hopefully the government put this into education as it devastates people's lives 33072019-07-30T11:42:46.41339941Ashley bramman Mental health services access is far to limited 33072019-07-30T11:53:36.79739942pallavi shuklaI sipport31842019-07-30T13:02:51.5239943Angela AndersonHelp our young people. They are the future.33072019-07-30T14:09:53.96339945Merridy ChalmersMore has to be done to many are dieing by suicide, it's all I'm seeing the amount of people that have taking the own life's is truly heartbreaking, I lost my dad 14 years ago to suicide broke my heart then and still broken and will never be fully healed.33072019-07-30T14:16:57.6239946Katie gibsonMental health needs more awareness33072019-07-30T15:04:21.0839947isabel cochraneso proud of FAMS and everyone that volenteers coming on board myself soon keep up the goid work each and everyone of you xx33072019-07-30T15:04:46.65739949Rebekah hoeyDefinitely need more help in schools with challenging mental health xx33072019-07-30T15:12:23.68339950Sree keerthi I want my other fellow humans to be safe and happy.31842019-07-30T15:33:58.4639951Yvonne Mcneil Something needs to be done 33072019-07-30T15:58:24.47739952Hannah Reilly Theres not enough services to combat mental health 33072019-07-30T17:18:04.5539958 Barbara Robinson Good affordable nutritious food should be available for every person in our society a human right enshrined in law.32902019-07-30T19:02:57.45739965Nikki Brannan Animal welfare is my main priority. Cruelty to animals is not acceptable in any form, for any reason 32902019-07-30T20:24:06.6539971Denise johnsonI personally haven't had one of my cats hit by a car but i am in a cat club called kingsheath cat club, there are any posts daily about cats being found on the side of the road and left for dead and peoples lives devastated by the thought of their cat just being left for dead, taking the cat to the vets for a chip check would ease the pain for some furkids family, so sad.31922019-07-31T13:35:41.31339983Elaine Macdougall Even with some school support in place family member only managed 6 weeks of high school and has since spent the last 5 years educating themself from home. For some children mainstream school will just not work but access to a national online curriculum would. This would benefit not just PDA children but other children who struggle with school for other reasons. The other thing for professionals to understand is the stress having a PDA child causes to to the whole household, often marriages fail and siblings develop extreme anxiety, leaving the parents feeling blamed instead of being supported.\r\n33182019-07-31T14:58:10.71339984Hilda CampbellIn terms of Maslow's Hierarchy of needs, Food, Water, Warmth and a safe place to sleep are our basic physiological needs, if these aren't met, it impacts on us in so many ways which aren't helpful and hold us back from our true potential. We surely all want to live in a country where no one lacks food, water, warmth and a safe place to sleep, without these all else we do and people try to achieve will be so much harder. How can we expect children who are all our futures achieve their full potential if they are hungry or feel stigma for using food banks. How together can we create a country where people have the resources to shop and make their own choices over the food they eat? Food banks should not become the norm this is the 21st century people should have the income which affords a quality of life which helps them be who they can be32902019-07-31T18:27:06.80739985Mary McGinleyEveryone should have access to a healthy diet and should have a level of income to allows this.\r\nHealthy food should be affordable and the minimum wage and basic benefits should be at a high enough level to let people meet their nutritional needs. 32902019-08-01T11:08:01.2339987Magnus Christie WilliamsonDespite our best efforts, this planet is still able to sustain her inhabitants many times over. The only thing which frustrates this is profiteering - from one of the most basic requirements to human life. This is in no way necessary, in no way inevitable, in no way right. It is a social construct, and one which can and must be replaced by something far better32902019-08-01T12:01:58.09739988Ruhina AslamGood Initiative, the place of worship should be free from hatred and Govt should provide fund to secure these place. 31842019-08-01T14:41:59.92739990Johan HardyCat's are equally members of our family just like dogs. Please change the law in recognition of this.31922019-08-01T15:16:33.6539991Brian MCCARTHY All places of worship should be safe..not just few.31842019-08-01T15:40:53.98739992Susan NuttgensIn support of the human right for adequate food.32902019-08-01T15:54:05.48339993Eileen McDonaldI agree with the petition too many drivers think its ok not to report it as its only a cat and it doesn't matter 31922019-08-01T17:23:00.62339994Catherine RodgersGreat idea would help relieve stress as I wouldnt have to worry about working as much and focus on my studies.32082019-08-01T18:03:37.39339995Lorna Douglas As a student teacher going into my year 3 placement I was shocked to hear there were no additional sources of income provided by the Scottish Government for student teachers. At the end of the day we are working within a school 9 till 3 sometimes much longer, 5 days a week for a whole year, as well as being a full time student and juggling assignments. As a result I will have to work a part-time job at the weekends which means I will be working 7 out of 7 days a week which nobody should have to do.32082019-08-01T19:09:20.18739996Lara PattersonWould relieve financial pressures of an already overwhelming year32082019-08-01T19:12:3439997Kathy WebberAn excellent way to get a bursary 32082019-08-01T19:30:53.89339998Lorna HyslopAll students should be paid through any training 32082019-08-01T20:32:41.14740002Trish ChallansI have lost two cats to being knocked down by cars and none stop. Drivers need to report a cat.31922019-08-01T21:11:29.82340004Amy Chambers This is so important for student teachers32082019-08-01T21:11:56.81340005Kimberly RodgersGood idea32082019-08-01T21:44:08.9740010Rosann ferrietI think people don't realise that our cats are part of the family and not something to be left at the side of the road when hit. Cats have feelings and feel pain like humans, and often they don't die straight away after being hit,some could be saved and their owners are entitled to know the outcome.31922019-08-01T23:21:52.9640013Claire Mooney I support this 100% as my own family members' story is proof of rights being ignored. 32792019-08-01T23:37:10.37740014Michaela ForestiWe are at school 5 days a week but with no bursary 32082019-08-01T23:54:42.74340015Erin scottAs a student teacher this would be a well received help. Always struggle with finding work to fit in with placements as well as the heavy workload that comes along with planning etc. 32082019-08-02T00:38:27.7940016Ayorinde AdewaleWhat is worth doing, is what doing best.\r\nIntakes demand special monitoring because the status of our life depend on it. I am in total support of this 32902019-08-02T01:08:28.04340017Cameron MullenWould be good for the many student teachers that are supporting families during their studies.32082019-08-02T08:14:34.98740018Norma Isobel McIntyreThe Bible states Give us this day our daily bread which means we are entitled to OUR daily bread, not just any daily bread.32902019-08-02T10:14:48.09340019Jill AlexanderI feel ashamed as a UK citizen and a human being, that rising numbers of people living in the 5th richest western nation in the world should have to apply for emergency food. To avoid becoming a nation of beggars, we need to enshrine the right to food in Scots law32902019-08-02T13:14:17.10740022Karen Finnie It is obscene to expect young adults to pay their rent, bills, food shops, travel expenses without any form of job due to their long placements 32082019-08-02T20:12:24.07340026Lauren MathesonRidiculous how people are robbed from family homes to pay for home care, needs to be exempt for sure 32672019-08-02T20:30:41.8240027Mrs Freda RourkeDisgraceful the way our students have to take jobs to fit in with UNI study not an easy task .32082019-08-02T20:51:43.5140028Paul BrownIt really important that services are kept at a good level and that we maintain or increase the level of our public sector.32082019-08-02T20:59:18.21340029Fiona Anderson Student placements should be paid 32082019-08-02T23:37:05.67340030Fiona AitkenAn adequate balanced diet doesn't need to be expensive.32902019-08-03T12:31:31.64740032Claire neilson Family member is not diagnosed yet. They are on the waiting list for asd and odd assessment. But family are 100% sure they are pda. This is all great work yous are doing and families and everyone else in this situation are so thankful. 33182019-08-03T16:10:23.1440034Steven Russam As someone who is actively trying to get into teaching a scheme like this would be hugely beneficial to me and my family. While I'm more than prepared to take a year out of full time employment to pursue my studies it does come with serious financial implications. A scheme like this would help immensely and could help encourage others in full time employment to consider retraining as teachers.32082019-08-04T00:48:26.54740035Anne MoodyFamily member has PDA, they are now home schooled. The education system has failed them on numerous occasions. The family has done their utmost to promote and educate others on their family member's experience with PDA. They are family member's only true support system. It is heart wrenching to see, hear and read of families' struggles with the system.\r\n\r\nA toolkit if followed would be fantastic. \r\n\r\n\r\nInvolve those who know, what these children and adults are suffering. Parents, grandparents and siblings and extended family have a wealth of experience and knowledge.33182019-08-04T01:58:08.45740036Helen Fergusonmore training needs to be done on PDA to help our kids be understood more and to get the help and support they need. It would help to keep them in mainstream school as a lot of these children are now having to be home school due to schools not being able to fulfill their educational, emotional , physical well being33182019-08-04T12:28:03.3440040Frances Tasker I fully support this petition. A family member has been in placement for the last Academic year. 8-5, 5 days a week. No expenses for a 50 mile daily return journey, evening preparation for classes, covering classes when no one able to cover for absence, working a part time job on top of this in order to ensure they had enough money. They found their placement was a brilliant experience and so valuable in preparing them for the future and the school they were in was wonderful in supporting them but they were completely exhausted at the end of term due to the hours in total they worked each week 6 full days work and evenings for 1 days pay from their part time job. Due to their amazing attitude to life and their passion for teaching they successfully completed this year but so many others had to drop out for mainly financial reasons, such a waste of talent which with financial support could be teaching children in a year. Wasted opportunity by our government to support opportunity and a valuable resource for the future.32082019-08-04T16:43:45.8940041sangeeta sharma i support this petition31842019-08-04T19:10:51.04340046Karen Armstrong My cat dizzy was killed on the road, car tooted at her causing her to panic, if driver had slowed down just a fraction she would have made it off the road, car didn't even stop. My dad and niece found her 2 minutes later, sadly too late to do anything. They are not just animals, like dogs they are our family so why is it ok to just drive off like they don't matter ?!31922019-08-04T20:44:23.6640047Calum duffIt would make life so much easier in a hard environment 32082019-08-04T22:52:12.57340049Rachel ReidIn my first year of a 4 year undergraduate teaching degree. I will undertake 4 placements of increasing amounts over these years. Placements also mean additional travel, uncovered by my university. I would greatly appreciate a change in this for myself and all future teachers to come. 32082019-08-05T07:17:07.6440050Sandra JordanI believe that anyone on placement for primary teaching should receive a bursery as they work really hard not just at school, also when they finish and preparing work for the next day. 32082019-08-05T07:28:52.3440051Erin WalshAt young age, family member was permanently excluded from their first primary school. At another school they were placed on a reduced timetable, at one point only going to school for an hour and a half on a Monday. . . They were banned from after school clubs, refused permission to attend the valentine's disco and was excluded on countless occasions between September and May.... They are still only young primary age. Just terrible, had no idea the reduced timetable was unlawful I just went with what the school said. Family had to give up job as they were excluded so frequently. Just terrible. They are in a specialist community school now but it is very very far away and they have had no exclusions which is a positive. But still, family member as PDA and if professionals were aware of what that actually is and how to manage it maybe family member wouldn't have been failed and traumatised simply because professionals couldn't manage them. This needs to change before more kids are failed. 33182019-08-05T09:36:37.1940052Jasmine ArndtBursaries should be provided to students undertaking a full time teaching position.32082019-08-05T09:54:20.20340053Kirsten LeaskWe need a 'right to *good* food', not just a 'right to food'. Food that's good for health, environment and economy. Simply asking for the 'right to food' may just encourage the production and provision of the kind of unhealthy, over-processed, chemical-laden food-like substances that are so often available in our obesogenic consumer society.32902019-08-05T11:49:10.54740054April PriorFamly member is adult and very clearly has PDA. The issue is that standard autism support is regimented and structured with full routines. This is exactly what they cannot cope with and they launch into damaging and self injurious behaviours. For 18 months family member has been an inpatient in an LD ward and family has fought and fought for this part of their autism profile to be taken on board. Family continue to be ignored. The amount of pressure people with PDA as part of their profile are under is inhumane. No they don't want to eat when you tell them to, they will eat when ready, no they don't want to go out when you are ready, they want to go out when they are ready. Family member now also has depression and anxiety and this is all down to people ignoring this part of their profile33182019-08-05T15:30:10.7140055Jen Downie I can understand why there would be any reason not to include this information in the baby box. It effects thousands if women and this information would really help. The baby box would be a perfect way to disseminate the information. 32912019-08-05T17:36:55.64740057Linsey BlueA family member has additional needs and the funding provides vital support and resources to allow them to continue education 33192019-08-05T17:38:13.46340058John KellyThe lack of infrastructure to take traffic away from the village is non existent. Amenities have been terrible for over 15 years31462019-08-05T17:46:05.13740060Nicola JoyceAgree wholeheartedly! Every child in mainstream education should have the same number of opportunities, and same standard of education. To fail to provide this for ASN children is discrimination. 33192019-08-05T18:07:47.10340062John wildishEdinburgh council you're a disgrace more interest in a festival and wasting money on pet projects than education for the people who need it most how are these people meant achieve the best they can be without the proper help and support at the beginning of life one wonders where the so called council members would be without their own EDUCATION.33192019-08-05T18:48:05.59340063Karen Mckeown I feel families should have the right to ask for a fai if they feel there loved one has been failed. My partner was failed after he was repeatedly turned away by the hospital, he went onto take his own life. I have repeatedly asked for a fai and been told his case does not fall under the rules and it not in the public best interests. I feel a fai would help prevent the same mistake from happen again and helping further generations. 31272019-08-05T18:52:08.67740064Gillian MurrayI wholeheartedly support this petition. A family member was failed by an NHS Board in October 2016. I had to petition to parliament for an inquiry (which is in progress), and the Crown Office is *still* deciding whether, "it is in the publics interest" to hold an FAI into the system defects which led to my family member being failed, ultimately leading to his death. We have been waiting for nearly 3 years for a response from COPFS. This adds further torture and trauma to an already traumatised family. When there are clear failings, there should be no excuses for COPFS to not hold an FAI.31272019-08-05T19:02:13.41340065Lisa macpheeIt has always been a struggle to get the correct support in school for our children due to lack of staff. Phone calls to tell you your child can not attend school as there is not enough staff. That was before the redesign. It will be far worse now. 33192019-08-05T19:05:04.64740066Michelle WatsonEven though a family member has a diagnosis the council will not find hours for a PSA, they have to share and this has a knock on effect for other children with additional needs. The government is failing all children with additional needs. When I die will they be able to look after themselves, this is a question I ask myself every day, will they be able to cope with money, will they be vulnerable and taken advantage of? Will they be able to support themselves and be educated enough to have a job? Who will look out for my family member when I am unable to. They have the right to an education just like any other child but isn't receiving this. I am now considering removing them from the school and the friends they have just made after years of trying because I am looking at their future without me. 33192019-08-05T19:07:48.91340067Sonia Lasta vital investment in our young people and their potential33192019-08-05T19:18:35.17740069Natasha MacCallum MillarHighland council has taken our PSA away, tell me how a 1 teacher school can run without the support from PSAs to help all children learn and develop33192019-08-05T19:29:21.6340070Phyllis MooreThis is needed33192019-08-05T20:15:47.84340072Karin Dalziel If a family member had support in primary and not been told they were disruptive and not bullied they might have been happier 33192019-08-05T20:16:46.18740073cathrine MightenI have family members with additional support needs and i'm well aware of the lack of funding which in turn means lack of support in schools which in turn leads to frustration and meltdowns 33192019-08-05T20:50:22.56340074Catherine McGintyRoads in Gartcosh cannot cope with the amount of cars from all the new houses. Infrastructure is nil.31462019-08-05T20:54:24.30340075Maya JamesA family member who has Down's syndrome was squeezed out of mainstream education. 33192019-08-05T21:00:19.97740076Elaine Kilgour A family member is starting Primary 1 this month. We have had to fight for additional support for when they start. They have Autism Spectrum Disorder 33192019-08-05T21:05:44.9340077Stevanna RoyAllow change before its too late 33192019-08-05T21:13:47.17740078Anne skeddDisgraceful this has to be fought for33192019-08-05T21:47:47.7940080Kirste JohnstonIt took until 1 week before primary 7 finishing for the summer term for me to have confirmed that a family member is dyslexic with a spelling age of 9, just as they were about to embark in their secondary education. My personal view is that even though the primary school is a dyslexia friendly school, without enough support for teachers, it makes it very difficult for them to support the children fully. Had there been more pupil support, more continuity of teachers I am convinced this would have been identified earlier, as I had flagged my own concerns when the family member was in primary 3. During some school terms their teacher changed 5 times throughout the school year. The local authorities need to find a better way to attract and importantly retain teachers long term and the government needs to address the teacher shortage in Scotland. Short term contracts and bank staff are not the answer. More investment needs made to improve the gap in teacher headcount and public support to assist the teachers. It am sure it's a complex challenge, however the movement of teachers from one school to another due to the insecurity in short term contract I believe is a huge contributor to the issues in education. Inclusion of children of all ability is key and for that to be a success the funding and headcount also needs to be there to achieve the idle. I believe the situation is critical and our children and country will pay the price in the long term if this is not addressed and quickly. 33192019-08-06T06:13:28.2640082Lynda Dalgleish More funding is needed to support children with additional needs in our schools. Teachers are over committed with inadequate support currently. 33192019-08-06T07:08:32.940083Carol PakeAll children are entitled to an adequate education which may require the help of a PSA or placement to special school. Children with ASN are already at a disadvantage, please don't disadvantage them further by not providing the required support or placement. What happens now will affect their future. What happens now is an investment to help them reach their full potential. Spending funds now will save funds in the long term and provide a a fuller, happier life for these children.33192019-08-06T08:48:24.3240087Pauline ClementThere is not adequate funding or staffing in schools to ensure that all childrens needs are bring met. \r\nThe process used to agree funding is not based on individual children's needs. The agreement of what funding is needed for schools in August for the 2019 to 2020 academic year was only finalized in the last week of the 2018 -19 school year leaving schools and parents with a lot of uncertainty. This process and it's timing needs some serious consideration to ensure the Scottish Government are getting it right fit every child.33192019-08-06T09:42:02.82740089Dominic HinesASN children need more support.33192019-08-06T09:57:36.64740091Sue KellyThe action called for in this petition is long overdue. The perverse consequences for people with life long learning disabilities of current legislation and practice cannot be allowed to continue a moment longer. Scotland should be leading the way in protecting the human rights of all, with no exception.32792019-08-06T10:08:39.9940092Bill ScottStrongly support this call for new laws to protect the rights of learning disabled people.32792019-08-06T10:11:03.63340093Morag Matheson A family member is Autistic and attends a mainstream high school in Highland Region. The Highland Council are making millions of pounds of cuts to the ASN budget. These cuts affect every single child who attends school not just the ones with additional support needs. Highland Council are GETTING IT WRONG FOR EVERY CHILD. This needs to be stopped........NOW!!!33192019-08-06T11:14:56.17340094Lynette WeirI signed this as I have family who live in Scotland and a family member is Autistic. I know how much this extra help is needed.33192019-08-06T11:29:39.42340095Jackie KerriganI'm surprised this is not in place already, but fully support student bursaries.32082019-08-06T11:42:27.14340096Maire DevlinI have family members with an Autism diagnosis who have been completely failed by the Scottish education system due to lack of staff & Support. 33192019-08-06T11:49:28.3940097Peter Turner Devlin I had no support at both primary and high school and was secluded and excluded due to this. I have been denied my education.33192019-08-06T12:24:21.8840098Bernie devlinPlease help our children who have been let down and ignored33192019-08-06T12:29:50.74740099Sean M. Cusick An improtant call to action to the Scottish government, to help fulfill Scotland's potential as a hub for Space Technology. 32502019-08-06T12:38:30.740100Eileen CaseuAssist student teachers to flourish while on placement , not worry about travelling costs !32082019-08-06T12:56:08.2840101Stephen OliverAn important issue that needs to bring learning disabilities into the modern age and accept it as a natural occurrence. People with learning disabilities are important members of our community and should not be 'hidden' or treated as an embarrassment.32792019-08-06T12:56:49.12340102Claire coleman-smith A basic human right, our duty of care for humans and the environment. Future proof our long term health and reduce health care costs. Commonsense surely?!32902019-08-06T13:19:07.40340103Margaret McLaughlanStudying should not be stressed out by having to work long hours just to make ends meet. 32082019-08-06T13:36:34.6140104Natalie ClarkStudent teachers work so hard to make sure each placement is a success. Not being supported financially is a serious concern and will impact on the amount of student teachers being able to complete the course successfully. Teaching can be a high pressure and at times stressful occupation. Asking students to work other jobs on top of a full time placement in order to be financially stable makes the situation even more stressful.32082019-08-06T13:54:2140105Lynn ChristieStudents on placement need to be supported financially or they cannot continue. 32082019-08-06T16:10:59.3640106Caroline CrozierYes disabled people should have the same rights as able bodied people.32792019-08-06T16:22:12.84740107Sue HawthorneFood banks are a national disgrace32902019-08-06T16:34:10.9140108MARYJANE FLEMINGI think this is scandalous in this day & age to expect someone to work for a year for no money???????32082019-08-06T16:39:15.41340109Anne baxterI support this. 32082019-08-06T16:41:21.11340110GEORGE FLEMINGIf can pay teachers assistant surely you can give student teachers minimum pay for there years work. NOT NOTHING!!!!!!!!32082019-08-06T16:48:23.77340111Elaine CairnsExcellent idea32082019-08-06T16:50:42.41340112Mary ramsayPeople with learning difficulties deserve support and help32792019-08-06T16:55:31.36740113Lindsey ReganAll children should be able to learn as well as they possibly can.33192019-08-06T16:57:15.69340114Raymond PorterThe inequality and resulting waste is reaching appalling levels. Let us make everyone feel that a basic requirement is not beyond them. 32902019-08-06T17:42:47.54340115Natalie MccloskeyCurrently no children are included in education. Education in Scotland needs major reform. 33192019-08-06T18:12:49.42340116Lesley Borthwick Every child has the right to a good support in education 33192019-08-06T18:13:35.12740117John FosterThis is a petition of importance to all tenants across Scotland. Please sign32562019-08-06T18:27:56.11340118Nicola JoyceI currently have a family member at mainstream primary who has ASN. I am acutely aware that the support they currently receive can be withdrawn at any time. It is completely unfair, and unethical that they should be disadvantaged due to Edinburgh Council funding cuts. They should have exactly the same opportunity for education, and standard of education as their peers. 33192019-08-06T18:59:50.5140119Jill ThomsonThis is extremely important. It needs to change.32082019-08-06T19:01:53.3240120David WoodsIn my three years as a teacher I have only had two PSAs work with students in my class. PSAs make a huge contribution to student education and also help reduce behaviour issues in those who struggle to engage with work they find difficult to understand without significant support. If the Scottish Govt wish to promote a policy of inclusion and not one of designed neglect hidden behind progressive language then they must provide meaningful support to students with assisted support needs.33192019-08-06T19:04:56.72740121Julia McDermott I feel a family member has this and family could do with support to help us help them. 33182019-08-06T20:58:14.27740122Samantha I had big problems with a family member who was diagnosed having ADHD with support at school. It was was always someone elses problem. 33192019-08-06T21:19:49.4240123Mary Taylor When cats go missing it's such a worrying and heartbreaking time for owners, If this was passed then people would know what has happened to their fur babies. 31922019-08-06T21:27:30.7840124Celia HendersonWoody, killed by driver, who did not stop. I just hope Woody was killed outright and not left for hours to die. He was wearing a prominent tag with our phone number and was microchipped. Just one quick phone call would have saved considerable sadness and misery. 31922019-08-06T21:37:25.0340125Jackie MaceiraThis has to happen 32792019-08-06T21:44:23.18740126Ian HoodNew legislation is very much needed and I would urge everyone to sign this petition. I think that even with new legislation there will still be much that needs to be done to ensure that people with learning disabilities enjoy the same rights as everyone else. But nonethelss the Scottish Government should do all it can, including new legisation to support this. 32792019-08-06T22:13:46.1640127Irene ArchibaldMany years have passed since I had wee (!) ones. I really wished someone had promoted this, way back then. Older I get more I dread getting a cold for fear of coughing or sneezing..lets get the younger generation educated in this important subject. 32912019-08-06T22:15:52.39340128Isabel NICHOLSON We as a country should make sure each child should be given the extra help and this is why we pay our taxes 33192019-08-06T23:07:30.1240130Helena In theory the inclusion policy is a wonderful thing but without adequate training and funding, its fails the future generation. It also pushes good teachers out of the profession as they are not trained to deal with the range of needs that exist in one classroom. Families of children with ASN (I have family members with ASN) have constant worry and pressure, they should not have to also keep fighting for the support that their child needs to achieve. Sometimes it's only a little amount of support but it goes a long way. I have been told several times that a family member won't get adequate support due to cut backs. Appalling!33192019-08-07T00:06:23.53740131Grainne Brady Well done Elaine . This has to be added. Pelvic floor is very important... would've loved this information when i was younger . 32912019-08-07T00:48:39.9340132Deborah mcgoldrick This is so important for all children to meet their potential 33192019-08-07T09:47:38.1840133Karla BarrThis is so important in our schools ! 33192019-08-07T09:51:55.99340135Alan McManusThe few natural amenities in this area need protection, such as locks and golf course.31462019-08-07T10:33:48.740137Carol DonachieThe amount of development taking place in Gartcosh is shocking. I no longer visit The Loch Tearoom because of the level of traffic 31462019-08-07T12:09:36.96340138Jamie Harper There are too many estates springing up with little thought for local amenities or infrastructure. The environment it under severe pressure and us being compromised by corporate greed.31462019-08-07T12:10:40.82340139Donna Quinn Community voice been lost amongst large scale developments. No infrastructure to support the number of house builds and it's the local people who are being affected and having to live with the daily effects of this, with no voice what so ever on the matter. 31462019-08-07T12:52:40.02740140Sandra CampbellVast amount of new housing in my part of North Lanarkshire but no new amenities. Hard to get G.P. appointment and grandchildrens school overflowing.31462019-08-07T13:47:17.45740142Dr Phillip NevillePeople with learning disabilities may have the same rights and aspirations as others but opportunity is sadly lacking. Discrimination is still very evident.32792019-08-07T16:17:58.18340144Barry GaleIt is not clear to me what obligations will be placed upon whom if the Right to Food will become part of Scots Law. Neither is it clear why this is a problem for anybody. As with energy, telephone and banking, it is quite easy to get good deals by shopping around, buying fresh and avoiding ready meals. 32902019-08-07T18:41:40.54740146Julie WestMy experience over past 7 years has been that of having to fight every step of the way both with health and education. This battle is not over as my family member is not receiving the support they need at school and they are being failed. How funding is used would be a good start and GIRFEC needs to be adhered to.33192019-08-07T18:46:03.54740147Jenny ClarkCurrently ASL support is woefully inadequate and many children have seen their hours either cut or removed completely. This is completely unacceptable as local authorities cut services for the most vulnerable. Our children are being failed by a system in crisis. Surely funding for children with additional needs should be ring fenced to ensure there needs are fully met. I would like to add that I have a family member who has ASD and my experience of services and funding has been highly disappointing, frustrating and i have no idea what the future holds. Action at a local and national level is required now.33192019-08-07T18:50:39.93740148Jane moodleyMore support is required 33192019-08-07T19:22:06.640149Gavin Fawkes BrewisThis should be reviewed no questions asked. Some of these individuals have seen their rent rise by 90 percent in some cases which is abysmal and way above the line of wage or benefit increases. The Scottish parliament must do more or lose votes!32562019-08-07T19:26:25.89740150Ann Marie ReidI believe we are unique able bodied so why not treat us as an equal as we can do just about anything we put our minds to. I think if they lived a life in our shoes they would know how hard it is to be excepted in society. Learning disabilities or mental health conditions. 32792019-08-07T21:05:32.43340151Vanda Clelland Too many homes being built without facilities in place to suit the growing villages. 31462019-08-07T22:04:46.0740152Noel DarlowThere is no good reason for anyone to go hungry in a wealthy country like Scotland.\r\n\r\nThe callous disregard for human life which can allow this will hurt us all in the long run.32902019-08-07T22:40:27.37340153Emmajane TerryPlease provide access to appropriate education33182019-08-07T22:53:26.3140154Mark McQue Please start to listen to our smaller communities 31462019-08-07T23:04:21.06340155cugie cugieParental blame. Even after diagnosis and proven disability there's still parental blame. Cuts are more prevalent because NHS depts can't afford to inform just in case parents ask for supports that cost money!33192019-08-07T23:08:07.65740156Evelyn VrouwenfelderA family member has autism and I had never heard of PDA. For school and families having a toolkit would be essential to childrens' wellbeing and educational achievement.33182019-08-07T23:12:17.2540157Cathrine Cook More awareness and support for parents and teachers to understand how to best support children with PDA. 33182019-08-08T00:29:26.35340158leslie jonesI support this petition.32562019-08-08T00:33:28.82340159Clare ChalmersTo fully understand and therefore offer appropriate help and support for children with PDA it is vital Practitioners receive training in the condition. Training leads to early recognition early intervention which can make all the difference. PDA is a development disorder which is distinct from autism, there are differences. It is anxiety driven with a need to feel in control the problem is incapacity rather than naughtiness. Without recognition children can be left with a trial and error situation which is frustrating for everyone. To Get it right for PDA children there needs to be correct diagnosis followed by support strategies which are specific. A toolkit for practitioners would be a good way to go, hopefully leading onto positive outcomes and happy stress free children. Although more PDA cases are being diagnosed more needs to be done.\r\nFamilies should be involved at all stages and contribute to producing an effective toolkit. The PDA society should also be invited to contribute to a toolkit.\r\nMany children with PDA have suffered and been wrongly labelled as a result of poor recognition and support, it is time to ensure Scotland GETs It Right For PDA children.\r\n33182019-08-08T05:04:31.9740160Leeanna EmmonsIt needs to be recognized in the united states33182019-08-08T08:01:27.41740161Eleanor andersonThe young people need help, the parents need help, and the teachers and assistants need help. PDA is a really demanding, difficult condition to understand and all help would be really appreciated 33182019-08-08T08:31:48.0940162Mandy law Not right this32792019-08-08T13:06:21.36340164Lynn WatsonThis is desperately needed. I have 1st hand experience of having to educate a family member at home during extended periods of ill-health.\r\nProvision for ASD here translates to 'stuck in a base doing worksheets' in some cases.33192019-08-08T17:27:02.2140166Christina Murray causes grief to families already grieving 32672019-08-08T17:41:03.74340168Patricia CollinsIn the year 2019 it is totally unacceptable that there is food poverty especially in a rich country all options need to be considered and acted upon including dare I say - taxing the rich !!!!32902019-08-08T18:58:51.0540169Nicola HowatRoads and surround facilities are unsuitable for any further development and the disruption to existing residents is never considered as a significant factor31462019-08-08T20:50:21.86340170Kirsten TerryI live in Kent and I have found an enormous lack of awareness and lack of education among health and education professionals regarding PDA. Many have absolutely no understanding of PDA or the difficulties faced by the families, children and young people who deal with PDA everyday. The majority of schools are unable or unwilling to support children with PDA and many blame parenting rather than bother to research how they could help. I believe the development of a PDA toolkit would have a very positive impact. First of all, parents would feel believed and support could be provided at a much earlier point. Children could receive a diagnosis which would help professionals recognise PDA and learn strategies to provide support. Recognition of PDA would improve as would understanding. I think it would also positively impact on the mental health of both parents and children touched by PDA. I think the team should be from multiple diaciplines - parents, educationalists, psychologists but ultimately all those involved should be passionate about improving the support and understanding of PDA. 33182019-08-08T22:13:23.84340171Eleanor FergusonA member of my family has a learning disability so I am interested in this petition32792019-08-09T12:57:58.75740173David RobinsonAs someone who struggles to afford healthy and sustaining food, this petition is incredibly important. 32902019-08-09T13:50:20.31340175Brenda eganI fully support this32562019-08-09T14:32:51.03740176Claire kennyThe fact that affordable access to nutritious food has to be petitioned is a sad sad state of affairs.32902019-08-09T16:40:53.53740178anne CurrieI have supported the work of Nourish Scotland for a prolonged period and hope that I can see results soon.32902019-08-09T17:27:26.440179Richie CalderHaving access to food is a basic and fundamental right in any civilised society 32902019-08-09T20:55:32.22740182Susan MoodyIt is an absolute disgrace that in this current day, there is members of our Society who are not being given an accurate diagnosis and individualised description of how their condition effects them and signposts to the correct strategies that allow them to thrive in life.\r\nIt is therefore imperative that such information is made available to all service providers to prevent further trauma associated with continuting to signpost individuals to typical parenting, support strategies or Autism strategies. \r\nA Toolkit specifically for PDA is therefore required imminently, if not as a stand alone resource as a subset within the current Autism Toolkit. \r\nWith the huge emphasis on Scotland being an ACE aware Nation, it is shocking to allow children and adults to continue tp experience the trauma caused by the lack of adequate support and mismanagement from all public services. \r\nIt is time to not just raise awareness or acceptance but to take action to allow these individuals to access the support they so desperately need. For those already suffering to have the support to recover and better support moving forward and for those yet to come to not be subjected to the sheer ignorance that we see today.33182019-08-09T22:12:25.15340183Deborah Best I had to fight for a family members full education to get adequate support. The toll on my ability to care for my family was compromised due to the fights I was forced to take forward to ensure their inclusion and equality in their mainstream school \r\n33192019-08-09T22:22:22.15740184Abdah javaidGive our kids s better deal33192019-08-10T08:40:02.66340185John SinclairI wholeheartedly agree.32902019-08-10T11:35:53.01740186David Fraser You write about launching satellites from the North of Scotland. Please seriously consider using Prestwick Airport as well and the nearby University.32502019-08-10T12:21:40.3540187Jacqueline KennedySupport the children 33192019-08-10T12:25:16.4640188Elaine shaneI've had to fight for 6 years and my family member was so badly provided for in mainstream they are in p7 and can only read cat hat and mat. Being left in back of classes as an hour a day IS maximum one on one provision in mainstream! That is not inclusion its exclusion esp when they start getting bullied as they are the dumb child but its really they have not had the proper care for their needs. My family member ended up on strong beta blockers to attend school. Now they are in an ALN with 98 % children with severe physical disabilities. No they do not belong their either but at least they feel safe! DISGRACE to our children the mess and stress for both teachers whom most haven't been trained for autism and learning difficulties in main stream schools and physically impossible to deal with 31 other children and our kids needs. The inclusion support is a joke33192019-08-10T13:04:43.59740190RAJAN KUMARI support this petition.31842019-08-10T15:15:58.40740191Stuart Graham No one should be punished for being poor and unfortunately this manifests as hunger when people can't afford food among the rising cost of everything and continued austerity 32902019-08-10T17:51:05.2440192Satish kumar gosiI support this petition 31842019-08-10T19:41:08.09340193Nikki Brannan Animals should be treated with respect and are entitled to a good quality of life 32902019-08-10T22:51:03.15340195Ayesha KhanI have a family member with severe autism and the local council social work are refusing to help giving them an SDS Budget. The local authority make you go through different processes to then refuse any help they qualify for. We are going through a very difficult time and no support is being given. 33192019-08-11T09:02:06.5940196Pauline Pettigrove Cats are a huge part of family life, how can they be treated as anything less. A family grieve over loss just as much as they would for any family members 31922019-08-11T16:36:30.63740197Sam GhoshI have a family member at asn school with autism 33192019-08-11T18:04:00.9940198babs macgregorWe have the resources to nourish all our people well - let's resolve at a political and community level to do this.32902019-08-11T20:03:38.13740199Ariane BurgessFood is essential for life, food sovereignty should be a human right. Everyone should have access to unprocessed, nutrient-rich, regeneratively grown food. 32902019-08-11T20:32:59.65340200JB McGuire Knowing the vital work being done daily by People First Scotland , I fully support this petition to improve the experience of people with learning disability and bring it in line with that enjoyed by other citiizens in Scotland. Equality of human rights and access to standards and treatment for people with learning disabilties - in every aspect of their lives - should be a given entitlement in any democracy and the right change in legislation would help improve this and change the public attitutde, enhancing the life environment for anyone with learning disability. Such a change would also raise the bar in the approach by professionals and their expectations of this vulnerable section of the population.32792019-08-12T10:36:24.9140201Cameron MorrisonI wholeheartedly support this petition and hope the right thing is done and the petition is successful in securing its objectives. Previous generations fought so hard to protect their land and property but it seems in recent times the land grab which we thought was buried in the past is reading its ugly head again.32672019-08-12T10:41:17.36340202Catherine MorrisonHope this will be taken seriously by all concerned32672019-08-12T11:24:28.1240203John Macdonald Well done for bringing this to our attention, should certainly be exempt 32672019-08-12T11:59:41.140204marjory greiga very worthwhile cause which would assist a lot of anxiety sufferers.33442019-08-12T13:34:02.3340206Zena MackenzieThis is long overdue. Well done you.32672019-08-12T14:20:05.69340207Jenny KiernanWhy is healthy food always so expensive but unhealthy food is so much cheaper?32902019-08-12T15:41:12.2440208Kath mMaceShould be exempt32672019-08-12T16:22:51.00740209Laura McVicar I have a family member with autism. Their school is clearly struggling to fund any additional support. You want to put children with ASN into a main stream school.... fine, but give the school the support it needs. It's so imperative children with ASL needs get the right education. They are human beings do not treat them as second class citizens, they have a right to learn, to be seen and to be heard. They want to learn like any other child and have an education. 33192019-08-12T17:49:31.75740210kenneth mac kinnonits morally wrong,those unfortunate people have worked hard all their lives,paid taxes and national insurance and for the government to deprive them of their family home because they need some care is just so wrong it should be illegal.32672019-08-12T17:50:52.2940211Fiona Mac LeodThe whole point of security of tenure for crofters was to keep people on and working the land but if crofts are going to be sold off like this to the highest bidder it defeats the whole purpose and will end this way of life in the Highlands and islands. Only those who can afford to pay the highest prices will be able to live here, unlikely to be young people with families. 32672019-08-12T18:31:50.8440212Elenor MacleayWrong on so many levels, robbery by muggers in pinstripe suits sitting at desks in the city!32672019-08-12T18:38:07.68740213Annette RussettCats are peoples' much loved pets. They should be respected. People should drive carefully where there are dwellings as there could be cats crossing the road.31922019-08-12T18:46:35.2840214John Maciverwhen you already pay £750 a month for care and they wish to the home to pay for care something needs to sorted out 32672019-08-12T19:39:38.14740215Stephen WalkerFamily member operates a Croft which has been in her family for many generations and which other family members take an active interest in. I feel it would be a travesty if the Croft and house had to be sold off if family members had to go into care. Is there not a parallel with the Clearances?32672019-08-12T19:55:08.16340217Kenneth MathesonA thoroughly bad, short sighted practice which further weakens and destabilises already fragile communities - and oddly being undertaken by a the body whose core remit ought to be supporting and strengthening their crofting communities. It ought to stop immediately. 32672019-08-12T21:23:28.47340218Naomi RobartsTotally agree Crofts should not be taken into account during assessment32672019-08-12T21:27:45.4940219Marie CummingExemption is a necessity for what is important lively hood for many32672019-08-12T21:28:33.03740220Fraser CummingCrofters should be exempt32672019-08-12T21:40:26.88340221Susan HarveyCurrently buying a croft tenancy, with every intention of passing it on to family member, who will also living there and in time, other family members. Given its not considered capital on which to raise a mortgage how can it be capital for council use? How is that incouraging families into crofting?32672019-08-12T22:18:07.79340222Anne MacleodGenerations of people have made untold sacrifices to pass on their homes and crofts to their children and their children's children. Very often the land and the home was all that they had. 32672019-08-12T22:23:43.01340223Anne MacleodGenerations of people have made untold sacrifices to pass on their homes and crofts to their children and their children's children. Very often the land and the home was all that they had. 32672019-08-12T22:29:49.59340224alex macdonaldunder no circumstances should we lose croftland32672019-08-12T22:42:58.29740225donald mac millanvery unfair32672019-08-12T22:45:54.54740226Christopher smithBest of luck with petition.32672019-08-12T23:28:05.55340227John Daniel PeterannaCroft should be exempt, to allow them to be left to the next generation 32672019-08-13T00:01:50.24340228Stuart PatersonThe right to food and therefore to live is a right that ought to be had by all. For those unfortunate enough not to have food, our country is wealthy enough to support and protect them.32902019-08-13T00:53:02.9740229Claire Hamilton Russell Disabled rights are human rights32792019-08-13T07:16:22.62740230Ian Murdo MacdonaldI hope this petition is successful. We are as a family in exactly the same position, with our family home being taken by CNES as part of the charges for a family member's care . Th effect of this policy is not only to deprive a family of a home in my case the only home I have as I live in a tied house, but further denude our villages and communities of local families who have lived there for generations. 32672019-08-13T08:21:33.47740231James MacDonaldCrofting needs to be supported in every way. 32672019-08-13T09:17:44.29740232Allan Cameron Maclachlan Hope this petition is successful 32672019-08-13T09:41:21.4440233Kathleen HartIt is a basic human right that people should have enough food to eat.32902019-08-13T10:07:14.6340234Derek Stewart Families built these houses and crofts to be handed on to there loved ones not to fill a council black hole try cutting some of the pointless travel that could be saved by using video conference calls 32672019-08-13T11:42:03.7940235Angus MacdonaldBefore the Crofting Act 1886 tenants were treated like a lower caste of human despite in many cases being more intelligent, more honest and less manipulative than their 'masters'. The bureaucracy of the crofting commission and crofting law sadly continues this character assassination. It is not the fault of people who have had to go away from home to fulfil their potential but the lack of investment and contempt over decades by ignorant politicians and bureaucrats. Enterprise stifled, communication backward, land use turning into wet deserts. I personally will not accept this contempt any longer.32672019-08-13T14:07:12.03740236Rev. Donald R LawrieFood means life good food and healthy eating means a quality of life that ultimately benefits everyone. Healthy body, mind and spirit amongst individuals ultimately means a healthier and less burdened society.32902019-08-13T15:36:55.59740237Mal MacleodCrofting tenure was always meant to pass to family members and should be exempt from any local authority charges32672019-08-13T16:43:19.30340238Wilma McKenzieI'm sick of people with special needs being treated so badly by the Government it's absolutely disgraceful.32792019-08-14T13:12:21.48340240Tracey Turner The inconsistencies across the UK beggars belief and makes parents, such as myself, so frustrated, angry, depressed with feelings of failure because of this. Some parents are paying in excess of £2k for a private diagnosis, just so they and their child can get the correct help and support. \r\nI have been advised by a charitable helpline that a family member appears to have PDA not clinical psychologists charging thousands to assess them for adhd for the last 6 years. \r\npsychologists should know symptoms and traits of all conditions, just in the same way a gp has a broad knowledge of nearly all physical illnesses. \r\n33182019-08-14T17:39:22.93740242Pauline Anderson Its important for all children to get an education. A toolbox for working with our children would make a vast difference. A family member is struggling in school and their school is using PDA strategies to help them cope. Thos should be the same for all children with PDA. Children are very clever and will be great members of society and the workforce. Please give them a chance to do by having a PDA toolbox in schools. 33182019-08-15T08:05:02.7540243Leif Brag Must be done if we are to have any trust in the system. \r\nThings cannot continue the way it is.33122019-08-15T08:28:34.12340245R Neil TheodoresonThis is required so that those tagging can't be accused of with holding information or tampering with the information gathered. It is only fair that this data is open and scrutable.33122019-08-15T08:36:29.57740246M PorterQuite why the Police are not insisting on all the historical tag data for a minimum period of 6 months prior to the tag failure in any alleged wildlife crime is a question in itself. Under disclosure law I would see this as necessary for the investigation and would robustly challenge any conviction or indeed initial investigation based on tag data from a short period of time. In criminal law all exculpatory evidence must be available in fairness to any suspect or accused to ensure fairness to an accused (a cornerstone of Scots law often ignored by groups with agendas).33122019-08-15T09:05:30.2740247Ian Macphee Time it was transparent 33122019-08-15T09:14:16.8240248Lindsay BellIndependent body is the only way forward. All to often evidence is withheld from police by people and groups with ulterior motives.33122019-08-15T09:27:12.74340249Alan James ParrThis needs to be monitored by the police who should have an open mind as to who are committing these crimes. The perpetrators should be dealt with robustly whoever they are. \r\nAlso misleading comments without sound evidence should also be dealt with. Many people are being branded wrongly I believe and it is affecting their lives as well as their families. 33122019-08-15T09:32:34.89740250Gareth MannGrouse moors are under increasing attack using data generated by these tracking devices. Its only fair that all interested parties should have access to this data. 33122019-08-15T09:34:00.61740251Bill CowieThere are many reasons for signing this petition, the independant experts are responsible for much disturbance of nests which go unrecorded and the fitting of any foreign body to a wild animal is in itself wrong, these animals were not designed to carry bits of plastic on their bodies, for what purpose?33122019-08-15T09:51:42.94740252Martyn O'ReillyGet rid of any doubts and have the raptors independently monitored . This will get rid of disinformation and lead to a sensible discussion about the future of the countryside33122019-08-15T10:19:33.12340253Martin KayIndependent custody and verification of tag data by Police Scotland will improve reaction times to suspected crimes and remove the potential for misuse of data for political or campaign purposes. The cost impact will not be significant as at present there is likely to be a significant cost impact in obtaining and assessing data. Standardisation of data format will also confer efficiency benefits.33122019-08-15T10:35:53.06340254Steve Evans Need level playing field to counter all the trials by social media33122019-08-15T10:51:11.17740255Falconer WallaceI wholeheartedly support this petition to pit an end to unproven accusations33122019-08-15T10:58:14.0540256Paul RobinsonThis monitoring must be introduced to aid in the crimes concerning raptor specied33122019-08-15T11:24:23.7140257Denis John ValentineAction must be taken NOW.33122019-08-15T11:47:34.74340258Terry BakerSick of the lies and false accusations of the RSPB and other organisations 33122019-08-15T11:51:34.52740259Kevin Atchison We need total transpatency needs to be an independant party.33122019-08-15T13:09:34.84740260David CaterNeeded to. Void false data being used against people employed in the countryside 33122019-08-15T13:13:31.69340261iain crosbieMore transparency is needed regarding the tagging of raptors33122019-08-15T13:45:20.77340263Daniel Monitoring should be carried out by independent Impartial bodies and not by one sided organisations with hidden agendas 33122019-08-15T13:57:44.07340264Colin LavinIn the interests of fairness and openness sattelite tag data must be made available to the public and especially to the Police when birds go missing or are found dead33122019-08-15T14:00:46.5940265Donald S WrightUnbiased evidence required.33122019-08-15T14:28:59.1640266Derek McLachlanThis is a fundamental essential to all and should be available to all no matter your circumstances and should include housing also.32902019-08-15T14:42:29.36740268Alistair Meikle We definitely need an independent organisation to monitor raptors to avoid any misinformation going on social media33122019-08-15T15:30:15.61740269Joanne RotherayI want to be able to eat good Scottish food32902019-08-15T15:41:22.10740270Charlotte Webb Without independent monitoring there is too much room for alteration, lack of recording, tampering. Any data needs to be correct and in order.33122019-08-15T16:11:04.15340271Melvin LackGood is everybody's right and should be available for all by sustained means.32902019-08-15T17:00:08.2340272Morag MackenzieGood quality, healthy and affordable food should be available for all and is certainly a basic human right. The production of the food we consume also needs to be good for the environment - that has to be a given. Governments need to ensure that food production is ethical, sustainable and affordable. Perhaps if food producers were held to account on what is proving to be profit over health then we might see a difference. We don't need the health service picking up the cost of poor diet.32902019-08-15T17:08:51.2440274Edward JentasWe all deserve to have available healthy and nutritious food, sufficient to feed the population of the world. We could always take away the obscene sums of money from the mega rich and spread it around. They can't take it with them 32902019-08-15T18:21:45.2140276ALEX StewartI have started to grow my own veg as it is getting expensive to buy and so is the other foods32902019-08-15T20:36:21.6940279wendy barriegood clean fair food for all32902019-08-15T20:56:49.8440280Sally Hesford Much more awareness and understanding of this condition is essential for Early Years practitioners and everyone who contributes to development in children. 33182019-08-16T05:53:49.12340284peter watersCentralisation and main town hubs are destroying long established towns and villages.31462019-08-16T08:01:09.16340287Ann WarrenThe right to decent food is such a basic right & I fully support this campaign.32902019-08-16T11:03:47.31740288Flora MacIsaacFamily homes and crofts should be kept in the family and passed down to the he next generation.I hope this petition is successful.32672019-08-16T11:04:54.7340289Marie LaceyI am working with children with additional needs and would welcome some guidance to help myself and others support this need,33182019-08-16T12:07:38.42740290Dixie PorterCrofts should be exempt to allow them to be passed to the next generation. Best of luck with petition.32672019-08-16T19:19:23.64340297WilsonAll buildings should be maintained to an acceptable standard, plus owners should be liable if this is not done.33482019-08-16T20:14:57.17340302Donald AndersonWe don't wish to return to the Highland Clearences, stop this nonsense.32672019-08-16T23:20:12.67740305Karen McCormick It is a disgrace that in this day and age that so many children are being failed by a system that could be so easily solved..... Parents are having to fight for the right for their childrens support & education.... This is so wrong on so many levels.... Utter disgrace.... The government & local councils should be ashamed of themselves.... We are in the 21st century not the dark ages..... Get a grip for the sake of our children's futures!!!!! 33182019-08-16T23:59:04.38740306Iain ClarkToo many listed buildings are being left too long whereby they fall into a state of disrepair far beyond the condition they would have been in had they been subjected to a maintenance plan.33482019-08-17T09:15:03.96340309Edward FowlerPeople with learning disabilities are ignored. Their human rights are abused and they are not listened to. They are not given legal advice or access to a solicitor. 32792019-08-17T11:28:42.8640311Barbara RichardsI was diagnosed with PTSD in 2005 and Asperger Syndrome in 2007, but I've been rediagnosed by local police as a pest and my GP colluded with others to stalk me so they could take away my PIP and now I am a prisoner I hardly go anywhere and people laugh at me and call me a loser and a nutter. I think they want me to kill myself and one day I nearly did, I was going to throw myself off the motorway bridge but my neighbour stopped me. I don't have a life in just existing I listen to music and paint and try to block it out but I get very very very depressed. I've tried to complain about it but all the complaints are blocked and PALS are useless and I can't get a lawyer so I feel like nothing. I am not allowed to marry my partner they've all ganged up on me and I don't know what to do. 33182019-08-17T12:12:30.1940313Marion Donnelly I think that the wording of the rent act is not sufficient and does not realistically ensure determination of a fair rent . Tennents should have the right to review decisions heard by persons who have a local knowledge of local properties. I am well aware of local residents who struggle to pay monthly rents .who's accommodation is under threat due to lack of finances .32562019-08-17T15:46:20.7540314Barbara Ann Dow Teachers do not get enough training or proper support in teaching for people with PDA. \r\nIf you want to get people with PDA into employment you need to give them and employers the tools to do so. 33182019-08-17T23:03:26.36340318Laura raynerplease make people more aware of PDA. Family member is suffering as there is no help or support out there. They are almost 10 33182019-08-18T08:03:06.09740319Alison PalmerIt is simple common decency to help save the life of any animal. Not only would this bill save a cat's life, it could act as a deterrent for speeding and to make drivers more aware of what is going on around them. Please make this bill law. I picked up someone's cat a few months ago that had been sadly killed, but left in the road. Cats are not just animals....they are part of someone's family. If your pet is killed away from home you sometimes never get closure. Spare a thought, please.31922019-08-18T12:39:38.15740322Fred Godden Fully agree that Croft and Croft property should be exempt from care charges.32672019-08-18T13:33:05.76340323John Gordon BoothWe must make a stand against this.32672019-08-18T13:43:53.29740324Angus John Campbell A total disgrace 32672019-08-18T15:42:42.41740325ianmacinnesThese crofts and croft houses have been in families for generations and should remain so other wise traditions and ways of life will be lost32672019-08-18T23:40:09.0340335Zabdi KeenFood without unnessesary packaging - Local food businesses like the Isle of Arrans creamery that has just had to close should be supported to allow local produce to be available. 32902019-08-18T23:43:42.3640336Iain MaciverIt is very sad that Crofters rights which were won at great cost are now being disregarded so shamefully by our Scottish Government.32672019-08-19T08:35:12.44340339Fiona McCormackOne of the biggest issues is the presumption of mainstream schooling for all without enough adequately trained staff, appropriate facilities or adequate funding. 33192019-08-19T09:57:39.540342Evie MurrayHow did we ever get to a situation whereby the most basic right of all, the right to food, is withheld from those most in need of it, in such cruel and humiliating ways.\r\n32902019-08-19T10:01:32.4440343Karen BirchWe see many challenges here in The Borders which I have no doubt are replicated across parts of Scotland - having to check for signs of malnutrition in our old folk when they attend community meals, fresh, local produce being unavailable or unaffordable in rural communities, obesity due to the ready access to high calorie but low nutritional value junk food and young people not knowing where their food comes from and how to prepare even the simplest meals. We need a bill that will ensure that everyone, regardless of personal circumstances, has access to healthy, nutritious food which has been fairly produced. 32902019-08-19T10:13:09.0840344Lindsey As a retired teacher I have first hand experience of how important support is, should be increased not decreased 33192019-08-19T10:36:32.9340346Jo HuntI work 70 hours a week growing healthy food on our family croft, and distributing it to 500 local people. Last year I earned £0.93 an hour for this work and relied on volunteers to help. We urgently need a more just food system.32902019-08-19T12:07:55.2240349Susan CrosthwaiteFood is medicine. Everyone should have the right to good quality healthy food and refined sugar and trans fats should be highlighted as a danger to health. 32902019-08-19T12:19:28.8740350Helen ScammellMany people in our community do not have access to decent healthy and cheap food or can't afford to buy food. \r\nIt is appalling in this day and age that people are forced to go to food banks because of sanctions or too little benefits to live a dignified fulfilling life.. Having to make choices between things like being warm, clothing your children or eating is not acceptable in this day and age and in this country. 32902019-08-19T12:47:05.51340352Leanne tweedieI have family members with support needs. One ADHD and other diagnosis there is not enough support or understanding 33192019-08-19T12:52:38.740353Susan CormackMy experience over 20 years and three generations of ASD children, not much has changed only got worse. 33192019-08-19T14:12:32.86340356Gordon RuddimanAmongst any other practical way we can get nutritious food to people in need how about the new Scottish Government Best Start Food cards just launched on the 12th of August. Can this scheme not be used to help those who can easily be identified by the benefits they are on whether working or not to receive extra funds for a possibly wider range of 'best start foods' instead of a blanket approach to 'holiday hunger'?32902019-08-19T14:15:46.19740357Maureen PriceI worked for 26 years in a school for young people with learning difficulties, from 5-17 years, and I realised that when they left school or college there was very little support for them. I spent a week going around firms that may offer suitable employment, but in most cases the work was automated. The lack of provision affects not only the young person but their families too. All through school families and schools and other groups working with the young people have to fight for what should be their right.32792019-08-19T15:09:17.2340358Caroline RobertsonBack to basics! Food is a necessity, not a luxury. \r\n The entire population must be more engaged in where their food comes from and in growing, buying , preparing , enjoying food. Does not need to be fancy, so called simple meals such as lentil soup, omelette, bean casserole, with or without meat are cheap and easy to prepare. But here's one of the catches, they do require a wee bit of forward planning and preparation, something which has been lost to too many folks. At the very least the Scottish government will have to reinstate home economics classes in schools as well as tackling the issue of unable or unwilling parents in this respect. Supermarkets have a role to play by reducing the range of rubbishy products on sale, but of course that means loss of revenue.32902019-08-19T15:12:22.240359Caroline RobertsonThe entire population must be more engaged in where their food comes from and be involved wherever possible in growing, shopping, preparing, eating, enjoying and valuing food as an intrinsic part of life.32902019-08-19T15:50:18.39740360Adewale AyorindeFood is inevitable to every living soul and not to be formated. Everybody should easily have access to fair and green foods.32902019-08-19T16:10:32.59740362Neil MacarthurAfter decades of striving for a reasonable lifestyle residing in a crofting community I find it appalling that after Decades of hard work and sacrifice made by our forefathers that their earned income which they carefully saved is now being plundered by Social Work Depts. of the various Local Authorities.Do they have any legal right to do this or is this decision taken on the whim of a so called "Legal Expert" I feel sore having paid thousands of pounds to Comhairle Nan Eileen to pay for the care of severely disabled family member.\r\nI hope that this petition is given the respect and consideration it deserves. It is fighting the case for the most vulnerable in our communities 32672019-08-19T18:01:24.60340363Sarah willshireHaving a family member with autism and pda I think this would be really beneficial especially in schools who have no idea how to deal with children like this and instead that child is being punished and excluded from school for behaviours they have no control of. They have personally been a victim of this situation and has been out of school now for 6months. They are 6years old and the way they have been treated is disgusting 33182019-08-19T18:55:07.83340364Donella FerrierCrofting tenancies should be exempt from local council Financial Assessment for care charges. 32672019-08-19T19:34:10.88740365Alastair lawWe only have one planet and we need to act now before it is too late33432019-08-19T19:42:24.51340366Jean FrewWe urgently need legislation to make supermarkets responsible for the plastic that they are forcing consumers to buy provisions in....they can then take it up with their suppliers33432019-08-19T19:45:21.4540367Jean FrewSupermarkets should be made to take back all the single use plastic and pay for its disposal...as they have to in Japan....where there is now hardly any single use plastic because of this law..33432019-08-19T20:13:04.3940369Phyllis mcneI fully support this to save our environment 33432019-08-19T21:24:51.30740370Tricia LaffertyThere is no need for some single covered plastics on foods such as cucumber, bananas and a whole lot more can be done to reduce plastics.33432019-08-19T21:44:10.18340372David AtkinsonFood should be at the heart of Scottish Culture\r\n We have a distinctive food production system which produces food and sustains producer and linked communities. We need to maintain this and to continue to work with our distinctive land resource which is just so fifferent from other parts of the UK32902019-08-19T21:54:48.96740373Kenny BartonAll children deserve appropriate and adequate support to ensure their full possible development 33192019-08-19T23:55:11.79740375Martin CharltonEven better give everyone a universal basic income, that would enable people to buy food tampons etc without being humiliated by poverty. 32902019-08-20T02:38:20.44340376Carol-Ann MillerThis is a well put together petition. The Parliament Committees, Scottish Government and Local Authorities also need to give thought to provision for children with additional needs during the long summer school holidays. There is hardly any specialist need provisions and those which do generally require a family member or carer to be present, which would prevent parents from working. Also many mainstream clubs use volunteers and coaches, so they have no actual childcare training or experience of dealing with children with additional needs. 33192019-08-20T07:21:54.12340377Sarah AlisonHad my hysterectomy at 37, just wish it had been years later and also a friend on Saturday was buried, she had womb cancer, thought it was just heavy periods. Says it all really.33212019-08-20T07:29:32.29740379Janet RichardsonInvest in our farmers, enable sustainable food production bearing in mind we are an island and unfortunately rely mainly on foreign imported food which in the future may not be affordable. Time to rethink food production in the U.K. 32902019-08-20T08:15:10.0940382Stuart MillerEveryone should have access to food, it's a fundamental right32902019-08-20T08:44:18.90740385Zereeshka Mackintosh More support needed for families 33192019-08-20T09:09:35.44340386AnnJane McKissockLooking to support a better world for my grandchild. There is no need for the amount of plastics used 33432019-08-20T11:36:45.4340389Tamara GillEarly prevention is so much better than curing and can be so life affecting if we get it wrong! This is the kind of stuff young women genuinely don't know about until it is too late. 32912019-08-20T12:20:26.440390James LowIt is important to protect the natural beauty of our countryside and the local wildlife. Unfortunately there is a growing number of persons and groups that abuse the "wild camping" ethos. The cost of camping equipment, bbq's, etc is now so inexpensive they are now throwaway items. unfortunately they have become abandoned items. Consultation will be required to agree a way forward however National Parks, Regional Parks should totally ban "wild camping" withe informed discussion undertaken to identify other areas. 33302019-08-20T12:59:42.61340392Margaret MackenzieSigning on behalf of people with complex combined needs32792019-08-20T13:18:53.24340393Deborah McLachlanWomen have the right to do as they wish with their bodies! It shouldn't be anyone else's decision! 33212019-08-20T13:50:30.57340396lauren mcphersonCome on Scotland, lets get this signed and shared - a great to start saving our planet!33432019-08-20T15:16:43.08740397Robertha GovanI want all this petition asks for also good support for the farmers involved who have done everything governments have asked for through every crisis, now they are facing CLIMATE CHANGE !32902019-08-20T15:28:21.03340398Gillian CameronKeep the natural environment.31462019-08-20T15:29:25.48740399Elise Rayner Having suffered from pelvic pain and knowing how the NHS provide very little support for pregnant and post-natal women in pain I fully support this request. I didn't know I was doing pelvic floor exercises wrong for 2 years until I saw a private physiotherapist. Advice like this could have made a difference. Too many women suffer in silence. 32912019-08-20T15:39:46.45740400May KeeganEducation is needed for all schools dealing with pda 33182019-08-20T16:52:29.140401Sally AndersonPDA IS REAL, Too many parents, claimed by medical & educational professionals. sent on loads of parenting courses being told how to parent children etc. Family were were lucky.it only took 4 years to get family member's correct diagnosis to be told, ignore everything you were tought on the course.it wont work or will make them worse. Family knew that.we they had been telling everyone else that for 4 years. because it's not yet in diagnosis manual there is far too many differences depending on the professional you deal with & also it's a postcode lottery. Children deserve every opportunity to live their lives to their best potential without either killing themselves intentionally or accidentally or another individuals because they cant cope with life.33182019-08-20T17:43:19.61340403Russell EastonWell done keith this is a good piece of work id like to be more involved in this 32792019-08-20T17:45:04.81740405Dawne Randell A young primary age family member has been to two primary schools and is now home schooled because the education system is not able to meet their needs. Family has found nobody in the education system so far that knows what they are doing for a child with PDA. It has been up to family to provide resources and sign post to resources for those who have worked with family membr but unfortunately it's not taken on board and they have suffered. There needs to be a complete overhall of the system. 33182019-08-20T18:02:56.0840407Nell WhitelawLong term disabilities should be recognised. 32792019-08-20T18:16:11.67340408jan craighaving suffered like Megan from the age of 15 i was in a bad way. at 23 after two investigative operations proved nothing i had a very bad experience and doctors thought incorrectly i was having a miscarriage. This happened 3 times and despite asking for a hysterectomy a further 3 times the pain and excess bleeding only stopped after a hysterical ablation and sterilisation at age 51. too many years wasted. the system needs to do more to help women33212019-08-20T18:25:27.78740409Donna BoyleI chose to have my hysterectomy when I was twenty seven. The pain was unbearable. Early menopause is manageable. You should be able to choose what you want and need to give you a better quality of life. 33212019-08-20T18:32:56.640411Martin McDonaldGood luck Megan33212019-08-20T19:40:56.2440413VICKY MCDONALDAttitudes to these kind of problems need to change. 33212019-08-20T20:12:21.09740414Emma carmichael I've had horrible periods since I started getting them and had no answers, completely agree with this cause 33212019-08-20T20:17:07.5240416Linda Bootland There should be support for all those who need it33192019-08-20T20:52:05.83740418Alka nandaI support this petition 32792019-08-20T21:18:34.3140421Liz AndersonGood luck in your fight. I have suffered with Endometriosis for over 20yrs & they palm you off with painkillers. We are the ones to suffer on a daily basis.. keep fighting. xx 33212019-08-20T21:27:04.34740422Maggie ThorburnSchools require funding to enable children with additional needs to achieve maximum potential and not stagnate in a corner.33192019-08-20T21:33:09.23340423Lauren walker Provide protection for small communities 31462019-08-20T22:31:48.02740425Elizabeth SouterTeachers need much more training and support in order to deal with all the issues that children with PDA have to deal with in their lives. 33182019-08-20T22:36:07.27340426Maria HarkinThis is a much needed service. PDA is still such a new diagnosis that most professionals have never even heard of it. For that reason parents aren't being heard and in turn are directed to the wrong services. 33182019-08-20T23:08:48.540428Elizabeth SouterPDA continues to be an unknown condition even to those working in the education system. Just a naughty child is usually the response! Time to get real in the Scottish Education system! Hope J S is reading this! 33182019-08-21T04:32:48.52740429Andrena BlizzardWe have these types of companion dogs in Australia. They do help tremendously..They are known generally as assistance dogs.33442019-08-21T06:55:14.6140430Carole BrownEven with a Coordinated Support Plan, it is difficult to obtain the supports stated in the plan. Appropriate support for speech impairments is especially difficult to obtain.33192019-08-21T07:41:21.55740431Fiona GartlandThese children and young adults are being failed by the system and its not fair on them or their families. They deserve so much more 33182019-08-21T08:16:47.68740433Lesley MacraeI am 38 years old and have had 2 children my family making is over now. After years of horrendous periods and struggling to get pregnant I have asked for a hysterectomy and yet they won't give me one. They know my full history and how much I have suffered and yet it is not even being considered. I think all women have a right to choose what happens to them and if they want this surgery then they should be able to at least speak about it and explore their options without being shut down at the first discussion. Yes it is a life changing procedure and a lot of counselling should be involved to make sure it is the right thing to do especially for younger women but we should be able to decide for ourselves what's best.33212019-08-21T09:28:46.29340437Catherine kelly I believe that Scotland should support people with additional learning needs32792019-08-21T10:34:34.03740449Andrew FindlayA long overdue move of focus in the way people with learning disabilities are treated by the state.32792019-08-21T10:54:08.32340452Elizabeth Atwell Personally think it should be lowered for any reason, not just medical but medical is definitely a more pressing issue.33212019-08-21T11:32:56.1140460Sheila GraySchool children's parents should be made more aware of all the duties ASN people do. Cutting funding for them does not only put a child with special needs at risk but also every other child in that school at risk too. Cuts should be made elsewhere as ASN support seems to be the first cut councils will make.They are invaluable to ever child in the school.33192019-08-21T11:47:59.56740462Sue FlemingOur bodies our choice! It is all about £ & litigation. They don't want to give younger women hysterectomies just incase they decide l8r to sue if they decide they wanted children!33212019-08-21T12:21:47.3840465Annemarie Osmond More funding & time to adapt lessons for sen children to go into mainstream schools 33192019-08-21T13:35:39.01740468Connie paterson Because family members and others deserve to be helped. 33182019-08-21T14:56:56.74340473Sheena Crosbie PDA is a real condition. Show it the respect it deserves and provide support and resources to help. 33182019-08-21T16:18:49.6540482Gillian JohnstonThe lack of understanding around PDA extends well beyond the failings of the Scottish Education system. This condition is so poorly understood that individuals and families are being placed under intolerable amounts of stress having to fight against misjudgements and mistreatment from across all aspects of society. I am hoping that the development of this PDA toolkit will be the start of real change that will educate people to fully understand the range of challenges being faced and what is the correct approach to take to offer support. I hope that everyone with an interest and willingness to get involved will be able to contribute towards the development of this vital resource.33182019-08-21T16:45:57.48340483Miriam McLeodWe have a very patchy experience of ASN provision. Individuals can be excellent but we have been continually 'encouraged' (i.e. forced) to work within mainstream, which has been hugely at a family member's expense. They have been excluded by peers and is often painted as much more able than they are. As parents we find our views, though asked for, are simply not listened to. I suspect pressure on budgets drive this culture. Its sickening to be at the receiving end of, and there are children really suffering. My family member is one of them. Improve resources and funding now.33192019-08-21T16:55:40.43740485Julia HollandI have a family member with ASD. They are on the social bit of the austism spectrum (and verbal), and yet the over crowed schools of Edinburgh South, and the lack of funding make it impossible for them to go to school with friends locally. They had to be sent to a speech and language class with not much social interaction with the rest of the school, 30 minutes drive away from our home. This is truly a sad start in their educational life, the law is on their side (for main stream) but not the facilities. Please act soon.33192019-08-21T17:06:11.71340487Julie StewartMy family member would have benefited from more help at a mainstream school33192019-08-21T18:09:27.11340491Kerryann mooneyA family member has additional needs and attends mainstream primary school , more money to fund additional staff33192019-08-21T18:37:11.60340494Deborah Punton I am 28 year years old and have been told I am unable to have children and have not had a "proper period" since my teens due to starting early. I have been told many times that I am not allowed a hysterectomy because "I may change my mind" when I don't actually have the choice at all! Things should change especially when we women suffer horrendous pain!33212019-08-21T18:54:06.84340495mary elliott rodden Please consider as no women should suffer unnecessarily 33212019-08-21T19:59:29.52340500Elizabeth russellLetting us all down 33192019-08-21T20:36:36.07740502Diane johnstonIt is an absolute disgrace that the funding for Support assistants in the schools in East Renfrewshire has been cut. The support assistants are valuable to aid with the teaching of the class and the fact that a family member who is now starting s4 does not have a permanent member of staff to support their needs is ludicrous.33192019-08-21T20:47:37.540503Ruth Macleod Please ensure adequate funding for children and young people with additional and complex health and support needs33192019-08-21T21:01:04.62740504Brenda WilliamsAs a retired Depute Headteacher, I KNOW how important this funding is and the amazing support that was given in the past when the funding was secure. 33192019-08-21T21:03:02.03340505Jayne ScollayMany children with ASN being failed with poor education and poor support. Our children are our future. Equal opportunities are worthless without adequate support 33192019-08-21T21:29:41.2840506zoe menelaws currently working in education with ASL see the effects of children with additional needs in mainstream 33192019-08-21T21:44:48.55740507Sarah martinMore important than extended nursery hours!33192019-08-21T22:02:42.4840509James MclayPeople with Life Long Learning disabilities require their human rights and services to be protected.32792019-08-21T22:35:43.80740512Kay MelvilleHaving taught as a class teacher and also a specialist teacher of ASN children I have to say that much more money for staff and other resources is desperately needed along with auxiliary staff training. Teachers and schools are already at breaking point. 33192019-08-21T22:55:04.6940513Carrie McCoy\r\nMuch more funding is needed.33192019-08-21T23:33:02.8340516Nicola Waddell GIRFEC is currently not working. Children with and without additional support needs are being failed. This is so far away from getting it right for every child! The Scottish education system is an appalling mess which is wrong for every child! 33192019-08-22T00:36:04.7240518Sheila yarrowPlease fund education better and life choices after school.33192019-08-22T07:31:22.93740520Alison GeddesAs a parent and clinician in CAMHS any cuts and changes to the provision for ASN children within schools is very sad indeed as kids whom I look after have little support, can school refuse a they cannot access the right learning support or set up. Additional services and support work with kids with ASN is required and ASAP!\r\n\r\nSmall classes for autistic children who struggle in mainstream would be helpful so that they feel they can thrive and achieve. Too many feel failed by stem in place as it stands 33192019-08-22T07:32:46.73340521Ian WatkinsThe funding levels for Special Needs education is almost at critical levels. How can the Scottish Government fund numerous vanity projects and overseas aid, an area not in their remit, and yet neglect the most precious in our society.33192019-08-22T07:35:57.26740522Ann BurnettI worked in management in a large ASN Service and can say that inclusion can work well but only if properly funded and supported. Properly trained PSAs can make inclusion succeed or fail. LA's react to trends and produce figures that need properly examined e.g. Children with English as an additional language are included and makeup a large proportion of the total despite many of these children needing minimal or no support. There are areas of ASN that should be the responsibility of mainstream such as EAL and Dyslexia and should be covered extensively in teacher training. However there are also many more neglected or cinderella areas of ASN such as children ill at home and in hospital, children with Developmental Language Disorder (approx 2 in every class) and children with behavioural needs. Having large ASN services means nothing if staff are not trained, off little direct support (current model relies heavily on the 'consultant model' schools told me they need less of the consultation and more direct support. I could go on but it's important we examine exactly what ASN support actually offers, how stable is it? and is it it properly planned? Adequate support at the early stages will save money in the the long run and avoid this combative approach that currently exists between parents, education authorities and the media.33192019-08-22T08:50:36.1340524Alison KinrossI have cleared up rubbish, including human excrement , left by wild campers on Islay and think that the mess left by these people spoils the environment for responsible visitors and local residents and that there has to be some action possible where this littering problem is reducing the quality of life for others.33302019-08-22T09:23:46.38740526Sarah ArguileIf a child needs specific help whilst growing up it is everyone's duty to see that they are not let down.33192019-08-22T09:29:26.34340527Marie MurphyThere should be more specialised support for teachers eg support from ASN teachers who are receiving less ASN children due to mainstream inclusion. There should be more visits from specialists to support both children and adults in the mainstream setting and to offer training as well. A family member has ADHD and possible dyslexia (assessment to be done) and their school work has to address his needs but I believe class sizes are too large for their needs to be fully addressed. 33192019-08-22T14:53:44.72340532Linda JacombA family member has struggled with ADHD all of their life. For them this manifests in low self esteem, lack of confidence, poor planning capabilities, poor communication skills with new or unknown people. The upside however is attention to detail, super fast brain, amazing retention for facts etc. Unfortunately this does not help them if employers don't see the potential - they then feel a failure which feeds their anxiety and confidence. They also do not receive the support they are entitled to and need from the Job Centre due to their inability to negotiate online forms and job applications due to IT failure and slow connections that drop out rather than their ability. This makes complying with Job Centre requirements almost impossible when applying for Universal Credit and as a result they have received many sanctions where support should have been provided.32792019-08-22T15:12:01.28740533Mrs Margaret MacLellanAreas of rural Scotland have seen a huge increase in visitors and some "wild camping", these areas often have dunes and machair, which must be protected from damage. Additional parking and toilet facilities need to be provided to accommodate the increase of visitors.33302019-08-22T16:01:16.48340536Andrew SamuelIt is not by any means the 'ideal' in and of itself. The legislation needs to be accompanied by a educational drive that aims to incalcate campers with the appropriate knowledge of and about the Scottish Access Code. Many people visiting Scotland and using their car or vans to park next to the road, often cite Scotland's right to roam as justification for their actions, but there is no right to roam as it's about a right to responsible access. This message needs properly disseminated and such a policy should accompany any new legislation that aims to curtail albeit in part these access rights.33302019-08-22T17:18:04.30740541Patricia MurrayA family member has high functioning ASD. This meant that they really struggled at school but would not have had any additional support. They were moved to a much smaller school where they could manage life a lot better, however at significant financial cost. This has meant that we have swapped nights awake worrying about them at school to nights awake worrying about finances. We are extremely lucky that we can do this at all and have been able to bypass the system but the educational system is not set up people with additional support needs and that is a huge failing. 33192019-08-22T18:03:17.29740542Karen Young All children should be educated and supported. GIRFEC!!! Need I say more.. Get it right for our children early on and in the long run the government will save money. Get it wrong and we have children with mental health problems and ending up in the criminal justice system. Parents shouldn't have to fight and be in crisis because of the lack of support. 33192019-08-22T21:12:00.70340550Martha SimpsonIt's very very very very very hard with funding. So without..... 33192019-08-22T21:45:17.540551Rach DannThe beautiful Highlands horrific and no income generated either. Human waste needs monitoring its truly shameful please look to Iceland and have decent campsites with facilities. Rats overflowing bins just a dump up here sort it out 33302019-08-22T22:59:48.440554Kim Shand Her name was Ruby. She was 8. She was hit by a car just a few feet from home and left.\r\nShe mattered \r\nShe was my best friend. \r\n#everylifematters#slowdownforRuby31922019-08-23T07:32:02.31340557June HallI agree with this to a point but parking up in a motorcaravan is not wildcamping. BUT this too needs stopping. NC500 Ltd is an environmental disaster.33302019-08-23T08:01:15.99340558peter Westthe less technology like this, the better\r\n32732019-08-23T08:32:34.60340559Pauline SingletonIf I knew then what I am experiencing now I would do them every day.32912019-08-23T08:35:39.37340560Margaret ForsythPlease help these children to be educated 33192019-08-23T09:21:40.7440563Hayley LewisThere needs to be a pan-scotland approach to this issue - otherwise problem just moves as evidenced by the Loch Lomond ban33302019-08-23T10:56:55.36340565Amy EmmersonIts a no brainer. Will save the health service a lot of money. Just think about it, it makes sense, its an innovative public health scheme. You could win awards!!! 32912019-08-23T14:14:35.72740566Jimminy cricket10 out of 10 33442019-08-23T14:58:57.9540569Denise ThompsonI often go through Drumnadrochit and it's awful! Camper vans parked in cemetery entrances, tents in picnic areas. People uri33302019-08-23T15:01:17.53740570Margaret Allison Children with additional needs at main stream school need additional support, just because you cant see it doesnt mean it doesn't exist 33192019-08-23T16:59:59.03340572Christopher PatemanI spent five years running the trade association for UK business to business telecommunications providers. We heard a great deal about how the public is clamouring for 5G. Much less about the ubiquitous infrastructure which will be required to enable it. Short-range high frequency radio signals will, effectively, require a repeater on top of every lamp-post, and several within each internal fire compartmented area within buildings. Given Scotland's unhappy experience with even 'super-fast' broadband outside densely populated areas, there is a real risk of furthering the haves vs have-nots divide.32732019-08-23T18:58:54.95340574valerie cooperlets save the planet33432019-08-23T21:41:18.62340575Terry McTernanThis would be an excellent first step forward in the midst of the current climate emergency. It would allow Scotland to be seen to be leading the way on these islands. 33432019-08-23T22:11:58.45740576Sarah HoustonI am a primary school teacher. Service provision can only be improved relative to the amount of funding allocation. Funding has been systematically slashed and so, provision can only deteriorate. It's not rocket science!!!33192019-08-24T18:08:03.68740580David ScottI Agree with this just because People with LD they should be treated as equally and long stay hospitals should be closed down for people with LD full stop.32792019-08-24T18:45:59.08740581Kirsty MenziesMy personal experience of ASN provision is that it is massively underfunded, having been refused audited hours for a family member in P1 and having to fight and badger and plead for audited hours we finally secured funding which provided a full time TA. It took months however to repair the damage to their mental health and anxiety having been abandoned in mainstream school (presumption of mainstream) with no aid. Thankfully due to being awarded funding they are thriving and happy however I know for many this is not the case. Presumption of mainstream should be what it is intended to be and not a cost cutting exercise. Limiting specialist placements and a blanket rule that all children should attend at least P1 in mainstream is all fine and well but unless the money is diverted to the mainstream schools for additional support, it puts enormous strain on first and foremost the child, the teacher and the other children in the class. 33192019-08-25T21:11:41.0540588chris smithour experience of additional needs is summed up using words like battle attritional , desperation.\r\nHighland Council in my experience would stop at nothing to prevent a child getting the help they are legally entitled to. \r\nNot some rediculous unattainable standard, but simple legislative minimum standards are avoided at all costs.\r\nThe HMI are implicated here, as is the ombudsmen and the children's commissioner. \r\nAll the above are curiously and conspicuously absent from the discussion. \r\nAll could if they were independent find thousands and thousands of cases where LEA's are acting unlawfully, and with prejudice towards children \r\n33192019-08-26T11:17:39.1140591Lynne MorrisonIf money is not put into assisting special needs children the government is blinded by the fact that our children now are our future. If we don't assist them now we will not reap the benefits in years to come. Does the Government want a society which will play havoc on other services in years to come i.e. the police, fire service because children with special needs have been failed by the Education Authorities. The Scottish Government need to look at the bigger picture now and stop concentrating all its efforts on Independence.33192019-08-26T17:08:13.0640593John MorrisonOur children are our future! Funding cuts for children with additional needs will not reap benefits in years to come. The majority of these children will become problem children unnecessarily, which will impact other sectors unnecessarily including police, fire etc simply because we have not put measures in place to protect and educate our children properly NOW. Let's follow the principle of GIRFEC (Getting It Right for Every Child) and not just use it as a slogan. Scotland can once again be a great Country for its fantastic education. Let's get the building blocks in place for our children with special needs now and not when our children end up in prison.33192019-08-26T18:06:25.19340596Tanya ByersI currently work with Early years children and agree with children with ASN attending mainstream setting however agree that these children should be provided with the appropriate support to meet their individual needs. 33192019-08-26T18:41:46.25740598Sarah McKimI have family members with ASN, who have been failed in primary school and one also failed in main stream high school. I had to fight to get one family member enrolled in a school which supports ASN kids. Another family member has now started their new high school and I am waiting to see what support will actually be put in place to help them. There needs to be more awareness with teachers as most do not understand kids with ASN, there needs to be more support teachers or assistants in every school year to enable all children to learn and grow within their class environment other than a couple of support services throughout a school. There are more and more children being diagnosed with ASN so we need to be supporting them to ensure they can achieve everything they wish. 33192019-08-26T19:39:52.12740599James Stark I am 100% behind this petition 32792019-08-26T20:28:31.9640600Ruth Holland Having visited the South side of Loch Tummel for nearly 20 years it has been devastating to witness the rubbish people leave behind when wild camping. Some of my favourite walking spots are now no go areas due to human waste and view spots are ruined by rubbish. I am all for people enjoying nature but it seems there is a lack of respect for nature and a belief that it is ok to leave everything behind. 33302019-08-26T23:03:22.85740602Jean Sivertsen CraigIt is your duty to support teachers and all pupils. If the pupils with additional needs do not receive adequate support the teacher is unable to deliver lessons and devote time to make sure all pupils needs are met. 33192019-08-27T07:56:12.60740604Kirsty SimpsonWithout additional funding we cannot get it right for every child. 33192019-08-27T17:14:09.140608Janet HindlePlease support this. A cat is STILL a loved pet31922019-08-27T23:53:20.12340611Derek PearceWell done, with regard to all your hard work.31922019-08-28T07:33:41.33740612David CummingsWe shouldn't be having this problem this should be much better funded 33192019-08-28T08:29:51.45340613Ilona CassidyShe was called Remi. She was 1 year old when she was run over in a cul-de-sac. She was tossed on the garbage truck and taken to the dump. No one contacted us even though she was chipped. We didn't find out until much later what had happened to her. 31922019-08-28T10:17:43.41740614Sandra LecuyerIn view of the research work being carried out at the moment into health hazards of 5G I am very alarmed that the Scottish Government plans to go ahead with this plan and ask that there be a moratorium for the moment. 32732019-08-28T22:25:55.52740621John Gibson3g and 4g are damaging to the microbiome and brain wave states and also our subconscious mind. The evidence is compelling. Shut it down or get debilitating illness. It's that simple. \r\n32732019-08-30T08:45:26.3440630Ruth Elizabeth CochraneScotland can be a world leader, lets make it happen!33432019-08-30T10:50:04.65340632Jim DalyWe got by just fine before plastic was wrapped around everything. The stuff kills marine life and ends up back in our mouths and our guts. Let's ditch it - if it is managed properly there are massive business opportunities here too.33432019-08-30T12:49:15.1940634Hazel grieveI have a family member with special needs and to cut asn funding is shocking the job they do is wonderful and the experience they have is crucial to our children's learning 33192019-08-30T13:51:52.7840635Samantha McclureImprove resources and more funding.33192019-08-30T14:46:56.60340637Joanna marchbankA family member has aspergers syndrome and adhd. They get no extra support in the local resourse school due to lack of funding. Disgraceful 33192019-08-30T15:19:17.57740638Gordon RobbLocal councils recruit Additional Need Assistants on temp contracts which I understand as the work is only there for the duration required by pupils at school, however everytime savings are to be made these roles are cut under the "No compulsory redundency" guise regardless of whether or not the role is justified and urgently required so the pupils are left to get on with it and parents made to feel they should just be happy with any support the school can provide under the circumstances. Hardly getting it right for every child is it! \r\nThose in higher positions like to say the right words while making it impossible to achieve.\r\nWhat generally happens is the pupils with extreme needs get the vast majority of the hours while pupils with learning disabilities are left scratching their heads.33192019-08-30T17:28:00.15740639Joyce Kilgour-BlaikieA family member has not received the support in school they have needed. They have no diagnosis despite pushing every door that I can to get support. Because they look fine and do not typically display asn they has been so let down. They are now home educated, and I am needing to pay for assessment and support they need. Many children are in trauma and confusion, in schools, and staff are fire fighting, do not have proper training and are left to cope and do as they are asked to do and not question or complain. This country and government needs to take the future and education of our children seriously and make supporting them PRIORITY. There needs to be a complete RADICAL REVIEW of EDUCATION, with HUMILITY. Funding needs to be IMMEDIATELY released so that staff can be poured into schools again. Then for PEOPLE to accept CHANGE IS NEEDED, and RADICAL CHANGES made to ensure we leave behind the colonial top down, controlling of victorian educational system is put behind us. Lets look at the Scandanavian Models of Education, Steiner, and so on and bring joy and hope back into our children and families lives, and this country. Lets let go of control and see people flourish and our country prosper again!!\r\n33192019-09-01T09:27:32.78740677Claire WilliamsonSo much food packaging is still non recyclable , the supermarkets and manufacturers need to be made to address this. 33432019-09-03T12:43:42.65340693Christine MacdonaldSchools should be considered first, before building thousands of new family homes. Our schools cannot cope.31462019-09-04T08:59:22.99340698Liz woodDone seeing bins over flowing in middle of nowhere and people having a no 2 outside their camping site! 33302019-09-04T09:05:55.71340699Fiona ProctorI support this petition32562019-09-04T12:46:41.10340701Serena Mason With increasing tourist pressure we need powers to manage an protect the landscape that attracts visitors.33302019-09-04T13:51:19.84740704Douglas carchrie I completely disagree with this petition, the outdoor access code works with little fault in Scotland. More education and policing is needed in certain parts of the country but imposing complete bans totally ruins it for those acting responsibly and goes against everything the current outdoor access code stands for!33302019-09-04T14:07:17.03740707Fiona OgilvieDespite multiple complex issues a family member has received no additional support in school despite having full time audit hours in nursery. Their needs have not changed - indeed have become more profound. You are denying them a chance to be the best they can be and at the tender age of 7 putting them on the scrap heap!!33192019-09-04T14:19:50.77340708Nic WelshThis petition seems to be the creation of a sole crusader. The rural communities referred to have elected representatives in the form on community councils and local councillors, and many are also represented by development trusts. If they feel strongly about the issue, it is these bodies that should be making representations and only after proper environmental research and consultation with those directly affected. Eroding the rights of all citizens is not the answer.33302019-09-04T20:35:28.74340716Elaine McRaeIt would be great for all children to go to mainstream Schools but without the funding how can that be. If the Government cannot fund special Schools how can they fund mainstream Schools. More money is needed for both.33192019-09-05T09:25:29.4840721Rachel Godding stop wild camping near peoples home as well as in carparks 33302019-09-05T11:51:40.60340722JULIE GAMBLELEARN FROM THE PAST:\r\nUSE PAPER BAGS (when necessary) for FRUIT, \r\nVEGETABLES & BAKERY PRODUCTS.\r\nFOR CARRYING SHOPPING: BAGS made from NATURAL FABRICS 33432019-09-05T16:55:05.21340725Ruth ClarkOnly looking for common decency and respec for homeowners privacy33302019-09-09T12:18:36.4540751Fiona DonaldsonAdditional Support provided in the first few years disappears in 5th and 6th years due to lack of funding and the schools having to make that choice. It is a major step for children willing to remain in school and learn to then be penalised when they do so.33192019-09-09T19:17:58.9540754Moira StewartLet's cut out this unnecessary plastic. We didn't need it before so why do we need it now? 33432019-09-10T08:59:55.21740756Lynne GeorgiadesTeachers need more support to be able to carry out their jobs, which are highly specialised. They don't need to be given extra responsibilities, such as speech and language therapy provision. SALT needs to be properly funded and provided to everyone, as a core part of their learning pathway.33192019-09-11T15:24:03.7740768Yasmin TaylorGreyhound racing has no place in the 21 st century. It is a cruel corrupt and out dated industry peddled as a sport. Thousands of dogs as killed simply for fun. If these dogs were labradors there would be an outcry. Ban this now33082019-09-11T18:49:46.40740771Conrad Kitson As a teacher, parent and grand parent l strongly believe that all children deserve equal opportunity of teaching and time being taught.32422019-09-11T18:51:32.340773Fiona BremnerTeaching should be consistent across the country 32422019-09-11T21:05:44.06740776David PodmoreGreyhound racing is cruel , 6000 Greyhounds die each year in Ireland , Ireland main supplier to UK 33082019-09-11T21:08:27.11340777Susan Lewis1,000 greyhounds killed and nearly 5,000 ,( one third of the racing population) injured each year by running dogs around dangerously configured tracks for the gambling industry is indefensible.33082019-09-11T21:09:41.78740778Deborah DruryAn outdated and cruel activity. The GBGB is a corrupt industry that relies on lies to get through each day. Tracks are in poor condition, causing injury to the greyhounds. Greyhound Racing is not a sport. There is no human interaction and for the sake of a bet, greyhounds are at risk of injury and in some cases, racing has caused death to the greys.33082019-09-11T21:15:03.1340779Susan Lewis1,000 greyhounds killed and 5,000 injured ( one third of the racing population) for the sake of the gambling industry is indefensible.33082019-09-11T21:18:14.78740781Jayne FrancesGreyhounds are a wonderful gentle sensitive breed, sadly they are exploited beyond belief, greyhound racing has now place in society any more, it must end before more of these gentle souls loose their lives. 33082019-09-11T21:43:38.07340784Rachel Baillie I think all kids with special needs get the support in education to help them with their future 33192019-09-11T21:46:12.0140785Noiren carrigg Please listen to the people regarding this subject 33082019-09-11T21:53:56.5140786Janette CruickshankThis cruel sport needs to stop33082019-09-11T22:16:55.54740788Catherine Lodge Greyhound Racing must be banned! It is not a sport! It is nothing but cruelty and exploitation! All about money and greed! Vile industry! BAN IT NOW!!! 33082019-09-11T22:20:35.6840789Susan Blane Please end greyhound racing animals should not be our entertainment,33082019-09-11T22:45:01.11340791Susan WellerLets stop this deliberate cruelty - animals should not pay the price for our greed33082019-09-11T23:20:21.99340792Michelle mitchellThe most abused and exploited gentle sentient being being the greyhound. The racing industry ought to be ashamed of themselves 33082019-09-11T23:22:29.6140793Reena GriffinOur precious greyhounds are suffering shocking brutality, injuries and horrible deaths and this cruelty must be shut down!\r\nThere is absolutely no excuse for the high rates of injuries and shocking death rates, including killing of dogs that are not fast enough! \r\nThis should be banned immediately, the evidence is clear! Even the drugging of these poor dogs has become common knowledge, but this still goes on, by owners and trainers who 'supposedly love their dogs"!!! \r\nAlso, rescue and bring back the 'discarded' greyhounds that have been exported to China and other countries that have practically nil animal welfare laws. These dogs have been sent to a cruel short future by greedy owners, who have used and abused their dogs, with no thought of retiring them to greyhound rescue organisations.\r\nThe dogs are used for breeding in absolutely shocking conditions, then sold to the barbaric dog meat business!!!! THIS CRUELTY MUST STOP!!!\r\nClose down all the breeding facilities, and close down all the racing facilities as soon as possible, and make preparations for the dogs in custody to be handed over to greyhound rescue organisations, to be fostered and rehomed to loving homes.\r\nGreyhounds make the most loving, loyal and easy pets, and this needs to be promoted extensively.\r\nPlease, we must help these beautiful loving dogs, enough of this cruelty!33082019-09-11T23:25:28.65740794Jane LindsayThis is a cruel, barbaric and unnecessary practice. It must be stopped33082019-09-12T00:00:22.64740795Emily RimicansScotland - Show the way against animal abuse 33082019-09-12T00:01:09.44340796harry morganWe're killing the planet and it's wildlife. let's stop it.33432019-09-12T02:04:47.6740797Linda Jacobs Please protect these gentle animals with they have such beautiful faces33082019-09-12T03:18:30.05740798Tage YoungI may not be from Scotland but my ancestors were. I am appalled by this barbaric so called sport. Please for the love of all animals stop this insanity. Stop the carnage. Stop greyhound racing. Thank you.33082019-09-12T06:27:23.72740800Karen McDonaldStop condoning the exploitation of Greyhounds!!!33082019-09-12T07:02:21.99740805Carol Jewell Every animals life matters and should not be used and abused to make people money 33082019-09-12T07:19:06.59340806David SMARTI'm afraid that this is still being regarded as as sport, that this petition will not be taken seriously. Please be aware... This is NOT A SPORT... It is legalised animal cruelty. Please do not ignore the cruelty. 33082019-09-12T08:20:46.7240807Janice MillsTime to end cruelty and abuse of greyhounds.There is no place for greyhound racing in the 21stC33082019-09-12T08:47:01.42740808Peter Kaye lone wolf All greyhound raceing must be closed down33082019-09-12T08:59:02.72340809Mrs.Maureen McDade Put simply, this barbarism in the name of "entertainment" must be banned everywhere. These gentle, loving souls must be protected and found loving homes, not cruelly exploited for someone else's "sport". 33082019-09-12T09:04:06.08340812Maureen McDade This cruel "sport" is being brought to it's knees and it is time the Greyhounds were given priority and found loving homes and this exploitation of such gentle and loving dogs is totally banned worldwide.33082019-09-12T09:07:34.12340813Karen MclynnGrey hound racing is cruel and should never be considered as a sport when many dogs suffer so humans can bet!33082019-09-12T09:07:41.29740814John McDade This cruelty in the name of "sport" has run it's race. Time for a worldwide ban-permanently.33082019-09-12T09:38:54.10340815Laura mcguireGreyhounds are the most beautiful loving pets 33082019-09-12T09:50:58.31740816Russ AkehurstGreyhound Racing has no place in a civilized society. Why should dogs be killed or injured just for humans amusement?33082019-09-12T10:29:16.8640817Lindsay MckennaRacing needs banning! It's cruel pure and simple33082019-09-12T11:01:58.17740818Annie BealGreyhounds are loving, loyal family dogs NOT racing machines.33082019-09-12T11:21:34.9440819David ColmanStop greyhound racing it cruel. 33082019-09-12T11:51:53.60740820margaret mortonI watched a deeply disturbing video, of exactly how the dogs were cast aside, when their racing days were over, taken to places to be destroyed, i couldn't believe my eyes, one man waited until his dog, which was casually shot in the head, stopped writhing before it died, the collar was removed and given to the man, payment made...i believe this particular video was from Ireland...the animals life is very cheap in the racing world...it just showed how un emotional these owners are, no love for the animal, no affection, just how much money can be made...it was an eye opener, and has to be stopped!!!\r\nGreyhounds are no different to any other household pet, just their ability for speed..No injury to any animal, is acceptable, certainly not for human entertainment!! I have no idea of the scale of race tracks or the number of breeders, but surely owners could be monitored in some way...I'm sure this is all very complicated to achieve....as for time scale...NOW!!!!33082019-09-12T12:50:43.2840821Josephine TreacyNo borders to stopping animal abuse and cruelty \r\nFrom this world .It isunfortunatly universal33082019-09-12T12:55:20.23340822Peter cadman Hi Imate a foster for sgs and love it .if know greyhound tracks are being reduced in Britain in numbers.let this continue for the love and welfare of these loving hounds33082019-09-12T13:08:46.10740823James AllanThis is fundamentally unfair. On a personal basis I have been paying into this scheme since the 70s. I like every other person of working age have already been penalised by having additional time added to when I can access my state pension. In addition to this Local Government Workers have been forced to endured below inflation wage rises for more than a decade. Why should Local Government workers be penalised again for getting old.32772019-09-12T13:38:47.28340824Lesley-Anne MulhollandOutdated and barbaric! No one is accountable to what happens to these poor dogs when they are seen as no longer of use! STOP DOG RACING NOW!33082019-09-12T13:53:55.75340825Paul MorrisChipping away at pension rights is an insult to hard working local government employees, particularly low paid and female colleagues. The changes extend working lives, or cost employees thousands. This endangers the health and wellbeing of workers and reduces opportunities for young people by keeping people artificially at work for years longer than they had planned for.32772019-09-12T13:55:56.25340826Kathleen MolloyI support this petition fully. 32772019-09-12T14:15:17.43340827Steven DohertyMost people get jailed for this type of theft, only thing that's missing is the ministers balaclava32772019-09-12T14:17:23.68340828Dennis McCueNye Bevan noted in the 1940s that 'All Tories are lower than scum' I thought that was a tad extreme but now agree with him.32772019-09-12T14:22:04.55740829ELIZABETH ALEXANDERSHAME ON ANY ELECTED GOVERNMENT WHO ARE HAPPY TO TAKE INFLATED PAY SETTLEMENTS AND CAREER END GOLDEN HANDSHAKES WHILE PENALISING HARD WORKING PEOPLE WITH OVER 40 YEARS+ CONTINUOUS SERVICE\r\nELECTED COUNCILLORS MPS AND MSPS CAN EASILY BECOME UNELECTED ALL IT TAKES IS A "X"32772019-09-12T14:27:23.30340830Thomas MackayThis is not acceptable to change our pensions 32772019-09-12T14:27:49.1840831Stephen McNallyIt is an absolute scandal that this changes like these are even being mooted. The pension rules that applied at the time a person joined the scheme should be honoured st the end of the scheme. Anything else is just plain robbery of pension rights. \r\nHow can any government condone these changes. \r\nI hope politicians who vote these changes through find themselves and their parties out of office. \r\nI support this petition. 32772019-09-12T14:28:17.16340832christine grayI will be affected by this. I will have 40 years service in 2020 and plan to retire around this time as i will be 60. I agree 24% is extreme to lose from a pension scheme that i have paid into for 40 years. In addition can i highlight the number of unmarried people within this pension scheme whereby their pension is 'lost' if they died. I have personal experience of this as my sister died having only six years retirement and had worked over 30 years service with the council.32772019-09-12T14:28:36.91340833Willie DowdlesI strongly agree. No I have not been affected.32772019-09-12T14:31:21.77740834Campbell BladesWhat gives these people the right to cut the values of the pensions we signed up to when we started work, and have constantly paid into. 32772019-09-12T14:37:10.51340835callum calderThe government are fraudsters who are stealing money from me.32772019-09-12T14:38:23.7840836Robert McDougall Why why why is it always those at the lower end that have to suffer. Those higher up the pay scale always get massive pay offs and full pension and we at the lowest end have to work until we drop. I probably want even see my pension. 32772019-09-12T14:40:10.62340837callum calderthe government are fraudsters who are stealing money from me. Disgusted by the situation! 32772019-09-12T14:40:39.24340838Jacqueline DownsGeneral Strike!32772019-09-12T14:42:30.9840840Andy carruth Leave our pension alone32772019-09-12T14:42:5840841Amanda Matthewsi currently have 34yrs service and I am only 50 years of age. at this moment in time I will have 50years service by the time I am 66years of age. this is ridiculous32772019-09-12T14:45:16.85340843Mairi MacVicarSigning up however many years ago for one scheme only for it to be subsequently and materially changed several times over with penalties applied. Do Scottish Ministers suffer the same pension injustices in their schemes?32772019-09-12T14:45:44.0940844Linda GowerI strongly agree as some jobs are physical and cannot be sustained after a certain age 32772019-09-12T14:50:51.32740845moira lauderI am now 62 I job shared for a number of years to look after my family, although I have nearly 40 service this is reduced because of my job sharing or reduced hours. Now I am losing again through these changes. This is not what I signed up for nearly 40 years ago32772019-09-12T14:53:34.39340846SHARRON CONNELLYI am appalled at the figures that have been published regarding my retirement. I have been working with GCC since I was 17 years old & have worked various secondary jobs also. These figures are alarming & give me no sense of security when I retire. Please assist to ensure myself & other retirees in the future will be able to live secure & financially safe.32772019-09-12T14:54:30.95740847Paul R BrannanHow many of these ministers get their pensions reduced when they stop before the state pension age?\r\nHow can they reduced your pension amount when it's money that is taken from my wage? Do basically they are stealing my money.\r\nThere is talk about the state pension age will be increased to 74. So will we then have to work until that age? Considering the average life expectancy for men is 71, do they expect us to work until we die?32772019-09-12T15:01:07.44340849william gouldplease get this sorted asap. people are ready and waiting to retire now. 32772019-09-12T15:01:26.3840850Christopher WhiteThe reduction % if you retire early are for too punitive and needs to be recalculated to be fairer.32772019-09-12T15:03:02.8140851John pollockI never signed for any reduction or change to a pension scheme I was promised in 1982.32772019-09-12T15:05:03.96740852Derek WatsonI do not agree with this.32772019-09-12T15:05:37.27740853Diane trainerNo\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\nNo \r\nEU32772019-09-12T15:14:26.12340855Isabel McCloyNo , i don't agree32772019-09-12T15:19:08.25740857Derek BrownStop stealing our hard earned money.32772019-09-12T15:38:54.14340859Christine TaylorI am almost 60. Have worked for almost 43 years non stop... I feel robbed of my right to retire now after all the hard earned cash I've paid into this country. 32772019-09-12T15:44:16.82340860Steven wallLiving in Scotland with a lower life expectancy than the rest of the UK, I may not reach 67.32772019-09-12T15:45:34.82340861June Gallagher Definitely too high. 32772019-09-12T15:47:13.30740862Ruth CraxtonI know a girl in Highland that has been on the school roll since April 2018 but only managed to attend a handful of weeks due to extreme anxiety. She has received next to no education since June 2018. Nothing, nada, zilch. This person even has a CSP!32422019-09-12T15:54:24.0840863Maria MccluskeyAgree that the pension scheme and its reductions unfairly discriminated female staff due to predominant caring role.32772019-09-12T16:03:36.5940864Rosemary scott Make pensions more affordable 32772019-09-12T16:07:56.2440865Charlene Doherty Yes I agree 32772019-09-12T16:08:03.61340866Jane LanganI completely agree that the levels of reductions to the local government pension scheme is very unfair and that particular note should be made to both low paid workers and females who often have to deal with particular caring responsibilities. The goalposts have systematically changed within the scheme and now demonstrate clear detriment to workers who attempt to retire even a few years before the existing state pension age. I am currently 52 with 36 years local government service. In order to reach my full pension award at the age of 67 I would be required to work for 51 years! The levels of reductions in place will make it almost impossible for me to consider retirement before the age of 67. Approximate calculations on my current salary demonstrate that retiral at 65 would see my pension decrease by more than £6,500 per year, with retiral at 60, seeing my pension drop by approximately £13,500 per year! I find this to be a very unfair situation.32772019-09-12T16:25:07.1140867Rosemary AshleyWe need to stick together.32772019-09-12T16:38:01.78340868Carol McfarlaneI was born in 1960, pension is not fully protected due to the ruling that its protected to April 2020, my birthday falls in December 2020. Where's the fairness in this, 31yrs service! People put in the pension in faith they would get a good return on their retirement, this is not happening due to government moving the goal posts all the time. 32772019-09-12T16:49:27.8440870Paul Mulholland Enough is enough 32772019-09-12T16:52:46.39340871Michael MatuszakAn absolute scandal. This has to be revised.32772019-09-12T16:54:17.04340872Janette SwansonI had to opt for flexible retirement due to health issues. I was subjected to a reduction in my benefits despite having joined the scheme when the 85 rule existed. My retirement age has gone from 60-67. I have had to continue to work part time to make up the deficit. 32772019-09-12T16:59:14.43340873Irene RuthefordRidiculous that this has been changed32772019-09-12T17:08:58.240874Sharon StevensonGive us what we have paid in, and what we are due.\r\nWe shouldn't have to work until we are in our 60's we will have worked long enough by that time I hope this government does the right thing for once !32772019-09-12T17:09:33.94340875Alex BruceI do not believe this is a fair and just process.32772019-09-12T17:13:29.8240876Elaine MartinI totally agree it should be reduced I'll be nearly 69 years old before I am entitled to my state pension. Shocking!!32772019-09-12T17:15:46.16340877Lynda RoganWhy don't the Government align themselves with a pay scheme (inc benefits and pension) linked to ours, it would then be ring-fenced - for sure!!!32772019-09-12T17:25:57.2940878Carol WoodwardA works pension is essential to survive, and many female workers have already sacrificed salary for family responsibilities.32772019-09-12T17:29:31.7940879Audrey WattI agree with the wording of this legislation.. 33702019-09-12T17:33:17.45340880Eric ProctorConned out of the Rule of 85, by a Labour Government, GCC and SPFO, following redundancy in ,2009.\r\n\r\nEnough is enough.32772019-09-12T17:42:20.84740881Catherine PatonThis is a punitive measure to hard working low paid individuals who have served their service and paid into a scheme that could lose a substantial amount. This will be det32772019-09-12T17:43:46.6940882Scott McGregor40yrs service for me is at 56yrs old. The punitive deductions are excessive even if I retired at 60 or 62 & must be reduced. Unfair for long serving employees to say the least32772019-09-12T18:06:05.6340884Jean kilpatrickChange to terms are unfair32772019-09-12T18:14:33.91340885Noreen ThomsonYes 32772019-09-12T18:28:11.2240886Maryrose AitkenThink is ridiculous as ppl work for as long as they can and most ppl retire due to whatever reason and due their pensions 32772019-09-12T18:28:55.42340887Regina SeecampEnd Greyhound racing, don't support the Industry!33082019-09-12T18:53:48.25740888Susan CrawfordI agree with the petition32772019-09-12T20:10:19.59340890Mary ParkhillNo need to support a dying industry.33082019-09-12T20:23:48.6940891Deborah McMillanI'm signing this as I'm sick and tired of the hard working people being so poor32772019-09-12T20:24:22.98740892Caroline GuestNo place for greyhound racing in this day and age, 33082019-09-12T20:48:33.8340895Helen StevensonI'm a 60 year old lady who works with special needs kids who are very challenging and don't think I can do this job which I love til I'm 67 been doing it for 25years some jobs u just can't do.32772019-09-12T20:50:35.0240896Angus ClarkScotlamd could take the lead by banning all single use plastic. For all industrial production they could introduce legislation requiring manufacturers to seek alternative materials where possible. Incentives could be introduced from government ie tax breaks with higher taxes on products which high plastic use. 33432019-09-12T21:14:18.5740897Charles ThompsonRacing greyhounds are often severely injured during races including leg, spine and neck breaks. Many of these injuries are fatal. Many greyhounds are euthanized at the end of their racing careers at a young age. There is evidence of trainers giving t their greyhounds illegal drugs to enhance or depress performance. 33082019-09-12T21:15:38.3240898Michelle BlockleyGreyhounds are pets.33082019-09-12T21:35:34.4840899Siegrid BermanSTOP CRUEL DEADLY GREYHOUND RACING33082019-09-12T21:35:49.3440900Patricia RogersDog racing is very cruel. Please stop this outdated practice.33082019-09-12T21:36:00.10340901Sharen OxmanI strongly oppose greyhound racing in Scotland33082019-09-12T21:36:10.88740902Rona mclachlanI do not agree that the level of reductions are fare.32772019-09-12T21:36:31.6240903Rebeca CastellanosStop this inhumane practice ! Dogs deserve better !33082019-09-12T21:36:46.5140904Tammy BunchAll Animals Have Feelings Too. 33082019-09-12T21:36:51.8140905Judy KitchenWe own 2 Greyhounds and they make perfect pets, no harm should ever come to these beautiful animals33082019-09-12T21:36:55.68340906Siegrid BermanPUT A STOP TO CRUEL GREYHOUND RACING33082019-09-12T21:36:55.24740907Rafael SantanaStop greyhound exploitation33082019-09-12T21:37:25.18340908Marie DixonThe exploitation of greyhounds must stop, the treatment of the racing dogs amounts to abuse. Scotland, you can do better.33082019-09-12T21:37:40.07340909Kevin CookLeave the dogs ALONE SCUMBAGS33082019-09-12T21:37:53.46340910Marilyn AllardyceThe use of any animal for sport or entertainment should have been banned along time ago. Lets finally make a start33082019-09-12T21:37:57.49740911Maria Gabriela Cicarellistop this nonsense inmediately 33082019-09-12T21:38:27.55740913Sherri LynnGreyhounds are not volunteers with regard to racing. Therefore I feel that it is not fair to make them race especially when many are abused and even discarded or killed in horrible ways when they are no longer of value to their owners. 33082019-09-12T21:38:53.32340914Janet Redfern The sooner that greyhound racing is a thing of the past the better. Please ban this vile pastime33082019-09-12T21:39:24.240915Lindsay DonzantiBarbaric33082019-09-12T21:39:52.63740916Maryrose Ciminomaybe time for dogs to race their owners and see who wins???33082019-09-12T21:40:18.46740918Mary Baker DittmanGreyhounds are beautiful dogs and should not be exploited. Greyhound racing is not a sport it is a means of gambling at the dogs expense.33082019-09-12T21:40:32.3140919thomas friedmangrayhounds are peole too33082019-09-12T21:40:32.3140920Sandy ColombiniAnimals should not have to suffer in order to entertain humans. End greyhound racing immediately!33082019-09-12T21:41:03.77740921Lynette EgglestonGreyhounds in all countries are treated as commodities. There is computed evidence of cruelty, poor care, "wastage" all in the name of making money.\r\n\r\nIt is abhorrent in 2019 that we know how bad the conditions are and yet we allow this abuse to continue.33082019-09-12T21:42:02.2340923Hollie dohanThis is extreme cruelty33082019-09-12T21:42:20.88740924Douglas JedlickaFreedom for all Greyhounds must happen immediately. Shut down all Greyhound Racing Tracks throughout the world.33082019-09-12T21:42:25.29340925Joshua WolffWe need legislative change to ban racing in our country, to tackle the high number of injuries, deaths and positive drug tests seen in this industry, and to reflect the lack of public support for this unsavoury use of animals for human entertainment and gambling profit.33082019-09-12T21:42:29.57340926Susan GascaThese dogs should not be used for sport. Greyhounds just want a loving home not a cage33082019-09-12T21:42:41.8140927Kate simI am doing what i can but the government needs to force the big companies who choose to look the other way33432019-09-12T21:43:38.29340928Graciela WilsonGreyhounds are not different from all other household pets, they are the same. They deserve to be protected, loved & cared for like any other beloved pet!!!! 33082019-09-12T21:44:07.65340929Albert MarraStop the killing for fun !33082019-09-12T21:44:26.40340930yolanda andrewsi've always hated racing these animals, it's cruel and inhumane, please stop it soonest.\r\n33082019-09-12T21:44:33.5940931Linda Leet HoweGreyhounds are not ours to make money with. They are intelligent, feeling animals who deserve better.33082019-09-12T21:44:38.35340932Patricia JohnsonEnd greyhound racing In Scotland33082019-09-12T21:44:48.04340933Susan StephensonIt's 2019: time for humans to evolve and shun barbaric sports. Yes, even Scots. 33082019-09-12T21:44:50.8140934Marguerite EliaPlease protect greyhounds from racing and allow no harm to any of them, in any form. Racing them is crass and cruel exploitation. Stop using them for profits and perverse entertainment.33082019-09-12T21:45:22.02740935Christina PatrickEnd Greyhound racing33082019-09-12T21:45:46.43340936SYLVANA ARGUELLOHAVE SOME EMPATHY AND END THIS CRUELTY ALREADY PLS...33082019-09-12T21:45:56.01340937Wendy HowesMore and more tracks are stoping the non-sense of dog racing. It is cruel and supports breeding which the world does not need anymore greyhounds. \r\nPlease stop this racing and cruelty to greyhounds !! Be a shining example for others.33082019-09-12T21:46:03.18340938Debra Goldstein-LustigTime to end greyhound racing once and for all. It is totally pure animal abuse and cruelty. 33082019-09-12T21:46:26.24740939Christina PatrickEnd Greyhound racing33082019-09-12T21:46:58.65340940Deborah kenakin These elegant dogs are pets... not a means to earn money off of their suffering 33082019-09-12T21:47:14.30740941Debra Goldstein-LustigEnd greyhound racing once and for all. Pure animal abuse and cruelty. 33082019-09-12T21:47:55.15340942Hugh D. JonesPLEASE Scotland\r\nDO THE RIGHT THING!!!!\r\n33082019-09-12T21:48:34.0640943Monica BellPlease stop the use and abuse of these beautiful, gentle, loving, intelligent creatures!!!33082019-09-12T21:48:59.99740944DIANE mcloughlinOUTDATED CRUEL SPORT33082019-09-12T21:49:57.59340945curtis mcloughlinOUTDATED CRUEL SPORT33082019-09-12T21:50:05.240946Colette AllenAbuse of these beautiful creatures is cruel and injustice evil . If this kind of behavior continues we lose our very Humanity in an already evil societies.33082019-09-12T21:50:40.35740947Kenneth E NahigianPlease respect the welfare of these beautiful animals.33082019-09-12T21:50:48.76340948Perry SmithTorturing dogs is cruel no matter what you call what you're doing.33082019-09-12T21:51:40.74740949Mirana ComstockWe had a lovely track rescue for many years and now have a greyhound mix. They are beautiful, sensitive, loving pets. They are not racing machines to be used for profit in a cruel blood sport.33082019-09-12T21:52:59.6740950Heather ColomboGreyhounds were never meant to be slaves for man.33082019-09-12T21:53:09.9240951Steven SpencerI have owned three greyhounds, all adopted from the racetrack curcuit in the USA. (Canada does not allow commercial dog-racing.) The third, which we currently have, shows clear signs of having been injured in his hind legs. Serious injuries are common in greyhound racing, and sometimes require euthanasia on the spot (e.g, for broken limbs and broken backs). No animals should be used in this way for our entertainment and profit. Please end this barbaric practice.33082019-09-12T21:53:42.46740952Jacqueline NotermanEnd cruel dog racing industry! 33082019-09-12T21:54:15.26340953sherry jourdanThis is cruel and I will not visit a country involved in this type activity. 33082019-09-12T21:55:14.43740954Natalie sinn Greyhounds are fabulous house pets, gentle, kind, and sweet. They are not animals to be raced and risked. Animals die during racing accidents, which are completely unacceptable and fully avoidable circumstances. Racing dogs has no place in society. I propose all greyhound racing be banned and tracks closed by 2024.33082019-09-12T21:55:48.48340955Barbara ChichesterEnd the misery and brutality of dog racing33082019-09-12T21:55:50.29340956Melanie L. MarshNo animal should be exploited for people's financial gain or entertainment purposes.33082019-09-12T21:56:00.5340957Andrew M Wray IVPlease stop racing greyhounds. It's not what people think it is. They have no idea that in the USA over 6000 or more greyhounds get.put down because they don't perform at a certain standard. It breaks my heart. 33082019-09-12T21:56:24.15740958Augusta MoorePlease end Greyhound racing in Scotland now and forever. 33082019-09-12T21:58:04.76340959Tina SahlstromWe should not accept this abuse33082019-09-12T21:58:35.0640960Laurence HolyoakPLEASE stop the abuse of these dogs. The confinement they endure while waiting to entertain simple minded humans is just not worth it. 33082019-09-12T21:59:16.96740961Lynda ReimersProtect these dogs they are truly wonderful dogs and pete33082019-09-12T21:59:29.73340962Melanie ValentineThis cruel industry needs to be brought to an end 33082019-09-12T21:59:38.26340963Anne TownsendThis is a cruel sport and needs to end worldwide. Scotland is a good start to show what humanity is.33082019-09-12T22:00:21.35740964Jeanine LarsenStop the racing33082019-09-12T22:00:44.1140965Cecile DoyleRacing dogs is very cruel...please put an end to it!33082019-09-12T22:03:12.26340967Brenda BoudreauxThe abuses upon other beings on this planet by mankind for our entertainment is unacceptable and must stop!33082019-09-12T22:03:32.93740968Donna S MullerNothing good from dog racing--only pain and death to the dogs.33082019-09-12T22:03:47.68740969Shannon BradyAnimal abuse just for money inhuman and unacceptable!!!33082019-09-12T22:04:3540970Laura PasseyI urge you to ask yourself just how honorable it is to preside over the abuse and suffering of animals.33082019-09-12T22:05:50.60740973Michael HallDog racing represents the regression of mankind. Our enlightening calls on mankind to progress.33082019-09-12T22:05:53.23340974April Morgan WHERE IS THE KINDNESS IN HUMANKIND?33082019-09-12T22:06:05.1740975Shirley LemonTHE DEATHS OF THESE GREAT DOGS IS HORRIBLE33082019-09-12T22:07:21.3940976Teresa lockeThis a cruel sport and should be band 33082019-09-12T22:10:15.62340978Joei FischerThis is a cruel & abusing industry! Please no more dog racing!!33082019-09-12T22:11:28.48340979Jackie CasanoDog racing is extremely cruel and has no place in a civilized society. Please put a stop to it.33082019-09-12T22:11:47.20340980Margaret J HintzPlease Stop this dog racing33082019-09-12T22:13:03.2540981Sherry M MangoldIn my adulthood I have rescued 9 greyhounds, 6 off of dog tracks and 3 Galgos from Spain. Animals are sentient beings, with both physical and emotional feelings. To remain civilized we must recognize that and treat them humanely. That means ending greyhound racing!33082019-09-12T22:13:10.01340982Maria BalickaEnd greyhound racing In Scotland.33082019-09-12T22:13:18.84340983Elizabeth SpoonerIf this involved Labradors or cockapoos there were be an national outcry!33082019-09-12T22:14:02.04740984Pat wildey Please ,this must be stopped,It is cruel and outraged.33082019-09-12T22:14:44.01740985Jennifer WrightWhy should greyhounds be regarded differently to beloved household pets? They are great Dogs who don't deserve to suffer this way33082019-09-12T22:16:1840986Diane EvansRacing those poor dogs is very wrong--What happens to them when they can no longer run ?33082019-09-12T22:16:31.01740987Jenn FieldsI live in a city and state where dog racing was banned several years ago -- it did not cost jobs or any of the scare mongering. We feel free of something that was horrendous cruel and outdated.33082019-09-12T22:18:38.31340988John C Wert IIIAny animal racing should be banned worldwide.33082019-09-12T22:18:4140989Alice Bowron Dogfighting is all about organized crime and destroying innocent animals for greed. 33082019-09-12T22:19:26.26740990Linda Chernenkoff Greyhounds should not be subject to conditions that we would never subject other animals to 33082019-09-12T22:20:49.03340991Ronnie LapensonAgainst all animal cruelty33082019-09-12T22:21:40.23740992Jane HazaOutlaw this barbaric sport of dog racing and treat domesticated animals as they should be- pets!33082019-09-12T22:22:06.8340993Susan ThiemBan the deaths of these dogs that are bred for entertainment and greed.33082019-09-12T22:22:31.34340995Deborah I KurkoskiPlease end this horrendous cruelty of our beloved greyhounds. They suffer emmensely at the hands of vile human beings, just for their entertainment. God bless all greyhounds, and the people that are trying to end this horrible racing once and for all.33082019-09-12T22:22:40.8940996Lynn HayesDog racing needs to be banned everywhere. The dogs are abused and given meds to make them race faster. Then they are euthanized because they no longer run fast. All of the dogs need to find forever homes and have some normalcy in their lives. Do the decent thing and stop racing.33082019-09-12T22:23:08.78340997Deborah I KurkoskiPlease end this horrendous cruelty of our beloved greyhounds. They suffer emmensely at the hands of vile human beings, just for their entertainment. God bless all greyhounds, and the people that are trying to end this horrible racing once and for all.33082019-09-12T22:24:53.67340999lynne burnleythese are beatiful graceful animals, who are very loyal and loving the way they are treated when therir career is over is shameful. stop treating them so badly\r\n33082019-09-12T22:25:04.95741000Anne RawlingdThese gentle dogs need protection from abuse and the racing industry must not continue to use them for selfish monetary gain.33082019-09-12T22:25:31.9741001Katherine Cregger-MarshallDogs should not be used for racing 33082019-09-12T22:26:13.73741002Rebecca Denise MuzychkaCalling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to put an end to greyhound racing in Scotland. 33082019-09-12T22:26:36.14341003Kimberly SimkinsPlease end racing these poor animals now!!33082019-09-12T22:28:08.34741004Lesley GardnerIt's an outdated past time that needs to be a part of history now! Animal welfare is more important 33082019-09-12T22:28:18.84741005Linda Lee BalkinScotland need to become a more humane country and banning Greyhound racing is the best step to take.33082019-09-12T22:30:12.20341006Andrea BatemanI used to love greyhound racing but having witnessed horrific events surrounding the poor dogs and the fact that they are being exported to China and places like Pakistan makes me feel that this is an evil sport. No beautiful greyhound should be treated in such a despicable way.33082019-09-12T22:31:03.0241007Rebecca Iris HorvathThis is a cruel, inhumane so called "sport". This must stop NOW!33082019-09-12T22:31:07.47341008Julie BaucumPlease stop this animal abuse and exploitation!33082019-09-12T22:32:32.20741009rosemary griffeeStop the suffering now!!!!33082019-09-12T22:32:40.2741010Mary Lynn ParodiI'm of Scottish descent and a huge animal lover and advocate for their safety. This cruel "sport" needs to end NOW!!!33082019-09-12T22:34:43.1641012Kathleen Bischel BeddowWe all are responsible for caring for the animals who live in the world and cannot speak for or protect themselves33082019-09-12T22:35:16.86341013Daniel KwongSupport the protections of animals on all mlm sports.\r\nLOVE33082019-09-12T22:35:31.45741014Rachel Le Huraythis is animal cruelty, ban it.33082019-09-12T22:37:32.20741015Linda K. RobertsGreyhounds should be pets, not property, to be used and abused for entertainment or financial gain!33082019-09-12T22:38:04.70741016Kelly RostanGreyhounds are sensitive and loving members of my family. They are not disposable! Greyhound racing needs to be abolished all over the world.33082019-09-12T22:43:31.3341019Teresa SmithStop the vile abuse of man's best friend.33082019-09-12T22:45:02.75741020Catherine liboironAnimals should be treated kindly and with dignity33082019-09-12T22:46:35.61741021Marie CantwellPlease end this horrible cruelty33082019-09-12T22:48:27.56741022Kerry DrozdThe abuse of greyhounds must end. Family dogs are protected from abuse and so should greyhounds have protection. End exploitation now33082019-09-12T22:48:33.7441023Darlene PietrzakAnimal racing is no longer a sport but the abuse of animals. Little care is given to the health or well being of the animal. Drugs are used to improve chances of winning. Animals are run until they are injured or dead and little vet care is given. We should be able to find other ways to feed our need for excitement then abusing animals.33082019-09-12T22:49:31.83341024Jan RobertsEnough of the suffering in the name of sport!33082019-09-12T22:49:35.20741025Gloria C ThomasThis is an extreme cruelty these beautiful dogs are forced to endure in the name of a so called sport for money. These dogs suffer unimaginable pain and sometimes death for human greed. I adopted one that was ready to be sent to slaughter, like so many of them are once they don't win races. He was the most loving and affectionate dog ever. No Greyhound or any dog should ever have to endure the cruelty of this senseless industry. Ever. 33082019-09-12T22:50:55.6641026Patricia McGrathGreys are wonderful dogs and should never be abused!33082019-09-12T22:56:03.80341028Irène Brizard De ForgesGreyhounds have to be regarded exactly like beloved household pets33082019-09-12T22:57:05.97741029Anna MortenUsing animals as a form of entertainment is outdated and redundant. Greyhounds deserve to be treated as any other breed of companion dog, not used and abused by a few who think this sport is still relevant in 2019.33082019-09-12T22:57:18.41341030Gail RobertsDog racing is cruel and inhumane.33082019-09-12T22:58:07.25741031Michele MeliEnd this torture for these beautiful, innocent dogs once and for all.33082019-09-12T22:59:24.3541032Brenda MillerEnd greyhound racing33082019-09-12T23:00:31.64741033Catherine Saunders-WatsonGreyhounds are amongst the most abused and exploited of all captive animals. It's time to set them free.33082019-09-12T23:00:49.94341034Ginny JohnsonPls stop the racing. 33082019-09-12T23:03:33.25741035Barbara NirenTotally agree32772019-09-12T23:37:33.7141062paul smithThere is no need for single use plastics. Super markets should be fined if they charge more for unpackaged food forcing the customer to purchase plastic covered food .33432019-09-13T00:28:28.98741093Deborah Montgomery I care for family members. However due to these changes I have had to return to work full time after being part time for 17 years.32772019-09-13T06:43:54.14741178Amanda RichmondTotally agree32772019-09-13T06:54:39.89341180Lynda Beveridge Ban single use plastics so our future generations don't have to clean up our mess & the oceans are still healthy. 33432019-09-13T07:25:03.38741191David DenoonWhere an alternative is possible, companies should be forced to use them. Plastic waste should be reduced as much as practically possible and where plastic is still needed all should be recyclable 33432019-09-13T08:37:59.25341200catherinelilleylet us get the pension before we die.32772019-09-13T08:56:20.4641203Bridget Linton Being a 1950s female I've been denied enough through delay in receiving my state pension 32772019-09-13T08:58:49.03741204Catherine LoganThis scheme is totally unfair especially on women who have had their retirement age increased significantly for many years and who also still do most of the caring issues in family life.32772019-09-13T09:08:02.16341206Paula MitchellAll children should have an equal right to equal hours and quality education in a progressive forward looking Scotland.\r\nIf we are looking to promote successful learners then it is hardly fair to reduce input to learners based on their post code.\r\nTeaching time is crucial to extend skills, knowledge and understanding in learners. It's only logical to assume that less teaching time means less input to learners development.32422019-09-13T09:08:04.49741207alice gillespieI am against any changes to reduce actuarial reductions to the Scottish local government pension scheme32772019-09-13T09:18:42.7641209Diane KaneI believe the Govt are robbing us of our private pension, that I have paid into for over 30 years. I am a carer to family members and it is likely I will be retiring earlier before I can access my state pension at 67, to care for them. After 30 years of public service why should I be penalised if I wish to retire on or after my 60th birthday. It is discussing that the Scottish Govt can do this to hard working, and low paid workers. Shame on them. !!! 32772019-09-13T09:53:15.5541220PAULINE SHERIDANHOPE THE PETITION IS SUCCESSFUL32772019-09-13T10:08:48.78741223Julia BrownI have stayed at home to bring my children up, I should not be penalised for this because of future legislation that gave me no opportunity to put aside any savings while having only one income coming into the household. 32772019-09-13T11:15:55.85341229Jim WatsonScheme changes should have been introduced with more thought and on a fairer basis , with more emphasis on new entrants being affected by them .32772019-09-13T11:27:15.30741235Isabella Dinnen-SmithI think it is shocking and a disgrace that part of my pension will clawed back because I choose to retire at the age I expected to retire when I began to pay into my pension. I expected to retire at 60. Now I have to work longer as I will be penalised further. Effectively I don't receive my state pension at 60 and I will be penalised if I try to access my private pension at 60. 32772019-09-13T11:33:54.7341236Suzanne GilmartinI totally agree that the levels of reductions to the local government pension scheme should be reduced. I have been directly effected by the changes to the local government scheme and by the changes to being able to receive my pension earlier. 32772019-09-13T13:18:16.77741248Linda Anderson Everyone deserves a descent pension 32772019-09-13T14:16:13.0241257Ian BriggsTo ensure fairness, I support the principle of a holistic review of the pension reduction calculations by Scottish Ministers. 32772019-09-13T15:38:44.58741299Patricia DohertyYes they should be reduced.32772019-09-13T21:00:50.5741329Sandra SeedWe need to stop polluting our planet with plastics-we can make a difference by banning single use plastics. Supermarkets need to make more effort to reduce their plastic waste33432019-09-13T23:39:14.65341350June MartinI have been denied my state pension, despite spending my working life assuming I would retire at 60. I now find that retiring early from my local government scheme will carry an actuarial reduction. This seems very unfair on women who are already being penalised.32772019-09-14T09:52:54.6741379Jean MacPhailThese ideas and actions need to be taught in all of our schools so that people grow up knowing all of this. 33432019-09-14T11:32:34.87741385Jean FrewTime is fast running out....stop the talking...start the action 33432019-09-14T12:51:19.68741390Ingrid Bain Pensions shouldn't be tampered with. 32772019-09-14T13:06:52.34341395Helen skuodasI'm totally behind this. Come on, let's do what we can to save our planet. 33432019-09-14T15:29:46.76341409Ellen CarmichaelActurial reduction too high. Penalising those who can least afford it.32772019-09-14T15:29:48.96741410Alan CarmichaelThe actuarial reductions are far to high 32772019-09-14T20:16:06.23341429Elaine Kerran urge to the Scottish Government to act now on behalf of all the low-paid workers32772019-09-14T22:19:19.5541436Hilary MacleodI am so fed up picking up single use plastic off the beach....and thinking of all the rest still in the sea, causing distress to sea creatures....Please help!33432019-09-15T09:01:23.41341454Margaret REIDWorked hard all my days. Pension age keeps rising and I have health issues. Do I work till I die?32772019-09-15T13:43:10.60341460Lynda Davison My hope is that where Scotland leads we will follow this is a no brained it has to happen33432019-09-15T15:18:39.89741463William McLaughlinsomething positive needs to be done and acted on we cant go on acting like this just throwing things away instead of recycling them.\r\n 33432019-09-15T17:02:43.341467nancy faythis scottish government are constantly penalising people who actually go out and earn money\r\n32772019-09-15T17:33:52.21341473Norman Henry McLeodWe're kidding ourselves if we think that inclusion, a good thing in itself, can possibly work without adequate funding for more and fully trained PSAs. 33192019-09-15T18:48:05.9441478Kathleen Mcletchie I have taken flexible retirement on August 2018 and am now working jobshare rather than full time due deterioration of my health after working 31years continuously un early years 32772019-09-15T20:20:22.98341483Alice PearsonAt last the people are putting pressure on the government to take action on this33432019-09-15T20:25:46.09341484Alice PearsonWell done for organizing this - very glad to be able to see a way we can put pressure on the government to take action at last 33432019-09-16T07:32:20.99741499Ingrid BainProtect our pensions 32772019-09-16T09:53:36.83741501michael bekierThis inquest is long overdue as i agreed to a pension in 1986 when I started and it has now been altered for the worse. 32772019-09-16T10:26:39.00341502Michael Mccormick No to lower pensions to low pay and female 32772019-09-16T14:16:14.56741510Callum Macdonald, Policy and Research Officer, Royal Blind and Scottish War BlindedRoyal Blind supports the call for adequate funding to support children with additional support needs. Research has shown that up to 80 per cent of learning takes place through our vision, which is why additional support for pupils who are blind and partially sighted is so important. Our education system must respond to a growing need to support children and young people who have vision impairment. The Scottish Government’s school census figures show that the number of blind or partially sighted pupils has more than doubled, from 2,005 in 2010 to 4,574 in 2018. It is vital that pupils benefit from learning approaches designed by specialist teachers with knowledge of delivering and designing a curriculum. A successful education for pupils with vision impairment must involve habilitation and skills for life, which too often are not being sufficiently provided through mainstream education. \r\n\r\nThe vision of inclusion in mainstream schools can only work if it is properly resourced. In many instances schools are not equipped to achieve equal and inclusive education for learners with vision impairment. Too often pupils are told they cannot participate in subjects because the staff do not have skills to teach them or the staff ratios required to facilitate the pupils learning are inadequate. We are concerned that in many instances the main driver for decisions over the education for blind and partially sighted children is based on budget, rather than where they will receive education which best meets their needs. Adequate funding must be matched with a change of culture to ensure children with vision impairment receive the support they require.\r\n\r\n33192019-09-16T14:35:15.95341513grant macdonaldIts time to stop the plastic "post bags" the chinese have plans in place to deal with this, we shop online now the numbers of plastic envelopes must outdo shopping bags now33432019-09-16T14:57:09.34741515Thomas Rodriguez More psa and resources to support teachers and psa is needed. My experience is that support have terribly reduced from p1 to P2, or from 2018 to 2019 33192019-09-16T14:58:05.77741516Elizabeth ClarkAs a women born in the 1950's & affected by pension age increase ( from 60 to 66years old) this is yet another slap in the face for having worked from age 16 years & not able to retire with a reasonable income. After 50 years working & contributing, I thought we would have been treated with a bit more respect.32772019-09-16T15:32:04.32741517E MairI've found reading dogs to be very successful so it would be good to have dogs working with trauma patients as they are a calming influence33442019-09-16T15:45:37.6441519Maureen ChisholmThe sooner we ban single use plastic the better.33432019-09-16T17:12:01.4841523Alison Melrose Am I reading this right I need to work to 67 to receive my full work pension which I have been paying into now for 33 years can I not retire at 60 !!!32772019-09-16T23:21:19.3541533Patricia Petri-Clark There is so much unnecessary packaging that could be reduced but also manufacturers should be required to use consistent plastics that can easily be recycled. Councils across the country need to improve and standardise recycling and give everyone clear, simple instructions on what to do.33432019-09-17T08:35:36.53741541catherine sharkeyI may not be in this category but I feel that anyone who is low paid should not have to suffer any losses due to schemes32772019-09-17T08:37:53.86341542Wilma BurtonI have had bypass surgery in March 2013. On my return to work I found it very tiring and detrimental to my health to work full time and I was concerned that I had to work till I am 67yrs. Due to this I decided to access flexible retirement and accessed my works pension. This allowed me to the reduced hours to promote my health and well being. I feel discriminated against as if I was retiring at 65 this would have been my preferred option. 32772019-09-17T09:12:26.6541543Rita O'NeillDISGRACE32772019-09-17T10:30:50.2441546gerry traceyyes, I agree that I have been disadvantaged financially as a result of this change32772019-09-17T10:41:02.53741547John HunterPeople in Scotland are dying younger, in reverse to the pattern in the rest of the UK, and as such pensions shouldn't be getting reduced so dramatically.32772019-09-17T12:09:09.6941551Karen RobertsonI think what I signed up to in 1980 should be legally binding and if not challenged in a court of law.32772019-09-17T21:51:58.32741575Philippa SharpI am very glad that someone feels as strongly about this as I do. A few years ago Councillors tried to garner the support of Parent councils to support the Highland Council in continuing with the shorter hours. There were many flaws in their persuasions. Indeed the most ridiculous was that the children have to travel further and are therefore too tired. Completely irrelevant in central Inverness when our younger children have to hang about for 30 minutes waiting for the only bus that arrives for the older ones. When discussed further at the subsequent Parent Council meeting, the Head and her staff were categorical that the extra time would be welcomed by them not least in being able to deliver the curriculum. 32422019-09-18T08:19:09.45741589Bronya BarnesFind environmently friendly materials instead. 33432019-09-18T11:49:59.93741601Katrine PatersonDon't think, just do it!\r\n33432019-09-18T16:14:11.741609Anita Gajreeagree32772019-09-18T17:47:12.9241611Ellie-Grace Sutherlandlet's save the planet! 33432019-09-18T20:07:04.9441619Lorraine CampbellIt is time to move forward and eliminate this unjust "CARE" package arrangement for better futures for all.\r\n32772019-09-18T20:07:05.4441620Lorraine CampbellIt is time to move forward and eliminate this unjust "CARE" package arrangement for better futures for all.\r\n32772019-09-19T06:59:30.27741629Mrs a m Newton We need to be proactive with all the rubbish in the sea. Why not get companies to recycle their own products?33432019-09-19T10:06:58.16341630Kathleen LeitchI completely agree with the statement from Unison and think manual workers will suffer more than most.32772019-09-19T10:15:17.40341631Hank CraggsMeasures like these need to be NOW. Politicians must be brave enough to control big businesses 33432019-09-19T11:06:31.3941633Elisabeth BaxterYes, I've been affected with changes to the Scottish Local Government Pension Scheme. I'm 57 passed in March and would happily retire now, however, the penalty is over 40% which I cannot afford to lose. I work for Glasgow City Council and have done for nearly 22 years. My children have started their own families but I'm not in a position to help them with child care, which is also very expensive. I believe that allowing voluntary early retirement would also allow young people to secure a job.32772019-09-19T12:27:45.15741636michael jonesban single use plastics33432019-09-20T13:39:49.0141653Frances GunnThe North Coast 500 has been a resounding success in terms of bringing tourists to the area. However the camper vans are causing much despair and dismay to the folk using the route every day. Litter and human excrement is left and the campers do not use the very good facilities 33302019-09-20T14:10:58.58741654Adam Clemo-backWe can only survive if the planet survives 33432019-09-21T01:16:42.2741662Dorothy PritchardI think it is a quite desperate situation camper vans simply refuse to use some excellent facilities. There is a lovely campsite in Tongue. Every night in the summer there is at least 12 campervans on the causeway 250 metres away refusing to use this modern facility. It is not a case of creating new facilities, it is using those which exist!33302019-09-22T12:59:19.78741677Carole MakehamI am 53, not at retiral age just yet but I would like to hope I had options in the coming years of how i would like to live those years either through illness or having quality family life with no financial worries. So you are right it's concerning that we are not in control of how much or how we get our own money returned to us.32772019-09-23T09:09:00.5341688Stephen HughesI do not think there should be any reductions in our pensions having moved into my 42nd year and to find I am now being penalized for having so much service.32772019-09-23T10:07:50.75741690Fraser KingNot all choices are convenient. All choices have consequences, including the choice of doing nothing. 33432019-09-23T10:45:45.32341691Michele SmithWe have the worse pension conditions in Europe32772019-09-23T10:59:54.2841692Marion Cunningham Shocking way to treat hard working people.Worked since I was 15 after school full time had children still went back to work still working at 60 . Please do something to help me enjoy my later life with some dignity .32772019-09-23T11:16:37.98741693Jennifer ramsayI am signing 32772019-09-23T12:38:50.01341694Mary StansfieldRaising the age has affected me as I cannot now afford to retire until the age of 6632772019-09-23T14:17:43.04741695Angela PhilipReductions should not be made that cause people to be poore at pension age!!32772019-09-23T15:36:08.75741696Derek McLayThe pension scheme has been tampered with for decades. Time for those in parliament to temper their payouts.32772019-09-23T16:13:27.15341698Henry HughesI am nearly 62 years of age so will not be affected by pension scheme changes as much as my younger fellow workers. I want them to be as protected as possible so they can afford to provide for themselves in retirement and feel valued for the contribution they have made to public service.32772019-09-23T16:17:37.23741699Heather McNeilI am female and intend to retire early to care for family members. The level of reduction to my pension may not make this possible and cause me hardship in retirement32772019-09-23T16:20:35.98741700Henry HughesI am nearly 62 years of age so will not be affected by pension scheme changes as much as some of my younger fellow workers. I want them to be protected as much as possible so they can provide for themselves in retirement and feel valued for their contribution to public service.32772019-09-23T16:35:16.1641701Catherine CarruthersI agree the reduction should be reduced as I never expected the pension age to rise and I would have to work another 6 years in an already physical job .32772019-09-23T19:29:04.49741706Lorraine ThomasWe're running out of time. If we act now we can begin to change the implications of our lifestyle changes before it's too late.33432019-09-23T21:12:41.02741707Michael Mcginley Yes a reduction 32772019-09-23T21:14:14.30341708Diane CowanDefinitely 32772019-09-24T05:25:30.72341710Bridget QuigleyThere is no need for all the plastic in use, plenty other biodegradable materials could be used.33432019-09-24T07:00:48.3641711Lucy WildingGoodbye single use plastic!!! 33432019-09-24T08:27:07.78741713Dermot LynchThe LGPS is a funded scheme which officers and authorities have been significantly funding through payments throughout their working careers(authorities usually paying in significantly more)- these changes are unfair and different to what was agreed when joining the pension scheme. This forces people to remain in posts they may not be fit for and are therefore blocking jobs for younger persons seeking employment. The reductions are too severe.32772019-09-24T08:50:55.87341715Chris JAmesDon't Punish Grafters 32772019-09-24T10:45:05.9241717Brian ArmstrongWhy do they always keep changing the rules? Stop fiddling with hard working peoples retirement futures.\r\nYou've survived 40 years of working in Local Government! What next?32772019-09-24T16:37:55.59341718Keven WilliamsonBritish works are struggling enough with poor pay and conditions, even more so with the issues with Brexit.32772019-09-24T16:40:59.1441719Marion Cunningham Shocking worked all my life 32772019-09-24T17:54:32.49341722William TollinI am directly affected by this. A family member has autism and another requires help looking after them. I want to retire asap. Not just women who are carers.\r\n32772019-09-24T18:56:20.37741723Marion CunninghamWorked all my life don't deserve to be a poorer pensioner 32772019-09-24T19:15:57.0241724Alyson BrightTake away plastic containers \r\nCould be changed to metal bento boxes \r\nDearer to start with but long term much cheaper and better.33432019-09-26T04:44:55.16341738Luiza Ewa PiwowarczykIt is a shame to see so much plastic being used and then sitting on lawns, pavements, in parks and on beaches, and everywhere actually. Maybe it is convenient to use them but we need to learn new habits to be able to minimise the damage we have caused. 33432019-09-26T11:06:06.7441739Shem Heather AllansonThis really is the stupidest thing we have ever done as a species! No safety studies, no consideration of the harms created by previous technology and no proper consultation with the public, either. 32732019-09-26T17:17:18.26341744Catherine kelly Encourage reusable bottles 33432019-09-26T18:04:03.3341745Elizabeth MorrisonClean up our beaches, they're our best places.33432019-09-27T07:59:57.18341749Caroline Finlay Please ban single use plastic. 33432019-09-27T12:46:20.80341751Hope Eley-WhitsonLet's be a positive example for the rest of the world and force a change of habits and mindset in our country! 33432019-09-27T12:46:21.61341752Hope Eley-WhitsonLet's be a positive example for the rest of the world and force a change of habits and mindset in our country! 33432019-09-27T13:12:56.19741753hilary thackerPlease add wet wipes to the list as they block the sewers. No need for them !33432019-09-27T14:51:55.0541755Alexandra CeliniThe banning of wet wipes should be included in the priority list. 33432019-09-27T17:07:32.22341756Carol RennieI've read the SPICe 'Briefing' and I think it is rather thin on detail - using indistinct language about the technology and "possible" effects. Surely we need facts based on good science and independent medical opinion about the actual effects. I have yet to come across any report that states that 5G is SAFE??? If there is one then please put it on display for all the public to see. Finally, why is there an ever increasing amount of independent scientists and medical professional calling for a halt to it's roll-out. Over 220 so far, from over 40 countries. No one has addressed these FACTS. I do not want to increase the possibility of myself or others getting Cancer. Regards the use of mice and rats in test - that does not invalidate the results from the Peer Review Study which concluded that there was "Clear Evidence of Carcinogenic Effect" For over 40 years rats & mice have been used to test many things - vaccine, pharmaceutical development etc etc. So no argument there. I clearly state that 5G and its augmentation (untested) with other telecommunication radiations is harmful and we are the test subjects. Look up these 2 things : The Nuremberg Code and The Precautionary Principle. Nothing should be foisted upon an unknown population without there consent, especially if there is any doubt as to its safety and outcome effect. I call for a Moratorium - Now.32732019-09-27T19:19:55.13741759Marianne HughesThis is a long time coming. Education on this should begin in schools, packaging firms given support to change33432019-09-27T20:23:59.17741761Deborah mancinoOn regular litterpicks, single use plastics comprise the bulk of what I pick up. They make up most of the rubbish from my household. It is out of control.33432019-09-27T22:03:40.29741762KateGee Get rid of plastics 33432019-09-28T11:53:01.52741766Sophie FinnA bottle deposit scheme and water fountains in every city and town, improved recycling collections and recycling bins available in every public area33432019-09-28T15:11:48.00741767Hugh JacksonI've read the SPICe 'Briefing' and I think it is rather thin on detail - using indistinct language about the technology and "possible" effects. Surely we need facts based on good science and independent medical opinion about the actual effects. I have yet to come across any report that states that 5G is SAFE??? If there is one then please put it on display for all the public to see. Finally, why is there an ever increasing amount of independent scientists and medical professional calling for a halt to it's roll-out. Over 220 so far, from over 40 countries. No one has addressed these FACTS. I do not want to increase the possibility of myself or others getting Cancer. Regards the use of mice and rats in test - that does not invalidate the results from the Peer Review Study which concluded that there was "Clear Evidence of Carcinogenic Effect" For over 40 years rats & mice have been used to test many things - vaccine, pharmaceutical development etc etc. So no argument there. I clearly state that 5G and its augmentation (untested) with other telecommunication radiations is harmful and we are the test subjects. Look up these 2 things : The Nuremberg Code and The Precautionary Principle. Nothing should be foisted upon an unknowing population without there consent, especially if there is any doubt as to its safety and outcome effect.32732019-09-28T20:52:57.86341770Thomas McCulloch Let's save the planet33432019-09-29T10:04:22.13341778Louise KnightWe know all the reasons why it has to be done. People have shown they are behind it, so lets have our government show leadership and make it happen!33432019-09-30T10:38:22.11741789Karin HeberI would like to see this happening fast. There has been talk about a bottle deposit scheme for years and nothing happened so far. Time is running out. Less talk more action please! Also wet wipes need to be banned. All Scottish beaches are covered in them!33432019-10-02T20:26:39.29341810Mr David Roger Eckton The principles outlined and requested in this petition should be applied to the renewal of rail franchises throughout the UK to benefit rail users and all members of the general public. Genuine action on this muddled situation is required urgently and now!!!33632019-10-03T01:22:28.4341811David Thompson We can't make progress on climate change without an effective public transport system designed to encourage usage and provide an economical alternative to using cars.33632019-10-03T10:13:44.76741815James A MackieThe recently introduced Domestic Abuse legislation is increasing the severity of this problem. Audit Scotland report an increase in numbers of individuals being detained and creating a shortage of custody places. People are being apprehended and detained with little or no evidence and then days later released on the orders of the Procurator Fiscal with no charges being proceeded on. In many cases children are taken into care. Once a parent has been apprehended and where no further proceedings are taken against them, social workers hold this as proof that there ahs been domestic abuse. One police officer told me that the outcome is totally irrelevant. It is the original complaint that must be the key decision marker.33702019-10-03T11:32:54.69341816elizabeth maitlandI think it is unfair what the government is doing and that the level of reduction should be reduced or cancelled altogether32772019-10-03T12:16:49.10741817Morag FramePerpetrators of domestic abuse should forfeit their right to a shared tenancy and be evicted from the property, leaving the woman and children if any to enjoy the tenancy in their own right.33702019-10-03T19:47:10.59741820Hugh mcgovernI do not agree with is proposal32772019-10-03T20:08:46.81741822Elisabeth CookeCompletely support the call for clear and visible pricing structure as soon as possible33632019-10-04T10:36:25.87341826Ian ThomsonThe factory-farming of red grouse for shooting has proven links to wildlife crime and biodiversity loss. So-called "legal" traps are routinely misused or are deployed to deliberately target protected wildlife, such as pine martens, otters, badgers or birds of prey. The unsustainable management of our moors has to stop. 33542019-10-04T10:59:13.7741827Mr Tim CosfordI strongly support a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland33542019-10-04T10:59:28.1341828Janice Morritt Agree with the statement below. Animals and other wildlife are not here for our entertainment to kill and destroy. We are supposed to be civilised!! 33542019-10-04T11:00:57.25741829Barbara DouglasLets recognise that we all want to live on this planet whether we are human or animal without being injured or killed for so called sport.33542019-10-04T11:01:11.61741830Leslene DunnI hope all the revolting vile humans that lay these traps fall into it themselves so they can feel the pain and suffering an innocent animals feels33542019-10-04T11:01:12.1341831Jacqueline NoltingkAction is urgently needed because of the suffering being causes and because of the appalling decline in wildlife in Scotland and the UK as a whole.33542019-10-04T11:02:46.0841832llund BadhamMan thinks he is above nature. Never , its impossible.Leave nature alone .33542019-10-04T11:03:35.5541834Humberto gonzalezSome day will be alone in this plant , there will be no more animals to keep us company , what a sad day that will be 33542019-10-04T11:06:38.08341836Nikki GreenSurely we have moved on enough as a society to know that this needle is killing is wrong. Please be an example for many parts of the world in being a voice for the voiceless. Thank you 33542019-10-04T11:08:52.23741838Joan PringleTime to end this barbaric indiscriminate practice33542019-10-04T11:09:42.28741839Denise YarrowIt is THEIR HOME. Please leave them alone to live their lives peacefully. PLEASE. Thank you. 33542019-10-04T11:10:31.61741840Jacqueline ChartersAnimals deserve better protection than this current Government is giving them. They need to wake up to public opinion and get a conscience of compassion33542019-10-04T11:10:43.72341841Monica WellerPlease work to protect and conserve our planet's biodiversity. All of the plants and animals that live here on earth with us deserve their space and to live. Thank you. 33542019-10-04T11:11:35.49341843linda ticehurstThis is primitive and outdated behaviour and has no place in British society or, indeed, today's world.33542019-10-04T11:13:35.94741844Fiona CrookesWhy is one animal more important than another? It's simply wrong that animals are killed for human fun and amusement. Traps cause a slow and painful death. How can this be right? 33542019-10-04T11:16:41.441845Lisa WoodOur wildlife is declining at an alarming rate, native species facing extinction and the threat of collapsing eco systems. Conservation must be our priority now above all!33542019-10-04T11:18:47.38341846Catherine WilliamsThis brutality must stop, the only way is laws with proper punishment for sadistic people.33542019-10-04T11:27:45.9641849Bernadette Boulton Scotland has to recognise the terrible atrocities to wild life and do something about it. 33542019-10-04T11:32:50.19741850Julie AngellTime to end the barbaric, indiscriminate cruelty and inhumanity of trapping. Come on Scottish Government. Do something useful for a change and prove that you are not ineffectual middle level bureaucrats just taking a wage & fat pension from the taxpayer. 33542019-10-04T11:36:29.72741851Christopher PanayiI believe that the world would like to know why the Scottish government would allow these barbaric practices to continue.33542019-10-04T11:44:28.52741852Jean BennPlease take notice and act on this petition.33542019-10-04T11:48:48.79341853Carrie FisherWe must protect our wildlife, all species, for future generations. 33542019-10-04T11:50:29.30741854Barbara HortonMust be stopped,33542019-10-04T11:59:58.55741855Caroline MooreAll animals deserve respect and protection.33542019-10-04T12:13:10.62741856Harry BlairGood luck with the petition. Something has to be done to stop the needless slaughter.33542019-10-04T12:15:33.5941857Victoria loganKilling wildlife in such a cruel and unnecessary way belongs in the dark ages. Humans know better now. We need our fellow earthlings to share our planet. Shame on all those animal abusers including gamekeepers and those who are involved in so called game killing and shooting. 33542019-10-04T12:19:44.34341858Fiona ThomasI still cannot believe that snare traps are legal. They shouldn't be. I still cannot believe that driven shooting of cage reared grouse is still allowed on the Scottish and English uplands. I still cannot believe that burning heather,slaughtering thousands of mountain hares and denying the ecosystem the time and space to restore itself is allowed. It's barbaric, and in our climate emergency, utterly counterproductive on so many levels.33542019-10-04T12:25:01.8941859Richard WealeEnough savage amusement from the killing industry time to conserve and treasure our wildlife.33542019-10-04T12:27:10.84741860Steve MacSweeneyKilling our indigenous wildlife in favour of killing intensively reared birds for recreation should be a criminal offence.33542019-10-04T12:33:15.84341861Maria PiaSTOP THIS CRUELTY !!!33542019-10-04T12:33:20.86341862Michael SudburyIt is now the right time to consigne the archaic indulgence of field sports, along with its privileged participants, to the history books. Even more urgent is the moral obligation to rid the countryside of gamekeepers whom, even though denying the fact, are responsible for the illegal killing of any birds of prey encountered. This is no longer a question of personal ethics, but one of modern-day ethics. The people of the world demand that politicians implement rules, regulations, and laws that reflect that we, as a species, are actually moving forward into the future, a future where all living creatures are shown compassion and respect.33542019-10-04T12:34:19.11341863Sheena FraserHelp save the animals future33542019-10-04T12:45:52.87741864Jemma MeechamPlease respect our precious wildlife!! We are a civilised country & we must not allow this cruelty to continue. All living beings deserve kindness. 33542019-10-04T12:50:12.67341865Gina ChronowiczWildlife is already struggling in so many areas and should not be suffering further declines to protect grouse for shooting. 33542019-10-04T12:56:18.9441866Tahoe LeighKilling is never the answer to anything and, besides, think about a world without animals if Man keeps killing them to the point of extinction..... Most people LOVE to see Wildlife around them and consider it a bonus if they spot species who normally hide from them!33542019-10-04T13:00:38.00341867Tahoe LeighKilling is never the answer and, besides, think of a World without animals if Man keeps exterminating them to the point of extinction..... Most people LOVE seeing Wildlife around them and consider it a bonus if they spot species who normally hide from them!33542019-10-04T13:17:54.0441868Kate KennerNo animal should ever have to endure being stick in one of these traps. They are torturous and cruel and in the end the issues thought to exist are not resolved. they will return and animals should not be killed in traps so that hunters can kill them instead. The reasoning is perverse, self centered, human centric, and entitled. Ban the traps now.33542019-10-04T13:24:24.19341869Hilary GeeMuch of the killing is unnecessary and ecologically harmful. Where it must happen, the least we can do as humans is to make it humane - fast and painless. The traps & poisons & lead shooting are horrible, cruel and we should stop them at once.33542019-10-04T13:29:30.2141870Judith PageTo pit dog against dog, use anima traps, poisons of any kind again a wild animal is barbaric. It serves no purpose at all. It is not a sport. It does not protect sheep, chickens that end up on your plate anyway... so why KILL?33542019-10-04T13:44:57.6841871Ethne BrownPlease stop animal suffering.33542019-10-04T14:28:45.541873Juliette raymond Kindness please 33542019-10-04T14:38:0641874Jeffery J BissOnly a worthless psychopath would trap. Trappers have no claim for mercy and should be granted none. End trapping and punish trappers.33542019-10-04T14:54:52.9141877Ian WardIt is disgusting and puts shame on our country, that we treat our wildlife in such a savage way. The disrespect and brutality inflicted on our wildlife, to suit individual's need of 'entertainment', has no bounds, judging by the violence meted out to species of animals. The brutality towards our wildlife must stop now 33542019-10-04T15:08:22.2141878Greg WindowsI cannot accept that traps of any kind are used these days to catch kill or maime animals and I hope the Scottish Government (who seem to have a far better history of listening to people than Westminster do) outlaws this barbaric practice.33542019-10-04T15:19:23.7441879Hazel GrantAs someone who lives surrounded by land used as grouse moors, I would love to see an end to the killing of wildlife in my area in the name of sport. 33542019-10-04T15:55:42.35741880Jackie SmithThis is an opportunity to finally ban snares which inflict unnecessary and severe painful death on wildlife and probably domestic animals also 33542019-10-04T15:56:11.35741881Diane DysonPlease end the cruel interference with these wild creatures' lives, as they have a right to live, as do human beings!33542019-10-04T16:13:01.841883Valerie NordbergThese days when wildlife is considered of little value it is imperative we are reminded that EVERYTHING living is interwoven and to create holes in the network through extinction is a disaster for the entirety.33542019-10-04T16:17:44.841884David PritchardScotland's wildlife needs real protection, snares and any form of traps have no place in a modern caring country.33542019-10-04T16:36:45.48741886Martina Rauhut I trust that intelligent people will realize the useless horrific cruelty caused by traps and prohibit them.\r\nThank-you.33542019-10-04T16:39:19.55341887Dave HilliardTraps and snares are cruel and cause suffering. \r\nPlease ban them outright. 33542019-10-04T16:42:55.39741888Gordon WilsonAnd end driven grouse shooting altogether. Make landowners responsible for the health and diversity of wildlife on their land. Ensure that penalties are strong and enforced. Forfeit or Compulsory management of land by NGOs if nature and wildlife are not protected33542019-10-04T16:52:20.58741889Sandra HilliardSnares are cruel. Please ban them. 33542019-10-04T17:09:56.85341890Diana BeamishIt is time we took more responsibility for our endangered wildlife and also showed more kindness and respect. We all have a right to live in this planet, not just humans.33542019-10-04T17:20:14.6541891Christina Brenda LiveseyWe do not and should not have the right to trap and kill any animal, unless it is an immediate threat to our life or that of another human being - or in some rare cases, where there is no other access to food and it is needed for survival. In the latter case, animals should only be killed in extreme circumstances and only for our immediate needs. Killing for so-called "Sport" is an abomination. It is neither ethical or sustainable to kill one type of animal (such as Grouse) in the same location, year after year.33542019-10-04T17:41:33.32341892Lorraine RossI h,ve recently come across a badger with a snare around it, a most cruel agonising death.33542019-10-04T17:42:36.57741893Roderick A.F. MacKayWe need to protect our wildlife and stop people killing animals and bird in our Scottish countryside!!!\r\n33542019-10-04T17:50:20.3641894Linda- Anne MacKayWe must protect our wildlife from people who think killing animals and is sport. It is completely unacceptable , and a disgrace, these idiots should never be allowed to hold a gun let alone use it!\r\n33542019-10-04T19:54:07.6941895Frances ButtonWildlife have a right to a life, stop all snares, horrible and painful let them run free.33542019-10-04T19:56:29.17341896Gaby NavarreteStop the cruelty with poison33542019-10-04T20:10:34.83341897Caroline McManusScotland cannot be a forward thinking compassionate country whilst snares are still legal33542019-10-04T20:34:43.97341899Fiona MackintoshI would like to see an end to grouse moors altogether. Our native wildlife is disappearing at an unprecedented rate and the over management of moorland for one species for the profit of landowners is a major contributor. Grouse shooting is outdated and laughably called sport by its advocates. It has no place in a modern Scotland. How can we call out the Japanese on whale hunting when we have open season on our moors. We claim to be leading the way in climate change. Well start with our moors and get the balance back in our precious ecosystems. This slaughter in the name of sport must stop. 33542019-10-04T20:35:52.56741900Vicki BlakePlease review the animal welfare impacts on the use of traps.33542019-10-04T23:46:55.19741902Dale Elizabeth WestwoodGive wildlife the respect and protection that it deserves, the future for our children is in your hands33542019-10-05T00:43:10.5741903Pam AlvestefferIt's disheartening that traps and snares are used in Scotland. Globally we need to stand strong and demand that all traps and snares be banned and laws be in place to protect wildlife and habitat33542019-10-05T04:26:34.4941904Sherian HoltJust leave God's creatures alone33542019-10-05T07:57:39.28341905Michael watsonThe killing must stop. A small minority killing wildlife for thesake of shooting grouse which are raised in abnormal numbers.33542019-10-05T10:38:36.7941906Diana BeardToo much unnecessary animal cruelty still going on. Lets love and appreciate them all. Soon there won't be any left. Mankind is very cruel.33542019-10-05T11:03:03.3441907Tony PatersonHow can we claim to be a progressive country? Snares are indiscriminate and barbaric. They are banned in European countries - many of whom we would like to think we are more civilised than. And yet we think its acceptable to condemn animals to slow excruciating deaths because areas of land that cannot even be reached by most humans require to be intensively managed to the point traps and snares are left to catch them. Leave that kind wild, and leave it to the animals.33542019-10-05T11:50:00.73741908Mary BetteridgeGrouse shooting and all killing of any wild animals on grouse moors should be banned. 33542019-10-05T11:57:52.9641909Miss Jade SmithThousands of sentient animals suffer and die in traps and snares on grouse moors across Scotland, set in order to control predators or so-called "vermin" that interfere with sporting pursuits. \r\n\r\nDo we have any right to kill one type of animal so that another can be killed for recreation?\r\n\r\nShould any traps be permitted for use against our wildlife? \r\n\r\nIf so, how can an instant and humane death be guaranteed? \r\n\r\nIs it ethical or sustainable to keep killing the same type of animals, year after year, in the same location?33542019-10-05T13:16:24.34341910Christine LadymanIt really is time to end the cruelty. Leave the wildlife alone, it's not here to satisfy people's urge to kill for 'fun' or profit. 33542019-10-05T15:05:09.51741911Alison YatesSnares and traps are barbaric and cruel. Animals are left to suffer with agonising injuries. This needs to stop.33542019-10-05T15:41:18.22341912Susan CheethamKeep animals safe33542019-10-05T15:44:28.9841913Alistair Macfarlane Stop killing innocent creatures. 33542019-10-05T19:44:17.6741914Pamela RogersStop killing wildlife. 33542019-10-05T21:30:54.56341916Susan WilsonAs a biologist I abhor the development of vast tracts of countryside as monoculture 'grouse moors' for a 'sport' and cruelly trapping, snaring and killing native mammals or birds. It is unacceptable in any civilised society and contrary to any 21st century ethic of animal welfare, conservation and ecology. 33542019-10-05T23:22:57.15741917Eileen EastonIt is almost 2020, and horrific, barbaric cruelties towards our animals is still going on! It disgusts me!!\r\nAll animals deserve to be treated humanely, and spared suffering, they do not deserve the pain suffering that humans inflict upon them.\r\nThis horrific cruelty has to end!! Animals are a gift to us, and every animal, every single one of them, should be treated humanely, with kindness, respect and dignity!!!!\r\n"COMPASSION IS THE SIGN OF A NATION'S GREATNESS"!!!!!33542019-10-05T23:27:27.73741918Edie EastleyBAN TRAPS, BAN ALL TRAPPING DEVICES!!!!!\r\nUNBELIVABLE cruelty to animals!!!!33542019-10-06T06:10:46.98341920Theo OdieThousands of sentient animals suffer and die in traps and snares on grouse moors across Scotland, set in order to control predators or so-called "vermin" that interfere with sporting pursuits. \r\n\r\nDo we have any right to kill one type of animal so that another can be killed for recreation?\r\n\r\nShould any traps be permitted for use against our wildlife? \r\n\r\nIf so, how can an instant and humane death be guaranteed? \r\n\r\nIs it ethical or sustainable to keep killing the same type of animals, year after year, in the same location?33542019-10-07T11:11:24.35341984Mrs Marilyn EcktonIt is time that rail ticket pricing is sorted out across the U K rail network33632019-10-07T11:29:43.51741987Hugh mcgoverneI do not agree with this proposal totally unaccetptabe32772019-10-07T15:09:16.78342002Ann TownsleyI agree\r\n32772019-10-07T16:13:50.91742010Mary MurrayI do not agreed with the levels of reduction32772019-10-07T17:26:50.75342017marion fraserI think that the % reduction is excessive 32772019-10-07T20:23:37.0842034Catherine PappasI would like Scottish Ministers to review and issue renewed guidance which significantly reduces the level of pension reductions to avoid low paid workers becoming even poorer pensioners.32772019-10-08T08:33:58.4442062Eileen Walls I am absolutely disgusted that I have to work until I am 66 as I have worked since I left school at fifteen years of age. its just so wrong on every level, as it prevents the younger generation from finding employment.32772019-10-08T08:44:32.57342063Isabel McLaughlinsupport for low paid workers32772019-10-08T08:58:48.5742065Loren McInallyI feel the Scottish Parliament should urge the Scottish Government to reduce the levels of reduction to the Scottish Local Government Pension32772019-10-08T09:03:08.04342066Lorraine McgarrachanTotally agree 32772019-10-08T09:11:27.3942067Helen McDougallNothing further to comment on32772019-10-08T09:29:58.2542068Reg FittonRail fares throughout UK are very confusing throughout UK and need a complete overhaul. Split ticketing, advanced fares, railcards etc. cause much confusion especially for those not computer savvy.33632019-10-08T09:31:06.16742069Jacqueline FlemingI think it is outrageous that once again the hard working class are being penalised and made to work for longer before accessing their pensions which they have worked hard for over decades. 32772019-10-08T09:48:58.3942070morag reillyI am totally offended that these decisions are being implemented and how they affect female and lower paid workers I am sure that these changes to pensions will not at all affect the fat cats who are creaming off funds before making these changes public disgusted council worker 32772019-10-08T10:11:50.3642071Barbara ThomsonYes, of course I've been affected! All my working life I expected to retire at 60yrs of age. Now I can't retire till I'm 66yrs old, with not enough notice to adjust long term financial plans. As I am a low paid worker I can't afford to lose any of my occupational pension so can't take the early retirement option due to huge deductions and without the state pension in place. I thought I had a contract with the government & my employer. As long as I kept paying my contributions, I would receive my pensions as originally agreed. Adjustment to both state & occupational pensions are akin to buying a car on a monthly payment agreement but on completion of payments, the dealer has decided the car is still not mine and they demand further payments for years ahead. This wouldn't be lawful, why are the Scottish Government & Westminster getting away with this.\r\nAngry and completed disgusted - Barbara Thomson32772019-10-08T11:18:57.3642075Isabella McNeillI feel the working class of this country are getting no support from their government at all. 32772019-10-08T18:23:02.91342084Matthew SharkeyI am a serving Police Officer and feel strongly that the Scottish Police Federation DO NOT represent my welfare and need. The top ranks are a closed order and there is no way for rank and file officers to oust the leadership 33822019-10-10T12:06:30.9642114Isabella Dinnen-SmithI have just recently turned 60. \r\nThis was supposed to be my milestone and now it is just a let down. As the government always advised I started to think about my retirement plan and put it into action. I began working full time again when the kids were older and started paying into the council pension 24 years ago to enable me to have a reasonable income receiving both my state pension and council pension at 60. \r\nNow I have to wait a further 6 years for my state pension. I thought, well I'll just have to try and manage on my council pension, but now I find I am penalised again by my council on the instruction of the Scottish Government my council will clawing back at least 25% if I choose to leave before the state retirement age. This cannot be morally right or fair. I am being penalised by the British Government and the Scottish Government for being a woman and a mother who tried to plan ahead with no other recourse to change my retirement plan I had planned. And who benefits from my 25% stolen council pension, if the pension age remained at 60 there would be no reduction, so were is it going. 32772019-10-11T08:43:44.64342136Maureen DonaldsonThis is a horrific thought. There is no way my health would allow this. Please let us enjoy the good years after 60. 32772019-10-12T20:13:39.2742154Norman TinlinAs a retired police officer I entirely agree with the sentiments of the petition33822019-10-13T15:42:34.58742162Derek TaylorTransparency is a must if want trust33822019-10-15T13:30:24.26342196Alison AkremiI am disgusted that when I started worked in 1982 and will have full 40 years service in May 20121 and was looking forward to retiring at 60, to find out I will be penalised for accessing my works pension at 60. My works pension is nothing to do with the Government old age pension which is now 67. This has been done without any consultation to those who will be affected by this. I have also missed out on the Rule of 85 which is also being taken away. I cannot afford to lose this amount of money from my works pension as I am only a local government assistant earning £28,00032772019-10-17T09:15:08.75742453Celia WorrallDisgusting and must be stopped now33542019-10-17T13:09:04.30342473Morag SharpeI agree wholeheartedly with the sentiments expressed below. Who made humans the more important species just because there are more of us - we have turned into the predators. Let our wildlife live in the habitat they belong. 33542019-10-17T14:31:23.59742475Brian LeecyThis disgraceful Victorian attitude needs consigning to the History Books.I am deeply ashamed and embarrassed,of what goes on in the UK.in order just to appease the rich and powerful,to have their bit of bloodlust fun at the expense of everything else33542019-10-17T14:36:03.59742476Jean NobbsI fully support this petition. Mountain hares are part of the natural environment and have declined seriously because of persecution by man. The natural environment comes before the "pleasures" of hunting in any form. 33542019-10-17T15:37:21.4842478Silvana FishlockNo member of another species should be killed for the 'sport' of humans. It is a cruel. barbaric practice which no country wishing to become fully civilised should tolerate, regardless of financial and trade considerations. The countryside can be more profitably developed than by allowing the current shameful activities, I fully support this petition.33542019-10-17T15:46:53.93342479Carol BretonThese horrific senseless murders must stop33542019-10-17T15:56:18.59342480Ron ThomsonDisgusting to think that this horrific cruelty to animals is still legal in Scotland33542019-10-17T16:28:08.0542481Theresà EassonAll life is scared and should not be harmed \r\n33542019-10-17T16:49:49.09742484Elizabeth RobertsonTraps and snares are cruel beyond belief. Please stop this barbaric practice. 33542019-10-17T17:00:58.11342486Christine NesbittAll animals should have the same rights and freedom to live as us sick humans33542019-10-17T17:07:49.2642487DEIRDRE BYRNEI WISH ALL THIS CRUELTY COULD BE STOPPED33542019-10-17T17:34:24.21742488Michael RobertsAs a Scot, I feel ashamed that beloved wild animals are being murdered inhumanely for the sake of a handful of wealthy individuals to engage in so-called sport. 33542019-10-17T17:40:53.88742489Michael DunsbeeHorrendous and evil, this must stop.33542019-10-17T18:25:38.6942491Ros McSweeneyI have spent a lot of time in Scotland, mostly in the Highlands and am so disappointed to find out that Scotland has this barbaric side, it's time to put an end to it and prosecute those who act in inhumane ways.33542019-10-17T18:28:41.842492connie feelywhere have all the deer gone from national trust lands our herd of 40 does is now 8 why the numbers were miscalculated and the cull took out most.this needs to stop. they are part of the reason tourists take photos but this year we have been asked where they are by touurists so i tell them the government killed them without checking figures no one does.33542019-10-17T22:49:12.642497pam mockBarbaric33542019-10-17T23:36:55.21742500Julie DouglassThe bloody pastimes of a few shouldn't be permitted to destroy the wildlife of these islands.33542019-10-18T09:12:16.81342504Patricia MalonePlease leave this creatures to live as they should and stop the cruelty33542019-10-18T10:17:45.0542506Phaedra DreschKilling wildlife is always wrong and killers should be in prison.33542019-10-18T10:53:12.63742507Rosie LeventonAppalling cruelty, I cant believe people still do this sort of thing.33542019-10-18T11:29:53.07742508Jacqueline LavanchyPlease we urge you to leave wildlife free from harm !!! Protect life, don't destroy it ! 33542019-10-18T11:45:22.62742510Mr David J HancockTraps and snare s should be made illegal, most are probably not even checked.33542019-10-18T12:08:37.51742511Lesley StewartAll blood sports should be outlawed now33542019-10-18T15:34:25.00342515Jay GattoIf I had to think about why this is important, there would be something wrong with me.33542019-10-18T16:07:56.19742516Anne GrantI am shocked at the carnage.33542019-10-18T17:21:57.15342517Lynn BeveridgeI wholly support this petition.33542019-10-18T19:39:34.6142518Lori Simpsonseriously Scotland?! Smarten up33542019-10-18T23:18:23.18742519Pamela ODonnellTraps, snares and such like do not discriminate between animals. They kill any animal caught up in them. These lethal contraptions need banning in our civilised society where we respect sentient beings. Protecting grouse is no excuse for these killings and are totally unjustified.33542019-10-19T01:13:16.45742522Christine CottonThis is a horrible and cruel practice and needs to be stopped! 33542019-10-19T22:17:15.27742541Janet RammStop the killing of wildlife on grouse moors. We have no right to cause such suffering to animals.33542019-10-19T22:46:11.02342542Stuart EtheridgeIt is so wrong to kill indigenous species. Stop allowing this to happen.33542019-10-20T00:30:54.99342544Ana-Paula Martins-FernandesPlease end the wildlife killings in Scotland!33542019-10-20T11:25:44.5742553Neil BarberThere is now a live petition by James Robertson on behalf of Families in Support of Evolutionary Studies which Edinburgh Secular Society is pleased to endorse.\r\nIt proposes to teach primary school children about evolutionary science in addition to important learning about world religions.\r\nWhile religious creation myths have poetic and metaphorical value they of course contain no literal truth.\r\nFar from being nihilistic, an understanding of the beautiful principles of evolution can be the very foundation of a meaningful life as, free from the distracting belief that purpose is given by a supernatural being, we can set out to define our own and in doing so, maximise every moment of our brief and lucky existences.\r\n\r\n31482019-10-20T17:35:17.43342564Colin Downes Maths, history and anything factual should be taught in schools. There should be no room for hypothesis such as creatism31482019-10-20T19:13:12.71342567Judi HallworthJust to enable people to shoot game birds many wild animals and birds of prey are killed mercilessly! This is horrifying and must stop! Many of these poor animals suffer terribly in traps 33542019-10-20T19:56:05.91742569Richard DamesNO ONE has the RIGHT to inflict ANY pain on ANY creature on Mother Earth. Animals have EVERY RIGHT to live on Mother Earth FREELY and Happily.33542019-10-21T02:22:20.7542577Lisa ScharinI have to say that it is always so upsetting when humans cannot respect, honor and care about the wildlife we share this planet with! \r\nAs a Christian-I am commanded to be a GOOD Steward of GOD's creatures and HE FORBIDS ANY Cruelty! Please END the killings of Mountain Hares, foxes!!! Thank-you!33542019-10-21T10:57:45.7342580Paul BullockSTOP killing our wildlife - It is ALL unnecessary and we need to mend our ways.33542019-10-21T12:27:50.23742582Lisa HuskissonThe Hunting Act came into force in the UK in Feb 2004. Hunters and their supporters have always flounted this law and have NO intention of ever abiding by it ! The Hunting Act 2004 MUST be strengthened and the consequences of the hunting community's actions MUST BE severe. Very large fines and prison sentences ( years not weeks or months ). 33542019-10-21T12:31:53.3842583Lisa HuskissonSnares and traps are hideous creations. Those who use them have no compassion at all. Animals caught often chew off their own legs to escape or they die in agony over a number of fays. The Moors are their ancient home, WE have infiltrated them. Native moorland animals are murdered so that the non native grouse can be reared there, and then in turn the grouse are slaughtered in their many thousands, by people who pay to blast them out of the skies. Murder on murder to make money ! 33542019-10-21T13:58:54.81742584Ian YarhamIt is important to move to a cruelty-free Scotland,33542019-10-21T15:55:10.1642588Dallas ArnoldThank you for the petition. \r\nMany humans are cruel. We are not the only creatures on this planet who feel joy, and pain.33542019-10-21T18:04:07.14342591Maria Lane Traps are cruel an outdated and their use should be criminalised.33542019-10-21T19:01:02.01342596Linda Gubitosi Animals should not be used as a form of entertainment, for clothing or sport!33542019-10-21T19:05:34.77742598Joanne WilliamsTraps are inhumane.33542019-10-21T19:07:18.13742600Stephen mcbrideSooner this whole so called blood sport(SPORT)??? Is stopped the better. 33542019-10-21T19:09:06.9542601Christine JardineIt is wrong to murder animals especially when it is so rich people can murder more poor defenseless animals33542019-10-21T19:16:16.29342602Rosanna CallaghanI'm supporting this petition33542019-10-21T22:33:26.2942605Linda Deon HansenI m horrified by this continued senseless violence against the environment.33542019-10-22T09:32:31.62742613Justin NugentThe indiscriminate killing of wildlife to facilitate the further killing of birds cannot be allowed to continue..\r\nThe placement of 'economy' over environment is no justification for a sentient being to lose it's life!33542019-10-22T10:55:06.61342614Paul BullockOUR country, OUR wildlife - what gives them the right to kill and persecute especially when they are saving one species to be killed for fun by a handful of sad perverted people?33542019-10-22T12:00:58.61742615Julie AngellTrapping and snaring is barbaric and should be consigned to history along with other outdated practices of a similar nature, such as whaling. 33542019-10-22T12:43:19.4142616david kerr i am totally opposed to not haveng the right to access pension fund until retirement age I have underlying health issue and I would like the option of addressing my own future plans with option available to access pension before retirement age 32772019-10-22T23:04:40.8442687Rebe Woodhouse My kitten came home without a paw the other month which lead to him losing his whole leg but it could have been his life from these awful traps and I really really hope the petition goes through! 33542019-10-23T08:53:08.07742702Brenda DysonSupporting OneKind for the sake of wildlife. The earth is not just for humans!33542019-10-23T10:33:26.4542705Michelle MurrayHate this sport. The abuse is awful. Please support the ban. I do. 33082019-10-23T11:54:31.27342710Tasmin TaylorGreyhounds are not afforded the same right as domestic pets even though they are dogs. Cases of drugging dogs with illegal substances such as cocaine and met-amphetamine have not been punished or addressed by the SSPCA. The GBGB have only addressed 1 case out of 10. Dogs are allowed to race in extreme heat when the guidelines for other dogs are not even to walk them when temperatures are high. Kennelled for 23 hrs in sparse conditions made to run during fireworks night and in ice and severe cold. Dogs killed for a broken toe due to not being financially viable and now exported to places like China where they are bred from until no longer of use and sent to slaughter for the dog meat trade in horrific conditions often boiled or skinned alive . Ban it now.33082019-10-23T16:26:16.26742722Cynthia ThomasPlease stop the trapping and killing of innocent animals! We humans have NO RIGHT to take the lives of any animal.33542019-10-23T18:09:40.20342730Hannah MorrisIt is a great concern of mine what environmental impact this has. Also I believe we have no right to kill one type of animal so that another can be killed purely for recreation.33542019-10-23T18:14:10.2542731Hannah MorrisScience, facts and history should not be distorted. Even some religious families may want the science taught to their children.31482019-10-23T18:24:10.6942732James BoyleThere is no excuse for killing animals on grouse moors, whether these animals are "raptors" or grouse. The unnecessary killing of animals for fun or profit is never acceptable in a civilised society. 33542019-10-23T20:45:57.8842737Alison PalmetWhy do we behave in this cruel way to allow cruel trapping and killing of wildlife to save the grouse. It is all about money! Shameful and this must stop now! 33542019-10-23T21:14:15.5642739Susan MackayAll the land belongs to wildlife!33542019-10-23T22:17:49.8842741Isla ARTHURNo one has the right to trap and kill any animal 33542019-10-23T22:48:47.8542743Jim McIntoshThank you for setting up this petition.33542019-10-23T22:58:57.6242745Ian M RodgerWhile aware that some schools are introducing this subject into the syllabus, it is too important to be squeezed into the teaching. It should stand alongside other scientific teachings31482019-10-24T21:36:30.13342747John LawlerRail fafe pricing is a minefield, and most confusing - especially for the elderly. Needs simplifying soonest!33632019-10-25T03:30:02.9542748Pamela BouldenThe callousness of these deaths of such beautiful creatures is beyond my comprehension.33542019-10-25T07:33:14.60742749Joan BrocklehurstHunting is barbaric33542019-10-25T12:25:10.38342750John WindleStop the senseless killing of our wildlife33542019-10-25T18:40:17.9842752Robert DisburyNature should not be put out of balance in the name of profit33542019-10-25T20:38:04.18742753Melinda CrookPlease take note of this petition and act on it. Scotland's wildlife is precious more precious than grouse shoots. Gamekeepers' abhorrent persecution of wildlife is unacceptable. Tourism can be a vast source of income to Scotland and wildlife tourism is big businessay. Grouse shoots only benefit wealthy Landowners not the wider community. Tourism does benefit the wider community. So get rid of the cruel and out dated shoots then more people will feel inclined to holiday in Scotland to enjoy wildlife and scenery.33542019-10-26T06:16:58.3142755Morag McCallum I think primary school teachers are expected to teach far too much and this will just add to their burden of teaching and reporting. We need to get back to the basics so that children leave primary school being able to read and count. We also need to stop all the formal testing and reporting which takes so much time away from teaching. A Scottish education used to be something to be proud of. Now because of interference by so called experts who know nothing about teaching (curriculum for excellence being a prime example ) Scottish education is one of the poorest in the Europe. 31482019-10-26T16:33:43.63342756Shona DavidsonOn a recent holiday in Scotland I bought a flexi-fare online. I could not find enough information on fares to determine if this was a good idea for me or not. Turned out that it was not and could have spent far less if I had bought the fares I needed in Scotland. I am a pensioner. Thank you. Shona Davidson33632019-10-27T08:23:00.55742757Maurice BenyonIf the SNP expect my vote, I expect action on the same level as Brexit, I have signed this petition repeatedly for several yearsb33542019-10-27T16:08:57.742758Pamela DawsonThis barbaric practice must be stopped. Horrific suffering is endured by these sentient beings. They have family, they are not just things33542019-10-28T19:10:21.56742759Josephine BucknullAny form of killing can ever be justified as recreation or sport as killing causes grief and pain and is simply called murder ... and murderers should be punished and locked up. What if it would be your dog, cat or child...!33542019-10-28T19:10:57.01742760Jonathan RuszkaDreadful that we allow our wildlife to be cruelly abused this way.33542019-10-28T19:14:44.64342761Calum DuncanBan Estate 'management' with blood 'sports' completely. 33542019-10-28T19:15:44.25342762Noreen JennisonAs a Scottish teacher working in a Scottish secondary school, I do all I can to educate my pupils, our future, about caring for their environment and developing an enlightened attitude towards caring for our wildlife. I am appalled that in our country cruelty and abuse of our wildlife continues with the backing of our government.33542019-10-28T19:23:49.7742763DIANE M KASTELThousands of sentient animals suffer, and, die, in traps, and, snares, on grouse moors across Scotland, set in order to control predators or, so-called "vermin" that interfere with sporting pursuits! \r\n\r\nDo we have any right to kill one type of animal so that another can be killed for recreation?\r\n\r\nShould any traps be permitted for use against our wildlife? \r\n\r\nIs it ethical, or, sustainable, or, moral to keep killing the same type of animals, year after year, in the same location?33542019-10-28T19:26:24.1942764mo millerit really is time to end this barbaric and outdated practice .. PLEASE let us have an end to unnecessary cruelty to wild animal who have every right to life 33542019-10-28T19:27:39.94342765Jo ArdellTreat All Animals With Kindness And Respect, and Humaneness.33542019-10-28T19:35:43.6642767Mary EnnsAbout time33542019-10-28T19:44:58.55342768Elizabeth GoumasThis is a totally inhumane and unnecessary practice, to satisfy a few people's desire to kill their selected animal33542019-10-28T19:50:42.83742770Patsi WaiteKilling wildlife so that shooters can kill birds is disgusting.33542019-10-28T19:59:15.77342771Christina CampbellRemember a country shows how far it has evolved by the way it treats its animals .....33542019-10-28T20:03:10.55742772beverley blockleyDo something now before you allow all our precious wildlife to be slaughtered 33542019-10-28T20:09:25.9842773Elizabeth PaytonAbout time the Scottich Government appreciated the wildlife and stopped grouse shooting. So sad so many raptors released in Scotland mysteriously disappear.33542019-10-28T20:33:04.4242775Janice HillIt's time to end cruelty to animals and protect wildlife.33542019-10-28T20:41:29.95342776Michelle HighfieldIt surely cannot be right that British native wild animals are killed in order for a relatively small number of people to take part in what is essentially a 'recreational pursuit' and that animals are killed in such an inhumane manner. 33542019-10-28T20:44:34.54742777Jon PainIt is time that animal persecution is brought under control in the UK. With climate change we are under increasing threat of losing native species. Killing animals to support blood sports is abhorent and inhumane.33542019-10-28T20:49:59.3142778dale riehartTrapping that murders one animal try and stop another is still just plain murder. You have to be smarter than just a plain murderer if you want to solve a problem. \r\n33542019-10-28T20:57:51.20342779Susan FlandersNo wildlife should suffer for the cruel enjoyment of humans' so called 'sport'.33542019-10-28T21:09:30.2742780Desiree SilverstoneThe greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated. Gandhi33542019-10-28T21:11:04.65742781Lorna McAllisterHunting and shooting are anachronistic barbaric pursuits. They have no place in the 21st century in a civilised country like Scotland.33542019-10-28T21:20:30.55342782Jackie LeBretWe must protect our precious wildlife, nature takes care of itself .\r\n\r\n33542019-10-28T21:28:10.00342783Joanne ChidleyWe need to stop and his33542019-10-28T21:29:12.33342784Nikki GreenThese animals should be protected, please do the right thing. Thank you 33542019-10-28T21:37:07.42742785Holly DucharmeThis needs to stop33542019-10-28T21:46:46.86742787John KeithWild LIFE\r\nThe clue is in the name33542019-10-28T21:47:57.32342788Graham MoodiePlease put an end to this mindless slaughter of wildlife in the name of "country sports"33542019-10-28T21:55:44.80742789Eric LorrimanWildlife matters to a lot of people just as much as hunting does to hunters. Strike a balance for goodness sake,stop trapping it's barbaric.33542019-10-28T22:00:58.43342790Peter SainsLets stop the slaughter of animals to enable the wealthy to pursue their bloodlust pleasures.33542019-10-28T22:11:01.0642791Irene BlackwoodAs a Scottish resident and national I am pleading the Scottish Government to ban the horrific traps that are used to kill wildlife in this country. 33542019-10-28T22:33:24.9242792natasha salgadoPlease stop the appalling killing. Animals have just as much a right to be here and live peacefully even more than humans as they all were here 1st. It's disgusting that mankind does not recognize this. PITIFUL.33542019-10-28T22:36:42.98342793Carol gardnetEnd cruel killing without delay 33542019-10-28T23:31:01.91342796Sandy LeafStop killing our precious wildlife.33542019-10-29T00:27:05.18742797Angeline SiebThis is so wrong. We have to stop all the killing. They have a right to live their life just as much as we do.33542019-10-29T01:55:29.4142799Karena Kirk-DrainPLEASE STOP THIS HORRENDOUS PRACTICE NOW!!33542019-10-29T02:04:57.05742800Merry RobinsonGOD told NOAH to SAVE THE ANIMALS NOT THE PEOPLE so we need to RESPECT HIS CREATIONS!33542019-10-29T02:05:06.85342801Merry RobinsonGOD told NOAH to SAVE THE ANIMALS NOT THE PEOPLE so we need to RESPECT HIS CREATIONS!33542019-10-29T06:26:07.1142802natasha buzakCruelty of man have no boundary.33542019-10-29T07:30:22.5742803DAVID SMARTWhy are animals being cruelly killed for the benefit of people who pay to kill another animal? 33542019-10-29T08:04:04.8142804Mark LundThe term vermin is so outdated, and subjective, in the 21st C. The reason for calling this wildlife, vermin is because some of it may, MAY! impact on the obscene numbers of overbred, protected, and invasive species that are shot for the fun, entertainment, by a relatively few number of mostly wealthy people who think they own the countryside, and therefore have limitless powers to destroy our wildlife for their fun, and the destruction is seemingly carried out by those who have no respect for the wildlife, or in their terms, vermin, for purely monetary reasons. This needs to stop and the illegal killing needs to be punished with fewer loopholes for the best lawyers to take advantage off.33542019-10-29T08:43:12.37742805Margaret BeckettThese poor animals need as much help from these cruel people and the pleasure they get from inflicting such awful cruelty33542019-10-29T08:50:30.1742806Jan RussellStop the senseless killing of animals. 33542019-10-29T09:24:37.47742807Barbara woodroughI do not think , humans have the right to kill any animals. 33542019-10-29T09:37:45.19342808Ian Workman he crucial need everywhere is to achieve a Balance in Nature, where all species survive and prosper. This of course includes ourselves, man, homo sapiens, us. We have through the centuries changed all this for sport and recreation. Not just to feed and clothe ourselves and our families. This has been the principal reason for the unbalance and the suffering and extinction of most other species. There is a need for respect to avoid a landscape devoid of any other wildlife at all. This is especially true on the shooting estates. Full of eye catching scenery but lifeless. It's been proven that city centres have a better Balance which, although good for city dwellers, it's very sad for the huge areas of moor and farmland in our country. It is time to change before it is too late. Probably won't happen in my lifetime but let's preserve something for our descendants. Prove to them that most of us do actually care, we do want people to enjoy our countryside. So let's get the ball rolling. The shooting estate employees have so many opportunities in the thriving tourism and photography markets. There's no need for unemployment concerns. The Estate owners and managers have shown their opportunism. They just need some persuasion to follow alternatives. It's been done elsewhere, it can be done here. But it is down to the law makers to set the baseline then it's the policing to ensure we stay on track. So, please, seriously consider this petition to at least get us all on the right track to achieve the so crucial Balance. 33542019-10-29T09:55:31.35742809Susan DuncanI've always been proud of my Scottish heritage, but this cruel killing of "predator" animals is nothing of which to be proud. Surely Scotland can do better.33542019-10-29T10:22:39.93342810Deborah Anne MoorePlease stop the unnecessary killing of these birds and any other innocent animals.33542019-10-29T10:33:03.36342811Jennifer GoldI stand by the request to call on the Scottish Government to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland. \r\n\r\n The ethics and sustainability of the routine and repeated killing of the same species in the same location must be investigated. \r\n\r\nAlso I support the banning of snares, Larsen traps and certain other types of live traps outright, and all spring traps on animal welfare grounds.\r\n\r\nI support a stronger mechanism to ensure proper scrutiny of all practices undertaken by hunters, shooters and those who trap, torture and kill animals.\r\n \r\nIt has been proven many times that those who cause pain and suffering to animals, also are capable of causing this pain and suffering to humans. The improvement of these laws not only prevents cruelty to animals, it can prevent cruelty to humans too.\r\n\r\nI look forward to hearing from you.33542019-10-29T12:30:34.73342814Eleanor HainingThose so called sports belong in the past Cruely of this nature is stomach churning 33542019-10-29T14:31:5442815Mairi DonaldSnares should have been banned a long time ago. How can we call ourselves animal lovers when we still permit snares - they are not humane at all. C'mon Scottish Government, lead they way with the snares. 33542019-10-29T15:49:58.27342816Yvonne RothwellI am an animal lover and I abhor any cruelty especially when it is for the benefit of hunters killing other animals. All traps should be banned everywhere in the UK33542019-10-29T17:39:47.43742818June MackayNo need for these barbaric practices to keep going, what a cruel horrific thing to do to any animal.33542019-10-29T17:54:39.1342819claire RidgesKilling wildlife for sport or entertainment is, in my opinion, both cruel and wrong and I want the practices to end as soon as possible. 33542019-10-29T18:17:12.48742820Brenda DysonSupporting OneKind for the sake of wildlife. The earth is not just for humans!33542019-10-29T18:49:20.41342821Gary Brian PrescottIt is always appallingly sad to cycle around the moorlands of Scotland, as I have on many occasions, and seen a dearth of wildlife due to the slaughter of anything that might mean that the murders of Red Grouse won't have the numbers they need for their sick sport. I hope that one day that the Scottish government will lead the way to stopping the evil perpetrated on the moors.33542019-10-29T21:39:28.06742822Debbie HunterIn humane act no need 33542019-10-30T04:38:54.13742823Rosemarie Bindon.I am anti-animal traps of any description. Every animal has the right to live. Killing animals IS NOT RECREATION! It is definitely not ethical or sustainable to destroy the same type of animals annually in the same area.33542019-10-30T08:17:18.5442824Alice Rose We have no right to torture and murder our wildlife33542019-10-30T09:55:28.22742825victor ronespeople must start respecting animals and birds if they respect their parents33542019-10-30T11:12:30.95742826George ShepherdTraps and Snares should be abolished in Scotland as should the killing of any animal so that another can be killed for recreation.33542019-10-30T11:42:53.43342827Janet HarperHappy to sign lets hope this madness stops 33542019-10-30T11:51:41.58742828Trisha WaghornPlease stop this use of traps.33542019-10-30T14:33:24.67342829Tim MarshallThese animals are not vermin they are part of the ecology of the land.33542019-10-30T18:02:06.76342830Susan FarquharsonNo one should have the right to kill our wildlife just for the sake of recreational grouse shooting.\r\nWhile such activities bring money into the Scottish economy, I believe that far greater economic gain could be achieved by promoting our wildlife, and creating a sustainable environment that all can enjoy.33542019-10-30T20:12:49.1742831Jane KingHaving recently moved back to England from the west coast of Scotland I am astounded by the complete disregard of nature when it comes to making money in both countries. It is evident that human profit is being put before protecting the environment and this has got to change on many levels. The destruction of the mountain hare population on this scale is unreprehensible and if the law makers refuse to do anything about it they are complicite with the business and landowners that profit from decimating nature. 33542019-10-30T21:12:50.80342832Mirella FloreaSaving animals to save the world is my wish.33542019-10-30T21:21:56.25742833Mary BainIt is very wrong that thousands of our native animals are slaughtered for the benefit of the wealthy few. In some areas our hare numbers are dangerously low.33542019-10-31T23:02:51.4242834George MurisonSNP seem to get more money from the treasury than they have accounted for ie brexit planning what have they done with the allocation of 90 million pounds. Also emails not covered by FOI from the first minister why was this allowed.31862019-11-01T09:02:32.0542835Ryska WatkinsI believe this petition is long overdue in order to have an honest insight into how the Scottish Assembly is being run and to ensure that applications for FOI are properly met.31862019-11-01T10:29:14.21742836David PeterThis is happening too often to be ignored, action is needed now.31862019-11-01T20:57:14.97742838George McBurnieThe killing of of wildlife is unacceptable. Profit through animal suffering and before a health countryside is barbaric 33542019-11-02T21:20:04.05342841Paul McDonaldNo animal should be killed in this way 33542019-11-02T22:09:43.47742842Georgina Kane Please leave our wildlife alone they should have the same right to life as we do. I ask this as they have no voice of their own and the pain they feel is the same pain as we would feel.33542019-11-03T16:56:53.76342844ian workmanThe crucial need everywhere is to achieve a Balance in Nature, where all species survive and prosper. This of course includes ourselves, man, homo sapiens, us. We have through the centuries changed all this for sport and recreation. Not just to feed and clothe ourselves and our families. This has been the principal reason for the unbalance and the suffering and extinction of most other species. There is a need for respect to avoid a landscape devoid of any other wildlife at all. This is especially true on the shooting estates. Full of eye catching scenery but lifeless. It's been proven that city centres have a better Balance which, although good for city dwellers, it's very sad for the huge areas of moor and farmland in our country. It is time to change before it is too late. Probably won't happen in my lifetime but let's preserve something for our descendants. Prove to them that most of us do actually care, we do want people to enjoy our countryside. So let's get the ball rolling. The shooting estate employees have so many opportunities in the thriving tourism and photography markets. There's no need for unemployment concerns. The Estate owners and managers have shown their opportunism. They just need some persuasion to follow alternatives. It's been done elsewhere, it can be done here. But it is down to the law makers to set the baseline then it's the policing to ensure we stay on track. So, please, seriously consider this petition to at least get us all on the right track to achieve the so crucial Balance.33542019-11-03T21:07:54.81342845Dave DickI have witnessed personally over the last 5 decades dozens of cases of supposedly protected wildlife killed by both legal and illegal traps and snares on scottish managed grouse moors. Time to end this pointless slaughter.33542019-11-03T22:23:02.33742846Joyce HodgesonThese barbaric acts have to be stopped and stopped soon. 2019 and we are still trying to stop blood sports it is beyond belief..33542019-11-03T23:11:25.54742847Steven WadeWhat have they got to hide ? PFEW has to comply so why not the SPF? 33822019-11-04T12:10:3842848Jean Coleban grouse moors\r\n33542019-11-04T22:01:17.85742849Eileen EastonAll animals deserve to be treated humanely and spared suffering, they do not deserve the atrocities that humans inflict upon them. It is almost 2020, time for all cruelties against these precious beings to end!!!!33542019-11-04T22:51:51.8842850Sharon priorIn this world is a lot of suffering especially where animals are concerned we don't need to use traps or Snares the pain is horrendous please can we stop33542019-11-05T11:56:57.9242852Kay Philips Wildlife must be allowed to co-exist with people. They must be shown dignity, compassion and respect. 33542019-11-05T17:27:37.7342854Jim Rooney Though I live in Derbyshire so close to the other killing fields I regularly travel through the Cairngorm NP to visit my gran children and see all the carnage inflicted on wildlife in the park by the purveyors of this sport. 33542019-11-05T19:04:07.06742855Graeme McBrideTransparency and accountability are words often used by Ministers. I'm pretty sure that everyone will agree that nobody should be above reproach when using a platform for defamation.31862019-11-06T07:26:24.5142856Yvonne DalyStop the slaughter of defensive animals NOW33542019-11-06T09:55:12.14742857Deanna Austin-Croweonly 4% of mammal life is wild we have obliterated the rest. Time to stop. Stop killing wildlife to sustain a cruel blood "sport"33542019-11-06T09:58:41.53342858Brian WilliamsAs a proud Scot now living 'abroad' it saddens me greatly that my country's reputation and image is sullied by the activities of the driven grouse shooting estates. We should be celebrating our natural wildlife not slaughtering it for the sake of a profit.33542019-11-06T10:07:17.4442859Mark LundThis is the 21st Century, and destroying our wildlife just to increase the overproduction of game birds shot by a relatively small number of the population for their enjoyment is no longer acceptable. There is no justification, and is carried out by those with no sympathy for the animals they destroy or any notion of what is right or wrong in this practice, but worse is that they are sponsored by their wealthy employers to maintain a low predator, high target ratio which is completely unnatural in the countryside, which is where this is happening. 33542019-11-06T10:14:12.6542861Karin chiltonThis is disgusting cruelty. Killing our beautiful wildlife to hunt grouse. 33542019-11-06T10:14:31.8842862Sheila DorsettPlease end this killing. I am committed to only visiting places free from hunting and shooting. I love Scotland and am sad to have given up my twice yearly visits. Wildlife tourism is big business so there is a potential for Scotland in the future. Plus stopping this cruelty would be the right thing to do. Please.. 33542019-11-06T10:27:58.30342863Keith AspdenPlease stop the killing of native wildlife to profit shooting estates. 33542019-11-06T10:43:25.38742864Gillian DuncanWe need to stop killing our natural wildlife. I live in a very rural areas and can see how empty the countryside is looking. It's shocking!33542019-11-06T10:51:25.88342865Gordon EcclestonThere is no need to kill these wonderful animals and birds33542019-11-06T11:35:01.59742867Nick AdamsGive an inch and these people take several mile. 33542019-11-06T12:23:34.5742870Karen Owen This has to stop it's disgusting. All in the name of farmers making money 33542019-11-06T12:36:02.4342871Spencer mckeeThis is wrong and brings shame on such a nice country. 33542019-11-06T12:38:11.04342872Linda RicouardI think snares and traps are cruel and barbaric and should be banned in Scotland and the entire country! 33542019-11-06T12:56:22.01342873Jillian Bland The world's opinion of the British is that, we have killed off our own wildlife population yet we go abroad to tell them to be kind to animals and to stop killing their wildlife. Yet with a reputation like ours, how can we. We're bulldozing Forests and calling Brazil for doing the exact same thing. Killing for the pleasure of it is vile, apart from the impact this has on human lives, of which the subject is too vast to comment on here. I understand that large amounts of money is made from this uncivilised trade but we must steer away from being Savages, even the wealthiest of us, Who know that they can do what ever vile thing they want. 33542019-11-06T13:00:37.8742874Eric MccabeIts a no-brainer. Enforce wildlife laws that are clearly flouted.33542019-11-06T13:04:16.91742875Bernard Burnett ElliottThis is needless cruelty and it belongs to a forgotten age.33542019-11-06T14:55:54.90342879Fran Rouse Please stop hunting if these beautiful animals \r\n33542019-11-06T15:10:27.45342880Brenda Lauren Kilburn I full support one kinds petition. I'm disappointed, personally, on SG slowness to swiftly take control of this situation. Many animals are dying and suffering immensely, needlessly. Action must be taken now. 33542019-11-06T15:24:42.40742881Alan Paul BussonPlease end this senseless killing of wild animals all in the name of brutal hunting. Times have moved on - we are no longer living in the 19th century. 33542019-11-06T15:40:36.20742882Dennis FallenThis is an outdated and elite nonsense that needs to stop immediately.33542019-11-06T16:20:23.35342883Daniel MCDONALDEnd the persecution of wildlife on the moors. Moors do not exist for the leisure pursuits of a select few to shoot grouse. 33542019-11-06T17:33:08.69342884Vicki Noble Cruel beyond words. These people need to evolve. Killing for fun is not sport, it's being a sadistic psychopath! 33542019-11-06T17:43:56.19342886John WillsonNo longer acceptable in this day and age. Traps are barbaric and cruel and there use should be ilegal and the law enforced. 33542019-11-06T18:01:44.0142887ANDY HOLDENHow long do right-minded people have to wait before the Government actually takes proper action AGAINST the killers of our of wildlfie? For crying out loud BAN driven grouse shooting NOW!33542019-11-06T18:25:34.9842888Anne ursellDreadful33542019-11-06T18:35:09.44742889Joanne AllenWe do not have any right to kill or snare animals!!33542019-11-06T19:09:45.2842890Marcie Sawkins No living thing should be made to suffer such traumatic end no man, no animal. 33542019-11-06T19:16:09.1142891Angela HathwayThis lust for blood is a disgrace and brings shame on the UK as a whole. The perpetrators are evil.33542019-11-06T19:51:15.11342892Caroline HughesJust STOP messing around with nature and its fauna!!! Its there for a reason and that is nothing to do with humans! Keep out of its way and stop killing needlessly!!!!33542019-11-06T20:09:31.50742893Michelle Lavender Just stop killing, nature will find it's own way. 33542019-11-06T20:51:30.8442898Debs WirralDisgusting treatment of animals have they got no respect...? David Attenborough would put them to shame!!33542019-11-06T20:56:10.46742899Susan ThomasThe persecution of wildlife to enable thousands of birds to be bred and reared purely to be shot and killed is totally unacceptable and immoral in every way. It should NOT BE TOLERATED IN A SUPPOSEDLY CIVILISED COUNTRY LIKE SCOTLAND33542019-11-06T21:08:32.26742900Chris RigbyWe are not the only species on this earth.\r\nWe should respect the natural eco environment and not manipulate it for sport and greed33542019-11-06T21:12:54.7542901Frances ButtonThis barbaric practice must stop. Stop all unnecessary anguish to poor animals. Stop shooting poor birds. Stop humans acting barbarically.33542019-11-06T21:18:00.79742902Annette DuffStop this animal cruelty 33542019-11-06T21:19:50.18742903Colin McIntoshThis practice underlines the attitude by staff and, more particularly, owners, of sporting estates that nothing can stand in the way of their right to make money. Like the persecution of raptors, this practice has no scientific justification, impoverishes the biosphere, and causes immeasurable suffering.33542019-11-06T21:35:43.8342904John KingContrary to how we may like to think of ourselves, we clearly aren't a civilised society. We have allowed our traditional industries to vanish, yet hang onto the anachronism that is hunting.....often excused because it provides poor employment for a few saddoes and a few outings for the inadequates that enjoy killing things. \r\n\r\nHere in the southeast of England, we have pheasant shooting. The native wildlife gets persecuted just the same and many of the birds that are shot get buried as there aren't the outlets for them. And that is nothing short of outrageous.\r\n\r\nI am a country hick well established into my seventh decade on this earth and have been about long enough to remember that all that got shot was eaten and that we didn't have to endure the almost constant gunfire that we have now. Indeed, these hunting people discharge their weapons on, or close to public land now, without any regard for the safety of others. 33542019-11-06T21:42:14.03742905tony plantthere is no future in killing33542019-11-06T21:46:33.9942906Gertrude WrightKilling animals so that there are more birds to kill is senseless slaughter33542019-11-06T22:07:09.27342907Linda NorrisGrouse moors are a scourge to wildlife, they benefit nobody but bloodthirsty, greedy morons. Our wildlife in jeopardy, time to put the moors back to their natural state!33542019-11-06T22:19:44.38342908Carlo Silvestrilove nature!!! ban hunt!!!33542019-11-06T22:31:04.5142909CAROLINE LEAThere is no justification to treat our precious wildlife with such cruelty. We need to preserve what we have. 33542019-11-06T22:31:44.3742910Paul McMillanWhy is this still legal?33542019-11-07T00:14:40.0142911Hilary Bartley Just heartbreaking , what a waste of beautiful creatures lives. Man is so cruel33542019-11-07T03:17:16.5242912Jane JenkinsWildlife needs to be left alone so it can recover from the mass slaughter it has suffered over the centuries. Please, don't let us lose our wild animals! 33542019-11-07T03:39:30.64742913Charlotte TupperIt is concerning to think other wildlife is being trapped here and these methods are harming other wildlife 33542019-11-07T04:57:32.1742914Ellen PriorPlease make sure there is no animal cruelty!33542019-11-07T06:51:51.87342915Angela ReedUnnecessary cruelty & suffering to life on earth33542019-11-07T06:58:32.70742916Shona HarrisTruly disgusting and mindless33542019-11-07T07:35:46.34742917Javatvasi DasaAside from protecting the persecuted animals and birds we are protecting the children who are indoctrinated into this carnivorous culture which severely reduces their opportunities for social interaction with their environmentally conscious generation. 33542019-11-07T07:45:46.55342918Andrew MeakinThe wildlife need us to help prevent all this cruelty. The wildlife are entitled to peace and to be free from persecution 33542019-11-07T07:46:04.14742919Andrew MeakinThe wildlife need us to help prevent all this cruelty. The wildlife are entitled to peace and to be free from persecution 33542019-11-07T09:16:46.19342921Patricia HarmsworthAbsolutely shocking.33542019-11-07T10:49:23.95342922Dona CrumMurdering these beautiful sentient creatures just so some rich murderer can murder with impunity is diabolical and degrades the whole human race!33542019-11-07T11:07:21.6142923Sandra TimmsI'm shocked that this barbaric behaviour towards our countries wildlife is still allowed in 2019! It has to stop!33542019-11-07T11:20:41.3542924peter reganwhy should a few tweed clad rich people,have the right to deprive people of the right to enjoy wildlife.\r\nThis industry wipes out wildlife destroys the enviroment it's contribution to anything is negated\r\nby it's massive destruction to nature.\r\nI live near moorland that is used for driven grouse\r\nshooting,thankfully much of it has been stopped by the\r\nlocal water authority who own the land,but only because of the devastating floods caused by the water\r\nrunning off the scoured moors.This exploitation and\r\ndestruction of wildife and the enviroment for a few rich\r\npeople has to end.\r\n33542019-11-07T11:25:03.0442925EvereldScotland is becoming as bad as the USA in killing animals who are merely doing what they need to do to survive. These vile traps must be stopped as must the killing of all wild animals for no good reason whatsoever. Scotland I am bitterly ashamed of you, ban the traps and the killing of innocent animals NOW please.33542019-11-07T11:41:15.49342926Ursina Hack-MaclellanEnd the useless killing of wildlife. Our natural environment must no longer be the playground of the rich.33542019-11-07T11:49:37.77342927hazel linda hamesShould be consigned to history along with all the other rubbish the aristocracy persist in hanging onto. 33542019-11-07T12:05:51.29342928Carmen Cardashian We destroyed their habitat to build ours and now we go killing them in their own territory too? Pathetic species we ,humans are!!33542019-11-07T13:01:13.99742929Lucie DudleyThis barbaric cruelty must stop now x33542019-11-07T14:21:42.70342930Jonathan BriscoeStop this barbaric pointless animal cruelty33542019-11-07T16:02:13.2442931Roxanne BrownShame on my mother land for allowing such barbatic ways33542019-11-07T16:20:13.0442932Beverley SnowdenPlease stop killing these animals. 33542019-11-07T16:22:41.9342933Steve D Mitchell.I am sick of seeing more and more evidence that scarce wildlife is being slaughtered so that rich can kill grouse for sport! When are the grouse to be issued shotguns? When a case comes to court, the OWNER of the estate should be required to stand in the dock!33542019-11-07T17:48:27.14742935Angela DuriezThis is barbaric and evil and has no place in this world.33542019-11-07T18:00:25.56342936Sandra BoltonSomething needs done, and fast. Please support this petition.33542019-11-07T18:10:34.59342937Elaine Whittaker.This persecution of our wildlife for greed must stop NOW!33542019-11-07T18:33:21.81742939valerie C Tippettthey must stop33542019-11-07T20:49:49.63342942Geoff TansleyAn embarrassing anachronism of cruelty.33542019-11-07T21:35:46.97742943June McAvoyI had to listen to the screaming of a suffering fox caught in a drag snare, dangling from its neck in agony for hours awaiting help from SSPCA. That sight and sound haunt me still. This cruelty is abhorrent to any civilised society. Please use your powers to put a stop to this.33542019-11-07T22:09:14.01742944Sheila Lothian Its disgusting & outrageous for animals to be mistreated & killed in this way, without regard for their suffering....this barbarism must stop !!!33542019-11-08T01:09:39.3542945Sarahjayne ThomasBarbaric and totally unnecessary!!!! 33542019-11-08T02:26:34.3542946Colin DaviesWildlife protections are needed in Law33542019-11-08T05:04:42.24742947Philip BahiaI hate animal abuse and killing them for no reason is inexcusable,those who do this to animals are not human at all their murderers and evil killing God's creatures.33542019-11-08T09:01:18.07342948Callum RussellI'm led to believe humane control of pests is done by gamekeepers & game wardens this doesn't look like the work of either and should berightly condemned 33542019-11-08T13:56:53.1642949John LumbardTraps including cage traps used to trap birds should not be allowed to be used under the General Licence. Traps are also the cause of death for many non target species. Banning is the only real solution. 33542019-11-09T19:03:38.8742951Mark WoodfinPlease stop the persecution of our wild species for the sake of a few so called "sportsmen". Ban trapping and shooting of native species.33542019-11-10T07:50:45.6542952Pat O'Sullivan This is Not sport or animal control. It is organised barbarism. Get it stopped 33542019-11-10T12:24:54.87342953Alistair GodfreyAnimal cruelty is against the law, but it persists. The law has been tightened, but persecution continues. Current legislation and how it is failing needs to be examined, reviewed and new measures implemented.\r\nIn some areas we have not progressed beyond the Victorian mentality of game management. Enlightened practices need to replace them.\r\nAll traps need to be banned.\r\nThe case for retaining grouse moors is difficult to support. The control of deer needs another approach. Humane deer control is a requirement to maintain ecology and has the potential, if carried out resonsibly, to be a sustainable practice.33542019-11-10T22:21:06.9742954Andrea McAdooAbsolutely unconscionable, reprehensible, repugnant, despicable an evil act of barbarism, PLEASE INVESTIGATE & BRING THE CRIMINALS TO JUSTICE THE GUILTY PARTY OR PARTIES TO JUDGEMENT FOR THE JUSTICE OF THESE PRECIOUS SENTIENT SOULS, LIVING BEINGS, PREGNANT MOTHERS, INFANTS, YOUNG & ADULTS WHOM SUFFERED UNTOLD & UNIMAGINABLY CRUEL NEGLECT, ABUSE, TORTUROUS DEATH UNDER YOUR ARCHAIC LOOSE AT BEST RULES AND LAWS WITH ABSOLUTELY NO PROTECTIONS UNDER YOUR LAWS!!!!33542019-11-11T18:05:13.74742955Fay van DunkThere is no justification to wilfully end an animal or bird's life. We have no right. Until we understand that animals are not inferior we will continue to be ignorant and continue to kill them33542019-11-12T08:12:41.11742957deborah theobaldban traps and snares33542019-11-12T08:20:27.20342958Julia KaminskiSnares are unbelievably cruel, and do we really want a future without wildlife? No!33542019-11-12T08:28:34.02742959Josephine A MunroI feel strongly that there is no appetite in modern Scotland for such animal cruelty, we have moved on from such behaviour and our people now care about animal welfare and expect our laws to reflect our feelings.33542019-11-12T08:32:08.20742960Tracey HunterThis disgusts me that men and woman want to kill animals for sport go play football and hockey you snobs leave the animals alone 33542019-11-12T08:38:18.49742961Carole Elizabeth HoughNationally our wildlife is under threat as never before. The beautiful Scottish hare is endangered & yet over 26,000 are killed in the name of sport. It is time that your government took some responsibility for the appalling & barbaric use of traps & snares that should be condemned to history!33542019-11-12T08:40:24.342962Margaret GillStop this cruelty now33542019-11-12T08:44:15.1642963Jean robinsonOur wildlife needs protection 33542019-11-12T08:49:07.17742964Sarah PittI would like to see a completely different approach to managing grouse moors and farmland where this trapping continues. it is totally acceptable in the 21st century to let healthy animals suffer in this way and leave them to do so for so long. II would go even further and ban recreational shooting unless it provides food for the person who shoots i.e. a quota at least for shooting birds should be bought in - no more than 2 birds per person. \r\nHave landowners not read the figures - British wildlife has declined by between 50-70% since the 2nd World War. We should not be taking out numbers either by trapping or shooting but nurturing our precious wildlife and the biodiversity it brings these lands so that their numbers can recover and a natural balance can be maintained. 33542019-11-12T08:55:41.92742965Jennifer Thomson ScotlandIt's time to safeguard the wilidlife in Scotland from hunters and those involved in bloodsports33542019-11-12T09:29:46.59742966Constance GotsopoulouPlease stop this barbaric behaviour we are in the 21st century. Killing sentient being should be illegal!33542019-11-12T09:35:30.10342967Priscilla LittmodenStop this cruelty. Every animal had the right to live33542019-11-12T09:53:45.3242968Anne StarkI have been campaigning against grouse shooting for years now. Lets hope the constant the constant awareness raising by petitions like this will lead to a total ban. The sooner the better.\r\n33542019-11-12T09:57:11.9642969Elizabeth CooperDisgusting behaviour must stop NOW 33542019-11-12T10:10:50.90742970Claire KordasCruelty has no place in our world33542019-11-12T10:37:04.09742971Rue EkinsThe destruction of wildlife including the ongoing persecution of raptors and mountain hares in pursuit of grouse shooting is an appalling stain on Scotland's reputation. There is no place for such a 'sport' in modern society if it depends on illegal activities and unsustainable killing of wildlife to secure its market. Completely unacceptable and the perpetrators should be held to account.33542019-11-12T10:43:27.57742972Colin WrightIt's a disgrace it's happening in our country,,!!!33542019-11-12T12:32:18.53742973Audrey KaufmanPlease show compassion!!33542019-11-12T12:42:22.83342974Brigitte BleyerAnimals don't have a voice, so you will never stop hearing Mine33542019-11-12T12:56:23.3742975Sallie JohnsonThis is the 21st century, not the Dark Ages. We need to join the rest of humanity and stop the slaughter.33542019-11-12T13:03:06.85342976Lorraine LowryThis madness has to end!!!33542019-11-12T13:44:55.25342977Angeline lucasThey put money before wildlife. These grouse moor owners are a disgrace 33542019-11-12T13:46:53.54742978Sonja ChanceALL murder of wild life should be banned it is disgusting and yes it is MURDER.33542019-11-12T14:33:22.7742979Anne grantThings have taken such a toll on our natural and beautiful animals we have to wonder what this life would be like without these glorious creatures ,they have a right to live and give us such a pleasure just in the wonder to our hearts to see them free and safe ,man has got to step back a bit and learn to live with what they have now instead of the pounds sign ,if they have to control the over breeding of certain species bring in a natural predator to control them ,the circle of life is a natural way ,I know they have predators but if they are not enough bring in more ,I am not nieve I know you have tried many ways to control these problems ,but think harder to find a more natural way to do it ,I know I have gone on a bit but I fear for the future of our wonderful gifts God has given us ,and Animals all over this wonderful creation we have been given to take care of now don't have a chance when Man starts to take over what was there homes ,think what you are going to do and make a difference today ,I wish you well and hope my thoughts are worth while x33542019-11-12T14:39:38.38742980Sharon HopkinsWhy is this barbarity still allowed in 2019? Many animals and wildlife are caught in traps, snares and other disgusting and cruel devices which are designed to ensure nothing interrupts shooting interests. It's also a vile and warped past-time for people with low mentality and inadequacy, it's all about power. We should be targeting companies that make traps and snares although many are home-made. I cannot imagine the terror, pain and suffering endured by creatures caught in these primitive and despicable devices.33542019-11-12T15:13:31.49342981Mr Colin JeffreyNative British wildlife is under threat from many sides and all native species must be properly protected for their own sake and for their important place in the eco system and not sacrificed for the financial gain of vested interests such as the hunting, shooting or fishing lobbies.33542019-11-12T15:29:50.96742983Linda Teasdale PluchardWe need to make laws stronger .Our wildlife needs all the help it can get.33542019-11-12T16:44:35.4842984Jan WebbWe must protect our beautiful wildlife and learn to live alongside them. They are such special beings and I abhor they way in which they are killed.33542019-11-12T18:03:50.55342986Sharon L RidlonNeedless killing of any animal is a disaster to nature\r\n. Their needs to be a balance.33542019-11-13T07:03:36.35743001Carole FraserThis is sheer brutality these Animals suffer a Herendous Death it's just vile Evil and very cruel stop this mass murder of these endangered species .33542019-11-13T07:54:45.91343002Francisco Sanchez MolinaGamekeepers are legally able to set cruel and outdated traps and snares to kill animals that are predators to red grouse, as they want as many red grouse available as possible for commercial shooting. \r\n\r\nFoxes, weasels and stoats are regularly targeted, but these traps are indiscriminate and domestic cats, dogs and badgers are also trapped. Tens of thousands of animals are killed each year on driven grouse moors.\r\n\r\nThis cruelty has to end. Animals deserve to be respected.33542019-11-13T08:37:43.82743003Betty (Elizabeth) LeeWhen I walk on the moors I would like the chance to see Hen Harriers, Golden Eagles, Hares, Badgers and other British animals. The moors look pretty dead to me - and I can guess why!!33542019-11-13T10:53:41.99743004Lynn MilneWe need to protect our wildlife not destroy it in barbaric ways.33542019-11-13T13:43:40.9643005Suzanne SpiersI am angry that wild indigenous animals are wantonly killed, often in very cruel ways, by human beings who have no regard for the fact that all indigenous animals have an important role in keeping ecosystems healthy. Take one animal, plant or insect out of that ecosystem, and the ecosystem is disrupted. \r\n\r\nPlease take the time to learn about the importance of helping indigenous animals to live as part of the natural environment.33542019-11-13T15:14:08.5843006Linda GunnellWild life needs to be preserved for all our futures33542019-11-13T15:17:29.68743007Fiona OrdThe sad picture says it all. 33542019-11-13T16:03:55.9843008Patricia Wood Our wildlife is under enough stress and this is an elitist pastime which takes a huge toll . It needs to stop causing death for sport is disgusting. 33542019-11-20T13:59:01.0343020Ruth CraxtonChildren's hearings should be audio recorded and paper transcript issued to all attendees. My experience of 'minutes' from child protection meetings is that the minutes are far from accurate and it is almost impossible to get the minutes altered to reflect what was actually said.34112019-11-20T16:27:19.843021Dorothy MurrayAll waterways should have life saving equipment at hand to help people yo save lives.\r\n33602019-11-20T16:31:23.10743022Gillian GallowayI think the right thing to do 33602019-11-20T16:59:44.8743024Michele Dickson It should be compulsory for children to TALK! 34112019-11-20T17:13:21.31743025Jane McGillion A recording of a hearing is there to refer back to and to ensure total transparency for all involved. Why on earth does this not happen at Children's Hearings when very important decisions are being made about a child's life? Unbelievable. 34112019-11-20T17:21:53.7143026Jane McGillion Recording Children's Hearings would ensure total transparency for everyone involved, as well as allowing there to be a reference point should future discussions need to take place. I find it unbelievable that there are no minutes or recording of what happens in these hearings, particularly when the outcome is likely to be life changing for the families involved.34112019-11-20T17:27:57.36743027Jane McGillion Recording or minuting of Children's Hearings is paramount in ensuring total transparency for all involved. It also provides a reference point should further discussions need to take place. I find it unbelievable that there is no recording of these hearings, particularly as the outcome of them are like to have a long term effect on the families involved.34112019-11-20T17:59:49.2243028George ParsonageSomething has to be done regarding the vandalism of emergency equipment33602019-11-20T20:19:05.1443030isabel mcphersonThis is an excellent move. I pray it succeeds33602019-11-21T00:00:23.2243031Wendy woolfson They should be re orded the same as in any other meeting and all parties associated with the meeting should have access. Its especially important for the young persons views to be recorded and decisions made. Why this isn't happening already is questionable 34112019-11-21T07:00:05.68743032Sara NobleThis is an absolute must. 34112019-11-21T10:09:19.6243033Gemma mcmasterI fully agree that the whole child protection system need to be utterly revamped ...Its disgusting 34112019-11-21T10:46:54.35743034William CampbellTampering of any safety equipment should carry severe punnishment, even involunrty manslaughter in event of equipment being unusable when needed resulting in death.33602019-11-21T12:14:14.41743035Peter StewartTotally agree.33602019-11-21T12:16:05.41743036Steven MuirWater safety on the Coastline and inland waterways is a must. Sadly too many lives are lost due to lack of lifesaving equipmemt by waterways and coastlines. I back this petotion 100%. 33602019-11-21T12:22:58.15343037Deirdre Oakley As a member of the locals Coastguard Team, it is imperative that these items be implemented to assist us in continuing to preserve and save lives.33602019-11-21T12:23:10.243038Peter StewartTotally agree33602019-11-21T12:26:36.41743039Paul McCaffertyGreat Idea get it done........33602019-11-21T12:27:49.0943040Stuart MainGreat idea equipment should be readily available and protected under law33602019-11-21T12:36:19.243041Gillian Connelly I agree with everything printed below. 33602019-11-21T13:16:48.7743042Mark kellyMaintaining vital safety infrastructure is imperative to preventing needless loss of life. We also need to ensure that the infrastructure is respected and protected appropriately.33602019-11-21T16:34:05.88343043Lynne MuldoonDo the right thing please 33602019-11-21T18:36:29.49343044Trevor John Robertson I fully support the 3 aims of this petition 33602019-11-22T20:06:26.45343046Mairi Robertson CarreyPlease support this petition and make our rivers, coasts, and waterways safer for all.33602019-11-23T08:42:10.73343047DEBORA MILAZZOStop chid trafficking. promote truth and transparency in the 'family' courts 34112019-11-25T00:08:46.94343050Laura LoudenThe social work need to be accountable for the lies they put in reports and tell at hearings. 34112019-11-25T01:39:42.67743051michele simmonsThe only way to help ensure no more miscarriage of justice happens.34112019-11-25T05:31:13.08743052Colin hamilton Saving lives 33602019-12-03T11:53:55.6943053Ciara MaherI wholeheartedly DISAGREE with the points made in this petition. \r\n1 LGBTQ young people need to be accepted and supported. This is vital to increase mental wellbeing, and decrease suicide rates and homelessness in young LGBTQ people. \r\n2 Children of LGBTQ parents, single or windowed parents, orphaned kids, and those living with grandparents, foster parents and so on, need to feel that their families are recognised, valid and included in school life. This vital for their wellbeing. \r\n3 The Netherlands used to have the highest rate of teen pregnancies in Europe. They implemented AGE APPROPRIATE relationship and sex education from age 5 or 6 and the teen pregnancy rate dropped. This is fact, not opinion. \r\n4 If you do not teach teenagers about sex, their only way to learn about it, is by doing it. And that probably will not be safe sex in a loving relationship. \r\n5 Denying children and young people AGE APPROPRIATE teaching on relationships and sex, can negatively effect their mental health, and make young people much more vulnerable to sexual abuse. \r\n6 Teaching kids religious belief and stories as if they are facts, can be very harmful to their mental health. \r\n7 Religion has no place in schools. \r\n8 Being LGBTQ is NOT a choice, and cannot be influenced by\r\neducation \r\nother LGBTQ people\r\nheterosexual people\r\nposters\r\nreligion or prayer. \r\nAn example of age appropriate teachings to a 6 year old asking what is a lesbian is, would be to say, \r\nA lesbian wants to marry a woman, rather than a man when she grows up. Lesbians are just 2 women who love each other, just like Mummy and Daddy love each other.\r\nIt is not complicated. 34132019-12-04T18:56:09.9743055Angela Mckichan It could save the life of one of your loved ones 33602019-12-06T11:48:47.14343056Evelyn ClarkDogs are man's best friend especially to service dogs, the lonely and vulnerable and need to be protected from cruelty33522019-12-06T12:58:31.79343057George Grant AndersonThe law must be unbiased. If men can be criminalized for committing rape. Then so must women. 33682019-12-06T15:25:53.5843058Lynne BevilacaquaLook at animal welfare and I will vote SNP at the election. How can an SNP candidate not know about Lucy's Law? 33522019-12-06T15:31:03.78343059Lynne Bevilacquastop puppy farming in Scotland33522019-12-06T15:58:23.45743060Peter Stewart KelbieI am an excare client taken into care at birth. There has been many worries and concerns regarding the Scottish Children's Panels over many decades. Best Wishes. 34112019-12-06T20:24:38.0143061James Bradie I wont the punishment for steeling dogs to be the same as taking a child..33522019-12-06T22:33:27.5243062Lynn BrownIf anyone stole my dogs it would break me. They are the children I didn't have. People who steal dogs should suffer a severe penalty. It is cruel and devastating for families. Material objects can be replaced but your dog can't.33522019-12-07T12:53:37.67743064Victoria StraineAnimals are sentient beings and deserve to be treated as such. 33522019-12-07T14:10:19.91343065Anne PeckAnyone who has a fog or like myself dogs as pets would be distraught at someone stealing their pet. Dogs as pets are part of families, lived and cherished and looked after. They also help with mental health issues and children grow up loving and being able to care for their pet in the right way. Stealing a dog from a family to me is like stealing a child and something should be done with regards the law about how this horrible crime is dealt with. 33522019-12-07T15:44:29.0643068Jayne DalgleishAnimals are warm blooded not inanimate objects33522019-12-07T19:33:57.90343069MISS CLARE BOWNESSpeople that harm animals should be jailed.33522019-12-07T21:31:01.10743070Dominika TorkaAnimals are the part of our families. Please share33522019-12-07T21:35:33.27343071Silly GrantAnimals have souls33522019-12-08T02:17:18.78743073John MorrisonThe emergency services rely on dogs to help in their jobs. We use them as service dogs and as therapy dogs. Its ludicrous that these wonderful animals are still classified as inanimate objects. The law needs to change asap.33522019-12-08T17:40:44.06743074Margaret Rooney We must treat dog cruelty and theft more harshly. Let the punishment fit the crime. 33522019-12-08T20:24:14.4243076Margaret wilsonMost are family members, how brokenhearted when they are gone33522019-12-08T21:32:31.443077Leslie BartchBDogs are companions, carers ,workers on farms, for police and many other jobs. 33522019-12-09T11:48:24.53343078Tilly ForrestI love dogs!33522019-12-09T11:53:48.1943080Kyle MetcalfDogs all the way33522019-12-10T01:03:47.0843082Marie Anderson from Leith Currently there is new bills passed in Parliament giving sentencing that came into effect to protect animals against animal cruelty. Therefore these sections in law should apply in instances of dog theft as the classification comes under animal cruelty. Dogs snatched from their owners can become distressed by separation anxiety from owners. Dogs are intelligent animals which are very therapeutic in reducing anxiety in their owners and extended family circle. The same applies to the dogs. Talking from experience, the lovely lady who created this petition gifted me her husky Stealth 3 years ago and in doing so has helped to reduce anxiety, isolation and disability from defamation suffered in custody battles. On a wider scale, dogs help the elderly out of isolation in troublesome climates, including maintaining balance. Dogs have feelings and a body. They understand more than we bargain for. Any living person, animal, mammel so forth by fact is not classified an object when taught to children in schools. Dogs do valuable working support such as farming, rounding the sheep in. Security measure by barking alert. Dogs are trained life humans do help people without arms or legs the assisting in pulling door handles, pressing buzzers, holding bags in their jaw, picking up items whilst shopping with owner. Dogs are great for visiting hospitals and care homes for therapy to the sickly. Specially trained army and police dogs are trained to sniff out unstable behaviour in people, drugs and hidden explosives. They can rescue people or other animals from ruble, fires and tight situations. Dogs aid blind, deaf and those with speech impairment. Dogs can sniff somebody's breath to know when a person is ill. Having a dog could possibly prevent crimes by keeping offenders out of trouble provided they maintain care of their dog. By art definition an object is non edible, chemical or manufactured. An object is not classified as a living specification whereas in our conclusion a dog is33522019-12-10T11:56:05.1843083Elizabeth RobertsonAbout time33522019-12-12T07:23:50.143086Linda berryWe petition the fact that you class our dogs as inanimate objects. 33522019-12-12T11:27:08.9543087Angel GoldieYes dogs and cats needs law protection ..if stolen ...the law uses k9 so why they are classified as Inanimate object ....they serve the public they have the right to be protected .....33522019-12-13T14:42:50.09343088Alan HooperAs a lay person with personal experience of cancer I whole heartedly support any initiatives that increase early intervention. Knowledge to act is a major part of our armoury to fight disease and the sooner disease is identified the better the chances of recovery.34242019-12-13T19:42:15.66343090Andrew FraserIt is only fair34252019-12-14T12:00:34.2243091Joanna CrotchHalf of the worlds population have ovaries - rants they worth protecting!34242019-12-15T16:49:57.38743092Jacqueline Rogers I have had ovarian cists, fibroids and adhesions and I have never been offered the test. 34242019-12-15T19:15:31.6543093Louise StewartI have endometriosis and treatment of it is sub par at best 34242019-12-15T23:34:56.04343094anne leitchI strongly agree women should be always offered the CA125 blood test. If ovarian cancer is not detected early enough then life expectancy is greatly reduced.34242019-12-17T08:46:27.5143095Sally dumbletonI have lost rwo friends and two more affected34242019-12-17T10:10:24.7343096denise hooperanimals are sentient. their ability to empathise it outstanding33522019-12-17T13:19:07.70343097Susan ColeI would like to add my voice to that of the previous commenter, Ciara Maher. The approach she outlines in her comment is what a modern, forward-looking, inclusive country should be looking to promote, rather than some bogus theory promoted by a small, vocal minority of religious zealots. Love is love is love.34132019-12-18T14:10:59.7443098Simon CookAs a salmon fisher for 40 years I have seen the decline in fish entering the rivers, hatcheries have been a great sucess in most cases 33762019-12-18T19:36:20.84743099Donald GowI strongly agree that the situation of wild Scottish salmon deserves full parliamentary discussion before any further action it taken.33762019-12-18T21:46:13.20743100Graeme Lightbody If nothing changes, nothing changes. If you keep doing what you're doing, you're going to keep getting what you're getting. You want change, make some.33762019-12-18T22:07:38.33343101Calum Raine Good luck, Bob. Well said.33762019-12-18T22:36:30.49743102Allan Lumsden In full support of the above33762019-12-18T22:41:37.63743103Tim GreenfieldEvery avenue must be explored to preserve and increase the numbers of Atlantic Salmon in Scotland and indeed the whole of the UK.33762019-12-19T07:51:45.49343104John tullett To ignore the people who work with rivers and salmon on a day basis over some science based policy is wrong. Science is based on certain facts in a short period , river knowledge has been built over years and passed through generations. Ignore at your peril and be the government who watched salmon die. 33762019-12-19T09:49:23.9743105Jim wilson Our fish on River Findhorn Forres, are being massacred by the seals33762019-12-19T10:25:28.79743106Bob MasonIt is vital to have more scrutiny of the policy, and more debate from both sides of the argument. The current policy will affect peoples livelihoods. 33762019-12-19T10:42:24.60343107Ian MaxwellAction is desperately needed to reverse falling salmon numbers. Let's make sure we listen to all points of view and get it right!33762019-12-19T11:15:48.08743108Alistair HuskieUrgent action is needed to preserve stocks for a sport that has existed for hundreds of years, is supported by thousands of anglers who bring prosperity to hard pressed rural communities. Giving nature a boost at this time would be a great benefit and if done right there is no need for the genetic integrity of a river systems stock to be eroded. We should be looking at ways to boost stocks not leave them to recover in the face of multiple dangers. Marine Scotland is not being even handed in this matter. Questions must continue to be asked if MS is unbiased due to their tolerance of excesses in the Aquaculture Industry.33762019-12-19T13:20:50.24343109Jim McLanaghanThere is a real need to explore ALL avenues and leave several options open in order to assist the numbers to increase.33762019-12-19T15:01:07.70343111Susan PurvisI have personally experienced bloating and advised my GP of this and the fact that a family member had ovarian cancer. Despite this information being disclosed I still was not offered a CA125 Blood test. I do think that the Scottish Govt could do more34242019-12-19T17:07:22.3343115Stuart hamilton Supermarkets should be closed 34252019-12-19T17:10:44.06343116Mavis ChalmersI work at leading supermarket and I should be spending it with friends and family. That should be a day off. We dont get double time either34252019-12-19T17:12:58.06343118Scott KingI work in retail security for a leading supermarket and I have to work every xmas eve and boxing day and new year eve and Jan 1st and for the mim wage I agree and believe all shops should close on boxing day and new year day give people time to relax with family and friends and enjoy it.34252019-12-19T17:14:24.59743119David SwankieWorking on this day should never happen34252019-12-19T17:14:47.8343120ALLAN J Hogg Rediculous no shop should be open on new years day. Our world has officially been diagnosed with craziness and pure greed. This goes for shopping centres as well! Edinburgh centres are just as bad...ie ocean terminal ..Cameron toll...and gyle to name but a few...stay closed money isn't everything for goodness sake!!!!34252019-12-19T17:15:38.4443122Kevin fraser I would love to get January 1st off work so getting a petition out there is a good idea 34252019-12-19T17:17:16.37743123Brian WardlawThis needs to happen34252019-12-19T17:18:13.03343124Stewart forrestRetail workers work hard they deserve to celebrate nerday the same as the rest of us 34252019-12-19T17:19:27.03343126Caroline DownieI think all shops should be closed 34252019-12-19T17:20:18.72343128Richie Venton345,000 retail workers in Scotland have families too! As do associated production and distribution workers. We deserve a proper break to spend time with family and friends. There is no earthly reason why the profit-driven consumer frenzy can't be shut down on Christmas Day, Boxing Day, 1st and 2nd January, so the Scottish government should step up in defense of workers and ensure this happens. 'Gis a break!! 34252019-12-19T17:20:48.34743129Brian LynchWe should be closed 25 , 26 December also.34252019-12-19T17:21:40.843131Margaret Donnelly All staff should get a chance to enjoy there time with kids and family 34252019-12-19T17:23:06.45743132Marion Jo-Anne HopeI think it's a disgrace that businesses are open on New year's Day this comes down to greed from the company's that are making their staff work. Maybe try making it compulsory for triple time if the businessess are open new year's Day then see how many want to open.34252019-12-19T17:23:12.61343133Michael peat With no public transport available i need to pay premium taxi fares or rely on family members to get me to and from work. 34252019-12-19T17:25:07.843134kayleigh youngmore time with families over the festive period34252019-12-19T17:28:56.03743135Joanne MeilI agree that workers should have a day of rest on New Years Day. I am working all through NY this year and will have to reframe from drinking and having a late night, whilst everyone else is enjoying themselves. 34252019-12-19T17:32:00.00343136Joanne MeilI am working all through New Year and will have to reframe from staying up late or drinking. Will affect visiting family and friends also. 34252019-12-19T17:32:19.97343137Fiona maxwellNo before time! 34252019-12-19T17:35:42.31743138John marley We should not be open new year's day 34252019-12-19T17:35:44.14743139Shirley Drummond Retail workers deserve to have holidays especially at Christmas and New Year. There is no need for large retailers to open other than greed.34252019-12-19T17:39:44.05343141paul kernachanLook at the distribution sites to and get them closed absolutely disgusting for these business to make staff work make time for the families 34252019-12-19T17:39:43.92743142Linda ClarkShops should be shut on New Years Day as there is no need for them to be open34252019-12-19T17:46:15.75743143Sheila HolmesIf we have to work should get well paid for it34252019-12-19T17:46:50.41343144christina hillBoxing day she also be a holiday 34252019-12-19T17:48:28.4343145John nicolThink its disgusting that you have to use one of your normal day's off as a holiday for Christmas day thought this was a bank holiday and yes totally agree no one should be working 25th 26th dec 1st and 2nd January 34252019-12-19T17:55:22.05743147Clare mcintyreBoxing day aswell should be a holiday for retail workers. It all comes from companies being greedy. Family should come first! 34252019-12-19T17:58:54.8243148Neil MacDonaldMSPs, please show some consideration, before condemning this. Retail workers work extremely long hours over the festive period, with little, no premium pay, many have no quality time to spend with family,friends. Also it's a chance to review or instil a Sunday trading working time directive, at present the working week is bordering on Dickensian34252019-12-19T18:04:38.82343149Andy Irvine1st & 2nd are holidays in Scotland, retailers should treat them as such. 34252019-12-19T18:06:32.02743150Andy Irvine1st & 2nd are holidays in Scotland, retailers should treat them as such. \r\n\r\nIf the government want people to work on these days I look forward to seeing government departments open on these days too.34252019-12-19T18:11:00.05743152Gwen RiggansNot just large stores but all stores including convenience stores 34252019-12-19T18:14:56.6543153david patonhow many times are we going round this roundabout time for usdaw to put there foot down 79% saying close 1and 2 january and back members comments34252019-12-19T18:16:25.40343154frank whitelawKeep campaigning Stewart. Merry Xmas to all in the Division.34252019-12-19T18:17:55.38743155linda TaitI think New Year and boxing day should be closed to let families be together in past decades it worked why not now in modern society.34252019-12-19T18:31:32.4543156Marc lammie Boxing day should be the same no need for all these shops to be open its nothing but pure greed everybody should be able to spend time with there families during the holiday season .34252019-12-19T18:46:12.7843157Jayne HastingsThis should include our petrol filling station! Oh yes the store will be closed, but no they are once again opening the pfs probably to sell 3 pints of milk. 2 human beings not being able to relax through this period in the year! Shocking!34252019-12-19T18:49:31.15743158aileen whitelawAll shops should close over the xmas period , each and every one has family and that's what xmas is all about not money in the tills . What did everyone do in the olden days when shops were closed .its about time something was done not just in Scotland \r\n34252019-12-19T18:49:46.12743159aileen whitelawAll shops should close over the xmas period , each and every one has family and that's what xmas is all about not money in the tills . What did everyone do in the olden days when shops were closed .its about time something was done not just in Scotland \r\n34252019-12-19T19:16:18.53343161Jamie begbieAs I work in retail I see it first hand. Bosses bullying young people to work Xmas eve, boxing day etc.. I think there should be a balance so family time can be enjoyable and not worrying about then there next in work 34252019-12-19T19:18:46.86343162Kelly MaitlandI was forced to work new years day so am signing the petion34252019-12-19T19:30:28.44343163Frank McElroyFamily should have time with family as work hard all year34252019-12-19T19:53:16.21343164Stewart Scott If the people who run this valuable resource get it wrong, how can we turn the return of this magnificent heritage ( Atlantic Salmon) around. What is there to lose with a trial period of hatcheries? My local river The Tyne in East Lothian had a hatchery for years. The river was full of fish. Since the hatchery ceased, the river is struggling to restock itself. Not helped by poaching which is not being pursued by the local authorities. 33762019-12-19T19:57:11.0443165Salim HaddadWould be nice to have New Year day off to get some rest after long year work only right after night of reflect on the year past by !!!?? 34252019-12-19T20:18:50.18343166Janette LahlouThe whole festive season should be a time for families to spend together. I have worked on previous new years day and it is literally customers looking for gravy granules or need more potatoes for their dinner. Why should we miss out in family time just for a slow string of people running in for last minute bits and Bob's. 34252019-12-19T20:39:42.543167Joanne Campbell I also think that all shops should be closed on Boxing Day, everyone should be able to enjoy Christmas.34252019-12-19T20:46:45.2843168Ross HarperEven if stores do open on New Year's Day, I feel that the pay rate should be higher than on Bank Holidays outside the festive period, and that opening hours should be the same as those operated by large stores in the other UK nations on Sundays. I also feel the same should be the case on 26th December. Considering these opening hours apply in Liverpool, Aberystwyth and Belfast for over 50 days per year, it is not unreasonable for such a restriction to apply in Livingston, Aberdeen and Bellshill for TWO days per year.34252019-12-19T21:22:19.45743169Elizabeth Wilkie It is unfair to keep people from their families. Time is prestiius34252019-12-19T21:37:40.44743170Miss Yvonne S DoyleEveryone should be permitted to spend time off from work on New Years day, not only for family time but for a rest to recuperate for the New Year 2020, that is fast approaching.\r\nThis should be passed as a new law.\r\nYvonne S Doyle.34252019-12-19T21:48:57.27343171Kim GibsonWell done Usdaw. Good call and about time x34252019-12-19T22:00:26.55743172Tracy BrownBoxing Day too please?34252019-12-19T22:04:38.63743173Alan BowesThe first, second and boxing day should be family time 34252019-12-19T22:06:40.243174Alan BowesThe 1st 2nd and boxing day should all be holidays and corporate company's should be first to close for family time.34252019-12-19T23:20:18.42743177Nita PattersonYes to both statements - shops should be closed on New Years Day + 2nd January34252019-12-20T00:02:29.52743179Jennifer GormleyIt would be so good for retail workers to spend some much needed time with family and friends through the festive period. 34252019-12-20T00:11:49.32743181kathleen reevesno need for shops to be open on new years day everyone deserves to spend time with their family34252019-12-20T01:03:59.1343182Karen PetrieTo ask the big supermarkets to close on just 2 days a year to allow their staff time with family and friends is not a lot to ask for. I'm sure all the CEO's of these companies cherish what time they get with their families so why should their employees be any different.34252019-12-20T05:46:57.96743183Michael AshcroftA family member works retail.Every year they work New years day.l agree shops should close.34252019-12-20T07:22:18.1543184Nessa abblettNo one should have to work on new years day we work hard all year and deserve time off to be with our familys.34252019-12-20T09:04:37.9643186jayne wesleyI work in retail we need more time with our families 34252019-12-20T09:16:44.21343187Tracy GIlbertThe Scottish Government can enact this piece of legislation and allow all their constituents a few days off with their families. support retail workers.34252019-12-20T09:46:03.07743188Hazel GunnAlso shouldn't have to reequest a days holiday to get xmas day off when the store is closed anyway34252019-12-20T10:28:57.78743190Jim Campbell It's unfair that that shops open new years day we work hard in the month of December and our reward Xmas day off give it time and companies will take that also 34252019-12-20T10:31:06.4143191Jim Campbell We work hard all year and even more so in December and our reward one day off in the entire year my company just took away new year's day how long before they try Xmas 34252019-12-20T12:07:40.48743192Alasdair CampbellOn New Year's Day people should be able to spend time with their families and not have to deal with bosses demanding that they work.\r\n\r\nI'm sure politicians and civil service workers have those days off. It is a bank holiday and they should be allowed time off.34252019-12-20T12:49:13.9643193Jim BerringtonBelieve everyone should be able to spend time with there family 34252019-12-20T12:52:11.88343194Declan ShieldsHogmanay and New Year is a special time of year in Scotland. I feel it is right that this should be protected and encouraged with the closure of shops to allow more people to enjoy the celebration.34252019-12-20T13:45:58.9243195Heather QuinnFamily time together is important x34252019-12-20T13:58:46.89343196Lynda HolmesNo-one should be made to work in a shop on 1 and 2 Dec. STATUTORY? Good luck, hope you win. Solidarity34252019-12-20T17:04:55.15343198Mhairi RossIt would be nice to spend new year with my family in Edinburgh 34252019-12-20T22:05:51.27343199Margaret Nicholson No one should work on New Year Day especially retail.34252019-12-21T00:20:37.59343200Brian McCannI have wanted a written, modern and inclusive constitution for all the Scottish people and not the few.33612019-12-21T01:21:26.50743201Ian ManionAs an USDAW member I support my Scottish colleagues 34252019-12-21T06:10:37.1143202Monics GenelliPlease stop large shops New Years day34252019-12-21T10:02:35.88743203Mike DansonLet's reclaim the Scottish New Year from the capitalists for the citizens.34252019-12-21T10:06:53.49743204Mike DansonLet's reclaim the Scottish New Year from the capitalists and for the citizens. 34252019-12-21T10:25:07.543205Archie McDonaldI have always said that all Big major supermarkets should close on 25th & 26th of December and 1st & 2nd of January 34252019-12-21T12:16:13.43743206Gordon Hyslop Save the Atlantic Salmon 33762019-12-21T14:09:36.1443207Debra McMahonOut with the family aspect, there's no need to open. No public transport available so ridiculous to expect staff to travel.34252019-12-21T21:02:55.64743210Ian VannIt is vital that policy decisions with respect to the salmon fishing industry take full account of the extraordinary expertise that exists in the ghillie community.33762019-12-21T22:19:12.8543211MARK CULLINANEGive families a holiday 34252019-12-22T10:52:24.46743213Margaret BrannanNo need for shops to open 1st or 2nd January34252019-12-22T12:47:07.77743214Terry DolanAbsolutely ridiculous having to work on the 1 st January having had to do it in the past ,it should remain in the past34252019-12-22T14:51:43.21743215David BamfordMarine Scotland Scientist are using data from Pacific salmon that is often done with little regard to the fishes river of origin. Comparing this to what is done in small hatcheries in Scotland is totally misleading and worst of all. BAD Science, by people who do know better! 33762019-12-22T16:03:33.52343216Jacqueline WrightWhen growing up shops were never open on new years day. Greed has taken over!! 34252019-12-23T06:23:10.6943217Stephen Davies Sticking provides help to river systems and are an invaluable way of protecting invaluable stocks33762019-12-23T06:48:11.52743218David AllanLet's get this done and help save the salmon!33762019-12-23T13:08:46.05743220Joosung LeeA proper holiday for all workers!34252019-12-23T16:10:28.73743221Miss Deborah K MurrayThink be a better for people to be with familys i doub shopper cant wait one day. 34252019-12-23T18:32:58.0843222Janine GreenfieldI agree with Robert White 33762019-12-23T21:27:23.15743223Steven ingramAll workers need this 34252019-12-24T09:10:18.91343225David HartleyBe sure the science is right.33762019-12-24T12:22:50.6943226Margaret sneddonI have worked in retail for years and it has had an impact on family life as cannot enjoy boxing day as always have to work. \r\nCannot enjoy a gid xmas break as you know you have to work. \r\nRetail life is hard and as we are accommodating members of public firms various sectors in retail we also as workers have a right to properly enjoy this time of year.\r\nIt's a tough industry and can have an impact on mental health so the extra time off would be fully appreciated by all in retail .34252019-12-24T15:33:39.6243227Madelyne SimpsonKeep shops closed on New Years Day!34252019-12-24T17:38:03.56743228Neil fordDo the directors or chief executive work on these days or are they enjoying time with family\r\n34252019-12-25T00:42:05.1443229Michael OrrClose the shops for our festive season . 34252019-12-25T12:53:39.14743231Neil ford fordHope msp,s enjoy Xmas and new year because its the shop workers make it possible for this to happen .stop and think of us at this time of year\r\n\r\n\r\n34252019-12-26T12:25:01.13743232Robert renwickNo one should need to work any of these days not just retail. I understand emergency services are needed but they could even have every 2nd year pt if you work Xmas you get new year off etc. They say we aren't slaves but make us work like slaves 34252019-12-27T07:28:21.8543233Richard McewanAll for it 34252019-12-27T09:20:34.30743234James McLanaghanIt really is time practitioners had a say rather than those who think they know best!33762019-12-27T15:04:19.2943235Ann CousinsAll retail staff need more time with family 34252019-12-27T15:57:22.73743237Robert Burnsthere is already too much time to shop. people need more family time. lets get a four day week34252019-12-27T16:48:12.79343239Mary Buchan Would love time of with my family34252019-12-27T16:53:08.55743240john carrThere is no need it's just greed 34252019-12-27T17:05:00.29343241Allan DuncanAll stores should be closed on all major holidays 34252019-12-27T17:26:55.37743242Alex Bruce I have already fought for this and won seems big companies can treat their staff how they like. Corporate greed is unbelievable I'm sure the C.E.Os are not in the office. They will be sitting at home with wives families and friends enjoying the holidays. It's time big companies treated staff with respect and if they did staff would be happier and in turn do more for the company34252019-12-27T18:39:41.68343243Patricia SheridanYes all shops should be close as it is family time X 34252019-12-27T21:33:06.20743244Julie Pattinson Please give respect to the people of Scotland who deserve the acknowledgment of new years day as a public holiday. English stores are closed on Easter Sunday. Why should Scotland not have the same acknowledgement. 34252019-12-28T01:51:51.63343245Carol O'meara Family time34252019-12-28T10:43:24.40743246Paul HoldenIts time to halt retail greed and thoroughly promote time off with families by closing all unnecessary workplaces at Christmas holidays.34252019-12-28T19:29:15.40743247Fiona forbesBoxing Day too, I Day with your family is not enough. Sales all the time now, so Boxing means nothing anymore34252019-12-28T21:04:15.3943248Pamela Watson I have to use a holiday day as I refuse to work new years day, it's just greed from retail34252019-12-28T21:32:01.29743249Eòin McIntyreAgreed.34252019-12-29T09:46:33.61743250Betty HaineyThey should also be off on Boxing Day and have 2 days off at New Year.Employees deserve a break after the biz if the Christmas shopping frenzy!34252019-12-29T10:00:30.8543251Natalia MckendrickLarger shops should never have been allowed to open on new year's day. People that work in retail have it hard enough of it being so busy this time of year. 34252019-12-29T10:07:11.10343252Irene forsythShops should be shut 2 days Christmas and 2 days New Year 34252019-12-29T18:48:31.81343255Ms Christina DunsmuirI Agree that all Stores & work places should be closed on 1st Jan34252019-12-29T19:08:47.64743256Marie OharaHaving new years day off allows people to enjoy time with loved ones... Do you really need to visit a shop on new year's day... Really... 34252019-12-29T19:54:59.55343257Eileen AllanI work in a supermarket and find profit comes before family. We are disposable assets34252019-12-29T21:53:26.85743258Moira WilloxShould be compulsory.for everyone34252019-12-29T22:42:19.22343259Eileen HarveyWhat about the small stores34252019-12-30T12:39:16.63343260Graham Gardner Get it done 34252019-12-30T22:45:11.21743261Helen MilneShould not be madeto work34252019-12-31T06:13:24.39343262thomas suttieBig supermarket chains have to much power34252019-12-31T13:07:23.38343263James Valentine No need for shops to be open just corporate greed in my opinion. 34252019-12-31T18:58:15.7443264Julie Pattinson All retailers should close on new years day and respect that this is a public holiday in Scotland. England stores are closed on Easter Sunday!! 34252019-12-31T19:40:37.40343265Marion Murdoch my country of scotland isn't here so I can't sign the petition which I would most certainly have done 34252020-01-03T08:56:27.9443267John mcmurray Wark We need more hatcheries 33762020-01-03T17:40:22.73343268James A MackieThis Petition makes good sense. Civil servants rarely listen to local and practical experience. Very good restocking programmes can be seen on the River Carron in Wester Ross and on the River Lochy. Ovber fishing, especially with nets in the past has left a stock of small wild fish. Egg numbers spawned are in relation to fish size. Smaller fish less eggs. Climate change has a major part to play in the decreasng numbers of ssalmon returning to our waters. Recent studies have shown that the number of Smolts getting to sea is much smaller than previously thought. Nobody knows how many eggs and smaller fish are predated on by Trout and birds. Marine Scotlands idea that rivers can only be restocked with eyed eggs and unfed fry is a non starter if nobody knows the survival rates. The Canadian Ssalmon numbers are kept high by a high number of hatcheries where fish are kept in containment to nearer the time of smolting. Too often policies are put in place through personal opinions rather than real scientific research and the understanding of a situation known fro local practical knowledge and experience. Acroos the worls there are many examples of rare species being brought back from near extinction by breeding and release programs.33762020-01-03T17:47:00.81343269Marlene Martin-Smith I believe rape is rape, no matter the sexuality.33682020-01-03T18:16:50.37743270Megan BainFor all women who are suffering!34242020-01-04T15:56:35.7943271Jacqueline MarshallI have had endometroid ovarian carcinoma but did not even have endometriosis. I do think women are not that aware of the variety of symptoms that can indicate the need for checking the ovaries.34242020-01-06T11:00:28.19343273Louise HorneI urge Parliament to screen for early detection of Ovarian cancer by a simple CA 125 blood test. This could reduce suffering and save lives.34242020-01-06T12:01:25.1743274Arthur PreouIt's clear to all Salmon fisherman there are insufficient fish in the rivers to naturally maintain the salmon runs they need our help in stocking linked with Habitat improvements a schemes like the the River Tyne is a proven model 33762020-01-06T12:09:52.5243275Barrie StewartSurely for a simple blood test this would save and lengthen many peoples lives34242020-01-06T12:44:55.23743276Alison RobinsonI have endometriosis and wasn't aware of the link or the blood test. I would strongly advocate for women being offered the CA125 blood test when they are diagnosed with conditions like endometriosis that raises the risk of ovarian cancer. Its a hard to detect cancer without any form test and early detection is crucial for better prognosis and treatment.34242020-01-06T15:34:05.07343277Kate StewartStrongly agree 34242020-01-06T18:15:09.7243278Liliane M McGeochI had no idea that endometriosis increases the risk of getting ovarian cancer34242020-01-06T20:20:44.20743279Iain RossI am 100% in favour of stocking salmon rivers from hatcheries 33762020-01-06T22:28:49.2443280Mr James ForsterThis needs to be discussed and considered. The Americans have been doing it in a bad way for many years, however methods in Iceland for stocking salmon is much better. It should all be part of a big plan. Managing the number of fish eating birds is an obvious necessity as many rivers are over run with birds that belong in the sea. Seals also need managing!!33762020-01-07T09:08:17.86743281Richard DoyleIf you don't have the stock you can't have the sport!33762020-01-07T13:03:58.5243282Morag BainIf an early blood test can extend life expentancy and save lives then this must surley be made available. 34242020-01-07T16:43:06.67743283Allan CuthbertI wish you greater success than we had in Wales, where anglers were treated with contempt. Good luck 33762020-01-07T17:01:43.0243284Jim DoyleAnything that helps to bring back salmon to Scottish rivers. It worked for the Tyne.33762020-01-07T17:11:10.2943285David Downie The Kielder hatchery on the Tyne has worked by stocking salmon parr which have been grown on to almost smolt size and released in late summer or in the autumn-they then migrate the following spring.\r\nWe have been catching hatchery fish for years---genetic integrity?? at least 10% of a rivers run has been proved by scientists to come from other river systems. The Scottish Government need to act before the situation gets worse. More work needed on reducing the effect of predatory birds and seals..33762020-01-07T22:55:30.36743286Jeni PearsonI work in a hospice and see women with young families die of this horrible disease, if we can do anything to prevent it we should. 34242020-01-08T10:22:46.5443287Peter CreswickIf we don't give nature a helping hand at this point there will be no Salmon left to study. Hatcheries need to work along side the Scientist who have been resurching this decline in Salmon as long as I've been fishing in Scotland and that 40 years and every year the problem is worsening without any conclusion from the Scientest. 33762020-01-08T13:58:58.89743288Malcolm BryantChildren cancer should be paramount34342020-01-08T13:59:57.16743290Isabel DickAstronaut Neil Armstrong daughter died of this a few years before the moon landing and yet 50 years on from the moon landing still no cure for this killer disease and minimal treatments no progress made time to change that 34342020-01-08T14:07:53.11743291James Fleming Leave the hatcheries to the people that know how they run them 33762020-01-08T14:13:25.19743292Ezra MacleanLogan was my big brother and I wanted to grow up with him34342020-01-08T14:55:05.07743294Mrs Debbie Gilbert Must find a cure to many families are being destroyed by this terrible disease 34342020-01-08T15:11:24.6143295Stephen JonesAbout time 33762020-01-08T15:45:27.08743296Beverly IngleMy great grandson, Ryder Tuck, was diagnosed with DIPG in June 2016 and died October 2016. We need a cure for this monster that is stealing our children and destroying families! Please find a cure!34342020-01-08T16:23:11.3443297Richard Sagar.I have watched the salmon and sea trout population of the UK decline. Over the past 60 years I have been fishing. It is time we did something to improve the situation I think this is any excellent way to boost stocks to their native rivers.\r\n33762020-01-08T16:54:54.35743298Alexander williamsTime for change so mental health can be supported in court.34032020-01-08T17:52:57.14743299Nigel GearyFrom a layperson venue the impact Kielder Hatchery has had on the Tyne has been outstanding. At what point does a river spiral to extinction due to inadequate egg deposition. The whole aspect of Salmon survival require a multi strategy attack. This includes better habit, predation controls and deposition support through hatcheries. 33762020-01-08T18:56:3543300Jack A MorrisonTime to change things for good. 34032020-01-08T19:05:12.95343301Simon Furniss We must be able to use the tool of a hatchery to help get numbers up in the nurseries where numbers are low and stock above impossible falls, where the juveniles will not be competing with wild progeny.33762020-01-08T20:26:21.77743302Donna blair 100percent something needs done and now 34342020-01-08T21:16:08.9443303Dougal Chalmers Get to grips with the ever increasing seal population the increase in seal numbers in the last decade is ten fold and has to have a significant effect on salmon returning to spawn!33762020-01-08T21:17:55.7743304Andrew FigginsHatchery on river Cree doing great work and now getting returning hatchery fish proves to me unquestionably that well run hatcheries work and ARE the way forward 33762020-01-08T21:33:51.33343305Tim DownYou need to do something otherwise you will lose the salmon fishing industry and the hotels and other jobs the provide for33762020-01-08T21:33:54.0243306Gary PriceA hatchery would have helped greatly in restocking the river Dee following storm Frank and perhaps the Tweed, both of which suffered massive losses of parr.33762020-01-08T21:37:31.28743307Tim DownSalmon fishing is dying if you do not do something to help it I.e. hatcheries it will die and all of the other industries that rely on it will die with it33762020-01-08T21:44:21.64743308Margie Akehurst Please provide funding for research in pediatric cancer, especially rare such as DIPG. Without funding a cure cannot be found. Our children deserve everything we can give. They are our future. 34342020-01-08T22:02:59.63743310Fiona LearFor my son and all the other children cruelly robbed of their childhoods and their lives34342020-01-08T22:16:28.94743311Brian LawsonWe must try to save the salmon33762020-01-08T22:16:56.8143312Donald MorrisonListen to those who live and work on the rivers - they know best.33762020-01-08T22:31:40.90343313Diane MunroI lost my precious grandson on 15th June 2017 to the monster DIPG brain tumour. We must do something to stop this most horrific of tumours.34342020-01-08T22:45:25.12743314Marshall GarrettHatcheries have been a notable success both at home and abroad over a significant period. Witness Ori Viguffson's spectacular success in Iceland in the last 20 years.To ignore this potential source of broodstock would be stupidity of the highest order.33762020-01-08T22:46:06.23343315David CarrickThere has never been a time when it is so obvious that nature requires help. Stocking wild fish from wild stock is the only way forward. Habitat improvement will not bring the fish back. A sensible restocking program will!33762020-01-08T22:47:14.56343316Tom BorthwickI feel that more action must be taken to protect our stock of salmon from the increasing numbers of predators preying on them,goosanders,mergansers,seals all having a devastating effect.I am pessimistic about the government tackling this in any meaninful way33762020-01-08T22:49:38.65743317thomas robert blacktake salmon farming off the sea they can rear them on land !!!! save our wild fish33762020-01-08T22:50:19.8643318Lawrence Crompton-Howe Absolutely agree with all comments, and whilst I believe that hatcheries will help with the increase in salmon within our rivers it must not be used as a means by the Government of balancing out decline or most importantly diverting attention away from the vastly damaging effects of the fish farms or uncontrolled increase in predatory species and under researched issues out at sea. \r\nOtherwise I fear we may simply be covering up the real problems with well intended effort, money, time and resource.33762020-01-08T22:55:41.90743319Gerry TyeDIPG is the worst of childhood cancers and it is terminal to all that are diagnosed. It is in our most vulnerable population, our children and young adults... Please support funding for research into stopping this cancer, we have the technology, we just need the will - DIPG is a World Wide Tragedy - My son Talin was just 6 years old and was diagnosed and gone in 13 weeks from DIPG - he died in my arms...34342020-01-08T23:16:34.95743320Graham HeyHatcheries appear to have worked elsewhere! (Iceland,Tyne....)33762020-01-08T23:19:06.11343321Graham HeySeems to have worked elsewhere (Iceland,Tyne....)33762020-01-08T23:38:16.5443322Jeremy Hopkins More hatcheries and more in river predator control and smolt shepherding33762020-01-09T02:25:14.32743323James d leacHI don't hear much about the impact of the fish farms. Perhaps they might also be considered33762020-01-09T06:07:13.62343325grant carsonIt is a natural step towards equality.33682020-01-09T06:36:52.3343326Peter AstburyTo combat predation from cormorants and seals etc, it just makes sense to have more hatcheries.33762020-01-09T06:51:46.3543327HELEN DalyEvery child, every life matters, looking at rare examples can give leaps of knowledge that solve more common problems. 34342020-01-09T07:04:34.30343328James kelletWe need to replenish depleted stocks of wild salmon.33762020-01-09T07:18:30.63343329Guy TollerEnsure the science is correct. Wild salmon are unique and a fragile part of the ecosystem33762020-01-09T07:31:52.7343330Diane PirrieI know the cancer charities work relentlessly in search for incurable cancers for treatments to at least make them treatable if not curable, but to do that there needs to be more money available to them 34342020-01-09T07:59:09.0143331Steve Baldingthe government are not doing enough to stop the netting of fish on the estuaries therefore we need to do what ever we can to rebuild the fish stocks.33762020-01-09T07:59:58.5743332Helen OgdenI am a british national living in Spain & i have a good friend in the uk whose daughter died aged 6 of DIPG. Please raise awareness & research into this dreadful illness.34342020-01-09T08:08:01.94743333John ClaphamI believe that the current system where the costs of fish science work and fish stocking comes from the same pot will never provide effective salmkn ftobk management as scientusts will tend to dicert resources to support the work that they do to the detrement of the sammon population inour rivers.33762020-01-09T08:20:2543334David Scott-MaldenAction needed now !33762020-01-09T08:21:43.543335Gerard PagoagaI have been a regular visitor for 30 years and I am now very worried about the future of the scottish salmon. I am convinced that full operating hatcheries can help as they do in many others countries. 33762020-01-09T09:01:19.78743336Clarence michael woodFor years I have seen dwindling stocks of salmon on the whiteadder and would love to see the past 14 years come back but alas I doubt this very much may just have to hang the rod up ps lovely part of the world many thanks (Mike)33762020-01-09T09:04:01.92343337John WarrenNo hatcheries, no fish eventually. The businesses that harvest stocks at sea should pay to maintain the stocks in the breeding rivers. Common sense.33762020-01-09T09:16:58.3243338DougAllan We dont know what's round the corner so grab life by horns and live it. Carpe diem.34342020-01-09T09:21:49.58343339john stewartMarine Scotland seem hell bent on killing off salmon with no science to back them up. Pererhaps they are an expense would should be dispensed with33762020-01-09T09:28:10.8743340Barry Gibson When the Banks were in crisis government intervened, nature needs intervention action now.33762020-01-09T09:32:34.4643341Ian KingI have met many keepers over the years and all have a deep knowledge of what improves stocks, and they have a strong determination to do so.33762020-01-09T09:42:57.24743342French WightStocking may not be necessary on all rivers but could be vital to keep up stocks on others, and should not be to restrictive.33762020-01-09T09:45:49.3443343Mrs Lorna LindsaySupport this cause.34342020-01-09T10:06:18.56343344Garry Watson The time for a change is now salmon are in massive decline due to many factors like fish farms ,sea birds ,And mass of seals in estuary 33762020-01-09T10:08:00.9543345Thomas CarruthersStocking works look at the tyne33762020-01-09T10:08:37.38743346Jonathan WebsterTwo of the most productive salmon rivers in the UK are the Tyne and the Helmsdale. Both have longstanding hatcheries, the Wye salmon is facing extinction within 10 years and the Welsh EA are insisting on a no hatcheries policy in Wales. Iceland is a likely destination for disenchanted Scottish salmon anglers and there hatcheries are the norm. When will the scientists" start learning from real world examples and give the Atlantic salmon the leg up it so desperately needs. 33762020-01-09T10:25:00.95743347William DuncanAs far as I am aware, stocking has worked everywhere it has been carried out. \r\n33762020-01-09T10:31:12.3143348Jason EvansWe need hatcheries to secure the future of wild salmon in the UK.33762020-01-09T10:41:34.57743349Bridget Bannister Lost my grandson to brain tumours Valentine's Day 2016-more research needed to stop it happening to more children. He fought it for 6 years and lost the battle at 18.534342020-01-09T10:44:52.34343350James RichardsWe have sales all year round. The Internet has changed everything regarding retail. Opening on such days represents a race to the bottom. And of course, give time off to hardworking staff. The world will not stop spinning if large business all close on a few select days of the year.34252020-01-09T11:05:27.0843351David WoodhouseI fully support a strictly monitored stocking policy for a period of time, for all our game rivers. They are in dire need of any help we can give them to help recover back to some of their former glory33762020-01-09T11:18:57.0143352Dr Peadar DavisThis activity is the only way those directly affected can mitigate wholesale threats from pollution, overfishing, fish farming etc. which have massively reduced the numbers of salmon naturally returning to spawn. The salmon is an important aspect of Scotland's natural heritage - rod caught salmon is a sadly underappreciated economic lever with great potential to aid Scotland's tourism and manufacturing industry - it is important now - imagine the potential if the fish and therefore catches were more plentiful and reliable. Policy needs to be evidence driven and the knowledge and expertise of those managing the rivers needs to be high on the list of key evidence utilised.33762020-01-09T12:17:22.5343353Colin McGregorEvery river authority should be adopting a stocking policy as a matter of course, not on a voluntary basis.33762020-01-09T12:17:41.5943354Nicholas MasonIt seems crazy to me not to fully research and debate stocking whilst there is a backdrop of falling wild numbers. 33762020-01-09T14:05:43.81343355Peter MooreAny help would do nothing but good and that goes for Trout as well.33762020-01-09T14:08:49.8343356John SawyerSalmon stocking must go on to preserve the salmon future.33762020-01-09T15:34:29.5643357Allan LumsdenTime is wasting away33762020-01-09T15:49:33.29743358Paula SpurrierListen to all viewpoints but pay particular interest to those who work within the industry.33762020-01-09T15:50:51.6443359John Anderson There has been too much interference from people who have no real knowledge of what is needed to solve the problem ..33762020-01-09T16:58:59.97343360Andrew HurstThis debate is long overdue. Science shouldn't just focus on possible genetic negatives, it should equally focus on how to optimise hatcheries to ensure diversity and fitness can be achieved. So far the hatchery debate has only ever focussed on the negatives with opposition being led by a few diehard antis. 33762020-01-09T17:10:44.96343361David HobkirkNeed good robust science which should incorporate the knowledge and experience of generations keepers and fisherman. \r\nNeed to assess the reliability and accuracy of the data on which decisions are being made, differentiating between weak and strong evidence. \r\nIdentify sources of bias be it political or from individual stake holders. \r\nAbove all we need to take the angling community on-board with shared objectives and goals moving away from the current them and us situation, the salmons existence as we know it is at stake .33762020-01-09T19:24:48.73343362Moira MaxwellWorked retail now for 15 years now and not once do I feel like it Christmas or new year as always having to work hours which leaves me unable to have that special time with family. 34252020-01-09T19:25:54.8943363Dave Sellerswe need more hatcheries33762020-01-09T19:32:46.1443364John TwinameWho makes the disition on who goes to these meetings was their anyone from south scotland ie castle douglas as we have not told this was happening rather upset about not being asked or even knowing some one who was invited it may be was just a jolly outing who think they k ow it all. John twiname33762020-01-09T19:53:27.29743365Ian KeightleyShops should stay closed on news year's day so we can spend money time with our families34252020-01-09T20:03:57.54743366Iain neilI am a simple man that does not ask much from life but I think saving an iconic emblem of Scotland is worth it.....when I think of Scotland it's one of the first things I think of.......we have a great eco system in Scotland I want to save or support it as much as I can and would love a policy formed on supporting wild salmon and helping them so they may continue to grace the waters of Scotland for generations to come.33762020-01-09T20:13:45.56743367Ian Flower Shut shops 34252020-01-09T20:16:07.03743368Alan Rorrison100% agree!34252020-01-09T20:22:40.75743369Carole Wood Let's spend time with family and friends 34252020-01-09T21:49:50.7743370Lois jacksonFamily member recently been diagnosed with dipg - brain tumour and it is shocking how little funding there is in this area of cancer. 34342020-01-09T21:58:07.59343371Mr John Mclean All these big retail companies make enough money and profits all the year round so it's about time the retail workers and the public services have a good Christmas and new year the same as all the big directors and bosses from these companies as well afterall its Christmas and new year for everyone 34252020-01-09T23:01:22.32743373Alan RobinsoWhen any animal or bird needs saving from extinction \r\nYou start a breeding program to help. But not for salmon?33762020-01-10T06:21:34.97343375Michelle SharpDIPG is literally trapping children in their bodies with full mental awareness before they die. Something needs to be done. 34342020-01-10T08:11:44.4443379Kerry Scott Come on Scottish government get you finger out and help these poor families. 34342020-01-10T09:18:42.99743383Stephanie ColangeloMy 5 year old Grand-daughter died from a DIPG brain tumor. No cure. Please help these innocent children to live and save their families this heartache.34342020-01-10T09:50:17.61343384Linzi baillieYes most certainly they should 34342020-01-10T13:53:19.57343386Claire MurdockAll cancers are important but childhood cancers are completely devastating. Please consider funding research and supporting early diagnosis by raising awareness. Thankyou.34342020-01-10T16:28:00.24343387Jacqui GibsonMove polluting Salmon Farms onto the land and give wild fish a chance to recover stocks.33762020-01-10T18:56:54.243389Mark McLair We need to send more smolts to sea. It's not rocket science 33762020-01-10T21:01:23.31343390Jacqueline McNeillI support this petition34342020-01-10T21:28:33.03743391George PottsYou need local knowledge of the rivers not that of scientists 33762020-01-11T01:53:44.08743392Sandy HarrisonGoverment, listen to the the people who work on the rivers for once in your life.33762020-01-11T09:52:15.1243393Lynn McCollMy daughter also died from a rare for of childhood cancer. No parent should ever be told that they cannot cure your child34342020-01-11T09:56:18.9243394William ThomsonLet's continue to support all measures which will ensure the survival of salmon stocks here and around the world.33762020-01-11T11:11:01.9743395Jim wilsonSomething must be done NOW \r\n33762020-01-11T11:44:10.4943396John InnesThe River Tweed Commission are totally against river stocking. Over thirty years ago I was told trout stocking was bad for salmon life however since the ice age both have been in the rivers, so that destroys that theory. Sensible stocking is a must and would help take pressure away from the salmon. Not every angler wishes to fish for salmon on a river and trout fishers tend to go to rainbow trout fisheries as the river trout fishing is so poor. Sensible stocking in the past never harmed the salmon so why should it do now? High time the authorities listened to anglers for a change instead of trying to manage rivers behind a laptop.33762020-01-11T12:04:32.6443397Paul McGuireTime to stop the political ping pong and get on with saving the entire eco-systems of our rivers.\r\n33762020-01-11T12:04:39.4843398Colin maclean Let's get the hatcheries up and running before it's too late 33762020-01-11T14:16:15.2843399Neil StephenListen to the Gillies and managers who work and live on the river twenty four seven. 33762020-01-11T14:26:46.1143400Rita Adcock Good luck with raising awarness into these horrible\r\nDiseases that claims very young innocent people xxx34342020-01-11T16:34:27.72343401Angela CousinsFor our children.34342020-01-11T17:16:56.02743402Paul ChambersI support this petition to support the future of our salmon33762020-01-11T18:34:38.00743403gary meldrumHatchery is a must on all rivers33762020-01-11T19:31:38.82743405william allcockthe people at grass roots level should have a say in these important decisions.33762020-01-11T20:30:55.2743406Susanne irvinePlease help these children. No-one should have to watch their child die.34342020-01-11T22:02:19.53343408Caroline Wright In Gods Name please help find a cure to stop the suffering these children go through when they are diagnosed with DIPG.. 34342020-01-11T22:46:19.77343409Nancy DaltreyThis cause must receive more funding34342020-01-12T00:28:18.6843410Claire mair I had never heard of this supposed to be rare childhood cancer and in the last 3-4 years 4 local children have lost their lives something must be done to research a cure\r\n34342020-01-12T01:17:09.65343411Valerie GreigSomething needs to be done for research into this terrible illness too many young children are dying from it.There is no treatment at all unless you are willing to travel abroad and even then the treatment only gives them a few more months and costs thousands of pounds.34342020-01-12T05:01:19.12343412Angela WhalenMore research urgently.34342020-01-12T08:03:51.53743413Carla oram More money and awareness for child cancer DIPG34342020-01-12T08:11:02.19743414Jen KellyTruly awful disease needs all the research possible. Best of luck with your petition. 34342020-01-12T08:25:58.1243415George BoyneOur wild atlantic salmon need all the help possible including greater protection from fish eating birds and other predators.33762020-01-12T08:28:54.77743417Zoe Stevenson No child should suffer. Especially not unnecessarily. 34342020-01-12T08:42:50.9443418Doris TrimmingNot enough is being done for children with DIPG or any other cancers, we urgently need to address this.34342020-01-12T09:39:48.07343419george kindnessHatcheries really do work if managed properly along with greater culling of all the predators which are totally out of control. The success of the Wester Ross River Carron just proves how a single person can increase returns almost 100 fold.33762020-01-12T09:41:26.42743420Lorraine WrightPlease help we lost our nephew Alex Logan 2018 6 years old 34342020-01-12T10:58:32.4643423David BurgessWe need to support a rural industry and stocking may help to do this. One comment is I would like to see some fish brought on to smolt stage.33762020-01-12T12:32:56.6343425Kevin j Clark \r\nThanks \r\n33762020-01-12T12:53:26.91343428Frank Myhre HansenI have for years seen hatcheries work. When used as eggboxes set in the gravel on sidestreams at places the fish dont hatch naturally. 33762020-01-12T13:00:10.02343429Alan Wilson Things need to change now before it's to late.33762020-01-12T13:14:40.61343430David McLaughlin I definitely do not agree this is the way forward what's need to be done all government bodies and government needs to introduce rejuvenation of spawning beds and habitats throughout all rivers get back to the basics bring in thinning out of predators land base and sea including factory ships banned from our waters and i do think hatcheries can work if eggs are put out into artificial reds 33762020-01-12T13:19:19.00343431Bill GreenSalmon stocks too low, they need our help. 33762020-01-12T13:38:08.39743432David BamfordWith Marine Survival of Atlantic salmon at an all time low it is it my strong belief that many rivers will lose their stock of salmon without sensible supportive stocking schemes. 33762020-01-12T15:10:43.35343433Ron moore When is Hollyrood going to wake up realise just how much salmon fishing brings to rural enconamies33762020-01-12T15:10:52.4843434Gillian Santos Family member has been diagnosed with DIPG which is an inoperable tumour there is no cure and no progress on finding a cure has been made in over 60 years. We need government funding to find a cure to give us hope for others who are battling this terrible cancer.34342020-01-12T16:16:35.89343435Charles JeffreyNature needs a helping hand immediately.33762020-01-12T16:22:16.37343437debbie WESTONthank you for letting me sign34342020-01-12T16:40:10.4743438Roland CravenPurely restrictive or negative measures are not going to resolve the issues. Positive steps, of which hatcheries are one, are essential.33762020-01-12T17:28:21.9543439Cameron ChapmanIt seems that the Scottish and British Government have agreed that the Scottish economy is more important than the Scottish ecology, especially that of its waters and the Future of the endeared species that are trying to survive in them.33762020-01-12T18:11:01.09743440Iain Wilson Listen to the professional, the ghiiies!!33762020-01-12T18:50:22.19743441Douglas GreenStart listening to the people who know the rivers they work on. We must have hatcheries and reduce the number of predators. Act now before we lose everything. 33762020-01-12T19:27:25.07743442Paul Pritchard Actions needs to be taken urgently. 33762020-01-12T21:04:23.88743443Gordon Duncan About time just hope it's not to late 33762020-01-12T22:15:21.71743445Ted EdgarGive the hatcheries an opportunity and examine the results, listen to those who work on the river, who know the river and want to improve it.33762020-01-12T23:11:11.9943446Brian KeyHatcheries are an obvious step in the right direction33762020-01-13T00:30:15.34743447George HollandI am the treasurer,secretary of an angling club on the river Ayr,where we used to run our own hatchery until we lost the ground on which it stood,I have 100 year's of catch returns to compare which marine and others have and know about the proof is undeniable, while our hatchery was running our catches went from average of 44 per year to well over 200 in a season,the whole system enjoyed this and would love to see it return,we now have a third of the membership and were still catching slightly above average,if it is done properly it will work I have information if they want it if they choose to listen,our club has purchased a third of the river Ayr through the years it would be a shame not being able to do what ever we can to help this amazing iconic fish .33762020-01-13T06:55:01.51743448Alan James ParrSadly in this day and age certain species need urgent help. I consider Salmon to be one. Why wait till they are on the brink before help is given. It would only take an outbreak of disease to finish them off completely. 33762020-01-13T07:58:31.01743450Sam valentine It's really important that we stop the decline in salmon numbers NOW whilst there's a chance to save our salmon33762020-01-13T08:21:16.72343451James robertson Long overdue 33762020-01-13T10:34:43.33343452murray stewartIt is criminal if salmon are allowed to die out we need to reduce the number of non native birds eating the salmon off spring33762020-01-13T10:59:02.3743453William McSpadyenSometimes nature needs a helping hand. Moreso in the current environmental climate.33762020-01-13T11:01:12.943454John mcmurray Wark We need more hatcheries 33762020-01-13T11:01:59.19743455Richard SaundersSalmon stocks need replenishing NOW, not in 20 or 30 years. Both SEPA & Marine Scotland have proven to be enemies of Salmon Stocks, with their ill-thought out policies & plans, and in the case of Marine Scotland, their highly questionable "Science"!33762020-01-13T11:36:47.11343456Stephen MitchellI am one of thousands of anglers who enjoy an angling trip to Scotland every year. I entirely agree with the idea that all interested parties should be consulted in this matter. Look what has happened in England! Do not allow Scotland to fall into the same trap.33762020-01-13T12:06:35.06743457Andy CliveAbout time33762020-01-13T15:29:52.7543459Louise Carter Such a good cause, I hope its successful.34342020-01-13T15:48:18.84743460Tom SpeirHatcheries are an essential and only way to restock or increase stocks of salmon. The river Tyne has proved this although the EA don't believe this, which ignores the evidence.33762020-01-13T18:17:55.44743461Simon ClarkI am unable to see how the critical mass of breeding fish will repair itself when none of the predators are being managed. Hatcheries must be a serious help as has been proven in Iceland on Rivers like the East Ranga. To ignore this option just hastens the demise of the scottish salmon and the economy that goes with it!33762020-01-13T23:05:26.28343463Jane MuirToo many children are losing their lives to this! 34342020-01-14T11:29:40.78343464Sir Peter CresswellPlease read "Swimming Against the Tide-Restoring Salmon to the Tyne" by Peter Gray and Michael Charleston published by The Medlar Press in 2011.33762020-01-14T14:46:05.85743465john castleIt is most often the Anglers who have technical knowledge and true respect for the salmon species as their quarry. Their views, balanced with realistic scientific information, should be valued and taken in to consideration.33762020-01-14T15:00:09.23343466Gordon HendersonTimes are dire and something has to be done. This is a good start to protect rural jobs long term.33762020-01-15T12:06:54.3843467David FarmerDo the science first, avoid a one size fits all policy and don't throw the small community led associations out with the bath water which is what is happening now. 33762020-01-15T21:27:37.96743468Gordon BarronGo with happened on dee in the past keep our salmon 33762020-01-15T22:24:35.82743469Kathy GivenMy grandson died at the age of 13 in 2017 with DIPG and would love to see more funds given for the research of this and other child cancers. 34342020-01-16T10:11:13.97343472Briony robertsGovernments should be striving to eradicate all cancers to the best of their ability, especially childhood cancers and raising awareness of how to spot all types of cancers. 34342020-01-16T12:14:44.78743474Hunter WatsonThe 2003 Mental Health Act does not provide for a complaints handling procedure. Neither the mental health tribunal nor the Mental Welfare Commission is required\r\n to investigate complaints34352020-01-16T12:53:55.65343475Judith KrameA cheap test to prevent a lifetime of disability is an essential.34362020-01-16T13:21:23.31343477Tommy Loudon At the moment there are no safeguards or Human Rights woven into Mental Health Services. It's designed to exploit patients. The Psychotropic \r\nDrugs are the first thing Clinicians reach for. They are a risk to themselves and a risk to others. \r\nAll will be revealed. 34352020-01-16T14:55:22.96743479Neil DewhurstAll parties probably agree that salmon decline is multifactorial.The current situation is critical and all options, including hatcheries, must be carefully appraised in an open and unbiased fashion. The final decisions must be on scientific grounds and evidence based.33762020-01-16T15:21:57.31343480David EmmersonI find it very sad that salmon fishing is being allowed to disappear.33762020-01-16T16:41:28.543482Maurice FrankIt was powers of this nature, in their 1980s incarnation, that, in a Western democracy, enabled a mental health unit to nurse to announce that they were going "to get you in here and change you."34352020-01-16T22:32:04.95343483Ian KitsonThe disaster that is salmon stocks cannot wait. More hatcheries is a quick start.33762020-01-17T05:15:33.5743484Lorraine Reardon This is a matter of urgency too many precious children are lost to this awful disease 34342020-01-17T09:19:01.91743485Leanne HubbardHelp childrens future from the beginning. In the womb.34362020-01-17T10:12:54.6143486Robby HowardIts just a shame smebody as yourself ( no disrespect intended mate ) has to put a petition out there to get this done, SHAME on the powers that be, SHAME. \r\nGood n you though mate. RESPECT. 34362020-01-17T10:30:31.6643488Judith RichardsonYou only need to look into there eyes33522020-01-17T10:31:09.50743489Mary carlin Please screen pregnant women for CMV34362020-01-17T18:32:10.14343491Anne GreigI urge the Scottish Parliament to investigate to stop this injustice within the Quasi-Autonomous Non-Governmental Organisation.within Mental Health 34352020-01-18T11:33:36.5943492john stewartmarine Scotland appear to have their own agenda33762020-01-18T12:20:51.47743493Linda Finnie My dog is part of my family..\r\n Not just an object !33522020-01-18T13:08:24.94743494Danna Quinn The quicker this is passed the better for our fur babies 33522020-01-18T13:39:16.2543495Jackie cruickshanks Dogs are not objects and have rights too 33522020-01-18T14:38:21.86743496Fiona RiddochThere are living,breathing beings and clearly not inanimate.They desperately need protection from human beings who seek to do them them harm.33522020-01-18T23:44:47.1143499Kayleigh hughesI hope awareness can be raised and children can be helped. God forbid anything like this happens to my daughter. I don't know how mums and grandmothers cope because I know I couldn't. Good luck for the future x34342020-01-18T23:56:42.67343500Amelia smithMore should be done for children with cancer 34342020-01-19T00:15:04.6943501Kerry CollinsPlease help these poor children.34342020-01-19T00:55:05.3643504Teresa McKayMore research is essential for treatment of childhood cancers34342020-01-19T08:33:46.52743506Deborah jeffreysKeep sharing this and use the power of people to change what governments do for cancer care34342020-01-19T08:58:06.18743508Tracey GomezJus do it!34342020-01-19T09:07:33.98743509Nicola PughGood luck 34342020-01-19T10:07:58.77343511Joanne NicholsonI too lost my daughter to a brain tumour in 2019 . We need to get this petition through. Xxxx34342020-01-19T10:14:11.0443512Jacqueline Tuck I hope this goes through and children can be saved x34342020-01-19T10:50:55.98343514Helen April SharpGood luck, this is amazing how people are getting together and giving their support34342020-01-19T11:27:09.2743517Catherine RaileyPlease help save the children with cancer34342020-01-19T12:31:33.18743518Karen White Fund research and treatment so that children are not dying waiting for treatment abroad 34342020-01-19T12:36:36.8143519Lee WhitesideFor all children with this cancer34342020-01-19T12:46:52.81343520Julie Peacock Only research will find treatments to help other children fight this awful disease. Sadly it is too late for our nine year old daughter but hope lies in research to prevent other families having to live through this devastating diagnosis.34342020-01-19T12:52:01.70343521angie fosterwe have been destroyed as a family as my beautiful niece passed away 5 months 1 day after being diagnosed with DIPG an incurable disease at 9 years old this should not happen34342020-01-19T14:34:04.41743522Lezlie FergusI would rather be with an animal than a human. The world would be in an even sorrier state without them. Respect where it is due.33522020-01-19T15:18:04.83343524Lauran dakin Please help this type of cancer does not have enough research or funds. My friends child is currently battling and her only hope is a trial in the USA :( 34342020-01-19T20:00:07.5343526Carly Catling \r\n\r\nThis needs urgent attention 34342020-01-20T11:27:29.36743528Carol BennettMore needs to be done to help the children34342020-01-20T12:10:10.9943529Timothy GrayI am opposed to hatcheries since as an expedient palliative they tend to defer or divert attention away from the fundamental issues. But I do think that there should be an informed debate.33762020-01-20T16:27:04.67343530Peter RandellLong overdue34252020-01-20T16:29:2343531Hugh RodgerIt has my full backing 34252020-01-20T16:31:25.03343532Karen BallardShould be closed Boxing Day and 1st and 2nd January this time of year is meant to be family time so let give people chance to spend quality time 34252020-01-20T16:32:49.64343533John McleanThese large retail companies make enough money throughout the year they can afford to close for a day and the directors and the high earners don't have to work so I don't think this is fare afterall it is our new year as well 34252020-01-20T16:35:54.37743534James Irvine People spend enough time at work festival season is time to spend with family 34252020-01-20T16:36:32.98743535garry mcdonaldThe festive period holidays should be for everybody to enjoy.34252020-01-20T16:41:02.09743536Mrs Gillian HutchisonI work in a large food store and would not welcome having to work on new year day. 34252020-01-20T16:41:21.4143537Elizabeth woodPeople fought for years to get these days off years ago and companies have slowly sneaked them back in and suppose to be voluntary. Try telling a manager that34252020-01-20T16:42:00.87743538Richard StephenCompletely agree34252020-01-20T16:43:33.0243539Ian Johnston To make it fair for all34252020-01-20T16:47:04.42743540Frances MCGRILLANAll shops should be closed not just the larger ones34252020-01-20T16:47:42.1943541Elaine BellinghamFestive time is for family and friends to get together , people buy enough shopping to last them for days .34252020-01-20T16:57:50.7443542Jacquline FerrisAs this is a time when owners get to sit and enjoy there family why can't I do the same 34252020-01-20T16:57:55.56743543Jane RutherfordShop is always very quiet on New Year's Day with customers being under the impression the shop is closed. 34252020-01-20T17:02:31.8243545Elaine KerrNo need to open new years day we deserve the time off 34252020-01-20T17:03:54.2743547James Smith Spend time with family 34252020-01-20T17:04:42.55343548Robert GoldieShould include Boxing day as well 34252020-01-20T17:21:56.5743549Patricia McDowellWould be great to enjoy the holidays with your family rather than looking after other people's who might I add don't even appreciate that someone you love is left sitting alone whilst you provide them a service.34252020-01-20T17:26:44.13343550Susan grantMissed time with family after them travelling 300 miles. 34252020-01-20T17:28:08.3743551mrs Heather Elizabeth VanceWould ne nice to be able to visit family I only used to see at new year 34252020-01-20T17:29:34.33743552Margaret GlenBig fat NO 34252020-01-20T17:31:44.94743553ann muirheadGive us our new year back34252020-01-20T17:54:10.82743554Aileen foster 100% agree that it should be open 34252020-01-20T17:57:08.12343555Robina Clark New Year day is a special day like Christmas day and should be shared with family and friends as the start of a Year is very important for families to commit to supporting each other and not giving up this this special time for companies to make bigger profits for shareholders and the Board. 34252020-01-20T18:02:51.82743556Fiona MacDonaldWorking in retail the run up to Christmas is bad enough it would be nice if we could have more than one day to get over that and spend time with our family 34252020-01-20T18:05:09.46743557Robyn CooperDoesn't affect me too much but everyone should definitely get an opportunity to spend some real time with their loved ones instead of being forced to work on one of the quietest days possible. 34252020-01-20T18:07:16.82743558Joyce GrantI don't think it is right that anyone has to work boxing day new year's day and the 2nd of January. In this day and age we should be thinking about family and loved ones. When I was a child I remember all businesses had early finish times running up to Christmas then more or less shut for the festive period or ran skeleton staff on less hours 34252020-01-20T18:07:22.43743559Michael C DonaldsonAll shops should be closed, to spend time with family and friends34252020-01-20T18:08:37.68743560Helen McMunnFamily member has to work on New Years Day as they runs a big store. Would rather they were home with their family.34252020-01-20T18:10:13.6143561Marion mcgovernOnly 2 days a year ,they are taking it away from us ,people in the past fought for these holidays,also not good for those who drive as they cannot celebrate the night before .34252020-01-20T18:26:40.14343563Mrs judith page100% agree34252020-01-20T18:30:48.51743564Heather TurnerThis should be family time. My family are off 2 weeks through Christmas and new year and we hardly have time together over this period as I have to work. Smaller corner shops stay open. We wont starve. 34252020-01-20T18:32:43.6643565Wendy AndersonConvenience store I work in opens please change this\r\n.. 34252020-01-20T18:34:59.1943566Carole-Anne patersonI worked a 8 hour shift this past new year & had to deal with verbal abuse for refusing someone who was very drunk, shiplifters & moans & complaints that we never had fresh bread delivery etc. Yep happy new year to us shop workers huh!! 34252020-01-20T18:35:21.1643567Carole-Anne patersonI worked a 8 hour shift this past new year & had to deal with verbal abuse for refusing someone who was very drunk, shiplifters & moans & complaints that we never had fresh bread delivery etc. Yep happy new year to us shop workers huh!! 34252020-01-20T18:43:46.0543568Daniel Boylewe should have 2 days off at Xmas and new year one day off should not be described, as the holiday's in my book it's a day off, no more .\r\n\r\n34252020-01-20T18:48:59.14743569Stephen FosterTotally agree against all holiday opening nit fair on families34252020-01-20T18:51:24.83343570Patricia Dorsett Iive been in retail for many years since I was 16 years old, I'm now 54 and seen many many changes in how consumer greed is the main reason that large retail outlets and convenience stores have to open on boxing day and new years day it's totally unnecessary, and unfair to those of us who are employed in these positions. There was a time that shops shut for a whole week so it was a proper Christmas holiday, gone are those days but I wish it could be brought back, consumers aren't going to starve just because the shops are shut for one extra day, greed and selfishness is what forces retailers to bow to the consumers demands.\r\nThis whole situation seriously needs an overhaul. 34252020-01-20T19:04:02.7443571Jill McDonaldKeep hearing about family values then through greed be expected to work over special holidays and then we are not missing time with our families no special memories apart from exhaustion through over worked34252020-01-20T19:17:04.75743572SHIRLEY MCLAUGHLAN 100% close all stores and spend quality time with our family 34252020-01-20T19:35:23.21343573Margaret Hamilton Let people spend more quality family time34252020-01-20T19:36:32.88743574Louise EsslemontSocial work have to much power they treat adults like children keep them apart from family 34412020-01-20T20:16:32.17343576Anne McGuire100% agree. Everyone should be able to spend quality time with family and friends at this time of year. Life is too short.34252020-01-20T20:32:46.51743577Graham Gardner Well if this works itll be the first thing usdaw has done that's good for me. 34252020-01-20T21:07:44.4643578Azam GoodarzyThese few years were not like Xmas or New year at all with shops being open on Boxing day and New years day. We would like to spend time with our family with out any stress , is it to much to ask? 34252020-01-20T21:16:11.10343579Calum BoydonThere is not enough holiday entitlement \r\nI retail sector 34252020-01-20T21:42:35.68343580Alistair PollockNew year is a family time, to be spent with family and loved ones, visiting those no longer with us and making plans for the year to come. NOT WORKING34252020-01-20T21:50:30.57743581linda mcilwraithXmas day, boxing day, 1st and 2nd jan all shops should be shut so people can spend time with their families 34252020-01-20T21:51:16.07743582Atis KUKURSIn most of Europe everything is closed for Christmas and New Year. Why to create a new wheel if it works in many other countries? Business is not going down but many people are more happy to be relaxed and together with their loved ones.34252020-01-21T05:03:22.5843584Louisa McNeill100 percent should be closed 34252020-01-21T06:49:20.57743586Claire DaviesI agree34252020-01-21T09:48:33.1843587Sandra FergusonSpend more time with family.34252020-01-21T14:59:29.45743589Franco Barbato Totally agree \r\n\r\n\r\nTotally agree \r\n34252020-01-21T16:11:00.76343590William galbraithOur river was full of salmon when we had hatchery now without one fish have vanished in river Lugar and Ayr 33762020-01-21T16:13:20.0343591William galbraithAll Scottish rivers should have a hatchery33762020-01-21T16:43:37.92343592Rebekah Elizabeth SimpsonSocial work shouldn't have the power very family's and children unless it is absolutely necessary for them to step in. I believe that social work have a tendency to abusE their power in many different ways and frequently do so34412020-01-21T17:29:26.05343593Stephen M.FieldingA good idea but more measures should be taken as well to protect smolts BEFORE they return to the sea.\r\nEstimated mortality rate circa 50%.33762020-01-21T17:57:15.52343594John AllanThank you Usdaw for organising against the bullying and threatening of some companies who are only interested in money and couldn't care or even think about the folk who produce the profit they enjoy . I bet you they make sure they get there holiday when they want it . 34252020-01-21T18:03:45.243595Amelia MainsShops should be closed on new years day and the 2nd so shop workers can spend time with their families and friends. 34252020-01-21T20:19:44.48343596Sheila Robertson Would love to spend time with family & friends at New year 34252020-01-21T21:08:47.55343597William Keogh We don't open on new years day,but I don't think any shop should be open on this day.34252020-01-21T22:03:35.00343598Alison Gow All shops should be closed on new years day staff need time to spend with family 34252020-01-21T22:39:58.64343599John RevieMake time for families instead of making more profits for capitalists.34252020-01-22T00:35:10.25743600Julie LofthouseWe should also have 1-2 week breaks for holidays with our children in summer to co inside with school holidays like we used to have.34252020-01-22T00:52:28.08743601Laura StroudPlease commit funds to DIPG research 34342020-01-22T08:36:03.743602Samantha KerrParental & Familial Alienation and Domestic Abuse including psychological coercive control of children by the abuser and third parties are intrinsically linked and the home and those closely connected to the child can be the very source and trigger for Children's Mental Health issues. 32992020-01-22T08:38:43.8443603Samantha KerrChildren who are in an alienated position or who are at risk of this are very likely to want someone to intervene on their behalf.32992020-01-22T10:06:30.47743605David StevensonEveryone deserves a decent break.34252020-01-22T14:25:51.2943606Tracey CollisonHaving worked in retail for over 17 years it would be amazing to have time off with my grandchildren as I missed out so much with my own children 34252020-01-22T17:03:01.03343607Joe PassmoreWorking people are the reason that we have commerce. They are the main commodity that businesses cannot do without. Respect your workers, respect their families and the will respect you.34252020-01-22T19:12:46.78343608Jo FiskNew Year is a splendid tradition in Scotland and should be upheld for family and friends to gather together. 34252020-01-22T19:21:18.03743609Jo CrumplinSolidarity with my colleagues in Scotland. Staff deserve a decent break, and time with thier families.34252020-01-22T21:02:25.343613Ann Morgan Just a personal comment that I am sure can be replicated. A family member had worked 10 days in a row during the festive period. They were unable to join a family gathering. Their retail job is demanding.Its time to look at pay and conditions and holidays for retail workers.34252020-01-22T22:00:35.05743614Salifu JoofLet me know anything or update me 32992020-01-22T23:31:21.81343615Gary BallantyneScotland has a broken seal when it comes to human rights, the mental health act is being abused and manipulated by courts, councils and health professionals. Curator ad litems are not even regulated ! The moral agent of MWC has been corrupted. The criminals seem to be charge now, no true checks nor balance of powers. 34352020-01-23T08:50:58.63743616Samantha KerrParental and familial alienation is no respecter of gender. 32992020-01-23T17:48:34.6243617David McclymontI fully support the idea of debating this subject matter to determine whether or not it would have a good effect on the situation in the future and how it would be funded, as the exit from the European union may now cause great difficulty in future sponsored activities. 33762020-01-25T00:59:02.7843618Samantha KerrThere are good parents and bad parents:\r\n\r\nThere are abusive men,\r\nThere are abusive women,\r\nThere are men who alienate,\r\nThere are women who alienate, \r\n\r\n\r\nThere are men that falsely accuse,\r\nThere are women who falsely accuse,\r\n\r\nNo wonder kids grow up with mental health problems!\r\nIts our job to stop the abuse 32992020-01-25T02:52:54.543619Janet McArthurThe Social Services are no longer (if they ever were) trusted by the people. They appear to cause more harm than good and their motives for many of their actions are suspect. No child should be forcibly adopted at great cost to the public when parents and wider family are still around. Even where there are huge problems in the families concerned, no child should be considered a profitable commodity and removed against their will.\r\n34412020-01-25T17:41:30.55343620Mrs Claire Patricia MuirEven if Psychiatric Rights Scotland have to stand up for Human Rights alone we will stand up for Human Rights. 34352020-01-25T21:49:51.0543621Arthur Mc FarlaneThe price of freedom is eternal vigilance. Our human rights rights can be stolen from us but we are not giving them up.34352020-01-26T12:57:49.6843623Linda Esslemont Yeah social work have too much power on kids and they treat adults like children which should not be allowed, 34412020-01-27T14:20:09.00743624gary meldrumNeed hatchery on every river in scotland33762020-01-27T14:42:57.3443625David TaylorThe TDSFB have many years of "on ground" experience and should be respected for this knowledge of the Tay system. 33762020-01-27T16:03:10.55343626John fraserI have always been against hatcheries but we are now at crisis point and without help I believe salmon fishing will not be viable within my lifetime 33762020-01-27T16:42:41.46343627Sheila MannionWe cannot allow this to to go through without stringent representations to the Scottish Government33762020-01-27T17:18:20.09343628John gallowayHatcherys are only way to keep rivers alive before all brood stock extinct 33762020-01-27T17:52:23.95743629Kevan JudgeInteresting how a hatcheries policy can been blundered in virtually immediately yet the Scottish Parliament can ignore rafts of information about the damage to the environment caused by the salmon farming industry. Double standards rule or is it more a case of palms being crossed with more silver by some than others?33762020-01-27T18:28:19.3743630Jim Johnstone Used to maintain the cctv cameras at tay hatcheries and they do an incredible job. 33762020-01-27T18:29:11.94743631Andrew SmithMarine Scotland have come to a debatable policy based on a selective take on old research and the absence of full and vigorous consultation is not acceptable in any way. 33762020-01-27T18:41:56.6643632Andrew SmithThe policy being adopted by Marine Scotland is based on old and selectively interpreted research.\r\nThere has to be full dialogue and involvement and it is disgraceful the way this is being railroaded through. 33762020-01-27T19:56:39.5943633George BessantPolicy decisions work best when you carry public support and have open discussions33762020-01-28T01:01:17.53343634Alex MacPheeThe people promoting the petition understand the system and have, over many years, pulled together and invested a great deal of time and resources in understanding and trying to address the continued and rapid decline in the numbers of Salmon in our rivers. As part of this process they firmly believe hatcheries are helping to stem the declines. Given their knowledge and selfless conviction, the Govt should take proper, considered account of what they have to say and enable the work of the hatcheries to continue. 33762020-01-28T02:07:08.18343635Nigel MckayIt's time for real change33762020-01-28T07:35:08.2643636David John GriffithsI've have been employed as a riverkeeper for 30 years and during that time this countries policies on Salmonid conservation has been a collection of failures. It is time we started taking action by boosting Salmonid numbers by stocking, controlling predators and habitat management. It's not rocket science. If nothing is done in the near future, I fear that I will see the end of the king of fish in my life.33762020-01-28T07:46:41.743637John GreethamCome on guys, childhood cancer gets hardly any awareness and the funding is about 1.5 percent of the total research budget, and that's for all childhood cancers combined. In many cases, most of the funding comes from the kids themselves running lemonade stalls and parent led foundations.34342020-01-28T13:20:50.30343638Stephen Kilpatrick Leave the hatcheries to the people who know how to run them and how to get the best results from restocking.33762020-01-28T14:14:05.48343639James Thomson Needs to be done and Now ! 33762020-01-29T10:07:12.9243640Jayne Scollay These are vital services which all children should have access to when they require it. We talk about early intervention but then those professionals are not there to support the families who need it the most 34452020-01-29T11:47:12.25343641Lynn Watsona family member has been severely alienated from me, my family & friends. Nobody 'official' is the least bit interested - school made things worse. Social work say school will deal with it. GP has 'never heard of parental alienation'. It's horribly real & causing long-term term trauma to children...32992020-01-29T13:08:19.58743643Janice NobleIt's really hard to get any professional specialist support and head teachers aren't always knowledgeable or qualified to be in the best position to know what to do to help.34452020-01-29T18:47:38.82743644Caroline yavuz Children and adults with additional needs deserve the same rights and education as everyone the same chances in life 34452020-01-29T22:14:39.8243645Rebbecca litchfieldNeed less NDAS waiting times and somewhere to get ongoing advice from professionals who know your child.34452020-01-30T05:51:43.243646Jennifer Clark More needs to be done to save our children. Please commit to more awareness and funds for DIPG research. 34342020-01-30T07:40:15.83343647Michelle Brown Definitely needs to be more invested in more professionals and much more support for families.34452020-01-30T07:44:09.41343648Michelle BrownMore needs invested in supporting families not just during diagnosis but also afterwards, there is a major lack in services and support.34452020-01-30T07:47:12.2143649Catriona Strachan Please provide extra funding 34342020-01-30T10:05:25.4443650Michelle Balfour A family member has Aspergers & a zspcial Anxiety Disorder. They also suffer badly with depression. School & child services totally failed them. They tried to take their own life, it's took this to get them the help & support they needed since primary school. Child services tried to silence us in the hope that we would just go away.\r\n 34452020-01-30T11:11:04.9543652James CavanaghMuch more support is needed in all areas of assisting these children 34452020-01-30T12:49:23.60343653Keith HarperVery important for services to clearly understand individuals fundemental human rights (and acts of law) must be upheld.34352020-01-30T15:25:26.56743654Linda NicolsonMore help is needed to help young children34342020-01-30T17:36:24.0543655Robert Craig Please support this cause. Far more needs to be done to help fight this and support families. There is money out there to be spent rather than wasting it on HS2 etc34342020-01-30T19:20:30.45743656Carol DixonAll children die from DIPG. Imagine being a parent and finding out there are no treatments available. There are other brain tumours too that cause high morbity with children. Brain tumours are the biggest cause of cancer death in children. Funding, research and awareness amongst clinicians is needed. NOW!34342020-01-30T20:49:20.2843657Evonne mckayOur kids are being failed and let down we need more professionals now to help our kids 34452020-01-30T21:06:08.39343658Nicola McCreadie Yes34342020-01-30T23:26:15.54343659Ben davis start helping the younger generation 34342020-01-31T14:16:48.75343661Samantha CumminsParental alienation shouldn't be happening. No matter of gender. 32992020-01-31T14:57:59.40343662Daniel DonaldsonAs a lawyer, I support a full review of how the rules of court and the table of fees affect access to justice.34032020-02-01T09:35:40.8343663Monaka BibiFamily member was drugged needlessly with clozapin, they are 23yrs old. They now have tachardia, parkinsoms, muscle loss, diabetes, vision loss, liver problems, thyroid problems, cognitive deficit, hair loss, skin rash.\r\nThey were never violent or delusional just autistic 34352020-02-01T12:11:42.07743664Tracey dicksOur children are being let down by there being lack of support. What future will they have if there being failed at such a young age. 34452020-02-01T22:25:21.243665Evelyne DupavilonAll kids deserve to live. I'm a voice to childhood cancer.34342020-02-02T22:23:10.91343666Carla OramWe need more funding for research into childhood cancers. Especially DIPG where the diagnosis has always been the same and still no treatment in the UK.34342020-02-02T22:57:23.6743667Nancy DaltreyI support this petition 34342020-02-02T23:50:34.2743668Leslie HoneycuttI lost my 17 yr. old grandson to DIPG 10 yrs ago. 34342020-02-03T01:37:17.8843669Beverley ClarkThe children must come first34342020-02-03T11:20:54.91343670Pearl HamiltonNon domestic rates should not be managed by local authorities. Small Business Scheme is crucial for survival of small businesses.33842020-02-03T13:03:27.97343671John Thomson500% increase in rates if continues I will have to close 33842020-02-03T13:10:31.82343673David PierottiPlease revisit the small business rate criteria and £18k threshold on rateable value , its killing small operators and costing jobs 33842020-02-04T19:08:28.24343678Lolita MilneMy family has experienced the lack of support that comes from a lack of funding into treatment of brain tumours, and the support patients and families need from research.34342020-02-04T19:16:45.94743679Jennifer Boles More need to be done for these children 34342020-02-04T20:03:34.84743680Janet GillFunding is so important to help develop understanding 34342020-02-04T20:14:17.6343681Morna Sinclair Please support this as we as a country still take far too long to diagnose brain tumours in children. Family member was only 2 when they were eventually diagnosed. Many doctors appointments and tearful phone calls. Eventually a video of them having a seizure worked. Thankfully they are now fully recovered but more needs to be done now!34342020-02-04T20:15:53.843682Bex Rae Campbell A lot more should be done about this and a lot more money should be gifted to childhood cancers ,please Scottish government please help by giving direct funding to kids cancer 34342020-02-04T20:33:26.33743683Roberta StancliffeFunds should be divided equally, cant understand why this charity only receives not even 2% !34342020-02-04T21:58:18.37743684Michael Cameron There must be as much research done for this disease.34342020-02-05T09:32:35.67743685Susan KellyI back this 100% and so should the Scottish government!34342020-02-05T11:38:55.72343686Daniel DonaldsonI support ending the exclusion of Disabled people in the Justice System.34032020-02-05T12:01:38.7943687James HarveyI would like to see the funding of a gamma knife in Scotland.34342020-02-05T20:52:14.61743688David RossMy grandson Aaron passed away on Friday from a hypothalamic glioma . There is little or no hope of a cure offered and treatment has changed little over the years generally consisting of treating the symptoms rather than curing the problem. More research is urgently needed to help Children from this dreadful disease.34342020-02-06T08:37:14.18343689Karan Simson Parents using their children against living and caring grandparents as pawns are creating adverse childhood experiences and trauma . 32992020-02-06T09:00:39.01743690Tracy Ord Lets do something about this Scotland\r\n Parent alienation and family alienation is on the rise Fathers has less rights than animals32992020-02-06T09:07:49.59343691Steve ord Lets get parents and family the help they need 32992020-02-06T10:05:26.0443692Frederick WalkerPlease commit to help our children34342020-02-06T20:02:22.9943695Andy DelaneyIt's the kids who are damaged parental alienation is abuse 32992020-02-06T20:41:26.3443696Marie Toolan This should be the case all over!!! 32992020-02-06T22:53:07.1643697Craig heaneyDisgusting that the government allow this to happen especially when the absent parent has to.pay so much to.a child they cant see. 32992020-02-07T02:15:19.19743698Lillian CumminsBout time this awful venomous situation is addressed and dealt with, all parents should have by law 50 50 access to their children and their upbringing, the injustice is immense and unless it is proved a person is a risk to their children then this alienation should be dealt with by law, the costs of parents going to court is extortionate and help should be available to arbitrate in disputes and both parties by law have to attend or get arrested, instead of dragging on for years through courts and having to pay huge legal costs, just get the parents sat down and sort out visitation agreements, that is what is best for the children32992020-02-08T19:24:25.2143701Fiona De StefanoAdequate funding for treatment and research into childhood cancers should be a priority.34342020-02-09T00:19:33.7543702Karen Orosco 17 month old family member diagnosed with a rare Cancer Rhabdomyosarcoma. What has happened to their little body that requires reconstructive surgery in their future is unimaginable. We must find cures to treat difficult childhood Cancer's. This cancer grows rapidly before you ever know it's there. The public needs to be aware that so many children are not only diagnosed but dying and without funding research this will continue. Our children deserve to live their lives to its fullest with their loving families. Imagine what they can do in this world if given the chance. Please make this a priority! 34342020-02-09T11:16:24.4543703Ann ReidResearch is vital to help find a cure and new cancer treatments. Funding from Scottish Government is urgently needed to carry out this research as little has changed over the years to find a cure for childhood cancers.34342020-02-10T10:25:58.15343704Jeanette FragaPsychiatric drugs are drugs, not medicine.34352020-02-10T15:12:12.0343705John DuffyUnfair Business Rates policies are severely damaging retail, and resulting in job losses 33842020-02-10T23:39:23.41343706Tina HarrisThis is great news34342020-02-11T16:52:15.6743708Steven BerridgePlease help with more research to finding cures for these horrible childhood cancers. 34342020-02-11T17:09:21.42343709Cara Riley Family member in remission from Ewings Sarcoma. The treatment was horrendous. It poisoned them and they had their leg amputated.34342020-02-11T17:32:00.6643710Emma powellI am totally backing this as I can personally say I have seen the devastating effects this has on families , having spent 11 weeks on a child cancer ward in London with family member I have met families which have had to suffer the devastating loss of this horrific disease!!34342020-02-11T17:34:07.69743711Heather RyceThis disgusting and cruel practice has to end. 34502020-02-11T18:10:37.23343712Suzanne Beesley I think more\r\nMoney and more\r\nResearch has to put towards childhood cancer34342020-02-11T18:22:32.18743713Denise keskinThis cause really needs funding these children need \r\ntreatment here not having to be taken to other countries.34342020-02-11T18:23:05.23743714Paula burtonAll cancers are hard to treat until you have the cure! Children deserve as much of a chance at life as an adult. More funding is urgently needed34342020-02-11T21:07:07.843716Gerry GallottPlease give more funding!! 34342020-02-12T15:57:56.4943718Valerie Loveys As the diagnosis rate of childhood cancer increases, the number of drugs available to treat children remains at two. Children are being treated with drugs designed for adults. You are not only saving children in your country, you are saving children globally. \r\nRegards,\r\nValerie Loveys \r\nCanada 34342020-02-13T18:01:08.76743719Ricardo Sanchesa family member was diagnosed when they were 9 years old, after at least 5 years of going to GPs and other medical professionals for clinical analysis. There were only correctly diagnosed because I ORGANIZED AND PAID myself for a private MRI scan. The NHS system did not see the need for a scan. I think this decision was driven by cost and poor understanding of symptoms and risks. More effective use of existing equipment and professionals could save lives - and could also save the NHS some money avoiding complex long term care. I support this petition. 34342020-02-13T18:30:17.20343720Dr Will KayParental Alienation is absolutely out of control in Scotland. The refusal of the Scottish Government to recognise it places Scotland as a joke nation in the eyes of the rest of the developed world, and the developing world where it is recognised and already legislated as a criminal offence in many countries. It is totally destructive and detrimental to the wellbeing of the children subjected to it - and it is a clear instance of the one of the worst forms of psychological child abuse!32992020-02-13T18:33:14.48743721Joseph MandavaParental Alienation breeds a generation of damaged children. If we are serious about tackling crime, mental health, suicide among others, this problem must be addressed soon rather than later.32992020-02-13T18:56:54.27343722Salifu JoofPlease help to stop family alienation 32992020-02-14T17:46:34.30343723Valentine ScarlettScotland should set an example in how best to treat animals and birds. This is a horrific way to treat newborn birds34502020-02-14T18:35:04.99343724Marjie ThorntonAt a time when we have never been more aware of the horrors of animal abuse, the Government must act to outlaw this particularly barbaric practice.34502020-02-15T08:25:11.5943725Caroline Wright My Grandson died from DIPG it is no Rare it is heartbreaking and every child that is diagnosed with this suffers its inhumane and a disgrace that nothing has changed in over 60 years to treat DIPG . It has a huge impact on family having to watch their child die .34342020-02-15T09:22:34.07743726Jodie StewartMore awareness and a cure for DIPG34342020-02-15T09:27:13.8843727Caroline MorrisonFar too many children are getting cancers that are incurable, what is it that we are doing to cause this, there has to be a reason.34342020-02-15T09:29:28.3843728Lisa Clayton It is vital Governments fund research to help our most vulnerable cancer patients-the children. My thoughts are with all families who have suffered. 34342020-02-15T11:41:21.6343729Penny MacdonaldNot acceptable....Scotland is better than this!34502020-02-15T12:15:35.5943730Dolly JonesFar too many children are losing their lives to cancer34342020-02-15T17:06:05.7443731Ken Thomson If you have never heard of Parental Alienation (PA) these are some reasons why\r\nFamily law cases are heard in private recorded on camera to protect the privacy of the family. Only officers of the court, the parties to the case, legal representation, witnesses, expert witnesses etc. will be in the courtroom while the case is being heard.32992020-02-15T17:22:13.75743732Samantha KerrFalse allegations of domestic abuse are often used to initiate and coverup Parental Alienation in a relationship breakdown.\r\nParental Alienators who make false allegations and perpetrate PA do not want PA recognised as they may be prosecuted in future for offences.\r\nParental Alienation can be very subtle & often the perpetrator comes across as the Victim and a Good Parent.\r\nThis ensures the State Departments inability to cope with complexity of PA.\r\n32992020-02-16T08:06:28.89743733Samantha KerrIT IS WELL KNOWN in this field that generic therapies fail alienated children and families and that adapted therapies that fit the dynamic are those that demonstrate clear resolution of the psychological splitting that underpins parental alienation. 32992020-02-16T08:13:24.81743734Samantha KerrTherefore case specific models of commissioned intervention are those that are adapted to the therapy requirements of the child and family. To do otherwise is to risk further harming already abused children and parents.32992020-02-16T10:37:54.88343735Barbara Reid We have a right to choose our future path.34302020-02-16T22:04:13.16743736Nikki OrrI cant imagine going through this as a parent never mind a poor child 34342020-02-17T17:25:13.6743737Som KhareParental Alienation should be recognised by the judiciary across the world as a crime on children and adequate measures should be adopted to avoid it.32992020-02-18T13:14:58.7343738Tommy RobisonIn memory of Calum Speirs, Rothesay, Isle of Bute, to whom I am related. Calums legacy resulted in what is the ever growing Calums Cabin Charity34342020-02-18T19:10:58.02743739Andrew FraserPublic bodies, I would hope, have more sense than to pay more than lip service to this nonsense. There are (obviously) far more important things to do. Linguistic diversity? Wouldn't it be better to force Scots to speak (e.g.) Polish? (Of course, there is a hidden agenda in this most dishonest of Parliaments.)33932020-02-20T22:27:16.38743740Alexandru AlexaI currently manage a business in Silverburn Shopping Centre and have tried to appeal this as it is a high rate to pay for the turnover we have year on year.33842020-02-21T12:51:28.16343741Marion ScottThis is not acceptable practice. Scotland leads the way in so many humanitarian areas and this should be one of them.34502020-02-21T18:36:15.89743742Paul BellI would like to see Gaelic first then English second on place names. This helped myself in the Republic of Ireland with Irish history.33932020-02-22T19:56:16.74343743John PatrickAs with other issues pertaining to animal rights and welfare, Scotland's lawmakers are doing nothing effective to prevent this suffering.\r\n\r\nWe hope that the petition is successful, and that it prompts further legislative action applicable to the industry.\r\n\r\n\r\nJohn Patrick\r\n\r\nScotland for Animals\r\n\r\n(Charity SC039109)34502020-02-23T10:14:57.12343744Alexander GrayIt's barbaric. There really is no need for any other words, is there?\r\n34502020-02-23T15:01:14.21743747Anne BradleyNo new born animals in Scotland should be culled. this is horrific animal abuse on sentient beings.34502020-02-23T17:36:46.6343748Ali ThomsonIf you wouldn't do it to a puppy or a kitten you shouldn't be doing it to any other baby animals.34502020-02-23T21:16:12.14343749Christine LordThis is a totally abhorrent practice.34502020-02-23T21:22:40.28743750Anne Milne Not acceptable in any circumstances 34502020-02-24T15:17:19.2843751James MartinNot acceptable, Scotland has standards far higher than this despicable practice and should set an example for the rest of the world 34502020-02-24T17:58:58.78743752Lesley ShaleTotally unacceptable in 202034502020-02-25T20:27:06.95743753Henry Mowat RendallAgree34642020-02-25T20:41:05.58343754Gill SinclairTotally horrific34502020-02-26T09:22:24.1643755James BoyleThere has to be a good reason for killing an animal and there is no good reason for killing these chicks.34502020-02-26T09:53:54.6743756Victoria loganThe unnecessary and cruel slaughter of chicks is not a practice for civilised c34502020-02-26T09:57:52.09343757Linda GrierNot acceptable, however you look at it. Would we think twice if it was puppies or kittens? 34502020-02-27T08:19:20.2443762Jennifer SmithNot acceptable its cruel and horrible that it even exists. About time something is done about it. 34502020-02-28T09:40:24.06343764David Marshall ADS results in people not investing in property and making improvements .\r\nLBTT stopped us moving house due to the excessive taxation and thus local contractors missed out on improvements. I view it as a ill thought out greed tax.34222020-02-28T13:21:41.30343766Carol Wallace In the 21st century - this type of inhuman activity is totally unacceptable !!34502020-02-28T21:13:33.1143767Martin BakerParental Alienation is the single biggest threat to the psychological and emotional health of our nation's children. \r\nQuite simply parental alienation is child abuse. And it rips families apart. It is non gender specific in that it can be perpetrated by both women and men, both Mums and Dads.\r\nChildren alienated and separated from a parent often then become alienated in turn from that parents family, one half of their own family.\r\nIn my personal experience its not fit for purpose. The Scottish Parliament also needs to recognise that parental alienation can involve the alienating parent using false allegations of abuse or domestic violence against the other parent to coercively control the alienated parent. Womens Aid don't accept this fact, even when an alienated Mother is coercively controlled by an alienating Father. Parental Alienation needs to be recognised for the severe form of psychological and emotional abuse it is. Now.32992020-02-29T11:23:41.83343768Ian Anderew TullyHightly concerned that this Bill does not recognise any difference between constitutional matters and other referendum subjects. It seems to treat citizens and non-citizen residents at equa status, when EU legislation only secured that position for region decisions without National implications.\r\nFurther it allows a simple majoiry to decide all matters regardless of any constitutional implications.contrary to most international convention.34302020-03-03T19:07:53.05743771Jim McDaidThese are the issues that governments at Westminster, Holyrood and elsewhere should be actively pursuing.34562020-03-03T19:47:58.20343772Isobelanne Robertson This is beyond cruel. How can anyone can carry out such an sickening job. 34502020-03-03T19:53:31.31343773Isobelanne RobertsonThese babies are killed in a very cruel way. How anyone can take part in this cruelty is beyond my understanding. 34502020-03-04T19:12:48.7843774Dorothy OliverAnother slap in the face for Bo'ness.34522020-03-04T20:01:17.79743775Jacqueline harrisonShame we can't over turn the ineos decision considering the msp represented Aberdeen who had the casting vote 34522020-03-05T08:42:17.9343776CHARLES ARCHIBALDHaving seen the closure of the A904 between Grangemouth - Bo'ness after an appeal was launched by Ineos after the Falkirk Council elected to keep the road open34522020-03-05T13:52:13.74343777Elyse BrownOffenders families are innocent, they are victims too. Innocent children are being put at risk by having their address printed in the press - how is this in the public interest? Quite simply it is NOT. It must be made illegal in order to protect families and especially children whose very lives are being put at risk. I ask the Scottish Government to silence the press immediately! 34642020-03-06T07:58:18.17743778Jenny gilmour If there was a major accident or fatalities on the only other road into Bo'ness the town would be cut off as no public transport would be able to run x34522020-03-07T19:47:35.15743779Pete Preston Keep it open34522020-03-09T13:42:36.3243781Mike FenwickI comment as the Petitioner.\r\n\r\nThe Human Rights Act, referred to in the Petition establishes a base line against which the treatment of any individual may be established as correct or incorrect, it presupposes each individual should be accorded their rights on a equal basis.\r\n\r\nI am not a lawyer, but would ask the Petitions Committee to be aware of the legal precedents in support of that statement from these cases:\r\n\r\nR v Secretary of State for Education and Employment, Ex p Begbie, \r\n\r\nR - On the application of Gallaher Group Ltd and others v The Competition and Markets Authority, \r\n\r\nMatadeen v Pointu\r\n\r\nR - O'Brien v Independent Assessor\r\n\r\nAny departure from the equality of treatment of an individual when being addressed under judicial review must be treated with the greatest care, or be open to legal challenge, supported by legal precedent.\r\n\r\nPS: The restriction on the characters allowed in these posts prevents me from stating the legal cases as they should appear.34302020-03-10T11:50:35.26743782Caroline kellyEnd this now 34502020-03-13T01:10:27.0743784William McLeanIt is obviously a good idea .34642020-03-16T21:53:36.99743785Caroline MartinScott ish govt. Stand on the right side of history.\r\nRemember without B.D.S. Nelson Mandela would never have been freed. Glasgow was the first British city to name a street after him. Don't let down the people of Palestine whom he loved.34552020-03-18T05:38:39.33743786Steven GrossmanThe clause, "and those who trade with them" is to enable people to have an excuse to discriminate against Jews and people who believe in Israel's right to exist - a right that is an incontrovertible part of international law because Israel is a UN member state. \r\nAsserting such a spurious "right" is tantamount to giving legal cover to anti-Semites. Therefore, only an anti-Semite will support such a malicious and hostile clause. \r\nIf you want to boycott Israeli products, do so. But to boycott those who do not join you in that? It's illegitimate. \r\n34552020-03-18T07:55:35.1543787Ron TemudThe German Parliament declared BDS anti-Semitic. 34552020-03-18T11:36:54.69743788Matana RamatiBDS is an anti Semite organization that adopted strategic tactics of the Nazis. They spread hate and lies and do not look for any resolution or peace, they are looking to destroy the only Jewish state that exist, a state so smal it takes 67 hours drive frim north to East and 25 minutes frim East to west. Please do not let hate win. Stop BDS and outlaw their activity. Even Germany de laid them as anti Semite organization. 34552020-03-18T13:23:15.08743790Rachell FriedDoes no one in Scotland have anything better to do than foster hate against Israel? On devices using Israeli technology, when Israel will soon be marketing a coronavirus vaccine?34552020-03-18T20:24:46.7143791Teresa TrainorBDS is a hate movement that does nothing to contribute to a peaceful solution. BDS is linked to and supported by terrorist organisations. It should be illegal for public bodies and institutions to endorse BDS. 34552020-03-19T18:32:55.25343792Tim Michael DonnellyTo support the granting of freedom to any people should always be a right afforded to all humanity. To be able to protest against Apartheid states should be a human right for all.34552020-03-20T19:50:53.35743794Elena NicolThis is ridiculous. There should be no place in Scotland for racism. This veiled attempt to justify and legalize BDS is not acceptable34552020-03-21T11:45:57.37343795Anthony Buxton.I believe that governance in Scotland should be the prerogative of the Scottish Government.\r\nThis issue is about Human Rights. Our right to say that the breaking of international agreements is wrong and should not be defended for economic or political reasons. The attempt to accuse objectors to the apartheid policies of the Israeli state of antisemitism is part of that states policy to legitimise itself and needs to be challenged.34552020-03-21T12:00:51.543796Anthony BuxtonIt is simply not right to punish the families of defendants for being related to them. Damage to the family has already been done by the defendant and the state. It should not be compounded by the press for financial gain.34642020-03-22T10:17:33.7243797Gordon WilsonThe case for action against Israeli government treatment of Palestinians is clear from evidence from Edinburgh Action for Palestine. It is as important as action agaisnt apartheid south africa was34552020-03-22T10:20:35.3343798Gordon WilsonThere is a very strong pressure from Israeli interests to suppress fight back from Palestinians against israeli government presecution and Scottish Government must resist it34552020-03-25T14:00:50.34743799Anatoliusz IvanovI used to work for BP Chemicals from the 1970's when it was a very much larger operation. BP would have liked the road closed back then but they accepted the fact that the road was there prior to them and that took precedence. There was no great inconvenience back then, no hold up for traffic. Any concerns about public safety should not be used in any discussions as unlike decades ago there is far less risk of any public danger. In the past there was far more hazardous chemicals that there is today and today's safety standards are far higher than they used to be. The only reason for Ineos wanting closure of this road is that they can reduce manpower at the gates.34522020-03-26T14:34:16.20743800Murray TaylorAn atrocious decision that may well have severe safety implications34692020-03-26T20:17:2143801Susan Macaulay The thought of cutting back our air traffic control is very worrying. It cannot happen !34692020-03-26T20:51:01.1343802Irene morrisonAll the very best with this 34692020-03-27T11:27:29.5943803Alan BewsWhilst I understand, and agree with, the need for modenisation including Surveillance and CAS, the "REMOTE" part of the programme offers NO increase in safety..in fact quite the opposite!! 34692020-03-27T18:07:14.39343804Pete WalkerThe Wick airport is a lifeline for so many in the community. The Scottish government have failed to invest in Caithness for many years and a potential airport closure will be another major service to go, along with others. The government should step in and act NOW, this would protect jobs, help the local economy and still give the local community the needed service. Caithness is becoming more and more cut-off from the rest of Scotland.34692020-03-27T19:00:41.4443805Neil LyonCentralisation is not the solution. 34692020-03-28T10:45:05.20743806Kathleen MacleodThis service needs to be kept local34692020-03-28T12:45:00.93343807John MorrisonThese proposals will have a devastating effect on our local communities and is not under "Island Proofing" as set out by the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018.34692020-03-28T13:21:30.67343808Chrissie MacaskillDone34692020-03-28T16:39:34.48343809Seonaidh MacDonaldSeriously flawed idea in my opinion and the timing of it is all wrong. One wonders as to the REAL motives and indeed 'agenda' behind this proposed change? Island economies are fragile at the best of times and employment sits at the core of this. Proposals like this do nothing to mitigate that fragility and should be resisted robustly. 34692020-03-28T21:29:44.03743810Colin BrandCost cutting exercise, safety a long way second.34692020-03-28T21:31:50.13343811Colin DavidsonLosing this service indicates we, as a country, are going back into the dark ages and that this government will not support local communities34692020-03-29T07:03:02.0743812Donald MacPhersonOur islands are fragile enough. Population decline is really worrying. The ATMS project is not helping with this. 34692020-03-29T15:04:03.57743817Loriana PauliDon't centralise. Jobs too important for island life34692020-03-30T09:55:52.9143818Marjorie langThe plane is a life line for the community 34692020-03-31T13:17:37.70343819Vic ThomasEvery time you close a school, business, facility etc involving jobs in a small local community on an island, remote or rural area, you further marginalise vulnerable communities. When this reaches a critical mass you would need to close the island, village or area & relocate to the areas your centrailsineg to. Is this nthe Scotland you want? Its not the Scotland i want. 34692020-03-31T14:34:58.2743820Alistair EastonI am far from convinced that the telecommunications links between Inverness and the Islands can be 100% secure.\r\nI also strongly object to the ATC jobs being taken from the islands and centralised in Inverness. 34692020-03-31T15:11:58.60343821Sue WailooThis needs to be looked at again . We don't have reliable connectivity yet in Shetland, we have weather events unlike those on the mainland, we are very exposed, what about emergencies. This is our lifeline service and proposals are unsafe 34692020-03-31T16:58:28.0443822Roy LongmuirIf the communications facilities are robust enough for HIAL to consider remote operations then the centre should be in Sumburgh, thus creating much needed jobs and showing government commitment to helping island communities create jobs34692020-03-31T17:20:11.2243823David MillerCentralisation does not enhance safety and will result in a loss of flexibility compared with on site controllers. Communities need good quality jobs and reliable infrastructure in order to be sustainable. This project offers no benefits in any of these areas.34692020-04-01T03:09:11.38743824Michael BiltonThe islands of Scotland ARE an integral part of the country. Saving money where passenger safety is concerned is shocking. Often planes in these islands can land in difficult conditions when line of sight control is available on the ground. Remote control is farcical in the islands, a truly idiotic idea. You are going to get many many fights turned back for no good reason and possibly bankrupt local airlines. The other possibility is a crash caused by a mistaken remote decision leading to many fatalities. The litigation would be horrendous. Drop this mad idea now. I have been visiting Shetland for 35 years, and Orkney, Fair Isle and Benbecular for even longer. Stop now. Stop making people deeply anxious. Scottish Island culture is unique in the world. Don't ruin their economies like this.34692020-04-01T11:19:57.46743825Peter LongI really can't see how this is societal progress. Taking keys regional jobs, and centralising them. Sacrificing safety in the name of cost saving. The costs of air traffic control should be paid for by the passengers. We do not need to lower the costs of air travel to promote more planes in the air. Surely there is not a good enough reason to push this through beyond saving some money.34692020-04-01T13:21:45.37743826Phyllis WarnerLeave it open34522020-04-01T13:41:49.6943827Robert PaddockAs a 20 year veteran IFR controller and ATC Automation Specialist, I'll be the first to agree that technological advancements are allowing some great new innovations in aviation. However I also believe that moving too quickly on remote tower automation could be very damaging to the industry. Once you remove the on field human intervention, you reduce your capacity to react to unplanned events and operational irregularities. Not to mention the decrease in pilot confidence in and around your airport. Too much too fast HIAL, take this back to the drafting table, for everyone's peace of mind.34692020-04-01T16:06:01.8243828George Rendall The only way to change things.34552020-04-01T18:26:39.23743829Lynsay YoungWe need better access to healthcare in cumbernauld34722020-04-01T18:37:05.15343830Elizabeth Ann GallacherCumbernauld is a very large town now and still growing its shocking we dont have our own local hospital instead having to travel far to airdrie or glasgow, not easy if you dont have a car!! 34722020-04-01T19:08:13.45343831Jolanta HadzicAs a Jewish girl all, I have to say that giving special privileges to apartheid Israel and endlessly covering their crimes do not benefit us Jews living in Scotland. We are sick and tired of our religion and identity being used as a human shield for Israel. We demand justice for Palestinians and right to boycott Israel which do not speak for us neither represent us.34552020-04-01T19:22:31.60743832Marga McCutcheonCumberland should have a hospital , the site that was offered free should be accepted.Frankly I don't understand the reluctance to at least carry out a feasibility study. It's outrageous that residents of this town have to travel to East Kilbride and Wishaw. My personal experience is after having attended Monklands opthalmology clinic for 5 years .due to shortage of opthalmologists was given appointments for Hairmyers I after attending on 2 occasions demanded I return to Monklands. It makes sense to build new hospital in Cumbernauld34722020-04-01T19:37:08.01343833LORAINE BOWIEI believe that Cumbernauld should have its own hospital. This is an enormous town and would also create a lot of jobs here. I do not drive and at present the only bus that takes me to our hospital which is Monklands is an early service. 34722020-04-01T19:56:05.90743834Susan RobsonOur Scottish NHS needs all the help possible. 34722020-04-01T20:15:56.05743835Catherine mcwilliamsbI live in Cumbernauld and it has long struggled with lack of a&e services and out of hours it would greatly benefit the town to have these services in the town itself 34722020-04-01T20:19:14.93343836Catherine McWilliamsI have lived in Cumbernauld for 47 years and Cumbernauld has long since struggled with lack of a&e and out of hours facilities it would greatly benefit the town to have them 34722020-04-01T23:18:52.1343837sandra bowfieldDon't leave the people of Cumbernauld with out proper access to hospital facilities. Out of hours walk in centre would be ideal if there was not an actual hospital in the vicinity of Cumbernauld.\r\n34722020-04-02T02:02:20.9843838Walter GreenExcellent idea. 34722020-04-02T02:03:33.6743839Walter GreenExcellent idea. 34722020-04-02T08:40:50.31743840David McDonald Think it should be looked at. Smaller localized hospitals might be the answer. 34722020-04-02T11:38:59.28343841Brenda McLaughlinMy mobility is restricted and it cost me £50 to travel to Wishaw Hospital for CT SCAN. which I needed following chemo. 34722020-04-02T11:53:44.62743842Michael BennettWe are currently living in a world where hindsight would have been a wonderful thing, given the pandemic. Let us avoid having to repeat this mantra when the very obvious issues with the 'Air Traffic Management Strategy Project' come home to roost. Act now, not when it is too late.34692020-04-02T15:44:49.5143844Peter ShearerThis plan is totally unnecessary, unlikely to bring any improvement to services and is damaging to the local communities and economies.34692020-04-02T19:04:40.3143845Donald R MacDonaldJobs count just as much in Benbecula etc as in Inverness.34692020-04-02T20:20:44.94743846Kenny Mackenzie Cumbernauld should have its own hospital, as it is the largest town in the Monklands catchment area. Every area should have an out of hours service within easy reach.34722020-04-02T21:45:56.91343847Janice RobertsonWe need our own out of hours and hospital.34722020-04-02T23:55:53.83343848Catherine Thomson Hospital badly needed in cumbernauld.mo lands is to far in emergency situations.34722020-04-03T01:02:11.88343849Joanne MackayCumbernauld is in desperate need of a hospital. With the population of the town ever growing, and the demand for easy access to health care provisions for all services users growing with it. It is vital for our community that we have this access without the added stress and worry of transport issues, and the nearest hospital being an hour away that will see the residents of Cumbernauld. 34722020-04-03T08:12:50.51743850Geraldine lorimerDue to the size and population of Cumbernauld we definitely should have access to local hospital or at least an A&E department34722020-04-03T11:41:30.79743851Rosie HutchisonCumbernauld has grown so big a a town and really need a hospital on site34722020-04-05T11:54:50.6543852Frank PoleSumburgh airport frequently has some of the worst weather of any airport in UK, with gales, rain and low cloud in the winter and fog in the summer. The terrain surrounding the airport adds additional risk, especially to fixed wing aircraft.\r\n\r\nAircraft accidents usually are due to a chain of events coming together, often likened to the holes in a Swiss cheese lining up. If an aircraft has a serious malfunction on a day of evil weather, and the proposed remote Air Traffic comms at Inverness go down at the critical moment, an aircraft emergency could turn into a disaster. \r\n\r\nThe HIAL must be persuaded to abandon this risky policy which is a real threat to a lifeline service.34692020-04-05T14:38:31.08743853yvonne bryanslow drip towards bringing service in a downward spiral for the islands travel34692020-04-05T14:54:27.9743855Elizabeth Davidson I strongly object on the basis of safety, reliability and the loss of local jobs34692020-04-05T15:20:53.8943856Fiona CelliWhat plans are in place should the internet connection break down? This is not uncommon in remote areas.34692020-04-05T16:03:14.74743857Allan Edgar Recognition , pay rise, free parking, cleaners re-enrolled into NHS, to much to mention. 34722020-04-05T16:47:16.12743858Miss BERNADETTE McMahonYes I think that the town is big enough in population to have a small hospital and the out of hours service needs reinstated I have attended a meeting with the chief of the health board and we were all agreeing that the Monklands hospital needs to be rebuilt in gartcosh as it is easier for commuting and has plenty space for the new purpose built hospital. Since this meeting it has changed dramatically the health board now wants to choice another new sight. The suggestion that it should b a small hospital to be built in Cumbernauld was not taken seriously.34722020-04-05T18:02:15.60743859John GrayCentralising ATC makes the system less resilient. Jobs are far more valuable located in remote communities, & especially such highly skilled types.34692020-04-05T22:49:15.93743860Ingirid Windwick JollyToo many vital services are being centralised to one or two centres in Britain with loss of local knowledge and observations34692020-04-06T09:38:08.6343862Ian MacLeodInsane idea taken with no regard for safety whatsoever. Madness!34692020-04-06T11:09:45.5543863Matthew LeggeI think the experience of coronavirus shows us that we cannot invest too much in our health service and that further provision of hospital beds in a distributed fashion is not over-provision or wasteful or inefficient, but actually a sensible precaution against the next pandemic (which globalisation and expanding human populations make almost inevitable).34722020-04-06T12:33:05.9243864Linda HamiltonConfidence, security, flexibility, local nous, employment and sense of worth in a tight knit community. Anything else is less.34692020-04-06T13:22:22.2443865VIVIENNE WILSONPlease, for all our safety, halt the transfer to Inverness 34692020-04-07T12:07:42.77343866Angus MacDonald Absolutely diabolical idea no regards towards people's safety madness of the first degree 34692020-04-07T17:19:22.34743868Margaret TomkinsAll action that stops democracy is unacceptable 34552020-04-07T18:02:23.24343869Martin MurphyAnti Zionism is not Anti Semitism. \r\nUphold civil and political democracy and freedom of speech in Scotland. You can not censor the people in their support of Palestinian struggle against apartheid. 34552020-04-07T22:33:15.78743870Amira Hunter BDS is a peaceful form of protest against Israeli state terrorism and the violation of human rights against the Palestinian people. Organisations and individuals should be allowed the right to peaceful protest in solidarity with those who are oppressed. 34552020-04-08T15:20:25.10743871Caroline KenneilPEO01803 fundamentally relates to the local participation of 'reasonable people', through their local public aurthorities and institutions, (these designed for the common good), to proportionately express their considerations and ultimately local decisions applied to all manner of discriminatory and harmful practices or omissions conducted by powerful 'Appointees in position of power', by governments or by the law enforcing legal sector. \r\nThis Petition is designed to protect individuals of differing religions, 'classes', races, animals and the environment from the ongoing abuse of powers and breaches of international law. Persons in positions of power often lose their proportionate, common sense and standards of natural justice. \r\nThe established civilised test for Reasonableness is: "what or how would the reasonable person consider: vis xxx". \r\nConsumers have a right to be properly informed and to make reasonable decisions. The Reasonable persons are us and our local participating representatives. The Globe is not a closed system, but what take place in one part now effects another. Where our powerful 'Law Enforcers' have lost their common sense, act in conflicts of interest, we have a right to express our concerns, and when not listened to, we have a participatory right to exclude our collective local participation in such errors to boycot the damaging and harmful practices or omissions through our local representatives. \r\nAdditional to being able to hold powerful and damaging Interests to reasonable account, when people feel unjustly unheard and damaged, then, they may turn to collective violence. \r\nSo 'To Boycot' is to enable a reasonable and effective 'on the ground voice'. \r\nMost people want a voice for justice, honest, fair and equitable dealings be they tax payers, students, old age pensioners or other. \r\n 34552020-04-09T13:44:08.82343873Ian RichmondNow we see the true importance of Healthcare & Hospitals. Never again should the NHS suffer funding cuts if fact the NHS should be given even more money, more staff and more facilities in future. This is my reason for backing this petition. 34722020-04-14T21:24:57.83343875Stuart SmithThis proposal is ridiculous. If it is such a great idea then why dont we turn this idea on its head and "control" HIALs airports from the islands? After all Scotlands political foundations are entwined in supporting the remote regions. Get a grip HIAL!34692020-04-15T14:53:52.9743876Paul ShorttEthics. Freedom of speech. We will NEVER be silenced.\r\n\r\nThe fact that Scotland isn't even an option in 'Country' says more than you realize.34552020-04-15T18:15:32.70743877Jim McElenySafety before profit. Scottish Government must get involved and engage with unions particularly Prospect, who know have members with skills and expertise in this field.34692020-04-15T19:02:57.90343878Maggie Bowden BDS is one of the few actions people can take against the cruelty of Zionism. While antisemitism is a crime anti Zionism is a right and a duty if you care about your fellow human beings. 34552020-04-18T09:54:44.70343879Caroline KenneilThe issue of consumers and Public Authorities direct action is important, because often Public Authorities higher organisations are not properly accountable for their errors, and or are a part of an unhealthy system, demanding the delivery inferior and damaging services and goods. The issues may be too cumberson and interlnked to maneuver away from a poor pubic policy decisions. The issues are not confined to the Human Rights protected classes, but related to any goods or services to the public which the informed publicand Authorities consider damaging to the public good. \r\nAt moments of great change, it is the People on the ground who often advise those in power for the collective good, as to matters in need of change. As stated it is hard to change an unhealthy entrenched culture in Public Bodies and institutions. \r\nFor instance, currently the public bodies appear unaware that there are very serious and major problems concerning global Monetary Market's subprime overleverage of both the Insurance Industries and the Pensions Industries. If the public and Public Bodiess become aware that change is needed, they will then be able to avert disaster. Thus it is wise and important that the 'on the grouund' public, and their own Public Authorities have a direct voice to vote with their feet for the Common good prior to real harm, and to ensure proper progress and a healthy culture. 34552020-04-18T10:20:15.5843880Tam Dean BurnAs it was for the previous anti-apartheid movement in solidarity with the people of South Africa, BDS is a peaceful, democratic means to support the rights of the Palestinian people and it has been their expressed call for BDS that underpins this solidarity. 34552020-04-20T17:47:11.49743881Marie shearerI believe this is a safety issue and should be abandoned. It will also remove high paid jobs on the islands34692020-04-20T17:54:42.72343882Andrew MackintoshCentralising services not for efficiency but to allow closer political control. 34692020-04-21T11:34:12.6243883Calvin AllenHow long must remote communities continue to suffer from this outside-in perspective which takes away the services which help bind us together?34692020-04-23T10:13:28.37343885Susan MoffatIt is essential that the public have the right to boycott goods, services and companies which are in or invest in Israel whilst Israel flout International law and occupies Palestinian territory.34552020-04-23T10:45:06.8343886Ian MasonThis is really important. Israel is committing crimes in front of our eyes but the UK media ignore it all.34552020-04-23T13:06:15.7443888Aminah Frank It wasn't wrong for Jews to encourage a boycott of Germany in support of German Jews in the 30s. It wasn't wrong to boycott South Africa to end apartheid. So how can it be wrong to boycott Israel until they end their apartheid policies and restore civil rights to Palestinians?34552020-04-23T13:08:44.22343889Haq GhaniIt's duty of every humane human to support human rights of Palestinians and oppose apartheid of illegal oppressive Israeli regime.34552020-04-23T15:51:35.70743890Mary McGregorBDS is an important act of solidarity with those living under illegal occupation. 34552020-04-23T16:17:00.55343891Jane FrereSilence in the face of violence is to be part of it. I will always maintain moral duty and fight on the side of justice and human rights for all people. Its unacceptable that I need to sign this, but I do out of principle.34552020-04-23T18:23:35.80743892Margaret TomkinsI'm appalled by the treatment of Palestinian people.34552020-04-23T19:12:06.72343893Eddie HunterBDS is a valid method of protesting the treatment of the Palestinians by the Israeli regime.34552020-04-23T22:40:45.843894John HilleyAs in the case of global resistance to apartheid South Africa, BDS is a legitimate expression of solidarity with the Palestinian people against Israel's illegal occupation and apartheid policies. All civil and public bodies should be free to support that worthy cause.34552020-04-23T22:50:45.34343895Paul HorthIn addition to the loss of jobs in remote communities it will introduce large areas of controlled airspace in remote areas of Scotland that will impact General Aviation in particular.34692020-04-24T21:59:33.1643896Christine McKennaAs a regular user of hospital and out of hours. The cumbernaul d area is badly served it is also the largest town in the area and it is abysmal at times trying to be seen. Shyness it been decided that gartcosh is not a suitable site is purely down to politics. Attending out of hours in the back of beyond and being greatest Hairmyers is a disaster waiting to happen if love to know the numbers of deaths of folk who don't make it there. Time cumbernauld. And Kilsyth were given a way in their health after all they pay the largest amount of council tax in th e area. 34722020-05-01T13:57:40.68343897Maria Sondergaard HansenWith Covid-19 and strike action - this semester and last - I have had approximately 8 weeks worth of classes out of 22. £6500 for that. 34982020-05-02T15:13:10.91343898Brian RobertsonWe should be trying to decentralise highly paid jobs from the Central Belt. This is doing the opposite.34692020-05-02T23:36:18.63743899Josh ElliottAs an English Student at Dundee, I'm paying 9.25k. Education is a service I pay for, yet I'm not recieving any service. Scottish and EU students do not pay any fees. It is completly unfair and is taking advantage of RUK and International students by not providing them with an adequate product. 34982020-05-05T11:52:02.05743901Frances Valente - ClerkLerwick Community Council has serious concerns about the safety issues relating to the remote air traffic control service that is proposed by HIAL.34692020-05-08T17:10:54.10343902Meredith Fuller With COVID 19 and Strike action this semester alone, I lost approx 7-8 weeks of teaching. Additionally, as an international student, even after classes and exams were cancelled, I was required to continue to make payments last month and this month (around £2000), despite no assignments, classes, lectures or new material. 34982020-05-15T19:30:36.8643903Alan PurvesThis action is unacceptable. Does this mean GDp's can select which bits of the SDR we would like to abide by?!35062020-05-16T08:03:41.59343904ziena harrisWe as dentists were doing all what we can since studying days , through training life and after graduation to keep the NHS standing upright but now we feel that there is no support to our career.\r\nWe have the fear of unknown future and what other aspects that the NHS will withdraw its support from 35062020-05-16T08:11:06.0943905David EdwardsPublic service employees, especially NHS and community care staff, are undervalued and we have all seen how crucial their roles are during the Covid-19 pandemic.\r\nIt is long overdue to ensure that their remuneration is appropriate to the service to our community they provide.35022020-05-16T11:55:07.8543906John E.SeenanI am ashamed that as one of the wealthiest economies on the planet, it takes a pandemic of this magnitude to make us aware of the low remuneration and poor terms of employment afforded those maintaining the essential services most of us depend on. The very least we can do, to begin the process of remedying this disparity, is to sign this petition. Once the pandemic has receded and attention turns to balancing the economy, we must continue to ensure that the vital role these people fulfill in our society is recognised appropriately. 35022020-05-17T09:34:03.79343907Marc BinghamYes35062020-05-17T10:28:57.16343908Asha KashyapI would be grateful if the CPDA costs are reinstated as this pays in part to some of the expensive good hands on course that we have to undertake to upskill ourselves. 35062020-05-19T21:06:53.5143909BRIAN SEENANIt has taken a pandemic for the Government to release money that it claimed was not available. Money is clearly not an issue, it's time it was used to protect the NHS and the dedicated people who work in it.35022020-05-21T09:51:04.34743910Stewart MartinA truly worthwhile proposal35022020-05-23T13:07:14.73343911Hilda WilsonIf the NHS had been any less capable during this pandemic, the Covid virus would have claimed many more lives than it has done. ALL employed by the NHS and in related public service posts have risked their own lives to help save others - they need to be acknowledged and appreciated with a suitable pay increase, NOT a cut in wages and numbers!35022020-06-03T16:42:08.57743913Ian WilsonCommonwealth Flag every time.34512020-06-05T16:27:52.76743914Nora CaseyNo - we should dismantle the British Empire.34512020-06-06T00:06:48.69343915Carol AcuttI do not agree with this at all. Scotland has ancient historic links with Europe, and has benefitted enormously from its support in recent years. It will hopefully become an independent country within Europe before too long. The European flag should continue to be flown34512020-06-06T17:40:03.38743916Jo HaythornthwaiteWe should remunerate these people properly35022020-06-07T11:48:54.55343917William GillespieI strongly support this initiative. The sums invoved have already been dwarfed by UK expenditure on Covid-19.35022020-06-07T20:32:06.7243918Craig HendryI agree that NHS, Social workers and Care Home staff are undervalued and merit an increase in their income BUT I think the situation in Scotland and the rest of the UK could have been better managed and there should be less manipulation of the data by governments. The biggest mistake made by the UK and Scottish Parliaments was to ignore the findings and fail to publish the result of studies into dealing with a pandemic. 35022020-06-08T11:22:43.51743919Joan BensonProper remuneration for the care and selfless dedication these people provide day in day out to protect the health of our nation is the only way forward. 35022020-06-08T11:55:41.68743920Malcolm BellThe Covid Pandemic highlights the incredible dangers our NHS and care workers face .Pay them accordingly. Get the priorities right !!! 35022020-06-09T15:13:19.37343921Gerry CondronCare Home staff are grossly underpaid - the funds allocated to care for our old folks from Scottish Government are totally inadequate and do not meet running costs - resulting in low wages for hard-working dedicated employees, 35022020-06-12T16:00:06.35343923Bryan John MorganMore than public service folk that are vital. I am not supporting this until private employees eg cleaners and security are included.35022020-06-12T16:00:13.19743924Eleanor AppsI feel strongly that we should keep the EU flag. I still feel more connected to Europe than the Commonwealth.34512020-06-18T09:21:36.16743925Dean WightNo keep the European Union flag flying ! .Respect the vote. Scotland voted to remain and not to try and resurrect the Empire.34512020-06-18T16:37:48.3943926Walter HayYep all for it 100%.35262020-06-18T22:32:33.5543928MRS AILSA HAIGAll sports need an independent body that they can turn to for assistance.35262020-06-18T22:35:58.29743930MRS AILSA HAIGI believe it us in the interest of every sport to have an independent body that they can turn to for unbiased support and assistance.35262020-06-18T22:54:08.19743931Andy SmithThis is long overdue for sport.35262020-06-19T11:22:37.73343932Ken & Pauline RichardsI support this petition35262020-06-21T12:17:06.99743933Noanie HeffronI do not agree with this at all. The notion of the British Commonwealth is colonialist and outdated whereas our links with the EU are ongoing despite Scotland being taken out of the EU against our majority vote of 60%+ to Remain. Please keep flying the EU flag.34512020-06-24T20:14:54.11743934David NelsonToo many people who should not be coaching children are 35262020-06-25T14:27:50.33343936Sean DowdAfrican Scottish history should be taught in schools35372020-06-25T16:16:21.4143937Naomi SpiritNew housing developments and roads routinely chop down ancient trees and ancient woodland areas. These are not able to be recreated elsewhere and we are losing important diversity. Ancient trees are the most powerful that we have in terms of helping remove CO2 from the environment. We must do everything in our power to save them from further harm. We can't simply plant to replace what is lost, it just doesn't work that we. We need to instead work around nature even if that is "inconvenient".35252020-06-25T17:05:57.3743938Linda JenkinsonProud to sign this petition 35252020-06-26T08:44:42.48343941Peter MacDonald Slowly but surely Scotland's ancient woodlands are being swallowed and "tamed" by a combination of "creeping development" and their submission to "leisure" amenities. It is of fundamental importance that this ancient natural resource is conserved and protected and allowed to prosper. 35252020-06-26T11:39:47.96743943George TahVery very important 35372020-06-26T11:54:54.3343944Christopher BairdI believe schools should teach Afro-Scottish history.35372020-06-26T15:07:11.77743945Leo FloresYes, I agree.35372020-06-26T15:21:27.5343946Elizabeth Oritsejolomi DudleySo important 35372020-06-26T16:02:46.843947Stephen CowleyThere is a danger of political indoctrination in using ethno-historical narratives in teaching materials. There should be a stress on critical analysis to reduce this, including critical methods of analysing narratives and original documents..35372020-06-26T16:37:59.49343949Chinwe NnajiI'll like national curriculum to be changed to involve Afro-Scottish history35372020-06-26T21:41:35.45743950Ann WanjaThe focus should not only be focused on slave trade but inclusive of the wider political,economic and social cultural dynamics particularly where there are links with Scotland35372020-06-26T22:22:19.77743951Michaela Damasus ritucciJust happy someone is listening to BAME teachers we just want to contribute.35372020-06-27T00:42:12.56343952Nora WoodBrilliant exactly the direction we should be going in35372020-06-27T10:33:13.93343953Elizabeth JenningsEducation should be inclusive and Scotland should be actively proud of its heritage.35372020-06-27T11:04:09.52343954Helen HamiltonWell done 35372020-06-27T11:45:14.74743955robert loveOverhaul the whole education system due to the overwhelming disparity between schools in affluant areas and poor areas 10 years plus of failed education policy.35372020-06-27T12:32:52.35343956Regina HopesMuch needed programme in the Scottish Curriculum. \r\n35372020-06-27T12:56:44.743957Eoin William MontgomeryThe history of black people in Scotland is as much a part of our history as the history of white people in Scotland is.35372020-06-27T13:17:10.57343958Christine CouttsIts important to fully understand our history, good and bad, to fully understand our present and to work for a better future. 35372020-06-27T13:17:33.31343959Calum Crosbie This would increase awareness of the value of African cultural heritage and its subjugation by the west thereby challenging racism within our society. 35372020-06-27T14:51:06.69743960Sean GrieveThe Scots have many long and very positive connections with Africans, as confirmed by Mr Thabo Mvuyelwa Mbeki when he addressed the Scottish Parliament. I do not think the current reactions to an American police officer should be allowed to undermine or overwrite that. \r\n\r\nCatholics, Jews, Trans, Fat, Women, Men and Old people have all been discriminated against and verbally and physically abused in many settings, simply because of what they are. Any new curriculum that focused solely on Afro-Scottish history, to address Ms Eunice Olumide's beliefs, would appear politically inspired and selective, leading to even more ill feeling. How could we explain to the 60,000 domestic abuse victims who seek help annually that their ongoing suffering is of less educational value than Afro-Scottish history? \r\n\r\nI think Afro-Scottish history could be part of a much larger subject that examines how we should treat other human beings at home and around the world, and how our children could make more ethical choices. Looking at the benefits we all currently enjoy from Chinese slave labour and political prisoners, while we completely ignore the human and ecological cost, it would seem incongruous, backward looking and racist to focus only on any past benefits from Africa.35372020-06-27T15:03:36.8343962Cameron Gazzola BlackOur Scotland has many faces and many shapes and colours. They must all be reflected.35372020-06-27T15:19:41.0143963Angela ReillyI wholeheartedly agree with this proposition and would like it noted that it is WELL overdue.35372020-06-27T16:01:00.80743964Linda Gibson This is an area of spectacular beauty. It is a very healing area. So calm and welcoming. The trees and walks are part of our heritage. 35252020-06-27T19:47:32.5143965Yvonne ShawOnce they are gone they are gone forever35252020-06-27T21:18:42.25743966George ShanksWhy just Afro-Scottish history? What about eg Asian Scottish history? Make it all encompassing and make the curriculum include BAME-Scottish history. 35372020-06-28T10:45:20.06343967Angela HeaneyYes I believe that the national curriculum should include afro-scottish history35372020-06-28T12:07:23.90343968Michael ReidEducation will stamp out ignorance 35372020-06-28T12:58:44.8843969Jayne FinchYes - absolutely. History should be inclusive of everyone and not just from one ethnic point of view. 35372020-06-28T14:13:02.15743970Roger FerdinandIn England there is 2.4% by area of ancient woodland left. We need to act to avoid falling further behind.35252020-06-28T15:13:57.5343971Soraya BishopFinally!35372020-06-28T17:32:56.0243973Ireoluwa ArowoloI feel that the full truth behind black history Should be taught more as well as other minorities 35372020-06-28T17:54:27.8843974Fiona GardnerAncient woodland is too precious to lose under the developers axe. 35252020-06-28T18:08:15.24343976Val RobinsonProtect Scotland from overdevelopment from large corporations. Ancient forests are already under threat35252020-06-28T20:45:35.8543977Garry haldaneThis is a very important move to help area dictate tacism35372020-06-28T20:54:21.64743978Naseem AkhtarAgree35372020-06-28T21:05:10.9143979Pat DoranScottish history and modern studies should include recognition of how the white population currently benefit from the dreadful treatment of black and minority populations. And how our streets, buildings and parks are named after the slave owners and oppressors. But also how what was regarded as perfectly acceptable and reasonable behaviour then is now rightly illegal and immoral. And whilst we can't hold our predecessors to the standards of today, we can and should change our futures. 35372020-06-28T21:09:08.38343980Fiona JamiesonInformation on all aspects of our history should be available to all school age children to provide a rounded view of how our nation was shaped.35372020-06-28T21:09:15.14743981Tania Pramschufer So important to start somewhere and this new addition to the curriculum will help educate and enrich. 35372020-06-28T21:34:41.02743982Cameron BoyleI deeply support all efforts to clarify the role the United Kingdom carried out in the Atlantic Slave Trade as well as other global atrocities in order to rectify the false image often portrayed in glorifying it's quest for global wealth at the fatal expense of others.35372020-06-28T23:13:20.78743983Sean LambInclude british colonialism 35372020-06-29T06:25:24.4243984Samba SeneLooking forward to seeing more Africans in the Scottish Parlement and Goverment.35372020-06-29T07:58:51.35343986Emily MnyayiThis is a huge gap in our history and should be taught 35372020-06-29T08:44:50.76743987Esther WrightAs a teacher I feel that it is extremely important that our schemes of work reflect the diversity of our communities. 35372020-06-29T10:09:01.85743988Thomas Eric We need change in our education system. 35372020-06-29T10:37:01.15743989Christina BellWe can no longer white wash our curriculum. It is time for schools to teach out true past and how is systemic racism is engrained in our society, in order for next generations to be educated, informed and actively anti racist in life. Change is now.35372020-06-29T12:38:48.5843990margaret mukundwaIts very important for children to learn proper history of what happened to black people and where the wealth of this country came from35372020-06-29T12:55:01.64743991Linda NovickI find solace in the woods in my country, the USA. Without woods and wild places the animals have no place to go. People should protect these places by legislation. We don't want a world that is completely paved over, without a bird song left. During Covid-19, the woods of Massachusetts have kept me sane. I believe we must save woodlands for the animals and future human generations.35252020-06-29T13:23:53.4943992Janine RowbothamBullying and the idea of superiority by Sport Governing Bodies needs to stop. There has to be somewhere independent for all involved in sport to be able to turn to. Bearing in mind a lot of people are volunteers and the majority of participants are not professionals so will not have the support that professional participants have. SGB staff are paid. Without the volunteers sports would not run.35262020-06-29T15:04:27.7643993Debbie O'Hara I am tired of local and National (Scotland and UK) councillors daing to listen and act on the conservation agenda, despite the strong voices of local, national and global populations.\r\nThis needs to change as a matter of urgency.\r\nOn our doorstep we are opposing development that will be detrimental to ancient woodland, wildlife habitat and endangered and all species.\r\nFinancial speculation should NEVER be put before conservation.35252020-06-29T16:30:29.12743996Funmi AkanmuThis is a very important topic for focused consideration. In order to see an end to racial discrimination and systemic shortcomings in the area of diversity and inclusion of African people and our place in history we need to start by giving accurate information of such through education and curriculum. 35372020-06-29T17:16:26.11743997Lauren wyper Well Done Eunice35372020-06-29T20:00:09.90743998Ranaa AhmedIt is important to teach about slavery and colonialism and the part Britain had to play. I also feel that pupils should be taught about the Palestinian-Israeli conflict stretching back to 1896 so that they have an understanding of what is happening in the Middle East. This is an important world issue and it is a failure of the Education system that most young people do not have a clue what it's all about. 35372020-06-29T20:03:15.01743999Ranaa Ahmed It is important to teach about slavery and colonialism and the part Britain had to play. I also feel that pupils should be taught about the Palestinian-Israeli conflict stretching back to 1896 so that they have an understanding of what is happening in the Middle East. This is an important world issue and it is a failure of the Education system that most young people do not have a clue what it's all about. 35372020-06-29T23:54:30.7744002Robbie BaldThe woodlands here in Scotland are very close to my heart so I want them protected fully 35252020-06-30T00:06:08.07744003Robbie BaldThe part about this petition that got me was the prejudice part I will never tolerate people being prejudice towards others here in Scotland that will not be tolerated here that is why i signed this petition 35262020-06-30T08:51:05.07344004Bella KerrPlease listen to the earth and save our woodlands for the future and for all 35252020-06-30T09:18:10.96344005Julie MartinLeaf them alone35252020-06-30T10:31:12.3244006wright gregsonconvince (?) the holders of large grouse moors to allow and encourage the return of the native forests over large areas of their holdings (and tax those who dont cooperate.35252020-06-30T10:45:28.8744008Ruth GotoAfrican Scottish history is very important for us all to understand where we came from.35372020-06-30T12:38:53.0444009Carole AlubaidPlease teach our young people the awful truth of our deep involvement in slavery. Please care about those who died in horrific circumstances and expose our shameful past.35372020-06-30T13:11:04.29744011Ada FraserAs s person from both a Scottish and Kenyan heritage- this is important in educating children on all aspects of African history so that Scottish children of all backgrounds can gain a better understanding of their history and help tackle racism in primary and secondary schools.35372020-06-30T17:48:50.05344013Davy touchwoodNot got any Money " But I've planted half million native trees as local as I can. How can I help? 35252020-06-30T18:32:35.4244014stefan duncanI make my living doing paintings of trees. They are literally "sacred" to me. They are symbolic of people with our feet as their roots and our arms as their branches ever reaching for the Light.35252020-06-30T19:40:29.78744015Jean FleetwoodImportant petition to help safe management of the land of Scotland.35252020-06-30T20:07:51.02344017Stuart GoodfellowThis would be a great boost to all sports and is a much needed appointment. 35262020-06-30T21:36:56.17744019Alison Campbell 100% agree legislation for this is needed. My comment is more on the process of adding my name to this - why are we asked to choose a Region instead of a country and why then is Scotland classed as a region? 35252020-06-30T21:48:12.80344020Christine walkerScotland is so beautiful. Please let us keep the beautiful country side we have. Leave the forests to prosper their natural beauty. Please protect them don't take them awau35252020-06-30T22:53:34.34344021Colin CampbellChildren should be taught how Scotland profited and was shaped by the slave trade and just how brutal and inhumane the slave trade was.35372020-06-30T23:18:08.35744022Rona McGreevyWe need to preserve the ancient trees for all to see and to allow the to regenerate for the sake of wildlife and mankind alike 35252020-07-01T02:38:11.32744023Marjorie Delaney Scotland must protect natural habitats35252020-07-01T14:23:24.00344027Nic warrilowSeems odd to be signing a petition asking for the truth to be told. Best of luck with it tho...35372020-07-01T14:32:11.35344028Ray MablyIn the days of global warming all forests are essential for the future of the planet. Time spent walking in forests has a beneficial mental effect on the people doing it so destroying any forest areas is totally irresponsible and stupid 35252020-07-01T22:08:34.5544029Kirsty RodgersSave our beautiful natural habitats.35252020-07-02T06:51:21.49344030Sandra Mains I was brought up in Ormiston and the yew tree is a symbol of Ormiston and should be left for other generations to enjoy35252020-07-02T08:32:41.1744031Franciscah Rufaro HoffmanKnowledge of all the people in Scotland can only serve as a way of developing tolerance and acceptance 35372020-07-02T12:13:36.5844033Rebecca MarslandLet's examine the "special relationship" with Malawi in this as well. 35372020-07-02T18:06:09.22744034Lara SlyceReform the national curriculum ! 35372020-07-02T18:45:32.2844035David RobertsonAncient Woodlands are not just the trees they are the entire environment in which they are located. The damage at this site has highlighted a gap in the existing legislation, that makes either SNH and Scottish Forestry unable to enforce protection for these areas. This should be rectified and I fully support this petition.35252020-07-02T18:50:40.5844036Emma Dalrymple This is such an important part of our history? How o earth can it be ignored in our curriculum? All that does is perpetuate the racism that is everpresent in our youth.35372020-07-02T21:24:59.03744037Elaine Bryan These woods are well used by walkers, runners & cyclists (see Strava). There are far more trails than on maps. They are home to many birds (see BirdNET). They are vital to both. Once destroyed always lost. The proposed road would sever the tracks which link Durno, Gallows Hill woods (where I often see badgers), Sprottie Woods, Logie Woodlands at Easterton, Logie Woodlands, South Logie Woodlands (where I often see deer) and so on. Don't ruin this amazingly scenic network - with views and landscapes as beautiful and special as Bennachie.35252020-07-03T09:30:29.86344040Caroline FairIt is very important that every nation teaches pupils there history whether they are Black or Scottish.It is more important to teach black history to every pupil as it is the others who need to learn.35372020-07-03T12:40:45.47744041Marianne Andrewswe need a bit more on Scottish History than Mary Queen of Scots and Skara Brae35372020-07-03T17:47:25.23744042Elizabeth TyrrellI would hope that with concern about climate change and the important part trees play that we would not follow Brazil and the Amazon and thaat Scotland where my roots are will save our ancient woodland- ,Please 35252020-07-03T17:50:29.86344043Carol AcuttProtecting Scotland's irreplaceable natural environment and wildlife is vital. i support all efforts towards this end.35252020-07-03T18:27:41.0444044Annabel GaltThe truth of our History can be taught35372020-07-03T21:17:07.81344045Jason vanhorneI think it should be both colours not just one white and back people are one we both done so much so yeh put up some black history 35372020-07-03T21:47:43.43744046Jamie Lee-HillI'm astonished this hasn't been on the curriculum for years. 35372020-07-03T21:50:14.1744047Ivy HerbertThis should happen35372020-07-03T22:08:29.9744048rhonda mcintoshtotally agree35372020-07-03T22:53:23.2144049Lisa WilliamsScotland has centuries of deep historical links with the Caribbean and Africa, which are just coming to the fore. Teachers across Scotland are very interested in learning about Scotland's Black History, and are keen to have teaching resources and training, both at Primary and Secondary level. It's important for children of all backgrounds to have greater context in order to become global citizens with a modern, international outlook and a deeper understanding of their own transnational history. 35372020-07-04T08:26:30.84744050Rebecca LeiversKeep green spaces 35252020-07-04T09:10:18.5444051John urehelp save our ancient woods35252020-07-04T10:16:47.2744052Prof Willy MaleyWe need to teach African history and literature in our schools and universities so that we can better understand the impact of colonialism on those affected by the British Empire. 35372020-07-04T11:19:53.57344053Suzanne EdwardsOur ancient woodlands have hundreds of years of ecosystems, and our vital to so many animals creatures and us . Although Scotland is a long way from me, I still care about the land, the whole of the world, but especially this Island and groups of islands. Please protect our forests and especially this ancient woodland. Once gone, it can never recover.\r\n35252020-07-04T12:07:38.39344055Saira AslamYes I agree this should be included in the curriculum, we cannot learn from the past if it is not taught to our children. 35372020-07-04T13:35:30.77744056Lesley BowmanPlease leave these woods alone as they are used by all the community for walking, running, dog walks and observing the local wildlife 35252020-07-04T14:45:39.31344057Charmaine Blaize-laCailleThis is important for all of our society but especially for African heritage children.35372020-07-04T15:43:41.3744058Martin WillcocksThis is a must , we are nature, destroying ancient woodland is like destroying ourselves, 35252020-07-04T17:15:03.4344059Tabitha Hall Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to reform the national curriculum to include Afro-Scottish history including artefacts of African diaspora, cultural and economic contributions, the role of the British Empire and the benefits to Scotland from colonies of Africa and The Caribbean \r\n35372020-07-04T19:38:43.944060John Parks It's time!35372020-07-04T20:07:26.8344061John fraserAncient Woodlands are irreplaceable - they need our protection to protect our planet35252020-07-04T20:27:08.58344062Sally TaylorProtect the trees protect earth35252020-07-04T22:04:14.12344064Leeanne CoyleLet's ensure our children are taught that their country's involvement in slave trading and ownership is the reason most of them are living such a privileged life today.35372020-07-04T22:48:01.4444065Marie GriffithsThe ancient woodlands are irreplaceable and need to be granted FULL legal protection35252020-07-04T23:38:36.7344066Robin DobsonVital for a balanced future35252020-07-04T23:51:27.844067Catherine Schriner Please save this forest for our future. We are losing so much of our world's treasures, don't let this be one of them. 35252020-07-04T23:53:06.8444068Christy MorganThank you for the effort to protect the trees. All trees matter and we need to fight for them35252020-07-05T00:02:01.08344069Joe McLoughlinSo little left to save. I hope there is a coherent vision to prevent its disappearance and encourage its regeneration.35252020-07-05T02:29:46.08744070Maria hearyI like to help anyone I. Anyway I possibly can35252020-07-05T02:45:36.32744071Pia KealeyOnly trees will save us35252020-07-05T11:00:07.78744073Maggie ImrenSo, so important for biodiversity and saving of various species from extinction 35252020-07-05T11:22:10.66744074Margie SwindellThese woodlands are irreplaceable. You cannot get rid of something like that! Generations to come to be able to marvel at the wonderment of it all. 35252020-07-05T11:25:44.72744075Jacquie Whitleytrees are the lungs of our plant so wrong to detroy them35252020-07-05T12:36:38.50344077Ellen WellensteinAncient woodlands are irreplaceable and deserve the highest levels of legal protection.35252020-07-05T13:32:31.2944078Joyce Juma-Phiri I believe that there should be an inclusion of Afro-Scottish history in the Scottish Curriculum so that children in schools learn relevant historic stories.35372020-07-05T13:48:50.1744079Michele RichieIncluding the African culturein your curriculum would demonstrate to your country the equality of all people,. There's enough racism going on everywhere, so break the cycle and set an example to the world.35372020-07-05T15:40:32.544080Lesley McGilvary A great lover of history it wasnt till i went to uni as a mature student that I learned about real Scottish history under prof Divine Scots of all creeds and colours should be taught about ALL their history not the narrow anglocentric version we've all been given thus far. 35372020-07-05T16:27:49.03744081SUE WAYThis breaks my heart, trees they provide a home for wildlife, oxygen, the beauty of trees, is one of the worlds wonders. They look after us. 35252020-07-05T19:02:56.73344083Mohammad NayefKeeping green lands will save the earth and humanity. The equation is simple, but few people take action. \r\n\r\nPlease Save forests, save earth, and save us.35252020-07-05T19:54:08.47344084Sylvia MellerIn times of climate change and intense destruction of our nature we have to make sure each and every tree is protected!35252020-07-05T19:54:44.45744085Laura Dunn Absolutely, we should have enshrined protection of native Woodlands in law decades ago. Only about 4 per cent of our tree cover is native, the rest made up of exotic conifer monoculture. Not sustainable, not ecologically helpful and the system needs to be radically reviewed. I also tried to sign this petition but it is not accepting my email address 35252020-07-05T21:30:52.65744086Mike DowningThis is massively important 35252020-07-05T23:34:16.9444087Kathy Quinn ArchambeauWe need to save our natural forests for the whole planet35252020-07-06T10:49:54.7244088Pat OliverWoods are so good for our mental and emotional well being. So, in some cases they save the NHS from having to treat patients with CBT etc.35252020-07-06T13:56:12.38744090Alan John CampbellThis is a timeous and excellent proposal which I support whole-heartedly. As a nation which purports to promote environmental sustainability and ecological stewardship, this type of progressive legislation is overdue. The logic and scientific argument in favour or establishing enhanced legal protection is sound. Landowners cannot be permitted to run roughshod, destructive and vandal-like over ancient, sensitive and unique local ecosystems. Ancient (and semi-native) woodlands and the floor habitats that support our indigenous species are 'irreplaceable' - that last word should worry us all with good reason. Now has come the point to show real action and true meaningfulness if we are to reflect the spirit of global environmental responsibility going forward. A modern, forward-looking 21st century country must view this as a obligation and not prevaricate on delivering these essential changes. It cannot be rationally contradicted or intelligently countered that Scotland has a duty to do this for present and future generations.35252020-07-06T15:27:42.94344091Nikki SlevinI can not believe you would even contemplate taking away our green space all the local schools use this to learn about nature and wildlife \r\nall you are teaching them is how do destroy and displace\r\nThere are plenty of other sites to use without harming our wildlife taking away their homes and moving the bulldozers in \r\nYou should be ashamed35252020-07-06T21:36:23.06344093Angela ForsythIrreplaceable, do the right thing and protect us all immediately35252020-07-06T22:58:56.66744094Sian R DaviesThis is long overdue. We need this in our curriculum.35372020-07-07T09:07:39.41744095ElizabethTyrrellScotlnd is a furward thinking country but with the longstanding climate crisis, the drastic effects on the environment it is vital to not only plant more trees but to protect the ancient, mature and beautiful woodland you already have. With the 3.5 billion promised today for green issues I hope Scotland and tree planting and protection with be a top prioity !!35252020-07-07T09:18:04.06744096Sandra J WethyIf we don't care for our planet, who will? I am a third-generation Scot living in the USA. I feel we must ALL do what we can to preserve our planet and ecosystems before it's too late. The human race could depend on it. Save the forests, otherwise, we develop our way to extinction.35252020-07-07T10:06:20.60344097Adrian StablerIt may be that in damaging the environment we provided perfect conditions for Covid-19 to proliferate, having been dormant for decades. Protect the environment, stop the virus.35252020-07-07T13:53:33.8144100Vicky Nyanga So Very much needed because much of the ignorance and bigotry that is out here in this country is because of lack of knowledge and the fact that the TRUTH has either been diluted or denied. 35372020-07-07T14:51:56.7544101Catriona MalanI firmly believe that the presence of green spaces open to the public are of great importance to the health of everyone, and we must fight for them to remain. It is ludicrous that some places are striving to create these kind of areas when other councils' planning committees allow the destruction of old or established woodlands.35252020-07-07T16:20:35.04344102Leslie BruceIf we as a country are going to be seen as leaders in fighting climate change and as hosts of next year's Environmental Conference we must preserve our natural assets and not destroy them in pursuit of so-called "progress".35252020-07-07T17:56:42.744103Caroline J BurkettPlease look to the future--woodlands are the biggest safety net to restore and protect the air we breath.35252020-07-07T17:59:56.46344104Louise McAllisterI would really like black history being incorporated into the current curriculum. I have young family members. There are some parts of history I had no clue about until recently 35372020-07-07T23:39:11.79744105JULIE ANNE COOKOur future generations need our woodlands, Nature and wildlife need a place to flourish. 35252020-07-08T08:35:21.99744106Tracey GarnerWe need your ancient woodlands for our flora , fauna \r\n& fungus to help the environment 35252020-07-08T12:02:53.83744108David Reidie I don't understand why this is not taught! Stop trying to hide the past35372020-07-08T13:02:50.2544110William John Charles this needs to be fixed it is annoying that people go not know about my past and ancestors35372020-07-08T13:32:05.61744111Kelly AdairVery important for people to grow up with an appreciation of their country's true history and not just the more palatable highlights. 35372020-07-08T14:08:25.69744112Scott ErwinGlad this is being brought up- context is everything and should fit in well with pupils' aims of Global Citizenship as well as understanding Fairtrade as well as trade injustices.35372020-07-08T14:38:23.8144113Jo cummingA more accurate teaching of history long overdue35372020-07-08T15:36:46.30344114Sonia JackettOnly by understanding history can we understand some of the issues we are now facing - institutional and systematic racism for example. It's vital we change the curriculum to make younger generations more aware and more able to make positive change. 35372020-07-08T16:48:40.64344116Charissa GregsonTeach our children accurate inclusive history, to minimise the damage caused to future generations.35372020-07-08T17:33:36.1244117James DalyLong overdue!35372020-07-08T17:49:22.27744118Ms Mariota DunningProtect our trees!35252020-07-08T18:02:40.4244119Brittany ShannahanI am proud of my degree in history from an ancient Scottish university. While doing research in an advanced honours class on knighthood and kingship in medieval and early renaissance Scotland, I noticed a lot of tangential references in some of the newer monographs to African connections that were present in the Scottish courts. This backed up a growing consensus among scholars that ethnic diversity and the presence of immigrants was much stronger in Scotland than had been previously realized. At the same time, while I attended from 2003 to 2007, save for one class on pre Columbian Latin America, there were no history classes available that studied non European peoples outside of colonization. I think it is worthy to note that medievalists at Scottish universities have, in the last few decades, increasingly prioritized the subject of diversity and ethnicity in Europe prior to the Renaissance. In part, this has been in response to the ways in which medieval histories are repurposed towards ethnonationalist ends, as in Braveheart. But this leadership at the research level has not trickled down to the national curriculum, or into the historical narratives celebrated by Scots and the Scottish diaspora. It should not be up to the TV series Outlander to teach young people about the Scottish relationship to slavery, especially since that representation of the issue is a spectacular and politically dangerous failure. Mark Twain famously remarked that the Waverly Novels by Walter Scott did more than any other cultural influence to instigate and justify both the Confederacy and the postbellum, lost cause narrative that saw the construction confederate monuments across the US in the early 20thC. Even now, white tourists travel to Scotland to validate an ethnonationalist origin story that has dominated white diaspora families since the late 60s, primarily as a racist backlash against desegregation and the civil rights movement.35372020-07-08T18:27:50.1144120Camilla Houstoun I think it is a great idea to clarify our history so that we can move forward into a future where people are understood and ignorant racism is no longer A Thing. Scotland is a beautiful cpuntry with many ugly stories in its past. It is a good idea that young people are taught the truth so that they can leave school with a realistic understanding of the wider world. 35372020-07-08T18:56:09.56744121Elizabeth ClutterbuckBlack children in Scotland should be able to see their presence in its history, and non-Black children should learn a full and not White-edited history. It's about time to destroy white supremacism in the education system. 35372020-07-08T21:21:50.09744122Alisdair McKayAt a national history level this is needed, though I would like to see it carried out with consultation with our existing community from international backgrounds who may have feel no relationship to our national historical story and need a broader story of current multiculturalism to be told.35372020-07-09T02:09:19.9544123Arun sachdeva Trees are the roots to our lives 35252020-07-09T09:25:47.59344124Evie PatersonEducation about ALL of Scottish history and our own part in world history (including the Empire and the slave trade) must be taught in schools. It is a vital part of understanding and combating racism and white privilege in our society. The onus should not be on people of colour to educate us on our own privilege and defend their own history against our revised version. 35372020-07-09T11:46:36.1744125Sarah McIntoshThis is crucial in opening up dialogue with our children. Education and discussion is in key in breaking down systemic racism in our culture. 35372020-07-09T18:20:57.86344127Jeffrey Portland, Oregon USAThis is an important issue in the USA as well so wanted to support efforts abroad as well. 35372020-07-09T19:54:03.26744128Heather SpenceThis is vital. I also hope there will be more education on the impact of colonialism on other parts of the world such as India, Pakistan and Hong Kong, and why we need to value the contribution immigrants to Scotland have made and continue to make. 35372020-07-09T20:55:58.75744129Peter COOKOld trees and forests are part of Scotland's history, like old historical buildings, ancient trees and forests deserve to be protected. 35252020-07-09T23:19:31.71344131Victoria LeeA knowledge of history makes more sense of the present be and hopefully makes it less likely mistakes are repeated.35372020-07-10T11:23:55.81344132Robert MotykaWe need to know all aspects of Scottish history in order to UNDERSTAND modern world.35372020-07-10T19:03:33.16344134Pauline Nichol Thankfully we are no longer part of the EU so why would we fly the flag of an organisation we are not part of?34512020-07-10T20:05:39.8944135Saarah MehmoodI completed secondary school only a year ago and was shocked at the complete lack of education on Britain's colonialism and the short tick a box approach to teaching Britain's role in the Slave trade. It greatly emphasised our role in ending slavery, a great whitewash of the horrific history. \r\n\r\nThe fact is the British Empire and the role we played in the Slave trade still is ingrained in the systems built from it. We need to educate ourselves. 35372020-07-10T21:00:35.8544136Olly SpiersLong overdue! We need a full account of British imperialism and it's contribution (and advancement) of the slave trade. British history (dating back to the Romans) is Black history too. I would fully support a true version being taught in our schools. 35372020-07-11T01:30:31.5844137Laura BrickellI think we have destroyed enough of Scotland's and Earth's natural heritage. Other species have an equal right to life. Forests are the foundation of all life - and soil- and are utterly vital to our well-being and regeneration of natural and ancient forests (rather than token tree plannting), should be a priority35252020-07-11T09:07:41.8744138Shona MacLeodI strongly object to this proposal. No, the commonwealth flag should not be flown as it is an outdated symbol of empire and colonialism. The European flag with its 12 stars do not represent the countries of Europe but rather are a symbol of completeness & unity (12 months in the year, 12 points on a clock face). Scotland voted to remain with our European neighbours & we should reflect that by continuing to fly the flag. 34512020-07-11T10:34:02.61744139Robert BellPlease take action. Social & environmental justice us required.35252020-07-11T18:32:17.33344140Linda L. SerafiniOur trees are the OverStory of our human existence.35252020-07-11T21:15:37.7544142Gillian de FeliceTrying to fight a small development in my neighbourhood which will mean the removal of several trees covered by TPOs and an area designated as ancient woodland.35252020-07-11T21:31:32.90344143Laura Stat Burrows Please save this precious living breathing ancient place of trees n wildlife too 35252020-07-11T21:38:49.39344144Sancha MartinOur woodland and trails are beautiful and should be protected. 35252020-07-11T21:41:16.9244145Irene whitelawShame the Planning reporters dont have the same values for ancient Woodland just look at a Planning application in Murieston where they are removing 100 trees which have TPOswhich also includes ancient Woodland for eigthten houses..double standards35252020-07-11T23:24:04.3444146Tracey BeveridgeDo the right thing and make a difference, a protection order is there for a reason! Do not allow development where trees and wildlife needs to be destroyed.35252020-07-12T09:48:38.40344147Amie ButchardCutting down ancient Woodlands for the sake of a few houses is not acceptable. The future quality of our air and environment for our children and grandchildren should be considered here, not the potential money that can be pocketed, this is short term gain, next generation will have longterm pain. 35252020-07-12T09:51:16.29344148Simon BaxendaleWe should be conserving all forests and Woodlands for future generations. There is no need to cut them down for unnecessary reasons especially just to build on. 35252020-07-12T12:00:09.5144149Claudia SerrainoIts part of the slavery history that did take place in Scotland. Knowledge is key and hopefully this way all races will understand and appreciate what people of colour have been through and in this way, more unity between people and compassion 35372020-07-12T12:29:12.29744150Nahid Aslamschools should teach the history of the colonial period. This will include Africa and all the other countries the UK exploited in order to make itself great. We teach children to to be truthful and not to bully others, yet our history shows actions far from that. We cannot change the past but we can learn from it and try to make the world a better place. But for that to happen me need to be open and honest about who we are and how we got here.35372020-07-12T14:56:38.3344151Carol HallesyTPOs and ancient woodland must be protected from developers who appear to be given a free reign to destroy these areas35252020-07-12T15:36:23.5744153Kofi AidooAll school children in Scotland should be given lesson in black slavery, its origin, MO, etc. It would help in recognition and equality of blacks in this country.35372020-07-12T15:45:08.944154Martin Ross Nature was here before us and will be here after us. We must respect it.35252020-07-12T16:10:13.8144155Adam KassimThis is important for the next generation to learn and understand about black history 35372020-07-12T17:12:25.91344156Peter RobertsonGood luck perhaps shame this government into preserving parts of Scotland35252020-07-12T18:43:12.1944157Karl McCranConsidering my first education on my heritage came from Def Comedy Jam... I would 100% endorse the younger generations leaning about their heritage35372020-07-13T02:34:51.87744158jean-marcLet's move forward !35372020-07-13T10:38:32.54344159Alistair EdwardsTo undo centuries of racism - external and internal, personal and institutional - it is imperative to educate. This should begin at nursery and be threaded through the curriculum at all stages.35372020-07-13T13:39:07.14344160James BrownAs well as the admiral and glorious aspects of our colonial past, history teaching should take account of the less admirable and less glorious.35372020-07-13T14:47:05.24344161Valentine scarlettThis is long overdue. A real look at history that includes the views of those citizens from BAME in how the curriculum should be drawn up, what it should include. I don't know I am white and ignorant. My knowledge is constantly unfolding before my appalled eyes. 35372020-07-13T16:24:56.58744162Megan Lindsay I think inclusion of Afro-Scottish history, as described in this petition, as part of the Scottish national curriculum would be extremely beneficial for Scottish students. It would allow for Black Scottish young people to feel more included in the history of their country and it could help to reduce racism and anti-immigrant sentiments amongst white Scottish students.\r\n\r\nI left high school in 2015 and had studied history at Standard Grade level, but I do not remember being taught about any of the topics mentioned in this petition. I think including these topics would allow students to learn a more well-rounded and inclusive version of our history. \r\n\r\nRegarding colonial history, I think this definitely should be taught to students in S1 to S4, as I sadly did not have any real understanding of colonialism, and the lasting effects of it, until I went to university. By excluding this from the history curriculum for younger students while simultaneously maintaining a major focus on WW1 and WW2, students learn a bias account of our history where only the better moments are recounted. 35372020-07-13T19:32:49.12344164Anne Docherty We need honest history 35372020-07-14T00:44:34.5944166Gina CharlesI love trees that may sound like a very strange think to admit however its true I do because they take in carbon dioxide and give us oxygen if they die just like the bee's and the oceans we die we are not God's we are custodians of the planet for future generation's trees are living things just like us .35252020-07-14T09:11:41.75344167Jean-Claude Education in the best interest of all35372020-07-14T18:52:39.11344168Kat LeeAncient woodlands need to be protected, and we need huge focused efforts to continue to plant trees and rewild where we can. 35252020-07-14T21:16:36.49344169Shauna MacAninchHistory, when told truthfully, can transform the future35372020-07-15T07:30:40.13744170Justin Vibert WilsonThis petition has had little or no publicity as far as I can tell and therefore the number of people signing should not be compared to other petitions.35252020-07-15T08:33:43.2444171Rachel WrightTrees are essential in our battle to stop climate change destroying our planet. We must keep what we have and plant many more too.35252020-07-15T10:44:23.79744173Tim CushanIntrinsically l believe we recognise the value of ancient Woodlands, not as an economic \r\n commodity, but as a precious resource of priceless benefit to the world and all life. It is the responsibility of these that have been elected and those' in and of power' to make decisions that will provide protection for further generations in Scotland and beyond. Please make the right decisions so it remains intact so it thrives rather than a segment of the history channel.35252020-07-15T12:18:26.28344174Barney Green Scotland, as part of the UK, is steeped in the trading past of the colonial British Empire and all that went along with that good as well as bad. This needs to be taught to our increasingly more diverse school going population, so they understand where they and we all came from and what has shaped us, in order to shape them, positively, in the future.35372020-07-16T05:13:40.97344175Deborah KehoeSave all of our precious old growth, ancient, native and woodland trees as they will help humans survive on so many levels. Without them, the planet cannot survive. 35252020-07-16T10:56:01.33344176Anthony O'RourkeEvery tree cut down, is another fibre on the rope that strangles you. 35252020-07-16T12:06:02.77344177Nick BibbyAt a time when there is much debate about restoring the land to a state where it will help avert the impending climate and biodiversity crises, it would seem odd not to protect the few remaining scraps of ancient woodland. Without wishing to get too poetic about it, these represent a bridge from our past to our hoped for future - a wood that was and will be again. 35252020-07-16T13:51:25.91344178Chloe WhyteThis is a vital petition to protect the rights of vulnerable LGBTQ+ people. As stated in the European Convention on Human Rights, which we are still mandated to follow post-Brexit, degrading treatment or punishment is prohibited under Article 3. We must uphold this, and prevent unnecessary psychological torture of the LGBTQ+ community.35602020-07-16T14:24:54.49744179Gregor MurrayI have contacted MSPs and the like several times on this to be told 'there's no evidence of it happening' so that it isn't a priority. LGBTI+ people are hurting, let's do something to help the community. 35602020-07-16T15:59:58.60344180Michael DriscollConversion therapy is harmful, forced, redundant in cause and still has no evidence of working.35602020-07-16T16:02:08.444181Ieisha Steel Conversion Therapy is abhorrent, dehumanising, traumatising and it's a crime that this is still being discussed. Endgame is that it's made illegal and it's criminalised if someone puts someone through it. This will do for now.35602020-07-16T16:14:07.99744182Samantha LoganYes, I believe that conversion therapy should be outlawed. There is no room in modern society for such a medieval practice, to force a person to conform to outdated and intolerant principles. People deserve to be themselves and be happy. 35602020-07-16T17:29:21.75744184Olivia WellsIt's the 21st century, let's act like it35602020-07-16T17:57:50.70344186Savannah GaleNo one should be forced, through abusive and violent means, to change their natural selves.35602020-07-16T18:01:27.3744187Brian Prosise LGBT+ are people. If this conversion practice is allowed, why not allow other forms of conversion to other social 'norms'? 35602020-07-16T18:25:03.644189Teale FaillaConversion therapy is barbaric and foolish. Scotland is better than this. 35602020-07-16T18:52:47.0144190Irene MotionWith everything I read and research it becomes more apparent just how important our woodlands are35252020-07-16T19:05:36.0144191Michael RichardsonConversion therapy is horrific and has no place in a modern, progressive Scotland35602020-07-16T19:12:52.35744192Fiona MarshallAs a person of faith, there is no reasonable excuse to ever allow the harm and trauma caused by the torture that is conversion therapy. Religious organisations need to be held accountable for their actions and be reminded that they are not removed from modern society. Torture is criminal and the Scottish Govt should use their powers to end this criminal practice.35602020-07-16T19:50:20.1944193Elvera GeenThe licences given to kill beavers (a protected species) are a joke, giving farmers freedom to murder as many as they like, ridiculous and shameful. Beavers are a wonderful addition to our landscape, improving biodiversity and habitat creation.35452020-07-16T19:56:46.844194Elizabeth TaylorThey were there before us & we need to keep them for our wildlife & habitat..35252020-07-16T20:11:58.0244195Tommy MooreLots of suitable environment to look at before lethal controls ever need to be considered.35452020-07-16T20:51:22.22744196Ana ReyesConversion therapy is inhumane and ineffective. It does so much more harm to innocent people. Conversion therapy should not continue, and should not be promoted.35602020-07-16T21:31:03.3944199John AllenI am very pleased to be able to support such a worthy cause for beavers and for the environment.35452020-07-16T21:50:22.04344201Edward HurstIt is complete madness to cull these creatures when a sensible and practical alternative is available. This is almost as bad as New Zealand dropping 1080 to control possums and killing everything by doing so. Scotland has the opportunity to support Beavers and has the greatest potential for ecological restoration. 35452020-07-16T21:55:45.00344203David GibbonIt is disgraceful that ScotGov is taking the opposite view and has dragged its feet in regard to beaver reintroduction from the start. This is not to say that farmers do not face very real difficulties but these difficulties should be managed with the help of the tool of translocation and of non lethal mitigation. Recourse to lethal control is wholly inappropriate at this very early stage in the reintroduction of the species and threatens the viability of the whole project, as is the intention of some of the vested interests. \r\n\r\nFar from giving in to these interests ScotGov should be imposing limits on how close to riparian areas it is permissible to farm or otherwise exploit natural habitat.\r\n\r\nAs a we face climate and species extinction emergencIes this keystone species should be permitted and encouraged to proliferate and vested interests should be faced down. \r\n\r\nIt is disgraceful that ScotGov is taking the opposite view and has dragged its feet in regard to beaver reintroduction from the start. This is not to say that farmers do not face very real difficulties but these difficulties should be managed with the help of the tool of translocation and of non we lethal mitigation. Recourse to lethal control is wholly inappropriate at this very early stage in the reintroduction of the species and threatens the viability of the whole project, as is the intention of some of the vested interests. \r\n\r\nFar from giving in to these interests ScotGov should be imposing limits on how close to riparian areas it is permissible to farm or otherwise exploit natural habitat.35452020-07-16T22:17:29.90744204Hugh ChalmersPlease allow beavers to spread to suitable areas where they will restore wetland habitats35452020-07-16T22:34:08.45744205Nicola MacLeod As well as being a unique and important reintroduced species, beavers are such an environmental asset that killing them is sher madness. They provide and construct incredible wet land habitat hugely increasing biodiversity but they alo are natural engineers of flood mitigation. Please don't allow another single beaver to be killed. If they are not wanted in one place somewhere else will definitely want them so trap them and move them. 35452020-07-16T22:45:53.19344206Roz BrooksWhy reintroduce a species just to kill them? Doesn't make sense? 35452020-07-16T22:59:15.64744207Victoria Grenfell Please leave our previous wildlife alone. Nature balances itself. 35452020-07-16T23:19:40.07744208RAYMOND&PEARL BELLPlease stop the Cull!35452020-07-17T00:08:23.7444209Nicola GowersThis plan makes perfetc sense. It is ludicrous that so many beavers are being killed so soon after their reintroduction to Scotland. This must change.35452020-07-17T00:29:14.5344210Debby mcilquhamWe must protect these wild animals as they have the right to live.35452020-07-17T04:37:44.49744212Pauline DviesWhy bring them back to cull them? Amazing creatures, learn to live with them!35452020-07-17T04:42:56.6744213Linda Harries Leave the widelife alone. 35452020-07-17T07:02:22.2444214GEN SAMSONIt is not acceptable or ethical to reintroduce a species only to cull when it does what any species does! 35452020-07-17T07:56:58.33744215Sharon nicolPlease do not cul the beaver now they have been reintraduced back into scotland after you hunted them to extinction.35452020-07-17T08:07:10.1444216Jan Lunsfordhumans killing wildlife so we can have their habitat, WRONG! let's live with nature, biodiversity.35452020-07-17T08:29:40.78344217Paul HawkinsPlease relocate the Beavers for the good of the environment. Thank you.35452020-07-17T08:33:50.31744218Karen Swan Please be compassionate. This cull is not necessary. 35452020-07-17T09:12:49.9944220Carol Reith Living in rural Angus I have seen the destruction that beavers cause.35452020-07-17T09:27:19.30744221Craig MunroConversion therapy is disgusting and barbaric and I can't believe it's not already illegal35602020-07-17T09:35:57.30744222Jenny PearsonBeavers across Scotland will boost biodiversity by creating fantastically rich wetland sites. In the times of an ecological crisis and in one of the most nature depleted countries in the world, beavers will be hugely beneficial. Also in combatting climate change related flooding, beavers will slow and steady water flows, protecting homes, businesses and lives. Beavers are a super animal and they belong I'm scotland.35452020-07-17T09:51:17.65744223Paul FisherReintroducing beavers costs money, taxpayers money. Licensing their culling also cost taxpayers money. Apart from being inefficient it is also brainless.35452020-07-17T10:37:45.8244225JAYNE Kettles Leave the beavers alone35452020-07-17T10:37:59.5744226Allan Bantick OBEWhilst limiting the range of the unofficial beavers in the east of Scotland may have seemed an appropriate measure at the time, matters have moved on. There is an appetite in other parts of Scotland with suitable beaver habitat for this native species to return and so move threatened beavers from the east of Scotland to these new sites now seems perfectly sensible.35452020-07-17T10:54:38.7744227James NairneExpanding beaver presence helps fight climate change and biodiversity loss. Translocating them to suitable new areas is such an obvious step35452020-07-17T10:57:19.81744228Sandra Strathie Please bring this cruelty to an end. What the point of reintroducing an animal then hunting it. Education required. 35452020-07-17T11:01:20.33344229Louise RamsayScotland, so far, has a very small number of beavers compared to most other European countries, and quarantine issues make it difficult to bring more into the UK. They are very much needed in many parts of Scotland to create and restore wetlands, to boost biodiversity in this time of crisis, and regulate water flow, reducing both flooding and drought exacerbated by climate change. There is also much scope for developing ecotourism based around beaver wetlands. When beavers are caught in conflict zones where mitigation has been shown not to work they should be relocated, not shot. As a protected species, shooting should be avoided unless no other options are available. The shooting of 87 beavers under license in 2019 has exposed a catastrophically misconceived approach and must be put right. Part of the solution is to open the rest of Scotland up to the possibility of relocation and to move more of these beavers conflict to other parts of Scotland. Farmers' organisations cannot be allowed to overly influence policy in this area. Their interests may often be in conflict with the public interest, and in this case it is in the public interest to increase the number of beavers in Scotland in the many parts of the countryside where they will bring nothing but benefits, rather than have them killed out in the low ground farms .35452020-07-17T11:25:40.13744230Jillian FordFor the love of your fellow humans, ban it. 35602020-07-17T11:47:35.37344231Katie FaulkConversion therapy is abusive, deeply harmful, and pointless. Ban it and its promotion for a better Scotland35602020-07-17T13:23:07.74744232Alex MulhollandSolidarity.35602020-07-17T14:01:46.70744233Alyssa WyattThere is no price to put on love. You're allowed to love your partner. If someone tried to take that away from you? Tried to split you up and tell you that you're wrong for loving someone? What would you do? Provoke outrage? Fight to get them back? LGBT+ peoples have been going through this for centuries. It's time for it to come to an end. Conversion therapy is inhuman, as it impedes and discourages love, which is every human's right to experience. 35602020-07-17T14:37:00.83744234Claire HorneConversion therapy is punishment and torture for being who you are, and not a "therapy". It creates traumatic experiences for LGBT+ folks. This inhumane pseudoscience needs to end.35602020-07-17T15:04:49.24744235Chris DaviesCome on Scotland - get your act together. 35452020-07-17T15:29:09.31344236Vaughn KhelifaAbhorrent 35452020-07-17T15:32:00.15744237Elizabeth Ormerod I am a Scottish veterinary surgeon. Beavers contribute to our ecology, so do not cull them35452020-07-17T15:50:54.25344238Tony EggelingKilling beavers should not even be under consideration. Isn't the whole idea meant to be re-introduction and not falling back on extermination at the first hurdle? 35452020-07-17T16:19:25.75744239Juliet ConwayThe issuing of the licence is a disgrace and the animals should have trapped and rereleased. A real disgrace and shows that the beavers were reintroduced with little consultation to landowners!35452020-07-17T17:16:21.1744240Tessa SimpsonYes conversion therapy should not exist!! 35602020-07-17T17:23:25.59344241Gavin KirbyConversion therapy refers to a set of unethical and unscientific practices that should have no place in a civilised society. It does not belong in 21st century Scotland.35602020-07-17T17:50:05.50344243KATHRYN GRANTPlease take a minute to sign this and preserve what remains of our ancient woodlands and the life they support35252020-07-17T18:15:28.17744244Lynne HardemanPlease try to relocate protected the Beaver community outside its range to minimise need to kill them 35452020-07-17T18:49:05.2344245Janie FaulknerThe reintroduction of beavers in Scotland has been a huge success but we need to prevent any further licenses being given unnecessarily. Relocation has to be the preferred option.35452020-07-17T19:01:51.63744246Lorna ArrollTrees are the lungs of the world. Protect our trees, so they protect us. 1979 symposium on global warming, a family member told me how planting trees in the desert would bring rain, at the time I thought he was crazy, now I know he was a man on a mission.35252020-07-17T19:55:08.6344248Evelyn McIntoshThis is disgusting, please let it stop asap!!35452020-07-17T20:09:07.66344250Jamie HughesConversion therapy is torture. It must be banned, and the ban must include the prohibiting of conversion therapy against transgender people (that is, any attempt to convince a trans person that they are not trans, that they should not transition, or that their identity is invalid). 35602020-07-17T20:11:52.00744251Edan Hughes Conversion therapy is torture, and it must be banned. Any prohibition of conversion therapy must include a ban against anti-transgender conversion therapy (that is, any attempt to convince a person who considers themself to be transgender that they are not trans, that they should not transition, or that the concepts of being transgender, transitioning, and non-binary identities are not valid or real concepts. 35602020-07-17T20:36:41.49344252Matilda Scharsach The loophole in the law that has enabled the widespread killing of beavers to continue makes any so called protection that they have absolutely meaningless. The Scottish government is truly committed to conservation and all the biodiversity benefits that they bring, then they will close this loophole and give beavers the genuine protection that they deserve. 35452020-07-17T22:46:36.8444253susan flemingStop killing beavers in Scotland!35452020-07-17T23:10:21.51744254Viktor Korpi Kardell'S e cùis-nàire don dhùthaich air fad a tha seo 's iad a' marbhadh cuid mhòr de dh'òigridh LGDT+. Abair sgrìos gu bheil seo fhathast ceadaichte. 35602020-07-17T23:45:02.94344255Trudi FordPlease fix this35452020-07-18T06:46:07.5844256Jo CartmellThe UK was one of the last countries in Europe to reintroduce beavers. We need to translocate them not cull them. We are probably the only country doing this!35452020-07-18T09:48:03.54344258Ian WhittakerTranslocation has to be the most environmentally sensible & beneficial option rather than the knee-jerk cull35452020-07-18T10:18:44.62744260Lilah DavidsonConversion therapy is a human rights violation and has no place in the 21st century. This must be banned. 35602020-07-18T10:49:18.61744261Beck DuncanConversion therapy is dangerous and no person should have to go through it. Nobody should have to change to fit societies standards, however society must become more compassionate. With a more accepting society lgbt+ communities will flourish. Please make conversion therapy illegal nobody's rights should have to be debated and equality should not be controversial. 35602020-07-18T11:11:45.99344263Ewan LewisEnd Conversion Therapy 35602020-07-18T11:40:29.1744264Darren massonPlease bring this to an end!!35602020-07-18T12:03:43.68744266Cameron WoodallBeavers are ecosystem engineers that can have a huge positive impact on the natural environment, providing unique wildlife habitats and improving watercourses. They need to be protected instead of killed and are a valuable wildlife asset to Scotland, but are in a fragile state with low numbers.35452020-07-18T13:04:55.65744268Maurice WilkinsTotally agree! We must get protection before it's too late! But there's no point in supporting such a project in Scotland generally if local councils do absolutely nothing to protect green spaces and fragments of woodland in our towns, in my case, Oban!35252020-07-18T13:33:23.18744269Gavin MorrisonMuch like the GRA, I'm amazed that this is something we still have to fight for35602020-07-18T14:27:12.2144270Chris Osborne It's time that this was outlawed. The Scottish public have very little awareness of what is involved in this practice. More needs to be done to expose the long term psychological damage by conversion therapies. 35602020-07-18T14:54:54.54344271Sharon Lashley Please try and help these animals co-exist alongside society. They are amazing ecosystems engineers as well as highly intelligent creatures. 35452020-07-18T17:15:43.0644274Jim WhannelConversion therapy is torture.35602020-07-18T19:37:15.72344275David StevensScotland needs nature based solutions to the climate and nature emergency. Beavers can help. Please don't kill them, relocate them!35452020-07-18T20:10:20.9344276Karl MulleeHad the good fortune to visit Knapdale where they have the Beavers and learned an awful lot. They get a bad press, but in actual fact their industrious Ness helps to guard against flooding in some flood hit areas by limiting the flow of water downstream. So they can act as a natural flood barrier.\r\nIn Knapdale this isn't such an issue. Originally neighbouring farms opposed their introduction, but in actual fact, once leaving the previous territory, moving on to where they are now: the soil quality in that previous territory was far better as a consequence of their activities, much more nutrient rich, so the farmer received a benefit also of their endeavours. They can be of huge benefit, both to homeowners and farmers, if we overcome the prejudices and false headlines of those with an agenda to not have them. 35452020-07-18T21:31:46.5744277Kay KellyBeavers are a keystone species, and their work reduces flood risk more effectively than the far more expensive measures sometimes employed.35452020-07-18T21:35:03.644278Amy Kapherr-Diamentrelocate35452020-07-18T23:43:55.01744279Anne Rogers I think Beavers have an important place in managing flood risk with climate change.35452020-07-18T23:45:47.84744280Anne Rogers Beavers are important in managing flood risk in climate change 35452020-07-19T06:43:32.744282Caroline MellorPlease protect the beavers!35452020-07-19T08:07:18.73344283Elaine Martay Beavers are good for biodiversity and flood control. 35452020-07-19T10:59:32.50744285David Anderson Translocation should be the first option and always before lethal control.35452020-07-19T13:49:03.58744287Douglas PorterToo many of these landowners think that they can do as they please. The people object to the cutting down of ancient woodland. Protect the environment and protect Scotland's heritage, ancient forests.35252020-07-19T13:53:09.2344288Helen LennonWe must stop the destruction of our beautiful countryside. No to greed and destruction.\r\n35252020-07-19T15:31:51.19344289Lisa collinsPlease leave the beautifull beavers alone35452020-07-19T17:19:27.77744290Karen O'KaneI am appalled to discover this has not already been criminalised.35602020-07-19T17:41:30.93744291Wendelien MeijerIt's inhumane. Why on earth is it not banned yet?!35602020-07-19T17:42:33.6744292James William Quinn Here's to the relocation of beavers to other part's of the country rather than killing them!35452020-07-19T21:20:20.844293Jane CarnallConversion therapy is both internationally recognised as torture, and also - doesn't work (like any form of torture). You cannot change a LGBT child to a cishet child by any known means whatsoever.35602020-07-19T22:08:42.22344295Elspeth StirlingWith a little cooperation there are beavers co-existing happily with farming in the heart of strathmore. Space for all. No need to kill or translocations. Beaver deceiver keeps field clear and farm uses beaver pool water for irrigation in times of drought. Been this way since Beavers first here. Proud of my farming neighbours. Ashamed of those that bankstrip and cause erosion just to starve out nature. 35452020-07-19T23:17:08.7744296Angela McCallLives of local people are being gravely affected by this project and it is adversely changing the local environment.35252020-07-20T06:41:15.6944300Fiona lynasA family member lives near by it I visit there often35252020-07-20T07:27:18.10344301Jane SearsThis policy of not allowing translocations within Scotland makes a mockery of Scot Gov commitments under the Bern Convention. Organisations like RSPB have offered to host displaced beavers within suitable habitat within the current range yet have been turned down by Scot Gov and SNH. Instead you are giving licences to kill twenty percent of the population. 35452020-07-20T08:55:39.4744302Tim BirchIts disgraceful that so many beavers are getting shot in Scotland. Please support a translocation project for Beavers immediately.35452020-07-20T09:01:29.09744303Susannah PeelI genuinely cannot believe conversion therapy or any kind of promotion of it hasn't been banned years ago! How is it not illegal already? 35602020-07-20T09:04:45.6844304Luke Phillips. Beavers are not apex predators, but they are a keystone species. The changes they make to the landscape are hugely beneficial to entire ecosystems, helping many species find food, water, and habitat. They also have been shown to prevent flooding in vulnerable areas. I am an ecotourist who spends a lot of money visiting Scotland for its wildlife. Please do more to protect it. Stop shooting seals and beavers, protect more, and encourage wildlife watching. 35452020-07-20T09:16:07.5544305Andrew DaviesPlease please please relocate the beavers. Do not kill them needlessly! 35452020-07-20T09:40:11.35744306Chris Learwood Animals can not speak for themselves so we must. If it was a planning decision to build a Dam to save flooding we would say yes so let these creatures thrive and pass a relocation law so they can help other communities across the country not just Scotland Lead the way please and do right by these animals35452020-07-20T09:47:28.54344308Emily Drinkwater Beaver play a crucial role as a 'keystone' species, restoring wetland eco-systems and producing a network of enriched riparian habitats. They should have full protection! 35452020-07-20T11:25:09.9644310Ross WheelerI do believe in more local and less central government. So I therefore support local councils having more powers over taxation, despite their incompetence.35512020-07-20T11:39:40.9644311Gabrielle MadsenGod has given us these precious creatures. We must learn respect because without reverence for them we violate our existence.35452020-07-20T11:46:25.40344312Caroi CalderBeavers are a great benefit to Biodiversity, Hedges built along waterways would increase biodiversity and help protect crops, Hedges would also help reduce Carbon Dioxide.35452020-07-20T12:52:01.644313Iain NicolSurprising and shocking that this is still legal. Signed.35602020-07-20T13:04:22.85344314Joan GrechIt is beyond my comprehension that anyone could consider it acceptable that a fifth of the small population of beavers can be brutally killed. On mainland Europe beavers flourish and even in Britain re-wilding and flood management projects are eager to reintroduce beavers in order to gain the considerable benefits that beavers bring. Even if locally the natural activity of beavers is incompatible with commercial interests the first option should be relocation of the beaver families. There is plenty of suitable land in Scotland for beavers.35452020-07-20T13:50:55.24744315Anthony O'RourkeThere are enough bike tracks. Too many. \r\nThey turn beautiful landscapes into gravelled mess. The hills at the back of Castlemilk used to be a nice walk through grass, now it's twisted aimless gravel paths that hardly anyone uses.\r\nBikes have all the roads traffic can use. They \r\ndon't need to cut into beautiful forests as well. \r\n35252020-07-20T16:07:06.01344316Felix BowersThis is horrible 35452020-07-20T18:02:46.2844319Carol MeachamI have had 2 people I trusted try this on me. It changed nothing and to this day I feel humiliated35602020-07-20T19:16:35.60344320Linda GrahamTrees are the root of life we need them and they need us 35252020-07-20T19:19:19.94744321Vicki RentonWas informed and inspired at an event hosted by Highland One World Centre featuring a presentation about Scotland's Black History. As a Scottish teacher who happens to be white I felt embarrassed being in my 40s and not knowing our nation's black history. I am now aware that there are some amazing resources out there BUT our children need more than a month a year #BlackHistoryMonth 35372020-07-20T19:29:38.41744322Maria LaneWhy are beavers being persecuted in Scotland? Not only is it cruel, they are magnificent waterworks engineers.35452020-07-20T20:14:11.3344325Theo OGBHEMHEIt is a no brainer. I think we can only truly say we are teaching history if it is 'complete'. How? By including Afro-Scottish history 35372020-07-20T20:14:11.81744326Jozef LeestmansBeavers are protected species in EU law, and they create excellent water habitats for lots of different species35452020-07-20T20:31:24.19344327Archie MathisonThe wildlife must be protected 35452020-07-20T22:35:02.05344328Louise RamsayBeaver policy in Scotland needs to change. Allowing relocation to other parts of Scotland for beavers caught in conflict is vital - partly to spread the huge benefits of beavers and partly to offer alternatives to lethal control of a protected species. The shooting of 87 beavers under license in their first year of protection is a tragic mistake and a terrible waste of eco system engineers at a time of biodiversity crisis.35452020-07-21T00:05:12.3644329Gillian KavanaghTrees are the lungs of the world. Ancient forests provide home to many different species of birds, mammals and, insects. The ancient trees also bring an opportunity for us humans to connect with nature in a spiritual sense of awe, trees uplift our weary souls and provide much needed shade on hot days. In Japan forest bathing is recommended for stressed out executives. As a Druid I have a spiritual relationship with the earth and my cathedral is the forest. 35252020-07-21T08:18:16.56344331Gordon WardropePlease protect all ancient woodlands. They cannot be replaced. They are part of our fragmented natural heritage and lifeboats for nature in an ocean of developments. 35252020-07-21T08:45:45.14744332Dorette EngiIt should be a crime to kill a protected animal in a terribly nature deprived country like Scotland or England 35452020-07-21T08:48:47.44344334Trevor Thorogood This cannot be allowed to happen, people have worked so hard to reintroduce these amazing animals back into our countryside! They do an incredible job unlike the people who are wiping them out, you have a beautiful nation, help make it even better by protecting Beavers and their territory.35452020-07-21T11:16:01.52744335Laurel ThomsonConversion Therapy is torture and has no place in a fair society. We need Scotland to lead by example in banning this practice.35602020-07-21T12:27:22.5544336Danyl Speirs"Conversion therapy" is, simply put, torture. You cannot reliably torture someone into believing the same thing as you, and it's amoral and unquestionably wrong to torture the LGBTQ+ youth of today - just as wrong as it always has been, but with the benefit of hindsight. Sort this out. 35602020-07-21T12:36:13.0244337Sally TaylorWhy shouldn't I support this. Lgbt rights, are human rights. 35602020-07-21T12:43:35.39344338Pam Duncan-GlancyConversion therapy is cruel and a breech of human rights. It should be abolished immediately. 35602020-07-21T14:20:39.70744340Leeze LawrenceStamp out conversion therapy from Scotland. 35602020-07-21T14:59:07.33744341Katy MontgomerieConversion therapy on LGBT people is torture35602020-07-21T16:13:35.07344344Ryan MackayPeople should be free to be the person they are inside. 35602020-07-21T16:29:19.62744345Zulaa Fleming The idea and practice of conversion therapy is absolutely horrific, dehuminising and just backwards.35602020-07-21T16:38:47.48744346Sarah-Jane FranklinI am disgusted that this is even legal and happening with the British Isles. It needs to stop, now.35602020-07-21T16:42:31.5544347Sarah-Jane FranklinI am shocked and disgusted that this is legal and happening in Britain. It has to stop immediately and those trying to force people to accept an identity and or sexuality that isn't theirs should be prosecuted for the abuse. 35602020-07-21T16:48:51.51344348Robert CanningIf someone advertised free dental work, told all comers that they needed fillings when they didn't, and started drilling away, with no training or qualifications in dentistry, the law might have something to say.\r\nAnd that's just teeth. "Conversion therapy" is messing with people's heads.35602020-07-21T17:51:32.18744350Lesley AllanCompletely unscientific and abusive35602020-07-21T18:23:37.76344351Ross GibsonThis "treatment" sounds more like a form of torture.35602020-07-21T18:48:58.39744352Charles OwenHomosexuality is found throughout the natural world and it is wrong that a small minority should pressure the majority into thinking it is unnatural and can be altered. This has got to stop.35602020-07-21T20:56:48.2144353Emily Lyon Why should ones sexuality need to be changed this is the same as shocking people with disabilities to conform to a society that u want evryone is different being apart of the lgbt+ community is not a crime nor something anyone should be ashamed of this is not the 1960s so why act like it is 35602020-07-21T21:17:51.69344354Ben Cormack The very thought of conversion therapy still being offered in this country makes my blood boil. I am thankful to have tolerant enough parents that accept me for who I love but I am under no illusion that there are those who would force their lgbtq+ children to undergo such treatment and it is simply inexcusable. These practices should be cracked down upon before they continue to do untold damage to those who have done nought but love who they love. 35602020-07-21T21:50:51.6244355Evan StrachanImagine being told that you must have surgery to change your eye colour, because blue eyes are the only acceptable colour of eyes to gaze lovingly into...35602020-07-21T23:05:12.51344356Sophie AlexanderConversion therapy is torture. There is so much evidence to prove this, and to prove it does nothing but force the person subjected to the therapy to hide who they are by basically becoming phobic of their own identity. When making the ban, please include gender identity conversion therapy. There's too many governments ignoring the trans conversation is just as dangerous as gay conversion therapy.35602020-07-22T07:04:33.4844357Samantha HarrisConversion therapy is inhumane and never should've been legal. It's cruel, it's hateful, and it kills35602020-07-22T07:54:11.64344358mike davidsonI WAS OFFERED CONVERSION THERAPY IN\r\nTORONTO IN 1966 I THOUGHT ABOUT IT & A FAMILY MEMBER SAID BE A MAN AND MAKE YOUR\r\nBODY DO WHAT ITS SUPPOSED TO DO. I HAVE HAD NUMEROUS LOVERS AND MOST FRIENDS ARE GAY.\r\nYOU CANNOT CHANGE A PERSONS \r\nSEXUALITY & RELIGION HAS HURT A LOT\r\nOF GAY PEOPLE\r\n35602020-07-22T08:07:22.45744359Craig StephensonIn a civil society there should be no question that conversion therapy is banned given the harm it does.35602020-07-22T08:15:27.08344360Laura FinnonI do not agree with this at all. People should be free to make their own choices. 35602020-07-22T08:16:03.50744361Fiona DryburghConversion therapy MUST be brought to an end. It has caused untold harm and misery to LGBTQI+ young people and adults. It would be shameful to allow this in any shape or form. 35602020-07-22T11:06:39.74344363Hugh MullinConversion therapy needs to end now to many people have been put through it and its deplorable 35602020-07-22T12:09:58.3944364Felicity MartinI am sickened that the population of a protected species is being decimated, rather than it's recolonisation of our country being supported. The population isn't large enough nor widespread enough yet to sustain this damage and are other options before lethal control of beavers if they are causing problems locally.35452020-07-22T13:11:19.32744365Deborah AllanConversion therapy denies the existence of LGBTQ+ people - it is degrading and a violation of human rights. Stop it.35602020-07-22T13:40:32.3944366Vicky WalkerThis inhumane and tremendously damaging practice must be eradicated from our civilised and forward thinking society where the LGBT community is celebrated35602020-07-22T17:47:48.43744368James KnightI support the translocation of beavers as an alternative to lethal control when they cause damage.35452020-07-22T19:28:26.51344370Hannah moran Stop this35602020-07-22T20:40:52.744371Beluga LagoonSigned. Shocking abuse of a protected species. 35452020-07-22T21:58:04.11344372Gina O NeillI live in an area that has beavers, it is lovely to see the work they are doing, it is not damage but natural water management. 35452020-07-22T22:50:57.49344373Ben HannahStop destroying wildlife. Not hard is it 35452020-07-22T23:33:18.0344374Alison KingHorrific to think this type of archaic practise stool goes on. 35602020-07-23T00:09:07.45744375Les WallaceIn the right places beavers could be helping to conserve other wildlife and prevent millions of pounds of flood damage to farms, businesses and homes, but instead of being moved there they are killed on what is too often a whim. It is far easier to kill a 'legally protected' beaver or move it to a flood reduction trial in England than it is to be moved to another part of Scotland where it could help keep someone's home dry. Scandalous stupidity.35452020-07-23T08:14:25.50344376Barbara HempenstallWhy are we still doing this ... Isle of Man has no badgers yet still have bovine TB!!!!!!35452020-07-23T08:40:45.44744377Elaine MellorStop killing wildlife in UK.35452020-07-23T10:24:13.39744379Delia CummingWhy is it, man's dominion over nature consider themselves superior to the humble wild animals essential for biodiversity...35452020-07-23T10:42:18.08744380Sarah QuinnConversion therapy is fundamentally wrong and tortures those subjected to it. All individuals deserve to have their gender identity respected and supported.35602020-07-23T13:42:56.3944382Claire McCallum An abbhorent practice 35602020-07-23T17:25:00.75344383Hazel TaylorIs it really necessary to try and wipe out all our native wildlife!! To what aim? In my opinion, the UK, as a whole, is losing so much of its flora and fauna through greed, corruption and badly run,\r\nor advised, local councils and government departments. Isn't it time to stop killing?\r\n35452020-07-23T21:43:16.42344384Ryan MulhollandConversion therapy is absolutely disgusting and dehumanizing- we need to put an end to this.35602020-07-24T08:21:34.344387Maureen SturrockPlease preserve these ancient woodlands. They are beautiful and special places which also contribute to the health of the planet and the mental health and wellbeing of human beings. 35252020-07-24T13:09:21.14744389Alastair DriverIt's crazy to be licencing the killing of beavers when 75% of farmers say they'd happily have them translocated, plenty of landowners with suitable land would welcome them and we know they're the most effective catchment restoration tool known to man.35452020-07-24T14:14:41.9844391Ingrid KnightHaving lived in Scotland for 13 years, we know these arguments well, and how easily governments are swayed by powerful farming lobbies, with short-term thinking. Do better Ms Sturgeon!35452020-07-24T16:21:41.89344392John MartinWe loved seeing this species and the superb wetland habitat is created in Scotland last year. Appalling that now it's 'protected' 20% of the currently small population is licensed to be killed 35452020-07-24T16:53:23.2544393Jan Woodward It has been proved Beavers have improved the area they live in and assist in the prevention of flooding. 35452020-07-24T17:19:19.82344394Matthew Hyndmanconversukn therapy is homophobic. It is damaging to one's sense of self. It creates long lasting pain and suffering. Please ban it.35602020-07-24T18:42:53.1944395David Shawit is shocking that Scottish Natural Heritage and the Scottish government show their total lack of concern about the destruction of nature in Scotalnd and seem paralysed by fear when the opportunity to really do something positive arises. Please change the protocols on beavers. Allow them to be translocated and offer other options to shooting - which should be the very last result and only when proof that other solutions have been tried has been produced.35452020-07-24T18:44:48.4144396Ann PricePlease do not kill these special animals35452020-07-24T18:59:58.5744397Dorothy Breckenridge All parties support translocation. So must Scottish Government 35452020-07-24T19:30:24.43344398Caroline KenneilThe source of much of the UK and Scotland's wealth arose directly from our involvement in the Slave Trade. We must learn from this. Today there is as much slavery as ever. Still, the financial system is not working at any level. \r\nThe global Culture, squeazing the Markets for profits by cut throat competition are in Trillions of dollars of debt, the US corporations alone holding $15 Trillion debts in June 2019, pre covide 19. Shares in these indebted companies continued to be bought and sold resulting from regulators enabling companies to insure all problems, but not away. People & the Environment are sick. Global insurnace backing has enabled Hedge Fund Managers to use our Pension funds to buy and sell these lifeless trades creating large commissions, calling this a "flourishing Financial Service Industry". Sucess is short lived, for the success of the debt creating banking economic Model is based upon cutting down margines till we have global slavery, pollution, wars, poverty and economic melt down. The cruelties of this economic model has escalated around the globe and their backers: namely, the global Insurance market, and the Financing Pensions markets are both in Sub-prime debt, this well pre Covid-19, More of the same model would deliver a Kleptocratic totalitarian regeme. But Ahead: we have extra ordinary possibilities arising from the innovations of AI, 3D Printing, robots, near free energy of Plasma and Hydrogen, Microbes, Algaes & fungi, Water Memory, Electro-magnetic fields to name a few, and a landscape to match. A Massive Green Re-generation is the only way foreward. Conflcts of Interest must cease and impartial guiding minds need to ask correct questons, obtain help from Quantum Computers as to the best models and methods of both finance and how to inclusively implement such collective endeavours for our new 'eon'.35372020-07-24T19:42:04.82344399Kevin DalzielThese beavers need to be saved for the good of the countryside 35452020-07-24T22:12:04.2244401Hilary WilliamsNative woodland is essential for the survival of many of our indigenous species. Please do everything possible to help them survive & thrive35252020-07-24T23:45:46.5944402Heather Beale Beavers make a valuable contribution to our countryside and must be free to live there35452020-07-25T08:06:11.7444403Mark JamesThis is utter madness! 35452020-07-25T11:00:42.37344405Ernie ScalesWell beyond time that the Scottish government applied and activated the name in its departmental title - ENVIRONMENT.35452020-07-25T11:09:56.34344406Will GlennBeavers are far more qualified at water management than humans, as we've seen with all the floods we've been having. If Beavers had been around, the risk would have been much less. For the Scottish Government to allow the killing of these creatures is, I believe, CRIMINAL.35452020-07-25T12:34:52.33744410Jeremy CalderwoodIt's always better to work with nature than against it.35452020-07-25T18:52:53.3444411Johann Crawford Trees give us oxygen, store carbon and stabilise the soil. This give life and safety for wildlife35252020-07-26T15:36:40.18344412Dan FooteDestroy the trees is to destroy our planet!35252020-07-26T16:32:47.8744413Patricia LeavyHow is this even being considered?35252020-07-26T16:34:56.02744414Peter ChalmersI hope this isn't someone in council planning acting in a clandestine manner35252020-07-26T16:55:10.35344415Steven M. BrowningConversion Therapy is wrang and shoud niver be a thing. Whit for is it no illegal?35602020-07-26T23:16:15.45344416Geraint MatthewsDo the right thing. Stop needless killings and help improve biodiversity, water quality, flood alleviation and carbon sequestration by allowing this incredible keystone species to thrive nationwide as it once did, and as it should once again. Due to climate change and biodiversity declines, we need beavers more than ever. 35452020-07-27T05:55:37.92744417Joanne LeighWhy would this be allowed and what evidence is there that the numbers are out of control? Is this act going to change native wildlife declines?35452020-07-27T09:34:26.44744419mairi e. macintoshI very much support this petition 35452020-07-27T10:17:31.2544420John LuckwellThe World's ecosystems require 'balance' and that includes trees along with the bees. Trees give us shelter, beauty and most of all, oxygen.35252020-07-27T10:22:30.81344421Julie LoganScotgov talk about planting more trees by 2030 yet are thinking of destroying an old forest! This forest belongs to the people & future generations YOU have NO rights to destroy healthy ancient trees!! These are rare old trees, treasures of Scotland, once cut down they cannot be replacd.35252020-07-27T10:22:59.28344422John LuckwellThe World's ecosystems require 'balance' and that includes trees, along with the bees etc. Trees give us shelter, beauty and most importantly, oxygen. Our woodlands are far more valuable to us than any man-made 'development'.35252020-07-27T10:58:05.15744423Amy-Beth WilliamsonLet religion be a choice, not a mandate. God does not make mistakes. 35602020-07-27T11:01:44.7544424Isabel ForbesI am so saddened that this is still legal. I hope this is disgusting practise is totally wiped out in all of the countries in the UK.35602020-07-27T13:31:44.10344425Laura ClementsConversion therapy is torture, pure and simple. It should be banned under law to protect the LGBTQIA+ community.35602020-07-27T14:06:48.9244426Patrick J Lee\r\n\r\nIn this day of acute climate change and the dangers for the populous therein. We the custodians of the planet must take action NOW. 35252020-07-27T14:41:50.40344428Lindsay Shortit seems totally mad to allow these creatures that can help flood defences to be shot. Why not move them to areas that would welcome their lives?35452020-07-27T15:34:36.0944429Huey McCauleyA no brained...35252020-07-27T17:12:44.5144430Michael watsonwhat is the point of protection if you dish out licenses to kill them?35452020-07-27T18:11:21.1944431satkartar kennedyBeavers are an important part of our ecology system...remember when animals become extinct or are removed by man it upsets the whole balance of nature as it takes a vital link in the chain out...they are natural dam builders...shame to lose them35452020-07-27T18:27:00.9144432Brendan CowanSaving the beaver is important but what we need is a predator for them! Look at Yellowstone and the great impact when the Wolf was reintroduced. Here in Scotland we need the wolf to be reintroduced, which in turn would not only help with beaver but help with our vast vast deer number issues. 35452020-07-27T22:42:43.9644433Sharon MccluskieToo much natural surroundings are being destroyed with unnecessary new builds when regeneration is required in other areas where housing already there. Destroying woodlands for pure financial greed.\r\n\r\nOur children will not known open green spaces locally or what was and should be protected green belt areas!\r\n\r\nMature trees and being felled for no good or justifiable reasons except again financial greed.\r\n\r\nSomething needs to be done now to protect before it is too late.35252020-07-28T01:28:06.9344434Karen EtheringtonRewilding Britain's water systems is an urgent first step towards effective flood management, as well as more sustainable agriculture and the recovery of our wildlife. \r\nBeavers are key to this transition, and farmers across the country need to be incentivised to understand and encourage the benefits they provide. \r\nMuch damage and expense has been caused by trying to control natural water courses and the floodplains they create. Beavers are far more efficient at holding and redistributing excess water as it occurs - and at restoring habitats for myriad wild species too.\r\nThe loss of agricultural land to rewilding would be well offset if the production of fruit and vegetables for human consumption was prioritised over crops for animal feed.35452020-07-28T07:57:29.41344436Elouise MayallThere are a protected species, killing them is illegal35452020-07-28T08:36:07.66744437Janice MurdochWhen will the Scottish government invest in protecting our wildlife? This is becoming a total embarrassment and a national disgrace. Shame on a county that prides themself on diversity and history.35452020-07-28T08:53:41.62344438Jonathan HillLet's show we can explore other alternatives before taking the decision to just kill. We are better than that surely. 35452020-07-28T09:03:37.8344439Sarah DavisI live in a flood zone on the river Soar and would welcome Beavers here to naturally help manage the \r\nRiver.... rewilding is also something I feel passionate about ... 35452020-07-28T10:14:41.99344440Anthony StoneStrongly agree, this is the type of animal protection a modern Scotland should have.35452020-07-28T11:15:40.1944441Catherine Ann BruceWhy is the Scottish Government allowing so many beavers to be killed?35452020-07-28T11:50:08.94744442Nicky AkehurstIt has been shown that beavers are able to control water to ensure no flooding downstream. They also create fertile land surrounding their lodges, which can only improve the fertility some of the surrounding farmland. However, where they are outbreeding their local environment then they should be moved as opposed to being killed.35452020-07-28T12:41:11.3144443Will GlennProtecting an animal means YOU PROTECT ITS LIFE.35452020-07-28T12:53:44.3944444Liz DavidsonThere is absolutely no excuse for killing beavers. Farmers should work with them to accommodate them. 35452020-07-28T13:14:37.5844445Tania PearceBeavers help improve the biodiversity of a landscape, allowing marshlands to form. They once adorned our shores. Please let them do this once more by protecting them and imprisoning anyone, no matter who, who would try to do the Beavers harm. Thank you.35452020-07-28T16:39:38.45744447Ellen RentonMore woodland, less driven grouse moors!35252020-07-28T18:47:06.2844448Leon RobinsonI very much hope that the Scottish Government will continue moving in the direction it showed in protection of wild hares and extend this protection in a meaningful way to reintroduced beavers.35452020-07-28T19:07:06.03344449Erryn MillerI honestly can't believe we even need to petition for this. it's inhumane and evil. 35602020-07-28T19:49:59.68344450Aileen ThomsonManaging all our countryside well requires a holistic approach, not ad hoc decisions are ineffective and damaging. Please rethink and act responsibly and for the future. 35452020-07-28T20:01:01.4344452Tina TeearuBeavers are essential and should be there to restore habitat. Let them be.35452020-07-28T21:27:33.0544454Elizabeth lambert I have seen how quickly a builder can destroy woodland that now lies bare. Don't let this happen protect our ancient woodland.35252020-07-28T23:33:19.25744455Janine Patricia PhillipsPleased to support this island of compassion, common sense and intelligence in a sea of ignorance, greed and cruelty 35452020-07-29T02:03:27.88744457Susan Pfeiffer Please stop35252020-07-29T03:42:02.27344458Elaine Hancockneed trees to breathe35252020-07-29T07:42:40.80344460Adam Loughron No no no... you can't be serious. Protect what little forest and habitat there is left. 35252020-07-29T08:13:46.86344461Michael VineBeavers are doing a great job and should be protected35452020-07-29T08:27:07.3444462Grant WeeksBeavers need to be protected, their activity create ecosystems which encourage endemic fauna and flora to flourish.35452020-07-29T08:50:54.04744463Natalie MartinAt this time of climate emergency, we have to do everything we can to restore nature into a better balance. Please let the good people do their work to move the beavers to save them. 35452020-07-29T08:57:07.0144464Sharri McGarryThis is an important petition...a clear case tying directly with our need for an Ecocide Law. The world is waking up to the fact that we need our mature trees and the ecosystems they support, not for their beauty but for our own survival as a species. 35252020-07-29T09:01:09.56344465Jean BennThis slaughter needs to stop!35452020-07-29T09:05:46.4544467Emma AikaDefinitely! As a kid I wish I knew more about the positive changes people like myself made to the UK35372020-07-29T09:28:33.9944468Patrick MarksI agree that there needs to be a more humane way to manage beavers 35452020-07-29T11:15:18.5844470Lizzie Hilton Nobody training to become a front line worker should worry about falling below the poverty line! Please support future paramedics 35782020-07-29T11:17:29.8344471June ByrneStudent Paramedics should get the same as all other NHS students. Think its ridiculous that they dont receive this. They are working toward a qualification as well.35782020-07-29T11:20:37.42344472leanne kanethey should get the same as nurses35782020-07-29T11:25:16.9944473Jennifer WinchIt is clear through this pandemic that we need more health care workers, including paramedics. They should receive the same financial support as nurses. 35782020-07-29T11:33:48.8544474Richard CameronIn the interest of fairness and for the public good I ask the government to introduce bursaries for those training to be paramedics.35782020-07-29T12:09:54.77744476Bernadette RennieA handclap wont feed you or pay rent!35782020-07-29T12:24:33.04344477Salomè SodiniAs nurse and midwifery students, paramedic students need to face an incredible amount of placements hours (37,5 every week, the same of a NHS full time job) & a demanding course that they don't really leave the chance to get a part time job. In order to help them to complete their degree without costantly struggling for money, a bursary is crucial. 35782020-07-29T12:32:55.4244478Emma GuinnessPlease give students the support they deserve. 35782020-07-29T12:32:58.1444479michelle oneilShould be no obstacles for people studying. They should enjoy the training without added pressures.35782020-07-29T12:56:20.17344480Kathleen HannahI think this should be given to all training members of staff35782020-07-29T13:27:28.83344481Maryann Christie They are every bit as important as student nurses and midwives and should get the same bursary 35782020-07-29T13:33:10.97344483Maja PepperIt is unacceptable. Beavers are part of a natural environment. They lived and co-lived with other animals and humans for millennia. Farming practices need urgent change as they are creating very serious problems on the river courses and degrading the fertility of the soil. With climate emergency, Beavers are vital and a key species for our rivers. 35452020-07-29T14:13:21.5944485Nicola DrummondParamedics should receive this also as they play a vital part in our healthcare35782020-07-29T14:31:29.13744487Paul ReidThere are more humane and better options than what we currently use. 35452020-07-29T14:41:27.23344490Rhiannon CoatsStudent paramedics should receive a bursary equal to student nurses. The bursary should be awarded to compensate for their living expenses and child care due to being on placement where they contribute greatly to the delivery of NHS emergency services. Also as a thank you for their efforts and bravery by going on the emergency register during COVID-19. 35782020-07-29T14:54:27.56344491ellie thomsonStudent paramedics should be entitled to the same as student muses and midwives 35782020-07-29T15:14:47.98744492Eleanor Robertson We need desperately to help balance our eco system 35452020-07-29T15:21:31.22344493Karen Fletcher During the current world pandemic thousands of us have rediscovered our deep connection with our natural world. For many it has saved their mental health from rapid and traumatic decline - we need the natural world to survive and in turn we should be taking every step possible to protect it and help it survive. Please, please stop and think before agreeing to such wanton destruction - our beloved Green spaces need our protection - thank you. 35252020-07-29T15:48:10.86744494Leigh LaurieThis should happen 35782020-07-29T17:10:46.99344495Ben WilliamsTrees are over due the protection buildings get.35252020-07-29T18:05:52.65744497Eileen Henderson What is the point of introducing beavers to cull them in a few years 35452020-07-29T19:51:42.6644498Douglas Cromar Equality for trainees required 35782020-07-29T19:59:21.1944500Jeannie ReillyBeavers are a benefit to nature35452020-07-29T20:29:26.64744501Sandra Thomson Equality should be across the board 35782020-07-29T20:37:08.2744502Pam Archer They deserve the same 35782020-07-29T20:50:25.8544503Susan Lochrie Nurses and midwives get a bursary. Don't understand why paramedics don't. 35782020-07-29T20:52:27.8544504Sandra BrownWe must protect these beautiful animals 35452020-07-29T20:56:26.9644505Murdo MacLeod As a paramedic who qualified at a time when we were funded by the service I fully support the idea of the financial support to assist the students 35782020-07-29T21:36:49.4544507Linda FergusonEqual pay for ALL.... paramedics are needed to get the patients to the nurses, midwives and keep them in jobs ..without paramedics they wouldn't have jobs ..fairs fair . \r\n35782020-07-29T22:56:07.4344510Sally McDonaldThe government needs to remember it is responsible and accountable for nature which is so vulnerable in the hands of money makers. 35452020-07-29T22:56:54.96344511Kathy mcdonaldThese students work hard and need money to exist35782020-07-29T23:39:16.35744512Alison Kirk It is terrible that they are wanting to cull beavers when they've only just reintroduced them. Abominable35452020-07-30T00:21:44.7344513Allan DallasWe are the custodians of this planet and every being on it.\r\nOur duty is to care for the environment, this is our purpose for being here, there's no other reason.\r\nExploiting and harming nature is the opposite of our natural way of life. I hope we as a species get our act together, what we do to nature we do to ourselves, it's right in front of our eyes.35452020-07-30T02:05:49.56744514Marcus BakerAll students need to be supported if their education takes away their ability to work and support themselves independently!35782020-07-30T02:42:38.68744515Melanie DawsonPlease assist beaver populations in the UK. They are vital for healthy rivers & flourishing ecosystems. In the 'decade for biodiversity', every country must pull its weight to protect, restore & regenerate our planet. Thank you.35452020-07-30T06:06:11.71744516Caroline Duncan Come on Scotland! Lead the way and protect our woodlands. 35252020-07-30T08:00:08.12344517Neil Galligan This government's unwillingness to protect Scotland's wildlife and natural heritage flies in the face of their claim to be Scotland's protectors. 35452020-07-30T08:06:41.2844518Natalie McQueenTo not supple a bursary for such a full on course means that such a course is only available to those who are already financially advantaged. This rules out so many wonderful students and limits the number of candidates who will apply. It would be completely impossible to do such a course while working full time - this is taken in to account with all other medical courses and it should be no different here.35782020-07-30T08:26:13.28344520Lynn Kyle I will be one of the qualifying students. I would be grateful if our payments were in line with student nurses. Our course is the same length of time and almost mirrors learning time and placements. 35782020-07-30T08:32:39.16744521Jean MoffatThis country needs paramedics and they need support35782020-07-30T08:40:52.99744522Helen FergusonGood luck folks 35782020-07-30T08:53:33.14744523Scott JohnstonThis is highly unfair that one group gets funding but others don't.35782020-07-30T08:59:25.85344524Mr Joshua R FarquharThis needs to happen35782020-07-30T09:53:15.16744525Joanne ForsythYes very unfair \r\n35782020-07-30T09:55:10.16744526Carolann harropA family member is giving up their job to start training and studying. They will have to work as well to support themselves. I honestly can't see the difference between this and nurses please help our young people who are willingly to dedicate their lives to helping others35782020-07-30T09:56:23.0644527Rhona CockburnI believe it is unfair that they are going to be working within a similar guideline but not getting the same benefits35782020-07-30T10:43:45.4744528Emma wrightBeavers are essential to the ecosystem and need to be protected. 35452020-07-30T12:01:49.54744529Cherie FosterLove your country. No nature? No future. 35252020-07-30T12:01:50.98344530Cherie FosterLove your country. No nature? No future. 35252020-07-30T13:16:19.0144531Sandra Strathie Can Scotland lead the way in treating animals humanely? 35452020-07-30T14:21:09.3444532Ross GoodallWe've not long reintroduced these creatures. We need to do better to help them stay alive and present in this world35452020-07-30T14:43:52.01344533Catherine WilliamsThere is no reason to kill these animals that are so beneficial to the environment!35452020-07-30T15:16:25.1644535Amber McSwainProtect our Land35252020-07-30T15:58:43.5444536Barbara EadeWhy does man have to interfere with nature, leave it alone, they don't bother us. 35452020-07-30T16:12:55.4844537Barb EadeWhat right gives man to destroy our wildlife, nature and environment. These things were on the planet before us. 35452020-07-30T16:14:10.0444538David McnaughtonHappy to support you.35452020-07-30T16:16:02.05744539Beverley MatthewsBeavers don't need to be shot. They can be controlled and managed without killing them. They can be moved safely to another site if they are not wanted where they are. They are brilliant eco-system engineers and can alleviate flooding. We need passive management rather than distructive management of beavers. 35452020-07-30T16:18:59.80744540Lily GrantThis government needs to get their finger out and start protecting beavers. I know farmers face difficulties but these can be managed.35452020-07-30T16:19:08.43344541Christopher WakeleyPlease help preserve beavers.35452020-07-30T16:23:16.5144542john hendriefarmers shoot anything they dont understand. they always blame something else for their poor land management. in this case the beaver !!35452020-07-30T16:40:17.10744544Jan Woodward It has been proven the land benefits greatly from the beavers behaviour eg flooding, habitat for many other species. 35452020-07-30T16:50:31.82744545Dave HilliardI believe beavers are of great benefit to the natural eco-systems and are incredibly useful at helping to prevent flooding and increasing bio-diversity. 35452020-07-30T16:55:08.81344547Maureen HallWe need to find a way to encourage beavers in a sustainable way.35452020-07-30T17:01:16.20344549Steve Clampin What is the point of reintroducing a native species if we then start to kill them as soon as they are in a place that is inconvenient?\r\n35452020-07-30T17:18:50.13744550David EvansThis is another example when the left hand and the right hand are not working in unison. Clear evidence suggests that beaver reintroductions and subsequent habitat change is beneficial for wildlife, for flood prevention and for (pre-Covid) tourism. None of these are served by exterminating animals that inconveniently cause problems for farmers. I acknowledge that these problems can be real, but relocation offers the opportunity to extend the areas that benefit without restricting the possibility such spread will occur naturally. A dead beaver cannot improve habitat elsewhere and cannot have progeny that can spread to to these other (non-agricultural) areas ... a relocated beaver can. I'm pleased to support this petition and hope that it encourages a rapid change in policy by ScotGov.35452020-07-30T17:20:02.97344551John RobinsonValue all life wherever possible35452020-07-30T17:28:01.36344552Marianne BrownPlease don't allow beavers to be killed35452020-07-30T17:28:46.98344553yvonne hopperi dislike the culling of any wild animal, especially when they can be relocated.35452020-07-30T17:30:28.55344554Lucy OsmondImmoral and nonsensical to be killing beavers when there is an available alternative which keeps them alive. Scotland should be ashamed of itself.35452020-07-30T17:33:32.0644555Janet Widdowsbeavers work to manage waterways and flooding, moving them will help to protect land and property efficiently 35452020-07-30T17:36:51.1444556Brenda AllenWe wiped them out. Beavers belong here. Scotland have banned shooting mountain hares, please don't stop there in bringing nature back.35452020-07-30T17:37:04.71744557Alan FraserIt is shameful & embarrassing that modern Scotland allows the killing of beavers in this manner. I acknowledge that the illegal release of beavers on Tayside was unhelpful to the missing species reintroduction movement. However, other similar European countries are able to adapt with little difficulty to the close proximity of beavers, people & agriculture. England is welcoming the return of beavers. Translocation to the many areas of Scotland where they would only be of benefit to the economy & environment is the obvious way forwards where beavers are genuinely incompatible with local economic interests. I hope the Scottish government will recognise & act on the genuine public outrage over this issue.35452020-07-30T17:42:44.94344558Valerie IrelandWe need as many beavers as we can keep going as they prevent flooding.35452020-07-30T17:43:19.56344559Hamish McLeodWhat is the point of having a species with protected states if 20 per cent of the population can be legally killed!35452020-07-30T17:52:59.4744561Lucie MaguireThese habitat-creating, biodiversity-boosting, flood-preventing creatures are a PROTECTED SPECIES... please respect the law and allow beavers to make their unique contribution to rescuing our landscape from human ignorance... thank you !35452020-07-30T17:57:08.48744563Rose SpencerSave all the Scottish Beavers!35452020-07-30T17:59:18.37744564Nancy ClarkeReport out today regarding dangerous loss of native mammals, of which beavers are an important species. Please protect them fully and stop the killing of these animals.35452020-07-30T18:02:45.4144565Eileen CameronPlease, please Scottish Government stop dragging your heels on environmental matters. Scotland has the potential to be so much richer in wildlife than it is. We have lots of space and yet we are poor in bio-diverse flora and fauna.35452020-07-30T18:06:59.38744566Susan IrvineWe need to change the whole way we think about our fellow-animals and our shared environment. Please protect the beavers35452020-07-30T18:10:24.73744567Peter RileyPlease stop lethal control of beavers35452020-07-30T18:12:51.80744568Sandra HilliardBeavers are far more use to us alive than dead. I believe its wrong to cull them and we should be working towards rewilding Scotland. 35452020-07-30T18:19:22.49744569Theresa Joan HughesCheck out Holland and their tolerance of beaver. We are pathetic as a nation to keep hammering anything that gets in the way of us increasing a profit.35452020-07-30T18:20:59.33344570Judith Jones I am beyond disgusted that these creatures were killed instead of being relocated 35452020-07-30T18:22:28.6744571Michael BishopIt is right to bring back creatures that used to live on these islands and were wiped out by humans. Beavers need all the protection we can give them.35452020-07-30T18:35:27.244572Michael EnticottIt makes absolutely no sense to block the relocation of beavers which have been reintroduced to improve biodiversity and benefit the landscape, to an area where they could improve the landscape but instead to kill them.35452020-07-30T19:06:26.24744573mathieu poudretplease don't kill the beavers35452020-07-30T19:16:44.12344574Robert PriceI would urge the Scottish Government to do everything possible to protect, not annihilate, beavers. They are at a critical stage of re-introduction into the wild. The situation can be managed without recourse to lethal controls. Please don't let these remarkable creatures die.35452020-07-30T19:20:40.67744575Ruhiena Duffin In an age and time of a global ecological and enviromental crises this seems a very response to such a crisis.35452020-07-30T19:21:33.11344576Wendy SharpI am pleased to sign this petition and can not support a government prepared to kill beavers. Protection must be offered to beavers. There is no reasonable excuse for using this method of control. Studies have shown they bring environmental benefits which help with flooding in the long term. 35452020-07-30T19:32:24.3244578Philip TaylorI was outraged to hear that beavers are being routinely culled in Scotland. This is madness. Surely relocation is a far better option. Even so how can beavers re-establish themselves if agricultural areas are deemed no go areas. An accommodation between beavers and farmers must be found. 35452020-07-30T20:02:28.50344579James HutchesonIt is utterly ridiculous that a species should try to be reintroduced and simultaneously killed under licence when there are ample areas they could be rehomed within this country. This attitude of wilful culling of animals needlessly shows what scant regard some people have for nature and the entitlement in believing that nature should bend to our needs rather than the other way around. 35452020-07-30T20:51:53.40744581Morag FergusonWe should be supporting wildlife and using all measures possible to avoid causing them suffering and distress35452020-07-30T21:07:46.97344582Sandra GourlayTotally unfair 35782020-07-30T21:27:44.84344583Louise WitterCompletely counterproductive policy to allow reintroduced populations to be killed.35452020-07-30T21:38:53.06344584Joyce MarriottSo disappointed that licences were granted to kill these wonderful creatures. This shames our country. Stop this cruelty now. 35452020-07-30T21:51:45.2744585Tim ClarkeI think it's outrageous, when everyone should be doing what they can to protect wildlife and improve diversity, that the Scottish Government allows beavers to be killed.35452020-07-30T22:19:00.0344586Ben Larsenyes\r\n35252020-07-30T22:51:55.65344588Mr Royd Charles SandersShould be a crime to cull an endangered species when they could be relocated and then well deserve protection.35452020-07-30T23:00:58.24744589Annie MassonWe've visited the National Nature Reserve near Crinan where the beavers are. The landscape there has been really enhanced. Its vital to protect them and outrageous this killing has been sanctioned. They should be creating greater understanding. We are in a climate energency and need to protect and enhance landscapes not denude them through ignorance 35452020-07-30T23:33:02.11744590Theresa Thomson Beavers have only recently been reintroduced into Britain. I believe that they need protection from selfish people who care only of their own gratification. Keep beavers safe by law35452020-07-30T23:37:25.9744593Roger ClayTotal madness to kill rather than move.35452020-07-31T07:09:15.1244594Betty AlbonWhat a ridiculous situation - protect them, and then give licences to kill them. The Scottish Government MUST do more to protect and encourage beavers35452020-07-31T07:45:32.34344596Stephen JohnstoneCulling of these creatures is absurd , the Scottish government that I have supported and voted for at every election should do what the bulk of people want and not cow tow to a few unenlightened farmers and landowners.Our rivers and waterways can only become healthier and much more diverse with beavers being left to do what they do best and should be relocated to other areas throughout our country if local numbers increase.35452020-07-31T07:45:37.6444597Steve ToozeBeavers are a keystone species for the desperately needed rewilding of our country. Please translocate these animals to other areas that need them rather than exterminating them because its a quick & easy solution. Show compassion & leadership here35452020-07-31T08:08:57.86344598Graham BusbyBeavers are thriving in the west country with no hint of victimisation, what a shame this is happening in Scotland. 35452020-07-31T08:56:18.4644599Alison WhiteInhumane to kill these creatures when they can be relocated and benefit the environment 35452020-07-31T09:37:37.26744601Lucy victoria OldhamBeavers are important for river ecosystems. Leave them be!!! 35452020-07-31T10:20:46.644602Geoff RobinsonAn absolute disgrace that the Scottish Goverment is not fully protecting the Beaver after allowing the reintroduction To issue licences to lethally control beavers on the Tay catchment is totally insane when other much more suitable areas are crying out for Beavers where there are few people.Shame on you Scottish Goverment.35452020-07-31T10:29:21.88344603Matt GilbertMadness that beavers are at once 'protected' and yet, when other areas are crying out for them and translocation is possible, they are instead shot and killed. It's farical and wrong.\r\n\r\nDo the sensible, moral, and ecologically sound thing!35452020-07-31T10:45:12.13344604gail emoPlease don't kill beavers.35452020-07-31T11:02:29.49744606Phyllis MacraeMore beaver dams,less flooding.35452020-07-31T11:51:07.20744607Valerie NasonI am signing this petition because no matter where we live in the World, cutting down old growth forests or even new forests is an act of aggression toward our Mother Earth.35252020-07-31T14:05:37.19344609Amanda Young We reintroduce them then kill them?????\r\nAbsolutely ridiculous!!!! 35452020-07-31T14:10:11.44344610Andrew CecilRewilding must be the priority!35452020-07-31T14:17:05.69344611Julia HumeBeavers can help to control flooding and do not eat fish35452020-07-31T14:38:11.5444612Jean WrenHaving been brought up in the Scottish countryside during the war with a plethora of wildlife and bountiful flora, I returned in the eighties to a much diminished wildlife scene. By the time I left 7 years ago, wild flowers in the intensive dairy farming countryside were few and far between, hares had disappeared totally,hedgehogs were rare, songbirds were drastically reduced and many totally absent. I am very disappointed in the Scottish government's inability to recognise the importance of nature for both the country and its people.Beavers could be such a help to controlling flooding and improving our environment. It is high time that giving in to farming blindly is a recipe for disaster eventually. The farming community must be prepared to work with nature instead of destroying it as a matter of course.35452020-07-31T15:08:13.26344613Dawn RobertsonI am dedicated to protecting as much wildlife as possible in every way. Beavers has as much right to exist as people and if they are doing harm somewhere they should be moved to a place where they'd be welcome. I will help all wildlife as much as I possibly can.35452020-07-31T15:24:46.04744614Simon CopeThere are practical solutions to all these conflicts. It just requires a conversation and agreement between conservationists and land managers.35452020-07-31T18:23:34.11744615Jonathan Kinghorn Action speaks louder than words stop sitting on your hands and show that you care about everything in Scotland not just big ticket issues35452020-07-31T18:59:56.38744616Mellisa DeanThese wonderful creatures have a right to live here, before we humans made them extinct. How can we live with ourselves if we do not take this opportunity to our past mistakes right? The beavers deserve a voice and we must be it. 35452020-07-31T19:01:31.57744617Michelle ThomassonBeavers are a beautiful keystone species, we need them now more than ever to help us combat the destructive stresses and biodiversity loss we have created.35452020-07-31T20:14:06.3644618Sue ClarkeBeavers are beautiful animals and very useful for the environment. 35452020-07-31T21:25:09.78344620Doreen Longmuir Why does government think killing our wildlife is acceptable 35452020-07-31T21:44:38.4244621Ruth AtkinsonBeavers near me are doing a great job of bringing water and wildlife in places they have had for centuries. And they bring a special quality to the upper Tay that is makes it feel that they belong here.\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n35452020-07-31T21:50:35.544622Sara SalyersYou are dropping the ball more and more often on urgent environmental protections. Stop 'pleasing' important people and start doing the right thing no matter what - the way you once did!35452020-07-31T22:05:04.39344623Ted McGeeHow do you expect these students to pay bills and survive without a wage.They are working on a career which is needed to save peoples lives.35782020-07-31T23:26:59.62344625christine watsonWaht madness to re - introduce a species and licence to kill it at the same time. Is this a way of capitalising on hunting?35452020-08-01T04:57:57.69344626Helen SmithBeavers are a known keystone species creating new but different ecosystems. Farmers should be supported to understand the long term changes and any relevant mitigation without licences being issued. Beavers should be translocations as a last resort but certainly not shot 35452020-08-01T07:53:46.8644627Richard JohnsonThis is wrong in So many ways, your allowing these Beautiful animal to be murdered, when its proven that Beavers help against flooding, plus in another part of the UK environmentalists reintroducing Beavers35452020-08-01T08:11:33.78344628Margaret CrawIf paramedics are to do the same as nurses, they deserve the same recognition, they should also keep up to date with training and pay their registration every year35782020-08-01T10:04:36.3644630Rebecca Oakley Help save the beavers 35452020-08-01T10:04:49.23744631Alexander TaitFully support35452020-08-01T10:19:24.1644632Shim ArnoAs the current ScotGov holds itself up as the viable future of an independent Scotland then it had better start promoting confidence and stop acting like the archaic institutions of old who basically supported ecological degradation and wildlife persecution in Scotland. I think we would all be encouraged and would like to know they are moving with the times and reading the modern science. We hope they understand importance of reversing the above mentioned trends which have brought Scotland to the depleted environmental mess it is in now. It is time the ScotGov pulled its finger out on these issues starting with proper support and policy for beaver reintroduction. They say they love and care about Scotland - then show us.35452020-08-01T10:20:57.6944633Evelyn WrightWe must stop this35452020-08-01T10:23:12.23744634Derek RobertsonIt is a national disgrace that beavers are being killed rather than relocated. Please rectify this situation.35452020-08-01T10:25:53.25344635fraser watson relocate the beavers to the highlands.. d not kill them .. Scottish Heritage has become, Scottish Heracy ... with all their licenses to kill birds and animals.. wake up to this .... x fraser35452020-08-01T11:27:56.2344636barbara brysonsave the beavers. why waste the opportunity of 35452020-08-01T11:46:51.98344639Sue noyceWhy kill any animal? Especially ones that make such a positive environment change. There needs to be a wholescale change in how this is managed. No licences for killing anything should be issued. Strong measures should be in place to encourage support for sustainable environment improvement.35452020-08-01T13:24:34.9744640Nancy KennedyPlease uphold protections for beavers.35452020-08-01T13:43:30.45344641John Tyrrellwe should be encouraging rewilding, not killing wildlife35452020-08-01T13:59:56.3344643Ruth LindsleyThere is absolutely no need to cull a re-introduced species when much better and humane alternatives are available. 35452020-08-01T14:02:06.98744644Ruth LindsleyIt is criminal in my opinion to cull a re-introduced and protected beavers when there is a much better way to deal with it, by relocating them! 35452020-08-01T14:03:08.11744645Madeleine J C MasseyIt is a shock that beavers were killed in Scotland as farmers? were not happy with them. Anglers and farmers in Germany actually like them - beavers help with flooding and provide habitat for tiny fish to develop, improving river ecology. Many other forms of life benefit from habitat made by beavers- more insect larvae in water will help bird life too.35452020-08-01T14:28:03.22744647Kellie Barnes It's shocking that paramedics don't get funding yet other nhs students do. It should be equal to all students 35782020-08-01T16:27:57.3444648Caroline ThomsonWhy cull beavers when they can be relocated? A beautiful animal that can fit into an ecosystem elsewhere in Scotland so why not?35452020-08-01T18:37:04.48344649Emma WhitfieldWhat does protected species mean in Scotland? It is disgraceful that beavers are being killed rather than moved. 35452020-08-01T18:42:46.89744650Chris RoseWaht's the point of restoring species to the UK only to start shooting them straight afterwards?????35452020-08-01T18:45:42.84344651Roselyn TwellWho is policing this to make sure beavers are not being overkilled?35452020-08-01T19:20:50.10744652EDWARD Duncan This is an excellent proposal. 35452020-08-01T20:05:50.36344654Peter patersonManage not kill35452020-08-01T20:31:30.44344655Nim KibblerWe need to learnt o embrace these creatures and use their ecosystem engineering to our benefits. Increasing relocation would really assist with this35452020-08-01T22:45:11.5144656Ruth GillettIt angers me that an animal is reintroduced only to be persecuted. These animals must be protected and moved rather than killed35452020-08-01T23:36:42.85744657Liz AngusOur wildlife is suffering. You can save it35452020-08-01T23:46:26.1144658Susan HilliardBeavers are beneficial to environment.35452020-08-02T01:32:16.79744659Phill BrownSuch a majestic beautiful little animal I hope they get the help they deserve35452020-08-02T07:03:39.7944660HELEN CARLYLESave the trees35252020-08-02T07:27:58.744661Linda MalpasI was dumbfounded when I heard of beavers being shot as a means of control, by farmers!! I thought they were a protected species!! Surely they can be controlled with non-lethal methods. Seems like this is the lazy way out - typical of the Scottish government's modus operandi (& why UK nature is in such a precarious state!!) For the sake of nature, of climate & ecological protection & so that our children and grandchildren have a future, get off your bottoms, Scottish government, and sort this out!! Please!!35452020-08-02T08:49:35.10344662Anila LadwaWe have no right to cull beavers and deny them their natural habitat. STOP this curelty. 35452020-08-02T09:17:51.74744663Pamela CawthorneI am more than happy to support a petition that protects beavers, such a vital creature! 35452020-08-02T09:39:51.23344664Michele Mclintock No need to kill other beings, if they are interfering with unman work just move them elsewhere more appropriate.35452020-08-02T09:39:52.1144665Michele Mclintock No need to kill other beings, if they are interfering with human work just move them elsewhere more appropriate.35452020-08-02T09:40:12.95344666Laura McGregorDo the right thing: save the Beavers & the environment. 35452020-08-02T10:24:42.1244667Maggie FreegardThere are many places in the UK including where I live in Cornwall where beavers can be relocated.35452020-08-02T11:00:43.7844668June Small Stop killing!!!35452020-08-02T13:17:01.31344669Ron BaronTranslocation is infinitely more preferable to killing. There is clear evidence that management skills exist to ensure that translocation can be successfully achieved and will ultimately prove a benefit to the environment. 35452020-08-02T13:19:08.35744670Heather SmithThere is no justification for culling beavers. They should be relocated if necessary. ScotGov should seek advice from successful beaver reintroduction programmes.35452020-08-02T14:44:58.93744672Graham CampbellI support this petition as a member of Glasgow City Council Education and Early Years City Policy Committee. I would like to see the National Curriculum amended so that a key learning outcome is that students know about African history prior to its encounters with European enslavers. We Africans have a past civilisation and culture much of which lent itself to the development of European civilisation. To stop the recreation of racist thoughts, feelings and ideas the Scottish people need a proper history of their country in the context of a world where Europe is not the only source of knowledge and culture and that the Scottish colonial footprint across Africa, Asia and the Caribbean is fully acknowledged. This petition is an important step in eliminating the traces of that misleading and non-historical legacy that justifies white supremacy in our education system.35372020-08-02T16:20:18.7744675Giscard kuimiVery good petition35372020-08-02T16:50:52.4344676Selena feelyWe should definitely be teaching Scottish history good or bad 35372020-08-02T18:57:07.51344678Valerie NordbergBeavers are an asset not a liability so the idea of killing them is abhorrent when an easy and profitable solution is to catch and transfer to a region where they can repair the ecosystem.35452020-08-02T20:57:53.2544679Linda johnston We need them as part of our environment 35452020-08-02T21:07:35.4544680Dave CumminsSo, so important for the future and well being of the planet....35252020-08-02T21:49:25.72344681Julie TempletonI would also like to see the true Scottish history taught too35372020-08-02T21:55:37.9944683Daye TuckerMy whole life has been spent in relative ignorance about our involvement in profiting from African suffering. Future generations must be better informed. I now look at the beautiful species trees brought here by the Plant Hunters, so much beauty possibly funded from cruelty.35372020-08-02T21:59:58.0444684Joan PringleStop the slaughter35452020-08-02T22:08:31.22344685Philip GravesHow can we self-righteously condemn the Brazilian Government for burning the Amazon Rain-forest when we look after our own "rain forest" so poorly - allowing overgrazing by deer and sheep and choking by invasive species.35252020-08-02T22:31:36.444686Deena WalkerTrees are one of our greatest defenses against climate change. They must be preserved and protected to help us in the fight against climate catastrophe. They are also a vital ecological force and for this reason should be protected at all costs.\r\n35252020-08-02T22:46:21.5944687Deborah Cain We've just reintroduced, these animals why are they being killed when there are alternatives?35452020-08-02T23:53:42.5544688Mark RaffertyBeavers deserve proper protection.35452020-08-03T02:15:26.83744691Christine HardingProtect these amazing creatures.35452020-08-03T02:55:30.8144692Kate Neilson Can we come up with some way of supporting the badgers without killing them. I don't agree with the cull. People have the right to love and enjoy our wildlife. If we kill our wildlife we will only have a photo of what they looked like in the future and all because some people can't get their head around how we can live side by side. 35452020-08-03T04:06:47.3444693Amaya AlvarezAll wildlife reintroduction needs to be managed and requires interventions to ensure success. Beavers are not at numbers to be 'culled' moving them makes much more sense, as they are too vulnerable and are facing the challenges of changed natural systems. Yes farmers have rights in this but many of them are happy for removal as well as part of a comprehensive wildlife management approach. In Australia many of our endangered or displaced animals have to be managed alongside agriculture, and have to be 'managed' proactively to ensure reintroduction is successful - koalas, wombats are among species that have to be relocated and reintroduced in areas where there is remnant habitat. 35452020-08-03T06:49:46.09744694Caroline JesselBeavers are great! 35452020-08-03T07:27:24.6944696Ruwan Uduwerage-PereraWhy would Afro-Scottish history not be taught given the physical presence and influence, for good and bad, of Scots in recent African history?35372020-08-03T09:45:11.08344697Neil ScooAs a teacher, and an Irish Scot, I know history I essential to belonging. I feel every new Scot should have access to their roots. Everyone's roots should be encouraged to spread and b stronger. Firm, confident, roots ensure confident people. Equality starts with ensuring all our citizens feel recognise, legitimised - seen - by our society. 35372020-08-03T10:01:09.7944699 Fiona MacdonaldWe (the human race) can not abuse the natural environment any further otherwise the planet will stop being about to support the over population of humans. We know that the more of one species will destroy the life cycle of any environment therefore a balance is essential. The beavers will develop an special environment for more wildlife and therefore restoring balance, retaining water to prevent flooding down the glen, encourage more trees to grow in the gaps they make, keep deer away for eating new saplings, more trees more birds and the balance returns. PROTECT OUR EVIRONMENT!!!!! 35452020-08-03T10:06:34.9644700Gavin ShanksI love the Loch Coille Bar, Beaver habitat in Knapdale & can see evidence of the benefits to habitat Beavers confer. 35452020-08-03T10:07:30.47344701Mathieu KervynThis cause has my full support.35452020-08-03T12:02:21.52744702Stanley GrossmanParliament must ensure that any team allocated to pursue this suggestion does not contain members having a hidden political agenda. The Scottish Government recently had its fingers burned over a proposed Palestine Teaching Resource formulated by teaching and union activists with racist and anti-Semitic associations. Government oversight found significant problems of balance and objectivity leading Education Scotland to announce itself unable to endorse the Resource.35372020-08-03T13:23:32.7244703David Howdle-smith Since 1970, 60% of wild animals have disappeared. We are in the middle of one of the greatest species extinction in history. Intensive farming has been identified in numerous reports as the main cause of species loss. If the Scottish Government are serious about tackling the climate and environmental emergency we are in they must be robust and show some backbone or fall at the first hurdle.35452020-08-03T13:26:52.85344704Des O'Sullivan Understand history to have a better future. Children are the future.35372020-08-03T14:10:46.1344706Rona MillerI have looked into this as far as possible and although I have some sympathy for people protecting land and housing, it does not ring true that 87 beavers would be killed for this reason, so the killing must stop, and penalties imposed on perpetrators. Presumably there would be a humane way of deterring them building in undesirable locations.35452020-08-03T14:34:55.7444707Rita FindlayThere are few green spaces left and they need to be protected. So many species rely on the tres and flora we should not be destroying these habitats. Keep them precious and save them for all of us to enjoy.35252020-08-03T15:52:49.5544709Heather MasseyWe must protect UK wildlife35452020-08-03T16:24:05.97744711Leeze LawrenceTorture of of a human being to closet their truth or be prevented from living ones truth should and forever should be illegal, and punishable. Lets commit ourselves to a Scotland, where everyone can live free from discrimination, fear and truth. away from the veil of ignorance and intolerance.35602020-08-03T16:49:49.98744712Antoinette Ballantyne Bursary should be paid. Disgrace that we need a petition to get one 35782020-08-03T17:09:20.1144713Wanda gorzkowskaBeavers can u understand flooding and use their dams to prevent flooding as has been proven. They are useful animals 35452020-08-03T17:27:35.56344714Stephanie PeayWhilst the unauthorized introduction should not have happened, there are other measures available now to avoid having to kill the beavers in Tayside. These include translocation to other areas, compensation for businesses if there is actual financial loss (tolerance), or purchase of the affected land, to allow room for partial re-naturalizing of the river valley (enhancement). Retaining the beavers and accepting some localized changes in the river valley has both environmental and social benefits, albeit there may be a need for mitigation in a few areas, e.g. if individual homes are directly affected by beaver activity. Those of us living in lowland areas will benefit from the slowing of the flow in river catchments, keeping water in wetlands and rivers for longer to benefit wildlife, conserve water resources and help to reduce spate flows. Whether by beavers alone, or by a combination of beavers, managed set-back and riparian enhancement, there is an urgent need to make space for rivers. This is so in Scotland and other parts of the UK. I ask ScotGov to reconsider the policy on beaver control.35452020-08-03T17:48:11.56744716Teal SkinnerI am a paramedic student in Scotland and would GREATLY benefit from this! It is also given to paramedic students in England already but not Scotland. 35782020-08-03T18:04:58.39744717Elaine Rees With so much scientific evidence supporting the benefits to our mental health of spending time with nature, we owe it to generations to come to preserve our ancient woodlands and the biodiversity supported within them.35252020-08-03T19:26:19.86744720Gillian ArmstrongIt is really important to plant more trees and also to protect native species of wildflowers and trees. Also we should be looking out for wildlife before any kind of change takes place in the environment around is. It is definitely not fair on birds or animals to destroy their habitat during the breeding season.\r\nPlease think very carefully before more land is destroyed.35252020-08-03T19:43:47.45744721Claire Shepherd No bursery provision for paramedic students is an unfair practice. Change needs to happen 35782020-08-03T19:59:00.38344722Andy dunlopThese beautiful animals help the countryside 35452020-08-03T20:30:39.52744723Junaid AshrafFantastic work Eunice and I'm really glad to have been involved in the planning of the petition. Can't wait to work on the next steps together!35372020-08-03T20:53:47.89344724William AndersonThe Scottish Govt should be mindful of the fact that environmental issues are becoming the main focus of everyones attention. So to hold a newly introduced, protected and such important species in such disregard will not go down to well come May's election!35452020-08-03T21:07:52.95344725Terrence PicklesWords fail me. The loss of any type of woodland in today's current climate is going backwards not forwards. 35252020-08-03T21:12:17.47744726Alastair KnealeAbsolutely essential that these precious woodlands are protected.35252020-08-03T21:53:16.54344727Lindsay SmithWe need to protect the ancient woodland we have left and get planting a whole lot more 'natural' woodland - not blanket coniferous forestry35252020-08-03T22:05:47.1444728Geraldine McEwanAfro Scottish history deserves it's place in our history.. I was never aware of our involvement in the slave trade until my adult life. Scotland owes this to the future generation. It's about time we choose to . Teach the truth once and for all. 35372020-08-03T22:54:44.77344729Maria HearyThink of the wildlife you destroy. Leave trees alone please. 35252020-08-03T23:29:56.30744731Sir Arthur Edwin Turner VCI fully agree with the petitioner. It is disgraceful that legal protection has been enacted by the Scottish Parliament for Beavers yet now death awaits them. Expand their range and end this wanton destruction of our heritage.35452020-08-04T00:45:26.3544732Dannii YoungHow is this still a thing in Scotland? I thought it had been banned years ago. 35602020-08-04T06:22:41.37744734Cherie Bradley African literature could easily be incorporated into the syllbus. I know people think they don't like change but good things happen when we progress. 35372020-08-04T07:35:34.60744735Ellen CoughlannWe must preserve this woodland. Listen to the experts, the scientists, the people who know. Are we turning into the Congo where rare species are being destroyed and we are horrified by the effects. If not then why are we doing the same thing. This is so wrong.35252020-08-04T08:13:53.32744736James J PatonSensible environmental and science favours translocation. Mere, flawed, economics, arable or otherwise is not a sustainability approach not sound ecologically. 35452020-08-04T08:36:11.844737Stella WinksStop this barbaric and unnecessary killing! They are an indigenous species! Not on! 35452020-08-04T10:33:55.08344740Darla BrewerSo important to protect areas such as these. 35252020-08-04T11:26:57.63744742Gordon McRobertThe beaver was re-introdcued under this government and rather than give in to these interests has given legal protection to them. Those are the facts. I am signing this petition because I believe if landowners and managers would welcome beavers elsewhere then relocation from areas where they are not valued and cause damage is much preferred to culling.35452020-08-04T11:59:31.6444743David CarterWhy are we killing beavers? Have we lost our senses completely? If they are a nuisance translocate them. Simple. No need to kill. We have become a kingdom of butchers and greedy businessmen, so greedy that have lost all our compassion and understanding. It see's that Scotland is a major offender in the massacre of beavers was well as the massacre of birds of prey. 35452020-08-04T12:22:05.3844744Ann CollyerOur well-managed beavers in Devon are proving very useful in flood control. It can be done.35452020-08-04T15:02:37.2644745Geoff RobinsonTotally insane killing a protected species just to placate farmers, many of whom can only survive in farming because of taxpayers money many of whom want beavers to thrive in Scotland .Surely any problem beavers could be easily caught and moved to much more suitable areas,with a very small human presence .35452020-08-04T15:16:2844746Jennifer HattePlease save and relocate these beautiful and essential animals. 35452020-08-04T16:09:06.1544747Alastair (Sandy) StuartThis should protect the beavers without harming the interests of farmers or other local interests.35452020-08-04T16:11:52.5144748Rizy Mohammedit is imperative we teach our children the brutal truth in its entirety..opposed to one si..ngular facet of history.35372020-08-04T16:21:29.05744749Sid KhanHistory from all the colonies including India 35372020-08-04T17:31:10.67744750Habeeba Ashraf Amazing initiative! 35372020-08-04T20:15:42.30744753mr stephen atigahWe have a share past 35372020-08-04T20:22:14.07744754Stuart Johnston Conversion therapy is an evil, disgusting and immoral practice that needs to be banned forever. 35602020-08-04T20:41:34.64744757Sajida BismilIn order to learn from past mistakes and atrocities we must share an honest, unbiased, warts and all account of our historical endeavours.35372020-08-04T21:12:28.4344760Hannatu GambaIf is time the Scots understand the place of Scotland in African history & why we are here today.35372020-08-04T22:01:24.29744763Pauline BrookesProtecting our natural world and caring for our environment has never been more pressing and important. Please act to protect wildlife and biodiversity 35452020-08-04T22:58:13.5744764Tom Hamilton The Scottish government is exceedingly slow as per mountain hares. Legislation passed. Still being culled 35452020-08-04T23:14:38.9944766Tressa BurkeIt is vital that we acknowledge the role our cities and countries haven played In history and that we learn from this to avoid making mistakes of the past35372020-08-04T23:57:46.96744768Talmadge Bethel This is very critical at this time,\r\n35372020-08-05T04:17:2744771Sheila KrausThe environment needs beavers35452020-08-05T04:44:32.68744772Graham RossMust do now, we do not have a lot of time.35252020-08-05T06:33:37.4544773Debra HallThis kind of flooding is inevitable as climate emergency increases. Stop all the Sitka planting. It is not helping.35252020-08-05T06:52:34.2444774Pauline Brookes Biodiversity and environmental protection has never been more important. Please act to preserve and not destroy 35452020-08-05T07:07:24.8744775Grace ManyiksLike David livingstone is taught to us as children and adults, Children need to know the truth about the real about the 401+ year relation between Africans, Scots and Brits history including how scotland was built and acquired the wealth it continues to enjoy today. Like David Livingston all other slave masters celebrated in street names and buildings need to be taught. At adult in America the families of the slave masters and the families the enslaved are meeting to reconcile as most turn outrelated. Yet the enslaved families are not included in the current wealth. 35372020-08-05T07:32:55.82744776Rosalind CheyneOur native woodlands need our protection.35252020-08-05T07:36:41.3144777Sophie FluxPlease stop killing Beavers and relocate them instead.35452020-08-05T07:37:06.87344778Roz BrooksPreserve ancient woodlands makes sense. Flooding is increased and wildlife disappears.35252020-08-05T07:42:43.84344779Darren LewisEverything we do against nature, we do to ourselves.35252020-08-05T07:46:20.61744780Sandy GallowayIf there is not room for all the animals on the planet then there is not room enough for too many humans.35452020-08-05T08:19:46.0844782Anna OwsiankaIt is unbelievable that the Scottish Govt has allowed the shooting of 20% of the Scottish beaver population over the past year. There are only about 500 beavers in Scotland, in two areas, along the river Tay and in Knapdale. They cannot easily spread to other suitable habitat, because they do not climb mountains or travel along coastlines. For beavers to be re-established in Scotland, they must be translocated from these two isolated populations to other suitable areas, instead of being killed.35452020-08-05T08:36:54.3944783Julia CawthorneVital that this is made part of the curriculum. Long overdue but so important. 35372020-08-05T09:59:4244784Elizabeth WallaceDisgusting. Humans putting themselves above every other species as usual.35452020-08-05T10:37:38.05344785Allan IrvinePlease stop killing animals, beavers are great for riverways. Why is it always the easy answer to kill something rather than coexist.35452020-08-05T10:49:40.8444786Eileen Henderson1 in 5 beaver killings is totally unacceptabl. So much for being protected species. 35452020-08-05T11:21:41.2344787Vincent KiddA holistic approach and time, rather than 'killing it' mentality may be beneficial in unforeseen ways...35452020-08-05T12:26:40.83344788Helen Martin I would like to get more involved. I have a ten acre oak and hazel wood in south Perthshire and supporting its biodiversity 35252020-08-05T13:37:51.75344790Rudolph BarIf certain trees need to be protected, would it be possible to wind some chicken wire around the trunk?35452020-08-05T14:13:44.22744791Lorraine biswell Please stop this 35452020-08-05T14:31:08.5944793Joan MaltStop killing beavers35452020-08-05T14:41:31.29344794Kelly HollidayAbsolutely vital part of everybody's education.35372020-08-05T15:03:22.9744795Mohammed haqVery important something which if addressed will help youngsters in hard situation early on in life\r\n35832020-08-05T15:12:16.28344797MR PETER W SLATERAs a former research assistant employed by the Livingstone Online project during my postgraduate studies at Glasgow University, I strongly urge you to heed and implement this petition. Livingstone's egalitarianism was lightyears ahead of it's time and his geographical, medicinal, botanical, and social work is something we can be proud of. It is of huge importance that his legacy is championed. I wish I had encountered Livingstones work well before my undergraduate studies. High school students are more likely to encounter the murderous exploits of Francis Galton than they are Livingstone's. Heeding this petition will add momentum to the progress and achievements currently being made by the Black Lives Matter movement. 35372020-08-05T16:39:47.26744799Kathleen MehtaAll history should be give, our children need correct information. Facts are important. No bias.\r\n35372020-08-05T16:44:52.75344800Ross CuffeI would expect the Scottish Government to be fully in support of exploring this initiative.35872020-08-05T17:27:37.4244801Steven WalkerProtect the beavers in Scotland now!35452020-08-05T18:00:19.71744802Stewart McCallSo much abandoned buildings in liveable conditions. A radical policy like this would give homeless people dignitiy and a better chance at accessing social services and health care and ultimately the chance to get their life back in order and better integrate into society. 35872020-08-05T18:22:10.3944803Jean Thomson The truth must come out. 35372020-08-05T19:22:46.944804Christy Brikinns Please amend the curriculum. Thanks35372020-08-05T20:54:43.47344805michelle woodWe need to stop giving licenses to kill Beavers. we need to respect them as serious habitat modifiers - to the betterment of all our habitat. \r\n35452020-08-05T21:14:40.2944807Sophie ThomsonStudent paramedics should have this bursary! 35782020-08-05T23:33:09.67344809Cassi StewartI transferred from Adult Nursing, my passion to working in the healthcare industry gives me the motivation to not allow this unfair gap to succumb my career. 35782020-08-06T06:24:43.33344810roberta campbellconversion therapy?? people need to grow up and get on with their own lives and STAY OUT of others, how dare these people try to change others for their own beliefs or satisfactions i would say an expletive here, but my comment would be banned !35602020-08-06T09:50:42.25744811Natasha RobertsonI fully agree the Scottish Govt should utilise abandoned places to create safe living facilities for homeless people. 35872020-08-06T10:39:45.45344813carol evansI know landowners waiting to take beavers into suitable habitats, make it happen please.35452020-08-06T11:01:51.6144814David CowanBeavers, like any other animals restored to the wild, should be allowed to flourish and to be culled after 1 year! Give them a chance to change their environment and we should be the ones adapting to their behaviour. 35452020-08-06T11:41:00.32744815Chris SnowWe were planning to come to Scotland for a holiday this year, cancelled due to coronavirus. But the only reason we were travelling up to Scotland was to see its wonderful wildlife. We were hoping to see mountain hares, eagles, otters, beavers, ospreys and dolphins. Please stop the persecution of your wildlife.35452020-08-06T11:42:05.9944816Ian Hawkins20% of the beaver population culled in a single year means the beaver reintroduction scheme and the return of this fantastic creature will only be heading one way. It would be shameful and damning if we cannot find room for these creatures in our countryside.35452020-08-06T12:06:28.3344817Doug PortmanRelocation should ALWAYS be the main control of populations, NEVER shooting! Humans are classed as animals on this planet remember, so I am sure the next housing development that requires humans to vacate the area will not be allowed to shoot the humans there! 35452020-08-06T12:33:59.23344818Richard JohnsonBeavers are being reintroduced in most of the UK so why are you allowing licences to murder Beavers?35452020-08-06T12:59:10.23744819Mo SandfordI live in the River Otter Valley in East Devon where beavers have been established and where local people and landowners have had to learn to appreciate that everything that beavers do is not perfect, but overall, their help to stabilise the natural environment is welcomed.35452020-08-06T13:46:07.90344820Janice AlexanderBeavers should be protected and not murdered35452020-08-06T13:55:52.16344821Philip AshmoleWhen I went on a beaver study tour in Bavaria, we were shown an example of how beavers are managed elsewhere. There was a hotline to a beaver management employee of a local NGO, funded largely by the provincial government, and he would visit the area where beavers had been causing problems. He advised on management measures to minimise problems, or trapped and translocated the beavers, or killed them as a last resort. I have a beaver pelt on our living room wall, culled in Bavaria when it proved really necessary, and with the proceeds of the sale going to support the management programme. In Britain we are often less clever in common sense management of wildlife problems.35452020-08-06T14:34:23.0244822Anthony Charles PalmerWhat is the point of releasing them and then shooting them, Madness.35452020-08-06T15:15:54.98744823John BurrowWe also need genetic reinforcement of the Tayside population of beavers. 35452020-08-06T15:53:55.6444824David SnodgrassI'm very uneasy about culling beavers. Relocating them is much preferable if control is indeed necessary. 35452020-08-06T17:59:33.44344826Aurelie PaoliWe need to work with nature not against it and beavers have been proven to benefit ecology and provide flood mitigation. Beavers belong in Scotland and we should not allow their needless killing. Please. 35452020-08-06T18:14:32.52344827Mark WildmanWe need vision and passion to keep Scotland rich in wildlife. Killing is not an an acceptable solution. 35452020-08-06T18:40:40.85744828Angus MaciverI think it incomprehensible that any government can pretend to protect a species and then allow farm managers to kill them whenever they deem them to be in the wrong place and causing damage to farm land35452020-08-06T18:42:10.45344829Cuisenaire. Martine Please let the Beavers co-exist with society. Thank you.35452020-08-06T18:51:49.43344832Mark Ranner Time for decisive action by the Scottish Government to protect the countries wildlife whilst we still have some and put in strong protection measures to ensure they are not flouted or circumvented via any licensing system with SNH.\r\n35452020-08-06T21:05:30.20344833Helen Martin Guidance is needed for the farming community where beavers are living. It is not good enough to kill beaver after beaver on licences because beavers are doing what beavers do. There are no right or wrong trees to them. We need to start fitting in with nature not the other way round. 35452020-08-06T21:44:52.77344834Peter RussellIf translocation offers a greater viability to protected status of beavers, given the victimisation practiced by estate managers, then I add my support for such practical measures.35452020-08-06T22:09:00.444835Kim Burgess We must stop destroying our countryside and our wildlife. 35452020-08-06T22:48:09.26344836Philippa GreenThere is no need to kill any of Gods Creatures! Please re locate, do not kill. Beavers can create a great ecological system if you let them be! 35452020-08-07T03:10:17.53744837Clive BirdTranslocate instead of killing35452020-08-07T04:07:51.26744838Dominic Dunnigan Beavers belong here. Only human predation caused their extinction.\r\nStop looking after the interests of corruption, commercialism and golf courses, and give us some of our amazing wildlife back!\r\n35452020-08-07T06:24:42.04344839Jane CampbellSNH has shown there is plenty of suitable habitat for beavers in other parts of Scotland where the conflicts over land use are far fewer than in the Tay catchment. There are organisations like Trees for Life and RSPB willing to undertake beaver translocations. It is madness to make beavers a protected species but then allow 20% of the population to be culled when alternative approaches exist. The current management framework contravenes what the Scottish Beaver Forum had originally agreed. 35452020-08-07T06:32:24.84344840Jane CampbellSNH has shown that there is plenty of suitable habitat for beavers in Scotland in areas where there are fewer conflicts than in Tayside. Organisations such as Trees for Life and RSPB are offering to undertake such translocations. So it is madness to give beavers protection but then enable 20% of the population to be killed when alternative measures are available. Come on Scot Gov- you can do better!35452020-08-07T07:05:53.0544841Juli HarrisWhat is the point of reintroducing a species to then shoot them? Stop handing out licences to kill, educate instead.35452020-08-07T07:12:10.58344842Alison Brewster 'Protected species status' should mean just that, not selective disregard when upsetting the 'hunting, shooting, fishing brigade minorities. 35452020-08-07T08:56:11.0144843Cheryl StevenWhy should paramedic students be treated any differently? We are all nhs students therefore should be entitled to an NHS bursary. Its hard to find a full time job while studying due to placement hours so we are having to support ourselves by taking out student loans.35782020-08-07T09:26:10.84344844Anne save MontarouSave the beavers35452020-08-07T09:33:27.9344845Alexander FrewYou would think Scotland of all places would understand the advantages of eco tourism, instead they slaughter, grouse, deer, badgers, hares, beavers and turn a blind eye to the illegal killing of birds of prey,35452020-08-07T10:04:58.8744846Linda MundellNo need to kill, just move them on to pastures new.35452020-08-07T10:31:00.32744847Paul BradingWe need to stop killing other species because it's 'convenient'. It's not just disrespectul to the rest of the natural world, it's harmful to our place in it. Humankind is part of the web of life. We need to stop acting like the deadly spider at the centre of it, constantly poised to strike.35452020-08-07T11:24:32.45344848Deirdre JamesBeavers are so important for flood control, biodiversity,35452020-08-07T12:12:38.63344849Elizabeth Banks ITV news reported that the beavers are to be protected as they are known to protect against flooding. This will save a lot of misery for people living in flood-prone areas - not to mention that enormous amount of money spent in building flood-barriers. These amazing animals need to be protected in Scotland as well. 35452020-08-07T13:05:22.78344850Sarah Cairncross We desperately need to protect these wonderful creatures for the good of us all.35452020-08-07T13:32:04.28744851Stephen HughesSurely, this is only common sense.35452020-08-07T14:10:17.6244852Melanie FisherKilling beavers is killing your future.35452020-08-07T14:53:52.37344853John Rowe Kill no beavers ! 35452020-08-07T15:32:20.33744854Paul V Irvingour beavers are important and should not be killed but could be spread to willing places35452020-08-07T16:31:16.26344856David ParkinNot ideal - but better than killing them because they get in the way of some farmers.35452020-08-07T18:35:46.92344857Lynn AlexanderThis is sooo cruel.. We need to. Protect our wildlife35452020-08-07T18:48:39.29744858Caroline KenneilThis is an important Petition providing one good solution to a highly urgent problem. \r\nThis Petition relates to a number of Committees, as Homelessness and insecurity is a major cause of ill health, inequality, inability to socially intergrate, find employment and contribute to family, friends and society. Additionally upgrading localities helps raise whole neighbourhoods and provides jobs.35872020-08-07T19:23:08.60344859Myrna ForresterAs soon as I heard beavers were to be reintroduced to the Scottish countryside, I wondered how long it would take before certain people would start to kill them. Any excuse does.35452020-08-07T21:52:19.5944860Harry SalmgrénOlder studies show benefits of beaver populations like this.\r\nA study into the ecology and habitat engineering of beavers reintroduced to a site on Tayside in 2002 has found the creatures can improve biodiversity, minimise pollutants and reduce downstream flooding. The dams also help improve pollutant levels and store flood water. And more recent are still more positive, Beavers Are the Ultimate Ecosystem Engineers\r\nThe aquatic rodents have rebounded, and they're reshaping watersheds for the better\r\nSo all in all: care for the beavers!35452020-08-07T23:04:07.54344861Anne Gordon It is obscene to allow a protected species to be killed instead of allowing translocation 35452020-08-07T23:44:45.46344862Lesley J EllisWe have to find ways of helping farming and wildlife live alongside each other. It is to the benefit of both. With climate change we need to build in resilience and trees and natural ponds are all part of that. It seems stupid and cruel to shoot beavers when they could be relocated.\r\n35452020-08-08T00:22:49.9644863Christopher EvansBeavers are an essential part of the natural environment! Please leave them in peace.\r\n35452020-08-08T00:35:47.9344864Janet S BeatonIts time we were embracing our beaver Cornwall have welcomed them with open arms why can't farmers embrace a change35452020-08-08T09:52:24.26344865Tina Starr I just don't get the desire to kill, rather than seek a more suitable alternative 35452020-08-08T20:32:22.63744867Tracy BrightenBeavers are incredible engineers, helping to control water flow and pollution in waterways, and create habitats for wildlife. We need to protect wildlife and restore Scotland's wild places - beavers are part of that rewilding process.35452020-08-08T22:56:45.20344869Annette AshtonHope the Scottish Government acts more quickly and effectively on this issue than they did on fox hunting. About time Wildlife was valued above arable land.35452020-08-08T23:59:32.9644871Ashlei HalbertAllowing this to be legal is inhumane.35602020-08-09T03:04:58.14344872Anni FarringtonBeavers are an asset on any waterway35452020-08-09T08:39:38.68744874Dr Nedim C BuyukmihciBeavers are an important keystone species. The Scottish government needs to stop allowing them to be killed, not only for the beavers' sake, but for the good of the local ecosystem. There are many ways to balance the needs of the beavers with the concerns of the people.35452020-08-09T08:51:20.41744875Duncan Orr-EwingPlease relocate beavers rather than kill them. Beavers are welcome in many parts of Scotland by the people who live there. 35452020-08-09T09:39:14.17744876Stephen Findlay Beavers are natural creatures of \r\nScotland, they should be encouraged not killed or removed.35452020-08-09T12:20:04.1744878Mark WilsonBeavers are natural water engineers they can radically change the hydrology of a river and reduce the possibility of downstream flooding. Slowing the flow! Climate change will potentially mean higher rainfall totals for northern Britain in the future. Natural solutions to flooding will be far cheaper than man made infrastructure. We need to learn lessons from European countries that have already re-introduced Eurasian Beaver to their ecosystems and are able to live in harmony. Beavers could become a strong income stream to Scotland through wildlife tourism.35452020-08-09T13:15:19.92744879Alan GilliesIts time the governemnt started to look at the bigger picture and not just what best for humans in the short run. This shortsightedness will have disastrous consequences for the future if we dont start to adopt a healthier attitude and respect towards our home. Beavers are native and helped shape our natural environment, one which has been finely honed over billions of years to perfection...we CANNOT improve upon it, we need to fix the real issue- us, it us thats encroached into their habitat through abuse of power. If not, witness the butterfly effect in full motion. Only a fool would want to destroy, again, a key member of our natural eco system.35452020-08-09T14:24:15.82344880Jason Weir This land belongs to nature as much as it does to us, we have no greater right to it than any other animal. If control is needed or should be robustly licensed35452020-08-09T16:21:54.12344881Alan Corbett There are plenty of places that would welcome these ecosystem engineers, move don't kill. 35452020-08-09T17:09:31.56744882Alex MilneIt strikes me that SNH have in this instance, as well as others frustrated the will both of the Scottisg Parliament and the people. Allowing and indeed encouraging that a significant proportion of the population of beavers is hardly the act of a body who should be ensuring that beavers attract the safety afforded them by legislation. \r\nA far better method of limiting the damage where absolutely necessary is available. The ability of rivers to perform the function of safely discharging large flows does not imply the right of landowners to prevent all water ingress on their land. Meadows should still be meadows in many instances.35452020-08-09T17:29:10.32744883Irene BurtBeavers should be located where they are safe from culling as they do an important job in managing rivers. They should not be subjected to culling35452020-08-09T19:26:52.03744884Richard Anderson The beavers need to be protected against any shootings or culling. They can help the environment against flooding & can help the flowing of water. 35452020-08-09T21:03:17.7444885Lindsay B CraikI support the petition35452020-08-09T21:56:21.1244886Julie BellWe need to work with the land, its wildlife and the climate to develop natural engineering solutions to floods, habitat destruction and restoration, and to strengthen ecosystems. Beavers should be part of this process. 35452020-08-09T22:48:45.61344887Isla ARTHURdo not kill relocate.35452020-08-09T23:13:54.36344888George BrownThere is no need to kill these animals.35452020-08-09T23:52:44.33744890Eileen.foremanBeavers are gorgeous,they are lovanble animals,they enhance the countryside,35452020-08-10T07:22:04.62744891Ted Stevens Beavers can help prevent flooding by building dams in the right area.35452020-08-10T11:23:11.6944895Kate AndrewsThis kind of thing makes me feel so misanthropic. Humans have the intelligence and ability to plan, reflect, and understand the consequences of our actions in nature and yet too often, we succumb to our short-sighted or single-minded "solutions" where a better one exists. Relocation of this now- species should be prioritised of course. And anybody who cries cost should be take a look at the cost of flooding - in large part due to intensive agriculture and destruction of woodlands - before opening their mouths. 35452020-08-10T12:54:53.98344896Dale Westwood Please relocate animals, do not kill them. 35452020-08-10T12:55:47.77744897Patricia Martin Please help keep these beautiful animals safe35452020-08-10T15:59:00.73744898Joyce MarriottThis unnecessary and cruel culling must stop. It shames Scotland. 35452020-08-10T16:05:32.87744899Kristine FosterBeavers are here for a reason..........nature knows best!35452020-08-10T16:21:17.33744901Estella abrahamAgree35832020-08-10T18:06:16.9444904Pam MercerYou really do have to ask WHY!!!!! Relocate these wonderful creatures. 35452020-08-10T18:14:24.97344905Mary Ann JonesSuch wonderful animals! Please relocate, nor kill!35452020-08-10T23:20:45.75344907Sally DunsPlease relocate these amazing animals. They can provide many benefits to the local environment including mitigation against flooding, increasing biodiversity and improving soil. They can also draw in tourism - I would travel to see them in action! 35452020-08-11T06:29:02.1444908Richard JohnsonBeavers are an important part of our ecosystem.35452020-08-11T08:05:13.83744909Diane FaulknerPlease allow our natural world to thrive and flourish.\r\nSome will never see these beautiful creatures, as City dwellers we sadly only see them in books or on TV. I've read of their value and their great engineering , please protect them.35452020-08-11T10:16:10.2944910Jorge EchegarayProtected species can not be culled or lethally removed. Public agencies should find non lethal alternatives35452020-08-11T16:02:57.70344913Liza HollingsheadThere must be room in Scotland for all animals, including humans!35452020-08-11T16:04:29.83744914Julie MahonDon't kill these industrious animals, help to relocate them to areas where they are needed.35452020-08-11T16:07:32.68344915John Vickerman I was so proud of Scotland pioneering the reintroduction of Beavers. The policy of not allowing their movement elsewhere seems very perverse and short-sighted.35452020-08-11T16:08:36.3644917Victor SealAny legal killing is bad for the environment and the world.35452020-08-11T16:09:06.21344918Anne RobinsonEnough extinction without adding to it.35452020-08-11T16:11:26.2244919Peter FishWhat is proposed seems both humane and common sense.35452020-08-11T16:12:23.07344920Angela JewellThe benefits from beaver activity seems to have been well proved and in this enlightened time it should be possible to live alongside wildlife, with translocation the option where there is serious conflict. It cannot be right to kill these protected animals. We need to learn to live alongside nature as apparently some enlightened farmers are doing.35452020-08-11T16:12:54.46344921Ann BanksExcellent leaky dam builders. Great to mitigate effects of flooding in Calderdale. Bring em on. Whatever you do DONT SHOOT THEM!35452020-08-11T16:14:21.82344923Paul HopewellScotland usually tries to set a good example to other countries. Please do so with your beavers.35452020-08-11T16:16:48.2344925Andrew JenkinsBeavers belong in Scotland and help undo the damage caused by overgrazing and poor land management. Priority should be given to this keystone species. In any case what right should people have to kill these beautiful animals?35452020-08-11T16:18:37.9544926Professor Alayne Street-PerrottShooting beavers is crass given their ecological and hydrological benefits. On the continent, farmers are compensated for beaver damage, which does not cost the economy very much compared to their valuable impacts on flood risk and biodiversity. The offending beavers should simply be moved to areas that would like them and the ecotourism income they might bring - which include parts of Wales.35452020-08-11T16:18:58.40744927Phil PickinAlthough I'm not a resident of Scotland it doesn't stop me from asking the Scottish Government to allow unwanted beavers to be relocated to other parts of Scotland where they could benefit the landscape and be welcomed by people, rather than being killed. It is madness to kill creatures that can provide a natural solution to flooding while creating much-needed wetlands.35452020-08-11T16:19:28.13744928Moyra RuffellAt a time like this when more people are taking an interest and valuing their environment more I cannot believe that beavers are being killed especially when the beavers could be moved to another part of the country and so enhancing that area where they would be appreciated.35452020-08-11T16:19:58.2344930Freda Drysdale We need all the diversity we can to combat Climate Change. It would be dreadful to kill these animals when relocation is the obvious answer.35452020-08-11T16:22:18.04344931Angela Estyn-JonesDevon in England, values the benefits beavers bring - wake up Scotland!35452020-08-11T16:29:42.51344932Nigel BerryBeavers were probably here before us.35452020-08-11T16:33:33.37344933David GarnerMove them somewhere they can flourish. They can do great work. Killing them is a wretched and fortunately totally unnecessary option.35452020-08-11T16:33:36.90344934Jill GreenSadly I am not living in Scotland any more. But I still love it and return as often as I can. I am sure you could find Wonderful Scottish volunteer beaver relocators to help35452020-08-11T16:36:20.37344935Dorothy SmithHave visited an area here in Cornwall with beavers, and been amazed at the increase in biodiversity after their introduction. More needed not fewer.35452020-08-11T16:36:39.22344936Angus RobertsonWhat is needed is open minds and collaboration not the usual capitulation to the landowning interest.35452020-08-11T16:43:58.59744937Alistair BrodieIt beggars belief - when most other countries in N America and Europe are able to live side by side with these wonderful creatures - that the Scottish Government deems it acceptable to issue licenses to allow "legal killing" of a species only just allocated protected status?? There are vast tracks of Scotland specifically and the UK in general where these animals can be allowed to live in peace, doing what they do best: improve the environment, increase habitats, provide - for free - flood mitigation "engineering". Please stop this unnecessary slaughter of an animal once extinct and only just reintroduced into the UK35452020-08-11T16:48:05.84344938Ian StorrThe British Isles are not rich in biodiversity and this is an opportunity to support the introduction of a species that was native. It is far too early to cull this useful and fascinating mammal if it is ever right to do so. 35452020-08-11T16:48:54.17344940Sylvia DavidsonKilling beavers should not be legal given their benign influence on the landscape.35452020-08-11T16:53:55.2244944John LowryBeavers can play an important role in coping with the effects of climate change and as ecosystem engineers they provide habitat for a whole range of living organisms.35452020-08-11T17:01:34.20744945Steve LordThe point of first protecting beavers by law but then issuing licenses in order that they may be killed in significant numbers escapes me.35452020-08-11T17:01:47.9144946Patrick Battersby Save our beavers. We need beavers helping our environment all over the UK.35452020-08-11T17:02:27.73744947Charles Watts.We have very successful trials in South West England (Otter Valley) and feel we could use displaced Scottish Beavers to help 'slow the flow' of water onto the Somerset Levels. 35452020-08-11T17:04:10.25344949Christine CarrShame on you Scotland. Beavers are a part of the whole ecosystem. Leave them alone.35452020-08-11T17:11:17.56744952Antoni WisniewskiWe constantly prioritise human need above other species and the environment. We do so at our collective peril.35452020-08-11T17:12:05.4444953Paul DumbletonIt would be so easy to agree to this. Why not?35452020-08-11T17:18:25.3844956Graham McKendryWhy is it every time something doesn't fit certain humans believe the answer is always to cull the creature rather than find an alternative where it lives along side us. Because slaughter is easier to implement that's why. It is not just a humans right to live but every creatures right. When we forget this we forget what life is all about.35452020-08-11T17:18:38.50744957Maryellen HillWhy would we want to kill theses beautiful helpful animals.35452020-08-11T17:20:14.20744958April McAlpineWe need to protect and support these animals in every way possible. They benefit us all.35452020-08-11T17:20:22.5244959penny beechThe attitude of killing anything that is a problem to our human lifestyle is horrendous. There are always alternative ways of resolving problems without resorting to barbaric culling. Will we never learn? It is about time humankind realised that there is method behind the complexity of the natural world. If it doesn't fit in exactly as we require it becomes a pest. I despair we are the problem not as in this case the innocent beavers.35452020-08-11T17:24:26.2144961Suzanne McLeodSo short sighted to destroy habitat and inhabitants. Please take a more far reaching approach to support the land, creatures and humans that depend on each other. Cannot take out one leg of a stool and expect it to stand.35452020-08-11T17:27:24.39744962Marilyn RelfPlease also consider relocation to England.35452020-08-11T17:34:57.86744963Jenny GilbertThere is space for all, humans and beavers alike. What's more, from the evidence it's clear that we need beavers far more than they need us.35452020-08-11T17:43:28.2944964Diana BrockbankPlease! please! please! give a chance to these wonderful creatures35452020-08-11T17:43:46.44744965Susan Clarke Beavers are beautiful and useful creatures. 35452020-08-11T18:00:47.4544968William AdamsWe need beavers here in Scotland.35452020-08-11T18:35:42.0344969Evelyn Cunningham Leave the animals alone.35452020-08-11T18:38:07.92344970Richard JohnsonThis is crazy Beavers have been recognised as a benefit to the environment, but your allowing them to be killed.35452020-08-11T18:42:43.23344971Guy ArschavirCan only see a convincing case for killing if there is no possibility of translocation - especially if they can offer benefit of improving habitat and improving hydrology elsewhere.35452020-08-11T18:59:36.42744972Julie Dhyana HugginsThank you for giving Beavers the right to live in Scotland and be part of the important diversity of life. Let us realise we as humans have no more right to be here than any other life. 35452020-08-11T19:02:44.92344973Douglas KerrI find it unbelievable and embarrassing the Scottish Government can allow the wanton killing of a supposedly protected species.35452020-08-11T19:28:02.24344975Andrew FisherProtection must mean real protection. Please give beavers a chance.35452020-08-11T19:47:07.22744976Kelvin U N BristolThese lovely creatures do a lot more good to the environment than harm so please let them have a life.35452020-08-11T19:57:42.32344977Stephanie WilliamsonThis should be an easy win for the Scottish government to show it's doing the right thing for the ecological emergency we face. I volunteer each year for Trees for Life, helping to restore the Caledonian forest. Beavers are coexisting happily with humans in Devon so why not in Scotland?!35452020-08-11T20:01:06.74744978Chrissie QuinnPlease show commitment to a more environmentally diverse and sustainable future for the beavers and Scotland.35452020-08-11T20:05:45.68344979VINCENT HAYESWhat's behind the Scots government decision to allow shooting? Is it to please some elements of the farming community - or is it the government's own belief that beavers are in some way a threat to agriculture, or to the Scottish environment, or are they just very annoyed that eco-groups have been flouting existing laws about the introduction of 'foreign' species - and so are showing their anger ?35452020-08-11T20:11:09.73344981Madeleine PreeceI truly thought Scottish politicians had more integrity than those south of the border. I holidayed in Scotland every year of my childhood and was awestruck by the golden eagles and ospreys, the lochs and beaches. Beavers seem to be part of the solution as they have such positive effects on the landscape and more importantly the wildlife. Please please please allow their relocation 35452020-08-11T20:34:13.5344982Emma OliverI support Trees for Life advice on beavers. 35452020-08-11T20:35:51.09344983Fiona McConnellWhy should people be allowed to kill beavers anyway? Live and let live! And if beavers are displaced, of course they must be found a suitable new home.35452020-08-11T20:42:19.844984Kate IrelandBeavers were once driven to extinction in Scotland through relentless slaughter. Today we have so many better options than this including relocating them to a location where they can exist safely. They are amazing animals and their activities encourage regeneration, restore landscape and reduce downstream flooding. Please preserve these amazing animals who have a right to live too. 35452020-08-11T20:42:44.81344985Vi ShannonPlease do not kill any more beavers!\r\nIf some Farmers object to their presence and find it difficult to adapt to them, then please arrange for the beavers to be relocated so that they can do their wonderful ecological work and be welcomed. Thank you.35452020-08-11T21:00:29.3844986Lindsey WhitelawBeavers make a huge contribution to maintaing a rich diverse ecologically balanced landscape and should be protected not slaughtered\r\n35452020-08-11T21:01:41.9944987Fiona LewisPlease make space for nature - if the beavers are in the wrong place, don't kill, relocate to appropriate place - humans need to rethink sharing the land - it is not exclusively ours.35452020-08-11T21:09:14.78744990Jamie Balfour-PaulUrgent - please listen to Trees for Life expertise35452020-08-11T21:26:01.94344991Michael ScottThis seems like a simple and effective way of protecting wildlife and encouraging biodiversity at a time that we should be trying to get more Green!35452020-08-11T21:27:31.64744992Suzanne M WardBeavers should be protected if necessary be rehired in a suitable environment certainly not killed!35452020-08-11T21:35:36.0444994Marc Rhodes-Taylorthank you for sharing this with me i hope that the beavers can still be saved35452020-08-11T21:45:20.96344995Jennifer MillerBeavers are essential to a healthy ecosystem. Please do the right thing and relocate them. Thank you 35452020-08-11T21:50:24.444996Alan McEwenEvidence suggests that habitat diversification & use of natural techniques, including wild animals like beavers can reduce environmental damage like flooding & erosion. It also adds biodiversity by the creation of new habitats & helps to allow ecosystems to self regulate. Supported effectively this can reduce many negative environmental impacts like flood damage but also support populations of new insects, invertebrates, small mammals, fish & birds. Used wisely it could be of great benefit.35452020-08-11T22:00:45.60744997Warren McAreeThere are all manner of better solutions than trapping or culling beaver. Relocation to appropriate locations will handed great benefits. 35452020-08-11T22:11:47.0944999Roy ConnollyIt's time we put nature first.35452020-08-11T22:40:38.50345000Paul OwenLicensed killing is a poor reflection on all concerned. We're better than this! \r\nLet's make room for nature on our land and in our hearts.35452020-08-11T22:46:57.5245001Iain McDonaldHow can Scotland look like a caring nation to the world when it allows this to happen. Combined with the lack of action to protect it's unique highland wildcat we are a laughing stock.35452020-08-11T23:12:19.4945002Kay PageMy daughter and family live in Scotland. I am there often throughout the year. I watch and take an interest in all things Scottish.35452020-08-11T23:22:01.22745004Richard YoungDon't kill things.35452020-08-11T23:45:07.6545005Helen AnkersTranslocation should be the first option, there is far too much killing of our beautiful animals. They have a right to live. 35452020-08-12T00:04:18.62345006Alan BlakeleyThe legislation must protect beavers and require farmers to cull only if there's no alternative.35452020-08-12T01:06:53.96745007Mhairi ScottAfter decades of catastrophic floods reported on the TV, eg in Yorkshire, adding beavers to the available solutions surely seems so logical?\r\n\r\nIt also seems likely that beavers in a large area of the Scottish Highlands, eg in deer or grouse hunting estates, would have negligible impact, because not troubling deer or grouse. So it seems utterly crazy not to relocate animals as a first resort. \r\n\r\nHowever, in addition, I watched a Heal Rewilding webinar with a farmer in Cornwall discussing beaver protection solutions. He did say that it will likely be the best solution in arable areas, for farmers to fence their crop fields with electric fences. \r\n\r\nPlease direct ELM funding to help farmers do this - it is so easy to install --- to achieve co-habitation without killing beaver or ruining farmers' hoped for incomes. 35452020-08-12T01:40:53.06745008Mr Royd SandersThey need our help you know and they need it now!35452020-08-12T03:50:44.80345009Stephen RoutledgeAs an ex-Scottish hill farmer and grouse moor owner i am all for diversity in our eco-systems.35452020-08-12T04:39:08.35745010Anne FrenchIm in shock at the information you provided about beavers being killed. Relocation must happen. Wishing you well with this critical petition35452020-08-12T05:26:28.03745011Barbara Penny Beavers are needed for biodiversity and the part they play in flood mitigation and they need protection.35452020-08-12T07:04:20.03345012Julie LaneBeavers are an important part of our future path towards a healthier more sustainable environment in this country. They must be allowed to live in peace in our countryside.35452020-08-12T07:37:09.8545015Jane BairdPlease Scottish Government, lead the way in conservation and the environment. I would expect such behaviour from the Tories in England. Be better than them.35452020-08-12T08:03:46.3445016Chris CullenRobust science shows that beavers have a significant role to play in boosting biodiversity, preventing floods and preserving and enhancing habitats. It makes no sense at all to allow them to be killed when they could be relocated to places where they can make a positive difference, particularly when so many reputable organisations such as Trees for Life and the RSPB have expressed enthusiasm to host them on their reserves and land. This is surely in line with the stated values of the SNP government. Please follow the science!35452020-08-12T08:08:41.9345017Carol HurstThe Cornwall Wildlife Trust has reintroduced beavers on a farm in Cornwall. They have been carefully monitored and are proving very successful in many ways: reducing the flow of water during heavy rainfall, filtering pollutants from the water, creating a diverse habitat for wildlife. After a 5 year trial, the beavers on the Otter river in Devon have been given government approval to stay. The benefits of beavers have been proven to outweigh the negatives and it is possible for beavers to live happily alongside communities. In this time of crisis for our UK wildlife, it is crucial to hold on to our key species. If there have been offers to relocate these beavers please do not kill them.35452020-08-12T08:24:38.65345018Chloe HurstThe Cornwall wildlife Trust has successfully reintroduced beavers on to a farm in Cornwall. Research with the University of Exeter has proved the many positive impacts the beavers are having here. Controlling the water flow during heavy rain, filtering pollutants from the water, creating a diverse habitat for wildlife. The beavers on the Otter River in Devon have been given government approval to stay after the 5 year trial showing the benefits of the beavers. We have a climate emergency and our wildlife across the UK is being decimated at an unrivalled rate. the beaver is a keysoem species and we should be protecting it across the UK.35452020-08-12T08:29:26.74345019Margaretha Bergmando not get beavers extinct! change habitat for them!35452020-08-12T08:59:57.8345020June EvansMany species are under threat from mankind. Let's do the right thing and co-operate with nature instead of fighting against it. 35452020-08-12T09:08:04.26745022Anja MellergaardThese creatures provided a positive effect on the environment why allow them to be killed when they can be removed?35452020-08-12T09:16:15.67345024Nigel SmithWe have a moral obligation to protect and bring back to its former range a species that only went extinct through the actions of man.35452020-08-12T09:28:05.78345026Martin VickermanBeavers are amazing animals, who help manage or forests and waterways.35452020-08-12T09:48:37.86745027Eiluned CollinsI am concerned that there needs to be a more sensitive and informed approach to beaver management and that translocation should be the most likely solution to any genuine problems that arise.35452020-08-12T10:31:17.5645028Gillian SmartI would love to see beavers in Renfrewshire and Ayrshire. The benefit to wildlife habitat would be fantastic.35452020-08-12T10:32:20.93745029Mary WalkerDisgraceful35452020-08-12T10:40:08.70345030David WharmbyBeavers can provide vital flood protection in certain areas.35452020-08-12T10:47:02.82745031Lucy SearleProgressive policies with proper enforcement should be in place to allow nature to co-exist with human activity. Killing beavers to suit a certain industry's needs should not be allowed - we must educate ourselves and do better as the dominant species.35452020-08-12T10:54:31.75745032Gail Simpson This is a service we need !!35782020-08-12T11:19:09.63745033Jack McPakeConversion Therapy has no place in a modern, progressive society. This barbaric practice must end ASAP.35602020-08-12T11:39:53.0645034Ro ScottI'm sure there are plenty of places that would welcome beavers and benefit from their activities, rather than killing them. 35452020-08-12T11:48:48.32745036Julia HumeThese creatures are a huge bonus to our waterways and should be encouraged as they can help to prevent flooding and do not eat fish.35452020-08-12T12:21:40.95745037Diana Oostervelda very necessary project, please support35452020-08-12T12:57:20.25745038Lavinia WebbPlease stop persecuting beavers.35452020-08-12T14:55:02.72745039Stephanie MelnickConversion therapy is an abusive practice that causes pain and attempts to force people to be something they are not. Allowing this to happen is to allow abuse, and it should be banned.35602020-08-12T14:55:11.1845040Sarah Jane PruceI don't understand why they are being killed. I've been lucky enough to see beavers recently in Devon - they are tolerated here and are doing very well, so why not in Scotland?35452020-08-12T16:10:10.345042Pamela ShanleyThank you for doing this SAVE the BEAVERS35452020-08-12T17:11:57.16745043Lisa McKnightStudies have shown the huge benefits of this keystone species. Please let's embrace a relocation option for the benefit of all. These sad and shocking deaths are not the solution!35452020-08-12T19:07:42.43345047Simon Etter It's astounding, we've only just got them back and now there is talk of know killing them . 35452020-08-12T19:26:17.32745048tanya vincentThey are introducing them back into the West Country bring them here.35452020-08-12T20:38:08.83745050Francis RourkeThis is a very worthy cause. 35452020-08-12T20:54:07.51345051Martin PaminterI was appalled to learn that, after declaring the beaver to be a protected species last year, the Scottish Government seem to be allowing them to be wiped out. Where is the logic in this?35452020-08-12T22:04:16.36745052Frankie ReynoldsThe untold damage this causes is a crime. End this now. 35602020-08-12T22:15:07.55745053Jonathan WittenbergScotland is a beautiful country with plenty of excellent safe habitat for beavers35452020-08-13T08:56:19.76745054Chevalley ElisabethSwitzerland is doing it! So can Scotland do it also. There is no need to kill Beavers as they do a great job.35452020-08-13T09:32:17.33745055jan fergusonTranslocate the beavers.35452020-08-13T09:56:23.77345056Ingrid WoodThis is a shocking waste of life. 20% of the population of beavers vacant be relocated. Let the animals do what comes naturally to them for the benefit of our countryside. 35452020-08-13T10:14:43.8145057Michelle Kershaw-WrightFor goodness sake let nature help us in the great many ways it does. Protect wildlife properly please 35452020-08-13T11:54:46.08745060Ben DowlingTo reintroduce a species and then allow it to be killed is just unthinkably stupid. Specifically when that species still only exists in tiny population numbers. There is so much additional space they could be utilised, or more intelligent strategies than just killing them.35452020-08-13T11:58:50.3545061Megan Hudson-PrenticeCompletely in favour of relocating beavers. There should never be a need to kill animals for the sake of farmland. There is enough space in Scotland for humans to happily live alongside nature without the need to destroy or kill it. 35452020-08-13T14:48:11.71745062Janet cuthbertson Our environment has been destroyed by human interference. It is time for nature to be able to help us repair the damage we have caused. 35452020-08-13T16:58:32.26745063Simon Robinson MScThe time, effort and expense to reintroduce these animals will be wasted by culling them. Surely they were never intended to only be present in the trial area? Please relocate them to other suitable areas to extend their reintroduction to more of the country.35452020-08-13T17:37:38.89745065Joan MuszynskiBeavers are positive for the environment. Increasing biodiversity and helping to manage flooding in an affordable and natural way. Compensate farmers but increase beavers. They should be part of our natural river systems. 35452020-08-13T20:03:24.27345068Duncan Bamford Just when the UK might want to employ the brilliant native environmental engineers, we're culling our home grown stocks. Absolute disgrace. They could be relocated within Scotland and certainly Wales and England will be grateful recipients very soon. 35452020-08-13T20:24:09.83345069Shirley Brogan Do this. No need to be killing everything. It's not a good look for a responsible government. 35452020-08-13T20:49:05.91745071Caro WilkinsonI was horrified to hear that so many beavers had been slaughtered (by licence). I heard an excellent talk earlier this year by a beaver expert, who claimed that beavers are nature's supreme conservationists, helping the rewilding process and able to prevent our towns and cities from the disastrous flooding we are experiencing with the changing climate - by building dams in the hills to slow the rush of huge amounts of rainwater towards where most of us live. So please, no more indiscriminate killing, and it's good to hear of plans to re-locate these wonderful animals from areas where they may have been a nuisance to farmers.35452020-08-13T21:42:38.42345072Julie WhitehousePlease leave our wildlife alone to live alongside human beings. 35452020-08-13T22:05:44.27345073Wendy Bradley If humans don't learn soon that nature is more valuable than the short term profits gained by a handful of short-sighted individuals it will be too late for us all. We must act now to protect nature and control human activity as we have become dangerously unbalanced.35452020-08-14T00:21:31.15345074Dorothea McRobbieIt just seems like yesterday that beavers were being reintroduced to Scotland. If there are issues then all options need to be looked at . Humans are too quick to go in and interfere with nature, I recall a cull happening in a Scottish island of hedgehogs as they were decimating the eggs of native birds. Why they could not be transferred to another location I'm not sure, but now people are bemoaning the lack of hedgehogs in the Scottish mainland. Perhaps people need to stop thinking that slaughtering animals that don't fit in with their rationale is a reasonable course of action. We do not own this planet nor it's creatures, we only share it for a short while35452020-08-14T01:52:51.5245075Marilyn Clark Nature should be left alone.35452020-08-14T08:46:32.73345077Maris ThomsonWhat was the point of reintroducing them if they were then to be killed? 35452020-08-14T10:35:46.9245078Robert Brownlie Leggate Killing or culling as some folk call it to make it sound as if they are doing the animal a favour is not the only answer, it is however man's answer to most things, we have little enough wild animals in Scotland, Britain especially ones that were reintroduced and now they want to start killing them what was the point of introducing them for them to be killed if we hadn't wiped out that many of our native creatures there would be natural preditors to sort things out naturally 35452020-08-14T11:46:35.945084Joan Patterson I am signing this petition to obviously Request the Scottish Government protects these Beavers in Scotland, asking that no further killing legal or not be allowed. I also recognise that our countryside needs protection and be allowed Its return to its natural environmental state. Enable natural species to return, recognise over farming and unnatural forestation is destroying this fragile natural eco systems and habitat. I support the wonderful work the Trees for Life organisation is doing in rewilding the Caledonian Forrest and other areas. Please take notice of their important work and their concerns raised for the reasons for protecting these beavers. There needs to be a way to support our farming and industrial industry companionably with protecting our Scottish wildlife and landscape. We need eco harmony. 35452020-08-14T12:15:00.5345086Dorette EngiPlease relocate beavers to where they are wanted. Don't just eliminate them. So brutal and primitive in this day and age of climate emergency35452020-08-14T12:34:50.74745087Ralph Radford We must do all we can to protect Beavers and hopefully reintroduce them into other parts of the UK35452020-08-14T13:20:04.0545088Frances MackiewiczPlease consider these actions for the welfare of these beavers. They are an asset to the environment. 35452020-08-14T15:19:02.845089Jane FletcherI cannot believe that 87 beavers have been legally killed rather than relocated. 35452020-08-14T15:26:49.85745090David GriffithsThere is way too much wildlife murder in Scotland already and the consensus is growing rapidly and widely that it needs to stop. Please do not add beavers to your growing list of disgrace.35452020-08-14T15:38:13.12345091Peter SimmonsThe only way to stop this barbarism is stop licencing farmers to do anything but grow food. Beavers are natural in the environment, farmers aren't.35452020-08-14T15:40:19.37345092Alan ThurmThere's space for all35452020-08-14T15:49:21.64745093Mary von HeideRewilding at Knepp Farm (England) has shown how useful beavers are to the environment. We need to protect and encourage them......not kill them!35452020-08-14T16:07:57.13345094Jacqueline ThomsonTranslocation is the answer35452020-08-14T16:08:17.33745095Andrew PalmerWe are Europe's number 1 wildlife watching destination and we need to rethink how we live along wildlife and be a country leading the way for nature conservation and ecotourism so that other countries may follow suite 35452020-08-14T16:08:36.88345096Catherine Ann BruceA law was passed to protect beavers, then DO that!!!35452020-08-14T16:29:34.17745097Adrian JaquesPlease do what is humane and in the best interests of the environment. Relocate the beavers instead of killing them. 35452020-08-14T16:33:25.94345098Adrian JaquesPlease do what is best for the beavers and the environment. Relocation over killing. 35452020-08-14T16:38:18.18745099Lorna Rowney-smithIn one week I've learnt and protested to the Scottish Parliament about the poisoning of birds of prey, the failure to implement MSP voted for mountain hare protection and now, the killing of 87 beavers in Scotland while giving them protected status. You seem more like early twentieth century Australia than belonging to the 21st century UK and Europe. Shameful. Shameful35452020-08-14T16:53:19.9745100Ash-Lynn TavenerBeavers provide a huge range of ecosystem services. I want to see them all across Scotland again. The worlds biodiversity is crashing and we need our leaders to address it immediately, this is an easy change that will make a huge difference. 35452020-08-14T16:56:46.92345101Ash-Lynn TavenerBeavers provide a range of ecosystem services. Biodiversity is crashing around the world and we need to take action. This is an easy change that'll make a big difference. Relocate them! 35452020-08-14T17:49:34.90745102Gerry O'RourkeDo something that future generations will that you for.35452020-08-14T17:53:20.2245103Amanda French I think is is disgusting and immoral, when there is an alternative, which there is it should be done. DON'T KILL THESE ANIMALS. 35452020-08-14T17:59:08.31745104Jayne Gough With a little cooperation there are beavers co-existing happily with farming in the heart of strathmore. Space for all. No need to kill or translocations. Beaver deceiver keeps field clear and farm uses beaver pool water for irrigation in times of drought. Been this way since Beavers first here. Proud of my farming neighbours. Ashamed of those that bankstrip and 35452020-08-14T18:01:01.74345105Emma DaviesCrazy to follow up a successful reintroduction programme with significant culling.\r\nBeavers can play a significant role in natural flood management and lessons could be learned and applied elsewhere in the UK. Climate change and associated extreme weather events make natural approaches even more important.35452020-08-14T18:03:34.75345106Paul SimsScotland is a beautiful country and its wildlife is an important part of it . Animals and birdlife are part of the attraction and should not be persecuted .35452020-08-14T18:25:44.24745107Vincent SmithLet's show compassion, forward thinking and common sense...35452020-08-14T18:55:54.42345109Rachel FoxleyThere are so many environements across the UK that would benefit from beavers being intorduced.It is a tragedy that an animal that was made extinct by man 400 years ago is already being hunted and killed again35452020-08-14T19:19:19.86345110Claire LawThe Beavers will be an excellent resource in the environment and a precious resource. As a wildlife enthusiasts and environmentalist I recognise not every species is as impactful as the beaver at protecting biodiversity 35452020-08-14T19:34:56.9945111Dave PartingtonKilling beavers when they are in the process of being re-introduced is an embarrassment to Scotland.35452020-08-14T20:18:26.32745112Estella LovettWe have to learn to live harmoniously with other life forms, our life on our one planet depends on it. Let's start by behaving intelligently with our beavers, we know they enrich our environment in various ways.35452020-08-14T21:04:37.6645114Rob JonesThere are other areas of Scotland and the wider UK that would benefit from beavers. why is a cull always the first port of call?35452020-08-14T23:33:15.30745116Diane MayAt this time more than ever we should care for wildlife and the environment and stop killing when relocation is a safe option35452020-08-15T03:03:30.80345117Lucy NorvalBeavers have a remarkable ability to prevent flooding if allowed to do what they do.35452020-08-15T05:57:14.1745118Jennifer Demeijer Sustainability: People, Profit, Planet are in balance. We have debts to Planet. 35452020-08-15T06:06:34.8945119Elaine MellorStop killing wildlife.35452020-08-15T06:32:57.67745120Sarah StockwellHumans must understand that we are connected to nature, dependent on it for our very survival. Every species has a vital role in an ecosystem, the beaver a vital role in river and water way management thst contributes to flood defence. We need leaders that understand the importance of nature to make policies that ensure we can live and work alongside it. If not our own species is heading to extinction.35452020-08-15T07:42:29.54745122Jacqui HarrisBeavers play a vital role in increasing diversity and controlling and purifying ground and flood water. There is no reason why, with the large areas of uncultivated land in Scotland, why beavers cannot be an integral part of our countryside. This is becoming an accepted strategy in England alongside rewinding projects. Do we want Scotland to be the dirty man of conservation, in a world where nature is critically struggling in many areas? Or do we want to stand out as leading the way, and making Scotland an environmental leader? Please consider this. So far I am ashamed of the way Scotland for the most part ignores the natural environment, does little to encourage and assist farmers to find ways of embracing it within the farming system and the constant focus on keeping the shooting fraternity sweet. The massive public interest in rewinding and conservation could bring in great financial benefits in it's own right.35452020-08-15T07:56:15.8945123Eleanor McCarrey Relocation must be the only alternative. Killing them should not be carried out35452020-08-15T08:37:01.2745124Evelyn McCall Makes no sense to kill like this35452020-08-15T09:21:54.1245125Katie BartonBeavers have been successfully reintroduced to Devon. We are trying to reintroduce this keystone species across the UK. We know they are beneficial to the ecology of the area they inhabit. They could be successfully relocated from areas that are apparently 'problematic'. To kill them is short-sighted, irresponsible and continues to support the interests of a few at the expense and detriment to the many who could benefit. 35452020-08-15T09:26:28.82345126Vanessa Stevenson Beavers help the eco systems of rivers and help restore balance, helping fish stocks Providing pools that help with carbon sequestration we need badgers on all our rivers35452020-08-15T10:08:06.48745128Sheila DorsettPlease protect or relocate the beavers. I am sure there are loads of suitable habitats in Scotland. Protect them and you will have lots of visitors to boost the economy. 35452020-08-15T10:15:42.28345129Laura HewittWe should protect natural wildlife as well as farmers35452020-08-15T10:20:23.81745130Andrea HudspethThe current approach is aimed at appeasing a small minority of landowners to the detriment of the majority of the population who take pleasure in watching the beavers. These animals belong in our waters and they can be accommodated alongside agricultural activities by employing mitigation measures and some tolerance. If this does not work, relocation should be employed instead of lethal control. Killing our precious wildlife should never be acceptable.35452020-08-15T10:23:58.11345131Claire fenwickwhy is the only option to kill wildlife? please consider relocation35452020-08-15T11:36:35.5445132David StevensTime to take positive action to restore our nature depleted environment. 35452020-08-15T12:00:49.55345133Dave CookeUse of lethal control should really be last resort for all species. Not sure that simply moving the animals will be long term effective? Don't we need a properly developed management plan to help landowners to live with beavers now that they are back? Different plans depending on the type of land involved too, it can't all be wild and we shouldn't want to exclude beaver from non-wild land?35452020-08-15T13:13:14.6445135Ann JacksonBeavers are not vermin and should not be murdered. They are beloved and should be protected, many people would enjoy watching these wonderful creatures35452020-08-15T14:18:56.62745138Simon CursonBeavers are important ecological drivers. They should not be killed if they are causing problems but relocated to areas without Beavers.35452020-08-15T14:28:46.02745139Linda GilgannonRelocation rate than killing!35452020-08-15T15:36:48.74745140Javed AhmedIn a day and age where global climate change, and species extinction are house hold terms, this needless culling of a magnificent species, which engineers it's environment, in a way which is beneficial not only to itself, but also to other species, is not only inhumane, but also ecologically unsound. \r\n\r\nRe-home. Don't exterminate.35452020-08-15T16:40:04.6645142Clive WorrallI cant believe in 2020 we are still killing animals just because they dont fit with the human way of life. Very depressing.35452020-08-15T16:42:14.24745143Richard Hannavy CousenRelocate these creatures. How can you get up in the morning - look in the mirror knowing today "I'll be slaughtering stuff, thats the solution" Unfathomable.....35452020-08-15T19:22:56.07345144Josephine CartmellBeavers are a keystone species and an ecosystem engineer whose presence reduces effects of climate change and allows nature to flourish. It is shocking that they are being killed rather than being moved to another location.35452020-08-15T19:39:34.51345146David MoxeyRelocating them is the only result that should happen35452020-08-15T20:22:26.81345147Rosemary ThirdYet another disgrace where SNH is not protecting a 'PROTECTED' species an d at a time when nature is in crisis and there is a critical need to restore the landscape, improve biodiversity , tackle climate Change and stop cruelty. We really do need to listen to the science and act upon it. Please relocate our beavers if absolutely necessary but please allow them to start restoring the landscape to improve biodiversity and to manage water flows and land relief.35452020-08-15T20:23:26.78345148Rosemary ThirdYet another disgrace where SNH is not protecting a 'PROTECTED' species an d at a time when nature is in crisis and there is a critical need to restore the landscape, improve biodiversity , tackle climate Change and stop cruelty. We really do need to listen to the science and act upon it. Please relocate our beavers if absolutely necessary but please allow them to start restoring the landscape to improve biodiversity and to manage water flows and land relief.35452020-08-15T20:32:49.11745149Clive Jones The value beavers do for ameliorating climate change adaptation far outweighs any supposed impact on farming. The greedy farmers who will take the benefits beavers bring but not move an inch to accommodate them. The amount of shooting of birds and animals in Scotland brings shame on a wonderful country. The recent flooding hazards are a warning that we need a rewilded landscape to help us cope.35452020-08-15T21:48:21.70745150Michael ShawWith a little cooperation there are beavers co-existing happily with farming in the heart of strathmore. Space for all. No need to kill or translocations. Beaver deceiver keeps field clear and farm uses beaver pool water for irrigation in times of drought. Been this way since Beavers first here. Proud of my farming neighbours. Ashamed of those that bankstrip and cause erosion just to starve out nature.35452020-08-16T07:46:34.4645151Sandy AndersinPlease do not kill these beautiful creatures. Re locate them if need be. Why on earth would u release them into wild then a few years later want to kill them? What is wrong with u? 35452020-08-16T08:13:28.5345152Diana WesterhoffFar too much killing of our wildlife for dubious benefits.35452020-08-16T08:39:48.08745153Dominic DunniganExplain to me the logic of reintroducing animals just to cull them.\r\nSame goes for Red Kites and Sea Eagles.\r\nWhose vested interests are really at threat here?\r\nBe honest!35452020-08-16T08:54:53.44345154Cathy GallagherHow are they supposed to thrive if people keep killing them? It ought to be prison - no matter who you are. The 35452020-08-16T09:19:58.63745155Cheryl Nield de CrespoI can't believe you allow the killing of beavers. Disgraceful.35452020-08-16T09:37:49.82745156Samantha CalvertBeavers create natural defences against flooding. If numbers are too high in a particular place, relocate them elsewhere. Manage them don't kill them 35452020-08-16T09:54:37.79745157Maureen LovattWhy put beavers there then kill them . They are good for ecology.35452020-08-16T09:59:36.86345159Linda HargieA sensible suggestion during a pandemic. 35832020-08-16T10:02:19.56745160Beverly Tibbleswhy I am signing when I live in NZ. Because I have an interest in UK wildlife through TV programmes, DVD, magazines, Twitter friends. The beaver is an iconic animal and part of the waterways wildlife ecosystems. Advantages of beave habitats outwieigh any disadvantages,35452020-08-16T10:14:35.09745161Angela J Rowlands These beautiful animals need a to be protected and kept safe. 35452020-08-16T10:24:05.28345162John PepperScotland must be more bold and move more rapidly with rewilding.35452020-08-16T10:33:04.3145163Huw ThomasThe benefits of reintroduction are well-established (hence protected status). That being the case, why not seize the opportunity presented here and relocate beavers to areas in which they are not currently present and in which there are landowners that are ready and willing to receive them? The benefits that they bring (biodiversity, flood prevention, water quality, tourism, etc.) must surely outweigh the relatively minor cost of relocation and it looks appalling for the Scottish government to be sanctioning the killing of such large numbers of a protected species every year.35452020-08-16T10:45:44.96745164Julie FulwellThis war against our wildlife must end! We are supposed to be a civilised society, please no more killing!35452020-08-16T13:47:41.6845165Donna HughesMove them don't kill them. They help keep our land balanced. 35452020-08-16T14:34:27.57345166Delia CummingThe granting of licence to shoot, maim, kill beavers by farmers needs to be rethought. With widespread, localised anthropogenic climate change causing more and more flooding to land and properties that usually evade this, but are now being subjected to flooding is, the beavers have their place in the aquatic world of river engineering. Don't wipe them out with gunshot. Farmers need to be educated. And I'm a smallholder who respects and lives with beavers when they choose my section of the river, unlike the almighty farming field and monster log cabin tourist facility on the other side that has no respect for any riparian corridor nor indeed, any consideration for anything other than their own wallets.35452020-08-16T14:36:57.6745167Elizabeth Timlin Instead of permitting a broad sweep killing season on this very recently reintroduced wild species, please allow beavers time to reproduce at least three generations, enabling them to settle into their habitat. Please adopt the suggested policy of translocation for beavers causing issues for farmers. This will assist the farmers & allow the beavers to do what they are environmentally skilled at doing, which, among other things, is managing land at flood risk. 35452020-08-16T16:46:01.7245168Barbara. Feal MartinezPlease don't kill relocate balance of animals is too important35452020-08-16T17:03:28.25345169Lizzi WaltonThis endless persecution and violence to our wildlife must be stopped. Politicians are not doing their job we must start protecting nature 35452020-08-16T18:00:01.3445170Jen ChamberlainIn this ever changing world we need to protect beavers as their habitats are diminishing... relocate and help save these very beautiful and so useful to the environment creatures.35452020-08-16T18:17:34.62745171Stephen KourikDon't cull, translocate instead.35452020-08-16T19:05:14.09345172Katie BloodBeavers are so important to maintaining the natural environment, and preventing further damage to our eco system, probably caused by humans in the first place! Save the Beavers 35452020-08-16T19:06:18.72745173Ian James LaceyI find it hard to believe that anywhere in Scotland can have an excess of beavers. Culling deer is understandable but what is the the population of beavers compared to them?35452020-08-16T19:34:32.10745174Eileen MccannWhat was the point of introducing beavers to allow people to shoot them. Can we please work cooperatively but not allow the killing? Please? 35452020-08-16T21:06:35.73345176Ian Ramsay. Animals deserve a life.....not to be cast aside because it doesn't suit humans .35452020-08-16T21:48:46.0345177Phil abramsonRelocate the critters. Why oh why do you have to kill these wonderful animals35452020-08-16T22:13:47.80345178Sir Douglas Brown-Walker Let's see if the Scottish government can't do one thing correctly 35452020-08-16T22:44:49.30345180Justin Gordon-FarleighUtterly preposterous!!!! Shooting Beavers now??? I have no words!!!!! 35452020-08-16T23:43:07.56745181Giulia Bartolomucci They were here before us it's just fair giving them the space and life they deserve. 35452020-08-17T07:13:48.82745183Eddy SullivanIncredible creatures that do so much good for the natural environment. 35452020-08-17T07:53:07.98745184Heather Manning Give land over to them to help areas prone to flooding like my own town of Stonehaven 35452020-08-17T07:58:04.4145186Melinda CrookBeavers help recent flooding. They are vegetarian. Culling is not called for. Therr activity can be managed without killing them. Scotland needs to show its intelligence not its brutality35452020-08-17T08:38:37.2645187Sharon HopkinsThis is appalling !! We saw a report on bbc news only last week that the beavers were given assurances they would be protected. Why is Scot Gov and SNH caving into the farmers and landowners to have them killed? Haven't these intelligent creatures suffered enough persecution? How about live and let live !35452020-08-17T09:11:40.1145188julia hammettBeavers are meant to be protected by law in Scotland. Why then are licences being given to landowners to kill them? Allow them to be translocated in safe areas in Scotland instead. Protection must mean protection for beavers and mountain hares. Resist capitulating to the shooting estates please. Conserve wildlife, stop killing it.35452020-08-17T10:06:21.16345190Rebecca ThurgurThe positive impact that beavers have on our landscape far outweighs any detriment. Find a space to allow them to live and thrive. 35452020-08-17T10:20:24.32345191Scott AppleyardAllowqing Farmers to shoot Beavers makes a mockery of their protected status, Scottish Natural Heritage are complicit in this draconian behaviour35452020-08-17T10:27:31.71345192Keith Taylor Beavers are essential for our biodiversity. They must be given space and time to become part of our beautiful country.35452020-08-17T10:37:02.35745194Frances BaillieRe-locate!! Allow volunteers trained by RSPB and other relevant charities to solve dilemma. Where this a productive answer, there should ALWAYS be a matched government response.35452020-08-17T11:01:45.7845195francoise stichelbautBeavers are good for nature and to combat climate change. Let's keep them as allies rather than allowing them to get killed, which is totally counterproductive!35452020-08-17T11:13:54.79345196David HoufeWith support to farmers where necessary, we should be spreading these natural flood mitigators, not killing them.35452020-08-17T11:54:34.09745197Stuart trelfaPlease move the beavers if they are causing real problems. Not a few farmers whims35452020-08-17T12:06:55.84745198John Childswhen will we stop killing our wildlife 35452020-08-17T12:15:58.945199Joan GrechThere is no excuse for killing beavers. Just move them to a location where the minimal damage they cause will be tolerated and the huge benefits they bring are appreciated.35452020-08-17T12:23:49.7145200Mrs Helen SeddonIt's so easy to slaughter wildlife but so hard to save and encourage it when we are running out of time!!35452020-08-17T12:32:23.77745201Hilary GeeBarbaric stupid & not necessary. Move not slaughter & use their flood control skills. 35452020-08-17T13:12:29.79345205Sarah DruryThey have been re introduced for a good reason, to help the environment so what's the point in starting to kill them again?!?! Please move them instead35452020-08-17T13:41:54.11745207Karin McDonaldOur wildlife needs more protection. It should be illegal to kill beavers because the improve our environment.35452020-08-17T13:42:18.39745208Yvonne DouglasIt is their world too35452020-08-17T13:42:23.7545209Chip Holger PonsfordPlease save ecosystems, beavers are part of our very vulnerable ecosystems, which support all, includinh human, life on earth. please make killing beavers illegal in line with theirstatus as protected.35452020-08-17T13:48:05.37745210Irene CaseyPlease do all you can to relocate these animals.35452020-08-17T13:54:12.75745211Stewart Andersonvisit kinnordy loch several times a week and the problem with the beavers population is the human part of the equation. You need a fair ammount of water in the loch to be classed by wildlife as a suitable wet-land to live successfully and rear offspring for all our future enjoyment . More use of RSPB drainpipe depth leveler systems should be made more use of35452020-08-17T14:00:28.4445212Helen Senn, RZSSAs partners in the Scottish Beaver Trial and Scottish Beavers project, the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland is partly responsible for the official reintroduction of beavers to Scotland. This marked the first successful reintroduction of a mammal in the UK.\r\n \r\nAs advocates for the reintroduction of beavers to Scotland, we believe that beavers, when released in the correct areas, can bring massive ecosystem and biodiversity benefits for this country. We also believe there are several areas in Scotland, as yet unoccupied by beavers, that would be suitable for releasing beavers caught in Tayside as part of human-wildlife conflict mitigation. Finally, we acknowledge that in certain specific situations, lethal control of beavers will be necessary as a last resort.\r\n \r\nWe would welcome translocations of beavers to suitable habitat outside their existing range if such translocations were conducted in line with IUCN guidelines on translocations, with the correct licensing and stakeholder engagement, and with the backing and guidance of the National Species Reintroduction Forum. RZSS representatives have raised this idea regularly at meetings of both the Scottish Beaver Forum and the National Species Reintroduction Forum. We also advocate for more stringent and transparent management of lethal control in beavers.\r\n \r\nWe are proud and excited that beavers are back in Scotland. Now is the time to work together to develop a well-planned translocation strategy and ensure these amazing ecosystem engineers have a bright future in our country.35452020-08-17T14:26:42.44345215Daniel VerhammeIf only Parliament had voted for Mark Ruskell's amendment to the Animals Bill in June...35452020-08-17T14:47:06.66745217Annie BerryWhy would anyone shoot these creatures when they can also be so beneficial to the countryside? Please please please stop it35452020-08-17T15:13:58.90345218Kaye BoydScotland should be leading the way in nature conservation instead of just kill, kill kill when there are completely viable alternative measures that can be taken. 35452020-08-17T15:16:20.5545219Debra HallI am completely opposed to any killing of beavers. They should be rehomed if absolutely necessary but never harmed.35452020-08-17T15:51:40.86345220John LeitchKilling reintroduce species... Wrong on so many levels35452020-08-17T16:00:00.1345221Beverley CaryThe beavers can play a vital role in combatting the disastrous impacts of climate change35452020-08-17T16:27:20.49745222Chrissie AytonTranslocation is the logical and viable alternative to the present totally unnecessary solution!35452020-08-17T16:28:21.5645223Matthew ZimmerThere must be a better way to handle this situation than to simply kill the beavers35452020-08-17T16:29:02.82745224David NutterIt seems contradictory to spend money on reintroducing the beaver only to kill specimens off in considerable numbers where they happen to be inconvenient to some. Ideally manage any potential conflict in situ using agricultural subsidy as a lever or in a pinch relocate animals elsewhere. Certainly don't shoot them. They're a a very important part of the ecosystem. 35452020-08-17T16:30:17.0745225Kathleen BrownIt is a discussion that can be so difficult but so useful to be open about. Thank you Sameena35832020-08-17T16:46:06.345226Neville COXthere is to much killing of wildlife going on in Scotland just needs to stop wildlife will balance its self out35452020-08-17T16:54:59.88745227Clive WestonPlease don't kill this keystone species. If necessary please move them to suitable habitat. 35452020-08-17T16:55:36.0245228Tony wattI urge you to consider this very sensible proposal to relocate beavers to suitable habitats rather than killing this incredibly important animal. \r\n\r\nThis policy will avoid unnecessary destruction & allow the species to improve habitats & biodiversity of other areas within Scotland. \r\n\r\nYour decision will likely influence future proposals on rewilding the UK, i urge you to consider this proposal\r\n\r\n35452020-08-17T16:55:47.65345229Clive WestonPlease don't kill this keystone species. If necessary please move them to suitable habitat. 35452020-08-17T16:57:46.58345230Charlotte ProbyThis is very important. We can live alongside these diligent creatures who will prevent flooding and improve our countryside as long as we locate them in appropriate areas. Scotland is rich in appropriate areas. We need to sort this in a sustainable and intelligent manner. Please pay attention to this petition. Thanks 35452020-08-17T17:16:45.04745231mark mcnultyThere needs to be immediate action to stop the killing of beavers that cause no damage .35452020-08-17T18:14:58.96745232Christopher ConnollyWhy introduce beavers and then allow them to be shot? Killing them is cruel. It's a moral issue. 35452020-08-17T18:16:37.63745233Robert Iles Please relocate beavers. Would really like some more South of the border. Lethal control should be an absolute last resort as there are so many places in the UK willing to have a population of beavers.35452020-08-17T18:17:34.1445234Eddie BathgateIt seems ridiculous to permit native mammals to be killed when they protect the environment downstream from flooding 35452020-08-17T18:18:14.62345235Joan MongerLeave the Beavers alone plz..35452020-08-17T18:20:00.2345236Catherine VictorCannot see the need to cull these poor animals35452020-08-17T18:57:13.4145238Stuart Morse These valuable creatures need protection as much as farming needs it's land. Relocate them to somewhere safe. 35452020-08-17T19:19:53.47745239Sue HarperWhat is the matter with people, killing beavers for what???? think that there are more important things to do than murder innocent animals35452020-08-17T19:21:26.50745241Angela DonaldWhy introduce animals back into our rivers ways only to persecute them, makes no sense 35452020-08-17T19:23:25.2145242Iain SharplesI didn't know this, I thought that Beavers had full protection, is nothing in the countryside safe from persecution.35452020-08-17T19:42:38.30345243Hilary DaltonMore Criminal acts against wild life What in Gods name is the matter with us?35452020-08-17T20:06:29.1445245Birgitta JansaThe voice for animals has no borders. Don't shoot the beavers! 35452020-08-17T20:07:38.07745246Keith WilliamsIf the beavers are in the wrong place let people move them to the right place dont kill them35452020-08-17T20:11:07.0945248James Aldridge We need beavers nationally, they are a vital part of our future. If beavers cannot remain in one area why not move them to another?35452020-08-17T20:12:23.4845249Deb SpencerAll the time and effort that people put in to reintroducing the beavers, and now some other people want to shoot them!! \r\nLeave the beavers alone or relocate. 35452020-08-17T20:30:07.20345250Alan J BlackPlease, why can't our nation, all nations, be kinder to animals. Our treatment of animals generally is something we should be ashamed of. How anyone can deliberately murder animals such as badgers is a disgrace. Rewilding should be encouraged in Scotland - not strangled at birth.35452020-08-17T20:49:31.2445251David StevensThe policy of not allowing translocation flies in the face of commitments made by Scot Gov in relation to the Climate Emergency it has declared. I regularly visit a country where beavers are accepted. The difference in the level of biodiversity is stark. Yes problems do occur but they are dealt with. We are being dictated to my a few landowners and land managers who are happy to collect subsidies but reluctant to accept any obligations that might be imposed on them for the common good. They restrict the freedom for other land managers and farmers who would welcome beavers on their land. Time for change.35452020-08-17T21:22:38.14745252Richard WaldenCome on Scotland you are better than this, put an end to the killing fields.35452020-08-17T21:55:53.57745253Valerie FinneganI agree totally that beavers should be relocated not exterminated 35452020-08-17T22:48:27.645254Douglas CrabtreeDon't kill the beavers! Completely unnecessary35452020-08-18T00:37:33.56745255Alison MooreCoexistence ideal, but translocation must be made legal in case that is not possible. 35452020-08-18T06:27:14.4745256Susannah FanshaweDisgusting to kill native mammals who were eradicated by humans and only just re-introduced into the countryside. Badgers are hugely positive for nature and have every right to be here.\r\nThe usual suspects want to kill everything that moves on 'their' land and are given licenses to do so. At the very least the animals should be relocated to areas where there are not at risk from those who want to kill them.35452020-08-18T08:09:40.61345257Pamela CawthorneBeavers are beneficial creatures, please do not eradicate them.35452020-08-18T08:21:28.43745258Yvonne BolesWhen there is such a huge scope to return beavers back to their natural range in Scotland, it seems completely illogical that they are just shot instead. We can do a lot better than this! 35452020-08-18T08:38:42.75745259Stephen WhiteCome on Scotland, we're better than this. Is the implementation of translocation really so difficult?35452020-08-18T08:50:15.1845260Katya BorowskiWe are living through a mass extinction of biodiversity - we must look to the creative solutions offered to prevent adding to this crisis. Scotland has shown great leadership to the world in recent months, please do it again with this issue! 35452020-08-18T09:00:29.47345261Mary GriffinRewilding, reintroduction of extinct species, and protection of our dwindling and threatened flora and fauna is vital and essential for the natural health and balance of the UK. 35452020-08-18T09:43:21.35745263richard pilkingtonok, so I'm English so shouldn't really have a say on this matter, but in an era where our country is increasingly run by tory idiots, the English are increasingly looking to the Scots for some kind of common sense. This one seems to be a no brainer.35452020-08-18T10:14:14.07745264Jenifer BunnettFar from being a nation of animal lovers, as we purport to be, we seem to kill as much as we can. Excuses abound to enable people to slaughter our wildlife. It has to stop, and we need to find ways to include ourselves in nature again, not set ourselves apart from it. 35452020-08-18T10:44:26.82745265Maria LaneWhy were they introduced if they are now to be murdered?35452020-08-18T12:18:41.0445267Anita O'ConnorPlease spare your wildlife, the joy of seeing them is to be protected not destroyed for sheer greed, I'm sorry there's nature for a reason and its a good reason, leave them be. Co-exist with nature or we will have nothing to show for it just drought and destruction.35452020-08-18T14:57:21.24345268Pam JonesBeyond words why this is happening!35452020-08-18T16:17:06.90345269Adrian AppleyThey must be saved.35452020-08-18T16:50:19.1845271GARY DAVISWhat with this and the raptor killing. I will be advising all bird and wildlife watchers I know to boycott Scotland. 35452020-08-18T18:06:16.0545272William WiswellThe presence of beavers has been shown to be more beneficial than harmful given the flooding we have seen in Scotland in the recent past the value of beavers in managing water flow cannot be ignored. Surely it is better to relocate than kill them.35452020-08-18T19:19:05.00345274Martha PotterStudent paramedics should be entitled to a bursary the same as student nurses35782020-08-18T19:48:17.7945275Margaret tealePlease do not kill these wonderful creatures\r\n35452020-08-18T19:55:30.20745276ian butlerPlease prevent the unnecessary slaughter of our country's fledgling beaver population and aid the translocation of them.35452020-08-18T20:15:21.70745277Joe GreenleesEmgland are leading the way on this35452020-08-18T20:34:10.46745278Robert WaterhouseI consider this to be appalling. Why do people persist in considering wildlife to be a 'problem' to be solved simply by killing them if they happen to be in the 'wrong' place. And shame upon the Scottish governmental organisations for letting it happen. You are supposed to be protecting wild animals, not killing them!35452020-08-18T22:01:31.23745279Natalie McGonigleThis is wrong and is not helpful. 35452020-08-18T22:17:19.35745281John GoodwinFor 60 years I have been listening to land owners talk about controlling things, when they mean shooting.\r\nBeavers are a keystone species and crucial to the healthy ecology of Scotland, and the benefits far outweigh the minor inconvenience to the odd wealthy landowner.\r\n35452020-08-19T00:01:27.4845284Melanie Pownall-HarrisIf farmers are having their lands damaged by Beavers they should be compensated and the rewilding should continue apace, we share this world and this should be recognised. 35452020-08-19T06:13:39.01345286Craig Lymm Allow them to naturally spread.35452020-08-19T07:52:36.245288Andrew AitkenPlease relocate not kill.\r\nWhat you are doing by allowing people to buy a licence to shoot a protected species is no better than the African states allowing people to shoot giraffes, elephants etc.35452020-08-19T07:56:18.65345289Gary EwartFarmers and shooting estates within Scotland are too quick to kill wildlife. Another option is a available please help.35452020-08-19T08:02:03.7345290Deryck van SteenderenCulling animals critical to ecosystem stabilisation is insanity. Relocation to other areas in need of ecosystem stabilisation is an intelligent solution. 35452020-08-19T08:04:33.9245291Naomi SharplesSurely it's not beyond the wit of people to be able to move the Beavers, rather than kill them. The decision to reintroduce them is a human one. Do the humane thing.35452020-08-19T08:10:22.3145292Rosemary Anne MacKinnonUk wildlife is already under too much threat. We reintroduced the beavers, we have a responsibility to care for them.35452020-08-19T08:22:49.56345293Christopher J ChappellIt is a disgace that licences are being issued to kill beavers and I will not viist Scotland while this policy persists. 35452020-08-19T08:34:16.9345295Mike PetersScotland wishes to be seen as a progressive nation yet continues to have very poor welfare of wild animals as it's treatment of beavers and it's continued tolerance of the sharing and shooting of wild animals and birds on grouse moors shows.35452020-08-19T08:36:32.3845296Trevor Thorogood A very backwards looking policy, vast open spaces and still you want to shoot anything that moves. A wonderful opportunity to return a native to the wild !35452020-08-19T08:54:21.39745298David MossShooting beavers does seem an odd way of protecting them.35452020-08-19T09:05:23.8945299Hugh BrownVisiting the Knapdale Beaver reserve last year was one of the highlights of our visit to Scotland. Killing these creatures is wrong.35452020-08-19T09:09:13.45345300Linda MalpasI was utterly staggered when I heard on Spring watch this year of the "licensed killing" of 87 Badgers in Scotland! I was simply shocked at the way the SNP fall over backwards for farmers in Scotland! Beavers are protected - I thought! Did not the Scottish government have the intelligence to think of alternative solutions? After all we are a). living with an existential crisis of species decline (including the human species) and b). Beavers have a hugely beneficial effect on the landscape, as is well documented. Shame on you Scottish government! 35452020-08-19T09:11:02.71745301Mark BloiceWe must protect them all. 35452020-08-19T09:15:41.99745302kris driessenIn a balanced ecosystem each plant and animal plays a part. You may think that beaver is insignificant, but that's because you need more education. Beavers play an important role in relation to other wildlife. Save the beaver.35452020-08-19T09:24:20.8145303Sarah CameronBeavers can help with management of watercourses and extensive areas of habitat and should be moved to new areas and not culled.35452020-08-19T09:57:45.64345305Ian McLeanWell beyond time to end lethal control and to take full advantage of all the benefits that Beavers bring to the countryside in Scotland.35452020-08-19T11:14:27.1745306Richard EbbsWhy is human instinct, when confronted with a wildlife "problem", inevitably to kill the perceived perpetrator? Insane!\r\n 35452020-08-19T11:57:57.9645307Nikki GrahamShooting a protected species is not the way forward. We need to learn how to live in harmony with wildlife as the natural world is vital for our own long-term survival.35452020-08-19T13:57:06.945309Simon TuckerTranslocation throughout the British Isles sounds like a fine idea.35452020-08-19T15:22:58.83345311Kim BlissRelocation not extermination.35452020-08-19T15:35:32.50745312SARAH ASPINALLPlease leave the beavers alone! 35452020-08-19T17:37:57.4945313Lydia Reid Our babies are too important to make cost an issue \r\nDo all we can \r\nIn the long run it may save money \r\n35892020-08-19T20:09:39.85745314Christine LassamTranslocating Beavers to Areas where Beavers are needed is vital to help the whole UK with Flooding. Better water retention. Better water quality and creating a better habitat for wildlife and fish. Grants to help farmers and having Beaver Consultants as they have in Bavaria would make a big difference to the way farmers think about Beavers. Culling beavers is such a waste of the Key species who will help us resolve many of the problems we have with extreme weather including Flooding and Drought.35452020-08-19T21:22:40.5445315Hazel GrantDon't hate, relocate! Really though, stop culling things!!35452020-08-19T21:27:38.66745317Rachael HoldingInstead of celebrating such wonderful creatures in Scotland, they seem intent on destroying them. I despair of this Scottish government.35452020-08-19T21:39:04.19745318Debra FosterPlease don't kill them, relocate them!35452020-08-19T21:40:49.1845319Angela CoatesShow some compassion please.35452020-08-19T22:37:17.59745320peter reganwhats wrong with this country,we spend years trying to introduce a keystone species. But because they become successful at what they do we exterminate them all over again, we never learn. Perhaps if we were to farm beaver they might stand a chance.\r\n35452020-08-19T22:37:30.09745321Alexander ClokeConsidering there are numerous confirmed suitable sites around the UK for beavers, it seems counterproductive killing them, particularly as they are few in number and now protected.35452020-08-20T11:27:59.8945323Robert CowburnI think the beaver are good for the ecological benefit of the locations. 35452020-08-20T11:29:42.06345324Alasdair MacKenzieA great deal of hard work has been put in over many years to reintroducing these iconic animals to Scotland and too allow them to be killed is an utter disgrace. Their skills should be used to modify existing habitats for the good of all and so please allow them to be moved to where they are wanted and can do a useful job rather than simply be slaughtered.35452020-08-20T11:37:18.28345325Graham BusbyBeavers are a necessary part of the ecosystem.35452020-08-20T11:46:32.2245326Graeme HullThe policy of issuing licences to cull beavers on Tayside, totally undermines their European Protected Status. Additionally, this policy particularly if it is expanded to cover other areas, highlights the Scottish government's half-hearted approach to the reintroduction of this pivotal species and wildlife conservation in general! 35452020-08-20T11:52:24.47345327Eric RoyWhat a waste, to introduce beavers to Scotland and then to consider killing then rather than relocation. 35452020-08-20T11:56:24.9145328Tony Biebuyck Shooting beavers is in microcosm the government failure to get on board with measures to combat environmental degradation. Opposition must put beavers in that context. We have an emergency with warming and pollution. Beavers are a test of awareness and serious policy change. 35452020-08-20T12:04:42.3245330Catherine ColstonBeavers can be a viable contribution to flood prevention and should be preserved where they can be a vital resource.35452020-08-20T12:41:21.61745331Mat LarkinTo reintroduce a native species while at the same time culling a fifth of its fragile population makes little sense in conservation terms. Translocate rather than kill please - there's many willing landowners waiting to receive beavers on their land with open arms. 35452020-08-20T13:06:04.545332Rosemary RooneyBeavers are experts in managing their environment. Having been reintroduced, they deserve protection and not death.35452020-08-20T13:34:07.0545333Alan CameronAt a time of climate emergency when beavers can be shown to have a positive effect on their environment, moving those few beavers who appear to be a problem to places where they can make positive difference makes environmental and economic sense.35452020-08-20T13:40:02.89345334Christine Packer Beavers are hugely beneficial to the landscape, to wildlife and for climate change. They belong here so let them have a home.35452020-08-20T13:53:21.7245336Paula Olde-WolbersIf the Scottish Government is serious about climate change and the environment - translocate beavers - do not shoot them! 35452020-08-20T14:02:55.97745337Mary Catherine macintyrelet our wildlife thrive.35452020-08-20T14:51:56.4845338Vanessa Anderson Communication and getting local land owners and farmers on board is very important to the success of the project. \r\nPerhaps an incentive scheme to allow some beavers on their land might be considered.35452020-08-20T14:54:36.85745340Roger LindsayStop the mass slaughter of Scotland's wildlife now.35452020-08-20T15:16:28.65745341Valerie HamblinThey should be allowed to co exist with us in their naturally habitat as they have in the past.35452020-08-20T15:57:29.83345344Carol HaydenAs the beavers have been reintroduced to Scotland to start with, surely we can move them to a better location if necessary.35452020-08-20T15:58:25.4345345Julie PriddlePlease relocate them, do not kill them!35452020-08-20T16:23:27.445346Judith MillarPlease do all you can. We need to give animals a voice.\r\n35452020-08-20T16:42:32.9545347Neil Andrew LewisThese beautiful animals are so important to our ecology and if left to do their thing, are a real benefit to river systems. Killing them for any reason is bad enough but the thought of re-introducing them, just so they can then be shot, is sickening. Move them if needs be but please, please end this terrible practice. Ditto, for the killing of raptors as part of the so-called 'sport' of grouse shooting. We are better than this! Thank you... 35452020-08-20T20:15:33.5945348Marsha Eastwood Beavers have a purpose so relocate never kill a healthy animal. 35452020-08-20T20:37:25.5945349Christine McPhersonBeavers are a protected species and should not be shot unnecessarily especially as so much effort has gone into reintroducing them in specific areas. 35452020-08-20T20:55:54.93745350ashlea shawPlease relocate beavers to improve waterway health across the country instead of any cull.35452020-08-20T20:56:46.39345351Helen BoyleCome on Scot Govt show you really are concerned about our wildlife and environment and not just selling us some rhetoric.35452020-08-20T21:53:44.16345352Martin RobertsIt's madness to deliberately kill beavers. They are nature's builders and create new habitats just by going about their daily lives. 35452020-08-20T21:53:50.01745353Jim MartinPlease.35452020-08-20T22:06:35.77345354Andrew AventThis is an entirely unnecessary and unjustifiable piece of persecution of a rare and valuable mammal. Please take our concerns seriously :)35452020-08-20T22:30:33.4345355Nicola BonarBan beaver hunting. In fact ban all hunting.35452020-08-20T22:45:30.80345356Eleanor AdamA review by Scottish Government is long overdue of farming vested interests and their impact on the wildlife and the environment.35452020-08-21T01:28:07.67345357Kay GibsonRelocation to suitable areas where they will benefit the environment is the logical solution. Appropriate expertise and habitats are available. Culling is wasteful and unnecessary.35452020-08-21T06:31:23.55745358Barry Graywhy reintroduce if we then allow them to be culled?35452020-08-21T07:23:10.89345360Nick EdenWhen I come up Scotland is to see the wildlife. Is love to see wild beavers. When I come up Scotland I support Scottish businesses and jobs.35452020-08-21T07:33:29.4945361Graeme ReidAll wildlife must be protected.35452020-08-21T07:42:22.5545362Paul TurnerThere is no reason to kill these animals when relocation to a more suitable location is possible.35452020-08-21T08:14:48.41745363Richard DelaneyLeave wildlife alone to live in peace35452020-08-21T08:18:49.3445364ANITA KEENEWish you and the beavers well - relocation sounds very effective - and the best solution for all!!! God bless.35452020-08-21T08:49:53.18745365Russell WoodBeavers can stop flooding, we should use them more.35452020-08-21T09:06:22.34345366Jonathan Thomas MERCERCulling of beavers is short-sighted in terms of their potential benefits to the environment, and contrary to the spirit of their legal protection. We would be happy to have "surplus" beavers here in Lochaber (writing on behalf of Lochaber Biodiversity Action Group) 35452020-08-21T09:10:18.92345367Steph AindowBeavers are a native species that was persecuted to extinction by our forebears. Reintroduction will have long term benefits for local environments - absolutely no excuse for killing these animals - relocate if you must disturb them.35452020-08-21T10:50:16.18745370Helen SennAs partners in the Scottish Beaver Trial and Scottish Beavers project, the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland is partly responsible for the official reintroduction of beavers to Scotland. This marked the first successful reintroduction of a mammal in the UK.\r\n\r\nAs advocates for the reintroduction of beavers to Scotland, we believe that beavers, when released in the correct areas, can bring massive ecosystem and biodiversity benefits for this country. We also believe there are several areas in Scotland, as yet unoccupied by beavers, that would be suitable for releasing beavers caught in Tayside as part of human-wildlife conflict mitigation.\r\n\r\nWe would welcome translocations of beavers to suitable habitat outside their existing range if such translocations were conducted in line with IUCN guidelines on translocations, with the correct licensing and stakeholder engagement, and with the backing and guidance of the National Species Reintroduction Forum. RZSS representatives have made these points repeatedly at meetings of both the Scottish Beaver Forum and the National Species Reintroduction Forum. In tandem with our partners at the Scottish Wildlife Trust, we have also advocated previously for more effective and transparent management of lethal control in beavers.\r\n\r\nWe are proud and excited that beavers are back in Scotland. Now is the time to develop a well-planned translocation strategy to ensure these amazing ecosystem engineers have a bright future in our wild landscapes.35452020-08-21T12:02:24.35345371Charles RutherfordI lived in Argyll for many years and worked in forestry\r\nAll over Scotland. There is ample scope for the beaver to exist alongside other land use. How can we have the conceit to irreparably damage vast tracks of the environment with massive machinery, and yet deny a native animal designed to steward the land and water table, the right to peacefully coexist?35452020-08-21T12:11:32.07345372Craig StewartUnnecessary culling of beavers must cease. They contribute so much to the biodiversity of Scotland.35452020-08-21T13:20:46.9145373Diana MaxwellWe have to have a greater respect for beavers and indeed wildlife in general, if only for the benefits, known or as yet unknown, that they bring to our environment.35452020-08-21T14:41:56.98345375JAYNE BUNTINGGuns versus common sense and compassion?35452020-08-21T14:54:25.28345376Catherine Nightingale Please relocate the beavers - killing them is just wrong.35452020-08-21T14:55:42.12745377Bob MarkhamLet's stop Beavers being the next Skydancers.35452020-08-21T15:49:49.16745378Susan FisherUnbelievable nature isnt ever left in peace. Whats the matter with people.35452020-08-21T16:13:52.9245379Carmelita AistonBeavers are hard working and deserve to live.35452020-08-21T16:30:49.93745380Denise WilkinSurely we must learn to co-exist with our fellow creatures without blasting them out of existence each time they are in our way. If it is possible to relocate them, please do so.35452020-08-21T16:49:07.17345381Chris WrightBeavers have helped to revitalise places where they've been released. You need these guys back.35452020-08-21T17:42:50.38345382Karen CobbettBeaver play a crucial role as a 'keystone' species, restoring wetland eco-systems and producing a network of enriched riparian habitats. They should have full protection!35452020-08-21T17:50:42.27745384Edward WhitemanWithout a doubt 36092020-08-21T18:58:53.645385David Oakley-HillBeavers SHOULD be here.\r\nAnyone killing a beaver should be prosecuted.35452020-08-21T19:27:32.24345386Zoe DempseyPlease put wildlife and nature at the top of the list. Without it we do not have a world worth living in.35452020-08-21T19:35:06.57345387Duncan MartinWe need to learn to work with nature and not against it. The "destruction" that beavers cause actually helps to create more habitat for the vital insects that make this entire planets ecosystem work. Constant distruction of wetland throughout the planet is having a massive dissuption on the wildlife that we rely on to help keep a balanced ecosystem. Without the insects, amphibians and small mammals that thrive in these areas, the larger animals and birds that feed on them start to decline. Its a knock on effect. The whole reason for reintroduction was to recreate a balance. In a few short years, predators will begin to start hunting them again and balance will be restored. To stop the beavers spreading too far, fencing can be installed around the desired area. If we can stop half tonne deer from moving around, we can stop small beavers too. A simple modification to the existing stock fencing should surfice. 35452020-08-21T20:04:21.0645388john bakerWhy does the human race have to kill everything that moves?35452020-08-21T21:18:21.54745389Jacqueline MarshallOld discarded council buildings should be put to better use other than storage, rather than waste public money on their upkeep, put them to better use and for the good of the community35872020-08-21T21:34:40.60345390Andrea NichollsToo often animals are killed if they cause inconvenience to man when they could be relocated to benefit another area. We have to find ways to share and learn from these beautiful creatures. 35452020-08-21T22:08:27.61345391ANDREW BISSITTPlease show some latitude in your decision regarding the licenced killing of beavers. The more something is given a 'legal' status, the more others will follow the lead illegally.35452020-08-21T22:08:56.5245392Bob MorleyYes, but very important not to create tomorrow's slums so insist on building standards, excellent insulation etc.35872020-08-22T06:26:22.9145394Kate DuncanThe interdependence of all aspects of the natural world are well know. Destroy one thing and it impacts elsewhere. Diversity is essential, enriching and declining in this country at a terrifying rate. Apart from that, beavers are beautiful, clever and can teach us a lot about saving us from floods. We need to learn from them, save them, not kill them. 35452020-08-22T06:34:27.7745395James WoodLeave wildlife alone. Stop "controlling" it.35452020-08-22T06:42:01.61345396Alyson BaldingNo species should be persecuted to distinction, man has no right, please find a solution.35452020-08-22T08:09:23.6145397Mary RipleyThis just doesn't need to happen.35452020-08-22T08:13:50.90745398Jeff lockeTotally agree, these beavers need protection.35452020-08-22T08:53:21.8545399Gary LawrenceWhen will we finally have people running our country who really want to put an end to killing animals?35452020-08-22T08:56:19.61745400Karen AllenThink before you kill. We need beavers to restore wetland habitats. Legal and effective protection now. 35452020-08-22T09:05:53.71345401Jane BrownBeavers are an asset to our precious environment. 35452020-08-22T09:08:11.2945402Rurh HurstThey just need to be given a chance. They can do so much good towards promoting biodiversity, promoting flood protection etc.35452020-08-22T11:20:40.01345404Rachael MuirPlease leave the beavers, and implement a policy of relocation instead. 35452020-08-22T13:30:31.51345406Aaron Sterritt"We can do better" \r\n\r\nThink about the wider ecological and economic benefits. Such as increased biodiversity and carbon capture, increased opportunities in an expanding eco-tourism market.35452020-08-22T13:42:51.98745407jan fergusonThere has to be a better way than culling.35452020-08-22T14:28:29.64745410Neil HuttonAfter all the work on reintroduction it seems criminal to shoot beavers now.35452020-08-22T15:04:32.745411Susan Clare FernieBeavers play an important role in conservation by helping to keep nature in balance thus restoring and protecting the natural ecosystem.35452020-08-22T16:06:01.1345412Neil rumbolWe must do all we can to save them. Similarly, we must help save the Scottish Wildcats as well - even rarer than the beavers.35452020-08-22T16:10:24.00745413Carol MacKenzie They all deserve a bursary 35782020-08-22T16:46:20.35345414Alexis HolmesI fully support this in memory of those we have lost.35892020-08-22T17:28:21.82745415Hilary GeeDaft and cruel. They manage streams & wetlands & reduce floods. We killed these native animals off - now we can repair the damage & improve our environment for free.35452020-08-22T20:46:57.77345417Jeanette BrindleyNurses and Midwives and Paramedics should be treated equally35782020-08-22T21:46:33.56345418Omar LakkisShooting a beaver is an immoral and stupid act. 35452020-08-22T22:04:23.245419Richard GrahamPlease allow beavers to be relocated - this will boost Scotland's biodiversity at the same time as reducing needless shooting of these amazing wild animals.35452020-08-22T22:55:39.0245420Ann EllisShooting is not a humane or sensible solution. Beavers are wonderful animals. Moving them makes much more sense.\r\n35452020-08-23T07:21:46.38345421Michael Farrell Educate and incentivise farmers to see the benefits of beavers on their land and support relocation or mitigation. 35452020-08-23T08:33:43.6645422Oliver ClanfordWe have a moral, ethical and environmental duty to live side by side with these native mammals. 35452020-08-23T09:49:24.9245425David WoodsBeavers are a keystone species which will prevent future catastrophic flooding, improve fish stocks and biodiversity. It is integral that beavers be relocated across all of the UK rather than exterminated.35452020-08-23T10:15:34.89745426Sally KeirBeavers are a vital part of our ecosystem and that is why they were reintroduced to Scotland. Relocate them where they can do most good. 35452020-08-23T11:38:37.9245427John BatesGolden eagles being killed. Sea eagles being poisoned. Beavers being shot. What gives Scotland? 35452020-08-23T14:14:31.44345430Edith LivesayBeavers can play a crucial part in restoring Scotland, my ancestral homeland. I ask that you work with Trees for Life to develop an effective relocation plan for beavers to expand their populations across more of their native range as a key measure in habitat restoration and climate change mitigation (as beaver ponds very effectively sequester carbon).35452020-08-23T14:42:17.54345431Jenny Bourne Find humane methods for relocating these animals.35452020-08-23T14:51:26.4545432Kam Tsang It is unnecessary to kill them in the first place and even more so when they can be relocated.35452020-08-23T15:09:37.6745433William GrayKilling off animals that help prevent flooding is idiotic as well as barbaric.35452020-08-23T15:16:52.49745434ashlea shawPlease relocate excess beavers elsewhere, would love to have them in Sussex!35452020-08-23T16:52:12.33745435Ellie MeadowsPlease stop!35452020-08-23T17:41:17.51745436Risa CaldwellHumans need to intervene. All creatures matter! 35452020-08-23T17:45:20.5545437Jeff DelveWhilst change will always be resisted the overall positives of beaver interaction with landscapes means they are a real positive in bringing back biodiversity and flood protection and drought protection too for the benefit of all. If verified local issues do arise then compensation or relocation should be the response not pandering to those whose response is always lethal control. 35452020-08-23T18:46:12.945438Mrs Julie BlackburnIt is totally unnecessary to have these animals used for "hunting" - they are beautiful and should be protected. There are proposals for alternatives to "open season" so please use them. 35452020-08-23T19:47:32.37745439Alice HarroldReintroduction of wildlife requires long term responsibility on behalf of the government, this can be an example to the rest of the UK on how to do it ethically and successfully. Please make the responsible decision for the cohabitants of the areas and the environment and relocate these animals!35452020-08-23T20:23:29.3545441James Harper Don't kill beavers - they are amazing creatures and have proved to have one of benefits in terms of reducing flooding.35452020-08-23T20:50:59.62345442Sandra Buttigieg We need these animals, please protect them rather than destroy them.35452020-08-23T21:35:31.3345443Caroline Anne SpinksBeaver are efficient tools in flood management & preventing land slips - use them to prevent the disaster that happened so recently!35452020-08-23T22:32:46.13345444Teresa MorenoStop all this killing.35452020-08-24T00:42:25.12345445Victory Ebuka AchinneStudent paramedics should receive same bursary because they have equal rights as other students in the health sector. 35782020-08-24T08:19:05.61745446Alan GilesCanadian conservationist "Grey Owl" writes eloquently about the use and importance of beavers in the landscape in his book "Men of the Last Frontier"35452020-08-24T13:54:43.0745448Vik CookePlease trans-locate the beavers asap. No living being should be murdered, but apparently they will be unless they are moved to a suitable and safe habitat35452020-08-24T14:36:18.68345450diane cameronThey should be left alone. Moving them would not solve the problem, we need them. Their dams prevent flooding they have a role to play.35452020-08-24T18:35:38.93745451Lisa LowI was saddened to read of these beavers being killed. Surely environmental groups and farmers can work together to provide a humane solution that we and our children can be proud of.35452020-08-24T18:52:02.5845452Kathy PenfoldSo disappointing that the Scottish Government routinely supports wildlife destruction. I really hoped for better, but I should have known better!\r\n35452020-08-24T20:17:59.2745453Adrian DavisReintroduce them to Argyll then limit their movements and repopulation to other parts of Scotland is short sighted. The government need a comprehensive plan and strategy in keeping with the vision of reintroduction. There are many people who want beavers in this country. 35452020-08-24T20:55:51.06345454Kate Rea More than ever we need our wild life so please stop killing them.35452020-08-24T22:29:17.63345455Fiona MacdonaldBeavers, as well as the illegal killing of birds of prey being allowed, too many housing developments in green spaces, utterly destructive developments of hydro systems is pristine Scottish habitat. Have we got to destroy everything before our so called politicians get it that we must protect it, not destroy it. Look at the Amazon rain forest? The lungs of the planet, almost totally ruined.35452020-08-24T22:42:08.40345456Janet stewartLet them live.35452020-08-24T22:53:31.41745457Ruby Hughes We reintroduced them so why do you want to cull them, they deserve the right to live their lives in natural surroundings. 35452020-08-25T00:07:05.07745459Colin DaviesKeep Beavers alive and well.35452020-08-25T08:52:17.01345460Michelle Kershaw-WrightHope your Scottish Beavers can help repopulate rivers in England, N Ireland and Wales.35452020-08-25T09:26:39.7845461Jim GemmellWhy introduce a beautiful creature to then kill it, move them to an area that would benefit from them.35452020-08-25T09:29:17.87745462Margaret Cowdrey We need beavers in the countryside.35452020-08-25T10:23:24.6245463maureen nicholIt is wrong to do this, catch them in cages not shoot them.35452020-08-25T10:33:16.68345464Catherine GrayLosing someone who has been close to you can have a profound and long lasting effect on anyone. A significant loss for a child or young person at school can be life threatening. I believe the topic of death and loss merits some attention throughout the education of every child.35832020-08-25T10:43:32.10745465Tracy PeetBecause we can do better than this.35452020-08-25T10:53:01.87345467Angelina SourenSigh. I can't believe that I have to sign a petition like this, and pertaining to Scotland! 35452020-08-25T10:57:48.07745468James PickardBeavers have only recently been re-introduced and need all of our help to re-establish themselves. They are crucial to building up natural flood defenses, storing carbon, and reinvigorated severely depleted landscapes devastated by drainage, canalisation, and over-grazing by deer and livestock. A humane relocation scheme is key to enabling them to thrive. 35452020-08-25T11:35:43.59345470Teresa KnoxScotland could be a leader in wildlife tourism instead of allowing killing of all that moves.35452020-08-25T11:57:13.14345471Aileen BirdPlease show compassion regarding nature and wildlife. Remember land owners want what's best for them! 35452020-08-25T12:21:12.24345473Marjan van elslandBeavers are part of your country and important for the balance in nature. They should be encouraged, not hunted!35452020-08-25T12:25:38.91345474Keith BarnsleyThis is just WRONG. 35452020-08-25T12:51:41.9845475Thomas SpencerBeavers are a central tenet of biodiversity.35452020-08-25T13:02:23.48345476Kevin LeedhamWildlife is an asset, not an inconvenience.35452020-08-25T13:12:40.9745477Kim Wilcocks Please stop killing creatures simply because they inconvenience you. Animals have a right to exist and they do so for a reason. We are all part of a food chain.35452020-08-25T13:18:15.96745478Tahoe LeighA cull is NEVER the answer & indeed can make things even worse!35452020-08-25T13:41:42.2545481Ann Adamson Eadie My understanding is that Beavers have a positive impact on the environment, so purely from this point of view, why would you kill them? If they have to be moved, then so be it, there are alternatives to death. 35452020-08-25T13:43:12.20345483Roselyn TwellWe fought to get them here we made them Scottish. So we should fight to keep them here.35452020-08-25T13:47:51.03345484Jamie sextonMore needs to be done to protect our wildlife.35452020-08-25T13:50:58.1645485Ian DaniellsI am signing this as a keen visitor to Scotland to see all forms of wildlife. One of the best times was watching beavers so why kill them when they do so much to improve the environment. Culling is not the answer, relocation is. 35452020-08-25T13:56:17.2745487Jacqueline ChartersIt's disgusting that these animals have been introduced with Mickey Mouse protection. If the Government were truly wanting to protect them they would allow them to be relocated. They can't relocate naturally as they are being killed before they get a chance.\r\n35452020-08-25T14:09:20.24345488Robert hendersonSave the beavers.35452020-08-25T14:11:35.56745489Sean AshleyThe wildlife in Scotland is being decimated, many plants and animals are on the endangered list, yet we are a first world country. Our relationship with nature must become a top priority.35452020-08-25T14:13:06.56745490Derek SimpsonWe have 5 dogs and some are rescues. We did not take them on lightly. We are responsible for their health, happiness and wellbeing. If you the Scottish Government agree then you the reintroduction if Beavers. Then you are ultimately responsible for them. So do not kill them because it is the easy option. Catch them and move if you have.35452020-08-25T14:44:48.0545491Stephen JohnPlease take the humane option. Choose life and translocation, not murder. 35452020-08-25T14:51:15.1545493Peter DaviesScotland has shown the way re. introductions and generally improving the land for wildlife In recent years with brave decisions and plenty of foresight, whilst the rest of the UK has been slow to tackle the same issues. Please don't lose your nerve now and take a backward step. 35452020-08-25T14:53:30.3745494Tommy Junor A magical creature that will absolutely enhance the biodiversity and natural aesthetics of a more greener, wilder Scotland for generations to cherish in the future. Please take heid and look after our new Scottish beavers. 35452020-08-25T14:54:11.1545495Maja pepper Unacceptable! I work for a Scottish organisation carrying out river erosion control and flooding and riparian and instream habitat, spending thousands of pounds doing the job that beavers are doing. Also, Scotland Declared climate emergency and killing beavers, which are a keystone species, increases several problems related to the changing climate . 35452020-08-25T14:59:19.40345496Tommy Mclelland Very good idea35872020-08-25T15:12:53.98345497Patricia HendersonBeavers don't harm the rivers or country side, so don't harm them please.35452020-08-25T15:13:56.245498Sandi CummingsAny killing of beavers is obscene, unnecessary and sickening. Let them live!35452020-08-25T15:14:52.75745499Markus HiemannI honestly cannot believe I'm having to sign this.35452020-08-25T15:32:31.19745500john d lambeEncourage wildlife.35452020-08-25T15:48:07.82345501Stefan Thomas-BacheStop killing the beavers!35452020-08-25T16:06:51.73345502Bob SmithI'm absolutely disgusted yet again at our so called progressive govt allowing "protected" species to be wantonly culled. I was under the impression that non-lethal mitigation would be looked at before more lethal methods were applied. This isn't happening and so the cull continues. I'm really losing faith in the current Scottish govt and their wishy-washy attitude to our wildlife. Raptor persecution is rife and isn't dealt with at all, now legal lethal licenses are supplied to a newly reintroduced species!!!! Can you not see the hypocrisy? Get a grip Scotgov before we lose more iconic species.35452020-08-25T16:10:25.6745503Jennie HewittBeavers will aid the ecosystem to recover. Let nature restore the balance. Beavers in the Cotswold water parks. The minor inconvenience they cause should not be a death sentence.35452020-08-25T16:11:47.59345504Liz HodgsonMoving them to where they are wanted seems like the obvious solution. Scotland's positive reputation elsewhere could only be enhanced that way.35452020-08-25T16:25:07.3545508Sue HennessyRelocate if you must, but we shouldn't be destroying an animal which has such a positive environmental impact. 35452020-08-25T16:26:40.3345509Richard JohnsonI thought I was living in the united kingdom well it doesn't seem that way, when Beavers are being killed in Scotland yet being introduced in England, is that not insane?35452020-08-25T16:26:58.51745510jeanette wardWhy kill them when it has been proven in Devon and Cornwall their use to the community and have been given permission to stay after being studied their advantage for five years.35452020-08-25T16:36:44.99345512Joan Lewis JonesBeavers are being reintroduced in a number of projects in England. Scotland started reintroduction in Argyll. Their numbers may need to be managed in the future but it seems quite wrong to exterminate them before we can judge their impact and effectiveness as habitat creators.35452020-08-25T16:37:53.9345513Mel AddisonKilling beavers is needless and senseless when there are several organisations that would be willing to move them to a more suitable location. This should be a criminal offence! 35452020-08-25T16:40:09.39345514Heather PenmanThis keystone species and ecosystem hero deserves our protection, not to be culled. 35452020-08-25T16:40:19.81745515Terry EatonThe lessons learnt from the beaver project in the South West of England show that beavers do a lot more good than harm from improvement of water management and creation of habitat that is not only good for them but a wide variety of other species both plant and animal.35452020-08-25T16:46:24.10345516Sue CoxTake them where they can live, thrive and contribute valuably to the wild environment.35452020-08-25T17:16:04.65345518Alan RossWhile other countries utilise the unique skills of beavers to mitigate the climate and ecological emergency we face, the Scottish Gov is shaming us with intolerance and ignorance. Killing beavers when their ecosystem services could save tax payers millions a year and reviving our degraded ecosystems. 35452020-08-25T17:26:27.42345519Brian ArnottPlease protect the Scottish beaver.35452020-08-25T17:26:33.45345520Victoria CurleyIt makes no sense not to translocate this species. Beavers can have huge posistive effects to biodiversity, the environment and tourism if moved to the right place. In the wrong place it is clearly detrimental and unfair on the animals and also does not suit the landowners. If we are to effectively conserve this now protected species and have it once again integrated into our landscape, we need to translocate them to more suitable areas (not just kill the few that are there). 35452020-08-25T17:26:40.46345521David E. ShellenbergerI support compassionate coexistence with beavers and rewilding the species.35452020-08-25T17:28:10.7245522Hazel HogganI am Scottish and ashamed of how my home country is treating wildlife 35452020-08-25T17:28:35.31345523Barry MerchantPlease save the Beaver35452020-08-25T17:36:40.3445524Kay Page I live in N.Cornwall and people are living with Beavers just over the border, very successfully. A family member lives in Ballachulish, Scotland and I feel they could thrive here too. I see so many similarities in our areas.35452020-08-25T17:44:12.86345525Helen WatermanPlease have some humanity. Listen to the scientific evidence about the positive benefits of beavers and please stop licensing their deaths.35452020-08-25T17:50:04.45745526Nanette FuellenkemperRe locating & re habitating can work for all.35452020-08-25T17:51:28.4145527Malcolm CalderThe way we treat wild animals in Scotland is a disgrace. Culling simply should not be allowed.35452020-08-25T17:53:41.24745528Nick Milsom Please find an alternative to this practice, we need to find ways to enhance biodiversity and return it to pre industrial levels. 35452020-08-25T17:55:01.39345529Janet Widdowsplease do not kill the beavers just like you would not kill a person, they are living breathing animals just like us and do more good for the world that we do 35452020-08-25T17:55:09.4545530Nick Milsom Please find an alternative to this practice, we need to find ways to enhance biodiversity and return it to pre industrial levels. 35452020-08-25T17:55:47.15345531Alison FreshwaterAfter introducing this wonderful animal back , why oh why then kill these lovely creatures!! What is stopping them from being just relocated? !!35452020-08-25T18:00:42.33345532johanna suttonThis is also a problem where I live. Mindless killing - a short term panic response like so many actions that are destroying the environment.35452020-08-25T18:01:23.4945533Eleanor KnightDisgraceful.how the Scottish Government doesnt care about.our wildlife !35452020-08-25T18:04:05.4145534Ottilie HunterI feel passionate about this as we also have a house near a river in Scotland and think beavers contribute so much to the wild environment. 35452020-08-25T18:12:08.92345535Avril EleyBeavers are amazing dam builders, who work for us for free, to mitigate flooding and soil erosion, both of which are sorely needed in our damaged world.35452020-08-25T18:12:30.97745536Claire GardnerLeave these creatures alone35452020-08-25T18:16:52.6845537Janet McPhersonKindness not cruelty.35452020-08-25T18:21:06.77345540Paul Brookes It's an absolute disgrace to be killing such amazing wonderful animals that could live perfectly happily in other places without any conflict with humans. What century are we living in?35452020-08-25T18:24:08.9645542Janet McPhersonKindness not cruelty35452020-08-25T18:55:39.49745544Dawn RobinsonI have travelled specially to see Scottish beavers in the past. Fabulous animals in their own right, they also improve biodiversity and they are a real tourist attraction.Why do landowners always have the final say on these matters? They are a tiny fraction of the population, and cause so much current habitat and wildlife destruction. 35452020-08-25T19:00:21.9545545Garry WilliamsBeavers need protection as well as birds of prey.\r\nWildlife enhances the country of Scotland35452020-08-25T19:01:51.68745546Jemma KerrHaving just seen a photo of a beaver shot on day two of hunting season I am appalled that this government cannot do better to protect these animals. Beavers are crucial to our ecosystems and provide flood protection. Help them and they will help us. Also, find the people who shot them and take away their guns and licences. 35452020-08-25T19:03:39.33745548Katy HardiePlease stop this madnesd35452020-08-25T19:32:37.73745550Jane DurkinBeevers create ecosystems, they are a flood defence. They create tourism. Leave them alone. 35452020-08-25T19:39:48.84745551Alison CuthbertBeavers are so beneficial to the environment prevent flooding. Please stop the killing.35452020-08-25T19:39:59.5245552Carmela De Luca BossaPlease please stop this needless killing, these animals do a fantastic job controlling riverways to the benefit of the environment and all other wildlife therein.35452020-08-25T19:49:34.18745553Amanda BarrettDon't pander to the minority of farmers. Go for the bigger picture, embrace the world and protect beavers35452020-08-25T19:52:23.5545554Lorna DevenishRelocation not slaughter35452020-08-25T19:53:28.8145555Dawn VallanceI am uncomfortable with the concept of killing wildlife in this way35452020-08-25T19:56:19.28745557Margaret JohnstonBeavers should not be killed,how can the Scottish Government allow this to happen. 35452020-08-25T19:56:20.90345558Marianne ReiterI struggle to comprehend that anyone would not be delighted about the return of these amazing animals35452020-08-25T20:20:44.03345559Valerie ShuffThere is no need to kill the beavers. They have as much right as us to be here. All to do with money and greed. Leave them alone!! 35452020-08-25T20:36:26.63745560Claire HamlettLots of places could benefit from beavers, translocation is obviously a better answer than killing.35452020-08-25T20:36:56.2745561Ruth OBrienIt is a disgrace reintroducing animals just to slaughter them again35452020-08-25T20:42:08.53745562Trevor MephamI don't understand. Killing beavers is not a great policy.35452020-08-25T20:51:43.78745564Mary McGee WoodEnvironmental benefits now proven in England35452020-08-25T20:59:25.14745565Jo LeightonI thought we had a progressive government who valued our wildlife and bio diversity. Conservation not killing.35452020-08-25T21:04:59.3145566Nikki RobinsonBeavers bring so many ecological benefits. Disgusting to see a supposedly protected species treated in this manner35452020-08-25T21:10:30.8945567Valerie ClarkThese animals have not long been reintroduced, it's shameful that they are not being relocated.but are culled instead. The Scottish government keep saying they want to be progressive, this would be a good way of proofing that. Protect the wonderful wildlife of Scotland35452020-08-25T21:15:01.51745568Shelley Ward There is NO need to kill the beavers. They are part of our ecosystem and should be respected, relocate them instead 35452020-08-25T21:32:06.4445570Sylvia MussonIt's better to relocate these beavers where they will help with flood management rather than to kill them35452020-08-25T21:39:40.39345571Elizabeth Crawfordan animal we have reintroduced into our environment is now being culled because we obviously have not done this properly35452020-08-25T21:49:18.50345572Lynne Mckissock These creatures are beneficial to our environment and should be relocated appropriately not killed if their impact is not beneficial to a particular area.35452020-08-25T21:51:12.3845573Suzy AustinWe have Beavers on the River Otter In Devon, just up the road from me. I think they are a wonderful addition to our countryside.35452020-08-25T22:10:35.98745575Art SangsterThese animals are biodiversity engineers and so beneficial to the environment!35452020-08-25T22:18:11.99345576George McCowanScottish Government should get behind this petition, instead of supporting the cull.35452020-08-25T22:26:39.21345579Sam HarrisThis is disgusting beavers are fascinating wonderful and vital creatures to the ecosystem 35452020-08-25T22:35:41.0145580Angela J Rowlands These beautiful creatures deserve to be alive, treasured and protected. No humans have the right to eradicate any species. Not Ok35452020-08-25T23:06:33.40745583Alan m frostThe Beaver is a protected rare species. It's protected by law. So please tell me why are you letting Blood thirsty Trophy hunters to kill Beavers for. Why can't you catch them and relocate them, somewhere in the UK. Who will benefit, having Beavers in the wild. To help stop flooding, and bringing back Fauna & Flora. 35452020-08-25T23:12:25.28345584Lisa Marie BrennanThe way we have exploited the beaver should make us ashamed. Hunted to extinction by humans in UK, reintroduced by humans to alleviate flooding, Farmers unhappy so we murder the beautiful beaver. Instead of choosing death as the easy option more planning and discussions need to ensue as to a peaceful resolution for humans and beavers to live alongside each other.35452020-08-25T23:17:26.8945585Carole Lockhart Stuart, Please allow are, do not cull them. Scotland should be oround to have our beavers here. 35452020-08-25T23:20:35.34745588Tony Orford Kindness is an approach to all life and as individuals or persons in position of power being selectively kind in not kindness. Some time kindness involves being inconvenienced to do what is Right, it is not what is in it for me, votes, money or self efficacy. It takes compassions, emotional maturity and being responsible to be kind, and it is a very simple choice be kind or not.35452020-08-25T23:21:06.53345589Francis Leslie BatesFull protection or a workable compensation scheme should be employed to give the Beavers in Scotland proper protection.\r\n35452020-08-25T23:23:30.5545590Susie DoddWhy introduce a species that exists to play a valuable role in the ecosystem only to kill them? This action is immoral and unnecessary. It makes no sense. Please save these animals and translocate them instead.35452020-08-25T23:47:10.19345591Trevor HeapThis is even worse than the badger cull south if the border. Unjustified killing of animals. 35452020-08-26T00:13:37.63345592Gerry BradleyBeavers are part of Scotland's natural heritage and should be protected for all to enjoy in celebration of our magnificent biodiversity!35452020-08-26T00:42:36.93745593Samantha TweddlePlease stop this hideous cruelty.35452020-08-26T04:47:51.09345594Debbie Fisher Stop killing our animals relocate 35452020-08-26T06:12:55.77345595Christopher DugganThis is not the way to treat any sentient species. Human beings take the kill option far too easily, and we only demean ourselves when we do. Please relocate them instead. They are an asset for Scotland in so many ways.35452020-08-26T06:55:48.44345596Margaret Sloan Please relocate the Beavers they are amazing animals and do help against flooding.35452020-08-26T07:28:48.03345597Angie NeilsonI'm horrified that this can be happening. Please do everything possible to stop it. We visit Scotland for its wildlife and scenery please don't ruin it.35452020-08-26T08:33:55.5645598Jules ChabeauxHumanity is not in charge of nature. We are merely a part of it. A part that sadly, has strayed so far from the natural laws that govern balance and health that we are literally destroying all life around us. When we remember this and step back and up to remember the true laws of nature, and act accordingly to these laws instead of manmade laws of greed and power over all else, then we will start to allow nature in all of her awesome power to repair the damage we have caused. The whole biosphere needs to repair, we can not play God and decide who to "bring in" and who to "wipe out" that is not our role and there are serious consequences for this mistaken thinking. Look around the world, see what we are doing and rethink our part in it. We must cease our insane thinking and respect and honour nature and give her the opportunity to heal herself before we wipe ourselves and most other life off this beautiful planet.35452020-08-26T08:37:48.1745599Janine Smith Do wild animals not deserve to be protected before they go extinct!!!35452020-08-26T08:43:40.11345601Julie Bell I'm appalled by the indiscriminate killing of these beautiful animals. We need to live and work in harmony with the environment and its wildlife, and manage issues like flooding in much more holistic ways. 35452020-08-26T08:43:56.92745602Susan Bullochplease relocate these wonderful animals, they should be protected. 35452020-08-26T08:55:29.73345604anita kingThese are protected animals and they are a natural way of mitigating the increased rainfall and creating ponds.35452020-08-26T09:02:14.66345605Amanda Wanstall - Rileyplease stop this senseless act of killing protected animals find those responsible and give custodial sentences and heavy fines.35452020-08-26T09:03:41.2545606Ruby Hughes Why reintroduce them then when they breed as was the plan they shoot them? Who gives them the right to decide what lives and what dies?35452020-08-26T09:09:11.80345607Sally Elborough Beavers are needed and can do an amazing job...ie flooding control, which is a major concern, considering the climate and the change in weather to come. 35452020-08-26T09:10:34.2145608Helen seniorSlaughter for unproven and unevidenced myths. Please can his barbarism end. The earth is more important for your future. You have no choice but to accept that life cannot stay as it is. We must allow nature to heal an ancient natural habitats for animals return. 35452020-08-26T09:14:55.2945610Joan Thomas Relocation can prove to be better for the new environment as well as for farmers in the existing habitat. 35452020-08-26T09:16:26.62745611audrey wheeler why,after all the effort to reintroduce these lovely animals who could prevent flooding35452020-08-26T09:17:27.2245612Stuart Heath I am appalled that we reintroduced a species that was once native to this country and then people think they have a given right to destroy them for whatever reason its absolutely disgusting and needs strong sentences for anyone proven to be doing so. 35452020-08-26T09:23:12.08745613Karen ShanklandPlease, please protect these incredible animals & forbid killing them. We introduced them back to the wild, we must respect and care for them.35452020-08-26T09:28:15.1345614Sandra Sneddon HaymanBeavers are being re-introduced in England as their beneficial habits for the environment have been recognised. Please investigate your finding further & stop killing Beavers.35452020-08-26T09:31:53.63345615Lucille conwayWe have got to stop All hunting of animals, it is not for us to decide which animals live or die. Also stop these people from fox hunting under the pretence of scent hunting. It's a wicked and dispicable act, even though people doing it are rich we should stand as a nation to stop this barbaric sport. No one is above the law. Let Scotland lead the way and say no more. 35452020-08-26T09:35:45.13745616Anne NelsonCaring societies do not blast our wildlife to death! Such cruelty is unacceptable This is not a Scotland I can be proud to belong to35452020-08-26T09:36:16.445617Sharon bakerWildlife is precious, wish all was left alone35452020-08-26T09:36:34.91745618Susan AshfordPlease relocate these animals. They can do so much good in helping prevent flooding35452020-08-26T09:37:25.845619Christina Ledger We have fought for these creatures to be reintroduced. We should be protecting them! 35452020-08-26T09:44:37.64745620Sarah coulsonIf Africa can move huge beasts to save from slaughter, surely you can move these beautiful creatures to England where we would cherish them!35452020-08-26T09:52:57.54345622Peter MintingThe licensing of shooting beavers should stop.35452020-08-26T09:55:24.33745623Nicole Gabriel I am devestated by the lack of 'clout' that the law had on dealing with wildlife crime, and the lack of respect we are showing the natural world. When you add up all of the anti-wildlife actions across the UK, it is sickening : the impact of grouse shooting on hen harrier, other raptor and mountain hare populations: the mass gassing of badgers: the illegal killing of beavers and other trapped wildlife that goes unprosecuted - how can our governments, how can the Scottish government allow this to continue? 35452020-08-26T09:55:52.72745624Marilyn Parkinson This is absolutely appalling behaviour and must be stopped. 35452020-08-26T10:00:49.43745625Felicity JonesI don't live in Scotland but have always admired your attitude to wildlife. 35452020-08-26T10:05:17.6445626Jan CooperThis is disgusting. When will farmers and hunters get the message? Beavers especially introduced and protected? It HAS to stop.35452020-08-26T10:11:45.79745627Jonathan SteadOur species is a lost cause if we carry on like this. 35452020-08-26T10:12:33.26745628Debbie ChaseHumans killing poor innocent animals again shame on you35452020-08-26T10:13:11.71345630julie hayesthere is no need to be killing them, show some compassion \r\n35452020-08-26T10:15:06.15745631Tracy StorrierDisgrace that they can do that to such a beautiful animal 35452020-08-26T10:16:54.68345632Judy DowlingPlease stop this needless slaughter. It has been proven that beavers are good for the countryside and for wildlife. 35452020-08-26T10:17:48.545633Susan RossLeave the wildlife alone! They cause way less destruction than us and deserve to be here more than we do!35452020-08-26T10:18:27.42345634Jane PerryShame on this slaughter. 35452020-08-26T10:20:03.27745635Yvonne Corbett I am horrified at the senseless murdering of these beautiful creatures which are essential to our eco systems, those responsible should be ashamed and feel the full force of the law. 35452020-08-26T10:22:29.1145636Judith Mary TiritasThese beautiful creatures have as much right to exist in the wild as any other animal. I am so disappointed that some farmers are behaving so badly. 35452020-08-26T10:23:42.77745637jill halpinThey can promote good housekeeping in the countryside. Presumably person who shot this beautiful hardworking creature had no understanding of their place with us!?35452020-08-26T10:23:49.37745638Elizabeth RichmondShooting defenceless animals is barbaric! 35452020-08-26T10:25:03.81345639Elizabeth GrimleyI am horrified that beavers may be killed in Scotland35452020-08-26T10:25:09.1145640Susan BusbyWildlife doesn't stand a chance. If there are alternative safer methods of control take them. You are upsetting the balance of nature.35452020-08-26T10:33:37.24745642Martin ThomasThere are many people qualified and willing to translocations beavers if absolutely necessary and plenty of landowners with suitable habitat who would happily give the animals a home. 35452020-08-26T10:34:18.04345643Jennifer HaywoodAbsolutely disgusted. Compassion and tolerance to all forms of life is not too much expect.35452020-08-26T10:35:44.1645644Roger ReevesPlease allow a tiny amount of space so these fine animals can live in peace35452020-08-26T10:39:54.72345645Jonathan WallaceShooting should not be the automatic response to beavers that are causing a problem. If local mitigation is not possible please translocate to other catchments to help the spread of this ecologically beneficial species.35452020-08-26T10:45:46.11345646alyson Mcleod This should stop immediately. Relocate but not KILL35452020-08-26T10:50:11.54745647STEVEN CHARLTONConsidering the fact we are in the middle of what has been referred to as the Next Global Mass Extinction (caused by human activity), It's about time we did somethingto prevent this from happening in our little bit of this Planet!!! The sooner something is done to STOP this, THE BETTER!!!35452020-08-26T10:52:44.78745648Mary WrightBeavers need protection, not elimination. They are very able at dealing with flood defence, please stop this killing. There must be places in Scotland that need beavers to stop flooding, if not they could be relocated to places in the UK where people regularly suffer flooding which disrupts their lives and destroys their homes.35452020-08-26T10:53:30.87745649Karen NokeI am appalled this is happening and something must be actioned immediately. 35452020-08-26T10:57:5445651Sarah HowesFarmers are meant to be the custodians of wildlife. It is possible to farm without resorting to illegal mutilation of nature. I live in a farming community & had farmers in the family. A few rotten apples need tougher sanctions clearly.35452020-08-26T10:59:07.42745652Marjorie MclayCome on Scot Gov. I know things are difficult right now, but it's time to put the vested interests, into their boxes. Wildlife on Grouse moors, Mountain Hares now Beavers, who or what is next?35452020-08-26T11:01:49.27345653Joanna WhitePlease stop this needless slaughter.35452020-08-26T11:02:50.7145654Joseph MoretonHistorically, this animal has as much right to live here as we do. Why not allow a more naturally diverse environment to live alongside?35452020-08-26T11:03:34.3945655Chris Thorpe As a recently re-introduced species back into Scotland, I find it astonishing that they are being persecuted. Please sort this problem out and start prosecuting the perpetrators with heavy fines and jail sentences for the persistent offenders. With this and the shame of the behaviour of gamekeepers protecting the grouse moors, killing everything in sight, please start dealing with these gamekeepers. 35452020-08-26T11:05:14.20345656Patrice Brown This is totally disgusting how these beautiful animals are being treated. Scottish Government needs to sort this NOW!35452020-08-26T11:06:22.27345657Stuart ChambersLet nature THRIVE. It's really not complicated.35452020-08-26T11:09:15.61745658Paul BoldrinIf you rewild then there should be a plan to relocate animals to other parts rather than shooting them!35452020-08-26T11:14:38.9345659Julie Dinmore Unacceptable!35452020-08-26T11:15:56.4445660Susan WilsonIt is disgraceful that reintroduced, protected animals are being shot by farmers. Move them to keep them safe. 35452020-08-26T11:16:43.39345662Rosie BlissI support beavers as wildlife creatures, no one has any right to kill or injure them, animal lives matter too.35452020-08-26T11:17:01.86745663Lesley WalkerRemoval and resisting of Beavers must be implemented rather than killing them. 35452020-08-26T11:19:06.45745664Adrian Lloyd JonesKilling beavers is almost always unnecessary as there are many ways to deal with their activities. We also need them imminently for our reintroduction plans in Wales so there is currently no reasonable excuse for killing beavers.35452020-08-26T11:19:54.63345665Valerie PageExiled in England but heart in Scotland. Let's show we are civilised people. A country can be judged by its treatment of its animals.\r\n35452020-08-26T11:22:33.9145666Finlay McGuireRefrain from doing harm to any other living thing. 35452020-08-26T11:37:20.52745668Annie WoolstonI support the introduction of beavers. I oppose the control of them by culling. I would prefer to see them being allowed to establish their own communities naturally, over time.35452020-08-26T11:40:43.82345669Lynsey SummersPlease relocate not kill these amazing animals. They are good for our wild water meadows and environment. We need to co-exist for our benefit as much as theirs. Rewilding is more important than ever. Stop killing our natural wilders!! 35452020-08-26T11:45:58.9845670Heather LiddellLive and let live.35452020-08-26T11:48:26.0745671brian mcardleDisgraceful act, time Scotland had far reaching Land reforms 35452020-08-26T11:48:43.35745672Robyn Baxter This is disgraceful. Please stop killing our wildlife. Beavers need homes too and are doing a great job keeping our rivers clean and healthy. Stop this!35452020-08-26T11:51:37.4545673Jean D CowleyWhy are some people so against wildlife?\r\nI thought farmers were keen to protect wildlife.35452020-08-26T11:55:06.5645674Janie Meikle BlandScotland has the opportunity to lead the way, establishing their reputation for rewinding and building sustainable ecosystems for all species. There are locations across Scotland where relocated beavers would be welcomed.35452020-08-26T11:56:04.9245675Graham WaltersIn 2020 why are people still killing wild animals?35452020-08-26T12:01:15.10745676Hazel GrantWhy reintroduce just to shoot them! Relocation is key!35452020-08-26T12:06:07.04745677Janet Mardell This is an outrageous wildlife crime which should be dealt with very harshly. These animals have been persecuted in the past and have only just started to recover so shooting them is criminal.35452020-08-26T12:17:59.0145678Alison FreshwaterAfter finally reintroducing these lovely creatures, what is the mentality behind killing rather than relocation?\r\nLikewise poor badgers still being culled rather than vaccination is shameful.35452020-08-26T12:19:05.06345679Paul LawrenceAlthough I live in Northumberland I visit Scotland 5 or 6 times a year to watch wildlife - spending money.35452020-08-26T12:20:20.77745680Catherine MurohyYou need to protect wildlife not destroy it. If you have no choice then why can't you relocate them.35452020-08-26T12:22:35.15345682Glenda HallaronApart from relocating these animals you need to make it illegal to harm them.35452020-08-26T12:23:52.95745683Jane MuirheadThis has got to be made illegal. Any Government that increases animal abusing as a prison sentence I will support.35452020-08-26T12:28:31.35745686Patricia PowetThe benefits that beavers bring to the countryside, which include helping to prevent flooding, was featured on a Scottish TV programme a few weeks ago and now the beavers are being shot. This does not make sense. We need to protect them. 35452020-08-26T12:30:18.51345687Alison FreshwaterAfter finally reintroducing these lovely creatures, what is the mentality behind killing, rather than relocating! Also shameful is the ongoing culling of badgers that were supposed to be saved by vaccination alternative!35452020-08-26T12:31:21.70345688David Racster Shame on Scotland.35452020-08-26T12:40:34.7445689Adrian Pope It's damaging the image of Scotland.35452020-08-26T12:42:23.86345690Natalie McQuade Stop killing Beavers.35452020-08-26T12:47:59.48345692isabella ChapmanThis is horrendous behaviour! This farmer should be imprisoned! I'm a Scot living in England but was delighted that these animals were reintroduced into the environment again.35452020-08-26T12:51:36.67745693Rosalynda PearsonRelocate immediately before more beavers are killed, and while your at it stop the illegal slaughter of birds of prey.35452020-08-26T12:58:23.73745696Michelle Gallagher What is the point of reintroducing species if farmers are allowed to kill them its crazy.35452020-08-26T12:59:34.3645697Laura TomlinsonWhy is this allowed to happen to an amazing reintroduced species? Please relocate them.35452020-08-26T13:00:04.4645698Kate JayneThank you Trees for Life you are a good organisation doing a great job.35452020-08-26T13:04:19.8645699Tom ByarsWe need an environmental minister that has a modicum of empathy for our wildlife ASAP.35452020-08-26T13:16:39.55745702Claire OswaldWe must do all we can to protect beavers and other animals from human beings. We owe it to them.35452020-08-26T13:26:24.6645704Paul Crampton I cannot believe this could happen after so much work has been done to reintroduce these fabulous creatures. More resources are needed even in these difficult times to tackle this needless action. 35452020-08-26T13:30:32.63745705Jill WoottonIt has been proven that areas where beavers have been introduced help stop flooding down stream. Please look at the facts, the farmers who shoot them should be in court.35452020-08-26T13:32:23.32345706Jan ColePlease stop this killing of a protected species. Beavers manage the environment much more effectively than humans. 35452020-08-26T13:35:00.8445707Heather PeacockWhat is the point in reintroducing these animals for farmers to shoot them. Disgraceful.35452020-08-26T13:36:46.64745708Julie Spillman Attention is needed to please help Beavers.35452020-08-26T13:39:12.90345709Wendi SchofieldThis killing is illegal and has to stop, with heavy penalties for the guilty.35452020-08-26T13:40:00.62345710Lorraine MartinI'm English, however, wildlife such as beavers need protecting before it's too late.35452020-08-26T13:45:17.19745711Glenys TaylorDevastated this is starting again. So many young Beavers allocated to areas to breed and this is happening all over again.\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\nSent from my iPhone\r\n35452020-08-26T14:03:51.8645712Lisa GrovesThis is such a poor example of how to manage wildlife in a compassionate and sustainable way - there is a better alternative. Relocating to where they can benefit the environment.35452020-08-26T14:08:25.65745713George MurdochThe current law offers no protection at all unless mechanisms are put in place and effectively enforced. As it is nothing has changed. How this is resolved will affect how i vote. 35452020-08-26T14:15:13.12745715Kathleen HarrisonGod forbid the day will ever come when this species is no longer here and please when the time comes come with a better word than cull they were not born to die like this we are the higher species or not depends how you look at there are other ways and not killing all the time.35452020-08-26T14:18:36.1745716Sandra Hornblow This is a despicable act.35452020-08-26T14:19:40.06345717Sarah Broadway What gives us as humans the right to kill any life on this planet. We should be protecting our wildlife. They live on this planet too. The arrogance of the human race make me sad and very angry.35452020-08-26T14:30:58.85745721Pamela McMillanLeave our wildlife alone. Go and kill something that has no value to the world, like capitalism. 35452020-08-26T14:34:59.39345723Phyllis MullaneyI am Scottish, I love my homeland, but why on earth re-introduce a species and then shoot them??\r\n35452020-08-26T14:35:07.28745724Lynder Pocock Amazing animal that needs as much protection as possible.35452020-08-26T14:36:57.28745725Lynne TateWe have to stop doing this. Introducing species that should have been here then culling them. The human species is everywhere should we kill humans? Farmers have to allow our indigenous species more land and too many of a certain species should be moved to another area - not killed!35452020-08-26T14:38:40.86345726Audrie CabenaAshamed this is on my doorstep.35452020-08-26T14:43:47.98345728Sandra von Esebeck Why on earth is it acceptable to destroy every piece of nature?35452020-08-26T14:49:09.2245729Ken ForresterIt's shocking that the Scottish Govt can have allowed such extensive culling of a newly-protected species.35452020-08-26T14:52:54.65745730Richard Murgatroyd We saw live Beavers at Knapdale Argyll & Bute and find it shocking that Beavers are being shot in Scotland.35452020-08-26T15:06:17.81745731Elizabeth FrenchI never realised that Beavers could be killed, so cruel and unnecessary.35452020-08-26T15:14:19.58745732Gary BlackThere is no science to excuse the needless destruction of wildlife.35452020-08-26T15:16:38.81745733Christine LeesBeavers improve the wildlife habitat for many other creatures and help human beings to avoid flooding. As a UK citizen I am appalled that they are being killed in Scotland.\r\n35452020-08-26T15:19:49.94345735Mick Baron.When will these people give our wildlife a chance.35452020-08-26T15:20:01.1545736mark raffertyLethal control should only be a last resort. Scotland has lots of suitable habitat and landowners wanting beavers.35452020-08-26T15:20:56.16345738Gerry GallagherI am Scottish living in Ireland. Both Counties have a poor record of looking after it's wildlife. This shooting deserves a jail sentence, totally barbaric and inexcusable!35452020-08-26T15:22:50.83345739Rose WithersPlease stop this needless and cruel practice.35452020-08-26T15:25:48.18345740Simone WhittleI can't quite believe how much the killing of innocent wildlife is enjoyed in Scotland. Shameful.35452020-08-26T15:34:45.4245741Irene Aitcheson Please could someone explain the sense in re-introducing a creature back into an area and when they are living successfully, is it sensible or correct to then slaughter the beavers?35452020-08-26T15:37:33.37345742Rosalind SYKESIgnorance needs education. Old ingrained ignorance is worst of all.35452020-08-26T15:44:47.5445743Alison HermistonThere needs to be lots more information on the good the beavers do and how they help other native species and their habitats. People think they just bring trees down and build dams. People also think they eat the fish in the rivers. There needs to be more education.35452020-08-26T16:02:03.35745744Carolline MasonWe must - absolutely must - learn to live at peace with all the non humans we share this land with. We will not survive unless we do. But not only that, our non-human cousins have as much right to existence as we do.35452020-08-26T16:04:45.46345745Anne Hanton The Scottish parliament needs to get tougher with animal welfare and abuse, right now I am ashamed to admit I am Scottish.35452020-08-26T16:14:27.38345746Debra Evans This is wrong. We need to protect our wildlife and try to live side by side with each other. We need to set a good example to our children. 35452020-08-26T16:16:12.73345748Valerie TomkinsonLive and Let Live. All Creatures are on this Earth for a purpose. It"s about time many considered this fact.35452020-08-26T16:17:22.37345749Anne Nagle For goodness have we not learned to treasure and protect our natural world.35452020-08-26T16:19:53.83745750Rose LaniganBeavers bring significant positive impacts to the environment and it is short sighted of farmers to shoot these animals. Please protect these animals.35452020-08-26T16:37:00.68345751Heather Robertson These animals were in Scotland long before humans. They have legal protection. I call for jail for those who hurt the beavers!35452020-08-26T16:40:01.5945752Susan Reynolds Shocking kill of a wonderful Beaver. On top of all the Raptor murders this year. SNP broken promises to protect wildlife. You must act now to stop this slaughter. 35452020-08-26T16:43:31.8345753MRS MARGARET CLARKIf they are protected how dare these farmers think it's their right to kill them.35452020-08-26T16:46:38.7345754Donna Brackley Why are we so intent on harming our wildlife.35452020-08-26T16:50:08.7245755Ken EbsworthyAgain and again farmers and landowners brutalise wildlife in the name of greed and profit. Don't you get it? People have had enough. 35452020-08-26T16:56:30.4545756Helena CarlI want this brutality stopped.35452020-08-26T16:59:13.08345757Lise OlsenOur government has a responsibility to protect and care for wildlife.35452020-08-26T17:01:22.03745758Pat ChorleyUnacceptable.35452020-08-26T17:07:04.20345759Andy PatonMove don't kill and expand the range for Beavers to live in Scotland as identified as suitable by Scottish Natural Heritage.35452020-08-26T17:08:02.26745760Gillian McNallyWhen will humans stop killing innocent animals! What is wrong with these people? 35452020-08-26T17:08:28.21745761Stan SheehanIrrespective wherever this happens in the UK it is disgraceful, these animals help the Countryside.35452020-08-26T17:09:26.06745762Marlene GotchEvery living creature has as much right to live in this world as humans. 35452020-08-26T17:14:05.03745763Loraine Sandford Please stop. Its cruel. Every thing is about money.35452020-08-26T17:14:11.50745764June CleggAn example of man bullying nature - not on.\r\n35452020-08-26T17:15:19.45345766Nancy NelsonDisgusted that these lovely creatures are being killed.35452020-08-26T17:16:34.3945767Pamela thompsonThis is wrong in every way.35452020-08-26T17:21:37.91345768Warren NichollsNo reason to kill them so don't.35452020-08-26T17:28:43.08745769Michele Dumbrowsky An American citizen who cares. 35452020-08-26T17:33:06.7245770Christine DochertyThe beaver can only improve the land and biodiversity in the long term, time for people to start looking at the bigger picture.35452020-08-26T17:34:37.20745771Marcia JonesThe relentless and systematic killing of wildlife, protected or not needs to stop. If necessary tougher legislation re gun ownership and use to stop criminal activity. 35452020-08-26T17:35:10.80745772Angi dodd Men again!! Poor creature. People have worked so hard to bring them back.35452020-08-26T17:37:07.36345773Andy PatonMove don't kill and hugely expand the range of Scotland for Beavers to live in safely as identified by Scottish Natural Heritage.35452020-08-26T17:38:01.6645774Mrs Joy SavilleAs a British citizen, I was delighted to hear about the rewilding. But now I'm appalled at what is happening. 35452020-08-26T17:39:15.1845775Joyce LothianAll animals have a right to live!35452020-08-26T17:40:12.0545776Dawn JonesThese animals are rare and beautiful. They were here first. Leave them alone.35452020-08-26T17:44:44.5445777Keith TurnecliffIt is a disgrace to allow this to happen.35452020-08-26T17:47:17.56745778Linda Thomson I believe the beavers should be for relocated kindly to an area that would benefit.35452020-08-26T17:53:03.78745779Steve MontgomeryBeavers are crucial for many areas of our country.35452020-08-26T17:59:15.25745780Lorraine CzajaAnother protected species being persecuted. Shame on humans.35452020-08-26T18:00:53.99745781David SpiersCould you please stop allowing everything to be killed in this what was once a beautiful country.35452020-08-26T18:02:33.49745782Lorraine RossStop the endless killing of our wildlife. 35452020-08-26T18:04:40.80345783DEE GOWERIf there is a law protecting these animals why and how can farmers kill and get away with it. Someone needs to be accountable for this and soon. 35452020-08-26T18:06:01.9645784Katrina MacFarlane Shocking if protected leave them alone.35452020-08-26T18:09:49.6745785Alex BalfourI am disgusted the way farmers and estate owners treat our wildlife. I would hope a spell in prison may stop the culprits from this disgusting behaviour.35452020-08-26T18:11:37.49345786Lesley FlintBring back as many species as possible.35452020-08-26T18:28:22.7245788Victoria Kragiel Please protect these animals.35452020-08-26T18:28:41.82745789Wendy IgnatiukVery unfair!!35782020-08-26T18:35:53.98745790Brenda UreyAnimals deserve freedom. 35452020-08-26T18:41:24.92345791Marion Oakley Wildlife was there before the farmers. 35452020-08-26T18:45:18.90345792Luise RyanSo sad that humans think they have the right to kill anything that inconveniences them. What is the matter with this world?35452020-08-26T18:46:12.62345793Kelly osullivan Wow they have only been back in the wild for such a short time and again humans killing wildlife, disgusting.35452020-08-26T18:49:29.14345794Caron Henderson This is a wildlife crime and as such should be investigated and those guilty prosecuted. 35452020-08-26T18:50:13.09745797Wendy McHughSo sad this goes on anywhere! 35452020-08-26T18:54:21.7745799Deborah haydenThey were on the land before human being they have as much right to be here and not be killed. 35452020-08-26T19:08:16.43745800Penelope Ebsary Humans worst species on the planet.35452020-08-26T19:12:17.06345801Jane McDowallThere is enough killing without killing innocent animals the world is for all.35452020-08-26T19:23:53.2145802James H A GrayDisgusting.35452020-08-26T19:24:02.00745803Dan BrownWe have a moral and ethical obligation to protect UK beavers and non-lethal alternatives should always be the first consideration. Scotland should be championing its wildlife not persecuting it. 35452020-08-26T19:27:12.0745804jill woodWildlife needs protecting we have already lost too much!35452020-08-26T19:27:57.7145805Milana Conroy Disgusting behaviour by these farmers! 35452020-08-26T19:29:28.96345806Diane StaintonThey were here before us and should be entitled to live their lives without being used as target practice.\r\n35452020-08-26T19:38:17.03745807Lyn LucasBeavers were here long before we were, they deserve to live peacefully without persecution in this country.35452020-08-26T19:38:33.59745808Georgette Karpel I am Scottish and I am thoroughly ashamed of the way our government has brushed this under the carpet. Animal lives matter, stand by your convictions, these animals are endangered.35452020-08-26T19:42:09.38745809Jaynie HansellWhen will humans stop killing helpless animals. It is disgusting behaviour. We will end up with no animals and it will be too late for us all.35452020-08-26T19:42:51.53745810Ginette PardoePlease protect these animals. They belong in the UK.35452020-08-26T19:45:06.92745811Peter McCarter It is time the Scottish Government started protecting its wildlife because you are failing in all areas from beavers, hares, birds of prey and your support for grouse moors. 35452020-08-26T19:49:20.41745812Georgina BellThere has to be a way to peacefully co-exist with these wonderful creatures, they have a useful place in our ecosystem.35452020-08-26T19:51:17.79345813sarah forbesStop this now evil humans.35452020-08-26T19:51:34.41745814Colin ShepherdIt seems appalling that a species which has only recently been reintroduced after having been hunted to extinction in the last few hundred years is allowed to be killed in this way. If there are local problems then surely relocation is a better answer. One suspect many landowners and farmers were opposed to the original reintroduction and will wish to take advantage of this loophole. 35452020-08-26T19:54:25.3445815James Cathal dugganProtecting beavers is absolutely vital. And relocating them away from areas where they are not wanted gives indigenous British animal a chance.35452020-08-26T20:00:44.32745816Mhairi MacdonaldThere is no excuse for this. We need to connect with nature. Animals are not ours to do what we like with.35452020-08-26T20:11:02.05745817Sandra Singleton This is disastrous, these are protected animals on the brink of extinction. How disgraceful of anyone hurting and or hunting them its heartbreaking and totally wrong. 35452020-08-26T20:20:51.98345818Karen verrallJust let animals be.35452020-08-26T20:29:32.99745821Lynne scarthCruel.35452020-08-26T20:30:01.9445822Jennifer PullingI am English but equally concerned for the future of these beautiful creatures. If only people understood the vital role they play in ecology, building dams helping river management. But apart from all that they are animals who have every right to live their lives and we do.35452020-08-26T20:31:49.57345823Paula Thompson Shame on you doing this to these lovely gentle creatures.35452020-08-26T20:32:00.99745824Sally CoxBeavers have a positive impact on the countryside, they should be here, they are an important keystone species.35452020-08-26T20:33:51.49745825Heli Cohen We need to learn to live with animals in order to protect not only their existence but ours too. This is just heartbreaking.35452020-08-26T20:51:40.08345826Carmela De Luca Bossa This is disgusting criminal behaviour, they should not go unpunished. 35452020-08-26T20:58:20.31345828Belinda MooreLiving side by side with nature enables us all to co-exist as it should be. 35452020-08-26T20:58:41.8645829Marilyn purkisThis is disgusting, leave our wildlife alone. 35452020-08-26T21:00:10.1345830Sharon O'Rourke-KilburnVery sad to see beavers being persecuted. Any animal that is introducing back into the wild for conservation purposes should be protected by law.35452020-08-26T21:03:14.7745831Jean HewittHow crazy that farmers choose to shoot rather than having help to relocate these beautiful creatures.\r\n35452020-08-26T21:05:04.70345832Mrs Polly SampsonI am in England but it does not stop me from supporting this petition. I am furious the government has issued licences to kill a protected species.35452020-08-26T21:05:05.47345833Jean HewittWhy on earth are farmers allowed to shoot these beautiful creatures? There will be many who will relocate them instead.35452020-08-26T21:06:39.2145834Barbara ThompsonThey introduce them then kill them! It's so wrong.35452020-08-26T21:11:16.27345835melody snowdenSo unnecessary. Please stop this. Save our wildlife.35452020-08-26T21:11:33.2245836Jane clowesWhy are some people hell bent on destroying the wonderful creatures on our Earth? Hunters should be imprisoned.35452020-08-26T21:23:12.945840Claire MasonThis is so cruel please leave these creatures to live in peace. They have as much right to be on this earth as we do!35452020-08-26T21:31:15.1845841Philip ClarkPlease stop the illegal killing of beavers. I come on holiday to see the beavers. If you allow this killing to go on I shall no longer wish to visit Scotland.35452020-08-26T21:36:42.37745842Zoe irvinThese beautiful animals have as much right to live on our land as we do. Why are humans such cruel creatures?35452020-08-26T21:39:17.05345843Jacqueline Godley Totally disgusted by these farmers. 35452020-08-26T21:39:27.80345844Marie mcAnulty Sad I thought the beavers where doing a good thing.35452020-08-26T21:41:18.1345845james innesThis is pure greed and cruelty. 35452020-08-26T21:41:32.0245846Janet Tonks Beavers are Gods creatures just as everything else in earth. Live and let live.35452020-08-26T21:47:47.30345847Hazel BatesYou should be disgusted with yourselves for letting this happen. 35452020-08-26T21:51:33.45745848Gillian Cockwill Seems daft to be killing them when they were reintroduced as a conservation project, which I understand, has been successful?35452020-08-26T21:54:24.09745850Stephen hopperIt is ridiculous that the proactive government who took the momentous step to reintroduce the beaver is allowing one of its departments to fundamentally undermine that decision by granting such a high number of kill licences. A ridiculous state of affairs.35452020-08-26T22:02:44.96345851sarah finchJust because you can, does that give anyone the right to take a life. Shame on them!35452020-08-26T22:06:58.97745853George Welsh What do you have against a healthy biodiversity? Without these animals there will be no healthy ecosystem and therefore no healthy humans. Its time to show back bone and allow large areas for wildlife and stop putting the minority people always first, those hell bent on destroying nature for there own selfish agenda! For the few and not majority of people!35452020-08-26T22:12:04.8845854Lisa Pearson Please stop the persecution of beavers and other species. There has to be much stiffer penalties for those killing35452020-08-26T22:13:01.3545855SUSAN BELLNo need whatsoever for this to be happening.35452020-08-26T22:14:27.9845856Rhona ForresterPlease don't let them be killed. Let's relocate them. They are wonderful Eco Engineers and should be treasured. 35452020-08-26T22:15:50.60345857Greg Logan I have been closely following the spread of Beavers in my local area. Walking up and down river banks, burns and irrigation ditches I have seen very little damage to farmland caused by beavers. Granted there is tree damage but there is also rejuvenation, beavers create habitat for more than 100 other species. In my view landowners are shooting beavers for daming water sources used to irrigate fields, or where undermining has occurred due to bank tunnelling but instead of landowners having discretion to shoot on sight they should be instructed to have any damage surveyed first and foremost to see if an alternative solution can be identified. Beavers are very easy targets so if they are a protected species they need to have protected status at the highest level not a tokenistic sentiment that can be overwritten whenever and wherever licence holders choose. 35452020-08-26T22:16:49.60345858Hazel PearsonTotal ignorance.35452020-08-26T22:18:54.1245859Sandra PetchOnly days ago I saw on the TV that beavers were being introduced to a river here in England, why are Scottish farmers shooting them? They deserved to exist on this planet as well.35452020-08-26T22:25:03.1545862Aline RobertsThis is a disgrace. Please stop.35452020-08-26T22:27:36.11745863Ian ClarkeBeavers should not be culled. There is no justification for it. 35452020-08-26T22:27:37.13345864Andrew ThompsonScottish Government policy allowing killing of beavers such a short time after they were given European Protected Status is morally indefensible, and amounts to a criminal waste of a potentially valuable opportunity to address the twin crises of biodiversity loss and climate breakdown. Please change the policy to allow 'problem' beavers to be moved to suitable habitat elsewhere in Scotland where landowners are happy to accommodate them.35452020-08-26T22:31:46.96345865Dawn Love It is shameful these amazing creatures are being persecuted. They protect watercourses, prevent flooding and have been part of our fauna and flora for thousands of years. Killing beavers should have a prison sentence. 35452020-08-26T22:32:39.32745867Claire HoweBeavers are part of our history. Man persecuted them to extinction, although they played an important role in our countryside. Their reintroduction is amazing & allows what is left of our beautiful land to thrive, re-wild & enhance our lives. Unfortunately, there are those that care only about money & nothing else! Our wildlife was on this world way before money. Leave them be & allow them to "do their thing" & we may all survive for a few more generations - we have a lot to learn from our wildlife! Beavers are brilliant!35452020-08-26T22:39:09.5345868Gay SutherlandSick!35452020-08-26T22:40:11.1445869Lucy WhittakerWhy kill these beautiful animals when there are alternatives to re-wilding them.35452020-08-26T22:45:07.46345870Derek CookIt would appear that we have reintroduced a beautiful animal just to re-enact the shameful actions of our past.35452020-08-26T22:45:55.09345871Linda bhattacharjee How can this be happening in our society?35452020-08-26T22:47:34.2845872linda Griffiths Embarrassed to be human sometimes.35452020-08-26T22:50:21.90745874Thea HollyPlease protect the wildlife before it's too late.35452020-08-26T22:51:10.51745875Mary ScottThe treatment of Scottish wildlife is a source of such shame to me. Whether it be beavers, mountain hares or raptors. We should be better than this. This is not ok.35452020-08-26T22:56:57.29345876Lynda mynottStop destroying our precious wildlife.35452020-08-26T23:00:06.6445877Claire PickI am sick of this cruelty and the shooting of hen harriers and badgers and foxes and so it goes on and on. Just stop.35452020-08-26T23:01:50.54345878Audrey ParryIt is not long since Scotland was so excited about introducing these lovely clever little animals. I can only presume they are damaging the lord of the manors bank account in some way. I am disgusted that one has been found dead.35452020-08-26T23:15:57.79745879Jackie Cartwright What is the point of a protection order if you give licences to kill the protected wildlife? Wildlife need full protection with no loopholes. 35452020-08-26T23:17:35.06345880Andrew Miles We share this planet, we don't own it. Respect nature & the benefits it brings. Are humans shot when somewhere they're not wanted in this country? Shameful level of arrogance & ignorance.35452020-08-26T23:24:24.99345881kath ahmedPlease stop killing these beautiful creatures, they are doing a job, they enhance the countryside with their dams and bring tourists to see them. 35452020-08-26T23:25:03.2545882Allison JonesTotally sickened by the needless slaughter of these creatures.35452020-08-26T23:25:04.52345883Sharlyn Bruce It's about time the Scottish Government got serious about protecting our wildlife. Too much talk and not enough action. 35452020-08-26T23:30:09.76745886Sandra FieldShame on you to hurt a defenceless beaver.35452020-08-26T23:30:10.05745887Philippa DodgsonWe are so fortunate to have wonderful wildlife and many don't have the opportunity to see or hear it. So sad that those that call themselves country folk, think it necessary to kill the wildlife. They need educating to see that we can coexist.35452020-08-26T23:38:53.69745889Marie Charlton A nation is judged by the way it treats its animals.35452020-08-26T23:44:52.3845891Michael John DooleyThese beavers are part of a monitored introduction. Leave them alone.35452020-08-26T23:48:23.50345892Sue HowardCan so called 'humans' leave nothing alone. They are never satisfied unless they are either killing or maiming animals. Leave them alone!35452020-08-26T23:50:32.51345893Valda WilliamsI know someone who did their PhD with the Scottish Beaver Project. To see this now is heartbreaking!\r\n\r\n35452020-08-26T23:51:00.9545894Andy PatonMove don't kill, and expand the range. 35452020-08-26T23:54:58.5945895Lisa Marie BrennanWe should be thoroughly ashamed of ourselves, already driven to extinction once before in UK due to human greed, we reintroduce them to assist us with flooding and when farmers are not happy we want to murder them again, makes me so mad. Can we please find a solution other than killing these beautiful creatures all over again.35452020-08-27T00:00:27.98345896Neil GardnerLet's help our wildlife thrive again.35452020-08-27T00:01:12.7445897Grant clinchNo more KILLING35452020-08-27T00:06:34.64745898Sue Ashmanwild life - not a life to take35452020-08-27T00:09:43.4645899Kitty CugleyLeave them be35452020-08-27T00:24:03.92345900Shaju puthusseryPlease stop the cruelty against this like poor animals35452020-08-27T00:44:49.31745902Maria AplinWhen does death and destruction end????35452020-08-27T00:53:53.10745903Penny BakerBeavers play an important part in flood control measures and should be translocated not killed35452020-08-27T01:46:23.14745904Catherine WilliamsStop killing Beavers they are a great asset to the environment, retain water in times of drought and prevent flooding in times of heavy rain.35452020-08-27T01:50:28.95745905Catherine WilliamsBeavers are a great assett to the environmrent, preventing floods in times of heavy rain and retaining water in times of drought.35452020-08-27T04:30:23.00345906Paul SmitherIf you have any intension to prevent further climate change relocating beavers is a no brainer 35452020-08-27T04:54:08.6445907Philippa DaviesI support the reintroduction of endangered species, l have a family member that is a farmer and know they are wrong to kill these animals....ignorance is not an excuse35452020-08-27T05:31:41.68345908Nick MottCulling should be the absolute last option. Translocate this keystone species to suitable areas throughout Britain. 35452020-08-27T06:06:34.51745909Claire SuzannePlease let our country lead the way in Conservation by showing the world that killing something that is innocent of any crime has a right to live its life without fear. Relocation, castration, birth control are options? Life is as precious to us as it is to an animal... They have emotions too.... Please stop these and other persecution killing.... Be remembered for the things you can stop and not for the things you ignore 35452020-08-27T06:19:21.89345911Brian EvansI am English and this may be ignored but animsks have a right to life as well. The unnecessary killing of wildlife must stop before it is too late.35452020-08-27T06:20:19.11345912Gaynor WarrinerDo you want yet another species to become extinct?? If not, and who the hell does, then STOP killing these animals IMMEDIATELY!!35452020-08-27T06:35:56.78745913Barbara vickersWhat harm is the beaver doing for gods sake leave wildlife alone to live a free and happy life as they were born to do 35452020-08-27T06:53:00.64745914Cherie blackstockCruel and unnecessary 35452020-08-27T07:25:06.79345915Susan Millington With the reintroduction about to start in Cheshire we need to enforce their protection now. Small world view money grabbing landowners not seeing the big picture in a time of climate change. Am so depressed by this short term view.35452020-08-27T07:26:29.3145917Caron CrispIt is beyond my comprehension that the Scottish Government thinks it is more appropriate to cull rather than translocate a species they themselves have protected. Shameful. 35452020-08-27T07:31:15.71745918Lois PackThis is not right, the creatures are part of our countryside, please rethink this, thank you. 35452020-08-27T07:37:34.59345919FIiona DallasThere is no need to kill these beavers. Shame on you. I thought Scotland was better than this.35452020-08-27T07:40:25.26745920Brian LewisI don't see any oint in reintroducing a species and giving it protected status only for farmers to shoot it.35452020-08-27T07:44:47.70345921Alison WalesI oppose killing beavers35452020-08-27T08:00:07.6645922Harriet WhittamEnd this vile practice and that of all your cruelty to killing wildlife. Scotland is beautiful, keep it that way. 35452020-08-27T08:04:39.28345923Fran MooreI want beavers to be protected not killed. 35452020-08-27T08:10:30.17745924Julie Hughes Please stop any killing of beavers and any other wildlife. Please relocate them if necessary. Thank you 35452020-08-27T08:12:02.00345925Penny BaileyI love Scotland for its wild beautiful scenery and wildlife. It is heartbreaking that these beavers are reintroduced and start to thrive then humans start to kill them. They have every right to be here and deserve protection. 35452020-08-27T08:24:07.05345926wendy leaWe need to care for our wildlife and protect species NOT shoot and kill. There will be none left for future generations.35452020-08-27T08:26:16.42745927Nicola DraperPlease please stop this - 35452020-08-27T08:26:26.3545928Christina votter Please stop this killing the world has gone crazy man does not have the right too kill every animal that breaths 35452020-08-27T08:27:33.19345929Nicola DraperThis cannot happens - Beavers are being re introduced in Cornwall - 35452020-08-27T08:29:07.36745931Simone Walton There can be no reason to shoot ! 35452020-08-27T08:35:59.88345933Gary CaneHuman interaction again upsetting the ecological balance then further down the line the animals will be blamed. A bit like the persecution of the Grey Squirrel man has to take its share of the blame for its removal of much of the habitat and food source.35452020-08-27T08:37:07.645934kay McinallyI support compassionate coexistence with all animals. Working alongside animals and people 35452020-08-27T08:39:48.58745935shelagh worsnopShould be having dialogue with farmers to resolve any issues. This is not the way to solve any problems.35452020-08-27T08:44:02.74345936Andrena CraigThe beavers deserve to live their lives in peace without the threat of being murdered based on where they live.35452020-08-27T08:55:36.1245938Sorrel PriceProtect wildlife.35452020-08-27T08:56:44.10345939Jan PhillipsRelocate please - why would you think of killing another living animal without a very compelling reason. Shameful35452020-08-27T09:02:46.6545941Sharon McTaggartHow terribly cruel. 35452020-08-27T09:05:00.74345942Jackie waughmanIs there ever going to be an end officially. Its just brutal. It's been going onon 4 years. PUT A STOP TO THIS 35452020-08-27T09:15:14.04345945Frances Aldous Beavers do a lot of good regarding flood relief and improving wildlife habitats. They are an asset and must be protected. 35452020-08-27T09:17:41.90345946Rachel Euba It is time for the 4 nations to get their houses in order - stop persecuting nature, promote respect based on science, and build eco tourism through promoting beavers instead of killing them. 35452020-08-27T09:19:25.87345947Wendy RhodesBeavers are part of our natural habitat. It would be heartbreaking for them to become extinct. 35452020-08-27T09:23:02.71745948Lesley LansomFarmers should learn to adapt and accommodate wild animals rather than resorting to killing them. They are responsible for wiping out many species and it has got to stop.35452020-08-27T09:26:37.32745949Sandra Holmes Why reintroduce to cull 35452020-08-27T09:47:01.545950Steven ClarkeWhat is the point of rewilding if we then allow the carnage mongers to happily shoot those that are rewilded? 35452020-08-27T09:48:17.1445951Georgia TraceyWhat was the beaver initiative all about? Here we are now with increasing shootings of this recolonised species being tolerated apparently or blind sided. The hypocrisy of it all is galling.35452020-08-27T09:55:31.9445952Margaret Nugent These wonderful creatures need our protection..35452020-08-27T09:58:12.11345953ATIA CHALMERSIt's very difficult for parents to prepare children for grief and bereavement when they themselves are grieving. Even worse if the child has to grieve a parent. 35832020-08-27T10:03:06.73745954Hillary Houston Feel disgusted and angry about this. Anyone abusing animals especially those protected by law should be jailed! 35452020-08-27T10:08:03.845955Mark GoldingWe have a great opportunity to relocate beavers that are having a detrimental effect for some landowners rather than being over reliant on issuing licences for them to be culled. There is a wide range of expertise and willing participants that could be used to help with this. Scotland needs to look at ways to reduce impacts of flooding, cleaning waterways, creating wetlands and increasing biodiversity. Translocation should be allowed.35452020-08-27T10:12:38.17745956Don StilesThis hunting has got to stop! nothing is sacred anymore 35452020-08-27T10:14:48.03745957Lynney EdwardsJust stop killing, capture and relocate! 35452020-08-27T10:25:07.94345958Mrs Naomi BarnesThere are plenty of rivers that need new beaver populations and people prepared to trap and relocate. Shooting them is not the solution.35452020-08-27T10:25:30.645959Brian PattersonThe Scottish government are being taken to the court in The Hague over their shocking treatment of the Scottish wildcat. \r\n 35452020-08-27T10:27:39.8545960Joe SyerWild habitats and the key species that dwell within these precious areas need far greater protection. 35452020-08-27T10:31:11.3545961kit shieldsThe is is just another case of the Scottish Executives disregard of wildlife35452020-08-27T10:33:24.11745962Sue ColeIt is wrong to kill beavers.\r\n35452020-08-27T10:38:32.49345964Janice BatesHow can they be allowed to kill a protected species?35452020-08-27T10:40:26.16345966Barbara ThomasNo justification for this...35452020-08-27T10:49:06.0745968Martin AmblerThese wonderful animals have been made extinct before in our country. Let's not do it again. 35452020-08-27T10:55:33.58745969johnny Rudkinthe introduction of beavers to scotland is a step in the right direction of flood water control.35452020-08-27T11:06:26.0645970Chas PennyBeavers are incredible but defenceless engineers who help habitat restoration and flooding. Shooting them illegally should carry a heavy sentence.35452020-08-27T11:09:21.77745971Vashni wyattThis is barbaric, there has to be a better way, a way to coexist 35452020-08-27T11:10:56.5645972Samuel CortisI appreciate that farmers have difficult job working the land and that for the individual Beavers could impact upon their work and productivity.\r\n\r\nFor far to long however these discussions have been tied to narratives associated with agriculture and production. If we were to look at this from a more holistic point of view we might realise that Beavers bring much greater levels of opportunity and benefit then damage. (See Duncan Martin's comment below as an example.) We need a system which understands this and therefore supports farmers adversely effected but not expensive of the Beaver community who are providing an ecological service that cannot be replicated by human hand. These creatures should be cherished.35452020-08-27T11:12:58.77745973Fiona Constable NatureScot is a misnomer... They are not supporting Scotland's wildlife by issuing shoot to kill licences for a huge range of wildlife... And using tax payers money! They seem intent on supporting landowners over wildlife. 35452020-08-27T11:13:57.37345974Karen Howard Nature should be left alone the circle of life everything is connected to kill off one species you'll kill other 35452020-08-27T11:15:24.40345975Sue bridlePlease protect these animals. Humans should be able to coexist with wildlife not just kill everything. This is terrible. 35452020-08-27T11:16:16.54745977LORRAINE ROWLEY Please save the beavers, and their habitat. 35452020-08-27T11:19:06.9545978Margaret RamseyThe Scottish government really needs to ask itself why it is in such thrall to large landowners ( often not Scottish based ) , over something that most of the rest of the population are appalled about.35452020-08-27T11:33:41.4745979Simon TuckerWe could do with a number of them in southwest England to expand the gene pool. Killing should not be an option. 35452020-08-27T11:44:09.6945980Tim MurgatroydWhen will we learn to work with nature, not against it?35452020-08-27T11:50:10.3645981Karen Brunton Beavers are beautiful creatures that need protection from humans too dumb to respect the wild 35452020-08-27T11:59:17.67745982Sandra MarshallBeavers are an important part of the ecology. They do a valuable job. Please do NOT cull them.35452020-08-27T12:09:48.7145983Kellie Jerram Kill kill kill, mother nature is fighting back35452020-08-27T12:13:44.81745984Barbara KeatingWe need to look at non lethal methods of control first, and use lethal ones only when all else looks to fail. 35452020-08-27T12:20:57.2145985Callum BuchanScotland has great wildlife and space to let it succeed and be a marvelous place to visit. Don't let it become like one big farm with fences, flat soil and dams, we would lose the magic. No need to be building marvelous structures, looking after out wildlife would make us stand out ahead of our neighbours certainly and internationally partly. 35452020-08-27T12:23:00.91345986DAWN DUCKER What a disgusting government we have, who enable Beaver killing shame on uk shame on Boris Johnson shame on Nicola sturgeon 35452020-08-27T12:23:38.44345987Caroline MooreIt is heartbreaking the way our animals are treated. 35452020-08-27T12:36:26.5445988douglas robertsonStop this madness \r\nShame on scottish government \r\nThey don't seem to care about wildlife protection 35452020-08-27T12:38:47.86745990Laura SelwayIt appears that in England they have finally relialisted that beavers are actually good for the environment and reduce flooding. Please give the beavers a chance! \r\n35452020-08-27T12:42:37.33745991Brenda DixonSo much research has gone into their release, why not give it a chance.35452020-08-27T12:42:45.08745992Tracy HunterWhat was the point of bringing these beautiful creatures to UK so farmers can kill them at will!!! They are protected.35452020-08-27T12:45:59.6245993 Nicola Parsons No one has the right to destroy this beautiful protected animal just because it's inconveniencing them. Please act now! 35452020-08-27T13:08:03.7845994Gary GornerMoney greed comes first, nature last. Time for change now.35452020-08-27T13:19:38.46745995Manuela MoisFarmers should be grateful to the beavers. They are a keystone species. They help reducing both flash flooding downstream and summer drought. Please learn how to cohabitate with them. You shall not kill.35452020-08-27T13:26:53.1145996Sarah Holloway They are useful and need to be relocated not killed 35452020-08-27T13:31:33.48745997Anne Marie Ricketts This is barbaric and pointless. 35452020-08-27T13:35:43.53745998Colin DaviesBeavers need assistance. Not a gun.35452020-08-27T13:50:02.4646001Colin HarperTry relocating the beavers, shooting them should be the last resort.35452020-08-27T14:08:01.69746003Heather McCallumKilling beavers should be a last, not a first, resort in beaver management35452020-08-27T14:17:14.4346004Jan BurtonIs nothing safe in the wild?35452020-08-27T14:28:38.66746005Diana DenchThis is appalling behaviour. It should be made a crime to injure or harm a beaver in any way with a large fine and prison sentence for disregarding35452020-08-27T14:28:42.38346006Phil SmithKilling should only EVER be the very last resort.. not the easy (cheaper) option... if indeed killing should ever be allowed. 35452020-08-27T14:28:42.69746007Susan DarbyAll animals deserve to live. We are not the only species on this earth35452020-08-27T14:36:42.9846008Mary GarbettBeavers were part of our natural fauna before they were hunted to extinction. Please let them live and help to rebalance the environment.35452020-08-27T14:42:28.66746009Mike MuscroftSend them here to the Norfolk Broads, plenty of dead wood to chew on and an abundance of water. If it will save their lives, I'll drive up to Scotland to fetch them!35452020-08-27T15:47:05.56746010Sue-Ellen WelfonderHave visited Scotland many times and hope to continue to do so. One of the things I've always most appreciated is the abundance of undisturbed nature - including the wildlife at home there. Please do not kill these innocent animals. Please do all it takes to protect them. Thank you.35452020-08-27T15:47:39.17746013John FoxThe beavers offer so much to the diversity of flora and fauna, they are an extremely important part of our ecology. They must be allowed to prosper.35452020-08-27T15:51:36.25746014Morag MacIntyreSupport for protecting the beavers35452020-08-27T16:02:11.3546015valerie newmanScotland is an unsafe place for mammals and birds of prey. Please remove the beavers, the families are being disrupted and protect these magnificent creatures.35452020-08-27T16:17:34.2946016Elaine EdwardsThese creatures do a lot to protect and enhance our environment35452020-08-27T16:33:21.7946017Lynn elderDisgusting human race.35452020-08-27T16:38:17.8446018Hilary BradshawHow can beavers be a protected species and then be culled in such high numbers? This makes no sense!35452020-08-27T16:40:00.40346020ALAN HOWIE Theres far to much needless killing going on in this world 35452020-08-27T16:47:44.60746021David AdamsonPlease support this petition35452020-08-27T17:14:43.18746022Katrina MearnsWhy must we kill of our wildlife? Surely we should be looking after them not the opposite. Stop this barbarism now !!!!!35452020-08-27T17:15:16.14346023Laura HastieThese animals deserve to be relocated to habitats where they can be beneficial.35452020-08-27T17:24:22.19346025Jennie phillipsThese wonderful animals belong in their natural habitat of Scotland, England and Wales. They bring a unique diversity which is vital to reducing flooding and increasing a greater environment for wildlife which is vital to our countryside.35452020-08-27T17:24:31.6946026Paul Adams That is so tragic35452020-08-27T17:29:44.6646028Rebecca JoynesI cannot believe this is happening!35452020-08-27T17:34:01.5546029Ann wood Surely there are ways for all of us to co exist. I suspect many farmers will be supportive of beavers 35452020-08-27T17:50:27.1846030Richard DayThese animals improve the environment for people by reducing surging flood waters, so it is really stupid to cull them.35452020-08-27T17:54:19.2146031Judy MackenzieIf Chris Packham supports this petition, that's good enough for me #movedon'tkill 35452020-08-27T17:55:37.2446032Anne MoghrabyStop this senseless killing and relocate. Lovely creatures35452020-08-27T17:57:10.5746033Claire WheaterPlease stop this senseless killing 35452020-08-27T17:57:26.5746034Martin DoreyIt's time for us to stop killing in the name of us. We have to learn to share our planet or we will kill it.35452020-08-27T17:59:09.8246035Alan HardyWe do enough killing. Just move them for heavens sake. 35452020-08-27T18:01:23.946038Hugh StilesIt is insane to re-introduce a species that humans wiped out in the British Isles, presumably after long consultation, only to then decide, one supposes at the behest of landowners, that it is then acceptable to kill them. At the very least they should be relocated. 35452020-08-27T18:04:10.0146039Frank MorrisThis is a great chance to make a statement about the value of such an amazing species playing a role in Scottish ecosystems. Please set an example as you do on so many other issues. 35452020-08-27T18:05:13.80746040Corinne Geeringplease don't do this, it is so unnecessary. 35452020-08-27T18:07:01.96346041Margaret EastonPlease relocate. Please let them live.35452020-08-27T18:10:17.7746042Carolyn RobertsonThese animals are a valuable contributor to the ecosystem and create an environment which can prevent flooding. You must know all these reasons. This need to destroy is unnecessary. There is always a better way. You do not need to destroy them. It is unnecessary, cruel and uncivilised. Start becoming better and doing better.35452020-08-27T18:10:26.80346043Catherine StirlandIt is vital to save and relocate the beavers for the survival of our ecosystem and for animal welfare.35452020-08-27T18:15:18.72746044Cheryl WoodThuggery, pointless cruelty. Listen to your conscience please and put an immediate stop to this shameful practice. 35452020-08-27T18:18:39.52746045Jean SadlerNo need for this at all, will do far more good to leave them be.35452020-08-27T18:20:27.46346046Lyn MearsPlease ensure these beautiful animals are protected 35452020-08-27T18:20:28.51346047Steve WilliamsWhy is the word 'compassion' never one of those considered important in a political debate?35452020-08-27T18:22:00.646048James AddisI'll take them, would rather them be in my back garden than dead. 35452020-08-27T18:26:53.3246051David HillMany studies have shown that beavers do much more good than harm. Leave them be to improve the landscape35452020-08-27T18:32:50.94746052Bob BeamanBeavers are a keystone species and are vital in restoring the cleanliness of our rivers, and their ability to mitigate flooding and water table imbalances, as well as massively increasing the biodiversity and volume of creatures within their area. This includes fish stocks which have been shown to increase markedly in better and cleaner spawning areas. \r\nWe should under no circumstances cull these creatures but relocate until the imbalance has been redressed. 35452020-08-27T18:33:05.02346053Jill HillJust stop this. When will people learn that animals are not only beautiful, but of immense importance in this world!35452020-08-27T18:33:11.1446054Andy BolsoverRelocate as required - stop the killing.35452020-08-27T18:33:51.08746055Paul FisherStop this carnage. Do people not know the benefit of these creatures to the eco system?35452020-08-27T18:37:08.85346056George WalkerStop this despicable cruelty35452020-08-27T18:41:16.7646058Donna RorkeWe must stop killing and instead value this indigenous species the beaver, who has a right to be here. They create unique habitats and any damage they cause is minimal compared to the benefits they bring.35452020-08-27T18:46:36.6146060Julie MclarenPlease relocate them. It is unbearable the torture that is being inflicted on helpless animals. 35452020-08-27T18:48:25.32746062Clare ValentineThis is a big enough country to accommodate all these creatures alongside humans. The countryside and all that should be in it is important for the wellbeing of our future generations as well as the planet. Let us live in balance with these creatures. 35452020-08-27T18:50:11.4746063Bryan CoxOh the natural world will be so relieved if when humans finally finish themselves off. Leave these beautiful creatures to do what they do best.35452020-08-27T19:23:12.2546064Gavin King-SmithIt seems too early to introduce culling measures when there is only very limited knowledge of the pros and cons of re-introducing beavers. Their benefits in tackling the climate emergency seem likely to outweigh drawbacks.\r\n\r\nThe proposed mitigation of relocation seems very appropriate.35452020-08-27T19:31:34.48746066Hilary McMillanBeavers help prevent floods!35452020-08-27T19:32:42.83346067Chris Smedley We have a responsibility to care for the natural world, which is dying and being killed at an alarming rate.35452020-08-27T19:37:36.9746069Marian CleaverWhy why why would you do such a thing, thriving in Devon, relocate to somewhere they are safe and valued for the amazing animals that they are.35452020-08-27T19:42:16.846070Kym HaggettPlease allow these creatures the safety and dignity they deserve and stop the killing. Relocate them please it's not impossible. You will feel a lot better in yourself and you'll definitely be a better person for it. 35452020-08-27T19:42:50.39746071Jane HomerRelocation, relocation, relocation Please! How can you be so cruel as to do otherwise?35452020-08-27T19:45:06.88346072Reverend Carole PearlPlease ban the shooting of the protected and much need beavers.\r\n35452020-08-27T19:54:53.55746073Anne Lloyd Absolutely no need to kill the beavers when they can be humanely relocated Where beavers are successfully integrated. They enhance the environment and provide tourist attraction. 35452020-08-27T19:55:12.0146074Laura GuilfoyleIronic to be killing creatures who can help to reduce flooding as the country is experiencing summer flooding. 35452020-08-27T19:57:57.33346075Gloria GinniverStop this cruelty, these animals have an important role to play in the environment.35452020-08-27T20:01:21.8846076Tracy DugdaleWhy do people think it's necessary to kill, rather than relocate them safely,these animals have been here much longer than us! What right do we have!\r\n\r\n\r\n35452020-08-27T20:03:01.6546077Lynda DickinsonPlease stop this awful cruelty.35452020-08-27T20:04:03.35346078Ms Tania PearceBeavers maintain fresh watercourses throughout the year and will inevitably help preserve precious fresh water supplies for the land, animals and humans too. Beavers also help maintain healthy ecosystems too.35452020-08-27T20:04:49.3746079Paul BelfordDon't kill, relocate.35452020-08-27T20:27:45.4546082James BoothPlease relocate these beavers instead of killing them. We must all make every effort to protect biodiversity wherever we find it.35452020-08-27T20:31:33.9546084Sandra whelanDisgusting, beautiful animals. 35452020-08-27T20:33:1046085Mark Lee DaviesThis is no way to treat nature and you have no right to take it upon yourself just to cull innocent wildlife. There are other options. 35452020-08-27T20:34:44.3146087Sue Dickins Why kill these beautiful creatures? Their work has also proved to aid the environment. If you must, relocate them. 35452020-08-27T20:35:15.26346088Mark Lee DaviesThis is no way to treat innocent wildlife or nature. You have no right to cull innocent animals when there are options. 35452020-08-27T20:35:34.02746089Ted CarrRelocation must be done sensitively taking into account farmers, Landowners and Beavers. 35452020-08-27T20:49:14.3646091Andy InglisCenturies of land mismanagement in Scotland has left it a barren, desperate landscape stripped of biodiversity. Reforest Scotland, reintroduce more native species and restore the ecosystem to its natural state. Protect the beavers.35452020-08-27T20:51:42.3446093Joanne HerbertPlease stop this horrendous unnecessary cruelty35452020-08-27T20:55:08.21746095Mhairi JohnstoneStop35452020-08-27T21:00:15.1946096Catherine HetheringtonWe are caretakers of this planet and yet choose to carry out the horrific murder of animals we should be looking after for our future generations. Please relocate not kill.35452020-08-27T21:06:09.7846097Deb DanielPlease stop needlessly killing defenceless animals. Choose the kinder option.35452020-08-27T21:06:33.07746098Shirley McGrealProtect the beavers! 35452020-08-27T21:09:20.48746099Susan McMurrayWhat is wrong with people? This is yet more senseless murder. Maybe you should issue orders to relocate these stupid landowners to a more appropriate habitat, preferably a desert, since that's the thing they seem to be aiming for.35452020-08-27T21:12:29.09346100Sandy FrameBeavers do naturally what humans find trouble to complete. We cannot control water but we can allow nature to do what it does best without human chaos.35452020-08-27T21:21:55.56746102Gilly Reason JonesDo the right thing and relocate these animals.35452020-08-27T21:25:55.1946103Paul dawsonThis is yet another example of farmers doing whatever they want. They need heavy fines and prison sentences. They are all demented.35452020-08-27T21:26:37.51746104Gillian RaeIf NatureScot's aim is to '#MakeSpaceForNature, then it must find the space, to translocate our beavers. 35452020-08-27T21:33:33.03346105Christine Ward-CampbellI support the move to fully protect the Scottish beavers, by re-location , and making it unlawful to kill them.35452020-08-27T21:34:40.66346106Paul MurrayI feel it is totally unnecessary to kill beavers,they are creatures that if they are affecting someones farmland then they can easily be transported to where they are needed where there is a lot of flooding.35452020-08-27T21:36:10.33746107Bill GrayKeep fighting for our wildlife.35452020-08-27T21:42:01.33346108Douglas RobertsonIf you believe in conservation you do not allow the killing of a reintroduced species. 35452020-08-27T21:51:52.47346110Graham Hamiltonit is a sad Government that can't recognise this this totally wrong. 35452020-08-27T21:57:42.61746111Matthew BarrettDisgusting treatment. 35452020-08-27T21:58:25.11746112Sandy FrameLet beavers do what they do best and what humans have tried to do but failed usually causing much more damage than any beaver ever has.This from a former civil engineer.35452020-08-27T21:58:39.92746113Helen EllisPlease reconsider this decision. Please relocate this amazing animals and be humane.35452020-08-27T22:01:10.3246114Mike ewenLeave the Beavers alone.\r\n35452020-08-27T22:02:11.50746115Jacqueline ParkerIntervention by the right parties avoids conflict and shooting. Someone isn't doing their job.35452020-08-27T22:03:35.82346116Jane HurleyPlease stop shooting beavers.35452020-08-27T22:08:40.3746117Laurinda LuffmanPlease allow beavers to be relocated. There is enough senseless killing in the world.35452020-08-27T22:10:50.63746118Liz GafferWildlife is already under serious threat, unnecessary slaughter like this will only make this worse.35452020-08-27T22:18:16.60746119Kate ShawThis is IMPORTANT. We live and depend on an ecosystem in which beavers are essential. Rehabit all beavers, they are as priceless as the ecosystem we rely on.35452020-08-27T22:26:41.7646120Lynda SmithI understand that Cheshire are reintroducing beavers over a five year period. Could some of the beavers be moved here? Just a thought. There may be other areas in UK also?35452020-08-27T22:30:35.2546121Jay FriedlanderBeavers have only just been reintroduced and have been proved beneficial to their habitats. They are a protected species. Why are farmers being allowed to get away with this? They cannot be overrun with beaver populations already. 35452020-08-27T22:39:34.1246122Tessa TimmisWith proper Organization planning communication education, these animals can co exist and benefit the local environment -rather than going back in time. Why is there slaughtering beavers to extinction again.. Good leadership is key, where is it?35452020-08-27T22:46:53.12346123Nigel WoolseyStop killing healthy animals. Move them if they are a problem.35452020-08-27T22:52:44.84746124MR DAVID J BUCKLERMove not kill, learn to live with nature! 35452020-08-27T22:56:56.76746125Jane MasonBeavers are a native mammal - they belong here and provide important ecosystem services. Killing is a brutal, unintelligent management option. Please relocate them if really necessary instead.35452020-08-27T23:42:53.8246129Debora MaltWhy? Having brought this animal to encourage the natural habitat they live and to promote the way these little industrial animals benefit the area and other wildlife....senseless killings....35452020-08-27T23:57:59.91346130Benjamin Edwards There is absolutely no need to slaughter valuable British forna for the saving of minimal funds.35452020-08-31T07:35:12.25746131David DeanSome buildings could also be used as workshops, classrooms, IT hubs or kitchens for the unemployed to gain new practical skills or upgrade existing ones. Could be accommodation for the vulnerable in our community, disabled, those with mental health concerns or challenging life choices. 35872020-09-01T10:45:17.98346133William ClarkToo many children are unaware of the facts surrounding bereavement. 35832020-09-01T10:52:09.65346134Suzanne Pirie Having a genetic condition myself that I didn't know about until my 20s I think it's important to know these things a lot sooner. I probably still wouldn't know about my condition had it not been for a professor from London doing genetic tests on my whole family 30 years ago. We need more testing in younger years. 35892020-09-01T12:40:58.67746135Gillian QueenAll babies are a treasure and must be treated as such.35892020-09-01T22:31:23.04346137Sandy GunnHaving taken a period on bereavement and funerals for 20 years, I found that many pupils mentioned - sometimes years later - that they had found it helpful to have had the topic mentioned before they had to face it themselves, for no one else had dealt with it. I have been particularly interested in it because my own father died when I was young.35832020-09-02T15:04:22.35346139Daniel FergusonIn the current time it is critical that this action is upheld and the provisions implemented.36092020-09-03T05:42:10.07346140Bryce McCutcheon30 day payment would help out the industry enormously.36092020-09-03T07:45:31.93746141Rhona BainDeath is a normal part of life and many children are affected by bereavement at a very young age. If all children have had age appropriate information about death and dying as they grow up then they will cope better when they do have a bereavement and they will have empathy with other children who have been bereaved. 35832020-09-03T07:57:43.10746142Kirsty CluffMy children have been let down terribly by the schooling system and their lack of understanding and training around bereavement. I even supplied the school with resources that I paid for to help. Despite Government ministers stating that funding had been given for bereavement training and support in schools we are yet to see any positive changes whatsoever! 35832020-09-03T12:10:13.0246145Derek cornerCash flow is critical 36092020-09-03T14:11:42.18346147Jill Zawadzka This should be part of the school learning without a doubt.35832020-09-03T15:03:02.84746148Jason Walsh30 Days is must for our industry36092020-09-04T17:19:29.38346149Stuart Whitby"Unused spaces" is pretty vague. This would indicate that the Scottish Government should be able to seize the property of people who cannot find a renter or buyer or use case for their property, and that's unacceptable.\r\n\r\nIf the proviso stands that these spaces are purchased at fair value from people who choose to sell, that might be okay, as would using public buildings for this purpose. Not private property though.\r\n\r\nIn response to the comment which would insist on building standards, excellent insulation etc. for these buildings, who pays? The answer is "you and me", and the Scottish Government is already spending far more than they earn.35872020-09-04T17:25:55.6246150Stuart WhitbyAny "compulsory" education on this should be avoided. Keep to the core subjects please, that teachers are semi capable of teaching. If outside charities or specialists can give a session, good stuff. Otherwise, the schooling system is doing badly enough in this country without introducing additional compulsory education on things that affect people differently where a one-size-fits-all solution is likely to be ineffective across the gamut of personalities.35832020-09-05T16:26:47.3846151Heather WalkerBereavement is inevitable and learning more about it and how to cope with it can only benefit children and make them more attuned to the emotions of themselves and others.35832020-09-06T02:47:33.29346154Brian McKenna A family member had an AVM (arteriovenous malformation) and was successfully treated at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow and the Western General Hospital in Edinburgh. 35892020-09-06T14:22:49.25346155Andrea TaylorBereavement should be as big a part of education as learning about birth as it happens to us all. 35832020-09-06T16:48:58.39746156Elaine Macdonald Now more than ever if SMEs are to thrive and boost our economy cash flow is needed. Therefore what better time to insist on this? 36092020-09-07T10:16:19.19346157Mark ReillyPlease sign this and support. 35892020-09-07T13:31:14.72346158Jill Zawadzka Totally agree.35832020-09-08T15:17:27.1546162Fauzia akhtarGreat idea should definitely be something available in schools.35832020-09-08T17:15:55.18746163Sadif AmjadChildren need to be able to understand and deal with bereavement.35832020-09-08T18:30:39.74346164Daniel clarkeWe need to bring death, dying and bereavement out of the closet and work on making it less taboo to talk about.35832020-09-08T22:30:40.22746165Arfa ShoaibDefinitely strongly agree.35832020-09-09T05:00:04.4446167Maryam Abdallah Yes should be in the curriculum is a big part of life and we can never escape it. 35832020-09-09T07:28:26.0646168Kirsty Cluff The Scottish minister for education made bold statements promising bereavement support in all Scottish schools. Both of the schools my children attend are severely lacking in their resources and training. I had to provide literature And work books to one school In order for them to support my daughter. Surely, in this day and age all staff in schools should be given training and access to resources so that all of our heartbroken youngsters can be supported and nurtured through the grieving process! 35832020-09-09T08:37:02.03746169Shazia Mehmood Nothing new has been developed in school to adapt with the changing times. It makes sense if you teach kids about health they should be taught about death and how to cope. Bereavement counselling is a sound idea. As adults it is difficult to understand death and question it. You can only imagine how devastating it can be for a child. It's time the curriculum was changed.35832020-09-09T15:00:20.87746171Kathleen HughesI agree it should be compulsory.35832020-09-12T12:27:03.7946172Robbie Meney I don't think demanding an emblem is important or urgent enough to be a problem for anyone.36152020-09-13T18:27:27.18746174Muhammad khuramPlease sign this.35892020-09-15T12:01:00.73346175Eddie FergusCash flow is critical.36092020-09-15T12:14:00.95346176Martin SneddonThis is well over due.36092020-09-15T12:14:12.95346177Amanda Lamb30 days is vital to allow our SME's and our economy to thrive.36092020-09-15T12:24:45.25346178Steven RawdingThere is a critical need for internal audit and verification of supply chain payment.36092020-09-15T12:50:53.9646179William MorrisonLong overdue!36092020-09-15T13:47:53.2846180leslie reekieThe sub contractors portion of the payment made by main contractors client should be deposited in \r\nsubcontractors designated bank accounts by a Act of Parliament. Small and Medium Enterprises have been used long enough by main contractors and verbal football by the politicians for the last twenty years as all indication points to the small and medium enterprises sector paying for the next twenty years the debt which is currently being incurred. 36092020-09-15T21:24:01.61346181James ScullionCash flow is crucial for all business, I'm a small business and struggle to get any less than 45 days to month end, a real struggle at times. 36092020-09-16T09:02:06.00746182Suzanne ByrneCash Flow is critical for small businesses.36092020-09-17T22:23:55.83346183William McGinleyThe Scottish Crossbill would be a good emblem as it is unique to our country.36152020-09-18T07:26:45.2346184Andrew AndersonI think the unicorn and thistle already meet the requirements. Although no doubt not intended at the time the unicorn was very forward looking given the association with diversity and acceptance of all that it now represents. Is that what is bothering the petitioner and this is on fact an attempt to get rid of the unicorn?36152020-09-26T01:59:02.9746185Stuart DochertyThe Lion Rampant should be adopted as the emblem.36152020-09-26T19:33:01.06746186Christine CatherLoving the unicorn and the thistle, no need to foist something new that might feel artificial to us.36152020-09-27T13:52:15.89346187Jan VettrainoWe do indeed need to work on improving many aspects of Scotland to better support the people of Scotland. But taking time to review its official emblem would only be a diversion, and even a smoke screen, rather than spending time on addressing the issues.36152020-09-30T14:32:13.51346191Russell CrokerVery good.36332020-09-30T14:51:19.48346192maureen harmerWe need our family to be with us and for us to be with our family. 36332020-09-30T15:41:59.47746195Tracy macraeI think people should be allowed in to be with their ill relatives to comfort and support them 36332020-09-30T15:50:07.41346196Charlotte maciver I totally ageee36332020-09-30T16:33:58.71746198Elizabeth keltie What about buying our own ppe to visit my 24 year old son in the hospital it is heartbreaking not to be there to support him36332020-09-30T17:05:08.14346199Ted Scanlon At times the best medicine is to see and feel a friend nearby. 36332020-09-30T17:16:42.64346200Jane hallHope you get this passed.36332020-09-30T17:38:21.30346201vicky Regan praying for use all36332020-09-30T18:23:34.0546202Lorraine Docherty Patients in intensive care need a visitor to support them in their recovery.36332020-09-30T19:02:06.80746203Rhian eddieThat family's should be aloud to see there family member if they are in intensive care 36332020-09-30T19:34:07.00746204Richie Marshall Patients in intensive care should be aloud a visitor 36332020-09-30T21:16:41.61346205sharon elizabeth toddI think that this could make a huge impact to a patient in need of support speaking as someone that has already lost family members to this awful pandemic, I know the difference this could have made even just to take some of the burden from their next of kin.36332020-09-30T21:31:35.84746206Bernadette MacphersonThe right thing to do for families. 36332020-09-30T21:39:32.64346207Linda Kelly One member of family could be with a patient at their moment of need it would also free up staff. 36332020-09-30T22:18:49.94746208Sheena DuboustIt seems quite inhumane not to allow a visitor- for both parties involved.36332020-10-01T18:31:27.49346210Ita Phillips Most definitely. 36332020-10-01T21:27:35.11346211Pamela BurnsYes, I fully support the request to allow a designated visitor for those in ICU. 36332020-10-02T07:11:36.51346212Francis cousins Yes36332020-10-02T16:35:24.90346213Duncan McLeodAll war memorials should be protected35852020-10-03T17:10:59.04746215Andrew QuinnProtect all Scotland war memorials 35852020-10-03T17:42:43.1946216Patrick mc manusI think it's disgusting that these men and woman gave the ultimate sacrifice so we could live a normal happy and free life, it sickens me what they are doing to the memorials.35852020-10-03T17:45:06.94346217Scott Mclaughlan It is our duty to protect the memory of those who served 35852020-10-03T17:49:16.97346218Patrick Michael McManus G209pj It disgusting the lack of respect these people have for the men and woman that died for their freedom 35852020-10-03T20:56:34.546221Gary Mills It is the duty of the Scottish Government to maintain our war memorials, to remember the eternal memory of those who made the ultimate sacrifice for their country. 35852020-10-03T22:22:30.7646222RuchazieBlue Great petition 35852020-10-04T08:56:23.12346223Carol watsonHeart breaking for people 36332020-10-04T09:24:18.93346224Liz Phillips For Gillian an everyone else needing the same. In all 4-- England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales. 36332020-10-04T09:26:51.49346225Liz Phillips I wud like to think, someone was with me, it's lonely by yourself. 36332020-10-04T13:13:47.33346227Javed Anwar All war memorial should be protected by law35852020-10-04T14:32:27.54746228Charles MacLeanhope the Government allow this 36332020-10-04T17:16:50.75746229George Blades Honour our dead35852020-10-04T17:47:53.93346232Jackie Robertson Lest We Forget35852020-10-04T17:55:38.49746233Gordon WhitehallAll war memorials and monuments and Street name plates must be protected 35852020-10-04T22:02:54.40746234Graham Forrest Shocking 35852020-10-05T08:08:52.1746235Jeannette Gray,Memorials are part of Scotland's proud history as much as Bannockburn and Bothwell Bridge. These people fought for Scotland's freedom too.35852020-10-05T09:03:29.8546236John hendrieRespect should be shown to all war memorials by all 35852020-10-05T11:14:52.0746237John McCannShould already be done. A Coatbridge man living in Belfast35852020-10-05T12:00:27.6346238Alexander James GlassIn recent years we have witnessed an increase in the number of war memorials that have been decorated. We need legislation to make this a criminal office to deter anyone from damaging our memorials. 35852020-10-05T12:01:42.51346239Linda watsonHistorical monuments are just that To remind is as all of history and a achievements of that period. 35852020-10-05T12:54:20.54346240bruce jamesAs an old soldier, I am appalled at some of the vandalism of war memorials.35852020-10-05T22:20:34.7246241Janette whitelaw I think anyone convicted as defacing or damaging our war memorials should be treated as a hate crime .its totally disrespectfull to our war vetrans who sacrificed so much for our freedom .there has been more of these damage to our war memorials and if it carried a prison sentance I think it would make those breaking the law think again35852020-10-05T23:29:38.54746243Jean LoganIt should be a criminal offence to vandalize our war memorials we owe those who gave their lives for our freedom so much and should always respect their memory 35852020-10-06T06:59:50.99346244Nancy Georgeson I feel strongly that intensive care patients should be allowed a designated visitor.36332020-10-06T17:54:44.91746245Rhona OmalleyIt is basic common decency to make this law.\r\n35852020-10-07T12:59:18.1746247Jim Baillie The vandalism that's happened in the last year to the war memorials is a total lack of respect. 35852020-10-07T16:06:46.99746248GARY ANDERSONIf retail can have background music on with no consequence or closure the hospitality sector must be allowed music. 36342020-10-07T16:51:54.84746249Dave WoodUtterly ridiculous. No need for it at all.36342020-10-08T07:14:29.70746250Samantha Pilbrow Having gone through this with my husband it is barbaric that they are not allowed. 36332020-10-08T07:36:53.5746251Adelle Farley I really hope this gets approved. 36332020-10-08T13:31:15.14346252alexander HaigThe ban on background music has a detrimental effect for many people in the hospitality sector with minimal benefit to tackling Covid 1936342020-10-08T15:11:19.2146253Louise CookI like the unicorn too, but maybe ditch the chains, not much equality there.36152020-10-08T17:30:27.83346254Stephen blackwood It is important to look after our memorials,our war heroes should never be forgotten for the sacrifice they made for our freedom.35852020-10-10T09:15:50.7646256Gerald Curley No one should be deprived of there loved ones reassurance when they are so poorly. 36332020-10-10T09:30:10.68346257Gerald Curley Poor family must be going out of there mind, this should not be happening. Also, more pressure added to the stressful job the nhs have to work under. 36332020-10-10T12:07:20.7946258Ian VartyGood luck on this.35852020-10-10T12:46:42.71346259Dave CarstairsThe sentence for this despicable action should reflect the public anger.35852020-10-10T17:14:56.29746260Lorna DonaldsonDesecration of War Memorials is disrespectful to the men and women who have laid down their lives for their country and for the freedom that we take for granted every day. I strongly agree that this should be a criminal offence.35852020-10-12T16:25:12.60746261Mrs Rosemary FootTotal lack of respect for those involved in the Wars or maybe understanding of what the world suffered during these dreadful Wars.35852020-10-13T08:17:15.1146262William Fleming My grandfather died in WW1 to save us from tyranny and his memory should never be disrespected by anyone for political points. 35852020-10-13T08:52:07.01746263Barry whiteAnyone caught vandalising war memorials should be charged and fined upto £10,000 and community service to clean memorial themselves. Also part of the community service should be enlisted into a history lesson of what these heroes battled against and defeated for the future generation...35852020-10-13T10:17:04.43346264Eddie BradleyProtect the memorials.35852020-10-13T18:38:43.43746265David BurkeOur war memorials remember those who laid down their lives that we can have a life, we must protect them lest we forget.35852020-10-13T20:36:13.21746266Robert Anderson It's a disgrace that our government needs to b petitioned over this. 35852020-10-13T22:46:27.5846269Robert HowittI grew up in Roslea Drive, Dennistoun, and the people of that area are FAR better than this...Lest We Forget.35852020-10-13T22:53:48.50346270Linda MeikleKeep Scotland's war memorials protected 35852020-10-14T12:45:41.93346271Pamela FlemingWar memorials deserve the same level of legal recognition as graveyards and cemeteries. Many of the soldiers listed on the memorials have no known grave and this is the only way that relatives can be near to them or pay their respects.35852020-10-14T17:28:43.93746273Janette whitelawI think anyone who desecrates or damages a cenotaph or war graves or private burial ground for war vetrans .anyone found committing this act should be treated very seriously as a specific crime and should be given a heavy prison sentance .35852020-10-16T16:23:56.82346274Elaine McDougallGreat petition 35852020-10-16T18:47:04.34346275Alan McLeodAs social beings, we express ourselves most Beautifully through art, most especially music. Our means of understanding each other and caring for each other is made much easier when music entwines itself around our existence. 36342020-10-16T22:21:22.02746276Brian CarsonIt make me sad whether you believe in a cause or not this is to remember those many of which did not have a choice but were conscripted. Well done to the group35852020-10-17T13:10:27.68346277Helen MurrayWe must protect our history35852020-10-17T15:23:34.87346278Graham BarnesI love listening to music (live and recorded) but as someone with hearing difficulties (I need to wear an aid in each ear to understand words said in a conversation) I find that background music in an environment where I need to listen to speech is one of the banes of my life because it is like adding an electronic 'noise' overlay that just confuses the speech.36342020-10-19T22:11:54.18346279Cllr Gordon MackettSigned and best of luck.35852020-10-20T17:00:51.8646280Alice MannMy mother and her brothers fought in world war two these monuments represent all who fought and died in war no matter what colour race are religion and should be preserved to remind all that is how we have freedom of speech Alice Mann 35852020-10-20T17:09:10.21346281Darren ScurfieldDon't think another emblem is needed, there are enough symbols of Scotland as a whole, unicorn, thistle, saltire, lion rampant. \r\nAre you asking us to all unite under the Scottish wildcat or the capercaillie. Beware "follow the gourd! No, follow the sandal!" Seems irrelevant really.\r\n36152020-10-21T11:17:46.14346282Lorna Stewart Clan Stewart of AppinThis is a misguided petition. It will divide people, not unite them. You cant add something new without subtracting importance from the existing. You need to encourage and invigorate Scotland at its core, the proudly unique nation that it is, steeped in brave and fascinating history and at the forefront of inventions past and present, always looking to lead ahead. You need to reinforce national pride, not introduce the idea that our emblems are not good enough. You have to rather revisit and explore the existing emblems, discuss their meanings and use those principles to encourage and empower. The Unicorn represents deep and glorious things. Examine closely with proper research, all the attributes it has represented for people in ancient and indeed present times. There is one attribute of its horn being able to clear muddy waters. Strength, honour and loyalty are at the forefront of its character. Likewise the thistle thrives in harsh conditions and stands out among flora being strong, complex, beautiful and unique, even though its largely seen as a thorny pest. People need strength now, they need to feel like a miracle is possible. You need to be looking at all the ways you can use the existing emblems to restore faith and strength for people and communities. Give them hope and instil the concept of empowerment. I am sure people dont give our emblems deep thought, so promote their qualities and concepts, tell of their beauty and strength and remarkable bearing. Champion them, dont diminish them. What's wrong with mythical legends? It inspires the youth. We should learn from history, the fact we dont is modern downfall. The appearance of the Unicorn has been altered in mass media to sell merchandise, but it always symbolises freedom, strength, courage, mystery, hope and miracles, qualities the thistle shares. These are all good, moral characteristics that inspire trust and confidence, empowering the youth, our future leaders. Focus, dont waste time.36152020-10-21T12:59:45.75346285Sheila McKinnonThe otter or the golden eagle might be possibilities.36152020-10-21T13:07:04.57346286John AngusIt makes me wonder if these vandals are actually part of the human race.35852020-10-21T17:43:57.57346290David SouthWhat a waste of time. Scotland is recognised all over the world by its many iconic symbols - unicorn, lion, thistle, tartan, saltire, Loch Ness monster even. Why on earth should our representatives have to waste time with this?36152020-10-21T18:50:51.14346291Graeme KnoxWell said Lorna Stewart. This is nonsense. Focus on what is important.36152020-10-23T20:01:06.0946294Moira FlemingThis our history, our families, still remembered. There is nothing better that a civilised society can do than revere those who gave there lives for our freedom and democracy.35852020-10-23T21:04:13.75746295Mrs M HayJudicious use of background music within a restaurant should not present a problem, to ban background music is simply tinkering. There are probably higher levels of background noise in places like supermarkets.36342020-10-24T19:40:19.70346296Roberta MurrayIt should be up to each establishment as they know their customer base. It has no effect on Covid 19 ad per any other virus out there around the world36342020-10-25T08:49:36.64346297Lorna ReidEssential to life itself. 36342020-10-25T08:52:06.64346298Lorna ReidEssential to life itself. Live and background music 36342020-10-26T09:24:18.63346299Jim GuyanI oppose this petition. Background music creates nothing but problems to people like myself who are hard of hearing and have two hearing aids. The main problem is that it has ceased to be background music but is set at a level that it is not background music. If we must have this then there must be limits set on what constitutes background music in terms of the volume. 36342020-10-26T17:50:08.1446300David GilmourShould not need a petition to protect these monuments. 35852020-10-28T18:25:03.96746301Erin ClarkVery important cause! Glad this is getting the attention it should. 36462020-10-28T18:33:26.87346302Mary DoonanInvaluable service36452020-10-28T21:53:15.43746303David FosterCAB are needed now more than ever.36452020-10-28T23:15:55.51346304Stuart Allison Please support 36452020-10-28T23:40:56.55746305Prof. Alyson Kettles (Ret.)CAB are an essential public service. Their work needs to be supported and properly funded. 36452020-10-29T08:54:53.93346306Samantha ScholeyPlease understand this disability. It has stopped me reaching my full potential in my career . At age 45 I still cannot move on. Sadly the support isn't there. Please help to change this. 36462020-10-29T17:38:26.84746307Mrs A McDonaldLet's help young people reach there true potential.36462020-10-29T20:03:34.8546308Denise CanningAbsolutely vital this is a recognised disability and the appropriate support is provided to assist everyone who suffers in silence.36462020-10-30T13:19:59.0646310V. ColvinI fully support this petition against corruption in criminalising intentionally misleading child protection procedures. It should also be a crime for professionals to withhold vital evidence refuting any allegations, concerns. Families should be able to request evidence of risk of significant harm in proceedings. Opinions, concerns must be demonstrable and not simply corroboration between professionals when GiRFEC gangs hunt down families. \r\nThese are real people, not simply a stat, no doubt many loving families who have come up against a professional who abuses their position and power. The system needs an overhaul, professionals need professional training as opposed inhouse training on necessity, thresholds for processing information, and GDPR in general, of which there is a serious lack in Scotland. The Supreme Court found that Scottish Child Protection legislation erred, and this also needs reviewed.36662020-10-30T16:30:41.56346311Glennis HigginsI believe that all statues should be left alone. We seems to be pandering to the minority in the U.K. these days with no thought at all about the achievements of those people who had statues selected for a reason! 35852020-10-30T16:33:57.4346312James McGrathThe Chinese cultural revolution didn't bring in a better world. 35852020-10-30T17:34:53.12746313Andrew FraserAs a musician, I think music should only be provided where it is welcome by ALL those in a venue, of whatever type. A ban isn't quite fair, but I am in no hurry to see it lifted, and I do sympathise with Jim Guyan. Causing problems to such as he is just plain bad manners. If people really cannot do without music - there are headphones. 36342020-10-30T20:54:07.8846317Peter Jackson Our history, our statues and monuments must be respected and preserved, not expunged and abandoned.35852020-10-30T23:37:51.96746318Clare ChalmersGirfec Shanarri indicators added to over a decade of unlawful data collection sharing of data at wellbeing levels has allowed practitioners to abuse so many families Often times colluding between organisations to produce red flags with no real substance. There is much evidence to support this has happened time and again leading to false child protection cases being raised. This must be addressed. This must be stopped. It is important those practitioners raising concerns are held responsible for their own actions.\r\nMany practitioners to this day do not appear to realise the difference between wellbeing and welfare nor how to apply the law accordingly. There is much in the system that needs to change and holding practitioners responsible for their actions will be one way of ensuring good and fair practice going forward. 36662020-10-31T00:01:47.2846320Clare ChalmersWe must ensure such safeguards are in place. 36652020-10-31T13:10:00.7546321Louise WelshParents are not believed. Professionals' word is taken without challenge. Evidence seems not to be required. 36652020-11-01T11:41:52.4546322Jim GuyanI fully support this petitionand also am off the opinion that this service should be fully funded by the SG. The support that they provide the community is exceptional and without it many people would be without the benefits they are entitled to claim. They also work alongside other third sector agencies thus ensuring that the needs of the individual are met.36452020-11-01T18:53:00.50746323steve austinname and shame the vandals 35852020-11-04T07:52:59.96746326David Jackprotect our history35852020-11-04T13:16:30.10746327Lesley WilsonOnce again the Scottish Government are forgetting about the detrimental impact this causes to the mother, partner, unborn babies and other family members. The distance in travel, accommodation and the families income in these stressful time.\r\nShame on you.36542020-11-04T14:19:11.5446328Peter ToddSomebody is going to end up getting killed due to the disgraceful situation over maternity in Caithness.36542020-11-04T15:10:20.21346329Val BroadHaving to travel 100 miles, and in some cases a fair bit more, to give birth can be extremely stressful for the mother to be and for the rest of her family. The journey from Caithness down to Raigmore can be particularly stressful in the winter when weather conditions are poor - on occasions the snow gates are closed. Can you imagine how much that adds to the stress for the family? There is a perfectly good hospital in Wick that could be used. Centralisation is great if you live in or near the cities, but for folk who live a distance away it can be a nightmare. I think we deserve better - we pay the same taxes but get a much inferior service.36542020-11-04T17:51:01.79346330Ron GunnI believe that in deciding to centralise maternity services, health boards are not giving enough consideration to the impact of that decision on the perinatal mental health of the mother, partner, unborn babies, other children in the families and the wider community.36542020-11-04T17:51:52.81346331Wendy campbellWe have to travel over100 miles to have our babies, leave our husband, and family, which is not good on our mental health.36542020-11-04T20:13:11.4746332Debbie SimmonsThere used to be an autism practioner and autism groups where I live. The practioner had regular interaction supporting our family, advising school and ran after school autism clubs. Now there is nothing. Schools don't have enough resource to support kids with ASD. Support is only given to those who have complex needs. Families are left unsupported and children are missing out in gaining vital social skills from the Clubs and also reaching their potential through lack of support.36472020-11-04T20:47:35.2146333Lynne DuncanTotally ludicrous that our mother's to be and their babies have to suffer the stresses of this journey.36542020-11-04T22:11:03.1346335S AndersonPlease reinstate the maternity unit so that it can be used to its full potential and stop the need to travel to Inverness, especially now with COVID transmission being an issue. Limit the travel and reduce the risk of exposure. Being away from home and your family to have your baby is not the experience you would wish to have. The staff at CGH were amazing when I had my daughter.36542020-11-05T13:24:32.12346337Shirley SutherlandWe should not be treated like second class citizens, we deserve to have the same services are anywhere else.36542020-11-06T16:12:02.94746340Coral blackwell I would not be allowed to move cattle over hundred miles in labour but its seems ok for a pregnant woman to do it often without family be able to go with her.36542020-11-06T21:30:13.39346341Samantha KerrI am in complete agreement with what this petitioner is asking the Scottish Parliament to consider very seriously, as the repercussions and the paramount wellbeing of the child is given no cognisance, and it is FACT that Police Scotland, Social Work and other agencies including Third Sector and Voluntary Organisations are giving evidence that has been shared unlawfully by Police Scotland iVPD. 36662020-11-06T21:35:34.50346342Samantha KerrThe provision for and awareness of dyscalculia is as in important as dyslexia, and should be mandatory in primary school for any child struggling in this area. 36462020-11-06T23:46:59.64346343Roberta MurrayIts ridiculous in Scotland, that no music allowed, and should go ahead, again. If live participants are not near audience. Background music is not a problem at all. But no dancing to music in small space I agree with. 36342020-11-07T01:21:24.71746344Emmanuel Bique Coercing a person or a child to hate another human being or his parent, is the worst example a parent teach their kids. The worst pathological damage done to the child present and future. 36662020-11-07T12:42:17.1146345Gordon DoullThe current situation is disgraceful and typical of the SNP thumb on Highland Health Board. 36542020-11-07T20:18:46.41746346Paul DeansThis behaviour is absolutely destroying kids lifes country wide. 35792020-11-07T23:12:08.7146347Elizabeth CandelandMy daughter in law took 7 hours to reach the maternity unit 100 miles away at 38 weeks pregnant with twins due to a lorry catching fire and totally blocking the road with no alternative route apart from an extremely long detour on single track roads not acceptable.36542020-11-08T08:13:48.84346348C Walker I believe I have dyscalculia I'm which was never recognised. My sons school teacher suggested that I have it. At 40 it's too late now but hopefully this helps others. 36462020-11-08T09:49:35.9846350Mairead MurrayAny professional who mispresents a child should be held accountable.36662020-11-08T15:05:08.97746351Zoe WoodsDefinitely needed. Professionals need to not think that they can walk around using the legal system as a tool using lies. It peverts real justice. And solicitor's are too scared to go up against them, why?36662020-11-08T21:32:38.65746352Lee FraserI think this is very important as being on the receiving end of false allegations that I was able to prove my ex would have been proven to be in contempt. 36662020-11-08T23:33:00.17346353Samantha KerrIt is essential that professional's working within the field of child protection do not make ill informed arbitrary decision's and when mistakes whether premediated or not accountability is required. \r\n\r\nProfessionals have ethical standards in public life especially when it comes to the paramount wellbeing of Children, and it is routine for many of these professionals to made pre-mediated and prejudged reports and decisions based on false and libellous reports, evidences of deliberate recordings of conversations, statements and reports have been found on their databases and for this they made that choice to act unprofessionally that has serious detriment and harm to innocent individuals and that is wilful criminality. 36662020-11-09T09:04:59.60346354David GreenwoodFully support this36662020-11-09T09:17:52.86746355Jackson ReynoldsThe system will change for the good of all.36662020-11-09T09:49:36.28346356Autumn Robinson As a partner of a father fighting for fair access to his son, I have been on the receiving end of lies told about my character by the mother in court.36662020-11-09T10:18:22.9146357Rachel PyleMy dyscalculia was not diagnosed until my last year of university. Reflecting back on my school and university studies, my dyscalculia had a huge impact on my ability to do certain things, including my exam performance as it impacts on my working memory and ability to retain information. Had I had extra time and support, I know I would have performed better. It has been very helpful to have my diagnosis, even if it did come a bit late, as I now know that my difficulties with maths and my memory are not a reflection on my intelligence or the effort I have put in to learn things but a recognised difficulty that I can use strategies to work around. 36462020-11-10T16:02:15.43746360Robert PyleIt will be even more important in a Post COVID world to ensure our children are given all the support they need to achieve the best they can. I wish I had known about my daughters learning disability much sooner and been able to find the necessary guidance and help to allow her to overcome this. These problems are not insurmountable once an awareness and help is available. 36462020-11-10T18:37:53.57346361William Hunter WatsonI know two women with autistic sons, each of which is quite improperly detained in the State Hospital at Carstairs. In my opinion each should be living with support in the community and no doubt would be if that support existed. The treatment to which each has been subjected in the State Hospital, including the use of chemical restraint, has been inhuman or degrading. Unfortunately the Scottish Government approves the use of chemical restraint even though that is incompatible with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.36472020-11-10T20:07:45.3546362Christina MarshallThe current backlogs and lack of support is a false economy. Additional support is sought while there is no diagnosis.36472020-11-11T10:22:27.6146363Gordon BairdThings are as bad in Galloway where patients in early labour have to make their own way 75 miles to Dumfries. If they are deemed not to be in labour, they are sent 75 miles back to await the onset of contractions. Local midwife services have been cut back. This was not always the case. 36542020-11-11T10:40:00.546364Angela ArmstrongAll rural communities deserve equality. 36542020-11-11T10:48:52.20746365Helen doddsLoss of a first class facility in Stranraer disgusting. 36542020-11-11T15:54:38.1746368Ruth HughesFully support this. I am well aware this happens constantly. There needs to be change. It is a criminal act that can have devastating consequences.\r\n 36662020-11-11T17:53:18.32746370E McEwanWe should have the same facilities as the central belt has.36542020-11-12T13:41:19.2546372D. Barker This is extremely important, as the current system is open to abuse, which I have seen and causes great pain.35792020-11-12T13:48:36.56346375Margaret GibsonSafe guards must be in place for the child. Too often the adult caring for that child is not as they may seem, and the child is not believed or the person with concerns... All to offen incidents are dismissed by professionals. 36652020-11-12T16:34:58.04346376Marie sharpThere is no help for sufferers of autism when they leave school.36472020-11-13T18:38:04.7546377Maurice FrankThe Autism Network Scotland's book An Ordinary Life Too, 2016, a guide document for the autism strategy, evidences the corrupt service practices to avoid and enforce prevention of, and the uncorrupt standards to meet, in delivering this.36472020-11-13T18:43:09.68346378Patricia GreyCits Advice Bureaux service is absolutely essential and saves money as well as lives. 36452020-11-13T19:54:52.8746379Alan McLeodFor years the central-belt centrist narrative has understandably not had the north Highlands on its radar. All of a sudden with lock-down, the north Highlands is a Garden of Eden. Please, please. All we ask is for you to walk a mile (or a 107 or so) in our shoes. 36542020-11-13T20:26:16.9546380Moira MunroMy first thought was that it's up to owners to check out the dog walker's standards. But the dog walker can lie about their maximum dog numbers, and it would be quite hard for an owner to check, short of taking time off work and trailing the dog walker.36752020-11-15T00:22:50.07346381Clive WylieChildren need the love and care of not just one parent. The other parent should not be denied the right of access. 35792020-11-15T17:32:29.29746382JANICE CLARKTOTALLY BEHIND THIS PETITION 100% HAVING EXPERIENCED FIRST HAND THE APPALLING ABUSE OF THE SYSTEM.35792020-11-15T19:23:04.15346384esther maureen mcveyFirst class Advocacy regulation is extremely important. I support the Petition35792020-11-15T20:36:01.67346385Vicky Archer This is something I had never heard of before despite years at school and university! Neither had my friends and family that I've told about it. Clearly there is a need for more awareness and research around dyscalculia. This petition is only a starting block for which further work should be done! 36462020-11-15T22:57:57.74746386Lynne GloverOur maternity services urgently need to meet the needs of remote and rural communities. The continued centralisation of our health services is a backward step for the physical and mental health of our community.36542020-11-15T23:45:41.85746387Angela CousinsI fully support this petition. This is a vital service and even more so now during the pandemic. CAB needs to be supported, so that they in turn can support our most vulnerable Scottish citizens. 36452020-11-16T13:44:21.95346389Bettina BlankeThe one good thing about the lockdown is blessedly quiet pubs and restaurants! I love music, but I want to decide when and where I listen to it, and what. If I want to listen to music, I go to a concert. When I'm eating or having a drink with friends, I want to be able to talk. Otherwise I might as well do my drinking at home.36342020-11-16T14:04:09.00346390Grace Wilson I would like to state that I am opposed to ending the ban on background music in pubs and restaurants. As someone with a moderate hearing disability, I have found the lack of background music during the pandemic an absolute godsend. It has been one of the few positive things to come out of these hard times. Previously, background music has meant that I find it very difficult to participate fully in conversations and there is a tendency to become isolated and opt out of social situations. If music has to be reintroduced, I would plead for hospitality venues to provide music free areas or at least for a reduction in the level of noise. After all, people like myself are paying customers and should not be discriminated against. 36342020-11-16T14:04:37.9946391Barry SmithWe should have a working maternity unit in caithness General. 36542020-11-16T14:17:39.66346392Dorothy LewisThe ban on background music in restaurants and bars during the pandemic has actually been very welcome to a large number of us. Enforced background music is intolerable to many people with a huge range of, often hidden, health problems. People with autism, hyperacusis, ME, tinnitus, impaired vision, brain injuries, etc., find that non stop music in public places makes their lives a misery. People with hearing loss, about 1 in 5 of the population, over 70 per cent of the over-70s, struggle to hear others talk in noisy bars and restaurants. If venues do bring back music, please could they try to provide quiet areas where background music is not played. They managed to provide non smoking areas before smoking was banned completely in public places, so surely non music areas are feasible, too. Otherwise we will return to the situation which existed before the ban on background music, where many people with hidden disabilities were reluctant to venture into noisy venues and risked becoming more isolated as a result.36342020-11-16T14:30:36.3246393Grace Wilson As someone with a moderate hearing loss I am opposed to lifting the ban on background music in hospitality venues. The lack of this extra noise has been an absolute godsend and one of the few positive things to come from the virus. For someone like myself, background music means that conversation is a huge struggle and I often give up in despair. This is one of the reasons why hearing impaired people become socially isolated and prone to depression. As a paying customer, surely my needs are as important as everyone else? If background music has to be reintroduced, I would plead for venues to provide music free zones or, at the very least, to reduce the volume of the music to a low level. 36342020-11-16T15:02:36.77346394Anne WellmanI am in favour of keeping the silence, please. Many people with hearing and sensory problems suffer great distress from background music.36342020-11-16T16:41:36.27746395Connie ReaderI oppose this petition. One of the few good things about the lockdown restrictions is that I can go into a pub or cafe (when they are allowed to open), and enjoy a quiet drink or a meal, or a chat with my friends, without having someone else's choice of music forced upon me.\r\n\r\nDon't get me wrong. I like music as much as the next person. In the same way, I like good food. But I don't want it to be forced down my throat everywhere I go.36342020-11-16T16:56:54.82346396M RamageI oppose the petition and strongly feel that loud background music should not be permitted in enclosed spaces. If you need to shout then it is too loud. I find it intrusive and it spoils my experience of restaurants, cafes etc. so much so that I will leave a shop or restaurant where loud music is playing, thereby depriving the business of income they would otherwise have had. I know of many people who feel the same, regardless of whether or not they have underlying health issues.36342020-11-16T17:30:11.65746398Heather Murray So important for the lives of children. 35792020-11-16T23:57:43.55746399penny mckeeI oppose this petition as I find 'background music' most irritating in cafes and restaurants, as I come to socialise and do not like shouting or straining to hear my companions speak. Glad it has been stopped because of epidemic. Music is often too noisy and intrusive. MOST young managers and waiters reluctant to turn it down but I am the customer.36342020-11-17T07:47:39.76346400Susan Foubister This is so important, I hope this gets the attention it rightfully deserves and changes are put in place to protect all victims. Thinking of the children first but also the many parents, families and friends that are suffering daily.35792020-11-17T10:18:44.69346401Drew Campbell LeithamOur son had help at school, but on leaving there was no continuity for support. 36472020-11-17T10:22:08.1846403Patricia SweeneyThe PIP treatment of those adults with autism and those who care for them is a disgrace, this has really evident during the pandemic.36472020-11-17T10:28:54.63346404Lorna aitchusonMy son had ASD and we have struggled to access support for him because he doesnt have a learning disability, he is socially isolated, hardly comes out of his room, left school at 16 but had been a school refuser since 14, so asdistance from school social worker, its very frustrating36472020-11-17T10:29:44.9346405Nina MegaI received good support at CAHMS but was dropped like a brick upon turning 18. Support for adult autistics in this country is effectively non-existent (except for small local charities such as Number 6)36472020-11-17T10:44:07.55746408Irene BirtwhistleThere is no support for autistic people in many parts of the country. The common phrase is "oh, it is part of the autism" and sent away again with no help. Most of the professional do not even understand autism.36472020-11-17T10:50:15.47346409Lynne MacLennan With funding being cut to Pupil Support in schools, it is often the case that young people do not receive the support they need. They should be more involved in the decisions that affect their lives and parents should be listened to instead of blamed and patronised by so called professionals. Quite often they do not know what is best for that young person and have actually caused trauma. From personal experience as a parent and Pupil Support.\r\nFirst step outlaw restraint and seclusion. It has no place in a supportive education system. These are children with communication issues, restraints regarding barbaric.36472020-11-17T10:50:24.69746410Brenda mccormick Diagnosis should be made as soon as possible and not left for years to be diagnosed. 36472020-11-17T10:50:52.96346411Marcello MegaTrying to shoehorn autistic children into mainstream education without adequate additional support is a disaster repeated every day in most schools, often leading to isolation, restraint and general abuse of children who deserve the right to thrive.36472020-11-17T10:59:56.93346412Angela Weddell I have a Daughter who is Autistic, she struggles at school and receives no help. She has enough to be contending with without being left behind due to lack of access to resources vital to her. When she leaves school, it's going to be the same thing over again. 36472020-11-17T11:22:49.0146414Yvonne CampbellWorthy and much needed.36472020-11-17T11:33:58.15346415Calum BroughI was only diagnosed aged 26, after graduating uni. Even then, with years of depression and anxiety disorders, it was only really after a meltdown in a meeting with a community support nurse followed by a formal complaint that my request for diagnosis was taken seriously. After, accessing autism support in South Ayrshire, I was told that they didn't really know what to do to help me, they had no experience in finding work for autistic people with graduate degrees, and I had already used up all five years of govt funding for university courses (which was their only other suggestion). Even allowing for autism, I still test as having "severe" depression, but there has been no further support in the last few years. I have a very relevant immunology and microbiology degree, but have never secured any employment in the field.36472020-11-17T12:12:22.58346416Tracey dicksPeople with autism need help not just in school but in adult hood also. 36472020-11-17T12:23:07.6646417Raymond Coyle There is next to nothing for support.\r\nPlease rectify this immediately. 36472020-11-17T12:27:02.72746418Fiona ConnorMy 6yo waiting 4 years for a diagnosis never mind support. It would have been more but luckily a family member helped us to go private. It's disgusting the lack of funding & supports available in Scotland. You want every child to go to a mainstream school and yet you have no supports in place. More understanding and recognition of PDA is needed too. My child wanted to kill herself at 5 years old (-due a lot to her first school) and no one helped us.36472020-11-17T13:15:25.8646419Joanne JacksonMore investment and staff are needed to support young people on the autistic spectrum. 36472020-11-17T13:17:54.70346420Donnie MacaulayThe lack of support for autistic young people transitioning to adulthood requires immediate attention.36472020-11-17T13:47:27.6646421Lorraine Currier I have a 13 year old with autism and learning difficulties. WE NEED SUPPORT.36472020-11-17T14:08:12.83346422Fiona FraserDue to Tory Austerity our education and social care systems have sustained brutal cuts. This is having a detrimental effect on those on the autistic spectrum. More needs to be done to offer the support desperately needed. 36472020-11-17T14:32:43.50746423Katy ReedMore support is needed now for families, the lack of support for children and adults is a disgrace!36472020-11-17T15:40:53.37346424Paula BarkerI support this petition.36472020-11-17T16:04:32.61346425alice couperWe need this urgently. 36472020-11-17T16:05:03.01746426Linda LevackIt is so so wrong to be transporting pregnant women, sometimes in labour over 100 miles to Raigmore Hospital. It is illegal to move our pregnant animals, within 10 day of due date so why for humans?36542020-11-17T17:53:37.5746427Shirley RossMy son is 13 and has been diagnosed with High function austism and hyperacusis. I don't receive any extra monies for him as he can function normally but his weakness comes from his triggers, sounds and smells. He takes thing literally so doesn't understand sarcasm, which leads to constant bullying from other children. I have concerns with his social skills as he gets older. I struggle now getting help to enable him to progress and be a fully functioning adult. He will always be vulnerable, in a world where autism is understood more it still has a long way to go to accept everyone as they are and not how they are supposed to be. 36472020-11-17T17:59:04.946428Lorraine ThomsonYears of waiting to have a diagnosis and a specific Autism Team would help reduce this for other families and also give positive structure for families and individuals who fall under the Autism umbrella. CAHMS do a marvellous job, but are overwhelmed. This grey area needs clarification within the Acts mentioned in the Petition History as too many children and adults have very little ongoing support networks or points of official contact in times of need.36472020-11-17T18:32:08.46346429Lorraine GilliesThere are huge correlations between autism and eating disorders. Its essential support understands this.36472020-11-17T18:43:56.98346430Ellen ForsythI support anything that will help people with autism.36472020-11-17T18:51:13.45346431Robert Anderson Social care in a whole require more financial support, packages have to be increased and more person centered not service centered, I believe that the majority of the big players exploit this and don't provide an adequate service,, I've worked in social care for 40 years, not now, you also have to stop funding agencies and get staff that are focused, well paid and supported with good training, staff that are valued can only value what they do x36472020-11-17T19:04:20.79746432alice couperWe desperately need this service. 36472020-11-17T19:08:16.92746433Catherine CarneyThere must be more support for our autistic community, sadly which is severely lacking in every way.36472020-11-17T19:17:42.7446434Patricia FergusonFantastic for Autistic kids to get this support.36472020-11-17T21:11:50.0246435Alexis McMillan We need to get proper support in place. 36472020-11-17T22:36:29.26346436Patricia morris I support this petition. 36472020-11-17T22:38:17.87346437John H. FergusonMany years ago I had reason to use the services of the Citizens Advice Bureaux. The help I received was excellent, for which I was very grateful. With the present state of affairs in this country due to the coronavirus, any reduction in the services of the C.A.B. is unacceptable and should be resisted. I would urge the Scottish Government to do all they can to assist this valuable service and provide funding which is so urgently required.36452020-11-17T23:17:12.53346438Heather MurrayMy grandson has just been diagnosed with Autism. Beautiful wee boy, but hard work, support is needed for all these children and their parents.36472020-11-18T00:01:33.9946439Miss Campbell People with autism don't seem to have much outside support.36472020-11-18T07:35:36.58346441Wilma De AthThis is badly needed. There is absolutely no support for these young people after they leave school. This leads to isolation & loneliness for them, more so since Covid 19. 36472020-11-18T07:41:52.18746442Malissa pierottiThere is little to no support for anyone diagnosed with ASD as an adult, especially if they also don't have an additional learning disability or mental health issue. It's very much a case of "yes you have autism, now off you pop"36472020-11-18T08:34:50.75746443Neve StewartThis is an amazing petition! 36472020-11-18T08:38:23.246444Iona MacleanSigned36472020-11-18T08:56:00.40746445Jacqueline Morison My Daughter has Autism age 25 and has had no support from age 18. 36472020-11-18T10:30:22.86746446Ian mckeeDisagree with this petition. Canned music spoils many social occasions and is particularly disagreeable in hospitals. It tends to be chosen by young members of staff who have often different tastes in music from their elder customers.36342020-11-18T12:06:16.97346447Christine MurdochCitizens Advice Bureaux serve all Scottish people and are of vital importance to the most disadvantaged.\r\n\r\nDo you agree that they should be funded to ensure people can get the help and support that they need?36452020-11-18T14:42:36.36346448Helen RowlesOffering Quiet hours might help for those who like socialising but cannot manage the music for varied reasons. 36342020-11-18T15:14:19.89746449Rachel LumbThere is a lack of support for adults and young People with autism when looking for employment. 36472020-11-18T15:21:15.49746450Deborah greenanThere needs to be more help and awareness in autism for teenagers sitting exams and getting ready for further education and work. 36472020-11-18T18:09:04.00346451Lynn Pattersonelliott Autism needs to be addressed at a young age there should be a national autism test for the young to stop people falling through the cracks in older age.36472020-11-18T22:12:24.69346453Julie NelsonIn our experience Autistic people have to be in crisis before support is provided. Also, diagnosis with CAMHS takes years. 36472020-11-19T09:56:49.5846454Susan JamesDedicated support is essential for people who live with Autism and for their families.36472020-11-19T10:52:44.2246455George Frederick WinterThe ban on background music should NOT be lifted. Having someone else's choice of music blaring in a cafe or restaurant subtracts from the natural atmosphere generated by conversation and laughter. In pubs and clubs managers want loud music because it prevents people from talking and encourages them to drink more.36342020-11-19T12:25:51.65746458Jim FarquharsonAs someone who had to make use of CAB services recently, it is a valuable service and should be fully funded by the Scottish Government.36452020-11-19T20:15:54.94746459Salifu JoofIt's frustrating for parents whose cases are hard without accountability and transparency. 35792020-11-19T20:22:04.16746460Lee davisThis is so important. I'm going through court for the past two years. It's no longer about my son but my ex partner accusing me of everything. 35792020-11-20T02:29:10.446461Francesco BrunelliThe task of the public institutions,in a democratic nation, is to remove the obstacles of an economic and social nature which, by de facto limiting freedom and equality, prevent the full development of the human person and the effective participation of all workers in the political, economic and social organisation of the nation36452020-11-20T11:18:12.9146462Robert CadmanChildren need the love and support from both parents. 35792020-11-20T13:35:40.1846463Maria Martinez I worked as an autistic specialist for 6 years. How we perceive autism is flawed. I believe we are witnessing evolution in action and as d uh ch society needs to create spaces that are specifically designed to allow for the full spectrum of autistic expression and experience. We need to stop perceiving autism as a mess than us disease and more as an evolutionary jump for which the future of society needs to cater for rather than attempt to kill through genetic identification and elimination.36472020-11-20T15:38:34.8346464Rachel MccannAgree36472020-11-21T15:19:59.28346465Isabel HarrisWe should not have to travel 110 miles too give birth!\r\n36542020-11-21T18:50:57.33746467Sandra Thomson No unlimited number of dogs on a walk can be dangerous. \r\nYour dog would be receiving more attention in a smaller group.36752020-11-22T11:43:10.76346468Kim BallantineWe as families do not want anyone to do the work for us, we require dedicated support for our autistic children to enable us all to enjoy life to the best of our abilities and avoid crisis points which in the end costs more!36472020-11-23T00:56:54.3146469Annette Sutherland Our area is crying out for babies to be born here, mums & their families shouldn't have to go to Inverness to give birth when we have a purpose built unit waiting to be used here!36542020-11-23T10:03:32.78746470Ruan PeatI was lucky enough to have my children in the local hospital, which allowed my husband to be there and friends to visit and support me. I have no idea how much harder it would be if I had been in Inverness! it is too far and dangerous as well as anti social.36542020-11-23T16:15:41.5246471Sue DillonThis is essential for people with autism. They need the support and they are being let down badly. 36472020-11-23T17:14:20.54746472Jeanette NunnerySupport for people with Autism need to be supported from cradle to grave... 36472020-11-23T18:48:21.7646473Anne ShearerAny help will be so appreciated there is never enough to know especially for Grandparents. \r\n36472020-11-24T13:48:32.53746475Helen Fletcher I petition this.36472020-11-25T08:37:38.4946477Jeffrey Allen Support the people who have autism please. 36472020-11-25T09:08:55.08746479Gillian StrachanThe lack of understanding and professional support is damaging to mental health and leaves many families with little or no income to support their children as have to give up good jobs. Little support in schools and health sectors if or when diagnosis is given. We need the energy to support our families not to battle basic human rights. 36472020-11-25T14:39:08.61746481David HamburghAll people and organisations with responsibility for vulnerable people should be governed, assessed and reviewed to, at the very least, the same degree of any public body. Particularly when the implications are life-changing for families. Scrutiny should not be feared, but seen as a badge of authenticity of intention.35792020-11-25T19:30:55.33346483Gary NicholsonWhole system is a shambles, closed family courts and family law solicitors make money by splitting up families, putting in place unequal arrangements as default to make people come back to court. The government makes money financially rewarding one parent for stopping or limiting another's access to their own children. Preventing parental equality, harming society but biggest harm is child victims who are losing parents.35792020-11-25T20:19:55.1946484arshad ali Parental alienation should be class as child abuse.35792020-11-25T20:44:31.9646485Adam BartonI have been in and out of Family Court in Inverness for almost 5yrs. I have faced every malicious false accusation imaginable. Proven beyond all doubt that these are malicious. Yet I (and my entire family) went 11months without seeing my two beautiful daughters. Now we get 5 weeks per year only. Court orders are repeatedly flouted by my ex. We have done nothing wrong and the children desperately want to spend time with us. Does anyone care? Ans. NO! 35792020-11-25T21:34:03.0646486Ian REEDChildren need Mothers and Fathers.35792020-11-25T22:45:01.70346488Kirsty ElliottDoing this for a dear friend who through no fault of his own has been denied access to his beloved children and they to him too. 35792020-11-25T22:49:36.64346489Douglas cormackI support this petition 110%.35792020-11-26T01:12:12.29346490Elizabeth YoungsonI have used the cab find them very helpful, we need this to be kept opened and should be funded.36452020-11-26T07:49:17.25346491Rachel McMenemyI had to make use of CAB a few years back now but I do not know what I would have done without them. This service should be fully funded by government. 36452020-11-26T14:09:32.43746493Jennifer Greenhorn This is 100% needed in Scotland. 36912020-11-26T14:21:39.27746494Jacqueline GreenhornThis is definitely required in Scotland. 36912020-11-26T15:14:24.53346495Jennifer GreenhornMy grandfather died in 2017 needlessly at the hands of the NHS. \r\n\r\n10 other familes have since become known to me who have also lost their loved ones needlessly due to negligence in the NHS. All cases were from the same Unit within the same hospital. The most recent was in January 2020. \r\nThis makes it fact that despite my complaint logged and external reviews by Health Improvements Scotland and 3 other NHS boards has made no improvement whatsoever therefor it is fact that an external regulatory body is required.36912020-11-26T15:41:54.85746496Courtney HendryThis is important and I agree. 36472020-11-26T16:52:24.3146498Barry DonnanTime for an urgent national debate on this issue. 36982020-11-26T17:24:21.6946499Paul Wilson We need the CAB offices where else are people going to get free advice? Also Why is Scotland not a option? I detest having to put the UK.36452020-11-26T18:39:08.54346500Marti Morrison This issue needs addressed. 36982020-11-26T21:19:37.5546503Charles ClarkBring Scottish law up to date \r\n(a patriot) \r\n36982020-11-27T08:25:39.67746504Andrew FraserThis is the wrong approach. Neither A82, nor the A9 (in particular) are high-risk roads. Surely, the petitioners were told that...36932020-11-27T10:23:59.0646505Mhairi Matheson CAB has given a lifeline to many, otherwise despairing of solving their problem.36452020-11-27T10:37:21.91746506James A MackieThe Petitioner is correct. However, this is not a problem peculiar to the NHS but to all public sector organisations. Public sector bodies all investigate themselves with every incentive to produce a cover up and no action. Situation gets worse when multiple agencies involved. They then pass the buck and the complaints get buried. SPSO take years to investigate complaints and they do not have the powers to force a re investigation when they find faults. SSSC again take years to investigate complaints and by their own admission by an FOI stated that they take no action in 99.7% of complaints from the public.36912020-11-27T12:44:25.26746507David Moir They are a lot safer than Tesco and Uber. 36952020-11-27T13:10:35.5146509Richard DraycottI have visited two snooker halls regularly during the pandemic and both have met the very highest standards of hygiene. Snooker halls are not exessively busy venues with rules on player numbers being easily adhered to and easy to enforce. These businesses will fail unless they are made exempt from closure.36952020-11-27T13:13:55.40346510David JohnstonProbably the safest sport out there to play considering you can be 12ft plus away.36952020-11-27T13:26:22.04346511Mike Keddie As a venue owner we had a number of vulnerable people who used our facilities. The visits were both with carers and in groups.36952020-11-27T14:19:28.2846513Mr kasim Yuce Snooker clubs should be allowed to open or support provide to tide them through this period. 36952020-11-27T14:19:50.45346514Tony Thompson Agree with all comments below. 36952020-11-27T14:51:27.35346515Jim ReillyOwners of these clubs provide a lifeline to many. I myself suffer from mental health issues and playing snooker once a week helped me maintain some degree of self worth, I haven't been able to play now for 2 months. This is affecting a lot of my life including my work life balance and my personal relationship. These owners have spent £1000's of pounds getting the club's safe only to be told to close again. I'm more at risk from covid on public transport and in the supermarkets. I cannot agree with your decision to close these venues on a risk basis. As a voter, my decision on whom to vote at the next election, this will be decided on the outcome of this petition. 36952020-11-27T15:02:50.4946516banaras mahmoodTime 2 let all the venues open with safety measures in place.36952020-11-27T15:14:54.346517Peter Raeburn Open up snooker halls. 36952020-11-27T15:43:56.83746519Neil mcgregorNeed pool back. 36952020-11-27T15:59:37.0446520Jennifer Greenhorn100% needed from my own experience over the past 3 years and that of other familes.36912020-11-27T16:00:31.27746521Ross McCulloch For all the common sense reasons explained in this petition please get our snooker halls back open ASAP.36952020-11-27T16:07:53.5946522Hugh Duffy Please allow the snooker clubs to open, there are more social distancing in them than visiting your local shop. 36952020-11-27T16:14:48.8146523Jamie mcglinchey U can so easily social distance in a snooker hall no problem unlike the schools that's spreading it. 36952020-11-27T16:18:29.63746524John RamsayPool and snooker venues are far safer than pubs and restaurants with the constant cleaning in place also get them open its effecting my mental health.36952020-11-27T16:19:57.146525Andy patersonIf you can go to a supermarket you surely can play snooker or pool. Common sense36952020-11-27T16:49:16.52746527Sean BoxallPlease consider opening of snooker and pool halls across Scotland.36952020-11-27T16:51:27.79746528Lori Bori Allow young people like my nephew to play snooker and have some enjoyment and feel good and connected. 36952020-11-27T16:51:44.9846529Sean BoxallPlease consider opening snooker and pool halls across Scotland.36952020-11-27T16:53:35.99346530Jackie RamsayI would like the pool and snooker club to open as all off the time I have been there the cleaning and all the restrictions that was put in this club in particular was second to none a lot cleaner than some pubs I have visited. It just a shame as you speak about people's mental health these places help to to get away from everything and play a few games help.36952020-11-27T17:03:19.86346532Steven wattI honestly think snooker and pool halls should be allowed to open. 36952020-11-27T17:04:50.5246533Paul Begg The upmost care and attention has been taken by Legends Aberdeen to make sure players have a safe environment to play. \r\nThis club is a social hub for the Aberdeen pool community of all ages, and is sorely missed.36952020-11-27T17:27:34.3246534James AndersonOur pool hall at the Fraserburgh leisure centre operated very safely before the tier system came into force, we see no reason why we can't operate safely as its a non contact sport With all the safety measures in place!36952020-11-27T17:27:55.67746535James AndersonOur pool hall at the Fraserburgh leisure centre operated very safely before the tier system came into force, we see no reason why we can't operate safely as its a non contact sport With all the safety measures in place!36952020-11-27T17:32:14.3546536Kevin O'KeefeIts vital that we dont loose recreational facilities or it will add to the health problems on the rise in the UK, people can take safety measures regarding use of PPE and sanitising hands and equipment until no longer necessary.36952020-11-27T17:43:56.9746537Carolann OharaI would like to see snooker halls open as we have a disability team and it is just as safe if safer than gyms and swimming. 36952020-11-27T18:00:37.45746539Carly Maclachlan Please give snooker and pool halls a chance to thrive again. 36952020-11-27T18:14:01.37346540Michael adams Absolute joke closing pool halls when swimming pools and leisure is still open let us play pool for god sake. 36952020-11-27T18:38:16.02346541Abbie BirniePool halls are a essential part of peoples lives and the owners are fully aware of the safety measures required.36952020-11-27T19:36:08.68346545Angela Armstrong Patients should not have to travel long distances to receive maternity services. It puts unacceptable strain on family and mothers.36542020-11-27T20:03:03.96746546Graham Smith As a table fitter for CAMELOT Q SPORTS, it's imperative snooker club's pool halls, and another venue that accommodates any kind of cue sports such be allowed to say open, all precautionary measures are in place and strict rules are enforced, these club's are safe than walking down the streets or going into supermarkets and shops. 36952020-11-27T20:46:14.31746547Mark Albiston Yes36952020-11-27T20:59:08.53746548Christopher haddenYes I believe snooker and pool venues are safe like restaurants and gyms and is a fantastic way to get everybody out socialising again and get some normality back.36952020-11-27T20:59:43.81746549Grant Wilson United Kingdom should be the 5th country listed in the drop down list. 36952020-11-27T20:59:55.64746550Michael woods Keep snooker halls open for peoples mental health, very low risk. 36952020-11-27T22:12:44.87746551Mike Keddie As a venue owner, we had a number of vulnerable people who used our facilities, both with a carer and as part of a group. 36952020-11-27T22:30:59.84346552Rab creeEnough is enough time we were back.36952020-11-27T23:01:13.2746553Steven bonnar2021 pool.36952020-11-27T23:05:09.7946554Alan Stevenson Snooker tables have 2 people playing 99% of the time which is 14 to 15 feet away from each other pool at least 8 to 10 feet with 2 at the table Much safer than pubs.36952020-11-27T23:10:11.17746555Sam McKay I want all snooker clubs to open.36952020-11-28T08:11:20.91746556Jim Berrington Atrocities 36982020-11-28T08:59:42.29346557Malcolm Gibson Please open the snooker clubs 36952020-11-28T09:32:00.4746559Mark mackinnonOpen legends 36952020-11-28T09:39:18.73746561Alan harmanThey are doing everything they have been ask to do so let the snooker clubs open again.36952020-11-28T11:27:37.4946562Cameron Taylor Snooker and pool halls should be open to support people struggling at these difficult times. I, myself have mental health problems and simply playing a game of snooker with my mate once or twice a week for an hour, boosts my mood, allows me to destress and take my mind of problems I have. 36952020-11-28T12:00:48.9846563Donna murrellSocial distancing and sanatization is a higher standard than the shops that are open we have went above the standard requirements in order to open but we are still being made to close. 36952020-11-28T13:18:25.4946564John Nicholas PaulWe are being too cavalier with businesses and livelihoods. The intentions appear to be good but it is being managed terribly. The treatment is unfair.36952020-11-28T14:30:54.93346565A Tanner To think that this is a place you can really socially distance and have cafeterias etc open is just so unfair. Alit of people need facilities like this for their Mental Health. 36952020-11-28T14:32:19.79346566Garry TigheControls are in place.36952020-11-28T19:40:57.02346568Kevin KeanSnooker pool halls have everything in place and have done since the start of this pandemic, I have seen a lot of other businesses that leave a lot to be desired, you can cram people into supermarkets but not allow a few people into snooker halls with all government stipulations in place....utter madness, people rely on halls for the good off their mental health, meeting, playing, conversing, do the right thing and allow opening please?36952020-11-28T21:05:14.25346569Cheryl GardinerAny more than 3 or 4 dogs is far too much for anyone to look after. I am a dog walker I mainly do solo walks and feel myself and the dog that I am walking at the time enjoys it a lot better as it's one to one, they have all my attention.36752020-11-29T02:16:42.25746570John Barrowman Indoor venues show more control than other venues already allowed to open. 36952020-11-29T08:38:01.4246571Marian PairmanAll dog walkers should only be allowed to walk no more than 2 dogs at a time and if in local parks etc keep dogs on a lead.36752020-11-29T11:36:42.68746572Christopher McelroyThese places need to be saved.36952020-11-29T12:04:00.32746573Allan duffy As a coach at one of the junior snooker academies, I know from speaking to the parents that these kids in our area are desperate to get back on the baize \r\nI believe we can do this safely. 36952020-11-29T13:37:02.46346574Douglas RossIts got to be the easiest thing to sort out lets get going. 36952020-11-29T14:15:09.05346575Mary TaitThese facilities are extremely important to men and women of all ages especially at this time!36952020-11-29T16:24:10.97346576Jonathan Gould Sign sign sign. 36472020-11-29T16:51:23.7146577James RushforthSnooker is social distance.36952020-11-29T16:59:09.91746578Dee Suckling They should get all the support they 336472020-11-29T17:50:21.95746579Katrina spiers Much more support is needed.36472020-11-29T20:48:19.74746581Gavin HoulistonYes - this nonsense needs to end. Department of Health and Social Care couldn't even provide evidence of the "virus" isolation. Get this country back up and running and let the politicians play their games elsewhere - like in a back room in prison.36952020-11-29T21:53:21.40746582Paige gould I hope this is helps and that people with autism get the help to achieve their goals and get the support they need. 36472020-11-29T21:53:50.51746583Mike LeslieAbsolute shocking decision from the government. 36952020-11-30T10:56:00.76746584Wendy CookDone 36472020-11-30T15:44:14.67346585G Ballantyne Please create a power of balance. This is lacking in most non statutory as it is lacking in most statutory compartment systems. The bottom is just reflecting the top with failing institutions in a place we used to call Scotland. Which was in the past an emblem of standard and virtue.35792020-11-30T15:49:01.5546586G BallantyneAnother example of dark pool unfair institutionally broken Scotland, without virtue and basic human rights.35792020-11-30T15:56:53.53746588G BallantyneA ward line to the police should be installed with phased ward records. NHS is compartmentalised in closed door human abuse without an external watchdog. Even the police ignore allegations blatant harm and death.36912020-12-01T01:02:05.03346590Mr G A WoodPool and snooker can be played quite safely, with minimal chance of spreading a virus, it's crazy that snooker halls can't remain open!!!36952020-12-01T06:08:00.07346591Lynne brownOpen all venues.36952020-12-01T10:09:26.1446592Eilidh Marshall The snooker bars are as safe as gyms, pubs and restaurants. 36952020-12-01T10:52:03.91746593Steven wilsonWe need to get out to or pool and snooker. 36952020-12-01T15:18:13.3746596Noel Kennedy Done36952020-12-01T15:22:59.47746597George FaganOpen up clubs.36952020-12-01T16:02:43.9246598Steven johnston Open them up.36952020-12-01T16:47:09.30746599Christopher hughes If a pub that sells food can open so should a pool and snooker hall. 36952020-12-01T17:45:48.40346600Ronnie flanaganDone 36952020-12-01T19:05:40.2346601Ellen reillyI agree snooker halls should be allowed open.36952020-12-01T19:14:24.79346602Martin Toal With the social distancing between tables and also the strict covid rules I believe that snooker and pool halls are a safe establishment.36952020-12-01T19:15:56.37346603Glen cooke Please come on let some folk enjoy there lives a little. 36952020-12-01T22:42:23.9846604Regan Boyle Please open pool venues. 36952020-12-02T13:13:14.63346607Andrew JonesA fair and balanced approach to understanding the legal aspects of age and acceptability to criminal responsibility. 36982020-12-02T13:38:20.27746608Jacqueline mclnnes Please open the snooker hall's and gyms Thanks 36952020-12-02T14:01:28.2846609Frances Ford Safer than lots of other venues. 36952020-12-02T14:55:35.7146610John Waterston We need the freedom.36952020-12-03T09:29:04.99346611Steven mceachran I think its disgraceful that snooker clubs are not allowed to open they are large enough in size to social distance in and they can put measures in place too keep people safe in these clubs. It is also a haven for some people to get out and about to meet their old friends that they have been going too the snooker clubs for years with.36952020-12-04T07:39:58.6946612Matthew Mcghie Please open snooker and pool\r\nHalls36952020-12-04T20:28:20.2846613Caroline KenneilSadly, history show that no industry sector is capable of satisfactory self regulatory conduct. \r\nThe public as well as every industry, including the Health sector, is automatically better served when scrutiny is wholly independent, proved to be independent and seen to be impartial as this removes temptation to corruption and or unfit conduct and service. \r\nThe Regulators have failed the global Public in most Industry sectors, which is why the world is currently so corrupted, and the economy broken well prior to Covid 19, \r\nOur NHS is generally one of the world's success stories. Let us help to protect it by voting for outside scrutiny to retain high standards. 36912020-12-04T22:01:47.46346614Caroline KenneilI believe that the Civil Law Legal System is unfit for purpose. Poor people cannot afford Lawyers. Access to a court or a judge is not necessarily the same as Access to Justice.\r\n\r\nJudges of the Inner House fully agree that the Civil Law is wholly unfit for purpose.\r\nIn Court on 20 April 2018, after consulting with two other judges, Lady Paton suggested to the participants that they return to the Parliaments and to MSPs to ask for "Root and Branch changes to the Legal System..... Civil Law". The judge said in this hearing: "Judges are Drowning in Procedures" and their "hands are tied". How much more so citizens with out legal help, surrounded by skilled adverseries who, I believe, are interested in Winning, money, but not interested in Justice.\r\n'Root and Branch' means the whole tree of the law needs changing.\r\n36452020-12-05T03:58:05.20746615Barry GaleI believe that all evidence in child protection proceedings should be given on oath, so that criminal proceedings can be brought if an offence is detected. \r\n\r\nPE01786 was a similar petition complaining about lack of prosecutions for the making of false or misleading statements in proceedings under the Mental Health Act. Evidence in those proceedings is also not given on oath. The petition was closed without this issue being acknowledged as a problem which causes disastrous outcomes for some patients. No action was recommended to tackle the issue. 36662020-12-05T05:18:06.3446616Andrew MuirThey tried to take our child off us - based on lies.36662020-12-06T18:43:54.80346617Peter FeeneyI think due to all forms of pool and snooker being on tables that are atleast 6x4 feet and standing on either side of the table to your opponent ensures social distancing it is Alot safer than most people will be even in their own homes this Christmas. Cues and tables can be sanitised very easily as well. These types of games are usually played in quiet rooms as well which prevents the risk of transferring the virus by shouting. There are many reasons why this game is safe and even healthy during covid times but these are just a few.\r\n\r\nI think it is a good option for people to enjoy rather than breaking covid guidelines and meeting people in other households.\r\n\r\nPlease allow us to enjoy our sport once again.36952020-12-07T11:01:14.3746618Brian Spence Worst road in the UK, probably never fix it because traffic couters are used in December giving false figures of how busy the road is.36932020-12-07T11:36:03.60346619William James MacLeodThe A82 is not fit for purpose and has been neglected while other projects get money thrown at them i.e. the A9.36932020-12-07T11:37:19.68746620Anna GrahamAs one of the busiest roads in Scotland it need upgrading now. 36932020-12-07T12:44:56.56746621Rachel CorriganUrgent attention is needed to improve the safety of the A82. 36932020-12-07T12:54:22.67746622Gillian stansfieldNeeds upgrading in most parts.36932020-12-07T13:59:04.3946623Eilidh EdgarWe live in hope. Upgrade urgently needed.36932020-12-07T14:21:00.7546624Stuart Murray Decades overdue, absolutely lethal, strangling all our economies, slow and increasing un relable. 36932020-12-07T14:26:44.7246625Susan beckDefinitely these roads need done ASAP. 36932020-12-07T14:26:45.51746626Mark LinfieldCommunities along this vital road have been campaigning for improvements for many years.36932020-12-07T14:53:30.11746629Ewen OliverPlease debate the A82 as the road urgently needs to be upgraded. It is the main artery from the South to the Highlands. Too many fatal accidents on such a main road. 36932020-12-07T15:18:57.88346630Andy Donaldson The A82 has for too long been sidelined for central belt A9 and A96 concerns despite a litany of broken promises and platitudes aplenty a lot of heartache and grief lies at the door of transport Scotland and the Parliament. 36932020-12-07T17:22:37.16746631John StaffordAs someone who travels to Glasow from Fort William every second week the main areas of concern are the section Tarbet to Inverbeg 8 miles and Fort William to Ballahulish Bridge road is too narrow for the amount of HGV vehicles and PSV vehicles using these stretches of road, overtaking is neigh impossible and motorists travelling through business get frustrated by sigh seeing motorists get frustrated.36932020-12-07T18:51:11.70746634David BoyleI drive to Fort William from Glasgow at least once a fortnight and in my travels I have seen some shocking sights. Tourists driving on the wrong side of the road and just stopping round a bend to take a picture of a mountain is 100% the most dangerous as ridiculous thing I've witnessed. Large lorries and busses often take a wing mirror off other vehicles around the loch lomond area as the road is far too narrow. Campervans and older folk driving at 30-40 miles per hour in a 60 zone can be excruciatingly annoying and cause other drivers to overtake on such a dangerous road. These are very important factors i suggest you should take into account when you decide to "upgrade" the A82.36932020-12-07T19:07:31.3246635Stephen MacLeodThe A82 is not fit for purpose. Sections have been restricted to 50mph, serious accidents are still taking place on these sections. It is time to get this arterial route up to A road standards.36932020-12-07T19:35:00.05746637Peter FlanaganIv driven and traveled on this road for 30+ years, the volume of traffic, the increased need for articulated vehicles has unfortunately reduced this road to death trap... Unfit for purpose. Needs upgrading over most parts.36932020-12-07T19:46:42.93746638Janet ShepherdUpgrade is required urgently especially along Loch Lomond to ensure safety of all users and enable traffic to move freely. 36932020-12-08T07:30:40.37346639Davie KerrWhile I appreciate that most of the A82 was built back in the '30s, it hasn't kept up with the size of modern HGV's and buses and is quite simply not fit for purpose in its present form, particularly on the Upper Loch Lomondside stretch between Tarbet and Inverarnan.36932020-12-08T16:56:19.546640Thomas Rooney Upgrade is needed, it cost lives, economically the delays cost businesses. 36932020-12-08T19:05:18.69746641Jenny LovattRoad needs an urgent upgrade. Traffic has quadrupled over the years and has become so dangerous!36932020-12-09T21:06:09.73746644LYDIA REID If a walker has too many dogs they run the risk of the dogs being out of control. \r\n36752020-12-10T10:31:23.37346647Paul FairlieDangerous road requires major work.36932020-12-10T23:32:40.1946648Andrews Garage Recovery LtdLives and vehicles continuously at heightened risk36932020-12-10T23:35:11.01746649Karen TaylorAppalling standard for a trunk road endangering lives.36932020-12-11T11:09:44.97346650John j corrGET THE CLUBS OPEN.. PLEASE36952020-12-11T12:40:13.49346651Angus NicolsonHigh time the North West saw some serious investment to make the A82 safe and fit for purpose.36932020-12-11T18:36:30.17746653Pete CairnsrI'm trying my best to get access to my son. So far I'm confused how the system works. Kids are meant to be first. But there is adults putting themselves first. Surely that can't be right.35792020-12-11T19:09:4446654Alexander Cubie Carmichael This change is overdue. Scotland should look like a mature and caring jurisdiction. In this respect, it does not. There are provisions in place that, if adapted, would easily embrace this change. Health, education, social care and justice bodies already work constructively to nurture and assist young people in difficulty. I feel sure that they would cope with this change.36982020-12-12T03:33:18.66746655Joseph Colin Mc ShaneAny body, be it police N.H.S. should not be investigating itself as it will always stick up for its members to the detriment of natural justice. This has been proven time after time. They use various stalling tactics also. Cases run for years and even if found guilty (as in the case of the Hillsborough disaster where 96 innocents died) they escape justice as they are either dead or ruled unfit to stand trial. Because of years of litigation.36912020-12-12T17:18:43.41346656John ramsayNot playing meeting friends is effecting my mental health. 36952020-12-13T14:02:14.4646657Thomas MoranAll of these snooker clubs adhere to Government guidance. 36952020-12-13T14:38:23.45746658John BaxterHi I've played snooker from the age of 9 one of the safest sports out there clubs have went out there way to make safety measures for all staff also the public. 12ft by 6ft two people surely that's safe since 12ft is 3.6metres please please open our snooker clubs and pool halls back open thanks. 36952020-12-14T03:28:33.2246659Roger GreenAt 12 years old my young mind had been educated via family, friends, peers and the education system to know right from wrong, anywhere on this planets, accepted there may be mitigating circumstances, whereby a child should not be prosecuted.36982020-12-14T08:15:33.14346660Sunil Sharma It's a non contract sport... Great for relaxing the mind.36952020-12-14T10:49:35.73746661Stuart FinayShould be open as safe uncrowded environment and for mental health reasons people need to be able to look forward to something, especially people with little other means of making social contact with others. This top down broad brush untargeted banning everything approach is ridiculous.36952020-12-14T20:39:45.32746662Jane StrangAssisting single father's maintaining contact with their children. Giving out information from organisations who can assist.35792020-12-18T14:03:34.2246664Marilyn SchofieldI STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS PETITION AFTER HAVING SIMILAR STRONG OPINIONS ABOUT THE TREATMENT OF MY FATHER BEFORE HIS DEATH.36912020-12-18T19:29:10.03746665Robert MartinI think that whatever is agreed here should also apply to Councils because of their involvement in Health and Care Partnerships. 36912020-12-19T18:41:36.69346666Andrew FraserGiven what we now know about the way in which our brains develop, I could hardly believe we are so far behind in this. About time we raised the voting age as well. 36982020-12-21T02:23:04.1846667Ian WilliamsonSnooker venues have gone to great lengths to make them safe. And by the nature of the game, are much safer than pubs or restaurants.36952020-12-25T08:05:11.3646668Peter BrockA 19th century road in the 21st century.36932020-12-25T09:25:15.2346669Colin MacdonaldA82 road users lives matter as well, substandard A class road needs investment and improvement. 36932020-12-25T17:00:04.61746675Gordon MacraeThe A82 gets busier year after year, the government needs to step up investment on this route not only to reduce the number of accidents but to also stimulate growth in the local communities. 36932020-12-26T09:45:23.57346681Stuart Riseley We drove the road after a year earlier and couldn't believe the deteriorating conditions, to say this is a major route into beautiful Scotland is a disgrace. The Scottish Government should be ashamed. 36932020-12-26T12:29:35.346682Jo HardieEven as someone who only uses this route a couple of times a year, it's clear the road is not suitable for the amount and type of traffic that use it.36932020-12-26T13:23:56.81346683Gerry MacLeodThe state of the A82 is appalling for a trunk road and should be thoroughly addressed by implementing the improvements and safety measures required.36932020-12-26T19:04:50.11346684Iain MurdisonThis road has long been forgotten and is in serious need of repair or replacement, in a lot of areas two large vehicles can't pass each other safely without losing a mirror or worse and the amount of cars that take major risks passing lorries and buses is now beyond belief as a local who uses this road a lot, I am terrified of tourist season as the road is shown as a major road on all maps but honestly it is not.36932020-12-27T07:12:31.17346686Brian SwinbanksThe so called A82 is our artery to the Ports to all the islands off the west coast of Scotland. The A82 is still an1850 cart tract with overlaid Tarmac. This road, this route, should be Scotland's number one priority. We must complete the left hand upstroke of 'H' for Highway. All other strokes of this graphic font when overlaid on the map of Scotland have been upgraded or are already motorways.36932020-12-27T07:33:04.25346688Susan MetcalfeThere are too many accidents in this road from Curran ferry to Fort William.36932020-12-27T13:59:44.86746689Neil MackayA class road, more like a b class. Shame on the Scottish govt.36932020-12-29T11:18:28.46746690Paula McAteerNo one else should go through what Samantha and her family have endured, the road needs sorting now not later!!36932020-12-29T20:44:53.6946691Alistair MacDonaldI was a delivery driver for a garage in Inverness and travelled on the A82 very often. It is definitely in poor condition and needs major repairs. It could do with some overtaking lanes.36932020-12-30T19:35:45.7146692stephen youngThis road is dangerous to all and should be upgraded as soon as possible.36932021-01-02T12:53:25.55746693Debbie NivenHaving travelled recently in the dark on the A82, the areas with the brighter cats eyes are fantastic, they make a massive difference and need to be used on the whole stretch of the road. Also the road sides in many places need firming up and strengthening as you would easily lose control if you needed to take avoiding action, some of the big lorries take up more than their side of the road on narrow stretches.36932021-01-03T09:30:47.5146695Evelyn CampbellI live on the isle of Skye and regularly use the A82. Myself and my husband were recently driving home from Fort William when through no fault of our own we were nearly involved in a road traffic collision. A motorcycle overtook approaching a corner on the hill going up Invergarry forcing us to brake sharply.36932021-01-03T10:12:32.47746696Trevor pocockI lost my brother in a car accident on the A82.36932021-01-03T14:02:55.00746697Archie AdamsThe A82 and A87 require serious upgrading. Having been involved in Road Safety for over 30 years in the south of England, the roads are not fit for purpose. Yet Holyrood can find money for lots of different projects, but not for one of the major trunk roads in our country, which has an appalling rate of collisions, injuries and fatalities. 36932021-01-03T21:19:11.24346698Kate GorhamThe A82 is the main artery serving the West Coast of Scotland. It is an essential road and as such should be given that recognition and made safe for travel. The accident statistics are high on this road. How many deaths before it is upgraded? Our link to the rest of the U.K. is via this road. Our supplies come by this road. There is a high volume of HGVs use this road both for serving our community with supplies and for taking produce from us to market including overseas market. Something which you as Politicians are keen to promote, it seems, is tourism. Do you think it is fit for the increased volume of traffic tourism brings. I do not. Make the right decision. Upgrade the A82, to a standard to be proud of. Let's remember it was a Scottish Engineer who invented the road surface, don't let him down.36932021-01-03T21:39:42.21746699Margaret LaidlawThe A82 is not fit for purpose, we seem to have money to spend in and around all our Scottish cities while the A82 is forgotten. 36932021-01-05T10:52:02.92346701Avril CameronHave experienced tailgating on this road travelling towards Inverness.36932021-01-05T13:58:05.38746702George Robertson About time we had snooker back in clubs if they can have other sports why not this one. 36952021-01-05T14:26:26.37346705Edward CurleyDue to this being a non contact sport I hope that we can get all snooker and pool halls back open again please. 36952021-01-05T14:54:28.90746706Michael MurphyI am absolutely baffled why something like snooker is not permitted. It is extremely easy to social distance and how contact sports like football and rugby be allowed, but not snooker, is beyond me. And why pubs are allowed open, ahead of a snooker hall, is just bonkers, frankly.36952021-01-05T15:03:21.59746707Brian ShepleyI believe there are ways around playing snooker that can keep everyone safe. 36952021-01-05T16:55:15.48746708William HallSnooker and pool can both easily be played maintaining social distance and wearing ppe and equipment cleaned appropriately. I see no reason why these activities cannot be resumed. 36952021-01-05T18:37:39.6146710Brian woodsGet the snooker halls open, plenty of space for social distancing 36952021-01-05T19:21:02.37346712Rashid baigSnooker halls should be able to open same time as hospitality. If they can have sit-in 2 meter distance so can snooker halls simple. 36952021-01-05T23:57:57.18346713Davie Hutchison Miss the snooker 36952021-01-06T15:28:06.94746715JASON BURNETTShould be open in more tiers.36952021-01-06T17:44:07.77746716James WI believe snooker with certain measures, which would be easy to maintain, should at least be tier 3 as it is non contact and good for mental health. 36952021-01-06T19:04:05.86746717Allan DochertyYes i do agree they are as safe as bars & gyms. Before this latest lockdown the local gym was allowed open with at least 10 people. Yet snooker halls are not allowed to be open at all? \r\n\r\nIf football leagues can play why cant we?\r\n \r\nAlso i suffer from depression. Because of this i am not working so snooker was the only way i got out the house and was in contact with anyone. \r\n\r\n36952021-01-06T21:14:42.6346719Neil DohertyThis specific sector has been crucified since day one. It's not only people's livelihoods that are effected you allowed Gyms to reopen but kept Snooker and Pool Halls closed, a baffling decision. \r\nI and many others would benefit from being allowed to play the Sport we Love(safely) and it would also help us destress during these most trying of times.36952021-01-07T11:55:31.6446720Douglas CameronI am related to the petitioner and have partial knowledge of some of the petitioners concerns. The details of what led up to this petition being seen as necessary unfolded over many years and had started as an obviously personal issue over a matter of civil law. But it became increasingly obvious that a pattern was developing in a much wider sense and across different, but not totally unconnected government agencies. I firmly believe that there is a systemic problem here, completely unrelated to the petitioners original case. The advice to submit a petition came from an MSP, Brian Whittle. The system appears to allow individuals within departments to make professional judgements about colleagues to whom they could subsequently be dependent on for a professional reference. Quite apart from the obvious concerns this gives any complainant, it is surely completely unfair to put any individual employee in such a professionally uncomfortable situation. The petition rules make it not permissible to name a previous MSP who was crucially involved in making representations that could have avoided the need for a petition in the first place. It is seriously worrying when an official figure with considerable authority makes inquiries and reports, in writing, his conclusion that the petitioner has a “compelling case” but that the agencies being complained about would “do nothing more than circle the wagons” and that in any case the mere mention of the petitioners name “frightened them off”. It is surely worrying when a government agency has the confidence to state that they have done something when it can be unarguably shown from written evidence that they have not. And unilaterally then close that particular issue down. It is surely wrong that a government agency can withhold data that “is normally shared”. I do hope the essence of this petition is truly understood by those who have the power to improve the system of justice in Scotland.34332021-01-21T19:08:26.0246721david mitchellBan grouse shoots.37012021-01-21T20:14:55.35746722Rosslyn McNallyFlood prevention measures on grouse moors have the potential to provide multiple benefits for very little cost to the landowners and the public, and exponential benefits for grouse, other wildlife and obviously humans if their dwellings are protected from flooding downstream. A no brainer I feel. 37012021-01-21T22:21:15.02346723Jude MaxwellYes, I agree.37012021-01-21T22:55:00.48746724kate macleanPeople and wildlife before dodgy sport.37012021-01-22T06:36:16.7446725Lynne TillyardNatural flood defences in these areas will become more critical as global warming intensified. Action is needed now to prevent flooding at protect homes.37012021-01-22T10:32:47.38746726Joanna FindlayThese are all much needed actions.37012021-01-22T19:36:06.33746727Stewart LovePeoples homes come before shooting grouse. The moorland used for shooting should be returned to natural state to keep water from flooding down stream from the moorland.37012021-01-23T14:11:20.8246728peter reganI live near Hebden bridge in Yorkshire, this is the same scenario that happens here, a fantastic group\r\nof people called siow the flow find natural ways to do\r\njust that. Unfortunately much of their hard work is undone, by having a intensely managed grouse moor\r\nat the head of the valley at Walshaw. Owned by the rich for the rich and sod everybody downstream of them.37012021-01-23T16:05:03.5746729David PritchardAn absolute yes, rather than as now degrading the land as at present.37012021-01-23T23:51:07.2946730Judith JonesThe future of our wildlife, our wild places and our climate is at stake. Grouse moors are for the benefit of a privileged few, but are detrimental to the environment and the majority of people. We are at a crucial time and must put the environment before profit and bloodlust.37012021-01-24T10:24:25.20346731Peter KempIf we consider ourselves to be civilised this needs to be done with some urgency.37012021-01-25T09:54:56.71746732Alex MilneI'd rather that driven grouse shooting was banned, but a strong set of licence conditions to limit the damage to biodiversity and the environment may be an acceptable start.37012021-01-25T10:16:48.98746733Roger SandersonWhy are arable farmers not allowed to burn stubble and straw, when grouse moors can burn heather?37012021-01-25T10:24:19.28346734Paul FisherConsidering any future land use must benefit the many, not the few as at present.37012021-01-25T10:31:24.70746735Lance MooreBurning moorland is outrageous37012021-01-25T11:40:57.13746736Peter McHughGood Luck37012021-01-25T11:52:13.56346737Jacqueline tingayIt would seem obvious that people and property should be protected as far as possible against allowing a select few to despoil the land for the sole purpose of killing wild life.37012021-01-25T12:01:41.2246738Harry BickerstaffThis is long overdue and puts human beings and their living conditions, ahead of increased Red Grouse productivity.37012021-01-25T12:15:52.0546739Angus maciverI totally agree with the comments for putting forward this petition37012021-01-25T12:22:47.86346740Finn WeddleThe land belongs to the nation before it belongs to private owners, and the nation's interest must be in protecting its people before protecting it businesses. If business is disturbing people's right to safe and secure housing, or damaging public infrastructure downstream of its activities, it is the moral duty of the state to regulate these businesses to protect these rights. If there are any flood risks associated with grouse moor management, it is imperative that grouse moor licensing is contingent on active and concerted flood mitigation efforts by the estate managers.37012021-01-25T12:43:21.41346741Colin HydeWe desperately need a licensing system to control the archaic land use currently employed by the grouse-shooting industry. It should also be the first step to a wider debate about the whole future of the rural economy in Scotland being pursued in a more environmentally aware basis.37012021-01-25T13:10:14.96346742Peter KempIt's time to introduce responsibility to everyone especially large landowners. Whatever happened to land reform? More long grass.37012021-01-25T13:11:16.96346743Bob DownieNo one should be allowed to manage land without considering the effects on people outwith the management area. Flooding resulting from poor management of upland moorland areas is well-known and thus a water management plan must be a condition for the award of a grouse moorland licence. 37012021-01-25T14:38:40.17746744Nigel JenningsThe severe environmental damage caused by common grouse moor management practices is often overshadowed by wildlife persecution issues. It must not be overlooked. 37012021-01-25T15:46:10.76346745Pete EtheridgeThis is an excellent idea and would help to alleviate flood damage and enhance wildlife.37012021-01-25T16:11:15.33346746Christopher HillWould like to see our wildlife protected and our landscapes managed in a way that encourages biodiversity.37012021-01-25T16:15:07.8346747Stewart LoveI's long past time that natural flood prevention should have happened years ago.37012021-01-25T16:41:42.2546748Ian ClarkeGood luck37012021-01-25T16:44:24.55746749Nick MoyesIt is essential that management of upland areas for shooting for sport takes into consideration the immense potential impact of that activity on communities living downstream. Mis-management (i.e. severe over-management) just for gamebird shooting must prevented in any licencing scheme so that the Natural Capital Asset that is upland peatlands are maintained for the good of everyone, and not just managed so as to profit a relatively small number of landowners. 37012021-01-25T16:49:47.18346750Conrad Auten Stop using our money to enable rich people to practise recreational blood sports and to mismanage our land.37012021-01-25T17:19:44.84346751Erica BeeforthI would support the conditions you explained, before licences are granted.37012021-01-25T17:53:00.46346752Edward O'DonnellyHeather burning is a redundant37012021-01-25T17:59:56.32346753Tony BurnFlooding is only going to get worse and burning moorland will speed this up.37012021-01-25T18:46:40.1946754Malcolm ScottWe should also ban shooting birds for fun. It's disgusting.37012021-01-25T19:16:14.90746755Robert BaileyIt's a complete no-brainer. So let's hope that the politicians can see this!37012021-01-25T19:49:04.29346756Neil RobertsonAt present the many suffer so the few can have a day out killing wee birds. Surely they must pay the full environmental cost for their dirty hobby.37012021-01-25T19:51:11.34746757Peter HackTrees whether by rewilding or tree planting also contribute to mitigating climate change which is a key inetre Governmental ambition if in mosaics of habitat that increases diversity.37012021-01-25T20:15:48.37346758Judith SmithYou've only to look at Calderdale and the flooding there to see the effects of moorland burning.37012021-01-25T21:08:32.65746759Caroline McManusLong past time this destructive and immensely costly - costly to our mental and physical health, environment and nature-activity was taxed out of existence.37012021-01-25T21:12:58.18746760Colin Pattenden Please put an end to these ridiculous practices that are so bad for climate change. 37012021-01-25T21:27:16.99346761Tim Crozier-ColeCommon sense.37012021-01-25T21:59:27.23346762Nadia FoxAll shooting should be banned.37012021-01-25T22:00:43.98346763Tim GeesonLand Stewardship is a privilege which needs to be exercised rationally. The grouse moors of the UK are wonderful and special habitat but the necessity to develop a more effective and environmental solutions is required in the 21st century. 37012021-01-25T23:54:19.35746764Alan DavisStop messing with nature. 37012021-01-26T00:59:48.1146765Janet HoptroffThe best solution to so many ills would be to ban driven grouse shooting completely.37012021-01-26T07:53:19.80746766RICHARD LESLIE ANTCLIFFif you believe climate change will make our winters much wetter then every thing should be done to prevent flooding of homes and businesses.37012021-01-26T08:29:09.01746768Jim DawsonGrouse moors need water so controlled burning is not a problem so far as flooding is concerned.\r\nThe problem lies with forest plantations where run off ditches are cut to allow the land to drain.\r\nGrouse moors prevent flooding downstream.37012021-01-26T08:57:37.92746769Hazel GreenstilesGrouse shooting destroys raptors as well, should be banned.37012021-01-26T08:59:37.95746770Boyd JohnstonDriven grouse shooting should be banned. All game bird shooting should be licensed. Estates where raptors disappear ore found dead should lose any licences. There should be incentives to re-wild moorland.37012021-01-26T09:31:35.8546771Donald McPhillimyGot to get our priorities right. Having been flooded once, I know how awful it is.\r\n37012021-01-26T10:34:18.0846773Mr K J FarrellWith one of the most depleted ecosystems in the world UK government and Scottish Parliament, grouse farmers should start taking this issue very seriously and she's not be so backward looking with environmental issues.37012021-01-26T11:03:46.14746774Kenneth Alan-GoddardI agree with the management of stocks, but do not agree with killing for pleasure!!! 37012021-01-26T11:37:18.79346775Paul m Ryland I object on the grounds of cruelty to wildlife.\r\nStraw burning was banned years ago.Burning Heather creates the same pollutants which damage the environment 37012021-01-26T18:36:56.70746777Alex SmithNo, because this is a deliberate attempt to manipulate our legislature and thus waste Parliament's time. Interesting that Mr Wallace offers no facts that link flooding to grouse moors - because there are none.37012021-01-27T07:54:22.9446778IA KirkWherever your home is, grouse moor management impacts the quality and protection of your nation environment. It is a practice in denial of knowledge37012021-01-27T08:13:02.80346779Roy HicksThe rich are to blame, its only those who are destroying our moorlands.37012021-01-27T08:21:38.99346780M J QuirkeThe proposed measures would also reduce Scotland's carbon footprint, reduce erosion, and reduce water pollution and improve the biodiversity of both the affected lands and the watercourses that are fed by them.37012021-01-27T09:27:59.20346783Robert kirbyMust end, save our wildlife and environment. 37012021-01-27T10:46:54.30746784Nonie CoulthardFlood and drought prevention (woodland and wetland sponges), clean air (no muirburn) and access to Nature are all public goods. Moorland can provide all these but not when it's trashed for driven grouse shooting to provide fun for a tiny number of rich people. DGS should be banned along with all these damaging practices and land managers paid instead to provide these public goods and ecosystem services to benefit all in Scotland. 37012021-01-27T11:11:26.59346786Kat DolanBan all grouse shooting.37012021-01-27T13:33:41.28746787peter foxShooting is now well known to detrimental to all wildlife. Uplands should now be returned to forest.37012021-01-27T13:49:45.57346788Lorna McAllisterEnvironmental demands are much more important than the profits amassed by the owners of the moors. Defend our flora and fauna. Raptors require protection. Ban grouse shooting. 37012021-01-27T14:17:27.2646789Mal TaylorHow much longer does the general public have to put up with the current situation where almost all living things are eradicated in the attempt to rear grouse at 40 times their natural levels so a very few rich and privileged people can blast as many as possible out of the sky for fun. It is a disgrace and needs to end. 37012021-01-27T14:24:18.35746790Simon TuckerFunny how the cost of flooding caused by the erosion of water retention on moorland managed for grouse shooting is never taken into account when the government and shooting industry claim how much they contribute to the economy.\r\n\r\nThe only benefit from driven grouse shooting is in the profit given to the landowners and their shipping it to offshore tax havens to avoid paying their dues.37012021-01-27T16:57:08.48346791Hillary SillittoThis is an excellent initiative I am very happy to support. Our land needs to be used for the benefit of all Scots, and it is not acceptable or fair for upstream landowners to increase flood risk to those living downstream by non optimum non holistic land management practices. 37012021-01-27T18:12:01.3946792Deborah MacKichanThis issue needs a rapid and radical response. We need to rewild vast swathes of Scotland not only in a direct response flooding but also to help mitigate the climatic weather extremes that cause the heavy downpours in the first place. 37012021-01-27T18:46:44.07746793Martin HindHaving seen through work and pleasure the devastation that is caused by management of grouse moors it needs to be controlled!37012021-01-27T20:30:54.24746794David SpiersPlease see sense, It’s time to stop abusing the land and our wildlife. Please do the right thing for everyone, you have the power to make a positive change, thank you37012021-01-27T20:56:55.39346795Greg CastLicence game bird shooting and protect the raptors and other apex predators. Do the right thing!37012021-01-28T07:37:27.82746796Madeleine J C MasseyGrouse moors are managed FOR grouse and the management results in flooding depleted tree cover and species poor land, together with consequential flooding.37012021-01-28T12:22:23.9946797Robin WallaceNot to mention wildlife persecution. 37012021-01-29T11:06:51.9946798andrew millerGrouse shooting is clearly not a flood risk. The management of moorland for grouse involves a number of practices which positively aid flood prevention. 37012021-01-30T13:50:53.03746800Paul CarrThis destruction has to stop, every winter this happens more and more37012021-01-30T17:56:50.7346801Jim KnightI agree with this petition. This issue affects a significant area of Scotland's land resource.37012021-01-30T18:57:19.37746802Fiona FrayserTime to move to 21st century and protect our countryside37012021-01-30T23:26:55.6246803Paula CARROLLThere is no excuse for selling out our future to profit. Our kids deserve to inherit a viable future.37012021-02-01T08:58:40.1246807Mary Cammack Driven grouse shooting needs to cease in order to protect moorland and towns37012021-02-01T15:23:23.12746808Paul GreavesThe upland areas of Scotland could provide so many benefits to the people of Scotland and reducing impacts from high rainfall events is just one of them. It is crazy that the uplands are being managed in a way that is so destructive for ecosystems to benefit so few people.37012021-02-03T09:58:57.49746810Gurch SamraConfidence in the other legal system is crucial for any civilization.37422021-02-03T10:18:21.84346811Mark LundIll sign anything that lessens the negative impact of any type of grouse moors. Those 'custodians of the countryside' need to manage it for the good of the environment, or take it away from them.37012021-02-03T14:46:01.22346813Dorothy HoldenOur Battlefields need to be protected and treated with the respect they deserve. Current planning controls are not working, they need to be much more rigourous and less easy to circumvent by developers37162021-02-03T17:37:01.3946814Kate MCMANUS Scottish importance. 37162021-02-03T17:45:23.8146815Dianne Y NelsonCulloden is sacred ground.Would you want people building and partying on your Mother's grave? Thought not.37162021-02-03T17:54:47.29746816sarah baileyBattlefields should be kept as a monument to all those who lost their lives as a sign of respect. 37162021-02-03T17:55:25.31346817Lisa DaviesWe need to protect Scotland's Battlefields for future generations, past & current planning applications at Culloden show that not enough is being done to protect these areas. 37162021-02-03T17:56:42.95346818David WildsWe should be safeguarding this and every battlefield for future generations and to honour the memory of all soldiers who fought and lost their lives here.37162021-02-03T18:04:04.2246819Ada CartwrightI fully expect SNP to intervene on this. 37162021-02-03T18:09:24.84346820Alison Dickie Culloden should be treated as a war cemetery. The dead deserve peace to rest. More protection is needed for our battlefields in Scotland. Legislation is required to stop reapplications when it has previously been denied. Tweaks should not be allowed. 37162021-02-03T18:18:17.346821Sonya Whitmire Scotland is known for its culture, and beauty. I can't imagine building over a gravesite. 37162021-02-03T18:19:37.64346822Linda FrantzThe historic battlefields of Scotland need permanently protected against any building or desecration of any kind. This IS Scotland's history!37162021-02-03T18:33:56.64746823Tonya BillingsWhile I know it is tempting to allow development. The battlefields are graveyards and of historical significance. They are what draws tourism. If you don't protect them then it is inevitable that revenue will be lost.37162021-02-03T18:44:05.16346824Dorothy HoldenOur battlefields need to be protected against unwanted and unnecessary development. Current legislation is not sufficient and a much more robust planning system needs to be brought into being.37162021-02-03T18:45:16.4646825Doug FosterSad to see historic sites not protected.37162021-02-03T18:49:59.75746826Sandra Anne MarshallIt would be a national disgrace if it was allowed to build on Culloden. Surely there are lots of brown field sites in Scotland to build on.37162021-02-03T18:56:21.146828Dorothy HoldenOur historic Battlefields need to be much more robustly protected from developers than at present37162021-02-03T19:05:49.4846830David McCallumBest thing as A83 a shambles. 37352021-02-03T19:06:04.66746831Leonie BellI agree, thanks for pushing for the pardon and apology. 37332021-02-03T19:10:34.69746833Margaret ManningIt does not become them at all when you have to continually lobby them to stop development . 37162021-02-03T19:17:19.58746834Theresa PreitzYour destroying am important part of our history. Make the sight heritage please.37162021-02-03T19:21:52.99746835Ewan Neilson I have friends down in Campbeltown and I visit regularly and this ferrry would benefit the community of Campbeltown. 37352021-02-03T19:22:04.49746836Diane MackayThis is a long overdue campaign to recognise these miscarriages of justice for so many innocent people. 37332021-02-03T19:26:12.12346837Lorraine AikenThis is a much needed service to ensure business can continue to thrive and to ensure a reliable connection for travel to and from the rest of Scotland.37352021-02-03T19:28:01.68346838Peter Stark Regular Kintore traveller from England increasingly frustrated and disillusioned by the Rest and Be Thankful fiasco and diversions. Alternative vital.37352021-02-03T19:29:50.74746839Lorraine AikenNeed to secure connection between Argyll and rest of Scotland.37352021-02-03T19:32:55.1746840Jeanie CorstorphineI am absolutely furious that HES did not object to this development. They are not fit for purpose and the developer's 3rd application, they have no thought whatsover or do not care about our History. If one development is allowed then there will numerous other ones no doubt. The protection of this battlefield should be enshrined in law. Isn't it bad enough that our ancestors were slaughteted as they were fleeing without us having to fight greedy developers time and time again.37162021-02-03T19:33:23.79746841David LearmonthA Scot, defending greater preservation of Scottish Battlefields, Culloden in particular.37162021-02-03T19:34:30.46746842Ian WedgburyI would use the ferry on a regular basis as a short cut from england.37352021-02-03T19:35:43.1746843Jeanie CorstorphineNo I do not believe it's adequate. Applications will continue to be put in regardless how many times they are turned down. Legislation enshrined in law is needed to protect the Battlefield.37162021-02-03T19:39:34.76346844JAMES D HAMILTONBest to lease a ship similar to the one that did the Ullapool- Stornoway freight run.37352021-02-03T19:42:12.18746845Kimberley PrestonNo and Yes37162021-02-03T19:44:25.6446846Catherine CoppingBorn and lived a lot of years in Campbeltown, and would help greatly to have the ferry running year round.37352021-02-03T19:46:27.0346847Ronnie BrownCampbeltown and the Kintyre area needs a lifeline ferry service as the access on the A83 is unreliable. Business need a guaranteed route to continue to operate and trade fairly.37352021-02-03T19:46:28.746848Dorothy MacarthurWould be brilliant, especially with the current situation with the rest and be thankful. 37352021-02-03T19:54:46.3646849Morag McLean hBorn & bred locally and feel other islands have a first class service but as we ate a peninsula we are ignored even although we have to re route in many occasions to get to our destination - This is the 21 st century & in my teens at least the steamer called once a day. 37352021-02-03T19:56:17.76746850Fiona SeivewrightThis is a gross injustice against women and deserves to be addressed.37332021-02-03T20:00:31.03346851Garry NewmanAbsolutely totally until a road tunnel has been built at the Rest and be Thankful. 37352021-02-03T20:02:35.56346852Laurna CronWe need to recognise the horror visited on those wrongfully accused. 37332021-02-03T20:05:20.95346853Caroline AndersonIt's so important for these women to be pardoned and remembered. 37332021-02-03T20:06:47.64346854Rosemary Cameron A very commendable project. 37332021-02-03T20:08:50.0546855Ronald RobertsUrgently needed. 37352021-02-03T20:10:30.34746856Claire M. DonoghueJustice for these persons must must be done and be seen to be done. Women who fought hard for rights should never be demonised and should never have such rights eradicated by bullying menace wrapped in the manipulative delusion of "being progressive and inclusive". To permit or encourage such lies to perpetrate in today's society is to allow these people to have died in vain.37332021-02-03T20:10:36.3846857aamer anwarJustice delayer is justice denied. 37332021-02-03T20:14:48.1646858Stephen McCormickThis service would be a lifeline for the west coast.37352021-02-03T20:29:11.45746859Julia CampanelliYes, I agree. The truth matters. Pardon those wrongly accused.37332021-02-03T20:35:59.61746860Arlene MacleanThe ferry is a much needed.37352021-02-03T20:41:45.9646861Valerie MccallumSomething needs to be done to give us a permanent link.37352021-02-03T20:43:09.44346862Fiona GilliesYes37352021-02-03T20:45:15.80346863Tracey LoveI am the first born out of Scotland for my family. my great grandmother and grandmother coming from golspie, and my mum dad sister and brother all coming from glasgow and paisley\r\nIn the last ten years I've bell reconnecting with my family and family history\r\nTo many of us immigrants this site is of extreme importance as well as the folk from Scotland.\r\n37162021-02-03T20:57:18.83746864Angela BellThis is long overdue. 37332021-02-03T21:03:39.58746865chelsea WillisThis would be a huge help for us as a family. 37352021-02-03T21:12:13.44746866Kathleen Silvia These people need a pardon after being horrifically killed and dishonored for hundreds of years. 37332021-02-03T21:16:55.946867Stephen McCormickThis service would be a life line for the west coast.37352021-02-03T21:19:04.0346869vicky mckerralYes I agree.37352021-02-03T21:19:56.57346870Caroline AndersonPlease pardon these women - they were just folk. 37332021-02-03T21:20:51.32346871Agnes CookThe ferry service in the past has been nothing short of disgraceful. This area NEEDS a reliable ferry, especially now with the Rest and Be Thankful problem.37352021-02-03T21:31:06.49746872Isobel Mc MillanDesperately needed vital link.37352021-02-03T21:33:59.1146873Mrs Marie McCullochYes i do agree to a pardon, apology and a National Monument. 37332021-02-03T21:48:49.9746874Jane scallyThis would be a great way for people to get to and from town.37352021-02-03T21:51:06.39346875Julia PunchMy Mother was a Fraser, descendent of Lord Lovat, Simon Fraser. 37162021-02-03T22:02:23.40746876Karen GiderStudying Arts and Humanities with Scottish history so this is right up my street . Let's fight for these woman ,I believe us females always need to stick together .37332021-02-03T22:21:06.94346877Jean-Marc Danquigny As a foot passenger , it's the most efficient mean of transport. 37352021-02-03T22:54:18.46346878Lise PoulinIts time that this historical site and war grave be adequately protected.37162021-02-03T23:05:05.04346879Jill CameronAfter hearing some of the harrowing stories about the way women were treated, a memorial is long overdue. 37332021-02-03T23:17:46.91746880Valentine ScarlettWitches are people who do good in their communities and always have. The evil ones are those who chose not to understand, close their minds, become angry at their own ignorance and take it out on easy targets. That is those who are different.37332021-02-03T23:30:34.73346881Aliceanne McKinlayThis would be an amazing service until they resolve the issues at the Rest and Be Thankful.37352021-02-03T23:36:37.81346882Jill ReidI agree. 37332021-02-03T23:50:07.03346883Judith JonesWe are cut off from the rest of the UK and at the mercy of the elements as the Rest and Be Thankful is not fit for purpose.37352021-02-03T23:52:22.86346884William Shaw of Easter LairCulloden is sacred ground.37162021-02-04T00:22:46.25746885Suzi PottsTruth loves to be naked! 37332021-02-04T01:31:33.71746888Fiona Goddard For all the women who were murdered, for our ancestors & for healing. 37332021-02-04T02:32:02.83746889Dorothy HoldenWe need to greatly strengthen the planning protection for site such as our Battlefields which are under constant threat from developers who have no interest in preserving our past history.37162021-02-04T03:13:06.20346891Lanier Cassada Please leave these shoulders to Rest In Peace. 37162021-02-04T03:44:30.20746892Anne CrossmanYes, I agree.37332021-02-04T03:52:46.70746893Susie TurnerYes, please pardon. Rest In Peace. 37332021-02-04T07:38:51.2746894Jane SandersA viable alternative is needed to the Rest and be Thankful which has suffered so many landslides.37352021-02-04T07:41:04.14746895Linda AndersonLet's protect our history.37162021-02-04T07:43:58.0246896michael john reillyGood idea.37352021-02-04T07:56:27.6846897Zeke PowerzThis doesn't erase the victimization of those executed. This does allow allow their descendants to have honor returned in their name. 37332021-02-04T08:01:35.00746898George WilsonA pardon and an apology is well overdue for these forgotten victims of Kirk and state repression and control of the day. A national monument would be a fitting memorial! (perhaps in Spott, East Lothian, adjacent to the "Witches Stane")\r\n37332021-02-04T08:06:39.7646899Sharon Graham This is extremely important.37332021-02-04T08:31:31.4246900Sandra BrownPowerful women are not WITCHES. 37332021-02-04T08:53:53.98346902C Tanner So much wisdom and knowledge lost, taken from communities and demonised, all for power and because of fear and indoctrination by the Christians leaders.\r\nI feel to honour these woman and men is the very least we can do. Just as the Jews became honoured and debased history is not erased, but learned from so we dont repeat it. 37332021-02-04T08:57:12.4746903Georgina ChickenWith the Rest & be Thankful issues it can be a much needed alternative for businesses.37352021-02-04T09:14:41.95746904Frances Palmer Been to Culloden many times. Am absolutely horrified that anyone would consider building on the battlefield.37162021-02-04T09:19:34.67746905Mel WoodsI fully support the request for a pardon, apology and and prominent national memorial for the witches of scotland. 37332021-02-04T09:39:40.94346906Caroline ClulowPlease don't allow property developers to ruin our heritage. It's important to show respect for our history so that generations to come can have the chance to reflect. 37162021-02-04T09:45:57.92746907Louise YoungmanThe deteriorating conditions on the Rest and be Thankful should warrant the solution asked for, especially as it appears that any resolution to the problem at the Rest will be many years away. This is a reasonable request to protect our local economy 37352021-02-04T09:56:11.13346908mandy RathjenI am in the friends of Burdiehouse burn valley park and we would really like to have a memorial to the local women who were accused of witchcraft and tortured or murdered. We started researching court records before the pandemic and will do more when we can. This is important work to bring justice to many women and their memories. Thank you 37332021-02-04T10:03:36.80746909peter aitchisonFor those 2,500 women and men who were executed by the state, and their bodies burned to erase all trace that they ever existed. We now give them their place in history, and remember their names and their lives.37332021-02-04T10:21:26.74746910Catriona E BrodieAs I travel between Campbeltown and Kirkcaldy every couple of weeks to my second home it is very frustrating to find the Rest and be Thankful closed . Not only is a long detour necessary but very frustrating when the diversion route is closed as well. The ferry would also be an advantage for tourists and traders therefore bringing more money and opportunities to the area I love so much.37352021-02-04T11:10:22.28346912Heather UpfieldI am wholeheartedly in favour of the aims of this petition. The suffering of these women and men needs to be recognised with a national response.37332021-02-04T11:17:52.95746913Mary ThomsonWe shouldn't even be having to do this, time and again applications going in for houses. Please stop this from happening by making it a Heritage site! Protect our history.37162021-02-04T11:41:42.5746915DIANE MACKAYA long overdue campaign to address an overwhelming quantity of miscarriages of justice.37332021-02-04T11:44:16.5746916Sophie HarvieI believe if we do not stand for injustice from our history then we cannot stand for any injustices that happen in todays society. 37332021-02-04T12:03:47.3746917Joanna Campbell This is greatly needed for the survival of Campbeltown. 37352021-02-04T12:08:34.2146918Catherine Mac kinnonVery much needed,with rest and be thank ful long way off been fixed.37352021-02-04T12:14:02.19746919Elaine RyanNot enough protection is afforded to Scottish battlefields. People died fighting for their cause and are buried on these sites. These are war graves and should be afforded the respect and decency shown to other battle does around the world. Planning protection must be given to all historical sites around Scotland. These sites are this country's history and must be protected for everyone.37162021-02-04T12:21:14.24346920Keith JohnsonA reliable daily service would enhance the area & encourage visitors to the area, bringing much need revenue to the area.37352021-02-04T12:26:00.13346921Gerard McAuleyIt is a sign of a mature nation that we interpret our history and preserve it for future generations. We need accessible artefacts in museums but we also need to guard and protect the ground where key historic events took place.37162021-02-04T12:43:45.5946922Catherine CowanEvery type of disability is different. Ms effects everyone differently. One day you may be able to walk 20 metres but there may be many days you cannot walk at all. This is a rule set by someone who has no idea of how disability affects individuals 37312021-02-04T12:49:14.6146923Michelle ShorttThe persecution of women and some men for witchcraft is a dark episode in human and particularly Scottish history. A urge the government to give justice to those thousands of people convicted of something that isn't scientifically possible. 37332021-02-04T12:52:25.7346925Alan BrownWitch hunts seem to still be with us. This move in regard to historical persecution of women may help open our eyes in the present day.37332021-02-04T13:00:45.3946926Jo LaidlawThis is long overdue. 2,500 women killed for being women - we will remember them. 37332021-02-04T13:03:02.4446927Debbie HarrogateWith all the upheaval of the rest and be thankful this would definitely help. We need this for our town. 37352021-02-04T13:51:15.74346928Mrs Sheryl HepworthThe battlefields of Scotland need full and proper protection as they contain the graves of so many Scots who fought for our Scotland. They are precious and should be sacrosanct. The level of protection accorded these places is totally inadequate and legislation is badly needed against rich, greedy speculators that would desecrate our graveyards. Please do not allow any further intrusion by land speculators by allowing our historic grounds to be threatened with modern buildings for profit. 37162021-02-04T14:06:37.38746929David FarrellBe acknowledge the sins of our past to build the world we desire. 37332021-02-04T14:17:59.6746930Catriona HylandYes I agree 20 metre rule must be removed . If the Powers that Be had their independence to walk & do the simplest activities taken from them for any length of time , how interesting it would be to see the changed attitude. No one wishes to be reliant others 37312021-02-04T14:23:13.21346931Janice campbell20 meter rule is not a true reflection on what life is like with multiple sclerosis 37312021-02-04T14:25:34.93746932Judi Evans Culloden Muir should never be built on again. It should be a designated War Grave.37162021-02-04T14:31:56.83746933Sharon MorrisonFor the abuse and torture of those accused, the poor souls murdered in the name of Christianity. A pardon in recognition of the inhumane period of our history where such practices were encouraged and applauded, is the least that can be expected.37332021-02-04T14:41:12.9546934Margaret murray This is the lowest of the lowest of Scotland do this to disabled people everybody has different needs just like MSP 37312021-02-04T14:55:05.30746935SisiI would like it to be addressed to women specifically, as it is a vast majority of women who were the victims of witch hunts. 37332021-02-04T15:08:42.40746937Julie GibbonsOrdinary folk, being human. Let's right a massive wrong that impacts us all today, whether we know it or not. Thank you \r\nClaire Mitchell QC (and collaborators.)37332021-02-04T15:17:40.246938Gayle McNeillA full pardon and apology are long overdue. 37332021-02-04T15:20:03.6446939Jean PattisonAlthough I live in the central belt I visit Campbeltown as often as I can and feel for the community with all the disruption caused with the A83 and apart from that it would be good for folk who live on the Ayrshire side and that area of the water as well.37352021-02-04T15:29:12.18746940Ruth GrayA ferry between Campbeltown and Ardrossan would facilitate a marked increase in business and leisure possibilities not only for the wee toon itself but also for the entire Kintyre peninsular as well as allowing people to travel and from the Ayrshire coast and further. This service would be widely benificial and well used. The Summer Ferry when it was on verifies the need for such a service.37352021-02-04T15:38:18.51746941Neil McKechnieThis is an important Petition for every decent member of the public in Scotland to preserve the Public Interest where it is being forsaken by politicians pandering to Vested Interests. \r\nMake no mistake this is about off the charts corruption to allow crooks to make money at the expense and to the detriment of the Scottish public. \r\nWe gave evidence to the Justice Committee back in 2007 when they promised us that the Law Society's corruption would be ended by the introduction of the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission (SLCC). However, the SLCC may be perceived as just the Law Society Of Scotland with a different hat on. This has resulted in further harm and lack of justice being available to clients of Scottish solicitors for 14 Years.\r\nThe politicians must be held accountable to the people.\r\nThe politicians have been given evidence that the SLCC broke the law by covering up serious crimes committed by the Law Society of Scotland and the Scottish Public also deserve to know the truth by reading the catalogue of crime in submissions to this Petition and to the Consultation regarding regulation of Scottish solicitors which is due to close this month.\r\n37422021-02-04T15:59:23.03746942Christine Diana RussellMy business would greatly benefit from increased visitor numbers.\r\nOur garden, near Campbeltown, is a valued resource for both locals and visitors and attracts many tourists each year. The income goes directly to local charities. A ferry would undoubtedly increase the number of visitors.37352021-02-04T16:47:15.68746943Philippa J MartinThis Battlefield is a place of remembrance for this lost in 1746. Many families go to visit there lost ancestors. It is Sacred for many. 37162021-02-04T17:09:13.01346945David Bruce Campbeltown is the most isolated town in Scotland and needs better links to ensure the community town and local area remains sustainable and would prosper from better links37352021-02-04T17:19:00.71746946Catherine CochraneI travel frequently especially during the spring and summer months to Campbeltown as I still have family and friends there. We also enjoy Campbeltown and the surrounding areas as our chosen holiday destination.The continuing Road closures at the Rest and be Thankful are such a nuisance to all and knowing you have the choice of the ferry journey would be very welcome.I believe that a ferry service would benefit everyone including businesses.37352021-02-04T17:23:36.87746947Sophie BrodieIt's time we acknowledged and remembered those who were targeted for being who they were. This is needed. 37332021-02-04T17:30:12.9146948Randi AichelLet them Rest In Peace! They are heroes who should be memorialized for all time! 37162021-02-04T17:31:50.95346949Malcolm Cochrane As a person who travels to Campbeltown regularly I believe that the ferry is an added necessity for residents of the area . I have used the ferry on several occasions and also the main A83 . As the rest and be thankful is in need of safety upgrade the ferry is in my view required. As to the ferry timetable I would flip the schedule so that people can travel to kintyre in the morning and return in the evening. This would allow more visitors to the area which would help economy and subsidy of the ferry . 37352021-02-04T17:46:04.78746950joseph mcmillanWe really need this service in Campbeltown, it will make travel much easier for lots of people. 37352021-02-04T18:24:17.63746951anna elliswe visit scotland twice yearly - my disabled son loves history , a castle visit every year !, we hope and pray the historical sites are left as they are now ,- wide open spaces for all to enjoy, as they were in battle. once planning laws are passed once allowing unnecessary building, there will be no end to the flood gates this will open. act now to preserve history for all FOREVER.37162021-02-04T19:07:24.78346953Gina StewartMust not let this happen it's a war grave and must remain so.37162021-02-04T19:18:41.68746955lorraine johnstonTime to address an old cruel injustice.37332021-02-04T19:23:21.6946956Cllr.Kate StewartJustice for the victims Accused of being Witches37332021-02-04T19:28:32.09746957Sean FlynnWhere to start, connectivity, business, tourism, social cohesion. Investing in your people can only be beneficial.37352021-02-04T19:40:03.9946958Kate Dingwall Connected communities via secure transport links brings benefits to the economy of deprived areas of Scotland. Please prioritise linking communities. 37352021-02-04T20:12:38.18346959Dayna ZarazinskiThis is an important piece of Scottish history! I am descended from the Kincaid family and dream of visiting Scotland and this site is on my list of places to see.37162021-02-04T20:28:03.37346960Scott MeikleWill stimulate tourism from entire UK.37352021-02-04T21:02:43.37746961Barbara MilneCulloden should be a protected site, it is a war grave37162021-02-04T21:24:46.33346963elaine sissonThis is sacred ground! Do NOT disturb!37162021-02-04T21:44:38.75346964Cat BrownA reliable service between these two destinations will benefit the economy in both.37352021-02-04T21:47:24.24346967Becky BohanThis is long overdue. The women (and men) deserve justice for the wrong doing that happened to create fear and control and for these people to be remembered and pardoned for their convictions.37332021-02-04T21:49:37.94346968Cristina TaurozziI am wholeheartedly in favor for all and each one who were executed and burned. May we give them a place to all those who were accused out of fear and ignorance. May the light be brought to free them from falsities. 37332021-02-04T22:19:17.9246969Katie GroganUrgently needed.37352021-02-05T00:01:11.47746973Stephen MacLennanAll battlefields should be given the highest degree of protection available so that there is never any building on these historical sites.\r\nSo much history has been lost to concrete jungles and it needs to stop otherwise there will be nothing to learn from. There will never be anymore knowledge to be gained from a developed battlefield, history and any future finds will be wiped out, destroyed and lost forever, this cannot and must not go on any longer.\r\nScottish government, please take note.\r\nRecently, we have seen several applications be turned down, now we need to stop any developments from ever happening again. 37162021-02-05T01:05:44.59746974Laura GilbardI've visited the battlefield a few times and find it horrifying that housing units would be built around it. This land is sacred and is the resting place of the Highlanders.37162021-02-05T01:32:55.03746975Kayla Seddon My dream is to visit this place. Please do not destroy it! 37162021-02-05T03:20:41.99346976Melissa LittleThis is beyond ridiculous!! This is a mass grave and a historical place! To even consider this is unbelievable!!37162021-02-05T03:59:23.96746977Caitlin MillerIt is totally unacceptable that Scotland's battlefields are not protected from development. Especially Culloden. The law needs to be changed so that Scotland's history is protected. It should not be up to individuals to continually lobby and protect these sites. It is shameful, truly shameful, that this is going on. If land is needed for development, tell the Queen to hand back Balmoral.37162021-02-05T04:20:34.26746978Heather BinksI believe battle fields should be treasured37162021-02-05T05:47:53.27746981Amy Kelly For our amazing ancestors who suffered such a huge miscarriage of justice. 37332021-02-05T06:42:41.65746986Jeltje Pollock-HeevelI agree wholeheartedly!37332021-02-05T06:52:12.06346987Barry ColvilleThis must be a high priority for the Scottish Government to sustain the fragile local economy's of South Argyll. 37352021-02-05T07:39:42.9346988Todd FergusonBetter protection is required to ensure our battlefields are preserved for future generations. There is undiscovered archaeological evidence which can shed more light on these events. It is unacceptable to have creeping developments and planning applications continually challenging the boundaries. I am calling on the government to extend the policy of battlefield protection and stop further developments and applications from coming forward.37162021-02-05T08:23:33.2546989ELAINE WINGI hope these poor people all get pardoned and a monument is put up for them. Bless them all37332021-02-05T08:59:55.48746991Wilma stuartCulloden should be classed a World heritage site and protected for ever more. This is our history and should never be forgotten. Ruthless Developers should get nowhere near this consecrated ground. The Council should all get kicked out for even considering passing this. They should remember and listen to the people that put them there to work for their community. " SAVE CULLODEN ITS OUR HISTORY".\r\nShould get nowhere near Culloden.\r\n37162021-02-05T09:26:38.63346992Eleanor BarrieScotland's history and heritage is priceless, it's not and never should be, up for debate, up for sale or up for being messed about with. We have lost too much already. Strong protection laws are urgently needed NOW! DO IT! 37162021-02-05T09:29:32.54346994Patricia ForbesCulloden, like other battlefields are sacred to our history and should be protected37162021-02-05T09:46:02.83746995Tricia McNicol-CookTo aid the economy of the Kintyre in the Campbeltown area this is a logical route to help as it is going to be a number of years before the Rest and Be Thankful situation is sorted out. To have a reliable alternative mode of transport is a must.37352021-02-05T10:09:38.32746996David CookThe ferry must offer both an economic alternative to the A83 and a practical timetable allowing say a trip to Glasgow to be completed in a day.37352021-02-05T10:16:32.07746997Bobby McPhersonI support the aims of this petition and hope for a public awareness campaign to improve our understanding of our herstory.37332021-02-05T10:51:49.8346998Carol ReidGive them their place in history37332021-02-05T11:09:53.64746999Mhairi RentonVery necessary link for business, personal use and tourism. The A83 closures are so detrimental to the area in many ways. Additional costs to business being paramount. 37352021-02-05T11:37:38.16347000elizabeth sinclairthis is disgusting its clear there is no justice when you go to the slcc37422021-02-05T11:50:04.57347001Johan AnderssonWould love that the Ardrossan - Campbeltown ferry go all year round. 37352021-02-05T12:09:31.73347002Deborah J ShawI have Scottish ancestors and I love Scotland. Please honor the sacred Culloden battlefield by protecting it.37162021-02-05T12:56:18.1347003Lesley WoodI think the 20 meter rule should be removed because it does not reflect how walking impacts on people like myself who have varying degrees of walking distances determined by how I may feel on and particular day. One day I may be able to walk about 20 meters and the next day I can barely walk a few meters without pain.37312021-02-05T12:56:45.5247004Jacqueline Sidwell I believe very strongly that ALL battlefield sites, all over the world should be preserved and the history of what happened there, the sacrifice of life and the reasons, preserved for all time, so that history and the lessons it can teach us are never, ever forgotten or destroyed.37162021-02-05T12:59:19.81747006Elaine ToddSo much needed. 37352021-02-05T13:16:05.4647007ANITA DUFFYIf a person with disabilities could walk 20metres on a particular day, but that was all......what do they do after 20metres if they can't go any further? If they are in too much pain to proceed? If they collapse? \r\n\r\nSeems a stupid test, if the idea is they can use a bus to get about. A bus only takes you to another bus stop....and then what? Not everything is 20metres from a bus stop!!!!!!37312021-02-05T14:15:19.7547008Elizabeth KellyI live in Galloway and have a son in Campbeltown. This ferry route enables us to visit each other with significantly reduced road travel time and reduces the wear on rural roads. Reduces our carbon footprint too. 37352021-02-05T15:24:14.03747009Jemma BalsdonThis is a wonderful Petition, these poor souls need justice and peace, they will be remembered.37332021-02-05T15:25:42.3247010Edward BrownShould be sailing more regular.37352021-02-05T15:44:16.13347011Misty NelsonMy ancestors gave their lives on those battle fields. Preserve them so their spirits know they did not die for not .37162021-02-05T15:54:10.65347012Wendy Maltman This is excellent news and something that should be protected forever. Sacred sites like this should be left well alone 37162021-02-05T15:58:27.54347014John crowderI have a caravan at Machrihanish and me and the family would certainly use the ferry if it was more reliable. 37352021-02-05T16:03:45.93347015Mairi Burgess As MS is such an unpredictable illness it is very unfair to penalise someone who could possibly walk 20 meters one day and be confined to bed the next. 37312021-02-05T16:07:04.27747016Rona YoungWith all the issues with the Rest and be Thankful it would give an alternative route.37352021-02-05T16:10:26.83347017Catrona LangThe ferry service from Campbeltown to Ardrossan is a great service and greatly missed. It provides a lovely, relaxed journey to Ardrossan with great food, comfort and just a much easier journey than by bus or car. I hope this goes ahead. 37352021-02-05T16:31:17.0347018Miss May GrahamI couldn't believe it when I heard they were going to build on this site its a total slap in the face for anyone globaly who has scottish blood in their veins. I didnt know much about the battle of Culloden growning up as in school we only got taught that the English won and money means more to the English than lives. Recently by watching the t.v series Outlander I have understood what many families whent through in the rise of 1746 and how thousands of highlanders where willing to risk their lives so that their families could eat have warmth and above all Tradition. Many bodies still lie in the surrounding area as the battle did not just happen on that Moor but all over into the woods and hills around. To think that you could have someones ancestor or better yet it could be my own ancestor under your house or in your garden well I wouldn't like to live there. If someone said tomorrow they wanted to build houses on Auschwitz the world would be appauled so why is it any different for Culloden? is it because it happened so long ago and we were all deprived the knowledge as to what happened, I certainly feel like I have been failed by my government as yet again they are failing to protect our ancestors like they did nearly 300 years ago. They will tell us its for houses to HELP people when in fact most of the houses will be for those that already have money and dont need our help its a constant lie they tell us highlanders so we feel pitifull, when in fact its so these politician's can get their fancy house and posh car. To think these men died for the thought of FREEDOM and to protect the highland way of life, just to be dug up someday and thought of like trash is utterly disgusting and shows how the government haven't changed in 300 years.37162021-02-05T16:50:16.44347020Melanie BrehautI feel such an affinity to these poor victims. I definitely would have been tried as a witch had I lived in those times! This is a long overdue apology and memorial and I hope both go ahead.37332021-02-05T17:02:00.9647021John BakesDue to the fragile nature of the A83 through Rest and Be Thankful, we need an alternative route to access the Central Belt and beyond, plus a more regular ferry service is needed to encourage visitors to the area, thus boosting the local economy.37352021-02-05T17:02:02.19347022John BakesDue to the fragile nature of the A83 through Rest and Be Thankful, we need an alternative route to access the Central Belt and beyond, plus a more regular ferry service is needed to encourage visitors to the area, thus boosting the local economy.37352021-02-05T17:07:55.9147023Stephen wyperWe need a reliable service to aid with the commute to Glasgow after the disaster of the rest, and to promote more tourists to the area37352021-02-05T17:09:52.08747024Elizabeth HicksAs a regular visitor to Campbeltown I use the ferry whenever I am home and it is available, I was surely use it more if it was available especially with the uncertainty of travel via road with the condition of The Rest and be Thankful.37352021-02-05T17:26:48.35347025Catherine MuirDefinitely need a service all year round for Kintyre residents,businesses,friends and family going home. The continuous closure of the Rest requires an alternative travel solution, especially for businesses who are relying on transportation of goods. 37352021-02-05T17:34:13.2347026Elaine YoungPeople with a known medical condition should not have to prove they qualify. A medical specialist's letter should be enough.37312021-02-05T17:34:26.4847027Morven mcmanusVital requirement for Campbeltown. 37352021-02-05T17:38:33.4847028Paul BellI could understand if this was a city centre site but to build upon land where people have died for their country is going too far. We need to protect these kind of lands for future generations.37162021-02-05T17:44:12.4547029Stephen JonesIt's badly needed.37352021-02-05T17:44:40.29347030Margaret KellyThe continuing problems with the A83 is a disgrace, especially the length of time the delays and closures have been going on for. It is Argyll & bute main road and it's only a miracle no one has been killed. Scottish Government definitely letting the constituents of A&B down for the past 9 years.37352021-02-05T18:12:18.73347032Allan LangFormerly of Campbeltown. Live in Ayrshire now. Used the ferry a few times to return to see \r\nfamily. \r\n\r\nI believe the ferry is moving to troon from march to allow harbour repairs in Ardrossan.\r\nAlso the Rest & Be thankful closures are not acceptable in this day and age.37352021-02-05T18:13:42.37747033Bobby GilliesIt will be good for a lot of business 37352021-02-05T18:24:47.20347034Tam HarperHaving ferry run all year round would make family coming to visit or us visit them easier37352021-02-05T18:31:52.98747035debbie smithThe locals need this all year round.37352021-02-05T18:39:45.5247036Janice Henderson The ferry is a lifeline in the area. Campbeltown has had so many things taken away, don't add to it. Need to have something to help the area grow.37352021-02-05T18:54:45.11347037Florence McEwanBoat much better than the road especially when the Rest and be thankful is so dangerous. 37352021-02-05T19:09:02.19347038Isabel REdmanVital link for the people of Campbeltown especially with the problems on the Rest and be Thankful. 37352021-02-05T19:14:34.4647039Jacqueline WhiteMakes sense to keep this ferry service all year round, not only for tourists like us, but for the benefit of the whole population of Argyll, easier and quicker access to hospital appointments, essential item deliveries et al given the recent travel difficulties for those affected by the closure of the road before the rest and be thankful, why wouldn't this service make sense, economically or otherwise 37352021-02-05T19:14:36.69347040Wendy crowtherThis would be a much easier way to travel to family in campbeltown.37352021-02-05T19:22:05.19747041Arlene MacleanThe ferry is now more than ever an essential for travel to Campbeltown due to the treachorous rest and be thankful.37352021-02-05T19:24:48.85347042Robert DennisTo the Scottish government and Scottish Parliament at Holyrood protect all Scottish Battlefield's and Wargraves from unscrupulous developments.37162021-02-05T19:26:20.1247043Robert DennisTo the Scottish government at Holyrood protect all Scottish Battlefield's and Wargraves from unscrupulous developments. 37162021-02-05T19:34:15.74347044Angela McMillanA much needed alternative with all the problems at Rest and Be Thankful on A83 to avoid the necessity of long delays and detours in the event of further landslides. Would be good for the local economy and we have a suitable harbour to accommodate a regular ferry service from Campbeltown to Ardrossan.37352021-02-05T19:59:39.0347045Ella MarshallA lifeline ferry is much needed between Campbeltown and Ardrossan.37352021-02-05T20:20:02.5547046Andrew RichardsonA ferry would make my elderly friends more accessible as the drive is too much for them. 37352021-02-05T20:46:35.42747047Susan Hadfield Leave the lands of Scottish battlefields as monuments to those valiant souls. Homes can be built other places.37162021-02-05T20:48:29.78747048Lorna DoxseyUse the ferry to visit family in Campbeltown. Wish it ran all year.37352021-02-05T20:48:56.53747049Karen Readings This is a vital link and would help with the regeneration of Campbeltown and Argyll. The problems with the rest and be thankful are truly awful and potentially cut off the communities on the road up to Campbeltown.37352021-02-05T21:04:01.35347050Fiona irwinFerry is vital for us.37352021-02-05T21:07:49.22747051David BriggsWe have a holiday cottage on Kintyre and our visitors may be put off without options when the Rest has problems. The ferry is as valuable to Kintyre as any ferry to the Islands.37352021-02-05T21:13:19.58347052Linda Taylor I signed this as it is more important than ever given the circumstance with the Rest and be thankful,\r\nI live in Lockerbie and use it to travel to see my family in Kintyre.37352021-02-05T21:36:42.08747053Sandra CresswellVery much needed. 37352021-02-05T21:39:22.21347055Susanne LangThe ferry is a great connection for me to kintyre have used often would love to see it go all year. 37352021-02-05T22:09:44.10347056Kimberly A. BellewPlease keep the lands preserved and intact. These are apart of your history that you can never get back if you disturb the land.37162021-02-05T22:11:27.8147057Susan MCMAHON Our battlefields need as much protection as our war graves, which they are, in many cases. Culloden may not have rows of white grave markers, but the dead lie there, and they deserve our respect and protection.37162021-02-05T22:35:53.78347058Patricia Ann RichNo way anyone should build on Sacred burial grounds37162021-02-05T22:42:25.3147059Ann BakerPlease do not diminish, disregard or destroy your county's heritage. It is what helped to form who you are.37162021-02-05T22:52:08.76747060Diane Taylor-LeighWe need to preserve the past for future generations 37162021-02-05T23:03:20.36747061Vicky SoineThe battle fields are what makes Scotland tourism and history alive . Why would anyone think it's neccessary to do away with them. Leave them be.37162021-02-05T23:27:37.1547062Sarah BaileyKeep a War Grave a War Grave!! Some much was taken from them in life: their lands, their titles, their families, and their culture. Let them have this!! Let them Rest in Peace!!37162021-02-05T23:33:39.67747063Laurie Coppock. Galbraith We need to protect our historical lands be it a ruin castle to acres of land that is a cemetery to many a soldier, farmer, or a clansman. My family was there do not desecrate that moor. 37162021-02-05T23:58:39.5647064Berenice RobertsonPlease preserve Culloden as this is a vital piece of history and a War Grave. Do not allow disrespect to happen.37162021-02-06T00:12:05.2647065Vannia YalanPeople who do not learn or protect history are condemned to repeat the same atrocities. Its happening in Peru and I do not want the same destiny for any other culture37162021-02-06T02:18:40.67347066Camryn Leutgens HollomanPlease protect sacred Scottish ground. My ancestors fought and died for Alba! 37162021-02-06T02:59:29.62747067Kiersten LogsdonI'm from the United States and hadn't even heard of Culloden until, you guessed it - Outlander. I've grown so fond of Scotland and its history. I went on a learning rampage and dove deep into all the battlefields the Scottish of old fought so hard on. They fought for their land, for their people. I believe developing it into anything other than a historical landmark would be a dishonour on those who bravely fought and lost their lives. Please keep Culloden as it is. I know you probably won't give two pennies as to what an American thinks, but know that I'm not the only outsider to Scotland whose heart feels this way.37162021-02-06T07:15:46.6247069Shirley MurrayPlease preserve and protect our battlefields. Its our heritage so many ancestors lost their life's protect their memories and for future generations to visit and reflect37162021-02-06T07:51:12.48347070Heidi Bagley So many lost their lives fighting for Scotland. Let us all remember with dignity, respect, and honour by leaving battlefields places where people can go to do just the above, for Scotland.37162021-02-06T08:04:41.84347071James StrangA life line for kintyre.\r\n37352021-02-06T09:41:0947072Gilbert McKillopCampbeltown deserves to have a ferry all year due to all the difficulties with rest and be thankfully.37352021-02-06T09:52:53.89347073Carine Debos - de La Morinerie Scotland has to protect its place of History\r\nHistory is People memory 37162021-02-06T10:20:32.1947074Catherine ArmstrongThe battlefields are an important part of our heritage.37162021-02-06T10:26:54.05347075John PatersonIt's my history ,everybody's history, leave it alone37162021-02-06T10:58:04.1247076Aileen McBrideThis is one solution to the continuing A83 problems.37352021-02-06T11:05:02.07347077Stephanie AdcockI am planning a trip to Scotland and I want to see the history Please protect the Scottish battlefields37162021-02-06T11:39:52.87347078Mary morransUse ferry to go and see our family in Campbeltown also good for town. 37352021-02-06T11:58:20.7747079Karen DavisWe need to protect our history for our future generations , building houses would be disastrous and disrespectful !37162021-02-06T12:00:00.7847080Karen HicksonThis will be amazingly for the town.37352021-02-06T12:04:35.34347081Kenneth Torrance RobertsonVisit Campbeltown several times a year. 37352021-02-06T12:47:38.14747082George SharpThis route will provide an essensial lifeline giving access to central Scotland and allowing travel into Argyll. \r\nA regular reliable ferry will boost business confidence toward investment which the current arrangments of a patchy seasonal service do not. Added to the appauling situation at The Rest and be thankful this is simply a no brained!37352021-02-06T13:34:17.56347083scott pattinsonScotlands legal system and its reporting body denied me of my human rights....it needs cleaned out!37422021-02-06T13:38:06.8647084Patricia Ann Stewart Fully agree with this petition!37312021-02-06T13:39:47.8947085Alison BrownUse it lots in summer to visit different places on Ayrshire coast which I would otherwise not do, due to long road journey.37352021-02-06T13:42:47.87347086Callum BrownUse in summer for work commitments this takes loads of time of my journey and much better for the environment. 37352021-02-06T14:03:20.23747088Claire SiebertThis ferry service is essential!37352021-02-06T14:07:10.83347089Christina BallBattlefields and buildings of historical important should be preserved and maintained by government for our future generations. These places are our future generations history and should be preserved as such.37162021-02-06T14:17:12.06747090Helen MurphyThis ferry is vital to us especially when the rest and be thankful has land slips. There is no reason we should not have one.37352021-02-06T14:26:20.1347091Deborah StreetI would love to get the ferry across to Campbeltown rather than drive around.37352021-02-06T14:31:36.95747092Neil BertramWe no longer live in the dark ages, wie the associated prejudice of perceived witchcraft.\r\nI wonder how many innocent humans and animals were put to death by ignorant fear and misconceptions...37332021-02-06T14:39:46.6347093Keith CashThe ferry needs to run at a more reasonable times. A late night ferry of a weekend would be useful when attending events in Glasgow that dont finish until late evening. 37352021-02-06T14:47:34.36747094Carolyn MackayPlease protect our heritage and our history.37162021-02-06T14:57:19.7647095Preston MacDougallThey were in England, not Scotland, but the Lancashire Witch Trials were historically important. Those in Lancaster had a very high conviction rate (10 witches condemned in a single trial). But the trial in Samlesbury led to acquittal of all three tried for witchcraft. I am a direct ancestor of one, Jane Southworth, and so was Franklin Delano Roosevelt!\r\nIt is LONG past time to right those wronged!37332021-02-06T14:59:12.19747096Natasha CookTo lose such important history would be unforgivable, how do we educate future generations with property development taking away such vital physical history 37162021-02-06T15:45:05.70347098Marion MullinsWe are regular visitors to Argyll. The closure of The Rest and Be Thankful has a serious impact.37352021-02-06T15:45:29.64347099ROBERT WILLIAMSHaving relations based in and around Campbeltown, as well as Largs, the ferry is a natural and more safe means for us to visit Kintyre more regularly rather than taking the nightmare road. 37352021-02-06T15:52:15.9747100Kimberley JonesI fully support this petition and hope this brings peace to tortured souls and healing to their descendants. The ongoing impact of these injustices is real and something I see daily in the women I counsel. I hope to petition the UK government for the witches of England. 37332021-02-06T15:58:32.8847101Joan Mackinnon The people need transportation the same as everyone else.37352021-02-06T16:33:42.4347104Alisdair omayFerry services required. 37352021-02-06T16:47:21.13747105Katharine ProudfootIt surely makes sense given the regular landslides at the Rest and be Thankful. Both for those living in the area and to promote tourism in a region which will have been badly hit by Covid-19. 37352021-02-06T17:22:45.2847107Maura SullivanCulloden Battlefield is a part of my family’s history. We have an obligation to the men who died on that field to let them rest peacefully. It’s our duty to protect our heritage for generations to come.37162021-02-06T17:37:52.9447108Chris MeadowsWe desperately need this service.37352021-02-06T17:40:34.8647109Chris MeadowsThis service will give a much needed lifeline to our community.37352021-02-06T17:53:30.67347111Raymond HartBe a great idea. 37352021-02-06T18:31:22.5947115Stewart W DonaghyAs the owner of a self catering property in Campbeltown, the unpredictable nature of the A83 is a problem. Small traders in Campbeltown are doing more than their best to improve the town. The Scottish Government needs to show the same level of commitment to the town. When diverted recently, parts of the A82 were also in poor condition. There are four crossings over the Forth for public and private transport. Can we get a reliable road link to Argyll please.37352021-02-06T18:50:44.40747116Lynne MartinLong overdue 37332021-02-06T18:59:55.87347117Thomas SloanLong overdue 37332021-02-06T19:03:02.14347118elizabeth sinclairi think what has happened to these people is just disgusting and it is clear if you are relying on the slcc you will get no justice whatsoever.37422021-02-06T19:33:19.67347119Margaret ScullionWith work starting on 'The Rest and Be Thankful' having a ferry service all year round would benefit countless people and the local Kintyre Community.\r\n\r\n\r\n37352021-02-06T21:49:56.70747120David MCDowellSo many poor souls murdered and tortured for no good or just reason and all this sanctioned by the Church Of Scotland which has failed to atone for its crimes against humanity. 37332021-02-06T22:07:04.29347122Peter Henry This is extremely important to Scottish history, this MUST be done...Save Those Sites!37162021-02-06T23:03:01.6947123Catherine GallagherAn all year round ferry service would provide a vital transport link for a Campbeltown and is needed to support the local economy. 37352021-02-07T01:32:05.7447124Carolina MonrealEvery country should respect and protect their history. The future generations will be able to visit these places.37162021-02-07T02:45:43.06747125Loretta MulhollandThis is a terrible feature of our history and the injustices suffered must be recognized.37332021-02-07T04:41:30.88747126Sheri RubolinoThe battlefield of Culloden and surrounding area is historical and should be preserved for all to know the history of Scotland. Homes should not encroach the land where brave men fought and their bones could still be there!37162021-02-07T05:14:11.62747127Iona Reid The ferry should continue all year as it is. a much more efficient and safe way of travelling to galshos and the central belt. 37352021-02-07T07:01:11.4247128Kristofor Dickinson Having fun watching the view all the staff are very nice great food and drinks and also the service great time in the ferry service ever and always. 37352021-02-07T09:07:21.01747129Su BlackUntil the A83 is a reliable route a regular ferry is essential for the Kintyre Peninsula 37352021-02-07T09:21:19.25347130Jacqui StearnI wholeheartedly support this petition to mark the persecution and state murder of women and men, which I hope is picked up in the other home nations of our islands. 37332021-02-07T09:53:49.4347131Doris SquireI lived and worked in Inverness for just over 3 years in the early 70's. I cannot believe this keeps coming up. If they're told 'no' then is should stand as is. Don't let them take away Scotland's Heritage.37162021-02-07T10:12:05.4447132John McLatchieWe need this service now. 37352021-02-07T11:31:26.31347133Alan DracupAs with the Holocaust, it was a travesty that should not be forgotten.37332021-02-07T15:50:25.50347135Erin CurrieMargaret Currie is also mentioned in a trial of 1654, Aberdour, taken to trial and executed.\r\n\r\nExcerpt from an email regarding family ancestors tried as witches. One of many names that should be pardoned. 37332021-02-07T17:06:09.9547136Ailsa HendersonI think national monuments are an anachronism and seen only by a small proportion of the population - the memorial to these people should rather be in the form of an online presence of some kind - maybe an educational website accessible to all, at all times ,in all parts of the country and the world. 37332021-02-07T17:54:33.30347137Jacqueline BradleyWe have family living in Campbeltown & keep hearing about the landslips & closures at the Rest & Be Thankful. Makes for very long journeys when having to go to Glasgow visiting family & hospital appointments. Also for tourists visiting & when we go to visit.37352021-02-07T18:12:28.60347138Alastair milligan keanIt takes long enough as it is to get to Argyll to visit with family now we have corona issues with rest and be thankfull. A ferry service has been long expected anyway. Before we crossed at Tarbert then drove over mountains to Dunoon. Thats just crazy. 37352021-02-07T18:58:37.56347139Adele Lynch Would be good to see this historic error of ignorance corrected. 37332021-02-07T20:30:13.7547141Craig inKirkyI wholeheartedly agree with this petition which is long overdue, may all those who were gruesomely persecuted and tormented all those years ago between 1563 to 1736 may they all rest in peace! And I hereby commend this petition to the Scottish Parliament and that of Westminster if applicable as soon as possible!37332021-02-07T20:46:56.37747142Mary MacDougall All remote areas like mine deserve all the help they can get. 37352021-02-07T21:51:28.46347143Rebecca B. TigheI have suffered my whole life with the internalized legacy of these horrific acts. I am a descendant of the McGirt and Smith clans. Though I had read or heard nothing of this history, it was written into my body and robbed me of the freedom of expression of my spiritual birthrights. While working with my ancestral trauma with Dr. Clarissa Pinkola Estes, I began to pray and ask for understanding and release for myself and my ancestors. During a weekend workshop, I heard Pat McCabe speak to her visions of the Scottish Witch Trials. This was the first time I had confirmation of the atrocities. Please understand the importance of attending to these multigenerational wounds. 37332021-02-08T00:05:45.5647144Barbara Plowden I believe that new legislation is needed to protect the battlefield. 37162021-02-08T04:14:35.07747145Carolyn SeggieCulloden is a war grave and deserves the same respect as The Somme. NO DEVELOPMENT37162021-02-08T07:03:02.3947146Carol kingTo acknowledge their existence and fir their descendants37332021-02-08T08:01:14.547147Frances KellyCivil rights37332021-02-08T08:15:53.39347148Phoenix Crane I've been to Scotland and England only once, but one day I'd like to take up residence in the UK. I love the history of these nations, and as a witch, I full support this petition. I've been to Salem, MA, which is only a taste of the persecution of women that occurred in Europe, but I found it incredibly moving and inspiring. I hope to see similar educational tributes in Scotland and England, especially.37332021-02-08T10:02:26.09747149Warren DuncanThe 20 metre rule needs to be reviewed and ultimately removed. It causes unnecessary stress and indignity. Scotland wants to be a progressive country the 20 metre rule is not progressive and embarrassing, people are losing out on benefits that they need for a 37312021-02-08T10:03:30.84747150Carolyn WestwoodI reckon that if I'd lived during those years I'd probably have been convicted too. 37332021-02-08T10:11:08.99347151Anthony Ian McLeanHope the Solway Witches are included?37332021-02-08T10:24:48.4147152Harvard DavisBy having a year round ferry service at an affordable price will will cut carbon emissions from cars and lorries as well as enhancing the connectivity of Kintyre to the main west coast hubs of central Scotland. In addition it will eliminate the need to use a dangerous Rest and be Thankful route as well as promoting a tourist route for most of the year to an area of great beauty which has been forgotten and neglected by Scottish Tourism for too long. 37352021-02-08T10:45:25.48347153Claire Boyd As a practicing witch I feel that our ancestors were wrongfully persecuted and executed and should be pardoned . Witches are all about nature , healing and learning. Not devil worship .37332021-02-08T10:46:32.09347154Helen McCrumI believe that the Scottish legal system, is unbalanced and unfair, with no voice for the ordinary person. There is a need for a root and branch review of all aspects of how the system treats people seeking justice. Also organisations such as SLCC, appear to exist only for the self regulation of its own self, from within, therefore anyone from outside in the general public, have no redress, for instances of corruption and wrongdoing of its members, lawyers and QC. Time has come for change, so that people who have been through the Scottish justice system, receive fair ness and complete transparency.37422021-02-08T11:07:02.61347155Paul McCrumI believe that the Scottish legal and Justice system in Scotland, has been broken for many decades. The System requires a total root and branch review, of all departmental operations ,from within and outwith. I have had personal experiences of injustice over the past 11 years of age case my friends have been involved, and may I say through no fault of their own. I personally wrote in support of my friends, to the SLCC, with a detailed description of failings by legal team and other matters of injustice in this case. Thus, I am still waiting for an answer to this or even conformation of my enquiry 7 years later? ? How can this possibility be correct? , that a public body funded by the taxpayers expense can be allowed to act like this? It appears that the SLCC and other organisations within the Justice system, are hiding behind the "cloak and the wig", and the therefore hindering justice to people who have been wronged ,and thrown on the scrapheap of the Justice system and forgotten. How again can this be any sort of Justice? ? So this is why we require this proper review fairly and urgently.37422021-02-08T11:15:13.95747156Iain J McAlisterAs the current road link from Glasgow to Argyll, including Campbeltown - A83 is currently a tenuous link, it is only logical that this area should have a reliable link to aid both the local population, visitors, travellers and businesses alike. Over the last few years Campbeltown in particular has become more isolated due to issues out with our control and has as a result received a raw deal due to this. The ferry is the obvious answer and will ease our problems. I am currently master distiller, distillery manager at Glen Scotia distillery in Campbeltown.37352021-02-08T11:16:07.66747157Barbara jackson-smithPeople with ms struggle to get recognised .If we don't look disabled then to others we are not but that is far from the truth.37312021-02-08T11:23:32.33347158Julia MacMillanIt is time to recognis those whos lives were made a misery by torture and ended by execution all in the name of superstition and fear. They should be recognised as innocent and memorialised out of regret and respect. 37332021-02-08T11:46:11.5447159Sue CooperThe brutality over the years must be remembered to heal the trauma inflicted on so many as we gather again in the feminine energies of care, compassion and truth. Gratitude for all who put their energy into making this happen.37332021-02-08T12:27:20.67747160chloe kanethese people deserve to be remembered as much as anyone else in this world and even more so for being wrongy convicted of witchcraft for just being themselves. 37332021-02-08T13:27:34.82747161Wendy LeonardMost definitely 37312021-02-08T14:00:45.6547162David LangA full time ferry crossing would be a huge benefit to the economy of Campbeltown. The number of people I know that have visited and tried to visit the town but the ongoing issues at the rest and be thankful puts them off. Even when it is open there are temporary traffic lights for ongoing works a good lot of the time. It really has put people off travelling to the town and will continue to do so, imagine being a lorry driver driving that road every day and then on top of that having a diversion to contend with, oh dear!!37352021-02-08T14:16:54.37347163Shona LawrenceWe can't change what has happened in the past, but we can learn from it, we can do our best to make amends, and we can take steps to ensure we never have to live through something like this again.37332021-02-08T18:56:47.5347164John Heirs All year round.37352021-02-08T20:21:16.38747165Kirsty Pritchard About time hopefully will help clear the ancestry line bringing love light and peace37332021-02-08T20:49:42.12747166Jamie BlairHaving gone through this process it's a shambles!37312021-02-08T22:43:46.4247167Alice Waugh WaughAbolish the 20 metre rule It is so unfair 37312021-02-08T22:55:05.1447168Sharon CollinsThis petition is a relevant statement not only for women wrongfully convicted but also as a statement against injustice against women kind today. 37332021-02-08T22:58:09.03347169Sharon CollinsThis petition is a relevant a statement against wrong doing against the wrongfully convicted. It matters not that these were different times, wrong doing against womenkind is never something we must sweep under the carpet of history. It is a statement as relevant today as it was then. 37332021-02-08T23:17:37.94347170Janet SchipkrIt's time to acknowledge and remediate a great injustice - the torturous deaths of so many innocent people. I fully support this campaign.37332021-02-09T03:49:07.68347171Norma BarclayI hope we lead the way in looking at our past and learning. ..Eyes open however difficult the view. Best wishes to ScotGov.37332021-02-09T05:41:35.6247172Starmond GarthWe must preserve the past or our current past will also be forgotten and erased.37162021-02-09T09:10:29.6647173Mary DouglasThe 29 metre rule impacts heavily on people with MS. It can be a fluctuating condition which makes mobility possible on one day but not on the next. It is not a fair measurement of ability37312021-02-09T10:05:29.03347174Stewart Fotheringham Make a decent timetable, so it enables day trippers,from Ardrossan and back on same day......37352021-02-09T10:12:30.0347175Catriona ReynoldsWe use the service most summers would really love to use it during the winter months.37352021-02-09T10:14:46.6147176Alexandra ColesThis would be most beneficial given the situation with the A83.37352021-02-09T10:16:09.29747177Scott KinniburghEssential service 37352021-02-09T10:19:17.51347178Alex mcmillan Would benefit the community a lot.37352021-02-09T10:47:46.8347179Kimberley K. Stone This pardon and memorial is integral to healing the colonialist history of Scotland. 37332021-02-09T10:51:21.2747180Lorna StephensonI think this should be considered a lifeline. Also anything to help the area recover 37352021-02-09T10:58:59.69747181Camille CostanzoI have been to Scotland and have visited Cullodon...would not like to see houses go up on the Battlefield over someones grave!37162021-02-09T11:01:33.8247184Audrey VictorI believe there will be a collective healing experience for the ancestors of those who were tortured and brutally murdered during this terrifying era of injustice and irrational fear. For some this may be a massive inner shift and other it may be just a long deep exhale and release. This is vital work you are doing I support it wholeheartedly! Rest in peace all those lost through injustice 37332021-02-09T11:54:50.48347185Sarah Ebbs Please start the healing 37332021-02-09T12:03:06.26347186Helen MitchellYou have the most amazing history, please don't destroy it. Tourists like to go there and pay respects. You are a great country keep it that way.37162021-02-09T12:54:47.5547187Linda PatersonThis would be very beneficial for the tourist industry for the town and surrounding areas especially with the Rest and be thankful out of commission quite a lot37352021-02-09T14:06:17.68747188Elizabeth GreerVisiting relatives in Kintyre very difficult due to rest and be thankful being closed. 37352021-02-09T14:08:37.2247189Sharon Taylor KerrWith the continuing A83 headache this would be a lifeline to the local community and those who travel to Kintyre often. 37352021-02-09T14:46:54.78747190Malcolm McMillanThe trial summer ferry service from Ardrossan to Campbeltown has demonstrated the benefit of additional transport links to the area can bring particularly for tourism. \r\nGiven the reputational damage that the past and present RABT closures has done to Argyll & Bute as a tourist and business destination, a year round, RELIABLE vehicle ferry service should be considered a minimum requirement to begin to amend for the negative impacts of the RABT closures for the last two decades. 37352021-02-09T15:35:14.0347191kenneth alexander macintoshshould be removed37312021-02-09T15:59:44.01747192Paul A HumphreysAn alternative to the Rest, what a boon for tourism for Campbeltown and Kintyre.37352021-02-09T17:32:37.64747193Sharon BellThis would be both a vital link for the community but also for tourism. The impact of the A83 problems means that travel for essential purposes is often impeded and visiting tourists are deterred from planning holidays in Kintyre.37352021-02-09T17:35:09.447194Lesley Smith MitchellCampbeltown needs a Ferry on a regular run all week not when there are gaps in other routes and not when Ferry on run is needed on another run.37352021-02-09T18:40:20.99747195Jane WhitehallIt would at least be another travel option especially to ayr.37352021-02-09T18:55:21.15747199Catherine McDougallPlease give Campbeltown a chance! A ferry is not a luxury but a much needed lifeline. For too long the A83, Rest and Be Thankful problem has been ignored. A reliable, dedicated ferry service is needed ASAP!!!37352021-02-09T20:07:00.79747200Trevor Swistchewin 2021 it is time to remember all who were targeted by ignorance and false belief 37332021-02-09T20:20:24.31347202Edward BrownThis route should be given to another operator who are willing to operate a more regular service.37352021-02-09T20:24:10.3147203Elsbeth McGaughrinIt's time to talk about the accused as people in the wrong place, time, and religion. And hopefully not make the mistakes again37332021-02-10T08:58:36.8347205Steven Holgan The 20 metre rule is a ridiculous concept. Just because someone can walk more than 20 metres does not mean they can go about a normal working day in many workplaces. I find myself potentially having retire early as I can't do my normal work duties do to MS...and I'm one of the lucky ones. Some people struggle with many normal functions but may still be able to walk 20 metres. It is an absurd rule.\r\n37312021-02-10T14:20:09.0547206Kim ChrystieIt should be the disease and not the symptoms the system should support. 37312021-02-10T14:37:07.14747207Dr Rachel PetrieMS is a fluctuating condition with many different disabling symptoms which are poorly understood by most. Whether someone can walk 20m has got very little to do with how disabled someone is. Please involve medically qualified professionals with assessment of disability. 37312021-02-10T14:45:29.7447208Christine Hunter20 metre rule should be removed. \r\n37312021-02-10T15:05:28.8747209John Wright DuncanUsing herbs and experience to heal people is not witchcraft. They did not inject poisons into people's arms to prevent a illness or anything. There are no records of any witches landing badly which would be hard to believe without the proper training.37332021-02-10T16:01:07.33347211John RichardsonI run a B&B and a self-catering place and have long argued for a more frequent ferry service. The cancellation of the ferry service in 2020 due to Covid-19 is plausibly understandable but not sustainable without a huge impact to Campbeltown and the surrounds. \r\nThe ongoing farce of the A83 RABT (not blaming the people working there, they do a great job) and the halfway house solutions have led us to the point where in 2020 we had 60-mile diversions on an already long journey.\r\nI have written to the First Minister and the Transport Minister as well as anyone else who will listen so to see this additional petition is welcome.\r\nIf the government are serious about economic and social recovery from Covid-19 and years of poor transport links then they will view this petition and realize its importance and value to the region.\r\nThe fact that there has to be a petition for something so obviously needed is a disgrace in itself, but here we are. 37352021-02-10T17:18:06.56747212Isabel BarkerDefinitely should be removed and soon.37312021-02-10T17:19:36.3647213George BarkerDefinitely needs to be removed.37312021-02-10T17:30:01.0347214Fiona KellyMy daughter was diagnosed at 18 last March she has good days were she feels good but her bad days she can't walk from the living room to the kitchen as her dizzy spells are very bad 37312021-02-10T17:35:35.4147215Stuart UsherThe Scottish legal system is a disgrace to the country. This particular case is just one of thousands of cases where the victims of Injustice were not accorded the Justice by the Scottish Legal Justice system.37422021-02-10T20:19:21.07347216Hilda EdgeContinuing and long standing problems with the A83 at Rest and be Thankful create regular serious disruption for travellers. This is of special concern when ambulances are being used to transfer patients to hospitals in Glasgow. A daily ferry service would be hugely beneficial to both residents and the tourism industry generally. 37352021-02-10T22:05:04.3747217Ashley weirBrilliant campaign and love the fabulous website. 37332021-02-10T22:31:47.5447219Rebecca SmithNow is the time to understand our connection to the elements in our world. Our connection to nature, animals and the earth elements. It is a true, deep connection and a birthrite. No one should be prosecuted for honouring and celebrating this. 37332021-02-11T11:15:09.2147220Diane HoggShould be removed, not a concept that is realistic, MS sufferers are not all unable to walk, I can walk but in debilitating pain, but I don't count, so as a progressive illness that affects sufferers at different levels it shouldn't be taken into account how much you can walk. MS doesn't go away they need to get that through their heads its progressive and painful unless they have it they will never understand.37312021-02-11T13:44:42.88747221Lili C RehakDefinitely need additional legislation to protect Scottish Battlefields as witnessed by the thoughtless encroaching development on these historic sites.37162021-02-11T13:53:23.85347223Alison ChandlerWould really give a message about what Scotland is instead of its colourful past, would respect what women are not what they are not and send a message to developing countries who still believe in witchcraft. 37332021-02-11T15:10:23.147224Alison RalstonI would definitely use this service more often if the timetable was more frequent and the boats used more reliable. Too often passengers were stranded without a vehicle when breakdowns or weather disruptions caused the sailing to be cancelled at short notice. This ferry link would definitely be preferable to the road alternative due to the ongoing disruptions and uncertainty with the A83.37352021-02-11T17:15:00.3847225Sharon MackintoshI back this petition 100%.37332021-02-11T18:06:28.34347226Bernadette BlackieThis would be a great acknowledgement for today's society to recognise the atrocities of the past based on fear, difference and lack of understanding.37332021-02-11T19:06:36.92747227Colin Cassidy Long overdue 37332021-02-11T19:57:01.07347228Mandy SamsonI painted one of the witch memorial plaques in Dalkeith so have an invested interest in them being pardoned37332021-02-11T20:43:41.00747229Sharon Craigmyle What a brilliant campaign \r\nI believe that no known person should be condemned for using nature 37332021-02-11T22:44:21.64347230Cathlene McGregorThe time is now to change this unjustified law. Witches are healers!37332021-02-11T23:50:13.18747231Joan FlynnWorth a vote!37332021-02-12T07:34:06.9547232AILEEN HuttonIt is vital that this ferry service is retained to boost the economy of the kintyre peninsula and further afield 37352021-02-12T07:48:26.48347233Mary BlairWe need to stop allowing the scape goating of innocents and take responsibility for looking the other way when injustice occur. These were real people like you and me.37332021-02-12T09:11:45.26347234Robin MillerI regularly travel to Campbeltown and the summer ferry service makes the journey much easier, even without the never ending delays and diversions at Rest and Be Thankful. As well as benefitting road users the ferry via Ardrossan effectively adds Kintyre to the rail network, which has to be good for the local economy.37352021-02-12T09:33:13.76747235Geoffrey TraceyThe abuse of women by casting them as witches in the past radical environment of oppression by abusive power is a terrible scar on the legacy of humankind and on natures wisdoms. This petition may not ever heal the pain caused to our ancestors for the persecution and pain visited on them but at least it can show willing and humility and recognition that what happened was wrong and there is intention to allow space for this healing to happen in. 37332021-02-12T09:45:03.00347236Donal NolanThe Scottish government are well aware that the judicial system in Scotland is flawed, the number of complaints that MP, and MSP receive every year proves beyond a shadow of doubt that this unfair and unjust process has to be changed and policed by an external committee to make sure that justice is served and the judiciary do not have the final say Mo Ali explained how her role as a former JCR (Judicial Complaints Reviewer) was a complete waste of time as her finding were never upheld and the Lord President had the final say. TIME FOR CHANGE37422021-02-12T11:34:27.78347237Isla WilsonWould really benefit from year round Ferry37352021-02-12T11:49:32.39347238keith abendrothThere should be a year round ferry provided Cal Mac can ensure the service will be reliable & not haphazzard as it has been in the past37352021-02-12T12:09:14.4847239john dobsonThis suggested ferry link would not only be lifeline but would be very environmentally friendly as it would cut the time on the road.37352021-02-12T13:21:30.847240Jill JohnsonIt's well time to right past wrongs against these brave women. 37332021-02-12T14:34:23.27747242Ruth FindlayThe 20m rule is discriminatory against people with MS. Many of us find walking painful and our conditions are highly variable.37312021-02-12T14:43:57.07347243TERRY SMITHMuch needed link with the mainland, A must37352021-02-12T14:48:55.27747244lynda smithImportant link for tourism to Kintyre peninsula37352021-02-12T14:58:30.98347245Elizabeth Valerie NimmoAs a member of Campbeltown Community Council, I know how important an alternative route to the Central Belt is to local industries and to tourism. Poor transport links are limiting tourist expansion in our area.37352021-02-12T17:28:53.45747246Karen KirkwoodVery overdue 37332021-02-12T18:41:10.13747247Donald SutherlandCulloden has such historical importance in the very being of Scotland. It represents a time of tyranny, of untold brutality, that changed a way of life for Scotland. This was not Scotland v England, it was religion v religion, relative v relative. The repercussions of which have shaped a country, it must never be forgotten. 37162021-02-12T19:19:07.36347248Kay BrownThere is insufficient planning protection in Place to protect sites like the battlefield in Culloden. Something needs to be sorted once and for all to protect this war grave 37162021-02-12T21:48:50.46347250Christie HunterWe are the granddaughters of all the witches you were never able to burn. 37332021-02-12T22:42:15.81347252Maureen BeattieAt last!37332021-02-12T23:38:28.4247253RennieAnn LindsayI'm all for this pardon as members of my family only boys at the time were among them37332021-02-13T07:55:51.97747255Elaine KeyteThis service would undoubtedly improve all transport links for Kintyre. On the periphery, a robust transport solution has yet to be found for us. Yes there are many factors beyond our control. I can only see, at this present time, the ferry to be a viable service to reduce our isolation when the road network fails.37352021-02-13T08:47:12.62747256Stephanie FowlerWe must preserve these historic battlefields. They are part of our heritage and history as well as being the last resting place of brave soldiers.37162021-02-13T12:12:35.15347259Iona macphail Much needed service for this area 37352021-02-13T13:38:37.61747260Paul PatersonDefinitely agree, This 20 meter should be scrapped! I have multiple sclerosis and things change from day to day one day I can reach the 20m next day I can't even get out of bed.37312021-02-13T16:15:58.98347261Doug JamesFully support37012021-02-13T16:19:44.43747262James DuncanAs a very ancient country Scotland simply must protect all our battle grounds, history and culture. as an ancient country Scotland must protect our battle fields, our history and culture37162021-02-13T18:09:34.1747264Marie MacLeod These women who were forced out of a mainstream society that found their wisdom intolerable should be honoured for their courageous example.37332021-02-13T20:53:22.56747265Ruth HadlandI have made the journey from the Midlands, up to four times a year, since I was a baby, I'm now 40. To have the option of the ferry all year round would be a fantastic addition for me and my family. More importantly, I know what a much needed link it is for those that live and work in Campbeltown. 37352021-02-13T21:12:03.58747266Warren FergusonClans are deeply connected to these places. Respect.37162021-02-13T21:36:23.51347267Mrs Hazel MeldrumSuch an interesting topic and campaign. The podcasts reveal many of the reasons, power and control behind the accusations. 37332021-02-14T06:43:41.347269Steve Lucas As a regular visitor to Scotland, obviously not in these times, I support any measure which will restore life and beauty to the current semi-desert state of the land. 37012021-02-14T14:51:01.4947270Elizabeth Mccrimmon It would help Campbeltown when the Rest and be Thankful is close37352021-02-14T16:07:58.33747271Jana BrentThis battlefield is the resting place of many. It should be protected.37162021-02-14T16:56:25.44747272Elizabeth AdamsAlways started too late and ended too early in the year, with the state of the road now an essential requirement37352021-02-14T17:32:09.95747273Lance MooreRewild, not destroy37012021-02-14T19:03:55.42747274Emma FolanThe 20 metre rule needs removed. This is not a realistic measure of MS sufferers disabilities. It can vary greatly depending on the day. This is discrimination. 37312021-02-14T19:37:39.39347275Robert BoydJustice For Us Witches.\r\n37332021-02-14T19:49:47.0547276Shirley parkerAll life is sacred.37012021-02-15T10:26:08.38347277Ian MalonePollution comes in many forms, please say no to unregulated abuse in the wild.37012021-02-15T13:37:54.86747278Brian DicksonTotally agree with this petition and it is time to at least acknowledge these terrible wrongs done in the past37332021-02-15T13:41:28.50347279Jane PorteousI believe we should have a museum. A building in my town built in 1812 came up and I put forward that suggestion but it is now business premises and a restaurant. It would be the only one in the world as far as I know 37332021-02-15T14:28:21.93747280James StrangIt would save time and wear and tear on car37352021-02-15T14:29:36.46747281James GroutCampbeltown needs alternative route as well as the A83 that has been closed for many months. A ferry service would open new opportunities for Kintyre 37352021-02-15T14:54:18.88747282Peter McCuaigDefinitely,should halve been done years ago and by that,I mean a fulltime service. 37352021-02-15T16:09:50.2947283Ian MacfarlaneSelf-evidently, for as long as the failure to adequately address the long-standing issues of unreliability of the Rest-and-be-Thankful section of the A83 continues, alternative routes are essential to meet commercial, social and medicative needs.37352021-02-15T16:21:07.62347284James McCallumArgyll will need every improvement to services and infrastructure it can get, if it's not to become a desert for young folk and business.37352021-02-15T16:57:13.3847285Fiona TaitThe 10-year timeframe for a permanent solution to the issues on the A83 at Rest and Be Thankful is far too long for the local business and for Tourism. Provision of an all year round ferry would ensure that the economy of the area is is not compromised any further in these challenging times. The Scottish Government must address this issue as a priority. 37352021-02-15T17:22:49.72747286William Anthony BranniganI do think that this ferry would be a great advantage to our area. It is a pity that it could not incorporate at least a once a week link to Ballycastle37352021-02-15T17:26:42.9647287Patricia O reillyIt should be an open route for cars to..with priority given to commercial37352021-02-15T17:49:08.44747288Campbell FoxThe Kintyre Seasports SCIO, a Campbeltown based collective of community groups and water sports clubs,has major potential to attract adventure tourism and maritime events to Campbeltown, as well as providing educational and vocational training facilities in winter. A year-round ferry service would undoubtedly help to realise the full potential of the project, and this petition has our wholehearted support. 37352021-02-15T18:47:22.56747289Alison RalstonIf this ferry service could guarantee a timetable that promoted a sensible schedule for tourism and local travel it would be well supported. However the contractor would have to ensure that the boat was one that could cope with the demand and minor weather disruptions. People lost faith in this service because of cancellations at short notice, stranding people miles away from home with no car and no availability on public transport. I think lots of people would use this ferry to avoid the unpredictability of the A83 at the Rest & Be Thankful.37352021-02-15T19:16:53.2447290Mary MarrisonA vital lifeline between Campbeltown and the central belt37352021-02-15T22:22:13.48747291Jamie G. MacTavishIt could be a handy link with so many problems at the Rest and BeThankful on the A83.37352021-02-16T04:59:28.6247292Marygrace LuciaAbout time..lest we forget37332021-02-16T08:17:21.56747293Ella EdgarSafer journey than the Rest & Be Thankful37352021-02-16T11:36:06.2247294Robert ChickenWith the A83 no longer fit for purpose, this ferry service is essential37352021-02-16T11:52:36.88747295Charles TierneyIt's got to be done37352021-02-16T14:15:08.1547298GillianIt is simply the right thing to do. We do so much to support women today, let us extend this through the centuries. Saor Alba. 37332021-02-16T17:12:57.57747299Jean MoffatA necessary lifeline for Campbeltown 37352021-02-16T17:31:25.8647300Keith Crawford The provision of a permanent ferry link between Campbeltown will provide greater choice for tourist and resident alike. As a resident the existing provision does little to encourage Kintyre residents to use the service in conjunction with the rail service to Glasgow. This can only be done on one day a week (Friday). A permanent link would benefit residents wishing to visit the Ayrshire coast and beyond to a much greater extent. It would provide a good alternative to the road trip over the unstable Rest and be Thankful and the potential delays and lengthy diversions that we have seen for some time. \r\n\r\nKintyre has a tremendous potential for visiting tourists seeking an alternative or extension to the very popular and busy North Coast 500. A permanent link between Campbeltown and Ardrossan will allow travelling tourists to consider the road trip down the Kintyre peninsula and then leave via the ferry instead of currently seeing the drive down the peninsula as one which they have to repeat because the ferry service is limited. A permanent service has the potential to hugely increase the tourist traffic and the spending power of these tourists in our many varied businesses in the area. \r\n\r\nA permanent link therefore would be a benefit to both residents and tourists and should be considered as a positive addition to our ferry services. 37352021-02-16T19:20:53.10747301Alan Boyter May help to take pressure off the A83. 37352021-02-16T20:50:44.13347302Joan BarclayYes37352021-02-16T21:36:59.75347303Stephen SharpSort this37352021-02-16T21:45:00.6147304Vanessa RoevesLong overdue and time to give those who died in such horrendous circumstances peace37332021-02-16T21:47:58.17347305Kelly GreigCouldn't agree more. Those wronged should be given a memorial and allowed to rest peacefully.37332021-02-17T00:43:56.38747306Heather PlaizierSooo much pain came of those trials and continued through the generations....37332021-02-17T04:16:12.27347307Kimberly Shackelford This battlefield is a burial ground for so many. They deserve to rest in undisturbed peace.37162021-02-17T10:57:04.85347308Jason SmithIt surely must be beneficial for these grouse moors to be more efficiently managed to help stop the flooding and reduce the impact of fires. And surely that will benefit far more than those who go to shoot the grouse which must be a far better thing. And if the grouse moor owners aren't willing to do this then they are denied a licence. Period. And the land turned over to be better enjoyed by many more and returned to be a much better environment for humans and nature in its many ways.37012021-02-17T13:34:20.92747309John lewisFerry is essential as A83 is not fit for purpose and closed most of the year37352021-02-17T16:47:48.78747310Thomas Tyler We must get behind this petition, you only have to read up on the hundreds of sites in England that are being lost just to build the H2S rail line. 37162021-02-17T17:17:12.1247311Louise RamsayIt is time to change the way we use our uplands. For the sake of climate action we need to rewild, not up burn Heather and kill predators for grouse shooting. The sport has had its day. 37012021-02-18T05:10:09.3847314Marie Lee It is an absolute disgrace for anyone to want to build on or close to this battlefield, war grave site. Is it ever acceptable to desecrate soldiers or any graves? The Scottish government need to stop this indefinitely ,right now 37162021-02-18T07:00:09.8847315owain williamsThe ferry service would be especially useful in the present circumstance.37352021-02-18T09:30:58.72747316Patrick HermannThese plans show no respect for your own history. These people who have planned it trampling over the memories of thousands of Scottish heroes.37162021-02-18T09:47:30.79347317Christian BucherThose who do not honour the past are trampling the future too... in such moments I am ashamed to be a human. 37162021-02-18T10:48:28.7847318Don DennisEspecially needed as the Rest & Be Thankful is shut so often now..!37352021-02-18T12:39:33.01347319Annemarie Baxterthere seems to be a complete disregard for our history recently, we need these areas to be fully protected\r\n\r\n37162021-02-18T12:49:10.8147320Andy MylesThis was a wrong created by teh old Scottish Parliament - and the new Scottish Parliament should put it right.37332021-02-18T14:05:34.27347321Margaret MartinOur history is important to all of us to disturb our battlefields is an insult to our history and to the men and women who fought there37162021-02-18T16:00:26.55747324Alan Cardwell What is the SNP doing about this shameful project-\r\nparticularly Nicole Sturgeon ?37162021-02-18T16:30:58.6647325Andy TaylorThe covid pandemic has decimated the taxi trade. Even though drivers can work, there is very little business out there. Monthly costs of running a cab are huge and these fixed costs still need to be paid. This is not sustainable much longer. Losing money every week.37372021-02-18T16:47:53.27347326Anne McPherson Please save this sacred history 37162021-02-18T17:06:43.06347327Steve HaithRewilding is important to us all37012021-02-18T18:00:06.71347328Margo Dunlop MurrayI always visit the Murray memorial when I am in the area.37162021-02-18T19:42:49.2947329Andrew SmithThere should be no need for a petition as with the Rest and Bethankfull in the condition it is in and no sign of a remedy in the near future, the ferry should be a fore gone conclusion for businesses and the hole community of Kintyre37352021-02-18T22:25:56.7847330Gus LaurensonConnectivity is vital to the area and the A83 is not reliable.37352021-02-18T22:27:19.7247331Ann Marie LaurensonYes this is vital to the area.37352021-02-18T22:54:34.43747332Madge FiShooting birds that are used to humans feeding them isn't sport, it's barbaric 37012021-02-18T23:11:53.62747333A. E. Claridge-ElstobA vital link for those on the Kintyre Peninsula.37352021-02-19T00:10:58.73347334EMILEE A RANDALLPlease protect these historic places, no amount of profit is worth the loss of our history!37162021-02-19T08:42:44.48747335JAMES Stewart SAMSONIt's time the taxi industry was treated with the same respect as the train and buses.these two individual transport providers swallow up any government subsidiaries time after time.if the scottish government want low emmision zones then fund it properly.37372021-02-19T08:58:09.5247336Jolyon GrittenWith out a reliable transport link for HGVs to Mid Argyll and Kintyre we will all have pay additional costs for deliveries and have to accept delays. Many companies that offer free delivery to consumers elsewhere change for delivery at present, this has an economic impact for many. Garages often struggle to get parts delivered meaning cars take longer to repair.37352021-02-19T09:16:48.9647337Steven bruceYes Covid 19 has decimated my business and my way off life37372021-02-19T09:30:39.0947338Thelma BanksNew legislation is required to protect Scottish battlefields37162021-02-19T09:37:50.16747339Philip DuncanEdinburgh council still charging test fees I am struggling to pay these 37372021-02-19T09:50:42.93347341Stephen knoxCovid has destroyed the taxi trade37372021-02-19T10:08:53.9247342Scott William GrayAs a new taxi driver I got no support whatsoever from the government as I don't have 3 year's tax returns to go by which I feel is totally wrong, I am still a taxi driver trying to get buy the same as a driver of 3 to 30 years who got help.37372021-02-19T10:17:06.2847343Steven smithPlease protect the trade37372021-02-19T10:19:05.92347345Peter KeeganAs a result of the Scottish government giving the taxi trade no financial support except a flimsy 1500 in 11 months I and my wife have no savings left, shame on you 37372021-02-19T10:22:32.53747346Anna RooneyMay tyranny end and we break cycles of silence and suffering 37332021-02-19T10:22:54.95347347Lynne Logan Please help we are really struggling and not getting a lot of help we are desperate are lively hoods are at risk and done of us could go bankrupt through no fault of own we need more help from Nicola sturgeon who is basically sitting on funding and not delivered to most business 37372021-02-19T10:27:0747348Gina TownsleyFamilies from taxi trade are suffering and falling into mental health and bad health due to the lack of financial support from our Government help us now please and stop suffering in many ways to our families37372021-02-19T10:27:55.6147349Jonathan BurnsAll three, valid, requests are necessary to pursue. As the pandemic has highlighted. Most taxis will require replacement for emissions. Lack of work, at present prohibits the move to cleaner vehicle, at present. A decent body for collaboration and debate are required. In my opinion\r\n 37372021-02-19T10:39:33.89347350Ryan Mclauchlan 2 months to go and I am bankrupt 37372021-02-19T10:46:51.5247351Thomas Bradley I support free masks for everyone 37742021-02-19T11:23:47.66347353Catharine ForbesThis ferry service would be of great benefit to all businesses that depend on visitors to our village.37352021-02-19T11:28:38.48347354Donald McAllisterAn excellent idea to support all businesses in the Mull of Kintyre as well as the islands of Islay, Jura and Gigha whilst the problems at the Rest And Be Thankful continue37352021-02-19T12:23:59.9747358Brian DaviePlease help.37372021-02-19T12:25:29.92347359Steven Fraser COVID has decimated my business as a taxi operator i need airports,restaurants bars , people in offices and tourism !!37372021-02-19T12:27:10.84747360Jacci Miller This year has been extremely difficult financially and mentally. Our work is down 80% and sitting around for hours on end is not helping. We need more government help. £1500 for the year does not help in the slightest. We are now slowing getting trickles of work to take people for covid vaccine, we NEED ours ASAP 37372021-02-19T12:30:53.62747361Billy AnsonThe Covid 19 Pandemic has affected our business massively37372021-02-19T12:31:02.12747362Philip BurnsGreatly reduced income 37372021-02-19T12:31:55.56347363James MagennisHELP!!!!37372021-02-19T12:34:26.00347364John TaylorIncome has been slashed to less than 25% off income plus still have the same business costs .\r\nMajor discrepancy between what Scots drivers have been offered financially in comparison to Wales and N.Ireland the other devolved nations 37372021-02-19T12:37:06.47347365Raymond callaghanNot enough support out here working all hours for nothing time you take running cost and fuel you have basically no wages37372021-02-19T12:37:42.06747366Alexander WattsDestroyed all savings, and currently heading for bankruptcy. 37372021-02-19T12:39:16.23747368Andrew CliffI feel that not enough has been done to support ALL\r\nTaxi operators and Drivers. My income is less than one fifth of what it used to be. Yet operating costs remain at usual levels. 37372021-02-19T12:41:16.45747369Eleanor LaurdHaving a cabbie on the family and seeing how financially crippled they have been is harrowing 37372021-02-19T12:44:15.4147370Pat veitchThe effects of covid has had a huge impact on my earnings .people to work from home - no bars restaurants cinemas theatres and people to stay at home ! No work 10 hour shift 30-40 less diesel and expenses . Mental health being effected trying to keep my taxi on road and pay my household bills .37372021-02-19T12:51:22.50747371Harry wardIt is actually embarrassing the amount of help our trade has had from our government 37372021-02-19T12:51:59.0247372sarah fieldI hope that a road equivalent tariff will be applied so that people can afford to use the service.37352021-02-19T12:53:39.7147373William MitchinsonHelp independent operators 37372021-02-19T12:56:14.3847374James McgaugheySave my business, I've invested 60k on an electric taxi 37372021-02-19T12:56:23.91347375Stephen DavidsonI rented my taxi before the covid know I can't afford to rent one as I can't make enough to cover the rental and expenses. Currently I am depending on help from the government to survive. God knows how the owner drivers with huge debts for the new taxis they had to purchase to abide by the new emissions rules coming in soon from Glasgow city Council. 37372021-02-19T12:56:59.8847376Philip StauntonLoss of taxi trade has left me with no savings left as I had have to support my business 37372021-02-19T12:58:51.147377Richard TodTaxi owners have been excluded from business grants because we have no fixed premises, this is completely unfair and unacceptable as we have numerous fixed costs such as\r\n1 High vehicle purchase and finance costs\r\n2 Substantial insurance costs\r\n3 High Licensing costs\r\n4 Road tax\r\n5 Repairs and servicing costs37372021-02-19T12:59:41.58347378KENNETH MURRAYAs a Taxi owner I do not feel there has been enough support from the Scottish government. 37372021-02-19T13:00:16.97747380Edward forrestLast time Worked was October37372021-02-19T13:08:42.44747382Andy StewartThis has been one disastrous year and we need a lot of help, particularly getting Glasgow City Council to put back the emission dates.37372021-02-19T13:09:29.61747383James LairdTaxi trade needs massive help 37372021-02-19T13:10:07.97747384Eamon CroweTaxi trade devastated. Spending three to four hours on ranks between jobs hires.\r\nWe are down on our knees37372021-02-19T13:10:32.49347385James LairdTaxi trade needs massive help 37372021-02-19T13:12:09.41347386William crilleyThe support for the taxi trade has been horrendous income has been reduced by about 80 percent the Scottish government has been too slow to help out the trade financially37372021-02-19T13:12:40.1547387Martin WoodThis pandemic has seriously affected my business finances and so has therefore seriously affected my domestic finances, I am struggling to pay bills and sinking into debt.\r\n37372021-02-19T13:16:58.58747388John GallowayWe need a voice 37372021-02-19T13:20:57.6847389Margaret andrewEssential for Kintyre with the Rest and be Thankful out of action most of the time.37352021-02-19T13:21:23.55747390George newallWe need help to survive37372021-02-19T13:28:24.19747391Martin ShieldsWe need support to the taxi trade 37372021-02-19T13:31:27.13747392Philip DuncanHaving problems affording fees for test37372021-02-19T13:32:45.04347393John DochertyA year round Ferry Service between Campbeltown and Ardorssan is now priority.37352021-02-19T13:36:58.43347394Peter HendersonI am a taxi operator i am struggling financially 37372021-02-19T13:41:47.15347395William AdamsDue to the various lockdown I have only managed to work 24 shifts due to the lack of night-time economy. I don't receive the EISS and have been living off savings and a works pension37372021-02-19T14:06:11.32747396Alexandra GomezI believe a road equivalent tariff should be applied so that people can afford to use the service.37352021-02-19T14:07:04.42747398Michael osborneThis pandemic has crippled me & my family, can't survive much longer as it is !37372021-02-19T14:19:10.39747400Roger PatersonLoss of 128 days of work 0% income for this period. SEISS grant very much welcome but know other financial help even though its obvious there is no economy for us to generate an income from and no financial help of any form.37372021-02-19T14:21:06.62747403James Caldwell As a taxi driver my income has been affected with no wages coming in and household expenses on the rise and when you go for financial support they seem to stall which is causing more stress in the household 37372021-02-19T14:26:24.86347404Syed kazmiWe have been struggling all the way since he start of the pandemic 37372021-02-19T14:42:23.4147405Terence nealonCould not claim 1500 grant to all taxi drivers. As licence suspended due to illness. I had a heart procedure 19.8. 2020 I reported it to council 25.8.2020 glasgow licence did not suspend my licence until 23.12.2020. This meant my licence was suspended between 9oct and 31dec and therefore not eligible for the govt grant.if glasgow licensing had acted on the date I emailed 4 months earlier I would have been eligible for the grant.37372021-02-19T14:45:08.36347406Steven Webster Covid has severely impacted my financial ability to provide for my family. It has also caused me severe stress and mental health issue, and the Scottish Gov have done nothing realistically to help our trade it is disgusting and heartless.37372021-02-19T14:55:33.14747407ronald mcalisterIncreased frequency and RET should promote this route to a reviving area.37352021-02-19T14:58:42.30347409john mcsorleyTaxi drivers have a hard enough job as it is without living on the breadline. 37372021-02-19T15:08:41.74347410Paul HendrieStruggling with overheads of £1040 + every month just to keep business on the road hemorrhaging all my savings that took me 49years to get, please help37372021-02-19T15:23:34.7347412Andrew McDonaldThe Pandemic has been a disaster for the Taxi Trade and for me because I'm type 2 Diabetic and my Wife has Medical issues I haven't worked it's only because of the UK Government giving us some Money that we've been getting by, but we have been living off our savings, the amount we got from the Scottish Government was a Joke, we need help the Welsh Government gave their Taxi Drivers £4k to help them.37372021-02-19T15:43:38.10747414John MckinstryAs a non radio taxi all I can depend on is people walking into my taxi off the street37372021-02-19T15:46:12.9547415Brian dowieReally been affected with COVID regarding lockdown. Still waiting on the financial help despite applying 3weeks ago37372021-02-19T16:28:17.4447416Peter DOUGLAS Brown£1500 grant whilst welcome is an absolute joke, my business cost are £800+ per month for radio, HP on vehicle and insurance and thats before we start counting fuel, repairs licences etc\r\n37372021-02-19T17:44:50.29747418Mandy Taylor Drivers are struggling to be able to fed themselves and their families 37372021-02-19T17:52:14.79747419Thomas McmahonA worthy cause. Trade in need of substantial injection of cash. If not forthcoming there might not be trade to return to. 37372021-02-19T18:24:43.3547421Elizabeth SomervilleA time when science was deemed superior to natural therapies, and still exists today. Fortunately we are not condemned for being different today 37332021-02-19T18:28:28.91347422Jacqueline Cameron Absolutely. So many people horrifically murdered. 37332021-02-19T18:34:10.86747423John McCaddenOnly fair that Taxi operators are fairly treated.37372021-02-19T18:36:16.41347424Stephen KellyWith A83 not reliable we need an alternative route.37352021-02-19T18:37:58.19347425Alison KellyEssential as the Rest is not reliable 37352021-02-19T18:41:21.71347426Allison NicolTime for pardons and peace to all who were executed.\r\nPardons and apologies are long overdue to all who were executed.37332021-02-19T19:08:56.8447429SHARON IRVINGI strongly agree. The loss of life and torture endured by innocent victims accused of witchcraft should never be forgotten. A national monument would serve not only as a place of remembrance for the victims but also as a warning of the dangers that prejudice and ignorance can bring to humanity 37332021-02-19T19:41:51.5247431PETER MACDONALDUntil the A83 Rest and be thankful problem can be successfully sorted for good the Ferry link should be an upgraded all year round service. 37352021-02-19T19:55:10.75347432Joanne BurkeAgreed37352021-02-19T19:59:58.2747433Duncan MacFarlaneDisgraceful way to treat innocent people who were put through hell by the establishment who preached love one another. 37332021-02-19T20:50:43.74747434Kenneth WallaceThis ferry is not only needed but it is imperative to the economy of Campbeltown. This ferry service needs to operate all year round and not only during the summer period.37352021-02-19T21:12:47.29347435Jacci Miller We have not had enough support, £1500 for a whole year is nowhere near enough when our earnings are less than 30%37372021-02-19T21:29:43.48347436Steven McternanI'm 54 when the pandemic started I was working and my wife had not worked for over a year. We have both worked hard in our lives and had decided my income could support both of us with me working some extra hours and she could spend time with the children. The pandemic has meant I now work from around 8am and am still working until after 10pm 7 days a week with my income now about a third of what is was previously. Thankfully we have had help through seiss and my wife has managed to get a job to help out. Although this is helping it is certainly not the life we had worked so hard for all our days. The help from the Scottish government has to be quite honest terrible. Thanks for reading. Steven Mcternan 37372021-02-19T21:40:15.76747437David Moyes I feel that there has been very little done to support the black taxi trade throughout this COVID 19 pandemic37372021-02-19T21:49:45.73747438Keith BarclayTakings are a fraction of what I was earning pre Covid but my outgoing have remained the same as before 37372021-02-19T21:53:16.45747439Sheena ArmourDue to state of A83 this would be a huge benefit to this area and build on tourism37352021-02-19T22:24:04.52347440Pauline LowThese women were targeted because they practised white medicine, looked different or did not conform to the norms of society at the time. They were tortured and "confessed" whilst no doubt hallucinating. We should remember them nationally.37332021-02-19T22:33:48.71347441Dave WardYes, a well needed service both for locals and businesses alike.37352021-02-19T22:42:47.40347443Roger StockmanWith the uncertainty and the continuing problems with the rest and be thankful road to the kintyre, the ferry is a lifeline for this community that I hold close to my heart,37352021-02-19T23:52:35.22347444Yusef JamaIf the Welsh Government can allow taxi access to the discretionary Grant, on the understanding of the impact Covid19 has had on the trade. As they are linked with hospitality, leisure and tourism, which has had additional support. Our trade should not be treated any different. This is a clear breach of inequality towards a specific business which needs a fair level grant system. Many drivers are going through anxiety, depression and even suicide thoughts due to the lack of support which can only end in tragedy for some families. Thus, I kindly request you to rethink the decision making as an error and take everything in to account the same as other businesses.37372021-02-20T03:30:29.2247445Todds TaxisNo operator support which is where most of the expense within the trade lies . Unable to get strategic framework as no premises yet the cost of vehicles on the road is a lot more than that a premises may bring 37372021-02-20T06:45:19.5447446Brian AllenAs a key worker who doesn't seem to be recognized, we need this backing, unlike phc we have followed strict guidelines and deserve better.37372021-02-20T08:33:36.72747447Stephen DochertyTo not make the Hackney driver the only taxi to be used during this pandemic has been a disgrace. They are the safest without question. The also stick to the rules !! Shame on you Glasgow. Honest hard working people. But we back others. Shameful 37372021-02-20T10:39:15.94747449James McKenna Taxi drivers need more assistance as our takings have gone down by a substantial amount. Earning £30 for a 12 hour day !!!37372021-02-20T10:41:40.88747450Hugh MckayCovid has affected my income drastically. Financial support has been negligible. Without proof of income, accessing financial support is non-existent.37372021-02-20T11:56:59.7447453George Hugh KellyDue to lack of financial support my credit history has been destroyed in less than a year as I can no longer keep up repayments on credit cards etc and my ability to obtain credit to replace my taxi with a green alternative.37372021-02-20T12:31:41.6247455Brian McGheeTaxi industry has been decimated 37372021-02-20T13:41:14.45747456Alistair TaitEmergency help is needed for the taxi trade, many are going under due to no income and high running costs.37372021-02-20T13:42:20.8847457Margaret McAteerTaxi drivers and owners need support during this Covid crisis 37372021-02-20T14:42:45.247458Alexander McLaren Decimated trade 37372021-02-20T14:56:36.21747459Stephen MonahanReview low emissions please. 37372021-02-20T15:39:34.26747460MICHAEL MCKAYAs a taxi driver if my wife did not work, I would have no income coming in to pay for my mortgage, car or food. We are struggling to cope with this pandemic. The money we have received from the government helps but it is not nearly enough. Taxi drivers need a lot more support from the Scottish government. We still need to keep the taxi roadworthy and to do that you need to work. There is no money for the upkeep of running the taxi on a day to day basis. There is no money for insurance ( £1000 - £1500 approx), no money for test work (£1000 - £2000 approx). We need help now.37372021-02-20T15:46:59.9647461Michael FultonCovid 19 has reduced my income to zero37372021-02-20T16:24:12.83747462Sophie Gore BrowneThe pain and horror of this injustice done to healer women still lives with us today - carrying a cultural collective trauma which has separated women from their innate earth connected wisdoms which are such a healing force for change at this 11th hour for the environment. This acknowledgement of the injustices done could make a real difference for those who feel called to any ancestral trauma they may still carry.37332021-02-20T16:26:31.94747463Jamie stalker Needs to be done37372021-02-20T17:50:45.39347466Owen Gallagher Help needed ASAP before I go bankrupt 37372021-02-20T17:53:54.3847467Peter GibsonRediculious how we have been treated37372021-02-20T18:29:50.80747468John Easton The grant of £1500 was a help but not enough 37372021-02-20T21:09:08.14347469Aileen ForrestA must for the community of Campbeltown and surrounding areas as the route via rest and be thankful is becoming too dangerous.37352021-02-20T21:39:15.347470Edward GriceAs a Private Hire Driver in Glasgow, my income has been terribly affected by the pandemic with a drop greater than 50% of turnover. Financial support from the Scottish government is woefully inadequate. I have fixed costs of around £1200 per month, but we have only received a one-off £1500 grant. The grant only covers just over one month of fixed costs. I have been unable to access loans to stay afloat, and instead have now got a £1000 overdraft that I can only hope to ever pay back. Meaningful help is urgently needed in our industry.37372021-02-21T00:12:30.5147471Stuart BurnsOnce again I find myself signing yet another petition to ask for something that we should have as a right! Firstly I had a 7 year old taxi but because of the City of Edinburgh Councils policy of not accepting the Vehicle for testing due to the euro 4 diesel engine I was forced to buy another vehicle costing £58500.00 having 2 years earlier finished paying my last taxi off £37000.00 , I never chose this as my previous vehicle was perfect and would have ran for many more years, thus I am now saddled with more debt than my flat cost me, twice in the space of 9 years but for reasons that haven't been explained the payment holiday on the energy saving trust loan was stopped and we now get to pay half the loan payment, Why? There is no work for me at all so the least that could have been done was to halt the payments until this is over.Let me give you a breakdown of this , self employed support grant in January £3417.00 City of Edinburgh Council £1500.00 grant in January total £4917.00 costs for the Taxi vehicle £3991.45 which leaves £925.55 over six months so I am left with the ridiculous sum of £35.59 per week over six months to live on. If for any reason you cannot understand this, as is clearly the case so far? Perhaps you should think about the £5.08 daily amount I have been left with to live on. \r\nIt's very sad but if you don't support me I can't support you, any of you, maybe you should take a good long hard look at the devestation wrought on people like myself and there must be many, I feel we may need to seek redress through the courts for our losses.\r\n37372021-02-21T08:30:29.37747472Paul Paul BarrettNever once mentioned in any statement regarding poor financial support to taxi industry37372021-02-21T08:38:25.12747473Petra CoveneyI support this petition in support of all\r\nPersecuted women37332021-02-21T08:51:11.62747474Abu MansurHi there , my income is very much less because of COVID-19. I am self employed and it was good before start the COVID-19. Thanks 37372021-02-21T09:23:21.9547475Louise DaillyWe do not believe in satanic or his works, witchcraft is all about good health, love and harmony 37332021-02-21T09:40:17.8747476Paul DuncanWithout help for our trade operators like myself will be out of business in a couple of months. Yesterday i received another letter from my finance company pressurising me for my taxi payment. This is starting to wear myself and my family down as we spiral deeper into poverty 37372021-02-21T09:46:47.46347477Rob CarlyleSo important37012021-02-21T11:21:07.747478Hazel RobinsonLong overdue - time to try and make small amends to all those poor folk and families who suffered.37332021-02-21T12:58:00.2747479Susan RitchieTreat the taxi trade fairly and the support other small businesses have been given37372021-02-21T13:34:33.6447480Rita BlairWould be safer than road a lot of landslides in that area37352021-02-21T14:12:06.47347481Chris ShiltonAlso vital to encourage Tourism to Kintyre.\r\nQueued last summer to use the OMR on the way to Carradale. The ferry would encourage many. 37352021-02-21T14:21:04.56747482John McGouldrick Like many other small businesses in the service sector my earning potential has completely disappeared. There is very little custom for the taxi trade and while I have received government support this is based upon my income and does not take account of the cost of the vehicle and other expenses. So in reality the cost of the vehicle and the license and various other expenses now come from the 80 or 70 percent of what the treasury sees as my income. Having said that I am still more fortunate than many who are not eligible for the scheme. 37372021-02-21T14:41:37.27347483Laura DarlingThese were real people with lives and families, who suffered horrendous fates for no good reason. They deserve to be to be remembered as such, rather than reduced to caricature and novelty.37332021-02-21T14:42:21.5147484Mary ThomsonAs my daughter lives in Ayr this would be a route we have used to visit her in the summer so a better ferry connection would be advantageous to us, especially if the Rest and be Thankful was closed.37352021-02-21T18:46:36.26747487Raje HarwoodAs a child I lived on the UK. At age six I saw a 'dunking machine' like a teeter totter, over a river, that was used to hold 'witches' and adulterors under water, and heard the explanation that this was punishment levied usually without a trial, and punishment for being suspected of being a witch or an adulteror was public shaming and drowning. I have never forgotten how I felt, seeing that, and knowing in that instant how evil and unjust people were. In later years I realized that the 'witch' was often a woman who lived alone in the forest just outside town, a woman so well acquainted with plants and their healing properties that she was often sought out by townspeople suffering all kinds of ailments who then took her herbs and were healed. Only when the 'law' accused her of witchcraft no one dared to stand up for her and instead witnessed her being cruelly and publicly tortured to death. I picture now this pardon and asking for forgiveness from the spirits of those brave women, and from their descendants, and a beautiful artistic memorial being built to honour those brave and intelligent souls.37332021-02-21T20:07:31.88747489Sara de RoseFor me, magic is real. I am sure that at least some of the women who were accused of witchcraft also believed in some form of what we now call magic. Yes, I believe these women need to receive a profound public apology for what they experienced. But perhaps not an apology for being what they very well could have been. Witches in the most real and positive sense of the term.37332021-02-21T23:01:00.2347490Naomi McAuliffeImportant to right these wrongs.37332021-02-22T00:42:30.55747491Elizabeth Sutherland This would be a great service for me and my family especially as the rest and be thankful is closed so often. \r\n37352021-02-22T09:04:57.5447492Evie PrydePlease keep Argyll open.37352021-02-22T10:53:27.7147493Christine Upfield This is an important issue for Scotland's heritage37162021-02-22T10:56:09.0347494Graeme MunroWish I was furloughed like every salaried job . It's ridiculous the begging procedure we have had to go through to get the grants that we have been entitled to.37372021-02-22T11:37:47.82347496Edward Wallis This pandemic has had a monumental affect on taxi business we need as much help as possible 37372021-02-22T12:36:08.4947497Robert CairnsAlways measured against the UK when doing well so why not measure us when doing badly\r\nMeasured against the rest of the UK when we are complimenting ourselves but not measured when wales have given £6000 and n.i. £3000 37372021-02-22T14:23:05.347499Mark McKay Lost 80% of our income.37372021-02-22T19:03:16.9547500Jennifer Marie GillmorIf there is any such way to honour our fore-bearers so unfairly convicted and cruelly punished, I am all for that!37332021-02-22T21:08:19.47747501Derek CrawfordI want to work37372021-02-22T21:43:27.26347502Jean Kelly Essential service for the growth of tourism and business both in argyll and in Ardrossan areas. Would promote more tourism in both areas and provide a much needed link due to road issues. 37352021-02-23T02:57:22.90747506Glenda BoltCultural resource management practices for a high level resource such as Culloden must value the space around a battle site. Sense of place, viewscape, sound levels, long term protection are all part of caring for a historic site of this level. I encourage you not to succumb to short term gain and think more about the educational opportunities to tell the story of your magnificent country and the cultural burden this historic site played a role in. 37162021-02-23T07:10:56.71747509John BennettStop this madness37162021-02-23T08:39:35.96347511Mark mckay 75% of our income disappeared overnight.37372021-02-23T08:43:49.68347512Lesley Glenn\r\nHistoric sites must be protected from development. 37162021-02-23T08:47:23.8147513Teresa HartThis is a war grave and should be treated with respect37162021-02-23T08:54:52.01347514Alison Corley-RhodesThis is a war grave site. How can it be built upon?37162021-02-23T09:26:00.11347516Graeme OrmistonEvery other business getting financial, yet with outgoings upwards of a 1000 per month. 37372021-02-23T09:26:17.847517Muhamah ArshadHard for us37372021-02-23T09:27:24.84747518Graeme OrmistonNeed financial help ASAP 37372021-02-23T09:31:20.06747519Peter corsie As a owner I feel we have been left behind other small businesses or taxi is our business drivers do not have the same out goings as a owner\r\n37372021-02-23T10:00:08.24347521Gary McIntosh My income has dropped by 80 percent but my running costs like the test fee and insurance have remained the same 37372021-02-23T10:01:12.47747522Gavin Tomlinson We need all the help we can get 37372021-02-23T10:17:05.4847523Peter corsie As a black cab owner I feel we have been left behind as a small business and as a owner we have more out going than a driver 37372021-02-23T10:44:49.3947524Angus OliphantWe are really struggling to survive with very little help from the council or government 37372021-02-23T11:19:23.92747525Matt JonesAs a taxi driver we desperately need support!37372021-02-23T11:50:20.91347526Dawood Masood The Scottish government needs to support the public transport sector as it has other businesses. The lock down was enforced by the government to protect the vulnerable people, it's outcome has been devastating to all trades especially the taxi trade as we have had almost 0 help. 37372021-02-23T12:03:41.7647527Bill NeilRunning out of money 37372021-02-23T13:18:44.17747529Mark Cullen As all politicians and health experts have received full pay all the way through the pandemic. I have received £1500 in total throughout the pandemic.\r\n37372021-02-23T13:24:00.39747530Nessue ReillyThose wronged are long overdue a pardon and should rest in peace37332021-02-23T13:43:48.4647531N. WalkerAs. Battlefield and war grave it is disgraceful to even contemplate development. There should be protective legislation in place to stop this issue from ever arising.37162021-02-23T14:03:38.93347532STEVEN ROYI am a full time taxi driver and due to the current climate due to covid I am finding it impossible to cover overheads which consists of unavoidable costs such as loan for new vehicle I had to buy also service plan combined with insurance, road tax which continue to run. Also the obvious home expenses. I am unable to advance my business in any due way to the regulations set for the trade all i can do is sit and wait for hours currently giving a return of less than minimum wage. I am very grateful for all the assistance been offer but i feel if business continues to be so poor i fear i will have to fold my business.\r\nThank you \r\nSteven Roy 37372021-02-23T14:39:38.38747533Liz Quinn Ferry is now more than ever an essential for travel to Campbeltown due to the treacherous rest and be thankful.37352021-02-23T14:44:59.76747534Habibur RahmanPlease help us the difficult time!37372021-02-23T16:50:43.56747535May CurrieAlternative route instead of A83. 37352021-02-23T17:34:03.6547536Abid MahfoozProtect Local Black cab jobs 37372021-02-23T18:34:5047537Peter corsie Taxi owners need help asap the bills are growing 37372021-02-24T04:57:17.10347539Frances Marlene CookThis is so important!\r\n37162021-02-24T07:36:07.33747540Philip SiddallCampbeltown needs a year round link. After all it is 2021.\r\n37352021-02-24T09:30:31.6147541Christine dooganRest and be thankful issues are making campbeltown and surrounding areas more cut off than ever. Access for medical appointments in Glasgow is becoming harder and having a huge impact on those who rely on them. 37352021-02-24T12:15:54.87747543Angela JeffsLong overdue. Criminal negligence in itself. \r\n37332021-02-24T13:25:32.3747544Des DiversI an a Dunoon Taxi driver and have found it almost impossible to get financial help during this pandemic including no help when forced to self isolate. 37372021-02-24T13:38:31.27747545Nancy HopeSafer Option. 37352021-02-24T14:55:06.9947547Alan WylliePlease rethink this. Find a better way of accessing needs without putting arbitrary barriers in front of disabled people.37312021-02-24T16:00:46.93747548Tina JacksonThe 20 metre, should be scrapped.37312021-02-24T16:01:09.48347549Hazel RutterI like the new name definitely should 'adopt' it.37312021-02-24T16:02:35.1747551richard holderI cannot walk 10metres let alone 20metres37312021-02-24T16:02:50.5847552David Allen20 meters gets me nowhere it would leave me stranded in the middle of nowhere exposed and extremely vulnerable. 37312021-02-24T16:02:54.6147553Anneliese PatersonMultiple Sclerosis is a variable and unpredictable condition , making the ruling unfair 37312021-02-24T16:04:11.34347555Diane MortimerThe 20 metre rule should not apply. 37312021-02-24T16:04:53.09347556Roger HortonI wish to support this petition.37312021-02-24T16:05:35.59347557Tina MarshallEvery day is different for people with motor skills disability and the 20 meters is not an indicative measure of abilities37312021-02-24T16:05:40.2247558Marie CorbettI have MS and some days I can do 20mtrs some days struggle to do 2.37312021-02-24T16:06:54.15747559john DohertyMs is a one way street for all who suffer. It is a disability downhill with years of suffering with no light at end of tunnel WE HAVE A DUTY TO LOOK AFTER OUR FAMILY AND FRIENDS THAT CANNOT LOOK AFTER THEMSELVES THEY ARE IN PAIN AND MISERY EVERY DAY.37312021-02-24T16:07:02.5347560Pat Crossley20 metre rule should be scrapped.37312021-02-24T16:07:11.6147561Brenda WhitleyI agree that the 20 metre should be removed and who ever thought up this rule made go on his or her bare knees for 20 metres. Imoral rule37312021-02-24T16:07:28.59347562Rachel BaileyWhere on earth is 20m going to get you? 37312021-02-24T16:07:54.90747563Bernice G AddisThis rule should not be applied to MS sufferers and is discriminatory. It is not realistic as disability can vary from day to day. Some days 20 metres might be possible but in immense amount of pain and on other days one can not even get out of bed.37312021-02-24T16:07:57.07747564Cathy DavidsonNot everyone is the same or day by day can be different please ban 20 metre rule for the whole of UK37312021-02-24T16:08:05.09747565Thomas DiganI agree the 20m rule needs to go my wife has ms and on a good day she may walk further than 20 m but most of the time she cant walk half of that she was on a lifetime mobilty award for 20yrs at the higher rate now she gets standard rate and was too scared to appeal and is terrified when the assessment comes37312021-02-24T16:09:02.1447566Alan MestonDue to my MS and the Covid restrictions like the 20m rule, I rarely go out as my balance, coordination and poor strength in my legs means I would be in breach of the rules.37312021-02-24T16:10:05.23347568Rebecca VallanceUnderstanding the disease and the enduring ups and downs both physically and mentally moment by moment. 37312021-02-24T16:11:01.7247569Rachel BaileyWhere on earth is 20m going to get you? 37312021-02-24T16:11:03.6147570Juanita WoolliscroftI have MS amd my walkingability fluctuates37312021-02-24T16:12:23.9447572Frances StewartMS ability to walk varies almost daily and no way can it be judged on 20 meters anytime 37312021-02-24T16:12:25.5847573Linda MurdochPeople with MS suffer37312021-02-24T16:13:14.73747574Vincent AshtonI have MS with seizures and it can vary on how far I can move in any direction. This ruling goes against others who are not able to cover this distance.37312021-02-24T16:14:11.34347575HELEN MACKENZIEIt is a scandalous and disgusting rule. You take away our dignity or what is left of it!!37312021-02-24T16:14:16.3647576Anthony LeeThis rule is cruel.37312021-02-24T16:14:19.1647577Shane EdgarMS is always there but noone can predict from day to day or even hour by hour how much it will have effect. I know having ppMS.37312021-02-24T16:14:36.1947578Catriona HalketThe 20 metre ru!e would be a joke only it isn't funny for people with ms37312021-02-24T16:16:29.03347579Chrissey Dunford The 20 metre rule is completely inapplicable to people with MS. It is discriminatory and, as such, should be illegal. Please try to understand what having MS entails and remove this inappropriate rule. Thank you.37312021-02-24T16:16:33.15747580KENNETH MACKENZIEI feel this rule is disgusting and undignified to those who have to go through these rules made up by able bodied people. Should never have been allowed in the first place.\r\n37312021-02-24T16:16:44.347581Yvonne WelshThe 20 metre rule is ridiculous having MS I may be able to walk it once but there is no thought if I could get back the 20 metres or I would even be able to walk it again let alone the same day or even the next day 37312021-02-24T16:17:22.95347582Jane KimberleyI have MS one day I am able to walk a mile to the shops on another I struggle to get around the house 20 m rule means this disability is not understood and is unfair to sufferers of MS37312021-02-24T16:17:50.39347583Dr June LuchjenbroersMS sufferers have highly variable abilities in 1 day37312021-02-24T16:17:58.9147585Jane ShanahanYes definitely, just to determine how someone is physically by walking 20 metres, is not understanding what MS is or its symptoms. From AM to PM can be make a difference for someone with MS! If you have a mobility problem & a diagnosis - this should be enough information needed.37312021-02-24T16:18:25.45747586Rebecca WestMS symptoms are so complex and the ability to walk 20m does not reflect the severity of MS symptoms which fluctuate within a day 37312021-02-24T16:18:52.73747587david mackenzieMy mum has m.s. and this rule is outrageously, and undignified that she has to go through this and gets herself all upset unnecessarily. Scrap the rule and give her what dignity she has left.37312021-02-24T16:19:19.98747589Kerry HammondIt is totally unjustified for a panel of people who does not suffer from MS have the right to say whether the 20 meter rule is correct. I challenge any able bodied person to step into my shoes and cope with MS for even a day, let alone the rest of their lives. The 20 meter rule needs to be scrapped NOW, it is totally unacceptable to have this rule.37312021-02-24T16:20:25.14347590linda JanschIt's discrimination 37312021-02-24T16:20:28.39347591sharon mackenzieThis is one of the worst rules that has ever been created. M.S. is a soul destroying disease so give those sufferers some dignity at least.\r\n37312021-02-24T16:20:58.12747592Gordon HastieMS difficult to understand even when you live with the condition, the idea that a stranger can judge your condition & abilities based on walking\r\n20m is astonishing! \r\n& highlights that the decision makers do not have any knowledge of issues they pass judgment on37312021-02-24T16:21:04.42347593Robert Robertson Each and every step is uncomfortable becoming painful in a couple of steps \r\n37312021-02-24T16:21:07.84747595Kerry HammondIt is totally unjustified for a panel of people who do not suffer from MS have the right to say whether the 20 mtr rule is correct. I challenge any any able bodied person to step into my shoes and cope with MS for even a day , let alone the rest of their lives.The 20 mtr rule needs to be scrapped NOW, it is totally unacceptable to have this rule.37312021-02-24T16:21:43.51747596Carol Ann WynnI am a Multiple Sclerosis sufferer and have been since 1991. Year on year i am getting worse and the 20m rule is discriminatory toward me and other people. Please scrap it for me, my daughter and the thousands of others who have this debilitating condition. 37312021-02-24T16:21:50.23747597Julie Davidson 20 metres is a totally unrealistic rule. For a long time the symptoms of MS can vary day by day. Some days walking is possible, on others it is not and even getting around the house can be an insurmountable task. It is in the best interests of everyone to ensure that all people with MS remain as independent as possible for as long as possible and this includes the best interests of the nation's finances. 37312021-02-24T16:22:24.81347599Kim Sharpington I suffer with psoriatic arthritis, one day i am able to get around & manage my pain, next day im like a 90yr old with a lot of pain.37312021-02-24T16:23:48.70747600Paul BoyceAlthough I am now almost fully confined to a wheelchair or recliner, I know from bitter experience that the 20 metre rule is assessed by people who fail to understand the changing nature of MS37312021-02-24T16:24:08.23747601Robin CoeRemove this rule please as unfair as changes happen daily some days better than others37312021-02-24T16:24:22.6647602Tina StarrRespect differences, treat each case as an individual person, and offer help according to their needs37312021-02-24T16:24:44.3347603Marina mollins I suffer osteoporosis and athritis , there are some days i cannot walk at all without pain and discomfort 37312021-02-24T16:25:41.51747604Rebecca VallanceThe 20m rule does not apply to any individual with MS because the disease is moment by moment, hour by hour, day by day inconsistent. One day not able to move and another able to walk to the shops. It affects every part of the body, brain and central nervous system. It's still not completely understood so how can it be qualified by PIP rules. Just having the diagnosis should be enough as it's both a physical and mental illness. Please reassess and listen to those that have it. Why are MS patients treated with such suspicion when their lives are so diminished by this deliberating illness. The loss that MS patients have to endure is immeasurable. No two cases are the same and the disease is life changing, life shortening and life quality reducing. Most can't work due to exhaustion, brain fog, cognitive challenges. Most employers haven't got the time or money to employ MS patients due to the inconsistency of the disease and ability to function from one day to the next. Why do they have to prove themselves. Its discrimination on every level. Dignity and respect is not part of the Adult and disability payment.37312021-02-24T16:26:18.9147605Barbara ScottThis arbitrary rule is no measure of the needs of someone with MS. It is a disease where no two people have the same issues and the effects it has change everyday. My neurosurgeon can't explain or predict this chronic disease so a standard form or a generic health care worker certainly can't. I can guarantee that every MS sufferer would trade their disability allowance for full health everyday. In short the 20m rule should be removed immediately, regardless of where the applicant lives.37312021-02-24T16:27:10.47347606Helena ToyntonHopefully this helps xx 37312021-02-24T16:27:16.5547607Anita RadfordMS can change from one day to another so the 20 metre rule is unfair to MS sufferers and should be scrapped totally.37312021-02-24T16:28:57.1347609Julie GrisiThis arbitrary distance is idiotic! 20 metres doesn't get you anywhere. Wake up people! You try walking in a disabled person's shoes! :-(37312021-02-24T16:29:20.28347610Shuffle Bucket I just agree with scrapping the 20m rule as I am disabled and struggle to walk37312021-02-24T16:29:56.12747611Susan HaywardMS disability is about more than the walking distance37312021-02-24T16:31:17.39347612Tom HunterThe 20 meter rule has nothing to do with measuring someone's disability is was thought up by politicians and civil servants as a rule to unfairly discriminate against disabled people and unfairly stop them for claiming the mobility section of PIP.\r\nIf I cannot walk 20 meters reliably, repetitively or safely. Just because I can force myself on the odd occasion whilst in pain doesn’t mean I can do it every day.\r\n37312021-02-24T16:32:13.64747614Roderick C McKayAs a person who has lost a Sister to MS and has a nephew who is suffering from MS I find this rule a slur on all right minded persons, and it does not only affect MS sufferers many stroke victims are made to suffer from it as well.37312021-02-24T16:34:26.6347615Dana Farren20 metre rule is not practical or fair and should be removed from ADP37312021-02-24T16:34:57.3547616Heather RyeA person with ms may be able to walk 20m one day but unable to the next. I therefore think it's a very unfair way to assecess peioples mobility 37312021-02-24T16:36:48.50347617Giovanni NasilloWe MSers have already lost so much37312021-02-24T16:37:51.19347618Len stoneCrazy unfair rule37312021-02-24T16:39:11.9947619Mrs Frances MannThe 20m rule is so unfair for people with MS, whose demeanor can change during the day from being mobile to bedbound37312021-02-24T16:40:12.97347620Ivor DavidsonThis arbitrary rule is profoundly discriminatory against MS sufferers, whose condition can vary enormously day to day and who are very frequently unable to move a fraction of this distance without immense struggle and indignity. 37312021-02-24T16:40:28.9947621HEATHER khebabi No I do not everyone with ms has good and bad day37312021-02-24T16:42:21.45747622Judith hudsonThis is not only insulting it is also degrading to ask anyone to perform such an assessment criterion37312021-02-24T16:42:22.64747623Grant MillerThe 20 metre 'rule' is, and has always been a ridiculous measure of mobility. There is nothing that can be done within 20 metres of my front door, Nearest Bus Stop is over 1,000 metres away, when arriving at the shops there are none within 10 metres of the bus stop (have to get back to the bus afterwards, remember, and then home from the bus stop). It is a really false measurement of mobility....37312021-02-24T16:42:30.00347624Pam HughesThe 20m rule is not realistic and needs removing37312021-02-24T16:43:34.3547625Carol Burnside The 20 meter rule is ridiculous. I could probably manage it with assistance but on my own it just wouldn't make it, I know I would end up falling37312021-02-24T16:43:38.77347626Hope RobertsonNeeds to be scrapped asap! MS takes many forms one day could possibly manage 20 metres next not even 20inches! Obviously rule decided on by someone with no idea of MS so just plucked number out of fresh air totally wrong!37312021-02-24T16:43:59.4647627Ross SmartWhat's next a 10m rule, seems to get lower the longer the benefits system continues.37312021-02-24T16:44:08.66347628Wilma BrownPlease scrap this unfair criteria.\r\n37312021-02-24T16:45:40.55347629June AndersonThis is absolutely disgusting. SNP try harder to sort this out.37312021-02-24T16:45:54.4347630Myra MacDonaldC'mon SG! You are better than this.37312021-02-24T16:46:30.05347631Tracey CulbertOne day I can, half an hour later I can't! All ms'ers can relate...37312021-02-24T16:46:37.05347632Marlon MeedinMS doesn't necessarily mean you cant walk more than 20 metres. Scrap this ridiculous rule now.37312021-02-24T16:47:26.02347633Diane BellThis is long overdue - a pointless rule which has no bearing on the needs of those affected. 37312021-02-24T16:51:17.1847634Aileen Arthur20 metres! Please remove this please. It is an unfair measure especially since MS differs from person to person and very much depends how the condition affects an individual on a daily basis. 37312021-02-24T16:51:47.3547635Virginia NelsonThis is something I feel strongly about. The 20m rule is discrimination 37312021-02-24T16:53:26.38347636Victoria MellingThe 20m rule is definitely flawed especially for ms sufferers where things can change drastically from day to day.\r\n37312021-02-24T16:54:23.74347637Jennifer M BeattieI live with mobility problems not connected to MS but I know a few folk who live with the condition - we're not all that dissimilar. The last time I attended a face-to-face session for a DWP assessment I had to use my manual wheelchair - not exactly easy for someone with fibromyalgia and having to propel myself around since my support services had already been cut, The 20m rule is totally nonsensical!\r\n37312021-02-24T16:55:19.9647639Caroline DayThe 20m rule is discriminatory against MS sufferers and should be removed.37312021-02-24T16:55:21.7947640Maria Kidd20metre ruling should be scrapped37312021-02-24T16:55:30.19347641William McKissockI have 10 years with MS, the good days are OK, 20m on a bad day is impossible, can any government assure me of a good day, or a cure?37312021-02-24T16:56:31.3547642Sandra BrookesHaving MS which is a progressive illness is very unfair on ms suffers.37312021-02-24T16:57:28.66347643Irene SteelHusband struggles with walking now it's a stupid rule\r\nShould be removed37312021-02-24T16:58:03.7147644Fraser HuntDisappointed that the 20 metre rule prevails. What happened to treating claimants with respect.37312021-02-24T16:58:25.47747645Angela Weddell MS symptoms varies from person to person on a daily basis. The 20m rule is discrimination. Please reconsider and make the system fairer. MS doesn't get better, it's debilitating. 37312021-02-24T17:01:48.72747646Terence John RollsSome days people with MS cannot stand much less walk 20m37312021-02-24T17:03:18.00747647Agnes McEwanI live with Multiple Sclerosis and the 20 meter rule is absurd. Some days, well most days I can not get out of bed. \r\n37312021-02-24T17:07:02.60347648Janet AnsleyThe 20m rule is highly discriminatory against people with MS as the condition is very variable from one day to the next. A lot of sufferers are often unable to walk a couple of steps never mind 20m, but on some days may have a day that enables them to walk a few more, but MS is so very unpredictable and fluctuating that each day is so different that to interview someone on a "good day" for them, may see them in bed the day after and quite unwell. That's why I feel the 20m rule is so unfair.37312021-02-24T17:10:46.21347649Laura GordonAs an MS sufferer I find this rule absurd. MS greatly fluctuates from one day to another. Perhaps the Scottish Government should consult with MS specialists and get a realistic understanding of the disease. The Scottish Government should hang their heads in shame!37312021-02-24T17:12:29.69747650JULIE GOULDMost people with MS can walk over 20m but struggle to walk further than 700- 800 m. Our balance is affected and we need to sit down regularly. Walking can be difficult and uncomfortable with many affected by Utthofs. As our nerves warm up with gentle walking, they stop working and we cannot walk any further without long rest.37312021-02-24T17:14:18.94747651Janette Maria BarnesOn a "good day" 20 metres MAY be possible however "good days" are not guaranteed. Having to justify yourself when you do not chose to be 'disabled' is incredibly demoralising and disempowering and not what one would chose to have37312021-02-24T17:15:31.99347652Samuel MccahonRemove 20 metre rule37312021-02-24T17:16:43.32347653Alan IsherwoodThis rule for all people would work if we were all the same but we are not. MS sufferers are lucky to have 2 days the same37312021-02-24T17:21:44.7647656Zineerah ali The 20m rule is discriminatory against people with MS. Many of us find walking painful and our conditions are highly variable.37312021-02-24T17:21:51.77747657Petra Johnstone20m is a ridiculous length, considering some houses are more than 20m end to end. I doubt that 20m would get many people to a shop or a bus stop. 37312021-02-24T17:24:55.27747659Gayle StocksScrap the 20m rule as it is not a fair indication, some days I could walk more than 20m without too much pain, other days I may not manage 5m without considerable pain.\r\n\r\nGayle Stocks37312021-02-24T17:25:11.57347660Myra MartinThis is a very unfair process on people with MS and other illnesses 37312021-02-24T17:25:19.04347661Stephen armstrongplease help us, we really need it.37312021-02-24T17:26:12.93347663Anthony (Tony) EllisI agree with this as I'm a sufferer of PPMS (primary progressive multiple sclerosis) \r\nOne day I can manage 20meters then the next I struggle. This should be put out throughout the UK.37312021-02-24T17:26:56.73347664Lynn AllabyThe condition of M.S. is different for everyone, and it can vary from day to day. What might be achieved one day will not necessarily work the following day.37312021-02-24T17:27:16.01347665Steven GrayThe 20m ruling is totally insensitive for anyone with MS.37312021-02-24T17:30:12.9547666Kay SouissiTotally agree with other people's comments.20 metre rule is not fair on MS suffers. 37312021-02-24T17:34:54.10747668Tracey WilliamsThis rule of 20m should be removed as walking with MS is never the same day by day as painful is normal by somedays it is not even successful.37312021-02-24T17:38:44.51347670Jane BennettRemove it. It discriminates against peope whose mobility fluctuates37312021-02-24T17:38:46.40347671Tracey WilliamsWalking with MS is never the same can normally be painful and sometimes not even successful, the rule of 20m should be removed as doesn't work for people with the MS disability.37312021-02-24T17:38:56.12747672Anne SidwellThis should be removed. Conditions differ daily.37312021-02-24T17:41:12.20347673Neil ClarkThis 20mtr rule is totally unfair to MS sufferers. It shows that the people who sort this out do NOT understand the difficulties MS have.\r\nThis ruling shows the people who are responsible for this ruling do NOT understand MS.37312021-02-24T17:41:12.31347674Anne MacDonaldI have the Progressive form of MS.\r\nMy ability to walk even within my home varies from day to day . Sometimes from am to pm.37312021-02-24T17:41:29.67347675Jane SwannM.S is so variable and can be so challenging. So much extra pressure doesn't help. 37312021-02-24T17:42:33.56347676Lesley Drotos\r\nThe 20 metre rule needs removed. This is not a realistic measure of MS sufferers disabilities. It can vary greatly depending on the day. This is discrimination.37312021-02-24T17:43:50.01747677Margaret RobinsonIf the Scottish government are able to change and rename the benefit they should change the mobility eligibility criteria! 37312021-02-24T17:45:56.1447679shaun KilbridePlease use common scense 37312021-02-24T17:47:21.87347680Sian ThorpeHow can the 20m rule work for someone that has an invisible illness that can be so different one day to the next?37312021-02-24T17:47:45.8347681Elizabeth McKellarThe 20m issue can be so dependent on how you feel each day. Some days I can walk a bit further but some days I have trouble walking to the bathroom.37312021-02-24T17:48:57.23347682Jenny Angus MS is such a variable condition, one day it might be possible to walk 20 meters (which not very much) other days it's not. It's a pointless distance to use 37312021-02-24T17:51:26.37347683Susan E Bradford Having Multiple Sclerosis which is a progressive and unpredictable condition, achievable distances vary from day to day. Some days I cannot even walk to my front gate never mind 20 metres. If I remember correctly the form mentions without pain or discomfort many MS sufferers have permanent problems with their mobility including pain, discomfort or altered sensation. 37312021-02-24T17:52:20.73747684Linda Burn20 metre rule is unfair to people with MS as their condition varies from day to day. Anyone with any knowledge of MS will be well aware of this.37312021-02-24T17:54:15.62347685Christine M ArchdeaconPlease drop the 20 metre rule. This is not a realistic measure for MS sufferers disabilities. It is discriminatory as the disability is so variable from day to day..37312021-02-24T17:58:53.87347686Christina HigginsPeople with MS may be able to walk the 20m but not without experiencing extreme pain. How can anyone like this work effectively. Plus, it's not just the walk but how they feel afterward. Exhaustion, fatigue, pain and then on top of that you have the mental effects. STOP the 20 metre rule! It's discrimination37312021-02-24T18:04:47.68747687Audrey Boal The 20 meter rule is rediculous, it prevented my mother from recieving the correct amount which she needed before she passed away a year later. The assessment was degrading and humiliating!! I am Scottish and lived in Scotland at that time. Please scrap this rule as conditions and abilities regularly .37312021-02-24T18:08:44.26747688Stephen GoodwinOn a good day my legs appear to work then the following day they stop, how can the 20mtr rule apply to that situation. Just scrap it and give MS people a chance.37312021-02-24T18:09:26.78747689Bridget Alyson HalcrowI cannot walk 2 metres unless I have a rollator - With the rollator I can walk a lot further - this rule makes no sense37312021-02-24T18:13:44.90747690Silvana Hansen I have MS and the symptoms are so varied from day to day. Some days are better and some I can barely move.37312021-02-24T18:14:27.53347691John WallisI've got MS. Walking abilities can vary from day to day as does everything else. More bad days than good now unfortunately.37312021-02-24T18:15:35.87747692David Wilson The 20 metre rule should be removed. MS for example is a complex fluctuating condition which can change from day to day. The ability to walk 20 metres or any distance on a particular day does not reflect the varying challenges which a person with MS experiences. As the father of someone who has MS I am aware of the effects it has on my daughter and in my view assessment should be holistic and not be discriminatory, or unfair and should respect the dignity of the person. Values which the Scottish Government should aspire to in this framework. 37312021-02-24T18:20:52.1847693Paula KeyesJust because you can walk 20 meters does not mean that you don't have other difficulties.\r\nNot all disabilities are visible. That doesn't mean life is easy.37312021-02-24T18:24:20.61747694Cara Jade BirchI had a full payment for mobility with DLA. PIP assessment denied me any payment. Life has been so so difficult since. This 20m rule is not fit for purpose, do the assessors not know anything about MS?! Using this 20m rule as a guide suggests they are entirely unaware of what the difficulties those with MS experience.37312021-02-24T18:25:04.1947695Linda HamiltonNo 2 days are the same, please think again,37312021-02-24T18:26:48.5247696steve williams20m one day but not always the next. It's the nature of MS37312021-02-24T18:28:11.28347697Pauline ThomasGood luck. Hopefully the Scottish Government can lead the way,37312021-02-24T18:31:44.58747698Helen Macclesfield The 20 metre rule is ridiculous, demeaning, and makes you feel even more useless ,embarrassed, ashamed,depressed and even worthless. To be told to do this and feel like you are on "show" to whomever is watching and taking notes makes me feel all of the above. Its not fair to be made to feel like a "performing monkey " just so that you get help to live your day to day life with a debilitating and soul destroying disease!!37312021-02-24T18:33:52.2647700Sharon GillkersonI definitely agree, I have multiple sclerosis, and walking this distance is painful. The 20 meter rule should be scrapped.37312021-02-24T18:41:20.53747702Niso StannardThis rule is ludicrous! We already struggle most days of the week?!? I may be able to walk for 20 metres one day, but can be completely incapacitated for the next 6 days! 37312021-02-24T18:41:40.7647703CLIVE WHITESIDEThe 20 Metre Rule is something that discriminates against people with MS and other conditions. It doesn't take account of many other issues such as how painful it can be etc 37312021-02-24T18:46:27.11747704Elaine TrichkovaRemove the 20 metre rule!37312021-02-24T18:48:21.8847705Carol MairI have MS and on my good days i can walk 20 metres but my bad days i cannot stand up on my own. The 20 metre rule is very unfair.37312021-02-24T18:48:31.1547706Margaret O'neilDisability is bad enough in its self. Let them take our illnesses for just one day. They wouldn't be long in changing the 20 metre rule.37312021-02-24T18:51:44.747707linda may blakemore This is surely an error that must be amended37312021-02-24T18:51:48.80747708kathryn loweAcknowledgement is a crucial part of the healing process, thank you.37332021-02-24T18:53:33.5747709Serena WattsBeing able to walk 20 metres does not enable a petson to function independently. Its impossible to park with 20m of a shop, and even then you wouldnt be able to get around the shop to buy food or pay bills. Real life is more than walking. Its trying to carry shopping or a handbag, or equipment for work, or trying to navigate uneven paths. MS is a disability and should be recognised as such regardless of how far the assessor thinks they can walk. Noone chooses to have a fluctuating disability. Give them some dignity 37312021-02-24T18:55:26.47747710Stephanie JamesI expect Scotland to lead the way on this! Show England how it's done.....37312021-02-24T18:55:57.02347711Robert wilkins The 20 meter rule can be done with a lot of effort but not safely, repeatedly or in a timely manner by most serious disabled persons let alone those suffering from MS37312021-02-24T18:58:38.90347712Jacqueline ArnoldSome people with MS cannot walk the 20 metres you are judging all the same it needs to be taken into account when people have relapse and can't even get out of bed never mind walk37312021-02-24T18:59:37.91347713Margaret Baillie This is not a realistic measure of ms suffers disabilities as it can vary from day to day37312021-02-24T19:00:36.19747714Margaret Baillie This is not a realistic measure of ms sufferers disabilities as it can vary from day to day .37312021-02-24T19:11:04.2847715Jenny HardyThis 20m rule is ridiculous. One day a person with MS may be able to walk this far but another day will find it impossible. MS changes from week to week in a lot of people. They should not be penalised for this variation. 37312021-02-24T19:11:34.68747716Lianne WilsonThe 20m rule is outdated and a disgusting attempt at making people with hidden disabilities fight for any support. For a government that claims it wants to make this fairer, keeping this rule and keeping points for enhanced mobility is not only degrading but humiliating those who have fluctuating and hidden disabilities37312021-02-24T19:12:32.1247717Red O'BrienMy wife cannot walk 1 metre with out help and needs a wheel chair. seen this with pip, had to lift her out of her wheel chair and she could not stand unaided.How bitter I felt, no dignity and no respect for her and now we will have the same again. 37312021-02-24T19:16:40.7847718Penny CopleyPlease do not consider the 20m rule for people with fluctuating incurable diseases such as MS. I have done as requested and tried to be as active, I've walked, I've tried yoga, I walk my dog and all of this is fab at the time. When I then come home to rest, I end up being unable to move without being in great pain, so if asked at that point to walk 20 metres, I would be crawling as the pain and heavy legs and shooting pains in my feet do not consider that I could do it in the morning.\r\nPlease consider this type of difficulty i lost when moved off of DLA to PIP because this was not considered37312021-02-24T19:16:57.2647719Fiona MurdochThis rule tells you so little about what life is like for any MS sufferer. We are ALL different but all are waging war with the nightmare that is MS.37312021-02-24T19:17:36.6447720Kim BridgesI do believe the 20 metre rule should be removed as ms can vary from minute to minute and is very disabling. 37312021-02-24T19:19:54.0947721David EdmistonThe 20m rule affects others with a range of conditions affecting mobility. It is arbitrary and often measured surreptitiously. It must be scrapped and not allowed as a legacy measure.37312021-02-24T19:27:49.17347722Ronald ParkerTHE 20 METRE RULE IS DISGRACEFUL TO APPLY THIS TO MS SUFFERERS.37312021-02-24T19:31:07.79347723Liz whiteThere is so much more to ms than focusing on this 20 meter rule. So needs to be removed, 37312021-02-24T19:35:07.4247724George FenwicktThe 20 metre rule ignores varying disabilities like MS and needs to be scrapped as a guide people should be judged as individuals. 37312021-02-24T19:41:21.42347725Janis FoxThis penalises many people, who are already suffering MS. Let's be realistic it should be scrapped.\r\n37312021-02-24T19:42:54.48747726Clara Fenwick The 20 metre rule is not only arbitrary & \r\ndiscriminatory, but displays a complete \r\nlack of education or understanding of\r\nthe nature of MS.\r\nThe 20 metre rule must be scrapped.37312021-02-24T19:47:00.82747727Fiona SymondsIt is frustrating for us to get from the car to our home, shop, hospital and doctors if often more than 20 meters. 20 meters is unrealistic and should be 50 meters as the distance to get Enhanced Rate PIP for mobiliy.37312021-02-24T19:47:21.61347728Sarah O'BrienPeople with multiple sclerosis might not be able to walk 20 metres unaided or unassisted. There's no dignity in the assessments expecting people to be able to do this. Have heard people being saying that they've been refused PIP, despite providing all. and more, information requested on the from and providing information from their personal medical records.37312021-02-24T19:49:45.53347729Meg CardyThe 20 metre rule needs to be removed now. What are people supposed to do when they've walked the 20 metres? 37312021-02-24T19:53:17.20347730Eleanor CookeThis 20m rule should be removed as illness and disability does not go by rules.everyday can be different as to a persons abilities37312021-02-24T19:59:21.40747731paula halkicas i am trained to fill benefit forms in and i have ms myself the 20metre rule should be removed and the individual assessed on their own merit. 37312021-02-24T20:12:49.81347732Martina NichollScrap the 20m rule....every day is different for us MS sufferers 37312021-02-24T20:14:12.31747733Patricia CorderyThe 20 metre rule needs removed. This is not a realistic measure for MS sufferers. The ability to move varies on a daily basis and can be affected greatly by individual levels of fatigue.. 37312021-02-24T20:16:49.92347734Wendy ThomasI have had multiple sclerosis for twenty years but for the last 4 to 5 years I need friends or family close to me when I am trying to mobilise or by electronic means. This twenty metre rule will never work for all.37312021-02-24T20:20:00.64747735Leslie WallaceSensible alternative solution!37352021-02-24T20:20:41.48747736Paul ReayThe 20 metre rule does not make sense at all.37312021-02-24T20:25:59.847737Frank D HoweThe constant reassessment and other hassle those that already have enough problems in their daily life disgusting. Where a condition like MS is concerned and no getting better can be pretty much guaranteed without a miracle. Mark that well and mark it clear on their records and leave the poor devils alone.37312021-02-24T20:35:16.86347739Fraser KirklandAs MS symptoms can change, asking people to perform a 20m walk is simply discrimination.37312021-02-24T20:35:33.6847740Fiona McDonaldI live in South Wales but was born and raised in North Lanarkshire. I know many people living with MS who would suffer if the 20 metre rule is maintained. Scotland can show the UK Government that it can shape a social security system that makes sense for disabled people instead of damaging them. It would be impossible to develop a disability assistance system based on dignity, fairness and respect whilst keeping the 20m rule - if you do, you should be ashamed of yourselves! \r\n37312021-02-24T20:46:21.11747741Sarah CarrsThis is not realistic as symptoms vary from day to day, sometimes I can't walk across the room!!37312021-02-24T20:49:57.83747742Ann PartingtonMy sister has MS and I know some days she struggles to get around the kitchen table and that's even when holding onto it. When will governments learn we are human beings and one size does not fit all37312021-02-24T20:50:50.9647743Ann PartingtonMy sister has MS and I know some days she struggkes to get around the kitchen table and that's even when holding onto it. When will governments learn we are human beings and one size does not fit all37312021-02-24T21:03:01.85747745Rebecca MainMs isn't as straight forward as other illnesses37312021-02-24T21:05:53.43747746Ailsa MarshallTotally agree.37312021-02-24T21:09:03.21747747John Anderson HodgeMy wife died of MS, each day was different, it's a hellish thing for anyone to get, this 20 meters should be scrapped.37312021-02-24T21:17:42.3447748Elizabeth GilmourTotally ridiculous way to measure disability. I have MS. 20 metres is manageable most days but with extreme effort and a great deal of pain.\r\n37312021-02-24T21:34:22.88347750Charles James GibbI support the use of these and other relevant requirements to demonstrate responsible land use management 37012021-02-24T21:41:20.48747751Judith CotterHaving MS and living with the pain and disability it brings the 20metre rule needs removing. 37312021-02-24T21:51:55.42747753Annette FarmerI have Secondary Progressive MS and the 20m rule needs to be scrapped. No days are the same with MS I can probably walk the 20m one day but the next day I could be laid up in bed due to pain problems with balance and walking. The 20m rule needs to be got rid of it is an insult to all disabled people.37312021-02-24T21:55:38.02747755Mehmet HalilOn a bad day my wife cannot take a single step and I have to pick her up off the floor or carry her to bed. This test does not reflect how conditions caused by MS can vary between a good and bad day. 37312021-02-24T21:55:54.08347756Jacquelinr Brown Edwards20mtr is possible some days and other days an impossibility. Unfair to people with ms !37312021-02-24T22:11:10.5747758Margaret KellettAs MS is variable in time and duration a single assessment of a person cannot be used to set the level of disability. 37312021-02-24T22:18:45.44747759Sharon trainor Stop making people feel like their a fraud!!37312021-02-24T22:22:59.5147760Stephen MusgroveThe 20 metre rule definitely needs to be scrapped, every MS sufferer is totally different, you may be able to walk 20 metres one day, and the next you cannot even walk 1 metre.37312021-02-24T22:26:27.15747761Beth ThomsonMS is such a variable condition, the 20 m rule penalises people with MS.37312021-02-24T22:27:12.43347762David BealeI have MS and after a dozen years on DLA with a hand-control car I have now lost this due only to the 20M rule in the chngae to PIP. This needs to change.37312021-02-24T22:33:13.93347763Stuart WilsonThe 20m rule is not fit for purpose. MS is a variable condition and someone's ability to undertake tasks will fluctuate throughout the day.37312021-02-24T22:52:54.29347764Jude Cotter The 20 metre rule should be removed. It is an insult to those who suffer with MS. 37312021-02-24T22:55:31.56747765Timothy PimlottAs many have said already MS is at once unpredictable, variable and in many cases invisible.\r\nI am virtualy always in some kind of neurological pain and too walk at all takes a great deal of mental effort and that can vary from day to day37312021-02-24T23:03:49.95347766Roddy MacleanNo earnings since 18th December, taxi bills still got to be payed. How can I keep going? Stay home, stay safe means no work to the taxi trade no help from this SNP gov.37372021-02-24T23:06:32.21747767Amanda BaileyMS is an un predictable disease and can change from one day to the next, this needs to be taken into account and the 20 metre rule should be scrapped37312021-02-24T23:06:50.64747768Steve Keal-FrayneTotally agree, the 20 metre rule should be scrapped. My wife suffers with MS and would love to be able to walk 20 metres once let alone regularly. Her condition varies daily.37312021-02-24T23:07:04.19347769Anne Brownscrap the 20mtr rule. Some days i have no problem with it, other days I can hardly walk to the toilet unaided. MS changes from day to day so this rule is pointless.37312021-02-24T23:10:46.56747770William Dougherty This is absolutely ridiculous. What do successive governments have against disabled people. Its not as if they have chosen disability. 37312021-02-24T23:20:19.52347771Penny De AbreuThe 20 metre rule clearly demonstrates no knowledge of this dreadful condition that insidiously but surely robs people of independence & dignity like pulling the rug from under your feet. The fatigue, the physical insecurity, the sheer effort involved in carrying out the simplest of tasks that are taken for granted by the fit, able bodied.\r\nWe should not be still fighting such battles. \r\nPenny De Abreu37312021-02-24T23:25:58.36747775Simon MatchettI lived in Edinburgh for 16 years. I have MS and live back in Northern Ireland now, and I am appalled that the Scottish Parliament are even considering this discriminatory rule in their new framework. MS is a rollercoaster or yoyo, whichever metaphor you prefer, they do not take into account that on the days you may be able to make that distance, however difficult and or painful it could be, that 9 times out of 10 you pay a high price like bedridden, fatigued beyond belief, pain etc. Dignity and respect will be stripped from people trying to remain a part of society.37312021-02-24T23:25:58.6147776Mark BishopDefinitely agree the 20 metre rule should be scrapped,I have multiple sclerosis and like other sufferer's,I struggle day to day with mobility depending on my fatigue along with complete numbness pins and needles in my feet, poor coordination and balance,the welfare system is very unfair where ms sufferer's are concerned.37312021-02-24T23:36:39.94747778Lisa SageThe 20m rule isn't fair. I might me able to walk 20m one day but then be in agony after it or be too fatigued for the rest of the day and maybe even the next. Its not a fair measure for people e with MS, Fibromyalgia and other disabling chronic illnesses. I'm disappointed that this has been kept. I thought Scotland were in a very unique position where they could rewrite the rule book to better help and support those of us who are unlucky enough in need it37312021-02-25T00:13:51.60747779Valda WilliamsThe very idea that this rule is fair shows a TOTAL misconception of what MS is all about. Ridiculous "ticking of boxes" rather than daring to deal with people! 2 of my siblings have (and did have) MS.37312021-02-25T00:25:05.70347780Steve TizzardNo doubt a rule made by someone that doesn't understand the condition.37312021-02-25T00:54:11.22347782Ian Stuart JohnsonI have MS. It is hugely variable - one day I might be able to walk 65ft (20m) but the next, no chance. \r\nI often use my wheelchair to be on the safe side.37312021-02-25T00:57:16.40747783Ian DracottAn arbitrary rule which is not fit for purpose37312021-02-25T06:11:05.10347786Jack cameron20m rule is shocking...you can walk...but always in pain of some sort.Also fatigue and all that goes with this terrible condition37312021-02-25T06:13:24.95347787Andrew HalcrowThe 20m rule is not a fair method of showing a level of disability in MS sufferers. The condition is hugely variable. A person may be able to walk 20m on one good day then have many terrible days. The rule should be scrapped. 37312021-02-25T07:03:34.61747788Kathryn OdgearMS should have an automatic right to disability money. Good luck37312021-02-25T07:08:32.41347789Elizabeth Eade The 20meter rule is unfair for people with MS as it is usually at a reduced pace and causes pain which can be very severe, it is not a relaxed normal walk37312021-02-25T07:31:13.03747791Joyce DavenportI've never agreed with this rule. Someone with MS is by the nature of the condition often has restricted mobility, and as such are made to undertake an action that could cause pain, embaressment, discomfort. Leave them with their dignity & pride intact for goodness sake37312021-02-25T07:59:52.65747792Paul RobertsWhat a daft rule It bears no relationship ti the disability. 37312021-02-25T08:02:07.32347793Judith BriscallI have Multiple Sclerosis. The 20 metre rule shows a complete misunderstanding of the mobility issues faced by people with this condition.\r\n37312021-02-25T08:07:22.5147794Robert McAllisterThe 20m rule is so arbitrary and not fit for purpose that it should be removed. It has no real application to real word situations as anyone with a disability knows.37312021-02-25T08:15:02.3647795diane elliottThis rule is not appropriate for may people with MS. and needs reviewing .How far you can walk is only one small part of the restrictions a disability can cause pain levels,balance ,safety .daily variation are just part of a walking disability yes and no answers are not enough.37312021-02-25T08:15:24.29347796Ian BrocklehurstThis rule is grossly unfair for people with MS as the condition severity changes day to day. I have days where I struggle to walk 20 metres abs other that are better how can I guarantee that on the assessment day what the severity of my condition will be37312021-02-25T08:27:25.38747797Loretta BurtMS is different each day and the 20m rule question rather insulting37312021-02-25T08:36:12.57747798Vivienne PollockThe 20m rule does not take into consideration fluctuating conditions and whether 20 m is walked easily or with a struggle with walking aids. Please reconsider.37312021-02-25T08:38:47.18747799Joan MackinnonPeople with MS have enough to suffer with lack of sleep, fatigue pain and the worry of a relapse is bad enough.37312021-02-25T09:04:42.4147801DAVID BELLDefinitely agree good day- maybe 20mts bad day forget it bodies not moving, Stupid rule37312021-02-25T09:13:30.17747803Kevin WhalleyDisabled people have been given a raw deal by governments for too long. We need to support each one their to strike back and fight any changes to our civil liberties that we need to stop.37312021-02-25T09:33:59.6347804Sara BeckettPeople with MS may be capable of walking 20 meters for one day in 365 days Oh how they would like to do that every day 37312021-02-25T09:38:47.7447805Susan Fellows20 m rule should be scrapped. I have MS and can walk more than 20 metres but my legs hurt from the first step onwards plus distance does vary and I do need a stick.37312021-02-25T09:39:15.61747806MAXINE HEELEYMobility issues,are bad enough without this rid ridiculous rule adding extra stress37312021-02-25T09:43:51.36747807John Fair The 20 meter rule is completely unfair. People with MS have hugely varying levels of the illness, which also affect people differently on a daily basis, with some good and bad days. It's only people with MS who fully understand this,. Scrap this rule, it is not indicative of or cover the overall affects of MS on all MS sufferers. 37312021-02-25T09:44:39.91347808June Brisco This rule is totally unrealistic for most ms sufferers every day can be different some days for me I stumble all over the place at home never mind go outside and walk 20 metres 37312021-02-25T10:00:34.57347809Gavin AlexanderI think that all owners of land should be held responsible for flood mitigation measures in proportion to the contribution their land makes to the river system. Grouse moors are large and are located high in catchment areas, therefore they are net high contributors.37012021-02-25T10:23:59.96747810Sandra WillisIt should, anyhow, be called the "10m one way and 10 metres back rule." PIP applications re MS (or any other disease) seem to have missed out the original sound condition that all activity should be capable "repeatedly and without pain, breathlessness, fatigue and exhaustion." That word "repeatedly" has disappeared as DWP have realised that applicants don't know or remember this condition.\r\n37312021-02-25T10:32:09.90347811Keith ShirleyI agree with the petition. I hope others sign as it is very important.37312021-02-25T10:35:35.6947812Kasine WestwoodI know firsthand how debilitating having MS is and how every day is different. MS doesn't fit in a box so why does the PIP assessment expect it to.37312021-02-25T10:35:54.93747813alison willisThe 20 metre rule is ridiculous, as depending on how well I feel, some days can walk more or less than this and no-one can predict on how m.s. decides how to affect the person on that particular day. 37312021-02-25T10:42:01.4747814Elaine DalgleishThe problem with MS is symptom's vary everyday. One day you might be able to walk 50meter however the next you can only walk 5. So having a 20m is very unfair 37312021-02-25T10:46:08.6147815Susan KimptonThe nature of the illness changes each day. A good day you might be in control to a greater degree of flexibility than the next.37312021-02-25T10:55:38.0847816Gail BulcockI am an MS sufferer and when I was applying for my pip I could barely walk the 20 meters but I was turned down initially. I had a very stressful time waiting to find out if I could get it overturned37312021-02-25T10:55:51.4747817Barbara PickerillThe 20 metre rule is unfair. I have MS. I can no longer walk without having to stop and rest, all the time. On bad days I just don't go out of the house at all. I use a stick to help balance but that does not mean I can walk further. I agree the 20 metre rule discriminates against people with MS and should be scrapped. 37312021-02-25T10:58:00.01747818Bernadette MurphyThe 20 metre rule is not a good assessment of disability caused by MS. It is too simplistic.37312021-02-25T11:03:03.28347819Andrew WelshThis rule is demeaning and I believe deliberately designed to make any potential claimant feel they are scamming the system and scared to make a claim. It is cynical and degrading.37312021-02-25T11:03:05.5247820Joanna FossI have been living with MS for almost 18 years. No day is the same. People who don't have the condition do not have a clue about its effect on our lives. The 20m rule should be removed, as it doesn't reflect the whole picture of this illness. Pain can't be seen...can it?37312021-02-25T11:15:27.67747821Anna HallThe 20 metre rule is an unreasonable rule. Most people with varying illness. Have differing walking ability. Which can change from one to several times a day. It can debilitate from hours, days and even weeks. No 2 days are ever the same.\r\nThis rediculous rule needs removing. 37312021-02-25T11:15:28.25347822Deborah BellassI do agree, the 20 metre rule should be removed 37312021-02-25T11:21:35.33347823Patricia NelsonI agree this should be removed37312021-02-25T11:43:31.91347825Zara WalshWhy would anybody fabricate such a terrible illness and have to justify the 20meter rule. Absolutely ridiculous. Is this decision made by an able bodied person?37312021-02-25T12:15:48.4847826Rosemary NordstromAfter two years of isolation in Campbeltown even without Covid, my family and I are ready to leave, taking our business, our taxes and our contribution to the local economy with us - along with a desperately needed teacher (our daughter). Without easy connections to the wider world, Campbeltown will continue to struggle.37352021-02-25T12:34:16.7847827Paula WebsterThe 20 metre rule needs to be removed having MS you can walk one day then next day you cannot 37312021-02-25T12:36:15.2247828Danielle Henry20M rule is discriminating, bad enough having MS let alone admitting you cant walk very far don't need reminders37312021-02-25T12:51:01.42347830Michela CecchettjI wish they would finally decide to engage a person who suffers MS when making decisions for MS suffers 37312021-02-25T12:55:37.0847831Beverley FodenThe mobility of m.s sufferers worldwide is different to each individual why make our lives and our choices so much harder by hanging on to this rule we need to be able to hold up our heads in pride not drop them with exhaustion 37312021-02-25T12:59:52.89347832Allan CravenAs a person with MS, the 20 meter rule is totally stupid.37312021-02-25T13:06:00.11347833Kay HitchcockWith all we have to contend with on a daily basis.. fatigue , tiredness, depression, blurred vision ,pain and much more we still find ourselves fighting to be heard. The clue is in the name... multiple sclerosis, affecting all aspects of life. We have to live one day at a time as we don't know how we will feel from day to day. I do believe that the 20 metre rule should be removed.37312021-02-25T13:17:56.97347834Fiona 3 WolversonI was diagnosed with ms when I was 23 and working as a nurse in the 1980s. Things have moved on in treatments. BUT not some attitudes. Help & empathy are vital for all. 37312021-02-25T13:27:21.3247836Beverley COYLEIf I walk 19m I get it and 21m I don't! for me every day is different! 37312021-02-25T13:29:44.44347837Elaine DuffyMS is an unpredictable and variable disease. I can walk some days and not others. And often a good day where I can walk I will suffer for the next day. 37312021-02-25T13:46:14.447838Kerriann PatersonI was part of a working group to help form the social security approach and I'm very unhappy that very reason I was invited to join the group, has been ignored. 37312021-02-25T14:09:15.60747839Will BuckleThis is something to affect anyone with MS in the UNITED Kingdom.Struggling to walk is as hurtful as struggling to breath and even if someone makes 20+metres they'll likely collapse unable to move again for another hour!37312021-02-25T14:29:1447840Robin TandyThe 20 metre rule is not a fair, representative, objective measure of MS disability and should be abandoned. The use of such a rigid measure to evaluate a condition that varies from one individual to the next is wholly unacceptable. When the impact to an individual can fluctuate markedly throughout the day, applying this rule is without foundation and, quite frankly, is an insult to all us MS sufferers. 37312021-02-25T14:30:59.15747841Chrissy RutterThere should be no rule concerning how far someone can or cannot walk. If someone has a confirmed medical condition which will not improve why should they have the indignation of being tested to see if they can walk?? its the body that is letting them down not their brain!!37312021-02-25T14:45:09.1947842John F BrownThe 20m rule is ridiculous. I have MS with the fatigue that it brings with it and can walk 20m but what should I do afterwards, other than sit down and wait for someone to help me get on with the rest of life? The fatigue is devastating.37312021-02-25T15:02:56.69347843Claire NetheryThe 20m rule does not realistically measure a person with Multiple Sclerosis and should be removed as each day is a new survival. Good and bad days are part of the course. Having to tell someone how rubbish some days are is not progressive in helping that person survive their illness but actually more than detrimental in the mental stress and coping ability of the person in handling their illness on a day to day basis. More work needs to go into the assessment process and level of humanity or empathy displayed by the assessors in the first instance. Along with a future structure that accounts for people suffering MS and many other disabilities. Perhaps when you go on to a register for DBT drugs there should be an automatic level of Adult Disability Payment at a lower rate with no assessment moving to a higher rate after assessment. This would seem much fairer than the current system.\r\n37312021-02-25T15:03:05.2447844Duncan SmithThe effects of Multiple sclerosis can be extremely variable from day to day. One day, walking 20 metres can be achieved, on another day, getting out of bed can be an impossible task.\r\nThe 20 metre rule should be scrapped throughout the United Kingdom 37312021-02-25T15:05:26.53747845Sandra Morrison20 metre rule is discriminatory against ms suffers.\r\nWhose walking abilities can change throughout the day, never mind from day to day. We should be helped, not penalised37312021-02-25T15:34:22.43347846Allan AuchterlonieWhilst every effort is made to keep mobile, support must surely be given to those to breach the 20m.37312021-02-25T15:47:40.52747848Julie WhiteThe 20 m rule discriminates people with MS who often cannot get disability payments or blue badges as day to the condition can vary greatly 37312021-02-25T15:54:57.96747849Caroline St MaurMS symptoms vary so much both individually and from day to day so this assessment should not be used 37312021-02-25T16:02:07.18347850Janet PenroseI live in England, but I am disabled, luckily now in receipt of PIP. I know from bitter experience that the 20 m rule is totally unrealistic37312021-02-25T16:39:27.73747851Karen mcguinness With chronic fatigue how can you measure a persons ability with a measurement an individuals autonomy is vital for there overall well being and the 20 meter rule causes and creates endless anxieties stress depression 37312021-02-25T16:40:52.84747852Sandra MortlockThis rule should not be applied as this unpredictable condition varies so much day to day. 37312021-02-25T16:54:48.64747853Kathleen MidgleyI have suffered with MS since aged 17 years I am now 69 sometimes I can walk 20 meters with a stick sometimes without!Mostly with aid of a stick or crutch. I have progressive MS.\r\nMy symptoms can change almost daily and life is not at all easy. We do not need to be treated like this by ignorant bureaucrats anymore only our Doctors can decide our level of dependency.We are fed up with this arbitrary discrimination. Kathleen Midgley 25th Feb 2021.37312021-02-25T16:56:23.33347854Carole ClokeI totally agree with the comments below.\r\nEvery day is different. \r\nI have numbness in my left foot which, again, is different each day.37312021-02-25T17:13:09.61747855Piers BirdThis would be a godsend! People could plan properly and the economic benefits would be encouraging for investment in the area. I myself am struggling to find tradesmen that will come this far to complete work keeping me on a economically viable schedule. 37352021-02-25T18:15:04.0347856Mrs Katina WrightI have MS, live in UK but completely agree that this rule discriminates through ignorance of the disease37312021-02-25T18:44:47.7447857James bradbury I believe that losing the ability to take blue hares in their natural environment within a falconry context will be a great shame for many reasons. Firstly it is one of the most natural forms of hunting and works highly on the basis of natural selection. \r\nSecondly the landscape and scenery in these places are breathtaking and one of many reasons that myself and many others annually trace to fly our hawks. Whilst there we always make the use of local amenities, B&Bs, hotels, pubs, restaurants, supermarkets and many other local shops and attractions bringing additional income to otherwise remote areas often out of the peak tourist times. \r\nAlso with less falconers allowed access to the land, often paying for the privilege of flying their hawks at blue hare, more intense levels of control will be sought resulting in a far higher number of licenses being requested. \r\n 37892021-02-25T18:45:21.47347858John LoydonPeople will not just give in to MS they will often try and walk as much as possible despite the pain as much for personal pride as much as anything else..it is unfair to be penalised for trying37312021-02-25T18:46:19.25747859Elizabeth WadeChanging from DLA to PIP was an absolute nightmare for me during the pandemic. I had to do it alone with no help. I was nearly one of the suicide statistics!!! We are genuine people not numbers and shouldn't have to go through all this. They said they had given me the same rate as I was on so how come I was £150 a month worse off.? I am physically worse now than when I originally got DLA which was supposed to be in perpetuity. the 20 metre rule should definitely be removed. 37312021-02-25T18:46:24.00347860Marion mc Garry Would be great with all the hassle of the road being closed. 37352021-02-25T18:47:14.1347861John Armour LamontWith the Rest being shut most of the time especially at winter time this could be vital for the Kintyre area.37352021-02-25T18:54:13.7747862Dylan Freeman Falconry is an ancient tradition that has value to conservation. 37892021-02-25T18:56:04.39747863David Trenier This manner of falconry should be held in our heritage and history for years to come. I fully agree with all comments made 37892021-02-25T19:04:08.97747865Susan GardinerDefinitely needed all year round due to constant ongoing problems on the A83.37352021-02-25T19:05:23.5447866Ann Marie MillerThis is an essential service that would help alleviate the problems with the Rest and Be Thankful.37352021-02-25T19:05:58.9647867sylvia mccullochUnfair measurement. People's conditions fluctuate daily37312021-02-25T19:07:56.19347868Alexander Nikolov Hitrov Never stop falconry. This is one of the great traditions in Scotland37892021-02-25T19:14:42.82347870Chas HughesShould be at least twice a day, and permanent.37352021-02-25T19:18:48.6247871Jean McLarenNeeds to be a permanent service.Good for tourism and towns economy.37352021-02-25T19:30:02.16747874Paul WalterI love the ferry from Adrossan to Kintyre. Last three times to Brodick, then Lochranza to Claonaig. Campbeltown was allways the final destination :-)37352021-02-25T19:31:02.16747875Jennifer SpinksPlease do the right thing. These people are helping many many animals and set them free. 37892021-02-25T19:33:39.4847876Sarah GeaterEach of us is different as this is a very unpredictable illness and our mobility can change at very short notice - one day we may be able to walk 20 metres, whereas on another we might not even be able to cope with 2 metres. This should be acknowledged on disability claims for those of us with MS.37312021-02-25T19:35:38.13747877Helen CameronI have followed several falconry sites on line for more than twenty years. The birds are well cared for, and the managers are engaged in an important part of our education about birds of prey and birding generally. It would be a great pity if this misguided legislation were to become final.37892021-02-25T19:39:01.2647878John HunterI feel that the Legislation has been passed which will end a lifetime of falconry, which is part of our heritage 37892021-02-25T19:40:18.88747879David KennedyYes to all questions37892021-02-25T19:41:07.12347880David GallagherA tradition and huge privilege dating back since before any of us can remember, is under threat to be taken away by those who have no awareness of the environment and detrimental effect of the mountain hare population this would bring.37892021-02-25T19:41:39.15347881Robin MansonI fully agree with the ban on the culling Mountain Hares, but I also agree that the practice of falconry is a part of our cultural heritage and this should be allowed to continue, perhaps under license to prevent vast numbers of Hares being hunted by unlicensed falconers who are carrying out the work that the shotguns used to do. 37892021-02-25T19:43:42.40347882Sarah KimballThis is important for falconry and the well being of the birds of prey! \r\nFalconry must continue world wide, in Scotland and everywhere!\r\nThis legislation will have a negative impact on falconry!\r\nThis legislation poses great risk to the welfare of the birds of prey!\r\n37892021-02-25T19:46:07.8147883Ann WallaceI agree with the terms and conditions stated.37892021-02-25T19:52:55.73347884Bruce LumsdenFalconry should be protected.37892021-02-25T19:54:23.90747885Dominique Willems Falconry the most honest and natural way of hunting.37892021-02-25T19:55:01.9247886Philip Monaghan I have been a falconer for 40 years this ban will have a devastating effect on my eagles health and wellbeing. This is why l think we as falconers should be exempt from the ban on hunting mountain hares.37892021-02-25T19:56:06.68747887Neil BirdTrue work with a Bird has been done for thousands of years and has never caused an issue. Let it be.37892021-02-25T19:57:54.09347888Joyce Ann TantocoFalconry should continue in Scotland.37892021-02-25T20:01:16.45347890Steve HayesOur art is a historic part of our history. Do not let it fall like other parts of our rich heritage. 37892021-02-25T20:01:40.73347891Susan LalloI travel to Scotland to enjoy the beauty , history and traditions . If you do not amend this you will destroy all three . Nature has a balance and caging these beautiful creatures would equal a death sentence . You can't cage a free spirit of all the countries in the world I am shocked Scotland would consider this.37892021-02-25T20:02:15.34347892Adam KarmaliFalconry should be legal.37892021-02-25T20:03:10.51747893Gary Mcfarlane \r\nFalconry needs to be maintained. These beautiful birds can not be confined to avaries. 37892021-02-25T20:05:18.48747894Mark FrenchHunting with birds of prey is an art that has been practiced for thousands of years, the Scottish economy suffers a big loss of income from falconers not visiting.37892021-02-25T20:06:06.5847895Helen Mainwood I grew up in Campbeltown and remember how long a journey it was by road to Glasgow. Given that that road is having to be closed so often now it is imperative that an easier way of travelling to and from the town be found, for both people and goods.37352021-02-25T20:06:52.34347896EDWARD DONALDI agree with the four statements below.\r\nDo you agree that the practice of falconry must continue within Scotland? Yes.\r\n\r\nDo you agree that the new legislation will have a negative impact on falconry related business?\r\nYes\r\nDo you agree that the new legislation poses a risk to the welfare of birds of prey?\r\nYes.\r\nDo you agree that outlawing the hunting of mountain hares in the practice of falconry will be harmful to hare conservation as more licences for shooting them will likely be sought? Yes\r\n\r\nLastly, a plea. Please do not seek to remove a specialised activity before considering the data carefully.\r\n\r\nBest regards 37892021-02-25T20:08:57.64347897Keith NicholasThis must be defeated.37892021-02-25T20:09:13.847898Karl JenningsI moved to Scotland as a young student specifically to learn and practice falconry. Every year we holiday in Scotland - attracted by the most stunning scenery and the ability to practice falconry.37892021-02-25T20:17:09.9447899David CairnsA positive move forward. 37352021-02-25T20:22:44.42747900Fiona MacQueen Allow the art of falconry to continue.37892021-02-25T20:33:33.4947902Graeme RoseFalconry does not remove a mass of mountain hares. \r\nAnd the welfare of BOP will suffer. 37892021-02-25T20:36:19.4947903Joanna colyerNo 2 days are the same with MS.\r\nCan work one day no strength to get out of bed the next, no warning 37312021-02-25T20:38:27.80347904Graham ForbesI strongly agree with the below statements regarding the future of falconry. Also very concerned about the increase in Hare shooting and the future of this species. 37892021-02-25T20:51:33.6547905Chris LewisPlease reconsider this law, falconers are respectful to our environments and care deeply for their birds. 37892021-02-25T20:55:34.11747907James FootIt would be good to still have the option & opportunity to be able to take my kids to watch me with my Goshawk hunt the amazing Mountain hare. 37892021-02-25T20:59:18.44747909Keith SherlockPlease take note those who experience limitations from MS37312021-02-25T20:59:29.5747910Susan LaneGrant Elite Falconry their requested exemption because they are an exceptional and vital organization that you can refer to with pride. Thanks for your consideration.37892021-02-25T21:02:38.6247911Steven heathIt should be legal to hunt with birds of pray.37892021-02-25T21:03:02.72747912Alexander MatkinsFalconry contributes to conservation. 37892021-02-25T21:06:26.5147913Thomas AhlFalcrony is an UNESCO World Haritage. And Important to Save and breed Birds of Pray All over the World.37892021-02-25T21:11:04.49347914Mary FlemingSafer journey than rest and be thankful.37352021-02-25T21:16:07.3747915Karl Hylton GarnettStop making it difficult for real people.37892021-02-25T21:20:34.38747916Ambrose W3oodhousei fully understand the need for this petition37312021-02-25T21:21:14.3447917Cheryl HowittYou can still be in servere pain if you can walk 20 metres or 10 metres 37312021-02-25T21:23:14.21747919Brigitte CohuThis tradition does not put pressure on game as there are minimal catches. Birds of prey are meant to hunt preys, like hares, to survive and feed, falconers are just letting their birds behave as raptors...37892021-02-25T21:24:12.79347920Daniel WalserWhy is it not possible to build anywhere else? there is enough land ... the history must be preserved for the next generations.37162021-02-25T21:32:47.62347921Ralph GivansI'm disgusted that this has been allowed to happen.\r\nThis site should definately be a world heritage site. 37162021-02-25T21:44:39.2547923Darren MunroI 100% agree that the age old sport should be aloud to continue. 37892021-02-25T21:47:23.95347924Angela ChickThere appears to be little evidence to support the banning of taking hare, which begs the question as to why this legislation has made any traction? Is it potentially a knee jerk reaction to engender support from town based voters who have little or no connection to the countryside.\r\n\r\nIt is vitally important that falconry is protected within Scotland. It is classified as a UNESCO traditional heritage occupation and has hundreds of years of history within Scotland and the Isles. Falconers are amongst the best advocates for wildlife conservation in the world and have provided invaluable information to the government when species approach crisis point (e.g. Peregrines in the 1950s and DDT). 37892021-02-25T21:59:51.81347925Janet BurridgeYes l agree the 20 metre rule should be removed from the Adult Disability Payment framework37312021-02-25T22:08:57.48747926Mark SteeleI believe that falconry should be protected in Great Britain for future generation to enjoy and to aid in promoting the opportunity to learn about and conserve the amazing raptors involved in this way of life.37892021-02-25T22:25:12.61347927Terry SmithNo way can being able to walk 20m once in a week when my MS is a little easier make me lose a tick37312021-02-25T22:30:36.9947928Joanne HoweHow can these birds be put into cages utter cruelty, we néed to keep population of animals down quickly. If this doesn't happen expect a great deal of injured hares through gun wounds from people who can't shoot correctly. 37892021-02-25T22:32:18.27347930Chris ListerWhy stop nature 37892021-02-25T22:48:09.60347932Iain MorrisonI cannot believe believe that you are adopting exactly the same mobility questions as PIP presently does!!\r\nWith MS it can be so incredibly painful walking even a very short distance.37312021-02-25T22:55:06.3247933Christopher BARBERI am a falconer, I live in Scotland. Although mountain hare is not my primary quarry, I feel strongly that all of the different aspects of falconry need to be fully respected and accepted within the law.37892021-02-25T23:00:04.32347934Nicolas TurnerAn all year round ferry service, which then continues to Ballycastle as well, would just be perfect .37352021-02-25T23:33:52.5647935Urszula KorolczukI agree that the practice of falconry should continue within Scotland. It is an ancient sport that, when practiced well and legally, likely had little impact on hare populations and can be practiced sustainably. The new legislation will have a negative impact on falconry and on the welfare if birds of prey currently being flown for the purposes of falconry in Scotland. I do not think that this legislation should be passed.37892021-02-25T23:46:20.0847936jeffrey a kornerModern falconers and falconry has had one of the biggest impacts on raptor and wildlife protection and education to the public, in the most positive way then any other source . i as a falconer and raptor propagator personally had a key roll in the come back from extinction of the peregrine . bald eagle and osprey in the united states .37892021-02-26T00:02:33.25347937Ian NewburyMy friend has MS, it took so long to be assisted over 20 m that after coffee she received a parking ticket because when had been there too long - ridiculous assessment\r\n\r\n\r\n37312021-02-26T00:33:02.61747938Paul JeanThis very ancient art is prescrives in more than eighty countries and was inscribed in the intangible cultural heritage of humanity by UNESCO on November 16, 2010! Nothing more to add.37892021-02-26T00:33:54.55347939Nguyen Dinh SiI agree that the practice of falconry must continue within Scotland.37892021-02-26T00:39:21.49347941Nguyen Dang KhoaI agree that The practice of falconry must continue within Scotland.37892021-02-26T01:00:18.18347944Tom CasperBeen a falconer since 1968. We have been at the forefront of wildlife enhancement. Most government agencies would like to assume the role of our creator, which has never worked out well for the environment or wildlife.37892021-02-26T01:24:06.21747946Kate Sumner-Wilson How stupid and ignorant to stop this!!37892021-02-26T01:27:18.51347947Karen CarrollEagle falconry has great tradition worldwide. It is a commune with one of nature's most spiritual bonds between humans and eagles. \r\n37892021-02-26T02:15:06.8847949Anita GreenDo you agree that the practice of falconry must continue within Scotland? YES\r\n\r\nDo you agree that the new legislation will have a negative impact on falconry related business? YES\r\n\r\nDo you agree that the new legislation poses a risk to the welfare of birds of prey? YES\r\n\r\nYES i agree that outlawing the hunting of mountain hares in the practice of falconry will be harmful to hare conservation as more licences for shooting them will likely be sought?\r\n37892021-02-26T02:23:34.00747952Paul cannadineI strongly agree with all the points listed below37892021-02-26T02:45:10.02347953Cheryl DalzielPlease do change the rule of 20 metres. It does not support inclusion for all. We all have a right to support no matter the distance. Please understand my worst days should not be measured allowing me to be discriminated 37312021-02-26T03:01:48.4847954Mr Alexander Lloyd MatossianA very valid and justifiable, nee essential demand to prevent a manifestly unjust consequence of legislation with insufficient exemptions37892021-02-26T03:15:30.4547955Saraj Rafique AnsariTaxi trad need help with financial, there is no work.37372021-02-26T03:52:09.20747956Dr. Muhammad Ahmad KhanIt's a great sport. Hare population is damaged by shooting more than falconery. It's old traditional thing. Keep it legal please37892021-02-26T04:16:50.5247957Jenni FraserI agree with all the conditions below37892021-02-26T05:19:03.20347959fiona Mitchell20m rule should be scrapped. Just because you could walk 20m today, tomorrow you may not. There is a reason its a invisible illness & there's a reason the word multiple is used in its name!! Its not just all about walking....so many other effects involved too.37312021-02-26T05:49:16.14347960Peter Barry DeversPlease retain the right for falconers to let their eagles and hawks hunt hare in Scotland. Hare are the natural prey of eagles and comparatively few are taken each season. 37892021-02-26T06:15:26.36747961Trevor FramminghamRidiculous legislation must be ammended37892021-02-26T06:25:16.65347963mickael plessierJe suis pour la fauconnerie37892021-02-26T06:39:17.24347964Luca MariThis activity allows to breed birds in freedom that can be used for the reproduction and re-introduction of the same species. Especially for those at risk of extinction. Don't block it.37892021-02-26T06:40:41.12347965Steven Enzo MacleodYES TO ALL BELOW 37892021-02-26T06:53:29.60347966Pete JayEveryday is different. Scrap the 20m. Try walking in my shoes and other sufferers of M.S.37312021-02-26T07:02:59.65747968Gillian PalmerFalconry is essential to our wildlife.37892021-02-26T07:05:38.87347969matthewbowesyes to all hunting 37892021-02-26T07:20:45.11347970Ian Houghton As a practising falconer of over 35 years, I totally agree with the continuation of this practice. The falconers involved are highly experienced and totally committed to the practice and also to the preservation of the landscape and all the wildlife it contains. These are the very people who are most concerned about these environments.37892021-02-26T07:23:32.40747971Richard RogersMany more pressing matters. please do the right thing.37892021-02-26T07:24:48.81747972Stuart WhybrowFor the sake of the welfare of captive intelligent birds this act is noting more than subjecting those birds to being kept in box for threst of their lives, find another solution if there is even a problem with the way it is. 37892021-02-26T07:26:50.5347973allan mcintyreKintyre has so much to offer visitors, but few would travel down to turn around and go back up. So apart from the Rest and Be Thankful on going problem I believe an all year ferry would encourage more visitors to this beautiful area.37352021-02-26T07:31:52.66347974Nigel BingeFalconry is an ancient sport, and eagles could be could be left in Aviaries with little freedom to fly for years. Eagles live for 50 plus years . Please reconsider.\r\n\r\n37892021-02-26T07:38:47.86747975Steven Smith Historic right enshrined by UNESCO 37892021-02-26T07:40:32.1947976Robin MansonI wholeheartedly agree with the ban on killing mountain hares. However I also think that Falconry is an integral part of our cultural heritage and therefore Falconers should be allowed to continue to hunt Hares, under license, which would allow proper practising falconers to continue their pastime and also prevent the people who were formerly culling Hares with shotguns turning to birds of prey instead to continue their practise. 37892021-02-26T08:16:22.47747978John SimonWalking is painful and increases spasms in my back, legs and feet. Its not about how far I can walk. (MS)37312021-02-26T08:19:02.83747979Konrad KohlertFor more than a decade I went every year up to Scotland for grouse hawking with my falcons. It must be able for future generations of falconers too!37892021-02-26T08:28:58.10747981Clint Coventry I am a falconer of 40 years and have always hunted my Golden Eagles in Scotland our last true wilderness, its the only place in the UK to see the birds do what they do naturally 37892021-02-26T08:34:09.93747983Francesco Bonomi Sono a favore della falconeria patrimonio UNESCO 37892021-02-26T08:35:17.13347984Tommy McNallyThe hunting of mountain hares with trained eagle's Will have no effect on the numbers of hares.37892021-02-26T08:36:00.24347985Rosemary ChampionWhy was this not picked up before? Sloppy work by ScotGov. Get it sorted.37892021-02-26T08:57:18.28347986Raffaele VitaleLa falconeria è patrimonio immateriale dell unesco37892021-02-26T08:59:57.17347987Clive Wingraveas a falconer and conservationist, this is part of our UNESCO heritage.37892021-02-26T09:07:52.09747988Paul EdwardsKeep falconry going37892021-02-26T09:23:37.84347990Andy KenyonAmend this legislation so that Mountain Hares in Scotland continue to be available as a quarry species for Eagles and Hawks.37892021-02-26T09:52:56.72747991Stuart BuddenNot all disabilities can be assessed simply through the 20m rule. Greater consideration must be taking when assessing cases. Please remove this simplistic measure.37312021-02-26T09:56:17.17747992jason friggieriIts absoultuly wrong to stop eagles from hunting,its against nature37892021-02-26T10:01:40.16347993Lynda Margaret RogersBecause you can walk 20m but no more than 30m doesn't mean to you are not struggling to walk.the same. 37312021-02-26T10:08:47.6847994Dale SmithBest of luck, hopefully the politicians will exercise some common sense. 37892021-02-26T10:10:40.74747995Guy VermeulenPlease do not take a heritage away. It is an artform to be able to fly Eagles and other bird of prey. 37892021-02-26T10:22:11.46347996Stuart CollinsThe 20 metre rule is inapplicable when you have MS. There are good days and very bad days. The rule is a misguided attempt to group all disabled people together and treat them as one.37312021-02-26T10:31:03.947997Fiona croweThis not equitable for people living with ms 37312021-02-26T10:54:51.32747998John RowlandYou are killing a sport that has been established for hundreds of years37892021-02-26T11:12:29.0347999Theresa Dorman Thus service will bring more visitors to your famous golf club! And boost tourism! 37352021-02-26T11:17:59.2448001Atholl Murrayhunting with eagles or hawks only results in very few hares being taken 37892021-02-26T11:20:50.6148002Stuart munroNeed help as time is going on. 37372021-02-26T11:26:03.73748003Wendy DavisSo people who can walk 19.5 metres deserve benefits while people who can walk 20 metres don't? That's just unfair, especially given the variable nature of multiple sclerosis. If I can walk 20m in the morning when I'm fresh, but not in the afternoon when I'm tired, how does that work?37312021-02-26T11:40:10.91348004MS ROSEMARY J BOWES20 m is ridiculous, when i'm having a good day I might be able to walk that distance and then be exhausted for the rest of the day. That should not count as being able to walk that distance.37312021-02-26T12:04:57.00748008Sarah SliwinskiI support the aim.37312021-02-26T12:05:06.7148009Ron SharpWe need more money end of37372021-02-26T12:16:13.79348010Nadine BaldwinThe 20 m rule is discriminating and needs to be removed. 37312021-02-26T12:30:54.9748011Judith SpencerEveryday is a different day for people with MS. Today I can stand and walk. \r\nThat is not the case tomorrow. Everyday is different. My body can go into spasms anytime and I can lose my ability to have the strength to stand never mind walk. When laspses come it can last years..\r\nThst is the nature of the illness. If I lose the feeling in my legs I am moonwalking. because I have lost the bottom half of my limbs. Fatigue is overwhelming... memory is affected and life as a married couple is difficult. So mental health comes into play. There is no text book case MS sufferer. There are many variants as indiseases. 37312021-02-26T12:31:51.1448012Philip Baker These birds need to fly37892021-02-26T13:09:13.12748013Andrew Clifford stenhouse As a Scottish expat I'm deeply shocked that such an action would even be considered37892021-02-26T13:14:20.89748014Theresa StarrFalconry is a UNESCO recognized activity of cultural human heritage, please allow eagle falconry to continue to hunt hares in Scotland.\r\n37892021-02-26T13:14:29.06748015Andrew Clifford stenhouse All of the legislation proposals should be tossed out37892021-02-26T13:32:04.55748016Fiona AtkinsI can walk 20 metres, but anybody meeting me would instantly agree that I am disabled & getting around is very difficult for me. Every day life takes a lot of planning. 37312021-02-26T13:46:00.7148017Joan Rachelle WalkerDo not destroy the history or practice of Falconry.37892021-02-26T13:51:39.90348018Christina Muir-Wallace It would be beneficial to everyone if ferry run all year.37352021-02-26T14:14:30.93748019Mary GoodeThe Road can be treacherous at times due to weather etc or the road closed for whatever reason and a ferry all year round would give better choices, also would give the towns tourist industry a little boost. 37352021-02-26T14:23:03.12348020Terence NewmanI honestly cannot believe that this has been discussed. Falconry has been around for over 4000 years and has been a sport of all, including Royal families.\r\nPlease do not destroy our history as all this does is placate a very small minority of small minded people.37892021-02-26T14:44:39.3348022Jose Belijar SaezLa cetreria una forma de vida. Bien de interes cultural. Patrimonio inmaterial por la unesco. 37892021-02-26T14:57:31.7748023Jamie LindsayI support allowing mountain hares to be hunted for the purposes of falconry37892021-02-26T15:18:34.33348024Hubert QuadeThe art of falconry and its Scottish traditions must be allowed to continue unhindered by legislation targeted to limit another issue..that is not related to falconry with eagles..37892021-02-26T15:23:55.38348025Moyra PatersonWe need this vital lifeline.37352021-02-26T15:26:03.41348026Denise crawford We need a regular ferry for quality of life to shop and visit family. 37352021-02-26T15:36:26.32348027Murray SimmondsThis form of protection for the mountain hare should allow for a small licensed take by Falconers37892021-02-26T15:47:43.88748028Andy Willicome Falconry. The most natural method of culling37892021-02-26T16:00:33.3448030Rachid Aili Taxis owners need help and support from the government as any other small businesses. 37372021-02-26T16:40:13.56748032Veronica MacDonaldSuch a variable disease changing on am almost daily basis where you can walk one day but not the next37312021-02-26T17:05:42.53748034Antonio sanchezTodo mi apoyo a que la cetreria pueda practicar37892021-02-26T17:18:17.74348035Wendy Denton20 mtrs is unfair37312021-02-26T17:20:14.10348036david tarpeyfalconry must continue in Scotland and other places it ,is heritage and the well being of the birds. 37892021-02-26T17:21:09.17748037Ramón Ponce Mora Estoy completamente de acuerdo 37892021-02-26T17:31:29.88348038Gary Bellis Yet another piece of totally unacceptable legislation being brought in by people who have absolutely no understanding of countryside management and the need for the control of the numbers of certain species by methods such as falconry to preserve the numbers of other species, many of which are on the endangered list already and only seem to do well in areas that are managed by Game keepers and such like37892021-02-26T17:33:18.75748039Felix Penasi estoy deacuerdo37892021-02-26T17:36:11.38348040Terrence Radford Taking hares with eagles will have almost 0 impact\r\n37892021-02-26T17:37:08.55348041john mahergood luck with this, minority sport .37892021-02-26T18:23:48.648043Jose Fernando Bleda GonzalezCetreria37892021-02-26T18:27:12.90748044John LittlerMy daughter died as a consequence of MS. As she deteriorated she gradually lost the ability to walk 20m.37312021-02-26T18:32:17.75748045Kris ChorleyDo not stop this fantastic sport and discipline! 37892021-02-26T18:37:30.7248046Sylvie GARDEUX The practice of falconry must continue within Scotland 37892021-02-26T18:44:04.52348048stephen Davisall the comments below and it is entirely natural37892021-02-26T18:46:14.25748049Wayne ScobleI am an Austringer, this is against the old hunting rights 37892021-02-26T18:51:05.16748050Russ GleesonPlease consider the implications of this legislation for the health and well-being of birds of pray37892021-02-26T19:06:21.88748052Tatiana RivarolaFalconry is an anciant Art and a way of living, thanks to Falconry many species of raptors today still alive, we must protect falconry 37892021-02-26T19:15:37.74748053Katie McEvoyLift this ridiculous ban please. 37892021-02-26T19:20:48.19348054George and Sheila HarrisWe have been visiting Campbeltown for the past 18 years. The worry that the A83 will be closed is always foremost in our minds as it is a very long detour if the old military road is not being used. It is vital for the region that they have a reliable service to get to Campbeltown so visitors can continue to enjoy the area, and locals can have a route to quote the main land unquote that ensures regular delivery of provisions.37352021-02-26T19:22:59.7148055Simon RousThese rights preserve and celebrate raptors both in the wild and in hand, rather than endangering them. 37892021-02-26T19:28:04.87348056Eduardo Ortega Ruiz I agree with falconery.37892021-02-26T19:35:26.84348058Mark SmithFalconry is the only reason I travel to Scotland, and do so multiple times per year spending thousands in the process supporting the rural economy 37892021-02-26T19:35:32.4348059Laura NisbetYes. This seems an important time to acknowledge the wrongs brought upon women through fear and the pursuit of control.37332021-02-26T19:47:26.7348060Simon GraceLeave all Fieldsports alone.37892021-02-26T19:49:02.01748061Paul HargreavesYet again another attack on fieldsports and historic pastimes37892021-02-26T20:05:29.87348062Carl AdynsHow is it possible that persons who don't know what hunting means for hunters and outdoor peoples decide what we can and can't do. Its a shame. 37892021-02-26T20:09:13.9248064Mary Cameron Much needed alternative route.37352021-02-26T20:26:45.4648065Paul roseI agree the practice of falconry must continue in Scotland 37892021-02-26T21:11:19.21748066Raymond FinlaysonOur history and heritage must be protected for the present and the future\r\n37162021-02-26T21:13:34.2148067Pauline ReddingsYou lose the natural history of the highlands at your peril. 37892021-02-26T21:14:35.49748068Raymond FinlaysonThe law must be changed to prevent the Reporter from overturning decisions made by Highland Council37162021-02-26T21:15:26.49748069Carey SinclairThe whole of Drummossie Moor aka Culloden Moor needs to be a protected site not just the area around the Cairn & Visitors Centre! \r\nThere should be NO developments of any kind allowed on the Battlefield! 37162021-02-26T21:17:56.77348070Margaret EvansCulloden Field is a National graveyard and MUST remain so. This is our heritage and history.\r\nNEVER should this area be desecrated for the purposes of those who wish to make money. There would be an outcry from U.K. if the war graves of Europe were used for house building! Having visited many of them I have seen how beautifully they are kept.\r\nThere must never be anything built on this land,37162021-02-26T21:23:38.23348071Susan O'BrienPlease reconsider developing the Culloden battlefield. That piece of land is a piece of history. Many millions of people worldwide have roots that go back to that battlefield. I am one who would love to visit that site in order to learn more about my heritage and to learn from the historical lessons learned. It's so hard to visit a site of historical significance only to see it developed. Visualizing what happened and where it happened it best done if one can walk the land where our forefathers walked. By preserving history, you demonstrate the importance of learning from the past and educating future generations so the same mistakes and positive actions can be learned from. It shows respect to maintain significant sites, which clearly Culloden is one. 37162021-02-26T21:37:06.3648072Matt PhillipsField sports need to stand together or fall alone37892021-02-26T21:54:58.3148073Karl Horsman Leave the practice of falconry alone.\r\nI agree to all below. 37892021-02-26T22:08:04.84348074Margaret RobertsonI agree with all the comments below.37892021-02-26T22:18:10.30348076Steve TatmanGolden Eagles are Scottish like Thistle. Their population is dropping world-wide. Please help.37892021-02-26T22:50:06.13748077Mark ZairThe numbers of hares in which we catch yearly is minimal compared to the vast shooting estates culling numbers. However more and more people are not willing to control animal animals which IS leading to a poorer vast amount of animals due to no control being allowed to MANAGE numbers. No one wants to see there hares wipes out, same as the wood pigeon population etc. 37892021-02-26T23:03:58.4248078Stuart HadleyGood wildlife management means using common sense and not emotions as doing management by emotion only benefits us and not the wildlife. 37892021-02-26T23:07:38.52748079Abdellatif chbira Support the taxi drivers 37372021-02-26T23:25:47.3648081Merlin Jaap Becker Stop eroding our cultural way of life just because of the misinformed, ignorant and disconnected many.\r\n37892021-02-26T23:46:58.98748082Alison DuncanIt is outrageous that known battle sites, war graves - or graves, artefacts from any era, should be disturbed. Certainly not for someone making money by building.......let the dead rest in peace, and leave the historical sites for future generations to learn, remember.......37162021-02-27T00:03:27.03748083Janice KuechlerThis battlefield needs to be respected. It was historically larger and has now shrunk to what it is now. This track of land is a seriously important piece of the history of Scotland - respect it - protect it !!!37162021-02-27T00:57:04.8748085Jenny Graham MarwoodCulloden Muir is revered by Scots and their descendants around the world as hallowed ground. It is also one of the most culturally significant sights for all Scots because of its history. I am a born and bred Scottish expat and I am horrified to think that the proposed desecration of any part of the Muir would be permitted for purely financial gain. Please put a stop to this or risk seriously diminish Scotland's reputation around the world. L37162021-02-27T01:41:31.1148086Colin FrostCulloden. This is the site of the last battle fought on British soil. It is, or should be a world heritage site. It is disgusting how developers in this country should even consider building on or near these sites. They know no shame. Their are bodies here that were left to rot or be picked clean by crows, and if I remember my last visit to Culloden, they are buried in mass graves, along with individual plots. Do not desecrate a war grave and one very important to Scottish people. Find a postage stamp to build on! My apologies if my words seem a little harsh, but this is an emotive subject.37162021-02-27T01:57:18.95748087John AndersonNeeds left as it is 37892021-02-27T02:48:02.948089Owen BartonThe drainage and devegetation that occurs on grouse moor shooting estates must be stopped due to the resultant intensification of flood events. The economically poor productive uplands which naturally receive higher rainfall totals would best serve society if they were sustainably kept to slow the flow. \r\nThis is also extremely important in order to mitigate against extreme drought. NatureScot warned this year that within two decades Scotland my experience a nine fold increase in extreme drought. Much of the upland areas that are managed as grouse shooting estates have been identified as being at-risk areas that are more vulnerable and have more extreme drought events that could by 2040 last up to three months longer than present. The need for reform in upland management is urgent and returning to nature-rich future in the uplands will bring considerable benefits. \r\n37012021-02-27T05:53:22.76348092Heather ErhartDo not destroy the history of Culloden. 37162021-02-27T05:55:26.78348093Katrina schrammFalconry is a thousands year relationship between human and animals and must be allowed to continue. Legislation that hinders the ability for falconers to hunt needs to be reconsidered. Hunting Raptors keeps them healthy and the more game animals available to sustainably hunt the better. 37892021-02-27T06:35:50.39348094Nick horten This legislation is unnecessary. 37892021-02-27T06:43:38.20748095Christina MorleyYet another country way of life being destroyed by desk bound warriors. Wake up and listen to those who actually understand nature 37892021-02-27T07:01:01.49748096Jenny lloydFalconry must continue! We as the UK are losing to much of or heritage 37892021-02-27T07:31:53.31348098Craig speak I believe that falconry should continue as it is part of our heritage and should be kept alive for younger generations to see and learn37892021-02-27T07:32:39.24348099Antony BurtI regularly visit Scotland to enjoy field sports stay in hotels use pubs and restaurants when I go. Field sports contribution to the Scottish economy is huge i would like this to continue. 37892021-02-27T07:47:16.79348103Alan mccormick Let's not try to take away another one of our traditions37892021-02-27T07:47:27.86348104Clayton Hastings Protect and stop taking away our field sports 37892021-02-27T07:48:54.3348105Russell RadleyI can understand if the evidence says a ban of shooting hares because of their population but you have to control numbers and birds of prey is a natural way and I believe its a right way37892021-02-27T07:52:05.2848107Cameron MacDonaldI think falconry, in general, is better and more controlled than shooting them37892021-02-27T07:53:53.38748108Timothy Blackman Please listen to GWCT (Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust) and the scientific evidence that they have undertaken into mountain hare populations. The taking of small numbers of hares by falconers would have only positive effects on populations in taking weaker or older individuals which would in all likelyhood not survive harsh weather conditions without suffering. 37892021-02-27T07:56:49.96748109Judith MorrisPlease leave managing the countryside to those who understand it.37892021-02-27T08:11:31.76748111Heather GibbWe need people in the Scottish government who actually know about rural work! people that will come and see all the amazing people working to keep the countryside beautiful37892021-02-27T08:17:46.54748114Rachel Frankland Theyre trying their best to kill our countryside pursuits because people choose not to understand them \r\n\r\n37892021-02-27T08:23:52.81348115Nigel MayShould be allowed with landowners permission 37892021-02-27T08:24:28.37748116Martin smithThe practice of falconry must continue within Scotland welfare of the birds must be paramount37892021-02-27T08:30:21.69748117Stuart BrownOur sporting heritage should be left alone. 37892021-02-27T08:31:42.97748118Annette HoodGet a grip planning and use some intelligence. I'm exasperated that we are even being asked to object37162021-02-27T08:42:58.33348119Leigh GregoryPlease reverse this decision for the welfare of all involved37892021-02-27T08:44:47.4848120Philip Ross Government's need to stop messing with centuries of heritage. 37892021-02-27T08:50:22.96748121Michael Hewer100% no , the history and the lives lost that's why it should be preserved for our children's.37162021-02-27T09:17:30.54748123Charlie RipmanThe very best and natural control method. 37892021-02-27T09:42:45.6948126Jarrod McCorriston I agree that the age old method of falconry should continue.\r\nThe new legislation will have an impact on falconry and impact related business's.\r\nThis legislation does pose a risk to the welfare of birds of prey. \r\nYes, the number of hares need to be controlled with falconry instead of mass culling.37892021-02-27T09:48:39.79348127Robin EnglishWhy would it be necessary to prevent this activity from taking place? 37892021-02-27T09:53:17.32748128Sue AndersonStop building on the graves of our ancestors. 37162021-02-27T09:54:26.30348129Sean DickThe Government is literally trying to exterminate any sort of country sports and rural life. \r\nAbsolutely shocking. 37892021-02-27T10:03:46.78748131Robert QuirkPlease leave the country side alone the Green Party dont no anything about this 37892021-02-27T10:13:55.448132Donna StuartAll battlefields should be protected. Culloden should be a world heritage site. 37162021-02-27T10:20:24.53348133Dr. David Glynne FoxHawking mountain hares in Scotland with eagles and other raptors has been carried out for a great many years. This new legislation will have a negative impact on falconry related businesses. If this legislation continues it will condemn many of these beautiful birds to a lifetime of 30 plus years in an aviary. The banning of hunting mountain hares by the use of falconry will most likely result in more shooting licences being issued and as we all know, with falconry, there is no wounding, it is either a kill or a miss.37892021-02-27T11:17:32.30748134Miguel DitilyeuLe respect des traditions et important il faut maintenir la fauconnerie qui est respectueuses des oiseaux et des prélèvements minimes pour l'environnement.37892021-02-27T11:19:43.07748135Jane BottazziThe 20 metre rule is ridiculous when it comes to MS sufferers. Was this put in place by people that do not suffer with this affliction? Each day and each person is different. 37312021-02-27T11:19:57.63748136Eddie ServiceToo many people don't ask, they just try and stop things that have worked well for years in the rural communities Good Luck. 37892021-02-27T12:53:18.52748137Dave KingThere already has been too much disregard for the heritage of the land.It\r\n\r\nThere has already been too much disregard for the heritage of these sites.It s all about the money as always.Thinking has to change !\r\n37162021-02-27T13:04:07.3748139Patrick powerIt's centuries old between human and bird working together37892021-02-27T13:07:23.35348140Samuel Van risseghemLaisser les oiseaux et leurs compagnons travailler en bonne harmonie 37892021-02-27T13:11:20.7648141Mark warrenderThis is a UNESCO accredited sport and should not be banned 37892021-02-27T13:30:42.9548142Thomas Glyn EdnieIt would be much more sensible to license and inspect the activities of falconers rather than ban professional flying of birds of prey.37892021-02-27T14:03:34.20348143Susan GibbsAnother example of the countryside way of life being dictated and changed by those that live in the urban areas with ideological views of what rural life should be. 37892021-02-27T14:10:28.92348144YIMIR GIL CERONI am against the falconry prohibition in any part of the world because of its historical, cultural, and environmental contribution.37892021-02-27T15:58:46.82748146Kelvin Fagence Falconers no matter what breed of bird they have deserve a right year round to hunt with these incredible animals. It's in the animals instincts to hunt prey and the keepers are exceptional people, making sure the bird is fit, healthy and functional 37892021-02-27T16:11:27.08348147David Clausen-ThueA regular ferry service would be of hugh benefit to all of Kintyre.37352021-02-27T16:15:40.52348148Fiona Macdonald-Adams I think it is outright disgusting that this can happen. It is totally disgusting. 37162021-02-27T16:46:30.3748149Mark AdamsLeave the countryside to those who live in it and understand it best.37892021-02-27T17:37:10.2348150Darren woottonFalconry is an excellent way of maintaining many problem numbers of rabbits, hares, squirrels too.37892021-02-27T18:16:00.1448152sylvain petaincontre37892021-02-27T18:16:32.5848153Mike DonaldThis petition should succeed 37892021-02-27T19:02:21.91348154Sue ChipI agree that the practice of falconry must continue in Scotland37892021-02-27T19:10:51.548155Cash RobertsonI am disgusted. I want deeper protections for Culloden. My Robertson ancestors fought for Scottish Independence on Culloden battlefield.37162021-02-27T19:59:11.87348156Rhonda PatersonAll places or buildings that concern our wonderful Scottish history should be protected for us and our future generations. Our culture is worth saving for everyone. Or we are going to lose it all and if we forget history we forget our ancestors and our culture37162021-02-27T20:02:40.2448157Charles SteeleI am greatly saddened that times have come to this. That a worldwide effort is necessary to do that which is right to begin with, is very distressing.37162021-02-27T20:18:25.48748159Baz Oxley Agree 37892021-02-27T20:48:06.3848162Trevor grahamPlease let this carry on, these birds are meant to fly and hunt. Not be confined to an aviary.37892021-02-27T21:10:16.61748163Melinda YaskoffThis must be a world heritage site. 37162021-02-27T21:15:32.9748164Roger SmithThis is a world heritage. It affects us all.37892021-02-27T21:29:18.03348165Kirsty MacleodThis is a historical site and it should be protected. Keep Scotlands history safe for future generations.37162021-02-27T21:33:53.07348166John ClarkSave our historical sites whether its battlefields or not37162021-02-27T21:36:44.58348167ELIZABETH MCNEILi am totally against any development at the culloden battle field \r\n37162021-02-27T21:47:41.90348168Margaret McCannInterfering with nature never works out for nature of mankind37892021-02-27T21:49:42.95348169Stephen Findlay Scottish historical site should remain as is for future generations. 37162021-02-27T21:51:08.12348170De MagnitotIl faut que toutes les chasses puissent conginuer dans leurs diversités 37892021-02-27T22:17:09.20748171Colin McNeilWe need a ferry to help join up the country.37352021-02-27T22:45:10.47748173Anne O DonnellI think its shocking whats happening and I feel as though the Scottish government are just ignoring whats going on in front of there eyes 37162021-02-27T23:11:06.448175Judi WattsI honestly think that all the Scottish battlefields should have stricter planning and be kept for future generations and be taught all the history in schools. 37162021-02-27T23:37:12.8148177Myriam Eggebrecht I'm disgusted that such an important site of heritage is about to be destroyed as if it was any odd parking lot... I strongly hope this can be stopped!! 37162021-02-27T23:38:49.29348178Beverly Hancock Please preserve this important part of Scotland's history. I can't imagine visiting and not being able to this site. Please don't let greed win.37162021-02-27T23:49:23.09348180Amy PorterAll historic sites must be protected for the future. Just as people fought to protect the Gettysburg Battlefield in the US so too shall forward thinking people protect this most sacred and historic site in Scotland. It is up to us to do what we can to fight the ever present greed of Developers.37162021-02-27T23:55:00.09348181Jaan Arthurs Respect the history and the people who died at Culloden. The proposed developers should be ashamed of themselves!37162021-02-28T00:37:41.61748182Thomas Stobie-BrownThey're not just battlefields they are the final resting place for the fallen its a graveyard leave alone37162021-02-28T01:21:51.49748183Xavier FernandezThe falconry must continue in Scotland because is an ancestral kind of hunting, training the birds of prey to keep them in perfect conditions to fly free every day. It mustn't be prohibited, never.37892021-02-28T09:08:10.29748185Lori MacGregorPlease protect our historical sites and monuments. So many things can be instantly replaced in our through away culture, but our historical sites cannot be recreated or replaced. 37162021-02-28T09:09:02.37348186Kortney CrosbyIt is a dream of mine to someday visit Scotland, the home of my ancestors, and bear witness to Golden Eagles pursuing Hares via falconry, a sport I love with all of my heart. If this legislation goes into effect, I'm afraid my dream might never become a reality. Falconry is an ancient sport that overflows with cultural significance and tradition, and given the relative low number of quarry that are harvested yearly by means of falconry, I feel it should be allowed to continue.37892021-02-28T11:16:15.56748189Ainsley EnrightMS is a lot harder to deal with than it appears 37312021-02-28T11:34:56.6348191Fiona Young It would be excellent if this ferry route was all year round, especially with all the problems at The Rest and Be Thankful. 37352021-02-28T11:41:42.58348192June GreyPlease protect the Culloden moor for all to pay their respects.37162021-02-28T11:52:01.50748193Pascal HamelI'm agree that practice of falconry must continue in Scotland37892021-02-28T12:15:02.83748194Carl AdamsI for one, like many others, are irate that we must petition against something that should never have been proposed in the first place. Cullodaen should be given status that this problem never rears its ugly head again..... This is nothing more than desecration to the memory of the fallen that fateful day in 1746, regardless of their nationality.... 37162021-02-28T13:16:19.48748195Sheila CiancioOur historical sites must be preserved for future generations and in respect for generations past37162021-02-28T13:40:58.7148196Heide HalsteadThis is a disgrace to those that are even considering to allow this to happen. Would you build on a cemetery? If you say yes, then shame on you. This is sacred and hallowed ground. I am sure there are many other locations that would be just as suited for whatever development. 37162021-02-28T13:51:46.96348197Jackie LiddellThey have every right to fly, are you going to stop the wild population of birds too?37892021-02-28T14:19:35.85348198Anne Thompson-LayYes I do think that the Scottish government should remove the 20 metre rule from the adult disability payment eligibility framework.\r\nI live in England and went through this whole process 2 years ago, in order to qualify for the PIP payment. Which I am entitled to receive, and do.37312021-02-28T14:33:44.46748199Michael Coethis ban should not happen to a legitimate legal activity37892021-02-28T15:09:03.1148200Ariane BurgessWe must acknowledge and apologise for what happened to these people. We must ensure barbaric acts like these never happen again. 37332021-02-28T16:26:04.3948201Charles kirkSome of these laws are ridiculous37892021-02-28T16:51:24.72348202Cath McEwingOur heritage can not be sold to the highest bidder. We would not sell the war graves in France, & we should not sell off Culliden field!37162021-02-28T17:11:21.47348203Laura Rotegard Culloden needs to be protected from local greed and decision making. Development needs to be eliminated from the Visual and archeological limits of this historic area. 37162021-02-28T19:02:26.648204John James ReidyPLEASE REDUCE 20M RULE37312021-02-28T19:09:45.55348205David BowmanAll branches of falconry have very low impact on prey species populations. \r\nFalconers should be allowed to hunt mountain hares and rabbits even if under licence in my opinion..37892021-02-28T19:31:17.1248206Elias SchubachFairer kann man nicht jagen...37892021-02-28T19:35:54.8448207Alexandra Schubach Ja zur Falknerei 37892021-02-28T19:51:57.21748208roehrig joella fauconnerie est un art ancestrale qu il faut defendre a titre de conservation des espèces rapaces 37892021-02-28T22:01:26.70348209Karin maddison Such a simple thing to do, plant a tree! A small thing but has huge benefits, life saving benefits..! For our wildlife human and the generations we leave behind... 37012021-02-28T22:24:51.4348210Atholl GowIt is wrong to sentence these wonderful birds to a long life in an a avery. 37892021-02-28T22:27:41.17348211Barbara DuckittI am a first generation Canadian of Scottish parents and have been to Scotland many times. A nation that diminishes its history, diminishes its identity. There are many places to build. Personal preference cannot override national interests. 37162021-02-28T22:28:35.6648212David E CouttsThis site should be protected by the United Nations as a world heritage site.37162021-02-28T22:56:00.80348214Jennifer Bowman-Reeves Descendant of Janet Bowman, aka Janet Boyman, convicted 12.29.1572.37332021-03-01T08:56:11.08748220Maxinr bell Falconry plays an important roll in the environment and also for tourism 37892021-03-01T09:33:34.60348221Roy McLellanThis ferry is imperative, especially as you seem to be unable to sort out the rest and be thankful problem.37352021-03-01T09:36:43.34348222Liz GibsonParliament should listen to the people who look after our countryside because their way of life depends on it. Not to people who do not understand or care about it 37892021-03-01T09:57:05.73348223Jen NewellAll historical sites within Scotland must be preserved. Battlefields, conservation areas, historical buildings and lands, must be protected.37162021-03-01T10:23:30.3648225Malcolm Napier-HolfordYet more ill thought out and poorly written laws from the Scottish government37892021-03-01T12:02:06.56348226Mrs MaryCayfordI have had MS for 43 years and had been awarded DLA for life. When I had to apply for PIP, my entire benefit was taken away from me until I went to tribunal, when it was reinstated. The whole system is inhumane and made my MS deteriorate greatly. 37312021-03-01T13:57:29.20348227fiona anne stewartI think this should be removed as I don't claim it currently but have MS and some days can walk well and other days different.37312021-03-01T14:10:42.87748229Helen chadfieldWe need to save this sport as owning my own falconry business. With no help or grants but it's important to all falconers before we cannot fly birds anymore.37892021-03-01T15:12:36.18348230Andy Morton If this ban goes ahead it will destroy falconry with eagles forever & do untold damage to the hare population & the environment .\r\nThe people coming out with these proposals have no idea about life in the highlands & fieldsports in general & need to look at the bigger picture & seek proper advice from people who actually know from experience & who participate in these wonderful pastimes .37892021-03-01T15:40:32.48348231Shaun Pearce I'm shocked by this decision 37892021-03-01T16:16:41.3848233Carol GunnSome days it can take M S suffers all they got to actually get out of bed let alone walk 20metres37312021-03-01T16:34:11.78748234Bill TowardThe practice of falconry must continue in Scotland to preserve and improve the welfare of birds of prey and maintain the health of all falconry related businesses 37892021-03-01T16:34:54.91348235Nicola GalbraithIf the A83 were the M8 or A9 the problems on it would have been rectified years ago . 37352021-03-01T17:15:24.2348236Valentine ScarlettMany people benefitted from these women's skills in using herbs etc to cure them off their ailments, help them have their babies, wrap their wounds. But when rumour paid a visit they had no problem forgetting the kindnesses they had been done and joining in the condemnation. It makes me angry that this went on for so long.37332021-03-01T18:11:24.58348237Rath TanjaIts an Unesco Heritage and traditional art of hunting that should be saved and given to the next generation37892021-03-01T18:51:49.77348238William Drummond This is a centuries old sport which makes hardly any impact on the hares, its another attack on rural sport 37892021-03-01T19:15:34.5648239Robert woottonFalconry is an aged tradition and must continue for the good of the people and tradition. Also for the good of the land 37892021-03-01T19:17:52.3148240Keith GoldenLeave falconry and hunting alone go and deal with all the anti social kids and people that litter the country and fly tip etc hunting is a way of life and a healthy free way to put food on the table, stop people feeding squirrel and fox etc in gardens around the towns and cities don't just pick on hunting deal with the bigger wildlife crimes.37892021-03-01T19:25:45.24748241Will KirbyWhy can't things be left alone! Poor Falconers struggle enough as it is!37892021-03-01T19:30:20.3948243Peter Burden The good work by falconers to protect and study birds of prey is not given enough recognition by the government. Practical falconers do a fantastic job in both education and very practical conservation 37892021-03-01T20:00:41.67748244Neil P HunterFlown golden eagles at mountain hares for 19 years. This legislation is pointless. I may have to give up my much loved hobby 37892021-03-01T20:00:48.59748245Chris sciarrilloWe need to protect all our falconry practices and game management 37892021-03-01T20:08:18.20748246Rebecca HallI would love to visit this piece of history one day. It should be kept for all to see. Outlander has me in love with Scotland. I would move there in a heart beat37162021-03-01T21:13:02.71748247Kim HumphreyDo not let Falconry in Scotland become history37892021-03-01T21:54:01.7748250Tara McEown It is time that we recognize the incorrect oppression of women who practise healing through the use of plant medicine and other ancient healing techniques. 37332021-03-01T21:56:37.848251Marie MillsI agree falconry practises should continue 37892021-03-01T21:58:43.3748252Anthony rawlings I agree with all circumstances within the petition 37892021-03-01T22:19:15.30348253Alan WrightThe impact to the wellbeing of captive bred eagles must not be overlooked.37892021-03-02T00:02:59.32748256Morag CloughleyTime to make what amends we can for those so dreadfully wronged. The fear that they must have felt & the horror their families & loved ones had to go through is harrowing. A cruel, unjust punishment for innocents by an establishment who used them to their own ends. 37332021-03-02T00:52:57.6348258James EyringAs a master falconer and lifelong environmental educator it saddens me to read this please reconsider.37892021-03-02T05:07:06.9348260Kevin Sheridan I agree to all of the below 37892021-03-02T07:59:24.548261Kathy magillPart of the world wide collective healing37332021-03-02T08:23:09.81348262Joe CarstairsQuite right. Our culture respects the memory of the Miners' Strike, of Red Clydeside, of penal transportation to Australia, of the Triangle Trade, of the persecution of Covenanters. But for this miscarriage of justice, we do little more than wear the odd pointy hat on Halloween. It's time we adressed this gap in our collective memory.37332021-03-02T08:51:03.11748263Adrian TrepkaKeep falconry open37892021-03-02T09:04:14.05348264Mrs Valerie FischbacherI have MS and sometimes I can walk 20 metres, sometimes I can't as this is a fluctuations and disabling disease which effects much more than just walking37312021-03-02T09:13:46.70748265Clive GilbertWe need to stick together on this issue37892021-03-02T09:14:50.2748266Audrey BelchI don't agree with the 20 meter. rule37312021-03-02T09:20:30.53748267Keith GoldenSave our hunting history 37892021-03-02T09:28:39.58348268Doug ClarkFive years ago I wrote to every member of Holyrood with this very suggestion. Received much support and useful avenues to pursue. Good luck!37332021-03-02T09:31:13.85748269Ian Fawcettlet's have a reliable year round ferry at road cost fare tariff from Campbeltown37352021-03-02T09:39:34.97748270Kathryn BrownThe deep, historical roots of misogyny in Scotland must be faced, tackled with equal vigour and energy as Scotland now, in the 21st century, seeks to prevent and eradicate on going gender inequalities and their outcomes - including all forms of oppression of and violence against women and girls. Trauma does not just disappear, it re-seeds itself throughout generations until and unless it is reconciled through accountability and apology. 37332021-03-02T11:26:20.07348271ALION WADSWORTHA year-round service on this ferry is now essential in view of the frequent closures of Rest and be Thankful. We frequently travel from Lancashire to Kintyre and would be stranded if the Rest and be Thankful was closed and no ferry running.37352021-03-02T12:57:47.1848273michelle helsingIt's time to acknowledge the wrong doing37332021-03-02T13:11:05.45748274Mike SawickiI am a falconer in the USA and I love visiting Scotland. I plan to make another trip specifically to observe Highland falconry. Please protect and preserve this amazing tradition.37892021-03-02T13:42:26.30748275Sandra JarvisI watched a documentary years ago called "The Burning Times". It was an eye opener and called the the period a "women's holocaust". We have lists of men buried at sea and lost in battles, the Jewish people who died in concentration camps. It is time to honor the poor innocent victims...female and male...that were tortured and killed using the insane and inhumane practices to rid the world of witches all due to their twisted perception of what a witch actually was.37332021-03-02T14:30:13.648277Patricia RobertsonConcerns about refused housing applications on very historical sensitive locations are often renewed again and again. One of a previous application was gladly refused by Scottish Ministers, due to the negative impact the proposed development would have of a site of historical national importance. After the refusal, the fourth appeal is recently proposed in an attempt to gain planning permission. \r\n\r\nSadly, as we are witnessing, area’s like Culloden Battlefield could be built more and more upon. Also other areas of historical significance are under threat from developers across Scotland. The serene unique experience of walking and experiencing the Battlefield and other historical areas are irreparably lost to future generations. \r\n\r\nAnother important fact is, that in these times, the need for rewilding nature has never been more evident, according to Climate Change & in scientific rapports and worldwide discussed, is the relation between Global Warming versus Covid-19. \r\n\r\nIt is more than ever necessary, that the natural habitats stays intact. \r\n\r\nClimate goals that recently are spoken about worldwide: \r\n\r\nRewilding Nature, because of the high importance due to climate and biodiversity emergencies. \r\n\r\nAll those positive benefits of rewilding nature, cleaner air, is a resilience to disease and climate change. \r\n\r\nThe grassland habitat at Culloden Battlefield belongs to a variety of different plants and many of them are medicinal plants. Wildlife is disturbed already, by the new houses, historical ground that is destroyed. My hope and urge, is that the damage will not go further by even more new houses and so on and out of respect for Scottish Heritage, the brave fallen & our present and future generations.37162021-03-02T15:31:08.85748278Robert SavageI agree the ban on hunting will have a negative impact on hare population and falconry. Leading to further conservation problems. 37892021-03-02T16:07:44.09748280Kurt SchmidtFalconry has no impact in prey populations. Frequently other human land management activities are to blame for the decline of a species and those with the least impact get restricted, whereas the land management practice causing the decline continues to do its damage and decimated the species. Please allow the hunting of hares by falconry to continue.37892021-03-02T16:07:46.6148281Brian AllanFlying a Eagle at hare will have a very low in pack on hare population opposed to shooting them. 37892021-03-02T16:17:55.31748282Martin AlldrittNo reason for this ban to go ahead37892021-03-02T16:27:54.50748283Barry RosePlease leave our heritage alone37892021-03-02T16:41:29.39748285Glenn BradwellYes lift this ban37892021-03-02T17:13:22.07348286Carrie ToddWe must teach people about these atrocities to ensure this doesn't happen again. I have done a lot of research into this historic barbarity 37332021-03-02T17:37:30.89348287Sheran BoelemaWill cause more harm than good for both hares and birds of prey37892021-03-02T19:18:04.42348288Steven Tolley Falconry is recognised as an Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity by UNESCO. 37892021-03-02T20:21:41.94348291Yves HAYAUX DU TILLYA gesture required to acknowledge a wrongdoing, bring justice and honour the victims of such atrocities to heal historical wounds.37332021-03-02T20:44:53.83748292Evonne Hynd Acknowledge and correct the wrongs doing towards all these women! 37332021-03-02T20:59:48.948293John Mease As a lifelong falconer, I'm very sad to see legislation like this ....hare need no protection they already have it on the shooting estates they live on! Where the largest numbers of hare can be found !37892021-03-02T21:01:04.5148295Matthew GageSustainable hunting has always been the most powerful and effective conservation tool. Hunters care, and know how to be sustainable.37892021-03-02T21:04:21.5148296Lewis Clifford 100% Back Falconry! Things are getting ridiculous regarding bans etc37892021-03-02T21:07:53.30748297Julie Stewart Historical practices have been used for good reason, stop changing what is right for the environment and those who live in the environment. You don't know better.37892021-03-02T21:13:54.1948298Philip DuncanThe Taxi trade in Scotland needs urgent help as soon as possible, I speak as an operator whose costs are high paying for a brand new taxi, we need help now 37372021-03-02T21:15:02.98748299Tessa rentonI agree with all the below statements regarding falconry.37892021-03-02T21:42:14.0348301patty culbertsonWe are not going to move out of the wasteland we have created until we elevate the feminine principle of care and caregiving for people and the planet. What will help us do that is to bring out of the shadows the deep misogyny that has now left its mark on our shared Mother Earth in a way that is potentially torturous to everyone on the planet if it continues. 37332021-03-02T22:16:07.58348302Alan walkerShould be licensed to falconers 37892021-03-03T02:59:55.4648303Harmony GreenPlease do the right thing finally! Bury the fear that took the lives of so many. 37332021-03-03T08:16:54.8848307Gary BaxterWhat you in the Parliament/Government have done yet again shows your ignorance and contempt for the countryside and its people your Hare population is now in great danger of disease and a slow painful death.Its a falconers right to hunt the mountain Hare and you have no right to take this from us.37892021-03-03T09:17:42.87348309Michael Smith Let's hope the Scottish government has more sense than their English counterparts. \r\nScrap the 20meter rule.37312021-03-03T10:03:10.06748310Clive richardsonI agree with all below37892021-03-03T10:21:26.33348311Pauline CameronThe 20 m rule is totally nonsense. As someone, with spina bifida, I could occasionally make that..but would be in agony!!37312021-03-03T10:32:15.94748312Sandie JohnstoneTry living in my shoes for a day .\r\nSo easy to judge when your not disabled 37312021-03-03T10:38:43.19748313John GallagherI agree with all statements regarding Falconry practices 37892021-03-03T14:22:24.52748315Colin FarrerAs a taxi operator, I need assistance to maintain a high standard of vehicle on the road37372021-03-03T16:17:52.85748316Jenny Hambidge10 metres there and ten metres back In couldn't even cross the main road.37312021-03-03T18:08:07.02348317Vinny YoungYes I agree 37892021-03-03T21:32:55.5248318Wendy BrannignPlease do the right thing and ban this once and for all.37012021-03-04T00:18:02.07348319Penny ChristmasMost victims were hung, not burned at the stake, men and women were accused by their neighbours and sometimes family if any land was involved. It was an atrocity and should be corrected.37332021-03-04T01:16:08.11348320Antoine helias \r\nJe suis d'accord avec toutes les déclarations concernant les pratiques de fauconnerie et faut savoir la fauconnerie est ici depuis 3500 ans donc c'est ordre questions qu'on enlève la fauconnerie !!! La fauconnerie c'est un art et c'est aussi un culture !! 37892021-03-04T03:29:29.73748321William Dollar I completely agree with, and support the Ancient Art of Falconry, in all its forms!!37892021-03-04T08:36:50.07748322Martin TomanDon't kill falconry in your beautiful country, please. 37892021-03-04T09:31:38.19748323Katharina WeinbergerScotland without Falconry is pointless and a disaster for the falconry37892021-03-04T12:54:43.6348324Russell Lehman It's not all Beatrix potter in the countryside where they all stop for tea and cucumber sandwiches. Proper countryside management must continue to ensure the correct biodiversity of rural areas and to support the local communities. 37892021-03-04T13:12:40.63348325Peter MillerI am surprised CalMac Scottish Government has not implemented this already. Having made the journey via Ambulance several times, non-emergency visits would be a lot less stressful.37352021-03-04T14:28:11.348326Theresa Dinsdale I totally agree with this petition 37892021-03-04T17:09:03.77748328Abderrahmane CherguiWe taxi owners were misinformed about low emissions. The cost of the taxi is like a mortgage. We must get a separate grant.37372021-03-04T17:51:24.15748330Julia AndersonThey need to be Pardoned.37332021-03-04T18:19:05.22348331Rocio Cayetano Because it's never too late to ask for justice.37332021-03-04T18:33:57.11348332Louise AvrilThese women need to be pardoned, and need to be recalled to history, for their legacy and for their descendants too. \r\n37332021-03-04T18:38:08.19348333David WilsonStood on the shore at Toryburn looking at a grave slab of a woman accused of being a witch, and I don't know why there isn't a plaque about the barbaric treatment of these women.37332021-03-04T19:12:54.55748334Dave A SimsPlease help support the future of falconry.37892021-03-04T19:21:08.1248335Robert AllottI agree with all statements37892021-03-04T19:33:19.37348336brian murphyI wholeheartedly agree with the below statements 37892021-03-04T19:56:06.9748337Tyler DentFalconry is often misunderstood as a pursuit that results in the taking of scores of game. The reality of success in falconry is found in teams of falconers, dogs and raptors that are presented with predation opportunities that more often than not result in missed attempts. Prey and predators are evenly matched, and falconers are lucky to leave the field, especially with any species of hare, with even a single head of game in the bag. Falconry is about the training and observation of raptors performing natural predation behaviours against prey that have evolved to evade predators. Falconry is not an effective means of taking large bags of prey, a fact that is made clear by the adoption of gunpowder for sustenance hunting. Modern falconry has never had a negative impact on the natural balance of prey and predator and allowing falconry on your hare populations will not inhibit their ability to effectively mate and succeed in the wild.37892021-03-04T20:26:39.0648339Edward McCluskeyFull pardon for all who were greatly wronged! 37332021-03-04T21:20:58.33348340Lance nicholsonRidiculous left wing policy, mid representing the rural community37892021-03-04T22:37:15.17348342Sharon CollinsThese trials are still as relevant today as they were then, we must stay conscious of the treatment to our womenkind. It must not be given a fools pardon and swept under the carpet. We are have our voice now, lets be heard! 37332021-03-05T02:04:11.64748343Junko YoshidaI agree with all statements regarding protecting falconry in Scotland. 37892021-03-05T07:17:06.39748344Sarah MoultonThis should be allowed to\r\ncontinue 37892021-03-05T08:58:22.46348346Doug GreavesFalconry is the sport of kings and its history is rich.\r\nEagles will hunt hares and rabbit naturally anyway and falconry will not make a big difference to the overall population. Please think before you act.\r\n37892021-03-05T09:12:26.148347Jennifer FreelA permanent ferry service is essential not only as an alternative to the frequent Rest and be Thankful closures but would also facilitate tourism. Frankly I am now worried about using the Rest and be Thankful route to Campbeltown, albeit a stunning route. 37352021-03-05T09:24:17.77348348Louise YoungWhy change it, the birds need to do what they normally do37892021-03-05T09:25:07.49348349Lynn CameronI agree with all the statements re: Falconry practices37892021-03-05T09:26:43.1448350David GlasgowAs a taxi operators I was forced by the council to purchase a new taxi in 2019 due to the emissions ruling. This has meant that I have payments of £500 every month. On top of this I have my normal expenditures, of which when all added up will equal around £1200 per month. I was asked by the government in May to only work if 100% necessary. I have 2 elderly aunt's who stay at home alone, and I was the only person around that could help them, therefore I also decided for their health that I would do there weekly shopping so had to keep clear of the virus and not work. When things got better at the end of July they decided it was ok to go to the shops again, so I went out to work again. The government have given all taxi drivers 76.66% of 9 months salary (based on the last 3 years). Unfortunately this has meant that my driver has not needed to work at all this year as he has no expenditures and his outgoings have drastically decreased, leaving me with just 76.6% of my previous years average salary after expenditures. With this I still have around £1200 per month expenditure to pay out. I have received an extra £1500 on top from the Scottish government, however even with this I still have to earn money to pay of my business bills before I start to earn money for myself. The fact is, the government had enabled my drivers to sit at home whilst the owners of the taxi that they drive have been left to fall into debt and possibly lose the business, therefore the rental driver will not have a job to go back to after having an easy year off. My income has drastically decreased when out working. I average around 5 to 6 jobs a day of 10 hours, and often make just £5 per hour on average before paying for fuel. This is unacceptable according to the government minimum wage. Having worked hard since August I am expecting to earn around £6000 after expenditures. With this I have to pay all my household bills, of which council tax and electricity is over half of this.37372021-03-05T09:26:57.67348351Rev Martyn Sullivan Falconers should continue to be able to fly their birds as they have done across the centuries. This is a culturally recognised practice and should remain so37892021-03-05T10:00:21.47348353mark whittetPH trade needs supportive MSP with hands on experience, new leaders and strategic direction to fight over-regulation.37372021-03-05T10:12:35.08348354Darren SmithEven before the Coronavirus crisis, the TAXI trade as a whole was increasingly under pressure. This was due to the high number of PHC (private hire companies) mainly UBER who have had a devastating effect on the TAXI Trade. People have to recognise that running costs for TAXIS are far higher than that of a car. Covid has just wiped some businesses out and will continue to do so.37372021-03-05T10:17:31.86748355Kevin aitken Please support taxi owner-operators, the cost of our Cab payments is unsustainable in the current lockdown situation.37372021-03-05T10:19:22.8248356Jacci Miller The Taxi trade needs urgent help. Taxi owners and drivers are suffering financially and mentally with the lack of support from Scotgov. 37372021-03-05T10:19:58.80348357William PurnellDuring this time I have seen my income drop by 70% and need excerpt assistance to continue. 37372021-03-05T10:32:39.5548358David ParryThe knowledge of people who commit their lives to this most demanding of sports helps preserve not only the birds that nurtured by committed falconers but the wild populations of both predator, prey and the habitat upon which they both depend. The same sense of wonder evoked by The Eagle Huntress - a film applauded by millions, is present on our doorstep and we must preserve it for future generations 37892021-03-05T11:07:01.37348359Gordon Macdonald Taxi operators like myself have invested in Euro 6 vehicles as dictated by the Council to improve the environment. \r\nThese vehicles range from £40-60 thousand pounds.\r\nTo commit to the taxi business this is what is now required and is akin to having a mortgage which has to be paid within 5 years.\r\nAs operators have more liabilities it follows that they have bigger costs.\r\nIf you have more than one taxi operating, you can imagine an even bigger strain.\r\nAs I myself run two taxis I understand this completely.\r\nI believe that operators require more help financially as they are doing their bit not only employing people who wish to drive a taxi but also doing their bit for the environment.\r\n37372021-03-05T12:31:34.9748360paul GrahamI am proud to be Scottish, this battlefield is a distinctive part of Scottish heritage and should be left alone.37162021-03-05T13:43:57.35748361Tom JonesI’ve hunted Blue Hares with a golden eagle when they were plentiful and not like most of nature now- under the cosh of Humanity. People need to get real. I agree that falconry in Scotland must continue but all of the other statements(below) are just self-serving nonsense and it concerns me that AFWF (an organisation with good intentions) has got itself associated with this cause as a stated project.37892021-03-05T14:49:41.96748362Vicki AndersonThese victims deserve justice. 37332021-03-05T14:53:05.7848363Patrick austFalconry is a important cultural link between humans and nature- it helps preserve a valuable reference point in our shared history 37892021-03-05T16:51:57.10748364Kevin SmithI agree with the comments on this petition. The practice of falconry has existed for over 4000 years. Please do not take actions which will threaten the viability of this culturally significant activity.37892021-03-05T17:24:28.59748365Emilie BarrThere were also men killed as so called witches in Scotland and it would appear to be a class issue as much as a gender one.37332021-03-05T17:26:21.48748366Kirsty HeggieSo mote it be.37332021-03-05T17:29:08.53348367norma groganIts essential to have a year round ferry service. 37352021-03-05T18:54:17.5348369Chad Robertsonwhy is it that all around the world people want to destroy the history of their nations. \r\n37162021-03-05T22:08:04.25348371Inmaculada DiazFair petition.37332021-03-05T23:11:27.96748372Misty Twisty The truth will come out and when it does I hope everyone who put those poor souls through hell will eat their words.37332021-03-06T07:02:19.94348373Jason hopeI believe the hunting of hares should be legal, especially with the use of birds of prey37892021-03-06T08:00:31.69348374Douglas MacdonaldA bus link for Glasgow from the ferry in Ardrossan is also required. 37352021-03-06T10:43:46.5548375Nigel Vernon Scrap the 20m rule, it is a very cruel and unnecessary rule.37312021-03-06T13:14:56.66748377Claudia San MiguelI have studied History for years. These unforgettable crimes against people, women particularly have been horrifying. I always feel really sad. Perhaps, this petition will put in order those fails. Although they have been tortured and murdered. They were completely innocent 37332021-03-06T13:30:52.79348379Carrie Cartmill These women were innocent. Healers, midwives, wisewomen were all something feared by the church for their skills. It still happens in some countries today. Please let us remember these women and let us tell their stories. 37332021-03-06T14:22:41.49348380Julie saleh solimanFalconry is an ancient sport and it must be saved, if this goes ahead what will be next?? 37892021-03-06T17:36:47.4948381Andrew PlattenI agree with all the statements and it would be a sad loss to falconry and the natural instincts of the birds to not allow this to continue37892021-03-06T20:41:52.8648383Ingrid Z. AllenCulloden as other battlefields are an important piece of history that needs to be preserved and protected. Covering up or developing such areas is disrespectful and disgraceful. Men died on that field. The development is wrong. 37162021-03-07T09:10:31.8348385Km AndersonOne of my ancestors Isobel Goudie was a victim.37332021-03-07T10:49:24.3348386Tracy Ferguson The hare population is exploding. Once out of control like all things licenses to cull will be next. Please reinstate the right to hunt with nature vs nature. 37892021-03-07T11:24:40.0148387Iolanda CavaScottish friends, I am with you.\r\nA few days ago I joined the manifesto No Eren Bruixes, promoted by catalan magazine Sapiens, for the recognition and dignity of #women accused of witchcraft in our country until the eighteenth century.\r\nSisters tortured to death for being free thinkers, vulnerable or different.37332021-03-07T12:17:29.46748388George JohnstonI agree with all the statements about falconry below.37892021-03-07T12:59:06.9648389Siusaidh NicNeillJustice should have no time limit. We must get justice for them now so that all women can move on and escape misogyny across the planet. 37332021-03-07T13:07:43.34748390Matteo Toniato Falconry and Hawking are the best human activities can save raptors in the wild as well in captivity. I totally agree what is written below 37892021-03-07T13:16:44.04348391William DrummondI agree with all comments 37892021-03-07T13:36:47.35348392Elspeth CowanI'm a bit late coming to this but absolutely believe it is essential to acknowledge the persecution and brutality women suffered during this period.\r\nGood luck! 37332021-03-07T14:11:30.29348393Samuel WhibleyI agree with all four statements presented and we absolutely must not let practises like this die out.37892021-03-07T16:04:48.50348394Rhona SmythWe need to give these women a voice!37332021-03-07T16:11:28.2848395Ruth McKayTime to look our history in the eye. The way women were treated in the past echoes in the present. 37332021-03-07T16:21:05.1648396Morag FrameThe fear still exists.37332021-03-07T16:21:16.7548397ZOE HELENEPardons, apologies, and a monument won't right the wrong -- but at least this vile HIStory won't remain hidden in some haunted dungeon. THANK YOU.37332021-03-07T16:25:01.42748398Marisa YeamanThese people deserve justice now, as there was none in their time, and the silence serves to erase the horrendous injustice that was committed.37332021-03-07T16:28:27.81748399Virginia GillespieThere are holes in my Scottish Heritage that this initiative can mend as well as restoring justice and balance. We can modify history by wise choices in the present that educate all and inspire tolerance and dignity and respect.37332021-03-07T16:30:02.0248400Susan MacleanWomen (and some men) were persecuted for many reasons, but not for the reason given. They were not witches, they were the old, the infirm, the disliked and unlucky. Many suffered a horrible fate. We can't help anything more than restore their reputations and apologise for what they suffered. Please do so. 37332021-03-07T16:40:48.7148401Margareth Stewart Great to see this 37332021-03-07T16:55:56.84748402Virginia WolffenbuttelLove for those who death!37332021-03-07T16:57:18.85348403Pete BlabyI agree that the new legislation will have a very negative impact on all falconry and related business 37892021-03-07T17:57:29.4548405Elaine BarrassScotland you did these Women wrong you served them poorly it's time to right this wrong37332021-03-07T18:09:26.92748406Scott CameronLet us put this wrong, right37332021-03-07T18:54:29.92748407paul drakethis would be so short-sighted to to effectively ban eagle falconry part of our cultural heritage37892021-03-07T19:51:32.07748409Gwen GeisingerThis is the right thing to do.37332021-03-07T20:12:04.67348410Lorna BurnsI find the 20 metre rule cruel. To be judged on something that has such consequences for me personally, is awful. 37312021-03-07T22:06:13.0848412Morag FrameThe poor and powerless always pay!37332021-03-08T06:36:21.348413Janis DicksonDefinitely agree, time these women were pardoned37332021-03-08T12:37:45.73348416Ann DeansAs MS is such a variable Ill health issue the 20metre rule is so unfair a definitely not a marker for such a cruel illness.37312021-03-08T12:57:30.28348418Laura GrahamFailing to understand the mistakes of history condemn us to repeat them. Recent history has shown us the power of the mob and how poorly conceived legislation can allow unexpected and frightening results for individuals. This has been a long time coming. An apology and exoneration of the supposed crimes is the least, we, as a society should do. 37332021-03-08T13:14:43.5248419Katy DenniffOf considerable symbolic significance at a time when women's rights are under unprecedented attack37332021-03-08T13:42:32.0748421Sarah CroftsWhat a powerful statement this would make, and help heal the wounds women still carry from these days. 37332021-03-08T14:19:32.2548423Jim SmithReusable masks are on sale in bargain shops for less than £1. Face coverings can be a scarf or any other piece of cloth37742021-03-08T14:35:22.12748424Esther Mancilla Rodriguez Apoyo la petición desde Spain 37332021-03-08T15:11:13.6448426Ale PatinhoWe need this37332021-03-08T15:38:23.39748427Melvyn TimminsSigning is the least I can do37332021-03-08T16:32:06.8148431Rosa Paz justice for the victims!!37332021-03-08T16:40:39.9548432William DurowseBanning the hawking of blue hares in scotland, would be very damaging, not only to the conservation of blue hares, which eagle hawking aids, but also to falconry as a whole, as it is Inscribed by UNESCO as an Intangible Cultural Heritage of Mankind, so to deny these practices the right to continue is to be erasing our culture 37892021-03-08T16:42:22.2848433Gail McGuireAbout time something was done to honour these victims of injustice.37332021-03-08T17:24:31.68348434Mandy Hughes We are the fortunate, many have suffered. Today, International Womens Day, I hope and pray for all those that have been silenced. For those that do not \r\nYet have a voice. 37332021-03-08T17:27:39.3848436Robert Jones The few mountain hares taken by falconers is no justification for government to ban them from their heritage sport that has existed for centuries 37892021-03-08T17:36:46.4648437Mayca López picóFor the love of my witch ancestors! 37332021-03-08T18:14:21.04348441Wendy ThomsonWitches walk among us. We are the womb. 37332021-03-08T18:34:37.76748442Kevin AmairaThe loss of a UNESCO HERITAGE recognised practice is deplorable. This is not a rich man's sport and represents a worldwide industry that guarantees the birds long existence and geology due to responsible breeding and natural training and hunting behaviour. Scotland is a world leader in this front, without the breeding of our falconers where will the young come from if the birds living wild come under pressure from extreme weather or disease? Hares must be controlled otherwise if their numbers rise un-challenged, food production for human and animal feed will suffer.37892021-03-08T18:53:54.33748443Celia MeriA national monument.37332021-03-08T19:41:27.5148445Graham Milton Better late than never.37332021-03-08T20:54:21.52748447Patricia CachoBringing historical fairness to women37332021-03-08T21:07:34.96748449Carmen Mora poloSi a realizar un monumento por aquellas mujeres asesinadas. 37332021-03-08T21:12:35.46748450John GordonAs I come from Paisley and having heard the stories as a kid, it's a great idea to acknowledge the wrongs done to those women and make it a proper part of history - for the right reasons. 37332021-03-08T21:19:34.52348451David KanellisAs a American falconer I support this petition. Falconry is rich with 4000 years of culture but sometimes is overlooked and falls victim when laws are created to stop another activity. Nothing is more honest and real as a wild or trained raptor doing what they do. Falconers are a small group and one of the biggest conservation minded group of people in reality. I have always planned to travel to Scotland to watch my fellow falconers across the pond fly on the moors. Please allow mountain hare hunting with falconry birds it's the right thing to do. 37892021-03-08T21:28:37.01348452Ana ZapataJusticia37332021-03-08T21:48:19.07348453Estefania BrunJustice for them all!37332021-03-08T21:59:08.9148455Peter JacksonDo this. 37332021-03-08T22:41:28.1548456Rachael ForbesI think that a pardon, an apology and a monument for all those women and men who underwent such brutal suffering is essential for Scotland. 37332021-03-08T23:15:52.9548458Paula Aguado FernandezJusticia37332021-03-08T23:27:25.7548459Noelia Martinez"Somos las nietas de las brujas que no pudieron matar"37332021-03-09T00:53:04.5548461Lidia Ruiz JordanIn memory of so many brave women and veneration of mother earth, forever.37332021-03-09T02:09:12.3848462alejandra sosaApoyo la causa y firmo en defensa de las injusticias cometidas hacia las mujeres37332021-03-09T03:16:40.6648464Luciana Valeria SosaAs one of them, I claim pardon, mercy and respect. Hope after so many years, the witches of Scotland, have what they deserve.37332021-03-09T03:56:30.27748465Rosemary MacKenzieTo remember and apologize is the least we can do.37332021-03-09T08:25:10.04748466Esther OviedoJustice must be done for these women who were unjustly executed. It is something symbolic but it represents doing justice for them.37332021-03-09T09:06:08.78748467Nerea FernandezWise women who took care of their community were tortured and murdered. We won't forget yous. In loving memory.37332021-03-09T09:21:00.948468Laura FeliuThe least we could do is to apologise and commemorate our ancestors. They are all in us. 37332021-03-09T09:22:34.5448469Fay McGheeI agree to the apology and quash the convictions.37332021-03-09T09:53:55.37348470Gen barkerThis cause is close to my heart. Those people deserve this to be passed.37332021-03-09T12:05:23.90748471Robin ClarkA very interesting and worthy petition for women who are mostly forgotten or deemed not worth bothering about. 37332021-03-09T14:41:38.34348473Ariel NihanyNecesitamos sanar las memorias ancestrales37332021-03-09T15:16:03.81348474Josafat ConcepcionBring Justice!37332021-03-09T15:24:53.3648476Matilde MunozEstoy de acuerdo en que fue una injusticia37332021-03-09T15:50:40.86348477Maria Jose Trevino CerrosDe acuerdo con esta peticion de disculpa y reconocimiento para las personas afectadas por la Ley de Brujeria de 156337332021-03-09T17:44:27.91348478Pat McCormackSadly this cannot save those poor women from the terrible fate they endured, but at least they will not be forgotten. Rest In Peace.37332021-03-09T18:18:07.94348479Adriana PeredaIt's so outrageous how far human's cruelty can go. I'm so upset and hurt about what happened with all those who were convicted. Getting an apology is the least we can do for all of them. 37332021-03-09T21:41:18.9448481Fionnag NicChoinnichIt's time to honour the memory of these people by removing the stigma of their unjust and inhumane convictions. These were all real people.37332021-03-09T21:50:18.32348482Mark McFeelyPlease keep Falconry alive and well 37892021-03-09T22:56:17.5248483Danielle DaleyI agree 37332021-03-09T23:50:25.40348484Misha McCullaghThank you for speaking up for all these people. Heres to their justice and memory. 37332021-03-10T08:50:19.30348485Mr James McLanaghanThese birds must be allowed to fly and "hunt" as that is in their blood and training and if stopped would deny them real life.37892021-03-10T09:33:50.17348486Jacqueline UrquhartPlease scrap the 20m rule! 37312021-03-10T09:49:11.25748488Elizabeth GrantAbility to walk or move can personally vary so much it cannot be defined in such general terms.37312021-03-10T10:21:01.89348490Patricia CongaltonThe 20 meter rule should be scrapped. It is so unfair 37312021-03-10T10:30:48.83348491JOANNE LINSKEYI Have Cp and can walk and feel penalised by this how far can you walk please scrap the 20m rule 37312021-03-10T10:35:59.11348492Aileen MacfarlaneMS is not consistent. Some days 20 metres is entirely possible, but it can take a few days to a week to fully recover from it. Its not fair to be based on one day, which could be a good day, and not see the results in the following week, like unable to get out of bed, only able to shuffle along a few feet before fatigue hits, unable to leave your house etc.37312021-03-10T10:44:18.13748493Joann Lightbody Just because somebody can walk 20mtrs doesn't take Into account the fatigue that takes over your body. 37312021-03-10T10:57:59.26348494Alexander BrownIt appears to be another Tory costcutting measure. It doesn't address people's needs. It restricts people's freedom, particularly in rural areas. It's all about punishment and control.37312021-03-10T11:03:21.54748495Ann Marie FreelI agree37332021-03-10T11:10:18.40748496Yvonne butlerIncredibly unfair, some days 20mtrs + may well be attainable , other days 20cm is impossible . 37312021-03-10T11:18:47.37748498Lesley GreenYes I do as most days I can only walk 10 steps and have to stop 37312021-03-10T11:45:20.8248499Alison Smith As a person with a disability, luckily, I can still drive but there will come a time when I cannot. 20m is a ridiculous restriction, that's from my front door to my garden gate. My MS means my condition varies from day to day and although I can easily walk that distance I struggle to carry anything that far and being on my feet for over half an hour is exhausting. The legislation must be more realistic in understanding the complexities of the many illnesses that impact on people's abilities just to do the daily basics37312021-03-10T11:56:04.02348500George GordonRobert Baillie principle of the University of Glasgow mentions in 1643 the regret of the multiplying of witches. above 30 being burnt in Fife, formed a committee to find a way to cure it. The regret was for the sin of witchcraft, not of the burning.37332021-03-10T12:43:16.26748501Carol WrightPlease scrap the 20 metre rule37312021-03-10T12:46:13.49348502Carol Wright Please scrap the 20 metre rule.37312021-03-10T13:46:40.34748504Gary WilliamsonPreviously been rejected because I managed to walk 20m with the aid of walking sticks, absolute disgrace 37312021-03-10T14:45:38.68348505Susan RitchieThe SEISS covers profit but not fixed costs. Please give the taxi trade in particular Operators additional business support. Most only purchased Euro 6 vehicles to comply with GCC LEZ originally to be brought in 2020. The trade needs more support.37372021-03-10T14:50:15.7248507marion johnstonPlease scrap the 20 m rule ,it not a fair marker for deciding entitlement especially with an illness such as ms and similar illnesses where ability can vary from day to day .37312021-03-10T15:09:13.848508Beverley DottJust another example of the DWP flouting the law. Would be great if there was a lawyer or MSP brave enough to raise their head above the parapet.37312021-03-10T15:28:52.95348509Kim ChrystieIt should be sufficient just to say I have MS and not have to explain symptoms 37312021-03-10T15:45:24.2148511Agnes Martin I have secondary progressive MS and this worries me.37312021-03-10T15:53:01.72748512Chris CurranWithout some form of government aid, I may be forced to hand my vehicle back to the hire purchase company as I have used all my savings on paying back payments and other related business costs.37372021-03-10T15:59:32.38348513Lilian Gray Please scrap the 20metre rule as Multiple Sclerosis is a fluctuating illness that gets worse over time with no cure!37312021-03-10T16:00:40.80748514Neil JardineTotally forgot about as if they look down their noses at us but certainly don't when they are drunk at Xmas parties. Then they rely on us.37372021-03-10T16:08:57.5448518Scott William GrayAfter being made redundant from my last place of work I have invested in an electric car as per Dundee city council regulations for new Taxi operator's at a cost of over £25,000 just before the pandemic hit thus leaving me with no income and no support whatsoever from the government due to not having any self assessment tax returns for them to check.37372021-03-10T16:18:13.27748519Joe Robbins HMRC assistance is only being received at the end of three-month periods and is not given to all taxi-drivers. Most, therefore, do not have sufficient savings to pay household bills as they fall due.37372021-03-10T16:31:04.62348520iris LongworthI believe that the Church too should apologise. Many were hanged for heresy.37332021-03-10T16:42:15.5348521kathleen dooleyI think as all illnesses and disabilities vary so much then the 20 metre rule should be scrapped and maybe base different rules on people's individual illness or ability.37312021-03-10T16:50:47.84748522Lynn ByersEvery day is different. Should have been scrapped before now!37312021-03-10T17:11:54.14348523Louise MorgonPlease scrap the 20m rule.37312021-03-10T17:17:29.2748524Coral LopezI agree37332021-03-10T17:25:08.09748525Vivien JarvieI wish to see the 20 meter rule removed from the ADP as not all disabilities are mobility disabling. 37312021-03-10T17:25:48.25748526Graham essonMaybe possible on a good day but days are not always good37312021-03-10T18:22:17.74748527Caroline SmithPlease scrap this rule, this will affect my daughter who suffers from MS. She needs an adapted car and couldn't get to work without one so therefore won't have a job which she enjoys while she is still able, this would also affect her mental health. She prides herself on still being able to contribute to society. 37312021-03-10T19:00:41.8348528Maureen CaisleyI agree the 20 metre rule should be scrapped.37312021-03-10T19:31:24.66348530Ashley Clyde I think this is shocking we with having to live with ms struggle to walk in our bad days and to scrap this is a discracise 37312021-03-10T19:42:01.72748532Jill MorrisonThe 20m rule is disgusting and degrading! 37312021-03-10T20:04:21.24348533Michelle DunnEven on the occasion we can manage the 20m we can and do trip ,fall and get injuries or because we stagger we are looked down apon as people assume we are under the influence, which is demeaning and embarrassing. Also any activity comes with a price which along with injuries from falls is fatigue which impacts on our life. 37312021-03-10T20:13:42.85748535Stephen mclellan A year of no earnings and excluded from any other help is just wrong workers being paid to stay home while taxi drivers have to go to work putting their families at risk is outrageous 37372021-03-10T20:15:08.82348536Nick alchin1500 for taxi drivers, 4000 for mobile close contact businesses, what are we then? 37372021-03-10T20:33:12.2848537Martin Macphee Please help we are struggling.37372021-03-10T20:38:27.9248538Darren ColthartIt would help.37372021-03-10T20:40:27.2848540James Baxter I have not been able to work from mid December till only last week due to Covid -19 circumstances. This has had a profound effect on my business as it has on all taxi and private hire drivers. We need help to cover our fixed costs while we could not work. Please consider this carefully. 37372021-03-10T20:40:37.32748541Wahid aliTaxi driver in north Lanarkshire we struggling really hard to cover payments loss of earning dropped massively we need urgent help.37372021-03-10T20:45:32.26348542Denise McElroyPlease scrap the 20 metre rule37312021-03-10T20:47:39.3348543Amar Ullah Not just the taxi trade the Private Hire trade is also effected.37372021-03-10T20:51:30.79748544John RitchieThe taxi trade needs more financial support.37372021-03-10T20:55:36.8948545Sylvia FotheringhamPoor, poor souls37332021-03-10T21:10:54.97348547Muhammad Rashid The financial support i.e. £1500 provided by the Scottish government to taxi and private hire drivers doesn't make a fraction of what our outgoing are, and it does not compare to Irish and Welsh governments support. I urge the Scottish government to review this fund and give us equal support as of those businesses with rateable properties i.e.£10,000. 37372021-03-10T21:20:09.16348549Naweed HafizHelp, need more money and grants to get us through this pandemic money is down by 60-70 percent.37372021-03-10T21:35:47.72748550Peter KeeganLost everything.37372021-03-10T21:43:14.96348551Annie NobleThe 20m rule is a nonsense and insulting to disabled people. Many days I can't get out of bed, others I can make it to the kitchen. Every few weeks on very special days I can walk to the end of the garden, that doesn't make me any less disabled but does make me feel like a real person again.37312021-03-10T21:47:27.88348552Margo ClarkeAs a retired Occupational Therapist who has assessed many people, the whole person and illness must be taken into consideration. It s a well known fact hat activity carried out one day can affect ability in subsequent days therefore an assessment must take all he facts into account and listen to what people who are living with MS are saying.37312021-03-10T21:49:18.14748553Angela HillLet's get justice for these people who were mainly poor women, trying to make a living as healers 37332021-03-10T21:58:18.93348554Julie LennoxRespect, Dignity and Fairness for all! Scotland can do better! Taking mobility away from those who need it due to this ridiculous rule will only further increase the already massive problem of social isolation for the most vulnerable in our society. 37312021-03-10T21:59:29.52348555Gina TownsleyTaxi trade has been left behind with support from the government. Families are suffering severe hardship.37372021-03-10T22:07:40.07348556ross hendryDuring Covid 19 my earnings have dropped to 50% and under. Impossible to keep the Hp, insurance radio and maintenance costs up. Taxi operators need help to maintain our businesses. 37372021-03-10T22:36:09.04748557Mohammed YusufI have seen my income drop by 70% as a taxi operator. I don't know how long I can go on for.37372021-03-10T22:37:58.548558William AnsonIt is absolutely shocking the way the Scottish Government has treated Taxi Drivers and others in this Pandemic.37372021-03-10T22:55:28.20748559Michael MaleyWe are all struggling to pay our bills and falling behind in taxi payments. Any help will be greatly appreciated.37372021-03-10T23:58:39.66748560Neil Gellatly MS is a cruel and unpredictable condition that makes me unreliable as my illness levels vary from day to day. Ultimately the progressive nature of MS has seen mu mobility and balance almost reduce to nearly nil or 100s metres but i always fear getting stuck away from home. \r\n\r\nIve been scared away from pip as the application process is notorious in MS circles as destroying your personal sanctity and belittling. \r\n\r\nI need a car but an paying myself when really i should receive a motability car but pip puts me off and 20 metres is arbitrary and without reason 37312021-03-11T00:44:37.31348561Rana umer sharifTreat Scotland as Wales pls.37372021-03-11T01:27:40.83348562David HorobinFalconry has at least 1300 years of heritage in Scotland and evidence suggests the Picts practised it - possibly even with eagles. It has long worked in tandem with Scotland's countryside and wildlife - a unique bond between humans and animals. Trained birds use the same skills their wild counterparts would to attempt to take prey that has evolved to outwit and evade them. What could be more natural? Precluding the selective, limited and sustainable use of a long established edible species (jugged hare!) when domestic cats indiscriminately, albeit inadvertently, kill countless numbers of birds and mammals to no benefit, except arguably in the case of mousing, seems a retrograde step when the majority of humans are totally divorced from the realities of the natural world. A child who grows up to depend on a truly commensual symbiotic relationship with nature is more likely to see the need to preserve it than one lacking interest or opportunity for personal involvement other than through media soundbites. Many of us signing this adore Scotland's natural heritage - all adore nature more generally - and contribute in some way to its active conservation and wider economy. As an acknowledged outsider, albeit one with distant Scottish roots, being on the moors has always felt like coming to a spiritual home, and friends the world over feel the same. That said, it is the love of landscape and wildlife that draws us back. 37892021-03-11T08:29:09.16348563Graeme O'DonohueScrap the 20 metre rule 37312021-03-11T08:34:23.12748564Martin JexI agree that there has to be some form of eligibility for Pip but MS is life long, never going to get better and depending on a good or bad day can result in a payment being removed that helps them with everyday living which also takes away a disability badge, which on a bad day walking 20 metres is the least of their problems, as they have to rely on others to do the things that independence living allows. So scrap the 20 metre rule, stop making people do a test that benefits the government and not the people, it is a disability, it is life long, scrap the stupid rule.37312021-03-11T08:48:51.7648565Lynda greerJustice, acknowledgement and apology needed. 37332021-03-11T09:06:38.248566Althea Joseph This needs to be scrapped. Mobility can vary greatly from day to day with MS. 20m won't get people that far and not a true marker of how people can manage their daily lives on a basic level.37312021-03-11T09:41:11.03348568Samantha ThorneMS is a chronic, degenerate disability. It is life altering and support is needed in every aspect of life. It is cruel and so is a 20m rule 37312021-03-11T10:03:06.25748569Idamay BrillEssential for the town, especially in winter with rest and be thankful closed 37352021-03-11T10:49:01.648570Joe Whaite This 20 meter rule. MS is an incredibly unpredictable disease and the ability to do something changes on a daily basis without warning. 37312021-03-11T11:05:29.10748571Bryan LowMany thanks petitioner.37332021-03-11T12:17:31.58748572Paul PatersonPlease end the 20m rule 37312021-03-11T12:26:06.41748573Heather MunroPlease scrap the 20 metre rule. \r\nThis is completely wrong on many levels.37312021-03-11T13:25:03.1148574George FordScrap the unrealistic 20 metre rule.37312021-03-11T13:34:39.39348575Margaret Freeman I can walk 20 metres with a stick but it can wipe me out for the rest of the day. This measurement does not take into account how ms affects me on a daily basis 37312021-03-11T14:36:41.2748576Ms Lorna HastieNow that RRMS (Relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis) has gone to SPMS (Secondary progressive multiple sclerosis), I not have even more unpredictable mobility issues37312021-03-11T16:11:51.69748580JOHN M S MURRAYDue to over 200 days Rest & Be Thankful being closed ferry will help Kintyre.37352021-03-11T16:28:45.46748581Malcolm mc millan We have been stuck with a road trip hit and hope the roads are open a ferry would make Scotland more accessible to all. 37352021-03-11T16:31:22.32748582John BarfordUsed by many tourists37352021-03-11T16:37:51.54748583Kenneth M CampbellI think Campbeltown should have a full-time ferry. But not Calmac as they are useless and only use Campbeltown ferry as a spare. Put Calmac services out to tender ASAP and move into the real world. 37352021-03-11T17:09:12.25348586Barry AlliboneThe town needs this service all year round as although the town is on the mainland it is very much like an island also only has one way in and same way out without the ferry we will loose a lot of tourists with a major effect on local business 37352021-03-11T17:31:56.02348587Lynn McDonald Our ancestors fought and died for us in these battlefields and it is a disgrace that they are not properly protected and designated as sacred ground. It is never ok to think of building on these sites as who we are and where we came from is vital to us as a nation. 37162021-03-11T17:37:17.22348588Catherine Simpson Having a brother with MS I have found that no two days are the same with his mobility. 37312021-03-11T17:55:09.91748589Donna ButchartPlease scrap the 20m rule. This is not a fair marker for those with an illness where ability can vary from day to day. 37312021-03-11T18:12:21.40348590Pat JamiesonPlease scrap this very unfair rule\r\n37312021-03-11T18:42:37.29348591Ann DalgettyVery hard for people MS is very variable from day to day but make no mistake it changes your life !37312021-03-11T19:02:14.75348592Sheona RowbothamScrap 20 metre rule37312021-03-11T19:45:07.39748593Jennifer Rosemary Wardenplease scrap the 20 metre rule for those who can't cope. 37312021-03-11T19:59:14.24348594Brandy ValentineIt's 202137332021-03-11T20:36:42.1748595Johnny ThurmanWho are we to deny food from anyone or anything on this planet? The human race is the biggest embarrassment to the rest of this Earth. \r\n37892021-03-11T21:37:26.86748596scott mandsThe 20mt rule is an unnecessary barrier to people with disabilities. 37312021-03-11T22:02:25.6848597Shona StrainMost days im unable to walk 20m others could be different so unfair with MS as the very odd good day would end up being my assesment day and no two days are remotely the same. 37312021-03-11T22:24:45.52748598Frances o Connell 20 metres is a disgrace, sort it out please 37312021-03-11T22:25:31.43348599Daniel Murphyall taxidrivers, should be supported.37372021-03-11T23:02:02.9448600Megan RobinsonPlease preserve all historical sites.37162021-03-11T23:09:06.53348601Amber HicksAs a Canadian with Sottish ancestry and a person who enjoys history and the environment I think it would incredibly sad to develop on a field that is essentially a grave for so many people and should be protected as an environmental reserve and historical site. I hope one day to walk on the battlefield of Culloden.37162021-03-11T23:13:22.6848602Jaxen MaynorAs a fourth generation Irish immigrant i know how important culture is. Scottish land like this shouldn't just be destroyed.37162021-03-11T23:15:49.30748603Liyba amer History matter and so did those peoples lives.37162021-03-11T23:35:49.78748608Justin PottsI think it is sad that people think we can just erase history and bulldoze over it for profit. That is how dictators rule do better.37162021-03-11T23:38:27.4648609Betsy Frazer Keyser As a descendant of Lovat Frasers, it crushes me to see developers have so little regard for what for the Jacobean revolt is sacred ground. That would be akin to the US allowing the battlefield of Gettysburg being plowed over and condos built. Please do not let this happen.37162021-03-11T23:44:48.38748610Nick GoldthorpeClearly the protection level of Scottish battlefields is not adequate if we are having to signa petition to stop someone building on Culloden. Disgusting behaviour.37162021-03-11T23:46:50.7148612Dade BatesThe fact they would even think to do this is an atrocity and an insult to all those buried there.37162021-03-11T23:52:23.97748613Shyla-Anne CoxLet's make our history stay.37162021-03-11T23:56:17.1748614Laurie CassellThe bones of our ancestors are buried in Culloden. Let them rest.37162021-03-11T23:56:21.6548615Maddie LornaI am proud to have Scottish heritage. 37162021-03-12T00:00:21.16748616Kathleen SwickCulloden is more important than any castle funded or supported by the national trust. It is uniquely associated with Scottish culture. It is so egregious to consider the destruction of the site at all, then alone for monetary purposes. 37162021-03-12T00:06:01.6548617Wendy Williamson-ScrimCulloden is sacred and historical ground. It should never be developed. 37162021-03-12T00:13:14.8448619Deborah Harvey Please don't disturb this site. This is the resting place for many men and boys that lost their life.37162021-03-12T00:15:29.76748620Brett WentzHistory must be remembered and taught, or we will repeat it. Historic battlefields, especially mass grave sites, must be preserved, in remembrance of the fallen. Would you really want a home on a mass gravesite?\r\n37162021-03-12T00:32:56.1448622Leann Safford Let the dead rest. And allow history to be seen. 37162021-03-12T00:35:57.1448623Mary Darroch KettererPlease save this land for a memorial, if we erase the past it will be forgotten.37162021-03-12T00:40:55.2548624Liam BryceDigging up the fallen to make new buildings or probably a parking lot is morally wrong and disgusting. 37162021-03-12T00:41:11.39748625Justine JefferyCulloden is not a place that should ever be developed in any way at all. We need to remember forever the terrible, terrible events that happened there and the people who died in appalling circumstances on that place and in the surrounding areas.37162021-03-12T00:43:52.93748626valerie lindolmRESPECT WAR GRAVES!\r\nRESPECT HISTORIC BATTLEFIELDS!\r\nHistory remembers Culloden. Scotland should too. Internationally important site of homage which must be preserved and given its natural context. Generations will come and go, make history, be remembered. Councils come and go and leave their mark - make your legacy a positive one for Scotland and Scottish descendants worldwide. Preserve Culloden - one day, more archaeological work will be done here, more information gathered. Be proud that you were one of those who respected your country's history for the world! I live on Canada's far west coast and my name is no longer Scottish - but my heart always will be. I will be back one day, many, many seek out Culloden. \r\nBe loyal and be proud of Scottish history, not of destroying it, and associated tourism. In Canada, our war graves and historic battlefields are respected, venerated and preserved, not wiped out or built on - housing?! There are always other options and lands available for building to be found that have not got the powerful and emotional potency of Culloden. PRESERVE & RESPECT PLEASE. 37162021-03-12T00:47:41.26748629Sara LosierCulloden is a national treasure, and should be treated as such! 37162021-03-12T00:57:41.06348631Bethany JuddHistoric battlefields should be preserved, especially one this significant in Scotland's history. Furthermore, it's essentially a cemetery for those who died there. Why develop the area?37162021-03-12T01:00:53.9448632Tina Beveridge Please preserve our heritage grounds. Please don't destroy or profit on the deeds of fallen Scotsman.37162021-03-12T01:06:35.53348634Karelle JonesNormally, I wouldn't care if a battlefield was developed into something else, though I would always prefer to leave nature alone. However, this particular battlefield, Culloden, marks such a major turning point in Scottish history and culture as the Highlander way of life was extinguished by the English that to cover over it or change it in any way seems unthinkable. It was the end of an era. You simply cannot turn it into a block of flats or a grocery store. Clearly, a higher level of planning protection is required. I hope to see new legislation introduced in the coming months to ensure Scotland's physical history is adequately protected. Apostrophes removed per this systems requirements. 37162021-03-12T01:08:29.1648635Natasha PetersI learned about this sacred place from Outlander. Would love to visit someday and rediscover my Scottish heritage. 37162021-03-12T01:10:37.7148636Jack Henry HutchisonProtect history, protect the memory of those who lie Culloden, do not allow modernity to supplant and erase past suffering and struggle.37162021-03-12T01:17:21.9148637ANDREA N EVANS SMITHI know that as a Canadian my opinion should not carry as much weight as that of the Scottish people, but I am proud of my Scottish heritage and would like to see locations like Culloden preserved as a matter of national importance. Once development is allowed to go forward o ln these historic battle sites we will never again be able to turn back the clock and reclaim them. 37162021-03-12T01:37:56.2948640Cat Idler BellmondLets respect those that fought and leave them where they are.37162021-03-12T01:49:20.9548642Kelly Sillers I have 3 family members buried there.37162021-03-12T01:53:25.13348646Vanessa KeithPlease preserve Scotland history.37162021-03-12T01:55:30.62348647Etienne augerAlthough I may not be Scottish I think that doing this is a disgrace to all people who fought on that battle field.37162021-03-12T02:01:38.02748648Kairn McLellan We must preserve these important historical places. I have travelled to Culloden just to stand and connect to this ground. 37162021-03-12T02:04:55.55748649Amal Attar-Guzman Being Canadian, living in a country where Scottish folks have made tremendous contributions in Canada, it would be a shame that Culloden be unpreserved and ultimately forgotten. While development is important, the destruction of a historical site and most poignantly a graveyard would not only harm the future teachings of this event but would disgrace those who have lost their lives in their fight for self-determination. Please preserve this site and find another alternative site for development, because not doing so would be a great shame.37162021-03-12T02:20:56.26348650Carrie ProwseThe resting place of so many highlanders should NOT be decimated. This battlefield needs to be preserved for generations to learn the history of Scotland!37162021-03-12T02:23:45.54348651Janelle PerryThis is such an important part of history! I am an American, but I am part Scottish and dream that someday I can travel there to see the history of my heritage and of the world. This impacts everyone... the whole world. Please preserve this sacred land! 37162021-03-12T02:27:10.93748652Lauren Seward-MundayPlease keep Culloden.37162021-03-12T02:27:25.00348653Kendra hadenOne day I hope to visit Scotland and see first hand their long history and walk the same paths many had for 100s of years.... Not stand near a luxury home with a neat little plaque that says "on this site..."37162021-03-12T02:27:36.6348654Michelle Coe It would a disservice to heritage and history to develop with land. I believe they need to be protected for generations to come.37162021-03-12T02:29:13.95748655Kim GosselinProtest Scottish history! Protect Culloden! Let them Rest In Peace. 37162021-03-12T02:30:05.0548656Sigrid LeeAs a resident of the US who has some ancestral ties to Scotland, destroying these battle sites and ruins is a disgrace to those who died defending them. They should be protected. 37162021-03-12T02:33:22.73348657Kirsten Anne MacDonald Please don't allow this development to be built. My ancestors fought at Culloden Moor. They fought for their way of life. They were forced to leave Scotland for the new world because of the clearances. They came to Northern Nova Scotia. To New Glasgow and Antigonish. We haven't forgotten the sacrifices our forefathers made for us. This war grave site should be protected forever. I'm the descendant of the Camerons of Lochiel and my husband's family are the descendants of Clan Ranald. To us it is like desecrating graves... they should be left to rest in peace.37162021-03-12T02:35:04.62348658Margaret MallonOne of the most sombre places I have ever been in this world. It needs to be protected!37162021-03-12T02:37:03.93748660Anthony Ford Why don't u put a theme park in Flanders or put up a SeaWorld park on the beaches of Gallipoli or Normandy... leave history and the places it was made and the body's of the men who fought alone. 37162021-03-12T02:45:34.9948662Kimberly LeichBattlefields are graveyards and should not be disturbed, especially not for something as insignificant as luxury homes. Build them elsewhere. 37162021-03-12T02:47:00.648663Yarrow Gurski Please don't develop the land my ancestors died on. This place is somewhere people like me could go to be with our ancestors, it is sacred. I am a McDonald, I am a Gray, I may be a Canadian now (I wish I could be Scottish again) but this is my home and I am begging you not to bury historical sites in condos. 37162021-03-12T02:47:27.6148664Britney McKeiganHistory is like the blood in our veins, without it we would be gone37162021-03-12T02:50:19.0748665Rori TrautzHistory repeats itself if it is erased.37162021-03-12T02:53:33.58748668Michael Thomas RiceMy History Degree at University was about the Battle of Culloden Moor. To open this solemn resting place of hundreds of souls at the last pitched battle of Scottish soil would be a disservice to The men who fought and died for the sake of Scottish Freedom and liberty. It would be a slap in the face of their descendants should this hallowed ground be desecrated by erecting modern buildings on the graves of these men regardless of which side they served. From the bottom of my heart do not destroy this monument to these souls interred at Culloden Moor. 37162021-03-12T02:53:52.94348669Emma LuceCulloden should be respected as the final resting place of hundreds of highlanders. It deserves to be treated as any other battle field or grave site.37162021-03-12T02:54:03.4148670Kara Allison-HoushCulloden has the blood of the Scots deep in its soil. Let the dead lie peacefully. Too many met their fates on that field. Leave it. 37162021-03-12T02:54:58.87748671Bethany ChomiakHistory is important especially this burial ground. Please protect Scotish history.37162021-03-12T02:56:27.11348672Donald ChalfyScotland's history and landmarks are precious and meaningful. It would be a real shame to dishonor Scotland's ancestors by erecting developments on top of hallowed ground. 37162021-03-12T02:57:27.86348674Dave DivelbissThis is important sacred history. We must not desecrate. 37162021-03-12T02:59:22.14348675Andrea HattIt would be disgraceful to destroy a piece of history like that and it disturb graves of fallen soldiers.37162021-03-12T03:00:20.7748676Kathy ChisholmDo NOT desecrate this sacred land!37162021-03-12T03:10:29.7748680Sara Susan GallagherI come from a family of highlanders who fought in these battles. It will be tragic to see the memories go.37162021-03-12T03:13:38.06748681Tamara MacInnisAs a decendant of Scottish Highlanders I feel it is my duty to speak out against the destruction of a historic site that holds so much of our collective memory and shared history. 37162021-03-12T03:16:36.78748682Ami Lynne RogersPlease save historical sites! So many cultures have lost so much of their stories due to modernization. Don't let Scotland be part of that!37162021-03-12T03:19:32.7748683Steve TurnerI am a Native Canadian and have seen Europeans peoples build ski resorts and the like over Native sacred sites and graves. Once it is gone, it is gone. Trust me. You have a chance my people never had. Use it.37162021-03-12T03:30:53.3748684Heather MalcolmThe fact that someone is even considering desecrating the graves of slaughtered Highlanders is disgusting. This should not be allowed, this area has such significance and history behind it...not to mention it is literally a graveyard.37162021-03-12T03:30:55.77348685Camryn McDonaldTo build over this historic site would be to erase the horrors that happened here, and after the battle itself was over. If this battlefield gets built over, it will be a stain on Scottish history for a Millenia to come.37162021-03-12T03:34:54.27348686Ewen CampbellI say yes to an all year ferry service.37352021-03-12T03:40:19.62348687Kimberly NeelyI may never get the chance to see Scotland, but I know it would be a shame if future generations never get to see that historic site. I still stop with my adult children and look at historic sites when driving in Texas.37162021-03-12T03:48:51.2348689Kendra FergusonCulloden battlefield is such an important part of Scottish history, and it needs to be preserved. 37162021-03-12T03:49:44.20348690Amber Derstine I'd really like to see the battlefield after we get our vaccines. My spouse is a huge fan of the Outlander series and I'd love to see the actual places that where in the books. Please preserve this site and others like it to teach the world your history! 37162021-03-12T03:51:37.1148691Laura Teeple Thinking of all the ancestors of the Jacobites. RIP, respect the honorable dead. 37162021-03-12T03:55:04.23348692WhiteFeather HunterThose of us with Scottish ancestry are looking forward to visit these sacred ancestral sites. Leave them alone! 37162021-03-12T04:01:34.32348693George GraneyAs a descendant of familys dating back to that era, I wish and hope you to preserve the graves battlefields of our ancestors from encroachment. 37162021-03-12T04:09:07.5648694Kevin FlowersI live near Glasgow Kentucky USA. Many people take our links to Scotland very serious. I also take history in general very serious. The loss of a historic site is a permanent loss to future generations. We need to preserve our history 37162021-03-12T04:24:06.14748695Heather MarìTo the women of history, who never backed down. My ancestors in spirit. 37332021-03-12T04:59:31.6148696Tammy GreerAs a granddaughter of a Scottish immigrant, I was raised on the history of the homeland. WHY would it be allowed to be erased?? Save our history!!!37162021-03-12T06:12:46.448697Emily HarrisonHistorical locations such as the Culloden Battlefield need to be protected and preserved for current and future generations. There needs to be legislation that protects historical sites from commercial development. 37162021-03-12T06:16:37.1248699Colleen Grace Weaver As a proud descendant of Clans MacBeth and Graham, as well as the descendants of Scottish immigrants, I am appalled that anyone should even propose the desecration of Culloden!37162021-03-12T06:27:00.8248701Mary Campbell This is sacred ground. The battle may have been 200+ years ago but that is a battle field, where men died and sacrificed their way of life. You can not desecrate a final resting place and a historical battle field. 37162021-03-12T06:41:27.4248705Christian RobertsI know in Europe, there is already so much history, but I think that battlefields like the one at Culloden are vital to our culture and our society. History is our greatest asset towards tracking progress, and to look back on how far we've grown and how we have yet to grow. Please reconsider any developments around this area of historical significance.37162021-03-12T06:46:44.22748706Sandra ConnorsI have visited some of these battlefields. They are important history for your country and all the descendants of the Scottish people across the world, and all your country's visitors. They need to be preserved and celebrated not plowed under! I cannot imagine Germany doing this to their important historical sites in 200 years. Just...gobsmacked....37162021-03-12T06:57:37.17348708Isobel McDonnell No history as prolific as this should be erased.37162021-03-12T07:01:50.6548711Noah MooreMy ancestors are from Scotland. This is a part of History. Not just for the world, but apart of my own family history. 37162021-03-12T07:02:15.96348712Jane SutherlandThe 20m rule needs to be removed from the Adult Disability Payment framework as it doesn't prove anything relating to a genuine assessment of a person's ability to be independent and is outdated in 2021.37312021-03-12T07:03:20.78348713Barbara MillerPlease do not destroy this important battlefield and piece of Scottish history. It is a burial ground and must be protected. 37162021-03-12T07:10:19.57348714Maite RussellHistory is full of lessons and warnings. Covering it up with new fancy things is ignoring extremely important information.37162021-03-12T07:12:05.71748715Mary EagerThis is sacred ground, where men bled and died for what they believed in. The land is valuable because of what THEY valued. Please do not desecrate their memory or their resting place. 37162021-03-12T07:12:51.49748716Frances holdenIf you were to build on the area, you would be erasing Scottish history. It's a grave site of hundreds if not thousands of souls. 37162021-03-12T07:37:30.148718Annette Kulesza I have Scottish ancestors and the Battle of Culloden is a part of my family history. I would hope that this battle field along with so many others that make up Scotlands history would be respected and preserved. 37162021-03-12T07:40:55.2148719Sheree CrawfordCulloden is one of our nations most iconic and historic places - it is also essentially a graveyard. To build on the bones of the dead will be to suppress Highland culture and history one last time, thereby robbing our nation and children of something priceless37162021-03-12T07:44:39.89748721Lauren HairPlease ... please let them rest.37162021-03-12T07:46:06.55348722Susan MerrillI'm a descendant of Clan MacLean. Please respect history and leave this graveyard alone.37162021-03-12T07:51:55.27348725Sarah WeberModern development is godless. What a terrible thing to be.37162021-03-12T07:56:35.72748726Maria Christina MartinezPlease do not desecrate the graves and preserve the history. 37162021-03-12T07:57:24.1648727Celine McGuireI was lucky enough to visit the battlefield and it is not an area to be developed. Plus the tourism side would be affected so not great on the economy. 37162021-03-12T07:59:44.72748728Owen WalkerWe must not build anything at Culloden.37162021-03-12T08:02:48.27348730Tracy McCallThere is plenty of land in Scotland why allow buiding on a historic site.37162021-03-12T08:07:04.96348733Tanya LyonHistorical landmarks should be preserved, not destroyed for revenue. Especially when that landmark is essentially a graveyard. 37162021-03-12T08:08:51.78748735Gabrielle J. Roberts It's imperative to the preservation of Scotlands history and wildlife that historic sites be protected from development. Future generations have a right to know they're cultural history, and be able to experience that birthright in person, and not just through books and third party description. The environmental impact of developing this land is also extremely harmful to the future generations of Scotland for obvious reasons and for which money made on such a bad faith arrangement will seem a pittance compared to what would be lost.\r\nPlease consider the future Scottish children whom you will be stealing from before selling your soul for cash.\r\nThank you. 37162021-03-12T08:14:19.3148738Mette klingeHISTORY IS IMPORTANT !! This is a graveyard that should be left alone. Everything else is disrespectful !! 37162021-03-12T08:14:42.27748739Lake baltz We need to save history.37162021-03-12T08:18:51.22348740Shadow DarkFyre Sacred must remain sacred.37162021-03-12T08:21:33.28748741Charlotte BarrettI do not believe that the current level of planning of protection is adequate for scottish battlefields and needs to be improved immediately. New legislation is essential to make sure that scottish battlefields stay protected\r\n37162021-03-12T08:34:29.4348743Christine KilkennyYes we need to protect our heritage.37162021-03-12T08:55:35.35348745Gordon BoyleScrap this unfair element of the assessment.37312021-03-12T09:49:30.99348749Brenda gonzalezPreserve history.37162021-03-12T09:50:32.13348750Tori DunlopThey make take out lives, but they will never take our battlefield!!!!!37162021-03-12T09:53:51.95748751Shalina M. HockhalterCulloden needs to be protected! This is absolutely outrageous, to want to destroy something of national History. In my personal opinion a "Development" is just another word for not caring about the Land and the beauty it holds , or who has died in these set fields, this is basically just desecration.37162021-03-12T09:55:58.5548755Flavia Silveira Very surprised that these battlefields are not already heritage sites. They should be. 37162021-03-12T10:01:50.64348757Glenda O'ConnorRemove rule as some days people with MS can walk further than other days where they cannot get out of bed.37312021-03-12T10:09:45.24748762Kirsty BakerPlease stop ruining land for development. 37162021-03-12T10:23:12.0348766Elizabeth LawriePlease scrap 20 metre rule37312021-03-12T10:28:39.12348768Lydia Sanders Please keep this an historical site for many more generations to learn about and be able to go see this place and to respect the people who died there. 37162021-03-12T10:35:41.05748771Kathryn HillAs someone who has several ancestors who fought, bled, and died on this battlefield while fighting to put a Stuart back on the throne the idea that people want to destroy this sacred land enrages me. So many Scots were slaughtered on that ground. Don't try to erase the history of this place. Scotland lost so much during that battle don't continue to take things from her by developing on this ground. 37162021-03-12T10:36:03.91748772Rose Anna GriffinThis is a burial ground. Fought and paid for with Scottish blood. Should never be built on. You can almost hear sounds of battle when you walk through it. 37162021-03-12T10:51:23.29748773Steph BrownThese battlefields are important places in history and I think it is disrespectful to then just build on top of it.37162021-03-12T10:52:25.15348774Hope NewmanMany brave men died and lay in this field. It must be protected not just for its historical significance but for the respect and honor these brave men deserve.37162021-03-12T10:53:03.8748775Katie Demers History must be saved for the future of all.37162021-03-12T11:00:35.59748776Kevin B MacLeanCulloden is more than a field. It is a piece of history, pride, hope and way of life. Across the world sites like this are being destroyed and it is wrong! This site symbolizes the death of my own ancestors and many families. This site symbolizes a fight to preserve ones culture and lifestyle, which should never need to happen. This site symbolizes the sacrifice people made due to hundreds of years of being attack, suppressed and oppressed. Getting rid of this site would cause a snowball effect against similar places. Whats next vimmy ridge, Auschwitz, no mans land. Or are they too important because its British history, last I remember they were to prevent the same thing these men died doing.\r\nOur history is just being opened up in our time and making a slow comeback. This is that memorial for those who cannot trace back further. This is that memorial for minority cultures that suffered oppression and shine a light of hope on them too.37162021-03-12T11:14:29.248779Gisela CarraderoCulloden as other battlefields are an important piece of history that needs to be preserved and protected. Covering up or developing such areas is disrespectful and wrong.37162021-03-12T11:22:20.17748781Vic gracy moresI hope we prevent this from happening. 37162021-03-12T11:29:49.648782Giselle WhitmireClan MacKenzie fell on that battlefield. My ancestors will not be forgotten.37162021-03-12T11:35:52.75748783Sophie ChristensenI found out about this because of a tiktok a nice lady posted. I am not Scottish but I am definitely on the team 'Respect the deads resting place and do not disturb or disrupt them' also on team 'History should be preserved and not hidden away' 37162021-03-12T11:36:06.33748784Alex MirautaPreserve historical places as they are. Don't sell them to profit 37162021-03-12T11:37:43.77348785Niall Prideaux GrahamBattlefields are an essential part of history, particularly Great Britain's battlefields. The many millions of people who died on those battlefields can and should be respected with history and their stories being told, as opposed to being built over for profit.37162021-03-12T11:42:04.11748789Samantha WeiselInjury happened many years ago at this site, let's not add more insult to it. Don't be like US.37162021-03-12T11:43:21.94748791Nisreen WeirRespect this land that hundreds of people died on!! It is a graveyard and needs to be seen and respected as one.37162021-03-12T11:44:01.69748792Marina nasrWe must protect history and land which many souls rest37162021-03-12T11:46:02.5448795Karen Kehl Enough world history has been destroyed and lost forever. We need to learn from history so as not to repeat it.37162021-03-12T11:50:02.22348796Justin MaGillThere should be no development on graveyards, or battlefields with historic significance, which this is.37162021-03-12T11:50:08.38348797Hanna KowalczeGood luck37162021-03-12T11:53:42.98748802Leala NesbethI am of Scottish Decent and we need to save this land!37162021-03-12T11:54:02.93348804Sarah Trevethan Those who do not study history are doomed to repeat it. It is our duty as humans to preserve the history of those that came before. If we allow this battlefield to be covered with some cheap commercial development what are we saying to their descendants about the value of the sacrifice of the men that died here? What are we saying to the future generations about the value of any sacrifices that they may be asked to make for the protection of their people? Covering up history doesn't change it, but it does alter people's perception of it. We need ty o be careful with the precedents we set.37162021-03-12T11:57:36.45748806Jeanelle GrowDo not destroy historic ground!37162021-03-12T12:00:48.55748808Margaret JonesI'm American, but my great grandmother was a proud Scot. I had the honour of being named after her and getting to know her before she passed. She loved to tell me stories about her family and her heritage and I think that she would be appalled at the idea of Culloden being desecrated like this. I have ancestors buried here who died fighting for their freedom. Culloden should be made a world heritage site because it is, there are people all over the world who can trace their roots back here and the tragedies that our ancestors endured deserve to be respected.37162021-03-12T12:01:59.39748809Deja van Alphen-SantoroHistory is both the people of a nation and the culture and memories of them. To destroy such a place as Culloden is disrespectful and damaging for future generations. You would be damaging the memories, the culture, the language, the freedom of people of today and tomorrow. Reconsider your actions, preserve Culloden, preserve history.37162021-03-12T12:02:26.86348810Keith EdwardsMy ancestors were probably there.37162021-03-12T12:06:40.66348812Vlad MercadoPlease, don't do this. Don't roll over our World's history. Preserve it.37162021-03-12T12:07:09.79348813Kolby BakerParts of history like this needs to be shown to the future generations. This development would destroy that.37162021-03-12T12:07:20.2648814Kelsey BabcockHistoric landmarks should remain exactly that no matter how much land there is. Plus no one truly wants to see developments when they can look at a beautiful peace of nature that honors that history.37162021-03-12T12:07:39.17748816Anastasia RusnakThis is an extremely important part of history and should be preserved at all costs. I recently visited and these grounds, they must be respected for the events that took place and countless lives lost here. 37162021-03-12T12:07:44.32348817James Leydenas someone whose ancestors came from Scotland. It saddens me to see this proud country's history removed . And the the men who bodies remain on this battlefield disrespected 37162021-03-12T12:07:55.248818Kiley RobinsonWhile I do not live in Scotland, both my dad and grandfather did. This is a part of Scottish history, and a graveyard for many. Culloden, as well as other battlefields like it, need preservation and protection.37162021-03-12T12:15:00.82748820Julie BishopAs a person of Scottish heritage, I am HORRIFIED that there is even a thought of building on Culloden. It's a important piece of Scottish history and a massive gravesite to those who died there. Developing that area would be height of disrespect.37162021-03-12T12:15:30.19348822Clair Fischer\r\nCulloden as other battlefields are an important piece of history that needs to be preserved and protected. Covering up or developing such areas is disrespectful and disgraceful. Men died on that field. The development is wrong37162021-03-12T12:17:46.07748823Jennifer GrahamIf you do not preserve and learn from history, you are doomed to repeat it. Preserve this monument in honour of those who sacrificed all that they had. 37162021-03-12T12:19:45.0748825Ellenor Jay Cowling I am absolutely disgusted at the notion. Building over one of scotlands most significant historical sites is completely disrespectful. Why is it not already protected completely by scottish law?\r\n37162021-03-12T12:23:07.94748827Jamie TannerMy Great Grandfather was from Scotland. He moved to the US when he was 17. I'm signing this in honor of him because I think he would hate to see pieces of his heritage taken away.37162021-03-12T12:29:03.8148830Star SawgleListen to your people. They have reached out to the world asking for help in preserving their history. 37162021-03-12T12:29:46.49348832Shannon BarrPlease stop destroying history. 37162021-03-12T12:31:06.0748833Rebecca SteeleIt is rather shameful that America preserves important battlefield while Culloden is in danger of being destroyed. This Scottish battle ground deserves to remain. It's significant and important.37162021-03-12T12:32:19.06348834Dee EdmondsSuch significant sites to Scottish history shouldn't be sold to developers. Build somewhere else. It's not like we don't have the space.37162021-03-12T12:32:58.72748837Danielle Chiapella The battlefield is not only a final resting place for soldiers, but for a way of life. Scotland has had its rich history erased enough as it is. It's unthinkable to further disrespect the people by building on this infamous landmark. 37162021-03-12T12:33:01.46348838Marcos G. Vicens Torres History and culture its more important than what ever they have plan for it37162021-03-12T12:33:01.7548839Hana Castillo History should never be forgotten and disregarded for profit. It is not only disrespectful to the bodies lying in the battle field, it is an embarrassment that this is even being considered. 37162021-03-12T12:34:00.18748840Babs LaingI am a proud Scot and that is our history they are destroying. They must be stopped37162021-03-12T12:34:17.38348842Ziv GolanThe land needs to be saved!37162021-03-12T12:35:28.29748845Violet McInroy Destroying a part of history for capital gain is disgraceful. 37162021-03-12T12:36:56.3648849Laurena FraserMy family are now Canadian because of this battle. They were displaced during the clearance. To hear that this piece of history is at risk of distruction is appalling. It should not go ahead and should be protected as a historic site. 37162021-03-12T12:38:28.35348852Nicole MairsCulloden battlefield is essentially a mass grave. The sight is the end of the Highland clans way of life. It would be so disrespectful and wrong to disturb the graves of those men. Let them rest in peace. Allow this site to be the historical lesson that it is. 37162021-03-12T12:39:57.6248853Joanne AndrewMS is such a horrible condition for people to have to live with and keeping this rule is counter productive. Effectively it forces people to stay at home, reducing their opportunities to exercise and socialise. The stress of this worsens other MS symptoms putting more pressure on the NHS, so the Government will not actually save any money by keeping this rule. Get rid of the rule so that people can maintain independence and have more of a normal life. This last year of lockdowns should have given everyone an insight into the daily life of disabled people, stuck at home, to whom this is normal.37312021-03-12T12:40:13.07348856Adrienne Emily Taylor Basic respect for the dead. 37162021-03-12T12:41:55.40748857Coralie BellAs someone with Scottish heritage and a military family, I know that battlefields and wargrounds should be respected and preserved, not torn up and ruined by buildings.37162021-03-12T12:43:35.03348861Monica DuncanHistory needs to be remembered not bulldozed!!!!37162021-03-12T12:43:43.53348863Lydia PruettI don't think any more history should be erased from Scotlands people and land. They deserve to keep it.37162021-03-12T12:44:14.948864Mary Catherine Moloney Do not build condos on the graves of my fathers. 37162021-03-12T12:48:46.8448868Molly McphieThis battlefield represents the hurt and might of my people, showing that we stay strong as people and it needs to be protected. Scottish battlefields are places of historical value, you wouldn't plan to knock down one of our treasured castles and this needs the same level of protection. 37162021-03-12T12:55:09.8348871Virginia Nicoll-Hernandez Preserve Scotland and its history. 37162021-03-12T12:55:17.92348872Terri MacLeodThis is historic!! Leave it alone. 37162021-03-12T12:58:15.67348875Nadia zayasPlease don't take it down.37162021-03-12T13:03:53.50348879Georgina Findlay StewartThis is so wrong should not even be considered it's a war memorial. 37162021-03-12T13:10:5248886Alexander FraserNecessary but via Brodick if this makes it more financially viable37352021-03-12T13:12:21.51348887Cassandra GrayThis is so dumb, history is important especially when it's freaking grave sight for soldiers. And then the ones who survived were hunted down, because they survived.37162021-03-12T13:14:10.98348889Ana ButlerStop destroying important parts of history. This is a mass grave of brave soldiers who fought for their freedom.37162021-03-12T13:16:39.18748892Alexandria JohnsonBattlefields - especially ancient & significant ones like Culloden - are graves and deserve preservation. Why not build on the beach at Normandy? At Auschwitz? Bc its an insult to the lives lost there!37162021-03-12T13:19:50.67748894Zoe BradleyIt is important to preserve this historic battlefield, so as not to forget the culture that tragically lies there. 37162021-03-12T13:20:53.90748895Thomas smith I have distant family who fought on these battle fields and history is there for us to learn from and grow we should not forget those who gave their lives to pave the road we walk today in our lives no mater how big or small the significance of their actions in history it should be a national historical landmark and not developed by commercial gains. 37162021-03-12T13:21:52.0348896Vanessa FrankThey idea of digging up and paving over these areas is disgusting and heart-breaking. This cannot be allowed to happen.37162021-03-12T13:22:31.75748897Julia Salvo There are so many places disappearing from history. Please protect as much as you can. 37162021-03-12T13:24:07.3648898Layton shadleThis land must be persevered at all costs. 37162021-03-12T13:25:38.72748900Deanna BrentsSave the Highlands!!!37162021-03-12T13:27:33.2448902Jacquie BartonDon't let big companies go in and wipe out your history. Here in the US they do it all the time. It's horrible. People come in and "create" communities, then they destroy the area. 37162021-03-12T13:28:53.8248903Deidra HellerI am an American, I have a Scottish lineage and a deep interest in history. The preservation of this historic landmark should not be washed away due to irresponsible development. The Culloden battlefield is a reminder to just how deep British colonialism ran and is a graveyard for brave soldiers trying to preserve their culture. Do not make the same mistakes as Americans have made, wiping away historic landmarks for the sake of real estate. 37162021-03-12T13:30:08.37748904Ashley OneillAlthough I work full time at the moment. This could well affect me if a becomes more disabled in the future. 37312021-03-12T13:31:43.58748905lydia raymondHistory needs to be preserved not destroyed by greedy housing developers.37162021-03-12T13:31:47.66348906Samantha HolgateThe history of our ancestors and their lives that were sacrificed, she continue to honoured. 37162021-03-12T13:33:43.4748907Courtney WiseHistory is so important and we must teach our children and generations afterwards the whole of history lest we repeat our past mistakes. 37162021-03-12T13:39:29.66348914Nicole WatkinPlease do not destroy all these important historical landmarks. Those who died in this historic battle deserve to be honoured.37162021-03-12T13:39:48.63348915Cassandra HaasHistoric battle grounds should be preserved not built upon. Please respect the dead. 37162021-03-12T13:40:16.62748916Megan EllisStop destroying history!!! These people died for us!!37162021-03-12T13:41:33.08748917Valery MorseThis is an historical area that deserves to be preserved as the people of Scotland deem fit.37162021-03-12T13:42:22.31748918Jade LarsonThis is my heritage too! My ancestors fought on this land and some died here. 37162021-03-12T13:42:31.52348919Callie gatesThis is a piece of history that needs to be protected. Shame on these people trying to take it away.37162021-03-12T13:45:02.69748920Maria Cruz-Lugo This battle was cruel and unnecessary because a greedy England nation which queen was not the rightful ruler. Please let them ready in peace. 37162021-03-12T13:45:38.67748921Samwise WellsHow cyclical it is that one of the final battlegrounds for pre-Christianised Scotland is now threatened by the greed of capitalism. This time we cannot afford to lose. Slating such an important historical graveyard for development is frankly disgraceful. New legislation should be passed to protect these battlefields for the sake of those who died there. 37162021-03-12T13:45:43.59748922Veronica PrietoPlease don't take this piece of history. 37162021-03-12T13:48:19.09748924Joshua HepworthPreserve history and the legacy of the people who battled there.37162021-03-12T13:49:40.1248927Katie BauhofMuch love 37162021-03-12T13:49:49.36348928Gabby CastoPlease preserve history.37162021-03-12T13:49:52.72348929Jennie HerronThis landmark his history from not only my family but my partners family. We have been having talks to come see it. Sadly if it is destroyed we will have part of our history erased.37162021-03-12T13:51:17.57348930Melissa Duijvestijn Great job. It is so important to preserve historic places like this one and others like it. 37162021-03-12T13:51:57.36348931Ihaiah MillerWe don't need more modern developments. This land is an important historical landmark, and should be preserved. 37162021-03-12T13:55:54.81748933Melanie RyanOne of my 6th Great Grandfathers died there, I do not want something built on what's essentially his grave. 37162021-03-12T13:59:35.13748935Margaret MulliganThis ruling is so unfair to numerous disabled people, it can vary so much, from day to day, from different times of day37312021-03-12T14:01:14.54348936Tameka BauerAlways preserve history leave the battlefield alone.37162021-03-12T14:05:06.6348938Darylann Johnson Preserving this historic monument and others like it is of the utmost importance to both the people whose history it is and the world internationally. 37162021-03-12T14:05:30.02748940Agnes GrayThis legislation has been passed without thorough investigation into all aspects of conservation. Birds of prey are a vital part of natural balance and responsible falconry conserves these birds and allows them to lead as natural a life as possible. To deny them this is a retrograde step.37892021-03-12T14:07:44.88748943Abby KennedyPreserving history should be our #1 priority over new development. 37162021-03-12T14:11:44.26348946Rae MohrPreserving history is critical to our understanding of our culture and should never be disrupted for capital gain.37162021-03-12T14:11:50.60748947Lexi HarrisonLet's do what we can to preserve history and remember the lives lost and culture erased on this land.37162021-03-12T14:12:35.74748948Kim Battern Preserve this battlefield. 37162021-03-12T14:13:23.80348949Amanda FineI am an American only because my people fled Scotland after Culloden. Its my mother land, my true home. Our clans and language were destroyed on that piece of land. So many of our people lay at rest there. It should be considered hallow ground and protected. 37162021-03-12T14:13:52.97748950Rick GebeleinThe best thing to do here is nothing at all.37162021-03-12T14:15:08.13348954Jessica BakerPreserving history is so important. History good or bad is not one-sided. We deserve the whole story. They didn't Die in vein.37162021-03-12T14:17:24.24348955Cynthia FennewaldRespect the memories of your fallen ancestors, and preserve your history. Respect and support for your cause coming from the U.S.37162021-03-12T14:17:27.85748956Sydney BishopI just do not want a great part of I land and history to be destroyed.37162021-03-12T14:18:27.4548957Fiona MaciverPlease scrap the 20 metres rule.37312021-03-12T14:18:59.19748958Katelyn clarkeI am tired of big corporations trying to steal land from people. Stop colonizing.37162021-03-12T14:19:42.7948959Camille BlouinMy family is Scottish and Irish and some came to Canada in order to escape the prosecution. This isn't affecting just the Scottish people, it's affecting many countries. 37162021-03-12T14:20:49.60348960Emily NixonIt is absolutely despicable and disrespectful to even consider allowing these battlefields to be developed. 37162021-03-12T14:21:51.87348962Tabitha Hapl History shouldn't be destroyed.37162021-03-12T14:25:12.12348964Mallory RoelkeOne of the reasons my family is planning a trip to Scotland is to see this battlefield. Please show some respect to the clans that are buried there.37162021-03-12T14:26:09.52348965Lindsey Mooney The world is developed enough. 37162021-03-12T14:28:15.60348966Tianna Campbell GerriorI live in an over developed area outside Toronto, Canada, It is so important to keep historical green spaces available so people can reconnect with their heritage and themselves.37162021-03-12T14:29:02.2648967Brandy ChristyPlease leave the Highlands alone.37162021-03-12T14:29:57.33748970Kathrine RaeOur ancestors fought for freedom and to preserve their way of life. We must continue to fight to protect our homeland. 37162021-03-12T14:31:23.9848971Lanie Medrano History needs to be preserved, not developed and forgotten. Forgetting history and its lessons damns us to repeat it.37162021-03-12T14:37:36.04748973Anna Whelan To build on this historic site is to wash away the sacrifices made in blood by the people of Scotland. 37162021-03-12T14:42:16.13748976Victoria Langham You have to protect your cultural history! I for one, would love to fly to Scotland to see this SPECIFIC battlefield. Secondly, this plot of land provides more ecosystem services than you think. When you develop this land, you will lose the CO2 sponging abilities of these native plants, while simultaneously denying birds and smaller mammals of a place to forage. This battlefield not only serves you provisioning ecosystem services in the form of air purification, but also provided you cultural ecosystem services through a place to bird watch, go for a walk or admire. Please preserve nature and your history for the world to see!37162021-03-12T14:42:20.28348977James LawsonAs a English person myself \r\n\r\nHistory must be preserved so that future generations can learn what the battle meant to everybody who lives in Highlands.37162021-03-12T14:43:01.74748978KATHRYN D PeteWe can't let this happen to the Brave men who died on that battlefield, They need to be left alone in peace! YOU CAN'T CHANGE HISTORY!!!!!!!!37162021-03-12T14:43:14.85748979Katherine EmrichAs a historian, this part of history will be lost if you do this. It negates the experience if you develop a portion of resistance history and the inspiration that this land offers to many people. Also it is highly disrespectful to the bodies that have been buried there for 100s of years. 37162021-03-12T14:47:29.9448980Holly PalmerI absolutely believe history needs to be preserved, especially such historical sites as battlefields.37162021-03-12T14:53:08.65348982Rebbecca-lynne Spurrier Not only is this the site of a major historical event, it is also the resting grounds of many brutally murdered people. That in and of itself is sacred and the fact that this land is even being CONSIDERED for development is disrespectful and disgusting. 37162021-03-12T14:58:09.22348984Maxx FordI hope this petition works.37162021-03-12T15:01:25.03748986Art hylandI am of Scottish and Irish descent and I believe in preserving important historical sites37162021-03-12T15:03:56.40348989Aurora Di TrapanoWe must preserve history and honour the lives we have lost. So much has been done to erase Scottish history and culture through the years. We must save this. 37162021-03-12T15:07:03.44348991Liliana Perez It is our job and our duty to ensure the battle sight of Culloden remains untouched and continued to be respected. It is the final place hundreds of Scots lost their lives in doing something they believed in only to lose everything. It is disrespectful the memory of the Highlanders who put their lives down almost 300 hundred years ago. 37162021-03-12T15:07:55.4248992Claryssa WebbThe highlands should be respected, and not build on. 37162021-03-12T15:08:36.7748993Victoria StalkerI have ancestors from Scotland, all must preserve the history, don't build developments on graves! Keep Scottish heritage alive!!!37162021-03-12T15:09:55.15748994Ayla MorphewIts ironic that this petition is ending the 17th, another day where the highlander way of life was suppressed. St. Patricks Day is the Celebration of the extermination of hundreds of thousands of pagans and their way of life. 37162021-03-12T15:10:48.51748995Jacqueline KremerThis battlefield and battlefields like it are graveyards. These are areas of holy land for Scottish people and the families who lost ancestors there. It would be a devastating loss of history if apartment buildings were built here. 37162021-03-12T15:10:49.9648996Erin Vogelpohl If you build on it your just going to have a haunted building if not a poltergeist. 37162021-03-12T15:10:51.26748997Paul MartinIn the interests of fairness, I support this request.37312021-03-12T15:11:08.93748998Jordan HoffmanScotland is my ancestral homeland. I am extremely prideful to come from a line of Scotsmen, and have always hoped to visit Scotland. Although I may not live there, I know for a fact that these incredible testaments to the strength of the scottish, and essentially burial grounds that are these battlefields, NEED to be preserved. They must be kept intact and protected, in order to preserve both history, and the resting place of many many loyal Scottish soldiers and fighters. It must not be touched. 37162021-03-12T15:13:52.87749000Hattie MarshallRespect the dead. Provide better planning protection and protect all battlefields in Scotland. 37162021-03-12T15:15:34.1149001Bailey BramhallAmericans have been preserving battlefields from the Revolutionary War, Spanish-American War, Civil War, and many more, by placing their protection under the national parks service. These sites seem to be taken out of time and can be found in the middle of a sprawling city, forests or fields. We have recently struggled with development threatening the sanctity of Indigenous lands in and around the Grand Canyon but the clans of the Navajo Nation successfully petitioned and protested to keep it as is. Please don't disrespect or build over the site of my ancestors sacrifice. Such places should be protected.37162021-03-12T15:15:38.549002Audree Olson If I was them I would not want to live on top of a bunch of dead bodies so leave it alone and build your modern crap somewhere else.37162021-03-12T15:18:44.86749003Sarah Kneeland This cannot happen. History preservation is a must! 37162021-03-12T15:18:53.09349004Halah Garrisonthis important part of history has to be protected.37162021-03-12T15:20:33.28749006Elizabeth MarvinThis isnt just a petition online. My family came to America from Scotland. Who knows how many of my ancestors are buried there. But I definitely dont consent to having my ancestors disrespected or relocated. Leave them where they are. 37162021-03-12T15:20:43.48749007Linda MacaulayCan't walk 20 metres without using my stick or holding on to furniture when in the house. 37312021-03-12T15:20:54.7549008Wilma Thomsonl think they should be less keen to say people are fakes. Just because you can't see the illness does not mean it is not there.37312021-03-12T15:22:49.17349010Anne TignanelliThis is a historical location. Extremely difficult to believe that a housing development could be built upon these burial grounds. 37162021-03-12T15:23:32.20349012Savannah Nelson I know that I am not a citizen of the United Kingdom, but I love Scotland and preserving its history and culture is important. People died for what they believed in, they fought for their way of life and to cover this historical site would be disrespectful to them and it would break my heart. It would feel like Scotland is lost. 37162021-03-12T15:23:37.08749013Jillian Lee Hamilton No, I do not believe that it is adequate if modern development or people want to modernize a historic area can even think of touching it should be protected at all costs and not touched at all. 37162021-03-12T15:25:11.9749014Martin AgnewI sometimes need a wheel chair to get about and am paralyse sometimes I can walk with a stick 20m it is not fair by any means. The Demands of the assessment mean it is only possible to attend on a good day. So that is the best not what we have to deal with all the time\r\n37312021-03-12T15:25:28.59749016Shelly HousemanProtect what is important and can never be replaced. Honour your heritage.37162021-03-12T15:27:28.7149018Maddie SpearsThis is basically a graveyard for thousands of people and a monument.37162021-03-12T15:27:49.69749019MEGHAN DAVIAUThese are graves where people died and an important part of history its been left alone for a reason. Don't mess it!!!!37162021-03-12T15:28:37.98749021Teresa GartnerDo not denigrate the field of battle and the graveyard of our ancestors!37162021-03-12T15:28:40.6949022Lisa TibbetsI am American and I stand with Scotland on this. It is so important to preserve the history of those who were colonized and had their way of life taken from them. 37162021-03-12T15:31:06.41349023Isabel RyeAll historical sites most certainly places of rest should be protected at all costs it is disrespectful and disgusting to do anything less.\r\n37162021-03-12T15:35:25.6849025Arden ValentineStop trying to erase history. 37162021-03-12T15:36:11.35349026Brandy BentleyWe cannot allow for another piece of Scottish history to be erased from the world. 37162021-03-12T15:36:33.83749027Sarah LawrenceThis is a historical site of great cultural importance, and to not protect it is disgraceful and disrespectful.37162021-03-12T15:39:12.96349030Jenna DallalIt is shameful to attempt to build over such a sacred site. To all of those involved in attempting to develop over history, you should be ashamed.37162021-03-12T15:39:30.08749031Helena Koerner I may not know much about them, but I can tell that they are important to the Native Highlanders. These grave stones must be remembered and the battlefield they fought on must be preserved.37162021-03-12T15:40:42.24349033Tracy HarveyLet's remember these men and women as the innocent mothers, daughters, sisters, aunts and granny's that they were.37332021-03-12T15:40:48.63349034Mori andersonWe need to respect the dead that fought here37162021-03-12T15:42:05.5449036Laura caseyI really hope we can stop the developers. History is so important, we need to save it. 37162021-03-12T15:42:22.72749037Sarah Rohan This is a graveyard and a historic battlefield! It needs to be protected not destroyed for money!! Do not disrespect everyone that lost their lives on that day and the Scottish people who had their culture stripped from them! 37162021-03-12T15:42:58.69749039Kim CarpendaleVisiting here is bucket list material. I have read so much about the history of Scotland. This is my first destination after covid. Trying to help, love from Canada37162021-03-12T15:43:02.97749040Emily HanawaltAs a historian, I find it absolutely appalling that development in this property is even being considered. This is just further suppression of the Jacobites and Scottish culture. Truly disgusting and horrific. Protect Scottish battlefields!!37162021-03-12T15:43:46.74349043Abigail CarmonaI think it is worth preserving every single thing of history that we have left. We are tired of erasure this is a story that needs to be told. Please save this.37162021-03-12T15:43:47.21349044JaLynn HillThis history has to be preserved. Do not become so foolish like my fellow Americans and start ripping history from our access. We need to preserve this history so we can learn from it and do better. We also need to honour the people who passed during this time. It is part of what makes us human.37162021-03-12T15:46:44.0149045Trevor MeyersWe need to preserve these sites were major events of history take place. We need to keep the fields open to walk around and see the clan rocks and remember that people have their life at that site. We need to protect the history to keep it from being forgotten in the future.37162021-03-12T15:49:16.18349046Elizabeth AdamsHistory must be protected. Developing on this land disrespects the lives of the brave men who fought and died there.37162021-03-12T15:51:18.1549048Mary MadduxThe McNabs, Abbotts, and all slain deserve to be honoured and respected. I believe my ancestors would expect as much from you.37162021-03-12T15:52:46.3749050Paul goochNever forgotten 37332021-03-12T15:53:03.07349051Natalie KlausHistory is supposed to be remembered and cherished. Scottish history should be celebrated and remembered as well.37162021-03-12T15:53:28.60749052Alex RossThis is a part of history that cannot be lost. 37162021-03-12T15:54:45.2649054Anna Chiara Tedeschi"Historia magistra vitae": history teaches life. I really hope this petition helps to prevent the desecration of such places.37162021-03-12T15:55:35.77749055Christina StomperDisgraceful!! Save the battle field!37162021-03-12T15:57:40.88749056Leonie JechtI've lived in Scotland only since July 2019, and it has grown so much on me. The English government has been taking whatever they want from this gorgeous country, and it needs to stop. 37162021-03-12T15:59:53.35749060AdrianaFernandez As it is done in my country, the lands were battles were fought and lives were lost serve as a historical treasure and remembrance to those Who fought for us and themselves they are also commemoration centres for lives and families that were lost37162021-03-12T16:02:37.40349061Susannah MannDeveloping on a literal graveyard and historical site should be illegal. We have to preserve our history, to protect it and learn from it. By allowing the development of historical battlefields you erase the memory of what became a cultural genocide. You deem these bodies, these souls irrelevant. Why would you continue the erasure of such a wonderful culture and the struggles they endured? Shame for even considering it.37162021-03-12T16:04:40.62349063Gwen GoldingThis place has huge historical significance to Scotland and to Scottish people around the world. History deserves to be preserved for our children in the future and share the stories of their ancestors.37162021-03-12T16:05:14.10749064Anna MartinoHistoric sites are so important to have. Nothing should be built over a battlefield like this. 37162021-03-12T16:05:34.98349065Killashandra Hawkins I believe Culloden field is a Valid Historical Landmark and should be kept that way, you wouldn't tear down Buckingham Palace, would you? Or Stonehenge? CULLODEN IS A GRAVEYARD FOR MY ANCESTORS\r\nPlease leave it be so that my children can one day see where they came from. Please stop killing Scottish history. We are valid to.\r\n37162021-03-12T16:05:37.57749066Sierra Lange-Green If a battle site where many people lost their lives is not worth preserving just to give way to modern development, what is the boundary going to be? Humans don't deserve to build on every part of this earth. Preserve history. Preserve nature. 37162021-03-12T16:05:51.99749068Shelby PointerI am currently studying history at college here in the United States. As someone who plans to focus on European history and has an interest in historical preservation this worries me. Historical lands deserve to be preserved and watched over and especially ones such as these in which are literal graveyards. Modern housing will destroy any historic importance to this land and disturb the resting places of numerous poor souls. How would you feel if they decided to one day build a home on your grandmas grave, or your own grave in the future37162021-03-12T16:08:37.82749071Marina AvalosPlease don't build over this site! It is the resting ground for so many :(37162021-03-12T16:09:00.5949072Christina CranstonThis battlefield and final resting place to many people who fought to preserve their way of life should never be built on. Take it from me, I live in Pennsylvania, USA, the whole US was basically built on burial grounds of indigenous peoples and look what monstrosities its resulted in. Anything you build there is wrong (and also will be haunted for sure). It's wrong to build over an existing cemetery so why is this different?37162021-03-12T16:09:29.07749073Muriel ThompsonAs a major in world history I would like to visit historic landmarks someday in the future in hopes to connect not only with my ancestral roots, but to make sure the victories and losses as well as pain and suffering of the forefathers that built the history we so blissfully ignore are never truly forgotten. 37162021-03-12T16:10:19.4549074Christine Rogers It should go without saying the past must be respected and progression does not need to include ruin past historical landmarks.37162021-03-12T16:12:34.12349075Dave InnesHistory, if lost, can never be regained. It is important for culture, as well, financially significant re the tourist trade.37162021-03-12T16:16:24.549078Kathryn Dynesko We need to preserve this land and respect those who died there37162021-03-12T16:17:30.15349079Elizabeth Simmerman Stop trying to colonize and erase the history of everything! The Highlanders lost their way of life, their culture, their history! Enough!37162021-03-12T16:18:09.82749081Kylie MaxwellThis battle Field is very important to Scottish history. So many Scots fought for their country on the Culloden battlefield. Doing something to destroy this historic landmark would not only be devastating but would also be disrespect to the thousands of people buried there. 37162021-03-12T16:20:50.59349085Logan sawyerI hope this helps, so they are not disrespected in the after life, as they were life37162021-03-12T16:21:02.84349086Chas CasimelHistory is important and I feel like this battle is very important to the Scottish culture. 37162021-03-12T16:23:54.57749087Merel de JongWe must protect history of Scotland no matter where you are from this is not only about a piece of land but about the resting ground of many Scots who fought for their life and freedom! Support and love from the Netherlands37162021-03-12T16:24:25.79749088Anna Wren I think history is so, so important. I hope this petition saves this glorious battlefield and lets the people buried there rest easy. 37162021-03-12T16:27:21.84349089John gallagher Many people on their worst day cannot walk anywhere near that37312021-03-12T16:29:54.17349092kimberly johnsoni think the historic battleground should be preserved not built on people died there37162021-03-12T16:31:47.37749095Peaches ZimmermanDevelopment cant come at such a high price that we lose our past.37162021-03-12T16:32:01.01749096Sam Thompson SpenceThe forced suppression of highland culture is why my whole family has little to no old family traditions left, please don't let a large part of that history be destroyed.37162021-03-12T16:36:16.29749098Shirley HarrisWe need to preserve not remove37162021-03-12T16:36:26.51749099Smatha McBrayerAs a relative to those men laying on that battle field, this can NOT happen. They didn't choose that to be their last resting place. This is a part of my history along with any others. What else will be taken away from the Scots? Kill them all, run them away, and now destroy where their dead family lay. 37162021-03-12T16:37:02.62749100Zornitsa PaprikovaSave the battlefields 37162021-03-12T16:37:19.9749101Mik KeithCivil War sites are under attack as well. We are losing 150 acres a year for the same reasons.37162021-03-12T16:43:55.76749103Ana CunhaHistory and the memories of the ones who passed to the other side can't be forgotten!\r\nDon't let anything happen to this piece of Land that has to much significance to an entire country and to its people!\r\nPreserve history and the memories of the people! 37162021-03-12T16:46:25.95749105Winter ClavillisHistory is our truth anywhere in the world kids have it to learn from it the only way to never let these things happen again if you take away history your erasing their truth 37162021-03-12T16:46:35.26749106Adrienne Gardner This is a final burial place for many people who were fighting for their way of life and holds incredible historical significance. To destroy in order to build luxury homes would be absolutely disgusting. 37162021-03-12T16:49:46.17749107Jadyn BagbyPlease do not tear down this important part of history37162021-03-12T16:50:35.11349108Aurora durhamWe need to preserve history 37162021-03-12T16:52:46.36349110Jacee Christofferson Although I'm American, my family heritage hails from Scotland. I've visited this historic site and these are hallowed grounds and we must preserve this history!! I have ancestors who died on that field! We must not let their memory be swept away by greed or any other excuse! I pray that one day I'll be able to visit again, and bring my children so they can learn to appreciate what our ancestors sacrificed in the fight for their freedoms, as I have! 37162021-03-12T16:54:57.00349112Robin MosesDon't destroy and suppress history! Respect the land and the people37162021-03-12T17:03:23.6649114Cynthia SchabatkaHistory needs protecting the Scottish has lost enough of their heritage37162021-03-12T17:08:45.0249115Alessia Lamanna I am outraged to see that after several attempts the government is not taking matters into its own hands. we only think of building on all the plots of land that exist in the world. it is shameful to let these real estate agents do it. no is no! let's leave our heritage alone. I don't have Scottish blood but Scotland is part of me. Therefore, no the battlefield must remain virgin of all constructions. history must be preserved to remember it.37162021-03-12T17:10:05.81749116jane brownThe 20 metre rule should be scrapped. It is not a fair indicator of a person's disability 37312021-03-12T17:10:16.36349117Kyra F. VerverdaPeople deserve respect even when they are dead. These people deserve to stay where they fought and be honoured for their sacrifice. Any important battlefield should stay that way because the history is just too important! 37162021-03-12T17:13:27.9149118Mackenzie CampbellThe history of Scotland does not deserve to be destroyed! The history is too rich.37162021-03-12T17:14:51.16349119Mackenzie CampbellProtect Scotland and its history!!!37162021-03-12T17:18:37.66349121Ton AalbersProtection of the greater battlefield is necessary, especially when proven that the areas were the planning to build are definitely a part of the battlefield. History will be lost, damages will be made and cannot be turned back when the building permission goes through. I have visited Culloden many times and it is definitely sacred ground and very important to many Scottish people and peoples worldwide. 37162021-03-12T17:21:18.78749123Philip wattAbsolutely disgraceful on or near this historic battlefield where so many of our ancestors died to further the cause they believed in. Please reject the planning appeal 37162021-03-12T17:22:02.38349125Stephanie HitchcockI hope this helps the accused heal and rest in peace. May it also been the heal the trauma that has been passed on to each of our ancestors and in our own bodies. 37332021-03-12T17:23:41.8549127Rashida Elvin I hope this helps you to preserved history.37162021-03-12T17:29:38.00749129Lynne raineyPlease scrap this awful unfair rule.37312021-03-12T17:30:09.5449131Josiah A. RodelaThe Highlanders that fought and died there will be remembered. Their sacrifice was not in vain.37162021-03-12T17:36:12.49349133Frank MacgillivrayThe spirits of my ancestors are alive on the moor37162021-03-12T17:40:29.94749135Amber RaglinThere are so many areas and different land to build on. Don't destroy a piece of history!! 37162021-03-12T17:41:35.19749136Anne DavidsonMobility is not just about walking. I can walk my dog, which helps my mental health & muscular pain but have to rest for hours afterwards. I can't bend or lift things. I need help with almost everything else in my life eg shopping, housework & have to use taxis to access GP, pharmacy, optician etc as the local bus comes nowhere near me & doesn't stop anywhere near anywhere I might need to go. I don't have a car & don't even get lower rate for mobility.37312021-03-12T17:53:19.52749144Holly ParrishPlease preserve Culloden battlefield! It's too important a site to use for housing.37162021-03-12T17:57:38.57349145Heather Petersen We should never cover or remove history. 37162021-03-12T18:15:55.04749148Margaret LangWhy cant we just have a complete ban on all buildings here. Its turning into a game with the people who cant seem to take 'No' for an answer. They are only going to keep going and try to brow beat the council. These type of prople show they have no respect for anyone or anywhere with this attitude.\r\n37162021-03-12T18:18:46.71749149Jackee ChandlerErasing history is always a bad thing. 37162021-03-12T18:21:01.12349152Haylie GleasonThis is not just a historical landmark but also a place where so many people were killed and are now currently resting. We need to protect history.37162021-03-12T18:28:53.20349154Kathy MattesI am a descendant of the Robertson Clan. I think the government needs to do more to protect my descendants historic land.37162021-03-12T18:29:52.82749155Margaret BrownPlease reconsider the 20m rule. It's hard enough for people with disabilities without placing yet more barriers in their way.37312021-03-12T18:30:18.2849156Elizabeth FineThis is a site worth remembering and honouring. 37162021-03-12T18:33:59.3649157Olivia Winburn Battlefields are part of history and history must be protected and preserved!37162021-03-12T18:35:14.04749158Madison Pantleo Honour those who fought and died for their land. We must preserve historic land and Scottish history. Save this battlefield and save those who paid the ultimate cost for their cause. 37162021-03-12T18:39:12.48749159Jaclyn ArienoYou can not possibly destroy this historic graveyard. Let our ancestors rest in peace instead of disturbing them for houses37162021-03-12T18:42:03.12749161Shirley FosterPlease stop this rule37312021-03-12T18:46:07.78349164Pauline PoleScottish heritage is so important particularly at the moment. Future generations rely on us to keep places like Culloden safe from development. We need to protect our history and if development is allowed to go ahead, what message does that send to our children? Is it okay for people to give their lives to protect their country, to be buried where they fall, only to have the land desecrated by unfeeling developers? Please respect our heritage and build somewhere else. Protect our battlefields at all costs.37162021-03-12T18:46:26.849165Amanda DoveFor Bonnie King Charlie and the lives lost. We fought for Tartan and will fight for your field of dreams too. 37162021-03-12T18:48:17.8349166Lisa SeamanScottish history is important and it's important to remember those who died and lost the ability to use their clan name and so much more ... please save history37162021-03-12T18:55:19.4149170Dayna ZarazinskiThis is site is of such historical importance. If we erase it, the vast numbers of Scots will have sacrificed in vain. This not only ended the Highlander way of life, but it ended the bloodlines of many. Respect the people and the history!! If I ever get to Scotland this place is on the top of my list to visit. Clan Kincaid!\r\n\r\n37162021-03-12T18:55:21.1349171Zoey wall History needs to be preserved so we don't risk repeating the mistakes of the past... So we may learn. 37162021-03-12T18:56:28.0249172Arsinoe Ravenwood Dubois History is extremely important, thus should be preserved. Saving this historic place from developers is a step in the right direction. 37162021-03-12T18:57:35.22349173Kayla HanakI look forward to the day we can travel, the first place I'll be going is Scotland. I'm intrigued by the history and everything we can learn from this magnificent place. It would be a down right shame to see history lost to the future.37162021-03-12T19:01:18.11349174Malia VanThose who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it. 37162021-03-12T19:03:59.72349177Jennifer CouchCulloden is a historical battlefield and graveyard. Let the brave men rest in peace already! Keep the history! Learn from history! Respect the history!37162021-03-12T19:08:30.00749178Alex Iznajar MaderoI really hope that one day we will stop erasing history and actually learning from it. 37162021-03-12T19:12:50.6849180Kaylee CampI am a history major at Mississippi University for Women. Seeing a historically significant site like this being threatened like this is appalling. 37162021-03-12T19:13:28.66349181Gary O'brienMore protection required for our history.37162021-03-12T19:19:19.91349183Taylor BrooksHistory is something you should keep around for furniture generations to know what happened and appreciate what they have and how their lifestyle got to be how it is. 37162021-03-12T19:26:08.7949186Kimberlie Elsenbeck We must preserve historical landmarks37162021-03-12T19:27:41.85349187Michelle Tonnemacher I have Scottish Ancestry so please save this important historical land.37162021-03-12T19:41:17.02749190Amy StottTo build over Culloden is not only a destruction of history but also the desecration of graves. 37162021-03-12T19:41:27.949191Tammy MorganWe don't need Modern Development, we need to preserve History. Some people just need to learn that Money and power isn't everything. 37162021-03-12T19:43:18.449193Tom LyonsThis is the site of one of the most important events on British soil, and many Highlanders died on this land in one of the last battles in the Highland tradition, those resisted the modern world even when change was inevitable. It must be preserved.37162021-03-12T19:49:20.96349196Jean Mallalieu Please stop the 20 metres rule. 37312021-03-12T19:49:27.99749197Olivia Autenrieth I believe it is important to preserve historical sites instead of constantly building new things on top of them. 37162021-03-12T19:59:05.79349204Cheyanne PettusI pray that this beautiful landside historical landmark does not get destroyed. Not only would it be a tragedy and insult to the fallen, but that's asking for a lot of trouble building on a gravesite.\r\nLord protect Scotland.37162021-03-12T20:03:21.04349205Elizabeth EspinosaRemoving parts of history serves to hide atrocities and letting people deny it happen and prevents the ability to learn and grow into better humans37162021-03-12T20:06:23.51349206Johnny GoodsonThis battlefield is historical landmark not to mention the cemetery it must be preserved haven't we wiped out enough of our history37162021-03-12T20:11:18.1149208Elizabeth RogersAll history should be preserved, protected, honored, and learned from.37162021-03-12T20:13:24.43749209Kris GordonAs not only an MS sufferer but someone who has had a prosthetic leg for over 20 years I believe the 20m rule is unjustifiable considering all of the variables. I was also asked how far I can walk without my prosthetic on. This is utterly humiliating.37312021-03-12T20:16:15.0649210Shirley MinesBeing 16% Scottish, I felt like it was my duty to sign this. Cause for all I know, that's part of my history as well.37162021-03-12T20:17:50.9749211Mary StewartHistorically a graveyard and of significant importance in Scotland's History and should never ever be built on37162021-03-12T20:18:30.95349213Kristen KellnerThe dead have earned their right to remain. Historic battlefields should never be developed.37162021-03-12T20:18:38.40749214Sunita BuddhuThis is an important part of Scottish and European history and should be preserved. 37162021-03-12T20:18:54.48349215Maria BrownI am a Scottish descent On my paternal grandfather side I am second generation I still have family in Scotland, England and Ireland Preserving the historical sites and landmarks of my ancestral homeland for future generations is important to me Please protect and preserve this against development37162021-03-12T20:26:35.79749217Tiffany izquierdo STOP BUILDING ON HISTORIC PROPERTY 37162021-03-12T20:29:1149218Gerry CassidyScrap the 20-metre rule. It's existence denies so many people with MS the financial assistance they need. There are other ways of assessing the needs of individuals who are living with the limitations imposed by MS. 37312021-03-12T20:36:40.15749219Shannon BohackI am from the United States and after watching the show Outlander my friends and I visited Scotland. We were amazed at how beautiful and green everything was. The landscape and history of this country are things that should be preserved not destroyed. I learned so much at the museum there and walking the grounds really helped me feel the presence of those who died fighting that day. Destroying this would be a disgrace to their sacrifice as well as their families. Please preserve this historical landmark as well as the nature in Scotland. It is such a beautiful country and as a tourist I went there for the history and landscape not for a new building to be built.37162021-03-12T20:41:36.9149224Rebecca Hartwig History must be preserved as a respect to all of those who lost their lives during this major historical event & also to teach those in the future what was. 37162021-03-12T20:44:19.70749225Rebecca Rebeske We need to preserve this land. 37162021-03-12T20:49:25.25349227William Moore As a historian I am appalled that any planning for building in this unique and historically important site could be applied for let alone approved by highland council. This is a site of significant Scottish and worldwide importance and should be preserved for future generations. 37162021-03-12T20:56:45.11349228MaryLindsay if you have a degenerative illness you should be awarded benefits not have to meet specific criterion, you're already there.37312021-03-12T21:01:33.50749230Charles ElliottPlease preserve this battlefield. 37162021-03-12T21:07:50.88349231Allister GibsonThis battlefield is of mass historical significance, and it should be regarded as such. The idea of developing upon a battlefield where bodies still lay is unconscionable. I come from a long line of Scottish ancestors, and I hope to visit this battleground some day. And when I do, I pray the grounds have not been torn apart. Please do not allow these sacred lands be disrespected and destroyed! 37162021-03-12T21:14:44.11749233Allison GibsonThese sacred lands must be protected! Although I was born & raised in Canada, I have a long line of Scottish ancestry, and I hope to visit this battlefield someday. And when I do, I pray that it has not been destroyed & developed upon. The idea of developing upon land where bodies still - knowingly - lay, is unconscionable. Please protect & preserve this battlefield. 37162021-03-12T21:18:18.58749234Destiny MooreThis place is not only a resting spot but a part of history37162021-03-12T21:20:09.449237Laci AlexandraAs someone who has Scottish lineage, this hurts me personally. I truly hope this petition works and keeps the battlefield the way it is 37162021-03-12T21:20:56.74349238Tiffany Corinne Stolle My family is buried there. Please let them rest, plant trees if you need it to look more pleasing to the eye but please don't disrespect them by placing homes over them. 37162021-03-12T21:21:06.0749239Matthew NewellHow dare people try to destroy this historic site that is basically a grave yard. 37162021-03-12T21:25:13.83749240Calysta VigoThis is a historical area that should be saved37162021-03-12T21:26:08.33749241Jacqueline L TorresWe should be preserving history not destroying it! 37162021-03-12T21:29:57.6549242Hannah leeI believe that all history should be protected maintained so that we may be able to learn from the actions of your ancestors and we may be respectful of historically important location37162021-03-12T21:36:47.43349245Jeffrey Robinson I had family on both sides of this rebellion and it must not be forgotten 37162021-03-12T21:36:51.9849246Jim Archibald This is an area of war graves an be kept clear development 37162021-03-12T21:37:13.55749247Lina SheahanWe do not need to develop every inch of our world. Leave some things be, especially historic sites that are also graveyards.37162021-03-12T21:42:05.10349248Jessica HuberThere is a reason why the land wasn t touched for hundreds of years, and we should keep it as it is.37162021-03-12T21:45:25.05749250Darian Rickard Enough has already been taken from this country and yes I view Scotland as an independent land. My great grandfather instilled a deep sense of pride for his home in our family and therefore pride in ourselves. Please respect these people's sacrifice by leaving this land untouched. When I finally have a chance to visit I would like to see my ancestors resting in the peace they deserved in life.37162021-03-12T21:45:45.65349251Victoria MacDonaldFor those in power to consider developing over a historic battlefield and gravesite, you should feel ashamed. Those who were killed in the battles deserve a peaceful place to rest and the respect that is deserved of a warrior. 37162021-03-12T21:55:14.35749252Haley Christoffersen I think history is very important. 37162021-03-12T21:58:11.9249253david stark20m is totally unrealistic 37312021-03-12T22:05:2849254Sarah SpurrierHistory must be preserved and the fallen must rest. 37162021-03-12T22:07:07.2549255Lori ScottPlease do justice to your heritage and save this land from development 37162021-03-12T22:10:12.20349256Dawn Mcwilliam Culloden battlefield is like a history graveyard, just like at Stirling where no planning is permitted why can you just do the same for here, no building end of, please!!! 37162021-03-12T22:14:53.7849257Corinne Morris My family has immigrated from Scotland to Canada - we have ancestors who died here. Don't dishonor them by destroy it. 37162021-03-12T22:17:01.07749258Charna Kathleen ElmorePlease do not build over the graves of so many souls.37162021-03-12T22:18:08.95349259Larissa Zahrobsky My ancestors are on that battle field. My blood. It is a disgrace that this is even considered . We want to preserve our heritage and have the right to come visit. I pray that this works. My family member and I are planning a trip to show them where we came from. It it so important to save history. 37162021-03-12T22:18:41.54749260Keigan ElliottThe fact that people want to turn what is essentially a graveyard into some kind of minimall disgusts me37162021-03-12T22:25:13.90749262Adrienne RobsonSome people want to be able to come and visit this historic sight and see where there ancestors fought! Stop trying to erase history as if it wasn't important or didn't happen! 37162021-03-12T22:25:51.1949263Riley SwackThis battle field is a historical place that needs to be preserved for future generations to understand cultural genocide. If you developed this land you would be further disrespecting the people who are buried there. 37162021-03-12T22:30:28.1949264Amy ScothernThis is an important part of history !! Don't lose it to development. 37162021-03-12T22:32:21.4149267Breanna Groneman Please preserve this historic and beautiful battlefield!! I would be so heartbroken to see that piece of history lost! It is a place to go to mourn not just those that died there (of which I have an ancestor) but an entire way of life. Please please don't destroy that place!37162021-03-12T22:46:14.19349269Philip WaldronPlease let my family members know history37162021-03-12T22:46:18.8849270Caitlin ModicaAlba gu bràth! MUST protect our Bonnie Scotland! #SCOTLAND!!!37162021-03-12T22:50:10.14749271Britteny Thomson I have family in Scotland. LET MY PEOPLE PRESERVE THEIR LAND AND HISTORY!!!37162021-03-12T22:52:47.47349272Rhiannon FergusonPlease with everything that is in me can we preserve our heritage. Born in the 90s in Scotland I want it to thrive as a historical and respected country. Lets keep our wits about us and show respect to what has happen to our ancestors. 37162021-03-12T22:54:15.64749274AkiFallsIt upsets me the level of disrespect for the dead is being done37162021-03-12T23:04:53.94349278Jessica HallI am an American but I have Scottish ancestry and I wholeheartedly believe that the Culloden Battlefield needs to be preserved and protected by the Scottish government and they MUST NOT allow for Modern Development on this hallowed land. 37162021-03-12T23:11:32.89749280Nicole McConnell The disrespect of building on top of what is essentially a grave site and a massively important and solemn historical site is completely disgusting and untenable. The fact that this petition needs to exist is shameful. To the Scottish government - step up and protect your people's history.37162021-03-12T23:12:00.47749281Tori CarterPreserve this for historical purposes please! 37162021-03-12T23:30:16.2349286Teena HolcombI have not had the opportunity to explore my heritage in full, which is Scot Choctaw. Seeing the Scottish countryside and battlefields is very much in my wish list, as well as visiting the modern attractions of Scotland. I beg you to enact legislation that will leave these historic places untouched, so that generations to come can see them.37162021-03-12T23:34:43.77749288Anna RounsevilleProtect the sacred resting places of my forefathers. I am part Scottish. I would like to see these burial places well tended to some day. Thank you. 37162021-03-12T23:37:44.1249290Jennifer LumleyThose who forget history are doomed to repeat it. Removing cultural heritage in the name of progress is actually regression. 37162021-03-12T23:38:25.91749291Ash SawHistory must be preserved and protected. As a human race, we need to start realizing we do not need more development, we need more preservation and appreciation of our history. I hope this petition works!! 37162021-03-12T23:41:58.32349292Karen McGrath ScarcelloAbsolutely save this battle field. 37162021-03-12T23:53:48.18749293Ashley Georgakopoulos Please preserve this land, for both historical and ecological purposes 37162021-03-12T23:56:24.85749294Brian AtwellI have been to Culloden moor, taken photos. It is certainly one of the most profound sites I've seen and must be preserved.37162021-03-12T23:57:12.1449295Tiffany EdwardsI was fortunate to visit Culloden in spring 2019. I felt the weight of history there, and I think it would be a tragedy if a major piece of Scottish history were to be destroyed for new development.37162021-03-13T00:07:27.26749300Brenda GordonIt's about time that it was changing. It's so unfair for many, they can't even walk a few feet never mind 60 feet. It's about time they got up with the times.37312021-03-13T00:18:09.39349304Natalie ThomsonTo even consider developing the resting place of so many is beyond comprehension. This is a historical memorial sacred to so many. We need to stop the development and ruining of this history. 37162021-03-13T00:30:19.4449305Misty RuleThis is a final resting place of the men that tried to save their homeland and now they are trying to take that from them. Shame on them37162021-03-13T00:33:54.22349306Helen EpleyPlease fully and permanently protect the most well known of Scottish battlefields. 37162021-03-13T00:36:34.45749307Olivia FriesSave historic land. Don't develop it.37162021-03-13T00:41:54.97349308Amber Nichols This is a historic grave site! We need to protect this land!37162021-03-13T00:44:20.9649310Morag FrameOur sacred grounds will not be given up for tourism!37162021-03-13T00:47:40.4949311Alex ChisholmI would prefer to ptotect the Historic battlefields of Scotland, there is a reason scots around the world know where and what the Culloden battle field means .Its not for its housing potential. 37162021-03-13T01:08:03.49349313Abdul AlwamThis is historical sanctuary it should not be modernized this fact is non negotiable.37162021-03-13T01:33:15.0949315Lee steinberg This battlefield should be saved because every culture matters and if events like this and their impact on societys arent remembered, then history repeats itself. These people have a right to their resting place. Please save this battlefield. 37162021-03-13T01:47:44.29749316Yvonne Kamang It's just disrespectful to even been considered for development.37162021-03-13T02:02:01.2849318Joyce Johnson Snelten (McColl)Culloden is sacred ground that must never be built upon. The Scottish soldiers that died on the battlefield are buried on that land and must not be disturbed. Planning to develop that land is sacrilegious and it's a vile disrespectful action against the Scottish culture and people.37162021-03-13T02:09:08.34349319Madeleine Tlapek-La Vean As a member of the Hannay clan and has very strong Scottish ties I a deeply sad and upset that a huge part of Scottish history is set up to be destroyed for modern building that will hold no meaning. 37162021-03-13T02:33:03.69749321Paige MacGillisPlease reconsider this decision when some of us are too young to even have had the chance to visit these places. Please preserve this valuable piece of history. 37162021-03-13T03:22:37.11749329Aldabi Sulaiman Save the battlefield 37162021-03-13T03:42:01.66749331JAYLINNE CASTILLOProtect the worlds history37162021-03-13T03:52:33.0749332Chevon Kellmanhistory was made there, and it is very important that greed doesn't win. It would be like they lost their lives all over again.37162021-03-13T04:11:36.90349335Patricia Kay NeSmith KosovicI may be an American with Scottish ancestors, but too many lives on both sides lost their lives that day. Noone won. Forget our history and we repeat it. Don't make the mistakes too many Americans make.37162021-03-13T04:46:32.23749336Devon TamHistory MUST be preserved and taught about in order for it to not be repeated. 37162021-03-13T04:58:51.2449337Bethany BossLeave the dead to rest37162021-03-13T05:07:46.40749339Wade caglePreserve world history 37162021-03-13T05:55:30.11749342Amanda HolmesMay they show some courtesy to the Fallen Soldiers let them rest in peace37162021-03-13T06:06:52.71349343Carly BarbittaProtect history 37162021-03-13T06:46:47.8349345Geraldine WalkerPlease scrap the 20 metre rule37312021-03-13T07:00:01.1649346Crystal PowellSave My Ancestry I just found out I am Scottish. I want to have my family members know and travel to Scotland. 37162021-03-13T07:00:11.1349347Paul MackenzieLeave the battlefield alone .37162021-03-13T07:11:34.28749350Stacey WrightPlease scrap this 20m rule it is not a fair marker for those suffering with MS! 37312021-03-13T07:53:55.38749352Molly LongPlease let us save this beautifully sad place and honour the men who died on this battle field 37162021-03-13T07:59:06.90349353Nathan Campbell Its very likely i have ancestors buried there. And i think its kind of disgusting that they would just pave over a historic grave site37162021-03-13T08:01:56.22749354Glenn GregorPlease inact legislation to save these historically significant sites.37162021-03-13T08:12:41.27749355Cynthia D. ConnThe battlefields of Scotland must be protected from being destroyed. They're Scotland's history, and they must be remembered. Leave the battlefields alone!37162021-03-13T08:20:11.5149358Naomi ColePreserving history so we can learn from it, respect it and dont make the same mistakes 37162021-03-13T08:26:20.60749360Elina SaariI hope that the government will protect these historically significant places. Battlefields are part of history as well as gravesites for many who fought there. Many places, such as Culloden are well known for their importance outside of Scotland as well. 37162021-03-13T08:37:25.37349362Fiona KellyJust because one day you may be able to walk 20 metres which might not be a easy task. Does not mean you can do this everyday and it could have taken you twice as long as someone who does not have MS. People soldier on with their condition but they should not be penalised for it.37312021-03-13T08:53:05.6349367Charlotte calwellThis is my Scottish heritage and I am proud of my heritage and it would be such a shame to see my heritage and my history to be bulldozed down to make way or housing or office buildings Think about the history and the sadness that lays underneath And the fallen Honour the history Of a Scottish heritage 37162021-03-13T09:09:20.64349369Aoibhinn Slattery From one Celtic Nation to another please do not destroy your history Scotland designate heritage status to the battlefields37162021-03-13T09:09:22.69349370Ryan BreenWe should preserve the history of this and keep the land modern building free this show the battle that happened here and if we destroy it technically shows that us people want to modernize the places that show true history 37162021-03-13T09:09:42.51749371mike cowsillTwenty metres means any large shop is unusable, as are most car parks. Its actually the length of the average house plus car and back again...seriously never thought up by anyone with mobilty issues.37312021-03-13T09:09:56.9349372CATHERINE WOODHEADThe 20 metre rule is so unjust and has caused great mental and financial anguish to many disabled people, many with MND and many others. Grimacing in pain and shuffling along on walking sticks or crutches does not and should not count as being able to walk 20 metres. It is inhumane to put people through this, making them struggle to try to reach the 20 metre mark because they know their case will depend on it. Enough is enough, Scottish Government, you need to treat people like humans, with dignity and fairness.37312021-03-13T09:29:27.7349373Ymir rise Why would you destroy a part of history and graveyard because of your own selfish wish 37162021-03-13T09:37:43.2149374Liliana VarelaWe must protect this historical battlefield at all costs. It is an important part of Scottish history. No developmental plan can outweigh this. 37162021-03-13T09:56:10.6549375David Lawriethis petition supports the work which we at NPHTA and PHTM have been doing at parliamentary and local authority levels for almost a year now, so we absolutely support this campaign, but would expand the requirement to not only engage with unions, but associations such as ours too, as we all stand shoulder to shoulder on this.\r\ni would also refer to the duty and burden placed on the local authorities and regulators to "actively engage with those they regulate as dictated by the regulators code, which is not optional, but instead MUST be complied with.37372021-03-13T10:15:58.31349379Sally elboroughThese women need to be remembered. 37332021-03-13T10:20:42.57349380Silvio HernandezI believe, this land needs to be protected, and not be used for modern development. There is too much rich history behind it37162021-03-13T10:35:25.73749382Sharon dixon To build over a graveyard is morally wrong. Please don't let this happen!!37162021-03-13T10:49:02.28749383LaMonica JordanWhile, I am in the United States, much of my genealogy traces me back to Scotland through the clans of McGregor, Wallace, Warren, Bruce, Daniel, and Callahan clans. I should one day like to visit Scotland and hope that these historic battlefields and other sites be preserved. This would be like putting a shopping mall on Gettysburg here in the states. Please preserve history for future generations.37162021-03-13T10:51:24.19349384Thomas TylerThe History of Scotland must be saved and protected for all time.37162021-03-13T10:59:44.95749385Ana Claudia Ekrem My grandmother was from Scotland and I have family there. Not be able to show my family members such a history battlefiel will be devastating. Plz preserve!!!!!!37162021-03-13T11:17:25.92749386Mitchell Elder Culloden is one of the most touching sites I've ever visited. I want my family to be able to visit it as I did. History must not be forgotten, lest it repeat itself. 37162021-03-13T11:20:01.6349387Rebecca Elizabeth dickson Hamilton I was bròn in Scotland and my family before me I have past relatives that where killed in this battle. And have suffered the affects of this battle even today please try your best to respect it 37162021-03-13T11:23:42.24349388Joanna Scott It will take big freight off the road particularly when the Rest and be thankful will be under repair for a long long time. 37352021-03-13T11:24:46.89749389Jennifer AvensProtect historic lands for the future of the country and make stay the memorial it should be. 37162021-03-13T11:26:53.1549390Abigail SommerDeveloping on top of a battlefield where people were slaughtered is nothing but disrespectful! 37162021-03-13T11:32:52.96349391Josephine LeesSo handy when travelling to see family in Campbeltown, can drive to Ardrossan, ferry to Campbeltown, and not an 8 hour drive to the town37352021-03-13T11:35:22.18349393Scarlett HillI think the erasure of scottish history is something that needs to be adressed more seriously. This battle field is essentialy a grave yard, so the idea of it being built on is nothing short of disgusting.37162021-03-13T11:38:34.14749396Dawn SwainUtter nonsense!!! Needs to be removed.37312021-03-13T11:38:46.83749397Jasmine HewittHow will the future generation learn the history of Scotland? I know I want to go visit and see it myself37162021-03-13T11:50:15.21749402Christine MacDonald Please scrap this rule. I'm in chronic pain and can't walk this distance without being completely floored. The nearest bus stop is further than 20m so easy exactly what am I supposed to do!!37312021-03-13T11:52:14.12349403Heidi Ratzlaff This is terrible to no know these heritage sites are being destroyed 37162021-03-13T12:10:29.90749406Ricardo Méndez Aguilar Save the battlefields. People deserve to have their history and their historical sites. 37162021-03-13T12:22:12.4549407Callie RoseIm a descendant of Clan Rose, of Kilravock Castle. My ancestors entertained the bonnie prince and his men at Kilravock just four days before the battle of Culloden. We were Jacobite sympathizers to say the least! I have many ancestors that lay to rest on Culloden Moor, and my stomach turns at the prospect of what is to become of their graves.37162021-03-13T12:24:36.12749408Nadine MacDonaldThis site is an important piece of history. If you pave over it with roads and houses, that's it, it's gone forever. Do not approve this project. 37162021-03-13T12:41:39.97349409Natalie Williams Enough history has been lost. Respect the resting place of many and a reminder of once was. Historical sites need to be preserved.37162021-03-13T12:58:29.56749410Raymond Thomson20m rule is a joke when most don't stay within 20m of a bus stop. Even the supermarket disabled spots are usually further than the mother and baby spaces. Sort it out!37312021-03-13T13:07:08.59749412Ruby CovingtonI it's not right not admiral to disturb the resting soldiers that fought and died there. Please do not disturb their final resting place but destroying their land and building something else on it. Let them rest in peace upon the ground where they sacrificed their lives for you and your country.37162021-03-13T13:18:29.85349413Keri WestThe Scottish Highlanders should be honored and remembered. This is a sacred site and should be kept as such. 37162021-03-13T13:28:33.2449416Kristin DillardThis Battlefield is sacred. Save this unique piece of Scottish history from development and greed37162021-03-13T13:36:12.82749418Christy Mackintosh We need to preserve history and stop erasing! 37162021-03-13T13:44:59.62349419Liz GlauberHistory is very important!!!37162021-03-13T14:08:43.52749425Cody GatesI'm signing this to protect my ancestral history! Go Scotland! Forever in my heart and we my history comes from. 37162021-03-13T14:20:3649428Heather MacDonaldBeing from Nova Scotia, I can tell you we have memorials here in my own county for that battle. It is important to preserve these hallowed places.37162021-03-13T14:27:01.28749429Sangeeta RamnananThose who forget history are doomed to repeat. Don't wipe out history.37162021-03-13T14:27:14.82749430Angela EllisAs an Outlander fan, I cannot bear the thought of Culloden battlefield being lost to development. If I ever get the chance to visit Scotland again, it would be top on my list of places to visit. 37162021-03-13T14:27:28.36349431Kassandra BugdenThis is a piece of history that we must honour and protect. Not only is this a historic battlefield but also a burial ground for so many Jacobite soldiers that were brutally murdered. So many have tried to erase Scottish history and it needs to end now.37162021-03-13T14:40:41.9949432Kellie LawtonHistorical sites are an important part of our history. It is disgusting behavior that any body would want to build anything over a graveyard and descerate graves. Protect historical sites.37162021-03-13T14:46:58.25749434Hilaire SmithWe don't need more concrete strip malls and cheaply made houses or condos. We do however need to respect history and grounds that are soaked in the blood of our ancestors. Preserving it and increasing tourism will ultimately serve Scotland better than any modern development37162021-03-13T14:51:33.8349436Jessica M. RoblesHistory is not just meant to be in books. This battlefield is a way to honor those who were lost 37162021-03-13T14:53:26.00749437Andrea Busby Please preserve this historical battlefield and monuments for future generations. 37162021-03-13T14:56:05.37749439Michele Grosspietsch Please preserve this sacred site from commercial development. The thousand that died there deserve to be respected and remembered. 37162021-03-13T15:00:15.7649440Christina ButlerThis is my heritage. Don't desecrate or erase my history. Our history. Have respect.37162021-03-13T15:02:19.46349442Terrie AllenProtect and respect the bodies of the dead. That is their final resting place. 37162021-03-13T15:09:24.1549443Ruthie backThe younger people need to know the truth 37162021-03-13T15:09:24.88349444Jaylie ClarkPreserve the history of this battlefield. Many good men lost their lives here. Let them Rest In Peace.37162021-03-13T15:18:50.05749445Tressa MerkHistory needs to be protected for this generation and next! Shopping mall and over sized home development needs to stop37162021-03-13T15:18:57.80749446Ari HavilandI believe that all historical sites should be preserved no matter what. Its a part of history. 37162021-03-13T15:23:39.41749447Penny JohnstonEssential. We have no reliable road. A ferry will alleviate the problem for both commercial and medical reasons. 37352021-03-13T15:24:56.26349448Marianna GriesackerMy dream is to go to Scotland into experience Scotland the way it was intended, with all of its natural beauty and so much historical history. Anyone trying to take that away is a horrible horrible person and to remove something so historical so monumental is just downright inhumane. I might live in the United States but my heart belongs in Scotland. 37162021-03-13T15:46:45.46749450McKenzie JacobitzThis is a place that history for Scotland took place. There are many people still buried beneath the ground and it would be tragic if you dug up their unmarked graves!37162021-03-13T16:04:09.40749452Ashlyn HufferStop destroying history, and leave this land untampered with for the sake of history and the people whose final resting place is here. 37162021-03-13T16:05:33.28349453Lawrence Moreno These lands must be preserved the heritage for future generations. 37162021-03-13T16:12:26.37749454Isobel ScatchardScrap the 20 metres rule. How can you judge an individual on this?37312021-03-13T16:19:34.0249455Denise MealeyA site that inhabits the remains of so many and that has so much significance for so many must be protected. 37162021-03-13T16:21:41.6649456Caroline HepburnThis is such a debilitating disease37312021-03-13T16:34:09.17749457Lorraine SmithThis is an extremely historic battleground that needs to be honoured and protected as an entire culture was killed that day. Those men did not deserve to be hunted and killed as they were by the English. Respect needs to be given to the fallen that still lay there. Do not build over the dead and give it the honour of restitution it needs to find peace. 37162021-03-13T16:35:24.8849458Isabella BarcellonaHistory needs to be preserved.37162021-03-13T16:43:15.649460Zophiel BokenhamHistorical sites such as these graveyards should be preserved on the left for the dead to rest in peace37162021-03-13T16:45:58.13349461Vanessa BaldwinPreserving history is a reminder to all of the atrocities of the past in hopes that they are never repeated. As an American Scot, Culloden is well known in our family history. These souls must not be removed from their resting place. 37162021-03-13T16:46:03.78749463Zophiel BokenhamHistorical sites such as these graveyards should be preserved and we should allow the Dead to rest in peace it is wrong to dig up any graveyard 37162021-03-13T16:52:30.1849466Senta Thompson-Phelps (Buchanan-Thompson Clans)Ancestors from birth of my familial clans fought and died at Culloden. This land is sacred and should be protected at all costs. 37162021-03-13T17:05:28.1549470Jessalynn SawyerThis is absolutely disgraceful!!! PLEASE do NOT do this, this land is sacred. 37162021-03-13T17:13:59.65349472Christina LandeTo disrespect the sacrifice those individuals made by allowing construction on historic sites is disgraceful. Please do not allow this to happen. 37162021-03-13T17:16:11.7349473Luci ScarlettThe land has history, leave those poor souls at peace and let the history live on. The world can't bare have more strings of hope be cutdown. Moreover, the next generation might just go having no knowledge if built upon the graveyard. Leave the souls at peace. 37162021-03-13T17:16:28.01349474Jackiey Pappenheim DavisI believe we need to protect this battlefield, for it's history, and the graves that were left behind.37162021-03-13T17:27:31.07749475Dezi zamoraJust dont there is so much land why here let it stand 37162021-03-13T17:29:57.6749476Lesley MillardThink rule is unfair37312021-03-13T17:42:24.90349478Kaia Smith History must be preserved to lose such an important part of Scottish heritage would be a great misfortune for present and future generations! 37162021-03-13T17:46:43.93749481Taylor BohannonI have ancestors from Scotland, and to know that the parliament is trying to discredit and uproot something of such historic significance is an absolute disgrace. 37162021-03-13T17:57:23.4749483Lacey StairsThis is a cultural and historic site. This is an essential part of history to keep preserved for generations to come. 37162021-03-13T18:07:44.349484Gracie RobisonThis is a resting place for thousands of soldiers, respect it and leave them in peace.37162021-03-13T18:15:42.9949485Danielle EhrlichSave the land 37162021-03-13T18:17:36.50349486sean stokesHistorical sites shouldn't be destroyed for profit.37162021-03-13T18:26:22.80349487JoElla SmithPlease do not disturb battlefields where people died.37162021-03-13T18:29:31.64749488Quinn SmithHistory needs to be preserved.37162021-03-13T18:37:28.19349491Alex Freeman-SmithMaintaining the historical battlefield is important to the preserving the highlander culture and way of life! Don't develop that land maintain it37162021-03-13T18:44:13.9349492Cheryl johnsonKeep the history in the world for future generations 37162021-03-13T18:48:00.61749493Jacqueline SloanEnough history has been destroyed by developers. Leave it alone!! 37162021-03-13T18:51:49.88349494Hailey DubeWe have to fight for the fallen ,its only justice that their bodies lye to rest in peacr37162021-03-13T18:55:52.66749495Miranda McIntyreI may be born and raised in Canada, but I have direct connection from both my maiden and married sides of the family to the battle of Culloden. I find it extremely frustrating and disappointing that anyone would consider desecration of where so many lay at rest. Especially one of such horrible means. We can not have a future without a respect for the past. 37162021-03-13T18:56:18.16749496Alana WoodThose you do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.37162021-03-13T18:58:50.8249497Kimberly HenryMy family are of Scottish decent and have visited Culloden. We were deeply moved by our time there. Don't do what Americans do and develop over your history. It's what we found so beautiful about being in Scotland. 37162021-03-13T19:13:03.90349499Valerie Johnston As a Scot living with MS, I am overjoyed at the Scottish gov for taking these steps. I trust that in the socialist, forward thinking, independent Scotland that we will soon become, we will go further and scrap this dehumanising 20 meter rule. I support the snp and I trust they will do the right thing 37312021-03-13T19:13:36.54349500Abigail BuenoWe need to save our history because that history is what make us what we are today37162021-03-13T19:15:55.37349502Kenneth macinnesScrap the 20 meter rule, its dehumanising and results in people having a reduced quality of life. I trust the Scottish gov to do the right thing.37312021-03-13T19:21:45.5349503Colin stewart Scrap the awful 20 meter rule. It was a dehumanising rule brought in by the Tories and has no place in a progressive Scotland. 37312021-03-13T19:37:29.65749505Shannon MartinThe majority of my ancestors are from the Scottish Highlands. Before the pandemic hit I was planning a trip to the highlands to explore the rich history including that of the Jacobites. If much of that historical sites including the battlefield at Culloden is overtaken by modern developments I'm not sure I would have as much incentive to visit in future. I have discovered my highlander ancestors clans names and have discovered many were likely involved in the Jacobite movement and therefore many are likely buried at Culloden. To build over these graves and to erase such an important and well known historical site makes no sense and I cant believe it would even be a consideration37162021-03-13T19:57:07.92349506Brianna SmithTo much history has been destroyed we need to fight to preserve what we have left!!!!37162021-03-13T20:03:38.2249507Lauren Mitchell We must respect the past soldiers who fought for there rights and preserve there burial sites. 37162021-03-13T20:11:29.12749508Lisa FoxI have ancestors that fought and died here. Too much of history is being destroyed. 37162021-03-13T20:43:39.2949510Rachel BoltzThis is a historical sight and should not be devolped on37162021-03-13T20:45:46.83749511Maddison RocheWe been to keep historical land the way it is.37162021-03-13T20:47:52.83749512William PatersonBattlefieldsmerd protection from developers.37162021-03-13T21:05:16.16749513Sedona KolmerArchaeology and medieval studies student plan to study abroad in Scotland next year and Culloden and many other battlefields like it are at the top of my list of historic sites to visit and learn about. So much has already been lost and it would be a shame for this history to be lost and these graves to be disturbed.37162021-03-13T21:08:10.71749514Louise Van RensburgThis should not and cannot be allowed to happen! Once planning is refused that should be the end of it! It is not right that developers can continue to apply until they basically get what they want by changing the wording of thier application!37162021-03-13T21:14:27.7349515AshLeigh NorlenNot only is this a historical site, it is a graveyard. To consider this for development is deeply distasteful, and whomever proposed it should be ashamed of themselves. Sites like this need to be preserved and protected. Let the dead rest with dignity.37162021-03-13T21:18:44.9549516John WagnerAll historic places need to be perserved around the world gor guture generations37162021-03-13T21:23:41.85749517Peter GottgensTime to be fair and show an understanding of MS and what it's about and how it affects people. 37312021-03-13T21:30:34.8649518Claire KuikenAcknowledgment of the dead and the preservation of history are what gives us a connection to the past. Some things should be left to rest, and as many things as possible preserved. 37162021-03-13T21:33:41.4249519Elizabeth McRoberts Battlefields of such significance, as Culloden must be preserved for posterity. It's history, ground zero and every Scottish schoolchild should be allowed the possibility of seeing it, as it is! Sacrilege to develope the burial grounds into housing, shopping or tourists exploitation!\r\nThe existing tourist center is perfect and serves an educational purpose, nothing else is required on the grounds! Be respectful, honor the dead, save the site!37162021-03-13T21:46:02.01749520Haylei BarberI have ancestors who died during the Battle at Culloden field. They were fighting to preserve their way of life. This site should be protected.37162021-03-13T21:50:55.53349522Beinnon MacNeilWe need to protect history because there are many people in cape breton and canada who don't know our history because we had to flee soctland or we would have been killed.37162021-03-13T22:02:10.92749524Zaxou NektariaPlease protect the history of this country\r\nI am obsessed with it!37162021-03-13T22:03:27.8849525Luke ReeveBattlefields hold a special place in the history not only of Scotland, but of countries around the world. They are brilliant places to teach and educate people about important moments in history, that will help people connect to the stories much more than just reading about them from a book. \r\n\r\nNot only that, often these are places where hundreds if not thousands of people have their final resting place. These people need to be shown dignity and respect, no matter how long they have been there. 37162021-03-13T22:09:52.08349526Dorothy WongPlease help Scotland 37162021-03-13T22:18:39.19349529Anne Marie MurphyRidiculous rule! 37312021-03-13T22:50:26.1249531Laura FultonPlease scrap this 20 metre rule37312021-03-13T23:17:12.0649532Deborah Shearer20m rule needs to be scrapped 37312021-03-13T23:19:45.45349533Josh burtonIt's disgraceful that they would even think about developing on this battle ground. They should be ashamed of themselves. Extremely disrespectful. 37162021-03-13T23:24:46.06349534Bill FlemingAs a native Nova Scotian with direct ties to the Culloden battlefields (we have our own cairn erected), the history is sacred, and no financial benefit can offset the loss if this land. Save Colloden. 37162021-03-13T23:42:55.5849535Mhairi FindlayPlease remove the 20m rule, I have MS and I have good and bad days . MS is a condition which has no cure and is progressive. 37312021-03-13T23:44:50.9749536Berenice RobertsonCulloden Battle Field is a War Grave,there is no denying this fact. This Battlefield should be given the same respect as ALL Battlefields around the world are given. Just because the area is filled with Headstones or Markers, does not mean that the Remains of the Fallen from all sides of this conflict do not lie there. Of course they do. Just imagine a developer asking for permission to build over your Families' Burial Plot - would you allow this - no you wouldn't. The current level of Planning Protection is woefully inadequate for ALL Scottish Battle Fields and the Government needs to step up and take control to give permanent protection to these Historic Sites. These Sites should be preserved for future generations, so that they can learn what their Ancestors fought so hard for - Freedom. Allowing Developers to build on any of these Battlefields is an act of desecration.\r\n37162021-03-14T00:20:56.36749537James Douglas McDowellAs so many have pointed out, there are plenty of places to develop that do not dishonor and desecrate such significant places in the history of Scotland.37162021-03-14T00:38:45.47749538Kelly Saindon The battle field and all others should be preserved. To keep the soldiers who were slaughtered can be left to rest in peace.37162021-03-14T00:43:28.32349539Eva McCullochA family member was born in Scotland and it saddens me to hear that places of such historic significance may be wiped away in the name of progress. Please designate them as heritage sites do that when I bring my family to Scotland, they can see the places that are so important to our history. 37162021-03-14T01:47:33.09749543Lisa NeshineMy ancestors are buried there37162021-03-14T01:54:19.2749545Liz StottPlease be realistic. Scrap the 20 mtr rule.37312021-03-14T01:59:37.09749546Terri Bryant Historical place this important needs to preserved37162021-03-14T02:17:47.02349547Mechelle SteenburgKeep history alive and protect beauty where it exists. Not every square inch of this beautiful Earth needs modern development! 37162021-03-14T02:28:35.58749549Amy Johnson"Run, and you'll live... at least a while. And dying in your beds, many years from now, would you be willin' to trade ALL the days, from this day to that, for one chance, just one chance, to come back here and tell our enemies that they may take our lives, but they'll never take... OUR FREEDOM!"\r\nPlease help preserve your history and the history of the noble men of your home land!37162021-03-14T02:32:45.5149550Randall C. HolsingerAll battlefields need to be preserved. If the moderation of society requires to build on a battlefield, then please come across the pond and build on Gettysburg, Antietam, or any other battlefield in America. There is plenty of Scottish people here and you would be hard put to try that.37162021-03-14T03:13:26.35749553Kristin HarrisThis is a sacred site and a place of rest. To develop on this land would be an affront to all those who learn from its history.37162021-03-14T03:37:32.2249555Tasha AdamsThey understand that burial grounds are sacred right? Like the USA is nothing but sacred burial grounds and weve been cursed since the beginning. They honestly need to be better. Not so disrespectful.... 37162021-03-14T03:49:04.14749557Jimmy SolisSave the battlefield 37162021-03-14T03:59:59.6349558Anna KoskiI might be in Canada but my family came from Scotland. Allowing people to dig up and build on land that people like my ancestors fought and died on is horrible. Preserve this land. It's a place of remembrance, not a place for a housing development or a strip mall37162021-03-14T04:04:53.17749559Haley HymersThis petition shouldn't even need to exist. Stop trying to destroy history37162021-03-14T04:04:59.83749560Ayden KitchenI had the absolute honor of visiting Culloden Moor in 2019. It was a humbling, historical, and beautiful visit. To develop this site would be an absolute waste of heritage, history, and a disgrace to all the Highlanders who lost their lives on that battlefield. 37162021-03-14T04:11:22.9349561Ruth miller My history goes back to Scotland clan MacNeil. I believe we should save our history . 37162021-03-14T04:15:06.9649562Connor DevineThat battlefield is a part of history37162021-03-14T04:21:20.08749565Brad Gentile this needs to be stopped. Any who disagree should be ashamed 37162021-03-14T04:26:03.0149566Sarah FoxHistory must be remembered and, to a degree, preserved, so that we may readily learn from the past for a better tomorrow. Covering over this raw source of history will serve only to forgetting the monumental battle that cost too many lives already. 37162021-03-14T04:32:40.1249567Jeremy AnayaPreserve this piece of history and honor those who lost their lives and loved ones 37162021-03-14T04:35:06.21349569Audrey BirdProgress does not mean encroaching upon historical monuments! Reconnect with the earth you live upon and understand the damage the human species has done to it in the name of "progress". We have so much work to do as a species! And you people seriously think that you should just build more stuff atop one of your most historical monuments ever??? No. Progress does not mean "make room" progress means improving what you already have. 37162021-03-14T04:51:57.28749570Janet FinanThis is a site of historical significance and needs to be preserved and protected. The bodies that died there and then became apart of the earth are to be honored. Please protect this land. 37162021-03-14T04:54:41.5249571Sarah FoxProtect History37162021-03-14T05:01:45.05349573Heather Pollock-SmithMy family immigrated from Coatbridge to Ontario, Canada. I would hate to see developments happen on historic ground. History should matter more to people.37162021-03-14T05:58:24.6749577Jen Isbister These (and all) battlefields must be protected to honour those lives that were lots and to prevent the loss of history.37162021-03-14T06:27:59.8349579Me Colin DoddsWe need financial help now.37372021-03-14T06:33:55.20749580ashley stewartPlease protect this place !37162021-03-14T06:35:28.7449581Tracy CaldwellOur local city council is trying to annex the last bit of the best agriculture land, Wood Colony, to pave over with industrial buildings. These kinds of things should never be considered, here or at a famous bttleground and graveyard in Scotland. How shameful 37162021-03-14T06:41:36.28749582Linda Fisher-CioppiTo learn that this land might be lost forever due to development is absolutely disgusting to all that have lost their lives fighting for their home, their history, their freedoms, their ways and for their country. That their bodies, their blood and their everything still resides within these lands. To have someone take this land and any other land just like this away is absurd, disgraceful, disgusting and wrong to the people of Scotland and of history. FOR WHAT? FOR GREED!!! Please preserve these lands for Scotlands history, for those of the now, and for those generations that are still to come. Too much is already lost. Please do not spit in the faces of the dead. I am a descendant of Scotland, I would like to come to Scotland and see where my family lived and died. PROTECT AND PRESERVE THESE LANDS!37162021-03-14T06:43:16.05349583Alexandra LeVaeIt saddens me so much to see such an important part of Scottish history at risk. These are areas that people sacrificed their lives on to protect Scotland and Scottish culture. Preserve that history and respect the dedication of those who died there. 37162021-03-14T06:58:40.63349584Morgan DeMouraLet historical sights live and breathe and be kept sacred! 37162021-03-14T07:19:21.9549585Margaret stewartPlease scrap the 20m rule37312021-03-14T07:22:26.10749586Becky Akridge WallerWas told I have some scotish irsh in me. I'm not sure but if I do this is some of my heritage.37162021-03-14T07:33:45.2349587Ami MacConnelStop the colonization already at let our ancestors Rest In Peace 37162021-03-14T07:46:06.6449589Alexis HaganThe battlefield is historic, it is also a national landmark representing, essentially, the bravery and ferocity of the highland people. People forgetting whatever quarrels they may have had with other clans, to come together and fight for their right to live the way they lived for centuries before the British invaded Scotland. Destroying this land, turning it into housing developments, would be in incredibly poor taste, and horrendously disrespectful to the lives lost in the fight for cultural freedom.37162021-03-14T08:21:14.06749591Lori MorenoSave this sacred site37162021-03-14T08:32:03.53749592Tory PopinskiI am a descendent McNaughton & Ferguson these battlefields are places we visit because of of heritage. If they are developed we will lose or right to visit, honor and pray on this land as some of my ancestors never left the fields.37162021-03-14T09:00:49.1249595Cherrie StewartWe must preserve our history. It is part of our daily life's and is a sin to try and get rid of it. 37162021-03-14T09:47:45.95349599Stuart MathewsonLeave historical sites alone 37162021-03-14T09:59:17.4449602Loree ShockPlease protect this very significant historical site. 37162021-03-14T10:45:03.36749603Yelina Uribe We should be able to honor those who lost there lives and lived on to give them a physical place to show further generations and help improve a link with our history. 37162021-03-14T10:55:56.7949604Terri BrownAs a person who comes from confirmed Jacobite ancestry, we have to recognise the cultural significance of the battlefields. Our culture and traditions were made illegal and plans to develop the ground the ancestors lie on is distasteful and disrespectful to Scottish people 37162021-03-14T11:11:03.90349606Rachel MurrayI stand with this.37332021-03-14T12:42:57.6549610Fiona sippleMy family lives in Scotland and I would be heartbroken and know they would too if a development was valued more than a historic landmark. Protect history. 37162021-03-14T12:44:09.19349611David smith Save the history!37162021-03-14T12:51:01.32349613Susan WhitsonHistory should not be paved over or built over with high density housing or any other sort of development. The same treachery is happening on the Southern US Civil War battlefields and graveyards.37162021-03-14T12:51:45.74349614Kara KnaussThe memory of those who died in battle defending their Scottish culture must be protected!37162021-03-14T12:59:37.15349616William Muirheadwe must are history \r\n37162021-03-14T13:05:17.7949617Tanya Von Black For my sisters and brothers murdered for their skills and those falsely accused as an excuse to kill you. I stand with you and you will not be forgotten. 37332021-03-14T13:05:56.99349618Tonya Earle Please preserve history. God bless37162021-03-14T13:08:22.12349619Catherine CraigI had the honor of visiting Culloden back in 2019. It was a profound experience and I want to be able to bring my family member. I hope this petition helps. 37162021-03-14T13:15:34.8149620Gregg Taylorhow far fo polititian have to walk before they get an expenses check37312021-03-14T13:25:10.549622Jaimie MacDonaldPlease honour these women (and men) as they deserve to be honoured. So much learning was lost from our human journey and growth by violently removing them from this world. 37332021-03-14T13:40:16.06349625Amanda Gage-CrollProtect history!37162021-03-14T13:41:59.14349626Courtney KohlCompletely disrespectful to even considering this idea! I pray this petition works! 37162021-03-14T13:42:08.7249627Amanda OrtegaAs a Texan who knows the importance of keeping historical areas protected I fully support this petition in urging scottish's government to protect this and all historic battlefields. 37162021-03-14T13:49:54.28349628Diana ManciniBeen there- makes me sad that it cld b destroyed!37162021-03-14T14:03:15.2249632Paula CollarLong overdue37332021-03-14T14:06:44.92749633Julie SweeneyThis needs to be removed.37312021-03-14T14:16:51.86349635Amber KeysBeing honest, I'm an American who ended up here through an Outlander forum. I've never been to Scotland (sadly) and only know about Culloden through the books. But the idea that someone could just wake up one day and sincerely think, "hey, I'd like to have more money. Building on a sacred battleground where countless people lost their lives is the way to go," I have no words. 37162021-03-14T14:19:28.9949637Neil Donald This rule needs to be reassessed as it can vary so much from day to day37312021-03-14T14:30:00.74349639Kaleigh CroftThis battlefield is the graveyard of mine and many others ancestors. They died her for what they believed in. It is a site of mourning and hope. This petition has to work. For all of our history. 37162021-03-14T14:30:33.8849640Roger Amidon IIIHistory should be preserved.37162021-03-14T14:33:10.69749641Stephen OdomRespect the battleground.37162021-03-14T14:34:39.3749642Jennifer Morrisson This location deserves to be respected, not developed.37162021-03-14T14:35:31.4349643Ashley Risher We need to protect our historically significant places. People died here, and to build over them and erase this history would do a great injustice to those who died. We need to preserve it!37162021-03-14T14:41:55.449644Mallory JohnstonThe destruction of this is horrid, and my ancestors fought bravely on this land. Modern development has no overcast to beautiful history, and should remain unscathed. Do not develop historical lands for meager development!!37162021-03-14T14:42:57.33749645Meghan HornPlease protect the sanctity and memory of historic battlefields and preserve Culloden. The site is an integral part of Scottish history and be preserved for future generations. I may not be Scottish myself, but I am an American with Scottish ancestry and I would like to see historical sites in my ancestral homeland treated with respect and dignity. Thank you for your time.37162021-03-14T14:52:08.57349646Maggie richardsI have a strong Scottish heritage, my ancestors fought in that battle, I really truly hope this petition works 37162021-03-14T14:57:32.49749647Holly E PattersonPart of my family is from Scotland. I think it is important to preserve historical sites that have significance like this one. 37162021-03-14T15:10:04.54349649Erika schulte SAVE THEM BATTLE FEILDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!37162021-03-14T15:19:45.38749650Litzy FraustoThis like this should be preserved. Its disrespectful to try and like move it around 37162021-03-14T15:24:55.6749651Tiffany DealWe need to respect historic battlegrounds and cemeteries where people have been laid to rest. 37162021-03-14T15:57:44.31749653James Reinhardt Throckmorton-BellAs someone who has relatives still in Scotland, I would like to sign the petition for preservation of this gravesite. This is a sacred place and it is wrong to develop over such a historic site. 37162021-03-14T16:08:21.2449654Angela HallMore understanding of variable disability is needed37312021-03-14T16:35:35.49349656Benjamin wagarHistory must be preserved regardless of the fact that is was a bloody battle and lots of lives were lost. It is now a grave yard essentially. 37162021-03-14T16:41:46.88749658Carlena FriddlePlease have better sense than the US. Destroying history is disrespectful to all who fought to give us life. 37162021-03-14T16:47:39.2349659Erica Meinecke Save the scottish battle fields 37162021-03-14T16:50:39.96349660Lynsey mcintyreDone im on pip and has to appeal as got deckined first tine then won it 37312021-03-14T16:58:14.18749661INEZ FRAMEPlease scrap this rule, it does not take into account the difference in good and bad days for mobility, a snapshot should not be how it is decided.37312021-03-14T16:58:27.2349662Jennifer mulligan Protect this sacred land 37162021-03-14T17:01:22.02749663Melissa Graysave colloden37162021-03-14T17:08:21.249664Sharon KeyBattle graveyards need to be protected. It's disrespectful to consider developing the land for business profits. It would be like destroying all graveyards and building shopping centers. This is a site of a major historical event. 37162021-03-14T17:11:25.2849665Lisa PedrozaSending prayers for and this this worthy cause. We have to preserve historical places like this for future generations to come. Good luck!37162021-03-14T17:20:03.62349666Rachel KiddFor all the healers wrongly accused 37332021-03-14T17:31:44.21349667Kimberly BeachMore countries need to protect their national Heritage, if anything it brings in tourism which brings in money. Lose the tourist lose money 37162021-03-14T17:55:56.72349668Susan McCannTo all those spirited women37332021-03-14T18:26:37.3649670Rebekah Bankert As someone loves history, I have visited many battlefields and their is a sense of time standing still in those places. Also those areas are haunted you don't have tentants whose homes are haunted they will not stay. Also respect the dead. 37162021-03-14T19:44:54.40349671Neil GalbraithIt can only do good for business in the local area \r\nAnd with the reoccurring problem with the rest and be thankful it has to go ahead 37352021-03-14T19:57:13.1749672Tina SloneThe history of our world is valuable and we must protect and preserve it for future generations. We don't want our worlds historic sites destroyed. Woah be to us when we have no country side to enjoy. No more cities.37162021-03-14T20:17:03.48749674Patrick de RooHow can you learn to not make the mistakes from the past if you destroy the heritage sites. Save the Scottish heritage too much has been lost already!37162021-03-14T20:25:08.09749675Marion DewarI suffer from MS and 100% agree with the removal of the 20m rule I manage to walk this but could not go to shops and carry bags home People do not see the after effects of this I can end up in bed for days after 37312021-03-14T20:27:02.23749676Christine MacdonaldOver 4000 people, mainly women, died in this period. We should remember them37332021-03-14T21:13:38.73749682Chelsea McKinney Some of my clan is buried there. The pain was so great my clan moved to Ireland. Please protect their resting place. 37162021-03-14T21:39:34.88749683Helen CarsonThe 20 meter rule doesn't affect me (yet)- even though I have MS, but I am one of the lucky ones who seems to be benign after 15 years of hardly any symptoms, though I am only too aware that my situation could have been very different.37312021-03-14T21:48:17.71749684Kathryn HowesMS is a progressive disease which can vary greatly from one person to another and from one day to the next and sometimes within a day! The 20m rule must be scrapped as it is further limiting people's lives who already have enough to deal with on a daily basis.37312021-03-14T21:53:48.01349686Mathias HellbergIf a developer seek to damage or destroy a historic site for economical gain it should be enough for a criminal investigation against them. 37162021-03-14T22:07:05.98749687William GreenleeI am from America and even I know that places like this needs to be preserved. I hope this petition works.37162021-03-14T22:18:02.07349688sonia chaviesThe battlefields where are ancestors fight and died should never be built upon they should be sacred grounds and kept as a historical monument so future generations can see what our ancestors died for if you choose to erase history we are Doom to repeat it37162021-03-14T22:45:48.8849689Douglas MillerLike the Gettysburg Battlefield it is a hallowed place for both North and South armys of the American Civil war. It is way to REMEMBER those soldiers that died for a cause. Either winning or loosing side. Remember Cullodin savd the Battlefield.37162021-03-14T22:51:22.96749690Stephanie Meikle BrownWe must protect this historic site! 37162021-03-14T23:33:07.849691Steve HollerDisgraceful. My family member has become worse over the years and their money has been greatly reduced. Shame on you. 37312021-03-14T23:56:34.51749692Hollace Craven HartnettPreserve the history of this country! 37162021-03-14T23:59:08.8649693Kayla Feliciano GarciaSave history37162021-03-15T00:06:24.8249694Nancy ThorsonAncestors were Kerr, Logan37162021-03-15T00:52:31.65749696Nancy WestMy Ancestors are buried here. Please let them stay at rest.37162021-03-15T01:13:32.10349697Christina LefeverI don't understand why this hallowed ground and others like it at not afforded the highest protection which they so rightly deserve.37162021-03-15T01:39:59.94349699Stephanie Olivero I'm half Scottish. Visiting the monuments and historical sites of my ancestors is important to me. Please protect these sites.37162021-03-15T02:03:46.02349701Finlay WilsonCulloden Itself represents the death of the Scottish way of life, highland culture and the massive loss of life from our ancestors, the fact that development was even considered is appalling. 37162021-03-15T02:36:40.84349704Piper ElwoodProtect important monuments to our history and respect the deceased.37162021-03-15T03:32:23.2549707Connor M RussellFor Scottish Lands 37162021-03-15T03:54:54.08749709Liz Scarbeary I have Scottish ancestry that fought in the Jacobite revolution. Knowing I could have ancestors buried there and that someone wants to mess with their final resting place is vile and atrocious. I hope to God this petition works. 37162021-03-15T06:52:29.5549710Alexis Godlewski We can not allow the fallen to be forgotten. 37162021-03-15T07:37:35.74349711Susie RoseAbout time too. 37332021-03-15T08:12:10.9549712Tara HumphriesHistory is never to be forgotten or bury37162021-03-15T08:20:36.2849713Martina DohertyPlease get rid of this 20 metre rule for all persons that have MS please 37312021-03-15T09:28:39.02349714stephanie wrightPlease leave our history alone, to much has already been taken from Scotland. 37162021-03-15T12:52:33.70749720Robin Taylor We need to be saving our history not destroying it for progress that is totally unnecessary.37162021-03-15T13:03:34.649721Claire NelissenThis is a war grave. Many people were slaughtered here. It would be criminal & offensive to build upon it. The land should be left as it it. 37162021-03-15T13:47:07.88749723Dean winhamThis is our history and observing nature in its raw form by sharing it with a bird of prey. 37892021-03-15T14:47:48.1149725Keshia Kennedy Save this historic place!!!!! I am from Scottish decent and this hits me hard please please save our history 37162021-03-15T16:16:21.3349726Erin HumphriesThis was a crime against humanity which created a wound, that is now our responsibility to heal.37332021-03-15T18:51:38.2649729Megan Stewart This is a sacred historical site as well as a burial place. Leave it alone. 37162021-03-15T21:07:30.9249730Mrs. J ATKINSONI believe that the golden eagles should be allowed to fly and hunt the hares so that they may retain their natural instincts and behaviour and not have it stymied by this proposed ban. A ban that was not introduced for this specific purpose. The Golden Eagle is a magnificent creature and should be allowed to fly free in it's natural habitat and seek out it's prey in the manner nature created it for, without human interference.37892021-03-16T03:18:39.51749733Dominick D'AmbrosioPlease no houses37162021-03-16T05:10:14.8949735Jennifer Marie LuceTo my ancestors. May this help heal some of my epigenetic trauma 37332021-03-16T07:19:11.62349736Jennifer RoyEducate your sons37332021-03-16T07:35:26.02749737Deborah HenleyMay you rest in peace.37332021-03-16T08:07:13.20349738Richard BlythThis petition makes absolute sense 37352021-03-16T08:19:23.6849739Tracy MiddletonI use this to go back home to the wee toon as I find it safer that the roads. 37352021-03-16T08:25:50.2949740Mary RossThis would help the local people a lot especially in the winter37352021-03-16T08:31:44.2649741Veronica BradyUnreasonable and unfair37312021-03-16T08:40:38.6249742William Charles RennieEssential for our town.37352021-03-16T08:43:32.8849743Johannes van der WerfIt's a necessity.37352021-03-16T08:50:39.92749745Kerry Gillespie This service is really needed for our wee town 37352021-03-16T08:55:46.26349746Mark EagersAgree that this is an essential service for the town.37352021-03-16T09:00:10.8849747Marion McDonald It is essential to ensure there are alternative options to travel into and out of Kintyre and Argyll whilst there is no permanent solution to the Rest and Be Thankful A83.37352021-03-16T09:07:45.71749748Jeanette LoveWe need it all year 37352021-03-16T09:14:30.7649750Elizabeth BlairMuch needed link to the city as the road link is a joke37352021-03-16T09:18:13.44749751Ailsa McGeachyCampbeltown is my home town which I visit frequently, a ferry is necessary 37352021-03-16T09:20:12.83749752John Stevenson This is badly needed 37352021-03-16T09:25:59.1249753Gilbert McKillopEssential service for our community37352021-03-16T09:27:34.42349754Louise GoslingSo fed up going the long way to Glasgow it would be a lot quicker on the Ferry.37352021-03-16T09:34:17.5949755Morven MacLeanWe need the Rest Fixed. It csn be a lifeline to us . 37352021-03-16T09:49:51.73349757Alexander RamsayIts essential to have a year round ferry service.37352021-03-16T10:31:51.949758Una BakerMight help to alleviate traffic at the Rest and Be Thankful 37352021-03-16T10:37:08.59749759Julie JordanA much needed service.37352021-03-16T10:55:13.16349761Mary WatsonA regular ferry service would alleviate the problems with the Rest but a better connection to Glasgow would also be required. 37352021-03-16T11:01:54.12349762Lorraine Gillespie Would be good to see a day return on a Saturday, at present it is only day return on a Friday when most people are working!! 37352021-03-16T11:16:12.16749763Martha RennieA Lifeline 37352021-03-16T11:27:13.64349764Debbie MckellEssential for us all when rest is closed causes a huge commute for glasgow hospital appointments with kids 37352021-03-16T11:48:23.4549765Wilma Stevenson Badly needed in this part of the country 37352021-03-16T12:23:46.71349766Scott Campbell Ferry is much needed to shorten distance for driving and better for the economy. 37352021-03-16T12:24:48.949768Elizabeth MacdonaldA ferry from Campbeltown to Ardrossan, is essential to assist movement, for people living in Argyll, who have to contend with problems with the Rest and be Thankful.37352021-03-16T12:29:42.17749769Jennifer WileyLong overdue and much deserved37332021-03-16T13:18:36.93349770Kenneth HastieAs General Manager of a seafoods company based in Ayr, we collect shellfish on a daily basis in and around Kintyre. With the ongoing problems on A83 at Rest and Be Thankful a lifeline ferry service between Campbeltown and Ardrossan would be a welcome alternative to ensure our products were not delayed by timely road diversions. I am sure this will be the case for many centrally located businesses who trade in and out of Kintyre. I would give this petition my full support.37352021-03-16T13:24:33.38749771Iris WeaverI've lived in Salem, MA, and I know descendants of the Salem witches. My church is the one that started the witch hysteria. \r\n\r\nAs a student of women's history and a modern wise woman practitioner, I understand the fear and power dynamics that drove the panic in the Colonies and Europe. \r\n\r\nIt is absolutely time to exonerate the victims, female and male, and to bring their existence and story into the public awareness. And it is so important to understand what these women and men were actually contributing to the society of their time.37332021-03-16T14:06:22.78349773Jean HamiltonWill help to boost the Campbeltown and surrounding rural economy37352021-03-16T14:19:07.11349774Heather ThrefallThis service is a vital service for residents & tourists, thousands of tourists visit and it would effect the economy which will impact on residents. \r\n37352021-03-16T14:51:17.3249775Robert TaitFerry is a must and should also go to Northern Ireland37352021-03-16T14:59:13.19749776Dorothy TaitThis is a must and should also go to Ballycastle37352021-03-16T15:02:44.24349777Lorraine TaitFerry should also go to Ballycastle37352021-03-16T15:49:00.3549779John LamontEssential for the area37352021-03-16T16:11:42.9149780Chas Hughes It's getting more and more expensive to travel to Glasgow. We need this option.37352021-03-16T16:15:19.98749781Iain WebbFrom Clan Baird. May this Pardon of falsely accused innocent women and men become fruitful. 37332021-03-16T16:28:09.44749782Greg MacfarlaneFeel neglected. Please help. 37372021-03-16T16:34:17.3549783Juliette AshmoonI think the women of Scotland who were unjustly burned as witches deserve a lot more but at least they deserve this small gesture. And let the present day witches practice the craft in peace!37332021-03-16T16:38:13.7149784Sharon RossiA witching wood would be a fitting memorial. I still have memories!!!!!37332021-03-16T17:19:05.73349785Gail Williams Essential for local economy. Life line link especially with rest and be thankful situation. 37352021-03-16T17:21:27.1449786David Rankin Local economy and essential alternative route due to rest and be thankful situation 37352021-03-16T17:58:28.36349787Stanley WatsonAll year round ferry would be so beneficial to local economy.37352021-03-16T18:48:16.43349790Mary MacLennanThese are war graves and should not be built on and should be protected 37162021-03-16T19:08:27.46749791Campbell omay Better than going the road to Glasgow37352021-03-16T19:12:20.45349792Graham Boyne No to more Houses on the irreplaceable sites of Scottish History. 37162021-03-16T19:29:08.15749793Sean RoseThe ferry brings tourism into the town and allows Campbelltown residents and those from surrounding areas access to and from Ardrossan without having to drive, especially more so now with the increased closure of the Rest and be Thankful. 37352021-03-16T19:39:34.7749794Jennie GreenLong overdue and yet sadly timely37332021-03-16T20:06:53.33349795Morag Kletkiene This is a essential service for Campbeltowns economy 37352021-03-16T20:07:52.14749796june wallaceThe Current level of planning protection is really inadequate -and yes new legislation is needed. We need to protect and cherish our history.37162021-03-16T20:26:23.35349799Campbell StewartKintyre might as well be an island the way things are at the Rest and be Thankful with no quick fix a year-round ferry service is essential.37352021-03-16T21:23:34.76749801Kareen CoxThis would benefit many of our tourism and businesses for the town, particularly during winter when the rest and be thankful is often closed to landslides or potential landslides. 37352021-03-16T22:38:08.13749802Helene HansenWhy this has not been done already is the most baffling thing. C'mon!37332021-03-16T22:45:32.48349803Margaret MarshallThis is a great idea, should definitely go ahead37352021-03-16T22:57:45.40749804Moyra PatersonA ferry is a lifeline to our area. 3.5 hours by car, 4.5 by bus.... roads infrastructure poor. We need a reliable option. 37352021-03-16T23:13:16.84349806Amanda DickeyFor my ancestors!37332021-03-16T23:16:17.73749807Natasha WhippleBlessed Be to my long ago gone but not forgotten ancestors. 37332021-03-16T23:24:05.72349808Amanda WerlingFor the Witches37332021-03-16T23:24:36.37749809Beth RatnerMany Thanks37332021-03-16T23:44:57.149810Cassandra EricksonWitch lives matter too!37332021-03-17T01:13:12.90749811Rebecca L. TallmanMy ancestors came from Scotland. This matters to me.37332021-03-17T01:17:57.36349812Amanda FoxBetter late than never. Time to make it right!37332021-03-17T01:35:46.7149813Kindell YoungOur ancestors suffered so we could soar. We owe them this. 37332021-03-17T02:08:22.7349814Linda Laing100% agree for this 37332021-03-17T03:03:19.45749816Debby Kramer I am signing this Petition to pardon all witches!! All the witches that were executed should have not ever been even arrested in the first place. 37332021-03-17T03:54:42.47749819Heather McGuireIt's time to honor those that were wrongfully persecuted. 37332021-03-17T06:08:25.0949822Jan NimmoLifeline service for Kintyre given the state of the A83 and road closures at the Rest and Be Thankful. Campbeltown needs a reliable, all year round service. 37352021-03-17T06:45:43.82749824Angela Diane Dunbarthe tattooed red headed chaos witch in texas...daughter of the sacred mothers-ancient fathers-winged brothers -vibrant elementals...we whisper to our selves...standing dude by side again...our cauldrons are now in the electric crossroads...our battle cries past present and future ...so mote it be so mote it be so mote it be 37332021-03-17T06:51:41.549825Candy DaughertyIt was wrong to kill so many. My ancestors need and deserve justice 37332021-03-17T07:12:20.6949826John McLatchieWe need this ferry as a lifeline service & to develop the community 37352021-03-17T07:58:27.89749827Joanna MackenzieThey were just folk37332021-03-17T09:29:05.33349829Darin Dominic KeenDarin Existed Male WITCH37332021-03-17T09:51:29.55749830Sian MannifieldThis is long overdue and will bring some justice in memorandum. 37332021-03-17T10:16:35.0949831JimnArlene TaylorThis should have been done, long ago. 37332021-03-17T10:20:04.4849832Shona ClarkI agree 37332021-03-17T10:20:19.46349833Karen GiderProud to be a part of this - Strong voices for the females who had no voice .37332021-03-17T10:34:06.45349835Shahnila Shafiqfor those women, for justice.37332021-03-17T11:49:01.79749836Leslie EnglishOne of the most important battles in Scottish history where the battlefield is not too developed, it is important for the future that it remains so.37162021-03-17T12:18:34.54349837Lorna Taylor Culloden battle field is what it says (Battle field) this is a place for all to come pay there respect to their fallen kinsmen and such a historic site for folk all over the world. Please stop and reconsider this application to stop any future planning on this Moor. 37162021-03-17T13:10:30.749838Vivienne PattersonStop stop stop this !!!37162021-03-17T13:42:44.05349839Caroline AdamsPersecuted throughout the ages. Women then and now will never wheesht37332021-03-17T14:05:42.7449840Mary WardIn memory of women labelled as witches everywhere 37332021-03-17T14:06:19.5249841Ann AgnewAbout time these women were recognised as having been murdered.37332021-03-17T14:10:14.1649842Max BakerI find it absurd that any historian of merit would oppose this measure. Might I suggest revisiting their credentials to ensure that our kids aren't being taught such garbage? 37332021-03-17T14:13:35.97349843alison baker I believe that these people were innocent.37332021-03-17T14:32:55.0349844Julie McLeanHaving read about the witches in Pittenweem, it is plain that these were just people accused because they were in the wrong place at the wrong time. 37332021-03-17T14:52:34.92349845Joy BoothbyCulloden Battlefield is a war grave it should never be divided or built upon. Its HISTORY and sacred37162021-03-17T15:09:25.72349846Kelly Bremner Please leave the Battlefield alone. Poor men died on that Battlefield. We don't need any developments to go ahead. Please leave alone, let these men Rest in peace. 37162021-03-17T15:13:25.6349847Debra Straub-Tazz A vital cultural and historical site to Scots throughout the world that should be protected and preserved. 37162021-03-17T16:19:05.22749849Teresa DufficyI whole heartedly back this and it is very good to see this happening.37332021-03-17T16:30:44.20349850Donna WotherspoonThis is an unfair and discriminatory rule for neurological conditions that vary from day to day. Family member has MS so have seen life with it at close quarters.37312021-03-17T16:50:33.32349851Jeanette VeitchStop the 20m rule. Very unfair and causing stress.37312021-03-17T17:06:08.46749853Paul wilson Now living in the USA but being born and raised in the north east of England and working for some time in Fife I feel strongly that this should be part of the fabric of Scotland 37892021-03-17T17:06:24.29749854John MacpheeA ferry link to the west coast of Scotland is essential and would be a massive boost to Argyllshire.37352021-03-17T17:16:44.87749855Lauren SmithPlease scrap the 20m rule. I have secondary progressive MS and really struggle to walk.37312021-03-17T17:24:29.64349856Margaret LangFor goodness sake, no means no\r\n..not 'maybe if you smile nicely i will say yes'37162021-03-17T17:59:04.47349857Andrew BrowningI strongly believe this should have been done many years ago!!37332021-03-17T18:47:57.68749858Carol WoodMany women who were found to be witches were midwives, herbalists, single women who were smart and widows who had land and money. Organised religion should also be made to apologise.37332021-03-17T18:54:34.0349859Gillian FoxAbout time we righted this shameful period in our history. A pardon, apology and memorial are long overdue.37332021-03-17T18:55:49.01749860Catherine CameronA memorial to those women cruelly persecuted in the past will also serve to show that female human beings continue to be oppressed on the basis of their sex.37332021-03-17T19:00:45.26749861Jacqueline McCarleyMy family is from Aberdeen and I'm pretty sure we lost a few relatives to the pyres.\r\nIt's time for Scotland to make amends for these horrendous crimes against women and the marginalized.37332021-03-17T19:08:30.0849862Janice EassonI'm sure I must be related to one of these women.37332021-03-17T19:20:33.61349863Oliver MillsA good cause for conservationists and culture. 37892021-03-17T19:24:54.34749865Jacqueline KayThese women deserve our respect, compassion and recognition so long overdue. 37332021-03-17T19:26:24.17749866Margo HutchisonThe majority of the women concerned were misunderstood by (patriarchal) society. They deserve better. Apologies and pardons are long overdue.37332021-03-17T19:39:38.5549867Margaret Millar Protect our battlefields 37162021-03-17T19:47:06.00749868George HutchisonOur birds and us are entitled to hunt scottish mountain hares wat is the point in keeping these birds if they aren't allowed to be flown at there natural quarry 37892021-03-17T19:50:55.1349869Andrew outtenCould you listen to the people who manage the moors and ask them what they want not what you think they need. Birds need to fly and hunt it keeps them alert and more like being in the wild. The mountain hare will get out of control. And before you know it it will be past the point of no return. 37892021-03-17T19:54:11.31749870Tom DonaldI think this would be a valuable marker of our commitment to oppose misogyny in all of its forms. 37332021-03-17T20:04:55.3549871Geraldine DolanI often travel from Edinbrgh to Campbelltown to support my sister and partner. They are foster carers and I am a registered respite carer. The ferry would mean I could give them more support through the year. 37352021-03-17T20:37:19.96349873Helena DavidsonEvery day is a mobility lottery for people with M.S.37312021-03-17T21:11:53.76749874Rosemary Venditozzi We cannot right the wrongs of the past without acknowledging them and their devastating impact and needless suffering over the ages. The least we can do now is to seek both pardon and publicly mark a day of mourning for families of those who lost loved ones. History has to reflect wrongful actions and consequences whose families were forever blemished by this. When we know better we have to do better and commemorate worldwide a day to mark their memory.37332021-03-17T21:14:42.17749875JEAN CURNOWThe use of a permanent ferry crossing will enable tourists, local residents and general trade to continue to support the local economy.37352021-03-17T21:21:11.50349876Gillian GrantScrap this ridiculous rule. 37312021-03-17T21:26:13.03749877Bob ChickenThe A83 is regularly closed. The A83 is unreliable .Campbeltown needs a ferry to the mainland to seriously improve the lives of folk who live in Kintyre.37352021-03-17T21:55:03.08749878MR RYAN M C SCOTTFalconry is an ancient sport. Like it or not our shared island has been moulded by man. If species are not managed as they have been for, you could argue several millennia. They will become extinct in the UK and that should be a crime against the nation.37892021-03-17T22:24:18.68349880Jacki MiddaughFor all of the powerful women of history, currently and for our future. 37332021-03-17T22:42:56.8649881Peter Julian Rudolf WhickerManaging land for hunting of all kinds is the only way in which habitats and the species within them are proven to be actively and sustainably conserved. As long as the livelihoods of the people conserving the land depend upon the success of quarry species that inhabit it, those species are safe, as is every other part of the ecosystem. Legal protection is not just meaningless and empty, it is directly harmful. It is a false and foolish policy that is enacted will bring miserable consequences that should rightly shame those behind it.37892021-03-17T22:59:50.48749882Bernadette Colee This development needs to be stopped. Where is Scotland's respect for its history and war dead? In times to come, do you really want to be remembered as the organisation that desecrated Scotlands most historic battlefield? There is a place for progress and development but this site is not that place and the development application should have been put to a halt long before this. It's a sad reflection of the world we live in when the little man has to fight so hard for something that should have automatic protections. This is truly shameful.37162021-03-17T23:15:15.33349883Ann BovillA worthwhile endeavour, hopefully the pardons will follow and despite the passage of time, justice will be served. 37332021-03-17T23:30:38.81749884Kim IngramAs always government has no idea of what is needed to support nature and the balances required by nature.37892021-03-18T01:19:57.3849886Spencer TseRidiculous legislation made up by people who know nothing about the subject. 37892021-03-18T15:52:33.35749890Graham F FrenchTypical of the woke brigade who want everything to be nice and fluffy to completely misunderstand what is needed in the countryside.\r\nSo much harm is done in the name of virtue signalling.37892021-03-18T16:33:37.3849893Kenneth Matthew McMillanYes falconry has been around since the middle ages as is one of the most effective ways of controlling the hare population, the new legislation will have a serious negative effect on the related businesses and the welfare of the birds as they are born to fly and hunt which is the most natural way. Outlawing the hunting of mountain hares by any means not just Eagle falconry will be harmful to the conservation of mountain hares not because more licences for shooting will be sought but because the poaching of mountain hares will increase.37892021-03-18T16:55:36.41749894Kenneth john sheldon The countryside should be managed by the people who live and work in the countryside not the people who live in the city and know nothing about the countryside 37892021-03-18T19:48:16.2549896Fraser SpittalYet another poorly implemented policy that will undoubtedly result in the extinction of the mountain hare. \r\nThe Greens and SNP have NO regard for the Scottish countryside or for the rural communities of Scotland and sadly only have one agenda. Votes37892021-03-18T19:53:48.11349897Ryan Thomson Falconry is an ancient sport and holds part of our history and it brings no harm to the community, if anything it helps bring population down 37892021-03-18T20:01:09.45749899Callum homesThe hunting and conservation work done by falconers is key to the mountain hares thriving in the Scottish Highlands. Without their work the population would simply boom then bust but with them thinning out the population it keeps a constant healthy balanced population.37892021-03-18T20:05:28.97349900darren breenFalcon flying must carry on, it's part of our heritage, like it or not, we are losing too many historical past times just because some people don't agree. 37892021-03-18T20:12:49.89349901Fraser SpittalYet another poorly implemented policy that will undoubtedly result in the extinction of the mountain hare. \r\nThe Greens and SNP have No regard to the Scottish countryside or for the communities within rural Scotland. Sadly they only have one agenda to maximise the number of votes for Scottish national party37892021-03-18T20:24:56.1649902Tom mcknightLeave things be.\r\n\r\n\r\n37892021-03-18T22:04:45.48749903Robert Mcilroy smithThese birds need to be flown and hunting is the best form of excercise.37892021-03-18T23:48:16.64349904Stephen FieldPlease listen to those that have hares on the ground they control and not those that control a baron landscape and blame everyone else for it.37892021-03-19T01:46:43.03749905Ricky SmithKeep the art of falconry alive.37892021-03-19T11:23:13.38349907Martin JohnstoneShouldn't be necessary but it clearly is necessary.. 37902021-03-19T11:55:17.74349908Graham Wilson Good luck Michael a very valid question to be asked 38082021-03-19T17:31:41.08349909Peter Graham Wilson An excellent idea Michael 38082021-03-19T17:48:05.34349910Tom Szemeti1)yes\r\n2)yes\r\n3)yes definately\r\n4)100% yes37892021-03-19T18:23:06.23749911David Gordon Good luck Michael 38082021-03-19T19:32:38.43349912Peter wilsonHope this happens38082021-03-19T19:37:32.69749914Camille DresslerThe island community voice must be represented as widely as possible! 37902021-03-19T19:57:11.0149915Yvonne Milligan I think this would be a positive step 38082021-03-19T20:10:13.4749917Alex HaltonJust listen to those who hunt and practice falconry the conservation and continued heritage must continue in the uk.37892021-03-19T21:13:09.55349918Jon maciverGood luck pal38082021-03-19T21:32:54.51349919Peter MenzelDo not outlaw the hunting of mountain hares.37892021-03-19T22:49:12.11749920Michael Campbell 100% checking PSA for one is important 38082021-03-19T23:05:56.66749921Roland HarrowerIf detected earlier so many lives could be saved with treatment that is available 38082021-03-19T23:18:07.16749922Ian GilliesI am very pleased to support this petition, seeking to redress the current situation of membership of public boards that have little relevance to the island communities they serve.37902021-03-20T02:00:14.87349923Wendy R Louie\r\nI am a practicing falconer of over 20 years in the United States, and I ask that you consider allowing falconers to hunt mountain hares in Scotland with trained Golden Eagles. \r\n\r\nThe chase and hunt between the eagle and the hare is as timeless and as natural as the earth and sky, and such a hunt provides the fairest chase of them all, as evolution itself has dictated.\r\n\r\nFalconry itself is an ancient sport that celebrates the bond between our species and those of the birds of prey. The practice has over 4,000 years of recorded history behind it, and indeed falconry has been declared by the United Nations to be an intangible cultural representative of human heritage. \r\n\r\nAs such, it should be allowed to exist and be practiced wherever it is biologically feasible (dictated by the populations of prey species, not by political whim or opinion). \r\n\r\nFalconry should be always permitted to exist and be allowed to be practiced as it has since time immemorial, with a free flying bird allowed to pursue its natural quarry in a wild state, and a human partner to assist the raptor as needed. \r\n\r\n\r\n37892021-03-20T07:20:02.77349924David G NewmanAs the Scottish Government has just published its Population Strategy I believe that decisions taken by public organisations like HIAL should also take into consideration whether de-population of island communities will also result.37902021-03-20T08:33:18.20749925Alex MooreGood work Mikey!38082021-03-20T10:54:53.66349926Chris Tilney Listen to people who really know for a change. 37892021-03-20T11:19:14.80749927Ian GilliesVery pleased to support this petition which seeks to redress the relevance and membership of public Boards to the island communities they serve.37902021-03-20T11:48:53.40349928Tania Korad kennedyThink this vitally important 38082021-03-20T13:20:57.33749930Emma WhiteThis rule should be scraped immediately.‘I was asked to do it over 60 years ago and I couldn’t do it then ,\r\nWhat chance would i have now none \r\nScrap it now we have all suffered enough !!\r\n 37312021-03-20T16:14:57.58749932Stephen FergusonThe neglect of cancer screening and treatment since the hysteria of Covid hit has been disgusting. 38082021-03-20T18:47:20.0649933Danny BoyleYou can walk on a grouse moor in Scotland with stepping on a hare, no problem with numbers. 37892021-03-20T20:12:08.52749934Stephen John ScottGood luck Michael for a good cause.38082021-03-20T20:15:03.46349935Anne GowHelp detect cancer early38082021-03-20T20:17:43.82349936Stephen John ScottGood luck Michael for a good cause.38082021-03-20T23:06:08.86349937Andrew LynchWithout correct conservation of hares by country sports such as falconry the hares will disappear for good. Stopping falconry will be detrimental to overall existence of the blue hare37892021-03-21T10:28:55.8749939Dean CarwinAbsolutely agree to this38082021-03-21T17:53:02.17349941David B MooreThis is crazy. They are going to be legislating these animals to extinction. Wake up people. You can't sit in your chair in a city or whatever and do things to wildlife that you do not understand. You can't bring your heart into wildlife management. Remember when they are gone it was not hunting it was this type of crazy management that will be the cause!!!!37892021-03-21T18:15:51.5249942Donald SansomThis has my full support.38082021-03-21T20:03:36.81349943Murdo MacleanFully support 37902021-03-21T22:03:16.12749944Rich Borquist Keep hare hawking alive. 37892021-03-21T22:13:44.38349945Kris WestermanIt is vital that islanders with actual knowledge of island issues and impacts should be fully involved in any decision making with regard to island issues. It is also vital that they not be there as a tick box exercise but actually listened to and taken notice of. One of the biggest exports from the islands is graduates, who after gaining a wealth of experience often return in later life. This experience should be harnessed.37902021-03-21T22:33:06.44349946Brian Welshleave things as they are. 37892021-03-21T22:43:42.79749947John Daniel Peteranna All islanders should support this 37902021-03-21T23:27:47.31749948Edward AnthonySave falconry in the uk.37892021-03-22T00:24:38.71349949Peter Thomas Hankeywe as a minority group have the right to hunt.37892021-03-22T00:49:41.82749950Roy Benton Please listen to people as falconry is part of our history and heritage.37892021-03-22T01:39:29.5249951james footI would like my kids to be able to watch me fly my birds at the amazing mountain hare! 37892021-03-22T02:46:32.15749953Cody EllensonEven if you stop the hunting of these animals in the sport of falconry they will still be taken with wild raptors. What is the point of this? Falconry does not effect the population 37892021-03-22T06:36:01.9249954Glyn wattsKeep the sport alive, these birds need to be flown and it is built into them to naturally chase and hunt.37892021-03-22T08:05:06.5949955Clint coventryI have had the pleasure of hunting with eagles for over 25 years, and can confirm that the only place to see them in there natural environment is Scotland, to remove this ability would condemn an awful lot of magnificent birds to a life in an aviary 37892021-03-22T08:57:22.76749956Bernie BellOnly those who live in a place can correctly assess the situation there.37902021-03-22T09:41:24.72749958Shaun careyFalconry is a national heritage , and\r\nNatural food for the golden eagle37892021-03-22T10:00:54.43349959Kenneth SwanWe are all part of this world we are the janitors of this planet and gamekeepers more than most. 37892021-03-22T10:33:04.79349960Mary SchmollerCommunity Representation needed. Of note, the address box in the petition does not offer islands only town and city37902021-03-22T12:32:05.4549962Peter HendersonPractical, first hand knowledge of Island life is a necessary skill needed to assess the impact a course of action will have when applied to an Island community. What seems a good business or financial solution does not always translate to a good outcome when applied to the Islands or other remote parts of Scotland. Local Board representatives are the only way to stop decisions being made that damage rather than improve our daily lives37902021-03-22T15:40:58.949964Mairi MacLeodAbsolutely essential that is genuine representation by community members who understand the importance of these services and the impact of their delivery (or non-delivery!)37902021-03-22T15:41:22.13349965Wanda GorzkowskaLife line services and their needs are best understood by those needing them37902021-03-22T17:15:17.67749966Raymond GrangeA lot of eagles in falconry are going to be deprived of hunting, the hare its natural food.37892021-03-22T17:17:07.77349967Joyce Murison I totally agree with more local community input into decisions that affect them. \r\n37902021-03-22T17:20:13.3249968Joyce MurisonI totally agree with local representatives being on committees that take decisions that impact their community. 37902021-03-22T17:41:13.6549970Mark SteeleIt is vital that no more of our traditions are taken away due to the complaints from those who do not value tradition at all37892021-03-22T17:43:02.80749971Marion WalkerFully Support this for our Island community37902021-03-22T18:49:51.06749974Ian M Wilson Essential for those who will be affected to have a voice. 37902021-03-22T20:58:46.03749975Matt BruceIt seems obvious that island residents should be on the board of transport organisations that provide essential services37902021-03-22T21:16:26.41349976Rodney ShannonWe need representation37902021-03-22T21:46:39.4849977Olivia FraserSigned with full support 38082021-03-22T22:03:42.51349978Zoe Paterson100% agree. Could save so many lives 38082021-03-22T22:21:56.28349979Karen MillerMy dad may still have been alive if his cancer had been detected early he had. No symptoms. The pain he suffered will stay with me forever. \r\nTruly hope this is passed 38082021-03-22T22:31:35.6849980James MacDonaldGreat cause Mickey! 38082021-03-22T22:33:53.69749981Samantha Morrison Brilliant cause! Good luck 38082021-03-22T22:42:11.05749982John Coyne100% agree, great cause. 38082021-03-22T23:55:44.5849983vanessa langleyThis has been a long battle with HIAL, still not over with the island communities feeling that their views have been minimised and undervalued which seems to be in complete contradiction to the island proofing of government decisions.For these to be taken without an island voice and proper representation on HIAL's Board seems to be negligent in the extreme.37902021-03-23T00:34:32.28749984Audrey IrvineHi, I've always thought that blood test are vital for prevention is better than a cure. Blood test should begin from the age of 50, which would determine if a person is at risk from Cancer, high cholesterol, which leads to High blood pressure , type 2 diabetes. The benefits from this out weighs the risks from not only early stages of cancer but high blood pressure, diabetes type 2, strokes, heart disease. Blood test are vital, and I back this cause to the hill. Lot of people are not educated enough to know that blood test are important for longevity to our Health and Wellbeing. 38082021-03-23T01:01:37.5949985Thomas BondFalconry must continue it's changed my life and given me the purpose of it was stopped I would have my life taken away save upland falconry \r\n37892021-03-23T03:14:10.5949986Lindsey AndersonAgree and fully support this.38082021-03-23T06:39:30.4849987Callum Buchanan Excellent idea.38082021-03-23T06:58:14.26749988Brian IrelandI have been saying this for years\r\nBlood tests should be carried out 55 years of age38082021-03-23T07:30:56.08349989Aileen FergusonShould be mandatory. Have family and friends who have or had prostate cancer which would have been found earlier with a simple test38082021-03-23T08:11:52.97749990James DobsonIt is essential, and obvious, that local representation is available on these boards to contribute to decisions that meet island needs and concerns.37902021-03-23T08:19:46.40349991Maureen Macdonald Hope you get a lot of support for this. Anything that helps to get an early cancer diagnosis is good. 38082021-03-23T08:51:27.9749992Chrisanne MacleodThis would help with early diagnosis and maybe catch MISSED diagnosis.38082021-03-23T11:15:17.15349995JAMES MACLENNANTHERE IS A DUTY-OF-CARE TOWARDS THIS COHORT, AND THIS SHOULD INCLUDE MANDATORY ANNUAL CANCER BLOOD TESTS.38082021-03-23T12:28:25.21349996Francisco FadelFalconry is a sustainable type of hunting37892021-03-23T13:26:40.9949997John A. MaciverI fully support this petition as an early diagnosis can make all the difference!38082021-03-23T13:30:48.20349998Alan wattBest way to save lives and save NHS money at the same time.38082021-03-23T13:34:04.17749999Eduardo Céspedes A legal hunter! It will always be a contribution to the conservation and balance of already damaged ecosystems and what better way to do it with a bird of prey where all are enhanced! Ecosystem, prey and raptor.37892021-03-23T14:28:37.94750001Frank CreightonI agree with petition37902021-03-23T18:12:29.2650003Robert Hutchinson Please continue to allow falconry to continue in Scotland with Eagles 37892021-03-23T19:13:13.95750004Kathleen GraceYes, I agree with this petition.37902021-03-23T19:35:48.19350006Angus MacDonald These boards need island representatives 37902021-03-23T19:50:22.3850007Morag MacAulayIt is essential and important that local representation is available on these boards to contribute to decisions that affect island issues, needs, and concerns. Vital even to have a representation.37902021-03-23T20:42:45.04750008Teen MacDonald I agree with petition 37902021-03-23T21:23:37.53350010William BarkerNo taxation without representation. Islander taxes help pay for the service. They are the primary users. The islands aren't an outpost or a central belt colony. A local voice in the decision making should be minimum requirement. 37902021-03-23T21:35:34.1650011Margaret DeyellI agree that local communities must have more say in decisions that affect them.37902021-03-23T21:46:34.850012Catherine MacarthurShould become law without hesitation38082021-03-23T21:57:22.43350013Angus MacDonald These boards need Island representation 37902021-03-23T22:50:52.0350014Theo LoganThis petition must take action immediately and many children want to sign this but due to the short timing of petitions due to the elections, it has to close quickly.37972021-03-23T23:55:05.1850015Kylie LauglinYes i agree that teacher assessed grades should be used in scotland as covid has disrupted education every child in this country deserves much better we all are affected by this37972021-03-23T23:59:03.83750016Tia WishartPlease move to teacher assessed grades I've been depressed and it's been a nightmare for our education37972021-03-24T00:00:12.850017Madeline CorcoranInstead of destroying sustainable traditions... support and applaud them.37892021-03-24T00:34:59.8750018Amanda Jamieson-SmithEarly diagnosis is essential in saving lives. \r\n38082021-03-24T03:21:38.8650019Hector Guadalupe Holguin Pacheco Se permita en Escocia la caza de la liebre por cetreria 37892021-03-24T08:03:41.45750020Steven MartinRegular testing for people may save many lives. 38082021-03-24T08:21:48.61350021John Mac LennanBit unfair giving such a tight timeline37902021-03-24T08:55:10.2950022robert skillingsHunting with birds of prey is a re-enactment of the natural world, the problem is the word sport Its not a sport, its a way of life37892021-03-24T08:57:27.79750023Lynn Mitchell This could make a huge difference for many people38082021-03-24T09:38:05.23350024Lynora KennedyPlease let falconers do their job, and maintain the country environment.37892021-03-24T09:53:40.7250026Heather CrawfordA progressive approach that would save lives, makes sense38082021-03-24T10:08:30.9450027Roger PatersonWe are the only true 24hr public transport service, every other form of public transport receive some sort of public funding we receive 0%37372021-03-24T10:35:19.74350028Billy and Isobel GrayIf this test is given early it can detect cancer cell count in the blood and help save countless lives. Early diagnosis can make the difference to people who have no symptoms but have this dreadful disease that takes so many lives each year.38082021-03-24T10:39:27.1550030Marie MacdonaldEarly diagnosis, and in fact dropping the age limit, will certainly only have a positive outcome. 38082021-03-24T10:55:45.21350032Donald Mac LeanI agree we need more representation37902021-03-24T10:58:23.52750033Ridge ElmPlease permit falconers to continue their practice and conservation efforts. It would be a shame to see this way of life dwindle any further.37892021-03-24T11:42:44.2550034Sharon Mackinnon100% agree. I'd go further to make it from age 50 as my husband age 54 diagnosed with advanced cancer, no family history.\r\n38082021-03-24T11:45:22.56350035Andrew Tait100% this is a must. will make a massive difference to peoples lives38082021-03-24T11:47:10.73750036Miss Lorraine McIntoshWe need to look after men as well as woman by cancer screening 38082021-03-24T12:37:47.5750037Moira McRobertI fully support this petition38082021-03-24T13:05:39.87350038Cailean McCombe100% and to be honest it should be opened up to younger age groups 38082021-03-24T13:40:57.37750039Patricia Wright Please let falconers do their job, and maintain the country environment.\r\n37892021-03-24T14:07:06.72350040Elizabeth McPhee I think this is a necessity 38082021-03-24T14:25:58.60350041Peter Quinn Annual blood screening for the over 55s should be implemented at the earliest practicable opportunity to save lives 38082021-03-24T16:12:59.63350042Lisa HutchisonCancer can be hidden for years or suddenly become very aggressive. Early diagnosis would be hugely beneficial.38082021-03-24T16:40:03.9850043Carol BlytherThe art of falconry should be allowed to continue and the natural instincts of raptors to be maintained in the natural environments. The extent and impact of this in the population of mountain hares would be negligible37892021-03-24T16:53:45.23350044Jamie Tonner Sorry to hear about your dad Micky, good luck bud 38082021-03-24T17:12:16.09350045Anne PollockI would be interested to know what blood tests the petitioner is proposing. 38082021-03-24T17:20:36.3950047KIRSTY MacluskeySo many tests but not the right ones made it too late for my mums diagnosis. She was only 60.38082021-03-24T17:36:50.95750048David mackenzieDefinitely a great idea! Well done to Michael for putting in a lot of hard work for a great cause38082021-03-24T18:15:04.5750049Sandy Carmichael Prevention better than cure - never was this more apt 38082021-03-24T19:10:56.250050Elaine HillisA great idea. 38082021-03-24T19:32:18.59350051Trish DicksonToo many young men being diagnosed with prostate cancer, some too late for life saving treatment. 38082021-03-24T19:51:56.81750052Andrew J Wilson In order to protect the wildlife in the United Kingd it is imperative that the people of the countryside are allowed to manage and protect it to our fullest ability. This bill, like many others similarly affecting the countryside, must be repealed.37892021-03-24T20:54:29.74750053Emma Smithi agree that teacher assessed grades must be used and my whole school including teachers agree which the cabinet secretary for education must implement37972021-03-24T21:10:13.2750055Christina Ferns Need to be done to save lives 38082021-03-24T21:50:01.6350056Nancy FraserShould be necessary for annual blood test for age over 55 38082021-03-24T22:15:53.43750057John N MacleodAgree with petition.37902021-03-24T23:27:17.77350058Rona MacFarlane This sounds a very proactive approach. 38082021-03-25T00:01:44.74750060Martyn TaylorFinancial support is so desperately required for private hire / taxi operators with fixed cost overheads a long with no trade I don’t know if my business can survive without support. Day on day it’s becoming more shocking that this vital hard working industry is being forgotten with families suffering the fallout. Help has fallen very short but other businesses seem to have been given financial support. I feel so let down.3737